video_id large_stringlengths 11 11 | video_link large_stringlengths 43 43 | title large_stringlengths 3 100 | text large_stringlengths 351 674k | channel large_stringlengths 1 86 | channel_id large_stringlengths 24 24 | date large_stringlengths 10 10 | license large_stringclasses 1 value | original_language large_stringclasses 1 value | language_id_method large_stringclasses 2 values | transcription_language large_stringclasses 1 value | word_count int64 101 112k | character_count int64 351 674k |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
so8Ih5isDY8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=so8Ih5isDY8 | finally BREAK FREE with this esoteric mindset | a science-y mindset a religious mindset and now your third option and mystic mindset [Music] if you're not familiar with the first two yet watch this video if you are in order to unpack what makes a mystic mindset we need to dive slightly deeper into all three what we will henceforth call the three pillars of understanding you've heard of them before but not like this this simple version is the physical mental and spiritual but when you unpack them practically this is what all three actually mean for you let's break it down [Music] science deals with all things on the physical planet [Music] foreign [Music] watch that again if you wanna i know it go fast but there is a lot to learn and unlearn from that breakdown so by this explanation of the three pillars of understanding we can understand that mystic things are mostly things above the physical plane and below the spiritual in this in between gray area that we call the mental plate it's a bit abstract even in its practicality you still with me if you are then let this one boil your noodles the mystic deals with all of the stuff that helps you figure out who you are and has the ability to help you navigate what you want from your life so goose i hear you say that's fascinating and all and brilliantly explained just really a bang-up job wow but what can i do with this information well only change your life forever maybe i i don't know depends on where you are in your journey but for starters you can stop attempting to use science and religion to answer questions of the self yourself i mean [Music] both of those mindsets are readily available in the world now so if it worked for you you probably wouldn't be here so let's try a new strategy just kidding it's actually a really old strategy ancient actually by literal thousands of years somehow over time we forgot how or why it was important to think of ourselves in terms of mysticism click here for why we forgot mysticism and here to find out more about what you can do once it's found you and remember you stay weird out there | Rainbow Goose | UCN-9LaUzFRYvZHUQyrW-vPA | 2022-05-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 381 | 2,057 |
VxQIpL-H42U | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VxQIpL-H42U | IMPROVE YOUR BEAUTY PHOTOGRAPHY WITH TWO LIGHTING TECHNIQUES| joeydutch | guys i've been teaching you how to shoot with different lighting setups i have put up the two light setup i've put up three light setup for light setup you've not seen me use any of the lighting setup for beauty and i normally shoot one light with beauty right so today it's a full house we have miss island and colorado right colorado for the makeup mess item for the hairstyle and we have a lovely model you guys have missed on my channel rosalind i'll link everyone's handle down the description below so you can check all of them out right so yeah so we'll be using two lights today right i have the godox ad600 and the godox 120 centimeter um softbox and the sk 400 and the seven feet parabolic so this will probably be the flat lighting where it just fills in so this will be my show light and this is my key lights this will give me the depth and dimension i'm looking for and this will just fill in whatever it is shadows that will be created so if i feel like i need more light i would introduce a reflector or the white side of the bounce card i'll be changing this too so just i'll let you guys see what the one light is doing and what the second light is doing and what both of them are doing then we can take it from there so before i leave make it a point to subscribe to the channel don't forget to turn on the bell notification icon and also share it to other people who might be interested in learning a thing or two about photography and also lighting beauty setup right i'll be tethering today so most of the time they'll be looking at that screen so that they can tell me what's the ones and what they don't want and i'll take it from there so i'll see you peace [Music] all right guys so like i mentioned when i started the video i did say i will show you what the one light is doing right so eyes here bring them here that's just the one light highlighting the face from camera right so to her left the style on the hair showing center head this way let's take one shot this way all right now you can see the style on there from the hair which looks nice okay we'll add this backlight which is the flat lighting flash power one over eight so i'm shooting iso 100 shutter speed 160 f7 right same center face the same the eyeballs here towards the monitor open your lips chin down and that's with the fill lights let me just kill off the um the main light let's do the same thing again so this is just a few lights so looking at these four images the first two is the one lives the second i mean the third image is both lighting right and the last image is just the flat lighting just to fill in right so yeah that's it probably this is the normal to light setup i would use when i'm shooting beauty so let's do more something i would like to post okay hello let's look again straight head on turn down tiptoe and open your lips so if you take a look at the eye there are two catch lights one from behind and one from the top making the eye look interesting if we should look at the makeup yeah great everything is the way i want it to be hairstyle great background let's and that's all we'll do two more shots just because i don't want this video to take that long right so yeah okay let's look here this time with a big smile okay so 10 i don't know turn into me with your ears that's right and lean your your chin towards the shoulder yes that's fine you're up a little bit great eyeballs here exactly what the big smile now eyeballs towards the light yeah okay so if we take a if we take a look at these two images these three images are like matt forget the smiling one i think i like the one on the left right so yeah this should be one way of shooting beauty when it comes to two lights etc if you don't have the parabolic you can use any 120 centimeter box or any other box you have just make sure you have two soft boxes two lights you can use a normal speed light to also get the same thing which i have showed you guys in my previous video i'll link it up here right so thank you for joining on this video don't forget to subscribe as usual don't forget to share this video to other friends who might be interested in learning a thing or two about lighting beauty with two lights and setup and don't forget to share because that's the most important part the others also learn from all of this i'll i'll see you let's see in my next video alright i will see you in my next video peace | Joey Dutch | UCnfSWXFkLGNVYDURyrP2ROw | 2021-03-10 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 880 | 4,415 |
5dYkJjDJK_c | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5dYkJjDJK_c | BORDERLANDS 3 l THE Revenge of The Cartels #moze #borderlands3walkthrough #borderlands3 | it's is and attack 2018 and blue welcome to another Borderlands 3 video I hope everybody is safe and well just be sure to press that like button and also would much appreciate it if you subscribe to to the channel much appreciated it will help the channel grow and grow and grow and more well today's video is mainly about the Revenge of the cartels how to activate the ver of the cartels is you have to make sure you go to the main menu on Border Lines 3 as you can see you will see the aridian in the background you go down to revenge of the cells enable you got to make sure they are enabled so we'll start from the beginning events are disabled you've got the bloody har broken hearts day revenge of cartels is is enabled going to make sure that's like that there you go that's where you know it's definitely on so you press continue and you go straight to sanry 3 ship I've also done a video on S 3 if you like to go and check out the other videos I'll G it gives you a lot more detail in all the rooms on the ship so you come to the main ship and we travel to Maurice the dinosaur this is an open Event now it used to be once a year event but now it's open for everyone to play plus it's a fre event as well so you go to Maurice we are have already accepted the mission but you press you press on reice and she talks to you and she tells you what you need to do basically you've got to travel to different parts of Boyland could be um on Pandora could be SL sh or also you can do the trials um a lot of people go to aenas as well aenas is good place to do a run through on to get the decodings it's a little bit like um bloody Harvest with the bloody Harvest you collect Echo plasms and they drop from the ghost with these it's the cartel bosses when you see them they glow up massive icon um glows up and they spawn in and they glow up with some stuff on their clothing and you know definitely know that's the cartel bosses sometimes the cartel actual cartels on the game you play afterwards sometimes they spawn in especially fish L I will also um show you the weapons what drop from the cardells as well we'll do that right at the end after we've killed Joey Viet Joey V is like a mini raid boss as well and this is a lot of reference to Scarface as well which is another good film so this is generally a lot of references is to so what we do we've already accepted so we need to search Galaxy for decod rings in total there's 30 what it is you we go to a gate go to a computer and the gate opens up it's different kind of enemies what what we'll see so we'll go do that in a second right K go to a fenus and now we go to the trials for this one I think we'll do a quick run through on on a fenus and then we'll finish off with the um trials let's see how many we get on a fenus so we will travel here you can travel here through the drop pod if you want or you can just use the teleporter what we have on the ship you just automatically go to Aus cuz as you can see there's our drop pod as long as you have unlocked the aenas you can just teleport it straight away it's going about border L 3 I'm hoping they do a lot of that on Borderland 4 so jump down here if you need to get any ammo press you y on the vending machines and I am using my toring Inferno moles build as well so feel free to go and check out check out M this build so let's going through here oh there you go these are the normal bosses no spawn in yet the all the all know spawning straight away depends on the the spawning so it's just got going on through shooting the enemies all right here you go they're spawning in now Cel fog and they're all L up so the just drop a cering yeah's go so all this one two three four four out 30 let me know in the comments and tell me how you like to farm for the deod r yourselves do you like to do a Slaughter shaft do you like to do a fenus or it's any Tri is what you like doing as well to collect all the de Rings through here right we' got quite a few here so there one there take right through here through here can't see any more so we don't know which one to get what Oh I thought it was one he wasn't all right so we got 10 out of 30 all right no spawn in yet no all right can hear beeping sound that means the enemies responding yeah so the AR are spawn in randomly as well long you soon as you see that soon as you hear that little sound you know they're definitely spawn in it it's like a fre second sound way up here what we'll do we'll go this way because a lot of enemies spawn in the graveyard basically you want to go where there's plenty of enemies spawned in yet might spawn in in this side so we just out the entrance so the might just fall in around here so we got 17 out of 303 so need to carry on come on SP got Legend right but we don't want Legend he one no he's not one I might SP spawned in here but he haven't let's get out of here then what we'll do we're going to jump on to one of the trials this is one of my favorites to go to to get all the decord Rings straight into the pring grounds so we spawn in yeah if you feel that they're not spawning in is quick just try a different area or you can just redo Aus see the spawn in just this quick now SP there we go oh now they might spawn in now on spawn in so we got 19 Alpha quite that see freaking roll got quite a lot of loot dropping there's today I got one more so we can open the G make our way for I guess all right so we've already got a few more to get now then we can go to travel to Sentry 3 go to Maurice and we'll go through the portal and ship and that will take us to the castels spawning in now wow a lot of legendaries are dropping today right we have now got all 30 de coder Rings we will go and travel to S sh so what do then we can travel so so we go straight to the cry free ship we go to Maurice and we go through the portal now and that will take us to Jo Violet's Planet this planet rides me a lot of aenis so we go to Maurice talk to Maurice Maurice Rel on your completion now we go through this portal and that'll take us to Joy Violet's Planet so there you go a giant mansion the middle of nowhere surrounded by the ocean and mountains so we traveled here so there's sany 3 so there is Jo V's Mansion so I just go down the hill and if you've already unlocked it you can just teleport straight to the cartel hideout like always you got two vending machines you got your ammo vending machine you've got your Shields all and there always these to break you get Amo out of these and it looks like it's clv enemies sometimes it's clv sometimes it's the malan soldiers or sometimes it's the actual cartels Joy violets enemies but this time it's the clv always try and shoot the bags as well cuz they kind of like leak aridian so on there the meet tban and that one's the meaty got the meat dier so I I got some crazy names so this is the uh enter password laun lber it's it's in stages so this is the first gate and we need to go through so we can't try and aim for the bugs we can the I is still on kill down so this is the first set of gates we gone through nice I go hisone kill down some reason the enemies are not spawning this quick I don't know why do don't know take this long to spawn in oh suicide clv nice one down try for the legs a for the bug all right going through the gate gate is open so I got care for a hit we just died first time I've died on an actual [Music] video so when you die you always go back to the teleporter and near the main gates so just Cas of you want to get ammo you get your ammo want to change your Shield you still change your Shield plus all your loot what's dropped is already still on the floor so you don't lose any loot I'm tell you usually if you save and quit then you lose all your loot and all the enemies will respawn so we'll get through the second gate today we're doing this I don't know why it the enemies not spawning in it as quick yes so this is the main door to the mansion so a lot of enemies will come out through the doors and those was a spawning from anywhere trying shoo before to come out we go we go got some good crits there done spin around spin around I know where they sh from there we go main enemies will have a giant skull on the map so that's when you know they the the main mini bosses so there you go we got our first boss coming out now and it's JZ Joel Jo drops one of the weapons as well opq PQ needle gun or maybe might drop the fish SL so these enemies has got a chance to drop the muffins the legend muffins all right plus just Dro something so well the first one she's dropped is she's dropped the opq system with 29 11 5 * 2 maximum damage is not a god roll but she's dropped sometimes she can or he can drop the um main M uh main dedicated drop right what you do now we come to a fountain somewhere in this Mansion there's a gold mask what we need to collect it could be outside it could be anywhere so basically you just got to follow on the map looks like it's upstairs and also there's idian as well to collect for for a mansion I just got to F out it is basically follow out L the enemy spawning oh no I don't forget to pick up your ammo as well or proove and pick up your aridian give plenty cover this reading all way around as well [Music] we'll get an enemy in a minute come through them doors one down one down up here don't p videoan [Music] nice he's come fore now all right this this fish flap he drops the fish flap grenade Tak bit to kill him got to be patient has he dropped the fish slap no he's dropped the Watson he's dropped the devil's forcing no this time he hasn't dro the fish FL but he does normally drop the fish again they will drop Will drops as well but not the dedicated drops to over enemies so this is a reference to Scarface where he is that on his desk so you pick up the pick up the mask there also a puzzle as well certain books you pull on certain icons there is they all light up and you get access to the chest behind let me know in the comments if you figured out how to do the puzzles pretty much appreciated so we've now got the mask and now we need to just go back down to the Fountain there's different rooms in in the in the uh Manion there like there's another gold in charot as well thing is the mass isn't always at the right place it can sometimes be outside so you got to go to the main floor and travel outside today the mask is not too far so after we got the Mas we'll put the mask on the fountain then it goes all the way down to Jo's Hideout and also you may notice there's a room there if you if you go down there fast enough and jump you can get access to a weapon chest I didn't make it any time so here we go this is Joy violet so leave feel free to leave a comment down below and tell me if you managed to get the into the room all right this one I just got to take out the enemies take here's a machine that that's out all right now you got Franco can you need to take out Franco now going around take all the rooster ass uh no it was Jo violent now it do take AES to take out right we're down we need an enemy to spawn in there we go no second win he is the ultimate ra boss in these events we got anchor back I don't like the Spinners they really do mind at him we can just keep on him sometimes Joey's got an habit of glitching so he's he's bar doesn't go down and then you just got to basically then you just reset the game it's jumping at us get out of his way so about halfway on this bar getting the critical hits that's the main thing I see he's got himself stuck into the wall so that's fine yeah Joy Violet is is literally a raid boss just got to keep firing I could fire eight weapon like the beiger man is is the best is the best thing it's the light sh is a good one for Fast Fire rate like I say it's literally glitched so if it's glitching into the wall you know right all it's got his first shield on now so that's fine we'll just wait for a little bit ch is out take out the turrets you get about two or three turrets inside building there's joy this is like three stages of him he gets bigger and bigger I got these finish let's get anle on take all turret go around this again just this here we can try and leave one enemy FL about yeah he's kind of glitched over here so we can just carry on Sho him P back of it he going the last moon phase I can't s it again he's over there he's glitched so he just concate our fire on him get some Gren over there as well oh someone just spawned in jumped on us that's fine Focus all right okay there we go got one ball left the enemies are spawning in the enemies will just keep spawning in all the time till till he's down I'll there set up to out uh not now for to go he's really all resistant take out turret there we go another turret down and there we go so stand back in case any more enemies spawn in as they do normally do no enemies right let's see what's been dropped right first one is the hell Walker again another B drop um he's dropped the pus and he dropped the Watson right this time he hasn't dropped the opq the needle G the pew pew but normally he does drop but luckily before reloaded in I literally picked out all the weapons out the out my chest so the first one is cost effective Amplified the lpq system you can pick this up from cartels it's not the god roll but it's closest I have got to the God all F amount of damage we've got the needle gun again that's the closest I can get to the god roll the yellow cake that's my highest damage yellow cake I have got 9 3,264 that's as closes I have got to a god roll some mus here and the grease strap again that's the closest I've got to a god roll for the G strap which is pretty cool is very good on Zane this weapon I picked it up from my Zan Zan Vault Hunter this one I'm currently using on Zane and also he very good with mold as well and last but not least is it's the fish lap again this is closest I have got to a god roll two links the fish rubber eyes 12781 so that's the closest I've gotten to a good roll for the fish l so he got Health damage Shield damage and armor damage so it's the lpq the needle the yellow cake and the the greas Trap and also the fish slap let me know in the comments if you managed to get all the god rolls for each weapon and which is your favorite weapon you like to use in any of your builds like I said the op system opq is a really good weapon I've got a build for the opq on Infinity moles where I'm just basically using the opq system there's the pew pew again this as Clos as I've got to a a uh God roll so feel free to leave a comment down below and tell me which weapons you've managed to get the god rolls and have you managed to get all the weapons yourselves so dead all we you can get in the cartels so when you finish obviously check out the other loot like like I say it's all will drop so anything can drop in the cartel event we got blues and pick up some ammo and at the end you'll come to a chest and two of these sometimes you got Legend weapons in these as well well this time we got no Legend weapons so after you've completed it you travel back to mace you you automatic go straight to Sanctuary 3E ship which is also pretty cool and you can just redo the Cs every time just s in the mission now what we're going to do now so might automatic go to Maurice and she gives you on a world as well so let's see what road we get still inside the egg she's G us a epic Shield and if you want to redo the mission you just press M cward continue he might have a problem you can just reset the mission go and down to Pandora or slot sha or a fenus or the trials and just recollect the decoder Rings you go back to Maurice through the pole or you can just directly travel to Joy's Planet that's what I normally do myself CU you know he's already unlocked just say you're going back to the ship you can just travel straight to Joy Joy Violet Planet that's what I normally do and also you go onto your menu where you get your infantry your skill trees your ging rank your Mayhem and you go to here Revenge after the cartels challenges 13 out of 18 to complete so what is you get certain things to do kill crypto set full with cry damage that's great Canda smashan dust piles solve the puzzle in aut filet Mansion fine all golden toilet in the Violet Mansion before you leave kill fish SL with and Mele damage re done one defeat Joy Mr Good Stuff defeat Joy Viet in May one or greater three minutes off Play Time defeat Joy Violet only three minutes kill Joy ultraviolet without taking damage with laser traps and CFT traps and kill cartel enem members complete revenge of cartel's missions without dying kill cartel under bosses kill six under bosses in one M play through kill under bosses in May one a greater kill tenderizer while healing he is healing kill Franco fire wall with his own crypto spikes shoot meet sacks and burnt and gang members shoot B packs of P pure traps crew gang members so these are what you complete I've done 13 out of 18 so you literally unlock these you get trinkets you get skins so there you go got another trinket and unlock we've got another trinket so these we need to unlock so not bad so get three out of five unlocked and I don't 13 of 18 so let me know Below in the comments how many of the rewards you have unlocked and have you completed it 18 Al 18 much appreciated so that's the Revenge of the cartels okay but okay everybody I hope you all enjoyed this revenge of the Cel video on Border Alles 3 feel free to like share and subscribe to the channel be much appreciated and I'd like to thank you everyone for those support you all been giving me on my YouTube channel there's a lot more content to come we're going to do a bloody Harvest um event video and a lot of videos CU I'm pushing so many videos fre for bloodland 3 because obviously we' got blood lines 4 coming out sometime this year or next year so I know there's a lot of new people who still play Borderlands and people who still come back to Borderlands and just replay it so feel free to check out my other video as well on on our Channel basically just going to be pure waterin content coming your way so a big shout out to duby as well duby is a drinks company I am famed with um my followers and want who comment en join in in the chat or just press the link below you will get 10% of your first order you can also just get a shake it and couple of samples just to try out you like it as you can see in the background I've got the dby flavors and also different kind of Cups they use as well so highly recommended to go over to duby the website I'll leave the link below for you to go and check them out just have a good brows room they are in America and they do um sell worldwide so for me it's like 10 to 15 days deliver it to the UK but as you can see I've got plenty of these subs and it's different flavors so I highly recommend as well so guys um thank you for you all watching this video today we much appreciated and hopefully I'll see I'll see you all soon um if you like to come and check me out over on TWiT on Twitter my name is Andy attack 20118 and my Instagram page is Andy attack 2018 on Tik Tok and also feel free to drop by and say hello while we are streaming over on Twitch we do variety games as well especially Borderlands so from me and blue you can't see at the moment you just want see a low ahead for me I'm blue thank you all for watching stay well stay safe look after your friends family loved ones and take care yourselves I shall see you soon in the next one | Andyatk2018 | UCYd5McBo8FWUO7ad3unsIfA | 2024-02-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 4,035 | 19,541 |
CaF1kR8uXfE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CaF1kR8uXfE | Morals (Moralia), Book 2 | Lucius Mestrius Plutarchus | *Non-fiction, Classics (Antiquity) | 10/11 | section 33 of the morals vol 2 this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox.org recording by Luke's art or the morals vol 2 by Plutarch translated by several hands corrected and revised by William EE Goodwin how a man may be sensible of his progress in virtue part 1 my friend socios senecio is it possible do you think that all the arguments in the world can make a man sensibly assured that he is a proficient in virtue upon this supposition that his proceedings do not in the least alleviate and abate his folly but the device in him weighing in equal balance against his good inclinations hold him down as heavy LED pulls down the yielding net in the study of music or grammar I am sure such a conclusion would be very absurd for the scholar could never be certain that he had made an improvement in those sciences if all the while he is a learning he did not exhaust by little and little his former ignorance about them but it remained during the whole progress of his application under the same degree of unskillful 'no sat first setting out the like may be said of those that are under the hands of a physician according to this assertion if the patient take physic which does not recruit his strength will give him ease by a baking the severity of the distemper it is absolutely impossible that he should discern any alteration in himself before the contrary habit is perfectly and in the highest degree induced and his body thoroughly sounded well as in these instances you cannot say the persons have advanced in anything so long as they perceive no sensible change in themselves by the abatement of the contrary weight and do not find that their minds are elevated as it were in the opposite scale just so in truth is it with those that profess philosophy they cannot be assured of any progress or improvement if the soul do not gradually advance and purge off the rest of its former imperfections but still lie under the like equal pressure and grievance of pure absolute unmixed evil till it have attained the state of perfect supreme good for the truth of it is a wise man cannot in a moment of time change from the lowest degree of vice imaginable to the most heroic perfection of virtue if he only make a brisk attempt to throw off vice all at once and do not constantly and resolutely endeavor by little and little to realize the burden and diss possess the evil habit of it you know very well how much trouble those give themselves you maintain this assertion and what strange questions they raise with regard to it for instance why a wise virtuous man should never perceive how he became such but should either be quite ignorant or at least doubt that ever by little in little now adding something now subtracting and removing others he advanced to the aggregate perfection of virtue now if as they affirm the change from bad to good or either so quick and sudden as that he that was extremely vicious in the morning may become eminently virtuous at night or that anyone going to bed a wicked might chance to rise a virtuous man next morning and having all the former days errors and imperfections absolutely removed out of his mind might say to them as it is in the pot vain dreams farewell like specters haste away at the new light of virtues glorious day do you think that anyone in the world could be ignorant of so extraordinary conversion and perfectly shut his eyes upon the beams of virtue and wisdom so fully and manifestly breaking in upon his soul in my opinion if any person should have senses foolish wish and be changed as it is reported he was from one sex to the other it is more probable that such a one should be altogether ignorant of the metamorphosis then that any should from a lazy unthinking debauched fellow commence a wise prudent and valiant hero and from a SATA Sh bestiality advance to the perfection of divine life and yet no nothing at all of the change it is a very good advice measure the stone by a rule and not your rule by the stone but the Stoics have not observed it for they not applying principles to things but forcing things which have no foundation of agreement in nature to agree to their principles have filled philosophy with a number of difficulties one of the hardest to be solved is this that all men whatsoever except him who is absolutely perfect are equally vicious hence is that enigma called progress or proficiency which though it has puzzled the learner to solve is in my opinion very foolish for it represents those that have advanced a little and are partly free from ignored inert and his tempers of mind to be as unhappy as those that are guilty the most heinous enormities and indeed the assertion is so absurd that their own actions are enough to confuse it for while they're maintained in their schools that Aristides and phalaris are equally unjust that bursitis and Dolan are equal cowards in that Plato and mellitus are equally senseless still in all affairs of life they seem to reject and avoid the latter of these as too harsh severe to be softened into compliance but crediting quote the former in all their writings as persons of extraordinary Worth and esteem this is what the Stoics assert but we you can better agree with Plato in this point finding by observation that in all kinds of Evil's especially that of a weak and unmanaged disposition of mind there are several degrees of more and less for here in one advance differs from another that the miserable darkness which the soul lies under begins more sensibly to abate when reason by little and little illuminates and purges the soul may be bold to affirm that the change from bad to good is very easily and manifestly discernible not as if one were drawn out of a pit on a sudden and could give no account of the degrees of the ascent but so plain that the several steps and advances may be computed the first argument that comes in my mind is this by way of simile pray examine it you know the art of navigation when the cement heist sail for the main ocean they give judgment of their voyage by observing together the space of time and the force of the wind that drives them and compute that in all probability in so many months with such a gale they have gone forward to such or such a place just so it is in the study of philosophy one may if he minded give a probable conjecture of the scholars proceedings he that is always at his business constantly upon the road never makes any steps or halts nor meets with obstacles and lets in the way but under the conduct of right reason travels smoothly securely and quietly along may be assured that he has one true sign of a proficient this of the poet had many lesser numbers in account your total will to a vast sum amount not only holds true as to the increase of money but also may serve as a rule to the knowledge of the advance of everything else especially a proficiency in virtue reason besides its ordinary influence requires the constancy of application and address which is necessary unusual in all other affairs whereas on the contrary the irregular proceedings and inconsistent silly assertions of some philosophers do not only lay rubs in the way and break the measures of a virtuous improvement but seem to give great advantage device during their lingering and idling upon their journey to tempt them into by paths or have persuade them to return whence they set out astronomers tell us that planets after they have finished their progressive motion for some small time acquiesce and become stationary as they turn it now in the study of philosophy it is not so there is no point of rest or acquiescence during the whole procedure for the nature of progress is to be always advancing more or less the scales in which our actions are as it were weighed cannot at all stand in equilibria but our soul is continually either raised by the addition of good or cast with the counterpoise of evil therefore as the Oracle told the sir hands that they ought to fight continually day and night so you and every wise man ought to be perpetually upon your guard and if you can be assured that you maintain a constant combat with Vice that you are always at enmity with it and never so much has come to terms or receive any diversions applications or applications as so many heralds from the enemies camp in order to a treat you with it then you may with a great deal of confidence and alacrity go on with the management of your warlike expedition and very reasonably at last expect a conquest and enjoy a crown of righteousness for your reward it is another very good argument to prove that by labor and exercise you have shaken off all stupidity and sluggishness of temper and that you are arrived at a perfection of virtue if for the future your resolutions may be more firm in your application more intense than there were when you first set out this appears true if you but observe contrary in order to retreat you with it then you may with a great deal of confidence and alacrity go on with the management of your warlike expedition and very reasonably at last expect a conquest and enjoy a crown of righteousness for your reward it is another very good argument to prove that by labor and exercise you have shaken off all stupidity and sluggishness of temper and that you are arrived at a perfection of virtue if for the future your resolutions be more firm and your application more intense than they were when you first set out this appears true if you but observe its contrary for it is a very bad sign if after a small time spent in trial you find many and repeated intermissions or your affections yielding or cooled in the pursuit this may be illustrated by what is observable in the growth of a cane at first it appears above ground with a full and pleasing sprout which by little and little taper wires by a continued and equal distribution of matter rises to a very great height towards the root you may observe that there are formed certain steps and joints which are at a considerable distance from one another because there the juice is plentiful and strong but toward the top nutriment of particles vibrate and palpitate as if they were quite spent with the length of their journey and thereupon you see they form themselves many small weak and tender joints are so many supports and breathing places so it happens with those that study philosophy at first setting out they take long steps and make great advances but if after some attempts they perceived not in themselves any alteration for the better but meet with frequent checks and avocations the further they go ordinarily they faint make any excuses to be off from their engagement despond of ever going through with it the narrow pond proceed no father but on the contrary he that he's wind with desire flies that the proposed advantage and by a stout and vigorous pursuit cuts off all pretenses of delay from crowding in upon him or hindering his journey in love it is a sign the passion is predominant if the love would be not only placed in the enjoyment of the beloved object for that's ordinary but also troubled and grieved at the absence of it after a manner not unlike this many youngsters as I've observed stand affected at the study of philosophy at first they buckled to their work with the greatest concern and emulation imaginable but as soon as ever they diverted either by business or any little pretenses the heat of their affection immediately flies off and they sit there and ignorant and very well content but he that perceives the pleasing sting of love whose poignant joy his trembling heart doth move will not only show that he is a proficient by his virtuous demeanour and agreeableness in all company in discourse but if he be called from his beer you may perceive him all on fire in pain in our needs and whatsoever he does either alone or in company and so concerned that he's unmindful of his best friends till he is restored to the quest of his beloved philosophy all of us ought to imitate such a noble example in all our studies we must not be affected with good discourse only while we are in place as we are with rich fragrant perfumes which we never mind but while we are a smelling to them but if by chance marriage in a state love or a campaign take us from our business we must still hunger and thirst after virtue and the more our proficiency is advanced by so much the more author our desire to know what we have not attained disquiet and excite us to the further pursuit and knowledge of it the grave account which Hesiod gives a proficiency years in my judgment either the very same or comes very near to this which I have now set down proficiency is says he when all difficulties are removed all unevenness smooth and cleared in the way made easy and possible it must be smoothed by frequent exercise plead by beams of divine light that guide the way to true philosophy nothing at all of the clouds of doubt error or in constancy in good resolutions remaining which are is usually incident to learners in their first attempts upon philosophy as distraction and solicitudes art to those who sailing from a known land cannot yet discover the place whither they abound thus I have known impatience office ters skip over common and ordinary notions before they have learned or attained better and lose themselves in the middle of their journey in so troublesome amazed that they would be willing to return if they could to their primitive state of quiet inactive ignorance sexiest a nobleman of Rome may serve for an instance of this he quitted all officers and places of honor that he might more freely and undisturbedly apply himself to the study of philosophy at first he met with many difficulties and finding himself unable to encounter or conquer them add a very despair and despondency he had thoughts of throwing himself out of a little boat into the river Tiber parallel to this was a Merry story told by Diogenes of Sinope when he first put on his gown it happened to be at a time when the Athenians celebrated a festival with extraordinary banquets night drinking sports and pageantry usually great solemnities the philosopher as he lay in the holidays in the corner of the street muffled up in his clothes to try if he could take a nap had some running thoughts in his head which checked the resolutions he had taken as to a philosophical life and troubled him extremely he reasoned with himself that there was no necessity for his entering into so troublesome and singular a way of living that he thereby have deprived himself of all the sweets and pleasures of life and the like while he was thinking thus with himself he aspired as the story goes a mouse venturing toward him and now and then nibbling at a moldy crust that he had in his pouch this sight which is much turned his thoughts and made him vexed and troubled at himself as much on the other side what says he is the matter with the Diogenes thou seest as tiny mouse lives well and is very glad of those scraps but thou who must need to be a person of quality forsooth art extremely sorry and out of humor because they are Durst not feast upon down beds and canst not have the gentle privilege at this merry time to be drunk as well as others another rational argument of gradual proficiency is when a vacations are not frequent upon us and when they happen very short while the substantial rules and precepts of wisdom as if they had been violently driven out presently return upon our minds and dispossessed all empty trouble and disconsolate thoughts and because scholars do not only fancy to themselves difficulties big enough to divert their week resolutions but also often met with serious persuasions from their friends to leave their studies and because sometimes such smart jests and roles are put upon them as have often discouraged frequently quite converted the endeavors of some it may seem to you a very good argument of a proficient if you find yourself indifferent and I'm concerned in that point as for example not to be cut to the heart and rapine when you were told that such such persons by name your equals once live splendidly at court have married great fortunes or have appeared publicly at the head of a great many freeholders that are ready to vote for them for some great office or representatives place he that is neither discomposed nor very much affected by such news as this is manifestly in the right and has philosophy by the shore a handle for it is impossible we should leave admiring things which most men esteem if the habit of virtue were not deeply rooted in us to avoid passionately what everyone cries down maybe in some persons the effect of anger and ignorance but utterly to despise what is admired abroad is a certain side of true and solid wisdom and resolution with what satisfaction and complacency many persons advanced to such a height of virtue compare themselves with others and break out in these verses of soul on we will not change virtues immortal crown for a whole mine of gold gold is uncertain but what we possess is still our own and never can be less none can deny that it was a very great in Diogenes to compare his shifting from the city of Corinth to Athens and from Thebes to Corinth to the king of Persia staking his progress in the spring to Susur in winter to Babylon intermedia in summer nor was it an argument of a much less spirit in aegis Ilyas who hearing this same king of Persia styled the great presently asked in what is he greater than I if he be not just to than I am Aristotle himself had exactly such notions in the light case for right into Antipater about his scholar Alexander he says of him that he ought not to value himself in this respect that he was advanced above others for whoever had a true notion of God was really as great as he and Zeno too deserves to be mentioned who hearing Theophrastus commended above any of the philosophers for his number of scholars put it off thus his choir is indeed larger than mine but mine has the sweet of voices for all these instances you may collect this great truth that whenever you do by setting the comforts of virtue and the difficulties and errors of study one against the other perceive that you have utterly expelled all emulation jealousy and everything else that uses to disturb or discourage young men you may then assuredly conclude with yourself that you have made very laudable progress another argument of proficiency in virtue is the alteration of your very style of writing and is your way of managing any argument or discourse most of those that nowadays design for scholars in ordinary speaking do prosecute almost none but popular studies to furnish out discourse and make themselves as the phrase is plausible men some few of them there are who you like silly larks are taken with the glaring light of natural philosophy in measuring themselves by their own levity and conceit I think they are able presently to attain the height of that science others like young whelps display toes similarly love to snap and bite at one another I need to gratify contentious skeptical and sophistical humour which they had first got by bad tuition and yield managed studies some again as soon as even they are initiated in the principles of logic presently comments' Safa stirs others spend their whole time collecting sentences and historical narrations these as Ana Casas said of the Grecians that he saw no occasion they had for money but only to count and tell it over have nothing at all to do but go about seeing and repeating what they have collected in commonplace books without any other benefit or satisfaction from their Labour's to these you may apply that of an Tiffany's which one ingeniously turned to plato's scholars this N Tiffany said merrily that in a certain city the cold was so intense that words were congeal there soon as spoken that after some time they thought and became audible so that the words spoken in winter were articulated next summer even so the many excellent precepts of Plato which he instilled into the tender ears of his scholars scarce perceived and distinguished by many of them till they grew men and attained the warm vigorous summer of their age such a cool disposition to virtue and philosophy as that philosopher said was in Plato's scholars when Jung often lasts in the most of us as was hinted before till our judgments grow to a solid firmness and maturity and we begin to value those precepts that are able to beget a composure and greatness of mind and diligently to trace and follow those discourses and precepts whose tracks as it is nice ops fables rather look in wood than outward to ourselves rather than others Sophocles said of himself that in writing his tragedies he first of all debated and pricked the humor of a sheila's invention and then corrected the harshness and over artifice of his composition and last of all changed his very style and elocution the thing which is most considerably persuasive in which most of all conduces to good manners even so young students when they pass from the fullness and luxurious II of panegyric and declamation to that more solid part of philosophy that regulates manners and smooths all rugged and disorderly passions then begin really to attain true and solid proficiency here upon let me advise you this wherever you read the writings or here the aerations of the philosophers at hand always things more than words and be not taken with what is curious and of a delicate threading contexture more than that which is strong nervous and beneficial so also in perusing poems or histories be sure that nothing escapes you that is a positively said in relation to the cultivating of manners or the calming turbulent you moderate passions but always give it a note and make it surely your own saman des said that a student philosophy should be like a be that laborious creature when it is amongst flowers makes it its business industriously to extract the yellow honey out of the mall while others care and seek for nothing else except the smell and the color so while some others employ their time in reading the poets only for diversion or for the wheat and fancy which usually adorned their works you my dear friend like a bee amongst a swarm of drones observe and collect what is sweet palatable and worthy your pains and seemed already by your constant custom and application to have attained a perfect knowledge of what is eminently good and proper as to those that peruse the works Plato and Xenophon only for the Styles sake and do cull out what is elegant an attic as the cream and flower of those authors pray what do they do but as it were admire the fragrance II and flavour of medicinal drugs yet at the same time neither understand nor inquire after their healing in purgative qualities whereas those that have advanced to a higher degree of perfection can extract benefit not only from philosophical discourses but also from everything they see or do and thence draw something that may be proper and fit for their purpose I'll give you some examples of a stylus and other very eminent men which may be very pad to this purpose Heelys chanced to be a spectator at the is Mian Games where some were engaged at sward play seeing one of the combatants wound and observing that the theatre immediately made a great shouting and hollowing upon it he jogged one iron and an inhabitant of the island kyles in sat next to him and whispered him thus do you see what exercise can do here that his wounded holds his peace and the spectators cry out for a situs the Lacedaemonian captain by chance caught a mouse monks and dry figs and being bit by her let her go with this exclamation by Hercules there is no creature so little all so weak that he cannot preserve its life if it dares but defend it Diogenes may serve for a thousand instances when he saw a boy drink out of the palm of his hand he throw away his dish which he used to carry always with him in his wallet thus the duality and application have a singular virtue to make us knowing and able to extract motives to virtue from everything that we meet with for it's not a difficult matter to attain such a temper of mind if the candidates were virtue into mixed discourse and reading with their actions not only exercising themselves amidst dangers as Thucydides said to some but also engaging pleasures disputing hard questions examining precedents pleading causes and so on to try themselves thoroughly undertaking some magistracy or public office giving thereby demonstration of their opinions and resolution or rather establishing their resolution by exercise whereas those that are not bred to it but like novices spy out and catch it anything that is curious in books and pragmatically run away with it either to the exchange the college or some club or tavern deserve no more the name of philosophers than those quacks that only truck off vile drugs and potions merit the character and value of physicians those Sophists does seem to me not unlike the bird mentioned in Homer and to have something of its quality whatsoever they catch a broad they presently bring home with them and cram it into their unfledged chicks they're illiterate scholars starving their own empty crops the while as the poet hazard for they neither digests nor convert what they take into true nourishment it is then indispensably our duty so to manage a discourse it may be beneficial both to ourselves and others we're not incurring the censure of being thought vainglorious arrogant by any to be always ready to hear than to teach and especially so to abate and moderate or vehemence II and passionate quarreling about trivial questions as that we may cease to attend and manage disputations with the same indifference II as you may have seen some exercise hurled bats and cudgelling that is so as to leave the stage with more satisfaction for having had a true hitch or coming off conquer then for having either learned ourselves or toward our antagonist any manner of skill by the engagement an evenness in wildness of tampering all such affairs which never will suffer us to enter the lists of vehemence II and passion nor to be hot concerned in settling an argument nor to scold and give bad words when we have vanquished our adversary naught to be very much dejected if we chanced to be quite baffled is I think a true sign of a great proficient in virtue Harris deepest was a great example of this for when in a set disputation he was baffled by the sophistry and forehead of an impudent wild an ignorant disputant and observed him to be flushed and higher with the conquest well says the philosopher I am certain I shall sleep quieter tonight than my antagonist not only upon the close and event of our philosophical contests but even in the midst of disputation we may privately take an estimate of this good quality in us which is a sign of a true proficient for example if upon a greater appearance of Auditors than was expected we be not afraid nor in confusion if the thinness of the congregation when there are but a few to hear us we be not dejected and troubled and lastly if when we are to speak before a numerous or honourable assembly we do not for want of fitting preparation miss the opportunity for ever it is reported that to us famous orators as ever were demosthenes in our sabai ADIZ somewhat weak and faulty in this point the timorousness of the former is named every schoolboy and as for oursa by ADIZ though he was as must be confessed as the gosh isn't happy and his thoughts as any men whatever yet for want of a little assurance in speaking a thing he very often miserably lost himself in his pleadings for he would falter and make pauses in the very middle of his durations purely for want of a single word or some neat expression that he had in his papers but could not presently remember to give you another instance of the Prince of poets homer he was so blinded with an overconfidence of his abilities in poetry that he is slipped a false quantity and left it on record in the very first verse of his Iliad 's seeing then the learner dust man in greatest artists have failed and may fail for want of caution or confidence it ought more nearly to concern those that earnestly follow virtue not to slip the least opportunity of improvement either by company or otherwise and not over much to regard the throng or applause of the theater when they do exercise will make any solemn harangue end of section 33 recording by Luke's Otto griffith music wails sex 34 of the morals vol 2 this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox.org [Music] recording by Luke's art wall the morals vol 2 by Plutarch translated by several hands corrected and revised by William W Goodwin how a man may be sensible of his progress in virtue part 2 nor is it enough that one take care of all his discourses and durations but he ought also to observe that the whole Tanner of his actions be guided by profit rather than vain pomp and by truth rather than ostentation for if a passionate lover who has placed his affection upon any beloved object seeks no witnesses to attest its sincerity that has such an eager desire when alone and in private that like covered flame it burns more vigorously and insensibly for being shut up much more autumn oralist and a philosopher who has attained both the habit and exercise of virtue sit down self-contented and applaud himself in private neither needing nor desiring in Kamiya's or auditors from abroad there is a humour in some of the poets of an old peevish housekeeper they calls to his maid allowed do you see Dionisio that is his maids name I am now pleased and have laid by all color and passion just such like is the practice of some who as soon as they have done anything which is obliging and civil presently blazed it abroad and turn their own heralds such men show plainly that they look beyond themselves for satisfaction that they are desirous of praise and applause and that they never were admitted near spectators of virtue never saw her in her noble role dress I only had sub transient sight of her in a dream or an empty Airy phantasm and indeed that they exposed their actions to the public as painters do their pictures to be gazed at and admired by the gaping multitude any sign of a proficient in virtue is when the proficient has given anything to his friend or done any kindness for anyone if he keeps it to himself and does not blab it to anybody and which is more if he had voted right against a majority of biased suffragan 'he's withstood that dishonest attempts of some rich and powerful man generously rejected bribes were offered abstained from inordinate drinking when a thirst and alone or at night when none sees or knows what he does lastly if he hath conquered the brisket attempts of love as he said of Agassi Laius if I say he contained himself from speaking of such actions and do not encompassed of his performances this I affirm such a one as can prove and try himself by himself and be fully satisfied in the verdict of his conscience as of an unexceptional witness and spectator what is right and good show his plainly that his reason looks inward and is well rooted within him and that the man as Democritus said is accustomed to take satisfaction from himself to borrow a simile from husbandmen and those that are concerned in the business of the fields they are always best pleased to see those ears of corn which decline and by reason of their fullness bent downwards to the earth but look upon those as empty deceitful and insignificant which because they have nothing in them grow bolt upright and appear above the rest so Diaz amongst students in philosophy those that are most empty-headed and have least firmness and silly have always the greatest chair of confidence formality and stiffness in their address look biggest walk with the most state and table upon and condemn others with the highest arrogance and severity of any living but when once their brains begin to fill and become well poised with solid notions they look down into themselves and quietly aside that insolent and arrogant humor which is proper only to youngsters give me leave to illustrate this by one similarly more when you pour water into bottles or any other vessels upon its being instilled into them the air that was in them before presently flies out and gives place to the more substantial body even so it is with those that have had many good precepts instilled into them and their minds replenished with solid truths they presently find that all empty vanity flies off that the imposture of pride breaks that they do not value themselves for beard and Gowan only but bend their actions and endeavors to the bettering of their rational faculties and lastly that when they reprove they begin at home turning the edge of their satire in invective upon themselves even when at the same time they are civil and complacent to all others beside it is indeed an argument of a generous and truly brave disposition in a scholar not to assume the name and character of one and as some used to do to put the philosopher amongst his titles but if any out of respect chance to give him that compilation to be surprised blush and with a modest smile answer him in that of the pot you compliment your friend he whom you so commend must needs be more than man far more than I pretend a Shia says of a young woman that if ever she have played the wanton you may discover it in her eyes and read her affections in as glances which she cannot conceal so a young scholar if he be once entered in the mysteries and have tasted the sweets of philosophy cannot possibly suppress the passion and concern for it as Safra sells his tongue falters when he would speak its praise his heart is warm with affection a secret flame does run through every part you will admire and love the assurance and compose earnest of his looks the affectionate nurse of his eyes and especially the winning decency and agreeableness of his words and expressions those that are to be initiated in the ceremonies of the Gods run to their temples at first with a great deal of noise clamor and rudeness but as soon as the solemnity is seen and over they attend with the profound silence and religious fear so it is with the candidates in philosophy you may perceive a throng noise and father about the school dolls by reason that several press thither eagerly rudely and violently for reputation more than learning but when you were once in and manifestly see the great light as if some royal shrine were open unto you you are presently possessed with the quite different notion of things I struck with silence and admiration and begin with humility and a reverent composure to comply with and follow the divine Oracle that which men Adiemus said in another case is very opposite to this sort of men those that went to the School of Athens were first of all wise next lovers of wisdom then our raters and at last in course of time plain common men for the longer they applied themselves to study and philosophy so much the more all vanity pride and pageantry abated in them in the nearer they came to plain downright honest men again as it is with those that are indisposed and out of order some if a tooth or finger do partake presently run to a physician others sent for one to their houses if they find themselves but the least feverish and desire his advice and assistance but those that are either melancholic or or but anyways crazed in their heads cannot endure so much as the looks of a physician but either keep out of sight when he comes or command him to be gone being altogether insensible of their condition so in persons that commit any heinous crime or fall into any error I look upon those is perfectly incurable who take it ill to be admonished of their fault and look upon reproof and admonition as the greatest rudeness and incivility in the world whereas those that can quietly hearken and submit to the advice of friends and superiors deserve a more favorable opinion and may be thought to be of a much better disposition but the greatest character of hopeful men and such as maybe probably excellent proficient in time belongs to those who upon a commission of a fault immediately apply themselves to such as will reprove and correct them who plainly disclose the grief and open their malady who do not rejoice in concealing their distemper and are not content to have their troubles unknown lastly you make a full confession of what they have done amiss and desire the help of a friend to examine and direct them for the future Diogenes I am sure was of it this opinion he said that whatsoever would be certainly and constantly in the right must get either a virtuous good friend or an incensed ill-natured enemy to his monitor the one by gentle admonition to reprove and persuade him the other to work upon him by severity and all him into a virtuous course of life there is a sort of man in the world that are so vain and foolish is to take a pride in being the first discoverers of their own imperfections if they have better rent or spot in their clothes or have got a torn pair of shoes on that the most forward of any totality company and which is more they are very apt out of a silly empty arrogant humor to make themselves the subject of their drollery if they are of a dwarfish stature or anyway deformed yet which is strange these very men at the very same time endeavoured to excuse and Paley ate the internal imperfections of the mind in the more ugly deformities of the soul as Envy evil custom detraction voluptuousness etc it will not suffer any of one either to see your problem these are as it were so many saw places and they cannot endure to have them touched and meddled with such men as these I may be bold to say have very few signs of proficiency or rather none at all now on the contrary he that examines his own failings with the greatest severity that impartially blames will correct himself as often as he does amiss or which is almost as commendable grows firmer and better by present advice as well as more able and ready to endure a ref remand for the future seems to me truly and sincerely to have rejected and forsaken vice it is certainly our duty to avoid all appearance of evil to be ashamed to give occasion even to be reputed vicious yet evil reports the sowing considerable to a wise men that if he have a greater aversion to the nature of evil than to the infamy that attends it he will not fear what he said of him abroad nor what calumnies arised if so be he be made the better by them it was handsomely said of Diogenes when he saw a young spark coming out of a tavern who were the sight of him drew back do not retire says he for the more you go backward the more you will be in the tavern even so every vicious person the more he denies and paly aids face the more aggravates and confirms it in with surer footing goes farther into wickedness like some persons of ordinary rank and quality who while they assume above themselves and out of arrogance would be thought rich I made really poor in necessitous by pretending to be otherwise Hippocrates I mean a wonderful skill in physic was very ingenious in this point and fit to be imitated by the greatest proficient in philosophy he confessed publicly that he had mistaken the nature of the sutures in the skull and has left an acknowledgment of his ignorance upon record under his own hand he thought it very unworthy a man of his profession not as a scuffle where he was in the wrong seeing others might suffer and by his authority and indeed it had been very unreasonable if he whose business and concern it was to save others and to set them right should not have had the courage to cure himself and to discover his weakness and imperfections in his own faculty pyrin and by on two eminent philosophers have given rules of proficiency but they seem rather signs of a complete habit of virtue then a progressive disposition to it by on told his friend that they then might be assured of their proficiency when they could endure a reproof from anybody with the same indifference and unconcernedly as they could hear the highest-income eum's even such a one as this at the poet sir some heavenly flame inspires your breast live great rejoice and be forever blessed the other to wit Chiron being at sea and in great danger by reason of a tempest that arose took particular notice as the story goes of a hog that was on board which all the while very unconcernedly fed upon some corn which lay scattered about he showed it to his companions and told them that they ought to acquire by reading a philosophy such an apathy and unconcerned earnest in all accidents and dangers as they saw that poor creature naturally have the opinion which is said to be xenos may deserve a consideration he said that any one might give a guess his proficiency from the observation of his dreams if when asleep he fancied nothing that was he modest nor seemed to consent to any wicked actions or dishonest intentions but found his fancy in passions of his mind undisturbed in a constant calm as it were always serene and enlightened with the beams of divine reason this very notion was hinted by Plato as I interpret his words where he's describing and delineating the soul which is tyrannical in its nature and showing what manner of operations it's fantasy and irrational appetite exert when a man is asleep he says a vicious person designs the satisfying and sensuous lust has a longing for all sorts of meat in differently whether allowed or prohibited and satisfy his appetite and desire in all manner of intemperance which is loose and unregarded which in the daytime either the laws shame him out of or fear to offend restrains as now those brute beasts that are accustomed to labor will not if the reins be let loose either turn aside or offer to leave the track or stumble in it so it is with the brutal Faculty of the mind when it is once made tame and manageable by the strength of Reason then it is unwilling carelessly to transgress or saucily to disobeyed sovereigns commands or to comply with any inordinate lusts either in sleep or sickness but it carefully observes and maintains its dictates to which it is accustomed and by frequent exercise advances to perfect strength and intention of virtue we find even in our own nature the strange effects of custom man is naturally able by much exercise and the use of historical apathy to bring the body and all its members into subjection so that not one orchid shall perform its operations the eyes shall not burst out with tears upon the sight of a lamentable object the heart shall not palpitate upon the apprehension of fear and the passions shall not be roused at the sight of any beautiful person whether men or women now it is much more probable that the faculties of the sense may be so brought in subjection by undergoing such exercise as we speak of that all its imaginations and motions may be smooth made agreeable to right reason even when we are asleep and keep not century it is reported to still PO the philosopher that he thought he saw Neptune in his sleep and that he seemed very much displeased with him because he had not as was usual with his priests sacrificed an ox in honor of him not in the least daunted at the apparition he thus boldly accosted Neptune what's this business you hear complain of he come hither like a child and they're angry with me because I did not borrow money and run in debt to please you and fill the city with costly odors but privately sacrificed to you in my own house such ordinary victims as I could get at this confer reply machine smiled and as the story goes reached him his hand as an assurance of his goodwill to him and told him that for his sake he would send the megarians abundance of fish that season in the Maine we may conclude thus much that those that have clear and pleasant dreams and are not troubled with any fright strange vicious or irregular apparitions in their sleep may assure themselves they may have some indications and warnings of proficiency whereas on the contrary those dreams which are mixed with any pain fear cowardly aversions from good childish exhortation or silly grief so that they are both frightful and unaccountable I like the breaking waves or the billows of the sea for the soul not having attained a perfect evenness of temper but being under the formation of laws and precepts but from whose guidance and discovery it is free in time of sleep is then slackened from its usual intenseness and laid open to all passions whatever weather this temper we speak of being an argument or proficiency or an indication of some other habit which is taken deeper rich in the soul grown strong and immovable by all the power of reason I leave to you to consider and determine seeing then an absolute apathy or freedom from all passions whatsoever is a great and divine perfection and with all considering that progress seems to consist in exert remission and moderation of those very passions we carry about us it unavoidably follows that if we will observe our passions with a relation to one another and also to themselves we may easily find out their differences for example first you may observe from the passions compared with themselves whether our desires be now more moderate than they used to be fear and anger less in more calm and whether or not we are more able to quench the heat and flame of our passions than we used to be secondly by comparing them with one another we may observe whether we now have the greater share of shame than of fear where the emulation be without any mixture of envy whether we have greater desire of glory than of riches whether we offend as a musician's termit in the dorian or basil or in the Lydian or treble notes that is whether we had more inured to abstinence and a hardship than otherwise whether we are unwilling rather than forward to appear in public and lastly whether we are undue admirers of the persons or performances of others or despises both of them and what they can do as it is a good sign of recovery of the sick person in the distemper lion the less principal parts of the body so in proficiency if vicious habits be changed into more tolerable passions it is a symptom that they are going off and ready to be quenched fairness the musician 3/7 strings added two more was asked by the magistrates whether he had rather they should cut the upper or lower of them the bass or treble now it is our business to cut off as it were both what is above and below if we would attain to the true medium and equality for proficiency in the first place remits the excess in sweetens the harmony of the evil affections which is according to Sophocles the mad man's greatest pleasure in disease we have already said that we ought to transfer a judgement to action and not to suffer our words to remain bare and naked words but to reduce them to deeds and that this is the chiefest sign of a proficient now another manifest indication is a desire of those things we commend and of readiness to perform those things which we admire but whatsoever we dis commend neither to will orange or it is probable that all the Athenians highly extolled the courage and valor of milk IDs but Themistocles who professed that the trophies of Milty IDs broke his sleep and often forced him out of his bed not only praised and admire what he had done but was manifestly struck with a zeal and emulation of his performances therefore we may be assured that we have profited little while we think at a vanity to admire those that have done well and cannot possibly be raised to an imitation of them to love the person of any man is not sufficient accept it have a mixture of emulation no more is that love of virtue ardent and exciting which does not put us forward and create in our breasts instead of envy to them as zealous affection for all good men and a desire of equal perfection with them for it is not enough as our sabai ADIZ was wanted to say that the heart should be turned upside down by hearing the discourses of a philosopher and that the tears should gush from the eyes but he that is a proficient indeed comparing himself with the designs and actions of a good perfect man he's pricked it the same with the consciousness of his own weakness and transported with hope and desire and big with irresistible assurance and indeed such a one is as semana d says like a little suckling fold running by the mother's sled and desires to be incorporated into the very same nature with a good man for this isn't a special sign of true proficiency to love and effect their way of life whose actions we emulate and upon account of an honorable opinion we always entertain for them to do as they do but whosoever he is that entertains a contentious or malicious design against his betters that him be assured that he is possessed with a greedy desire of honour or greatness but has neither a true respect nor admiration for virtue when therefore we once begins so to love good men as not only according to Plato to esteem the wise man himself happy and him who hears his discourses sharer in his felicity but also to admire and love his habit gate look and very smile so as to wish ourselves to be that very person then we may be assured the we have made very good proficiency this assurance will be advanced if we do not only admire good men in prosperity but like lovers who were taken over with the less Pekin pale looks of their mistresses as are our speeds is said to have been smitten with the tears and dejected looks of a mournful and afflicted Panthea have an affection for virtue in its most mournful dress so as not at all to dread the banishment of Aristides the imprisonment of anaxagoras the poverty of Socrates nor the hard fate of Fosse on the to embrace and respect their virtues even under such injustice and upon thoughts of it to repeat this verse of Euripides how do all fortunes decently become a generous well tuned soul this is certain if anyone addresses himself to virtue with this resolution not to be dejected at the appearance of difficulty but hardly admires and prosecutes its divine perfection none of the evil we have spoken of can divert his good intentions to what I have said I may add this then when we go upon any business undertake any office or chance upon any affair whatever we must set before our eyes some excellent person either alive or dead and considered with ourselves what Plato for the purpose would have done in this affair whatever men on us would have said what Lycurgus or agus elias would have behaved themselves that addressing ourselves and adorning our minds at these mirrors we may correct every disagreeing word in irregular passion it is commonly said that those that have got by heart the names of the EDA doc Tilly made use of them as charms to drive away fear that they can but confidently repeat them one by one so the consideration in remembrance of good men being present and entertained in our minds do you preserve their proficiency in all affections and doubts regular and immovable whether you may judge this is also a token of a proficient in virtue you may observe further that not to be in a confusion not to blush not to hide or correct your clothes or anything about you at the unexpected appearance of an honorable and wise person but have an assurance as if you were often conversed with such is almost a perfect demonstration of a very intelligent person it is reported to Val exam de that one night seeing a messenger joyfully running towards him and stretching out his hand as if he had something to deliver to him he said to the apparition friend what news do you bring me is Homer risen from the dead that admirable monarch thought that nothing was wanting to his great exploits but such a herald as Homer consider this if a young man thrive in the world it is customary for him to desire nothing more than to be seen in the company of virtuous in good men to show them his whole furniture his table his wife and children his study his diary or collections and he is so pleased with himself he wishes his father or tutor were alive that they might see him in so good a way of living he could hardly pray that they were alive to be spectators of his life and actions but on the contrary those that have neglected their business or lost themselves in the world cannot endure the site or company of their relations without a great deal of fear and confusion join this if you please to what we said before for it is no more sign if the proficient does esteem every little Fault a great one and studiously observe and avoid all for as those persons who despair of ever being rich make little account of small expenses thinking that little added to a little will never make any great sum but when they come once to have got a competency and hope to be at last very rich it advances their desires so it happens in the affairs of virtue he that does not quiet his mind by saying with himself what matters it what comes after if for the present it be so and so yet better days will come but who attends everything and does not careless if the lease device pass uncondensed troubled and concerned at it such a one makes it appear that he has attained something that is pure which he brightens by use and will not suffer to corrupt for a preconceived opinion that nothing we have is valuable according to a Silas makes us careless and indifferent about everything if any one be to make a dry wall or an ordinary hedge it matters not much if he makes use of ordinary wood or common stone any old gravestones or the like so wicked persons who confusedly mix and blend all their designs and actions in one heap cannot what materials they put together but the proficient sin Verte you who have already laid the golden solid foundation of a virtuous life as of a sacred and royal building take a special care of the whole work examine and model every part of it according to the rule of Reason believing that it was well said by Poli Cletus that the hardest work remained for them to do whose nails must touch the clay that is to lay the top stone is the great business in masterpiece of the work the last stroke gives beauty and perfection to the whole piece end of section 34 recording by Luke's art or Griffith New South Wales section 35 of the morals vol 2 this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox.org [Music] recording by Luke's art or the morals vol 2 by Plutarch translated by several hands corrected and revised by William EE Goodwin of fortune mortals Affairs fortune not council rules and does not justice rule the affairs of mortals nor in partiality nor moderation nor decorum but was it of fortune and long of forging that Aristides remained obstinate in his poverty although he could have made himself master of much wealth and that skippy oh when he had taking a third neither received nor so much as saw any part of the beauty was it a fortune and long of fortune though fill aqua tees having received a sum of gold of King Philip laid it out in halls in fish and that last the nice and youth equities by measuring their happiness by their bellies in the most abject of follies lost Olympus was it a fortune that Alexander son of Philip refrained from the captive women himself and punished those that offered them any indignity while Alexander son of Priam long of an evil demon and fortune first V ciated his hosts wife and then took her away with him and filled both the continents with war and calamities and if such things as these can come by fortune what hinders but that we may as well plead that cats goats and monkeys are constrained by fortune to be ravenous lustful and ridiculous there be such things to be found as moderation justice and fortitude how can it stand with a reason there should not be such a thing as wisdom also and if there be wisdom how can it be but there must be good counsel for moderation is as they are used to say a certain sort of wisdom and justice cannot subsist without wisdom certainly we call that Good Counsel and wisdom that render us mindful in pleasures continence and moderation in dangers and hardships endurance and resolution and in communities and public business equality and justice and therefore if we will need have it that the effects of conduct belong to fortune let then both the effects of justice and moderation belong to fortune also now by Jove that stealing be ascribed to fortune - in cutting of purses and a lustful lewd life and let us query our reasoning quiet and turn ourselves loose to fortune to be carried and driven like filth and dust before an impetuous wind if there be no such thing as conduct it must have necessity followed that there should be no such thing is advising about our affairs nor any consultation or inquiry about utility and that Sophocles did talk idly when he said whatever is sought it may be caught but what we shun will from us run and when elsewhere he made this distribution of things I learn what's to be taught I seek was to be sought I beg the rest of heaven for what is to be sought or what is to be learned by mortals if all things go by fortune and what Senate of the Republic is not overthrown or what Council of the Prince is not solved if all things are subject to fortune which we use to upbraid with blindness because we blindly fall into it and indeed how can we otherwise choose when we first pluck good castle-like our eyes out of our heads and then take us a blind guide of our lives imagine that now some one of us should say cease affairs fortune not eyesight rules nor yet the eyes which Plato calls light bearers and again here is affairs are by blind fortune ruled and not by a certain power receptive of the strokes of the air conveyed to it through the organ of the ear and brain it would be same us then doubtless to pay a due respect to our sense at our sight hearing and smelling with the other parts of our bodies faculties were bestowed upon us by nature to minister unto good conduct and discretion and it is the mind that sees in the mind that he is the rest are deaf and blind and as within or the Sun we might for all the other stars pass our days in darkness as Heraclitus says so had man neither mind nor reason his life would be for all his senses nothing better than that of brutes but it is by neither fortune nor chance that we exceed them and bear sway over them but prometheus that is reason is the cause which gives both horse and us and oxen strong to carry us and ease our labour long as a stylus speaks for the greater part of brutes are much happier than we as to the fortune inform of their constitution but some of them are armed with horns some with teeth and some with stings and the urchins back say empedocles bristles with prickly thorns others again Arshad others are clad with scales others with shaggy hair and others with hard claws and hoofs but man alone as pedro speaks was left by nature naked unarmed unshod and uncovered but all those ills she sweetened with one gift reason care and forecast small is the strength of poor frail old man yet by his shifting wit he can enslave the arts and properties of all on land in sea and skies the lightest and sweetest things are horses but they run for men a dog is a fierce and an angry animal but it guards man fish is the sweetest thing in swine the fattest but they are man's nourishment and cheer what is bigger than an elephant but this also has become man's plaything and a spectacle of public solemnities and it learns to skip dance and kneel such things as these are not introduced in vain but that we may learn by them with the knowledge advances men and above what things it sets him and how it comes to be master and exceed all other things for we nor boxes nor good wrestlers are nor yet good runners yet in all these we are far more unhappy than the brutes but by our experience memory Witten dexterity as an axe acorus speaks we may use of what is theirs we press out there honey we milk them we catch them and drive them up and down as we please so that in all this there is nothing that depends on fortune but all on counsel and forecast moreover the affairs of carpenters are affairs of mortals and so are those of copper founders builders and statuaries among stream yet we can see nothing brought to perfection by chance or at random further there falls in but little of fortune to an expert artist with the founder or builder but that the most and greatest part of their workmanship it's performed by me art have been thus insinuated by a certain part go forth into the street he craftsman all who on green village Dogana to call that stuck with sacred baskets all around for the trades have a Ghana and Minerva for their patroness and not fortune it is indeed reported of one that as he was drawing a horse and had hit right in all the rest both shapes and colors but was not well satisfied with the draught he had made of a puff of froth that was tempered by the bit and wrought out with the horses breathing he therefore had often wiped it off but that at length he integrate fumes struck his sponge full of colours as it was against the board and that this as it lighted to admiration made a most lively impress and so filled up what was defective in the piece this is the only artificial work of fortune that history mentions artists everywhere make use of rules blinds measures and arithmetical proportions that their works may know where have in them anything that is casual or fortuitous and the truth is arts are styled the sort of petit wisdoms though there might be much better called certain shadings or filings of it sprinkled upon the several needful services of human life as is obscurely riddled to us in the fire faint to have been / prometheus and then scattered up and down the world for just so certain little particles and fragments of wisdom as it were crumbled and broken small fell into ranks and methods it seems therefore very strange how it came to pass that arts should stand in no need of fortune to compass their proper end but that which is the greatest and most complete of all arts in which is the very sum of bands worth and commendation should prove to be nothing at all but there is a kind of good counsel than stretching and slackening of strings which they call the art of music and in dressing of meats which we call cookery and in washing of clothes which we call the art of fooling and we teach our children how to put on their shoes and clothes and take their meat in their right hand and hold their bread in their left as being sensible that even such common things as these do not come by fortune but require attention and heed but do the greatest things and the most important to a happy state require no wisdom and have no share in rational proceeding and forecasts yet no man ever wet and clay and then left it as if there would be bricks by chance and fortune nor having provided wool and leather sat him down and prayed to fortune that they might be made clothes and shoes for him nor can any man when he hath amassed together much gold and silver and furnished himself with a multitude of slaves and attendants and enclosed himself in a great palace with many gates and set out costly couches and tables fancy to himself that if he have not wisdom with them these things will be his happiness and an undisturbed blissful and unchangeable life one asked if Fikret is the general by way of torned what he was for he was neither spearmen nor Archer nor yet bore light Armour I am replied he one that commands and uses all these in like manner wisdom is itself neither gold nor silver nor Fame nor wealth health north strength nor beauty what then is it is it what can use all these with decora and by means of which every one of these is made pleasant commendable and useful and without which they become useless unprofitable and prejudicial and the burden and shame of their possessors hazards Prometheus therefore gives very good advised Epimetheus brother be sure you never take a boon from Jove but gift in back meaning things of fortune and external for as if he had beat him not to play on a flute if ignorant of music nor to read a book if he knew not his letters nor to ride if he understood not a horse so it would be if he advised him not to govern if a fool nor to be a rich man if a miser and not to marry if apt to be ruled by a woman for success above desert is to Falls an occasion of miss thinking as demosthenes saith yes and good fortune above desert is to the unwise and occasion of miss dooming and of section 35 recording by league site or Griffith New South Wales section 36 of the morals vol 2 this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox.org recording by Lucas our tour the morals vol 2 by Plutarch translated by several hands corrected and revised by William W Goodwin of virtue and device it is apparent that clothes make a man warm not by warming him themselves or by imparting heat to him for every garment is of itself cold which is the reason that we see those that are very hot and in a fever often shifting and changing one thing for another but what heat a man exhales out of himself that the garment lying close to his body keeps together and contracts and when it hath driven it inward it will not suffer it again to dissipate this being the very case of external affairs - it is this that cheats vulgar heads but making them think that if they might but enclose themselves in great houses and heaped together abundance of slaves and riches they might then live to their own minds but an agreeable in gay life is not to be found without us on the contrary it is man that out of his own temper as out of a spring adds pleasure and gaiety to the things about him the house looks merrier when the fire burns and wealth is the more agreeable and Fame and power the more resplendent when they had the joy of the mind to accompany them since we see how that through a mild and tame disposition men can bear poverty banishment an old age easily and sweetly for his odors perfume threadbare coats and poor rags our prints and cases also sent for the loathsome purulence when the foul tent dripped on his purple robe even so every state and condition of life if accompanied with virtue is undisturbed and delightful but when vices intermixed it Randers even things that appear splendid sumptuous and magnificent most distasteful nauseas and unacceptable to the possessors this man's thought and happy in the marketplace but when he opens his doors hell is his case the woman governs all commands and brawls though one may without any great difficulty get rid of a weakened cross-grained wife if you be but a man and not a slave but a man cannot write a bill of divorce to his vice and thereby free himself from further trouble and procure his own repose by living apart but it still cohabits with him and dwelled in his very bowels and Cleaves to him both by night and by day it burns without torch and hastens crude old age being through its vain glory of burdensome fellow traveler and through its veracity a chargeable table companion and two troublesome bed fellow by breaking in spoiling one sleep night with cares anxieties and surmises for when he does sleep his bodies indeed at rest and quiet but his mind is through superstition in terrors dreams and frights when in my slumbers sorrows fill me then frightful dreams and visions kill me saith one just thus Envy fear anger and lust affect us for by daytime our vice by looking abroad and fashioning herself to the manner of others grows shamefaced and finds herself obliged to mask her own disorders and does not yield herself up wholly to our appetites but oftentimes resists and struggles with them but in times of sleep when it escapes both the opinions of men and the laws and is that the remotest distance from all and respect it stirs every desire and raises up its malignity and lewdness for it attempts as Plato speaks in braces of a mother it pervades unlawful meats and refrains from no sort of action enjoying villainy as far as it is practicable in shades and phantoms at end in no real pleasure or accomplishment of desire but have only power to stir up and enrage disorders and distempers where then is the pleasure of vice if there be nowhere to be found either freedom from care or exemption from trouble or satisfaction or undisturbedly or repose a sound complexion and good health of body give indeed both place and birth to the flesh as pleasures but they cannot be engendered engaging cheerfulness in the mind unless under water dis assurance or an immovable serenity be the foundation nay if some hope or satisfaction should simple a little this would be soon coddled and disturbed by some sudden eruption of care like a smooth sea by a rock heap up gold gathered together silver raised up walks fill your house with slaves in the town with debtors if you do not appease the disorders of your own mind and stint your insatiable desire and deliver yourself from fears and cares you do but wrack wine for a man in a fever and administer honey to a man disturbed with the bile and prepare meat in good cheer for people that have the flux or grapes you can neither retain it nor be strengthened by it but are over and above spoilt by it do you not see how sick persons the loath spit out and refuse the finest and most costly meats though they be proffered and forced upon them and how again when their complexion alters and good spirits sweet blood and acai natural heat are engendered they get up and gladly and willingly eat brown bread cheese and crises such disposition as this is it that reason works in mind and you will have sufficiency if you will but learn what a notable and generous mind is you will live luxuriously in poverty and be a prince and you will be as much in love with the vacant and private life as with that of a general or king if you once apply to philosophy you will never live without pleasure but you will learn to be everywhere pleased and with everything you will be pleased with wealth for making you beneficial to many and with poverty for not having much to care for with Fame for being honored and with obscurity for being on an bid end of section 36 recording by leaks title griffith new south wales section 37 of the morals vol 2 this is a librivox recording all librivox recordings are in the public domain for more information or to volunteer please visit librivox.org recording by Larry Wilson the morals vol 2 by Plutarch translated by several hands corrected and revised by William W Goodwin conjugal precepts part 1 plutarch - poly honest and your DC sendeth greeting now that the nuptial ceremonies are over and the priestess of Ceres has joined you both together in the bans of matrimony according to the custom of the country I thought a short discourse of this nature might not be either unacceptable or unseasonable but rather serve as a kind Pepa thalam IAM to congratulate your happy conjunction more especially since there can be nothing more useful in conjugal society than the observance of wise and wholesome precepts suitable to the harmony of matrimonial converse for among the variety of musical moods and measures there is one which is called HIPAA Thoris a sort of composition to the flute and hot boy made use to encourage and provoke stallions to cover mares but philosophy being furnished with many noble and profitable discourses the not anyone subject that deserves a more serious study than that of wedlock whereby they who are engaged in a long community of bed and board are more steadfastly united in affection and made more pliable one to another in humor and condition to this purpose having reduced under several short heads and similes some certain instructions and admonitions which you as tutored up in philosophy have frequently already heard I send you the collection as a present beseeching the muses so with their presence to assist the goddess Venus that the harmony of your mutual society and complacency in domestic diligences may out cry the melodious Conchords of lute and harp while you live United together by reason and philosophy therefore it was that the ancients placed the Statue of Venus by that of mercury to signify that the pleasures of matrimony chiefly consists in the sweetness of conversation they also set the graces in the Cedella of the goddess of eloquence together to show that the married couple were not to act only by persuasion and not to use the violence's of wrangling and contention one salon advices that the bride should eat a quince before she entered the nuptial seats intimating thereby in my opinion that the man was to expect his first pleasures from the breath and speech of his new married bedfellow to in BO Asia it is the custom when they Veil the virgin bride to set upon her head a chaplet of wild asparagus which from a thorny stalk affords a most delicious fruit to let us understand that a new married man discreetly Brooking at the beginning the first distaste of marriage restraints grows yielding ly complacent at length and and makes conforming wedlock a happiness to each and indeed such husbands who cannot bear with the little disdains and first FRA possessive imprudent youth are like to those that choose the sour grapes and leave to others the ripe delicious clusters on the other side those young lady that take a disdain to their husbands by reason of their first debates and encounters maybe well compared to those that patiently endure the sting but fling away the honey free it especially behooves those people who are newly married to avoid the first occasions of discord and dissension considering that vessels newly formed are subject to be bruised and put out of shape by many slight accidents but when the materials come wants to be settled and hardened by time nor fire nor sword will hardly prejudice to solid substance for fire takes speedy hold of straw or hares fur but soon goes out again unless fed with an addition of more fuel thus that same love whose flames are nourished only by heat of youth and loser charms of beauty seldom proves of long continuance our grows to wedlock maturity unless it have taken a deep root in conformity of manners and mutual affection will be enlivened by the intermixture of souls as well as bodies while prudence and discretion feed the noble flame 5 they who bake their hooks with intoxicated drugs with little pains surprised the hungry fish but then they prove unsavory to the taste and dangers to eat thus women that by the force of charms and filters endeavour to subdue their husbands to the satisfaction of their pleasure become at length the wives of madmen thoughts and fools for they whom the sorceress Circe had enchanted being then no better than swine and asses were no longer able to please or do her service but she loved Ulysses entirely whose prudence avoided her venomous intoxications and rendered his conversation highly grateful 6 they who rather choose to be the mistress of senseless fools than the obedient wives of wise and sober husbands are like those people that prefer miss guidance of the blind before the conduct of them that can see and know the way 7 they will not believe that passeth a the consort of a prince could ever be enamored of a bowl and yet themselves are so extravagant as to abandon the Society of their husbands men of wisdom temperance and gravity and be take themselves to the Beast Yule embraces of those who are given wholly to right and debauchery as if they were dogs or goats ate some men either unable or unwilling to mount themselves into their saddles through infirmity or laziness teach their horses to fall upon their knees and in that posture to receive their riders in like manner they are some persons who have a married young ladies not less considerable for the nobility of their birth than their wealthy dowries take little care of themselves to improve the advantages of such a splendid conjunction but with a severe moroseness labor to depress and degrade their wives proud of the mastery and vaunting in domestic tyranny whereas in this case it becomes a man to use the reins of government with as equal regard to the quality and dignity of the woman as to the stature of the horse 9 we behold the moon then shining with a full and glorious orb when farthest distant from the Sun but as she warps back again to meet her illustrious mate the nearer she makes her approach the more she is eclipsed until no longer seen quite otherwise a woman ought to display the charms of her virtue and the sweetness of her disposition in her husband's presence but in his absence to retire to silence and reserve it nests at home 10 nor can we approve the saying of Herodotus that a woman lays aside her modesty with her shift for surely then it is that a chaste woman chiefly veils herself with bashfulness when in the privacies of matrimonial duties excess of love and made in reverence become the secret signals and testimonies of mutual affection 11 as in musical Conchords when the upper strings are so tuned exactly to accord the base always gives the tone so in well regulated and well ordered families all things are carried on with the harmonious consent and agreement of both parties but the conduct and contrivance chiefly redounds to the reputation and management of the husband twelve it is a common proverb that the son is too strong for the north wind for the more the wind ruffles and strives to force a man's upper garment from his back the faster he holds it and the closer he wraps it about his shoulders but he who so briskly defended himself from being plundered by the wind when once the Sun begins to scald the air all in a dropping sweat is think constrained to throw away not only his flowing garment but his tunic also this puts us in mind of the practice of most women who being limited by their husbands in their extravagance of feasting and superfluities of habit presently fill the house with noise and uproar whereas if they would but suffer themselves to be convinced by reason and soft persuasion they would of themselves acknowledge their vanity and submit to moderation 13 Cato ejected a certain Roman out of the Senate for kissing his wife in the presence of his daughter it is true the punishment was somewhat too severe but if kissing and calling and hugging in the sight of others be so unseemly as indeed it is how much more indecent is it to chide and Baal a maunder at one another while strangers are in company if lawful familiarity and caresses between man and wife are not to be allowed but in their private retirements shall the bitter interchanges and now discoveries of invective and inconsiderate passion be thought and entertainment pleasingly proper for unconcerned and public ears 14 as there is little or no use to be made of a mirror though in a frame of golden chaste with all the sparkling variety of the richest gem unless it render back the true similitude of the image it receives so is there nothing of profit in a wealthy dowry unless the conditions the temper the humor of the wife be comfortable to the natural disposition and inclination of her husband and he sees the virtue of his own mind exactly represented in hers or if a fair and beautiful mirror that makes a sad and pensive vis each looks gioconda and gay or a wanton or smiling countenance show pensive and mournful is therefore presently rejected as of no value thus may not she be thought an angry peevish and importunate woman that louts and lowers upon the caresses of a husband and when he courts the pastime of her affections entertains him with frumps and taunts but when she finds him serious in business alors him then with her unseasonable toys to pleasure and enjoyment for the one is an offence of impertinence e the other a contempt of her husband's kindness but as geometrician 'he's affirmed that lines and surfaces are not moved of themselves but according to the motions of the bodies to which they belong so it behooves a woman to challenge no peculiar passion or affection as her own but to share with her husband in business in his recreations in his cares and in his mirth 15 as they who were offended to see their wives eat and drink freely in their company dooba whet their appetites to glut and gourmand eyes in corners by themselves so they who refused to frolic in retirement with their wives or to let them participate of their private pastimes and dalliance --is do but instruct them to cater for their own pleasures and delights 16 the Persian kings when they contain themselves within the limits of their usual banquets suffer their married wives to sit down at their tables but when they once designed to indulge in provocations of amorous heats and wine then they send away their wives and call for their you buys their gypsies in their song stresses with their lascivious Tunes and wanton galleons wherein they do dwell not thinking it proper to debauch their wise with the tipsy frolics and des aleut extravagances of their intemperance if therefore any private person swayed by the unruly motions of his inconstancy happen at any time to make a trip with a kind she friend or his wife's chambermaid it becomes not the wife presently to lure and take pepper in the nose but rather to believe that it was his respect to her which made him unwilling she should behold the follies of a pariah T and foul and temperance seventeen Prince's that be addicted to music increased the number of excellent musicians if they be lovers of learning all men strive to excel in reading and in eloquence if given to martial exercises a military ardor arouses straight the drowsy sloth of all their subjects thus husbands effeminately finical only teach their wives to paint and polish themselves with borrowed luster the studious of pleasure render them in modest and on the other side men as serious honest and virtuous conversations make sober chaste and prudent wives 18 a young lass Adamo nian lass being asked by an acquaintance of hers whether she had yet embraced her husband made no answer no but that he had embraced her and after this manner in my opinion it behooves an honest woman to behave herself toward her husband never to shun nor to disdain the caresses and dalliance --is of his amorous inclinations when he himself begins but never herself to offer the first occasion of provocation for the one savors of impedance a harlotry the other displays a female pride in imperiousness void of conjugal affection 19 it behooves a woman not to make peculiar and private friendships of her own but to esteem only her husband's acquaintances and familiars as hers now as the gods are our chiefest and most beneficial friends it behooves her to worship and adore only those deities which her husband repute s-- and reverences for such but as for quaint opinions and superstitious innovations let them be exterminated from her outermost threshold for no sacrifices or services can be acceptable to the gods performed by women as it were by stealth and in secret without the knowledge of the husband 20 Plato asserts those cities to be their most happy and best regulated where these expressions this is mine and this is not mine our Silva must made a use of for that then the citizens and joy in common so far as is convenient those things that are of greatest importance but in wedlock those expressions are utterly to be abolished for as the physician says that the right side being bruised or beaten communicates its pain to the left side so indeed the husband ought to sympathise in the sorrows and afflictions of the woman and much more does it become the wife to be sensible of the miseries and calamities of the husband through the intent that as nots are made fast by knitting the boughs of a thread one within another so the ligaments of conjugal society may be strengthened by the mutual interchange of kindness and affection this nature herself instructs us by mixing us in our bodies while she takes apart from each and then blending the whole together produces a beam common to both to the end that neither may be able to discern or distinguish what was belonging to the other or lay claim to assured propriety therefore his community of estate and purses chiefly requisite among married couples whose principal aim it ought to be to mix and incorporate their purchases and disbursements into one's substance neither pretended to call this hers or that his but accounting all inseparably peculiar to both however as in a goblet where the proportion of water exceeds the juice of the grape yet still we call the mixture wine in like manner the house and estate must be reputed the possession of the husband although the woman brought in the chiefest part 21 Helen was covetous Paris luxurious on the other side Ulysses was prudent Penelope chaste happy therefore was the match between the latter but the nuptials of the former brought an Iliad of miseries as well upon the Greeks as barbarians 22 the question being put by some of his friends to a certain Roman why he had put away his wife both sober beautiful and chaste and rich the gentleman putting forth his foot and showing his buskin said is not this and you had some complete shoe yet no man but myself knows where it pinches me therefore ought not a woman to boast either of her dower her parentage or beauty but in such things as most delight a husband pleasantness of converse sweetness of disposition and briskness of humour there to show nothing of harshness nothing distasteful nothing offensive but from day to day to study behavior Jacques in de Blythe and conformable threw his temper for as physicians are much more afraid of fevers that proceeded from hidden causes which have been by little and little contracting for a long time together then those that receive their nourishment from apparent and manifest unkink Auctions thus if daily continued the petty snubs and frumps between man and wife though perhaps unknown to others or of that force that above all things else they canker conjugal affection and destroy the pleasure of cohabitation 22 King Philip so far doted on a fair thulasi and lady that she was suspected to have used some private arts of fascination towards him wherefore Olympius laboured to get the supposed sorceress into her power but when the Queen had viewed her well and duly examined her Beauty beheld the graces of her deportment and considered her discourse be spake her no less than a person of noble descent and education hence fond suspicions hence Vayner Cullum knees said she for I plainly find the charms which thou makest use of or in thyself certainly there for a lawful wife surpasses the common acceptation of happiness when without enhancing the advantages of her wealth nobility in form or vaunting the possession of Venus cestus in itself she makes it her business to win her husband's affection by her virtue and sweetness of disposition 24 another time the same Olympius understanding that a young courier had married a lady beautiful indeed but of no good report said sure the Hotspur had little brains otherwise he would never have married with his eyes for they are fools who in the choice of a wife believe the report of their sight or fingers like those who tellin out the portion in their thoughts take the woman upon content never examining what her conditions are or whether she is proper to make him a fit wife or no.25 Socrates was want to give this advice to young men that accustomed themselves to their mirrors if ill-favored to correct their deformity by the practice of virtue if handsome not to blemish their outward form with inward vice in like manner it would not be a miss for a mistress of a family when she holds her mirror in her hands to discourse her own thoughts if deformed thus should I prove lewd and wicked too on the other side thus the fair one what if chaste beside for dads a kind of veneration to a woman not so handsome that she is more beloved were the perfections of her mind than the outside graces of her body 26 Dionysius the tyrant of Sicily sent several costly presents of rich apparel necklaces and bracelets to the daughters of Lysander which however the father would never permit the virgins to accept saying these gaudy presents will procure more infamy than honor to my daughters and indeed before Lysander Sophocles in one of his tragedies had uttered the following sentence to the same effect mistake not silly wretch this pompous trim rather disgrace then proclaims the great and shows the rage of thy lascivious Heat for as kratie said that is ornament which adorns and that adorns a woman which renders her more comely and decent this is an honor conferred upon her not by the lustre of gold the sparkling of emeralds and diamonds nor splendor of the purple tincture but by the real embellishments of gravity discretion humility and modesty 27 they who offer to Juno as the goddess of wedlock never consecrate the gall with the other parts of the sacrifice but having drawn it forth they cast it behind the altar which constitution of the lawgiver fairly implies that all manner of passionate anger and bitterness of reproach should be exterminated from the thresholds a nuptial cohabitation not but that a certain kind of austerity becomes the mistress of a family which however should be like that of wine profitable and delightful not like a loath biting and medicinally ungrateful to the palate end of section 37 you | Priceless Audiobooks | UCly1zcKPGzGW9wZMCZodWOA | 2018-03-27 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 16,403 | 90,123 |
tp7egTTiQCI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tp7egTTiQCI | Five Nights At Hickey's Remastered Nights 1 And 2 | [Music] hey everybody angela bottle here and welcome to five nights at hickey's remastered well this is a fnaf fan game made by eli 667 hickey voiced by patrick the stone phone guy and looney voiced by locksmir larson fanath made by scott kathleen which is the inspiration for every fnat fan game and this game was released this year in 2021 anyways ralph furdue will start a new game soon as another for us [Music] oh we have a newspaper okay new night shift job open at local animatronic diner after the unfortunate resignation of the former night guard at the infamous hickeys diner the position is and i didn't get to finish reading that okay so what's next oh just jumps into that one that's definitely a nice touch with the tv right there okay here we go on 291 let's see what has to offer for us space for the camera a for the door d left or d for the right door click on tv to activate uh hello [Applause] there we go hello uh hey how are you doing stephen um it's my job to instruct you on a few things that you can expect to see during your first night here at the job i know it can be pretty stressful starting out here especially in the position you're in a power model but don't i love pepsi so i'm sure you've heard a lot of rumors about this place and disappearances and whatnot and then had a fun incident a while back yeah um but i don't pay any money to that i just want you to forget all about that and focus on your work all right good now [Applause] let's go to basics if you follow the company's email you should be in the security office right good good now if you look around and you'll see a few things you should take note of the main thing being a tablet that the company provides for you should be on the table right there you can use that to look around the entire building using cctv cameras that we designed specifically for the service now along with this there's also a remote that you can use to close and open the two large metal doors on the side of you now now i know what you're thinking why on earth would i need these big doors well it's quite simple but we they were installed a while back after one of the guards complained that if someone broke in oh they just moved oh somebody just moved i heard someone talking so at up to a night generator that we keep in the basement how this generator works is well certain things around the building such as the tablet doors etc will drain the power [Applause] [Music] [Applause] there's no way to recharge it except going to the basement but if you've got the company's memo then only then only higher ups can go into the basement so i guess you're just gonna have to try to reserve that element and just try not to use the doors or the tablet too much keep that in mind you can view how much power you have using the tablet um and one more thing oh yeah yeah so if you look around and then there's one more thing you should pay attention to in your office on the back there there's a little screen if you click on them then you should be introduced to a power interface well the backup generator that we got is kind of cheap and every now and then tends to go offline you really don't want to um [Applause] let me check well [Applause] when the advertisers arrive to my door it means i have to close all right so the character in the green shirt showed up to the right door so i gotta close it are you sure about that can they actually harm you okay he left that guy left good she can open the door again um all right so apparently i do not need to check the camera as much for night one i only i'm only going to check it just for the time and to see if anybody is on the left office and right office hallway camera which i don't do it much so that's a good thing all right so yeah that's really all i got okay i'm running low on power i gotta conserve it's almost 5 am all right there's nobody nearby so i can just keep the camera down for a little while let me check the time it is 5 am okay [Music] oh i gotta repair that um camera system thing i heard i heard an error sound so i gotta repair this there you go repaired the camera and the power maintenance panel kill me [Music] okay so whenever something if something if one of the power models brings blinks red it means i have to fix it in the power maintenance cam okay he's coming near me so i gotta wait till he comes then close the door and i'm already running low on power so i gotta conserve it and we beat knight once so that's a good thing oh and it still shows the power draining look at that i don't know that's probably a bug or something but anyways let's see what's next night two code three two p oh so we got a passcode for each night okay i gotta write this down on my on my notes on my piece of paper i have around here somewhere okay let me see i'm actually going to go grab my phone because i don't have a paper near me because i'm going to take a picture of the night codes so that i can remember it for night two wherever my phone is let's see yeah sorry i turned the lights off the light on i gotta look for my phone right now or my ipad whichever i can find i'll just use my ipad to take the photo which i'm going to take the photo of the knight 2 code right now which is 32p alright took the picture i took the picture there we go hmm what do i do okay i don't know why it's stuck in this section do i like skip okay so i'm actually going to close out of the game then restart it to get to knight 2 because i don't know what's going on here but since i got enough time left in this video we're going to take on knight 2 as well once i get this game once i get five nights at hickeys remastered software and slash game whatever you want to call it start it up so i'm getting it started up right now because this is one of those games that runs on like a flash player from like scratch or something i can't remember the name of it all right so on to night two and there is hickey himself the clown all right so we got under passcode pascal 492 is 32p so i'm gonna answer that there we are now we can get tonight too [Music] this game reminds me a lot of five nights at chuck e cheese's i mean i mean sorry this game reminds me a lot of those nights at chuck e cheese's as well as um five nights at nintendo landed five nights as smart as one because we had to enter a passcode for those games same with the five nights at the smash bros series we had to enter past those with those games alright so on to night two let's see what has to offer for us uh hello uh hey so if you're uh if you're hearing this then you should be on the next night uh grace i hope everything went okay last night right good um i'm glad so i just thought i'd call you again to check in on you make sure you that you know what you're doing um um the company also wanted me to tell you about something back what god told you about yesterday and it's about some certain malfunctions with apparently he's been acting very strange and sporadic the previous night before you complained that in a quote he would slowly get off the stage then he would run towards the office he would break cameras he ran so he said that any cameras that he ran by just went offline it's weird but uh maybe don't pay attention to it i don't know maybe a few nights of sitting alone in the dark um i'm gonna let you go sorry this was much shorter i have kind of a busy schedule i'll talk to you again tomorrow bye okay so what do i do with bobby do i have to like shut the door if he runs to it or do i just reboot a camera i'm kind of confused on what to do with bobby because bobby is clearly foxy in this game where i gotta keep my eye on him to make sure he doesn't move and then hickey's the only one that hasn't moved yet and i'm assuming he's gonna be active on night three and apparently he's gonna work like freddy i'm assuming or he won't leave the stage much okay there's hickey or bobby sorry okay that's okay bobby's moving closer okay i gotta find out which door to close when bobby moves i'll close both doors when bobby leaves the camera and then i'll find out which camera he runs to whenever he um leaves because apparently bobby disables a camera i don't know why but according to the phone guy he has a malfunction mind if i join huh okay [Applause] okay so bobby's gonna be going to the left door so that means when bobby leaves the stage camera he will run to the left door and we have to close it and we have to check on him from time to time to slow down to slow him down like you would with foxy i know you're here somewhere okay okay i gotta reboot the i gotta reboot the power mod model one because it's having a malfunction alright so apparently the character that's taught the characters that have voice actors okay that's bobby i see him moving okay so the characters that are talking right now are bobby and looney luna ludy's the one that's has the demonic voice saying i know where you are okay i don't know who rooney is is he the one in like the green okay i'm assuming rooney is the one in the green shirt oh wait he is the one in the green shirt because i dealt with him on night one he comes to like the right door bobby comes to the left door and then i don't know about hickey and what's that guy's face that i don't remember okay there's rooney okay there's looney i heard looney moving there's bobby he's starting to move so i gotta start checking on him constantly and then close the left door when he leaves okay and i'm checking the doors to see if looney's coming or anyone else because looney's the one with the demonic voice bobby's the one with like the robot sound voice and then okay who okay i just heard looney moving i don't see him but i heard him and bobby's starting to move closer okay bobby's moving closer and that's very intimidating to me means he's going to run to the left door and we have to close it and i'm checking for looney because rooney whoop up here's looney speak of the devil rooney will show up in the darkness from the right door and we have to close it all right looney just left so that means we can open the right door we will check cam one to see if looney left the right door which he just did so that's good and we'll listen to bobby and then we will close the left door what are you doing in a place like this oh my god bobby's coming so i gotta close the right door this time okay so apparently bobby comes to both the left and the right door and so does um looney so if if if if the camera to the left hallway or the right hall is disabled that means we have to close the corresponding door and then if looney shows up at one of the doors like if you see him then we have to close it like you would with bobby all right okay that's rooney i just saw a rude oh i gotta just i gotta repair the fourth camera okay there you go i fixed that did rooney just leave [Applause] okay is there two characters named looney because i see two characters dressed in the same elephant let me know who the four characters in the comments because i don't know because the only characters names i know so far are bobby hickey and looney okay reboot the power power three and apparently says this what are you doing in a place like this apparently when he says that it means he shows up to my door okay i'm checking for bobbing still on the camera good i'm a night guard looney that's does that answer your question all right and we beat knight too i'm gonna find out what the passcode is for night 3 because then i can go take a picture of it on my ipad so i'm going to need to do that okay so let me see what is knight 2's code okay so i'm just grabbing my ipad okay knight three's code is let's see 4j x so i'm gonna take that picture on my ipad just so that we have a reminder for when i do make three in the next video which we will take on night three in the next video thank you for watching everybody please hit the like button also comment and subscribe i appreciate for you have given me hit the bell to receive all notifications of upcoming videos on my channel and i'll see you in the next video goodbye | AndrewRibaudo2021 | UCqaHgu0ckzPL7NLOmPKELgw | 2021-12-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,426 | 12,097 |
jZm1OIz7A4I | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZm1OIz7A4I | Our “BLACK and BROWN” people have given up the spirit to FIGHT! | the reason Christ came to the Earth the reason Christ was raised up so that we the so-called black Hispanic and Native American man can be saved from our enemies that's right but this is foreign language to black men today today our black men we don't care about salvation we think what we have in America is sufficient and good enough when God created you to be over the earth now we just peasants on the earth and we're satisfied with that bring it out given up that spirit that the god that most high God gave us to fight we don't longer have that Spirit oh I would say you don't have that spirit because the men you see standing up here purle we're going to fight for our people that's right | IUIC Columbia SC | UCLoGxxKcJvt-Ry0MXUbPc-g | 2024-04-07 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 134 | 695 |
Ub5sjjLVXvA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ub5sjjLVXvA | Freedom in America, The State of Individual Sovereignty | hello my name is Raymond bakar cesky and I am a living Christ the message i should like to share with all the people of this world specifically with those who who live in America the message is entitled freedom in America the state of individual sovereignty now this will probably be misunderstood by all but a few of you but here goes anyway you each of you are living breathing flesh-and-blood sentient natural men and women are holistic creatures are men and women creations of God children of God the essence of infinite intelligence which manifests as life itself the unbounded unlimited the timeless essence of truth itself truth is holistic you each of you are truth where you are holistic you are fundamentally all of Christ consciousness all that arises from the intellectual consciousness of man is a fiction with a satanic an origin and this is and opposing in nature such satanic fragmentation and confusion is very nature of civilized society the nature of Hell itself as this fact this truth is self-evident do all to see no explanation is necessary for those who have the spiritual eyes due to see and the ears to hear that ! by the spiritually blind and the dead those who are trapped in the confusion of their own satanic ly imposed outer programmed intellectual thought now it is not my intention to insult anyone but by the above statement you shall all know who and what you are and where you fit into life that point is self-evident it cannot be argued are you a living man or a one or are you a governmental II created good fictional person now that isn't hard for you to to comprehend is it once you've determined for yourselves who and what you are life becomes very simple uncomplicated direct and peaceful the non-dualistic essence of love replaces the dualistic struggle Road of a satanic oppositional intellect that attaches itself to to every thought every concept every idea and belief that makes up the intellectually driven fictional person the non living room robotic human resource obedient automation with condition to serve mindless soulless satanic system of control each of you and voluntarily consented to your own satanic slavery through the indoctrinated intellectual fear which imprisons your consciousness your purpose in life is to transcend to break loose from the fictional hell that you call civilized society obedience to groupthink is the source of all of your your own site Alec hell and cannot bring about a better world for it and has had its opportunity to do so since the beginning of time and you can see what such ignorance has wrought isn't it time for you folks to wake up thank you for your time | Raymond Karczewski | UC8XkQtdv8_kIPQdCLHWTwtg | 2016-04-25 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 463 | 2,654 |
j5oEUF7PKc0 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j5oEUF7PKc0 | Over 400 Drawings of Horses Go Into Box to Conclude Danwahl's 400 Horses Project | >> DANWAHL: I'm feeling sad, I'm putting away the 400 Horses Project, the four hundred horses drawings in 2015, and, uh, it started out as a project to draw 400 horses, and it turned into a project of learning to like... Learning not to doubt your horses. And so I thought I had 400, and then I went to the coffee shop, I found, I was journaling, some, this little girl was spying on me through the, through the ficus plant, and I said to her mom, Would she like to draw? And so I gave her my uh, my uh, sketchbook and some pens, and the little girl drew this, this drawing, which is awesome. And so after she was done and gave the sketchbook back, I sat and I admired the drawing, and I turned it over and I realized I had drawn a final horse that I didn't know I had drawn. I had forgotten about it. So this final horse is going into the box with the hope for the future on top of that. [clattering and shuffling] >> DANWAHL: Zuzu was a great participant through the whole process, so it's very fitting that she's here too. What do you think Zuzu, is it done? She says yes. | Dan Wahl | UCukc0i4MoMEqBURVKeNesAw | 2016-01-17 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | detection | en | 212 | 1,087 |
6NVwNCcjxag | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6NVwNCcjxag | FAST AS EMINEM?! Rapper Reacts to Mori Calliope's Godzilla Verse! ALSO... | what's up ladies and gentlemen it's your boy roar and you know what i'm jumping into something you guys told me that i should react to maury calliope doing the fast part of godzilla by eminem if you guys haven't heard the whole song you definitely should listen to it the guy is really good however if you're not aware of a lot of the different uh little hidden meanings of stuff he says then a lot of it might go over your head like when he says you know it's like bringing back fat fat pete's you know you'd be like fat pete's what the heck is that um and there are plenty of artists out there like myself that do lyrical breakdowns but they're more knowledgeable on that stuff than me like knox hill is a really good guy i'll leave a link to the description in that as well uh but for right now we have um oh gosh oh gosh this is so unprofessional uh we have the lyrics up here on screen we have godzilla lyrics the fast part that everyone's been thinking about and uh i actually have tried to wrap this before and i can't do it i'll just show you an example fill them with the venom and eliminate them other words i minute made them fill it kill them and dump them all the effing bodies in the lake obliterate everything incident renegade them and i'll make and i'll make anybody who want it with the pen afraid don't want to be the enemy of the demon every bit of you all right uh i'm not even going to read this off uh the lyrics are here on screen you guys can check that out while uh we listen to maury let's see how she does trigger happy packy but it's black and evil half of the bad meats evil that means take a backseat take it back to fat beats for the maxi single look at my rap sheet what attracts these people is my gangster [ __ ] like apache with a catchy jingle stacked chips you barely gotta have feeding cheetos okay so that's before the part that these lyrics have on that these lyrics entail on screen and that was really good pronounced pronunciation um gonna see how she does with this part fill him with the venom and eliminate him otherwise i don't want to hurt him but i'm getting him in a fitted radiation motor and again nobody elevated for the killing [ __ ] bodies in the liquid rating everything incinerator renegade i'm gonna make anybody who want it with a penetrating don't nobody want it but they're gonna get it anyway i'mma get him to feel like i'm mentally ill i'm still killed to be killing my killer be the vanilla gorilla you bringing the killer within me out of me you don't want to be the enemy of the demon who ended me okay i'm pausing right there for a second definitely stumbled over parts of this but her pronunciation was still good i could still hear what she was saying if you guys have been following along on this you could see what she's what she's oh my gosh wow she said okay she's she's doing good pronunciation you know even though she's stumbling along a little bit academy you don't want to be the enemy of the demon who added me and being the receiving enemy what's the pity everybody is the epitome of the spider when i'm in the city [ __ ] you better duck you finna be dead the minute you're running me 100 percent of you isn't for the person i'm about to [ __ ] finish you [ __ ] i'm fatal you want a battle i'm available i'm blowing it up and inflatable i'm undebatable unavoidable i'm invaded i'm on the toilet bowl got a trail full of money and a paintable i'm not afraid for the man stop look what i'm planning it's not perfect you still have to take a couple breaths in the middle i had to take a couple breaths in the middle but we'll get it perfect someday oh my gosh that was really cool she she really brought it like seriously that that's a lot better than anything i could do i'll try it again here i hope i cut out the beginning of this video where i just was trying and trying i felt bad about doing that on my last video where i just get anyway fill them with the venom and eliminate them other words i meant it made them i don't want to hurt them but i did it in a fit of rage i'm murdering again nobody will evade him i'm infinite i finna kill him and dump all the effing bodies in the lake obliterate everything incinerate and renegade them and i'll make anyone who won it with the penetrate but don't nobody want it but they're going to get it anyway because i begin to feel like a mentally ill matilla killer be killed i'll be killer every bit of me is the epitome of a spitter when i'm the vicinity [ __ ] you better duck or finna be dead the minute you run into me i had a fail all right i'm done for that reason i have another wrap for you guys hope you enjoy it no this kind of plays on a fictional story here but given the light of the holidays and how for the holidays it can really be a disastrous time for people i'd hope that this song in a way could encourage you guys to seek out something that makes you laugh this season and maybe it can come from a person who you might have otherwise not even heard from anyway enjoy this story your way to my brain dead not a vegetable i got beef with the life i'm living what's left for me sitting in my room can't eat don't even sleep the sun rises not as pretty as the view of my balcony alchemy any sort of witchcraft or sorcery semantics put aside i put aside my humanity reaching out to any single type of entity if you can help me breathe then i beseech static i can't manage to hear anything through it tragic when my dad left and mom couldn't influence any of my choices cause she was scared translucent a shell of herself and had color beaten to it we all hurt ourselves more than anyone else those bullies at my school didn't know about the living hell i had waiting in my room between my sheets i yelled we're a family that buries a hurt we do not tell so i reached out trembling fingers hit the ipad quite surprisingly soon i find myself laugh right after an ad for a christmas toy drive i found a silly group of friends called whole of life murray calliope the tough one of the bunch with a stiff upper lip and a scythe in her clutch i used to fantasize death wasn't taken from the world that i hated but now death has become a humorous vessel hefting me while i wrestle against the stress every day that tried to strangle which years in my eyes i climbed from my bed towards my parents old room maybe mom would get a chuckle a ghoul of herself mom turned and smiled didn't even use words i just showed the channel soon we were laughing tears of every type streaming can't believe one person made us see so clearly [Music] you | ROARTHERAPPER | UCwXQV0dnk-er2R4DU7GjOpQ | 2020-12-20 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,280 | 6,634 |
c3G5bdjBHl4 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c3G5bdjBHl4 | Zoonotic Disease Threats to Livestock and Poultry Agriculture Workers | foreign [Music] as I said at Texas A M and thank you for the kind introduction earlier for the next 15 minutes I'm going to try real briefly just to give you Food For Thought related to a zoonotic disease threats in the environment of the folks that are on this call it's not my intention to make you diagnosticians but there's some Basics that if you just remember and understand it'll go a long way about protecting yourself and your workers from disease or pest threats that are associated with livestock and poultry AG workers so let's get going here so if you think about it as zoonotic disease what does that mean it just means it's a disease that either an animal can give to a human and humans can give diseases to animals and it happens all the time and of course the environmental component is the wild card that we're going to talk about and what y'all uh interact with on a daily basis how can we catch a disease from an animal well some of them are common sense and you're aware of them maybe some of these are just food for thought vectors animal bites bug bites you can swallow it it could be food it could be water fecal contamination inhalation aerosol dust these are both everyday environmental challenges for folks working in ag sector and your mucous membranes if you'll just remember that your eyes your nose your mouth are are pretty much open doors for bugs germs to get into your body and so anyway that you can mitigate that potential then you're going a long way towards protecting yourself and then fomites deserve their own slide and here it is and maybe most of y'all know what this is but fomite is just an inanimate object that where disease agents hang out and I intentionally put a couple different slides on here with dirty boots it's one of the easiest ways to track around germs and also to introduce uh the pathogens to places they shouldn't be as well as you can see there's a squeeze Chute and then and the doorknob is kind of almost a joke but that's that's a very common foamite but equipment closed bedding water and and one thing to keep in mind is organic material in general such as manure or straw or bedding hides viruses bacteria other organisms very well they can persist inside that because it stays cool and moist and wet and they like that so that's probably one of the biggest things that can that is done when there's a biosecurity concern is cleaning and disinfecting half the disinfectant is obviously using chemicals but the cleaning is just removing organic matter here's a basic principle I probably should show this slide more than once because it's really all you need to remember on how diseases are spread and if you can break this cycle in any one of these three components um it's how you can prevent disease introduction agent host and environment and so um the host would be us right be a human and uh agent could be the Infectious material that we're worried about whether it's a virus or bacteria and then the environment this is this is where you can mitigate this and this is what I'm assuming most of y'all um most of y'all uh work in every day is a is the uh is the environment where you can clean disinfect you can protect yourselves minimize dust avoid runoff lagoons and all those kinds of things and so you can have the agent you know around and you can even be a susceptible host but if you properly mitigate the environment through good and best practices then there's still not a disease transmission and mainly just remember this isn't an accident you have to have all three of these things working together to actually transmit disease and there's indirect transmission and direct transmission and these are just terms for you to keep in mind and just reinforce the idea that you don't actually have to touch an animal that's sick to get the disease you can uh you know come in contact with their crates uh the bedding the manure as I've said and then when it comes to indirect transmission now we're talking about the doorknob which is a foamite dirty boots or vectors such as mosquitoes or ticks there's a number of different kinds of disease agents and it's not important that you know much about them other than I just want you to understand these are all living organisms in different ways and they're all different sizes and have different characteristics and when I'll just run through some of these for you so you understand that you know you realize how common these are rabies is a common virus E coli is a bacteria fungi it would be a ringworm would be a good example of a fungal infection and ziardia is a protozoan and and how do you keep them uh separate and how do you understand all these well it takes a little time and practice the one thing to keep in mind is they're very different they're not all the same that means different disinfectants work different measures would work different environments are are more or less risky for these but here's one just to give you a visualization how small a virus is compared to uh the protozoa which are the largest of these four types of infectious agents just pretend here you're looking at Mount Everest as a protozoa then a three foot child child would be a virus bacteria are bigger than a virus and a fungi is in between a bacteria and the protozoas here's an example of a transmission cycle and this is actually relevant because it's going on right now so I need to change this slide versus the last outbreak was in 2015. this is a current event happening right now and for those of you all in the uh culture industry you're very much aware of it but this is not only in animal disease but Avian Influenza and type A influenzas can also affect humans and here's here's just a little diagram of how this could happen the the virus is actually circulating all the time in wild birds and it's the migratory wild birds that come all the way down from Canada Alaska come on down through the different flyaways such as Pacific Flyway in the west and the Atlantic and the Mississippi flyways and they bring these viruses with them and a lot of these waterfowl are not that sick when they catch them they're just transporting it and but when they come in contact with our domestic birds and poultry uh chickens and both uh broilers and egg layer uh pulp chickens as well as turkeys and other domestic Birds when the virus jumps species oftentimes it changes in its pathogenicity and its ability to make animals sick humans are just another type of animal in this case and so we can catch it from the poultry litter we can catch it from handling the birds or their eggs or their crates and this is a classic example of a zoonotic disease transmission from animal to animal to humans here's just some examples of them different settings I just try to put together some some pictures that kind of resonate with with you all on the audience as to where you might uh work or where you might interact with animals and always just in the back of your mind be thinking about disease transmission not only for yourself but your co-workers and your family if that's appropriate concentrated animal operations feedlots dairies poultry houses swine facilities obviously biosecurity is is at the top of the list of important uh policies and business uh decisions made every day but also in this context remember we're talking about you as well as the animals backyard chickens Urban transitional backyards settings are some of the highest risk one because if you go to the commercial Opera picture on the right the folks there are probably a little more educated about biosafeting biosecurity but backyard folks just wanted some chickens to lay eggs for their kids or Recreation or fun or Hobbies you you know they're not as educated in something as simple as you know touching your hands to your mouth or your face or your ears can transmit these diseases and for children that's a huge risk livestock Wildlife interface this is a kind of a cool picture it's just some zebras near cattle in Africa and obviously here's a way that a disease can get from Wildlife to domestic animals and then on to their human caretakers there's more of the same there on the fair shows and exhibitions some of the most common ways that zoonotic diseases are spread at times are live birthing exhibitions and there's an entire protocol and setting down the public health side that helps folks out in the show's fairs exhibitions that want to do either a petting zoo or a live birthing exhibit things they can do to mitigate the possibility of disease transmission such as hand washing stations and educational information provided outside the pins here's here's a few examples of some zoonotic disease threats and again I'm not trying to make any of you all diagnosticians but just give you some examples in a variety of ways that animals can give diseases or pests uh to humans rabies everyone's heard of that and it doesn't have to be a wild animal it could be a lot it could be a domestic animal but that's a virus and that's spread by bites and saliva and then brucellosis is a bacteria that wild hogs have it's about in uh in Texas about 10 of the wild hogs have brucellosis or brucella sue us and in Yellowstone there's a problem there with some of the elk and the bison and Yellowstone we eradicated the abortus in our cattle population about 15 years ago in the U.S it used to be a problem is really now why we still pasteurize our milk and milk products is to prevent the disease transmission of that here's a couple of uh here's a couple of pictures of uh pests mange or a Mite infestation in swine and then you would get this through direct contact the animals are touching their bedding where the the mites might live A couple of tick-borne diseases Rocky Mountain spotted fever and lime they affect humans and you know I want to be sure and mention here that for any of these zoonotic considerations including lime and Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever if you or your workers are sick and decide to go to a doctor it is very important that you tell those folks that you work in the AG sector because if I just walked in tomorrow with the disease and I just said well I got a fever and a sore throat and a slight cough Etc they're thinking the flu they're thinking coronavirus they're thinking the common cold and those are some of the same symptoms you might get with with some AG related diseases so it's always important to tell a human or a medical doctor that you work around animals and livestock and environmental conditions that are conducive to disease spread if you go to the doctor E coli everyone's heard of that and I think the pictures here are obviously um pertinent to this audience and they live in contaminated water feces equipment soil chlamydia avian chlamydiosis another bacteria aerosolized feces contaminated water and feed and carcasses and again all of these are why you know the personal protective equipment is what it is when you start to protect yourself from diseases and finally a couple more just for reference different kinds of transmission potentialities salmonella is and pigs in in the commercial swine salmonellosis looks very similar to some foreign animals these is actually some that can be caused by a virus or other other things and so salmonella is a common disease of animals and obviously as you all know humans can catch it as well there's a number of varieties of salmonella and then Giardia also known as beaver fever if you go camping in the mountains can persist in contaminated Soil and Water and that's a protozoa so we'll we'll talk here as I wrap up my talk a couple common terms that get misunderstood and I want to give an example of each of those um bioseking biosecurity and if no and put them together and there's your integrated risk management for those of y'all that are um the supervisors on this call you're very familiar with that and if you're just a worker that's performing these activities just think of it this way biosafety is a precautionary measures you take to protect yourself and biosecurity are the things you do to keep from spreading disease and I have a slide on each of these so here you go biosafety measures are taken by an individual to protect prevent the introduction of the harmful organisms to themselves and like I said hand washing protective equipment Etc not touching your eyes and mouth are huge for that biosecurity are the kinds of things you and your co-workers do to prevent the transmission of the disease from your farm or your AG setting to another Farm or another egg sitting and this is huge any of you all are doing commercial culture right now you're worried about Avian Influenza if you're in the commercial swine industry you're worried about purrs and and other different infectious diseases of swine and so this is a huge part of your life every day if you work in those two settings as we wrap up here here's just some things to consider and again not sure whether y'all are in management or you're on the ground working but employee education if you're in management make sure your your employees are understand this you know take my presentation and give it to them for more than 15 minutes obviously they need to understand the risks how to mitigate the risks and then you need make sure they have the right equipment to protect themselves and then are they using that equipment that's important part of that if you're worried about biosecurity again just always keep in mind the one health concept that's that's the main thing in my talk is that these organisms and vectors can transmit back and forth between humans and animals and they can persist in the environment that's the buzzword that's growing in importance every day now in the in around the world for disease risk mitigation procedures your employees need to practice they need to practice practice practice some things as simple as if you've got got disease on a farm while you go to your Healthy animals first and then you go to the dirty animal second if we're talking about a lagoon or some kind of runoff or some kind of a disposal equipment that's always dirty you know so I'll keep that in mind if you're dealing with animals and environmental hazards changing clothes Footwear some really Common Sense things but again from a management perspective do you have policies are your people educated about those policies are they following those policies and that should actually be part of their job performance and reward them if they're doing a great job and if they're not you know trying to re-educate them so again I didn't want to try and make this too complicated but just remember the the host the agent and the environment y'all are working in the environment every day and if you take a good care of your problems there it'll mitigate the risk to your uh your host or your own employees regardless of the agent I'll stop there and turn it back over [Music] foreign | Livestock & Poultry Environ. Learning Community | UCLObpc9E9ZTivFAmbj3Qazw | 2022-10-24 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,703 | 14,973 |
7YE1N9cjAks | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7YE1N9cjAks | No Man's Sky News New Quicksilver Decals - Captain Steve NMS - The QS Store Is Working !! | no I [Music] can't well how do that Chums we've got some news for you today people got myself a lovely cup of tea and when I say I've got some news I did a video the other day wondering weather the Quicksilver items will come into store inside of No Man's sky this game right here let's jump over into that game show we people cha Chom let's head on over to the kiosk because look the bar has actually reset if you wondering what I mean by the bar it's this thing here this little seethrough bar you can see that it's got a little faint Blue Line there that means we've started unlocking something new inside of the quick silver store people inside of I guess we have right so let's H head on over to the old Quicksilver Merchant Johnny 5 as I call him cuz he looks a little bit like the guy out of short circuit let's see if we can sneak in through the side here which yeah managed to lovely jly and let's see what he's got inside of the Quicksilver store this is where you can also collect your Quicksilver items and Expedition items but anyway let's go into here and yes there's free new things we've got the blue system decal we've got the Cleo tempat techological decal yeah the beetle one and we've also got the fluttering decal freaking lovely jly hey yeah so three different decals now these ones are probably used by my Wonder projectors if I've got these in my wonders that' be pretty darn cool the blue system one maybe if I've got a Bas in the blue system could stick it on the freaking wall don't know I don't know whether I'd ever use that one it might look good as a tablecloth or a doorm though might it that you can find a use for it I'm sure but there we go so they're all 400 quick silver each usually if it's about 200 quick silver I say about a day and a half for 200 Quicksilver so 400 Quicksilver what's that three days roughly so each of these are going to take three days 3 69 I think about 9 days and we should have all of these okay all right people sometimes they go a little bit quicker over the weekend though so if there is a weekend in between that I do speed that up a little bit so I might reduce that to seven in my old estimates you know but anyway there we go Pips um yeah we got some decals that we can unlock now so hopefully you can get your quick Silvers you can see here I got quite a lot of Quick Silver already but to run Quicksilver missions you hit up this Cube over here and it's usually the top Mission inside of here so right now I could do eliminate hazardous Flora earn myself 400 Quicksilver that's going to earn one of those decals and you can see here I've got three stacked it Stacks up to three so yeah you can leave them for a couple of days then come in and do all three back to back if you if you wanted and get yourself 400 Quicksilver a throw that' be 1,200 quick silver yeah go Mass this this time of the morning never a strong point okay anyway what comes next after those decals well I know what comes next after those decals cuz I myself have got the No Man's Sky assistant app so here you go I've got my phone in my hand that's a no man Sky assistant app icon right there boom there's man Sky assistant app and then if I just go into Community Mission and I can see the rewards right here they're all right there on the screen but if I go to next Community reward you can see here there's ice statues ice statues so we got this one to go that one's going to come next then after that we've got a Diplo ice statue heck yes Diplo I statue and after that one we have got a ship ice statue all three of these will appear at the same time after those decals and then there's another set of decals after that very similar to the ones that we getting now so yeah there we go people that's your kind of No Man's Sky News so yeah hopefully you enjoyed that people inside the view of us and I've got Dragon's Dogma coming to my channel on the 22nd of March Dragon's Dogma 2 will be coming to my channel and if you haven't heard of Dragon's Dogma before it's a Capcom game it's it's very cool very very awesome Greek Mythos think Sim bad think um you know Clash of Titans and all that good stuff from the ' 80s they stop frame animation like movies that in a video game that's about the best as I can describe it people inside the viewers anyway thank you very much for watching until next time goodbye goodbye goodbye again he guys [Music] [Applause] I can life I really really want you to step [Music] out me at the I [Music] can't time | Captain Steve | UCtAkYahXNSJ8RVOil0O_Rnw | 2024-03-19 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 892 | 4,493 |
futfTZUm400 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=futfTZUm400 | 9/17 Tegan & Sara - See You on Snapchat + The Con @ 9:30 Club #2, Washington, DC 11/07/16 | [Applause] Oh so here we're just talking before I came on stage whatever our dear friends are here with us I'm traveling around right now and we were talking about them and strangers approaching she has a series it's very troubling in my opinion tales about strangers approaching her and kneeling it's just something you know and then at the end of that exchange she has on occasion given that person when I heard like not for anything other than just like feeling there was a connection we were like you're gonna get kidnapped but then I want my instinct participants so me think that's what's missing from the world like I think that there were so many things that we came up you know in the nineties as teenagers and inserted recruiter later even when [Music] [Applause] garbage it's my back in the day of salvation until there's a temptation to reward that kind of human action random Union connection but it almost always happens to me [Applause] [Music] [Applause] just every reaction that you have to make to zero we'll take a number that we were discussing what you say even fake phone number when we were saying our strategy of goodness as we meet amazing people in our time but we just had to stop because sometimes a normal interaction turns it [Music] and just say actually if my phone number oh but here's this email address that they just get to support when I shop I never check that you know there like what do you guys do like do you give a fake number you whatever they do I suggested Oh sleep if something happens you could say I'll find you on facebook you say what you say [Applause] what does the satrap thing mean Lulu you say I'll see once you find the one Rousseff's memories being like so when you meet someone on the street having interaction with the community like take a picture of [Applause] actually though this is plainly losses by accident but tiny but this these connectors also cover these exports on the back you know from a republic on [Applause] I was attempting to land like to get into a relationship with someone who was on MySpace sorry [Applause] so I didn't like what she had a myspace and I was like okay [Applause] I'll shoot I [Music] [Applause] [Music] Sanna Sanna nervous [Music] you think [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] | wojo4hitz | UCVBeHtekkZtJ-KVG4q883kA | 2016-11-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 419 | 2,353 |
MH5utFmuRRI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MH5utFmuRRI | Color Theory Suite | [Music] hello Stanford Kelly Atchison at a stamp above comm coming to you from the Nashua scottson today I am going to show you how to make this really fun summer card and I've used this bundle before but I have to say this is one of the best bundles that I own it's got spring summer winter and fall in it and a set of framelits these are called the seasonal layers framelits and the colorful season stamp set remember the Adriatic chair card that I made with a fun background this is really an awesome stamps that I love this branch and on Monday I showed you a card using the scalloped edge so that's also a very fun edge lit so let's get started and I'll show you how to make it I'm going to start out here with our cardstock layers I've got a card base of dapper denim and this is four and a quarter by 11 and I've scored it here at 5 and 1/2 so give it a good burnish I've got a layer at 4 by 5 and 1/4 and this is for the inside of our card then I've got a layer of crushed curry that's also 4 by 5 and a quarter a piece of color serie designer series paper that's 2 and 3/4 by 5 and 1/8 and also another piece here out of the same designer series paper stack that's one and a quarter by five and 1/8 and then I've got a scrap of whisper white let me show you this color theory paper stack this is in the catalogue on page 187 and you get all of these designs I love the crackle paint layers and also like the repeat swatches these they come in dapper denim berry burst crushed curry and old olive and if you've been watching me and watching my videos you know I've been using a lot of the enamel dot and that is the exact same color palette as the color theory these are part of the color theory suite so very cool all right let's get some stamping done here I'm going to take this scrap and I'm going to stamp this little glass with the straw in it which i think is so cute and I'm just going to stamp this a couple times and I'm going to take this over to my Big Shot and cut it out with this cute little framelit isn't that adorable hang tight I'll be right back alright the other thing we're going to do here is we're going to stamp directly on our designer series paper I always think that's a really cool technique to use and if your paper is very subtle and light-colored you can do that of course you can all sign it too if you want to use white embossing powder I'm using dapper denim ink and I'm going to stamp the beach chair look at all that ink I got on the edge of my stamp I'm going to wipe that off first because I don't want any problems here I'm going to stamp my beach chair and then I'm going to come in with the part that you sit on let's stamp that right in between just like that isn't that neat it looks kind of 3d ish - I really like that and then we have the greeting life is a beautiful thing and isn't that the truth oh by the way I haven't updated on my husband he just got released to take his neck collar off for you know an hour today maybe two hours tomorrow three or four hours the next day so we just got released to be able to do stuff now so I'm super excited I'm going to bring in these little drinks aren't they cute just adorable I forgot to show you those when I guess I die cutting them I'm sorry about that we've got these mini dimensionals and if you don't have any of these yet I highly recommend them because they fit perfectly on these tiny little objects you don't have to be cutting dimensional heart and having them stick all over your scissors and all that kind of nonsense so I'm just going to put my little drinks I'm going to put one here on the lawn chair so that my imaginary person can reach it yes I'm going to put another one right over here in the corner and now we're ready to assemble our card we're going to put this piece on the crushed curry and it's got a very thin border I just wanted that little pop of color and this one is going to layer over the top just a little bit it doesn't butt up against it it's just going to lay over the top a little bit here we go with some liquid glue that looks a little crooked there we go again I love the sliding of the glue oh just crinkled or crackled paint look is really pretty on the other side too there we go then we've got this mini Chevron ribbon that I thought would look really cute on here it's a great accent and this is how I like to do my ribbon I like to cut it so it's a little bit longer than my cards back layer and I'm going to take some real tape and tape that on the back here's another tip for you it takes some snail and I'm just going to put it right on here if my ribbon stay in place I don't like that when your ribbon is flopping around put some more right here and another piece of tape on the back lit in place there we go I'm going to take my ribbon and tie a single mat right here and I do this for a couple reasons number one it saves a little bit on ribbon not that much and I leave it attached to my spool too because if you had to cut it you're gonna have to cut four inches to be able to maneuver it with your fingers I leave it attached to my spool and you only have a single knot here now so you don't have any problems with shipping and having to pay extra postage because there's not a big bump in there it's just a little bump and you could put a piece of cardstock over the front of this like a scrap that's the same size and I just slide it right into my envelope like that so you don't have any bumps that cause distress to your Postal Service because they get pretty ornery about that don't they we know that I think they don't literally like stampers and they really should because let's face it there's not a lot going on with a mail these days and we are supporting them so they need to start treating us nicer how do you feel about that I think that's a true statement isn't it you need to stop giving us dirty looks when we bring the bumpy mail in okay now I'm just going to pop a few of these literate enamel dots around my project because that's going to give me a little bit of glimmer that I want and just randomly putting them around here and then we've got the inside left and what I decided to do on the inside of my card let's stamp these little flowers because I just thought they were really really cute so I'm just going to stamp off the edge a little bit and make them look pretty random and because they look so uniform I'm going to come in and do a little bit of something here so that they don't look so random and I did pretty good right okay we can put this inside our card and then we only have one thing left can you guess what it is you know if you've been following me you know what else I have to do yet so you know it's time for envelope and I want to stamp that up so it looks really cute too I am going to take the greeting from the stamp set you make me smile and I'm inking that up with my finger haha in some dapper denim and I'm just going to stamp that right over here in the corner and then I've got this cute little flower I'll put that in the crushed curry and stamp that right down here and now we have an adorable envelope with our awesome card ready to go in the mail now this color theory sweet anybody who orders this colorful seasons and seasonal layers or a $50 order if you would like it I have a tutorial of 14 different cards including this one with all the instructions dimensions ingredients that I will be sharing with everyone who places a $50 order with me or orders this bundle so if you've already ordered this bundle from me pop me an email I'm going to try and go through my orders and see who did that but I'm going to be on vacation here for a week if you know you that you have this pop me an email and I will send you this tutorial you're going to love it there's some great ideas and there's and I think an even number of each season so winter summer spring and fall you're going to get a great sampling of ideas to use with this whole suite and it's pretty much kind of limited to the sweet 2 there's a few extra products that were used in it but not much so that's a great benefit don't forget I have an incentive while I'm away in Thailand if you place a $50 order I send you a card kit with six cards six designer series papers and a sampling of ribbon if your order is $100 I send you 12 card vases and designer series papers along with a ribbon sampling also so we've got that going on bonus days is happening right now Stampin Up will give you a $5 coupon to use in August when your order reaches $50 during July so for every $50 you get a $5 coupon to use in August so that's pretty exciting and we have our discount shopper kit that comes with a bunch of additional product and its value is 200 $9.50 and it's only 99 bucks so check out all these details are on my blog post with this card WWF of calm and this is going to be posted on July 14th so check it out you can also go to my youtube channel look for this video underneath the video is a description the link will be right in there also so you can get right to here I am going to let you go like I said I am in Thailand right now and I am really enjoying myself I'm sure actually while I'm making this video I'm at home sitting in my in my stamping studio right but you're going to be watching this when I'm in Thailand so thanks again for your support your orders are greatly appreciated and I couldn't be on this vacation without you I just want you to know how much I appreciate you thanks so much you guys and you have a wonderful day [Music] you | Kelly Acheson - AStampAbove | UCm7s9J_UJp9hVimHidbeUtw | 2017-07-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,939 | 9,537 |
X77h3IBCBMY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X77h3IBCBMY | Replacing the battery on a YI dash cam | hey guys um this is the xiaomi dash cam it's called the yi smart dash camera and you can see the model information there so the battery on this died recently and i wanted to get it replaced instead of buying a new dash i did some research and i found a replacement battery for it online so i went ahead and ordered one through ebay i'll put the link in the comments and for this video i'm going to take it apart and put a new battery in i've already taken the battery out the previous battery so that i could get the part number but i'll i want to make this video so i could so document the process of putting a new battery in so this is what the battery looks like this is the battery i took out so it's 3.7 volts 240 milliamps and let me get the new one yeah so this new battery um well but i put the old one okay just the old one and you can see the old ones all puffed up now so that's not good and a new one is just slimming nice okay so um to pry it open i'll recommend using a plastic knife like this so the easiest way i found to go in is from the side with the usb port um you know just put the butter knife in a little crack here and try to pry it open yep that's it okay and take the top off and just the lcd screen you can see the memory card there so the battery sits um inside so we gotta take this pcb board out and you'll have to unscrew a couple of screws for that okay so i've got this position screwdrivers i'll use that to take the full screw so there's one screw there one there and i think there is one there right there was a sticker there before that voids your warranty and there's another one there hmm okay so let's do the plastic bit comes out screw the screen okay so the battery plugs in there so the battery plugs in there and it goes in only one way and you would rest the battery right below here there is a little gap in there you can put the battery um okay so before i put the screws back on i'll just power it up um with the usb cable see if it works okay so quite a problem it didn't start up and i think i know what the problem is the polarities for the cables are wrong so i could have to replace them i'll swap them around so just the original battery and if you see the connector i think it's called j connector it's it's red white and black and on the new connector it's the other way around so i could just switch the red and the black and then i should be good to go be right back okay i'm back um swap was fairly easy all you do is you use a needle like this and you just pull this little plastic tab up here and you hang the cable out it's fairly easy took me about a minute so i'll swap the cables out and i'm going to plug it in now let's see so plug it in oh it's a good sign so there's an led on and i don't have the usb cable plugged in here so that mr battery has power in it and let me try and plug the usb in now and see what happens and yeah that worked okay i'll put it all together and hopefully it stays that way so this piece goes okay okay so the plastic bead goes there push it off back together and we can put the screws back on okay so i've got one of these position screwdrivers now you said take the full screw so there's one screw there one there and i think there is one there right there was a sticker there before that voids your warranty and there's another one there okay okay so the battery plugs in there yeah so the battery plugs in there and it goes in only one way and you would rest the battery right below here there is a little gap in whenever you put the battery um okay so before i put the screws back on i'll just power it up um with the usb cable see if it works do okay so quite a problem it didn't start up and i think i know what the problem is the polarities for the cables are wrong so i've got to have to replace them i'll swap them around so just the original battery and if you see the connector i think it's called a j connector it's it's red white and black and on the new connector it's the other way around so i could just switch the red and black and then i should be good to go be right back okay i'm back um swap was fairly easy all you do is you use a needle like this and you just um pull this little plastic tab up here and you hang the cable out it's fairly easy took me about a minute so i'll swap the cables out and i'm going to plug it in now let's see so plug it in oh that's a good sign so there's an led on and i don't have the usb cable plugged in here so that mr battery has power in it and let me try and plug the usb in now and see what happens and hey that worked okay i'll put it all together and hopefully it stays that way okay so the plastic bead goes there push it off back together and we can put the screws back on it's gonna be fun so i've got this uh magnetizers that i got on amazon just so that the screws will stick onto it so i think i got them a pair for five bucks setting okay okay that looks good put the usb cable in [Music] set date okay now fine plug let's see if remembers the date okay so looks like it is not the battery didn't work um so when i unplug when i first got this when unplugged you will still get a display saying shutdown i'll give you a few seconds before you powered off um the odd thing is there's still a light the led is still on here indicating that there's power coming from the battery but if you see when i plug it back in [Music] it doesn't remember my configuration and it just goes back to the date and time that i initially configured and this configuration is actually stored on the memory card and not on the chip or on the rom right so looks like this thing is busted and i might just take the battery out and uh test it again but if anything changes i will post an updated video i hope you guys find this useful if you need to change it but yeah good luck thank you for watching | Danesh Manoharan | UCzbTbebMnSwyZsSgu7TScXA | 2021-01-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,220 | 5,845 |
KO2N22C7jps | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KO2N22C7jps | HIJAB TUTORIAL : Simple With Pin | [Music] salamualikum' today I'm going to share with you guys how I apply or how I put on my hijab I think a lot of you can also see like this is the most easiest hijab style but I have been getting so many questions to film how I put on my hijab just so easy it's just the most basic way how to do it you can do it in 1 seconds and also I have been getting so many questions on what I use this year guys is what I use so this is how it looks I don't know if this is made for hijabs but this is what I use so I have my scar like this I folded my hijab one time because I don't like the ends of the hijab or of the scarf is I don't like how it's like yeah how it looks so I like to fold it this side is just a little bit shorter than this side because I'm going to put this one to that side now how I tie it it do this like yeah this put this together then we have this and I push this this this is how I do it you can like put it in here I do not always do that so all I do is this let me do that a little bit slower this that's it and then all I do I take this piece and I bring it to this side that's it but maybe it looks different I don't know the scarf is from Arabian import the cotton wool I don't know if they still sell them they send me like three colors and these are just the best scarves in my opinion I always get questions on what kind of fabric this is and I don't know what to tell them the it's the same name as other scarfs and I go to he Jeff stores they have like the same name of the fabric but if I look at the fabric itself it's not the same and this year where I got this so I can actually find this in every he jeff store like my city now mija has a store with these ties but also like if you go to Amsterdam or roser them there are so many stores with like a lot of scarves and they always have these so I just go run them in stores and I just grab a few every time because I'm losing them that every time I don't know if you can order them online probably maybe you can look up on Aliexpress it always has everything but yeah for me I would say just go to the store I don't know about other countries of course so yeah and I have no idea how it is it's called sorry so now I also answered all the questions about my hijab style and this little tie here um yeah I hope this video was helpful and thank you guys for watching and I will see you girls in my next videos [Music] Oh [Music] | New Muslim Guide | UC9G4D8c2AwkSOW2Ri2vSNXg | 2019-02-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 528 | 2,411 |
D_EpFoi8zaE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D_EpFoi8zaE | Tilt Hydrometer Repeater with ESP32 | Jiki boy come on hi folks welcome along to the vlog chances upstairs and adjust adjust this so every time chance is upstairs because today we've been brewing and yesterday we also brewed a beer but I didn't pick the camera yesterday but I have today that's right because today we're actually going to be playing around with the tilt hydrometers yes so I'm looking up at the screen behind you just there so a lot of you guys who are subscribed to the channel will be aware that we've got this tilt hydrometer raspberry-pi receiver and monitor setup there so just turn around again because the cool has kicked in so basically what's happening is all the tanks have their own Raspberry Pi as fortune would have it we have eight tanks and there are eight versions of the tilt do that's a Raspberry Pi then I mean tilt there are eight versions of the tilt we have eight tanks so that's handy and I've named all the tanks after the colors black blue green pink purple yellow red I think that's all of them and bought because we have stainless steel tanks and those tanks are insulated with rock wall and timber sometimes the signal can find it a little bit difficult to escape from the tank up to the receiver which I have up here you see that little box up there we've got the Raspberry Pi in that box and that's kind of equidistant it's kind of equidistant between all eight tanks if you get one I'm coming from but still some of the signals can be intermittent and we might not get a signal for an hour or two and whilst that isn't a real issue in terms of data log into truck fermentation and what-have-you on the spreadsheet which is ultimately where all this data ends up it's nice to have that television screen that monitor in the brewery so at a glance I can have a look and I can see where each individual beer is so I can see that I've got proof of concept in there its sat at nineteen point four degrees and the gravity is 10:35 you've no idea how convenient that is when I have all the things to think about I don't take a sample from the tank to see where we are etc so let me get to the point I have been fortunate enough to have been given access to some code which I think I can share with you it is in the public domain it's on github I believe it's called and I think the chap who shared it with me his name's David gray I don't think it's the singer and I will leave a link down below to the to the code and this code is to be written on to an ESP 32 so that can then be used as a very cheap Bluetooth signal repeater for each of the tilts and the code that is written as well he's been expanding on it and you can actually also select which tilt you want the ESP 32 to repeat so I don't know if there'd be a problem with all all eight tilts broadcast into the ESP 32 or not they didn't seem to because I've been trialing an earlier version of the code on one of these little modules but either way what I've done is I've ordered from China and ESP 32 for each tank and we're gonna code each tank for each color tilt that goes in there so for instance tank number six that will always have the purple tilt into it the reason why I've done that is when all eight tilts are live I'll take it down and I'll show you something so when all eight tilts are live this is the order that they come out in black blue green orange pink purple red and yellow so what I've done if we populate every single fermenter with some beer they're all going to have a tilt in there ultimately so this at a glance I will be able to see the FV for is tank for on the monitor they just keep things very very simple for me so these are the ESP 32 modules we'll take a closer look at them later on and basically I've written on each one what color tilt it's going to be coded for and we'll go upstairs and I'll just take one randomly like this purple one here and we will get stuck in two how I've coded put the put the program onto these little machines I don't know if I'm doing it 100% right but it works so I think I'm getting pretty close but yes we'll go upstairs we'll have a little bit of a play with some of the software that is required for this and we'll put the program on this ESP 32 with the software also I've got some other little dc-to-dc book converters I believe they're called which were left over from another project but they are like 50 pence on ebay and we're going to utilize that along with these cheap 69p USB cables from pound world or whatever it was in order to pin to the 12 volt supply that already exists on my fermenter controllers so these can live inside the control box and be powered internally with the supply that's already there instead of me having to I don't think I've got one available but you know having to get a USB plug for each one how I want to be doing that anyway all will be revealed throughout the video so let's go upstairs and let's put some code onto this little little gizmo right folks I'm in the office I've not got the software on this computer to do a screen grab so I'm trying our best to talk you through everything that is going on so first things first you'll want you're going to want to browse to the code so the code is on gift github.com and the user name is david gray m3m is 1/5 and the project is tilt repeater dot a and L so you're going to go ahead and download the zip there's a zip file just here we're going to download that onto our local machine to open up later on and then also you're going to want to go ahead and download Arduino for Windows or whatever else it is that you're running arduino ide it's free go ahead and download that onto the machine and then we can get started with the whole thing so what we're going to do I know it's a busy desktop is we're going to open up Arduino you can either do it through the programs file or from the downloaded till the repeater that we've got from the github file you can just open it up there and it should all things being equal open up onto your machine and here it is so this is the tilt repeater this caught the corner sketch but it is basically all the code that we're going to be interested in into putting on our little ASP 32 so what I'm gonna do now is I want to take my ESP 32 I'm gonna plug it into a USB and making sure that this USB cable has actually got a data link inside and it's not just a charging cable and we're going to stick that into the PC and as you can see we've got a little red light that's lit up there which means that we're connected so a couple of things that you might have to do in order to get this to work you want to go to tools you want to go to es and it to the board and you want to select the correct board the correct board is the ESP v 2 dev module so we've got that receptor selected and then also you may want to open em let's have a look what's it called the device device manager because we want to know what port this particular tool little dude is actually on and you can go down here into ports on device manager and you can see it'll say Silicon Labs CP 2 1 o blardy blardy blar but it importantly it says con 3 at the end so that's the port we're in and you may have to select that port under here port so you can see it says port com3 as long as that's right we're right that was under tools and then what we're going to go ahead and do is we're going to put this code on to here but we want to make sure that we've got the correct color so along here you can't see this I imagine because she's so far away from the screen but trust me it gives you David's giving us instructions in the code so we know what number to put in for the color of Peter to select purple and that is number 4 so we're going to go ahead and change that number 2 four and we're just going to hit the upload button there we go so down here in this bottom corner you probably can't see this down here it does say dev module on comm three so we've got that working fine and whilst it's decided it's compiling the sketch before it uploads it will say searching or something like that on the screen here and you have to press and hold the boot button on the ESP 32 in order for the code to be written hard-coded in if you like I can't think of the correct terminology to be written on to the chip so we're just going to wait until the computer basically asks us to do that that's Depp there are other links as well online if if you want to more comprehensive tutorial on how to code this because I really am playing it by ear a little bit but if you search for kind of ESP 32 projects and what-have-you on the internet there are several websites which can kind of help you program these little do that and I think I'll try my best to maybe leave a link or two in the description of the video should I should I remember to do that so we'll just wait in a second here another green bar has gone all the way to the end but sometimes that don't mean anything there we go so now it says connecting and it's got dots coming up so now we're going to press and hold that boom button and you'll see just down there look it's writing the code in and I've still got my finger on the bottom and then right at the end it says writing 2% you'll scroll down 30 40 60 and then it says complete heart Reese via RT s pin so you can let go now and we can pull the whole thing off that has now got our Tilt repeater code on it it really is that simple so let's go downstairs and let's see if we can hook this up to a power supply and then install it directly into a fermenter controllers okay so here we are at the workbench so I'm just gonna set up a few things first of all firstly we have the soldering iron which we're gonna need so we'll turn that on now get that heated up secondly you can see we've already been experimenting with one here I'm going to remove this module because we're going to install a new one so I've got this 12 volt power supply here in order for me to calibrate the power supplies that we'll be using to control our ESP 30 tools so these little book converters are called let me open it up and show you they are L M 25 96 DC to DC book converters that pennies on ebay bang God all that kind of stuff all those websites and the idea here for us is to attach the end of a USB cable we've already got one here give you an idea so this power lead is going to go to our 12 volt supply which we already have in the fermentis I've just got one here so I can dial things in before we go that end and then this side I've taken the microUSB off of a full length USB cable I've isolated the positive and the negative rail which are the two outside cables and on this particular USB cable they were all white in there apart from one lead one of them was pink and the one next to the pink closest to the pink on the outside was actually the positive lead so I just got myself a permanent marker and just call it that in red so we can kind of see what we're working with but I'm just gonna pause and go and get another USB cable so we can attach it and then we'll get down and we'll do a bit of soldering but ultimately this book convertor is going to take our 12-volt power supply bring it down to below 5 volts which is what these ESP thirty twos want and we can just plug that in then like that and that will run forever more and I've tested it as well it draws less than kind of 20 milliamps there's very little power on these these things so let me go and get another USB cable we'll zoom down onto the table and hopefully we'll be able to do this before the alarm goes off to tell me that my whirlpool is over because I am brewing the vacant gesture at the same time right I hope I've moved that into a position where we can see what's actually going on it's a bit difficult with I haven't tidied the workshop up very much really so we've got the USB cable these are from pound world.there 69p and they're three meters long really it's a bit of overkill but nevermind we've got a bit of extra cable should we need it so all I'm gonna do is slice off a bit that I need and then we're going to cut down the edge of the cable just here I knew I'd be straight out to shop before we've even started anything now we've got how's that so let's go down the edge of these two outside cables try not to damage the inner cable as we do so I'm really finding this difficult to keep in shot yeah we got I think you started it at least so let's just stretch this back both sides so we can see what we're working with so there we go that's not bad at all so we can see that here we have four white well three white and one pink internal cable if I can just get that one out and then there is another one hiding in there but that doesn't really matter cuz we're not going to need in what we ultimately need to do is identify the positive and the negative rail so there we go we can see what we've got now they just strip away all the scrap all the scrap plastic insulation like so so four cables so we've got white pink white white we know that this one next to the pink on this particular USB cable is the five volt rail so we're going to color that end like so the two internal ones the pink and the second white we don't need so we're just going to cut them out like that and then we've got basically a live or a five volt and a ground rail so I'm just gonna strip a little bit of the installation back on these two and then we're going to twist the strands together a touch and now I want to bring in a little bit of extra cable that we've got sat to one side just a little bit of normal I think it's point seven five million could use thinner just electrical cable and what we're going to do with these two little fellas is we're going to weld them on or solder should I say solder them on to the input side of our book converter so we've got an input side here on about a hot shot of positive and negative remember we are still using DC so what I want to do is just tin the ends of these bits of cable here just like that there's one and here yes to my son like I'm rushing a little bit because I am aware that the whirlpools gonna be finished very soon and the brew that we've got going and then also what I want to do on the the little book converter is there are four parts obviously for positive in positive out negative in negative out so I'm just gonna flow a little bit of solder onto all four of these pads like this just so we've got something that we kind of connect to in a moment there we go and then we're going to make sure we've got the right end in and we want in positive will just flow that connection on there like so there we go again the same with the negative rail crunch here we go that's work nicely and then on the other side because these wires are so small I didn't really need to tin them last time so we're going to make sure we've got the plier to the right way around we're going to put the positive on to the positive and then we're gonna put the negative indeed on to the negative this is the output and a little bit tricky oh yeah Booker come on now we need to be able to hold down onto there without absolutely making a hash of it there we go that's got it so there we go so we've got 12 volts effectively coming in on one side of the book converter and then we've got our friendly 5 volt mini USB connector on the other side now what we need to do is we need to regulate the voltage on this book converter cell just to the side here we have got a 12 volt power supply let's get connected to that positive and negative zoom out so you can see what we're doing so there we go that's a positive in the correct term and all the negative in the same and then we're going to power the whole thing up with the cliff quick test itself there we go so that's now powered up as you can see and with the light just turn this up with the light showing at one side there of the power supply unit or the book converter so what we will need to do now is turn it down so if I just set the multimeter to DC you'll be able to see that we have got coming out of the book converter we've got twelve point six volts DC and going into the book converter we've also got 12 point 7 volts DC so we need to bring up DC voltage down and fortunately for us if I can get these two prongs to stay there like that very well how's that there's a little bit of a potentiometer I think is the right term on the top here there we go and you can see it falling now talk a bit of winding but the ESP thirty twos don't want anything over 5 volts really so to be on the safe side we're going to wind this down to 3.9 4 volts that will be happy there like that and then when we plug RESP 32 in then we're not going to blow the board there we go so now we have 12 volts coming in to our little book converter 4 volts coming out to our ESP 32 now this whole shebang this whole setup if I take it out it's ready to go directly into the fermenters so we already have a 12 volt power supply not as big as that one there but we already have a small LED power supply 12 volts inside the control units in order to actuate the valves for the glycol so the amount of power that these little things take which is effectively nothing we can just kind of piggyback off the back of those modules in order to get the repeater to work for us so I'm gonna go and start the transfer for the beer because it is time and then we're going to come back in a moment maybe with background sound effects of beer being transferred and we're going to we're going to hardwire purple into position so this is the inside of the broader control boxes you know at one point I did have a schematic for this but I don't know where I put it but if you go to my channel and search fermentation control or something similar then you will be able to find a schematic flawless so here on the back if you can see that is a 12-volt power supply module so we're going to pop these cables back in cuz this cable here controls the actuators the valve and of course we know now that this cable is controlling our SP 32 I think we've got them two in the rathole so we'll tighten them down it's pretty solid to me and then we'll get the other cable or the wire and we'll pop that in well maybe I've got some long nose pliers for this job and in hindsight but you seem to be getting by just fine so that's now in stick the negative cable in as well but doesn't want to go this isn't ideal as I say I'd have probably been better off taking these blocks out and then maybe adapting them putting away go on or something like that but we'll see how it goes if it nips it and it has then that's good enough for me right so then what I'm going to do is I've got a glue gun hooked in down here there we go rapid glue gun and I'm gonna splurge a load of glue onto the back wall of this box and then I'm gonna stick the power supply module just to the back just like that really yes no airs or graces here we're just gonna stick it up stick it right up and then the same thing for the ESP 32 I'm just going to find a place on the side of the side of the control box here I'm gonna run a couple beads of glue and I'm just gonna stick those pins straight into that glue and we're going to stick the ESP 32 on the side of the box that really is it folks if you want to have a peek inside you see we've got the ESP thing to on the back wall there we've got the power the buck converter just to put the top and then all of the other switching mechanisms in here for it to work so now all we need to do is close this bad boy as you can see it's got purple on it and then once this ferment is full of beer which is not going to be long quite frankly so once that ferment is full of beer and we'll drop our tilt in there and we'll see if indeed it sends a signal off to the TV screen or the monitor there's called I think so I thought it might be wise to show you exactly what we've got power in or calling that FV there so that is this maxi 310 chiller down here is at nine point four degrees but you'll get to minus five in no time at all come on Chauncey boy that away and then on the front I thought I'd better just show you it all illuminated so as you can see we have power to the SP feet - we are power to thee obviously to the book convert everything is working as it should in there that's not a problem but the STC's off well that's because it's turned off that's no bother either and you can see that we're going into the fermenter at 21 degrees just 21.1 let's have a quick look at the transfer over here it says 23 on there the beer degree or two of discrepancy obviously we just keep an eye on that but yeah it's all working so well it's all illuminated and it's all stuck up like I want it to be on to the board's so I want to go and close this box up now and we'll get the purple tilt out and see just how it's going to perform transfer complete and yes indeed [Music] we have the purple tilt broadcasting so I think the numbers might be a little bit out 1033 1034 looking better should be around 10:35 1036 for the vacant but could just be home up on the side for the minute so Tom hotel will leave that in there and hopefully it'll settle out later on one thing I can notice on the tilt though is that the signal is being updated every 3 or 4 seconds which means it's got really good Bluetooth connection and looking up there at the moment - 74 DBM which I'm guessing is merely decibels or something like that basically if it gets to minus 95 or above it tends to drop the signal so in the - 70s it's a good signal so I think that repeater is absolutely doing its job so then we're gonna want to cut the video here because otherwise it's going to end up being extremely long I hope all the information that you need to get yourself set up with one of these cheap and affordable repeaters is in either the video or the description below if you've got any questions you can leave them in the comments but I can't guarantee I'll answer them because I'm flying by the seat of my pants with this project as well it just seems to have worked because of the network of support that we've got out there on YouTube but yeah if if mr. gray is about and he wants to leave a comment below with regards to his program then you're more than welcome to do so sir and are now putting them your way so they can go and download this coding to put on your own ESP 32 now we'll go out sit we'll see you on the next one Cheers [Music] | HarryBrew69 | UCIIYTzYpd8D7y816diZB0Dw | 2019-11-30 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 4,555 | 22,397 |
NQRRnKdwY_c | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NQRRnKdwY_c | Fabolous Screams At Emily B’s Dad That He Has ‘A Bullet With Your Name On It’ In Scary Video | [Music] fabless was arrested this week on a domestic violence charge and new footage of an incident leading up to the police interference has been released by TMZ the clip shows the rapper going off on his baby mama Emily B and her father while brandishing a sharp object and threatening to shoot them the video was shot on the evening of March 28th in the couple's driveway at their Englewood NJ residents fabs bodyguard can be seen attempting to restrain him as he yells at his girlfriend and her dad at one point he asks the love the incident is what prompted police to respond to the home and fabless to turn himself in that night according to the website as previously reported he was arrested for aggravated assault and making a terroristic threat in the footage Emily can also be spotted trying to record her boyfriend which angered him more he lunged at her a few times with the sharp object in his hand and she quickly backed off while screaming a few days after the arrest North Jersey released information from court documents an affidavit of probable cause said that on March 7th Emily was punched in the face by fabless seven times which caused severe damage to her two front teeth that resulted in them falling out she then allegedly called her father to remove two handguns from the residence due to her fear that they may be used against her once the flipmode singer returned back to their place he confronted her her brother and her father before heading upstairs to search for the weapons when he could not locate the guns the defendant left the house but not before informing the victim her father and her brother that he had a bullet for them the court documents said | news star 24/7 | UCo2wQjIMeSKe04hpOHECquw | 2018-03-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 304 | 1,687 |
FcHrawaT3_U | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcHrawaT3_U | Alfalfa / Kuthiraimasal / Lucerne (Medicago sativa) || Seed Germination Test | Vanek America nah man the pineal apocalyptic alfalfa I work with Rama Salada seed germination tested number Paco for Mariano on the REC received a renovation test and I'ma kinda bring it over the plate method a disc method s and a method either voila narrator key method on their number normal on the Bou cycle our field a little bit panda Maria they move on look over tools at the output off in the laboratory lava if they were Scylla method long follow phenomena number Russa along the field alagaësia Pathak probe method of a roll towel method other than the number cada cloth the use for knee number germination for some danger number Parker aza people even from the first day here non-identical all there's the testing of the kuru kuru patella or in Naruto in LA I recede oh come on the count money at the clock in LA or operation Tiger is gone now when the countin money at the time I knew seats here Ekrem re-editing that the law number over record a cloth or a piece of the grow up around over thread they cut her finger to the draw a firm on the number 10 years ago we ran out of money narrow month attorney novo reporter our candle over all part of the copper on the seats are they number remove ponytail Alan Farragut Caracalla of the cedar on this hula hula chick cut detail opera thermal on the number daniel knowledge if their other on the rich in the bowel other laughs numb on this serum and the treatment of the radiator see it something is light on the technique for a cricket or a tender male recovers and even though would you pick to have dinner first the malt and along they were a different nutria every positive funneling the money narrow in the number the sample is there are therefore a great at the Parker Brothers opened a path of ena generation and the logarithm that they up for a new receipt somewhat new rear the Miranda Medicine check for new piping arena a possum day Jenna I wouldn't agree in the seats on generally recovering today in Cody eight number sample path of Maria whose angle becomes the other couple on the field local Aaron number easier interpreter or a standard number or a stronger and there's no Rydia creditor or other work interpreter Ivan Perez a number reticle on Landry | PURE AGROVET ENTERPRISES | UCscIUHeA3oEGpZ2difp2U2Q | 2020-04-29 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 413 | 2,226 |
UPm-ZqGvuIs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UPm-ZqGvuIs | We., 10/11/17 [1Box RANDOM COUNTRY] #4 - 2017 Panini Nobility Football (Soccer) | good afternoon everyone show for TAS nice hobby land we are starting the day off with some nobility soccer 2017 panini nobility soccer one box random country break number four from jaspis hobby land calm as you can see the next one already in the store sorry performs what I meant to write it there big thanks to these folks right here for getting it to the action there are your countries we compote some countries if there happens to be a country that we didn't list here that pops out then will will randomize it to one person in this break right here also players in there their club uniforms or their club shirts will go to the country that they represent all right here we go so let's roll the dice let's randomize each list three and a three six times six the hard way one two three four five and a six that final time so we have count down to kallen and then once again six times for the countries one two three four five and six we've got Portugal on top Argentina on the bottom all the other other of the other countries in between alright so County of Portugal nice Ricky with Italy mark you've got Denmark Mexico Wales Cal with Spain Carlos last bought mojo Germany David kiss with England Carlos with Austria Colombia Costa Rica Samuel Klein with Brazil David Cay with Sweden excuse me Ireland Ukraine Chris Wilson with our United States not not a good week at soccer for us Chris Wilson with the Netherlands Carlos with Russia Paraguay will with France count with Argentina so there we go that's alpha ties by country I don't think there's going to be any any trades I rarely see trades in these one box breaks but while people are think about it we're gonna do a random we're gonna generate a number that's a two by the way it's two three five seven and eight are the numbers that are left so let's go to rent org again we'll use the true random number generator right here and that will generate a number until we get until we get the which will call it a box that's available like four well we've done four already six we've done six seven we've not done seven lucky seven so there are seven right there and I don't see any trade so that list right here remains the same will close up the trade window TWC trade window closed alright good luck everybody box seven two autographs per box and each case has a each case has a pellet the either a relic or a relic autograph so that should be pretty she'll be pretty big I really like the design of this too it's pretty inexpensive and we looked all the autos and stuff up on eBay the if you get like a relatively well recognized player you could get hundreds of dollars for just even just the base autograph it's pretty crazy all right pack one good luck we have not seen the Pele cake it yet alright let's start off with Puyol all cards ship I really do like the the design here even the number the serial numbered cards will have some solid value too we start off with aldo sadhana for italy 179 out of 199 that goes to ricky Hulbert and italy forza zooty nice there you go old school guy and another Italian Roberto Donadoni another old school Italian right here 115 out of 199 on that one and another Wow in Italy box or Italy pack the autograph is a nod heart autumn of Carlo Ancelotti nice you know him as I think most of you may know him as a as a manager at first yeah the Italian calleb you're right I feel like a lot of the a lot of the hits seem to be seem to feature a lot of Italians here all right we got some cool inserts here two of their Shay Given which will also top-load a lot of even some of these like these national heroes cards could have value on a secondary market there's a Rivaldo for Brazil that'll go to Sam that's a nice one to the Shay Given there's an Ireland that'll go to David kissed and then we've got diego maradona and got vanilla Bautista right here will even sleeve up that meta Dona so a lot of these cards will still carry some value alright one more pack to go another autograph to go good luck rude I think he just uh he just retired after his vacation for a couple seasons in the United States there's Angelotti again and we got Michael Ballack 60 out of 99 for the German Carlos with the last pot mojo Edie the autograph is Ian right iconic signatures Ian right 207 out of 300 nice one for England that'll go to David kissed with that autograph we also have nice 51 is 75 for Costa Rica it'll go to Carlos that's uh that's Paulo Wanchope a nice one for Costa Rica and nobility bar key moments nice Cristiano Ronaldo cr7 for I think Callen has Portugal nice it's a lot of inserts that this in this pack here a nice iker casillas championship-caliber insert for Spain that'll also go to Kalin and this is the case it that we're looking for folks we still haven't seen it yet there's Beckenbauer and there's Pele this is who we're looking for four boxes to go in this case we're still looking for the Pele case hit who's gonna get it we're gonna see we're already halfway through the case not seeing the Pele case hit yet keep it going on Josh B's hobby that calm thanks everyone will soccer with you next time | Jaspys Case Breaks | UCjFmkmzvMl5pwHgFVV7F5gw | 2017-10-11 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 983 | 5,117 |
NZ0UIkTaaFs | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZ0UIkTaaFs | Angular is reactive .. in the State of JS | hey hey what's up people we're back I have to do the excuse me we have to do the of course do the stream things we're live uh I need to update is just say that or because we're live on doing Live on YouTube and on Twitch but I have it update my Twitter profile to say I'm live on Twitch but either way works hey tiamba Anthony what's up how are you all doing thanks for coming through uh that always start with the you gotta you gotta put something funny and sometimes for the the twitch intro and um so I'll try to think of something catchy to put in there and I maybe not click baby but catchy at least make you chuckle or something so sometimes it seems it seems to work sometimes so we're gonna keep keep rolling with it they put it there for a reason for bunch of lots and things so yeah do you know the Pines Twitter account I do not know the post Twitter account but it's pretty uh that was I'm pretty sure it's going to be hilarious because who doesn't like plans um there's a person on the angular team they their handle is to punt the Ponder woman Jessica uh which sees that on Twitter as much anymore but she's on Mastodon now uh but yes I'm sure she probably already subscribed to that still full of gold okay I had to check it out let's see what that's about but yeah thanks um those who are here and people who are coming through um it's been a good week so far um just been doing the usual stuff still working on open sourced moving along with that getting the insights open source which is pretty cool so definitely check that out if you haven't already hey Chandler what's up how are you thanks for coming through I'm good glad to see more people people dropping in some people I see sometimes and then some new people dropping in sometimes so that's always pretty cool then I see uh Ania just ping me in a thread on uh Twitter about something so let's check it out really quick hey Jason what's up how are you I saw you I saw you posted earlier that uh you weren't going to be streaming tonight because it had some family stuff to do which which is is good and I hope you have a good time either way so well what's up let's see we got we got the the people as they got the delayed message or something will what's up thanks for coming through my daughter's team is doing really well this year that's great good to hear uh Huff I'm not not sure how to pronounce your name but I'm just gonna call you Huff for for purposes but yeah on the agenda I'm gonna be looking at uh I'm gonna give her some at least some takes on the state of JS uh front-end Frameworks maybe angular and specifically gonna do some stuff with analog and um because they did have did ship some updates there um which I'm excited about now like I said in my message last week on the stream was I built an entire meta framework to go to write a blog post um so this is kind of on brand for that where we are putting some of the pieces together to be able to build a Blog with analog pretty quickly so uh startup Builder what's up did you see hey Kate Chris what's up glad to see you let me stop some of these things that are running extra things that are running here startup Builder yes ngrx is a set of libraries for building reactive angular applications uh open source for angular apps uh so yeah that's that's the the Quick Pitch anyway Andres what's up smart people hey you you're in here also so welcome welcome to you uh did you see angular will support SAS properly now yes I did see that uh angular is supporting SAS in the experimental es build Builder uh which is cool I definitely been following that along with that um just from working on analog and is using some of the same things that the es build Builder uses um so they're they're able to parse the component temp like inline Styles and um inline Styles and external styles to be able to use SAS with those now which is pretty cool um everybody just throwing in their uh hopes and dreams into the chat uh but yes analog also supports uh SAS for inline inline SAS also and it's kind of using like say using some of the same mechanisms but it's using V transforms to uh make that happen so we're still like staying within the within the pipeline which is pretty cool somebody must ask a question about this so we're going to jump into Twitter really quickly here this week on Twitter this week in angular Twitter we'll see if that's what we call it uh but yes ping me on something somebody must ask a question about angular let's see trying a few Google searches where I use angular in 2023 stuff like that every single article is garbage favorite one is angular's popular among entrepreneurs wow angular is popular my entrepreneurs as it helps them capture a GNC audience that's nice analog Works only works with Standalone components uh no that is not the case and you can use analog with um we'll get back to this in a second but I just kind of wanted to show that with the what I got pinged on right there uh so we'll go back to monologue for you there we go um no analog actually works with or without Standalone components the if you want to use file based routing yes that is true but you can use a traditional I don't know for that's what I want to call it traditional application that uses uh NG modules with analog also and it'll still work uh the same I've actually tried it with a couple of sample projects that are using like the the oh I don't want to call it the old way but the more traditional way of bootstrapping an entry module but that all still works well too so I do want to provide at least some Avenue for people who necessarily maybe have an existing angular app and want to try it out um with analog so cool tiam but why did you go with the name analog just curious yes I can give you some backstory there um I'm going to go back to the repo here uh yes why is this project named analog so um analog not digital yes this project the name for the project was inspired and I actually created it the the person in the readme um about this but you see the contributors there the engine modules are dead uh yes so um yes the original project that uh I was that I got this name from was this project by a person who used to work at Google I believe they used to work at Google and as you see this project is long gone by now but uh this project was effectively trying to use trying to use a different component authoring format and it looks similar to um into modules not NG modules looks similar to jsx um there so ciao what's up um man I got all our live live in the chat today I must say but yes analog um I think his name's Rob Delaney wrote this project a while long ago and if let's see if I can find the Tweet uh Brandon T Roberts rent free it's bad that I uh still remember these things yes here it is this was the original tweet for the uh that kind of sparked this whole thing uh he the Tweet was what if I told you this was angular and as you can see he has some components that look like uh jsx components so a counter you state use pipe those things are familiar through angular and then we have a component down here that's used templates using jsx but all of this kind of compiled down to angular so I have been digging digging digging for this project uh and actually this part this was four years ago I had been digging for this tweet forever and then I've actually found it and um and so of course this project didn't really go anywhere but uh the name of the project is what stuck out to me so I was trying to think of a name for a meta framework for angular and and analog came to mind uh this project came to mind so I was like okay cool that that's a pretty kind of generic name so I went with analog JS like okay that might work so then of course we go to npm and we say okay is analog is analog available on npm um and of course we look go to npm so I go back in time it's like oh published eight years ago there's a project called analog already okay cool um but analog JS was not taken on npm so that was the first drop in the in the bucket here for analog uh so analog was analog JS was available npm so when it grabbed that org uh winning grab the org on GitHub analog Js uh when I grabbed the org on GitHub it's like okay cool that was there um so when it looked domain went and grabbed the domain analog.js was there I'm like man all these things kind of like fell in place um all these things fell in place for analog to at least have the name so I wouldn't have to have you know I wanted a consistent name and like brand everywhere so uh have the like I said was able to grab the npm Org the GitHub org and the domain and Marco who's on the ngrx team uh pointed me to the Twitter handle he said hey the Twitter handle is available uh you should grab it before somebody else does and I was like yes I like created a Gmail account and went through that uh signed up for the the Gmail account created the analog account on Twitter um and so I had all the pieces in place to for the project itself as far as a name even if I never did anything with it like I had the domains and everything that was there so that was the uh that is more or less the back story of how I got the name analog and plus it was similar to angular so that was kind of like the icing on top um but yes I wanted something that was similar to that and that's of course as you can see with the logo um the logo is similar to the angular logo with two parts most of the other meta Frameworks use for some reason use triangles like if we go to next.js what do you see triangle uh if we go to next uh what do we see triangles so uh what do we do with analog triangles uh but the the colors and the kind of theme match the red and the white the two shades of red and the white uh with angular so everything kind of just works together there uh because you got to be able to like tell a story right uh be able to tell a story with what your what you're trying to promote so being able to tie all those things together was kind of was kind of like worked out like I say it worked out in the favor for the project so whether I had ever done anything with it or not I still had all the branding and stuff there so that's kind of the back story of how analog came to be just like the original project it's a crazy idea that may or may not go anywhere but I'm going to do it either way so there you go sounds like the start of a casino's Piercy triangles everywhere hey I wouldn't uh doubt that uh let's see let me catch up on chat here um yeah Anthony said want to register digital the opposite of analog hey good luck uh I was not going to get a Hotmail account even though I did have one back in the day triangles is a strong shape analog J is that pizza is available hmm that would be a nice Crossover with open sourced I must say uh do you plan on integration integration analog with some back-end framework Niche yes or other uh it can out of the box let's switch back here guess we're doing monologue for you today out of the box um analog comes with a pre-built server a node server out of the box but you can use it with an sjs I did an example of using it with angular Universal um like using an existing angular Universal project and kind of using a custom server there so it is possible to do that and use that instead of like the webpack build so that part is possible too but uh you can you can use it with your server rendering stack of choice I guess it is whether it be node or use express or an sjs or any of those other tools it may just take a little bit of setup to do that but it is possible though because it is the thing that some the server side of analog is built on top of nitro which is very flexible in itself so let's see so I'm catching up on the chat and we'll get into some of the other thing I wanted to cover there triangles the Illuminati is involved I don't want I'm not in the Illuminati I don't want to be a part of that uh would you explain what does it mean they want to make angular zoneless do you think they tend to go to Something in react you state you signal uh yes um so Zone JS is the is the magic let's say let's we'll keep it that way Zone JS is a library that uh angular uses under the hood to patch a bunch of browser apis um or patched the native apis most of them browser-based but things like promises async Activity Set timeout all those things it patches those things so we can Anglers change detection system can use those to signal to the framework that something needs to be updated so this is why click handlers and a lot other things in angular just work because it is already it has knowledge of all those events that happen the problem comes in where with Zone JS is that of course it handling all that for you you may it becomes it can become noisy if you have a lot of um a lot of streams of data a lot of events coming through it may give you a bottleneck there as far as performance and so if you want to kind of squeeze out more performance and you can choose the zoneless route where you control all the events that happen or the events that happen don't trigger Zone JS and then don't trigger angular so you have a little bit more granular control about how angular gets updated so you can squeeze out more performance in those type of scenarios but there's like a balance to be had there do you want the magic of Zone JS to handle all that for you or do you want the uh the hands-off approach to where he's you say that um I I I know what I'm doing here uh I can trigger the change when I'm ready so um angular going zoneless will there's not like they're just removing his own JS or making it optional and not giving you anything else there is um some Rumblings going around I will call it about using signals in angular to make uh Zone JS optional and in using something like signals we can still notify the framework that something needs to get updated but not have to rely on patching all these apis and using Zone JS in that way so we have to see which all this is still you know being discussed of how it's going to work and of course the migration path of new apps and things like that because there are apps out there that just not going to move off of Zone JS so but there are some be opportunity there in the future for new apps to be able to use it so that's something we have to keep out looking out for and uh CF signals will be the answer of uh reactivity in angular that's first first class first party uh for everyone to use out of the box so and then you can kind of layer your rxjs on top of that and everything else so we'll have to see how that goes Emma replied to my tweet she said it will be good okay cool [Music] um power and thanks for coming through uh Alex thanks for coming through also ciao I see you switched over to the to the other chat there uh it felt lonely on YouTube there's a few people hanging out on YouTube I have to I don't know what the split is I'll have to see let's look and see what the the split is on um restream here set up for zoom Okay cool so we got nine people on uh YouTube and 17 people on Twitch um well by the way if you're watching the live stream go ahead and hit the like button gotta throw that in there so other people will be able to see the video after it's finished um more excited about Zone JS and local compilation mode yes that is another thing that it will be potentially coming also um moving the Titanic version of an app yes is going to be interesting Josh I will I will say I'm gonna go out on a limb and say there's a project that me and you worked on that Will Never Move off of Zone Jazz I'm just going to go ahead and say it uh because the app is just too big too many moving Parts um it's just gonna be that way until they move off of angular um so and you I think you know what that that project is so [Laughter] Josh to jva took out the chat box real estate yeah uh that Josh is uh he's he's he's moving in he got his elbows out he's you know wrestling the chat so oh I have to make him a um uh mod or something make some people some mods let some other people muscle in remember to like his tweets he lives for those likes hey you got to get the dopamine hit sometimes right how can we learn angular interesting interesting question there are many ways to learn angular you can go to the uh let's go here let's go into pitch mode for people that still want to learn anger because it kind of gets into the the topic that at least I want to cover in a second here but how can you learn angular of course the first step is always to try the angular docs I will say that the the angular docs are getting a refresh as far as content goes the getting started is getting updated and the um the getting started is getting updated so there might be something new here to for how you can go through getting started with angular because we got Standalone components coming in we've got the new new other new things coming in so it kind of changes how you go through the flow as a new angular developer so that's one way another way would be to code through free cocamp angular let's see this may be santosh's course here angular for beginners free code Camp is a completely free course I believe this is the right one I'm looking for um I don't see santosh's name on here there we go Santosh Santos made this free course on uh free Co camp for angular for beginner so if you want to learn about that that's definitely another link I'll link all these in the description anyway uh Joe Eames has a course on thinkster yes we're just gonna plug all the things if you go to thinkster.io they have courses on angular uh 191 lessons oh man okay maybe next time 13 hours of video fundamentals of angular free course reactive forms and angular free course uh there we go thanks for the link uh is it this one fundamentals there we go uh Joe is a fantastic uh teacher and we're all really passionate about angular teaching angular and helping people learn it also um so definitely check those out if you're looking for to learn how to use angular uh good question did I answer the angular yearly survey yet I did not answer the survey yet I was thinking about doing that on stream but I don't know how much longer the survey is going to be out but uh I didn't want to um I'll keep my my honest opinions Anonymous as they say uh for that so hey uh Tomo laforge thanks for coming through uh angular challenges on GitHub another good resource drop that link in there and in the chat and we'll add it to the to the show notes also introduction to angular on the Google Chrome Developers YouTube channel oh man that's a mouthful YouTube Google Chrome developers angular okay cool there's another one by my good buddy Mark in the angular team introduction angular that is another good resource for uh learning angular you can hear the sound so we're not gonna I could pipe it through the this audio here but um but yeah definitely check this video out or drop that link in the show notes also and I'll drop it in the chat so I can reference it later um yes audio mix live on stream is key yeah I do actually do have the audio piped into the the stream um but we're not doing we're not doing a live reaction video so that could be something we could do in the future also uh angular challenges on GitHub yep drop that link in there and uh we'll show it up here let's probably can find it here uh left Forge angular there it is hey as you can see it's probably already in my history angular challenges is another good one if you want to level up some of your angular skills and he took my advice I said if you create a thing then you got to have a logo and uh there's a logo in this one also so if anything you could uh definitely try that out uh this um out there or even contribute to it if you would like Zach Mr super ship himself uh in the chat here appreciate you for coming through um if you haven't checked out man I'm just plugging all the things if you haven't checked out [Music] um Zach's course on supership.io uh you should because you can get 50 off of this course um and it and it's relatively relatively inexpensive I will say that I did buy this course myself uh I have not gone through the whole thing yet but um yes go to supership.io purchase the course it's a one-time fee and then you get the course for forever so check that out also yeah so we got the A-list stars in the chat today everybody's coming through I like it I'm gonna have to do some longer streams uh one day and then we can just kind of Vibe for a while and see how that goes excuse me at work we have a big Enterprise and we use more imperative approach subscribing to API calls Etc and the components not using async pipe feel bad it has a Twitter sphere recommends going async pipe all the way yes uh if you're using angular and you use an rxjs you most likely want to use the async pipe um just because it helps you avoid subtle and not so subtle bugs in your code mainly because in this kind of leads to where angular may be going is today you have to subscribe and unsubscribe mainly for observables to avoid memory leaks now there may be a future to where you don't have to do that with rxjs and angular but we aren't there yet so to help level up your team and level up your app um if impossible when possible use the async pipe and pass your observables or even promises to that because it handles both to be able to subscribe and unsubscribe directly from those without you having to do it yourself and avoiding those things so you don't have to change everything in one day uh you can kind of refactor some of that stuff over time and then it just becomes part of your workflow so yeah but yeah so we're not going to shame anyone for subscribing because sometimes you got to subscribe but if you're over subscribing to observables and angular you can kind of level up there so hope that helps you can clip this and uh you can clip this and pass it to the team and uh tell them that uh I said that you should not be subscribing to things manually to save your save your own uh save yourself some heartache I always recommend slowly introducing patterns to interview Enterprise environments yes so many so much things going on in Enterprise environments that you gotta you gotta kind of ease those things in and then kind of let them take take over as they go show them how the code can be simplified and it will change their minds yes that's true uh Dan thanks for coming through also Edition addict thanks to you too where I work I use best practices in the files I'm working on so by removing bad practices or deliver my work Balancing Act yes that is true um the one of the one of the the challenges is uh or one some of the things you can do there is like if you know there are other people looking at your code then you kind of have to be a little more cautious about or a little more strict about what you do because that code that you take somebody else is going to like copy and paste it somewhere else and um they're going to take that code copy and paste it and then that code is going to grow somewhere else so uh if you have good practices like try to enforce those good practices out from the beginning then the other developers who come behind you will naturally kind of see what you're doing maybe they'll copy some of that stuff too and they won't copy the bad parts they'll copy the good practices and and then maybe you get to a point where you can kind of implement those things up front you can do these things with like lint rules and things like that but lint rules can be annoying sometimes I must say yeah that is true others others are gonna have to review it so uh be mindful of that too um when you're doing that sort of thing because if they're just copying and pasting it without knowing like what's going on then it might not help as much there because then they're just gonna be like I did it because I saw it done this way I didn't actually know that that I shouldn't have done it uh in this particular case so foreign yes hey man y'all are y'all are live in the chat today I must say even restream is telling me uh I got um 100 messages so far so it's pretty cool how far is analog from V1 good question um a ways away we're still some of the packages are still in Alpha um but we will move those into beta soon uh but yes V1 is a state of mind as Anthony said uh for me V1 just means that I mean for me people would already be using analog and production before it reaches a V1 so uh which I think is usually the case for open source projects I mean I've used stuff I've been using open source projects that weren't that have never reached a V1 per se but they were stable enough to be used so um V1 is a nice Milestone nice round Milestone to hit um but I prefer that I can just say that it's stable for you to use and then we'll fix bugs as they come up as a as a point of reference so what's the best way and then let's talk about evolutionary steps yes how can we get this working what's the ideal what is the ideal uh step what is the ideal scenario and how can we get there if we can Zone JS never hits V1 oh yes um yeah there was a there was a point in time where Zone JS they were trying to get Zone JS basically built into the browser apis so that angular wouldn't be the owner necessarily be the owner of uh that library that will be listening to these events and provide this mechanism for uh angular to listen to but that never really got that far that's a good question uh let's get with there's a lot of stuff happening but let's say aren't API calls unsubscribed on their own how would you force refetching data refetchdata.next um yes the HTTP client will complete the observable for you unless you're doing like a streaming streaming responses uh but um but other places it doesn't work that way like the framework does a good job of handling some of this stuff for you as far as the observables it provides like HTTP in the router um but not everywhere so just still have to be mindful of those things do you think analog should feature in the state of JS this year that is a good question um my answer is no unless it's some there's some kind of upcoming or uh there's some kind of stage for upcoming new and upcoming projects sure let's go with that but uh that's a good question and I did want to uh talk about the state of Js um and I didn't want to I didn't want to talk about the state of Js because it's happened again will of course we we I don't know if people look forward to state of JS uh survey every year but it's been going on for a few years now and uh since five years of relative stability many are beginning to question the status quo there's of course there's new things that come up every year and of course this year was no different and the state of JS kind of takes a look back they do the survey they calculate this data every year and they get a bunch of responses about how different front-end Frameworks are doing where these people's backgrounds are from and a lot of other things that um would uh maybe this way people who decision makers maybe they don't um but the state of JS is a thing and it does cause um a lot of words to be said and a lot of thoughts to happen every year so uh as you can see and you've seen a lot of other videos in this talking about the state of JS and they didn't want to look at some of the things here in here so we'll dive right into the to the uh the the front end Frameworks part here because that's kind of where the space that uh I occupy in these days and of course all the a lot of familiar faces here got reactive view angular um spelled is I don't want to say it spells new because it's been around for a while solid as solid has been around for a while also but and then quick is real it's probably one of the the newer ones so um yeah this provides some numbers over time as far as uh how front-end Frameworks are doing and of course if we take a look at angular we can see that angular has definitely dropped over time so in the in the survey itself so if we move that back there angular kind of started out when 2016 I guess that's when they started a survey 68 percent and if we take a look at where react was a 2016 it was at 92 percent so uh and this these things are retention interest usage things like that so as you can see angular has definitely uh declined over the years uh in retention from developers and that just means that uh they've used angular uh they would or would not use it again and I think there's a few factors that uh a few things that factor into this of course if you used angular a few years ago and uh you didn't like the experience and somebody brought angular to you again today and that's your only memory is like no no thanks um especially if you were around for a pre-standalone components pre-new apis uh pre uh angular kind of evolving over time so and even the whole thing of mixing angularjs into this mix I don't know if they still would lump those angular and angularjs together angularjs being the old deprecated framework um the precursor to angular and then angular being the more the modern one so there was a point in time to where these were getting mixed up pretty regularly so maybe some of that has been cleaned up here but you can look and see through the different ways here how Anglers kind of dropped over time now someone asked me if I thought that or they were saying they were kind of hesitant about where angular is and I was I was saying that angular is not going to go away uh just because unless Google comes out in uh sun sets it uh yeah so a lot of the experience that people have was pre-iv um pre uh and a lot of things basically got iv'd and in that way so uh looking at this through the lens of that I could see how some people would not prefer uh angular if they use it back then but some people just aren't going to prefer angler anyway so this is not necessarily for those people um but if you've used it and you had a decent experience with it and you kind of stuck with the framework as I have over these this time then you'll kind of get well how these numbers are where they are now my response was to that was that I think that angular will still move on just because not because it'll be the most popular uh but because it angular is still evolving like they're still making changes to the framework improving it for the people that are using the framework and along that way you'll get some people that are that'll switch over that are maybe try to react that haven't moved to something like solid or uh spelled yet but angular is still like that familiar thing there so I think that angular will still have some have a uh of course a place in the the front-end framework ecosystem even if it hit a smaller audience like the audience right now is more tailored towards Enterprise and large projects like that and these other front-end Frameworks have been uh people are using these in more startup like environments and things like that so angular is trying to be like the framework that that kind of grows with you so we'll see uh if that's the case and you can see like awareness of course just about everyone knows what angular is as far as voting goes but all the other like key metrics or shows angular in Decline um but that is that's not to say that angular is like in a free fall because it has been some time where angular was has moved forward or at least ticked back up some in usage or in these other areas so uh that at least shows that they are improving the framework for the people who use it today and the people that are using in the future because uh if they stop supporting it then of course they're going to just drop all the way down to the bottom because nobody's going to be nobody wants to use something and isn't it being maintained anymore and that's definitely not the case with angular so uh it is one of those things that uh people like to dunk on and everything so we'll just you know we'll we'll stick to just uh shipping things and uh angular still move along as it as it goes so and then of course these other tools some of these other things I'm actually interested in like solid and things like that so uh I may end up doing something like that doing something along a video along those lines too but angular is still here here today it'll be here tomorrow and we'll see what the rest of the the future holds there foreign I remember early angular was chaotic I think things actually stabilized around V12 yes angular angular version 3 was a mess now like angular version 3 never happened a lot of third-party lives are no longer maintained and there isn't really a lot of them compared to react been doing react for a few years professionally but I miss angular sometime once you learn angular it's hard for to forget it hey that is that is true I've been doing some I'm doing some react these days also and uh they are definitely different in that way um and how you kind of think about how you build with them so we'll see please don't provoke Google they would do it at a moment's notice yes that is true um Google is known for sending things to the graveyard so we'll see if uh angular that is a good thing angler has managed to survive this long uh even with all the other things that have been killed by Google so um I think that says something to the about the framework itself as a newbie I gave myself three months with react three months with angular angular's logic and system was a no-brainer interesting yeah it it I guess it depends on how you want to to build things if the angular kind of fits your mental model then it makes it easier to to consume or easier to like look over the things that it doesn't do like jsx for some reason is like the thing I can point to to like just about everybody everybody else is doing jsx except for angular uh and uh Angler's on an island in in that way but um but yes angular's future is bright I would agree um because of the things on the roadmap and I should have talked about some of those things also but maybe we'll save that for another one uh yes the the road map is solid and uh the angular roadmap is solid and uh definitely bright so like to see more of that satisfaction for angler grows because people who hate it finally could switch over from it hmm interesting take um I don't know they will still have to take the survey so well they are people that would still take the survey so they could switch away from it and not recommend it but then that will still cause the satisfaction to go down so um but like I said the I believe the angular team and well that there was an angular developer survey that also recently came out I don't know if it's still active or not uh let's see angular yes there's still a survey here if you haven't taken it uh definitely check that out uh fill out the survey if you use angular and you still want to give the team some feedback definitely check out that survey and fill that out too but I'm probably preaching to the choir here in the chat at least the angular people anyway Google has 3 000 plus internal apps they use so they have a lot of skin in the game yeah that's true but angular also has other web Frameworks in turn another web framework eternally too so it's not as the developer experience for that framework isn't as nice as angulars but it's not it is a more geared towards uh scale and high performance so and miscos talked about this in in his um when he's talked about angular also about the framework internally at Google called Wiz that a lot of the like Google search and other things are are built with so but angler is definitely still used inside of Google and I know this because njrx is still being used inside of Google and Alex okrsco was our main point of contact uh inside of Google when he was there and uh we still have conversations with people who are using it internally there so we know it's still being used on experienced over time graph ain't going to have lots of not interested people and what I can see right now is angular team changes the framework to make it interesting for the audience maybe so I don't like I guess to me like either you like angular or you don't um like fundamentally like either you like jsx and you don't like the way that angular works or you think angular is too like heavy-handed with what it prescribes uh so you don't tend to use things like that so uh then the all the thing always used to be hey angular is a framework react is a library blah blah blah and then things like next came along and um other meta Frameworks built on top of react that kind of offer that same experience that angular has so I thought it was very interesting to look at those how like that conversation has evolved over time with regards to angular the framework and react uh reactive framework because at this point they're giving you client and server Primitives so I would I would call it to that I was say it's closer to that now regarding jsx felt doesn't use it I think it's considered to have a better DX yeah that's true they have their own special syntax uh Forestville it kind of well it doesn't kind of it doesn't look necessarily that much like jsx it's Phil is this felt.dev there we go I know my my buddy Tim the Shriver is a big fan of svelte also and I've looked at it too but I haven't gotten um really deep into it yet but I do look at of course I'm building analog I look at other things other meta Frameworks and see what they're doing like spell kit and I have looked at some of the things of house felt kind of works and things like that so to at least for inspiration and things like that because Phil stores was a thing or it's a thing it's felt um that I was hoping would get adopted by angular at some point as far as being able to use observables directly and it knows just know how to handle them in the template without the async pipe so uh if you're not familiar svelt has these things called stores or spill has like a reactive Primitives itself to where you can attack things with a dollar sign um to mark them as reactive to say that these things will update uh when these props change or these other things change so uh spelled has successful has these reactive Primitives so that these things will update when the prop changes and all that kind of is kind of magic um so and that was like I said along with this felt stores you can have a store they did an observable you can use observables with spelled and it will just handle them also which was I thought was pretty nice foreign view is the closest to angular yes I would say if we are looking at like HTML syntax in uh how it feels I would definitely say view is the closest to angular as far as the template syntax goes with the bindings interpolation those things um yeah because Evan you used to work uh it used to be in the angular community angularjs community I should say uh so maybe he took some of that those things with um from angularjs and took them to view and kind of did it started out just looking look kind of looking like angularjs if angularjs had went 2.0 but then they've gone a whole different Direction with the reactivity and everything else so you can see with the V4 looks familiar to ng4 uh those sort of things event handling I think is different uh they have like the at click instead of the um parentheses as far as that goes so yeah there's that angular copies felt it would be perfect for me the robustness and consistent of angular spell clean syntax yeah I view also has di they do um that is true they have the provided inject and when I saw this I was like this looks oddly familiar uh that view has this where you can use the inject to get things from the or that you provide of course the the mechanism how it works is different than how angulars is but uh it's nice that it has that I'm not doing ads I'm just gotta take a sip my framework shouldn't be doing magic I'm the one that's supposed to be doing the magic that's right Josh you are the angular magician after all uh let's see I think I'm caught up on chat and the most important person procrastination question is the extent the vs code theme is night owl uh Night Owl whoops Night Owl by Sarah Dresner if you ever want a good Dark theme I'm not one I'm not a person that changes themes uh often so I kind of pick one and stick to it I was just using um my own I was just using like the vanilla one that came with vs code which is probably uh programmers uh uh no no but Sarah Dresner night owl download it a bunch of times definitely check that one out if you're looking for a nice clean theme and I've stuck use it and stuck with it so it works for me any advice on starting your own meta framework wow that's a big question um it depends on what you want to do I guess uh I started out with like a list of I started out with a list of things that I wanted my meta framework to have and those things have kind of remained true to what I wanted to be um I would use I wanted to use Veet because uh I feel like feet is like the next tool of choice that's currently out there and it has a wide ecosystem so that was one thing I did want to have was wide ecosystem support um but I mean past that it depends on what you want to do like file based routing was on my list API routes was on my list uh SSR SSG seems to be like a or server-side rendering and static site generation seems to be a um table Stakes as they would say like these are things that your middle birth framework must do at a minimum but some of the other things could be optional like I I kind of think that I could have went without the API routes and just leave that up to the developers to use for how they want to implement those but it's nice to have you don't have to use them but they're there so I haven't seen anybody making any like requests for features on those as much as some of the other things like when we added markdown using markdown as routes to analog that seems to be the one that's at least gotten the most traction recently uh just because you can build static sites with it uh uh with the mark down this route makes that part easier so if you want to build a static site with angular uh and analog that's pretty straightforward there if I use chain sets before a child no I have not used chain sets I've seen it around a lot this is like watch Brandon Google things uh session time that's okay uh I have not used change sets I am still looking at always track back to analog um I have an open issue here for automating publishing of packages because I'm doing things manually at the moment and if I could have a way for it to just have a way for it to detect the chat packages that changed bump those versions and then have those inner point ready points I could release them if I just push up a tag or something like that and then do release those and I would uh definitely look into doing that playwright integration is also on the list uh yes there is an open issue um it's going through all my uh playwright history here uh let's see there's an open issue somewhere for anger I think supposed to maybe this is the one because somebody actually pinged me on this one and I put together a repo that shows angular and playwright component tests working together uh but it's just it shows that it works um I'll drop this in the in the chat also uh it shows that it works but it definitely need some more work for it to be like a shippable thing so I don't know if if we could I mean we could put this in analog but if they would put this in um the Microsoft playwright repo and use the analog Plugin or the V plugin that would be even better I would think the analog is open source well I have news for you friend analog case open source it's completely open source there's a link uh to the repo um feel free to contribute if you like maybe some good first issues I don't know if I have any labeled at the moment um but yeah I think I haven't it's been a minute since I went through and labeled the good first issues but um yeah if you definitely want to check out the project join the the Discord and we can talk about it more there I'll drop a link to the Discord in chat too but things things a project always needs docs people to try it File books all those things uh help a project get more stable and that's what I would like to see is like the core of it is there the V plugin is there I just want to be it be more stable for a usage and I do have some people that are using it already um and they have things that we've been able to go back and forth on and fix things with so uh definitely hop in the Discord check it out file some issues uh yeah because it doesn't seem like at least the the work that I've done on it has been has gone noticed by others uh in the in the space so that was pretty cool to see uh but I will have to check out chain sets I have not checked out check that out cool so we talked about this Theta JS um yeah I can talk about some analog stuff here also one thing that a thing that we did add recently was like I said Mark down his routes is well this is another thing I need to revamp the docs on analog because it just looks like a bunch of packages now and the content package isn't even up here yet but what I want to do is add a like a getting started and it could be just like you build a Blog build a Blog with analog it has a nice ring to it I keep saying it over and over but um take you through the steps of how to build a Blog and um that way you can have a guide that can show you what it does like the file based routing shows you how to do that shows you how to use markdown as routes so you can still use regular angular routes if you have a mix of uh content there and um still have to still be able to use it just as you would any other angular app there so that's one of the things that I have an open issue on for docs is to update there so if you have some experience with docusource and you want to contribute uh definitely check that out have you tried running analog Zone lists um I have not but I don't see any reason why it wouldn't work because you can use it with a Zone full or zoneless application let's see I had a GitHub repo around here somewhere uh let's see repositories uh this is my angular analog SSR example um but I'm just showing this mainly to show that this one is a app that uses an NG module based traditional NG module based app so you could make this zone list and use it also the only part that requires Standalone components is the routing so if you want to bring your existing routing set up with just the vanilla angular router you can do that too like it shows in this app here so it's not like you don't have to like switch over everything the file based routing and all that to use analog so drop that link in the chat definitely check that one out if you're looking for a an example of uh SSR with even a well this this particular one was using fastified with analog and angular which worked also but um yeah let me check the twitch thing here because I haven't checked follows and things so I'm probably slacking on that um oh I see we got some some familiars uh Pollock thanks for the follow um startup Builder power in uh Preston thanks for the follow Thomas Thanks for the follow jmw 5598 thanks for the follow um just catching up on those so those people uh either lurking or just already just already came through uh yes where was I yes documentation as I as I mentioned before um looking to up those though updated with a real getting started like this just shows you how to get an application off the ground or spin up a new app but I want to have it be like a quick tutorial of how you can use that so um yeah Dominic thanks for uh coming through I didn't mention that earlier but let's check and see what we've got let's just here okay cool um yeah so uh what I did want to show with whatever where I was going with that was uh on the last stream I did show a link with I did I did building a Blog with analog where I was trying to build start from scratch and show you how I could do that so uh we have added a few extra things since last time um so last time I'll spin this up uh NG serve if you're hesitant about switching but you still want that nice angular feel it works with NG serve so there's that but what I showed last time was just a simple blog uh it's probably real reloading here my first post my second post and a link to there um so this is just a a few links and some content in these couple of photos here now manually linking to these blog posts here and I had a route for the blog and one for just a couple of links here uh we did release a newer version that handled some of this stuff for you so as far as giving you a list of the things in the content folder and making it so you can build a Blog and have the content that you store there a little easier so I'm going to update to I'm going to remove that and reinstall latest packages and um we'll see we'll let that install ing all the latest package of analog and let's make sure it's got the right version that I'm looking for 0.1.3 and that's 23 for five okay and let's check here just to make sure because it just did a re release try this morning yeah 0.1.3 for five oh that looks good so um in here I have an inject content um I don't know what we call these in angular with the inject inject content function it's not a hook per se but I also had a place to where like if I want to list the blog posts I'm just doing this manually now but now we have this and here I have welcome to my Vlog so what I want to do here is I'm going to copy this one and I'm going to rename this to index.ts and we'll name this one block home and bring in ng4 so I can iterate over a list hook ejector that's a good that's a pretty good one uh I like it um so I don't need a router Outlet do need router link and uh that one so this would just be the page that you go to when you're on slash blog uh so before now I want to change this to we can name this simple to something like posts and we have an unordered list it was just kind of uh okay we're just gonna lit uh this do it for me blog post slug okay it's not doing quite what I wanted to there so the machines haven't won just yet so UL and I also want to I'm going to create an interface here for a post and we'll say this post has a title string and a slug of string so we can see in here in my content folder I have a couple of posts here I don't have any front matter in these posts so I'll add that for here we go to title my first post and a slug uh which will just match the file name here so we'll take that one and we'll add one for my second post and we'll take the slug for that one also so we'll save those two and so we have our posts here and those are in our content folder um but what I want to do is get a list of those things and with the latest version we have another uh hook here so I'll call this post and say this inject content files so inject content files will give me a list of the files that were got files that were um read out of this folder with their contents and the front matter that is along with them so I want to inject content files and I'll say that their attributes are have the type of post so here I will add a router link and I will say that this is a this will link to slash blog I have route slash blog and then the slug so we'll link to post extent so I have lit post of posts and then we'll have our posts and I believe this attributes attributes dot um slug if I remember correctly in post that attributes Dot title so we have our link here and then we can save that um so if I did it go start up our NG serve and go back to my app here and unless I broke something oh that's nice uh front matter is not resolved okay so I did add a new package here also that I didn't install so we're going to add front matter and we'll get that version clearly that nice big air there and we'll run yarn to get the front matter package and let's try that again I believe I have the other ones for the content package it has front matter marked prism J and prism JS so I think those are the ones that it needs let's see if we get a Reload here okay now we have okay cool so we have our menu bar here for the app component and my container here so I can remove these from here and now I have posts and let's let's go back to here and we'll have we'll name this one router link I'll go to slash home uh Slash home and slash about and then we'll wrap this in div foreign over the place so wrap that into divs just so it puts it on the next line so we have home and about and I have my posts I could use some extra lines here let's wrap this one in an H2 uh suppose my first post and my second post so uh now you have to at least have those two pieces uh to be able to list your content and render that content without having to wire a whole lot of things up manually and you can still use the the markdown based uh routes for the other parts so all that is nice and well working together now in the latest version of analog so if you're a current user you can update to the latest packages or if you're new then you can run the npm command to initiate to create a new project and all that will be ready to go out of the box and this is what I'm kind of getting to with the with the the new um getting started that's going to happen in the docs and I'll and I'm looking at making this a template starter also uh so if you go create analog today it'll generate it like a vanilla angular v15 app and then we'll have a Blog starter there that'll give you some posts and give you a list of posts just out of the box something super simple um not too many styles or things like that but just something you can customize out of the box to get up and running pretty quickly so and also did deprecate the route meta there so we're just using a type there now instead of the function route yeah so there's that analog compare is analog comparable to Nesh JS um no analog is more comparable to next JS and spell kit and next um so this JS I can open this up nist .js.com is a doe JS framework uh that builds on top of Express and fastify um and analog is a meta framework on top of angular so you could use an sjs AS like a server for an analog project if you wanted to for like doing server side rendering so it's a tool you can use with an sjs it doesn't uh replace it um it does have API routes uh so if you wanted something super simple super simple API then you could get those out of the box with analog but if you wanted something a lot more robust and a lot more full feature than sjs it's definitely a good choice there I'm using sjs on the project that I'm working on now and I like it some of the things that I could switch of course um all the decorators being one thing but uh whatever but overall I really like how it works and how it makes things easier there so uh so yes definitely want to give a quick shout out to the contributors to analog uh Robin have been talking to this person uh recently who had been who contributed some of the features for the content files that I just showed there and some other stuff too uh definitely got his first few open source contributions in analog which is pretty cool so uh if you definitely want to get involved definitely check out check out the project and um like I said I'll look at the open issues and see what we can Mark as good first issues but of course if you see typos or things in the docs or things that are unclear uh definitely check those out uh too let's see Antoine codes thanks for the follow I may have missed they may have came in and uh went uh popped through so thanks for thanks for that so yeah that is the the let's say I went like they went through state of Js we went through like the not the entire angular ecosystem but um a good bit of the the things going on there and uh but if you of course Chad if you see something uh then you'd like to chat or talk about in the future feel free to hit me up on Twitter or anywhere else for that matter to get that conversation going uh one more yes I almost forgot if I can remember the um YouTube here I am going to be on a live stream tomorrow [Music] on with uh Nick Taylor from netlify so there's a link to the Channel there I will go to it here also this is live stream uh so I'll be on the live stream tomorrow and we will talk about angular some things angular analog and open source also definitely check that out it'd be on Twitch tomorrow so you can follow his profile there and find me on those uh platforms um so yeah definitely check that out and it will uh hopefully I'll see you all around tomorrow it'll be out tomorrow at 12 P.M Central Time uh so definitely check that out too so yeah I think I think that's probably a good a good place to uh uh wrap up this one um yeah we'll be back next week same time same place I guess we'll go to the switch over to here yeah thanks for coming through everyone uh thanks to for the people who were chatting it up earlier definitely appreciated that and uh yeah we will be back same time well maybe do one of these as like a hacking session or something like that so um work on some stuff on stream and uh Hey addition addict I appreciate that uh thank you all for coming through and I will see you all in the next one | Brandon Roberts | UClb3aBqsBD_srhaSGTAEq-Q | 2023-01-20 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 11,485 | 57,409 |
BfY1RgB4gCE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BfY1RgB4gCE | THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF BENJAMIN FRANKLIN PART 7 by Benjamin Franklin 🎧 📖 FULL AUDIO BOOK | Meredith came accordingly in the evening when we talked my affair over he had conceived a great regard for me and was very unwilling that I should leave the house while he remained in it he didn't recant ooh think of he reminded me that Kaymer was in debt for all he possessed that his creditors began to be uneasy that he kept his shop miserably sold often without profit for ready money and often trusted without keeping accounts that he must therefore fall which would make a vacancy I might profit of I objected my want of money he then let me know that his father had a high opinion of me and from some discourse that had passed between them he was sure would advance money to set us up if I would enter into partnership with him my time says he will be out with Kaymer in the spring by that time we may have our press and types in from London I am sensible I am no workman if you like it your skill in the business shall be set against the stock I furnish and we will share the profits equally the proposal was agreeable and I consented his father was in town and approved of it the more as he saw I had great influence with his son had prevailed on him to abstain long from DRAM drinking and hope might break him of that wretched habit entirely I gave an inventory to the father who carried it to a merchant the things were sent for the secret was to be kept till they should arrive and in the meantime I was to get work if I could at the other printing house but I found no vacancy there and so remained idle a few days when Kaymer on a prospect of being employed to print some paper money in New Jersey which would require cuts and various types that I only could supply and apprehending Bradford might engage me and get the job from him sent me a very civil message that old friends should not part for a few words Meredith persuaded me to comply as it would give more opportunity for his improvement under my daily instructions so I returned and we went on more smoothly than some time before the New Jersey job was obtained I contrived a copper plate press for it the first that had been seen in the country I cut several ornaments and checks for the bills we went together to Burlington where I executed the whole to satisfaction and he received so large a sum for the work as to be enabled thereby to keep his head much longer above water at Burlington I made an acquaintance with many principal people of the province several of them had been appointed by the assembly a committee to attend the press and take care that no more bills were printed than the law directed they were therefore by turns constantly with us generally he who attended brought with him a friend or two for company my mind having been much more improved by reading than climbers I suppose it was for that reason my conversation seemed to be more valued they had me to their houses introduced me to their friends and showed me much civility while he though the master was a little neglected in truth he was an odd fish ignorant of common life fond of rudely opposing received opinions enthusiastic in some points of religion and a little Navy SH with all we continued there near three months and by that time I could reckon among my acquired friends judge Allen Samuel bestow the secretary of the province Isaac Pearson Joseph Cooper and several of the Smiths members of the assembly and Isaac de Cao the surveyor general the latter was a shrewd sagacious old man who told me that he began for himself when young by wheeling clay for the brick makers learned to write after he was of age carried the chains for surveyors who taught him surveying and he had now by his industry acquired a good estate and says he I foresee that you will soon work this man out of business and make a fortune in it at Philadelphia he had not then the least intimation of my intention to set up there or anywhere these friends were afterwards of great use to me as I occasionally was to some of them they all continued their regard for me as long as they lived before I entered upon my public appearance in business it may be well to let you know the then state of my mind with regard to my principles and morals that may see how far those influenced the future events of my life my parents had early given me religious impressions and brought me through my childhood piously in the dissenting way but I was scarce 15 when after doubting by turns of several points as I found them disputed in the different books I read I began to doubt of Revelation itself some books against deism fell into my hands they were said to be the substance of sermons preached at Boyles lectures it happened they wrought an effect on me quite contrary to what was intended by them for the arguments of the dias which were quoted to be refuted appeared to me much stronger than the refute ations in short I soon became a thorough deist my arguments perverted some others particularly Collins and Ralph but each of them having afterwards wronged me greatly with the least compunction and recollecting Keith's conduct toward me who was another free thinker and my own towards Vernon and miss Reed which at times gave me great trouble I began to suspect that this doctrine though it might be true was not very useful my London pamphlet which had for its motto these lines of Dryden whatever is is right though pure blind man sees but a part of the chain the nearest blink his eyes not carrying to the equal beam that poises all above and from the attributes of God His infinite wisdom goodness and power concluded that nothing could possibly be wrong in the world and that vice and virtue were empty distinctions no such things existing appeared now not so clever of performance as I once thought it and I doubted whether some error had not insinuated itself unperceived into my argument so as to infect all that followed as is common in metaphysical reasonings I grew convinced that truth sincerity and integrity in dealings between man and man were of the utmost importance to the Felicity of life and I formed written resolutions which still remain in my drone book to practice them ever while I lived revelation had indeed no weight with me as such but I entertained an opinion that though certain actions might not be bad because they were forbidden by it or good because it commanded them yet probably these actions might be forbidden because they were bad for us or commanded because they were beneficial to us in their own natures all the circumstances of things considered and this persuasion with the kind hand of Providence or some guardian angel or accidental favorable circumstances and situations or altogether preserved me through this dangerous time of youth and the hazardous situations I was sometimes in among strangers remote from the eye and advice of my father without any willful gross immorality or injustice that might have been expected from my want of religion I say willful because the instances I have mentioned had something of necessity in them from my youth in experience and the knavery of others I had therefore a tolerable character to begin the world with I valued it properly and determined to preserve it we had not long returned to Philadelphia before the new types arrived from London we settled with Kaymer and left him by his consent before he heard of it we found a house to hire near the market and took it to lessen the rent which was then but 24 pounds a year though I have since known it to be let for 70 we took to Thomas Godfrey a glazier as family who would pay a considerable part of it to us we had scarce opened our letters and put our press in order before George housed an acquaintance of mine brought a countryman to us whom he had met in the street inquiring for a printer all our cash was now expended in the variety of particulars we had been obliged to procure and this country man's five shillings being our first fruits and coming so seasonably gave me more pleasure than any crown I have since earned and the gratitude I felt toward house has made me more and ready than perhaps I should otherwise have been to assist young beginners there are Croaker's in every country always boating its ruin such a one then lived in Philadelphia a person of note an elderly man with a wise look a very grave manner of speaking his name was Samuel Mikkel this gentleman a stranger to me stopped one day at my door and asked me if I was the young man who had lately opened a new printing house being answered in the affirmative he said he was sorry for me because it was an expensive undertaking and the expense would be lost for Philadelphia was a sinking place the people already have bankrupt or near being so all appearances to the contrary such as new buildings and the rise of rents being to her certain knowledge fallacious for they were in fact among the things that would soon ruin us he gave me such a detail of misfortunes now existing that he left me half melancholy had i known him before i engaged in this business probably I never should have done it this man continued to live in this decaying place and Tuda claim the same strain refusing for many years to buy a house there because all was going to destruction and at last I had the pleasure of seeing him give five times as much for one as he might have bought it when he first began his croaking I should have mentioned before that in the autumn of the preceding year I had formed most of my ingenious acquaintances into a club of mutual improvement which we called the junto we met on Friday evenings the rules that I drew up required that every member in his turn should produce one or more queries on any point of morals politics or natural philosophy and once in three months produced and read an essay of his own writing on any subject he pleased our debates were to be under the direction of a president and to be conducted in the sincere spirit of inquiry after truth without fondness for dispute or desire of victory and to prevent warmth all expressions of positiveness in opinions or direct contradiction where after sometime made contraband and prohibited under small pecuniary penalties the first members were Joseph Brighton all a copier of Deeds for their scriveners a good-natured friendly middle-aged man a great lover of poetry reading all he could meet with and writing some that was tolerable very ingenious in many little knick-knack URIs and of sensible conversation Thomas Godfrey a self-taught mathematician great in his way and afterward inventor of what is now called Hadley squadron but he knew little out of his way and was not a policing companion as like most great mathematicians I have met he expected universal precision and everything said or was forever denying or distinguishing upon trifles to the disturbance of all conversation he soon left us Nicholas scull a surveyor afterwards surveyor general who loved books and sometimes made a few verses William Parsons bread a shoemaker but loving reading had acquired a considerable share of mathematics which he first studied with a view to astrology that he afterwards laughed at it he also became Surveyor General William Moggridge a joiner a most exquisite mechanic and a solid sensible man Hugh Meredith Stephen Potts and George Webb I've characterized before Robert grace a young gentleman of some fortune generous lively and witty a lover of punting and of his friends and William Coleman then a merchants Clerk about my age who had the coolest dearest head the best heart and the exact dysmorphia came afterwards a merchant of great note and one of our provincial judges our friendship continued without interruption to his death upward of 40 years and the club continued almost as long and was the best school of philosophy morality and politics that then existed in the province for our queries which were read the week preceding their discussion put us upon reading with attention upon the several subjects that we might speak more to the purpose and here too we acquired better habits of conversation everything being studied in our rules which might prevent our disgusting each other from hence the long continuance of the club which I shall have frequent occasion to speak further of hereafter but my giving this account of it here is to show something of the interest I had every one of these exerting themselves in recommending business to us brenton all particularly procured us from the Quakers the printing forty sheets of their history the rest being done by Kaymer and upon this we worked exceedingly hard for the price was low it was a folio pro patria size in pica with long primer notes I composed Evatt a sheet a day and meredith worked it off at press it was often 11:00 at night and sometimes later before I had finished my distribution for the next day's work for the little job sent in by our other friends now and then put us back but so determined I was to continue doing a sheet of day of the folio that one night when having imposed my forms I thought my days work over one of them by accident was broken and two pages reduced to pieces I immediately distributed and imposed it over again before I went to bed and this industry visible to our neighbors began to give us character and credit particularly I was told that mentioned being made of the new printing office at the merchants every night club the general opinion was that it must fail there being already two printers in the place Kaymer and bradford but dr. Baird whom you and I saw many years after at his native place st. Andrews in Scotland gave a contrary opinion for the industry of that Franklin says he is superior to anything I ever saw of the kind I see him still at work when I go home from club and he is at work again before his neighbors are out of bed this struck the rest and we soon after had offers from one of them to supply us with stationery but as yet we did not choose to engage in shop business I mentioned this industry the more particularly and the more freely though it seems to be talking in my own praise that those of my posterity who shall read it may know the use of that virtue when they see its effects in my favor throughout this relation George Webb who had found a female friend that lent him wherewith to purchase his time of Kaymer now came to offer himself as a journeyman to us we could not then employ him but I foolishly let him know as a secret that I soon intended to begin a newspaper and might then have worked for him my hopes of success as I told him were founded on this that the then only newspaper printed by Bradford was a paltry thing wretchedly managed no way entertaining and yet was profitable to him I therefore thought a good paper would scarcely fail of good encouragement I requested Webb not to mention it but he told it to Kaymer who immediately to be beforehand with me published proposals for printing one himself on which Webb was to be employed I resented this and to counteract them as I could not yet begin our paper I wrote several pieces of entertainment for Bradford's paper under the title of the busybody which Breton Oh continued some months by this means the attention of the public was fixed on that paper and comers proposals which we burlesque and ridiculed were disregarded he began his paper however and after carrying it on three-quarters of a year with at most only ninety subscribers he offered it to me for a trifle and I having been ready for some time to go on with it took it in hand directly and it proved in a few years extremely profitable to me I perceived that I am apt to speak in a singular number though our partnership still continued the reason may be that in fact the whole management of the business lay upon me Meredith was no compositor a poor Pressman and seldom sober my friends lamented my connection with him but I was to make the best of it our first papers made a quite different appearance from any before in the province a better type and better printed but some spirited remarks of my writing on the dispute then going on between governor Burnett and the Massachusetts assembly struck the principal people occasioned the paper and the manager of it to be much talked of and in a few weeks brought them all to be our subscribers their example was followed by many and our number went on growing continually this was one of the first good effects of my having learned a little to scribble another was that the leading men seeing a newspaper now and in the hands of one who could also handle a pen thought it convenient to oblige and encouraged me Bradford still printed the votes and laws and other public business he had printed an address of the house to the governor in a course blundering manner we reprinted it elegantly and correctly and sent one to every member they were sensible of the difference it strengthened the hands of our friends in the house and they voted us their printers for the year ensuing among my friends in the house I must not forget mr. Hamilton before mention who was then returned from England and had a seat in it he interested himself for me strongly in that instance as he did in many others afterward continuing his patronage till his death mr. Vernon about this time put me in mind of the debt I owed him but did not press me I wrote him an ingenious letter of acknowledgement craved his forbearance a little longer which he allowed me and as soon as I was able I paid the principal with interest and many thanks so that erratum was in some degree corrected but now another difficulty came upon me which I had never the least reason to expect mr. Meredith's father who was to have paid for our printing house according to the expectations given was able to advance only 100 pounds currency which had been paid and a hundred more was due to the merchants who grew impatient and sued us all we gave bail but saw that if the money could not be raised in time the soup must soon come to judgment and execution and our hopeful prospects must with us be ruined as the press and the letters must be sold for payment perhaps at half price in this distress two friends whose kindness I have never forgotten nor ever shall forget while I can remember anything came to me separately unknown to each other and without any application from me offering each of them to advance me all the money that should be necessary to enable me to take the whole business upon myself if that should be practicable but they did not like my continuing the partnership with Meredith who as they said was often seen drunk in the streets and playing at low games and ale houses much to our discredit these two friends were William Coleman and Robert grace I told them I could not propose a separation while any prospect remained of the merit of this fulfilling their part of our agreement because I thought myself under great obligation to them for what they had done and would do if they could but if they finally failed in their performance and our partnership must be dissolved I should then think myself at liberty to accept the assistance of my friends thus the matter rested for some time when I said to my partner perhaps your father is dissatisfied at the part you have undertaken in this affair of ours and is unwilling to advance for you and me what he would for you alone if that is the case tell me and I will resign the whole to you and go about my business no said he my father has really been disappointed and is really unable and I am unwilling to distress him farther I see this as a business I am not fit for I was bred a farmer and it was a folly for me to come to town and put myself at thirty years of age an apprentice to learn a new trade many of our Welsh people are going to settle in North Carolina where land is cheap I am inclined to go with them and follow my old employment you may find friends to assist you if you will take the debts of the company upon you return to my father the hundred pound he has advanced pay my little personal debts and give me 30 pounds in a new saddle I will relinquish the partnership and leave the whole in your hands I agreed to this proposal it was drawn up in writing signed and sealed immediately I gave him what he demanded and he went soon after to Carolina from whence he sent me next year two long letters containing the best account that had been given of that country the climate the soil husbandry etc for in those matters he was very judicious I printed them in the papers and they gave great satisfaction to the public as soon as he was gone I recurred to my two friends and because I would not give an unkind preference to either I took half of what each had offered and I wanted of one and a half to the other paid off the company's debt and went on with the business in my own name advertising that the partnership was dissolved I think this was in or about the year 1729 about this time there was a cry among the people for more paper money only fifteen thousand pounds being extent on the province and that soon to be sunk the wealthy inhabitants opposed any addition being against all paper currency from an apprehension that it would be depreciate as it had done in New England to the prejudice of all creditors we had discussed this point in our junto where I was on the side of an addition being persuaded that the first small sum struck in 1723 had done much good by increasing the trade employment and number of inhabitants in the province since now I saw all the old house inhabited and many new ones building whereas I remembered well that when I first walked about the streets of Philadelphia eating my roll I saw most of the houses in Walnut Street between second and Front streets with bills on their doors to be led and many likewise in Chestnut Street and other streets which made me then think the inhabitants of the city were deserting at one after another our debates possessed me so fully of the subject that I wrote and printed an anonymous pamphlet on it entitled the nature and necessity of a paper currency it was well received by the common people in general but the rich men disliked it for it increased and strengthened the clamor for more money and they happening to have no writers among them that were able to answer it their opposition slackened and the point was carried by a majority in the house my friends there who conceived I had been of some service thought fit to reward me by employing me in printing the money a very profitable job and a great help to me this was another advantage gained by my being able to write the utility of this currency became by time and experience so evident as never afterward to be much disputed so that it grew soon to fifty five thousand pounds and in 1739 to 80 thousand pounds since which it arose during war to upwards of three hundred and fifty thousand pounds trade building and inhabitants all the while increasing till now I think there are limits beyond which the quantity may be hurtful I soon after obtained through my friend Hamilton the printing of the Newcastle paper money another profitable job as I then thought it small things appearing great to those in small circumstances and these to me were really great advantages as they were great encouragement he procured for me also the printing of the laws and votes of that government which continued in my hands as long as I followed the business I now opened a little stationers shop I had in it blanks of all sorts the correctness that ever appeared among us being assisted in that by my friend Brighton all I had also paper parchment Chapman's books etc one white mash a compositor I had known in London an excellent workman now came to me and worked with me constantly and diligently and I took an apprentice the son of a key rose I began now gradually to pay off the debt I was under for the printing house in order to secure my credit and character as a tradesmen I took care not only to be in reality industrious and frugal but to avoid all appearances to the contrary I dressed plainly I was seen at know places of idle diversion I never went out of fishing or shooting a book indeed sometimes to botch me from my work but that was seldom snug and gave no scandal and to show that I was not above my business I sometimes brought home the paper I purchased at the stores through the streets on a wheelbarrow thus being esteemed an industrious thriving young man and paying dually for what I bought the merchants who imported stationery solicited my custom others proposed supplying me with books and I went on swimmingly in the meantime timers credit and business declining daily he was at last forced to sell his printing house to satisfy his creditors he went to Barbados and there lived some years in very poor circumstances his apprentice David Harry whom I had instructed while I worked with him set up in his place at Philadelphia having bought his materials I was at first apprehensive of a powerful rival in Harry as his friends were very able and had a good deal of interest I therefore proposed a partnership to him which he fortunately for me rejected with scorn he was very proud dressed like a gentleman lived expensively took much diversion and pleasure abroad ran in debt and neglected his business upon which all business left him and finding nothing to do he followed timer to Barbados taking the printing house with him there this apprentice employed his former master as a journeyman they quarreled often Harry went continually behindhand and at length was forced to sell his types and returned to his country work in Pennsylvania the person that bought them employed Kaymer to use them but in a few years he died there remained now no competi with me at Philadelphia but the old one Bradford who was rich and easy did a little printing now and then by straggling hands but was not very anxious about the business however as he kept the post office it was imagined he had better opportunities of obtaining news his paper was thought a better distributor of advertisements than mine and therefore had many more which was a profitable thing to him and a disadvantage to me for though I did indeed receive and send papers by the post yet the public opinion was otherwise for what I did send was by bribing the writers who took them privately Bradford being unkind enough to forbid it which occasioned some resentment on my part and I thought so meanly of him for that that when I afterward came into his situation I took care never to imitate it I had hitherto continued to board with Godfrey who lived in part of my house with his wife and children and had one side of the shop for his Glaser's business though he worked little being always absorbed in his mathematics mrs. Godfrey projected a match for me with a relations daughter took opportunities of bringing us often together till a serious courtship on my part and sued the girl being in herself very deserving the old folks encouraged me by continual invitation to supper and by leaving us together till at length it was time to explain mrs. Godfrey managed our little treaty I let her know that I expected as much money with their daughter as would pay off my remaining debt for the printing house which I believe was not then above a hundred pounds she brought me word they had no such sum to spare I said they might mortgage their house the answer to this after some days was that they did not approve the match that on inquiry of Bradford they had been informed the printing business was not a profitable one the types would soon be worn out and more wanted that s Kaymer and d harry had failed one after the other and I should probably soon follow them and therefore I was forbidden the house and the daughter shut up whether this was a real change of sentiment or only artifice on a supposition of our being too far engaged in affection to retract and therefore that we should steal a marriage which would leave them at liberty to give or withhold what they pleased I know not but I suspected the latter | Wide Records Equilibrio | UCepxKP5dMRYTiSmifV-9R-g | 2020-06-17 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 5,166 | 28,050 |
