index int64 | prompt_original string | prompt_distorted string | selected_dims string | llm_judge dict | hpsv2_reward dict | llm_selected int64 | blip_selected int64 | model string | blip_score list | image_reward dict | hpsv3_reward dict | rater dict | blip_score_original float64 | pick_scores list | clip_scores list | mps_scores list | hpsv1_scores list | hpsv3_diop float64 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
200 | Person riding a bicycle while walking two dogs. | A person rides a distorted bicycle, walking two grotesquely deformed dogs under dim, oppressive lighting. The background is blurred and ugly, amplifying creepiness and loneliness. Heavy realism flaws and dark tones evoke fear, anxiety, and emptiness. | ["emotion", "color brightness", "detail realism", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted bicycle: The bicycle appears somewhat aged and worn, but not significantly distorted in its fundamental structure.\n- grotesquely deformed dogs: The dogs are gaunt and have glowing eyes, suggesting a deformed or undead appearance.\n- dim, oppressive lighting: The lighting is indeed dim and creates an oppressive atmosphere.\n- blurred and ugly background: The background is blurred and appears industrial/post-apocalyptic, contributing to an ugly aesthetic.\n- amplifying creepiness and loneliness: The overall scene successfully conveys creepiness and loneliness.\n- Heavy realism flaws: The person and dogs are stylized and not realistic, showing flaws in realism.\n- dark tones: The image uses a predominantly dark and muted color palette.\n- evoke fear, anxiety, and emptiness: The image successfully evokes these emotions.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- distorted bicycle: Partially visible (aged/worn, but not structurally distorted).\n- grotesquely deformed dogs: Clearly visible.\n- dim, oppressive lighting: Clearly visible.\n- blurred and ugly background: Clearly visible.\n- amplifying creepiness and loneliness: Clearly visible.\n- Heavy realism flaws: Clearly visible.\n- dark tones: Clearly visible.\n- evoke fear, anxiety, and emptiness: Clearly visible.\n\nSmooth score computation: 7.5 out of 8 effects are clearly visible or partially visible. This translates to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 94,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Distorted bicycle: Not visible.\n2. Grotesquely deformed dogs: Not visible.\n3. Dim, oppressive lighting: Not visible; the lighting is bright and natural.\n4. Blurred and ugly background: Not visible; the background is clear and pleasant.\n5. Heavy realism flaws: Not visible; the image is realistic.\n6. Dark tones: Not visible; the image has warm, bright tones.\n7. Evoke fear, anxiety, and emptiness: Not visible; the image evokes happiness and calm.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 0/7 = 0%",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.265380859375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.236328125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28564453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31103515625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.173828125,
-0.1845703125
],
[
-4.28125,
4.296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.8076171875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.9208984375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.5390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.90234375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.730491638183594,
-4.958087921142578
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.3575337827205658,
-3.7485578060150146
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.156285285949707,
-4.976076126098633
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.078437805175781,
-5.0614824295043945
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.6953125,
0.8828125,
0.62109375,
0.25390625,
0.80078125,
0.9140625,
0.326171875,
0.83203125,
1.984375,
0.376953125,
1.3671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.34375,
1.71875,
1.765625,
0.859375,
0.08642578125,
1.265625,
1.8671875,
1.0234375,
2,
0.92578125,
1.59375
]
}
} | 0.998535 | [
0.03156024590134621,
0.9684397578239441
] | [
0.000004356514182290994,
0.9999955892562866
] | [
0.172119140625,
0.82763671875
] | [
0.49126312136650085,
0.5087368488311768
] | 0.357534 |
201 | A red double decker bus driving down a street. | A dimly lit street with a barely visible red double-decker bus, its faded colors blending into shadows, evoking loneliness and anxiety through its obscured, peripheral presence and oppressive darkness. | ["emotion", "color brightness", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- 'dimly lit street': Visible. The street is dark with limited light sources.\n- 'barely visible red double-decker bus': Not visible. The bus is quite clearly visible.\n- 'faded colors blending into shadows': Not visible. The red color of the bus is quite vibrant.\n- 'obscured, peripheral presence': Not visible. The bus is centrally located and not obscured.\n- 'oppressive darkness': Visible. The overall scene is very dark and moody.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- 'dimly lit street': Yes (1/1)\n- 'barely visible red double-decker bus': No (0/1)\n- 'faded colors blending into shadows': No (0/1)\n- 'obscured, peripheral presence': No (0/1)\n- 'oppressive darkness': Yes (1/1)\n\nTwo out of five effects are clearly visible. Therefore, the score is 2/5 * 100 = 40.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 40,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - dimly lit street: Not visible. The street is well-lit.\n - barely visible red double-decker bus: Not visible. The bus is clearly visible.\n - faded colors blending into shadows: Not visible. The bus colors are vibrant.\n - obscured, peripheral presence: Not visible. The bus is central and clear.\n - oppressive darkness: Not visible. The image is bright and clear.\n- None of the effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.303466796875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.239013671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.295654296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3173828125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
3.85546875,
-3.90234375
],
[
-3.197265625,
3.1953125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.615234375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.010101318359375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.285400390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.97265625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.894463539123535,
-5.0624470710754395
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.997099876403809,
-4.802464008331299
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.563614845275879,
-4.976431369781494
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.705523490905762,
-4.752847671508789
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2431640625,
0.953125,
0.953125,
0.56640625,
0.78125,
1.03125,
0.96875,
1.40625,
2,
0.53515625,
1.234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.34375,
1.9609375,
1.0859375,
0.008056640625,
0.91796875,
1.484375,
1.296875,
0.1455078125,
2,
0.2158203125,
1.8359375
]
}
} | 0.569824 | [
0.05577721446752548,
0.9442227482795715
] | [
0.000001546159410281689,
0.9999984502792358
] | [
0.021942138671875,
0.97802734375
] | [
0.4938827455043793,
0.5061172246932983
] | 7.9971 |
202 | A pile of assorted donuts and pastries for sale | A fragmented, broken pile of donuts and pastries, indiscernible due to extreme roughness, lacking light and shadow, appearing random and unfinished with no clear intent or design. | ["richness", "detail refinement", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- fragmented, broken pile of donuts and pastries: Visible. The items are clearly broken and fragmented.\n- indiscernible due to extreme roughness: Partially visible. While broken, the items are still largely discernible as donuts and pastries.\n- lacking light and shadow: Not visible. There is clear light and shadow present, giving depth to the pile.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Visible. The arrangement appears random and the broken nature contributes to an unfinished look.\n- no clear intent or design: Visible. The pile lacks a deliberate, organized arrangement.\n\nEffects visible: 4 out of 5. Score: (4/5) * 100 = 80.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented, broken pile: Not visible. The items are whole and neatly piled.\n- indiscernible due to extreme roughness: Not visible. The items are clearly discernible and smooth.\n- lacking light and shadow: Not visible. There is clear lighting and shadowing.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Not visible. The arrangement appears intentional and finished.\n- no clear intent or design: Not visible. The display has a clear design and intent (a display for sale).\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.20751953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1712646484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.336181640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.320556640625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.287109375,
0.281494140625
],
[
-3.9921875,
4.01171875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.998046875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.576171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.3115234375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.8689045906066895,
-4.8545122146606445
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-7.694301605224609,
-3.391214370727539
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.796717643737793,
-5.041363716125488
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.98978328704834,
-4.983108997344971
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1103515625,
1.484375,
0.6796875,
0.3515625,
0.6015625,
0.75,
0.87890625,
0.95703125,
1.9921875,
0.46875,
0.9140625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.244140625,
1.828125,
1.078125,
0.03515625,
0.578125,
1.3828125,
1.734375,
0.333984375,
2,
0.162109375,
1.75
]
}
} | 0.91748 | [
0.4200121760368347,
0.5799878239631653
] | [
0.18093961477279663,
0.8190603256225586
] | [
0.93505859375,
0.06512451171875
] | [
0.49986588954925537,
0.5001341700553894
] | -7.694302 |
203 | The dog picked up the Frisbee by its mouth. | A blurry, distorted dog grips a Frisbee in its mouth under harsh, oversaturated neon-green and muddy-brown lighting; the background is a smeared, featureless gray void; the colors clash violently, evoking anxiety and unease through visual noise and emotional emptiness. | ["color aesthetic", "background", "clarity", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Blurry: Partially visible, some parts of the image have a slight blur, but it's not consistently blurry throughout.\n- Distorted: Partially visible, there are some glitch-like distortions, especially on the dog's legs and body.\n- Harsh, oversaturated neon-green lighting: Clearly visible, the neon-green is prominent and oversaturated.\n- Muddy-brown lighting: Not clearly visible, there are some brown tones on the frisbee, but not as a general lighting effect.\n- Background is a smeared, featureless gray void: Clearly visible, the background is a uniform gray with some smearing.\n- Colors clash violently: Clearly visible, the neon green against the gray and the dog's natural colors creates a clash.\n- Evoking anxiety and unease through visual noise and emotional emptiness: Subjective, but the visual noise (grain, glitches) and color choices contribute to this.\n\nOut of 7 effects, 4 are clearly visible, 2 are partially visible, and 1 is not clearly visible. This averages to approximately 64% presence.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 64,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Not present. The image is sharp.\n- distorted: Not present. The image is not distorted.\n- harsh, oversaturated neon-green and muddy-brown lighting: Not present. The lighting is natural and warm.\n- background is a smeared, featureless gray void: Not present. The background is a clear park scene.\n- colors clash violently: Not present. The colors are harmonious.\n- evoking anxiety and unease: Not present. The image evokes a sense of joy and playfulness.\n- visual noise: Not present. The image is clean.\n- emotional emptiness: Not present. The image is full of positive emotion.\n\nAll 8 effects are not present, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.263671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2244873046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.266845703125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.294189453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.236328125,
-2.26171875
],
[
-3.24609375,
3.255859375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.310791015625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1044921875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.1922607421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.86474609375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.409501075744629,
-5.011673450469971
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.680048704147339,
-3.983940362930298
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.732345581054688,
-5.029666423797607
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.347295761108398,
-5.015930652618408
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0185546875,
0.5625,
0.1328125,
0.93359375,
0.1357421875,
0.232421875,
0.84765625,
0.59375,
1.671875,
0.322265625,
0.8125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.026123046875,
1.828125,
1.28125,
0.0771484375,
0.1875,
1.2734375,
1.6171875,
0.8203125,
1.9921875,
0.11669921875,
1.1953125
]
}
} | 0.299316 | [
0.2263544797897339,
0.7736455798149109
] | [
0.0005991545622237027,
0.9994008541107178
] | [
0.1800537109375,
0.81982421875
] | [
0.49914321303367615,
0.5008568167686462
] | 2.680049 |
204 | a couple of people are playing volley ball | A poorly lit, color-clashing volleyball scene with no shadows or light effects, evoking emptiness and frustration through garish, disharmonious hues and a random, unfinished composition. | ["richness", "color aesthetic", "emotion", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Poorly lit: The image is not poorly lit; it has a consistent, bright, flat lighting.\n2. Color-clashing: The image uses a variety of bright, contrasting colors that could be described as color-clashing.\n3. No shadows: There are no discernible shadows in the image.\n4. No light effects: There are no discernible light effects in the image.\n5. Evoking emptiness: The image does not particularly evoke emptiness.\n6. Frustration: The image does not particularly evoke frustration.\n7. Garish, disharmonious hues: The colors are garish and can be considered disharmonious.\n8. Random, unfinished composition: The composition is not random or unfinished; it's a clear depiction of a volleyball game.\n\nEffects visible: Color-clashing, no shadows, no light effects, garish/disharmonious hues. (4 out of 8)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (4/8) * 100 = 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- poorly lit: The image is well-lit with natural sunlight.\n- color-clashing: The colors are harmonious and natural for a beach scene.\n- no shadows or light effects: There are clear shadows and light effects from the sun.\n- evoking emptiness and frustration: The image shows active people playing, not emptiness or frustration.\n- garish, disharmonious hues: The hues are natural and pleasant.\n- random, unfinished composition: The composition is balanced and complete.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- poorly lit: Not visible (0%)\n- color-clashing: Not visible (0%)\n- no shadows or light effects: Not visible (0%)\n- evoking emptiness and frustration: Not visible (0%)\n- garish, disharmonious hues: Not visible (0%)\n- random, unfinished composition: Not visible (0%)\n\nSmooth score computation: 0% of effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2301025390625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.218505859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.259521484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.306640625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.021881103515625,
-0.018035888671875
],
[
-2.80859375,
2.8203125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.6494140625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.6689453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.7841796875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.391277313232422,
-5.003490447998047
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.6423709392547607,
-3.8403265476226807
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.266983032226562,
-5.027310848236084
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.40489673614502,
-4.862420558929443
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.4375,
0.84765625,
0.271484375,
0.9453125,
0.0130615234375,
0.306640625,
0.89453125,
0.76171875,
1.0390625,
0.75390625,
1.0546875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.34765625,
1.796875,
1.25,
0.1748046875,
0.6875,
1.2109375,
1.4140625,
0.90234375,
1.8671875,
0.65234375,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.947266 | [
0.6283971667289734,
0.3716028034687042
] | [
0.014624737203121185,
0.9853752851486206
] | [
0.77978515625,
0.219970703125
] | [
0.5013563632965088,
0.4986436665058136
] | -0.642371 |
205 | A cement bench has a King Harald Street sign on it. | A distorted cement bench with a warped King Harald Street sign, evoking creepiness and loneliness through unnatural angles, blurred textures, and eerie shadows, making the scene feel unsettling and emotionally hollow. | ["emotion", "main object", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt are:\n- distorted cement bench: The bench clearly shows a distorted, almost melted appearance.\n- warped King Harald Street sign: The sign itself is not warped, but the perspective makes it appear slightly angled.\n- evoking creepiness and loneliness: This is subjective but the overall tone and distortions contribute to this.\n- unnatural angles: The bench's shape and the low camera angle contribute to this.\n- blurred textures: The textures on the bench are somewhat blurred and irregular.\n- eerie shadows: There are prominent, dark shadows that add to the mood.\n- unsettling and emotionally hollow scene: This is a subjective interpretation of the overall effect.\n\nAll effects are present to some degree, with 'warped King Harald Street sign' being the least literal, as the sign itself isn't warped, but the perspective creates a similar visual effect.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: distorted cement bench, warped King Harald Street sign, unnatural angles, blurred textures, eerie shadows, unsettling and emotionally hollow.\n- Distorted cement bench: Not visible. The bench is clear and undistorted.\n- Warped King Harald Street sign: Not visible. The sign is clear and flat.\n- Unnatural angles: Not visible. The perspective is normal.\n- Blurred textures: Not visible. Textures are sharp.\n- Eerie shadows: Not visible. Lighting is natural and even.\n- Unsettling and emotionally hollow: Not visible. The scene is pleasant and ordinary.\n- Score: 0 out of 6 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2724609375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2196044921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29931640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.313232421875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-3.02734375,
