sentence1 stringclasses 538
values | sentence2 stringlengths 12 241 | labels stringclasses 2
values | metadata stringlengths 187 265 |
|---|---|---|---|
The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better | The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 650, "id": "650:5263", "native_cluster": [5263], "perspective_id": 5263, "split_group_id": "67aaa245b20a7fc3388ab8d0a0c378c6a09385d6008d32a085fecf664902b336", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better | Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 650, "id": "650:5257", "native_cluster": [5257], "perspective_id": 5257, "split_group_id": "67aaa245b20a7fc3388ab8d0a0c378c6a09385d6008d32a085fecf664902b336", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better | Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 650, "id": "650:1984", "native_cluster": [1984, 5254, 5255, 22728, 22727], "perspective_id": 1984, "split_group_id": "67aaa245b20a7fc3388ab8d0a0c378c6a09385d6008d32a085fecf664902b336", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better | Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 650, "id": "650:5256", "native_cluster": [5256], "perspective_id": 5256, "split_group_id": "67aaa245b20a7fc3388ab8d0a0c378c6a09385d6008d32a085fecf664902b336", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better | It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 650, "id": "650:5258", "native_cluster": [5258], "perspective_id": 5258, "split_group_id": "67aaa245b20a7fc3388ab8d0a0c378c6a09385d6008d32a085fecf664902b336", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better | All the people worldwide have the same rights and are equal to one another. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 650, "id": "650:6620", "native_cluster": [6620], "perspective_id": 6620, "split_group_id": "67aaa245b20a7fc3388ab8d0a0c378c6a09385d6008d32a085fecf664902b336", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better | The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 650, "id": "650:6619", "native_cluster": [6619], "perspective_id": 6619, "split_group_id": "67aaa245b20a7fc3388ab8d0a0c378c6a09385d6008d32a085fecf664902b336", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline | Environmental risks | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 433, "id": "433:3229", "native_cluster": [3229], "perspective_id": 3229, "split_group_id": "676db4ee9cbb2187e7cacde015006a507e39dbc8224785c6c5510bb73e50c45d", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline | The pipeline will reduce American dependence on Middle Eastern and Latin American oil | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 433, "id": "433:3226", "native_cluster": [3226, 23677, 23678], "perspective_id": 3226, "split_group_id": "676db4ee9cbb2187e7cacde015006a507e39dbc8224785c6c5510bb73e50c45d", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline | Job creation | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 433, "id": "433:3227", "native_cluster": [3227], "perspective_id": 3227, "split_group_id": "676db4ee9cbb2187e7cacde015006a507e39dbc8224785c6c5510bb73e50c45d", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline | America should not become more dependent on oil | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 433, "id": "433:3230", "native_cluster": [3230, 23679, 23680], "perspective_id": 3230, "split_group_id": "676db4ee9cbb2187e7cacde015006a507e39dbc8224785c6c5510bb73e50c45d", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power | The nuclear industry has constantly required government bailouts and has never been commercially viable in an open market | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 523, "id": "523:3864", "native_cluster": [3864], "perspective_id": 3864, "split_group_id": "a62785f725f8b356c5f4d2ee7b9237fa1cc8408912ecc0e755d87e87759b05ca", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power | The nuclear industry is constantly judged on criteria that do not take its externalities into account | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 523, "id": "523:3865", "native_cluster": [3865], "perspective_id": 3865, "split_group_id": "a62785f725f8b356c5f4d2ee7b9237fa1cc8408912ecc0e755d87e87759b05ca", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power | There is no instance in which renewable energy has been able to provide a major share in the energy market | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 523, "id": "523:3867", "native_cluster": [3867], "perspective_id": 3867, "split_group_id": "a62785f725f8b356c5f4d2ee7b9237fa1cc8408912ecc0e755d87e87759b05ca", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power | Nuclear power has a proven track record in France, Canada and Russia and an increasing role in new energy markets | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 523, "id": "523:3869", "native_cluster": [3869], "perspective_id": 3869, "split_group_id": "a62785f725f8b356c5f4d2ee7b9237fa1cc8408912ecc0e755d87e87759b05ca", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power | Renewables are mostly unproven, experimental technologies being developed on a small-scale basis that is not ready to take up