Add reviewer-requested secondary analyses

README.md

@@ -27,6 +27,8 @@ configurations and seeds, with each command held for two environment steps.
 | `live_validation.json` | Complete live-study export, measurements, clustered analyses and raw-file checksums |
 | `controller_timing.json` | Complete matched-time follow-up export and clustered comparisons |
 | `live_reproduction.zip` | Both October studies: evaluator, analysis, tests, protocols, selections, traces, initial arrays, physics parameters, deduplicated initial images and excluded implementation checks |
+| `round2_analysis.json` | Secondary request-swap contrasts, coverage/choice decomposition, benchmark-only sensitivity and fixture-level donor audit; unchanged rollout data |
+| `round2_reproduction.zip` | Small analysis supplement: code, specification, tests and two manuscript table-panel generators |
 | `confirmation.json`, `extension.json` | Unchanged September exports, with 320 and 60 scheduled attempts |
 | `reproduction.zip` | September reproduction code, inputs, traces and separate development records |
 | `SHA256SUMS.json` | Checksums of the files at this repository revision |
@@ -76,6 +78,26 @@ python paper/reproduce/live_assets.py --live-export ../live_validation.json \
   --timing-export ../controller_timing.json --output ../manuscript_assets
 ```
 
+## Reproduce the secondary analysis
+
+Download `round2_analysis.json` and extract `round2_reproduction.zip` into the same
+directory as the original archive. The supplement adds files without replacing the
+original evaluator or primary analyzer. From `code/`:
+
+```bash
+python -m experiments.revision.round2_analysis --export ../live_validation.json \
+  --out ../checked_round2.json
+ROUND2_PRIMARY_EXPORT=../live_validation.json ROUND2_SECONDARY_EXPORT=../round2_analysis.json \
+  python -m pytest tests/test_round2_analysis.py -q
+python -m paper.reproduce.round2_assets --export ../round2_analysis.json \
+  --output ../manuscript_assets
+```
+
+Compare `checked_round2.json` with `round2_analysis.json`. These reviewer-requested
+secondary estimates reuse the original stratified scene bootstrap. They do not add
+rollouts or replace the four original primary tests. The specification defines the
+swap contrast, additive components, donor-overlap rule and benchmark-only restriction.
+
 ## Rerun the live evaluation
 
 Use separate simulator and policy environments, with versions and lock files

SHA256SUMS.json

@@ -1,9 +1,11 @@
 {
-  "README.md": "6629f84ef23f9a4517b91f73fc1cc87b5359cc55a0110e968c0edeac39f6d603",
+  "README.md": "5154964981d2a6eed2bac391d58db1edb1c6f5dff1526712c223476734cdf35c",
   "controller_timing.json": "ff60147c42ad7c39701759cb17b644dbbf52ee0a09d5f6e997724d9de1275690",
   "live_reproduction.zip": "a888a4b4b7e2eaa4d453228acd03d77e320d02a848ea131168f6ff9699fea498",
   "live_validation.json": "5de8fb7ddd7252aebc0f14834dd4609e3bae5367f66a265fe5d1a46fbc974e1f",
   "confirmation.json": "7fb9e519d36d2dd48405f475b1f4edb7b804fdcbdd26f7fe30e4b990a90e18a3",
   "extension.json": "7ec8074aab116bd3dd8f41073a2bd856e62d98f2736028f5966e10f7cbd98f1f",
-  "reproduction.zip": "d10a531056efe36ff092146e925c9fc3cc86a7cd821115ca4964d9abb1c7de96"
+  "reproduction.zip": "d10a531056efe36ff092146e925c9fc3cc86a7cd821115ca4964d9abb1c7de96",
+  "round2_analysis.json": "6c24d6e42b0de29a33a0a4f67de7b7b12a5cc11dfea4b75c34f3f2548c2032b6",
+  "round2_reproduction.zip": "d6c9f9d547c57ea1ea415cf6b6a2c7c1260ccf4308ffc6d4e14a4603b5ced70f"
 }

round2_analysis.json

@@ -0,0 +1,1368 @@
+{
+  "schema": "review_round2_secondary_v1",
+  "status": "Reviewer-requested secondary analyses after results; original primary tests unchanged.",
+  "policies": {
+    "smolvla": {
+      "swap_benchmark": {
+        "original": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.0,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.058333333333333334,
+            0.058333333333333334
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 1.0,
+          "permutations": 100000,
+          "counts": {
+            "attempts_per_request": 120,
+            "own_request": 13,
+            "other_request": 13
+          }
+        },
+        "switched": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.0,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.05,
+            0.05
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 1.0,
+          "permutations": 100000,
+          "counts": {
+            "attempts_per_request": 120,
+            "own_request": 9,
+            "other_request": 9
+          }
+        },
+        "symmetric": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 1.3877787807814458e-18,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.041666666666666664,
+            0.04583333333333333
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 1.0,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "switched_conditional_choice_descriptive": {
+          "requested": 9,
+          "alternative": 13,
+          "goal_reaching": 22,
+          "fraction": 0.4090909090909091,
+          "attempts": 120,
+          "technical_errors": 1