xN59XBv_A6s | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xN59XBv_A6s | Is it Important to add Uncomfortable Truths about Our Colonial History into Alberta’s K-4 Curriculum | good morning everyone and uh thank you for joining us for another live stackpile live stream during this time of social and physical distancing sakta believes it's important to keep engaging with the public on issues of the day and in order to do so we are very thankful for the continuing support received from the university of leffert shaw spotlight and the lethbridge herald our speaker today is dr henrahan on the topic of is it important to add uncomfortable truths about canada's colonial history into alberta's k24 curriculum dr hamrahan is currently board of governors research chair tier 2 coordinator of the canadian studies program and associate professor in the department of geography and environment at the university of lethbridge she's also an adjunct professor with the environmental policy institute at memorial university she has a phd from the london school of economics and political science and our work is interdisciplinary drawing from geography and other social science disciplines thank you very much for joining us today um and we very much look forward to your talk thank you for the invitation and i'm delighted to be here i'd like to say that sakpa does great work it's very important work especially now when evidence-based policy is backgrounded and sometimes even derided it's certainly undervalued i'd like to review a few things before i engage with the topic residential schools in our school curriculum i need to point out that i'm not an expert on residential schooling in canada or elsewhere you know that academics tend to be specialized and this is not one of my areas of specialization i did one study that involved residential schooling and i'll return to that later that was about 15 years ago so uh the invitation to speak here came out of the letter in the newspaper that my students and i had written students in my indigenous health course their third year students who were very interested in residential schools they were given for their research assignment they were asked to choose any topic that related to indigenous health and over half of them so over 20 of them chose residential schools and we wrote the letter to the paper subsequent to that the lethbridge herald i should point out also that i'm not an expert on the education of children either i'm speaking here as a parent as a citizen and as a scholar who's work who's talk whose work has touched on this subject the effects of it every day in our society i'm aware of 3d7 and metis region 3 but i'm ambivalent about land acknowledgements i'd like to see them tied to action somehow so i'm not doing formal acknowledgements acknowledgements until i give this practice some more thought to tell you a little bit about myself grew up in newfoundland and labrador i'm trini migma my community band is splatig migma first nation and our indian act band is halibu migma first nation i'm also the daughter of an immigrant from ireland right on the irish border another site of ongoing colonialism so i'm both and indigenous and settler because of my appearance i live a life of white privilege interestingly my appearance also puts me in the position of hearing um questionable remarks that speakers assume i'll agree with so i've been asked to address the question of whether or not this topic residential schools should be something that our children learn about in k24 and my answer is yes but first i want to talk a little bit about residential schools themselves and the history of the institutionalization of undesirable people people who are not wanted by the colonial state and the and the neo-liberal state which privileges capitalism and is built on white supremacy the neoliberal state and its partner capitalism are both exclusive not everyone is included or needed margaret thatcher would have been one of the first to realize this polit as a political strategy the presence of some gets in the way of neo-liberal and capital goals capitalist goals so canada is naturally white the settler state of canada is naturally white and indigenous people have always posed an existential threat to this state indigenous people had land land that was coveted for settlement and the generation of profit indigenous people moved with the seasons capitalism is based on land tenure permanent year-round settlement and continuous predictable use indigenous people hold property in common capitalism is based on private property indigenous people value maintenance stability balance capitalism is based on continuous growth thus indigenous people pose an existential threat to the state the indian act aimed to contain indigenous people to shrink their land bases to end their land use practices and movements and to erase indigenous values this was deliberate all paul it undergirded all policy it was aimed at removing indigenous power and shifting power to the settler state all of this was aimed at the simulation erasure of indigenous values and the cultures built on these values so that they and and so sorry so that any and all initiatives of the settler state would be unfettered the script system to which metis were subject the resettlement of the inuit all these actions had the same goal residential schooling taking the indian out of the child was key to these goals and i should say that first nations metis and inuit were all targeted for residential schooling slide please so this is a map of showing that there were 130 residential schools in canada over a 165-year period so that's almost two centuries an estimated 150 000 children attended these schools and that's the population the size of lethbridge half again the first one opened in ontario in 1831 and the last one closed in saskatchewan in 1996. here in alberta there were no less than 25 residential schools including two nearby at cardston where children from the blood reserve the ghana nation went these were government-sponsored schools run by churches saint mary's was catholic while saint paul's was anglican i should also mention that the map is inaccurate in that it doesn't include newfoundland and labrador which i'll come back to there's a reason that former students refer to themselves as survivors teachers and staff inflicted abuse including physical abuse and repeated sexual assault at the schools this was not uncommon many school authorities deprived children of food sometimes leading to malnutrition children suffered preventable diseases like tuberculosis and influenza we don't know the exact number but it's estimated that approximately 6 000 children died at residential schools many buried in unmarked mass graves children received little education little classroom time and they learned only the basics the three hours if you like in english they were generally not allowed to speak their own language remember the purpose was assimilation not education children spent about half their day working and this was gender stratified so girls cooked cleaned sold and did laundry while boys did carpentry construction and farming children had other chores as well and those who survived did not have the skills for further education or to for decent jobs a settlement agreement with the federal government was signed in 2007 and the next year prime minister stephen harper offered a formal public apology to some but not all survivors the indigenous people of newfoundland and labrador were excluded from both the settlement and the apology because the reasoning went newfoundland and labrador did not join confederation until 1949. meanwhile many former students as the federal government calls them live with what has been described as residential school syndrome residential school syndrome is characterized by acute self-conflict and low self-esteem by emotional numbing which interferes with the ability to trust other people and to form lasting bonds also chronic depression and anxiety post traumatic stress disorder or many features of post-traumatic stress disorder such as insomnia flashbacks nightmares disassociation with residential school system there are also strong tendencies towards the use of alcohol drugs and suicidality the residential school system was a tool that we can situate in the history of the institutionalization of undesirable people and especially in british colonial history the old poor law of england and wales allowed for the grievous whipping and branding of rogues and vagabonds people who moved who wandered this was in 1572 similar legislation was later introduced in ireland one of britain's first colonies the theft of irish land by british aristocrats and the british state evicted millions of irish from their small firm holdings leading to widespread hunger long before the great famine of the mid 19th century slide 3 please in 1838 workhouses were introduced and became what has been called the characteristic stamp of british rule in ireland hated by the whole nation inmates as they were called were given two meals a day milk and potatoes occasionally they were giving herring this might be starting to ring bells now families were segregated by gender including young children who were separated from their mothers parents spent their days working with work being uh gender stratified men broke stones or worked in the fields while women did housework laundry and sewing workhouse incarceration peaked in 1850 with 200 000 inmates when war broke out in 1914 there were still 35 000 people in irish workhouses these institutions were a pipeline to jail and often to lives of addiction and poverty all caused by trauma next slide please work houses were technically abolished in 1922 with irish independence but really the new irish state turned them into what they called county homes and industrial boarding schools for poor and so-called troubled youth mostly boys dominated by the catholic church for the next 50 years the irish state-funded church-run industrial schools now considered sites of industrial child abuse next slide please i mentioned boys girls with troubled backgrounds were identified some were unmarried and pregnant their children would often be sold to the to the united states one in one record there was a teenage girl who refused to obey an order another incarcerated girl was um too pretty to be free these girls and women were sent to magdalen laundries where they were called penitents and had their name changed or were given a number which they were referred all the time the women worked as slaves entirely unpaid while the host convents made profits off their work some women were there for life the last magdalen laundry closed in 1996 which you might recall is the same year the last residential school closed in saskatchewan in canada many of these women were buried in mass graves their great their deaths not recorded in 2011 the united nations committee against torture criticized the irish government for not acknowledging the pain and abuse suffered by these women more recently there has been a redress scheme though it is limited so ireland internalized the colonialism imposed upon it in a cultural sense it's recent it's only recently emerging from this colonialism ireland locked up more of its citizens per capita than anywhere in the world including the united states not in prisons but in psychiatric hospitals magdalen laundries and industrial schools i don't know but i suspect that the indigenous irish travelers or minsir were over represented in all in all these institutions they moved the minster the travelers caravans they did not own land they were and they were targeted by legislation that restricted their wandering and their issuing of settlement culture i tell this irish story because it runs parallel in many ways to colonialism and the residential school system in canada i suspect that more trade more traditional indigenous people in canada like the irish travelers were more vulnerable to being taken or kidnapped really for residential schooling i have a friend who was age six trapping with his parents in remote northern quebec when the rcmp arrived in floatplanes to take him and his siblings away they had no notice of this i believe this family's entrenched indigenous values and practices made them targets british colonialism tried to destroy irish culture to acquire to acquire profitable land sometimes it's easier to see how colonialism worked and works if we look at it from a distance close to home so many of us have benefited from colonialism does it seem more natural to talk about colonialism in ireland and other places i follow this story in ireland today mainly via radio and there's no sense that irish children should be protected from it many of them are the grandchildren and great-grandchild or great-grandchildren of women and men imprisoned in workhouses laundries and industrial schools in ireland you have multiple multi-generational trauma with the loss of family life the experience of being parented the sense of abandonment children felt and grew up with and of course the abuse slide six please this brings us back to residential schools in canada and a proposal being considered by the provincial government to exclude residential schooling from the k-4 curriculum in tuesday in 2014 alberta affirmed its commitment to indigenous perspectives and experiences in k-12 schools at a truth and reconciliation commission event in edmonton alberta's promise included mandatory content for all alberta students on residential schools on treaties on first nations metis and inuit experiences and perspectives cultures and contributions to historical and contemporary in content in historical and contemporary contexts now this promise has not been taken seriously residential schooling we're told is too sad to teach young children when the topic is introduced residential schooling will be framed as harsh schooling it's it's okay to see it as harsh schooling but it is not just or even honest to leave it at that why was this approach taken why did residential schools exist why was schooling harsh who experienced harsh schooling whose interests did it serve who established it who maintained it how was it enforced what effects did it have what effects does it have i've already stated my position that residential schooling was a tool aimed at erasing indigenous values and identity because these pose an existential threat to canada as a neo-liberal settler state this is the same reason why so many first nations reserves lack potable water by the way but these things will not be taught in alberta schools the minister of education wants to take politics out of curriculum in her words now this is just silly because everything is political the objective understanding quote unquote that lagrange aims for is impossible objective understanding really means a default to the status quo to the invisibility of indigenous and colonial history to white privilege and to history being written by the winners initially all eight subject matter experts commissioned by minister lagrange were men this is the ucp way of doing business this is normal for them their goal is the maintenance of male privilege and the dominance of male perspectives especially white male perspectives one of their experts chris champion calls the inclusion of first nations perspectives in school lessons are fad minister lagrange's spokespeople say this is only advice but it is solicited advice and it would overturn good curriculum work that included indigenous perspectives and took an approach that was not based solely on content and techniques like memorization as the current proposals are i've had several university students come to me in the past few years just after they've learned about residential schools for the first time and they're angry a young woman from calgary approached me on social media upset that she had not known about residential schooling these young people all of whom have settler backgrounds feel robbed imagine if irish students weren't told about their own national experience of colonialism and about the residential institutions that propped it up imagine if students in the united states weren't taught about slavery which also existed in this country or if german students weren't taught about the holocaust and the devouring of the roma slide seven please our young people have a right to know their history especially since its effects are ongoing we see this in poor population health among indigenous people inuit suicide rates are eight times the national average to we still have tuberculosis among poorly housed inuit there are assaults on migma fishermen there are dozens of opioid related deaths every year among the blackfoot people our neighbors colonialism is enacted on indigenous bodies as scholar mary ellen kelm reminds us i could speak about resilience but i have a question about resilience and it's what it is it is this i see a lot of resilience but why is resilience necessary why is so much resilience demanded next slide please what will children miss if residential schooling and indigenous perspectives are not in the curriculum besides the history of outlined already they wouldn't know about resistance there's the metis resistance of course but in spite of numerous obstacles indigenous people resisted residential schooling even developing systems to do so so i did a study in nova scotia uh that involved several communities one of which was two mile and in that community someone was always on the lookout for the indian agent or the rcmp and whose goal was to kidnap children for residential schools and when any of these people were cited parents hid their children in the woods they gave them blankets and lunches that were always at the ready and the children stayed there for a couple of nights this strategy was successful and saved many children from the trauma of residential schooling next slide please without indigenous history in schools children wouldn't know that alberta is the only province in canada we have a constitutionally protected land base the eight settlements peavine elizabeth lake and so on they won't know that the treaties are actually the basis of canadian law and that we are all treaty people and this means something without indigenous perspectives in school children won't learn that there are different ways of knowing now this is a gross generalization but while western science focuses a great deal on naming and categorizing indigenous science focuses more on relationships between bees so in migma culture an object is alive if it's touched or if it's being moved by something else so a rock can be a living object and these are just little hints of complex knowledge systems next slide please the last thing i want to address is the sadness issue the minister wants to protect children from sadness children need to learn to identify and process emotions and sadness is part of life so is empathy which i imagine we want to cultivate in our children teaching children about the showa for instance can be done in age appropriate ways children in grade four in alberta aren't shown pictures of skeletal corpses at elsevich but at least some of them read hannah's suitcase in grade four this is the sad story of hannah brady a czech jewish girl who died in the camps at only 13. next slide parents and educators have always known how important it is to instill compassion in children younger children are primed for this when they are read a christmas carol which has the imposition of human suffering and the abuse of power as its primary themes another dickens classic oliver twist prepares children to learn about injustice directed at children oliver is born in a workhouse and he's later sold to an apprenticeship next slide please the dear canada novels aimed at girls teach canadian history and delve into topics like slavery a desperate road to freedom the underground railroad diary of julia mae jackson and residential schooling these are my words the residential school diary of violet pusheens by ruby slipperjack an anishinabe survivor herself many many alberta school libraries have these popular books so we do teach children about sad things we teach our children about unnecessary suffering structural injustice human cruelty accordingly we have to ask why the ucp government doesn't want our children exposed to sad things imposed on and experienced by indigenous people i'm reminded of judith butler's contention that some lives matters more some lives matter more than others apparently the suffering of some does not count as far as the ucp is concerned next slide please some go even further than the ucp recently middle school children in british columbia were given an assignment to identify five positive things about residential schools this is the first nation parent christa mcinnis who brought this issue to national attention i'm sure that good things did happen in residential schools occasionally because good things happen everywhere even in elsevidge but curriculum like this is a denial of long-term structural injustice and used to have lasting negative impacts on real living people i'll end with advice from rebecca sokbasan who teaches educational policy studies at the university of alberta rebecca says the earlier that we can introduce children to the truth about canada's history the sooner we can account for what has happened and ensure it doesn't ever happen again thank you william you very much um i don't see any questions currently in the queue i think um so um could you explain a little bit about the process currently in the curriculum i know that alberta is reviewing the curriculum but are they currently including this in the curriculum i couldn't find the um grade four curriculum online that might be me but i couldn't find it i do know when my daughter was in grade four they uh she was in a catholic school at that time and they did uh hannah's suitcase was on the curriculum uh the story of the czech girl who died in elsevitch all the classes did that not just her class and they did assignments on it and hannah's suitcase is in a museum in japan they wrote to the museum in japan as an exercise so uh i know that there's certainly uh education about suffering is uh is in there in grade four they learned very little about residential schools in passing um so there it didn't seem to be much of a theme and i can't recall what the materials were so i'm not sure what happens now i know that the albert the government of alberta had an extensive exercise that went on for some time and involved uh curriculum experts content experts and thousands and thousands of albertans um contributed to it and so the 2014 promise um was uh is another factor that went into the development of that curriculum and that very much includes indigenous perspectives and history but this curriculum is something that the ucp government is not interested in okay we have um some questions coming in now um laura our first question is from laurie schultz well let's first of all say jim miller uh applause beth mendel what a powerful talk thank you so our first actual question comes from laura schultz in the context of ireland and germany can you comment on if there was pushback against including their history i don't know about germany i spent a little bit of time in germany not a lot i went to uh grad school with german friends so my knowledge of germany is kind of casual but i know my german friends told me they definitely learned about the holocaust in germany and i remember walking down the street in frankfurt and seeing um stones in the street that um discussed how jewish people were taken from this site and so on so very public um in a push back in ireland uh so mainly i listened to radio telephos aaron uh the radio programs from the state broadcaster uh i so i've heard a lot of talk shows about this and interviews with survivors there and you you get a lot of sympathetic calls uh and this is just anecdotal now hey so um but uh there would be so i don't see pushback from the population i'd see pushback from the irish state in terms of how much compensation should be given to these women uh the magdalene laundry women for instance how many hoops they should have to go through the industrial school survivors who are male don't seem to have as strong of an advocacy scheme or lobby or campaign and many of them ended up in britain there are support agencies for them in britain um rte and the bbc have documented how a lot of these men ended up single uh precariously house uh and on the streets of england actually so there are agencies set up in birmingham and other cities specifically to help irish survivors of um industrial schools i don't know if the links are made to colonialism or not but um yeah those are just some some initial thoughts i have in response to your question lori our next question comes from mark goodall are you aware of any studies comparing the adulthood of those children who went to residential school versus those that escaped by being hidden in the woods i'm not uh but this is not really my area it's uh i did one study on it um uh and it wasn't comparative it was uh for a land claim and litigation for acadia first nation in nova scotia and many of their uh they were elders then when i interviewed them many of them were able to escape because of that system they set up but in terms of comparative studies i i don't know i'm not aware uh you could try google scholar and see if there's um something there but i mean we we certainly do know there's a link there is residential school syndrome and there's a link between the schools and trauma that lasts through life our next question comes from jim miller is our current curriculum telling other sad stories about history in alberta of which there are many why do you think government is focusing on indigenous history in residential schools i again like i don't know everything that's in the curriculum i would hope the story of japanese internment is in there as well uh that's certainly a story that we need to know about and it's very close to home here you can go to a sugar beet factory that's even within the city limits um the focus on indigenous people i think like i said earlier like the i think the the values the indigenous way of know of doing things is is completely different um now people tend to be bicultural these days but uh you know land and property is held commonly that is a direct conflict to the private property system that's privileged in canadian law canadian criminal law and certainly in the ideology of the ucp um so i think if you follow the money it ends up being about land and profit i mean it's inconvenient uh for the ucp and their oil and gas allies if indigenous people are in opposition to pipelines for instance uh because indigenous people are not merely part of the multicultural mosaic of canada but have constitutional rights and have the right the legal right to be consulted on proposed developments and so on so it serves the ucp and their right-wing allies i think if um indigenous voices are are quelled and not heard and invisible and i think it's in the interests of the ucp not to educate its base to keep the status quo as it is thank you um our next question comes from timothy from the left bridge herald um how do you characterize the ucp's relationship with first nations they offer a billion dollars for economic development but at the same time don't want children to learn about residential schools yeah so i guess that's ironic and i guess i would just have some questions what do you mean by economic development is this economic development that's going to be guided by indigenous values is this economic development that will serve indigenous communities that will contribute to indigenous self-governance and self-determination or is it an attempt to um privatize indigenous lands like they're trying to privatize our beautiful parks that we love so much um is it does it serve indigenous people was it developed uh the fund and the use of the fund the policies regulations were they developed um with a representative uh very a wide representation of indigenous people or is this yet this kind of policy framework uh dressed up as an opportunity you can probably tell that i'm cynical but i think the best predictor of um future behavior is past behavior and what we're seeing is uh cuts to uh what we've seen is cuts to children with disabilities uh severe cuts to our post-secondary institutions over 300 layoffs at the university of lethbridge forced upon us um so damage to our economy the removal of emergency services a lot huge loss of jobs and privatization in alberta hospitals so it's hard to think it's hard to be i'm not initially convinced shall we say that anything like such a fund would be in the interests of indigenous people given the uh record of the the kennedy government and their cuts our next question comes from ted mitsui um he agrees with pat with beth mendel's comment about the very powerful talk thank you churches operated those schools and some apologized what does an apology mean um it means different things to different people i know that the harper apology meant a lot to a lot of people and it was greeted with joy um in indigenous nations i think that an apology uh if it's genuine it recognizes that that i have hurt you that i have made you suffer i acknowledge that so and i think that recognition and acknowledgement is really important so i said that my own home province i was excluded from the apology and i know for inuit in labrador in particular that hurt a lot and they wanted an apology a federal apology so happily a couple of years ago prime minister trudeau did go to labrador and make a special apology to the labrador inuit and there were i wasn't there but i watched it and there were elders in the audience and older people who had not so and not so old who had gone through the schools who tears were streaming down their faces so the recognition and the acknowledgement uh of an injustice it it goes a long way toward repair and towards better relationships i think our next question comes from laurie schultz recently the minister of education called for a one-week turnaround for nominations of teachers to review the curriculum can you comment on this process and order status of the review one week for could you i don't understand the process sorry um i'll reread the question recently the minister of education called for a one-week turnaround for nominations of teachers to review the curriculum can you comment on the process and or the status and or the status of this review um i don't know about the review lori but one week sounds a bit rushed to me and i would wonder what the rush is i know an indigenous culture uh there's uh very much uh a tendency not to hurry to take our time to do things with a lot of thought so uh i i myself um i get concerned about things that are rushed our next question comes from terry shirlington how would you challenge the notion that in grade 5 and up kids are old enough to grasp these in in quotation sadness themes but k4 are too young well i guess we're back to age-appropriate teaching right so with hannah's suitcase is a very sad story but it's an entryway it's a book written for children by karen levine and it's based on a true story so they see the photographs of hannah in the book and um but it's a i won't say a gentle introduction but it's uh i don't know maybe a gentle introduction into the holocaust uh which the further you get into it you understand how absolutely horrific it was right but uh so hannah's suitcase they learn about one girl and they learn also that her suitcase is in a museum and she's honored and remembered her brother survived and he still he he was alive a few years ago anyway and uh so he's taking care of her legacy so there's a bit of a comfort in that story um so also the deer the deer canada stories as well if you read those you see the the the characters um resilience there's it's not 100 percent the the stories aren't 100 negative there's it's up and down for kids to keep i suppose to keep their attention i don't know really but if you think about fairy tales hansel and gretel and and uh i mean we're preparing children for uh you know the fact that the world is complex and there's a lot of sadness and there's a lot of cruelty and so on but you're not throwing everything at once so something like oliver the movie is kind of a primer i would say for uh for children to learn later on maybe or to i don't know at what age but that you know oliver wasn't just one character this whole he was part of this whole system of the incarceration of poor the poor and and undesirables and so on so i suppose it needs to happen in levels and i think that's how most of us would parent our children tell them bit by bit what's appropriate our next question comes from jim miller the parallel between residential schools in canada and iron ireland history is fascinating is that parallel because british and because of british empire influencing both ireland and canada yes as far as i can tell the workhouses and the institutionalization of people uh in massive structures was a british invention uh i might be wrong but i'm not aware of other cultures and that i know others other european cultures have orphanages and that this practice has been spread through the uh south as well but the the in as far as i can tell and i'm not a historian in this area either but the idea of warehousing people um in institutions like that uh sometimes for life it seems to have been a british institution and it was used uh with their own people in britain with uh pete with uh the roman initial the uh the indigenous uh traveler people of britain it was used with poor people surplus people uh people who are different who are poor uh who were had mental illnesses and so on and um then it was used in ireland as a result of a royal commission uh the workhouse system was brought uh to ireland in i think in the early 1800s 1838 might have been the first one around the same time that the first residential school opened in canada uh for mohawk people in southern ontario and of course australia too right yeah so you can see this kind of tool or device of institutionalizing people as a kind of a prong or tool in the colonial toolbox if you like um our next question comes from ian hurdle my early years were near a reserve reserve and i probably bicycled within three kilometers of a residential school that i did not know existed until age 20. i was up to date on freedomite residential schools any comment and you were up to date on what residential schools freedom might what i don't know what they are how does how's that spell f e f r e e o freedomite yeah i don't know what they are but i have um i mentioned in the talk that a young woman i guess she looked me up i don't know in calgary approached me on social media and she was just so upset she had been hiking and come across an abandoned residential school and she wanted to know what it was and there was a little plaque there and and said uh you know it had been a residential school and then she said she looked this up on wikipedia she's in her about 25 years old and she was really shocked and then she contacted me for some reason to get more information about it she was very very angry we had a lengthy exchange that she'd grown up in calgary and not known about this so it is curious that i i'd like to know how that happens that you live next to a reserve and i'm not blaming you how does it happen that you the school is there and you don't it's not talked about it's i'm really curious about that myself and i'm not blaming you this is ver a very very common phenomena across the country and i don't know that the magdalene laundries were right in the middle of uh the cities in ireland um it's it's uh amazing that that we somehow we all have this ability to to not see things that we should see i suppose um ian hertl just uh updated to say it's the duke aboard protests in the 60s oh okay okay so the the duke war children were taken from their parents weren't they yeah and the duke of war people um so i mean i said i'm i don't know much about them but they're rush formerly russian right and they're they they had a way of life that was very very different from kind of the white canadian settler society that was being imposed i don't know if did the duke boris hold property in common i know there were ways that they were different so we were really afraid of difference and look what happened to the japanese people and british columbia shipped here to alberta during the war uh and it seems like you know that the neoliberal state has ways of um and the colonial state has ways of trying to make these differences invisible and trying to the same way and it sounds like i must look look up the freedomized schools it sounds like the duke of boers were victims of that as well i know their children were taken from were taken from them which was extremely traumatic when you traumatize the population how does the population recover from that okay our next question comes from um beth mundo what do you think what do you think it is in the british system that promoted the neoliberal model of injustice was it related to their sea dominance well then that colonialism would not have happened without the british navy and without british maritime skill so that's for sure um i don't know i i mean the market has off has all often sorry i mean the notion of private property we read john locke hundreds of years ago and it's there it's been privileged for centuries in british law and in british society and in british ideology uh and it seems to be i lived in britain for three years very much taken for granted private property uh and um the notion that a cat a british an englishman's home is his castle i mean it sounds like a cliche but it's true i mean for if you cross the farmer's field in england they would more than likely get extremely upset about it um and there are um special paths set aside that people have to agree like the local authority and the the farmer agree that ramblers walkers can walk in their property so the the notion of private property is very very entrenched there uh as is capitalism in the market and capitalism has an ever expanding it has a need to continuously expand so that's something that the empire serves but there's there's certainly an imperialist thrust that comes from britain um and and has you know uh much of the world was pink on those old maps right part of the british uh british empire um so i lost my train of thought there but i was just thinking about i think you were saying something about um oh the navy and so on right and the new yeah neoliberal model of injustice and whatever right yeah so and when the industry particularly when the industrialization comes the uh and it's it's first in britain uh the factories need cotton and they need wool and they need raw materials and these come from the the outer reaches of the empire to make money in britain but of course the wealth of cruise upward and the working classes uh rural people are displaced you had the um the enclosure of the commons hundreds of years ago in britain the loss of rural common areas and the industrialization uh in the in 1900s also displaces rural people so these are excess people these are surplus people they're not necessary for the generation of profit and one of britain's answers to them is to institutionalize them okay our next question comes from peterson religious ideology and probably racism is arguably at the root of the current alberta government overhaul of school curriculum what can we do to at least modify this problem this is really tough because i've been in alberta for years i don't understand why anyone votes ucpp i just don't understand it um this is a government that is not taking care of us as uh you know our people are dying from from covet this is a government led by a man who had a snitch line when he was minister of immigrant federal minister of immigration uh calling in rat on refugees i mean this is this these are not albertans i had you know seem to me to be nice people in general but yet the you know these are nice people tyler chandra is is not a nice guy picking fights with doctors and and causing this level of stress that we're going to lose our doctors so i mean they're not behaving well and and you could see it coming so i don't know i don't understand how why why people would vote for them um and i said i know that propaganda plays a large part in it if you look at what they said about the carbon tax i mean it was there were basically lies about the carbon tax alberta gained from the carbon tax and individual households gained from the rebates um but that's gone and now that money goes to ottawa actually as that's money that's not coming into alberta yet you know that was one of the propaganda tools that was used to you know vote in kenny so i suppose propaganda is a big part of it what can we do well this is important these kinds of forums um a lot of us at the university are writing to our mlas we're writing to the ministers i've written to my mp rachel harder a few times i am not sure how fruitful that is some of us have signs on our lawns about defending alberta parks uh we need to organize i think we need more more demonstrations although that's impossible now um i don't know the usual things the written word is is the first thing that that dictators go after and i'm not saying that kenny is a dictator but it just shows you how important the written word is so i mean my it's always my weapon to write and i just think we should keep doing it our next question comes from laurie schultz aside from an inclusive curriculum are you able to share any insights by your students well i mean ours yeah i think this generation of students is fantastic i think you know today the values that i see in the young people coming up i mean they know they're not going to be as wealthy as their parents or perhaps even their grandparents but a lot of them you know they're they're not materialistic they're not interested in accumulation and prestige i mean i'm generalizing now but i see really good values among this generation and um sorry could you repeat the question again i lost track of it there yeah um aside from inclusive curriculum are you able to share any insights by your students yeah so i mean i teach uh geography and i teach indigenous studies so in this one sense i mean i'm seeing students who are self-selected right they're going to be studying these things but i have had lots of students say in the indigenous studies 1000 class who are there because their program puts them there they have to be there and they don't really want to be there but there's an openness to those young people that is actually quite encouraging not all the time but um they seem to be more convinced by evidence than they say the ucp does um so they're they're interested in in evidence and i don't know i just feel more hopeful about them same with the united states i mean the young people are we're behind black lives matters so i'm pretty optimistic if we can get over a few hurdles i'm pretty optimistic about the next generation for sure our next question comes from timothy at the left bridge held are you concerned settler cultures and white supremacist cultures will at some point simply reject the id atonement for anything we seem to be seeing that more but not us that was in the past they say yes that's right uh they pull and that polarization so we know that in the western united states and in alberta and bc there are pockets of very committed white supremacists white supremacists and this is something that a government that had true leadership uh would be very concerned about but instead you see the premier kind of hinting the other day that a certain uh community of new canadians was responsible for covet outbreaks in one of our large cities so there's that kind of gas lighting that uh some might consider racism so we're like we don't have the leadership to combat white supremacy and we talked to our children about our history um and if they're not going to know uh anything about indigenous people i mean that really opens the gateway for ignorance and it opens and where they're losing an opportunity to learn about uh to learn compassion which is a characteristic they'll need for their lives another concern i have is that uh if we're gonna we if this goes through this business of not teaching about residential schools and and and some of the other ideas that they have there's a lot of emphasis on memorization for instance this is really going to disadvantage alberta students as canadian citizens and as uh employees and employers in the future i mean presumably some of them will want to live and work in other provinces uh they're going to be disadvantaged they're going to show up on another campus to do their to do a degree or another college in saskatchewan or wherever and and they just won't have the knowledge space that other canadians will have i mean we already suffer from an image problem in alberta lots of jokes that about you know the redneck aspect of alberta culture and uh we will actually be taking steps backwards and disadvantaging our own students to work in a canada and live in canada that is increasingly multicultural and that is increasingly moving towards indigenization um not just in universities and colleges but in many businesses in fact um our next question comes from mundo was the system of poor houses in britain a precursor or part of this neoliberal system of removing people from the system precursor or part of it i suppose i would just say that the ideology would have been building up for a long time um kind of the privileging of capitalism in the market and the uh special place of private property in british law i would i'm not um i would say that all of those things at some point become knit together and you have this solution to excess people and undesirable people uh and uh resulting in in poor laws and um institutionalization i mean the fact that the poor law the old poor law it was called of 1572 the fact that it identifies wanderers and bag of vagabonds as a problem the that it that implies that they want permanent year-round settlement predictable continuous land use and private property so they're identifying movement of people and which is a certain kind of freedom they're identifying that as a problem and they're putting uh laws in place to um to to kind of contain it very early on okay um we've got a couple more questions we're coming up to one o'clock um is that okay yeah sure yeah i don't know if i can answer that at all but i'll try um cloud peterson many other atrocities was perpetuated towards indigenous people in canada to what degree are those facts being taught in schools as part of the curriculum well i'm not sure one of the things that bothers me about the way anything indigenous is taught is i've seen it kind of taught in a way that emphasizes the performative aspects of indigenous culture so you might have a pow-wow at in a school for a day or an afternoon or something and that's fine but i wonder how much context is around that so uh i i get concerned that indigenous people should not be seen as part of the merely part of the multicultural mosaic of canada because first nations metis and inuit are separate are different in that first nations matinee who would have constitutional constitutionally protected rights unlike any other group and as communities indigenous people have political goals political aspirations and there are other uh there's other legislation environmental legislation and so on coming out of court decisions about consultation on land use and so on so it the the emphasis on the performative aspect i suppose it's an introduction and a way into learning about indigenous people but i think it's very important that it not end at that uh that that powwows are contextualized uh as as um you know uh gatherings and so on with uh as assertions of identity and let's talk about that identity let's explore it so we go into the history and so on our next question is from laurie schultz there appears to be a resistance in acknowledging post-traumatic stress disorders be it from indigenous people history or veterans of canadian armed forces can you comment on this resistance i can and i actually am a veteran of the canadian armed forces and there is resistance to this it's expensive if we're going to admit that uh ptsd has been caused by um either the military or by um policies of the government of canada it's expensive it costs money what what do we privilege we privilege money so the canadian federal government has had to pay out a lot of money in the uh residential school settlements there's a military class action sexual misconduct lawsuit uh now that has been approved and i think they'll be paid i won't give the numbers i'm terrible with numbers but uh that is it well well well into the um lots and lots of money that also will be paid out very expensive uh and of course in addition to that you have bureaucrats who are uh be spending all their time responding to these lawsuits and uh the redress schemes and and so on so i mean ptsd is expensive business so we also are paying for ptsd through our prison system our criminal justice system our health care system it's expensive business it's best not to prevent it how do we prevent it we prevent it by education and teaching empathy to children which is something that this government doesn't really seem to get um our we've got a few comments um which i'll actually leave to the end we have one question isn't removing history from the curriculum as bad as book burning by beth mendel yes yes it is i would say so yeah and then um in hurdle after self-education on my own it was even more startling to live in newfoundland and learn the ethics history interesting that some residents now admitting family history yeah so they're uh we were taught in schools uh that the biatic were uh this is really interesting that the biathik were uh exterminated and they were and but we were taught that it was the migma who did it the mig mock came over from nova scotia and killed the biathik now that's an interesting story who who whose interest does that story serve so that renders the mig visitors to newfoundland you can't really file a land claim if you're a visitor uh and the that that it places premier brian peckford placed the migma presence in newfoundland after settlers so the settlers came first and they brought the migma over kind kind of a it doesn't really make a lot of sense and didn't happen anywhere else uh but the biatic did die they were newfoundland is a mostly sub-arctic tundra and boreal forest the ninth largest island in the world very uh sparse resources in terms of living like large mammals you'd have caribou you'd have uh black bear they but they're small so the biathlon would have numbered about 300 people and they spent year they were on the island year round um so they that's kind of pretty kind of a precarious situation so they died from european diseases they died from uh losing access to the coastal resources you really really need to get access to fish if you're um living in newfoundland for protein and food um and they also died uh from violence skirmishes with saddlers there was no official campaign to exterminate them but that was the effect of the presence of the settlers and for many years uh the newfoundland government uh propagated the idea that there were no indigenous people left in newfoundland and that the br and then when in fact it was hard for them to prove that was the case they would say that this settlers came before the um the uh the indigenous people did so this is uh yeah firsting and lasting uh there's a gene o'brien who's an indigenous scholar in the states she calls it similar to new england some of the new england governors argued that um the indigenous people there arrived after the settlers did they came from other parts of the continent and so on it's it's very political as as you can see um we have our final question since we are all humans aren't powwows white history or so and are the atrocities of european countries also the sins of all humans okay so can you say that again annalise please this question comes from denver florence since we are all humans aren't powwows white and white is in um quotation marks white history also and are the atrocities of european countries also the sins of all humans yeah so powerhouse can be a part of uh canadian history um and canadia and are you know they can be part of the indigenization of this country and the recognize the recognition that you know we're founded on indigenous law and the treaties um so and i know there are powwows in lethbridge at the uh nmac center that everybody is welcome to so yes um i would with regard to the atrocities that happened in europe i i recall hannah aaron the german jewish philosopher who said that the holocaust there were dangers in looking at the holocaust as a sin against the jewish people or a crime against the jewish people only because it was very much a crime against humanity and she her concern there was that we have in us the ability to commit crimes against whatever group happens to be inconvenient at that time while acknowledging the extreme suffering of the jewish people um so you reminded me of hannah aaron with that with that comment there and the urge to you know to look inward and be be careful what we do and how we treat others okay so we've come to the end i'd like to read some of the thank you comments jim miller thank you very much for fascinating and educational talk it is very much appreciated laurie schultz thank you very much thank you for a very enlightened presentation the parallels between ireland and residential schools gives much food for thought um belinda closen thank you very much for the presentation and for providing us with so much to think about and act on beth mendel thank you very much there's lots there um i want to thank you on behalf of sacpa and before we end this live stream is there any take-home message that you have for our audience today um well i would some of you suggested activism and what we can do and and i mean the problem there's so much coming at us from this ucp government right now the parks the schools the universities the hospitals i've chosen two causes that i can manage that i can handle that i can follow and those are the causes that i engage in politically so maybe if each of us could pick one or two causes so we don't get overwhelmed by them all and raise our voices and uh keep writing and talking and opposing some of the things that are being done here in alberta okay thank you and um we um just to let you know everybody we have a special sackbas session coming up on uh tuesday december the 8th with dr simon sweeney from the united kingdom uh talking about brexit no hiding place for the uk government which seems very timely given that um that's gonna be happening at the end of december so that's at 10 o'clock mountain standard time and i hope you'll join us then and thank you for tuning in today thank you | Southern Alberta Council on Public Affairs | UCFUQ5mUHv1gfmMFVr8d9dNA | 2020-12-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 9,880 | 55,548 |
MOG7M6YJiUU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MOG7M6YJiUU | European Society of Gynaecological Oncology Wikipedia Article Audio | European Society of China ecological oncology Wikipedia audio the European Society of China ecological oncology is a europe-wide society of healthcare professionals and researchers specializing in the study prevention treatment and care of China ecological cancers the society which has more than 1,000 members from over 30 European countries was founded in Venice Italy in 1983 SGO aims to promote communication with scientific and professional bodies in order to create a dynamic and democratic European platform of individual professionals including specialists fellows and nurses for networking sharing of knowledge and improving Jenica logic Cancer Care in Europe mission Gio's biennial conference regularly attracts over 1500 participants and enables European healthcare professionals and researchers involved in the field of China ecological oncology to network discuss debate and disseminate new medical and scientific studies relating to the treatment and care of China ecological cancer addition to its conferences es geo organizes a number of educational events workshops and backed meetings throughout the year and provides travel grants to its members es geo is also active in developing educational tools such as videos DVDs and webcast lectures for the use of relevant health professionals the European network of China ecological oncological trial groups an integral part of EES geo is active in coordinating and promoting clinical trials on patients suffering from China ecological cancers all over Europe in cooperation with the European board and College of obstetrics and gynaecology and on behalf of the European Union of medical specialists es geo provides certification for trained China ecologic oncologists and also accredits relevant instructional institutions es Gio's China ecological oncology training and accreditation programs have become recognized standards in a number of European countries es Gio's peer-reviewed official medical journal the International Journal of gynecological cancer is published bimonthly and covers research related to China ecological cancer such as experimental studies chemotherapy radiotherapy diagnostic techniques pathology epidemiology and surgery activities tation Journal | Wikipedia Audio | UCwQK5AEJwsGn3-9VoXVMw0Q | 2018-05-10 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 318 | 2,238 |
U83MdrRaaCE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U83MdrRaaCE | Acting is not a recipe, it’s art #shorts | so what most actors will do is they will take all the classes in the city whether they're starting or they're being around the block they want the best Mentor the best actor the best teacher and the problem of that is the more classes you take the more teaching you take the more you try to learn acting the less you are being present in the Moment Like Only You Can acting is not about learning steps or a method there's no art that is about learning steps or a method it's not math it's not a recipe it's art and art is the thing that happens inevitably when you show up so what we do in my reset Journey from resistance to Freedom is we help actors back into their freedom working through the resistances that are in the way of that freedom that's already there so it's really different than a class than a teaching you're not learning anything you're actually deconstructing and earn on | Jo Kelly | UC0iHxQ3hjK2O6UAYU0P2zCA | 2023-04-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 168 | 890 |
jmFc6tmTNCI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmFc6tmTNCI | Views from the Sideline 10-26-2022 | foreign [Music] and welcome into views from the sidelines I'm your host Joey Tyson my partner Malik Hill and uh we're back from the Pistons home opener last week a week ago no more special guests unfortunately no more hot takes from the Chris Pappas uh but now we're into the NBA season things are going good how are you enjoying it so far Malik it has been weird uh teams that will be bad are playing great teams that will be really good are playing bad the Lakers are hilarious which might be like the highlight of the season so far the Pistons are one in three and that's good and we saw their only win yes we were we were at that electric game saw highlights from Jayden Ivy and Jalen Durham Franz Wagner and Paolo will be a force should be I won't say will be yeah should be a force in Orlando for a long time that's if Orlando can get it together yeah but they have the players in place it's a it's been a weird start but it's been entertaining it has uh just funny enough like teams that we talked about last week about being bottom of the barrel Hornets two in one Knicks two and one Spurs three and one yeah that's all three and one three and one yeah um Portland is 4-0 which they might be decent yes but the afore no start Dame's looking like Dame so things are all over the place I know it's only you know we're a week into the NBA season but at the same time you can already start seeing things that are just kind of wild and don't make sense 76ers one and three um and they've gotten good production out of James Harden and Joel embiid so it is what it is uh I want to just take a couple minutes to talk about the Pistons real quick they're looking good so far obviously they're one and three so they're struggling to seal the deal it feels like the home opener was when they got their win they looked really bad for the first a quarter and a half maybe two quarters gotta go in more so in the second half kind of pulled away a little bit at one point and finished off the magic now it feels like in their last three games have started really hot had an early lead in almost every game and blown it by the second half so that's kind of the one problem that I have so far with the Pistons just seems like you know Young new team kind of struggling to finish off games for the most part um the new additions Jaden Ivey Jalen during bowyon bogdanovic are all playing quite good actually uh bogdanovic I think is our leading scorer right now and the only concern is that Kade Cunningham is struggling a little bit his numbers are okay but they're not like what they were at the end of last season his shooting percentages are down which is just a little nerve-wracking um I still think they're giving Isaiah Stewart maybe a little too many shots too much of a green light yeah um not that he can't make it we've seen him hit threes and stuff now uh and I I do think it's gonna turn out better than the Andre Drummond experience a few years ago when they tried to let him shoot threes but I I don't need I don't think I need Isaiah Stewart to be a focal point of this offense like it's just not he doesn't need to be getting 11 shots a game which is kind of what he's been around and maybe that's in part due to you know livers just getting back Alec Burke's not back yet Marvin Bagley not back yet I'm hoping that's more so the case but we'll see um what have you seen out of the Pistons that you like or don't like so far in these the small small sample size I mean outside of a few negatives the biggest negative is probably the the Killian Haze experiment will probably be done soon I mean yeah he's on the level of like a mid major point guard and this is his third year in the league now he hasn't made any progress in terms of like any having any offensive skill he can still pass he can still defend some but yeah Kevin Knox he needs to go soon he needs to go he's mostly playing because Isaiah livers is hurt and Marvin Bagley but yeah he he's not a major contributor he's a guy that's going to be out very soon he did only get three minutes last night he had three fouls in those three minutes so yeah also hamadu Diallo he played some in the first game is he dealing with injury also it seems like he's like in and out of the lineup he played 17 minutes last night okay seven points seven rebounds that's that's good I think he's one that probably needs more minutes I I agree because against the pace he confuses me while like we don't see him more yeah against the Pacers six minutes oh of two two rebounds to assist but it seems like when he gets in he plays hard yeah and I would rather him Play More Than This weird rotation of them playing Corey Joseph and Killian Hayes at the same time like 300 that just feels weird again maybe it's because of the injuries so our rotations are all kind of messed up but I feel like Alex Burke's and Corey Joseph would probably be playing a lot more of those second unit minutes yeah mixed with Kelly and Hayes because they still want to see if he has something right so it's kind of a wait and see until we get our full complement of players I would think um we play Atlanta tonight so that's probably gonna get another loss most likely gonna be crushing defeat Atlanta's looking pretty good I think Trey young and Deontay Murray are gonna be solid together um yeah also Jayden Jayden Ivy Jalen Dern thumbs up so far loving what they're showing their energy they're they're doing exactly what they're supposed to do and Troy Weaver just seeing that he hit on another two yeah fantastic I think it's another thing to bring up to like don't get too high of expectations of this team don't do what we did with the Lions or whatever yeah they're young exciting the Pistons are getting better but they're not there yet so we just have to be patient but I think they're on the right track still so we'll have to wait and see um college football we didn't really talk about it last week um we briefly mentioned Tennessee beat Alabama which was crazy [Music] um and then this past week um nothing too crazy happened in the past weekend yeah there there were a few quality games nothing crazy yeah the only one that like for me that was exciting um was that Syracuse Clemson game unfortunately Syracuse kind of blew it in the fourth quarter they had a chance to do in terms of overall drama it was probably the most entertaining game but Oregon UCLA was probably the best matchup right two quality teams this is probably the best the back the Pac-12 has been in years yeah and that kind of sucks because they might not be a conference anymore in a few years USC and UCLA will be gone but yeah Oregon bonix that offense there for real and after that Georgia loss they've just gotten better every week they're a top 10 team now they beat UCLA 45 to 30. it was Bo Nick's best game of his career uh they're they're just they're firing on all cylinders right now and Dan Lanning is doing a really good job with that team UCLA is still good they just took it out to a really good team at Oregon Oklahoma State beat Texas Texas still isn't back let's calm down Quinn yours had a horrible game they showed that he's human yes after looking he missed a lot of open passes and his receivers dropped several passes but Bichon Robinson I'm just going to bring him up every week because he's a top 10 pick he is a monster of a running back he's a guy that a lot of teams are going to want he had another big game but Oklahoma State ended up winning it uh Penn State got a get back game against Minnesota after that excruciating loss to Michigan they beat Minnesota 45-17 Minnesota's backup played but still good to get a blowout in conference and then TCU probably would have lost to Kansas state if Adrian Martinez played the entire game but he went down halfway through the first quarter they still were able to build a 28-10 lead over TCU with their backup in but then he got hurt also and the third Stringer came in he threw a pick they lost all momentum at that point and TCU ended up taking it yeah they played TCU has played a string of teams where their starters have gotten hurt like four straight games so it's a lot of luck but they're also a good team right so yeah that's a lot of interesting stuff going on LSU uh beat Ole Miss when they were number seven at the time but they really weren't the seventh best team in the country but a really great win for LSU Jayden Daniels probably had his best game of his career Ohio State played decent if they played a better team it probably would have been closer but Iowa they have to do something they they got it they gotta do something Kirk ference and what he's allowed his son Brian parents to do to that offense it's just terrible yeah I mean Spencer Petrus 49 passing yards two picks they started it started the game with Spencer Petrus rolling out to the right out of the shot to the left out of the shotgun and he just threw it right to Ohio State DB like to start the game and they they put in their backup Alex Padilla later on but it was too late basically they had no momentum I was a disgrace right now they're I feel bad for their fan base like their defense has been good enough for the past like decade for them to win eight to ten games a season and Kirk ference has just let the offense fall every single year is it like it might be almost like worse than what dantonio did with MSU in his last few years because this is it's depressing watching how bad their offense is and how he just accepts it and he says his coaches are fine and he trusts Spencer Petrus it's delusional at this point so I will I hope they make a change somewhere because it's just bad they gotta find something when Ohio State wins again they blow out Iowa yeah so not too much as changed in the rankings uh it's still Georgia Ohio State Tennessee Michigan Clemson Alabama um with some minor adjustments here and there like you said Ole Miss kind of falling off um and then Tulane ranked 23rd shouts out two lane man always kind of cool to see they're having their best seasons since I believe I'll watch some of the game I think since like 1997 they went undefeated that year that was the one undefeated season they've had in their program history so if they were able to pull this off this would be huge for their program Willie Fritz has been one of the better underrated coaches in the country for a while now and his name might be more on the map after the season if they keep this up yeah and now on to the main course one more thing okay Texas A M is an embarrassment they gave Jimbo Fisher that huge contract he's key he's he's just he's ruining that program hey they got a big window shout out to South South Carolina who's five and two with a offense that honestly isn't that great and they're just figuring it out Shane Beamer good for you now on to uh yeah the real meat and potatoes if you will the meat and potatoes um it's Michigan Michigan State this week another year another year another edition of this rivalry oh we're at the big house yeah Under The Lights I'm excited to be under the lights last year they were under the lights they lost in the big house John o'corn was the quarterback Michigan State fans they they look back on that final corn yeah it's a name I haven't thought of in a long time it's a name I don't think about a lot the most Michigan fans don't like to hmm all right Malik how you feeling about this game not good Joey I'm not feeling good Michigan has a lot of hype they smack Penn State they're a really good team but this man I'll read you in this game I'll read you the lines Malik the spread is Plus 23. it's not good I don't like this in a rivalry game Michigan 7-0 Michigan State's three and four listen Okay so JJ McCarthy almost I mean he's only a couple hundred yards behind Payton Thorne but way better touchdown to interception ratio Blake Quorum is accounting for more yards and touchdowns than Michigan State running back Michigan is a very good team in Michigan State isn't very good let's just make it that simple but it's the Rivalry game but it's the Rivalry game listen 2018 Michigan wins that MSU weight that was 2016. yeah they win at MSU when MSU isn't good at all and MSU keeps it close 2017 I think MSU won it's this this rival I Michigan Michigan should win I'm not going to guarantee anything I'm not gonna better I'm not gonna put up a score I don't know how this game is going to go I would love for this game to go like it did in 2019 when Michigan was much better and MSU wasn't good and Michigan just put him away I would love for it to go like that but uh Mel Tucker and that offense the running backs don't scare me but they've gotten a little better their defense isn't very good that's that's the one that msu's defense just isn't they still have Jacoby winmen but they have injuries and machine should win so Michigan should win by at least two touchdowns let's just go back through this rivalry just since I'm gonna go back to like 2002 crazy oh boy Michigan went on a stretch it was just dominating the Rival the era I grew up in that that established what I thought about this rivalry but even when Michigan was dominant in the Rivalry 2002 49-3 below out then 2003 27 to 20. there there have been yeah there were closer ones in between there keep in mind this is when Michigan state was not a good team 2003 27 20. 2004 triple over time to 37. Michigan state was honestly just on top of them during regulation 2005 3431 Michigan in overtime yeah 2006 31-13 2007 28 24. these are all Michigan wins but each being like a score the records never matter the rankings never matter except for those like Brady hoked Antonio gears where it didn't matter because the Antonio was just smashing Michigan yeah and just thinking of like this 23-point spread the last time one of these teams won by 23 points well it's besides 2019 I guess that was the big blowout was all the way back to 2013. we uh when Michigan State won 29-6 that game was ugly for Michigan and after Michigan had won six in a row back in 2002 Michigan State came back one four in a row then Michigan won in 2012. State won three in a row then Michigan won in 2016. 2017 was Michigan State 2018 was Michigan 19 was Michigan and Michigan State has won in 20 in 2021. I mean the last one Kenneth Walker who's lighting it up in the NFL right now as a rookie he was just a generational guy that took over yeah in 2020 I I don't like I've said this before I don't count that season it was just nonsense outside of the top teams and I just point that out because I think it's kind of fun with this rivalry that I don't have yes I play the Michigan State Michigan State Side on a lot of our debates and things like that but at the same time at the end of the day I ultimately don't care I like when these teams are both good I like when the Rivalry can be fun and even when both teams aren't good the Rivalry tends to be fun as you can see by this list of crazy close games neither sometimes one team is supposed to be way better than the other um it's just it's just interesting to me um and I agree with you like I don't know foreign I guess I fully I don't fully know how Michigan State wins I have an idea you somehow figure out how to stop Blake quorum you do that I think you have a chance I think realistically when you get down to the nitty-gritty it's a simple game plan of can you stop Lake Quorum then you have a chance but but that's easier said than done and also the the secondary that's secondary I I can never get past that yeah but like against teams that don't have explosive passing games like Wisconsin they figured out a way to win that game two weeks ago Michigan's offense passing offense isn't extremely explosive but they've shown they can get what they want when they need it yeah and they can just pick a team apart when they have to this game I think it most likely will be close going into the Third but I think in the second half Michigan separates I said I wouldn't predict the score but you know what I'll just go ahead and do it I will go Michigan wins 41. to 24. okay it could end up being like 35 24. things get weird in this rivalry but because this is more like 2019 where there's a clear similarity like between the differences in teams and the strength of each team yeah I'm 35 24. okay 35. I think it gets weird in several moments Michigan State might get a toner turnover to might get some weird stops might block a field goal might it's SEC JJ McCarthy while he's running around and get like a strip sack touchdown or something this game always has weird stuff yeah so I'll go with 35-24 Michigan yeah oh that plus 1 000 money line is very interesting for Michigan State very intriguing I won't take it but um if Mark if Mark d'antonio was coaching this team I might just I might have taken Michigan State so just because all the pressures would be on Michigan what I'm going to say Michigan State needs to do just ditch the running game I don't care that's what they did in 2020 just just ditch it exactly ridiculous years where they just threw it non-stop with Rocky Lombardi because I think there's just almost no way they can try to play a slow methodical game with Michigan because that's exactly what Michigan would love to do um and if you give Blake Quorum more chances then Elijah Collins jalenberg like anybody from Michigan State play quorum's gonna come out on top you haven't even brought up Donovan Edwards yet which is no [ __ ] yeah so just scrap that you have in my opinion the better Talent and Keon Coleman and Jayden Reed try to use it like you said I I've said multiple times Peyton Thorn has been quite a bit disappointment from what I expected him to be this season this would be the time for him to prove himself Peyton Thorne go out there and just sling it he he didn't play very well last year either no he he didn't they were down big mostly because Peyton Thorne just wasn't getting it done yeah and Kenneth Walker just he wouldn't he went crazy and we can't expect that we have to change that game plan get away from it I I agree I think they need to come out with the the game plan Indiana out against Michigan where they just came out quick plays complete a pass get back to the line complete a pass and keep it going no no slow stuff you go and you go and you go you take deep shots you got to get lucky yeah you got to get lucky several times in this game to win this game you gotta win 50 50 balls more than Michigan just flat out plays their game you gotta win on those deep shots that are just like and that's we'll see what happens that's what I'm saying I gotta win on those Keon Coleman he's huge he should be able to I would think potentially he'd be able to win a good amount Jayden Reed like that's what those guys are there for um so that's like where I would expect them to get a chance I guess it would have it was it would have to take a lot because that Michigan State's o-line versus Michigan State's d-line I think is a mismatch in this Michigan's overall d-line is better than it was last year they don't have the two superstars on the outside but they have a complete unit and Michigan State's o-line has been banged up and below average to bad for most of the Season yep so giving your quarterback time can they can they do that consistently I don't know I don't think they can for four full quarters against Michigan's defense I think they probably could for like two and a half quarters but the damn will break eventually and that's why I think Michigan wins it doesn't take much it doesn't take much to get him to make mistakes yeah I mean ultimately I think I agree with you I think Michigan will win this game but I'm just hoping this would be my prediction a lot would have to go wrong for Michigan and a lot would have to go so right for Michigan State it has to be like the 2020 game almost yeah the over under is 55. I think it's going to go over and I think it would have to go over for any chance for Michigan State to win I think it has to be a shootout if they're gonna win um my prediction I think is going to be I won 35-24 and I'm thinking it's gonna be closer and the like that 24 it could be like 35 17 Michigan in the Michigan State scores a garbage time touchdown like it I think it could be something like that I'm thinking something like a 38 34. I wanted to push it to like 45 38 but I feel like that might be a little too high but it's possible this is this could theoretically be JJ's biggest game Michigan State Mel throw everything you have at JJ McCarthy forget about Blake corm it's one of those things where it's like let Michigan play their game you play something different don't play to their game play your own game Blake Horn's gonna get his he's gotten it all season so do everything in your power to make JJ uncomfortable show him what this rivalry is all about and make something happen last year Katie that's how I ever had his best career game against them yeah so there has to be and he wasn't very he's not nowhere near as mobile as JJ is they could barely get to Cade you have to figure out a way to make them uncomfortable JJ's still young he's to me that's the most challenging part of this game for Michigan State how do you make them uncomfortable right how because I mean you've had a hard time figuring it out this season it's obviously it's through JJ that you have to make uncomfortable how do you get to that point how do you figure out how to get pressure on him that's easier said than done too but I don't doubt Jacoby winmen could get two to three sacks in this game they'll they'll call some blitzes where he'll get to JJ yeah and I I think that's how do they capitalize after that sorry for interrupting you know how do they capitalize after they make that play yeah when it's second and 17 after Jacoby women makes a play are you just gonna trust your defense to okay let's settle into our regular defense now and that's when things go wrong for Michigan State yeah well that's what I said I think you've got to play you got to play differently to show something different you're three and four like there's nothing like at this point in this season there's nothing for Michigan State to lose the only advantage that gives that makes it very scary to play them because Michigan Michigan's lost the last two years and now it's almost in the same position Michigan sitting undefeated Michigan States kind of got well last year they had things to play for this year they're playing for pride right yeah this year it's like we got to show up for the Rivalry game yeah and they tend to do that does it always give them the win no but I think they got to take a lot of risks Blitz the crap out of them try to get stops and when you're on offense take every deep shot you can I just just play a risky risky game who cares if you get blown out by Michigan that was expected unload the clip but if you have a chance if you have a chance to hang with them like doing some crazy stuff go for it like this is the time so again I expect actually a pretty good game I don't think I could be wrong but I don't think it's going to be a blowout for once yeah I don't think it'll be terrible either but be because they don't have that game breaker like that last year it was a magical season but I think all Michigan State fans can can agree that last year's team was better than this one they are more consistent overall even with Kenneth even with Kenneth Walker going crazy they were a better team it's easier Michigan jumped out on him and was controlling that game yeah it's easier to set up a game plan when you have a a runner that is like Kenneth Walker yeah so I'm excited for the game it's gonna be good hopefully that's that's all I ever asked for just be a good game listen I put Malik on edge please I am going to I'm going to put a same game parlay on this one I'm not betting winner I'm betting yards okay points in yards I think we should both go in on this one I think I'm gonna take that plus 23 spread listen let's do a podcast parlay let's do this okay what are we doing let's I think we go we go let's go passing yards both way we'll figure this out let's not do it on the spotlight we'll talk about it later we'll figure this out by Saturday and have the perfect mix we'll make sure to put it in writing and then we'll talk about it next week once we hit we'll split the money and we'll go crazy we'll see how we did anyway so big game this weekend for college football that's going to be a lot of fun now on to the NFL week eight and uh we're already just about halfway done with the NFL season that is wild yeah crazy to think about um is this season hasn't gone I don't think anybody's predicted no how this season has gone week seven was another weird one unfortunately there was quite a few uh major injuries in week seven um yeah some some young Talent getting hurt which stinks and we'll touch on it when we get to those games in picks last week though with Chris being our special guest [Music] um he did all right but technically he lost last place uh Chris got eight correct picks which you know has been pretty around the number that we've been getting that's not bad so ultimately not too bad but unfortunately yet again Malik and I both nine picks correct we are what is this a stalemate for like three weeks and we have been pretty good at picking different games yeah um this is wild so yeah so here we sit and now Malik your total is at 55 correct and I am at 58. oh man I like the this is kind of frustrating but also I like where this is going this neck and neck yeah the entire time so it's been pretty good so starting off with tomorrow's game Thursday Night Football this game isn't as interesting as you thought no a few weeks ago no like this looking at this game you would be really excited normally but Baltimore at Tampa Bay man Tampa Bay has some problems the biggest storyline of this game might be Tom Brady's life is falling apart yeah that's like the biggest storyline of every Bucks game right now and that's sad yeah it's very sad Baltimore finally closed off a game though last week they almost blew it again yeah um so I mean they gotta win Lamar Jackson struggled a little bit lately though yeah Mark Andrews went out too yeah I think he's supposed to be back I didn't know what he went out with yeah I haven't gotten a full practice report from like today he is questionable okay the only player out is Ben Cleveland guard okay yeah so we'll see about that at some point you got to expect Tampa Bay to turn it around but but it yeah I don't know I I don't know I don't even know how to pick this game because even if Baltimore gets an early lead all of a sudden they can blow the lead like they've been doing and then Tampa Bay gets into momentum then Tampa Bay makes it to the Super Bowl but like who knows what happens from this game this could be a pretty important game for both of these team Seasons honestly I think it is I yeah the more I talk about it the more I can can see it and I've had faith in Tom Brady for almost his entire career whenever his teams have a bit of a fall off he usually gets them back on track things are looking different right now yeah his his like his ability to be like a fiery leader like that Michael Jordan Kobe Bryant type of we're gonna get on the same page because I can't handle I can't take losing yeah we're going we're going to win it doesn't look like it's getting to the young guys no it looks like he's just a tyrant on the sidelines right now it's changed he doesn't have Gronk to just like be his guy there anymore this changing head coaches with Todd Bowles seems like it's not doing great yeah there's just no there's no energy there's no there's no juice with this team and that Panthers lost man with no Christian McCaffrey yeah trouble Hubbard and Deontay form and you let them Kill You Phillip Walker had a really good game against that defense I can't trust the bucks right now I just can't yeah Mike Evans and Chris Godwin still might put up some stats but I gotta go Ravens I trust Lamar Jackson to keep getting that team wins I'm going with the Ravens all right Ravens are my team but I think this is a viable against your Gods I think this is a viable spot to do so maybe I can make a lead out of this I'll go Tampa Bay just there's got to be a Get Right game at some point right although I would love to see them fail I'm just going to go with you know a good 50 50 shot all right then on Sunday early morning in England I am not getting up for this this game is on ESPN Plus it's not even on NFL Network because most of the uh this is ESPN Plus on my app wow I could watch it but I won't who is waking up early to watch this nope outside of Jacksonville in Denver I've already barely enjoyed getting up for the other Sunday early morning England games yuck Denver at Jacksonville at Jacksonville I'm taking Jacksonville I have no faith in Russell Wilson anymore I just don't he's back for this game but I'm I'm with you I they're giving the reins to Travis etn this week I'm excited to see what he does it's wild they just completely they they've literally given it all to him yeah they traded James Robinson and just said it's yours I mean after these past three games I kind of understand he's he's becoming the guy everybody thought he was right but yeah and he just looks fast who is their backup running back at this point uh I don't remember seeing any other runs they still have oh they have Joe Michael hasty I did not know that yeah because he had a couple touches like the last couple weeks or something like that okay so yeah interesting Miami at Detroit how do you I didn't even hear you say I'm taking Jacksonville too yeah I'm agreeing okay uh Miami at Detroit how how hot is the seat for Dan Campbell it's hot I I'm right there it you know he had a lot of promise but over the last few games there's just been weird everything looks like it's just falling apart like two like three weeks ago technically you know all the fourth Downs that he went for never kicking this past week never like trying to challenge against Dallas like the weird plays that happened the questionable calls Trayvon Diggs did he get an interception or not it looked like he did to me but everybody on the broadcast is like that's a challenge like you should challenge that why wouldn't you challenge that I agree why I wouldn't why wouldn't you try it and then like at the end of the game who knows if it makes a difference either Jamal Williams fumble but they should have been on like the inch yard line why wouldn't you challenge the spot of the ball because that sets up your play calling to probably be a quarterback sneak I would assume who knows again it might not change the outcome of the game but it's just like why are you not trying to challenge that stuff as a coach to me it's almost like he's backing down like like a couple weeks ago going for every fourth down being risky taking risks and then this last week being very safe like choose one I don't know it's confusing to me yeah it it looks like he's taking shots in the dark right now and I I don't know if this is like this could be far-fetched it seems like his if his energy isn't high and he's like full Dan Campbell it seems like his coaching ability kind of Falls too yeah like it's strange he loses his Mojo yeah and you can't have a coach like that yeah you gotta have a guy that's just a consistent I understand these situations I know these calls I know where to put my players in the right positions with him you go to the sideline and you need to he's either like excited or he's just completely down there's like no middle for Dan Campbell yeah and yeah that that might not last too too much longer because it seems like it's affecting his decision making yeah and I think it's another one of those scenarios where you know Hard Knocks made the team look good and kind of gave this illusion that the first two games made them look good too yeah and that people were like oh Dan Campbell for sure has this whole year to grow I don't know he's proven himself that like in certain scenarios he's he's struggling so yeah I I'm on board with you know putting him on the hot seat that yes it's a new Young team granted we haven't had a Monroe Saint Brown DJ shark Swift swift like they've had a lot of injuries and dear golf's play is just completely plateaued yeah yeah that was a weird one too I mean his last three weeks have just been cut he was like pretty brutal 21 of 26 in the game but he had two picks two fumbles like he's efficient but then when he misses it's bad yeah so it's unfortunate Detroit does play better at home but man how in the like if you ever needed a win the Lions struggle against running backs Rahim Mozart's getting going he's one of the fastest backs in the league the Dolphins had that hot start against Pittsburgh but then they kind of they just went flat for the rest of the game yeah but Pittsburgh has guys like Minka Fitzpatrick and Casey Hayward and all those guys and like you know they have a secondary that can kind of stop Tyree kill the lines do not um so I'm terrified to see what Tyreek Hill and Jalen waddle can do against this team I can't pick Detroit anymore it's all over I don't even think I can pick them against Chicago coming up they're getting better yeah I I want to pick Detroit for some reason but I'm gonna go Miami I can't take that shot I just can't do it Carolina at Atlanta I think this is a fun game I don't know where Carolina why is the NFC South so bad I don't know Carolina all of a sudden has some juice even though they traded away Christian McCaffrey Robbie Anderson got rid of their coaches I don't know all of a sudden chuba Hubbard's playing a little better I don't know if he's gonna play this week because he did get banged up Jonathan Foreman looked solid I mean he looks solid with Tennessee last year all of a sudden PJ Walker found DJ Moore for a touchdown and then Atlanta man they are so I know everybody says this they are so frustrating to watch I saw something on I've seen something on Twitter several times in the past week there are Falcons fans and football fans overall saying Arthur Smith isn't drawing a place where Kyle Pitts and Drake London because Marcus Mariota is the quarterback he can't get it to them aren't you just supposed to be able to draw up stuff for them to get open like easily yeah in the open field I watched they're big body receivers it shouldn't be hard to get them looks even with Marcus Mariota and then why don't you play Desmond Ritter yeah if Marcus what I don't I don't get it I've heard so many people say well they can't get it to them so no I watched this I watched Atlanta play a lot last week against Cincinnati they got carved up by Cincinnati on defense and I thought okay maybe we finally get to see Atlanta's passing game no they're not trying they stuck to exactly their game plan even when they're down 20 some points it was wild like Kyle Pitts constantly lining up like George Kittle as a blocker now it's good that maybe they can use Kyle Pitts as a blocker like that too but even when San Francisco's down that's when they start to run plays to George Kittle Kyle Pitts had three catches for nine yards now I get it like technically they could still win this division the way that they're playing they could get a wild card the way they're playing but man I just feel bad for Kyle Pitts and Drake London because it feels like right now even though they could become a playoff team their talents are not being utilized to their Highest Potential why don't start the quarterback you drafted and throw it to your draft picks because they're in games they're technically winning games use the guys you've you put everything into these young players I know these Superstars that guys that can be Superstars it's almost I've heard some people say it's almost like Arthur Smith is like trying to slap everybody in the face that it's not about them it's about their team and about him and whatnot okay but all right Arthur but look like so you're making it about yourself as well but just think like they are in games and doing well the way they're playing just running the ball having Marcus Mariota throw it 17 times they're about to get Cordero Patterson back who's hardly even caught the ball this year when last year like his strength was being able to run and catch the ball just think of like the weapons if they were able to utilize the weapons you might win more and you could still play more of a run heavy offense just a little bit less like throw the ball a little bit more Drake London proved in the first couple games he can get touchdowns cow pits last year had a thousand yards as a rookie that's never been done before now he has I don't even know I don't think I think he has less than 100 yards on the season oh I'm about to check um he has one touchdown and it's just bad um so I don't know they're the most frustrating team in the league Drake London leads them with 315 yards and Kyle Pitts Kyle Pitts has a 178 receiving okay so there's more than I thought that's ridiculous 178 receiving yards yeah it's it's it's rough I get it they're winning games it's sort of working whatever they're doing but after all of that I'll still take the Falcons in this game okay I'll take Carolina because Carolina is playing with a lot of heart and pride yeah but I think I think the Falcons just throw to your guys just get it to your weapons yeah use your weapons it's seven weeks I don't think they're going to um and for me I think Atlanta's defense is struggling lately um they're not wrong they've had some injuries AJ Terrell is not as good as he was last year um they're just having some issues there um Carolina's defenses look better so I'm gonna go with Carolina Chicago at Dallas this is actually interesting after the Monday night game can you really go with the stretch of Justin Fields beating that defense I feel like Michael Parsons is gonna they are going to bait him into trying to run several times maybe and he's gonna just meet Micah face to face maybe and it won't be fun also their their defense has just been awesome like that's like Dallas's offense hasn't been all that great yet it hasn't Dak but their defense keeps them alive now that Dak has a week under his belt maybe he's better but I don't believe in Chicago's offense enough to give them this one I just it feels in Chicago I would give them more of a chance but I'm going with Dallas okay I'm gonna go with Chicago I'm just gonna ride the wave I think we still might just be swimming around in the pool man that's a risky one but we're not quite in the ocean I still have that little the little cushion I can use okay Arizona and Minnesota that's another weird one we saw DeAndre Hopkins come back I didn't watch a single highlight of that when they had they only targeted DeAndre Hopkins I'm about to look at the stats right now like I haven't paid a bit of attention to that game I think they would have lost catches 103 yards if they didn't have two pick sixes they would have lost the game touchdowns three picks his three picks were really well two of them were not his fault 1347 is like a good game one was 100 his fault but honestly Andy Dalton was carving up the the Cardinal second that's all just yeah besides the pick sixes which I know are huge they probably should have won that's what it looks like yes they would have won so you still can't trust Arizona so Arizona is still weird and I'm not sure where to put them Minnesota coming off there by how long does Minnesota like grind this they're not about to go like 15-2 NFC North is bad they are but NFC is looking back Minnesota still has to be Minnesota a few weeks I'm just gonna go with the weird Arizona win okay I'm gonna go with a low score in like like 21 to like 17 just strange game I think these two teams are being a shootout um they could so I'll go with Minnesota well you we've also seen Minnesota just have those games where they barely can do anything they can collapse that's for sure uh Las Vegas at New Orleans shouts out to the comeback of Josh Jacobs they try to just they tried to give up on them and I never understood why yeah I was surprised when they said people were saying he was a bust all of a sudden like beginning of the season they were talking about going straight to Samir white using a mere Abdullah more they tried that for one game and then now they've gone really run heavy taking a little pressure off of Derek Carr and Devonte Adams and Josh Eggers has had over 140 yards in each of the last three games these look good in New Orleans they're looking all right too um so I'm still kind of confused on how to rate this game it doesn't look like James is going to be back for this game uh sounds like Andy Dalton is going to get another start but he is supposed to get Michael Thomas and Jarvis Landry back so they will have their Full Slate of weapons can I pick first let's go for it because I'll probably pick the opposite I am going to go with the Raiders okay I think they're figuring it out Derek Carr has played well with hey a balanced offense that helps the quarterback doesn't it yeah they're playing more balanced football Derek Carr is playing cleaner Football Josh Jacobs is just doing what he does when he has good blocking in open field and I think they just keep riding a wave like you said a small wave yeah I hope so I I like Vegas I like them as a team um but I will go New Orleans I think this is a close enough game to take the opposite I think this could be one of those scenarios where New Orleans defense is maybe just a little bit better could slow down Josh Jacobs a little bit um so I'll go with them New England at the Jets oh man I feel bad for the Jets this is a real this is a this is a strange matchup the Jets just lost Breese Hall to the season towards ACL super sad after he had four rushes for 74 yards and a touchdown he's he's like he could be a generational guy if he gets back healthy yeah um so it's unfortunate for them but they did go out and trade for James Robinson so they got James Robinson I kind of feel bad for Michael Carter too he just cannot take over for that backfield at any point uh so maybe he hasn't proven himself but um jets are just finding ways to win Zach Wilson not really throwing the ball you know what you you keep going you keep going oh I was going to go over to New England at this point of like Mac Jones vs Bailey's Abby it's 2001 all over again Drew Bledsoe versus Tom Brady it's so and they're younger and in the post game stuff people were asking about uh asking Belichick like who decided to go to Bailey's Abby I did well what was the plan there I chose to put him in like nobody else knew that that was gonna happen they asked him if it had something to do with Mac Jones play and he said no yeah what was it Matt Patricia didn't know that was the going on and nothing Belichick just said put him Bailey also they put in Bailey and that play calling kind of changed up it looked they opened it up for him yeah it was I'm not sure what's going on and he looked good for that drive and maybe the rest of the first half second half though he didn't really do anything so I don't know it sounds like they're still in good good spirits but they got a lot of things to work out in the midst of this QB battle I'm gonna go with the Patriots defense because Zach Wilson is scaring Jets fans and I never bought into the hype I don't think you did either no I still hope he's good but boy he's not looking good no even when he has time they've looked better with Joe Flacco then I don't say that as a bias they have which is a problem even when he has like time it's just not working out great so yeah I think even in New York I think it's just going to be a weird atmosphere in that stadium with James Robinson getting a lot of carries and Bruce Hall out well Michael Carter might get a lot of the carries so they're going to try to figure out the running back situation I think that New England defense is going to make it a problem for Zach Wilson and the Patriots win yeah I'm gonna go same reasoning but I'm gonna go with the Jets I think it's gonna be a weird defensive game uh Jets defense is much improved um I think they can maybe slow down I feel like their running game has gotten it going to New England's running game is going pretty good with LeBron James Stevenson so it might be a slow boring game but I think the Jets they might just keep winning it's it's weird to even say that Pittsburgh at Philadelphia we're not picking pit right okay I think half of Kenny Pickett's picks aren't his fault no but it's just not looking good yeah I feel like they're kind of throwing like they cannot get back they cannot get the Run game going I think they're forcing him to throw it a lot more and to be fair like Deontay Johnson hasn't looked as good as he has in the years past he's not getting as open so it's been a little harder um they got to figure out a way to scheme up better plays for like like they have deante Johnson George Pickens and Chase Claypool now it sounds like Chase Cleveland will probably be on the Move uh towards the trade deadline there's been a lot of rumors there but I don't know Philadelphia is just rolling right now Tennessee at Houston I can't just Tennessee by default yeah you know there was a point where I thought Houston was like decent and they would be like competitive kind of like they were last year where they would stay in a lot as long as Lovey Smith is their coach I can't Davis Mills has he had his best game last week and it still didn't matter yeah he's taken a step back from last year like last year towards the end he was like decent like looked like maybe he could be something um because Damien Pierce is he looks like he's the truth he's for real yeah and they have good young Talent like Derek Stingley and they got some other good guys Nico Collins is kind of coming into his own yeah uh I think Brandon Cooks is another one that might be on the trade deadline uh it might be on the move so that would be interesting too um here we go Taylor heinecke versus Sam Ellinger I can't believe I'm saying that listen Washington at Indianapolis I'm going I'm going with Sam mellinger this is literally based off of like 15 plays in the preseason it looks good where he looked good yep I really like how he looked in the preseason I think he gives that offense much more they should open up the Playbook more yeah because of his ability to run hopefully won't give up as many sacks because of his Mobility yes and maybe it helps Jonathan Taylor because man I'm just gonna go with Sam Ellinger in his first start because I want it to go well yeah I agree with you I think I'm just gonna go with Washington in this game just because I think it's close enough um they did pre they played well against Green Bay yeah their defense is getting better they're starting to get into more of a rhythm um I'm a little bit nervous about like Jonathan Taylor is also due for a Get Right game so that might be tough play Sam Howe please that would be nice sandverse Sam Francisco at the Rams Rams coming off there by San Francisco after basically beating the Rams and then looking really good for a little while have lost their last two straight games yeah they've also they they blew out the 49ers and they I mean they blew out the Panthers and they lost to the Falcons and Chiefs yeah um Chiefs you can't really blame them too much but they just didn't look good at all they do have Christian McCaffrey now for a full week of practice we didn't even get to talk about that trade but McCaffrey got traded for a bunch of picks craziness perfect system in my opinion so it'll be real interesting to see how they use all their weapons um now in this game and the Rams they have to win like this is a must win game for them or they are in a lot of trouble I'm gonna go with San Francisco because I love to see La fall I can't go with the Rams I can't it seems like every bit of Mojo they had is gone and it's just Cooper copper bust yeah and you yeah and like every time they complete a good pass to Allen Robinson the fans go crazy and then that's it it's unfortunate um I don't know if they're getting van Jefferson back this week but that might help them they need him uh they need him the cam Makers Thing is wild I don't know it's I love seeing La fall it's just one of those things I just don't like them as a franchise the fact that they like they barely have a fan base they're fake fans Sports yeah Sports barely matter in that City I just that's that's part of why I don't like LA Sports here's another why have teams been so eager to move to LA so much when the fan Market just isn't it's money sports are going but I mean the opponent's crowds are usually bigger in L.A yes Giants at Seahawks this is a really fun matchup the Giants have only lost one game yeah Daniel Jones had a great game last week saquon Barkley is healthy and back he he looks better than he did his he is it's it's hard to put into words Brian taball is being creative the cuts he makes Barry Sanders asking Cuts Like it looks like he's moving faster than everybody on the field when he's like jumping around it's crazy with saquan and Daniel Jones is like I think he's close to Lamar Jackson in terms of like rushing yards for the season I feel like crazy Brian dabel is using Daniel Jones the way he's meant to be used yes get him running a little bit don't force him into too many crazy throws now they have wandell Robinson healthy they can do like short Dink and dunk stuff they've used Sequon in direct snaps like they're being creative it's it's actually fun to watch the Giants as weird as that is to say and Seattle they're starting to lose their Thunder a little bit just a little bit I think sure I think so well I don't think either of us think they're Super Bowl contenders no but I just I have belief in Geno has I have belief in what they're doing right now yeah yeah but I think Geno has simmered a little bit like he had a really hot start not that I expected him to keep it up necessarily but he's he started to show he's still statistically one of the better quarterbacks in the League this year which is insane yeah and it sounds like DK Metcalf avoided a serious injury so he should be okay to go in this game I'm just gonna keep we'll keep riding the wave that's the theme of this week Giants Kenneth Walker has 67 carries for 411 yards yeah it's been it's been kind of insane he had a 74 yard to touchdown last week um towards the end of the game uh it's been nuts I'm gonna ride with the Giants too okay okay yeah I'm gonna pick them to go seven and one Green Bay at Buffalo Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady what a universe we are in Aaron Rodgers choosing to resign that big contract was not smart yeah I don't think he thought that went all the way through now now he just has to deal with a bunch of rookie receipts trade deadline Aaron Rodgers gets traded where I don't know flip him in Russ oh the original plan in Denver apparently was to get Aaron Rodgers yeah he'd I'm sure Denver would probably be a winning team if he was there right now yeah yeah that's just a weird Universe we live in yeah Cincinnati at Cleveland Scentsy yeah these afternoon games are not as exciting I'm going with Cincinnati as well they looked so good last week they look like the team everybody thought they were I guess the last two weeks like Joe Burrows got back on track and Cleveland's defense is nowhere near as good as I thought they might be their entire everything they had a few years ago seems to be falling off yeah Kevin stefansky isn't doing that great either which I'm glad that you know Cleveland if they lose like a couple more games they're basically out of the playoffs which is great because I would I I didn't like the idea of like DeShaun Watson being back and maybe being able to get them in the playoffs I just I forget he's coming back at some point yeah week 12 isn't it I know it's at Houston yeah it's like 12 or 13. ridiculous yeah all right that's week 12. not week 12. so I think it's 13 then okay uh that's our week eight picks that's everything going on in the NFL and things like that um it's gonna be a fun weekend like I said Michigan Michigan State and we got NFL stuff next week more Pistons updates smaller uh a little bit bigger NBA sample size we can talk about some more things we'll go over the Michigan Michigan State stuff go over our picks see where we're at but this has been views from the sidelines we'll see you guys next time who's in a work spot right now Russell Wilson Russell Westbury which for us as it works debated next time | Orion Neighborhood Television | UCSSt3KuvosgTXBvp1NR2NPQ | 2022-10-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 10,324 | 52,970 |
t7msF_BN3Jo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7msF_BN3Jo | Open Education Intro | Hi, I'm here to talk to you about open education which includes three parts to it. OER or open educational resources, open pedagogy and open access. OER is really all about the open license, so while copyright is important and protects authors the open license or the Creative Commons license allows us to retain our copyright but also to enable and actually encourage the sharing of materials. This becomes important when we think about educational materials like textbooks. Where right now students are paying exorbitant amounts of money each semester in order to pay for books when we can use these open licenses not only to reduce textbook costs actually effectively to zero, but also to allow professors and students to engage in the revision of their educational materials. By using the five R's that are enabled by OER we are we can actually have a new relationship between learners and their texts, and this is pretty exciting not just because it saves students money which is hugely important for access issues, but also because it opens up a whole new world which we are now beginning to call open pedagogy. So what exactly is open pedagogy? Open pedagogy is a way of thinking about learners as contributors to knowledge not just consumers of knowledge. So it's really about opening the academy to the public which allows our students to interact with real world communities, communities of scholars but also in terms of service learning and other engaged projects. It also allows the community to benefit more easily from the knowledge that the academy is producing. So we can think about this in many ways for example we can think about students moving from the locked-down LMS like Canvas or Moodle and instead starting to work in more public arenas, by building networks through Twitter, or by developing ePortfolios and websites where they can post their work and engage with collaborators. They can use Twitter to build networks, and to ask questions, and to get assistance for more established scholars, or to share their work. And they can do more experiential learning out in the community through some of these networks that they create. The final piece of the open education puzzle is open access, this is really about scholarship and research. The idea here is that we want to increase the impact of our research and one of the things that happens now of course is that sometimes we have research that's publicly funded particularly in the sciences, but that research ends up behind paywalls in journals that libraries have to pay exorbitant amounts to access, which can often leave people who are not affiliated with universities, or people who are in areas where universities and libraries can't afford the fees unable to access that research that they may very well have funded with their public dollars. My small institution pays almost a half a million dollars a year to access paywalled journals. So the move to open access publishing is a move to call on scholars to share their work in journals that don't have paywalls. This does not mean they don't have peer review we can still have very robust peer review. We can actually improve peer review by making it more transparent and collaborative, but the idea here is that we're going to redefine impact so it's not just about elitism and exclusivity for some kind of promotion and tenure process, but it's really about allowing our work to shape the world to its maximum potential. In my opinion open education is a movement. It's about reducing barriers to education, empowering learners and connecting the academy to the world that it serves. I hope that you'll join in because the movement is growing and it's new and there's lots of challenges and problems still to be worked out. But it's exciting and I hope you'll come on board and offer your ideas. Thanks. | R DeRosa | UCNWFsdYMvPbqGvhxeCsW1CA | 2016-01-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 657 | 3,844 |
F-o4qphJ1pc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-o4qphJ1pc | Keynote: Good Devops Copy; Great Devops Steal - DevOpsDays Singapore 2017 | let's see if this works this alright so as anyone know what this quote is does anyone heard this quote it's a Picasso that's right that's a little Picasso little talk Capasso painting but his his point was that everything is derivative right like he didn't he didn't invent art he was a very gifted painter he's a prodigy but he didn't he didn't invent art and his point was that everyone has good ideas you could steal them right has anyone ever stole anything don't answer this is this is an alternative title and this is this is the theme of what I've been trying to convince people is the core of DevOps is is learning and I'm gonna a revisit that theme a few times but there's there's a couple themes learning and then advantage sustained advantage does anyone want any advantage yeah who likes to lose anyone no all right so this is a word from my sponsor they pay for me to fly around pivotal transform how the world build software and then Andrew my mission is personally to try to transform how the world operates software but I'm not doing it alone I'm doing with you right so this is agenda I'll just let you read it well I get your quarter I took out most of the bike shedding and that was on the agenda earlier but does anyone know what bike shedding is Austin Lee black shading later so there's a introduction I have done a few things and I think the best way to frame this is DevOps has been very good to me and the last 10 years of my life I basically been trying to help people build better IT systems with better tools and better processes and I was heavily influenced by agile software development and open source and it's a bunch of this stuff with you know everything is touching everything at this point so these are projects I've been involved with these are books or events I've helped organize or write and then this is the best methodology for delivering software it is artisanal retro-futurism cross with team scale anarcho-syndicalism and if you don't know what that is well maybe that's why you're not very good at this just kidding this is the most important slide because it has my twitter handle and that's that's gonna be important for your future and just to make it you know mix things up I wanted to make sure you knew that I come little idea comes in various phases of beard and hair so there's important for the next time you see me especially outside of Asia I might look very different than I do right now it's important I've also got a plethora of videos you can watch on YouTube or I'll sell you CDs if anyone has a device that still plays CDs from the trunk of my car has anyone ever seen me talk before beside Sergio and Matt who's laughing alright so this is the most important thing you should do I'm serious about this so the most important thing you should do for your tech career is you should learn how to write you should learn how to speak you should steal good ideas and you should follow the leidy on twitter so moving on I'm going to tell you some stories I'm going to tell you some patterns and some framing about how I see the world and that is maybe gonna be meaningful to you and maybe it won't be the one thing to keep in mind here is this notion of bias selection bias has anybody ever heard of survivorship bias or survival bias so the very famous story and there's a couple other examples but this is my favorite one where there was a study of the aircraft that were returning from from war and they they were studying where the aircraft had bullet holes and they decided that where they have bullet holes they needed to add more armor but that's actually completely wrong because the only aircraft that were returning or the ones that weren't lost and it's actually the opposite of where those holes are there are the are the vital places for that aircraft that you need more armor so there's lots of things that we see that we we have bias so you could give and people have given talks about bias and how that frames how we feed the world but what I hope happens a little bit today is that we we shift some of our bias as a group towards things that help us change our behavior and do things and that's uh that's gonna be reinforced so this is the short version of the talk you are software enabled how many people work in a company that has said out loud we are not a software company anyone know got a hand up I guarantee more of you have I've been in meetings with executives probably a companies that you work for where they said we're not a software company right like we're a bank we're a manufacturing like we do all this other stuff we're not a software company it's like well that's interesting because you have like 10,000 developers on payroll so like what are you doing with that right so if you're not software Nabal you're gonna lose it someone who is in the world that we live in I saw a few hands went up when they we they said it cell phones I got off an airplane in Singapore yesterday morning at 6:00 a.m. I got out my little supercomputer that carry my pocket and I pushed the button and a car came and got me at the airport and drove me to this building right like that that is that was not possible ten years ago that was not possible like everything has changed right it's not the world we were born into and software's what's eating that changing that so the best way to improve development I I don't actually believe that in developer happiness like I keep hearing people talk about developer happiness like where the hell is that like give them cocaine like what are you talking about looks like what it just doesn't make sense at all I don't understand but people keep saying so the best way to improve development is actually doing prove all ups you don't want I don't I don't actually want happy developers I want I want healthy developers right I want a healthy system I'm trying to think about this whole system not about your you know random mystery meat dockerfile that you're building and then last but not least you're going to build a learning organization or you're going to lose to someone who has and I'm gonna define learning organization at the very very end but I want to start with this so where are we and why are we here when I go to places in the world I've never been to Singapore before I like to read a little bit about their history and the and the and the events that kind of formed that culture and I learned lots of interesting things along the way and I've incorporated lots of interesting things from that in how I think about the world but Singapore literally didn't exist until you know 70 80 years ago right it was like created from most of the like what I learned is most of the land is actually reclaimed from the sea right where we are right now was built up from nothing and I know this is true that this lion symbolizes courage strength and excellence because I read it on Wikipedia and everyone knows that Wikipedia is true and it also it also stands for this resilience in the face of challenge and and the reason I bring that up is I think that a lot of the challenges that people are facing in IT is basically rebuilding things for reclaiming things from the sea especially if you work in in a legacy situation but why we're here is we want to continuously DevOps micro services or die trying' right if you're reading Cochrane news does anyone read happy news this is a blog post from O'Reilly radar from 2007 so it's ten years old it's exactly ten years old now because there's October and this blog post is arguing in 2007 ten years ago the operations is a competitive advantage it's the secret sauce of startups and what it's arguing here is that if you do things with traditional operations that you're gonna have all this toil that you're going to have all this human work so that's the number of hours on the on the y-axis and then there's the scale of the number of servers on the x-axis and that this new secret way the new secret sauce was was giving people you know the competitive advantage right and this is this is sort of like you know the Golden Age of puppet 2007 chefs about to be born basically and it's funny because like we still have to keep saying this stuff I heard I heard people in the open space yesterday say there is like is there any data or there's like anyone doing anything better anything faster and in fact the data is there like this is not debatable anymore if you go look at the state of DevOps report and you look at what people are actually doing what they're reporting they're doing the the difference between the high-performing teams and the low-performing teams in terms of delivering ite in terms of recovering from failure it is a drastic difference right and if you if you don't believe that you're just in denial faster is safer right and people say that and lots of talks and I'm going to try to give you a little more than then like what you could get from reading a blog post or watching the rest of these talks but this is this is what's going on all this stuff there's a little bit of a problem though in that the way that gets framed and part of this is the survivorship bias is that it all just starts to sound like pandas vomiting rainbows and especially if you're in a place that's difficult to deal with you're dealing with legacy systems you have a legacy culture you have legacy processes it's very difficult and you hear people talk about you know the fancy stuff they're doing with some new tool or the fancy thing they did or some process and that's just this is this is hard it's hard to I started to bridge the gap between what I should do in the in the world that I live in and and this thing that I just saw on Hacker News are on you know stage and everyone wants this pan is bobbing rainbows who doesn't want that I mean come on but they actually don't want that here's what they really want I mean they do want the rainbows they want scalability they want availability they want reliability they want operability they want usability they want it all for free and they want it without changing anything right who's mad this person who works for this person who is this person you know i3j so to make a point sometimes I just like to make the words bigger and I used to get really frustrated with this and and you know some of the work I did and some of the consulting like I did everything I could and I got emotionally attached to the outcome and I wanted people to succeed and they're like we you know how can we do the DevOps oh I'll change anything it's like just pay me and I'll go you know like can't help you but but what I came to understand this is actually a recent thing I've been reading it's very interesting is this notion of institutionalization theory and it kind of finally explains to me why people don't actually want to change or why they want to change minimal amount and and this curve that some of you should be familiar with has anyone ever read crossing the chasm I was like familiar with this adoption curve yes yes so there's this there's this tendency as things move towards institutionalization that people are doing things not to seek advantage right so in this institutionalization theory model and unless let's be clear all models are wrong but some models are useful the the early adopters and the innovators are are seeking advantage they're trying to seek advantage at some point as that advantage becomes clear as the data demonstrates the the the state of DevOps reports demonstrates that that's clear people stopped actually seeking advantage institutions organizations stopped seeking advantage and when they're actually trying to do is legitimize themselves well they're actually trying to do is become quote-unquote legitimate and so they start to adopt the wording but they don't adopt that practices the the words cross the chasm but actually changing behavior doesn't or it does much slower right and you see the same thing with with all these waves with agile with the rest of it right and these are based on this model of institutional theory kind of these three forces that create isomorphic the isomorphic pressures and isomorphic means the same so same shape so there's there's copying those coercion and then there's normal the point where something is you know the certified accreditation that people want then that's what they do right like how many people have scrum masters yeah that's a terrible thing like how the hell can you beat a master in two days give me a break and then it's further complicated by the fact that these things just keep building and building on each other right like there's not a single wave of change that's happening in tech right now right there's this wave of configuration management there's this wave of cloud there's this wave of DevOps like all of them are superimposed on each other right and so it's very hard to kind of keep that that's straight unless you're I think you you have this tension between learning about all the stuff that's changing and like actually doing anything it useful if your life right getting any work done this is a very famous painting I love it and it's basically these waves are gonna crash if you have the waves crashing then that is potentially bad but can also be potentially awesome right is anyone surf before yeah so warning surfing is hard has anyone ever ate crab in this her in the breakers yeah the waves will pummel you and and I also want to like this fair warning software is actually hard to it's not pianos vomiting rainbows Safa was always hard people talk about the the Renaissance and you know the the collaboration and all these metrics and the panel bombing rainbows but I was there and it often felt a little more like this right and this is actually picture of me trying to manage OpenStack right like is all mud and blood and you try to tell people it's hard and they're like and they're like well I'm just gonna build an open stack public cloud and somehow become a service provider I'm like okay cool story but this is this is how I kind of came to frame my understanding of DevOps and software the five stages what stage were you in depression I heard some depression so this is how I framed DevOps in my own understanding as Andrew I wrote a blog post in 2010 that kind of had these three bullet points which I think are still true now but I've simplified it and I'll give you my working definition today in a moment and that is the developers and operations can and should work together I don't think that's controversial although sometimes it seems hard in organizations that system administration is evolving to look more and more like software development so in 2010 you know ec2 has been out for a while public's been out for a while you had the ability to provision systems with API you have the ability to configure systems with a pigo the ability to do things with monitoring with api's all this stuff that was was traditionally operations work looks suspiciously like software development if you're writing it's ap is that software development and you can take all the lessons that you learned and all the tools that you have to do software development you know with respect to planning with respect to version control the rest of that we could apply that to saw to operations work and then last but not least and I think this is actually the most important one and this is what brings me to places like Singapore is that we are a global community of practice sharing solutions that the solutions that we have and the problems that we have are similar and that we should help each other do them and then and then all these all these communities are doing that because anyone on slack or IRC channels talking to people about the tools and processes I mean there's a lot of great communities to be part of right now and if you're not part of communities right now like you should become part of cádiz and then this is a model that I'm very fond of and I'm gonna I'm gonna use this model a lot for the rest of the talk is stealing from my friend John Willis and Damon Edwards is is this model of camps and they started with cams and then I like adding lean because I think saying columns is way better than saying cams but it's this notion of culture automation it's ensuring I'm gonna break those down a bit more as we go but my most simple version of DevOps so what DevOps means to me 2017 is DevOps is optimizing human performance and experience operating software with software and with humans right this notion of a social technical system it's not all about humans it's not all about tools is both of them are one thing one system and software is hard but humans are harder and here's a little aside so these are humans and these are humans I trained martial arts with in my life so they'll just put them up there and the reason I put this up here to transition from this notion of humans is what I learned from my practice you know when I was young and not slow it's that the principles are actually more important than the practices that if you get locked in this notion of what the technique is and then someone throws a punch slightly different like you're in trouble right the punch that hits you is never wrong the punch the haters not the wrong punch right so you have to understand the principles and apply them in real time not not something that you did as a ritual and if you don't put principles into practice they're worthless right so a lot of times you have this opposite thing where people get so so caught up in their mental models of how things should work that they don't actually can actually fight anymore it's like lost especially as we move to these cultures they're more and more nonviolent which I kind of like you know not being fighting all the time but in the old old world like it wasn't a theory right like you either died or you didn't right and that's the survivorship bias again and then the other thing I learned which I believe is very useful is that if you don't have the intention to do better to win to whatever have that advantage it doesn't matter doesn't matter how good your technique is if someone else has more intention to kick your ass they will but you can't both and I never really cared about any belts or ranks or whatever like the only system that I care about is like you can either beat me or you can't right and and that that's manifest in lots of ways and you get a lot of feedback when someone punches you right or chokes you or whatever so as they're interested in being DevOps like this is a thing that happened not because anyone wanted to be DevOps people wanted competitive advantage people wanted to win people were trying to solve problems that competitive advantage is what drove all this stuff we're talking about that's like without that impetus to have a competitive engine and that's that's in the curve right the institutionalization curve is those initial innovations are driven by the desire for an advantage and it's cool that you just want to do anything from ritual does anyone know what cargo Colts are no this is a very fascinating human behavior so the the cargo coltan is typically referred to as like sociology archeology those kind of things it's a it's a reference to a group of indigenous people in the South Pacific that happened to be on an island where the US built a base during the war and they were flying these planes full of supplies onto the island and the and the people there decided those were God's sending stuff from heaven and when the people left the base they built a essentially a religious ritual and practiced around they would build these coconut earphones and they would make these things and they make these straw airplanes to try to get the gods to bring back the goods right but they didn't understand and it's cool that people go through and like they copy the thing that they saw in the blog post or the conference talk but they're not gonna get an understanding of what that person like actually did just by doing the the ritual with the coconuts right it won't deliver better software so here here's something I added from conversation yesterday so I tilt sort of this last wave right if people are talking about in implementing ITIL and ITIL probably seemed like a good idea once upon time right the idea is basically we're going to minimize the number of incidents we have by going really slow by making sure everyone checks off and signs off and thinks about it really hard and we'll think about it again they'll sign a thing and then we'll think about it some more than we'll sign everything right and that's cool but like we moved off on that right there's there's there's ways to do things better and we're not thinking about we're basically not going to think about minimizing incidents we're gonna think about minimizing the time to recover and we're also going to get rid of a whole host of complexity there's a bunch of questions about complexity yesterday that you can solve a lot of your complexity problems by collapsing them to not have them right so in in the cloud native world you don't have a different configuration for every possible machine that's like with a project the mooster thing you build racks and racks and racks of identical stuff you collapse it complexity at the bottom you make people build on top of that and you spend all your complexity budget delivering value at the top of the pyramid and that's what I mean if you look at the first version of ec2 it came out there's like three different instance sizes that's it like there's no networking model it's all l3 like there's there's none of this stuff that people do with like complicated architectures and ITIL is not how the web's built it's a it's a huge disadvantage now it's a huge disadvantage so this is a question I want you to seriously ask yourself if you're working on implementing ITIL today are you doing that for some advantage or you're doing that because everyone else does or everyone else did and you're in your like little vertical right you're just doing that to be normative and you're just doing that because that's that's the professional thing to do it's not gonna help you win the other thing and this is I verified this because people are saying oh ITIL has this notion of separation responsibility how you do that I told does not say that ITIL got implemented that way and that's been copied and coerced and normalized but if you go look at what I tell actually says that's not what it says so this is this traditional IT model we're gonna put a wall confusion between everyone don't let them talk to each other except through the ticket system wonder why everyone is unhappy and then and then there's shenanigans right who does this yeah that this is the transformation but but in reality these are actually just their opposing forces they're at odds with each other in some ways by design like offices they're to do things that are stabilized and Devas they're to make things happen but the reality is your business your your organization whatever doesn't really get differentiating value for all this other stuff and this could be you know let's get out of more and more stuff but the point I actually want to make here is this all software right to the very bottom until there's actually silicon it's all software and that in organizations that you have operational responsibilities at all of them so when people talk about oh you know developers are gonna have this operational burden from under their application no they're not actually gonna have that much operational burden they just have a little tiny bit of operational burden at the very very top of the of the iceberg right for their application that they wrote like they don't have to understand how the networking works they don't have to understand how storage works like just make the logic of your thing not you know bring down the database too often like that's all I'm asking and this this practice of operations is moving right so what we call operations today is going to look very different tomorrow right and it already does from 10 years ago and and you know it's changing even now so server less whatever like there's a next wave of this changing so the task will change but someone should make sure things actually work who's with me I never understand that developers feel like they commit code they deploy and then it's like it's literally busted you're like you never even ran this thing so like why did you go home on Friday anyway so people people often refer to Amazon is like this innovator on cloud and they just certainly did some things they should get credit for bringing it to market not that they're I'm going to talk a little bit about Google and meta too but this is a quote from 2006 so this is the year that ec2 was launched and Amazon already had a decade of managing the you know large scale ecommerce infrastructure they had so this this quote another Cerreta the traditional models that you take your software to the wall that separates development operations you throw it over and then forget about it not at Amazon you build it you run it that brings developers into contact with the day-to-day operation of their software it also brings them into day-to-day contact with the customer the customer feedback loops is essential for improving the quality of service now I know people that work in Amazon and Jesse Robbins some these other people are there at this time and it doesn't mean that all these developers were operating the the networking in the storage right like they they were operating their service right and we need to as a community understand what that means when I say your developers should wear pagers it does not mean your developers will now do every task that's this avenues used to do who knows what that is so this is this is a model I've been using and it's the it's the Chinese five elements from Chinese medicine and the reason I like this model is it sort of maps to the five things that you know the five pillars of DevOps in a way that I want to point out that they're not they're not separate they reinforce each other and in some ways they sometimes kind of destroy each other too right so there's these cycles of creation and destruction so I'm gonna walk through the small really quick so culture you know people say all this stuff about culture this is a spectrum of culture so this is the west room topology model and it talks about pathological cultures bureaucratic cultures and generative cultures and then it has a bunch of things that categorize each of those and so what I'm gonna try to do copying off westrom is sort of bring that notion of a spectrum to like all the five elements and and and I think that if you read these most of us you know that are saying people will read this and think things like novelty crushed is probably not a good thing if you're trying to innovate around software right how many how many people work in an organization where they feel that it's generative right absent flows right the this is at least you know you don't have to say anything or not agree but I think it's easy to say the things on one end of the spectrum are probably better than things on the other if you're if you're actually trying to generate create innovate any of this stuff so this these cultural ideas are really to me around aligning incentives and interests so when people talk about the problem with silos the problem is not that you have silos the problem is that you have misaligned interests and information hiding right people are people are strategically politicizing the work instead of instead of doing the right thing for the organization and one of the things that really really hurts IT in general is this notion of the framing of a cost center versus a competitive an in much of IT you even have CTOs that report to the to the CFO right and so when you framed everything as a cost center then you get very different behavior than if you're actually trying to drive competitive advantage right you're often under-resourced there's a bunch of problems that come out of that and and probably most people in this room aren't in a in a situation to refactor your organization but you should at least know that this is possible and and there's there's other organizations right so one of the things I'm fond of saying is you should change your organization or you should change your organization so automation is this thing that we all get excited about I'm going to add that it's actually also quite a bit about architecture and and you go through this phase when you start learning about these tools that you want to automate everything and that's very exciting and you know you got your favorite tool and you're gonna do that and then you start building stuff and and has anyone ever built this this is automation right no I'm gonna say this is not automation that's manual this is automation alright and and the point I want to make here is that what we automate is is often as important is what we do right and there's things that you can try to automate that will resist automation they weren't designed to be automated they were designed before this and so it's a huge opportunity when you when you go and you do these sudden projects to revisit why things exist and you don't want to lose that opportunity it is a is a failure to just take what exists and automate it with the new with the new tools right and and if you do that you're gonna take things and you know maybe got this container thing and you're gonna just put it all in containers and we're gonna schedule it it's gonna be awesome except for that doesn't actually help because what you really got out of that for the most part was just the the sysadmin didn't have to restart the process right like you didn't get very you didn't get a lot of advantages around the way that those things fail the way those things actually can be operated you just got the ability to restart it and like let the scheduler do stuff does anyone ever play Tetris yeah so I'm sure a lot of you've lived this or you bout to you so this spectrum for for me I think on the on the one end you have a bunch of toil humans doing work in the middle you've started to script things and then on this on this far end you're starting to have the the software itself is a platform that's providing lots of these pieces for you right and and when I say platform I don't mean things like you know cloud foundry or kubernetes or whatever I mean more like the platform is your organization it's specific to you it does whatever it needs to do to be to be able to to take care of the business you you're in right and that's a that's evolving rapidly those capabilities does Aemon ever read the Borg paper does anyone know what the Borg is yeah so all the stuff is inspired by Borg meso Cloud Foundry kubernetes is all inspired by Borg it's a tool that was built internally to run all the stuff that Google does and they've run it you know for a while they got some good ideas they just published a paper I remember back in the day 2008 and Puppet was doing lots of work with Google they were managing thirty thousand machines with puppet and they would not talk to you about Borg if you said the word Borg in a room with people that worked at Google they would all look at each other and then stop talking to you for the rest of the night till he gotten really drunk but this is the most important sentence most important piece of the Borg paper so there's all this stuff about about container scheduling and the rest of that this is actually more important in my opinion and it's overlooked every task writing her board contains a built-in HTTP server that publishes information to all the health of the task and thousands of performance metrics if your software tells you when it's healthy you have huge advantage over trying to come after the fact and put monitoring on it right so get getting that is a huge thing so that takes us to metrics this is the this is from the service reliability site reliability book and the service reliability hierarchy which I don't know why they switch back for between service and site in their own writing but this this base of the pyramid from a Google perspective this is Google telling you how they do things is is monitoring so service level objectives I'm gonna come back to that a little bit later what are your service lo objectives anyone know that means does anyone know what their service load objectives are this is language that I hope we all adopt as an industry steal it from Google what are your service lo directives and and how do you know if you're meeting them what are your service level indicators so so this next phase is that is adding to this idea of the evolution I'm going to come back to that actually I this is I didn't set this up as properly as I could have but there's this notion of of the S curve of commoditization is that things start as an innovation this is stealing from Simon wordly sorry is an innovation and then they move up to commoditize so in IT what we've seen what cloud computing actually represents is a movement from innovation to commoditization through this utility model and that slide was probably a little bit out of place but the the spectrum for monitoring is at the level of insight so now there's this massive debate / discussion around observability they when following this discussion so so there's we've moved from unmonitored to having some base like the understanding that we should have some metrics to now getting really really fine grained tools being able to ask questions about the the software that were writing and we're coming to the homestretch of this model so there's no chef sharing so we're a global community of practice right like group hug everyone smiles and then people have this this well confused between their dev in their ops and they think the way we're going to solve that internally is we're gonna make a new silo so we're gonna solve our problem with silos by adding a new silo I'm going to say you shouldn't do that not not because you shouldn't have silos but because that won't actually solve the problem of silos just don't do that what you actually want to be able to do and this is oversimplified is that because because developers are not a monolith right and developers on the front end there's not the same as the developers on the back end and then operations we already talked about the stratification of the of the platform up through you know from the bottom of the hardware up through the services to do some things like deployment monitoring each of those have their own operational aspects and then let's not forget the business probably a good idea to have something that makes this get paid and then you know last but not least but they they should always be the least and on the bottom it's security what we actually want to do is create these communities of interest so each of these in its own right is a community of practice has notions of excellence has notions of best practices and then inside of our organizations we want to be connected and sharing information and aligning incentives to deliver value as a community of interest across all these concerns so this is a this is my little model spectrum in in terms of sharing that in pathological situations there's a lot of information that's hidden there very strong silos everything is secret and then in the middle you maybe get a little bit more alignment and you're starting to have things that are secret to the company but they're maybe shared internally and then last but not least I think that the you know the highest evolution of this is participating in global community of practice and I can you know I could calm a tray in Australia anytime and ask him questions about habitat and he'll probably answer them right and you could too and then last but not least lean actually subsumes all this stuff if you go look at lean and what that model talked about and what they they did in that community you know it got sort of started in manufacturing but it has this notion of continuous improvement and I think that's that's what I like adding lean for is so it's not just about having metrics it's not just about having culture it's about continuously improving the notion of continuously improving that stuff and also because column sounds really better in the camps so that's a little you know little win walk through this notion of the five five pillars this five model we can talk about it in the open space later and here's a you know ham-fisted attempt to kind of build this spectrum so that you could see the at least a framing that I like about what is better and what is worse for each of these five and then this is just me being funny because you gotta give that Chi to flow right so coming into to the end towards the end there's still there's still a bunch of slides but I'm gonna go really fast so well I want you understand is the context is key right and that scale breaks everything and I said this yesterday in the open space so there's this ant and ants can lift 50 finds their body weight right and they're very very humble about it and then there's elephants and they're big and you know they spent all day eating right so can you have an elephant sized ant well there's a problem and that's the physics get in the way right so you have this thing called the square cube law and that is that when scaling a physical object the new surface area is proportional to the square of the multiplier and the new volume is proportional to cuba the multiplier which means that the elephant needs to have bigger bones right the ant actually breathes oxygen through its exoskeleton and if you try to make an elephant sized ant it would require hurricane-strength winds to drive enough air over the pores in the skin or its exoskeleton to even have a chance to die and then if it tried to move it immediately die and just crush itself right so lots of DevOps conversations sound like hey I can lift 50 times my body weight right when you're getting advice from from the people on you know whatever conference and they have this little startup and they're like we did this fancy thing it's like well I work it in elephants right and like if I try that everyone will die so what's the organizational equivalent of the square cube law I don't know either but I know scale breaks everything and DevOps the scale there's a existence proof that that there's this way to do things at Google and it's free and you should go read this book so this site reliability engineering book has a bunch of great things from Google and I'm gonna give you some homework in a minute but sharing is caring right they're part of this global community of practice took them a while they used to be secret about Borg but now they're sharing and you can read the book right all these things that I said about developers and operations working together solving system installations with software and participating in global community it's all in that book right the five check marks but the thing is you start to realize when you read this is that sres are actually architects too like they're basically architects governance compliance of the way Google does stuff right they change that whole mental model about how new security how they do the rest of it because of the way that that that process and the and the software first mentality changed everything so this is actually a quote from the book so another way perhaps the best is to short-circuits the process by which specially creates systems with lots of individual variation and up arriving an SR eased or provide product development with the platform of SR revalidate infrastructure upon which they can build their systems this platform will have the double benefit of both being reliable and scalable you collapse the complexity by giving people solutions that don't have that complexity right you you make that problem go away the SRU builds framework modules to implement canonical solutions for the concern production area as a result development teams can focus on the business logic because the framework takes care of correct infrastructure use so people read about sre and they're like oh the sres took the burden from the software developers they took the burden production it's actually wrong and it's it's a it's a blessing and a benefit to get sre support inside Google and most projects start without it right so the developers are actually the operations for their own stuff on the services they have the the full the full pallet of you know Google's platform to build with but they're the one that run their service until the authorities get involved but the goal is not to take the operational burden from the software developers the goal is to make the operational burden negligible right so we're trying to eliminate toil by making those tools making those libraries making those modules reduce the cost of operations so this is your homework I want you to read embracing risk service low objectives and eliminating toil from the free book that you can get if you search sree sree book you should read that so where are your service flow objectives you should tell me next time when I talk to you and we don't get it aside when the competition gets an advantage but we can decide to learn and we can decide to act and I've been to lots of places I've had people read the same books being the same conferences giving the same advice the same tools same resources basically the same organizations everything about them looks the same but they get drastically different results why is that well what I what I came to realize is that that's correlated with their ability to change their behavior so learning is to me is about change behavior if you're trying to learn to play chess if you're trying to learn to play music you're not better until you can beat someone better you're not better at music until you could play the new song and that's really easy to measure in in organizations and delivering IT we're not always good at that so this is a model all models are wrong some malls are useful about organizational learning I what I recommend you do is read the organizational learning model and there's a questionnaire and take the ideas from the questions and reframe them as statements and I don't have time to go into all this stuff but if you're if you're in a place where people are continuously learning everyone can ask questions the team's learning everyone's empowered regardless of their rank you have a model for how you communicate the system's connected in your leadership strategic you're probably gonna have a pretty good time so very very very very big finish to come to the end yeah I don't learn anything until you change your behavior this is one of my friends I hope it's not you I'll just let you read it so saying DevOps does not fix a pathological culture saying DevOps does not fill a lack of vision saying DevOps does not align incentives and interest you haven't learnt anything till you change your behavior software is creative software's complex software is not digging ditches software is not running factories software is closer to art than science the principles are more important than the practices more important the tools I don't really talk about tools at all today the mindsets are more important than the skill sets are more important than the tool sets adapting is more important than adopting why is more important than what so this is my call to action investing yourself by investing your community don't attach your identity to your tasks to be is to do talk does not cook rice eliminate toil change your behavior change your behavior change your behavior good ideas are for everyone steal them and then give them away so these problems are not technical they're not people the problem is social technical it's one system altogether and you have to solve both of them so let's build better software let's build better organizations and let's build a better world we could change everything again I'm gonna keep saying this you haven't learned anything until you're changing behavior so here's what you need to succeed you need courage strength excellence and resilience in the face of challenges I'm gonna steal that thank you so I'm not here to answer questions I'm here to have conversations we'll have the open space later last my lease that's it | DevOpsDays Singapore | UCvKd52G5RaLAWVugTdY4pBA | 2017-11-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 8,187 | 44,643 |
ukQ9wR_ZvRU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukQ9wR_ZvRU | EXIPURE REVIEW EXIPURE CAUTION BEFORE BUYING Exipure Reviews Exipure Supplement | hello my friends how are you today i hope you're all okay my name is victoria and i'm here because i really want to talk to you about exit pure okay my exciter has just arrived at my house so i decided to pass by really quickly just to give you some important information about exit pure okay so stay tuned to the end of this video that for sure it's going to be the most complete video video you will see today on the internet about exit pure but first guys i really need to give you an alert about exit pure okay um exepure is only sold on the official website of the producer of the product it's not sold anywhere else okay so um to help you out guys i'm gonna leave the link for the official website uh here down here okay in the description box there and only there you can buy your original exit pure now let's talk a little bit about it okay thousands of women are having great results about exit pure so if you're here i'm sure that you won you want to know more information about it so basically exit pure is a totally natural supplement that will help you to lose weight in a healthy manner and in a fast manner okay keep that in mind as it's totally natural there's no contradictions no side effects anyone can take exit pure okay guys i really like to take my execure in the morning because one of the benefits of exit is to give you more disposition and energy during the day so when i take my exit during the morning i really have a good day so i really like to take it in the morning and i recommend you to do it so okay also guys i drink a lot of water when i'm taking my eggs pure okay and it's important you to do it too because the water helps your organism to absorb everything that has in the formula so acid pure has some amazing ingredients like um perilla kudzu properlies among others and they will not just help you to lose weight but otherwise other benefits like i said disposition energy speed up your metabolism you will reduce the stress anxiety okay guys so it's the perfect product for you who is struggling to lose weight with traditional diets and you can't do it with ex pure you can uh okay guys so each bottle comes with 30 capsules and you will take one capsule per day and experience a treatment so it needs discipline okay when taking it so take it for at least three months but if you do want to lose weight to do and see results you can take the complete treatment of six months okay guys so these four information i wanted to share with you uh like i said i just came here very quickly just to tell you the important alert of the website and give you the principal benefits of exit pure but don't forget to check the website okay there you can see testimonials pictures of before and after if you buy a three bottle kit or six bottle kit on this link you will receive two free books that will happen even more in all of this process uh you can check the ingredients all the benefits of each one of them and i recommend to you to see the kids of exit pure because the kids are cheaper than buying just one bottle okay so thank you for watching until here i hope i have helped you okay and if you have more questions leave here that i'll help you thank you very much and goodbye | Best Weight loss supplements | UCr10NPNoiP76leK2Yv2V3Kw | 2022-05-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 632 | 3,220 |
bwqkb2nAT08 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwqkb2nAT08 | Towards Democracy | Edward Carpenter | Culture & Heritage, Poetry | Soundbook | English | 2/3 | section five of towards democracy by Edward carpenter this LibriVox recording is in the public domain 30 - I charged you Oh traveler that you disbelieve not a voice comes in the cool of the evening I charge you that in the secret unspoken word you disbelieve not sacred and the first almighty thing moving among cities and over the open sea advancing to deliverance in us night and day youth and old age willing and unwilling advancing to deliverance in us dumb and of no account her beauty now and then only or at night when no one is near before the glass disrobing trembling lonely unresponded yet mightier than all the array and splendor of the earth i charge you that you do not disbelieve outwards all precedes Brahma from himself sheds and shreds the universes I from myself you from yourself today the slave goes first in his chains and the voiceless and those that are without arguments and always in the wrong and the prisoner was slouched head and the suspected and insulted in rags and those whose hearts bleed silently because of what they see and the old forsaken mother and the cast aside woman and the child and the favored las' and the drunkard shall go first the mechanic today shall go before his master the bricklayer shall be saluted in the street before the architect the Navy shall be accounted more than the politician and I will give the illiterate the advantage of those that read and write the scouted and the exiled and the unheard-of laborers in the fields and in mines quarry Minh and lime kiln errs and brick burners and makers and cleaners of drains and household drudges shall be nearest in honor the burdened of every day and the sufferers he overworked and hopeful lorne and the concealers of sin and sorrow and despair shall head the procession and with them one of whom I have spoken moving unseen hither and thither side by side first with one and then with another shall resume and make all plain shall be himself the beginning and ending of it all 33 when he descends when he comes to take Dominion do you think that anything else will do do you think that he will perhaps be put off by offers sufficiently liberal and arguments do you think that he will be deeply impressed by your grave how how and it cannot be or that he will ascend into your high houses and take his ease with you and Lounge smoking and looking warily at the sky till he forgets what he has come for do you think he will pay great attention to your hat and boots or to what they write before or after your name or to what they say of you next door or will ask what church you go to or what conventicle or Schism shop or inquire into the soundness of your investments do you think he will drive about with you in your carriages dispensing charities like an oriental prince and occasionally even say a few words to the coachman or that it will be pretence or mere kindly patronage if he prefers the Coachman's company to yours do you think that perhaps he will be very bland and gentle and never be rude or coarsely dressed and that he will be highly interested in what you tell him and that he won't add a single look no all that ever you did do you suppose that he will not know which is the top and which is the bottom of things or that he will be impressed by your cleverness and smartness parties or that he will reckon you up by the number of books you have read do not deceive yourself for it is yourself that you are trying to deceive not him 34 the magistrate sits on the bench but he does not exercise judgment the doctor dispenses medicine but he has heard no tidings of what health is the parson opens his mouth but no intelligible sound comes forth the merchant distributes evils just the same as goods do you suppose it is all for nothing that disbelief has gone out over the world that weariness has taken possession of the souls of the rich and that fatal darkness in folds the head of wealth and education that men disbelieve in the human heart and think that the source of power is set other where than in its burning glowing depths that the powers which they worship are but so many withered emblems of power dead scoria nodding and jostling over the living lava stream do you suppose it is all for nothing that the eyes of brothers avoid in the street and none sees what is before him that the heel is upon the head and earth alone regards the faces of them that are oppressed that the stones in the wintry fields are become confidence and the ground is sewn with compressed thought like seeds one yet there is peace over the world as of the sea swooning away in its hollows and differences our sullen like rocks and ebb tide and brackish dismal mud flats lie between and the Sun stands motionless overhead and contempt trickles malarious and avoidance and negation and fear loom up against the sky and men cling like rotting weeds about their bases and the soul stifles for the swinging life of the waves and the breath of the wind that blows from one end of the world to the other do you suppose it means nothing that that which satisfied once satisfies now no more not till the whole ground has been made but unrest and hunger are eating through men's souls that a new need gone up is more than all precedent and history shrivels before the will even if it be only of one man that the pilgrimage has begun and men are leaving their long loved homes by thousands and the tenderest hearted are the first to sever the old ties that centuries of suffering have compressed thought and purpose into one till they are harder than rock so that you shall remove mountains but you shall not remove the word which has gone forth that expediency and logic expostulate in vain and man has become wholly unreasonable and is calm to drop utility into the bottomless pit and the wise cover their lights but the foolish flashed theirs and our world away like fireflies into a thunderstorm do you suppose it means nothing when the godlike hand comes forth the awful hand sacred with the kisses of the generations of men when the hand of necessity comes forth from the cloud and covers dark the faces of them who have never known it turning them back from their ruin but stands in the clear sky beckoning bright like a pillar of fire for weary fugitives when the awful vision moves across the sky and the earth is electric under it and the grass stands stiffly and the blue thistle in the hedge is erect with meaning and men are amorous for the naked stinging touch of the world and to wrestle limb to limb with the wind and the waves when poverty and hardship smile for their expose 'el and fierce endurance is fused into one passion with love and the glitter of concealment is torn away and the loins are compressed and the eyes of flame with lust toward that which shall surely be born when wealth is slowly and visibly putrifying and putrefying the old order of things when the surface test is final the rainbow-colored scum and society rotting down beneath it a trick of clothing or speech metallic in the pocket white skin soft hands fawning and lying looks everywhere the thrust of rejection the bond of redemption no where the sacred gifts all violated stale and profaned men and women falling off from them listless like satiated leeches when labour is not loyal and true no the laborers loyal and true to each other when a man has no pride in the creation of his hands nor rejoices to make it perfect when machinery is perfectly organized and human souls are hopelessly disorganized do you think all these things mean nothing 35 England are beating beat heart no wonder you are weary weary of talk weary seeking amid the scramble amid the scramble of words and the scramble of wealth amid the fashionable the scientific the artistic the commercial the political below nerd and literary scramble weary seeking seeking seeking for a God as it ever was and will be as a thief in the night silently and where you least expect unlearned perhaps without words without arguments without influential friends or money leaning on himself alone without accomplishments and graces without any liniments for your old doubts or recipes for constructing new theological or philosophical systems with just the whole look of himself in his eyes the son of man shall yes shall appear in your midst o beating heart your lover and your judge shall appear he will not bring a new revelation he will not at first make any reply to the eager questions about death and immortality he will present no stainless perfection but he will do better he will present something absolute primal the living rock something necessary and at first hand and Men will cling to him therefore he will restore the true balance he will not condemn but he will be absolute in himself he will be the terrible judge to whom everyone will run he will be the lover and the judge in one the son of man ponder well these words after all I cannot explain them it is impossible possible to explain that which is itself initial and elementary you will look a thousand times before you see that which you are looking for it is so simple not science Oh beating heart nor theology nor wrappings nor philanthropy nor high acrobatic philosophy but the Sun and so equally the daughter of man [Music] 36 I hear the sound of the wedding of Sighs the beautiful grass stands tall in the meadows mixed with sorrel and buttercups the steamships move on across the sea leaving trails of distant smoke I see the tall White Cliffs of Albion I smell the smell of the new moon grass the waft of the thought of death the white fleeces of the clouds move on in the everlasting blue with the dashing and the spray of waves below it comes and recedes again and comes nearer out of the waves and the tall white cliffs and the clouds and the grass end of section five section 6 of towards democracy by Edward carpenter this LibriVox recording is in the public domain [Music] 37 the towers of westminster stand up by the river and within the supposed rulers contend and argue but they hear nothing it comes to them last the long lines of princely mansions stretched through Belgravia and kensington close-lipped death plague stricken lines of carriages crowd the park cheer above tear at the Opera our faces and flowers there are clubs and literary cliques and entertainment but the voice of human joy native once more in the world there is scarcely a note over all the towns and villages of the land the fingers of the spires point dumb to the driving clouds York Minster stands up like a watchtower in the Rising Sun and from the midst of its Roman walls looks out over leagues of meadows and cornfields Salsbury stands up and Ely lonesome among its old world fans but they report nothing seen from the hall at Plymouth the promenade loafers looked down upon the decks of passing vessels the line of the breakwater stretches and the wild sea beyond the convicts thousands motionless faced in yellow dressed gangs dot the thinly grasped rocks and fortress walls of the Isle of Portland Victoria the Queen peers from the high windows of Osborne back upon Portsmouth crowded with shipping and the grass downs of the island that lies behind it the male steamers go to and fro of Dover and Folkston the passengers arrive from the continent idlers are watching the arrivals and police officers in disguise but they report nothing when Chelsea and rye stand forgotten by the water on rocks beaten now only by the waving Meadows the old Martello towers dot the long low Shores down the Thames with the tide the great vessels come swinging st. Pauls looks out upon them white in Far glimpses over the great city the seagulls dip and Hoffer where the waters meet the cutters of Yarmouth leave the river and make between the long sands were the open sea and the banks 38 England spreads like a map below me I see the mudflats of the wash striped with water at low tide the embankments grown with mugwort and c ester's and boston stump and King's Lynn and the square sail Briggs in the offing beachy head stands up beautiful with white walls and pinnacles from its slopes of yellow poppy in boo gloss the sea below creeps with a gray fog the vessels pass and are folded out of sight within it I hear their foghorn sounding Flamborough Head stands up dividing the waves up its steep gullies the fishermen haul their boats in its caves the waters make perpetual music I see the rockbound coast of Anglesey with projecting ribs of Rex the hills of Wicklow are faintly outlined across the water I ascend the mountains of Wales the torrents and streams lie silver below me the valleys are dark moral sea Abad stands up beautiful and treefon and kata idris in the morning air i descend the waii and pass through the ancient streets of Monmouth and of Bristol I thread the feathery birch Haunted Kunz of Somerset I ascend the high points of the Cotswolds and look out over the rich Vale of Gloucester to the Malvern hills and see the old city clustering around its church and the broad waters of the Severn and the distant towers of Berkeley castle the river streams run on below me the broad deep bosom Trent through the rich Meadows full of cattle under tall shady trees runs on I trace it to its birthplace in the Hills I see the Derbyshire Derwent darting in trout Haunted's shallows over its stones I taste and bathe in the clear brown more fed water I see the sweet breath cottage homes and homesteads dotted for miles and miles and miles it comes near to them I enter the wheelwrights cottage by the angle of the river the door stands open against the water and catches it's changing syllables all day long roses twine and the smell of the wood yard comes in wafts the castle rocks of Nottingham stand up bowled over the Trent Valley the tall Flagstaff waives its flag the old market place is full of town and country folk the river goes on broadening seaward I see where it runs beneath the great iron swing bridges of the railroads there are canals connecting with it and the sails of the canal boats gliding on a level with the meadows the great sad colorless flood of the Humber stretches before me the low-lying banks the fog the solitary vessels the brackish marshes and the water birds hull stretches with its docks vessels are unladen bags of shellfish cargoes of oranges timber fish I see the flat lands beyond Hull and the enormous flights of Puetz the Thames runs down with the sound of many voices I hear the sound of the sawmills and flour mills of the Cotswolds I can see racing boats and hear the shouts of partisans villages bask in the Sun below me Sawney and Maidenhead anglers and artists are hidden nooks among tall willow herbs I glide with tub and outrigger past flower gardens meadows parks parties of laughing girls handle the oars and tiller ropes Teddington Twickenham Richmond brenford glide past I hear the songs I hear Elizabeth Ian echoes I come within sound of the roar of London I see the woodland and rocky banks of the Tavey and Tamar and of the arrow II dart the Yorkshire use wine sluggish below me afar off i catched the sussex hooves and aaron breaking seaward through the gaps in the downs i looked down from the Cheshire Moors upon the D in their pride the beautiful cities of England stand up before me from the midst of her antique Elms and lilac and laburnum haunted gardens the grey gateways and towers of Cambridge stand up IV groan Warwick peeps out of thick foliage I see Canterbury and Winchester and chester and werster proud by her riverside and the ancient castles York and Lancaster looking out seaward and Carlisle I see the glistening of carriage wheels and the sumptuous shine of miles of sea frontage at Brighton and Hastings and Scarborough Clifton climbs to her heights over the Avon and ruins of Whitby Abbey our crusted with spray I hear the ring of hammers and the shipyards at Chatham and Portsmouth and qiyam and looked down upon wildernesses of masts and dark basins I see the Observatory at Greenwich and catch the pulses of star taken time spreading in waves over the land I see the delicate spiderweb of the Telegraph's and the rush of the traffic of the great main lines north west and south I see the solid flow of businessman northward across London Bridge in the morning and the abbé at evening I see the eternal systole and diastole of exports and imports through the United Kingdom and the armies of those who assist in the processes of secretion and assimilation and the great markets I explore the palaces of dukes the parks and picture galleries Chatsworth Hardwick arendelle and the numberless old Abbey's I walked through the tall windowed hospitals and asylums of the great cities and here chants caught up and wandering from Ward to ward I see all over the land the beautiful centuries growing villages and farmhouses nestling down among their trees the dear old lanes and footpaths and the great clean highways connecting the fields every one to the people known by its own name and hedgerows and little struggling copses and village greens I see the great sweeps of country the rich wields of Sussex and Kent the orchards and deep lanes of Devon the willow haunted flats of Huntington Cambridge and South Lincolnshire Sherwood Forest and the New Forest and the light pastures of the North and South Downs the south and Midland and eastern agricultural districts the wild moorlands of the north and west and the intermediate districts of coal and iron the oval shaped manufacturing heart of England lies below me at night the clouds flicker in the lurid glare I hear the sob and gasp of pumps and the solid beat of steam and tilt hammers I see streams of pale lilac and saffron tinted fire I see the swarthy Vulcan reeking towns the belching chimneys the slums the liquor shops chapels dancing saloons running grounds the blameless remote village dances I see the huge warehouses of Manchester the mini storied mills the machinery the great bail Laden and raised the magnificent horses I walked through the Liverpool exchange the brokers stand in knots the greetings the frock coats the rosebuds the handling and comparing of cotton samples leads lies below me I hear the great Bell I see the rush along bore lane and Brigid I enter the hot machine shops smelling of oil and wool dust I see Sheffield among her hills and the white dashing of her many waterwheels and the sulfurous black cloud going up to heaven in her midst Newcastle I recognise and her lofty bridge and I look out over the river gates of the Mersey 39 I see a great land poised as in a dream waiting for the word by which it may live again I see the stretched sleeping figure waiting for the kiss and the reawakening I hear the bells pealing and the crash of hammers and see beautiful parks spread as in a toy show I see a great land waiting for its own people to come and take possession of it 40 the clouds fly overhead still and the waves curdle in the blue beneath the smell of the new moan grass comes and the tall white cliffs stand up all depends upon a word spoken do you think perhaps that there is no answer do you think that the highlight houses looking out over the wall the sea itself careering beyond them that the plowed lands and the rocks that are hewn into great cities are indifferent to who owned to who trespass upon them that they are dumb dead and of no account do you think that they have nothing to say to all this that they will not deliver themselves upon whom they choose that they have not in their power to bless and to curse that they cannot repay love a hundredfold do you not know that the streets houses public buildings of the city where you live have tongues arms eyes that they are on the watch that the trees and streams around you are alive with answers and that the common clay knows the tread of its true owner do you think that England or any land will rise into life will display her surpassing beauty will pour out her love to the touch of false owners to people who finger banknotes who make traffic buying and selling her who owned by force of title deeds laws police who yet deny her turning their backs upon her wins and her waves and ashamed to touch her soil with their hands do you think that she will arise to the call of these Oh do you not know how she yearns for the mastery of her true owners how she leans her self backward displaying her charms inviting breathing courage even into faint souls to know their manhood to come upon her boldly to let none stand between oh no well that it shall be that the land they dwell on that the earth for whatsoever people is worthy shall become impossible to be separated from them even in of those who are truly the people they are jealous of their land the woods and the fields and the open sea are covered with their love inseparable from life every hedgerow every old Lum and coppice the nature of the soils in every field and part of a field the suffs the bedrock pastures plow lands and fallows the quarries and places of the best stone for road mending building walling roofing draining the best stuff for mending footpaths the best water for miles round and the taste and quality of the various wells and Springs the Clay's were puddling and for brick burning the Basset een out and the dips of the beds the cattle and livestock up and down their various breeds treatments and condition the Moors forests streams rivers sea coasts familiar by sunlight moonlight starlight and on dark nights every nook and corner of them the old trees and their histories the waterside trees and where pheasants frequently roost and the places for netting rabbits and hares or for spearing trout by lantern light or where the crabapple and the cluster Berry and the mountain flax and agrimony grow the haunts of the wild duck and snipe the decoy of the corncrake the nests of the storm and the water hen and the pewte the legends told of old hollows and caves and crags the bold and beautiful headlands the taste of the air upon them the old streets of the towns and their histories and the histories of the houses in them and of those who lived in the houses the old villages and their traditions customs specialties notorious characters feasts and frolics the knowledge of the arts of sea and her fishing oyster and scallop dredging the trawl the Seine and the driftnet farming fruit growing timber growing pilling and dressing canal making sea walling shipbuilding irrigation the great crafts in stone wood iron of the Masons the Smiths the joiners the tool makers work of the clean use of tools of all faithful and perfect work and the joy and mastery that comes of it everything that the land has calls an answer in the breasts of the people and quickly grows love for the use of those that live on it without this love no people can exist this is the creation nourishment and defence of Nations it is this that shall save England as it has saved Ireland which ultimately of the very earth shall become the nurse of humanity between a great people and the earth Springs a passionate attachment lifelong and the earth loves indeed her children broad breasted broad broad and talks with them night and day storm and sunshine summer and winter alike here indeed is the key to the whole secret of education owners and occupiers then fall into their places the trees wave proud and free upon the headlands the little Brooks run with a wonderful new music under the brambles and the grass determined is the word henceforth to worship nothing no ownership which is unreal no title deeds money smells respect abilities authorities to be arrogant unpersuadable faithful free not unworthy of the trees waving upon the high-tops and of the earth through the starlit night government and laws and police then fall into their places the earth gives her own laws democracy just begins to open her eyes and peep and the rabble of unfaithful bishops priests generals landlords capitalists lawyers kings queens patronize errs and polite idlers goes scuttling down into general oblivion faithfulness emerges self-reliance self-help passion and comradeship freedom emerges the loveable and the broad waters the air the undulating fields the flow of cities and the people there in their faces and the looks of them no less than the rush of the tides and the slow hardy growth of the oak and the tender herbage of spring and stiff clay and storms and transparent air all depends upon a word spoken or unspoken the clouds fly overhead still and the smell of the new mown grass is wafted by it comes and recedes again I hear the awful syllable change and see all things qualities impersonations gliding from the embraces of their own names but I hear beyond I hear beyond the sound of the hone and strick 'el and look in the eyes of the moor under the shade of his broad straw hat it comes and recedes again and comes nearer the little waves lip up against the great black ship as she glides down river Oh sailor sitting on a plank over the side beware the ship itself the rigging the tidal river the docks the wharves and the long busy streets and country beyond the shows of life and death who makes and who unmake them I touch you lightly I am the spray I touch you that you remember and forget not who you are [Music] end of section 6 section 7 of towards democracy by Edward carpenter this LibriVox recording is in the public domain [Music] 41 I look upon him who makes all things I sit at his feet in silence as he lights his pipe and feel the careless resting of his fingers upon my neck I see the fire leaping in the great I see the nodding of grasses and blackberry sprays in the hedges I hear the long surge and hush of the wind I hear his voice speaking to me all rivers and hills of Albion oh clouds that sail from the Atlantic to the North Sea and wrinkled old Abbey's and modern towers and streets of heavily laden Gray's behind your masks I am aware of an imperceptible change surely it must be the appearance of a face 42 the word travels on I have been on a and my boots are dusty and hob nailed and my clothes are torn do not ask me into your house God knows I might spoon my food with a knife give me a penny on the doorstep and let me pass on I have sat with you long and loved you well unknown to you but now I go other where 43 the word travels on out of the mists of time out of innumerable births of endless journeys transfigure months lives deaths sorrows emerging my voice sounds to self to you nearer than all thought tentatively trying the first notes wandering at its beauty of the song strange word of joy to spread abroad over the earth to be realized in time freedom to be realized in time for which the whole of history has been a struggle and a preparation the dream of the soul slow disentanglement o blessed it is he that has passed away blessed alive or dead whom the bitter taunts of existence reach not no betrayals protruded from dear faces no weariness the cold nor pain dwelling in heaven and looking forth in peace upon the world blessed thrice blessed by day by night blessed who sleeps with him blessed who eats walks talks blessed who Labor's in the field beside him blessed who ever though he be dead shall know him to be eternally near I am the poet of hitherto unheard joy a little bird told me the secret in the night and henceforth I go about seeking to whom to whisper it I see the heavens laughing I discerned a half hidden faces of the gods wherever I go I see the transparent opaque veil in which they hide themselves yet I dare not say what I see lest I should be locked up children go with me and rude people are my companions I trust them and they me day and night we are together and are content to them what I would say is near yet it is nothing that can be named or in the giving or taking of any one thing but rather in all things laughter Oh laughter Oh endless journey o soul exhale who's suffering arising free little bird petrol through the stormy seas diving darting they boundless home oh clouds and sunshine shattering elf in thine own dark eyes gazing old beckoner of companions hastening onward wind spirit divine dirt round with laughter laughter laughter forty-four I am come to be the interpreter of yourself to yourself do I not stand behind the Sun and Moon do I not wait behind the air that you breathe for this born beyond Maya I now descend into materials the dandelion by the path and the pink buds of the Sycamore and the face of the sweep who comes to sweep your chimney shall henceforth have a new meaning to you how do you know that I am NOT the chimney sweep the nettles growing against the gatepost and the dry log on the grass where you stop and sit the faithful tool that is in your hand and the sweat on your forehead the sound of the dear old village band across the fields these shall be for memorials between us and I in them will surely draw towards you and to you when I am dead they shall deliver the words which still I had not sense encouraged to speak hear them where I was not faithful these shall be faithful to you where I was vain and silly these shall look you clear of all vanity and silliness where I was afraid to utter my thoughts dumb things shall utter for you words impossible to be misunderstood the Sun shall shine the clouds draw across the sky the fire leap in the grate the kettle boil to purposes which you cannot fathom the simplest shall look you in the face two meanings ever profounder and founder than all thought behind them behind the woven veil accepting not rejecting my own vanities cowardice is giving them also their due place I to wait in silence till the full armed shall come to give me birth again 45 in silence I wait and accept all the glare of misapprehension I accept I sit at the fashionable dinner table and accept what has brought to me I am a painter on the house side the sight of the distant landscape pleases me and the scraps of conversation caught from the street below my back aches singling turnips through the long hot day my fingers freeze getting potatoes I help the farmer drive his scared cattle home at midnight by the fitful flicker of lightning I go Moyne at early morning while the Twilight creeps in the Northeast I sleep in the hot hours and mow again on into the night I am a scene unseen Adam travelling with others through space or remaining centuries in one place again I resume a body and disclose myself I am one of the people who spend their lives sitting on their haunches in drawing rooms and studies I grow gradually feeble and fret fuller I am a boy once more in tall hat and gloves walking wearily among crowds of well-dressed hopelessly well-dressed people up and down a certain promenade I enter the young prostitutes chamber where he is arranging the photographs of fashionable beauties and favorite companions and stay with him we are at ease and understand each other I dance at the village feast in the upper room of a public my partner shows me the steps and figures the elderly Harper so noble and dignified companies his sons fiddle or goes round to collect the pence but all the while his thoughts are with his only daughter in Australia the wheel turns but whatever it brings uppermost iswell 46 I lie Abed in illness and experience strange extensions of spirit I am close to those afar off and the present and near at hand are discounted I spent nights of pain and loneliness I dream of the beautiful life I go down to the sea with Fisher folk and spend chill nights on the great deep under the stars the Sun rises on faces round me of freedom and experience I see everywhere the old simple occupations the making and mending of nets the growing of flax and hemp the tending of gardens cattle the old sweet excuses for existence their meaning now partly understood the faith that grows in the open air and out of all honest work till it surrounds and redeems the soul the blacksmith blows up his fire he listens for the sound of the great heat he taps the glowing iron in advance of the blows of the striker and turns it deftly with the tongs the butter of roses bends among the low bushes with a quick motion he floats out the wood and vines the bud on the wild stalk the wire weaver stands at his loom working the treadles with his foot and throwing the shuttle with alternate hand the old coach body maker stands at his bench gray-haired worn thoughtful the young apprentice comes down whistling from the trimming shop to ask him a question the sunlight streams in broad shafts through the chinks of the blinds into the carpenter's shop with grizzled beard and hair and something of a stoop in his shoulders the governor stands penciling out a fresh job a tall young fellow sits astride of a door style cutting a mortise and a dab of light on the floor sends a reflection up in his arch humored face the bathers in the late Twilight almost dark advance naked under the trees by the waterside five or six together superb unashamed scarcely touching the ground the budding pens of love scorch all over me my skin is too tight I am ready to burst through it a flaming girdle is round my middle eyes hair lips hands waist thighs Oh naked mad tremors in the dark feeding pasturing flames Oh soul spreading spreading impalpable sunlight behind the sunlight the tall thin gray bearded man I meet daily in the street with lined brow silent full of experience the stout matron in the greengrocers shop loquacious clear-eyed with clear indubitable voice the thick side hot coarse fleshed young bricklayer with the strap around his waist the young printer but he has a wife and family at home with large dreamy projecting eyes going absent miles away over his work thinking of Swedenborg and the dance of atoms and angels the young woman at the refreshment bar her thick light-colored hair her well-formed features and the bored look in her eyes as she returns the shaft of the carefully dressed young man across the counter the military looking official at the door of the hotel the despondency of drink which he conceals beneath his loud-voiced smart exterior the ragged boy with rare intense eyes not to be misunderstood in amidst of much dirt and ignorance the soul through suffering and franchised exhaled here to shining like the sunlight redeeming justifying all it lights on the of a girl who has become a mother the ready doubt among her neighbors who was the father the stupid loving way in which he crams the child to her breast sitting on a stone by the fireside utterly oblivious of opinion the good-natured fair-haired tighten at work in the fields the little woman with large dark eyes who is so clever and managing among the poor and with their children the thin close-lipped frizz haired commercial traveller unworried walking long distances to save railway or coach fare well posted in all local information for fifty miles round his wife so comfortable and for thoughtful at home so evil tongue abroad and the bevy of red haired red cheeked girls well drilled in scrubbing and cooking and not without a veneer of accomplishments the railway lamp foremen tall strong fleet of foot with gentle voice lover of the fields and flowers going long walks Sundays or late evenings by moonlight sending the balance of his earnings to support his aged father and mother the bright sunny girl child with long beautiful hair envied of the other children and poignant blossoming lips and eyes the girl in the tobacconists shop her drooping lashes her taper fingers and provocative inimitable composure and all the time her mother is incurably dying The Hunchback cobbler young courted thinking incessantly of Jesus praying night and day for the gift of preaching the drunken father reeling home in the rain across country he has more than a mile to go singing cursing tumbling hands and knees in the mire his son following unbeknown at a little distance he had been watching a long time for his father outside the beer shop the late moon rising on the strange scene the hiccuped oaths of the old man through the Silence of the night end of section 7 section 8 of towards democracy by Edward Carpenter this LibriVox recording is in the public domain 47 lo I touch you softly yearning I touch you and pass on dreaming the dream of the soul slow disentanglement sharp cut thin-lipped sad scholastic plane featured unembarrassed affectionate and you beautiful careless boy and you strange eternal anxious mother face how shall I say what I have to say how shall I speak the word which sums up all words that are spoken how shall I speak that for which the moon and the stars and running waters and the universe itself subsist to speak it which if it could be uttered in a word there were no need of all these things Oh death take me away take me away kindly death lead me forth lead me through the entire universe let me pass hold me back I say no longer for I am tired I am sick of talking and I forbode other ways for I would be the dust and I would be the silver rays of the moon and the stars and the washing sound of the midnight sea and nourishing sweet air and running water for the lips of them that I choose to pass to put on the invisible cap to run round about the world unseen and I will be the plain unguarded facts of life with continual nearness 'as the train arriving at the station shall not be nearer or more solid with the lifting and transporting of boxes and goods nor the grasp of the handles to them that open and shut the doors I will be the ground underfoot and the common clay the plowman shall turn me up with his plow share among the roots of the twitch in the sweet smelling furrow the Potter shall mould me running his finger along my whirling edge we will be faithful to one another he and I the bricklayer shall lay me he shall tap me into place with a handle of his trowel and to him I will utter the word which with my lips I have not spoken 48 I arise and pass I am a spirit passing by a light air on the hills saying unto you in death there is peace out of all mortal suffering out of the bruised and broken heart out of tears tears falling scene falling inward and unseen out of the withering flame of desire and out of all illusion my spirit exhaled floats free my brother and sister for you over the world eternally joy oh joy for you too beyond this visible through the gates of mortal passion and suffering for the exhaled spirit for you too beyond this broken dream this bitter waking in tears something how can I tell it which I have seen which I might perhaps give you and yet which I cannot give you but in me weights also for you oh how long something that I have promised I give you the token faithfully when you recognize and return it shall you have that you desire I am the light air on the hills deny me not by desire which was not satisfied is satisfied and yet can never be satisfied I pass and pass and pass from the hills I creep down into the great city fresh and pervading to all the streets I pass him I touch and her I touch and you I touch I can never be satisfied I who desired one give myself to all I who would be the companion of one become the companion of all companions the lowest and who knows me not him I know best and love best the child of the suffering heart I take my arms pass under his shoulders and under the hollow of his thighs his arm lies around my neck my lips yearn close to his on my breast at length he slumbers peacefully and long the blind and aged woman descends the steps living to the basement of the tall London house the east wind blows bitter with dust along the street she feels along the wall and for the door and timidly knocks I cannot see who opens the door but it is slammed immediately in her face I take her by the hand and speak words to her and her sightless eyes are as though they saw once more [Music] once I walked the world of rocks and grass of space and time of ambition and action and could imagine no other for I was in that one now I roam through other fields and have the freedom of worlds innumerable and am familiar where be or was darkness and silence 49 I arise and pass in her tall windowed sitting room alone the Setting Sun casts long shafts of light across the path and beneath the trees were knee-deep in grass a milk-white calf is browsing in her tall windowed sitting room with his antique peer glasses and profuse handsome ornaments alone the old Dowager sits her silver gray hair lies smooth under lace cap lace and silk are her dress her thin fingers are well-stocked with rings lonely is the great house her old life and the voices of children have long passed away she goes to the window to pass the time and through the glass looks out upon the still landscape after a while she turns and rings a bell a tall young footman appears her voice is quiet and gentle as she gives her order and flexible still with intelligence very taking with her old-fashioned refinement or her manners but in a moment what she requires is there and she is alone again everything is done for her into her chair once more she resigns herself to knit and Anton Makassar without how peaceful the scene the crisp sound of browsing the liquid blue violet eyes of the white calf her budding horns her sweet breath her muscular tongue encircling the Tufts of grass the impatient sideway thrust of her head with which she tears them the fearlessness with which she gives her head to be caressed and hugged by the little girl just come down from the farm the son withdraws his Ray's the many shadows are merged in one the sweet odour of the white Campion comes floating and of the wild roses in neighboring hedgerows and a the distant bean fields Twilight comes and dusk comes and the height of the sky lifts and lifts the last of the long daylight fades over the fields and by the hedgerows and along the sprawling suburban streets of London the last of the long daylight fades over the roof of the high opera house late gray and ghostly in contrast with the myriad twinkling lamps below by those within unthought-of it fades where amid a blaze of light and Colour elate to her full height drawn tear upon tear of faces thousands of eyes confronting and saturated with the excitement of the moment every vein in her beautiful body bounding the prima donna lifts clear and unfaltering in the finale her splendid voice and retires amid a storm of flowers the sword goes out to so alone in the morning the early October morning so beautiful and calm the flanks of the clods are creeping with thin vapour and the little cops alongside the field is full of white trailing veils of it while now like a flood the rising yellow sunlight pours in among the brambles and under the square oak boughs and splashes through in great streaks of light over the plowed land beautiful is the morning alone over the field to and fro to and fro with ample alternate hand sweep he goes at every step right and left the grain broadcast flies in a glittering shower with the Sun and the earth four companions with brown arms and face and dazzle littered eyes thick booted untiring all day the sower goes sowing what in due time shall become daily bread in the mouths of thousands the caravan has halted it is the hour of prayer the tents are already pitched on his carpet the old Sheikh kneels upright his arms and eyes uplifted above the living blue breathless miracle bends the sky the others are around him with their faces buried in the sand the camels are tethered a few paces off his voice ascends by the doors of the tents from the scanty fires just lighted three columns of smoke perfectly straight also ascend that is all the smoke creeps upward and is lost continually in the blue his voice who prays creeps upward and is lost around spreads silent with loose stones and a few weeds the desert above the sky the sky fifty I arise and pass after 80 years having been once like the rest a little vacant eyed child in his mother's arms having dense lived and toiled and enjoyed much hither and thither over the earth now being very weary and day after day and week after week growing more and more weary all all old interests refusing for death longing the old lawyer lies down to sleep it is but for an hour or two Death Comes not yet the leaves still tremble in the evening wind the clouds in solemn transformation float on voices of children call in the garden below the last few miles the old familiar country the well-known roads and garden lands yet no glance there on the strange immortal instinct pressing the veiled figure always in front beckoning now at this time the creatures of the forest to their lairs retiring await the approach of night the great mountains stand in awe amid the hush of their own waters Twilight fades and the Stars once more appear deep under dead leaves in the wood or buried in the earth the baby fly white and unformed the two dark specks which will be its eyes just appearing in his oak spangled cradle sleeps with their mother played it in a ball of dry grass warm and soft the young field mice like quiet or chirp nosing for their food the pools of water are full of creatures that cannot rest to the starlit surface rising they spread wings and fly forth into the fields of air in heaven world by resistless tradition and necessity descending from God knows when Jupiter the great planet swims and swathes itself wondrous in clouds prophetic heav'n bends above the earth opens disclosing innumerable births beneath he lies weary slumbering for a moment the pen the desk the half-finished letter are there the gas makes a slight singing noise overhead solid walls and stones grow transparent and penetrable the earth and all that is in it fade and recede to make way for the traveler 51 i arise and pass an unfinished house standing at the edge of a field is burning and the roof has caught first one vast sheet of flame ascends spiral in the night and casts its glare upon thousands of faces in the street and fields below low the wonderful colors of the flame the pitchy night above the dazzling white and red mixed with the greens and blue greens of the burning metals and the great twisted column of tawny smoke with red sparkles flying on the wind low with strange light cast upon the wall of full foliage Elms and far more wonderful than all at their feet the crowd of living faces the mad pushing sweating crowd the flushed eager faces dominated all controlled and riveted by that flaming sign holy holy holy night and flame night and flame entering in entering Oh arched wonder of many eyes through the visible into the invisible holy holy holy night and flame entering in and one with you treading softly through the myriad marvelous chambers to dwell to dwell for months years to transfuse enlarge to touch with wonder ardour exultation to be remembered afterwards years and years perhaps upon his bed by that child there the Jets of flame through the roof the strange wreathing smoke the solemn dark of the sky the bravery of the firemen the thrill of the falling timbers to mix with the yearnings of the growing lonely boy to be a strange symbol burning in his heart to fire the slumbering train in some compressed girls soul of adventurous resolve to mingle with the fears of motherhood at last to merge and become indistinguishable in each one of these to merge night and flame leaving out not one holy holy holy and lo the crowd still standing and now out of all two alone by the curbstone in the forefront of the crowd a man a navy with his hands clasp in front of him on the breast of his little son the boy timid standing between his father's feet pressing back against his legs with his own little hands the great hands clasping the to equal child like with parallel upward eyes by the flame riveted their rapt unconscious demeanor the strong likeness between them and the meanings apart which the wonderful roaring just stick elating flame in the night signifies secretly to each end of section eight section 9 of torts democracy by Edward carpenter this LibriVox recording is in the public domain [Music] 52i arise and pass with struggles and strange exhausting birth Lee penis with long intervals of sleep when it's all over with long long sweet sleep with the unwashed wet of birth of love still upon me with the clinging of the love of men and women with the sweat of night long companions with the bruised sweetness of love with sleep sleep with the wine of life and death with kisses given and received with the reaching of arms round neck and shoulder and the answer of quiet eyes with nakedness unashamed with divine comradeship and laughter with the enclosing shadow of death far lost in daring outposts on the verge of the unknown with soldiership and armor unremitted exultant with childhood and the least trifle content with eternal nowness with perfected carelessness with night day rain sun winter summer morning evening solitude pain pleasure and the looking forth of innumerable faces with chastity and ascendancy with invulnerability and superhuman power with unchastity and effusion with live clinging threads of love reaching down to the remotest time with the endless journey begun with trades by sea and land simple food coarse clothing common features with the breath of the common air and the Freemasonry of the old crafts all over the world shaggy coat shakings revolts rejection of accepted things travels disappearances reappearances Swimming's away Oblivion's arising again on earth irresistible to supreme master e to savagery and the Wildwoods with unfettered step to rocks and hanging branches to the dens of the animals to wind and Sun glowing shining through and I through them to evade and arise with joy over the world democracy born again into heaven over the mountain peaks and the Seas in the unfathomable air screaming with shouts of joy hurling the nations with her breath into heaven arising and passing I arise and pass dreaming the dream of the soul slow disentanglement 53 where you are where the fire light flickers about your room and the wind moans in the window and the railway whistle over suburban roofs sounds hollow through the night where you sit alone and your thoughts spread making a great space about you where you go for that early morning with your bass of trusty tools and your shadow shoots long before you down the frosty sparkling road where you return that evening weary and out of humour with your life I dream the dream where you open your eyes upon the world and the beauty of it is upon you like the touch of beloved fingers or the still flame burns in your soul hidden away from the lightest breath of curious man or the fire of consecration burns yet the world closes in at last and the lamp grows dim and you lie like one half dead of the bitter wounds of the faces of men and the taunts of existence I dream the dream I dream the dream of the soul slow disentanglement where you bend ankle deep in mud all day in the rice plantations were a few halfpence and the Sun sails on slow slow over the steamy land where you walk following the old employee shepherding sheep in the sweet crisp air of the Highlands where you stand pale and worn eyed in the gloomy north amid the hot smell of machinery and the wicked scream of wheels where you stand adjusting the threads making the same answering movement of the hand for the millionth time where you lie wedged in under a coal seam working by the light of a tallow dip stuck in clay or grind size all day bending over or race your wheel with the racing steel where you sit high up on the fragrant mountains of salon with a great flood of moonlight at your feet leaning your soul out from the verandah to the slow lifting and floating of palm fronds in the exquisite breeze and memories come trooping back upon you like the clouds of small yellow butterflies that along your coasts between the sand and the sea be annually up against the wind where you recline by your campfire in the African wild watching the moonlight dances of the natives the fantastic leaps of the dancer the rhythmical hand clapping of the spectators where you drop down the river in the Sun past the dreaded mud banks and wildernesses of mangroves I dream the dream [Music] 54 where you sit in your armchair by the hearth sleeping long and long where you wake to look back upon your life lying hushed below you like one who looks back from the summit of a mountain and the children that come to you in the morning have gone from you at evening dusk and the lesson of unfulfilled longing is yours and of the inn flow of immortality where they go out over the earth where the children of the universal mother go and the wind carries them over the sea blowing them into all lands where they flow through the straights and narrows and over the great oceans of the earth dwelling for nights together among the white leaping crests under the stars where strange faces meet under other slanting Suns amid new scenes and colors were light encounters dark and in their meeting glance lie now social ideals and civilizations slumbering for the mother of them all sits dreaming where the young poet peers in by moonlight through the bars of the tomb of Dante and turns away with a silent prayer were the artists with easel and palette sit swathed in coats upon a hillside watching the untroubled dawn for the old Hindu feeling the approach of death leaves his family and retires to a hut in the jungle there to spend his last days in prayer and solitude were royalty dwells lonely in spacious chambers or moves along corridors past scarlet coated footmen were young and old at Eventide in the dreamy flicker of firelight sits silent or go away wandering in thought after the brother the son and lover of their dreams following quickly softly with each and kissing the sacred footsteps through the dark where the young mother prays for hours bending over the face of her sleeping child with a young man dreams all night of the face of his newfound friend and the kisses of his lips where the river glides down by night past the great city broadening to the sea I dreamed the dream the wind blows up fresh and cold where the waves are slapping against Chetty red and green lights skim rapidly over the water the cold light of the half moon stands overhead breaking its way through combed fleece clouds the horizon stretches misty white like the edge of an ice bond see the moon pushes her way for a moment through the clouds to look down upon the still scene of human toil and suffering the wind blows up keen against those who still linger on the jetty kingly it blows away over the waste sea and wraps itself around a thousand solitary watchers of the deep on the wind I ride and dream the dream of the soul slow disentanglement 55 I have passed away and entered the gate of heaven I am absolved from all torment all is well with me a tiny infant am I once more leaning out from my mother's arms as one leans from a balcony but the world hangs flat before me like a painted curtain the Sun and the moon and men's faces are all alike this is my dream The Sound of Music comes calling to me calling calling listening I lean forward with open mouths and far distant gaze and am profoundly still let who looks upon me see with his own eyes my dark souls myriad reawakening I am a wild cat crouching at night and the angle of a bow I am Arjun reasoning on the battlefield with Krishna learning the lessons of divine knowledge I am a teacher scanning the faces of those who sit opposite to me all is well I labor all day in the drizzle with pick and shovel the smell of fire I strike from the rock pleases me I returned home tired and wet in the early dusk too mighty I am one of a rustic party of actors in the old farm parlor we rehearse our parts with shouts of laughter I go into the cowshed last thing at night with my lantern to see that all is well I am a shepherd on the breezy Hills the wholesome aromatic odours of the grass transfused me my sheep graze on and on through the noonday I lie in the Sun and think and speak of little beside use and tups I stand in the chamber of death and gaze upon the suave larval form the solid world recedes around it through the just open window come the cries of hawkers and the creak of cartwheels I laugh and chat with the other girls and women in the edge tool warehouse I run home in the evening to my old mother and to prepare the dinners for next day the din of the riveting shop goes on round me I hate the bully red-faced master coming on his rounds with his insulting voice and answer him not murderous thoughts haunt my mind I plot with others to murder the captain on board ship I am satisfied with the deed and experience no remorse it is off the coast of China I go ashore afterwards and spend the night at a sing-song shop all is well the least action as well as the greatest the beautiful and the deformed are alike beautiful I am happy now and not tomorrow and am absolved for motives on the northernmost point of Australia decent in my single Cowrie shell I stand the white man comes ashore in his boat from the great ship and gives me some old hoop iron and I give him a wooden Lance's in return I am a long eyed Japanese in the shadow of the sacred thicket I lie with a great seated image of Buddha hollow within for a shrine breaks above me against the blue sky the sharp shadows lie under his sleepy lids and soft mouth smiling inwardly I see on his forehead the sacred spot and from between his feet the emblematic lotus springing all is well in the shadow of the thicket I lie spreading my fevered limbs to the cool breeze bruising their unslaked passion against the stony earth in the cool shadow I lie and gaze at his face I know so well and through the immortal calm of it the spirit of the holy one steals upon me the fever of life departs I stand near the door of my cottage busy with the weeks washing thinking of my husband in the doorway to and fro my baby swings in the little seat he has made petulant soft wafts of spring air steel in this warm February morning I am very happy I am very happy by the door of my own little house at last I stand entranced I look out upon the world and know not which way to go o world you have been very gentle to me strangely as to the dead your beauty comes to me now little house where I have lived so long I thank you too I know well that you are different from what you appear disembodied I cry I cry over the earth I shake the sleepers in their tombs with unutterable joy o arise o air and elements break forth into singing Great Sea washing the shores of Earth o earth of countless the hour of your disclosure is at hand the bounds of mortality at length are passed I arise and pass once more I travel forth into all lands nothing detains me any longer by the ever beautiful coastline of human life in all climates and countries wandering on a stranger unworried I meet the old faces I come never away from home I lift the latch of the cottage door and the place I love is laid for me for supper I depart yet never to depart again laws and limitations fade time and distance are no more no bars can hold me no chamber shut me in on those that bear me to the grave I descend in peace the arched doors of the eyebrows of innumerable multitudes open around me new heavens I see and the earth may new because of them I will stop here then I will not leave the earth after all I am content and need go no further and was this oh love the cause of your so long aching that you might have the added that you might enter in at last and be at rest end of section 9 [Music] section 10 of towards democracy by Edward carpenter this LibriVox recording is in the public domain [Music] 56 slowly on you to the meanings the light sparkles on water Tufts of weed in winter the least things dandelion and grounsell have you seen the wild bees nest in the field the cells the grubs the transparent white baby bees turning brown hairy the young bees beginning to fly raking the moss down over the disturbed cells the parasites have you seen the face of your brother or sister have you seen the little robin hopping and peering under the bushes have you seen the Sun Rise or set I do not know I do not think that I have when your unquiet brain has ceased to spin its cobwebs over the calm and miraculous beauty of the world when the air and the sunlight shall have penetrated your body through and through and the earth and sea have become part of it when at last like a sheath long concealing the swelling green chute the love of learning and the regard for elaborate art which manners dress or anything rare or costly whatever shall drop clean off from you on your body for to this it must inevitably return has become shining and transparent before you in every part however deformed then o blessed one these things also transparent possibly shall surrender themselves the least things shall speak to you words of deliverance the stones are anywhere and everywhere the temple roof is the sky the materials are the kettle boiling on the fire the bread in the oven the washing dolly the axe the grave lock the product is God and the little kitchen where you live the shelves the pewter the nightly lamp the fingers and faces of your children a finished and beautiful transparency of your own body 57 I saw the cow gave birth to her firstborn calf I saw the beautiful helpless creature laid under her nose I saw the calm woman who sprinkled the young thing with meal and tended the exhausted mother I see the many women who managed cattle well and gardens and understand the breeding of sheep I see the noble and natural women of all the earth I see their well-formed feet and fearless ample stride their supple strong frames and attitudes well braced and beautiful on those that are with them long love and wisdom descend everything that is near them seems to be in its place they do not pass by little things nor are afraid of big things but they love the open air and the sight of the sky in the early morning blessed of such women are the children and blessed are they in childbirth the open air and the Sun and the moon and the running streams they love all the more passionately for the sake of that which lies sleeping within them 58 recurved and clothes lie the little feet and hands close as in the attitude of sleep folds the head and the little lips are hardly parted the living mother flesh folds round in darkness the mother's life is an unspoken prayer her body a temple of the holy one I am amazed and troubled my child she whispers at the thought of you I hardly dare to speak of it you are so sacred when I feel you leap I do not know myself anymore I am filled with wonder and joy if any injury should happen to you I will keep my body pure very pure the sweet air will I breathe and pure water drink I will stay out in the open hours together that my flesh may become pure and fragrant for your sake holy thoughts will I think I will brood in the thought of mother love I will fill myself with beauty trees and running brook shall be my companions and I will pray that I may become transparent that the Sun may shine and the moon my beloved upon you even before you are born fifty nine out of night and nothingness a body appears the threads of a thousand past ages run together in it out of its loins and the look of its eyes a thousand ages part their way into the future eyes out of which I see ears through which I hear formed in my mother's womb in silence mother of mine walking the earth no more to me closer than ever out of all tears suffusing light over the world equal with God for whose sake night and day evermore our sacred body by which I ascend and know myself mysteries of life and death slowly parting and transforming around me Oh glad not for one year or two but for how many thousands I out of deep and infinite peace salute you the doctor does not give health but the winds of heaven happiness does not proceed by chance nor is got by supplication but is inevitable wherever the master is doubts part aside I hear grown and bearded men shouting in the woods for joy shouting singing with the birds I hear the immense chorus over all the world of the return of joy come my friend in the still autumn morning while the Sun is yet low upon the hills among the dead leaves come walk with me those and the like of those that have been my companions are with you also and shall be to all time I give you but a hint and a word of commendation I open a door outwards the gentle and the stormy winds the clouds sailing in heaven the plow stilts the boat tiller sitting at dinner with the winters sun looking in at the open door natural men and women common as uncor Drakh around you love granted or not granted the companionship of the dead the savage eternal peaks the solitary signals Walt Whitman Jesus of Nazareth your own self distantly deriding you these are always with you have you doubted it is well but now you shall forget your doubts have you suffered it is good to suffer but soon you shall suffer no longer have you looked at the sky and the earth and the long busy streets and thought them dead of all poetry and beauty it is you have been ill night to death but be at peace life shall surely return to you I have seen your struggles your long wakeful nights I have sat by you I have heard the voice which calls you come with me here is rest here is peace I give you a little while by the edge of this wood sitting I with you then to depart never yet to depart again words unspoken yet wafted over all lands through all times eternal no more mine than yours I give them again to the wide embracing air happily a little breath for you to breathe to enter scarcely perceived into your body a little time to dwell transforming within you happily mementos indications broken halves of ancient changeless symbols eternal possessions treasures incorruptible of love which changes not to be duly presented again the broken halves to be joined I a child sitting at your feet content the odour of dead leaves all around are walking with you your comrade through the night often we lean and touch each other's lips as we go or very old and near and dear to death are you sure you know me when you look upon me behold a mystery these eyes these lips this hair these loins see you me in them you shall see me where they are not long looking the face of the world shall change surely by the edge of the little wood I will come and sit with you all riches promised and far more I give to you have you used the summer well then the winter shall be beautiful to you have you made good use of life then death shall be exceeding glorious all this day we will go together the Sun shall circle overhead our shadows swing round us on the road the winter sunshine shall float wonderful promises to us from the hills the evening see us in another land the night ever insatiate of love we will sleep together and rise early and go forward again in the morning wherever the road shall lead us in solitary places or among the crowd it shall be well we shall not desire to come to the end of the journey nor consider what the end may be the end of all things shall be with us sixty this is my trade teach me yours and I will teach you mine are you a carpenter a Mason a grower of herbs and flowers a breaker of horses a wheelwright boat builder engine tender dock yard laborer do you take in washing or sewing do you rock the youngest in the cradle with your foot while you knit stockings for the elder ones it is well weaning yourself from external results learn the true purpose of things wherever the sea and the land are is my trade and it has been known since the eldest time the ancient mysteries and Oracle's hinted at it the venerable sages of India knew it and men and women who walked this earth before all history in the remotest stars it is exactly the same as here and in all the circles of intelligences whether they dwell in fire or water or in the midst of what is solid or in the thinnest vacuum many an old woman sitting by her cottage door is far more profoundly versed in it than I am many a fisherman pouncing on crabs along the shores of the Mediterranean has in it long ago served his apprenticeship if you think or desire by coming with me to know more or be better than these you mistake me and what I have to tell you learning and superiority are of no use in the face of all this they depart much as they came but to come near to understanding the use of materials is divine and he that has never despised a weaker or more ignorant than himself is nearest to this many are the roads but there is one end to which they all lead there are many profitable trades but there is one whose profits are past all reckoning in of section 10 [Music] section 11 of towards democracy Edward carpenter this LibriVox recording is in the public domain 61 hand-in-hand for an hour I sit with you in the great garden of time equals we possessors and enjoyers ask no more than simply to be this our equal of all others that were or shall be itself perfect the other hours as they come or go perfect meeting once to meet often and often again is not the whole garden ours we shall not forget we shall not hasten or delay from this day it is not so much we that change as the hours that glide past us each bends low as it passes with a gift earth Kings on their Thrones faintly foreshadowed this the old myths and legends of heaven were the indistinct dreams of the everlasting peace of the soul 62 and you to ye hours of suffering and warfare grim unrest we confront each perfect we contain you storms and darkness surging around we have seen round you hours of pain and darkness within evil conscience and heavy burdens of concealment hours of black and obstinate desire eyes turning a swerve trembling guilty tongue hungry mortal hours caught in the cleave of your jaws I deny you not far from it I welcome you you are my friends as good as any I give you equal places with the rest if not better for what indeed should I understand if you had not me each beautiful countless myriads to be known over the hills and green plains of eternity pasturing forever widening mortal immortal swift-footed slow-footed oh ye ours and desires you are all mine my heard by beauties my glossy supple with arched necks my gentle and caressing my wild fierce passionate divine satanic there is room and plenty for you all o beautiful creatures not because sometimes you show your teeth at each other will I disown you not if you should all turn upon one to rend him will I cast that one out never so black or ungainly be he Avant over the hills with lightning speed fly tossing your nostrils but know that I easily out speed you all you cannot delude or escape me wild herd be getting and be getting innumerable progeny all mine see if to my chariot at length harnessed I will not drive you irresistible and triumphant through all the kingdoms of space sixty-three beautiful is the winter by the sea the grey waves come rolling with locks tossed back by the north wind in his hot on the beach the fisherman cooks his dinner the clock that belongs to the herring boat ticks against the wall the drift nets are mended the boat is overhauled and repaired the boat lanterns and the pump are painted out on the great deep the balance and plunge goes on the sails steadies in the wind the land and well-known points fade the circle of water completes itself beautiful is the winter inland the wind and wild clouds with rain rush over the world the valleys are full of the sound of dreams the farmer cleans out his ditches and drains and mends the footpaths across his fields the turnip pit is completed and the apples and potatoes are picked over in the storeroom the snow descends upon the young blade of corn the soft fingered flakes wrap all the world in white frost seals the earth in silence he stands by the door of the house place at night the moon leans out and the stars and the great planets from heaven Orion hunts with his dogs in the morning the field fairs and starlings go by in flights do I ask of you perfections do you think that winter is perhaps less perfect in summer or that there is not perfection everywhere for the soul casts its light be not careful about perfections I declare to you the day shall come when everything shall be perfect to you to be ungainly or deformed shall after all be no hindrance your ignorance and rags shall not avail for a disguise past your own futility and vanity you shall walk unfettered and just gaze upon them as you go by if learning and skill admit you to wonders ignorance and awkwardness shall give you entrances equally or more desirable take care I have warned you before how you touch these words with curious intellect come not near lest I utterly destroy you but come with bold heart and true and careless and they shall bless you beyond imagination I do not turn you back from self-seeking on the contrary I know that you shall never rest till you have found yourself if you seek it in money fame and the idle gratification of inordinate organs and that is all very well for a time but you will have to do better than that if you seek it in duty goodness renunciation they also are very well for a time but you will do better sixty-four beautiful is the figure of the lusty full-grown groom on his superb horse the skin of the animal is saturated with love radiant health Oh kisses of Sun and wind tall fir trees and moss covered rocks Oh boundless joy of nature on the mountaintops coming back at last to you wild songs inside of the sea wild dances along the sands glances of the Risen moon echoes of old old refrains coming down from an imagined a rolling through the air superb prophetic spirit of man pulse of divine health equalizing the universe vast over all the world expanding spirit oh joy of the liberated soul finished purpose and acquittal of civilization daring all things light step life held in the palm of the hand o Swift and eager delight of battle fierce passion of love destroying and destroying the body eternal and glorious war liberation the soul like an eagle from gaping wounds and death rushing forth screaming into its vast and eternal heaven see the Divine Mother goes forth with her babe all creation circles round God dwells once more in a woman's womb friend goes with friend flesh Cleaves to flesh the path that rounds the universe Oh everyday sweet and delicious food kisses to the lips of sweet-smelling fruit and bread milk and green herbs strong welded muscles quick healing glossy skin body for kisses all over radiant health to breath oh joy to sleep never enough to be expressed for the taste of fruit ripening warm in the Sun for the distant sight of the deep liquid sea for the sight of the naked bodies of the bathers bathing by the hot sea banks the pleasant consciousness of those who are unashamed the glance of their eyes the beautiful proud step of the human-animal on the sand for the touch of the air on my face or creeping over my unclothed body for the rustling sound of it in the trees and the appearance of their tall stems springing so lightly from the earth joy joy and thanks forever 65 for the face of the farm lad who came and sat beside me the handfuls of peas that he offered me for the taste of their juicy sweet pods the pressure of the earth against me as I lay on it the light since riding on it of tremendous forces charity me onward for the like sense in my will and actions of being borne along oh the splendid wind careening over earth an ocean the Sun darting between the great white clouds oh the lifting of arms to nature heaven wrapped around one's body the unflagging pleasure of food the crisp and toothsome growths of the soil drafts of running water in summer the evenings by the fire in winter the ease after labour the steady sleepy heat the sleepy flicker on the wall the presence of others in the room for the voices of children for the beautiful faces and ever more beautiful appearing of boughs I meet in the doorway or meals the mortal father mother sister brother faces for the glorified face of him I love the long days out alone together in the woods the night's superb of comradeship and love oh joy returning morn noon and night day long as in a dream walking over earth enchanted waking deep midnight out of sleep in the ocean of joy lo the beautiful surface the rippling of waves the moon shining down deep deep drafts of all that life can give gone into feed the flame joy joy and thanks forever Oh burning behind all worlds immortal essences flames of this ever consuming universe never consumed to laugh and laugh with you and of our laughter shake forth creation wonderful wave after wave clouds rain when day and night the sea by night in storms in the morning over the hills for grief and joy for solitude and companionship for the birth of babes and the putting away of the husks of the feeble and aged in the ground for the great processions of the seasons over the earth and the dead lying below and the dead rising again in the pure translucent air to begin a new existence with unutterable joy bursting outwards from them beyond all mortal bounds with shouts and pians into the blue ether of God joy joy and thanks forever and for the strange individual decree of each one the daily hunger and thirst after sympathy ever new for the pleasant putting forth of affection and for the excess for prostrate unspeakable love for the pleasant moods of the soul for the finite masterly enjoyment of the world and for the painful moods for the vicious agony and the vast dark after death of desire for the transcendent pouring and pouring of the soul out into other worlds for the tragic moments of life and for the long same stretches of the commonplace for the wonderful looming rise upon one of the great arch of death as one approaches it for the dim perception of the infinite stretches beyond for the final deep abiding sense of rest in thee for the touch of thy self growing continually out of everything more actual star like perfect and for all experience joy joy and thanks for ever end of section 11 | Priceless Audiobooks | UCly1zcKPGzGW9wZMCZodWOA | 2017-12-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 14,531 | 78,228 |
ff824jJKYjY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ff824jJKYjY | SHTF News - Wars, Disasters, and Extreme World Events (Oct 31, 2016) | the RS 28 sore mat dove Satan to buy natal has been widely reported to have a top speed of seven kilometers as second in an expected range of nearly 10,000 kilometers this would allow Moscow to attack European cities as well as reaching cities in America's west and east coasts and it's also reported that missile could destroy an area that size of friends sport Texas the summit has been designed to outfox anti-missile shield systems according to the Daily Mail the Russian defence ministry plans to put the sama into service in late 2018 Russia's as NATO's enhancement of military presence on its eastern side will not remain unanswered Russia's permanent representative to the Alliance said NATO's activities are clearly aimed at military force projection in the Black Sea and Eastern Europe Alexander grishko added that the biggest military buildup along Russia's borders since the Cold War has no anti-terrorism value and is not bolstering European security rather it's creating additional obvious risks he also warned of NATO and the United States active exploration of the black sea waters with multifunctional combat platforms which have a serious strike and miss our potential I do our TV Red Alert in a soviet-style nuclear bunker for a couple of Russians are racing to prevent a catastrophic strike on the United States nuclear bombs oh my gosh in one hour the aim of the quest the latest gaming craze in Moscow is to find the nuclear launch codes the activator hitters red button it's already been pressed by a mad Russian general of course is complete fantasy but amid the current tensions with Russia nor feels a little unsettling be worried that something like this could happen in real life okay I'm not no I'm not thinking about it I'm worried because it's a very stupid information for both side and I know that normal people in all over the world they don't want any work his world we are anonymous for the last two months we have been consistently reporting on a possible global conflict world war three between the United States and its allies in the west and Russia and its allies in the east the dispute on the South China Sea has severely damaged the United States relations with the People's Republic of China after the permanent court of arbitration in The Hague ruled that China's nine-dash line claimed in the South China Sea and its land reclamation activities on islets are invalid and unlawful the United States has been preparing to sail in the area under a so-called freedom of navigation principle this has angered the Chinese in August the Chinese Defense Minister Cham want one told his country's citizens to prepare for what he described as the people's war at sea mr. want one was referring directly to the United States planned provocation under the pretext of freedom of navigation China has since vowed to take all necessary measures available to protect its sovereignty over the South China Sea this petilla of eight ships headed by the Admiral Kuznetsov has headed down the eastern coast of the UK and of course into the english channel into the dover straits the norwegian air force filmed them when they were off the Shetland Islands those are some pretty great pictures and then locals and media gathered to watch them in Dover and of course they could see them off the coast because it's just 21 miles wide that stretch of water that was earlier on Friday and of course they're being watched very closely by ships from the navies of a number of different countries as the UK's HMS Duncan of course which has been man marking early flotilla according to the defense secretary the Norwegians the finish they all have ships in the area that are watching the progress these destroyers and several NATO vessels and planes as well extraordinary display of Russian military power just a few miles off the British coast one Moscow newspaper called it an armada and it's chosen route straight down the English Channel it's likely to have been chosen deliberately the warships could have gone round the north coast of Scotland but this was the route that sent a powerful message one which a former Royal Navy admiral said was a wake-up call since the end of the Cold War we've allowed our capabilities to decline and I also think our skills have declined as well we need to get back into the game of actually countering the Russians whenever they seek to coerce by the European nations or project power like they have done with this task group the task group will be reinforcing what's already a big Russian presence in Syria today the EU blocked by Italy stopped short of threatening sanctions against Russia for what it called atrocities like the bombing of civilians in aleppo while Moscow's ambassador to Brussels denied that this was all a massive demonstration of hard power Syrian rebels say they're pushing forward with a huge offensive aimed at breaking a weeks-long government siege on Eastern another world war at least 15 civilians have been killed in heavy shelling and suicide car bomb attacks among them a number of children according to the uk-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights over a hundred people offered to have been injured since the operation began on Friday morning Russian news agency Interfax later reported the Defense Ministry had asked President Vladimir Putin's authority to assume airstrikes against militants in the east of the city following a tenday fierce fighting on the front lines of eastern anything even as opposition fighters launched a life skill offensive on the government-held west of the city and number of groups are trying to break the government siege of a position how there is knowledge ahead Chen we are fighting the regime forces on every front in the East to ensure they don't reinforce their colleagues in the west haven until recently Russian and Syrian air strikes had killed hundreds in the east of Aleppo these are posing those attacks and russia says it won't restart them just yet but the opposition fighters say they are not taking any chances here children help them burn tires and keep on replenishing the fires the smoke is meant to obscure rebel positions from the view of Syrian and Russian pilots the offensive has been weeks in the making the rebels have brought with them plenty of firepower hundreds of rockets targeting government positions but they have just something as powerful and new unity and suicide car bombs in numbers far greater than before serious fighting rages in the al-zahra neighborhood at northwestern Aleppo opposition fighters launched a counter-offensive on government our parts of the city on friday a syrian pro-rebel media announced on saturday rebels had taken the residential server of da here are a start kuraki commanders say ISIL militants south of nazo have been withdrawing north of the city taking hundreds of civilians with them NBC's Matt Bradley reports from Iraq Isis is going door-to-door in towns and villages south of Mosul Iraq second-largest city demanding the civilians move north marching them north into Mosul proper where they'll join some 1.2 million other civilians will no doubt be used as human shields this is what the associated press and reuters are both reporting this morning so troubling new development of what this indicates of anything is that Isis is planning on making a last stand in motion there had been some talking for that maybe Isis would work in the city and move west into Syria and take up positions in raka with civilians with their families with the fighters from in foreign areas who come to this area in order to defend the so-called caliphate that they declared two years ago this development shows that this could be a suicide that Iraqi forces pesh MERGA were based here in northern Iraq could be in for a long list during battle and take back mostly it's feared Iraq could be facing the worst humanitarian crisis in its history more than a million people in Mosul are expected to be impacted by the military campaign aimed at retaking the city from ISIL those who've already fled have been relocated in five camps near Mosul a groups are warning that facilities in the region could be overwhelmed element vario we left the village he says we went from house to house until we were able to escape the situation was difficult there were no facilities no electricity no water on life was very difficult my mom my [ __ ] was up here the Russian military is accused the us-led coalition of bombing civilians and airstrikes and muscle a nearby areas so you would score the military's General Staff said that more than 60 civilians have been killed and 200 wounded in such strikes over the past three days this guy said that he was jet struck a school for girls on Friday in the southern part of my soul and airstrikes targeted residential areas in several cities near muscle over the weekend Russian military official noted that dodge terrorists continue moving from iraq to syria over 300 terrorists have already arrived in the city of Daraa also are from a soul anti-government protests are once again erupting across Venezuela on Tuesday the opposition led Congress voted for impeachment proceedings against president Nicolas Maduro accusing him of violating the Constitution it's a symbolic gesture because the assembly has been stripped of most of its powers the opposition is upset the pro Maduro electoral council tossed out there recall referendum scuffles in Venezuela's opposition-led National Assembly as lawmakers debate whether to put president Nicolas Maduro on trial for violating democracy one of maduros allies tells the opposition it doesn't have the courage to go through with it the opposition says Maduro is undermining the legislature to strengthen his grip on power but either way Maduro socialist government says these hearings are meaningless because it's already declared congress illegitimate it's all about the economy protests like this one in San Cristobal accused Maduro of incompetents and economic mismanagement and public anger is growing after plans for an opposition referendum to remove Maduro from power was suspended graphene upon his foes accuse Maduro of ruining the economy as digit inflation and food shortages have people routinely skipping meals a neighboring Columbia peace talks between the government and the country's second-biggest rebel force postponed negotiations with the leftist National Liberation Army or eln or to start Thursday in Quito Ecuador the government wanted the rebels to first release an ex lawmaker they're holding hostage well this did not happen the peace talks were meant to coincide with an historic agreement with the country's biggest rebel group the FARC that Accord was narrowly rejected in a referendum this month overnight police held the ground where they clash with Native American protesters near cannonball North Dakota an army of 200 officers clearing demonstrators blocking a highway used to access a controversial oil pipeline under construction many of the protesters that would get right in the faces of the officers and say nasty things to them what links is North Dakota willing to go to defend a multi-billion dollar oil corporation many are raising questions now as to the level of force that was used on the activists RT correspondent Alexia our chefs ki has that report in London hundreds of people have march on Downing Street against police brutality and suspects in custody when do we want it we wanted cops a powerful earthquake is its central and southern Italy according to the US Geological Center the magnitude 6.6 quake centered six kilometers north of the town of north zone the temblor was also felt in the capital Rome many buildings of collapsed across central Italy including morsa emergency workers say a number people have been injured but no deaths have been reported so far a series of strong earthquake struck the area on Wednesday dramatic footage has emerged at the moment a road bridge collapsed on a busy road in Italy one man was killed and five others hurt in the incident in laconia milan on friday evening the bridge buckled when a truck weighing more than a hundred tons drove over it that sent the vehicle and concrete structure crashing down totally crushing one car below anas Italy's Road agency has blamed local authorities saying it called for the crossing to be closed hours before prosecutors have launched a criminal investigation my turkish president says his government is soon going to ask Parliament to reintroduce the death penalty project I Berlin made the announcement while addressing supporters who are marking the 97th anniversary of the Republic of Turkey foundation he said a capital punishment will be a proper retribution for those behind the failed mid-july coup he also rejected the West criticism of his post-coup crackdown saying that he does what his nation needs him to do not what the West dictates the death penalty was abolished in Turkey back in 2004 when Ankara was trying to muster support from European countries first a bit to join the European Union Italy's once trustworthy banking system appears to be on its knees the overall amount of non-performing loans or loans overdue held by Italian banks has reached an estimated value of 360 billion euros roughly a third of all the bad debt at European Union banks in simple words Italian banks are struggling to recuperate both the capital and interests of the money they have learnt in past years with excessive carelessness Italy's banks are neck-deep in non-performing loans now the question is how anyone can believe that no bankers saw it coming how policymakers and government regulators could not anticipate that lending money to individuals wanted to be entrepreneurs with no experience at all or on the condition they would buy the bank stocks would take the country's banking system to the brink of collapse it's towers above Frankfurt and for many a collapse is unthinkable Deutsche Bank's results have helped to lay those fears to some extent Germany's biggest lender made an unexpected but relatively small profit do 78 million euros it was thanks to a 14-percent rebound in bond trading but there's still no sign of a settlement with us justice authorities they're still in negotiations with the DOJ to try and bring the fine down from 14 billion dollars down something that it considers more reasonable at around five point six billion dollars which has been set aside now in litigation fees so it does what like we are seeing some progress here but I think people are still going to remain concerned CEO John cryin has vowed to redouble restructuring efforts he also wrote to staff warning the situation will stay difficult for a while this is a massively systemically important bank and not just in Germany but in the eurozone as a whole I think the other concern is well aside from the fact that the bank is so big and probably is too big to fail it does just reignite these concerns about the banking region in the euro area as a whole Greece is to receive three billion dollars of loans under a bailout agreement with its international lenders eurozone officials made the announcement in a statement saying the loan is an indication that the Greek are quote steadily making progress in reforming their country the disbursement of the newly approved financial aid marks the formal end of the first review of Greece's up to 86 billion euro bailout which was agreed to in August 2015 happening right now we are getting multiple reports of strange lights in the sky over the East Valley into our newsroom this video is just in showing an unidentified object flying over right now we are getting similar reports from queen creek and also globe at this hour in that video you can kind of see the lights out there in the distance witnesses say there are multiple lights as well as helicopters kind of circling that area right now once the other said that the lights appear to be moving north to south we have calls into law enforcement as well as Sky Harbor to find out exactly what those lights could be so far it's a mystery similar lights were reported in the sky last Friday phone is just ringing off the hook right now and of course Phoenix was the site of these famous flying lights back in the 1990's if you are here you probably would not forget those five lights flying in formation have always been controversial the military always said they were part of a routine flare exercise but a lot of people didn't buy that explanation it was the largest mass UFO sighting of all time these beautiful beasts lives are under threat and with them the rest of the world's wildlife the Earth's population of mammals birds fish and invertebrates has declined by more than sixty percent since 1970 hitting the world on cause for the first mass extinction of animal life since the dinosaurs a new report from the WWF and the Zoological Society of London paint a pretty grim picture of human impact on earth but UNESCO World Heritage Committee has passed a resolution that reaffirms the Islamic nature of the elapse our mosque compound in Jerusalem alberts the resolution also condemned Israel for acts against Islamic holy sites in the city it slams the quote aggressions by the Israeli occupation authorities the majority of the 21 nation committee voted for the resolution proposed by Palestinians and Jordanians the annual meeting was held in paris on wednesday israel representative to the UN has reacted angrily cooling the resolution craziness it claims that UN is trying to remove Jewish people from their historical homeland also following the vote trolo be recalled it's UNESCO representative to demonstrate dissatisfaction meanwhile the Palestinian ambassador to UNESCO has condemned Israel for politicizing religion | Ready To Go Survival | UC9pvT-aJbcUI3gtKPgWaIvQ | 2016-10-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,021 | 17,843 |
1bMrECpX6y8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1bMrECpX6y8 | Hindu denominations | Wikipedia audio article | Wikipedia audio article | hindu denominations are traditions within Hinduism centered on one or more gods or goddesses such as Shiva Vishnu and Brahma sometimes the term is used for sampradayas led by a particular guru with a particular philosophy Hinduism has no central doctrinal authority and many practicing Hindus do not claim to belong to any particular denomination or tradition four major traditions are however used in scholarly studies vation of ism Shaivism shaktism and smart ism these are sometimes referred to as the denominations of Hinduism and they differ in the primary deity at the centre of the tradition a notable feature of Hindu denominations as that they do not deny other concepts of the divine or deity and often celebrate the other as hena theistic equivalent the denominations of Hinduism states Lipner are unlike those found in major religions of the world because Hindu denominations are fuzzy with individuals practicing more than one and he suggests the term Hindu Pali centrosome although Hinduism contains many denominations and philosophies it is linked by shared concepts recognizable rituals cosmology shared textual resources pilgrimage to sacred sites and the questioning of authority topic typology you Hindus subscribe to a diversity of ideas on spirituality and traditions but have no ecclesiastical order no unquestionable religious authorities no governing body no prophets nor any binding holy book Hindus can choose to be polytheistic pantheistic monotheistic monistic agnostic atheistic or humanist Hinduism as it is commonly known can be subdivided into a number of major currents of the historical division into six dar Santas philosophies to schools vedanta and yoga are currently the most prominent classified by primary deity or deities for major Hinduism modern currents are vation of ism Vishnu Shaivism Shiva shocked ISM Devi and smart ISM five deities treated as same these deities centered denominations feature a synthesis of various philosophies such as samkhya yoga and Vedanta as well as shared spiritual concepts such as moksha dharma karma samsara ethical precepts such as ahimsa texts Upanishads Puranas Mahabharata agamas ritual grammar and rites of passage topic McDaniel 6 generic types McDaniel 2007 distinguishes six generic types of Hinduism in an attempt to accommodate a variety of views on a rather complex subject folk Hinduism based on local traditions and cults of local deities and extending back to prehistoric times or at least prior to written Vedas Schroth or Vedic Hinduism is practiced by traditionalist brahmins shraddha n--'s Vedantic hinduism including advaita vedanta smart ism based on the philosophical approach of the Upanishads yogic Hinduism especially the sect based on the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali dharmic Hinduism or daily morality based on karma and upon societal norms such as Viva ha Hindu marriage customs bhakti or devotional asti's topic sampradaya in Hinduism a sampradaya I ast sampradaya is a denomination these are teaching traditions with autonomous practices and monastic centers with a guru lineage with ideas developed and transmitted redefined and reviewed by each successive generation of followers a particular guru lineage is called para para by receiving diksha initiation into the param para of a living guru one belongs to its proper sampradaya topic main denominations topic vation of ism vation of ism is a devotional sect of hinduism which worships the god vishnu as the supreme lord swayam bhagavaan as well as Vishnu himself followers of the sect also worship Vishnu's ten incarnations the dashavatara the two most worshipped incarnations of Vishnu are Krishna and Rama whose stories are told in the Mahabharata and the Ramayana respectively the adherents of this sect are generally non ascetic monastic and devoted to meditative practice and ecstatic chanting vation of i'ts are deeply devotional their religion as rich in saints temples and scriptures the vaishnava sampradaya is include Rama Nandi sampradaya also known as the Ramayana diya or the Rama that sampradaya adheres to the teachings of the Advaita scholar Ramananda this is the largest monastic group within Hinduism and in Asia and these Vaishnava monks are known as ramen Indies barrages or barrages this East Advaita includes Adama sampradaya - which also the Swami Narayan sampradaya belongs they adhere to the teachings of vicious debate a scholar ramanuja Sri vaishnavism Sri vaishnava sampradaya Sri Vaishnavi Sri sampradaya Iyengar is associated with Lakshmi the principal acharya tsar Ramanujan Arya and Vedanta desiccant swaminarayan Hinduism or swaminarayan ism based on the teachings of swaminarayan Brahma sampradaya is associated with Vishnu who is the parabrahma universal creator not to be confused with the Brahma deity the founder of this sampradaya was the divided of Vedanta philosopher madhvacharya gaudiya vaishnavism is associated with Brahma sampradaya and is associated with chaitanya mahaprabhu Gowron acharya the International Society for Krishna consciousness belongs to this sampradaya krishna ism or Bhagavat ism Rudra sampradaya the principal Acharya is vallabhacharya kumara sampradaya as the tradition associated with four kumaras the principal acharya as nimbarka hence nimbarka sampradaya other Vaishnava schools and the principal teachers connected with them are Man avala Mammon Eagles sect is the oldest Vaishnava sect in India this Samper day was followed by Vyasa parasara body jana the lineage of Acharya is Lord Narayana next lakshmi and then Vishu ex inner nammal war that ham Unni yuya-kun dar manacle namby a lavender Parian ambi Ramanujan area and finally Vaden - desiccant as per the Vidigal i sampradaya dean acharya sampradaya vacant aweso sampradaya the principal acharya is vacant ASSA eka sarin is amorous ohmy evasion of ism adheres to the teachings of sri Monda Sankar deva krishna pranaam ii sampradaya adheres to the teachings of devi chandra maharaj varkari sampradaya teaching of bhakti saints of maharashtra Mahanama sampradaya adheres to the teachings of prabhu jagged bandeau who is considered to be the incarnation of Shri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu the founder of Gaudiya Vaishnavism is considered to be an incarnation of Vishnu topic shaivism Shiva's or shaivites are those who primarily worship Shiva as the Supreme God both immanent and transcendent Shaivism embraces at the same time monism specifically non-dualism and dualism to shaivites Shiva's both with and without form he is the supreme dancer Nataraja and is Linga without beginning or end Shiva is sometimes depicted as the fierce God Bhairava safest SAR more attracted to asceticism than adherents of other Hindu sects and may be found wandering India with ashen faces performing self purification rituals they worship in the temple and practice yoga striving to be one with Shiva within the major schools of Sevilla min clewd save a Siddhanta adheres to the teachings of Terah Mueller sundar Anitha Nandina the sampradaya the monistic school or of makin da Deva make ender sampradaya the dualistic school Adinath sampradaya or Siddha Siddhanta adheres to the teachings of Gorakhnath and mats and reigneth shiva advaita adheres to the teachings of Neelakanta Sri Kanta and a pea diction er Kashmir Shaivism adheres to the teachings of Vasu Gupta and his discipline and lineage including abhinavagupta pashupati shaivism adheres to the teachings of Lac ELISA other branches Ling Guyot ism or veresov ISM virus ah've ism is a distinct shaivite tradition in India established in the 12th century by the philosopher and social reformer Basavanna it makes several departures from mainstream Hinduism and propounds monotheism through worship centred on Lord Shiva in the form of Linga or each day Linga it also rejects the authority of the Vedas in the caste system AI anism as a religion claiming to be a form of pure Dravidian Hinduism and identifying as a Shaivite branch it is incorporated in the AI in world forum topic shaktism shock does worship goddesses mother Shakti in different forms these forms may include Kali Durga Laxmi and Saraswati the branch of Hinduism that worships the goddess known as Devi is called shaktism followers of shaktism recognized Shakti as the power that underlies the male principle and Devi is often depicted as parvati the consort of shiva or as lakshmi the consort of Vishnu she is also depicted in other guises such as the fierce Kali or Durga shaktism is closely related with tantric Hinduism which teaches rituals and practices for purification of the mind and body animal sacrifice of cockerels goats and to a lesser extent water buffalos as practiced by Shakti devotees mainly at temples of goddesses such as Bhavani or Kali topic smart ism you smartest treat all deities the same and their temples include five deities panco persona or pancha devata as personal Saguna divine with form manifestation of the Nirguna divine without form absolute the brahman the choice of the nature of God is up to the individual worshipers since different manifestations of God are held to be equivalent it is non-sectarian as it encourages the worship of any personal God along with others such as ganesha shiva devi shakti vishnu surya the smarta tradition accepts two concepts of brahman which are the saguna brahman the brahman with attributes and Nirguna brahman the brahman without attributes the Nirguna Brahman is the unchanging reality however the saguna brahman is posited as a means to realizing this laguna brahman the concept of the saguna brahman is considered in this tradition to be a useful symbolism and means for those who are still on their spiritual journey but the Saguna concept is abandoned by the fully enlightened once he or she realizes the identity of their own soul with that of the Nirguna brahman a smart Amaechi zeni Saguna deity is stood Avada such as vishnu shiva Durga Surya Ganesha or any other and this is viewed in smarta tradition as an interim step towards meditating on the ohm and true nature of supreme reality thereby realizing the Nirguna brahman and its equivalents to one's own Atman as in Advaita Vedanta the movement is credited to Shankara till to 8th century CE II who is regarded as the greatest teacher and reformer of the smarta according to hilt vital Shankara established the non Duelist interpretation of the Upanishads as the touchstone of a revived smarta tradition the screen Jerry Sharada monastery founded by Adi Shankara acharya in karnataka is still the center of the smartest sect topic overlap how fast states that although traditions such as shaivism invasion of ism may be regarded as self-contained religious constellations there is a degree of interaction and reference between the theoreticians and literary representatives of each tradition which indicates the presence of a wider sense of identity a sense of coherence in a shared context and of inclusion in a common framework in horizon it is common to find Hindus revering Shiva Vishnu and Shakti and celebrating festivals related to them at different times of the year temples often feature more than one of them and Hinduism is better understood as polycentric theosophy that leaves the choice of deity and ideas to the individual the key concepts and practices of the four major denominations of Hinduism can be compared as below topic other denominations topic schrott ISM strata communities are very rare in India the most well-known being the ultra-orthodox nambudiri brahmin ins of kerala they follow the curva my mom saw earlier portion of Vedas in contrast to Vedanta followed by other Brahmins they place importance on the performance of Vedic sacrifice yajna the nambudiri brahmin uns are famous for their preservation of the ancient soma yogam Agni keanu rituals which have vanished in other parts of India surrealism soar ISM the sir yet or surahs are followers of a Hindu denomination that started in Vedic tradition and worship Surya as the main visible form of the saguna brahman the Soraa tradition was influential in South Asia particularly in the west north and other regions with numerous Surya idols and temples built between 800 and 1000 CE II the Konark Sun temple was built in mid 13th century during the iconoclasm of Islamic invasions and Hindu Muslim Wars the temples dedicated to Sun God were among those desecrated images smashed and the resident priests of Sora tradition were killed States andrei wink the syria tradition of hinduism declined in the 12th and 13th century CE II and today remains as a very small movement topic gonna pit ism Ganapathy zoom is a hindu denomination in which Lord Ganesha is worshipped as the main form of the saguna brahman this sect was widespread and influential in the past and has remained important in Maharashtra topic cal murim camera mass a sect of Hindus especially found in South India and Sri Lanka where Lord Muruga kartikeya as the supreme Godhead Lord Muruga is considered superior to the Trimurti the worshipers of Lord Muruga are called Kumaris topic Indonesian Hinduism you Hinduism flourished on the island of Java and Sumatra until the late 16th century when a vast majority of the population converted by will or forced to Islam only the Balinese people who formed a majority on the island of Bali retained this form of Hinduism over the centuries theologically Balinese or Indonesian Hinduism is closer to Shaivism than to other major sects of Hinduism the adherents consider acintya the Supreme God and all other gods as his manifestations the term a Gama Hindu Dharma the anonymous Indonesian name for Indonesian Hinduism can also refer to the traditional practices in Kalimantan Sumatra Sulawesi and other places in Indonesia where people have started to identify and accept their agamas as Hinduism or Hindu worship has been revived the revival of hinduism in indonesia has given rise to a national organization the para sada hindu dharma topic newer movements the new movements that arose in the 19th to 20th century include ananda marga arya samaj aaaah vazhi Brahmo ism partner Samaj ramakrishna mission Sri Narayana Dharmapuri Polana swathi a Parivar movement Sathya Sai organization topic slavic vedas 'm or neo veda ism slavic vedas 'm slavic hinduism or neo veda ism or simply vedas amar terms used to describe the contemporary indigenous development of vedic forms of religion in Russia Siberia other Slavic countries the Commonwealth of Independent States members and generally all the post-soviet states Slavic Vedas omim volved the use of Vedic rituals and worship of ancient Vedic deities distinguishing from other groups which have maintained a stronger bond with modern Indian Hinduism although Krrish Nate groups often identify themselves as Vedic - also some syncretic groups within Ron ovary Slavic neo-paganism use the term Veda ism and worship vedic gods but mainstream Ron ovary is characterized by its use of indigenous Slavic rituals and Slavic names for the gods topic cross denominational influences topic at manana Jane yonder is a Sanskrit word that means knowledge in Vedas it means true knowledge that Atman is identical with Brahman it is also referred to as at manana which is frequently translated as self-realization topic bhakti movement the bhakti movement was a theistic devotional trend that originated in the seventh century Tamil South India now parts of Tamil Nadu and Kerala and spread northwards it swept over East in North India from the 15th century onwards reaching its zenith between the 15th and 17th century CE II the bhakti movement regionally developed as Hindu denominations around different gods and goddesses such as Vaishnavism Vishnu Shaivism Shiva Shakti zoom Shakti goddesses and smart ISM the movement was inspired by many poet saints who championed a wide range of philosophical positions ranging from theistic dualism of davido to absolute monism of Advaita Vedanta scriptures of the bhakti movement include the bhagavad-gita bod vada purana and padma purana as part of the legacy of the avars v Vaishnava philosophical traditions sampradayas has developed at the later stages topic schools of Indian philosophy Hindu philosophy is traditionally divided into six a Stuka sanskrit attic orthodox schools of thought or darshanam darshana view which accept the Vedas as the supreme revealed scriptures the schools are samkhya an atheistic and strongly dualist theoretical exposition of consciousness and matter yoga a school emphasizing meditation contemplation and liberation Naya or logic explores sources of knowledge Naya sutras vaisheshika an empiricist school of atomism mimamsa an aunty ascetic and aunty mist assist school of orthopraxy vedanta the last segment of knowledge in the Vedas or the JNA n knowledge Kanda section the nastika schools are in chronological order carvaka Jainism a he Vica Buddhism however medieval philosophers like vidyaranya classified Indian philosophy into sixteen schools where schools belonging to Saiva panini and raises vara thought are included with others and the three vedantic schools at Veda Vicious did Veda and de vida which had emerged as distinct schools by then are classified separately in Hindu history the distinction of the six Orthodox schools was current in the Gupta period Golden Age of Hinduism with the disappearance of vaisheshika and mimamsa it was obsolete by the later Middle Ages when the various sub schools of Vedanta Davida dualism Advaita Vedanta non-dualism and others began to rise to prominence as the main divisions of religious philosophy Naya survived into the 17th century as Navi nyah-nyah-nyah while samkhya gradually lost its status as an independent school its tenants absorbed into yoga and Vedanta topic see also topic notes topic references topic sources topic external links overview of the four divisions of Hinduism description of four denominations | wikipedia tts | UCsPs4JQVxo2-IjKMs4NkZPg | 2018-11-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,867 | 17,909 |
HS32obFQ8DA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HS32obFQ8DA | Whats Neat in model railroading | June 2017 Model Railroad Hobbyist | Ken Patterson | hi I'm Alan and June what seat starts right now [Music] this is what sneak for June 2017 I'm your host Ken Patterson and this month George Bull tech stops by to show us his tricked-out thirty-nine 85 challenger locomotive complete with sound in the boiler and an array of servicing lights all around the model just like the prototype the layout construction at present an update on the progress of my bps log mill facility showing how I built the bench work to be functional and have a furniture like appearance for photography this month we shoot a model photo using real fire to light the scene with some pretty dramatic results Matt Herman from ESU look sound came by the studio to explain in great detail how no two prime movers sound the same from cylinder count to motor block size along with all the various other mechanics built into a locomotive and how that affects the way that they sound while operating Matt explains how low ground captures the sound for our model locomotives for scene reconstruction we carve a scene and foam to include the correct track profile which is dictated of course by water runoff we do this real-time in just a few minutes showing the process and the tools and just how easy this is now if you like f-scale narrow gauge this past April st. Louis was the place to be 32nd annual sn3 symposium was held at the airport Marriott hotel the show included many dealers and vendors specializing in sn3 products the display layouts in the ballroom were well lit and very detailed like the rock ridge layout display complete with beautiful bench work and very realistic sound there were a lot of F scale brass locomotives available for purchase along with educational clinics on all aspects of the Hobby code there were layout tours of some of the most beautiful home layouts in the st. Louis area and the contest room which was a show unto itself had Master Craftsmen structures of all types covering the tables in the entire room next year's show will be held in Dallas Texas April 5th through 7th 2018 visit their website ww 2018 sn3 symposium comm for more information on this and with that let's continue on with the rest of June's what's neat [Music] ah for this photography segment of what's neat again you're asking yourself maybe what's ken Patterson doing at two o'clock in the morning and I can tell you tonight I'm shooting a train set for a third the first responder train set which is my 45th box our shot that I've done for train sets from many manufactures over the years but what I'm doing tonight is a special effect shot which may lend itself well if you're looking to do a photo contest entry and you want to do something a little special and tonight's photo involves fire and what I'm doing is I'm shooting the first responder train set with all of my mountains set up in the background and then I'm taking this this uh stick with fire and I'm literally waving it in the background of all the mountains and I'm waving it behind the locomotive to light the scene I'm also using a flashlight to light the scene and I'm shooting this in complete darkness I've got all the HomeLife in the back of the house turned off for this photo shoot and I'm doing about a two minute long exposure with DP feeding hooked up to the tracks so that we can have the headlights slick and so after all of that running around with fire behind the mountains and not setting the foam on fire I can show you the result that we got showing this photo shoot something kind of interesting a little bit of flare a little excitement just something different for the first responder trainset photo that we're doing for a Tharin tonight so that's this quick photography segment on what's neat [Applause] [Music] [Applause] mic though I've downloaded all Kim's videos man and I still think it is profile right man play my message I want you to know like to track profile yeah okay this looks like totally with your stuff looks real what am I missing I think that's been in our videos um let's do something let's just make a quick trip track profile on this piece of foam or let's go to another piece and let's just real quick carve it out as if it's a final finish scene the first thing you want to think about really and what I think about when I'm building a seam like this edge is you've got to imagine where the water is going to go and you want the track to be the highest point within an area of about nine to twelve feet on either side and these track specific designs are in the railroad prototype standard books but just imagine yourself for a minute if it's raining and where's the water going to go a lot of times when I pour resin cream I'll fill the crepe with water so I can anticipate the flow of the resin before I pour it it really helps a lot and doing rivers but just imagine where the water is going to go and then carve our scenery down from there so you don't require cork to achieve is melkor it's all about the tools and it's specifically about the type of tool to use this rasp is one of the most valuable tools on either side of the track for doing track profile so let's grab a sheet of foam and let's just carve up something real quick and see if we can make some track look good okay all right the first thing I like to do ad is once you decide where your tracks can go I like to draw a line on either side of the track with a marker so it'll allow me to know where not to car tracks got a flat base so I've got this bent raft ad and it works great for carving out the track profiles on both sides of the track and that's what we're going to do right now it goes really quick you're just imagining now where the waters going to go so effectively I've got the profile stripe this is from the wood Smith stores at the name of place wood crap you wood craft store that's where I found the bent grass I've never seen these anywhere else you might be able to find them online but now what we want to do you want to carve a creek in here sure let's and what we'll do is we'll take out the surrounding scenery now mind you if you are doing mountainous terrain you would still have the water runoff immediately on either side of the track and then your scenery would go up from there but we're probably gonna carve this down at the flat field on either side okay run a drainage just through here real quick so let's pull out the hot phone card sort cutting out our drainage ditch so let's try to Creek sort of run through right here and we'll cut out the I got a hot foam cutter here and we use that real quick to cut out of it we'll just cut out a quick little area here where there'd be a culvert you can put in a concrete culvert or wooden railroad tie over here see how all this machine does is it speeds up the cut time and it squares the edges but now you can take a long saw and cut out the main part of your crepe yeah let's [Music] creak with a broken foot breath Reuben air bike yeah you do that what on so now tell ya this tool will get you that seems sharpness of pruning saw blade to the best most rapid clean cutting simple phone now if you were going to photo a small trestle or something you can just cut that out sure a small bridge but you're going to do with culverts link if you either way right now if you have in a creek bridge throwing some Walker's trestle banks or drop in a piece of pipe or some soda straws yeah a pipe is a little more unusual I think next step is to feel everything in latex paint so that visually you can see the typography because a pink makes it really hard to speak out yeah stain is not a nice latex Brown like a carrot color brown let's do part space I think that ain't it we're going to smooth it down with this sure form planer there it'll help us safe pink because we really don't need a lot of typography here once it's covered up with fake fur [Music] like in Thea covered a whole area now that gives you a good idea of how your scene is going to look first look like correct agra feet right obama so we've got our track I usually glue track down with liquid nail but right now we're going to let the paint since it's wet glue down the track and glue down the dirt and actually we're going to do some static grass too because it's wet it will all stick so we're going what dirt are they hey Hank itself be the glue tonight awesome because that way we could do this demonstration in less than 15 minutes do you ever ever paint your track first before you glue it down you can do that I've done that on the garden railroad I had that on the midwest valley modelers layout but what i also like to do is come back with a paintbrush and paint white tie right i I just get a little variation in the color of ties it's very noticeable when it seems finish to the paper for what we're doing tonight that's the time right let's just cover up the scene with a little bit of dirt we'll put some static grass on that this dirt will get glued in a place with the paint in fact we'll dump the absense right off now you just can't imagine that the track is losing out with liquid nails for this demonstration it's not going to be because of the essence of time now this will still be moist enough to get the static grass to stick in our experiment water to a dirty okay maybe you know how we just put down little teeny scrum foam that would be easy yeah now I guess now normally we would just spray this with woodland scenic scene cement and let the dirt set up the way it is but tonight we're going to let it the paint glue it so let's dump off the excess our cena cena council stuck to the paint next is ballast the key to balance isn't so much fine ballast is important but the key to ballast is a type of brush that you use to spread the ballast the best brush is a round brush like this because it allows this the tip of the brush to touch the ballast which gives you a lot more control or spreading it's smooth between times just let the ballast fall with gravity takes it because we've carved the topography with that in mind seems like a lot of ballast it is we'll spread this with paintbrush spread around the ballast away from your the rails and stick it on the sides of the rails it looks really unfortunate like this gotcha I like to have the tops of all ties join okay anyway okay and I got the woodland singing sink cement you guys getting down to cyclists what it look like I'm going to use a lot of glue on this balance everything we're also to wet the dirt so the static grass will stick in this glue and stand straight up we'll have a scene go for like 15 years if you wanted to use fake firm this would be the time to glue down your fake fur color and put it in place we're using static crafts today I've got some green and you've done here the gun is on all you simply want to do is put the alligator clip on the surface that will create your current so the grass will stand straight up typically in order thank you a collab wouldn't seem seen Josh ground foam and various things to this the last thing we want to do is drop in some rocks here put a cauldron under for the creek yeah it ran a pipe or something move to spread out some rocks different sizes and work of education on both sides of gravel about what a creek would be to support your present basis if you report a resident one year what's the boulders in here on the side little RepRap just kind of mix it up a little bit you know put some little CSS on it like that set up hard and other than putting plywood sides on your diorama and trees and other things I say you've got yourself a real quick profile which is kind of what we were inquiring about how do we carve down the profile real quick with ya what tools degrees like better than just a flat piece of more by my wood so good question yeah it was it was just natural that you ask a question and hopefully maybe we've got a new video but thank you for asking and in the event this did turn out to be a video that's this segment on scenery on what's neat hi my name is Ron Perry and you're watching Ken Patterson's let's meet there's some nice boss for Mike vine for this segment of what's neat I've got George book etat from Durango Colorado and he just customized a 39 85 Challenger he's going to share with us today with like two steps of speakers sound actually comes out of the boiler on this one George tell us about this magnificent model were looking at okay and what I did was with the new tsunami - I had to install this into my Challenger my personal little vice is the U P passenger set so I had to have this one done up properly so with the tsunami two and six lighting functions that allowed me to light this thing up properly so what we have is we have the headlight we have the marker light or the class light sub problem we have the number boards lit up and we have the side running lights along the inside we have a tab light on interior and a red flashing emergency on the back of the the tender one of the cool things that the tsunami to allows me to do is to dim the lights to be constant them when they're on and I can adjust the brilliance for how bright or dim the light is and so that allowed me to do the number of Lords on the front of their proper brilliance and the marker lights and the running lights along the side of the locomotive at different brilliance --is so that it appears more realistic than just simply having to play with resistor values to make that work now what I did was I installed the decoder actually right here behind the back head up in the front of the locomotive on the locomotive side and I've got a sound track committee cube up under the exhaust stack and then I've got a non tracks 28 by 40 millimeter speaker in the tenders so that it gives a good range of sound but also doesn't seem like the sound is coming from the tender so when the locomotive passes you you hear the sound from the locomotive and not from the tender and with the tsunami - we've got a lot of cool features that you can customise the decoder for operation so we've got an articulated exhaust job with the wheels going in and out of sync with each other we've got an oil burning sound with an atomizer running in the background that you can hear we've got dual steam dynamos running we've got a non lifting type injector and many many more or customized sounds in the tsunami - that helped me recreate this audible more active and the lights are beautiful on it it sounds fantastic George thanks a lot - sir in this masterpiece with us on what's new thank you Ken [Applause] [Laughter] [Applause] [Laughter] for this layout construction segment at once needs I want to give you an update on my VTS log mill complex and project that I have been working on I started the process of building the BTS log mill by figuring the space required for all the buildings and then I started placing track around this with function operation and a minimum radius of 27 inches in mind I drew lines along the edges of the track to mark the tracks placement onto the phone I then started stacking or layering 2-inch sheets of foam by gluing them together with the foam Pro adhesive after pressing the top layer of foam into the glue evenly all around I placed an assortment of weights and boards on top of this for about 30 minutes until the glue cured I then cut the new layer of foam to match the top layer and remove this which then sort of determine the size of the diorama I repeated this process gluing a third layer of foam into place moving the modular section about six inches thick I cut around the edges with a pole saw removing the excess foam revealing the size and the overall look of scene to hold the foam module I built bench work about two by fours measuring from the floor to the point of the rails height every leg had to be built to a different length because I wasn't going to use leg levelers on this project now this different length had to be compensated for you know to compensate for the uneven concrete floor ensuring a level surface for the entire modular diorama I attached the v's 2-way locking wheels I found the home depot it's very important not only to be able to lock the wheels role but also to lock the pivot locking this pivot point ensures the modules won't wiggle from side to side on the bearings ensuring solid and tight bench work when complete I rounded all the corners on the wood bench work with a 1/2 inch router bit ensuring a smooth edge I then sanded the woodwork with 120 grit smooth sandpaper ensuring every surface that your hands come into contact with will feel smooth I then applied red oak stain and three coats of polyurethane to finish the bench work into a furniture like appearance it was now time to put all the pieces together I rolled the bench work into position close to the bridge module that will connect with the sawmill diorama now if I did all my measuring correctly the rails height will match perfectly on both scenes as they go together I slid the sawmill diorama on top of the bench work and put it into place I carefully position the foam even and square to the bench working matching marks that I had already drawn underneath the foam ensuring an exact placement on top of the smooth bench work when I rolled the scene into position it matched the height of the adjoining module perfectly I love it when a plan goes together like this now to hold the foam from sliding on the top of the smooth bench work I drilled a few holes underneath the bottom of the wood at a 45 degree angle countersunk and then I put in three inch screws screwing these screws up into the foam ensuring that things won't slide sideways at all but yet I can take them out easily when I need to remove things and take things outside I also attached brass plumb Bob's to each end of the bench work these will point to an X on the floor this will ensure that when the seams are taken outside for photography and video and then they are brought back in they can be placed in their exact locations matching the plumb Bob's point to the center X on the floor which will guarantee rail alignment when every reassembles and that's a quick update on the progress of the log mill project that I've been working on simply the bench work was a big hurdle to get over but now it'll be time to start laying track and working on the scenery and working on the edges of the foam diorama finishing things off with wood work and we'll do follow-ups on future what's needs so that's this layout construction segment for what's need [Applause] again as we were talking earlier we've done a lot of prime movers for our product line and there's a reason why we've done so many because there's a lot of differences in prime mover we've talked a little bit about education and the mission that I'm on to educate them and part of that is explaining why we've done so many prime movers every serial number of every locomotive if you can have 5 s d 4 2 s 2 s from serial number the serial number the serial numbers they will all sound different there's going to be some times they have a new turbo put into them sometimes they have different air compressors just low idle high idle you know st 40's to s there were 3,000 of them made so they were made over many many years so advancements happened you had dynamic range or extended range dynamics you had different types of fans on them so there was a lot of differences so that's just one engine so let me explain as we go down through all these beautiful engines behind us why we've created some of the prime movers that we have and what we've got available so the first is just a GP 38s - this is a 16 cylinder 645 EE this is a non turbo locomotive we've because so many differences do exist between prime movers and engine the engine we've actually got three or four of those recorded now so we have some variation so if you bought three GP 38 - 2 s and they all came when Lok sound you could actually upload the two other differences within that locomotive because they're programmable decoder we don't just have a GP array I'm sorry a 645 turbo and a 645 non turbo we have about every cylinder and every block variation that came available which means this is a 16 cylinder 645 e the next one is a 12 cylinder 645 e we're working on an eight cylinder 645 e you know there's lots of variation this is a GP 15 we've recorded multiple GP 15 so you have some variation just in that model but we've also done multiple SW 1500s they have a little bit different stack something more like this one over here but you know there's still the 645 e prime mover so they have a similar sound but just enough to be different so that you have those subtleties so you can run multiple unit lash ups and have that distinguished ability in between them the next is a 567 this is a 16 cylinder 567 we have now recorded I believe almost every 567 block available again this is a 16 cylinder but there were 16 cylinder A's and B's and C's and BCS and we've done just about every one we've done with exhaust silencers without we've done you know multiple stack variations this is a 12 cylinder 567 this is a six cylinder 567 last week I recorded in 8 cylinder 567 and you know those are there's all those variations in between now when we get to the 16 again there's lots of variations there's even times where in both the 12 and the 16s they've replaced the power assemblies with 645 power assemblies we've recorded those two we've even got different exhaust we've got 2 or 2 exhaust for power assemblies using 645 and we've got four exhaust for things like GP 16s which there was programs out in hundreds and hundreds of engines existed that way SW 1200 same thing they had 12 cylinder 645 power assemblies put in there's lots and lots of variation and that's just 2 567 s here's another variation of a 567 this is a 567 d3 this would happen to be a GP 30 they're also good for us to 24 and GP 35 if you go back to the d2 s and and before we recorded a GP 20 G P 20 has a little bit different idle speed so even though it's a 567 turbo not all 567 turbos are the same so again more variation here's a couple of alko's this is a 16 cylinder fighter 251 we've recorded C engines we've recorded B engines we recorded 12 cylinder 251 B's and mole the pulls of them we have again different governors we've got different startups in the 16-cylinder versions we've done air start we've done electric start we've done multiples of all of those prime movers as well we've done C 420 s m4 20s Rs 11 SRS 18s all 12 cylinder 250 ones and they all sound different and we want those variations in between we've done 244 s we've done 8 cylinder 250 once we've done six cylinder 251 every one of them has its own subtleties its own character and we want that on the layout if not you just have been not me and it gets boring because everything starts to sound the same this is a new engine this is a SD 39 we there's this is the number 40 is about the only SD 39 that still exists and runs I've just recorded that exact engine so that's a 12 cylinder 645 with a turbo the next one is a 16 cylinder 645 with a turbo that's that SP 40 that's - that we just talked about we've also done a 20 cylinder 645 with a turbo and many of these we've done multiples of them we've done a couple we've done a GP 39 - - and we've done an SD 39 - - both 1260 are 12 cylinders 645 II or III s we've done about five SD 40 - 2 s high idles low idles extended range dynamics normal dynamics without dynamics - twos - threes with the electronics they make things happen at a different pace a different rate you're idling is a little bit different 45 45 - 2 s 45 - two T's there's a lots and lots of variation we just want to make sure that everything doesn't sound the same because that's that 4th dimension that nobody really thinks about they're always worried about the detail on the outside the beautiful streets and the houses and the trees and whether it's got the right grab irons or not whether it's got the right lift rings in the right places well it's time to super detail that sound inside as well and that's what we're after so why don't we hear some of them run why don't we take some out Waldo Emerson [Laughter] [Applause] hahaha [Applause] [Laughter] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] you [Music] | Model Railroad Hobbyist magazine | UCSqUkqVT9Vh-4Sy5wRtZqwg | 2017-05-23 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 4,683 | 24,274 |
GE9VyKw92Ys | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GE9VyKw92Ys | We Met The Witch!!! [Roblox The Mimic Chapter 2](Playing with My Friends!!!) | [Music] hello everyone emma here is mtv hello hello and welcome everybody to today we're going to play the mimic chapter two how how do you guys feel everybody's scared welcome oh okay okay sorry and guys do you guys wonder why why assemble tv is not playing with us a simple tv show your arm it's bad yeah it's just bad he won't be able to play but thankfully he can see my vision he's technically in my pocket he's gonna be he's gonna be part of my pocket is it this way oh he's not this way let's go all right and the queen revealed the voice who are you oh okay oh friend i remove the sound you're going to turn out the sound what oh who the hell is that what is that oh oh it's not that fast no thank thank god that's not that fast wait wait who is going to die search for a key upstairs oh oh what oh my god oh my god that that this ghost kills oh what the hell oh god that's disgusting i found the key you found the key e1 oh yeah [Music] key [Music] that's the old picture okay where do you use this key i forgot you forgot yes oh no did you check this room no okay oh god it's a bridge that bridge i think do you need to find something no there's nothing okay i think we're good i think we're good i need to fight i need to find the lever hey okay follow me [Applause] come after me oh god let's taste disgusting hey oh no oh okay okay okay yeah that's disgusting hey oh god oh god right i tried to i tried to jump you died yes i died oh this is scary is it this way is it this way [Music] oh my god you look ugly as hell that's disgusting as hell i'm sorry i won't do it okay do it right oh they're all the same they're all the same it won't happen again i promise it won't i won't do it again i am sorry i won't do it again do it again it mean whatever this guy is it's a oh oh oh this is disgusting oh i think that opens the door hey over here again oh no this is the second time you died oh what do you need to do there do it oh it's of course oh [Applause] oh my god blood oh oh god okay no one ever loved me for who i who i am i'll be someone else that's obvious do you need to go to the second one now all right i think i think all right i'm ready to die i'm ready to die again come on i'm not ready come back to me come to me get to the second floor i need i hate this place yes agree they ran just like you what did you do i shall leave follow me my troops oh what the hell well this display oh what happens if i fall don't be scared what the whoa that was terrifying oh chase you oh oh we need to go that way yes if that's the only way you can follow me oh follow me why am i so slow oh oh oh oh all right all right i'm gonna close the door butterfly spin it okay you ain't gonna come through now but play spirit is needed to walk through this path oh you can do it she created it oh oh you're in the left right oh my god oh you have it yeah all right yeah oh that's demonic oh god that's demonic that's so demonic i'm sorry i forgot what demonic means what is demonic this place isn't real she created it it's not real it's you what it's nothing that cost their lives what a bunch of idiots so beautiful yep i will be someone else promise i can change i will open the doodle house peter hospital great uh whoa all right i forgot you thought you turned off your volume didn't you oh my god who's banging the door hey shut the hell up okay who's banging the door by the way i'm really i'm starting to get really mad whoa do you saw that on the tv wait so what i didn't say there's something standing right here i didn't see that oh no oh no why me i didn't see something scary yeah but something must have been trapped here i think look at these chains so you need to check this place too all right let's go wow by the time you're reading this it might have been too late she already got to to the others too i was the last one and this last one i don't think i'll make it out alive either your friend kyla someone saying that's so terrifying wait what what happens in the other side there's one more door i saw i saw on my door or if i die again i'm gonna be pissed there lies a greater okay you can only die once oh thank goodness oh jesus yes oh what the heck it's going to the light i don't want to die yet it's not my time it's not my time oh we can run now use the spirits as your guidance oh so so these butterflies are our spirits okay thank you [Music] who gave us the key i haven't i haven't seen you around before well please be careful around here oh how so sad let's go he's gonna be with his brother now [Music] i should continue following the butterfly big sakura tree oh oh that's a big ass tree oh giant oh now that's oh wait wait that thing's going under oh jesus that that thing's too big and we found the spirit yeah that thing was huge yes okay well that thing was too big imagine getting chased by that thing oh that is a big ass tree that's super nice red so who's going first oh so who's going oh okay wait which way i think yeah i think that's what i think that way yeah okay that's i'm very scared of this chapter two i hate it don't worry i shall lead oh no it's the school from chapter one i think oh there is a hospital i hate disaster hey what kind of place is this everything has been a mimics of your reality since this is kind of a loop i hate this place okay do you need to search here search for a key and i hid in butterfly to escape ah nah that's terrifying listen to the footsteps that's huge there's a lot of footsteps you hear that oh god something huge is coming i just think this is the footsteps isn't this the footsteps like a big giant big ass footsteps oh why are you guys there oh there's nothing here right look when the mannequin like turns his head like uh 180 degrees that's so not cool oh yep i was froze i need a key for this door oh we need to use this for here we just go next side be brave everybody oh my god oh god i could hardly find what i am looking for well there is something across there there is a monster so we're gonna go first me bye okay i'm dying too many times today hey you're not the one who keeps dying i'm i'm keep that as well oh jesus i i think i kind of see something at the end over there okay mac is moving george goodbye [Laughter] [Music] oh oh water oh oh that's water what what what what what i'm thinking what you didn't see that wait what was that oh oh no oh wait i feel like i need to go there oh no turn around good luck you can do it you died not yet he's alive yeah he's alive i still want to have kids why you just keep happening to me no no you can't you always say that you're dumb you're down you're very good i got it i got it [Music] loading please wait oh we're doing good yeah good yo keep going wait why am i not teleporting okay oh hello it's always [Music] um okay [Music] foreign oh foreign um so we finally meet search for the hidden exit by using experience as your guidance and use the safe house okay okay i'm at the middle wait am i am i the wrong forest sama kill me okay okay yes i have it okay i have it now i need to find yes [Music] foreign oh keep watching [Music] oh okay this summer foreign [Music] oh um you will never escape the curse of the witch [Music] oh yes oh so guys this is gonna be it for today if you enjoyed this video leave a like and subscribe and if you want us to play chapter three no then you better subscribe okay you better subscribe and tell us in the comments below thanks for watching thanks for watching and we'll see you guys next time bye bye bye peace out let them say bye bye [Music] you | Ed Mole | UCKCCfznr8sfmNPSzP8YuVdQ | 2022-06-06 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,577 | 7,550 |