the gap to move away from fossil fuels under climate change agreements | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 523, "id": "523:3868", "native_cluster": [3868, 24293, 24294], "perspective_id": 3868, "split_group_id": "a62785f725f8b356c5f4d2ee7b9237fa1cc8408912ecc0e755d87e87759b05ca", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | Asbo's dont work - swift punishment may prevent bad behaviour later | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:7827", "native_cluster": [7827], "perspective_id": 7827, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | It brings fear in the person | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:7838", "native_cluster": [7838], "perspective_id": 7838, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | Allowing children to be hit sends the message that it is OK to treat children in this way. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:7842", "native_cluster": [7842], "perspective_id": 7842, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 0, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | It depends on how the actual punishement is administered | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:7829", "native_cluster": [7829], "perspective_id": 7829, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | Corporal punishment is the appropriate discipline for certain children when used in moderation. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:5085", "native_cluster": [5085, 25537, 25538], "perspective_id": 5085, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | Corporal punishment creates an unsafe and violent school environment. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:5089", "native_cluster": [5089, 25543, 25544], "perspective_id": 5089, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | Corporal punishment is an inappropriate punishment that harms the education of children. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:5088", "native_cluster": [5088, 25541, 25542], "perspective_id": 5088, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | Corporal punishment sets clear boundaries and motivates children to behave in school. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:5086", "native_cluster": [5086, 25539, 25540], "perspective_id": 5086, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced | Corporal punishment can inflict long-lasting physical and mental harm on students. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 976, "id": "976:5090", "native_cluster": [5090, 25545, 25546], "perspective_id": 5090, "split_group_id": "ab59f9061ea53f1f21aae30cb813ffe479cea8f3c83b86469180366f9b50bde1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Nuclear technology must be adopted | Nuclear power is very expensive | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 46, "id": "46:339", "native_cluster": [339, 21145, 21146], "perspective_id": 339, "split_group_id": "43457ad15ee47f11fe84745575864ff4e4b8ebb59d20895bcd59a8f253106da5", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
Nuclear technology must be adopted | Nuclear power gives countries energy security and self-sufficiency | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 46, "id": "46:338", "native_cluster": [338], "perspective_id": 338, "split_group_id": "43457ad15ee47f11fe84745575864ff4e4b8ebb59d20895bcd59a8f253106da5", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Resources have a negative influence on foreign policy in the Middle East | Oil = Rentier economies = weak internal cohesion | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 851, "id": "851:6918", "native_cluster": [6918, 26653, 26654], "perspective_id": 6918, "split_group_id": "fa62f6f1f6d5d892b916203a23cf326ff67ab78de4c6c7b185a15feaf092abe9", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Aid is killing Africa | ‘Systemic aid’ is detrimental to African society | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 693, "id": "693:5751", "native_cluster": [5751], "perspective_id": 5751, "split_group_id": "16ef64599cda26fbbe686f256bff57a19df883215d6f611118d7a6ae146a0174", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Aid is killing Africa | Aid serves a purpose and should not be discouraged | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 693, "id": "693:5756", "native_cluster": [5756], "perspective_id": 5756, "split_group_id": "16ef64599cda26fbbe686f256bff57a19df883215d6f611118d7a6ae146a0174", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Aid is killing Africa | Aid is donated inefficiently as a quick-fix solution | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 693, "id": "693:5752", "native_cluster": [5752], "perspective_id": 5752, "split_group_id": "16ef64599cda26fbbe686f256bff57a19df883215d6f611118d7a6ae146a0174", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Aid is killing Africa | £1 trillion of aid in the past 50 years has only caused the African economy to deteriorate | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 693, "id": "693:5749", "native_cluster": [5749], "perspective_id": 5749, "split_group_id": "16ef64599cda26fbbe686f256bff57a19df883215d6f611118d7a6ae146a0174", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There Should be a Minimum Weight Limit For Professional Models | Size zero models should be banned. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 612, "id": "612:5097", "native_cluster": [5097], "perspective_id": 5097, "split_group_id": "9cac8ece7fd0d64a6dc525ff3c7aad4d7470c99c04c814697c7e92b23e1bfbb8", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | Progressive taxes place an unfair and disproportionate burden on the wealthy | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4109", "native_cluster": [4109, 24472, 24473], "perspective_id": 4109, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | The ability to orchestrate a progressive taxation regime gives undue and dangerous power to the state | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4110", "native_cluster": [4110, 24474, 24475], "perspective_id": 4110, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | The aim of taxation should be to provide equality of opportunity, not of outcom | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4112", "native_cluster": [4112], "perspective_id": 4112, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [0, 0, 3, 0, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | Progressive systems are invariably highly complex and inefficient in implementation, breeding the knock-on inefficiencies of evasion and avoidance | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4111", "native_cluster": [4111], "perspective_id": 4111, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | A well-implemented progressive taxation scheme serve to promote economic growth | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4107", "native_cluster": [4107, 24471], "perspective_id": 4107, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | Individuals’ property and income are an index of deserving achievement, and of value contributed in the market place to society | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4108", "native_cluster": [4108], "perspective_id": 4108, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [0, 0, 3, 0, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | Those who have more owe more to the state | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4104", "native_cluster": [4104, 24466, 24467], "perspective_id": 4104, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | Progressive taxation promotes a more equal, more harmonious society | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4106", "native_cluster": [4106, 24468, 24469], "perspective_id": 4106, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There must be a progressive tax rate | Those able to pay more should pay more into the tax system | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 558, "id": "558:4103", "native_cluster": [4103, 24464, 24465], "perspective_id": 4103, "split_group_id": "a5aee1fbe646400b5a540f068e1eb1805a8df46db1cbb056e1a81032651dfa1e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Smoking should further be restricted | Restrictions reach out to the general population | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 6, "id": "6:42", "native_cluster": [42], "perspective_id": 42, "split_group_id": "009841343b0b0faef7c92a989a769e1ea4d4f27e2b50a680ed9faca4fc006e3d", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Smoking should further be restricted | Restrictions benefit the health of third parties | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 6, "id": "6:41", "native_cluster": [41, 20875, 20876], "perspective_id": 41, "split_group_id": "009841343b0b0faef7c92a989a769e1ea4d4f27e2b50a680ed9faca4fc006e3d", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Smoking should further be restricted | Democratic systems should educate on smoking rather than restrict it | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 6, "id": "6:45", "native_cluster": [45, 20878], "perspective_id": 45, "split_group_id": "009841343b0b0faef7c92a989a769e1ea4d4f27e2b50a680ed9faca4fc006e3d", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We have to offer amnesty to bloggers currently prosecuted by their native states | The offer of amnesty allows home governments to discredit bloggers and paint them as foreign agents of disruption | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 148, "id": "148:1096", "native_cluster": [1096], "perspective_id": 1096, "split_group_id": "db2e7a91d0fd639b7bf9689958f45a31081bbf8bb27d0d8e71a966c7ebddbf18", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 4, 0]} |
We have to offer amnesty to bloggers currently prosecuted by their native states | These people are under serious threat for their pursuit of justice | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 148, "id": "148:1091", "native_cluster": [1091], "perspective_id": 1091, "split_group_id": "db2e7a91d0fd639b7bf9689958f45a31081bbf8bb27d0d8e71a966c7ebddbf18", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We have to offer amnesty to bloggers currently prosecuted by their native states | An amnesty policy will serve only to alienate regimes, shutting down the possibility of discourse or reform | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 148, "id": "148:1094", "native_cluster": [1094], "perspective_id": 1094, "split_group_id": "db2e7a91d0fd639b7bf9689958f45a31081bbf8bb27d0d8e71a966c7ebddbf18", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 4, 0]} |