+        }
+      },
+      "decomposition_all_fixtures": {
+        "blank": {
+          "requested_total": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.013888888888888888,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              -0.01111111111111111,
+              0.044444444444444446
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.5288747112528874,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "coverage_half": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.008333333333333333,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              -0.006944444444444444,
+              0.025
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.4954650453495465,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "choice_half_net": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.005555555555555556,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              -0.009722222222222222,
+              0.024999999999999994
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.6718532814671854,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "counts": {
+            "trusted": {
+              "neither": 308,
+              "requested": 26,
+              "alternative": 22,
+              "technical_error": 4
+            },
+            "control_labels": {
+              "neither": 318,
+              "requested": 21,
+              "alternative": 21
+            },
+            "control_physical": {
+              "neither": 159,
+              "requested": 12,
+              "alternative": 9
+            }
+          }
+        },
+        "shuffled": {
+          "requested_total": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": -0.01111111111111111,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              -0.03055555555555555,
+              0.008333333333333331
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.46425535744642554,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "coverage_half": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": -0.016666666666666666,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              -0.034722222222222224,
+              -0.0013888888888888883
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.12196878031219688,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "choice_half_net": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.005555555555555556,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              -0.009722222222222222,
+              0.024999999999999994
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.6718532814671854,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "counts": {
+            "trusted": {
+              "neither": 308,
+              "requested": 26,
+              "alternative": 22,
+              "technical_error": 4
+            },
+            "control_labels": {
+              "neither": 298,
+              "requested": 30,
+              "alternative": 30,
+              "technical_error": 2
+            },
+            "control_physical": {
+              "neither": 149,
+              "requested": 19,
+              "alternative": 11,
+              "technical_error": 1
+            }
+          }
+        }
+      },
+      "shuffled_benchmark_only": {
+        "requested_total": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": -0.016666666666666666,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.04583333333333334,
+            0.012499999999999999
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.46479535204647954,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "coverage_half": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": -0.016666666666666663,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.037500000000000006,
+            0.004166666666666667
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.23705762942370576,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "choice_half_net": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 6.938893903907229e-19,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.020833333333333332,
+            0.022916666666666665
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 1.0,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "counts": {
+          "trusted": {
+            "neither": 192,
+            "requested": 22,
+            "alternative": 22,
+            "technical_error": 4
+          },
+          "control_labels": {
+            "neither": 186,
+            "requested": 26,
+            "alternative": 26,
+            "technical_error": 2
+          },
+          "control_physical": {
+            "neither": 93,
+            "requested": 15,
+            "alternative": 11,
+            "technical_error": 1
+          }
+        }
+      }
+    },
+    "pi0": {
+      "swap_benchmark": {
+        "original": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.15,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            0.05000000000000001,
+            0.25
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.01966980330196698,
+          "permutations": 100000,
