sentence1 stringclasses 538
values | sentence2 stringlengths 12 241 | labels stringclasses 2
values | metadata stringlengths 187 265 |
|---|---|---|---|
Proportional representation is necessary. | PR leads to weaker government. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:62", "native_cluster": [62, 20887], "perspective_id": 62, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Proportional representation is necessary. | Extremist parties will rise under PR. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:66", "native_cluster": [66], "perspective_id": 66, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Proportional representation is necessary. | The link between constituencies and Members of Parliament is important. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:65", "native_cluster": [65, 20898], "perspective_id": 65, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Proportional representation is necessary. | Coalition government is a good thing. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:59", "native_cluster": [59, 20884], "perspective_id": 59, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
Proportional representation is necessary. | PR decreases political engagement. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:64", "native_cluster": [64, 20893], "perspective_id": 64, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Proportional representation is necessary. | PR creates an unfair balance of power. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 8, "id": "8:63", "native_cluster": [63, 20890, 20891], "perspective_id": 63, "split_group_id": "a998f09fa648cbee10fcf39f93afaa77d5367f903af7127e48f32abd238d4900", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Human-caused global warming is changing weather systems and making heat waves and droughts more intense and more frequent. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4968", "native_cluster": [4968], "perspective_id": 4968, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Global warming and cooling are primarily caused by fluctuations in the sun's heat (solar forcing), not by human activity. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4976", "native_cluster": [4976], "perspective_id": 4976, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Rising levels of human-produced gases released into the atmosphere create a greenhouse effect that traps heat and causes global warming. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4958", "native_cluster": [4958], "perspective_id": 4958, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Earth's climate has always warmed and cooled, and the 20th century rise in global temperature is within the bounds of natural temperature fluctuations over the past 3,000 years. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4972", "native_cluster": [4972], "perspective_id": 4972, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | More than one thousand scientists disagree that human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4971", "native_cluster": [4971], "perspective_id": 4971, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Global warming caused by human-produced greenhouse gases is causing the Arctic ice cap to melt at an increasing rate. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4963", "native_cluster": [4963], "perspective_id": 4963, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Predictions of accelerating human-caused climate change are based upon computerized climate models that are inadequate and incorrect. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4980", "native_cluster": [4980, 25388, 25389], "perspective_id": 4980, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Deep ocean currents, not human activity, are a primary driver of natural climate warming and cooling cycles. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4982", "native_cluster": [4982], "perspective_id": 4982, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Ocean acidity levels are increasing at an unprecedented rate that can only be explained by human activity. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4965", "native_cluster": [4965, 25384, 25385], "perspective_id": 4965, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | The specific type of CO2 that is increasing in earth's atmosphere can be directly connected to human activity. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4960", "native_cluster": [4960, 4959], "perspective_id": 4960, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Sea levels have been steadily rising for thousands of years, and the increase has nothing to do with humans. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4978", "native_cluster": [4978], "perspective_id": 4978, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | The acidity levels of the oceans are within past natural levels, and the current rise in acidity is a natural fluctuation, not the result of human caused climate change. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4979", "native_cluster": [4979], "perspective_id": 4979, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Overwhelming scientific consensus says human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4957", "native_cluster": [4957], "perspective_id": 4957, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Dramatic changes in precipitation, such as heavier storms and less snow, are another sign that humans are causing global climate change. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4969", "native_cluster": [4969], "perspective_id": 4969, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Rising levels of atmospheric CO2 do not necessarily cause global warming, which contradicts the core thesis of human-caused climate change. