sentence1 stringclasses 538
values | sentence2 stringlengths 12 241 | labels stringclasses 2
values | metadata stringlengths 187 265 |
|---|---|---|---|
Abolish nuclear weapons | both sides will avoid threatening vital interests | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:5411", "native_cluster": [5411], "perspective_id": 5411, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 3]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | The development of tactical nuclear weapons by one state would lead to a new global arms race. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:2082", "native_cluster": [2082], "perspective_id": 2082, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Countries need to design nuclear devices to adapt with changing defensive technology. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:2074", "native_cluster": [2074], "perspective_id": 2074, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 3]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Tactical nuclear weapons are very expensive to design and build, yet will likely have no new strategic value. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:2079", "native_cluster": [2079], "perspective_id": 2079, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 3, 0, 0, 0]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | Tactical nuclear warheads are more serviceable for use in intimidation and retaliation toward enemies, as they are considerably less catastrophically destructive than those of current nuclear arsenals. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:2076", "native_cluster": [2076], "perspective_id": 2076, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 0, 3]} |
Abolish nuclear weapons | The way tactical nuclear weapons need to be deployed control of their use is devolved to field commanders, vastly increasing the probability that in the event of conflict they would be used. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 282, "id": "282:2081", "native_cluster": [2081], "perspective_id": 2081, "split_group_id": "ab85f5d65651c6e4b2f440b17eafc57161ed6335ccff1eed57aea09d4763febd", "votes": [0, 2, 1, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the depiction of smoking in films | Tobacco companies may use movies to circumvent bans on advertising cigarettes | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 381, "id": "381:2831", "native_cluster": [2831, 23388, 23389], "perspective_id": 2831, "split_group_id": "60bbc5e49556101d0ec17ddc3ff8512d7a5560d047d56619edf58a9c612cec34", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the depiction of smoking in films | Depictions of glamourous and famous people smoking could be seen as an endorsement of the habit | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 381, "id": "381:2830", "native_cluster": [2830], "perspective_id": 2830, "split_group_id": "60bbc5e49556101d0ec17ddc3ff8512d7a5560d047d56619edf58a9c612cec34", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the depiction of smoking in films | Film does not directly influence the actions and decisions of individuals | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 381, "id": "381:2836", "native_cluster": [2836, 23392, 23393], "perspective_id": 2836, "split_group_id": "60bbc5e49556101d0ec17ddc3ff8512d7a5560d047d56619edf58a9c612cec34", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should ban the depiction of smoking in films | The act of smoking is often portrayed postively in films | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 381, "id": "381:2832", "native_cluster": [2832], "perspective_id": 2832, "split_group_id": "60bbc5e49556101d0ec17ddc3ff8512d7a5560d047d56619edf58a9c612cec34", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the depiction of smoking in films | A blanket ban on depictions of smoking ignores the context that it might be used in by directors | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 381, "id": "381:2835", "native_cluster": [2835], "perspective_id": 2835, "split_group_id": "60bbc5e49556101d0ec17ddc3ff8512d7a5560d047d56619edf58a9c612cec34", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
We should ban the depiction of smoking in films | The state has no right to interfere in this particular form of free expression | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 381, "id": "381:2834", "native_cluster": [2834, 23390, 23391], "perspective_id": 2834, "split_group_id": "60bbc5e49556101d0ec17ddc3ff8512d7a5560d047d56619edf58a9c612cec34", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The US should have done more for Darfur | The Conflict is an internal inter-tribal conflict – arming the Darfur tribes would be better | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 386, "id": "386:2872", "native_cluster": [2872], "perspective_id": 2872, "split_group_id": "21666ad51d5b820997993ab9368d438b5308f9027151a4bd12e79333fa37132d", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
