sentence1 stringclasses 538
values | sentence2 stringlengths 12 241 | labels stringclasses 2
values | metadata stringlengths 187 265 |
|---|---|---|---|
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | The development of tactical nuclear weapons by one state would lead to a new global arms race. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:2082", "native_cluster": [2082], "perspective_id": 2082, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Countries need to design nuclear devices to adapt with changing defensive technology. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:2074", "native_cluster": [2074], "perspective_id": 2074, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Tactical nuclear weapons are very expensive to design and build, yet will likely have no new strategic value. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:2079", "native_cluster": [2079], "perspective_id": 2079, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Tactical nuclear warheads are more serviceable for use in intimidation and retaliation toward enemies, as they are considerably less catastrophically destructive than those of current nuclear arsenals. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:2076", "native_cluster": [2076], "perspective_id": 2076, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | The way tactical nuclear weapons need to be deployed control of their use is devolved to field commanders, vastly increasing the probability that in the event of conflict they would be used. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:2081", "native_cluster": [2081], "perspective_id": 2081, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:1573", "native_cluster": [1573, 22362, 22364], "perspective_id": 1573, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:1575", "native_cluster": [1575, 22369, 22370, 22372], "perspective_id": 1575, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons are required for deterrence | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:2088", "native_cluster": [2088, 1570], "perspective_id": 2088, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons give states valuable agenda-setting power on the international stage | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:1568", "native_cluster": [1568, 22357, 22359], "perspective_id": 1568, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:1574", "native_cluster": [1574], "perspective_id": 1574, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | No country has an inherent right to invade or use aggression against another. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:1989", "native_cluster": [1989], "perspective_id": 1989, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | The United States has an obligation to protect international stability due to its unique military strength. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:1982", "native_cluster": [1982, 22725, 22726], "perspective_id": 1982, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5265", "native_cluster": [5265], "perspective_id": 5265, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Disarmament is impossible, rendering efforts to disarm pointless and simply wasteful | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5264", "native_cluster": [5264, 2089], "perspective_id": 5264, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 1, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Small countries would be able to pursue their independence without having to rely on larger countries. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:26469", "native_cluster": [26469, 25670, 26470, 25671, 5262, 6621], "perspective_id": 26469, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5263", "native_cluster": [5263], "perspective_id": 5263, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5257", "native_cluster": [5257], "perspective_id": 5257, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:1984", "native_cluster": [1984, 2085, 5254, 22727, 22728, 5255], "perspective_id": 1984, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5256", "native_cluster": [5256], "perspective_id": 5256, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5258", "native_cluster": [5258], "perspective_id": 5258, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 2]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | All the people worldwide have the same rights and are equal to one another. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:6620", "native_cluster": [6620], "perspective_id": 6620, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:6619", "native_cluster": [6619], "perspective_id": 6619, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | any conflict will rapidly de-escalate | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5410", "native_cluster": [5410, 25769, 25770], "perspective_id": 5410, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | both sides will avoid threatening vital interests | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:5411", "native_cluster": [5411], "perspective_id": 5411, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There is a need for developing tactical nuclear weapons | Both the use and threat of nuclear weapons are illegal | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 281, "id": "281:2086", "native_cluster": [2086], "perspective_id": 2086, "split_group_id": "7ccb7c6150072a2f49318cfc4fbf15e2561afbc9e8107292d94879d9f06e50d5", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Greece should default on its debt and return to the Drachma | Defaulting would be the quickest route to economic recovery | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 231, "id": "231:1706", "native_cluster": [1706], "perspective_id": 1706, "split_group_id": "cb20414d728b1408a485146843cb4b55907db584f8ab155e9bc37aa378d504fb", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Greece should default on its debt and return to the Drachma | A Greek default would have a negative domino-effect on other Eurozone countries. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 231, "id": "231:1710", "native_cluster": [1710], "perspective_id": 1710, "split_group_id": "cb20414d728b1408a485146843cb4b55907db584f8ab155e9bc37aa378d504fb", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The state should provide broadband internet through nationalized companies | The state can work more effectively through the private sector | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 152, "id": "152:1126", "native_cluster": [1126], "perspective_id": 1126, "split_group_id": "9816dc13d5feddf9d1ef340cd7e5bd86dcac0dc035cc5b9b40a526017b16be11", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