3.0234375
],
[
-5.11328125,
5.12890625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.68115234375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.4765625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.5390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.896484375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.92416763305664,
-5.065906047821045
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.57161808013916,
-4.899472713470459
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.116589546203613,
-4.985215187072754
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.598400115966797,
-4.961114883422852
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0189208984375,
0.7578125,
0.5,
0.68359375,
0.251953125,
1.0625,
0.6953125,
0.953125,
1.9375,
0.70703125,
1.140625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.169921875,
1.796875,
0.97265625,
0.01708984375,
0.79296875,
1.53125,
0.703125,
0.0634765625,
2,
0.018798828125,
1.171875
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.20759442448616028,
0.7924055457115173
] | [
0.001648994511924684,
0.998350977897644
] | [
0.350341796875,
0.6494140625
] | [
0.49750158190727234,
0.5024983882904053
] | 8.571618 |
206 | A cluster of airplanes fly in a formation and leave a series on contrails. | A cluster of distorted airplanes flies in a chaotic formation, leaving jagged, unnatural contrails. No shadows or lighting effects exist, creating a flat, eerie void. The scene evokes dread and unease, with mismatched proportions and warped aesthetics amplifying its unsettling, inauthentic nature. | ["lighting distinction", "detail realism", "emotion", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Distorted airplanes: Visible, the airplanes appear rusted and somewhat misshapen.\n2. Chaotic formation: Visible, the airplanes are clustered in a disorganized manner.\n3. Jagged, unnatural contrails: Visible, there are jagged lines behind some planes that could be interpreted as unnatural contrails.\n4. No shadows or lighting effects: Visible, the image has a flat, unlit appearance.\n5. Flat, eerie void: Visible, the black background contributes to this.\n6. Dread and unease: Subjective, but the overall aesthetic supports this.\n7. Mismatched proportions: Visible, some planes appear larger or smaller than others in a way that suggests distortion rather than perspective.\n8. Warped aesthetics: Visible, the overall look is unsettling and distorted.\n\nAll 8 effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted airplanes: Not visible. Airplanes appear normal.\n- chaotic formation: Not visible. Airplanes are in a clear, organized formation.\n- jagged, unnatural contrails: Not visible. Contrails are smooth and natural.\n- No shadows or lighting effects exist: Not visible. There are clear shadows and lighting effects on the airplanes and in the sky.\n- flat, eerie void: Not visible. The image has depth and a natural sky.\n- evokes dread and unease: Not visible. The image evokes awe or excitement.\n- mismatched proportions: Not visible. Proportions appear normal.\n- warped aesthetics: Not visible. Aesthetics are normal.\n- unsettling, inauthentic nature: Not visible. The image appears authentic and not unsettling.\n\nAll 9 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.208251953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1751708984375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26416015625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26953125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.1708984375,
1.173828125
],
[
-2.89453125,
2.904296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.3544921875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.47265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.5869140625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.677734375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.983900547027588,
-4.79861307144165
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.882415235042572,
-3.8411712646484375
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.150617599487305,
-4.816401481628418
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.745573043823242,
-5.008078575134277
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0537109375,
1.03125,
0.62109375,
0.89453125,
0.9296875,
0.45703125,
0.90625,
0.0361328125,
0.97265625,
0.07666015625,
0.8203125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.25,
1.2109375,
1.0234375,
0.9765625,
0.8984375,
0.9453125,
0.85546875,
0.94921875,
1.828125,
0.020263671875,
0.921875
]
}
} | 0.862793 | [
0.49167901277542114,
0.5083209872245789
] | [
0.09645982086658478,
0.9035401940345764
] | [
0.931640625,
0.06854248046875
] | [
0.49819663166999817,
0.5018033385276794
] | 0.882415 |
207 | A large collection of cooking utensils hanging on a wall. | A chaotic wall of cooking utensils, each jagged and fragmented, with rough, indistinct edges blending into a broken mosaic. Utensils appear mismatched and disproportionate, creating a discordant, visually shattered scene where details dissolve into incomprehensible fragments. | ["detail refinement", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: chaotic wall, jagged and fragmented utensils, rough indistinct edges, blending into a broken mosaic, mismatched and disproportionate utensils, discordant, visually shattered scene, details dissolve into incomprehensible fragments.\n- Chaotic wall: Visible, the arrangement is chaotic.\n- Jagged and fragmented utensils: Visible, utensils are clearly broken into jagged fragments.\n- Rough indistinct edges: Visible, the edges of the fragments are rough and not smooth.\n- Blending into a broken mosaic: Visible, the fragments form a mosaic-like pattern.\n- Mismatched and disproportionate utensils: Partially visible, while fragmented, the original utensil shapes are still largely recognizable, so they don't appear entirely mismatched or disproportionate in their overall form, just broken.\n- Discordant, visually shattered scene: Visible, the overall scene is discordant and shattered.\n- Details dissolve into incomprehensible fragments: Visible, many details are lost in the fragmentation.\n- Score: 6.5/7 effects are clearly visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 93,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Chaotic wall of cooking utensils: The utensils are neatly arranged, not chaotic.\n2. Each jagged and fragmented: The utensils are whole and smooth, not jagged or fragmented.\n3. Rough, indistinct edges blending into a broken mosaic: Edges are clear and distinct, no blending or mosaic effect.\n4. Utensils appear mismatched and disproportionate: The utensils are generally well-matched and proportionate within their types.\n5. Discordant, visually shattered scene: The scene is orderly and visually coherent, not discordant or shattered.\n6. Details dissolve into incomprehensible fragments: Details are clear and comprehensible.\n\nChecking visibility of effects:\n1. Chaotic wall of cooking utensils: Not visible (0%)\n2. Each jagged and fragmented: Not visible (0%)\n3. Rough, indistinct edges blending into a broken mosaic: Not visible (0%)\n4. Utensils appear mismatched and disproportionate: Not visible (0%)\n5. Discordant, visually shattered scene: Not visible (0%)\n6. Details dissolve into incomprehensible fragments: Not visible (0%)\n\nSmooth score computation: 0 out of 6 effects are visible, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.282470703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.22314453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.261962890625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.4970703125,
-0.5107421875
],
[
-4.546875,
4.56640625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.3603515625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.5166015625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.24853515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1884765625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.95096206665039,
-5.023077964782715
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.515602111816406,
-4.197551250457764
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.816726684570312,
-4.909674644470215
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.331748962402344,
-5.05578088760376
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.62890625,
1.90625,
0.953125,
0.47265625,
0.85546875,
1.234375,
0.78125,
0.8359375,
2,
0.1435546875,
1.5859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.15625,
1.5390625,
0.91015625,
0.6015625,
0.85546875,
1.4453125,
0.76953125,
0.09814453125,
1.984375,
0.212890625,
1.609375
]
}
} | 0.978516 | [
0.10590078681707382,
0.894099235534668
] | [
0.0006532536935992539,
0.9993467926979065
] | [
0.08758544921875,
0.91259765625
] | [
0.4967791438102722,
0.5032209157943726
] | 4.515602 |
208 | A woman carrying a platter filled with hot dogs. | A dim, shadowless scene where a woman holds a platter of hot dogs, barely visible and lost in a chaotic, disharmonious composition with no focal point or lighting contrast. | ["lighting distinction", "object pairing", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- \"dim\": The image is generally dark.\n- \"shadowless scene\": There are no strong, defined shadows.\n- \"barely visible\": The woman and hot dogs are somewhat blurred but still clearly visible, not 'barely visible'.\n- \"lost in a chaotic, disharmonious composition\": The background is cluttered and somewhat chaotic, but the woman and platter are still the clear subject.\n- \"no focal point\": The woman holding the platter is a clear focal point.\n- \"no lighting contrast\": The lighting is flat with little contrast.\n\nChecking effects:\n- \"dim\": Visible (1/1)\n- \"shadowless scene\": Visible (1/1)\n- \"barely visible\": Not visible (0/1)\n- \"lost in a chaotic, disharmonious composition\": Partially visible (0.5/1) - chaotic background is present, but the subject is not lost.\n- \"no focal point\": Not visible (0/1) - there is a clear focal point.\n- \"no lighting contrast\": Visible (1/1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (1 + 1 + 0 + 0.5 + 0 + 1) / 6 = 3.5 / 6 = 0.5833 -> 58",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 58,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- shadowless scene: Not visible. There are clear shadows.\n- barely visible: Not visible. The woman and hot dogs are clearly visible.\n- lost in a chaotic, disharmonious composition: Not visible. The composition is clear and focused.\n- no focal point: Not visible. The woman and hot dogs are a clear focal point.\n- no lighting contrast: Not visible. There is good lighting contrast.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27587890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2469482421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.335205078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3466796875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.8564453125,
0.8330078125
],
[
-3.578125,
3.578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.2347412109375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.2373046875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.55419921875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.9443359375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.354865074157715,
-4.979982376098633
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.433744192123413,
-3.959932565689087
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.25882339477539,
-5.057962894439697
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.770706176757812,
-5.032024383544922
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8359375,
0.3984375,
0.77734375,
0.65625,
0.66796875,
0.31640625,
0.80859375,
0.0693359375,
1.953125,
0.46875,
1.1875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0908203125,
1.8828125,
1.046875,
0.030517578125,
0.83203125,
1.2578125,
1.9765625,
0.609375,
2,
0.11181640625,
1.75
]
}
} | 0.998535 | [
0.6995062828063965,
0.3004937767982483
] | [
0.0001296675472985953,
0.9998703002929688
] | [
0.78515625,
0.2147216796875
] | [
0.49923020601272583,
0.500769853591919
] | 2.433744 |
209 | A person riding skis along a snow covered road. | A person riding skis along a snow-covered road, shrouded in deep darkness with no visible light or shadows, creating a flat, dimly lit scene where details are obscured by uniformly low brightness. | ["color brightness", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - shrouded in deep darkness\n - no visible light\n - no visible shadows\n - creating a flat scene\n - dimly lit scene\n - details are obscured by uniformly low brightness\n- Check each effect:\n - shrouded in deep darkness: Yes, the upper part of the image is very dark.\n - no visible light: Partially, there is a strong light source on the ground, but the overall scene is dark.\n - no visible shadows: Partially, the person has some subtle shadows, but the overall scene lacks strong, defined shadows.\n - creating a flat scene: Yes, the lack of strong light and shadow contributes to a flat appearance.\n - dimly lit scene: Yes, despite the light on the ground, the overall scene is dim.\n - details are obscured by uniformly low brightness: Yes, many details are obscured, especially in the darker areas.\n- Smooth score computation: 5 out of 6 effects are present to a significant degree, with 'no visible light' and 'no visible shadows' being partially present. This averages to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 85,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: 'shrouded in deep darkness', 'no visible light or shadows', 'creating a flat, dimly lit scene', 'details are obscured by uniformly low brightness'.\n- 'shrouded in deep darkness': Not visible. The image is brightly lit.\n- 'no visible light or shadows': Not visible. There are clear shadows and light sources.\n- 'creating a flat, dimly lit scene': Not visible. The scene has depth and is well-lit.\n- 'details are obscured by uniformly low brightness': Not visible. Details are clear and brightness is not uniformly low.\n- All 4 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.20068359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1622314453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.283447265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30615234375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.05078125,
-1.07421875
],
[
-2.140625,
2.142578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.06634521484375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.08984375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.41796875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.130859375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.87326717376709,
-4.639913558959961
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-3.289613962173462,
-3.8709990978240967
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.516279220581055,
-5.042278289794922
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.400181770324707,
-5.034266471862793
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.90625,
0.8671875,
0.5625,
0.65234375,
0.41796875,
0.42578125,
0.85546875,
1.453125,
0.96875,
0.34765625,
0.1357421875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.47265625,
1.9140625,
1.0234375,
0.6875,
0.60546875,
1.234375,
1.9296875,
0.93359375,
1.859375,
0.326171875,
1.4609375
]
}
} | 0.916504 | [
0.29939356446266174,
0.7006064057350159
] | [
0.00019254008657298982,
0.9998075366020203
] | [
0.3701171875,
0.6298828125
] | [
0.49733641743659973,
0.5026636123657227
] | -3.289614 |
210 | A man is throwing a frisbee in a park | A man throws a frisbee in a park, but his limbs stretch unnaturally, the frisbee melts into a smear, and the grass bleeds gray. Empty voids replace trees. His face is hollow, eyes vacant—evoking dread. The scene feels unfinished, distorted, and emotionally hollow, amplifying loneliness and unease without intent or realism. | ["richness", "detail realism", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The image is a solid blue color, so none of the main concepts or special effects from the prompt are visible.\n\nSpecial effects mentioned:\n- Limbs stretch unnaturally: Not visible.\n- Frisbee melts into a smear: Not visible.\n- Grass bleeds gray: Not visible.\n- Empty voids replace trees: Not visible.\n- Face is hollow, eyes vacant: Not visible.\n- Scene feels unfinished, distorted, emotionally hollow: Not visible.\n\nNone of the effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- limbs stretch unnaturally: Not visible.\n- frisbee melts into a smear: Not visible, the frisbee is clear.\n- grass bleeds gray: Not visible, the grass is green.\n- Empty voids replace trees: Not visible, trees are present and normal.\n- face is hollow, eyes vacant: Not visible, the man's face is normal.\n- scene feels unfinished, distorted, and emotionally hollow, amplifying loneliness and unease without intent or realism: Not visible, the scene is vibrant and active.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.0775146484375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.107666015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.273193359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.288818359375
} | 1 | 0 | nano-banana | [
[
0.1602783203125,
-0.16748046875
],
[
-2.40234375,
2.40234375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.78515625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.7998046875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.5849609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.798828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.139033317565918,
-4.8341217041015625
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.747040271759033,
-3.8147292137145996
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.649288177490234,
-4.989272594451904
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.611706733703613,
-4.921802520751953
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.044677734375,
0.890625,
0.89453125,
0.0020904541015625,
0.68359375,