The US should have done more for Darfur | Airstrikes would likely be politically ineffective | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 386, "id": "386:2870", "native_cluster": [2870], "perspective_id": 2870, "split_group_id": "21666ad51d5b820997993ab9368d438b5308f9027151a4bd12e79333fa37132d", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The US should have done more for Darfur | Intervention might destabilize the peace deal in the South | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 386, "id": "386:2871", "native_cluster": [2871, 23409], "perspective_id": 2871, "split_group_id": "21666ad51d5b820997993ab9368d438b5308f9027151a4bd12e79333fa37132d", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Wind farms are a good solution to the energy crisis | Wind Farms Help Reduce Carbon Emissions | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 733, "id": "733:6055", "native_cluster": [6055], "perspective_id": 6055, "split_group_id": "87e757ee1e40b7789001590516cf6b0dcbe01f7ee0cf1225cde2c00fffdd02f0", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Wind farms are a good solution to the energy crisis | Cost will make energy prices rise | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 733, "id": "733:6060", "native_cluster": [6060], "perspective_id": 6060, "split_group_id": "87e757ee1e40b7789001590516cf6b0dcbe01f7ee0cf1225cde2c00fffdd02f0", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The European Union should be a trade bloc rather than a political union | A European political union intrudes on its members’ sovereignty | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 418, "id": "418:3110", "native_cluster": [3110, 23579, 23580], "perspective_id": 3110, "split_group_id": "dd92d06441c122ebe937faa7c1bcaf4cab216b18a508da710113e027bde607a3", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The European Union should be a trade bloc rather than a political union | Political union has numerous non-economic benefits which a trade bloc lacks | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 418, "id": "418:3117", "native_cluster": [3117], "perspective_id": 3117, "split_group_id": "dd92d06441c122ebe937faa7c1bcaf4cab216b18a508da710113e027bde607a3", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 2, 0]} |
The European Union should be a trade bloc rather than a political union | The EU as a trade bloc would be more inclusive to current and new members | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 418, "id": "418:3111", "native_cluster": [3111], "perspective_id": 3111, "split_group_id": "dd92d06441c122ebe937faa7c1bcaf4cab216b18a508da710113e027bde607a3", "votes": [2, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The European Union should be a trade bloc rather than a political union | A European trade bloc can succeed without a political union | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 418, "id": "418:3112", "native_cluster": [3112], "perspective_id": 3112, "split_group_id": "dd92d06441c122ebe937faa7c1bcaf4cab216b18a508da710113e027bde607a3", "votes": [1, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The European Union should be a trade bloc rather than a political union | The EU now has the necessary foreign policy organs. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 418, "id": "418:3305", "native_cluster": [3305], "perspective_id": 3305, "split_group_id": "dd92d06441c122ebe937faa7c1bcaf4cab216b18a508da710113e027bde607a3", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 1, 2]} |
We must invade and forcibly reunify the Korean peninsula | Reunification of the Korea peninsular is unaffordable | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 266, "id": "266:1959", "native_cluster": [1959], "perspective_id": 1959, "split_group_id": "42b98f58a9ebfd65e3c94661ec027632ad62852ee88770edf0869190014a6b9f", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
We must invade and forcibly reunify the Korean peninsula | Forcible "liberation" is contrary to the principle of self determination | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 266, "id": "266:1960", "native_cluster": [1960, 22711], "perspective_id": 1960, "split_group_id": "42b98f58a9ebfd65e3c94661ec027632ad62852ee88770edf0869190014a6b9f", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
We must invade and forcibly reunify the Korean peninsula | There is little interest in unification among young people in South Korea | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 266, "id": "266:1961", "native_cluster": [1961, 22713], "perspective_id": 1961, "split_group_id": "42b98f58a9ebfd65e3c94661ec027632ad62852ee88770edf0869190014a6b9f", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Any society must have a national minimum wage | The minimum wage restricts an individual’s fundamental right to work | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 554, "id": "554:4078", "native_cluster": [4078, 24442, 24443], "perspective_id": 4078, "split_group_id": "4de81041ec3a648cc64bf743f92496619c92daccbd06d0831f7563abdc3dc399", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Any society must have a national minimum wage | The minimum wage is little more than a political tool that ultimately harms the overall economy by raising the unemployment rate and driving businesses elsewhere | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 554, "id": "554:4080", "native_cluster": [4080, 24444, 24445], "perspective_id": 