iPEB5r0A870 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPEB5r0A870 | Iain Duncan Smith on #Marr | well Ian Duncan Smith's resignation from the cabinet on Friday night was high drama indeed no one seems to have seen it coming least of all the prime minister who said he was puzzled and disappointed in the parents had many other things as well so what was the background mr. Duncan Smith's unexpected move we can find out now from man himself good morning to you Andrew before we go into the detail of this particular argument can I ask about your general view of what's happened do you think the disability cuts in the context of the tax cuts as well are simply immoral I think actually what we have here is a proposal which we put out as a consultation last year to look at a problem that had come about through without getting too complicated court cases and other judgments that had made some changes to this that consultation was I always felt to be part of a much wider program that we look at and consult further on bigger changes that bring into line the present disability benefit Pip and other things like social care and health care which are all traction I wanted to look at it as a wider change that got the money that was necessary and the support practical support to those most in need and that it was nice being gone about being consulted on and what happened next well my concern was that what happened directly after the the Christmas period was that pressure began to grow because this pressure was about the budget and that the problem over the revised figures for the budget and what worried and concerned me was we then came under pressure to put the consultation and respond to it before the budget and I'd always hoped we would do this after the budget says not to get caught up with the budget but we able to make the point this should be part of a process of looking at how better we can aid those most in need and that pressure really was to get out a definitive answer on the on the consultation there were lots of arguments and debates about that Downing Street and the Treasury wanted the full extensive set of changes we argued first of all for no change at this point and then to to ensure that if we did we wanted a smaller level of change but most importantly to continue the dialogue and not to have this a fixed point and a thing that we were going to do absolutely and the difference between pre budgets and after budget was you knew perfectly well there will be a figure attached to it so you be you be stung for 1.4 in this case 1.4 billion pounds of savings and you didn't want to be in that position is that right yeah it again as you said not to get too detailed about this but I simply say that the problem was the institution of the welfare cap which was lowered directly after the last election pretty arbitrarily and that meant that everything we were doing put us above the line essentially as you saw tax credit changes put us above the line in costs and this was meant to go above the line because of the changes now my point really was we shouldn't be debating that in the context of just being above a welfare cap which is an arbitrary position we should be discussing it in terms of how could we get the best aid to those who most need it and then work from there as to how this changes came and rushing that before the budget which is genuinely what I felt we run a massive pressure to do I felt only risked linking this to the budget which it was not part of and it should not have been part of and that in turn made it juxtapose and I didn't to that stage know anything about tax reductions and still a so this is interesting because your critics in government say two things first of all this was your scheme the Pips was your idea and indeed revising it was your idea and you defended it right up to the last minute you SAT through the cabinet on the budget didn't say anything about it didn't raise the problem then I deal with us well I kept on and then and then you didn't go and see the Prime Minister and then as late as Friday morning your department were briefing as it were in favor of the change that you have resigned over her going to steal all that first of all you are you know let me go right back to the time of the election after the election last year I took a decision these are decisions you take if you're going to join government you have to balance whether or not you can make changes you can do what you hope to do on balance you'll have to compromise but do those compromise benefit or damage society I have been passionate about the issue of social justice I set up the Center for social justice years ago I have campaigned to make sure that there's a conservative way of delivering help and support to those who most in need not just through money but through a whole variety of other way of getting people back into work my problem throughout this last pair didn't start last week or the week before through the despite that the debates and the disputes that I've had on tax credits on the cutting away and a roading of universal credits allowances and then the big assault on the taper what is the taper it helps people move on up the hours it would benefit people enormously it's a long-running thing this has been a long-running problem where I felt really semi-detached in the sense isolated more often in these debates because I'm not able to be able to convince people that what we were losing progressively and it was my worry was the narrative that the Conservative Party was this one nation party caring about those who don't even necessarily vote for it who may never vote for that is my problem and this I supposed to double Crociere then you went along with all those clots and then in the key cabinet meeting you didn't say anything well I him I actually thought last year about resigning I think that actually got into the papers as well over this attack on universal credit and again I balance this and said I will continue because we can continue to make these arguments what happened in the run-up to this was I progressively got more and more depressed about the idea that we were running to an arbitrary budget agenda which had a welfare cabinet and although when people and I've heard one or two people trying allege certain things about me let me just say something about this it's quite important i SAT silently at eight o'clock in the morning of the budget presentation because I then realized the full state of what was actually happening with regards to both the tax cuts and this junk junk in a budget is putting it to do just opposing at that point that made me really go away I didn't actually by the way come in for the budget so those pictures are an old budget I didn't come in for the budget I had to attend a funeral but it gave me time to think about this and I thought long and hard and I then agreed tried to agree with the Downing Street that what we would put out is a wider statement that stopped meaning it was a set in concrete proposal that we would consult more and continue to consult but even with that which is the point of the statement that I put out that dear colleague was as a no no don't worry we're going to continue consulting this is the letter you wrote after the budget well this is the dear colleague letter I tried to get the colleagues saying no it's not what it sounds like in the budget it's not to do with the budget it's different I put this clear colleague out saying it's a wider consultation there are facts and issues here but there are wider consequences what I realized is through thursday and friday was that it was no way that I what I'd hope for was I'd be able to stop this process and get this wide wide debate and I felt that I was losing that and by Friday this is really important to me by Friday I really decided that it was just impossible and this idea is somehow by the way this put about that why do that when government policy is changing just about to ask you that very thing what can I just say in answer to that first of all it is a very peculiar way to try and set policy against a media agenda where you start Friday morning absolutely apparently saying to everybody you must go out and defend it and then by friday evening you're drifting away from it and then later on Friday evening somehow you say we've kicked into the long grass the money required from the Department for Work and pension still sits in the red book it will be a requirement that will bear down on working age benefits and that is the problem that I have and in my left and I was clear about this and which is the reason why I resigned collectively over that period I had come to believe that we had begun to lose our sense that we if we really want to do this so that all people bear this and those who can't bear the least of the burden then we are beginning to lose that message and that was my concern wasn't about friday night or wednesday it was a collective sense that from the last election we had begun to abandon that position and I felt that would narrow us and the party that I love dearly and serve and the country that I love would not benefit from that I want us to be in government but to govern for all the people all the time now in very very sort of clear simple terms that's why I asked you the beginning do you think this is an unfair or immoral situation because you're cutting taxes for the better off at the same time as you're cutting benefits for disabled people do you think that's unfixed opposed as it is as it came through in the budget that is deeply unfair and was perceived to be unfair and that unfairness is damaging to the government it's damaging to the party and it's actually damaging to the public you know I i am in politics genuinely I am passionate and you know whatever people can disagree with me about issues about my own policies and things but has just been said earlier on I am passionate about trying to improve the quality of life for those in difficult circumstances now I want to do that and I want my party to do that but I felt that I am losing my ability to influence that and that was where the culmination of all of this came to by friday and i had consulted with everybody and I had talked to them all and I felt that I was not getting that message across Ian Duncan Smith do you understand that among a lot of disabled campaigners and so forth will be a certain amount of hollow laughter because they still see you as the man that supported things like the benefits cap that supported the bedroom tax that's what in lots of things which have caused real hardship to people at the bottom of the heap and they they say they see you as the bad guy and they find it hard to see you as the great reformer and champion well just below I would say is behind the scenes we have spent a lot trying to even out and smooth out those proposals and policies you know for example discretionary housing payments massively increased at my request and demand from the Treasury so that people who had difficult problems local authorities be able to give them much more money and support them you know we did exempt disability benefits we actually did not Mort the whole entire row forever the sa rah or was a was a router do with that running that I'm talking about from the budget period onwards about this desperate search for savings and my concern about all of this is that we don't lose sight of this there are reforms that are important and good be very clear were you against what happened on esa note my sense about what the esa was about was actually saying look we want more people to be in the support group which is where they are protected and supported properly with higher levels of money and not to be languishing in a demi section of the benefit unable therefore to either go to work or to be fully supported and i've argued for a white paper to look at getting rid of this binary system that says you either too sick to work or you can work I want people if they can work no matter what the condition to work and that was the proposed changes I wanted to bring forward and this year what are you thing to do do you think a fairer overall government would have taken some of the benefits away from richer pensioners might not have done the triple lock in order to avoid these kind of cuts Andrew my concern as I accept the letter as I said absolutely it's all about how we are perceived and how that balance is right my property now knows if it is about how people perceive them to be and then in application yeah how that balance of change is made and my deep concern has been that this very limited narrow attack on what is working age benefits means that we simply don't get that balance we lose the balance of the generations you know we have a triple lock on pensions which I was proud to do you know that six years ago but you know with inflation running at zero we we really need to look at things like this and ask do we just keep saying it's working age that bear the brunt and the one point I want to say is you know we've taken will have taken by 1920 against the 2010s much 33 billion pounds a year out of working age benefits my argument now is we can't go on to too far that I think you following the straw that broke your back might that exactly the problem I face is it in my care for my countrymen and women leads me to believe I am resigning because I want my government to think again about this and get back to that position that i believe which is about being a one nation this is not some secondary attempt to attack the prime minister or about Europe there's nothing to do with that at all if I wanted to do that I would have been clear I've never ever hidden my views about something and I'm not doing it now I am genuinely Cordingley concerned did he call you hypocritical and something worse than those conversation look you know they're only two people engaged in this conversation Andrew and I'm always intrigued when others who weren't actually engage in those conversations seem to know what happened my sense about this is was it was robust we had a long set of conversations I listened to him I acted on what he asked me to do to think about things and I reached finally the conclusion that I just simply couldn't stay but as I've made clear in the letter i wowed to serve with the Prime Minister I'm proud of what we've achieved in the last five to six years but I my sense is now that I believe I'm losing that ability to influence events from inside to change the terrain again as that we go become as we ought be a one nation party that cares about even those who don't vote for us let me pick you up directly on that in your in your letter you say I'm unable to watch passively whilst certain policies are enacted in order to meet the fiscal self-imposed restraints and you think a more distinctly political than good for the country those fiscal restraints what are they are you saying there that you are against the benefit the welfare cap yes in short my concern has grown partly because when the welfare cap was brought in it had larger margins and it allowed much more flexibility after the last election what really troubled me was arbitrarily that welfare cap was lowered which put us under enormous pressure just to meet the cat let alone the changes in the cuts that would expect my bikes on the 12 billion what about the general policy of ending this Parliament with a surplus which is the overarching thing behind all of this I suppose look the Chancellor has to make his position clear about what he thinks the economy should be doing I am a big supporter of the fact that if you don't eradicate the deficit of course the people that suffer most are those on the lowest incomes and the things we were doing to raise taxation I'm you know thresholds for those low thing I'm very supportive of but the truth is yes we need to get the deficit down but we need to make sure we widen the scope of where we look to get that deficit down and not just narrow it down on working-age benefits and there's a reason for that because otherwise it just looks like we see this as a pot of money that it doesn't matter because they don't vote for us and that's my concern they are there are people who I want to get into work and we've done a lot to get them into work to change their lives passionately audio cases the Chancellor is wrong on his overall glennon his welfare cap he's wrong and I where he's attributing the pain he's been protecting as it were better off voters at the expense of people who are more vulnerable these are a series of body blows to the Chancellor can I put it you you just don't like him he doesn't like you this has been simmering for years and years and years there are people saying you heard them earlier on this is the beginning of a coup against George Osborne and David Cameron first of all this is not personal i know people may think it's personal because when you resign as personal it's not personal III in this i am genuinely for us i have no personal ambitions Andrew I have absolutely no personal ambitions if I never go back into government again then I will not cry about that that is not my ambition I only came into this government and let me be clear about this I came into this government because I cared about welfare reform I'd spent eight years with the Center for social justice which I set up talking to charities and small community groups trying to figure out why certain communities were so badly off and how could we and back to work and how could we solve their problems so everything that I've done has been driven by my desire to improve the quality of life of the worst off we can debate my policies we can argue about them but my motivation has always been about that and my motive now without any question in my mind is that I am concerned that this government that I want to succeed is actually not able to do the kinds of things that it should because it has become too focused on narrowly getting the deficit down without being able to say where that should fall other than simply on those who I think progressively can less afford to have that fall on and in the context of this failed conversation as you were inside government impression is given that things are run entirely by the Treasury and by number 10 Jacob rees-mogg has effectively said that cabinet government needs to be reestablished do you think there is a functional problem I think someone has called them ant and Dec running the country the rest of you as it were squeezed out well I do think genuinely that there needs to be a greater kind of collegiate sense to the way decisions are made I mean we just come back to what we were talking about with this benefit changing literally by our you know I wasn't consulted on the Friday about those changes I didn't know anything about them till media started ringing me up and telling me this is not the way to do government all I'm simply saying is look I want the Chancellor and the Prime Minister to succeed I want them to succeed because Britain needs them to succeed we need to get that deficit down but we need to get welfare reform going I simply thought you're saying also they need to change direction and change the way they run government in order to succeed look I think that what is in my letter and what I'm trying to say today is and the colleagues don't doubt my motive on this you know I am NOT about seeing the Prime Minister depart I genuinely am NOT because if there was a vote on it tomorrow I would vote for him and I want the team to succeed as a one nation team as a as a team that I came to join believing that social justice was right at the heart of what they did we can debate how that's delivered but we shouldn't debate the fact that what we should be trying to do is not keep bearing down on the same group of people widen that and talk about sharing that burden a bit more and making sure therefore that the reform process can take place without being hamstrung through demands for short term savings all the time when things don't go right according to the forecast do you think George Osborne make a good sorry I'm his necklace do you think George Osborne would make a good Prime Minister I think certainly that if he was to stand and he was selected by the electric which is not just me there's everybody else that I would hope that he would but I think the same for almost anybody else I have no view about anybody to be Prime Minister because the Prime Minister is there at the moment and I have a high regard for him i'm a and understand ppl think me out in my view is the present Prime Minister's done a very good job but i believe they're losing sight of the direction of travel that they should be in to be absolutely clear all those people who say you know in the end there is a move against cameron and osborne by Euroskeptic ministers who are using this opportunity when the party seems a bit fragmented and in trouble to my nothing against him and that you know Boris Johnson is there in the background you're saying all of that is piffle it's all nonsense and it's nonsense in my in what I am about let me just say one very brief thing to you I served in the army because I care about my country and I care about the people who live here and I came into politics because I care about my country and I care about the people who live here I do not have political ambition I would not stand for leader I would not support somebody who stands the leader at the moment I am supportive of the Prime Minister I care for one thing and one thing only it is that the people that don't get the choices that my children get are left behind I do not want them left behind I want them given that opportunity and everything I've tried to do has been about that yes we can debate some of those things that people didn't like because they're more about that deficit than about welfare reform but under overarching Lee what I am passionate about is getting that reform done so society is reformed so that we have more of those people who've been left behind brought back into the sphere and the arena where we play daily but they do not that is what I'm about and what I have been concerned about and raises time and again is that we are beginning to lose that focus and I cannot do this from inside that is my frustration I believe I have to step out it's not easy it's painful to resign I don't want to resign but I'm resigning because i think it's the only where I can do this and because and I come right back to the beginning of our conversation because what is happening at the moment is immoral I think it is in danger of drifting in a direction that divides society rather than unites it and then I think is unfair I'm not in the business of morality and everything else because I leave that to church men I simply say that as far as I'm concerned the risk is there were not there yet but I want to change that I resigned I've cleared away my career whatever it was it never thought much about a career and I've said i would rather campaign to change that I want the Prime Minister and I want the Chancellor to continue to do that but to do it for the right reasons those are my passionate cares Ian Duncan Smith thank you very much indeed for joining us today nothing quiet about that over to nagger for the news headlines | Ben Claimant | UCguTvlPM9PK6eTiiw0wTGaA | 2016-03-20 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 4,479 | 23,382 |
Q54_tbOblJc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q54_tbOblJc | Confessions........... | [Music] I was about to say good morning it is not morning it is so evening time good evening good evening good evening you hey y'all hey I got some light on listen I wanted to be in my in my Den but I couldn't I had to I'm still in my room and uh I had to child it is cold outside y'all it's cold I listen we are not used to this this is this this is not our at all this is not what we do y'all come on in the room go ahead and uh tap that screen for me let me move this on this side let me see if I can get my light on this side y'all so I can see the comments over here we good let me get it to my comment comments over here cuz they are not here thank you love my earbobs thank you sugar let me get over here hey hey hey come on in the room listen listen this is what I need y'all to do go ahead and light the hearts up go ahead and light those hearts up I'm g go ahead and get me a sip of uh y'all I found zero sugar Snapple Apple this was Papa Sugar's favorite Snapple drink snap apple apple and so y'all know we don't need that sugar so I was shopping and I found the zero sugar Snapper Apple so yeah I need some of this but this good y'all this is really oh my goodness y'all this is good zero sugar Snapp or apple okay let me let me message Snapple and tell them honey y'all got y'all s something but let me let me go ahead and say some hell this evening y'all go ahead and jump right on in jump right on in make sure you're tapping those hard thank you so much for tapping the hearts we are at 19 Hearts 58 folks in here this evening great great cuz y'all it's confession time y'all I told you I'm coming on in the room with a little uh with a little um not too much not too much we not gonna get down like cat are we we not gonna get down like Cat Williams are we we not we not come on in the room y'all I do have some things to share I'm super excited about it and can't wait but um hold on one second CU I got my team over here I just want to make sure I get everything out that I need to get out um hold on hey D hey Heidi hey Tracy hey Stephanie hey RJ hey D hey Mary hey Marielle hey Cheryl hey Miss Janette hey Lynn hey reita let me see hey Glenda hey Cynthia hey Kathy it is freezing y'all hey Sean hey Tanya hey Addie hey Pamela hey gwendaline hey Debbie it it oh is I think it's disrespectful C everywhere okay hey Virgie um in bed eating watermelon with tahen let's come on watermelon let's get it let's get it hey duudes are we advertising for Snapper sugar no but I just had to tell y'all about that Snapple because that Snapple is good we are not advertising for Snapple but definitely uh you know what let me let me rephrase that we are not advertising for Snapple yet uh we're not you you listen you know we do have the the capabilities uh to sell out uh so I'm excited please call our names Tara you haven't done that in a while I did I'm calling your name Su but well I guess this came out later I wasn't I hadn't called anybody's names yet so but hey arj um Kathy did I call your name my sugar Rita I'm about to bring the tea baby is it sweeten with aspartame um um yes I do believe it is I can't um I can't see it I can't see it I don't have on my I don't first I don't have on my glasses that's one I don't have on my glasses but I'll definitely go and check and see it probably is and that's probably why I have not um paid attention to it before because I don't do too much with aspart tane or the um was yeah that um because it's those it's that gassy sugar and uh but this is really good and usually I try to stick with stuff that has jusia in it Glenda say it's time to buy the case oh my goodness hey Harriet hey maryan hey susette hey Michelle it is freezing hey Sheila what's going on Lynn hey Cynthia it was 56 degrees here I saw you outside Tracy up under my blanket sipping on a glass of wine I know that's right come on in the room with it yes hey Brandy what's up girl um hey Cassandra happy Founders Day thank you so very much thank you so much um so I'm super excited because it is it is our founders day so uh to all of my sers who may be on the line right now to all the beautiful women of Alpha Kappa Alpha Sor royy Incorporated happy Founders Day um it is it has been a wonderful day uh we didn't get a chance to get out too much today because you know it's all um it's cold outside it's cold um yep it's aspartame okay uh Sean looked it up y'all so it's aspan so that's what's in there hey Chronicle um Susan said the California weather is amazing um oh my gosh Dukes Peach Archard um Archard Clearly Canadian I used to drink Clearly Canadian back when I was a kid oh my gosh it was the absolute best so that was that let me tell you something that was exciting that was really exciting first things first y'all let me tell y'all this weekend I I um here in Jamaica come on yes fra yes I am thinking about uh we were actually thinking about going back um and going back to Jamaica we just we enjoyed it so much and loved it so we were like H that might be out a little spot um congratulations to all my AKA sugars from a 50y old Delta let's go let's go thank you so much good evening Tara please give a shout out to the damico Ryan in the Houston Texas Deo Ryan who is deo Ryan baby y'all got to tell me of who oh the Texas oh okay shouting out shouting them out y'all know I don't know I do not know so uh shout out to demo Ryan and the Houston Texans so y'all listen CA y'all know I don't know listen y'all hear POA sugar over there helping me out y'all tell demo y'all tell Deo we look the women outside like him we hey we good we we we good we good we love we we good just let them know we good um thanks so much thanks so much I don't know who that is and said Happy Father's day babe but thank you so much I appreciate that I absolutely appreciate that so y'all this weekend one of the things that I found is um the my social media manager Angel used a song that I absolutely loved and I have been listening to it all weekend so I'm definitely going to put it on uh I'm going to create another like uh slow andgo um fun uh not I and I'm saying fun but a relaxing uh instrumental I was about to say soundtrack but no um put some songs together and give you guys a playlist I'm going to do that uh I'll do that soon uh please come visit my Village when you come I'm in the same area near where you stay really Freda you must inbox me you must inbox me we have another sugar in um in Jamaica and and we are you know we're going to Dubai this year our big trip this year is Dubai next year our big trip is Cairo Egypt uh we're doing Cairo Egypt and the Nile and all those things and we have a sugar in Cairo and I'm super excited about that I cannot wait um she's already messaged me we're going to get together we're going to chat so I can't wait to put that together um our travel agent is working on that and uh she just as a matter of fact she messaged me earlier today and she says hey I got some amazing things going for CYO so she was like I cannot wait um to give you that information so I'm super excited about us going to Cairo next year so 2025 we will be hitting Cairo Egypt and I can boy that's gonna be amazing so I cannot wait I cannot wait um that's going to be something so exciting so let me just say um that y'all that song has had me in a whole like mood so I've been listening to that all weekend and it has been really getting me together on you know the things and the changes that's going on and uh and what's about to happen so I I am making a um a pretty nice call Tatum she's calling me let her know that I'm live um I'm I'm making something I'm making a change I'm doing I'm making some changes um to what we all know um as what what I've been um who I've been who I've represented myself as um all the things so I'm really excited about about uh being able to make this change and uh y'all going to see it in real time you'll see you know you'll see some things in in real time happen happening so um first thing is the uh if you look in the far right corner you'll see that um patio chick logo and that patio chick logo is going to go away because um patio chick as you know it uh will no longer be the same uh we are changing uh the logo we are changing uh the overall name of the patio chick and we are changing to TLP which is my name so uh we are changing everything so it's Tara L page and it's the patio chick under that um you can't see it really large right now but you'll see it in an email I will be shipping that out to you and you'll be able to see uh the new spelling of the patio chick which is very exciting uh and chick is you I no longer have to explain so just in [Music] um and I'm trying to think of you know how and I don't know how to how to say it other than you know what it was time for a change it was time for a change and so this is when this is when the confessions come um during the time that I created um black women who love Outdoor Living Spaces that is my that that's my baby and that'll never change um and I promised everyone that I said you know what um black women who who uh black women who love Outdoor Living Spaces um will will never change it will always be um black women who love outdor Living Spaces it will always stay the same it will always be for black women it will always that will be the criteria um if you want to you know um follow me on any other platform you are absolutely welcome it does not matter who you are what you know what you however you want to do that you can you can follow me but that group will always be exclusive for black women um and that was my promise that's going to always be my promise and that's going to always be uh what I want to do um when I started the patio chick I was a lost puppy like I have done businesses and all the things but y'all for me to start something like like this and for it to grow the way it grew um was way out of my league um so I thought um it was just it was just something that was different right I didn't not um there were things that I had no clue about I did not understand I did not know I was like oh my gosh what is happening and then to be called upon by um so many so many people and you know when I say so many people when when people were contacting me from Forbes when good morning in America was contacting me when um Good Housekeeping and D Magazine and you know all these all these magazines were contacting me I was like wait a minute you know wait a minute I don't know if I'm ready I don't know if I'm ready and I I I played that way I played scared and I I sat back and I for four years I sat back and I was I was really scared I didn't know if I wanted to to use my name I didn't know if I wanted to you know and then then the biggest thing was I trusted I I I I trusted people to come in and assist me and those people did not come to assist those people came to tear down and so with the patio chick as everyone knows it you know the way I spelled it everything the way I the way I did things and the way I did business people came in and you know did things that that just weren't weren't my way um and they it it just it it it messed it just messed me up you know and I was like you know what you know what I I I don't I don't need to hide behind a title I don't need to hide behind any of that I can be me I can be Tera El page and that's who I am and you know I can be Tara L page on the patio I can be Tera L page talking I can be T listen I can be ter L page and I'm so excited about it because this is totally me and it gives me the opportunity and it it just it just opens the door for me to just be me I I'm not hiding behind anything you know teror is Terror and when you see you'll see teror when you see something pop up you'll see Terror and so I'm excited to be able to be me to just you know what this is a tera El page brand and it's not I mean and the patio chick is still there it's just different it's spelled different I'm bringing my Louisiana roots in there um I'm bringing you know like this is and and so our tagline which is I'm so excited about it it's um cun charm outdoor Grace with the hint of sugar sophistication discover the patio chick elevated in Louisiana Roots one stylish bite at a time I get a chance to just be me I get a chance to just do me I get a chance to just make me me and am I okay yeah I'm great I am I'm I'm a little uh Tey because I get to do me I get to do me in a big way and I um I don't have to hide behind anything I can show up and be me and because I'm showing up and and being me and because I'm showing up as my name it makes me a little bit more careful with who I allow in my circle and it makes me a little bit more careful about who I allow to carry the ball or to carry you know because I have to have people to go where I'm going um to move where I'm moving I have to have people and I have to have good people it's unfortunate that I connected with some people who were only here to tear me down to gain what they could gain from it to steal from me to take from me in Major Way in big ways um this it's unfortunate but you know people will be people and what I what I love now is yeah you you don't you don't get a chance to Fumble this ball you don't you don't get a chance to Fumble this you don't get a chance to take who I am and just fumble the ball you can't you can't do that so while I have to have people and while I have to um you know I have to do things uh differently we we have we have some amazing people in place we have some amazing people in place to um which is great because uh you don't you can't you can't fumble this ball you can't and so uh before you get here before listen that's sad you know fool me once honey listen there will not be any more mishandling do you hear me everybody in your Inner Circle is not your in your corner greater as com absolutely everybody Circle was not in my corner and that's okay um but it it was it it was evident it was evident and um and a lot of you all saw it uh it was it was right in your face it was absolutely evident and and you saw it and you mentioned it and you said you know what you you prayed and we moved on right we moved on but what I'm so thankful for is the people that I have in my corner now um I've got you know benetta who's the finance manager who's amazing um who's right here um we've got Allison who's my legal counsel who's the attorney for T TLP um you is it's can't get too much past her she's coming through um which is which is exciting you know as you grow everyone can't come circles are getting smaller and that's okay it is it is um circles are getting smaller and that is okay uh where I'm going everybody cannot come everybody cannot be in that space um and that's okay that's okay I'm okay with that um I struggled with that I struggled with that because I wanted everybody to come I wanted everybody to be able to um to join me I wanted everybody I wanted to be able to give everybody an opportunity but um unfortunately you you can't I I can't give everybody an opportunity I can't um my platform is not that big so it's not it's not big enough for everybody um uh to to gain everything for them from me right and so I just am not able to um allow people that aren't that aren't in the position for us to collaborate and move forward together can't come here he can't no no you can't do that so are we having TPC cont absolutely absolutely it's gonna be a little few changes but absolutely TBC con is not going anywhere that's not going to change that's not gonna CH well let me say this um so it TPC is still TPC the patio chick is still uh uh the patio chick so we still you know the patio chick um we may change the name a little bit so we're working on that now um there's going to be a few name changes um to a couple of things in the patio chick conference may be one of them um the um the basis of that and what it is and how we come together is not going to change that's not going to change I love you too latan man I love you girl man I love you thank you thank you um you can't take everyone with you do do you sorrow God will always be with you amen Cassandra thank you so much sugar is hard but uh guess what what God have uh have you nobody can take that from you absolutely absolutely and I'm I'm excited about that um I'm excited about where God has me going and where he's taking me and he has been very clear about Direction and um and I'm okay with that because sometimes I you know because me and God got this this relationship and I'm like Lord you really talking to me you don't really want me to do that you're not really talk you don't want me to do that and he' be like yeah I said what I said now listen and you can not listen if you want to but I said what I said blink blink and I'm like okay so he was very clear um very clear about some things and some changes that I needed to make and some uh people that I needed to add to my circle some people that I needed to be able to trust some positions that I need need to create um which one of the positions that I have to have is I have to have an assistant and that's right here in Dallas and that's that's a hard position I'm just being honest it's a hard position it's a hard position because there's a lot there's a whole lot of pieces that go with everything that goes on there's it's just a lot it's it's a it's a big job it's big it's big shoes to feel it's it's just it's a lot involved in that um but uh whatever manetta but but it's something that I have to have and it's something that we're going to put out um soon because I have to have I have to have that person I have to have that person that um that I have to trust it I mean it comes with a very um um it's an interview process and I mean because this you know the personal assistant that I need is someone who is going to become is gonna show up at my house or is not or I mean it's gonna be with me it's going to travel with me it's going to move around with me it's going to move around the world with me like I have to have somebody who I can absolutely trust that because I don't want you know of course the NDA is going to be so Ironclad you won't be able to talk you you the only person you'll be able to talk to is God that's it and that's it CU if you say anything about anything I mean but that's that's how that's how things are being run or ran and this is how things have to be done at this point um and it's and that's okay like we just we just restructured um behind the scenes we're just doing some things in a different way and we're just really really excited about it so that's you know I am I am super super excited about where we're going with that come on NDA on them baby yes it is a big job I wish I could it's a big job um and so the um what you know as the patio chick the website it has changed over to Tel page.com um you can still email us um at the old you know the patio chick until we change everything over um it's it's a process so everything is being changed over right now so Tera lpage you can go to TL page.com um the store will change we'll have TL page home or TLP home which is good I'm excited about that um so the furniture line will be there um um so the furniture line um and that was one of the reasons of the delay for the furniture is because it's going to have my name on it it's not just gonna have Tera ELP it's not gonna have the the patio chick on it's gonna have my name so when you when you look at it's gonna have my name on it my name yeah my name and so um um I'm excited about that I don't the patio chick is a secondary name but when you order when you order furniture from TLP home you'll see Tera L page on there it'll be my signature on your furniture at your house I don't know about y'all but that's pretty got dog on excited and although I love you know the patio chick and all that the way that the patio chick was set up initially and the things that there was just a lot of negative and I'm ready to bury that and move towards Ward the positive and there is nothing more positive to me than me being me than me being the Tera that I know how to be um greeting everybody with a hay sugar and a big old fat hug so there's nothing bigger or better to me than showing up like that so I am um I'm excited I'm very very excited about that and and I can't wait I cannot wait to continue to roll these things out um and continue to roll out so you so you guys can see it so you can see what what that you know when the box is coming it has my name on the side like that is insane like what that's crazy oh my gosh so I'm excited about that I'm just just I'm yes I'm just crazy excited about that um time for a rebirth yes um kind of like um the Bible when life changed so your name a new name yep yep yep yep um Tara I'm sorry you've been taken advantage of hold your head up move forward watch your back yes I felt it but I felt I was wrong thanks for your transparency um do what you can within limits and move on you cannot include everyone don't trust everyone pray process process pray and move slow not fast absolutely absolutely and thank you so very much oh my gosh oh my gosh y'all just don't know um how many oh it I mean y'all when I tell y'all it was it has been a it has been a lot it has been a lot um to uh handle and deal with and get away from and try to you know get over the hump and crawl through the valley and get over the hill and climb to the top of the mountain and get away from the Foolery and the foolishness and the crazy people oh my gosh it was a lot um but you know what you saw you saw what you felt you felt and it had nothing to do with me it had everything to do with their own personal agendas and all the things so but now we get to move on and we get to have an amazing time uh just just enjoying uh putting this together so super I'm just when I tell you I'm super excited about this um so um discernment sharpeners yes discernment sharpeners um so let me also say um the magazine the magazine y'all so because we're doing some changes because we're doing some changes um the magazine the the magazine is dropping obviously the magazine is Dr dropping um hey Sheila thank you thank you love you love you big hugs to all of y'all oh my gosh big hugs to y'all um the magazine is dropping in March and let me tell y'all when I tell y'all I need y'all when we have the subscription when we drop the subscription the pre-sale should happen this weekend so the pre-sale for the subscript to the magazine should happen this weekend um but when it happened y'all let me tell you something hey thetus love you babe um when when I tell y'all I need y'all to show up and show out and listen I need y'all when I put this out for the magazine I need y'all to tell all your doctors to go and get it I need you to tell everybody I listen I wanted at the churches everybody I need y to tell everybody Hey listen I need you to get this subscription to this magazine y'all need to have this like we have goals for um for our magazine subscriptions of course we want to reach a certain number but a certain number just changes the way folks look at what you're doing right um and so I was like man I need I need everybody I need everybody so when we dropped the magazine so the early we we're putting together um kind of like a sneak peek of what you'll see so you won't see anything that's going to be in the magazine we're going to we're putting together um what what you will experience like the things that you experienc in the magazine which is really cool we're really excited about that um but this this is what I need help with because we've changed it and it's not just the patio chick magazine um I want y'all's help in naming this magazine yes we're doing a mockup um and so you'll see like what parts you know what parts you'll be able to experience and the things that you'll be able to see um and over time I'll be adding um I'll have some guests on the show because we're changing tour the patio we're changing into something new um I'll I'll I'll share that with you guys as well and um so that's going to be fun so we'll be interviewing some amazing people and when I do that um some of those people that'll be coming on the show to be interviewed are going to be showing up in the magazine and that's going to be really exciting uh because these are some really Heavy Hitters and I'm excited about it um I had a phone call I had a phone call last week for or someone to be a part of the magazine y'all that is a part of one of the biggest boy bands ever I was like who and they were like um well yeah um I would like I was like are you in are you serious so yeah I'm like we're even dis not this person being because I'm going to be the only one on on the front cover I'll be the only one on the cover of the magazine it's only gonna be me but this person's name um would be you know on the front like you know you know like you have the little Headliners and stuff like that so this is that is so cool that is that was so cool but but to have to have this person reach out um or their team reach out um about it just insane just insane so I was like okay and every time stuff like that happens it's like okay God you're telling me I'm doing the right thing I was like okay all right all right you you you you directed my path okay then we we're moving on we're moving on with this so I'm excited about that um but I'll I'll let y'all no I can't tell you yet I can't tell you yeah you uhuh look I can't tell you yet I have to have we have to child we gotta have that stuff on paper and once Allison approves with contracts then we can go with it yes we will have ad space so hopefully um this weekend this weekend so the uh subscription will go on sale the pre-sales will start the pre-sales will start um this weekend we also have information for ad space um the ad space is different so every body's business can go in there because it's not going to be a magazine full of just like ads um they're just um their opportunities to get in there now these are this is a full color magazine it's just like a magazine that you would see in you know at bnes & Nobles or you know old magazine or whatever like it's a full color magazine so we have it's it's a little bit I mean you know it's it's it's real magazine so um it's uh it's it's going to be it is going to be amazing it is going to be really good so yes we'll have ad space available um you'll be able to purchase ads um that goes through a process though because everybody it's not just a you know point and click and pay for an ad and oh we're gonna put your ad in it it's it's not like that um so we have to we have to be very very mindful of the ads that we put in there um the businesses that we put in there um the type of ads all the things we got to make sure that it doesn't you know like it's not too many of this or too many of this a certain amount of everything um so the team is putting that together but there is an opportunity um for ad space if you're interested in ad space that information will be available you'll be able to apply um for ad space you'll be able to see the pricing um and all that good stuff so yes there is AD space available and pre-sale will happen this weekend I'm hoping on Friday um and I'm excited about that thank you so much Robin so I'm super excited about that and so we'll be putting that out make sure um you're on the email list because it's ter L page um uh all of that we'll be going back and doing some um you'll be able to um add you'll be able to be added to um the new email um list as well so if you're already on the email list no worries we'll we're going to transfer you right on over so you'll be good will there be something that we can share on social media during pre-sale absolutely we're going to be having all kind of stuff that you can share that you can you can say you can say hey I'm gonna I you know I've got my subscription to um to the magazine and remember I'm GNA need y'all's help in figuring out this name okay yes we will have Patron ads um it is a quarterly subscription for 2024 is quarterly um 20 25 um we'll have six subscriptions and then in 2026 it will be a monthly magazine so we are going to take our time and really develop this magazine um really just really just go all in so this first the first this first year is going to be quarterly so you'll get four sub four magazines um and if you get your subscription they're going to come right to your door so I'm so excited I'm so excited about that because they're going to be floating all over the mail like yes in the little plastic sleeve and all the things and they're just going to be all in the mail and I am just so excited about that like that is going to be so crazy good like y'all that is GNA be so crazy good and so I'm excited about that because it's it's just gonna be good we be be notified by email um to purchase subscription yes we're going to be sending out emails to let you know that you can you can um purchase your subscription if you have a office if you I mean your church home y'all everybody we listen we want everybody we want this magazine everywhere we want everybody we want everybody to grab a magazine we want everybody to get a subscription um to this magazine we just want I mean y'all we want to put this out we want to put this out and if we get like no not if when when we just meet our goals of the subscriptions and all this stuff you know we're going to just get more attention which is going to be great um so more people will see your ads more people will see what we're talking about what we're doing more people will see all the content and all the things that we do like it is going to be so amazing where there be an option to give subscription absolutely you will be able to gift a subscription if you want to um so it'll be so exciting so we'll have all of those things set up for you um when we send it out we'll send it out via email you'll see it on social media you'll be able to share it via social media there'll be of course QR codes that you can share it out to um it's going to be exciting y'all it is going to be so exciting but I cannot do this by myself I'm going to need everybody I'm gonna need all hands on deck like everybody to just share this out all my look all my teacher friends all my American Airline friends all of my you know all my patio chicks listen listen we need to tell everybody we want everybody to get it out there want folks and listen if you have folks if you know people who are in the design space I am looking for the design folks like like crazy so if you have people that are in a design space tell them to get in contact with me get in contact with me thank you so much Sheila I appreciate that um I think I've gone over everything Tera refined Comfort is the brand of my dear cousin she is amazingly Talent with logos and marketing and more is that um who is that um Candy is that Candace is that you I think that's candy um I I believe I saw it and messag me or yes okay okay yes yes Candace okay okay okay that's what I thought that's what I thought yeah absolutely hit me up hit me in my inbox please uh this Georgia Clay yes hit me up uh refine Comfort I love it um y'all hit me up in my inbox we gotta we gotta get together and work um we are we we've been doing some some restructuring so that has taken me away a little bit uh but we're pulling some things together um which is really exciting um it's been it's been good y'all I'm excited so I hope you en I hope you're liking I I have a screen I was trying to point but um looking at the the new you know branding and all that stuff like it's going to be just amazing I'm just excited I'm also in the group um okay oh okay awesome awesome yes yes yes yes yes yes we chatted yes yes yes I got I got you I got you and please look up this yep got it my brilliant cousins got it got it got it um I also have a young lady that has her own brand and business I informed her of your magazine and we'll be reaching back out absolutely send me an email too you can send me you can inbox me you can inbox me or inbox me the information that will work um that's all good um that because the we're we're switching over emails because we're switching over branding and moving everything over um we're also restructuring the business and all that good stuff so we're doing a whole lot which is good we are preparing to go big and it's like go big or go home and I am planning on going super big I am not leaving anything on the table I'm going I'm going big I'm going forward so y'all I'm going to get ready to get out of here I wanted to tell you guys all of this and um um I wanted y'all to be excited I wanted y'all to be as excited as I am um but I am I am so ready hey Michelle girl I know I owe you like lunch call phone everything honey I have been oh honey it's been a lot but I got you I you on my list I promise you on my list we have been doing so much um so much to you know make some changes and all the all the good things but I am super excited about the changes that we're making I'm super excited about where we're going and what we're doing and uh super excited that you guys are coming along and uh we're about to do this man we are about to do this we are about to do this and I am so excited I'm so excited y'all this and this magazine oh my gosh y'all this magazine is going to be so dope like it's gonna be in everybody's doctor's office everybody GNA be like wait a minute yeah we going for it so anyway y'all I'mma get out of here y'all have an amazing amazing amazing amazing night I'll see y'all in the morning pray on the patio 7:30 a.m. Central Standard Time inside the group um I'm going to open that up soon but not just yet but y'all have an amazing night keep me lifted keep me prayed up I got a lot to do but I need some prayer through this process but I love y'all and I thank yall so much for riding with me I'll see y'all soon bye bye | Tara L. Paige | The Patio Chic | UChv-pkK1iRR1ZimshOs1-xA | 2024-01-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 7,096 | 34,037 |
mveBl1MPJCc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mveBl1MPJCc | You'e so hot Overused Hollywood Clichés | you guys think you're so hot you're so hot I'm so hot now that you're so hot it's ridiculous oh you're so hot I'm so hot I'm burning up you're so hot you're so hot I know you're so hot oh my God you're so hot so hot I think I might actually die yeah I'm so hot I think I'm sweating I'm so hot I'm so hot it's just so hot tonight I'm so hot you're so hot it's so hot Lana you're so hot you're so hot oh it's so hot it's so hot I'm so hot it's so hot I'm so hot there's anything here so hot well right now baby I'm so hot I'm burning up you're so hot you know you're so hot you think you're so hot you think you're so hot you're so hot you're so hot it feels so hot you're so hot you're so hot you're so hot you're so hot you're so hot oh you're so hot you're so hot you're so hot you make me wish I was a lesbian | Pop Goes The Culture TV | UCFZd4bSVJCPG2iwXB4Ct15g | 2023-01-09 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 181 | 811 |
am9K7Td2zIg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=am9K7Td2zIg | Hotel Tour: Home2 Suites by Hilton Downtown Greenville, SC | have you ever ever searched for a modern hotel that has never been modern that you that was mod they was not every one of the hotels in Greenville are getting older and older except this one you're right it's me Tessa Hotel tours and we are going to take tour home to Sweet by Hilton in Greenville South Carolina this is the new s South Carolina we have Brandon here at the Val desk uh uh right here is uh your bell desk where you can park and uh uh um so this is the B guy he will help he will help you if you don't if you don't have any if you have [Music] something my mom is working with there so this is the Bell desk and the bell desk he he also does valet here um valet parking how many floors does this hotel have six FL uh pretty sure it's four four floors [Music] okay all right we are going inside this is the for these are the carts you can grab so you can put your stuff in the room uh I I don't know what's in there I think that's the manager's [Music] office this is this is the St Lobby okay let's tell her what you doing uh I'm doing Hotel tours I'm going to put these on YouTube okay tell her your name my name is Tessa and you are very interested and I'm very interested in in hotel your name is what my name is Tessa and what is her name your name is Tess as well yes that's very rare and can you tell her how many hotels that you've been to in Greenville I've been to 40 hotels in Greenville and so you take tours is that cool you take tours and you put them on your Tessa hotel's YouTube channel yes and you guys are I think you guys are the the newer hotel that we hav't oh um if you don't if you forgot something you have a convenience here get snacks here candy your sitting area here one got one computer here the Business Center business owner if you if you have an emergency do zero for the front desk 911 emergency back here is uh uh the the B this is very rare for someone to have the same name as me uh we got coffee here this is a coffee [Music] station [Music] H and these right here are the elevators this is a very great elevator and they have a little rule here it says two is a couple three is a crowd 10 in the elevator is more than round please be safe and don't overc now here's a sneak peak at the the spin two cycle the fitness center that's you call spin cycle as you can see here I got tows I got chairs so you can fit s Rox she has the same name as me that [Music] is the zelle um so so so we got wait before I realiz do you guys have any room we do can I go see one um well right now we don't have any management here to take you up to see the room well but but yeah you can come back um tomorrow morning you want to be room we'll have to come back some other time honey I take a picture of you since your name Isa you want stand next to Tessa since T well I hope you enjoyed this mil Hotel tour Hotel book and I will see you next time for more | K Kizito | UCXP-ue5QiegbAmPAiqM3jTA | 2017-01-22 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 608 | 2,890 |
AuVg2nUgmDo | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AuVg2nUgmDo | Best Pie Crust Tip for Homemade Pie Crust, Why Does Loose it's Shape? | hey y'all it's timmy with collard valley cooks i'm going to start making all holiday recipes things that we would have on our holiday table today we're making a homemade pie crust because you can't have the holidays without making a pie this pie crust is in our volume 2 cookbook now this pie crust today is made with shortening i have several different ones when you use shortening the pea sized shortening pieces help the crust fluff up and be flaky that's my favorite pie crust shortening pie crust we're going to start out with one and one half cups of flour one and a half cups of flour now we're going to use a whole half cup of shortening that's a lot y'all all right we're going to add a quarter teaspoon of salt and then we're going to blend this with a blending fork start it off with flour on top of the shortening and that way it doesn't get your blending fork too sticky to start with and it will just continue to blend really really well you're going to just press your shortening up against the sides of the bowl if you have a fully fork blending fork like i use make sure you have pyrex uh bowl set because it fits right up against the edges really easy and um it will save you a lot of time because it just does such a good job in this type of a bowl the shape of it's perfect for your foley fork now you can see the shortening is about the size of a pea for the most part and that's where you want it to be do not blend it until it's all incorporated in tiny pieces or your pie crust will not be as flaky now this is the last step we're going to add water until this dough just barely stops cleaning from the sides of the bowl it can vary by how you measured your flour so i'm going to go ahead and start out because i know it's going to take four at least so i'm just gonna go ahead and add four i think i might have drizzled some in there at the same time it's anywhere from three to five tablespoons typically about how much it's going to take so now you're just going to take your fork and press it in together good you need to continue to blend and don't add extra water unless you absolutely need it so just continue pressing it into the bowl with your foley fork we've still got a little bit of flour on this opposite side so i'm going to try to get that incorporated in and if i can then i don't have to add any more water i think it's good to go now at this point you clean off your foley fork you take your hand and you grab all the dough together this is how it should look in your bowl it should still look dry but your crust is nice and moist at the same time now i'm just going to take this dough we just need to let the shortening and water react with the flour so a lot of mistakes people make is they mix up a pie crust and they go ahead and roll it out and you have to wrap it with saran wrap or plastic wrap and put it in the refrigerator for 30 minutes so that it can go through a process if you don't then your dough is going to shrink up in your pie plate you can refrigerate it longer just make sure it's a minimum of 30 minutes in the refrigerator before you roll it out for your pie this is a pre-baked crust that was not refrigerated before it was rolled out you can see how the sides look and how they've drawn from the edge and how they're not nice and smooth and pretty they're just kind of dimply looking that's what happens when you don't refrigerate all right we've got our pie crust it was in the refrigerator probably about an hour actually and you can leave it in there longer and i've had it out for just a few minutes so it's still kind of it's still pretty cold um we're going to use our sifter and just barely lightly set the surface with a little flour put out our pie crust sift it a little bit and we're going to roll it now when you roll a pie crust you turn it quarter turns and you just keep oh let's need it first let's knead it a little bit first just a few times now you can see how it looks flaky that's how you want it to look and that's what the shortening does a lot of people make a pie crust out of oil and it works but it's not going to be real flaky like this crust is going to be so you're just going to turn it as you roll [Music] now you're going to take your pie plate and lay down on it and you can see we don't have a good inch around the edges so we do not have it rolled out quite good enough and if you have to take some off and fill in some holes do it before you continue to roll it you can you can wet it just a little bit get the stick better now if you get a really big pipeline you might have to go inch and a half around the edge but i've just got a standard pyrex old-fashioned pie plate they're my favorite because they have an edge that you can use for your pie crust and we're going to roll this up i'm actually going to roll it out bottom to the top because it's the prettiest okay and we're going to lay this in the plate until we kind of get it straight all right okay here we have our pie in our nice beautiful crust you can tell this has been refrigerated just by the way it looks it looks so different than the one that wasn't and i am just going to start decorating the sides i'm going to pinch them i'm just going to fold it over and pinch it fold it over and pinch it like that i was missing a little bit of dough right here so i'm going to trade it out so that was on the other side just so that it's pretty there's a there's a skippy wimpy section two all right you're going to be able to really tell a difference in the crust that you refrigerated and the crust that you did not refrigerate you can already tell that it's smoother looking before we even put it in the oven and show them that one over there close up now look at this one and look at the difference it's going to make a big difference in the texture of your pie crust same ingredients all right here's our homemade crust and i want you to see that it's nice and flaky this is the shortening crust i'm just showing you the crust it's nice and dry with that egg custard in there and it was a really wet feeling you can see when i break it apart that you can kind of see the layers in there and see that it's flaky it's a really good pie dough i love it you | Collard Valley Cooks | UCm99dyZUE7Oa6Lm9-wZVlcg | 2020-09-10 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,271 | 6,225 |
SOjSzRPKZ-8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SOjSzRPKZ-8 | [Latest News] Brie Larson takes flight as Captain Marvel on this week's EW cover - 2018 | [Music] there's a bright new star in the Marvel Cinematic Universe Captain Marvel leads the cover of Entertainment Weekly's new issue with an exclusive first look at brie Larson's Air Force pilot turned into your galactic hero film fans know Carol Danvers only as the mysterious person paged by Nick Fury Samuel hell Jackson in the last scene of Avengers infinity war and she'll appear in the still untitled Avengers 4 presumably to help beat up on Venice but before that she's got her own story to tell and he who has all the exclusive Intel under upcoming solo film when Captain Marvel hits theaters March 8 2019 it'll be the 21st entry in the MCU and the first to star a solo female superhero in the past decade the MCU has assembled a diverse lineup of female heroes from witches and warriors to widows and wasps but never before has a woman headlined her own story until Captain Marvel the part three part human pilot who made her Comics debut back in 1968 she can't help but be herself Larson tells you look she can be aggressive and she can have a temper and she can be a little invasive and in-your-face she's also quick to jump to things which makes her amazing in battle because she's the first one out there and doesn't always wait for orders but the not waiting for orders is to some a character block he was covered below finds Carol somewhere between we heard and the sky a fitting place for a hero who's trying to figure out how to reconcile her alien abilities with her more human flaws directed by Anna Boden Ryan black captain marvel sidesteps the traditional origin story template and when it begins Carol already has her powers she's left her earthly life behind to join an elite Kree military team called Star Force led by Jude Law's enigmatic commander but before long Carol finds herself back on earth with new questions about her past and she's got a formidable enemy in the form of the Skrulls the notorious marvel bat has made all the more dangerous by their shape-shifting abilities ben mendelsohn plays their leader Talos whose fear hence astro invasion of earth speaking of earth Captain Marvel takes place in the mid - 90s long before Steve Rogers which defrosted or Tony Stark built his first suit that allows the film to introduce younger version of familiar Marvel faces like Jackson's Nick Fury who's still a two-eyed s.h.i.e.l.d desk jockey as well as let Carol carve out her own unique space in the MCU [Music] | USA Morning | UCtofAt3j1KSpV8CzQHdRe8w | 2018-09-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 438 | 2,446 |
AZFquAWKruE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZFquAWKruE | Four-dimensional Supersymmetric Dynamics from Six Dimensions - Lecture 3 | all right so Roma will continue with a third lecture today thank you okay so let me remind you where we ended hour and a half ago so we're discussing the reduction of Eastern Theory from six dimensions to four dimensions and the thing that we mentioned about this ring is that it is some 60s C of T that has an e 8 symmetry the 6d symmetry is e 8 and we mentioned that upon compactification to 5d this theory has a description and effective description as an su 2 t plus 8 hyper multiplets and from this we did use that we might have punctures in this theory when we compactify the C string theory on a riemann surface with punctures the punctures will carry a signal a symmetry which is the 5 d gauge symmetry which is frozen on this boundary which will be as you - ok so the way we did in our general discussion when we discuss punctures we said that this flavor symmetry arises because we freeze when we put boundary condition delish lab boundary conditions on the boundary for the gauge fields of the 5d gauge theory and we need to specify some boundary conditions for other fields so again there are some variety of boundary conditions that one can consider and there is a useful boundary condition here where you do this directly boundary condition for the vector fields and you also do the richland for eight chiral so you can think of the eight hyper multiplets in the four dimensional n equal one languages being eight built like every hyper is built from to carol's like leonardo was discussing and then we put neumann boundary condition for other update of Cairo so all in all we have 16 Carroll fields and we put the rest a boundary condition for eight of them and Norman boundary condition for others and then you need to do something for the fermions so the claim is that the research boundary condition which preserves supersymmetry now what is my what is interesting about these boundary conditions when you put when you put some of these boundary conditions they break some of the symmetry of the 5d theory explicitly so as we discuss the 6d symmetry is e8 once we turn on hollow noemi's certain Helana me which breaks 8 2 a so 14 times c1 we expect to get an S of 14 times u 1 symmetry in five dimensions in this case we get actually a symmetry which is a so 16 times a1 which comes from the from the instantons and these types of boundary conditions break this s so 16 further to su 8 times u 1 so there are various ways we can break different symmetries in these compactification one of them is the choice of flux that we will in a moment discuss the when we go to five dimensions there are these falada miss that can break symmetries and also the boundary conditions that the punctures can break symmetry so in presence of this type of punctures which we'll call maximal the expected symmetry of the four-dimensional theory once will continue compacta fiying this theory down to four dimensions is expected to be at most as u 8 times C 1 and symmetry so next what we will do is discuss go back to six dimensions and discuss what type of fluxes can we turn on for the global symmetry for the e8 a global symmetry that we have in things dimensions yes yes yes that's so the this will be this will be making this so you basically frozen the field so the the comp the the field is frozen on the boundary now you need to make it dynamical so you need to integrate over it in the past integral so that's what you do yes oh so you can introduce there is some freedom in defining these punctures is is a rich there is a rich story there you can do it in a various way for example you can choose in some sense what modes live live on the boundary there is some choice of what you can do what happens is that when you glue two punctures together you know these modes whatever you introduce on a puncture should be such that they wants you you identify the the gauge fields of the two theories you this edge mode should disappear for example if you introduce some fields some chiral fields that live on this on this boundary they should become massive when you glue to glue things together maybe when we will discuss a very concrete example of what kind of you know theory you will get in in four dimensions what is the theory on the domain wall and on this cylinder you will see how it comes about that ask me again if that answer is not will not be good enough okay so now we will do some group to your exercise so we need to understand we have a 6d theory we put it on a Riemann surface and we want to turn on some flux on this riemann surface so what are the allowed choices of fluxes so this turns out to be a very rich question to ask as we discussed yesterday different choices of fluxes might lead to different theories so what are the different choices of fluxes here so let me give first an example of a simpler group than the eight I don't think many people have intuition about the eight I certainly don't have an intuition about eight but we have intuition about sinking smaller groups so for example let's say the symmetry was su for something simpler that we can understand and then you can ask say you want to choose some u one inside this su for internal flux for this u1 what type of inequivalent choices you can have and even for this simple group you have some inequivalent choices for example you can choose any one in such a way that su for breaks into su 3 times u1 this is one choice that you can make in this choice for example a fundamental office you for will be a fundamental of SU 3 with some charge under this u1 and then a singlet with some other charge and the less you want there are other choices however that you can entertain for example you can take an su 4 and break it to su 2 times su 2 times u 1 this is another thing you can do it is in equivalent breaking the group's after you choose this u 1 are different and this in this choice you take a 4 and then you break it to something like singlet of 1 su 2 a doublet of another and this will have charge plus 1 and then you will have 2 1 charge minus 1 so it's a different breaking so if you turn on flux in this u 1 or in this u 1 the symmetry that will be preserved by the choice of flux will be different here the symmetry will be su 3 times u 1 here it will be a su 2 times a CO 2 times u 1 this would be X they expected symmetry of the four dimension theory and it is different and again there are other things which can break the symmetry for example choices of punctures but just the flux can give you a very rich variety of behaviors and there is a neat way to understand these different patterns of breaking of symmetry using dinking diagram so let me draw it here for example the dinking diagram of off su for is something like that and then a choice of u1 inside inside thus you for and is given by choosing a node in this thinking diagram so for example this corresponds to choosing the first node the last node or the first node and then this is the Dinkin diagram of s u3 that is what remains after you chose the one or you can do the node in the center and then the mutant group will be to ask you to and this you won so let us now do this analysis of possible fluxes that you can have for the e8 group and the eight group is much richer group then su for and you have a very wide variety of fluxes that you can turn on so what is the linking diagram of e8 this is this monstrosity again some people might not call it a monstrosity okay and then we can classify all the possible inequivalent choices of of you want embed it in the eight and they would correspond to choosing a node on this link in degree for example choosing the first node we will have a flux which breaks the eight to is seven times u1 this is the seven is what we are left with and then we can continue choosing this node will get e 6 times su 2 times u1 then choosing choosing the next node we will get NSO 10 times su 3 times u1 and we can continue there are many choices there are basically a choices so we will discuss in detail these two choices as well as another one where we will get an Esso 14 times C 1 and this corresponds there so 14 times u1 corresponds to choosing this node in the Lincoln diagram so there is a very wide varieties of groups that you can break - and these groups are expected to be the symmetry groups of the fourth dimension theory so we start with a single theory in six dimensions which has an e 8 symmetry and then upon choosing fluxes in different subgroups of U 1 of this of this e 8 different subgroups different embeddings of u 1 inside this 8 we can get different groups in 4 dimensions and then of course on top of this we can start turning fluxes in more than one you want and we can start breaking the symmetries which are listed here to further - much richer set of symmetries in in the end we can get a lot of different theories with different symmetry properties in four dimensions is this clear okay so now what kept there was a question so now what we can do as I also mentioned to you in the end of last last lecture we don't know just the the symmetry of this theory we'll also know that host anomalies which can be packaged in the eighth form anomaly polynomial so now by turning on a flux and compactify on the riemann surface we also can predict what will be the anomalies that host anomalies of the 42 and the computation is very simple to compute the 16 anomaly polynomial so sorry the for the anomaly polynomial which is some six form so it's the anomaly polynomial for T the only thing that you need to do is to take your 6t anomaly polynomial and date form anomaly polynomial in 60 and integrate it over the riemann surface in presence of the flux that you have turned on so remember that I have written down this anomaly polynomial in terms of some characteristic classes so you need to turn on this background gauge fields that you that are supported on this riemann surface and integrate over the choice of your riemann surface so in indiana stock and also tomorrow we will only consider the riemann surface which will be a torus but this procedure is completely generic and the computation is right there a rather straightforward you need to be well-versed in all these types of group theories and manipulating characteristic classes but it's basically something you can just fill to Mathematica or find a graduate student who can feed it to Mathematica and forget about it once and for all it's rather simple computer and let me just outline to like couple of important ingredients which go into it and in particular how these choices of Lux different embeddings of the you want since I did enter in this type of computation so there are various characteristic classes which appear there for example there appeared ec2 of eight inside this anomaly polynomial that I have written down and the moment you have broken down and broken the symmetry you have explicitly turn on some flux for some u1 in this eight you need to specify how this characteristic class breaks into into characteristic classes of groups which remain after the breaking for example is six times as you to ten times e1 and so on so this is a group theory exercise that you can do and you can find that in this this is given by the following so there is some for every choice of U 1 so a labels the choice of U 1 so here we have these choices of you ones you will get the following group theoretical result that you get characteristic class of this some characteristic class of this u 1 multiplied by some number given by the choice of that u 1 which I will soon right and then you sum over the groups which appear in the commute and of this u 1 these are the G J's different factors here except for these factors are all of the factors will appear in in this decomposition and what I need to specify to you is what what is what are these values of say say a for different choices of the groups so this say a is equal to 1 for example when the commute --nt is equal to 7 it's equal to 2 when the commute is equal to 6 times su 2 and I don't remember the others by heart so in case of a so 10 you get a 6 and in case of a so 14 you get sorry here you get a 3 here you get the tool some group theory computation that you need to perform after doing this you just declare that that you turn on some flux for the you wanted that you have chosen and to do so you find some form some to form which some canonical form which is supported on this riemann surface and you demand that it integrates to one with proper normalization and you define that this characteristic class for the u1 that you have chosen this u 1 a is just given by your choice of flux which is the number now times this to form plus the following thing plus c1 of u1 f whereby u1 f i call the symmetry this u 1 symmetry which remains in four dimension so you have this u 1 symmetry to which you turn on in flux and this flux the can have support on these two dimensional riemann surface this is given here but also you can turn on background gauge fields which are supporting in four dimensions and this part which is supported in four dimensions i call it like that so once you have done that and you know how to decompose different characteristic classes which appear in the anomaly polynomial again you find a graduate student or your friend in your case and ask them to feed it into Mathematica they feed it into Mathematica and compute this integral and which spits out the anomaly polynomial of the four dimension theory so now what you know is what are the symmetries of the theories you obtain in these compactification and what are the anomalies what are the truth the nominees so this is a rather it's rather technical and often subtle group theoretically computation to perform but it's completely straightforward ok so once you have obtained anomaly polynomial in four dimensions you have gotten this all of the two of the nominees you can ask interesting questions for example you can ask what are these conformal anomalies a and C that Leonardo has mentioned in the previous hour of this four dimension theories that you obtain so how would you compute this this conformal anomalies so the you started in six dimensions from some theory which had this global symmetry but it was so was a supersymmetric theories so it had some are symmetry and then you are you go down to four dimensions you you get the theory which has an N equal one our symmetry in four dimension in an equivalent supersymmetry in four dimensions which has an ER symmetry and this six dimensional symmetry deduces reduces to their symmetry in four dimensions but because you have the the you want the the global symmetry has has been broken from this non abelian group he ate down to some non abelian factors and a one this you want to which you gave a flux to can now add mix mix with the r symmetry the six dimension are symmetry which you get the are symmetry in four dimensions which you get directly from their symmetry in six dimensions and as also appeared in the in in Leonardo's lectures their symmetry is very important it appears it is part of the super conformal algebra so there is a question of what is the exactly they are symmetry which appears in the super conformal algebra and that our symmetry will be some mixing of this 61u one are symmetry that you can call it 61 r plus some some coefficient some some some parameter times the symmetry the the one symmetry that you get in this compactification and you need to fix this epsilon there was a question yes of fluxes so the flux that we are talking about which parameter is the compactification is a flux supported on the riemann surface then you can turn on anything you want you can consider the four dimension manifold to be whatever you want and you can put whatever classical gauge configurations that you want on that four dimensional space you don't compactify it so you just keep it generic and then your anomaly polynomial in 4d will be a function of those fluxes the fluxes that you turned on on the riemann surface will parameterize different choices of theories those fluxes will just parameterizing different there are some parameters in the anomaly polynomial and they from from expanding this anomaly polynomial you can in in this characteristic classes you can read off the different of the nominees okay so now the question is how you fix this epsilon and this epsilon is famously fixed by what is called a maximization procedure so let me just remind you what it is so the maximization of interrogator and weft what you do you write you use a very neat relation between these anomalies a and C and super super conformal are symmetries so again as leonardo was mentioning in the previous talk all these quantities all these different charges talk to each other different conserved currents in reading live in the same same multiplets and this anomalous appearing in some correlation functions of stress energy tensor so there are some neat relations between these anomalies and and our symmetries for example the a anomaly satisfies the following relation it is given simply by three over thirty-two times thrice the cubic anomaly of the earth symmetry - trace of are the linear anomaly in in art and the C is given by 1 over 32 times 9 trace R cubed minus 5 trays are and so what you do what in Thrilla gator and whacked and tell us to do so this holds only for the super conformal our symmetry so what you do you choose to parameterize your our symmetry by you're naive guess which is here naturally given by the 6d our symmetry and you had mixed to it arbitrarily this you want f that you get you get some expression for this anomaly which depends on this parameter epsilon and you maximize it and you're super conformal or symmetry assignment is whatever you got you get by this maximization there are assumptions in this procedure for example this procedure only works if you identified all your symmetries correctly so if you know all the you want symmetries then you can do this procedure as we are discussing emergence of symmetries and and and phenomena like that it can be that we have some symmetries which existence of which we expect from this compactification procedure but once we go to four dimensions some accidental you want symmetries appear and then this procedure of getting super conformal a and C's by using this a maximization will be wrong because we need to add mix here all the possible you wants nevertheless in the case that I am discussing this there is no actually interesting you want that that appear and you can do this computation so I will just give you the final result so again you just take the 60 anomaly polynomial you integrate it over the riemann surface with your choice of fluxes and you can compute your a and c and in this particular case where you take an e string on a torus with flux to one to a single u1 the answer is very simple for example the a anomaly is it given by twice square root of sy times the value of flux absolute value of flux and the thea normally is five halves where root of sy times the value of flux okay very simple result maybe I should stress that you because of this issue that you might worry about accidental you want said you will appear you don't have to compute these anomalies you simply can look for theories which in four dimensions which will reproduce the full anomaly polynomial the four dimensional anomaly polynomial but these numbers are very easy to remember and there it is easy to compare so the next thing we will need to do is to try to find four dimensional theories which have these anomalies and more generally the anomaly polynomial exactly the same anomaly polynomial that we will deduce from six dimensions and the same symmetries that we would deduce from six dimensions okay so these are predictions from six dimensions that we can have very very simple predictions following just by knowing the symmetry and they are normally polynomial of the six dimensional field there is another small group Theory exercise that I will need to perform to generalize this result and then we will finally go to four dimensions okay so the group Theory exercise I want to tell you about is a nice parameterization of fluxes for for more general choices so say you have many you choose many you wants inside this e8 and you turn on arbitrary fluxes for them so what is the nice choice of you want that nice basis of you wants in terms of which you can work in terms of which you can specify the fluxes there are many different choices so this is a rank a group you can choose many combination of the eighty ones which appear in the curtain of the c8 there is one particularly nice parameterization in it uses the fact that he eight has a maximal subgroup maximal subgroup which is Esso sixteen and although we don't most of us don't have nice intuition about it most of us do have intuition about Cecil sixteen this is a very simple group it is also ranked eighth group this is the maximum subgroup of eight so we can parameterize the different choices of Fluxus as Fluxus for the curtain generators of this so sixteenth in particular for example a flux in our normalization flux which will be of the form four zero zero zero there will be seven zeros here hey this will be a vector of fluxes for the eight different carton generators of this s Oh 16 this flux breaks a so sixteen symmetry to a so 14 times u1 and this is easy to understand you have you have here these a generators and do you just choose one so2 and you give a flux for that asoto and you get a you and you get that asymmetry break stress so 14 times u1 there are other equivalent choices different but equivalent choices of fluxes for example you can use wild symmetry of s so 16 to turn on flux which is of the form 0 4 0 so on this is also breaks this is also breaking the they e8 symmetry down to a so 14 times u1 this is rather simple to understand what is less simple to understand is that you can use wild symmetry while of e8 to generate these types of permutations we use well symmetry of a so 16 which we intuitively understand to get equivalent values of fluxes but using the wild symmetry of 8 which is rather less intuitive one can show that also such choices of fluxes corresponds to breaking the symmetry down to s of 14 times u1 okay and this I don't know how to explain to maybe somebody else can okay and let me mention what in this basis what are the fluxes which correspond to break the symmetry breaking the symmetry to other groups that we will later use in four dimensions so for example if you want to break the symmetry to u1 x e7 this is a simple flux which has the form 1 1 just all eight values being 1 then we can there is an equivalent choice of flux again by using the wild symmetry of of 8 which will give two nonzero values and then rest being zeros and for e 6 times a CO 2 you get the vector of flux which will be one one six ones and two zeros and you can generate other choices by playing this well symmetry for games but we will not use it later on and finally in terms of these choices of fluxes law so let me call these eight numbers to call them to be fi then turning on a general value for these fluxes the a and C anomaly take the very simple form so a is equal twice times square root of 2 sum of I equals 1 till 8 F I over a Phi squared a Phi over 4 squared okay and C is equal to 5 halves sum over to sum of i from 1 to 8 F I over 4 squared so these are the all the predictions we will use from 6 dimensions to try to find four-dimensional theories okay so now we will move to deriving this four dimensional view so any questions about that okay so the next step in our program after we understood what the Fluxus we can turn on and made some generic prescriptions about what type of what type of numbers we can get in four dimensions what type of symmetries and what type of anomalies the next step would be to go to five dimensions and to understand the domain walls which correspond to these different values of flux okay so I remind you we are going to five dimensions and we engineering the flux in five dimensions as some kind of domain wall which interpolates between two different theories on the left and on the right two different hole on Amis and two different different and these two different : amis like the exact relation between the autonomy on the left and Alana mural on the right should give us some very particular value of flux so figuring out this problem given the flux what is the domain well it's very very hard problem to do I don't know how to do it algorithmically okay for example you would think that taking two comma zero theory and which has more supersymmetry and trying to understand this domain walls for two comma zero will be a simple problem but it's actually a hard problem except for the a 1 2 comma 0 theory I don't know what is domain wall theories are for so in general this domain wall theories can be complicated so the way to go is usually you go about things when you do do physics and and encounter complicated problems you make an educated guess you make an educated guess and then you check it in all the possible ways so we're going to make this educated guess and I will tell you what are types of checks that one can perform so the the claim is that if you take flux to be there is seven flags and in the normalization I use there the flux is such that all these entries are a half then what you get on a domain wall with particular choice of punctures is a very simple theory so the theory looks like that okay on the domain wall you have just a collection of free fields which I will denote like that so on on the Left we have an su 2 gauge symmetry and we have an su 2 gauge symmetry on the right so let's call it a and B so on the domain wall leaves a simple theory which is a theory of free a chiral fields it's a four dimensional theory the we have by fundamental fields that I will denote by Q so these are the by fundamental fields and another field that I will denote by X and it will see they're not the cuivre notation the graphic notation will be just crossing the the corresponding line this X is a chiral field which is a singlet under ditch under both of this su 2 symmetries and there is a super potential coupling them so these are by fundamental fields of to SEO toes so we have a super potential which is of the form epsilon IJ epsilon a B Q I a QJ B times X okay where I and they the two indices are indices under this su 2 and this su 2 these are just free fields that you get so the claim is that this is the theory on the domain well it's an extremely simple theory and these theory couples to the two the theory on the left to the gauge fields on the left this is the symmetry which is gauge on the left and this is the symmetry of which is gauged on the right and attack couples also to the matter that we have on the left hand on the right remember that on the left and on the right we have this hyper multiplets and the claim is the the theory you obtain by taking this system of this domain wall theory coupled to the metal fields on the left hand on the right is this resume in a model so you add an octet of fields these are the eight chiral fields to which we gave Neumann boundary conditions when we define the puncture on the left and optative fields which gotten a neumann boundary condition on the right and once you are down to four dimensions the theory that you get is this extremely simple resume in a model so let's call this field Phi left and this Phi right so there is an additional term in the super-super potential which is Phi left if I write x this field Q this by fundamental field Q so as usual if you have a quiver theory you can read off a super super potential term from it by going over the face over of the quiver and I need to specify to you different charges of the fields so for example the are charges of these fields are 1 1 these are the six dimensional charges are charges you deduce from six dimensions and Q has our charge zero and exists are charged to and there is an additional u1 that that you have here and under that you want this is charged plus 1 this is just plus 1 q is charged minus 2 and X is charged for ok and the symmetry that you see this theory has there is another you want which is accidental but this this u 1 and this su 8 are the important symmetries and these are exactly the symmetries we expect a tube like that to have remember that the boundary conditions have broken the symmetry down to su 8 times u 1 so this is the su L and the yellow charges here denote charge assignments under the u 1 symmetry so this is a conjecture this is an educated guess why is it an educated guess what what went into guessing this thing what went into guessing thing into guessing this thing was comparing anomalous of these theorists to 2 and theory that theorists that one can build from it as we will discuss now to the anomalies predicted from six dimensions and making making a very wide varieties of checks that I will discuss today and tomorrow okay so we're finally in four dimensions we we have a conjecture for a theory which corresponds to compactification so on a very very simple surface with very particular value of flux and now we need to check whether you know the theories will build from this very simple theory for example gluing these theories together to form a torus with arbitrary values of flux and we will see how one can build an arbitrary theories with theories with arbitrary values of flux from this very simple building block whether they reproduce the anomalies that are predicted from six dimensions and symmetry properties that are predicted in six dimensions so these are the anomalies we need to reproduce and then they have this really funny symmetries that we need to get sometimes the symmetry we would expect will be a so 14 sometimes the symmetry we expect will be seven depending on the value of the total flux when we can combine these species together so in seven is six times as you 2 times e1 there will be many different things the building block has very simple symmetry su a times u1 and if what we are saying is correct the theory is that we will build have to have this enhanced symmetry which is a highly non-trivial check of the proposal and this is exactly how we discussed yesterday this emergence of symmetry could be predicted and engineered in these types of constructions any questions ok so to build theories from this building block I need to tell you how I glue these theories together how I combined them together so geometrically as we discussed what we say we understand one building block with some flux F and another building block with sorry with another flux F Prime geometrically what we need to do is just glue these two tubes together and I indicated that what you need to do when you glue these things together in filter E is to gauge the symmetry which corresponds to the puncture identify symmetries of two of two tubes and gauge them together okay and reintroduce whatever fields you gave directly boundary conditions to so let us do it for this tube so let us take two tubes su 2 and su 2 and then we have an su 8 here so this is one tube like that with that value of flux and we put next to it another tube the same types of type of tube and we ask ourselves how should we glue these things together okay so the symmetry which corresponds to the puncture is this su 2 this is the symmetry corresponding to this puncture this is a c2 corresponding to this puncture this is u 2 corresponds to the puncture on the left and this is U 2 corresponds to the function on the right here so what we are instructed to do is to take this flavor su two symmetries and make them dynamical take the diagonal combination of this su to engage them so we identify these two su to us and we gauge them another thing we need to do we need to reintroduce the chiral fields to which we gave de richelieu boundary conditions to remember that we gave Noah minbari boundary conditions to one octet and de richelieu boundary conditions to the other octet in the in the hyper multiplet so we need to arraign to reduce another octet of fields of fundamental fields when we are doing this gauging however the here since we have duration fields which I had Norman boundary conditions on the left and on the right we have two copies of them but originally we had only one copy we need to get rid of one of the two copies and that we do by turning on some super potential so let's call for this by fundamental of this su 2 x su 8 a field fine so the super potential that we turn which identifies between this field to this field is a term of the form W equals Phi times this Phi Phi right 1 times Phi left 2 so this is Phi right 1 and this is Phi sorry fun not like that Phi left 2 so this is the super potential plus not x ok and then by chiral ring relations by acclaim by equations of this Phi we set to 0 1 combinations of this two fields Phi and only one remains ok and by lead by explicitly writing this gauge theory that you obtain you get that this tier is equal just to 2 then this gave one of the less you to bang in the middle became a dynamical su 2 then you have an su 2 here and then the quaver looks like that 8 or something like that ok and with an X here okay so this is the theory you have obtained by gluing together two tubes you started with two tubes we have which have this flux so this theory that we obtained by gluing two theories together two tubes together should have flux which is equal the sum of fluxes so this tube should have flux which is one and like all the entries are 1 and again what we need to do is check whether this this statement this does the statement that this and in theory should correspond to a tube with this value of flux meets all the requirements of symmetry enhancement and whether it reproduces the anomalies I did not tell you how how to compute anomalies of theories with punctures of what is the the prediction for anomalies of theories of punctures I only told you what are the predictions for territories which correspond to compactification zone the torus so to compare to these types of result I need to take many such tubes and glue them together to form a torus okay so how is such a theory look like it will have the following form okay so taking two F tubes of this form and gluing them together to form a torus you will obtain a quaver theory which looks like that so you have many gauge as you to gauge groups you have such a circle of a co2 gauge groups and then you have by fundamental fields of of this su a x su tow and the number of the gauge groups is 2 F where F is the value of flux for day 7 so if our predictions are correct what this theory should have at hand it should have these types of anomalies where 4f is you know you put the right value of the facts and it should have symmetry which is an e7 symmetry the explicit symmetry that you see in this quiver theory is again only su 8 times C 1 so this is the SU 8 that I have written down and there is another non-anomalous you want that you can find moving around again under that you want these filters are charge plus 1 all of them and these fields are charge minus 2 so ok so first thing we need to do is to compute the a and C are normally anomalous of this theory now this is extremely simple thing to do so what you need to find first is what is the choice of the super conformal are symmetry for this quiver now look on each gauge no each gauge node has 12 chiral 12 fundamental chiral fields the way it goes that you have to coming from here to fundamentals coming from here and an octet of fundamentals coming from here soul and all you have 12 fundamental fields so in terms of this classification of su and theories with the numbers of flavours so what we have is an su to Tier II with six flavors the way you count the flavors you have enough fundamentals and enough aunty fundamentals here there is no difference between fundamentals and ante fundamentals so you have six flavors which means you have six 12 fundamentals in total you might know that this particular theory the super conformal are symmetry that that you can assign to if you just look at this theory on a single node then they are normally free are symmetry which which is that which doesn't break any of these of the symmetry that this theory has is equal to 2/3 it's a freer symmetry and if you look on a single node in this gauge Theory every single node is a free node the one loop beta function vanishes and actually it is believed that every single node in isolation is an a our free theory is just a free theory with the super conformal our symmetries being given by 2/3 however when you combine these these gauge groups together with these super potentials you can show and I will not do it today maybe I will do it tomorrow this theory actually has a conformal manifold it's not a free theory confirm a manifold of the type that Leonardo has mentioned which passes through zero coupling ok so it's a theory which is basically conformal like N equals 4t or is conformal N equals four theory passes through 0 coupling but it has a conformal manifold this theory also has such a conformal month now using this assignment of charges are equal to 2/3 using the relation between a and C and super conformal symmetry that I have mentioned it is very easy to compute and I encourage you to do that that the a anomaly of this tier is simply given by twice the value of the flux okay and the value of the flux is given here the the number of gauge groups is twice the value of the flux so that's how the flux enters into this quaver description and the value of the c anomaly is precisely five halves times F okay so exactly as was predicted from six dimensions that the theory with any seven flux should have okay so this is a very non-trivial check of this proposal the first check that I discussed so again this was an educated guess this is a first check of that educated guess when we combine these theories together we get the right anomalies for the for the flux that we claimed that this type of a tube should have however if we have any seven facts the theory should have any seven symmetry is seven times you want symmetry this theory has only as you eight times u 1 symmetry okay so what is happening here okay what you can do is you can study what are the gauging what are the gauge invariant say protected operators that you have in this theory this is a very nice set of operators that you can discuss so the simplest operators are just just the gauge singlet fields that you can build from these fields which I called Phi basically take this fields Phi I a Phi IB and enticing symmetrize I I and J indices here these are the su 2 indices and then you need to ante symmetrize the a and B indices which are the su 8 indices so these are some operators gauge invariant operators that you can build from a single field here these are the simplest gauge invariant operators that you can build and one of these you see this there are two types of operators depending on the on the arrow so there are fundamentals or anti fundamentals so one of them will give you something which is in 20 in representation in twenty eight dimensional representation of this sua the other one will give you 28 bar okay and then the number of such fields such operators that you have you have F operators of this type and F operators of this type because you have F lines of one type and DEF lines of the other type so all in all what you have that the simplest say protected operators that you have they the number of you can think of them as f copies of something which transforms in 28 plus 28 bar dimensional representation of as you ate and if you think of is 7 in terms of its su-8 subgroup 28 plus 28 bar is the decomposition of simplest representation of e 7 which is called which is a 56 dimensional representation and if you look now on any product that operators that this theory has you will always find that this operators sit in these seven representations ok so what this hints is that maybe you don't see the is 7 symmetry appearing for this theory at wake up link at the origin of this model of this conformal manifold but it is one can one can entertain the possibility that somewhere on this conformal manifold maybe in some strongly coupled regime the e7 symmetry appears it enhances ok so this is how the seven symmetry appears here and this is how the anomalies are consistent with the sixty prediction ok the questions yes say it again so we can divide it into arbitrary number of parts so the the building block that I have defined is a building block for for a flux which is given by this vector of fluxes half half and half all of all of the entries halves so if we want a flux which is f we need to take two F such blocks and glue them together so if you wish we started from a torus which has two F in flux to F and we divided in sorry flux F and we divide it into 2 F pieces and you could divide it in just into two pieces but then we I didn't tell you what the Theory corresponding to those pieces would be and then you know you would need to continue dividing until you get a building block that you know what it is okay so this is a very simple example of a theory which we believe has a symmetry enhancement it is it it is kind of not very impressive in the sense that you don't really see the seventh symmetry you only see an su 8 symmetry you can make various claims that about plausibility of is seven symmetry appearing on the conformal manifold of this theory tomorrow we will see much more impressive appearance of enhanced symmetry where literally the theory that we will see will have it will not be a conformal theory like that it will be theory which flows to something and in the UV you will have small symmetry and in the eye area will have a much bigger symmetry and the conformal manifold in the IR will be just a point they will won't be a conformal manifold so there will be no choice but for symmetry to be enhanced relative to what you seen in the UV okay but before we get to that example we have we can do a huge variety of other checks from this particular theory we can now start constructing theories which would correspond to any value of these fluxes in particular we will need to reproduce the anomalous and again symmetry enhancements yes yes they don't run this is a conformal theory that's right it's like animals forest or n equal to lagrangian's at Leonardo have mentioned it doesn't run it is a conformal theory by itself and you know you don't see the symmetry property in that particular point of the conformal manifold but somewhere on the conformal manifold it might appear I think in this case is 8 if I remember correctly it's a it's not a small conformal manifold so the dimension of conformal manifold as I mentioned I think yesterday can also be predicted from this type of of considerations it's a very rough prediction and in in this particular case again if I remember correctly the expectation is actually 9 that like this rough prediction would predict that the dimension of conformal manifold this nine the eight of this nine correspond to hole on amis for this curtains of e8 that you can turn on you compactify on a torus so you can turn on hole on amis for this for these curtains of this e8 so that these are eight parameters which will parameterize in a dimensional subspace and an additional one you expect is the complex structure model a on on naive grounds and that actually seems to be missing in this description and I yes no it's I mean can I tell you like there are many exactly margin there are many super potential terms are gauge coupling so you need to do the current the counting properly it not hard just you know these are free are free are charges so you just count everything which has our charge - and you count the gauge couplings and you do what you whatever trick you you like to do to count exactly margin of the formations either aliens raster analysis so this analysis by ug czar and cyber can friends of some particular quotient and you get the dimension of this conformal manifold yes it's probably a point because again in this hollow no me picture what the way you should think about it is that say you compactify with this value of flux but you don't turn on any homonymous then you should get any seventy at the moment you turn on Helana meas you are moving on the conformal manifold but you're explicitly breaking dc-7 symmetry so you expect a point but it's nobody guaranteed that this point will be at with coupling it might be a strong coupling so it's not it's not a pro I don't have a proof that this theory has any seventh symmetry but it is consistent with it being there somewhere on the confer moment okay and again if we will engineer an example of such a construction where the conformal manifold is a point the symmetry better be there otherwise there is something inconsistent and we will see such an example later ok so let me now consider building more generic theories how much time how much minutes okay so let me just give you the rules of the game and we will build things later on tomorrow so one thing I told you is what is the theory corresponding to this value of flux to a positive value of flux so to build other values of flux you know this this is a vector if we just add it to to itself we will only get you know products of this vector so we need to do something more sophisticated so the first thing and maybe the only that I will manage to do in these three minutes is tell you what is the theory corresponding to all entries beanie being a minus 1/2 okay this is just a choice of flux which is which has opposite sign ok so in terms of his seven flux this thing has a flux which is minus 1/2 that theory has flux 1/2 this one has minus 1/2 nothing is holy about the sign of the flux nothing is interesting about the sign of the flux or the theory should be just the same theory just what we call to us and what we call - so the difference will be a little bit subtle so let me rewrite the theory which we associate to positive value of the flux here so this is the theory which we associate to say - the positive value of the flux the theory that we will associate to the negative value of the plug flux will be exactly the same theory but complex conjugated ok so in particular I will switch all the arrows I didn't do that so I will switch all the arrows in this quiver and in particular there was this u 1 symmetry for which we assign charges plus 1 to these guys and minus 2 to these guys here the assignment of charges will be opposite again if you look on a single Theory like that this is just a choice it's meaningless ok this choice whether to to call this charge plus 1 or a minus 1 is just a choice whether to call this fundamental or anti fundamental it's just a choice but the moment we will start combining these theories together this will play a role ok so this is the theory with flux plus 1/2 this is a theory with flux minus 1/2 but now I need to mod when I have two theories like that with opposite orientation of these lines I need to modify what how I glue these theories together I changed basically the definition of the puncture the types of fields which I pretty I gave Neumann boundary condition to are now different before I glue you know punctures of the same type I gave the Neumann boundary condition to the same octet so fields so I needed to reintroduce the other octet of fields and then remove some linear combinations of the two that I had before here I already have the fields I need there is a Newman field which got no man boundary condition from here field which got Neumann boundary condition from here so just this matter content will give Lee give give me the the matter content I want in five dimensions so let me call this fight this field fire r1 and this field fight left - okay so now this fields have exactly opposite charges under this u 1 symmetry and these are the fields that I want to get in five dimensions so what I do now I J if I want to combine these theories together I just gauge this su 2 symmetry and I turn on the super potential which is just Phi right 1 times Phi left - okay I don't introduce any field this field the motivation of introducing this field was to reintroduce the metal content of the five dimensions if I glue to such punctures together then the matter content is already there I don't need to reintroduce anything and again people who know the class as business how things are working in classes these two types of combining together things should and strike a familiar note okay and this is related to the question you were asking before how you gluing things together so you need to be careful you need to glue things in such a way that a matter content will be the five dimensional matter content in the end okay so with this I will stop today and what we will do tomorrow we will use these two ways of combining the basic building blocks to engineer theories which have arbitrary fluxes okay correspond to compactification of arbitrary fluxes and Vogel's how symmetries other similar types of symmetries like a so 14 and is six times as you to appear in this business thank you [Applause] | ICTP High Energy, Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics | UC0XjPHyIE3NO4hK2rMO1Osw | 2019-04-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 9,472 | 49,447 |
ZPzsM1LOifI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPzsM1LOifI | Upton Gardens Girls Centre Undertakes Strategic Review | additional moves towards the Upton Garden School Center becoming the leading Catalyst for change for adolescent girls in St Lucia have taken place on August 8 2023 staff of the educational and behavioral change institution met with a wide cross-section of stakeholders for a strategic review of its functioning and operations present at the meeting of Mines seeking Solutions outside of the box where Ministry of Education officials social workers St Lucia Social Development Fund ssdf Personnel youth representatives and others along with Ministry of equity social justice and empowerment officials under whose jurisdiction the center Falls resident social worker at the new beginnings Transit home Eleanor Monroe's Henry assists the agency that works in tandem with the Upton Garden School Center says stakeholder participation is critical to achieve developmental continuity basically my agency Works closely with the Upton Garden Grill Center so it is very important that we are part of this Workshop to plan the way forward for our girls and to provide the necessary support that they will need recently appointed director Olympia Piper cools veterans says coming out of the exercise will be a practical three to five year comprehensive strategic plan that will guide the institution's operations moving forward the aim of reviewing our objectives and our strategic plan is to explore where we are at what are the challenges and how do we have this phenomenal product at the Upton Gardens girls Center packaged in a manner that persons in our society would see it as a valuable resource to access for their adolescent females along with reviewing the center's diverse academic offerings other vital areas placed under the microscope as part of the Strategic consultation with the income generating aspect of the central strengthening family engagement and overall Staff Development Center personality the old stigma of the institution being a place for Wayward girls must also be dispelled the Upton Garden School Center seeks to empower and support your females ages 12 to 18 years experiencing challenges | Saint Lucia Government | UC4al3A_gysYEIzAM1L2qZbg | 2023-09-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 334 | 2,111 |
9KLS__XJCqY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9KLS__XJCqY | Raid Max Bug Barrier - BEST HOME DEFENSE AGAINTS BUGS | Chopper anyways so what is it made now I guess like may I don't know 15th something like that I don't even keep up with dates no more so hard but anyways anyways spring cleaning spring cleaning I should say next spring bleeding is a you know still Among Us some of y'all still need to get to it most recently me and April we cleaned our little front closet right there by the front door we threw away a lot of stuff did a lot of donating from like like wrapping paper to board games to we even give away a pair of shoes that April Don't Wear No More some Jordans from like three years ago anyways uh I just want to recommend the bug spray to the households and apartment people living dwellers in America Europe where the you are it's this raid Bug Barrier Raid Max but barrier yeah yeah as you see I got two this one's full this one's empty because uh they come with the trigger heads I mean I can still probably take the batteries out of it what's in there some Double A's two Double A's free basically it's about ten dollars investment maybe cheaper I get it from the grocery store or Target uh it works it's indoor and outdoor as I was saying it's indoor and outdoor uh what's it say here keeps killing German cockroaches for up to 12 months and it does because I don't know what the German cockroach is but uh I'll be outside in the outdoor roaches that be looking all dead and uh what else does it do keeps listed bugs out I'm guessing uh there's a list but most people don't look at the list they just look at the picture see spiders ants and like two types of roaches the outdoor Road just beating big ass was right there boy big ass nasty looking ones and black ones and the ones that we had the garbage cans anyways of course you know it's gonna be toxic because it's bug spray it's raid but uh I really like it I sprayed it out I spray the perimeter you know I'll go outside and spray around stuff gotta make sure your cat don't get out so just deal with me but I'll come out and I'll spray around the edges of the unit this is the patio I'll even do the front door area I'll do my neighbor's door you know we live on the first floor so I'll go all the way up to the the cars right there in the parking lot uh should I spray a little bit in the rocks by the windows all around squares basically just follow the line looking connect the dots with it but I think it really works it's supposedly lasts six months but I think it lasts longer the only time the only reason I buy multiples is because it rains in Vegas like weird like when it rains it really rains you know like we get floods tight rain so I feel like it just washes it away and the bugs come out and they're like oh Sanctuary but um yeah man this Raid Max Bug Barrier dude if I was you I'd buy it of course you want to clean first if you have kids or pets you want to spray it and you know keep them out the house for maybe like six hours before you bring it back just let it dry at least but spread it outside the inside bathroom kitchens cupboards bedrooms hallways and any bugs that come through the cracks of your doors man they they just they're about to get it usually they die like 20 feet that's what I've noticed but uh what else can I say about it did I say it lasts about six months that's supposedly what it says I think that's how they used to advertise the commercial uh the trigger is awesome just unlock it bam unlock and you just go to work and the spray is a pretty good stream yeah it's not really long distance it gets kind of messy so I mean if you stand in like two feet away from where you need to spray you're good but just spray the spray and spray around the door sales you're good man I'm telling you the roaches ain't gonna with you you might see their bodies but they ain't gonna be up in your you have to worry about that and the way I see it man when it's cold they be hiding in your walls somewhere your neighbor's walls outside and the cars because they probably warm and in the sewer but when the summer and the springs around the like to come out you've seen them in the garbage can but if you can see them outside on the parking lot you know they're in your house no they in your house so spray this keep you one of them little extra little black flags you know the regular ones that people use in the house keep that handy just in case you ain't trying to wait for them to die you see them coming in you know while they out there like help me you just finish them off right quick there you have it man I recommend it right bug backs married Raid Max Bug Barrier peace | The Vegas Soup | UC-Vo8gREkS0849wsYBxWWGA | 2016-03-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 915 | 4,577 |
w-lew8aXSSA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w-lew8aXSSA | TELLING MY BOYFRIEND THERE'S A SNACK ON THE TABLE!! | basically be telling him that i'm his snack for the day i'm gonna ask if he's hungry i'm gonna be sitting here all sexy and hot for him i'm your snack what did you guys walk up to a whole snack this is my yoga pose my heart dropped when i walked in there this should be the best day of your life what is good marvel squad and welcome back to our channel so today is a crazy day me and bill are packing up for florida but when you guys see this video it is currently a monday and we are already down here in florida which is actually insane to even think about how quick it came i literally remember you know months ago planning out april 12th was gonna be the day that we moved down to florida and it's actually here so crazy guys but i'm going to show you guys a little bit of what we have packed so far before we get on to that as you guys read by today's title i'm going to be pulling a little prank i wouldn't really say it's a prank i'd say it's more like a reaction i don't know if you guys have seen this trend on like tic tac i've seen a few trends on youtube about it but it's mostly on tick tock where the girlfriend will sit on the counter or they will be like anywhere in like the living room or whatever and basically being like telling their boyfriend that there's a snack ready for them on a table so that is what i'm doing today i'm basically telling him that i'm his snack for the day i'm gonna ask if he's hungry i'm gonna be sitting here all sexy and hot for him when he comes back upstairs he actually went downstairs right now to go and clean out the car because we are selling our eclipse which is crazy because i've had that car since the beginning and we're selling it to my sister's boyfriend so it is going into good hands um but we did ship out our corvette which will be in florida very soon actually it's probably already down there by the time you guys are seeing this video so we are super excited i cannot wait but bill is actually right downstairs right now cleaning out that car so i thought i'd just film a quick intro set up the camera i have a little bit of time because he's going to be down there for a couple minutes cleaning it up because there's a lot that we have to clean but when he comes back up here i'm basically going to tell him that i'm the snack today and i'm wearing these really really really cute leggings let me show you guys really quick they're kind of like a butt lifting type of lugging but they're not the famous butt lifting leggings let me show you guys all right so here oh ignore the bed if you guys don't know those we were sleeping out here for a while just because we had a tv that we could use because when we get our house we're gonna put a tv in our room but here is the leggings they make your butt look bigger and i just think this is a really like vibrant outfit i think he's gonna definitely be like oh what is that you know he already has like he really likes this uh workout set it's a workout fit so i'm basically gonna be doing that for today's video so make sure you give this video a big thumbs up if you guys haven't already make sure to hit that subscribe button and join our family because crazy epic things are about to come me and bill are getting in our fitness which i've been working on for three weeks now which i am so proud of myself i'm already seeing progress i've been eating healthier and i'm also just so excited that i'm gonna be living in my dream state i don't know just different vibes good vibes are coming our way and i'm just so blessed i just want to say thank you guys so much for all your love support because without you guys you would not be here and you know it's definitely going to be an emotional journey so stay tuned for wednesday's youtube video because that's when we're going to be saying goodbye to our family and like it's just going to be a really all-around emotional but really sentimental video so make sure you guys are staying tuned for that and then the following videos will be in florida i'm so excited um let me show you guys what we have so far packed up so i don't know if you guys remember but we had a bunch of succulents right here we had some silverware and stuff so that's all packed up and then in here we actually took out a lot of our pots and pans had our kitchenaid our smoothie blender we had our crockpot we had all those appliances we already packed up we still have to pack this up also with this we forgot to do the molding on it so we still have to figure out what we're gonna do with that we took down a lot of our stuff on the walls we still have to take down these but that will be super quick and then we gotta take down that poster so then tomorrow we'll take down all the lights because that's when we're like officially moving out of here and then here is how much i don't know if you guys remember but this room we showed you guys in the previous videos how much was in here we got so much done basically everything is packed up like look at the closet this was all filled and we got we got literally almost all of it done we're almost done packing which is actually crazy i cannot believe that it's going this well and then also we got more boxes today because we still have some more packing to do i have to pack all this up and then here's the bedroom it's a little dark i'm packing all this stuff up this is all stuff i'm putting my suitcase and all that you got to pack up the bed demands the dresser take down this and bubble wrap it and really we really don't have much left to do and then we're going to demand this too so really we only have like a little bit of stuff left in here i just think it's so crazy that we're literally we literally just moved in here and now we're moving and we're going to florida our dream state and i'm just so excited guys so make sure to stay tuned for this journey i'm gonna go ahead and set up the camera and i will see you guys in a second i'm excited to get this prank on a roll so yeah all right guys so um bill's actually on his way up i'm gonna show you guys how i'm gonna be placed so i'm gonna sit up on the counter like this and i'm just gonna be sitting here like this with my butt kind of like you take my shoes off i'm just gonna be sitting here kind of like kind of like this like kind of like bent over a little bit when he walks into the door and we're gonna get into the reaction he's gonna be like what are you doing and be like i'm your snack look this is so cringy guys but you know what team a ride in the house make sure you guys are commenting team aria is about to be insane he's definitely going to be like a baby being a little weird but can't get enough of this all right guys so now we just wait also you guys are wondering what i said at the camera i have you guys over by our couch on behind our pillows so it's perfect spot he's not able to see obviously so let's get it [Music] hold up what i'm just i'm just stretching i'm just scratching babe actually what are you doing i'm stretching that is way more oh my god i'm doing my yoga poses why are you judging me [Music] look at your treats we can just sit back relax pack and after my yoga poses right here like this you can't pack with that on the table oh see like what you see yeah i did not expect that at all wait dude look at it look there's all the stuff in the car that's it oh yeah well i look like a lot i found a whole little garbage bag of garbage well this is the garbage you get to walk up to a whole snack this is my yoga pose my heart dropped when i walked in there why did it look good yeah like this is liking set yeah but you're in front of the the windows are open so there's people where there's people cutting again so um um they can watch this sign up i'm a snack on the table you don't even need your snack you don't even need lunch your snack is right here what are you doing the snack is right here [Music] don't actually [Music] all right what do you want to do with you what do you want me to do i'm going to eat me up how do you want me to do that i don't know we just keep doing my yoga poses but for right now this is just a snack on the table okay i got my pink drink tomatoes my pink drink okay okay i can't pack with you like that though why why are you like that why are you doing this this could be your entertainment like your motivation put on some music can you play some music no because you don't need no music when you got this this is music to your face to your ears to everything okay well i'm going to go for this what who's going to leave a snack sitting here on a table no i know you look good you're going to leave a hot snack that's sitting on the table okay unattended really no fine you know what i'm gonna go ask a lot more grass cutters down there if they want to snap i'm pretty sure i am scared i'm pretty sure they would be running up the stairs if they saw this sitting on the counter i bet you they would this shocked me if you saw my face when i walked in i was literally like what the heck well you're not appreciating the stack you're going to appreciate it can you come over here this should be the best day of your life can you come over here this should be the best day of your life sitting on the counter waiting for you to shut the world when you arrive you know all right no because i'm wearing a nice butt lifting leggings for you here well then how am i supposed to have a stack if it's like come over here up here go to the bedroom we'll live here just sit up here the snacks up here hey there's literally people right there they can dad see us okay they can go they're like the same level as those they're so if he turns his head over he's okay you guys wanna shush okay why is it man can i shut the door no why because i can see the snack without face towards them [Music] holy cow yeah get off the table on the snackdown actually if i want to close you literally cannot do anything on the table yes we can this is small okay how would you rate the snack how do you rate it 100 out of 10. 100.000 you don't have to wear makeup don't look pretty i love you i love you now come here come here come here shut up no what do you mean you don't want anyone i just want to start packing i thought you said you were going to be on the table while i'm packing that's the whole point it gets me going and we need to turn on music yeah but i don't want to do it anymore yes you do i don't yes you do oh my god don't stop now stop shut [Music] get ready for you are you back up back up come on ready oh snap [Music] what are you doing stanford tell them tell them you're not filming tell them snap tell them are you starting to tell them what tell them what there ain't no snack on the table yes there is a snack on the table there is a snack it's your snack yeah it's filming i've been filming for 10 minutes now why are you filming because are we doing our intro tea mariah came back with a little bit it's with one wait there is a trend on tick tock where the girl sits on the counter and they tell their man that there's a snack on the table no they're no yeah off camera we can still you know you can still stay on the table for you off camera but i try to get your reaction and you succeeded you were being so hyped oh i love you baby i'm sorry i didn't get you like that it wasn't really a prank it was i mean it kind of was cause i i didn't really actually do this intentionally to tell you no wonder i was gonna say mariah never ryan never treats me to snacks like this listen i know today's a busy day i know today's a busy day obviously when the marble squad seeing this we'll be in florida i'm in the car but and you're playing on the table but we'll already be in florida when this happens but i wanted to just to film a quick reaction video of you telling you there's a snack on the table and i succeeded you really enjoyed it you were really excited but now unfortunately we have to start packing and there's the snack is um and the snack is unattended guys i i had i had the one thing that i had to look forward to today was my snack and now she's saying that she doesn't even want to be my snack anymore that'd still be your snack but you kind of you know no you're getting your ass to work though she's not sitting up here though no that so use that as an excuse babe i'm your snack i get to stay on the counter while you pack up everything no that's not how this works this is we're a team all right who's been doing more packing junk who's been doing the most packing out of all of us bill we've both been packing we've all been packing but we've been doing the most passionate you have done more like candy like oh you're right no no no cuddle up there i've done more periods period guys don't let him think that he's doing all that okay we both put in our work i just have a harder working mentality oh so i i'm like go go go go go she's she's like let's go watch netflix i'm like no let's go pack no don't say that because we are a very go-go-go couple in general but when it comes to like handiness like making sure everything's wrapped right i leave it to you because you're gonna get it done right we don't want anything to go wrong no we don't and i don't trust myself enough i trust mariah tape up a box you'll pick it up and everything will fall through the bottom no no we literally we work so well as a team as you can tell on our you know youtube and our you know social medias we want to be here without each other and without you guys thank you so much for watching this video what is this called snack okay yeah whatever video this is but all right guys i hope you guys enjoyed today's video before we end this video we have to give a post notification shout out shout out this shout out goes to emily.m shout out to you shout out to you thank you so much i love you so much and we hope you guys enjoyed today's video the next video you guys see will be one more video and then we will be we're we're in the tropical uh state of florida we're actually in the tropical state right now guys so so make sure to follow us on instagram so you can see our stories and our posts and everything because literally we are gonna be going crazy with the stories i'm sure and we're gonna be posting a lot and we cannot wait until we can literally like just start filming youtube videos down there because i just feel like everything is just like such a good i'm just telling them that the intro like the the fact that we've been working out getting our health better and then just the vibes in florida we're going to be such a better we're just going to be still i feel like this is a year of people working out i feel like more people are working out this year than they ever have guys if you have a goal go out and get it don't even question it just go start doing it otherwise you'll never start just go do it you know what i mean like we're moving we're just gonna go do it we're just moving across country just like that like not don't even think about it you know think later yep but anyways guys we will see you in the next video but until then peace love you guys | Mariah and Bill | UCW0ulUd4BZY4k_vHqLFWTuw | 2021-04-13 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,082 | 15,133 |
9L2BimRt2hE | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9L2BimRt2hE | Motivations for Sustaining a Roundtrip of Links Between Collectors and their Specimen Records | Greetings everyone and welcome. We're very happy to be presenting here at ECN, 2023 to talk about the motivations. The importance and the opportunities in Setting up and curating the links between specimens and those who collect them and identify them. With that. Imagine, we know that many of us have been sharing our collections data to the global community via the Global Biodiversity Information Facility. We've become quite a depth at geo referencing, for example, our locality information because points on a map have proven to be computationally useful and useful for finding errors. We've focused less on the utility of people names in our collections data. Perhaps because we've not appreciated the value. Or it's been perceived as an intractable problem. At present, people names for collectors and determiners are shared in a noisy, inconsistent way. See the slide. But we're here to explain that this is perfectly acceptable because the varied expressions of people names is a form of evidence or provenance. Instead, we make an argument the communicating identity requires an approach the new shared layer and some citizen science like activities to address the very long tail of unknown people names. Each of our own windows of knowledge on heritage are limited. But collectively, we may pull back all the curtains on all the windows. What's our motivation? Turning strings of people names into a computational layer that communicates shared concepts of identity requires that we figure out or disambiguate the strings. Many people share the same name. And many people have or had different names. The motivations for this work are many. And will list more. But they also include some of the verbs you see here to discover, complete. Track, Measure, Collaborate and Reveal, among others. The core of these desires can be summarized. As us having a common goal to overcome institutional, cultural and trust barriers to accelerate interdisciplinary collaboration and knowledge integration. If you'd like to, you may read more about our thoughts on what it means to disambiguate people names in biological collections and beyond across the products of biological sciences. That might bring to mind what's in your collection or research database. Got people? We advocate for a layer of people identifiers that are globally unique. Useful but we recognize that there may be many identifiers for people. And so we should aspire to support. Many of them in our collections management systems. As an example. The ORCID Organization. With your ORCID, consider that it's a not-for-profit organization, an international organization financially supported by national and regional consortium memberships. You have undoubtedly used your ORCID identifier in the submission of manuscripts or journals or grant applications to funding agencies. Another identifier. Is a wikidata Q number. And from Wikidata, unlike ORCID, Wikidata accommodates demographic facts like birth and death rates with the inclusion of evidence for those facts. With these identifiers in mind, Next up, David will tell us more about how this work can actually take place. Thanks, and hello, everyone. I'm a public servant with agriculture and agri food Canada, as many of you know. But in this particular talk with Deb, I'm a private citizen with this submission and the bionomia infrastructure itself is a self-funded project of mine. And a personal interest that I launched in about 2018. The seed of the idea germinated about a decade to a decade and a half ago. At its simplest level, as Deb likes to call it, Bionomia is a enormous pivot table on people names. And those people names emerge from GBIF, the Global Biodiversity Information Facility. Every other week about 210 million specimen records are downloaded from GBIF and parsed for their people names. And then exposed into an enormous search engine. And then the interface allows you to find specimens data of your own or to contribute them or link them up to other people that you admire or revere. So if you name happens to be Ashley Whiffen for example and you have an ORCID ID. When you log in to bionomia using your ORCID, you begin to see some of the records that are potentially attributable to yourself and you can claim them as your own. So in this case here's a handful that Ashley could claim as having collected or identified them. ORCID is used for the living in binomia and wikidata for the deceased. So when you go this through this exercise, you have the option to auto archive your records to Zenodo. An international organization that, archives data and their their head offices are in CERN in Switzerland. So you can get a datacite DOI for this work and that data package then could appear in ORCID as an example or an expression of the data packages that you might have contributed elsewhere alongside your publications. So a number of people have done this and then padded their CVs with this data package because it illustrates the breadth of their field and curatorial work. Within bionomia, you might also have the opportunity to actively link past champions to their specimen records and here's an example of Terry Erwin with his wikidata Q number. Allow you to find his specimen records and link him up to those specimen records as they might be found in multiple institutions throughout the world. And here's a number of examples where we know that Terry Erwin's specimens are deposited. And likewise, you can begin examining and exploring the genealogical social networks if you will of co-collectors by virtue of the data that appear on Terry Erwin's specimen records with the individuals who he has collected with in the past. And this is lovely because it's immediately from the specimen data from GBIF, not necessarily from anecdotes or publication records, but from the specimen data themselves. This act of linking activity also helps us to better appreciate the impact of underrepresented individuals in our our midst in both past and present. Here's one example of Margaret S. Collins. Who was an African American child prodigy. And later an entomologist specializing in the study of termites. She was also a civil rights advocate. Margaret was nicknamed the termite lady for her expertise on termites. She was one of the very first individuals to receive a PhD in entomology. As an African-american herself and the third African-american female zoologist. Which is a remarkable accomplishment. A team of individuals have recognized the potential for examining these micro histories right within the specimen data themselves. And have been doing deep dives into this kind of work. And have established a number of Educational resources for undergraduate students in this organization. QUBES or the quantitative undergraduate biology education and synthesis, QUBES for short. So I draw attention to this work and you should go explore QUBES if you have undergraduate teaching duties and are thinking about how to incorporate this work. into your specimen-based teachings. One of the goals for bionomia is to turn this volunteer work right back and reside back into the collections. So one of the data packages that get produced in bionomia is something called frictionless data. And within these packages are zipped up CSV files. One of these is a unique list of the collectors and determiners of the specimen records. And another is who made the link and when they made the link so you can have a sense of the confidence. And the trust in terms of the the links as they get made in bionomia and yet another one is a signal about potential issues with the the way in which collecting event dates have been presented to the world via GBIF from your specimen-based data. Should those event dates happen before the birth date or after the death date of the linked up collector. So that might turn out to be quite useful for you. The ultimate outcome of doing this kind of round trip work is the ability for you to share your people names and their identifiers. Out through 2 relatively new terms in Darwin Core, one called recorded by ID, and the other one called identified by ID. Nice compliments to the terms that you're probably already familiar with. Recorded by and identified by. So not only can you share the raw people names, you can also share their identity by virtue of the identifiers that are indicative of who they are and in a shared way. I hand it back over to you, Deb. Now that we've learned a little bit more, we come back to why do this work? Take a step back and think about the motivations that we might have for figuring out who is who. For disambiguating people names through linking to shared concepts for their identity. In a way that's open, an open data curatorial exercise. We finally land on some motivations. Some of these are individual such as pride and reverence. But we're also motivated to empower our trainees when we have a simple way to draw attention to their efforts. Let's not discount the entertainment value. If we're honest about this, some of us do this while watching television because it often requires minimal cognitive effort and frankly it's fun. At another level, we could speak about institutional and organizational drivers that may align with things like key performance indicators. This novel participatory approach affords new visibility, efficiencies and cross department and cross organization and institution coordination. Many collectors were and are generalist natural historians. Depositing objects in multiple collections within and across institutions. A link to a collector made for one organization often benefits many others. And there are academic drivers. The disambiguation of people names and subsequent linking to their specimen records can assist with the production of data products. Such as the more accurate geo-referenced localities for collections of horseshoe bats. Or to foster more inclusivity in systematics, represent underrepresented groups, for example, and training in open data best practices with a simple way to self-advocate. If you're excited about this and you'd like to get started, the next event you could take part in is round-tripping people identifiers in collection management systems. David is hosting and organizing this workshop, having asked those of us to come and talk about and you might be one of those. But about what's in your CMS or what vision do you have for doing this work in your CMS. Thanks for the link in the chat, David. With that, we have many people to thank. We hope you have motive. The people listed here from Siobhan, Sabina, Jennifer, Samanta, and Andrew and all the people in the biodiversity data task group. In biodiversity Information standards. TDWG, we must say thank you to them and many, many more. Thank you and thank you, David. | David Shorthouse | UCovFFzEZVWtNQNmi7Vc7KbA | 2023-11-15 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,802 | 10,836 |
9ctyacKlVQU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ctyacKlVQU | Museveni bimusobedde, Abe kisoro bekalakasiza ,Laba ekigenda mumaso bibino | [Music] to burn argents from inaudible some people are being kidnapped and taken away from those places and some are the ordinary person [Music] so now my brother father his car has been stunned by a parish and this is a this is a serious issue so if so who will sign for this declaration reforms if they're kidnapping the audience these elections will be very peaceful but they want a very peaceful election and also there are some some vehicles being run by security with open without numbers and this is it's our worry if you are keeping security why should you bring the cows out numbers always you see the numbers so that we don't see we don't see them so i'm appearing that in the midst of security before me foreign | PROJOURN MEDIA TV | UCQrzJPS-2N1GWzicG6KYk_Q | 2022-08-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 134 | 722 |
6khuc7bL1mA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6khuc7bL1mA | Face The Book TV and IPNE Present: A Conversation with Paige Allen, IngramSpark | we are live with paige allen the new director at ingram spark a company that's very familiar to the members of independent publishers of new england hi paige how are you doing hi great to be here thank you so much yeah thanks for doing this little preview and and you know you're going to be one of our keynote speakers at the conference um in november 5th 6th and we have another small workshop on the 7th but 5th and 6th of november i'm charlotte pierce and i am the producer of face the book tv which is the program you're on and in collaboration with ip e we just thought we did we'd have you on and just kind of get people excited about the conference i think it's going to be really good and uh really valuable for people so can you just tell us a little bit about how long you've been there and and what's what's it been like in the first few months of your uh directorship at uh at ingramspark yeah well one i just want to say thank you for the opportunity i'm very much so looking forward to the ipme conference um in early november and it's really just a great opportunity to to be really in front of independent publishers so so excited for that um yeah so when uh i guess what it's been it's been a year uh it was a year october 8th so it's definitely been quite interesting and it has moved fast so you came in right in the right of the yeah the uh what what do we call it um the holiday season yeah the business holiday season in the pandemic yeah yeah yeah so definitely it's been like uh it's been a lot to learn um and i think like this is this is the best time that you can sort of learn is when things are busy and um and there's you know some of just the the day-to-day pressures that we see within the industry and then you know some of those nuances that were caused by um by the pandemic but yeah it's it's been a fun very exciting year it's been a building year um in terms of just internal infrastructure for our platform so that we can introduce reintroduce some services and then introduce new services um coming into to q1 so we've got a a lot of things in you know in that in our roadmap that i'll be able to talk to a little bit in our keynote and uh like i was telling you before you know like probably more than half of our members are solo self publishers uh have one book they're not not all completely knowledgeable about the publishing process or about some sometimes even about using um online you know services so is there something that you're or are there measures that you're putting in place to kind of help newbies or do you have you know yeah so we're working with uh we're currently you know seeking out an education partner um but because we want to build out our academy and the tools and services that we're able to offer there i will definitely say it is um it's sort of like where the rub is right so you have a you're an independent publisher you have a self-publishing platform um and i understand like there's always there's there's sometimes when there's uh difficulty right there there needs to be that maybe heightened level of support and so that's something that you know we understand we want to be able to provide the education and then we also want to go a little bit beyond in terms of the service that we're doing um and make sure that we're providing that excellent quality great response time so i know earlier in the year on the u.s side we switched um you know phones off and we switched chat off and we i really focused on email just so that we could turn things around in terms of getting back to people quickly but we will be rolling chat and phone back um oh thank god that's great yeah next year no it's it's you know people just like to have it's feel like it's like i was i was just recently traveling and delta airlines you know it took me literally i was waiting on a phone for 24 hours never got someone to come on but the chat they they put the chat you know i i reached someone on the chat and they they solved my issue and it was really it was a yeah satisfying so so i'm glad to hear about that but um and how many publishers do you have uh you know just how many customers clients or whatever we have over a hundred thousand over a hundred thousand and growing so yeah um and that's a mix of you know indie publishers um authors some small press you know but yeah it's a it's a good account makeup yeah and uh we had a few questions that people have been asking over the since they heard that you were coming um so how many publishers is one um approach to customer service you talked about that a little bit but but um when will you start rolling out the chat or do you i will say it will be q1 but um we don't have a specific date in q1 again we'll contingent on some technology but and it won't be available to all it will be based off of some account levels but yeah right well you want to do it right so right i understand that there'll be a phased approach it's all iterative that's what we say right exactly so telling something um everything is beta now you know you just you put up a blog post and then you change something well speaking of beta one thing that i'm really excited about is our new reporting tool uh reporting tools and dashboard that will also be made available in q1 again like 2021 um has been a lot of building blocks in terms of making sure that we have the internal infrastructure within the platform and in order to do some really new and exciting things in 2022 so in q1 will also be and and fingers crossed uh it will be january um we were shooting for a november date but um but you know sometimes things move um but in january we'll be launching a new a beta reporting dashboard that will have uh a new look and feel to design um a customization uh uh you know feature as well as uh new export features and just new data you know we really want to be able to bring new data trends interest um to our authors and independent publishers to help them be more successful very good yeah that's i can't imagine what it's been like just jumping into a job like that it's it's you know bringing all those things along and having the vision you know you know and then the the details that make up the process um what mary katherine was asking about she's an audiobook she's our conference chair and she's um she's an audiobook producer uh is there anything that you're planning along those lines or yeah audios down the road um you know i think in terms of bringing it to a self-published independent published audience in a scalable fashion right at a pretty low price point can be a little bit difficult but it's definitely in our road map um and we would do that in partnership with our core source and core source plus business which is our digital our ebook and audio side uh of the business but that is something that we definitely have in our roadmap if it's not 2022 um i definitely want to check that box come 2023. very good that's exciting yeah i mean that's actually how i read most of my books now i shouldn't admit that but i do well no i mean i mean when we talk about like formats it's it's very interesting to see even over the past year we've just seen an uptick in terms of heart cover um in terms of that in terms of that format and for me i'm more of a i prefer sort of the the sturdiness of a hardcover book um and i pair that always with the audiobook now sometimes it doesn't line up but that's just i'm in auditory and visual you know learner so got it well that that is really something to look forward to and um i was going to ask you do you you print on the same presses as lightning source we do you do yeah i've been really happy with the quality i just have to say you know it's it's it's really pretty good awesome that's great to hear and we're constantly you know looking at new products looking at new operations ourselves ourselves and business operations team work handyman um but yeah we all we all we also understand that there are improvements that can be made but no i'm so happy to hear that you really yeah i've been you know i usually pull a sample and look at it and you know try and you know go with the best paper that i can afford and stuff but uh so we don't want to give away all the things you're going to be talking about at the conference but um one more question is you know do you have any questions about ipne or who's going to be there or what you know what's you know just about our organization yeah i mean i've uh mary catherine has done a great job in terms of educating me about ipne um but no i i definitely think i want to hear it's great to have these questions here but i want to share what's coming in the platform but if there's any particular questions you know that or or themes that have been popular within your within your membership yeah i think you know i i don't know if this is something you're going to cover in your in your education um but you know marketing i i have yet to find the secret sauce just selling actually selling the dang books you know um getting them produced isn't isn't such an issue but yeah do i have to advertise you know like stuff like that and and you help people with that yeah that is um what my my session i plan um so i i also will be bringing in josh floyd who is our business development manager for the us but we plan to talk about really how to reach your audience right and how to utilize things like ai how to how to um how to really dissect and understand certain data points and then how of course there's other non-traditional marketing channels and advertising channels that you can use but we tend to just focus you know especially with the us audience space we tend to focus about marketing to the us but we often see a lot of authors and independent publishers have success maybe a us author but begin to see more success in like uk australia channels other rest of world channels before they begin to see that success in the us so we want to have a global approach to what we're talking about in our and reaching your audience in your marketing strategy that's great to hear yeah i mean i kind of like to you know if there's a template you know do these five things and then if this doesn't work then try that because i have children's i have uh you know travel and alternative education so it's kind of like it's a dis diverse uh topic areas and stuff yeah and i know that that can be it can be again it can be difficult but i would love to get to a point where we're able to provide a dedicated level of service and consultation to our authors too to provide them with yeah that would be cool i mean i'd even pay for you know a consult fee or something you know yeah it's just there's just too much it's like a fire hose of information that comes at you when you're in a small publisher but anyway i really um any anything else you'd like to add about you know that what you'll be talking about or or you know something that's coming up in ingram no i'm just again i am excited um what i will also be talking a little bit about supply chain issues that's something big in terms of the industry yeah the effects on raw materials how that affects you know availability delivery things like that so we've done a lot of research across our sales and operations team but we have really worked together across ingram to make sure that we're going into our busy season in a very comfortable place which is is not necessarily the same message that you're seeing across the industry so um can i still order books for holiday sales you can you have it to november 5th yay good to know good to know that's the first day of the conference thank you so much paige i will um this will be on our website and and we'll be we will be pulling the audio out for a distribution on on audio podcasts so we'll let you know where those links are and we'll see you on november 5th all right perfect thanks so much thank you so much all right | Independent Publishers of New England | UCMKrnUMKOwqlYQoV1IYJv6Q | 2021-10-12 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,335 | 11,949 |
C4WkzQKwpYg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4WkzQKwpYg | Simplifying Game Based Definitions | thanks brother thanks for the introduction where's my slide oh okay so for this talk I'm going to present a new definitional framework called indistinguishability up to crack knees I am DC for short so just in one sentence it is a new technique for you to write security definitions or to design security games in such a way that you don't need to attend to tribal wins or more specifically but specifically excluding tribal ways from the adversary hence the title simply find game based definitions so let's first start with a review about indistinguishability are in deep or short as we are not we're all familiar with indistinct ability is about an adversary's advantage notion that measures how good he is in distinguishing a real game G from an ideal game age in this setting an adversary a would ask questions to one of the two games and receive responses from the games his job is to differentiate which games he is interacting with so the indistinguishability advantage of an adversary a against games g and g and h are defined to be this probability difference that he outputs one in both worlds so this concludes somehow okay so based on such an atmosphere advantage a game G is it's called indistinguishable from an ideal game age for all adversary with reasonable amount of resource he's distinguishing advantage is small this is all very familiar but I want to emphasize is that indistinguishability won't be so useful and so important to our field if this slide is all what is about if you go through the literature most of the definitional work uses indistinguishability in the following way the games G and H are really constructed in such a way that it depends on some crypto scheme spy and then people would define all kinds of security advantage against such a scheme high as the IND advantage of the games G and H that are instantiated with this pile there are this talk I'm going to call this way of defining security as the conventional way so let's first go through some examples of what commercial games look like in the literature so here is a game that defines key in distinguishability or bi-directional ratcheted key exchange the relevant talk was even right here by Porter two days ago here is another one that's about that models integrity property of a primitive called data stream channels it is a joint work done by official in at all in crypto 15 yet another one that model circuit hiding property of any encryption by the way onion encryption is the encryption algorithms used in Onion Routing network like tor and mixed nuts this is a recent work done by Tycho Brahe understand I believe you your crab dated all these games are really complex so maybe let's switch some switch or a mine and start with some games that look not that complex here is a game called all sub I it borrows the authenticity property of State for authenticated encryption the same topic as a as mine hmm so if you look at their secret it is a joint work done by Boyd Hale poisonous the media in CT RSA 2060 if you look at their code it doesn't look that bad at least it's comprehendible however just waiting one year after their first publication to CD RSA the same others publish a revision in which they revise the pseudocode of their security gates to ePrint in which they added this special processing to warm their sub cases and even this revision is still not correct because there really should be a return or statement between line 5 and line 6 I believe it's just a typo so all these stories and and complex games are motivated us to think about what are the essential problems about indistinct ability paradigm so as you can see from the previous life the definitions or the security games related to those are really complex and subtle in such a way toward degree that they're just hard to debug and believe worse a prior work of Valerie Hoffman's and kills showed that even with the most basic security definitions like ing CCA security for public encryption schemes people still would mess up and they are way in terms that they are wave of how to evoke queries from adversary's artists allowed the orders showed that just by tweaking the way that Tremmel queries are this allowed you can define multiple ie equivalent security notions for ind CCA security for public key encryption schemes and key wrapping algorithms as well in summary it's just hard to justify for a cryptographer once he writes down some pseudocode of security games for some security properties it's just it's hard to justify for him does this game really capture what I want part of the reason for that is there's no good theory for cryptographers to use as how to create security definitions in the literature we have many good tools and theorists to upper bound adversary's advantage given existing security definitions security notions like coefficient H methods expectation arguments for example but as for how to create that security definitions typically we're on our own so our IDC framework is supposed to fill in this gap you know high level it works like a definitional compiler where you feed into this compiler to security games that capture what you want but really do not work because there will be trivial winning strategy for the adversary so the definition on the left hand side is bogus however you live with that you pass these security games to the compiler and it will automatically generate two edited games for you whose ind advantage results in relevant reasonable security notion in which there is no triple win so what is this definitional compiler then it's a process we call Oracle editing it works like this we start with two utopian games G and H the games are called utopian because there are trivial ways to win this there are trivial winning strategy for the adversary's win these games we again prabha we in addition provide a kragnes class C that is mathematically just a set of crypto schemes of which satisfies certain kragnes conditions the kragnes condition is just a familiar functional property that a class of schemes need to satisfy in order to work for example for public key encryption this will just be the decryption needs to be the reverse process of encryption you pass these three building blocks to the process of Oracle auditing and this will output the edited games GTO de and H tilde we then define a new adversary advantage called IMTC advantage in the middle at the bottom against G H and C simply it will be the plane indistinguishability advantage against G tilde and H tilde the same advantage there used to be what happens security advantage against the underlying scheme pie okay so what is this article editing process in particular mmm in order to illustrate this I would first go deep into our game playing model as shown here security games in our model consists of initialization procedure or encode procedure and finalization procedures these are written in pseudocode and they are stateful they have stays so that the game states are maintained across invocation an adversary a will simply ask questions to the oracle procedure receiving responses and then he would under Edward Alice at his will output his own Abruzzi which surely echoes through the game outcome Omega this will be what the utopian games behave like like I said there needs to be added done so what is this editing well we added the utopian games by adding this yellow demultiplexer this demultiplexer will before each time the response is given to the adversary confused a silencing function so on the current game transcript the game transcript includes all previous adversary queries and responses and if this silencing function returns true the response of the oracle why i will be replaced by a special diamond symbol we call this oracle silencing okay so now comes the real crux of our whole framework how should we define this silencing function because this really captures what we mean by tribal queries so we think that a query is trivial if the adversary based only on the current game transcript and based solely on the fact that the underlying scheme is in the kragnes class C knows the answer beforehand so let me repeat this this is very important we think a query is trivial so it should be silenced when an adversary based solely on the card transcript that includes all his courage and responses at this point and based solely on the fact that the scheme is in a chronic lass knows the owner before know the anger before had formalizing this idea we define a silencing function in this way that given T the answer is fixed across all schemes Pi in the Class C for the real if the animals are interacted with the real game we formed eyes we give definition formulas for their stylists functions I don't want to go team into this but only you want to point that the silencing function here is a logical or of a thickness predicate that means whenever there were priorities that needs to be silenced it reminiscent so it's like a silence then shut down approach this concludes the description of NDC but before I leave this topic I need to mention one important caveat that is the silence function needs to be efficiently computable or at least on the domain that matters transcripts that arise in G sub pi / H sub pi if this does not hold the intuition that because the adversary knows the response so he should not ask it simply would not hold that summarize how we use I and easy to create definitions we first formalized intensive cry of schemes PI then the correctness condition this will give us a kragnes class at the same step as the conventional way we next design utopian games G and H and in doing so we don't need to attend to logic for excluding treble-winning queries for example along with C this determines the IND CC curry notion we want finally we need to verify the silence function silence of CG is efficiently computable on the relevant sets of transcripts ok so that is the conclusion of Ind C framework let me go through two examples for that the first example is let's use it to define IND CCA security for public key encryption schemes a very familiar notion I'm going to perform this definitional process first in the commercial way and then by our IND C way as we're all familiar with a public key encryption scheme consists of two probabilistic key algorithms key generation and encryption than a deterministic decryption algorithm the correctness property is just that for all messages if you encrypt by a public key generated by the key generation algorithm and you decrypt that you would get back the original message all these are very simple so let's try to design security games for IND CCA security this is the first attempt both the real size g1 are the ideal size each one share initialize key decryption finalize procedures that have natural semantics except for the encryption Oracle we're in the real side you encrypt the real message but in the ideal side you include an all zero bit messages if we are working in a setting of conventional way I'm sorry if we are going to give conventional indistinguishability based definitions we know that this is not enough there are ways to trebly win this game adversary simply asks encryption and gasbag see the hit equals C so that by practice in the real world you will see the regional message and but in the idea that he will say D or zero bit messages are traditionally there are multiple ways to exclude such remove wins you can either exclude from consideration exclude from consideration all adversary's that make such trivial queries or you can first allow such trivial queries but finalize in the finalized procedure you penalize that behavior by returning zero bellario opens and Q's called the first one exclusion style the second one panel histone okay this is the conventional way what about our int C way we need to have first syntax Crimea's condition which we already did we need to have new token games G 1 and H 1 this looks the same as the first attempt and the difference with the previous slide is there is no logic for excluding there's no code that attends to the exclusion of the trivial queries all the security code here looks very natural and that's it C 1 G 1 H 1 define and IND C is equally notion and we shown that we've shown that the resulting identity security definition is equivalent to the conventional one ok you might say this doesn't look very promising you only managed to remove two lines of code so let's go to our main example of state authenticated encryption there have been many prior work on this at least three of them as you might imagine they tend to have different syntax different security goes and they have relatively complex security games that's most important so let's try to use int Siong Stateville often you can equip ssin first the syntax we simply augment the traditional authenticated encryption syntax by a state space both in the input and in the output and the next we need to define Krakus somehow surprisingly this question to the best of our knowledge was not answered explicitly in the literature we choose it if you think about the question what is a correct state of authenticated encryption so if you apply that over a reliable channel things really matter here if you apply that over a reliable channel then you might only receive the required a receiver to decrypt correctly only just for the cipher text that's receiving order but if you are using stateful authenticated encryption over unreliable channel then you might need a stronger correctness requirement you might require the receiver to decrypt correctly for any out of order cipher text except for replay for example between these two can be many variants about this level of fidelity for the receivers we choose to model that by a level set L this is just a set of natural number sequences so that a number sequence is in this level set if and only if it is considered a permissible orderings of the ciphertext generated by the sender at the bottom is our formalization for this Cronus class that's parameterize by this level set L the next let the next step is to give real and ideal utopian games as you can see compared to prior work our security games are much more simple thanks to the IND C because we never we no longer need to write how the explicit logic to exclude those treble-winning queries from the adversary we have an safe o AE construction that satisfies the resulting in DCC CC a security notion as well so finally then we conclude with some of the possible variants for int C framework Oh so everything I just talked about actually it's about one central question how do we formalize the silencing function to reflect the idea of excluding drivel wins there are many definitional traces apart from our silencing function which is a silence near shutdown style we can instead silence once but allow additional queries there can be ideal side editing we don't silence the real rows but instead we added the ideal world responses by the railroad ones there can be penalties to editing where you simply modify the finalization procedure to penalize whenever in the transcript there is a fixed miss query there can even be symmetric silencing let me skip this but I want to mention that out of these four three of them we show that they are expressively they're equivalently expensive as our initial version however convenience does come with some price first definition is coming out of Ind see our abstract in terms of the edited games do not have conquered a security code however most of the time it can be concretely recapitalized so that you can do the conventional security analysis against it it is still a speculative proposal we've only used it on an encryption public key encryption and state fault indicated encryption but we expect the idea can be broadly applicable and there definitely needs to be more work done on this topic to understand how general this idea works and that's all for the talk any questions [Applause] | IACR | UCV-WittrGkRyONzX6UmCaiA | 2018-10-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,833 | 16,018 |
DQRP6cbM5F4 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQRP6cbM5F4 | Should You League Start Bows? How Good Is The Buff? - Path of Exile 3.21 Crucible | yo what's up guys Grim here and in today's video we're gonna be taking on the main question I've been getting asked and that is oh boy are you excited about the bow boss and I think there's quite a lot to talk about here in the early game and the end game we're going to be covering both let's cover the bow Buffs now unfortunately while the Buffs are pretty cool uh they are not exclusively Buffs uh it was a little bit of a a transaction that went on here uh and we're gonna cover both sides of the transaction and it's going to inform you whether or not it's gonna be better or worse to League start and play bows in the end game so what was this transaction well we have gained uh two arrows one is in the form of a brand new cluster up the top here uh which is four points and in range of Timeless Jewels for you and game players and also easily accessible for fresh builds any build that is Ranger is pretty much always gonna pass on the outside here got to get those bow nodes and you know you're gonna come up here eventually to get all the juice up here anyway so pretty much every Ranger is going to have access to that wheel there which is pretty damn good extra projectile is pretty nice in addition that we also have changed Master Fletcher to having an additional projector which is pretty damn cool as well um you know projectiles are a really big deal namely in the early game as well as mid game for bow builds we'll get to that though but what did we lose in exchange for these changes because you know they didn't come free you know this node used to do something else so overall we gained two projectiles potentially we'll get to that um but what was the loss at what cost well this third here Master Fletcher it used to provide 15 increase attack speed 20 increased accuracy and 20 increased projectile speed which when you actually have the mastering which pretty much everybody player is going to take uh is about 20 increase damage uh so overall you did lose a lot of damage from that node that arrow that is a steep cost baby to get that Arrow um you know obviously you get a lot of quality of life and utility and feel goodness from that Arrow but man is that a lot of damage to lose and you're gonna feel that in the early game what you don't have insane gear uh it's definitely gonna be noticeable especially when you're in that like level 50 to 60 to 70 range when you will like pick up these nodes to try and get that massive power Spike uh you'll still get the arrow but you will not get the damage and the the attack speed is especially gonna probably feel a little bit weird um so that's definitely a bit of a downside now the notes that lead up to it also have been reduced in power so previously these used to be nodes which granted 10 increased damage and four percent increased attack speed now there are only five percent increase attack speed so you traded 10 percent damage for one percent attack speed that's not a very good trade in my opinion so um you know that's definitely enough there and it's across three nodes uh so in total you lost 30 damage there uh which kind of sucks and then on this entry node you also lost 10 uh sorry six percent accuracy which is you know when you combine that with the uh the last on there you lost 26 increase accuracy 50 increase damage if you took the the Mastery and 15 increased attack speed and you gained three percent tax feedback so 12 attack speed loss that is a big pile of stats you just lost oh boy that is a lot um so the question is uh does the one projectile make up for that well we'll have to talk about that at the end of the video all right but it doesn't stop there uh we also did lose a few other things so the next thing we lost was the uh Mastery Force suppression uh now pretty much everyone like League starter end game uh you know everyone took this Mastery and what it did was it gave you Critical Strike rating equal to your suppression amount now being a danger you pretty much always had 100 spell suppression even on like day two day one of your build like even as like a beginner like the Rangers death spell suppression that's kind of just how it goes uh so you basically lost a hundred percent increased Critical Strike uh to kind of put that in perspective that is a diamond flask a permanent Diamond flask that you just lost uh or if a watch's eye modifier uh that you lost on your builds uh it's it's definitely a lot and if you actually do want to like math it out it works out to be about uh you know probably like seven to eight percent crit on every single build that you just lost so if you were at a hundred uh you'll be at 92 now uh if you were at 80 you'd be at 72 and you can see like that's definitely like very noticeable very very noticeable so there's not a whole lot of ways to get that back uh not really like people were already like you know kind of stretching together 100 crit so uh definitely a pretty big damage Nerf there which is you know a bit unfortunate but you know that's the way it goes adapt overcome uh you know evolve next up we also do have some changes to the mark cluster here which again was another bow fan favorite now this one came into came into action a little bit later on your Leaf data um so it's not going to affect you in the early Maps uh it's not going to affect you in the yellow Maps it's going to affect you in the Reds when you get to those red maps and you're looking for that single Target damage this one will start to feel a little bit uh you know kind of like cool so what do we lose well these small nodes here got changed to increase flask uh charges for you which is uh you know uh less than ideal and what we lost for that was uh 20 increased damage as well as 10 increase marker effect now the mark effect is the main part of the story here uh that was a pretty big damage increase like massive damage increase I'm gonna set um and you know that kind of sucks to lose you know a bit unfortunate but you know of course uh we do have those extra arrows man so when you get to the Mastery though this is kind of where it's like kind of like a neutral point uh they remove the 25 increased effect of Mark's option now I personally didn't use that option but I know a lot of people did um you can either go for the massive damage multiplier which is that uh or uh pretty much guaranteed 100 frenzy charge up time now I always went with a frenzy charge up time and you know I was feeling pretty good about it uh but if you did go for the damage variant you're basically forced into going for the frenzies now uh which you know it's fine I mean as someone who played all my in-game builds all my League status pretty much everything with the frenzies uh it feels good uh but you know the fact that you lose that option I guess could be construed as a Nerf all right okay so now that we've covered the adjustments uh let's talk a little bit about how this is gonna play out we'll start out with leak starters as you know it's League start man we're gonna we're gonna talk about that first uh I think actually overall uh with the transaction complete uh pound for pound with bows specifically in mind not considering the new of our skill gems it is a buff for bow League starters and the reason for that is that the premiere Elemental boat leak startup right now is artillery ballista and it has some very important projectile breakpoints which right now you're not actually able to hit very easily the first one is getting the helmet enchant which takes your projectiles from six to eight which is a massive damage increase and then the second one is going from eight to ten which is previously pretty easy to do but then in 320 they made it much harder with the reduction in drop rate of the um the Splinter Jewel which Dave totem's extra two projectiles you can't really get that anymore in League starter so we're essentially giving that to us back so you're going to be getting a ton of extra damage from those plus two projectiles which is really really good and it's going to make your early leave starting on the single Target especially in those early Maps uh feel pretty damn awesome in addition to that when you're doing stuff like Bridges and when you're doing like tough parts of Legion and you know like all sorts of stuff like a business you put those turns down as well and it's going to increase your clear as well as the damage in those scenarios so overall that's going to feel pretty incredible in addition to that in the earlier parts of the league you know before you get super Juiced out of your mind you're going to be using lightning Arrow or I shot alongside your artillery blister and it's going to be your very next destination as a bow build after you like get off of that least idea you're going to be investing a lot of your attention in beefing up your lightning arrow and your clear and really making that the focus of your build and in the beginning when your character is just getting started you do not have access to projectiles you do not have access to awaken GMP you don't have access to a plus two bow a plus one quiver or any of that stuff like that it's just incredibly difficult to acquire that early on and it's never really worth it and the cool thing is now you have access to plus two arrows and it cannot be overstated enough just how much of an impact that has on your clear speed as a bow character it's it's phenomenal amount of increase in terms of wait when you're considering doing stuff like Legions or breaches or delirium or anything like that it's substantial like really really big and it's going to feel incredible to have those arrows early on um basically you start out with that you know roughly Seven Arrows as a lightning Arrow build so you get two from Dead Eye four from GMP and one Baseline and now you're gonna be going up to nine so if you think about it it's like a code and then it becomes like a full Arc that's kind of how it feels to play Lightning arrow and that's going to feel really good now there is quite a lot of costs associated with allocating the second form of the projectile which is here and when you're playing in the early part of the league you're going to have a lot of spare skill points on a boat build because you don't have access to clusters you don't have access to a massive threat of Hope and you know it's going to feel really easy to go ahead and grab that four pointer there and get that extra projectile you're gonna get some of that tax feedback that you just lost before and it's gonna feel really really good and you've obviously got the other one over there now the only thing which happens when this transaction starts to come into effect in end game that's when it kind of us to feel a little bit uh you know because your skill points are a massive resource for both pretty much every point you take is like eight to ten percent more damage every point that you level up when you're on an end game bow build and investing four for you know marginal gains on the three travel points and then the Multi Shot is like just like you know it's a good bottle but it's nothing insane it's just not gonna be worth it I don't think in the end game even the most crazy builds I don't think they're gonna take this um right now I'm on the fence about it and I'm like leaning towards not taking it in the end game it's something I'm going to respect out of um but yeah it's it's not thrilling I'm not thrilled by the the prospect of spending four skill points here and having to drop like sleight of hand or you know or you know wheel of blades or anything like that which comes from the massive threat of Hope um you know skill points are incredibly valuable to Bow builds and losing that um for the for the extra projectile just doesn't feel like it's worth it when you've got the insane gear okay so basically you feel the art of the video is that bows are going to feel way smoother way better they're going to get online way earlier in the early game your Elite starters if you liked bows before well you're gonna like them even more now in the league start if you're an end game player you know that kind of sucks uh you definitely got nerfed here um in like a vacuum if you're not considering Crucible it is going to be a reduction in power in addition to that your top end also got caught a little bit you're not going to be able to get that that synthesized bow implicit you know for the two people that get that all that synthesized quiver implicit for the three people that get that so that's definitely gonna suck but for the most part let's refocus here on League starters it is going to be a massive quality of life boost so the lead starter I'm personally playing and did play lastly I feel more confident about playing at this league because you know those projectiles are going to be a big deal they're going to make it so that I can Farm stuff way earlier way easier and way smoother and I am really excited about that now in addition to that we also do have to discuss these vile skills coming out now I have no idea how good they going to be you really do have to get in there and play with them to really get a good understanding of what that's going to look like but the most likely candidate for success is going to be a lightning arrow and that is because Lightning Out is just the mechanically Superior skill in addition to that the Vol variant also does look like it does have a little bit more potential for shotgunning and messing around with it and the Damage multipliers do look maybe a little bit better on that from what I can see so far but you know it's going to take us getting in game and using it to really understand so that is also going to be a buff in some capacity to that League start variant where you know you get on there you know you've got file line error now instead of normal lighting arrow and when you get to a boss or when you get to a legion general or when you get to anything you just bang it's just free damage you know why not uh you know it's gonna do something surely so you know overall it's gonna be a buff there and it maybe it makes your single Target a feel a little bit better so you put down your totems pop violating error smash it you know you know should be pretty good it remains to be seen how impactful that will be uh best case scenario it's like maybe so good you don't even have to run the totem setup anymore what's this scenario is you know it's like 10 more damage which you know is welcome anyway you would run it it's not like it's going to cost you vassals that much in the grand scheme of things you'll still be able to keep all his stuff it's going to take an extra like two seconds to charge at the start of the map no big deal all right um so now to round things out I want to talk about Crucible trees as a lot of the nurse are pretty much going to be completely mitigated by The Crucible trees uh they are a form of borrowed power so you know we're gonna probably lose them the league after this and that's when you really feel bad about the Nerfs but this league you don't really have to feel bad about them at all because there is base Critical Strike chance on the tree on The Crucible trees we've seen it uh it looks strong and you could just get that on the boat there's stuff like accuracy there's stuff like attributes which you can stack for Omni so maybe you can respect Omni stuff in the late game you don't need to take this anymore put those points in the extra projectile um you know you get damage there could be build defining nodes you know it's not going to feel terrible I'm pretty sure you're gonna be able to get most of the power back uh and more like substantially more from The Crucible trees so if you're on the fence like ah man don't want to play our nerfed build uh just know that like in a vacuum without the crystal trees it's probably Stronger by quite a lot in the early game and in the end game considering Crucible trees it's probably stronger there too by quite a lot I would imagine and then the final note is that there could be potential for the new bow to be pretty damn strong still running the numbers on that you can expect a video on that coming probably pretty soon if it looks good and if that is a unique which is accessible in the earlier parts of the league that could really smooth out the progression of bows and make it like you know very competitive as a league starter so overall that's gonna be the video guys hope you guys enjoyed uh if you're wondering about Bose definitely go for it I can highly recommend it it's got great one to ten act leveling and it's really really nice in the early game of maps as well the only weakness I would say of the build is that it does struggle a little bit with the Pinnacle bosses unless you are mechanically gifted unfortunately I'm not I'm going to be buying those TFT areas with the rest of the year um but anyway I digress hopefully you guys enjoyed I will be streaming on Twitch for League start so definitely check that out and also if you enjoy the video subscribe and like so YouTube knows that it's a good video and until next time cheers [Music] thank you [Music] | Grimro | UCW-hxsDOLJ_F9ZMoh_izpRQ | 2023-04-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,351 | 17,220 |
6-tGwHO1o7w | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-tGwHO1o7w | C8-Ocean currents upsc ias-Gulf Strem,North Atlantic Drift,Bengula,Kuroshio,Oyashio | Hello friends welcome to video series on geography this is my blog pmf is.com previously I've had a different domain Forman friend.org but now I've shifted shifted to pmf is.com so all my noes are available on this blog in my previous videos I've explained about pressure belts and permanent winds pressure belts permanent winds and ocean currents play an important role in determining the temperature Distribution on Earth and H ocean currents will be dealt under climatology instead of under oceanography ocean currents are a regular movement of water in a definite path and Direction and the forces that influence this moment of water are solar energy wind gravity and corus force of all the forces the most important force is the wind we'll see about the influence of permanent winds on the ocean currents in detail in this video other than wind we have solar energy solar energy is the prime driving force of the primary energy which creates pressure systems and wind systems so the ultimate source is Sun but the direct influence of solar energy is comparatively low compared to the winds and we have gravity and coris force solar energy creates differences in levels of ocean surface for example at the Equator the levels of waterers are comparatively higher compared to at the poles so this is because of differences difference in heat reception at equator there is greater amount of Sun's insulation and hence the volume of water is higher because of greater greater temperature received whereas at the PO the amount of heat received is is low and hence the density is greater so the water molecules are much more Compact and hence the levels of water surface here is lower so this differences in temperature are leveled by gravity so gravity simply moves water from a region of higher level to region of lower level so this irregular levels of water is leveled down by gravity so gravity is important in movement from region of higher level to region of lower level coming to coris force coris force influences the direction of ocean currents in northern hemisphere the movement of ocean currents is clockwise in Direction whereas in southern hemisphere they are anticlockwise so in my previous video I explained about Coralis Force Coralis force is a deflection Force where the body moving in northern hemisphere moves or deflects towards it its right whereas a body moving in southern hemisphere deflects towards its left this is because of coris effect and coris effect in turn is generated due to Earth's rotation and we have two different kinds of ocean currents one is horizontal ocean currents other ones are vertical ocean currents horizontal ocean currents are the ones we see in this figure vertical ocean currents mainly occur due to differences in temperature and salinity the water which is cold and is higher in salinity is usually denser and this water falls to the bottom layers whereas the water which is less salign or lesser has lesser temperature is usually warmer and it is less denser and it it raises towards the top layers so this is nothing but convection so convection influences vertical distribution or vertical movement of water whereas the horizontal movement is influenced by mainly primary winds so cold water flows at the bottom levels whereas warm water flows at the surface or subsurface levels so let us assume that this is the top layers of ocean water and this is bottom layers so in the top layers the warm water flows and in the bottom layers the movement of water is mainly in the form of cold Waters because cold water is denser so it flows at the bottom layers so subsurface is nothing but a layer which is about 500 400 M below the upper surface So within this layer the horizontal M of warm water dominates so coming to types of ocean currents they mainly types based on whether they flow on the surface or the bottom so one is surface currents other one is deep water currents and then we have cold or warm water currents so cold currents flows from higher latitudes to lower latitudes whereas warm currents flow from lower latitudes lower latitudes to higher latitudes and we have currents based on Direction one is clockwise in the Northern Hemisphere and anticlockwise in the southern hemisphere this is because of coris effect coming to general characteristics we have ocean currents which follow ferals law ferals law is nothing but the law that states object moving in the northern hemisphere moves towards its right and the object moving in the southern hemisphere moves towards its left so this is nothing but ferals law and the force that that is governed by ferals law is called as coris force and at lower latitudes we see cold currents on Eastern parts of the oceans and warm currents on the western parts whereas at higher latitudes we see warm currents on the western parts and cold currents on the Eastern parts and air circulation over the oceans in middle latitudes is mainly anticyclonic so we'll see this why and the exact opposite in the higher latitudes first one is feral law we have seen how feral law influences the direction of wind ocean currents and then we have ocean currents which are cold at the lower levels that is at the lower latitudes we see cold currents in the western parts of the oceans as these cold currents flow from for towards equator whereas on the west sorry on the Eastern parts of the oceans we see cold currents at the lower latitudes whereas on the western parts the cold currents move from equator towards the western parts of the oceans so this current or this waters are completely warmer so we see warm currents along western parts and this warm currents moves towards higher latitudes so at higher latitudes we observe warm currents at the western parts of the oceans whereas this warm currents mix with cold currents and move as cold currents at the top layers so we have warm currents on the western parts of the oceans and cold currents on the Eastern parts of the oceans at higher latitudes and we have air circulation which is which is anticyclonic in lower latitudes that is mostly in the presence of high pressure Zone we have subtropical high pressure Zone which is at about 25 to 35° North and South latitudes so here the a subsides to the bottom layers so I've discussed this in detail in my previous video so this subsidence is associated with Divergence process so in northern hemisphere convergence creates circular motion of wind this circular motion is usually anticyclonic so we have ocean currents which are cyclonic in movement but if we consider the movement of or the circulation of air cells we find that they are anticyclonic nature so when convergence is anticyclonic the Divergence will be cyclonic so Divergence in the lower latitudes is cyclonic hence the movement of ocean currents or the guers in the oceans the GU is nothing but circular movement of water are influenced by anticyclonic movement in lower latitudes that is in subtropical hybri belt whereas in subpolar low pressure belt we have convergence occurring at the surface convergence is associated with wind moving towards a low pressure center so this winds create a circular motion or spiraling effect which is anticlockwise in Direction so this anticlockwise direction also creates an anticlock anticlockwise movement of ocean waters in the upper levels so at the bottom layers we have the clockwise movement because of Divergence whereas in Upper layers we have anticlockwise movement because of convergence coming to ocean currents first let us look at the ocean currents of Pacific Ocean so in Pacific Ocean depends on depending on season the presence of various currents occur at various latitudes for example usually the north equatorial current in Sama occurs about 5 to 10° above equator and this current flows towards West this is under the influence of easterly Trade Winds so we know that at the intertropical Convergence Zone that is where Trade Winds meet it more more or less coincides with the equator in Pacific Ocean here the winds from both the hemispheres converge so at the equator we have deflection because of coris force so these converging winds influence the ocean currents so the trade winds coming from northern hria are most more influential hence they push towards West so this is nothing but North equatorial current so this current piles off lot of warm water at the Indonesian Islands so this is what happens during normal conditions in elino condition usually the trade winds are weaker and hence the piling up of ocean warm water at the Indonesian islands is comparatively lower and the upwelling process at the Peru and Equador Coast is comparatively lower and this event is called as elino about which I'll be discussing in detail later so in normal condition what we see is piling up of warm water at the Indonesian Islands so this water that is a part of Eastern Pacific moves towards Western Pacific this is because of North Equador current this current moves towards Japanese islands and kamka peninsula in the form of kishino current so kushino current is a warm current and at this point there are two currents which converge at the upper hikaro Japanese island so this is called as hikaro Japanese island so one current coming from shalan islands that is this part of oceans which is called as okart current and the other one is kamka current or oo current which is coming from this region so this peninsula is called as kamka Peninsula so this currents converge with kishino hot current or warm current so these flow in the form of North Pacific current towards North America so here the the movement of ocean currents is influenced by Westerly so in near in the tropics what we have are easterly mostly easterly so this moment of water is from east to west whereas in the upper latitudes about that is about the regions between subpolar low and subtropical High what we have is wester Le so Wester Le make this converging currents move towards West so these West moving currents further divides into two branches one is Cold current other one is hot current so the Alaska current is Cold current whereas the California Current which flows along the coast of North America is called as California current which is a cold current so when we me say it is a cold current it simply doesn't mean that it is very cold it only means that it is comparatively colder than the surrounding regions whereas we see that Alaska is warm current so it is not a very warm current it is definitely very cold but it is comparatively warmer compared to the surrounding environment so usually the surrounding surrounding environment is very cold so this Alaska current is comparatively warmer so it is called as warm current so this California current completes the cycle by converging with North equatorial current and this cycle repeats so depending on Seasons the north equatorial currents shift North and South along with other other currents for example in Winter usually intertropical Convergence Zone moves towards the equator that is south of equator and at this point the north equatorial current is somewhere along the Equator so this shift is mainly due to change in seasons in summers we have greater temperatures in northern hemisphere so North equatorial current shifts further towards north and coming to Southern Pacific just like Northern equatorial current we have Southern equatorial current but the most important factor is counter equatorial current so counter equatorial current is a current which flows in opposite direction Compared to North equatorial current and South equatorial current so due to trade winds we have South equatorial current which is Flowing from east to west and we have North equatorial current which is also flowing from east to west and the counter equatorial current as the name itself suggest it flows in opposite direction from east to sorry west to east so what creates counter equatorial current usually the north equatorial current and the South equatorial current pile up huge amount of warm water near the Indonesian and new guinia islands so this piling up of very warm water creates high higher level of higher levels of oceans and we have seen how gravity plays a role in leveling down this surface and the region between North equatorial current and South equatorial current is associated with do drums we have seen that intertropical Convergence Zone is nothing but region of very calm winds at the surface so we have upliftment of air at the do rums so there is huge amount of cloud formation and range but at the surface of oceans usually the air is very calm and hence there is no air that pushes from the current from east to west and hence due to absence of this air the counter equatorial current becomes very strong and it moves from west to east so the primary reason is the piling up of water on the the West Coast but the most important reason is the do drums that is presence of calm region between North and South equatorial currents so South equatorial current breaks up as East Australian current which is also warm current it mixes with West Wind Drift West Wind Drift is a current that is comparatively cooler and the winds that are flowing in this region are west east and they are very Swift Ming moving winds because of less amount of continents so the EST is influenced this current that is East Australian current in a great way and then we have this current forming as South Pacific current which is a cold current as the regions are very cold and a branch moves towards Atlantic Ocean and another Branch moves towards the equator in form of Peru Current Peru Current is a cold current which is also called as humal current H MB ldt current so per current is a very important one because it brings cold water towards the eador and Peru Coast so this cold water is very important as it creates Rich fishing grounds so and again the convergence of warm currents and cold currents is a very important reason because they are the richest fishing grounds in the world for example we have seen at the haadio island of Japanese Coast we have seen this convergence of warm and cold currents that is we have cold currents oo oats which are converging with cruso current so the this region is a very rich fishing ground because of mixing of cold and warm currents likewise we have another mixing Zone here that is Peru Current mixes with South equatorial current so this also creates a very rich fishing ground so why are these rich fishing grounds first we need to know about Plankton phytoplankton contains Dingo flates and then we have uh diatoms blue green alga that is sorry blue green alga Etc which are which are photosynthetic in nature so these are very important because they form food for various marine organisms es especially fish so phytoplankton usually require two important components one is sunlight other one is nutrients nutrients like phosphates sulfates Etc but we have ocean levels that is we have top layers and bottom layers usually at top layers sunlight is abundant evidently available whereas at the top layers the presence of phosphates and other nutrients is very low they are present at sub subsurfaces so the photosynthetic process of phytoplankton is comparatively very low when this kind of situation occurs so when there is mixing of cold Waters and warm Waters usually the cold waters are very nich in nutrient rich in nutrients that is phosphates so when this nutrient Rich water mixes with the warm water it is nothing but up filling of cold water so what we have is cold currents which are flowing at subsurfaces so this cold water is uplifted so when this movement creates South equatorial current there is a kind of vacuum created in this region this vacuum is is filled by Peruvian current which is Flowing from bottom levels to top levels so this is nothing but upwelling so when there is upwelling of this cold Peruan current it usually brings Rich nutrients towards the surface now the phyto phyto flankton at the surface have the two components which are very essential one is sunlight other one is nutrients so so the nutrients are brought by Cold current so in the presence of nutrients and sunlight they create that is they prepare food in the form of photosynthesis and they multiply in large quantities which form great food for fish so this mixing of cold and warm currents is very important as they breed a very rich fishing grounds so again remember the role of phyto Plankton phyto means light and Plankton are very small marine organisms other than this we have great Banks of North America so this is great Banks region this is also a very rich fishing ground so we'll see that how before that let us take a question which was asked in 2015 prelims what explains the Eastward movement of counter equatorial current so we have seen that counter equatorial current is caused mainly due to two reasons one is piling up of water on the west Western part of oceans and the presence of do drums so in this question both the options are pres present that is Convergence of two equatorial currents and then occurrence of belt of come near the equator the other two options are completely unrelated that is differences in salinity of water and Earth rotation on its axis so earth rotation creates the coris force which only influences direction of uh that is clockwise Direction in Northern Hemisphere and counterclockwise Direction in southern hemisphere that is this movement of ocean waters is influenced by Earth's rotation so along with this we have one more important property if suppose this is a continent we know that Earth is rotating from west to east so this continent is also moving from west to east so there is opposite Force which is acting on the water so the water is moving from east to west because of the opposite movement of land so there is piling up of water on the eastern part of ocean or western part of Contin sorry eastern part of continent or western part of ocean because of Earth's rotation so Earth's rotation is a factor which brings water from west to east but it is not an important factor that creates West sorry which Earth's rotation brings water from east to west so this is east and this is West and we have do drums or under of which the counter equator equatorial current happens here the counter equatorial current is from west to east so west to east is not under the influence of Earth rotation this is wrong and differences in salinity creates only vertical movements not horizontal movements so this is also wrong coming to convergence convergence is an important factor but above convergence there is one very important factor which is the presence of doal drums so the answer for this is D though there is conflict between B and D but D is the most important point so D will be the answer now let us move on to currents of Atlantic Ocean like in Pacific we have North equatorial counter equatorial and South equatorial currents so the northern North equatorial current splits as an relase current which flows on the east of West Indies and other branch which flows towards Gulf of Mexico here due to the reception of water from Mississippi River the levels of water in Florida that is Gulf of Mexico is much higher so this flows towards the Cape of fish so this region is Cape of fish in the form of Florida Florida current which is the warm current it mixes with Anis current and from here what we have is Gulf Stream So this warm current which flows from Cape of Fes towards great Banks is called as Gulf Stream so these are great Banks it is this island is called as new formed land which is part of Canada and we have NOA stia which is also an important Island here we have Bay of fun funi which is important for his tital range about this we'll see later but now let us see about Gul Stream So Gul stream converges with Labrador current and East Greenland current which are cold currents so this mixing of warm and cold currents G gives rise to a very rich fishing grounds around new formed land again remember how this mixing gives rise to upwelling of water so upwelling of cold water brings nutrient Rich water to the surface and this helps in multiplying of phy phylon numbers and this will in turn give rise to Rich amount of food for fishes and hence these are very rich fishing grounds so new found land and the continental shelf of new found land is called as great Banks so usually continental shelf also plays a very important role continental shelf is a very shallow region of oceans so all these factors a in making these grounds a rich fishing grounds so from here we what we have is North North Atlantic drift drift which is a warm current this is one of the very important ocean currents because it greatly influences the climate of climates of in Britain Norway and all these regions Scandinavian countries Etc usually these countries are very close to Artic Circle which is somewhere here but in spite of being under the influence of AR Arctic Circle the temperatures are comparatively higher because of North Atlantic Atlantic drift and this current is very important in keeping the baron sea that is this part of the sea free of ice in summers so Russia is able to transport or continuous supplies in this direction because of the the presence of North Atlantic drift which keeps all this part of the ocean free of ice in summers but in Winters as the temperatures are very very low usually this part is completely Frozen but still in Sama it is great it is of great economic importance for all these countries that is Britain Norway and Russia so most important cities of Russia like moscos ALR Etc are present on the western part of Russia so it gets a direct axis from with this help of North Equador North Atlantic drift so it gets SE route towards USA and other parts of the world so North Atlantic drift is from economic perspective and climatology perspective is a very important current so from there we have Norwegian current which is comparatively warmer so it helps Scandinavian countries in maintaining comparatively less extreme climates and this Branch splits as can Canary's current canis current is a very cold current so it keeps the climates of Portugal Spain and some African nations comparatively colder so again this completes the cycle but here we have one important physical feature called as saragas sarasi is formed mainly due to the the M of ocean waters so the North Atlantic drift anatas current Gulf Stream North Atlantic North Atlantic drift North equatorial current and caneris current all this creates a GU or circular movement of ocean water so this circular movement of ocean water creates a c called as saraso SE so sarasu sea is important from environment perspective because it it is a very rich Marine echo region its productivity is comparatively very higher this is because when there is circular M of water usually solid particles accumulate at the center so you can observe this in a bucket of water where you put some sand or something else and if you just rotate or create a w poool in that water we see that all the solid particles accumulate at the center so this is what the principle that helps in making SAS a very important echo region so this gu or circular mov of water brings all the nutrients and all of the solid particles towards all of the floating particles towards the center of the SAS so this nutrient Rich water helps in uh greater Marine productivity so the most important uh fish organisms available here are sea which are also called as sasum that's the end the name saso SE so it is unique because of this species and there is huge amount of productivity in this region and hence there is thriving marine ecosystems so again important feature is that it has this sea has no land border so it is bordered by all ocean currents on all the directions it it is also called as North Atlantic subtropical gu because it it it is under the influence of the diverence of winds that are at the that forms at the subtropical high pressure belt we have seen that in subtropical high pressure belt we have diversion so due to Divergence we have this anti uh clockwise direction of the movement of ocean currents or the movement of ocean currents in sasos so it roughly coincides with aorai aorai is the high which is a broken region of subtropical High which coincides with the location of sasos so usually somewhere here is azor's high now let us see the South Atlantic Ocean like in the South Pacific we also we have the warm currents like Brazil current which is the branch of South equatorial current and there is one current which is Flowing towards the part eastern coast of Argentina which is called as faland current so these islands are faland Falkland Islands so FAL faland islands are not a part of Argentina as they appear to be they are part of Great Britain so these territory are a part of Great Britain these are overseas territories of Great Britain so this is Cold current and again here there is mixing of warm and cold currents hence this is also a good fishing ground and then we have Brazil current which mixes with West one drift and it flows towards West here this cold current breaks up as bangula current so bangula current is important as this also creates a rich fishing ground but this mixing occurs mainly at tropical waters so the productivity is comparatively low as I've so told you that in tropical waters usually the nutrients are present at bottom layers and H the the amount of nutrients available in tropical waters is low and hence the productivity is comparatively low compared to other regions like new found land or uh the Japanese Islands so let us now look at currents of Indian Ocean so Indian ocean currents are mainly influenced by monsoon winds so here the currents behave in a different manner let us look at Wich in winter season in winter season we have Northwest Northeast monsoons so this is usually the direction of Northeast monsoons which bring rainfall to Tamil Nadu so some a branch splits and flows along the coastal regions so this doesn't bring any rain much rain to Northern parts of India because because of absence of ocean from which it is traversing so it is comparatively dry here so this wind is very important in creating anticlockwise movement of water in Bay of Bengal here there is North equatorial current so which flows in this direction creating anticlockwise Motion in Arabian C and the anticlockwise direction in Bay of Bengal is due to North Northeast monsoons so it creates a complete cycle in the Bay of Bengal so this is a cycle complete cycle in Bay of Bengal so here the monsoons plays a very important role and like in Atlantic Ocean we have South equatorial current and counter equatorial current the mozic current flows between madagaskar Madagascar and mozambik of Africa and the other branch is called as aalas current this mixes with again Westwind drift it flow as West Australian current and again this region is a good fishing ground but it is not as good as those in temperature regions because of as it as it is pres present in tropical regions so tropical regions are comparatively low in Marine productivity because of less amount of nutrients and less amount of f phytoplankton and coming to Summers we don't have North equatorial current and counter equatorial current this is the most important part because in summers what what we have is there is Shifting of intertropical conversion Zone towards uh the north of equator and hence there is Shifting of ocean currents as well so instead of North and South counter equatorial current what we have is South equatorial current which shift towards north of equator so this current flows in this direction creating an anticlockwise sorry clockwise movement in Arabian Sea so this flows again into Bay of Bengal creating one more anticlockwise movement so here it is the North equatorial current and counter equatorial current are absent so what we see here is South equatorial current which splits up as a branch in Arabian Sea and B of Bengal and another branch of mozic current so again exactly the same thing happens with the southern region as in winter so the southern Parts have same behavior whereas in the Northern parts the movement of ocean waters is influenced by monsoon winds so in some of this is the direction of monsoon winds usually we have mascarin high from where the EAS least change their Direction and moves towards India in the form of monsoon winds so this monsoon winds creates this movement of ocean currents in B of Bengal and Arabian Sea so in Indian Ocean the movement of ocean water in the northern part of Indian Ocean is mainly influenced by Monsoon drift or monsoon winds so let us look at look at a question on this which of the following factors is responsible for the change in regular direction of ocean currents in Indian Ocean Indian Ocean is half an ocean is means that the northern part is not full because it is occupied by land Indian Ocean as Monsoon drift Indian Ocean is a landlocked ocean and Indian Ocean has great variation in salinity coming to salinity salinity the behavior of salinity is similar in almost all the major oceans so this point is wrong Indian Ocean is a landlocked ocean that is Indian Ocean is landlocked and Indian Ocean is half an ocean are similar points and they have no effect on the movement of ocean currents they only influence the path but they don't influence the reversal of ocean currents so so change in regular direction is mainly attributed to Monsoon drift as we have seen so the answer is mon drift this is comparatively easier question so this is complete picture of all ocean currents so the red ones are warm currents whereas the blue ones are cold currents so I've discussed all these till now this is a complete picture in the given map which of the following pairs of ocean currents are shown so recall the ocean currents till now we have discussed bangula and Faline current so these currents are a part which flow in the part of South South America so we have South America we see one as Faline current other one is Brazil current and then it moves and at Africa it breaks up as bangula current so in this region what we see is bangula current so the answer must have bangula current and it must not have FAL current because FAL current occurs at Argentina so this option is wrong and then we have Canary and humbal current humbal current is nothing but Peruvian current the other name for Peruan current is humal current and canares current are the ones which flow near the northern Northwestern regions of Africa so this is also not an answer and we have aulas and Goa current aulas current flows on the eastern part of Africa so this is also not an option and the only left one is Ban guina so Gina is a minor current but again this part is called as a country called as G is present in this region so the current here is called as gy current and in general we have bangula current so the option is D so location based questions will be asked in this manner now let us look at effects of ocean currents so one important factor is Desert formation in tropical and subtropical West Coast previously I've explained the effect of Trade Winds and also onshore and offshore winds in the form in the for formation of deserts their role in formation of deserts in this part we'll see the role of ocean currents so moderate climates at the coast are created because of ocean currents we we have seen that the ocean currents bring cold Waters into warmer regions and warmer Waters into colder colder regions and there is moderating effect and we have seen about Eastern the behavior of ocean currents in higher and lower latitudes and mixing of cold and warm Waters be bear Rich fishing grounds and they are the most important part in ocean currents and the mixing also creates a very foggy like climate with little drizzle that is rainfall in the form of drizzle so foggy climate are associated with very completely covered skies and with the visibility is very low so these regions are not good for navigation that is air navigation but the foggy climate is important as it is very favorable for fishing because of the Pres presence of Cold current and the absence of intensity of Sun so results in warm and rainy climates in tropical and subtropical latitudes so they are the major source of tropical Cyclones so we have seen that in Pacific ocean that is in the Indonesian Islands Etc the piling up of warm water so this piling up of warm water is important in creating typhoons in Pacific Ocean in Indian Ocean in Bay of Bengal we see the formation of cyclones again Cyclones are formed due to accumulation of warm Waters so ocean currents in import are important play an important role in bringing Cyclones so the question is the presence of hot deserts between 20 and 30° latitudes so let us look at regions where cold currents influence the weather we can see in this region we have Californian current so it creates a foggy condition and in this region at the new so in this region at New Foundland and great Banks we have the movement of Gulf Stream and mixing of Labrador and Eastern Greenland currents so again here it's a foggy climate and here we have Canary current we have bangula current here and then we have Peruan or Humbolt current and here we have West Australian current here we see kuso oo and Art's current meeting so all these regions are foggy uh have foggy climates so and because of presence of fog and also presence of cold currents these regions create a desting effect of atmosphere so atmosphere has little amount of moisture and this cold Curren doesn't Aid the formation of great amount of moisture because the cold Waters usually are bad because they don't there is no great amount of evaporation when there is no evaporation there is no moisture in water so they create a desting effect and then the air surrounding this parts has has very little MOA and H they don't bring any rain towards these regions and this is why these regions are extremely arid because there is no rain formation because of presence of cold Waters so cold Waters play an important role in formation of deserts only in tropical and subtropical regions so what would be the main reason for the formation of African and European desert belt it is located in the subtropical hyper belt so we have seen how presence of subtropics subtropical hyper belt create deserts and then we have seen how cold currents a in desert formation but in option we have seen that influence of warm current so this option is wrong so the answer is only one and again ocean currents are slow surface moving of water in the ocean ocean currents assist in maintaining the Earth heat balance ocean currents are set in motion primarily by prevailing winds ocean currents are affected by conf configuration of the oceans so this is true prevailing winds it is true and Earth seat balance this is also true and the most tricky option is ocean currents are slow surface moving Waters so coming to the movement of ocean currents usually the movement of ocean currents in Pacific Ocean is about five kns so one KN is equal to 1.8 km so 5 kns will be equal to about 9 km that is the ocean currents travel at a speed of 9 to 10 kilm per hour so this can be considered as a comparatively faster movement of water so it cannot be ocean currents cannot be considered as slow surface slow movement of water so this option is wrong so this particular option is very tricky so the answer identifying the answer will be very a tough a tough job and this is kind of a a tough question we can see there are two options present so it is tough to decide between point one but according to official key the answer is one and also ocean CRS are usually considered as fast moving movements of ocean waters so consider the following factors rotation of Earth air pressure and wind density of ocean water revolution of Earth which are the following influence ocean currents coming to rotation I have told that due to Westward west east movement of Earth we have east to west movement of ocean waters this is because of rotation and also due to wind there is greater push of east to west water and then we have density of ocean water which creates horizontal movements sorry vertical movements so all these factors Aid in movement of ocean waters coming to Revolution of Earth revolution of Earth mainly creates Seasons so Seasons only shift the intertropical Convergence Zone so they only shift the location of these currents that is they shift towards north in the in the summer and South towards in the winter so coming to which factors influence the ocean currents so the answer can be taken as all the four but the official key has given b as answer so they have ignored revolution of Earth because it indirectly affects it doesn't affect directly so that may be the reason why they excluded this answer but if you consider rotation of Earth it results in seasons and Seasons also influence ocean currents so coming to the presence of phyto phyto Plankton and Marine diversity we can see that the temperate regions which are very green in color as we can see are very rich with fight of lankton because of cold currents and also uh lesser temperatures creates ideal grounds for breeding of fight of lankton whereas if you see at Tropical regions even though there is mixing of cold and warm currents in certain regions like here here and then here we see that the presence of phytoplankton is very low because the tropical that is the the productivity at equator is very low as I've already explained because there is little upwelling and there is little amount of nutrients available for fop flankton so this is what till now we have discussed about pressure belts wind wind systems and ocean currents so all these factors influence in temperature distribution and temperature distribution is indicated in terms of isms so isms are imaginary lines draining places with equal temperatures so this is about General isothermal Trend they're influenced by continential usually as we go deep within the contus the temperature range greatly varies in in Winters they are very cold whereas in summers they are very hot and then we have other reasons as you can read in this slide So based on all these factors we have distribution of ocean uh that is temperature distribution so making use of knowledge of wind systems and ocean currents we can arrive at the temperature Distribution on Earth so I'm not going to discuss this in detail I'll be only telling about important features so in this figure we see isms in January Northern Hemisphere that is it is winter in northern hemisphere so here we see this upward bending of iso this is because of the presence of North Atlantic Drift We have seen that North Atlantic drift brings greater temperatures into this higher latitudes so we can see this Bend is mainly due to the presence of North Atlantic drift so usually when isms move towards much towards higher latitude it simply means that the temperature difference is very low and we can see there is close spacing between ISS it simply means that there is greater changes in temperatures in these regions whereas wide spacing indicates that the temperature fall is very low so here the temperature fall is very low whereas if we consider the same between this very closely spaced isms the temperature difference is very sharp so this is the distribution in July so by studying this you can understand usually in July it is summer in Northern Hemisphere and winter winter in southern hemisphere so the warm waters are very hot so we have cold currents on the other side so we can see this shift in this change in behavior of isoon is due to presence of warm currents on Eastern parts of the continents and West cold currents on the western parts so you imagine how this is formed so explaining this will take a lot of time and also they are not much important for exam so the important one is North Atlantic drift and how it bulges these ISS towards north so this is all about ocean currents and the temperature difference based on ocean currents so if you like my video please subscribe to my channel where you can uh you'll get be you'll be getting the updates regularly and thanks for watching keep visiting | PMF IAS | UCHMn4_Z8494w0hFlaAE-nzQ | 2015-10-09 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 7,168 | 40,477 |
Yteh-5Ur30I | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yteh-5Ur30I | IUIC CHRISTIANS IN PURPLE DONT UNDERSTAND ADULTERY AND LUST BECAUSE THEY LACK THE NAME OF THE LORD | if my heart have been deceived by a woman kamar or if i had laid weight at my neighbor's door then let my wife grind onto another what does that mean show of hands what does that mean let me hear you bro just give it a shot give it a shot microphone right behind you and uh white grinder to another uh i guess uh she can go ahead and sing with another right he's saying if i if i lay with another sister you understand let my wife go away with a multitude of dudes let her go do her thing that's what job is saying all right very good read that verse again verse 10 then let my wife grind unto another and let others bow down upon her he said make it even worse if i commit adultery hey let all these dudes just line up and take it and have their way with my wife that's what job is saying right here but who so committed adultery with those who commit adultery read with a woman lacking understanding they don't really understand things just like when it comes to children right or they or they go onto um an outlet with a key you like why would they do that because they don't really understand their you comes to marriage hey that's an honorable thing in the sight of god come on [Applause] so if you wanna you make take pictures and make videos it don't matter you can do whatever you want but you gotta be married you're single brothers where you at silver brothers hey cap you can't sell them you can't sell you can't sell them wow [Music] wow can i sell them yes don't sell them please but if you marry do you think do what you got to do but you single brothers no you cannot engage in any of it until you're married you understand that no you cannot engage in any of it until you're buried you understand that all praises they're strong in the back brother stay strong all right stay strong all right but you single brothers no you cannot engage in any of it until you're married you understand that all praises they're strong in the back brother stay strong all right stay strong all right now go back to sorak 9 and said you stay strong too brother i said you stay strong too brother i said you stay strong too brother they said you stay strong too brother i want to give all the praises in the honor to yahuwah hashem yahweh hashem her and double honest to the apostles and the elders of great millstone also associate shalom peace to the elect scattered abroad i want to go on this video i didn't really want to go into this but you know you can go on iuic page and find out all kinds of doctrines and things they go off on and i think the biggest part of their doctrine they're going off on is the name of the lord it's always most high in christ blessed or um jesus the christ or whatever i don't know this group you know and the reason why i'm doing a video on these guys because they're claiming to be israelites and there's you know you need to know the truth anyway this guy these guys are saying that um basically lust going into lust and adultery okay porn or whatever they want they're calling it when we tell you that looking at a woman is not lust you're looking at a woman and you liking what you see with a woman as long as she's not married is not lust you know it's not lust and if because you lay with a woman and you have a wife if she's not married it's not lust i mean it's not adultery okay so you know when we wake up to the fact that we're hebrew israelites you gotta know that everything that this man has taught you uh was a jeremiah 20 was it isaiah 29 surely you're turning things upside down everything that this man has taught you is the total opposite you know that whole one wife thing that pushed that through the churches to do eugenics with margaret sanger that's what that was all about and linda baines johnson uh set up these uh churches with the 501c3 tax write-offs this is why these guys got to teach what they teach this is crazy anyway let's go on what they said in joe and job the 31st chapter let me go there real quick i'ma jump to the point because it's quite a few scriptures i have lined up but i'll probably hit him quick we'll see where it goes joel 31-9 it says if my heart had been deceived by a woman or if i had laid weight at my neighbor's door then let my wife grind unto another and let others bow down upon her neck i meant selaki upon her okay and it goes on to say for this is a heinous crime yeah it is an iniquity to be punished by judges by the judges so when you go into the text there are certain times where it's actual woman in certain times where jeremiah 6 and 2 says well israel is like uh like into a commonly woman okay so let's go to um let's go to let's go to the text if my heart received by a woman right and i think when you go on down um slovakia let's go to um verse 13 if i despise the cause of my maidservant or my maidservant okay my manservant or my maidservant when they contend with me when they contend with me and this is why when you go up he talks about his neighbors okay let me go on and on it says in my heart have been deceived by a woman or if i have laid weight at my neighbor's door okay so let's go here to woman like king david that would not have been adultery when he laid with bathsheba if she wasn't married but she was married that's where the adultery came came in okay that's when it became adultery adultery that's when it became a wicked act because she belonged to someone when you go into deuteronomy i believe i think it's the 21st chapter when it talks about it for man is betrothed to a woman okay so-called engaged okay let's go to this woman by a woman h802 okay let's see what it says and then we'll go to lust okay this word woman in this text says woman wife female woman opposite a man wife woman married to a man female of animals so you'll see the one a b c d because they can apply but it says woman wife right woman married to a man okay so is it's in our customs and you can go all through google in history it was always in our customs to have more than one wife woman remember paul even said in the first corinthians 11 chapter man was not created for the woman but the woman for the man now if you in a society today the only thing that would fix that lonely woman heart thing because you got to remember there's a lot of jake waking up to the truth so you can imagine if we kept that ideology of only being with one wife right what about all the other women that is that's waking up what about the woman that one you know want to come into the truth what about those women what are they supposed to do stay on the side and and you know and some of them may have to not saying that they don't they'll pray that the most i send them a true man of the lord we're not saying everyone would just go jump on a man that just because he's holding the bible and saying he's the israelite no you got to pray for that but wouldn't things be a whole lot more simpler if a man if if a woman she's with a man and um let's say he's so-called cheats this is what society teaches you now she has to leave him and do what go with another man then that man do the same thing then he leaves her and go through another man you see how the cycle continues when she could if if you're going to be with all these men that's going to so-called cheat why would you be with a man that have different wives lisa's not cheating you know what's going on you got the same you got y'all dealing with the same man a man gonna come back the same size that he was when he left you ain't but he will if you know what i'm talking about anyway let me go on okay so you gotta understand sometime when your taxes are applied okay you can keep commit adultery to other gods you can commit adultery uh to other philosophies okay but i'm trying to make this quick let's go to genesis 30. let's see if this is adultery and lust and you know there's nothing wrong with looking if you're a man and you look at a woman right and she's not with anybody and you excited and what you see in her that's not adultery okay that's absolutely lawful and if you're a woman right and you look at uh if you're a woman and you're looking at a man and you kind of excited by by him and you like what you see and you think it may work even if he has other woman that's not adultery you know it's not adultery let's go to the scriptures let's go to genesis 31 and when rachel saw that she bared jacob no children you ever watched this show game game of thrones you know you know the real adulteress when you really look at the lust and adultery look at that guy bishop cannot man what did he do what did he do with all that money with all that bacon you know we used to call money bacon back in the day what did he do with all that i see that that's being adulterous i mean that's committing adultery you know adulterer let me say that that's the lust of the heart the lust of the flesh anyway let's go back to genesis and when rachel saw that she bear jacob no children rachel envied her sister and said unto her give me children or else i die because that was important thing so if you got a woman today you're married to the so-called israelite sister right and y'all want children and she can't have children what are y'all supposed to do adopt are you going to go to edom's way of doing things and just go uh a lottery and pick up whatever children child you can anyway and jacob anger was kindled against rachel and he said and my god steve he got frustrated because he was you know you want a son it was about having a son and i'm uh in god's steed who hath withheld from the the fruit of the womb and she said behold my maid bilhah go in unto her and she shall bear upon thy niece that i may also have children by her and she gave him bilhah her handmaid to wife right this guy's talking about at the end of this the thing you know you can't do anything unless you get married where's that in the scriptures these guys are just making it up as they go along these guys that's christian that's christianity man right anyway and she gave bill hall her handmade to wife laying you know laying down you know you might have had a ceremony but laying down with a partner that would make you um that would make her your wife husband and wife because you came together right and jacob went in unto her right this is what it says and he says and she gave him bill har her handmaid to wife and jacob when went in unto her and bilhah conceive and bear jacob a son and rachel said god have judged me god have judged me and have also heard my voice and have given me a son therefore uh called she his name dan and bilhar wraith rachel's made conceived again and bear jacob as second son so even when you go to the story there's so many scriptures on that when you go to the story of um abraham and sarah and sarah gave abraham hagar right to uh because she couldn't have you couldn't conceive and hagar who um conceived and then eventually sarah i believe did conceive you know the malachod three and six said the lord changed not so if this was all wicked why would a lot the lord allow abraham to do that and tell him to do that and don't say it's some special occasion okay and why did the lord allow according to the laws the ancient laws of israel why was jacob why was rachel allowed to give bill right jacob to wife if it was so illegal according to the bible right there's certain instances where when you read deuteronomy 17th chapter where you had kings who were in certain positions where they didn't have time to have all these wives this is why paul said those that have wise beings thought he had none and paul said let a bishop be blameless and have uh but one wife you know who knows if he had other women you know he might have messed with but then you would more more likely of some age and reputation and you didn't have time for that so this is why bishop nathaniel okay if he wants to just be with one wife and any other brother viewers want one wife you want one wife but there's nothing illegal about having two or more wives you know jake's just making this stuff up because he's in synth mode you know jake's in set mode man let's go to exodus 21. um let me go to 21 let me see the uh the scripture uh and 10 exodus 21 and 10 it says um if he take him another wife her food her arraignment and her duty of marriage shall not diminish okay i'm just going through a couple of these scriptures um getting to the point let's go to second chronicles looks like 11. um no second chronicles two it's quite a few scriptures i'd be all day going through all these scriptures okay two and twenty six jarrah jeremiel had also another wife whose name was she was the mother of onam right so i'm just going through these you know a couple scriptures to prove that if it was illegal according to the law because these these was laws that was kept with us there was nothing illegal as and it still is nothing illegal about having more than one wife but this is what iuic is pushing you know if you're single you can't do anything until you get married where is that see it's about nature with the most high set up even in animals the most high set us up to have attraction for one another right it's because we so out of order is where so much adultery is taking place because the women are not in order men not in order either nobody's nothing's in order you are supposed to have some form of attraction to somebody right especially men we will have attraction to a woman you know a shape of curves and it was women who have some form of attraction to men but we have way more testosterone right so we have the stronger drive as as males as men where's the manhood at you know where's the manhood at jake just don't have the manhood let's see what isaiah 4-1 say okay let's see what i was here for in one day say and in that day seven women shall take hold of one man so when when did it all change when did it all change this is going in in this future prophecy after all the hell right after everything was out of order the most high is going to start setting things back in order especially our women you know under the men of the lord and in that day seven women shall take hold of one man saying we will eat our own bread and wear our own apparel only let us be called by thy name to take away our reproach you know these names are very very important in all of us really but mainly the heavenly father you know at the end of the at the end of the day is you you have to call on the name of the lord your how and your household you have to call on that name everything stems off that name if you don't have that name you don't have the holy spirit the holy spirit is not with you if the holy spirit is not with you how can you make any uh kind of corrections on the bible how can you even teach the bible the correct way okay it just doesn't make sense what these guys do they just come up and they make it up they don't go into the text they don't go to purely into studies and they just make it up and they use scriptures and the thing about the bible you could use one scripture another scripture bring it together to plead your cause and and create your own narrative of what you want it's real easy to do but the truth is the truth you know malcolm 3 and 6 said the lord didn't change never change when did he change now let me get this last scripture galatians 6 uh is it galatians 5 16 then i say then walk in the spirit and ye shall not fulfill the lust of the flesh okay the lust of the flesh 1939 desire craving longing desire for what is forbidding see there's nothing wrong with desire desiring okay and longing for a woman there's nothing wrong with that but if she's forbidden then you can't do it right and i'm just going into women there's other things too that you may have lust and desires for you know it's a balance on it you can you can have lust and desires for the truth the truth is not forbidden you can lust for this truth you could crave this truth you can have longing for this truth but you shouldn't have longing for easter okay or these holidays or babylon you get the point you jake's got to come out of that christianity man that's all it is that's all i have on that shallow warm | Defendthetruth | UCGf_M8RuaM9b7YGiIBWC0ag | 2020-10-11 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,231 | 16,200 |
KqJMKjTv6dI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KqJMKjTv6dI | Uricel Review - Does This Product Really Work? DON'T BUY URICEL UNTIL YOU WATCH THIS VIDEO! | what is your a cell euro cell is a gout treatment supplement that claims to be made using ingredients imported from where they are natively grown according to the manufacturer of your cell the product is intended to support healthy uric acid levels while reducing pain and inflammation in joints the goal of this product is to support healthy uric acid levels and inhibit future joint discomfort and also support mobility the manufacturer states that it is processed into extract form under strict Good Manufacturing Practices GMP guidelines in an FDA inspected facility to know more about this product continue watching ingredients euro cell is not a drug it is an all natural dietary supplement which combines six ingredients into a proprietary four step relieving process one tart cherry extract one of the richest sources of anthocyanins tart cherries have been scientifically shown to dramatically lower uric acid and fight gout attacks two celery seeds celery seeds contain powerful pain relieving and inflammation fighting flights such as three and beutel's slide 3 and b3 turmeric contained in the spice circum and turmeric is a powerful pain and inflammation fighter that has the added benefit of directly lowering uric acid for yucca root yucca root contains an active compound called steroidal Sapan in which stops local pain and inflammation yucca root when prepared properly as in uracil a gout remedy will interrupt the body's inflammation response allowing pain and swelling in the affected joint to melt away yucca root can prevent the body from causing more pain and inflammation even if it wants to 5 devil's claw a well-studied pain and inflammation fighter devil's claw is thought to reduce pain much the way prescription cox-2 inhibitors such as Vioxx work devil's claw can prevent pain and inflammation in the body before it starts this is a substance you do not want to miss out on when suffering from a gout attack six Chang capira Chang capital which means Stonebreaker in Spanish has been used for thousands of years to clear gall stones and kidney stones but has recently been discovered that it may help clear uric acid crystals formations which caused gout pain and swelling directions the manufacturer of the supplement advises to take quarter teaspoon one point two three milliliters one to three times a day or as needed you can also mix with water or take straight from spoon it is very important not to mix with soda you should keep your daily water and take very high and let your a cell work on your body based on the manufacturers claims users should begin to feel pain relief immediately and reduced swelling it is also recommended that an individual undergoes a course of a minimum of thirty to sixty days in order to ensure a thorough cleansing Eirik acid possible side effects the ingredients for this supplement is carefully sourced and manufactured with strict standards so as to guarantee potency and purity based on the manufacturers claims euro cell customers users have not reported any negative side effects while taking your a cell however you should contact a medical professional if you are pregnant breastfeeding or under prescribed medication before using this formula price at the time of our review a two ounce bottle of uracil was selling for $44.90 on Amazon multi bottle discounts were also available two bottles for eighty one dollars and 37 cents and three bottles for $119 and seventeen cents saving you about four dollars and five dollars per bottle respectively manufacturer's commitment the manufacturer is extremely confident in the product that they offer an airtight 60-day money-back guarantee if within 60 days of taking your cell you are not satisfied with your results then you should return the bottles used or unused and you will be refunded in full - shipping costs they were several positive reviews for this product at the time of writing this review our final review of yourself your a cell looks like a potentially helpful gout relief formula that works for many though not all it comes with a good money back guarantee allowing you to test it for a significant amount of time and it does not seem to have any adverse side effects however it could be a little more expensive with a bottle lasting only 15 days if used at the recommended dosage there is only one size bottle of yourself however you can purchase multiple bottles at once for a deeper discount | Video Penguin | UCBDLxwKQl4Qi0O-lrob5drA | 2017-10-29 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 749 | 4,435 |