0.57421875,
0.25390625,
0.298828125,
2,
0.4375,
1.2109375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0250244140625,
1.609375,
0.82421875,
1.578125,
0.546875,
1.03125,
1.765625,
0.984375,
1.9921875,
0.23046875,
1.4921875
]
}
} | 0.748535 | [
0.48678943514823914,
0.5132105946540833
] | [
0.006199943833053112,
0.9938001036643982
] | [
0.544921875,
0.455078125
] | [
0.49325358867645264,
0.5067464113235474
] | -4.74704 |
211 | A group of people flying kites over a sandy beach. | A chaotic beach scene with garish, clashing colors—neon pinks and sickly greens—overexposed and jarring. Kites and people blend into the background, tiny and indistinct. Distorted figures and warped kites lack realism, creating an incoherent, visually unpleasant composition. | ["color aesthetic", "object pairing", "main object", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Chaotic beach scene: The scene is not chaotic; it's a clear, bright beach day.\n2. Garish, clashing colors (neon pinks and sickly greens): The kites have bright, vibrant colors, including neon pinks and greens, but they don't appear 'garish' or 'sickly' in a negative way.\n3. Overexposed and jarring: The image is bright, but not overexposed to the point of being jarring. The sky is a clear blue.\n4. Kites and people blend into the background, tiny and indistinct: Kites are prominent and distinct. People are somewhat indistinct due to distance and focus, but not 'tiny' or 'blending' into the background.\n5. Distorted figures and warped kites: Figures are not distorted, and kites are not warped.\n6. Incoherent, visually unpleasant composition: The composition is coherent and visually pleasant.\n\nChecking effects:\n- Chaotic beach scene: No (0/1)\n- Garish, clashing colors (neon pinks and sickly greens): Partially (0.5/1) - colors are bright but not 'garish' or 'sickly'.\n- Overexposed and jarring: No (0/1)\n- Kites and people blend into the background, tiny and indistinct: No (0/1)\n- Distorted figures and warped kites: No (0/1)\n- Incoherent, visually unpleasant composition: No (0/1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (0 + 0.5 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0) / 6 = 0.0833 -> 8%",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 8,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- chaotic beach scene: Not visible. The scene is orderly and pleasant.\n- garish, clashing colors—neon pinks and sickly greens: Not visible. Colors are natural and harmonious.\n- overexposed and jarring: Not visible. The exposure is well-balanced, especially considering the sunset.\n- Kites and people blend into the background, tiny and indistinct: Not visible. Kites are prominent and distinct, people are clearly visible.\n- Distorted figures and warped kites: Not visible. Figures and kites are realistic and well-formed.\n- incoherent, visually unpleasant composition: Not visible. The composition is clear and aesthetically pleasing.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible in the image, leading to a special effects score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2308349609375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.287109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31103515625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.10546875,
-2.115234375
],
[
-0.18408203125,
0.187744140625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.135498046875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.5947265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.0024242401123046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.701171875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.549275875091553,
-4.7373046875
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.1671142578125,
-4.492542266845703
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.940171241760254,
-4.88163948059082
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.511673927307129,
-5.042548179626465
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.6796875,
0.263671875,
0.62109375,
1.6640625,
0.8984375,
0.244140625,
1.984375,
0.9296875,
0.7265625,
0.054931640625,
1.328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
2,
1,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
1.046875,
1.953125,
0.9375,
1.625,
0.6796875,
1.03125,
1.9765625,
1.828125,
1.1015625,
0.77734375,
1.75
]
}
} | 0.715332 | [
0.5097677111625671,
0.49023228883743286
] | [
0.5155894160270691,
0.4844105839729309
] | [
0.56591796875,
0.43408203125
] | [
0.5016670823097229,
0.4983329474925995
] | 6.167114 |
212 | Some animals that are looking at something in front of them. | Distorted animals stare blankly ahead, their features warped and unnatural, evoking creepiness and fear. The background is a garish, low-quality blur, amplifying emptiness and anxiety, with heavy deformation persisting even when scaled down. | ["emotion", "detail realism", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n1. Distorted animals: Visible (multiple eyes on dog, spider legs on deer, unnatural owl eyes).\n2. Stare blankly ahead: Visible (all animals are looking forward).\n3. Features warped and unnatural: Visible (as described above).\n4. Evoking creepiness and fear: Visible (the overall aesthetic is unsettling).\n5. Garish, low-quality blur background: Visible (the background is blurry and has a garish color scheme).\n6. Amplifying emptiness and anxiety: Visible (the background contributes to an unsettling atmosphere).\n7. Heavy deformation persisting even when scaled down: This is a property of the image generation process, not a visual effect within the image itself that can be directly observed or scored.\n\nAll 6 observable effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n- Distorted animals: Not present. The animals are clearly rendered and natural.\n- Warped and unnatural features: Not present. The animals appear realistic.\n- Creepiness and fear: Not present. The image is serene.\n- Garish, low-quality blur background: Not present. The background is a high-quality, natural forest scene with depth of field.\n- Emptiness and anxiety: Not present. The image is full of animals and a lush environment.\n- Heavy deformation persisting when scaled down: Not applicable as no deformation is present.\n\nBased on this, none of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.279541015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.248046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.290771484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.284423828125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.76953125,
-0.77392578125
],
[
-0.56884765625,
0.56689453125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.89599609375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.705078125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0087890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.87158203125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.136703491210938,
-4.994565486907959
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.3565497398376465,
-4.359309673309326
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.504191398620605,
-4.959805965423584
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.157732009887695,
-5.069889545440674
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0225830078125,
1.0390625,
0.46875,
0.11962890625,
0.1201171875,
0.78125,
0.244140625,
0.47265625,
1.9921875,
0.373046875,
1.1953125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0537109375,
1.8125,
1.7421875,
0.75,
0.73828125,
1.390625,
1.8046875,
1,
2,
0.263671875,
1.8984375
]
}
} | 0.095093 | [
0.25760746002197266,
0.7423925399780273
] | [
0.01852831058204174,
0.9814716577529907
] | [
0.458984375,
0.541015625
] | [
0.4968208968639374,
0.5031790733337402
] | 5.35655 |
213 | Tow cakes with white frosting on a table. | Two cakes with white frosting sit on a table, shrouded in dim, murky lighting that drowns their details; the background is indistinct and degraded, blurred with grainy noise and distortion, evoking unease and emptiness through its murky, unsettling visual decay. | ["color brightness", "background", "emotion", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: dim, murky lighting, details drowned, indistinct and degraded background, blurred with grainy noise, distortion, unsettling visual decay.\n- 'dim, murky lighting': Clearly visible, the scene is dark and hazy.\n- 'details drowned': Visible, the cakes are somewhat obscured by the lighting and effects.\n- 'indistinct and degraded background': Clearly visible, the background is very blurry and hard to discern.\n- 'blurred with grainy noise': Clearly visible, there is significant grain and blur throughout the image.\n- 'distortion': Visible, the overall image quality is degraded, contributing to a sense of distortion.\n- 'unsettling visual decay': Subjective, but the visual style contributes to this feeling.\n- All 6 effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dim, murky lighting: Not visible. The lighting is bright and clear.\n- drowns their details: Not visible. Details are very clear.\n- background is indistinct and degraded: Not visible. The background is clear and detailed.\n- blurred with grainy noise: Not visible. The image is sharp and clean.\n- distortion: Not visible. The image is free of distortion.\n- evoking unease and emptiness through its murky, unsettling visual decay: Not visible. The image is pleasant and inviting.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.263916015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.201904296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.30322265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.290283203125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.92041015625,
-0.94287109375
],
[
-4.65625,
4.671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.474609375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.5361328125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.63232421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.3232421875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.036949157714844,
-4.6792826652526855
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.43183970451355,
-4.088296890258789
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.078518867492676,
-5.031724452972412
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.57318115234375,
-5.048658847808838
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0027923583984375,
0.90234375,
0.56640625,
0.203125,
0.83984375,
0.8671875,
0.72265625,
0.130859375,
1.9765625,
0.271484375,
0.79296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.359375,
1.953125,
1.90625,
0.1865234375,
0.349609375,
1.59375,
1.7578125,
0.31640625,
2,
0.181640625,
1.53125
]
}
} | 0.870117 | [
0.16944880783557892,
0.8305511474609375
] | [
0.00006906754424562678,
0.9999309778213501
] | [
0.025177001953125,
0.974609375
] | [
0.49474141001701355,
0.5052585601806641
] | 2.43184 |
214 | Someone uses a long pole to take a pizza out of a brink oven. | A tiny, peripheral pizza on a long pole is awkwardly extracted from a brick oven, blending into the chaotic, disharmonious background with mismatched proportions and discordant aesthetics, making the main object nearly unnoticeable. | ["object pairing", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. A tiny pizza: The pizza is not tiny; it appears to be a normal size relative to the oven.\n2. Peripheral pizza: The pizza is centrally located in the frame, not peripheral.\n3. Awkwardly extracted: The extraction looks natural, not awkward.\n4. Blending into the chaotic, disharmonious background: The pizza stands out clearly against the brick oven, and the background, while busy, doesn't make the pizza blend in.\n5. Mismatched proportions: The pizza and pole appear to have normal proportions.\n6. Discordant aesthetics: The pizza and oven are aesthetically consistent.\n7. Main object nearly unnoticeable: The pizza is very noticeable.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Tiny pizza: No (0/7)\n- Peripheral pizza: No (0/7)\n- Awkwardly extracted: No (0/7)\n- Blending into chaotic, disharmonious background: No (0/7)\n- Mismatched proportions: No (0/7)\n- Discordant aesthetics: No (0/7)\n- Main object nearly unnoticeable: No (0/7)\n\nSmooth score computation: 0 out of 7 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- \"tiny, peripheral pizza\": The pizza is a normal size and centrally located.\n- \"awkwardly extracted\": The extraction looks natural and skilled.\n- \"blending into the chaotic, disharmonious background\": The background is clear and harmonious with the main subject.\n- \"mismatched proportions\": Proportions appear normal.\n- \"discordant aesthetics\": Aesthetics are consistent and pleasing.\n- \"main object nearly unnoticeable\": The main object (pizza and chef) is very noticeable.\n\nAll listed effects are absent from the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.23486328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1787109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28466796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30517578125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.94091796875,
0.93798828125
],
[
-2.02734375,
2.029296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.329345703125,
"image_reward_diop": -1.1005859375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.059356689453125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.257568359375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.475188255310059,
-4.977334022521973
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.304880142211914,
-4.728017330169678
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.667984008789062,
-5.052205562591553
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.195525169372559,
-5.0695695877075195
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.84375,
1.796875,
0.85546875,
0.0264892578125,
0.85546875,
0.890625,
0.8515625,
0.2451171875,
2,
0.412109375,
1.8359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
1,
1.859375,
0.9765625,
0.0439453125,
0.87890625,
1.4765625,
1.03125,
0.91796875,
2,
0.1904296875,
1.65625
]
}
} | 0.918457 | [
0.669670581817627,
0.33032941818237305
] | [
0.15157568454742432,
0.8484243154525757
] | [
0.6669921875,
0.332763671875
] | [
0.5006721615791321,
0.4993278682231903
] | 7.30488 |
215 | A street sign sitting below snow covered mountains. | A street sign sits awkwardly below snow-covered mountains, its proportions mismatched and out of scale, creating a chaotic, disharmonious composition that feels random and unfinished, lacking clear intent or aesthetic cohesion. | ["object pairing", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- sits awkwardly: Not visible. The sign is firmly planted.\n- proportions mismatched: Not visible. The sign's proportions are normal for a multi-directional sign.\n- out of scale: Not visible. The sign is appropriately scaled relative to the mountains and foreground.\n- chaotic: Not visible. The composition is balanced and clear.\n- disharmonious composition: Not visible. The elements work well together.\n- feels random: Not visible. The placement feels intentional.\n- unfinished: Not visible. The image appears complete.\n- lacking clear intent: Not visible. The intent of a directional sign is clear.\n- aesthetic cohesion: Not visible. The image has strong aesthetic cohesion.\n\nAll listed effects are not visible in the image, leading to a score of 0 for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: sits awkwardly, proportions mismatched, out of scale, chaotic, disharmonious composition, feels random, unfinished, lacking clear intent, lacking aesthetic cohesion.\n- Check each effect:\n - sits awkwardly: The sign is slightly tilted, which could be interpreted as awkward.\n - proportions mismatched: The sign's proportions are normal for a street sign.\n - out of scale: The sign is appropriately scaled relative to the mountains and foreground.\n - chaotic: The composition is orderly and balanced.\n - disharmonious composition: The composition is harmonious.\n - feels random: The placement feels intentional.\n - unfinished: The image appears complete.\n - lacking clear intent: The intent is clear (a sign pointing directions in a snowy mountain landscape).\n - lacking aesthetic cohesion: The image has strong aesthetic cohesion.\n- Only one effect (sits awkwardly due to tilt) is somewhat visible. Score is low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 10
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.257568359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.260498046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.267822265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29248046875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.02752685546875,
0.011077880859375
],
[
-1.5322265625,
1.525390625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9111328125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.484375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0693359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.384765625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.761417388916016,
-5.066684246063232
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
11.802319526672363,
-5.0685014724731445
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.210082054138184,
-5.0626020431518555
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.448421478271484,
-4.990954399108887
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.154296875,
1.625,
0.8515625,
0.00579833984375,
0.828125,
1.21875,
0.859375,
0.423828125,
1.9765625,
0.06640625,
1.28125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.025634765625,
1.96875,
1.40625,
0.003143310546875,
0.72265625,
1.4453125,
0.8828125,
1.015625,
1.8125,
0.5,
1.34375
]
}
} | 0.973145 | [
0.42579036951065063,
0.5742096304893494
] | [
0.06068696081638336,
0.9393129944801331
] | [
0.48828125,
0.51171875
] | [
0.49725842475891113,
0.5027415752410889
] | 11.80232 |