4080, "split_group_id": "4de81041ec3a648cc64bf743f92496619c92daccbd06d0831f7563abdc3dc399", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Any society must have a national minimum wage | The minimum wage encourages people to join the workforce rather than pursuing income through illegal channels | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 554, "id": "554:4077", "native_cluster": [4077], "perspective_id": 4077, "split_group_id": "4de81041ec3a648cc64bf743f92496619c92daccbd06d0831f7563abdc3dc399", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Any society must have a national minimum wage | The minimum wage provides a baseline minimum allowing people to embark freely in the pursuit of happiness | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 554, "id": "554:4075", "native_cluster": [4075, 24437], "perspective_id": 4075, "split_group_id": "4de81041ec3a648cc64bf743f92496619c92daccbd06d0831f7563abdc3dc399", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Any society must have a national minimum wage | Higher wages boost economic growth | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 554, "id": "554:4076", "native_cluster": [4076, 24439], "perspective_id": 4076, "split_group_id": "4de81041ec3a648cc64bf743f92496619c92daccbd06d0831f7563abdc3dc399", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Any society must have a national minimum wage | The free market tends to treat workers fairly | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 554, "id": "554:4081", "native_cluster": [4081], "perspective_id": 4081, "split_group_id": "4de81041ec3a648cc64bf743f92496619c92daccbd06d0831f7563abdc3dc399", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 1, 0]} |
Any society must have a national minimum wage | The minimum wage aids in the propagation of social justice and the fair treatment of workers | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 554, "id": "554:4074", "native_cluster": [4074, 24434, 24435], "perspective_id": 4074, "split_group_id": "4de81041ec3a648cc64bf743f92496619c92daccbd06d0831f7563abdc3dc399", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Europe still needs a constitution | The ECJ has often been accused of over-stepping the legitimate boundaries of | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 429, "id": "429:3200", "native_cluster": [3200, 23653, 23654, 23655, 23656], "perspective_id": 3200, "split_group_id": "653a6ad37f699c04801370d04a11b32726cd06cf6d343f54d8430de45565f561", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Europe still needs a constitution | There already are constitutional documents | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 429, "id": "429:3201", "native_cluster": [3201, 23657, 23658], "perspective_id": 3201, "split_group_id": "653a6ad37f699c04801370d04a11b32726cd06cf6d343f54d8430de45565f561", "votes": [0, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
Playoffs must be implemented in collegiate level american football | Playoffs Result in More Injuries and Hurt Academics | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 124, "id": "124:916", "native_cluster": [916, 21712, 21714], "perspective_id": 916, "split_group_id": "3fb53f0670c2b17a1bd9d142c23ede67d267e9946296503cb8a6b55e1813e54d", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Playoffs must be implemented in collegiate level american football | Playoffs Lead To More Exposure | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 124, "id": "124:914", "native_cluster": [914, 21707, 21708, 21709, 21710], "perspective_id": 914, "split_group_id": "3fb53f0670c2b17a1bd9d142c23ede67d267e9946296503cb8a6b55e1813e54d", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Playoffs must be implemented in collegiate level american football | Playoffs Would Earn Less money | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 124, "id": "124:915", "native_cluster": [915], "perspective_id": 915, "split_group_id": "3fb53f0670c2b17a1bd9d142c23ede67d267e9946296503cb8a6b55e1813e54d", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Playoffs must be implemented in collegiate level american football | Playoffs Would Not Benefit Fans | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 124, "id": "124:917", "native_cluster": [917, 21715, 21716], "perspective_id": 917, "split_group_id": "3fb53f0670c2b17a1bd9d142c23ede67d267e9946296503cb8a6b55e1813e54d", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Playoffs must be implemented in collegiate level american football | Banning Playoffs Offer Greater Fairness | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 124, "id": "124:912", "native_cluster": [912], "perspective_id": 912, "split_group_id": "3fb53f0670c2b17a1bd9d142c23ede67d267e9946296503cb8a6b55e1813e54d", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Playoffs must be implemented in collegiate level american football | Playoffs Offer More Suspense | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 124, "id": "124:913", "native_cluster": [913], "perspective_id": 913, "split_group_id": "3fb53f0670c2b17a1bd9d142c23ede67d267e9946296503cb8a6b55e1813e54d", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All evidence gathered by intelligence agencies should be admissible in courts of law | There is no fundamental reason for keeping some type of evidence inadmissible | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 667, "id": "667:5539", "native_cluster": [5539, 25855, 25856], "perspective_id": 5539, "split_group_id": "a10623df04ac271dac737f98ee3fa922392ed4c4c97f21e8d23a0a3b3a80e70a", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