The state should provide broadband internet through nationalized companies | It would provide an efficient service for everyone | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 152, "id": "152:1122", "native_cluster": [1122, 21873, 21874], "perspective_id": 1122, "split_group_id": "9816dc13d5feddf9d1ef340cd7e5bd86dcac0dc035cc5b9b40a526017b16be11", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The state should provide broadband internet through nationalized companies | The information age demands a right to broadband access | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 152, "id": "152:1121", "native_cluster": [1121, 21871, 21872], "perspective_id": 1121, "split_group_id": "9816dc13d5feddf9d1ef340cd7e5bd86dcac0dc035cc5b9b40a526017b16be11", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The state should provide broadband internet through nationalized companies | Broad-based access to broadband is essential for countries to be competitive and to excel | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 152, "id": "152:1123", "native_cluster": [1123, 21875, 21876], "perspective_id": 1123, "split_group_id": "9816dc13d5feddf9d1ef340cd7e5bd86dcac0dc035cc5b9b40a526017b16be11", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Immunity for head of state is a good idea | Necessity for diplomatic relations | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 368, "id": "368:2738", "native_cluster": [2738], "perspective_id": 2738, "split_group_id": "1e280597719098d9125c0659b9b58700984d2c642c5946074723e97e6a1adbe5", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Immunity for head of state is a good idea | Helps avoid political stunt trials | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 368, "id": "368:2739", "native_cluster": [2739, 23348, 23349], "perspective_id": 2739, "split_group_id": "1e280597719098d9125c0659b9b58700984d2c642c5946074723e97e6a1adbe5", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | There are more efficient policies than death penalty | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:5608", "native_cluster": [5608, 25893, 25894], "perspective_id": 5608, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | we are increasing the hate inside terrorist organizations and the dead person will be seen as a hero that animates their fight. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:5609", "native_cluster": [5609, 25895, 25896], "perspective_id": 5609, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | Execution helps alleviate the overcrowding of prisons. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2221", "native_cluster": [2221, 23019, 23020], "perspective_id": 2221, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [3, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | The death penalty can produce irreversible miscarriages of justice. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2225", "native_cluster": [2225, 23025, 23026], "perspective_id": 2225, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 4, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | Necessary for punitive justice | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2722", "native_cluster": [2722, 23018, 2220], "perspective_id": 2722, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | The death penalty is a financial burden on the state. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2223", "native_cluster": [2223, 23023, 23024], "perspective_id": 2223, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | The penalty of death is a crime deterrent. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:23011", "native_cluster": [23011, 23012, 23013, 23014, 2218, 2219], "perspective_id": 23011, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | State-sanctioned killing is wrong. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2222", "native_cluster": [2222, 23021, 23022], "perspective_id": 2222, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | Too many innocents killed | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2727", "native_cluster": [2727, 23344, 23345], "perspective_id": 2727, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | Can be reserved for the worst of the worst | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2724", "native_cluster": [2724, 23342, 23343], "perspective_id": 2724, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The Death Penalty Should Be Imposed For Acts Of Terror That Cause Death | Killers must die to satisfy society | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 674, "id": "674:2725", "native_cluster": [2725], "perspective_id": 2725, "split_group_id": "5ea0661c9105ef1885bc6222e389d90d4aef459af3c7c20a8832ed138e38d8c8", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There should be video replays for refs in football | Only in Top Class football - make a monitor available to the match officials for replay of 'ball over the goal line' incidents only. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 692, "id": "692:5743", "native_cluster": [5743], "perspective_id": 5743, "split_group_id": "c0a7fd0d3467a7e9e88161aec4fc715233440c0f0779b6798fb7fbc4039c6de9", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There should be video replays for refs in football | Video replays would take away from the entertainment | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 692, "id": "692:5744", "native_cluster": [5744, 25946], "perspective_id": 5744, "split_group_id": "c0a7fd0d3467a7e9e88161aec4fc715233440c0f0779b6798fb7fbc4039c6de9", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
There should be video replays for refs in football | Football is political and we love to analyse | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 692, "id": "692:5746", "native_cluster": [5746], "perspective_id": 5746, "split_group_id": "c0a7fd0d3467a7e9e88161aec4fc715233440c0f0779b6798fb7fbc4039c6de9", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