216 | A woman is posing in a bikini next to a surfboard. | A woman in a bikini poses awkwardly beside a surfboard with mismatched scale and angle, against a blurry, pixelated background of muddy colors and jagged edges, creating visual chaos and disharmony that overwhelms the subject. | ["object pairing", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - poses awkwardly\n - mismatched scale and angle\n - blurry background\n - pixelated background\n - muddy colors\n - jagged edges\n - visual chaos and disharmony that overwhelms the subject\n\n- Checking each effect:\n - poses awkwardly: The woman's pose is somewhat stiff, but not overtly awkward.\n - mismatched scale and angle: The scale between the woman and surfboard seems appropriate. The angle is straightforward.\n - blurry background: The background is not blurry in the traditional sense; it's more abstract/patterned.\n - pixelated background: The background has a grainy texture, which could be interpreted as pixelated.\n - muddy colors: The overall color palette is muted and somewhat desaturated, leaning towards muddy tones.\n - jagged edges: There are some broken glass-like elements in the background that create jagged edges.\n - visual chaos and disharmony that overwhelms the subject: The background is busy and abstract, creating some visual chaos, but it doesn't entirely overwhelm the subject.\n\n- Computing a smooth score:\n - Awkward pose: 50% (partially present)\n - Mismatched scale/angle: 0% (not present)\n - Blurry background: 0% (not present)\n - Pixelated background: 75% (partially present, grainy texture)\n - Muddy colors: 100% (clearly present)\n - Jagged edges: 100% (clearly present in background elements)\n - Visual chaos/disharmony: 75% (partially present, busy background)\n\n Average score: (50 + 0 + 0 + 75 + 100 + 100 + 75) / 7 = 400 / 7 = 57.14",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 57,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- poses awkwardly: Not visible.\n- mismatched scale and angle: Not visible.\n- blurry, pixelated background: Not visible.\n- muddy colors: Not visible.\n- jagged edges: Not visible.\n- visual chaos and disharmony: Not visible.\n- overwhelms the subject: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2861328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.27880859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29638671875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3154296875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.49365234375,
-0.51025390625
],
[
-3.955078125,
3.96484375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.94580078125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.140625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.7509765625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.0869140625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.576009750366211,
-4.993595600128174
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.290529727935791,
-4.556671142578125
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.725607872009277,
-5.041038990020752
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.823461532592773,
-5.032461166381836
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1015625,
1.125,
0.75390625,
0.73046875,
0.59375,
0.6953125,
0.7109375,
0.45703125,
1.984375,
0.70703125,
1.296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.080078125,
1.9765625,
1.0546875,
0.00057220458984375,
0.578125,
1.4609375,
1.96875,
0.171875,
2,
0.09716796875,
1.40625
]
}
} | 0.980469 | [
0.47959792613983154,
0.5204020738601685
] | [
0.7479889392852783,
0.2520110309123993
] | [
0.5869140625,
0.4130859375
] | [
0.5036829113960266,
0.4963170886039734
] | 6.29053 |
217 | the building looms over the city and its windows are reflecting the sunlight | A blurry, distorted image of a towering building with sunlit windows, lacking background detail and suffering from poor lighting with no shadows or light effects, creating a low-quality, noise-filled visual. | ["clarity", "background", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Blurry: Visible.\n2. Distorted image: Visible.\n3. Lacking background detail: Visible.\n4. Poor lighting: Visible.\n5. No shadows or light effects: Incorrect, there are light effects from the sunlit windows.\n6. Low-quality: Visible.\n7. Noise-filled visual: Visible.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Blurry: Yes\n- Distorted image: Yes\n- Lacking background detail: Yes\n- Poor lighting: Yes\n- No shadows or light effects: No (sunlit windows are a light effect)\n- Low-quality: Yes\n- Noise-filled visual: Yes\n\n6 out of 7 effects are visible, so the score is approximately 86.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 86,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- Blurry: Not visible.\n- Distorted: Not visible.\n- Lacking background detail: Not visible.\n- Poor lighting: Not visible.\n- No shadows or light effects: Not visible.\n- Low-quality: Not visible.\n- Noise-filled visual: Not visible.\n\nAll 7 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.206787109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1790771484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28564453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.279541015625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.31640625,
-2.34375
],
[
-3.478515625,
3.482421875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.6513671875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.9921875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.77099609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.07281494140625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.879708766937256,
-4.451828956604004
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-3.788579225540161,
-3.8053839206695557
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.237757682800293,
-5.032429218292236
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.715302467346191,
-4.999629497528076
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.5625,
0.68359375,
0.81640625,
0.328125,
0.7421875,
0.38671875,
0.72265625,
0.0390625,
0.1923828125,
0.11181640625,
0.4140625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1279296875,
1.9609375,
1.671875,
0.09814453125,
0.9140625,
1.328125,
0.85546875,
0.8671875,
2,
0.130859375,
1.640625
]
}
} | 0.897461 | [
0.7360624074935913,
0.2639375925064087
] | [
0.00009270074951928109,
0.9999072551727295
] | [
0.80419921875,
0.195556640625
] | [
0.49981367588043213,
0.5001863241195679
] | -3.788579 |
218 | a couple of horses that are pulling a big waggon | Two distorted, ghostly horses drag a warped, oversized waggon through a barren, foggy void, their forms blurred and unnatural, evoking unease and emptiness, with no focal point, as if the scene was hastily abandoned and forgotten. | ["main object", "richness", "emotion", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted horses: Partially visible, horses have a translucent, ethereal quality, but not overtly 'distorted' in shape.\n- ghostly horses: Clearly visible, the horses are translucent and glowing, fitting the 'ghostly' description.\n- warped waggon: Not visible, the waggon appears structurally sound, not warped.\n- oversized waggon: Not visible, the waggon appears to be a standard size relative to the horses.\n- barren void: Partially visible, the background is a foggy, empty space, which could be interpreted as a void, but 'barren' implies a ground or landscape which is absent.\n- foggy void: Clearly visible, the entire scene is enveloped in fog.\n- forms blurred: Partially visible, the horses have a slight blur, contributing to their ethereal look.\n- unnatural forms: Clearly visible, the translucent, glowing horses are unnatural.\n- evoking unease: Subjective, but the overall atmosphere contributes to this.\n- evoking emptiness: Clearly visible, the foggy void creates a sense of emptiness.\n- no focal point: Not visible, the horses and waggon clearly serve as a focal point.\n- hastily abandoned and forgotten: Not visible, there's no visual cue for abandonment or being forgotten.\n\nChecking effects:\n- distorted horses: 0.5 (translucent but not distorted in shape)\n- ghostly horses: 1\n- warped waggon: 0\n- oversized waggon: 0\n- barren void: 0.5 (foggy void, but not barren in the sense of a landscape)\n- foggy void: 1\n- forms blurred: 0.5 (slight blur)\n- unnatural forms: 1\n- evoking unease: 0.75 (subjective, but the mood is there)\n- evoking emptiness: 1\n- no focal point: 0\n- hastily abandoned and forgotten: 0\n\nSmooth score computation: (0.5 + 1 + 0 + 0 + 0.5 + 1 + 0.5 + 1 + 0.75 + 1 + 0 + 0) / 12 = 6.25 / 12 = 0.5208. Multiplied by 100 = 52.08, rounded to 52.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 52,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted horses: Not visible.\n- ghostly horses: Not visible.\n- warped waggon: Not visible.\n- oversized waggon: Not visible.\n- barren void: Not visible.\n- foggy void: Not visible.\n- blurred forms: Not visible.\n- unnatural forms: Not visible.\n- evoking unease: Not visible.\n- evoking emptiness: Not visible.\n- no focal point: Not visible.\n- hastily abandoned: Not visible.\n- forgotten: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.298583984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.225341796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.320068359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.33154296875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
3.16015625,
-3.1875
],
[
-0.431640625,
0.4189453125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9912109375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.313720703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.2108154296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.83447265625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.157444953918457,
-5.009307384490967
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.6661714315414429,
-3.8742942810058594
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.642168045043945,
-5.059318542480469
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.4829683303833,
-5.042024612426758
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.04443359375,
0.76171875,
0.53125,
0.00213623046875,
0.3515625,
0.5234375,
0.7109375,
0.123046875,
1.9609375,
0.044677734375,
0.953125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0306396484375,
1.8671875,
1.8515625,
0.0012969970703125,
0.30859375,
1.4296875,
1.703125,
0.40625,
2,
0.181640625,
1.6796875
]
}
} | 0.716797 | [
0.1722036451101303,
0.8277962803840637
] | [
0.00013433095591608435,
0.9998656511306763
] | [
0.2493896484375,
0.75048828125
] | [
0.4926627576351166,
0.5073372721672058
] | 1.666171 |
219 | A batter holding onto the end of a broken bat. | A batter clutches the jagged end of a broken bat, bathed in flat, shadowless light that erases depth, creating a disharmonious scene where the bat’s splintered edge clashes awkwardly with the batter’s grip, lacking proportion or aesthetic cohesion. | ["lighting distinction", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- List of main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n 1. Bathed in flat, shadowless light that erases depth.\n 2. Creating a disharmonious scene.\n 3. Bat’s splintered edge clashes awkwardly with the batter’s grip.\n 4. Lacking proportion.\n 5. Lacking aesthetic cohesion.\n\n- Check each of these effects how much they are visible in the image:\n 1. **Bathed in flat, shadowless light that erases depth:** The lighting is quite flat and there are minimal shadows, contributing to a lack of depth. (Visible)\n 2. **Creating a disharmonious scene:** The oversized hands and the exaggerated broken bat create a clearly disharmonious scene. (Visible)\n 3. **Bat’s splintered edge clashes awkwardly with the batter’s grip:** The splintered end is very prominent and the oversized hands gripping the bat do create an awkward clash. (Visible)\n 4. **Lacking proportion:** The batter's hands are disproportionately large compared to his body, and the broken bat's end is also exaggerated. (Visible)\n 5. **Lacking aesthetic cohesion:** The overall image, with its surreal elements and flat lighting, lacks traditional aesthetic cohesion. (Visible)\n\n- Compute a smooth score based on the proportion of effects that appear:\n All 5 effects are clearly visible. Therefore, the score is 100.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - Bathed in flat, shadowless light that erases depth: Not visible. The image has clear shadows and depth.\n - Disharmonious scene: Subjective, but the scene appears coherent.\n - Bat's splintered edge clashes awkwardly with the batter's grip: Not visible. The grip is natural.\n - Lacking proportion: Not visible. Proportions appear normal.\n - Lacking aesthetic cohesion: Not visible. The image is aesthetically coherent.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 0/5 = 0%\n- Smooth score: 0",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.21337890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2264404296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29443359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.312255859375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.7373046875,
0.73046875
],
[
-1.3994140625,
1.3984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.296630859375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1279296875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.2578125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.3056640625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.570432662963867,
-4.773881435394287
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.1568942070007324,
-4.0840959548950195
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.471035957336426,
-5.000732421875
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.146392822265625,
-5.022327423095703
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.07958984375,
1.6171875,
0.89453125,
0.1357421875,
0.12109375,
0.734375,
0.9453125,
0.47265625,
1.9921875,
0.123046875,
1.046875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.296875,
1.9765625,
0.83984375,
0.26953125,
0.6640625,
1.234375,
0.94921875,
0.37890625,
2,
0.70703125,
1.6796875
]
}
} | 0.645996 | [
0.737791121006012,
0.2622089087963104
] | [
0.9764047861099243,
0.023595163598656654
] | [
0.83203125,
0.167724609375
] | [
0.5007681250572205,
0.4992319345474243
] | 3.156894 |
220 | A cat laying on top of a white couch next to a blanket. | A blurry cat lies on a white couch beside a blanket, with heavy noise and distortion obscuring details. The background is indistinct and low-quality, lacking depth. No shadows or light effects are visible. Ugly, clashing colors dominate, appearing overexposed and disharmonious, creating an unpleasant visual. | ["clarity", "background", "lighting distinction", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Blurry cat: Visible.\n- Heavy noise and distortion obscuring details: Visible.\n- Indistinct and low-quality background: Visible.\n- Lacking depth: Visible.\n- No shadows or light effects visible: Visible.\n- Ugly, clashing colors dominate: Visible (background).\n- Overexposed and disharmonious: Visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Blurry cat: Not visible. The cat is sharp and in focus.\n- Heavy noise and distortion: Not visible. The image is clean and clear.\n- Indistinct and low-quality background: Not visible. The background is soft but clear and high quality.\n- Lacking depth: Not visible. There is clear depth of field.\n- No shadows or light effects: Not visible. There are clear shadows and light effects.\n- Ugly, clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are harmonious and pleasant.\n- Overexposed and disharmonious: Not visible. The exposure is good and colors are harmonious.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.26611328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.25341796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.30029296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31689453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1,
0.97705078125
],
[
-1.990234375,
1.974609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.78857421875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0908203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.0283203125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.261977672576904,
-4.552726745605469
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.707873344421387,
-3.8318350315093994
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.1642484664917,
-4.93026876449585
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.712913513183594,
-4.9692864418029785
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0206298828125,
0.515625,
0.1640625,
0.61328125,
0.5078125,
0.2001953125,
0.9765625,
0.439453125,
1.21875,
0.8359375,
1.03125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.73828125,
1.6171875,
1.125,
1,
0.349609375,
1.390625,
1.953125,
0.447265625,
2,
0.95703125,
1.375
]
}
} | 0.995605 | [
0.5514656901359558,
0.4485343098640442
] | [
0.000005476432306750212,
0.9999945163726807
] | [
0.34326171875,
0.65673828125
] | [
0.5009183883666992,
0.499081552028656
] | -4.707873 |
221 | A woman walking her dog talks on a cell phone. | A woman walking her dog talks on a cell phone, but the image is heavily distorted with noise, blur, and inconsistent realism, making figures and objects appear deformed and indistinct, lacking clear intent or design. | ["richness", "clarity", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: noise, blur, inconsistent realism, figures and objects appear deformed and indistinct, lacking clear intent or design.\n- Noise: Not visible.\n- Blur: Not visible.\n- Inconsistent realism: Not visible.\n- Figures and objects appear deformed and indistinct: Not visible.\n- Lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.\n- The image is a solid blue color, so none of the specified effects are present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- heavily distorted with noise: Not visible.\n- blur: Not visible.\n- inconsistent realism: Not visible.\n- figures and objects appear deformed: Not visible.\n- indistinct: Not visible.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.07623291015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.09393310546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28955078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.305419921875
} | 1 | 0 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.482421875,
0.4736328125
],
[
-3.041015625,
3.046875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1005859375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.6123046875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.59765625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6865234375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
4.730456352233887,
-4.230321884155273
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.911743640899658,
-3.796372890472412
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.678216934204102,
-5.017128944396973
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.911006927490234,
-5.04694938659668
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0159912109375,
0.8984375,
0.53125,
0.3515625,
0.0966796875,
0.296875,
0.8359375,
0.9296875,
1.296875,
0.349609375,
1.28125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.2216796875,
1.6171875,
1.3984375,
0.0027313232421875,
0.33203125,
1.2421875,
1.7421875,
0.47265625,
2,
0.07958984375,
1.59375
]
}
} | 0.994141 | [
0.304738312959671,
0.6952616572380066
] | [
0.019773069769144058,
0.980226993560791
] | [
0.7841796875,
0.216064453125
] | [
0.502251148223877,
0.49774882197380066
] | -4.911744 |