We have to offer amnesty to bloggers currently prosecuted by their native states | This offer of amnesty serves as a powerful public statement in favour of free speech and rule of law | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 148, "id": "148:1093", "native_cluster": [1093], "perspective_id": 1093, "split_group_id": "db2e7a91d0fd639b7bf9689958f45a31081bbf8bb27d0d8e71a966c7ebddbf18", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Neo-functionalism explains the integration of the European Union | Neo-functionalism explains the cause of integration | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 309, "id": "309:2288", "native_cluster": [2288], "perspective_id": 2288, "split_group_id": "ad10254ec2ff19ddc4bc19fffc19d7dd04faa332c53b24cb1a76a04bb8bfb6c7", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Neo-functionalism explains the integration of the European Union | Neo-functionalism proposes a purpose to EU integration. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 309, "id": "309:2289", "native_cluster": [2289], "perspective_id": 2289, "split_group_id": "ad10254ec2ff19ddc4bc19fffc19d7dd04faa332c53b24cb1a76a04bb8bfb6c7", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Wikipedia is a force for good | Wikipedia is an excellent starting point for enquiries | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 59, "id": "59:440", "native_cluster": [440, 21247, 21248], "perspective_id": 440, "split_group_id": "3a2af906a7f13c5138046ddd87fc70f94ced703f15fc1a5db614202d0a3a8d7b", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Wikipedia is a force for good | Wikipedia provides free, open access to knowledge | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 59, "id": "59:438", "native_cluster": [438], "perspective_id": 438, "split_group_id": "3a2af906a7f13c5138046ddd87fc70f94ced703f15fc1a5db614202d0a3a8d7b", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Socialism is a failed government subdomain | Both socialism and communism have their roots in the idea of utopianism; all are unrealistic, unachievable and deny the nature and dignity of the individual. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 680, "id": "680:5653", "native_cluster": [5653, 25919, 25920], "perspective_id": 5653, "split_group_id": "8de7212f1d29726881342426496c7a1e594f6c352e12d03407c618836b5a130c", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Socialism is a failed government subdomain | the reasoning in the debate summary is pitiful | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 680, "id": "680:5654", "native_cluster": [5654, 25921, 25922], "perspective_id": 5654, "split_group_id": "8de7212f1d29726881342426496c7a1e594f6c352e12d03407c618836b5a130c", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 1, 0]} |
Gender equality will not happen anytime soon | The media exploits women. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 819, "id": "819:6571", "native_cluster": [6571], "perspective_id": 6571, "split_group_id": "3efdbaa918c111ba506f1a4fc8d6f918d0447f26111309e77992f763a7271fc5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Gender equality will not happen anytime soon | Women are targeted for use in sexist advertising. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 819, "id": "819:26449", "native_cluster": [26449], "perspective_id": 26449, "split_group_id": "3efdbaa918c111ba506f1a4fc8d6f918d0447f26111309e77992f763a7271fc5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Barbie Dolls are affecting the mental image we create for ourselves | Lack of Ethnic Diversity | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 907, "id": "907:7241", "native_cluster": [7241], "perspective_id": 7241, "split_group_id": "41da8181cacd0e735e5783b61107e5af6a29f0b2db7e8dba89e841d71a91cefd", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Barbie Dolls are affecting the mental image we create for ourselves | Body image shaped in childhood can be conveyed into adulthood | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 907, "id": "907:7240", "native_cluster": [7240, 26797], "perspective_id": 7240, "split_group_id": "41da8181cacd0e735e5783b61107e5af6a29f0b2db7e8dba89e841d71a91cefd", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Adults should have the right to carry a concealed handgun | The majority of Americans support allowing the concealed carry of handguns. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 580, "id": "580:4562", "native_cluster": [4562, 24947], "perspective_id": 4562, "split_group_id": "65edd60f841c03c9ebfdf7c0dcb9d1f5ea340fb0ce2a9e9f16316940dad0b7f6", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Adults should have the right to carry a concealed handgun | Concealed carry application requirements and background checks do not prevent dangerous people from acquiring weapons. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 580, "id": "580:4566", "native_cluster": [4566, 24951, 24952], "perspective_id": 4566, "split_group_id": "65edd60f841c03c9ebfdf7c0dcb9d1f5ea340fb0ce2a9e9f16316940dad0b7f6", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Adults should have the right to carry a concealed handgun | Public safety should be left to professionally qualified police officers, not private citizens with little or no expert training. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 580, "id": "580:4568", "native_cluster": [4568, 24953, 24954], "perspective_id": 4568, "split_group_id": "65edd60f841c03c9ebfdf7c0dcb9d1f5ea340fb0ce2a9e9f16316940dad0b7f6", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Adults should have the right to carry a concealed handgun | Carrying a concealed handgun could help stop a public shooting spree. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 580, "id": "580:4560", "native_cluster": [4560, 24945, 24946], "perspective_id": 4560, "split_group_id": "65edd60f841c03c9ebfdf7c0dcb9d1f5ea340fb0ce2a9e9f16316940dad0b7f6", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Adults should have the right to carry a concealed handgun | Carrying a concealed handgun increases the chances of a confrontation escalating and turning lethal. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 580, "id": "580:4564", "native_cluster": [4564, 24949, 24950], "perspective_id": 4564, "split_group_id": "65edd60f841c03c9ebfdf7c0dcb9d1f5ea340fb0ce2a9e9f16316940dad0b7f6", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Adults should have the right to carry a concealed handgun | A handgun ban reduces crime and deaths | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 580, "id": "580:1643", "native_cluster": [1643, 22414, 22415], "perspective_id": 1643, "split_group_id": "65edd60f841c03c9ebfdf7c0dcb9d1f5ea340fb0ce2a9e9f16316940dad0b7f6", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
Adults should have the right to carry a concealed handgun | Handguns are uniquely dangerous when compared with other weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 580, "id": "580:1642", "native_cluster": [1642], "perspective_id": 1642, "split_group_id": "65edd60f841c03c9ebfdf7c0dcb9d1f5ea340fb0ce2a9e9f16316940dad0b7f6", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
African governments must implement tougher protections for animals | Natural habitats being are destroyed | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 484, "id": "484:3591", "native_cluster": [3591, 24006], "perspective_id": 3591, "split_group_id": "477398df0f6e5f4984926b9d6b27971424b4827afd667c046c58d474e725d853", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
African governments must implement tougher protections for animals | Poaching is linked to terrorism | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 484, "id": "484:3594", "native_cluster": [3594, 24008], "perspective_id": 3594, "split_group_id": "477398df0f6e5f4984926b9d6b27971424b4827afd667c046c58d474e725d853", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
African governments must implement tougher protections for animals | Heavy handed approaches do not solve the motivations for poaching | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 484, "id": "484:3599", "native_cluster": [3599, 24010, 24011], "perspective_id": 3599, "split_group_id": "477398df0f6e5f4984926b9d6b27971424b4827afd667c046c58d474e725d853", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Make the raising of business and labour standards a prerequisite for developmental aid | International labour and business standards go hand in hand with development standards and will de facto increase implementation levels | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 551, "id": "551:4051", "native_cluster": [4051], "perspective_id": 4051, "split_group_id": "dfde01fbf939b6aa805c6a9c1de1dc614eb4fe0227a2a908c06b58f8c903b8b6", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Allow donations of vital organs even at the expense of the donor's life | The role of society is to save lives not to assist in suicide | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 305, "id": "305:2264", "native_cluster": [2264], "perspective_id": 2264, "split_group_id": "103b6013e24d0b47a7c0d57144b99d89bda52545386ab6f57bfc21ac94853e19", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Allow donations of vital organs even at the expense of the donor's life | The recipient is forced to receive the sacrifice of another | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 305, "id": "305:2262", "native_cluster": [2262], "perspective_id": 2262, "split_group_id": "103b6013e24d0b47a7c0d57144b99d89bda52545386ab6f57bfc21ac94853e19", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
Allow donations of vital organs even at the expense of the donor's life | It is a natural thing to do | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 305, "id": "305:2256", "native_cluster": [2256], "perspective_id": 2256, "split_group_id": "103b6013e24d0b47a7c0d57144b99d89bda52545386ab6f57bfc21ac94853e19", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Allow donations of vital organs even at the expense of the donor's life | This would encourage coercion for some to die to save others | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 305, "id": "305:2263", "native_cluster": [2263], "perspective_id": 2263, "split_group_id": "103b6013e24d0b47a7c0d57144b99d89bda52545386ab6f57bfc21ac94853e19", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