There should be video replays for refs in football | It would ruin football’s simplicity and non-exclusivity. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 692, "id": "692:5747", "native_cluster": [5747, 25947, 25948], "perspective_id": 5747, "split_group_id": "c0a7fd0d3467a7e9e88161aec4fc715233440c0f0779b6798fb7fbc4039c6de9", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Slang prevent young people from being able to communicate properly | Slang prevents young people to become potential employers as well as prepared for the future | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 737, "id": "737:6086", "native_cluster": [6086, 26128, 26129], "perspective_id": 6086, "split_group_id": "6c7462ef7e96e4052928eff659a5a5aeb82d65b846fe7a8ab4bf5ce75feda68f", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We must extend NATO membership to Georgia and Ukraine | Expansion is in the interests of NATO | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 265, "id": "265:1951", "native_cluster": [1951, 22707], "perspective_id": 1951, "split_group_id": "2a3adf2f2543f528820b1886f1ed7ea4d7a61d64d05f92edf2982f0577748101", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
We must extend NATO membership to Georgia and Ukraine | The people of Ukraine and Georgia want to join | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 265, "id": "265:1950", "native_cluster": [1950, 22705], "perspective_id": 1950, "split_group_id": "2a3adf2f2543f528820b1886f1ed7ea4d7a61d64d05f92edf2982f0577748101", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
We must extend NATO membership to Georgia and Ukraine | There is a strong precedent for expansion | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 265, "id": "265:1952", "native_cluster": [1952, 22710], "perspective_id": 1952, "split_group_id": "2a3adf2f2543f528820b1886f1ed7ea4d7a61d64d05f92edf2982f0577748101", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Net neutrality regulations are unnecessary because the internet developed amazingly well in their absence | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:5027", "native_cluster": [5027], "perspective_id": 5027, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 6, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Net neutrality reduces investment in internet services resulting in less access and higher costs for consumers | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:5029", "native_cluster": [5029], "perspective_id": 5029, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 6, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Net neutrality protects consumers by preventing ISPs from speeding, slowing, or charging higher fees for select online content | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:5025", "native_cluster": [5025, 25444, 25445, 25446, 25447], "perspective_id": 5025, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [6, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Net neutrality created burdensome and overreaching regulations to govern the internet | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:5028", "native_cluster": [5028, 25452, 25453, 25454, 25455, 8115], "perspective_id": 5028, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 6, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Free speech is a right that should be allowed online. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:25440", "native_cluster": [25440, 5024, 25441, 25442, 27209, 27210, 8113], "perspective_id": 25440, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [5, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Net neutrality is required to preserve the existing structure of the internet. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:8117", "native_cluster": [8117], "perspective_id": 8117, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | A government that ensures net neutrality is one that violates principles of freedom. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:8119", "native_cluster": [8119, 27211, 27212], "perspective_id": 8119, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Net neutrality provides for the free circulation of data and services. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:8112", "native_cluster": [8112], "perspective_id": 8112, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Ensuring net neutrality represents excessive government regulation and control over business. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:8118", "native_cluster": [8118], "perspective_id": 8118, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Net neutrality should be restored | Net neutrality promotes competition by providing a level playing field for new companies | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 600, "id": "600:5026", "native_cluster": [5026, 25448, 25449, 25450, 25451, 8114], "perspective_id": 5026, "split_group_id": "f20c9604fda711c3c8ffabd427bda5ffed41e857fd029de3137d3ee99356ea5a", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5265", "native_cluster": [5265], "perspective_id": 5265, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Disarmament is impossible, rendering efforts to disarm pointless and simply wasteful | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5264", "native_cluster": [5264, 5708], "perspective_id": 5264, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 1, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, as there can never be any guarantee that a nation has disarmed | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5262", "native_cluster": [5262, 25670, 25671], "perspective_id": 5262, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5263", "native_cluster": [5263], "perspective_id": 5263, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5257", "native_cluster": [5257], "perspective_id": 5257, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5256", "native_cluster": [5256], "perspective_id": 5256, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5258", "native_cluster": [5258], "perspective_id": 5258, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:1984", "native_cluster": [1984, 5254, 5255, 22728, 22727], "perspective_id": 1984, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:1573", "native_cluster": [1573, 22362, 22364], "perspective_id": 