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4973", "native_cluster": [4973], "perspective_id": 4973, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Glaciers have been growing and receding for thousands of years due to natural causes, not human activity. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4981", "native_cluster": [4981, 25390, 25391], "perspective_id": 4981, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Increased hurricane activity and other extreme weather events are a result of natural weather patterns, not human-caused climate change. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:4983", "native_cluster": [4983, 25392], "perspective_id": 4983, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Human activity is primarily responsible for global climate change | Lack of scientific understanding | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 594, "id": "594:7234", "native_cluster": [7234], "perspective_id": 7234, "split_group_id": "f8dd28710b070af3e736ac66e44283afc6a7dcc0491a2c0810219c60c476e09e", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | Terrorists use our own media to terrify our people and create a climate of fear. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6935", "native_cluster": [6935, 26657, 26658], "perspective_id": 6935, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | Censorship of news can have a boomerang effect. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6944", "native_cluster": [6944, 26665, 26666], "perspective_id": 6944, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | Excessive publicity of terrorist acts corrupt good decision-making by placing undue focus upon terrorism. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6938", "native_cluster": [6938, 26661, 26662], "perspective_id": 6938, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | If you deny terrorists publicity, you prevent future terrorist attacks. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6934", "native_cluster": [6934], "perspective_id": 6934, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | Recruitment occurs through various other channels than through public news sources. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6943", "native_cluster": [6943], "perspective_id": 6943, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | Citizens and the world community have a right to be informed. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6942", "native_cluster": [6942], "perspective_id": 6942, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | The lack of extensive publicity would also reduce social unrest among citizens. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6939", "native_cluster": [6939], "perspective_id": 6939, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | The oxygen of publicity is a good way to expose terrorism. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6940", "native_cluster": [6940, 26664], "perspective_id": 6940, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Terrorism should not be allowed publicity | Publicity creates a public forum for terrorist organizations. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 853, "id": "853:6936", "native_cluster": [6936, 6937, 26659], "perspective_id": 6936, "split_group_id": "20a22fc024fd599d41d469aaa33d39ee2a6cc95f79b774616fbbfffd3284e19a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Any job is better than no job | Can leave you financially worse off. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 688, "id": "688:5711", "native_cluster": [5711], "perspective_id": 5711, "split_group_id": "763948e17bad06d05c647e3a8cf87ecb54c2860ba3c16f77cb69f2ee9af75143", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Any job is better than no job | Some jobs genuinely need higher qualifications. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 688, "id": "688:5713", "native_cluster": [5713], "perspective_id": 5713, "split_group_id": "763948e17bad06d05c647e3a8cf87ecb54c2860ba3c16f77cb69f2ee9af75143", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
India should give up Kashmir | Give it to the Roma. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 865, "id": "865:7055", "native_cluster": [7055], "perspective_id": 7055, "split_group_id": "fe745990ae44d4be604425004c782867f9a11ebc4ce0ab06594a987544bee674", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | Arming the rebels would be unpopular | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3132", "native_cluster": [3132, 23591, 23592], "perspective_id": 3132, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | Sovereignty and non intervention in internal affairs | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3131", "native_cluster": [3131, 23589, 23590], "perspective_id": 3131, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | Unforeseeable consequences | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3133", "native_cluster": [3133], "perspective_id": 3133, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | It is in the national interest for democracies to support those seeking to oust dictators | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3127", "native_cluster": [3127, 23587, 23588], "perspective_id": 3127, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | Diplomacy is not going anywhere | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3130", "native_cluster": [3130], "perspective_id": 3130, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | Would balance the support for Syrian government | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3129", "native_cluster": [3129], "perspective_id": 