EU member states should guarantee people under 25 a temporary workplace when they have been unemployed for six months | The policy is not a long term solution. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 549, "id": "549:4041", "native_cluster": [4041], "perspective_id": 4041, "split_group_id": "4062e083ec2c10a0e4c2f94e015afa0847c36cde73cbe7e6e0ea7389b671a3a7", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
EU member states should guarantee people under 25 a temporary workplace when they have been unemployed for six months | This policy is good for EU economies. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 549, "id": "549:4038", "native_cluster": [4038], "perspective_id": 4038, "split_group_id": "4062e083ec2c10a0e4c2f94e015afa0847c36cde73cbe7e6e0ea7389b671a3a7", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
EU member states should guarantee people under 25 a temporary workplace when they have been unemployed for six months | The EU should guarantee youth a job in order to equal their chances. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 549, "id": "549:4035", "native_cluster": [4035], "perspective_id": 4035, "split_group_id": "4062e083ec2c10a0e4c2f94e015afa0847c36cde73cbe7e6e0ea7389b671a3a7", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
EU member states should guarantee people under 25 a temporary workplace when they have been unemployed for six months | Temporary employment for youth acts against freedom of choice for businesses | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 549, "id": "549:4039", "native_cluster": [4039], "perspective_id": 4039, "split_group_id": "4062e083ec2c10a0e4c2f94e015afa0847c36cde73cbe7e6e0ea7389b671a3a7", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
EU member states should guarantee people under 25 a temporary workplace when they have been unemployed for six months | This policy would only serve to discriminate against unemployed people older than 25 | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 549, "id": "549:4040", "native_cluster": [4040, 24398, 24400, 24401], "perspective_id": 4040, "split_group_id": "4062e083ec2c10a0e4c2f94e015afa0847c36cde73cbe7e6e0ea7389b671a3a7", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
US must help in fighting terrorist organisations in Africa | African states can’t afford the full cost | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 295, "id": "295:2184", "native_cluster": [2184], "perspective_id": 2184, "split_group_id": "0d3e39727152f5c375e1c42aa4884a62028d352019e5e7bb940812a8c7c24f33", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
US must help in fighting terrorist organisations in Africa | Increased global security | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 295, "id": "295:2186", "native_cluster": [2186, 22982], "perspective_id": 2186, "split_group_id": "0d3e39727152f5c375e1c42aa4884a62028d352019e5e7bb940812a8c7c24f33", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
politicians have no right to privacy | All individuals have a legitimate right to privacy | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 147, "id": "147:1087", "native_cluster": [1087, 21851, 21852], "perspective_id": 1087, "split_group_id": "a2f4f33f67dfc3aa7e5c37571580742a6b0005291e365c7587573284825f5f51", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
politicians have no right to privacy | Citizens have a right to know who is being elected to represent them | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 147, "id": "147:1084", "native_cluster": [1084], "perspective_id": 1084, "split_group_id": "a2f4f33f67dfc3aa7e5c37571580742a6b0005291e365c7587573284825f5f51", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
politicians have no right to privacy | Heavy scrutiny forces politicians to dedicate themselves fully to their public service | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 147, "id": "147:1085", "native_cluster": [1085, 21849, 21850], "perspective_id": 1085, "split_group_id": "a2f4f33f67dfc3aa7e5c37571580742a6b0005291e365c7587573284825f5f51", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