0T2PZ_iVwmM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0T2PZ_iVwmM | NMRG Interim Meeting, 2020-04-14 | if you want to add anything feel free to stop me so this is an immediate trial meeting for April we will start with a brief introduction for the meeting logistic and the agenda and we switch after that to the technical presentation first a couple of reminding slides about the goal of the Archaea the IHF conducts research it is not a standards development organization the for an idea for cases on longer term research issues related to the Internet and our affiliated or sister organization the internet Engineering Task Force focuses on shorter term issues of engineering and standards making we would like to make it clear the distinction between both and our GF can publish information on an experimental documents in the RFC series its primary goal is to promote development of research collaboration and teamwork in exploring research issues related to internet protocols applications architecture and technology and you can get more information for instance in our GF primer for IETF participants RFC 741 I okay following that we have also some policies the RDF generally follows IETF policies and this is the so-called not well just as a high-level reminder for you that this is a reminder of the IETF policies in effect on BIOS topics especially regarding intellectual property or code of conduct so these are important elements we invite you to to be aware of and especially as a reminder by participating to follow ITF processes and policies you're aware that any IHF contributions is an application but are all more control by you or your sponsors must be disclosed as a participants or at indeed to any ATF activity you acknowledge that written audio video and photographic records of meetings may be made public and for information this meeting will be recorded personal information that you provide to ATF will be handled in accordance to the IETF IETF privacy statements and as participants are attendee you agree to work respectfully with other participants and if you're facing any issue please conduct the ambans team and you have a set of other best current practices documents that gives you further guidelines on these ITF policies now that we are also conducting more virtual meetings and especially with series of virtual interims that have been following the IETF 107 that was helpful eerily there are some kind of global etiquette across research group and working group so we would like to highlight a few points please remember that all sessions are being recorded as it is the case for this meeting make sure that your video is off to save man with keep yourself muted unless you are speaking we will end on the cue WebEx chat so if you want to make a comment please type our H in the WebEx chat that means raising n you want to say something and if you want to remove from the queue or not any more comments you may type LH and the cheers will end the queue okay and when you are speaking please for the sake of time please stay to the point be concise and precise I hope everything is clear until now a few links I think if you are already online it means that you know a bit to navigate but this may always be useful the agenda materials are available on the IETF data tracker you have the etherpad which is a shared path you may know its past events etc to the path this is also what we will use as a basis for the minutes the recording will be made available after the meeting and please aside please add your name at the bottom of if not touch the page is very useful to track attendance overview of our agenda for today we have a packed agenda a lot of topics we would like to cover and especially initially we had planned to have two sessions in the IETF one of seven meetings so we want it still to be able to to cover most of those topics so this will be a bit along meeting today but we hope you can stay with us and Cydia so this is the current first load meeting resisting an agenda it will be finished in 1 minute and then we will start our technical presentations with Pedro for intelligent reasoning on external events on the track management and then Sonia will give us an overview of their work in telefónica on metadata based aggregation of telemetry flows we will have then new coming from from me lad on fault tolerance for cervix function change as an introduction of their work and we see also connections with some other activities in IETF on SFC then a new draft coming to the energy with transpose lies in tenth and final notice coming from based on some work in a European project then automate the design of network services from network service requirement is a research article research work he's also in the scope of again work plan then we have some draft energy and ops area working group intent classification with chu-young will give us an update on the current document and some next steps we will have been you are giving us an update on assurance for ibn architecture which is working robot is of course of interest for the idea and definition and finally if we hope we have still time to give you the main research group updates at the end of this meeting I hope the agenda is fine for you if you have any questions or changes please let us know because it's very packed and we would like to start right away share home I don't know if you want to add something oh if we can move on no nothing more from my site perfect but I will protect the slides and you will just tell me or when you want to move to the next site okay roughly it's for presentation and we try to keep time for questions for every person so let's go so I don't see don't see changing no okay so thank you very much for presenting for introducing me I will just present this update and on the draft and working on its it is called intelligent reasoning only certain happens for network management and slightly I have been working on this together with Hamas and from entity to mainly particularize the requirements from Network slicing for for especially from this AI involvement in network management so first quick context that we have is the solutions must work in Symphony with all the network management solutions so they alone it works to grow in complexity to be faster decisions etc so but solutions work only on performance they normally the other AI solutions require more information and intelligent reasoning solutions need to collaborate with network to retrieve topology real-time situation etc and they need some special efficient semantic representation annexation or data for for this adoption of in AI promise me this is the main context we have been working on research challenges and topics in in this overall integration of different not just machine learning about different kinds of machine of artificial intelligence solutions in in network management and especially again I insist that we we have been working together with entity to get requirements from the West lysine in order to fulfill this this involvement next slide please so we're objective has been now to mainly to gather this information the most benefit of the application of this in reasoning me mainly because for now as we can no silly from the last I see a conference we it was very clear that the current status of research on automation and similar tools for the network management is mainly focused on machine learning so it's not bad thing but what I mean is that we have exploited the learning face of intelligence very well but now we have to move forward and in the artificial intelligent world we have the next step and it was also commented in this latest conference the next step is rationing so what is what are the requirements in this sense of from reasoning to exploit the network sorry destroyed artificial intelligence in network management we aim to define some gaps to this required us to this region in application and what will be the challenges to integrate reasoning into next slide please so I think that we can skip this is like that please notice in this one because we have the background I will just comment it so we have different kinds of network systems that will be to computers Sdn etc and we are also focusing on on management and slice slicing so this is the context is very very straightforward and now I will focus on what would be this application of AI to network management as I haven't told in previous meetings I already introduced I am working on this concept and in the latest draft version of the draft I am working on we are emphasizing this so to apply the item and romance mean we need to move beyond machine learning machine learning it's very specific tool and it has very specific way of doing things like it requires one formalization of information in vectors etc and some very efficient or even though it can be computational intensive is very efficient calculations to get some kind of model after that can be exploited okay but for now is it would be good for freeing the machine is there a problem my system but now we have more complex versions like well should emigrate what this built machine to accomplish my goals okay so intelligence is needed for this and the new function for example that answer this question hello network devices to be more autonomic and can be fed to the animal world next slide please so one key that we are working on on these is to extend management operation to achieve some intelligent network management process and this in this sense we have four to make the decisions will have four key points first will be retrieving the information in insolence of different like performance measurement but also other kind of information from the databases external events etc this information is fed to current for example machine learning tools and we obtain the model after that we also execute the rezoning process recently processes will infer new knowledge and rules etc from this information and models both together so we have new rules that will be also fed back to the mobile so it will be constantly building a better view of the network management from the management point of view in order to go to this nexus 10 the system will be to solving potential problems this view will find problems and some specific operation process from what happened Scott would be executed in order to resolve those problems so there will be the solving part and finally once the solution is phone we have to plan that plan how to implement that solution into the network how to require in the network to adjust the amount of resources that are involved or things like that so this four processes will be executed and one key point is that they executed in parallel so they will be inter dependencies but also some way of independence from them among them so it is very tricky way so there are challenges there interface definitions that we must consider in order to to make all these processes work together okay we also have been have been working on the what we call the closed control loop management approach that means that once we have these previously mentioned processes in order to achieve management goals using them we enforce the resulting decisions and after that we constantly check that the decisions are being effective no so what we do is that the close this control loop so one way or another this processes I mentioned before they will be required to connect their outputs to the inputs but in different kinds of a different way so some planning would connect to solving etc so at the end you Tavish that data plane elements would will be involved also in this reasoning because they must provide Sun even small information to check that the that the enforce decision is taking some is being effective so we need that okay Inessa slide please so what we the main way now to execute those processes would be by a specific general Swift Ono of the the metaphor of network management so in this way exploitation of AI and that reminds me what we do is that we begin with data and we want to achieve wisdom so all our solutions become like being able to take this kind of taking decisions by getting data processing the data getting information what we is called or the data formatted in some kind of information then from the information we reason we obtain knowledge and we but we are familiar the knowledge base but with that knowledge well after the application it's at the exploitation of the knowledge what we get is that is a system is a wise system so what we get is wisdom we are also in the in the draft focusing we are also introducing the the achievement of this tangle the wisdom by executing the four processes of AI I mentioned before we we exploit all the knowledge information also we hold the knowledge storing that in the knowledge base in order to achieve a system that is more wise so when I see this wisdom okay so that that would be the key of this exploitation part so next slide please that will be the last slide I don't know how if I am on time of not that I will just finish so for now what we are identifying in this draft is that the challenges we are now facing out the reason or network behavior from perform measurements and Stephanie means that's our main challenge we have a mainly identify right now in the sense of never slicing from network slicing part so the gaps what we find also identify there would be we need some metal for frog for a low in different provides some method and then dos be able to coax it and work together that means that they can exchange information they can understand to each other in the terms of these intelligence data and as I mentioned before the wisdom of that they obtained from all these processes so one key point also what we have identified in the draft if is that we we need some kind of method for the assessment of the quality of the AI that means that if we have different algorithms different modules we can benchmark some way models but not just in the set marking - to know the performance or something like that know just hey I am more focusing on assess that they are working as they are expected because one key difference is that today when we buy or when we integrate some component physical or logical component they normally we we expect no they work well no we are not let's say we we can be deterministic no in the sense that we know that it will work in some way but when we are introducing some AI module we cannot be deterministic we cannot know we cannot be sure that the module will work so we need some way to assess the quality of the model that means that the model will work most of the time that's it things like MTV eventhough something like that but something more focused on the intelligence is house marked how much is the intelligent of this module okay so and in order to achieve this gaps to fill these gaps we have also identified that we need some consistency from ontological concepts so different vendors again on different providers can go exit and on they start to each other so the concept must be ontologically defined and finally what we have identified that the protocol just published information must respond to some concentrate on the target uses that means that for example when we are sharing some data some information of knowledge items among different providers different modules or different modules of that will analyze that information we must be sure that in some software or even organizational contract they will do to the information what we are expecting them to do not just in the terms of security or privacy but in terms of what I mean again is a software contract know that the target model will do what we are expecting it to do and that's what we have right now and from now but we are over main target by saving this draft in the animality is mainly to ask other contributors from the in the sense of both structure for the application of AI to network management but also of course in this kind of challenges and gaps for this again for the completion to achieve more complete spectrum of the of the work that is required to fully exploit the application of a network management that's it okay Thank You Pedro is this the end of representation okay so we have suppose it should be marucho's is acting as cohen research group in the chat rating and so maybe she has a question yeah I'm sorry when you go into WebEx and you use whatever accounting I'm not here as the ecology chair I'm he was a person okay I have two questions comments when I think it's interesting that you didn't mention datasets hear you talk about ontology but it's more than that it's the data set what are the data is that you're going to use for what you call network management and they should be problem specific there's a ton of things that happen in a network that are completely disconnected so what do you mean by having this very generic reasoning the other one you seem to be kind of confused about the role of machine learning machine learning is just not just accumulate data for in comma learning it's also to infer on that learning what you call the AI part so again you have a good data set and you actually have your machine learning then your system becomes by itself autonomous and and so and when you say that you you you need to know if the information is right or not well that's actually what machine learning is designed to do throughout the machine learning process either by automatic decision making or by annotating by experts so you know while you train your algorithm you can have inputs from experts who say well this is the behavior that we we expect so you have your training set so I think you're what I see is that yet there's a lot of good stuff in there but there's a lot of things that seem to be incomplete or mixed up so do you intend in your next version of your draft to make this more clear because right now it's too vague what is the problem you're trying to solve yes that's and so for now we are not focusing in just one problem but again I insist to gather this kind of challenges okay I understand your your points well then I am more in this sense maybe it's not so clear the difference that we are trying to clarify here I said in the sense of this particular difference between the laning phase not just I am NOT saying that machine learning only gathers information machine learning is what it has it builds a model from the information that we we have it will say model of knowledge it's okay but the inference that machine learning has is just for the output of this information what we want is to go beyond that inference to do reasoning on that inference let's say not just learning and and stop there but build the model okay but dynamically change the model in order to do that we must establish new rules and new ways to do that so the idea is that after machine learning process has finished okay we can take decisions with the output but what the next step would be those decisions also output from massive level would be reasoning beyond that I put in order to obtain meta information let's say information about the machine learning tool and let's say change that tool with new rules and new conditions etc that the reasoning operation is doing in that sense after that we again I insisted we have the planning and set robot will be video but the main point where now the deaf the next step right now would be to exploit the risk this reasoning part and we want to clarify that so if you want for example collaborating this draft in order to clarify the point the involvement of machine learning in all this process we are open to new collaborative work with our target right now we are not focusing in in specific problems but in order we have more wide spectrum to define the challenges and gaps and find collaborators that can provide this kind of details that we are missing in the draft ok ok so thanks Mary Joseph for raising your points and thank Pedro trying to address them we are a bit tight on schedule so my recommendation and because I think this is good discussion and we is to follow up with your visual draft maybe with a dressings on the mailing list the comments raised by Rosie trying to develop further what could be your your common understanding on that as you will see later Jerome will present also we have we are producing a new documents on research challenges for AI in network management I believe that some of your inputs could really go to these documents also to contribute to these other documents and as we have seen it will be nice also if you can try to to develop a bit further the next step for your documents and and going from this I will see more higher level views but more concrete proposals how we can develop this further in energy or elsewhere but at least from your initial vision what can be the next steps ok ok final remark but this we can also work offline as properly raised in the chat I mean we see that you have a confidential tag in we have not seen that when we accepted the slides but I think it will be better if you can send us a revised version without this competing shoulder I'm just changing it right now I will send them worries it's okay it's fine okay so give me time to switch to the presentation which I think will be Sonia we already already a bit late with respect to our planning so I will ask our presenters to to really try to be to their time and also fall for that question [Music] good afternoon my name is Sonia and I work in the transport an IP network division in the loyalty tio unit in telefónica research and development so a bit into introversion myself did in the last two years I've been working in different European breeds regarding new telemetry mechanism for Network Devices in 15 that works so in relation with these now we are exploring about a metadata base obligation of telemetry flows which is the main peak of this presentation next slide please so for this presentation we are going through a short introduction followed by the description of the standard in which we base our initial work and then we will see the initial report of our work and finally we will state some conclusions and a request for this research group next next one please as you already know over the years telecommunication network have evolved in order to others they did a man of the new services so the increasing number of nose that forms the the networks and the advanced capabilities the evolution of the underlying technologies and all the different ways to access the network has turned a telecommunication networks into battery genius networks not only regarding the technologies but also traffic requirements from the provision of different services so this situation rise a new way in the network management in which the data is the key element for handing these heterogeneous networks next please in these data oriented networks in which is necessary to handle the rigidity of all of these components is important to offer data in a consistent way to all of the different applications needed for the closed loop automation systems such as some application about artificial intelligence or Big Data or whatever so for this work we propose the use of a semantic metadata framework for aggregation of all of the data coming from the network next so this semantic metadata framework is based on on the idea of using a model to describe the different network elements that are present in a data flow this metadata will not be used for sending the data itself but it models the data the device is capable of providing so using the semantics metadata framework the different data sources or flows will be described by means of this metadata and it would then be necessary to adapt all of the control elements one by one so apart from this the application of this semantic model will imply some changes in the current definition of the descriptors but as we are in a very early stage we are not focusing in this part yet so for the starting point of this idea of defining the framework is based on and the T standard called context information management so I'm going to introduce you a little bit of this concept this is standard defines an API for context information management enable access to information coming from many different sources so for implementing this the standard provides an information model that defines the structure of context information that must be supported by the system initially it was thought for IOT data sources but the scope is not tight for these data sources so this standard allows users to provide consume and subscribe to context information in different scenarios next one please so besides the sim standard does not find a specific architecture for implement in this system they provide some recommendations about three possible architectures a centralized a distributed and a federated architecture a nevertheless the three architecture have the same key components that are the ones that you can see here which are the contacts consumer that is basically the application that needs this context information a of the data sources for the question where information or another they're ones that fits for the application then it is the context producer or context sources which corresponds with all the data sources that produce some data and thus they need the definition of this context data then there is a central piece which is the main the main one which is the broker is responsible for handling these requests from the consumers application and asking information to the source and finally depending on the on the architecture that you choose there is another component which is the contacts registry which is a component that can be in the broker or can be in a separate one in which basically the data source register the context information they can provide and is available we request by the broker for the contract corresponding request a done by the consumers in this one so as you can see here this is the proposal that is in the standard for distributed architecture as you can see all the interactions between the consumers and the source are gone through a broker who requests the context information of the data sources to the contacts registry and the contacts source a previously a were registered in the contact registry next one so as I said before this standard provides an information model that defines the structure of the contacts information that should be supported by the system that I shown in a previous slide so this information model relies on the idea of having an ontology which basically provides the definition of a set of concepts data taxonomy and the relationship that governs this concept so this figure shown a UML representation of the information model defined in the standard which is composed by different entities relationships and properties next one so now once the base for this work is present we are going to to see the initial steps we went through for applying this to the telemetry metadata so one of the final goals we have for implementing this work is trying to build a generic patterns for metadata definition however until reaching these general patterns we start first collecting multiple context serve that we will have available in different scenarios and an initial static definition of sand information models for this context or that we identify so at the same time we are defining all of these information models we would like to start building a semantic aggregator or the broker at desist call in the sim stander by making use of tools already available in the industry for making processing of the data and introduction for the digital models of this architecture and finally all of this work is trying to be aligned with the sim standard as much as possible as we take it as a reference next one apart from from that we start to think how can we integrate this semantic framework into a general and a commune architecture using the current projects that we are working on so as you can see here we had the semantic elevator plus the contest registry in in two possible domains the network service provider domain and the local one these two domains will be able to inter work also in the in in this level and by doing this all the elements available and allowed by the network service provider can be used by the local semantic aggregator to be request by the local service application such as artificial intelligence some monitoring plans for or whatever application it's need in the local domain next one so here you can see some of the data source we have already identified in the place that we are working so some of them are network based profs such as an ICMP probe HTTP DNS IP fix and so on and we are also considering a devices that already defines the information through a general model a for example that are located in some time series database next one so starting from in the next two slides you will see some examples of the information model we have start to define for some of the context source that I shown before so in this case in this slide this correspond to the information model for the network based probe such as an ICMP probe so as you can see it follows the sim standard in which the information model is composed of different entities the the white boxes properties some relationships between these entities so apart from the specific things of this context source the ICMP probe this information model implements two important characteristics the first one how is the information structure of this ICMP probe by the definition of the schema property as you can see with the German dictionary and the second property will be how the semantics of relator the broker can reach this ICMP probe by the definition of the entity employ characterized by the entity URI next one please so the second the second example will be for John based device so we are still defining this information model and it could be sound a little repetitive because the youngin data models have already defined the structure of the information and that word device can provide but a idea of the semantic aggregator is trying to unify all the possible data source needed and not all of these data source implements yon data motives for this reason we thought that it would be good to take advantage of the already defined game models in the device for inferring the properties for this entity device that owns multiple entities of young model next one next one please is the last last slide so as summary we have been seen that the data driven network management requires the aggregation of the original sources of data that we have to do to the different services that are provided and all of the devices that confirm the network's also as we have previously comment we aim to extend existing metadata model for IOT environment to the network management environment and finally we would like to kindly ask you if you are interested in this work and if so trying to document it in an ID so this is a very early stage of the work so this is all from my side we are happy to hear from you anything you want to ask Matson being so very on time unless I'm mistaken I have not seen people raising him to comments I have a one question but would like to give the float orders first if not I understood from from what you say about this idea greater that somehow it will be a kind of this contextual I mean the patterns that you described or that it will be a bit like bottom-up I mean it will be like organic I mean you will be observing what's going up from the network in terms of telemetry and out of that try to build a more aggregated model of all patterns this is correct understanding the idea if I understood you correctly in your system that all the sources that you have available you can register once you know it and then this model can sent to the application needed by your system this information for example you have these three data sources and information that they can provide to you is these information this information and this information so by doing this the application can select which is the information that really needs for working properly okay thanks for the explanation I've seen also that in that other have been several comments and exchanged on different aspects we will try to capture that also in the minutes of the meeting and also from from your last point about the interest from the research group and relating the newest comments yes please documented given for I will prefer that a model instead of an information model and data models provide API is a new a data model versus I am so I think at least personally not as the chair and I think from what I saw on the chat lady there are some interest today to move further with this proposal and it will be nice to get a bit more I would say much of yours to read from you I think it could really benefit to order items we have in the research group either the the Ramon I related or even maybe or what the pillow just mentioned which needs for ontologies and semantic aspects of data think this could be benefiting a discussion in the research so yes you will only be reading more from your on this topic okay thank you it all your eraser now can you came in now it's okay no in fact what I just wanted to point that see the CIA model can be a good way to let's say implement the ontology that I was mentioning before I was a few years ago I'm working with CIA man it is quite complete complete for this task so we can collaborate in these two topics together to put them together in the same place let's say the relation between the AI application and the CI M model for the for this information retrieval today okay yes let's let's talk in the future please okay okay thanks for the presentation do also to time constraints we like the line now and switch to the next presentation so I think the next one is millet and let me just switch to the right you want to be able to present it's not possible that I present myself it's possible but sometimes just for anything smoothly the transition is better if we slide but if you have this we can the other thing is like you know I sent the latest version last night and I sent you the latest version right now possible it's not that much different what if I that would be that would be great but if it's not possible that's totally fine yeah I apologize maybe just for the sake of time because we're already running at its level of course is not so critical it will be better if we can handle it is the current version sure you have you have the control you can click to go to the next slide hi everyone I'm malade I'm from University of Waterloo and I present falter in service functions unique it's a joint work between me and my colleagues a lot other poor professor birack long prophesied images other folks around Catawba so in this presentation I will talk about fault our search function training and the idea is that how can keep a service function chain running after f-number of its service functions failure and I will talk about how we can integrate FCC fault armed chaining with an asset to provide the fault tolerance for industry here's the outline of my presentation functions or middleboxes our network function that received the traffic processor traffic and forward the traffic here are two examples for example on left side you see network address translators and they act as a bridge between privates Network and public network for example in in this figure Alice and Bob are citing the privates network they send a traffic and they use private IP addresses and then that translates these private IP addresses to public IP addresses that are accessible in in the internet and change the header of the packet that it receives from Alice and Bob to public IP addresses and send a packet to the internet indeterminant receives the packets back it can replace the header into private addresses answer to correct address on right side there's another example firewall that receives packets and filter them based on some rules for example it receives blue and red packets and based on the rules it only allows blue packets to pass service functions a fail and they're failing it could be damaging 43% of high severity incidents in data centers networks are due to failure of middle boxes even major players like Google and Amazon also has have suffers from the failure of middle boxes the to combat this issue there are fall turns approaches and the main idea behind alternate approaches is that we only need to replicate the state of that particular service function for example in this example to make and to make not fall turns we only we need to replicate its connection state it uses this connection state to remember who is talking to whom for example in here it's the not remembers that Alice is talking to Apple Bob is talking to Bing and based on these connection estates it can translates the packets like an forth between private IP addresses and public IP addresses so to make that fault-tolerant we have a replica and naturally that exactly replicates that connection state so that if the original NAT fails and if you lose the original last connection state we still have a replica of that and the only thing that we need to do is redirect the traffic through the secondary not but actually the devil is in details and there are [Music] main work that describe how we can achieve these replication and they mainly focus on single middleboxes single for service functions and they are a snapshot based system but it's not should I mean that they frequently take the snapshot of the service phone service function state and replicate it into some a separate replicas so that if the primary fails we have the replica a snapshot of this that in some other place in the network our work is to make a service function chain fault horns and we - this of our knowledge we're first to address this problem but why do we why is that different from from making individual middleboxes individual service functions for turns it turns out if we use existing system existing snapshot based system for a chain of service function the throughput drop is massive on left so you see that if we have a change of 5 meter box there's five service functions we almost lose half of their true put because of the snapshots the reason that we lose that much of a true put is that then one of service function is taking a snapshot it has to bus its operation but by pausing its operation then touch and stall and with longer chains we have more passed time and knows more no service time and that's why we have a lot of throughput overhead approach is different we don't do a snapshot based and we make the entire chain fall turned the key here the key difference is that we lose the chain itself to make a service function chain faltered but how do we do that I'm not going to go to in the interest of time - all the details about our system but I will talk about two aspects of our system as they piggybacking and in chain replication if you don't mind I first talked about in China application and then I come back to state to get back in so as I as I mentioned before in existing approach to to provide all turns for a service function what we need is that we replicate the state of service function in some separate replicas across the network we wait for their acknowledgment and then at that time we can release any packet that has modified the state but in our system we use the chain itself to make the chain alternate we observe that already traffic goes through the chain from service function one search function to 2003 for example so why not we use the next the subsequent service functions in the chain as the replica for the for example first service function in this example for example we can use sales function - as a replica of service function one let me combine when we combine into a replication with state piggybacking but it's a backing I mean that existing approach each we observe two traffic streams coming out of each service function one is that they are data traffic the normal traffic that we process and the other traffic is stream is to disseminate is to disseminate the state updates to wrap the cost for a state ratification in our approach instead of doing that whatever state has been changed to processing a packet we piggyback that onto the packet itself and there's only one traffic a stream going to coming out of a service function combining a state piggybacking and engine replication gives us a system that can achieve high performance so let's let's see let's see in more detail our system work so let's say that we want to provide fall turns for two service functions as f1 and s f2 and they're running in separate servers to tolerate one failure we instantiate three replicas r1 r2 and r3 and they are they're located in separate servers in order to isolate their failures so that if one of them fail its failure is independent of the others it doesn't cause the failure in other replicas in the in here as a state of first service function is replicated by r1 and r2 and the state of the second service function is replicated by r2 and r3 also intercepts packets and they provide state management API for service function so that they can trace and they can track whatever it is that has been changed by the service function so that they can replicate it and send it to them through next replica as I mentioned before whatever state has been changed by processing a packet or system piggyback that onto the packet so for example in here when the first packet comes to our system the first replica send it to the service first service function and tracks whatever state has been changed to the processing guide packet and when the service module releases the packet the first replica piggyback state changes due to processing that packet onto that packet and releases the packet to the next replica on the chain now part two receives that packet replicates the state detaches the piggyback let's say send it to the service function track whatever state could be changed by in processing that packet and when service function to sends the packet out it receives the packet piggyback state changes into the packet and sorry to the third replica an archer even which receives the packet it replicates this thing piggyback the state street that the piggyback is States from the packet and then finally release the original packet to the outside wall while doing so basically we achieve high performance and here is one of the results that we achieved by running our system we compared our system with non fault Ireland a service with non faltering service function chain which is basically the baseline the highest performance that we can achieve and we compare it with their state of art FTM B you see two labels for FDM B Afghan people and if they only plus a snapshot can ignore FTM B everything B plus a snapshot is actually the actual system and as you can see for a chain link are four different chain lengths we achieve almost twice as the state of the state of the art and for the chain length of five we achieved 3.5 times higher throughput believe that FTC could provide a good platform for fault tolerance of service functions and service function chains and combined with NS edge we believe that we can provide a great platforms that is supported by because nsh are which is a protocol designed by IETF is already supported by industry and we think that while combining an aesthetic with FDC we can provide a great platform for fault and service functions let's delve into the details of an SH so network service header or NSA has been defined in RFC eight three zero zero sorry to enjoy I think we are approaching to the end of your presentation time and we're all a bit late so if you have slides that you can maybe accelerate a bit the poem this will be nice so we have and a message has three main component service function for warrior service function which is as before and in a such packets service section for order can implement a replica and the task lady does is basically I cannot okay that's working so SFF can replicate can implement or a replica currently NIH supports packet forwarding to chain but our contribution and our ongoing work is extending an SH for extending a service function for order to provide also state management API understates replication and we add the support of a message into click modular rather we also working on supporting and as such using any such header to a piggyback estate and I searched header so here we see the a message header and there are lots of fields here but the only thing that I want to focus here is variable length context header which is the variable which allows us to carry which allows us to carry metadata inside service function chain and we can use that to piggyback estate I passed this one interest of time currently in a search provides packet encapsulation and variable link from the data but our contribution is we define how we can use an assessment data to us to piggyback a state and because they're these information are sensitive information about the network we also need to devise our secure approaches that maintains the confidentiality of the data thank you very much and that was money our presentation thanks minute for to the point any comments from people Juwan yes Thank You millet for your presentation I know we have already had some talk but can you give me because I think it's very interesting the idea of piggybacking of the states but what what is a because you want to put in some a Indiana sage what we can expect in terms of size that we need here to piggyback States I mean for certain service if you have some example in mind so in our system we work we implemented that for not usually one packet and may cause adding some information to connection state which is around 40 bytes so load balance are also stateful load balancer they are around the same size around like you know 40 to 60 bytes so lots of lots of middle boxes lots of service function we expect that one packet shouldn't go beyond a few dozen bytes and we think that an asset should be enough and such a that should be enough to carry this native one but that's the the question that you ask is very interesting because for longer chains when we have more service function and when we want to support higher failure so for example let's say that you want to stop port 5 failures so we need to pack it needs to carry the state of 6 middle boxes 6 service functions for those cases could be challenging because it could go pro to myself there is a problem there is a limitation there that we cannot go beyond some some number of failures or beyond some size of service option chain actually okay thank you thanks Adam I also raise a question on the chat so maybe just for the sake of time not need to to process it now but maybe offline by email whatever we can discuss further about this I think it's not also work you plan to produce propose to what SF's a working group yeah that would be our intention yeah okay okay so we will hear from you I think probably thanks Mila sorry for being a bit I mean abroad because we are a tough presentation and we like to take time to go through all of them but of course we can continue to discuss offline on the mailing list for them direct unions Thanks thank you very much let me just check what you have next on the agenda we are switching a bit more to what the intern base networking aspect of the research group activities and the next one will be here Louis for the transport slides into the slide can you hear me well okay I'm sure in your slides please let me know when they are okay I can see them now okay could you enter the presentation mode because some of them are animated but basically one of them just to to be sure that the animation okay thank you yeah here we send the intent we have a starting to augment it in a you can see they're referenced between telefónica and wings and this has been initiated in the framework of one of these European poets if I give and so we will provide it a listen the following slides next slide please so the background for this work is basically we started to explore these ideas of hidden based mechanisms but applied to the nebulous Lyceum concept it was already presented in the presentation that I refer there in the slides in the Singapore meeting at that time the world was basically focused on the Asian and is the instantiation and placement of different billionaires some des facilities and so even though this PNM's are finally connected there was not an emphasis on the transpolar slice in itself that there is some initiative in in the teens were working group now what we are people working in a design team which is actually focus on on that forest icing we try to so mean these ideas of being carried out in the final project used specifically on a transport part how we could apply basically these for equestrian Estancia teen transport slices okay regarding this initiative in entities working group there are actually currently two outcomes one transporters lies definition draft and another described in the framework for these times realizing if we look at the first page and a transpose lies definition is measuring their respected by the triangle potential transpose less controller would be a way in the novel in the face I mean a way of expressing the need of connectivity in a technology agnostic way basically we would not require a data stage in a northbound part recognize any kind of complete configuration so we could expect there a more declarative and interactive way of requesting the slices request just put in the last sentence in the paragraph so the request to instantiate the transporter slice it is represented with some indicators such as service level objectives so no technologies are selected and later on the technologies will be selected and managed accordingly once this is more or less a process okay looking at this we thought that the team-based approach could be for the provision of this transport level slices so as far as we could provide appropriate level of abstraction we could manage manage those requests with these indicts based mechanisms this is basically we are sprouting in this draft next slide please so the for first polling that we look at the case of the fib services which are basically the ones that will firstly require require from the network potatoes the capability of instance 18 and were slices in the 3gpp or the three VP defines a way of instantiating and requesting these slices into n in the figure basically it is expected to have a VP be management system that could manage control seated in the corner girl part but also instruct the transport management system to instance Ketsana slices and to connect the different slice parts that slice instances that could be deployed end to end basically here we are focusing on the yellow boxes the network management system will be the one receiving they come the request or deploy in the transport slice in the underlying support interest ability the optics IPO we be here basically trying to address the interface between this EP management system and the transport network management system or an interface I mean how to apply the internet-based mechanisms on this relationship between both management system nexus right please looking at the concept definitions drafting in an emerging basically internal is defined as a high-level declarative goal to define outcomes and high level of pressure goals related to the to the 3gpp to the FIVB transom even just may basically they are defining a generic Islamist and plate in order to allow users of the network in this case vertical customers who specify different kind of attributes in order to deploy this slice into an and for those attributes you can consider things like for instance the speed of the healthy terminals or the location or whatever pad also there are also other attributes that are related to the transport part deserts like the bandwidth lady latency and so on so far basically what we were looking at is that probably this generic is lice template could be a very good foundation for these transparent lice intense in the sense that there would be a way of expressing attributes that the customer complete could fill out in order to request them the properties of this lies to be accomplished in the transport part next slide please then looking at the internal life cycle that is been defined in this concept definition draft on energy for the intent based systems basically we see that it could be applicability of this unique a slice template concept please in the slide because this is a limited just to okay we first we do foresee that at this point there would be some processing of the Jenica sliced and plated listen in the transport concerns in such a way that when the customer requests when the customer the practical user a feel and request the transport slice and there will be a process by the intake my intent based system in order to understand and to process the information of this slice template and then apply them to the configuration of the network so we will help somehow to processes here so they the processing and understanding of the day and slice template attributes come from the general be concise template and another process it's very fun instructing the dead-ball in this way the transporter slice controller once these parameters has been processed and if if let's say the request has been completely characterized we could to manage the attributes like the ones in the genetic a slice template and the thesis based okay this other stage we could respect okay to interact with the transparent ice controller through the northbound interface and here we reference another work that where we are trying to identify parameters that could be part of this northbound interface in the transporter slice controller the transport is less intense so it is clear we need a well-defined context aware that it used to be a bit up on Tori roadies for okay so with this context aware attribute that would be an unambiguous wave of in the the transporter slice through this in turn dragon and mechanisms and this will be basically a combination of a structure set of attributes that somehow could be communicated be an intent bassist an underlying system the 3gpp in the amplified II but could be others examples of the use cases with user input attributes that in such a way that we can complete all the intent pays for the transport slice and in the end the integrated system could check the validity of the request and so relation approaches what we are investigating now basically the benefit of the natural language processing techniques so we are considering that this boss was all done in the initial work in the we will refer to the novel /ascent when we think that this not running much processing techniques could enable making the voice the say of an even this high-level expression of requirements will be missed and probably in an indian help us for once the attributes in the registers template offer from the upper system because we will consider the sport of artificial intelligence and machine learning mechanisms in order to support let's say that translation mechanisms and to make this learning process once we start running transfers devices in the system so this is intended work to be developed in the framework of this draft so go into the very last slide I think react ok as nesic steps so we will keep working on this basically with these ideas of the natural language processing and so we will continue working on analyzing the attributes that are coming from the generic sliced time listen coming from the industry and also on other these cases that could be the interconnection of any be environments or network sharing situations or evolution of wholesale services and so we want to keep this work aligned with the progress in these neighbors like in design team and basically to complement the work being done there here we would like to basically request comments from on the audience from the group from the village group and input for new versions we are in the process of preparing a new version will be a new version for Madrid meeting but probably before even before whether they were based on other questions and just to reflect the fact that gift Angela as your innocence quarrel we are open from contributions and we expect that this could have interest for the for the research group and that's all from my side thank you you thanks Lewis let me just check that because I just I just have one question if I may I'm just wondering in terms of your attributes at the intent for the transport a slice layer do you envisage that the attributes would be delay jitter etc or would the attribute be more high-level decorative in terms of who needs this kind of slice for example is it EMB B is it slice for EMB B is it slice for some of the specific types for 3gpp service types thank you there could be probably a combination of both of them so there would be something that could be more or less straightforward translated to transport requirements like throughput which basically can be translated to bandwidth or latency and so and there will be other attributes that are not directly are integrally impacting the transport network for instance mobility reliability is maybe he could make the the transport network to create some protecting paths in order to accomplish given reliability even if the nice template declares the need of deployment service in a given location so indirectly you can infer the capabilities in that area that the geographical areas hope so there could be probably a mix of of them or both of them in one of the words that I prefer there they is MPI is trying to digest how these attributes could be impact directly or indirectly in the transport part so there is a parallel ongoing work on on this direction so I invite you to check and document it Thanks so you envisage that it would be more like space cific requirements not high-level requirements av saying give me the slice for this application and then that the transport layer understands the requirements in terms of bandwidth and delay and jitter from higher level abstraction starting point is to genetics wise template from GSMA on the nest the equivalent in 3gpp we have like throughput we don't need to infer so much on that because if there's lies need to support 100g so we need to provide 100g generic and I'm required to be in the example I mentioned before about the reliability so if 99.99 percent of a service availability then probably I need to instantiate different parts in the transport part in order to guarantee such level of availability or a mix of them kora starting point let me remark this is the general concise template from that going a higher level like mbb or you ll see and so on is not never we need something else to I mean do you need some kind of attributes and we'll always start in ponies the GST and we are working from that sure if I Mabel to fully address your question if not we can talk offline Thanks ok you see that every question so just as a clarification the the intent in the work that's going on right now is that the transport network doesn't understand the actual application that are applying applying for us transport slice so the intent would not include any information about exactly what this slice is used for it's just information about how what what the characterizations are attributes as we'd says that are to be communicated to the transport system yes that's the point yeah so I don't know if Eric was ok for you but since we're also running a bit late with respect to the initial agenda I would like to close the discussion now it's you another draft that we have for the group there are interesting points to be further develop and some interaction as we have seen with other members of the group so I hope that this will continue on the meaning list or M before the next virtual or in-person meetings and so will having more time to investigate some of those points further and I would like to switch to an explantation okay thank you it's for the presentation and the input to the blue thank you our next presentation will be Navi on automated design of network services from network service requirements and so as we are running late if you can be quite to the point this will be appreciated let me just bring up the slides hi yes sir okay sorry thank you I'm not saying yes here it is okay hello everyone my name is Nabi then like presentation today is on the project automated design of services funded for service requirements this project is a recent project Concordia University in Montreal and it is in the collaboration with Ericsson and it's supervised by dr. fair attendant dr. Mario tutorial from Ericsson next slide please so when outside a quick background during the motivation of the goal of the project an overall picture for method and after that talking about the modeling framework that we have and then discussing the the method steps and prototype children we are designed developed and finally fiction next slide please so as a quick background so network service is an interconnection of network functions that provide the composite functionality as a general concept network function is the functional block in the network define functionality external interfaces so as I hope you all are familiar in a few system or network function virtualization there's more functions are there for services came to be anything system and one of the main management management locks consisting is anything management orchestration of manner requires a deployment template for an effort service in order to deploy in emphasis to the elephant system and that template was called little service descriptor which describes that of observers from all virtualization prospect mix like this so NEC generation corners that design the desired network sales begin and the design process is the process of selecting proper natural functions and arranging them together to achieve the compass of functionality behavior this is a lovely school board anything and it is done manually by experts today the issue that is anestis on processes knowledge of many different tenants might want different types of network services for different domains and that's really knowledge excessively design and many other NSE generation is also there because of mainly details and in general doesn't fit until it comes into touch vision so automation of Aniston is the design is desired mistimed desirable annexed isn't fixed so the goal of our project is to devise a method for automatic network service design that fulfills the tenants intents that are high level or low level those are the things for basically we therefore service requirements we call them industry generated so the main goal is to generate and then actually design the Ennis is to generate the innocence according to the ED sees any from standards to be used by anything at all for illustration illustration and part because of the direction of its leverage their models and excellence so the overall picture of our metal starts from the tenant go by those details and the output though is the NSD at standard innocent but there is a huge gap in its because the intense of high-level innocence so we feel this yet with our method so we take the intents or the inner straight from the tenants and the method technologies which he called little function ontology it has the knowledge of function of the composition is an architectural information for lift or sales design samples our industry information and then based on that new Civic from kettle and then we generate for autographs according to those knowledge and then finally the jury is loose that's going to use by anything that'll mix like things so as I said our approaches model-driven so we have a Model T framework and the basis of the start on this picture every little function from two different aspects one is functional and the other is like a picture I found functional perspective a network function is a functionality always functional and from an architectural perspective from a more concrete point of view that functionality can be realized by more concrete and more concrete elements like an architectural block and for instance an architecture what defines the interfaces and the protocols used to realize that function and our assumption is based on our definition their real implementation out there Millicent pianets the virtual network functions are physical functions are equal innovations according to those architectural so keeping that exist in mind I start from introducing in astral model I start from an example let's consider the tenant requires the vaults and syllabus with voice for our registration functionalities and 6 megabits per second throughput for small and 50 registrations persons and the constraint is using finest occupation so the baby model is shown in this picture you can see the vaulting decomposed to most part the registration and you can see the non-functional requirements attached to this it's little bit personal the treatment end of the crystals and the architectural constant so that's the baby model and if you go to the looks like I can show the overall picture of the little model so here is an overview of the industry as a model in history metal model consists of functional requirements architectures and non-functional as you can see functional requirements can be composed a little functional units and other blocks attached to each function is small which we use a UML and profiling methodology so next up is that the ontology the knowledge base that you capture knowledge into the ontology structure is quite similar to the model but it consists of more details in the world information so the first model consists of functionalities and decomposition to architectural blocks and there are different decompositions and easy compositions they became captures from standards and different research papers or any knowledge of an expert and in which this ontology and here at the bottom you can see a picture of area an instance of this ontology so you can see a volte with its complete decomposition to a lower-level functionalities like messaging worst reputation registration usually for short and on the left side you can see what the picture or the ILS system and you can see the relation and how those functionalities can be realized wait is iris blocks and that's how to capture the knowledge of functional decomposition in general facilities here quickly I discuss the vnf neutral method functions information models as well so the energies are standardized by Etsy and they provide they provide on the metal model for those information elements including the universe which in some other party but those are all virtualization for right information from the aspect of virtualization perspective so what for in its design in the application perspective information so you can propose an extension to this unit information and nearly 40 picture this group of architecture descriptor provenza see the information about the functionality of components functionalities and vnf application into a person's and we assume that this unit is all this unit architecture this is also provided from the vendor so the capture all these information and in the catalog so I talked about those three main information areas that we use as our inputs and here that's how we process them so the first step we generate a solution model initialize assumption on mobile it's an intermediary model that captures all the information throughout us new generation costs in step two we have to begin with we have the information from the industry into the solution so instead to the map to the ontology and eat reverse ontology to capture the subtrees under function also that architectural side that matches those into those requirements and he captured them into our solution map in this third step we take those captured architectural blocks and we go look to our nyan F catalog and we select the proper nearest matching those architectural works and we bring them and put in your solution organization then after that now we have all the information that means from the ontology but you need to separate alternative alternative solutions because you can see that we have multiple levels and layers of the compositions so in three sub steps this different layers alternative service first we look at the function of the composition and we generate a functional form are the worst those are sequences of functionalities that each of them all of its functionalities together can compose a dual functionality that is desired for delivering service so after the opposite from each of the regenerate architectural elements which is a sequence of architecture what's that no one's of those functional and we the same token you generate premia 50 which is basically Vienna for London graphs but without with 40 elements like muchas leads then the detail flows so premium atrophy is basically a combination of the combination of units that can all together compose the designer for sales as I said each per unit that she is a potential solution so for each pre-university regenerate regenerate that for service descriptive because it has founded in of stats can compose the little sadist and I call it January because they are just introspective functional of the working picture just composition of what the picture boards not the networking part and not the visual so in this part in this that the design of the children's he designed the series expose descriptors and we generate Vienna for garden graph these filters as we had a step to also ensure ontology if the NSD generation was successful so far so we take information coming from the industry and try to English on yes so this is the final step of our leopard snow in this step you take the non-functional requirements into account if you remember in my example ratio that cheated or m/s it was kind of requirement so but first we designed the flows because of the fields according to the tenants requirements whether he or she has required Christopher specifically on some functionality so according to the design different floors packing flows and he used dependencies between the mutual meeting the others and using the internal phase of units which does the foundation has been captured so for design flows and then you take using non-functional requirements that he propagated throughout his floors to anticipate them are supposed to be exposed on each field therefore we are able to dimension html5 that's meeting that load so by considering that and deployment fingers on each the dimensional appearance and circles and that's the endpoint of our method so at this point we have his on instance people each are anticipated to load for the leaves and the evaluation tailored service to speak next ladies so we have developed the prototype tool has a roof of council and as I mentioned used at last transformation language and use you know profile and he's the person to generate and the use case that we had previously was since our pictures it makes like the conclusion so so far we have proposed and it's to automatically design that four sentences based on the food service requirements for the infants for benefit services that tenants hope by decomposing those intense using a lot of toys and then select a suitable units from the catalog really and then designer for writing drafts and based on that design generated as if you're sure right now you're working on renovating your method further in several cases studies specifically the 3gpp mission critical system and also another parallel won't be able to nan in Baku but it's been done by a little person is we the same concept but designing Network slices that's an idea for slash design which is the same principle features so thank you very much listen we're happy to answer your questions thanks about maybe that to be very on the point concerning time I see that chin has a question on the chat you may raise it locally if you like please how the inner part in temperature the scripture is different from yes so well in Vienna is a neutral Network function network service is a composition of via notes so first this VN of architecture district there is a descriptor for that year but the NSD is a descriptor for the network sales which is a higher level or composites element other than that also lien of architecture descriptor is our extension or it consists of information regarding application aspect of that mean you know course two descriptors each Etsy provides those are just neutralization aspect elements meaning they just provide information we don't know what's the structure of this let's say vnf has visualized element for instance whether its components is how do you figure to get in how they are connected together to visual is over there external connection pools but they don't talk about their functionalities they don't talk about their for instance 8 yards each regarding the functionalities so this be an important picture descriptive captures those architectural aspect information opposed to the descriptors okay yeah also is to make a comment yes just a question we're getting the easier you in your approach when you work is there a way to have requirements that have some dependency in a way that I mean not all requirement must need to be fulfilled at the same time it can be combination of requirement and some exception or let's say yeah alternative requirements is there a way to do 25 such kind of things or not that you mean for instance I'm just clarifying myself for understanding the question so you mean the requirements you have have multiple different types of requirements and I captured them all together or how these resolved yeah some requirements that alternative like you imagine yes some logic between requirements like are usually we comments I just kind of condition that only to be fulfilled but some kind of may have more complex requirement for services so the requirements that we get we matched to the ontology and from the normals and travels every time each one of those who access requirement in certain extant ontology because we rely on so any requirement that is in contradiction to the ontology for instance let's say there is a composition or there is a dependency that wasn't of it is providing a totally unique knick-knack requirement that is still intelligent because we assumed that and might not provide us with SUNY compatible requirements so we stick to be ontology basically resolve those requirements by taking from the knowledge from the entity that's information yeah it's good thank you thank you so we download for the question we will move to the next presentation Thanks maybe what is interesting work and I think we will get in touch for for the next steps thank you okay can you hear me let me just bring up the slide okay flourish oh sorry I didn't say anything anybody see the slider yes I can't hear yes yes okay hello everyone my name is Angela from China Telecom next let me introduce the draft of intent classification the Nexus left please excuse me I do there was some delay but now it's a slight tool okay the goal of this draft is to paren clarity to what an intent represents for different state colors by means of classification of various their missions such as solutions users and the intent hence this classification would ensure a common understanding across all participates and it can be used to identify the scope and the priorities of individual projects fuses research or open source of projects this is achieved proposing initial classification tables and as a mythology used for generating zone this mythology can be used to update the table space adding or removing different solutions users or incentives in order to cater for futures and Orioles applications or domains this drafted together with drop to era TF and MRG ibn concepts definitions and to aims to become the dolphin Dacian for future intent related topic discussions where all participants have the same common understanding next please since the update of the crafter variant 2 in November 2019 we have received the support of experts and suggestions for improvements to the draft the following is a summary of all the comments we received offline and online and address the corresponding solutions one by one let the comment expressed by a gherkin that alignment with the draft the Colombians and amarjot it's the intent we addressed that by updating the draft and the referring in the introduction time and explaining what the scope of the each draft the wrong and Laurent commented that the value of the document and the tables not clearly explained as well Randy salami Isaiah committed that intended obstruction should be formal therefore we address the by updating the introduction section and the discussions on the mailing list as well as explaining in the introduction the purpose of this draft and that is not planning to be a formal definition of intent here al-khatib said under ministers that it is not clear what is a difference between intent and the policy in your draft and we addressed by updating the introduction and the referencing drafted that describes the differences between service policy and intent as well we updated the section four and the subsections of five four points three four five and six by making them intent and in those policy focused similarly we also have received some suggestions such as your ROM and the law rental suggested that or draft shoe the presenter intent on methodology and they were adopted by ending a new subsection 5.1 and a 5.2 rule also otherwise that it would be better if we could have some concrete examples of intents from different perspectives in response to the subject to this suggestion we have added examples to the tables in Section 5.1 a five point three point one four point four point one and a fair point fair point one natalia bob committed that it is unclear what is the scope of the poll as a continuum section in the straddle draft thus we held remove the deception in the draft in summary we updated the draft two variants ray as follows in section one the updated introduction to clarify the scope of the draft in Section four we updated the section 4 to make it more in 10 and up not polished forecast and the instruction file will add in the intent classification mass dollar tree and the examples for the intent tabs and the in sexes in section 6 will removed as a policy continuum section okay next is less please for ease of viewing the place marker in red as a major changes of this draft it can be seen that in section 4 we have made many changes compared to the previous version such as adding new subsections about in turn telescope and the internist network scope and modifying the content of the original subsections about intend obstruction and the lab cycle and the adjusting the logical relationships between each subsections next I will detail the the updated the updated content of each part next the place in section 5 where I did the intended classification Mestalla G as shown on the right the proposed master G can be used to create new intended classifications from scratch by analyzing the solution knowledge as well to update existing classification tables by adding or removing different solutions users or intent tabs in order to cater for future scenarios applications or domains first Eclair we first her classifier in turns into it in tabs and the describe each tab based on the solution is a blast tool and the word intern user it is a form with them present different categories that this intent can belong to based on intense scope network scope into the obstruction and the life cycle is about mythology the old arrows means the following you put the improve represent the solution knowledge or comparison of knowledge about solution requirements target use cases available technologies and networks actors intent requirements and the rx UX arrows mean reviewing the existing classification and they use add remove the internal solution user tabs until tabs and a surfer okay max it please this should we have either added an Internet examples for our intern tabs in all the tables in section 5.2 3.1 and the four point one and this 5.1 the picture otherwise in snippet the snippet from high-resolution table instruction five point three point one for example for a network operator with the intent AB is network our service intent the operating the operations that may be desired is request to network service with delay guarantee for access custom a ok next slide please section for the update is this section to make it a more intent and an odd policy focused when newly added for four point three and a four point four four subsections and updated a four point five and a four plus six subsections even subsection 4.3 redefined is the scope of the intent the intent are used to manager the behavior of the network's they are applied to and all intents are applied within a specific scope such as connectivity security application and ACK us and the in Subsection four point four regardless on the intended user type their internal request is affecting the network or network components which are responsible representing the intent pockets thus it and blood work scope can represented we haves or PDFs physical network elements compressed networks as d1 networks and the cloud edge clock or branch and so on the next slide please we updated our Phi upon me by renamed as interned obstruction to focus on characteristics of faith Bank of intent and the Internet can be classified by whether it is necessary to fit back her techno technical networker information or non technical information to the intended proponent after the intent is executed as well it an abstraction covers the level of technical details in the tank in turn itself and we also updated 4.6 internal F circle renamed the live internal app cycle to classify in turn into transiency transcending and persistent if it was the internal transient it has no lifecycle management as soon as the specific specify the operation is successfully carried out the intent is finished and they can no longer affect as a target object in turn a is persistent it has left cycle management once the intent is successfully and activated and deployed the system will keep all relevant and intense active until they are deactivated or removed the next slide please we have updated in the introduction to better explain the need of intent a classification and acknowledged contracts for different different additional concepts and terminology lab is currently leading these efforts by defining it and at higher level the corrupt declarative positive that operates at the level of network and a services it provides however even this propose the internal concepts and terminology and agreement on corner internal characteristics and instantly still be billed in different ways by different stakeholders for different use cases and the solutions thus the goal of this draft is to bring clarity to what an incentive represents for different stakeholders by means of classification of various dimensions the classification would ensure a common understanding across all participates and it can be used to identify the scope and the priorities of individual projects theosis research or open source projects this drafted together must climb aims to become the foundation for future in turn related topic discussions where all participants have the same common understanding ok the nexus lab please concluded the corporate vision has addressed Oklahoma's received online and offline and furthermore we want to ask for adoption as a research group practice especially the next step of this craft the summary is a following of work plans first add a section briefly describing intent works that has related to intended classification and tax a tax on autonomy in other a skills such as the 3gpp and ETS a and mes victims the drops are aligned with the trapped air ta mr.kia beyond concepts definitions what's more work with the community to derive unify the intent definition that encompasses all internet apps for all solutions and the intent users as last improves or drop to folder based on any new comments or introductions to this draft update that's all thank you for listening you know we will check on the chat there are comments or questions on the presentation okay maybe as I was speaking as a chair regarding your your last night so first of all thank you for you very hard work to improve the document and insert different question regarding the process one of the suggestion I would like to give to you may be its first to publish the release version as as the version feels individual draft I think that will be the first step and then before ring for asking for the adaption my advice will be first to go for a very short round of comments regarding this version free on the mainland leagues like two weeks but we could are from people living comment on the previous version to see if they are satisfied with how you address a comment and that after this check if everything is fine maybe there could be we can we last for adoption officially fuzzy fuzzy document that will be my advice the char two to be sure that before you as reduction which would be somehow enter into let's say official process the commands you received from previews from people who have previously made this comment our okay with and the manner you modify the document but of course do not forget to first published version fee of the document I know you sentence a mailing list but please upload on the data tracker that is is fully shared and into Z into the document of will that be okay with you and I just give a comment Tara like I think thank you very much for your suggestion also but I just wanted to say in regards to comments to engage the comment authors I think just reminds that we went through the extensive phase of emails and powerpoints with all the comments and asking the comment orders for the for the conclusions and and for their feedbacks in regards to how we wanted to address the comments just wanted to remind you about that meant probably I would say a month of exchanges and discussions but I do believe it is better to do it with the Version three so thank you very much we will repeat the process but I just want to remind that we tried to do that already and we had powerpoints with all the comments and asked for people to reply but we didn't get replies from everybody okay I understand your point so as in a world of culture if you publish it as version free we will also push a bit of the mailing list said that people including me as a personal as well replied to the to the new document oh yeah address the comments to give you the feedback in a relative short period of time like as I said two or three weeks maximum although to support this for because I think it's good you made a lot of very concrete modification to the document but yeah for me it's if you go in this way is better than before you go into the process of adoption and then you have to wait and maybe a bit more it will be to be sure that at issue more chance to have a document then I'll be the first in the group you just just kind of for for the sake of checking that the way you address the document is aligned with the document you receive Zara Zara has no misunderstanding but of course as chair we can push rivets on the mailing list to receive comments and as well that okay any further comments concerning the next set what is that what we could also because we already had the first call for adoption in December for this to happen after that they have been together in the sea different so maybe we could clarify by the least the discussion today what we have seen in the slide presented today our recommendation as chairs for publication of d03 to be the new baseline ask for comments for a period of two weeks and the conclusion of this period to be able to restart a new call for adoption if you can clarify this my email I think it wouldn't make a good point on them in English with respect to the previous column yes agreed for the presentation no it's already quite a table for our participants in Asia and so we will move on I think that slide is it should be burnwell for an update on the service assurance for in turn based architecture just breath all right so in this 15 minutes I want to present two draft that have been presented to the absolute value G but as you were mentioning lo-har the beginning they're highly relevant to you anymore G so the two draft are mentioned they're the things that I want to mention first is that we believe we address mostly feedback received in NMR G last time verbally or many verbally and uh during the research group session and also the feedback received from the AuSable ug the second thing is that you would see from the list of authors we've been working with many operators and I see Paulo and Diego on the list here so much feedback address there so next slide please the the issue were having is that yes we've got yang yes we could configure networks but the fact is that we all know it we've got like a service configure but it doesn't mean that it's operating correctly there could be many issues there now we're telling okay we're giving to send telemetry but we see it coming we've got like way too much telemetry this is the issue of the needle in the haystack right now whatever service degrades the the the thing is any knock wants to discover world fault yes and by this I mean there are easy ones like okay there is the Witco interfaces down for example great we know it almost directly but whenever we've got like symptoms it's get like most difficult lives a and B and sometimes C then we have the symptoms you know what's happening the other issue would ring to solve is that okay now I've got like a component that fails that's an optic or ferrous or degrades now which services are impacted is also key to understand we have to understand as well the first step is like close to perturbation this is what we trying to solve here the next slide please however we know that the end goal which is like intend based not working it's like a pyramid of needs right you're able to do configuration and you've got operation later I wish telemetry then you close the loop then one of you close the loops you could potentially go to self star two in ten base right and this is what we're trying to do trying to decompose this from bottom at and twenty decomposes into smaller components what we call is sip service then we've got an assurance graph that is going to link those services and we're going to have we're going to map it to service in tens I'm going to show you how we'll do it then the idea would be to assure all these sub services independently I mean it's a fact that we all collect like the interface counters but okay so what you have a nice graph it would be way better to understand if the interface behaves correctly then we would have like a health score for the interface health now because you've got this runs graph we could bubble up the infirmed score of the service and I want to stress inferred right because this this architecture complements the end-to-end active probing right we're going to get like the the real packet loss and then delay and and and jitter and all this so whatever you've got those two solution understand it we start to have a good architecture next slide please so if I take it's very simple the simplest service you could have like a tunnel like a tunnel instance if we look at the dependency three the assurance graph we want to have returners to be healthy we want to have on the left-hand side the two interfaces Pier one being healthy as well as the pure to being a destination and those two have rely on the house of a physical interface right and and then that you've relied on the house device you know it would be ways year if you would have like a device and the ability to say this device is healthy so if you look for a problem this is not where the problem is on the right side the Turner service instance also depends on the IP connectivity between A to B or p1 p2 that also depends on on a control plane in this case is is so we've got to search the top and the SIP services the sub service instances are at the bottom right next think you went one too far oh yeah that's one yes so then what you could be doing there as as I mentioned if we know it interface is like unhealthy an optic is bad is degraded right we have a the house of that interface so that uptake sorry and then we could just say well obviously because you got the eshton's graph the specific Turner service instance is affected so I could infer the health of a tunnel source instance by looking at the health of the components into three the assurance graph and on the next slide I want you sure that there are two different types of dependencies right obviously if I got like an interface being down that's obvious that my tunnel will be down certainly call an impacting dependency right this is the root cause we know it and on the next slide we've got like typically an informational dependency meaning I've got this dinner service when it goes over for ecmp pause right one of them is down is my serious impacted yes or no maybe yes maybe no right but the point is that I want to be aware of that symptom and this is what we mentioned by informal informational dependency here because that's some some combined with a different symptoms let's say I see a package a packet distribution change in interface and I see an e CMP issue for example because there is like a bad load balancing we might find a correlation between those two events all right on the next slide trying to summarize what we've seen so far when a service degrade we could discover what a fault is whether it is a symptom or root cause but most of the time the most interesting ones are the symptoms because the root cause are easy and then we know so that whenever a component fails it was mentioning the object then we know which service instances are impacted all right next please I want to show here that - so nice something here it's like in architecture sorry and we try to do it for multi-vendor it has to be because they are not many networks in the world that are only a single vendor and we did it with the yang module it was somehow my my feedback to one of the previous draft that was yang we could use we could generate api's and this architecture is flexible in terms of components I will show you that in terms of service and sub services so we could be adding new sub services as we see them right if someone needs multicast we could add a multicast service an expander shion's graph it's also flexible and open in terms of distributed graphs because we see it coming different controllers could have part of the graphs or even like in routers you could have particle rafts and to refer to one of the previous presentation it works for physical and virtual so next please so architecture so we get the intent from the service configuration Orchestrator we get like the service ID the service config and then we extract the intent of that service we create the assurance graph that goes into some sane agent and then we collect the require metric where telemetry and we send the house core and the symptoms of all of those sub services along with this assurance graph and then we have all information we need to potentially close the loop and the value of this is that it's all model-based so the config and telemetry so we're comparing apples to apples the next slides I want to show that basically it's flexible in terms of components we could have like the same agent and in router it switches and we could have like the orchestrator and the scene or castrator both into a single box the point in next slide is that what we want to do is this open architecture monitor so you want to specify the interfaces so this is where we've got the arrows with yang and they want to be open so there are there was a young module however in the next slides what we don't want to do is we don't want to sort eyes an Orchestrator or an agent basically this software right it would be like forcing a specification of an implementation it's way better to have like the api's all right now next slide please if I look at the young models here very quickly right I want to go to details of yang but we have a model dependency relationship by telling impacting informational on the next slide we have also a model the health score and the symptoms percept service in the next slides we've been adding a maintenance window typically I mean if you're upgrading or a device or if you're replacing this bad optic or if you doing erotic rotting colic adjustment you don't want to receive any symptoms from that specific sub service so you could just disable receiving symptoms there all right in the next slides the additions is that we've been adding like a yang module for the assurance we'll interface and somehow it shows like if you're assuring a device you've got the device ID as a parameter if you are sharing Sunanda shirring interface you're assuring you need to parameters the device ID interface ID and we showed how we could extend this even with some vendor specific sub services right in my first slide for example if I got like a Nokia one way or juniper device there should be the one having the device health all right and I think we'll be happy lahar my next slide is the last one something that needs to be improved this is I need to align the the draft better with the the MRG concept and definition feedback I've been asking is like is this a valid problem to solve at the ITF and now we're going in the right direction and then I asked that question to the observable ug it was for adoption however the feedback of this group is that it's I would like to get the feedback to make sure that all the concept definition are - going the right discussion according to what discussing the research so thank you Thank You Benoa I think on the chat we have at least Luis reading in you may need to unmute we cannot hear you yes yeah my question is for Renoir is doing and also to work in the meditation of this sub services or it's just do you plan just to stay on the model that's a very good question and I believe the answer is yes and no yes because there are some of them that should be solid eyes I'm thinking you know as I mentioned we all monitoring like the interface counters and whether whatever router vendor you have trying to get like the Houseman interface should be should be under standard this is not what the value is right the value is higher in the inner in the stack so some of them yes protocols I was mentioning I Esiason purpose right or segment rotting or spring what if we would be thinking directly about the assurance whenever we're developing a protocol I could envision having a couple of service assurance yang model like interface like for some protocol we've got the knowledge in the ITF and and as I said this is not where the value is for for all the vendors we have Alex it's not this is Alex I have a quick question because looking at you're looking at your trivial and your gang module you'll mean that you expect to maintain all the dependencies as configured information one question that I would have regarding the practicality of this because presumably you're going to have a lot of in the dependencies between a lot of objects so do you have any comments on that how these relationships a lot of dependencies a lot of which maybe may be highly dynamic and yeah and so forth that that's right I mean you you you are fully right so this would be a complex graph so we could set different levels you could just say say at what was configured as you know getting like the house of the IP connectivity that was mentioning in arms like whatever just trying to get that and potentially trying to see where it goes it goes from A to Z going from BCD etc or ecmp ecmp is dynamic right poor definition right I mean if we could just solve the EMP issue it would be great so yes there is a lot of dynamics ax T in there we we've been experimenting with code and this is what we're focusing on and yes it will be a huge graph it could be as huge as you want work setting this also in the virtual world abnormal dependencies there flawless in the line thanks Benno can you go back to the architecture picture might 11 yep you is it the one you want to see yeah so I think the one of the interesting question to me is you know to run through some example of workflows right I think that's that's that's you know some some amount of work that would be good understand what could be gotten out of this so for example the way I kind of imagine how this this ultimately works is that I have you know different levels of abstraction right what what comes from the service configuration orchestrators you know more high-level and then when it goes further down then then I've got some some lower level like let's say existing yang based configuration of individual Network elements and the way I see it what what what would be lovely is to have a way of attaching one level to the other through references so that you know when I look at configuration of a router I'll be able to see which of the you know services are you know requiring a particular configuration or vice versa when I basically want to do some inventory management or something like that that at the service level I can see you know what network components or you know configurations are there so that that mutual referencing you know I'm not seeing this expressed but that would ultimately I guess be something that you know the orchestrator might might need to do what's what's your thought on this right so you're right in a sense right so basically we take a service model on top of registrate ER then we configure something device there are two different choices either it's a CLI or this yang Yang then we have a starter solution because you already have the yang models that we have that we need for config and then based on that we could try to find a mapping and it's easier if you start from yang models it's number two is that you start from CLI and then it is it's harder to do and I agree with you with the lower level and that may be your so to answer Alex is that okay there thing that we know from the config of the service there are that we know from the network right I mention examples is is your service model will not configure eyes is the IGP is there by default right so as a consequence need to learn it from the network and there are extra things that we won't want to have like I mentioned multicast right we we might want to see a specific service use multicast or not and there we might need to have the operator input to constrict the first graph because we could graph the first time we got a new service type make sense yeah I mean the whole concept of let's say we have two different levels right so it seems like you know just let's let's take just I mean ultimately I think there will be multiple levels right but that's just the fact in the most simple case we have two levels let's say the service level and then the per device level configuration forget about the CLI stuff agreed makes it more difficult so device config is also yang but purely you know the abstraction models by which I can say oh okay here I'm looking now at the device level configuration but attached to each I don't know level or something else in the yang device level configuration are pointers pointing back to the services that are requiring this so that I'm basically this edge version I said but we've got in slide 7 right where we just say we've got the top of the assurance graph is the service ID that comes from the orchestrator and this is the top of this tree comes from the service and this is the link that you that you need right so okay right so I mean this was was very fast and I think this one yeah the tuner service I instance there it comes from your castrator and you this is something you configure like an LTV penalty P and with an ID with a customer who's a tenant whatever and then for that specific instance you've got the entire tree there so you would say that you know one of the overheads might be if I want to be able on a router to kind of see the service dependencies then the router ultimately would capture the whole free even if you know he isn't didn't mention that I mentioned distributed the router would know about part of his serve services the device house interface health telemetry house whatever but not the entire tree however because it's yang you could just have a leaf ref right and just and okay so let's a give cough line I guess large is what you want right and all of these are existing yang structural elements or as any of this requires you know structural enhancements to yang thank you thanks people for all the nice interactions so I think we can keep adding I mean interaction missus document I know it's progressed more in ability but I think again links to to the activity on again the research group and has been no mention with flashlights expect further reviews and feedback on Fitness of the concept that he's considering and I think any review and feedback are always valuable so I would like to maintain this specific active and possible and we see how it goes for the next uh next time so next in the agenda will be a very quick updates I apologize to everyone for the sport agenda we have to make too much stuff well really much overtime we will try to go very quick on the last technical presentation and give save a few minutes to give some research group updates to the people that ken has still be connected at this time so the next presentation will be on the 14 concept and definition draft let me grab the slide this should be very quick of me so I will present as a cohort dates so this draft is the dinner so this is a person one of wrought iron chef and energy I'd be any concept and definitions very recent history so this document was adopted as we serve to document in December last year we made some changes in run essentially completed each other video of the document we have also revised and aligned definitions for in terms after the document which is basis actually on the introduction mailing list and with the draft on intern classification which triggered some let us know about some inconsistency in the definition so this was a good catch we have also reworked and improved refined text for the sections five imprinted some of the principles were so big slightly worked we swapped section 6 section 7 so now the new section 6 is functionality and section 7 is a life cycle this allows us to explain a bit before going into the details of the diagram a bit more in a higher level the main functionality and the composition of the infant life cycle from a textual point of view description point of view and then we have in section new section 7 the life cycle diagram and some quick explanation of the diagram in this life cycle section initially we had two diagrams two kind of competing diagram so we decided to keep that was comprehensive enough to cover all the different elements of the life cycle we thought were essential for the job we still have to consolidate a bit further and stealing from a bit on the description of this life cycle but now it's a bit more clear also for the external readers about this single life cycle diagram and I think one of the major update we made Martian Tier one was to add the complete new section on security considerations before that we knew wanted to address security consideration even if it's the kind of conceptual document but since IBM is a completely new topic but it addresses a new approach to how we do network management we felt necessary to think broad terms how the security consideration should approach for IBM so I invite you to have a look clearly in this section and give us some feedback or highlighting the main updates on version zero which was adopted to version one I'm not going into the details of the document structure everything because we don't have time first and also because all this was the stages we had in Singapore and in December this has not changed mainly some we architect clearing and improvement of the take up the next steps so we are working on the Russian 0 2 which should be available in time soon we will continue to improve the which say the text of the draft we still have a few principles that we wanted to add there were to-do list so we will provide input for that we will also work in the concept and definition draft slightly improve all sort of sectional acronym stands and definitions to have proper entries into this section of the document with respect to the concept and definitions define throughout the text as I said complication of the lifecycle diagram we will also collect any feedback on if this is complete and angry enough to proceed and we have some training comments and reviews that we received some months ago and more recently that we need to integrate in the different sections of the talking so this is pretty straight forward in terms of evolution knowing that this document we believe is pretty stable it's not finished but we don't expect that merger reactivating of the structure of the document so according to the research group milestones there is a target to send his dog the corresponding documents not necessarily only this one - IRS G review by November 2020 so this is still in our plan but it will depend how we move on with the next version and the comments we may receive for that but in our perspective as a group of co-authors we think it's becoming more and more stable and it would be nice to reach these targets by the end of the year that's it for the quick update on this document any comments it's not ok thanks so we are not going to continue with the chair slides and conclude this meeting with some updates on the research group so to broach quickly as ever more so don't hesitate add things on my flow the general information we had our new charter approved end of March so this is still quite recent so congratulations and thanks to everyone that participated in providing inputs comments and support or the revised Charter the inputs in terms of technical content review etc and also to our ITF chair for bringing this forward we initiated type a long time ago but I think it was really useful for bringing a very nice research agenda for for the non glance the research group and now we have a long list of a very interesting and ambitious items to investigate well I just copy paste a quick snapshot of a milestone you can find on the data tracker it's not usual for wishes group milestones but we believe that some of our work items deserve it and it will help us also to try to put energy and a bit of pace in our in our research there because I think the industry is expecting also some some answers what could move towards also ITN and other groups we have also initiated a few months ago the a bit up organization for energy so you can find the links here we invite you to join as contributors and we will plan to host repositories for of course research group documents but we can also offer repositories for individual documents if you want to get there also for the code we have a few implementation and be an ID and proof of concept that we are going to port there and also we are looking forward we are looking in how we can use also get a maybe as a rendering engine for kind of website the different resources hosted by energy so that it is a bit more easier access and data tracker for people that are bit less connected to the IETF processes gyro maybe you can take the floor for this one yeah sure so here is an update of the activities regarding artificial intelligence that we started in the group so things of first the major thing is this research challenges document so this is something we we talked a bit in particle in the in Singapore where we wanted to document in order to actually have detailed description of the different challenges of artificial intelligence applied to network management use case I'm not sure we have time to go through the document itself law or maybe I should just summarize that what do you think we still have a bit of time okay so maybe you can open it I will display quickly the document I think we should try also to be concise okay so just to okay so nobody have the document so that you'll appear with the idea that right because I know that we know that a lot of people were willing to contribute we are submitting and son but we need a little bit to have some structure to 12c Dickey Matt written so we started to write drafting from a table of content that we present hint in previous virtual meeting so the idea is this document of course the core part of the documented big challenge is ready to in network management we have identified some of them during some sign meetings in previous IETF we also be doing some real chair meetings so here in the basically in the in the if you go bit below Aloha is you have the you have those a talk and the table of content that is ok a bit expanded so that to two main sections so challenges as well as the goals of a network management has ones are the two main sections that we would like to work at this time and of course maybe on the section and research challenges for each section we provide some kind of a guidelines a question to answer to our people to know what type of contents you are expecting here yeah as long I like idea for challenges and so for the different challenge we have identified but of course you can add some challenges that you have in mind you should try to write the text in a way that you answer the different questions and of course shall identify yourself and interest contribute to this document here is a draft example I've worked on lightwei I for network management of course base you have different sections so and all school it needs to be documented with reference and so on to have already something quite concrete and of course an attempt to free font files are that are other challenges we have we have in mind based on the discussion where the previous meetings so basically if people are willing to contribute this document of course we'd share again the mailing list please clearly have a look on this table look as judge challenger interesting into participating identify yourself as a contributor here in the document he in the beginning of the clinic on and the table and also propose some contact so you have detailed instructions at the beginning of the document so you will have some kind of clear restriction to be honest we we have a use case section it's the document but we do not we request at that time content for this section because we know from previous experience that if you go directly into use case it would be it would be completely on let's say separate use cases without really some kind of some kind of or to say um some kind of commonalities between use cases so here's the goal you'll really tomorrow look into the challenges of course in the goals section you can provide all those some kind of overview of use case but not detail use case at that time which will come later in order to have a moth entities view on the challenges it's really work yeah on purpose that we did that and so yeah that's really key is a document document document version and if you go back to the slide please so no but I think it may be some some kind of delay but so then it just only on the other part of the stages so area with just a summary of the process as I said before if you are willing to contribute just yeah you identify yourself in the document also give feedback if you disagree with what you proposed in terms of table of contents of course it's not fixed future it may evolve I think one good one description we have also usually is what what is what is a publication target for such a document for some discussion we should say that it should appear kind of the draft in the group in order to have some repeat visibility but at some point it's my kind of a white paper so it should be it should be it should be yes publishes white paper or Journal magazine but it will be long term long term goals but as many people says that it's interesting to participate to such an initiative but we will need visibilities will be good to have this document chest as a draft as well so here's a proposition regarding yes the type of half way to to collaborate you start with Google Docs it just to facilitate this the starting of the collaboration does that mean that you will continue with Google Docs personally phew if we want to use the github that Aloha mentioned previously is that yeah yes we will probably use it but to be as most possible as open at the beginning we will start with Google Docs but it's not does not mean that it should be the final final version the final type of tools that we will use so here we are really willing for contributors and feedback on the process and the document content that we would like to have so if you have yeah and if it by just tell us now or in mailing this because I know we have a bit short of time now maybe I just just presented the full slide and then you can somebody asked question can just raise the hand regarding a hi we have in my episode forgot that is more regular that's a series of talk regarding regarding this topic in order to have more technical talk as it was suggested to us as well so this is really something which is in the panimalai step it should not be actually we we do not especially see that as only enemy activities but we would like something more global with other group and community is that a different at a different place but in order to have some kind of frequent like every month or every two months to have this kind of a series but is very preliminary as as I said we have also in mind this ái challenges that we I mean technical challenges our competition so II we just we just mentioned to exist in one not an animagus specific so one is proposed by ITU and noting that registration is open so if you want to participate to the challenge as a participant you can follow this link also one which is a proposed not only by but partially by by the Polytechnic Polytechnic University of Catalonia about what neural network so it was supposed to to be open soon but you know with the situation it's not clear when it will be open and and don't think we don't have all been here regarding an emoji as far as I know all the unfortunately all the project a bit but stop now but of course it's still open if an emoji would like to propose a technical challenges I mean participant of an emoji so it's still open but as far as I know there is no project that is continuing for this last data so here is a summary of the slide so if you have any common question do not hesitate I suggest we move on yep sure is more a just on the Internet orky workman of subgroup so as you can see this is the table of my two students we have corresponding to what you have in the Charter I try to map everything in terms of work items with respect to basic milestones when the adopted and the rlg review the dates and with the stages just wanted to highlight okay it's in red but it's not critical okay we are not a working group there is no pgp periods or whatever it's just I like a bit of a critical situation in terms of where we stand with respect to our initial goals for these three three items the other ones are a bit more on track so just focusing on the first one the first Brigade and we had was documented problem statement design goals and challenges for in ten days of working we initially a discrete first work items together as a batch we wanted to which research group adoption by the end of last year unfortunately we have no corresponding documents currently on this specific work I tell the initial goal was to describe the problem and solution space identified the limits of current technologies and methods and variety associated research challenges needs to be a very long document but at least I believe gentleman I we believe that this is of utmost importance that this work happens in the research group becomes help us to define clearly what we are trying to solve we already engage in two other documents but I think this this aspects of the proto statement goals are important I see Alex in the queue but let me just finish with the slide and I take as possible next steps this is just open proposal we mainly find them of course to come up quickly with a new document to address specifically this point or to move parts or all this work item to existing documents for instance draft IBM concept and definition or we can at least you last resort drop this or Qaeda which I don't encourage us to do where we try to find ultimately Alex you want to comment on this yes yeah I was just wondering so basically we saw you say I'm wondering busy is there somebody working on this right now or is it just there's really no no no document and racing we were waiting for someone to create a new one there is no I was in developments that have been proposed to watch the energy I mean personally as an individual I'm working on that for Nokia so we have a draft not a draft but a draft document not yet ready to be sure so we if we could contribute that to energy we we have to find the right window to do that and yes it would be nice from a research group perspective to have something coming in as new documents or based on something else this would be appreciated okay thank you can collaborate amis that needs to be a one one person or one organization document of course this is completely a collaborative by the for sure yeah I think if there's a need and I think there's a lot of people who are very motivated to work on stuff here we should take it up so I hadn't really been aware so so thanks for something we can share so on the on the mailing list or point-to-point with the people at I'm at least raise the call for for contributions to the meaningless and see if we have a group of person interested to move forward with this one I don't believe it's so complex so difficult it's just that we are this in our work item and big milestones so if we can achieve that it would be better for to be consistent with what we have defined in the chart he thinks okay the second one is still in the workmen cohort then there's networking but it's addressing a different part which i think is the most important one we should work on in the research group so this is about so called architecture so the goal was to determine the elementary functional blocks of an IBM system their interactions input and outputs and propose different techniques applicable for the different functions we are planning to have something as an early result of adoption for July this year currently we we had previously some individual document that were addressing this architecture discussion that are expired now there have been a few meetings where we have have technical proposal towards architecture discussion but currently we don't have active documents and new proposal for that so I believe it's a very central piece of the Ibn workman will be able to come with this common architectural framework especially in continuation with what we saw currently with the intent classification and the concept and definition possible next steps again to come quickly with new documents or activate expired documents to really risk in this activity and I think really not I think beyond this starting the restarting of this activity we should really increase considerably the level of activity and research group on this item this is a big piece of work we don't go into formal specification or at least this reference model will be very useful in order to have different pieces of the solutions to come together we have seen that friends but know with each party ops now other works also in ops that are of interest in any model also some calls in the past I think there are many groups and expectation and if we can contribute with something that apps to reach this common architecture of view it will be very hard the next one so next one is item five this one is more on so-called use cases or validation scenarios it's a bit the same situation we wanted to go to what having some phenomenal results and documents end of plaster this was okay we we had this but we don't have the corresponding document we have a some proof-of-concept demonstration and in October last year but from it's important from a validation point of view and so potential next steps to come again with documents like use case documents experimental or implementation description that could show how to complete application of our ITN concepts in real settings also improve the links with implementation and proof of concept this is the item six in the work plan so as I say we have some proof of concept demos and two that are being the block but we need to have the corresponding description of those of those experiments to be able to progress on on our work plan and again the level of activity in that space which will also increase Louis you had comments notice on this one of the previous one my comment is that I wonder if the trans internet a business that could be considered as use case for this I think that from my point of view yes would like to know what is your perspective could you hear me yes sir really say it a bit difficult for me to hear you the last sentence please I was basically considering that probably that the transfer is nice he could be a dues case for it for this just to know your opinion on that yeah this is a very good point because when I was reviewing a bit the content for this meeting I thought that the work that you are proposing with the transport slice intent and also the think you proposed before that actually could be really related to that we can have use case around transport slice or a kind of leasing network provider plus particle interactions for for intense instantiation this could be a way of to see a kind of experiments or use case is concrete boundaries to that and I know also that you're also on this number five also working on corresponding I mean testbed and proof of concept so I believe if you have willingness to contribute this could be a good starting point yes for sure and and also we could live with a activities working group I think that we could have a very nice story on this okay the position finally work then we also had in mind who we are this Akutan project we wanted to contribute with more practical aspect of IDL what we are going to do is to consult with the different in more teams that we managed to contact that we know have claims in that space interact with them to define a proper scope and objectives of what we would like to achieve with such kind of academic project whole overall planning when we we can be ready respected objective and aligned with the research with myself we initially had in mind to a target participation in the next IITs meeting in July in Madrid there are still some uncertainty from the meeting point of view if it will be in person and what will be the ability of people to travel or participate on the site or remotely so this is very open and then shunt and so we have to reassess the practicality of targeting something concrete from July doesn't mean that we will not work but we have to understand it it will be a bit more different theme different setting you have to see what will be what will make more sense and also for the future maybe more at the end of the year so we will communicate towards the research group with this framework but we would like to know for sure so that everyone can be aware and express interest and willingness to contribute and of course if you have any willingness to support and help us in this we're really welcoming your name and brain last point in the technical update for the research group we have referred for research activity which is more towards the self-driving self management frameworks so our idea so this is just to host a forum of discussion see a bit what's going on and insurance for the developments of internal management and operations what we observe a bit was that we could organize a kind of dedicated session based on what we have seen recently inputs coming from different groups especially the ops area working group or we have seen this we see a framework for self management or work from automating service a network management framework so this assurance void in architecture that was presented at this meeting by Renoir so there are already knobs several works that are touching architecture close with automation policy based management automation all of correlated items that I've been progress by different organization different groups of person in animal working group they also this reference model an ACP that finally will be able to move forward so this can be also a way to reconnect with some architectural work that was a pro should be anima they may be also other working this is not exhaustive they have been also a more recently some duplication of specification architectures in order s do such as it sees an SM Eni we can also invite them to participate and of course start to see also from other will say research or even less research e academic and industry initiative on network management architecture so try to bring together these different initiatives and proposal and see commonalities trends that are emerging and make people discuss together we could have this for the next IETF on the way it may be the one after if it's more relevant in terms of organization dedicated in virtual meetings we have to we already open to do the best option and you know recommend in your opinion on that okay so you just because we already quite over time finally just a very quick view on the future meetings so next week we should have had a in-person intermitting in Budapest for the ultra polynomials conference but the nomes conference will be fully virtual this year so we decided to cancel the special session on energy because the idea was more to meet people and gather with the different communities but nonce is maintained it will be a virtual compound so we can still register and attend it's very good program that will be next week all the keynotes all the technical speeches we had also planned special session dedicated meeting with the IPOP conference in Tokyo but again this conference has been moved to September this year so we currently have to cancel our kind of that and September was not a good slot to an energy participation due to absence of the chairs so we decided to conserve our position for the moment we desiccate possibility makes your game we are making in July Madrid which is currently maintained given there are plans to consider face to face of virtual meetings but we have there if you make some targets in terms of I Catherine and Sarah we shall put my stone so this will be an important time of the year for us make for the future meetings here is that we want to say until further notice the default mode of operation will increasingly rely on meetings you have you done that for few times now so it's we are quite used to it we want to use more the meaning list what cross our technical session and also reliance on collaborative platform that you have seen pointment with the document at Jerome I liked it for these Google Docs if it's accessible for people or for from the drafts and activities and of course not educate to share your question ideas or needs with the entire group or the chairs and we know that maybe it's difficult for some of us to be organized since we are not meeting face-to-face for Alex you wanted to erase something before so you've withdrawn but maybe you still won't sure I just want to mention that this is misleading right noms cancel it's the meeting that has been canceled so noms is virtual exactly yes the I truthfully numbers conference will not be an in-person conference it will be maintained virtually it's next week a lot of tourists radio but the energy participation to knows this cancer dates your own you don't know if you want to add something nothing else I think you say everything readings updates my decide I would like to find a lot all the participants was challenging 12 very long meaty especially because we are very diverse dynamism so thank you for all the ones that had to stay up very late or taken very early it's always a challenge from our perspective to find the right slot but thank you for your very good technical presentation very good interactions also for the chat I hope we will get very good minutes and able to continue actually I've seen a lot of you good very good technical discussion that are a lot of potential progress and again contribution driven as we say so please continue working like this thank you very much analyze whatever part of the day you have left thank thank you very much no thank you bye bye by kids | IETF - Internet Engineering Task Force | UC8dtK9njBLdFnBahHFp0eZQ | 2020-05-11 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 24,281 | 134,054 |
AxwCna03HXA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxwCna03HXA | WILL I BUY IT ? SEPHORA JUST ARRIVED | Karen Harris Makeup | [Music] hey guys welcome back to my channel today I'm filming a video that I haven't quite done one like this but basically my camera battery needed to charge and I was scrolling through YouTube and I found a video by LS and she basically was doing like a lil I buy it but she was going through what was new at Sephora and she said hey this isn't like a recommendation video this is just me telling you about whether I'm gonna buy some new things on sephora.com or not and I was kind of inspired because the Sephora sale is on right now and there is another weekend coming up for VIP members and so I thought it would be kind of fun to do the same thing I am gonna throw in recommendations because some of the products on here I have tried and I want to let you guys know if they're worth the money or not especially with the sale if you want to pick some of these things up I would totally recommend and my like pets are here's did you hear any random meows or grunts or barks it's because one of the dogs or one of the cats decided to speak up as well anyway I'm not gonna keep blabbering Thank You Ella for the idea and I hope you guys enjoy this video I am NOT gonna do a recommendations video for this for sale and I don't know I just feel like there's not enough time anyway plus I have a really hard time committing to like being like oh I swear by this you need to buy it but there are a lot of products I do recommend I have a little highlight on my Instagram jewelry so you guys want to say that but I'm gonna pretty much talk about all of that stuff that's on there in this video so hopefully you guys will have a solid idea of everything after this video is done so let's get into it now I just went to the just arrives page on the app just like L did know I'm on the Sephora u.s. app she was on the Canadian app so of course we're gonna be talking about some different things so the first thing I see on here is the NARS orgasm infatuation palette now I really want to buy this mostly because of the packaging I already have the Tris palette here I bought this before the sale and I'm sure it'll come up in here but is gorgeous so I'm like dying to buy more of them but the reason I'm not buying this is because of the shades in here so it comes with the Laguna bronzer which is not really my shade I like to wear the casino bronzer the orgasm blush which I'm kind of over to be honest I used to love orgasm blush and I actually went through a whole orgasm blush but I don't want to repurchase it a highlighting blush and also the shade orgasm so these shades just don't appeal to me which is why I am not picking that particular palette up and the next thing on here is the Sephora collection Pro smoky jewels palette now I actually bought two of the three original palettes that they launched last year and they were okay but I couldn't justify keeping them for that price tag and so I actually ended up returning those palettes and so because I learned my lesson the first time I'm not actually picking up any of these Sephora collection palettes the dyson special edition supersonic gifts that this is the dyson hairdryer it is a very tempting because I like Dyson products we have a Dyson fan and a Dyson vacuum and those work really well but I don't think I could justify to my husband buying a $400 blow-dryer I have the one from the Drybar how that works fine I also try to let my hair air dry when I have opportunity so yeah I won't be buying that the finchy beauty by Rihanna diamond bomb all-over diamond veil highlighter I really want this highlighter but something is telling me no I don't think it's gonna work on my skin tone I saw my friend Nick me use it at this highlighter and it looks really pretty on her but I just feel like I'm gonna get it and be really disappointed so so far I haven't purchased it the Urban Decay Naked cherry I should have palette I am tempted to buy this just cuz I can get it for 20% off but I know as soon as I get it I'm gonna instantly regret having put the money towards it so I'm not gonna buy it and I'm okay with it I bought the naked heat palette I didn't think it was that great and I returned it I feel like the Urban Decay Naked palette I'm just that point right now in my life I've moved on to like pepper grass and stuff nothing wrong with the urban decay palettes I just bought so many palettes recently I don't need to just keep buying stuff for the sake of buying it the Urban Decay all nighter long-lasting makeup setting spray I actually bought the set last year and I still haven't even made a dent in one bottle so I don't need to replace anything I personally don't see this prolonging my makeup wear by any means so I would not recommend you purchasing it the Anastasia Beverly Hills sultry eye shadow palette this is limited edition and $45 now this is their holiday palette I believe and I actually did buy this when it launched on honest Ozzy's website and I actually ended up returning it because um the shades were just not my cup of tea I thought the shimmers were beautiful but I didn't think the matte pairings made a whole lot of sense to me Padma grad labs mothership sublime bronze temptation eyeshadow palette limited edition and $55 it's actually the action of palette I am wearing on my eyes today I have some videos that I filmed with this palette coming up so stay tuned but you guys these mini palettes are really nice I've only worn two of the three on my eyes so far and so far I've really really enjoyed so yeah if you guys want to pick it up on a sale now is the time to do that Kat Von D liner X I did see support ooh alive on this eyeliner personally I have a few other liquid liners I'm much more a fan of so I won't be buying this the support favorites holiday perfume sampler I actually got one of these as a gift last Christmas and I haven't even walked into Sephora and redeemed it I know a lot of people love to say it's like a really nice gift and I think it definitely is I just like for my experience I have not gone into Sephora to redeem it hopefully there's not an expiration on that coupon to claim a full-size because if there is I I'm probably gonna miss it okay the Too Faced peaches and dreams face it for $52 this comes with the peaches palette as well as the face palette and then one of those like oils lip oils I million and I would not recommend this I don't like the shades in the peach college I know some people really enjoy that particular Too Faced palette it's not my cup of tea by any means so I'm not interested in that so for our favorites so coach Tokyo I believe this is just the Japanese skincare favorites box and looks fun I haven't bought a Sephora favorite set in a long time I just don't like sample sizes of things like I get so many samples just from my Sephora orders that I I just don't want to buy anymore okay velvet matte lipstick pencil vault from Walt molt from NARS for a hundred and fifty dollars I don't like this formula enough to spend any money on it so I will be passing on that Sephora collection Pro essential brush set rose gold edition for a hundred and seventy five dollars honestly Sephora makes some amazing brushes they aren't cruelty free so I know a lot of people have issue with that so I just want to let you know about that but I think this would be an amazing brush set for anyone that wants to invest in some good brushes I have a few brushes from them and I really enjoy ok so Becca glow kitchen kit from Becca and Chrissy Teigen I passed fresh best rose buds I think this is a nice deal you get the fresh rose toner as well as the cream like the face moisturizer and I think that's awesome because you get to try both of these products I've used both of these in the past I'm trying to stay away from this rose toner because I didn't think it was that great I mean like I didn't didn't think it did anything magical on my face but I know it's like blew up because Jeffrey star talked about it like last year sometime and I've seen quite a few influences actually receive it in PR so I've seen a lot of people talk about it but it's not something I would recommend like you run out and get but if you're interested 6363 dollars is a good price for both of those products jamayne cosmetics rose gold collection set looks like there is a lip topper and some things I don't know I used to really be - joy but I'm not anymore so I'm not picking anything up from that astrology by.bite limited edition color for this month is out I'm not really into traditional lipsticks anymore so I don't need that one of the bloggers I follow talked about this Beauty bio blush glitter glow pearl facial region regeneration tool for $199 I wasn't really comprehending what it actually does and I not really heard a lot of people talk about this brand Beauty bio she seemed to really enjoy it she's got beautiful skin but I'm not buying this okay so I'm dry bar set I like that hair dryer like I said I did try that tool that looks like the brush what is something called brush crush heated straightening brush I tried it because I was so curious I think if you have fine hair it might work well for you but honestly it isn't a replacement for a straightener I feel like it's just extra work and I'm not really interested in that just a violet Voss the little mini eyeshadow palettes are now available on Sephora calm so you can pick them up for 20% off because you guys know I'm such a I shadow palette junkie but I swear nothing about these I should have palettes appeal to me so I'm just passing on the whole collection because I really don't need any of those eyeshadow palettes I'm saying for the libertine I should have palette by Vizier that's now available on sephora's website and I can pick it up with the sale but I don't want to Sela has a liquid eyeshadow vault all eyes on you for a hundred and ninety five dollars I was looking at it this morning and I was like that's got to be a joke because why would you ever want to spend a hundred and ninety five dollars on glitter and glows granted it's a great concept but I feel like if you have one or two that is more than enough don't feel like you need a bowl don't feel like you need to have like ten types of glitter to do an eye look I have four of them and I haven't used them in forever so it's just it's kind of one of those things where they capitalize on your love for our product and I don't think you should do it there is a Sunday Riley ultimate volt collection $385 huge fan of Sunday Riley but honestly you guys it's gonna be very few people that can use all of these skin products with the type of skin they have so keep that in mind even though it's a great deal doesn't mean that the Juno oil is gonna work on somebody that needs the Luna oil and like vice versa I mean I have all the oils that I use them you know at different times but I don't know I just I get that skin care sets are really good value but I also feel like it's kind of odd I feel like they try to bundle it and give you this good deal but sometimes and you end up buying products you don't necessarily need Sephora collection has a once upon a night blockbuster limited edition $49 it literally looks like a bug like I think Georgia Harris talked about that in one of our videos it's just like weird I should have palette I can see like somebody really new to makeup being really into something like that or if you're on a budget you're like oh my gosh look at all this product I can get fifty bucks but I don't know it's really not for me Charlotte Tilbury stars in your eyes I should have palette for $75 really not into that color scheme and I don't really think Charlotte Tilbury products are made for deeper skin tones so I'm passing on that I really really really really really want the ambient lighting edit volume four by hourglass but I'm not going to buy it because I have two of their previous pallets now if you've never tried it and you're curious to try it honestly I would say get it especially if you can get it for 20% off because it's a great deal and they make amazing powder products four of the fifoota obsession palettes I bought amethyst I bought Ruby I bought sapphire and I bought emerald I haven't really reviewed the palettes on my channel I've really talked about them in a review roundup video and I do like them I wouldn't say you need all of them I would just say get one or two of your favorite shades and if you like all the shades then get them all like I'm not you know the boss of you so the Natasha de Nonna gold eyeshadow palette honestly I never thought I would actually have anything good too about Natasha Donora but I actually really like that eyeshadow palette so I'm very excited that I have it and I think if you can get it on a sale even better huda beauty overachiever high coverage concealer I'm still trying to figure out how I feel about it I feel like I like it but then some days I'm like is this coverage like really that high coverage like sometimes I feel like it's fades faster than other days so I'm still like very undecided on my thoughts on that concealer Beauty Blender sweet indulgence said I picked this up a long long time ago but I haven't broken into it yet it's so weird I'm such a weirdo like I'm like holding on to it like I'm semi hoarding it for some reason cuz I'm like oh but like I don't know like maybe I should just you know wait before I use it like you know I don't want to waste it like I always think like waste I'm actually like looking around my room right now because they don't even know where I put it moving on uh herbivore rose water hydration hydration trio honestly I don't really like the bed every war I like the brand youth of the people a lot more than ever war in case any of you care I bought some of their products on their website when they had a sale and I just didn't think they were that great I'm Charlotte Tilbury met revolution lipstick everyone talks about the shade pillow top I wanted to buy one just so I could have one but honestly I know myself I'm never gonna use it so I'm gonna pass on it to face gingerbread spice I should have palette it's a good palette but some of the palettes I've already talked about in this video are so much better so I would honestly skip the Too Faced and go for a Natasha to Nona or a Pat McGrath to be very honest I really want to try the Charlotte Tilbury airbrush flawless finish setting powder for $45 but I have so many powders and so I'm like trying to tell myself like no girl you don't need it jumble on London cologne collection this is one hundred and fifteen dollars and you get five little sample sizes and I honestly have not met a Jo Malone perk alone that I am a huge fan of so I really can't imagine spending $115 on that there is a YSL rouge pur Couture slim matte lipstick I stopped coffee break with Danny talked about these and she said they're like amazing but then she kind of went on to say like how it's a square bullet well I guess it's not a bullet it's a square shaped and she said it's very hard to apply and I'm like why would anyone buy that bit so the NARS hot triste cheek palette for $59 this one Mel Thompson really sold it to me I didn't probably need it but I kind of wanted it after I saw her video and I'm actually wearing one of the shades on my cheeks today so yeah I don't know it's it's a nice palette but I don't know if the it's a baked Chalet so you need a specific kind of brush to like pick up the pigmentation you know um first all a skin to blur perfecting primer serum for $54 I bought I think they're unicorn drops and I didn't think they were that exciting so I won't be trying for Sally for a while and then there is the Becca shimmering skin perfector that the little macaroon set I am not really interested in any of those particular shades that they have put in that little kit for $40 so I'm gonna be passing on that as well okay guys so that was everything that is on the just arrived page at Sephora currently and I just thought this would be helpful I'm kind of like if we were walking through Sephora and picking makeup out just like Ella had said I basically just quoted her so I want to make sure I give her credit but I just thought it was a cool idea to just go through the just arrived page especially with the sales happening this weekend and next weekend so I hope you guys enjoyed this video thank you so much for watching if you want to see more go ahead and watch Ella's video and I will see you guys in the next one bye [Music] | Karen Harris | UCUfLdPjR9QjS4S8RQALfuEQ | 2018-10-31 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,261 | 16,545 |
Fu1NoCuZvSw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fu1NoCuZvSw | Negation — your turn 1 | Activity one well learning to say no is sometimes difficult even in one's own language so we really have to put in a few practice sessions in order to learn how to do it in German we start with the most obvious way to practice negation that is we give you a positive sentence and you have to put it into the negative so if you hear ish Warner in Berlin you simply have to state you on an IFFT in Berlin that's easy enough but remember that words like Heitor and Morgan and both direct and indirect objects squeezed in between the verb and the NICHD so we thought we'd spice this activity up by including a few of them I'm gonna schedule nisht let's start ish Warner in Berlin ivana NICHD in berlin Ashfield for spire ash build need for spell Ashby and Morgan for spire Ashe built Morgan niched foosball each father McMahon in father each violinist MIT meinem father it's hell for minam father a healthy minam fatten eat seek often Suba mark time she carved nicked em super Martin | Deutsch e-rklärt | UCYhPUokAQHYy7RTvHOiGaSA | 2020-01-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 184 | 979 |
pBULYNXnjAc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pBULYNXnjAc | Game Freak BANNED This Move... | they're scared they're scared they're running there's always there's always there's always a wind condition it's called internet explosion and they're playing for that yeah CU they know they're coed yeah this is what dozo players do right like they legit just play the timer then it's protect remember that yeah I remember that ductor it was a hard time to be me oh my God they dropped their defenses it didn't matter but it does even more now may any idea where their focus was it's probably on this thing but we still have walking wake in the back so if the doo drops it's probably clear look at that [Applause] yeah but he's not going he's off the channel he talked first he talked before me he's off the Channel all right let's do this hey everybody I was seeing like who would who would talk first who do I have to smack in the mouth anyway Hello everybody welcome back to the channel welcome to Dragon cheer the movie and by the movie I mean it's going to be a solid like 30 minutes we need to do another movie we need to do another movie dude the low kicks movie yeah they still talk about the low kicks movie they still they still talk about big sucker punch yeah dude 80 80 with that team scors sey you know other directors they think about the low kicks movie today we're using quit o woo um I chose that name 5 seconds ago this channel is partnered with gamer Subs if you want to support my work and get great tasting drinks you can order gamer Subs through my link in the description down below or with code Moxy boosted that checkout for 10% off Subs is a caffeinated product that I recommend only to my 18 plus viewers but my link will send you to their caffeine free product section just in case every product purchased through my link supports my channel financially so I'd really appreciate the support now back to the video we're using so this is supposed to be the walking wake showcase and despite that so if you click this looking for walking wake damage maybe you'll get something you'll get you'll get something if you came here looking for walking wake to click Dragon cheer you came to the right place we got dundo we got dundo literally only match this strategy is good in let's go dream match up drag energy everything let's just go for it let's just go for it I am so words I can't say on the video Yeah question which one of our dragons is clicking Dragon Che booster guy okay perfect yeah look look at the build on this Reggie Dro it looked like melting cheese chill it looked like melting cheese bro that EV spread looks like melting cheese we take we take specs modesty gleam 100% of the time Lee you're about to be dead po poor guy yeah he doesn't know what's coming I'm only scared if they lead reg Lecky because like anything but dondoo on preview is like okay they know what they're doing what if they hardly dondoo then perfect then we're could them then then the game is over see like now I'm scared cuz they let I think we protect Dragon cheer I we can protect do we take a draco from Tatu if they go for something weird like that on the W abely they'll just miss I think we just Dragon she protect this turn let the walking wake go down uh and then next turn we get in one guy and then we win we swe just lose with this oh my God are they self both switching out I hope so they're going to explode dude I'm happy with this no it's that's awesome oh no it is we're fast I wasn't sure we out at plus one cuz I I don't want walk away no no no something's not right here I saw that guy outspeed plus one Pokemon before yeah I I wasn't sure we outs SP I think that regi Al's explosion animation is the hardest of all cuz he slams the floor yeah he does we live that's a good thing no we needed Tailwind because they're and they're going to come in with um what you call it with the uh the flamigo the co are you like are you like we turn we still we still have a turn to do it we still get in the guy this turn and if you T you don't die yeah they're probably going to protect right yeah yeah okay so if if they're protect you cover by going tornadoes and torn and Draco not dra and if they stay in You cover by turning into a different type and Draco yeah do you think they always protect uh well this cover both right do I have to ter it if they order up do I die I don't think it matters you die if they order up you're a dragon T so you ter to not die but they can also earthquake is the issue because I can drop the earthquake no because you're plus one crit rate they have to hit you with the move that kills them no if no I'm not going to ter because if we if we ter we actually only have a 50% chance to crit I'm just going to go for no no no the dragon chair is already up it's not 100% oh God this no no because we turn into a seal type yeah but it does not decrease I tested it oh okay okay okay then I'll I'll tear then the only thing that matters is the type you are when the cheer happens so if you ter a steel before the cheer you don't get the full Boost but if you ter a steel after you've already been cheer you keep the full Boost that's Professor M with the knowledge he he went to a library bro he went to library bro where did you study they always protect Doo players are the most predictable players on the planet next to Earth and Luna play okay I'll agree with you on that but like we definitely only covered for one option one we only coverx Mar only covered for one but funny enough now we can tailwind and dragon energy and they both or what I'm a little concerned about the plus two for Migo what's the speed onig is it faster than our Dragon it's probably faster let me check the meigo speed set we might have gotten cooked but I have no idea we could Tailwind protect and then Bleak wind that's what I'm thinking listen if you put me in a box and told me to guess flamigo and regid dgo speed stats without looking it up I would stay in that box forever I wouldn't get out I'm going to Tailwind protect and then next turn we might be able to Bleak one drop or or maybe they just like wave crash into our uh tornado and we win Flamingo 90 you telling me this Flamingo is faster than our our Dragon yeah Flamingo is base 90 okay cool cool cool I think that one shots all right cool yeah no no no we're fine we're F follow me yeah we have follow follow me oh it's up it's up there you go that's how you went it's so up thank God they killed two of their own Pokemon cuz we didn't follow me they going to do so so much recoil to themselves with like if they Brave Bird yeah follow me dragon energy wait does that guy get wide guard wait no they would not click that here call this is insane there's a good chance that this is the only time this happens so keep watching to find out if we ever get another one of if we ever get this chance again oh they went for it they they just lost they hard they lost there's no way this thing they hard lose oh well they're stalling out the Tailwind oh we we just we have three turns left they think they're him but they're actually double triple protect I'm going to Vegas and betting it all on black if that's what happens they're stalling the inev nuk they're stalling the inevitable hey you want to see something that should be illegal to see otherwise we only attacked once this game and we won I swear to god dude I swear to god dude if this actually isn't plus two crit rate I'm going to I'm going to hit you in the mouth if you try to search this turn on Google Images it's blurred you have to turn on safe you have to turn off safe search cuz there scared they're scared they're running there's always there's always there's always a wi Condition it's called internet explosion and they're playing for that yeah cuz they know they're cooked this is what dozo players do right like they legit just play the timer then it's protect remember that yeah I remember that the D ductor it was a hard time to be me oh my God they dropped their defenses it didn't matter but it does even more now any idea where their focus was it's probably on this thing but we still have walking wake in the back so if the doo drops it's probably look at that y we did it it was all worth it in the end it was all worth it in the end we clicked one attack this game one attack the whole game and we just won dude we did the special beam Cannon we were like Goku hold him for like 5 10 minutes 5 10 minutes special beam Cannon tornado is just pickle low that's crazy yeah tornado like special beam Cannon oh yo oh we can cook this I'm so ready to click the move and then click tailwind and then click the move and then click the move we can cook this do we bring uh Wellspring or incin um I'm leaning towards Wellspring you see the why not bring the dark type into the scan team though because man the SI spam isn't real cuz here's here's what happens let's say they lead off let's say they in their Infinite Wisdom lead off with like Indi and tol what's stopping us from just clicking dragon chear and Draco the indeed iron Crown lead clicking helping hand expanding Force no we have we we we have terra steel and then Terra steel the next turn also just Dragon cheer protect Tail wins GG oh I forget we're speed boosting okay I'm actively hating I'm going to stop doing [Laughter] that oh this could be no I think instead of a tornado then maybe we have to get the um ogon in you just click it right you just click Dragon chear Dr uh dragon energy right like I'm going to Dragon Che here there's no way they after you they have to sleep something I think they sleep the walking way no no no no no they sleep the dro they s the Drago I'm going to protect her no they don't no why would they do that don't give them a chance don't give them don't give them a chance to Target one oh yeah yeah don't give them don't give them a chance to Target one they're trying to sleep both with this play but like yeah they are it's chill though cuz it's fast sleep so you have the first turn being burnt right now yeah yeah and and you still wall both is the cool part they have a chance honestly I think you hydro steam the too for when they miss SLE powder uh no I go for the lant cuz it's sash agree like toal is the one that's walled the most here yeah that's the one that's wall the most right yeah I'll just hro steam the lant it does a decent amount of damage and like it it doesn't they might bring down the sash oh yo they would drop insane if we wake up here go after the to if we wake up here that's insane they switch from fire type to fire type they're still walled so they're just relying on the Sleep powders here oh yeah yeah it's fine still K thog don't care they they kind of trolled going for close com if we wake this up it's just over come on ready it's over I mean it's a crit but like it's not doing that much the incin Will Survive the incin will Sur now we that didn't do anything huh no it's actually that might be a in that didn't do a lot even like with the crit that's got to be a I think 100% AV right like Reggie dgo is an animal cuz your base power isn't that low it's somewhere around like 80 right now um they have their own little walking we're Speed Booster bro we just double protect yeah just double protect and it's what they oh they're also Speed Booster yikes we have ta hey you know what we do here maybe we should no no CU that's going to that's going to get dropped fine protect we can well we can so we can attack with one no cuz we're going to get faked out I think they just fake out one and then go for the speed tie in the Wake so we just double protect you turn off fake outs but protecting on both mons and then you click two dragon moves into the walk we have to remember fell that we are two dragon types and they brought four Pokemon all get walled by dragon types can't hit us all right there's their ter tear it off if it's fair we can just fire that's fine I think we Draco into that slot and hydro steam the incense so you're telling me they brought three fire types to the Double Dragon lead yes they did that's a tough life to live I'm I'm telling you walking wake your swag too different your crits too strong they'll kill you walking wake Terra on Wake ter water then do that so you live and then kill them back with Draco Hy even better they've already ter C just drops the hydro steam yeah and I ter a water here in case they want to go for that and they win the speed tie also nothing switches in on hydro steam of the sun they Terra water but yeah um they got three fire types where are they going no but Atrix just a heads up you only get the crit boost on your partner oh we won oh they don't both get it yeah it's only I'm so glad we got Dragon cheer in the first game cuz we're like never going to get that anything no right here we're going to do it right now watch this CR Draco watch this CR Draco you know they went for the speed tie yeah they went and they lost hey hey check this one out killed you is crazy check this one out dude it's ins son it might be specs I feel like yeah okay life forb makes more sense all right goodbye Michael I hope this gives you really good inspiration for the thumbnail oh I mean yeah there shouldn't be like 900 Draco meteors in that cuz you can't we C it so many times oh my gosh uh what's they have left just the toal by itself swag click click I am I'm going to click rain dance literally literally like twl is doing that thing in like in like uh TV shows where like you know his girlfriend breaks up with him like he already got he lost his job and he goes well at least the day can't get any worse and then it starts raining wor it starts raining wow raincloud over yeah this is from Looney Tunes that's crazy poor little guy peace out little homie Sun zooo I've been reading a lot of him I've been reading a lot of The Art of War yeah what you do the first line in that book he told me to lead two dragon types into triple fire so son yeah I studied this match FYI that's exactly why we didn't build a sun walking wake team because they're kind of trash it okay but like dude this team let's be completely real what we're doing here is matchup fishing and we're 20 on great match also like look at the rest of the team the rest of the team's fine we're going double fake out balance and we're going to be punching our computers cuz it's going to be so hard to do anything it's dude they just hand these games they're just handing F okay they're handing these games to us Bro Look somebody's got to hate somebody's got to hate like we just keep getting all right what's our last I think our last is in s actually we can still make a case for well yeah maybe with have follow me yeah we just do the same even goo would have been fine here too no merro on lead good game no good game well played they play themselves are they Speed Booster I don't think that matters no cuz we go first so I think just protect and dragon cheer cuz then we can te steal the next turn yo Electro Furia electr Furia that's the hardest name in the game I kind of hope we go down here yeah again we are two dragon types I think they click the spread fairy move yeah yeah for sure which by the way we hopefully hopefully it kills wake say hopefully it kills wake man it doesn't even matter if it kills wake they didn't get a a booster energy so they're most likely specs which means if you Terra and Drago this next turn what are they that did no damage dra yeah we ter the dra we for the Draco flash you don't want to flash Canon the flut I'm going to ter blast the FL but we still Draco the this guy we clear flutter M Dragon th clap they're trolling an amazing turn cuz now it's on the next turn you go into your follow me Pokemon and then you protect on both to stall the fake out and then you have or uh Drake dragon energy there's no shot they protected here no if they're specs we would have dropped I think they're just it might be some like weird item like sash could be pixie plate that's a that's AV as hell pixie plate is more likely sash kind of fell off I'm hoping the pixie plate I don't want to have to deal with the sash here sash should be y throw a ball at him oh my goodness I sash sash uh I mean I feel like the game plan is still the same right I'm cover we just go into it yeah just getting your Tailwind now yeah I like that yeah Tailwind protect and then Bleak wind will pick up the flutter you can Tailwind protect and then switch to ogre PA I literally think that you should always have the follow me pressure next to um drgo on the next turn yeah because we just that you can't get Thunder clapped yeah fake out fake out fake out fake out fake out nerd don't call them a nerd they are nerd you're not paying attention to what you have fake out pressure that's a VGC law oh yo the oh oh get owned I'm sorry I'm on their team again hey you know what I think we still beat this I think we still just I think we just go hard ogre Pon here I say we click blein and Draco and leave them with their last two Pokemon now yeah let's blein Draco and then we get ogon in not damage we got a lot of bulk there's no way we drop to this double up uhoh no we got a lot of bulk I'm crazy I'm crazy with it look check this out it bounces off of oh my goodness uh you lose to raging bolt in G no we don't yeah yeah we just we just protect and then we switch in the yine and then we but so because they actually we always take the dazzling gleam after two turns of leftovers recovery so we do just go hard here cuz they're going to want a thunder CL they're going to Thunderbolt sweep I know my electr Furia CS who do not I know my raging bolt C I don't know my Electro Furia KS I'll be real yeah get over it grow up what language I'm older than you they should de here I think SpongeBob good enough oh they Cal Min it I can't wait to crit that guy okay so that does mean no Thunderbolt this actually is one aable gun yeah now now it's follow me CRM uh it's kind of a 50/50 though cuz if they protect and they Shadow wall or deam then you go down the next turn after well then we if they start protecting we're stoling out turns of trick we're getting leftovers how much Tailwind turns do we have left is another question cuz if our regie Drago starts to spe flutter that's good two turns left have two turns of trick room we one turn left to Tailwind I think we just follow me and go for the electr Furia yeah okay yes because then our uh Tailwind is down and then we can outspeed the FL have don't under speed all right no protection they go for thunder clap goggles is also how we lose they Thunder you loser nice don't call them that Shadow Ball them clicking priority moves is a loser play is so tough this opponent is getting diced this whole game all right you know what this ogre Pon just KO this flutter man now and yo I bet they were like so excited when they clicked trick room on our tail we like haha I got them no you didn't we are not trapped in here with you you are trapped in here with us I felt like the quickest Tailwind ever anybody else that yo it did I felt like we Tailwind did like last turn it was already done yeah we need to get rid of flutter so we can to double flutter cuz they can only take 1 K Max and then you win with either of these two plus 20 actually why don't we just double attack yeah like into both like it doesn't matter well they can oh that's also that's also doable no I like that I like that hly I don't even think you d a drain punch oh you're we're only 11 14 speed yeah the thing with h is they're always like fast enough to out speed you but in this case it worked against oh my gosh dead flutter they were max speed on both weren't they it might have been God yeah thanks for the trick room dude yeah right wait okay okay to their credit to their credit Tri on your Tailwind so they here's the thing it's it's a video we have to like we have to act like we were you have insult your opponent every look I'm I like Cesar Cesar my boy Cesar all of our Caesar what is it stand stand tall stand proud you were strong wait hold on wait fire makes me feel like they have dragon sh also but I guess we'll find out together don't care you know that the this the first game we fought where they have they have two dragon resists so we might actually be this is the first game we fought where they had two dragon types calm down right yeah you get some and you lose some Unfortunately they were double weak to drink as genuinely I hope they bring the Grim snor I want screens I want them to waste a turn I hope they bring the OG Pine as well I want to Quick through that this is a good video we should do you know what you should do I've been hating all game you should play me for the final game not going to play you reie Draco might be the oh wait this is uh this is definitely Dragon we just go the attack turn one dude I honestly I think we go for the attack turn one I think we Terra dragon uh Terra Draco meteor well remember if you Terra you're not 100% crit boost oh you're right you're right you're right I also don't think they're going to click a dragon move into you cuz what dragon moves do they have dragon dragonclaw it's it's it's possible yeah let's just protect this turn I don't think I care I mean Dragon Dance Dragon dance burning bull work uh you need fire coverage and you need a way to hit incenter it's probably stomping so I think you wall no teror literally no teror they probably they probably just lie I think you could have attacked are this Dragon dancing are they yeah I would think Dragon danc right man we just Draco meteor them and they have they have like insane confidence to be able to Dragon Dance in front of two dragons but oh they're cooked they're ceded hold on Buddy I think I don't ter BL and Draco no we can't do that I think we do ter I'm worried about them being ter fairy do you think they're Terra fairy they're probably ter grass if they're playing stall right they don't want get put to sleep yeah yeah I don't think we have to worry about that guy cuz he clicked fire spin let's just dra and go OG even if they bullwark we should be okay if they if they bullwark and also like Spirit Break they they're going to think they have like oh I have screens and Spirit Break no it doesn't matter I'm sorry my child Spirit Break is like the only thing in this match up that is actually any like even remotely scary not really wait no it's not cuz you crit through the drops that's what I'm saying cuz we crit through the drops okay I'm literally trying my hardest to make sure to like justify to myself that this team is not like really really good but it just keeps being really really good so I don't know I'm going be hating for no re trying to hate every time he hates he believes more oh hold on I do yeah hold on hold on if this is Terra faery we're in trouble ter grass ter grass ter grass ter grass ter grass ter grass dang it we have Terra Blast if we make it out of this situation alive we follow me ter blast we're fine also I'm going to say next turn they definitely protect I'm going to Target into that um yeah I'm going to Target into the um yeah we can kill that yeah they're going to protect here you should double it for sure double double burn just good yo that did a lot they're binding band yeah but they're protecting here I would never not protect there if you're holding a binding band protect is your favorite move in the game really y they are not protecting that's pretty wild are they do they trying to like fire spin our other slot they're just going to miss I hope so uh this won't kill and that's probably faster what is this set cuz then you can IV C I just realized we are faster oh killed what oh you have catch up look man look I'm not used to 100% CR okay why are you snar oh my God snar that they aren't either they are also not used to 100% CR all right we need to get rid of this thing this thing's annoying as hell yeah yeah it is it's getting mad annoying what if it's like assault V yo I'm not going to lie I think we just take out the golden go with Ivy Kel and Draco we're going to crit through it we're going to double crit it'll be fine if we crit Ivy K they're going to cry I am a fan of just leaving that really bad Pokemon to the left there alone just cuz it's not doing anything and it's the only it's the only one that I think might protect this turn if they protect golden gold they stream sniping oh y they're stream sniping I don't know how but they're doing I just think they're protecting this better be a double protect no they're just crazy is this thing ever going to protect maybe it doesn't have it there's no way I mean what moves right snarl fire spin I feel they snaring again are they snarling again y they could be AV breaking SW AV does make a lot of sense actually yeah they're AV they're AV which means that we don't have to worry about a move here we just just double attack here's the funniest thing possible though cuz if you ter blasted their protect that means they've got you literally every turn of the game we kill that next turn I think that the double up will do it I I just believe in Draco meteor with a crit yeah Draco got this Drago got us also we're going to we're going to crit with the other guy too but so their last move can't be a fire move otherwise they would have clicked it into the Steel type right yeah yeah it's definitely not a fire that's not a crit Draco oh they're faster oh which means they're not that bul oh we don't love that follow me the dra off okay the next win condition is uh rain dance they mo it is a fire move wow why did they cck that I don't know all right I'm going to be real I'm going to be real I think this person just did not play well and they got rewarded yeah I don't know I think they've got you every turn dog they snarled through 100% I they set up screens and snarled they were not playing well yeah it's probably rain dance I have an idea are you you are not about to like try to go go for Dragon chear and yeah rain Ste I'm going to go for the golden go the biggest issue is that they have screens so like how much screens do they have they're going to protect probably they have too many oh my God they're light clay they have they have three more turns I'm just going to hydro Steam and no we we'll go for the left slot yeah yeah they're just going to protect and snar they are an actual bot our turn to get play do you think they're AV though cuz they're for Tex yeah they're of course they're a not Dage yo they are like super AV this is the close team Sheet special I will say our team you could say our team's close team Sheet special I'll say as soon as the dragon chear goes off you better you better know what we're doing our our team is Fun close team Sheet special check this out for the for the for the culture I think this has to be your play yeah just to do damage through screen they also still have a third Pokemon in the book is the craziest part no they have four we didn't take down a Pokemon yet I'm pretty sure Grim didn't die Grim died we cred oh yeah yeah you're right you're right all right Ultra Mega count Ultra Mega super actually can you like Dragon cheer multiple times no yo oh oh speed drop ow all right they need to start missing these uh I can't believe they're like AV fire spinar honestly sarl breaking swipe on a bulky Pokemon will always be good I'm skeptical about the fire spin like I think he has a better move than that Hydro steam Bleak wind imaginary technique Hydro steam crit okay they're protecting for no reasons this is great if you double yeah they're not doing any damage that does so little chat can we agree that everything went right for them everything definitely this is definitely going to be a Moxy boost to DM right I just played you on ladder with with the binding band that you taught me I didn't teach him about the binding band oh no that's not g to be a DM I'm about to DM you in Japanese yo tripple Genie no dragon resist teil think about it because they have at least one AV on the team right they have dog if we get if we get Eerie impulsed I'm going to be so happy if we get Thunder waved I'm going to break this computer they probably do lead Eerie impulse thund into like what looks like a torn Drago lead right has gold hit has gold come out once today no Gold's a fake Gold's here to make people think it's a regular Drago team it's there to make them think they shouldn't bring their fairy types but then they just turn into a fairy type and then it's like wait wish wish I had a gold all right double beastball double Genie oh my gosh double cheek duck on a third afternoon dude honestly I think we literally just attack yeah just go for it I don't care the only thing is that they Thunder Wave the walking wake dude I don't care it doesn't matter it doesn't matter let's go for it they're going to miss Thunder Wave anyway and they both are Pokemon is going to die an eer Impulse maybe they do the thing maybe maybe they do the thing that happened to us in team testing where they get the double wild Bol Pera they're just going to do what exactly we said last game they're going to be like I hate open team shets it's over it's over good game it's over we got the we got the shake my hand uh B please put this at the start shake my hand the preview GG's well Play to US yeah GG's well Play Play This is the preview this is the game preview this got to be the preview blein who cares oh no actually we might not one shot just kidding we definitely no we will We one shot 10 times over oh owned what that's whack they're like zero at the beginning all right you that's crazy we already got other stuff can go in the beginning all right I think we just uh you do it again I mean like y yo yo yo yo yo you know what the real play is you know what the real place protect cuz they're going to they're going to paralyze the left slot what go maybe yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah we can like tear the ogre Pond and make sure we always live follow me well I mean I just think you like redirect the Thunder Wave so you can just click keep clicking Dragon moves yeah I think we have to attack here though why we got to get rid of this guy follow me no no no no they're going to they're going to thunder wave cuz they know they have to you going to you mean you're going to attack with the Wake yeah yeah yeah what is going on what are they thinking we'll take it we don't though because like we we don't have to take it we'll just kill it we just attack it with wake two stronger two stronger Pokemon uh next to each other is probably better or is probably worse for us than tornad on the field still tornad is pretty weak right now that's going to be Lander what did they bring out oh wait I just remembered the game's bugged why why can't we just drink all the Lando the game is bugged you can switch out and still crit things go go tornado here go tornadoes here yeah oh my God wait they didn't expect us to start cheating yeah we're cheating now we're cheating we're cheating I forgot the game's bugged you keep the you keep the Boost this move would be so good if it was meant to do that there's probably somebody in the comments uh typing in the last game you switched out that move would be better but the problem is I think that you can like crit boost your whole team which feels a little bit too strong yeah that'd be stupid yeah Tailwind with two crit items too all right check this out check this out Hydro steam the left slot cuz you know they're about to protect Lando most likely and if they don't protect look at these Bots look at these bots gets one play right starts calling them Bots I remind you what happened last game need I remind you that one because they play like a bot they snar bro snar protected every other turn that's bot Behavior little little did you know that that was my that was my my homie I called him up I was like snipers stream snipers I'll relay all information to you I was dming them every turn our CH oh I'm so ready for this end game bro they think that that's going to save them I'm so ready for this end game we just Bleak wind Hydro steam actually I'm going to Terra Hydro steam just to make sure should I rain dance I'm going to rain dance I'm going to be disrespectful I'm going to give him that I'm going to give him the opportunity completely unnecessary Terra coming right up CU they can terraz they can also Terra yeah I just need to make sure I get this koing Lander makes our chadon fight a 1v3 and I don't think you could do that watch them be sash for no reason let's go the featur Manon got a kill let's go all right hit us with that all right man man fine I'll do it myself I'll do it myself feing look at them feing the Terra if they tear a fairy I'm be mad dog man we have Flash oh no we don't was we're fine yo you sure we are fine nah we got the ogre pawn and you gave them Electra shot you about to get reverse yeah wait a minute wait a minute yeah come come on my side man come on my hating side please we're fine we're fine he deserves this for this type of behavior he deserves the hating we're fine don't lie to me you know we're fine come on baby cakes we're fine fine you know what's funny you can like ter still win crit teror blast it's not stab but crit teror blast will probably do de 80 base power turns to 120 and then we yeah no I we're fine don't lie to me Michael Miguel Miguel he call me he call me this Miguel Rogers he call me the family name I'm a Family Guy what can I say they suck why are their Pokemon notes Duron oh wow this one's garbage interesting interesting all right go ahead and like yeah they still lose dude imagine losing to the non stab teror blast fine I'll do it myself no don't do that again son don't even click follow me just attack oh you want the KO fine fine but dude what if you H roll the last teror blast that'd be insane rich is a hilarious guy cuz he really just be like throwing beams around for no reason yeah right he's a Dragon Ball character dude he is a dragon ball is special beam dude it's a dragon ball and he tossed out the special beam can in game one incar even hit the field once no no y we used four mons all game all right all right viewers Friends of the channel Gamers this is the rental code that will save your life you know a lot of people don't understand the power that Pokemon has you know you got to unlock the power that's in inside that power that's a crit Razer claw Reggie Drago dragon energy thank you for watching make sure you subscribe to the main event and Mike Raj Mike Raj does not have a YouTube channel that's good you don't upload he does he just don't upload to me record the speed Arts just upload oh they have been y' not already 2024 we dropping bombs you said 2023 you'd be doing that n four my all right whatever make sure you sub to the main event how many Subs you I collected The Last Dragon Ball I summoned Shenron and he came to my house and he said 2024 it's your year how many Subs you this very moment I'm like 1645 man why how come I told you guys go sub to him last video why aren't you subbing 2000 I I want that on my desk on my desk video like 10 p.m. that's true but it still got good views thanks for watching everybody have a nice night bye | Moxie Boosted | UCAVKuhZ5Og4O86jkgUgUcyg | 2024-01-15 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 7,109 | 35,262 |
X0rp8rYynHM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0rp8rYynHM | Big Lenny gets put ON BLAST by serious tough guy | i'm making this video and it's just sent out to big money not accepting your apology it's unacceptable what you do in the gym your racial comments you're making fun of uh kids with special needs women that have no idea on film and your channel with all your trolls i check in everywhere i go my gym my shop forever at the time i check in matter of fact i check in five minutes before so if you're looking for me little trolls that's what i'll be lenny i'm gonna put you on blast my friends my brothers [Music] you'll be seen one day just like i saw you on the avenue and you'll have to deal with that and all your trolls that are threatening my life here i am | 300poundsRipped | UC4duYoZzXa_vux2VMkLxUiw | 2022-05-20 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 132 | 659 |
M1Iu6GtLKZA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M1Iu6GtLKZA | HANDS in the Kitchen: Foods for Digestive Health | [Music] hi i'm chef robin welcome to hands in the kitchen workshop about foods that aid digestion we have done quite a few of these workshops speaking about different parts of the healthy plate and in order for that healthy plate to be um of use for us of use to our body it's interesting to know about the digestive system and how it actually works and how it actually breaks down those particles for us to make use of so we're going to go through the digestive system today we're going to talk about what is digestion what is your gi tract or your gastrointestinal tract which is referred to as your gut i know my mother would not like to hear me say that but they do speak of it as being your gut um also the steps of digestion what is healthy and unhealthy digestion foods for great gut health what prebiotic means what probiotic means what cultured beings and what fermented means so you might have heard these words lately they're very much in the news gut health has only been a relevant topic for like the past 20 years gastroenterology didn't really start to become an issue or something that was researched heavily until the 1990s so in the medical world it's kind of a new phenomena or a new kind of thought digestion is very simply the breakdown of food into smaller components that can be absorbed into the bloodstream by mechanical and enzymic action so if you think about or just look at your bloodstream look at your veins and you think about the size of a particle of food that you eat and how tiny tiny it has to be broken down in order to be absorbed up into your bloodstream to go to all those organs and systems that need those nutrients a lot has to happen and you're responsible for helping that happen by having a healthy gut so we're gonna go through how we can create that healthy gut biome and not have tummy aches and otherwise the steps of digestion happen pretty fast actually but then they can slow up and that's where we run into trouble so first we ingest food by our mouth very natural to do very easy to do we start it from childbirth and our mouth and tongue work with chewing and saliva to push it back to the back of our throat where a little tiny flap will come down and shut it's called a sphincter and a little tiny flap shuts down so that that food doesn't go down our windpipe but goes down through our esophagus our esophagus through a process called periscolosis peristalsis uh contracts relaxes contracts relaxes and pushes that food down so our food is mixed up with salama in our mouth should chew at least 20 bites a piece um until we have smaller particles with a lot of saliva easily swallowed down automatically swallowed down and it drops down into our stomach okay there's also a little flap at the end of our esophagus that shuts down so that we don't regurgitate that food back up unless we violently have to hurl and then that flap comes open and food does come back up but generally the food is now partially digested and in our stomach now these three organs the pancreas the gallbladder and the liver all send enzymes to our stomach and what happens is these two processes right here begin to occur mechanical and chemical processes the stomach through peristalsis as well contracts relaxes contracts relaxes turns that food up with bile that's coming from the liver other enzymes that are coming from the pancreas and the gallbladder breaking it up breaking it up breaking it up until it drops down into our small intestine in our small intestine more enzymes are released through our small intestine and most of the digestive process is actually happening there so pieces that are broken down even even smaller small and smaller coming into our small intestine breaking down smaller smaller smaller then traveling into our large intestine our large intestine is responsible for absorbing most of the water out of anything that's left from those food particles and creating stool so most of the water that comes in this digestive bits of food particles in our large intestine the water will be absorbed into the walls of the large intestine stool will be created that's hangs out in the rectum which is right here and then finally discharged to the anus now if everything goes great we have a lovely bm mostly twice or once a day should be on a regular basis but if things don't happen correctly stools can be held in your body for up to 48 to 72 hours which is a crazy amount of time you may not have enough liquid you may not have things that are working correctly and we run into problems when that happens because it's a waste material that your body actually needs to discharge so you don't want to hold on to that waste you want to get rid of it so in the system of our gut the gi tract there are trillions trillions of bacteria some of them good some of them not so good we really want to keep a balance between the good and the bad but with the good coming out on top so if we talk about good gut health good gut health is going to aid digestion good good health is going to lead to healthy elimination of waste good good good gut health excuse me is going to mean that we get nutrient mineral and vitamin vitamin absorption into our bloodstream also you may not know this but 70 of our immune function comes from our gut which is really an extremely large number so it stimulates immune function want it to be working right and also it's involved in brain development you may have heard people refer to your gut as your second brain or go with your gut or trust your gut it's because the gut and the brain are constantly talking constantly sending back messages to each other and the gut is actually sending material to the brain to help it to become stronger to help your memory to work to help your emotions stay stable it's amazing it's really just amazing and it also in addition more even more great stuff it will regulate your sugar levels so lots and lots of stuff is going on that we want to make sure stays in the good department as opposed to the bad department when you get bad gut health and we've all been there with a tummy ache before or something that's upset us and for a couple days maybe a virus even wipes us out but when you consistently have a bad gut microbiome going on situation yes which is unpleasant and also embarrassing but then it can lead to irritable bowel syndrome it can lead to crohn's disease i have going on inside of our bodies so how do we try and avoid that there's lots of different ways we're talking here on this poster about triggers that create those tummy aches situations we've all done it we've all you know we're not saints when it comes to our diet or health but some of them are relatively easy to avoid the first trigger for a tummy ache that we're all familiar with is just eating too much food people tend to keep on their plates which is relatively not a very smart thing to do it can lead to overweight it can lead to your stomach being too full to process that food the other thing about a trigger for tummy ache and i didn't put it on there but it's just as important is too little sleep not eating enough food to where you're always feeling fatigued to where you're never having enough energy to where you're just not maintaining that caloric intake that you need to be healthy so too little or too much food and then this is a big big deal for seniors too little water seniors seem to be like frightened of water for some reason but it's seriously seriously important that you try to drink water throughout your day um i got a tip from a friend of mine who says she just keeps a cup in the bathroom and when she has to go to the bathroom even if it's just to wash her hands she'll drink a cup of water and yes it seems kind of counterproductive or intuitive to drink water and then be in the bathroom and go to the bathroom and drink water and go to the bathroom but you actually need this amount of water for all your systems to function and especially your digestive system to function correctly so six to eight cups daily there is some leniency some doctors will accept decaf coffee some will accept seltzer water some will accept water with lemon some will accept decaf tea so whatever kind of combination you necessarily need to achieve eight to six glasses of liquid mostly water try to find that niche for yourself um too much food too little food way too little water and then we get into things that probably you're very familiar with and are aware of greasy food is a super cult culprit for trigger for tummy eggs i'm not anti pizza but when you open up that lid of pizza and you see a pool of grease on the top maybe sparingly eat pizza don't make pizza your go-to five night a week dinner just be aware that it is giving you a lot of fats that are not necessarily the healthiest for you to digest also just greasy fair food is what i call it anything that's put down in a deep fryer if it's not fried correctly and it comes out saturated with the grease from the fryer it really cannot be good for you and it really can trigger a tummy ache or worse bacon is another one that we should be sparing up even though it's a vermont favorite just be aware that bacon every day is probably contributing somewhat to a situation that could be avoidable and probably is not going to lead you to good health so in addition to greasy food this is a culprit right here too much soda and one thing about soda is that it's carbonated so it's already gassed up so it's going to create bubbles inside of you that may be difficult to digest but mostly the thing about diet sodas is the sugar that's in those diet sodas immediately goes through your system and it rushes through so fast that it really creates some issues in your digestive system so overloading on diet soda can be a problem remember these are too much too much so too much alcohol too much soda too much acid no one is telling you to do away with drinking orange juice or to do away with eating a grapefruit or to enjoy an occasional beer or something on rocks or even a diet soda just balance it out with other good healthy food for your gut so now we are at that healthy food for your gut poster and this is where i would ask if there are any questions we're going to break down what prebiotics and probiotics are all about and fibers soluble and inside so prebiotic foods you're probably hearing a lot about prebiotics are contained in a rainbow of foods all right all of these foods here in their natural state contain prebiotics and a lot of it is contained in the skin so vegetables and fruits that have skins although you don't eat a banana skin but in ginger and garlic squashes apples berries a rainbow of colors a rainbow of food prunes fist prints even probiotic brands so um prebiotics are like booster rockets for probiotics so the essential prebiotic nature of these foods when eaten with a probiotic food helps the probiotic bacteria kind of overwhelm the bad bacteria in your gut okay we're talking about good gut health and bad guys so just to simplify and break that down a little bit let's talk about probiotics and cultured and fermented foods so these foods not this one or this one although these are good for you but these foods right here and i'll hold them up so you can see them better have all been inoculated or cultured with a good bacteria and what that means exactly is microorganisms like yeast or bacteria are added into carbohydrates and that carbohydrate is then converted into carbohydrates like starches and sugars are then converted into alcohols and acids okay so you take a product like milk you add an inoculant to it it creates buttermilk or yogurt or kefir which is a drink a yogurt kefir sorry kefir is cultured low-fat milk or yogurt it's probiotic it says right there so um it converts it into alcohols and acids which act as a natural preservative okay but it also promotes the growth of beneficial bacteria which is known as a probiotic so the probiotic is actually a form of bacteria that's created after another bacteria an inoculant a microorganism like yeast or bacteria is added to the product at hand so say you're making sauerkraut your product at hand is a head of cabbage chop chop slice slice you're going to take salt massage it into that cabbage then you're going to let that cabbage rest in a cool dark place the process that's happening right there is creating another bacteria that's going to preserve that cabbage as a pickled cabbage called sauerkraut so sauerkraut is a is a probiotic and it's a very healthy thing to have even if you have it on a hot dog still healthy okay and it's probiotic you can tell people i have my probiotic sauerkraut today so kimchi is a similar product to sauerkraut except that it's made with very hot chilies but same kind of process where a bacterial agent came about from the process of fermentation and culturing to create a probiotic product okay miso which is added into soups or stews are inoculated soybeans or chickpeas this one is chickpea miso so the chickpeas are taken dried rinsed grown um and then inoculated with the bacteria set aside for a while to allow to ferment and become tasty and processed into miso so this is a probiotic product the same with yogurt the same with kefir and a lot of so culturing and fermenting has been around for hundreds of years the only thing that's new for us to think is the term probiotic fermenting and culturing have been around forever when there were too many breaks would they turn it into they turned it into wine through fermenting when you had sourdough starter that was a result of wanting to save for the next loaf of bread so it's not a new concept to us it's just new to know the beneficial qualities of preserving food in this way actually makes it much healthier for us and much healthier for our gut this is a product that you might not be as familiar with this is inoculated soybeans and it's called tempeh tempeh is a little cake when the inoculation is done and the fermentation has happened it turns into a little brick cake it's sold vacuum sealed in this package it usually comes with a recipe it has all the dietary breakdown for you on the back but this is a probiotic product that you might want to consider adding into your diet you can roast it you can sear it it's relatively inexpensive and it's a plant-based protein that you can use that's also not going to lead you to having a saturated fat red meat protein for dinner so there's a lot of food items out there that are readily available and that shouldn't be too scary that you can start to kind of blend into your diet again when you make any change to your diet you don't want to suddenly go to bran flakes five mornings a week flaxseed shakes five mid mornings a week because sudden change is also something that your body reacts to suddenly and abruptly so small steps of including probiotics into your diet if you have none at all you may have been eating all of these things already and not really realize how healthy you're keeping your gut biome but if you have not if you have been possibly maintaining the tummy ache diet you may want to consider slowly proceeding to add in more healthy probiotics and they're not really difficult to do so i mean it's not a difficult thing to do most of these items should be very familiar to you in some manner than or the other kefir maybe is not yogurt definitely is uh this is plain yogurt but the you can buy fruity flavored yogurt if you like the only thing that you need to make sure of is that on the back it will tell you if it has live cultures and if it has live cultures that means that those probiotic bacteria are in this yogurt and going to do the healthy gut health for you this is such a topical uh topic or a topic that people are so much talking about now that when i went to the grocery store to actually pick up these items for this workshop this was on the grocery store stand right beside the cash register so um gun health 101 and this uh i'm not advising that you go out and buy this i'm just advising you that this is something that a lot of people are talking about a lot of uh food purveyors are going to be advertising more and more that their foods are probiotic because they want to you know go a little dollar but if you just know that a probiotic food is a food that's been cultured then you can look for that on the grocery store shelf and not necessarily have to search out something exotic or unfamiliar to you so but this was a good read and it was very interesting to me to find that it was so much in the food world now a topic that is um really getting a lot of buzz should we say so we're right on time with stuff talking about probiotics and hopefully um these were helpful to you i didn't necessarily make a colored illustrations but uh also these cheeses i forgot to mention gouda parmesan and swiss cheese have a probiotic nature and kombucha which is an inoculated black or green tea which a lot of people like to drink is also a cultured probiotic so so grab some probiotic food enjoy it at your leisure and see if you feel healthier or if you're experiencing any of these tummy ache issues maybe cut out or regulate your water or regulate your intake and hopefully you will be healthier and your tummy will be healthier for it you | Town Meeting TV | UCJkWMLSqRNKLoyUZQiNoAcQ | 2021-04-05 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,251 | 17,344 |
L3YPm5JNmJQ | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3YPm5JNmJQ | Black Beauty - Part III, Chapter XXXV | chapter 35 jerry barker i never knew a better man than my new master he was kind and good and as strong for the right as john manley and so good tempered and mary that very few people could pick a quarrel with him he was very fond of making little songs and singing them to himself one he was very fond of was this come father and mother and sister and brother come all of you turn to and help one another and so they did harry was as clever at stable work as a much older boy and always wanted to do what he could then polly and dolly used to come in the morning to help with the cab to brush and beat the cushions and rub the glass while jerry was giving us a cleaning in the yard and harry was rubbing the harness there used to be a great deal of laughing and fun between them and it put captain and me in much better spirits than if we had heard scalding and hard words they were always early in the morning for jerry would say if you in the morning throw minutes away you can't pick them up in the course of the day you may hurry and scurry and flurry and worry you've lost them forever forever and i you could not bear any careless loitering and waste of time and nothing was so near making him angry as to find people who were always late wanting a cab horse to be driven hard to make up for their idleness one day two wild looking young men came out of the tavern close by the stand and called jerry here gabby look sharp we are rather late put on the steam will you and take us to the victoria in time for the one o'clock train you shall have a shilling extra i will take you at the regular pace gentlemen shillings don't pay for putting on the steam like that larry's cab was standing next to ours he flung open the door and said i'm your man gentlemen take my cab my horse will get you there all right and as he shut them in with a wink towards jerry's head it's against his conscience to go beyond a dog trot then slashing his jaded horse he set off as hard as he could jerry patted me on the neck no jack a shilling would not pay for that sort of thing would it old boy although jerry was determinedly set against hard driving to please careless people he always went a good fair pace and was not against putting on the scene as he said if only he knew why i well remember one morning as we were on the stand waiting for affair that a young man carrying a heavy portmanteau trod on a piece of orange peel which lay on the pavement and fell down with great force jerry was the first to run and lift him up he seemed much stunned and as they led him into a shot he walked as if he were in great pain jerry of course came back to the stand but in about 10 minutes one of the shot men called him so he drew up to the pavement can you take me to the southeastern railway so the young man this unlucky fall has made me late i fear but it is of great importance that i shall not lose the 12 o'clock train i should be most thankful if you could get me there in time and will gladly pay you an extra fare i'll do my very best said jerry hardily if you think you are well enough sir for he looked dreadfully white and ill i must go he said earnestly pleased to open the door and let us lose no time the next minute jerry was on the box with the cheery chirp to me and a twitch to the ring that i well understood now then jack my boy said he spin along we'll show them how we can get over the ground if only know why it was difficult to drive fast in the city in the middle of the day when the streets are full of traffic what we did what could be done and when a good driver and a good horse who understand each other are of one mind it is wonderful what they can do i had a very good mouth that is i could be guided by the slightest touch of the rain and that is a great thing in london amongst carriages omnibuses carts fans trucks cabs and great wagons creeping along at a walking pace some going one way some another some going slow others wanting to pass them on the buses stopping short every few minutes take up a passenger obliging a horse that is coming behind to pull up to or to pass and get before them perhaps you try to pass but just then something else comes dashing in through the narrow opening you have to keep in behind the omnibus again presently you think you see a chance and managed to get to the front going so near the wheels on each side that half an inch here and they would scrape well you get along for a bit but soon you find yourself in a long train of carts and carriages all obliged to go on a walk perhaps you come to a regular block up and have to stand still for minutes altogether till something clears out into a side street or the policeman interferes you have to be ready for any chance to dash forward if there to be an opening and be quick as a rat dog to see if there be room and if there'd be time lest you get your own wheels locked or smashed or the shaft is some other vehicle run into your chest or shoulder all this is what you have to be ready for if you want to get through london fast in the middle of the day it wants a deal of practice jerry and i were used to it and no one could beat us at getting through when we were set upon i was quick and bold and could always trust my driver jerry was quick and patient at the same time and could trust his force which was a great thing too he very seldom used the whip i knew by his voice and his clip click when he wanted to get on fast and by the rain where i was to go so there was no need for whipping but i must go back to my story the streets were very full that day but we got on pretty well as far as the bottom of cheap side where there was a block for three or four minutes the young man put his head out and said anxiously i think i had better get out and walk i shall never get there if this goes on i'll do all that can be done sir said jerry i think we shall be in time this block up cannot last much longer and your luggage is very heavy for you to carry sir just then the cart in front of us began to move on and then we had a good turn in and out in and out we went as fast as four splash could do it and for a wonder had a good clear time on london bridge where there was a whole train of cabs and carriages all going our way at a quick try perhaps wanting to catch that very train at any rate we whirled into the station with many more just as the great clock pointed to eight minutes to twelve o'clock thank god we are in times of the young man and thank you too my friends and your good horse you have saved me more than any money could ever pay for take this extra half crown no sir no thank you all the same so glad we hit the time sir but don't stay now sir the bell is ringing here porter take this gentleman's luggage dover lying 12 o'clock train that's it and without waiting for another word jerry wheeled me around to make room for other cabs that were dashing up at the last minute and drew up one side till the crush was passed so glad he said so glad poor young fellow i wonder what it was that made him so anxious jerry often talked to himself quite loud enough for me to hear when we were not moving on jerry's return to the rank there was a good deal of laughing and chaffing at him for driving hard to the train for an extra fare as i said all against his principles and he wanted to know how much he had pocketed a good deal more than i generally get said he nodding slyly what he gave me will keep me in little comforts for several days common someone he's a humbug said another preaching to us and then doing the same himself look here mates said jerry the gentleman offered me half a crown extra but i didn't take it she was quite pay enough for me to see how glad he was to catch that train and if jack and i choose to have a quick run now and then to please ourselves that's our business and not yours well said larry you'll never be a rich man most likely not said jerry but i don't know that i should be the less happy for that i have heard the commandments read a great many times and i never noticed that any of them said thou shalt be rich and there are good many curious things said in the new testament about rich men that i think would make me feel rather clear if i was one of them if you ever do get rich said governor gray looking over his shoulder across the top of his cab you'll deserve it jerry and you won't find a curse come with your wealth as for you larry you'll die poor you spend too much in whip court well said larry that what is a fellow to do if this forest won't go without it you never take the trouble to see if you will go without it your whip is always going as if you had the saint fighter stance in your arms and it does not wear you out and wears your horses out you know you are always changing your horses and why because you never give them any peace or encouragement well i have not had good luck said larry that's where it is and you never will said the governor good luck is rather particular who she rides with and mostly prefers those who have got common sense and a good heart at least that is my experience governor gray turned round again to his newspaper and the other men went to their cabs | Sonrise Tutoring | UCUy21_JI3ogao-mFJQaDrcQ | 2021-06-19 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,882 | 9,179 |
nVFfo5Cq_iA | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVFfo5Cq_iA | QMainWindow - Udemy Preview - Qt Widgets for Beginners | all right if you're sick of working with cue dialogue and you want to actually test out cue main window today is the day there's a reason we haven't covered it yet though it's very complex if you look at the documentation it just goes on and on and on I mean this reads like a horror novel but really what you need to understand is the cue main window comes with some functionality baked right into it for example menu bar status bars toolbars you can dock widgets and a central widget which it takes a little bit of explaining what a central widget is but basically it's the reason why you're looking at the window for example this web browser the central widget would be well this web page area it's the entire reason why you have the application so a text editor you'd have a giant text area you know so on and so on let's go ahead and just dive in here and let's take a look at how to build one of these so we're gonna say new and let's just call this cute with this beginning here 7-1 and we're gonna leave this as q' main window and just leave everything as the default next next finish now from a code perspective things don't look too different we're just inheriting Q main windows the Q dialog the user interface though looks different you notice right off the bat we have this type here if we kind of scroll down we can scale as you can see we have this status bar down here might not be readily available in the video but it's there and we have this little actions editor down here hmm we could right-click and then we go to new we can actually make some new actions so let's call this new it's automatically named action new and we can have tooltips icons make it checkable I have shortcuts and all sorts of other stuff we're just going to keep this video super simple now there's action new let's make a few more let's call it open save copy-pasted you know just some general actions in case you're wondering how I'm coming up with these actions it's pretty much standard that most applications have things like undo redo cut copy paste things like that and let's see here we've got copy paste we don't have a cut so let's do cut let's keep this simple and let's say Neil and we're gonna say select all and what could say select all and it actually renames it with the underscore automatically you may be wondering so what's the point of having these actions well there's really two main reasons a we want to populate right here this is called a menu so when I say file and let's just double click in their file and hit enter there we go you see tada now we suddenly have menus and we can type here or we can drag and drop so for example let's just drag up here and you see that little red line there's new open save and then we can go over here let's type edit drag and drop we don't want new here because we got it over here so we can just cancel off let's go copy cut let's go paste and I want to add select all but I want to add a separator which is just a little line see if we can find one here yeah see this line right here between these two that's a separator so we're going to go here I'm going to just click the double click the add separator adds it in automatically and then we're going to select all grab that move it up now if you're not super skilled with Mouse you can actually just do them right here you can just type right where it says type and it'll make the action for you a little bit error-prone that's why I like doing it down here and then dragging and dropping now let's say we want a toolbar right here we want buttons going across what we need to do is actually look at this you can see by default there's no toolbar we can just right click add toolbar and you get that thin little line right there then you can just drag and drop oops I missed it that's what I mean by not particularly skilled with mouse and keyboard sometimes and we're graphically building our interface and we can right click and we can append the separator it adds a little line might not be readily available in the video but we can just add the copy let's go with cut and let's say paste now we have a very basic interface let's save this let's go ahead and run this and see what this thing looks like here this is our main window in all its glory we have our actions going across and our actions in the menu and they call the same code so for example if you right-click and you go to slot tada we have our cue actions and we have changed hovered toggled triggered and triggered so we're just gonna go triggered without any parameters and there's our code so trigger is really defined on when the user clicks them and I think my interface is just taking a minute there it goes so we're just going to actually go in we're going to define the slots for each one of these this is a bit of the boring part of development is just doing what I call the plumbing connecting everything up now the great thing about this is you have one slot that can be used multiple times either via the menu or via the toolbar let's go back here and we're going to add a plain text edit let's go ahead add it in here and we can try and set some sort of layout or something and it kind of looks okay save and run this but you notice how we have this little area around it it's not very attractive we want that going right to the edge here so let's flip back in here let's go to our implementation file and we're going to say UI and there's set up UI don't get that confused with what we're about to do set up UI is different than set central widget you don't want the user interface so I see a lot of people asking that question why don't I see the option to set the central widget in the UI it's because it's not part of the UI class it's part of the Q main window so we're going to say this set central widget and it just takes q widget now we can say UI plain text edit save it run and let's see what this looks like now now you see how it goes right to the edge it actually ignore is any layout that we put in there just goes right to that edge and we have pretty much a text editor here comes complete with scroll bars and I'm going to just grab some text off the screen here and we've got just a mini text editor complete with word wrap and you guessed it menus so let's go ahead and fill in some code here to make this thing somewhat functional let's close that let's go in here and first things first we want our includes so we're going to say include cue file dialogue actual s2q file first cue file dialogue and let's do we want the cue text stream cue message box in case you guessed what we're doing yes we are making a very very basic text editor if you're on Windows it's gonna be something very similar to notepad you can call this whatever you want you call a file name and file name whatever doesn't matter as long as you have it in there now from here really we just do what I call the plumbing we start filling out these slots in that way things are start happening when we click buttons it's pretty simple alright now we've got our constructor we're going to leave the Deconstructor just the way it is now we just simply need to start filling out some things and we're going to go into the new button or the new action where it's a UI plain text edit and we're going to actually clear that out I'm gonna say UI status bar and we're show a message and we're just going to clear out any message that we have in case you're wondering no this video is not going to make a complete app I'm going to actually break this out through the entire section just because this type of programming does take a while and we'll be here for a few hours talking about this for example open gets a little bit more complex we're gonna say a Q string half equals and we want the Q file dialogue which does exactly what we think it does we're going to say get and there's open file URL and open file name we want get open file name this and open a file and it does exactly what you think I do it pops open a dialog saying hey what file do you want to open it I'll let you select a file off your local path here I'm going to say Q file file and let's go ahead feed at the path that the user just selected and we're going to say if file open and we want the QIO device read-only just in case you've skipped ahead yes we do cover all this in the cute core beginners intermediate and advanced series out on udemy so we're not going to really in-depth cover qio device in these videos and we're gonna say if we cannot open these and then we're going to show a critical message box to the user let them know hey you screwed up not my fault you the user screwed up and we're gonna get the error string indicating why we can't open that file and then let's go ahead and return and then let's go ahead and queue text stream this yeah stream we're gonna hand this handle to the file and if we're here we have an open file so we need to close this file some people don't do that force of habit I always do it just case I don't want to lock up any resources and then we're gonna say a plain text edit we're going to set that plain text by reading the entire file pretty simple pretty easy to understand but then we also want to get a little added bonus that status bar at the bottom case you wonder where the status bar is technically this is a status bar although that's a tool bar but the status bar is that thing on the bottom that usually shows the file or some other message so we're gonna say UI status bar and we want to show a message notice how we can add a message or a timeout along with that we're gonna do just the message the timeout will actually make it disappear I just want to show that message and let's go ahead and say M file what path might be getting a little ahead of myself that might confuse me in another video let's go ahead and copy this because save is pretty much just doing the opposite of what we wanted to do initially so in save we're going to say get save filename not get open and then save file there we go notice the difference between get save and get open they're two distinctly different dialog boxes although they may look identical on your operating system set this to write only and then we're just going to change this we're gonna say stream UI plain text edit to plain text I really wish they change that to just text and then don't need to set any of that because it's already saved but we're going to anyways just leave it right the way it is and everything should just go I mean now we've got a semi functional text editor at this point we can open a file the user can modify it they can save the file so let's fill out some real simple signals and slots here so we've got our action is called copy and then we've got paste cut select also we're just gonna say UI plain text edit and we want to copy we could have very easily just you know connected those viola signals and slots using a bunch of connection code up here I like doing it here in case I didn't want to like show on the status bar hey we copied hey we pasted we did something some people don't like doing this I like doing it because it gives me the option to just say oh yep I want to add some extra code here and then it's just very boring we just say cut and select all and we're just calling the slots on the q plain text edit save and run make sure we got no build issues here and we can open something and see there's our open dialog and all of its glory and we could actually open something up if we really wanted to I'm not gonna mess around with that we can actually say new news it out and let's just say let's come back in here I want to actually jump in here where's our new code cuz I know somebody's gonna grab this and say oh it doesn't work and they didn't follow the entire series so we could actually just sit clear you want to clear that out now we have a semi functional text editor so we can we can say new we can open things we can close things and you know of course we need a little bit more air handling and things like that we can add in some some just code here so let me just grab something off screen you know for example you can grab here you can copy and then you can just go in here and you can paste or you could say edit select all cut you can actually paste it back in doesn't matter if you do it to the menu or through the toolbar they're the same slot and it's actually just pretty cool I hope you enjoyed this video it's part of a larger project Adam to you to me called acute widgets for beginners with C++ this is a large course with 73 lectures in 17 hours of video footage this course covers everything from what is a widget all the way down to complete example applications using the skills you've learned in this course sorry there's no qml in this course this is strictly cute widgets I will make a qml course later on but this just focus on widgets from a beginner's perspective even those as a beginners course you do need to have some fundamental information available you need to know C++ and the cute core lives I do have some courses available out on udemy cute core beginners intermediate advanced it's not necessary you take these courses but it is highly recommended and as always I'm available out on the void roams Facebook group along with 3,000 other programmers see you there | VoidRealms | UCYP0nk48grsMwO3iL8YaAKA | 2019-12-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,633 | 13,325 |
CLvywJhNOwk | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CLvywJhNOwk | Shooting of Laquan McDonald | Wikipedia audio article | the murder of laQuan McDonald took place on October 20th 2014 in Chicago Illinois when the 17 year old african-american was fatally shot by Chicago Police Officer Jason van Dyke police had initially reported that McDonald was behaving erratically while walking down the street refused to put down a knife he was carrying and lunged at them preliminary internal police reports described the incident similarly and ruled the shooting justified and van Dyke was not charged in the shooting at that time when the police released a dashcam video of the shooting 13 months later on November 24th 2015 it showed McDonald had been walking away from the police when he was shot that same day officer van Dyke was charged with first-degree murder and initially held without bail at the Cook County Jail he was released on bail on November 30th the city reached a settlement with McDonald's family on October 5th 2018 Van Dyke was found guilty at trial of second-degree murder as well as 16 counts of aggravated battery with a firearm protests following the shooting of McDonald demanded changes in police and judicial procedure and for the dismissal or resignation of city and county officials rahm emanuel won a second term in 2015 as mayor of Chicago but Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez lost her bid for re-election in 2016 at the request of Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan the United States Department of Justice initiated a civil rights investigation into MacDonald's death and the activities of the Chicago Police Department it released its report in January 2017 describing the police as having a culture of excessive violence especially against minority suspects and of having poor training and supervision DOJ and city officials signed a consent decree for a plan for improvement to be overseen by the courts three Chicago police officers tried for allegedly attempting to cover up events related to the shooting were found not guilty by the Cook County Circuit Court on January 17 2019 you topic profiles you topic laQuan McDonald laQuan McDonald September 25th 1997 to October 20th 2014 was from the 37th Ward of Chicago according to NBC Chicago news McDonald earned $1100 working after school in the youth advocate program in 2014 his final report card showed that he had earned an a' in personal finance and music a B in world studies in reading and a C in biology and Algebra one of McDonald's teachers described him as very respectful and reserved the teacher added that McDonald was not aggressive toxicology reports later revealed that McDonald had PCP in his blood in urine at the time of the encounter with police defense expert pharmacologist James Thomas O'Donnell testified that the amount found was enough to suggest he had taken the drug on the day of the shooting and that it could cause significant bizarre behavior topic Jason van Dyke Jason D Van Dyke born C 1978 was born in Hinsdale Illinois and graduated from Hinsdale South High School in 1996 he earned a bachelor's degree in criminal justice from Saint Xavier University in Chicago a 14-year veteran of the Chicago Police Department and earning a salary of 78,000 $12 Van Dyke is married and has two children since 2001 some 20 citizen complaints have been filed against officer van Dyke but none resulted in disciplinary action ten of the complaints allege he used excessive force and to involve the use of a firearm a jury awarded a Chicago man $350,000 after determining Van Dyke employed excessive force during a traffic stop one complaint involved verbal abuse by Van Dyke who used a racial slur Van Dyke may have been involved in the cover-up of a separate shooting in 2005 according to CNN the Chicago Police Department has about 12,000 officers like Van Dyke 400 two officers have 20 or more complaints on file in the database the most complaints against any officer according to the database is 68 the database shows that of the 20 complaints against Van Dyke none resulted in discipline 5 complaints in the database were not sustained 5 were unfounded 4 resulted in exoneration 5 had unknown outcomes and one resulted in no action taken you topic events shortly before 10 p.m. police were called to investigate McDonald at 4100 South Pulaski Road responding to reports that he was carrying a knife and breaking into vehicles in a trucking yard at 41st Street and cold-air Avenue when officers confronted McDonald he used a knife with a three-inch seven point five centimeters blade to slice the tire on a patrol vehicle and damaged its windshield McDonald walked away from police after numerous verbal instructions from officers to drop the knife at which point responding officers requested taser backup according to radio recordings released December 30th 2015 to Politico and NBC Chicago in response to Illinois Freedom of Information Act requests video of the shooting shows that van Dyke was advancing on McDonald while McDonald was walking away from Van Dyke when the first shot was fired the first shot hit McDonald who spun and fell to the ground as McDonald lay on the ground still holding the knife van Dyke fired more shots into him in total van Dyke fired 16 shots at McDonald in 14 to 15 seconds expending the maximum capacity of his 9-millimeter semi-automatic firearm Van Dyke was on the scene for less than 30 seconds before opening fire and began shooting approximately 6 seconds after exiting his car the first responding officer said that he did not see the need to use force and none of the at least eight other officers on the scene fired their weapons laQuan McDonald was taken to Mount Sinai Hospital where he was pronounced dead at 10:42 p.m. you topic initial police report the initial police portrayals of the incident consisting of about 400 pages of typed and handwritten reports prompted police supervisors to rule the case a justifiable homicide and within the bounds of the department's use of force guidelines the reports did not say how many times McDonald was shot and said McDonald was acting crazed and lunged at officers after refusing to drop his knife Michael D Robbins one of the attorneys representing the McDonald estate said his initial thoughts were that I didn't think there was a case if he had lunged at a police officer adding the police narrative without exception is that the use of force has justified and necessary which it sometimes as one police report described that McDonald raised the knife across chest and pointed it at Van Dyke Van Dyke told investigators that he feared McDonald would rush him with the knife or throw it at him and he also recalled a 2012 police department bulletin warning about a knife that was also capable of firing a bullet as well as throwing knives and also spring-loaded knives capable of propelling the blade one report noted that McDonald's knife was in the open position but when announcing charges against Van Dyke Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez said the knife was found folded at the scene topic medical report according to the Cook County Medical Examiner's Office 'as autopsy report which was revealed by journalist Jamie Calvin through a public records request McDonald was shot in his neck chest back both arms right leg and a graze wound to his left scalp nine of the 16 shots hit McDonald's back and he was shot as he lay on the ground his death was ruled a homicide topic dashcam video 5 police videos of the incident are known to exist including the view from a camera mounted in the marked police SUV that Van Dyke was riding in as he and his partner responded to the scene the videos show that at least eight police vehicles responded to the scene but no video has been released from the other three vehicles Chicago police officers are required to make sure that their video systems are working properly and that they should submit a ticket if they are unable to download digitally recorded data there were no repair tickets requested by any of the three vehicles missing video on the scene that night when video footage was initially released it did not contain audio although Chicago police dashboard cameras should automatically record audio when the video recording is activated according to a CPD video the in-car camera system automatically engages both the audio and the video recording when the vehicle's emergency roof lights are activated and each vehicle has a front and rear camera and microphone city officials initially blamed a technical problem it was later revealed that the audio recording equipment in officer Van Dyke's vehicle had been intentionally damaged according to records from police technicians another cars audio was disabled because the microphones were in the glove compartment with the batteries inserted backwards for another a mobile start up recorder was corrupted and a third was processing other video at the time the Sun Times published that a sergeant reported officers throwing their microphones on the roof of the Jefferson Park police station to the internal Police Review Authority a month and a half before the release of the laQuan McDonald dashcam video in an apparent protest against being recorded Fraternal Order of Police president Dean Angelo defended officers in an interview saying that operator error could be any number of accidents adding things always trickle downhill so it winds up the responsibility of the beat officer god forbid it's the responsibility of the agency you topic Burger King surveillance video there was also a security camera at a nearby Burger King restaurant that may have captured the shooting but during the time of the shooting there is a gap of 86 minutes in the recording the manager of the restaurant said that on the night of the shooting five Chicago police officers gained access to the video and passwords on the equipment and that by the time the Independent Police Review Authority requested to view the footage the next day it had been erased The Tribune later obtained footage showing a Chicago Police employee working on the restaurants computers after the shooting however according to FBI sources the video taken from the Burger King surveillance camera was not altered and there were gaps throughout the surveillance video because the system at Burger King was a mess topic five million dollar settlement attorneys for the estate of laQuan McDonald entered into negotiations with the city of Chicago to settle claims arising out of his death the Chicago City Council approved a five million dollar settlement to MacDonald's family on April 15 2015 although the family had not yet filed a wrongful death lawsuit emails from the mayor's office surrounding the case later revealed the settlement deal was finalized the day after the mayor of Chicago Rahm Emanuel secured his second term by a runoff election part of the settlement agreement required that the video be sealed until investigations were completed which could have delayed the release of the video for years aldermen were not shown the dashcam video before approving the settlement although City Corporation Counsel Stephon Patton said the existence of the video influenced the council's decision to settle before a lawsuit and details about the video were given to the Finance Committee during a hearing the decision took only five seconds out of a two-hour 45-minute meeting to approve dick Simpson a UIC political scientist and former Chicago aldermen said it's odd not only in this case but maybe in others that there isn't more debate on the floor because that's where the public gets informed you topic legal proceedings you topic requests for documents you reporters noted inconsistencies between the narrative police told reporters the autopsy and an anonymous eyewitness account before the video was publicly released a whistleblower expressed concern over the handling of the McDonald shooting a few weeks after the shooting revealing that there was a video and that it was horrific to journalist Jamie Calvin and attorney Craig Futterman the pair issued a statement calling on Chicago police to release the dashcam video of the incident the city of Chicago denied at least 15 requests for its release Brandon Smith a freelance journalist and William Calloway a community activist filed a request for the video under the Freedom of Information Act in May 2015 when the request was denied Smith filed a lawsuit against the city of Chicago in Cook County Circuit Court Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan sent a letter to the police department the day before a court hearing stating that they cannot withhold the video she said that they had not substantiated their claim that releasing the video would interfere with an ongoing investigation or jeopardize a fair trial if any officer was charged on November 19th Cook County judge Franklin Valderrama denied the city's request for a stay ordering the video to be released to the public no later than November 25th the city did not appeal the judge's decision on November 24th after a press conference the video was released that showed an officer fatally shooting McDonald you topic investigations a criminal investigation also began weeks after the shooting when the Independent Police Review Authority IPRA forwarded the case to the state's attorney's office and the FBI the US Attorney's Office confirmed on April 13 2015 that they had been conducting a federal criminal investigation of the Macdonald case in conjunction with the State Attorney's Office after contradictions were found between the initial police report and the dashcam video the police report said that McDonald had lunged at an officer but the video footage showed that McDonald made no lunges the video does show that McDonald was swinging the knife in his right hand in a wide but aimless manner as he walked down the street and also appears to show that McDonald turned slightly to look briefly at Van Dyke and another officer who are pointing guns at him but that he continues to walk away from both officers at the moment Van Dyke opens fire on him on December 2nd 2015 Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan asked the US Justice Department to launch a separate civil rights investigation of Chicago police tactics DOJ enlarged the scope of their investigation based on early findings issuing a report in January 2017 see later section on this Topic Van Dyke's trial on November 24 2015 Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez announced that Van Dyke was charged with first-degree murder and Van Dyke turned himself in to authorities he was initially held without bail at Cook County Jail for six days crowdfunding website GoFundMe shut down a page that was set up to raise funds for his legal-defense shortly after it had raised just over ten thousand dollars on November 30th Van Dyke was granted bail set at 1 million five hundred thousand dollars he posted one hundred fifty thousand dollars ten percent of the bail and was released from jail on December 16th Van Dyke was indicted by a grand jury on six counts of first degree murder and one count of official misconduct the six counts of first degree murder were murder intent to kill injure with firearm murder strong probability to kill injure with firearm murder intent to kill injured discharged firearm murder strong probability to kill injured discharged firearm murder intent to kill injured discharged firearm proximately and murder strong probability to kill injured discharged firearm proximately on December 29th 2015 van Dyke pleaded not guilty to the charges Van Dyke's attorney Daniel Herbert said that his client fears for his life a few protesters yelled at him and called him names as he approached the courthouse for his arraignment Van Dyke had a history of complaints in his police career but was cleared in most cases after the arraignment Herbert said he was looking for evidence to clear his clients name On January 29 2016 herbert accused Chicago's mayor of tainting possible jurors as he considered an effort to move the trial outside of Cook County it's been dozens and dozens of comments where rahm emanuel essentially indicted my client he's characterized my clients actions as being heinous without even seeing the videotape so when the mayor of the city in which the pool of jurors as drawn from has taken such an adamant stance it makes it extremely difficult for us to get a juror here who is not predisposed to a finding of guilt if convicted of first-degree murder Van Dyck would have faced a prison sentence of 20 years to life the case marked the first time in nearly 35 years that a Chicago police officer has been charged with first degree murder for an on-duty fatality on March 23rd 2017 the charges against Van Dyke were six counts of first-degree murder and 16 counts of aggravated battery one for each shot fired at laQuan McDonald jury selection began on September 5th 2018 and the trial commenced on September 17th on October 5th 2018 Van Dyke was found guilty of second-degree murder and 16 counts of aggravated battery with a firearm but was found not guilty of official misconduct On January 18 2019 Van Dyke was sentenced to six point seven five years in prison for the second-degree murder conviction alone which is permitted by Illinois law Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul filed a request with the Illinois Supreme Court to vacate Van Dyke's sentence for second-degree murder and impose a sentence on each of the 16 aggravated battery counts the request was denied without comment the Illinois Department of Corrections refused to disclose the state prison where Van Dyke was initially incarcerated to serve his sentence citing safety reasons he was transferred on February 5th 2019 to the Federal Correctional Institution in Danbury Connecticut during his first week at this facility he was assaulted by other inmates while in the general population sometime after the assault he was transferred to the Federal Correctional Institution Otisville in Otisville New York his current place of encourage in meit locator website you topic trial of March Walsh and gas me On June 27th 2017 three current or former Chicago police officers were charged with conspiracy official misconduct and obstruction of justice connected with a cover-up of the shooting those charged were David March the lead detective in this case Joseph Walsh Van Dyke's partner on the night of the shooting and Thomas Gaffney their bench trial began on November 27 2018 and a verdict was expected by January 15 2019 On January 17 2019 they were acquitted of the cover-up charges you topic reactions to video you topic protests you topic November protests after the release of the video on November 24 2015 a few hundred people blocked the intersection of Roosevelt and Michigan Avenue in protest on November 25th 2015 more protests were held on the second night of protest marchers tore off lights from a public Christmas tree in Daley Plaza and multiple marchers were arrested on Friday November 27th a major day for Christmas shopping in the u.s. a group of protesters chanted sixteen shots and other slogans while marching on Michigan Avenue the city of Chicago's central shopping district this caused some businesses to shut their doors and the police closed Michigan Avenue a six-lane Street topic December protests a 16-hour sit-in at the Cook County Building on December 3rd 2015 proceeded after Alvarez refused to resign on December 2nd protests erupted in the loop after mayor Emanuel called a special council meeting to apologize for his slow reaction to fix problems within the Chicago Police Department on December 24th a month after the video had been published protests disrupting Christmas season shopping were again held on Michigan Avenue protestors also stood in the alley behind Emmanuel's home the last three days in a row in December promising to continue for 13 more days to symbolize the 16 shots McDonald took from police in an effort to force a Manuel to resign on New Year's Eve protesters temporarily took over parts of City Hall and the Hyatt Hotel lobby chanting Brahm gotta go topic January protests over 100 african-american pastors boycotted the 30-year tradition of the Rev Martin Luther King jr. interfaith breakfast hosted by Chicago's mayor Reverend Matthew Ross did attend the breakfast but he interrupted the proceedings when he stood up and began to chant 16 shots and the cover up the day after Martin Luther King jr. Day about 200 black youth project 100 Chicago chapter members dressed in black t-shirts with the words fund black futures written across them blocked the entrance of the Chicago patrolman's Federal Credit Union in an effort to protest the Fraternal Order of Police is advocacy of the Chicago Police Department city officials continue to deal with the aftermath of the McDonald shooting and are working to change the long-standing policy of keeping police shooting video under wraps protesters chanted 16 shots and a coverup as officer van Dyke walked into court for a status hearing on January 29th 2016 topic February protests laQuan McDonald protesters hijacked a rally to support Apple's decision to fight back in the FBI Apple encryption dispute in front of the Apple store on Michigan Avenue On February 24th 2016 protesters started chance against Alvarez and Emanuel but the crowd dispersed after several in the crowd got into a shoving match with police topic March protests a rally started at state and Jackson consisting of less than 50 people on March 2nd 2016 to mark 500 days since the shooting of laQuan McDonald other protesters were arrested for blocking the flow of traffic on Adams near Michigan Avenue topic threat by Jabari Dean on Sunday November 29th 2015 Jabari Dean a student at the University of Illinois at Chicago posted an online threat to kill 16 unspecified white males one for every shot fired at McDonald plus any white police officers who might intervene at the University of Chicago the University announced that classes would be canceled the next day the same day the FBI arrested Dean who was charged with transmitting in interstate commerce communications containing a threat to injure the person of another federal prosecutors stated they did not believe Dean had the means to carry out the attack he had threatened the federal charge was later dropped against Dean topic other reactions on November 25th senator and presidential candidate Bernie Sanders released a statement sending condolences to MacDonald's family and criticizing the Emanuel administration and Chicago's police force chance the rapper referred to the shooting on Saturday Night Live on December 12 2015 he would refer to the shooting again on his second appearance on the show with Kanye West on February 13 2016 on june 2nd 2016 vic mensa released a song entitled 16 shots referring to MacDonald's death topic aftermath you topic the Chicago police accountability task force on December 1st 2015 rahm emanuel created the chicago police accountability task force led by then-president of the Chicago Police Board Lori Lightfoot to review the system of accountability oversight and training that is currently in place for Chicago's police officers the task force's final report published April 13 2016 find racism and systemic failures in the city's police force validating complaints made for years by african-american residents you topic firing of Superintendent Garry McCarthy a manual fired Superintendent Garry McCarthy on December 1st 2015 under political pressure from protesters McCarthy knew of the dashcam video a few weeks after the shooting and stripped officer van Dyke of his police powers due to the IPRA investigation underway McCarthy could not fire the officer nor discipline him or put him on a no pay status McCarthy refused to resign so Emanuel fired him topic calls for Anita Alvarez's resignation Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez was criticized by political challengers and others for the delay in the release of the dashcam video which she viewed weeks after the shooting and the long wait to charge van Dyck for MacDonald's death this took more than a year and was completed only hours before the court-ordered release of the video she faced a difficult primary election in March 2016 calls for her resignation came from within her own party including Cook County Board president Tony prick Winkle as of December 2nd 2015 Alvarez had refused to resign which prompted a 16-hour sit-in by protesters at the Cook County Building on December 3rd 2015 Alvarez said she had been cooperating with the FBI investigation since November 2014 and asked her critics why she would call in the FBI if she was attempting a cover-up she also defended Mayor Rahm Emmanuel's comments that it would be premature to release the dashcam video in light of the investigation saying it was in the best interest of the investigation Kim Foxx a former prosecutor running against Alvarez with support by Jesse Jackson and other civil rights leaders disagrees by waiting so long to press charges in this case state's attorney Alvarez has done the McDonald family and the entire criminal justice system a heinous disservice she waited until her hand was forced by intense political and media pressure surrounding the release of this painful video she waited even after City Hall was prepared to pay the McDonald family five million dollars in damages Alvarez lost her bid for re-election in March 2016 earning 29 percent of the votes Kim Fox won with 58% of the votes you topic calls for Rahm Emmanuel's resignation mcDonald's killing occurred four months before Emanuel faced a difficult campaign for re-election in February 2015 he failed to win the majority and was elected by 56% in a runoff election the first in Chicago's history against hey-zeus Chuy Garcia the delayed timing of release of the video the Chicago City Council's awarding the family five million dollars within weeks of McDonald's death and Emanuel firing Police Superintendent Garry McCarthy prompted some commentators to accuse the city of cover-up journalist Ben jurafsky wrote in the Chicago Reader just imagine mayor Emanuel had released the video in say November 2014 without being forced to by a lawsuit but of course he didn't do the right thing he buried the video he allowed officials to mislead the public he hid the tapes because most likely he assumed it would hurt his re-election campaign thus he not only did the immoral thing he did the politically stupid thing Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez probably would have quickly responded with an indictment just like she did earlier this week when the tape actually was released I mean it's really hard to look at that tape and not call for an indictment if the mayor had done that he wouldn't be the villain in this sordid story he'd be the hero or at least the guy who finally for once in his life did the right thing Emanuel has since created the task force on police accountability to review current training and oversight for Chicago's police officers he also maintains he never saw the dashcam video until it was publicly released and will not resign a Manuel's image received a blow when US District Judge Edmund Chong accused City Attorney Jordan Marsh an attorney who handled cases in the office that represents the city in police misconduct lawsuits of hiding evidence in a fatal police shooting there is no legal mechanism to force a Manuel's resignation State Representative Lashon K Ford filed House bill 4356 to set up the mechanism for a recall election but it was not past Illinois Republican Governor Bruce rauner said he would sign such a bill topic video released of shooting of Ronald Johnson three on December 1st 2015 the city announced that there was a video of a fatal police shooting that took place on October 12 2014 Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez's office investigated possible criminal charges against officer Jorge Hernandez whose name was revealed on December 7th who shot Ronald Johnson three in the back during a foot chase the officer opened fire seconds after arriving on the scene when Johnson was moving away from police johnson was allegedly a known gang member and also allegedly armed a gun was recovered at the scene the attorney for Johnson's family contends police planted the weapon the city fought to keep the video of the incident secret so as not to jeopardize the officers right to a fair trial should he be indicted as in the McDonald case the video lacks audio the city released the video on December 7th due to pressure for transparency prompted by the McDonald case no charges have been filed against Hernandez topic de-escalation and taser training on December 30th 2015 Emanuel announced sweeping reforms within the police department including new police training for handling tense situations and equipping every officer with a Taser to be used to control suspects all officers were to be equipped and trained by June 2016 officers at the Macdonald scene were waiting for a Taser to arrive before Van Dyke shot the suspect at that time 21.5 percent of officers had been trained to use a Taser Dean Angelo president of the Chicago chapter of the Fraternal Order of Police said on the subject I know there are people on the job for nine or ten years who have not been trained I can't say they have all requested training but I am sure some have it's very hard to get the proper training as a Chicago police officer and that's something that has been going on for a very long time there is certainly a percentage of my members who believe that the Chicago Police Department doesn't offer the same level of training or the same opportunities to obtain training as many other police departments in the country I think the general attitude as that's just welcome to the Chicago Police Department topic emails from the mayor's office released on December 31st 2015 3085 pages of emails split across seven PDFs regarding the McDonald case and other police related matters were obtained under the Illinois Freedom of Information Act the timing of the release on New Year's Eve has been described by reporters as strategic the exchanges show that the mayor staff had been communicating with both the IPRA in the office of the Cook County State Attorney since the October 2014 shooting they document fact gathering and news monitoring to crafting a unified message on how to respond to media inquiries regarding the McDonald shooting the emails included several highly redacted speech drafts to use if the video was released prepared nearly a year before the release of the dashcam video which Emmanuel's top aides knew existed the emails also cover the topics of discrepancies between the police reports and dashcam video the lack of audio on the dashcam videos which senior mayoral advisor David spiel Fogle noted the number of malfunctions seems a bit odd express exasperation with statements made by the IPRA note the missing Burger King footage and reports on protests and social media activity all of which is highly redacted the media characterized the emails as calling into question the independence of the Independent Police Review Authority IPRA an agency approved by Chicago City Hall in 2007 to investigate allegations of police misconduct and made up entirely of civilian members aides to the mayor have responded that the communications were routine and did not interfere with the IPRA s investigation Scott and O the former head of the IPRA who was fired by a manual in December concurred that the mayor's office never interfered in the agency's investigations he said we were generally asked to clear every messaging or release to the press I really think if I'd been allowed to be more responsive to the questions that were posed it would have cleared the air a lot sooner Adam Collins a spokesperson for the mayor has defended the mayor's office to the media saying the mayor's office obviously does not direct investigations nor are any employees involved in those investigations in a May 26th email to Janie Roundtree deputy chief of staff for Public Safety Collins wrote against my recommendation IPRA has already provided this response that was a little antagonistic I've asked that they follow up with this as well to soften and reinforce their message the emails also reveal communication from the mayor's office with influential religious leaders Reverend Jesse Jackson and father Michael Pfleger asking them to soften their critical remarks on the case and explain the city could not fire officer van Dyke due to the IPRA investigation several persons including streets blog Chicago reporter Steven Vance Chicago teachers union member Luke Carmen and Twitter user Natalie solidarity and others collaborated on an effort to catalog the documents for easier access by readers you topic documents from 2005 incident in May 2016 CNN revealed documents of a 2005 incident in which Van Dyck had written a police report without speaking to any of the personnel or witnesses at the scene of another police shooting records of the investigation indicated that Van Dyke had also inappropriately thrown out the original documents pertaining to the case topic two recommendations that officers be fired on august 16 2016 inspector Joseph Ferguson recommended that ten officers be fired this is followed on August 18 2016 by superintendent Eddie Johnson recommendation that seven police officers be fired for false or misleading statements made about the incident topic 20:17 DOJ report an agreement for oversight of city police DOJ announced the completion of their investigation and issued a scathing report in early January 2017 noting problems in a police culture of excessive violence especially against minorities and lack of training and oversight DOJ and the city have a preliminary agreement to undertake broad reforms for improvement with the goal of increasing the safety of both citizens and officers it noted the department's improvements such as training and escalation to avoid use of force issuance of Tasers officers wearing body cameras and the reshaping of a police oversight body also in January 2017 the city and DOJ signed an agreement in principle to work together with community input to create a federal court enforceable consent decree addressing the deficiencies uncovered during the investigation an independent monitor who has yet to be chosen will oversee compliance in February 2017 US Attorney General Jeff Sessions signaled that the Trump administration would pull back on federal civil rights probes of local police departments he would not commit to enforcing the consent decree signed by Chicago and the Department of Justice in June 2017 mayor Emanuel backed off his commitment to enter a court enforced agreement with the federal government he said that an independent monitor selected by the city could work with the Justice Department to pursue police reforms without court oversight later that month a group of civil rights organizations filed a federal lawsuit seeking court enforcement of police reforms also in June Tony Priyanka the president of the Cook County Board of Commissioners and hey Seuss Chuy Garcia another member of the Cook County Board advocated for judicial oversight as did Chicago Inspector General Joseph Ferguson in August 2017 Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan filed a lawsuit in federal court requesting that a judge oversee police reform in Chicago in July 2018 Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel and Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan announced a proposed court settlement that was the first draft of a consent decree that would eventually serve as a court enforced mandate governing reforms of the Chicago Police Department topic documentary films the blue wall as a documentary film about the shooting of laQuan McDonald and the subsequent police cover-up it was directed by Richard Rowley and produced by Jacqueline suhan and Jamie Calvin it premiered on May 1st 2018 at the hot docs Canadian International Documentary festival in Toronto on May 14 2019 it was announced that another documentary film titled 16 shots will premiere on June 14 2019 on Showtime topic see also list of killings by law-enforcement officers in the United States October 2014 skullcap Cru | wikipedia tts | UClqS6IYGeofUnMEBJmSzf2g | 2019-07-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 6,056 | 36,318 |
Ga_kNyptkqI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ga_kNyptkqI | Green Coding - Measuring energy use of arbitrary applications and software stacks (EN) | all right I think we're good Dora is kind of close so I will start and people might be dropping in um yeah so hello everybody I'm Arna I'm the founder of green coding Berlin and I will be presenting today an open source tool which which you can measure arbitrary software so I don't know if in which talks you have been today so far but I for instance have seen a talk where there was a lot about software upload and how software is not efficiently designed because we live in the scaling economy and stuff like this so I will be talking mostly today about just measuring and about transparency of software in particular okay so first of all the slide what so what is the green Matrix tool that's the title of the talk already given is an open source software tool that is able to measure the energy and in particular also the CO2 consumption of the software that you either as developers have or it can also consume consume a software at somebody else has written it measures typical parameters that you know as developers which is like Network i o but it can also measure stuff like CPU energy it can also measure dram energy it can measure hard disk energy in particular and AC DC power some of you who work with um yeah in German many people have maybe German don't see these terms so it really depends on where you check the signal of the electricity that you want to measure um it measures these according because you some of you are probably developers you know that measuring software is tricky so it measures this with the concept of a standard usage scenario so this is very important for the cause of the talk so this is why I explain it here a bit if you think of a typical software let's say a userland software that everybody uses like telegram or Whatsapp right and you want to compare these two they obviously have different functionalities so it's it's you very easily get in a situation where you're comparing apples to oranges right and the thing with the standard usage scenario in particular is that is you you define a use case or workload that holds true for 80 80 of the users so let's make an example with a word application so you say what do you typically do with the word application you open it you write a one-page document you maybe print it you make some fonts fat you maybe introduce a nice word art or clippy the nice mascot of Windows 95 so something like that which holds true for 90 of the users and this allows you to pair softwares given a use case against each other because it's obviously tricky to compare notepad to word right because they have very different feature sets so that the one application uses more it's kind of typical so this is why we have used the concept of a standard usage scenario which actually originates from the work around the Blue Angel for software if you're if you know that the tool has a visualization on board because you want to see aggregate metrics you want to see changes over time and it has an API on board which I will talk about later because we pictured as an open API later on that everybody can carry data from um the question also arises why why did we build the green metrics tool so here about the technical parts so measuring software and energy consumption was possible before the green metrics tool there are other tools which can do so scafandra can do so tools from the Intel uh install uh Power Gadget can do so AMD has a tool that they are all kind of very isolated very targeted to the infrastructure and not very targeted to software developers in particular so our goal is to make it as easy as running a CI CD pipeline so you just fire it off you can reuse infrastructure files that you already have so I come from a web perspective so I think about development processes very often I think about Google Lighthouse which makes it easy to see if your website is performing well we want to have the process um not exactly like this but we won't have it as easy as that measuring software is complex so best practices for measuring are typically tough so many people are probably here engineering students are at the two building or have studied engineering before so you know that measuring can be very tricky because you have to cater for very strong and fixed boundary conditions because if you just put a program on this machine I absolutely cannot compare it to anything else on any other machine before I know the boundary conditions where I'm in so we create our tool to set them for you basically based on Research or empirical best practices why did we build a green Matrix Tool Part Two um comparing software is complex so this is what I shared before basically when talking about Telegram and WhatsApp so software must be classified and attributed automatically because I can make these use cases with very specific softwares but when I will I mean given the plurality of software that there are millions of different softwares out there everybody has to classify it manually so this is obviously not working so the framework has to do it for you so it has to identify what the software generally does to put it in same baskets with different software to make it at least comparable given certain boundary conditions uh we're measuring the transparency on the energy consumption uh sorry we're missing transparency on the energy consumption of software so the dream with our tool is that because it's open source and will when people would use it and measure their software you will have an idea of what a typical application consumes so probably nobody of you knows by firing up word how much word actually consumes in terms of energy and what kind of CO2 this is however you might know it for your car because typically or at least for some people a buying decision you might know it for your fridge at least you might know the energy rating of your fridge but you don't don't do this for software coming back to this later so what is the concept of the tool so before I dive into screenshots I have to talk a bit dry stuff and then we see actually some some stuff which some of you can probably better relate to um by catering for these boundary conditions that I told before what we do and I will just go quickly over it and we can talk about it later so so we think we have quite an ample time for Q a is we package a software and containers so we leverage some functionality that Linux has on board to isolate the applications as good as we can and to get the most reproducible metrics as good as we can for people who are not developers I try to put it here in a graphic that makes you understand of what a web application is comprised of so if you use something like Eco grader or you use something like website carbon many couple of people maybe know it as a service where you plug in your website just the URL it's a form box and it tells you okay by going to this website you would you have produced or there was an end budget occurred of 0.5 grams of carbon right because all the electricity the network transfer Etc adds up to a certain carbon budget what this only tells you these tools is only this right part so it only tells you what the browser is sending to you in terms of network however as probably everybody of you knows there is also a server that actually delivers this website so here we're talking about the left part so when we talk about benchmarking or measuring an application with our tool we always want to look at the whole distribution that is possible so here we're talking about a very easy distribution it's just a front end part so the right part the Chrome browser and it's a server part so here we're talking about database which stores the data whatever you're looking at let's say you go to Facebook so that the posts and everything is in there and a server that's basically delivering the data in a format that the browser can understand and our tool orchestrates all these three containers isolates them from each other queries these metrics separately that you need to understand what is actually going on there and also to need to get the energy and it puts them in Docker containers this is a I would say technicality here in particular but the isolation is the important part and also the firing it up and firing it down because then you can also see when the application starts so boot Chimes obviously face and when it Cycles down going one slide further I'm going to keep it short because I know people hate uml diagrams in general but what you can see on the left side is that there is something ingested so you have architecture files that you typically use Docker files you have kubernetes files which I have to say kubernetes is not yet supported but coming to the later on but you will have at some point kubernetes you can consume a Docker compose file or it can also technically consume a terraform file or whatever you feed in whatever you already have and then you give it a flow that you typically also already have so people typically have unit tests of some sort they have end-to-end tests either in selenium called section whatever session replays you can think of it whatever you already have for your application typically to keep the quality of the clip application in check but you can feed that indirectly because it typically you test what you believe is important and what people typically use in your application so this is what you also have to look where the most energy uh where the least energy should be drawn then it's put into the green metrics tool so this is our logo extremely creative you probably have seen these brackets before and it orchestrates these containers containers are measured and then this is basically the metrics that you that you want to collect and it puts it out into apis so I think the most important point that you see here is that stuff is ingested so we try to reuse stuff that developers already have so not create another very complex tool and everything we output comes out as a posix stream so you can feed it to a file you can feed it to a grafana dashboard you can feed it to an API wherever you want to choose every one of these reporters is separately reusable if everybody thinks and you're also happy to contribute I'm coming on this later if you think hey I can do this better I want to reuse something from it you can reuse the components all open source every free to free to use so how does the output actually look like and what is presented to maybe non-extremely technical users but more like people in a management domain so to say I'm coming to normal users also later on so here is what the output looks like if you just look at the compound metrics so typically this is metrics you typically get from profiling applications right you get to network IO you get the memory average and you get the CPU load and these are metrics that are also I would say easy to get technically measuring is the values are typically known every one of you knows kilowatt hours this is just milliwatt hours so it's divided by a thousand and another thousand then you you obviously can guess software incurs very lower values compared to like a vacuum which directly hits with one kilowatt hour sorry with one kilowatt if you let it run for an hour and here you see that this is the energy budget of the CPU this is the energy budget of the memory of the dram this is the memory budget of the network for people who have never seen how that network has an energy budget this is typically done when you say there's transfer happening and because it has to go through through routers it has to maybe go over a satellite it has to go to um uh through basically Network components of any kind they are plugged into electricity uh into the electricity grid so they obviously have a network have an energy budget entailed to them this one you cannot measure directly you have to use a formula and the way you typically go is you take the kilowatt hour sorry the kilobytes or the gigabytes transferred you multiply it with a constant or with a dynamic Factor you can get them out of papers you can get them out of databases and then you have an idea of what on average a network request would consume that has gone back and forth we make compound metrics out of it I think this is um pretty clear you can add up CPU and memory and then you get to here right so I think this is very easy understandable but also we measure at different points so so these measurements here we get directly from the CPU there is a modern Intel CPUs and an AMD CPUs and nowadays also in many arm CPUs there is a kind of like a voltage regulator on the CPU which can tell you how much the CPU is currently consuming these values we measure outside of the system so this is the AC power this is what you directly get from the wall plug so this is what you maybe have seen in your house when you want to say hey how much is my microwave using and you just plug this thing from Amazon on which is 20 euros or so so we have this kind of like cable through the PC in our lab but it gives the same reading and ATX energy is basically if you look at the main board after the PSU it's a technicality I just wanted to tell you if you look at the numbers here and you get the CO2 out of it which basically comes out of the electrical energy so you lose electrical energy as a proxy you look at your grit where you currently are so let's say I am here in Berlin so we have a mixed grid so I would use a higher factor to get from kilowatt hours to energy if I'm in France I have a nuclear energy I'll use a lower factor and this Factor you get out of an API um here you see also another part of the tool which basically tells you some overview metrics um so I think the most important takeaway part is here is the duration and that we pin repositories so we picture that every software that is open source or in some form of repository should be measured and should be directly visible to other people okay at this point in time sorry at at this point in time I will be looking at this repository and then I know what exact version of the software was measured what we could make here on top is also the hash of the current GitHub commit which would make it easier for developers but but you already have all the information that you need just looking at this to say okay this is what was measured and here we have measured A reproduction measurement of the Blue Angel for ocular Blue Angel is a software certificate I don't know of a talk by Jens gruga for instance today has already happened so he has been talking about that and we've just reproduced the measurement with our tool to show that it's capable of um doing the certification process so yeah the certificate pinning is important part that you can look okay this is the software version that was measured and I can falsify myself so you don't have to trust our tool and the readings that it uh puts online on the free data open API database this is a typical graph you get out of it so as I said in the top left charts obviously I think the charts itself doesn't tell you much but it tells you that here is the CPU utilization measured on container level a CPU utilization on a system level and there is also another chart which then gives you the energy and what I've done here in particular and it will cycle back and forth a bit is that you can see that energy and utilization is very similar but it does not necessarily align always so it can be depending on what instruction the processor issues or if there's currently a hold on the processor like if it's currently fetching memory and cannot really do instructions you will get some deviation in these charts which depending on which granular granularity you want to measure on can be important for what you're doing um you see here some other metrics which basically take away message here is and I said this before you have these plugins in our tool and you can also write a plugin yourself it's usually just 100 to 200 lines of code to get these metrics from somewhere and you can hook it into the tool and it will generate a graph out of it for you which basically displays the usage over time for this specific resource so here CPU utilization memory total memory energy for replmsr this is this thing on the CPU the voltage regulator that I've been talking about etc etc um what kind of applications are supported with tool in particular so the application that the tool currently supports is a desktop application like Firefox it is put in this container they have told before but from there on you can use it normally so you can feed it any URL it has to go to you can also give it a plugin Etc and then get an energy budget out of it it can take in command light applications this is particularly interesting because this also means that machine learning models are directly included so if you've ever worked with python it typically is just a call on the command line so this is what our tool can directly use and directly generate all this data from you if you just you just have to give it one line where it shall call the application it will fire up all the containers for you and you can obviously use web applications because this is where I came from and with the idea for the tool was originally born so here you have to do a bit more for the infrastructure file because you have to tell which server to use which image and how they are connected but as said before you might have these files already because it can consume a standard Docker file Docker compose file sorry what can you do with it in terms of analysis so I've told you now okay these charts are coming out of it but what are we for instance looking in particular when we generate an application report right it's not just for a certification process I want to do something actionable with it as a developer so different code different Scopes so for a machine learning application that typically runs I don't know how big models couple of you build but the machine learning apps can run for a couple of days so typically you utilize all the resources anyway as much as you can so your CPU runs at 100 all the time you can just come in it's no problem you can also walk here behind me if there's any if this is a fit um yeah so for machine learning episode for running code you typically want to just get the energy budget you just want to know okay how much does it even cost to run one training on my machine learning model or how much does inference on my model cost because oftentimes people don't really know they know what they are built by the cloud providers but they don't know the energy budget that is entailed with it and we believe that it becomes more important over time and we want to create also a tool that can bring this transparency in the world so just people know and Society can make a decision on it whatever that means I mean it can be that it's okay for machine learning model to consume 1000 terawatt hours if it has the right use case right for web applications it's typically important to identify idling systems so this is where if you're a web developer is a concept like serverless typically comes into play so people should use serverless in order to get this idle time down but our application can tell you how bad it is really that your machines are constantly idling and you're not cycling your machines down and where in the application workflow these idle times actually occur for algorithms it's important to understand how your code behaves if your system is differently configured so here it comes into play what I told before that if you want to measure on a very high granularity then it is important to really not only look at CPU utilization create an idea of the energy from it but look at how your application behaves when it's configured differently for instance our tool shell it currently consumes just part of it but it shell consumes all the typical parameters you have to set to make your measurement reproducible so a CPU typically Cycles up and Cycles down the frequency all the time it can go into turbo boost so it can even use a bit of more energy for a certain period of time to make like for instance making the monitor like flipping it up and your PC responds directly this typically has a bit of an energy cost because CPU can go into a turbo State very quickly to be very responsive but there's also more to the equation what is CPU in terms of features has that come along with it so here you see a typical memory anomaly that you would typically not get out of a formula so the typical formula that's currently used in the cloud is the more memory you use and here you see that the memory budget goes up um the more memory you use the more energy you will consume so you multiply multiply it with a constant Factor this is how it's done in tools like Cloud carbon footprint or in the teets engineering model if you've heard that it's some models that people use to measure Cloud energy at the moment because we don't have many sensors available in the cloud but you would expect the same qualitative shape on the right side because you see here this is memory energy and this is just memory total so here you see a very different curve so this is what what I also these curves can can align this is not atypical that they align but this is kind of a memory anomaly you would say because you use more memory but actually the energy of the memory is not really consumed because so so you you now have to drill down what the what the case here is in particular but it's mostly because memory is reserved but there is no rights or reads happening in this one particular then you have here A system that kind of has a creep over time so you see here that although I'm running a constant load in terms of CPU um which is not given here but um you have to take my word that there is a constant CPU load behind it is that the memory typically goes up over time so the energy goes up over time which is a normal feature of a CPU so the CPU gets hot there's a quadratic function for the transistors for a hot system to use More Voltage and in turn more amps but then it also goes down a bit and this is because some instructions are already cached so so you're still using High CPU utilization to query all the information but you you typically don't have to um don't have to do costly compute anymore this is our current understanding of this code in particular what I don't want to give you here is an explanation why stuff is happening but I will give I want to give you a view of how our tool can use to spot something here and say okay what is actually going on here and is this even relevant even right because we're also talking maybe not about strong jumps here in in the data that you're seeing but you wouldn't have seen this before if you don't measure the energy over time what your code is actually doing because the CPU utilization was constant so you see here that there is a difference in this one in particular um going to the example that I had before with the service in particular as you configure web servers are mostly idle right they are provisioned to have to handle a peak load but not always people are going to the website and using it constantly however there can be another case which is quite confusing actually what we have here measured is that you see here this is how a green metrics tool displays it every color is a part of the front end back end Tuple that I've told you before so blue is actually the web server which serves the HTML data green is the Puppeteer container so this is the browser this is Chrome and yellow is the database and red is the nodes so this is the stuff that you see here so you would expect that if you make a request right so the browser has a peak so we are looking at CPU utilization here so the browser has a peak in terms of utilization so something is happening on the browser and then the server responds and it fetches something from the database and then displays it to the browser and the browser renders the page so this is basically what happens here and then here is the next page coming and here you would expect that here after the request has happened the system should go to idle right the browser is actually going to either a browser that's not doing much so a bit of here but it's so minimal um but why is the web server constantly drawing CPU utilization so what is it doing I actually don't know maybe there's also a good reason for it um having a web being a web developer for 16 years now I don't know the good reason so it's it's but it's still interesting I mean Apache is usually a solid web server so I would be curious of what's going on here but this is where I would be looking at um if I were the developer and what we also want to do with the tool is that we want to have users and developers challenging the developers and asking what is your tool actually doing here I mean do you have a good reason fine but why do you use energy all the time if there's really nothing happening is is this is this for the good or is this for the worst could be pre-fetching resources right could be doing something very logical but it could also be like bad code so this is what you can for instance do with our tool and this is what you then can do as a user related on when you want to spot problems in the application or why your battery is currently draining if you look into mobile what is our vision for the tool so basically the roadmap that we want to have features coming in over the next couple of months um or even longer so first of all technical features so we currently don't have Android application and Windows support quite interesting but since Android applications are already very optimized this was not the first thing that we've been looking at distributed application which basically power most of what we have on the infrastructure Cloud side at the moment so typically um yeah no relevant application is only run on one single node right because we have to look at distribute applications in particular we can do this currently in Docker setups so if you use Docker swarm for instance or typically easy Docker container service this one works but kubernetes for instance doesn't work and and other very strong distributed systems don't work so this is what we want to look at inline reporting is very important so I would really make a decision as a developer on a uh on a software just looking at the guitar repository and seeing a batch okay this software uses uh for just its testing process let's say one one ton of CO2 a day because it runs a thousand times a day it's very large code base and it runs two or three pipelines in parallel for instance question for it if I were to know that right so we want to make our tool to be pluggable in something like GitHub actions so where do you see ICD pipelines typically run or as a gitlab reporter where you can get an awareness of the testing costs uh we want to have energy splitting on the process level I talked about this technicality before so currently we split the um the energy by time on a um for the energy we get from the CPU so you get the total energy of your system and you have to split it by time to account for only the process but also splitting on an instruction level is very interesting if you want to have the tool used in more granular environments so this is a very strong technicality but I thought interesting for people who are a bit deeper in the in the material and we want to at some point like this is the Finish Line so to say we want to provide recommendations for energy optimizations automatically so without you having a background uh in this field and looking at the charts and knowing exactly what is going on to see okay this is what I can do better the way that Google Lighthouse does it at the moment it tells you hey you're requesting this resource five times although I've already seen it on the first page you don't have to do that this is what we want to do in our tool also providing developers with answers so our tool is is mostly tailored to developers at the moment but we want to shift to users at some point we'll talk about developers now first so a typical developer question that comes up that we see in our meetups here in Berlin is that people ask okay I can do static website but how much do I actually save compared to Wordpress or I know about graphql but is it so much better than rest just looking at the energy I mean we've heard about response times can be farther and you don't over fetch but actually I I don't know like can you tell me is flask better than fast API like if if you're using flask or if you're using fast API they are mostly identical for my use cases I've used them before both are Frameworks where you can make an API with um so how do I decide if all the boundary conditions are equal and I'm free to choose the most energy efficient framework how would I know the data is currently not out there and there is also not that many tools that can measure energy in general and we believe that our tool can be an answer for developers to answer this question and graphql I had it before this is for instance one question and here you see that's the first question that we have tried to answer so we have made a case study on our website where we have built an identical site once with a static site Builder so something that if you don't know what for instance WordPress does exactly wordpress's blogging platform fetches the data from the database every time you request if it's not particularly configured but in the default mode it fetches the data every time you visit the page it generates the dynamic page all the time a new the template all the time in you and if you use a static site it just spurts out just just reading from the file system just words or the file as HTML and this is what is called Hugo so this is the system we have been using and here you see WordPress so what you see here on the right side is that for one request on a page WordPress consumes the amount of energy in and I think the value is joules here that we're looking at but even if we were kilowatt hours at the the relative ratio counts so let's say it's joules because this is also very um this makes sense that is 10 joules um you see here that you you need to use 10 joules just to deliver one page with WordPress however if you have a static site you are at around 1.5 joules one Fair Point you have to say in order to generate a static site you have to build it at some point right it's just not there like WordPress all the time so WordPress generates these sites fresh when a requests come in so you have to pre-create all the possible pages so this here can be um can even go a bit up if you have like 10 variants of your web page that could be handled by this request in particular but the important takeaway in Massachusetts for our system in particular where we had I think 30 sub Pages this is the whole build of all 30 sub Pages sorry I confuse requests and built before so build is here left side and this is the actual request so for all the 30 sub Pages this is all the cost that was needed to generate the whole page and then looking at one particularly page one particular page is this bar chart here and you can see the uncertainty range because we've made a couple of iterations can even be so close to zero that our tool could not even measure it given the uncertainty could also be higher to be fair but what you see here is that you can easily generate 30 pages and make a full request when WordPress could not even handle a fourth or a fifth of a request in particular so so this is the energy difference that we're talking about and WordPress is one of the if not even the most used and most distributed web applications that we currently have um what is our reason for the tool for users so providing users answers for you as a user you typically want to say um if I have software given certain boundary conditions or usage scenario how do they how do they compare and I will jump a bit forward because now reading it the question is a bit more too complex I want to show it to you in a picture so if you just look at Telegram and WhatsApp what would be interesting to you is say hey I know telegram uses less Network i o and this is no actual data this is a concept picture so we have not measured anything here but it could be a typical outcome you say hey telegram always advertises it's using less energy and it uses less Network because it saves so much in terms of images caches whatever but in turn it uses more CPU in order to leverage these caches or to unpack data etc etc and this is one possible visualization that could be consumed by a user because I have seen charts like this I don't know if you have seen these charts when I compare mobile phones so when I compare mobile phones and verses.com I see okay it has a it has a bigger battery but in turn it does not have Wi-Fi five and then here it does not have Bluetooth 4 so it don't have to be descriptive values here which maybe are not in your daily life like typically not everybody looks at DC energy all the time but it could also be different values we're saying for sending a message it is at this point for sending it video it is at this point and then you look here to Whatsapp where sending a video is maybe out of the chart but sending a message is maybe lower right and they say hey I'm just sending messages I'm a WhatsApp user or I'm sending video telegrams better it really depends on the boundary condition if you can make these switches but currently you don't even have the data to make the decision so this is what we picture for as a user to consume our data so it will not be non-technical it would it would not be a no-brainer which just just use WhatsApp this is not coming out of it I at least I don't believe that this is possible but if you want to make even though an informed decision our tool will hopefully give this information at some point if people use it as an open source tool and generate and measure these data um Network level anomalies so this is also a bit cryptic now because I want to make it approachable to user I'm probably going to reformulate it in the next iteration of the talk but what you are probably interesting or what's probably interesting for you as a user is just to see how often is my Facebook application or whatever application querying a service like how often is it making update requests is this making every five minutes is this really necessary or is it even going to an ad service instead of just to graph.facebook to fetch the latest messages is it even going to um is it yeah is it fetching ads this is basically what I want to say for instance because this is typically what you don't want to have of your application you want the functionality but you don't want the app you don't want the tracking you don't want the Telemetry and you can see in our tool um if this is really happening constantly or just one time a day or even at all so this is what I mean by transparency and also giving users choices and it can also issue a certificate so the Blue Angel for software is a possible certificate which can uh which could be issued because this one applies some minimum standards that we that the blue engine wants to have for application like it has to um yeah it has to have a minimum amount of energy that it should be using at least in the in the next iteration I've had this chart before so this is hopefully a slide that is better consumable for users so if you if you want to take away something away from the slide what we believe could be the vision of the tool is that you can think of it as the euchar or the code check of software so typically when I um look at something um that I buy from DM or that I buy from Rossman I want to know if there's something in there that I don't want in particular I'm not allergic or so but I don't want microplastics for instance in in my shower gel so this is what you can do with code check kocheck directly tells you yeah if you want to drill down this is all the special income names that is in here but it also tells you with the red flag at the top contains microplastic so so the typical warning signs that people really want to look for this we picture for our tools so a typical warning flag that could be is this software is or this data center of this software are in Poland and Poland runs on cold power so this might be a decision where you say no this is not acceptable for me it's it's okay if you use energy in general but please host it at least somewhere where you have hydrothermal energy where you have solar power so so this is easily digestible it gives you a directly a binary decision basically so you say okay I don't support coal you can also say I don't support nuclear energy if this if this has a different concern for you although it's in this contact of CO2 a positive energy form but this is what we want to have we want to have it at some point as easy as Yuka and code check to make decisions for user just asking is there a more carbon-friendly alternative to my software or is there a software that makes Nest Network request etc etc so this is the end of the talk and as I said before the software is open source and super happy to get contributions or interest for you from you of any kind we do have a Meetup Group here in Berlin where we host free meetups for everybody who's technical or non-technical we have had speakers like Chris from the green software Foundation before the KDE team which basically makes the KDE plasma desktop and they have been talking about their free and open source software approach with the blower angle um and also some other green companies here from Berlin and also talks from us like our projects how they are going along um yeah we're looking for contributors in the tool but also super happy hit me up directly if you're just interested in the concept and want to help me explain more or if you just want to talk to me on uh on green coding in general or something else just also read me on LinkedIn or also write me an email whatever works for you in terms of a tool so thank you very much and I hope we have time for questions thank you [Applause] all right um yeah do you want to hand mics out sure let's do that one microphone which is here so you have to pass it um I would like to ask a little technical question how does it work this is somewhat like a site is like a side container or it does work it's inside of the container I'm currently working or on the host system and the second question there what is missing about kubernetes or what is the difference that this doesn't work or kubernetes over yep so um it works outside of the docker container system so basically the docker containers run all rootless and we are on the host system and we orchestrate these containers so we can control the docker Daemon and orchestrate these containers and then we pull the metrics you can pull them with Docker stats technically we use a different approach we pull them out of the Linux subsystems out of the virtual file endpoints and then we can generate the metrics so we are not forwarding the end point inside of the docker container to measure in there but it could be done scaffolder for instance does like so if you Google up later on scafunder is another tool that can measure energy it does it like so it however cannot do this orchestration part it just can forward this information in the container for you if you control the hypervisor so if you run Q emu somewhere for instance heads now for instance does it you could forward it to the client into the hypervisor so this is what our tool cannot do but it's called 400 for instance can uh coming to your second question can you go again please on the second question based on this technical fix what is missing on on kubernetes so what's the difference there because we have almost the same situation yeah exactly so so the files are very similar just supporting kubernetes would be probably a very minor point the thing is that kubernetes typically um if you control the architecture yourself the change would be very minimal right but this would mean that you have to set up your own kubernetes cluster which people typically don't do so it would be nice if you can use a kubernetes server uh service right so you go to Google use that human needs service and then just use our tool inside of it so to say if if you want to call it like so the problem and this is basically true for all the cloud services at the moment is that all these machines have locked down certain points where we query data from so you cannot read Rebel for instance this is the thing that infill provides the running running average power limit because this is a register in the CPU that is only available in ring zero so you have to have a kernel extension installed in Linux to get this information and this one is typically locked down so what we are doing at the moment before we go this one step further is we're trying to create a machine learning model that can kind of estimate the information of energy based on the utilization metrics right this is what I said before that CPU utilization and energy doesn't always co-align we have to get that first down to make solid predictions of what we are expecting the energy really to be and then we could plug it into the kubernetes service even running inside of the pot so it does not sorry even running inside of the container so it doesn't have to be on the Pod orchestrator level it can then be used inside of the container so this is the problem in general but if you have kubernetes self-hosted you could use the tool thank you very much um I'm not super experienced with the wrapper counters but I thought they only allow for like system-wide measurements and then my question would be um how can you attribute the energy measurements to some such a certain application yeah so um this is what I had before in splitting by time and splitting by energy so an easy way and our tool of this is currently in in the dev Branch it's not in the main branch is that you just say you look at one minute of time you have two kilowatt hours so it's a very strong example here but bear with me so I have two kilowatt hours and I have two applications running right and then I look at the information of CPU utilization and SC okay this application has run for let's say it was one kilowatt hour this application has run for 10 of the time and the other application has run for 90 of the time right and then you would say okay this one is then 100 watt hours for this application and this is 900 watt hours for the other application or for just being being idle right so this is how you split by time this however has the problem that time does not always as a co-aligned with the work that is actually be done so you would assume that the instruction that the processor was issuing has a different energy budget entails right there are there are vector instructions which use very many registers there's a pause instruction there is a no op instruction um so you would say okay it would be nicer to look at the instructions than just at the time because this gives me a more better idea which work has actually been done right because the instruction is kind of the unit of work um yeah so so there's two ways to split it um to be fair I have seen no implementation of instruction splitting so far this is what we're currently working on but you probably need both the way we currently or we also need PSU energy which is the energy that comes into the uh yeah if you don't know what a PSU is I mean it says net style in German so it's basically the thing which converts the AC power to the DC power that the main ball can understand and this one has losses and these losses can be non-linear so they are typically quickly not that strong if your system is running at full power but they make up most of the losses if your system is idling so you need this measurement point you need the measurement point on the main board and you need the measurement point in the CPU directly so this is why we see these two topics as very similar to generate all of these metrics at some point But to answer your question one sentence you can split by by instructions or you can split by time to my knowledge but there might be more okay thanks um thank you for the talk and to questions one is do you or did you measure um stream processing engines yet or do you have a use case for that in your system and the second one is do you plan on including GPU or TPU measurement um well we can include GPU measurements this is I've seen this very often you can do this with the Nvidia API TPU measurements I you email TPU right I'm I don't have any experience in that I don't know if there is to mine this is all A6 right so you need some custom proprietary framework if this even exists I don't know if that exists but very interesting so if you work in that and you see it please shoot me an email and we have not measured stream processing engines but I would encourage you to maybe use our tool to do so and publicize the data so it would be very interesting and what I've not talked about before is you can see this as uh as a second point so if you just want to go after the talk and see something and also see the upload form we basically hosted we host an implementation of our tool on metrics.greencoding.org so you can use it locally as an open source tool it will generate an own web server but if you want to see where we publicize all the measurements that we have done it is on metrics.greencoding.org it looks a bit beta-ish though but you will feel at home if you've seen the slides before all right any else um hello uh well congratulations on the work actually I think it's really awesome I was going I was curious about um asking how will this affect if you are using many micro cloud services for example such as for many like file management it's completely different if you're just sending requests or if you're actually handling files such as using cloudinary or Firebase some stuff like that uh how will this be affected if you're using many Cloud systems and if you are actually able to I think you kind of mentioned it that you are not having completely access to the CPU because the cloud service naturally doesn't give you but how will this be a factor or how can we have like a better outcome about using this uh green column so if you say how is this affected would are you asking me how much the impact of all these Services is that is put on top or if they will react to our measurements I am hosting all the services or if I am using cloud services okay yeah this is a bit hard to tell um and I had it I had this yeah um this is a bit hard to tell and I had a discussion with Adin here in the audience before so if you want to hit him up about Cloud functions and how actually this goes on is is a layer deeper so to say it's not the full service but it's already an implementation of that so there is no data out of there and since most of these services are kind of proprietary we cannot tell so a next interesting step that we want to do is that we want to host at least the function as a service platforms right with which is to the layer deeper so you orchestrate or you set up your own server made out of Amazon firecracker or you set up your own server made of the V8 worker engine from cloudflare and just see how the same application with the same workload the same usage scenario compares to a monolithic instance of Apache with JavaScript engine also as installed right so these two comparisons are super interesting because I'm a big fan of serverless actually but I don't know how much it actually has a game and we've asked Google we have ask cloudflare and they are currently not shared they are not able to share so I think the services are good but they don't want to publicize or they don't even have the data so this is what I can tell you from my personal experience yeah and just curious uh you mentioned that there's a note that's saying what is the server and the database being activated or yeah do you even answer maybe might that be like web sockets or something related in this scenario not it was just a really plain WordPress site WordPress has no web sockets to my knowledge um but even if it is web sockets right why is there data transfer going on all the time um it was not a chat application and there was nobody on the other end so yeah right um yeah so I would kind of love uh the idea to to have this in a CI pipeline running and checking how much energy consumption my code actually has um I mean what would I need to do to have this would I need to have a bare metal machine that actually runs I mean I would need a bare metal machine to have access to CPU voltage apis right yeah so I would have to set up a dedicated machine that runs your software and yeah well there's a couple of ways to do it so last week and I think Max has already left Max from the SAA they hosted the hackathon last week with the um where this topic was strong ongoing and what they provide for instance and I hope they will provide it to everybody in a bigger fashion at some point is that they have a dedicated gitlab Runner so on GitHub you just take an Azure virtual machine and it runs it for you which is quite nice I really love the servers but this one has this lockdown problem so it uses the Microsoft hyperview hypervisor none of these registers is available so what you can do there is you can use a machine learning model with the estimation that we're currently working on so you have to wait a couple of weeks up and then use the model so this will give you a good reading already however if you want to host it yourself you can um plug this in gitlab for instance so in gitlab you can plug in a so-called gitlab Runner and this would be configured the way that it gives you this information and there's currently a project from the sdaa where they try to open source this concept of a gitlab runner so it's basically a Docker orchestrator that forwards the founder and we had the uh you had the question before forwards got founder inside of this container and then you can read Rebel inside of there so it's a privileged container that has this measurement available and then you just have to use one of our reporters and then you have it so it's three Hoops so it's not as easy as we want it to be at some point but this is the current point in time where you could do that so yeah so either you see SCA tool host it yourself plug it into GitHub or wait for the model that we're currently working on does that answer your question otherwise please shoot please show the follow-up but if you forward it into a container then you have the double problem that you also have to calculate the share of the container compared to other Runners doing the same thing on the same machine right the share of a container well I I think the gitlab runner is although it creates a container it's an isolated VM so so this this is on its own uh in general you have this problem so if you think about Heroku right you and you create a machine learning model you have a different operating Pawn that you're on so if your estimate of CPU utilization you can tell what your CPU civilization is but not the one of the whole package which might have 10 cores so this is a problem on its own we're trying to fix that but I can't tell you how good the model is at the moment because we're just Gathering data at this point in time yeah but good question yeah this is some an ongoing problem no actually when I'm in a in a bit processor I can build big images or big Docker builds or small ones which are very heavy for for the network interaction this will also also a figure we should measure it right yeah you could measure it and there is actually a very good PhD thesis from zandro Creighton if you ever looked that up at some point he has measured Docker build process in particular and they're very interesting findings in there not only what you're talking about that the docker cache right you don't you download resources all the time like pip inside of the docker container does not know which packages have been fetched so it always refetches it right this is this is what you mean if you build something with Docker inside of there three years ago I tried it a little bit very naive way just counting my CPU usage and try different page strategies stacked one or Elizabeth yeah if you're five years ago the thesis has actually uh Docker uses ah don't pin me up I think docky is built pack now it's it's a new way of creating these images and there's way more energy efficient than five years ago and this is actually what he talks about in The Thesis so look that up in particular but what you also has found that if you work with Docker you have typically Docker run right where you can just fire up a container from the command line or you can use Docker compose and just these two tools already have a five times energy budget so five times indifference of the energy budget that they use just to start this container not even talking about the build process so there's a lot going in there you could even use pot Man versus Docker and look at this one in particular right because they have different approaches how they build containers so yeah this is an ongoing topic and we are trying to create the data to make this more transparent so you don't have to make this tedious runs all the time but you get an overview picture of how do they generally compare yeah k-r-e-t-e-n if you don't find it just hit me up and I will ask him if I can send you the thesis that I have but here's also a video on YouTube so if you look on YouTube Central Creighton he presents most of the stuff in there in an easy consumable 30 minutes format because the thesis as you can figure a thousand Pages or so how these doctor thesis are yeah all right all right oh no cool time is up um thanks for this very interesting talk and for the hard work you have done very exciting so big Applause to Arnold [Applause] | media.ccc.de | UC2TXq_t06Hjdr2g_KdKpHQg | 2022-10-01 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 10,412 | 54,381 |
8xfKecCyDqU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8xfKecCyDqU | IS BACON OVERRATED? 🤔 🥓 | i i went to freaking uh a brunch place today and i was so disappointed that no one told me there's no bacon at this place like how [ __ ] and no bacon and no salmon i think if you don't have those two things you shouldn't call yourself a branch one like it's just like legally not a lot salmon's good all right man i can't support bacon eaters why what well i don't know if you're capping around because like if there's some things that you can see are the best things you've ever eaten bacon is pretty up high up there like if there was a family feud and they say best things ever eaten bacon's on that list did like you'd get like a good decent amount of points on that yeah and i'm upset about that [Laughter] most undeserved i don't know man like i feel like you're someone's [ __ ] up your bacon maybe you start cooking your own bacon right to how you want to hide all right after i've tried all sorts of things i mean i mean unlucky for you man maybe you just have different uh taste buds your testimony just unlucky that's unlucky right that's so unlucky it's like those people who can't who can't enjoy um what's that um what's that uh the thing that tastes like this so far so korean yeah yeah and those people are unlucky unlucky youth you know what i mean like those people who tastes like so hot unlucky like rough dude like it happens understandable but roughed it it's like that is because they're like oh it's just so fatty and oily this is like in the 50s and so they're like you know what we'll do we'll make it oh yeah it can taste nice eggs bacon that's good intrinsically human level you're not supposed to eat a heavy breakfast yeah even even even tori said it's legally not allowed to be a cafe if you don't have like salmon and megan i rise above corporate city what easy boys don't worry about it don't worry about it don't worry about it boys you oh that's so good oh my god hey oh i killed the operator that's the operator down [Music] quack dead yeah baby you will not kill my allies nice oh okay own that kid own that kid mid mid he's got two kills just absolutely dunked on them that round planted all right one enemy remains all right all right all right [Music] | 42ndAlpha | UCf1005AR_sRfk45kXpF42fw | 2021-11-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 425 | 2,212 |
AJHGOO-rXpQ | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJHGOO-rXpQ | Requirements for a polygraph, lie detector test? What is needed to do a polygraph test? | [Music] you what do I need to do a polygraph test well it's very simple basically you don't need much you just need to be of legal age 18 and older be physically and mentally stable and of course submit voluntarily to the polygraph test now there might be some exceptions to this three simple variables however this is basically what you need to do a polygraph test okay I hope this answered your question but if if you have another question but you have another doubt why don't you visit or look or take a look at the other videos we have on this playlist that might actually answer may be another doubt another question you might have and if not if you can't find the answer to your question please send us an email and we will reply to you as soon as we can just a little message before you go and watch some other video if you want to be updated about the most recent videos we upload the questions we answer the opinions we might have about our industry subscribe and you will be the first one to be informed about the latest videos our most recent opinion subscribe have you okay I don't lie to me don't lie to me should I take out the polygraph oh okay okay subscribe | bearforensics | UCEUsj1vIWFFy22MxjsYCc4A | 2018-09-27 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 226 | 1,174 |