3129, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | Possibility of being drawn into a long drawn out conflict | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3134", "native_cluster": [3134], "perspective_id": 3134, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | The Free Syrian Army is outgunned | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3128", "native_cluster": [3128], "perspective_id": 3128, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The world must arm the Syrian rebels | Syria clearly meets the standards for intervention | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 420, "id": "420:3126", "native_cluster": [3126, 23586], "perspective_id": 3126, "split_group_id": "7519f3a5c4a1bbbbcc69c4a3c47f6bac1af8f9da799410cbd5c41dc478ca6c29", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Act to regulate the activities of Sovereign Wealth Funds | Sovereign Wealth funds are not transparent | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 557, "id": "557:4096", "native_cluster": [4096], "perspective_id": 4096, "split_group_id": "b0eaaeef80d783e6f08d02bb582737083427d816c347b4fa78775293523537bd", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Act to regulate the activities of Sovereign Wealth Funds | Sovereign wealth funds must be regulated | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 557, "id": "557:4098", "native_cluster": [4098], "perspective_id": 4098, "split_group_id": "b0eaaeef80d783e6f08d02bb582737083427d816c347b4fa78775293523537bd", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Act to regulate the activities of Sovereign Wealth Funds | SWFs can harm national security | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 557, "id": "557:4095", "native_cluster": [4095], "perspective_id": 4095, "split_group_id": "b0eaaeef80d783e6f08d02bb582737083427d816c347b4fa78775293523537bd", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Act to regulate the activities of Sovereign Wealth Funds | SWFs should be welcomed for the benefits they bring rather than ostracized for doing what others do. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 557, "id": "557:4102", "native_cluster": [4102], "perspective_id": 4102, "split_group_id": "b0eaaeef80d783e6f08d02bb582737083427d816c347b4fa78775293523537bd", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
We should detain terror suspects without trial | Internment without trial exacerbates the antagonism of enemies and subsequent risk to civilians. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 291, "id": "291:2156", "native_cluster": [2156, 22937, 22938], "perspective_id": 2156, "split_group_id": "21fdb0197d193d7c182791e7c0e9d587cebe50b3209c2295c3622f093b93f9ac", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
We should detain terror suspects without trial | Internment without trial encourages the bad behaviour of other states. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 291, "id": "291:2155", "native_cluster": [2155, 22935, 22936], "perspective_id": 2155, "split_group_id": "21fdb0197d193d7c182791e7c0e9d587cebe50b3209c2295c3622f093b93f9ac", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should detain terror suspects without trial | The protection of intelligence sources is more important than trying suspects. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 291, "id": "291:2153", "native_cluster": [2153, 22931, 22932, 22933, 22934], "perspective_id": 2153, "split_group_id": "21fdb0197d193d7c182791e7c0e9d587cebe50b3209c2295c3622f093b93f9ac", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should detain terror suspects without trial | Internment without trial undermines democratic values. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 291, "id": "291:2159", "native_cluster": [2159, 22943, 22944], "perspective_id": 2159, "split_group_id": "21fdb0197d193d7c182791e7c0e9d587cebe50b3209c2295c3622f093b93f9ac", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should detain terror suspects without trial | Internment without trial fails to make society safer. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 291, "id": "291:2158", "native_cluster": [2158, 22941, 22942], "perspective_id": 2158, "split_group_id": "21fdb0197d193d7c182791e7c0e9d587cebe50b3209c2295c3622f093b93f9ac", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should detain terror suspects without trial | The war on terror is not an armed conflict, and therefore internment without trial is illegal. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 291, "id": "291:2157", "native_cluster": [2157, 22939, 22940], "perspective_id": 2157, "split_group_id": "21fdb0197d193d7c182791e7c0e9d587cebe50b3209c2295c3622f093b93f9ac", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should detain terror suspects without trial | Tribunals are adequate replacements that maintain respect for detainees' rights. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 291, "id": "291:2152", "native_cluster": [2152, 22927, 22928, 22929, 22930], "perspective_id": 2152, "split_group_id": "21fdb0197d193d7c182791e7c0e9d587cebe50b3209c2295c3622f093b93f9ac", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Sao Tome would drop relations with Taiwan in favour of Mainland China | PRC is clearly the China that matters | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 476, "id": "476:3533", "native_cluster": [3533, 23968, 23969], "perspective_id": 3533, "split_group_id": "8e1da8d53838232c9f5f542e06cc598616b22fbeda05f4a33619b377625e2c12", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Sao Tome would drop relations with Taiwan in favour of Mainland China | Should recognise a democracy | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 476, "id": "476:3537", "native_cluster": [3537], "perspective_id": 