+          "counts": {
+            "attempts_per_request": 120,
+            "own_request": 45,
+            "other_request": 27
+          }
+        },
+        "switched": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.05,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.025,
+            0.13333333333333333
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.35354646453535465,
+          "permutations": 100000,
+          "counts": {
+            "attempts_per_request": 120,
+            "own_request": 20,
+            "other_request": 14
+          }
+        },
+        "symmetric": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.1,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            0.03333333333333333,
+            0.17083333333333334
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.02105978940210598,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "switched_conditional_choice_descriptive": {
+          "requested": 20,
+          "alternative": 27,
+          "goal_reaching": 47,
+          "fraction": 0.425531914893617,
+          "attempts": 120,
+          "technical_errors": 4
+        }
+      },
+      "decomposition_all_fixtures": {
+        "blank": {
+          "requested_total": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.14722222222222223,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              0.10277777777777777,
+              0.19166666666666668
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 9.99990000099999e-06,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "coverage_half": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.1138888888888889,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              0.08194444444444444,
+              0.14583333333333334
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 9.99990000099999e-06,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "choice_half_net": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.03333333333333333,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              0.01111111111111111,
+              0.056944444444444436
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.02169978300216998,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "counts": {
+            "trusted": {
+              "neither": 245,
+              "requested": 65,
+              "alternative": 41,
+              "technical_error": 9
+            },
+            "control_labels": {
+              "neither": 336,
+              "requested": 12,
+              "alternative": 12
+            },
+            "control_physical": {
+              "neither": 168,
+              "requested": 8,
+              "alternative": 4
+            }
+          }
+        },
+        "shuffled": {
+          "requested_total": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.05555555555555556,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              0.019444444444444445,
+              0.09444444444444443
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.016049839501604983,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "coverage_half": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.02222222222222222,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              -0.0055555555555555506,
+              0.049999999999999996
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.17057829421705784,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "choice_half_net": {
+            "scene_clusters": 44,
+            "nominal_fixture_weight": 60.0,
+            "paired_difference": 0.03333333333333333,
+            "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+              0.01111111111111111,
+              0.056944444444444436
+            ],
+            "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.02169978300216998,
+            "permutations": 100000
+          },
+          "counts": {
+            "trusted": {
+              "neither": 245,
+              "requested": 65,
+              "alternative": 41,
+              "technical_error": 9
+            },
+            "control_labels": {
+              "neither": 262,
+              "requested": 45,
+              "alternative": 45,
+              "technical_error": 8
+            },
+            "control_physical": {
+              "neither": 131,
+              "requested": 30,
+              "alternative": 15,
+              "technical_error": 4
+            }
+          }
+        }
+      },
+      "shuffled_benchmark_only": {
+        "requested_total": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.08333333333333333,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            0.029166666666666664,
+            0.1375
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.016559834401655982,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "coverage_half": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.033333333333333326,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            -0.008333333333333335,
+            0.07291666666666666