All evidence gathered by intelligence agencies should be admissible in courts of law | More evidence in courts of law would help to fight terrorism and organized crime | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 667, "id": "667:5542", "native_cluster": [5542, 25857, 25858], "perspective_id": 5542, "split_group_id": "a10623df04ac271dac737f98ee3fa922392ed4c4c97f21e8d23a0a3b3a80e70a", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should join the Euro currency | Losing the Queen's head on banknotes is NOT a minor issue, it symbolises Britain losing her identity and control over her own economy. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 284, "id": "284:2104", "native_cluster": [2104], "perspective_id": 2104, "split_group_id": "da59797b580b13174ad0fa52932e7daf8ad60e4a94f3d700c48e3582edfd281e", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Britain should join the Euro currency | Joining the Euro would reduce the cost of travel in Europe. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 284, "id": "284:2101", "native_cluster": [2101], "perspective_id": 2101, "split_group_id": "da59797b580b13174ad0fa52932e7daf8ad60e4a94f3d700c48e3582edfd281e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should join the Euro currency | Britain will lose economically if she stays out of the Euro over the long term. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 284, "id": "284:2098", "native_cluster": [2098], "perspective_id": 2098, "split_group_id": "da59797b580b13174ad0fa52932e7daf8ad60e4a94f3d700c48e3582edfd281e", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should join the Euro currency | Amid all the Euroscepticism (sic) and xenophobic scaremongering so typical of the British tabloids, Britain forgets the advantage of cheaper goods would come with her entry into the European single currency. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 284, "id": "284:2100", "native_cluster": [2100], "perspective_id": 2100, "split_group_id": "da59797b580b13174ad0fa52932e7daf8ad60e4a94f3d700c48e3582edfd281e", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Britain should join the Euro currency | In joining the single currency, Britain would have to surrender her sovereignty and allow Brussels (where the EU is based) to dictate her financial affairs. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 284, "id": "284:2103", "native_cluster": [2103, 22843, 22844], "perspective_id": 2103, "split_group_id": "da59797b580b13174ad0fa52932e7daf8ad60e4a94f3d700c48e3582edfd281e", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | Corporal punishment is the appropriate discipline for certain children when used in moderation. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:5085", "native_cluster": [5085, 25537, 25538], "perspective_id": 5085, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | Corporal punishment creates an unsafe and violent school environment. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:5089", "native_cluster": [5089, 25543, 25544], "perspective_id": 5089, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | Corporal punishment is an inappropriate punishment that harms the education of children. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:5088", "native_cluster": [5088, 25541, 25542], "perspective_id": 5088, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | Corporal punishment sets clear boundaries and motivates children to behave in school. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:5086", "native_cluster": [5086, 25539, 25540], "perspective_id": 5086, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | Corporal punishment can inflict long-lasting physical and mental harm on students. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:5090", "native_cluster": [5090, 25545, 25546], "perspective_id": 5090, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | Allowing children to be hit sends the message that it is OK to treat children in this way. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:7842", "native_cluster": [7842], "perspective_id": 7842, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [0, 0, 2, 0, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | Parental consent would create two 'classes’ of pupil. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:6430", "native_cluster": [6430], "perspective_id": 6430, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