3537, "split_group_id": "8e1da8d53838232c9f5f542e06cc598616b22fbeda05f4a33619b377625e2c12", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Sao Tome would drop relations with Taiwan in favour of Mainland China | Economically beneficial | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 476, "id": "476:3534", "native_cluster": [3534], "perspective_id": 3534, "split_group_id": "8e1da8d53838232c9f5f542e06cc598616b22fbeda05f4a33619b377625e2c12", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Ethiopia is right to build a dam on the River Nile | Economic benefits of the dam for Ethiopia | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 412, "id": "412:3069", "native_cluster": [3069, 23574], "perspective_id": 3069, "split_group_id": "2e911cff0e107ea158b41ad773c772711913b159f3f18aaf2af5168980155f53", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Ethiopia is right to build a dam on the River Nile | The dam is predicted to provide energy for all of Ethiopia | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 412, "id": "412:3068", "native_cluster": [3068, 23572], "perspective_id": 3068, "split_group_id": "2e911cff0e107ea158b41ad773c772711913b159f3f18aaf2af5168980155f53", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Ethiopia is right to build a dam on the River Nile | Ethiopia does not need another hydroelectric dam | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 412, "id": "412:3072", "native_cluster": [3072, 23575], "perspective_id": 3072, "split_group_id": "2e911cff0e107ea158b41ad773c772711913b159f3f18aaf2af5168980155f53", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Governments should lower the voting age to 16 | Parents are guardians and should be trusted to vote in their children’s interests | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 344, "id": "344:2562", "native_cluster": [2562, 23264, 23265], "perspective_id": 2562, "split_group_id": "ac514ed6e9ca456aca75e537c18633b825a4bc003efc96270a0399271a51796b", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Governments should lower the voting age to 16 | Voting at a lower age would increase participation | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 344, "id": "344:2560", "native_cluster": [2560, 23262, 23263], "perspective_id": 2560, "split_group_id": "ac514ed6e9ca456aca75e537c18633b825a4bc003efc96270a0399271a51796b", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Governments should lower the voting age to 16 | Young people would be more likely to misuse their vote | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 344, "id": "344:2564", "native_cluster": [2564, 23266, 23267], "perspective_id": 2564, "split_group_id": "ac514ed6e9ca456aca75e537c18633b825a4bc003efc96270a0399271a51796b", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Governments should lower the voting age to 16 | 16 year olds are mature enough to vote | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 344, "id": "344:2558", "native_cluster": [2558, 23260, 23261], "perspective_id": 2558, "split_group_id": "ac514ed6e9ca456aca75e537c18633b825a4bc003efc96270a0399271a51796b", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Governments should lower the voting age to 16 | At sixteen there is a lack of maturity that is necessary to vote responsibly. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 344, "id": "344:25792", "native_cluster": [25792, 25793, 25794, 5426, 5428, 25787, 25788, 25789, 25790, 25791], "perspective_id": 25792, "split_group_id": "ac514ed6e9ca456aca75e537c18633b825a4bc003efc96270a0399271a51796b", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Governments should lower the voting age to 16 | YES, give them the rights they deserve! | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 344, "id": "344:5269", "native_cluster": [5269, 25672, 25674, 25675], "perspective_id": 5269, "split_group_id": "ac514ed6e9ca456aca75e537c18633b825a4bc003efc96270a0399271a51796b", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Governments should lower the voting age to 16 | Would complicate elections | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 344, "id": "344:2173", "native_cluster": [2173, 22959, 22960, 22961, 22962], "perspective_id": 2173, "split_group_id": "ac514ed6e9ca456aca75e537c18633b825a4bc003efc96270a0399271a51796b", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 5, 0]} |
Criminal trials should not be televised, and the ICC is no exception | Broadcasting provides a public record | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 369, "id": "369:2749", "native_cluster": [2749, 23352, 23353], "perspective_id": 2749, "split_group_id": "8f6cbdb4093537eef299b2319b7f17b99fcd502bae0bd38f39fa02831b76f0d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 5, 0]} |
Criminal trials should not be televised, and the ICC is no exception | ICC does not have same problems as other legal systems | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 369, "id": "369:2747", "native_cluster": [2747], "perspective_id": 2747, "split_group_id": "8f6cbdb4093537eef299b2319b7f17b99fcd502bae0bd38f39fa02831b76f0d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 5, 0]} |
Criminal trials should not be televised, and the ICC is no exception | Televising turns justice into entertainment | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 369, "id": "369:2744", "native_cluster": [2744], "perspective_id": 2744, "split_group_id": "8f6cbdb4093537eef299b2319b7f17b99fcd502bae0bd38f39fa02831b76f0d5", "votes": [5, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Criminal trials should not be televised, and the ICC is no exception | Witnesses might be identified and placed in danger | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 369, "id": "369:2745", "native_cluster": [2745, 23350, 23351], "perspective_id": 2745, "split_group_id": "8f6cbdb4093537eef299b2319b7f17b99fcd502bae0bd38f39fa02831b76f0d5", "votes": [5, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