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.17041829581704182,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "choice_half_net": {
+          "scene_clusters": 40,
+          "nominal_fixture_weight": 40.0,
+          "paired_difference": 0.05,
+          "scene_bootstrap_95_ci": [
+            0.016666666666666666,
+            0.08541666666666667
+          ],
+          "two_sided_scene_sign_flip_p": 0.02105978940210598,
+          "permutations": 100000
+        },
+        "counts": {
+          "trusted": {
+            "requested": 65,
+            "alternative": 41,
+            "neither": 125,
+            "technical_error": 9
+          },
+          "control_labels": {
+            "requested": 45,
+            "alternative": 45,
+            "neither": 142,
+            "technical_error": 8
+          },
+          "control_physical": {
+            "requested": 30,
+            "neither": 71,
+            "alternative": 15,
+            "technical_error": 4
+          }
+        }
+      }
+    }
+  },
+  "donor_overlap": {
+    "definition": "Complete recipient target phrase in donor text; casefolded whitespace-normalized word-boundary match.",
+    "benchmark": {
+      "fixtures": 40,
+      "overlaps_A": 6,
+      "overlaps_B": 4,
+      "overlaps_either": 10,
+      "equals_A_command": 6,
+      "equals_B_command": 4
+    },
+    "constructed": {
+      "fixtures": 20,
+      "overlaps_A": 20,
+      "overlaps_B": 0,
+      "overlaps_either": 20,
+      "equals_A_command": 20,
+      "equals_B_command": 0
+    },
+    "by_template": {
+      "attribute__constructed_attribute_1": {
+        "fixtures": 10,
+        "overlaps_A": 10,
+        "overlaps_B": 0,
+        "overlaps_either": 10,
+        "equals_A_command": 10,
+        "equals_B_command": 0
+      },
+      "attribute__constructed_attribute_2": {
+        "fixtures": 10,
+        "overlaps_A": 10,
+        "overlaps_B": 0,
+        "overlaps_either": 10,
+        "equals_A_command": 10,
+        "equals_B_command": 0
+      },
+      "attribute__select_chemistry_tube": {
+        "fixtures": 9,
+        "overlaps_A": 4,
+        "overlaps_B": 2,
+        "overlaps_either": 6,
+        "equals_A_command": 4,
+        "equals_B_command": 2
+      },
+      "attribute__select_mahjong": {
+        "fixtures": 10,
+        "overlaps_A": 0,
+        "overlaps_B": 0,
+        "overlaps_either": 0,
+        "equals_A_command": 0,
+        "equals_B_command": 0
+      },
+      "attribute__select_poker": {
+        "fixtures": 7,
+        "overlaps_A": 0,
+        "overlaps_B": 0,
+        "overlaps_either": 0,
+        "equals_A_command": 0,
+        "equals_B_command": 0
+      },
+      "object__select_book": {
+        "fixtures": 8,
+        "overlaps_A": 1,
+        "overlaps_B": 1,
+        "overlaps_either": 2,
+        "equals_A_command": 1,
+        "equals_B_command": 1
+      },
+      "object__select_fruit": {
+        "fixtures": 6,
+        "overlaps_A": 1,
+        "overlaps_B": 1,
+        "overlaps_either": 2,
+        "equals_A_command": 1,
+        "equals_B_command": 1
+      }
+    },
+    "fixtures": [
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:0895a703b3c08607906f4706d60e18b78401f8286b72697f77147e88881252be",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:11100b3107e2e0d869007006a4bc035310b9c7148195495c368564411ee4c8c6",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:11100b3107e2e0d869007006a4bc035310b9c7148195495c368564411ee4c8c6",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:2575153eb8b77ffb5e1f2730994cb9570d2c319eb28b23caf43b4ffdc60f6b12",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:2575153eb8b77ffb5e1f2730994cb9570d2c319eb28b23caf43b4ffdc60f6b12",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:2f790430bf14ba1003fe29371756fdec8a69fba893faa4e1ca1a594b449715b3",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:2f790430bf14ba1003fe29371756fdec8a69fba893faa4e1ca1a594b449715b3",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:33f6d2e2e35b0217bceeff4d67612267ae6e659a4eaa090718ad79cac608c45c",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:33f6d2e2e35b0217bceeff4d67612267ae6e659a4eaa090718ad79cac608c45c",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:43a0a2265e0195478f5512ca0c0dd89694072d709669a67bb0ff454444eb04ff",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:43a0a2265e0195478f5512ca0c0dd89694072d709669a67bb0ff454444eb04ff",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:4e79fa51ce4a30c98826da72916c539ea93706635457b6f59ea77d98d2cf8178",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:4e79fa51ce4a30c98826da72916c539ea93706635457b6f59ea77d98d2cf8178",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:4f0c1cda8aa24f17a6151e5a30982c7f7f97cae02e433a6a1a46a915d70db38d",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:4f0c1cda8aa24f17a6151e5a30982c7f7f97cae02e433a6a1a46a915d70db38d",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:7f8e3558179cf18f0059f393d577e55c5b78d96440bc8ed6505f0c8587ae9aaf",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:7f8e3558179cf18f0059f393d577e55c5b78d96440bc8ed6505f0c8587ae9aaf",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:9ec98aa8f0a7d9fb631dfc2fb4924d165743aea276c64bc0577c2627ea6708d6",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:9ec98aa8f0a7d9fb631dfc2fb4924d165743aea276c64bc0577c2627ea6708d6",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_1:0895a703b3c08607906f4706d60e18b78401f8286b72697f77147e88881252be",