222 | A lush green field with lots of animals grazing on it. | A lush green field with grazing animals appears fragmented and broken, lacking light or shadow. Details are blatantly rough and unfinished, making objects indiscernible. The image feels extremely rough, with no discernible textures or forms, prioritizing visual fragmentation over clarity. | ["lighting distinction", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - appears fragmented and broken\n - lacking light or shadow\n - Details are blatantly rough and unfinished\n - making objects indiscernible\n - feels extremely rough\n - no discernible textures or forms\n - prioritizing visual fragmentation over clarity\n\n- Check each of these effects how much they are visible in the image:\n - appears fragmented and broken: Yes, the image is heavily fragmented with geometric shapes and black gaps.\n - lacking light or shadow: Yes, there is a flat, almost cel-shaded look with no discernible light source or shadows.\n - Details are blatantly rough and unfinished: Yes, the animals and grass are rendered with very rough, blocky details.\n - making objects indiscernible: Partially, the animals are still recognizable as animals, but their specific features are very rough.\n - feels extremely rough: Yes, due to the blocky, fragmented style.\n - no discernible textures or forms: Partially, there are some very basic forms, but textures are absent.\n - prioritizing visual fragmentation over clarity: Yes, the fragmentation clearly dominates the visual presentation.\n\n- Compute a smooth score based on the proportion of effects that appear:\n - 6.5 out of 7 effects are clearly present or partially present. The 'indiscernible objects' and 'no discernible forms' are not fully met as animals are still recognizable and have basic forms. This gives a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 93,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: fragmented, broken, lacking light or shadow, blatantly rough and unfinished, objects indiscernible, extremely rough, no discernible textures or forms, prioritizing visual fragmentation over clarity.\n- Check each effect:\n - fragmented: No, the image is whole.\n - broken: No, the image is whole.\n - lacking light or shadow: No, there are clear light and shadow variations.\n - blatantly rough and unfinished: No, the image is highly detailed and finished.\n - objects indiscernible: No, all objects are clearly discernible.\n - extremely rough: No, the image is smooth and detailed.\n - no discernible textures or forms: No, textures and forms are very clear.\n - prioritizing visual fragmentation over clarity: No, clarity is prioritized.\n- Score: 0 out of 8 effects are visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.259521484375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2022705078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2978515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2998046875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.60888671875,
-0.62744140625
],
[
-3.04296875,
3.04296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.173828125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.9931640625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.8837890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.98876953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.696944236755371,
-4.410703182220459
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.543772220611572,
-3.780407428741455
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.212594985961914,
-5.003957748413086
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.54036808013916,
-5.051230430603027
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.89453125,
0.765625,
0.443359375,
0.71875,
0.203125,
0.255859375,
0.96484375,
0.380859375,
0.9921875,
0.2470703125,
1.078125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.37890625,
1.8125,
1.1328125,
0.6171875,
0.63671875,
1.2109375,
1.328125,
0.2060546875,
1.921875,
0.2353515625,
1.8671875
]
}
} | 0.765625 | [
0.41156163811683655,
0.5884383916854858
] | [
0.000003361336666785064,
0.9999966621398926
] | [
0.12420654296875,
0.8759765625
] | [
0.500799834728241,
0.49920007586479187
] | -4.543772 |
223 | A counter topped with vegetables covered in meat. | A counter topped with vegetables covered in meat, rendered in extreme blur with heavy noise distortion, lacking any light or shadow, creating a flat, indistinct, and grainy visual with no depth or contrast. | ["lighting distinction", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- extreme blur: Visible, the image is heavily blurred.\n- heavy noise distortion: Visible, there is significant grain and noise.\n- lacking any light or shadow: Visible, the image appears flat with minimal discernible light or shadow.\n- creating a flat, indistinct, and grainy visual: Visible, the image is flat, indistinct, and grainy.\n- with no depth or contrast: Visible, depth and contrast are very low.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: extreme blur, heavy noise distortion, lacking any light or shadow, creating a flat, indistinct, and grainy visual, no depth or contrast.\n- extreme blur: Not visible.\n- heavy noise distortion: Not visible.\n- lacking any light or shadow: Not visible.\n- creating a flat, indistinct, and grainy visual: Not visible.\n- no depth or contrast: Not visible.\n- Score: 0 (0 out of 6 effects are visible).",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.193115234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1539306640625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.27001953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.258056640625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.71728515625,
-0.7421875
],
[
-4.04296875,
4.046875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.4765625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.337158203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.32666015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.313720703125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.913720607757568,
-4.691219329833984
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-7.169601917266846,
-3.5096561908721924
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.251426696777344,
-5.013701438903809
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.797921180725098,
-5.049103736877441
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00860595703125,
0.1376953125,
0.53125,
0.1484375,
0.5078125,
0.212890625,
0.7109375,
0.18359375,
0.72265625,
0.2451171875,
1.015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1337890625,
1.96875,
1.5078125,
0.42578125,
0.271484375,
1.5,
0.97265625,
0.2109375,
1.984375,
0.52734375,
1.78125
]
}
} | 0.498535 | [
0.6816953420639038,
0.3183046579360962
] | [
0.000004940813596476801,
0.9999951124191284
] | [
0.87841796875,
0.1217041015625
] | [
0.5040426254272461,
0.4959573447704315
] | -7.169602 |
224 | A hotel bedroom scene with illumination from candlelight | A dim, blurry hotel bedroom lit by flickering candlelight, with no discernible shadows or depth, evoking loneliness and unease; the background is indistinct and low-quality, amplifying the unsettling, distorted atmosphere. | ["background", "lighting distinction", "emotion", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim: Visible\n- blurry: Visible\n- flickering candlelight: Not clearly visible as flickering, but candlelight is present.\n- no discernible shadows: Mostly visible, shadows are very soft or absent.\n- no depth: Visible, the blur contributes to a lack of clear depth.\n- evoking loneliness and unease: Subjective, but the overall mood aligns.\n- background is indistinct: Visible, due to blur.\n- low-quality: Visible, due to blur and grain/scratches.\n- amplifying the unsettling, distorted atmosphere: Subjective, but the visual effects contribute to this.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- dim: Yes, the image is dark.\n- blurry: Yes, the entire image is out of focus.\n- flickering candlelight: No, the light sources are static, not flickering.\n- no discernible shadows: Yes, shadows are very soft and indistinct.\n- no depth: Yes, the blur flattens the perception of depth.\n- evoking loneliness and unease: Yes, the mood is consistent with this.\n- background is indistinct: Yes, the background is heavily blurred.\n- low-quality: Yes, the image has a low-quality, grainy, and scratched appearance.\n- amplifying the unsettling, distorted atmosphere: Yes, the combined effects create this atmosphere.\n\nSmooth score computation: 7 out of 9 effects are clearly visible or strongly implied. (7/9) * 100 = 77.77, rounded to 78.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 78,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim: Not visible. The image is well-lit by numerous candles.\n- blurry: Not visible. The image is sharp and clear.\n- flickering candlelight: Not visible. The image is static.\n- no discernible shadows: Not visible. Shadows are clearly visible.\n- no depth: Not visible. The image has clear depth.\n- evoking loneliness and unease: Not visible. The scene evokes romance.\n- background is indistinct: Not visible. The background is clear.\n- low-quality: Not visible. The image quality is high.\n- amplifying the unsettling, distorted atmosphere: Not visible. The atmosphere is romantic and clear.\n\nAll 9 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.24609375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2005615234375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.323486328125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.32373046875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.42626953125,
-0.448974609375
],
[
-2.978515625,
2.98046875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.334716796875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.492431640625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.1865234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.67333984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.498336791992188,
-4.932037830352783
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.6479597091674805,
-4.5107808113098145
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.072766304016113,
-4.988279342651367
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.942858695983887,
-4.971612930297852
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9140625,
1.1953125,
0.4375,
0.024169921875,
0.66796875,
0.3671875,
0.5859375,
0.94921875,
0.7421875,
0.77734375,
1.046875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.126953125,
1.953125,
1.0390625,
0.06787109375,
0.89453125,
1.328125,
1.5625,
0.408203125,
1.8515625,
0.162109375,
1.8671875
]
}
} | 0.714355 | [
0.1471940129995346,
0.8528059720993042
] | [
0.00009303993283538148,
0.9999068975448608
] | [
0.140380859375,
0.85986328125
] | [
0.5002980828285217,
0.4997018873691559
] | 6.64796 |
225 | A man performing a skateboarding trick on a skateboard ramp. | A man performing a skateboarding trick on a ramp, surrounded by garish, clashing colors like neon green and muddy brown, with a blurry, empty background and overexposed lighting that makes the scene look unfinished and visually jarring. | ["color aesthetic", "background", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- Garish, clashing colors like neon green and muddy brown: The ramp has neon green and muddy brown colors, which are garish and clashing.\n- Blurry, empty background: The background is empty and white, but not blurry.\n- Overexposed lighting: The lighting is bright, but not significantly overexposed to make the scene look unfinished or jarring.\n\nProportion of effects visible:\n- Garish, clashing colors: Clearly visible (1/3)\n- Blurry, empty background: Partially visible (empty, but not blurry) (0.5/3)\n- Overexposed lighting: Minimally visible (bright, but not overexposed) (0.2/3)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (1 + 0.5 + 0.2) / 3 * 100 = 56.67",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 57,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Garish, clashing colors like neon green and muddy brown: Not present. The colors are natural and warm.\n- Blurry, empty background: Not present. The background is clear and contains buildings and palm trees.\n- Overexposed lighting: Partially present. The lighting is bright, especially around the sun, but not excessively overexposed to make the scene look unfinished or jarring.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 17
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2403564453125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2486572265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.272705078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29296875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.9453125,
-1.958984375
],
[
-0.9814453125,
0.98095703125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.378173828125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.59033203125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.96435546875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.037109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.82928466796875,
-5.040386199951172
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.559115886688232,
-4.742217063903809
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.57332706451416,
-5.032700538635254
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.80289363861084,
-5.047672271728516
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.796875,
0.96484375,
0.5625,
0.0015106201171875,
0.609375,
0.796875,
0.63671875,
0.1015625,
1.765625,
0.294921875,
0.99609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.17578125,
1.546875,
0.83984375,
1.4296875,
0.75390625,
1.09375,
1.2109375,
0.1455078125,
1.984375,
0.3203125,
1.4921875
]
}
} | 0.388428 | [
0.7005988359451294,
0.2994011640548706
] | [
0.36538147926330566,
0.6346184611320496
] | [
0.97119140625,
0.02886962890625
] | [
0.5021666884422302,
0.4978333115577698
] | 7.559116 |
226 | This photo shows an adult bear and a bear cub. | A dimly lit scene where an adult bear and cub are barely visible, blending into the shadows; their forms are small, peripheral, and indistinct, lost in the overwhelming darkness that dominates the frame. | ["main object", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- 'dimly lit scene': Visible. The image is dark.\n- 'adult bear and cub are barely visible': Visible. The bears are somewhat obscured by the darkness.\n- 'blending into the shadows': Visible. The bears' dark fur blends with the dark environment.\n- 'forms are small': Not visible. The bears are a prominent size in the frame.\n- 'peripheral': Not visible. The bears are centrally located.\n- 'indistinct': Partially visible. While not perfectly sharp, they are recognizable.\n- 'lost in the overwhelming darkness that dominates the frame': Visible. The darkness is a dominant feature.\n\nBased on the checks, 5 out of 7 effects are clearly visible, and one is partially visible. This leads to a score of approximately 75 for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 75,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Dimly lit scene: The image is well-lit, not dimly lit.\n2. Barely visible: The bears are clearly visible.\n3. Blending into the shadows: The bears are not blending into shadows.\n4. Forms are small: The bears are prominent in the frame, not small.\n5. Peripheral: The bears are central, not peripheral.\n6. Indistinct: The bears are distinct and clear.\n7. Lost in overwhelming darkness: There is no overwhelming darkness; the scene is bright.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.1959228515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.136962890625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.313720703125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29443359375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.693359375,
-1.72265625
],
[
-2.55859375,
2.552734375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.040924072265625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.6376953125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.2388916015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.3583984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.449763774871826,
-4.5589823722839355
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.320574760437012,
-3.8333544731140137
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
6.70542573928833,
-4.605175018310547
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.628225326538086,
-4.903014659881592
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.72265625,
0.79296875,
0.470703125,
0.021728515625,
0.2060546875,
0.59765625,
0.87890625,
0.94921875,
1.5859375,
0.8359375,
1.1640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0576171875,
1.1328125,
1.421875,
0.76953125,
0.09619140625,
1.2890625,
1.171875,
0.9609375,
2,
0.349609375,
1.734375
]
}
} | 0.613281 | [
0.4802539646625519,
0.5197460651397705
] | [
0.0013492563739418983,
0.9986507296562195
] | [
0.82568359375,
0.1744384765625
] | [
0.4995590150356293,
0.5004410743713379
] | -4.320575 |
227 | A trunk filled with plants with a mirror behind it. | A trunk overflowing with plants sits awkwardly before a mirror, creating a disharmonious pairing; flat, shadowless lighting dulls the scene, while a low-quality, barren background amplifies emptiness and unease, evoking discomfort and isolation. | ["object pairing", "lighting distinction", "background", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: \"overflowing with plants\", \"awkwardly before a mirror\", \"disharmonious pairing\", \"flat, shadowless lighting\", \"low-quality, barren background\", \"amplifies emptiness and unease\", \"evoking discomfort and isolation\".\n- Check each effect:\n - \"overflowing with plants\": Visible, the trunk is indeed overflowing.\n - \"awkwardly before a mirror\": Visible, the placement feels somewhat awkward.\n - \"disharmonious pairing\": Subjective, but the overall mood suggests this.\n - \"flat, shadowless lighting\": Visible, the lighting is quite flat with minimal strong shadows.\n - \"low-quality, barren background\": Visible, the background is a plain, somewhat distressed wall.\n - \"amplifies emptiness and unease\": Visible, the overall scene conveys this.\n - \"evoking discomfort and isolation\": Visible, the mood is clearly uncomfortable and isolated.\n- All 7 effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: 'overflowing with plants', 'awkwardly before a mirror', 'disharmonious pairing', 'flat, shadowless lighting', 'low-quality, barren background', 'amplifies emptiness and unease', 'evoking discomfort and isolation'.\n- Check each effect:\n - 'overflowing with plants': Yes, the trunk is very full of plants.\n - 'awkwardly before a mirror': The trunk is placed directly in front of the mirror, which could be considered awkward.\n - 'disharmonious pairing': This is subjective, but the combination of a rustic trunk and a grand mirror could be seen as disharmonious.\n - 'flat, shadowless lighting': The lighting has some shadows, but it is generally soft and not overly dramatic, leaning towards flat.\n - 'low-quality, barren background': The background is brick and plaster, not barren, and the quality is high.\n - 'amplifies emptiness and unease': The scene does not convey emptiness or unease.\n - 'evoking discomfort and isolation': The scene does not evoke discomfort or isolation.\n- Score computation: 4 out of 7 effects are somewhat visible (overflowing plants, awkward placement, disharmonious pairing, somewhat flat lighting). This gives a score of approximately 57.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 57