It is important to use foreign aid funds to research and distribute software that allows bloggers and journalists in non-democratic countries to evade censorship and conceal their online activities. | Funding technologies to evade censorship could have immense benefits for very little cost | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 12, "id": "12:91", "native_cluster": [91, 20937, 20938], "perspective_id": 91, "split_group_id": "3ca29c738c8f71d4005749ee88efa959e74060bc36abd110d705b9a460d6fe12", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
It is important to use foreign aid funds to research and distribute software that allows bloggers and journalists in non-democratic countries to evade censorship and conceal their online activities. | We all have an obligation to help maintain freedom of speech. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 12, "id": "12:89", "native_cluster": [89, 20935, 20936], "perspective_id": 89, "split_group_id": "3ca29c738c8f71d4005749ee88efa959e74060bc36abd110d705b9a460d6fe12", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
It is important to use foreign aid funds to research and distribute software that allows bloggers and journalists in non-democratic countries to evade censorship and conceal their online activities. | Violation of Sovereignty | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 12, "id": "12:92", "native_cluster": [92, 20939, 20940], "perspective_id": 92, "split_group_id": "3ca29c738c8f71d4005749ee88efa959e74060bc36abd110d705b9a460d6fe12", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
It is important to use foreign aid funds to research and distribute software that allows bloggers and journalists in non-democratic countries to evade censorship and conceal their online activities. | This will needlessly antagonise non-democratic countries | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 12, "id": "12:95", "native_cluster": [95], "perspective_id": 95, "split_group_id": "3ca29c738c8f71d4005749ee88efa959e74060bc36abd110d705b9a460d6fe12", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Build hydroelectric dams | Hydroelectric dams destroy communities | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 520, "id": "520:3852", "native_cluster": [3852, 24267, 24268, 24269, 24270], "perspective_id": 3852, "split_group_id": "79f8c00ba4d2bb8aa33d628be8e734fa8f6e32a7be0a20d2793b071e0c4f8b58", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Build hydroelectric dams | Hydroelectric dams increase methane emissions | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 520, "id": "520:3850", "native_cluster": [3850, 24259, 24261], "perspective_id": 3850, "split_group_id": "79f8c00ba4d2bb8aa33d628be8e734fa8f6e32a7be0a20d2793b071e0c4f8b58", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Build hydroelectric dams | Hydroelectric dams can be used to provide flood control and irrigation | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 520, "id": "520:3849", "native_cluster": [3849, 24255, 24256, 24257], "perspective_id": 3849, "split_group_id": "79f8c00ba4d2bb8aa33d628be8e734fa8f6e32a7be0a20d2793b071e0c4f8b58", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Build hydroelectric dams | Hydro electric dams reduce carbon dioxide emissions | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 520, "id": "520:3847", "native_cluster": [3847, 24248, 24249, 24250], "perspective_id": 3847, "split_group_id": "79f8c00ba4d2bb8aa33d628be8e734fa8f6e32a7be0a20d2793b071e0c4f8b58", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Build hydroelectric dams | Hydroelectric dams provide cheap access to renewable energy | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 520, "id": "520:3848", "native_cluster": [3848, 24252, 24253, 24254], "perspective_id": 3848, "split_group_id": "79f8c00ba4d2bb8aa33d628be8e734fa8f6e32a7be0a20d2793b071e0c4f8b58", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Build hydroelectric dams | Hydro electric dams destroy existing ecosystems | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 520, "id": "520:3851", "native_cluster": [3851, 24263, 24264, 24265, 24266], "perspective_id": 3851, "split_group_id": "79f8c00ba4d2bb8aa33d628be8e734fa8f6e32a7be0a20d2793b071e0c4f8b58", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Atheism is the only way | Entirely natural theories can adequately explain the existence and development of the Universe and all it contains, making God irrelevant to the discussion of reality: | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 26, "id": "26:193", "native_cluster": [193, 21039, 21040], "perspective_id": 193, "split_group_id": "40dcf4641ed5e5390ec36ae340d09ec8a6e45ccb0ef791253fbf933184ebacff", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Atheism is the only way | The nature of God as it is conventionally described is logically contradictory: | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 26, "id": "26:196", "native_cluster": [196, 21044], "perspective_id": 196, "split_group_id": "40dcf4641ed5e5390ec36ae340d09ec8a6e45ccb0ef791253fbf933184ebacff", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Atheism is the only way | Even if atheism was wrong and God did exist His seeming lack of interest and interaction with the Universe as far as humans can perceive means his existence is irrelevant: | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 26, "id": "26:199", "native_cluster": [199], "perspective_id": 199, "split_group_id": "40dcf4641ed5e5390ec36ae340d09ec8a6e45ccb0ef791253fbf933184ebacff", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Atheism