XHTnvNQkyPY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHTnvNQkyPY | ULS 02/24/05: Keeping LA Clean and Healthy: Water and Sanitation | uh i do have a powerpoint presentation powerpoint i'm not used to going first the business i'm in we're dealing the tail end of things so yeah this is backwards that's right um as dr garris said i graduated from lmu uh or from loyola university at the time i won't tell you how many years ago a long time ago well you were one of dr fitzgerald's students right absolutely uh the great dr fitzgerald um with a degree in civil engineering and then pursued a career in environmental engineering and the organization that i work for very similar to a school district it's not part of county government it's a special district for those of you in political science it's a special district governed by the mayors of 78 of the 88 cities in los angeles county for the very specific purpose of of the collection this collection treatment and disposal and as you'll see in a minute some of the slides that i have the reuse of wastewater and also uh involved in solid waste management now what dr garrett didn't tell you was rhonda stalem also in his life prior to being the guru of water for the metropolitan water districts was also involved in the private sector and solid waste management and it's a very fascinating field both wastewater and solid waste management because you are dealing with something that society doesn't want for example on the wastewater side of it to be just cut to it and be frank about it you flush it you want it to go away and you don't want to see it again and when you put it on the curb in the garbage can you want it picked up and you'd like it picked up often you don't want to pay an awful lot and you don't want to see it again and that includes the recyclables that you put out there so from that standpoint in operating the business it is it's difficult because you're starting off with the negative and the challenge is to turn that negative into a positive and there are some excellent technological advances that have allowed us to be able uh to do that now i just got i'm gonna go through this quickly and i i think about ten minutes sure okay let me go through this quickly to lay out both waste water and solid waste for you and start off um yeah go to the next one the the map and it's kind of hard to see uh trying to squeeze in on this map here the names of all of the the 78 cities that we serve that area is los angeles county and there are 88 cities in los angeles county the largest of which is the city of los angeles and they are one of the one of the better run city governments in in in the united states uh and certainly uh dominic's going to talk to you about their responsibilities uh in in water and power for the city of l.a but for everything outside of the city of la essentially it's served by the organization uh that that i head up called the county sanitation districts of l.a county for the specific purpose of handling wastewater and and and solid waste and all of the names of the 78 cities are in there and you can see we go as far north as lancaster and palmdale the fast growing area of the santa clarita valley and if you've been up to magic mountain that's the area that i'm that i'm talking about and then south of the san gabriels all of those colored jurisdictions are these many small large cities long beach torrents or the larger ones pasadena 78 of these cities and it's 25 separate districts and the boards of directors are made up of the city mayors and the chair of the county board of supervisors so um i have a panel of bosses if you will made up of the mayors of these of these 78 cities and it's in law that the mayor sits as the as the representative it can't be the mayor's cousin who happens to be a sewer contractor it's the mayor uh and and there is in some ways a collegiality uh devoid of the politics that you will see in a city council room because they sit there uh talking with their brother or sister from the adjacent city mayor to mayor and so there's more of a business atmosphere that's worked well for us over the years we were founded uh in in 1923 so we've been around for a long long time uh functioning uh as i talked about it we we provide water and wastewater i mean water wastewater treatment and solid waste management let's go to the next slide um click it again for me please there's la county you know the the you give one more click please uh the sewerage system in in gold here is the sewage system of the city of los angeles uh and they're out the ball a lot of you have probably toured or noaa of the hyperion plant which is located just south of the uh western edge of lax runway right off of uh off of imperial highway and they discharged their treated waste water out into santa monica bay proper and it is a massive system and what i refer to here is the cash umbilical cord that ties the city of la proper to l.a harbor in the san pedro area and then click the next one please and then the orange county sanitation districts to the south and then click it again and the inland empire utility agency which handles wastewater treatment in in the san bernardino area and then click it again please and so the rest of that map is filled out by the sanitation districts of l.a county the yellow represents major trunk lines or sewers you've got to collect everything that comes out of your house and then the blue dots represent water reclamation plants and our main facility is located in the city of carson and what water we aren't able to reclaim and reuse is put out into the pacific ocean right off of white's point on the border between rancho pv and the city of l.a go to the next stop now those of you that enjoy looking at grass and the history of of growth and sewers in los angeles county get out of the way here starting in 1940 this top line in yellow represents the amount of sillage well after world war ii you can see the steep growth in the population in l.a county and more growth more people more sewage and so this top line represents the total amount of flow i took the los angeles county and a million people is about 100 million gallons a day so our service area serves about five five and a half million people and one of the things that our organization is exceptionally proud of is that beginning in uh in 1960 we designed and instituted started operation of a water reclamation plant that reclaimed a tremendous amount of water that prior to that time was wasting to the ocean makes good environmental sense and as ron we'll talk to you later about the metropolitan water districts and trying to find alternative water supplies reclaimed water can be treated to a level where it can be used in fact it's used on this campus for irrigation and you uh you can use it for a number of different groundwater recharge a number of different uses and ever since that plant started we've built an infrastructure of other treatment plants and you can see now the float in the ocean since about uh 1970 has been constant if if in fact it hasn't gone down some so the fact of the matter is all the growth in our system over the last 35 years has been taken up in water reclamation plants which makes as i said good economic sense good environmental sense and then the amount of material being discharged to the ocean has gone down substantially which again makes for good environmental sense however this material has to go somewhere and if it doesn't go to the ocean it's got to be recycled on land the one thing that's uh that's axiomatic in our business uh is it doesn't disappear and and you there's no free lunch you've got to find a way to do it physics no destruction of matter no destruction of matter you can change form but there's no destruction of it let's go to the next one real quick please uh that's the quality of the water that comes out of our water reclamation plants that's not the quality that's not that's water not being wasted to the ocean but this is water actually being reused and it it it meets uh uh essentially all drinking water standards and is uh essentially virus free go to the next one but yet we don't drink it you don't drink and that that um i'll put it this way doctor um that that what was what's in that beaker it says higher quality of a lot of the water supplies along the mississippi river but still there is more of a psychological barrier um health services would say that i'm wrong in stating that that is more than psychological where people don't want to see it in their in their drinking water supply directly but that's okay because there's an awful lot of uses that it that it can be put to where it replaces fresh water supplies now or will replaces where fresh water is being used for example on the irrigation of parks during golf courses there's over 500 sites that we have in conjunction with water supply agencies water distribution agencies that are being used in los angeles county where this water this high quality water is being used go to the next one get through these quicker this is just a pie diagram that gives you an idea of the amount of reclaimed water that is being used in los angeles county for the last uh fiscal fiscal year a year ago 2003-2004 uh 72 000 acre feet of water is actually being reused now that's the water supply of a population of about 350 000 people in rough numbers that is a big community so water reclamation is making a significant contribution as an alternative supply uh and it's not that we can't do a lot more before ron left and we were talking about a lot of things that can be used to broaden their horizons and increase the amount of water by far the majority of it 50 percent of it is in groundwater recharge you allow this water to pond in in sandy areas in the san gabriel rio hondo river and then it gets further natural treatment and goes down through the soil and then augments the groundwater supply uh and then the rest of it is being used in these other other areas landscape agricultural industrial and environmental is like in wetlands so let's go to the next quickly now i want to turn to garbage that's just a quick summary on wastewater where you serve five and a half million people and have this environmental ethic of of of producing this this high quality water and there's a lot more to the whole system and the engineering of it and the politics of it but that gives you i think just a broad brush flavor for it in los angeles county besides producing sewage we produce garbage and in all of los angeles county right now there's about 78 almost 80 000 tons a day of garbage okay that's a tremendous amount of refuse but there's a lot of people almost 11 million people the good news is uh about half of it fifty percent a little over fifty percent of it is actually being recycled and that's the highest percentage in the united states for any state that i'm aware of uh and and a lot of that is because of uh of laws that have been enacted by the legislature a lot of discussion going on as to whether recycling is cost effective but the fact of the matter is it's keeping it out of of landfills because the majority of the refugees disposed of in los angeles county goes to landfills this is just a truck going into one of our sites one of the largest sites in the united states go to the next flight quick this is where all of our sites are operated i showed you a map before that showed all of the water reclamation plants and our treatment plants and this is a where all of our sites are in los angeles county for landfills refuse to energy facilities trash burn plants there's not a lot of those in la county because of the concern for air quality but yet these plants produce an alternative source of energy and that's really important for us let's go to the next slide this is an ariel of of some people would refer to it to a dump as a dump but it's a it's a modern metropolitan landfill it's not a dump because it recovers all of the gas that goes in there's a tremendous amount of recycling that goes on at modern metropolitan landfills there there is not leachate or groundwater pollution because the site uh the more newer portions of the site are lined but there's a lot of technology that goes into developing and uh operating these sites such that they are they're very much environmentally uh sound and sensitive and you can see the kind of contouring that's been done uh to make it as uh as attractive as possible for people passing by this is the polona freeway here out near the 605 that's a the cemetery in the uh the back rose hill cemetery in the back and hussey in the heights community on the left let's go to the next one please we just have completed the uh the construction and the final throws of the construction of a materials recovery facility and this is a facility where when uh the landfill when the trucks come into the landfill if the truck is laden with a lot of recyclables like cardboards things like that then you would divert it to this facility and it'll be processed such that those recyclables will be recovered then the material that can't be recovered is sent back to the landfill let's go the next slide that's the artist's rendering and then the next one is the facility itself just about completed 35 million dollars it's a huge building 200 000 square feet under roof that will handle a bun a great deal of refuse 4 thousand tons of new revenues go to the next one now this is uh the last one that i have because you need to think about the fact that when i showed you this landfill it has a finite life some people would say well you shouldn't be filling canyons but the fact of the matter is it's a it really is a an environmentally sensitive cost-effective way to be able to handle refuse but what are you going to do when we run out of space in l.a county and we're approaching that now well we've embarked upon implementing a system that's going to take refuge from los angeles county by rail to imperial county and the landfill has been permitted so it's going to go in containers in closed containers on a train 200 miles to the south and a landfill will be built in a remote part of of imperial county it's a massive massive undertaking in the construction of the infrastructure and there's still be a tremendous amount of recycling that goes on before the material is ever put in a train so as i'm sure that that ron and dominic are going to talk to you about on the water supply end of it it's it's not just it's not just cost effectiveness but it's a sensitivity to the environment within uh within the existing political structure that brings about uh the the management of these systems and in los angeles county uh including the city of los angeles i think you'll find that it's one of the most advanced systems in the in the united states if not the world so we're going to ask you a lot about the politics of all of this in a second after we get ron and dominic to comment about them so ron please about metropolitan water district and why did why did you leave well i'll get to that i want that um i started at whittier college i graduated from whittier college i had a double major in political science and economics went on to ucla law school where i attended law school with dominic so we've been good friends since that time and really got in the water business once i had spent some time in the central california area i was working for farm workers actually and it became very apparent to me that water is one of the along with energy without water without energy without our key essentials this state has no economy so i became fascinated with water and i was pointed to the metropolitan water district of southern california where i began working early in my career um what is the metropolitan water district i'm going to tell you a little bit about what metropolitan is i'm going to tell you what i think our water supply is here in southern california our outlook of water supply if you will and then i'm going to give you a brief commentary on politics or governance and how it relates to key decisions that have been made and will be made on our water supply in southern california the metropolitan water district of southern california was formed in the 1930 or thereabouts when it was became clear to the city of los angeles and 12 other cities that southern california was going to grow and our existing water supplies was simply not going to meet that growth so they looked to the colorado river and they designed an aqueduct system that brings water from the colorado river all the way to here in urban southern california they built this aqueduct about 242 miles that has been the backbone of metropolitan's water supply as the supplemental water supplier for our region today that that supply is still intact and we've added supplies from what is called the state water project back when governor pat brown was in charge of this state he championed the development of the state water project which brings water from north of the sacramento san juan delta lake oroville through the delta and through various pipes and facilities to central california and southern california so we import through those two main sources about 60 percent of the water that is consumed in urban southern california ventura county los angeles county orange county san diego county riverside county and parts of san bernardino the metropolitan water district a public agency serves about 18 million people every year about 60 percent of the water that's consumed so it's a big big player the metropolitan water district's governance is a 37-member board of directors there are 26 member public agencies the city of los angeles one of the founding members is a it continues to be a member today and they appoint representatives to our board they're appointed that's a key uh point i'm going to make and as i talk about our politics so our board comes together they make the key decisions about water supply investment water rates those kinds of things it is a special district but broad broad powers in providing water for our area so what is our water supply outlook after being at the helm of the metropolitan water district for almost six years i have a pretty good sense and i know it may sound optimistic and the glass is half full but i absolutely believe there are no limits virtually no limits on our ability to serve our population today and for the foreseeable future in urban southern california why do i say that well we are drawing from three watersheds the colorado river yes the colorado river is stressed there's tremendous growth in las vegas and arizona and throughout the colorado river basin but california is entitled to 4.4 million acre feet of water from the colorado river the lion's share of colorado river water the bulk of that today goes to farming in the imperial valley in the urban area we really take a relatively small share but in the future we have the ability to buy water from the agricultural area we've already started doing that tremendous amount of water supply that is there the amount of water that is in northern california is again tremendous dwarfs even the colorado river water supplies we have all the plumbing in place to be able to move that water to urban southern california it's not easy lots of politics but the basic fundamentals are there where else do we have water we have water in urban southern california there is natural runoff from the mountains a tremendous amount today we have really untapped sources jim talked about recycled water we're just we're just beginning to skim the surface of the potential of healthful sanitary use of reclaimed water we have conservation we have many ways that we can use water more smartly here in urban southern california to stretch our supplies and a new frontier a fourth area of water supply is a pacific ocean we absolutely know how to get that water treat it to the highest standards and apply it to beneficial use and again it's an unlimited source not easy costly tremendous politics but the fundamentals are there if we need it to be able to do that in an environmentally responsible way so i'm bullish on our water supply and uh easier said than done but we've just gone through seven years of historic drought and here in urban southern california we didn't miss a beat other areas were stressed but because of our planning our reservoir systems our treatment plants the tremendous investment that we've made since the early 1930s in our water supply we're in relatively good shape well on politics um first an observation on infrastructure i've been in the waste management industry i've been in the water industry i'm about to go into the energy business and there are similarities across the board in how you deal with infrastructure clearly politics is a big part of it finance how you finance these major capital investments and do the o m on a regular basis to keep them up huge huge challenge engineering you need really top flight engineers to apply their skills and the latest technologies to be able to maintain and build these infrastructure systems and finally public relations there's a huge disconnect between the public the average citizen and what it really takes to build and maintain infrastructure and we're constantly struggling with politicians who will take on reclaimed water for example because they are playing to the worst fears of the public when in fact is a tremendous resource that could be available to us our job is to try and overcome that and deal with it public relations is a big part of what we do in infrastructure management the metropolitan water district has been successful because some really smart people figured out how to spread the cost of major infrastructure over large areas so we use the tax base we're entitled to use a small piece of the tax base it's now dwindling but it used to be more to be able to make these major investments when we sell water to 18 million people you can imagine the revenues are tremendous and allows us the opportunity to leverage those sales issue bonds and again finance huge works we just built a reservoir out in hemet a two billion dollar investment that we are paying for today and we're going to continue to pay for but in the drought it really was our saving grace and more more works are are on the books the rate structure at an organization like metropolitan is critical so having those fundamentals of a financing system having a rate structure that reflects your costs and a board of directors that is applying business principles finance principles and i would argue to you not running for election running for election is a very very difficult thing to do and at the same time make these hard decisions that these appointed officials have to make to make these long-term investments they're not getting a return tomorrow they're looking for return for the next 25 and 50 years so fundamentals are appointed basic rate structure that has integrity and public officials who come to the table ready to make the hard decisions then we as managers using our engineers using our political public relations have the opportunity to build the kind of systems that we have here and enjoy like the metropolitan waterstream thank you thanks dominic i'm last and we were first los angeles department of water and power has been around a long time it was formally founded in 1902 but had underpinnings going back to the founding of the pueblo here in los angeles the pueblo was as you know founded in the 1770s and the source of water for the city at that point was the los angeles river the most important person in the pueblo for the longest period of time uh was the sanhedel sanjeto was the head ditch digger who controlled the flow of water into the city the distribution of the water the allocation of the water and for the longest time the sanjetos made more money than the city council members and the mayor and they were more important and we we have that as the history and legacy of dwp in the 1862 era the leadership of the city was stressed for money didn't have the resources able to sustain the department and so they privatized it a lot of people don't realize that there was a private company that was in charge of all of the water supply for the city of los angeles that was a los angeles water company and it was in existence from 1862 to 1902 and was the predecessor uh to the department of water and power there were a number of people that recognized as ron mentioned that los angeles was never going to reach its potential was never going to grow and be able to accommodate projected growth that was in the future without that water supply being in public hands there was litigation throughout the 1890s that culminated in a lawsuit uh that resulted in the sale of that private water company back to the city in 1902. dwp is was formula formed it was a department of water at the time power came a little later and i'll get to that in a moment and our governance is significantly simpler than my two predecessors this evening dwp serves only the city of los angeles we supply the water and the power within the city boundaries of the city of los angeles we don't go outside the city except on some rare circumstances in terms of supplying water or power we are a creature of the city charter the city charter specifically designates the existence of the department how we function and our governance we are comprised of a board of of commissioners there are five of us that are appointed by the mayor confirmed by the city council we uh serve for five year terms and we are the basically the board of directors for the department of water and power we have able managers a general manager assistant general managers that that run the department ron is very interesting and that he was shy and didn't tell you that prior to the time that he became the general manager of the met he was a board member of the met so very unusual representing the city of los angeles representing the city of los angeles and actually ron and i were appointed at the same time the same day he was appointed to the met board i was appointed that appointed the dwp board and it's sort of it is odd because we were classmates in law school back in the 60s so the dwp is the largest municipally owned utility in the united states we have 8 100 employees at one time we had as many as approaching 13 000 employees it is a huge huge company and as i said we supply all of the water to the city of los angeles as well as all of the power to the city of los angeles the the development of the infrastructure and this is what your class is about and the history of the department are completely intertwined dwp sits here today because of infrastructure investments that were made by our grandparents and our great grandparents we are sitting on the shoulders of giants there are people in the history of the dwp in the city of los angeles that had a vision that's very difficult to explain and at times i wonder where their inspiration came from but they clearly understood that for for los angeles to meet its uh potential and to fulfill its obligations to you and to your children i had decisions had to be made a long time ago and the city was willing to tax itself and the city was willing to commit itself a perfect example was los angeles uh aqueduct which is a major source of water from the eastern sierra a watershed that ron did not mention uh that aqueduct was built in the uh the late 1900s to 1912 and at the time that it was built it represented 100 percent of the bonding capacity of the entire city the entire bonding capacity of the city was pledged for the creation of that aqueduct and today we are getting the benefits of that ron talked about the water coming from the met we are members of the met we were founders of the met william mulholland the founder of the department of water and power was the founder of the met but to give you an idea of the value of what that means and what it means today the infrastructure investment that was made almost 100 years ago when we get water from the eastern sierra it comes to us uh through the aqueduct that i described comes into uh into the somar area where the 5 and the 14 freeway meet there's a couple of uh treatment facilities there there's the met facility the jensen facility and our our facility there's uh and when the water gets there from the eastern sierra it probably cost us a hundred dollars a hundred dollars an acre foot and that may may not mean a lot to you but when we go to ron and we buy water from the met it costs pretty close to four hundred dollars an acre foot 451. there you are the man knows exactly what he's selling for so that price differential is the differential between an infrastructure investment that took place 100 years ago it's going to be there a hundred years from now it is a phenomenal gift that gift has basically subsidized growth in the city of los angeles it has subsidized business it has subsidized schools universities it has it has led to the creation of wealth in los angeles that would not have been possible but for those investments the interesting thing about that aqueduct and the elegant element of that aqueduct was that mulholland not only had the vision for the existence of the need he not only had the vision for the uh the the uh scene where that need to be solved how it could be solved but he came up with a system that is just phenomenal the from the intake uh the levine intake in uh just uh west of mammoth to los angeles in san pedro uh that distance is 330 miles and that is one long aqueduct one impressive infrastructure investment and in designing it and building it he went beyond and what he did is he realized that that from that distance to here it's all downhill so understanding and being a good engineer as ron alluded to earlier he understood that there were opportunities there and one of the opportunities was the creation of power so the gravity flow of the water was harnessed through a series of power plants that still exist today that supply power to the city of los angeles that help reduce the cost of delivering that water and it's a win-win situation ultimately the same philosophy of municipal ownership of water systems led to the involvement of the dwp into the power side and up until 1939 there were multiple power providers edison other private companies providing power within the city of la and 18 in 1939 those those companies were bought out we bought them out we consolidated it and since that time we have been the sole supplier of power to the uh to the city uh our power comes uh from local power plants that we have within the los angeles basin uh it comes from a variety of different sources in types we are reflective of the society that we live in at one time our power plants were exclusively coal burning we have power plants in arizona nevada utah and we have a wide range now a balanced portfolio if you will we are able to meet all of our demands for power some of you can remember back four or five years ago when we had the energy crisis created by elected politicians that ron had alluded to was it mr peace from san diego i don't want to point fingers but i think they all voted for it yeah everyone in the in the senate and the assembly i believe voted uh i don't believe it was a single extension and the net result of that is they were trying to solve problems on a political basis uh that really didn't lend themselves to a political solution created this great energy crisis and when that hit there were no negative consequences within the city of los angeles because of the infrastructure investment that had taken place 50 years ago no blackouts no blackouts was the last time ellis had a blackout well i was born in 1944 and i don't remember in my lifetime any of them i really don't i do not remember a single blackout so all of that comes from infrastructure investment and the the interesting thing that i tell my colleagues on my board and i tell people that are interested in infrastructure is that we are not being judged none of the three of us here are being judged by what we're doing today we can do things today and it'll come and go and it'll be covered in the paper and it'll be gone the way in which we will be judged is five years from now 10 years from now 20 years from now and 40 years from now when you are our age and the city still works there's still water the lights are still on and and that your children will be in college and the system will continue to work that's when we will be measured that's how we should be measured i believe uh in opposite of elected officials who have term limits who are are looking at their next political seat and i don't i don't mean to beat up on them but but it is important so you're against uh popular democracy for the election of decision makers well on boards such as this i think the progressive era uh thought a lot about that and i think they they developed they developed the concept of separation of powers uh even farther than the form framers of the constitution where you had of course the legislative the uh the executive and the judicial branch and the decision that was made in the city of los angeles was a creation of citizen commissions these commissions functioned very well today and in the late 1900s 1990s when the charter was being revised and updated and changed one of the major considerations was whether or not commissions were still vital and whether they still functioned and i believe they do i'm a strong proponent of that i've had the opportunity to serve on a number of different commissions for the city and i've seen them work and yes fernando i am not in favor of elected commissioners so that that's but that that does not surprise people in terms of the dwp when you think about the history of the dwp you think about the movie chinatown man it's an old movie but you know starring jack nicholson faye dunaway etc and i don't want to go through the whole thing but they were like it kind of implied some shady aspects of how the dwp was able to get water et cetera is that is that what happened well i know you weren't around at that time well i will tell you this i've actually had the opportunity to lecture with robert town on the uh the difference between the fictionalized uh chinatown story robert town was a screenwriter who wrote chinatown and in the year 1974 when the godfather won every academy award robert town won the street best screenplay for chinatown uh and that was pretty impressive given what happened that year with with the godfather but robert and i have uh have actually we've lectured in cinema classes together on the gap between the fictionalization of chinatown and the reality but what's interesting is is uh in chinatown there were there were two polemics that were were the good and evil that were percent of personified by noah cross and hollis mole ray now obviously mo ray was a take off on mulholland and what uh people don't know is that that noah cross the villain was the so-called distillation of uh fred eaton and it was the conflict between the actual historic conflict between fred eaton and william mulholland with regards to their beliefs as to who should own the water supply that led to some of the greatest uh conflicts in the movie and yes there was there is a colorful history of dwp and what fernando is alluding to was at the time that the aqueduct was built uh as you may know the aqueduct pretty much follows highway 395 highway 14 and then 395 up up into mono uh county up to mammoth and those lands up there did not belong to dwp and if you don't own the land you don't own the water supply under california law and uh there's other subtleties to it but but generally what happened was los angeles realized that it needed more water it looked at other available water supplies at the time and that was prior to the time that mahal had thought about bringing the water in from the colorado river and the thought was that to do so you have to own the land and if you go out and you buy land at market value and you're a continued buyer of land at market value you create the market and what happens is the value of real estate will sky skyrocket and what fernando is alluding to is that the city of los angeles used surrogates used privacy now some would use other words including a young man who once worked for ron who his name will not go mentioned but we went up and we we bought the land from the farmers and the people that owned the land up in the owens valley not telling them that you were going to buy it to take the water down to southern california absolutely we did we we uh we dealt with them at arm's length in a commercial uh transaction we bought it many times above market uh we we bought it when it became available we did not have eminent domain we had no capacity to take it from them so it was totally their choice and in many instances what we did is we bought it from families paid them uh the value of the land and their turning right around and lease the land back to them and some of our leases in the owens valley today have been our leases for 100 years so uh their families are still using the land so i mean but you know people talk about the dwp remember it's a city agency and they call it you know it's pretty expansionistic imperialistic in the minds of many because they own property as you mentioned earlier in arizona nevada utah they own property throughout all of the sierra nevadas i mean that's very unusual for a city to own property throughout the whole west we're the only city agency that uh that has those assets outside the city boundaries we had uh richard alcone here last week yes and then many of you many of you have probably seen his commercial where he's putting us well exactly that's what i was going to ask he talked about the dwp and one of the reasons he's running for mayor is because this unresponsive imperialistic expansionistic agency unrepresented without elected officials on the commission raised the rates without doing it properly so he got mad and he sued that's according to his opinion yeah he's smarter than that he knows what really went on the city of los angeles city council has been raiding the treasury of dwp for years and because they couldn't raise rates without the city's approval they got in a bit of a pickle when they needed to raise rates and at the same time the city council was expecting this subsidy the public was sort of shocked i think at the whole thing and mr albert cohen is taking advantage of uh well that situation why would a politician do that because he's running for office well i i i was uh i was uh asked uh by the newspapers to comment on mr ellercon when he first brought up the issue of a state audit of dwp and the validity of the transfer of surplus funds from dwp to the general funds of the city of los angeles and i believe the language or my terminology in describing him and his actions were scumbag opportunists scumbag opportunist and i asked the newspaper to publish that and they refused to publish it now if mr ellicott were right here i would use those exact words again and i believe i said scumbag opportunist so if the record isn't clear a city of la tv station so if he becomes mayor we're going to be in trouble i'm going to go back no no i'll be in trouble because i'll be an ex-commissioner but that's okay because the reason why i have that opinion was because when the city of los angeles modified its charter in 1924 the charter provided for the department of water and power to create a rate structure to pay for its cost its operation its maintenance investments into the future and if there was surplus that that surplus could be transferred to the general fund now political political political opportunists will say that that's stealing from the citizens of los angeles but you were listening to me earlier when i told you that we only serve the city of los angeles so to describe to you what mr ellicott is objecting to is the following money on a dwp that is surplus fund is taken out of this pocket because it is given there by the ratepayers right and that money is sneakily taken out of this pocket and brought and put into this pocket the citizens there is not one gap of difference between a citizen in the city of los angeles and a rate payer so if it bothers you that the money that you have in this pocket should be in this pocket and mr alekan who served on the city council for eight years and accepted that money himself was not offended by that at that time you can see where i have the formulation of my opinion are you voting for mayor it is not mr ellicott by the way we have we have made that transfer since the 1920s before mr elechan was born the matter has been litigated and the matter has been approved and authorized by the courts mr al khan served for many years as an aide to mayor bradley never once raised the issue never once was concerned about that when the money came from dwp to fund all of the activities that transpired in the city when he was elected to the city council he did not once object to this or to getting the money having to transfer one pocket going back to the question though why are we increasing rates if we have a surplus well the surplus is is a is a a mixture of a number of factors um that you're trying to sound like a politician now no the surplus the surplus see look at that anytime someone talks like it has that little stutter that means they're trying to uh come up with a a cute answer you should have voted with him more often dominic the surplus is a creation of a number of things the surplus does not mean that we are debt-free the surplus does not mean that we are without long-term debts bonds as ron mentioned or other kinds it means that we have an operating service surplus on that given year for that year of operation now the reason we have a rate increase is that we have a number of different mandates that have been imposed upon dwp that have come from the federal government and from the state government with regards to the quality of water that we serve to you uh james just mentioned earlier about the caliber of water that was in that retreat where we recycled water absolutely correct that's probably better water than ninety percent of the people in the united states are getting but because of changing scientific capacities there are greater abilities to measure hence greater standards and so we have now a shifting standards of water quality that we have to deliver those mandates in many many instances i can't think of a single one that's an exception to this come unfunded which means we don't we don't uh get money from the feds to pay for this so if they say that this water has to have zero parts per trillion of arsenic and we know that hot springs in the eastern sierra creates a little bit of arsenic and we have four parts per trillion of which it has no health impact but because of this mandate we have to take it out and we have to take our treatment facility in sylmar redo it have new technologies apply to it it's going to cost about 360 million dollars to do so so we many times are are being pushed by politicians to meet standards that have very little to do with actual health uh requirements uh it is a little frustrating at times particularly when those mandates come unfunded and uh and we have to uh pay for those we meaning you and we meaning the the poorest people in los angeles have to pay for it but that's part of the deal now in 1992 okay 1992 was the last time we had a water rate increase in the city of los angeles it happened at that time to be 11 by coincidence um and i have all of the clippings and all the news stories by city council and the mayor and everybody was all upset at the time and it's funny because if you read that in 1992 and you change the date it's exactly the same what are the water rates in la are they higher or lower than the ones in like san diego or i mean how do we average that they're lower we're significantly lower particularly we're significantly lower than the member agencies of the met who are 100 reliant upon ron's water and you of course know that because he told you that water from him is 441 an acre foot and i just told you we get a lot of the water for 125 an acre foot so we create blended rates we have various sources of water including the met uh we're able to provide water significantly cheaper than our competitors one last question these two gentlemen next to me are basically the ceos of their corporation they are the top guys you are on the board of directors that then selects the top guy so you get paid what i'll get paid exactly what i'm worth fernando zero right he doesn't get pitted zero that's why ron gave up being a board member to become the general manager where he made this huge income on the public trough i'm not dumb i'm not talking about what are you paying right now you're your general manager what does he get paid are general managers getting paid about 312 313 000 a year you started out earlier that that sangero got paid the highest more than the mayor well that's much more than the mayor or any other he's the highest paid city official and i think he's the highest paid public official in the state of california if i'm not mistaken he makes more than anyone at the airport he makes more than the sheriff and he's worth every penny of it he's a bargain it's not unusual to have so you can make some money being in public administration we want to ask these gentlemen what they're what they're making that uh that's that's a good middle class income um continuing with the continuing with the mayor's race uh james uh all five of the major candidates have uh are against the uh sunshine uh canyon landfill um and when we earlier had this theme about they're not really investing for the future uh can we close sunshine canyon down like some electives would want us to do tomorrow can you close it sure you can close it and what happens is it the responsible decision to close it um in my opinion uh as an engineer and a manager no i think it is describe sunshine canyon for them a little bit where sunset canyon is a landfill operated by uh the private sector uh in the uh northern uh end of the san fernando valley are two treatment plants that's right but if you know where the intersection of the five and the fourteen is it's just on the western side and it is a modern a modern landfill and i i think that that it it's environmentally sound i mean i take a great deal of pride in the fact that i don't think that it is as good a site as we have at 20 hills but i mean you know there's always pride in your own company it's your own organization but your members don't take trash up there uh they do not this this some i shouldn't say that some of our cities take trash up there through transfer stations uh and let me back off let me let me answer your question then i want to add to why our cities some take trash up there and some don't the the the sunshine canyon landfill provides the city of los angeles with very cost effective refuse disposal and if you were to shut that landfill down and i'm not favoring one candidate or another these are the facts all five are against it but what i'm saying is if you were to shut that down then those trucks are going to have to go to more distant sites and there will be more uh traffic there will be more air pollution from that standpoint even though they were talking about consolidating the loads and taking it to another area aha outside of the city of los angeles so if you've heard of nimby's not in my backyard so it's okay to close a well operating facility within your jurisdiction but you still have to get rid of the refuse you still have to provide an outlet so what are they going to do take it someplace else and then somebody can be against closing that site so i i think that is what what dominic was saying what ron was saying is that you need uh commissioners or you need appointed boards in the infrastructure business that act in in the better for the betterment of the whole now there might be one particular area of a given jurisdiction or a city that wants to see a facility shut down that doesn't shutting that facility down isn't necessarily the best decision for the whole and that's the success of the water and power of department of water and power because i believe that they've always made the decisions for the betterment of the whole not one particular group certainly metropolitan and serving 18 million people that have done that and in serving uh 78 of the 88 cities in l.a county and you have the mayors on my bosses in essence sitting on the board of directors they make they rarely have anything other than a unanimous decision even though the arguments and the benefits pros and cons are fully vetted because they're sitting there wanting to do not what's best for the short term but for the short term and the long term they're not in essence making a decision because i'm going to have to run for office tomorrow on that decision but they're making it as elected citizens because on my board they're mayors but they're not running on a platform to get elected to the board of the sanitation districts that is the local issue for them so when they sit there they sit there as really intelligent people from the community that makes a decision that's best for the community so when you get back to sunshine canyon i i would say that anytime you're going to close down any facility water treatment wastewater treatment or solid waste management and you're not going to close down a water treatment plant because you've got pipes coming in there you're not going to close down a wastewater treatment plant because there's pipes coming in there but it's really easy to close down a landfill because it comes in by truck don't let the truck drive someplace else so the mobility associated with refuse management leads to some very difficult political decisions that people take in my opinion the easy way just shut it down yeah in talking about the easy way if if uh all of the trash that goes to sunshine were to go to eagle mountain or any of the alternative sites available what would be the economic impact on the city of los angeles well it would be tremendous dominic i think you know the numbers i think you pay somewhere around all say 24 a ton of refuse right now it used to be 21 and i think recently you're paying 24 a ton um if you were to have to haul it ultimately uh to to say one of our waste by rail sites uh in today's dollars it would cost you about sixty dollars a time so three times but the city of new york pays 100 150 so even the 60 is a bargain but the point is now where is that money going to come from that additional money for all of the other pressure points within the city of l.a and and i don't want to pick on the city valley i'm saying that exactly i'm saying that for any local government there has to be this this balance uh in societal society's needs certainly it's going to be on education police fire and if in the infrastructure business if you decide today that i'm going to raid the money that's set aside for water infrastructure why because i got to get by this election so i'm going to raid that money out of there and i'm going to put it over here for fire police that's going to come back to haunt you because someday you're going to have to improve that infrastructure and then at that point in time you get yourself into a bind and you go out and you sell huge bonds and you pay a tremendous amount of interest on those bonds and you wind up paying a lot more than you would have if you would have made the reasoned decision in the beginning yeah let me ask ron a question and i'm going to open it up to the students to ask questions um i mean it's been a constant theme of this panel but also every single week with the exception of when the elected officials were here but even then it's that no one wants it next to we're talking about infrastructure okay three things no one wants it next to them no one wants to pay for it and no one wants to plan for it that's been a constant theme the mwd of the three agents really been something someone that's built something lately you mentioned the the uh that that reservoir out in hemet two billion dollars how in the heck did you were you able to cite it pay for it and plan for it how did that come about well two million as i said the board of directors is somewhat removed from local politics we have the financial ability without raising rates significantly so they were politically secure in looking at this the engineers came to the table and said we can do this i think some very creative people in the planning process said we need to try and approach us a different way we know there are people out there that don't want new infrastructure what can we do for that community so we created a preserve a natural preserve that is twice the size of the reservoir and it was very very popular with the local community we're now in the throes of deciding how much recreation we're going to add so it was it was uh involving the community it was some bargaining process um and admittedly a reservoir is a lot easier to sell than a landfill yeah but it's very different than when we talked about historically what the dwp did up in the eastern sierras in terms of what you just did in terms of involving the community you cannot build things uh without involving the community anymore well i think that that's exactly right although in defense of mulholland in his time they probably did more than most people did by paying fair value and and going overboard and trying to pay for what they were getting that was probably pretty extreme for the time right but we've just learned over time that you have to do more and that's what we're doing any questions out there no questions can i make a statement about infrastructure yeah we've got yeah we'll make the statement then we'll get your question right over here yeah the statement i wanted to make about no one wanted it near them is something that the politicians have real trouble with and and people like the three of us i think have a lot less trouble with because we're not elected officials and it's this all as you said fernando all of us want the benefit of all of these infrastructures all of us want the benefit of having the harbor here because we can get all of the goods that come from asia that are produced here cheaply and we are the beneficiaries of that and we have an enhanced lifestyle at a lower price because of the of the harbor all of us want the airport i mean the minute one of you guys gets a free ticket to go to the super bowl i mean you know you'd be really unhappy if you had to go to san francisco for an airport you know you want that airport you want to be able to use that airport it creates commerce it facilitates the way we live landfills treatment plants power plants all are necessary and vital for an organic living entity that we call municipalities cities megalopolises to exist nobody wants them well you can't have a city without those infrastructures you can't have a functioning society without those facilities whether it's a freeway it's a it's a subway line it's some other kind of transportation i just don't want him right next to me well then you don't have to you don't have to live next to him fernando you you get a part-time job you make a little bit more more money than you're making as a college professor and you buy a lovely home in westchester okay well no that's the airport right now you can't you can't get away with it you know the 405 everything we all we all we all have a sacrifice that we all have to pay in one form or another to live with this many people together in this kind of an environment call the city get a question over here who unfortunately said um that there's a balance between being cost effective environmentally friendly and then playing in the political systems to get what you need to get done and someone else also said that you hope to be judged in five to twenty years for what you're doing where does your pressure come from um as far as being cost effective environmentally friendly or the political system as far as how soon do you need to see results when that pressure's coming down let's start with ron well i don't think i don't think i said that i think that bottom line you have to be environmentally friendly in our society in order to accomplish even the short-term goals the public demands environmental awareness and security and right behind the public are some very effective advocates but there's nothing wrong with that i mean we just know more i'm not saying about the environment that's wrong and we're willing to pay more for it as a manager that's the reality i deal with and frankly i feel better about it so you don't get to sacrifice the environment and in fact i think we have learned that when you pay attention to the environment your investments are going to be better received by the public and probably are going to going to be better in the long term in terms of sustainability yeah way back there in light of our record-setting weather and all the catastrophes that have accompanied it what would you suggest in terms of infrastructure improvements to better handle situations like this i think the death toll is at nine right now um what would you change what would you do different how can we better manage the water flow that we do get when we have too much of it the flood control system well i mean that's not under any one of your jurisdictions no flood control comes within the county there's a separate agency county flood control uh that operates uh the system along with the army corps of engineers uh which helped build the system um is that that's fair to say i mean you've got uh i think all of you appreciate the fact that these are record rainfalls there was a 15-day period at the beginning of of january where it was the most amount of rain in the 127-year record of keeping track of rainfall in los angeles county tremendous amount of rain the topography of this area is such that it runs off the mountains into a flat plain and it just as they call it and hydrology time of concentration is like that and i mean you go from you go from a trickle in the stream to a tremendous wall and and i i personally think even though there's been a lot of damage but i think in some ways typical of the media it's been simplified and exaggerated in terms of what you see on tv i my heart goes out to to the people that have lost their lives i know the city of l.a lost one worker uh in the repair of a sinkhole and people have had homes damaged but when you think of just for los angeles county the 10 million people that live here and the tremendous amount of rain that we got i think it's been managed exceptionally well incredible success as well i i really think that's the case and i think the question that you asked is well what can you do to manage it better i'm not i just think it's it's been a tremendous success but there are issues out there and i just want to answer the one question that ron you had talked about because i was the one that had made the statement about cost effective and environmentally sound i don't think those have to be mutually exclusive ron is absolutely right i think any organization any organization that's going to succeed has to have a strong environmental conscience and the pressure comes from not only the the ceo but it's going to come from the elected officials because uh people want to have uh an environment that they can enjoy but you they even though the board might want that you've got to have the leadership and you've got to have the staff that understands that you've got to do the environmentally proper thing but in doing that try to do it as cost-effectively as you can and there's a lot of value judgments that come up there it's easy for me to say and ron and dominic well it's got to be environmentally sound there's a lot of judgments as to what's the environmental sound and how far you go and cost and that's just the reality fernando can i get back to the question about the water flow on the river one thing that a lot of people don't realize is the los angeles river has its origin in the verdugos and san gabriel mountains the drop in elevation from the los angeles river from its inception all the way down to san pedro is greater in altitude than the drop of the mississippi river from its origins in in minnesota all the way down to new orleans so we have a river that's extremely high um differential in altitude in a very short distance which creates all sorts of infrastructure problems if we had los angeles as it existed in the 1850s and we had vast open lands a lot of open land a lot of available land we could create a number of different catch basins we could create recharge facilities and we could do a number of different things many of those things are not available anymore and not doable uh given the development of what's happened in los angeles and the conditions that we're in today in fact fernando's favorite guy mike davis wrote about that's right the floods and troubles here in the city fernando just one other point here building standards look at your building standards hillsides you've got to enforce and and make sure that we're being very careful about that but you can bet that a lot of people are going to rebuild right where those things well but that's going to take some some real discipline on the part of officials in dealing with the fact that it just may not be a place where they can say yes um we've got to look at our pavement are there places where we can replace pavement with with uh surfaces that will allow infiltration of water and not the runoff and native plants uh are going to do a lot better in holding the terrain and and are going to be a lot more friendly in terms of falling over and creating damage so clearly things that we can do to be better prepared but i would agree with your assessment we've done a tremendous amount to be successful let me go here and then over here half this campus is reclaimed water uh as most of the students here know there's like a foul odor from it are you sure that's from the water yeah i don't know but anyway what is that odor and is there anything being done about it or what can be done about it here's a pessimistic about the about this that's a good question i was also the irrigation mechanic for two years so i'm familiar with it i think uh i mean first of all i think you ought to contact the the city of los angeles and i i'm not i think they so you're passing the buck to dwp no no no no that's public works that's public work sanitation okay so it's not dwp i honestly believe they want that kind of input oftentimes when you have a problem in a system uh because you can't go out there and check every single one and if you have a problem in the system unless a citizen in a meaningful way uh reports it and says hey sometimes but that's what gets it corrected my my professional judgment is that more than likely the problem exists because there are there are algal growths in the line and and oftentimes at night i will respire and you will get a swamp smell in a way if you go near river channels or at bionic creek for example before it was built out the way it is and uh you will go down there and you'll find algorithm and it it smells and there's a lot of nutrients in the reclaimed water that's why the grass is green and so that's great for the grass but the algae also grow and you sometimes you get slime layers in there and and the the technique is to chlorinate and flush those lines out so that you can keep them clean and that's a maintenance issue so if you contact you might i think you will so it wouldn't happen what that wouldn't happen if it was regular dwp water it won't happen no it wouldn't it wouldn't happen for a couple reasons number one uh our system is a closed system and we use chlorine as a disinfectant to prevent the growth of organics in the system the met uses chloramines which is just a different technology which is actually probably better since we are moving towards chloramines to facilitate both infrastructure compatibility and economics but those chemicals kill all of the organics that would grow for example if you had a standing reservoir like stone canyon which supplies a lot of the west side uh when it was operational we would have to even though the water had been treated prior to the time it got there we would have to come in and we would have to chlorinate particularly uh hot summer days uh with a lot of sunshine which was which uh facilitate the growth of the organics there's chlora i'm sure there's chlorine i think i know there's chlorine in that water the question becomes if you're near the end of the system whether or not there was enough to begin with and so you have to make that adjustment you maintain your car you have to maintain a distribution you had a follow-up we are the end of the system uh i don't need that we needed to record it though or the cameras uh yeah we're in the system but uh play vista is actually in the system right after graduation we've been taken off the system temporarily uh we also have a coordinator that we just put in last year which didn't quite help it enough we're thinking that smell is now going to go down to play vista and we'll be okay up here everyone will hear about them at the end of the line okay we had a question over here in the guy right there in the middle hold on one second we need you just because it records it can you hear me now um there's a lot of people in l.a and it keeps getting like bigger and there's even more waste production do you think there's going to have to be a shift in lifestyle in order to keep la going for a longer time because i know the new landfills are supposed to hold for another 100 years or whatever but with increased population isn't there increased waste and how do we address like lifestyle to ensure that you know companies are selling um products that don't overuse things you know like if you go to mcdonald's there's so much packaging just for one meal compared to if you ate at home there's hardly any packaging how do we reduce waste as far as lifestyle and how do you as uh i guess as the as a as a as the powers that distribute all of this work actually encourage that or do you even encourage that because i would think the more waste the more business you get what are the plans for the future in terms of that and how can you uh impact quality of life decisions that create more more waste i mean have have we been effective in that area well first of all let me answer the question about population i'm sure dominic and ron will take a shot at it but as far as population is concerned in in my organization in a lot of ways not to pass the buck but we respond to growth when you uh you manage the waste from all of these cities and it is the elected officials so you you really determine it at the ballot box in terms of the policies that are enacted by the people that you elect and it is the elected officials that make the value judgments in passing the plans as to what the community will sustain in growth uh if ron was talking about building ordinances but there's also ordinances as far as how many homes you're going to be allowed how you're going to allow to be built within a given community some communities are very pro-growth some communities aren't um over and above that i would say to you that if if you said no more we're going to drop the line right here no more no more people coming into the state especially from oregon in nevada wherever uh the excess the excess the excess of birth over death is a challenging problem for us in the infrastructure uh so so it it it is it is it is before us but i would say to you that that in the infrastructure business there's really not much that you can do because we're not on the policy end of setting what growth ought to be nor are we on the end of determining that general mills or procter gamble ought to package their toothpaste this way but you have been tremendously successful though in getting people to recycle yeah it's an incredible successful story so that has to come from the legislature on the political side of it there has to be the will in the legislature to pass packaging laws and then you run into issues of the lobbying against that and and that's a whole another subject but there was a bill passed in the state legislature called ab939 which mandated uh recycling for cities they had to reach 50 by the year 2000 and for the slide that i showed you uh for the most part in los angeles county on the average they have done that and there has been a great deal of of recycling people got used to the fact that i don't want to throw my aluminum cans uh into a separate can and now it's a lifestyle so it takes a while and and the commitment has to be uh in in the general population is recycling and i would dare say to you as far as i'm concerned i'm looking at the future in you as to how you practice that in in recycling and in your children practicing we put a tremendous amount into educating the public and and young people about the fact that recycling makes good environmental live in the sense and have like grass lawns and things like that like palm springs yeah and water i mean why would we do that if we could have um in palm springs and the coachella valley have over 300 golf courses and they sit on one of the biggest aquifers in the world so they have the water no no they don't well they don't sorry they don't they're running out of it they really are i find that hard to believe well it's true tell me about it that's true because i i read when i had i used to have a place there and they used to tell us coachella water district used to send out their their annual report ron and they would tell us about this aqueduct and how many years it would last and well i'm glad you believed them but i just came out of negotiations with them where we were fighting tooth and nail over colorado river water because they know they need it oh they want it absolutely well i think that the governmental answer to the question is agencies like us typically don't have the power to tell the public or anybody you shall do this so what we end up doing is educating and subsidizing so we'll pay you las vegas for example today is paying people to take their lawns out so that's how they get the public to respond ultimately you end up with an elected official who has to make the call on whether they're going to mandate use the stick and even there the courts will often tell them you can't do it the interstate commerce clause for example is a huge huge problem in trying to regulate packaging or anything moving across state borders so short answer is it's very complex and i think we decided that the best way we can do it is with example we've got an actress that helps us renee russo on native plants people listen to her education and subsidize and yeah back to population that's a really good question but as as ron mentioned you cannot control commerce locally there's federal laws we also have the u.s constitution in the constitution guarantees every one of you the opportunity and the choice to live anywhere you want all of you can graduate from wyola and leave california and there's no law that says you can't do it conversely there are people who will continue to come into los angeles and come into california and our population is going to grow in 1997 and in 1998 dwp did two demographic studies one on the water side and one on the power side to take a look at what was going to happen in populations from the year 2000 to the year 2020 both of them independent from one another came to the conclusion that within the city of la i'm not talking la county southern california california i'm talking within the boundaries of the city of los angeles our growth rate was going to be one and a half percent per year now if you extrapolate that out from 2000 to 2020 that's a 30 increase in growth in numbers that means about 4 million people going to about 5 and a half million people it's going to happen there's the law is such our constitution is such there's nothing you can do it's going to be a con a combination of immigration and birth rates as was noted the people are going to be here but on average are we producing more waste per person less than ever before or are we managing well no i think if you look at the net we are producing less waste per per person because of the tremendous amount of recycling to answer your question the the way we're going to manage it on the wastewater side is uh as i've said and ron talked about but certainly what dominic's talked about for dwp and as an organization we promote aggressively and have for the last 40 years you're going to need to get over this psychological hurdle that you shouldn't be using reclaimed water you're going to have to use more and more recovery instead of saying well it stinks shut it down the engineer in me says if it stinks find the problem and correct it solve the problem because the use of the water uh is far too valuable uh to to not take a can i have a contrary opinion if i might sure and ron disagreed with me earlier and and now i have to agree with ron i believe ron i kicked him under the table no i believe ron's analysis with regards to water i'm not talking about waste and i'm not talking about any other resource but with regards to water i do believe that the future will be will be good uh and it's it's this fact and please this is one one statistic you should keep in mind in the state of california all of the water that is used for human use is called developed water of all of the developed water within the state of california 83 percent of it goes to agriculture right now agriculture is six percent of our gross state product so we're using 83 of the water to create six percent of the value in our society that's not going to hold that's going to change there will be factors there will be visionaries like ron who went to sacramento negotiated with the rice farmers and moved 200 000 acre feet of water from the sacramento delta down for urban and industrial and commercial uses here in southern california that kind of leadership is what's going to solve our problems not elected officials let's have a question right here um in particular like i have a problem with the beaches you know like um sewage spills in particular and how are we gonna like have the beaches be healthy for the people you know to even use them because i know that i live near the beach i've lived near the beach my whole life and i wouldn't get in that water just it's just nasty so are you dumping on the beach no i i think the issue as far as wastewater treatment is concerned but then you know some storms you showed us that the map that had you uh taking some of that waste out there though right well it is treated waste water that means is that there's water again no it meets very stringent standards as i said you can you can you can put fresh water into bionic creek and let it stand there long enough with the runoff fertilizers and you'll get the smell that this you've got to overcome the issues related to smell and whether or not there's a problem but in terms of the beach the the beach closures as far as waste water is concerned what the city of la puts out and what we put out if you look at the report card that heal the bay has almost all of those beaches as far as the impact from waste water are rated a's rated a's uh any plus or an a but there are there are periods particularly after rains for two or three days where a number of the beaches people say uh there's there's a problem not people don't say you test it and there's a problem there and that's from the runoff from streets uh from uh from animals uh and and that is an issue that has to be addressed but but as we were talking before if you go out and stand on biona creek for example in this huge rain right and you look at the amount of water that is coming down there and you say well i want to treat that water okay it's huge dollars huge dollars and where are those dollars going to come from dominic was talking about one pocket to the other pocket and you say well i want to pay for that well then it's going to come out of some pocket in the city of la that's now looking at roads or other issues but it's it's it is a problem that is at the forefront on the on the storm water side of it that it it's at the forefront that is being argued at the governmental level but i would say to you that southern california beaches are as clean as they have ever been in in their history except for these periods after me i lived near pv where you showed um one of those where you have a plant or something i don't know where you're not going to want tv has nasty water it's just it's unsafe to even go in there torence that area and then you know once you get to redondo beach you know and all that you just can't it's not really like healthy to even get in the water and there's signs even that says you can't get in the water because it's unhealthy and even imperial beach right here like you know you can't get in the water if you go around the palos verdes peninsula i'd like to know where the signs are because on the palace very peninsula on the side where we discharge the signs are not there permit preventing you from going into the water so i really would like to know that if you get down over to to rat for example i don't believe that there are any signs in there if you get into redondo beach where the pier is where they have uh used to have a storm drain going in there and there's an enclosed body of water yes there that's the problem when you get stagnation as i was talking about but if you go further down uh harando uh in hermosa and manhattan that's exceptional quality water now i'm talking about for the most part except right after storms uh for a few days but other than that i think you'll find it's good don't get in the water after a storm hey you know one of the one of the classes out here is a chicano studies class so i'm going to ask you two guys um you know how did you two guys uh end up in water i mean uh you know young mexican kids don't grow up saying hey i want to be in the water i want to be a water executive you know how did that happen and it's very unusual when you take a look at most of these infrastructure boards they're very few especially your generation you know where there were very few opportunities especially in this area how did it happen that two guys from uh east l.a end up in these very important water executive positions well you're right we didn't start out thinking that that's where we wanted to end up i started out out of law school as a legal aid lawyer in a very poor community in denver and then i moved to gilroy california representing farm workers and as i told you it became very apparent to me that in order to affect lives of lots of people and to improve our economy for a long long time these basic infrastructure issues are hugely important that's not for everybody it just happened to really interest me and i developed my interests there i for many many years there were no other brown faces in the room none except for for me and then later on dominic when we started working together that's not true today i think that the industry is open a lot of good engineers coming up and it's really important stuff but i think that certainly earlier on the focus in college and chicano studies was how do you get in the inner city and deal with issues that were right in front of us you know schools and discrimination and and and things like that and uh i did that for a while but ultimately i moved off into the area that i'm in it's been great actually i started in solid waste maybe before you did i started solid waste in 1962. i was a trash collector and i i worked in landfills before they were called sanitary landfills they were called dumps in those days and they were dumps and and i worked as a trash collector as i was working my way through college in college i had a a good professor much like fernando who knew a little bit about history and i wrote a paper on mulholland and believe it or not even when i was in college i had an awareness and appreciation for dwp that has lasted with me my entire year my entire my entire life and in 1980 when mayor bradley asked me to serve as a fire commissioner which is the first of my commission assignments with the city even then i knew at some at some point at some opportunity that i was going to serve on dwp i knew it i just knew it was it was something of great interest to me i care an awful lot about it i understand the interwoven nature between dwp and the leadership and and the investment in the infrastructure and the development of the city of los angeles is so intertwined that um it was irresistible to me i mean obviously in addition to dwp he served on the harbor commission the coliseum commission the transportation commission harbor commission record parks correct so yeah didn't uh when you were on the fire commission there were all kinds of fires that happened when you're on the coliseum the rams and the raiders left every time you've been on a commission there's been a problem i've just realized that now in terms of all these uh that's a coincidence isn't it now watch this rate increase with you're on the commission actually the the raiders left after i left the coliseum commission the the harbor uh reached uh revenue heights that have been unprecedented from the time i served you don't have to defend yourself no i know and and fires and i will tell you this about fire about the fire department all of you should next time you go by a fire station just take a look at those people and think about what they do it's an incredible incredible profession incredible opportunity to serve on that commission a lot of the women do go by and think about what they do it's just like who had another well that's how no let me let me finish on that okay i was president of the fire commission when we hired the first women and we changed the rules and changed a lot of things and created some interesting career opportunities okay got time for two more questions one over here and then one over here for mr solids curious to know if there are any development opportunities for the metropolitan waste areas or waste sites you know are you able to but golf courses or cemeteries or shopping centers i don't know what kind of opportunities lie for those places and if those are safe to do that yeah what happens to old dump sites ron you closed one down what happened to it well jim is as well relatively limited use it's got to be open space where it's solid ground because because trash does compress over time you can develop compatible uses recreational uses and the landfill gas jim can tell you a lot more is a tremendous fuel that can generate electricity and is essentially a renewable resource there are many there are many examples of closed landfills that have been put to multiple purpose uses there is a a a park a multiple purpose park in the city of rolling hills estates where there are baseball diamonds uh equestrian center and it is located on a former landfill there are places where golf courses up in the city of uh in the city of glendale they have a golf course on a on a former landfill those of you that have ever gone up through sepulveda pass you'll see a road winding up through there the mountain gate country club uh is built on a uh on a former landfill so it can be done and in some ways you can look at the former landfill site as dedicated open space if you want to call it a golf course or just open space in general because i can assure you with the premium on home sites in southern california if it wouldn't have been a landfill it probably would have been a heck of a lot of homes by now so from that standpoint i i honestly believe that there is a a societal benefit in the long run and in the short time not only for refuge disposal but ultimately in terms of the use of the of the site and it can be done not that there aren't cases where there have been a lot of problems but you know that i i don't care what you're in uh political science psychology uh you name the the field that you're in and you're always gonna be able to look at an outlier and say well look how bad this is but there are far far more good stories in the problem nowadays and in fact all the time the problem is the good stories often don't sell and so you don't hear an awful lot about any other questions anybody else besides david no okay last question better be a good one david you could talk loud very loud question i don't know you know which one you would be the best answer about drinking water tap water um i just came back recently i did this semester in europe you know i grew up in southern california my whole life and i didn't realize when i went there that tap water is actually drinkable in some places um because to be perfectly honest our tap water does not taste good here and i was just kind of curious as to what accounts for that kind of difference do we only use chemical filtration if you notice with all of our previous uh panelists we always gave them bottled water but this group we gave them dwp water which brand how frequently do you change a filter when's the last time you change the filter i guarantee you it was not as recently as we filtered the water that's coming through there but it tastes better than the water well let me let me okay let me let me deal with that yes the water the water that you get within the city of los angeles comes from multiple different sources as ron mentioned to you some of it comes from the colorado river some of it comes from northern california in the central valley project some of it comes from local groundwater wells that we have primarily in the san fernando valley and some of it comes from the eastern sierra all of the water that comes to the city of los angeles comes with certain assets in certain liabilities the waters are different they're very very different and what happens is all of the water has to be treated to federal standards to state california standards and to drinking water standards that we are all accompanied with now there can be within the city differentials as to the water if you live in the north san fernando valley your water source is going to probably be a combination of central valley water and the the water from the eastern sierra if you live in san pedro if you live in wilmington if you live in harbor city a lot of that water is going to come from the colorado river from our two intakes that we have with the met in the south part of the city so you can have differentials we do an awful lot with uh with chlorine and now going to chloramines to uh to treat the water to to make the water meet standards however you can you can at certain times of the year or under certain circumstances see or taste differences in the water for example uh depending on where you're at in the city if you go to your shower and you close a shower up and you crank on the hot water and you turn it onto hot water with no cold water you let it really run real hot and steam up you can get a slight chlorine smell that comes from the evaporation of chlorine as it comes out in hot water you won't experience that with cold water you do the best you can to deal with that within the city of la to try to address that we have gone on a 20-year program of sleeving our main trunk lines and our feeder lines and we also have uh cement lined the inside of the water pipes throughout the city of los angeles we're about 95 percent done with that and uh when you take a water pipe over time you'll help you'll have the buildup of chemicals primarily calcification and other chemicals and that can affect over time the way water tastes well what we've done is we come through with it with this roto-rooter system and you clean out the pipes and then you put a machine on the inside that puts a thin lining of cement that prevents that from happening and uh we think that uh we're doing a good job trying to address that so when we get the water from different sources how is it filtered before we get to it absolutely yeah yeah primarily we have about there we have 10 seconds wrong okay different waters just taste different because of the constituents our job is to give you healthy water our water doesn't necessarily taste as good as bottled water their job is to try and convince you that their water tastes better that's why they make a lot of money and getting back to that the reason i ask you which brand some of you drink crystal glyser crystal geyser water alpine water i don't it's the same you know it's the same as all the rest of these bottled waters where does that come from it comes from atlanta where's alansha it's at the bottom of the owens lake how is that water anywhere different from dwp water it's exactly the same water well they run it through an additional filter yeah they do they do to try and improve the taste that's where we're going in our industry we will continue to filter we're going to ozonation now as the next level of filtration at all our treatment plants to try and address ozonation that's right hey let's give our panelists a big you | LMUstudyLA | UCKET1XIO8QTGMfq60LPjH2A | 2012-07-12 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 17,012 | 89,851 |
UE4aJ3q4H-c | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UE4aJ3q4H-c | Week 10 Studs & Duds + Sinking Ships, Monday Punday | Fantasy Football 2022 - Ep. 1330 | welcome to the fantasy footballers podcast uh this is my fourth or fifth introduction for this video I have not been able to land this so let me just I'm gonna peel back the curtain and let you on the inside of our journey here I had a bad weekend for Fantasy Football I'm hoping you had a great weekend for Fantasy Football we're going to process all of our emotions here we're gonna go through the studs we're gonna go through the Duds I'm glad you're here with us please enjoy the show the fantasy footballer studio is brought to you by Samsung Galaxy visit samsung.com to learn more [Music] welcome to the fantasy footballers podcast with your hosts Andy Holloway Jason Moore and Mike Wright [Music] oh welcome man [Music] Monday November 14th welcome one and all Andy Mike and Jason the fantasy footballers podcast producers in the building today the borgogen papa Josh judge Giamatti uh Papa Josh far too cheery just in general yeah just in life yeah not like this morning just every morning no but on mornings like this when you guys you know you guys are a little bit uh a little sour a little razzled by a by a rough weekend of fantasy football and then here's Papa Josh bouncing off the walls as always in his late 40s I'm not I'm not saying now I know exactly what it was like to be on the Titanic right but I'm not not saying that good good at least we're not being hyperbolic this morning we would never no you are essentially the victim of a large do you know you know the scene where it goes way up and the the people are hitting the propellers oh yeah they're trying way down yeah yeah been there yeah been there metaphorically I am that's my fantasy season oh good so I will be reacting to all that today we've got studs and Duds the weekly rewind we do have injuries to talk about because fantasy football there's a lot of a lot of people out there that's have hit by the injuries also uh Jeff Saturday yeah undefeated just Saturday gets the big win over the incredible Las Vegas Raiders who have still retained their coach they're very similar to a Titanic as well uh but bonjour because I'm sure that we have picked up hundreds of thousands of listeners from Germany after The Sensational game over there the crab was incredible so bonjour what's up everybody and welcome bonjour why does it seem like we're embittered by London Games but now huge fans of Munich games so because the crowd he was singing John Denver yeah the people were incredible and uh not in London anymore or is it because we've been soured on all the London Games being like well the Jacksonville only the yes that doesn't help things uh but also the difference being because of of daylight savings time when everyone else switches their clubs that's right it moves the game to like an acceptable 7 30 or whatever it was yeah so it was a fun game in Germany it got low got a little close at the end ridiculous Geno Smith throws but uh as always we react to a weekend of fantasy football through puns this is how we process the weekend and we put out the requests for submissions and you guys well you did what you always do yes well let's begin here with uh wow Vin cook how about Robert tanyon Cooper hiccup uh wait we're going after Cooper no it's just a hang up in his career okay Greg dullsich I've got another yoner here board Daryl Patterson oh but generic Henry oh generic Henry uh Christian my dear Watson what a game just win Fields I'm in Roars that's so stupid that was difficult that's the one that crosses the lines that's the one that broke it for me Alvin Kamara saquon sparkly smirk Clyde Edwards Despair and squashed Palmer who really let me down yeah Mike couldn't handle Ammon Roar Saint Brown yeah so you didn't have to actually roar I think that was the problem yeah you read it I'm on roar I I disagree you got to sell that thing would you have preferred um what was it Christian wat father because I saw that too that's kind of up your alley changing son to father that's kind of the thing you do oh you know what I mean no okay good I didn't put that one in there either I don't do that one maybe you're just more embittered by your weekend you couldn't Embrace maybe maybe everything's terrible who knows who I mean look from what I understand as the Titanic went down nobody appreciated any puns at that time yeah they probably did not into the news we go by USA well the Rams wide receiver Cooper cup hmm exit with a right ankle injury he will undergo an MRI today initial reports are that he avoided a fractured fibula the concern now is a high ankle sprain which would sideline him for a while he was on a ton of paint yeah it didn't look good uh there's a lot of speculation about the the fibula that it's great news that he didn't break his leg but this you would expect him to miss maybe a month and this is now a Rams team having lost to the Cardinals that is pretty much out of it right last season I don't think that they're trying to rush Cooper cup back to do anything good for the rest of their season that's that's a good point like you could get him back for the playoffs or yeah we we still need more news but just me speculating I'd say there's there's a chance they just shut him down there are implications I mean I've seen people speculate on obj I think there's a zero percent chance he goes to Los Angeles he wants to win I agree but Alan Robinson Ben Jefferson and Tyler Higby uh all going to see necessarily or a necessary increase in utilization well there were an average of 150 targets a game going to Cooper cup so those now will have to go somewhere else I mean the to me I mean we're not in the waiver day of course but low-key Ben scleronic I think might be far more involved than people are expecting yeah I think he's going to be more involved than fan Jefferson will be yeah van Jefferson didn't come into the game until Cooper cup got hurt yeah the ram season is uh it's going down and if you had Cooper cup he was same Rams same it was uh Cooper cup was a you know he's a backbone player for your team yeah zachards left knee injury multiple weeks team believes the ACL is intact he will have an MRI as well but a major knee injury for Zach ertz Rondell Moore will be even more secure yeah Hopkins of course but I mean you've lost Hollywood Brown you've lost stack hurts now and they had a ton of targets and zackers was man he yeah you're right Kyle he looks sad being carted off the field yeah he looked like he knew but Rondell Moore is having a very low-key breakout season yeah I mean we saw in the beginning of the year Greg dolsich in kind of that George thank you Greg George um having a lot of fantasy relevance to start the season kind of in that rondale role and now he's taking it over that was the hope is now you're getting a more talented player getting that utilization there's not a big difference between I mean look the targets for Ron ml 13 10 and 8 the last three weeks he's been a top 20 wide receiver in all of them that's 136 reception pace so or sorry top 24 yeah 7 21 and 17. yep uh big place coupled downfield from that quarterback uh Cole McCoy it was nice to see the Cardinals able to move the ball did you did it did it climb into your mind at all that maybe Jason the offense is all right and the execution is wrong it climbed it looked good it climbed into my mind that maybe the execution is worse than given credit for and all the credit goes to the coaching I still think both are bad juju went down with a very scary concussion yeah he's now in the protocol so uh probably going to miss some time Leonard fournette exited with a hip injury the Buccaneers do go into the buy though so if you were looking to uh get the kind of full workload to Rashad white next week he's not playing yeah it's uh but really really interesting because he did get the start in the game Rashad white started the game but then as the game went on Leonard fournette was out touching Rashad white up into the third quarter then fournette gets injury and Rashad white takes over has his Breakout game so you go into the bye week and you're thinking maybe this will be the time now where this really does become Rashad White's team you know he is a he'll be a top priority pickup um I hate it when you get injury I mean on a weekend like if you go out and play yeah uh Leonard fournette hip injury Khalil Herbert hip injury yeah the the Herbert one we don't I didn't even know about that till this morning yeah they're I don't know that we have much information on it but it was a he left the field and they quickly said he's out so you I mean that's that's just anecdotal at this point but a lot of times when a player is like even uh I think Zach are he got carted off they're like questionable right he might be back and wasn't it late in the game though sometimes that's part of it so perhaps but Cleo Herbert was immediately ruled out so hopefully he's all right Cole came got banged up as well in this game Jerry Judy exited with an ankle injury the uh they're reporting it's not the Achilles but it is the back of the ankle the fact that it's not the Achilles after watching it is that feels like a miracle because it was fully non-contact he went down grabbed his Achilles uh and it looked terrible but if it's just an ankle maybe maybe he's back some time this season I don't know did you see that if they had scored 18 points in every one of their games they would be eight and one the Broncos defense what is happening to you if if you're out there and you're listening to this podcast and you're part of the defense and you're part of the the Denver Broncos defense I am so sorry yeah because you guys are awesome you might be the best defense in the NFL fantastic play good job guys you suck I mean your team sucks with Derrick Henry was in the the pun day getting clowned yeah generic Henry like I mean that takes a pretty strong defense to make that happen and yet another L yeah and now no jury duty for a while yep man can you imagine how good the Broncos would be with Gino that'd be really good it's not even a joke like it's a joke it's said to make a joke but it's actually true I mean what we I think that we still need yeah I'll put it out there I think we still need a little bit of time to know for sure that Russell Wilson is toast with the injuries that like well there are a number a torn lat a bum hamstring yeah the hand last year um yeah the brain the uh the sandwiches yeah no I mean ultimately there's a process for this process one is is going to be to blame the coach I mean if he continues to struggle I can do that if he continues to struggle we'll be 100 Nathaniel hackett's fault yep um then there's injury and then eventually acceptance and that's when you make a trade for like a Drew lock and get your offense going uh Gerald Everett groin injury now DeSean Watson eligible to return to practice this week and can play in week 13. who's Voldemort oh I get it I love it he He Who Shall Not Be Named okay oh my goodness yeah that's a good nickname Voldemort it is uh PJ it's oh man high ankle sprain for PJ Walker Steve Wilkes said Baker's gonna get the start against Baltimore start your Baltimore Ravens defense I don't think I'll ever call him anything but again the rest of my life that's so good it's pretty good man uh Jihan dodson's officially playing tonight JD mckissick's officially out and uh that was today's news and notes presented by USAA Insurance learn more at usaa.com insurance there were good stories there was some there was good stuff let's get into it [Music] this week's fantasy stud muffins go ahead Mike Justin Fields Forever it I mean look it took me you Kyle out but that's all right because Justin Fields is a thing the guy is dominating over the last five weeks uh the leading rusher in the league is quarterback Justin Fields 12 for 20 through the air uh two huge touchdowns to uh start of the week Cole commit who chasing the points came through but 13 for 147 and two on the ground just a week after breaking the regular season single game rushing record for a quarterback puts 147 up this is this is Sensational and so much fun to watch he is on Pace to break the single season record for rushing and he will and he just got started like it's really if you have Justin fields and you were on and you were on the cusp of being a good fantasy team there is a decent chance you can ride Justin Fields into a championship like that is the it's not a guarantee but it is a possibility you do have a bye week coming up but the defense is that bad and the offense is that effective now well the bye week is not for a while and this week coming up Atlanta that's uh yeah I mean I don't even know if that's good he's been better again I mean it's yes it's all good for Justin Fields but it's not as good as playing a good team yeah you want a team that's going to score points and you have to play catch-up if you take out the first two weeks where this new coaching staff was trying to figure out what to do with Justin fields and obviously there's a very completely different offense in the beginning of the year since week three on he's on Pace for a 1500 rushing yard season that's like as good as a running back can do yeah as quarterback so you know I'm seeing questions about trading wise with Justin Fields would you trade them high uh doubt it yeah there I mean usually it's pretty good advice to to trade High when someone's exploding like this but this is the type of player that you if you added him off the waiver wire a week ago two weeks ago I mean when a quarterback is putting up 40 to 50 points in your scoring format doubling every other quarterback I don't I don't know why you would trade at this point of the Season no you just gotta think I think you keep capturing that you know lightning in a bottle for the rest of the year the thing is about Justin fields and I agree with you Andy it's better if he plays a good offense a good team I mean we we saw when he played against the Dallas Cowboys great defense he was a top five quarterback New England in New England he was the top five quarterback but New England's not a good offense no I'm sure but I'm saying the the defense was scary but if you look at the playoffs week 15 week 16 to start your fantasy playoffs the Philadelphia Eagles that's a problem and the Buffalo Bills that's a problem I'm saying I think that could be great for Justin Fields I mean if I don't know how anybody stops what he's able to do if the Buffalo Bills have shown anything over the last couple weeks it's that people can act they can run on them that's true running backs have been having success and if Justin Fields is the running back maybe just don't worry about the opponent in place yep well Patrick Mahomes is really good yep four more touchdowns ran for 39 yards and then uh tuatanga vailoa continues to be hyper efficient this off the offense did not punt yeah the whole game yeah I guess I don't know if they punted once they brought the backups in with two minutes left or whatever but up until two left the field they never punted the football um you know Mike McDaniels got it going with this scheme and they go for it too I don't know how you stopped this offense because what Jeff Wilson and Raheem moster are able to do as a one-two punch on the ground while you have the The Unbelievable one-two punch of Tyree kill and Jalen waddle like I just don't I don't think you can plan for those four players they're too fast it's uh it's been fun to watch in Miami and uh their defense is not strong enough to keep people at Bay so it's been fun to you know it it's crazy because you Miami was a team that was in the Voldemort sweepstakes as well as Russell Wilson situation you know you had oh we got to move on from Tula like Tua is great like he's playing great football 25 for 32 285 and three um it's been impressive what are we gonna do uh uh what are we gonna do uh um in our DraftKings lineups this week without Tyree kill and Jalen waddle because they're Staples yeah they're just they're they're so good but now they're going on by that's so sad I might play them anyway okay yeah that's probably my advice to the did I do that right Kyle for the DFS world do you play them even on by yeah just just lock them in right lock them got it or you you play the the wide receiver one for this next guy for Matt Ryan yeah uh I don't I don't know how Matt Ryan's in these studs uh section I think with 222-1 on the through the air he had a rushing touchdown as well I think it's not you know oh the quarterback scoring was you just want to talk about Matt Ryan is that what quarterback scoring was not fantastic this week but uh Matt Ryan started after the Declaration that Sam Ellen goodger would be the starter for the rest of the season it was a genius move bite and then you fire the coach and you're like oh we should put Matt Ryan back in apparently this was good enough for qb4 on the week it really uh 222 and one through the air I mean look at the ground yeah he had the Run he had like a so he had finished with 38 yards I thought the Run was 39 yards that sounds about right but it was seeing Matt Ryan run down the field through open space it was very exhilarating uh Mike let's be accurate jog he jogged down there okay what well no he was putting the effort in he wasn't jogging he was running we did immediately following his jaunt I'll say okay that's fine um we did I did do a little Google search on his age because I wanted to see how close I was to Matt Ryan's age because that looked like I would have looked going down the field uh I oh no you did you want to say I would have been much faster go on no I I just wanted to confirm it was a 39-yard run good good uh Aaron Rodgers first three touchdown Game of the Year all three of them to the rookie Christian Watson uh this was a game in which the Packers you know 14 completions for Aaron Rodgers yeah established it yeah there was a lot of Aaron Jones and AJ Dylan which makes sense Dak 26 for 46 passed it 26 more times than Rogers in the same game three touchdowns but two picks has Minnesota in Minnesota next week that'll be an exciting game uh Josh Allen was wait Josh Ellen made it on the list I mean it was a disappointing game for him he's definitely struggling right now two picks one touchdown but 84 rushing yards is going to get you on the list okay um let's skip this next guy here at running back uh no I mean look Jonathan Taylor 22 for 147 and one uh he was on the field for 100 of the Colts passing plays let's not forget the Fallout from Naim heinz's trade sure which was you know he was a staple on third down uh getting out there at least for a good portion of them and now Jonathan Taylor healthy yep Raiders Plus explosive plays equals Monster game yeah I mean the the what we've been waiting for is him to be healthy and you just weren't sure how long it's going to take with the coaching change what's gonna happen yada yada well he was back he was healthy Philly next week yeah you don't have a 66-yard run unless you're healthy and obviously that is not the best matchup but they did lose uh was Jordan Davis in the middle of that defense Philly was ran on quite a bit last week weren't they so I'm interested they'll play tonight and we'll see how their their own defense holds up uh we've got other running backs to talk about but I'm going to take a quick break and then come back and talk about Aaron Johnson [Music] foreign for 138 and one Aaron Jones the rb8 on the year doing what he does that's just that seems not fair uh he's super good at football I agree but so many games of being like so the running back 30. so he's been the running back 29 or worse five times so 50 he's like the Aaron Jones of always yeah just saying that it feels unfair for you to be bad 50 of the time but you're like nope I'm running back eight baby well because when he's good he's great and it's it's weird you see these boom bust type of players all the time but they are usually wide receivers who you know the Gabe Davis where you know you yeah when he catches the ball it's usually in the end zone and you get big performances and and low volume you don't see that as much with running backs because their volume is more secure but that's certainly how it is with uh Aaron Jones brooksy do we have playoff primer this Wednesday is that the schedule yes sir so we'll be looking at some of the end of season schedules for these players which is going to be pretty important especially for you know 50 50 guys like Aaron Jones see what they have uh coming down the stretch Tennessee Philadelphia the next two weeks saquon Barkley 35 carries yikes for 152-1 and they tabled extension talks they had brought them up during the bye week but uh no extension yeah yeah I mean it's it's not fair when you get to play Houston um and your saquon Barkley you can expect a massive performance it's also not fair when you get to play the Lions and that is who he gets to play yeah Barkley is doing the old uh wait one more match-up yeah well I can get some more value and then he'll bring the contract back up Dalvin cook had an 81-yard touchdown run went 14 for 119 and one he's the rb9 on the year just behind Aaron Jones yeah great still got it he's still got the juice pull away from people uh James Connor you guys talked about him as a buy candidate yeah he was also a touchdown positive touchdown regression candidate and he scored twice I played 96 of snaps yeah like you know Benjamin didn't even see the field I think maybe one carry One Snap it was all Conor um so never not working it kind of came true and never not working for all the names we mentioned Devin Singletary was another one he ended up scoring twice this week Chris Godwin yeah I was getting a little scared I got into the second targets but I was scared and I wasn't scared they threw the flag on the touchdown I was like No And then they picked it back I gave him a call yeah they I buzzed them I said no this one stands uh but you put uh you put a few bucks down on it right I sure did paid off put a little Sammy put a little Sammy down how often do you bet 55 instead of 50. all every time every single time you go through and look at my bets you go 55 just to get the for the brand it's my unit that may not be the most responsible of getting units no no I'm not I'm not recommending anybody do anything I'm just saying this is what I'm doing that's your unit let's talk about the Miami super backfield uh both Jeff Wilson and Rheem Oster scored a rushing touchdown Jeff Wilson was 17 for 119 and one Raheem moster was eight for 65 and one had four receptions for 22 yards Wilson at two for 24. yeah it feels uh feels really good to have dropped Jeff Wilson after the Christopher McCaffrey trade wow you shouldn't have done that whoops shouldn't have done that uh wow yeah that is um yeah oh because because McCaffrey came over yeah Wilson wasn't traded yet yeah gotcha I mean it was it was just a backup then and then he got traded and now he's the starter for Miami I don't know it seems like the backup to Christian McCaffrey the starter uh bye week for the Dolphins running backs and then they get Houston on the way out to make up for the missed week they'll just tack those double up the points yeah Tony Pollard 22 for 115 first time he's gotten over 15 carries in a game scored a touchdown looked great as always Minnesota next week we'll see yeah if Zeke is soft his words his words not mine Josh Jacobs 21 for 78 and a touchdown he also got targeted a lot in this game you know missing Renfro and Waller we were like oh Matt Collins oh there's Josh Jacobs yeah I think you you will see that more and more he's a very capable pass catcher and they need to utilize him in that game that being said he's on the road in Denver this coming week not a not a great uh matchup they are bad the Raiders oh there's they're real and it's it's unraveling yeah can you start Russell Wilson no no uh did we already have a good game but no Jerry Judy now I wouldn't I wouldn't I'm sure there's someone else we could find but maybe I'd start it's funny because I wouldn't start Russ but I would start Sutton and Greg D against the Raiders so ipso facto Russ should be okay deonta Foreman did it again 31 for 130 and 1 on Thursday night if only he could play the Falcons every single week oh that's who he dominated before right yes what happened last night Christian McCaffrey 14 for 38 on the ground Elijah Mitchell 18 for 89 on the ground targets went to McCaffrey yep touchdown went to McCaffrey was this just hot hand like did Elijah Mitchell have it on the ground that is my interpretation of it because Elijah Mitchell looked great um and McCaffrey was pretty inefficient with with his carries but he got 20 opportunities and if you if you had finished the game like if Elijah Mitchell hadn't had uh not had 18 for 89 you just said well we got 20 opportunities for Christian McCaffrey you'd be like okay that's not bad it feels bad when you put it next to the fact that another running back got 20 opportunities so I mean it just was everything went to the running back position they are they're playing for the playoffs they're going to try and make sure that Christian McCaffrey doesn't get overloaded like he did in Carolina so I'm not I'm not super concerned about it you did have sorry Jason he had 36 opportunities in the previous week so we that's how it feels bad too like his sure his opportunities were nearly cut in half from his super week yeah that being said it was 65 percent of the snaps for Christian McCaffrey 35 of the snaps for Elijah Mitchell okay so I don't I don't see Elijah Mitchell as someone that you can reliably start obviously he got a ton of carries looked great and you might be able to put him in as a flex option but I you know 35 of the snaps he's he is the backup here where if you don't get a ton of work I think you could be disappointed there's a good run Arizona Saints Miami I think Elijah Mitchell like Mike said trying to keep McCaffrey a little bit healthier um he wasn't going to stay healthy with 40 opportunities a game right no it's good for the 49ers it's good for McCaffrey ironically it seems very similar to what they're doing with Jeff Wilson and Raheem mostert from that you know same system that went to Miami like just use both it's funny because it's fantasy players we tell ourselves we want 36 40 opportunities for your player but you can't you know go back in time and say like all right just give me 20 but give me him the whole year like you don't get to go back after an injury and say that like oh no wait just take five opportunities away for the last six weeks and I'd rather keep him on the roster but sometimes that's what it takes yeah I'm always afraid when when Derek Henry has his 35 carry game I'm like okay thank you but maybe calm down a little bit CD lamb let's start at the wide receiver position CD lamb yeah 15 targets 11 for 150 and two Monster game huge week much better than waddle over in a dynasty League yeah any regrets one weekend uh not yet but it was look it was really really nice it was very nice to see a an alpha game with Dak Prescott this is you really haven't uh seen this type of a performance when given the opportunity before and being the number one wide receiver on a week that is awesome is this CD lamp's highest fantasy total in his career I have to yes I had a third I haven't looked it up but yes 31.6 points last year in one game what was it yesterday 32 so this well there you go I think that might have been CD Lamb's best game I just verified it is yep okay yeah I mean that's that's impressive and a tough defense too so Christian Watson eight targets four four one a seven and three this team seems very committed to Christian Watson I mean every time he's come back from a concussion or a hamstring which has been like almost a handful of times they do put them right back out there and Aaron Rodgers does take a chance on that speed two bad drops in this game as well uh thankfully he caught three touchdowns so and they won he's the hero he'll be very interesting going forward as far as can you actually rely on him next week they're at home again the Tennessee Titans defense is beatable by players like Christian Watson specifically I'm sure I'm gonna put him in my lineup and get a goose 42 of the targets for Christian Watson and Mike was bemoaning the usage of Alan Lazard but Aaron Rodgers had eyes for for the youngster well I mean I it made total sense because Watson just kept burning everybody is very fast he's very fast Justin Jefferson 16 targets 10 for 193 one touchdown including the best catch I've ever seen it that's your favorite of all time I think that is my favorite catch I've ever seen better than the Odell Beckham catch it was the old it was the Odell Beckham catch but with a Defender he's got his hands it was a top tier catch it yeah that one in the Edelman one those are the two that come to mind the edelman's Super Bowl double catch the double catch yeah yeah I mean David Tyrese catches in there the the yeah The Tyree situations was makes it elevated as well but the the situation for the Jefferson catch was it was fourth and 18 right if they don't catch this the game is over because the bills would have been able to run out the clock and the defender had two hands on it Jefferson had one and took his lunch money Jefferson is currently sitting at the third most receiving yards by a wide receiver in the first nine games of a season ironically Tyreek Hill is ahead of him this year as well and I mean and Justin Jefferson had a terrible game right am I remember like oh you're saying earlier on the season oh yeah yeah yeah he did I can verify that he's on my league of record team and he had his worst performance ever dare complain about Justin Jefferson I'm not I'm just there but saying to be where he is with the yardage week two 48 yards week three 14 yards he had 14 yards against the Lions yeah and here he is just dominating he's very good Dallas next week yeah he's fine well always and then but Dallas and the New England Christian Kirk bounced back again nine for 105 and two so he's been super used in the red zone and then Devonte Adams nine for one 26 and one 14 targets he was kind of rolling he was he was balling out Stefan Diggs Gabe Davis both had big weeks Gabe Davis six for 93 and one was great to see 12 for 128 for digs including another amazing one-handed catching I mean he jumped twice his height I mean that that bills the bills Vikings game if you didn't get to experience it live I am so sorry for you because that is a game that will be into the history books yes certainly the game of the year the last minute of that game was the wild of Regulation was just wild and practical impossible and uh thankfully the Vikings won and I say that only because on on the the last drive for the bills there was a booth Replay that never happened that should have negated a pretty important play whenever that yeah the Gabe Davis catch that should have been overruled that instead goes to Gabe Davis and helps his fantasy points and there are people out there right now had that play been yep different definitely they win and Gabe Davis doesn't get those points I'm on Ross ain't Brown 11 targets or as Mike calls him I'm on Roar same brown uh 10 for 119. came back to form nice to see as well didn't get into the end zone I don't think he scored since like week two two I was gonna say three yeah that's been a while Paris Campbell oh the awful Tower is back yeah what was this built Beam by beam yes by Matt Ryan seven for 76 in a touchdown three games with Matt Ryan the last three 97 route participation 29 targets 24 receptions three touchdowns Paris Campbell is this year's Hunter Renfro of sorts it is so is so baffling that it I mean it makes sense but I'm saying that seeing these players where if you're matched up with a certain quarterback your career goes to completely different directions because the way that Sam Ellinger played Paris gamble did not get targets he just that that was not the way that that Sam played football but Matt Ryan pairs perfectly with the way that Paris Campbell is used in this offense and like he should it's a better play than Michael Pittman that when I was saying the wide receiver won at the when we were talking about Ryan I was making the joke of it's Paris Campbell because he just he gets non-stop targets he's a he's a better play than Pitman he's three games with Ryan were all top 12 and Naim Heinz is gone yeah like that is not you don't have short area targets with Naim Heinz so we we've all been we've all been kind of like taking the brunt of this whole head coaching change quarterback change situation like Jason traded away Michael Pittman on the basis of we're stuck with Sam Ellinger right uh Jonathan Taylor didn't look great with Sam ellinger's situation moving forward that's been changed Paris gamble too yep uh Kadarius Tony 4 for 57 in a touchdown you had a game where you you already missing Nicole Hardman due to injury and now you're going to be missing Juju Smith Schuster Tony is dynamic yep he's so crazy out there and look we've said this before a lot of people have said this he just looks like Tyree killing that in that short area burst that pretty much no one else on the planet has he's now forced into the lineup as far as you know he's going to be playing a really important amount of snaps I I would assume this next week against the Chargers he's going to be a must start type of player Chris Godwin eight targets six for 71 in a touchdown heads into the Buy he I hope you bought low because and maybe you can buy him because he is on the bye week bye bye bye bye bye uh but you know there was talk by the sideline reporter about Chris Godwin talking about his recovery and his health and the fact that you know he hasn't been able to do the same cuts and be the same player yet but he's feeling like he's finally getting there and he was like this is the time I feel like the breakout's about to happen but now he goes into a week of rest we're coming out for the second half of the Season he should be a really really good fantasy wide receiver I believe Tom Brady leads the league in past attempts by a wide margin yeah but it didn't happen this last week they finally flipped that script I think this was the most rushing attempts in the last three years for a Tom Brady team it shows you that efficiency is sometimes more valuable right yes uh I think the two leading past attempt players Herbert and Brady have struggled for Fantasy purposes this was a game where Brady gotten ends on a couple times tight ends oh he got there fast and then the Duke is slow [Music] down in Cocoa coconut please it's Kokomo I refuse okay uh Can Cole commit please be a thing uh please sure he did get injured or four for 74 two touchdowns yeah we will need to scour the news this week to see if he's good to go becoming a thing at tight end is very easy you just do this once well it's just twice now I know that's so he's definitely a thing come on just be healthy though the injury is a concern Travis Kelsey 6 for 81 in a touchdown on seven targets he's great he'll continue to be great especially with the Titan or the wide receiver injuries Dalton Schultz the doctor I mean we we said this early go get him when Jack returned his four games with decks seven for sixty two five for 49 6 for 74 and now six for 54 at a touchdown yep very solid he is going to be reliable and that is that's at the top of the resume for the tight end position reliable Juwan Johnson scored again uh Foster Moreau scored and uh Tyler Higby eight yep for 73 yep uh with no Cooper cup moving forward Tyler Higby will become Mr necessary yep after very bad week's big start against Arizona a lot of garbage time uh with Mr Wolford as well done time sure pooped in his big boy pants [Applause] it is just not happening for Justin Herbert this year his his pants are shrinking by the moment it is not his fault no it isn't I mean you just have lost all of your weapons when you don't have Keenan you don't have Mike Williams you lose Gerald ever I mean Gerald Everett was probably his best weapon on the field think about what I just said Gerald Everett was his best weapon and then he loses that it's not it's not fair he is completing 66 percent of his passes which he did last year and the year before so everything that you know from completing passes perspective you just don't have explosive plays he's giving him short yeah and uh Joshua Palmer did not do him any favors yesterday I will say that that is true Mike watching the game having Joshua Palmer I was very disappointed with how often the checkdowns came so they're you know guards per attempt is down by 1.2 and the offensive line is hurt yeah they've dealt with so many injuries and they're still a good team they are still in that playoff hunt uh the you know they won or they were leading for a lot of that game last night but he needs Playmakers and he has very few right now do you think uh Mike has any regrets about Mr Andy Dalton yeah it did not work out those are Underpants filled they are filled and you can't they don't absorb no no that's you've been sitting in it that's why you wear them uh uh yeah it was the first step I agree but I thought that he would be able to get it done in the first half we were trending to exactly what you need of about 200 plus and two touchdowns but second half really fell apart there was why won't they play Jameis Winston I don't know I do not have any idea what's going on with the quarterback room and they're insisting to put uh Andy Dalton it's not been great for olave with Andy Dalton and it's not been great for the Saints I don't know their season's lost I mean obviously it's it's over and now it's you know what do they do for the future a quarterback it's very bizarre like James I don't know to me like I'm an outsider but it seemed like James was playing fine and then he had a what fractures in his back uh an article came out I didn't get a chance to read the full article but it was Jameis Winston saying that he was told he would not be replaced if he took some time to heal and he got replaced by Andy Dalton because it sounds like James is actually healthy and could play now maybe he gets back in next week though we shall see Russell Wilson Tom Brady Jimmy G Brady was uh 258-2 how is that a bad finish in the Matt Ryan is a good finish I'm so confused the the Matt Ryan had 13 eight yards and a rushing touch he had an extra passing touchdown if you count as rushing yards okay all right Jimmy G got it done but the uh you know the win what was what was the record ten and two ten and two Jimmy Garoppolo is ten and two when throwing for zero touchdowns I mean the team is just the team is so much better when you don't throw touchdowns that was that a possible stat I mean this that's wild he's great at inspiring from the Huddle yeah you have to score to win a game he's like Christian I'm gonna hand this ball to you so good you you take care of it Eliza you beat the missile I'm gonna get I can put that ball right in your tummy tum and then you run maybe it makes the defense play harder because they know that you know maybe it's frustrating for the other defense when they're like guys it's Jimmy Garoppolo this should not be a problem and then you just start slowly losing like guys we shouldn't be losing to Jimmy Garoppolo and then they say very handsome they could be looking at him oh yeah yeah the handsome Factor yeah he just pink oh the wink yeah and then that lets the running backs go wild Alvin Kamara eight for 26. dude what the Pittsburgh defense is much better with TJ watt they were sure in the beginning of the year they lost what they were bad but they got what back they were good the the my biggest what is 12 opportunities for Alvin Kamara their drives were ending so quick in a game that was like very close I I think it was 10 to 10 at the half so it was the usage was very bizarre anti-dalton that's that's my policy the usage it wasn't like they weren't getting Khmer involved it was what Andy said they didn't have very many plays it was three and out he had 89 percent of the running back Rush attempts like he he got it all there just wasn't anything to have because it was a very defensive battle in this game they're telling me that there was a total of nine running back Rush attempts that's what the math would imply had eight and you said 89 that's weird Derrick Henry 19 for 53 did not break the big one and that hurt you against Denver's stunt defense yeah I believe is the word you're looking for yes I feel like Papa Josh was nodding that it was a word no just staunch is a strange word staunch is good word staunch daunt is a new one staunt isn't a word right uh staunch is is a good word but it also one of the things that it it just sounds smelly staunch yeah oh like something gets stuck in your staunch uh no oh not like that but like you know it's just uh if it's stinky it's the the actual definition is loyal and committed in Attitude yeah yeah I have a staunch opinion about you know well I thought I had a staunch opinion about Jason Hill but I'm starting to flip yeah [Laughter] people yeah I mean it's somebody who who is invested in Crystal Lobby yeah you know it just feels like you are tossing an anvil off the back of your boat when you're finally piecing a drive together and I know Tayson Mills very much when he plays great you're happy yeah and when he doesn't you can make fun of it but man he's annoying me right now because he's been coming into these games and doing nothing that's the party pack I feel like you're better off like why isn't this offense willing to just play him a quarterback at least you'd have the Justin Fields Pathway to success for the Saints offense yes the EV everything that's going on with the Saints right now is makes no sense no no very stauntlet uh Austin Eckler DeAndre Swift oh DeAndre Swift what is happening you might have DeAndre wift on your trade yeah DeAndre Swift is just simply not healthy and that's seen by them having him you know sub 30 snaps he's not on the field that much they're trying to help him get healthy and until I mean what's crazy is he got another touchdown so he's like he almost had two right should have had two that jumped the goal line was Kyle pretty comical Kyle I can't read that definition yeah yeah but but there is apparently a urban state is a word well that's an urban dictionary oh yeah nope nope yep it's it's um hide your kids it's a word that I won't use ever again uh cordarrell Patterson what happened in that game I don't know Avery Williams was getting carries and and it was important like end of game drives for the Falcons and Cordero wasn't anywhere to be seen like do you have any insight there Kyle yeah they gave it a third down Carrie to Williams that was like mind-blowing it was an important down yeah so no comment no comment from the Atlanta truthers out there you don't understand the usage I know Patterson did come out and he had been having to respond to a number of tweets related to Fantasy production don't tweet at Players but he did take it in stride at least do you know his handle uh uh I don't remember it it's I don't remember the whole thing but it is is C something P but he spells out P like p-e-e very quality um it's a good old P joke right in the Twitter handle I was trying to find him but there's a lot of verified Cordell Patterson oh man I'm not gonna be able to find it that's funny is that true is that just a good job oh that's a good joke I I sincerely can't find him but um yeah there you go uh let's talk about a couple other players here David Montgomery has been declining right like fantasy production under 10 points for three straight weeks these are games that the Bears are scoring 30 points and he's not producing he's a backup running back to the starting running back who gets the ball first every time the ball goes into the hands of Justin Fields it's very difficult when he Fields is rushing for 150 yards to have anyone else do anything good now that being said if Khalil Herbert misses time we don't know the you know the depth of that hip injury but if you combine what Khalil Herbert and David Montgomery have been doing you got a rb4 you have a you have a decent running back there yeah that would be something to watch this week especially with bye weeks for some other players uh you might not pivot away from David Montgomery quite yet as tempting as it might agree Travis CTN not a good game against Kansas City 11 for 45 did have three targets for 28 yards I'll just let it go Jericho Hasty is seeing the field too much agreed it's he is not hasty he needs a different name uh elaire oh man do you have we have the sad music uh I'm sure we've got some sad music I mean just his stat line a zero for zero on the ground yes go on uh he did see two Targets but his final stat line in the receiving game was also zero for zero saw six percent of the snaps first round pick I got three more letters for you Clyde Edwards bye bring your evening yes that's right you nailed it first try Mike bring your evening I think you were with me Jason I have no idea he was he was just spelling by yeah goodbye I mean Clyde is uh he doesn't represent anything positive for your fantasy roster so to me I'd rather drop the bomb on the waiver wire let somebody else put him on their roster because his name is 100 in games that they're going to be able to run it's gonna be Isaiah Pacheco in games that they have to throw it's going to be Derek McKinnon do you know I'm looking this up uh it appears he played Four total snaps one was around the goal line yeah yep and we literally didn't know who it was we had watched the game so long it was like who is that do you remember him from years past they made the wrong pick yeah which made a lot of us make the wrong pick Mr Reed yeah Bray he's Brian Westbrook that's anything no that's Andy Reid no please do it again he's the wildest running back in the wilderness glad get on the bench clad I got a seventh rounder to replace you oh let me give you a mustache here's Brian Westbrook you know trying to imbue that Brian Westbrook into Clyde hey they were the ones that were telling me these things right that's not on you no should have drafted Jonathan Taylor Dave would be really really good with Jonathan Taylor should have traded for cream hunt get him back on the roster Kareem Hunt's not being used happening with Kareem hunt why did you not trade him yeah you stupid Browns you're not gonna use him and you're gonna just not let him go anywhere and have relevance oh that's so upsetting Kareem pun him off a bridge right now I mean they I guess if you're looking at you know the pick situation they if Kareem hunt goes and and signs anything of a relevant contract they could get a third round pick uh added just because of of the compensatory and maybe no one was willing to trade uh three and so they just said hey we'd rather wait on the three than take a four Kareem hunt is uh not doing it for your fantasy team I'd rather have Hunter Montgomery rest of season Montgomery okay easily yeah yeah I'm running 70 of the snaps as opposed to 30 percent of the snaps that's what that's what Kareem hunt played it's just dumb when they were losing that's his lowest of the year they're losing the whole entire game Kareem Hunt is a very talented pass catching running back and he saw one target yeah Nick Chubb had uh four targets I mean it's it's wild all right let's Blitz these uh disappointing wide receivers so that people don't have to think about them too long no um so I'm gonna bring up names that I think you could have some real concern with okay uh there were dud games for Evans and waddo whatever no one cares yep you keep playing them but Debo Samuel let's talk about Debo because this was a game that they won and Brandon iuk had 84 yards receiving he did Debo had 24 yards receiving on two catches he had four carries but Debo has not got it going this year now this was the first week back from an injury and also it was that's four straight games for Brandon iuk with 80 plus yards yeah and I I guess I'm curious your opinion guys on you know Jason you brought up trading low for Chris Godwin ahead of his breakout performance touchdown is Debo fitting that category for you where you look at him right now as the he's the wide receiver 26 on the year okay that doesn't sound so bad but what do we got like one two finishes inside the top 26. yeah I I don't view I don't view Debo as a trade for Target that's not to say he doesn't have good games here or there along the way he's super talented you can't tackle him easily if you look at this last game you know he was on the field for 87 of the snaps that's that's how he's always been used he's not you know because of the the scheme there you don't have 100 of snaps for uh Debo so his utilization is fine but now with Christian McCaffrey I've got worries like yeah playing well Brandon 80 yards four games in a row George Kittle you know Debo there's just not enough this isn't a team that I think is going to go out there and score 35-40 points on a regular basis they have a great defense and they run the ball this is a team that I think is going to win a lot of games with uh you know 20 to 24 points and when you divide that up amongst a lot of good options including Christian McCaffrey it's going to be inconsistent for the pass catchers George Kittle will have a good game Brandon and I you go have a good game and Tebow will have good games but they won't be consistent and they won't be weekly happy starts Crystal lava was just three for forty any concerns there I mean if it's Andy Dalton yeah Joshua Palmer 3 for 44 has not really again I'm disappointed in the season for Joshua Palmer sure I thought he was capable of becoming more of a I mean especially 100 yards last week you know a part-time Alpha right when your other guys are down Darnell mooney4 for 57 uh whatever it is what it is Chase Claypool hasn't done anything yet uh let me bring up um let me bring up a couple of players one is Amari Cooper who Kyle I mean this road Amari Cooper I mean he can't amazing he can't do it right I mean give me the road totals he's like two for 20 on average yeah this is the simulation that's confirmed when he's on the road just I mean how do you how do you do that though he's got Buffalo in Buffalo next week on the road yeah no thanks put him down set him Cortland Sutton is a really difficult discussion because it is attempting to find a ruby in a pile of manure dookie yeah in a pile of just I mean I don't want to dig through the manure to hopefully find a gym inside of it so there's part of me that just wants to distance myself from this offense Cortland Sutton was six for 66. that is the mark of the beast another reason to stay away um that wow Josh have you never heard that joke we tell that joke like every three weeks on this show uh but this one this time is real however the Raiders however no Judy however Russell Wilson I mean Sutton is probably a flex play right now targets so this isn't me giving you a oh he had 35 percent of the targets when there was none but 11 raw targets that's brah raw he also had a couple of great catches where he had to go up and Moss someone he was coming back to the ball falling had to reach behind him on a bad throw caught the ball against the Raiders I'm putting Cortland Sutton in my lineup this next week he'll have the target percentage the the matchup is uh great and yeah you're just you're certainly disappointed with six for 66 this last week but Talent opportunity just wish he had a quarterback yeah one deal man Rondell has been useless yeah just to go backwards real quick I did look up the specific splits for Amari Cooper uh home and wrote 21 points on average at home impressive five on the road I mean they are he he he basically is dominating right now at home averaging 10 targets at home 90 receiving yards at home 30. he's got a killer mattress is that what he did I was trying to think is is it his local Wi-Fi or something I'm like very comfortable he's getting whatever rest he gets at home he doesn't get on the road yeah Kyle I was I was having Kyle pull up some of the uh separation numbers for Cortland Sutton because we've all we've seen something throughout his career be able to high ball you know go up and get get it and make a competitive catch and he's always been good at that um numbers you sending me Target separation is ranked 82nd in the league so that would be uh I mean that's way down there for a guy that's supposed to be a a number one wide receiver I wonder why he you know he just disappears he's disappeared his whole career and it's bewildering so but Las Vegas If You're Gonna Play him that's the best matchup you can without jury duty wandell is uh like I said he's doing nothing yeah wandela is doing absolutely very very disappointing that we haven't seen the numbers increase I mean he's not uh at this point with bye weeks I don't roster in one Dale that's fine Al Lazar three for 45. yeah and it was it was all one huge catch in overtime uh it's this is very TBD because Alan Lazard has been quite good on the season the question will be Christian Watson is that breakout something that that the team is looking of this is what we were waiting for we will now heavily feature Christian Watson and Alan lizard is the wide receiver too for the team or was this just a very specific match-up that Watson was able to exploit they get Tennessee next week the passing volume we said it was very very low for Aaron Rodgers uh so I would still be playing lizard next week but eyes will be on it Jason Brandon Cooks had seven targets four for 37. that's kind of touchdown called back yeah that's kind of what he's done this year is uh enough targets to be okay not enough production to be good for Fantasy um obviously he gets that touchdown he's not in this section but it was nice that he was back out there and I do think that in the right match up you can still start him going forward all right real quick here uh disappointing tight end performances Kittle Everett with the injury yeah fire mute four for 36 with really a struggling uh Kenny Pickett like he seems very limited right now and that's going to hurt Hawkinson 7 for 45 I take that that's not that's not a bad game at all no way Oxon had 10 targets haters back there delete it Hawkinson is a big part of the Vikings um Kyle pitts2 for 28 Greg Dolce one for 11 Robert 10yon one for eight uh yeah I mean the good news for Greg Dolson she was still out there essentially like every snap this it's a he could take advantage of his offense problems of the Judy situation he could and they get the Raiders yep so I think Greg D can climb into your lineup especially if you lost uh a tight end like Zachary ertz to injury taysom Hill outscored Clyde Edwards the layer by one yard this one is putting into perspective climb that Hill shout it from the top Mike this is oh this is your time to shine I mean he's coming back for like oh I know 400 yards I know next week that's this is the game that you play when you're anti-taysom Hill is they'll name him the starter next week like you know those the old school movie fights where it's just completely unblocked Haymakers oh yeah and you just absorb it and then you you just trade them that's that's me and take some Hill it's it's just good good fun anybody else you want to talk about Jason no nobody else uh I'm sure there will be massive Duds on my roster tonight in Monday Night Football good to see we could uh bringing it back where it belongs in my heart division leader over here Jason Moore on the way to the playoffs just uh you know emotionally processing the season we all want to win too we all want to win let's let's uh let's see what happens tonight well we got a big waiver show tomorrow lots of Juicy names yep I wonder uh I wonder who we're gonna talk about it's such a mystery tomorrow everybody enjoy the game tonight stay safe goodbye thank you for listening to another episode of the fantasy footballers podcast join our fantasy football community on jointhefoot.com and follow us on Twitter at the FF ballers [Music] | The Fantasy Footballers | UC-No2ITxJsNt50oJQ3fLmUA | 2022-11-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 11,073 | 56,619 |
JLfYouzso5I | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLfYouzso5I | Fast 2 Raven timing push vs Terran l StarCraft 2: Legacy of the Void l Crank | okay the image of is random versus Terran in Mac Depot I get a place some MIDI game timing pushes you super aggressively I could render old Karen okay I got her on okay here it is super aggressive meter game timing push okay let's go let's go let's go go let's go let's go let's go go I kind of wanna play some cyclone tank double Raven by King Mary not a lot of other stuff like that after stock on the base the to do to do to do to this thing okay Barack's I did a guess first Oh - let me - no more three okay no more than three doo doo doo doo doo oh I should get sick of the gif oh my god what am I thinking oh my god I will have less guests and I want you know all tomorrow Biscay YouTube channel I found some really old awkward videos of you oh really which video is it what did i do there what kind of dumb am i doing there antara Skippy command center upgrade complete of a Reaper my factory has to be like this we know you progress if I bill to second guess earlier dammit god dammit did I want to go to a double rival right can I have to make it some hair day onwards I come first right before tax wrap intervals to check English over your humid ah any inverter what all of you do Kyle I want to repair it for we redid it the city first normally I don't know they don't they do they know community I could to more great others great I tell me the main resource and so I hedaan complete what's going on okay let me bearded more bops and give it away dear me man filter upgrade complete no you know and I don't marry okay let me go to buy King marine two tank Oh Ted okay insufficiency yes addition was the fibers required insufficient so let's go let's go let's go let's go go this will be not less hotel I'm preparing another opportunity so let's go let's go go let's go let's go let's go take your request engineer engineering and your head on completely head on complete who algae algae here nothing here nothing there nothing oh my god this is great okay this is nothing okay high five scanning | Crank | UCS2OAdHoLt-9T6cG9A2H49Q | 2017-08-18 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 409 | 2,007 |
jdGE3RH4o7o | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdGE3RH4o7o | Red, White, and Blue Labour at The World Transformed 2018 | so no matter how many times it's been pronounced dead the nation still resurfaces as a key kind of category through which people identify politically or through which different political ideologies are articulated and particularly in the wake of the Windrush scandal hello particularly in the wake of the Windrush scandal and the Scottish independence referendum the rise of nationalist governments across the global north and with brexit looming ever closer on the horizon ideas around national identity and what it means to belong to a community are once more at the heart of our politics so this panel is going to address Labour's historic relationships with communities of color and ask the question if national whether or not nationalism has a place in the labor movement whether it's possible to win over an electorate and challenge racism at the same time in a context of heightened xenophobia and we're also going to be thinking about the future of citizenship under labour so I'm going to introduce our panelists and then we will kick off because you came to see them not me so we have a shocker who is a senior editor at Navarro media and a lecturer in global politics at Anglia Ruskin University and the Sandburg Institute we have koto quorum who is a lecturer at Birkbeck law school and his research interests include questions around international law empire and race we have morris basment who is a political theorist Labour peer and the founder of blue labor and we have Josh Denham who is the former secretary of state and the director of the English Labour Network so ash we're gonna start with you crap I heard it I've heard it said that you can't even say your English anymore otherwise they'll lock you up and arrest you or frown at you or make you feel that you're some kind of illiterate racist bigot and I've come here to echo all of those sentiments and that I'm going to go home I'm actually not interested in questions of identity which sounds like a strange way to start off this discussion and also I helped write the copy for it so I'm just gonna say that I found my own copy very boring I'm not interested in identity do you want to identify yourself as British go for it you want to identify yourself as English go for it you want to identify yourself as European the citizen of nowhere part of the People's Republic of palmer's green even better and go for it to me that is not either an interesting or a powerful question because it's a question which on some level doesn't need to be asked or challenged in people where do you belong the answer is obvious the answer is wherever it is we find ourselves how we identify ourselves within the community in which we live for me the much more interesting question is not where do we belong but how do we belong what do these processes look like what are the mechanisms of exclusion and then perhaps as a backdrop to it which I know that comrades Kojo Quran will elucidate on at length is well why do we belong what are the historical forces that shape it on this question of how do we belong it's never quite as simple as simply being born in a place or being able to move to a place I'm not an immigrant I was born in North London I've hardly ever moved from there apart from one brief sojourn South London and then no one came to visit me so I moved back but still I am racialized as a migrant the process of racialization doesn't care about facts it cares about a structure of feeling which has had decades if not centuries to be formed similarly when we think about this process of racialization how arbitrary it is I think about what it means to be racialized as a Muslim so I'm a Muslim I've never claimed to be a particularly good or observant one and wait until I hit 30 and then I'll you know change my ways but I'm still racialized as a Muslim in this country in other countries that I go to I'm not racialized as a Muslim an example of not having to be Muslim to be racialized as one is John Charles de Menezes shots and killed whole station not a Muslim but Brown enough to die as one and this is really important for thinking about the nation-state for thinking about how these arbitrary processes of racialization which fundamentally aren't about how we see ourselves but how we are seen by the state apparatus by how we see one another and how we construct a social reality all of these things affect whether or not the nation-state is itself a malleable enough container for a progressive or indeed a radical politic the reason why I focused so much on race when I talk about the nation-state isn't because I think that nation-states are necessarily inherently racialized but because in practice and in history nation-states are the formation of nation-states and the formation of race as a technology of governance these things happen at roughly the same time in history and was interesting to me isn't just the twinning together of race and nation states as both fixed categories but that both have been remarkably kaleidoscopic they go through periods of change and transformation according to different or political and economic needs at different points in history and I think that since the end of colonialism the end of Empire in this country there has been a trauma a collective trauma from which this country has never really recovered and in the words of one of my esteemed panelists Kojo and also a friend of mine quorum nation journey it is the trauma that Britain had its ass handed to it by people was that it considered racially inferior so immigration becomes a much more loaded question one not about our identity in how we see ourselves but how we are seen by the rest of the world it is a constant reminder of this trauma right the idea of these peoples who had you know handed Britain its ass coming to this country making demands have been demanding to be seen as citizens and not subject is inherently a challenge to British national identity in how the state functions and so then we see these processes which inhibit our ability to belong as citizens like anyone else some of these social processes are informal if not explicitly backed by the state of sometimes police by the state so we're thinking about you know racial harassment you know racially targeted hate crimes these are crimes but we know that these crimes aren't taken nearly as seriously as crimes against other members of society I think here of BG&E Brahimi killed in Bristol a few years ago because he was racialized as a Muslim he was racialized as migrant whose very presence was an inherent threat and so after being targeted and harassed by pretty much his whole estate who was murdered his lawyer accused the police of institutional racism in this regard so here's an informal but deeply powerful deeply violent social process which inhibits our sense of belonging in the nation-state the experience of racism and violence and then there are laws which are shaped and not necessarily inherently racialized but in practice they are racialized so something like the prevent agenda which to me will for me hits particularly close to home because as a teacher as someone who lectures it inhibits my ability to have open and frank and direct conversations with my students in teaching I'm scared that one of them might end up getting reported to police or I myself might get end up getting reported to police we know that disproportionately the prevent agenda affects our ability as Muslims or indeed people racialized as Muslims to exercise that foundational premise of democratic participation freedom of expression and then there are then there are processes which are formally racialized processes and here I'm thinking in particular of immigration detention deportation we remember the New Labour era as an era about cosmopolitan values where there is a state's multi multiculturalism in which we can all feel represented right it's an inherently diverse project and there are things that I think we should look back on and celebrate the Macpherson report was a huge step forward the race relations at 2000 another huge step forward but one of the funny things about the race relations act 2000 is that a certain group of people are made exempt from it so in a sense could racially discriminate those people were immigration enforcement the race relations act 2000 was essentially calling open season on Tamil migrants on Somalian migrants on Afghan migrants so these are all things which inhibit our sense of belonging so what's our solution to this as leftists as progressives as people that want to see as all of us want to see on this panel a Labour government is it fighting anti racism in terms of what you can or what you can't identify as is it merely a project of endless critique and analysis no we want a point of traction right and I think that that point of traction for us and our central demand will have to be a rien tera Gatien of citizenship itself how can you make citizenship which so far has been a process of excluding many people of color and people who are racialized as other in different ways from the body politic how can you make it a much more inclusive project well perhaps rather than thinking of citizenship as a set of Rights conferred by a state as a set of obligations that we will have to our community and to our society rather than thinking of citizenship is something that you pay for quite literally pay for we could think of it as a mandatory obligation which you have after a certain amount of years in residency now this was once a core part of anti-racist movements demanding residency rights not just citizenship rights and then we can think of what some of those politicized obligations that we have are perhaps it is making sure that your tax money is paid in the United Kingdom here and then we can start calling into the question the citizenship arrangements of those financial elites you seek to benefit from our society and yet not pay into it this is the kind of and bold anti-racist policymaking that the Labour Party should be embracing we can't just tinker around the edges of an unjust immigration system we have to strike at the very heart of it and upend what it is it's meant to do thank you so much for listening [Applause] okay um up next we have John okay thank you very much and very pleased to be here I want to make four brief points one to agree with Ashe before almost completely disagreeing with her other question of identity not in what she said about fighting racism but on the identity issue the point where I agree with her is there is no right or wrong and there is no must about identity if it doesn't matter to you it doesn't matter to you and you don't if you not English or British that doesn't matter it's not saying there should be an identity that everybody has to sign up to but in terms of whether the left should respond to these questions of identity we do disagree which is why I'm here I think I want to argue that the left and not just in this country but certainly right across Western Europe needs to learn to argue it's politics in part at least in the language of progressive patriotism secondly I will make a few points about the evolution and importance today of British and English identity and I want to share some thoughts finally about the less response I start from this point if our politics are for the many not the few it raises the question of who are the many the many two people on the left two people are socialists can't be a consistent struct just a list of all of those who are not part of the 1% or part of the 5% for Democratic socialists the many if we're going to change society at all must have a sense of who they are as the many they must have a shared identity a set of responsibilities towards each other and a determination to work together to build a different Society this is not a matter of simply electing a government that's going to make things better even she can get the other government elected in the first place for much of the left's history the core of that many that sense of shared identity was born in the unionized industrial working class and the communities and collective identity that they shared but because of economic change not political change that core class consciousness is today much weaker and shared by fewer people because fewer people have that experience but people in societies across Western Europe being people still crave a sense of shared identity and if you like whether we like it or not increasingly that identity is expressed as the identities of nation of people and of place and the problem is that the left across Europe has failed to respond or engage partly because of its distrust of patriotism and of national identity it's been left to the right to engage so the rights have been allowed to define nation as something inward-looking and hostile the people in ethnic terms and it's taken root most in places and amongst people who feel that they have lost most from globalization and the failure to engage is a real problem because of a fundamental feature of democratic politics before many people would engage with policy or ideology they asked a much more visceral question can I trust this person can I trust this party to stand up for people like me so if people feel patriotic and whether this audience does or doesn't doesn't really matter because most people do feel patriotic and if they are rather more people in England who feel English more than they feel British and if Labour comes across as anti patriotic if Labour seems to ignore English identity or worse disparage it then we fail to make that very important initial connection these people they think will fail to stand up for people like me because they are not people like me and of course labour often does come across like that now not everybody feel like that of course but many people do and very often there are people that we should want to represent because they're the people who have suffered most from globalization and we actually need them to vote for us because they live disproportionately in the smaller English towns we must win at the next election and they make a larger part of the electorate there so if Labour does not come across as a patriotic and English party and not saying that's all we should be of course but at least in part we will do badly we will probably not win but that means thinking about our identity more cleverly than we often do because identities are complex and both are major identities in this country English and British which are the most commonly held they're both contested they're both contested between right-wing exclusive ideas and progressive inclusive identities now I would argue we'll see what others say that compared with 40 years ago we have had significant victories in the argument about Britishness and I would argue that we're much closer to winning arguments about Englishness than many on the Left assume let's remember that 30 years ago many on the left argue that Britishness would never be open to non-white communities because of its association with imperialism and racism yet today it's black and minority ethnic communities who are if anything more likely to identify with Britishness than the country as a whole and that change was largely brought about not by the goodness of white liberals but by people who are not white demanding the right to be British on an equal status to everyone else no British myths of course are we touched on this is partly an argument about an equal citizenship in which everyone is fully included Englishness is not a citizenship because you cannot be an English citizen so it's more of a cultural struggle and partly because English is not a citizenship it has become widely understood as something you get from being born here not being born to white parents but by being born here so it's not as easily available to new migrants as we saw this summer with the football the idea that you have to be white to be English is very much a minority view unless amongst the young the less by ignoring these questions has actually made things worse we are land the far right forty years ago to take the Union Jack and we're in danger of allowing groups around Tommy Robinson to claim the son George cross yet eighty percent of the people who live in England say they feel strongly English now that either means there's an awful lot more fascists than most of us have been counting on or actually there's an awful lot of people who feel English are proud to be English who aren't associated with a far right and a final point if we don't engage with Englishness because it does have some right-wing associations we cut ourselves off from the radical elements of English history and so as I getting the nod I'll make this the last point this is probably my 42nd Labor Party conference it's extraordinary really if you put it like that but what I used to come in the 1970s and listen to Tony Benn you often got in part a lecture about English radical history about the Levellers the charts is the peasants revolt because they were an explicit part of his socialism and if we cut ourselves off from Englishness because of its right-wing associations we also cut us off from part of our own history which can still be part of our own inspiration [Applause] thank you very much John next up we have a coach Oh brilliant hello everybody thank you for having me this is actually only my second leave a conference or not at 42 are the same levels as John so in terms of electoral strategy I will probably defer to my other panelists but what I instead want to talk to you about is to share with you a little bit of my analysis of the way in which the narrative around Britishness and the way in which the narrative around our own national history is often a missing part of our understandings of the potential potency the nationalism can be as an organizing political principle specifically what I want to focus on is the extent to which an imperial amnesia tends to color in our understandings of what Britishness is and what it can be in the 21st century I hope to win you all over to this argument and firstly because Ash has introduced me as someone who goes around bragging about how I handed English people their ass and but you know I grew up around these areas I know how dangerous talking about handing people's ass can be so what a first of all qualify my understanding of that a little bit further but also because I think it's an important part of trying to understand what this particular political movement is within the United Kingdom so it's interesting to be here talking about nationalism again as an academic it wasn't so long ago that with the rise of globalization it was commonplace for academics to talk about the end of nationalism a rise of integration within different countries um bilateral and multilateral trade agreements such as NAFTA ensuring that those greater economic coherence between nation states the supposed promise of supranational organisations like the European Union like the Organization of American States like the Economic Community of West Africa you know seem to indicate perhaps nationalism no longer being a significant question in the 21st century but when academics often a something the end of whether it's the end of history end of nationalism that's often the kiss of death so if you ever see anyone name anything like that it might be about to make a political resurgence and that's what we've seen with nationalism everywhere from the Philippines to France from Turkey to the United States and so I think that leads us here in the United Kingdom a country that has always had a certain distaste for overt flag-waving kind of the crude nationalism of places like the United States it leaves us with a question of how is this going to influence and in fact politics within this particular country and for me when thinking about nationalism with the United Kingdom I think you have to start by understanding that the project of Britain was always an imperial project as in it wasn't it's not it's not accurate to describe the idea of Britain as a nation that had an empire it's part it's more accurate to think about Britain has been constituted by the Empire itself from the act of the Union all the way through the allegiances between the different functions of the United Kingdom the imperial project both produced and sustained the United Kingdom up until the colonisation the mid 20th century and ease of transition into supranational organisations like the European Union and you could even argue that at this particular historical moment we're actually wrestling with the question of what it means to be an independent British nation for the very first time why that's particularly relevant is because I think it runs completely counter to the narrative of Britishness that we all often accept due to a perception of an island nation due to a history that in fact marked by moments of ideals of anti-imperialism as opposed to imperialism Britain has a quite a quite distinct national story from its perhaps recorded history if you think about the kind of most familiar moments of history we'll be talking about the defeat of the Spanish Armada we'll be talking about the defeat of Napoleon in Waterloo with you talking about the narrative of Britain standing alone against the fascist threat in the Second World War these are ideas of an independent island nation state standing up against an imperial Appirio aggression and a thinks of something that the brexit ears understood very well that's how the narrative eyes dwell the brexit moment was the idea that Britain needs to be independent again against the imperial ambitions of the European Union that's a pretty unique national story or a pretty confusing national story for a country that had the largest empire in recorded history in terms of scale population in terms of landmass and I think that this is something that's very much arrayed within our own understandings something I'd like to do with a few my students to show the extent of which we have a certain Imperial amnesia as opposed to the debate around whether we should be proud of our imperial past or whether we should be ashamed of our imperial past I argue to my students we don't know about our imperial past it's completely erased and I'm just gonna take a couple of minutes or just a minute never couple minutes left to share see see whether this thing works out with this audience it doesn't work out with my students we know they're young undergraduates I'm sure the savvy world transformed audience will be able to overcome this and it's a very simple game I play called they bring colonized or not where you offer two different countries one of which was part of the British Empire the other one wasn't and to see how many people able to identify the right country so I'm just gonna start off with a couple of examples were running out of time one example is a combination between Kuwait and Qatar one of them was part of the British Empire one of them wasn't I just get hands raised for who thinks q8 was part the British Empire can I get hands raised for who thinks Qataris by the National Empire better than usual so was q8 correct and that was the majority solutely can I ask another one Lesotho or Gabon class hands of Lesotho which is part of the National Empire yeah can I have hands which think Obon was again the majority do you choose answer to but a few people did of course choose the wrong countries and both examples and a lot more people decided not to put the hands up because they were like I have no idea and I think that that reflects like I say this amnesia that we have about what Britain has been and where Britain has been and without an understanding of the scale of the British Empire I think it's very difficult to try and use nationalism as a vehicle through which to understand a lot of the problems that are facing this country today without a full interrogation understanding of the scope of empire I don't think we can understand issues such as the prices around the Irish book question that we're facing at the moment without understanding of British imperial history we can't understand what is the trajectory that even makes the stage have the demographics that it has today what is the trajectory that brings people from Ghana or from Bangladesh or from Egypt or from Jamaica to the United Kingdom today where those perhaps coming from what is the economic division of labor that led to the kind of separation and wealth that we see between the north of England the South of England why a cities like the city Liverpool like other in northern industrial cities that were built for specific purpose suffering with industrial decline in the post Imperial stage without a full understanding of British Empire I don't think we can answer those questions and I think that that should be something that anchors any debates that we have around what it means to be British or English thank you [Applause] thank you very much for that closure and closing these opening remarks we have Morris Glassman thank you I'm really lovely to be here even better because I just found out the Spurs have gone one up so that's an unusual thing and basically my head is sort of exploding with things so I'm just gonna just begin with a weight with a with a couple of thoughts that I pick up so I've got I'm very uneasy with this word progressive as a way of talking about this I tend to think that it's quite in evasive time I usually say it's the last thing you want to hear when you go to the doctor isn't it it's progressive and that's that's just to pick up on this idea that perhaps the least true thing that was ever said in a political campaign was things can only get better right it's just not true at any level and that's what progressive is Society is that there's this arc of history and things are gonna get better and I think that what we're confronting now is a genuine threat from the right a real populist threat from the right that has to be understood democratically and has to be understood in class and race terms and if we can't get to grips with that we're going to be we're really going to have a progressive illness where we are going to gradually die really without really being able to understand why that's the so the first thing I wanted to say was that when we're talking about this stuff about the nation-state and the construction of the nation we've got to look at the states that are involved because if we can't advocate a democratic and inclusive democratic politics that can engage in the resistance of the domination of capital and at the same time articulating a generalist democratic politics at which all can participate as citizens we've lost it because there's what Graham she would call a war of position on and John and I are old enough it's very nice that you're not but we're old enough to remember when we lost the war position in the 70s it was full of energy it was full of ideas and then when I was 18 that she got elected and she still is in power you know it goes on for ages so that's where I just wanted to begin the second is you know I'm really interested in in engaging co-chairing in which that there's different types of imperialism and what's really the invisible thing in British imperialism is the distinctive role of the maritime trade of the City of London in particular and the particular forms of capitalism of of globalization that it engendered and that makes it different than the more territorial forms of imperialism under Spain and forms and that opened up a whole different dynamic and degree of space so I want to go there so the first distinction that I want to make really is between internationalism and globalization and then if we start thinking that internationalism is global capitalism is enforced by treaty law through multilateral organizations we're stuffed and that's a really important thing to grab hold of and the second is the distinguishing nationalism and patriotism which is worth investigating and looking at because nationalism is the absolute supremacy of a single usually ethnic group patriotism is more like how do we live in a shared polity that can be better than it is how do you how can you be part of something of something good so that's where it stands in the real nature of the issue is a class issue so labor does very well at the moment among middle class people with degrees and there's a huge amount of skepticism to labor from working class people who don't really think that job put it that we're on their side that we're really engaging with them and that's why I'm really hoping that we can articulate a genuine democratic vision of how brexit can work because that's one of the key to full issues in relation to to citizenship which which Ashe mentioned for me it's just a it's a set of relationships with people who share a fate and a set of political institutions that's that citizenship based on the liberty and equality of each person um in that so that's a very open thing and how do we develop the relationships between communities as well as individuals so that's where I would say and this is really boring way I'm going to put it I can't put it another way I think you're right about identity and epistemological terms but not in terms of ontology people feel part of things and act as part of things and sometimes like with the nation-state it's just something you inherit so the distinction that I would make to you the reason I don't like to describe myself as progressive is because I'm socialist and socialist means that you recognize that there's a social inheritance that we are social beings that there's attachments and sense of belonging between people that is deeply political and if you can build a wide solidarity around that then you then you can win so that there's an element in which the relationship between groups is vital in developing and that's where the progressive thing it's much more of an Enlightenment idea that we all do it exclusively as individuals when I would say though if we look at ourselves as social beings we think much more about coalition's between classes coalition's between groups and the key challenge before us is precisely how to build a genuine coalition between migrant communities and the descendants of migrants and the working class that was here before 45 the back coalition is the most vital aspect and that's precisely for example where they ultimate progressive Hillary Clinton completely blew it she couldn't make that coalition okay so I've just been told that it's two minutes so I've got a kind of concentrate on how to to finish up so I think I'll just do it there they're not to be afraid of this conversation not to be afraid of the possibilities of democracy that emerged that the key miracle of Labor historically people don't recognize this in 1889 in the Dockers strike which founded the labor movement there was a coalition which maybe maybe will mean something in Liverpool and perhaps Glasgow but probably nowhere else in the country there was a coalition between Catholic workers and Protestant workers which had never existed before that's the formation of the labor movement overwhelmingly the Catholic workers were from the Northwest and from Ireland and they'd come down a lot of them bought in a strike makers Protestant workers overwhelmingly from the southeast what was distinctive about labour was that he bought those two communities together in a movement to protect the dignity of people that they're not commodities this was the language of it so you had people like William Booth from the Salvation Army Colonel Manning from the Catholic Church marching with the Dockers and in the end they won recognition from the dock owners and they created the Labour representation committees in other words labour has been that movement that builds a common institution between people through which their humanity can be preserved from the domination of capitalism but also from the state from the oppression of the state and the homogeneous power that it exerts and so my heart is really full of hope about this we know how to do it and we've done it before and I think we're just gonna have to do it again [Applause] thank you very much to all our panelists so I'm gonna start by just sort of gang ups were warmed up with a few questions that I've and that kind of pops it's my head and that I prepared before and then we're gonna move on to the floor so I kind of wanted to talk about this idea of winning of winning elections because the argument around you know this idea that we need to kind of embrace nationalism or patriotism is that labor needs to frame itself in these terms in order to gain back voters or in order to get voters that we are not getting at the moment so I just wanted to see what the panel thought of whether or not you ever worry about the voters that you might lose should this kind of patriotic this particular kind of patriotism or as many people would argue a patriotism that is inextricable from particular racialized and gendered power relations how do you feel about you know these kind of communities like young people queer people people of color who for good reason do not feel represented by these narratives do you ever worry that we might lose those votes especially considering that they were so integral to the gaining of seats in the last election and also we're so integral you know the fact that the Tories alienated those people were so integral to their loss of seats so I would just wanted to know what the panel thought about that I mean my aim is to construct a politics that includes those who feel that I was particularly talking about English that includes that within the many they feel excluded from it at the moment now the challenge is to do exactly to avoid exactly what you said to do that in a particular strident way or to use images and practices of Englishness that would be alienating to people and the same would be of Britishness to my real issue at the moment is that we almost willfully leave England out of the story it's not that we go overboard in bringing England into the story just give you a classic example today we're going to nationalize the water industry but only make sense in England because it's not run for profits in any other part of the Union why don't we say England when we mean we're going to nationalize the water industry in England because that's the only place we're going to do it we're gonna have a national education service what nation not whale it's not Scotland not Northern Ireland because they run their own education system it's England so very simple why calling for is actually not incredibly radical it's actually think according things what they are but it matters to those people who currently feel excluded now I think there's a really important discussion here and I've have can't go into details not time but I mean so Hampton I have four years experience working with others to run an inclusive st. George's Day Festival precisely because I didn't we want to be involved in Assen George's Day that was for one part of the community because this is a national day and to do that you have to construct a story about Southampton and Englishness and it being built by all the people who've made their lives there and then you do get participation from all communities and people are pleased to be asked you look at a lot of st. George's Day ceremonies on websites including English Heritage you won't find a single non-white face anywhere in there publicity that is damaging that is the wrong sort of thing to do so I don't argue we have to have a really important debate about the practice of doing this but if you say to me can it be done in a way that doesn't alienate those people say well actually this stuff doesn't get turn me on at all yes I think we can do that so I mean so you believe that we can actual Kodo do you have any responses to this idea do you think it is something that can be reclaimed or is it sort of from its Genesis constructed in that particular way so when you say can this be reclaimed I'd say well reclaimed by who and for what purposes so this is what I mean by my my focus here isn't on policing people's identity me and Kojo are both avid grime fans and I'm sure that Lord Glassman here is as well and what what has been really striking and this is something that we've talked about a lot is that in grime there is a space for a particular subversion of Englishness right you listen to Wiley's early work he sounds like a geezer do you know I mean you'd listen to you know you listen to a Jay Tracy and you know it's like Stuart Hall's been writing a 6:16 right he's talking about you know in Trinidad thumb I'm English right so it's actually about this kind of hybridized identity and it's there my I'm a so may she was a nip with that I find that tremendously inspiring for me the issue is is what do you mean when you say in English radical history what do you mean when you say in English history is it history that has happened to have taken place in England or is it the history of England as England and for me it's the England as England bit which is the tricky part and this is kind of why I'm calling to crime and also thinking about Stuart Hall is that there is no history of England as England as kurtosis has been constituted in the international but an even before 1945 with the you know significant presence of working-class people of color in this country we were here in the form of commodities mr. famous bit from old and new ethnicities old and new identities by Stuart Hall I'm the sugar at the bottom of the English cup of tea what do you know about the English I can't get through the day without a cup of tea others if you're from Sri Lanka or India you're the tea itself you're the outside history in the inside history of the English and for me the issue is when you try and turn these things into political projects within these bounded forms then you start cutting off that history you start cutting off a history which has often been antagonistic and you cut off I think some of the cultural richness which produces forms like grime ideas get out and you make it sort of a bit like oh that's like put some brown faces and samosas and a cinch or just a celebration I don't I think it loses the thing which there wasn't a samosa in sight add no no no no the points the point just quickly because this this is actually crucial because what we said look so Hamptons in English city that's always been built by all the people who've made their homes there that was an explicit story of an English history that set out to include it so how did we do it for four years we told the stories through videos through performance through drama of all the people who had made so Hampton what it is today so English history yeah it's happened in England it's not a defined set to certain things Cable Street that's not argue whether this english original cable street is part of that history the bristol bus boycott where passengers from all backgrounds joined the boycott the buses because the transport and General Workers Union refused to let any big black get a job on the buses that's part of English history and you see we if we don't deal with this we can't make this part of our story today I'm I'm not a grime fan but I'm one of those people of my age who sort of come across it seems to me it's the first authentic English or British folk music since punk it's that you couldn't have been produced anywhere else in the world that's part of our story the last thing I would do is have a politics that shove that into a corner somewhere and draw it drawing on that and kind of picking up on some of the things that came up there another kind of inflection I wanted to put into that is you know Morris you spoke a lot about how you know we need to bring people like this idea of unity we need to bring people together because that is the only way that we can you know defeat global capital which is what we all won right way but global capital is that it's it's global so how if our primary way of thinking about ourselves is through an age how does that connect us to the working classes globally who we need to be in solidarity with in order to defeat global capital okay so that you know that's the knot that's the novel how do you resist global capital and I think we've reached the end of the road in thinking that this can be resisted through the wall of administrators and lawyers in undemocratic and unaccountable multinational organizations it's got to be built ultimately on the building of relationships between working people of different backgrounds and generating a labor movement and the Communists that's the key distinction between internationalism and solidarity so so that that in a way it's fundamental just to go back to cojo and there was one the event you missed our because in the distinction between is the Norman Conquest you would have thought just say campaigning in the referendum you would have thought that the Norman Conquest would have happened yesterday as well and that's a that's an English story above all so I've got a heretical view that the English history is more radical to British that the British is the Imperial story with the formation of the global Empire and then the integration of Scotland in particular against France in that competition by English history is a gradual way you know well one of the lines is you know in 1066 98 percent of the land was handed over to 12 French men you know and it's been pretty much uphill ever since that's a framework within which you can understand dispossession you can understand colonisation you can understand the incredible importance to English people in particular of land but has it happened again in the enclosures in the enclosures there was the absolute assertion a freehold title over customary practice and English peasantry was completely expelled from their land that's another fundamental origin of the labor movements to reclaim some home in the world through democracy so the answer to your question is the absolute solidarity with all democratic laid the movements all over the world with unions but the idea that you can resist this without having those movements with with power in the country is a Shimura and the second is to assert and here I'm with Ashe about these the subordination of the primacy of identity to issues around democratic coalition's around class that's an incredibly important part of that so the choice before us is not a sort of liberal administrative progressive internationalism which which doesn't exist the choice before us is in the Democratic frame are we going to have a nasties and a phobic right-wing nationalism that is in fact controlled by capital or I'll be capable here of actually articulating a democratic politics that can give inspiration and institutional support to other movements in the world that's that's why I see cojo which you would you like to come back on that I mean it's not it's not the first time I think that we've heard this disclaimer in this campaign the idea of reclaiming a radical particularly English history in opposition to the imperial legacy of the British Empire and this is something that you can see from you know great Dione's of left-wing socialism from EP Thompson's not only you know particularly as I say the peculiarities of the English is one thing that's fantastically talks about the idea of the English sensibility being particularly agreeable to revolution the thing about George Orwell and the Lion the eunuch on socialism and the English genius you know so again very humble in its in its articulation but I I mean there's no denying of course if there's a radical history of things that have happened within the landmass of England you know and you can trace that you can trace John Bourdon the pet pedals of or you can trace childe Wynd Stanley and you can plot together another national story that's more parochial more kind of unconnected to the land and struggle and use that as a replacement of a national story my main issue with that is it goes back to the point that I'll say it initially is I don't know if it takes us closer to understanding the legacy of the British Empire for forming the political institutions and communities that we have today whether it allows us to actually escape from those it actually allows us to say oh no that wasn't us that was the British Empire and ignoring the ignoring that ignoring the significant role that England had within the configuration of Britain so something that you mentioned a little bit job was this silence of the idea of England when we talk about Britain the silence when people talk about national projects but ignoring the fact that it early reflecting in England and that is definitely true there's no doubt often legislation might be passed that only can affect England but as articulated as being a British issue but that is because of the super versus role that England played with in that political configuration the the reason that that there is a silence around England the reason why there's not an English Parliament and the wrists of all governments within the other regions the United Kingdom isn't simply because Englishness has been suppressed but because English missus operates it with such power that that power has been silenced and invisible eyes and so I think to to simply to try and reclaim that and not ignore the way in which English this has been synthesized with imperialism is it's dangerous on both levels in particular on a level which I think both of you made something that's a key concern of yours in your presentations this idea of constructing allegiances and constructing forms of bonding and when I think about the idea you know if people want to identify as English I think that's fantastic and like I said you know I think it's great when you see a kano video and he's in an East London you know greasy spoons and he's got a mug with a st. George's flag on you know it's it is exciting its own way but if we make that the kind of driving vehicle of our politics I think I just are concerned about what happens to those who have allegiances that exceed the national boundaries and it also for me does a disservice to that radical history of English socialism which was always explicitly internationalist in a lot of ways when you think about the the commitment of those working-class can at ease in places like here to go and fight in against the Spanish fractious forces thing Catalonia when you think about the way in which the anti-apartheid movement found its home here in England I think it's the political coordinates of English leftism have not often been English and are worried about making themselves [Applause] there's there's a huge amount there that that I I agree with and let me tell you how I square the circle and do it both in terms of identity and democracy which Morris raised it's worth remembering in our history that in the 19th century and into the 20th century with the ILP socialists conceived of the English nation that meaning the people not the state important distinction as a focus of opposition to capitalism and imperialism and so the ILP talked about England as the place that could challenge capitalism and imperialism we've forgotten that from our from our history but the particularly important thing you're right about is our institution I've written this in several things which around a conference actually our institutions were created for Empire and part of the crisis that we with is particular to the UK at the moment is that with the unwinding of empire we are left with a set of imperial institutions that no longer have the empire to function and actually from the partition of Ireland in the 1920s suta Scotia 12th revolution this has been a process of unwinding an imperial set of institutions that no longer work or give people the reason to be in one single state I would argue that the particular crisis of England is England is stuck with the same imperial institution no longer lording it over Italy in a way that undoubtedly happened in the past but the only part of the UK that is run by the UK government rather than democratically by the people of England I would argue that the reason it was England not the rest of the UK that provided the lion's share of the brexit vote was it to a limited degree at least Scotland Wales and Northern Ireland have been able to imagine themselves as modern 21st century post-imperial nations in a way that England has not been able to do because we have no fora in which that discussion takes place now the solutions we need and use a really important point about not making this a central point about our politics I entirely agree ultimately the political answers we come up with have to work democratically and for the majority which the things that Morrison I have said but if we don't include the people who do feel English in that project we will lose part of our core constituencies so it's about inclusion of English nurse not basing our politics around either a British or an English politics as though all the other things that we bring us to this conference don't matter to us because they do it's a vehicle for achieved achieving that change sorry I mean I think I would like to posit some questions and and these are intended as as provocations as well as questions which is what is Englishness without whiteness what is Englishness without supremacy do we have models for thinking these through in any meaningful way and models of these identities which can reconcile themselves to Britain's changing role in the world so that can no longer sort of keep enjoying it's like you know when you wake up still drunk from the night before and that's shortly before the hangover hits that's like in like Britain enjoying its colonial legacy on the world stage now we're in the hangover period we're not just still coursing through and last night's rare nephew what conceptions of these are not just collective models of identity but democratic institutions social institutions political institutions do we have without those things I don't think that they've been thoroughly imagined well I think what we've have had is instead attempts to define these things into being in a way which is still I think very much hoping that it will be taken as a lip surface to the patriotism which is inherently linked to a sort of Imperial not just amnesia but nostalgia the longing for something which is lost and very much tied to the patriotism of hope to return of domination and I think that as as leftists whether you're a socialist we call yourself a progressive whether in my case you put yourself a communist we end up in a in a strange position where we say yes we want to show that we are hearing you forgotten England and screwed over by deindustrialization in which people of color are only ever an emblem of globalization and not demographics also affected and shaped by globalization in this country what all we do is try and posit our politics as a form of lip service of a yes I'm hearing you well then reassuring the anti-racist left communities of color but this won't actually mean anything my plea as much as anything is not say I've got every single answer to that English story but this is a story from which the left must not abstain the Neth must not take a position of saying until you've answered all my questions I don't want anything to do with this because the world is changing these identities are contested it's up to us to decide whether we want to help resolve that in a way which actually produces the inclusive out what we want or we don't and the world has changed I just is actually a bad choice of afternoon because I went to watch Southampton play Liverpool I should have done something else but Liverpool had a football a court called John Barnes when John Barnes played for England and scored many English supporters refused to count his goals as English goals because he was black you saw it was different this summer people are working out and sport isn't everything a different form of Englishness now we have an opportunity to include our radical history and the one things we want to see and the anti-racist struggles as part of the tale of England that we want to have and if we just abstain because there's some difficult bits we end up with the politics which doesn't include people that we do need to include you | Novara Media | UCOzMAa6IhV6uwYQATYG_2kg | 2018-09-23 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 9,518 | 52,843 |
HSZI_0wxnzM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSZI_0wxnzM | Julián Rey: Primordial black holes in an early matter-dominated era and stochastic inflation | hello everybody and welcome to the latin american webinar of physics today we have a very interesting talk is the webinar number 108 of this webinar cycle that we have we started more or less in 2015 so we have a lot of webinars in the in the body let's say so this time it's going to be a very interesting webinar because it's going to be about the primordial black hole the speaker is julian ray that he is a phd student at the universidad autonoma de madrid in spain and basically he he obtained a bachelor in venezuela in the university of bolivia and now is here in in madrid doing his phd so the title of his talk is primordial black hole in a early early matter-dominated era and a stochastic inflation don't forget that you can you can see the webinars in this in our youtube channel and also to ask questions to julian using the the chat in the live transmission otherwise you can make comments to the video once it's finished so julian welcome to low physics and you can start whenever you want [Music] okay can you see the screen yes yes uh so uh thank you for the introduction and uh thank you very much for for having me uh so to what i'm gonna talk about today is the work that i've been doing for my phd thesis which is about primordial black holes uh the talk is based on the three papers that you can see at the bottom of this slide and at the end of the presentation there is a full list of references so let me start by saying that primordial black holes are a very relevant dark matter candidates today and what makes them interesting in my opinion is the fact that they do not require any physics beyond inflation and there is still a very large window of masses that remains viable meaning that it remains unconstrained by experiments of about five orders of magnitude the lower end in this mass range comes from hawking radiation bounds from uh from bounce on the radiation that these black holes would produce if they evaporated and the higher end on this mass range comes from microlensing experiments something else that makes these black holes very interesting is the fact that they're astrophysical signatures namely the the fact that they produce gravitational waves and gravitational lensing is something that could be probed within the next decade uh what we want to do in this talk is we want to determine the effects that these two things would have on the abundance of black holes the first one is the equation of state of the universe at the time of which the black holes form and concretely we're going to assume that they form either during a radiation era or during an early matter dominated era and uh the second thing we want to determine is the effect of the formalism of stochastic inflation on their on their abundance and i will tell you more later about the what the stochastic inflation actually is we're going to explore these aspects in the context of three different inflationary models two of which are numerical and one of which is analytical so let me tell you a little bit about dark matter first any any dark matter county we know it should be dark meaning it doesn't interact with uh electromagnetism uh the second thing they should satisfy so they should be quickly interacting and the third is that they should be cold and the black hole satisfy all these criteria there are many ideas for what dark matter could be for example wimps actions strong neutrinos and machos and by matches here i mean neutron stars and brown dwarfs and it's important to distinguish which is uh because people often lump uh primordial black holes together with these machos but as i will show you in a moment the primordial black holes that we're going to be considering are very very very small and uh at least in comparison to these uh to neutron stars and brown dwarfs so uh it's not exactly they are compact objects but it's not exactly right to lump them together and the oldest surviving dark matter candidates are actually these uh promoted black holes because they were first proposed in the 1970s so let me tell you what they are primordial black holes are black holes that are formed in the early universe by some mechanism different to the usual stellar collapse there are many ways that you can get promoted black holes for instance from the collapse of bubbles or from topological defects but the way that we're going to get them today the mechanism that we're interested in is how to get them from a given model of inflation this is the the a plot with the constraints on the up on the cell black holes so here in the back the vertical axis i'm plotting the fraction of uh the fraction of dark matter that could be in the form of primary black holes so this is a number between zero and one and in the horizontal axis i'm plotting the the the mass of the primordial black holes so you see that on the left of the plot there is a window that is still open meaning that it is some constrained by experiments and on the below 10 to the minus 16 solar masses or so there's uh you can see the constraints coming from this the one let's say uh aj gamma these are the constraints coming from extra galactic gamma rays and uh this is basically a constraint uh because we do not observe the radiation that black holes very very small black holes would produce if they have operated so we know that they're the black holes cannot be that small um and above 10 to the minus 11 solar masses more or less we have the microlensing constraints and in between this window is completely unconstrained but this is a region that could be probed within the next 10 years or so either by femto lensing experiments or by gravitational wave interferometers like lisa for comparison i have also on on the right side you can see a little tag that says ligo and this is where the uh the masses of the black holes that ligo has measured uh would be so you can see that the the black holes that we're considering are at least 10 orders of magnitude smaller than what ligo has observed so they're very very small so how do we get primordial black holes from inflation and if we want the black holes to form what we need is to have very large density fluctuations uh at a scale that is comparable to a hubble horizon yeah so we define this number delta which is the combo we call the combining density contrast and this is the ratio between the density perturbation and the background and energy density and we're going to assume that these fluctuations are produced during inflation as is usually done we're also going to assume that transitions between different eras are instantaneous so in this plot illustrates the the situation um in the in the vertical axis the function that i'm plotting here is the evolution of the hubble parameter as a function of time and the horizontal axis is time or or temperature however you want to see it and we have plotted the different eras of the history of the universe yeah on the far left we have inflation and then right after inflation ends we have this emd which is an early matter dominated era then after this is something that we're going to conjecture here it's not something that has been observed or anything then after this early matter dominated era we have a radiation error and after this radiation era we have there a standard matter-dominated error that occurs after a big bang nuclear synthesis and then at the end of the very right of the plot we have the this lambda dominator there which is the cosmological constant error that we live in today so uh every density fluctuation every energy density fluctuation has a certain scale associated to it because we usually work with the fourier transform so it's better to think about the wave number and then what happens is that the scale leaves the horizon as inflation goes on and by leaves the horizon what i mean is that the the scale associated to each fluctuation at some point is above the curve so if you look at the black line that i have drawn here the one that's a slope of one over k you can see that the scale is we say it's outside the horizon uh on the left of the plot where it is above the the the color region and eventually the scale re-enters the horizon which for this example it happens during radiation domination and uh it is only after the scale re-enters the horizon that it is going to induce the collapse so the scale the fluctuation is produced during inflation and the the the scale associated to this fluctuation leaves the horizon and once it re-enters the horizon uh the fluctuation is going to tell the matter inside the horizon that it has to collapse into a black hole so the collapse occurs long after inflation has ended so how do we estimate the the mass and the abundance of these black holes in a radiation era uh usually the the assumption that we make is that the the the mass of the black holes is proportional to the energy density contained within a hubble patch at the time of which the black holes form so this is what is uh written in the first equation here and we put a a proportionality constant in front which we call gamma and uh because of causality the this gamma should be less than one because the energy density of collapses cannot be bigger than what is contained within the hubble patch at that moment and this gamma basically measures the efficiency of the process yeah this is a constant that tells you how efficient the the collapse is basically uh we know that this from simulations we know that this is uh about 0.2 then if we play around with this equation a little bit we find after a short calculation that the mass of the black holes is actually inversely proportional to the square of the square of the the scale associated to these fluctuations that is collapsing so uh if you want to produce very small black holes which uh what we want from the from the plot that i showed you earlier with the constraints we know that the unconstrained masses are the small ones and if we want to produce very very small black holes then we need the fluctuations that are collapsing to have a very large gate as the next thing to that that we can estimate is the abundance of these black holes the other th or in other words the fraction of dark matter that is in the form of black holes and there's a number that is denoted by f bbh is the one that you can see on the last equation here and the important thing here is that it's proportional to its function beta beta is a function that tells you how what proportion of the energy density is collapsing into black holes and if you assume that the fluctuations are gaussian then this beta should be should be a gaussian basically and you can think of it as going roughly as the exponential of one over the power spectrum of the fluctuations so uh what's important here is that the well let me tell you what the power spectrum is the power spectrum is a quantity that tells us how these fluctuations are distributed across different scales and this is actually a quantity that is computed from a model of inflation you can if you have a model inflation then you can compute the the the power spectrum and this is actually measured by cmp experiments so one might wonder if this is actually measured uh what can is the the value that we have measured by cmb experiments uh enough to produce uh enough framework like also explain all dark matter and it turns out that it isn't uh the value that we have measured for the power spectrum is about 10 to the minus nine at c and b scales but uh the one that we need to produce uh enough remote black holes to explain all of the dark matter is of about 10 to the minus 2 or so but this is not a problem because as i told you before the mass of these black holes is inversely proportional to the scale of the fluctuation and you want the since we want very small black holes because these are the ones that are unconstrained we want the the scale of the fluctuation to be large so in other words we need the enhancement of the power spectrum to occur at scales which are much much smaller than the ones that we observed at the cmb meaning at a k that is much larger than the one that we observe uh the an example of the power spectrum is shown on the right hand side uh before we're going to explain the plot let me first say uh how we can get a large power spectrum from a given model of inflation so in any model of inflation the power spectrum is inversely proportional to the speed of the inflaton uh at least in the in the slow roll approximation which we actually need to break but this is enough uh to understand the intuitive idea here so the power spectrum is inversely proportional to the speed of the inflaton within a model of inflation and then what you want to get a large power spectrum before the inflaton to be very very slow so what we need to do is to have a feature some kind of feature in the potential that is going to slow down the inflation once it rolls down for instance an inflection point or a small hill so the kind of potential that we're considering is shown on the left plot here and you see that at very small field values on the on the left of the plot we have the the part that will correspond to them to the fluctuations that we observed at the cmb and then later on uh at the scales are smaller and smaller so for large k uh we have an inflection point in the potential which is the the place at which the primordial black holes are going to be produced and then at the end of the inflation we have reheating which is when inflation ends uh so the power spectrum that will correspond to this potential is shown on the right side and once again you can see on the left side the of this power spectrum the uh the value that we measured at the cmb which is ten to the minus nine and then uh as uh eventually for large k we have the peak that would correspond to this uh inflection point that you see on the left and the simplest model that we could consider is uh to obtain display motor black holes is actually simply to put a scalar field and coupled through gravity so uh let's uh as you can see in this action the the model that we're going to consider now this is one of the numerical models that i was telling you in the beginning simply to take a scalar field and copy to the richie uh scalar in this way by this via this term x i phi squared times r and then what you do is you get you can get you can actually get rid of this coupling by redefining the fields so if you take this action and you really find the metric and you really find the the the the influence field uh then you can get rid of the coupling to r which is what uh what i show on the action that is at the bottom of the page and the the price that you pay for getting rid of this coupling which you see is no longer in the lagrangian is that your potential is not going to be divided by this factor omega to the fourth and omega it comes from there from from redefining the field is defined on the in the here in the middle of the page the first so the first of the three equations you see that is proportional to five so the price for this uh redefinition of the field is simply that uh now your potential is going to be divided by a quartic polynomial but the simplest potential that we could have chosen in the first place was also a polynomial so the ratio would be the ratio of two polynomials so you see that the the new potential which is a function of h which is a new field that occurs after you you redefine the the fields in the lagrangian is now a quotient of two quartic polynomials and this is going to give us what we want because uh as long as the parameters satisfy a certain relationship among themselves we're going to get an inflection point in the potential this inflection point is shown on the on the blue curve here the blue dash curve this is what i'm plotting and this corresponds to the potential and the horizontal axis here is simply the field value normalized to to m planck so you see that uh when h is around one m planck uh this blue curve the potential has an inflection point so around one plank is where we're where we're going to produce these black holes uh the red curve here is simply the speed of the of the of the field and you see that it goes to zero uh when the field is near the uh the inflection point which is uh what is going to give us the enhancement of the power spectrum uh so something you might wonder is whether we actually needed to do this uh field redefinition to get the the inflection point because on the numerator we already have a polynomial that could have an inflection point if we choose a 2 3 and 4 correctly so what the denominator is actually doing is that at large field values it makes the potential constant so you see that the blue curve at large field values as they as h becomes bigger it tends to a constant yeah it's extending to a plateau and this is going to help a lot when fitting the cmb data so the reason that we need to include this denominator is that it makes it easier for us to fit the the cmb data at large field values and so the the intuitive idea that i gave you before where the power spectrum was simply one over the speed of the inflaton is actually not entirely correct and this is only violating what is known as the slow roll approximation and it turns out that when the power spec when the field is very very slowly is rolling very very slowly we actually break this lawful approximation and we are in a regime known as ultra slow roll and uh this picture where the power spectrum goes as simply as one over the speed of the improton is uh actually broken so uh to be able to compute the power spectrum what you need to do now is to take this differential equation that should not uh at the top here it's known as the mukhanov zaki equation and uh and solve it numerically usually numerically um the the power spectrum can then be obtained simply by by squaring the the solution that you obtain here this equation is obtained simply by considering uh perturbation theory so on the plot that i have on the left here you can see the result that would that we would obtain for the power spectrum if the uh if we follow the the if we use the slow raw approximation in the red curve and by solving this differential equation in the black curve so you see that uh after the slow row face ends so near the the end of the plot where you are in ultra slow roll uh one is actually underestimating the power spectrum if one uses a slower approximation by many orders of magnitude so it is important uh to solve this equation numerically to to get an accurate an accurate power spectrum uh the the main issue that we run into with this polynomial model is actually adjusting the tilt of the power spectrum at cmp scales which is also known as a spectral index so the the spectral end is simply simply the the the slope of the power spectrum at uh at a given scale and the problem that we run into is that trying to adjust this regular index we run into problems with the with the bounds coming from the hocking radiation of the black holes so let me let me elaborate on this if you try to that okay let me first say that the spectral index that we get from the from this polynomial model is about 0.95 but the spectral index that we measure in measured by planck for instance in cmb experiments it's 0.965 this is a measurement that is done by assuming only lambda cdm so you see that there is a bit of difference and the problem is that if we want to increase the spectral index yeah if we want to fit the tilt of the power spectrum uh better at cmb scales what we have to do is we have to change the starting position of the inflaton in the potential but if we do this and we're also going to be shifting the position of the peak in the power spectrum and if we change the position of the peak then we're changing the masses of the black holes so this is why trying to adjust the the spectral index at cnb scales results in a problem with adjusting the masses of the black holes and we run into problems with the evaporation bounds so there are two possible solutions to this problem both of which are well motivated the first one is we can actually extend lambda cdm by adding very reasonable uh or by adding very reasonable extensions like the neutrino masses or adding the effective number of relativistic degrees of freedom or just allowing the the spectral index to run and if you add these these things to under cdn uh blank has already that the blank collaboration has already performed this analysis and what you find is that the new spectral index is about 0.95 which is very close to what we find so this is one possible solution to the problem just extending lambda cdm another solution if you want to leave lambda city game as it is and you don't want to add these things is to add higher dimensional operators to the potential uh these higher dimensional operators are expected anyway because you're dealing with a model that is non-very normalizable right because the infrastructure is called to the rich scaler so if you add these higher dimensional operators then what's going to happen is that they're going to change the potential at very large field values and then you're going to be able to fit the cmb data better and that low field values which is where the inflection point is and it's where where you produce the black holes the potential is going to be basically the same because these uh these uh terms are not gonna have an effect there so uh the effect of these terms is to change the potential at the cmb but leave it uh the same at the the inflection point and uh because the potential changes are the cmd scales if you have these terms then uh you're going to have a few a few more parameters that you can fit that you can use to fit the cmb data so this also solves this increases the spectral index solving the problem um on the left plot on this page what i'm plotting is the the abundance of these black holes once again in the vertical axis and in the horizontal axis the masses of the black holes so there are uh you can see in the in the the color the regions with the black lines going across are the the experimental constraints that i showed you before so the red one is the one from hawking radiation and the uh the orange one is the one coming from microlensing experiments and the the the two curves here the two the the green one and the blue one are the solutions that i have just mentioned so the green one corresponds to simply using a fourth order polynomial and extending lambda cdm and the blue one corresponds to adding higher dimensional operators to the to the potential so you see that with both of them we can get a fraction of uh dark matter in the form of black holes of one so we can basically explain all of dark matter with black holes something important about this and that is also there's actually not just for this model but this is a generic feature of all of these models of inflection point inflation is that we get a very large uh gravitational wave signal and the reason is that this is it's important to to emphasize that the signal is not coming from the mergers or the black holes or anything like this it's actually due only to the to the large power spectrum that we have because if you expand if you expand einstein's equations uh to second order and you look at the equation of motion of the tensor modes which are the ones that correspond to gravitational waves at second at first order these are uh these are uh unsourced by any other perturbation the other they're by themselves but if you expand the equations to second order what you're gonna get is that the second order tensor modes are now going to be sourced by first order scalars squared and because we have a very large power spectrum we have a peak in the scalar perturbations and then this is going to lead yeah this equation of motion is going to lead to a peak in the second order transfer modes and uh you can calculate this peak and it turns out that for the black holes that we're interested in it falls exactly in the uh frequency range that lysor and the cycle are going to measure so so yeah so this is something that uh this is a model that could be probed within the next uh 10 or 20 years once these experiments are active so the next thing i want to tell you about is the formalism of stochastic inflation in stochastic inflation what happens is that we allow quantum fluctuations of the field to back react on the classical trajectory and these quantum fluctuations are then going to modify the background evolution of the of the field for the equation of motion that we have for the field in slow roll is what is shown here in in this gray box so the the first term the one involving the derivative of the potential is the one that you would obtain if you were not considering the the back reaction of the quantum fluctuations yeah so if if you're in slope rolling you do not consider the back reaction what you would obtain is simply that the derivative of i is equal to this uh this first term yeah the derivative of the of the potential then uh if you consider the uh the quantum fluctuations what you obtain is a second term uh and then the second term you can think of it as a stochastic noise term so at every uh point in time this uh uh this uh this uh term xi which is a stochastic noise is going to give a kick to the inflaton so this is why it modifies the the the background trajectory of the field and then uh if you want to to check how big this effect is you want to check whether or not it has an effect what you can do because this is uh uh this psi is uh basically just a probability distribution of the noise so it's a number between zero and one what you can do is you can divide the coefficients of both terms to see and check whether the result is bigger or smaller than one yet to estimate whether or not it has an effect then if you do this what you find is that for the stochastic noise to not have any effect on the trajectory the condition that you have to satisfy is that the power spectrum has to be much smaller than one uh this is actually an equation that is only valid in slow role and as i told you before we actually have to break slope rule so this is not a very good uh estimation but it's enough to understand intuitively what's uh what's happening so uh for the power spectrum that we measure at the cmb which is around ten to the minus nine or so uh this doesn't matter you don't have to take into account the stochastic noise because uh ten to the minus nine is uh many much much more smaller than one but because now we are enhancing the power spectrum in order to produce the black holes and the power spectrum that we need is of order 10 to the minus 2 so it is a lot closer to 1 and then it's important it becomes important to understand whether or not this has an effect so this is the intuitive idea and uh what you do to take into account this uh these quantum fluctuations operationally is that you take the field the infraton field and then you split it into a coarse grained part and a perturbation so the the first term in this equation this phi bar represents the coarse grained field and the second term represents the the perturbation you can see that the perturbation is actually multiplied by this function w this is a window function that basically it separates small scales from large scales so this k sigma is a cutoff that is going to this cutoff is going to tell you which ones of the scales are classical and super horizon and which of the scales are quantum and sub horizon uh then what you can do once you have this splitting of the coarse grain field and the perturbation is you can plug it back into the equations of motion and you're going to find that the fields now satisfy what are known as the longivan equations which are the two that are shown at the bottom and this is these are the equations for the field and this conjugate momentum and each one has its own uh stochastic noise term and uh and these are the equations that you have to solve basically solving these equations uh numerically it's very difficult so what we're going to do is we're going to develop an analytical formalism that is going to allow us to estimate the effect of this uh of this stochastic noise so uh because we have quantized the perturbation in principle you have to think of the perturbation and the noise as operators but it turns out that the commutator of the noise and the perturbations actually vanishes on small scales and then instead of thinking of them as quantum operators you can think of them as classical stochastic variables so uh they're classical because the the the the commutator vanishes um but even though they're classical you cannot think of them as a single number because they are probability distributions so you have to you have to think about them as stochastic variables even though they're classical and it turns out that if we choose a window function that is a heavyside step function so yeah this is this is the simplest possible window function that would be choose just a heavy side what we obtain is that the noise that is generated is then gaussian which simplifies the equations a lot so this is this the window function has to be chosen by hand uh this is not something that comes directly from the from the model yeah you have to you have to choose by hand what you consider classical and what you consider quantum modes and if you choose the a heavyside step function then you find that the noise is gaussian and now because the perturbations are stochastic variables they're uh evolution is described simply of their properties if you want are described by their uh statistical moments yeah for so they're they're gonna be described now by their endpoint functions in particular we're interested in the two point functions which uh you can compute by solving this this uh set of three couple differential equations and uh you see that this uh each one of these equations is sourced by this term d which is the one that is related to the noise because d is defined as this linear combination of thetas and these thetas are precisely the uh the correlation functions of the of a stochastic noise so once you solve these differential equations uh if you if you manage to solve them and you find the two point functions of the or the statistical moments of the perturbations then you can find the power spectrum because you can show that the power spectrum is given by the sum of these three terms so the first term this d5i the one that is shown in black here is what you would obtain if the perturbation if the if you were not considering the stochastic formalism so this is the the result that i was showing you before is the one that is obtained simply by considering this first term these two terms that are shown in red are the additional contributions from the stochastic formalism so what we want to check is whether or not these two terms that the sum of these two terms vanishes and if we find that it vanishes then uh what we're going to get is that the the power spectrum is uh is the same that we had before and it's not affected by the by the stochastic formalism so uh one with the the way that we're going to do this is by anal by developing an analytical model uh yeah that is going to allow us to calculate explicit expressions for the stochastic noise so this is a model that is actually quite generic and that all of the models of the inflection point inflation that produce primordial black holes behave in the in more or less the same way so the model that we're going to develop here is quite generic for all of the models of this type uh the the model we develop is a three region model so and it's illustrated on the plot that's shown on the left here and what i'm plotting here is the second slow roll parameter eta and basically what eta is is a parameter that controls the acceleration of the inflaton as it rolls down the potential so in the beginning at early times eta is zero because the field is in slow row so the slower parameter has to be small so simply consider it to be zero and then eventually eta grows to a very large value so bigger than three of order one and uh at the end of the model at the end of the of the trajectory of the inflation eta decreases back to a negative value so the blue curve that i'm showing here the blue dash curve is what you would obtain for eta in a numerical model yeah so for instance think about the uh the polynomial model that i showed you before eta is what you would obtain if you were considering the actual level of numerical evolution of the inflation so the simplest way that we can model this evolution is simply by fitting eta with three heavy side functions one after each other and the despite the fact that this is a very crude approximation it turns out that it actually reproduces quite well the results of the of the model so uh by having the simple parameterization of eta we can actually reconstruct everything that we need we can reconstruct the potential the trajectory of the infraton the the first level parameter and most importantly the power spectrum and because the parameterization is simply simply a constant eta in three different regions solving them kind of sazaki equation analytically is very easy so the biggest advantage that we find with this approach is that now we can find explicit analytical expressions for the noise so uh this um the expressions that we find for theta theta remember is the the correlation function of the of the stochastic noise uh the form the the results that we find are shown in this table and the the actual values uh uh the actual expressions are not that important right now what's important is the fact that by developing this analytical model we're able to find the explicit expressions for the for the noise and uh it turns out you can show that uh then by by using this expression for the noise you can solve for the statistical moments of the perturbations and you can show that the two additional terms that appear in the power spectrum due to this new formalism actually vanish so uh what we find basically is that this stochastic formalism does not have an effect on the power spectrum so uh it's the same thing i told you before so at the power spectrum is the sum of these three terms and the the sum of the second two vanishes as we can show analytically and then the power spectrum is only given by the first term which is what you would obtain if you were doing the calculation classically and what's important is that this vanishes only in the sigma going to zero limit so let me show you once again the the cutoff here so if you remember uh the uh the field is defined into is split into a coarse grain part and the perturbation and uh these parts uh what you consider uh classical versus what you consider quantum modes uh is basically determined by the cutoff that you choose here inside the window function and the cutoff that we choose is simply sigma times a times h because you can show that if sigma is small enough then this kind of accurately separates the quantum modes from the classical ones so what we're plotting here is uh what's important here is that you're only going to be able to separate the modes accurately if you choose sigma to be small enough so if you don't choose sigma to be small enough then you're going to get a different power spectrum but this is uh only because you haven't chosen the cut off correctly so uh on the right side you can see the the the column for different values of sigma which are these red lines and the black line basically tells you when the modes uh become uh when the quantum modes become classical so you see that for instance if you choose sigma equal to ten to the minus two then uh as long as the field is in slow row uh this is uh this is a good uh this is a good choice but uh once the field is in once you have an ultra slow row phase the uh the most take a little bit longer to become classical which is why this black line is uh has a has this uh nasty dependence on the number of defaults so if you basically what you want is for the entirety of the black line to be above the red line that you're choosing so in this example the minimum sigma that you would need to choose to accurately separate the quantum modes from the classical ones is 10 to the minus 6 and you see indeed that the power spectrum which is shown on the left that is obtained by choosing each value of sigma which are the spectral shown in red tends to the green curve a sigma becomes smaller and smaller and the reason is that the green curve is the correct result which is the one that you would obtain classically so the stochastic inflation formulation does not have an effect on the power spectrum as long as you choose the cutoff correctly the last thing that i want to tell you about is what happens if the black holes collapse during a matter dominated era instead of a radiation-dominated era so the one that we have been considering so far is the collapse of black holes during a radiation era and if they form during an early matter-dominated era then we need to we actually need to estimate again the masses and the abundances of black holes so uh as i showed you way in the beginning way back in the beginning the mass of the black holes if they produce if they are produced during a radiation era is proportional to k to the minus 2 where k is the scale of the fluctuation and we can compute the mass in if they form during a during an early matter dominated era and what we find is that now they are inversely proportional to the to the q to the third power of k and uh this is not very important basically it's almost the same dependence as before but what is important now is that the mass is also proportional to the temperature at which the transition between these early matter dominated era and the radiation era occurs similarly you can do the same calculation for the abundance and what you find is that if the black holes form uh well during a radiation era then uh you remember that it was proportional to this function beta which was the uh amount of energy density that collapses into black holes it's what is shown here is beta rd and this this uh you you would not expect the amount of density of energy density that collapses into black holes to be the same uh if the universe is dominated by radiation than it if is if it's dominated by matter then you would expect it to change and this is what is indeed what happens so if you the the the abundance for the black holes in a matter dominated era is now going to be proportional to us to a different beta function which we know by b time d and once again we find that it depends on the temperature at which the transition between matter and variation occurs so these are the two key points the first is that these expressions now depend on the transition temperature and the second is that the the fraction of collapsing energy density is given by a different function so uh as i said before beta is the fraction of energy density that collapses into black holes and the the dependence of this function in the power spectrum is very different uh depending on which era the black holes form in so the radiation function is the the first one that is shown in the this between these two equations in the middle um you can obtain this function by considering the price sector formalism and postulating that a given density fluctuation only collapses as long as it is above some critical threshold which is why this integral grows from some threshold delta c to infinity and this is uh assuming that the distribution the probability distribution for this uh delta function is uh is gaussian on the other hand if these uh black holes form during a matter terminated error what you find is the second function here and this function was found in these papers are cited here and this function takes into account the non-sphericity and the angular momentum of the collapsing cloud so if you were to estimate naively what what if you were to think about without doing any math to think about what would happen if the black holes from during a matter of dominated era what you would expect is that the collapse is a lot easier because now there is no radiation pressure that is supposing the collapse and indeed if you were to use the first formula and simply take the the limit of the equation of state going to zero what you would find is that all of the matter in the universe collapses into black holes because there is no radiation to stop it but this is vastly overestimating what happens what actually happens is that the whether the the the cloud that is collapsing is spherical or not has an effect and uh if it is spinning then the angular momentum actually also inhibits the collapse so even though the equation of state is zero uh you need to be careful about the calculation and if you take this effect into account then you find that even though the collapse is easier than in radiation domination not not everything in the universe collapses into black holes so uh collapsed during uh this early matter domination has two very big advantages the first one is that because of what i just said because collapse is easier during matter domination and the power spectrum that you need to produce uh to explain all of dark matter in the form of black holes is actually smaller so for in the radiation cases about ten to the minus two what you need but in the matter case you only need it to be around ten to the minus four and the second significant advantage is that the abundance of the black holes because beta is different the abundance is now a lot less sensitive to small changes in the height of the power spectrum so let me elaborate on these two points and with these plots in the plot that i show on the left side what we have is the in the vertical axis we have the temperature the transition temperature between matter and radiation and the horizontal axis what we have are the the scales of the fluctuations that are collapsing so the the two shaded regions what they show is that the the regions that are forbidden the blue region is forbidden because uh for those choices of scale and transition temperature the scale actually re-enters during radiation domination so this is not what we want what we want is for the scale to re-enter the horizon during matter domination during this early matter dominated era and then for that to happen you have to be below the blue region so yeah the the white region on the right side of the plot uh well first let me tell you the uh the orange lines that are going across in the vertically or diagonally rather are the masses of the black holes that you would produce for each one of these choices of temperature and scale so you see that smaller masses are to the right side and if you recall from the product that i showed you ages ago the smaller masses are constrained by the bounds coming from the hawking variation of the black holes and this is what is shown in the red region the red region corresponds to the uh the hawking variation balance so it's uh which would correspond to all to small masses and therefore it's also forbidden so the the region that is allowed is the one shown in this white triangle and you can see that the best case scenario would occur on the top right of the triangle um which is for the power spectrum which is given by this horizontal dashed line is uh smallest so uh in the best case scenario the the temperature that you would need to produce uh black holes to explain a lot of dark matter is around 10 to the 5 or 10 to the 6 gav so we're talking here about very very low reheating temperatures very low uh transition temperatures uh so yeah the key point here after all that is simply that if you have a an early matter dominated era that ends when the universe has a temperature of 10 to the 5 or 10 to the 6 gb then you only need a power spectrum of 10 to the minus 4 to produce the the black holes which is an improvement over the the radiation case on the plot of the right side what i'm showing is the uh the sensitivity of the abundance to small changes in the height of the power spectrum so the purple curve shows the uh sensitivity of the abundance if there are the black holes formed during a radiation era and the blue curve shows the sensitivity of the abundance of the black holes form during a matter era so you see the important point here is that the blue region is a lot bigger than the purple region and what i'm depicting here is that one order by major change as i change the parameters inside the function so you see that uh if i change the vowel spectrum by a little bit just by a little bit in the horizontal axis i already reach a one-order magnitude change in the purple in the radiation case which is why the purple region is so small but to reach the same amount of change in the blue case i have to change the power spectrum by a lot so that the point here is that it is the the abundance is a lot less sensitive to small changes in the height of the power spectrum and this is good because it means that you're going to have to tune the parameters in your model less to get the same amount of black holes as a way of implementing this mechanism you can consider this uh action monodrome inspired potential and what this potential does is it features a bunch of oscillations because of the cosine term and this quadratic near the minimum so why is this important is because once the inflation reaches the minimum of a potential what you have is you can show that if the minimum is quadratic enough uh what you have is uh that the inflation is uh when it oscillates around the the the minimum behaves as a smarter so if if the once once inflation ends and the infrastructure starts oscillating near the minimum of the potential what you're going to have is a long epoch of matter domination as long as for heating is preservative meaning that no preheating occurs but this is going to depend of course on the on the coupling of the influence of the other particles in your model so the the original motivation that we had well let me first tell you about the parameters in the potential this p parameter that is shown here controls the slope of the potential at large field values so uh this p parameter basically is what is the the main thing that is going to determine how good how how well you're going to fit the cmb data because it's what changes the potential at large field values at low field values as you can see in this plot this p parameter doesn't really have an effect and what does have an effect is this kappa parameter this kappa which is multiplying the cosine changes the depth of each one of these minima and uh this depth is what uh it's what you want to to to change in order to obtain the large enhancement of the power spectrum so basically this capability is going to determine how big your power spectrum is and the p parameter is going to determine how well you can fit the uh the cmb data so uh the last thing i wanted to tell you here is that the the the motivation that we had to choose this potential was we thought maybe by having many many oscillations in the potential we could reduce the tuning in the uh the parameters of the model reason being that it is uh if you have several minima then maybe even if the implant does not produce the black holes in one of the minima it would produce them once you reach the next minimum and it turns out that this is not the case because the abundance is so sensitive to this uh to the depth of each one of these minima that you have basically just have to choose one of the minima and tune that to to get the the correct amount of black holes so actually you didn't need the you don't need to use a potential this complicated to you to do to implement the matter dominated scenario uh as long as you can get uh an early matter dominated there via some other mechanism you can always uh for instance further from the same uh polynomial model that we had before you could also get the the the black holes so uh nevertheless we're going to choose this potential and the mechanism is now illustrated in these examples that i show here so on the left side you can see the power spectra that we get or when all of the the parameters in the potential are equal to between each example except for kappa which as i said is the parameter that controls the depth of each minima and therefore is what controls the the size of the power spectrum and so the highest of this power spectra which is around 10 to the minus 2 is what's going to correspond to the to producing these black holes during a radiation era and the two smaller spectra correspond to producing this black holes during an early mature dominated era and the corresponding up the abundances corresponding to each one of these three examples uh shown on the right side so uh once again the the power specs that you need to produce them during radiation you can see that it's a lot bigger than what you would need if you wanted to produce them in mass domination the different abundances are shown on the right side and uh you can see that the abundance corresponding to the radiation case is actually a lot narrower than the one corresponding to the matter case and the reason is that uh precisely because the beta function that the that determines the abundance is different uh and because you don't have the in the matter case you don't have the exponential dependence that you had in the radiation case this uh this exponential this exponential dependence in the variation case was actually giving you a suppression to this uh to this abundance now because you lose that suppression distributions are a little wider and this is a problem because if they are too wide then you can see that you run into problems with the the bounds coming from hawking variation which are shown in in red so one way to overcome this uh this problem is to actually change the parameter i that is in in the beta function and which is uh related to the angular momentum of the collapsing cloud so let's go back quickly to the the function you see that in the second uh beta function you have this parameter y which is as i said is related to the angular momentum of the collapsing cloud and uh this this should be a parameter if you estimate it you find that it should be a parameter of order one so uh if you play around with this parameter meaning that uh basically what what you're doing is you're changing the the angular momentum of the cloud that is collapsing what you find is that uh you get a bit of additional suppression to the to the abundance and the the price that you have to pay of course is that the power spectrum now has to be a little bit bigger to account for this but uh by changing the this parameter a little bit you can evade the operation bounds so the conclusion here is that the main advantage of the matter dominated scenario is also the biggest drawback which is that lack of suppression makes it more difficult to evade the evaporation bounds and with this i conclude so the the the first thing i want to say is that the simplest potential that can produce promoted black holes is still viable provided that you either extend lambda by the simplest potential what i mean is that the polynomial potential that i showed you at the beginning it's viable provided you either extend lambda cdm or you add higher dimensional operators to the to the potential and both of these are natural solutions uh the second thing is that if dark matter is in the form of black holes then we should be able to detect the corresponding gravitational wave signal with plaster on the psycho if they formed a radiation domination the third thing is that we have shown analytically that at leading order at least the stochastic inflation formalism does not affect the power spectrum even in the presence of an ultra slope of phase uh it's important to know that this is only a leading order this does not mean that the formalization stochastic inflation does not have any effect on the abundance of the black holes but at least at the with the approximations that we made it we find that it doesn't you would have to solve the the the length of an equations uh completely numerically to find the the the correct effect of the of the formalism but within the approximations that we've made we find that it does not have a an effect uh the next thing is that the promoter black confirmation in an early matter dominated era has two big advantages one is that because of the lack of radiation pressure you need a smaller enhancement of the power spectrum to produce your black holes and the second one is that the parameters in your potential are now going to be less tuned precisely because the beta function is different then it is a lot less sensitive to small changes in these parameters and the final thing is that the the drawback of this matter-dominated scenario is that the this lack of suppression makes it a lot more difficult to evade of operation bounds and uh yeah that is everything i wanted to talk to you about so thank you very much and thanks again for for having me thank you very much julian so just before to to start with the session round you can for the people that is following the youtube channel you can ask questions via the youtube chat so in the beginning we are going to start with some questions from here from the audience of the law physics so i guess alejandro cardenas want to address a question for for julian thank you roberto and thank you julian for this very interesting talk and well presented top with a lot of details i'm not an expert on this uh but but i'm curious about them for example here your second conclusion here about the detectability so i believe what you show for this uh to address detectability is the gravitational wave energy density uh which is like it seems like you compute the perturbations and then you hit the noise curve to to assess that it will be below above the noise curve of lisa does detect but so my question is is more about how actually this will be detectable in the sense that it is i believe that what we typically do is we compute gravitational waves and then we will do either much filtering or something to extract that signal yes so could you please comment on on these cosmological things like do they actually yeah so this uh what you're talking about this match filtering is actually what what you would use if you were detecting for instance a burst uh correct a burst of a signal right if you had a merger or something like this but what i'm talking about here is actually a stochastic background so you would not see a burst but rather what you would find is that there is additional noise in the mirrors that you do not know how to account for it's basically the same thing that happened when we found the the cmb there was this additional noise that nobody knew where it was coming from and it turns out that it's uh because of this stochastic radiation that's in the background it's exactly the same here so uh this is this would just show up a stochastic noise in the in the movement of the mirrors so has do you know if there are any works related like if this actually for example for lisa can be extracted in the sense that uh lisa will have a lot of constant sources uh in this like i don't know a white dwarf population so this is different uh like in ligo for example is more or less what you just mentioned that you will have a burst and then you can detect it because you can you can fit this but in lisa is different because all the sources are sort of turned on at the same time uh so do you know like even though here for example it looks like it's way above the noise curve i don't it means that um so so it would be a detectable in that sense because you can really model this noise and then extract it yeah so so what you're seeing here in this noise curve is precisely uh it actually gives you that information right as long as you have a curve above this uh this curve it means that you can account for the so the the what the noise curve is showing you is every uh source of noise that we know about and this is actually what it what is model when you when you draw this curve so uh yeah as long as you find anything that is not this curve as long as you find anything that is above it uh then you know that the the this is a source of noise that you have not accounted for and i guess as once you rule out everything like uh i don't know as astrophysical sources of noise for instance which is actually where it's modeled in this curve uh well the first thing that you would think is that it has a stochastic uh background right okay so yeah so it's detectable as long as it is above this this noise curve yes but but for example if you think about i don't know for example the nominal or like the first gravitational wave detection with uh ligo that could have been observed with lisa but then you see that it just leaves the band and then goes to like a band for example but then even in those cases i believe it's quite actually challenging even though it's above the noise curve that are as i said like a lot of other sources so my question is like if somebody has actually performed an analysis saying like you can indeed model for uh white dwarfs and i don't know supermassive black holes embryos gravity ligo type sources that will be seen first at lego in lisa and then this stochastic background my understanding is that this this noise curve actually already accounts for all of these uh different noise sources uh i may be wrong but my understanding is that that this this red curve for instance that i show here as lisa is actually already has all of those noise sources into account um and i don't know if they're maybe i'm wrong i don't know but this is my understanding okay thank you okay let's uh let's see if there are some questions for the people in youtube if they want to ask to julian so meanwhile we can start with some other questions here for the audience in the in the zoom session i don't know nicole has one task okay thanks for the night talk uh could you go back to your slide i think it was 16 when you talked about the formation of pbh in the matter era yes okay first one question this tm correspond to the reheating temperature or did you say transition temperature but what's that exactly so uh the tm let me show you the the plot i had before so it's a problem with a different error so you can see that tm is the temperature that corresponds between to the to the change between the early macro dominator and the radiation error so uh i call it by heating temperature sometimes because the uh the easiest way that you can get an early matter dominated era is if you have perturbative preheating so if the infertile is oscillating around the minimum of the potential and the heating is preservative then the ceramic dominated the air comes from the heating but the models that i'm showing you here are not dependent on that so tm is basically the transition temperature regardless of whatever mechanism you use to get this early matter dominated era okay but yeah but it is the onset of the radiation right yes yes okay and thanks and if you go back to that slide so 16 so maybe it's my um intuition that it's miserably failing but you say that pbh only grows during radiation i was expecting the opposite right i mean in matter there's no pressure so they're expecting pbh to grow even faster than radiation no so so what uh what happens to the material is that this is when they form so you're correct when they form it's easier for them to form if they are in a mother era than if they're in a radiation era but once they have formed once you have already all of your black holes in the universe uh the because the black holes behave as matter right this is why we can think of them as dark matter but they behave as some other fluid their energy density that the energy density of the total amount of black holes red shifts as uh the scale factor to the power minus three right because it's matter but radiation red shifts uh as eight to the minus four and so uh if you take the ratio you find that uh uh radiation red shifts more quickly than the the black holes and this is why the the total energy density actually grows during the radiation era so if the universe was always matter dominated for instance you would you would not have a growth of the of the abundance right because the ratio would be the same always so this is why the the it's why it grows during radiation okay so you mean that the proportion of uh energy stored in pbh is growing correct tv that a single pbh is like accreting or something like this no no no no exactly okay okay thanks okay maybe are there other questions for the moment just from youtube the rv fair he's saying that it was a very nice talk that he thanks to you you julian so uh i don't know if there are other questions but i have a very small question about uh if you can comment about desi go because you i mean i didn't know that existed so maybe it's my hand most of the the the the the capability of the signal was in the in the area in which your model is producing a lot of signal so yeah so i don't know much about the experiment so i can't say a lot uh i don't know it's it's a little bit to the right uh in the frequency range is a little bit to the right of lisa but there's some overlap between both as you can see here and uh i don't know what this is an experiment that is uh planned yeah and it's not something it's constructed yet same as lisa and uh well there's not much more i can say i think uh um it's an experiment that we do not have yet but uh yeah it falls uh it would if it gets constructed uh it would be uh good to probe this this kind of model so it's sort of complementary to lisa in the same frequency range okay but just a nice question so this design is is ground-based no i think it's i think basically maybe i'm wrong but i think it's space-based as well yeah just like this okay so and another question very i mean also a naive question is when you were talking about the stochastic inflation because it looks very similar just just not not the the physics behind but just the formalism it looks very similar to when people try to solve the stochastic differential equation is it is in the same yeah this is a transition it's a these are these are actually stochastic differential equations so uh if you want to do them if you want to solve them completely numerically you know to get a full solution you have to use uh stochastic methods uh so yeah this is exactly what happens at each at each step in time this thing gets a stochastic kick so you have to do to solve them many many many times and and build like a probability distribution of the solution so yeah they are a stochastic questions okay so yeah okay yeah because when i look there the formula yeah it looks very similar because in in other fields also they appear like yeah yeah and i think that where is the randomness the okay yeah just that question so i don't know if that we have more question from from the audience okay i guess oscar zapata wants to have one [Music] okay thank you for the nice presentation i i would like to [Music] do julian regarding the constraints and of the lemsing constraints could you comment something uh about them and yeah i i i heard that there is some i don't know tension in that kind of constraints yeah so well the the real constraints that we have come from microlensing from femto lensing effect the phantom lensing constraints are the ones that are shown in in in pink here and this is this is not an actual constraint it's just a projection of future constraints we could have from fentanyl lensing the microlensing constraints are actual constraints and uh let me show they are this uh uh this curve that is around the tensile minus elaboration of masses from the subaru experiment so uh i don't know the story about this constraint so well but you're right as you can see here there is a very uh this is like a vertical uh line that is cutting this uh constraints below ten to the minus eleven and they think that on the the the tension that you were referring to is the fact that before this uh this wasn't the vertical line right this was uh a full constraint that went uh to around the middle of this open window but then i think i think what happens is that people realize there were some astrophysical uncertainties with these constraints and then what happened was that they they had to revisit the original estimation they had to cut this uh this site because of these uh astrophysical uncertainties um and then um this uh the i think the the actual uh the actual constraints that we have now are more or less this i don't know if there are some uh updated plots but as far as i know they're the these these are the ones and uh they end at around 10 to the minus 11 there's this sharp the sharp cut here precisely because of the the the uncertainties that we're not taking into account before another answer is the question you think okay i don't know maybe if there is another question for for julian let me just check fast in there okay it seems that we are okay and also due to time we have to close here so let's invite to everybody to first to thanks to to julian to for his very interesting talk indeed was very i mean i learned a lot with with his talk so for the rest of the people you can you know that you can follow the low physics youtube channel you can subscribe to be updated with all the latest webinars that we are programming during the the year since 2021 so and for the next the webinar is going to be around two weeks more it's going to be webinar 109 and it's going to be christoph dermes from university of torino so he will talk about neutrino oscillations more or less that is going to be the topic so i invite everybody to to join for the next webinar law physics webinar and see you in the next time thanks julian again for your nice webinar uh thank you very much for having me and we see it we see each other next time here in offices bye | lawphysics | UCy8fqkl7nywr1TRT4nPwS4A | 2021-03-03 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 12,617 | 66,459 |
TnY91HyD1ZU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TnY91HyD1ZU | HOW TO Object Tracking | Davinci Resolve 18 Tutorial | how to track things in DaVinci Resolve let's go place the media want to track over your clip select both right click new Fusion clip select your clip where you want to track something in it shift space and type in play node tracker and hit enter now go to the beginning of your clip hit set draw a rough circle around the thing you want to track in my case my watch change your tracker mode to hybrid and the motion type translation and hit track to end the Fiverr don't work drive with point so my watch is not tracked from beginning to end now hit create planar transform now I place the trainer platform between my image and a merge node by holding shift and drag it on Let It Go Boom now you can see my image is already tracked on my watch but I have to resize it that it perfectly matches my watch selective title transform shift space and type in transform hit enter and now you can adjust the size or Center of your tracked image after adjusting the center of X and Y you can now see the logo is perfectly tracked to my watch oh thanks for watching see you in the next one like and follow for more editing tips | DAWIET | UCtMj6OQY8-_iIogVmO_IyuQ | 2022-11-02 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 220 | 1,117 |
Ebz1-jfVJ90 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ebz1-jfVJ90 | Paula Detjen on Problem Gambling | hi my name is Carl Arnold I'm an attorney and mediator uh in Minnesota with Arnold law and mediation and I've run into some issues with clients regarding gambling recently and I thought I'd try to learn more about it and that's why we're having this conversation this is Paula detjen she's a licensed and marriage and family therapist and she's also a Minnesota state approved provider on problem gambling hi Paula hi Carl so let me ask you what is problem gambling sure the problem gambling is the inability um over an extended time to resist impulses to gamble there's an increased preoccupation with gambling and a loss of control individuals may find themselves chasing your losses feeling the need to bet more and a continued uh disregard for the consequences of their gambling Behavior so uh there's all sorts of gambling there's betting on horses there's betting on Collegiate games I'm sure and whatever else what other forms of G I guess playing cards right what else there's the casinos there's playing cards for money betting on sports lottery tickets pull tabs scratch offs stocks and day trading we have we have slot machines to name a few okay so who becomes a problem Gambler in other words is there a certain type of person or is it just anyone yep anyone can become a problem Gambler it could be men women old young wealthy or people of any color any faith uh or any tradition anyone can become a problem gambler okay so are there warning signs uh about problem gambling mhm yeah some of the warning signs uh someone could look for is neglecting family and work responsibilities lying about um being lying and being secretive about finances promising to stop and then gambling again increasing time and money spent on gambling uh lack of of interest in activities that once used to be pleasurable convinced that past losses can be one back you may see anxiety depression uh feelings of guilt even suicidal thoughts and for some problem gamblers there's committing illegal acts such as forgery fraud embezzlement in order to get money to continue gambling well let me direct a question at let's say somebody's viewing this and they're thinking to themselves am I a problem Gambler do I you know how would I even think about that what questions could I ask myself good question well a person can ask themselves in the past year have I gambled more than intended have I borrowed money for beding and not repa it uh have I felt badly about the amount that I've bet uh felt need to continue gambling until there's a win spend a lot of time thinking about winning or planning on when the next play will be returning to gamble to win back the losses had arguments about money centered around gambling convinced that a big win is just around the corner or claim to be winning money but really weren't if an individual answers yes to one or more more of these then they may be at risk for developing a gam a gambling problem is gambling something that's just here with us uh with individuals and with our community or is there is there help out there there is help and particularly here in Minnesota we we have studies that show that treatment is effective in many cases in Minnesota there are programs ranging from Gamblers Anonymous to Community outpatient and inpatient treatment centers there are more than 50 programs throughout Minnesota with state approved professionals trained in helping problem gamblers and their family members or what we call affected others there are also State funds available for outpatient treatment as well as inpatient Services by the state U with an approved provider on problem handling residents who qualify will be able to have have all or part of the cost of their treatment paid if they meet the criteria the clinical diagnosis and demonstrate Financial need there is help for family members for a friend for a coworker for oneself and this can be found simply by calling the Minnesota problem gambling hotline and that number is800 3334 or 4 4673 again 1 800 333 4673 there you'll you will find that you'll be able to receive help Hope and free of judgment well thank you so if somebody was looking to learn more about your practice and perhaps meet with you uh how would what information can you give out sure um anyone can contact or visit me at my website and that address is www.en counseling.com uh spell D like David E T J N Run that together with counseling dchen counseling.com uh or I can be reached at 507 58143 well so this has been Carl Arnold with Arnold La mediation and this is also been uh Paula dejen she's a licensed marriage and family therapist and also a Minnesota state approved provider on problem gambling thanks a lot Paula thanks Carl | pokercasinoreview | UC8vNZeN0iy2FKptjUeyGIVQ | 2011-12-29 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 837 | 4,710 |
fYBrunn1um0 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fYBrunn1um0 | Sagittarius: YOU'RE ON A HIGH!! 🚀♐ - Sagittarius February 2024 | welcome Sagittarius let's unveil the stars and dive deep into our weekly horoscope for 12 to 18 February 2024 this week is brimming with promise and potential as the stars align from February 12th to 18th 20124 a wave of energy is set to boost your every Endeavor let's dive into what the cosmos has in store for you this week your ruling planet Jupiter encourages you to dream big the universe Whispers expand your horizons whether it's a personal project or a professional ambition Now's the Time to push beyond your limits in terms of health the Stars signal a need for balance Mars suggests Vigor yet warns against overexertion incorporate mindful practices like yoga or meditation into your routine they're your allies in maintaining equilibrium and boosting Vitality relationships enter a harmonious phase with Venus casting of favorable glow connections deepen misunderstandings dissolve and for those single The Winds of romance May blow in your direction Embrace openness and honesty for thriving bonds career-wise Mercury's position encourages Clarity in communication a project or idea you've been nurturing could catch the eyes of those that matter be bold in your proposals and expect fruitful discussions and negotiations the week ALS o presents an ideal time for financial planning Saturn's influence urges prudence and long-term thinking review your Investments and budget consider Consulting a financial adviser to maximize your resources efficiently creatively you're on a high Neptune enhances your imaginative faculties urging you to channel your inner artist whether it's writing painting or music your creative outputs could find appreciative audiences or Inspire new projects by the weekend take stock of the progress made reflect on the lessons learned and how they shape your path forward this introspection solidifies your gains and prepares you for the next Cosmic phase Sagittarius as this week unfolds remember the power within you to shape your destiny with the Stars as your guide embrace the journey ahead with confidence and a spirit of Adventure here's to a week of growth connection and discovery | Sagittariusdynasty | UCki2oM_LExMCscD279S8Iqw | 2024-02-12 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 339 | 2,131 |
YVtatKEVXrk | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVtatKEVXrk | Kailash Chandra Vol 1, Exercise 2 Font, Speed- 90 | yes be ready start I should like now to make a few observations on the budget . this budget marks a turning point in the history of our country . it is no use attempting as so as some of my friends have done either - Deb deprecated the budget very strongly or to suggest that we are not witnessing a new revolution in our methods of fiscal training and technique . i want it to be quite clearly pointed out to many to my friends that we are now facing the lean years of indian finance . hitherto we had revenue sir policies which were a form of public saving and which were meant to be utilized for capital development . hereafter this form of revenue surplus would not be available . we have therefore to find out ways and means of implementing our great program of national reconstruction at minimum cost . my point is that the deficit on revenue account would be of the order of about rupees 19 to 20 crores . here let me point out that i do not agree with those o my friend in the finance department who have attempted to suggest that rupees 9 to 18 crores which are obtained from Pakistan should be put to the revenue side of the budget they are to be put on the capital side . but that does not seriously alter the trend of my argument . what i am suggesting is that we would have to be prepared for a deficit of a much higher order even on the revenue side . that itself should make us realize that there are very many problems which we have to face and that we have to undertake ways and means of increasing the resources of our country so that it might be possible for us to have a greater amount of surplus or a greater amount of public saving for the purpose of financing capital development . the finance minister in the course of his speech mr. deputy minister pointed out that the deficits during the past two years were of the order of rupees 83 crores . i venture humbly to disagree with him because I plead that when we are talking up deficits we must take into account the overall deficit incurred by the central government and that would be of the order of rupees 200 crores . during the years of really relatively light expenditure we had shortfall we had a shortfall hope about rupees 200 crores | Steno Point | UCOkNx5xXbz7qT7aRLE_zJHw | 2018-02-27 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 425 | 2,216 |
73i6OakG5U0 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73i6OakG5U0 | Home Canning: Cultural Narratives, Technological Change & the Status of Traditional Knowledge | from the Library of Congress in Washington DC you hello my name is Nancy Grossman I'm a folklorist at the American Folklife Center here at the Library of Congress and I'd like to welcome you to the latest presentation on our ongoing Benjamin a Botkin lecture series the bakken series allows us to highlight their work the work of leading scholars in the discipline of folklore ethnomusicology oral history and cultural heritage while enhancing the collections here at the American Folklife Center for the center and the library the bakken lectures form an important facet of acquisitions activities each lecture is videotaped and becomes part of a permanent collections in addition the lectures are later posted as webcasts on the library's website where they are available for viewing to Internet patrons throughout the world so if you haven't already done so now would be an excellent time to turn off any electronic devices you have with you very often the American Folklife Center partners with other divisions here at the Library of Congress to put on lectures and concerts and today I'm delighted to say that this event is being co-sponsored by the John W Kluge Center and I want to thank the Kluge Center for their their help and support in this project one of the great joys of working as a folklorist of the enormous scope of topics that folklorists are encouraged to study although folklorists might be better known for their research in music and legends myths and customs and material culture many folklorists are also involved in studying traditions and practices are surrounding food food preparation and preparation and preservation and the use of food in rituals and celebration the American Folklife Center our archive contains an enormous amount of materials about food and food relations rated lis food-related traditions and I welcome you all to come and do research in our holdings today I have the pleasure of introducing folklorist daniil LC Christensen over the last year or so has as a Kluge fellow has been here at the library and using the resources of the American Folklife Life Center as well as the holdings of numerous other divisions to study they'll be addressing today which will be addressed in today's talk dr. Christiansen received her PhD in folklore from Indiana University and is an assistant tech her work focuses on the ways people shape everyday speech actions and the objects they seek to influence and persuade others she's especially interested in gender domestic domestic labor as a site of commentary and display in 2015 she was awarded a prestigious John W clukey fellowship by the Library of Congress and she's presently completing her book about freedom from want home canning in the in the American imagination which is based on her Cooley project today she will be speaking on home canning cultural narratives technological change and the status of traditional knowledge I'd ask you to join me in welcoming her dr. Kristin [Applause] hello it's good to see so many friends out there and thank you for giving up your lunch hour and I apologize in advance for talking about food during the lunch hour that you're giving up my topic today is home canning that is the preserving of heat sarah lights fruit vegetables and meat and sealed containers I'm interested in the technologies involved in the artifacts and processes that turn perishable matter into stuff that can be stored and exchanged according to human desires but I also want to know how technologies them excuse me I want to know how technologies themselves and the societies in which they are apart are shaped by talk so in a moment moment I'm going to share some of the narratives that circle around home canning what kinds of values and agendas has candy been connected with and who and and how who is telling these stories and why what kinds of power relationships emerge are there good guys and bad guys and how do changes in technology and other material contexts affect how these stories play out I'll spend some time sharing an overview of cultural narratives that emerged in materials from the Library of Congress and then are shifting to do narratives about progress and authoritative knowledge that tend to erase women's roles first though let me share my appreciation for everyone who's made my time here at the Library of Congress that's so amazing I've been here since February and unfortunately I'm headed back to Blacksburg and two weeks glad to be going back to Blacksburg but sad to be leaving the library so to my Cooley my Kluge colleagues who were still in the United States and made the trek over from our offices in the Jefferson building thanks for the conversation commiseration and willingness to act excited over small scholarly breakthroughs the Kluge staff also have my gratitude for their support problem-solving ability to procure European chocolate and general goodwill Nancy Gross and others at the American Folklife Center did the lake legwork for the spot can lecture which is one small part of the regular permit programming my current work in progress as Nancy mentioned is a book called freedom from watch home canning in the American imagination and I got its start here at the Library of Congress in 2012 when I was privileged to receive a Parsons fellowship during the two summers I spent doing concentrated work in the American Folklife Center Reading Room I read field notes examined photographs and transcribed interviews about food preservation in mountains of North Carolina and Virginia and West Virginia's cold river valley on ranches in Nevada and among immigrant families in the American West my folklore colleagues here at the library offered invaluable help and encouragement over those those years and the collections themselves helped me understand how home bottling traditions fit into a matrix of preservation activities the Blue Ridge and Coal River collections for example demonstrate a range of dehydration practices that continue because they make sense in terms of local tastes social structures built environments and values such as a reluctance to be completely dependent on electricity so Thursday a Easter and some of his technology here's a carry sievert her this image and her interviews and things in the collection demonstrate how some technologies are dependent on on others such as her drying rack and wood stove combination the drying rack is not too useful without the stove and I don't have a photo of anyone using a car dashboard as a drying rack but that's another strategy that's very efficient here's Maisie Beamer of Galax Virginia who noted that people drive food on class and the son of they don't have space inside a roof she said well dry food in a hurry when it's a hot day in fact she'd gotten tired of eating the fresh beans in her refrigerator and puts them out to dry in her Stella Ruth the day folklorist Jerry Johnson stopped to talk with her and I'll be showing lots of photographs today I feel like I spent at least two months in prints and photographs and then two months in Folklife and so I wanted to showcase some of the really great resources that we have here so it's here here's one last photo from the AFC collections this is from the coal River project and here's an example of leather britches beans strung unthread and hung from porch beans or rafters the pods take four or five days to dry outside unless it's rainy or damp when the weather turns you've got to bring them inside the drying beans look pretty festooning rafters and port railings like Chula Vista's in New Mexico strong leather breeches act as a visual symbol of shared culture within Appalachian communities I also spent a lot of time as I said in prints and photographs the staff there took me hostage for two months always finding new things for me to look at and I'm really grateful thank you I see you in the back row you'll see plenty of examples throughout the presentation and I did finally make it two rare books and manuscripts so I thanks to Michael North mephone Ashman Stephanie and others who helped me track down the books I needed including this book Anna Mary Dutton's book from 1800 in 18th century and 19th century English language sources they make clear distinctions between the verbs to preserve which means to use sugar right to pickle which means to use a salt brine or vinegar and to keep which means to maintain for a relatively long time and relative means like until Christmas or all winter or the next year without the use of a taste altering preservative so that distinction that we often think about as being just part of contemporary caning where you don't add sugar and things right you can find it in these these older books as well this so-called cold water method to keep barberries that's up here was still being advocated in 1919 to preserve rhubarb cranberries gooseberries and sour cherries although the 1919 author olive hayes noted in italics that quote this method is not always successful as the acid content varies with the ripeness and the locality in which the fruits are grown and I'll come back to her concern with context a little bit later also in rare books I found this British Bill Affair published in 1708 which called for February meals that included peas asparagus strawberries and cream several apple pies raspberry cream and gooseberry tarts some of the fruit had probably been over wintered in coolest cellars or forced early in greenhouses the menus were created by Henry Howard who was a well-regarded chef employed by several members of the aristocracy so he would have had access to hot houses but the gooseberry tarts were possible because at least by the late 1680s people knew how to store a firm whole firm acidic fruits including gooseberries currants cherries bonuses and damsons and sealed bottles and jars and vilasa and damsons like plums belong to the genus Prunus though they're smaller drier and tighter than their sweet meaty cousins I'm this book which included the the menus was first published in 1703 by 1726 the book had gone into a fifth printing a recipe Howard calls to keep gooseberries appeared unchanged and the the second 7:08 Edition and the fifth printings and it's likely it appears in the original 1703 book as well as you'll see the recipe relies on two the two procedures fundamental to what we now call canning first existing detrimental yeast molds and bacteria are killed or through the application of heat and second further contamination is minimized by sealing the container and by stopping down close you notice that he actually calls for clarified mutton fat to be used to seal the the damsons and what's interesting so in the the preface to this book he talks about the different kinds of manuscript sources that these come from all right so finally I'm indebted to Allison Kelly and Connie Carter in the library science technology and business division who have loaned me their personal books offered me snacks and some relevant materials over the past four years and actually the other day Connie just gave me this replica Baltar so I show you in the stacks I discovered more than I thought I needed to know about 19th century technologies like this wax sealer and I also learned how fluid food preservation processes in terms were the turn of the century so at the third annual Lake Placid conference on home economics this is mrs. Melville doing Annie Dewey who was the wife of Dewey Decimal Fame right and so she's setting out sort of a scheme of how to organize preservation I think she was actually part of a larger home economics section of the Dewey Decimal System and I have found recipes for preserving a food with borax so that's not a mistake but the sort of organizational scheme seems a little fuzzy to me here you know so the boiling and sterilization can overlap so they're sort of coming to clarify those terms I guess for themselves I also accumulated a lot of food safety texts and food science and technology and so I think this is as good a time at any to go over a few food safety principles that will be useful in understanding the rest of the conversation today right so first you need to sort of kill or disable existing microbes so you can do that through sterilization high temps over a sufficient enough time you can also add sugar or salt or acid or you can dehydrate things to desiccation once you have sort of disable the microbes need to keep in microbes out so you need to have some sort of a seal right so that's sort of the basic parameters were working within and you can see that in this 1876 set of instructions where you take cold fruit and put a hot syrup and put into a jar you place the open jar in a boiler lined with a great pebbles and straw to sort of protect it from breakage you fill it up with water to the neck you cover the boiler and boil for a specific amount of time depending on what you're cooking you remove it and let it the darts stand for five minutes and then you add a rubber ring and a cap and screw it down with a wrench because this is a zinc cap that you have to really put a lot of effort into getting it down there but you can see that this is a little problematic because it doesn't add the seal until after the serialization it's already processed right so you've got a chance for contamination to occur so again you need to do it in that order right first you sort of cover it you sterilize it and then you make sure that it's sealed airtight okay so the last acknowledgement I want to give is to Benjamin Botkin for whom this lecture series is named he's shown here in his Victory Garden during World War two but can champion the notion that vernacular expressive culture is always relevant to contemporary social and political life the pattern things people say do and make in everyday life are not merely practical or decorative and but in fact they shape structures of power and home canning is a case in point shelf-stable canned goods have been part of everyday American life since the mid 19th century while industrial canning utilized Middletons and mechanized processes other forms of canning came to rely on glass bottles and the domestic labor of women and I should reiterate that that in the United States home canning has come to refer almost exclusively to preserving fruit and vegetables in airtight jars in the literature it's not unusual to hear people talk about glass cans right when they're referring to jars of course the job is not fine exclusively to women so here you see this couple from New Mexico working on currants and apricots that said the story of canning is complicated right even in the early 1900's the practice had multiple meanings for some homecare old-fashioned inefficient or embarrassing already by like the early 1900s for others it was a valuable skill to be displayed in public and mobilized in times of need in today's context of economic instability automated systems and cultural and environmental change do-it-yourself candy is experiencing a revival more people are canning their own food the process can be a way to recall people in places to perform authentic or esoteric taste and to enact abstract values such as stewardship or self-sufficiency that is a vernacular process i canning becomes instrumental in articulating and further materializing ideographs those seemingly self-evident words and phrases that quote function as guides warrants reasons or excuses for behavior and belief and that's Michael McKee these one time one term sums of an orientation include things like tradition heritage authenticity art identity but also a number of key words and code words that index broader cultural narratives and ideologies I'll show you a few examples so one cultural narrative or sort of idea graph that indexes these larger cultural narratives is creativity these images one from 2011 the other from the 1940s demonstrate how canning can be an expressive creative practice not merely a practical one people often think of canning in the past as people just did it because they had to when we do it now because we choose to but that's not an accurate depiction of what it from what I have found of people's motivations for canning right Beauty has always been something that people have been interested in and sought after I'm going to show you a range of photos that sort of emphasize how home canning can be a site of display so you're here you have mrs. Frank Jacobs who is carefully placing pears in a jar and that has a practical effect of making sure that you've got it closed an efficient pack right so things are seems to be floating up but it's also aesthetically pleasing especially in terms of sort of evenness and regularity which is often valued among people who can here's another sort of sense of canning as display you can't see the the sign very well right here but it's actually sort of a call for people to contribute exhibits I can sort of a rotating exhibit each of these has the name of the woman who made it some of them I've been able to read um with magnification but this display is interesting in that it sort of brings together national security which I'll get to in a moment because it's part of a World War one IRRI display but it's also a chance in this public venue right the library for women to explain handiwork and here we have the Gonzales County Fair I should say that display is not incidental among many canners it may ask actually affect the procedures that they employ when illinois bacteriologist noted in 1935 that taste texture color and arrangement of jarred foods are one thing when it comes to earning social recognition at the county fair but concerned about public health risks to trump other performance agendas you thought he railed against housewives and they're ill informed teachers who use unsafe procedures in the name of display numerous books he observed cautioned that quote temperatures higher than boiling tend to injure the Delic delicate color and texture of most fruits in an attempt to preserve flavor and yet address growing awareness of microscopic threats in the early 1900's some canners experimented with a sterilization process in which food was heated several times but at temperatures below boiling and this is also a similar process was actually promoted by the USDA as in the teens and the internment method as a way to sort of kill off the idea was that spores might not germinate the first day but if he waited another day then they were germinate and then you could boil them again and kill that right in 1932 well actually in 1913 three students at Stanford died because they ate food I'm used using this method so that does have some risks here's another sort of version of canning as a sight for display this is from the 1960s and it's part of a concerted effort to make canning appealing to younger women and what's really interesting in this is that it says can't you just see yourself praised admired envied appreciated and it goes through each of these different sort of potential audiences this young woman might have and shows how canning could help her win some social status another sort of ideograph or narrative that index is this idea of abundance right so here we're back at this other image because it was produced by the Office of War Information during World War two it's also concerned with abundance and it actually sort of steps out of display conventions that many home painters have when they're not I'm like this is posed by a photographer right so often these will be arranged according to sort of color and type of food right and these are sort of mismatched but they show the the variety of different kinds of foods from potatoes to to beets and peas greens right that's available I can be available to families during wartime sometimes I have been overwhelmed by the abundance that I've seen in the FSA in owi files this family was actually the doc and Julia Miller family they're White Plains Georgia they have eight kids four teenagers there is a lot of variety and the kinds of foods that they're on display but I have to wonder how they got all that food up in the middle of the yard right I mean here's sort of a another view and a lot of times when Farm Security Administration photographers were in some ways documenting the results funds that have been given to families as part of various recovery programs and I'm afraid that at times was inconvenient for them to display but it is an impressive show and here we see a narrative of self-sufficiency the idea that you can pull yourself up by your bootstraps but you might need a little help along the way so on the on this one side it says John was not getting the right kind of food no garden no cow no canned stuff for winter thousands of farm families were sick because they do not grow their own food on the other side John two years later after his family started to live at home farming I need to eat the right things to eat the families have learned to grow their own good health and script through Farm Securities program of live at home farming okay and these exact same images were used for another panel that was called they need our help to help themselves okay so sort of posing this was a choice that's available to the individual and also to the society another thing that you see is economic security and actually if you think about it canning is a practice that an axon ations dominant economic system right it is a literal accumulation of capital stored up to enable future productive capacity another theme is national security both in terms of food produced at home and abroad so the southern food will win the war and write the peace but also here you see it as a metaphor for geopolitical containment all right of the Kaiser and the national security images seem to inspire a lot of sort of moments of levity at least given canteens tremendous pun potential so here we have women from Summit New Jersey dressed in food conservation uniforms ready for a parade to promote Hoover's voluntary food conservation plan right there wasn't mandatory rationing and World War one so the right for parade and they've made these signs that say work or waste can a can for Uncle Sam canner collapse preserver Paris is another one that not here right so they've got their placards they've got their uniforms they're ready to go I also found so there are various youth groups including 4-h and Red Cross groups and conservation groups who got together and they would have these songs that they sing so if anyone wants to sing this it's to the tune of Oh Maryland or would Tannenbaum I will give you this jar of raspberry jam that I made earlier this summer any takers basically so this last part is a garden truck we here preserve our food supply we now can serve and so democracy we serve right here in Thompson Center thank you and I believe Thompson Center is here close by in in Maryland right okay we also have other ponds here we have Elsie Borden inter calf Beulah enlist the help of Elmer the bull and bringing in tomatoes from the garden note that they're using older with a lightning style jars with a glass lid and wire bale perhaps because of war shortages of metal but also for its nostalgic value and so we see this idea of preserving the American Way and encoded in that sort of notion of the American Way that you see here is a division of labor based in gender and there's a strikingly similar New Yorker cover by um Helen Hawkinson that also illustrates division of labor based in class and race as well so caning along with other domestic tests and skills was also used as a tool of assimilation and/or became a mark of acculturation on American Indian reservations and in boarding schools especially at the turn of the century so this idea of a particular kind of domesticity is also related to canning and this is a group that's gathered to learn about pressure cookers in Oklahoma the woman in the middle as far as I can identify her her in her 60s is Lady a human striker who was a schoolteacher and married to a local judge the four boys in front were for each boys who had to gather wood for the fire but this caning is also sort of a source of pride and connection right about how preserving strategies sync with indigenous fruit planting and harvesting traditions so this display of I can't tell exactly but I imagine at least some of those are peaches it would make sense because of the orchards that did any people have attended for hundreds of years and then we also here's another image by Virginia Stroud that is referring to gathering cactus fruit and berries as indigenous practiced in many parts of United States and then finally here is another form of sort of connection right we have a celebrity with common roots and this post on Loretta Lynn's official Facebook page was shared almost 3,000 times and liked by more than 30,000 people in less than 24 hours and it elicited thousands of really fascinating comments so that's just a quick rundown of some of the cultural narratives that King plays a role in that gives a sense of the discursive and ideological context that we're talking about and the context in which canning has or does play a part so I'm going to switch gears a little bit now because my thinking about context has been stimulated by in the last few months and by a book called the mushroom at the end of the world my aunt alone helped saying the books subject is the matsutake mushroom a much sought after fungus that flourishes in the wake of disruption in Oregon it loves living near the junky put lodged pine lodgepole pines that emerge after the ponderous ponderosas are gone in Japan matsusaki thrive in forests soils scraped clean by peasant forest II this mushrooms life ways are complex always attuned to and responding to other factors in its immediate environment matsutake life seeing rights is out of step with modern capitalism which is predicated on the ability to scale up to expand smoothly and new spaces without having to rethink its framing assumptions scalability has achieved she writes by minimizing encounter monoculture populations I'm sorry monoculture plantations for instance become infinitely scalable by first wiping local context clean by clear cutting forests existing communities and then importing cloned sugarcane sort of a plant life that's oblivious to encounter and coerced labor that's been shorn of social relations that could make a difference right this plantation style alienation where parts are infinitely interchangeable and exchangeable in the market can also be seen in fast-food franchises which seems so similar and their workers so dispensable blank slate ferments in the food world are another example of an attempt to make production predictable my by mitigating context in this case makers of cheese beer or wine produce a consistent product by first removing existing organisms in the base liquid and then reading inoculating it with a pure culture of the bacteria they wish to do its work and so I've been thinking about scalability in relation to the ways that home canning is often coupled narratively to fear into compliance if you google botulism you get pictures of mason jars botulism is a spectra that has haunted hunk finally since the early decades of this century not long ago when I attended a high high-end canning workshop traveling lecturer Marissa McLellan started her demonstration way she always starts by asking who's afraid of killing your whole family she then explained why the food she makes jams jellies and chutneys is no more dangerous than moldy bread you can kill anyone with pickles she told the crowd but people are still afraid and I should acknowledge here that there are real health risks involved in food processing emissions the deaths from botulism earlier and especially in the bottling of vegetables and meat up to date canning guidelines are important and I encourage you to consult the National Center for home food preservation at the University of Georgia for more specific information about current recommendations these nationwide guidelines are intended to ensure safety for all regardless of specific context and the wake of botulism scares of the 1920s for instance government instructors were asked to recommend only pressure painting just to be safe so for everything in instruction books like this hazel atlas manual from 1924 started telling their readers to boil the contents of every bottle of vegetables and meat before consuming it just to be safe context-free practices like the that have arguably defined modern life and notions of progress also do violence to localized knowledge which has learned through lifetimes of observation and practice and developed within certain strive circumscribed intertwine ecosystems in the case of home canning I'm going to focus on two examples of metaphorical clear-cutting in the name of progress first I'll explore how the idea of invention and discovery erase the complex networks that actually give rise to innovation and in this case erroneously reduce women to passive consumers of technology the histories of canning that crop up in everything from food magazines to microbiology textbooks books invariably celebrate a single father of canning Nicklaus up here and you can see he's a hero in France as well right he has his own stamp and this is a park with a statue that's devoted to him further a pair is depicted as a scientist motivated by military concerns and aligns progress with the blank slate of the laboratory a space positioned in contrast to Grandma's methods second I'll consider Clostridium botulinum the bacteria whose spore produces the botulism toxin an example of living complexity not unlike the matsutake one that emerges from an indeed is created by the ruins of the modern world appreciate the complexity of this microbes life wings makes me wary of blaming traditional knowledge when something breaks down the efficacy of some local practices canning corn and tomatoes together for instance or sealing cooked sausage and lard may be rendered useless or even dangerous by external factors that include changes in population mobility so people are new moving to new places at different altitudes and climates by changes in environmental conditions food systems food technologies and even changes in the chemistry of the food itself but these practices and the people who do them experience another blow when they are then blamed for these failures by being characterized as backwards sloppy habit driven or simply ignorant when existing systems break down and I'm not saying that local practice is apparently harmless for instance I would not try to convene the sausages in the dishwasher which I have heard of people trying to do um so let me just take you through sort of this story of home candy that it's often out there and I chose this one because it's kind of fun it's from the brochures that was handed out in my hometown of Columbus Ohio in the 1950s and I found it at the National Museum of American History and here's the story right home canning was first started by a great soldier an emperor they're losing men allocated 12,000 francs to any Frenchman who finds a simple way to preserve food so a pair you know drops everything he starts doing experiments he has some setbacks like any good inventor does and then after 15 long years you see a food is sealed from air it will keep for a long time but different foods need different Capri cooking times and you've made this time time chart for all foods amazing finally in 1810 he receives the prize and at the same time in england england you're seeing food metal canisters mr. Brent and that should be Durand yes you might see I'm canning food might into candy became widespread by 1850 but no one knew why I worked but thankfully there was Louie Pasteur and he figures out that the bacteria is the cause right and heating kills them they're in the sealer container and then we jump to the mason jar invented 96 years ago right and some different versions penny jars and they claim the today more food as canon homes and the combined output of all canning factories i have not been able to verify that claim that in any case this same history has been replete is repeated and almost every three obtaining that you will find in the magazine Lucky peach in a film that is distributed in four science classes for instance and this USDA website which was recently launched does an excellent job bringing together primary resources and documents related to the history of home canning and I encourage you to check it out and also to depicts very effectively the dominant history of canning looks like in these stories okay so you have this huge blank before a pair comes on the scene then you have this then nothing until John Mason invents the the mason jar 1858 and then the ball corporation comes in so this sort of a pair gets it gets lionized and actually James Collins who wrote sort of the history that everybody goes back to for the history of the commercial canning industry he writes that nobody had ever preserved fresh vegetables or fruits before for ages the world had known only drying salting and smoking to keep meats fish and a few fruits from season to season and he's actually publishing this in a canning trade periodical and asking for other commercial Cantor's to give him feedback so that the destroy will resort of reflect well on the canning industry so um this the sort of story that he tells is very similar to others histories of food preservation generally right and it's a very gendered story so this undated poster perhaps intended to grace the walls of a mid-century home a classroom tells a heroic narrative which engineered cold replaces passive heat as a way to arrest for food decay food preservation from caveman to kitchen chronicles technological advances that begin with Egyptian slaves drying fish in the Sun and end with an apron housewife unwrapping stakes pulled from the built-in chest freezer in her modern kitchen in between our decades of exploration experimentation and conquest and you can see here this is where right here is where the Napoleon a pear story comes in and most of this pictorial history women are bystanders to the various forms of physical and intellectual labor involved in making food last except for the final three frames of the chronology here they stand alone with refrigerators and freezers apparently enjoying freedom from extra work but historians Susan Strasser and Ruth Swartz Cohen have long since dispelled the notion the new household gadgets fuels and processes actually or automatically make women's lives easier new technologies have often simply created different work settled the full burden of work on a single woman shoulders or remove compensatory factions such as social interaction or opportunities for just Glade to display skill and beauty and the images in this poster confirm these losses these liberated women for instance are noticeably divorced from messy sensory stimuli and human interaction a more recent source also asserts that men and their inventions improve women's live lives does so a bit more suddenly this 1975 Canyon guide explains traditionally man has provided food and woman has preserved it but traditions change and roll switch in fact the canning process for preserving food was discovered by a man the next paragraph describes two colossal pairs experiments at the behest of Napoleon and then it continues a Paris discovery made life easier for women who had come to preserve summer harvests for winter nourishment and so home canning soon became a family tradition with one generation of women passing their special canning secrets along to the next like the food preservation poster the barnardine manual reduces the idea of liberation to extra leisure time a pair made life easier for women but in addition and like the suffrage era Campbell's soup adds that Catherine Parkin has analyzed this 1975 manual co-op's feminist discourses it raises the ideas of changing gender roles increased freedoms and distinctive kinds of knowledge but it does so in order to reassert the authority of men that is even in regard to women's work men did it first and they did it more rationally so men discover and women have secrets right and even this purported special knowledge is undermined by the next section of the manual which reveals just what those canning secrets are continual improvements in canning technologies often rendered the experiencial knowledge of women obsolete and grandma's knowledge was presented as dangerous even life-threatening so I just want to quickly show some of the predecessors that were out there there was an Italian abbe who in 1765 had done some experiments with meat extracts enclosed flasks but he didn't really apply that so James cullin who wrote the history of canning thought that was sort of a lame if you can't apply it in the commercial world right it doesn't really count as a discovery but there's also if you look at the manuscript sources you can see that these sort of food preservation processes but don't involve sugar that involve heating and sealing right are happening this particular one uses an oven this is from this the same cookbook of Mary Mott this is another recipe for gooseberries you can see that is quite close to the one that was published in 1703 that we saw earlier I'm going to compare these on a graph because I have time to sort of read all of these but you can see that they appear and most of these sources are from Great Britain but there are some that are from the United States especially in the nineteenth century this on the very first page of this book right you get a recipe for preserving currants and then there's also one there's another version read below here's from one from 1829 and this one has four different recipes for bottling fruit okay and so let me just show you this graph of all of these different recipes based on place ingredients for the you'll notice that they hardly any of them use liquid right and hardly any of them use sugar until you get into sort of later in the century almost all of them there are a couple that sort of baked things in the oven but the others are all scalded in water they're all except for these two are sealed before and they're sealed after with some particular kind of with rosin or pitch or other kinds of things there's precautions to take them from breakage right and also sometimes they're supposed to be for a particular duration well that sort of big takeaway is that there are all of these right that are going on people are sharing with each other they're attributing them to other women right before salvington Thomas Addington in English and the close up here in France I actually get patents on these sort of processes okay so they are the snowland is circulating and in fact in 1814 there's a review that basically says oh you didn't discover this on behalf of our country women you must observe that unless they have forsaken the example and precepts of their ancestors they must in general be more or less acquainted already with the methods of mr. up here right so there's this at least then there's sort of a knowledge that this is a common process that people are building from but it's sort of been erased in our histories since then let me just go over briefly some of the technological shifts that were happening because they explain why the climate is so sort of confusing in terms of processing over the course of the 19th and 20th centuries home canning technologies containers closures processing equipment processing techniques and even raw foods themselves underwent a series of small but ultimately dramatic changes here's a small sampling of closure types that people try to the end of the 19th century when home bottling as opposed to long-standing salt sugar vinegar based preservation methods Kaymer common these closures depend on wax or liquid lead or air pressure a rubber rings or mechanical pressure from wires your clamps or a combination of all these four just for good measure measure and then we have the open kettle method people are using visual measures in order to sort of figure out what's happening and if they need to reboil something or there's one example of one of these recipes I showed you said okay well if you it's good if you can keep it on the shelf because then you can watch to see if it starts bubbling and when it starts bubbling and you should take it off and do something else right so people are really using sensory sensory information to evaluate what's happening and the problem with botulism is that it is not detectable in the ways that people have been trained to detect and manage spoilage right so it's and it's tasteless and and so that presents all sorts of difficulties when I found interesting is that rather than being presented as sort of ignorant or unaware of what was going on when you look at the transcripts of people who've been canning for lifetimes they'll often express that they are very very aware of the kinds of things that are recommended right and they talk about the ways that their own families have kind of mediated or managed those kinds of things so she's given here specific information about how long she's processing it and things like that I wanted to just close today by talking about some of our own sort of contexts that are changing right so the botulism is interesting and that context always matters it matters sort of what your altitude is it matters how much fat is in your process it matters what kinds of sort of temperature or humidity that you're working with and so and all of these things can sort of combine or intertwine even now contexts are changing in these so there is a brush tech made automatic comb cane system that has been initially initiated right it capitalizes on the social value of sharing homemade food and pitches itself as a solution for busy households perhaps for for 40 moms in any case they say it's as easy as 1 2 3 literally you pick up one of 28 Jam jiggle-jelly pickled tomato sauce or salsa recipes prepare six half pint or three quart jars load the jars push the button that corresponds to your recipe and walk away as the online description declares this machine and it's 70 built-in safety features take quote the guesswork out of canning and there's a whole there's a whole sort of literature I could talk to you about and the ways that women's knowledge has been sort of it has literally been described as guesswork right on this kind of experimentation and sensory investment in what's going on trial and error accounts we dismissed as guesswork and with this latest this latest invention of ball there are cameras that are pushing back against the latest tool to remove guesswork write comments on the website make it clear that most reviewers dislike the confines of this automated system wanting the freedom to experiment with recipes to can all types of foods and to further develop their own skills and someone pointed out of the canner works in the logic of fear suggesting they'll finally deal with a can of safe product by playing on the risk of danger and the allure of dependency that have characterized much discourse on domestic technology in the last century ball can sell a product that is essentially an electric water bath but not everyone's buying context keep changing and so will candy just not long ago ball revealed that because it's changed the composition of its sealing compound oh and lids is no longer necessary and it's in fact detrimental which caused a big outcry because it's the one thing that's changed in the last 70 years in terms caning right so people got concerned and so what I hope that sir will leave thinking about today is a story about how modernity was a spacial mobility rapid changes to work processes and technological systems and emphasis and receive knowledge can undercut knowledge based in place personal experience and sensory perception the woman in the materials I've encountered are not by a large sloppy careless or unintelligent instead they are working with a complicated set of variables that feel the rippln that feel the ripples of seemingly small or unconnected actions like the matsutake ecosystem it's also the story of how any invention is really a network of skills and gestures but by consolidating things in the sort of the figure of a pair a copy person with a particular method right we can identify a point of before and after time moves forward then as brindled horses marked by progress in reality life is a messy overlap of technologies material environmental contexts each of us work within these systems but because Canning ism systems so enmeshed in the physical world because in fact death is on the line these interconnections become a bit more visible perhaps it can help us think more clearly about the roles our everyday material worlds play in acquiring articulating validating endorsing and affirming expert status thank you [Applause] Industrial right right well part of it I mean it's linked to it's linked to the rise of so when through the laboratory and Sciences valorized as a sign of authentic knowledge and I could show you pictures of these sort of men sitting around on the jamb boards right and they're like evaluating the dam then domestic science you starts sort of moving from spaces that seem less so a laboratory is a space and what you're able to isolate a particular variable right it's this sort of blank slate in a sense and that things start to make sense because you're only looking at one particular thing in your bracketing everything else out right and so even in terms of sort of uniforms that people start wearing and how it in domestic science classes the ways that domestics labs are sort of set up as these sterile environments right in some ways we try to adopt this the power of scientific discourse for themselves so it happens through schools it happens through club work where kids are being taught you know it was a scientific method I think there's a picture I have so this is a jam board right of the USDA chemistry guys these are women who are using a sort of doing community candy with a large steam cooker right or what boiling water bath alongside the creek and here's another example of a sort of a canning class a demonstration that's taking place outside in a playground those are very different from the laboratory but you also have these more rationalized spaces these community caning spaces and here is a good example of a caning club girl who is part of a tomato caning club in which the girls in the 19-teens would do these experiments right so she is doing she is back train rocketing out that one variable of what kind of fertilizer are you using and they were they would write reports they earn their own money they're proud of being involved in the scientific process so this is another mechanism in which that kind of happens and then on the flip side you've got popular magazines and things that are downplaying grandma's knowledge as there's a really great let's see there's lots of displays of people with pressure cookers or pressure canner is to show that they know the right safe way to do it right here's that here's some instructions but then you've got like these images of Grandma in which anybody like the processes are so simple that anybody can operate it and there's actually this is an interesting source that I I found I started out I got to it from Princeton photographs but she basically says you know it's amazing how people can't read a couple of granulated sugar means a cup of anything sweet shows she's she's saying that longtime practices of substitution and flexibility right are no good and a good recipe is important to those wonderful old recipes handed down from Grandma worked for your mother but only because she'd used an experimented with them many times they were probably frequent failures blamed on the bad weather other insignificant factors it's much better to rely on modern guides most of them have been tested more times than you could count so the logic here is really screwy because it says like your grandma's recipes worked because they've been tried a lot of times but you should really try these other recipes that have been tried a lot of times by different people right like the scientists versus your gram on the scientist wind so the other questions yeah notes extensity beginning therefore much happening that was one thing I'm an industrial scale Oh the commercial Kanner's trace themselves back to up hair and to Peter Durand in in England who basically one scholar argues that Duran took a Paris patent and just wrote it in English and also added other stuff just for good measure and sent it in and then it was actually bought by another company who actually like started canning in tin using that patent so commercial canning yes so in the United States by there's some by at least 1825 there were commercial tanneries that are operating the United States from the other early I would be interested to know I haven't looked at any these are the the earliest manuscripts that may just get books that I've found in in rare books but I would love to know I'm sure he goes back much farther right yeah the manuscript is due in March of this next year so probably will be a year and a half or so it would have been better than my singing I'm sure i I think really that flexibility variation is a big one especially when it comes to things like canning because because one thing that a pear did do that was innovative is that and and also a bit hubris in my own mind is that he decided that I mean he figured out how to can every single thing that you could ever think of doing right he figured out how much time you would need to and so you know for some vegetables and meats that's like four or five hours of boiling before you could get a high before he had pressure tanners that you could raise the temperature to 240 or 250 degrees and so a pair he decides that he wants to can every single thing whereas in most people's practice right they have these this multiplicity of techniques that meets their goals and their needs for like the performance of the product right so frozen corn tastes better and lasts better than canned corn right or or dried apples or better for fried pies because they don't have this much moisture they don't get soggy right so people and like women in real life are sort of choosing all of these things but a parrot has rationalized the process so much that it's like this this idea of the plantation alienation in some ways right he just like says we're gonna we're gonna apply this to the we're gonna scale it up to every single thing regardless of how good it tastes or whatever right and could you remind me of the initial question because I think I've gotten off a little bit all right okay so multiplicity flexibility also there's interesting so part of that flexibility is flexibility and the kinds of technology that you're using and so there's in 1935 the same sort of grumpy bacteriologist who is mad about other things that women are doing says you know some people can in washtubs which is I can't imagine how you get a sanitary project from washtub except that it's all like boiling I I mean and so this idea of where as a lot of sort of caning literature from earlier in the century is encouraging like you can do this everybody can do this is accessible to you all you need is some sort of pan something to put in the bottom of it to keep your your bottles off the middle right and you're ready to go and so I think just the open endedness of it all right is it doesn't fit within that paradigm of control thanks the wonder if you could kind of help graph that up for me or explain any tension between a domestic and whether they kind of fall a little long the same kind of grass because why I'm Fanning I think of the opposite of mmm-hmm I think that's probably why it so popular now because its production yeah wait and I wonder if you can kind of help me graph those things together or whether that you need me how how its commercial canning and home canning and dialogue with each other yeah or whether there is whether that same kind of tension between you know rationalized processes domestic processes also commercial processes you mean we're sort of domestic processes less rationalized relatively speaking then yeah I mean they definitely happened on smaller scales although there were some people who were doing lots of quantity canning the one of the the reasons that people thought a pair was so revolutionary actually is that he devised a plan for scaling up like this is an I this is how I did it and this is how we can build a bigger apparatus and do it so that we can sell it right um so that's one of the things that happened I would say that domestic sciences and also through the threat of botulism has sort of taken a lot of the flexibility out of home canning procedures now right because because when people move to different areas of the country they're using maybe foodstuffs that are not as you know tomatoes that aren't as acidic as they used to me or there are lots of sort of variables that happen now that require this sort of blanket everyone do the same thing so that everybody was covered and we're not gonna have any leeway because there's so many variables now that have changed that people can't necessarily rely on traditional methods anymore so I don't know if I answered your question but I think one more question I'm focusing on the United States on context yeah but I would be curious to know I know that Eastern Europe has traditionally had a lot of pickling and I would be interested to know if there's a strong non-sugar non salt non vinegar based practice as well that we've gotten to social you know social factors which everything back rather than we are related because you know covers the season for the time just coming from the culture that I do the Lord of yeah I think you know a lot of people don't know that the things that people process at home most of the time nowadays jams jellies pickles does a bachelor's but it's not really an issue because you've got those added preservatives already built in right um but definitely in the sort of 80's and 90's the candy the candy industry people were really like aware of all these other sort of social factors that were also affecting people's practice and yet I think it's easy for people just say oh I'm afraid of doing that because I don't want to do it wrong right it's an easy out for not having to sort of be involved in the practice especially if other people think you should be doing it right yeah I want to thank you so much I wanna thank Danielle because Daniel Christensen for coming and for you all for coming and for a great talk thank you this has been a presentation of the Library of Congress visit us at loc.gov | Humanoid History | UCDidQxwQteZmWObcV90Ea_w | 2020-09-30 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 9,729 | 55,142 |
