text
stringlengths
0
6.44k
basin. It is difficult to identify one dominant cause of disturbance in habitat over the
course of the sampling period due to the limitations of the study and the number of
possible variables involved in vegetation growth and distribution.
4.4.1 Algae and Nutrient Changes Related to Seagrass Variations
During the past century, human activities have had a tremendous impact on the
global cycling of nutrients in coastal systems (Caccia and Boyer 2007). The export of
phosphorus to the oceans has increased threefold compared to pre-industrial and preagricultural levels while the export of nitrogen has increased even more dramatically
(Caraco 1995). Most seagrass beds contain benthic and epiphytic algae (FMNH 2015)
that may contribute significantly to the system (Heijs 1987; Verheij and Erftemeijer
1993; Jupp et al. 1996; Sidik et al. 2001). However, when a water quality disturbance
involving nutrients occurs in an area, there is the potential to shift the dynamics between
the seagrass and algae cover (Fourqurean et al. 1995; FMNH 2015). Multer (1988) found
that high biomass of macroalgae appears under the conditions on low and moderate
seagrass shoot density, indirectly demonstrating the competitive relationship between
seagrasses and macroalgae. It was expected that there would be stronger competition
between grass and algae in POM because of the low seagrass cover-density recorded;
however, no significant shifts were detected during the study period. The lowest
79
occurrence of algae in record in POM was in 2006 and the highest in 2007 (Figure 5).
Without an accurate record of nutrient concentrations for these sample years, it is difficult
to determine the cause behind this shift. It is possible the change in occurrence may be
due to overall shallower sites sampled in 2007, which may support more algae species.
Monitoring over the past century has been inconsistent in the POM region, so it is
difficult to establish a solid data record. The useable data from the SFWMD agencies
showed little to no significant variation in measured nutrients between sampling years for
most of the variables. There were no consistent data records from the SFWMD prior to
2008 for TP (total phosphate) or NOx (nitrate+nitrite) concentrations within the POM
basin. Data show that available nutrient concentrations have remained fairly low over the
last four years of the study period. Between 2008 and 2011 the TP averaged 0.004 ±
0.017 mg/L and NOx concentrations averaged 0.004 ± 0.017 mg/L (Table 11). There are
many forms of Nitrogen in an aquatic environment, and since the SFWMD records for
Nitrogen measurements covered several different types between agencies, it is difficult to
determine any significant relationships between variables within the basin. The lack of
consistent nutrient data for some variables makes it difficult to make solid connections
between agencies. Even with a large uncertainty in pairing the sample collection dates
and times, is it suggested a reasonable correlation can be made for some variables
between other agencies and monitoring programs (RECOVER 2014).
There have been indications that the Biscayne Bay ecosystem is slowly
recovering, although conditions are not expected to return to those of the early 1900s,
before settlement (Cantillo et al. 2000). The water quality in North Biscayne Bay has
improved substantially in the last 30 years and now generally meets or exceeds local,
state and federal standards for recreational uses and propagation of fish and wildlife
through regulatory action and shoreline revetment and restoration projects (SFWMD
2000). DERM has even documented significant return of benthic communities in some
portions of North Biscayne Bay as a result of improved water quality (SFWMD 2000).
The bay still receives a considerable amount of nutrients, trace metals, organic chemicals
and particulates from storm water runoff, canal discharge, and other sources (BBAP
2011) which is still a concern for environmental agencies.
80
Initially detected in 2002, a macroalgae bloom composed of mainly Anadyomene
spp. has continually persisted along parts of the western shoreline of Biscayne Bay, just
south of the Rickenbacker Causeway and the Port of Miami basin (RECOVER 2014).
The impact of the prolonged algae bloom has resulted in a shift from a seagrass
dominated community to a macroalgal dominated community in that region (RECOVER
2012). Macroalgae can potentially have one of the greatest effects on the seagrass coverdensities in an area, but even with some significant increases in cover detected in of some
algae groups in the POM between years, there was no obvious detrimental impact
observed to the seagrass. The fragile balance between the seagrass and algae must be
maintained through proper water management practices.
The Integrated Biscayne Bay Ecological Assessment and Monitoring Project
(IBBEAM) report for CERP combined the sampling efforts of four individual projects
funded by the RECOVER Monitoring and Assessment Plan (MAP): Salinity Monitoring
Network, Nearshore SAV (submerged aquatic vegetation), Alongshore Epifauna, and
Mangrove Fish. The project concluded that the nearshore habitats in Biscayne Bay are
occupied by floral and faunal species assemblages operating below their productive
potential, due, in part, to inadequate and unnatural freshwater flows limiting the duration
and spatial extent of mesohaline conditions (RECOVER 2014). Despite this, IBBEAM
determined that the occurrence of H. wrightii and T. testudinum in the study area
remained largely stable over the period of record, similar to the findings from this study
(FIAN). Seagrass cover-density and spatial distribution fluctuated somewhat seasonally
and varied across years within the POM basin, but no clear temporal trend in seagrass
cover was apparent. The seagrass species remain fairly stable within the port.
4.5 Future Threats to Seagrass Habitats
Over the next century, the predicted changes in global climate will alter many of
the factors that shape the coastal ecosystem of South Florida (RECOVER 2014). Climate
change has the potential to cause sea level rise, increased temperatures, changes in
precipitation patterns, and changes in the intensity and/or frequency of extreme weather
events (ICLEI 2010). This can lead to a rapid loss and substantial changes to the benthic
communities along the coasts (Wanless et al. 1994). Studies done by the Organization
for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) identified Miami–Dade as the
81
county with the highest amount of vulnerable assets exposed to potential coastal flooding,
with costs projected at around $3.5 trillion (Nicholls et al. 2007). A major consequence
of climate change is an increase in water temperature in the North Atlantic. Models
predict that increases in tropical sea surface temperature can lead to an increase in
number and intensity of tropical storms, with larger peak wind speeds and more heavy
precipitation (Mann et al. 2009; IPCC 2007). Global sea surface temperature increasing
by one degree Celsius could result in a 30% increase in category 4 and 5 storms
worldwide (Elsner et al. 2008). Over the past decade the Copenhagen Diagnosis (a report
written by twenty-six climate scientist from eight countries) has found evidence of a
global increase in the number of category 4 and 5 hurricanes (Allison et al. 2009). These
climate deviations can alter habitat productivity and eutrophication by changing the
delivery of fresh water, nutrients, and sediments (Scavia et al. 2002). With climate
changes, the composition and distribution of biotics that occur in the coastal ecosystem
will shift (Scavia et al. 2002).
5.0 Conclusions
The primary objectives of this study were to: 1) characterize the seagrass
community (e.g., species composition, cover, and distribution); and 2) characterize the
environmental and physical conditions (e.g., salinity, temperature, turbidity, and water
and sediment depths); and 3) determine if there are relationships between the seagrass
community and the environmental and physical conditions; and 4) evaluate if the natural