politicians have no right to privacy | Fixating on personal lives results in infringing the rights of more than just the politicians themselves | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 147, "id": "147:1088", "native_cluster": [1088, 21853, 21854], "perspective_id": 1088, "split_group_id": "a2f4f33f67dfc3aa7e5c37571580742a6b0005291e365c7587573284825f5f51", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Leaving the EU would increase British security | Leaving the EU would mean leaving their security services too | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 320, "id": "320:23122", "native_cluster": [23122, 23123, 23117, 2374], "perspective_id": 23122, "split_group_id": "73fbebfbe1cff7f3188d896632ea55cbeafc28456dd417595c5675b2d3d19362", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Leaving the EU would increase British security | The EU causes instability | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 320, "id": "320:2370", "native_cluster": [2370, 23114, 23115], "perspective_id": 2370, "split_group_id": "73fbebfbe1cff7f3188d896632ea55cbeafc28456dd417595c5675b2d3d19362", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Leaving the EU would increase British security | Security is better shared | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 320, "id": "320:2373", "native_cluster": [2373, 23116, 23117, 23118, 23119], "perspective_id": 2373, "split_group_id": "73fbebfbe1cff7f3188d896632ea55cbeafc28456dd417595c5675b2d3d19362", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Leaving the EU would increase British security | A nation state can only rely on itself for security | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 320, "id": "320:2369", "native_cluster": [2369, 23108, 23109, 23110, 23111], "perspective_id": 2369, "split_group_id": "73fbebfbe1cff7f3188d896632ea55cbeafc28456dd417595c5675b2d3d19362", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Switzerland and Norway should apply to join the EU | The EU shares the same values as Norway and Switzerland | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 436, "id": "436:3252", "native_cluster": [3252, 23695], "perspective_id": 3252, "split_group_id": "a49dfbc72af7fc7060cf5ef4fd5fc6db22bce9d524c59e7d661820de75fa72c2", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Constitutions Should Not Give Special Recognition To Minority Groups | Lack of special recognition disables the acquisition of constitutional rights | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 834, "id": "834:6734", "native_cluster": [6734], "perspective_id": 6734, "split_group_id": "f5aff9d01f97e8388bf7b4f30eda6b694a9e282523bb2de3cc70f08ecc0be9d4", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Constitutions Should Not Give Special Recognition To Minority Groups | Special recognition protects and fortifies minority rights | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 834, "id": "834:6732", "native_cluster": [6732], "perspective_id": 6732, "split_group_id": "f5aff9d01f97e8388bf7b4f30eda6b694a9e282523bb2de3cc70f08ecc0be9d4", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
There must be compulsory identity cards | Identity cards can assist in the efficient monitoring of immigration | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 262, "id": "262:1930", "native_cluster": [1930, 22673], "perspective_id": 1930, "split_group_id": "0ee1c553b3a4bf5c639ec4a9b8b526dfc537ee60727213745ccedf0cf4ed9ea2", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There must be compulsory identity cards | The scheme does not prevent forgery or identity theft | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 262, "id": "262:1935", "native_cluster": [1935, 22679, 22680, 22681, 22682], "perspective_id": 1935, "split_group_id": "0ee1c553b3a4bf5c639ec4a9b8b526dfc537ee60727213745ccedf0cf4ed9ea2", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
There must be compulsory identity cards | Identity cards confer advantages on their users | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 262, "id": "262:1929", "native_cluster": [1929, 22671], "perspective_id": 1929, "split_group_id": "0ee1c553b3a4bf5c639ec4a9b8b526dfc537ee60727213745ccedf0cf4ed9ea2", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There must be compulsory identity cards | The scheme would cause inconvenience and public discontent | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 262, "id": "262:1936", "native_cluster": [1936, 22683, 22684, 22685, 22686], "perspective_id": 1936, "split_group_id": "0ee1c553b3a4bf5c639ec4a9b8b526dfc537ee60727213745ccedf0cf4ed9ea2", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There must be compulsory identity cards | Identity cards improve public safety | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 262, "id": "262:1928", "native_cluster": [1928, 22669], "perspective_id": 1928, "split_group_id": "0ee1c553b3a4bf5c639ec4a9b8b526dfc537ee60727213745ccedf0cf4ed9ea2", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There must be compulsory identity cards | An identity card scheme is open to subversion and abuse | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 262, "id": "262:1934", "native_cluster": [1934, 22675, 22676, 22677, 22678], "perspective_id": 1934, "split_group_id": "0ee1c553b3a4bf5c639ec4a9b8b526dfc537ee60727213745ccedf0cf4ed9ea2", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Proportional representation is necessary. | PR produces fairer results | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:58", "native_cluster": [58, 20881, 20882], "perspective_id": 58, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Proportional representation is necessary. | PR increases political engagement which benefits society. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:60", "native_cluster": [60, 20885, 20886], "perspective_id": 60, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.