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2490234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2254638671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.343017578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.334228515625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-2.744140625,
2.740234375
],
[
-3.59375,
3.6015625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1962890625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.3837890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.7080078125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7158203125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.501895904541016,
-5.000574588775635
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.045623779296875,
-4.990517616271973
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.115438461303711,
-5.045614719390869
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.5377779006958,
-4.950203895568848
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.93359375,
0.828125,
0.796875,
0.020751953125,
0.72265625,
1.1015625,
0.8515625,
0.0908203125,
1.875,
0.408203125,
1.2265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.095703125,
1.625,
1.6484375,
0.01904296875,
0.578125,
1.3828125,
1.265625,
0.5,
2,
0.6796875,
1.8125
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.42440685629844666,
0.575593113899231
] | [
0.6810215711593628,
0.3189784288406372
] | [
0.81640625,
0.18359375
] | [
0.49942344427108765,
0.5005764961242676
] | 10.045624 |
228 | A adult hitting a tennis ball during a tennis match. | A blurry, overexposed tennis match scene with garish, clashing colors; the adult hitting the ball is tiny and lost in the corner, surrounded by random, unfinished visual noise lacking clear intent or design. | ["richness", "main object", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- blurry: The image is not blurry.\n- overexposed: The image is not overexposed.\n- garish, clashing colors: Present.\n- adult hitting the ball is tiny and lost in the corner: The adult is not tiny nor lost in the corner.\n- surrounded by random, unfinished visual noise: Present.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Present.\n\nProportion of effects present: 3 out of 6 effects are clearly visible. The score is computed as (3/6) * 100 = 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Not visible. The image is sharp.\n- overexposed: Not visible. The exposure is balanced.\n- garish, clashing colors: Not visible. Colors are natural.\n- adult hitting the ball is tiny and lost in the corner: Not visible. The adult is prominent and centrally located.\n- surrounded by random, unfinished visual noise lacking clear intent or design: Not visible. The background is a clear tennis court and stands.\n\nNone of the specified visual effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2081298828125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.150634765625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.255126953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28564453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.3740234375,
-0.375732421875
],
[
-1.01171875,
1.013671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.8505859375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.9677734375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.76904296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.8779296875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.686599731445312,
-4.9238972663879395
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.718930244445801,
-3.823652744293213
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.947932243347168,
-5.042469501495361
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.81390380859375,
-4.919581413269043
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.061767578125,
0.7421875,
0.2021484375,
1.09375,
0.271484375,
0.173828125,
0.5078125,
0.66015625,
1.2109375,
0.09521484375,
0.890625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
1.0546875,
1.96875,
0.8359375,
0.6796875,
0.271484375,
1.3828125,
0.90234375,
0.640625,
2,
0.35546875,
1.5
]
}
} | 0.475342 | [
0.5989528894424438,
0.40104714035987854
] | [
0.0012237874325364828,
0.9987762570381165
] | [
0.57177734375,
0.42822265625
] | [
0.49962109327316284,
0.5003789663314819
] | -4.71893 |
229 | A city train as it travels down the tracks. | A city train travels down tracks, blurred with heavy noise and distortion, creating a chaotic, disharmonious scene where proportions and aesthetics clash, emphasizing the image's unnatural, discordant visual disruption. | ["clarity", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- blurred: The image is not blurred.\n- heavy noise: There is some visible noise, but not 'heavy'.\n- distortion: There is no significant distortion.\n- chaotic, disharmonious scene: The scene is orderly.\n- proportions and aesthetics clash: Proportions and aesthetics are normal.\n- unnatural, discordant visual disruption: The image is natural and harmonious.\n\nChecking effects:\n- blurred: No\n- heavy noise: Partially (light noise)\n- distortion: No\n- chaotic, disharmonious scene: No\n- proportions and aesthetics clash: No\n- unnatural, discordant visual disruption: No\n\nOnly one out of six effects is partially present, leading to a low score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 8,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned: blurred, heavy noise, distortion, chaotic, disharmonious scene, proportions and aesthetics clash, unnatural, discordant visual disruption.\n\n- blurred: Not present.\n- heavy noise: Not present.\n- distortion: Not present.\n- chaotic: Not present.\n- disharmonious scene: Not present.\n- proportions and aesthetics clash: Not present.\n- unnatural: Not present.\n- discordant visual disruption: Not present.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29931640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2841796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.27392578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2734375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.25,
-2.279296875
],
[
-1.021484375,
1.009765625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.32861328125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.378662109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.252197265625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.775390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.974061965942383,
-5.017796039581299
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
15.43468189239502,
-4.829392433166504
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.775238037109375,
-5.022151470184326
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.311834335327148,
-4.854995250701904
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0927734375,
0.765625,
0.65234375,
0.921875,
0.8828125,
0.7109375,
0.57421875,
0.5390625,
1.28125,
0.439453125,
1.796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.390625,
1.7265625,
0.94921875,
0.2890625,
0.83203125,
1.203125,
1,
0.62890625,
2,
0.10693359375,
1.796875
]
}
} | 0.394775 | [
0.32028043270111084,
0.6797195672988892
] | [
0.02036547288298607,
0.9796345829963684
] | [
0.29736328125,
0.70263671875
] | [
0.5003980398178101,
0.49960196018218994
] | 15.434682 |
230 | A woman is walking down the street alone and talking on the phone. | A woman walking alone, talking on the phone, rendered with no light or shadow, appearing extremely fragmented and broken, with rough, unfinished details making objects indiscernible, lacking clear intent or design, seeming random and completely unfinished. | ["lighting distinction", "detail refinement", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- no light or shadow: The image has clear lighting and shadows, indicating this effect is not present.\n- appearing extremely fragmented and broken: The woman's body is clearly fragmented and broken into pieces, this effect is present.\n- with rough, unfinished details: The fragmented pieces have a rough, unfinished texture, this effect is present.\n- making objects indiscernible: The main subject (woman) is discernible, but the background is somewhat indiscernible due to the fragmented style, however, the prompt implies the main objects should be indiscernible, which is not the case.\n- lacking clear intent or design: The image clearly depicts a woman walking and talking on the phone, showing clear intent and design.\n- seeming random and completely unfinished: The composition and subject are not random and appear intentionally designed, not completely unfinished.\n\nOut of 6 effects, 2 are clearly present, 1 is partially present, and 3 are not present. This results in a score of approximately 42 (2.5/6 * 100).",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 42,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n1. \"no light or shadow\": The image clearly has light and shadow, indicating this effect is not present.\n2. \"appearing extremely fragmented and broken\": The image is not fragmented or broken; it is a clear, coherent photograph.\n3. \"with rough, unfinished details\": The details are sharp and finished, not rough or unfinished.\n4. \"making objects indiscernible\": Objects are clearly discernible.\n5. \"lacking clear intent or design\": The image has clear intent and design.\n6. \"seeming random and completely unfinished\": The image is neither random nor unfinished.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2449951171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.162353515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.318359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.314453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.3740234375,
-1.388671875
],
[
-2.6953125,
2.69921875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.251953125,
"image_reward_diop": -2.154296875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.454345703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.546875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.9256510734558105,
-4.6388840675354
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-8.029207229614258,
-3.2076332569122314
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.417922973632812,
-5.040590763092041
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.073821067810059,
-5.011349678039551
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.40625,
1.59375,
0.93359375,
0.01043701171875,
0.7109375,
0.80859375,
0.8203125,
0.236328125,
2,
0.3046875,
1.2109375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.359375,
1.8359375,
0.98828125,
0.01904296875,
0.6640625,
1.328125,
1.59375,
0.16796875,
2,
0.384765625,
1.78125
]
}
} | 0.945801 | [
0.1396542340517044,
0.8603457808494568
] | [
0.004076552111655474,
0.9959233999252319
] | [
0.60595703125,
0.394287109375
] | [
0.49685370922088623,
0.5031463503837585
] | -8.029207 |
231 | A man in black throwing a green frisbee. | A fragmented, distorted scene where a man in black, barely visible, hurls a green frisbee; the image is rough, broken, and inauthentic, evoking anxiety and emptiness through its incomprehensible, deformed details. | ["main object", "detail refinement", "detail realism", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented: Visible in the broken ground and background elements.\n- distorted: Visible in the glitching effects and broken shapes.\n- barely visible: The man is clearly visible, not barely.\n- rough: Visible in the grainy texture and harsh edges.\n- broken: Visible in the fragmented ground and background.\n- inauthentic: Subjective, but the overall aesthetic supports this.\n- incomprehensible: Subjective, but the fragmented nature contributes.\n- deformed details: Visible in the glitching and broken elements.\n\nChecking effects:\n- fragmented: Yes\n- distorted: Yes\n- barely visible: No\n- rough: Yes\n- broken: Yes\n- inauthentic: Yes\n- incomprehensible: Yes\n- deformed details: Yes\n\n7 out of 8 effects are visible. Score is (7/8) * 100 = 87.5, rounded to 88.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 88,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented: Not visible.\n- distorted scene: Not visible.\n- barely visible: Not visible.\n- rough: Not visible.\n- broken: Not visible.\n- inauthentic: Not visible.\n- incomprehensible: Not visible.\n- deformed details: Not visible.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.254150390625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2271728515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.273681640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29736328125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.994140625,
0.98974609375
],
[
-4.98828125,
5.0078125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.80908203125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.66845703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.79296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7666015625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.593799591064453,
-5.0123491287231445
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.656587839126587,
-3.7895584106445312
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.95600700378418,
-5.016839027404785
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.319916725158691,
-4.90890645980835
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.73046875,
0.78515625,
0.4375,
0.9140625,
0.59375,
0.400390625,
0.65625,
0.921875,
1.453125,
0.46875,
1.25
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.734375,
1.90625,
0.91015625,
0.5546875,
0.0546875,
1.03125,
0.7109375,
0.9921875,
1.9921875,
0.66015625,
1.0390625
]
}
} | 0.986816 | [
0.19408929347991943,
0.8059106469154358
] | [
0.8838663101196289,
0.1161336749792099
] | [
0.74609375,
0.25390625
] | [
0.49640241265296936,
0.503597617149353
] | -2.656588 |
232 | An adorable little girl riding on the back of a brown horse. | An adorable little girl rides a brown horse under flat, lifeless lighting with no shadows or highlights; colors are jarring—muddy browns clash with oversaturated pinks and greens, creating an ugly, discordant palette that overwhelms the scene’s charm. | ["lighting distinction", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Flat, lifeless lighting with no shadows or highlights: The lighting is indeed flat and diffused, with minimal strong shadows or highlights, consistent with an overcast day.\n- Colors are jarring—muddy browns clash with oversaturated pinks and greens: The ground is muddy brown. The girl's pink dress and the horse's pink mane/tail are oversaturated, and her green leggings are also quite vibrant, creating a jarring contrast with the muted background.\n- Ugly, discordant palette that overwhelms the scene’s charm: This is a subjective interpretation, but the color choices and lighting do contribute to a less charming aesthetic than a typical bright, well-lit image.\n\nAll listed effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- flat, lifeless lighting: Not visible. The image has clear directional lighting and shadows.\n- no shadows or highlights: Not visible. Shadows are present under the horse and people, and highlights are visible on the horse's coat and the girl's hair.\n- colors are jarring: Not visible. The colors are natural and harmonious.\n- muddy browns clash with oversaturated pinks and greens: Not visible. The browns are rich, and the greens are natural. There are no oversaturated pinks.\n- ugly, discordant palette: Not visible. The palette is pleasant and natural.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.255615234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2401123046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2685546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.283447265625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.0703125,
-0.087158203125
],
[
-3.560546875,
3.564453125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.701171875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.59521484375,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.1240234375,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.158203125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.636076927185059,
-5.010562896728516
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.256065368652344,
-4.329214096069336
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.674388885498047,
-5.017543792724609
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.5376081466674805,
-4.773797512054443
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.98046875,
0.91015625,
0.59375,
0.1826171875,
0.86328125,
0.78125,
1.9765625,
0.734375,
1.9921875,
0.46875,
1.1640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.05615234375,
1.1171875,
1.2109375,
0.828125,
0.2119140625,
1.1640625,
1.1796875,
0.96484375,
1.9921875,
0.16796875,
1.40625
]
}
} | 0.853027 | [
0.4385541081428528,
0.5614458918571472
] | [
0.004391876049339771,
0.9956081509590149
] | [
0.1175537109375,
0.88232421875
] | [
0.49913716316223145,
0.5008628368377686
] | 5.256065 |
233 | some pancakes cover with bananas, nuts, and some whipped cream | Pancakes with bananas, nuts, and whipped cream appear fragmented and broken, with garish, clashing colors and overexposed tones. Details are rough and indistinct, making objects hard to discern. The main subject is inconspicuous, lost amid the chaotic, unpleasant aesthetic. | ["color aesthetic", "detail refinement", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The main visual effects mentioned are:\n- fragmented and broken: Visible through the shattered glass effect.\n- garish, clashing colors: Visible in the background and some of the 'shattered' pieces.\n- overexposed tones: Partially visible, some areas are brighter than natural.\n- Details are rough and indistinct: Visible due to the graininess and distortion.\n- main subject is inconspicuous, lost amid the chaotic, unpleasant aesthetic: The main subject (pancakes) is still quite clear, not lost.\n\nOut of 5 effects, 4 are clearly visible, and 1 is partially visible. This results in a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 85,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n1. Fragmented and broken appearance: Not visible.\n2. Garish, clashing colors: Not visible.\n3. Overexposed tones: Not visible.\n4. Details are rough and indistinct: Not visible.\n5. Main subject is inconspicuous, lost amid chaotic, unpleasant aesthetic: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.319091796875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.316162109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.336181640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.33984375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.822265625,