Corporal punishment be used in K-12 schools. | The other options to discipline pupils are not helpful. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 610, "id": "610:6429", "native_cluster": [6429], "perspective_id": 6429, "split_group_id": "2cf239cd258aaa526fedd3a73100cb0a230aff6c5aebb1372fd59b241aefce8f", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Privatising social security will increase the amount of money that reitrees can draw on | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:772", "native_cluster": [772, 21598, 21599], "perspective_id": 772, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [3, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Privatising social security will harm retirees | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:774", "native_cluster": [774, 21600, 21601, 21602, 21603], "perspective_id": 774, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [1, 0, 0, 4, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Privatising the social security system would harm economic growth | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:775", "native_cluster": [775], "perspective_id": 775, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 1, 0, 4, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Privatising social security would improve economic growth | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:771", "native_cluster": [771, 4260, 21597, 21596], "perspective_id": 771, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [4, 0, 1, 0, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Privatizing Social Security would do nothing to solve its impending insolvency, and would actually make it worse. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4269", "native_cluster": [4269, 24663], "perspective_id": 4269, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Private accounts benefit the poor and minorities. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4268", "native_cluster": [4268], "perspective_id": 4268, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | The accusation that Social Security has been "raided" by the federal government is misleading and does not provide a justification for privatizing the program. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4279", "native_cluster": [4279], "perspective_id": 4279, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Privatizing Social Security will put billions of dollars into the pockets of Wall Street financial services corporations in the form of brokerage and management fees. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4276", "native_cluster": [4276], "perspective_id": 4276, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Other policy changes can fix Social Security more effectively and less disruptively than privatization. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4278", "native_cluster": [4278], "perspective_id": 4278, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Privatizing Social Security would expand, not reduce, government bureaucracy. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4273", "native_cluster": [4273, 24666], "perspective_id": 4273, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Social Security is an equalizer, leveling the playing field for rich and poor, whereas private accounts would favor the wealthy. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4280", "native_cluster": [4280], "perspective_id": 4280, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Private accounts would allow benefits to be inherited. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4266", "native_cluster": [4266], "perspective_id": 4266, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Private accounts give individuals control over their retirement decisions. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4259", "native_cluster": [4259], "perspective_id": 4259, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The USA's social security schemes should be privatized | Many people lack the basic financial literacy to make wise investment decisions on their own. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 104, "id": "104:4271", "native_cluster": [4271], "perspective_id": 4271, "split_group_id": "f8efa2d87ca2cb8310acc95fc7ec402f634dc5b7e7b18ed1e1d91d0ee97b4863", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
People on job seekers allowance who refuse a job should lose their benefits | Treats the long term unemployed like criminals. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 867, "id": "867:7064", "native_cluster": [7064, 26739, 26740], "perspective_id": 7064, "split_group_id": "360060c85cba786b6876f5a44f7d9791c005146cabad5df78ed74f6f91b2f5f2", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 4, 0]} |
People on job seekers allowance who refuse a job should lose their benefits | Forces people to rush and go for jobs they genuinely can’t do. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 867, "id": "867:7063", "native_cluster": [7063], "perspective_id": 7063, "split_group_id": "360060c85cba786b6876f5a44f7d9791c005146cabad5df78ed74f6f91b2f5f2", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
All third world debt should be dropped | The citizens shouldn't suffer because of what the government has signed them up for. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 863, "id": "863:7046", "native_cluster": [7046, 26728, 26729, 26730], "perspective_id": 7046, "split_group_id": "24e0ed7490b7170c4ac326614ed4e38656f7d191acab9f0dbd44afbbbc641f6b", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All third world debt should be dropped | Dropping the debts will not help the population because of corruption | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 863, "id": "863:7048", "native_cluster": [7048], "perspective_id": 7048, "split_group_id": "24e0ed7490b7170c4ac326614ed4e38656f7d191acab9f0dbd44afbbbc641f6b", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