+        "target_A": "yellow",
+        "target_B": "blue",
+        "instruction": "Put the yellow ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:026e99a021519eb2c5a1e14e5948dd4f5f30489d7ac162da68f77c765883ef67",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:0895a703b3c08607906f4706d60e18b78401f8286b72697f77147e88881252be",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:0895a703b3c08607906f4706d60e18b78401f8286b72697f77147e88881252be",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:0af837a827fa972d969a5eb662abc5d355831a80ef4f04b30e4ff6751c9e1f9b",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:0af837a827fa972d969a5eb662abc5d355831a80ef4f04b30e4ff6751c9e1f9b",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:11100b3107e2e0d869007006a4bc035310b9c7148195495c368564411ee4c8c6",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:11100b3107e2e0d869007006a4bc035310b9c7148195495c368564411ee4c8c6",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:17dcd30d2ef681fc30c322c683dd1fb57b3613ba5e71db51ec0220ad89ae9938",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:17dcd30d2ef681fc30c322c683dd1fb57b3613ba5e71db51ec0220ad89ae9938",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:2575153eb8b77ffb5e1f2730994cb9570d2c319eb28b23caf43b4ffdc60f6b12",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:2575153eb8b77ffb5e1f2730994cb9570d2c319eb28b23caf43b4ffdc60f6b12",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:2f790430bf14ba1003fe29371756fdec8a69fba893faa4e1ca1a594b449715b3",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:2f790430bf14ba1003fe29371756fdec8a69fba893faa4e1ca1a594b449715b3",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:43a0a2265e0195478f5512ca0c0dd89694072d709669a67bb0ff454444eb04ff",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:43a0a2265e0195478f5512ca0c0dd89694072d709669a67bb0ff454444eb04ff",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:7f8e3558179cf18f0059f393d577e55c5b78d96440bc8ed6505f0c8587ae9aaf",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:7f8e3558179cf18f0059f393d577e55c5b78d96440bc8ed6505f0c8587ae9aaf",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:86e2d0b6a020dd3b12bed84e14ed9b3f18180dcc60a276198ffc4a9118cef723",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:86e2d0b6a020dd3b12bed84e14ed9b3f18180dcc60a276198ffc4a9118cef723",
+        "source": "constructed",
+        "template": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__constructed_attribute_2:026e99a021519eb2c5a1e14e5948dd4f5f30489d7ac162da68f77c765883ef67",
+        "target_A": "solid",
+        "target_B": "striped",
+        "instruction": "Put the solid ball into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:000e0626c8da75c0dd2aeb59b065e8c063bdb055aca227d3fc6ff181196ed24c",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:119d25b10cb0286c33406cb7ac9d9df060f5d9190a2554c50d81b86168bc35f4",
+        "target_A": "CuCl2",
+        "target_B": "I2",
+        "instruction": "Take out the KMnO4 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:119d25b10cb0286c33406cb7ac9d9df060f5d9190a2554c50d81b86168bc35f4",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:25e3706261f7efff7fd6f6dbf950b212c110137799b829901a45c925bb6ed3e8",
+        "target_A": "KMnO4",
+        "target_B": "I2",
+        "instruction": "Take out the KMnO4 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:25e3706261f7efff7fd6f6dbf950b212c110137799b829901a45c925bb6ed3e8",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:3dc8148c68e6aab0157ea8ae0661bfacba13030c794f679a49818f24f6f646e1",
+        "target_A": "KMnO4",
+        "target_B": "FeCl3",
+        "instruction": "Take out the KMnO4 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:3dc8148c68e6aab0157ea8ae0661bfacba13030c794f679a49818f24f6f646e1",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:4b5d2c499865ca5c90b539a84a969adc45b302e8e2e61c349295b613ece179c9",
+        "target_A": "KMnO4",
+        "target_B": "FeCl3",
+        "instruction": "Take out the CuCl2 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:4b5d2c499865ca5c90b539a84a969adc45b302e8e2e61c349295b613ece179c9",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:a6f0a47acbd9d7996a093e6be9c1091d67d4a7a3b7113a37ecb19ac175f64e49",
+        "target_A": "CuCl2",
+        "target_B": "KMnO4",
+        "instruction": "Take out the FeCl3 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:a6f0a47acbd9d7996a093e6be9c1091d67d4a7a3b7113a37ecb19ac175f64e49",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:ce871ba355a316ae6971b524e366b0bd12a3bb54b973291e2ccb7030a8e38120",
+        "target_A": "FeCl3",
+        "target_B": "CuCl2",