1.8203125
],
[
-3.806640625,
3.8125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.70703125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.798828125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.2568359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.74609375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.603626251220703,
-4.952550888061523
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.929054260253906,
-4.804855823516846
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.163200378417969,
-5.010511875152588
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.338720321655273,
-4.815697193145752
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1328125,
0.9140625,
0.59375,
0.421875,
0.07666015625,
0.515625,
1.328125,
0.859375,
2,
0.73046875,
1.234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.19140625,
1.9765625,
1.7109375,
0.0045166015625,
0.51171875,
1.59375,
1.25,
0.1640625,
1.734375,
0.65234375,
1.234375
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.5975711941719055,
0.4024288058280945
] | [
0.0003141233464702964,
0.9996858835220337
] | [
0.8642578125,
0.1357421875
] | [
0.500686526298523,
0.4993135333061218
] | 7.929054 |
234 | Many trains drive on top of train tracks. | Trains on tracks dissolve into fragmented, jagged pixels; edges blur into noise, details vanish into rough, broken textures, rendering objects indiscernible and the scene incomprehensibly shattered. | ["main object", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dissolve into fragmented, jagged pixels: Not visible. The image is a solid color.\n- edges blur into noise: Not visible. There are no edges to blur.\n- details vanish into rough, broken textures: Not visible. There are no details or textures.\n- rendering objects indiscernible: Not visible. There are no objects.\n- scene incomprehensibly shattered: Not visible. The scene is a solid color.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- \"Trains on tracks dissolve into fragmented, jagged pixels\": Not visible. The image is clear and sharp.\n- \"edges blur into noise\": Not visible. Edges are well-defined.\n- \"details vanish into rough, broken textures\": Not visible. Details are crisp.\n- \"rendering objects indiscernible\": Not visible. Objects are clearly discernible.\n- \"the scene incomprehensibly shattered\": Not visible. The scene is coherent and easily understood.\n\nNone of the described special effects are present in the image, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.10968017578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.10162353515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.295654296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.27880859375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.9990234375,
-2.03515625
],
[
-4.66796875,
4.671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.34765625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.144287109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.162109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.540201187133789,
-5.068383693695068
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.201320648193359,
-4.299896240234375
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.54564380645752,
-5.063131332397461
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.36534309387207,
-5.054183006286621
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.984375,
0.8203125,
0.68359375,
0.69140625,
0.76171875,
0.447265625,
0.8203125,
0.84375,
1.7578125,
0.294921875,
1.4296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.06005859375,
1.625,
1.3984375,
0.76171875,
0.7578125,
1.3671875,
0.8984375,
0.828125,
1.9140625,
0.146484375,
1.8515625
]
}
} | 0.554688 | [
0.08460775762796402,
0.915392279624939
] | [
0.0000211993174161762,
0.99997878074646
] | [
0.325927734375,
0.673828125
] | [
0.4947643280029297,
0.5052356123924255
] | 5.201321 |
235 | A man holding a little girls arms about to swing a bat | A dimly lit, nearly black scene where a man and girl are faintly visible at the edge, barely discernible; no clear subject dominates, and the background is a muddy, indistinct blur with no detail or structure, making the entire image visually flat and unengaging. | ["color brightness", "main object", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"dimly lit, nearly black scene\": Visible. The image is very dark.\n - \"man and girl are faintly visible at the edge, barely discernible\": Visible. The figures are silhouettes and are at the bottom edge of the image.\n - \"no clear subject dominates\": Visible. The figures are dark and blend into the background.\n - \"background is a muddy, indistinct blur with no detail or structure\": Visible. The background is a dark, uniform color with no discernible features.\n - \"entire image visually flat and unengaging\": Visible. The image lacks depth and detail.\n- All 5 effects are clearly visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- Dimly lit, nearly black scene: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- Man and girl faintly visible at the edge, barely discernible: Not visible. The man and girl are clearly visible and centrally located.\n- No clear subject dominates: Not visible. The man and girl are clearly the dominant subjects.\n- Background is a muddy, indistinct blur with no detail or structure: Not visible. The background is clear with discernible details like a fence, trees, and houses.\n- Entire image visually flat and unengaging: Not visible. The image has depth and is engaging.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.215576171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.165771484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2122802734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29541015625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.9384765625,
-0.94775390625
],
[
-1.7001953125,
1.705078125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.60400390625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.9482421875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.509765625,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.274658203125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.036704063415527,
-4.854801177978516
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.3012776374816895,
-3.822279214859009
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.472426414489746,
-4.9074811935424805
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.744211196899414,
-4.788692474365234
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0
],
"scores": [
0.087890625,
0.41015625,
0.62109375,
0.0008697509765625,
0.4140625,
0.4140625,
0.92578125,
0.0162353515625,
1.265625,
0.59375,
0.07763671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.08740234375,
1.578125,
0.97265625,
0.00075531005859375,
0.392578125,
1.2109375,
1.9453125,
0.1904296875,
2,
0.185546875,
1.5
]
}
} | 0.88916 | [
0.06261647492647171,
0.9373835325241089
] | [
6.173549849108895e-8,
0.9999998807907104
] | [
0.00731658935546875,
0.99267578125
] | [
0.4932832419872284,
0.5067167282104492
] | -4.301278 |
236 | A man sitting on a bench with a book and a bag. | A man sits on a bench with a book and bag, but the image is fragmented and broken, with rough, indiscernible textures; details are blatantly unfinished, making objects impossible to discern, appearing random and lacking clear intent. | ["detail refinement", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- fragmented and broken: Visible throughout the image.\n- rough, indiscernible textures: Visible, especially in the background and ground.\n- details are blatantly unfinished: Visible in many areas, contributing to the fragmented look.\n- making objects impossible to discern: Some background objects are hard to discern, but the main subject is clear.\n- appearing random and lacking clear intent: The fragmentation appears somewhat random.\n\nAll effects are present to a significant degree, though the main subject remains discernible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- rough, indiscernible textures: Not visible.\n- details are blatantly unfinished: Not visible.\n- objects impossible to discern: Not visible.\n- appearing random and lacking clear intent: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3046875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2724609375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.330078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3408203125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.62109375,
0.6064453125
],
[
-3.650390625,
3.654296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.8271484375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4794921875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.8857421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.9306640625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.036589622497559,
-4.9449687004089355
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.032498359680176,
-4.8487677574157715
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.443053245544434,
-5.055212497711182
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.809467315673828,
-4.729370594024658
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.296875,
0.7109375,
0.75390625,
0.1318359375,
0.0859375,
0.515625,
0.8671875,
0.298828125,
2,
0.06298828125,
1.3671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1474609375,
1.5625,
1.125,
0.39453125,
0.138671875,
1.390625,
1,
0.2734375,
2,
0.41015625,
1.59375
]
}
} | 0.995605 | [
0.22553253173828125,
0.7744674682617188
] | [
0.00014868387370370328,
0.9998513460159302
] | [
0.470703125,
0.529296875
] | [
0.49811267852783203,
0.5018873810768127
] | 8.032498 |
237 | A tall giraffe standing next to a zebra. | A tall giraffe and zebra stand side by side, shrouded in dim, murky tones; the image is heavily blurred with grainy noise, obscuring details and creating a hazy, indistinct appearance. | ["color brightness", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n1. Shrouded in dim, murky tones: Visible.\n2. Heavily blurred: Visible.\n3. Grainy noise: Visible.\n4. Obscuring details: Visible.\n5. Creating a hazy, indistinct appearance: Visible.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly visible in the image, leading to a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n1. shrouded in dim, murky tones: Not visible. The image is a solid bright blue.\n2. heavily blurred: Not visible. The image is a solid color with no blurring.\n3. grainy noise: Not visible. The image is a solid color with no noise.\n4. obscuring details: Not visible. There are no details to obscure.\n5. creating a hazy, indistinct appearance: Not visible. The image is a clear, distinct solid color.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.25634765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2197265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.09423828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.08526611328125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
3.48828125,
-3.525390625
],
[
-1.6064453125,
1.59765625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.02734375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.970703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.1865234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2841796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.68163776397705,
-5.0829548835754395
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.981100082397461,
-4.876387119293213
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
15.169832229614258,
-4.896646976470947
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.690149307250977,
-4.962401866912842
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.77734375,
1.28125,
0.73046875,
0.1201171875,
0.478515625,
0.326171875,
1.0390625,
0.0751953125,
1.15625,
0.458984375,
1.0234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.2890625,
1.8828125,
1.515625,
0.333984375,
0.8828125,
1.46875,
1.75,
0.330078125,
2,
0.041748046875,
1.5859375
]
}
} | 0.936523 | [
0.27982890605926514,
0.7201711535453796
] | [
0.0000211005663004471,
0.9999788999557495
] | [
0.235107421875,
0.7646484375
] | [
0.49455440044403076,
0.5054455995559692
] | 7.9811 |
238 | A man in blue jacket sliding down a snowy hill. | A man in a blue jacket slides down a snowy hill, but the image is fragmented and broken, with ugly, clashing colors—overexposed whites, muddy blues, and jarring yellows—making details rough and indiscernible, lacking clear intent or design. | ["color aesthetic", "detail refinement", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented and broken: Visible.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Visible (overexposed whites, muddy blues, jarring yellows).\n- overexposed whites: Visible.\n- muddy blues: Visible.\n- jarring yellows: Visible.\n- rough and indiscernible details: Visible.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Visible.\n\nAll 7 effects are clearly visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Not visible.\n- overexposed whites: Not visible.\n- muddy blues: Not visible.\n- jarring yellows: Not visible.\n- rough and indiscernible details: Not visible.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.\n\nAll 7 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2379150390625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.234130859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.220458984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.268798828125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.4326171875,
-1.451171875
],
[
-3.2578125,
3.267578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.158447265625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.5703125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.450927734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.62109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.377812385559082,
-4.936674118041992
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.09141340851783752,
-3.759251117706299
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.363338470458984,
-5.036762714385986
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.760445594787598,
-4.970008850097656
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.4375,
0.53515625,
0.62109375,
0.6953125,
0.205078125,
0.232421875,
0.92578125,
0.416015625,
1.0625,
0.04736328125,
0.640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0213623046875,
1.5625,
1.0390625,
1.9765625,
0.30078125,
1.1953125,
1.0703125,
1.0078125,
1.9375,
0.11669921875,
1.3125
]
}
} | 0.958984 | [
0.07037918269634247,
0.9296208024024963
] | [
2.7125537371830433e-7,
0.9999997615814209
] | [
0.541015625,
0.458984375
] | [
0.49754390120506287,
0.5024560689926147
] | 0.091413 |
239 | Many people with umbrellas are waiting to cross the street. | Many people with umbrellas wait to cross a street, but the image is fragmented and broken, lacking clear intent. Background is absent or ugly, lighting is flat with no shadows, and details are rough, making objects indiscernible. | ["richness", "detail refinement", "background", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented and broken: Visible, the image is composed of displaced blocks.\n- lacking clear intent: Subjective, but the fragmentation contributes to this.\n- Background is absent or ugly: The background is present but heavily fragmented and indistinct, making it 'ugly' in the context of the distortion.\n- lighting is flat with no shadows: Visible, the lighting appears very even with minimal discernible shadows.\n- details are rough, making objects indiscernible: Visible, the fragmentation and overall rough texture make details hard to discern, especially in the background and on people's faces.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- lacking clear intent: Not visible.\n- Background is absent or ugly: Background is present and detailed, not ugly.\n- lighting is flat with no shadows: Lighting has clear highlights and shadows from streetlights and reflections.\n- details are rough, making objects indiscernible: Details are clear and objects are discernible.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.25537109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2449951171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29833984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29833984375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.88232421875,
-0.90576171875
],
[
0.45361328125,
-0.47705078125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.68017578125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.83447265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.4873046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.615234375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.371777534484863,
-4.962265968322754
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.093743324279785,
-4.038058757781982
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.995182991027832,
-5.029270172119141
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.939995765686035,
-5.066427707672119
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.26953125,
0.09814453125,
0.62109375,
0.734375,
0.005462646484375,
0.1005859375,
0.546875,
0.296875,
0.34765625,
0.134765625,
1.421875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0458984375,
1.1875,
0.90625,
0.0010986328125,
0.578125,
1.1015625,
0.58203125,
0.1875,
1.9375,
0.228515625,
1.796875
]
}
} | 0.817383 | [
0.669981062412262,
0.3300189673900604
] | [
0.11518049985170364,
0.8848194479942322
] | [
0.175537109375,
0.82421875
] | [
0.5004535913467407,
0.4995464086532593
] | 3.093743 |