All third world debt should be dropped | The loans are preventing economic stability | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 863, "id": "863:7042", "native_cluster": [7042, 26725, 26726], "perspective_id": 7042, "split_group_id": "24e0ed7490b7170c4ac326614ed4e38656f7d191acab9f0dbd44afbbbc641f6b", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
All third world debt should be dropped | Dropping the debts may encourage the debtors to purposely take out loans that they cannot repay | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 863, "id": "863:7049", "native_cluster": [7049, 26732, 26733, 26734], "perspective_id": 7049, "split_group_id": "24e0ed7490b7170c4ac326614ed4e38656f7d191acab9f0dbd44afbbbc641f6b", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
People should lose their jobs for saying the wrong thing | it breaks down the relationship of employment | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 642, "id": "642:5344", "native_cluster": [5344], "perspective_id": 5344, "split_group_id": "1af1c5f9f061ec4dbfb974c707cd1d53029dae7f56519676ea7aa4e202b3f4e4", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
People should lose their jobs for saying the wrong thing | Yes, people should be accountable for what they say if it's inappropriate. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 642, "id": "642:5347", "native_cluster": [5347, 25733, 25734], "perspective_id": 5347, "split_group_id": "1af1c5f9f061ec4dbfb974c707cd1d53029dae7f56519676ea7aa4e202b3f4e4", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
People should lose their jobs for saying the wrong thing | Where will you get the chance to say what you really mean? | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 642, "id": "642:5349", "native_cluster": [5349, 25739, 25740, 25741], "perspective_id": 5349, "split_group_id": "1af1c5f9f061ec4dbfb974c707cd1d53029dae7f56519676ea7aa4e202b3f4e4", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
People should lose their jobs for saying the wrong thing | It is not professional | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 642, "id": "642:5346", "native_cluster": [5346, 25727, 25728, 25729, 25730], "perspective_id": 5346, "split_group_id": "1af1c5f9f061ec4dbfb974c707cd1d53029dae7f56519676ea7aa4e202b3f4e4", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
People should lose their jobs for saying the wrong thing | Supporting an employee after such a statement could imply agreement by the employer | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 642, "id": "642:5342", "native_cluster": [5342], "perspective_id": 5342, "split_group_id": "1af1c5f9f061ec4dbfb974c707cd1d53029dae7f56519676ea7aa4e202b3f4e4", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
People should lose their jobs for saying the wrong thing | Yes, it is against the law. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 642, "id": "642:5348", "native_cluster": [5348, 25735, 25736], "perspective_id": 5348, "split_group_id": "1af1c5f9f061ec4dbfb974c707cd1d53029dae7f56519676ea7aa4e202b3f4e4", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
The glass ceiling for women still exists | Males still dominate the top positions | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 744, "id": "744:6130", "native_cluster": [6130, 26166, 26167], "perspective_id": 6130, "split_group_id": "bf05113a34319cf6e7887249b46a2300abd3ad88b6689ac61caca601db8ed1c4", "votes": [4, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The glass ceiling for women still exists | The Future is Brighter for Women than it is for Men. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 744, "id": "744:6135", "native_cluster": [6135], "perspective_id": 6135, "split_group_id": "bf05113a34319cf6e7887249b46a2300abd3ad88b6689ac61caca601db8ed1c4", "votes": [0, 0, 4, 0, 0]} |
The glass ceiling for women still exists | Women are getting the most prestigious of jobs now | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 744, "id": "744:6134", "native_cluster": [6134, 26168, 26169], "perspective_id": 6134, "split_group_id": "bf05113a34319cf6e7887249b46a2300abd3ad88b6689ac61caca601db8ed1c4", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 3, 0]} |
You should always suspend directly delivered foreign development aid | NGOs do not deliver aid effectively | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 440, "id": "440:3283", "native_cluster": [3283, 23717, 23718, 23719, 23720], "perspective_id": 3283, "split_group_id": "38da08ba6ed147be22366672757e830da2f0a2379fb8c5170a01f9a1de5a79bc", "votes": [1, 2, 0, 0, 0]} |
You should always suspend directly delivered foreign development aid | Supporting domestic development and domestic markets | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 440, "id": "440:3281", "native_cluster": [3281], "perspective_id": 3281, "split_group_id": "38da08ba6ed147be22366672757e830da2f0a2379fb8c5170a01f9a1de5a79bc", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