+        "instruction": "Take out the FeCl3 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:ce871ba355a316ae6971b524e366b0bd12a3bb54b973291e2ccb7030a8e38120",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:e544d53bd01a6474976ce38aa74170ef744a47605f40c8ae2ddd5434685f16bd",
+        "target_A": "FeCl3",
+        "target_B": "CuSO4",
+        "instruction": "Take out the CuSO4 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": true,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": true
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:e544d53bd01a6474976ce38aa74170ef744a47605f40c8ae2ddd5434685f16bd",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:ee955700005e5b4d395126b033e0c150f7e8803e8666834fb71ec8a801026a8c",
+        "target_A": "CuSO4",
+        "target_B": "KMnO4",
+        "instruction": "Take out the CuSO4 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:ee955700005e5b4d395126b033e0c150f7e8803e8666834fb71ec8a801026a8c",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_chemistry_tube:000e0626c8da75c0dd2aeb59b065e8c063bdb055aca227d3fc6ff181196ed24c",
+        "target_A": "CuSO4",
+        "target_B": "CuCl2",
+        "instruction": "Take out the CuCl2 solution",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": true,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": true
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:01cd91e27349fe3c55e0094f530fdc2f3cfa963ba6b129a43097aa0f67963d8a",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:155f24a574cf851ddd97a2f481d6ede8bb35d72ec48cb507e73b21ea4af19535",
+        "target_A": "3 pin",
+        "target_B": "5 pin",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 9 pin",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:155f24a574cf851ddd97a2f481d6ede8bb35d72ec48cb507e73b21ea4af19535",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:302e166fd0892ad74fa03c9a5c685e02bb92bc48fe8af6d8440d299e62b6b387",
+        "target_A": "9 pin",
+        "target_B": "5 pin",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 9 man",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:302e166fd0892ad74fa03c9a5c685e02bb92bc48fe8af6d8440d299e62b6b387",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:39c7ecf85d42a8fe21c12278e4dba9a7cd5feff21c8b50e96a0451e31c049911",
+        "target_A": "9 man",
+        "target_B": "5 man",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 7 man",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:39c7ecf85d42a8fe21c12278e4dba9a7cd5feff21c8b50e96a0451e31c049911",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:58b1f91ce63cef712284c783d2e59f6e184c975cda9d245620740f40d9462281",
+        "target_A": "7 man",
+        "target_B": "1 man",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 1 pin",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:58b1f91ce63cef712284c783d2e59f6e184c975cda9d245620740f40d9462281",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:63ef20edafc29318a18739070afcc10c09f549dae215483a6df71b5060003ece",
+        "target_A": "1 pin",
+        "target_B": "1 man",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 8 sou",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:63ef20edafc29318a18739070afcc10c09f549dae215483a6df71b5060003ece",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:bd73b5d4348bd0907d3e9b83c9ff681b460681d18767775af2a2f340ef0648ed",
+        "target_A": "8 sou",
+        "target_B": "6 sou",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 7 man",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:bd73b5d4348bd0907d3e9b83c9ff681b460681d18767775af2a2f340ef0648ed",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:c6828ba4490662b18eb39403a3bfea8d254bee5c76e2554d5ec3c4e7b3294a6e",
+        "target_A": "7 man",
+        "target_B": "1 man",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 4 sou",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:c6828ba4490662b18eb39403a3bfea8d254bee5c76e2554d5ec3c4e7b3294a6e",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:f18095052920e2b6b8f2b17a5dc4e8ae5b0a06db0621d33093d2022fb4f77f65",
+        "target_A": "4 sou",
+        "target_B": "2 sou",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 5 man",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:f18095052920e2b6b8f2b17a5dc4e8ae5b0a06db0621d33093d2022fb4f77f65",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:fcf31db921621aebc37bdb2e9f3d8582222dbc423cd8cfaba6ce9266299e49f8",
+        "target_A": "5 man",
+        "target_B": "1 man",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 7 man",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:fcf31db921621aebc37bdb2e9f3d8582222dbc423cd8cfaba6ce9266299e49f8",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_mahjong",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_mahjong:01cd91e27349fe3c55e0094f530fdc2f3cfa963ba6b129a43097aa0f67963d8a",
+        "target_A": "7 man",
+        "target_B": "3 man",
+        "instruction": "Pick up the mahjong of 3 pin",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_poker:2a73c19ca4845dd5157e27e4552134bc2d799e632e9b8cd8c651f8dd60d8cceb",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_poker",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_poker:3719e87901241bcdee404617a3d2fdabacfe9373c8f22f76664a6b955d71fc1f",