1573, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:1575", "native_cluster": [1575, 22369, 22370, 22372], "perspective_id": 1575, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 2, 1, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Public acknowledgement of the right to nuclear deterrence will benefit the public regulation of nuclear weapons generally | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:1570", "native_cluster": [1570], "perspective_id": 1570, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons give states valuable agenda-setting power on the international stage | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:1568", "native_cluster": [1568, 22357, 22359], "perspective_id": 1568, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | All countries have a right to defend themselves with nuclear weapons, even when they lack the capacity in conventional weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:1566", "native_cluster": [1566, 22353, 22354, 22355, 22356], "perspective_id": 1566, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:1574", "native_cluster": [1574], "perspective_id": 1574, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [0, 2, 1, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | There will be less nuclear weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5707", "native_cluster": [5707], "perspective_id": 5707, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
States ought not possess nuclear weapons | The potential for a safer world. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 633, "id": "633:5706", "native_cluster": [5706], "perspective_id": 5706, "split_group_id": "6f8d28dec116e556f453dd869b6df513f5f4f4dcfe891a25087673ad0363e3f1", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Foreign workers should be given the right to vote in local elections where they work | Granting Foreign Workers Suffrage would Protect Them from Human Exploitation | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 967, "id": "967:7734", "native_cluster": [7734], "perspective_id": 7734, "split_group_id": "6624a5b09b30a2b3a16e77d24663b52729939583a31873d043855fedc64bae15", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons are required for deterrence | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:2088", "native_cluster": [2088, 1570], "perspective_id": 2088, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1984", "native_cluster": [1984, 2085, 5254, 22727, 22728, 5255], "perspective_id": 1984, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Disarmament is impossible, rendering efforts to disarm pointless and simply wasteful | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5264", "native_cluster": [5264, 2089], "perspective_id": 5264, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Both the use and threat of nuclear weapons are illegal | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:2086", "native_cluster": [2086], "perspective_id": 2086, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1573", "native_cluster": [1573, 22362, 22364], "perspective_id": 1573, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1575", "native_cluster": [1575, 22369, 22370, 22372], "perspective_id": 1575, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 2, 1, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Nuclear weapons give states valuable agenda-setting power on the international stage | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1568", "native_cluster": [1568, 22357, 22359], "perspective_id": 1568, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | All countries have a right to defend themselves with nuclear weapons, even when they lack the capacity in conventional weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1566", "native_cluster": [1566, 22353, 22354, 22355, 22356], "perspective_id": 1566, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1574", "native_cluster": [1574], "perspective_id": 1574, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 2, 1, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | No country has an inherent right to invade or use aggression against another. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1989", "native_cluster": [1989], "perspective_id": 1989, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | The United States has an obligation to protect international stability due to its unique military strength. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1982", "native_cluster": [1982, 22725, 22726], "perspective_id": 1982, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | [Iran specific] Others, particularly Israel, would act if the United States did not | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:1987", "native_cluster": [1987, 22731], "perspective_id": 1987, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5265", "native_cluster": [5265], "perspective_id": 5265, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Small countries would be able to pursue their independence without having to rely on larger countries. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:26469", "native_cluster": [26469, 25670, 26470, 25671, 5262, 6621], "perspective_id": 26469, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5263", "native_cluster": [5263], "perspective_id": 5263, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5257", "native_cluster": [5257], "perspective_id": 5257, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5256", "native_cluster": [5256], "perspective_id": 5256, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5258", "native_cluster": [5258], "perspective_id": 5258, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | All the people worldwide have the same rights and are equal to one another. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:6620", "native_cluster": [6620], "perspective_id": 6620, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:6619", "native_cluster": [6619], "perspective_id": 6619, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 3]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | any conflict will rapidly de-escalate | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5410", "native_cluster": [5410, 25769, 25770], "perspective_id": 5410, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 3]} |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.