is the only way | In the absence of positive evidence for the existence of God the rational position is agnosticism, not atheism: | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 26, "id": "26:200", "native_cluster": [200], "perspective_id": 200, "split_group_id": "40dcf4641ed5e5390ec36ae340d09ec8a6e45ccb0ef791253fbf933184ebacff", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Atheism is the only way | If there were a God there would be irrefutable evidence of His existence and people would feel compelled to belief by the fact of it: | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 26, "id": "26:195", "native_cluster": [195], "perspective_id": 195, "split_group_id": "40dcf4641ed5e5390ec36ae340d09ec8a6e45ccb0ef791253fbf933184ebacff", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Atheism is the only way | The complexity of the universe and of life cannot be explained by atheism: | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 26, "id": "26:201", "native_cluster": [201, 21047, 21048], "perspective_id": 201, "split_group_id": "40dcf4641ed5e5390ec36ae340d09ec8a6e45ccb0ef791253fbf933184ebacff", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
African leaders should be transparent about their health | The head of state/government must be accountable to the people | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 323, "id": "323:2394", "native_cluster": [2394, 23134, 23135], "perspective_id": 2394, "split_group_id": "aa1bb702ac032d22fb7a429936a74f2f4b4965dc878bf31c49892a6e40e309ca", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
African leaders should be transparent about their health | Transparency allows citizens to choose for a healthy leader as to ensure proper functioning | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 323, "id": "323:2396", "native_cluster": [2396, 23136, 23137], "perspective_id": 2396, "split_group_id": "aa1bb702ac032d22fb7a429936a74f2f4b4965dc878bf31c49892a6e40e309ca", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
African leaders should be transparent about their health | A lack of transparency can endanger the leader | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 323, "id": "323:2397", "native_cluster": [2397, 23138, 23139], "perspective_id": 2397, "split_group_id": "aa1bb702ac032d22fb7a429936a74f2f4b4965dc878bf31c49892a6e40e309ca", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should dramatically increase the rate of income tax paid by the rich | Income tax is not the best way to redistribute wealth or pay for public goods. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 924, "id": "924:7466", "native_cluster": [7466, 26908, 26909, 26910, 26911], "perspective_id": 7466, "split_group_id": "fad08f6bcc4c14cefb22c990188ba4c644c9d9aec88b276dd7e570d131afdece", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should dramatically increase the rate of income tax paid by the rich | Balancing governmental deficits for common good of society | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 924, "id": "924:7455", "native_cluster": [7455, 26900, 26901, 26902, 26903], "perspective_id": 7455, "split_group_id": "fad08f6bcc4c14cefb22c990188ba4c644c9d9aec88b276dd7e570d131afdece", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should dramatically increase the rate of income tax paid by the rich | Redistributing wealth to balance the inequality of income disparity | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 924, "id": "924:7454", "native_cluster": [7454, 26896, 26897, 26898], "perspective_id": 7454, "split_group_id": "fad08f6bcc4c14cefb22c990188ba4c644c9d9aec88b276dd7e570d131afdece", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should dramatically increase the rate of income tax paid by the rich | more taxes on rich could create more backlash | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 924, "id": "924:26906", "native_cluster": [26906, 7458, 7463], "perspective_id": 26906, "split_group_id": "fad08f6bcc4c14cefb22c990188ba4c644c9d9aec88b276dd7e570d131afdece", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Lesotho should be annexed by South Africa | Annexation is not needed where there is already extensive cooperation between the countries | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 297, "id": "297:2201", "native_cluster": [2201], "perspective_id": 2201, "split_group_id": "dafa041eec41ef3b55bb7b98a8b04b27de70d59867b583e4a38045cceff159a1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Lesotho should be annexed by South Africa | Lesotho is in a dire condition and needs help from its closest ally | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 297, "id": "297:2199", "native_cluster": [2199, 22990], "perspective_id": 2199, "split_group_id": "dafa041eec41ef3b55bb7b98a8b04b27de70d59867b583e4a38045cceff159a1", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Lesotho should be annexed by South Africa | It is not in the interest of South Africa to annex a poor, underdeveloped country | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 297, "id": "297:2203", "native_cluster": [2203, 22995, 22996, 22997, 22998], "perspective_id": 2203, "split_group_id": "dafa041eec41ef3b55bb7b98a8b04b27de70d59867b583e4a38045cceff159a1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Lesotho should be annexed by South Africa | South Africa will gain influence, stability and a better image on the international stage | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 297, "id": "297:2200", "native_cluster": [2200, 22991], "perspective_id": 2200, "split_group_id": "dafa041eec41ef3b55bb7b98a8b04b27de70d59867b583e4a38045cceff159a1", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.