Un82g6u_LkY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Un82g6u_LkY | 3 Recent Facebook Changes You Need to Know About | three recent facebook changes you need to know about the first one is that facebook now let's marketers newsfeed bomb other pages now this is news this past Tuesday so this past Tuesday facebook said hey guess what you can now tag other pages like you always have but when you do that sometimes your post will actually appear in the news feed of the facebook fans of that page you tag a page in an update you've always been able to do that alright so in order to tag a page it's a good idea to go to that page and like that page as a page that will ensure that their name will actually appear when you type in at you know the at sign type in their name and then you say something really nice about them and then you post that update so that's always been the case what's new now is that some of the fans of that page will start to see those updates okay and I'm going to emphasize some because there are a few factors here that come into play they're going to make sure first of all that that post is getting a lot of good quality engagement and also the facebook fans of your page are engaged in similar topics you know if you're a breast cancer organization and you mention a local clinic that's doing a workshop about breast cancer it will be a high likelihood that the fans of that page will see that update as well posts that are getting the most engagement from people who like both pages so there's something here about well people like both pages a lot of people like both pages relevant topics that the page is share like I said before Breast Cancer Foundation Health Care Clinic they're both talking about add you know educating people about breast cancer okay and then the degree of overlap with the fan base so this is the first thing that's that's kind of huge I think of course marketers going to come along and some are going to spam and try and you know just at mention as many pages as they can in an update as a way to kind of gain the system but unfortunately the newsfeed will dominate everything and so those techniques won't really work in the long term okay number two you can now add a call to action to a link post so we all know like comment and share these are the call to actions that are that make facebook where facebook is now what facebook is saying is hey you can add other call to actions much more specific and relevant to what you're trying to achieve with the link that you posted so if you post a link to register for an event facebook says hey great you can tell people that they can sign up for that event you could use book now learn more shop now download download is going to be for an e-book course you know some resource ebook a checklist something that's going to be really useful that people can get and your posting of the link your posting the link of course to drive people to your website but also to convert people know they join an email list or they sign up or they book now or they learn more there's some action that they're going to take on your website facebook is allowing you to create these call to actions in link posts so the question you're asking is well how do you do this and the answer is I made a video and here's a link so there's a youtube video I created it's actually in one of my most recent blog posts you can read that there as well or you can do the video there as well but I'll include it in the slides and i'm going to send out the link to these slides on friday so everything's all in one nice little package here you have to use the power editor that's the thing you have to use the power editor that's why there's a video because some of you are saying well how do i use the power editor then this video doesn't show you how to use the entire power editor but it does show you how to use it to create a link post with a call to action in it okay so that's number 23 is you can now target recent website visitors with facebook ads okay so what does this mean this means that you can now display a Facebook ad to someone who was just on your website okay now what's really powerful about this is that this targets fans based on their recent behavior all right targets not just facebook fans but any Facebook user targets them on their recent behavior so the audience is highly relevant if someone's on your website and they're reading an article and then they go back to Facebook and they see some sort of you know post or update from the page about that same topic they're going to be more likely to take whatever action you're asking them to take okay because the audience is highly relevant based on their terms based on their decision this is what's unique about this it's not about targeting people based on their likes and interests which is most of what makes up facebook ads what people like what their interests are and so forth which is relatively a static thing when you think about it when you think about a person their likes and interests they don't really change from day to day but their behavior is really different depending upon what's going on in their life so this is really the first time we're you're targeting people based on their recent behavior what they've done recently which is visited your website you can even target people based on specific web pages they visited so you use the power editor and you simply click on create an audience create an audience click on create a custom audience now up until now you were limited in your options and the options used to be just email phone number Facebook ID ok so those were the options and I've actually talked about custom audiences before uploading an email list into Facebook and then targeting ads based targeting ads to those facebook users that have you know those emails and their profiles so this is different this is now doing a custom audience on your website so you click on create an audience you'll see this option custom audience or website you click on that and then you create an audience it's gives you a little bit of information about retargeting so retargeting if you've heard that term it basically means targeting ads in response to someone's internet behavior typically it's going to be them visiting a web page then they come back then they see the ad and we've prepped you've probably had this experience where you're on Facebook you look in your sidebar and you'll see wow I was just on that website that's really interesting i was just on that website looking shopping around and you're going to see that ad that is retargeting and that's what this does ok so you click on create an audience and then you fill in the rest you fill in the name description you put a link in here and follow the instructions more details at john lumic calm so that's it less than 15 minutes so the first question is from Charlotte will the power end or work on my iPad Mini know the power editor will not work on the ipad mini in fact you have to actually use Google Chrome which is a little ironic because these two companies are arch enemies google and facebook but for some reason you have to use google chrome and the reason why Charlotte is because maybe not for the web retargeting piece but if you're going to upload emails you have to use google chrome because what happens from a technical standpoint is that the google chrome browser will hash up the data or mix up the data somehow and then when you upload it it it has a certain amount of anonymity the data isn't really usable unless its associated with a facebook user so facebook has no ability to see or even use any extra emails that are in that list and that's why you have to use chrome because it has that piece to it where it's it's hashing the data so you have to use google chrome just to review the three big changes again and the first one the strategy here is developing partnerships that's what this really speaks to developing partnerships with peer organizations sponsors for profits that support your cause that's what number one speaks to okay number two speaks to converting people being really smart testing out different language and converting people with a very explicit ask okay you know call to actions are much more in your face so this is really about converting people and then the last piece here is really what do we want our website visitors to do once they leave our website oh well we we have this other campaign this is what we can do we can target these people and recency which is really what this is about is about recent behavior recency influences whether someone will take action right if someone goes to an event at your you know that you have and then they go home they go to bed they get an email the next morning they're way more likely to open that email that morning then they would if they didn't go to an event and they haven't heard from you in months so recency is a real critical part of this so with that I will say thank you and have a great day stay warm if you are freezing like I am up in the Northeast and we will talk very very soon I | John Haydon | UC1-XLZMTVxjFHD_pfkPtmwQ | 2014-02-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,712 | 9,020 |
6LxiPBbBCeY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LxiPBbBCeY | Slendrina The Cellar, Eyes The Horror Game, Granny 1,2,3, Labirin Kuyang, The Fear 3 | foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] laughs [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] bye [Applause] foreign [Applause] [Music] [Applause] thank you [Applause] [Music] [Applause] foreign [Music] [Laughter] [Music] [Applause] awesome [Applause] [Laughter] [Applause] foreign [Music] there you are [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] I see you [Music] foreign [Applause] [Music] [Applause] foreign [Applause] all right [Applause] [Music] [Applause] hey yeah [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] thank you [Applause] thank you [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Applause] all right [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] foreign [Music] [Applause] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] thank you [Laughter] thank you [Music] [Applause] foreign [Applause] [Music] foreign [Applause] [Music] granny [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] thank you foreign [Applause] | Horror Gameplay | UCwV-2zV0843TeNAEs2FI0lw | 2023-04-30 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 147 | 1,237 |
1mBjFTiXiww | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1mBjFTiXiww | Irrigation of the Ear | [Music] this video will show you the procedure for irrigation of the ear wash your hands identify the patient introduce yourself and put on your gloves view the affected ear with an otoscope to see where cerumen or the foreign object is located so that the flow of solution can be directed properly [Music] ask the patient to turn his or her head to the affected side and toward the back place a water absorbent pad or towel over the patient's shoulder to protect his or her clothing position the ear basin under the ear for the patient to hold to catch the solution use a gauze square to wipe away any particles from the outer ear before proceeding fill a water bottle or an ear system with body temperature water or other solution ordered by the provider twist on the disposable tip other options may include water put in a basin and using a syringe use two hands to direct the flow of the solution with one hand place the tip end into the ear canal with the other use the trigger handle to spray solution into the ear canal use gauze squares to wipe the excess solution from the outside of the patient's ear always check in on your patient and make sure they are feeling well inspect the ear canal with an otoscope to determine whether the desired results have been obtained repeat irrigation if needed give the patient several gauze squares or tissues and have the patient tilt his or her head to the side to allow drainage of excess solution from the canal dispose of material remove gloves and wash hands provide patient education and document the procedure in the patient's chart | Lauren Ramirez | UCehtRYCdpKGrBOHbos30hzw | 2020-12-02 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 287 | 1,586 |
giIwyF74aIM | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=giIwyF74aIM | EFAP #239 - The Cinema Wars - Wins VS. Sins on Doctor Strange in The Multiverse of Madness! | don't even see a lot of clips of them so I'm I don't know maybe it's just not entertaining or anything I can't imagine it's entertaining the holiday special they want to destroy all the clips of them speaking it was a miracle America very glad it happened and had it not happened we would have been a lesser Society slash culture for it that's what I think absolutely 100 don't think I can be proved wrong on that either pretty much in the Stone ah stream is Live Chat is is this people there before it's working so hello everyone welcome to your allotted efap episode of this yes you are are you ready to turn in your one-quarter portion Redemption ticket for your weekly efappery wow I know I am that was Simon Pegg that's that's his contribution to Star Wars that guy yeah do you remember well remember Stephen Fry was in The Hobbit he was that was um that was a roll too that was a roll he got paid he did um well um I feel like it should be acknowledged immediately but uh as um elephant the Golem could be um uh me and Matt will actually the Chads beat it yesterday completely won the race that was totally happening between the three of us won the race and the argument um at least I think he's finished it I haven't been able to check because I've been setting up the old fabins but um last I saw him he was looking at the cutscenes at the end I don't know if he chose to break the bird's neck he let it let him let him live really this is the debate of our age yes um has finished it there you go yeah I just finished it good for him I'm glad he's gone past it it's uh it was a tough one it was it was a it was it was a legendary thing that was made for those who don't know you can see myself metal or as player on our assorted areas of the internet it is a glitch-filled dis diet it's a mess it's horrible it's one of the worst things ever could have been better yeah yeah a little bit it's like it follows full potential has not yet been realized it's it's quite a quite amazing it got made it all and apparently they're making more they got yeah metal paid them to make more so yeah sorry about that they already got two million in Germany's tax money to make more a lot of the Rings content can they have gotten the 2 million to fix the current game no that seems like it would make more sense than making a whole [ __ ] new game but Germany doesn't worry about old mistakes they just know carry on and they just try to move on to me yeah this this is what Oh wrong [ __ ] evolving but just backwards yeah I've seen this one it's the kind of [ __ ] that uh is so embarrassing that you kind of wonder how did this even happen um no it looks like you play Meme and then I saw Golems like oh that actually looks like Gollum he looks so goofy in that picture that's that's how he looks at the whole game the little guy a little Gooba I don't know what they're going for I was actually expecting the character models to change at some point it's like oh this is like a younger version because he's been doing stuff earlier and then he is in Mordor for years apparently and then he gets to his even grosser face but no that's just I give them too much credit I thought it just said the only like that doesn't work in in [ __ ] the description is Metals why every [ __ ] time wait again I didn't even look it changes it right so when I put it into the description it says at Metals I think at Metals Forge right that's that's the yeah the hyperlink you put it in you go live and then it changes it to the gobbled [ __ ] and it's like why I don't know I don't know I had to that was a problem I think I was having with my description yesterday like it would it would it have the drop down menu when you put in the channel and you'd click on it yeah then you'd expect it to work and then when you post it it just turns into it yeah it would probably be something you can click on yeah because the actual links are at whatever you put there but if you do it via this click thingy as you just said it just breaks every time I don't know why which is weird you know because it looks like it's supposed to work like oh it's like at r-a-g oh click and then it's like see Look it's even a little gray box and yeah but in reality no you fool yeah I've updated it and hopefully it [ __ ] stays that way but who knows if it's normal now it already updated itself actually crazy god wow we've got a big helping of flames today but before I introduce what we're up to I figure we should uh we should take the opportunity because I don't know when else we'll fit this in to talk about the fact that me bringing and Rags after several recommendations actually got together and watched a television show from start to finish good no no it's kind of insane TV show it's not recommended take the recommendation we we watched it all the way to the end it's been in Super Chat several times I saw a couple of Clips I really like Brian Cox as an actress I was like [ __ ] it I'll bite the bullet and I watched an episode no I think two one or two of uh of succession and then I was like this is so good but I'm gonna drag rags and free into it obviously the idea was show them and then see if they want to join and I think you guys were pretty thoroughly impressed by the opening episodes as well right we were like holy [ __ ] the potential the acting the writing yeah for those who don't know the premise the premises that of basically a big old is allegorical to like uh would you say fox is supposed to be uh yeah the mood yeah so like a and it's a family-run giant corporation that runs theme parks cruises news uh Outlets media all kinds of stuff and that we're seeing the sort of leader the big old dad the patriarch of this whole family is coming to the end of his Reign and what's gonna happen next when he's got four children and many people working in high positions and you know the the complications that come with it it sounds like it would be maybe boring to some out there who like it's just a show about people making deals dude there's no lasers no spaceships a single laser not a single spaceship there are cars is there a single laser is there a gun fired in the show I remember one gunfire there's one at least it's the yeah it's in the distance you don't see it outside gunshot yeah um there's like oh there's a car crash there is a car crash that's the most exciting thing that happened in like an action sceny kind of way yeah so maybe you won't be uh interested in that vein but we were so thoroughly impressed with the characterization that we were following this family and whether or not uh certain people will rise or fall in power levels or positions though we were just oh just just in it just watching it oh lovely getting nice and addicted I'd say the peak of investment possibly for even even say the three of us was uh post season two we were like this is two solid seasons of just building up everything and you can see where all the things are going to come in and possibly crash down in a very potent dramatic sense um then we watch season three I'm trying to remain positive here because it is you should you should be positive I think for the first two seasons were Stellar top tier incredible the third season was it was okay all slow paced I don't feel like we were really making much progress but you know everyone was you know behaving in character and things seemed to be doing all right you were like okay it was a kill into this I think things should happen more things should happen but you know this is really good still you know it's good stuff there's a couple instances of oh you you could have gone this way but you went that way and that though they both with viable ways I just I think I would have prefer to go the other way but that's all right the way I said it on Gary's stream was uh felt like season three was the spinning the Wheels season they wanted to keep everybody sort of in limbo they weren't sure exactly how they were going to end story lines and so we sort of ended up repeating pushing characters into places and then pulling them back and then pushing them out again uh I think that that folk that contrast between the way that the seasons were progressing felt really sharp because like by the end of season two it felt like we'd progressed quite significantly with a lot of characters yeah like that they had changed pretty dramatically from where they were or at the very least were like on the path to to pretty uh significant change like lots of conflicts bubbling to the surface um development regression for people like yeah it was it was like really moving along in those first two seasons then season three was like hmm yeah we're not I don't know I feel like we didn't achieve nearly as much as in those last two seasons didn't feel quite as dense there were plenty of strong scenes uh in season three that progressed some stuff and the final scene of season three was like oh I'm trying to avoid spoilers in a sense I guess um because well we'll get there so uh the the the part of the bigger reason why I was checking out the show too is one thing I didn't mention was the hype for season four everyone kept talking about this season was coming out and I was just like well I haven't seen any of it so but I said to rags and freaking ain't it neat how good season one and two were and that four is the one that the fans go in nuts over so that's very true because that's exciting season one and two then surely season four must be something incredible beyond belief if if you know if you watch the first two seasons and you were really excited about the fourth makes you wonder what hooked what was the hook of the show you know that got them in um and so I think we maybe we should switch over to spoiler mode now because uh so for those who are currently watching succession or wish to watch it you're gonna have to mute or leave and uh I will signal to you that we're done with the spoiler talk by um uh I'll open up watch together and the screen will go down that'll be the signal that'll that'll let you know so just just mute we'll be right back I don't know how long we'll be but we'll go right now so season four starts up and uh we we we watched because it's it's episode four is the big one that everyone was talking about and oh sorry and luckily for uh all three of us we had no idea why people were talking about it we had no idea why it was was famed why it was getting like 9.9 to 10 out of tens everywhere I was like holy [ __ ] I can't wait for that I love me some you know excellent TV episodes so we uh you know first two everything is running kind of like season three it's mostly fine and then episode three comes around and the reason why that one is so famous is because it's when Logan Roy the main man in charge the one who got the the brain bleed in episode one that set all of this off in a sense he finally dies yeah if it comes to an aneurysm was it or um I forget I think it was a pulmonary embolism so uh and you know when we understood that that was what was happening you know we ran some theories like oh maybe it's a a lie and he's trying to see what his kids would do as a result of it or maybe it's um misunderstood or maybe he's actually dead and turns out he is actually dead the episode is him dying and then you see the kids sort of react to it and things start moving forward um and you know we're not going to be doing like a season breakdown or even necessarily scene breakdowns of any particular favorites but the rest of the season rolls out and the finale came out I want to say a week ago two weeks ago something like that you get your endings for everybody the show is over series end um this is it it's all done the story has concluded I will say our little Discord call that was connected up while we were watching it by the end we hit credits so I would say the word might be miserable yes Furious yeah yeah really really curious just closer Furious was closer than miserable uh I I don't think I've ever been angrier at a TV show I think that the fourth season is trash uh I think there's virtually nothing of value maybe like literally a couple exchanges that ultimately don't really end up meaning anything but uh boy I am shocked that people think that this is not only not terrible but it's really good I have no clue why they think that and it makes me question how did you fall in love with this show in the first place if you praise the fourth season which is like the antithesis of the first two seasons uh the thing uh first thing that struck me come to realize is one of the biggest flaws that they had as a writing team seemed to be that they just didn't know how to make characters grow they didn't want them to they had an archetype and then they just relied on it characters would go through circumstances and then just repeat them again and again and again seemingly not understanding anything about history not understanding anything they don't learn anything they get backstabbed by the individual characters get backstabbed by the same people throughout the show like five times in a row and every time they'll just be like well let's go again you know whatever and then it's like almost like five minutes later we're just back to normal whatever it's fine it [ __ ] sucks when they do significant damage in the form of career monetary or just uh betrayals of like trust and stuff and then like you know Following episode it's kind of forgotten about and they move on really annoying when you compare it to like season one where Kendall takes a shot and fails and it's like a dramatic consequence for him he's out like you'd lose like he's he's just out he's done excommunicado and he even changes his attitudes quite significantly when he's with the family next though he's on drugs to be fair uh but he's he's so much more Curt with everybody less business-like you know several episodes of building back up ramping back up to his next big move as opposed to just like yeah I mean you did something but you know it's okay yeah it's fine you know it's cool like we'll give you another shot 30 characters just basically get to whenever they [ __ ] up in in astronomical ways be it to characters or potential damage to the company it really does like oh it's fine this is the next next episode thing I was forgiven I was fine there's no issues no problems whatever no consequences for you um there's you know we can tackle a couple different things but one of them is um they just had plot threads that didn't go anywhere or were forgotten about throughout the whole show totally totally dropped like in season four dealing with kendo's addiction problem like that wasn't that wasn't like an element of that season at all season one was the main one to build that up and then it kind of just didn't get deal like it was pushed in certain directions drinking cocaine all these different stuff always kind of referencing it never went anywhere yeah it didn't go anywhere it's the the last they they just sort of he just isn't an addict anymore I guess because it's never a part of the show it stops being an issue people use it again the density of people using against him goes further back I think they just decided to Peter it out and not do anything with it um Masha takes up a significant portion of the whole show and we discover it all amounts to her basically saying I really loved Logan it's like yeah I don't think uh I don't think the show yeah it seems like they changed directory a trajectory on a lot of things because last we saw her before that essentially got wrapped up that way was that uh she was basically negotiating for a [ __ ] ton of money and power in order to be used as a like Logan's in a healthy and happy marriage like this that's one of my that I actually really liked that's probably one of my favorite uh Masha scenes is where her and her lawyer are talking to how I think Logan's lawyer and there's like um we need him to look like he's strong he's married he's happy and then she's like that's great uh but he broke my heart and so if I'm coming back like I'm gonna need and then she like has a list of Demands we never even saw if those demands got satisfied we assume now I don't know they made it sound like it was a desperate thing though to have her back in the scene you know and viewed um but uh yeah she sort of drops in with every girl that you remember what was the name of the girl that he was like with but not with but kind of with was it Kelly or Carrie Carrie right yeah yeah I think so something like that yeah that was strange too that didn't seem to really it felt it felt like a show wasn't sure what to do with that um then yeah as you mentioned Gil there was this whole political angle yeah with the candidate that we learned about since season one and he like dropped this is really great stuff that's season three right the the court stuff the trial uh yes really like that that was awesome it was all to do with the cruises which is actually relevant in a sec with something else but uh Gill has like made himself clear as this character who's running um I think for President right uh yes ultimately um we haven't even reached the primaries yet he's just sorting out his campaign he's running with it and he has uh Logan Roy's daughter working for him he's like what an interesting dynamic because he hates Logan Roy and wants to sabotage him stop him and you know regulate him as much as possible he considers him a cancer on America sort of thing like oh yeah okay that's a great Dynamic where the [ __ ] did Gil go no the last time we saw him was at the Congressional hearing and that was it as far as we had the whole election and we didn't even see his side or whether or not candidate different candidate was actually like up for presidency I think he was meant to be like VP and it's just like why would I don't know why like what I don't understand why we dropped that thread like it just seems like there's a lot of potential there um dare I even say Connor is a [ __ ] dropped thread yeah I don't know what I don't know what the point of all that was there was four seasons of a worthless pointless character around and it never amounted to anything Connor never amounted to anything in the show and they had it in his relationship with Willa too it just was like Hey okay they had it all right there they set up is it the end of season one there's an implication you might run for president it's like oh what a great way to make use of him go go go go go go and they barely do a thing by the time like the last payoff of him trying to run for president is I have one percent of Voters going for me and this is the election night maybe if I drop out and endorse someone else which doesn't happen the night of like when the actual like final results are coming in uh I could buy for some level of power or position and then he's offered ambassador of uh I don't remember what country it was dude Somalia subtly [ __ ] bizarre and then he just sort of drifts away towards a few End episodes and the biggest payoff I think we ever get is him just being like you guys don't care about me it's like they don't nobody does show doesn't it's really like it just he's in that basket of all the threads and plot ideas that just got actually forgotten or they just didn't amount to anything and so much of what made the first couple Seasons so incredible is this idea that they were presenting of you have all of these things that are going on in this world and there's going to be a payoff or all these things are going to come to a head there's going to be a resolution to all of these little these things we're setting up there's going to be payoffs to all this stuff and looking back it's actually kind of nuts how many things just literally went nowhere my favorite disappear as plot threads favorite Corner thing in the entire series is the speech he gave at the funeral uh and you might like the the funeral with the what's his name uh MO you know oh yeah that [ __ ] was [ __ ] hilarious and uh it was very funny it was really great for a representative of being representative of his character it's just Such a Pity it just went nowhere um but hey we're building toward the uh the bigger and bigger problems here so I mentioned cruises and uh what I liked about that was uh for those who don't know or those who do know but need to be reminded cruises was this horrible skeleton in uh way star royco's closet basically it was a collection it represented a collection of all of the horrors that had happened on their cruise line that have been you know given hush money or um people have died and they've sort of brushed under the carpet in whatever possible ways they can they have a stack of all the history of things that they've done wrong with it and um there's a guy his name Bob or Steve or something he was the head of IT controlling it and he passes it on to our uh our one of our characters Tom in season one really early on and uh it's basically a time bomb it's just uh hopefully no one discovers it and hopefully you can deal with it sit on it and eventually you'll retire happy you know and as The Show Goes On more people poke at it and it gets uh brought up to be used as leverage um it's something that permeates throughout the show and has loads of different consequences and the plot lines develop from it really good that is wrapped up like uh in in several ways and then there's little leaks like characters taking extra pieces of information holding on to it or um people being aware of it but making a deal and it'll come back that sort of thing um season four everything like it feels like different people wrote it because a lot of the dramas and ways the characters get leverage and stuff just happens at a thin [ __ ] Air instead of cruises being planted really early on and characters making decisions about it that match them that have ultimate repercussions we have things like um the kids have to make a decision whether or not they want to sync their dad's reputation in order to boost their own when he's dead and they decide against it uh two of the kids out of three and then candles like well it's really important we need to do it how can I get it done and um Hugo just comes up to him and says hey um my I told my daughter that Logan had died before it became public news and she sold his stock obviously before it plummeted so that's bad and then Kendall's just like huh yeah that is bad um I'm gonna use that now as leverage against you if so that you help me sabotage my dad's uh reputation without letting the other kids know Hugo just hands him leverage on a thread that was invented that episode really [ __ ] annoying so she's like oh that's just that just came out of nowhere really [ __ ] thin is what that is why that was working in the earlier Seasons yeah characters just decide to say things against their better judgment or without any like reasons or against their own interests things sort of happened because of it yeah everyone kind of turns super stupid in that uh in that aspect yeah we started to notice one of more and more of them as they went along obviously because of doing this as fast as I can for people who don't care about succession okay we try to get through because we're almost to the the big one right but uh you have that you have um the the whole of season four is dealing with a deal with Gojo um who's that's organized by Lucas Matson is that that's the name right um who's played by one of Stellan skarsgard's son and he's great unfortunately though they need to create drama with him and so like he's pretty solid right up until he's a bit of a you could call a Maverick for business he does things differently but he's also super successful that's kind of how he's introduced and then randomly you have um shivroy who's one of the primary people who's involved with like the company's merger slash uh being bought out by each other he like takes her into a room and just tells her that he's been freezing bricks of his blood and sending it to his like Communications officer which has started to get him in trouble and we were just like what what he just randomly tells her this stuff that she can use for no reason because he just does I guess and and he was just like oh I guess we just we're just making him insane like what why who's blood bricks and why is he telling her and what what and then it was like uh the next episode they have like a private meeting about how they've got a connection and that those two are going to work together her brothers and we were literally just like he's gonna stab they pulled this out of their ass in the family these two don't have a connection why did he tell her about the blood breaks why were the blood Pricks a thing and uh that ends up being right that that is the Inception so to speak of the ultimate payoff in this show like that's where um uh shiv's deceits like sort of begin for no reason at all um the three of them agree that they're going to work together with all decisions going forward after their dad dies and then like you know they split off immediately and like I said she talks to him who has no reason to give her any information at all and he just starts telling her about this incredible [ __ ] controversy that's under because if that became public right if anyone knew that like Bill Gates sent a bunch of blood breaks to one of his people he was interested in I feel like that that would never be forgotten but um that's that's felt like the writing was starting to really fall apart now um since I've been talking a lot I I don't mind if either of you want to take a bit should we talk about living Plus um let's just start talking about random uh yeah let's just start talking about living where did that come from it was invent living plus was just invented in the episode that it became an insanely important point that made Kendall episodes as well like it just it didn't [ __ ] matter anymore do um you know an episode opens and it's Logan Roy after he's died delivering his presentation related to living plus and I was like the [ __ ] is living Plus never heard of this it's incredibly important and it's going to matter significantly in loads of different ways and uh the kids have to figure out what they're gonna do with it drop it or uh try and boost it up as best they can you're so funny was it the whole episode or was it two episodes that we were demanding the show tell us what the [ __ ] living plus is just one episode I think it was he was gaslighting us into thinking we just like skipped an episode or missed one so it was it was insane at the beginning of the episode with like a recording of Logan it was apparently a project he'd been working on and then it was like that episode was all focused on that as like a project that Kendall could create to essentially like inflate in the eyes of the world like the value of way Star royco as like an entity that could continue as its own thing because he wanted to destroy the merger and essentially attack yeah Lucas had offered them a price to buy the stock a very good one and uh Kendall comes up with this radical plan that if he can sell Living plus then he can Skyrocket the stock price and we were all just in there like good luck whatever living plus is good luck getting it above the price he's just offered you that's not gonna happen and then we found out what living plus was it was like some corporate hellscape like like a town run by a corporation that you live in where like everything like all of the entertainment within the town is like supplied by the company at apparently like when he pitched this it was like popular and successful it was so funny look yeah literally Disneyland suburbs basically but for waystar royco um it was so funny because we've heard about this IRL and every time it's mentioned everyone thinks it's a [ __ ] horrible idea that's just gross like a just dystopic like like why the [ __ ] would anyone ever want to do that you live in like Disney houses with Disney bucks and you watch the Disney Channel constantly and Disney news and Disney newspaper and you go to your Disney toilet and you can have your Disney cereal it's all like it's just no no that's never the way and they pitched that and the whole world is like whoa that's amazing and then all of like the internet are like oh it's so [ __ ] good that Lucas matz is so annoyed he tweets out something incredibly offensive about the Holocaust this [ __ ] happening because he doesn't want the the price to go up so you have to pay more blah blah he doesn't believe in living plus so he just does that we were just like what like what is happening I can't even get over the fact that living plus would be popular and that the stock would go up but then he just does that and the only reason we've got is like yeah well he's [ __ ] nuts he makes blood bricks like okay fine sure man and yeah that that pushes the kids back you know further up in in terms of Leverage um which which we thought was terrible but now should we talk about the election um sure I we could talk about the election uh the fact is that two is it's down to like a couple of votes with these these two candidates one that we like you so to speak with race star royco like our characters want them to win and one that they don't and the one that they uh do want to win they discover they can sort of help because is it 200 000 votes get burned yeah like in Wisconsin yeah a building gets like exploded or bent down and we lose that many votes and then um based on projections it was understood that those votes would most likely was it go to a particular candidate but uh sorry that's shiv's logic as to why they should announce for the candidate a and then Romans logic is that they don't count now they're out so we we assume nothing they they're not counted like we vote for the Canada B right that was that was like the the the the argument pretty much and we were sitting there losing our [ __ ] minds being like you've the votes have been bid this will be like the most controversial [ __ ] ever you can't just announce that they don't matter now or that you you assume what the votes would have been this doesn't make any [ __ ] sense at all and then by the end of the episode ATN actually made the decision to Simply announce who they believe is the winner well and remember the the reason why they make that decision and why Kendall makes the decision is because shiv is like oh yeah I talked to the other candidate they might be open to regulatory matches to block the deal because that's essentially the motivation behind the decision as they believe candidate B will block the deal they believe candidate A1 she was like oh no I talk saw me well and then can't feel colds and then finds out oh no she didn't like she didn't even answer like she pretends to get on the phone to talk to them instead of actually getting on the phone and maybe asking for a favor you know like she just doesn't do anything smart at all and that's the reason why he makes that decision of the entire show she does stupid risky backstabbing [ __ ] all the time and it like she never gets her comeuppance for it no and and people say didn't that happen in real life 200 000 votes getting burned in a building uh no I didn't no there's nothing in real life that is connected to that and then you can't the show was aware of this by the way it is trying to acknowledge that this is an insane all the characters say you can't do it you can't do it it's literal it's just illegal it doesn't work it doesn't [ __ ] and then they're just like nah do it anyway and then the next episode they have like a news report about who might be uh having to go to court who might have to be dealt with and then we just never deal with it again it's just passed it's like oh okay um don't worry about it so yeah and and the thing I really want to highlight there isn't whether or not I believe that like uh because someone could argue the legal [ __ ] happened after the show was over or something ultimately it was really delayed it's that none of the characters are this stupid it was really sad to see like Kendall Roman all of them being incredibly [ __ ] stupid yeah we're constantly asking like what are you doing who the [ __ ] are you what's happening what what about all the stuff that led us here have we learned nothing have we totally regressed into some just some idiot some loser some some insanely risky person for no reason like what's going on and that was the third season that's wondering what the [ __ ] happened to everyone um which I guess uh to wrap this up the final subject of the final episode before we go there and and what happens to all of our characters um the ultimate decision comes down to whether or not the board will vote for Gojo to uh buy out was it buyer or buy the stock for um basically total acquisition of the company yeah um which would mean like they wouldn't control it anymore as a family which is kind of you know since episode one been the huge deal of waystar Rocco must remain in the family we have to honor our dad and all the work he did you know it's our our company we gotta fight for this and by the time you hit the last episode the three kids have agreed to work together and that Kendall will be CEO um the other two with you know strong positions and that they have the votes they'll have the majority and everyone votes and we get a deadlock waiting for shiv's vote and uh she says she needs to think about it which we were pretty baffled by uh we had no idea what the angle was going to be this time we assume maybe that it was just she had some kind of deal with it with Matson or there's someone who's gonna pull out their ass it was good at the beginning she was really like arrogant about having one and all the while she had like neglected to account for the fact that like Madison at any point in time could make the call of like no you're not going to be CEO you have no experience yeah she don't know if she doesn't every single this is another thing that shiv never seems to learn in an entire show is that her lack of experience means that no one ever actually takes her seriously in anything and she gets shocked every single time someone says you have no experience he's like what um and yeah she was promised CEO and then she was immediately like lied to about that she assumed that she had been promised CEO he never said anything oh right yeah they do that wait wasn't that like the actual scene she says like uh can we talk about it and he says maybe later she's like no talk about it now and then he says yeah yeah we'll talk about it and then they don't talk about it and then yeah exactly yeah that was in the election episode it was just yeah we were being driven nuts by that too um in any case she explains to Kendall that uh uh well and remember that the big drama of this episode is she tells Tom that she found out that Madison was looking for another CEO who says that Greg told her yeah and then Tom announces that he's the person who's been chosen they have a big fight and then there's this dramatic music playing as they're all like ramping up to have this big battle it's like what what the f like all of this was set up by these two having a conversation that they and everyone used to be smarter with how much information they would leak but everyone's just leaking all over the place [ __ ] annoying um she basically explains um we finally get it out of her that she doesn't want to vote in favor of uh you know team royco because she doesn't want Kendall in charge because she doesn't like him and doesn't think he's good for the job that's basically what it comes down to one of the huge frustrations around a lot of the show is that like Kendall is the obvious choice throughout the seasons of the show he's made a lot of really good decisions he seems to legitimately care deeply for the company and keeping it going yeah everything is taken from him most of the time when he's actually running something it's perfectly fine there's a reason why he was first in place to get the company in the first place um and even um we never actually got that was kind of a regret on season one it would have been interesting to explore exactly what decision he should have made when Logan was in a coma we never really got to have that discussion either he just didn't like the the debt was solved by uh giving stock to Sandy right and um Stewie um so yeah she says that and you get kind of baffled by it because why there's one of two choices here even if you don't like Kendall why would you go with uh why would why would that be better doesn't really make much sense uh Until you realize that she just her relationship with Tom goes on a big old Loop and she gets her result but you have to watch a scene um it was it was kind of funny to watch because we knew that everything had to fall apart but there was nothing to use as a writer there's no there's no spark there to Make Them Fall Apart like how do you get Kendall and Roman to like everyone for to hate each other in that room um so she starts out being like confused and Kendall's a bit aggressive he's like you know what are you doing what are you doing until um different things just start coming out and everyone's getting anger and anger and saying [ __ ] that uh just felt completely out of character and just unsupported uh which is such a shame Kendall You could argue this is the biggest moment of his whole life and every single thing he says will have great consequence he recognizes that he always does in these sorts of situations you'll get nervous and he might even stutter but he usually comes through um funny enough a living plus would be an example of the fact that the show supports that like this defined by everyone else is this thing that will absolutely not work it's a huge stress and he does it anyway and pulls through he does the um the speech in the funeral the Roman couldn't do like there's a lot of times where uh it's clear that he's the one and the show seems to back him on that right up until the show reveals to you that there's a second motivation that's actually his primary it's really the thing that defines candle at least that's what the writers would want you to believe which is that he feels he deserves the role because he's the oldest boy and he shouts that at her and it was cringe as [ __ ] yeah I'm the oldest boy and when he does that she's like whoa um and they make uh Roman come out with something that I've seen people say like that didn't seem right at all and they don't take the next step into saying it's completely out of character I don't think because they don't be too much of a dick to the show Roman implies Kendall's kids for the first time in the entirety of the Four Seasons um out of nowhere uh his kids are illegitimate they're not like Roy's um and they're not even his yeah not real Roy's and then they're not even his which felt like weird as [ __ ] it comes out of nowhere this has never been brought up or mentioned before in the show this idea that Roman is like especially in Roman's own familial issues like we that's another drop thread that we're not even going or his girlfriend all that stuff has never that's done that's another drop thread but this just happens out of nowhere that whole convert I'm mad thinking about it yeah just thinking about it I [ __ ] hate this show also and and I [ __ ] hate this show it's like why would they do it and it's like well what do you think Kendall's gonna do when Roman tells him that they're not his kids and they're not Roy's he's gonna [ __ ] hurt him he's gonna do something he's gonna get mad anyone would if you do that about their [ __ ] you say that about their kids at A Moment Like This and so he arguably attacks him and then that makes everything spiral out everyone's screaming at each other throwing [ __ ] around and it's all over they're just kids fighting over the dad's Fortune done and you know that everyone's gonna have that commentary on the show it's like that's pretty genius or This Is What It ultimately came down to it's the dad's Legacy was just torn over and picked up for scraps by his kids who none of them deserved it when Kendall in that situation he wouldn't say I'm the eldest boy he would have said I have Infinite Experience compared to you guys Roman just doesn't have the spine for this he doesn't have the confidence he doesn't have the Killer Instinct dad said that was the one aspect that was like struggling on my part but I've shown in the past like few years that I can handle this [ __ ] on my own and I can push through any of these deals on my own I know exactly what to do shiv you know better than anybody you've got no chance of being CEO and what are you trying to suggest that Luke Madson would be better do you wanna you wanna team up with the Swede have him take over the dads dad's entire history his whole life his work instead of his children it's like the whole scene would have to go one way but they couldn't they want to have a different ending so they had to make the three of them do Insane nonsense to make them all fight so then shiv votes for Matson uh Kendall's whole [ __ ] life is ruined Roman just goes to a bar and has some drinks shiv just teams back up with Tom [ __ ] God Knows Why when she's done what she's done to him and then she so she gets to be married to the chosen CEO and have a kid with him uh and stay a part of the the family while uh Kendall and Roman been booted out and candles like [ __ ] the implication he's considering suicide which is real fun yeah so that's great Kendall the the most competent by a mile the person who legitimately cares about the company so much who works so hard to keep it together who saved the company in the first season who had the most interesting relationship with Logan um you know he's fighting all his demons and everything Kendall he's he loses I don't even know what the [ __ ] going on with Roman Roman I guess loses and shiv the the nastiest of the three the the worst person in the show that conniving backstabbing [ __ ] wins and it's just like [ __ ] this show I can't believe it we had to go through so much character destruction and plot contrivance and nonsense to get to this point one of the worst endings possible it literally is like the worst ending possible um it was I mean it's worth emphasizing is like the nature of how like this ending just does not feel like it lines up with a lot of things that were developed in the earlier Seasons think about like the ending of season two for instance where throughout That season Kendall was basically utterly subservient to Logan um and then It All Leads up to there's going to be the big blowout with the cruises thing they need to basically somebody that they're going to sacrifice they're gonna be the Fall Guy they're gonna uh they're gonna yeah they're gonna take the fall for it uh and then there's a big conversation a super interesting conversation where all of the characters make like decisions about who they reckon they should throw under the bus and make Arguments for and of course this is back when I the show was really great so they're all making really interesting and compelling Arguments for different people but I mean obviously like as you're watching it you realize that it's it's like Tom is a big candidate or a Kendall as well because of like Kendall's super subservient position at that point um there's a lot of great drama that happens in that episode and ultimately culminates in uh Kendall has a conversation with Logan where where it's like oh it's going to be you you know like you like he believes essentially because of how subservient he is that he'll do it he'll be a good Fall Guy and he'll save the company and then uh Kendall basically asked him was it ever going to be was I ever going to be the person that was going to be like CEO uh and that's you know when Logan basically says like you don't have the Killer Instinct and then Kendall goes to the big press meeting where he's going to throw himself under the bus and then he's he's ramping up to talking about it and then this is a big old but actually Logan is like the malignant tumor within the company um and and that he's got the evidence that Greg had kept from cruises and he's gonna fight him and it's and then and then the end of the episode is Logan Smiles because very subtly yeah well why do you think he knows his company and his legacy are going to be safe Kendall's got it Kindle actually does have it after basically being brought down to the absolute lowest point that you could take that character to no um I don't see how like you look at that ending and where we ended up at the end of season four and like how these fit together you know what I mean like how do these sort of things fit together like really neatly as uh story elements that like no really fundamentally at the end of it was just that he was promised something as a child and that was like that was it he's the oldest boy so he should be CEO but like that was all there was so sad to see him absolutely fumble and make arguments he would never seen him make before instead of all of the normal actually substantive arguments the problem is that he's given those arguments before to them and all of a sudden Romans flip-flopping for no [ __ ] reason shiv is being a [ __ ] is normal and thinks that she should just get all this [ __ ] for free she's the most entitled one of the bunch by a considerable margin and the show does not punish her for that yeah the show like rewards her of course she is I mean she's the one who's at least involved in the company he's the most backstabbing she's a traitor to the family in the company many times over but she ends up just winning it a hall in the end and I'm gonna go get a drink [ __ ] the show it is interesting right you compare this sort of because it was something that we were wondering as a thread as we were earlier on and the show was like each season going to be essentially building up and then knocking down each of the kids she's with Kendall build him up knock him down and then season two that was more of like a focus on where the shiv would potentially become CEO and then there was that dinner with The Pierces that they had where she basically just like openly so I'm going to be a CEO and destroyed it like tank the deal and then that all sort of like LED down the road and screwed everything up excellent scene by the way it was it was a fantastic scene but I guess if you think like long term it's like what were the long-term consequences really that she suffered from like that blunder which was a massive blunder because I needed that pierce deal the reality became quickly understood she has no [ __ ] business making any decisions in this company basically at all Beyond just uh standard critical thinking in terms of normal discussions like someone explains to hear all of the components of a thing and it's like this decision gives us this this decision you know like an ultimate things that all of us could weigh in on um but she doesn't actually know anything Works she hasn't been there at all she doesn't know any of the people she doesn't know any of the systems or any of the individual industries that are a part of all of it and so it's just like you should never ever be CEO and that's what the show kept teaching us as we went along and then Logan did something that I was saying should have happened ages ago or would happen to make her shut up he gives her the role of President of waystar royco I'm like what does that mean it's like well it sounds really good but you don't have to do [ __ ] anything you sound you sound really important you are really important you don't do anything you can just do whatever the [ __ ] you want like oh that's that's shiv that sums her up and that's a really smart move by someone like Logan Roy to shut her up but to give her something that she clearly wants but she also doesn't have any accountability or reliability on anything she's just there what is arguably the next best thing or even a better thing for her to end up with well not CEO but wife of CEO that that's like perfect she gets to have the influence at a level she wants but she again doesn't have any accountability or responsibility and she's uh she's arguably anchored herself in with a kid it's gonna be really hard for Tom to get rid of her uh after that it's just such a [ __ ] shame that she gets to have everything she wants well it's just I I it's um it's it's kind of when you compare to someone like Kendall who was punished significantly but then of course there's a contrast with like he made several significant moves it's the reason why I was so baffling that like that that uh that like Shivan and Roman seemed like so insistent that it couldn't possibly be him it's like it's hard to generate the arguments when he is like he was single-handedly responsible for like dealing the most damage you could say to the company essentially in trying to take over it yeah um or more aptly that he made a lot of the best moves he almost won the uh the board meeting in in episode six the reason why I lost that was because he was it was that it was that uncertainty that he had like the insecurity that he had to go over to the lack of a killer instance yeah because he talked to Ewan I just wanted to talk to you when he works yeah it's one of the best representations that you have him faltering on all those individual pieces trying to fix them up and repair them and ultimately it kills him meanwhile what does Logan do comes in for a normal day is annoyed that they take him in so long finds out the whole company is about to get taken from underneath him and he just shouts at everybody shouts of all the like counters a lot of the the arguments gets them all scared and then actually wins like it was the power of Logan Roy and that was the one aspect that Kendall needed to have and he began his path to really nailing it at the end of season two and then we find out like they undo it they roll it back it's just like uh what a [ __ ] shame because I think the reality is like it just I don't know maybe people disagree but like to me it seemed like the player and obvious route to take for the show in terms of like the broad overarching narrative is that like Kendall becomes his father essentially he turns into Logan Roy not quite the same like a different version of him but ultimately like the same version through like complete destruction and yeah we would expect destruction of that character don't don't get us wrong we're not looking for the good ending or the happy ending we're looking for the sensical ending and where it seemed to be building everything up to until you hit season four is the candle was going to become his father and it was going to be harsh to watch but impressive that he would he would become a lot more ruthless um I got those moments it was all built it was really [ __ ] executed well and then it got [ __ ] uh they changed their minds and I'm inclined to agree with Brian Cox Logan left the show way too [ __ ] early well his death closed the door to a lot of like further narrative payoffs and of course like the the counter Aragon would be like well it was shocking right and like the death was kind of handled in a way that felt more um realistic in the sense that it begins with like uncertainty as to whether he's dead like this situation is developing and evolving like you get what I mean like sort of a more um grounded uh and then of course the fact that you know sometimes people die unexpectedly like sometimes people die and and you don't see it coming like an illness that something happens to them so it's got all of those elements but like Logan Roy was like such an interesting character to not have him anymore like that absence really was fun gotta be careful and make sure you know what you're doing uh but it felt like they didn't and yeah so in conclusion um I hated season four and it's it's arguably like it's taught the show so bad um I was trying to explain this the exact same way of Game of Thrones the the it's like just double up everything right season one and two golden seasons one through four and Game of Thrones are pretty much golden and then the last season just killing it through [ __ ] up all the characters just failing the plot writing and killing the overall thematic element of the show that I was so [ __ ] interested in a couple of things here and there you might like a couple of performances couple of scenes couple this that and the other is so you know cool and stuff but [ __ ] me that season and it's to the point where someone said like so do you recommend it it's really [ __ ] hard too and I would probably recommend stopping after season two and you can imagine how everything went it's a really solid ending um honestly yeah because ending of season two was it was like the high point we were so excited oh man that was the peak of investment you gotta understand guys we were thoroughly impressed with this show like for those first two seasons yeah like pretty enamored with it some of the best TV I've seen it was absolutely um and it's probably my favorite role from Brian Cox he's [ __ ] brilliant he was fantastic everybody's great like the performances are excellent like every everybody's everybody's uh really great at embodying those characters and giving them those little subtleties and nuances um soundtrack is awesome I really like the soundtrack yeah um yeah we've been sitting on that for a while and we needed to get that out yeah and I'm memory holding a lot of that show at this point I'm gonna forget a lot in a month's time I'm probably not gonna remember most of it um it upset me quite a bit so it's it's going away now we're all upset on that one that was uh that was pretty painful especially during that finale holy [ __ ] but I loved I loved the times that I left with it you know unless yeah smile because it happened now I've seen some people say like wow so what are the four hours today only all the successions like that's not how it works don't worry we're gonna finish we finish the videos okay so it takes as long as it takes chill now I'm gonna I guess signal that the spoiler times are undone okay we're not gonna say anything about succession now it's all over that was it that's all done I know they're gonna be hyper passionate fans like they need to address further they need to make a better breakdown you're not getting it that was it that's all we want to do about [ __ ] it um it's you know we do different breakdowns of different things that one that was just that was that was painful and uh I'm done I don't wanna I don't want to think about succession ever again upset me um don't recommend now we're talking about uh what are we doing today is is the first of I think we did it once before but we're doing a kind of different format slightly Skywalker I think do we do it for Joker do we do a cinema wins and sins on joker as well I remember remember that muted The Gunshot uh what we're doing is we're gonna check out good old uh Cinema wins and sins but we're gonna we're gonna mock them and we're gonna see who wins and I'd like to take a bet before we start uh on behalf of I suppose the audience and ourselves as to who do you believe will win now the rules are I want to be very clear uh they get one point per highlighted point on their video that we consider valid now not significant or substantive necessarily let me explain should we do like points and half points maybe oh that's like I think binary might be the way to go I don't know well I I think I think it'd be it'd be better to say because you know a lot of the times when we cover people they make like observations that are just really kind of like surface level and you don't really like yeah you don't get much credit for that I get like half a point right and then you have like a a full point or we can do a point in two points like oh you that's really like if they say something particularly insightful they get like let's do an example one or two points if okay if so what would you give them if one of them said uh Benedict Cumberbatch does a really good job he's acting well uh 0.5 that'd be half a point off a point hmm what do you think Frankie because I think uh uh I don't think that that should no I don't I don't know that I I wanna I'm gonna give them points for like real sort of insight okay so I am I love how all three of us have a different point of view I was actually going to make it binary that if it's valid and fair and true then point if it's not then no point uh I don't know I don't know how much I want to reward like oh yeah Benedict Cumberbatch is a good actor it's like yeah it's real like yeah no [ __ ] yeah like we all know it's pretty clear that he's doing a good job it doesn't mean that much it's like yep nice safe boring observations like let's uh okay so what about the the rags suggestion that they get at least 0.5 for non-substantive True points and then substantive true points get upon a point um I think that's oh damn like I don't know I'm almost thinking you know to be true because there was a there's one about negative points as someone said negative points for lying slash misrepresenting oh okay well then it would just be a battle of who's less negative which would be funny but um there was a there's a show I don't I think it's called like around the horn it's like a sports show that I've just caught idly on when I met like bars or restaurants and it's playing and they have four guests and the guests talk about sports topics and things of that nature and there's a host and the host gives them a number of points based on how true or insightful the thing is which is sort of where I get the idea well oh yeah that's true that's a correct stat so a point or someone says well this this player got traded to there and that matches well with this other player so that means that their stats and they'll be like ding ding ding that's three points that's very interesting and insightful so that way it's not just a matter of who could name off the most observations part of the reason why I was gonna go with the binary is because at the very we're not only going to have trouble deciding whether or not something is a half point a negative pointer point would depend on the system but we'll also we may disagree as a team of five but luckily because we're five we can vote to go like say three of us said it was a the two of us didn't then that can overrule and you know and that's much easier with binary than it is with like if I say that's half a point Mel says yeah half a point then right's like no that's a point meme says that's point then Frank's like oh I I don't I don't know I think it's like two points it's so good we'll never have a tie you would if you have more than two options that's what I'm saying yes yeah all right um that's why I'm voted that's why I prefer binary because we can't [ __ ] that up then um I don't think it's a matter of us [ __ ] it up really well no we wouldn't I just that was just like a colloquial term I just mean we won't deadlock at any point it'll be quick and simple uh I gotcha I still like mine but I'm not I'm not like attached to it in particular if we could well you know this won't be the only time we do it depending on how people like this insane nonsense uh we could do it again and uh yeah I like the idea the concept's really fun um because if we I I it is it fair if I just say can we try it this way this time and then we'll we'll not do whatever again if it doesn't work so um so just to be clear with everyone the criteria is if they say something that is true accurate and fair they get a point if it fails any of those it's uh it's not a point I don't think we do negatives so it's just you get a point per you know good good shout now um I guess I want to ask let's let's start a poll with the audience um who will win let's see what chat believe wins for me this is easy I've already I've I I knew but as you at as you started asking the question I already knew what my answer would be well it may as well I was going to give give a chance for all of us to answer so we'll go from left to right I guess uh sins will win my vote um it's it's not like out of the realm of possibility that wins it's a good win but no it's gonna be sins I think Mel yeah I think it's gonna be since uh ranks I think Cinema Sins is going to win meme yeah I'm not going to be breaking the mold on this one um he's such Giga cringe that wins person unfortunately that even though sins is also pretty cringe I think the cringe in wins will out cringe the sins there we go there's your rhyme for the day I can't see your vote right now because chat will be biased I I mean they're here there are we listen we've accepted that I think this one's gonna be hard for wins right like if we were to make Windsor's video this would be difficult but I think I could make 27 minutes worth of praise or Multiverse manners um it wouldn't be very substantive though that would be the the caveat yeah it could be done are we talking about the stunts all the special effects sometimes or the acting or the some of the editing some of the cinematography you know it would mainly be that but uh we could be surprised you don't know absolutely we could I hope to be surprised I'll knock it off when it hits a thousand and we'll see last time I got surprised I have to play Gollum I don't know if I want a surprise okay fair enough to make sure we're Fair okay we're gonna give wins every win he earns oh another question I guess is worth asking is who should go first wins or sins oh good question how do we decide uh let's do because because well I think because most of us seem to think that sins is going to win let's do sins first and then give wins a chance to come up from behind bottom of the ninth he's down by four the bases maybe there's some people on base I don't know um it may be he needs to hit that home run and have that you know that that win at the very end it's tense you know the sides have swap for the last time that's what I think we should do so I go chat votes uh 76 likely for wins um and we do we say we're starting with sins yeah because I think he's more likely to win which I will dramatic keep a track of his points as we go as everyone is in yeah so we'll start with Cinema since we're here uh for those who don't know a channel based around just making a fun goofy comedy video about how a movie is bad and he applies it to all films so a few different results in terms of what you might try and make a joke but he might also try and actually criticize the film you never quite know uh oh this is not a good stop oh I hadn't even what's the date on this video geez better help I mean better help I've seen Rising again I think they've maybe they've they've fixed up the [ __ ] I don't know I don't know maybe the app is I would have wanted to Rebrand if I would have though wait is it is better help has a crazy history of back in the day being uh I think like presented by so many YouTubers who then one of them two of them whatever look to the actual like way the thing works and as far as I know you submit yourself uh you sign up you subscribe whatever and you get given a counselor to tell you like you know are you okay the talk and it was sold as though professionals will be helping you and the way that you could become a counselor on there it required nothing you could just sign up basically oh um so basically you just get some someone to talk to yeah you know ultimately you could say it's people call it a scam it's like uh it's just [ __ ] Discord almost it's just like I'll just jump in with you guy uh but I don't want to make any claims about it right now I haven't looked into it recently this was I'm talking [ __ ] what was this like remake no claims it was like eight years ago something like that it was a number of years ago it feels like it was ages ago the better help Scandal happened but if you look it up on YouTube you'll find all kinds of videos about it um I like I said I haven't looked into them recently but apparently I didn't even know they were around eight years ago I know of them because of like since last year or something when people start talking about it I didn't know they were along around for so long it's interesting yeah the original Scandal was one of those like early be careful who you promote right right oh yeah yeah all right nowadays it's weird is everyone ready I assume so yeah let's go look we understand the importance of mental health and are glad to continue to encourage our viewers to find time to connect with a licensed therapist that will work with you betterhelp.com I'm sure they wouldn't still be claiming their licensed therapists if they weren't I'm sure like it couldn't possibly right yeah that would be uh um will guide you through questions that will help you connect to a great therapeutic map yeah you could be matched a little 48 hours and be able to talk to someone on your time all from the comfort of your home get 10 off your first month with our link below oh boy [Music] include negatives we definitely not doing that like one zero or negative one depending on I'm trying to think of a time where we'll really want one say for example he said something like [ __ ] I don't know like an actor is in this when they're not like something that's just blatantly [ __ ] false would we want to give out negatives or no so this is the problem with the cinema said it's hard to tell the difference between criticisms deliberately inaccurate criticisms and jokes well so yeah what you'll find from a sins fan is they'll say he does that with every movie It's supposed to be funny around this like uh yeah but is what he said accurate or not and uh uh I guess is it obvious is it signposted Etc is there I forget what the rules were but you know part of it is like fine will treat it all the same way um you know like like it's hard to tell a difference a lot of the time and that why don't you just treat the the assessment of it as a joke if it's gonna upset you too much because this is all for fun anyway but um I don't know what to do with 34 seconds of logos like I guess that's true but it's not exactly is I would I don't know if I counted as Fair I mean I haven't timed it though because it's long yeah yeah like what we wanted for for counting uh as a point is fair and accurate right so right um well in that case yeah it's probably yeah it's not fair right logos long it's a legal thing they can't actually do anything about the local logo necessarily but so you know they they worked hard on a movie they can have their logos up for a while before it you know yeah yeah we'll just say no points awarded for that one I'm sorry since yeah no points 34 seconds of logo the whole American viewing public this star on the back of America's jacket which is something I'm supposed to be excited about but the fact that I'm not just makes me feel like I've been thrown into an exam I haven't studied for in a class and I didn't know I was taking to school I didn't realize I was attending I don't know what that was I don't know wait what was that even a criticism like no I think I don't I think that's one of the jokes I think yeah it's tempting to have a negative point system it really is but I guess we're committing to no negatives we don't have to commit we just started this like it's true it is true but what were the criteria just so I'm clear Baron Acura is a point I guess either fair or non-accurate or not not fair enough I don't [ __ ] it's zero what would zero be exactly like what we gotta be clear in our rules well zero well we could be you know zero like the first one right like it's the true it's the 30 SEC four seconds of logos but like that's fine that's just like you just made an observation that but you like made it a negative when it isn't so it's kind of like that balance of oh you think it's negative but it's true but it's not so it's just like okay neutral we come out neutral how do we Define negative one like what would a negative one be negative one would be something that's probably that he thinks is a problem or something that he like he gets it wrong in terms of saying it's quality but he also gets it wrong and what he took away from the observation so he he he he he noticed the thing wrong or he got a detail wrong or he was inaccurate and he made an inaccurate of quality statement about it as well so should we just say the inverse of one point which if it was fair and accurate for a point unfair and inaccurate for negative one yeah something like that yeah I think yeah and then zero is just when it's a bit of a combinational murky ground of both that's probably the best we can do I think so sure okay also you're you're writing this down right I'm gonna tally him yeah I'm just making sure before we go that we're all not just keeping mental notes the first point is a zero but the second point I don't know what to do with this I don't even know what he's I think it was correct whoever said it just that's just a joke but it's not anything yeah so zero I think he has zero is fair yeah it just makes me feel like I've been thrown into an exam for a class and I didn't know I was taking to school I didn't realize I was attending I like three different cuts in there I mean why not just freeze it again is he out of referral correct one point oh my God see this well all kinds of things will happen here I'm sure who knows I mean why not just freeze it again is he out of refrigerant it's too strong I can't hold it well then instead of [ __ ] watching it for the rest of your life why don't you try doing whatever it is you came here to wait why are we here I'm assuming it has more function than just defending my eyes with an amethyst CGI soup oh sure well that's not a very good though to get the book of Ashanti so yeah it's like he was almost there because what you want to say is Doctor Strange spends way too much time not doing things in this moment yeah um but I guess you could argue like he's considering killing her and that's why he's 50 50 but then that we have to get into like how stupid it is that he hasn't decided to just [ __ ] do it straight away like chop ahead off sort of stuff you know it that that was just half baked it was close so is that a zero I guess if you wanted to have a half point that would be what it would be where he's right and then he [ __ ] up we're introducing another I don't think we're doing half points here I think it's harder you get it right it's a zero or you got it wrong negative I think he says I give it a zero it's like you're almost there you need to straighten it out of it yeah if I'm half was there are no half points went on IGN no half measures I'm not you know what I'm not going to give I'm not going to give IGN the uh the ownership of the half point system oh well IGN actually I I think I got it wrong IGN's not just half points they do like point one they have the seven points we've got a suggestion that he was outright wrong because they do point out they're trying to get to the book and someone else said uh he's right because he's pointing out that um that he's the the the the it's he's pointing out that they should be trying to get to the the book but like I said it's very gray to me in terms of exactly if we let's do it one more time let's see if we can really figure out any definitive point he's making too strong I can't hold it well then instead of [ __ ] watching it for the rest of your life why don't you try doing whatever it is you came here to wait why are we here I'm assuming it has more functions yes and it's weird that he wrote it this way as though he doesn't know that they're getting the book it was it was signed posted in the scene that they get in the book so yeah I don't know what he means by amethyst CGI soup amethyst because I know an amethyst is it's my birthstone in fact whoa fun fact about Rags the amethyst is my my birthstone but I don't know what he means when he says an amethyst seizure suit maybe it has maybe it's like um what's that when people say the color maybe yeah isn't that a color what starts it's purple right and yeah amethyst is purple that's what he's saying it's a purple CGI landscape oh the landscape I thought he was talking about the monster Oh I thought he was talking about like the monster of the props or something going on here well look but I guess it's purpley in the back kind of yeah that's purpley yeah um this is zero points because someone said the reason he's not mentioning the book is because he's making the joke that we they should I'm just like I I hate the multi-layered analysis how ironic he's being oh sure you can suck out the multi-dimensional powers of this girl with your right hand while trying to keep a barrier around the demon with your left hand but for some reason you can't just use that right hand to strengthen the barrier or throw lollipops at it or whatever it is you dirty Sorcerers do with that right hand correct it's like the amount of hands and focus that you use on a spell should kind of determine how strong yeah multitasking with magic seems like it diverts your attention and thus the power of the Spells do you think he freeze with the other hand right over there yeah strengthen it with the other like he said yeah it's just I don't know what he's doing strange pretty basic for fiction the more you can focus on a singular thing the better that thing will be multitasking is where the skill and the practice and the concentration comes in Steven turned to his left and the next shot is him looking at his watch despite it being on the table to his right so um oh yeah that's the [ __ ] out of the 180 rule I think um well no that's not even 180 rule that's just it it's it's complicated because you could just argue well no he turned again between those shots because you don't show everything but it's it's a little unintuitive for the viewer I think yeah with that right hand Steven turns his reflection left and the next shot is him looking at his watch despite it being on the table to his right I think that's fair uh and I'm sure you can see the significant I think it's fair yeah yeah could there be a like a really weird angle for the camera to be like like behind the nightstand by the books the books literally looking in the wrong direction yeah that's what I'm trying to I think though is the watch is facing the right way as well I think it is yeah but like it's it's it's just a it's a really really small thing that you know when they're filming they must have an entirely different time and place like it wasn't hard as him looking at his watch despite it being on the table so yeah we give him one for that right yeah it's really small um but I still I think you have to consider it fair and accurate it's still a good observation yeah it was right so either someone in charge of continuity the sub or we missed an epic double take that would have snapped Strange's neck I suppose this was in case you forgot he was magic you guys might if I well I think that's just so tying ties isn't difficult but it's nice to be able to use it no points no points awarded for that no points you would too yeah and he's got broken hands they're probably doing it with magic is less painful for him I would imagine I'd be upset that Christine isn't marrying Stephen in this scene but I'm more upset that we never got a scene with her makes that long awaited Sherlock that I've been holding on to for sure we've already decided so yeah we know Cinemas is those references where he just says remember this other thing and it's like that's no points I'm sorry it's not a sin that's just you referencing something else you get no points I'm sorry I wish it had been different I wish to skip remember the day oh but I guess he's just like I guess he's saying it's boring I think I think you get negative thoughts for that you might oh [ __ ] I went through that whole conversation when I reviewed it about the cats so yeah are we actually awarding negative one um what we had with our description for that is inaccurate and unfair does it qualify or is it qualified something else it's sufficiently unfair um it's just there's nothing else to it right like there's no well that's it's neither accurate nor inaccurate and it's unfair so I think that's one point I think chat seemed to feel it's uh it's a negative one as well all right very well I'm ready to give it a negative it's two conversations that are skipped one of which is going to be our foundation foreign on the fun as well I wish have been different I wish sorry I completely forgot you're right yeah he skipped the conversation he had with the doctor other doctor forget his name yeah the two kinds yeah a good amount of stuff right remember the days when we would use mobile phone to call Emergency Services instead of just using them to record people in trouble good times if there are points yeah um yeah because it's not out of character but it is kind of lame that he would do that instead of immediately calling people that's that guy you know and I can believe someone would do that unfortunately [Music] it's just an observation at that point it's not a criticism yeah yeah zero gosh he's stacking up Court people in trouble good times but the actual flying is strange doing here he sees this car hurtling towards oh yeah eat the car and fly away instead of eating the car and the mother and child he's trying to save that is he saying that it seems like he's saying that oh Doctor Strange I guess just hope that the monster wouldn't eat the woman as well so I think I think you've actually gone oh [ __ ] did he [ __ ] it up yeah oh no instead Springs right he's saying that it's dog strange summoned this thing in the hopes that it would only deal with the car and it wouldn't turn on the mother and child which is not a worry at all it's a spell oh you are so close it's the idea that was an easy dunk dude oh we were so hopeful and then it was just like oh it's a good thing you didn't eat the mother and the kid too it's like yeah I get well I'll be more concerned with the car that [ __ ] lad did on some innocent civilian yeah or is he trying to say that the nature of the spell is such that he has to hope it only eats the car and not that's so I think it's a bad faith assumption to to say that he doesn't have control over the head yeah he believes the head like has some agency of its own rather than like just being a thing that is directly and solely controlled by uh strange so yeah that's that's a good point I don't I don't know if it's I can believe someone thinking that he's summoning ahead from like another dimension and it's doing its thing uh it's not no it's not an impossibility but the the way you right you always go good faith you don't go bad faith right it's so it's well in the realm of possibilities to him in the sense that I think that's what he could reasonably think based on how no yeah we know that he put in the video of course he thinks this it's just that it's not it's not fair the actual criticism he should be making here is like why are you summoning a demon head to eat the car like why is that the way yeah and it sends the car flying like look you can see it the car's like flying elsewhere yeah the criticism is not oh it's weird as well didn't eat the woman like that's what yeah he's highlighted that like wow you're lucky it at eight the car and flew away it's like well it kind of it it it moved the car it didn't even fly away with the car you know like it so yeah uh he almost had it he had components he needed to iron that one out because uh yep it's weird like if he was actually saying like so weird to summon a creature to eat the car I'd be like well I think he's just that's just the form it took he's just trying to move it but the document is using the spell is stupid it's I still think it's a plus one no it's not accurate it's not fully accurate it's uh it went off the rails a bit though listen if you you understand the kind of thing we're doing here we gave him a point for the watch one when that is like not consequential whatsoever and in you know but it's because it's actually accurate and written well like it's it's that is what is happening and this is not what is happening instead of eating the car and the mother and child he's trying to save again why the [ __ ] is strange picking the most complicated ways to deal with these obstacles what's stopping him from sling ringing that into the Antarctic look at that I think that's fair yeah yeah one point yeah you did it was that did he put it into his counter we get two yeah from sling ringing that into the Antarctic he's creating behind him we're only nine minutes in we're already waiting dangerously close to Green Lantern summoning a [ __ ] machine gun levels of dumbassery looks like yeah that count is two also another thing we should probably highlight then are we always going to stick to whatever they decide is the conclusion like the ding or are we gonna go by how many points they make uh I think that's a good question is do we want to beholden to their ding systems because I can't remember if their game systems are the same between sins and wins so say for example he said like you could have used this spell and you didn't you could have used this spell and you didn't you could have used this spell and you didn't and then he does a ding well that counts as three for us or one like I think that would count as one because he's listing like you could have used an alternative spells like these and this one would be why aren't you using this one piece of equipment you did this which caused a separate issue which is the Carnage behind you I think I see what you what you're saying so I get what you're saying but I almost think that like the way that it should work is using their system that constitutes apparently like what they consider the sin yeah okay I I think the issue might happen if if something happens really are different but we'll see when we get there so we'll figure it out yeah yeah well just before we go on just something worth I'm looking into the future right now into the future where we switch to wins and I'm just remembering that wins is a lot more long-winded than sins and that he might actually have like four five six seven eight points within a single win um that might make us re-question the system again I just wanted to bring that up that could end up [ __ ] it up a little bit we'll have to see and we may have to feel it out at that point like say for example sins has you know a hundred points and we give him uh 50 of them while wins makes like 40 points and we give them 10 feels weird right yeah we can reassess we can reassess it's a Green Lantern something of machine gun levels of dumbassery looks like Miss America went to the Prometheus School running away from Suicide Squad rip-offs sure I don't know that I well shoot there's lots of places you can go but I feel like that's the best one it's the you need to get away from this thing not it's not necessarily only going for why would he he's treating it like it's the donut it's not a donut it'll move too so this is not a white this is not a wide open field this is a street with a lot of options it's broken from the get-go the tentacle monster is chasing her it's not just going in the Direction that's what I was about to say yeah it's a living thing because she turns the corner in the next shot I'm pretty sure uh and he turns because he's alive and Chase a ghost and yeah I I won't give her really any [ __ ] for being in a stressful situation like that seeing an open space ahead of you and the idea of things to the left and right yes was that a zero or negative one one I would say it's a negative one that's an accurate because I don't think it's true so I think it's inaccurate and unfair yeah because it said he wanted to do the Prometheus strike because that's one of his running gags so yeah it's negative one point Sorry these are you're yeah these are not the same scenario you cannot compare them they did not go to the same time yeah exactly it looks bad why are the squishy Sorcerers engaging in hand to technical combat keep your distance do some spells and oh where else I agree that is a problem yes good job sir excellent yes this person trying to drive his motorcycle through here typical motorcycle driver think the road belongs to them excellent another Point cloak is smarter than this right instead of whisking America away out of sight it's just flying straight up in the air so a monster can throw a motorcycle at it I think that's cool I said let's go around a corner as soon as possible so it's pretty much the same point I think so it's going quite high up right like it's very lucky that America landed on that ledge so yeah I think that's I think he gets a point yeah you could argue the cloak is making two mistakes there um yeah making it so that if he drops her she has to suffer in the uh it's still in range of identical boys so valid yeah yeah also because I edited this part in your video more than I'm getting such post-traumatic yeah how [ __ ] long it takes to edit the whole thing you'd get like one fight scene done you're like yay yay yeah well especially because it's so bad yeah it's so seeing more flaws and now they're using magic chains to try and restrain the octopus monster which has shockingly a little effect on it so either these are the name of sorcerers to ever Source or they are deliberately [ __ ] around and ignoring any inconvenience damage or death sustain to the New York taxpayers wow I almost almost want to give him two points for that in terms of good good faith he actually said like you know if this is a viable spell then why is it doing nothing and then if it's not viable why the hell are you using it okay so I guess we are deciding then our system is not bound by well I'm just saying uh that was that was some good faith you don't always get in these videos yeah that was good faith surprisingly so um what are we what do we feel we are we introducing plus two which is when he's accurate fair and kind of goes above and beyond to make sure yeah I think we got to be sparing with it I think that it takes up like a plus two is the most that you could probably get maybe like that's our ceiling for points you can get so as long as we treat it with a bit of reverence then um I would be okay with it what did you think about that one do you think it owns it um part of this will depend retroactively on what else we give two points to but um we could flip a coin on it no I want to know your opinion well that's why I said a lot of this will depend on what we give point you know twos in the future because why don't you why don't you put like one with an asterisk that this could turn into two depending on Absolutely I'll give him two I'm feeling if I can make the argument again the point he could have made is what a stupid spell to cast it goes completely wrong and it's like yeah okay that's a point but then to say and if like it's delving into like the specifics of how the characters would make this decision and that he's he's knocked out any possible counter argument which is like that's pretty good because someone could have said like you can't say they're stupid for using it they're Sorcerers they know what they're doing it's like well they mix plot and character a bit to make maybe that is what helps elevate it that it takes both of those someone's right your next important in chat you made a negative two as well I kind of agree with that I agree that might come up if it's if it's a foul a stupid point it might hurt it say for example if [ __ ] cinnabowitz says Wanda was right that's negative negative in my friend so okay you know what okay if we give a plus two we can give a negative two we are enabling you to do great and terrible things out of control yeah our system has evolved we'll be handing out minus sevens in an hour minus 100 points I don't think this is spiraling at all I think it's we've got under control defining the system I feel like I have a grip on low at our block of marble and slowly but surely the piano is taking shape it might not it looks a little rough few right now but one day we will have a beautiful Virgin Mary Jesus Christ I just noticed America looks like she's dabbing she's dabbing on God [Music] oh God okay so uh yeah okay let's continue or they are deliberately [ __ ] around convenience damage or death sustained to the New York taxpayers I can't put my finger on it but the Doc Octopus fight is so reminiscent of Spider-Man 2. I can't figure out totally disagree with that it's just a reference well the reason why you haven't considered it is because they're not even the same at all yes well I guess there's like a tentacle-ish thing on a building side right between them it's just like the fight 100 no I I nah it wouldn't matter anyway he's getting zero no matter what this is subjective like it feels like something and I don't know I don't even I don't know how he possibly feels that way think about like I'll give it to him I'll be like okay tentacles a building side woman in Peril like what about like the actual nature of the fight the fact that it's yes those are different size tentacle creatures versus woman that's the same tentacle tentacle creature trying to get a woman on the side of a building like I get it I never thought about it until this moment until he brought it up but like I guess if that's what his brain goes to I don't have a problem with that if that's what he talks about I really don't see that I don't either but I see how I'm actually going to go ahead and say I don't [ __ ] care it's a it's a tidy thing that he thought about who cares like it's it's connected vaguely it doesn't have to be a substantive connection if it was literally just him saying doesn't the Tactical man remind you could be like no but it's fine he brings it up it's fine it's not I guess it changes it comes to your mind okay you gotta understand mola I'm not like arguing that it should be a negative point I'm just sad I don't see the connection at all I really don't see it um we're literally just going like oh Sam Remy directed both of these tea here I wonder if that's gonna be a running gag in this video it's just like oh that's what I mean that's why I'm awarding zero but just whatever I don't get it took me less than five minutes of playing Portal to realize how momentum works so I can confidently say this is a dumbass way to save yourself oh wow make the exit portal fire him up so that gravity can slow his second descent oh that's my suggestion that would have been cool as [ __ ] yourself is that two points there so one is pointing out this is really stupid and two is presenting an alternative that's like actually kind of like that would work exactly I I still think this is one territory two is a value two is a precious thing I think two I would have assumed this is a one but this is a winner this is a winner I can understand that one day with enough care and treatment and you know if it's well watered and kept in the sunlight is necessary it could one day develop and do it too no 1.5 even I'm even I'm gonna be like complicated enough yeah by the way just just so we're clear we've basically replaced the 0.5 in one system with a one and two system just super clear one is a complete good point above and beyond good point yeah we've got we've got five different point Awards right now so this system was never even suggested but we haven't now said it was Spiderman what man how the [ __ ] has America not run into another Spider-Man already [Music] and the Multiverse why would we yeah well let me well 72 universes all of them that have Spider-Man and never have met him or heard of him so I don't think that's a very good point at all he couldn't be in a different city he could be I mean he maybe they just it depends on how long she spent in those worlds what uh what year are those timelines in are they necessarily running so the time component of jumping universes we're not even gonna [ __ ] get into it the important thing is Spider-Man is not an inevitability in the Multiverse I think that's the important part here Spider-Man is not inevitable I mean well I guess I guess it depends on which ones you go to she would have to miss all of the infinite possibility we're getting into Multiverse stuff yeah this infinite universes where he doesn't exist and infinite universe is where he does so it's just [ __ ] it's the kind of thing with weighing this up is that like you have two sets of infinite and if it's not an actual number how many Doctor strangers was it two before this one uh I think she met two was it right in any case whichever one she met was a part of teams that didn't involve Spider-Man in those universes can you buy that it's like yeah yeah and you're like I shouldn't spend much time in a lot of these universes and a lot of them are like paint or something that's absurd that doesn't have any Spider-Mans or anything man in it you know yes surely it's more likely that a doctor strange in a car accident [ __ ] up his hands than a Peter Parker gets bitten by a radioactive spider surely the doctor strange one is more likely to happen I just think it's it is possible this has happened it's not entirely unreasonable and it's just it's just it's not really a point zero yeah because only 72 compared to impedance yeah I think I think this is perfectly reasonable criticism to make it's just not accurate I would almost consider this fair but not accurate I think that because of the confusing nature of the Multiverse and infinites and how this movie plays with it yeah he's kind of off the hook a little bit later chances are you'd have run into that John Mulaney one by now finds wall shoots webs yeah Bingo out of his butt why would this be your default assumption that's actually kind of well it's a spider's web but a spider it's a posterior area but I don't uh makes me wonder what does she think he looks like Star Trek awful amalgamate like some the fly [ __ ] or like what does she think the spiders man which is uh like a 10 000 spiders that take humanoids form and believe they're Peter Parker that's a comic reference good job how are we feeling everybody is that a fair thing for her to assume or not depends on her care her character whether she would us maybe assume that or not but and I don't know we have enough to work with and I think Department the thing about it is I think you can justify it by saying that she might consider it a possibility and is worth saying because it's funny like she might be saying it for that reason I don't have a problem with her saying that yeah in which case it would make his point a zero right yeah I think so zero yeah everything else is a fairly this is inoffensive it wasn't a dream proven so either that portal conveniently landed America and her strange on top of this building or she decided to drag his dead ass all the way up to the roof uh I mean yeah right yeah that's fair um hip hop can open anywhere uh because it's random yeah and what about the ocean more likely and I think you do have to fairly highlight there are far more likely of all the places that could open way more like vastly more of them will kill you than won't oh well then again at the end of the film it says you always open to where you needed to go that doesn't work that's like that's a post-haw crash it doesn't even work well things sort of worked out in the end I guess but they didn't but whatever it would be cool if it did work that you look back at all what are you saying how could you possibly argue that like what she did to her parents was deliberate in a subconscious way it's like no yeah and the Illuminati and all this [ __ ] and the Inquisition inquisitions like again his the rationale is well we're not dead oh yeah uh I I don't think that would be a good thing so this remains accurate yeah multiversal um like you know when they were going through all the Multiverse um all the universes um before they ended up in [ __ ] Universe um uh what's the difference which one is yeah which one is you know there are degrees um but but like there are there are a lot of um if my memory serves a lot of those universes they were smashing through weren't in a safe location so yeah um it kind of kills that assumption um right there of our multiversal cells that's actually kind of funny well so the problem is do we do because I like that one too but I don't know if we give points for funny it's zero oh yeah sort of like you're like that that's you basically said what the [ __ ] and that was it so you don't get any points because you have to actually say words I think so yeah explain yourself I like it and I'm pretty sure I know what he's talking about but he didn't say any of it yes I'm not gonna I'm not gonna do that kind of heavy lifting for you unfortunately that's a zero pointer but it did make me laugh so Bravo and really that's probably the that's one that you could really take with you you know Bank of that one yeah previously on One Division what's one division oh it's just a six hour TV show that you need to have watched so you can fully appreciate what's happening in this movie well it's it's about making it completely redundant that is true uh what do we thinking yes so hey if the director didn't feel the need to finish it or the writer then yeah um I would back him in saying you do need it to understand fully what is happening here which is exactly what he said because you you will miss out if you haven't seen one division in a really bad way too like I said in my videos some people didn't even know what they were basing it on that Wanda would take over the Multiverse they're like where the [ __ ] did you get that from it's like yeah they don't mention that in this movie don't mention the dark holds uh uh prophesizing that they only say it is prophesized that's just it it's like since when from who and you know so you get that if you watch One Division but at the same time you could argue yeah one division's it's such a like small scale nothing event now compared to what happened in this that this will this this will be everything to do with Wanda now the the stuff happened in [ __ ] Westview won't even matter you know yeah except Vision if he eventually [ __ ] comes back so is that do we do we say a point for that so okay finish my mind do you do you want Penny talk I made wait what what that's the joke pity [ __ ] joke pity [ __ ] pity talk oh oh I see um yeah zero that's a zero mistakes and people were hurt all true but the main thing is that you've learned from those mistakes I'm ready to move on there's no way this movie would undo an entire season of character growth in 90 minutes right you don't agree that that was character development do you this might be approaching negative two territory well you know okay so you watched One Division and you know that despite how horribly written it is the point that they're clearly making by the end is that she understands what she did wrong and undid it quote unquote she understands that suffering is bad and that she shouldn't cause it right you could say that yeah I think that's the point he's tried to make is like did you spend a whole season learning that you shouldn't [ __ ] like torture people and you wouldn't undo that in this film would you so I think it's right um obviously the counter would be the dark hold uh affected her character whatever but that argument goes out the second you dig into it as well so I would have given him two points if he dug into that but he doesn't so he's just making the valid point I would say okay yeah I can yeah I think so yeah waiting ranks you're on board I will I'll go I'll go with the flow on this one wow you never told me her name did you Jesus Wanda how the [ __ ] did you make this rookie mistake of saying the name you shouldn't know he grew up watching television from old DVDs they were all sitcoms but I bet someone made this exact mistake in one of them and I can't believe this is what makes Dr Strange realize Wanda is not his friend well it's just like an intelligence thing you don't you know like see you just yeah I think it's really disappointing that Wanda [ __ ] it up uh on just saying a name she shouldn't know the whole DVD thing I assume that's just for a joke that's not like an argument I don't think like you you watch them you watch sitcoms you should know how to count to the I think but I think it's valid to say that it's just out of character for it to have made that mistake when she's you know puppeteering all of this yeah yeah when she's no yes when she knows it's coming and she should be prepared and you know give him one for that right yeah hello yes I would agree yes yeah I would agree yeah I know it's the book of the Damned and then it corrupts everything and everyone that it touches except all the times that it doesn't just saying yeah yeah and we're expected to buy that the discount Book of the Dead is solely to blame for making Wanda evil this means the movie can make her do as many [ __ ] up things as it pleases and we don't have to care because it's not really Wanda doing it I'm going to leave this room that's um that's not is coolie's highlighted he hasn't made the second half you have to do the second half which is that it's inconsistent it's uh it's kind of a [ __ ] excuse it doesn't really make sense all he said is oh so that's your excuse fine he's just said that that's their excuse yeah there's um I mean in The Lord of the Rings when the ring corrupts people you could tell when it's working we could you could tell when Boromir is influenced by it and when he's back to being himself it doesn't straddle that line of ooh anything bad that you do could be like the the ring or whatever it's like it's it's definitely doing a good job at showing the difference um so people think he's mocking it he's saying it's bad he has to say why you can't just say it's bad there's a whole point yeah we want explanation you've got to say why it's good that you recognized it's bad but like why are you here when Wong slammed into the car how do you just said that's stupid you'd be like oh well that's zero working yes yes show your work reality and go to one where I can be with my children oh great a movie is stealing from goddamn Cloverfield Paradox is it the one a mother going to an alternate first off making me remember Cloverfield I was gonna say I don't remember oh well Cloverfield Paradox well to catch catch those up who who are lucky enough to not remember a Cloverfield Paradox there's a woman whose kids die and then when the ship goes into an alternate universe in this universe the woman is alive with her kids in this alternate universe and she wants to go see her kids and everything and she needs to accept that um she should be happy for this universe as people and she can't just like barge in on their life and there's like a copy of them with the two moms and stuff so it's it's a decent parallel to make in terms of shitty movie comparisons but it's just a reference [Music] it's the same Multiverse of yeah when we go to a different Universe we're in the same point in the timeline or similar point in the timeline so it all makes you know so it all makes for a great fun movie uh someone said he I disagree the video format is quick points he's not going to explain all of them so all he had to say was it's applied inconsistently so it's not a good excuse that's the second to Long yeah and then like the idea The Long Point he spent like 10 seconds explaining what was wrong with that when he could have just said that was a really stupid move because it's going to hurt you instead of save you also anticipate in those videos there's plenty of times where he goes on for like 30 45 seconds for one point so and remember folks yeah uh something to really really understand about the way we're marking this this isn't um we we gave we said earlier he was funny he didn't get any points for it it's good to be funny but it's not going to get you points on the system we're marking we've seen the validity of the sin which we already knew going in he's not gonna like the references ones are all gonna be zeros so don't worry about it like it doesn't mean that it shouldn't be in the video it just means that uh it wouldn't be an accurate sin and we're seeing which one gets tallied as more accurate by the end yeah exactly oh great a movie is stealing from goddamn Cloverfield Paradox is it the one you used when you gave Thanos the time Stone evil Martha Marcy May Marlene has a point in Infinity War we sort of gave strange a pass for handing the time Stone to Thanos because hey after all he looked at 14 million different Futures and it was the only scenario that came back positive but seeing the [ __ ] that's come after that I feel like 14 million possibilities actually weren't enough that's so [ __ ] um first of all like I don't agree with the assessment in the way that he did it but I still like there's a point there but that's a point against Infinity war and that's a point in favor of this film if he actually was yeah like yes they Wanda's got a point it's like no uh no uh so yeah this is [ __ ] like I don't know what to say about this like it's maybe negative one like it's I'm I guess because from his point of view he should be rewarding the film for this there should have been more possibilities I wonder if that earns him anything that he made that observation well that's the thing though it's only that would be in favor of Wanda like at the time yeah so yeah so negative one point just yeah that's completely [ __ ] sorry man Dr Rooney I wonder if either either of wins or SIDS will end up with a negative like points at total I don't know the reality is she chooses and is prophesized to either rule or annihilate the cosmos so this is definitely something we should be worried about then like something that might bring Spider-Man or falcon or Ant-Man Into The Fray no well all right then whatever okay yeah you got one point yeah that's definitely a point and uh I remember counters that were made by people were like what are they going to do against here it's like it's the end of the [ __ ] Multiverse they should be there yeah what's the guy with the Archer pointing out there it's a Golden Falcon but he's Captain America no he's Captain Falcon sorry it's still inaccurate then Captain Falcon I think well I I'm gonna let him slide for calling him Falcon I think it's fair it's one point well you know the two points there would have been um I know that they may not be able to make uh you know a complete difference but they should be here you know it's so stupid to assume like oh we won't want to call Spider-Man he can't beat a wizard or with witch whatever whether the sorcerer Supreme asks of us shall be done as long as it can be done by six people or less kind of the same Point again it's a lot more than six though that's just there they're the leaders so yeah that's kind of yeah yeah the zeroes as well okay those creatures after her instead of myself was mercy no it was just a waste of goddamn time it's the thing a villain does to disguise their evilness too early in the movie when all they had to do was show up and get what they wanted in the first five minutes he's correct um there's just a lot of other things you could say the the such is it's against her interest to have done it but that's kind of covered by him saying it would take much longer so you know uh yeah yeah say that's a point that would not have been Mercy since you have to kill America anyway where you're going to water border or something the movie's gonna run with his excuse twice as if the real reason wasn't to cover up the fact that she's the antagonist of this movie correct that's another point very true Cinema Sins good job I do hope you understand that even now Michael Waldron you're like what the hell alone you can't fry them that's mean I will do what I want I think this is supposed to make us believe that Wanda is deliberately neutering her powers to some degree instead of tearing apart the fabric of reality to get to America as we all know in evil Scarlet Witch absolutely could I think it was older she was really referring to was that she's not going to be sending things anymore she's coming from now I think that this criticism is inaccurate like it's magic against magic yeah and there's a lot of people having to work together yeah I you know what I think you missed the mark on that one yeah all that's happening there is she's saying like give me America and he's like no and she's like okay but you know what you've seen so far like with the tentacle guy and the weird past a monster from the opening not that he saw that but you know um she'd be like I'm not sending that anymore now I'm coming and I'm gonna kill all of you which he does he's correct he's got the wrong workings no because I feel like you're missing the second portion of that where it's like oh in fact can we Replay that because I'm pretty sure that yeah who's making it let's go this mess is supposed to make us believe that Wanda is deliberately neutering her power yeah like right instead of tearing apart the fabric of reality well neutering her powers by deliberately neutering your powers you could interpret that as I'm sending creatures that aren't as powerful as me to do the job but if you [ __ ] with that then I'm gonna be coming like but you know that's a I that's that's what she means he's saying neutering that's a choice of words but what he's saying is the truth is that even in this scene she's neutering her own powers because she could tear reality which isn't I think that's what he's saying which is uh the problem is you're fighting magic users like she probably could just [ __ ] auto win here depending on how you know like it's it's all it's all very strange this whole scene in terms of like what she can and can't do what you can and can't do throughout the whole movie is a big problem same for strange yeah I'm not sure how I feel about this one in terms of a point I might I might recuse myself then because I'm a little now I'm just confused uh yeah I'm gonna go neutral as well I feel like I don't have enough explanation for him minus seven points whoa this is zero but my I've gotta I'm looking at you like out of brow race so I'm a little like um zero with the brow rise write that down to get to America as we all know in evil Scarlet Witch absolutely could should and would yes premature Source abrasion you got nothing for that no you get nothing zero it's unfortunate because you just highlight like why she's human why isn't that doing anything yeah I thought that's what he's gonna do but a little bit of difference but I'm surprised that the greatest Sorcerers on the planet are showing an extreme lack of imagination in the variety of their attacks they basically have magic arrows and a magic ballista where are the floating monster hands or the witch that we saw earlier true um yeah yeah it's true absolutely yeah they could be doing all kinds of different crazy stuff to especially with you know knowing what the stakes are yeah you could be we could be especially if you're like a Sorcerers and you're at the sorcerer school you're here at Hogwarts and you're like man you should be excited that you could use all these crazy ideas you've been thinking of yeah you could also add that uh long and strange both don't help with the barrier at all even though they can make huge ones they're really powerful themselves yep so that's it for Wanda then as much as I'd love for as much as I'd love to see the attempt I don't see how season two of one division is going to bring her back from that yeah you got a point for that because yeah do you get a point for that what's the point what's the criticism the point the point is so Wanda's done as a character right we're not actually going to pretend like she can is that a criticism she's actually gonna get a Redemption knock I um uh I think it's is it a metacriticism like it was also I assume the criticism should be stories um this is either this is out of character or that post this they try to redeem her and it's it's like it's morally [ __ ] or something saying that she killed someone ruthlessly and that it's gonna be difficult to come back from that isn't criticism so this should probably be a part of whenever we get the quote-unquote Redemption for her at the end social either that or I'm happy for this to be said I think this is this is assassinating it right now right but I don't I don't know that that's what he's saying he even says as much as I'd love to see them attempt to redeem her like everyone and then she should have cremated a bunch of sorcerers here 's here as much as I'd love to see the attempt I don't see how season two of one division is going to bring her back from that okay yeah observation right and the recognition of they will try and fail yeah which is probably correct about but that doesn't really that's not fair this movie points well I guess what happens if they actually get like a super talented writer who manages to write a compelling like Wonder Redemption story which by the way it is possible it's just not so many Marvel's capable of yeah you know why yeah I believe that's a zero if he would have said something along the lines of yeah he maybe he could have made something out of this like well these these ones were defenseless and out of the fight or whatever and she vaporized him anyway semantics it's a one that's so it's not semantics substantive he's he's saying I don't see how they will bring her back from this that's not a criticism that's that's just an observation that he's interested in yeah first of all we haven't even seen them do that yet like in terms of a like he's special he specified season two of One Division doesn't even exist yet and I don't think that's ever going to exist right so yeah that's really not it's just it's just not it's not the same criticism as we would have made here and uh I don't see how it's accurate like oh I don't see that's fair to this film as a sin it's just an observation about the future which could happen it could be really cringe that they try and redeem it I would expect that to happen too you want the girl from that you want the girl you'll have to go through me fine well then why the [ __ ] didn't we open with this did he really have to sacrifice all these people it's not like he used that time to get America to safety he waited until the last possible second to start playing House of mirrors correct yeah he could have just he could have just said no one shows not gonna do anything we're just going to trick her to think that yeah should have done first thing was mirror verse put her in there right like I can't believe he does that as a last resort it's so [ __ ] up put her on that straight away she's using the reflections she's what she's what what does that even here because you trapped her in a whole and a whole things uh I think that's enough pointing out that there doesn't seem to be any rules whatsoever magic can be intuitive with how you see how one thing connects to another you know like it's like the force right it used to it used to be kind of intuitive but this is just like you're in a Hall of Mirrors so now because there's Reflections on puddles that means that you could get out of the house dimension of mirrors light reflects on [ __ ] everything like the idea they have to cover the puzzles yeah it's so stupid she's using the reflections like oh the whole room then yeah like no the puddles the puddles there are puddles in the room for some reason why are there puddles in the room why are there puddles in the room what kind of roofer you got there but yes he's correct If You Can Count On Me Stephen I'm gonna cover up all the reflections well except this one that I'm going to inexplicably stare directly into why that's a good point yeah excellent point yeah good point yeah Amanda you have no children they don't exist but the other universe in every idea of a Multiverse was that every possible outcome to every decision possible exists somewhere shouldn't there be countless universes with countless wandas all pissed off and trying for the same thing yeah absolutely correct guide in car accidents Michael Waldron doesn't know how any of that works he's just like she's the only one to doing this right now and I remember people in the comments being like well yes because Wanda's a Nexus being a what now a Nexus being that means there's only one oh the movie no there's two of them why would it why would you why would it need to be in the movie yeah what an idiot God why would that be a thing that you would need to hear yeah on a roll right now full corrects in a row keep it up God damn son did it goes strange couldn't open a portal because something so it kind of makes me want to wonder should we do like a streak like a street counter who gets broken to cut you off but I think no streets out of his hands so I'm wondering if the portal is off the table now or did he just forget that he could yeah so yeah the point he's making is how come he can't open portals but he can't open serpents does he not know is it off the table how does that work it's like well what they showed us is that the sling ring was poofed out of existence sorry you get negative one points this is wrong yep wrong okay even mad like a whole scene where it's just gone and that's part of the magic [ __ ] you can just do that you think that's a negative one rather than a zero just checking I've this is negative one wrong because this is yeah because the sling ring especially because there was a specific scene devoted yeah all right um yeah and it sucks because he was if he paid a little more attention then he'd have an easy criticism which is what the [ __ ] Wanda can just there was a whole scene devoted to strange noticing the ring was gone and that was its own you showed it too oh [ __ ] you could do this like [ __ ] what the [ __ ] no it counts as America and strange tumble through the multiverses I'm not convinced the movie fully understands the implications of showing this animated one I mean we may never see that Universe again but now we all know it exists what the hell does that even mean why would an artistic medium from our universe exist as its own distinct Universe I'm curious about what he is going to say when he invariably covers across the spider-verse I'm not sure what to say about that I don't I don't know well no no is he saying that like the world itself is an artistic medium that we use I feel like that's a zero which might which might be where but you could still coincidentally have a universe with a different set of laws of physics that look like an animated Universe coincidentally well don't we go into like an old-timey something thing at one point yeah yeah it's like literally filters on the screen that are happening but not everything yeah the the the the issue is I don't think that we have any reason to believe that it's logically possible for that to happen so a universe where that exists isn't even going to occur but we don't know I don't know but I would err on the side of it I would err on the side of him probably being correct I would air on the side of it being incorrect yeah I don't think I want to give him that one I don't know I'm not talking about giving them a point but I he may be right but I don't know um but I yeah no I don't think he gets points for that but I'm just saying that the idea of what he's talking I would have to give him a it's fair to say but I don't think he's right I agreeish yeah I essentially agree yeah it could be right but you get don't get points for it because I don't know I don't know how to be able to this universe doesn't have a me well how do you know that because I've looked and because I never dream a lot of people can't even remember their dreams why is this a measuring stick and you can't afford it sorry uh oh Cinema you might have made a big error here a slim finish I guess yeah in every Universe for another version of you all right all right okay yeah I think does he get like that's inaccurate then well the second half is accurate You couldn't possibly have checked that's not something you could possibly know is what he's saying hold up filing from account for the uh the rule that this film establishes that dreams are direct connections to parallel universe versions of you which he did acknowledge um but it looks like he's saying the fact that people can't remember their dreams is is a reason why that's not uh from her point of view it's not enough reality right that's our world not this crazy Marvel world where apparently your dreams are direct connections well yeah but I'm sure they still forget their dreams in this universe uh I mean people can forget their dreams but they don't forget that they have dreams right like people no that's that's the part I was gonna zero in on is the yeah just because people don't remember them they often they're very fully aware of it I think I would know if I've never dreamed no because people know what dreams are and I think that they would understand like wait why do people talk about dreams when I've never had one ever in my life however white people know they're colorblind it's it's not like I still think it's [ __ ] but even if I didn't because apparently there are people who don't dream so if if I were a person who would never dreamed I wouldn't then assume from what strangers said that I'm the only American Chavez uh was this before or after how does she know that dreams oh this is after they've established it but I still don't I don't know I don't buy that that's good enough if he said to me dreams or or so whoever says dreams are a way to look into your other realities it's like oh I don't dream so I guess I'm the only one of me it's like I don't think I don't think we can assume that yeah so that would give us zero points then right I think or are you or do we think that this is an accurate criticism of America Chavez the interesting thing is if you knock out a lot of people can't even remember their dreams if you knock that out this is a one point it just looks like that's hit one of his cause like there's a foundation for the argument but I think I assume it's more than just that I got much again I got you now it still leans to the side of a point because it of the head you remove a lot of people can't remember their dreams it's just I don't have dreams why is that your metric for whether you exist in other multiverses and then he does say you can't have checked every nook like that on its own is a there's a point um yeah I I'm leaning to giving them a point on this um yeah I'm leaning towards a point you know I am leaning to a point as well okay I'll give you however give him the point before we press I wanna someone in chat said Loki established different universes are created by choices the question is why would that cause the universe to look cartoony um well it could be that the diversions could be at the bit point of the Big Bang Yeah like go all the way back to maybe even before creation and that this choice is being made yeah are there choices being made at that point we have to go good faith right you have to assume the Marvel Universe the way it's created we have no idea how it was created so we have to just opt to go okay apparently that's possible I don't think it contradicts anything necessarily it's like insane theoretical you know [ __ ] yeah we're in the realm of insane Theory but I guess under those crazy rules whether you've abandoned reason and all of it's yeah it's it's um I would happily call it like lazy it's just like lazy in the sense that they're like we want a quick route to getting some cool visuals and it's like I guess you can do that sure in the same way that Multiverse is lazy it's like I want to have access to these characters but they're dead okay we'll just go to the Multiverse [ __ ] you okay it kind of possibly checked every nook of every Universe for another version of you the three in most universes actually hey right you didn't pay for that how the [ __ ] did 838 Ash not know that America had walked off with a pizza bowl without paying for it somewhere else Pizza bowls lying around for people to pick up or does he prepare them for each customer like a normal vendor maybe for himself because I can understand someone saying that we just have to think for five seconds he could have them prepared he could have them prepared as an example like this you can buy you know and then he looked the other way while she grabbed it that's a zero he's a vendor he has one it's a pretty uh decent connection to make and it might have been his Michael stop in a few minutes about three weeks the guy asked America to pay for her pizza balls and because he insulted you a little bit you cursed him to punch himself for three weeks which is gonna put this vendor out of business I'm glad you think this is hilarious what a fool he is to not counter the upcoming [ __ ] slurry of comments saying it's reference to Evil Dead idiot wait I know yeah I know it was evil demons making him do that and the evil dead and here it's Doctor Strange yeah why the fire you make no evil demons uh yeah you get a point absolutely very accurate replay your significant memories this really isn't how memories work each time we recall something we are literally recreating the events on our head it isn't like a Blu-ray player this rendition is just as likely to be filled with our own biases and false Recollections and if anything we'll just end up compounding them oh agreed oh yeah yeah yeah yeah there were there were several ways to break down how stupid this is he's chosen one that I think is valid so yep yeah yeah absolutely that's accurate yeah you you took you could have taken many shots you took one and you hit it so I feel like this technology would be way too easy to abuse or misuse oh he's still going you just know movies would immediately adopt it as a lazy way to give us Exposition about where's this damn it yeah neat way of delivering that too oh yes it is yeah good on you for the bit of artistry and craftsmanship there good job for this doctor strange would be amazing it's [ __ ] is the same video where we had zero points for that one okay wait we don't have time for the yeah like Doctor Strange is correct and then you saying he's good at CinemaSins implies that you're saying that he is correct to criticize her for doing this but that would be a point to the film's favor not against it yeah we don't have time that's how the layers here get confusing sometimes Doctor Strange would be amazing that's a zero you know this doctor strange mate not the one from the first movie but uh he'd do it way better but this doctor's stranger backwards you lost his streak again combo break Oh no you're curious by now no Ultra kill for you how does a portal open up behind America's parents and in front of America in this memory but every other portal that's open in this movie has opened behind America convenient superhero loses their parents storyline is convenient now that's not that doesn't seem like a point to me but why so in two instances it opens behind her and one instance is opens in front of her so it seems like we don't know enough to establish any kind of pattern I'm trying to think of all the times it opens up so once you punched under the prologue well you can't count any of the times where she has full control over it all right behind in the prologue behind when they travel into different universes and in front here so that's that's three times right yeah that's like flipping a coin three times and being like how the [ __ ] did I get a heads when I had two tails there is not a pattern to go off yeah I think that's wrong is what unless they would they'd have to explain why it appears behind her and then it randomly appears in front of her for no reason that's what they'd have to do but because we're just going purely off description you opting for a negative one left ringy and and then of course because someone in a chat saying it's convenient it's not convenient all three of them get sucked through the portal so it doesn't change anything that's actually true yeah how come they landed in different places if they got sucked into the same portal uh well it's crazy I don't know the way the portals work it does seem like they're they're going like boom boom boom boom boom so if you get sucked in and then someone else gets sucked in a few seconds later I can buy that they end up in different places one yeah well inaccurate and unfair I think it does qualify yeah which is interesting because what I first heard him said I was like oh is that a point that I was like no another thing why wouldn't it show us what happens after America goes through the portal so this universe yeah yeah is that everyone dresses monotone the cities are decorated with an abundance of foliage and the traffic light colors are flipped imagination I mean I'm giving him a point I don't [ __ ] Twitter hated that one but it's true it's so true Rwanda has the ability to conjure demons and monsters to attack America in other universes on the surface this is one of the most worthless Powers I can think of unless you were writing the script to Doctor Strange too conveniently doesn't know how to use their multiversal powers to drive the plot it's a very specific thing that you could do I can attack alternate versions of you in different dimensions so take that yeah through monsters not even me doing it it is a very very specific power that you have and no one would know if you're lying or not people would just assume you're lying they're like you can't do that it has I'm gonna kill you in Minecraft energy is that is that a funny zero or is that a one it's a funny zero but I'm feeling funny zero but I could be zero but it is it is kind of a funny thing yeah it is yeah all right A Dream walking sorcerer projects that it's like my power is I can I can emit a Wi-Fi signal but only when there are no phones around you know it's like it's a superpower but it's really useless you know Kinda Yeah their own Consciousness from their Universe into another they may Puppeteer this Unholy document careful here for copyrights playing a lot of the movie yeah and you can pursue their enemies from afar you know just in case their enemies can travel between multiverses Tails all this time these uh that's actually it's it's kind of interesting because there is a point there remember that like people can't just travel the Multiverse freely like that's not possible so it's no well well according to doctor strange one that's the problem there unless you know Spider-Man is Peter Parker so like what is the nature of like dream walking is it a thing that would even exist if people can't travel the Multiverse like what does it even mean to have that ability I guess it's almost like this is like the dark hole that lets you do all of these different things and also ability4621-b is that it lets you do this but until now it's never been useful or applicable in any way and someone oh like wow guys guys did you read page 491 there's actually a power that the dark hole gives you that is so specific it helps us in this particular plot multiversal anthropology that's about it up until this point I'd say that's fair to give them a point for that like I don't know if I want to give him a point I'm not sure do we wanna do we wanna put like a do you want to put like a little um like a little tick by the the score screen and next time he gets a maybe a point we add them together and he gets a point five we ain't doing those just because there isn't an apparent utility for something doesn't mean that it's not something that could be like possible well is the idea that it's insanely um like convenient that this power is a useful one in this kind of a plot um I mean I feel like you could make that argument in a lot of instances for something that's like a hyper specific utility is it the situation that rises that you would use it I don't I think it's not convenient necessarily because it's the book that got her on America's Trail in the first place right and like it's all and it's a book that you need to use to like even do dreamwalking anyway you can't I think you could argue with this connection is the convenience the invention of this book for this plot that it just allows her to do these things I but how is it convenient it's inconvenient it's like the thrust for all of the drama of like for the whole film well it's I guess it's extremely convenient for Wanda I guess like I mean I that's that seems strange as like an observation it's a book that's evil and it makes you evil and it creates all of the conflict in the film like find a way to get a thing that she wants as was set up by the show but she only really wants it because she was reading it right like that's the thing that the like it's [ __ ] with their brain making her evil so she like I guess are you saying that the dark holder is convenient like its very existence is convenient I if you have Wanda I think you might want to say coincidental rather than convenient right I guess um yeah I think so yeah it's really convenient for her because that is a fundamental thing about a lot of this that we've talked about before that people don't like as a criticism but it's true for example you know Spider-Man will happen to be in the same city as all these other people doing these insane things that generate them into villains like the dark hole itself is in the same universe as all the Infinity Stones and same Universal that you know all the crazy magic fantasy [ __ ] that's all if we build up the idea that Wanda wants to be with her kids and she can't and then she finds the dark hold that gives her the ability to dreamwatch and the story where that was happening because she got it in one division that didn't happen like between movies that was like did well it whether she like even if she starts off like having it because she got it at the very end the power of the dark hold was it that she was able to pound a dreamwalker in this movie added in and so are you saying what a [ __ ] coincidence that the dark hole let you do that when that's exactly what she needs the dark hole just happens to have this insanely specific power that will allow her to get what she wanted from the other uh from the other show I think that's fair to say because there's no reason to assume the dark hole would have the ability to DreamWork in it that's a very it's it's so insanely specific to the multiversal stuff and it allows her to track a person that they invented for this movie who's a Nova person that of which there's only a Nexus individual of which there is only a single one so that she can use that specific power to find this very specific person with their specific power so that she can get the thing that she wants what I will say is one division does kind of it literally the post credits where you hear the sound of her children's voices I think there's an implication the dark hold is a direct connection to like multiversal stuff and so then is it okay to assume it might have an ability to use slash effect of the multiverses in it or like resurrect them from the dead or to make them real or it's it this is one of those weird ones fine with giving this a zero or a one because I do think there's this level of like you know the eye roll how many things of convenience line up for you that allow the coincidences to meld so that we can invent things to make this one particular power useful to have a plot that relies on it very specifically uh I'm not gonna I want I I think I've you know said my piece I think I I would personally big deal yeah I'm on a zero for this one I I shouldn't do this but I really want to abstain I'm not sure I'm not decided all right for a little bit I don't know what we're talking about to be honest all right meme it's up to you sorry oh for God's sake I don't I don't know I'm lost I'm so lost I'm Gonna Roll it again I'm Gonna Roll it again and then I'm just gonna decide from there okay let's just yeah they may Puppeteer this Unholy doppelganger and pursue their enemies their enemies can travel between multiverses Tails all this time peace well let it let us also consider another element where this applies very specifically to a a Nexus individual because they can travel themselves between the multiverses and still be like themselves and they're the only one so if you were trying to use this power on literally anyone else in the cosmos you'd be attacking a different version of that person that wasn't your actual Target so I think that adds another layer of like this is a power that would literally only be useful against America Chavez like I I'm not going to even say America and someone else literally only America Chavez does this spell actually the Scarlet Witch is a Nexus being two so she used it on herself it was I'm just joking um so I think uh that's an interesting I was gonna say I think so I think I think this is like the card in your YouTube deck that are specifically supposed to counter one specific card in all of you yeah and that extended to Infinity how insane it is that you know you have the one spell that counters the one literal individual across the cosmos which is weird you think the darkhold would have her actual name in it written because she's the only one but um someone said that's not the point he made technically he did I don't know if he meant to because he says just in case their enemies can travel between Multiverse is the implication of the statement is there is only one person who can do that it's America Chavez that's according to the film [Laughter] it's a goddamn miracle that Wanda survives more than five seconds without immediately Catching Fire [Music] so the thing about the camp I thought he was going to go the direction of how she set them up all the time just like magic can answer that um but then like it's a miracle she's not getting set on Fires like um why their candles are they an essential part of the ritual I don't [ __ ] know but that's you know uh whether or not if it's only for funnies then it wouldn't matter it's just a zero but I don't think there's any validity to that um good it may be the Scarlet Witch the dreamwalking explanation is a little confusing because mordo talks about the Scarlet Witch possessing demons in other universes that track since we've seen two demons attacking America in this movie but the movie's ultimate rule is that the dreamwalker can only possess the alternate versions of themselves so how is she possessing demons or even Conjuring them why isn't there a spell where she can just go to another Universe by herself I think they're not the same thing yeah yeah I'm pretty sure those are two different spells be able to because or control or command a demon to go I'm pretty yeah I'm pretty sure she can summon a demon in another universe or she can take control of herself in another universe but she cannot take control of anyone else in the universe or travel to it with the dark old I'm pretty sure that is consistent throughout the whole movie I think you know his movies this is literally my pick for worst movie of all time and I'm trying to I think they stick to that so yeah I think that's a zero yeah I guess the uh yeah she would have to take control of a demon in another dimension yeah okay uh she said she summons a demon that does her bidding in a different dimension how does the demon get America back to her that was that was a that's a point that's something that they never address that's a good question actually Scarlet Witch possessing demons I mean he hasn't brought up yet he could he could get that he could snatch that extra point he hasn't done it yet that track since we've seen two demons attacking America in this movie but the movie's ultimate rule is that the dreamwalker can only possess the alternate versions of themselves so how is she possessing demons or even Conjuring them why isn't there a spell where she can just go to another Universe by herself and uh just to address that last bit it's just like it's more so for funnies I assume because it's just well there isn't and it's up to them what spells are in the dark hold I guess it can give a sorcerer whatever I [ __ ] hate that book if I push their enemy seriously if you're not wouldn't uh shouldn't um mordo here be really like should he be kind of startled that it was even brought up the book of vishanti if it's only thing if it's only something the sorcerer Supreme knows about or maybe in this rule the rules are completely different on who gets knowledge of the book of the thing yeah it could be countless reasons why this strange knows something vague about it you know is I don't feel like there should be more of a recognition of you you mentioned that book like the idea that it's a very even in this universe it's a very special and secretive thing you know that probably would have helped if he was almost like startled by like how do you know about that not even going to try to describe it in a way that doesn't seem immensely convenient let's call it mcguffin's Big Book of sorcerer mcgovernry by m m McGuffin and just own that it is it's pronounced McMuffin but okay um I think that's fair he's basically just saying about how [ __ ] convenient it's like yep yep this is the win button we need to go press it don't worry it's entirely dissimilar to the other win button at the center of the universe quote unquote that grants any wish to anyone or whatever it's not one maximoff who threatens our reality it's the two of you except you literally just explain the very specific ways that Wanda could pick up this free album true you got a point absolutely yeah it's so [ __ ] stupid Moto's like oh yeah she's coming and she can do it this way cool anyway you guys we need to sort you out not here to catch up I think yeah wins is in trouble this is gonna be tough oh wins I'm not uh I'll say it so far since is having a pretty good show over the best video we've seen from sins actually ironically I think that's correct yeah I knew this would give him good fodder for his very interesting system and he hasn't well he's he's not too disappointing so far yeah sins is doing all right and only the only thing it took was the literal worst movie ever made [Laughter] all right what was in that team I actually I mean I don't make fun of I don't I don't make fun of five-year-olds for not hitting the you know the ball off the tee I guess so yeah go ahead blame Doctor Strange quite a bit for trusting this T was there a need for tea couldn't you have just declined the T that you don't know who to trust from the Wanda encounter are you ever aware of the situation correct Stephen Strange is one of the smartest [ __ ] characters in all Universe the fact that you just drink tea because why not is [ __ ] in a different universe don't trust anything bro what if it's just what if it's not only it's poisoned or whatever it's just like oh maybe there's something in there that my University yeah it's gonna [ __ ] yourself so furiously that you just die or something yeah the tea in this universe is made out of like poison or something like that yeah it's natural like you don't go to other universes and just start eating everything you know people are saying that we should uh next time do one where we cover like a good movie you know like a really good movie to try and balance it and see what happens which I'm totally on board with I was even gonna suggest we could do uh who's literally doesn't say that yeah yay that could be interesting because that would really give wins an easy Edge compared I think yeah I think so also have you it's it I think what happened is that it was like in heavy rain where the button prompts were switched around on Doctor Strange and that's why he drank the tea it's like an obscure reference only three people will get it but I had to get it out I'm gonna pretend like I got it yeah no nice job yeah yeah high five yeah hi Rooney sure it's crazy yeah all right yeah there was a point there ever aware of the situation [Music] irony sure that's just a funny you know it's a zero I think um yeah yeah uh yeah I think so it's a little funny yeah it's creepiest Harry Potter trying to photograph and creating an ocean and a coffee mug of anything to do with possessing an alternate version of yourself um fair to say but you can just justify by saying you see weird [ __ ] when someone takes control of you that's all yeah like I I agree that it doesn't seem to be like an intuitive extension of the spell but I guess it's just that's how it works I guess creepy stuff happens Tommy or Billy says this instead of asking hey why are the lights flickering why did you smash those two bowls and why I don't remember that any of that's actually happening I don't know yeah I mean the balls would have shattered right or is she holding if she dropped them they must have hit the floor at least or maybe she's still holding them no she's clearly not holding them right so yeah yeah the balls had to go somewhere I assume so I think that's exactly would this be correct point but incorrect bookings or fair enough to say correct um I think yeah what yeah it's like well something happened to the Bulls who either drop them or they shattered or well if they shatter from getting tossed onto the thing they'll probably break from the floor so that's what I'm saying yeah give them a point yeah I think so I think that's fair enough the kids should have known something weird there yeah how did you just stare at the camera that you shouldn't know is there that's nothing there's nothing yeah I'm sorry buddy it's okay [Music] so wait a couple of minutes ago you were arguing about the 2003 Tigers and calling each other doofuses with various Googleplex multipliers and in the short time it took Wanda to get possessed you've come up with this lame song about ice cream they want ice cream the kids they may have come up with this before it's come on dude whatever I was a child once I I came up with many strange things in very short amounts of time that's a zero yeah zero what an amazing moment for the Scarlet Witch to get in some mom time almost immediately she is being she's in the house with her kids she will have them all the time and it's more than likely she's doing something with the kids all the time yeah yeah yes also zero I like you're at school it's night time they're they're home could that go further than zero or is it a zero zero I think zero I'm happy with Justice is that unfair is what it was this criticism unfair well it's like um if you thought about it for even a second surely you would conclude that it's very likely she'll be doing something at this time with her kids it's gonna be a it's gonna be a high likelihood they live in the same house oh and she's a full-time mom as far as I know in this universe oh yeah I could see a point there [Music] I I landed on zero just for any reference [Music] nice emotional blackmail well you got nothing for that it's a zero again that's a clear-cut zero it's a little pun oh all right this is here we go oh we skip the dark hole being destroyed Sorcerers who have always died in the attempt to stop Wanda isn't the whole point put their lives on the line and make sure she can't [ __ ] up the Multiverse that feels like a different point which is why did you tell her yeah it's like it's part of the point there is that element of like they died to stop her from getting the dark hold and he's like lol there's a copy um like I guess like I I'll I'll have all of the I'm willing to sacrifice in essence everyone here at kamertage to stop you but these three guys behind me that's where I draw the line um I I think that's totally fair to say though because the thing is here I just I formatted the criticism much different than this like this is you know the idea that he's like could you allow hundreds of people to die to stop it from doing a thing but then could you deal with people getting tortured right in front of you those are very different experiences um and they can make you go like I give up I can't I can't deal with the screams that's the thing it's not entirely like but yeah the [ __ ] up part was that he gave her the clue he never should have given her any clues you should have just said like what do you mean there is no other that that was the dark old woman you destroyed it what do you mean what do you mean there's another one there is no other one that's all you have to do yeah I still think this is worth a point um but I feel like this is also like yeah you made a point you could have like you could have had like five and this is not the best one that could be made I still think it's accurate it's just a to me his criticism is Wong is giving in here uh because people are getting tortured when he's already had hundreds of people dies like those are different experiences to have to deal with as a human why I'm not included yeah the criticism I think it should be the one gave the clue which is not quite what he's saying anything yeah as any rational person would as if you to the dozens of sorcerers who have already died in the attempt to stop Wanda because like saying it's a [ __ ] you to all of them I could even agree with that but it's not criticism if he said it was out of character which seems to be the implication like I don't know that we can say that um I think Wong would be susceptible to having Sorcerers tortured in front of him to give information it's just information you didn't have to [ __ ] give nobody knows it's true except him isn't the whole point to put their lives make sure she can't [ __ ] up the Multiverse our universe is 838 and we've designated yours 616. I I have curiosity maybe he'll say in a second why would you call your Universe anything other than one yeah yeah it's it's really weird isn't it because in any manner in which they're discovering other universes they need to start labeling and surely this would just have to be one or even zero I guess but one seems like the so we've designated yours like so I guess they know of 600 or at least 800 yeah I don't know why you started that number one and when we find another that'll be two could be there is some form of signature to the universes that they have somehow ordered and it ended up providing these numbers in some [ __ ] way it is like not impossible that it could end up that way I just it is weird and I'm not gonna I yeah I apparently I didn't have to go to the Internet for this one but outright saying that the MCU takes place on Earth 616 is such a hard choice that makes it the same universe that the most well-established Marvel Comics are set in instead of making it its own distinct Universe which would have been the perfect way to maybe satisfy some fans who wonder why so many events play out differently compared to the comics they love you because if they had said this is 615 then they're acknowledging almost that 616 is the comic universe and that it could be traveled to in this universe wow yeah I guess the question is like how does this uh because I'm pretty sure that uh across the spider verse explicitly references the MCU universe as like as the correct number correct yeah yeah well so you have to canonize I guess the [ __ ] Regina George over here is an idiot she read it wrong or she's she's mislabeled it that's what you have to assume I will default to miguelo hero in this one I don't know like I like the I like the thing but I don't know if it's Point worthy in terms of it being more of a meta thing why didn't they do this comic book you know well I think it might be more than meta because of the fact that if if we're accepting that all the universes coexist Comics whatever else and then this movie says this is labeled this the same as the comics it's like oh you [ __ ] that up that can't be true I guess what if Kevin feige says it's different continuity completely including the Multiverse fundamentally different continuity has he said any of that in the movie is that in the movie at all well yeah but like what if you've never heard of the comics at all like what how does that have any bearing on like your observations about like bear in mind I don't like this Choice yeah but I could say what if you've never watched any of the other MCU movies like it's on you to watch that if they're a part of the universe but know that information yeah but like what what is the conclusion that we're drawing here that there's like some error in the this universe is called she's mislabeled them it can't be that way because they couldn't coexist because they have different continuities that would have to be the conclusion um I mean spider verse has basically made it so that that's true right uh was part of us says it's a different spider verse says that it is part of yeah what I'm I guess I'm arguing is spider versus said something that makes way more sense and is therefore like this I guess it's teachering literally on meta to actual in content criticism yeah um it's a very illogical Choice grand scheme wise because he framed it as though it's a it's a fan related thing that would have been nice as opposed to like an any kind of contradiction in universe so maybe that would make it a zero because he hasn't even contextualized it further than that maybe what we think chat how's everyone feeling on this one zero one I would guess that a lot of people are going to go with one on this one they would for how they feel about it I'm just curious if we get any zeros yeah that's the thing like I feel a one but I don't think it lines up with actually getting a point uh by the criteria but it's something like I'm glad it's in the you know it's in his video it's an interesting thing to you know you've talked too long and I don't care uh Cinemas fans are in the chat now uh ones and zeros oh hello hi uh we're grading your boy yeah don't worry we got we got we're gonna get pissed off even more people with the wins one I'm pretty sure he's liked more than uh since so uh that's okay just you wait but get over it since it's so split in chat let's just do the vote left to right fringing what have we got uh I think I'm going with the zero I'm gonna go with zero myself well I'm next uh I I feel a zero as well my heart says one but my brain says zero I was basically gonna say that so what rag said all right zero it is zero it is but good for being I good on you for putting in the video it was yeah yeah quick reminder just because it doesn't count as a point doesn't mean it shouldn't be in the video it's just a whether or not it's a sin against the movie is it a movie is failed or not it's the question and if he's saying it would have been nice for fans if you had said there were difficulties with the comics that's not really that's not really a sin on the movie's part as as we understand it's criticism to work it's like if we get to the uh wait get to the Illuminati what make your appointment sorry I was I was no no I I was like I wasn't looking at the screen when I said that I was just thinking I don't know I had a lot of thoughts like when we get to the Illuminati part and he says like why the [ __ ] did you choose to do this ding like I was like yeah I get it like isn't it insane that this is what they did but I guess it's not actually uh yeah we need more you know which is funny right 100 like yeah if we're great in anybody including ourselves if we simply said that's overtly stupid and then we moved on it's like well yeah that wouldn't be a point defense play out differently compared to the comics they love you guys are going to this coldest place and you don't want to bring warmer clothing no I get it your costumes are rad and all but they can't be providing that yeah you're freezing extreme weather correct I agree yeah there's a point correct even acknowledge that people are gonna be like this is a cool costume right then you could freeze in your costume yeah boss up there my magic can only take us so far masters of the Mystic Arts were invented pausing for safety but [ __ ] this stupid [ __ ] too I wonder what he'll say try to find the Forbidden grounds of Wonder core no but they should take you right to their doorstep so what's the [ __ ] difference I Point hmm I'll give him a point for that one I'm I'm thinking what's the this is almost like let's say that you have a dark you have a dark magical castle and it exudes this force that prevents magic at one point that no effect is going to it only prevents sling ring attack that's it yeah suddenly prevents magic is fine everything else is bad so you can just do the thing that uh motto what's yeah that's his name wrong Which flies up there with them using their magic yeah but that's witchcraft not sorcery oh well he uses sorcery later don't worry about it exactly yeah he is a sorcery later um so I'm just looking at his point but they sure as [ __ ] take you right Doctor Strange flies up there using sorcery yeah that's the thing like uh I I I'm trying to figure out how the point he's making works with what's I'm assuming the movie I thought where you're gonna go would be that if they made this this barrier how far would it go what would be the reason why would you expect it to go that's that's kind of what I was thinking thinking like if his point is well it allows portals an inch past its influence it's like yeah but that's not a point against it right it has to the effect has to end somewhere and at that point you can use portals that doesn't mean this is why it's useless there is a viability to the augment because like if you said it covered the whole planet it'd be like well okay I guess but it's like that's [ __ ] useful yeah it's still gonna do that so it like covers the whole Mountain it's like oh okay that yeah I can understand it's like covers most of the top of the mountain like um it depends of this place and you having to like travel through mundane means to get to the top of the mountain that's actually quite an obstacle but well without having the source this is this is the problem I think that you should be like this is dumb as [ __ ] it only blocks out sling ring that's it that's stupid but because you can use so many other ways to get up there that involve either sorcery or witchcraft or magic whatever but CinemaSins is specifically saying uh why the [ __ ] did it block only up to here which you know I think it's funny um I'm not sure it's entirely stupid like you'd want this rather than not having it you know you know yeah like I get this point and I think there's a validity to it but I want to know what he's like where do his dots connect exactly and what exactly he's trying to say because I think he would say it should be the whole Mountain not just the [ __ ] top of it um I I'd have to see like how far away it is but even then the problem is like what if the [ __ ] demon that did this said like I can't that's I can't do that I could only do this much I did the most I could definitely the limits of what its power is is that it you can't like it's not like they choose to like oh okay we have a a 500 meter one kilometer two kilometer barrier line it might just be this is just what it is it's not like a choice for how far it goes this is just an effect of the the of Wonder Gore um I don't I still don't know what to what do you think about all that thingy how you feeling um I mean I I uh I understand all of that but I guess I still default back to yeah it seems like really stupid that it only blocks you to the point that you're like basically right there but not right right there that just seems dumb would you opt to have that on there uh rather than not though um I mean I guess so but it seems like a distinction without a difference really like I guess I would but like it means fuckle because if it really worked as if like this is as close as you can portal to it and now what I did where he made a staircase like you'd make a little magic steps and just walk over there it's like what's the difference like if you're trying to block Magic users you've done it's actually yeah yeah um the big thing in my head is I completely agree with all those arguments I just I don't know if the it's fair to say this is the nature of the spell this is how far I can make the barrier I'm putting it on because I may as well put it on why would I not put it on it's better than not putting it on that's the only thing I could defend the great demon that did this okay um I think I'm more inclined to say it's valid on sinspa I think I'm giving it a one yeah I think it's the one yeah I'm on board with the one the ones have it don't even need to watch the other two I'll get a wrecked democracy attracted planes about not being able to portal straight to the place but then simply flies there so there was no reason for her to be upset about this and absolutely no reason to preempt our probable sin about it I mean uh it's it's like a nitpick on her part though you like we can't just go straight up there it's like no it doesn't let us like fine I guess we'll just you know what I mean like it would be kind of annoying but like it's nothing it's what I'm trying to say is that she is in Universe being a bit of a [ __ ] right so yeah it's not exactly out of character or anything it's just I could see someone saying it if once you show up the portal opens and you look at the spooky castle and it's all the way over there in the next mountain peak you would ask like why haven't we why did you go here and not up there like I think that's pretty reasonable for her to ask yeah I I think it's fair she says something what's going on here how come we're not there this isn't the portal also before we walk through but zero down some ancient demon around to the point of not allowing sorceros to teleport up here but still allow them to use spells like whatever this Shield is and begin to think either Wong or the movie is just making this up as they go yeah correct I mean the best steel man or [ __ ] defense you could possibly come up with this yeah well that's all he could do the great demon he said like oh you can't use the sling rig but I can't stop him from using anything else it's just like that sounds stupid I don't see how that works at all wouldn't it just be a blanket sorcery why is it all these sling Rings why don't they use the runes from One Division just like a general diminishment of sorceries like we can't use portals we can use some spells but they're weaker like there's like a the closer we get to it the less effective our magic gets so like we can use a little bit but you know you can't use the big stuff no so many cat heads or you know things like that Juju why not God remember all this is not necessary you gotten a point for that I'll give a point for that yeah that was really [ __ ] stupid the the best events you have is that she's trying to intimidate him she hates him but there's nothing there it makes no sense for her to hate him so I can't I what I guess I'm trying to say is introduce argument argument has no [ __ ] validity at one point one point yep Captain Marvel Reed Richards hey she has a face I don't like it so it's the terrific three now or the wait I guess what is that team oh um the just gosh God great three the triumphant you'll hear the cheers in the theater but I honestly think the scene will come to be seen as the worst Christmas ever imagine you get every single present on your list even the limited edition ones the ones that no one else liked or the ones that were murdered by franka Johnson and resurrected by Brian Singer all of them you get to play with them for a while but the next day your parents hide all the presents in the basement and don't tell you when you're next able to play with them then instead of hiding all the presents in the basement the parents burn them all in front of their sobbing kids okay so the point the spirit of the point is they presented a whole bunch of [ __ ] fads wanted and then they killed them all yeah um that's more meta I'm afraid but it's funny it is it's a bit more metal I like the point I sympathize with it immensely I didn't want to see another [ __ ] uh Captain Marvel I didn't want to see uh the her as um Captain America the other ones were neat it was neat to see um you know Patrick Stewart he was like give it a point I think it's funny it is good and I I like this video but I don't think it's it's not anything it's just yeah these characters are here that they got killed that's not that is an accurate observation and I share and how stupid this was as a decision but um it doesn't get a point right now I'm so sorry we didn't give it six one six we can't give it this it's kind of oh my God kind of in the same thing yeah hit a guy here there oh guys shark in the 60s the strangest Choice the MCU ever made was to bury that post endgame movie which explained how the spirit of Tony Stark transferred itself into Doctor Strange's body really would help to explain why he's suddenly full of one-liners and quippy insults [Music] well they were having back and forth in Infinity War weren't they they were um I I mean it wasn't this [ __ ] [ __ ] but the the general sense of it was there I think I think this is like part of his character I don't know that I would argue that he never gave wippy one lines or insults I'm pretty sure he was quite insulting I think the point here is that the quips are [ __ ] yeah that would be a good point yeah yeah I think that's they're out of character they're just [ __ ] they're terrible zero yeah it's like it's not yeah for me doing a bad bit you're like well I mean this isn't like wrong it's just [ __ ] alrighty Captain Marvel defender of the cosmos I think you mean 007 but it's possible that in a Multiverse that Lashana Lynch is just playing multiple alternate versions of characters who will only have that title briefly before it's taken away for five seconds oh yeah zero but funny uh hold up I need what video just died versions of characters oh I accidentally hit the back button on my mouse okay and it like it kept the watch together but it went back to the Llama video we'll review it one day guys don't worry yeah but um yeah yeah but we're good yeah all right take it away I'm sure black bolts need for silence is a big part of his character but shouldn't that be Reed Richards who desires this to be a quiet place [Music] incursion occurs when the boundary between two universities destroying one or both entirely information you literally can't have like how could you know that does your Universe been destroyed yeah you can say one Universe maybe the one you visited but how would you know both there's no way no way yeah you'd have to have like Universe detecting magic or technology in order to know that the conjunction of the Spheres happened or whatever and they're like oh our reality in there is just bumping up against each other but not like a physical way but sort of not really but kind of if you don't think about it your alternate self created the Illuminati to make difficult decisions that no one else could so the Illuminati was created to prevent threats to the Multiverse but how the hell are they achieving that if there are only six of them five of whom are largely based on Earth no one behind this movie seems to be comprehending how big one universe is that's an MCU problem yeah wait so sorry I kind of missed the what is he saying like who sang like how were you even equipped to deal with multiversal threats like if there's only five of you because I yeah I remember this we've definitely discussed this it's the then the nature of it is that if people arrive and claim they're from a different Universe they put them in the little Cube which is so stupid for so many reasons they're like we can't let you out of that Cube you might have infections it's like you've already walked them through the facility and put them in the what do you and that what are you gonna do with like the Hulk well Thanos he comes through like a big difference so this uh I think this is a point then yes I know the comics in this movie yeah because they have the opportunity to do more right it's one of those yeah if they weren't able if you didn't have like Captain Marvel and the magic spells to do everything like that you know you're trying it's good that you tried you know it's better than not trying but um so the problem here is that there's not just five of them it's the whole facility it's like sure but um I think that would be counted by what we are shown of how they deal with other Universal threats is hilarious and stupid even though there's a [ __ ] like if they had left it completely to our imagination it probably wouldn't be a point but the fact that we saw it like he would it's like he's made the point there exists a counter but there exists a very good counter to that counter therefore the point still stands I think that's worth a point that's how that works for us on the word infinite it should be nearly a countless number of strangers Wanda's and hey maybe some non-humans attempting that's actually also valid that uh if strange isn't an axis being y on this [ __ ] thousands of strangers here with this this strange this strange should be peeling off loads of strangers you know and all of those strangers should be invested in America Chavez who is an access being apparently and so all of them would come to her the strangers would be interested in other strangers which by the way was a suggested ending I think that we made on our coverage we said that could have been a cool finale like millions of different strangers from multiverses coming in to fight wander altogether that could have been fun yep that could have been fun oh why the [ __ ] is every futuristic High Court set up this way oh wait so that's that's a point right I think so yes yes I'm expecting the multi-face judge from Transformers the movie to render a verdict in this scene reference really yeah yeah yeah does some Scarlet Witch tries to turn this wall into a white dude can you not boy sorry hang on was that a separate thing I'm going to understand that it was a joke I Wong into a white yeah I was just trying to check if that was a dangerous yeah you get no points like an Undead yeah it's it's a it's a clever little thing but it's not a dude can you not portal I don't remember taking a sling ring after you portal to this place you so best faith analysis is that you literally can't portal you can use all your other sorcery so if we go with that then yeah you can't portal I guess it seems to be with the movie is displaying yeah to worship Wanda when she arrive and I know you said some [ __ ] I think we didn't we highlight a meme eventually that he is shown to have it but it goes it just goes off his hand at some point I feel like we're missing the point he can't portal no we highlighted that point I'm talking about a different one now okay yeah um I'm thinking it's either some kind of continuity error or you're supposed to believe that Wanda poofed it like she did with Dr strangers randomly at some point that's probably the best thing you can do with that exactly to wonder core because of some Rune that doesn't mean you can't actually use magic right or portal away from this place or else you wouldn't be able to do the other magic you've been doing well no it's stupid but you have to assume that yeah there's rules for the sling ring and there's not rules for the don't apply to the other sorcery it's [ __ ] that's a negative actually let him finish the sentence [ __ ] get used to it this Bruce Almighty moon is so big I wouldn't be surprised if in this universe the Earth orbits the moon awesome that was a big [ __ ] Moon yeah that was a big Moon the Moon does look bigger in photography a lot of the time so I don't know what do we do with that though is is it fair to say that Moon's bigger than it should look is that fair um it could be an optical illusion I don't know and it's another Universe I don't think I even want to entertain that as potentially being a fair point Moon looks big yeah Universe it's totally possible I guess that the Moon is a lot closer I don't even want to go that far Moon looks big like yeah all right sometimes it does look big zero points but has it ever look that big for me hmm but it's the is it work um you know just in case you forgot that I said that just before the movie cut away to the Wanda Wong show Steve yeah you got a point I think that's fair uh yeah yeah Charles Charles is not someone who's gonna be [ __ ] wasting time with what he says usually even as always chose to go It Alone he turned to the dark hole well not as always he created the Illuminati Chinese okay in hopes that our Salvation might lie in the Multiverse Jesus does everyone get a chance to tell a piece of this story it brought strange in here telling the story of our strange but let's make sure everyone gets a line you know to be fair Also let's rewind this a bit that's a point it's really [ __ ] weird to tell a story that way again everyone seems to get their cues just like the idea like Charles starts it up he's about to continue that someone else starts everybody looks over them like excuse me I'm telling the story yeah it's like yeah I think you know how this has never once happened and ever in the real world this just doesn't happen the way that people do this story yeah no it doesn't you might get away with it with two people but not [ __ ] three bouncing back and forth before how everybody get involved just imagine someone start a conversation like this and it just stops just looks to the other guys like come on guys continue the story one of the guys like I wasn't there what are you talking about tell the story one of them's not really paying attention oh [ __ ] are we at the Thanos playing Tetris he's in the middle of Texas [Music] he tells the first dude the story looks over this all goes uh yeah yeah I agree yeah a minute need to hear that again confused me in hopes that our Salvation might lie in the Multiverse and guess what it didn't wait what okay maybe he didn't find the answer but the solution absolutely exists in the Multiverse because this strain found that [ __ ] one of the 14 million chance you can argue that she used that phrasing to mean he didn't find it not that it doesn't exist at all but I can understand it's clunky as [ __ ] because it sounds like she's saying it doesn't exist in the Multiverse when it totally does all unlimited I would be curious if the [ __ ] stupid book of Ashanti or the the the the in uh what's called eternity I wonder if those things can counter incursions I wonder if you can make a wish that means no more occasions happen I I mean I wish there are no more incursions would that work but I don't see why it wouldn't work I don't see why what it seems to [ __ ] with everything on a fundamental level so nothing more powerful than a wish depending on what the rules are for your magic system so uh so is that a point well we'll let him finish uh [Music] I don't know I uh I'm I'm kind of looking forward Faith are we being to Captain Marvel pretty much yeah it's just dependent on whether or not you think Captain Marvel's just using words to mean something that she didn't quite mean to me so I don't know but if you talk I will say no but I mean if the orthod does like logically just but considering the context she hates their doctor strange and she's saying it as partly an insult to him like of course a [ __ ] didn't idiot like you you and you you destroyed a universe but they did find the book of Ashanti to kill Thanos this Shanty and that doesn't um apply to like Multiverse I'm pretty sure he found that in their own Universe right oh wait no because it's outside of all universes so I guess he must have traveled outside of the universe yeah so she's just [ __ ] definitively wrong [Music] I mean the film seems to think there are [ __ ] right well yes but because I think I don't even know if this is in my video but the fact that she's just said it was the answer to solving this problem isn't in the Multiverse like it actually has to be because the book of Ashanti is outside of your universe so you're just totally she's just totally wrong yeah no I you know what I think we'll give it to him yeah because this strange found that [ __ ] War when Dr Strange was running all those calculations did Crossing multiverses not pop up as one of the possible options was that not the thing about it half the universe wow remember it's crazy [ __ ] because there was one Universe at that time according to I think it's fair this this should have been entertained long ago especially because I'm afraid Doctor Strange introduced the idea of multiverses and so now if you're calling this Multiverse is then he knew about it you can't say he didn't know about it is Doctor Strange one yeah you got to do better you want to explain that you're better for that you never told us the details of what had happened only that you had inadvertently triggered an incursion oh we all know the 838 strange caused an incursion when he tried to help Peter Parker forget he got a B in gym class but that's why he didn't tell his buddies what happened Steve I was that an incursion that's uh I don't even know that's a joke but the best you could say is it's a criticism of no way home which isn't a criticism of this yeah right so I'll be zero zero even renounce the dark holes evil and helped us find the book of Ashanti yeah which Universe was that in hmm that's actually a really really great question now how did you find the book of Ashanti if he wasn't looking in the Multiverse [Music] did he make that portal or was the portal already there did he stumble across it who knows whatever means [ __ ] five hour video and we're still finding criticisms [ __ ] me so two people have said it would be criticism of this because they're not acknowledging the past of that having happened in no way home no they they're not not acknowledging anything they're not that's not anything for them to consider that he did a spell for Peter that's not anything in fact these guys don't even know that oh [ __ ] keeper God feet strange search the Multiverse for an answer before in fact they would know it though if Charles was to [ __ ] read his mind which he never does it would solve all your problems exploring the idea of using an artifact from his own universe that he definitely knew about also [Music] wait what range search the Multiverse for an answer before exploring the idea of using an artifact from his own Universe he definitely [ __ ] knew about it wasn't from his own Universe though yeah this is a [ __ ] criticism because of the information he's interpreted from the film which is inaccurate on the film's part you know what I mean the film is described to him how something works and he's criticized it based on that but the film's not telling you the truth like fully because vashanti's not from their universe would do you think it might be possible that Dr Strange thought that the Hub world was just a part of his Universe at that point well I mean it seems that they understand exactly what the Gap Junction is it's between all universes so I'm assuming he knows that but would he then say that's not the Multiverse that's just uh Universe Plus or something that's not yeah like an extra yeah like a waiting room to the other universes but hmm Universal waiting room it's this is uh this is weird I'm gonna I'm just gonna say it this is weird strange search a Multiverse for an answer before explaining the idea of using an artifact from his own Universe whether it's the implications that he discovered bashanti after the multiversal [ __ ] though it's not like he knew about it and chose not to use it he would obviously have chosen to use it if he knew about it before the Multiverse stuff because that's an automatic win book yep but it's only fair to assume he discovered the information regarding vishanti after he stopped visiting the Multiverse absolutely amazing Lobby is zero I think so the so that means all the Thanos stuff is after he realized that there was a Multiverse yes yes kind of piece to get so he Doctor Strange as being doctor strange but he assembled the Illuminati to fight multiversal threats so the Illumina they were just working together to beat Thanos threat here's what I'm saying the he assembled the Illuminati in order to fight multiversal threats Thanos isn't a multiversal threat but before I mean that makes sense yeah yeah they're here you use them but he used the book of did he use the book of vishanti to to be yes yeah yeah so somehow that caused a fight that they had to like instead of just automatically winning I don't really know how that works either so he used the book of Ashanti at that point realizing there was a Multiverse so like he discovered on the way to fight Thanos that there is a multiversal throw so the the way it goes is dog destroy oh wait you're saying so Thanos arrives doing Thanos things and he starts looking in the Multiverse for a way to stop him correct that's that's that's why he went to the Multiverse in the first place with the dark hold and then he comes to these guys and says I destroyed a universe I can't do multiversal traveling anymore I'll have to find something else he finds a book of Ashanti they use that to beat Thanos I think that's after that they're like You Gotta Die yeah which is all of it is [ __ ] but yes I don't know [Laughter] oh man I'm using an artifact from his own universe that he definitely knew about also yeah I think by the film's logic that's not the case [Music] um our Strange think of using the book of Ashanti okay maybe it was one of the 14 million scenarios that didn't work out but he doesn't know about it is what they say and he certainly doesn't know how to get to it when he finds out about it he finds out about it and I guess he's saying how did he find out about it from the looking into the 14 million it's like well you have to assume he looked into 14 million that didn't know about it either but but there would have been so he would have had to essentially get the coin flip correct 14 million times to where he didn't get universes that knew about it or had it I guess you could say incorrect as in like he got the bad result if only he had found a universe where the book of Ashanti was a thing so he could be like oh oh [ __ ] how do we get that that sounds like it was so full of a problem and it's like yeah you have to get it by doing this this and then he could get it and you know but yeah right now remember he finds out about the book of Ashanti in this film so he didn't know about it from looking at other universes which means he looked in a bunch of universes that didn't know about it or have it that's just where some people would argue that makes sense because the 14 he would have theoretically checked would have been theoretically branches off of his one which and his one doesn't know about it the Wong knows about it Wong does because the sorcerer Supreme gets to know him oh [ __ ] like yeah he's aware universes yeah I was about to say well okay maybe Wong found out about it somewhere he's like no Wong found out about it because he sorced for a supreme that's what they say and also in his little secret book or whatever strange should have known about it it's so [ __ ] hard to keep all this straight it's not a nightmare he would have found out oh I don't know in any way because he was I think it's fair to say he should have known them because Wong knows and wanches you know what was it wasn't wasn't the [ __ ] thing uh they say earlier that strangers didn't know about the secret book with all the secret things in it yeah that's another that's what they said in the movie and it's just absolutely ridiculous yeah because they know they know how stupid it is especially when they say the sorcerer Supreme knows about it I remember [ __ ] talking about this now because it's like it's in a book you can read about it and it's like oh yes Steven strange wasn't known for reading basically every last written word about magic that's not a literal meme from the first [ __ ] film but oh well no that if you give it 14 million read books that were forbidden yep so you tell me that you wouldn't read a book meant for the sorcerer Supreme cool begun our answer he should have known absolutely yeah you didn't look into other universes he looked into the time to see other outcomes that's it's almost a distinction without a difference if they're going to be separated into other universes and would have different results but the fact is Wong would be in all of them by that logic and he knows about it in all of them because he's sorced for a supreme which means strange should know which means all of the extensions including the core of his own timeline should have access to the information that's kind of the problem Doctor Strange should no that's the conclusion yeah but what is he really stupid though because it didn't work out but an artifact you'd have to teach you exactly what you need to defeat your enemy seems like the perfect place to start unless of course it didn't exist until this movie are we giving him a point for that I think yeah before whatever so it's getting real complicated um I think he sort of identified the Nugget of sort of an issue here um should know about it which is why I'm happy to give him a point yeah and I'm not gonna like are we gonna be super tough on people not understanding the mechanics of this is where it gets tough yeah because there's so much to remember and consider about everything everyone's done and all the rules that Michael Waldron said count yeah if he if he sort of grasps that there's like an issue here and he can't quite articulate it I don't blame him at all so I'll give him I'll give him a point for recognizing it something's up all right sadistically shows us a multiversion of Avengers The Age of Ultron why does that's nothing that's a nothing burger with nothing cheese also she should be dead I think but Wanda even entertain the idea of stopping a rampage here America is one room away do we think she has this kind of patience at this point in the game well she doesn't stop she goes through them she does um the thing is up to this point she's been killing those of robots so you can argue that this is still a step further that she wasn't necessarily hoping to take she was she was going to give him a chance and also these guys the sorcerer this is by the way this is part of the argument for why the dark hole doesn't fully corrupt a person it just doesn't she should blast through them if it does yes so if you go with that you know it's a problem either way but I think we're supposed to believe that yes she doesn't really want to kill these people but she will if she has to zero then yeah she does it also it's probably a good idea for her to size up this opposition because they're clearly not like the rest and they're they got special outfits and everything yeah I could do this all day oh man I wish I could give you all of the boys say that line because it's not her line yeah there's an argument you can make for that um yeah that's it's a Steve Rogers line that came from a very specific Steve Rogers an alternate universe Steve Rogers might not at all say that line because there's no reason why she would have developed that line it's it's uh it's silly and it's just it's just you guys trying to do [ __ ] jangly keys yeah but good on you for noticing that it's uh good good on you sighing the dings I like it then one of the handcuffs come loose oh they were created using the sins of the Santi or some [ __ ] but a good hard whack losing some up in no time yes yeah there but boy they sure do let him do the thing he wanted to do it's gonna be so interesting if like there's ever a time where it's something that's been labeled a sin and we've agreed comes up just verbatim the same thing and wins but as a point in favor of the film oh God like he describes it the same way and says this is good I was like wait a minute but the thing is I can't see it I could see it the choice to create a movie where magic and sorcery exist but then literally handcuffing the two most powerful Sorcerers alive so they have to resort to a fist fight instead of all the awesome magic I'm gonna disagree with you on that one there's viability they're gonna make that really cool the idea that they're both so used to sorcery and they're both forced to use hand to hand I think there's a lot of potential with something like that would be cool if they had like no hand-to-handed or training it was just really a really sloppy slide that's a direction you could go it's also cool to see that they both do have expertise yeah absolutely that would be a fun comedic point if they try to use magic or something stops them or prevents them and they have to just sort of get into this awkward Barbarian sort of yeah and they're clearly like they don't know what the [ __ ] they're doing because they don't know how to wrestle why would they know how to wrestle that could be actually kind of fun as you say that could be a direction I even had to clarify because I couldn't remember without re-watching the first dog strange if he did if he gets like fighting training but he does they both presumably have extensive um the only thing that you could say is like well it doesn't that work better as a comparison we don't get to see the magic fight at all it's like yeah that's true yeah but I still think it's it's not automatically a fail to have two great Sorcerers have to fight without their magic no no yeah I'm kind of a relevant example um my um there's a Green Lantern comic called Sinestro core war and uh the way that one is resolved is um they actually de-power um Hal depowers the nestros ring because his Ring's already gone so he um grabbed something to de-power his ring and it's just this gritty slug match on the top of a building and that's um how they defeat him and at the end of that and it's a really um satisfying sequence because one has military training the other guy not as much um so you get to see what happens when these two get into a physical brawl after doing so much crazy like lanterny [ __ ] so yeah it's a cool concept Christine knows exactly how strong these cages are and she's seriously trying to smash them with a [ __ ] fire extinguisher yeah so true so [ __ ] true yeah what a [ __ ] you she built them with other people and she's trying to use a [ __ ] it's yes yes yes one point the maximum the mind is being held hostage by your alternate self oh is that what this white void is with the blown out building and rebar everywhere I know we're creating physical objects to represent abstract Concepts I just I just thought it would look cooler in a witch's brain I'm actually gonna defend the film I like it I think that she's trapped in what Wanda would consider her worst nightmare of her whole life which was under the rubble of her house I kind of like it right You could argue it's like well why is the background all white it's like it's a minimalistic choice I guess I don't know the you know I would consider that a bad thing so yeah I'm gonna get it yeah blank um it's outside of where she's sort of Trapped in a way into it in a way matter um it's not what she's thinking about or focused on oh no Professor X is dead yet again where's Olivia Williams when you need her that's one nothing yes yes a reference to X3 right could have had a point here and Logan as well pun intended how uh how he loses so easily in his area of expertise is right yeah you'd think he would have brought that in but nope because it's literally just I'm gonna sneak up on you and your neck is broken goodbye that's blame like not even the struggle fight or whatever and nothing it's just just over just like that yeah this is the fourth time he's died too on screen and uh this is uh the easily the lamest one is everybody down this tunnel well Christine closes a bunch of hatches and why are there so many hatches in this tunnel anyway I get the immediate sense right now but doesn't they go for a second there I thought he was gonna [ __ ] it up but his sin was that she could have beaten them and she hasn't yet which is true yep why are there so many blast doors in this tunnel like they could be countless reasons for that but uh yeah that's still a valley point they closed the Last Hatch and just stand there for some reason even though they just saw Wanda blast every door on the way here Cinema wins you've got to really bring your A game yeah yeah I have a feeling uh it's not gonna be enough did you kill her no just bought us some time all you've done is buy the time back that you wasted staring at the door a minute ago he's right yep why the [ __ ] did you do that should have killed her um she wrapped herself in telekinesic Shields Rags are you stupid how did you know that very true very specific to me something on the eye right now specific to a u that has been raised and lived in a different Universe you know what as tempting as it is to make this video a two-parter I'm just gonna add a hundred cents here for all the ways without being limited by what hey that's you know and oh I disagree Rags I think that's good uh I'm impressed almost if he has to you say there's a million ways this film Breaks by not understanding how Multiverse or infinite work and that he's not going to list them because I would take way too long well yeah that's why I'm agreeing I thought you were saying no something else no no I I 100 I 100 agree with him so yeah what I'm saying something I'm wondering is so you only get one point for that right um 100 points he's alluded to like a hundred arguments he could make and he would get a point for each of them but he's not making them maybe this is another two at least because I would be happy to give him two yeah and then identified the broader process of the film is highlight in a very real issue it would take a very long time longer than this video currently is to explain all the ways that they [ __ ] that up writing in his narration he could have been doing this all along the way ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding ding this through the whole video and it would have been so I'm happy to give him two points gold star yeah yes this film [ __ ] the space [ __ ] this movie these points were Rags too what kills me hearing all this is how strange said he bought them some time and they waste every second of it admiring the Gap Junction instead of it yeah do your [ __ ] holy [ __ ] oh my God when's the Redemption Arc here in video games man if something's chasing you you don't [ __ ] around you you run and you grab the thing to the point where when you're in a cut scene when your character is limited to walking you're like God damn it guys send doctor strange and Christine to another Universe when you could just kill them yes I guess yes just integrate them they are only a potential issue even if she puts them in a dying universe that is still better for them than killing them they are the only I think it's valid they're the only ones that can stop you now they're the only ones that know to stop you yeah one is I guess her power to disintegrate she could use it she can kill him she could definitely kill him no problemo oh crap look Wanda seems to be able to pick whatever Universe She Wants so count yourself lucky that you aren't floating in space leaving his paint or part of the dceu no that's true yeah yeah especially the DCU pot well it sucks to be part of me though but yeah there's a zero end of the streak or is it just on pause the joke does that end the streak or is it until he does something wrong if you're playing one of them them sports ball games and you get a bunch of goals and then you miss that ends the streak right surely no but I I don't think that's that I don't think that's fair because he hasn't missed he's just yeah he's missed in terms of our rules though let's frame it differently then you're playing the sports bowl game you miss but some somebody on your team catches it and it passes back to you versus you mess and it goes out and then I I don't think that's right because he's not pissing he's just making a joke he's not trying to criticize the movie he's just making a joke and that's that's actually this one the last time it's actually separate from him now the last time we significantly highlighted a break of streak it was from a negative one rather than a zero um yes so a joke well a joke's not going to give him points either way whether it's a good joke or a bad well I did I did say like just don't make a reference or a joke and you can keep the street going that's what I said and then so I assumed that the street would be broken by a joke or reference well um neutral observation then like one word where we just go like zero um if it's a neutral observation I feel like it still holds the streak maybe it does it it doesn't add to the streak but it doesn't take away from it the street actually like I'm inclined to agree with someone in chat saying that even if we were to decide that this doesn't break the streak it would feel like it's broken the streak of win Point win Point win Point joke oh we're hoping for like a win Point again that's what the nature of the streak was as far as I was aware it's not like there's any bonus points to my finger streak anyway Rags actually suggested that as a possibility yeah maybe maybe you're better you know when you're playing like Devil May Cry and you you know you're getting like your Combos and [ __ ] and you're getting your your scores up if you just stand there and do nothing it goes down and then you lose well that's because the streaks in that game are literally relevant on seconds passing well the reality is we're making the rules up as we [ __ ] go that's so yeah that I feel if he yes or no left to right I think the streak is broken yeah I think the streak is broken yes oh wow look at that I'm afraid it's four to one but I I feel as if you're making points and then you decide to tell a little joke still going it's on pause I I feel like that it is either in the spirit of the streak that is not a Flawless Victory but still I actually don't even know that you fully buy into it right because if you made another reference and then another joke and then a valid thing and then another joke and then another valid thing another valid thing I don't think you'd be at the point being like yes he's still got the streak I feel he'd be over depends if the joke was like neutral in terms of it's being correct then it it's on pause right the streak goes because he's not not doing anything how long is this until it ends you know um it will because the streak is not about time passing then I would essentially say that as long as you keep saying as long as you don't say anything wrong or make any incorrect observations or you know or [ __ ] it up you're good I'll allow you to tell joke books in the meanwhile you don't get credit for the jokes regardless of how funny but he also doesn't end the streak if it's not a good joke but if the joke is reliant on something that's incorrect that will break the streak [Laughter] sorry I just see a doctor strange it's actually freaky holding some goose yeah the joke neither adds to nor takes away it's totally the joke is neutral that's cool but like if you guys want to do that that's okay that's fine you hate democracy what's going on I do hate democracy oh my God you're not like permitted holy [ __ ] Jesus Christ I guess the day after a moment I forgot to take the morning after pill and it had a conception with Inception wow streak broken yeah the streak is dead there are some who you know when you know agree with that prove it yeah he had a sister Donna you had a sister you for all you know this guy lived on a farm and was raised by an alpaca this scene right you got a point yeah what do we do with that because it's a goofy ass scene that makes no [ __ ] sense uh but you can have fun with it so what do you do what do we do with that can I hear it again he just called it great that was a great scene I lived on a farm and was raised by an alpaca this scene is wrong I mean it's a lot like the scene with the harpists and Kung Fu Hustle but this is some great Samurai madness here it's worth a sin-off all right the same raininess of it and the the craziness of it because it seems pretty would it be a zero at that point or I feel it right so I'm sinking zero I'm thinking zero I think this is subjective found chat really wanted that negative one I think I understand yeah I wouldn't give it a negative I think this is just saying likes it yeah he's not said it means anything in any particular direction yeah what the [ __ ] why does this one harp note break this entire ball of magic conflict some yeah I'm uh I think I agree it seems very it at some point there's just this level of unintuitiveness to what I'm watching but wouldn't it be is that it isn't that just like an extension of the call point which is none of this makes sense I think that there is a level of well we see that the like the notes do things and they come from the paper so there's some level of like like like connection between the dots and so when you see this massive ball of stuff between them and one little note is added to it there's no like there's no way to connect some elements of why that would break it all up I just I don't I don't know why there's even a connecting dot the idea that he pulls a bunch of notes out of a book and the other one would it even pull out stuff from like he like turns it around and buys it back I don't know how what am I supposed to draw how do I know anything I think that I I would give I st I would give him a point for this because I think there is a there is a point where there's like this um I guess I'm more substantive or more intuitive break within the logic of the fight um we don't have much to work with and it seems to be kind of nonsensical but within that framework there are some lines of like oh this will probably happen if you do this and this will probably happen if you do that and the notes seem to be having this effect and they're they're pulled from this place and they can cause this kind of damage and there's this big jumble of stuff and I I think it's fair for him to go you know that this just seems to not it's not equally fair to say ah that last note tipped the balance anyone uh eyes like this is my whole point we have nothing to work with how can we go either direction yeah and that's not what he said he just said how does it make sense that this one is to make what makes the win the fight win it's like how does any of it make sense what exactly were you making sense of at first I gotcha yeah yeah is that neutral or is that that's a zero I think he's close he's just not going there he didn't seem to get any frostbite or have any ill effects from the cold whatsoever you know what's funny is um that's what we'll be with more if he'd given it more right because like the fact that he survived is one the fact he's not now Frozen is another but he's is that just one then I yeah I guess yeah how does he survive because of these reasons and I think that's like yeah labeled like a couple of things that would have killed him and we'd say well because of the Heat and because of the cold and because of the lack of atmosphere and you know that sort of thing yeah all you strangers you're the same what the [ __ ] was she expecting here why is strange who's in the dark hole to get back to his Universe a surprise how the [ __ ] else was he gonna pull it off absolutely true I don't know why the plan wasn't explained here before and I don't know what what else is there Regina what are you gonna do this is it I guess I'll die that's all we've got yes I'll die at least your principles are intact then oh okay well I'm under I needed to protect my body Souls of the Damned pronoun game aside this movie Just invented a whole last reason out of thin air it'll make strange seem like a better version of all the other strangers by asking for help from Christine and besides how does he know that's going to happen when he just heard about dreamwalking like an hour ago you're bringing no this is It's the possessing a body of the Dead yeah that's the Dead part but to be fit is that who do you learn that from I can remember it's like he's saying right he only learned about the room walking like an hour ago so yeah so then how could he know about that part of it can you possess the body of a corpse without dreamwalking because another dimension so in your own Dimension if you could I guess you can pop it here of course also yeah just just to clarify right he found out about dreamwalking incredibly recently and this seems to be a subsection of the rules of dreamwalking right I think that this is just I I think that the rules regarding um controlling a corpse in this case that's always going to happen if you if ever you take control of a corpse you are you gonna get the demon visit and if you dream walk it's just because you're walking into your own corpse then the demons come in because you're because of the corpse part that's why it didn't happen to Wanda when she dreamed walked it's puppeteering a corpse in any way your own corpse in another dimension or just dream or or just controlling a corpse in your own Dimension the demons are going to come I don't understand that second part of controlling a corpse that's never been a thing ever it's just dream walking that's what it is can you pause it did they invent that for this is it always like this room said nothing about that being anything to do with like Monsters coming to get you it's just walking into a dead they said you dream walking to someone who's dead you're not allowed to do that and the Monsters will come and get you that's it that's come from trolling so do when the demons say that something's forbidden is it do they specifically say dream walking or possessing you Conjuring walk into a dead body that's that's it that's what that's what the demons say it's they say dream walking you know after that yep so that's why I was checking the script they say uh the the demon people this would be the only thing that would probably support it to be honest with you what Rags is saying that they say uh because they use the word possess um strange possessing a dead body is forbidden but they then say cease your dream walk you know it's yeah exactly it feels like it's interchangeable can so can you possess things as as a form of magic is that just a thing that magic allows you to do to possess we've never seen other I don't think we've never seen it all right we haven't seen any sort of reforms of possession unless I'm missing something I can't think of anything in the MCU that would constitute that no maybe it's something that can be done but I think because it's so poorly explained I'm not sure like is is is I guess the question is is dreamwalking the only form of possession or is it it's the only one we've ever seen and and it doesn't matter right like it is dreamwalking because it's in an alternate universe so like regardless of whether it constitutes possession or not it is dreamwalking it has to be and it is an issue with the demons that it's a corpse he's dream walking into yeah that's the specific issue that they have because it's baffling right because one is possessing a real like living human is apparently less bad than a dead body yeah it doesn't make any sense it shouldn't be there should be no like you're not essentially committing a moral crime by possessing a corpse in and of itself because you're not violent you know well I mean certainly less than a person who was actually alive yeah you're not like pausing someone's Consciousness or removing their you know autonomy and all that sort of thing yeah it's so it's weird it's just one of those like ooh isn't it like spookier to possess a corpse or whatever it's like I I no not I mean only only like that visceral sort of look to it but that doesn't mean anything really just to clarify them the defense of him knowing is that he's aware of a rule that's a general rule do not possess dead bodies and he's like if I dreamwalk into a dead body that's gonna apply to that that rule that I'm aware of but the criticism of course is that you shouldn't be aware of this rule because he doesn't know anything about dream walking it just sounds yeah like to me that's like invented doing a lot of work for the film that wasn't yeah my when I watch this my takeaway is that possessing a corpse makes the demons come and get you that's forbidden the dream walking element is separate but not necessarily contradictory to the control of a dead body and that's why the demons come to me I feel like that's doing a lot of work for the movie that wasn't in the film I wouldn't be much more comfortable if Christine said what do you know about dreamwalking he's like oh this goes well beyond dreamwalking this is like yeah something like that spiritual rules but you're saying we could just we could infer that on its own I think that's one of those really murky ones where it's like uh is there enough because comparing that with Wanda dreamwalking herself she dream walks an alive person and the demons don't care even though it's dreamwalking I think part of the problem is that possession would be super useful across many of the interactions he's had in this universe and he's never used it or talked about it I agree though like wouldn't you reasonably infer there is no possession spells I don't think so maybe if this was a really well-written clarify if they highlighted in this film that he could possess say wander in the middle of a fight we'd be like what the [ __ ] why hasn't he done that in any other fight before but I but I wonder because there's not a Consciousness in a corpse if that's just a thing you could do like I'm gonna take control of this corpse because it's just a thing I could move it's essentially like remote telekinesis in a way um I'm going to your astral form or something like yeah like to me there seems to be like built into the idea of possessing a live person versus a corpse you know a meaningful difference between being able to do that like you have to put someone on pause or kick them out with a living person whereas a dead body why are we assuming that this is possible though when we've never seen it happen ever like in a Marvel film the key point if it were introduced we would then have questions about previous stuff yeah yeah of course which is why shouldn't even then assume it's not a thing yeah if that's what I'm saying like why are we listening the product of how bad like a lot of the magic is done in this stuff well so then you agree so you agree with yeah because like your point seems to be possession is like the um overarching umbrella and then there's dream walking and specifically it's the possession of a dead body that will get you in trouble with demons and Doctor Strange knew that rather than he's just wrong and somehow knew something he didn't know which is that you can't really walk into a dead guy meanwhile I would say it can't be what you're saying anymore because possession would screw up previous films they'd have to commit to no possession or possession is something that requires the consent of the person or something like that yeah I know what you mean I I just it's hard to like tell based on every all the information they give and the implications of it knowing you know the stuff that exists with all the weird [ __ ] portals and [ __ ] and the magic stuff that they pull out of their ass and you know how what I would say is use things and to me I think simpler explanation is it's made up [ __ ] in this film like they pulled it yeah and the sins would be correct yeah like that whatever rule that there would be about like demons not liking you doing anything bad with like corpses I just to me it seems simpler Doctor Strange needs to dreamwalk into zombie because zombie looks cool and then monsters will come out and fight him and he shouldn't know this like to me that just makes that's that just makes way more sense to me is like the [ __ ] up not that he knew that the demons didn't like you doing any crazy magic stuff like with dead people and he already knew that beforehand like sorry to me so the demons are tied to the dark hold specifically or they are they do they exist outside like the I think they're like spawn out of his eyeballs or something well if dreamwalking exists only as part of the dark hold why would you have a whole host of I get like so all the demons they just wait until someone uses the dark hold the dreamwalk into a corpse or is it just the people there's other roles yeah they probably do all this stuff I I guess um I don't know I I'm pretty I guess I'm pretty neutral on it I just don't I think sins is correct yeah I certainly yeah I think he's right yeah it's worth what you guys decide on you going to happen when he just heard about dreamwalking like an hour ago you're bringing in the candles sure but how can you be sure this is enough that's just a joke yeah yeah it's strange possessing a dead body so that's where you [ __ ] draw along I guess it's part of the rules of the magic but it's insane and stupid but if they don't contradict it I guess uh I don't know you know it's like with the undead Spirit demon people only care about corpses being taped inside it just sounds so stupid but I guess so well that's had more issue with that than I guess they don't maybe they don't handle the living ones but there is no one who handles the living ones so yeah it's it's like a guild it's heavily unionized the demons do they live like between the universes as well then evil spirit demon skull people per universe that take care of it for their own okay and so whenever it's total sense yeah it's like if you no that doesn't make sense because then those universes don't know that it's another Street I just tripped over all my things never mind it's like you go on the internet and you commit a crime virtually in another country then the country that you're doing the stuff in they're like oh something's bad and the person who's doing it is in this other country and so the they have to it's like that man can we make friends with these demons if they know like every everyone who uses them to defeat her yeah oh yeah he does it seems to be against their will I don't know if they're friends yeah no it's fine because it's not contradictory in any way it's just it just seems stupid you know I agree with you sentiment but it is a zero it's like we would highlight this too um oh yeah we have yeah you know of talking about the movie but it I guess the it's it's you know that the rules are stupid not that they exist I guess yeah that's where you [ __ ] draw the line this works yeah that's fair yeah they were [ __ ] Spirit demon and she could kick it like okay that doesn't really line up in this spiritual I don't I don't I don't get it I just fine Spirit damage that must be ancient sorcerer speak for the tube of exactly the thing I need exactly when I need it go back you know does it have what it is written in English on the front of it she does yeah but I remember us saying like why wasn't there a moment just earlier which you know just explaining their weapons in this room you can use it was so [ __ ] stupid strange was just like defend me from the spirits of hell it's like with what uh uh this is something she does spontaneously she looks around she's like uh this smashes thing because yeah she she knows about it it's the the uh bars of the little it has like a funny name in the first film brazer of bomb Goliath yeah I should have started punching them with a fire Stinger thing a sting X it's [ __ ] hell extinguisher again with her and hits things with it yeah um so what he's highlighting is how convenient um uh I'm trying to think of exactly where the the convenience would be labeled like it makes sense that this thing is in this room it makes sense that a lot of sorcerer items would be effective against Spiritual Beings um the two of exactly the thing I need exactly when I need it it's not necessarily it's one of many things that would probably affect and be affectionate against those things that she would be aware of I'm not I'm not sure that's the criticism I'll show how that's how I would put it I guess given the context of where they are um there's some level of like yeah I mean I guess it's not unheard of that this this magic isn't it the first thing she tries though it's like she recognizes it she knows what it is so she goes for it so to speak right I guess you could say it's conveniently backed up into this area this thing exactly that would that be the point I guess the yeah because I feel like the flaw here that should be made is the whole like you're gonna help me out with some stuff you're gonna give me a magic item you're gonna Point me into something I can use or it's just like protect me you'll figure it out because I think in the actual action scene she literally turns around she's right next to it she could have been at any point in this room really exactly the thing I need exactly when I need it go back to Hell fortunately the discount Goblet of Fire doesn't need a special enchantment or any kind of magical abilities to use it just flame we'll do the trick this is basically a very fancy lighter and deodorant can I guess with a sharpened piece of metal so yeah well it's just I guess that's how it was how it works yeah I guess how it works fires a fire I guess well like um Moto has that sorcerer sword I'm assuming that just that works I don't know because they have sorcerer imbued items right you don't need to be a soldier to use them I'm sure I assume I mean they they just uh we know this because uh the sling ring is one of those items and Ned uses that like straight away right so you don't have to train but as like to become understanding you don't cast spells to activate the items I guess is what I'm saying I think the items just work and so anyone can use them it's like putting magic into an item and then that item has now got you know power and so anyone can use it I think that's how that works so that would be a zero then I think it's a zeroid yeah yeah I think so all right I feel like the first draft of this movie went to Marvel and they said we like it but it needs more rainy and then Remy was like well I'm flattered but I think I've ejected about as much Ramey into this as I can without breaking some MCU fundamentals and then Marvel was like look buddy if you don't get your I don't know if the visual in the background is playing for too long here I don't know if this is all it is scary your ass back in there and give us a scene where strange possesses his own dead body and flies into battle with a cape made of damned Spirits from the underworld just gonna be careful just I don't know I feel like this is going for a little too long so help us fighting we will give this gig to Edgar and right also holy I uh I mean this is just it's just references really something yeah I think feige actually said that literally the only feedback they gave him was more rainisms like make it even more rainy okay so that's uh that's a good guess on his part I'm not gonna give him points but it's a good guess every single one of these [ __ ] points for the cloak zero when there was a zombie sorcerer flying towards them just a second ago I guess that type of thing is easy to forget now what the hell [ __ ] sounds coming from my phone what is happening ah you pissed off Wanda come just coming to you from across the multi oh my god did he actually die that was terrifying it just started playing a video and it's off like I told you Wanda was not happy maybe maybe it's some kind of like did any of us say play video but then how would it I don't know I don't know why that just happened but hey darkhold I don't know because there's a reflection on your phone screen and I'm gonna replay now because I completely lost we will give this gig to Edgar right also holy [ __ ] he's using a whole bunch of demons as a flying cloak every single one of these [ __ ] Focus their attention on Wong when there was a zombie sorcerer flying towards them just a second ago I guess that type of thing is easy to forget I mean they just didn't see him uh I'd have to rewatch the scene I don't remember if if they just don't see him he comes in too fast he's like fully black on a very snowy background so that's racist um well did we give it to him or not I don't know yeah I'm kind of running zero there feeling pretty neutral on that one I'm gonna say zero I don't know enough oh sorry we're on they all let's see what you think of this Rags okay is there attention oh wait all right let's start with some so help us fighting we will give this gig to Edgar [ __ ] right also holy [ __ ] he's using a whole bunch of demons as a flying cloak every single one of these [ __ ] Focus their attention on Wong when there was a zombie sorcerer flying towards them just a second ago I guess that type of thing is easy to forget uh the fact that there's three of them uh they shouldn't all be focused on Wong surely you think one of them might try to knock off Wong while the other two focus on the flying no well I I thought the whole point is they hadn't noticed him yet um if they hadn't noticed them yet then yeah because there's nothing else to focus I can't remember if they know about Doctor Strange yet if they don't then it's fine they focus on Wong if they do know he's coming then they shouldn't all be focused on Long especially because Wong is super vulnerable one of them can finish off Wong I'm booting up the movie the darkness my old friend oh here we go yeah you're inviting more curses into your technology well I'm oh they've they must have seen him yeah they definitely see him they definitely 100 in fact it looks like him arriving is what makes them walk over to the edge oh yeah yeah yeah okay well again I completely forgot the scene so they all see him right and they're like oh we're gonna [ __ ] you up and then one of them gets stabbed by Wong and then they all realize Wong is there then they all focus on Wong and it's like no you should probably keep an eye on the [ __ ] sorcerer yeah because there's one point then that is a point yeah there yep one by one instead of throwing multiple rocks and where the [ __ ] is Scarlet Witch she's at home washing her tights Scarlett otherwise um I've the thing about it is the general criticism is she should have sucked the powers out by now but she's just not doing anything every time we cut to her she's just sort of looking at things I think I think that's fair just to say yeah sounds about right yeah which throws a red energy at zombie strain and the demons suck it all up which is great I'd remove a sin for this if I understood why they were able to do this rather than just get demolished trying it ah yeah that he was gonna go that's cool so point but the nonsensicalness of it was too powerful and so he gave it a sin that's a point I guess that's actually the first time I I realized that's even a thing that was a fight versus logic there I guess that's that's what that's something that crossed his line yeah um you know to trust yourself it's your power I wish they had found some sort of way other than believe in yourself for America to use your power here considering how long she's been wandering around the Multiverse you'd think she would have practiced it a bit learned a couple things but never mastering it so when it came to this scene it wouldn't sound like a commercial for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints true yeah yeah I agree absolutely what he's highlighted there is just that yeah there was nothing that actually led to her learning [ __ ] it just it's just believing yourself as he said it's you don't have anything to learn it's all inside of you and you just have to believe that you can do it it's not actually there's nothing that's coming from outside of you that you have to change and grow with it's just it's not even like a confidence thing like the issue isn't you know I just I just can't do it and I don't think I have what it takes and then she gets the pep talk it's just no this is you just do it and she does yeah you opened a portal you sent us exactly where we needed to go if that's true there must have been an easier way to do this sending you both to the fox Universe got a lot of people killed and Wanda was the one who sent you to the dead Universe with the dark hole which led you here and even if America is innately controlling where you ended up that means she's controlling the portals and can tell the [ __ ] future because how else would she know the perfect route to defeating her why doesn't that oh that was like two points yeah yeah that sounds like two points to me I agree I think that gets a two-pointer yeah natural ability for her to tell the future and that yeah that that's not really anything I just said before but everyone who's understood anything about this movie would just be like Doctor Strange is full of [ __ ] that can't be true it's like [ __ ] America's star white punch open up a portal behind Scarlet Witcher into a new universe every single portal has been a Hoover back I'm afraid this is when she's controlling them so someone has it on that one that's a zero thoughtlessly [Music] well what does everyone think do you think that's a zero or negative one can I hear that again you might be saying that every portal UPS this point has been sucking people in this one doesn't why when this is the first portal after she's got control over him yeah I I think I'm gonna go with negative one on this one I think it's fair uh yeah especially considering the whole point of now she can control it yeah because that's stupid as stupid as it is with the whole pep talk the the yeah what's supposed to happen basically that is yeah that's what they're trying to sell all righty sorry lessons why do they think running just behind the banister the stairs is going to protect them the kids you know yeah they're scared they don't want to leave their mum but they also don't want to be in the open that makes enough sense to me yeah so yeah that's kind of uh it's kind of an unfair criticism I mean it's weird that he wouldn't have ignored he wouldn't have said like I know they're kids but you know you'd usually put it that way if you are understanding that but it seems like he just doesn't even yeah even yeah look I know they're just kidding oh sorry okay okay well then at that point it's probably a zero for me um it seems like he thinks it's still Fair knowing their kids okay yeah yeah okay like it's the kind of thing where if you were in this call right now he's like I know they're kids but surely they're smart enough to realize that's not going to protect them and then we would say yeah but they're that scared they don't know what to do they they're like terrified and they don't leave their mum so you know I could see him being like fine I could I could see him saying fine to that yeah character references anyway for them individually so we can default to kids here pretty easily kids but why do they think running just behind the banister of the stairs is going to protect them and because Wanda's shown the ghost of Chris Multiverse she will now suddenly see the light and stop her Crusade but multiple characters have raised the system I was willing to buy her ignoring that logic because of the dark hole being all evil and know that she's listening to reason now makes me wonder why the dark holds influence oh my God this feels like more than plus one this is like wrapping up the dark hold influences possibly still find a way to root for Wanda yeah you got two points any point in watching the other video listen he can you can try to earn more points that's the key yeah and not lose anything until they are or when Batman puts the rubble of the Scarlet Witch Kingdom back together through his computer and is able to read all the symbols carved in the rock so it was just saying it'll be gone forever but I mean from her POV it's fair that she's saying it that way you know there's a lot of logic Loops you can find that would mean it wouldn't be the end but I don't know that is that more so what he's highlighting because I mean it's weird that he highlights when Batman puts the rubble back together and reads the word like that I feel like that's less likely but it's not impossible it so if if she believes that she's destroying all of the dark hole it's basically as long as Wanda believes it reasonably to be true then it's okay well that right um it's just I guess it kind of depends on what does it feel like he's saying here is he trying to contradict her and say she's an idiot for thinking this or is he just trying to point out that that's just not true way to root for Wanda I think he's trying to find out again until they are or when Batman puts the rubble of the Scarlet Witch Kingdom back together through I'm inclined to give a point here I think um how's everyone else feeling what what's your rational out there though that he's right I think what life is right it'll eventually get like figured out someone will figure out a way to interpret the information there are a couple ways it can come back we we've talked about them before like the whole other people these temples exist in other worlds so once you've transcribed the temple to a book you can then use that book to dreamwalk into this world and then you can transcribe into this world but as he said I I never even thought about the idea of re putting all this building back together because like how could they do that it's like well this they have insane Tech in these universes now that maybe constraints just uses I guess magic to just reassemble it well you don't have the timestamp anymore but you could get it if he wanted it you did the thing with the bus right didn't he just disassemble and reassemble a full bus just with magic [Music] I guess the thing is is like what is she supposed to repair right is she wrong to just say like well it's the it does seem like it's the movie's opinion that this is this is the case sure but yeah I guess at that but I mean are we appealing to that or is it you know I think that's why I'm teetering I'm not sure how's everyone believing that taking all the precautions to destroy the book for good they also have [ __ ] they have a time machine you can obviously get this back of course you're so [ __ ] yeah [Laughter] oh my God it's not even fair we haven't even seen this video yet about 29.88 I'm glad that fullback could exist at least with evap I think it was fused I'm really trying to say to give this a point either way I'm not sure what he like what the sin is referring to so exactly on one hand he's saying this doesn't get rid of the dark hold forever movie that's stupid but on the other you could say well it's the the movie's not claiming that it's just Wanda she thinks it is but it's like uh I'm pretty sure that it's like you guys would all see it as the movie's point right that the dark hole will never be used again yeah absolutely that's uh that's what Michael Waldron believes yeah and so that's why I'm more inclined to give him a point for this because it truly is very relevant that you can get the dark hole back it's not done you haven't wiped it from the universe it's not gone probably not even possible yeah no well with the time machine is certainly not possible the Wonders wander's got to survive this and Go destroy the time machine and anyone who does sort of make a time machine at this point no she just kill everything just kill all kill everything in all multiverses so that you definitely make sure there's no more dark old through his computer and his able to replace is that okay we on a one yeah um okay yeah we'll give him that read all the symbols carved in the rock yeah this is why I think it's the movie's opinion that she was right about that which is she's not did she do that that's a great Point how the [ __ ] did she do that yeah you got a point for that yeah how yeah oh it was nice of America to wait long enough for 616 strange and 838 Christine to have their moment before extracting them from this universe but also yeah yeah uh yeah I mean there's no reason why they took so long she would have portaled her and Wong out and then she should immediately portal for them but she doesn't for some reason like three or four minutes just enough for them to have a speech why are they still in the frozen tundra of Lambeau Field America's star portaled out of that oh my God a minute ago I didn't even think of that well pointed out they forgot where they were when they made that nice good catch parents would be proud I hope you'll get to show him well great point now that she can control her powers why isn't she off Universe hopping and trying to find them again it's not even a matter of it's instant she can do it based on the people I'm glad I fell into here that's a point [Music] the death of multiple Sorcerers and the very real possibility of an evil witch dominating the Multiverse true about it man here we are look you caused an incursion Jesus Christ it is an impressive feat to undermine the dramatic ending of your movie before the credits have even finished rolling we just skip right over strange freaking out wow yeah let's go Universe hopping with sudden Cipher from reindeer games Fame and get oculating yeah true true yeah they feel like they're made by two different people those scenes yeah they probably are it's funny but why hasn't anybody tried to help this poor bastard yet or arrested him I feel like the 838 Rachel McAdams would have found this guy by now and fixed that oh yeah I mean it definitely would have been people who would have helped him he he's right eventually the police like he's he's been trying to make it work but he's having such a terrible time he can't make pizzas and everything well yeah you just feel bad for the [ __ ] that's it yeah you just feel really bad because he was kind of a good dude and he didn't want people to steal his [ __ ] and he got punished by a dick didn't even lose weight in that time so my friend and I said come here look at this stuff it's on exact replica what do you think thanks again so what is the rest of this just better health Jesus everyone who watches Multiverse of Madness could probably use a therapist but he just references okay it's time to tally to reveal the score uh how very exciting yeah so uh give me a sec talk about yourselves I'm just gonna count my numbers spreadsheet uh no just a notepad and I put one zero or negative one to whatever the thing was all right okay I could have kept it going the whole time but I just decided not to you think I know to use Excel what am I a wizard yeah to just like add everything up right oh here I'm adding one dude while he adds I think it's safe to say that this was a pretty strong showing from uh CinemaSins he surprised me honestly I didn't expect yeah do uh this well he pointed out some good stuff he had some insights I hadn't considered so good on your Cinema Sins uh you definitely exceeded my expectations yeah good stuff the only real question is if you you're gonna have what it takes to beat in the one round fight you're gonna have what it takes to to beat your your inverse Cinema wins which you just might be able to I believe in you the negative I think if victory was your goal you might uh I think you've done good so far but we'll see you never know I mean cinemasin surprised me here so Cinema wins could surprise me uh next grand total of 67 points according to the way wow I recorded it 67 67. I think it was a total of like 150 points there if you exclude the extra hundred that he added on so that means half of them were considered to be like worthwhile um yeah not bad really that's probably the best Cinema since video we've watched absolutely yeah I would actually go as far as seeing it was a good video I think oh yeah I think so this really is madness there was a couple inaccuracies but really not some of them were very understandable considering how confusing this movie is um well just there was some there was some like more fundamental kind of insights in that video that were worthwhile so not just like basic arguments but like much more thorough comprehensive sort of uh core points you know like about the nature of the Multiverse and how uh yeah and how uh like if you actually want to delve into the nature of the Multiverse and the decisions that people make and how those choices can radically change their lives that it's like blows the doors open or wander that part of the end of summarizing Wonder I was surprised it's like that's actually like that's that's not only accurate but like you've untangled something that is like quite Tangled which is who the hell is Wonder yeah he has ascended in multiple instances past that tier one of movie criticism yeah he's been able to kind of be you know to really think about it and actually engage with the information and be critical of it uh I yeah why do we think is it because the film was so bad that it's it was it was easier sometimes that's what it takes because well a lot of people just I'd say like virtually everyone they're just not consistent and this was one of those things where it's really easy to look at and see the issues and see the problems and like whether like it was kind of like tlj for me sort of snapped me out of that sort of movie LOL and got me to be critical about stuff like that so sometimes it just takes a really bad movie just to kind of make you go oh wait you know like wow this is bad I mean everyone has like their breaking point right you know that's like you're not saying accumulation breaking point though yeah I don't think this is like a permanent thing I don't think this is like some permanent change but oh no but you look at it and they're just so bad on their face or there's so much stuff going on that you can just point it out because even I mean that's what I mean yeah every everyone's got that movie that we can all point out and be like yeah that's bad because this and this and this and plot this plot that and that doesn't make sense they just won't be consistent with that on a movie that they like so yeah I think this was one where I guess that kind of you know tipped over the line for me interesting how like Multiverse at this point the ruined that film came out everybody thought it was really good now everybody agrees that the script sucks like that is just consensus I think people will still reconnect the whole like yeah but it's visually speaking and it's like yeah but mostly everybody now agrees that script was horrendous and even on the visuals people are now like not as thrilled I'd say like cinematography sometimes maybe but like people [ __ ] on the visual effects yep so this is slightly relevant remember that uh and or guy I was talking to you about before um so um you know guess what his favorite Marvel film is um let me guess oh let me guess so this is the guy who thought it was like boring or he wouldn't watch Andor so he said that Star Wars shouldn't isn't about you shouldn't have interest uh shouldn't have incredible dialogue that guy what would he have as his favorite MCU movie I'm trying to think of the most like heady feels he doesn't make sense one that there is it might be end game but it could but I feel like a lot of people might say in-game so you might not have brought it up for that reason so I might go with uh Winter Soldier Multiverse of Madness wow I guess it's so topical I should have probably guessed that but yeah I guess logically that he's you know he would he would he would yeah I guess you know uh water world I guess it's time then here it is in this corner a different approach now as we've highlighted not the easiest task for those who don't know this channel is focused on praising film no matter what the film is we praise it we give it points we talk about its pluses and again we're gonna have the exact same system as long as what he says is true and representative and you know Fair it's just like yeah you'll get a point but I'm I'm sure we're going to encounter some strange [ __ ] because defending this film's writing is real [ __ ] hard and uh gonna have to you have to move some facts around in order to do it effectively I would imagine this video is sponsored by yeah oh we start with the sponsor too [Music] I guess except for the except they're playing on a the I guess the field if you could say that this movie is that they're both playing on is is the worst movie ever [ __ ] made but uh we'll see you never know maybe Cinema wins can pull it out sponsored by nebula classes and specifically Patrick willem's brand new class how to make a movie um [Laughter] has Patrick Williams made a movie I think he's made like a short film or something maybe I don't know okay I'm curious hey that doesn't count that's that's messy that doesn't count that doesn't count it's hilarious that he thinks that I will never forget the Black Widow one where it goes ah then places just children screaming do you remember [Music] oh all right seems to be a little extra strange in Wanda in the Marvel logo this time and that makes these Multiverse of Madness style opening credits um the equivalent of sins they would be like they're [ __ ] shoving a bunch of doctors you know we would say zero either way I think right it's not you have to do more yeah you'd have to say more than that so that's got to be a zero I'm afraid I think so yeah hey it even ends on a sling ring oh [ __ ] uh zero to me it's like saying Benedict Cumberbatch is in this it's like you don't know anything you gotta tell me why that's meaningful tell me why that's worthwhile or impressed that's why he's in this and just dropping us right into the action with the grooviest hair dude strange to date is that right yeah come on wins come on yeah these opening notes are very reminiscent of the one division theme which would make sense since it's actually her attacking Defender strange I think thematically that's okay on the theme because she's the one controlling the demon which is going to be revealed later right uh I mean I guess you use any particular theme that is pertaining to any character like does that necessarily what does that mean that that's good that's a connection [Music] um I mean it's a connection sure but is it appropriate like what is the one division theme what like which which part of the theme is that like I don't know uh that's all I remember is that it's like a a fairy tale like so I think it like it matches in this you know I I think that is more than neutral yeah what do you think rags I'm okay I agree that it's very I I think I know what fringy means here it's just like yep that's that's Wanda sort of behind it so we have the one division theme um which I think the fact that it's a secret that she's controlling this thing quote unquote you know you already knew if you I read like foreshadowing it's something more than like if we knew this was her and it was just playing her it's vaguely something to do with this song I feel less inclined to compliment it but the fact that it's like in a sense giving you a clue as to what what the antagonist is I think that's kind of neat sure yeah because I have no idea like which part of the theme is yeah I don't think he plays it let's see if he yeah with the grooviest hairdude strange to date but also while we're here these opening notes he played the cough of it I think I don't know yeah I don't I don't actually hear the okay fine you get yeah you get one point moving on television theme which would make sense since it's actually another attack and Defender strange in America through the slinky dude the first word spoken are in English loving the audience gets treated like adults no it's stupid it's they wouldn't just randomly switch between languages it's not yeah that's dumb that's a negative yeah you get it it feels more like pandery like like look we've got a different language and it's like why just for the hell of it especially when it's in subtitles you know I I liked it in Andor when all the flashback scenes of vandora's childhood you there were no subtitles to their language and you had to pay attention to their gesticulations their expressions their inflections I think you could even argue it's it's the opposite of treating us as adults like it's it's that's what I'm saying with the negative yeah oh [ __ ] okay uh I think I'm I think I might go with a negative one on this because you're praising something that I think is actually bad not even like negative it's it's more it is with the language switching um there is yeah there's only one of the time she does it is for a joke and that's it yeah otherwise uh yeah they speak on English and when she meets the other doctor strange I think doesn't they start talking in English and everything so yeah it would be really it'd be really cool if they incorporate it properly but this is only here I think just to be praised for being here like that's why it's like cheap like if she met a new doctor strange adults treat you like adults because they're not speaking English like I don't understand what that even means especially if there's subtitles also what if you just speak Spanish it's like we're treating you like an adult by speaking your language also it doesn't make sense to switch in a high emotional state she does it later just for a meme so like it's that's the two examples we have and then none for the rest of the film so I don't buy it I mean everything everywhere all at once is kind of a like go-to extended how to do it in a way that you know this is how you swap link or incorporate multiple languages in a way that makes sense and feels natural I love it we're talking to and like there's English words mixed in here and there in a sentence because they're not as coherent on like every sentence and how it's structured because they don't they're not as familiar with the rules of the language and stuff versus just they speak this language here now they don't okay so yeah I I I I I'd have to be convinced for a negative one I'd say zero but I'm on zero right personally I am personally going with the negative but of course if everyone wants to give it a zero we'll go with whatever if I correct me from wrong but for any email you just said zero as well yeah yes zero Z continuing we are not messing around this time that's a gnarly magical wound you must have found a director who's familiar with horror this time around you got nothing for that this is really good nothing yeah if I'm wrong but he's saying that uh isn't it great that there's violence in this more so than we usually have is that the compliment I mean if anything showing incredible injuries and not having the characters react to them could be a negative thing so conveying so far this is just an observation yeah I would say that's why it's a zero it's you're just saying that's why yeah this is a zero yeah this is my only way and I thought that ponytail was the most evil thing about him oh come on this again I literally have a ponytail right now I don't know well yeah but not for that reason that's just yeah Darth Vader was bald [ __ ] off I mean I don't know what's going on here it was a joke it wasn't a particularly funny one it's a zero it's funny somehow your sacrifice is worth more in your life comeuppance see that's all comeuppance he's trying to save the Multiverse you [ __ ] what instant easy negative one yeah if anything you did a nice thing by trying to explain to her why he's doing he didn't want to start the last resort Liz if you didn't know he if she she dies anyway she's dead either way never mind so many people don't understand this about the movie like I just fine negative one the cinema wins oh my God I don't know why I don't care if he was a good guy he's gonna kill a kid are we on level one of morality jeez what do you what you can there's just no scenario where killing the kid could be considered moral that's just impossible do you know who Damien is what I don't care if he's a good guy he was gonna kill a kid again so when Wonder gets crushed under the debris he's gonna say come up and I'm curious just how he would deal with the trolley problem with they're all kids what happens then what's the moral choice just die and you shouldn't have to make them all kids like the person the the single person is the kid and the five on the other side are adults and I mean like it doesn't even like we're giving them easy mode here um with that example but yeah you wonder what he's gonna say but like I'm sorry that you're on like level one of Ethics uh I grow up I don't I just I just don't get how he hasn't considered what uh Defender strings trying to do in this scene but that's that's I mean he's gonna kill a kid simple as that also is she a kid is she um I can buy people referring to teens as kids I get what they mean by it but I know what you're saying as well but uh yeah he's an abortion are kid comeuppance a slight moment of redemption defend the strangers absolute chat he's like unironically kind of like the most heroic character um he just wasn't fast enough with his decisions okay if anything is a wife from the evil monster so that's a negative one right uh kind of it's characterizing him as like it kind of rolls into the last point because if anything the last Point shows that the reason that she's alive is because he was showing her a kindness by explaining why he had to kill her um which which actually if anything kind of caused trouble here um instead of him just doing the thing um wait someone said it's still the previous point is he dinged yet it's a slight moment of redemption for cutting her free with his last Act slightly Redemption I mean there's nothing he needs to redeem himself for so it's true so I'm going to lower well that's the thing I want to give him negative one for [ __ ] everything yeah well we haven't right A lot of these have been zero yes uh so uh what so was that one neutral because I think this rolls into the last Point yeah this one relies on the last one so yeah zero for this one just like a shitty thing to say but it's a zero [Music] and this one relies on that kind of characterization so it kind of rolls into the last point the last one's a setup for this one what a slick transition to Bob newhartos about this cold open you kids know about The Bob Newhart Show right no um I mean I think it's a smooth transition I think that that is a one he's just he added on a reference that's all yeah I'm okay with complimenting that cinematography it is kind of cool sure yep yeah um lowering the buff with difficulty if you can get into positive numbers by the end and that will be a victory Paul's not lower there that's just like a I think that's like yeah it's fair yeah it's so easy to forget that he's one of the celebrities so everyone is weird around him well I was it was weird around him but there's that one guy to to the bottom left there you see him that's like one guy the problem is yeah I was about to say good note and yes but then it's like but who else is nobody really yeah sorry I'm afraid that is a zero because you're close I think that the way I would have said this was valid as he had said look at this guy reacted because he knows Doctor Strange of course he would Doctor Strange is famous like I think that would be fine but the fact that you said everybody is reacting to it was like no they're not celebrities so everyone I don't know maybe you could argue that girl in the red back there is kind of looking at him maybe in the guy ah nah it's kind of it's kind of points he's making me think about how to react to him he's made me think about how there should be more people looking at him he's like holy [ __ ] let's talk yeah he might have kind of hurt himself here because now I'm thinking yeah on the Avengers part of the dealer yards save the whole universe they recognize that it's something to acknowledge but they decided that it would only be this one guy really that's well let's use your example from uh Black Widow how uh in the MCU um doctor strange is more famous in his Universe than Benedict Cumberbatch is in ours yes so yeah people would be so then they come a batch tuning up to a wedding would have many people being like holy [ __ ] that's better he's Doctor Strange he's talking strange he's more famous than himself what the [ __ ] I call him Smaug oh yeah of course you're around him well I was gone wait so that was a zero yeah I would say a zero but that one almost is like that almost Teeters on like oh like you I guess it's more of an OBS yeah it doesn't change what's in the movie but it's almost like you've you've kind of almost made the movie worse by saying something I lost both my cats and my brother priorities but I really do like the MCU isn't playing the blip off like it wouldn't totally screw everyone's life up I never understand yeah famously really committing to the blip yep that's what the mcu's doing there by by every once in a while mentioning it and it essentially throwaway conversation they're really committing yeah it's like you're sometimes acknowledging it 99 of life was wiped out and I walk around in a city and just it's it's like everything is fine and I see a lot of people and I'm just like yeah and it's like and then there's a corpse on the floor and it's like I love that they acknowledge the 99 people who died no not even close like oh I don't I don't wanna I don't want to spam negative ones okay let's just zero I assume yeah yep I'd say zero I guess depending on our scoring is he saying something that's just not true they are acknowledging the blip here this is what's happening it's just says it's true but the the MCU is absolutely playing the blip off like it doesn't screw everyone's lives up they totally do I don't know why he's saying that they don't they do what about the priorities line the whole like what if the cat maybe he wasn't on a good relationship with his brother like it's totally like believable that you know he was you know I he liked his cats more than his brother um I think Vanadium can be made for negative one I'm just trying to stop throwing them all out that's that's what I'm saying I feel like especially with the hey isn't it cool that they noticed doctor strange and then we're like wait like no one is noticing Doctor Strange um let's see and then the priorities part oh that's actually a good point that uh Roadie would be considered evil for suggesting stopping Thanos when he was a baby yeah I guess the the the the atmosphere in that scene is that he's wrong for suggesting that and besides they have a [ __ ] time machine so they can do a hell of a lot more things than just kill everybody's a baby there's plenty of options so detonated species uh so uh did we do we need a vote maybe on zero negative one oh I'm zero if you wanna I'm I don't I do not want to come across as being unfairly negative but I'm gonna go with negative one on this I think the both of these back to back just especially with the last one I think they I think that I think this is a negative one yeah negative one for me ah balls because I'm like right on the edge I could go either way really the edging because [ __ ] off because I also don't like the whole oh we acknowledge it but that one is dumb priorities or whatever but also yeah I also don't want to spam the negatives because he's bringing because he's bringing up because remember he says I really do like that the MCU isn't playing the blip off he's not saying like this scene and this like Doctor Strange the movie he's saying the MCU isn't playing the blip off but it is I was just thinking about how if this is if this red I really do like that the movie isn't playing the blip off that I'd be like well this moment maybe but the rest of the movie doesn't really acknowledge the blip and so maybe that would be a zero but the fact that he said the MCU which has absolutely given zero [ __ ] about the blip feels more like a negative one see you but will that count towards only the movie then when they just he could have said this movie he could have said something along the lines of even though I feel like the MCU doesn't often you know reference this event it's nice that at least there's some recognition here in this scene yeah and they didn't know what I'm saying is because we made the distinction in in the other video that if it's in another movie it didn't count metal correct if you had an accurate criticism of a different film it wouldn't count for a point so if you had an accurate criticism inaccurate criticism of another film meaning the rest of the MCU I would still would you say that would you say the difference is that he references the MCU for which this is a part of that's an interesting point yeah because the MCU is simultaneously not any single movie but also not like it's in all of them but also none of them it's not any single movie but it's in all of them that's what I'm trying to say yeah it's like if we were covering a Star Wars movie and he referenced the Star Wars franchise well that this is a part of that thing it's not just a reference to a different movie as just a reference for reference's sake or a joke this is like to a degree like like substantively a part of the MCU for which he's making the Judgment this is adding to that it is part of the MCU that's all that's the whole point of the CU any of that convincing to you for any are you sticking to the zero um I the reason why I think I'm at a zero is because like I can see that argument in favor of of the negative but like the observation like is is the observation that what he has said is overplayed because this is acknowledgment of what happened it's just that he's giving it more credit than I think it deserves I don't know if that's enough to constitute a negative for me fair I understand that all right Mel we gotta vote oh uh I'll go with zero [ __ ] that actually means I'm the final vote okay well decide up to you yeah um what are we looking like you might decide it for me wow I'm phoning the audio what is it called call the ask the audience negative one negative you can't use this Lifeline again oh that's a lot of negative ones okay the negative ones everybody reminds me of as playthrough today of Gollum where people were well we still get a puzzle people are saying call a friend call the friend choker lock balls lock box you'll find out about it someday probably I'm sure I'll watch your streams uh how I learned about the ball locking and the best superhero look like you still didn't get the girl I mean he deserves that one he didn't even climb a ferris wheel for her no he does not [ __ ] deserve that one he does not deserve that one damn it dude why are you nice and positive it's like that's not very nice is it really no yeah the second half as a reference I can also reference to notebook I believe of which he was in with Ryan Gosling but um um could it be interpreted that he's simply joking he doesn't actually mean he deserves that one because the second half is a reference to Ryan Gosling doing that to get a date with her in that movie uh I don't know how do we maybe maybe it gets elaborated on and like subsequent let's give it another listen does he sound serious or joking I mean he deserves that one he didn't even climb a ferris wheel for her what I'm not a joke I think I think it's a joke okay all right it was a joke what are you doing let's see what comes on here wait hold on now I can't remember if I wrote down negative one which one is this 13 hang on that's just that saying loves you okay uh I'll just I'm gonna I'm gonna undo my recently how many negative ones we had in a row just one now right I think it was just the one the one it was gonna be two you know it's just one okay it yeah uh that old classic Jesus trick sorry illusion Michael what an illusion yeah he does it he's specifically getting her wine that's the point of that but yeah yeah I wish I'd have been different no no to this do not do this at the wedding you want to apologize I'll let them know how you feel great you have literally every other day you're playing yourself strange he is actively engaging in this conversation wait did he give that a win that's a great Point holy [ __ ] wait what is this observation that it's like us it's a win because it's in character but that wasn't part of what he said is that what that doesn't sound at all like it sounds like he's just saying it's bad like it's not that doesn't as far as I'm aware from his system that wouldn't be considered a win that would be not you know what I mean like I'm like lost it would take it away you know it's a win because it's a thing that's happening and it's a cat in character I guess I was about to say if the argument is this is kind of good drama because it's in character and it's not something that someone should do then that would make sense and then we would actually give him a point is that what's Happening Here uh but you're playing yourself strange that sounds like it could be a compliment do not do this at the wedding you want to apologize or let them know how you feel I think that it would be very cathartic if someone came up to you and apologized for something that they'd done in the past it would be like a resolution to something which I think would make the day better it was that because that's a good thing to happen right if someone I think you're right but if you watch the scene it does seem like he's probably going a little further than that yeah yeah he definitely was I think I think he drops it to you right I can't remember you can see him in his eyes yeah um I am inclined to go hyper good faith and assume he is trying to say this is good writing because strange is in character and it's it's not a good thing to do which is actually something of a like okay that's the case then that would be a point I just is his system can be it's just like sins where he can he can be confusing with it as well other day yeah find yourself strange little details like this are great so but yeah I guess that's that's what he wanted to do in the context of this character this chuggy moment isn't a cool let's get it done moment strange is emotionally struggling and also probably going into this fight Buzz it's rough [Music] he chugs that drink down after talking to Christine because that was so emotionally stressful and he chugs another one down on his way to fight someone knows how exactly how it's gonna go I think I can buy that as like that's kind of solid not a lot it's not a lot but it's it's it's more than nothing right it is it's more than nothing it is it's not explicitly highlighted and it's something you can draw being like strange drinks in order to feel better about situations either way what a masterful exit a king at the height of his craft it's not showing off if it's what you were born to do I mean it is but if Megamind can do what strange can do it um at the height of his craft is I mean what we're about to see is definitely against that oh well I guess she's talking about what's happening right away with a masterful exit I quite like that the transition into his uh outfit um but like his compliment is too strange himself yes um it's not showing off if it's what you were born to do is that like a preemptive like he's showing off and that's bad but it's not bad because it's just what he does it's uh I don't know I'm trying to figure out what his compliment is if it's to the character writing or if it's just to the Spanish like this is a cool way of showing that he's really competent that would be my guess it's like a really straightforward honest like pretty quick like few seconds where I've shown that he's confident just but if he's sort of gracefully leaps up about me confident I guess yeah he is being confident if he's talking about him being competent then that start I think that starts to approach into negative Terry territory with all the stuff that he does but surely in isolation it would count because he is supposed to be constellation yeah I guess it's not supposed to be a [ __ ] [ __ ] but they unfortunately make it so that he is with um I'll give him this one I think I'm inclined to give him his whatever yeah don't know he's on a three-win streak oh I came out of nowhere wow another height of his craft it's not showing off if it's what you were born to do I mean it is but if Megamind can do it strange can do it wait Did he just summon a monster head to stop that car from flipping up negative one there we go let me re-explain the concept of negative one is that by the nature of his compliment there he's like completely undercut the actual reality that's horrifying he like dropped a car on an innocent civilian and used a spell that was really stupid to deal with the situation his commentary here should probably be this is clear evidence that he's drunk because he's doing something horrifically uh yeah that's right you could then turn that into a compliment you could be like this is this is in line because he's just had those drinks and he's pulling out spells here that are more showy than necessary he could have made a compliment there yeah unfortunately just says this is amazing yeah didn't you say morla that he would have wins in here that uh would have almost the same wording yeah since but it would be positive yes sins is like trying to highlight how this is destructive and then wins is like this is amazing did he give us was that the one thing no that's one I thought he gave it for amazing and for who directed this movie that's one point I mean yes but if Mega Man can do it strange can do it yeah wait did he just summon a monster head to stop that car from flipping onto people this is amazing so who directed this movie oh look in the monster's faces he stares directly at strange as if he's pissed that strange just revealed him and then totally surprised by strange disassembling the box it's one point that he looks mad that he got revealed because they took the time to make sure the anime didn't Express the expression through a giant eyeball oh that's what they did but why does that get him a point yeah the anime he's got a point for noticing that like especially how this works I mean that's all the stuff he points is all the stuff that the writers I would say is different for me as like I thought everybody saw that like the drink thing was kind of like oh that's kind of like that's kind of like an above and beyond observation I thought everybody saw the monster was angry I don't think that the requirement of our points is people have seen it or noticed it well I think it's I think there's a there's an amount of subtlety in the things that you notice that make your commentary more valuable I disagree with some of the stuff that we've got in here is some of the most blatant [ __ ] ups and we give points for that yeah like you know like uh what they do to the the Illuminati everyone all over the world was pissed about that and it's still valid well like if if we were covering like Empire Strikes Back and you know we say like oh Luke's really upset at hearing that you know Vader saying he's his father yeah I'd consider that fair well what is he pointing is that the acting that's being pointed out here for the like the most oh no this is the work on the animators part which I do think is worth complimenting yeah sure um yeah all right yeah it could have had it be neutral as an eyeball but look at the expression I think he's right I was surprised by strange disassembling the Box oh that part is more yeah both of them I'll I'll give them I like I like the look here that the tentacle guy gives because he looks as Cinema wins points out he's like what the f where did my cloak go did you just [ __ ] remove it like he's like [ __ ] it else he's angry I like that yeah okay yeah for the for the bus disassembly and the the Revelation I'll give a point I'll give him something to heal them and then totally surprised by strange disassembling yeah I'm impressed by that just and I'm inclined to say that there's one he's highlighted two points but I'd say this one it's the Expressions on one yeah yeah there's a lot of them have one all right these back-to-back Expressions yeah and fun fact garganto's eye is a scan of Elizabeth Olsen's eye um that's neat yeah I guess that's okay I think I would give that a point for the same reason I give that theme thing a point like the idea that she she creates the monster she summons them so it has some aspect of her that's something yeah like that's that's like legitimately cool but I think that's totally meta if like that can't be used as a clue or anything in universe as to what's going on it's more of those like you read it on a tweet after the fact and like oh that's like that's the really neat but you know I like what is that is that a credit to the I mean it was gonna be someone's eye having it be her eye makes some sense but what does that do for the movie I suppose wait yeah from the movie you say I think no you said it is no it's a fun fact okay um I am inclined to say that's too matter like there's just no way to who's gonna recognize that here I it is too uh you'd only be able to know that there's no way you could yeah in the same thing but it is a zero yeah like if this is some stuff like it you know they said what about like you know the Jimmy Kimmel's cousin was in the first episode of Mando stuff like that would that be considered nothing I think that's nothing right yeah that's a zero that's like oh it's neat this you could be like Peter Jackson and he's a carrot it was like yeah that's neat but it's not like uh yeah this is something as in there could be a reason why the eye looks like that in universe is reasoning but you'll never be able to be able to put those pieces together those eyes a scan of Elizabeth Olsen's eye tight moment that again shows how old hat it all is for strange negative one again [Music] in there yep negative one no oh wins I was hoping it'd be a bit more neck and neck than this I genuinely do get a sense that he knows and he just can't highlight it he knows he can't highlight it it's like come on man you saw this that was insane highlights wins yeah you can you're welcome to be like though that was probably not the best spell that's how I would expect him to do it it's a concern about his Deja Vu yeah sick match cut um it looks like that see like do that in the middle they go the framing pretty pretty oh but I thought you were treating us as adults yes that's right he speaks like he you gave him you gave a win because they speak Spanish and that's treating me like an adult because at the same time like I was there two minutes ago I like match Cuts but that's a pretty that's like gonna be the lowest level of a match cut right well it's just a character standing and one portion of the screen right yeah like it's the easiest to recreate and it's the most straightforward it's just a person there's nothing more you can't draw anything out of that meaningfully you're just like that's just so it's it's a neutral because it is not a sick match cut it just is one yeah and I um I'm I'm super inclined to complement the cinematography where necessary but like I don't know about that one that one seems really strict like are we gonna be complimenting like if he's like look a dolly it's like uh look they used you know just basic that it feels like that's that's not quite enough to give compliment to so I'd probably say zero yeah I'll go with it I would say zero as well though it annoys me I understand make a match cut yes monster Vision where have I seen that before [Music] um [Music] 0.3 or something I'm like it's something but it's so little I think this is where I'm starting to wonder like if how fair is it if it's like ah see the points accumulate pretty well and it's like every single thing here where it's just like oh see that was kind of like a neat little observation compared to like a substantive meaningful like point about the storytelling you know what I mean like oh like how much is that gonna skew just like oh yeah I mean we gave points to sins for any of his we did accuracies that was the same one as many of those how do we Wan the accuracy how we don't we don't do wait really at all do we as far as I'm aware we threw that out at the beginning it's just something I'm wondering now I know this is something I'm wondering about this is the only way Wednesday standard chance you have to make the margins as broad as possible the Monster High one like I said I would as far as I could go is like 0.3 so just round it to zero okay yeah um there he is is the chorus singing Wong because they should and it would be amazing but are they because yeah it would be amazing [ __ ] cringe which uh I don't know if it did I don't know if they actually said Wong and quiet for that uh it's kind of hard to judge that one I'm gonna have to honor zero because we don't really know I'm saying I like the music well no it would be saying the music is matching the characters coming on screen it's just I don't know that it does because I was supposed to say if they if he had said doc strange come on scream and Doc strange theme starts playing it's like we're gonna need a little more than that I think helpful drinks in make sense he's so zonked that's not why he's that's he's he was thrown through the building yeah yeah um and the cloak [ __ ] up so much in the scene uh like it the there's a couple remember it doesn't opt to save strange when it could it doesn't move him out of the way of like several he gets thrown into that building because the cloak just sits there he doesn't move him but it usually does nothing or is that inaccurate helpfulness it's like that does you're ignoring all of the not helpfulness and then he's tutoring soon it's like that's not why he's knocked out he's thrown through a building maybe that's a negative one it's just like I think I think both points he's just wrong and he's ignoring evidence that he knows it's there so it's negative one has got to be and also like how fast does alcohol work exactly he's not drank that much I don't understand no bearing on the fact that he just got thrown yeah I can't I can't like he's thrown through a building that's what did that probably yeah he's at least two drinks in makes sense he's so zonked yes the Andrew bits look as gross as I expected sound design matches perfectly it almost seems like wow so it's just like yeah like this fundamentally we're talking about is he accurately saying what things are good about this film and the under flash of whatever this creature is it does look good yeah so you know so that gets you that gets you as many points as when that is the format that they do right that's yeah all right well yeah okay yeah remember what do you say that you looked in the reflection that was the wrong direction that was one example like like given a point which means that's the rule okay all right yep no essentially custom to power in the presence of the sorcerer's Supreme yeah I'm aware of the Customs it's almost like strangers read the comics and knows he's supposed to be sorcerer's supreme but glad to see is handling it with so much maturity he's just he's passive aggressive because he was sorcerer Supreme not because he read the comics um which I know it's a joke I'm just saying that like is that is that enough to be a point or is that a zero that's just a zero I think because people think it's a joke so it's a zero but he's he's correct he is being passive aggressive because he believes he should be the sorcerer Supreme or is he saying the reason is because of the comics I'm that's the joke part I'm sure no that's the joke okay of course it's not the comics like that can't be a real point oh yeah we know that but you know I wonder oh no like a cinema wins can't be making a real Point like oh yeah Doctor Strange In This film has read Marvel Comics what I'm saying too is like he why the reason why he's being this way I think he's just taking an opportunity to make a joke about it he's obvious I I would have to say we must understand that he's highlighting this because it is true that strange is annoyed that he's not super sorcerer Supreme right now yeah I guess that that would be an accurate description of what's Happening yeah I mean I think that's enough I should probably fine with it there's gonna be people in the world especially because they don't watch all these movies they'll be like why is is he like annoyed at Wong he'd be like yeah because of this event in this previous thing and now they're properly representing that that's still something yeah and if anything I'm glad he is annoyed because it's so [ __ ] weird the whole situation so I'm I'm inclined to give him one for this everybody's saying zero I haven't seen zeros but it's it's true about the character it's true about the attitude and it's not explicit you have to put that together yeah yeah I feel like we're Bound by the rules to say that's a one y'all got baby gloves on we gave the same baby gloves to sins we yeah we were being nice to sins and I'm fine being nice to wins even though he's crazy and he really needs it was so much maturity that's incredible it takes a confident man to know that your wife dated a superhero and still think that Superhero is awesome kudos for finding a guy who's good with who he is Christine he's talking about the [ __ ] giant tactical monster I'm pretty sure if anything his character should maybe be one of Terror and concern for this yeah it doesn't really make much sense that's his reaction what's really [ __ ] annoying the hit on his character actually yeah so [Music] um for finding a guy who's good with who he is to know that your wife dated yeah he's self-assured enough that he thinks Doctor Strange is cool without it like getting and interfering with like I don't know his real life the fact that she did him yeah it's just like yeah he's still cool so like the pointers is not insecure that's like a praise of the film yes that's true I don't know um but he's he's this is literally the first we've heard him speak so it's not connecting to anything else it's just that's just that is a fact about his personality now it's not really I can't I can't figure out sorry I can't remember did their husband invite him to the wedding I think that wasn't it said that he liked Doctor Strange I think she said that he's a fan yeah but I guess that is the way you'd have to make this video you have to isolate every last piece that is of of like cause and effect of another thing that's been established and ignore everything else around it because so that's that's the question then for the writing then how much can we like account for that while also ignoring that he doesn't care about the destruction going on in his home you know I think that's got to count for something that he's not more concerned uh about the fact that this is a horrifying situation so then does is that enough to skew it into negative territory is that it should yeah because wins has taken the opportunity after this to complement him on his characteristics instead of criticizing him which he should probably do I know that you could say these are different elements of his personality but the fact is that's what this character is this is what he's reacting with right now which is unusual you can see see that guy there to the the one actually both the guys on the left those are those are expressions that are much more accurate to the situation I would say they're like oh yeah this is [ __ ] this is a big ass monster right over there we should probably run away even though yeah even the waitress is just like I remember holy [ __ ] being especially disappointed with Christine because she like face Palms goes ugh like like there goes Doctor Strange again where it's like you know Doctor Christine would be mortified she'd be like holy [ __ ] people are gonna die also to check uh to the left of Christine there like grasping her chest like well yeah I mean it'll be like yeah it's like that's dramatic but yeah the question is where do we settle oh um right now oh this is like an element of uh you're pointing out a thing but actually if you point out the thing and it goes the other way you've decided to bring this up and so if we really look at it um hmm it's split between zero negative one clearly has uh it's hard to say yeah it is hard to say I think if you wouldn't have said anything it would have been a zero of course but by saying it takes a confident man to know your way still think superhero was awesome I mean maybe it's just it's one thing to say that maybe he shouldn't have this reaction to this Peril that's happening in front of him to praise his character for doing it when he probably shouldn't is it just an admission another angle it could be that he is correct that this is a part of his personality and that's what informs this reaction however he's not acknowledging the fact that his reaction should be that of Terror yeah yeah that's what I'm thinking you're trying to use this as a point but it's dragged down by the part you didn't mention yeah which is going to happen a lot probably and even though I'm still leaning towards negative one maybe but I'll go with zero but yeah I think it yeah superhero and still think that Superhero is awesome kudos for finding a guy who's good with who he is Christine Speedy thing goes in Speedy thing comes out oh no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no you don't get yeah negative one yep both both of them made reference to portal only one of them got the analysis right God damn it the star shape cuts the stone she was always using her powers even when she didn't know so yeah but what does that means or annoyed me that she's aware she would have seen that this is yeah yeah blowing the stone blocks yeah the stone block is cut out in the shape of a star she'd look at it and see that it glows there's always yeah like I feel like because he's trying to say even when she's the conclusion at the end of the film let's see she always was in controls to some extent they were always there but like all it does is raise more questions it not only uh can she see the symbol happening but it makes a sound all it does is identify something that goes completely ignored by her throughout the film when it could have been consequential if they're talking about it more if you don't get anything for that well it's negative one he's he's highlighted as a positive and it's actually Incorrect and the thing about it is I know why he did this this was set in the film for that exact reason it's supposed to be like C the power was always there but it's like yeah well you should have [ __ ] shown it so that she didn't see it it has come that has consequences if the power was always there and she realized the power he's always there then she should have been using the power that was always there she said she wasn't looking she totally would have seen it I don't buy it at all you shouldn't have filmed it so that he's looking [ __ ] right at it when she steps on it star shape cuts the stone she was always using her powers even when she didn't know yeah look yeah she's looking so it's the same monster the strange key pieces of one monster to use as he pleases that that is a stretch and a half I don't even I figured it was just another like set of monster arms like is it better or worse that it's just summoned things or parts of a demon that he's using is that not the same neatness as the eye thing no I'm I I'm talking about whether or not it's neat for either of those things I'm asking which of those is more neat the fact that it's just a spell or the fact that it's all from the same demon which is more neat I don't know but where is he getting them is it like but it is continuity for him to summon things it's also contributing to some things from the same demon uh do you think it's possible then um like sure I don't know why we would compliment one over the other I don't really know so then does that if if that's a conclusion we come to is that not is that not just neutral straight away well so this ultimately for some strangers using spells I don't know but right like you've sort of used different language to essentially get to the same point I think I'd probably give it to him if he was to be like look at the amazing effects on all the different spells he's using but I don't know about using spells just in general maybe if you use it in clever ways and you point that out this is pretty straightforward he just grabs the thing and then pokes him in the eye right you know so um okay seriously who directed oh dang oh dang it your hands popped out its eyeball right it's Rich it's raining Sam Ramey directed this that's what's the win there just the zero he's correct this yeah he did good whoops yeah yeah no maybe I don't know love this first that they basically know nothing about Spider-Man after no way home and I know him well no you know what no no no no no she knows everything about Spider-Man yeah please Mr wins I want you to live up to your name and actually win something man please get crap for always having these types of jokes about superhero names but it's because superhero names are ridiculous all right so like maybe I I'm making it worse man I've never understood that like personally I never had a problem with like Batman or Spider-Man or Iron Man as like names I don't know yeah she's never it's never taken me out of a story ever version of Spider-Man so America's not wrong for asking questions just well no but but that remember that was only part of your observation part of your observation is ah see that's good continuity that doctor strange doesn't the opposite understand or no so yeah that's negative one I'm sorry therefore with the amount of clip you're showing their wins oh let me let me guess oh Sam Remy beats and they go back and forth I'm gonna take off 47 points it feels grotesque the second time it feels comedic like prove it kiddo I'm dead it feels committed it's like oh [ __ ] here's an alternate version of me that died yeah I think that's a zero yeah I'm just worried of like the tone of a scene I certainly don't get the sense that it was supposed to be comedic I really don't no I don't think that you're meant to laugh will you understand this movie without watching One Division probably should you not that's great if anything should you what was the win I don't know was it was one division music The One Division oh you have to listen to what he says right you can't just so it's like should you watch One Division it's like Pro probably but do you really good it sounded like the wind was one division is good which would just be a zero uh uh sure all right he said he said uh if he's if the statement is one division's good that'd be a negative one no no no he said that's right he says yeah that's great and honestly yeah let's just we actually what do we think does the film make more or less sense with one division like probably less I think because because you've got to be wondering why the hell aren't you talking about Vision more when he was a pretty prominent part of One Division for starters yeah there's a lot of things to question once you watch One Division yeah so that edge is the comment to a negative one but I think we'll just sell a lot of zero we sell on zero zero zero I think that's fair actually I know a lot of people yeah emcu stuff is too interconnected and you can't just enjoy staying alone these days but I love that the shows and movies are so connected they [ __ ] each other up is what you actually mean to say yeah kind of in the dark and there weren't any wikis to get you up to date so I guess I'm saying consume all content you plebs yeah that seems right down right like because it's not a negative anymore because he's saying that um it's all like the film makes more sense and works better with which it doesn't apply a negative one to the last one too or ah [ __ ] it's this is hard um my my brain also people are very upset by the consume um we know that's a zero I know I hate it too but it's not a point there are a problem someone said how is that a good thing if if he was correct and that it all adds to the experience then I think that'll be a fine comment we'd probably say it you should watch the TV shows because they're great and then they add to this you know [Music] so yeah uh I don't know we're gonna sell out zero then zero rock yeah yeah zero zero yeah I'm sure I don't need to tell you it doesn't not looking good for wins right now it's the zero but that doesn't mean I have to be happy about it should I get the the tape for the pants now or later no later oh we need the snooze oh I get it oh from the mid head stroke cut to Wanda waking up and all the warmth and light being sucked out of the room it's a good Trend yeah at one point for that but yeah I was about to give him the point and then he said all the warmth and light gets sucked out of the room because it gets darker yeah I think he's just using the township language the image gets a little bit more desaturated and darker which is true well so I actually think this is an awesome cut so yeah there are compliments we give to uh to this movie and it's like all the ones that we've given was like I hope he hits them because he's got us straight away with those well we'll agree with you straight away though don't convince indeed Wanda waking up and all the warmth and light being sucked out of the room does he get two for that for the cut and for the lighting and for the lighting yeah did he give it to or was it just one is the lighting a part of the cut comes in the form of the music