+        "target_A": "7 of hearts",
+        "target_B": "jack of hearts",
+        "instruction": "Please pick the poker 4 of clubs",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_poker:3719e87901241bcdee404617a3d2fdabacfe9373c8f22f76664a6b955d71fc1f",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_poker",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_poker:6bdfe1b8febd245316e9659129369402bc48a01bc98537dc897c3d796c3351b1",
+        "target_A": "4 of clubs",
+        "target_B": "8 of clubs",
+        "instruction": "Please pick the poker jack of spades",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_poker:6bdfe1b8febd245316e9659129369402bc48a01bc98537dc897c3d796c3351b1",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_poker",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_poker:892ea674cb6b8245c3497d2d5bfffc63da8d9f2247b120c088db3140b1426059",
+        "target_A": "jack of spades",
+        "target_B": "ace of spades",
+        "instruction": "Please pick the poker 6 of spades",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_poker:892ea674cb6b8245c3497d2d5bfffc63da8d9f2247b120c088db3140b1426059",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_poker",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_poker:8bc086dc6b6e5dab7ca69365762e07b8ff13ea14a96c8ec673d8841d6b94027a",
+        "target_A": "6 of spades",
+        "target_B": "ace of spades",
+        "instruction": "Please pick the poker king of hearts",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_poker:8bc086dc6b6e5dab7ca69365762e07b8ff13ea14a96c8ec673d8841d6b94027a",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_poker",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_poker:9f6f0468c41ff0cbcf28d82381df8298898347015632d1f403c9bb4313ba9eaa",
+        "target_A": "king of hearts",
+        "target_B": "king of spades",
+        "instruction": "Please pick the poker ace of clubs",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_poker:9f6f0468c41ff0cbcf28d82381df8298898347015632d1f403c9bb4313ba9eaa",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_poker",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_poker:a6ec83058b4f79a1f775c7ee6f279ba2bc496e8a5b51913e4fcd46c728d6f9be",
+        "target_A": "ace of clubs",
+        "target_B": "9 of clubs",
+        "instruction": "Please pick the poker 3 of diamonds",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "attribute__select_poker:a6ec83058b4f79a1f775c7ee6f279ba2bc496e8a5b51913e4fcd46c728d6f9be",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "attribute__select_poker",
+        "donor_fixture": "attribute__select_poker:2a73c19ca4845dd5157e27e4552134bc2d799e632e9b8cd8c651f8dd60d8cceb",
+        "target_A": "3 of diamonds",
+        "target_B": "king of diamonds",
+        "instruction": "Please pick the poker 7 of hearts",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:101105b16fd527acdbd4b7c0076c542585f07c945d0bc9220a2c11d7448c7982",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:30f74c10d0b1b2e3d8d00c56181d8270bdea2a0ca3b1d2254e3b7444865af2d5",
+        "target_A": "critical infrastructure protection in homeland security",
+        "target_B": "the autobiography of benjamin franklin",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book landmark cases in property law",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:30f74c10d0b1b2e3d8d00c56181d8270bdea2a0ca3b1d2254e3b7444865af2d5",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:386584795068bf324022616f1914f17e0e36947319f3e347355d956e4b69bf9d",
+        "target_A": "landmark cases in property law",
+        "target_B": "steve jobs",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book foundamentals of molecular biology",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:386584795068bf324022616f1914f17e0e36947319f3e347355d956e4b69bf9d",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:6eca3d0b773d76d2542a7e4b5c3ff42507e87e4c1bc210a3e1478ef45f7beafd",
+        "target_A": "foundamentals of molecular biology",
+        "target_B": "scholars of contract law",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book steve jobs",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:6eca3d0b773d76d2542a7e4b5c3ff42507e87e4c1bc210a3e1478ef45f7beafd",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:79cb6502b4901d8265475ee9dca1bf9a63acde952bcdfd09b0e37afae5f276d3",
+        "target_A": "steve jobs",
+        "target_B": "critical infrastructure protection in homeland security",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book engineering biopolymers",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:79cb6502b4901d8265475ee9dca1bf9a63acde952bcdfd09b0e37afae5f276d3",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:d758a4f538835e922896b4f43ee1a9f0505fb3faf4ea5f2137736ee24f18aa4a",
+        "target_A": "engineering biopolymers",