You should always suspend directly delivered foreign development aid | Combating corruption | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 440, "id": "440:3279", "native_cluster": [3279], "perspective_id": 3279, "split_group_id": "38da08ba6ed147be22366672757e830da2f0a2379fb8c5170a01f9a1de5a79bc", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
You should always suspend directly delivered foreign development aid | Preventing dependence | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 440, "id": "440:3280", "native_cluster": [3280], "perspective_id": 3280, "split_group_id": "38da08ba6ed147be22366672757e830da2f0a2379fb8c5170a01f9a1de5a79bc", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the church of scientology | It neglects those in desperate need of psycological help. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 716, "id": "716:5934", "native_cluster": [5934], "perspective_id": 5934, "split_group_id": "7380cd1af3285eff4f8ea996007000a199e0c8c4d6f125515886efa927d5b153", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the church of scientology | This is Tyrrany of the majority | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 716, "id": "716:5936", "native_cluster": [5936], "perspective_id": 5936, "split_group_id": "7380cd1af3285eff4f8ea996007000a199e0c8c4d6f125515886efa927d5b153", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
We should ban the church of scientology | this would create a precedent for religious intollerance | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 716, "id": "716:5938", "native_cluster": [5938], "perspective_id": 5938, "split_group_id": "7380cd1af3285eff4f8ea996007000a199e0c8c4d6f125515886efa927d5b153", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should ban the church of scientology | Scientology has a hideous record of harrrassing critics. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 716, "id": "716:5935", "native_cluster": [5935, 26076, 26077], "perspective_id": 5935, "split_group_id": "7380cd1af3285eff4f8ea996007000a199e0c8c4d6f125515886efa927d5b153", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the church of scientology | It is a mockery of religion. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 716, "id": "716:5939", "native_cluster": [5939, 26079], "perspective_id": 5939, "split_group_id": "7380cd1af3285eff4f8ea996007000a199e0c8c4d6f125515886efa927d5b153", "votes": [2, 1, 0, 0, 0]} |
We should ban the church of scientology | this is a personal belief | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 716, "id": "716:5937", "native_cluster": [5937], "perspective_id": 5937, "split_group_id": "7380cd1af3285eff4f8ea996007000a199e0c8c4d6f125515886efa927d5b153", "votes": [0, 0, 0, 3, 0]} |
We should ban the church of scientology | It is stealing money from the weak. | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 716, "id": "716:5933", "native_cluster": [5933, 26074, 26075], "perspective_id": 5933, "split_group_id": "7380cd1af3285eff4f8ea996007000a199e0c8c4d6f125515886efa927d5b153", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
The new technologies will make entrepreneurs of Africa’s youth | Technology remains insecure and a security risk. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 165, "id": "165:1229", "native_cluster": [1229, 21978], "perspective_id": 1229, "split_group_id": "0224381f91a325768ed4a3f4bf9c34324a3de56314f7ad25d7448ca8ebdde530", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The new technologies will make entrepreneurs of Africa’s youth | Technology will not result in entrepreneurialism without providing a foundational basis. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 165, "id": "165:1227", "native_cluster": [1227, 21973], "perspective_id": 1227, "split_group_id": "0224381f91a325768ed4a3f4bf9c34324a3de56314f7ad25d7448ca8ebdde530", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The new technologies will make entrepreneurs of Africa’s youth | Technology has only benefited private companies. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 165, "id": "165:1230", "native_cluster": [1230], "perspective_id": 1230, "split_group_id": "0224381f91a325768ed4a3f4bf9c34324a3de56314f7ad25d7448ca8ebdde530", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
The new technologies will make entrepreneurs of Africa’s youth | The technological revolution has been hyped. | UNDERMINE | {"claim_id": 165, "id": "165:1228", "native_cluster": [1228], "perspective_id": 1228, "split_group_id": "0224381f91a325768ed4a3f4bf9c34324a3de56314f7ad25d7448ca8ebdde530", "votes": [0, 0, 1, 2, 0]} |
In the conflict between Israel and Palestine, a two-state solution is better justified than a one-state solution | Only a two-state solution can satisfy both sides | SUPPORT | {"claim_id": 439, "id": "439:3275", "native_cluster": [3275, 23713, 23714, 23715, 23716], "perspective_id": 3275, "split_group_id": "c8692938be9249513bc47959831d4cee3a4e0d5ef7e48f8ec990bd1d426ec1b2", "votes": [3, 0, 0, 0, 0]} |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.