getting cut out and the like just it's audio and its lighting right and cinematography which you could argue is a part of lighting is a part of signature but I think two is in there hmm okay well I mean what do you guys think what I'm saying okay but I don't know everybody else thinks so is it did we give one or two points for these two things even though he only did one no he did too that's why okay wait let's try it again warmth and light being sucked out of there it was turning off yeah [Music] I think so that's two then uh well one one I gotta it's one I think he's being overly generous to himself but you know he he needs I think those things I think those things I think you need the second to have the first so to count it as two different points is not fair I'm not sure that that's true they could have done what the half of it or the other half of it you could theoretically do a different form of a cut you could you could not cut out the audio you could have it fade there's a lot of different decisions you could make and he's highlights yeah the lighting change is different from the transition to the next scenes yeah you could have it so the light and doesn't change or that it doesn't desaturate yeah given the choice between the Archer with the Mohawk or one of the most powerful I'm gonna definitely pause here this [ __ ] scene cost me so many re-uploads really yeah it's because Doctor Strange says this enormous sentence to be fair this and there's one other scene in this one taught me in future that um if ever I've written in my script like for a scene I'm starting to pay way more attention to how long exactly does that scene last I don't just put in whatever I want it's like no you have to actually help me in the editing Bay in future so yeah this one it was a nightmare oh Magic wielders on the planet it's an easy call always appreciate when they acknowledge things like this someone like Hulk is super powerful but sometimes you don't need Hulk smash sometimes you need hoax at this one out negative one the problem well you gotta you gotta elaborate name [Music] uh so here's the problem um literally anyone could help out with the situation they're not useless they're not worthless um you kind of need them and it's going to get even worse later on when they still don't call them in once this [ __ ] we don't need to go that far because I'm with you yeah I would have had a more a more reasonable direction to go as Wonder has recently done something really bad um it's probably worthwhile to consider other options before going to her considering what happened in one division it's so insane because you might want to make the some people did they were like this is a magic problem right those things were magic related they had runes on them they highlight this therefore they need they're like witch magic therefore they need a witch it's like you [ __ ] went at it with chains and Wong went at it with a sword don't [ __ ] tell me that you need magic uses for it you tell me Spider-Man wouldn't be useful at all Hulk wouldn't be useful at all Ant-Man giant man wouldn't be useful at all smart Hulk that's so they say I yeah inclined to agree with the idea of the point that it's cool when they recognize like you know what I won't contact this person for this job because they are entirely unsuitable um but that's not this so are we in negative one territory unfortunately oh I think I'd say this is a negative one because it's like it was a really bad call to make yeah getting all the information he had at the time it was a bad call yeah it only what does he say the only bug themed Heroes to help me with this one it's like oh like oh yeah cool bug theme Heroes like Ant-Man who was one of the most instrumental people would have been more useful than [ __ ] Doctor Strange against gargantos who would have gone big grabbed him and ripped him in half exactly or Spider-Man as well it's like yeah he'll [ __ ] me all guys got some crazy arrows man he's got some crazy Iron Man he's an ore themed superheroes metal theme a Year's War Machine for help he would have destroyed that thing what are they gonna do with a gun themed superhero hahaha I don't know he brought America here Captain America with freedom things you're right this is great yeah this is the thing we said they're both gonna show it and then one of them's gonna say why the [ __ ] did she fail this the other's gonna say isn't it great that she failed this yes I sort of hate the I didn't tell you their name reviews the conversation really but but no no no excuses it for me oh he was so close okay you don't have to pass out wins like I don't know hot cross buns or whatever it was all there he could have just been like yeah I don't I don't really like I Think It's too convenient uh but but because she says she's bad at lying that is sufficient reason it's not self-fulfilling at all it's like I'm focusing on the hex you see I can't focus on whether or not I remember our names like oh God she doesn't like it does not like lying therefore she's bad at lying that's just a negative here's the thing yeah I'm watching the negative coup well I mean I don't like lying but I'm really good at it or am I well I think I'm a liar if we're gonna actually die where are you I don't know are you satisfied with the character saying yeah I'm not good at lying and that's like ah see knock it away at one point even though it takes off the entire film his conclusion she doesn't like lying oh yeah that's right yeah it's not even that she's bad at it it's that she doesn't like it so she's bad at it the magic of child but like come on he's complimenting her delivery not the line itself so oh you're right that's crazy actually I am inclined to give the point because she's pretty damn good throughout the whole movie Elizabeth Olsen yeah it's just a shame that the writing is uh I'm not sure it described it as epic and heart-wrenching as opposed to she's clearly hiding a level of distraction it's like beneath it like and you could argue she's in denial that's what every mother does wouldn't um epic epic is a I wouldn't say that after it's a weird description 50 50 for me I'd be like yeah I can survive that way I probably wouldn't but um so here's the question here's the question if you point out like oh yeah the acting's good and then you deliberately ignore like the underlying logic behind the writing what how does that level I think it's fair to separate the two things the the line quality and the delivery of the line hmm if so that's uh in a reversal card this one it's not the first time it's happened we've we've been blown away by their thing and then we think about it in a deeper way and it's like you know maybe oh my God reversible to one point well to be fierce more of a like a 0.5 because epic isn't really at all wow but that rounds up to a one so if we're going to make distinctions here do you think that there's a meaningful difference between the acting as a meta and the acting as like in Universe how the character behaves so like when we complement the acting we're talking about the fact that the movie convinces you she feels a particular way so it's a compliment to the movie bill yeah I'm I don't know it's a thought maybe I need to form more well delivering a line that is fundamentally contradictory to the way that the character is acting at a criticism of the um well because like this is the talent of a real person that we're talking about how does that relate to and does it justify giving a point if it's not in service to how the in-universe character should be feeling or behaving well it depends in service to what is happening in that specification like I am a surgeon like he's pouring his heart out but it's cringe you know that I like there are there are lots of different uh ways to break it down because another way would be like is she doing good acting in universe as a character right now that she's feels a bit very particular and Powerful way about this but she's trying to come across as though she's much more calm so that's like a compliment to the character and their choice to portray themselves this way but then there's also Elizabeth Olsen nailing that performance like uh like Robert Downey Jr and Tropic Thunder he's nailing a character that is nailing a particular portrayal of it you know I mean it can get complicated with the layers but I'm willing to just give this a point same here yes big old Uno reversal there epic her sacrifice would be for the greater good how can this be for the greater good also throwing ponytail strangers logic right back at him but no it's not no it's not negative negative one yeah not the same logic I wonder is holding a [ __ ] pistol to the whole world saying I won't pull the trigger if you give me what I want Doctor Strange ponytail strange was trying to kill someone to prevent that gun from being able to go off like he's not firing it does that put this in the negative two territory no it's one point negative one right because we because we're talking about her and him and how he's like mischaracterizing I mean he's already gotten the negative points for the stuff he said about strange if this was the first we'd heard of this maybe yeah okay all right we also give out because we just we said four kind of when it's building on things that he set in stone already it's no longer like new information necessarily uh all right where every time is mentioned it'll be another negative point on top of whatever he's saying which is he's he's got no [ __ ] chance to begin with so yeah [ __ ] no hero I do it and I become the enemy I'm more sympathetic to Wanda in this movie than most but I'm not sure that line is the dunk she thinks it is Strange's rule breaking was to save existence oh wow what about ponytails strange oh how do you do that because there's no kid involved in this one no rule breaking aspect right of doing things that you're not supposed to do but it seems like he's recognizing the difference relating to the destruction of the whole will which is why Defender strange was doing it uh I mean yeah but I almost feel like he doesn't recognize like he's not drawing that comparison you know he's talking about specifically like a rule that was enforced by like the sorcerers don't do this with the time and then he does it you're also gonna try my best to ignore that and just be like this is fair in isolation at this point is strong well because he's saying he's saying this yeah one but he's about to give it a win for this Wanda's was in response to her own trauma and only benefited her I'm not even saying if strange was right but it's still a false equivalence why did you even know we must interpret that that he's saying she's incorrect but it is something that she would say question mark oh Christ why would she say that after the events of One Division I guess is what the like we'd have would she say that after coming to realize that everything she did was wrong and what it happened on good authority that she doesn't like lying therefore she must believe this okay the way this would make most sense to me is that she knows that she's full of [ __ ] but she's saying it as the best way to try and argue a way in which is why it wouldn't necessarily be a flaw but I'm pretty sure it is just her being [ __ ] batshit insane I don't want to die in which case it would probably be a floor is it the idea that she could ever be convinced in any way shape or form about that logic is insane yeah so him saying that would be a but he gave it a win he gave it a win that's why I'm confused doesn't that like flip our system like we would have said he's right and give him a point but now that he's giving it a win means it flips back it's like he's saying this is a good thing for the film it's like no um we are on the side of caution and just go zero uh what do you think chat anyone else because I'm um oh is this like the the the little neutrality at the end of this Rocky section of the video that I don't even know it's it's just so dependent on how it warps in with the rest what I'm saying is we were going to say he was right and give him a point right up until he said this was a win for the film which to me kind of defines it as a negative one at that point doesn't it uh It's gotta be a negative one yeah if you're wrong about it if it's not accurate done something like that earlier where he gave something a win that seemed confusing we just said like nothing well no because he said Doctor Strange shouldn't be doing this at a wedding but it can't but that is in character and so it was like okay so that is a win for the film um okay so when he States something that is a negative and then gives it a win then it's just what defaults we have to assume he's saying this is in character for Wonder and I'm trying to say it's such a batshit stupid perspective that the only way you could argue it is in characters that she's simply trying to convince strange but why would he be convinced by that of course okay yeah all right negative one that's yeah no good it's hard to argue anything else but that's the thing about these videos is that they just say things and then ding sometimes they don't even zero [Music] did he get himself did he give a win though yeah but that was an observation oh well then again that makes you wonder about the Wanda thing you just observing she's wrong but then ah it's so [ __ ] confusing he's making I think he's making a qualitative statement because he gives it a win right well loads of people did they said that transition was amazing I just find it [ __ ] hilarious yeah but they're all wrong you're not a film connoisseur yeah you don't know about film or how to talk about it yeah you don't know how to eat film you don't know how so your tongue still I'd settle on a zero I don't know what are you guys thinking yep I'm five or zero yeah I'm fine with zero oh my goodness um yeah sure cool thing sure that like we're talking just the score of the music no the well there's drums in universe and then they transition to being as part of the soundtrack that's kind of cool yeah uh yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah to make it diegetic in a way yeah I'm fine with that sounds all right yep Nifty little touch yeah why not [ __ ] it alrighty and you're talking green bull exciting stuff all around Minotaur live action rintra is pretty dope honestly is that he's just there he likes the bull guys that's that's zero yeah yeah um also just just like this all that stupid [ __ ] about how we don't need all bug themed Heroes but then simultaneously just have a bowl guy yeah no there's no way point I'm just saying that like we're gonna bring in the bull guy like why should he be risked I guess because he's a sorcerer if you're a sorcerer you're [ __ ] you're just getting brought in blew a hole through the head of the man I left and it met nothing yeah since strange gave Thanos the time Stone I can imagine why she'd be a little extra peeved at him no she knows why they won the day man they ultimately won I knew it was dumb as [ __ ] but they won the day this is a post-n-game movie and let's not forget Vision exists yeah vision is out there remember you can't bring up Vision as his memories and yeah she may not no doesn't she know about the camera she knows about the memories part but she definitely knows visionwork exists she knows that he exists but I don't think she knows about the restored but she would know if she was to go and search for him and figure out what the [ __ ] going on with him like she would have found that out by now but yeah the held in a grudge again strange for something that was completely out of his hands like as far as he was aware yeah it's not like he knows exactly what's even if he did though she must understand why or she really she's just that character this would be if Wanda just ignores the reality that like none of this would have happened if you if like Vision essentially got what he wanted which was just destroy the stone now because remember it's like that it destroyed the stone like before they had gone to wakanda and did all the battle and everything like Thanos couldn't have won at least as far as we were aware it seems like the time Stone maybe he could have used that to reverse it a bit more but and honestly this scene is not as far as I'm concerned some kind of like recognition that she has a personal issue with strange it's more it comes across as she's just annoyed in general yeah it seemed like kind of a it was just her because wasn't it he said like I know that you've like your life sucks and then she said that and then was like yeah you don't know [ __ ] about like sucking and it's like well I mean Doctor Strange has had plenty of uh yeah yeah potentially thousands of times to save the world yeah which is pretty bad as the experiences go that's not a fun one I know I know killing your own loved one you know um a misread of the scene or do we think that this is a fair it does use the word imagine so he's not saying it's a fact okay is that is that the escape hatch yeah I guess so he's like it's like he's saying that that's something that he's thinking about not necessarily in the film okay but then he's gonna give it a win what I mean he just as we it's it's hard it's what he just says a thing that gives a win it's hard I don't know I mean so what is it it's nothing uh um I can imagine she's a little extra peep to him this is never referenced so I need a physicist other than when she like said you know the decision that you made was okay but the one that I make isn't like the implication there isn't that she thought what he did was immoral it's just that I should be able to do it too it should be allowed to do it yeah that's it yeah so uh right yeah I mean I'm happy with zero yeah I'll I'll go with that too yeah I mean you're gonna run I'm gonna run we're all gonna run if you hear you far away enemy's voice speaking I might not even think about it I might just turn around and punch it this isn't this isn't what's going on though he's running because of some crazy like magic [ __ ] I thought it was mind control you're actually just saying run yeah some sort of suggestion of the you know thing yeah and uh that's negative one because mystery um or no I don't know is it nothing is it another thing because he's misbreeding what's happening because it could just be it's the meme right like uh yeah see you're gonna run huh yeah I guess it could be that yeah um I don't know [Laughter] we're all gonna run if you hear your Faraway enemy's voice speaking right into you I'm pretty sure she's [ __ ] with them mentally he says steal your minds right it's definitely because they remember we had a problem it's not like she had basically a magic move but they have this big magic barrier that should do things but this goes through so there's two things one Wong is explicit he's basically saying it's not about like don't run when she tells you to run guys stay he's like no steal your minds away from her control over them that's what he's saying secondly the claim of this is a joke and so it should just be a zero anyway maybe is hard to tell with him as it is with sins hmm what are We There is should we are the safety there would be zero I guess yeah yeah that's the safer position though everything in my body wants a negative one but I am going I'll stick with zero for now I guess it's yeah well it's not gonna change right because I think whatever we settle here we're probably not gonna return the Age of Ultron powers um that's not high Age of Ultron Powers it's a little it's different yeah isn't that how she always used her powers I think uh well I guess when he's saying Age of Ultron specifically like the the Mind Control part when they were in uh it was in South Africa right oh that's funny I thought he just meant the the like CG the the red lights and stuff if he means the mind control then I guess but I don't think it's quite the same right because with that deepest like fears or whatever she also had to do like a pulse into their head but I guess maybe she's more powerful now and she can just do it without it yeah I mean she is way more powerful yeah is that fair then it's a continuation this is all one point this is all one point he didn't do a ding for this part out of your ears oh wait that does clear it up then because he's recognizing that it's mind control right oh okay so then it's just one hours yeah okay yeah all right congratulations Mr wins congratulations finally get to see how powerful Wanda actually is in a wide shot where she's taken out dozens this is one of those like you know characters breathing when she's been shown to breathe before which is pretty neat it's like she was always this [ __ ] powerful she was scared yeah so that's just a zero yeah in fact it's funny to me too because she's against such useless enemies like what are they gonna do when that shouldn't be this useless what are they gonna do against who they've shown us that they are useless definitely like it's annoying they shouldn't be because of [ __ ] whole screen's gone blue what's going on there we go all right um the uh use of the mirror verse for example or mirror Dimension or uh any of the more powerful spells you just don't see them and it's like the film's decided like she outclasses all of the uh Sorcerers definitively it's like okay so you know it's like the films decided it goes this way and I just I don't buy it so it's almost a really complicated compliment like look how powerful she is we already knew that but she shouldn't be this good against them but she is but it's I mean she would be against finally part lower level sorcerers actually is in a wide shot where she's taken out dozens of sorcerers at a time for that nothing he just said Ray me yeah you've got nothing as much as I want to take away see that you want to freak someone out music boxes even the Scarlet freaking witch who's about to do this gets freaked out of Music Box he is indeed saying that doctor strange is playing a music box to freak her out you would have to bring a music boxes even the Scarlet freaking witch who's about what do we have to what do we do with this this is the mirror Dimensions he's never been in it before right yeah that's good I mean it's the double you know the double element of surely it's being brought to this new dimension of mirrors that's going to freak you out more than a music box and also the music box is not diegetic it's the soundtrack it's not an actual music box playing in the mirror Dimension surely No Doctor Strange little box in there and he wound it up that's just wrong right is that negative one I think that's I think that's two wrongs and I think those are negative one I think they add up together I mean they're you know they're paired up and he's trying to say that it's a positive thing when he just flat out seems to have misidentified it and there's no way she's freaking out about the music box when I mean look at this diegetic diet Jesus Christ nice yeah seems like people are split on whether it would be negative 201 I think it's a negative one I think there's like the little pair just sort of in a bundle here makes it a two things that aren't very well I agree about to do this gets freaked out and there's Wanda's reality bending power showing up I didn't even notice his slingy disappearing in theaters uh if you if you buy that she has reality bending Powers then why the [ __ ] didn't she pull out these cards way earlier such as disarming them of their greatest abilities don't you think that'll be the first thing she'd do and then if she can do that what else can she do she did that while she was in the [ __ ] mirror Dimension dude I don't know like the compliments attempt here is she has reality bending powers and she used them good job but I just think that that has to ignore all the times that she's not using them and and the nature of it being used here is kind of insane so I don't know if it's not negative one I give it a try so much but anyone hello uh um I feel the life draining out of me feel a little empty just at this I'm not asking how you guys feel whether or not all right man what's the question I was just pointing out that she uses them so just check this out I don't know if you've seen it there's Wanda's reality bending power showing up I didn't even notice his slingy disappearing in theaters but yeah okay so what's what's uh what's the problem so I'm posting is that negative one because it ignores all the that kind of power should be used in all kinds of ways way before this you're calling attention to like an aspect of the film and saying isn't that neat in isolation while ignoring the elephant in the room of why doesn't she use that power in a more substantial way well and is it viable that she used that while in the Mirror Universe uh the problem is like Wanda seems to the mirror it doesn't seem to do anything to her that's what they seem to do something she gets stopped in there for a few seconds at least he does um yeah but like this feels like we're all kind of are We branching beyond the scope of what he's saying here to like our criticism if you isolate him hardcore he's saying she has reality bending Powers she manages to Magic away his sling ring does that line up and it's like I don't think that I can be highlighted without being like well why can't she just you know bind them why can't she make them unconscious agree but I feel like we've not done this for some of his prior points I'm trying to I'm trying to make sure that we're being stupid if you can find one we might be able to figure out what our system is I mean I I would be happy to count that as a negative I don't think that's that feels that feels like you're ignoring a huge part of the conversation to give like a minor praise um I don't think that's oh I was thinking it was it was when we were trying to figure out about the husband right like how much do we need to consider the totality of what's going on in that moment we uh entered on zero with the logic that that is an aspect that's been continued on but it's not necessarily something that he should ex like uh it's feeling in isolation yeah you should feel more than just that it was the positive of I guess noticing a consistent character trait contrasted against the fundamental fact that like he should be reacting in a different way in this case I'd say the negative is way more substantial than the positive so I yeah I could go negative on this one all right the negative one negative one I am going to go that as well yes I don't think that you can uh you can't have your cake and eat it too in a kind of way you know you're gonna have to you might have to pick up some of the baggage if you're gonna try and count something as a win oh it was never going to reach a one there's something ever gonna get to zero at best but not even that oh no yeah that's what I'm saying he's counting it as a win so sorry full-on nightmare stuff here positive out of the water is this another one of like you have to ignore the fact that that dude is standing on the one puddle that she can even move through the puddles to grab people reflection is he simply saying getting sucked through a puddle is nightmarish I mean I guess it is yeah I think it's a zero yeah yeah yeah yeah I'm gonna I'm happy with zero for this Zero's cut I'm fine with zero come on give us some more substance wins you can do it here heck yeah Samara and this is some commitment she either cut herself on all the glass or more likely the sharp broken edges of The Gong she forced her way through sorry I have no clue what's happening today I don't know that's true wow wow she broke her bones I did that one's complicated because it's like yeah it does look like she's seriously like injured herself basically clawing away out and like that as a detail was kind of interesting but then it's like what is the nature of her being able to survive this like yeah what does that mean just reassemble herself immediately as well it's like oh okay magic magic is [ __ ] nuts yeah yeah but this was just again hey that's the thing that happened right that's why I'm not sure if I want to give that one to him or just one troll if we said to him he'd be like she's a witch and then I'd be like what does that even mean I don't know can she be killed I think that that gray area is enough to say this is probably a zero like it's it's a good observation in terms of a thing that happened but it ignores elements that are murky we have no idea how a power works so it's kind of complementing it would be like complementing the verb holes thing it's like okay you can complement in terms of setup and payoff but complimenting in terms of biology it would be like well you I guess I don't know that's just how that works there's no reason to think it works that way no veb is the best thing about that movie I think you could call up with a set of a payoff I just mean that it's saying like it makes sense that he would do that that creature it would be like does it I don't know it doesn't make sense yeah and that's what I'm saying about this it's like does it make sense that she can do this it's like [ __ ] I don't know I don't think he's saying that it makes sense I think he's just know that that's where it would have a point that's where he would get a point he's not getting a point because he's just saying that's what happened and it's like does that I don't know okay yeah that is what happened I guess um okay I guess I'm just trying to figure out the con I'm just thinking I'm just thinking about we gotta we've got to be nice and consistent here I guess yeah um yeah okay sure we could get that zero thank you loving these huge horns I know something okay all right that's a zero I like the music that's a zero yeah yeah those are some huge horns I was looking at actual horns like there's the hordes here the whole by the way that moment sounds like uh the Loki theme yeah I know some people's eyes might glaze over but we have actually that was it I thought he might make a okay that's fine the thing is if because of course to clarify if he like delved into how the music was like reinforcing whatever the tone was of a scene it's like oh well you know you've expanded on your point that'd be worth it I think we'll make for a better video it would achieve the goal better too why what is the point of the video that just says I like this it would be more convincing to somebody who is uh on the fence right about like any given part of the film it would help explain your arguments I would help the people who hate the film that come around but it would also help the people who like the film because they'd be like oh sweet yeah that is true about that that's cool this is why it's so neat and cool and there's actually layers I didn't know before oh wow it's in his name well but sometimes he explains stuff he's like sins sometimes sometimes it does it's almost like they only ever explain it when they have something that they can explain when they don't know why a thing is good they just say it's good we're doing sequences like this but I never get tired of them show me every single Universe bee World dinos and comic and paint Hydro World give me a show that covers every one of these please and thank you that's a weird phrase of a sequence that I really like in that I could watch this way better praises to make of that scene he just said like I like that there's different Wheels cinematography is awesome it's a longer version of saying I like the horns it's just I like this place I like this place I like why couldn't you highlight why it's so incredibly interesting that they chose those ones or what they are yep and how they interact with each of those environments for the limited time that they're there [ __ ] a lot of people say about CinemaSins that the reason he's [ __ ] is he just says things that are happening but no one will ever say that if you do in the context of positive oh my gosh it's the true Mysterio but also not sure how I'm gonna use it but I'm stealing that line nothing nothing that is true he was gonna play Mysterio one point yeah yeah about three weeks and if it was anyone else I would be upset but I know Ash can handle it just get that man a chance is smashing you right now oh man it's okay for you to say man that's kind of [ __ ] up kind of [ __ ] up he'd say I love Doctor Strange's new badass character he doesn't take [ __ ] from anyone I could like I could have seen that happening yeah so 838 is just I love a Black Mirror attack but it's like good what store is good from your head you think that's good it's not good it's bad negative one is so blatantly not a good thing it's so bad out of your brain they better commercialize memory in front of everybody with loud sounds you know the memory Source doesn't obvious fail it's so weird that people like Miss on it so hard young kids with intense superpowers really would cause some problems braver and style this is not the issue it makes sense that kids with superpowers would cause problems okay you're not wrong it's just you're missing a lot of uh surrounding context uh with convenience oh yeah dog steps on a bee the the primary criticism is that she has her portals activated by uh extreme pressures emotionally and apparently a bee landing on it was the first time she'd felt that and that's why it opens it up which doesn't really line up at all doesn't feel like it makes sense it's uh you know but he's he's broadened it out to a child with lots of power can lead to bad things which is true I mean yeah but like what do we do bad things if you don't know what they are and don't know how to control them it's just it's pretty bad is like the borderline like well for a child yes but like it's a borderline again where it's like I don't know if that's enough to say it's a point I don't know if that's anything nope don't think it's one I feel like we need a little bit more than just when she was a kid she had the power and therefore bad things happened it's like okay did you talk about the scene no it has to be hard to come up with alternate universe fashion but I love the subtlety of 838s subtlety subtlety everyone is wearing the same colors that's not subtle it'll subtleties everyone wearing Shades of Black and White draws attention to the multicolored flowers um but like I know but like it's not subtle I know that everyone is wearing gray in white black everyone's wearing black and white so that's not that's just not subtle like isn't that bizarre and unfortunately he's really only highlighted what's happening he's not giving us anything for why or how you can draw something from it furthermore does it's not call a tent why is it why is nobody inter uh like noticing the two people walking through with very like bald colors yeah arguably an eyesore potentially I mean yeah for the people here I mean it's not just the fashion that's Doctor Strange that's another big reason yeah yeah people should be like afraid Doctor Strange I thought you died man so great to see you differently so the problem is this is all beyond the scope of his point it's contrasting against the colorful landscapes uh okay I guess it's observations I know there's a lot of greenery I'm happy to settle on a zero for this I assume you guys this is a zero yeah this is the zero on not a one not a why would it be a one it's it's for an accurate observation of what's happening it's not connected to anything though it's like saying Benedict Cumberbatch is on screen so I don't think that's accurate all right yeah okay but you know but you know what it's distracting me about the clothing it almost I'm not sure if they did something to it in post but some of the backs of the heads when you can't see their faces it looks like the hair has been grayed out as well for some of them like they forgot to not gray out the hair if they were doing something to it subtly and uh it's it's the longer I look at it the more it looks like a filter to come up with alternate universe fashion but I love the subtlety of eight three eights different configurations weird scarf placements but everyone is wearing Shades of Black and White draws attention to the multicolored flowers and verdancy everywhere it also seems like you can't be out in public without autism again so as far as I'm aware funnily enough I remember reading this somewhere the idea with this world is that they've uh they did this for the sake of like getting as many trees and plants growing in the world as possible to combat I guess whatever the [ __ ] is going on in the world and that everyone has umbrellas and hats because there's sprinkler like artificial sprinklers constantly everywhere on certain timers that covers the whole world basically that's why I remember reading about like behind the whatever but obviously that's not in the movie at all you don't even see it rain in this [ __ ] world I would just assume that hats are fashionable here and that you you want to you know it's very very you want to wear a hat it's it's part of like your your tire well so they all got umbrellas as well that's why that that's happening it's the they have it for in case of sprinkler in case of false rain it's something like I guess the Tony Stark of this world or something made like a giant false rain that can pray across you know I I I remember reading it somewhere it's gonna be paraphrased but the thing is like he could have found out about that and talked about it but he just he just sort of went with the he was like I don't know isn't it neat that they have different stuff they could have gotten sprayed on and everyone else took out their umbrellas real quick and they were left without theirs and it could be really confusing should be like wait wait you designed the water to spray on the paths but on the plants it'd be very efficient for water if you weren't spraying something they didn't even have it in the movies no they didn't talk anymore he blew it course I wonder how many leaves blew it with other Julius nah none we've got game for ages zero what I don't even know I don't even understand what happened is that him Lee I'm assuming he's referencing him and his significant other I don't know anything about them all right hugging hello stranger no he shouldn't be so trusting of mordo he's not nice that's okay for here because his reaction is okay like that's okay but would you let this mordo get like that close enough to you that's fair I think if we're operating under America's logic which is like don't like you don't know anything plus based on yeah don't assume anything and also your version of mordo uh not a guy you want to have next to you and you're very calm with him getting close to you and reaching around you like that um like I mean it's a general correct statement that uh Dog stream should have been way more [ __ ] careful throughout this whole interaction but he says it's hugging it's a zero exactly well that's exactly how it is well it's if the compliment is the hugging and he shouldn't be doing this hugging in general right he likes hugging in general yeah but so but not this hug not particularly these two hugging character reasons just hugging in general hugging yeah exactly stuff after it okay really Nails the he didn't really think we were there as friends type hug um I guess he does kind of like nail it as a performance so is that a one I think that that's the nailed the performance but I don't know if that's accurate to what strange should be do strings should be like wow and we gave that up we gave that a plus what conversation I thought we talked about we have to figure out whether or not he's talking about stranger he's talking about Cumberbatch here although strange really Nails there I didn't think we what does it mean for a character to nail a a true feeling that they're having wouldn't that just be what the you know what I mean like it'll be under the signal unless he's like trying to come across as a particular way uh that he doesn't necessarily feel um yeah but like strange wouldn't be deliberately trying to come across as like distant right like why would he deliberately do that to this person well and he can't even see his face when he does it so that's what I'm saying it has to be a performance thing so it just has to be you must mean you should have said it although Cumberbatch really Nails the I didn't think we were really yeah yeah I agree with that but I think that's what he's going for there so if it's an acting compliment which there is Friends type hug it's not the most difficult thing to nail but he nailed it I guess yeah okay okay [Laughter] this is Sam raymie transitions man he's gonna just Ray me explanation points bit of analysis see this is true film analysis is when you know film you just say rainy rainy rainy rainy rainy rainy rainy rainy rainy choices oh he could be the drugs [Music] strange isn't seeing this no but I get this I mean just a joke oh wait oh wait or is he actually talking about the things that was put in the Sands of whatever yeah this could be this could be Representatives a lot of these visuals aren't even like things strange can see but oh but that would also be inaccurate because he only got like dizzy when he stood up so that can't be it right here that is true as well he doesn't seem to recognize any difference until he stands up Ray me I don't think he's joking so this is one of the ones I would say I guess is is a fair comment to have made but I don't think if you look at the references that it's accurate yeah okay this is a zero to me ripping off into a drug Haze would definitely be accompanied by 90s jam band Rock okay [Music] okay we'll respond anyway but this time it's the point of view of a hero who's now a baddie I know that's what is so specifically it's the prv like shot that's that's what it is you feel like uh there's nothing to dig there other than it's just that's what she it's kind of weird too what is she hiding from when she's like spiritually naughty you know what I mean yeah now now now I'm getting real confused didn't we give a point for the monster Vision uh for gargantos earlier did we yeah I think we did um well I did I think all right I think no I think help me out here chat did we or did we not if you I can't remember if we gave the point for that but I still remember what I just I don't know if you heard but what I was saying is I don't even know that it makes sense here why is she hiding She's Not Invisible uh and it doesn't matter because the second she gets to it you can't stop someone from dream walking into you that's like the whole thing yeah would be more worthy of a point than this because this is incongruent with like what is actually I have no idea why and it's not it's not a special Vision it just looks like a camera you know I mean like there's nothing I'm confused I don't know anymore but there's more to complement with gargantos because it's actual special effects involved too which is always fun anyway but this time it's the point of view of a hero I know we all have Tick Tock filters that can do this zero or is that a negative one no it's zero right zero all right yeah okay but nope that's still gonna haunt my dreams especially with the way the champagne remains still why you gotta be a dick to your old self Wanda I mean it's a cool shot yeah he said yeah he says creepy which I think I I can agree with as well like it's it's done well especially because it's like a happy thing and then it turns straight to just staring almost neutrally at you which is kind of creepy but I think we can give them that yeah yeah like he gets a point for pointing out it's creepy wow he got a point for pointing out that gargantosaurus was angry and so if he gets a point for that he got a point for pointing out that animators work to show Expressions on a CG monster which I think is good yeah well this is the same work right so well yeah and I think that's fair as well I would even give him a point for saying that the Fidelity of the sea in the mug I don't know what he's about to say but like there's a lot of things you can say to compliment it that he won't because he's just trying to fulfill enough time to make a video and that's kind of the nature of all of this is to see how well they represent the film both of them I just love the Tempest in a teapot shot teacup there's a tempest seagulls and ocean sounds to go along why but where are the seagulls are they tiny that's fine wind blowing over us as it goes over the sea it doesn't it's all it's all mind [ __ ] right so you there's any justification is fine it's just the I think he comes so close to getting a point there but then he doesn't make it like he just says what it is why he says he likes it and doesn't really expand on why and then kind of relies on you also liking it to do the work for him yeah there's no reason behind it here like I I like it clever I'll be like what's about to happen to or what's happening to her is so mind [ __ ] that it's like combining a lot of how she understands different things and that she's Associated like tea water with the sea and it's like put it in there almost as like a stretch of her own imagination and the the her brain falling apart or not being able to have complete control like there's there's something there that could be said to be like complementary to not just the fact that it's a strange visual there's something in the narrative that can match it but he's not going anywhere near it he's just saying I like it with the seagulls and ocean sounds to go along fourth wall is translucent to Scarlet Witch just look me in the eyes you didn't do anything yeah you didn't handle a lot right on that point so you get nothing it wouldn't it shouldn't be this one because they both said she looked at the camera sin win okay yes you noticed that she looked at the camera yeah I mean how is this not the same [ __ ] no one happened nice then is that that bottle by the um by the sink the spout is facing away from the sink I understand what he's saying but it could have been the last person to use it picked it up to use it and then put it back without realizing they had faced it the wrong way they picked it up so I'm trying to pick up the whole bottle to use some people do that that's okay you you can live your life that's the left-handed it would be like a comfortable way it's okay I've seen people do it I've seen it happen [ __ ] crazy let's first off this kitchen's a mess but man that that that shampoo that that's not I don't know why I said shampoo bottle it's probably not shampoo but that hand lotion thing facing away I was like what happens to get it to face away like that it just seems so strange like it would just sit there and you just tap tap on the top and obviously the spout's facing towards you so it's awful off yes sweetheart like I said you'll find me to be a Wanda apologist in this one and I love how I know why yeah because Elizabeth Olsen is a really good actress and she's really hot that's why I think a lot of people felt that way I don't disagree I'm not a Wanda apologist I'm just like Elizabeth Olsen's a really good actress yes yes Elizabeth Olsen fights with herself here it's like she's not fighting with herself what there's no fight I'm just realizing that she's making a choice about whether or not she wants to like just have fun with the kids right now oh as opposed to oh so yeah okay okay so I agree with the acting compliment if you just spent the whole video every scene of his saying she's doing good acting we might might be able to Wilson yeah I would go as far as soon she's one of the greatest actresses out there right now if she if we just had Cinema wins say that she's a good actress here and here and here and here and here like ding ding ding ding ding with that like count can you just do that over and over and over he's not gonna do that if he did maybe we wouldn't have to well and what I would say as a counter is like I do think that we should probably give multiple points instead of just her acting as good throughout like for individuals like good moments like um when she's like losing it in the finale for example that's probably one of the best parts in the film figure acting that I'd want to give a compliment to as well I'm hoping he does carbon Inception where all he wants to see is his kids faces but knows they aren't real so we refrains in this case well white this is real and this is what she wants yeah the conflict deception is as you already said it's the she can wait like every second she doesn't go and secure her position in this world and be spent with these guys but she she shouldn't she needs to go so yeah that's a bit I mean he complemented the acting which is totally fair but he's kind of got this bit I wanna know she has some crappy stuff to do still and you can almost see her telling herself okay I'm just gonna murder a few people murder and steal the power from that girl and then I get to be their mom but before that I gotta do witch girl shiz I either way her trauma is deep it feel I feel like he's off the mark a little bit it's it's that she needs to go but she loves spending time with these two but he's saying she's realizing that she has to be a bad person in order to be the person she wants to be which is ultimately that's not in it no because the way that the character is done in this point in the film is that you're all wrong I'm right and you're all able to give me what I want but you refuse to because you're [ __ ] like and I'm gonna kill you for it she's not like crying as she kills people which gets confusing because she tries to spare the Fantastic whatever they are the group illuminudi The Illuminati [Music] being careful for copyright be good I take it back though that song makes me think she should just bail it's just a joke ain't nothing we can do with the Habit a joke brutal [Music] yeah okay you're definitely not wrong about the brutality big match cut I think that one's way better yeah continuous yeah that's the point got it oh and this time as her connection Fades the match cut slips out of alignment hot dang let me see um [Music] for that one it's it's something that it's just really anyone will notice so good job do more of that yeah more of that yeah yeah station superficial I don't know if they would have made that video yeah yeah senior fellow with the Baxter Foundation okay I know Reed is about to show up but if you're a nerd and didn't have the cameos spoiled that Baxter Foundation name drop would have set off some mind players knew no you know it's it's a little bit of set up ahead of time right if we gave it the one division little note thing then referencing backs to like uh before you talk about uh yeah like he's I think that's fair it's just it's just nothing for the movie because it's relying on um is it uh well it is relying on meta but it is set up ahead of time I guess if it's like information that you find out later well I'm trying to think of how this would begin you know a Fantastic Four movie later on you got the Baxter building or something it's like oh yes see yeah yeah like in Multiverse Madness can you retroactively make it into more of a thing that's a tough one it is a tough one isn't it trying to figure out if that's just a matter really or if it should count as a bit of foreshadowing kinda I mean you'd only like could you does that have any value if you aren't aware of the meta I think it's something that could be something that's a neat detail if they pay it off later on but as it stands in this moment in time it really is only meta I'm I'm inclined to go with zero on it okay all right alrighty what were we to each other in this universe not sure why he wants to know especially since he's so happy honestly love that he wears it on his sleeve this what oh I'm inclined to give a point for that yeah give them a point yeah it's an observation that's like in character right with strange yeah it's the yeah he's clearly desperate for Christine but he doesn't want to try and get that away yeah yeah I'm fine with that yeah I agree you can give him a point shot is awesome at first it just seems like a wide shot of one to gore but then we see those tiny glowing specks of Wanda and Wong to give us some perspective of the scale of the temple it's big yeah I'll give you that one I think that's enough to give him a point that's enough yeah for me I think you did I think you did sufficient like work there yeah I think so look at how I don't agree but I'm fine if you guys want to give him a point Well why'd you disagree why do you disagree I feel it's too surface level of look how big it is compared to how them how they are small right but he's appealing to the framing right of like you spin the camera around you're taking it in the castle Yeah like your brain might assume it's a particular size and then you see them you're like holy [ __ ] that thing is huge the problem of how this hasn't been noticed before if he's praising how big it is it has been noticed before the sorcerer is considered like a forbidden area to go to right well the rest of the world I mean I I can't speak to that that's like a separate clue that's beyond the scope of the point that he's making here right so if if it were the case that everyone knew about this thing in the universe and this was still the first time we saw it it would still be valid as a as a point of it's it's mainly talking about the way that it's framed that was a point I still don't think it's Point worthy but why it's been a big deal I just I don't think that being like it it might not be as big as you like you might have thought it wasn't as big as it was but then when you look at it for a little bit longer you see how it is relative to people and it's maybe bigger than you thought it was if you assumed it was smaller I just don't see that there's a lot when do you think you would so why do we why do we like the opening shot from A New Hope like why do we like that one so much do you reckon yeah yeah where you you see a little you see a ship and it's like oh it's a pretty big ship and then it just keeps going stop I think one of the thing that's like it shows the the power differential between the the Empire and the the rebels I agree the the like the impossibility of them escaping how they're being I I guess I don't get that from this scene well this isn't going for the same things like a big castle I guess I just don't see the what about it is it is literally an attempts to do with comparison of why one works and why one doesn't I I don't know I I guess to me it just the castle revelation of scale is the connection in Star Wars we learned the Empire is powerful and that they stand little chance here we understand this building is likely ancient and full of power as well it's big yeah almost golden big I I just I don't I just don't really and it just does work for me I don't quite I just don't see it that way I suppose wonders it'll be Wonder Isn't small it's not when we connected to two things it's not they're identical the fringe's not saying this is a spaceship and that the you know you have to go a little bit this good is the one in Star Wars can't no it's trying to [ __ ] obvious it's it's the I thought that something is presented as a particular size and then it's revealed to be much larger than you thought which changes your perspective about what this is specifically framing like cinematography yeah God damn and and if anything you wouldn't say oh so I don't like this movie at all well they know we hear so like it wouldn't be you wouldn't conclude wander is small and weak you'd conclude wander is powerful look how [ __ ] enormous this thing is like I absolutely think that's valid how is that not valid I don't understand that castle is not a ship wait why is that yeah I know they're not the scale applies to more things than ships no oh it's not like it should be considered great but it's definitely something it's a trick of the way that the camera focused around he pointed it out and he didn't have to so he gets a point absolutely I I fail to understand any argument that would counter that it might be small arguably but it's still absolutely a point at first it just seems he did the thing we all wanted to do he said it was good that he explained why it was good explain why because it does something more than simply presenting the castle uh come on what's going on help help me understand if anyone needs it said me and Frankie both believe the New Hope opening shot is better there's more to draw from it of course of course it's better him saying it's awesome you can say that he's being hyperbolic but that doesn't really change the validity of the point he's probably more accurate than not if he's going with what the actual definition is this thing is awe-inspiring even if it doesn't really Inspire much or no yeah you you know what I mean like we don't give a [ __ ] because of what it just doesn't mean anything like ultimately this thing gets destroyed in this movie before but yeah you know that's not that's gotten zero relevance to the work of the camera and the work of the design of the building that's all the writer's [ __ ] faults to wasting all this stuff did something right but it doesn't yeah the whole point of the system is if it's accurate and reasonable like if it's accurate or fair you gotta wait it is remember cinemasin's got one for pointing out that the watch was on the wrong desk you got a point for that absolutely it was gargantos were shocked when the bus split apart that was like a really small like one second detail but that got a point if that gets a point this place I'm very confused but then we see those tiny glowing specks of Wanda and Wong to give us some perspective of the scale of the temple true Cinema wins Juan goes from ready to ready ready to fight in a split second um I mean project he he he's you're describing that he's using he swaps from a shield to a sword Shields the swords why doesn't he keep one as a shield and one as a sword I don't know he's ready to fight I I don't they feel like this is a zero it's just like yep he's he quickly transitions this is nothing yeah I don't know why we would think anything else why wouldn't you do that it's a friend that now he's ready to fight yeah yeah he is yeah Sorcerers do have the shield moves in the attack moves that's the thing he also has white data moves in this put him in the mirror Dimension it does feel like it's more on the level of they need to go over there and they started walking there because they can walk now it's a problem what's going on oh I don't want to get into all that are we the baddies she only has that moment right at the end for some I don't know what can even zero question mark it's so confusing this isn't it too it's like Wanda standing on her own dress strange thing statue to another version of himself had to be weird but seeing a statue of yourself in your own world in an evil Throne Room created for you with your kids at your side yeah I'd be able to you can only ignore the signs other side in that I'd be evil too no I mean he's joking no I wouldn't I maybe I I think so but the joke is the joke the joke is that this is incredibly overwhelming in terms of like prophecy and that you may as well just follow it at this point but I'm sure he's joking I know he actually means that he's just yeah I don't know this is zero I guess that's what you wanted and see what happens yeah Ultron is still a jerk in A380 yeah Carl fair question Captain cotton uh yeah I'm trying to think is there anything you can draw out of that just he's interested in the fact that his first name is Carl and he never knew that in his own Universe I guess yeah it just it's just not enough besides he didn't say anything other than it's a question it's a fair question it's like okay First Avenger apparently Haley Atwell is Ageless which works well when you're playing captain that gets you nothing yes yeah yeah I can't even even if you were to say Haley atwell's just pretty you'd be like oh but yeah that show was not great but it's awesome they let Anthony whoa whoa yeah well you got to do a cinema wins on these humans TV show hey remember do it it could still be good even if it's not great even if it's not great that's true he'll have to focus exclusively on Anson mount's facial acting and so uh let out something about attempt to do justice to the character good thing you said attempt good job or was he just doomed yeah we got a chance I like him for like the three seconds he was there yeah read Richards the definition of fan service and I've got zero complaints really that's a problem wait zero complaints as of like the two seconds that we've seen of him I assume he means overall I don't know if he means right now but if he means just right now and sure we'll find out I guess we'll find out yeah we've got zero complaints you've also got zero zero points full zeros right now is this a so it's just the reference it's not anything yeah all right joke to you well there's a guy over there with a fork on his head so yeah a little bit again Fair no no no what do you mean you don't know [ __ ] about it but you don't know anything about the guy not really anything simple your nails are strange also he should be taking this very seriously it is weird that he's not because you want to make a good impression with these people like yeah they have all the power you work with a [ __ ] Minotaur dude you know I'm a gym fan but the 90s cartoon X-men theme and that version of his yellow wheelchair cumbersome okay because all he said is hell yeah X-men theme is that different I think it feels different very key jangly like there's nothing else he said yeah remember it's the one with Wanda like that was better than this right we said that I agree this is just look it's the guy and this is the theme of the thing he's from [Music] but he didn't Multiverse there's a cure for every illness a solution to every problem there are helicopter moms who fix problems for their kids lawnmower moms who prevent problems for their kids and then murdered to make their kids Immortal okay zero points could also be considered a lawnmower on a big zero streak right now yeah but that's not what I like um one line is also an interesting glimpse into her psyche that's awesome you just want your kids so go to a [ __ ] Universe where their mom's dead yeah this doesn't work by the way no big deal and also you don't mention Vision you keep not mentioning Vision when you talk about things you want yeah enough [Music] no honesty I uh I love this race right by the way um the problem is well I'm not highlighting the other options but I mean this zero I guess yeah get zero yeah extreme honestyles that's another zero zero um falling into place you're just balling we oh that's neat had I'm happy to give that a plus I'm conceding yes but like you you would it should be counted as a negative then that he didn't have his [ __ ] surgical scars on in the opening fight they didn't put them on I I I do agree with that yeah but it's fine it's fine I'm just I'm just Patty okay that's all I'm sorry I'm sorry not sorry but also I'd like to see this story these absolute Masters went to Titan altogether as a team and poned Thanos while barely even changing barely even changing the planet it looks I can't tell it looks really damaged that could be no damage old full okay maybe just one the thing is should have made it so the insta win right yeah that's not fair oh wow it's just a smooth transition to the oh no all right no ad yet but that was like if anything that's a negative one yes he's just like forgot what happened in night of them with the insta win mechanic yeah like he's like oh wow this they took him on with even less Heroes then that's another stupid thing to say you could have eight heroes and then you can have on the other side you just have God but like they'll say here it's not gonna [ __ ] matter are they Superman versus eight like Spider-Man I don't know if the Spiderman are gonna win he built a statue the world needs Heroes firsthand that maybe this Illuminati doesn't know what they're talking about statues no the compliment there is like the dog strange is realizing that he wasn't the good hero that he wants to be in this universe turns out the reality is he'd [ __ ] up I loved that bit where he says you built a statue he's like he's like how could it possibly be that I I wasn't like I thought I was a hero yeah like this this the first instance that the Illuminati doesn't know what they're talking about the real heroes might make sense statues to folks who commit genocide not so much [ __ ] me in a [ __ ] they did they didn't know the people who are gonna see the statue like everyone who isn't the Illuminati doesn't know that's not why strangers didn't even know dreams of sex he's realizing that a alternate version of himself failed he feels partially responsible that's why he's tearing up he built a statue it's a really good small thing that happens on Benedict cumberbatch's part I've always liked that delivery the world needs Heroes first in that maybe this Illuminati doesn't know what they're talking about and that's actually like not a bad idea like the world can remember him as a hero which by the way was always his intention he never wanted to hurt anyone he did everything he did to try and save the world it was an unfortunate side who the [ __ ] you know the by dream walking you would destroy an entire who knows these things nobody no one knew it until they made it up for this movie exactly it could have been that it wasn't a rule at all so this is a negative one it has to be he's this is totally misunderstood he's misunderstood the character's reaction and I don't I don't like this whole like statues to folks to commit genocide the guy allowed himself to be murdered in case it would have any negative effects on his own universe as a result of something that he's trying to do saves the universe this is what I mean like he was a hero absolutely 100 he's like the most heroic person in the whole movie like if anything is too heroic Jane Theory just mentioned that there's so many statues on the planet currently that go to war people that aren't perfect and I know you're gonna be like odd perfect committing genocide it's like well that's pretty [ __ ] dumb to refer to it as committing genocide it kind of ignores all the context doesn't it and then it doesn't account for any of the good things that he did yeah yeah it isn't fair He just flat out isn't fair it was a whoopsie he was the reason they defeated Thanos and he gave his life in order to possibly prevent the potential of destroying his own Universe like what else is he supposed to do die oh wait what are you gonna do die literally yeah that already happened also two genocides do you does it require intent I think so it does require intent right yes I defined as the deliberate killing of a large number of people oh yeah because the homicide um wouldn't be isn't just someone dying right it needs to be it's very specific genocide is defined and it includes violent attacks of the specific intent to destroy in whole or impart a nation ethnic racial or religious group yeah you didn't even accidentally like introduce a sickness or something like that or something along those lines and yeah I'm not sure what word you would give to what he did but it's not genocide yeah um I guess Omni side is closer but even that implies intent it's just the accidental destruction of a universe I mean it's yeah the negative one actually I would say so absolutely yeah statues to real heroes might make sense statues to folks who commit genocide not so much love that you can follow each of these camera angles from their respective Ultron and as far as I can tell this continuity is flawless um um I would give the point if that's true it's hard to check it is a lot of different angles to keep track of all at once um like I think it's matching I'm just having a little look around it looks like it is yeah I'm willing to give the point for that yeah yeah makes sense statues to folks who commit genocide not so much love that you can follow each of these camera angles from their respective Ultron and as far as I can tell this continuity is Flawless just someone stumbles and loses their way no please don't just say it sorry don't just give me more than that I'm begging you because I hate that this line is here I get my zero gun ready well if that isn't the most Professor Xavier thing to say pure zero you said it I mean we are inclined to give a negative one here because of the uh the reality all of the surrounding context yeah yeah because there's no way you should say this Mr stumble Yep this talk to strange hasn't stumbled he hasn't done anything wrong he hasn't done anything wrong yeah oh yeah that makes it even worse this one hasn't stumbled the one that did quote unquote stumble if you even want to call it that is like you didn't give him a second chance when he did everything right so yeah this is kind of a [ __ ] you sort of thing yeah negative one I think it's negative yeah that has bad girl oh come on shut up at the beginning of the video if you were desperate you could be like not only does that look cool but she's making sure to Nuke like every last form of the security she can find just in case for example it could have a self-destruct or it could record blah blah blah like just get rid of everything she doesn't even need to look at it yeah you could try something anything but you got zero zero and a nice cheap the Ultron oil to give her a real carry look in St PG-13 what looks to be a blood-stained character in your you know lower level movie rating-wise I think that's worth a compliment of things yeah yeah I think so it's um it's it's like again he has to stick with superficialities he really does because it's the only way he's getting points I guess are writing a lot of blood does yeah um but if you've got a lot of blood it's uh you know like when uh yeah uh uh his name Drax is inside the alien creature at the beginning of the audience like it's all yellow there's yellow Flash and yellow blood like if that was all red and guts that look will resemble human-ish ones you know just like familiarity with organs or Earthly animals that would get you in some trouble it's like gotta be careful because that looks too scary I think it's very quiet because in Halo the blood of the Covenant is uh but the people have like when you die or when Marines die there's blood but obviously like in Halo the aliens have glowy sort of oh yeah no you can have plenty of red blood as long as it's in the form of like see all the wounds they have at the end of Civil War right like that's that's fine to keep that right yeah but yeah if you had someone get their you know half their body chopped and he's like oh it's too much too much too much and so a lot of the time they'll have aliens with blue blood green blood and whenever it's a person that'll have they'll have blood on uh coming out of their nose or like a cut on their forehead like it's it's never too bad yeah uh Dusk Till Dawn had vampire eyes with green blood just so they could get away with more I'm not sure I think that movie might still be R-rated but it was to avoid getting like an nc7 oh and a great example in the reverse is how [ __ ] it can be when for example a girl gets her neck slit open in Black Panther and there's no blood not even red I don't think yeah yeah I don't know yeah it was awkward as [ __ ] or when a lot of the blood effects look clearly CGI and fake although when people get shot Water smoke or dust will come out of them at the back they'll get shot and it's like it's like there's no blood because yeah yeah Avengers almost got an R because of Colston getting impaled they had to really edit that down compared to what it was the first time you watch this moment it seems pretty baller however it's funny because they'll land with so much Swagger and confidence and they're all about to get just absolutely wrecked I don't know if confidence okay so you get you get a negative for that one because you're meant to think this is cool and you're like it's not a plus that like they're actually feeble and worthless for that one it's like you're trying to twist like this Richard's look is being confident I think he's apprehensious it's uh it's like if the gun had five bullets it shoots four and is out and it's like isn't that interesting that he thought they were more in there that sure is interesting yeah you got negative one for that one yeah that's just he's coping this is gonna be there's gonna be a lot of cope at this point yes good there will be someone left to raise them you just got [Music] every time a villain was like I'm gonna get you then like he wouldn't be a hero or whatever what like oh you shouldn't and compliment I would have gone with was that was kind of an interesting way to threaten him from Wonder and the performance is top-notch again she's selling the like Stone Face like I will [ __ ] kill you like sort of thing but instead he went with you got dunked on yeah it doesn't I guess I'll give a zero because he's not wrong that it's a it's a dunk I don't know but um it's so like you're not giving us anything you're not saying anything you can you can talk about the character motivations here oh God here we go what's he gonna say I think Wanda is just a matrix stand at this point first the glass portal and now the mouth then hey you should go watch my resurrections videos because no just stay away from Resurrection no that's almost like a negative one for whining well it's it's no it's just zero because it's a reference Matrix oh okay okay that was wise that was wise yeah you need to get past this part as fast as possible yeah oh Ray me that's a that's awesome ding this is a jaw on the floor moment at least it was for me in theaters you bring in all these characters this is not me rooting for her and it's not me laughing uh what what are we doing I think he's again repeating the point of like look how amazing and Powerful they looked and look how much they got annihilated yeah right that's not good though well it's all because they're [ __ ] everybody on the internet has come around to this position now there's no one left everybody agrees on the Italian like telling her about the math thing like everybody agrees at this point it's over it's as stupid as [ __ ] scene every one of them shouldn't be here and shouldn't be in these positions if they're that thick like it's just that that obvious so yeah one last time so there's a negative one again yeah I'll give them a negative one for that one if he feels it's worth bringing up twice we have had a long streak of either negative ones or zeros this is yes I'm not surprised no if you remember instead of a SIDS said this was [ __ ] cringe I just moved on which was the correct take he just didn't get any points for it what are we gonna get here good I could do this all day always a great line but we now know that he does eventually it's not always a great dude all day no no what are you gonna say about this bisection shadowing oh wow okay wow wow so The Logical is that uh it could feel even cap eventually gives up so that kind of foreshadows that she will not be able to do it all day that's because I guess that's a joke so it's a zero but what the [ __ ] yeah that's all you got man come on and what a gross all righty I almost seems surprised that she sliced her in half just a note of regret there she definitely knew well yes she for some reason it's only Peggy that gets given a chance uh additionally to the group chance to leave she says when you have enough she gives her a chance to I don't know why she gives more of a chance to pack it than anyone else but as if that's a reason to give her a break I don't even know that Steve would have told Wanda all about Peggy same person this is a different Universe maybe and yeah that's true too and these are all human beings anyway there were people exactly is it like oh well that's Peggy so it'd be worse if I chopped her in half oopsie so what's what is that one then that's it I mean [ __ ] that's like a tangled web isn't it it is towards the negative though this video is bad I don't know what to give it it's uh I I really haven't applied to negative one on this one um negative one from me he's just making [ __ ] up yeah but we knew we have to doesn't check it let's not check out oh [Music] as being pretty strong saying stuff louder oh my god oh damn all right so you you actually don't like tackled all the way back to like big rug about this it's so funny because right back he's gonna say like Captain Marvel's really strong he's like why can't she just [ __ ] stop it hard if she can just turn your mouth off why Black Bolt is supposed to be one of the most powerful creatures in existence right isn't he supposed to be super super powerful loud I find super interesting is the stretchy brain and as much as that sounds like [ __ ] it's the his brain could be altered less banded yeah like he's incred he's the most intelligent for a reason it's to do with the power sucks ass so [ __ ] much this is so post talk like if she just insta killed Captain Marvel if she didn't kill Captain Marvel and in a different order done all of this and fast Mr Fantastic the last one he'd probably be like well you have to understand Captain Marvel she could go fast and punch things she has laser beams I guess this guy could talk loud Captain America Mr Fantastic though this is the this is the [ __ ] that annoys me right it's like yeah I'm the super positive guy and then it's like wow these are some pretty reductive statements on like well yeah I mean this is lame to defend this crap movie but Rambo is pretty dang powerful in the comics so while she was in the comics you could just say she would be powerful in that [ __ ] film but similarly the others are [ __ ] powerful well you don't need the comments to know that either oh yeah the only one so far that gave Wanda any kind of fight the fact that it still only took about 30 seconds really should let us know how much of another level Wanda is on the no I I don't know about that like Captain Marvel versus Wonder I don't know the Wonder wins I don't think Wonder should have won she shouldn't have beaten Professor X either I don't see how like how come captain remember Marvel didn't just laser beam her light speed light speed she can't react boss she would be dominated but then there's also just he says this like it made sense like dropping a [ __ ] statue a dense object being dropped on top of Captain Marvel stop there what do you mean when Captain Marvel flew through Thanos suspension she flew through a statue that was thrown at her earlier so this is this is negative two for sure negative two I think I think we gotta go first oh my God I'm just raffled off he just rattled off several points about how like so many wrong things in the corner now the pants have fallen down they have fallen get the tape medal I'm getting the tape there it is that's the excuse people try to run but it's nothing and what why is it that Scarlet Witch can absorb cosmic power what I thought we respected the difference she's a magic person she's a witchcraft person she's not Cosmic so why do we respect that difference anymore why is that thrown out now and why is it the Captain Marvel can't suck the Scarlet Witch's power who said that this was how it works what's Captain Marvel doesn't and if you look he says like she dominates [ __ ] scholar which looks like she's absolutely smashed by this fight she's limping around yeah how many points since we made rules of like only sticking to the negative two at maximum I'm happy to just say that yeah but my God in spirit that's like a negative five include these proceedings when they return all of existence is being torn down around him as his friends die in horrific ways and he thinks he's a good existence I think we can just gloss over whatever that was well I mean exactly and he's like yeah that's you know that's more though I'm just talking no it's all right so what's that is that negative one I think it's a negative one because it's just highlighted something really stupid in the movie and then try to make a joke out of it it's like yeah you're desperate mate we are yeah shut up yes let's go past it all right dang that was a mission impossible two level close one although you know with lesser this is of course a zero because again it's just a reference yeah yeah it was close yeah you gotta hurry man that Meme is becoming all too real yeah I didn't know how much I wanted to see benedict cumberbatchia for fighting powerless hand-to-hand combat is it again isn't this so interesting it's the same thing the problem is like there is a compliment to be made he could have made the reverse of what sins did but all he said was I like seeing them fight okay he could have made the better argument which is of course what does it looked like when two incredibly powerful sources for a sorcerer's Supreme what does it look like when they're stripped of their abilities and what does it look like when one of them knows the terrain and the other one doesn't yeah that's super interesting but it's just like yeah I like it so zero points zero again oh no it's time all right what do they say is Morpheus in there the red I'm seeing red creamy nightmares that's the part you're not gonna show your kids because of what that's the reason you won't show this to your kids I don't [ __ ] zero zero yeah it says I can't believe you brought Xavier back just to kill him again and then there's the other part of me that says Sir Patrick Stewart is always a win why do you kill the part of your brain that works why why are you like yeah why do you do that do you not do you not wonder why that part of you say that are you not curious I don't know what does a part of me think that it's better self-mutilation it's better to do wins than sins why would you focus on that thing we were right there bad that's what this feels like every time yeah it's not it's just yeah it's not zero I guess is it uh that's a zero I guess so yeah he's like something else it's a win that Patrick Stewart is here which we've said is already just a zero and him coming back for this little part shows he's always a win you just gave it kind of negative because you made one point into two points well he's a way to kind of turn it into a negative one because he started with saying they brought him back just to kill him uh but it is Patrick Stewart and it is Patrick Stewart here the kids yeah you just said him being here was a bad thing like it was a bad use of him but then you say it's a good use of him so yeah so I think it is a negative one yeah negative one sorry you shouldn't have told us how you really felt at the beginning there I was wondering if Cinema Woods was gonna pull a clutch Victory by just pointing out these tiny little details and he started talking about the film more significantly [Music] hit with a 3 8 ranges cloak which is a little weird like getting a hand transplant from your mirror versus evil twin really as if any of us understand anything about how any of that works I'm going to give him a point for noticing that the cloak is the same color as that universe's cloak that's yeah yeah how the [ __ ] do you fix a magic cloak I don't know don't care we'll just move on it's gonna be so fresh are we anywhere near held captive by handcuffs that get turned off by a Subaru key fob well I mean if that was something that we designed to counteract magic well I guess isn't that the same as being like a big powerful bodybuilder is killed by a collection of metal like in his head or something it's just like well I mean yeah that's just the tech that's that's what it is I don't know everything hurts he's annoyed that it got a remote that's a zero surely yep is it all right oh Ray me this one's Remy come on with the orawanda with that low angle push in and now a slasher chasing complete with limping percentage actually because you didn't really explain the shot I don't know if I wanted we did say like him highlighting a shot exists sometimes it's Gotta Give us give us a why like he did with the uh the the the match Cuts Like give us a why it's meaningful now a slasher chasing completely is it enough that he's saying it evokes the slash of movies of of old it's a slasher killer POV well not POV just shot um herself it's like he's almost he's almost there that's not why it's considering on the edge I would probably also like that her being out of focus makes her come across a lot more like demonic and uh uncertain she's scarier when she's out of focus yeah like maybe from the from the point of view of like strange in everybody like she'd be blurry because it's the idea of her that's chasing him they're not actually looking at her so she's a bit less defined and not as visual or something yeah so what are we thinking zero one or negative well it wouldn't be negative one over there uh it's not negative it's just more zero to me it's just too descriptive and not there's no explanation here really it's just like this is what the shot is she's out of focus and then she's in focus come on why is that good though why is it useful what is it doing I think I can see through the edge but it's definitely zero yeah is it possessed by another herself and inappropriate reaction got the same one for me in theaters really really okay all right um I mean it's appropriate in Universe for sure but I don't know if that's how far are we going with this is that worth a point cheeseburgers win acts like a human being it's funny if he had complimented it for the acting we'd probably be able to give it but the idea that he's complimenting that the character would be afraid in this scenario and she represented that uh uh I don't know that's just I think that's zero isn't it oh wins let me work with something man we haven't had a win in ages oh no wait we have one gotta try it harder we had one right yeah it's it could be better and if you're wondering about it was just alerting us to what Strange's next move might be um that's kind of interesting because it is very noticeable you can shot and it's not in other shots I think the argument would be that that's would have been part of how he clued into what his plan would be rather than it's telling us what his plan is like I would have rather complimented it saying that he came to the conclusion relatively because it's dripping and it's like oh [ __ ] we're beneath we're beneath water all right I can use that the idea that it's a clue to us about what's gonna happen next and what his plan is I don't know um it's something but is it enough the to imply that this is what's going to happen next I don't know the underground suburi kind of look you're like water dripping from above I don't know just give him a point where we are like in the film right now and especially these lost few like how many minutes of just consistent negatives or nothing it's just like he doesn't talk much about what's actually like the character stuff that's going on in this film does he especially Doctor Strange which I can understand why it's because it's really hard to latch onto any one through line because there's so many but I'm just noticing how like little of the character is being discussed here everyone is asking for a Pity point I'm inclined to give him a Pity point he's so behind he can catch up though he's got sure if all of them are bangers from now on anything is possible he can do it the value that all strangers place on all christines have the correct analysis here which is that's crap that shouldn't be how it should work we got an infinite [ __ ] infinite strangers who don't care about it and there's a negative infinite amount of strangers who don't even know about Christine's existence those two characters don't even know about each other in an infinite amount of possibilities [ __ ] in my balls book I I was about to point out how long they waste I don't think he'll do it I don't think he has the balls to do it and it's almost too fast to catch but it does that's America's star on the page strangely in America I'm sorry whoa whoa whoa what just happened what just happened I'm so confused okay and it's almost too fast to catch but it does I think that's because he said all right give me what I need and then the book like opens up on a page with a star on it that doesn't stop to me I don't think that's doesn't mean it either it doesn't it doesn't require a protect America's spell he cries defeat Scarlet Witch spell yeah oh but but remember the point of the film is that defeating Scarlet Witch is just getting America Chavez oh someone could try and spin some [ __ ] what's their picture destroying the book was the book's plan or something Rhymes the pictures I mean was there a picture of Thanos when it was I was actually going to say so the pages change based on the user maybe if you ask the book for something does the book like read your mind and give you what you need is that like I guess that's got to be how it works so the Stars I don't know but what's the start tomorrow it's the America Chavez that's what I'm saying if no that's what I'm saying would it have a star for Wanda as well if she was going to use it uh maybe uh oh what like if she asked about it and then that's just like if she what could she do with it yeah what could she do she wanted right well that's the great irony of all of this if she had known what that book was we wouldn't have a problem she would just take it use it and everything would be fine yeah which is interesting like you covered with some great strange crazy book and it's just done before she even she probably did she ever learn what it was even for ever no she did a lot of context yesterday not just America Chavez it does it even makes I guess because she'd make stars when she has a star and a jack and she makes Stars when she opens portals but I don't know this this there's not much connecting this for me I don't I don't it's there's a star there sure and it might be intentional on the creators but I don't see much substance in the writing for it like but he noticed it so what is that worth probably I would probably opt for 0.5 and that would round up to one okay so one point all right yeah sure um it's a shame that he has to miss you know everything is surrounding it to point out a star I was gonna say he is very tactfully avoided everything else he's surrounded but that's a shitty story but uh like he is surrounded the you think the book of I think he would have a better baby or he's just blowing in the wind sort of thing yeah oh my God guys yeah what do you mean I pointed it out I just said that you even got it the fact that you even got it wrong at the first place I'm gonna have to get something wrong with a [ __ ] static image you kidding me no you're not absolutely I am that's a pain it's not in motion you plumbus I know it's not Emoji but like you know that this is a moving picture you know so if you go yes because I would never expect him to make a mistake in this one I think that no the bottom right be like warp 2 in the same way if this page was not right it is definitely that the pages do you think it's like a floopy looking style yeah I think it might be a floopy looking star okay so we're gonna play it then and then Rags will be maybe I'm looking at it it wouldn't change anything if it were he's saying it could be that's what I said look at this embarrassment trust yourself look at that you see wait wait wait just to be clear what's my position because like that is the way that the star actually looks on the page not that it is the first time we see it it looks floopy when it's just laying yeah it looks like a floopy star okay okay now we need to rewind now the arguments become even more interesting let's look at that there's a star on the page how was that look at that that's a normal one it looks pretty flumpy it does look at that the Flop one is compared to the bottom left actually right is actually right clearly floopy it was so cool wait a minute absolutely oh I think you're right yeah on the side they're really tidy yeah yeah look at this rag Zell oh my God it's Rags double gear I agree yeah from the jaws of Victory I snatched victory yeah so we can it's a branch W I agree it's one of my many powers incredible Arc that's crazy that is only if anything the bending of the page might make it seem more normal it looks better here when it's all bent because it's oh the book of Ashanti trust yourself drawn by hand see this Wanda actually cares about her kids I what so what do you think about the white so what is your conclusion then about like Wanda's perspective right so I guess he does realize then Wanda's [ __ ] nuts well actually does care about her kids but she but evil Wanda does it will wow I didn't have her own weird [ __ ] up way well but no but she does she also cares about a bunch of she's also insane you know what I mean like it's there it's definitely there see this Wanda actually cares about her kids what she always did what do you mean what do you mean I really don't get what he's trying to say this is this is the ultimate about Wanda this is the uh the the yeah but what's the actually is this is this like when people say main wonder doesn't that's what he means but they want it definitely does she's just insane she does all of them do so does that mean that he that is that's a negative then he's got it wrong well yeah I would say so because I've talked about this before it's a pet peeve of mine when people say actually and then refer to something that's expected it was actually really good some people saying yeah but the owl crazy wonder it doesn't have any actual kids and it's like I don't think that's what he's saying actually cares not actual kids so I don't get it yeah to say that I don't I don't get yeah I don't see the actually they all of the wanders care about the kids um I guess even the main Wanda that we have that doesn't have the kids she the idea of the kids and wanting to be with those other kids he clearly cares about them a great deal it's causing her immense distress yeah so yeah I think it's a negative one words are important and what you say actually like I said I I feel like he did this deliberately but I don't know what he's trying to say because it couldn't possibly be that evil Wanda doesn't care about kids because she does of course she does that's like the whole point of the movie It's what pulls her away from ultimate Evil is the realization that she's causing more damage than she's you know solving or whatever but I okay Delta 88 Uncle Ben's car I don't know it's just reference zero there's nothing to draw it's one of those like it's neat but why would Uncle Ben's car be here why not Rags you you bigot again I thought that the Sam Raimi reference is that this is the car from Evil Dead well it could be both well I don't know I'm sure that shows up as well I can't remember if that is Uncle Ben's card I have to check um but like that seems like the reference you'd want to go so I I like this shot um it does show the scale yeah excellent just come back in a movie filled with cool shots this is an extremely cool shot and I'm gonna stairwell to seemingly nowhere completely disconnected from what we know is reality yeah you got that one I think I'll give him up yeah I I guess I'd want it more but I think that's good enough it's reality on its reader I mean look at me do you want to be Emo too that was nothing he had two ones there I'm just saying dude yeah and we were yeah probably me yeah I know the eye is creepy but how about those pointy Spock eyebrows you got nothing for that nothing what are is he playing the pointy Spock eyebrows or creepy or I don't know I think he's just having fun nothing I guess zero I love the music oh oh no that's different oh yeah they're fine if the argument would be like he's using them as a weapon therefore they've been sharpened and they kind of resemble Weaponry yes it is a compliment of the special effects people yeah they don't look like Lilo and stitches yeah I dare I it's really inventive that's the point it's inventive inventive I don't know if it's inventive maybe somewhat but it was probably the closest thing to complimenting this scene that you can get yeah I kind of want to give it to him for that like avoiding everything else like the notes are sharp when they fly at them and it's and that it's creative inventive it takes notes off a page and then throws them at someone I guess that's like I have no idea what any of it means but sure it's it's something that makes you go oh he has done it before I think he has it's gonna be tough while talking about this scene I gotta say yeah he's had one three streak before can he get it again ah the old staff defense oh snap oh that's uh why is it like a bow staff you get a joke there so you blew it I'm sorry I thought they're not staff defense staff defense is is there is there a like a pun there like that oh yeah that's what it is that's the status I just don't quite buy like why do you say bo staff music no no because a bow is like the thing the staff is called the bow like the bow it's kind of like what people have pointed out he ruined it by explaining it it's like he could have just could have left it is this thing it's just the only thing that connects it is the word staff well uh like like I I this is a zero there's just nothing there okay I was just sort of waiting for conclusion cause I wasn't sure fair enough strange Prime got shattered into multiple Echo selves damn music okay yeah uh is that a music thing I feel like there is a compliment to be made but he didn't catch it I don't think I'm not even sure what I would say is the common one is probably to do more so with the special effects of it um rather than I don't know what you would argue is happening there storytelling wise he gets hit by the magical staff and then that turns them into Echoes for a moment and I don't see me [Music] dubstep Electro is so jealous this is how you music fight complete with Bach versus Beethoven nothing again just a win this is just cringe oh Winnie um yeah I'm trying I'm struggling to find anything that I could say is worthwhile about that but it's just it's cool pretty much I'm surprised he doesn't said Raymond yet the sound design and score here is amazing not since Scott defeated a failed vegan has it been this good and if you were unclear how dangerous the musical notes are watch the little table foreign he said it's good but he didn't really elaborate uh is it is it worth anything that the table disintegrates the close of the bowl the matter gets to it that's that's something yeah no because part of me is like well isn't it implied that that thing is dangerous isn't that like what we already know if you see the effect of the danger I guess yeah I guess it's true well the plus one here would be like the the dissonance and the the score is reflective of the visual of all the music notes getting rammed together without anything yeah that's what would be to say if you wanted to get a point like that like like a visual representation of the music and how they you know go together the table's with something though yeah I'll give him the table I guess I've gone through all the stages of grief especially because it's in the middle of the frame but I guess your eyes are just trying to pull it back okay he knows he's trying to get in here yeah and what an insane ending to the battle why was the harp note a nuke no clue who cares okay who cares wait wait wait dude he's gonna follow up actually wait what if it's because it's a single clashing note oh the whole thing was clashing yeah so I'm I'm leaning on negative one because his his explanation was not intuitive based on what we saw it's so strange and I don't I hate the who cares thing because he would um he would likely argue with many other portions that like something being in congruent is a problem like he would whenever he's willing to highlight something like that but here he was like I don't think this makes any sense whatever it's just like why why even [ __ ] highlight if that's all you got to say and then like you know the whole clashing note thing that's nothing the whole thing is clashing the whole start of it is throwing notes at him and he blocks it they all Clash like it's yeah you're talking about oh who cares who cares but you're sitting here praising it why not why not care why not yeah yeah please care please appropriate reaction yeah What Becomes of it nothing we don't give points for that right at that point reacts as she would react to that plenty of MCU characters who if they died I wouldn't even blink Wong is not one of those characters stay safe King so that's him knowing that he should be dead but he's not yeah I don't know that's close to the negative one right because that exact same thing what's in said about that scene was just he should be dead in multiple ways and then moved on and we gave him a point for that because he was correct so do we have to give the inverse a negative I think so this is highlighting that he probably should be dead but he's glad he's Knox he likes Wong I yeah then we gotta go negative one I think for the sake of fairness we've got to go negative one a more perfect line delivery I guess um yeah it was good delivery exposed you know yeah come a bundle doing well yeah I don't yeah I don't think it's good enough you a point though yeah I feel like if we're going to be highlighting you know good delivery we really should be saving it for like the best we gotta have a height here High bar for delivery and acting yeah it feels like a zero right now it's a zero yeah I feel like a very big zero zero Cumberbatch yeah it's a true zombie moment He does care what do you mean when he doesn't care is he a good actor or does he not care I'm not sure what he means but he doesn't care he's not chewing up the scenery he's like giving a [ __ ] I think it's like he's not self-conscious he's just getting fully into it that is honestly the best actors when they don't have an ego so they can let themselves go this I would argue is probably appropriate slash was directed this way the I don't know uh doesn't even care does he does he is he maybe trying to say he doesn't care about how he looks he's going for it yeah in that case um you know yeah but no one looks at I don't think people see it him you know him in his mocap suit doing smog lines on the floor and says wow he doesn't even care it is really weird to put it that way so you're like he's like oh he doesn't give a [ __ ] but like if people say that in a positive way zero because it's a little confusing with his wording and how he means it and I I mean I don't even care yes it's a true zombie moment okay a true zero moment zombie horns Danny Elfman truly stands alone I don't know what zombie hones are like horns horns you're gonna get not the thing you want please please make Ash Williams part of the MCU reference right I mean you're just never gonna get tired of monsters for three weeks stay shy and the Expressions on Christine's face um reacted to the third eye opening up it's like yeah that's that's what this is complimenting the shot he's trying to like he's saying this gives you a sense of maybe the POV gives you a sense of the monster that's the thing is I don't think this is as creative as gargantos division with the fish die and the expressions it would be funny if all the skeletons saw was like maybe semi-translucent like the demon sees her skeleton and sees through her or something he sees her heart beating or something yeah it doesn't I some doesn't feel like camera I'm gonna say zero on this one it's really nothing he hasn't really said anything he just said it's monster Vision which he only knows that because it's the monster there's nothing else that tells you that teen space you tell me all strange needed to take out guy celius was a flame strange picked that up and threw it at kaisalius but that's because he didn't know how it worked he didn't know what it was um even if strange had a flame he wouldn't I don't know that he would have done this I don't he doesn't know how it works so stop them probably yeah so I don't know what to do with this that negative one because it's like not respecting the what was happening but then again it's about a different movie I I don't know I don't know anymore zero probably zero zero [Music] it's corny as crap but Eddie Munson would love that moment stranger things reference yeah that's the thing yeah I know crazy [ __ ] hell mate we're just we're just zero zero zero zero zero zero yeah look it's [ __ ] look it's Raby look it's that character's screaming look it's monster Vision look at some jingly keys can you say something please no please don't just say Remy I beg you know it's awesome badass good is he good because of dark hole and zombies whatever badass strange guy at least you didn't say Raymond he just said he's cool you're gonna be in the very next thing isn't it anyway yeah everything he's had something like [ __ ] 12 zeros in a row right now all right I just stepped out for two minutes all he keeps saying is this is cool this is cool this is this actress this is this actor this is from Remy this is this this is it's just nothing this time it's good a machine good of neutrality Christine's reaction yeah it's cheesy it's real cheesy and strange is trying to be tough and cool and he is but your number one can always see through it and knows when you're being cringe that's uh zero for that first one there was a gymnast at zero [Music] all right no boo give me something please I think modern horror movies have lost is the Normie voice for damn Souls bring back the Normie voices that wasn't a normie voice it was just like a high-pitched explain no me please okay it's a voice yeah Mandalorian I was surrounded by water hey it's so hard to make of what's Happening he's got to talk about character now come on from America well so wait what do you think do you think that involves killing a kid my dude you wouldn't want to kill a kid now would you yeah what do you think about America saying this and also it's just a positive character trait to give yourself up in order for the greater good that's pretty much all he said it's not really anything that's not connecting anything to anything the way you would compliment it is she's come to learn this across the film through the event she suffered like that that would be a compliment to the writing right now all he said is she's gonna sacrifice herself like yeah that's what she said and after he's just shattered all over Defender strained at the beginning uh you would think that this no I know you you can get that out of him and yeah he's just see if he got anything else trust your power and while this is absolutely a turning point for strange that I want to talk about more in the conclusion I love that he can't stop zombie twitching as he delivers this very heartfelt encouragement so I'm willing to give a point on the performance from cover bash like when he's he's doing character stuff and he has to continuously do the zombie acting I think that's [Music] oh [ __ ] yeah did I mention that Benny cummer doesn't even care I'm assuming he must mean he doesn't care how he looks he's willing to go for it that must be what he's saying yeah I know we just did a conference was acting We're Not Gonna spam him okay and we wanted this the whole video oh Okay negative 1000.00 just because it's a bad joke yeah you know I'll give you what you want well that's some Ingenuity and I truly love that America well it's not ingenuity she didn't push her into Mustafa that was her obvious win yeah yeah I mean she seems pretty strong right um what I will say I'm willing I think I'm willing to give a point in isolation to the concept of this this being a way to stop her presenting her like Horrors in front of her children it's like yeah that's that's a little work right it's just there's a couple of things with life for those kids what's with America in that shock you see that she's like half of her is gone absolutely oh yeah um so yeah uh it's it's a tough one for me because like it's an idea and it's one that would work it's just there's so many other characters motivations and decisions that everyone makes to get here that are stupid but you know what I mean it's like what do we think would we give a point for the fact that this was a this was a plan to defeat Wanda that does have viability um yeah I mean I guess so if you're taking a total vacuum Innovation I think it is I'll give them a Pity Point why not knowing how powerful Wanda is to do this and hope that it turns her heart in the right direction is an insane risk oh yeah compared to knocking her into Mustafa for sure so I don't I don't think I could give her credit for using this as a plan like it works but like if I close my eyes score the game-winning goal yeah even Snow White is the E38 version with a different color dress yeah that's neat is that Mesa would that be more than that um um no I think that's a white well-known enough that it almost is uh it's like I guess you're appealing to something that's beyond the scope of the film but it's like a neat detail [Music] yeah but in this one you could see Snow White and you're like oh she's wearing the same muted colors as the rest of the people in this universe have because in the original she's got like a Bluetooth I think you can get yellow okay however you think about how come her kids get to wear color and no no shut up it would never hurt anyone I'm not a monster monster says what nice dude uh you play that scene and you don't go like what a what a what an inspiring and haunting delivery she gave for having to play this [ __ ] character but like what a great performance Elizabeth you're really trying it's so amazing to me because we know these actors have no [ __ ] clue what's going on and yet they can do that with the material you know what I mean her skill and ability Wanda apologist over here again feel for there's pretty much nothing I wouldn't do for my kids and the idea of losing them is something my would you kill a kid because I can't believe this [ __ ] man it's so stupid like the the anyone who kills a kid is [ __ ] immoral in my book but I would do anything for my kids the kids of the entire [ __ ] world the kids of the entire [ __ ] Multiverse for my kids like including killing a kid to save all of the kids she's just an [ __ ] it doesn't make any sense at all rain won't even it's so annoying to give her the passive she's doing this for her children she doesn't have any stop not really a lot it's like it's like all the characters keep pointing out to her and then she [ __ ] attacks out yeah but the pain she's showing here is no what you mean is the actress is doing an incredible job but the character isn't right yeah let's not conflate these two points yeah so performance here is very very very good but like the character is just very very bad absolutely these children in this room are interchangeable with all the other ones she could have stolen so I don't know why like she could just flip and flip the channel essentially if she wants to to put everything back to normal this is why this payoff just doesn't [ __ ] work as if it was like her kids being afraid of her that changes everything when she magic them up she created them and their perception of her it's also [ __ ] and like not considered tangible the pain of being seen as a monster in your and maybe another woman's kid's eyes yeah and I love that as well the implications that all the horrors that she's done throughout this whole movie just never phased it but it was a kid seeing the horrors that really did it like as if she thought that the kids would be chilled with that dude getting disintegrated at kamitage well she never considered how her kids might feel about all of these things or doctor I'm not Doctor Strange Mr Fantastic you think he turned into spaghetti you think she's the kind of character at this point especially with the dark holds effects and stuff that she would probably demand like you children idiot you don't understand I'm doing this all for you they forced me or they're like cope it would never stop coping right like that's the kind of character she is and then when they're like no you're horrible and scary she's like ah [ __ ] this universe I'll get a new one this one [ __ ] in reality it's pretty simple this film made a big mistake with Wanda uh that they're probably not going to be able to recover from they wanted her to be the villain and they thought that they had something like grasping at straws for like any motivation to make her one um which is interesting when like one that has aspects of like these big failings right Ultron like that was that's on her to some extent um yeah it's obviously it's on it's on Tony writes on Bruce but it's on her um there was all of the happenings in Civil War and like the decisions he made there yeah you can even say that there's something to be said about like her wanting to Vision was like okay with dying she refused to let that happen and so did the team and that was a big like thing that enabled Thanos to win essentially was that they were unwilling to they were unwilling to sacrifice Vision there's like plenty of things to latch onto but it was like the weird one division like fake kids thing was the angle that they went with and like now it's it's yeah like the characters in the place where it's like damn man salvaging her it's gonna be really tough you go ahead you go ahead I'll be quick I swear the the realization that destroys the whole movie several times over in and among other multiversal infinite blah blah things is that like so wonder what do you truly want she's like I want to be with my children but every children I find has a mother that I have to get rid of it's like there's infinite worlds baby just go for the one where she falls into a [ __ ] garbage disposal and get in there you'll be fine exactly but no we have to pretend this is again sins highlighted this wins avoids it because you have to avoid it for anything to win yeah I think it's a bit of a bit weird how her kids and these real universes look exactly like her fake kids that she conjured up in her head so the implication we're supposed to draw is that she Drew from the Multiverse when she did that when she created them she's drawing from something that existed takes the can down the road though doesn't it right because all of the all of the versions you know like how she does the illusion to show different universes they all look the same even attempt to find a way to defend it because it's so broken [ __ ] and stupid but I guess what an implication could be is that she's drawn from one Splinter like one big timeline of where those kids are her kids then she's looking at millions of splinters of that unless of course and I think this would be the correct interpretation the the film is going for no no wonder gets those particular kids in basically all universes it's great and it's just like you have no understanding of how any of this should work there'll be daughters approaches contrast sharply within Spider-Man they're all pay to pocket but they're all different age and they look different and they've had different [ __ ] lives and they've had different lives exactly and they have different powers a more mature way of doing the Multiverse this is cringe this is Mega cringe kids eyes the paralyzing that you have to sacrifice yourself and what you need for them it all hits her like a freight train yeah wait what is she sacrifice she what is she sacrificing for who she she's sacrificing herself to get them out of a situation she created for them pretty much yeah and remember she can just wipe this go to a different one there's no sacrifice the idea that she's like no these two kids particularly it's like shut up absolutely shut up there's so many there are better universes than this for her as we've gone over so as far as I'm concerned that's a big negative one he's not addressing like how any of the mechanics function he's just totally avoiding yeah absolutely there's an elephant in the room and who's avoiding it no Google why do my eyes burn so much I suck um I have to close it and if you think this turn was fast that's just what happens when your kids are involved [ __ ] off hey kids we're always involved but also not always involved because they're not her kids because they're not us they didn't stop her earlier there is still there is it's so [ __ ] insane there is still nothing stopping her from remember we talked about this America could just open a portal to the perfect world where she just died and her kids need a mother just send her to that one but you can't do that just like you can't have it join any will permanently because it causes incursions this is another thing you completely forgot Mr Waldron when you made this payoff you had no idea what you were doing they could never stick to that rule no they can't it limits all the stories you can tell and the Multiverse it's [ __ ] quite frankly I don't know how I'd really like to see Wanda getting her super happy ending consequences after all the [ __ ] that she did if it's not if uh America just gave her the Boop Oh They'll be with your kids and everything's great I'd be like oh on a minute here I don't know how much I don't think I like this I'm certainly not highlighting what should have happened it's just that there's this easy solution you didn't have to kill everything you just could have done that but never mind shown up saying hey America can you use your powers to take me to a universe where my kids are alive or I got some kids and and my version of the diet in there and I'll I don't know I'll use my magic to make up an explanation or whatever because you do that for me thanks awesome bye did she explode or magic her little self right out of there he's fine I hope there's no win there yeah nothing no certainly not if she actually comes back you're asking what happened and saying it's a win we'd have to call it a zero the closest you could get the closer you could get to a point is that he's highlighted something that you might miss but I just don't think that's enough anymore nobody misses that right surely I don't think many people would have missed it but there's gonna be people I guess we'll be like oh there is a little red thing it's too bad though could have been one hell of an incursion hey nice she's talking about them incursioning zero zero if your lady refers to your love life as incursions I don't know man uh I love hearing every Universe no it's a lie though it's not wrong I actually have to have to just say that's a negative one that's just negative one because it is true and it's not good if it's true that's bad yes you love her in every Universe you love the hood that kills people you love the hair that's a psycho you love the hair that hates you you love to hear that you love the hair destroyed like everything is possible infinite possibilities what they say unconditional love is bad that's true live America the dimension hopping there's no point because the cow guy is alive well the bull I guess bull guy is alive I'm I'm glad he's okay look at him I'm glad he's okay I'm glad that like not every sorcerer is dead I guess yeah I heard that he's getting some counseling after getting tortured by Wanda though like that's yeah watching all of his friends [ __ ] get vaporized and yeah uh but him saying he's alive what do we do with that zero sounds tight no it doesn't it sounds [ __ ] horrific and I never want to see your face again it's another zero sometimes I buy other lives and I remain I'm gonna pause for copyrights we should do that no that's [ __ ] no that's fine it was it was one of the most basic resolutions of the yeah it is resolution of that idea I don't agree with what he's saying that we should do that be like think about all of your alternate first off how is that supposed to help me like if I've got a shitty life and things are going bad for me and I watch this movie and I hear Wong saying what what am I supposed to do think about all of the ways things could have been and been like well I'm this way so well it's funny right because this movie came out not too far away from everything everyone at once which tackles the subject of how should you feel about your not lived lives your past not taken to be fair that film's like basically all about that while this one is not but it's still cringe that this one's like you know what the conclusion is okay it's fine you know where is everything that's a far more sophisticated and nuanced perspective on all of it oh yeah they spend time on it so there's probably a zero it's this there's something happening here but all you've said is we should do what Wong said that's it you could you could have made a point here no one rules but also respect they're long as [ __ ] I don't hate Wong I I like one a lot um I don't like anyone in the MCU I guess at this point except for maybe Spider-Man and yeah and uh oh wow that's sort of a pending we'll have to see what happens there yeah and then there's some like there's some like half like nebula I'd still I rock it characters like they're okay I like them I because yeah Wong was in shoe Hulk and he was terrible John Walker John Walker indeed John Walker yes of course risen to like the top five oh no um listen we did how many like eight hours or something on God you don't give it a listen if you want to know what we think you're not gonna like it no complaining about length all right yeah they gotta say short members as soon as we have this stream um so the thing about this is that it's a payoff for that thing earlier in the film but he's not highlighting that he's just saying respect yeah zero no you could say like well isn't the point that he's highlighting that I'd be like I don't I don't think that's good enough any more than that no should it's just brilliant but also respect there's something poetic about strange fixing his watch without magic the effort makes it a solid way of putting the past behind him and moving on well wouldn't it if anything wouldn't it make more sense that he uses his magic kind of in the same vein as he moved on from being a surgeon who does use this that's actually honestly what I was thinking negative one the mechanical aspect I mean I want to try and be as Fair as possible here because I thought that was okay like it's it's analysis we don't get any of that in this video usually but but it's but how accurate is it that's the thing he's doing things in a nuts and bolts kind of way and it's like yeah kind of like a surgeon did he is a surgeon but he is now a sorcerer oh yeah you're right I think it would be more poetic for him to very delicately even do it with sorcery right like having the pieces move slowly and him looking at it all coming together I actually think that the the take there would then be accurate but this I don't know that you could say like he's doing it very deliberately and slowly by hand to really put the past behind him he's like he's like a non-stack yeah it's if the connection here was like he wanted to have a more personal connection with the object itself and he wanted to like instead of just imagining magicing it together without having to touch it like a physical connection with the object physically having to do it it's like um it's almost like the the digging the grave and the uh DC movie The what is it the Snyder Justice League yeah Justice League it's like I like yeah you could just do it really really fast with your power or there was that level of like no we should do this like this normally and I'll get like so what do you put in there as well I guess it's like a deliberateness to it there's there's something there which is why I'm more willing to say zero I don't really want to go to negative one zero I'm not gonna give it negative one because yeah he's almost there I think there needs to be more like if I'm to agree with his perspective he needs to develop it more and talk about like why he needed to do it that way but like I said I think I would have preferred it if he was doing it with magic I'm still thinking about that I am a surgeon but that's just hilarious don't you say rainy come on now ah you know what Eddie Munson shredding in the background means don't you do it we're about to get the screen oh thank God kidding they weren't kidding there are no consequences face the Eternal consequences they stop if to the next after credit scene specifically for using the dock hold well no because the third eye came for the the evil strange and he had a third because that's right and he didn't do any of this as far as I know they didn't say he went into a corpse yeah just living people but what an appropriate horror the end as long as we ignore as long as we ignore the post-credit scene yeah I guess I guess you can say this is an MCU horror movie but it feels weird to say so I don't know I don't I I almost don't feel like that I know they're um but it's like saying it is a stealth game it's not it's an accident Adventure game with stealth elements in it would you say this is an action adventure movie [Laughter] oh he's fine it looks very similar to where strange met Dorman will have come to I know that's fine Dr mentioned you can figure it out Bruce Campbell also that's a Fork the mini Ash is used against big Ash it's over thank God God I've never been more glad to have that happen I was all just zeros so yeah yeah all right so now this is his big stuff yeah so the way he does it as far as I remember is he'll do like a connecting pieces without the good and he'll give them wins so we're still in it folks as you can tell he's done like he's coming up to almost twice the amount of points that um so he's just I can't believe I'm saying this but you could infer from the fact that they have similar if not almost the same length of time but wins has way more points that sins spends more time on average explaining these points oh [ __ ] oh my God it does seem to be that way Multiverse of Madness the second or third best Multiverse film of the year Well it pause it there let me use the loop real quick and then we can continue I want to make sure I am also going to take advantage of the loo wow oh I thought we were here like press nons yeah that's okay they're stalling us ringy it's just you know you can just sort of like you can go and then you can be in your little seat yeah you actually know you look like Golem what Gollum with a little piss bucket hey I just have to assume he pees there's like cloth I don't know yeah those are the collectible I don't know cloth maybe piece on that P cloth P cloth for storing piss for light up use people are already assuming that sins of one you don't know that we haven't tallied you ever know that things yet the true question is whether or not winds will actually make it to positive numbers that is the question legitimately yeah because the longer it went on the more it started being zero and negative it was eating away at his tally that was actually kind of high early on I think skewed that way more he was forced to talk about the film The Harder it got just fun fact so far uh he hasn't scored a single two wins while sin scored I think three twos damn that's it is kind of because remember uh Cinema since we what says Suicide Squad video right side Squad we every Cinema sensory we have watched before this one today we've pretty much thought was like dross yeah he's not he's not good at it's typically not good at uh but as we pointed out if there's gonna be a video he should nail it's probably on the what we consider to be the worst movie of all time yeah writing anyway um yeah are we ready we look like we're ready yeah I'm ready ready let's get some minor critiques out of the way okay dialogue is rough here and there so not uh rewrites and some obvious reshoots are hard to ignore you can track wait what do we do now he doesn't apply wins he just says the criticisms what do we do they only count when he does the ding I think can we at least give him a chance and for every good point he makes give him a point okay all right exceedingly fair so he said that the some of the dialogue's wonky I'm not going to give him a point because he didn't give us any examples no no yeah yeah you got to be more specific than that so he said you can track the discontinuity with Wong's changing hair do you think that's enough observation I think he gets a point for that for that as well yeah right then by Wong's ever-changing hair I don't really care to get into it because I think the final results work extremely well and I love Juan he's slowly I mean that's a oh that's just a negative one sorry man yeah yeah you got the point and then you lost it straight away I think that's how he does it he'll be like this thing is disgusting and horrible and terrible it makes no sense I love it I love it okay put it on my screen becoming one of my favorite MCU characters so maybe we'll find out that actually it was all seven different Wongs but I doubt it joke zero here I think Elizabeth Olsen killed it as the Baddie in this film I also think they her acting was very good I guess she acting was good but like that's not talking when you say killed it as a baddie we have to assume he's saying the performance right and that's fair yeah I think that's what my mind goes to yeah I'm gonna give him a point even though that's pretty generous because we've given him a lot of Elizabeth Olsen his good points he's been he's been squeezing that we're getting the points out of there struggle to balance that line between full evil murderer and anti-hero just trying to get her kids no that's not his fault that's the writing that's the writing it's confused because they told her to deliver these lines as a particular way she Nails it but it's confusing because you don't know how any of this is working so that's interesting because it's like she struggles he's saying she's struggling but I don't think I don't think so uh well he said wait so when he says I think it's the production yeah in that case would that be a point uh I mean I don't think they struggled they failed I think that's with something right it's true there was definitely a struggle we would just consider it much worse than he would right oh okay I'm sorry for saying that they struggled to figure out how to make her like somewhat sympathetic and like absolutely completely like in utterly I think that is true yeah um we would say they it was a disaster and he's saying they struggled since he got a point for that it wasn't bad I'm just nervous trying to help him out okay maybe there's somebody else doing the tiebreaker just trying to help out the pity points boom let's continue I understand that struggle though because she can't oh he [ __ ] it up anyway he's Justified stop doing this Wanda's a shitty terrible awful awful person [ __ ] off back on The Lunchbox but I can make her turn at the end feel quick and it's clear that her willingness to kill is a direct result of the dark hole negative negative one there yeah you did say the turn was quick it's not worth anything but no but remember he praised it he gave it a point that was quick she goes full horror villain not just because Remy wanted to have these Stellar scenes but because she compromised her morals and ethics to accomplish her goal she was warned about the darkness she did it anyway so her turn can be looked at as her finally realizing that she was not doing any of this for her kids and it was all for her no that's obviously I want you to think though because this is you have to tie this to what he said earlier about her not caring about the kids it's completely [ __ ] as analysis of course yeah yeah yeah of course she's doing it for selfish reasons quote unquote meaning that she wants to be with her children but she does care about them but yeah absolutely it's so strange to like move it around this way like if she's finally realizing she wasn't doing this for her kids it was doing it for her it's like she was always doing it for her to get to the kids because she cares about the kids she believes they would be better off with her remember they're lying about how she said that um with her and her power they would never die because she would always be able to find through the Multiverse a solution to any illness or sickness whatever they have she cares about them no and that's part of the movie's theme that I like completely it's a perfect companion to the main theme that's set up right in Defender Strange's first line this is the only way you can't control it but I can and then solidify but he's right he was right he can't control it and he seemingly can the only problem was that logically speaking he had no time to suck at Power because it takes [ __ ] 10 years you need to kill her sorry that's just and he seemed to be on board with this he was killing her anyway Biden Christine's line you have to be the one holding my life strange doesn't rely on anyone else the thing is these things that's not true he made the Illuminati well if we're talking about this strange specifically he relied on Tony big time he was dead like he got to rely on on turning in The Avengers to come through obviously it was a potentiality yeah no you're wrong you just totally wrong and where does he go he goes with all of the sorcerers to defend everything and Wong it's this thing where the movie told you that it could have been that they were like dog strange most of his mouth we're gonna make it about we're gonna make it about how Doctor Strange has father issues he just has serious father issues and the Christine and him are together now and she's pregnant and she's about to give birth as you know we're at eight months or something and that uh he's he's super worried and stressed out that he's just inadequate as a father because of his father he'll be like what okay I guess we could try and make that work the funny thing about that is it's more congruent because it's new and that we didn't get told about it this doesn't line up one of the biggest moves he ever made in the MCU was relinquishing control yep it's it's just an invented made up a new thread for this film one of many but himself he thinks he's right even when he's not and he struggles to ever admit he's wrong it's not a new message by why did you show this as a visual because he's being a dick which is not the same as being wrong by the way it's not a new message by any means but I execute it very well negative one point this is so many negative one points four again right now you just heard the theme and accepted it he's already done with the criticism spot I'm guessing I'm guessing so yeah or that there'll be light one sprinkled in that are immediately followed up with her but that's okay or no it's actually good that like that kind of pattern but they execute it very well his first step to Redemption is Justin Christine to help him dreamwalk and then obviously the big turn is when he does this so what about all the other times the end of the movie what about asking Wonder for help is the first [ __ ] thing he does in this movie yeah it's wonderful help and then they call in other sorcerers to help no he's always gonna be holding the knife the thing about this is you couldn't you can actually like just move it around so much you could never be wrong you'd be like no no when he asks for help he's still in control because he's the one that asks for help well I mean if we do it like that then there's nothing there's no references again he doesn't control this because he told America what to do and then she did it so exactly he had full control he never stopped holding that darn knife exactly Defender strange did and trusts America I hate this analysis what do you think Defender strange was supposed to do America I've been stabbed with something that looks like it's probably gonna kill me I need you to believe in yourself and defeat this monster I have no reason to think you can do that at all but [ __ ] it I could kill you and save the whole Multiverse right but why would I do that because I'm immoral it just sucks man I feel bad for Defender strange every day that poor guy gets shadowed by everybody he lets go of the knife it's a huge emotional Arc for him that ends perfectly with his bow to Wong no and even Beyond thematic stuff this film is a super easy one perfect the whole premise of your video it's entertaining you'll tell us why apparently Olsen shot some of these sequences back to back with one division which must have been a trip that is a criticism not a compliment but I guess you could say it's good that she managed to maintain um is what I said earlier imagine you're like filming you being a horrible villain then you filled the scene where you realize you were wrong for torturing people like I'm sorry wait wait what's the order for this well it's just really it would be really awkward for her right one division wandered us something terrible wrong and then tries to stop it and that's meant to be like a little Redemption thing for her and then she's immediately back to being even more evil you know in a normal video you'd be like uh despite the fact that Elizabeth Olsen Nails the performance throughout if you knew this it kind of makes it seem a little more Awkward the fact is she was filming scenes from One Division and scenes from this film back to back in different portions you know really struggling with the fact that she couldn't really know what was happening you can play clips of her saying that and then you'd be like this is a very bad way to construct your stories because it's not helping your actors and it doesn't need to be this stupid you could actually like organize it and schedule it so it's competent and that they can actually get into the stories and understand them famously Cumberbatch said he has no idea what his Arc is in this film that's not good that's bad you shouldn't say uh you shouldn't highlight that and then say that's really good that that he's doing it despite all that you should say it's bad the racing thing with Elizabeth Olsen is she said that she stopped reading the revisions for the script because it just kept getting Rewritten that's bad that is a bad thing really bad and bad for the actors it doesn't it makes it harder for them to do well and there's no there's just no shame in highlighting that it's bad you don't have to be toxic positivity is a real thing like yeah it really is Cameo is our favorite oh the cameos are fantastic yeah really because they are cameos the whole thing I don't care what anyone this is not the definition of fan service they have [ __ ] humiliated and destroyed how is this analysis made to be stupid this is an analysis then he says after but honestly what was even more fun were their deaths I don't believe that you think he's just throwing you for that negative 10 000 points he just won like oh you like the cat the cameos okay I guess I get it but then you should probably be like oh he turned him into spaghetti the other one got exploded and the other one this is all died fun like what's fun about that you like the you like the fun gory stuff because it's Ray me that's all it is isn't it Ray Ray me you just did another rainbow without saying nicely what was even more fun were their deaths so gruesome so unexpected oh my God it was funny like on the side of not liking it you have all these [ __ ] arguments about all the characters how they built up what their powers are this doesn't make any sense the motivations you're like that's bad then he's like well I think it's good and you can't change my mind okay I guess that's great Mr analysis analysis movies person YouTube video what's the point of you other than you can you could have your own beating in life I just beat these videos it just feels like a missed opportunity explain to people why this is worthwhile why they should do it again why it was a good choice give us something and if you can't maybe you have to accept like man I only have superficial praise for this you don't get Remy if you don't want him to Ray me and it's not that it's not required this [ __ ] happens what are you doing Winnie you could have said raymie I need you to like have them like they die but like make it you know like not [ __ ] this is the thing how does Wanda defeat the Illuminati is like with how it's presented it's gonna be pretty [ __ ] hard to justify it but you could find a way you have to work at it you can't just have it walk in and kill everybody Point Blank it's so bad that they all know she's coming to see her have the powers that they do and then they lose it's like okay is Doctor Strange and every performance of the character he does a great job of making I'm not allowing him to have a point again for strangers but no you know you don't get no you don't get a lot Does Benedict Cumberbatch is a great actor yep everybody knows everybody agrees like yeah this many times yes he is like probably the perfect casting for Doctor Strange yep you don't get points for that very likable anyway so just a little bit of a cocky jerk and Rachel McAdams continues to be great as multiple I think Rachel McAdams is a great actress at his best she doesn't do anything as Christine I'm sorry she's barely well yeah the most character you get from here is in the first movie and even that is thin so yeah Christine's and this isn't even our Christine's different Christine he sells the Stephen I used to love you but you're just too much Vibe but the real standout of the film is Sochi Gomez I disagree extreme I'm more than happy to say she did a good job but she's I'm sorry she's not on the Cumberbatch she was barely mentioned in this whole video and now she's saying yeah a particular performance for me it's not to me that she was 14 when they started she's good especially if she's 14 that's fair this yeah she's never not a teen in this film but it never feels like she can't keep up she does fine okay fine I mean this is another way of comment sure she had to play both the captive and the hero at times and uh sure it seems Supernatural for her it's Sochi and others like Miss Marvel's Iman balani the MCU is doing an excellent job of finding the next generation of MCU here they're doing so good model doesn't tend to they seem to cost people who are like really competent typically like his performers but the actual new generation of characters who are you really latching on to at this point you know of like man I'm so interested in seeing what you know happens next for um whose new characters that I've introduced Miss Marvel Riri Williams yeah I can't wait to see what happens with Riri Williams and wakanda and iron suit Adam I can't wait to see She-Hulk anybody is it's the way that he said it right because I didn't if he had said job in finding the Next Generation MCU actors I'd have been like well yeah kind of they usually they usually highlight like they usually grab good actors they don't often grab an actor you go oh what the [ __ ] Seth Rogen is Doctor Strange or anything but uh yeah next generation of MCU characters it's so funny to say that because that is basically the huge issue right now they are out of characters they used to have a roster of like 50. yeah but it doesn't matter they've all been burned and discarded you could have all the greatest actors in the world if they're playing characters everyone [ __ ] hates I.E Game of Thrones season eight it doesn't [ __ ] matter so good on them and if you want to make movies for the MCU someday oh my god oh no oh no he covers everything from here really it's like that's all you had for the compliments even you Mr compliments everything happens you have no idea where to start I did his glass it's fantastic behind the scenes info on how he's there anything else oh gosh that's a long ad how much were you paid ah okay wait the shittiness of this video is like did you like did did Patrick William Williams class did it like infect your brain to think that this movie was good he struggled he struggled to talk about it in a positive light because I think he like he has to know right that this film was really weak um because there was so little of uh like there in those last couple of minutes and a lot of it was just like well I really enjoyed it or like yeah that was super entertaining yeah it's kind of dumb but I don't care like I don't know it just reflects like a lack of a I guess confidence in this film but if you've sat about to make a video called Everything great about Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness like yeah it's going to be a struggle um it runs into the same problem that CinemaSins has in the opposite direction of like doing a sins video for a really great film when you like when you need criticisms uh and you're like fishing for criticisms it just maybe just make a short but accurate video yeah it's always something you could do well yeah it's 97 minutes is better right the longer the better yeah I guess yeah it's according to make a shorter video too like it takes you less time and it but whatever you know a wind counter that has over 200 it's nicer to look at as like a oh I have five wins here but anyway see you next time it's like yeah I have tallied his score right so what I have to say about this is that we had a lot of negative ones at the end that I didn't even write down because I just I was so despondent like it was just piling on so this score you have to keep in mind in reality it would have been lower than this this was a generous and we were being very generous with a lot we we gave him some pity points we were being very generous um uh do you want to just for the fun of it the four of you guess what it might be um negative 16. negative 12. uh negative 37. I'm gonna go ahead and guess some like negative five so the like I said the reality is it could be any of those depending on how much I didn't write down because we just got to a point where it was spamming negatives uh it is so it's just Cinema Sins ended with 67 points which generally we're just like that's actually pretty good good job not bad uh and he had plenty of negative ones in there but you know uh wins included according to the what I wrote down which isn't entirely accurate it would be much lower than this on a plus two the most accurate so positive it just seemed like it would be a real Slim margin if it was because the negative started piling on towards me um we need to do this again with the Last Wish and then we need to compare the ultimate results because that would be really interesting that'll be good I would agree that's the real test the cinema wins accurately and thoroughly like nailed a price for a good film or is it as vacuous as well yeah like how well do you do when criticizing a really bad film and trying to prize a really bad film we need that opposite and then maybe something in the middle if we wanted to do it a third time yeah choose a choose like a mid movie if if we can find one that would match that uh unreal a real average one oh that's a good one hmm what what will we consider that well I mean yeah but we already did that yeah like no way home maybe um one has like plot problems but High character moments it's possible we'd have to look at the rustics I don't even know what movies they cover in full both of them like you know I wonder what their coverage each would be on Quantum Mania for example but I don't think either um well that's that what what has to speak included from this both channels are [ __ ] but ultimately here Sims came out as like a channel that's not worthless there's stuff to gain from watching this video especially because they're bite size I consider half an hour bite size um especially if it's a movie yeah so you know but uh luckily we have more context on CinemaSins we know that he's like notoriously [ __ ] at his job with a lot of stuff doesn't have to be he's got both of them have the exact same problem they never go further they never detail they never really show any true understanding of like what is Meaningful in writing they mostly just just explain something happened and that's it which is so ironic because that's what we get as a criticism from a lot of people it's like all you're doing is highlighting what's there it's like I don't know we always want a context of How It's damaging to something that's established or it's contradictory to something but the amount how many times did Cinema wins just say something was there because there was nothing else to add by any of us as well Cinema Sins came out they're way ahead on that front like he did do a video now you know saying what was there but he did a lot of yeah actual things delve into it a bit he was really kind of analytical and critical yeah um hosting guests give their own scores you mean like for the channels huh well in general or for those I don't like either of them I don't think anyone here thinks yeah I don't think that I don't think Senator sins makes good videos no he makes very mass-produced videos people keep telling me that wins is so much better in general but I think people just feel that way because of positivity that's a great Theory you know that's a good idea that's a great Theory yeah yep I I love the idea of the cinema wins Channel and it could be so much [ __ ] better it uh it's not in the under this this the the idea that like it's better to be positive about anything it's more so just I like the challenge of trying to make an analysis where you are biased in One Direction you can actually find all of the most interesting complementary things to the writing slash production of a film that's cool but he's really bad at it well it's a it's just hunting for whatever can get that counter higher up right it's literally the exact same strategy as sins yeah it's just the meme it's like let's see how high the counter can go then we had like arbitrary numbers in there it's like oh this was so cool this gets plus 17 it's like oh okay but like it's just never gonna be accepted on a wider level because he's positive it's like how why would why would you go after someone who's just being positive and it's like oh I okay it's gonna be funny because if you then have like a video where you agree with the points where it's like yeah it's still [ __ ] because you didn't tell me why it's good like I agree that this is good but I'm probably going to tell you why it is good in a couple of minutes instead of going like this is good Remy ding it's like [ __ ] off nothing um well bad well I mean you know there you have it what more could more can possibly be said yeah that is yeah that is uh that's a that's an efap for you yeah white that was a very draining video I didn't have redemption in Winnie 29.88 wins 29.88 they will meet again I hadn't put this up yeah the meme the rags meme ponytail Rags is evil oh yeah ponytail denotes villainy you know it looks like a British um like producer like music you know gout for there's a guy yeah I see what you mean it does I don't get that I never knew that ponytails were evil I had no clue it was better that you know now I wonder where you wonder where he pulled that from what made him think that must have met a lot of ponytailed people that just just wants to just grab him by the ponytail and yank them around and be like why why do you why are you why would you do this why why do you wear the mark of the beast the mark of evil the ponytail why do you bear him this is the Beast Banner so so meme repository what are you up to these days where can people find you yeah um well I'm streaming uh Shadow of Mordor right now to kind of give the contrast with the uh um Gollum games uh so that's so that's what I'm doing um at the very present moment and I'm also um editing um a little uh TV series um which um hopefully you'll you guys will get to see um within the next the coming months um and uh yeah then after that I'll be back to stream repositories I've got a stream I got a uh Kevin Conroy tribute stream that um is like is in like that final bit uh before it's ready but I haven't had a chance to like do that final bit so it's kind of just hanging at 98 at the moment I've got to get back to that afterwards and then yeah just uh gonna be just um I got a bunch of notes that I've taken for a bunch of things I need to turn them into videos so that I'll be trying to do that as well so that's that's me wow awesome forward to it um Link in description and chat or at least it is if you scroll up uh mortal what are you doing what's what's up with you well that was the stinky guy that might be played as a Golem game [Music] yeah I I finished that yesterday if you want to want to go watch those vlots that are still in the playlist they're not on the archive Channel yet but uh just go to my my little Channel page and then go to the the Flim Flam playlist and then you will find all the streams unlisted there also yeah three four just this month yeah we're kicking it off this month because we got spider verse Flash and uh Indiana Jones I think that would be more forges but gosh Don you just needed to play that Golem game it was all the way yeah for just gonna be next Sunday so not tomorrow or today whatever your time zone is uh that will be next Sunday so that's gonna be good fun uh yeah and then just uh going back to my video which will be ready when it's ready um link again the correct link in description it works I'm sure of it uh fringy Rags what are you guys up to what's going on hmm well with me um I should have a dog bites video out on Monday uh tomorrow I'm gonna have I'm gonna be busy with some IRL stuff so I don't think I'll be able to work on it but I might it's not I'm not sure maybe but either a Monday or uh Tuesday I should have a dog bites out and I did put one out yesterday as well and work work is progressing on the big chunky boy for the main Channel and I think once that's done uh you'll really really like it I think it'll have a lot of staying power to repeat so there is a dog bites video out right now a new one and he talks about the old and or and it's quite a good video I thought it was rather fun made a quickie little one yesterday um for uh synthetic man Junior uh but if you uh but yeah Monday or Tuesday I'll have another one out I'm trying to get them out more regularly and um not at the risk of being spammed or spum I suppose is at the risk of being spum if you find good stuff that you want me to respond to or take a look at you know give me a tag send to my way email them to me I I would legitimately appreciate uh you know you guys looking for stuff because I'm a busy lad I do a lot so give me a yeah send them my way C is always right uh that's where I'm just working that's it working working that's the thing that's going to be what I'm going to say as well working working it's non-stop work timeline getting chunkier and chunkier as things do uh um I'm still dealing with horrible copyright issues on basically everything including the super cut for Mando which the longer time goes on the more Awkward it'll be when it releases but I what am I to do like I just that's just the reality of it one day that'll go like I'm assuming I'll ask you guys probably on the efat prior to it if you want it premiered or not I don't know anymore like chat I don't know if you prefer that or not it's you know sometimes it's just awkward or if it's it's preferred if you'd want to watch it all again it's a real great series it's just that you know it's really far away from when Mando came out now but um like the copyright Works differently on the individual videos to the main big one I don't [ __ ] know um yeah uh efat movies are still in production you gotta wait longer on that one before more information and uh there is something else cooking I'm probably not going to give information on EX I don't know if it'll happen or not um but as me mentioned you have got an efap TV series that's on the way uh it'll start up needy in the next few time who knows exactly when that's a complicated thing to ask okay chat how dare you but uh oh a lot of the things they would want the premiere okay like I said I'll ask you again when we get around to it or something who knows what you'll think but then but yeah um you know more things are getting tooled away at if you want to find me in other places I'll be on open bar on Thursdays real BBC on Tuesdays and uh you'll get your uh more Super Chat catch-ups every Wednesday and hopefully like I said the start of a evap TV series eventually but we're we're actually getting this feels the way we're getting close to the anniversary again yeah oh my goodness release just it just goes so fast uh so obviously we'll have to prep for that as well but we still I think one efap ahead um so who knows what will exactly happened with that but yeah that's about that so um thank you all so much for joining us for your uh kind and interesting messages your company and I hope you had fun but I I say you'll have to find somewhere else to go for now maybe go to sleep have some food I know we're gonna consider a lot of things you do in life since we've been here for eight hours yeah I got a few cats yeah lots of real life I'm tired and hungry and um that's about as much Cinema sin slash wins that I can take for today yeah well we'll revisit them some other time yeah that was more draining than I was expecting like that was especially wins what the [ __ ] happened what the [ __ ] okay bye bye everybody bye everybody go lock them balls hell yeah | MooLer | UCHH-ybUwH1CfJrXxnqw6Ljw | 2023-06-04 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 88,089 | 455,439 |
UdNDC-lFOiw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdNDC-lFOiw | Decluttering Eyeshadow Palettes Part 2 | everyone welcome back and welcome back to part 2 of my declutter video I will link the part one down below for you guys if you want to see that building video but that one had mostly the eyeshadow palettes the big ones this one here will go through what's left in this drawer the single ones that are in here and go through the palettes that are in here and also that's in my overflow and I'll probably bring that container down here so you can see but let's go through this one here these are just Zee pallets of single eyeshadows I mean mostly from makeup geek and on Asajj your Beverly Hills now these let me show you I think is it this one here yeah it's these right here okay I'm gonna show you the four shadows I know please excuse that one that one broke I guess I can go ahead and get rid of that one and this one's curtaincall my makeup peak yeah that one broke so I guess this one can go hey so I got rid of curtain call but these shadows right here one two three four these shadows came in a purchase with purchase from Lancome I couldn't even tell you what the names of these shadows were but these were the four shadows that I would use firm eyes as you can see there's no transition shade there's no matte shade these are what I was putting on my lids yeah not a very good look and actually I didn't think that I was looking good with those shadows but I am now getting a little bit better by watching other youtubers do their shadows but these are saying yeah those those have holds some significance to me so whenever I look at these I'll see wow I've come a long way but yes so most of these single shadows in these Z palettes are from makeup geek or Beverly Hills the Anastasia Beverly Hills one and my four Lancome one all right here's another seat palette again these are mostly my metallics my shimmers in here and another one here with with mostly meds and maybe a few shivers all right and this one here this one are mostly Matt cheese in here again Anasazi or Beverly Hills oops yeah and these two pellets these are mostly highlighters so because of their shape they're gonna stay in this drawer but you have the laura geller ones here and i believe you these are the anastasia beverly hills their palettes and I just depotted them and just put them in here just to save space this one here by Ella from the highlighter and contour palette this one's thing it's gonna be staying in this drawer here just for the shape but I really like these highlighters and contour I mean who doesn't like the pyramid one okay let me clean this out here a little bit alright now let's go with this one here we've got some Stila all right here let's go with the big one here believe this one's smoldering satin this one here smoldering set and I'm gonna swatch these for you these are staying this one here it's a nice purple one I believe this is violet vixen and this one here is peg al Piggly Oh golly I believe that's how you say it that's a real pretty red one so this one is staying this one here is kitten the popular one nice little pretty light color and this one here is molten midnight I'm gonna put down right here whoops did not do it very good swatch sorry about that guys and here's a three Peck mini two of these are the same as my full-size ones kitten and smoldering sentence so I will be giving those away to a new home and this is the rose gold one let me switch that swatch that one I know it's my baby hands I have four color pop shock super shock shadows this one by color pop this one is Porter this one here is on the rocks and this one is drift and this one's hustle I will be keeping these I really like these I really like the color pop formula this quad from Chanel this one was an impulse buy but I'll still keep it because it was on sale so finding Chanel's shadows on sale is a good thing so this one staying now these right here that's in this little container see let me turn it around this way these were also an impulse buy these were by make upbeat geek these are the loose shadows ah yeah I think I'll be giving these away I really don't need these I don't reach for these some of the colors or just not me I mean like this color right here mmm No yeah so these shadows right here they will be going I mean there's a couple in here that are pretty but I just don't reach for loose pigment so sorry to say these are going alright let me take those out alright wow look at this it's empty this is the one that was in my overflowed drawer so we'll go through this one I'm just gonna put this one here I think this will fit here okay yay hopefully won't fall on this but I've got several visi art palace let's put that aside here that's good let's get this one first this is another one by honest taja some single shadows and I have it in this quad because these were the format shadows that I would use on a go and this one will stay this one here by Marc Jacobs this is the glam Bishan palette yeah this one's staying I really do like the Marc Jacobs formula and I do like these colors for a nice natural look so this one's saying another one by Natasha de Nonna this is the the new one here which one was this one called the mini sunset palette and since I really like the big sunset palette this one is staying alright I have several here from vizier theory palettes all right let's go through these this one here is the nuance the new one the pink one I like this one so this one's staying this one here is minx I always keep the the plastic covers I just think it protects them this one here is another favorite of mine I really like this one this one you know I could take travel just stick this one in in my makeup bag and I've got pretty much everything I've got something to set my primer transition an outer corner there shimmers so yeah I'm keeping this one this one here a siren I like the colors I like this one so this one's staying and this one is Koroma I think I'm going to keep this one too because even though it is a little bit darker than what I'm used to I still would like to play with it and try to create that smoky eye look so this one's gonna be staying oh this one's a blush palette I don't know what it's doing here but it's saying you know I'll keep it in my blush drawer this one's enamored and this one by Vizier this is the petite Pro palette again it's a nice small compact for travel and I like the colors so this one's staying this one here by hourglass this one is the infinity another one that I bought on a whim but I am to keep this one I like the colors I like the the warm Browns in this one and you could also probably use this as a bronzer so this one is staying this one here it's a the Too Faced chocolate bar I think this one came like in a kit and I will keep this one I like this one I also like the the bronzer and this one so this one's staying and this one here by makeup geek so this is more singles from makeup geek and I keep this one in this little Z palette because I reach for this more and this one's a nice one to take also to travel if I want a little bit more bling like in this one and it's got two outer V colors right here a lot of good transitions so yeah this one's staying and I like the the singles in this palette right here I have three singles from Kat Von D this one's called raw power this one here a synergy and Doge this one kind of broke but these three right here I keep this with the visi aren't the more mattes palette and I'll throw these in here for travel I really do like so these are staying and I have a couple of cream shadows this one here is by Charlotte Tilbury the eyes to mesmerize and Mona Lisa and this is what I use if I want a quick makeup look I'll just put a primer on then I'll set it with powder and then I'll just pop this color on my lids and I'm good to go and then this cream shadow by Tom Ford this is spiced again I'll just pop this on my lid you know do my eyeliner and mascara and blush and I'm good to go so these are staying okay we are almost done here we've got two from L'Oreal this one here is number 202 I haven't used this one yet so I'm going to keep this one 202 is a shimmer metallic one and this one here is number 306 this is a matte real pretty warm Brown so I'll keep this one these two I've had for over two years these are just I shadow sticks from Bobbi Brown this one here is in the shade truffle and golden pink since I've had these for a while and they are cream shadows I'm not gonna keep these are giving away I'm just gonna throw it I'm just gonna throw it away this one here is golden pink and this one is truffle so yeah I'm not gonna keep these I'm just gonna throw it away not really my colors - i tints from giorgio armani i do like them but i don't like them that much this one here is oops this one here is 22 and 29 yeah I will keep these just for a little bit while longer because these aren't you know cheap and I do want to play with these some more just you know for an eyelid color like the cream shadows just put it on my lid and I'm good to go yeah this one okay this one again number 22 and this one here is number 29 yeah I'll still keep these and play with these but they're not my favorite but again I'll still keep these to do eye shadows from Kiko this one here is the number 15 a pretty mom purpley color I like this the sustain this one's number six I like these you probably use this one as a bronzer so I think that would be pretty yeah real pretty bronze shade golden there so I will keep this one too last one and it's it's kind of dirty I know this one here is by Tom Ford it's the new single shadows this one took me forever to figure out how to open this thing up finally figured out you just pull that down and lift that up this one here it's called smoked opaline I believe that's what it's called but I think that's how you say it so real pretty olive green this one was another impulse buy it's not very pigmented on my hand as you can see this one wasn't cheap and this one was an impulse buy but I think I want to give this away to a family member yeah I'm not gonna reach for it this one was just like bottom line just to see what it look like but I wasn't impressed with it so this one is going alright that's all on this one and you know what I just remembered some other palettes that was in the old YouTube room so let me get those real quick all right here they are right here let me see if I could put that there this one here I haven't opened this one yet or you know let alone use it and this one I got in the lucky bag by Beauty lish so let me open this one and this here is by Kevin o Quan this is the art of makeup palettes real pretty I think it's like an all looking one you've got highlighter contour blush and some eyeshadows so I will keep this one and then these are the snow white the 1937 collection eyeshadow palettes this is the wishing palette and they keep singing palette I did a video on these and I'll link that video down below but here is the wishing palette real pretty it's got the original cell from the movie Snow White as the cover and here's what the shadows look like sorry about the reflection there but again you know I won't harp on these too much because of the video I do have a video out there but I'm gonna keep these these are really nice collector's item palettes and some most of the shadows are really nice a couple of them were kind of dry and weren't blendable but again I'm gonna keep these just for collector's item and here's the keep singing palette again original artwork sell from the movie and here the shadows real pretty the red one was one of the ones that didn't blend out very well but all in all it was real nice so yes I'm keeping these this one here is another Snow White at the 1937 collection I should mention that the first two palettes from Snow White there from Besame and this one's also from Besame cosmetics and this one came out first and this one sold up right away and I was fortunate enough to get one and when you take it out it looks just like the books the Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs you had the seven doors embossed right here real pretty binder and on the back that's what the back looks like and then when you open it up there's a picture of Snow White with the mirror right there again with the plastic I know I keep the plastic but just think it protects my shadows so here's a little plastic overlay right here and it kind of tells you the colors that were used on her face so you remove that and there's a pretty picture of Snow White and here's the story of how Besame cosmetics was able to do this income in collaboration with the Disney Department and here are the shadows right here and again these were the exact colors that was used in the movie and these are all matte shadows let me take this plastic cover off but again all matte shadows and this one here I've used it you know a couple of times and I really like it but again I'm keeping it just for collectors items because it is a beautiful beautiful beautiful palette at least the packaging I mean that's just real pretty so this one I'm keeping and this one here is by profusion this is the mixed metals eyes and lips in the shade peach I bought this at Target and this whole package was $10 so I was gonna try this out and see if it was worth $10 and here's what the eye shadows look like I think that's a good angle right there but those are the shades right there it's got some mattes and some shimmers and it comes with a lip pencil a brush and a lipstick or a lip lip cream so I had this off to the side so I could you know maybe do a video on this palette hopefully soon hopefully soon but that's why it wasn't in this drawer so for $10 really can't go wrong with that so this one's saying alright I guess now you could say that I have decluttered let me move this dirty thing out of the way and we've got an empty drawer yay so yeah we finally have an empty drawer and I can't wait to fit the palettes back in here in an organized neat manner and it will probably be a lot more accessible to get the palettes through this drawer and hopefully I've made some room for some new palettes coming their way alright you guys thank you so much for watching my declutter video the part 2 part 1 and part 2 if you like this video please give it a thumbs up and hit the subscribe button so you can see more videos like this and you all have a wonderful day and I'll see you next time bye bye you | Heba S | UCcGGmF1WBs72qejBT_q3Azw | 2018-05-28 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,913 | 14,458 |
HqhcA6tQcWg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HqhcA6tQcWg | Tokyo In Tulsa by Fly The Coop MC Swab | I'm MC swamp next stop tokyo in tulsa oklahoma is largest anime pop culture extravaganza anything goes as these attendees love to dress up as their favorite animated character it's like halloween in july and so cosplay is actually what does that really mean I don't really know it's like a costume play is actually what it's derived I like acting out as your favorite character but dressing up and that's with a much more mainstream it's no longer the fringe group so anything goes here anything goes and the craftsmanship in them is amazing yeah and how long did it take you to make this I have 300 hours invested in 300 hours and you were how old nine you're nine and you came and made this costume all by yourself yes how did you do it um let's sweat and tears Wow it was it really hard to do yeah it took about eight months eight months what they keep taking picture that I do because you're so cute you like it in there yeah is it but but it gets a little hot okay now floor mats I'll like the puzzle piece for mass you can get at walmart i love tokyo in tulsa because i'm with my people all of my nerds I'm of the accepting act this year the family-friendly convention and if people are kind and no one has run into my wings on purpose and so why do you like being him I love being him because I that everyone should want to look up to someone who wants to see people do good and injustice and that's a beautiful thing you're at a dentist you're a teacher you're a project manager yeah I don't got all walks of light and it brings everybody together because why because we love anime we love cartoons we love crafting and we just like to be a little bit creative I was the one coming to school with the Princess Leia guns getting picked on yeah now being nerd is cool ah | Fly The Coop | UCVHH88i0h6TxrZIYCto8YHQ | 2015-07-23 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 346 | 1,776 |
nQC6kR2l7lg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQC6kR2l7lg | MIDC RECRUITMENT 2019 | I started to toss all that have come a new challenger new zombie much methodically in my AC trying to show the RAND Corporation non buying my job vacancy Colliers cavada me to scale put your money is immobile movement the ravenous chicken to ask a little home PA : with you first Lincoln skillful ticketing and engineers channel blocker and the system escaped without incurring little Cajun heaven potato this world could elect a number of polls change 65 chicken sorry to question in 65 end of this carefully bring it over here Facebook evangelize now playing 65 poster again so glad you guys is not a guest told investigator age any chicken okay so I guess those are mr. Bailey we have phone line up like a chicken for official website engage you can kick in a little coming out of life doesn't escape any difficulty applying my first chicken got the heart channel to subscribe for DJ all my life and professional creation maitake up from that it's a completely deserted City | job news now | UCX2HlOmCUfP2CPo4n8bUHBA | 2019-07-17 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 175 | 977 |
R_-etZU_zYU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R_-etZU_zYU | WWE ULTIMATE EDITION SETH ROLLINS FIGURE REVIEW! | [Music] thank you [Music] what is good everybody welcome back to another my name toys video today we are back with a brand new WWE Ultimate Edition review on the WWE Ultimate Edition Series 17 Seth Rollins figure now this is a figure that we have been waiting on for a very long time right this this figure has been on my wish list for a long time ever since we saw it at Hogan's Beach Shop ringside Fest down there in Florida I have wanted this figure man I just think it's beautiful I cannot wait to actually feel it in hand see what it's like get to see all of the details we actually did get to see this figure on display at the Wrestlemania Superstore and we didn't even have an idea about the fur coat and then bam there it is fur coat on display at the superstore out in La where I got to go and actually see it in person and the figure was Immaculate so to finally have it in my hands now I am super excited man but this isn't my favorite gear I do like the gear but this isn't my favorite Seth Rollins gear of all time but I do like it and enjoy it figure looks pretty good men on card standard Ultimate Edition packaging here nothing out of the ordinary or wacky you have the fur coat you have your three interchangeable heads no championship this time but it is your standard Ultra Edition packaging Ultimate Edition logo here you have an image of the beautiful specimen on the side on the back you get an image of Rollins here and this is this looks like an early Proto or something man like the head doesn't look like it really has any true effects you have like this yellowy color or like not as much black going on on the robe no chest or stomach care that's kind of interesting Seth Rollins here Seth Rollins here says down here he is a Visionary he is a revolutionary you know he's got a nice derriere what do you mean by that Seth Rollins on this side as well and that pretty much wraps up our packaging for Seth freaking Rollins man I'm excited I don't want to wait any longer man so without further Ado actually I do want to add something if you guys would like to grab this figure I don't know if it's on back order or still on pre-order if they have it in stock right now ringside collectibles but use code MD toys to save ourselves 10 always appreciate them but with that being said let's crack this man out of the packaging find out what he's all about and get started here is is the Visionary out of his packaging really enjoying the figure so far man I just love this figure of Seth Rollins I think I don't know we may have to wait till the end of the video but this in terms of quality in terms of details and how great this figure looks aesthetically and how well he poses and feels in hand this might actually be the best Seth Rollins action figure ever created could that be we'll have to see but this is nice and I'm enjoying it so far man but we won't know unless we dive into all the details so what we're going to do first is absolutely take a look at his accessories and then we'll take a closer look at Seth Rollins himself all right man so getting into everything you get with the ultimate edition Seth Rollins you get the fur jacket you get the three interchangeable head Scopes you get the interchangeable hands you don't get a championship okay this isn't BK you don't get it your way I'll take this every damn day of the week I mean this fur coat is freaking fantastic man look at this right here I love how you have these silver dots going over it then you have this rainbow colored brickish Mosaic sort of pattern going on it looks really cool it's almost like stained glass as well it looks really excellent the fur on here feels super soft it almost feels like so so in my family my dog Charlie beautiful chocolate lab her ears people always like an ongoing running joke in the family that her ears are the softest thing ever it feels like Mattel ripped off my dog's ears and put them on this robe that's what this feels like it's super soft you have like this orangish brown fading to Black I don't know how they did that I don't know how they do this on a mass like level you know what I'm saying there are claw they're t-shirt companies and people that make these jackets for real you'll never get this craftsmanship out of those jackets you won't even get how well this feels and this is a jacket shrunk down into this scale it's absolutely impossible and I gotta be real with you this is probably a top five accessory from Mattel ever it's definitely up there like it can compete with the best of any of these robes that we've seen in the past it's very very nice it has some heft to it it is cool this is great fantastic work by Mattel here you guys saw it on the figure it looks fantastic this is damn good this makes the figure this almost makes it worth the figure alone you try to go get somebody in the community that makes Custom Clothes Like This detailed it'll be probably more for the jacket than you will pay for this figure at retail price and you get the jacket and the figure something to think about Brad now for these head Scopes I really really enjoyed this one I don't know if it's my favorite it's definitely my it's either my favorite or my second favorite but tell me this one doesn't look identical to the old fan takeover one at least it I will give you this one does look better than the one on the left over here but it's still very very similar I mean they are the same guy given you know what I mean but the hair scope's practically the only difference it looks like they increased the size as well like the size of the one on the right is definitely more noticeable but I do think it has more likeness I think this one looks better and yeah I definitely like this one on the ultimate better but the likeness is pretty similar to that one but I enjoy this head scope you got the longer hair on there it looks good then you have like the gritty smile store sort of head sculpt that looks very similar are the old SummerSlam Elite which is this head skull right here ever since the first time we saw this head sculpt I thought it was this one over here like it looks so much like it the lightness is there I mean these are very much the same and I don't really care for these to be honest with you I probably won't ever get like I never use this one this is like a makeshift custom thrown together at the last minute I never liked this headscope from a tail so anytime we ever got it I was always like you know what what are we doing over here but this one looks uh better than that one for sure but this still isn't my favorite but it's not the biggest deal you know I'm not going to use it that much but you do get that one and last but not least you get the screaming expression which is probably my favorite one out of the bunch I really enjoy this one I like the sculpt to it I like the hair this has good lightness to Rollins I like the beer this is a this is a nice head sculpt I like this one I wouldn't be shocked if we don't see this over and over but they don't typically like to plug in Ultimate Edition heads clubs you guys ever noticed that they don't like to just reuse ultimates in Elite Form which I don't know if that's but I don't know what the deal is with that but that just seems to be an ongoing thing like it happens don't get me wrong it happens but it's not it doesn't happen that often but I like the screaming expression and then for interchangeable hands you do get the signature fisted hands which every figure pretty much comes with nowadays from Mattel you have the hands that make the world go around with the mic holding weapon wielding style hands which are always a a select group of fans that have to come together you got to have these with every figure and then some hands that pretty much come with every figure it seems like nowadays you have the Ricochet entrance Kawhi Leonard handshaking style hands which I don't even know if anybody watching this video knows what I'm talking about when I say Kawhi Leonard I call them that because these first came with Ricochet I'm pretty sure in the like Elite 69 figure and we have gotten them on a clip ever since and they're just so damn big that they remind me of the claw Kawhi Leonard so you know that's just the way it is but uh yeah you get these and then I think a beautiful inclusion was the Randy Orton entrance style hands I think these fit perfect with Seth Rollins current look the way his entrance music goes you guys know the whole deal this is a beautiful inclusion and nothing beats being there live to see a hundred thousand people singing along with Seth Rollins while he does his little dancing dance this is good good stuff right here this is a great inclusion by Mattel very creative and a good usage of these hands all right so getting into Seth Rollins himself this figure looks fantastic man I like the way the head sits on here we already looked at the head sculpts I need to I definitely will be heating this up and then putting this in position and making it there that way it falls naturally and looks better than this garbage like look at that warpage right there what the hell it's not that big of a deal man relax don't tell me what to do Brad going down to the chest this is pretty much the exact same chest decal you get on his elite figures let's go ahead and make a comparison here and yeah they're the exact same I just think that with the butterfly joints you don't get as wide of a torso on this Elite here as this ultimate this is the Rick Rude torso I think it looks beautiful man the proportions here are great I like the you know the way everything looks here one thing I will say is just like a little nitpick for the future I'd like to see them use like for smaller guys even though he's smaller than Bobby Lashley you guys know how like Bobby lashley's figures and other guys have like the striation new shoulder sculpt they need to add that to guys like you know HBK and Seth Rollins and stuff like that because I think it would really add to the figure you get a little bit there maybe I don't know if that's accidental or if it's meant to be there but I'd like to see like those muscular shoulders rather than just the circle style that these have right now but I like the double jointed arms the black tape this is probably one of my favorite pieces of the whole figure and that is this newly sculpted crotch piece I want to see this implemented on a lot of figures going forward not just the ultimate editions I'd like to see this in the elites I'd like to see this customized you know you get that great belt sculpt in there and this is another thing is you know now that we have all these updated Rollins with this new formula we need to see old Rollins redone we need to say Elite 45 we need to see the cash in Rollins which we're getting in the greatest hits wave we've already discussed that but you do have you know the belt scope going all the way around this is not sculpted actually but all this here is painted on so all this you know all the colors and everything right here this isn't like bad gear but it's not my favorite gear of all time reminds me a lot of like the Tron gear from back in like 2017 at SummerSlam it's not like a gear that I hate but it's not one that I'm like oh yeah that gear is the best of all time so so I enjoy the gear but I do like the sculpture on the kick pads I like the way all this stuff looks here the ultimate edition boot articulation just a really well established and aesthetic figure he just moves around well man I mean look at this Ultimate Edition like everybody knows that the ultimate editions don't pose around the best as far as torso and ab crunch this is something I'd like to see improve somehow but you do get at least a good range here the butterfly joints are really tight I think that's something the Mattel has pretty well improved on you know I think you know you can give come across here he can reach back very far there he can do the splits he does have the drop down hips which can get loose and get on my nerves but I'm not noticing any losage here right now just want to be careful with that not to snap it or anything you get the upper thigh cut double jointed knee kick pad rotation ankle rocker which it's not a Spider-Man figure so it doesn't need to be the best but the angles move up and down and you get the toe pivot there double jointed arms you know how they are they're fantastic ever since the inflammation you know we we've been waiting like ever since Hotel introduced that they've just been on fire with that these figures are just the best best wrestling action figures ever made and you know we still have plenty of figures to come and this is just a great figure man I'm really enjoying the Seth Rollins I think uh he's up there he feels really quality in hand which is always something if if you hear me say it feels good in the hand in a review probably worth the grab now getting into some Seth Rollins Elite figure comparisons you have the elite 80s 8.99 Series 17 the elite top talents from this year and then you have the elite 93 of it here and you guys will notice this one has two gloves working on something there just stay with me he's smelling what I'm stepping in there but I don't know man like seeing this figure up next to the rest I think if like this oh man this is the problem when you collect for a long time you have these old formulas like this figure was great I literally owned seven of these and now I feel like it's kind of obsolete in comparison to the formula that you're getting with the ultimate and these New Elites and that's what I'm saying man we need flashback Rollins in those old gears in the updated formula similar to what they're doing with Hulk Hogan I'm sure in the future we're gonna get re-releases and stuff like that but this is the ultimate edition Series 17 Rollins and then I wanted to compare it to my custom that my boy Ty Goodrich nice patron member of the channel here hail me out with this MDT style and I always felt like these kind of reminded me of each other but I'm gonna be real I like this I like this attire better but it's not because it says my damn Rollins on it all right it's not but seriously though uh I just want to compare these because they remind me of each other but yeah the Seth Rollins figure is just so good man he posed around with the best of them bro I want to get some ultimate additions in here though for comparison and then for some Ultimate Edition figure of ultimate this is the ultimate he's just got the gold Gauntlet but then you have Seth Rollins there kind of got like a t raising the bar here all three of these look pretty good up next to each other I'd say in terms of height they'll scale pretty well I'd say and I'm enjoying it man these are great honestly not even gonna bullsh with you I bet if you put this on this figure put this torso on this figure put the AJ Styles tattoo on this right here and you might be uh that might be so you might have a little something special going on there young man let me see here put that AJ tattoo right there bro yeah you I think you'd have something there man I think you could uh yeah I might I might play around with that see what's up nonetheless I'm loving all these current ultimates we're getting man you need to fill out the whole damn every ever I mean like think about the current list you have you have Seth Rollins AJ Styles Roman Reigns Randy Orton Cody Rhodes Rey Mysterio's giving one even though it's not up today you have John Cena who I guess is part-time still but Brock Lesnar Edge Damon Finn Balor shinsuke Nakamura we have a pretty good collection of ultimates nonetheless that does it for your Seth Rollins figure comparisons but I think that pretty much wraps up our ultimate edition Series 17 Seth Rollins review man had a ton of fun with this guy I think at the end of the day he's a fun figure man he he just feels so good in the hand I think personally that at the end of the year this guy's gonna be up there with your AJ Styles he's gonna be up there with some of the best ultimates of the Year some of the best action figures all year from Mattel and WWE I've I've just had a blast on this figure I'm a big Seth Rollins guy so I like it but I would skip the elite 93 I would skip ooh the elite 99 is a damn good figure but I love this figure and the way it looks and I've really came around on Mattel's butterfly joints they used to be kind of loose they tightened them up they feel really great and strong so that leads me to believe that this figure might be better than his Elite 99 I certainly like the head skull better than Elite 99 the jacket is pretty much on par with Elite 99 and then it just comes down to gear which is a personal preference so I I get this one man this this figure is fantastic I think it is a must-have for any Rollins fan if you are one to update your Rollins this is the one to get I really really like it even though the elite 99 is undefeated and it was the second best figure of all of last year in my opinion I still like this Ultimate Edition I think you guys should grab it and if you guys want to go over to ringside collectibles use code MD toys to save yourselves 10 of course when shopping over there but this has the sale of approval for me I would put this guy up there with the ultimate edition Ronda I put him up there with the ultimate edition Brock from series 15. he is up there man he feels Immaculate in hand poses around well does all the bells and whistles you want fur coat I mean it writes itself man this is a great piece and I think you should go at it now before we get out of here I do want to get a huge shout out to our patrons over there on the MDT patreon page if you guys are interested in doing that definitely go check it out we had a new sign up yesterday I know I'm gonna butcher this last name so I do apologize but it's Michael it's hack hack I I know I'm butchering that and I do apologize that for that but a huge shout out to Michael man thank you so much brother for being a patron being a new patron of the MDT patreon if you guys are interested in that cool perks over there we're giving away an elite 100 Rey Mysterio this month and you have I think like one to two days left stream division members or higher get in on the giveaways every single month and I think the drawing for that will be either tomorrow or the next day so time's running out definitely go get on on that if you're interested but that is going to wrap up today's video man thank you guys so very much for watching hope you guys did enjoy I had a lot of technical problems getting this review up so a like would greatly be appreciated leave me your thoughts on the Seth Rollins figure down in the comment section below I'm getting out of here man thank you guys for watching subscribe to the channel follow me on Instagram Twitter and Tick Tock at my damn toys I'll see you guys in the next video have a blessed one and I'll see you next time [Music] we're coming [Applause] [Music] foreign foreign [Music] | My Damn Toys | UCNKDPYyiF_XY4hYAkBuU_TQ | 2023-04-29 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,752 | 19,123 |
4G_VNEWxdlQ | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4G_VNEWxdlQ | TildeShambles - The Legend Of Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom - Part 28 | all right let's uh continue if you're watching that on YouTube as always thanks for clicking hope you're enjoying yeah I'm good all right uh I think it's I still want to hunt down the dragon but it's like it's a bit of a wild goose chase it really is jeez I still want to go to luralin as well so [Music] this has got to be bait right I saw this on the map earlier see I bet I can get this like this hooks without being baited into a fight I don't know just touching it with it I thought I can't hear over the sound of being dead already [Music] pulse I already knew that's that that was the result of that that wasn't dumb I just thought maybe there'd be a way to be sneaky and get bananas without it okay um let's see if I can do some upgrading oh there is one upgrade I can do one of the Sages foreign [Music] yeah so you can pick you can't upgrade tool in the second time so we'll go with side on [Music] foreign just attack power doesn't affect the skill well I got no choice let's offers sir let's be glad children got the upgrade first [Music] foreign [Music] okay next in line can other people see them no I only link cam I mean maybe Zelda can but now it's this link [Music] can they hear them they can't interact with them only link can see in here it's like the old uh imaginary friend thing I'm so convinced that they're just a result of linked psychosis from uh sleeping for 100 years and they don't really exist [Music] but now I can oh wow you need us you need sticky frog um I need way more fireflies but I guess let's get the chess piece upgraded ah [Music] um yeah I mean I don't have enough what about right I can upgrade the pants now though so that's good I guess there was some use in getting the scale [Music] so what I need I need din no maybe nature scale [Music] let's see dins okay noted [Music] they're all invest in these pants to go really strong pants because I've got a chest piece that's 20. this this right here [Music] so I mean that would make my strongest combination hold on because we're talking about what to wear in general this is the strongest combination I think I mean I can wear the light one but the light one doesn't look great but in terms of raw armor values these these are my strongest items now which yeah yeah [Music] okay one thing I'm gonna do the first Tower yeah that was the uh the island that was high up in the area here but I needed waterfall ability so [Music] what's up oh God damn it that's it's guy time it's Sky time what's in the sky [Music] okay where was I saw it I saw it I saw it where is it [Music] should be facing [Music] should be facing this way somewhere they don't vanish I just need to look where are they I saw it foreign [Music] I was able to see it from hebra no [Music] yeah I don't see it I just saw it off in the distance and I thought okay I have spotted it I can go for it but it's not here uh I mean they'll walk along but it looks like it's not here okay [Music] the Fast Travel is instant but I think it does despawn [Music] it used to happen in breath of the wild as well so okay but I've walked around the perimeter of this and nothing [Music] okay just figured it might be worth a try let's just go back foreign okay let me get myself to a point where I can see this island that I couldn't get to and I'm gonna flap there [Music] probably a good idea to go from here hang on okay where is that there's the boat that's the mountain it should be a waterfall somewhere around here that's that's a it's a set of islands over there so okay I'm gonna I'm gonna make my flying machine foreign [Music] I love this thing oh it should get me though I will have to be Arena first [Music] that's the island I was looking for it doesn't matter too much we'll we'll be heading there anyway [Music] I think I needed a big one [Music] how's it about to get cold I mean so I don't waste the big one I should go to this one first yeah it's about to get cold okay oh that's still really cold there we go of course there is but you know what this will serve as a way to get to the others it's like uh mirror type thing going on here oh that's fine as long as the device is safe [Music] God damn it foreign [Music] that's the problem if I go for it now I can't get back here easily or is it or is it or it's over there how far away is it what time is it it's three okay three P.M 3 P.M on this island no dude that's a that's an eternity eye there's no way I'm getting there nah that's gonna take too long 3 P.M on the Asylum I've got it oh [ __ ] I need this fish that's too far away look I'll get the shrine first and then we'll see if it's still in the sky but 3 P.M on this island foreign why would you do that make the pickup button the same as the sage button that's great oh [ __ ] hey what a car oh it's not hard [Music] huh thank you oh no what's this a lot okay listen we're equipped for this oh [ __ ] okay kinda that was very anticlimactic made me think there was a pit here look up [Music] a mirror [Music] this is new look up I mean coal this is definitely bringing back old Zelda vibes I like it foreign [Music] making very large assumptions here oh okay sure that works all right [Music] so I could have found this without this it looks like it keeps going okay so that's fine [Applause] this feels like the entry to a dungeon I kind of like it even though it's not it's gonna be a shrine it's still still fun oh and then hahaha wow it's pretty satisfying this is just back up what did I do this in reverse no no no no no no no what is this why but this this is accessible without me doing oh crap what is this what [Music] unless this wasn't unless this door wasn't open let's just trust that this wasn't open before and it didn't just make me do this for no reason I'm gonna try so this wasn't open before okay already worthy so I'm guessing yeah foreign kind of annoying but oh [Applause] I was expecting anti-gravity in here anyway cool another heart [Music] thank you [Music] foreign because the car off there's a machine there's a bit of everything here the plus side is now I have a way up to get up to these so that's nice I'm guessing this is going to give me mirrors I said it's a little surprising but only now I've seen this but maybe magrudo Valley it might be more prominent yeah so mirror light balloon Wing Harborstone I could use a few more hover stones all right spring okay right yeah okay I already know what this is of course it is [Music] okay this is still fine because I got to go to the island I wanted to go to anyway the drive is most likely gone I took note of the time though so there's still stuff to explore anyway so I'm sure we might get a second glimpse of it [Music] you know what I should probably oh this is another shrine I should probably wait for this Blood Moon to uh do its thing before attacking hurry up Zelda that's uh not a good time for that to happen shines upon the land am I gonna Dodge the monsters oh boy it's fine foreign [Applause] okay I'm a Ponca an hour [Music] [Applause] [Music] thank you foreign please tell me it's just right behind me I'm not on an island somewhere else because that would suck if it was okay well I mean the plus side is there's plenty of fans look up oh yeah we'll be fine I've made this device before attach more batteries attach more fans we've got this in fact to be honest this is probably fine as is thank you this is a better flying machine okay the one thing I will do to it though what is this what is this [ __ ] right here this is the only thing that I don't agree with is like this should be there we go and then this can be placed here all right since it's low gravity I I believe this is gonna go there down downtown ah Star Fox music is great oh is this bad no it's perfect else quite ah [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] oh God damn it it's gone yeah that's annoying on the bright side the machine should be back yeah it's back okay it's okay at least this will take me there again I can't believe that actually happened all I save is the last result I think this is fine I'd only use two batteries well it'll be okay this will this will make it again the low gravity actually screwed me because it made a bounce more than it should have all right let's try and desperately to catch up with them I I slipped and I couldn't use the uh the return okay well oh try again some gonna be more deliberate with the angle foreign [Music] as long as I can ah got it just had to rewind enough to grab it [Music] that was an ordeal foreign [Music] island with the waterfall assuming it's not this one that's fine [Music] foreign [Music] I mean I guess I have to make the champion weapons I still haven't made ravali's bow or whatever it's called [Music] thank you [Music] foreign can transport a korok I think I might throw it off balance but it'd be cool if I could use it I got the feeling it's going to cause it to spiral like it's a single person vehicle okay hold on let me clear this island you look just a sec oh no look at something 's not new is that all of them let's see yeah that's all the ones possible here uh okay so I haven't been to this island here or this island here but uh but if I was to guess no it's not that Island okay [Music] oh yeah it's over there I love this Auto Harvest thing hmm but there'd be more here [Music] aha okay uh that's straightforward though I think I hope I'm gonna I'm gonna shoot the arrow while standing on top of this thing there we go um yeah make sure it doesn't fall off the edge [Music] next time I play this I think I have to go into the underground because I've got like 20 treasure maps yeah and I think it's probably about time [Music] okay uh where are we going Green Island first and yellow green Islands over there uh uh yeah I'm gonna need a flying machine okay foreign [Music] Ty yeah not the trash yeah okay all right the next one [Music] yeah I have to go down there oh [ __ ] yeah okay [ __ ] um well this is gonna this is gonna be a tricky maneuver I think I've lost it this time okay quickly did I got it I don't see it hang on no I think it's gone yeah it's an awkward camera angle okay low gravity what's this don't tell me this was nothing [Music] okay I mean these mushrooms these yellow ones are red now so [Music] I think instead of trying to fix the fact that they're too good for crafting they just make a morale oh [Music] all right uh uh is there at least what's this gotta be a reason this is here it's probably a treasure chest off the edge or something otherwise why would this be here it's not the guy back up because you can use the ceiling ability to get back up oh hmm okay I don't see anything let me go back up and look off this Edge gotta be a point to this island I mean I I guess as long as there's something up here [Music] I don't see the point look there's nothing here let's set the clock huh all right whatever uh okay I gotta get to the gold Island next down below okay that's the gold Island which okay it's pointless again but then the waterfall island is coming up around yeah okay [Music] foreign okay it's fine oh there's a lot here laughs it's a little brutal [Applause] I don't have to sneak up on stuff though [Applause] oh we're on Minecarts okay hang on hopefully there's uh there's fans nearby what hmm apparently not okay that's fine uh I got plenty one should be enough oh there's Rockets but I think we need a way to continue I'm thinking the long term here I'm not the short term but okay it's fine it's fine it's fine fine it's fine I think nothing bad happened nothing bad nothing bad happened it's fine it almost sent me off the edge yeah the Rockets are just the bait sometimes they knew what they were doing with these Rockets foreign am I no no no no we are not going that way all right so then I guess continue oh [ __ ] I mean at this point I might as well make my flying machine like there's there's two fans here I just need to drop a steering wheel look I know what it wants me to do but this is the superior design here what's that that one [Music] okay Superior design provided I can control the damn thing [Music] sir sir okay okay that's fine it's fine under control oh [ __ ] how's that auto safe looking uh four minutes ago probably too far back tilted when I crashed into the the track that's where it went wrong because it's a go off center and yeah it was over all right get under this so that's neat I don't think there's nearly as much this time it was more last time it's fine that's okay I'm just gonna cut the middleman out here I'm just gonna make the Damned flying machine because the Middle Island has nothing for me oh [ __ ] [Music] I stopped myself before that got any more out of control yeah okay okay okay there we go this better be worth it [Music] okay well I thought what's left in this acapella there's a few straw oh no see I haven't been to that okay we're going to the to that [Music] it's pretty much just straight ahead so okay oh all right take off a successful I might be able to make it with this battery oh that's that's uh huh well I mean I've made an effort to come here that's that's uh that's a hell of a fight that awaits me wait a minute oh [ __ ] it's uh that's a hybrid it's got all three elements that's not a single element glioc holy [ __ ] all right I'm ready hide here for a minute so we can save that was such a clutch okay hide I have I can save that's good all right um it also will let me okay the problem here is I need okay I know what I'm gonna do um how long is that six minutes six minutes eight minutes uh seven minutes four minutes okay I haven't done this since breath of the wild but effectively it's I'm just looking at what what can do the most good for me here foreign defense and offense all right King Glock prepare that soft chat to learn [Music] [ __ ] this [ __ ] [Music] just hearing those headshots go off is so satisfying oh I worry about what this thing's second phase is gonna be [Music] thank you okay hang on I'm gonna see if I can do something on the Fly [Music] foreign [Music] holy [ __ ] [Music] oh this is gonna this is gonna suck now whatever this is this is about to suck all right it's gone stop [Music] okay let's prepare this because this is what was necessary before it's really not letting me [Music] out there got two heads down [Music] to learn [Music] okay [Music] I'm kind of heavy heavy heavy heavy sword here [Music] uh let's go this one this isn't too bad it's not happening okay spoke too soon [Music] [ __ ] me this is gonna suck all right uh for perfect impact [Music] I only really have it's that raising food cut much as that that's what covers you don't want place that [Music] oh [ __ ] oh holy [ __ ] oh it's not letting me ride on come on come on get up get up get up go go go go go go go oh my God this thing is such a dick dude it's it's not it's not letting me it just it backs up one over the other it was going well up until that point that's a little unfair um okay I'm gonna think how best to deal with this foreign everything else was fine about the fight [Music] all right let's just [Music] honestly [ __ ] that second phase [Music] this thing is such an [ __ ] [Music] [ __ ] children help please [Music] [Applause] [Music] okay [Music] man hey [Music] what's going on oh [ __ ] you know what I forgot yeah that forgot about that it's okay I had two heads that's fine it's like that [Music] [ __ ] [Music] with the bear with the back okay um okay hold on hold on hold on Pizza [Music] [ __ ] dude [Music] move there we go [Music] what's up a couple Castle [Music] thank you hang on hang on the offense real quick [Music] all right uh let's do this thank you I have an idea I don't know if it'll work [Music] should I take out the rocket hang on [Music] let's go oh it doesn't go up any higher okay [ __ ] it do it [Music] not high enough uh [Music] yeah the problem now is Lightning's gonna [ __ ] me up if I'm not careful okay I'm gonna swap [Music] so irritating wow look it just does not give you any room one one attack gets you one way or the other Day come on come on come on come on [Music] I don't think I hit him I got him okay oh I did it that was stressful got it [Music] jeez foreign man because that is not pretty [Music] gliac guts still a very very cool fight you need you need all resistances for this it's a good thing I had that shock resist yep a sage as well yeah I mean you would hope so it had to be something of that tier I'm already halfway to the next one well I mean now I kind of have nothing to fear about the electric one the electric one I feel like I know what it's going to do now it's the file one that I'm curious about its second form what it would do [Music] everything else is fine [Music] okay what's this thing if there's anything else to collect here in second attempt so not bad uh okay so there's another Island here let's go do that foreign [Music] lots of fun oh yeah this is a low gravity one okay so it's to the south of here it's over there I think I'm currently facing it no I'm not that's something else that's the Dorito um [Music] uh another lettering where is it there oh [Music] apparently have it this way that's blue it's green there's green I think I can no that's ages away like I think I can fly it down no I can't I cannot you know for that fight not gonna lie I almost felt tempted to get this thing out and uh use that to get into the air I had shot the Glock but I don't think it would have given me the chance I almost did it I don't know how much longer I'll be going but let's see I wonder if this design I mean I'm just worried it's gonna throw it out of whack foreign [Music] I'm running out of zonai charges I got a murder some constructions constructs so I guess I'll be doing here [Music] all right I need to work on my battery a bit more that's all right thank you okay this is made we're in the middle of it now well I tried to save it it's okay [Music] headshot oh man just invaluable okay in the middle now oh it keeps moving [Music] all right destroyed my bow foreign you're losing your hands and your legs [Music] does nothing now there we go enjoy [Applause] what oh [ __ ] weird I'm taking the chest already another Sage as well wow thank you [Music] all these Sage Wills if you never lucky enough might actually get his upgrade today as well [Music] oh yeah what's that okay I mean I'm saying why the most good can be done yeah let's get uh mcleodus guy um yeah we'll set the groundwork for where I want to go to next anyway [Music] all right um wait is there a spot to cook here maybe I think that was out here I need more food what happens if I do this and that's honestly not bad foreign do on their own oh wow that yeah that's a big Improvement oh I don't want to use fish because it's used to upgrade stuff it's a full recovery plus eight that's good we need at least one of those all right what about fruit and mushroom isn't great [Music] it's a good one [Music] all right okay I mean that should do for a while [Music] I'm not sure I need cold resist anymore what's up thank God it's all ready uh okay all right yeah this is just to get over here there's another fight that awaits me [Music] foreign [Music] I've created a little bit of a [Music] okay there's cannons here which is good foreign [Music] use the last of that sword thank you yeah construct has it that's fine that's nice and straightforward just someone not accidentally losing the fairy oh I gotta get over the gap that's uh hmm I know what it wants me to do but I don't think I'm gonna do that it looks high risk of uh losing it okay hang on oh already [Music] that's fine where is it where is it where is it where is it where is it [Music] oh let's go yeah [Applause] [Music] It's Your Land oops [Music] did I just move it at the last second or third [Applause] damn it newly [Music] drop damn it [Music] Unova is a pacifist it seems that way sometimes I think the problem is you never has a massive wind up on his attacks because they guess they're heavy you could classify him as a heavy now I know what I know what it wants me to do here but it just seems stupid to do it this way look at it it would seem to me that this is just going to cause problems this is going to cause problems like really using a springboard to launch this yeah that's yep I'm totally gonna get on that that's that's not what what I'm about to do here why why would I ever do that no no no no no no I'm I'm not joking about this do you want to know what's more fun think of the content I am thinking of the content that's why I'm doing this the return of bridge gun I mean a very stylish bridge at that oh needs to be a little longer I have too many of these anyways so it's like I'm using them [Music] a bridge John gets an upgrade before you know bro yep I think this is more interesting so since it's not it's not 100 straightforward it is difficult to play stuff when it's this big [Music] oh I think it needs to be just a little bit long oh God come back okay hold on they made it okay yeah that look that looks stable to me [ __ ] that springboard I'm not about to do that oh that was not about to happen [Music] 100 the intended solution it's how we do things around here nothing but the intended solution honestly that's pretty much what I'm going to use that that is for they're going to be Bridges anytime I can make a bridge that's going to be made out of those if I need to make a bridge I have way too many of them I'm never going to use them all but they're pretty common to find as well they just seem to be everywhere [Music] please [Music] oh damn I'm like up to this is number 110. this was breath of the wild it'd be 10 remaining so but since it isn't this still the gorilla this game is long man so much longer I still can't believe there are people out there talking about this being A7 maybe all the DLC still it's not I mean these are the same people that'll probably purchase like Call of Duty every year or like an EA Sports Game or some [ __ ] man [Music] that's fine if you enjoy those titles by the way it's just let's be real if you want to talk about anything being a 70 DLC those games are more more than that especially since yeah the latest entry seem to be rehashing old entries [Music] I recognize that the shrines yeah that's the same but is that necessarily a bad thing I don't think it is there's a fresh of enough perspective on them that they feel different 110. okay all right so where is this going to get me to next this is going to get me to all right so we need to face that way the next Arena I hope stop oh no the oh yeah no this is not going to get me to the next Arena okay we need the flying machine again foreign luck there'll be another Sage thing there and then your number can get his upgrade come on that that's that's great uh uh that makes me laugh I love that thumbnail that's awesome oh there's like two arenas I mean let's fly around oh [ __ ] oh almost lost control of it we'll go to this one first this can also take me to even tide so if I lose the vehicle we can go to Urban tide I mean this is very Skyward Sword Vibes here just like going to the next Island I don't know it just needs the music [Music] oh this one is an eternity away and before Glock again I went to this one because I'm willing to bet this is something significant because it's really out of the way [Music] oh damn I mean even this might not be enough to get there yeah it's it's this [ __ ] again um okay I've fought it before I can do it again I'm I'm prepared for this [ __ ] except this time this time I don't need to have ice bath that's good this is going to be a slightly easier fight because I don't have to worry about cold at least called well I should probably still apply it just because getting Frozen is a little a little annoying all right I'm also going to keep the uh the machine nearby [Music] because I think this is the way I honestly I'm gonna get to these okay uh was the Lionel boat there it is double glare fire chat double Glock [Music] oh that's bad [Music] uh that is kind of an awkward spot but it's fine [Music] come on [Music] I'm going to see my ships okay it's somewhere whoa [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] and I love having to run up to something to get a shield this is bad this is really bad it's kind of stuck in an awkward spot foreign [Music] okay let's just heal I think the problem here is I'm going too defensive I need to have this on and sacrifice some defense [Music] that's cool oh it's really getting into these annoying spots damn it thank you [Music] I was thinking that maybe the fire I had would be weak to water but it's not it doesn't take that into account [Applause] thank you wanker I mean so far so good oh no come on come on come on [Music] all right that's a backstab weapon uh let's go the big one [Music] I don't think it's enraged just yet wait for right now thank you [Music] dude I don't that was my machine assuming it's still around I don't think it is [Music] a man falling off the edge chat [Music] yeah I don't see it anywhere okay just gonna be patient wait for the opening [ __ ] oh this is so annoying [Music] this is like just pray that this doesn't hit me got it oh you [ __ ] that's what the fire one does all right I can still no I can't get a hidden that's all he stopped me [Music] okay hang on I need to heal so [ __ ] annoying man the spam [Music] this is just like a prayer that it doesn't hit you what's the Hat deal with the file one first foreign here I don't have ours [Music] okay first try the second time [Music] it's still a fun fight I don't know where my flying machine went but I was gonna use it to climb up I just got rid of it just because it's like no no luxuries what do you mean but you must fight with honor no machines allowed oh look at that two gliac kills I mean this has to be the sage thing I would be shocked if it wasn't or an armor piece something of significance yeah there we go and just like that guess who gets an upgrade now I could save them for the next Sage I could do that let's let's just I don't know you never doesn't seem to do a whole lot compared to the others I have yet to see the last search but you know so far the bar is uh pretty damn low okay I'm just gonna go down here since we're here [Music] uh this is either intentionally that it's raining or just coincidental when I got that feeling I have to take something off the hill here [Music] [Applause] [Music] okay directly below there's got to be like a cave entrance or something oh once the horses so just check out everything oh just check out everything here that's easy I would have known I already got I would have gotten a head start on it I just photograph this is nothing [Music] in fact we can go full deity on this one [Music] okay not the line away that'll do I mean even if there's one shot at left in it it's still a triple shot all right [Music] I don't have many hours left let's just leave it yeah ow jeez that electricity [Music] not expecting that [Music] all right whoever the electric Archer is they're going down first view [ __ ] all right Archers first [Music] oh they're all like electricity all right [Music] it's like that thank you [Music] apparently there's one more alive somewhere wow survive the fall where'd you go no I have to go down there ding ding ding it's just just purging every camp foreign okay those supplies in here soaring Boomerang what the heck okay well I don't see any sign of what's to come so let's go to the next camp I got the feeling this is all this is just okay I need to steal this thank you yeah okay this is all this is what's happening get rid of this one first this is the biggest threat all the health is here okay I got it bouncy stick what the [ __ ] is a bouncy stick [Music] okay it's another Camp done I got arrows so that was what a bunch of fire fruit okay that was definitely worth it [Music] should probably open all these foreign times I've done that [Music] I want the wood thank you I feel like this is all just defeat everything you know it wouldn't make sense for this wow [Music] this is probably why you got the quest oh here though Misty must have a death wish to make your way to this island you've heard the rumors right they say this is where the pirates that attack lural and hide out I mean I should want to be here but I'm on a mission to locate the Pirates Hideout for the monster control crew three strongholds okay yeah here we go I do think papyr is somewhere on this island ah I want to finish my scouting and go home already if only these strongholds weren't there yeah working on it working on it working on it foreign I saw the health bars that this was going to be the case [Music] oh I wanted all that fruit okay oh that was bad okay can I can I say something let me see what this walks okay I mean it made the sound effect but it didn't really [ __ ] all right that's what I got for trying something that's a bouncy stick and it didn't really do bouncy [ __ ] laughs it's wrecked me into thinking that it was a weapon that when you hit them sends them flying nope deceived okay well let's just do this again foreign [Music] thank you that's what I got for being sneaky [Music] you [Music] thank you so yeah [Music] couldn't die [Music] laughs [Music] okay um this was pointless give me that weapon the island seems so much more tranquil could it be you cleared out the monster strongholds all three of them you're amazing you didn't even know how big of a help that is perfect timing too since I just saw a pirate ship coming in but it's strange as soon as it went around the rear of the island the ship disappeared so where where'd it go maybe the Pirates really do have a hideout on this island and that's where the ship disappeared to but that would make it the monster control crew's duty to find and eradicate them not just Scout things out I can handle one or two enemies but that sounds more like uh I'm so nervous I'm frozen to the spot do I Retreat do I look for The Hideout and try to fight the Pirates himself what should I do okay in the words of Wario it's time to [ __ ] let's see [Music] thank you good thank you [Music] for your shadows but I think I've ever beaten a silver one [Music] thanks to the distraction buddy that's an excellent photo [Music] nice okay this is already over I got the three big ones [Music] oh no I don't three big ones okay now I got now I got it [Music] I just had children take one out [Music] all right good enough there's one more somewhere thank you where's that coming from right here up top got it oh that's so fun [ __ ] oh yeah this should be a uh bubble frog somewhere oh foreign thank you oh look at the spikes everywhere foreign my my thing how do I get back on the ship [Music] oh my God oh okay it's not it's not a simple I gotta be higher probably from the Crow's Nest foreign [Music] I mean this is like actual pirate treasure here I mean that that's cool I like that especially since even tired is kind of in spirit everywhere now so this was cool okay blessing [Music] excellent [Music] thank you damn one more and I got another heart the two hearts gotta be a lot of shrines left then because yeah I don't know we'll see we'll see how this plays out because let's see 112 will get me to that yeah weird Okay chat uh I'm gonna leave it here for tonight but I want to say thank you so much for watching it was uh fun doing all those fights and whatnot so I enjoyed it uh tomorrow I have a day off so I'll probably play something during the day of my time uh Diablo 4 comes out but [Music] it coming out and serve as being stable are two completely different things so we'll see how tomorrow goes but uh yeah we might do some bonus content during the day uh in the meantime if you wanna watch more stuff uh head on over to YouTube just search for the Channel all over there or go to shambles.gg and just click the links there it'll take you to all that good stuff uh and if you're watching later on YouTube thanks for sticking around to the end um consider clicking buttons and whatnot for the algorithm purposes uh and I want to say thanks to those that have been doing that it has been a tremendous help so thank you all right uh yeah I'm gonna go chill for the rest of the evening thank you so much for watching again and uh we'll do more Zelda over this longer weekend I have now so all right take care everyone | TildeShambles - Stream Archive | UC9RK3eBTYZlJrfQxy9Wzxsw | 2023-06-02 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 6,467 | 33,004 |
milt3qukN7I | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=milt3qukN7I | Asian Wild Game Dishes with The Sporting Chef | coming up on the sporting chef today on the show on adding Asian flavors to my fishing game also I've got Susie Jimenez Jeff's callin ducks Melissa's of talking deer he'll see dubs makin chili and buddy's cooking Cajun in Mexico what do you get when you find the best fish and game chef's cookbook authors Award winners fish mongers outdoor experts and put them on the fastest half hour on outdoor television [Music] hosted by one of America's best-known wild game ships Scott LASIK the sporting ship brought to you by camp chef the way to cook outdoors so I really like Asian flavors whether it's with Fish and Game or domestic meats I don't like to overpower my food but I like the flavors of Asian soy sauce pickled ginger I'm a big big big fan of fish that's not cooked sashimi which shouldn't surprise people that watch the show because I don't cook the stuff that should be cooked all that much anyway the critical component for cooking any kind of Asian stuff stir-fry fast cooking stuff is to have all your ingredients chopped and on deck it moves really fast this is fast and hot cooking when you're doing a stir-fry for instance so if all of a sudden in the middle of it you have to chop some onions you're gonna end up overcooking something your vegetables aren't going to be crisp your meats going to be overcooked today I've got three asian-inspired recipes and they may not be authentic Asian recipes but they're my take using Asian flavors first is a Korean bulgogi that I'm doing with venison soy sauce sesame oil it's kind of sweet in there also so it's got some brown sugar it's a good marinade especially if you have a stronger tasting animal like perhaps a rangy antelope or sea ducks that require a little help a little bit more marinade I also have a foil wrapped pheasant foil wrap chicken is a pretty typical Asian dish that you kind of have cooked the chicken if it's a chicken dish it's got some sauce in there it's foil wrapped and then it's going to be deep-fried and a Western fryer and finally I have asabi salmon balls and no that's not a medical condition it's a spicy use of some leftover salmon I'm using smoked salmon in this case I'm gonna get two all about right here on the show but first I want you to check out Suzy Jimenez one of my favorite Latina chefs who has a risotto cakes Chef Scott sometimes we have a hard time crazy this starts that's going to go with our wild game right so I've created some risotto cakes and when you get it box of risotto follow the directions I mean you're cooking it risotto in like 8 the pasta right so it takes a lot of time and patience but it's got a lot of starts so you'll see that you keep warm great a little cakes like this now honestly I did put an egg in there to bind it very well but once you get the toppings on this you're gonna love it so we're gonna sear them with a little olive oil on medium-high heat until they're golden brown flip them over one and they should be ready to go in the meantime we're going to go ahead and work with there's a wild turkey drumstick now these wild turkey drumsticks like our very very top so you got to break them down a lot I place mine in duck fat and put it in the oven it cooked it for about four to five hours and now you'll see how tender it is today I'm just gonna grab this leg you're just gonna pull all this meat off of there what we're trying to do is to saute this you'll notice too that the wild turkey like drumstick it's like pink and the inside don't be discouraged by that it does not mean that it's not cooked that is the color of wild games sometimes you have to be a little you know you gotta just a little bit even elk is better than like beef you know so don't get discouraged you cooked it for five hours it's done the simplicity of this is I'm just gonna add a little bit of salt and then I made a mint cilantro chutney now I tend to use a lot of cilantro but sometimes it needs to be powered by something that's a little more refreshed so I added one bunch of cilantro one bunch of mint one jalapeno line in a blender with his salt pepper and I blended it up [Music] now remember you don't have to just use Turkey you do stuff you use rabbits elf whatever the whole point is to get this starts at the bottom right so that you can start adding a little different spices to your dishes every day so thank you so much for the awesome tip of the day and how do you start on your everyday well TV you can find out more about Suzy on her Facebook page stay with her like her we love her I like rice and if you're gonna be cooking Asian food rice seemed like a very natural to go with it now if you're in a hurry sometimes making rice doesn't seem like something that you're gonna have time for when I make a big batch of rice what I like to do is put it up in a FoodSaver game-saver unit here but the most important part is that your rice comes from the USA make sure that your rice says grown in the USA make sure it's grown in America raised in America made in America let's support us not them you might think if you put rice in a vacuum packing unit in a game saver unit like this and you squeeze it too much it's gonna be a little bit too compressed especially if your rice is overcooked true dat I've learned that what I like to do when I do take rice is I like to leave a little bit of room in it don't feel like whenever you use a game saver that you have to squeeze the life out of everything what it does is it seals it and once you put it in this bag and you seal it stop it before it gets all the way there and so it'll leave a little air space in there when you want to have rice you drop it into boiling water it's a heck of a lot cheaper than buying it already pre-made you can make it taste better because you're making it yourself we're just getting started with the Asian thing then there's also a calling tip Melissa Bachman Sita and buddy I'd highly recommend a cold Japanese beer and I'll meet you back here in just a couple of minutes [Music] welcome back to the sporting chef I'm Scott lacf and friends of mine who watched the show say that I do this a lot Deven does this me apparently yes venison bulgogi that Korean marinated venison that you can use actually with any kind of dark flesh game meat it's got a lot of flavor I've got some already done here this is venison hind quarter you can tell how tender it is so if your venison hind quarter is not tender like this what happened you probably overcooked it I've got garlic brown sugar brown sugar is gonna obviously give it some sweetness sesame seeds you can add at the end or in the beginning doesn't matter here's some crushed black pepper green onions pickled or fresh ginger a little bit of sesame oil and a little bit of sesame oil goes a long way this is low-sodium soy sauce leave this in here for at least 6 hours we want this to have a lot of flavor I have some right here I'm gonna put it over here on this Camp Chef stove in a cast-iron skillet you can use a wok if you happen to have that at home and while I'm getting that ready I want you to check out Jeff Smith who's got a calling tip big question I get is Jeff how do you do a feeding call and what I like to do is just say tip tip tip tip I like to cup my hand down real tight to get some back pressure I don't do a traditional rolling feed which is ticka ticka ticka ticka ticka so by just saying tip to tip tip tip tip and then putting a single pin in there very very realistic and what I like to do is just basically throw that into my routine when I'm calling out a duck and just basically fill it so I want to keep my Ducks attention if it's on the corner and coming in the last you know 50 yards it scuffed up I'm just gonna cluck at it okay with a rolling feed chatter you typically hear ducks doing that when they're flying and a rolling feed chatter is take a ticket ticket ticket or do good dooba dooba do that Jeff Smith is a very important part of the California waterfowl association I've got the marinated bulgogi venison that's gonna go into the hot skillet this is only gonna cook for a minute or two just enough to get it lightly browned on the outside and still very very tender and now some greens kale spinach I added greens and shitake mushrooms and I got the bulgogi out of the pan now quickly into the pheasant foil-wrapped pheasant little pheasant breast don't need the leg the wing I'm gonna cut this into small pieces depending on how much you want to put into your foil wrapped a little pheasant package here there's the pheasant over here is the sauce got some oil in the skillet I've got garlic and ginger and that's gonna go quickly because I do not want to burn my garlic or ginger pheasant pieces just want to get them a little bit Brown because they're gonna deep-fry once I wrap them in foil I want them to be lightly browned but still not all the way cooked through soy sauce green onions a little bit of hoisin and some chili garlic sauce take it off the heat and let it cool you know one of the things that people ask me about is is venison safe to eat our ducks safe to eat well given the option I would much rather have a duck that's flown back and forth from Canada a couple of times as opposed to a six week old chicken in the grocery store we don't shoot three-legged deer with mange we shoot healthy animals and nobody knows the importance of having a healthy deer population more than Melissa Bachman and she's got a tip on how to have healthier deer in your own deer lease if you live in a state where attractants are legal one thing you may want to think about is using those attractive paired with your cutting backs now in this situation I've got a cutting back on the tree it's probably about eight nine feet away from where I'm at and what I like about this location is deer are already naturally coming through here I have two trails right behind you that intersect so I've got this only a couple feet off those trails now what I'm using today I've got the analogic some bragging rights eight corner attractant now as a hunter we all know that white tails fake love acorns so with this attractive it's really a grain based type of attractive and like all their quality products it contains an XI of T X 4 which is a deer concentrated power pack to promote good health if you've got strong healthy beer you're gonna have a bigger deer which equals more meat we're also gonna have bigger racks so not only will the smell draw on it but once they eat it they will keep coming back for more so not only are you giving them something that's gonna taste good but it's really good for them too so I'm gonna put the rest of this here and then I'm gonna head off hunting and hopefully I'll get some nice pictures and some big bucks in here I'm gonna finish up the foil repped pheasant and then get to work on the salmon or sabi balls C dubs got chili and buddies in Mazatlan up next right here [Music] welcome back to the sporting chef I'm Scott lacf I have three asian-inspired dishes today did the venison bulgogi this is the foil wrapped pheasant breast I've taken the the pheasant it's been sauced it hasn't been cooked all the way through it's been cooled take a square of foil place pheasant that already has the sauce in it in the square fold it over into a triangle seal both sides and this part might seem a little odd to you I've got a bunch of these already made it's going in the West End deep fryer only takes a couple of minutes these are going to drain I've got one more recipe wasabi salmon balls but here's C dub with some texas chili scott one of my all-time favorite meals in camp is cornbread and chili and we're gonna do something with our chili that's a little different so we're gonna just show you the difference between yankee chili and the way a texan makes chili down there without being so we want to get our cornbread started person we're gonna do that in a 12-inch dutch oven on our stove and we're going to use the dome we don't have to fire up any charcoal all my dry ingredients are in here this is just C dubs version of a cornbread mix that you buy in the store gonna take just out of my FoodSaver bag and give it a stir okay so we have our dry ingredients all mixed up and what we're going to do where I'm going to take two eggs here I'm one of these guys I don't like to do a lot of dishes so I need about 2 tablespoons of oil our buttermilk is acidic our baking powder or baking soda are both bases so that chemical reaction gives us a little more lip come in here with about 2 cups of buttermilk here again we're using our Dutch oven dome our Dutch oven is sitting on the diffuser plates which is on the burner and they're going okay so we're going to just take our wet ingredients makes them in here with our cornmeal our cornbread is ready to go we're gonna get our lid on and we're just gonna bake it stovetop here get our Dutch oven dome on to go with our cornbread that we've already got started let's make some genuine Texas chili we have a Dutch oven going here and our oils hot and here I have some coarse ground elk burgers while we're browning our meat let's go ahead and get some of our other ingredients in there and we're gonna take and start with some garlic and then we have some onions here and we're gonna get this and we're going to brown this all together and we're gonna start with a little bit of Mexican oregano and I just use all about that much we're gonna add just a little bit of cayenne pepper cumin and then it gives that that very distinct Southwest flavor so let's just start adding some liquid and I'm gonna start here with just a little bit of water okay we're gonna have just a 12 ounce can of tomato juice now we're gonna add about a quarter cup of chili powder and we're going to add some tomato sauce okay now this is starting to look good tomato paste we're gonna get our tomato paste pretty well stirred into there and then I'm gonna add a little bit more water and we're going to let this simmer for a few minutes there you go chili and cornbread for supper tonight all right this is gonna go fast pay close attention I have cooked salmon this was smoked salmon ran it through a food processor it's dumped and go time green onions pickled ginger sesame oil lime juice crunchy water chestnuts a little cornstarch to help bind it one egg wasabi powder mix cold water an egg salmon wasabi balls into the egg mixture this is panko and sesame seeds into the westin fryer time's up here's buddy [Music] a little bit twice [Music] my transmission Thank You Gigi I owe that they make you been alive enough right now we'll get our man has to pay he stands his room that's ready and chefs here I made an excellent lobster bisque this is gonna really have a richness to this [Applause] you know I might have crammed too much into today's show but I have complete confidence that our editors will make it work right guys come on back for the big food shot [Music] welcome back to the sporting chef bulgogi venison right here lots of flavor one of the camera guys at during the break he started eating it and went wow and it is good here's the crispy crunchy salmon wasabi balls crunchy on the outside salmon e on the inside the foil wrapped pheasant when you serve it people just unwrap it thusly and on the inside you have the delicious marinated pheasant already in its own sauce and since the salmon balls are a little bit spicy with the wasabi I have some chili sauce that I'm going to dunk it in I guess that's it the big thanks today to everybody that was on the show Susie Jeff melissa sedum and buddy and as always I want you to thank our sponsors that make it possible for me to invade your kitchens your living rooms or wherever it is you watch this every day and if I do this a lot well you know it's me I'm Scott leisa the sporting chef and we'll see you next week [Music] you [Music] | The Sporting Chef | UCk7uarRgwmgZ_FCFzVEqgOQ | 2019-09-11 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,101 | 15,896 |
6-25zl3knzU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6-25zl3knzU | NH: Drug commissioners wont say if they've used drugs | are you an advocate of keeping some drugs illegal yeah have you ever used an illegal drug yourself edition of The Riddler report is brought to you by Lauren da da I don't want you to hear them mr. Bartholomew are you an advocate of keeping certain drugs illegal how you use illegal drugs yourself are you on the Commission yeah question for you are you an advocate of keeping certain drugs illegal yeah anyone the permission yes the NR you on the commissioner Diane talking about him enough not on this mission what I suggested are you on the Commission is there a question for you so what extent is affected the state actually sells drugs in the form of alcohol take away from your efforts here it wasn't exactly the hardest question I've ever asked are you on the Commission question for you are you an advocate action it judge Kelly oh are you on the Commission mr.foster useful trying to stop people from uploading pictures of their ballots what's with that what are your priorities exactly if you're doing something like that another definition senators yes question for you are you an advocate of keeping some drugs illegal yes have you ever used an illegal drug yourself why should we trust you on the Commission if you won't even tell us whether you've used drugs are you on the direct Commission yeah question for you what extent is the state's status as a drug dealer itself undermine your efforts to stop people from using drugs excuse me okay all right yes sir thanks ticker nope can't do that federal agents on the streets of keene new hampshire they're investigating reports of an unlicensed radio station said to be broadcasting lrm FM so why all the fuss what is lr n dot FM well it's probably not something these agents want you to listen to it's a 24-hour news talk broadcast all-pro Liberty a true authoritarian free zone tune in at lr EFM to listen or broadcast their signal lr n dot FM h don't want you to hear then [Music] | RidleyReport | UCE_3GcvLERTeS9XFZPtRsIA | 2017-03-02 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 353 | 1,944 |
C9f3DMPvj2M | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9f3DMPvj2M | 1337 Wine and Vinously Speaking Part Deux - Episode #202 | hello everybody Welcome to lead wine TV I'm hello everybody Welcome to Elite wine TV anyway all right hello everybody Welcome to lead wine TV I'm your host Mark felsker here for another episode of show and we're again I've got Gary I'm sorry you got a wine shop and your blog you're cool but I got two much better looking ladies right here than you do there you go I called you out that wasn't Mr Gary I'm just saying anyway so yes Melissa unsol here uh with uh units speaking and well wanting to find wine shop that will become there you go so I'll let them introduce themselves because they'll do a much better job than I will so again um I'm Professor Barreto and hold on your microphone's not on again see we can see hold on there you go we're good okay so hey that's why I guess it makes your mind's on earlier you probably saw me you probably saw me doing green lights were good thing and I was saying veronique if that matters anyways so I'm Ceci Barreto first name veronique and this is Melissa unsel and we write venusly speaking wine blog and we pretty much right here is the wine blogger market of San Antonio San Antonio so consider yourself privileged that's right all of us in one room at one time and we all got our branding going on absolutely you know and this this whole Gathering was predestined because I didn't know him he didn't know me I kind of knew her they didn't know each other and then all of a sudden we're like Hey we're on episode 200 and he's like I'm on episode 200. so we decided we're gonna do this so is predestined we're supposed to combine and collaborate and all that good stuff so um starting the second of our episodes for this 200th episode Extravaganza um Olay Imports is our Focus today uh I met Magda of Olay Imports um at a tasting in Austin and she I was literally tasting all these wines okay I just I've seen her in the corner and she came up to me and she's like excuse me can you please come taste my wine I was like oh wow okay so she'll have to ask me twice she called me over and I was like why I mean she sought me out so she was very informative and I really liked the wines I've tasted I've tasted several without knowing they were from import Olay Imports um so anyways she was talking about how their emphasis is really on focusing on bloggers which anybody watching this that distributes wine um we have a live audience so we don't just you know take it and drink it we actually bring people and we have evangelists and Sans right stalkers so let us know about these lines so Olam if only all of our audience members had microphones you don't want to know what they're saying so Ole Imports represents many of the Iberian Peninsula I.E Spanish Portuguese wines mainly Spain and they were gracious enough to send us six bottles to sample so this is in our celebration of our 200th episode we share them with at least wine one three three seven wine blog and our panel of Judges audience so a little bit about the background Olay Imports was started by a gentleman named Patrick Montes if you want to stay with a Spanish accent he grew up working on Vineyards in Spain started making Wines in the 1800s in Malaga in southern Spain a shout out to a good friend I have in Malaga Paula I love you if you're watching this in 1998 he came to the U.S to finish his college education and at the young tender age of 20 he decided that with his best friend Alberto orte that they were going to import wine from their college dorm when I was in college I didn't think about importing wine I don't know about you no unfortunately not no I wasn't thinking about wine at all time in import wine so they started with three wines importing and now they have 140 wines and 43 U.S states 10 countries really intense he's like not even 30 30 something so it makes me feel kind of bad kind of a little bit don't feel bad about yourself whatever we're on our 200 post yeah that's right we have more posts no but anyways great job Patrick apparently he's a really great guy I get to meet him but apparently Magda just talks about him he's a great guy Patrick come to San Antonio meet us meet our crew we have a huge fan base here's a little picture Patrick okay there you go moving on to the wines we're going to pour the first wine it is the navaran dama it is a Cava coming from the job sorry you know we have an unruly crowd here um so we're going to pour on this cover I will pour myself first and you guys can take care of it well my mother is in the crowd and she's oh anyways uh okay continue on so the wine that we're pouring is a kava for those of you that don't know about sparkling wine around the world um in the Champagne region of France it's called champagne obviously it's made there anywhere else it's sparkling wine particularly from Spain it's called Cava from Italy Prosecco uh Germany nobody nobody else had Jerry drinks it um pretty much kava is usually produced with a ferello parallada and macabeo grape this one and she's pronouncing those because you're very good awesome I practice every night got it so this one is actually not any of those no it has one it's a Chardonnay and parallada chardonnayada say it with me okay so this comes from this company from the region pinedes it's 80 Chardonnay 20 parallada it's a sustainable farming so for those of you that aren't familiar with the green efforts in the wine industry sustainable just means that they take a lot of effort to make sure that their winemaking process when growing is environmental and that can include lots of things they're not necessarily organic but sustainable um this particular Cava there's only 2 000 cases made so pretty hard to find but delicious and they do produce a line of kavas this brand so if you can't find this particular one you'll find them elsewhere 2 000 cases made 900 for the US so we're gonna fight to the death for who can have these 24 months are on leaves for those of you that don't know leaves are just basically residual Dead Yourself Dead yourself yummy sounds appetizing huh um yeah so anyways let's taste all right okay chair again yeah cheers we have some good we have some uh some nice cavas at that Glazier thing too right sounds good yeah big fan high school buddy right here okay I get a little smokiness on this right you sold the bakery sold the bakery you've been making uh making TJ cinnamon are they around anymore still I don't know sourdough yes sourdough you don't see her but marinara was ongoing yes sourdough on that marinara with Embroidery Creations for all your embroidery needs very nice she made this shirt she's always short she didn't make that shirt I don't know one of those online I don't know whether I can't remember it was either Cafe Press or Zazzle I got one of each she's going to make a shirt there you go thank you I get okay so you're walking by a bakery in like a Spanish morning right you're walking streets of Spain and you smell a bakery at like five in the morning you're done drinking at the bars I'm not waking up at five in the morning and um you smell the bakery let me see if you're going to go where I'm thinking all right keep going so then the the bakery is going to make these like fine pastries but he's gonna like put a lot of lemon zest on it okay I get that yeah all right well now here's what I was and some almonds and powdered sugar I would say you know we were talking about we talked about apples on the last episode about getting the apples I'm now getting those apples like a like a bakery like an apple pie almost I like them apples yeah I like how do you like them apples so I'm getting that yeah definitely on the nose and the bakery and I like the sourdough yes does everybody like the Slime crowd it's yummy yeah um is there anything that you would particularly pair this with in particular friend or memory or an event cheese what kind of cheese yeah Manchego I love Manchego y'all hear this one okay you know me and salads and sparkly wines just always seemed to happen a spinach salad a spinach salad with the blue cheese crumbles you know that type of you know the the typical dressing they put all like a honey balsamic or something like that with a little bit of spicy sauce nice sounds delicious sounds good to me right and cranberries on there some pecans hey all right we have a very engaged back to Halloween I was just I was just me in a cape okay so out of curiosity at a suggested retail price what everybody's still buy this wine at twenty dollars yeah twenty dollars good personally another unique thing that I would like to point out is that this is 16 but you know 20 is good enough I would like to be free oh wait we did the unique thing too is that it's a vintage so normally you don't see vintages for twenty dollars on a vintage because usually they like to maintain a style a style so they mix and combine years and barrels Etc and with this one they said 2008 was amazing let's keep it that way so for twenty dollars for a vintage yeah that's actually a phenomenal price it's a great Bottle too what would you pair with the succession Miss Melissa so for a fashion pairing for this since we have the veniously Chic section of venusly speaking and we like we like to mix things up a little bit we like to have a little fun on our on our blog so for this I would definitely go with something very very vibrant and I'm thinking just wear some like awesome fashion like booties that have fur on them and then have a bolero with fur on top as well and starting so anyway that I would I would totally do that tons of fun yeah I'm just like Mark with furry booties Apple Bottom Jeans boots with the fur yeah of course a faux fur all right are we moving on we're moving on next line holy Imports thank you for the navaran delicious delicious next we are moving on to the bodegas Barco de Piedra okay from Rivera Del duero anytime I do anything Spanish wine I'm gonna have since you come over I mean I can pronounce this stuff but I can't pronounce it as well but the funny thing is I don't speak Spanish she does speak French yes any french wine French accent says okay anyways so yeah we pour a nice talk okay give me a second okay 2010 the bark of the foot maybe I don't know yeah right from the Rivera Del duero it is 100 tempranio tempranio in case you don't know is the grape meaning temprano in Spanish which means early so it's been early ripening grape 25 year old Vines almost as old as I am oh really definitely not close to my age except that you're 27 on 25 so okay yeah um it's got um it's got three three thousand one hundred cases made but only 1450 for the US so again we're gonna fight to the death for these um five months in French Oak with a Teensy bit of American Oak and that's all I'm gonna say until we get to the tasting part of it um spice some Plum a little bit of wood kind of like um um I feel like I'm back at Salt Lake barbecue sorry I was there over there last week met Scott the owner and and Damien owner of the Duckman dukeman did you really yeah I met him yeah anyway um when I went to go see Driftwood Winery by the way that's going to be the episode between 200 and this one just because I promised them I'd have it up by a certain day um so this will be episode 202. maybe the next episode of 200 so I haven't been over there but I I there's a ton of Texas wines the Texas whiners gotta go there okay I'll let you know anyway um but I kind of like that you know kind of like your you've got the wood fire going it's it's very it's very good yeah yeah very vibrant I kind of want to turn on my fire you know it's very you can't really see it again they make a fire but I'm just gonna turn it on turn on the fire what a switch Plumbing yes very plummy yes very Plumbing on that come on baby but I also get kind of a chocolatey thing this wine is fantastic I'm not gonna lie those are really nice yeah it does you know we weren't talking about you know we talked before we started recording that we weren't going to score these wines but I would score this one very high I mean yeah very high as far as how high score I don't really give anything above a 90 of it out of 100 very often so this would be somewhere 90 or more um not 100 because kind of like how I value my employees nobody's a perfect you know apparently Robert Parker feels there's 100.1 except me oh yeah yeah delicious well I just think just in general temper NEOS are just great like meat wines and barbecue wines steak wines not really yeah I mean really I I really think that they they do well with that type of pairing and they're they're I keep talking about how Cabernet Franc is becoming my favorite but but temperedu has that kind of like that I'm really enjoying tempranio's yeah Frank is really kind of like my new like favorite thing oh yeah what kind of would you pair this with so I'm feeling that we need some velvety texture to go along with this one so the velvet Elvis yes exactly used to be doing the fashion pairings you know what right now I forfeit phineasley chic actually I was thinking like I seriously think like Rodeo yeah yeah like like you know the whole barbecue thing and temporary liners okay Rodeo occurs here in San Antonio in February I'm on it velvety chapters Chic on the side and bling bling I'm kind of yeah I'm kind of feeling like a beef carpaccio with this oh yeah I'm hungry okay so I'm going to tell you guys the retail price but I don't believe them really well wait let's ask what do you think it is okay anyone but maybe anyone what do you all think the retail price on there price a dollar for this one the suggested retail price for our audience is 19.99 it's actually nope no but it's 15. very very well priced I think it's a really really good that's well fried Olay important I think it's very reasonably priced for that for what it is I mean like I said I think it's an excellent wine I would highly recommend it so good okay um a great price a Lamport and that's just fine number one in the Reds drink up absolutely yeah for sure in Texas we love our barbecues you know honestly you guys are going to be really shocked at the prices I'm not going to tell you what they are but but remember Spanish wines are usually value wines maybe not as much as value one as they used to be but they're still you still get some great great wines for a good price Portugal let's talk about Portugal you can get some really good Portuguese wines for real cheap on you know good prices I noticed that we don't have a Spokane because these are really great I could use this glasses but hey I did that at one time yeah I did I had to had the glass and yeah moving on all right moving on to what we got next vacuum all right chatty Chatterton friends in the audience okay guardiana is that right diapers hey as my parents can tell you and as a good friend you had it okay guys you pronounce Spanish I just I just say I can't okay so talking about this wine while it's being poured it is 2010 again 100 temprania so we can compare it with the one before and this one so let's see what they say yeah there's 4 000 cases made and 3 000 for the US so it's a bit more so we don't have to fight to the death just to the extreme pain of the person who loses um that's for you Eddie Izzard um it's two months two months in French Oak really just two months so it's a bit less the other one was five months in French where's it from yeah towards Portugal South East no sorry Southwest yeah I always do that too because everything's east of us right yeah okay good I'm not the only one that does that yeah seriously it'll be Southwest I'm like no it's South no yeah it's Southwest I'm sorry it's uh located west of La Mancha near the Portuguese Borderland okay friends so what do we smell but larger than the last one yeah I don't get as much Plum but I get I don't know maybe a bit of cherry I don't know yeah honestly yeah I'm on that black cherry yeah um but I am sorry I do kind of get some alcohol on it so you know what you're gonna do with this you're gonna like just take a little bit and glaze like a pork tenderloin oh that would be delicious so being that the last timpreneur is a little bit velvety what would you say this one would pair with this fashion so I think with this one I automatically think feathers feathers nice and you know what's funny I have a dress in my closet that's all sparkly up here yeah feathers on the bottom nice perfect huh yeah I got nothing for you on Fashion on this perfect anything feathery walk around with it oh yeah oh yeah brown sugar brown brown sugar you know that's interesting yes also great Rolling Stones yeah there you go you know and then even a little bit on the palette you know a little bit of sweetness on it um it would it'd be excellent wrap that pork tenderloin and some bacon I mean it's it's definitely more of a fruit forward wine than a quote old old world you know um vegetable spicy you know spicy wine more of a fruit forward wine I think I think the black cherries are really coming through more on the palette than the note so the word we're on the street what on the street take a little bit of this wine reduce it put on your pork tenderloin your steaks there you go something that's going to be amazing uh as far as the cheese manga side more aged cheese I'll go with that nothing yeah the ones that crumble you can't shave them all right yeah Wisconsin chetas all right so what do you do what do y'all thinking what do you guys think this wine costs 12 bucks everybody it is nine dollars everyone take it home that's a great price point for the science excellent you can do a lot of things with it I'll lay Imports so far three for three yeah so are we ready for the next we're gonna move on yes yes we have a pretty unruly crowd yeah well you know I don't know come on you another advocate of getting you know wasted but I mean I'm like you guys are like fall behind me here what do they hear us did she hear us more in the crowd Yes actually that microphone because that microphone pipe picks up a little bit of the crowd okay everyone's doing the wave they're doing away without the microphones you wouldn't be able to hear us right now I hold no responsibility for our friends there you go that's coming from my mom she said that she's not my friend and I just made an observation but for veniously Chic everyone in the audience is either wearing black or red or polka dots and well it's swimming for me and we have a green in our audience as well so we have Christmas colors we have herbaceous notes with the greens if we were able to we would form a pyramid and Brian would be on top because he would be the star s except better because those of you know dignating yoga everybody I'm taking over here I'm taking over your spot too everybody put your glass to your mouth everybody glass to your mouth glass to your mouth glass finish up your wine so we can go to the next one it works for a little bit all I am towards your wines are amazing okay next nabuko is that like a Star Wars all right okay everybody you know well I've never heard of this attention wine crabs I'm talking oh hello all eyes on me no and your mouth not on me no there's no editing remember that well I don't know okay you just go right okay and get glasses and receipts and everything so eye contact nabuko nabuko 2010 again third line yes it's from the producer senorio de barrawonda it's from yatla which is in the south east region of Southeast for you guys uh Spain um Southeast it's 50 monasterel for those of you that don't know when Estrella is the Spanish name for more beds in French and 50 Syrah sustainable farming again they're concerned about the environment so we should support them 2000 cases made 2000 for the US so I think that we pretty much have the market on this one so if you're living in Spain sorry or anywhere else sorry um did you mention yeah three months three months in French Oak and this wine maker is a lady I think is that a Sally a woman yes yes I have an artist Ellie at work and it's a woman so I would you're not a woman we're sorry but we're claiming it's a woman that's it this one is going to taste amazing what do you smell Mark audience I I get the plum again but I you know honestly I get I it seems a little bit I get a lot of alcohol still I mean it's really it feels like it's kind of hot I'm gonna I'm gonna make a guess is it these ones have been open for like 14 14 and a half percent or more alcohol in there when you look at the bottle alcohol content what's the alcohol content there well maybe it's like 13 and a half 14. yeah this wine has been open for three hours too bad too bad uh you know the the certified test doesn't really care how you can tell how alcoholic a wine is but you know I'm just gonna say this no you know what okay so here's yeah yeah yeah so I just got a little bit of um like brush like like wood not not hair brush but like you're out like in the the country a little bit you're out in like the fields and you get like the the brush it you know I don't have much hair to brush hey maybe okay but you know get kind of like that that I don't want to see rag Ragweed but the type of like you know um yes Briar yeah I just like brush you know like Brushwood this type of thing but a little bit of that we can't take our friends anywhere Dolce what's up there you go actually we take them everywhere to tell you the honest truth we take our friends so what do you think audience tell us talk to us do you like it it is very smoothly I'm personally gonna say I personally believe Halloween callback I was Miss South Carolina go watch the Titans South Carolina whatever you'll find on YouTube I personally believe that nabuki wines are suitable for South Texas wine drinkers because certain people out there make barbecue items and anyways it would go great with barbecue that's excellent excellent yeah very mellow okay yes yes like your little French onion tartlets all right so yes Marion you're makes them amazing how many of you know what a chimichurri sauce is oh yeah yes this right here can we try there you go did it work at the day job so um at work we weave in well one of the one of the restaurants we were suggesting a certain pairing of wine because there's a there's a spice to the wine and you go to chimichurri but honestly I think this would be a better pairing because it's a little more forward yeah and I think it would work well with the spiciness of something like a sauce like that yeah that's not necessary chimichurri but I think we'll work with that so yes the spicy barbecue we mentioned earlier I think it worked well and I know counteract that I know that it's not only important but I tasted some Santa Julia wines at a lunch and Chef Anna Rodriguez made an amazing chimichurri sauce so I'm sorry only Imports but I do have to put a plug in for Santa Julia chef and I do get a lot of things on the palace still got a lot of that wood that like you know Brushwood or whatever Briar Briar that's gonna be another one this will be a new word new explanation I get a lot of that basically what this is this is one of those ones I will say tastes like you're you're in Texas it tastes like the state even though it's not from Texas I feel like I'm somewhere in like a field somewhere and there's a bunch of like you know trees and I can taste the wood and not not an oak type of where you taste like the Oak from water but that type of stuff and what fashion pairing would you buy with this yeah so for fashion with this one we have 50 50 on the grapes here and so I'm gonna say a nice chunky necklace with a little bit of bling and a little bit of subdued mate colors as well it's going to be excellent with this wine very nice absolutely maybe a little cowboy hat to like make a new detective like radio fashion maybe I don't know what I don't even own cowboy boots or a half yeah but if you would like to wear them no absolutely fine I do but I took them to France and they're still there my Texan boots are in France all right ladies and gentlemen all right moving on audience we have two more wonderful wines to taste all right what was next okay so I'll let you pour that first while I drink uh veronique and myself were obviously uh slow tasters too busy talking it's okay it's coming along this way yeah right here and now oh yeah price point audiences called me out good job right yes no what do you think it was exactly the Little Tone that I kept hearing at the at the Paris airport just for those that are wondering of course this is going to be the next written blog post about traveling to France it might mean stuck at the Paris airport for like eight hours the Little Tone they used to announce that the trains are arriving is literally the same three tones from Soldier Boy literally hearing that for eight hours straight anyway no I did not break into dance I would at the wedding last week I taught everyone How to Dougie I don't even know how to play so we'll do that after the tasting everyone yeah oh yeah yeah I would just like actually yes I would like to point out for oh absolutely let's get a little close-up of the label on the back I don't know oh I am sorry great information on there so I don't know if you saw that but yeah I wish every I wish all wine labels give you a line well unless it is if they can't read it if you're an importer or you're doing oh that was Aaron Rodgers okay everybody taboosh um the back label is the grape it says the vine the location the soil the climate follow this uh maybe we can put like a picture of it yes yes I wasn't really looking at the labels here but all of them this is definitely an Olay thing because good job yes thank you I mean it provides a wine blogger he's a wine blogger I mean I really want or just a wine enthusiast I want to know these things whereas you get a lot of wines and you don't know anything all they put is a bunch of marketing fluff on the back and this is just yeah it tells you what it is I think the only thing I would maybe add if you don't have it is preparing pairings that's about it however yes however our audience has been very good at identifying food pairings yes as well so if you have more wines only Imports which you do because I have your book send us more all right so tell us about this one we do love them all ones these are really astonishing us with the pricing and okay everybody okay so so this is the priorat um so this comes from the region priorat it sounds really weird but actually I'm not gonna lie to you guys I really like priorat as a region pre-road it sounds cool I like to say it drink it big fan I don't know what that means periods like near Barcelona area it's 50 karanacha 30 mazuelo mazuela if you remember from the Cava 10 Cabernet Sauvignon and 10 Syrah 3 000 cases made in 1 300 made for the US fight for the death um aged eight months in French Oak what do you smell it's just like a little knife you know I just get clean out of it just there's nothing I don't get anything really like nothing predominant out of it it's just it just smells like it's just a clean nose uh not not not a not a bad chemical clean not like bleach type of clean but just it's just tight yeah it's very it's very tight nose I don't get much of it just it's just a clean a clean nose and I can't I can't give up I guess so I just can't get anything I can't get any fruit or spice out of it but you know that's okay perfect I get a little like what lavender okay floral I would guess yes because I have a hard time with floral stuff but I can kind of get that floral type under brush are you reading the notes no but I'm gonna say I'm gonna say that it's a Spice Box I don't know what that means like a potpourri type of thing peppery yeah spicy you know those kind of um very understated blueberries dated here understated okay it looks very nice blueberry would you buy it we'd buy all of these I would buy all we'd buy all of these although my friends so far I would think everybody his lovely Olay you win Olay wins I'd love to hear that um fashion as she drinks um first one on the palette again very very smooth um not not a lot of heat to it um not super tannic um moderate acid on there I get I heard some say blueberries and I kind of get that on the palette you know like a berries type of thing um in a little a hint of wood but not nothing not a lot um it's just it's it's easy drinking um this is something you could drink by itself without food yeah and it's easy like Sunday morning anyway time for some music pairing karaoke yeah there you go absolutely we should do episode 210 for San Antonio this is so silky smooth and clean silky smooth and clean so we need a silk jacket that goes just to the thigh maybe three quarter length sleeves with a little um maybe floral notes on it maybe they're black floral but maybe they're a little bit colorful yeah and silky with like a black floral and I'm just gonna throw another Another music reference a short skirt with a Long Jacket a little cake there's a music Major coming out the music of the green coming out I see music in my parents in our future all right um definitely like it I'm gonna guess eleven dollars I like the guessing game we have going on here so what would you guys guess for this 13. 14. price prices maybe yeah all right fifteen dollars oh wow wow we underpriced this all of these ones what did they say oh yeah they're a little nuts there did it say hold on all right um I'm even at 15 I think it's good um but but I think I would rather see it but otherwise better they just it's just that it's not as complex as some of the other wines that's why this is easy drinking so 15's maybe a little bit high but this is um this one says that it doesn't say it doesn't say that's okay it's okay figure out though all right so let's talk about Price Point again we were at I only I didn't hear any price point on there so it's all about price point uh first of all oh by the way uh the battery died the back um we luckily noticed the red the red light wasn't on recording so we shouldn't have missed too much so we're back and I think we missed the whole price point if not you'll hear it twice but it's 0.5 price point on there okay eighteen dollars right we were giving plugs that's why I was like I was typing in typing information and that's when I noticed it was the light was wrong okay I'm gonna make sure we have nearly here I've embroidery yes foreign and um you hear like a radio voice thing going on too all your it needs okay thank you um High School s I'm not going to say anything because I have a few things I could say but not listening yeah in about two weeks someone's gonna buy your hot nanny.com very good virginia.com it's going viral people it's going viral we have Mario America that's right no actually I don't mention where I work at okay just so you know it just it is a personal thing I I am a restaurant manager I just don't I just try to keep my restaurant management and my personal stuff there you go you can you can whoa whoa you can plug that's right yes I'm also a marketing director for a litigation technology for firm and this is so excited about very good can't wait to market now that my microphone works again hello you probably had a huge volume on this but anyways you probably do yours probably picked me up a little bit that's okay I didn't say anything important trust me yeah the audience is ready wrap it along we'll go last I guess we're ready okay ready we're ready apparently I needed a drink special one for me the wine maker it's a party so these are broken so many Brokers everybody all right so side point it's okay because we have like several of these glasses don't worry not a problem she doesn't go over there yeah okay so okay we pause for a second we're about to taste a special wine very special yeah so this comes from Cellar pinol and seller pinol is with Olay Imports but um wanjo Juan Ho is the gentleman that makes the wines he's one of the wine makers and he came to San Antonio and so we were at Joe sagameni's wine shop which we support small business wine shops so even though we are wanting to find wine shop Joe sakum Denis wine uh fine wine shop it's so cool very good support them so um anyways he was there and he was doing a great tasting so we met him and he signed a bunch of bottles really cool guys so if you can find Stellar pinol they have a bunch of labels um of their wine we're tasting the ludovicus and so I fully support them a lot these all these ones are great but this one is um definitely one it was very fun to me very personal guy which I imagine that anybody that Olay takes on is going to be the same way so did you want to pour yourself in um yes all right so no on the palette I get I still get a plum thing I mean he's a kind of a recurring theme among some of these wines but get the plum thing on on the nose yeah I have a dog here by the way okay come back over here she doesn't have her own business so I didn't plug her I forgot to tell you about this one can I interrupt you yeah no absolutely let's go okay so Ludovic is 2010 which I think everyone is almost 2010. okay so we have uh ludovicus 2010. it's uh the seller Pinon so there's many labels of these um it's from Alta region which is just outside of Barcelona Barcelona marcelona it's a 40 garanacha 15 karinena 10 Merlot twenty percent Syrah and 15 tempranio again it's 40 karacha fifteen percent ten percent Merlot twenty percent Syrah and fifteen percent they spared no expense 9 000 cases made seven thousand for the us so we don't have to fight the death just for the extreme pain three months in French Oak in America and American so what do you smell oh so I got the Oh serious awesome sauce okay um I got the plum made a little chocolate on it that's about it it's all I get anyone else so what Fashion Place are you just waving over here okay anyone else you guys you have to like realize that our audience is wild audience what do you smell no chocolate amazingness chocolate plum oh I would like to put a plug we had a we had a Halloween event and we put this one there yeah we had a Halloween event we did a veniously speaking Halloween event we had this wine attention we're doing the fashion pairing now you know I would like to ask the audience what you would wear one what would you like because sleeping I I've seen some of you comments on what you would wear what you are feeling when you're drinking this wine what would you wear say Robert something about it we have a shirt with cherries it's a bit silky too I do have to say on a more serious fashion note if you were in the mood yeah the cold weather you could have like one of those red jackets it's like a long run jacket with this one a little red jacket with a little cinch little coat tie oh purple okay okay we have a we have a point of contention red or purple 86 the red it's purple yeah yes I love that purple so Robert's gonna wear a long purple jacket and I'm gonna wear a long red jacket like oh pajamas okay ooh my mom said silk red pajamas silk red pajamas see there you go suggestions what do you guys think the price what would you pay I looked what she had to cover so I I don't know 15.99 nice I'm thinking more 19.99 17.99 we have a lot of okay all right so I'm going lower 7.99 veronique eleven eleven dollars okay more minutes everybody everybody put your glass in your mouth the whole thing I am knocking away just to be a shirt everyone everyone thank you I would just like to say no listen here just in case the audio does not come through I would just like to say a big I would like to say a big thank you to Ole Imports yes for sending us this wine for being holy Imports thank you for being a part of this monumentous episode posting of one three three seven litwine blog and venusly speaking and wine a fine wine shop and all the other plugs we made thank you very much for sending these wines we appreciate it I think everyone here was surprised by the prices so I think that and how good everything was and how good it was very amazing wine and I know I think you did a good job with your quality and they like your wine labels on the back labels anything else um and and Dolce the wine dog right Dolce Dolce Barreto and Bailey barbaresco are the wine dogs of the shop of the shop yes um so thank you very much Elaine Imports um thank you thank you cheers thank you we enjoyed it all right Cheers Cheers thank you all right I'm out of wine but anyway all right I was just gonna wrap it up for this episode uh as always stop by the website check everything out on there and uh we'll see you again next time thank you | Wine World TV | UCPmfD45krhbgj8SHq2EfyPQ | 2011-12-19 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 7,251 | 36,710 |
3CszO4xOQW8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3CszO4xOQW8 | Cupid's Corner - Love life advice! Topic: Having disagreements / arguments & the 5-5-5 rule! | foreign [Music] what's up guys I'm John I'm Sharif and we are back with another Cupid's Corner that's right every week every Sunday 11 A.M me and my beautiful wife over here are bringing you guys new tips tricks and ways to excite ignite and hopefully take your relationship to a whole new healthy positive level and hopefully extend the longevity of that relationship and don't worry for your people out there your guys and girls that are in a relationship just store all these away put them as mental notes so you guys can utilize these tips and tricks to help you in your future relationship and hopefully that will be a long lasting positive healthy relationship so let's just get into it so this week we're going to talk about something that every relationship should have and not everybody looks for these things right so let's talk about having a disagreement or an argument this is something that is very common and is necessary for a healthy relationship this shows that you have your own opinion or you want to talk about something or you feel a certain way about something that your partner may not feel the exact same way about or you guys might disagree on something that you guys want to get or buy you need to agree to disagree or take in whatever it may be you guys are making decisions and now you have a partner to make that decision with so you guys got to you guys are going to have to agree on these decisions about what they are and if you're just starting a relationship these might be minor things like hey where are we going to go on our date are you gonna spend the night at my house are you gonna spend the night at your house some of these little things right and then as you get into your relationship and you start really really committing to that person new things start happening and this might cause disagreements arguments or even fights down the road now like I said it's healthy everybody should have an argument or disagreement not even a relationship you will you will you will unless you have a really submissive partner that just takes everything even the submissive people I think still yeah I do I think at some point even in their submissiveness they might still go along with it but they might have that one point where like well you know and they might they're not gonna maybe not aggressive you know like me or whatever you know I'm like you know um but maybe they might just be like well and then that might be the cue where the other partner is like okay let me be fair here like that's where you're supposed to jump in and be the fair person instead of just always being the decision maker and being the person making all decisions all the time true like I said different people different things true and the different relationships different ways that they abide by these different things so it really depends on how your relationship is structured right now if you guys are both Alphas you guys might butt heads even more than the regular person that has a submissive partner because you guys are both in the driver's seat or trying to be and both people want their foot on the pedal but I really like driving a lot like a lot yeah you're gonna have to establish you know the dominance level who's Alpha who's debate in the relationship it just is what it is it's true you can't have two Alphas it just does not work like that now they could be the alpha in their own sense yeah I'm the alpha in my own he's talking about me in front of me right now yes I'm talking about our relationship he's literally talking about us in front of me [Laughter] it was like a like a thing he read online but this is like this is happening it's active it's just a prime example that I want to give you guys I mean it's funny you know because really though I mean I am an alpha female right I have always been an alpha female I I like I make the calls I do Drive I've always driven blah blah blah okay so I meet an alpha male and I needed okay and you guys gotta you guys should really think about this actually so I needed an alpha male in my life to balance me because if I had a beta even though you were thinking Alpha and a beta go together sometimes an alpha needs another Alpha to have a balance instead of having a beta because then you may not you might tip over sideways and you might not it just may not work out that well but it took many years to establish okay well all right I'll be the beta when I'm with you but outside of this relationship I'm the alpha like you know with our staff or with my friends or whatever it might be so we've established that but it that did not happen overnight and that took many many years I mean even to this day there might be a situation that happens that we're butting heads like that just because of our personalities and we're both we're both so much alike yet so different in many aspects but we are alike in a lot of ways and sometimes being alike you don't always agree because you are alike it's true so you know it's it's it's you there you can't have the two Alphas it doesn't work that way and that's if you're dating a girl a guy girl girl guy guy whatever it is out there you know it's it's irrelevant somebody's gonna have to step down now with that being said whether you're an alpha or beta let's remove Alpha and beta names right here's person a person B you guys are gonna have to come to some sort of agreement right you can't always be like okay I'm now we're doing what the alpha says it doesn't work like that you guys have to come to like a 50 50 agreement okay sometimes you'll agree to disagree sometimes one person will be like okay fine we'll go with that or the next person okay fine we'll go with that but you guys have to meet each other at a halfway point there is a halfway point you have to meet each other at it's fair being fair I don't know if anybody has to reach out to a middle point but it would probably be a good idea some people will never do that some people will never give in and you will find a downfall in your relationships if you do do that so you might have to rethink some of the different ways that you've been before in the past and that's harder as we get older because we're still set in our ways you know prime example is my dad oh my gosh dudes like you know sitting there he's like I don't want to be with another woman because you know I like things my way and they're going to try to change me and do that like all right well listen you know if you if you want companionship you want a partner um you know you got you got to have some sort of you know opening and balance to a certain extent you don't want them to change you who you are either but you know big shout out to my dad yeah [Laughter] listen hold on I'm getting into that I'm fine so the big thing about this and we we talk about every time is communication and that's the only way you're going to get past these disagreements or arguments and fights and you want to talk civilly right it's not screaming at each other aggressively you know because that doesn't do anything one person screams the other person screams louder the other person screams louder than that and then you guys are getting more aggressive down the road start being calm when you talk right you can feel a certain way or very passionate about it and you can express that without being super aggressive and it might be hard for some of you guys out there so that's where self-control really comes into play now let's talk about because we're about the five minute warning let's talk about the 555 method with the five minute warning and we've never we've never had you know we've never used this method per se on ourselves we haven't but I'm always looking for new tools to help couples out there really get over some of the humps or problems that they're going through you know I've already went through my home so my you know my roadblocks you know to get by there and make sure that everything is working in my uh in my little track but you guys got to make sure that your track is cleared so when I talk about this we talk about communication right but the 555 method is probably going to be one of your Best Bets to be able to utilize as a couple so you haven't heard of this let's talk about it I haven't so three fives right they all stand for something the first five right the first two I guess the first two are going to be five minutes each for each partner and in those five minutes you cannot interrupt your partner you have to listen to them and you gotta make eye contact and be fully involved with what they're saying for five minutes after that five minutes is done then your partner gets their five minutes and they get to talk without you talking to them and you listening to them with eye contact and full involvement the last five minutes is going to be you guys talking out together now you've heard each other's points in the five minutes so really think about those five points get your points together if you're gonna do the five five because you only have five minutes well I mean five minutes is a long time to talk I mean you know if it's a a huge one problem thing I think you just being straightforward and communicating what that problem is or what made you upset or what you didn't like or what the boundary is I think you can get that point across in five minutes without just going to offsuit and just keep coming back and back and just you know repeating things over and over be direct say what the problem is say we don't like say what the boundary is and then let your partner talk and then let them talk and really hear them out really what they're saying put yourself in their shoes and think about would you like that if your partner was doing that to you and if you say yes then at that point tell them say listen I would expect the exact same to happen to me if I was in your shoes but if you don't agree then you can say listen I do see it from your side and even if you don't agree with them you need to see their perspectives yeah 100 you need at least all the thighs somewhere because even if you don't see it that's fine people see things in different ways so you have to really understand them and say listen I agree with your perspective but I have a different perspective on this and then you guys will move on hopefully that communication the last five minutes will get you over the hump or get you past the problem or argument or whatever it may be and the biggest thing you have to do at the end of this is find a resolution yeah don't let it keep going on oh yeah because you can complain about it all day long but what's gonna be how are we going to fix it yeah right you know as me and John have gotten older over the years and busier we've become I believe you correct me from wrong but I think we've become a little bit more direct and a little bit more like okay if this is the problem what is it to fix it all right what we're gonna do fix it okay cool let's fix it and move on right it's one of those kind of things because we have no time I mean I have no time at all so out on time so it's got to be direct it's got to be here this is how we're going to do it fix it whatever so in that five minutes the very last five minutes of your five five five rule um you guys need to come to some sort of resolution on how you're going to fix the issue or maybe even like maybe bullet points and things that you guys can do to help get to the resolution because it may not be fixed overnight right it might not be no there's things that may not that might take time to fix you know and it takes time to go through it and you gotta it's just time you can't make time go faster but it does sometimes it takes my specific goals that you guys may want to achieve together what you want to achieve going forward what's made you guys upset what's made you guys fight and um try to resolve that try to get it out of the way because if you just don't talk about it faster just faster than starts building up this can cause negativity throughout the relationship um it can cause you to really not like your partner right and say like I don't even want to be around you and literally not want to be around them and that could be the downfall of your relationship and if this is something that you really love you probably should take the time to listen understand and hopefully try to find some resolution and make them happy and make you happy in the same light just know that like you know being silent and giving the silent treatment because I I used to do this and it doesn't work and like slamming things and like you know you know pushing drawers in really loud and like slamming down your cup and stuff obviously they know you're mad and like y'all have to talk about it at this point because if not it's just you're just slamming things at that point he knows that I'm mad and it's like okay what's your problem like what just tell me what your problem is right you know so just get it out of the way it takes less time so guys I hope you you guys will like this tip and trick that we're talking about today use the 555 method right all right so we'll be back every Sunday 11 A.M ABC if you guys can't watch us live make sure to DVRs and like I said if you missed that just go to YouTube hit in tight Medical Center hit the Subscribe button almost education Bill and you'll get to see me and this pretty little lady over here [Music] | Titan Medical Center | UCqC7wZ9WhpJn7nFE0F5lXBw | 2023-04-17 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 2,622 | 13,464 |
A_03g2sNNZc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A_03g2sNNZc | Plant Hybridization & Objectives | Hello friends welcome back today we'll discuss about hybridization hybridization in plant now what is hybridization is a Crossing or meeting of two plants of dissimilar genotype it's a Crossing or meeting of two plants of dissimilar genotypes in the plants The Crossing is done by transferring the Poland uh from the anth of one plant it is transferred to the stigma or the female genotype of another plant so one becomes the male parent another becomes the female parent this Crossing between to dissimilar genotype is called hybridization this process is essentially done to prevent self pollination among the plants now here you see the white flower is crossed with purple flower the first freny which is which we receive is called F1 hybrids that means the F1 hybrid is the uh result of cross between the two dissimilar genotype the first preny is called F1 hybrid now the preny which received from the hybrids or F1 is intercrossed intermitted uh between each other to create another progeny the next proy which is called as segregating generation the subsequent gener ation is called segregating Generation Now what are the main objectives of hybridization or creating hybrids one the main objective is creating genetic variations to create uh genetic variation or to assemble certain required characters in certain progeny which is uh which which would help uh in increasing the say yield or some desire character to be obtain in the next preny that's why to create genetic variation we do hybridization second is the transfer of desired characters the two parents may be having different characters when they are combined together the third generation the F1 generation is having a new character set to obtain this type of desired character combination we do hybridization now the degree of variation or degree of variation in the cross depends upon the heterogeneous genes they have if this the genes in the parents or or different heterogen series then the probability of variation is very high in the progen like if the both the parents are closely related then the probability of uh genetic variation is very less and other way if they are not closely related they're distant related then the probability of number of gene or the characters coming uh in varied manner is a probability now we can divide the objectives of uh hybridization into two types two purposes you can see first is combination breeding second is trangressive transgressive breeding the main name of combination breeding is uh to transfer one or more characters into a single variety a certain plant may be having certain design desirable character one or two desirable characters which we have to transfer in certain um certain uh progeny then we have to do combination breeding the main purpose is to increase the number of tillers for example like to create a disease resistant plant the certain one of the parents must be having some disease resistance genes which is transferred to the progeny and it becomes disease resistance number of greens per Spike to be increased so these are the different characters which we which we desire which is outcome of combination breeding not necessary the yield may be increasing most probably most of the time the yield is not affected or it is less than both the parents the parents individually on other hand the second type of transgressive breeding the main aim is to create a superior character or Superior yield by crossing the two different parents this uh transgressive segregation is a production of plant in which in F2 Generation in F2 Generation which are much more Superior than their parent Generations they may Superior than one of the single parents or both the parents in combination both the parents to achieve the second type objective transgressive breeding or transgressive segregation we have to keep certain thing in mind like the compatibility of parents second thing you have to keep in mind the diverse genetic W this will help us to combine two different type of genetic setup into one particular hybrid these are two important factor which we have to keep in mind while uh achieving the second objective of transgressive breeding so these are the basics of certain brief of hybridization and some objectives of hybridization in the next session we'll discuss more about the types of uh uh hybrization and how to achieve uh differentation processes | QuickGlanceVideos QGV Channel | UCD55VudhLr223NkUyi7R5qw | 2013-06-14 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 740 | 4,401 |