+        "target_B": "contract law in japan",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book contract law in japan",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": true,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": true
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:d758a4f538835e922896b4f43ee1a9f0505fb3faf4ea5f2137736ee24f18aa4a",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:ddcbca9fd2f2a3a58c3bf06e625df046382d7cfcd6addad26959abe7a4da010f",
+        "target_A": "contract law in japan",
+        "target_B": "scholars of contract law",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book the story of american freedom",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:ddcbca9fd2f2a3a58c3bf06e625df046382d7cfcd6addad26959abe7a4da010f",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:eac880fc1e0fd186df3a86f013fa645afca8c0ee45159a42a231a1a8a3f325d7",
+        "target_A": "the story of american freedom",
+        "target_B": "the great divergence china europe and the making of the modern world economy",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book the story of american freedom",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_book:eac880fc1e0fd186df3a86f013fa645afca8c0ee45159a42a231a1a8a3f325d7",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_book",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_book:101105b16fd527acdbd4b7c0076c542585f07c945d0bc9220a2c11d7448c7982",
+        "target_A": "the story of american freedom",
+        "target_B": "the autobiography of benjamin franklin",
+        "instruction": "Please take the book critical infrastructure protection in homeland security",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_fruit:8fbff2ea2978f67727f88945037496859d0327a0d6bb17b13504068d451556a3",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_fruit",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_fruit:ac015954ca644b7c28c539a36dfab7fb47025d9717579ff8af10950236ebc96d",
+        "target_A": "pear",
+        "target_B": "banana",
+        "instruction": "Put the banana into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": true,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": true
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_fruit:ac015954ca644b7c28c539a36dfab7fb47025d9717579ff8af10950236ebc96d",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_fruit",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_fruit:d64046355ab80850802815515ef60f29cfb3a0222958bbdde1db661699d53aa4",
+        "target_A": "banana",
+        "target_B": "apple",
+        "instruction": "Put the pear into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_fruit:d64046355ab80850802815515ef60f29cfb3a0222958bbdde1db661699d53aa4",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_fruit",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_fruit:e2f93673553b85b0a5bfe11fdca1521b3b4429ed65eb8dac2b177a6bcd77ee54",
+        "target_A": "pear",
+        "target_B": "peach",
+        "instruction": "Put the apple into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_fruit:e2f93673553b85b0a5bfe11fdca1521b3b4429ed65eb8dac2b177a6bcd77ee54",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_fruit",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_fruit:e6d1a4d212ecf6baa0a3299816cd6f8ef789890e4f6a909dd73e3b53bf5ad58c",
+        "target_A": "apple",
+        "target_B": "kiwi",
+        "instruction": "Put the orange into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_fruit:e6d1a4d212ecf6baa0a3299816cd6f8ef789890e4f6a909dd73e3b53bf5ad58c",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_fruit",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_fruit:e9cbe82c192440dbb8b125c127ae2fd4d1a890d746aa63415b59c3cf386f4657",
+        "target_A": "orange",
+        "target_B": "kiwi",
+        "instruction": "Put the pear into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": false,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": false,
+        "equals_A_command": false,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      },
+      {
+        "fixture": "object__select_fruit:e9cbe82c192440dbb8b125c127ae2fd4d1a890d746aa63415b59c3cf386f4657",
+        "source": "native",
+        "template": "object__select_fruit",
+        "donor_fixture": "object__select_fruit:8fbff2ea2978f67727f88945037496859d0327a0d6bb17b13504068d451556a3",
+        "target_A": "pear",
+        "target_B": "mango",
+        "instruction": "Put the pear into the plate",
+        "overlaps_A": true,
+        "overlaps_B": false,
+        "overlaps_either": true,
+        "equals_A_command": true,
+        "equals_B_command": false
+      }
+    ]
+  },
+  "input_sha256": "5de8fb7ddd7252aebc0f14834dd4609e3bae5367f66a265fe5d1a46fbc974e1f",
+  "analysis_sha256": "8d6ccd33e9268ea8c0d60a6c05c0b5583fefbd3ac96e7a8f2f8f95d6c0e4e54a",
+  "specification_sha256": "fd809c96c971de29386c781a1bf21074f982c6b6e475a7cf5036544e35f99eca"
+}

round2_reproduction.zip

@@ -0,0 +1,3 @@
+version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
+oid sha256:d6c9f9d547c57ea1ea415cf6b6a2c7c1260ccf4308ffc6d4e14a4603b5ced70f
+size 8952