1VgFdHix-xI | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1VgFdHix-xI | 💥What EXACTLY is Jada Still Hiding? | today we're going to talk about Jada pinket and this is the second interview we've analyzed on her Greg want you tell us about the videos we're going to watch so we're going to watch excerts from two videos one is an interview where she went to correct something from her first interview with Hoda from today and then we will have a j Shetty interview with her which is a very different style video I think it's telling if you find another great love or If Will finds another great love there's no finding another great love and I think that's the point it's like we are in a place now that we are in a deep healing space and we are really concentrating on healing the relationship between us so it may not be the divorce on paper anymore there's no divorce on paper I mean not on paper there might not be a divorce in theory anymore yeah no we really have been working hard oh see okay well I didn't know I was trying to well wa I totally missed that on the H that's the thing so wait so wait just so I'm 100% clear you were divorced not on paper but now we might be a point where we're back together we are working very hard at bringing our relation yes bringing our relationship together back to a marriage again back to a life partnership yes because here's the thing about tell husband wife marriage for me for my healing process I came into that with very specific ideas right very specific ideas that were blocks to me just seeing will as who he is he can't be this perfect idealized husband I have to be able to accept him for the human that he is he accepts me for the human that I am and we want to love each other there okay so you might like live in the same house and have the yeah okay well that's the only part that's the only only part in the special that I felt like got lost well guess what it is found we found it today we found it today Jada thank you so much I really appreciate your all right Chase what do you got I want to know what y'all think but uh if Stanley kubric was still alive this looks like a scene from some dystopian candy shop where the employees are in there with this colors and the white turtleneck and the white couch it looks like Stanley kubra to me I'll uh let y'all figure that out or answer that one thing you're seeing a lot of is this and this is commonly referred to as a stop gesture the fingers are all the way extended and in your history if you've ever tried to talk someone out of doing something or try to get someone to stop doing something your fingers extend even if your hand is in your pocket down at your side in your purse doesn't matter we naturally kind of do this to stop somebody from doing doing something when she says relationship between us is a strong chin boss movement right there and she says he can't be perfect and there's no mention of her being imperfect she doesn't mention her imperfection at all just her being a human being and right at the moment that she says living that hod says you can live in the same house there is pure disgust and if you just think of the facial expression of disgust everything kind of squeezes in toward the middle a little bit you imagine like smelling a rotten jug of milk and then her eyes close all the way when she says yeah about living in the same house that had some huge red flags for me y'all probably picked up on even more Scott what did you say all right yeah well I won't repeat that part of it but yeah that's that's I think we saw a lot in here and the thing is this originally was the last video we going to show Then Greg called and said Hey listen we should put that one at the beginning and do the first video because she contradicts a few things in that thing and this first video we can go through and watch that so here we're seeing this pretty pretty much the same gestures the same illustrators we're seeing the same body language we're seeing in in the in the following videos in a different interview that we're seeing here except for they're not as animated there are some spots in the other ones where there where she's more animated but in this one I agree with you it seems so fake I mean it is because it's tv nobody has a couch like that at home no you wouldn't talk that way at home I don't anyway I know you guys don't talk that way so the whole thing seems a little bit odd but she seems she falls back into and watch from now on in the other video say she falls into this thing where she starts like you were saying using her hand but she starts this teaching mode thing where she starts telling you about what's happening and what she's learned and all these wonderful things that have happened and how she's in control of it everything looks as it should if you're in that world if you're in the TV world and you're on TV and you're an actress and you're or an actor I what they call them these days and you're an actor and you're trying to be this person you've shown everyone you are and trying to stay in that that character I think everything looks the way it should um especially since she's following that protocol she always follows of trying to be in charge of what's happening and telling you what's happening and teaching you something as you go along Greg what do you got yeah she almost gumed up the wrong answer there I love that when she asked her can you live together yeah that's the oddest answer of all of the things she does but let's leave it at that and go backward and look at everything else Mark you and I talked last week about glass painting is what I call it and we were saying maybe we come up with a collective name for it but she glass pains and by that I mean she is there to deliver a package of goods that is packaged for consumption by that person that takes a hell of a lot of practice to be good at which is a bad sign that somebody's being that casual and that selective with the way they deliver information chase you have a security clearance you did when you're active military it's like the first time you walk up and you're talking to somebody about something you know and you can't talk about the topic in detail because you know something that they might learn and they're fishing and poking they don't know that you know this thing but you do and so you're so careful with it you do your best to avoid it at every turn and you holding off at a distance that's what she's doing here with the way she uses her words I love the body language in this one because there's a whole lot of mechanical stuff going on here she when Hoda asked the question this first question look at her lower teeth get exposed that's anger arrows her eyes are narrowed and then it's followed by some asymmetry in the left side of her face or contempt as she starts to describe what this is what this is this is not what that is her tone says everything to me listen to that shift in tone it's not an angry tone it's a patronizing tone it's very strong in my opinion and then you look at those elongated key points that she elongates the vowels and the words she's trying to drive and I was wondering Chase I was thinking is because she does some false cognit and other places I've never seen anybody capable of controlling their chin so I don't think it is but it's in an odd kind of abandoned place and that left eye that data intake eye and her as narrow as it can be in this situation we're going to see very different situ when she's sitting with somebody talking about something she wants and when she says yes her head bubbles I got a 1958 impal I think a a jaded do would look really good on top of the dash just doing that look like something from the 1950s none of it looks real none of it looks believable and it looks like she came to your point packaged as some person to fit into the situation and to give the details very different from what we saw last week and all this bubbly over the top about this relationship and avoiding outright the question about where they're going move in together now Mark what do you get yeah so I would call this Jade explaining going on to Hoda uh it is very forceful it is quite condescending uh I think also it kind of switches codes you've got this first explaining part where she's very very forceful and direct and then she tries to I think amate that a little bit with something more kind of colloquial to the two of them something more banish the pitch starts you know going right up there and I think she's trying to you know level out how explaining she's doing but but as an explainer she's to my understanding She's Come On To redress something that wasn't fully understood the first time around I'm no clearer as to what on Earth is going on here it's not a good explainer the cynic uh inside of me would suggest it's like one of those emails you get from a company that's marketing when it says in the title uh you know we messed up we got something wrong but all they're trying to do is get another ey shot at you to send you through their link it feels the same to me that the the cynic inside me would go you're correcting a mistake that you don't think was a mistake because you're getting another shot at pitching your book listen no problem I you know I don't mind people who who send me those emails to go we messed up I I kind of know what you're doing and so I kind of feel like I know what's happening here which is which is a little little bit disappointing um yeah I have no doubt they're not going to live in the same house you know there's that inflection there there's the disgust that we see there there's even a bit of a peach snort beforehand as well to to see Hoda out of that territory um she she spins it's very political what's happening there she tries to reframe a lot of the ideas that are going on it and and we see the start of something we're going to see throughout the next lot of videos which is I think she finds it very hard to explain her feelings in very literal form of who will do what and where and what things actually tangibly are and look and feel like and she goes for Concepts that we're not allowed to touch and we're not allowed to question those Concepts she does it here uh and we'll see that going on interesting start of that chase with the you're right with that all that white White against white it really is the the the Savior uh look Will Smith did did the same in one of his videos by literally having a a white light behind him in a Halo it was it was uh interestingly uh done so the Savior has shown up and I think that's something of her her idea that she is a a spiritual master of some sort and and and I think that's the icon she's now looking to to push which is tricky because she she she maybe doesn't have some of the self knowledge that you would probably think somebody should have in order to fit that category one of those tape replays if you find another great love or If Will finds another great love there's no finding another great love and I think that's the point it's like we are in a place now that we are in a deep healing space and we are really concentrating on healing the relationship between us so it may not be the divorce on paper anymore there's no divorce on paper I mean not on paper there might not be a divorce in theory anymore yeah no we really have been working hard oh see well I didn't know that I was trying to well wait totally missed that on the whole that's the whole thing so wait so wait just so I'm 100% clear you were divorced not on paper but now we might be a point where we're back together we are working very hard at bringing our relation yes bringing our relationship together back to a marriage again back to a life partnersh yes because here's the thing about husband wife marriage for me for my healing process I came into that with very specific ideas right very specific ideas that were blocks to me just seeing will as who he is he can't be this perfect idealized husband I have to be able to accept him for the human that he is he accepts me for the human that I am and we want to love each other there okay so you might like live in the same house and have the yeah okay well hold it that's the only part that's the only part in the special that I felt like got lost okay well guess what it is found we found it today we found it today Jada thank you so much I really appreciate your I wanted you to walk us through like what were the stages and how would you define the stages as you doing this book your stages of your relationship with will because I feel that that's the part that people get blurry because they're looking at it through their lens but you both have been so clear about stages of your relationship internally which I actually think is the hardest part and so how would you define the stages of your partnership with will that help people understand like the conversations that you're having behind the scenes from like being madly in love to you know yeahoo the stages of getting to the most authentic and it's difficult so I just want to honor that for a second like it's almost like talking about relationships and the Romanticism around the idea of relating is sometimes as detrimental mental is talking about politics and God because it's such a it's such a staple in how people look at marriage and relating culturally right and all of the Romanticism around it and will and I have been what I would consider kind of the relationship goals mhm this romanticized version mhm all right Greg what do you got yeah I love this interview for one reason not because I love it but because I like knowing who I'm dealing with and meaning all facets of a person she does a lot of embedded confession in that last video we watched where she says she can change to fit the situation that's being chameleon likee which is okay but not if it's to get what you want that there's a certain personality type that has that well there's several personality types but her Baseline here is dramatically different than the one we just watched and very different from the NBC interview this is why I always say to you guys you can't look at Baseline in person at home eating Cheetos on the couch you got to look at the Baseline for where they start and look for deviations in that situation this is a great opportunity Mark I was going to wait till the end I know you got to have something to say about a wardrobe Choice considering the situation and what we're talking about I mean if she if she's not if she's not trying to look like a Hari Krishna I don't know what she's doing all the loose clothing and all that maybe it's just me maybe it's a wardrobe decision maybe I'm projecting under her but it sure sure looks like it's an intentional wardrobe decision um I'll leave that one alone just because I think it's a hot one but this guy is a this guy I'm J shett does a textbook image of what we call internal voice if you see him looking down to his left as he works through a question that is exactly what we mean by internal Voice or internal conversation or discourse he's thinking he's using words and and bringing them up as he thinks through the process and it's a great great illustration of it she came here to pontificate and I think that's part of this whole interchange that they do and you can see that that's part of their whole game because she's doing this right right that she would do in other places when she's pontificating then there's that edit and you guys are going to talk about the edit I'm sure but how do we go from that topic to another topic entirely in there what my immediate brain wants to say is why did that happen and who chose to take out whatever that was don't know what it was had to be something of significance they wouldn't have cut it that poorly I'll just leave it at that and say uh Scott what you got I agree with you about the edits I had a big thing about that because on some of these she's got one expression is just blaring out and you go to the next one it's completely changed and you can see where they they piece these things together one time in one of these her arms are crossed and the other when you come back and they're not crossed it's it's just but I there may be a reason for that I don't know um like you were saying I don't know what the reason would be or who decided to make that decision but it may be she may be like me in some cases where she talks and then Waits a few seconds and it starts jumbling up and they just cut that out and then to make it shorter and Tighter and a better conversation I don't see her running over her words like I do because here we see where her head goes down and she starts um gripping those her ankle just above her ankle with both hands and then starts talking from this quarter inch de of of new found knowledge she's she's got from all these therapy books apparently she's been reading and these are then these are just platitudes that she that she's talking that that she's spewing out that's all it is it's just things she's heard before she she's just giving you things from these books I know somebody like that that does that and she does the exact same thing that's why I was like oh my gosh I recognize this I think there's a bunch of people that that might do that and it's probably because they're excited and they want to tell you about what they've learned but it always seems to go Inward and from this narcissistic perspective that's the person that I know that does this that's that's the way uh they handle it so it's kind of unnerving when you get when you start getting deeper with it then and I just did this but Jade is doing this a lot that's really odd to be talking throwing your illustrators out and go we talk we did this without saying we talked about something we did this and she's making this little sock puppet gesture with her hand which was odd to me we've seen it before in the last episode we did she was doing that a couple of times but here uh she doesn't it it seems out of place when she's doing this notice the words she uses as well she uses words and we'll hear these over and over honor healing of course me my myself I those words transparency Journey path trauma response acceptance and share we hear all those things and there's nothing wrong with those words individually in and of themselves by themselves but when they keep coming together in groups and you keep hearing the same thing over and over that's how we know she's she's you know eyeball deep in these therapy books because that's the way those things uh present themselves once you once you you've ingested all that information you start puking it up and telling everybody you know it like when we read books on uh behavior and body language we we get in here I I get so excited I can't hardly stand it I can't I can't slow down and get it out quick enough but she's been thinking about this long enough where she wants to be the teacher here or the the guru in this situ ation and teach you these things as she's going along if if she didn't take the narcissistic approach to it where it's all I me to me I think it I think would it would be accepted a little easier on my part anyway than from the way she's handling it and then um I think her her illustrators I think she's being honest about this I don't see any deception cues in this thing because her your her illustrators are right on point land where they should she seems to you know when she uses her her illustrators are up high they're good they're solid she's talking in a great volume she's got and it's even it's steady her Cadence seems to be just rolling right along it seems fine so I think she's speaking from the heart and when she does she does this too and she touches her her chest and her heart so I as well I think this is an example of the more someone talks the less they know and we're seeing that here the more she talks about this the more you start realizing she doesn't know a whole lot the depth of it's very very shallow because she doesn't she's learning about it I don't think I don't think she knows as much as she'd like to but I think she knows more than is comfortable for us to listen to if that makes any sense Mark what do you got uh yeah so I totally agree with you Greg um she's shown up in a monastic like clothing uh yet we could both of us be projecting on on that knowing that the interviewer is an ex har Krishna uh monk um but you know possibly not the environment is not hers the environment is his but she gets to choose her clothing and it is interesting what she's gone for there given that circumstance and also the circumstance of of like you say Scott the idea that she's trying to get across now of being um spiritually you know a woken and and um wanting to tell people people about that okay so uh Jay who's interviewing her puts forward gives her an offer there of a metaphor that she picks up on and goes with which is people get blurry other people's lenses are blurry when they look at her situation um so external people looking at this are blurred and romanticized they they both both uh both the interviewer and the subject agree and put forward this idea where whereas internally Will and Jada are clear and authentic so their lens is clear they're authentic our lens as an outsider we're blurred and romanticizing this thing well no lens doesn't have that opportunity all our lens can deal with is what you project to us we we don't really have a lens to look at it you you you're in control very much of the image that's being put forward and we the public got a a very different idea uh than you're now saying is the internal thing why because your machine and you communicated very clearly to the public what you wanted us to believe and we believed it because what else had we got we hadn't got anything else uh to go on she then puts forward this idea that this this um talking about this relationship is like politics and God and culture so she's basically gone you get off this territory you do not question this if you question how I'm seeing this it's it's political it's it's it's religious and it's cultural she gave us the three top things which in certainly in in America will get you into an argument with somebody politics religion and culture I I think we just got seen off the territory here though I'm I'm still in I'm English I'm still in I don't know I don't know what I'm talking about I'm I'm a bit obtuse you know and and uh not well uh not well bought up so I'll just dive straight in there though she has tried to see all of us off on commenting on any of this in an in a in a um a detailed way because we'd get ourselves into trouble if we do that chase what do you got yeah I think it's it's funny hear how Jay says they both have been so clear about their relationship he says this in the video about her lying about the relationship and she she says the stages to getting the most authentic and its difficult that's a sentence that was used the stages to getting the most authentic and its difficult whatever that means then she saysi want you to count the number of distancing phrases that you hear in this sentence it's almost like talking about relationships and the Romanticism around the idea of relating is sometimes that's in one sentence this might be the most avoidant empty and distancing sentence that we have ever analyzed here on the show 300 plus episodes maybe 200 plus I don't know but then she says it's such a staple in how people look at marriage and relating this sentence has no reference no meaning no origin and the word staple I think is used to describe something that she isn't talking about or referring to at all and I don't think staple means what she thinks it means then she says will and I have been what I would consider kind kind of the relationship goals that's a real sentence will and I have been what I would consider kind of the relationship goals I genuinely don't think she's doing this on purpose and she isn't aware of these fragments making no sense at all I think for a lot of people in Hollywood there's a tendency to speak in this way that sounds like it makes sense but means literally nothing it's kind of like the people who spend 10 15 years in college subconsciously start thinking that sounding boring and emotionless means they're an intellectual because their professors sounded that way see a lot of that the only time we see respect and true happiness in all of her interviews is when she talks about Tupac one of those tape replays I wanted you to walk us through like what were the stages and how would you define the stages as you do in this book your stages of your relationship with will because I feel that that's the part that people get blurry because they're looking at it through their lens but you both have been so clear about stages of your relationship internally which I actually think is the hardest part and so how would you define the stages of your partnership with will that help people understand like the conversations that you're having behind the scenes from like being madly in love to you know yeah woo the stages of getting to the most authentic and that's difficult so I just want to honor that for a second like it's almost like talking about relationships and the Romanticism around the idea of relating is sometimes as detrimental as talking about politics and God because it's such a it's such a staple in how people look at marriage and relating culturally right and all of the Romanticism around it and will and I have been what I would consider kind of the relationship goals MH this romanticized version MH I had to in my own relationship with Will dissolve my Romanticism around what I thought marriage would be should be and honestly we really never had what I would consider the ideal honeymoon stage you know even though you do have the honeymoon stage but our relationship started with some challenges you know because he was divorcing and then our life just took off like a rocket ship we just took on this huge life in our early 20s and where his Focus was really about hey I want to be the biggest movie star in the world and I knew that going into our relationship and I knew there would be sacrifices with that and then along the way and I talk about this in the book just having those different perspectives mhm and really trying to figure out how to Recon recile those different perspectives and also deal with a lot of challenges so I think one of the things that I address in the book in regards to you know people thinking that we've had an open marriage and we haven't had an open marriage I talk about starting off pretty much early on in our marriage of having the need for transparency and that is a big difference between hey you can do whatever you want you know versus like hey here we are very young people in this place called Hollywood that has a lot of Temptation let's have a partnership around this let's be very realistic of what this life is if we're talking about we're going to be together forever and ever and ever that means there's going to be some temptation that come up let's be in Partnership and let's talk about that all right Mark what do you got uh okay yeah just one thing on this which is just as I said on the first video the inability to land on anything solid tangible events things that happen with people things people say the intention behind those things you know the stuff that you might talk about if you're having a a real conversation with some to really understand like what is actually really happening for you and other people what did you do what did you say how did that feel to you no we've got challenges transparency Temptation uh realistic partnership nothing all good Concepts but this list of Concepts which mean we can't get our fingers on any any event that ever happens and if we try and get to an event with her it'll just be thrown up into a conceptual area which means again we can't touch it so she's seen us off the territory with politics and God and culture and now if we're going to stay in this territory and try and try and analyze what's going on because we may be just we may be actually interested in it again we can't get a finger hold in in any of it there's nothing solid uh in there uh Greg what do you think what do you got on this one you know why that's because feelings aren't real things they are only real things to you they aren't real things to me they aren't real things to any of us we can see the symptoms that's what we're looking for but they aren't tangible and this is a person who is living in a world of feelings in my opinion and all they do is talk about how they feel and how things are we didn't hear any facts in almost anything we've heard to now she'll go in and tell us all of these feelings and how she's going to work if you watch her we talk about eye accessing on this show fairly often you see her going left going over to this auditory kind of place that she's recalling something you ask her conversation and she went boom now we get to start looking and she's going back to the same place for memory the problem is when you lay down something in your head as wrote something you've read something you've becomes a mantra for you to use a word then that kind of becomes just auditory memory and we're seeing that auditory memory in her as she goes back and she's pulling pieces of conversations or things she's read that are becoming part of her operating system and how she feels and why she feels that way that's my opinion of this she overcomes all that Botox or whatever she's had done to her forehead to actually get a wrinkle in her forehead when she says dissolve my Romanticism and it's actually pretty pronounced as a request for approval do you get what I'm saying and then when we see her move off to the right and up to a different part of her brain her eyes are moving up high and the opposite side she's going to talk about something where she's saying we didn't really have a honeymoon and she's visual izing that honeymoon the perfect honeymoon and then she realizes well wait a minute I'm rich and the rest of the world isn't and we probably did have a perfect see those Regulators those stop motions as you called it Chase and she thrust her hand forward to take that over really interesting to see and then after she said I knew there would be sacrifices because will wanted to be the world's biggest movie star you see this taste in her mouth that's pretty interesting then she moves immediately to over pronouncing the word open and she over pronounces a word open she does that with words that she's going to try to drive home to you she then shifts gears and turns into Bill Clinton and redefines a word I think it's really a good indicator that mostly what we're going to see from her anyway is going to be feelings not facts Chase what you got Mark I want you to elaborate on this if you can is her use of the word Romanticism I don't think that means what she thinks it means uh I think it mean she's thinking romantic ideas about romantic Behavior but I think Romanticism might mean something different do you agree with that or no well I think there are two potential meanings here one is is um one is the Romantic ideal which would be you know uh let's say you know roses and candles and and riding in on horses and you know it'll mean different things to different people those are the images that I'm going to pick for this ideal of Romanticism then there's when you romanticize something which is make it perfect um so I think there are two possible things that she's that she's picking from yeah there I would say yeah when you were saying the first idea all I could think was just cut scenes from every season of The Bachelor would be that right right that exact thing so and drinking drinking from a mug like this with two hands yeah so she says we had different ideas about the world we had to figure out how to reconcile perspectives we had to deal with challenges we need transparency in the marriage show me someone that who that's every human that's every relationship in the world this just generic blather it's Hollow generic blather but this is honest Behavior here and there's no deception really about what she's saying her Cadence is smooth her deliveries consist consistent with her Baseline there's nothing off about her movement uh especially with all the stuff that we did find in the last video with some red flags When She interviewed with Hoda with all that said there's nothing she's saying that is detailed transparent actually conveying an answer to the question so while we aren't seeing deception here we're seeing other types of Truth avoidance and there's eight types that I teach in my training and I'll let you decide which of these eight you're seeing in the video here you put it in the comments there's propagandizing gaslighting deception selective truth coverups self-enhancement omission and avoiding so with that little list I'll let you decide what you see there Scott all right here she continues to a light upon the obvious with this profound and original Discovery Vibe she's got going on like look I've discovered this no you haven't you're just puking up stuff you've read uh in these books and on Google she's just Googling stuff and it's coming maybe she's not Googling but she's definitely underlining words and phrases in these books and then sitting around thinking about it memorizing them and then when she gets the chance like here is the perfect example just pukes them out and think it makes her sound profound and it doesn't at all she speaks really slowly so she can construct these sentences with these phrases she knows because I'm sure there s up here in a bubble just you know and she just connects with those and starts putting them in order like those little things on refrigerator where you have all those words and you can make sentences out of them it's kind of like that because that's what it sounds like when she when she speaks it's it sounds I think she thinks it makes her sound intelligent whereas it doesn't this this is one of those things that gets on my last note where somebody uses these words and phrases to to help enhance the the way they look to someone from an intellectual perspective and it just right in the commode it does doesn't work at all here because you get that creepy feeling of what's wrong here and this is what's wrong here so nothing original it's just regurgitation of the things she's read and things she's underlined and and that's all it is if I sound a little bit been out of shape it's because it did these kind of things just get on my last nerve when somebody does this and it's so obvious it's it's just it's so bad you're sounding like you need some deep healing Scott around this yeah I doing hey I'm on my journey man on my journey on the path to Healing good journey deep healing Journey yeah it really [Laughter] is I need some healing after watching two and a half hours of this video one of those tape replays I had to in my own Rel relationship with will dissolve my Romanticism around what I thought marriage would be should be and honestly we really never had what I would consider the ideal honeymoon stage you know even though you do have the honeymoon stage but our relationship started with some challenges you know because he was divorcing and then our life just took off like a rocket ship we just took on this huge life in our early 20s and where his Focus was really about hey I want to be the biggest movie star in the world and I knew that going into our relationship and I knew there would be sacrifices with that and then along the way and I talk about this in the book just having those different perspectives mhm and really trying to figure out how to reconcile those different perspectives and also deal with a lot of challenges so I think one of the things that I address in the book in regards to you know people thinking that we've had an open marriage and we haven't had an open marriage I talk about starting off pretty much early on in our marriage of having the need for Trans transparency and that is a big difference between hey you can do whatever you want you know versus is like hey here we are very young people in this place called Hollywood that has a lot of Temptation let's have a partnership around this let's be very realistic of what this life is if we're talking about we're going to be together forever and ever and ever that means there's going to be some temptations that come up let's be in Partnership and let's talk about that marriage like I am going to be my husband is never ever ever going to look at anybody else you know what I mean like I I just I am just a realist in a lot of ways I know what it's been like for me right when I first came to Hollywood and I could go into the club and have anybody just the the level of just like that just like you know what I mean it's just like you just yeah intoxicating it's so intoxicating that's one now what I do believe that what people don't know that I talk about in the book a lot is that there have been several breakups between will and I will talks about it my 40th birthday which was a big bre up for us we were actually looking towards separating and divorcing and we separated the world just didn't know then we had a Reconciliation and then 2016 came and we had the ultimate break but the world didn't know mhm and I think that that's where some of the misconception about having an open marriage came into play because we were living lives as single people mhm and the world didn't know over the span of 12 Years of just trying to figure out this thing called love and marriage between will and I it's been a trip and I think that even with that entanglement piece which I talk about extensively in the book how I played a part in the misconception of that Narrative of allowing myself to be portrayed as an adulteress allowing myself to be portrayed as someone that had betrayed will and that wasn't the case we broke up in 2016 he went on to live a life as a single man I went on to live a life as a single woman and then when we had the talk at the red table I was going to go to the red table by myself all right Chase what do you got can we go back I have a mouth full of ice cubes I think you got CH okay Chase what do you got I think I'm confident here saying that there's a pattern with her using the word right and she uses that word the moment she's bringing up a topic which she thinks could incur some form of judgment or criticism so there's some social buyin from the interviewer when someone doesn't use this word often pay attention when they use it and you'll start to see the exact situations that make them feel like they need backup or social backup this can tell you a lot more about their psychology than you might imagine there's a slight smile at the word breakups here which I thought was really bizarre and I think some people might misinterpret this as being happy about the breakup but with how fast it comes on to her face and secondly how she makes brief eye contact while she's smiling this is what's called social confirmation smile or maybe another word for it but we use this to make sure somebody else is comfortable and that they're still with us in the conversation and there's a hand gesture she's doing here Mark picks up on these so much that hopefully I'm taking uh something away from what he's about to tell you get ready to cross it out there's a hand gesture where she's flipping over a document like this and then moving the document closer and then further away from somebody with her hand here this is unusual for her so I wanted to pay attention and there might have been some document involved with this process she's talking about like maybe a divorce degree a prenup or you know whatever I only say this because of her Baseline she's known to illustrate and narrate when she's being truthful and she does this in a way that she's interacting with an object which she does all the time so two incredible pieces of advice that I got from my late grandfather growing up was number one you have to love your person more than you need them that's a big deal to understand that you have to love them more than you need them because when that scale tips you're in for a huge disaster and two only get mad one person at a time all the behavior that I'm seeing here look like the same unusualness that we see when we when we see kamla Harris ever talking on any camera ever it's the same kind of behavior as as you see with KLA Harris Mark what do you think yeah it could be could be a document she could be turning on the gas cooker I don't know could be could be one could be one or the other um well certainly look it is a a what I've put as a broad performance a broad performance around this idea of in the intoxicating nature of being able to have anyone her hand comes right up into the ecstatic plane so she's getting really excited by that and I I believe her I mean I you know when she you're right Chase when she gets more animated um it's it's more true I would say to a trained dancer who is being really expressive and I believe every moment of that cuz she her her body uh you know really fills and all the lines of of energy complete there's nothing flaccid in there um it's quite exciting to watch we can see a really good physical uh performer there for sure um and contrast that to when she talks about other stuff that she wants to be more um obscure and closed around and she's barrier you know so when when we see her cross-legged and and what are traditionally people might say oh you know she's barried but we could easily go actually well it kind of looks like her Baseline you know and that might be true but look what happens when she's excited about something and she becomes a really good honest Storyteller or certainly maybe not honest but um more expressive Storyteller because she want she's got clear detail and she wants to get it out well she's big she's bold which is great to see um I just picked up on the idea of her talking about love and marriage uh it's a classic Sinatra uh phrase and it just reminded me uh she used lyrics of I I'll be there when she was talking about being there for Will and it seems to me you know talking about Romanticism chase you know often when we're being romantic about something we use you know popular culture or poetry to to explain Our Lives because you know often we haven't experienced the panoply of life but poets try and and and artists try and give us what it would be like by creating songs and lyrics and pictures and and so when we're when we're living a situation we'll often talk about it in the Poetry of the artists because it's the nearest thing we have so we get Love and Marriage the Sinatra and and uh you know I'll be there um uh I don't think she's using in it in the Michael Jackson uh sense uh because she puts her stress on on the um uh um on the there rather than the aisle anyway uh she talks in classic lyrics She is a romanticist I would say uh Greg what do you got on this one yeah I'm just going to cover a couple of things one is pay attention to what she's talking about when she does this whole move is something I call the let me tell you move not the teaching face thing the let me tell you move you see people narrow and purse their lips they half swallow when they're talking they may chew the inside of their mouth they have their head tilted down and they're rocking their head as they're telling you they may be doing this or that but they're telling you something and they're looking down at you pay attention to that because that's a let me tell you and that's a little bit of a again a little bit of a um patronizing move when they're doing that you see people chewing their mouth when they do it as well that's one the second one is when she's talking about positive things about herself she's large and she's in active voice go to the P to the bar pick have my pick she's saying these words not like they happened to her but like their actions and she has some control when she gets to the bad things around going to the red table she goes to passive voice played a part allowing myself to be portrayed and then she does that weird adapter where she grabs her leg at going to the red table by myself look this thing's filmed I think this was a pretty big series and recorded and it was something she could have said well that episode's never going to see the light of day because it was in her house her Studio was in her house so you know she has a little more editorial control than she's letting on here she's a victim by this she shifted gears and went to that whole passive voice don't not a real big fan of that Scott what you got all right so they recorded this in her house that's her place yeah the the red table was done in their house yeah not this interview oh not this one okay table okay great great well in this clip this is the most Animated she gets when she's talking about how famous she is and how she could have her choice of anybody in the club let me tell you let me ladies let me a little secret here if you're a woman you can go to any club and have any guy you want in there just so you know that's on the table that's on Scott's beige table you know take that with you and do with it what you will but know that that is a fact now notice when she talks about herself she's either really loud or she gets really quiet with that head down a little bit and she uses that voice where she sounds like she's just come off the mountain with a Tay do with a burning bush and she's come down to hip the cattle to the way things are and about her and it's it's just mindblowing the self absorption that must have gone on before this to to be able to to let that out of your mouth some of the things she's talking about however these are all cues of confidence some may say overconfidence or superc confident but for some reason it's not playing right it just doesn't sound or look right but these are all the things you see in a confident person that's the things we a lot of these things are things we train people to look like when going in to whatever the situation is to look confident a lot of this is what that is but for some reason maybe it's what's coming out of her mouth that's making those things Clash together what's coming off off her from her body language and what she's actually saying maybe those are clashing and that's what it is I I don't know but they're all cues of confidence and like uh Greg was saying she's she's it's not the I'm teaching you something as much as it is I'm um what was the phrase you use Greg listen listen to me yeah yeah they they'll listen to me so that let me tell you listen to me or is the one I yeah let me tell you so yeah that I think that's what's happening now I've just slammed her so bad but let me tell you something this is this is uh something that I I have to tell you since I've been talking so bad about her when we go do Dr Phil show we get we have someone that will come pick us up right and so one of these times I was there by myself and the driver came pick me up and I always there's two questions I always ask the first one is who's the nicest person you've had to to to drive that you've gotten to drive for who's the nicest person who's the the best one and I've had two people tell me Shaquille O'Neal's the nicest one oh they say that guy this one guy told me he said look I won to use his name but he said when we go somewhere we go to these really nice restaurants and I drop him off he says what do you want and and even when he said even when he says I don't want anything he sends the waiter out and he says he told me I have to I have to take something you have to tell tell me what you want to eat or I can't go back in there and so he tells them what he wants to eat and they bring out this big layout for him to eat the driver and I thought that was so cool now having said that I said who's the worst and and one of them said Will Smith is the worst and I said really he said yeah I said what makes him the worst and he said he when he gets in the car he he never says hello never says anything doesn't address me and then when he needs something he just keeps looking down and says get my bags or do this or do whatever and when we get out of the car we always sort of open the door and get out ourselves he waits for the guy to come around and let him out of the door nothing wrong some people are like that and he said however the one the one thing that the good that came out of that was his wife Jada he said she is so nice and she is always so pleasant to me she is the nicest person every time i' I've driven for them she comes out and apologizes for the way he acts once once he's in and I said and I said oh my gosh you're a kidding he said no she is the sweetest thing she he said I really like like her a lot so there's that there's that the ju depos of that as to what we're seeing I don't know I don't know what's happen I hope I don't get that guy in trouble should I put that story in or not I don't know but I love it that we're in now a Hollywood gossip Channel that's true that's what that's turning into like we're now Okay magazine there nothing wrong with that nothing wrong with that nothing wrong with that story yeah yeah yeah yeah we're okay magazine we're we're now who who who would how would they know what's him there's thousand drivers in La yeah okay all right is that all of us yeah yeah yeah one of those tape replays marriage like I am going to be my husband is never ever ever going to look at anybody else you know what I mean like I I just I am just a realist in a lot of ways I know what it's been like for me right when I first came to Hollywood and I could go into the clubs and have anybody just the the level of just like that just the like you know what I mean it's just like you just yeah intoxicating it's so intoxicating that's one now what I do believe that what people don't know that I talk about in the book a lot is that there have been several breakups between will and I will talks about it my 40th birthday which was a big breakup for us we were actually looking towards separating and divorcing and we separated the world just didn't know then we had a Reconciliation and then 2016 came and we had the ultimate break but the world didn't know mhm and I think that that's where some of the misconception about having an open marriage came into play because we were living lives as single people mhm and the world didn't know over the span of 12 Years of just trying to figure out this thing called love and marriage between will and I it's been a trip and I think that even with that entanglement piece which I talk about extensively in the book how I played a part in the misconception of that Narrative of allowing myself to be portrayed as an adulteress allowing myself to be portrayed as someone that had betrayed will and that wasn't the case we broke up in 2016 he went on to live a life as a single man I went on to live a life as a single woman and then when we had the talk at the red table I was going to go to the red table by myself to talk about the entanglement MH mhm but we'll decide that he wanted to come with me and we were going to then tell the world hey we haven't been together and this happened during that time well when we got to the table will wasn't ready he wasn't ready he wasn't ready for the world to know that I had to respect that well I didn't have to but I wanted to but I was ready I was ready to let go of the Persona I had created around myself that had put me in a golden cage I wanted to let that go and so I had to stay on my journey I had to stay on my path while also respecting that will wasn't ready so I said you know what this is my mess anyway I'm going to take this heat because guess what the heat is coming either way whether when we decide to get divorced when we decide to separate whatever whatever this is my practice run strip It Down Let It Go Jada and then let's see what's left I didn't have to put that particular show out but I had already gotten myself so ready for that Journey for myself and to me that was moving closer to my freedom then holding back and creating a narrative that I felt like was just going to entrap me more and as difficult as it's been cuz the irony is I spent so much of our relationship having this open communication between the between he and I creating this beautiful friendship of authenticity and um honesty and so to be labeled as someone who had cheated on him was devastating but it also put me in a position where I had to learn how to let go of what anybody thought about me and really be 10 toes down on understanding who I am and being able to walk in that no matter what anybody thought about me but I needed that Journey for myself you know it's kind of like that is the walk when they talk about walking on hot coals it's like creating that level of when we talk about that inner world work and creating that like strong Foundation within yourself of knowing exactly who you are no matter what other people think about you I mean I've gotten that to a certain degree and so that was a very challenging moment and I talk about it in the book all right Greg what do you got yeah a handful of things she has her brow up and her lips pursed and when she says will wasn't ready that that's condemning to me and then there's one of her brows is higher than the other skepticism so there's clearly some irritation there we can't tell what we can just see the symptoms we're talking about one of things to point out you know we're talking about J because she's the one talking and relationships are sticky nasty messy things we don't know what happened in the past that might have been an egregious act to her that caused her to behave a certain way with Will Smith we don't know any of that so we're only trying to read symptoms and what we can see we're not trying to tell you what's going on inside the relationship except for how we see things playing out in a conversation and our opinions there's a shift in tones and she elongates again she says I was ready and batoning she drives her Point home then she talks about her journey her path and healing well this might be healing for her and it might not be healing for him I had a cat I might name it Jada you know that might be a just kind of poking around and toying with somebody as they're in that situation and you're back and forth what do you think is going to happen what kind of healing do you think is going to happen when you go going to say hey we were separated and I had an affair or I you know had this relationship but you don't include that we were separated part what do you think that outcome is going to be is there a logic piece missing here in thinking about what will happen is that healing is the question that comes to me the big thing to me that's missing here are the hard questions from the interviewer and I don't think that's kind of interview it is I would have said what the hell were you thinking didn't you know this would turn out bad and then she does that last thing where she says I didn't have to put this show out I agree with her she didn't have to and you see her foot flex so probably there's some maybe remorse who knows what showing up there uh Chase what do you got uh entanglement is something that I experience annually and it's with Christmas lights that are stuffed into Old Amazon boxes and other than a few jiu-jitsu classes I've not really been entangled with a human so it's interesting these extra words that are outside of Norm uh that she uses for all the stuff and her repeating he wasn't ready three times is significant here her body language is all flowing and honest which doesn't mean she's being transparent so let's make that distinction honest and transparent are not the same thing so there's something in her psychology about his lack of Readiness that I would pick up on as an interviewer here and I would keep that phrase in my back pocket because she's exposing what's called a reasoning process so when you hear these in somebody's speech you know that these are powerful phrases that you can later use to help them open up or make a decision later in the conversation and then she says the heat is coming I'm assuming she means from people she doesn't know and that's the trouble with living in what she refers to here as a Persona it means you will be emotionally affected by strangers you don't even know like if someone I don't know leaves a mean comment on our video and it hurts me that means I have a very serious problem with reality so if you're struggling with judgment from people who don't know you there's a problem with you knowing you that's the big issue here her talking about knowing herself and being in herself and not even knowing who she is enough to be unaffected by these people's opinion so her behavior here is similar to baseline from the other videos which is restrained uh self- soothing at every point she's talking about Will and consistently seeking social confirmation from the interviewer and this is likely a mirror to her life think about those three things that I just said it's a mirror to her life since we see it in most of her interviews and she's still not speaking a word about Will's Journey his character his desires his Integrity only him not being ready and I will leave that to you to make a guess at what that means and it will be a guess Mark what do you got uh yeah look I couldn't agree with you more on the uh will wasn't ready and here here's why with with my journey and closer to my freedom we get really strong direct down it would be actually down her wheel plane which is like that Center plane there if she didn't have a mic in front of her I think she's only to the side of it because she can't come right down her wheel plane there which means she's very direct and very decided about my journey and closer to my freedom then we get this great control gesture here a couple of times um on my mess my heat again direct clear controlling we get we get stripp it down where she comes right down the side at an at an angle and and really cuts the air and I'll talk in our in our next uh video about what I think she's talking about in terms of strip it down because we will see her repeat that gesture with a different a different phrase but with Will wasn't there we get the hand coming out and we get we get no line of energy there so if you imagine you know with all these things here if she had an object in her hand she would not drop that object she had a ball in her hand it would still be there the ball in her hand over here would just fall off her fingers and fall onto the floor she she drops the ball of that and that shows a very definite feeling I would say in how she talks about control and will wasn't ready so there may be something um about about him not being um powerful enough because these are really powerful gestures I don't mean powerful enough in terms of his Hollywood status there's no nobody more powerful probably but there was clearly for her something that's lacking in him something that is that is limp around around that you know an energy that isn't there I would say um uh and she talks about the internal relationship again and authenticity and honesty and I'll come back to this idea of the internal and the external in our next uh video Scott what do you got on this one all right I'm not seeing any cues of deception here I mean there's nothing to be deceptive about these are just confident cues of a skilled communicator and I really think she's a skilled Communicator she's an actress or actor how however you say it these days and I think she's doing a great job of getting what she wants to say across however from a psychological perspective let's listen let's talk about what she's talking about whenever you start explaining things to the world and your concern is what how the world sees you and you start telling uh people what you've been doing because you've decided to tell the world what you're doing the level of narcissism in that may be unrivaled when when get to that point here well she gets better if you if you think the world is concerned whether or not you're getting the world is just is concerned whether or not you're getting a divorce how removed from reality must you be earlier I said what a sweetheart she was and how wonderful she was to this this guy gu I think that's fantastic but there's something here that separates that maybe she's maybe this is a character she's playing or something that's the only thing I can think of maybe this is just her her public Persona that we're seeing and the other one is who she really is she's that that sweetheart that nice person that makes sure everything's good takes care of people apologizes for other people's mistakes even who are in her group or whatever to make sure everything's okay because when you start talking about the world and what the world thinks about you well fever say something like that you call somebody call Dr Phil get in here tell him needs to go up in there and get tweak some things man because that's not that's not right that's not right and again she talks about like Mark was saying she talks about herself and her journey and but illustrators are all falling in the right place everything is is where it should be and as it should be and and I I I don't feel I'm I might feel sorry for her because she's putting all this stuff out there I think that might be the new personality she's moving to from this Persona we're seeing or that she was before to this new one she's created a new person that she's becoming and maybe that's why she's saying all these things like this but that's not a lot to do with body language it's mostly from the psychology side of it but still that that this is some odd behavior we're seeing from someone who is other than this has has not done anything weird or or or out of the ordinary as far as I'm I'm aware so yeah you know I don't know but you you said it's not body language it is behavior and that's after all what we are is behavior panel for me one of the interesting you you're dancing around something very specific here in my opinion and that is every time we interrogate if you've ever interrogated a prisoner it's about finding the role you're going to talk to and pulling that person forward and that every one of us is many roles you know you're a father a brother whatever you are in your life and you're you know a somebody who gives advice your whatever your role is you might be a fireman you might be whatever I don't want to talk to the tough role I want to pick that weak role and pull that weak roll out and show them how fragile their luos are and if she is playing her only card out front and this is really who she is and she's worried about whether people how people feel about her divorce that's that's dangerous territory Chase to your point and I'm thinking about all the people that are watching right now what Greg just said is worth at least $10,000 if you take that piece of advice about speaking to certain roles and Mark I cannot believe you didn't get the golden cage thing oh the golden cage is like a Hari Krishna uh key principle of like the bird is dying inside the cage but we're polishing the outside yeah it's also a song by a band called the Whitest Boy Alive pretty good song classic music hall song I'm only a bird in a gilded cage it's uh yeah yeah beautiful beautiful British Musical song but the last question I have is did anybody else notice in the interview she said they were never going to divorce but she's talking about divorce here yeah lot of that yeah weird yeah all over the place well that was the other persona yeah right she should have brought to the dance one of those tape replays to talk about the entanglement mhm mhm but will decided he wanted to come with me and we were going to then tell the world hey we haven't been together and this happened during that time well when we got to the table will wasn't ready he wasn't ready he wasn't ready for the world to know that I had to respect that well I didn't have to but I wanted to but I was ready I was ready to let go of the Persona I had created around myself that had put me in a golden cage I wanted to let that go and so I had to stay on my journey I had to stay on my path while also respecting that will wasn't ready so I said you know what this is my mess anyway I'm going to take this heat because guess what the heat is coming either way whether when we decide to get divorced when we decide to separate whatever what whatever this is my practice run strip It Down Let It Go Jada and then let's see what's left I didn't have to put that particular show out but I had already gotten myself so ready for that Journey for myself and to me that was moving closer to my freedom than holding back and creating a narrative that I felt like was just going to entrap me more and as difficult as it's been because the irony is I spent so much of our relationship having this open communication between the between he and I creating this beautiful friendship of authenticity and um honesty and so to be labeled as someone who had cheated on him was devastating but it also put me in a position where I had to learn how to let go of what anybody thought about me and really be T toes down on understanding who I am and being able to walk in that no matter what anybody thought about me but I needed that Journey for myself you know it's kind of like that is the walk when they talk about walking on hot coals it's like creating that level of when we talk about that inner world work and creating that like strong Foundation within yourself of knowing exactly who you are no matter what other people think about you I mean I've gotten that to a certain degree and so that was a very challenging moment and I talk about it in the book when when that is there and it's being deconstructed someone would look at you be like why would you do that like why why do I need to know what and really I just want to highlight and I want you to share about that that the intention was healing the intention wasn't to save face or the int and I know this cuz we were talking about it the intention wasn't to yeah it wasn't to save face and it surely wasn't and I need people to know I didn't ask Will to come to the table yeah yeah that was not my idea MH will wanted to come to the table cuz he didn't want me to be there by myself he had all the best intentions yeah and got there and was I think his trauma response kicked in like I'm not ready so many people were like don't do this and I'm like nah I'm doing it for myself for myself because I want to live because I'm ready I don't want this whole thing anymore this whole Jada will I'm done with that it was part of the work that I was ready for and it was what I needed and everybody's in different places in their Journey also that's also a dynamic I had to look at Within Myself in regards to so it was two things there's this healthy J is like tear it down I want I don't want that Persona anymore tear my ego down and there was this other part of me that was like oh my God I need to prot you know he's not ready you know he's not ready my you know codependency kicks in and I go this is what I do I'm the Martyr I can do the Martyr thing so once again it's both things it's healing like I'm ready like I'm ready for I'm ready for the tear down and then this martyr that's like and I want to make sure will as long as you're okay I'm okay that's part of my relationship with my mother's addiction that I brought into my relationship with will that created a certain Dynamic with in myself in my relationship with him that I also needed to get my eyes on that I didn't see that that needed to be healed as well without that table without that moment I would have never recognized that as painful as it was for people to watch existential disappointment in a collective I'm so sorry I wish it could have happened another way I'm sorry that it had to be so messy in front of everybody I'm sorry but I needed that what I got to clear up what I got to clean what I got to see and to be able to sit here with you today and embrace it all and have so much acceptance for myself for all of the choices I've made and people ask me if you had to do it over again would you do it any different I don't think so all right Chase what do you got let's kick it off with saying she says it wasn't to save face and I need people to know that's what Saving Face is I need to go back and make sure everybody knows and I thought that was stunning that those were in the same sentence there and then you're you're going to see this you're going to see this little shoulder shrug here is out of Baseline for her and it spikes the moment that she's saying she didn't ask Will to come to the table so if you're not familiar with that gesture it means that a person might be lacking in confidence in what they're saying and we also see a really pronounced lip retraction here the lips go back into the mouth and you're going to see that and there there's rapid no head shaking which is way outside of her contained and restrained Baseline here so this is just a cluster not just a single Behavior but a cluster of uncertainty and deviation from Baseline which he says uh that was not my idea again another shoulder shrug and you know what that means and and she says a few things about healing and I'm not sure how healing needs to be done on camera in front of millions of people I've never seen that psychology textbook that that talks about that maybe it's a new thing and her issues are all from external sources nothing about her there's nothing internally that that's really coming forward here and there's anger clearly on her face when she's speaking about uh a couple of the things and she's saying I wish it could have happened another way I don't believe this at all and I'm willing to bet anything she's heard of a therapist a room without a camera a counselor or even talking at a kitchen table that might be wood instead of red uh she's saying I don't think it could have happened any other way I think that's so strange to hear and I think she's also very aware of a delete button when it comes to recording and then deleting a video since the healing took place why publish the video so this is all just responsibility shedding and when healing absolutely has to happen in public it's not a person healing it's a Persona that's healing because the public has to participate so it's a Persona that's being healed not a person so this has so many Hallmarks of what I think is a sunk cost fallacy that seems to be this relationship the sunk cost fallacy if you don't know what that is in Psychology you can Google it or maybe one of you guys will roll into there Greg it's in the book it's in the book yeah byy my book so Chase I'm going to hit a couple of points you just hit just add I'm going to see your cluster of a rising shoulder lip withdrawal um Short Stroke nodding I'm going to add to that eye blocking she just does all that when she says it wasn't my idea to bring will to the table so all of that makes us have less than confident belief that that's true there's also the piece you were just covering about her feeling the need to be in front of people she actually says out loud a couple of things that I find interesting she thought that their relationship breaking up caused us pain I candidly don't remember when I found out they were breaking up or that she had had an affair only time I even know is because I watched these videos and this was 2 and a half of it all this talk if you're putting up with us all the time I can't imagine this is a combination of self-help books you said it Scott there's some self-help there's some real therapy in here around being a martyr and around not being able to control her mother's addiction and those kinds of things there's some other pieces in here there's some har Krishna stuff we heard there's even we're going to hear something that sounds a little bit like Scientology coming up so she's got a mix of all these things that she's created a whole new religion and this whatever you want want to call it whether it's your belief system your whatever it becomes a religion when you're doing all this and I need to heal and okay you're healing is one thing but as I listened to her talking about Will Smith was not ready but she went ahead and did this is there healing part for him is this dealing for him or dealing for her and then it gets to be pretty subjective in whose religion it is that you're enforcing and I'm not a big fan of people enforcing their religion on me in any way shape form or fashion maybe it's because of where come from and all that kind of thing but it gets pretty subjective after that so yeah Scott he does she does one thing in here that you're talking about a lot and that's the teaching phas say some words watch you as soon as you get it say some words watch you well it's all over here it is all over here you explained it and and so anyway that self-importance is there's just a lot of stuff if you really want some healing watch the show Scott what are you what you kid um I know it sounds like we're we're bashing therapy but we're actually not that is if if you if you need that if you if you've experienced trauma or something like that go do that it I've seen it change people's lives make them from just the the living a mundane life they go to therapy man they come out and they're actually happy their lives change because somebody said no man you're looking at this from the wrong perspective look at it like this and they go like that they go ohly smokes you're right that's that's such an important thing to to keep in mind as we're going through this we're not slamming therapy we're not slamming somebody getting help for that we're specifically talking about this one person in this one video or one group of videos that's it so if if you are in therapy don't get out because we're talking about her she thinks a therapist I don't want you to think that's what I said by any stret oh no no no you don't that's no I'm just saying I want everybody to know that while we're sitting here talking because I've Le do it over here about how she thinks she's a guru but at the same time for real if for therapy stuff man you do it do it at least check it out if if something's up or something's wrong or you're you know things seem like they're going a little bit sideways on you do that it gets you fix quick mark what do you got uh yeah well look maybe she is making that Journey towards the possibility of that Guru status here's maybe why she does a a big ecstatic Wipeout gesture um right at the top there around I think the the external world that she's talking around then she does this this gesture that I was talking about before cutting through and and instead of strip down she says tear down the ego um so look the the if she's using the Freudian idea of the ego and I don't know what I idea or ideal she has about that you you've got your your your ID which is like that that that authentic um animal let's say um reaction to stuff and then you've got uh the part of you that kind of projects out that other people see and then you've got your ego which is like the mediator the moderator between the two of those things and if you tear down that ego there now is nothing between you know your um reactive feelings and the thing that projects out to other people so people are going to see the internal you there's no moderator in between and there's no moderator for you there's nothing protecting you anymore socially or even uh personality wise from from you know the outside world's reaction to who you are well you know if you go through that process of tearing down the ego like some people do it in monasteries of some sort and it takes them a long long time some people can manage to do it with some very very strong drugs you know and and it's like you know that'll that'll sort things out for for a few moments and then it's like then you you spring back again it's like wow what happened there I was totally egoless you like everything seemed to make sense for a moment and I really felt like me and it all kind of felt felt right at the time so you can you know there's a couple of ways there's some other ways you can you can you can I mean you know H you can get you know metal spikes and stick them through yourself and you know hang from ropes and all kind there's all kinds of stuff you can you can you can do if you want if you want to go down that route but it's but most of it is is is monastic or very very counterculture um or just plain dangerous just plain dangerous to do so it's not that you can't do that but usually you've marked yourself out as having some kind of uh very pure kind of spiritual journey that you're now on and and and and you know many of many go on that journey and few come back with the results that they were hoping for because it's a pretty tricky Journey but those that do come back from that uh egoless often become teachers of spirituality and that's maybe why they went on that so look maybe she is on that on that Journey uh who am I to to to say uh you know it's not it's not my story to tell is it it's not my story to tell so uh so let's let's see and you're right Scott you know none of us here are saying anything that that um of of of that therapy or all or spirituality is a is a bad place a fantastic place to go uh but you know you one would have to be careful I think not to have a kind of a boilin the bag approach to it which is like if I just take a whole bunch of ready-made recipes and dip them together in the same pan of boiling water that I'll come out with some kind of you know three star Michelin meal it's like no it won't work like that Mark I had my notes further down this is a low country foil approach to religion right okay one of those tape replays when when that is there and it's being deconstructed someone would look at you be like why would you do that like why why do I need to know and really I just want to highlight and I want you to share about that that the intention was healing the intention wasn't to save face or the int and I know this cuz we were talking about it like the intention wasn't to yeah wasn't to save face and wasn't and I need people to know I didn't ask Will to come to the table yeah yeah that was not my idea mhm will wanted to come to the table cuz he didn't want me to be there by myself he had all the best intentions yeah and got there and was I think his trauma response kicked in like I'm not ready so many people were like don't do this and I'm like nah I'm doing it for myself for myself because I want to live because I'm ready I don't want this whole thing anymore this whole Jada will I'm done with that it was part of the work that I was ready for and it was what I needed and everybody's in different places in their Journey also that's also a dynamic I had to look at Within Myself in regards to so it's two things there's this healthy J is like tear it down I want I don't want that Persona anymore tear my ego down and there was this other part of me that was like oh my God I need to protect you know he's not ready you know he's not ready my you know codependency kicks in and I go this is what I do I'm the Martyr I can do the Martyr thing so once again it's both things it's healing like I'm ready like I'm ready for I'm ready for the tear down and then this Marty that's like and I want to make sure will as long as you're okay I'm okay that's part of my relationship with my mother's addiction that I brought into my relationship with will that created a certain Dynamic Within Myself in my relationship with him that I also needed to get my eyes on that I didn't see mhm that that needed to be healed as well without that table without that moment I would have never recognized that as painful as it was for people to watch existential disappointment in a collective I'm so sorry I wish it could have happened another way I'm sorry that it had to be so messy in front of everybody I'm sorry but I needed that what I got to clear up what I got to clean up what I got to see and to be able to sit here with you today and embrace it all and have so much acceptance for myself for all of the choices I've made and people ask me if you had to do it over again would you do it any different I don't think so and so I I wanted to talk to you about you know I think when when it all went down on Oscar's night the and you talk about this in the book and so I want to leave everyone to read about in full but the but the perception was that you were so offended that you'd kind of urg this action which is bizarre in and of itself for so many reasons that you lay out in the book but I want to hear from you like what were you actually hurt by about the condition that you were going through and in that gap between what we saw yeah and what we didn't get to see which everyone had their own theory on what was actually your thought space or where were you let me start with that was a really layered moment let me start with also that there was so much that people didn't know in regards to what was happening with will and I at that time and I I will leave for people to get the book yeah absolutely because there's so much history mhm mhm and you go into break it down I break it down hence why I did not exactly it's so much history that I think would give people a lot more context to understand that moment let me also say that I know that was a difficult moment to watch because of history that Chris and I had um in regards to the 2016 Oscar so white and I let people read to get up to speed on that but when I first saw Chris's name come on stage come up as one of the presenters I said oh boy I looked to will and I like he's not going to be able to help himself this is going to be something I was like I knew I already knew and I was like okay so will had been going back and forth backstage all night so when Chris said what he said I looked to will as if to say see I knew it right um and then I was like oh boy that's not cool to like talk about a medical condition that people there's nothing you can like it's it's it's not something that can be cured right and that how many stories I had heard of people you know young people committing suicide and the shame and just how many people suffer and you don't even know like once I had the condition and I saw how many people around me had I was like all these years I didn't know and people expressed the shame the level of Shame they had around it I'm going to be okay as far as my condition as you can see my hair is growing back that's what it does it'll grow it'll fall out it'll grow back again pieces of my eyebrows will fall out grow back you know I'm having a good moment right now my alipa is not as Extreme as most people who are dealing with that condition and I just felt like that's not okay so I wasn't I wasn't upset about me and I I don't remember actually rolling my eyes I think what people saw was me looking at will going I told you I knew he was going to do that and oh boy here we go again mhm yeah that was kind of yeah you know oh here we go but I wasn't upset about me it really wasn't it wasn't about me it was just all the stories I had heard and that I continue to hear about people who have suffered from this condition all right Greg what do you got yeah she starts off with this so much history and she says that in an elongated fashion and I think that is probably her again broadcasting what her key things she thinks about her Baseline fundamentally changed here but she sits back and she does that whole hand thing she's doing differently but she is supporting what she's saying with her words as she goes through this like I'm I'm going to cut short on the body language piece do we think that she went in that night and said go slap him if he does something goofy I don't I don't think so I think like she said the history from your relationship boils up a lot of stuff adds up people do things that tells you that one person's journey to Healing might not help the other person at all whatever that healing is and you don't we have no idea what has gone on inside their relationship people been together however many years they've been 30 years whatever it is there's all kinds of baggage all kinds of cues all kinds of things they microculture and I always talk about microcultures meaning two people can have so many signals between them if you're involved with somebody right now you probably have signals that tell somebody something across the room that no one else will pick up on they may pick up that you're doing something but they probably can't pick up the the detail in what that means to the other person my wife's Greek and she's always saying God I wish she spoke Greek because there times I want to say something to you in in a room that I can't and I said don't worry I can see it in your body language all the time and you can cause person to behave a certain way not because you intend to but because of all the history that goes with it I think all of us are guilty of some of that even the four of us who've been together for now three and a half years can get on each other's nerves with something we do or say that's subtle because the other person has seen it enough times imagine you spend 25 years every day with somebody and take into account people who have enough money that they don't have to go out every day to earn a living and you are always together probably are doing more of that in a Morey fashion and the other problem is and this happens to all of us happened to a lot of people during Co the narrower your group of people get the more you have to satisfy your maslo in odd ways because now in when you go to work there's the dumb guy there's the person who's a pain in your ass there's all these people but when there's only two of you you're going to fill those roles for each other so we have to be really careful when we're judging from outside and I want you to hear that about this relationship as well Mark what do you got yeah um look ultimately here's what I learned from from from that one is that we cannot trust anything that a Hollywood ceremony delivers to us we've got we've got a couple turning up that as far as we're concerned as a as a public are a couple their husband's wife as far there's no information that tells me that that's not the case Zero nothing nothing at all and we find out that the outer world is not reflective at all of this inner world world that there is an ego or a super ego there that is absolutely carefully moderating what we as a public get to see and then says well you know um it's kind of your fault that you don't you don't understand this why because you know it's layered it's it's layered and it's complex and you'll understand it if you read the book but but unless if you don't read the book and get yourself up to speed then you'll be you'll be slow so we as the public end up as we're slow idiots because there's this moderation system that's deciding what we can and cannot see of of the inner reality of of Hollywood doesn't doesn't sound like my fault somebody who was called you know slow at school and a bit behind and a bit stupid I'm like no I don't think I am I don't think that's my fault I don't think you're teaching me very well I don't think you're giving me all the information then you're going to blame it on me no I don't don't buy that at all well says in the end look I was just there as family just there as family it's all I was there for so to your point Greg it is that well you know family do affect each other you know family and family without family and family without family you know we've said it once we've said it a thousand times um so they do affect each each other and saying I was just there as a member of the family doesn't make you any less culpable yes I don't I don't think you you'd walked in there and gone if Chris Rock says anything bad give him a smack I don't think you gave anybody that look at all but you are family and and you are part of the you know it's either him or you and him or him or you it's probably a combination of all of those things I I would imagine Chase what do you got on this one yeah this is her saying we deceived you for a very long time and you have a problem understanding the truth and it's your fault uh one thing in this video that you're going to see is Jay who I subscribe to on YouTube gets a little uncomfortable about plugging the book so much here you can see a very uncharacteristic shuffling with his feet uh I know this is not something he does often I watch Jay's videos pretty regularly and with Jada the facial touching here goes from zero to 100 and it's all wiping her nose and stuff already she's saying I knew I already knew as a single shrug uh here and then back down to locked body language and then she says that whole look was see I knew it there's more social approval seeking because she says see I knew it right she's asking for approval from Jay and I think this is revisionist as there was no enjoyment or happiness in this moment but she's trying to rewrite that back into that moment and she's increasing her use of this word right and her eyes are closing which Greg frequently calls this eye blocking which you've probably heard Greg say before or Scott or me this long period while she's telling us this complex and detailed process of medical conditions and stories in her mind at this moment but here's what's actually happening this video and you're to see it and you won't unsee it after I tell you this she gives us two completely separate stories about the reaction to the joke from Chris Story number one she's sad and upset and hurting for all the people who suffer from alopecia story two she's smiling and laughing it off that she knew it was going to happen all along those are two separate Stories being told in the exact same 60-second time span Scott what you got well I this is my favorite one so far because we see a great example of watching an answer being constructed being created and constructed structured and then let go when he asks that first question her head goes down she closes off the world so she can think by herself so she can get in there and start thinking as she drops her head and then she's clas clasps her hands and she looks straight down and pauses and she didn't hadn't done a whole lot of of long pauses I think this is the longest one so far and that lets the inter interviewer know hang on a second I'm getting ready to say something so that gives her a a little um pause button on him so he won't say anything then she uses her hands to illustrate distance and time this thing here when she talks about uh uh people didn't know that's when she clasped her hands together and that let let you know it's something important because she's bring this together all to the middle and going hey look at this check this out this is really important voice gets lower just a little bit not a whole lot as she start starts firing that off then when she talks about um what's H what was happening with will and I she moves her hands over to the left so that's where she's making the creating the space the distance with whatever happened with those two from whatever it happened and then she has them pressed together and she's illustrating when she says so much history because again that's important to her when she's tgh that's I think these are the most important things we're hearing she's trying to really make a point and get it across in a strong uh manner or method that's the one she uses and then she says um I'll let people read then you see an edit uh to to get up to speed on that so that's another the case I don't know what we missed in there but there was more than one or two seconds in there I think I don't think it was 30 seconds or a big thing she went off on on talking about something but there's definitely an edit there and her hands are in a different spot so go back and forth a couple of times and watch that you'll see what I'm talking about then she starts goof around with her nose as she's talking about Chris and the Oscars and we can she's got a see she's got a slight gastric upset and that's we call that the psychogenic belching we've seen that with uh what's his name Robert Durst in the video we did on him when he was talking about the murders then he got a little bit um a little bit Burpy there I guess you'd say but that's psychogenic belching now we've also seen it on who's the other person we saw that on the the U it was a woman Stephie Lazarus she's really yeah so we can see the stress level growing as she starts to talk and later later on people are going to hear her Sniff and they're gonna say ah maybe it's drugs or something like that I think it's just leapt over from when she was goofing with her nose earlier maybe it itched maybe she got a little emotional and that's why she was messing around with it um and then she touches and Crosses her chest a couple of times during this several times during this when she's talking about alpia and I really do think like some people are Greg and I were talking today I said does your hair grow back when you get alope and he said I I don't know I have know the idea maybe sometimes it does or doesn't I think it does for some people depending on how bad it is I have no earthly idea anything about alopecia but it's I believe her when she says that's happening I don't really believe she she has that we got a lot of comments where people say I don't think she has alopecia that's a lot I think she actually has it because she's showing all the the body language of true concern not just like you know I'm really concerned about so and so she's doing she's doing the the classics that we know and I don't think she's paying attention to that when she's Crossing her like that now I always read the comments I get in there and I'll put Hearts by if you've commented you get in you say I put you get a heart by it it's usually me 90% of the time because I I I go through every day and I try to read as many as I can you know if I can read them all it'd be there are thousands so it's impossible for each for to to find each one so people get mad when we don't find them or answer them and I know that because I really say I've been you know commenting forever you never answer my things and I always say something like I'm sorry we don't answer comments you know we wouldn't read one like this and I make him let him know that I'm actually reading them by saying no we we don't read comments anymore but I've just read it in comment and replied to it so if you have a story if you have alopecia and you have a story and or something you can Enlighten us with give us less than a paragraph don't do a whole novel get there give us about a paragraph and tell us what that's like and tell us about um if it comes and goes or or how that works I have nor earthly idea I could Google it and look into it and all that but I want to hear your experience from it so if you have that or know somebody or live somebody that with somebody that does tell us about that down in the comments I'll read them yeah I read I read as many as I possibly can so I think it's got to be tough for a woman losing her hair more than a a man too I mean it's just part for me you know having been look who's talking through it through it I remember when you first start losing your hair you're like what hold on this is not supposed to happen to me so I can only imagine especially for women in our culture one of those tape replays and so I wanted to talk to you about you know I think when when it all went down on Oscar's night the and you talk about this in the book and so I want to leave everyone to read about it in full but the but the perception was that you were so offended that you'd kind of urg this action which is bizarre in and of itself for so many reasons that you lay out in the book but I want to hear from you like what were you actually hurt by about the condition that you were going through and in that gap between what we saw yeah and what we didn't get to see which everyone had their own theory on what was actually your thought space or where were you let me start with that was a really layered moment let me start with also that there was so much that people didn't know in regards to what was happening with will and I at that time and I I will leave for people to get the book yeah absolutely because there's so much history and you go into break it down I break it down why I did not exactly it's so much history that I think would give people a lot more context to understand that moment let me also say that I know that was a difficult moment to watch because of history that Chris and I had um in regards to the 2016 Oscar so white and I let people read to get up to speed on that but when I first saw Chris's name come on stage come up as one of the presenters I said oh boy I looked to will and I like he's not going to be able to help himself this is going to be something I was like I knew I already knew and I was like like okay so will have been going back and forth backstage all night so when Chris said what he said I looked to will as if to say see I knew it right um and then I was like oh boy that's not cool to like talk about a medical condition that people okay there's nothing you can like it's it's it's not something that can be cured right and that how many stories I had heard of people you know young people committing suicide and the shame and just how many people suffer and you don't even know like once I had the condition and I saw how many people around me had it I was like all these years I didn't know and people Express the shame the level of Shame they had around it I'm going to be okay as far as my condition as you can see my hair is growing back that's what it does it will grow it'll fall out it'll grow back again pieces of my eyebrows will fall out grow back you know I'm having a good moment right now my alopecia is not as Extreme as most people who are dealing with that condition and I just felt like that's not okay so I wasn't I wasn't upset about me and I I don't remember actually rolling my eyes I think what people saw was me looking at will going I told you I knew he was going to do that and oh boy here we go again mhm yeah that was kind of the yeah you know oh here we go but I wasn't upset about me I really wasn't it wasn't about me it was just all the stories I had heard and that I continue to hear about people who have suffered from this condition condition and obviously you didn't want what happened to happen like I think that I'm just clarifying I know that I'm just clarifying it of course it wasn't like I looked at will and said you know I know but and that's the kind of you know those are the kind of moments of context that I I lost sometimes listen there was an aspect of that that I was as shocked as anyone because will and I hadn't been referring to each other as husband and wife since 2016 I was like wife of me that's right I am I'm okay that's right I am your wife and that kicked in I'm like yep here we are in that moment that that did happen I was like we came together we're leaving together you know that part of me that put everything else aside and was like this is going to be something I need to make sure Will's okay we're going to get through this I had no idea that that was none whatsoever and I came as family I actually didn't go to the Oscars as Will's wife and I know for people that's weird but what was going on behind the scenes will and I have been like we weren't living as husband and wife MH since 2016 I was happy he asked me to go I was happy he wanted to share that moment with me still and I was going to be by his side and I think also people weren't really aware of the journey that had taken place after emancipation as far as Will's concerned to it was a really difficult movie and afterwards he decided to get into therapeutic settings and he asked me to join him cuz a lot of stuff was coming up a lot of stuff from his past childhood stuff I think people didn't understand that there was a history there between he and Chris as well so there was a lot of context that people just didn't have yeah yeah you know and I'm going to tell you something else I understand why people thought it was me I understand why people blame me I don't think it's right but I understand you know considering the narratives that were out there that I was part of I had have to take responsibility for that and I talk about that in the book you know me being the adulterous wife that had you know push will to his limit I get it so I couldn't even take any of it personally and I had to put myself in the shoes of the audience and go if I was looking at this how would what would I say I probably would have said the same thing and then that made me really look at like oh man like culturally we're always blaming women like I had to really go deep into that why do we do that all right Mark what do you got uh yeah not much on that I mean look it seems that you know Will's it's it's all Will's fault isn't it uh he went and did a film very worthy film um got himself into a head space uh Chase as you were indicating before then got himself into therapeutic situations I'm not not sure whether that's therapy or or I don't know hot BS or cold BS I'm not could be anything between Natural Therapy um you know some kind of you know could be any could be any I mean my mind has gone wild as to what that could possibly be uh but in the end in the end he goes up and uh you know thumps somebody mainly because apparently he got himself into these these situations and um and then she has to put herself in the shoes of the audience which in my experience that was like as an that's something that you should always be doing is like when how are they going to see this like what's it going to be like for them what what would they be even before the event is happening you're going you're going so what are we going to do how are they going to see that are they going to see it as we intend it to be seen so it's interesting the language there who's who because of something very very worthy has been driven into behaviors that they probably wouldn't have normally done and then driven somebody else into a behavior that they're having to put the shoes of an audience on and and see things from their angle uh very odd Greg what do you got on this one yeah so I'm just going to be me be interrogator me I'm not going to talk much about body language for me Behavior matters only as a tool it matters for me to be able to get to why so I can get the person to give me whatever it is I need in terms of interrogation in that body language is a symptom of that behavior and a symptom of things going on in their head so when you're looking for this stuff all the things we're talking about we're looking for a fracture a weakness something to go after and when I see somebody who only lives in feelings I can usually tell by language they use when I poke and prod and we get into a discussion about government things or anything else and a person gets to I feel I'm done I usually say well I'm not going to go into feelings because I can't feel what you feel and I know how to manipulate feelings and that's not fair to you this is a situation where if this is who she is if she's playing her her Ace card her her hidden card or vest card whatever you want to call it out front then she is a person who works mostly in feelings mostly in that maybe that's because it's this specific kind of interview with Jay and maybe he does a good job bringing it out if that's the case but what we have seen with her today is she is very evasive with facts Mark we talked about it last time around this what I call this glass pane image that it appears I'm giving you what you need but it's mostly in feelings I haven't heard a lot in facts in any of these things other than the therapeutic situations Chase what you got which isn't AFF fact at all and Scott uh you went last last time why don't you take this oh sorry yeah go all right thanks Chase um so let me get this straight she's made such a big deal the last episode we did when she talked to Hoda about uh the um being married and staying married but now she's forgotten that she was married during this she's talking about how she had forgotten that she was married to Will Smith she's there with him is going to go with him and then the whole thing where I'm sure she has to go to his house and have him picked up or that's going to work or they stay together that day or something and she forgets that she's married going back to what you're saying Greg as an interrogator this is where you'd light her up that's where the interviewer could have done it's laying right there I mean it's right there and he scoot he doesn't even bring it up but from an interrogation perspective you'd say oh there it is I got this now but but no he doesn't do that and then she con contradicts herself again by saying uh she went as his wife that she intended to go as his wife there it is again and you could just you could just light her up with that there's and at that point there's there's not much way there's not there's a slim way out of it but it's not it's it's very narrow if you're going to get out of that one and I think this is where we lose all the feeling of validity for her story or any any value in it being completely uh true this is where it starts to look like it's constructed for what Mark was talking about earlier for the the Persona to be out out in public you know this is what we're seeing that's just this that's the story she's constru constructed for all of us to see and hear so which I understand kofka said you know every man must be the hero of his own story that's paraphrased but I get that and that's that's what she's doing she's protecting her ego by creating this situation where uh she said she she forgot she was his wife and then she remembered or I guess she did remember because she said I went as his wife but then goes back and starting trying to protect it there so it's it's it's confusing from the point of trying to to see this as a valid um statement or statements that she's making okay Chase what do you got yeah this as I'm speaking right now my laptop is sat on top of a giant colle a boxed set of Carl Jung uh books it's called The Black Books set and uh what we're looking at here is a someone who doesn't know the shadow so this is very common in some and I call this an Enlightenment Placebo or a self- knowledge placebo where a person is convinced that they've kind of gone to the depths and what we're seeing here is a full video of somebody who has no blame no flaws and only needed healing from things that were way outside of their control and we don't see any admission of insecurities no anger no resentment no fault there's a moment she gestures all the way to her right when she's talking about not referring to each other as husband and wife since 2016 and we associate right with future in our timelines this might confuse some people uh especially if you've been a subscriber for a while so when the video comes back on you'll see a few references over to her right side here so at the Oscars this is where Will Smith was sitting beside her and she's pointing to will here not referencing a timeline so just keep that in mind she's very referential with her gestures when she's telling the truth about stuff and she's talking about having to go deep I want to really process this she's talking about having to go deep to understand why people thought the things they did and how did they think this how did they all think this and then winds up at people just defaulting to blaming women and I think she ignored the fact that she was almost a decade of false narratives deliberately being played out that she participated in and also allowed to happen in her own words uh saying saying a lot of this stuff but she had to dig deep to understand it I don't understand how that's possible one of those tape replays and obviously you didn't want what happened to happen like I think that just clarifying I know that I'm just clarifying it of course it wasn't like I looked at will and said you know you know I know but and that's the kind of you know those are the kind of moments of context that I I lost sometimes listen there was an aspect of that that I was as shocked as anyone because will and I hadn't been referring to each other as husband and wife since 2016 I was like wife of me that's right I am I'm okay that's right I am your wife and that kicked in I'm like yep here we are in that moment that that did happen I was like we came together we're leaving together you know that part of me that put everything else aside and it's like this is going to be something I need to make sure Will's okay we're going to get through this I had no idea that that was none whatsoever and I came as family I actually didn't go to the Oscars as Will's wife and I know for people that's weird but what was going on behind the scenes will and I have been said like we weren't living as husband and wife since 2016 I was happy he asked me to go I was happy he wanted to share that moment with me still and I was going to be by his side and I think also so people weren't really aware of the journey that had taken place after emancipation as far as Will's concerned tot it was a really difficult movie and afterwards he decided to get into therapeutic settings and he asked me to join him because a lot of stuff was coming up a lot of stuff from his past childhood stuff I think people didn't understand that there was a history there between he and Chris as well so there was a lot of context that people just didn't have yeah you know and I'm going to tell you something else I understand why people thought it was me I understand why people blame me I don't think it's right but I understand you know considering the narratives that were out there that I was part of I have to take responsibility for that and I talk about that in the book you know me being the adulterous wife that had you know push will to his limit I get it so I couldn't even take any of it personally and I had put myself in the shoes of the audience and go if I was looking at this how would what would I say I probably would have said the same thing and then that made me really look at like oh man like culturally we're always blaming women like I had to really go deep into that why do we do that to Jada one of the things that you mentioned was that you went to the Oscars as family but not as a wife yeah and I wanted to ask you you how do you define the status of your relationship now and what is it like you know right now of course we've had it's been an intense two years and we've really been doing some deep healing together and that's why I was saying before the idea of how just really disruptive situations can amplify love in a certain manner because it kind of forces you to have to dive a little deeper that's what we've been doing we've just been growing together and see what happens then see what grows from there you know but like I said in the book it's like we have this beautiful friendship and we really look at our marriage as being the Cornerstone of family we're both kind of of coming up with different definitions of what marriage means for us we're still figuring all of that out yeah but the beautiful part is that there's been some really deep healing going on yeah I mean you know that all right Greg what do you got yeah I'm just gonna start with one line different definitions of marriage and I'm going to tell you that that's how you end up on this show if different definitions of marriage and somebody ends up in the housefire and the other person's being analyzed by the four of us that's how stuff happens you can pretend all you want that you can have those two things aligned just be cautious how you think when you get in that situation when he first starts talking about family not wife watch her this is the first real discomfort I see in her she shuffles she bobbles in the chair and her feet move and then she lip Grooms and that's probably just so that she will be more attractive in the video don't know but then she changes voice tone and goes to a s and yeah there's contempt at an intense two years just before she moves to that deep healing and then she talks about something about you can't walk away you can you this doesn't force you to do anything and people end up sometimes one of the people is thinking they're doing some good for the other and the other isn't as she says that deep healing and she's showing her hands up about deep healing she's doing that T-Rex thing we talk about all the time her elbows are welded to her sides and her hands are moving that's not openness that's fed openness this doesn't feel good this doesn't feel like I'm getting good things coming out of this whatever deep healing is for her may not be deep healing for the other guy it may be something else and she may be keenly aware of that not sure could be a lot of stuff going on there's a lot of uncertainty some discomfort and lack of transparency as she raises her hands this way uh yeah so look I I think none of us saying that you can't have a different definition of marriage than the the one that the priest had when they married you or the one that the law office had when they but if you want to be in a partnership you're going to have something of the same definition you like for three and a half years almost four years we've made this show and I would suggest the reason we managed to make it week after week is we have a very similar definition of what the show is a very similar value system if not the exact same value system which means we start displaying all the same kind of behaviors but if one of us had a whole different definition of the show and a different value system you'd see them doing very different behaviors and be like well this isn't Gon Work so in some kind of partnership you have to have similar definitions so to your point Greg I couldn't agree more it's okay to have a different definition of marriage but the two people in the marriage will need to to have something of that different definition which they you know they live by and it and it seems that that seems to be the problem now um what's the state of the relationship is the question she comes up with nebulous Concepts which I think is just chaff Greg which is deep healing together and growing together so it's about depth it's about growth the question is is what's the status of the relationship like what's which for me is like what's going on what's going on so I think you know I think this is a good interview in that this person is getting her talking and and she's talking in a certain way that I think she's enjoying and it means we've got a lot of Gris for the mill here in terms of what we do but we don't have any very defined answers for really understanding what does her daily life look like if it were me interviewing I might start with that question you know what's the status of the relationship but I wouldn't let deep healing together and growing together I won't be nodding my head I mean I might be nodding my head and go yeah yeah exactly what's a day actually look like what happens in a day would be my question um when you have a conversation with will like what happens yeah and if she said well you know a lot of deep healing I would go yeah I get that like I get that that's really good but give me some of the words that you say like how would you start talking what might will say in return to that um and and and like where just basic stuff where did you see each other where where did you when did you last see each other and where and what did you say and what happened these basic fundamental things these are not the questions that that are getting asked and so you know she is getting away with I would say nebulous ideas and and read the book which is the real issue here uh because it it did open at quite a high rank uh but has now dropped I think to about a 44 which is which is it needs buy the book because she needs to sell that book like you know if you do anything today buy the book and have a read because she really needs you to buy that book you know uh Chase what do you got on this one yeah this is a perfect example Mark to your point of someone pretending to be public about a relationship pretending to be public if you started asking me questions about my relationship I would say I think it's adorable that you think you're entitled to that information I think it's just adorable and then I would tell you to piss off uh but when somebody's pretending to be transparent they're they're still not revealing anything and it's still behind closed doors but they're pretending like there's an Open Door there and count in this video how many times does she mention Will's name and let me walk you through what she mentions here and and I'll do it I think word for word I think disruptive situations can amplify love in a certain manner okay see what that what does that mean to you here's another one we've just been growing together see what grows from there you know like I said in the book we have this friendship and we look at our marriage as being the Cornerstone of family we're both coming up with kind of different definitions of what marriage means there's been some really deep healing going on I mean you know that's the core of what was said here what information was conveyed so to analyze any Behavior here would require some information something tangible to associate the behavior with there was only one mention of something tangible here and it was about disruptive situations where there were some emotional downright eye accessing and even then there's nothing mentioned there at all Scott what do you got yeah out of all the videos that we've seen she moves the least in this one she's leaned way back and she talks about the new ways they're defining their marriage and and what it's what it is for them and she's quiet and very still and her illustrating is at this point where you use your hands and you your to your brain emphasizing specific words and phrases those things have dropped to zero until she starts talking about will again and and she starts using words like um healing and family and growing that we'll see him there as well things that excited them we'll see him light up a little bit then they calm back down and this let this suggest to me anyway that she wants to give the impression she's got it all under control and I don't think she does and after she says and see what grows from there the smile immediately disappears right after that we've talked about this in other videos we've seen the Amber herd thing where she's smiling and it goes away that lets us know she's acting or this is put on because that's not a true motion Expressions when you go from one to another one they sort of blend into each other as you go along they fade Smiles fade and fake doesn't last fake Expressions they go away really if you're smiling and it goes away quickly that lets you know that person that wasn't real for whatever reason it may not be that they're being deceptive or whatever they just may be doing that to make you feel better or make somebody else feel better for whatever reason and the editing here leaves so much out every cut has something edited out of it so if you watch really really closely these shots as they change from the straight angle that they're static cameras so one angle to the next angle watch the changes in her um seating position where her arms or her hands are where what her face is doing watch those from Cut to cut you'll see what I'm talking about um it may like again it may have been to make the the whole thing shorter she may have just been blathering on for a long time or she may have gotten too serious about something or she may have you know talked too in depth about something that isn't very interesting maybe that's why it was cut out but we're I don't think we're getting the entire shot of her here or they may be editing it so it looks it makes her look better I don't know I don't think they do it so it make her look worse one of those tape replays to Jada one of the things that you mentioned was that you went to the Oscars as family yeah but not as a wife yeah and I wanted to ask you how do you define the status of your relationship now and what is it like you know right now of course we've had it's been an intense two years and we've really been doing some deep healing together and that's why I was saying before the idea of how just really disrupt situations can amplify love in a certain manner because it kind of forces you to have to dive a little deeper that's what we've been doing we've just been growing together and see what happens then see what grows from there you know but like I said in the book it's like we have this beautiful friendship and we really look at our marriage as being the Cornerstone of family we're both kind of coming up with different definitions of what marriage means for us we're still figuring all of that out yeah but the beautiful part is that there's been some really deep healing going on yeah I mean you know that you've both talked about how you feel like you're a mirror for each other yeah and when I've spoken to will as well it's like he feels like you're the person who knows him to his core absolutely and he know and he knows you to your core like you know everything yeah that potentially there is to know about each other and you're obviously still learning yeah what's really interesting about that is some people would say well why not just get divorced yeah everybody's always like why don't you just get divorced and it's like that's like quitting I don't think there's any person that could embrace the best and the worst of me and be able be willing to hold space in the way that will hold space for me in the way that I hold space for him and I know that most people probably go into their relationship as like you are here to please me and yeah our relationship isn't quite that you know it's like it's more about there's no greater mirror I could have than will he doesn't I can't I can't get around myself just like he can't get around himself with me and I think that that's just been what this has been all about like it's been a deep clearing like really having to look at yourself in ways in that mirror that sure we talk about this all the time would it be easier to go and find somebody else and have a more pleasing more comfortable relationship maybe but would that get me to the person that I really want to be I don't think so and I'm not saying that everybody's relationship is supposed to be that I'm not here to say that I'm just saying that that's what my relationship is that's something I desire to get to a a deeper part a more spiritually sound emotionally sound and really understand love unconditionally and the thing that I've learned about unconditional love you can't really understand what unconditional love in ideal circumstances to really get to what it is to love yourself and someone else completely with all that that's divine all that's human all that's perfect and all that is deeply flawed and have full acceptance for it all I tell you this is you know marriage is not for the faint it heart it's just not and it is definitely I believe I believe you know different people get married for different reasons so I'm not trying to say why anybody else should be married but for me the holy path of getting to a Divine aspect of myself in partnership with Will and it seems like will wants the same for himself and it's taken us you know I mean we got together at what I was 23 okay 23 when I first decided to commit myself to Willard Carol Smith Lord Jesus so young so young we were babies babies trying to figure this out and you know what interesting about young relationships you create these young patterns that get so like these really young immature patterns in yourself and how you relate to your partner and then you create these Dynamics between one another that it takes a while to like really be willing to look at that stuff and dissolve it and let it go and mature and grow it takes some real like self inventory patience courage right because you're breaking down everything all your romantic ideas everything you thought you know relationship or marriage all your romantic fantasies you know just you know Blow Up in Flames but it's really been freeing it's really been freeing to see what's more true right I'm not saying that I know the truth yet I just feel like I'm seeing more of what's true you know as regards to what love and partnership is about cuz I was definitely one of those people that's like you're here to make me happy and when you don't do it that's a problem all right Greg what do you got I'm just going to hit a few things everybody says get a divorce I thought nobody knew you were living apart nobody nobody it's just us clearly that's number one maybe there are other people and she's just using that word broadly this is another 180 to her story though because she acts like they're together I mean she's nobody knows I'm still learning we're doing this that's weird to me that she's suddenly done 180 like they're living together and they're every day working on this thing or that thing I candidly I think she's more about feelings than she is about facts and I think that's what we're seeing she feels like this she feels like they're connected and that makes it a tough discussion when you're talking to somebody who does that she also adds the word clearing clearing this is clearing that's very specific language to a very specific religion so here's yet another decorator crab of religion or a low country boil of religion we're getting together nothing not there's anything wrong with creating your own religion clearly people have made a ton of money doing it in the past but that's what it is and it's pulling together she talks about I desire she doesn't talk about will one time she says I desire in this situation well if I have a very different opinion than you do about what marriage is and I want to keep you in it because it's going to make me clear and better that doesn't sound like a very healthy relationship from my angle everybody has to figure out their own relationship and how all that works all I would say is in the approach of saying these words you have to be careful that you're not perceived as being some kind of a monster and I think people tore her to pieces in our last chat in our last live um our live debut or Live premiere people are tearing her to Pieces because they have this perception of her as some kind of a monster so you have to be really careful when you're using language this way that I desire he has a different opinion and we can't separate and and and we're back to Scott something you just said you're kind of a marriage hostage not necessarily a partner okay Mark what do you got uh yeah look um I I think it's helpful to have something of a mirror out there though it's it's confusing as to what a mirror to yourself would ever be because of course you know you are it I mean you're you're Perce you're doing the final perception so everything everything out there is basically a mirror of you um and and I would be concerned especially within uh Hollywood um or any entertainment world that the mirror is not a Fairground mirror a very distorted mirror uh so so there's a there's a bit of an irony there about the the this external world she looks to this external world as the as the most important reflection of of her uh divorce is quitting she says I think that again speaks Chase to your sun cost fallacy idea divorce is quitting well is it more like in fact that she won't change mirrors because some people would say yeah you know you've probably had it with that mirror change the mirror yeah but I you know this mirror knows me best it's rather like with a therapist when you won't change therapists it's like but we've done all this work and they know so much about me and like I've done like no it's not working like go find another one and start again I know it's hard but start again it isn't isn't working uh for you uh exactly the same Greg deep clearing in fact deep clearing has has is is going on there um look it seems to me from what she's saying and I haven't really talked about much about body language throughout this um because it's very interesting what she says it seems to me that will for her is a tool for the holy path of finding the Divine aspect of herself he's he's one of the things she's having to use or she's going to use in order to come out of this this journey that she's on of finding the Divine in her uh look no nothing wrong with that nothing wrong with that I just my opinion is I wouldn't want to be will in that situation unless i' really signed up for this at the start and God I will do that for you I will be the fair ground Mir that will that will show you the reflection of you walking along this path to your Divine self I hope for her she gets that design Divine self that she's looking for and um you know I'll I'll buy the book when that one comes out maybe uh because that that could be interesting uh Chase what do you got this is like if you asked chat GPT to come up with generic words to randomly talk about marriage that's kind of what this video is there's no reference to her flaws only Wills there's all these rumors about her being controlling about will being controlled and subordinated about her being almost domineering over him where is the denial where is one sentence that really denies this or gives will some agency some credit some respect to him except saying he's human which is kind of the only message we got about will here throughout these videos that's all I got Scott all right here's where it gets a little bit strange for me she lives a life of a divorced person however she doesn't want to get divorced so I found I thought that was interesting and after she says he holds a space for me and I hold a space for him she says and there's a huge expression of contempt I think that expression is for the next the following sentence where she talks about um the people who think differently than she does about a relationship and marriage then she laughs about that like her version of marriage is the one and can't believe how everybody else doesn't see that which makes sense because she's been reading all these books and it makes a lot of sense to her what she's thinking or what she's figured out at this point and then what she goes on to describe sounds like she's holding almost like she's holding him hostage by staying married like she doesn't want to do anything things that things that come with marriage she doesn't want to hang out with him every night she doesn't want to eat with them every night she doesn't want to watch um videos with them every night she doesn't want to do any of this stuff she wants to live in her own place she wants him to live live in his place but she still wants that connection of marriage it sounds like she's almost holding him hostage as being married whatever situation they have going on sounds like it's really odd um and maybe it's some some religious thing they haven't we haven't found out about yet or she hasn't told the world about yet that won't let him get divorced maybe it's something like that but it's sounds like she's holding on to him and he can't get away almost like a hostage situation one of those tape replays you've both talked about how you feel like you're a mirror for each other yeah and when I've spoken to will as well it's like he feels like you're the person who knows him to his core absolutely and he know and he knows you to your core like you know everything yeah there potentially there is to know about each other and you're obviously still learning yeah what's really interesting about that is some people would say well why not just get divorced yeah everybody's always like why don't you just get divorced and it's like that's like quitting I don't think there's any person that could embrace the best and the worst of me and be able be willing to hold space in the way that will hold space for me in the way that I hold space for him and I know that most people probably go into their relationship as like you were here to please me and yeah our relationship isn't quite that you know it's like it's more about there's no greater mirror I could have then will he doesn't I can't I can't get around myself just like he can't get around himself with me and I think that that's just been what this has been all about like it's been a deep clearing like really having to look at yourself in ways in that mirror that sure we talk about this all the time would it be easier to go and find somebody else and have a more pleasing more comfortable relationship maybe but would that get me to the person that I really want to be I don't think so and I'm not saying that everybody's relationship is supposed to be that I'm not here to say that I'm just saying that that's what my relationship is that's something I desire to get to a a deeper part a more spiritually sound emotionally sound and really understand love unconditionally and the thing that I've learned about unconditional love you can't really understand what unconditional love in ideal circumstances to really get to what it is to love yourself and someone else completely with all that's divine all that's human all that's perfect in all that is deeply flawed and have full acceptance for it all I tell you this is you know marriage is not for the faint at heart it's just not and it is definitely I believe I believe you know different people get married for different reasons so I'm not trying to say why anybody else should be married but for me the holy path of getting to a Divine aspect of myself in partnership with Will and it seems like will wants the same for himself and it's taken us you know I mean we got together at what I was 23 okay 2 three when I first decided to commit myself to will Carol Smith Lord [Laughter] Jesus so young so young we were babies babies trying to figure this out and you know what's interesting about young relationships you create these young patterns that get so like these really young immature patterns in yourself and how you relate to your partner and then you create these Dynamics between one another that it takes a while to like really be willing to look at that stuff and dissolve it and let it go and mature and grow it takes some real like self-inventory patience courage right because you're breaking down everything all your romantic ideas everything you thought you know relationship or marriage all your romantic fantasies you know just you know Blow Up in Flames but it's really been freeing it's really been freeing to see what's more true right I'm not saying that I know the truth yet I just feel like I'm seeing more of what's true you know as regards to what love and partnership is about cuz I was definitely one of those people that's like you're here to make me happy and when you don't do it that's a problem just one more thing all right Mark what have you seen so far up to this point look I'm I'm maybe a little oldfashioned when I hear an interview with somebody I usually like you know a few facts I like to hear some feelings um and I like to hear a bit of conceptual stuff as well you know I like the full the full meal the full dinner uh I hear a lot of conceptual stuff here um I hear a you know a little bit of feelings but they tend to get chunked up more for me in in Concepts and I hear very little factual detail if if any really and so the more I listen to uh Jada the the more um confused us I I get um and I don't think that's because of my intelligence level or not really being able to you know understand the layers or even that I haven't read the book um though some of this does really convince me that I should go out and buy the book so that I really can understand every potential you know context for this and understand it so much better you know what is going on here uh but I get left I would say a little bit Hollow uh by it and maybe there's an irony in that that I get left Hollow Chase what do you got I can already hear like some people are going to say like well they did this for their kids and why don't you talk about them doing this for their kids you know why we didn't talk about that because they didn't say it and this is artificial transparency this shows a consistent use of vague and evasive language suggesting that there's a whole book you can go by but there's also an effort on her part to appear profound while I think avoiding anything of real substance and we're seeing just repeated needs for validation with this right and all of this stuff which I think might go to her personal psychology and I think Jada positions herself as a passive recipient of external events avoiding a lot of responsibility then when it comes to the mention of healing what needs to heal wounds need to heal and the way she refers to Healing as being in progress would suggest that none of the wounds have healed yet some people talk about their wounds which should have turned into scars a long time ago so be careful around those people especially old-fashioned kind of people like Mark who just want to hear facts and real things in a conversation that's a weird Greg Mark take one for the team read the book tell me what's in it not interested had enough two like I said two and a half hours of this I might go slap Chris Rock fourth Will Smith I just it was just too much for me a lot of feelings a lot of and you said it probably better A lot of ideas Concepts about feelings not real feelings hey I felt this way he did this he did that my guess is deep buried in all of this if we were to get their therapist to talk is they have some egregious problem between them way back when that caused all this AB changes but that coming together and going we all know that the more cloistered you are the more likely your ideas are to become strange every one of you there was a pandemic you're living at home having very little interaction with people other than two or three think about what that did to your psyche in that short period of time now plug yourself into an environment where you are sequestered because the nature of their life and if you don't take some kind of input then you start getting very Naval gazing kind of mindset ideas and when you come out and tell them to the public they'll seem really outlandish and really off so you have to be very careful how you approach this and doing this therapy talk with a person where we can all listen to her might reinforce the beliefs that other people had and it might not be true it might be that Will Smith did something horrific and she's angry and she's holding vengeful thought to him it might be that she's trying to make the best of things we will never know that we can only say what we see Scott what you got I'm with Mark the cesan pros of Jada pinket Smith has left me Hollow I don't have that stuff just there's nothing there there's a fellow named Steph bishop and one time he Saidi feel so miserable without you it's almost like you're here and I would surmise I would believe that's probably the way will thinks when he sees things like this when he when he hears what's happened gosh this is so negative but I think she's probably not a horrible person I think she is Chase I think think if if she were not saying all this this stuff you probably would like her in the conversation she's probably a nice woman you enjoy talking to her and she's not doing herself any favors is the problem the more you spill your psyche and you play that card I mean you hit it early on that should be a role should be a role sorry Scott I interrupted you no it's totally cool no I I was finished anyway but I did hear like a from a person who dealt with her said she was the sweetest person in the world and so nice and so wants to he couldn't go on enough about her so he said she was really wonderful so I'm more apt to believe the guy and think she's probably wonderful and this is probably just something she's doing as her Persona to uh and that's possible sure protect herself or to be the person she wants everybody to see so all right fellas thanks this another good one and we'll see you next time so what you got hey heyo how get away | The Behavior Panel | UCx_8ri2rYergbu_06VNSPlw | 2023-10-26 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 27,618 | 141,525 |
CUj2t0OwO9k | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CUj2t0OwO9k | Debunking Immoral Statist Non-Debunking Debunker Common Law | all right now i hope it's working [ __ ] let's wait and see i don't know why there we go all right let me explore that all right this is freedom and chain channel welcome we are here to uh debunk a debunker well they call themselves debunkers but they never debunk anything it's just their opinion this one's from uh rd corporate fiction which that's about the only thing he gets right is understanding he's a corporate fiction so uh let's just get started um don't forget to subscribe to the channel please like this video leave me a comment um the trolls go ahead and leave a comment too show us how uneducated you are and let's go i love these debunkers they like uh they're all about america but then they uh they don't do anything american they just uh am communists i guess are you guys leftists is that what your problem is [Music] you welcome welcome everyone because apparently um we have an interesting one to get through today because apparently there's a new kid on the block who is trying to call us debunkers out now i say debunkers because he mentions two of the more infamous debunkers but he doesn't mention me which i'm kind of salty about but it is what it is that you know i i have an ego i i have some pride right so i'm gonna be i'm gonna be i'm gonna be upset damn it but so you're going to be upset or you are upset um sorry man you either uh don't know how to get the algorithm to work for yourself you get in front of the people so i do watch your debunkers just to find other people because it's you know hard in this community actually find people that are like-minded and trying to learn uh law and stay out of the legal fiction so maybe you should work on your algorithm a little bit to help people get in front of you you again he's uh okay let me let's let's start this off his first video the video that where he calls people out he is he re-uploaded a video that i'm sure many of you have already seen and he gives you the perfect example on how not to do fair use because he doesn't add anything to the video at all other than yeah what this guy said so we're only going to briefly touch that because the point of this vid point of this live stream was intended to debunk what he says not what he somebody else says i'm glad that's your point of your live stream but the point of calling people out was to get someone to actually debunk a video so i said debunk this video and i showed the video so go ahead and go debunk that video which no one's have you i haven't seen it yet or if someone has please put in the comments for me i would love to see you debunkers debunking something um and also fair use i don't really give a [ __ ] about fair use um you guys can use any of my videos go ahead up re-upload them if you want wish you know uh like most people that uh trying to spread truth they don't really care if uh you reuse their content so uh yeah go ahead and do that so we're only gonna briefly touch that but we are gonna go on to his latter video where he goes deep into the whole common lobby s so we'll get to find out what's going on here so all right at least you use the word common law instead of trying to shove everybody into the uh made up word called uh solvent citizen it's not work please get this show here there and [Music] i apologize guys there he is there's that beautiful face all right thank you man i don't have a beautiful face it's good for you to be a honorable man and try not to try to be nasty but uh you know it doesn't take very long for you to start trying to be nasty his channel is called for those uh unaware is uh i think it's uh freedom unleashed is the name of his channel so is that because you don't have a good memory you just don't know how to read it's called freedom unchained so go ahead and subscribe we'll get that started by the way uh i saw that smarty marty thank you for the 499 super chat lurkin aren't we all hello welcome to freedom unchained my name is garrett and i have another right to travel video for you guys a successful one a gentleman a man that actually knows what's going on in a law so this is kind of a also a call out for those uh i think jim rhodes has it that's who he reminds me of he reminds me of randy johnson more than anything else i don't know who randy johnson is but i'll look it up for you trying to debunk sovereign citizens because they are not smart enough to even know what sovereign citizen means so they go ahead and throw everybody in the bucket of sovereign citizens so van balon then bell on channel bad valiant you guys uh debunk this one or uh shout out to you van for giving everybody almost everybody in the community the content that keeps us going you're you're a special person i love you man hey you're a special person man you know those ones that don't even know how to debunk but they call themselves debunkers yep those ones very special you're amazing to that community the community of status unmoral people since academy joe pimetto joe the lawyer come on shout out to you joe haven't seen you in a while man yeah shout out to you joe the lawyer which i don't even think you're a lawyer because you don't talk actual law when you actually do your debunkings you just go oh my god this guy's an idiot you debunking this man to his right to travel don't forget to subscribe to the channel if you guys want more content like this and uh like the video help the algorithm out leave a comment and get the conversation started it's a good one i clipped a few things because uh the cop and him go on to talk about a few things that probably youtube don't want on my channel so i don't want to get a strike again okay i've watched this entire video from start to finish from virtually from start to finish um before going live i don't remember where he cut any part of the traffic stop i kept the part of them talking about the cv man you know that uh fake thing that people are pushing and then not actually educating keep people healthy that thing that youtube has taken down many times especially the one of uh doctors having a conference and then they're like oh [ __ ] man real scientist we gotta stop that so go ahead in the link hey karen description the link in the description go to his channel this is from it's paul enslaved no i don't stop that these losers uh rabbit uh van balian uh shared him on his community and that's how i found out who this guy was actually i shared my video on vanvelion because i subscribe to you idiots because uh it's a great way to find other like-minded individuals and uh it's kind of hilarious as well you guys never debunking something this is his channel go check it out and watch the whole video if you guys like but here we go let's get started let me just start my video please yeah i'm just going to record this interaction okay so that is it that is literally the end of his [ __ ] commentary i have to use language because that's what pissed me off about this he less than two minutes he talks about the setup to the video then the rest of it is this dude's traffic stop where he spouts the typical bingo card sovereign citizen arguments common law the definition of driver uh uh you know commercial activity everything that you would expect somebody trying to make a right to travel argument throughout this entire endeavor and his only way that they're claiming victory is that the cops let him go but all the cops did was get his vin number which he allowed the cops to get he and just to make sure that he wasn't driving a stolen vehicle but because the guy was apparently very nice and very cordial the cops decide to give him a break and let him go but apparently that's being taught as a victory even though at no point in the entire video did the cops ever agree to his points there he goes using the word sovereign citizen again i missed it the first time um i hope i went i let that go too long forgot what i was about to say but anyways uh yeah he's uh stating the actu the officers rules to him not his rules it's the officer's rules and the officer was very interested in what he had to say because he seemed like a moral man he actually wanted to do good he's he's probably there to actually serve and protect and not write tickets and act like a gang member gang member so yeah the cops at every single moment said that we just have a difference of opinion on what the law is and how we interpret the law yeah he did say that in the beginning but by the end he was not spouting any of that that's it and then after that he goes through the entire freaking video here's the end no license no registration no insurance no nothing because i don't need any of that to travel from point a to point b the supreme court has ruled on it so now i'm going to post this video and i hope everybody enjoyed it and i'm feeling good about myself right now oh i bet you are all right i hope you guys liked that video it was really good really informati and really informative the cop was actually a gentleman and uh he was really interested in the truth he seemed like he knew a little bit about what was going on but he was still uh kind of mixed up in their uh legal fiction stuff but in the end it all turned out good so i hope you guys uh like the video like i said before please comment hit the like button to help he is reading a skip leave a comment i want to get a copy no i'm not reading the script because uh i'm a horrible reader and a horrible writer because i was in the indoctrination camp like all you guys and uh i learned a little bit different than most people so i actually had to go to a whole separate reading class to actually learn how to read better i'm not an expert i don't say i'm an expert at anything but i have deprogrammed myself from your indoctrination camps that's for sure conversation started he's reading off a script but we're gonna see the next video which which do you guys think is better him doing a one solid take him doing 45 billion takes which we're going to see there's a lot of cuts in this video actually i'm new i'm not the best i'm learning man you know uh most things i do on my phone because uh it's just easier to edit because i don't have good internet at my location i'm in a different location here i'm watching a house for my parents because they're out of town and i got a little dispute with the uh comcast people for being shitty uh customer service people so i just decided not to uh deal with them anymore uh instead i'm just gonna build me skyminer with skycoin and uh helped take back the internet with a mesh network so we can finally cut off these shitty internet people but the reason my eyes are shifting is because uh i'm too lazy to face the camera the other way and i'm looking at my screen i try to look at the camera but then i look back at the screen it goes back and forth that's why my eyes are getting shifty uh this one's pretty much for the trolls so go ahead and trolls right in the comment let me see your comments of uh how much of an idiot this guy is and how stupid he is and so on and so forth so um that is it so until next time i'm gonna leave you guys in the love and light one infinite creator peace i again i came into this video thinking that you were going to be making the arguments like do some commentary as the traffic stop was going along to uh back up what the driver was saying you didn't do [ __ ] yeah because like normal you guys assume a lot of things i don't know why you just assume things is it because your indoctrination is so deep you just you know assume that uh what these government people are telling you is true i will do some more videos where i break down things um i got one here shortly coming up where a cop actually knows common law and starts to school the driver about what he's he needs to do to do what he wants to do what is up with that uh b p m thing is that your heart rate so you know when you're gonna have a heart attack or something you were all you did was rip this dude's traffic stop and say ha ha see look and then you did nothing to add on to it because it was a really good video needed to be shared that's the first time i saw it so i just shared it in my video it helps me learn how to do things more efficiently and better when i can put as many videos out as possible unlike you where you just go uh do a live stream and uh you try to debunk people with your opinions and not actual any facts all right let's just go to the next video so yeah facts are different than laws facts are uh have to be agreed up on two people if you knew actually what a court system a court is then uh when you put a foot fax into a court then both parties have to agree oh we'll sign i'll see what he says here all right hello oh god ah ah the aspect ratio i'm sorry hold on he oh god he that's why he did it vertically hold on [ __ ] uh yeah i did vertically i don't really like to do videos vertically but i started with the paper papers vertically and that's how i i did the second part first and that's why i kind of cut up the first part is because uh i was trying to stay on topic and uh i was thinking as i was speaking instead of maybe i should have wrote down a script and then read it huh probably right um [ __ ] a man i look like those uh underground people that your deep state buddies your corporate overlords have been hiding away in sex trafficking jeez have i not seen looks like i haven't seen the light of day in a while wide version i was not expecting this all right let's just let's just all right there we go buddy channel i want to make a quick video for you guys helping you understand how government has no authority over man let's put it this way if i had to drink every time he did a jump cut i would probably be under the table in about five minutes uh just as a fair warning to you guys uh holly are uh hilarious aha hilarious thank you for the 999 super chat paul is one of those opposites who talks yells over everyone and loves to argue with the lowly his person wherever he goes and yells over them because he can't produce any of it evidence yeah i understand that's a typical tactic where if they talk long enough and loud enough and not give somebody a chance to respond then they'll like take it as a victory it's called keeping control of the situation he's not yelling over anybody you guys are just uh the government has no authority to make laws and why man has the right to travel oh yeah i got all this uh court stuff we can go over for you guys your court not ours your court decisions right here that will say exactly what i'm saying in this video he has the right to do i found that one on paul's channel so thank you paul for that anything he wishes to do unless he causes harm injury or loss to another man okay i'm trying to focus on what he's saying and not on the jump cuts but what did he say there the government has no authority to make laws and why a man has the right to travel he has the right to do anything he wishes to do unless he causes harm injury or loss to another man and then that is when our court system comes comes into place okay so if you pay attention to what he just said there he just made a glaring contradiction right off the bat what did he no i didn't but i'll explain after you have your little point here just he said that government cannot uh pass laws against man he then says that man can do anything he wants unless he causes uh injury or loss to another man and then the court system comes into play but i thought government cannot impose law against man you your your exceptions to this rule of man can do whatever the [ __ ] they want is a law so which is it can government impose laws against man or can't they you you're thinking you know what you're talking about but government and court are not one in the same there are two separate things court was actually around way before governments it's actually in the bible go read the bible you'll find it in the bible it doesn't say court but it explains how you go to your man that has harmed you and tried to talk it out you you can't have here let's see right here it says uh a statue is not a law floor in uh versus first national bank of uh shrivaport you go i got all these in the description there's a link for you guys if you guys wanna go check all those out i'm not the best reader so i probably gonna butcher every [ __ ] name that i have on this paper have it both ways here and every court you can't have it both ways because there are two separate things of this land authorized by the cons there's another one i think there was another one here a code is not a law in re self versus rey constitution will uphold these principles that i'm about to teach you about again the constitution is a set document that imposes boundaries and it's itself a law but again i thought government cannot impose law against other men that would include laws that it would make it punishable to harm another man actually the constitution there's two parts the constitution one is expressing laws that are god-given the second part of the constitution is the structure of government that is set in place to protect those rights they're not they're not man-made laws as long as you understand how to stand as man in court and to insist on being in a court of record and not their administrative court most people don't understand there are many courts out there i'm going to roll his eyes because he has no idea what the [ __ ] i'm talking about just thinks i'm wrong because he's indoctrinated and each court has different rules and a court of record do you think he's a leftist i really think he's a leftist is where man can bring a claim against another man he's immoral like leftists and only man can appear in a court of record a creation of man cannot appear in a court of record yeah they can't only no they can't pure good debunking there man no they can't here let's see i think did i have that one in here i'll find it for you guys real quick or have a attorney rep represent represent what a man cannot appear in a court of record it can only appear or have a attorney rep represent represent this fictional entity in an administrative procedure or court so let's get to it well i guess technically he's correct a company cannot represent themselves they have to be represented uh by council so i and so i'm going to give him the benefit there and say that he's correct in that aspect that a corporation cannot be pro se uh they have to be represented by council yes that is true and also a fictional entity cannot appear in a court of record only man can appear in court of record so a lawyer prosecutor cannot bring charges in a court of record i don't think i don't know exactly but i don't even think you bring charges in a quarter record at all i think it's just a claim correct can someone correct me on that or not before we get started don't forget to subscribe to the channel hit the uh like button dab on that like button fam hit that bell notification yeah smash that like button as well uh please leave me a comment so we can get a conversation started and uh share this video around because everybody needs to understand where the government gets their authority i'm going to teach you guys how authority is giving that [ __ ] cut though come on man i'm trying to actually take you seriously i had to cut there did you hear my door like a door open that was my dog is walking around and [ __ ] like that so uh that point i had to cut it just to keep the sound play where the government gets their authority i'm going to teach you guys how authority is given and can be taken back so here we go let's get started people seem to have a hard time understanding where authority comes from so i'm just going to make a simple explanation to help you guys understand where government gets their authority there's a hierarchy in this universe and it all stems from okay we're also known as the one infinite you can see his immoralness right there he sees the word god and he's like okay creator okay so he's uh on the christian aspect of it no i'm actually not on the christian axe book but i'm in the universal law aspect of it if you understand uh how this universe works you understand everything's energy and that is what god is his energy i'll explain that here you know further for you so you understand but you know maybe you should go do some science go look up some science and actually learn what god is creates everything in the universe including man so god created man okay so god gives authority to man god can take authority from man okay as he wishes as so he can give authority so he can take the life and he can give life to man man because he is part of god if you guys want to learn what god is go study the law of one i'm a horrible writer man my brain thinks faster than my pen does and you'll understand how the universe works and what god is let me give you a hint god is just energy everything is energy stable his energy look at his eyes look at his face he has no idea what the [ __ ] i'm talking about his paper is energy my body go uh study some nicola tesla he'll teach you everything about energy he understood this whole universe is energy and that's why he wanted to give us free energy but your corporate overloads that you love and bow to and lick boots wanted to hide all that from us so they went ahead and destroyed the man's life and then took all its work for themselves his energy the infinity i mean dignity of the universe i guess manifestation of energy god expressing itself to figure out himself itself our self we are all one so this one infinite creator creates man it's a vessel for our soul i didn't have to go on and on about law of one but i kind of like to put that in there just to you know plant some seeds for you guys to actually learn what god is and uh stop being manipulated by a book that man wrote of his interpretation of the word of god the good information in the bible i don't say it's those stories aren't true or aren't good stories and that jesus isn't doesn't didn't exist on this earth uh but the interpretations are incorrect our energy and this just like most people like this guy and uh every person against sovereign citizens uh and misinterpret the piece of paper that man writes man because it is god can manifest and create anything it wishes in this world so it creates things i thought we were talking about common law like government that's what common law is dude it's a god-given laws god given rights right maybe these debunkers should actually learn like what the people that they're debunking thinks before they start trying to debunk people because they never i still haven't seen a debunked video that actually debunks anything it's all your opinion i should have like a fact tally like and something he's actually trying to express a fact probably i think you we might have one by now it's his name corporate fiction so man gives governments their authority so man can take away government authority it can create governments and it can destroy governments it also can create organizations so he's of the mind that because government can create companies is a man created entity man as in the individual though i feel like he's interchanging man in that drawing as both man individually and man is in mankind yes and no i should maybe shouldn't have said destroyed maybe maybe i should have said replace or uh use something else like use a different government that he's created and leave that other one alone and not mess with it sorry you know this was all off the top of my head i was just late late one night i just like wanted to get this idea out and i think i actually did a pretty good job that man both the individual and mankind does not have to abide by government because man ultimately created government that's that's the logic train that we're trying to follow here or corporations create ideas and so on what man has done so they can cooperate look at his face he's having such a hard time actually learning something i wonder if that's what his face looked like when teachers try to teach them something and get along with other could you just imagine him like a little mini me i bet you he had facial hair in college or in high school probably had a junior high man or men created yeah i got a baby's face make fun of my baby face this thing called government and what they do is they register these organizations and these companies and their ideas with this thing that man has created called the government okay asshat there he goes he could he couldn't keep his uh gentle meanly demeanor very long government is created so that when there is man versus man we have this entity this institution called government to uh he's really trying petition to for a redress of grievances against that man be it petition the hell i can't use this petition why would you ever petition the government for anything and you don't petition a court you file claims into a court which that's not technically true harm fun but it's more true than what this guy is saying natural harm is intended so that man does not take retribution on his own or alternatively the victim the man who does not may not have the strength to engage in his own retribution has this entity to like he says so man doesn't go out and implement his retribution help him or if the man doesn't have the strength to do so either one you know em redress uh uh his grievances he's misunderstanding the difference between government and courts they're not one of the same like we said before there are two different things you can have court without government or you know engage in a petition to make life a little easier and to protect their property that they have created property maybe i should have broke it off like for you at court i have government so you would understand that they're two different entities it's just a creation of man so when man registers their property with a government they give the government authority to administrate their property but man can take that authority away from the government to administrate the property at any time god that is why we say man has a god he is he's he's not even gonna answer that [ __ ] uh the point i made is he what point did you make a point a point that you don't understand the difference between government court of course of course he won't i'm gonna do quickly super chats uh tony tony i tony a thank you very much for joining us remember um hank thank you for 10 super chat everyone needs to understand what an idiot he is i agree great i'm an idiot i actually want to make his shirts that i'm an idiot because you don't understand what the [ __ ] word idiot means it means that i'm not a part of your i'm unknowing of your culture and your structure of life or your communities how can i express that properly i don't know but yeah i'm an idiot to uh your stupid things you guys write on papers and expect and think that's a law three and see carl go two dollar super chat which god there is about five thousand of them there's another idiot that doesn't understand what god is there's that if you actually go study every religion they all reference the same god they're just misinterpreting i don't know if there's one religion i haven't studied them all but i don't know if there's one religion that actually understands what god is maybe most maybe the buddhas probably or hindus or something understand it the best given in oh my god okay guys just skip through all that it says freedom and liberties are expressed yeah i don't know if he understands the word expressed in the bill of rights and constitution it's only there's only like two and a half minutes there's only two and a half minutes left uh man their rights they just simply express a the laws of that are universal given by god now if you can't understand that explanation of why governments have no authority to make law they only have authority to write rules for the property except that in your entire arguments especially in the arguments that your buddy paul made paul relied on court decisions and interpretations of law to further his argument he did not just go by well i only follow god's law i don't follow the laws of man he cited supreme court decisions so he relies on the supreme court first um i didn't make this video to prove paul's video but what paul was doing in his video was giving the police their rules and their laws by their courts so that he wouldn't get thrown out of a vehicle and beat maybe killed and his property damaged and locked up in jail for being a free man as an institution of authority that man let's see here we go u.s supreme court decision the common law is the real law the supreme law of the land the code rules regulation policy and statutes are not the law self versus rey registers with the government oh my god government is here to protect our rights yet how are gay how do they protect our rights if they have no authority how will they protect my rights my life liberty and property if they have no authority if my [ __ ] gets stolen who do i turn to if the government doesn't have authority i love how he doesn't understand that my first point in the very beginning of the video is that the courts are used when a man causes harm injury or loss to you that is what the police are there for so when you get a warrant in a court they can go out and bring that man into court so that you guys can work it out they go catch the criminals the criminals not the rule breakers or the policy breakers or the statute breakers or the regulation breakers to enforce my property rights government cannot give or take away a man's rights no matter what you think if you believe a government has like he's he's starting to uh get very confused at this point i think his his brain's exploding with facts and actual logic it's like [ __ ] logic's coming into my brain i think it's exploding power over man to lock him up because of a rule what if he harms me effing that is called a law not a rule your rules don't talk well they might talk about harming people but you don't need rules to prevent men from harming each other idiot oh you dunning krueger [ __ ] i'm an intelligent man okay man this guy mirror that's called reflection i like how one of your uh little followers your minions came over and used that same word in one of my videos i was like i know exactly where you came from so hope you guys like this video please subscribe trying to argue that you have a right to be a slave i am so ashamed to be a slave you should be ashamed of yourself i apologize to everybody watching right now yeah you should be because you couldn't debunk anything you didn't debunk one thing that like button you thought it would be easy you thought you'd have like uh you shoot fish in a barrel i thought this would be an easy one you thought it would be an actual sovereign citizen that doesn't actually know what he's talking about and going going out and trying to interact with police without actually knowing what they're talking about and if you find this useful please share it around and like always we'll leave you guys in the love and light of the one infinite creator oh my god archangel you on i have already had this discussion in our in our debate and i'm still not finding the answer where you guys say you know god's law is up on high government equally has no authority to impose law against man but also is there to protect your rights he wants to find something like it's written down on paper like man's gonna write it down on paper for him so he can understand it easier how are is governments supposed to protect your god-given rights if they have no authority over man because they're there to catch the criminals because you don't understand what a crime is that's not my fault doug the god emperor isn't going to help us out because we don't have space marines yet we're not we we barely have a space force the god emperor you're as stupid as i don't even want to use that word you're misinterpreting just as as bad as christians do where they think god is in the clouds are you that ignorant you can't understand that god is everything you're one little cell you you have a mother and a father they get they only get you two little cells and all of that information from your father and your mother are in these little cells that is called that is the power of god everything holds the information of the universe in it within it you even though you want to be an immoral status you still hold all the answers your brain might but your mind does [ __ ] hell oh oh my god i don't know is he thinking trying to think how to debunk something actually try to put some information out there for his audience i i apologize to you guys i thought this was actually i don't know what i was expecting i i'm sorry guys man i thought it was gonna be fish in the barrel i thought it would be easy cause 99 of people have been indoctrinated and most of them haven't been deprogrammed generally don't know what i was expecting oh yeah uh will is uh live right now and he still hasn't responded to my uh uh uh debate uh wishes but what the hell i saw i'll debate you right here come uh contact me we'll set up a debate me and you will debate man if you wanna debate so bad i'm gonna i'm gonna quickly post it here hey will it's been about oh you guys can't even see it yet hold on about a week no actually about 10 days since we like how he has the codes and statutes right behind him they don't understand that you just take one of those words and you show how it's a lie and it's not fact that it destroys every other word that comes before and after it i emailed you about our debate is it still happening huh talk about free group uh i don't wanna talk i do not want to talk about free groceries all right oh press nh now was arrested by the way jacob maria yeah the wmui yeah that didn't really do so this is a guy you like throw in the same bucket as everybody else so you can try to bash them because it makes it easier for you get that great all right you know i'm gonna i'm gonna post the arrest here uh the first minute is and just because an officer arrests a man doesn't mean the officer is right it's him just chilling for for my i love how they think that they're like oh my god you got arrested oh yeah you're so wrong you got arrested please let him know how you feel all links into i'll get arrested any time because i'd rather not get [ __ ] shot or beat by the police that are ignorant and are hired because they're [ __ ] stupid there's court cases that people sue police departments because they're too smart to get in the police department because they need dumb people to indoctrinate description pressing h now over and out press nh now christie what is going on anyway all right uh press nh now i don't know if you know this but it doesn't matter whether or not you um not saying all cops are stupid there are smart ones because um a lot of smart people actually do bad in school and taking tests and stuff like that like myself actually i didn't do bad at school most everything was easy except for reading spelling because the indoctrination camps uh didn't know how to actually teach different people with different minds to learn different things have your video setting to 1440p or 4k uh if your bit rate is dog [ __ ] your video is going to be dog [ __ ] even at 4k oh my god he said a fact he finally stated a fact something's going on over here that might be even considered a law because of the uh natural aspects of computer and mathematics because computers is just mathematics and that is what the world is is mathematics you you can explore the world if you go understand some mathematics down this first guys oh by the way okay just real briefly about the setup because i remember watching a little bit of this um earlier oh i apologize i remember watching a little bit of this the uh press nh now spent about three hours uh driving around manchester new hampshire with a police blotter looking for [ __ ] to video record because you know they have nothing better to do with their lives uh this man speaks speaks of the devil is he reflecting once again apparently at the very last second they heard about um a shooting that took place so they're they decided to drive themselves up to an active at least these auditors are doing something better than this guy at least they're uh trying to be moral people i actually learned the truth unlike this guy shooter situation down the spruce is it closed off is it closed off shooting yeah all right calm down buddy hey why don't you mind your business and do what you're doing hey man he has a right to go over there and get shot if you wish to do yourself you said don't go down spruce i'm not going down spruce there's a normal tyrant there's a sovereign citizen for you right there that would be confirmed that would be known as a sovereign citizen a police officer a gang member on the street for me to not go down spruce street i'm not going down spruce street don't tell me what to do why don't you block it i think i'm going to start doing these debunking sovereign citizen videos and they're just going to be all cop doing the cops awesome i'm telling you leave a publix please leave we're just getting involved block it off go now and leave it off won't you calm the video quality is [ __ ] but the cops are actually have their ars out so that's the situation that we're in at the moment calm down i will take as [ __ ] long as i need to i got a comment here comments the last one is pretty interesting god laws also enslave people no no no man's interpretation of god's laws enslave people because they they believe the church understands what the bible is saying which they don't plus they write i don't i don't know why anybody would go to a church they register with the corporate fiction anyways that anywhere in the bible says that a church should register i don't even think a church is what it is now in in life or what it a building i think a church with jesus church was going to like-minded individuals houses and living quarters and uh and talking spirituality and uh you know the bible and stuff like that i am walking away you ain't tough with that bro i don't care about being tough i know i know where is it open show me where it's open to the public go from here show me where it's open to the public show me where it's open to the public and that's it that i know it's a little bit of whole home but that's it like the cops were obviously not uh dealing with uh did not have the patience to deal with them and yeah obviously they don't have the patience to deal with it because they're low integrity people immoral most of them are immoral not all most of them any [ __ ] man um you know it's not his fault there's nothing he could have done he's apparently live right now you know it is what it is at the time so you know they told him to leave he left and he went right to the pd and that's where he should have gone you know and i would have done the same thing for him so it's a big shout out to to go cartoon man um you know that's it i mean oh everybody said what up and uh yeah he's all here with me um like i said he hasn't left my side yet you know what i mean last time i seen him i would love to respond to this this comment you retracted a comment uh artie these there are 30 000 different denominations that's that word sorry moral reader like i said the damn indoctrination camps did horrible on me of christianity alone yeah yeah there's people that have different ideas in this world oh my god that's why you can't shove everybody in little buckets like you guys like to to just to try to shame them was when i went in and the last uh real quick the super chats uh but religion and what understanding what god is is not one of the same uh uh kit five dollars this man has corkboards up with a lot of string going from item to item yeah he probably does uh kit 190 gale makes more sense to this guy with two dollar super chat uh see carl go two dollars to use a green marker to give some authority back kira 808 state i don't think he uh wants to spend any time actually producing his own content you know that would take some effort to actually write something down and actually express an idea 4.99 this guy's insane yeah he might also be just a guru catching clout i mean if i if you look at his youtube channel it's it's full of like click-baity [ __ ] for a particular uh clientele um i don't know if he's talking about me or not but yeah i'm not a guru i'm just uh a man trying to uh be free in this world hey the adults are talking five dollars super chat do you think he has a wall covered in pie and ideas pinned ideas how to connect with string like a detective and he's really convinced himself of this what like that [ __ ] uh always sunny in philadelphia meme maybe probably smartymarty499 super chat wow i actually have a lot of sticky notes and stuff on my walls to uh get my ideas out but they're not about common law it's about how to actually replace the government with blockchain because that's what's gonna happen in the future and you can't stop it no matter what you guys think you can't stop the blockchain and uh it's gonna be me or somebody else that's gonna create a government system that will replace the government and people will move over to it and they will start using it and it will be based off of the common law court system not your fictional court sex system oh our bad i guess let everyone out of jail yeah let everybody out of jail it hasn't harmed anybody so drug dealers anybody that uh got caught up in your court system breaking a code rule regulation policy or statute because uh like it says it's not a law and robbie anderson for uh for he laughs like oh that's such a good comment oh you're so intelligent my fellow listeners my answer chad screw this guy let's talk about free groceries i do not want to talk about free groceries and this idea that apparently all food in grocery stores are prepaid and you can avoid dealing with the federal reserve to get them and have an absolute defense against larceny at least he has a little bit of moral base there unlike his followers that want to be immoral and go steal things that sounds as bad as the guys that think you could go clear clean your uh credit the sovereign citizen people that think that you can clean your credit using your birth certificate and the uh number that they gave you that's not your it's not your property you didn't make that a government made that so you can't administrate that property um they use it yeah they do they sell you on the socks train they put it put it in a fund or what is it mutual fund or something like that i forget what they do and then they go sell it around you know they trade you around hmm yeah he threw it out of my hands you know it's like come on dude so uncalled for your phone no i got a good case on it exactly since uh there was some comments that said the cop had been in your videos before do you know him from past encounter he might be a smart guy and putting a good phone on his case because the case on his phone because he understands the cops are immoral and they'll destroy your property with no reason you know um the whole department knows me guys i mean i'm no secret to any of these guys that work in here you know all the way from the top down i mean there's no secret even dispatch knows me everybody knows me this is just fine i really don't care wonder if i have a channel um the problem is is that you know they probably have me on road calls and [ __ ] on friday nights i i wouldn't doubt it and you know i'm not gloating i'm not saying oh hey you know the cops like hey press save i got some comments oh he deleted all his comments why what are you going to do to me what are you talking about stream lab somebody said please refrain from sending long messages i didn't i didn't write that i don't know how that got into uh oh street yeah that's yes that wasn't i didn't send that streamlab sent that to you sorry go ahead and send as many little messages you want but i guess streamlab won't i guess they don't want you to send long messages because uh it's a live chat people can't read that fast but after this video go ahead you can put as many long messages you want in the bottom we'll start a conversation with you you know personally i mean how they not i mean at this point they're they don't they should i don't think they need to be but press nh i have noticed that more than one auditor had our as being um subject to no contact orders from actual police officers like individually because they're getting that out of control i don't think that's lawful i don't think that's illegal in your own in your own rules definitely not moral i'm just gonna put a restraining order or don't contact because i'm scared i am the guy with the the gun that walks around threatening people but i'm scared it's been you know investigating further into what was happening rather than dealing with me exactly leave me alone you got charlie's uh charlie oh yeah it's like a charlie go carson hell yeah guys yeah for real breathing is definitely resisting too um you know i i don't really know i have to look into it um i have tons of public records i'm going to look into uh that i pulled in the past but i may or may not have i i don't know i'm not 100 i i think so though all right we'll read some of these while we uh slowly go through the rest of this video i want to respond a few more things probably maybe not i don't remember how boring this gets but u.s supreme court decision 1796 there every man is independent of all laws except those prescribed by nature that would be common law he is not bound by any in institutes formed by his fellow man without the consent his consent cruden versus neil i think he was on a call at one point for me but either way they all know me it doesn't really matter what up db what up nick oh let's go in the shade it's a little warm out here this is a good one there have never been any judges in america since 1798 or 1789 sorry i'm dyslexic you know probably why i don't read spell very good because i'm dyslexic and the indoctrination camps have a hard time teaching dyslexic people instead of actually trying to figure out a different way to teach them they just tried to medicate them yeah no [ __ ] no but anyways that is uh there are only been administrators f r c versus g e rights is resisting for real that sound is bright too sorry guys yeah so i haven't seen a cop come out of this station and a few man no contact order is uh you know just uh it's kind of basic basically the same thing as a um a tro like you know do not uh you know approach him do not try to talk to him do not call that type of thing may well very we may well very uh may very well be the same thing as the trl i really don't all right the supreme court has warned because of what appears to be lawful commands statute rules regulation codes ordinance and restrictions on the surface many citizens because of their respect for what appears to be law are cunningly coerced into waiving their rights due to ignorance yes please all the ignorant people in the comments please comment about this [Music] deceptive practices constructive fraud battery legal plunder conversion and malicious prosecution in in in forens inference administration courts in administrative state courts capital s state not lower s state which is just a state of being united states versus uh minker thank you i appreciate that man yeah i mean i don't know exactly who said what it's not that crazy of a deal um you know i just i just all right i'm there he's just obviously saying absolutely nothing um but there it is guys i i honestly expected that to have more substance than it really did uh so i kind of actually want to apologize to you guys sorry you guys you actually are being educated for um i don't know wasting y'all's time i feel like so uh so i'm gonna stop here we'll see if uh mr unleashed uh will respond to me and at least i try to read even though i'm a horrible reader at least i try to read it's called unchained unchained no not because you love the leash uh so yeah i so again thank you guys for watching i appreciate all y'all support it's called unchained because uh the blockchain is going to unchain us from your rules regulations and your indoctrination and your slavery system that's what's going to happen i uh i think we're going to stop here can the legislature make auditing a public nuisance law there is his uh immoral dictators again those leftists that want to uh make rules up for everybody so they feel better for themselves exercise the fertility no i would say that the uh the see he doesn't even make the moral argument of not why not to do this he makes a legal argument why it cannot be done they can't do that um because it's already pretty strongly ingrained in most circuit courts that you know the you know police can be subject to filming you know in public um it's just a matter of degree where when again it's as as with everything it's like a time place and manner um i mean the legislature could do it but it would be challenged and more than likely be struck down um so yeah that that would probably not be the best idea of doing that i know texas has that uh that law i'm kind of curious as to what that what hap what what may happen to that law um if it's challenged but generally speaking the courts are very clear that you know you police can be subject to filming in public it's just a matter of you know when where and the degree in which they're allowed to film um i would love to know your personal opinion on that would you like that to happen and oftentimes that's and that ends up being like a case-by-case basis so az the kid thank you very much for the all right a concurrent or joint resolution of legislation is not law krogen versus flynn and a whole bunch of other ones there's like one two three four five six five in there or something like that all codes rules regulations are from argh for government authority only not human creators in accordance with god's law all codes rules and regulations are unconstitutional and lack due process of law rod [Music] versus rey donovan us department in labor this man actually knows what the [ __ ] going on he doesn't he doesn't he's not suing the u.s department of labor he's suing the man he's pulling the man away from out from behind his uh badge or his oath or his whatever to pull him out lacking due process of law in that in that they are void from ambiguity in their failure to specify the statutes applicability to natural persons otherwise all right i'm gonna keep butchering that but you get the point go research it all in the link for you guys in down below the 4.99 uh sticker uh princess toad still thank you for the two pound super chat no need to apologize already never waste of time uh i i still feel bad because that was just an ah the guy was just asinine he i'm annoyed i'm annoyed that i watched his entire thing and he added nothing to the traffic stop and he vomited a bunch of [ __ ] i've heard before about the hyper you know the hyper christian sect of sovereign citizenry that here he goes reflecting again vomiting this man bombing it's all over like his opinion and i haven't i think i've gotten two facts out of you first your name and something else i forgot that is ultimately contradictory uh at its core contradictory score no because you don't understand the difference between government and court or a government's court or a government's administrative procedure versus common law courts of record anyway thank you guys again have a good night thank you guys again you guys have a good day i'll leave you guys in the love and light of the one infinite creator | Freedom Unchained | UC7HkjDpuxvAOJiVjrjpbGNw | 2021-06-08 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 10,068 | 52,355 |
982LKf9HsTg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=982LKf9HsTg | PowerLeague to Masters Episode 5: The win streak begins | foreign [Music] yo what's going on guys Bobby here and today we are back with another video now before we get into it I wanted to talk about last video a couple of you guys in the comment section were upset about the bow game and how the bow was treated and stuff like that so I just wanted to go over a couple of things one first and foremost is most important I would never ever ever get anyone banned for anything nonetheless playing bad in a brawl Stars game in the report system it doesn't work just flat out doesn't work I have personally tried to report many people who have constantly thrown my power League games if I want to get someone banned or something like that I have to go to Frank or to Danny and personally ask them send them their tag all that stuff that one report is not going to do anything to the bow and I know that second off if you guys want to see real games and want to see me in actual time and don't want to see cookie cutter videos where I play 10 and I pick the best two and show you guys so you guys can see my actual reaction my actual emotion stuff like that there are gonna be some stuff where I get frustrated and say some things it's already a YouTube video where I'm holding back stuff that I want to say holding back how I really feel I'm kind of just putting a smile on my face and playing but with that being said you know obviously I'm not trying to lose obviously I'm going to get upset if you guys want to see losses that type of stuff is going to come with it um I reached out to the boat I didn't get a response if he's in the comment section you can DM me on Twitter on Discord whatever you want we can talk about it uh and figure stuff out if you're upset at all um but yeah I wouldn't get anyone banned it's a really big kind of overreaction by you guys um I feel like you guys should know that as a tier three Creator as someone who spends 10 hours a day on the game I'm not gonna get someone banned I'm not gonna do anything like that or you know just do anything wrong in general so again I apologize to the bow uh but from my viewers I expect a little bit less of an overreaction for stuff that's you know so basic and not like nothing really even happened uh so with that being said let's just uh hop into the video and let's keep it going all right so going to the game we got someone else who has a shiny green name just like us and a diamond so you know maybe he's a fan maybe he's going to be on the channel so you know what I won't make fun of him at all not like I made fun of the bow I won't even get mad and I'm you know I'm gonna banbo as well so you know what now there's not gonna be any more bows in my game uh but with that being said we're gonna try one time to show you guys the entire draft how it plays out stuff like that uh and we're only gonna do two games because draft takes a little bit but we'll see how it goes um so we are going to ban tick and Gene now tick and Gene are two really good first picks dick kind of fell off a little bit as a first pick because tanks are so good kind of the same with Jean but still really good first picks and they're gonna ban Sam Grom and squeak so they actually have really good bands this is something that I would do in a competitive game game event squeak so you can take Penny or Janet stuff like that it's actually really smart so looking at the available Brawlers I kind of want to go with Piper now Piper isn't necessarily the best pick here um but in comp you know we might actually end up going with Piper because we do have last pick which means we can counter tanks if they go tanks we can counter stuff if they go uh I run it down cop now the Brock pick is kind of interesting because with two three what you want to achieve is you want to kind of cover all your bases so if we're taking Piper something that's good into long range something that can break the map a little bit stuff like that with our second pick in the 2-3 slot we want to take something that counters tanks um this pretty well into lanes because then obviously they can go something like Max which counters both of us so if I were to make that pick I would have probably gone with Otis because what do you really go into an Otis in a piper you kind of have everything covered all right dude got us with the Dodge um but yeah you kind of have everything covered when you take two things like that and instead of getting counted like we did with the Max and the dude obviously dodged um you know you can get a pretty good draft so we're gonna run it back again shooting star they have first pick so the number one rule when someone has first pick on shooting star is you need to get Piper banned because Piper is the strongest brawler in draft on shooting star because what the thing with Piper is if you have Piper not into Nani it's a per it's a free game there is nothing that you can do about it like the other team's just gonna wreck you but if Nani isn't banned and Piper isn't banned then Nani instantly becomes the best brawler and they're gonna have Nani and you're gonna have Piper and you just can't win that lane so it's just really imperative that you banned Piper if they go Nani you can just go Gene the best part about Nani on this map is the fact that the Return to Sender counters you know Big Shot stuff uh but if you just go Jean and poke the Nani it's actually really really easy to win Lane uh just like that so hopefully someone goes Gene spike is not the pick Jesus Christ um all right dude's gonna go Spike um so we're gonna go Gene uh hopefully this guy doesn't throw our game Spike's a pretty interesting pick on this map uh I would have probably gone Jean and Gus or Gene and Brock the reason I like to go Brock 2-3 is because so they can't go a thrower but we can still go a thrower if we want um so here we want to take something like a gus something like a Mandy even though Mandy's band I just want to give an example like a Bonnie I mean that just kind of runs them down um I'm gonna suggest Bonnie B is not the pick here and B is not the pick because B is really good into every single range or or sorry every single brawler that's not range and range counters it specifically Nani specifically Brock and specifically Belle so uh this is a really bad draft please no one ever copy this draft um this is really really not good or just cut but we are gonna try and win this regardless um and we're gonna do our best to not get mad at anyone so uh I'm gonna try and get the blue star I'm trying to apply some pressure over here um unfortunately our B is gonna go down but we we did get blue so we're only down one kill here uh yeah the spike is spinning I would also spin if I had to deal with that Bell Lane as a spike uh but you know what maybe use a spike man he's gonna figure it out we don't know he's gonna camp in that bush a little bit try and get a pull but doesn't look like that's gonna be an option uh this Brock is playing this really really safe staying as far back as possible basically uh we're gonna get the Frog to break its own wall so that's really good because that just helps us move up a little bit uh we're gonna spray out this gadget get two of them low we have three of them so now we can start applying some pressure here uh we should be able to get a kill here we just gotta not rush it just take our time but we're looking pretty good I think that's going to get us at least one kill it does uh our B is in a tough spot so we're gonna try and get our B out please all right good shot by the bee and there we go so honestly this shouldn't be working like it is but it is I guess for now good shot by the Bee maybe just a one trick B I don't know and he likes playing into counters we're gonna have our super in a shot so we're gonna try and pull this unsuspecting Brock never mind the Proctor though so I guess we're just gonna pull the Nani um but yeah it's pretty wild uh Belle should be able to win Lane versus Spike like 10 times probably considering it's a counter and it's just a wide open map in range so I think the spike went oh and O which I can't really ask for anything else outside of it going even the B did really good um and the Brock on their team I think they're just being a little bit too passive like they can literally just run in a straight line and uh kind of just take us out but they're really playing it slow so uh we'll see what ends up happening the Brock is one we're gonna be able to get the Brock really easily and we're also gonna get the Nani pretty low um we should be able to get this kill we will that's the best part about Gene it's it's just so easy to clean up and again just take out that Return to Sender um it can't do anything to a gene does like 20 damage or something so just getting it out is really important for your teammates and yeah you can kind of just chill right here Do Your Own Thing um they're getting oh my God oh my God I'm just trying to pull the Nani when it uses heads I'm trying to stay somewhat in the mix here oh my god oh and he was one shot too that's so bad [Music] but as long as we're somewhat closing Nani's gonna lose head now which is a really bad idea you definitely don't ever want to use head when someone's close I don't think he did but if people are close you're basically making it a 3v2 when you're in the head so we never ever ever want to do that that guy's one so we're just gonna be able to get the kill over there and six stars so I mean we're doing pretty good um we are I guess on a main I'm just gonna run into that uh playing Power league so I guess that makes sense but yeah we're chilling looking good this one is looking like a w unless we really hard throw but I'm just gonna camp in a bush and go for a Kill uh we call this Dyna Ray where you just sit in the bush and then jump out with your super that guy stole my kill I wanted Seven Stars instead of Dinah Ray I guess I'm I don't know Gene I don't know what to say really uh but yeah so it looks like we're gonna be able to get the win here this Nani's got to go back to driving school as it just went around me two times but yeah so really bad draft don't copy this draft if you're gonna take anything from this um I don't know Jean's really good into Nani that's what I would take from this and to ban Piper 100 of the time so really good win for us there uh we're gonna get the W move up a little bit let's move on to the second game and let's see what happens all right so going into the next game we're on Hard Rock mine um this is a really easy one so here we would take the dog hopefully Chris actually takes the dog if dog is ever open you definitely want to take a first on this map first pick is a lot harder than second pick second pick it's really easy all you want to do two three is kind of get two Brawlers that are well-rounded you know so for example Piper Otis from the lair cake draft that we never actually finished um or a gene in a range from the last draft that we just did um but first pick it's and then you counter with the last pick but first pick it's not really that easy you have to cover all the bases with your first brawler and then four and five so it's kind of in reverse order so the instead of getting a counter last pick which you want is to try and get the very best brawler on the map so what we got was dog and then with four and five you want to kind of cover all the bases so right now we need a mid and then we need another Lane um so I think we should go 8-bit I'm gonna let easy pick on his own and see what he does see what he picks and then we'll pick around it Easy's gonna go with Carl okay so Carl really bad pick you don't pick Carl into surge because surge is a counter um and then Gene is pretty good into Carl so you definitely don't want to take it um I'm gonna go with 8-bit personally I hate 8-bit on this map but I'm gonna try it just for fun um if I were to pick a lane I would probably go stew or I don't know or even Mr P to be honest because I don't really see what they can take into us that's really going to dominate a Mr P dog an 8-bit probably an ash I guess so maybe Mr P's off the table um but something good into tanks but not necessarily Carl I don't know they go stew Stu is probably the pick to be honest if we had dog stew and 8-bit this would be a pretty easy win um but nonetheless we do counter the mid the stupid is okay by them not really the biggest fan and I'm gonna go Vision in speed now there's a lot of different 8-bit builds that you can have that are really good personally I like vision and speed on this map as the mid just because you want to be able to know where everyone is you're holding the gems and even without speed while you're holding the gems is very scary so any you know boost of speed that you can have is really important with 8-bit all you really want to do is get to clipping at the start because that's really all that matters in the game if you can get your turret fast you're gonna win unless you throw you can't get it fast you're going to lose because they're going to back you up really easily so I'm just going to chill around here wait for the gene or someone to overextend so I can get my turret couple shots off there we go and now we're just going to slide this right over here and now we're just this you know kind of insane killing machine right now that can do a lot of damage so again our draft isn't really the best but it's probably gonna work out just because most of the games usually work out um and for your turret I probably wouldn't put it over here just because it's really easy to take out I would probably put it behind but now we just got to be careful about this Gene that is lurking the mid see how we have Vision though we're always kind of knowing where it is it's really important again oh we know it's somewhere around here so we're not going to go to aggro just trying to make sure we don't lose all of our gems Serge is still behind us and you don't want to throw your turret down when you have another one because you want them to waste ammo on the turret and there we go we're just gonna go behind the bag and really easy now this Gene has no charge towards pull we know exactly where he is and uh we are we still have three TPS left so this is looking like a pretty done game at this point we're gonna pick this up didn't even need any of the teepees so really good game right there um Carl I don't know the car was a pretty interesting pick I'm still not the biggest fan of the way that that went but you guys saw the dog kind of just held Lane all game you can't be picking surge into dog because dog counters surge dog counters Gene and they pick two things that the dog counters into it so you can't you can't be doing stuff like that like doing stuff like that is just goofy uh but if you can get a first pick dog on this map it's really good because it kind of counters a lot of the lanes and it's just the best brawler on the map kind of how Rico used to be but this one is a RICO with bags that also gives treats so again we're gonna play this start a little bit slow we're just gonna try and get our super and if you're playing gene into this all you're really trying to do is poke and help your lanes so your lanes can move up and put pressure on the 8-Bit you don't want to really be doing anything else into this uh yeezy's doing a really good job I'm gonna shoot under he's gonna shoot over it's really important to work with your teammates on stuff like that so make sure you guys are doing that but this again this is looking like a game over already um another pretty good draft I mean no drafts with randoms are going to be perfect so if the worst thing we have is this is a Carl then you know we've been through worse we've had a bow on Earth yeah they're probably gonna take that out so I'm just gonna move my turret down there by the thing by the way the bow thing is a joke please don't get mad at me again uh pretty easy clip over there and yeah this is this is pretty simple now the scary thing is we don't know where the gene is so I'm just gonna go back there but I wouldn't suggest doing that if you're up eight nothing and all you have to do is get two more gems and you have three more teepees I wouldn't put yourself in a position where you can die like that now this Carl I don't know exactly where he's going but he's going to survive on literally one HP he's gonna get that kill over there again didn't really need to go that aggro especially the Carl but you know we did anyways we got the win and that is gonna be it for today so two pretty clean games two wins two star players whatever we are gonna move up in the rankings and again you know we're kind of far away we're gonna start uploading a little bit more frequently um but you know what we're making our way up there now with that being said to end this video I'm actually moving to Las Vegas so I'll probably have one more video out uh that I have pre-recorded that I'm gonna do while I'm moving but expect more content I'm gonna be settled in by February 3rd February 4th so it's going to be a couple days um and then I'm gonna get the content ramping back up again so if you guys enjoyed like comment subscribe all that and we'll see you guys again later peace hey you yes you there watching this on your phone have you ever wanted to be the best the most handsome the most loved player on your team and support your favorite Creator at the same time well I have good news you can be all of that and more by using Code Bobby but you have to do it now because this is a limited time offer use code Bobby at any supercell game store | bobbyBS | UCcvJdy945lh9KNQnW2yr_0A | 2023-02-01 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,627 | 17,676 |
Aut-IME4M7o | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aut-IME4M7o | Relieve Neck Sprain: Chiropractic Care for Working Women | [Music] look after them [Music] this is straight arm straight arm straight down straight arm straight up I spend this no it's not easy straight arm again straight [Music] um oh God you have to stop things I'm sorry yeah foreign [Music] [Music] oh God [Music] without [Music] um easy relax now one more time breathe out no breathe out now on your back [Music] okay shoulder images [Music] thank you easy easy I know what you're going to do you know a little not much so I'm still trying to figure easy to Let It Go all right so I just don't know what to do what do you create what do you do HRS HR function I'm gonna join a new job on Monday which is the 10th and I have to be absolutely okay no no I know easy okay come and sit here now | Acctive Plus Chiropractic | UCBJ-BQFSklp3h0Mm9QX50rA | 2023-05-22 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 148 | 736 |
TGxeNu4EbVg | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGxeNu4EbVg | Kane & Lynch 2 - Dog Days FULL GAMES PART 1 Gameplay Walkthrough en #francais | foreign [Music] each other [Music] okay no uh you could hey it's you [Music] hey Shanghai [Music] the beach boys foreign [Music] hey [Music] let's go flying go down [Music] look at it [Music] [Applause] foreign thank you [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [ __ ] [ __ ] hey go down [Music] [ __ ] [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] the show [Music] let's go [Music] [Applause] [Music] thank you [Applause] foreign [Applause] [Music] vehicle foreign [Music] foreign [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] wait come on yeah [Music] foreign oh wow you ready on Africa the families hey no seizure though there's some point that people Cycles all right foreign [Music] right again thank you [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] good Ness [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] foreign [Music] stable 50c [Music] m ouse okay thank you [Music] foreign [Music] beautiful yes thank you [Music] thank you let's go yeah [Music] foreign [Music] disability whatever foreign now watching me Lord what should you show us your paste media um [Music] okay okay [Music] it is [Music] Frontier two foreign [Music] cheers [Music] made this cartoon [Music] foreign [Music] thank you [Music] beautiful man foreign anyway s okay | SHINE GAMES | UCqYpDVBMIawvlR0GNY8ecuA | 2023-01-16 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 205 | 1,360 |
yCgtLExysTw | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yCgtLExysTw | 1994 Maywood Park ANXIOUS DEBONAIR Dave Magee | here's the field for the seventh rice number one genome with danny knox driving number two matt's venture and jim curran number three anxious debonair dave mcgee number four is explosive gold and dale heightman number five termination daryl bussey six inexplicable and ron marsh number seven morrow's robbie randy jacobs number eight town yankee laverne hostether that's the field five minutes so post just five minutes don't forget ladies and gentlemen we invite you to sign up tonight and join the maywood park preferred players club they've reached the starting gate the gate is to return here they come they're off anxious debonair between horses coming right for the lead into the turn they race an anxious dubliner has the lead but inexplicable driving second now drops in second general and third two legs back to matt's venture followed in that turn by explosive gold two legs back to termination full of memories robbie and tony yankee trailing out of the turn moving for the quran anxious your leader length and a quarter inexplicable second two likes it's genimal and third by the quarter twenty nine and two positions on change it's dave mcgee an anxious debonair with the lead now opens up two and a half lengths it's inexplicable second two and a half likes genimal right there and third explosive gold is first over here comes termination with cover matt's venture on the oats on morrow's robbie and town yankee they're heading for the half it's anxious demeter with the lead they're halfway home 59 and two anxious debit air euro leader but explosive gold inches upon the outside second explicable in third hold on the outside termination it's genimal and mauro's robbie honor the turn the criminal of the box for an anxious debonair a length and a quarter now by two likes it's inexplicable back to second it's explosive gold and third termination he's moving up three wide they race by three quarters anxious debiter your leader 128 and three three quarters anxious debonair has a lead explosive gold is on the outside inexplicable genital needs racing room maru's robbie three wide and is coming on here they come turning for home it's anxious debonair with the lead it's inexplicable and mar ruiz robbie jennifer is there it's anxious debonair with the lead inexplicable it's anxious debonair inexplicable and genimal up for third number three anxious debonair was first number six inexplicable was second number one journal third number seven mauro's robbie was four let's check in at belmoral racing fans were eight minutes away from belmoro park's eighth race this is the knights of columbus council number 404 seven monsignor writers owned by ken huberkov sandwich trained by ronnie robertson driven by dave mcgee the seventh race the melrose park gales football and cheerleading organization purse we had no winners tonight in the twin trifecta ladies and gentlemen we have a real nice carryover for tomorrow night 10 245 38 cents will be added to tomorrow night's twin trifecta ball you | harnessdom | UCscHBaZIjEgT90_khDmG8ow | 2020-05-06 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 507 | 3,012 |
qeb6gD9rp2o | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qeb6gD9rp2o | CoverPage Web Account administration | you can access your cover page Account Details through the web open your browser and go to www.coverpageapp.com and click on the green button in the upper right of the window from here you can sign in with your username and password the first page you'll see is the account overview page on the left are the different parts of your account on the lower right are usage and statistics to help keep track of your activity click on my profile to see your user profile here is where you can edit or change information anytime the menu shows subsections including subscribing for the newsletter the most important part of your profile is that user account subsection you are an administrator of this account but you can also add co-workers and manage their roles right here as well you can edit the profile of your current users or add new users by clicking the add new button fill in the name password and email of the person you want to add this will be their name and password for logging into cover page choose a role for the person you added admins have the same rights as you a publisher can publish their projects to your application and manage those publish themselves you can manage your viewers here and Link them with the Publications in the publication management section watch how to link them later in this video in the purchase section you'll find all the details about your purchase history clicking on Publications brings you to your newsstand window where you have control over both the Publications and the viewers who have downloaded them you can remove Publications from the server at any time and also hide them from General View once a file is removed from the server it will also disappear from viewers in the cover page reader as it updates you can publish into the sandbox mode and when your project has been tested and you want to go public simply uncheck the Box the viewer button allows you to manage your viewers and Link them with a particular publication in this case I'm only going to give George access to the how to make sushi project this means that it'll only be visible to George John and Thomas won't be able to see it this is a great way to share files and get client feedback before releasing your app adding another device to your account in my devices section means that the sandbox Publications will be visible only on added devices all paid projects will be available for free this is your beta interface where you can test your projects before they go public to add a device download any of the udid apps in the App Store in seconds they will tell you what your udid code is add the correct device model and you're done | coverpageapp | UCzppnAHBOtDKTnptrzJYjiA | 2012-08-02 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 483 | 2,660 |
gOo-Dmo0B_Y | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOo-Dmo0B_Y | Nicholas Urruty: Spring 2023 Special Session Scholarship for New Students Recipient | hello my name is Nicholas yurti and this message is for the San Jose State University student awards and scholarship committee I have just learned that I have received the special session scholarship for new students and I cannot be more grateful to you thank you so much for for this for the the trust that you've placed in me and my abilities by by giving me this I I promise you that you will not regret this and I'm going to do great things both at sjsu and in the future okay yeah I I had a plan for how I was going to to get graduate school paid for and I was confident that I was going to be able to pull that off but this has changed everything for for the better um seeds before they're so much better um this is going to not only make my my time at the school that much easier but it's going to open up opportunities for me that much sooner once once I graduate so from the from the bottom of my heart thank you so much for for your kindness and I'm going to pay it forward | SJSU School of Information | UCtGthCqkWXZsbQbvfK_FHNQ | 2023-02-25 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 199 | 983 |
SljIxHsRc0A | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SljIxHsRc0A | Jonicide 52 Birthday Bash | hi everybody this is your stay-at-home grandma and it is john's birthday so everybody wants to come on and wish him a happy birthday um and john i'm not joey at all but i'm gonna do my best to entertain you uh and i'm not gonna sing happy birthday i'd like you to like me okay i lost my voice during the stroke epidemic trying to get comfortable here so it's his 52nd birthday and let's see when he gets on let's see who else comes on i'm just sitting here i'm cold this is not right because it's cold out there and then we're supposed to have thunderstorms the thunderstorms i got and we could use the rain i guess but i don't know but anyway and then as soon as it gets held up become clean and then i'm hot or even though i have air conditioner everywhere but um so i'll tell you while waiting for people to come on that um i was going to take a nap because you know like i said around eight o'clock i turn into a pumpkin hey john look at me i'm a little tiny i know i know i'm not joey but happy birthday thank you i mean you've been supporting me since day one when we lost them i got to support you and would you please do me a favor and um email me your um out okay i can do that okay all right i'll put my email down and it's in here in the chat because i don't know whether you know it or not um i seek i see it yahoo or is that i see this screen thing going by yeah there's a couple of them here i just emailed it i mean i just um wrote it in the in the chat so okay well overnight if someone can do that so happy birthday thank you so you are now 52. so i realized that you and joe were are actually were actually the same age because he would have been 52 yeah but anyway just a couple months older than me yeah so did you have a good day today did you work today no i took the day off from work yeah i actually got off at half hour early yesterday which never happens he actually tells me my boss told me to do something i'm like all right well i ain't getting out here to like four which is a half hour past when i'm supposed to and then i go all right let me go to the bathroom and i'll come out head out and do that and i come up change of plans go do this okay and i'm like i'm gonna get done like an hour early so i went and did that really quick and then it came back and he says go do that then just take the car go home okay so yeah and me and renee went out for breakfast and then we went and did a little shopping i bought a little bit of some mead there's a local meadery in my town which i didn't know about a couple weeks ago so one of the stores in town has it so i went there and i got a fig mead um i'm not sure my drink a little bit later i'm not sure there was that uh i think it was a saffron and i'm like i don't i'll try the fig i don't want to try the saffron i don't know so i did that and then what by the way was what was the fig in the saffron i don't know it was just it was a saffron flavored meat that's what it said oh okay all right saffron well i've cooked with saffron and i think it's pretty good that the i don't i really can't tell you how the taste is but it's good you know what i mean the fig i think are good if it's fig with black tea and brown sugar is what they used to make it so it means made with honey so they add bread so i'm like that actually doesn't sound bad so let's give that a taste nice like if i don't like it i have friends that'll drink it and if i do like it well i'll drink it okay all right hey moms if you want to come up and tell them jonas said happy birthday um it's in the chat but i'll put it back on again i talked to bg's today out in australia i told her we were doing this hoping she shows up but i don't know what the time difference is for her it might be a crazy time for us she's just in the uk right she's in australia she's an adolescent oh okay yeah so i'm not sure you know and then i know jilly knows about it but she's been she's still struggling with her health you know you know yeah so hopefully she'll show up but if she doesn't she doesn't and i was on the ground i was watching the grannies earlier but really um i was eating breakfast while they were on so i kind of like maggie and um and robin are together there was uh robin and uh corey maggie maggie's still taking some time yeah they have to get just them just shooting the [ __ ] so i was in their chat for a little bit but you know i was also running around doing stuff at the same time yeah and other than that you know my uh my what my foster kid got me a uh apron my why renee bought me a nice bag with odin on it um i don't know that you know i'm just happy to have a day off yeah yeah you're always working uh yeah we're short staffed and i'm i'm lucky that i can work and still do some youtube stuff i can't always do youtube stuff but because i'm out in the field i'm out doing stuff so i uh i can watch youtube and listen and sometimes i can chat depending on what i'm doing you know i get breaks so i take my breaks and like i'll be in a chat like i'd read bosco's you're like you know you didn't do much today and i'm like i got stuck in a youtube chat he's like come on he's supposed to be working i'm like yeah well i didn't warn anybody else he's like that's true he he i get away with so much because when he asks me to do something i do it and like he goes that's the one thing he's taking next tuesday off he has to take a personal day and he goes i'm counting on you i've already i've already figured out what i want you to do and i'm like tell me what needs to be done i'll i'll get it done if i can if i can't i ran out of time he's like i'm not worried about it but he worries about everybody else he even tells me he's like can you talk to this guy like oh you know okay we have a short timer only works one day a week can you give him a little hint that he still works here like because he works one day a week so he's checked out but you know hey you really still do your job he's like i know i had a bad day okay don't have another one though the guy won't like or quit you know you can that is an option it's like i don't want to quit i like doing this okay well well then if you like doing it do it yeah but yeah he wanted to get um he was part-time well he was 30 hours a week and he went to amazon's delivery driver now he gets over 40 someday of some weeks and then some weeks they just tell him well we don't have a route and he'll just come down pick up like a half a half a shift six hour shift with us as we've all we're short staffed we've got three full time and we need six full time so i think everybody is short staffed it seems like it my friends down the street from me they have um a restaurant you know because we're we're on the water so it's called crabbies and um my my um caregiver's daughter works there and um she says she's one of the managers in the kitchen and she said that it's it's hard keeping help now yeah because there's so everybody can go out again there's a mcdonald's that's completely always hiring and i don't go to mcdonald's but i drive by and they're always hiring so i was talking to somebody and they like they have a fast turnaround because if someone that gets hired that's younger has any kind of conflict or whatever all of a sudden just go oh well you know i'll go work for jack in the box they're hired you know and they've had people that have jumped around in a year that have gone from like mcdonald's burger king jack of the box taco bell back to mcdonald's they got hired back are you going to quit the way you did last time no but they hire because they need the people but then again you like you know my my granddaughter just graduated from college now she's just got she just got her job and stuff like that but she works for amazon and she is a driver for um what is it not instacart the other one she she delivers food okay so she can pick up shifts and she can work all day okay so a lot of them go to things where they can come and they can kind of go as they please i'm doing fine how you doing mobs mom you can come up if you want him and now you can come up too somebody got to see him right there i can't sing every day [Applause] i cannot sing okay a friend of mine just turned like 55 and we were talking about it and uh her uh partner was mad that she didn't get any you know they're gonna go out for dinner and you didn't get any presents you didn't get anything and i'm like did you want presents is there something you want you weren't gonna buy for yourself but she goes no i mean it's nice to get surprised she's like but you know what i like this that's what i like too on facebook people took time out of their day just to wish me a happy birthday that means more to me than you know people i see you know in real life people i've never met wishing manhattan that's that's true i had to do that tonight because like i said from day one since joe since you know joey's you know lost everybody has been there for me you know what i mean so i had to do that for you i know i'm not joey i wish i was because apparently uh he had a really charismatic personality he did i mean i knew he he always had a personality he was always so much fun but the people that he knew i just you know i just didn't really know about it i was talking i've talked to my friends about this i go a man i never met in the real world only knew him from his youtube show then being on his youtube channel affected me more than a guy i knew 15 years that passed away i mean it's just i go and i can't explain it i i go it was it was just his personality who he was he saw through people so fast and he saw people i just think he knew when someone was decent we bonded over the fact we're the same age and he would just make movie references and i would in cartoon and comic book and i mean i'm not the biggest comic book guy but i know enough that i keep the conversation going but i got the references i got all well i got 90 of the movie references and about 75 of the music references because we did listen to different styles of music growing up but we both watched mtv growing up so anything he said that i'd do with mtv he didn't make i tell like i told my kids this i was a metal hat i listen to heavy metal but i watched mtv and you watched everything on mtv and yeah yeah you you you it didn't matter it's like same with like movies he's like how do you know you know how to get you sucker i'm like yeah at first it was a funny movie but it was on cable we watched everything it didn't matter what it was it was i haven't seen this let's watch this if it's funny you watched it several times if it was good you watched it several times yeah we used to go to the movies like every tuesday when he was like when he was you know up until he was about maybe 14 and they used to have a tuesday where it was a dollar night and we would go to every movie and every tuesday and then it was funny because at one particular time i think we had seen every movie out before they could get you know but it was something that he like we like to do and to be perfectly honest with you i didn't have any idea what the star wars star wars movies were at first but then i started getting into him so you know that was his thing but and people would say why do you if we could you're a teacher why do you let him read comic books i said because he's reading but he read everything but you know people always have to question what they see but he i would give him books and he would read them and then we would talk about them my mom i mean i i'm dyslexic so i had a really hard time learning to read really hard i didn't want to learn to read i couldn't read i'd seen words i don't see letters backwards i see words out of place so i have to double check my chat sometimes i haven't done it in a while but every now and then instead of saying like the red house i write the house red you know i just things like that and i reverse numbers a little bit sometimes but when i got to read my mom i remember she bought me a book and there's like 25 30 books of the series now 40 years later and i still but she got me to read and me and my mom we didn't read the same things but she always she go to the store she'd come back i got you a book and i'm like okay a book of fantasies books about wolves if anything that i could do to read she was all about and i'm i don't read as much now but i listen to audible almost every day we'll see the thing is yeah the thing the trick is with children is school is already made mapped out for them so at home when you get something for them to read take a look at what they're interested in and then give them that so he liked comic books and he liked you know star wars books and you know astro you know different different kinds of books and stuff like that so he'll be saying like what are you reading and i would tell me something when you're finished give it to me so he would you know if it interests him i would give it to him you know so so anyway you know i mean i just am amazed and i mean i'm still hearing from people you know so you know i mean you know it was a good ride with him it really was why does he think it's um we're going to feel this for years i mean there's just going to be years that and um the weirdest thing happened to me yesterday i actually almost called jill while it was happening but i was driving and i don't have her programmed into my speed dial yet um the theme song for paranormal hood came on well it showed up like it's supposed to play but it didn't play and i was like i haven't heard the song in a very long time when it comes on my spotify for a while i've i've been skipping it because i just can't listen to it and it came up and it's near my birthday and i'm like oh i really want to hear this song now and i start turning the radio up so everybody else can hear the song it didn't play though i'm like and i just out loud go are you messing with me are you messing you're messing with me you know it's not my birth you're messing with me i want to hear the song just play the song and i'm in traffic and i pick up my phone to see if it's maybe it's pause it's loading a lot of signals something nope nothing i'm like all right you're messing with me and i skipped the song went to the next song and that song started to play then i went back to it are you going to play it now and it started and i'm like i knew you were messing with me you could say whatever you want to me joey was telling me happy birthday oh i have my little conversations with him when i'm out in the garden you know for some reason of other because when he used to come here now we had gardens when he when we were when they were little my daughter just didn't start gardening until about the last two or three years but he would always come out and he would just sit there and drink his drink and whatever and hand me the shovel and what's that and you know and everything like that you know he didn't really participate in it but he always kept me company and so i've been out in the garden pretty much every day except today and you know he would go out and sit out in the garden and he's been sitting out there with me you know so yeah we're not gonna get ready ever get over it i don't think so now this it's like my parents my parents died two years apart um within two years my mom and dad died and a friend of mine's mom died about two years ago and he was devastated and i just reached out to him and said hey man i know it's hard but it does get better he goes does it really get better and i said no it doesn't but you get used to it i go and if you need to talk i'm here and in the last two years i've talked to maybe three times and i see him now um when i'm working i run into him every now and then and he's like you know you're the only one that reached out to me because i was just you know like you know why can't he why is no one reaching out to me you know i mean i'm hurting and everyone's talking about they've lost people doing and i was like he's the only one i'm like well i hate to tell you this but some people don't know how to deal with their grief it's a hard thing to deal with you know and that's why i think that you know every two weeks we're gonna have this little chat on how we feel because nobody really talks to to how they feel because nobody really really wants to listen and you know as a school council and stuff like that you know you get a lot of a lot of grief and i've also trained as a grief counsel as well but you get a lot of grief and stuff like that and you have to talk to it and you don't always have to go to a therapist you know what i mean so you know having said that you know i just decided that you know and i wasn't going to do it every week because i think that after a while it becomes repetitious so if we do it a couple of times a month the first of the month and then oh i changed this wednesday to next wednesday so yeah you know so we'll be good to just talking about it and getting it off our chest because it's something especially when you lose parents or a child okay that weighs heavily on you because you always think that your parents are invincible that they're always going to be and when they're suddenly not you're like what the hell you know what i mean how did happen when my dad got cancer he had a methyl melanoma i hope i said that right though lung cancer from asbestos and they gave him three years and he lived four and a half after they they told him and i'm just like my my thing with my guilt with him is and i know it's my guilt he wanted ice cream the day before he passed away he thought that it said ice cubes and he thought it said ice cream and had i known this would be the second last time i'd seen my father i would have said hey i'll be right back and i would have ran down to the store to the whatever i had and bought him a little bit of ice cream and um you know i feel guilty i didn't do that but i didn't know and then that's not it's not a fair guilt for me but i still feel it and i'm aware of that how you get over it because you don't yeah you know my mom was different she uh we she was gonna go it was a sunday saturday night she all the kids but the one that's in uh that lives out of state and she called we were there we all came by and saw her most of the grandkids came by and so except the ones that are out of state and we're gonna come in the next day give her a shower and the next day she was gonna go into a home to get um not a home but a rehab center because she got so she had a urinary tract infection that got so bad she was losing muscle tone and she she wasn't any pain she just couldn't figure why she couldn't walk there was no discomfort but then when we took her into the doctor that's what's going on we have to hospitalize you you're you'll get you need to be on iv antibiotics and all this and she was in the hospital a couple days and then we go in that sunday to give her a bath and as i walk towards her room all i hear is that's her family and i and i i swear like so like i just dropped in my head i just i just like oh god something's going on and i didn't have power of attorney which i can't remember the name of a power of attorney i kept saying i'm not in charge i'm not in charge my sister jamie's in charge i'm not in charge and the doctor's just like but you're here what do you want to do and i'm like what's going on she had a heart episode she had a heart attack but they said hard episode do you want to try to give her uh bring her back how long have you been working on her over five minutes i said no it'll be brain damage she doesn't want to be a vegetable we've already had this conversation no he goes okay he goes and then he comes back and he goes okay we shot up with some drugs so she i'm sure she's still here and i'm like you just like start to feel relief he goes but once the drugs were off she's gonna go what do you want us to do i'll let her go then and i had to tell my my family and the nice thing about my family i have three sisters and a brother none of them said i made the wrong decision hold on one second hi angel how are you thank you for coming into this is jonah side and it's his birthday and he helped me through the whole the whole turmoil of my son this is angel she's wonderful you got to go to her channel i'll try to remember that angel if you want to come on i'll put the link in again yeah but that's dealing with my uh yeah my family all the only thing that got me is i told my sister how to pick up my brother from church and i told them text me when you're in the parking lot so let you know what's going on and they texted me in the elevator we're almost to her room and i and my text back she passed we're downstairs because they have a grief room at the hospitals you know and my brother goes you know i'm glad you got us but over a text and i said i told you to text me when you got into the parking lot and i go listen the text text me when you're in the parking lot you text me on the elevator he's like i'm just giving you crap i'm trying to find humor now and yeah there was no humor in that for a while but now we kind of laugh about it because he's just like at least you texted me and i'm like yeah but you know that's how you found it your mom dies there's a text from your brother he's like hey it's better to walk into the room seeing him work on her like that's true that's true so we have we see the humor in it now because it's been 11 years well this year will be 11 years and i can joke about some stuff about it but like with my dad when he passed i swear my dad did not like any tool utility light fixture anything that's still available he bought the last of the ones they stopped making the day after he died i swear to god we couldn't find light bulbs before we had to replace our front porch light we had to replace just a bunch of things because he bought oh they don't make those anymore they haven't made those for like eight years like what i need a light bulb for that well we don't have them because it was a specialty light bulb we don't have it well now i need a new light bulb and it'll do outdoor light which i got put one in it's pretty okay that's just that's the thing [ __ ] about that and lung cancer because my mother never smoked but she had lung cancer and it's funny too because she went to the hospital and they s and they you know operated on her and stuff like that and they said well you better get all your house in order because you only got six months four years later right before um i think it was christmas it was her last holiday with me i do know that so it wasn't christmas it wasn't so easy she was cooking and we were cooking and she started laughing and i said what are you laughing at and she said that's the longest six months i've ever had in my life look you always told me they're not gone so you know hey um and then after that she lived another five or six months and then she died and it she was in a coma and they were going to move her into like another like living facility you know to take care of and stuff like that because i wouldn't let them pull the plug on her and um she was supposed to go that monday that sunday she died so you know i said well she obviously she said she never wanted to go into a home of any sort so yeah my mom was the same way because my grandma her mom spent like three years in the home and i don't remember if she had dementia or alzheimer's or but she she forgot who she was and it was just a really bad i barely remember my grandma i never met my dad's mom she was because they lived across the country and my both my grandfathers i always think it's funny because of age thing both my grandfathers were world war one vets you know and um they died my the one i'm named after died uh about a month before i was born and then my mom's dad died in the 50s i want to say 50 54 or 55 right around there and yeah that's because people are talking about yeah my grandfather was in world war ii as kids and i'm like my grandfather's fought in world war one my mom was 42 when she had me in 1970 and a lot of people like 197 they were like no don't have it you're too old to have a child where now it's it's it's commonplace even to be close to your beard she was at 46 47 she just had her first kid he really wasn't even ryan i guess but they weren't trying they just you know they decided you know for years they were trying nothing happened and they're like okay i guess we're not going to have kids and then you know their daughter got born less than a year ago not even a year old yet and i'm just like how do you feel about that she's like we're ecstatic it's just we're going to be older parents i said yeah well just get used to everything grandpa and grandpa later you know when you start look showing your age because they don't yet well i'll go with no gray don't dye my hair just take after my mom's dad didn't turn he didn't turn gray until his 60s when he had a stroke and then he went gray overnight so i'm like i'm good then because i have a friend that's mad at me because he's a year he's a year actually he's a year younger exactly this day's his birthday and he's going gray his beard's all gray he's just like how come you dye your hair i'm like no i want more gray i look more like a wizard well you'll get it when you get it yeah i'm not worried about it i don't got no vanity about that yeah because my hair is mostly all right so i don't care i'm happy to be alive oh okay oh the dog yeah yep he was always on the jiggy show so yeah he hears me talking he's just like you talking to me they come and get you yeah let me get embarked in it robin i always wanted to do that getting to train him to go when i say robin from start barking but he won't do it yeah then he's ray said his race said he's a cute dog he is a cute dog i remember him because lots of times i would come on say hi to everybody and not just stay there and everything like that and just let it you know play and stuff like that and i'd look on every now and then because i never knew to be perfectly honest with you i never knew what you guys were talking about once or twice you know he hit it where you know i could actually make some comments and stuff like that but that was way over my head so you know that's my mom in the chat he's like ask her ask her anything you want i never lied about it he never did he always said ask guitar help she'll tell you what i'm doing what i've done yeah i know because one day he was actually talking about me when i was on right and i didn't put say hi to him or anything like that because i wanted to hear the whole story and i said oh so now you're talking about me i think you were on there you're talking about me and i'm not here to defend myself and i was it was just really funny but he would you know yeah he's six drops thank you yeah hey oh yeah hey six straps how are you so she was ignoring me robin's if you want to come on six drops it's i'll give it i'll put it again tell him happy birthday if you want to send to him that's fine i'll listen because i'm not singing because i know that he'll disown me never i know you won't but i'm just saying now my voice is it used to be a usable voice now it's just a voice i can talk that's about it i'm happy and this is honey bear she's coming because she heard me talking and she said i'll be giving uh xerxes loving so now she's got to get her loving of course they're just like kids they are oh they are they they are if i take one of the dogs well a thor's foot right here somewhere is our other dog if i take him and not xerxes you can hear xerxes crying all the way to the car really but if i and then i take both of them and then thor just whines because he wanted to be by himself we told them with the other day i took the boy to the bank and uh but took the dogs i wasn't getting out of the car boxing ride with us it's nice to windows down and thor wine the entire time like you wanted because xerxes came along and it's kind of like yeah you know like xerxes gets to go sometimes without and if that takes thor wines and then he actually comes up to me and gives me kisses then he ignores me like okay you're back good now i'm mad at you and he'll ignore me it's so funny yeah see i don't have any animals anymore because when the kids were coming up we had what was known as the webb city zoo we had everything rabbits dogs cats gerbils um hamsters guinea pigs we had everything not all at the same time but i remember like joey had fish and he came home and we brought up this goldfish and i said so what are you gonna name him so he made this song up called goldie and pinky and fanny and greeny and he used to sing it every day to them good morning goldie and pinky and fanny and green and we would die yep i gotta smoke so i i write songs for all my dogs there's little like lyrics i sing to them like honey berries just simply honey bear honey bear oh oh the honey bear honey bear and she just she knows it's her song my dog super fly had a song of course you know it wasn't the superfly i named him after the curtis mayfield song i was really into curtis mayfield for a little bit because his guitar playing that guy's a genius i mean he tuned so weird he put um his guitar he'd be all like every string would be a g and then the b string would be in you know e and he'd write a whole and i'm like how do you i can't figure out how to play it and so i take it to my guitar teacher who's this guy i've known my entire life and pj's like hey he goes yeah you're on your own on this one and i'm like okay he's like everything's in g i'm like yeah i know everything's in g he's like but i think that's e but i don't know i couldn't tell you and i'm like trying you know but i really and i just love that song the movie not so much but the song and the soundtrack was so good that i'm like i'm money my dog's super fly and uh and when i was thinking that the dog got pregnant and so in day two of the pregnant the puppies was my sister's dog i went that one's mine his name's superfly and for 14 years that was my dog superfly i remember that movie and i thought it was the stupidest movie ever okay but joey's father and i were married at the time and um you know he liked all of those movies you know what i mean he was he wasn't even pimp material but he liked him you know he was he was a straight lace kind of guy but um he would go to all the movies and everything anything that uh i can't think of but ron i i forgot where all the people's names were and everything like that but now now james bond movies i liked yeah yeah i like that but no none of the pep movies we grew up it was um it wasn't every week but like on the weekends as kids would always hit a movie it seemed like especially in grade school to junior high and then in high school if a movie came on we wanted to see we would go and see it you know and then what i always thought was funny in my 20s is when i go see movies more than once in the theater you know if i really liked the movie we go see that there we already saw this now let's go see it again okay which i always thought was funny that we did that those before online stuff you know and before stuff was on cable you know the vhs would be a year or year and a half out of course in my 30s my uh my neighbor who was in high school and he's one of my best friends now in fact he just turned 37 a couple months ago he has one of his best friends got a job at the movie theater and i'm like just talking to him i go so uh how do i get a free movie he's like we'll come into the last show and i'll get you in for free i'm like okay so i'd show up on a friday or saturday night you know text him hey um i'm outside yeah come on in stop walking he's like this is my guy this is my pass for the day or whatever and i'd go on key movies for free for i mean i saw everything back in like 2002 to 2003 every like every week i was in the movie theater really yeah i saw i mean i saw bad movies good movies it didn't even matter you just i was going to see something that's also when i got i got drugs on television so that was it was escaped from that more than anything i have fire sticks so i i could just about see anything ray of sunshine she said she can't have any animals because her son has allergies but i was going to tell you right if you can stand it getting one of those hairless cats or dogs they're ugly i don't know whether you have a friend that has the the sphinx cats there's also hypoallergenic cats uh russian blues are hypoallergenic so they don't have uh the dandruff i don't know there's i think it's somewhat i can't remember i want to say it's a labradoodle but it's a mixed dog but for some reason it's it's hypoallergenic yeah it doesn't have to be have human some human-like hair yeah yeah but yeah the russians won't get because i remember some of my songs like just dogs like i'm allergic to cats and they will get a russian blue because you could they they don't have the dandruff they're hyper i'm like both of them now because of the stroke and stuff like that but then so is one of my granddaughters she's allergic to dogs cats and everything but they have a rabbit so she's not allergic to rabbit hair so but i was just saying you know you could get those those um hairless cats and dogs but they're so ugly though oh god oh crush they're the hairless dogs really one breed of the hairless dog yeah and then the sphinx cats yeah my friends got springs cats and they the point problem with them is they have heart murmurs so she had one after eight years it just one day it just laid down and she goes she washed it a breath struggled with the breath took one more breath and that was it and [ __ ] yes though well that's horrible yeah so that's that's the only thing about the sphinx cats and and they are weird looking though because they have no hair yeah i like her i like her cuz their cats are awesome you know they come up and say that it's like they knew i was allergic to cats when they come up with friends on facebook and she bought one of those hairless cats and then she showed it and i'm like oh god i couldn't even go to sleep with something like that in the house i mean you know i really couldn't i mean like skinny would jump up in the bed or something and look at me and i'd be like half asleep and and and if joey was alive he would tell you when i'm half asleep i see all kinds of things okay you know what i mean and so i would probably think it was some kind of monster from outer space or something i don't know i just yeah can't be saying happy birthday to you i can't be thank you just went to vegas with her husband they had a blast to look like i love vegas i think this is fun i've only been there once but i really liked it when i went in 2007. twice my aunt used to live before she passed she was known as the rose lady of rose queen rose lady of vegas she won all the rose she grew roses in her garden she went all these rows um yeah she was there's a bunch of paper stuff like there's like she's in the paper several times um and then and then she knew everybody like the old school she always talked about wayne newton was the nicest guy she ever met and uh her husband at the time worked at the one of the last mob dome casinos and i always thought that was funny um i forgot what name of the casino was the imperial it was the last mo medulla casino before the corporations took over which you know a different kind of mob with corporations and nothing but anatomic mob responses anyway yep i don't know i might go back i don't know first of all i got to be able to travel yeah yeah i'm kind of like we're traveling right now i live in life that was four-hour drive camera news like i'm from l.a it was a four-hour drive for us hey carol thank you again i'm gonna go to um to england yeah carol how are you doing carol wait what's second john carroll you a pizza type of situation you know those little pizza the ones and you want to know how i know that huh okay you'll answer me in a minute um i am i want to go to england and uh yeah i think it's um jimmy i want to visit jimmy yeah because he was supposed to get together go to the castle and all this other kind of stuff so i really would like to be able to travel one more time to my to my mother's home well my grandfather's home portugal and then i would like to go to england so yeah jimmy and sarah and micah and then go up and meet up with maggie and uh there's a couple other people i know that uh stevie i don't know if he's been here but he's been in joey's chat a couple times he's a little more aloof um but he's a real nice guy i like to see him then if i go to eat like i gotta go to ireland gotta go to scotland um i'd love to go to portugal and spain i think that would be really cool because i don't know too much about those countries as far as the histories of the architecture other than what i see i don't know anything about spain but i do know i know a little bit about portugal because my grandfather my grandfather and grandmother came from my mother's mother and so my mother has been back and when i was kid we went back a couple of times and stuff like that and then my grandfather came here okay and um well he was here he was back and forth for a while from what i understand i don't know but he came here and um started a little farm so what are you doing making weird noises like what's he doing it's um the pizza um rat that's wood carol um and you're wondering why i knew that i heard on um aaliyah's deals that you had asked for it because i think i have two of them i think i have to probably show them to you over the um i'll have to go up and show them to you sometime when we're on i'll let you see you but yeah yeah that's where i want to go i can't even really tell you about the architect in portugal because i was a kid yeah i wasn't kidding with the washington dc and i couldn't tell you anything other than it was a boring trip and i was bored the entire time yeah well the first time i went i was a kid but then i went when i was an adult you know i took my class with me and stuff like that and then i went to the vietnam wall because i lost a lot of people in the vietnam wall so i've got a cousin that's on that wall but right now i can't think of his name but i i know it i just have to remember it but then i remember seeing oh they remember it's the lincoln memorial but it looked as a kid it was huge and then seeing pictures and people standing in front of it it's not as big as i remember but i want to go back to see but other than that ice remember i was bored thank you ray i like that smith's going to be awesome gotta go to the estonian i've been in the smithsonian i when i was working with the kids i used to you know we used to take them on trips and stuff like that you know when i was a teacher and um i used to work for upward bound in the summertime and so we went to the smithsonian two or three times back my my middle granddaughter i took her with me and stuff so you know i've been a lot of little play i've been more america than outside america you know i've been to jamaica and bermuda and a couple of other places but i've been more in america visiting america than outside america and that's really what i wanted to do but i do i i would i would love to go to you to to europe yeah europe would be cool australia of course um yeah i like to go like i want to go to easter island okay i want to see those big heads you know those big statues and i want to go down to machu picchu in peru and uh in honduras and costa ricans and mexico and see all those pyramids that are there other than egypt too to see those pyramids and you know and then uh okay carol thank you for stopping by and wishing him happy birthday hey thank you carol you have a good day give that puppy love i know you've got one left give him a lot of love i don't wait a minute don't be blaming that on me all i did was make a statement that you need everybody needs to go on elia's deals okay you did that yourself don't try to blame me but yeah well i'm gonna get ready to go to bed you know i turned into a pumpkin i was farming okay i'm here it's not even five o'clock yet so i'm okay it was about five o'clock yet yeah it's only 4 43 here oh where are you at i'm near seattle oh okay all right yeah all right i'm on the best coast we'll see it's 7 43 here and then it becomes 8 o'clock and then you know i have to go through a whole ritual i have to go clean up my kitchen you know in fact you know he's cooking right now so i'll probably take my shower and stuff and then clean out my kitchen because i can't go i i dream of dirty dishes in the sink they attacked me so i have to clean my kitchen yeah well i dreamed work last week uh i kept waking up dreaming i was working like no i don't get up wake up get up walk around have some water pet the dogs you know go back lay back down right back into the same dream all night and i was like no i woke up tired and then i had a bad day at work because of it it was just like why i'm going to work why don't i dreaming about it i wonder about cool things i don't even know what i dream you know and when i do actually know what i dream it usually has to do with something or someone in the family well i have a i dream in color i have vivid dreams and every now and then before the pandemic i used to lucid dream all the time this is a pandemic i can't do it now i think it's you know i don't know what's going on with that i fixed my anxiety with a pandemic but probably so i think everybody's got anxiety with the pandemic hence all the daggone killings and stuff that are going on for no reason we have a mental health problem in this country and no one wants to recognize it nobody wants to recognize it we really really do it thank you for doing this i very much appreciate it i'm sorry that i i'm you know like because joey would have this all nighter and stuff like we'd be going for we'd be going to midnight my time he could keep us going all you know all night yeah see he was that kind of an entertaining kind of guy you know what i mean yeah um like i said i get uh i wake up at about 5 30 in the morning i don't get out i get up about seven but i'm awake at 5 30. so and it's been like that forever because i used to go to work and i used to have i used to be at work i didn't have to be there till i got there but you know because i had appointments all scheduled well when i taught i had to be there but then when i was working as a counselor you know i would just be there and you know do what i have to do and um i would always be there with about seven seven thirty with me for work and then days like on um sundays and mondays are my days off i try to sleep till seven that's my goal and i'm up at five i just go back to bed and i'm up at six i wake up at 6 30 and it's like all right you're up you know might as well start your day um bray said that the day before the colonoscopy she had a vivid dream about eating a sandwich it was so sure she was so sure that she cheated on the fast yeah you gotta yeah my husband just had one i had one a few years ago renee's had him they found polyps on her first one so she has to go every couple years now yeah yeah see hey that's why you had that dream because you know you couldn't eat and you were fasting and stuff like that and yeah i got lucky when i had mine because i was in the hospital anyway so they just said well we wanna just go ahead and give her the whole gambit so it you know i mean i really didn't care but my husband just had his last week i think it was sometime last week or the maybe the the end of the end part of the week before that but it was real close but anyway that poor man that one minute i tried not to make anything that you know gave out odor or anything like that so i made sandwiches and stuff you know so that he wouldn't yeah i just felt so bad for him because especially you know because he he likes food you know when he he's he doesn't gain any weight i can't stand him okay but i'm just saying he doesn't gain any weight or anything like that but he likes food and he likes my cooking and he likes his own cooking and you know um he just couldn't eat that day and he was like miserable just miserable so i said just go to bed early and stuff like that but then you can't go to bed because you have to get up and go to the bathroom yeah so i don't know you know but anyway he's fine so that was good you know stuff like that so that's good today and and today was like really funny because everybody in the world called me today but i did get all my appointments straightened out and stuff like that so i'm good yeah i've gotten recipes but you know it's my birthday my brother called me i hadn't hadn't talked to him in a couple weeks i was like oh they could catch up with them yeah i think that's good you're going to catch up with people and stuff like that um because tomorrow is definitely not promised to you you know so i'm um i'm just amazed that you know i think i think with all of the sad things that are going on in the world there's a lot of good things going on too though i think that people who really have hole to themselves are really trying to reach out and more and stuff like that even like you know people that i haven't heard from in my family before joey you know um started like reaching out and calling and things like that making sure that you know i was all right because i'm the no i'm not the furthest away because i have relatives in california and stuff now but i'm one of the furthest away from a lot of my family you know so i'm lucky most of my family's still around in the area you know everyone's within probably an hour maybe an hour and a half drive at the furthest and then uh i have a sister that lives in kansas and her family's a little more spread out one of my nieces lives i want to say kentucky but it might be tennessee i get him confused i do i don't know which one she lives in she doesn't want to one or the other and then the other one one of my sisters my nieces excuse me one of my nieces uh lives in the same town as my sister and then everyone lives uh about two hours away and she's the one that comes up and visits she goes she travels she comes up she was an engineer i was bowing then they split from boeing but she's now she's in um human resources because she could she goes i just couldn't take the engineering anymore it was nothing but stress we had all these deadlines and we can impossible tasks and so she went and she went back to college uh they paid for it got a degree in whatever the human resource degree is i can't remember off top my head and she's in human resources now and she loves it she feels she's making a contribution to her job instead of being you know like it's just it was like you get an impossible task this has to be done in two weeks and six weeks later they finish it it's perfect but they're all mad that well it's a month overdue yeah but you told two weeks it's gonna take six we told you that the beginning yeah so i could never do a job like that was with you i wanted to be a chef but my mother said no way so i wanted to be an fbi agent when i was in high school really yeah i i was thinking about it you know and then i joined the army to go in to go i'll go the army i got the gi bill when i'm in the army i'll take some classes for criminal i'll learn to speak spanish and all these plans and i blew my knee out in the army and they kicked me out before i was in six months i wasn't for four i was just i was the day i went into ait which is i was infantry so your basic and what they call i have to use advantage training is all the same thing i hit a curve right on my knee i heard a pop and i you know can't walk you know can't run can't do anything you're out because they didn't want to do the surgery and they didn't need surgery nothing was torn but i i cracked my uh i missed a piece of my kneecap we don't know what happened to it and my legs swelled up but like six months later my leg was you know not fine but better and now it's fine you know it's been that's been 30 years now 32 years actually and yeah when that happened i i mean i'm i got a job as a cook fortunately i got you know became a bartender got into drugs but you know living the best life i can now yeah story yeah i didn't have a backup upon it and i needed a backup plan yeah that was my pride i told you like you know you have a backup plan it's your dream but have a backup plan because things happen that you can't control yeah that's true but like i said i i wanted to be a chef you know and my mother said no you're not gonna be a chef and i'm like okay so then i pick teaching but then i was glad that i actually picked teaching because when everybody started to get on my nerves we had vacation and it was the only place and then like i said i studied on and became a therapist and i became a school counselor but it was the only place where you could act at one particular time you know the banks closed at three o'clock and it was the only place the only job that i know of that i could actually make the bank yeah i had a friend that was funny because he was uh he kept saying in high school i'm gonna become a teacher i'm gonna become a teacher and i don't see him and then i run into him like what do you do i'm a teacher i'm like because he wanted the summers off he was just like yeah summer's off and i'm like how does that work out for you goes yeah you know summer's off he had no i'm going to school in the summer because there's something now i knew i got to learn and he's like i had my first summer off and every summer since then i'm going to school or teaching um summer school or doing something to make my get my job to get the bonuses to get the things but he's like he loved that he did for like 12 years but i never really worked the whole when my kids were little i didn't work in the summertime and stuff like that unless i work in the summer camp so they could go but i'll tell you what okay that was the only thing that got on my nerves because i was off the same time the kids were off that was a pain in the butt until i remember until i remembered camp because my mother sent me to camp now i know why so then i said let's try to send my kids to camp so at least for two weeks and then when their father and i divorced of course they would spend two weeks in camp and then right after the fourth of july and then they would go directly to one week with me again and then they would go to their father for the rest of the summer so that was really good because um that was kind of um a pain in the butt in the summertime because you had to think of things to do with them yeah you know what i mean so when they got old enough to camp i had i signed them up real fast that's what i liked about summer students my parents worked so it was like we ran with somebody i don't know i confirmed this was a different time we knew what we could get away with and what we couldn't you know some of it was trial and error some of it was common sense like nah this isn't going to work we're going to get in trouble if we do this and the other kids i ran with were really troublemakers i mean we were we were you know we were kids or teenage boys so yeah we're troublemakers but we didn't go looking for trouble with the police trouble with this we never break we did do yeah we smoked pot we drank beer but we didn't go out of our way to cause trouble for anybody else hey jilly beans hey jilly how are you doing nah well in my generation until i was a teenager we just played baseball and all this other kind of stuff and you know did all kinds of things and we went to outdoor camp you know because i we i was raised in the city so but then when i went away i always go for two weeks to stay with my grandfather and then you know my aunts things like that they all live down in connecticut and down the cape but for the most part i was a city girl and i used to just you know go to the library and they had this like i i guess it's like i have a reading or something within the library and i used to sit out there and read and stuff like that so i kind of stayed out of trouble because i was into art and things like that so i was not one of the real cool kids i was what's known in the business as a nerd yeah i always think that's funny because i was a like a long-haired metal head but i played d and d i hung out with the kids that played d and d i also played in a band um i i talked with the friends that were jocks i i got along with everybody the thing i always thought was funny was um i remember the jocks were picking on this kid because he was wearing a dress this is back in the 80s when you really you know you didn't do that you got beat up for doing and they beat them up and i'm like why'd you beat him up because he was wearing a dress like i'm scottish i'll wear kilts you're going to beat me up and i remember like in high school picking up the table and dropping on their lunches being like come on who's going to take me on three of you beat up this little kid you're all 17 18 years old he's like 14 and you beat him up but i'm standing in front of you same age same size and you're going to sit there like cowards you know and i got a lot of respect for doing that because it's so exciting to me it just pissed me off that that not that you were bullying because everyone gets bullied everyone does bully as a kid you know i mean it's just how we are as kids how we learn but it pissed me off that i was trying to get a kilt at the time and my mom was like well i can make you one i'm like can you make me one like this and she's like me she never made it because my dad told her i wasn't wearing a kilt and i've got him now but i actually lost too much weight and i can't wear them but uh i i wanted to wear a kilt like that i mean i was i was told growing up i was scottish i found out later that i'm i'm you know a bro i call myself a celtic viking i'm percent uh the outtake islands forty percent scandinavian and then ten percent everything else you know down the uh up into caucasian mountains down to turkey in armenia one percent pacific islander two which i have like okay i have no idea where that comes from but it's only one percent which just trips me out how do they know that you know how far back does that go that i i don't really know you know what i mean i don't really know i just know what my mother told me and i mean i know what my father is because he came from mississippi so you know but um you know he's and he's um chata and he's black black american so but my mother is portuguese but when my girlfriend years ago um she was studying she was studying you know to be a doctor and she had to do the dna testing and all that so she said can i usually was a guinea pig i said why not so um yeah gilly jilly being i know that first time that you dropped that kid off with your friends and you just feel like i need to be there i know what you're feeling but you know so she did my dna and when we discovered that i know using portuguese but then i had irish in me and um some french and some kind of um i don't know there was brazil i don't know now i gotta go pull those papers out but i'm like oh damn i didn't know all that yeah it's weird when they break it like the the first one i got was real simple your british isles scandinavian and then it was like one percent and it was uh caucasian mountains um turkish armenian and then one percent pacific islander then it breaks up to where i'm like 15 british 12 scottish 8 welch whatever's left of that 50s irish and then it went three percent two percent all along the scandinavian coast and then it went even into britain or into um norway not norway uh denmark netherlands belgium and then into france and then it goes then it went like the one percent everything became like a little bit of germany a little more german um then then the i lost the turkey in armenia disappeared on that one but i was still one percent pacific islander which i just like okay again i don't i don't know how it works i was always told though growing up that i was cherokee that you're part cherokee you're like one six tooth cherokee i'm not cherokee at all i got no native american blood which i always thought i always felt guilty because i never felt a connection to the native american culture until i found out i wasn't and then i felt a connection to it yeah more respect for it more maybe that might be the better word i'm part charter well that's on my dad's side so he's i know what tribe his he his family came from and i know my grandmother you know my grandmother and my grand my grandfather was the indian on my father's side so and actually my great-grandmother was a child of a slave she was emancipated at 13 i believe either 12 or 13 because you know they didn't know much about age then and when they were leaving okay and they were just you know out of slavery and stuff like that you know the carpet baggers used to come after them and so the indians hid them so my mother my grandmother at the time was this really pretty girl and stuff like that and she married the chief's son from what i understand and um he tried to live off the reservation but then he went back and so you know my father used to visit him from time to time you know he somehow or other they had their own way of visitation rights and stuff like that but then my father left mississippi and went into the coast guard he went into the navy first and then he went into the coast guard after i don't know when all this so happened because when my parents got married my mother was like 30 when she had me 31 32 so you know my father was a little bit he was about five years older than my mother so but i do have his um papers from the coast guard and i just never i never really like you know i could probably just sort it all out and stuff like that i really don't give a damn i mean you know he was my father that's all i knew and that's all i cared about yeah well my dad was actually 10 years younger than my mom really yeah my mom but my dad met my mom i want to say he was 28 27 20 and she was 37 she's twice divorced and she had uh four kids but the my three oldest siblings were with their dad because um when they got divorced i can't remember where they were living but she wanted to move and the kids didn't want to leave the high school well the two older girls didn't want me to high school my brother he kind of wanted to go with his mom but he also wanted to stay with his sisters and so they all stayed and they were in west seattle and then my mom moved back over to bremerton and then um and then married another man and had my my next sister and then they got divorced and then she was i think my sister was three years old when my dad came into her life and then they tried having me for a bunch of years then gave up and then in 70 boom here i come like surprise but when you gave up yeah but you know i mean it's it's it's fun and kind of funny um so you portrait you got portuguese in you too huh jelly bean huh i think portuguese and something else i don't remember yeah she's listening to what we talked about with joey we talked all this stuff with josh it's just like being with joey we talked about all this yeah and it's funny because i speak about as much portuguese i speak more spanish than i do portuguese because i'm not around my family i've been around my family like that for years the last family reunion we had was like in 2000 2007 when i went to las vegas and i came back in time for the family reunion okay we haven't had five years i think it is every three years but i haven't been invited the last 10 or 15 i can't remember the last time i was invited i think they forgot i'm up here because my dad died i really do oh you know i don't know i i really i mean i haven't i haven't been to connecticut since before coving okay but um and i think two years before that because i don't really i had the the stroke like 10 years ago so i'm just really getting into feeling much much better so you know because the first two years i couldn't even travel you know so but you know well you know it's about that time for me because you know i'm turning into a pumpkin and i don't want to be i know that there was a person i don't know there was a male or a female that used to fall asleep on joey's channel mari yeah i've come close because you know um i take the i partake of the marijuana and sometimes they'd like are you asleep i'm like nope just high my eyes will get really low and i remember one time i was like but i'll let you go again thank you for this appreciate it so much i appreciate all of you thank everybody for coming too it was really nice don't forget to email me when i ask you to email me i will all right okay all right well i'm gonna as in the infamous words of reyes sunshine i'm gonna go love my pillow yep well i have i have a ritual i gotta go clean the kitchen cause he's cooked and everything like that so i gotta go clean the kitchen up and everything like i can't go to bed without cleaning that kitchen you don't know the dishes become so big and ominous okay and then they come and they wake me up you know and things like that so i can't but anyway everybody i love you all thank you all for coming everybody thanks for the blueprint and um i will see you in a couple of days i guess okay well i gotta come on tomorrow anyway so i'll see you then good night everybody i love you stay safe god bless hold your families close okay and take care bye bye see you in the next video good night everybody thank you for coming ray | Donia's Stroke Talk, Diy's, Cooking & Reviews. | UCztOQjGdUnKzKNlijRNp5rQ | 2022-06-23 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 12,952 | 61,944 |
MBBS12lLAVc | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MBBS12lLAVc | The Narcissist Has To See You | [Music] [Applause] [Music] the narcissist has to see you narcissists are spectators they enjoy watching and making observations they are voyeuristic [Music] they derive enjoyment from seeing your pain and distress and making sexual pleasure from watching you when you are naked or engaged in sexual activity many narcissists may suffer from voyeuristic disorder where they feel compelled to see you [Music] especially in situations where you cannot see them although in some situations they may want you to see them and this may further gratify them [Music] narcissists need people need a physical body and an active mind [Music] something that they can play with [Music] something that they can use to obtain supply they cannot function without you [Music] they have to see you with their own eyes [Music] it's not enough for them to talk to you on the phone or even through facetime or video call they have to see you in person they have to see your physical body everything they do is in reaction to you [Music] rather than something coming from within themselves they take all of their cues from you [Music] anything you say do or experience could serve as a signal for them to begin their performance it indicates how they might need to behave in particular circumstances and that is how they always know what they need to do next by seeing you and making observations when the narcissist sees you in person they can observe your body language they can observe your conscious and unconscious movements and postures by which attitudes and feelings are communicated this may include facial expressions body posture gestures eye movement touch and the use of space this is a very satisfying experience for the narcissist and it allows them to gauge where you are in the mind [Music] which will then determine what they are going to do next [Music] narcissists can become very frustrated if they don't get to see you it makes them anxious it irritates them they may become very angry and say or do things to hurt you [Music] or they will stalk you covertly [Music] because they just have to know what you're thinking they have to know where you are and what you're doing they have to trap you in their web because that's where they can gain power and control over you that's where they can influence and direct your behavior at the course of events [Music] if they cannot see you they lose their power over you they lose their ability to control you [Music] because they don't know what's going on in your mind [Music] they don't know what you're going to do next sometimes you may catch or feel the narcissist is watching you you can feel that eyes on you and you may be doing something as simple as eating or watching tv [Music] but you just know that they're closely observing you [Music] they're studying your every move studying your behavior [Music] they are looking for micro expressions and emotional responses they are trying to explain the meaning of your actions or certain information they are constantly in this mode of observation and interpretation for no apparent reason you don't have to be doing anything significant or important [Music] they just become fixated in whatever you're engaged in and then use it to try and pull you closer to them they want to get you into a corner where they can have you all to themselves and play with you as their own personal puppet they want to be tied to you they want there to be this firm unbreakable attachment between you and them or they can lock you into their realm for their own purpose or needs they are trying to take you into their possession by control or force [Music] the narcissist has to see you they experience these obsessive all-consuming dominated thoughts about you but they just can't let go they can't move on their lives they will do whatever it takes to keep you tethered to them they will set limitations and restrictions for you they will enclose surround circle confine whatever it takes to keep you locked in where they can have you all to themselves and use you for whatever purpose or need they have assigned to you the less you want to be around them the greater of an acquisition you are they see it as though you are something they have managed to succeed or achieve by effort [Music] they have acquired or secured you as a result of the conflict like a victory triumph conquest a highly successful example of something something to brag and boast about regardless of how you might feel about the situation [Music] regardless of how you might not even want to be there it's not about you it's about them and how great they are for securing you and locking you down within their chamber when they capture you they take your power away from you it makes them feel stronger and more confident it makes them feel as though they have accomplished something difficult when the narcissist sees you [Music] they make up all kinds of stories inside their minds from what they believe they've observed in your body language and facial expressions which can often send them on a wild goose chase they might see you laughing or smiling and then they will create a story to go with that or they might see you not smiling and make up a story for that whatever you are saying doing or experiencing they will always have some type of narration to go with it they will leave no stones unturned they will make every possible effort to find something or solve their problem [Music] when you are their target you preoccupy and fill their minds to a troubling extent you are unknowingly devouring them and there is nothing they can do to stop this from happening thank you for watching i hope this video resonates with you please like comment share subscribe click the bell icon receive notifications for my future videos if you would like to donate my paypal link is in the video description coaching enquiries you can email me at knoxville coaching gmail.com thank you for watching and i'll talk to you soon [Music] you | Narc Survivor | UCb1hm2xSWdQJGpJDckV7CoA | 2020-08-30 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 1,062 | 5,990 |
6GIwIRNl6x8 | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6GIwIRNl6x8 | Create your own Fedora image & push it to cloud - DevConf.CZ 2021 | so we are going to talk about creating your own federal images and pushing them to cloud using osborne composer andrzej can you display the next slide okay so first of all i would like to introduce the project that we work on it's called the os build project and we focus on building tools that you can use to create operating system images so for example if you want to create default images for your distribution or if you want to create a customized image again for example that contains an http proxy for amazon or just a simple qcow image with some pre-installed software who os build composer should be the right tool to do this and oswald composer itself is based on tool which we call os build we presented it last year at devconf and you can see a link to the presentation in the slides so i will just briefly explain what it is about so os build is a very low level tool it takes very detailed machine readable image description which is just a huge json file and it produces an image now what makes it different from all the other tools for creating operating system images is that we want the image to be well defined and we especially want the image build process to be reproducible so that's why we created was built in the first place now uh because os build is a very low level tool it's not very user-friendly let's say and it's also not meant for end users that's why we created os build composer some of you might remember a lorax composer which was the tool for creating customized operating system images in fedora and we created a hosbilt composer as a drop-in replacement this means that we provide the same rest api as lorex composer did and so you can use the same client-side tooling as you could when you were using lorax composer the difference from os build is that now instead of writing a huge json file you simply define customizations that should be applied to the default distribution image this means that inside of os build composer we define what it means to be a default fedora image for example and then we apply these customizations to the image so that you can get the image you want next slide please you can see an example of such customization here we call it a blueprint and it is a simple double file and in this blueprint you can specify for example a new user that should be present in the system or and package that should be installed or a systemd service that should be enabled and then when you have the blueprint you can apply it to uh to a distribution and image type so for example if you want to create fedora 33 image for aws you would select the distribution and the image type and then apply apply the blueprint and now andre will talk about uploading to cloud okay so uh this is uh this is uh the huge advantage of other composer in comparison with the old backend because oswald's composer can not only build those images but it can also directly upload them to cloud uh if you wanted to do this manually this was very tedious and like the apis of all cloud providers are different are often a bit weird so we did all the hard work for you and uh osborne composer with the same process images to various clouds uh currently we support aws and azure and just this week we merged uh support for vmware uh shootouts to uh josef that i saw in the audience uh so yeah uh this is uh how hospital composer can really help you to uh run to easily run instances from uh your customized images in clouds i think that uh you are now pretty hyped about our project uh and you want to try it uh so how uh to use it locally uh you have two options here uh one is graphical the second one is in terminal uh let's speak about the graphical option first uh it's actually an application in cockpit it's called image builder or the package is named cockpit composer and you can just click around in the gui add packages at users whatever you want uh and then you can just use a simple wizard to upload it uh to aws azure or vmware in the future so yeah it's very simple uh you can just use your mouse to do everything and i think that even your grandmother can do it uh and for the cli uh if you want to be feel like a hacker or you want to automate it maybe you can use the cli client composer cli uh you can just uh push a blueprint in tamil format to a composer cli and then run some commands to upload the image into cloud but let's not talk about theory anymore let's go to the demo uh the first demo uh is about the image builder application in cockpit uh we will use it to build a custom image and upload it into aws and verify uh that it uh put it so uh let's run it okay uh so let's start in the cockpit console where i can open uh the applications and i can very easily install uh the image builder application uh once it's installed i can open it i need to enable the image building service and now i can create my book my first blueprint let's name it demo and yeah on the screen uh i can add components or packages uh into the into the image for example i want an http server so i can just search for nginx and after a while i can click on the on the plus icon an extra nginx and it's selected i can also review all the dependencies that got pulled by uh by nginx so these are all the packages that will be installed when i'm happy with the package set i can just commit the changes and that's everything if the packages but i want some more customizations for for example i want a user in the predefined in the image so i can just fill this form with a user of user demo which will be administrator i will add a password please don't do this in production that might be dangerous and yeah now i'm happy with customization so let's just build an image let's select aws image because i said that we are uploading to aws i will check that i indeed want to upload i can choose an image size let's use 10 gigs for this demo why not on the screen i need to enter my aws credentials they are not shared with anyone and they are just used locally so we can upload the image into your account account now i need to fill some more details like image name or aws region in which i want the image and as free bucket which is used in the process and that's it now i can just review the values click finish and the image build and upload process will start so uh in reality this can take like 10 minutes but this is a recorded video so i got some parts out uh but yeah the image is now uploaded so let's verify that i indeed have it in my aws account let's open the aws console and let's go to amis that's amazon machine image i think and yeah my demo image is here so i can just launch it very easily from here uh let's use just some same defaults now aws will ask me if i want to insert a keypair inside the instance but i don't want to because i already created a user in image builder okay and it's now running so i can uh just copy the ip address from the console and head straight into my terminal and ssh into the machine yeah now it asks for my password that i inserted before and let's uh make sure that it's fedora yeah it's fedora and is nginx installed yes it is so yeah uh so uh this is a very simple way uh to build your own image with your own customizations uh with your packages and upload it to cloud if you do this a different way it would take you more time and uh you have to like work with azure cli and uh aws and all that stuff but we just made it possible in in a web browser so yeah i would say that uh image builder really makes your life easier so martin are we ready for your demo yes we are so uh in this demo you will see exactly the same but using command line instead of a copy composer as you can see here we again define a blueprint this time as a domo file and the cloud configuration and this time again as a tumble file instead of filling the form in cockpit now before you can start to compose you need to push the blueprint inside into the running os build instance and now you can start to compose here i display the help text for the compose command and as you can see we will need to specify the blueprint the image type which in this case will be ami for aws images image name is the name you will see in aws console and finally the cloud profile which specifies your credentials and yes so you will type composer cli compose start the name of your blueprint ami then the name of your image and finally the cloud configuration file and hit enter now os build is processing the request and you can use compose status to monitor the status of the running compose and again it will take at least few minutes maybe few hours depending on your internet connection well i have adsl connection so it took me like three hours yeah so back to you on j okay so i need to jump to the next slide okay uh so what's the what's the current state of uh os build composer uh so uh it's already available in uh stable fedora so you can just install it right now if you are running fedora it's available on the also in rel 8.3 so you can build your own rail images and upload them to uh clouds uh also uh we've just merged support for building center stream images so uh if you want uh to have center stream in aws you can just use the image builder to build them this will add soon because we've merged it uh like this week i think uh so yeah stay stay tuned for this feature uh so if you want to try it right now just type dnf install uh copy composer and it will pull all the dependencies like os build composer and voice build and it will be just fine and yeah open the cockpit console and you can just build your first image right there uh we have a new upstream guide which is very cool it uh have some information about what you can uh do uh in blueprints uh how you can upload these images there are some uh technical uh stuff so uh this is very nice uh we also like this is a month ago we did this thing so it's pretty up-to-date i would say we have of course a github account with discussions uh with issues so if you have anything if you feel like we are missing a feature just go there and tell us because we are interested in what you need and i saw already in in comments that some of you are interested about os3 uh comments images or what these things are uh yeah we can build them too uh so there will be a talk about building federal iot uh trees uh at uh 5 p.m today in session room 2 uh martin with christian will be speaking there so go there and see it uh federer iot is like to think of the future so go there and see how we are assembling those images and this is uh pretty much everything from us uh thank you for your attention if you have any question just use the qa panel in hoping uh or we can just hang out in in in the discord room afterwards if you don't have any questions just go install cockpit composer and uh try it because it's awesome and yeah that's it thanks um thank you thank you andrea barton actually there are a lot of questions there are a lot of questions in the chat and also in q a section so i'm not sure if we will have time to read all of them but for sure you can move to the chat room and uh talk to our speakers for this session so i will start reading questions miroslav asked a lot of things and i'm not sure but probably already answered in the chat how far is she built supporting and zebel for doing some of the stuff yeah so thanks for the question and i will repeat the answer so you cannot actually use ansible during the image build it's because we don't actually run the system we operate only with file system file system trees whereas ansible needs a running running system so what you can do is to include your playbook and run it during the first boot or you can rewrite the customizations that you have in os in ansible playbook and you can rewrite them to ice build composer blueprint thanks martin next question from martin how well oc built can handle custom kernel and dracad models is human that they are already packaged as a pams yeah we did some work in supporting alternative kernels uh for iot so that should definitely work for the iot stuff i'm not sure about like regular images but it should be possible i'm just not sure if it's implemented so i need to look it up yes if i can add to this so the screen allows you to specify additional rpms and also to specify additional command line arguments and this is definitely implemented and already available in released osbot composer we don't actually support any customizations here we are currently just using the default setup that record uses okay thank you next question is uh can you include both the free profile support for the uploads that was from david duncan do you want to answer this uh during the presentation i tried to look up what it is and i'm still not sure uh so uh we can i think but uh please maybe open an issue on github because we need more information i think thanks for suggestion though because yeah you are an aws expert the next question is again from eras will they be uh enough build service available to fedora users some time well we are definitely working on os build or rather image builder as a service but i cannot guarantee any availability at the moment but we are working on image builder as a service okay thank you the next question is from richard uh is the newly built image based on the system running oc build in other words can a fedora 33 system can only build another fedora 33 images okay uh if you if you are using a composer or the component cli yes then fedora 33 can build only fedora 33 but this is just the limitation of the api internally we are able to uh build across this draw are able to build groceries uh images like cross distro so uh we actually are able to build rail images on fedora and fedora images on the rail uh but it's not just it's not currently exposed to uh in the api thank you uh the next question is from mark can it use cash depends so it doesn't take three hours to build well it depends so we definitely don't use the system cache we download rpms for ourselves but if if you build the several images that are similar and use the same rpm set we cache the rpms but only those that were downloaded by os build composer itself so we do not share any caches with the system we are trying to be as we are trying to separate was built composer from the system as much as possible thank you uh i'm not sure but probably already answered what does blueprint mean okay uh so blueprint uh is uh a definition of uh how i want to image uh the image to look uh so i can put additional packages into blueprint i can add some more customization like enabling services adding users uh what else yeah customizing kernel command line uh and there are definitely some more and i think that uh they are in the guides on the osborne.org website if not just helping us and we will send you documentation uh thank you andrei and probably the last question from mirasla anything else i'm afraid we have to move to the chatroom uh what blueprints are planned to be added the current list seems quite limited and there is a link on that blueprint reference on the well welder dot io web page yes so we have our own uh blueprint reference you can see it in the slide here it's uh os build.org slash guides and it contains a blueprint reference and we know that the set of customizations is is limited for example if you compare it to the available customizations in ansible playbooks but there are no current plans for adding new customizations like we don't we don't have any exact plans right now but if you uh want some specific customizations feel free to open an issue in the os build composer repository andre do we want to add something to this yeah surely go to go to our github and just say us what you want because uh we are building images and we have a limited understanding of what people need so just tell us and uh we can chat and we can like uh decide if how to approach uh the problems that our users have because yeah we are not really sure what uh what users want so please come to us and tell us what you want we really want to hear it | DevConf | UCmYAQDZIQGm_kPvemBc_qwg | 2021-04-06 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 3,161 | 16,114 |
hIpdADTF2tU | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hIpdADTF2tU | The Truth About Being an Airline Pilot Debunking the Myths About Danger #debunking #pilot | overall flying on commercial airlines is considered to be one of the safest forms of transportation Airlines and Pilots are subject to strict regulations and oversight by Aviation authorities such as the Federal Aviation Administration in the U.S where the European Aviation safety agency in Europe to ensure the safety of passengers and crew airline pilots go through rigorous training and must pass regular medical and psychological evaluations to ensure that they are fit to fly they also undergo regular training and proficiency checks to maintain their skills and knowledge however like any profession there are risks associated with being an airline pilot Pilots May face hazards such as turbulence icing and bird strikes as well as other operational risks additionally there is always a risk of human error which can be mitigated through training regulations and oversight it's important to note that the aviation industry has an excellent safety record and continues to improve its safety standards through technology and new procedures in summary while there are risks associated with being an airline pilot the industry has taken significant steps to minimize these risks and ensure the safety of passengers and crew the overall safety record of commercial airlines is quite good and flying on a commercial aircraft is considered to be one of the safest forms of transportation foreign | Airplane Pilot Life | UCG3knWcMrJO-fPKrpg_QvBw | 2023-04-02 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 221 | 1,395 |
UpMB0K9_0HY | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UpMB0K9_0HY | Friends in the Kitchen - Stewed Apples | so they are going to make some simple stewed apples and hopefully you will enjoy them what's the recipe and how we made it so first we're going to peel the apples and cut them into small pieces okay so we cut and peel the apples and put them in a pot for water and now we're going to put it on the stove oh the apples that have just started to boil and in about half an hour they should be ready to change the pot because the other one was a bit too small for all our apples but now that it's been boiling we're going to add and the sugar all of the sugar all in there we are nice okay and we're going to mix it bubbling okay and also going to add the cinnamon then in chat again okay we've added the ingredient now it's boiling nicely we need to let it boil for the next 30 minutes and should be ready it's not just cook them until they turn my brown color and foggy enough okay and since we like things are going add one more tablespoon of sugar hey they have been cooking for about 25 minutes and they are nice and brown we'll just give it an extra five minutes so that they can get even softer and then we'll show you the next step okay they're ready we're just going to put it in a bowl and put it on the windowsill so it can cool down and make some nice beautiful for us week okay we put it on the windowsill so it can cool just look at it mmm okay we have put the apples into for dessert bowls and now we're going to make the topping so for the topic we are going to use two bananas and like half cup of yogurt to make top we're putting the vaynernation to this pot - got about a tablespoon of water so that the bananas don't burn and wait till they get soft and mushy and then you take them off the pan and put some yogurt in with them okay it's nice and mushy now see then you just gotta cook it a little bit longer - a little bits of banana get softened and you'll see blended the bananas into a nice mushy pate your finish - should look like this nice and creamy banana and yes and we're just an extreme and mix it nicely need a nice texture and you're gonna mix that so the cold air can get in and yeah now I just have to let it cool for about five six seven minutes for some plain yogurt on top of this dutiful and we're just waiting for the banana mix to cool and then I'll put that on top and now for the finishing touch we're just going to put one almond on top of each of them and then hmm who is he mm-hmm there is it since your solution you see buddy tasted that's what matters who are conservative well they didn't have that menu region we finished sugar packet oh um so subscribe um and when you make this dessert enjoy I'm reading some idea for a little simple afternoon um bye | FriendsInTheKitchen | UCPxhE4OJ8WYStU4QDRmMPYg | 2013-03-07 | Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed) | en | metadata | en | 553 | 2,699 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.