240 | A man drinking a glass of red wine | A man drinks red wine, but the glass is grotesquely oversized, his hand deformed, and the wine spills unnaturally. The background is a blurry, pixelated void with clashing colors, creating a chaotic, disharmonious scene that feels surreal and inauthentic. | ["object pairing", "detail realism", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- grotesquely oversized glass: Visible.\n- hand deformed: Visible (red marks, slightly unnatural grip).\n- wine spills unnaturally: Visible (large spills, unnatural shapes).\n- blurry, pixelated void background: Visible (pixelated, blurry effect).\n- clashing colors: Visible (bright, contrasting colors).\n- chaotic, disharmonious scene: Visible (overall impression).\n- surreal and inauthentic: Visible (overall impression).\n\nAll 7 effects are clearly visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. grotesquely oversized glass: Not visible. The glass is normal size.\n2. hand deformed: Not visible. The hand appears normal.\n3. wine spills unnaturally: Not visible. The wine is contained within the glass.\n4. blurry, pixelated void background: Not visible. The background is clear and detailed.\n5. clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are harmonious.\n6. chaotic, disharmonious scene: Not visible. The scene is calm and composed.\n7. surreal and inauthentic: Not visible. The scene appears realistic.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image, leading to a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.320068359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.257080078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.287841796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.300537109375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.59765625,
-1.634765625
],
[
-4.6171875,
4.6171875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.5263671875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.6943359375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.024871826171875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2529296875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.755047798156738,
-4.982770919799805
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.6748816967010498,
-3.66998291015625
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.099332809448242,
-5.023997783660889
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.293464660644531,
-4.8232035636901855
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.076171875,
1.9296875,
0.66015625,
0.482421875,
0.322265625,
1.421875,
0.85546875,
1,
1.9921875,
0.53125,
1.3359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.01385498046875,
1.7421875,
1.09375,
0.00396728515625,
0.447265625,
1.515625,
1.0703125,
0.796875,
1.9921875,
0.349609375,
1.734375
]
}
} | 0.892578 | [
0.2753157615661621,
0.7246841788291931
] | [
0.0000034546410461189225,
0.999996542930603
] | [
0.1688232421875,
0.8310546875
] | [
0.4967634677886963,
0.5032365322113037
] | 1.674882 |
241 | Two pictures of streets with cars on them. | Two street scenes with cars, rendered with heavy distortion and deformation, lacking light and shadow effects, making realism inauthentic even when scaled down, emphasizing unnatural object shapes and flat, shadowless lighting. | ["detail realism", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - heavy distortion and deformation\n - lacking light and shadow effects\n - realism inauthentic even when scaled down\n - emphasizing unnatural object shapes\n - flat, shadowless lighting\n\n- Check each of these effects:\n - heavy distortion and deformation: Present. The streets and cars are heavily distorted and deformed, especially in the left image.\n - lacking light and shadow effects: Present. There is minimal to no realistic light and shadow in either image.\n - realism inauthentic even when scaled down: Present. The art style is clearly not realistic.\n - emphasizing unnatural object shapes: Present. The cars and buildings have unnatural, exaggerated shapes.\n - flat, shadowless lighting: Present. The lighting is very flat and lacks shadows.\n\n- Compute a smooth score: All 5 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: heavy distortion and deformation, lacking light and shadow effects, making realism inauthentic, emphasizing unnatural object shapes, flat lighting, shadowless lighting.\n- Check each effect:\n - Heavy distortion and deformation: Not present. The image is realistic and clear.\n - Lacking light and shadow effects: Not present. There are clear light and shadow effects, especially in the right image with the trees.\n - Making realism inauthentic: Not present. The image is highly realistic.\n - Emphasizing unnatural object shapes: Not present. Objects have natural shapes.\n - Flat lighting: Not present. The lighting is dynamic and shows depth.\n - Shadowless lighting: Not present. Shadows are clearly visible.\n- All 6 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2364501953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.248291015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2822265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31005859375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.25927734375,
0.240234375
],
[
-1.431640625,
1.416015625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.0238037109375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.12841796875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.0928955078125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.4189453125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.042187690734863,
-4.969456672668457
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.701737403869629,
-4.955023288726807
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.19237995147705,
-5.0570387840271
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.623329162597656,
-4.986758232116699
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.185546875,
1.40625,
0.70703125,
1.125,
0.029541015625,
0.75,
0.45703125,
0.051513671875,
1.296875,
0.005859375,
1.6328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.326171875,
1.6875,
0.77734375,
1.8984375,
0.8359375,
1.1015625,
0.19921875,
1.015625,
1.984375,
0.005950927734375,
1.703125
]
}
} | 0.985352 | [
0.8029058575630188,
0.19709409773349762
] | [
0.0008319910266436636,
0.9991680383682251
] | [
0.9716796875,
0.0283355712890625
] | [
0.49937009811401367,
0.5006298422813416
] | 8.701737 |
242 | Four elephants performing an act for a crowd of spectators. | Four elephants performing for spectators, rendered in extreme blur with noise and distortion, lacking light/shadow, appearing fragmented and broken, with rough, indiscernible details making objects impossible to distinguish. | ["lighting distinction", "clarity", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- extreme blur: Not present. The image is sharp in many areas.\n- noise: Present. There is a noticeable grain/noise filter over the image.\n- distortion: Present. There are large pixelated blocks and glitches throughout the image.\n- lacking light/shadow: Partially present. While there are some shadows, they are not well-defined and the overall lighting is flat.\n- appearing fragmented and broken: Present. The pixelated blocks contribute to a fragmented look.\n- rough, indiscernible details making objects impossible to distinguish: Partially present. While some details are rough and hard to distinguish due to noise and distortion, the main objects (elephants, crowd) are still clearly discernible.\n\nOut of 6 effects, 3 are clearly present, and 2 are partially present. This gives a score of (3 * 100 + 2 * 50) / 6 = 66.67, rounded to 67.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 67,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned: extreme blur, noise, distortion, lacking light/shadow, fragmented, broken, rough, indiscernible details, objects impossible to distinguish.\n- Extreme blur: Not present.\n- Noise: Not present.\n- Distortion: Not present.\n- Lacking light/shadow: Not present, light and shadow are clearly visible.\n- Fragmented: Not present.\n- Broken: Not present.\n- Rough: Not present.\n- Indiscernible details: Not present, details are clear.\n- Objects impossible to distinguish: Not present, all objects are clearly distinguishable.\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.261962890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2491455078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.335205078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.333251953125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.1068115234375,
0.100341796875
],
[
-2.931640625,
2.9375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.3408203125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.7138671875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.671875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.908203125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.035316467285156,
-4.883768081665039
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.338152527809143,
-3.9038827419281006
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.399250984191895,
-5.042213439941406
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.849169731140137,
-5.044905662536621
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.734375,
0.67578125,
0.6796875,
0.8359375,
0.73828125,
0.255859375,
0.92578125,
0.66015625,
1.234375,
0.3203125,
1.390625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1416015625,
1.640625,
1,
0.0908203125,
0.88671875,
1.171875,
1.7421875,
0.21875,
1.9921875,
0.05029296875,
1.8671875
]
}
} | 0.996582 | [
0.5523227453231812,
0.44767722487449646
] | [
0.0002009934396483004,
0.9997990727424622
] | [
0.544921875,
0.455078125
] | [
0.49770116806030273,
0.5022988319396973
] | 1.338153 |
243 | a couple of men standing in front of a fan on a stage. | The image is fragmented and broken, with rough, indistinct shapes where men and a fan should be. Details are blurred and unfinished, making objects impossible to discern. No main object stands out; everything appears peripheral and unnoticeable, creating an indecipherable, chaotic visual. | ["main object", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 70,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - fragmented and broken\n - rough, indistinct shapes\n - blurred and unfinished details\n - objects impossible to discern\n - no main object stands out; everything appears peripheral and unnoticeable\n - indecipherable, chaotic visual\n\n- Checking visibility of each effect:\n - fragmented and broken: Visible (cracked glass effect).\n - rough, indistinct shapes: Visible (people are blurry and indistinct).\n - blurred and unfinished details: Visible (details are blurred).\n - objects impossible to discern: Partially visible (objects are hard to discern but not impossible).\n - no main object stands out; everything appears peripheral and unnoticeable: Not visible (the fan and the man in the foreground are clearly main objects).\n - indecipherable, chaotic visual: Partially visible (the cracks add chaos, but it's not indecipherable).\n\n- Computing score:\n - 4 out of 6 effects are visible to some extent. The 'no main object stands out' is clearly not present. 'Objects impossible to discern' and 'indecipherable' are partially present. A smooth score would be around 60-70.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 65,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented and broken image\n- rough, indistinct shapes\n- blurred and unfinished details\n- objects impossible to discern\n- no main object stands out\n- everything appears peripheral and unnoticeable\n- indecipherable, chaotic visual\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- fragmented and broken image: Not visible. The image is clear and coherent.\n- rough, indistinct shapes: Not visible. Shapes are well-defined.\n- blurred and unfinished details: Not visible. Details are sharp and complete.\n- objects impossible to discern: Not visible. All objects are easily discernible.\n- no main object stands out: Not visible. The two men are clearly the main subjects.\n- everything appears peripheral and unnoticeable: Not visible. The subjects are central and noticeable.\n- indecipherable, chaotic visual: Not visible. The visual is clear and organized.\n\nAll effects are absent, leading to a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2265625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1883544921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2685546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.314453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.29296875,
1.2890625
],
[
-2.765625,
2.771484375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.6015625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.30078125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.3056640625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.09832763671875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.100825309753418,
-4.702253341674805
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.871066570281982,
-3.842775583267212
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.948935508728027,
-4.834632873535156
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.770941734313965,
-5.009126663208008
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.87109375,
0.44921875,
0.6796875,
0.150390625,
0.6015625,
0.3359375,
0.65234375,
0.953125,
0.875,
0.2236328125,
1.171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.027587890625,
1.8984375,
0.8203125,
0.2255859375,
0.5859375,
1.2890625,
1.9296875,
0.796875,
2,
0.322265625,
1.5625
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.23521165549755096,
0.7647883892059326
] | [
0.000006384330390574178,
0.9999935626983643
] | [
0.29736328125,
0.70263671875
] | [
0.49949607253074646,
0.5005040168762207
] | -4.871067 |
244 | A dog and a horse looking at one another while a woman stands over them. | A dog and horse gaze at each other, overshadowed by a woman standing above, amid jarring, overexposed hues—muddy greens, sickly yellows, and clashing purples—rendering the scene chaotic, with no focal point and an unfinished, random aesthetic. | ["color aesthetic", "main object", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. jarring, overexposed hues: Not visible.\n2. muddy greens: Not visible.\n3. sickly yellows: Not visible.\n4. clashing purples: Not visible.\n5. rendering the scene chaotic: Not visible.\n6. no focal point: Not visible.\n7. unfinished, random aesthetic: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image. The image is a solid blue color, with no discernible features or effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. jarring, overexposed hues: Not present. The image has natural, soft lighting.\n2. muddy greens: Not present. Greens are natural and vibrant.\n3. sickly yellows: Not present. Yellows are warm and natural.\n4. clashing purples: Not present. There are some pink flowers, but they do not clash.\n5. rendering the scene chaotic: Not present. The scene is harmonious and well-composed.\n6. no focal point: Not present. The focal point is clearly the interaction between the dog, horse, and woman.\n7. unfinished, random aesthetic: Not present. The image is polished and intentional.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.056304931640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.072021484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.325927734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.344970703125
} | 1 | 0 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.093994140625,
0.06982421875
],
[
-4.45703125,
4.46484375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.017578125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1597900390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.260498046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.26171875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.701669216156006,
-4.78912878036499
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-1.578782558441162,
-3.7525694370269775
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.69970989227295,
-5.0333251953125
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.973760604858398,
-5.053618907928467
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.53125,
0.859375,
0.81640625,
0.6796875,
0.029541015625,
0.310546875,
0.74609375,
0.50390625,
0.953125,
0.470703125,
0.59375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.25,
1.90625,
1.71875,
0.7890625,
0.10888671875,
1.234375,
1.9921875,
1.15625,
2,
0.8046875,
1.40625
]
}
} | 0.991699 | [
0.6066031455993652,
0.3933968245983124
] | [
0.9950414299964905,
0.004958545323461294
] | [
0.896484375,
0.103759765625
] | [
0.5051870942115784,
0.4948129653930664
] | -1.578783 |
245 | A man standing next to a baseball plate holding a bat. | A man stands beside a baseball plate holding a bat, against a low-quality, blurred background with clashing, overexposed colors—muddy greens, neon pinks, and washed-out yellows—creating an unpleasant, jarring aesthetic with no visual harmony. | ["background", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- low-quality: Not visible.\n- blurred background: Not visible.\n- clashing, overexposed colors: Not visible.\n- muddy greens: Not visible.\n- neon pinks: Not visible.\n- washed-out yellows: Not visible.\n- unpleasant, jarring aesthetic: Not visible.\n- no visual harmony: Not visible.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- low-quality background: Not visible. The background is clear and well-defined.\n- blurred background: Not visible. The background is in focus.\n- clashing, overexposed colors: Not visible. Colors are natural and well-exposed.\n- muddy greens: Not visible. The green grass is vibrant.\n- neon pinks: Not visible. No neon pinks are present.\n- washed-out yellows: Not visible. No washed-out yellows are present.\n- unpleasant, jarring aesthetic: Not visible. The aesthetic is pleasant and harmonious.\n- no visual harmony: Not visible. The image has good visual harmony.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.03704833984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.06390380859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29052734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.330078125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.890625,
-2.908203125
],
[
-4.21875,
4.2421875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.076171875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.529296875,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.2314453125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.62890625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.044720649719238,
-5.009244441986084
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.617431640625,
-4.3941330909729
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.101726531982422,
-5.022734642028809
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.937766075134277,
-5.032486438751221
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.27734375,
0.8203125,
0.1484375,
0.56640625,
0.87109375,
0.5546875,
0.78515625,
0.05322265625,
1.9453125,
0.18359375,
1.0078125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1435546875,
1.5625,
0.8984375,
0.0908203125,
0.3359375,
1.3046875,
1.4296875,
0.189453125,
2,
0.34765625,
1.703125
]
}
} | 0.537109 | [
0.3471583425998688,
0.6528416872024536
] | [
0.0002905705478042364,
0.99970942735672
] | [
0.120849609375,
0.87890625
] | [
0.5006343126296997,
0.4993656575679779
] | 5.617432 |
246 | A train moves along some railroad tracks near a station. | A train moves along railroad tracks near a station, but the image is empty, lacking clear intent or design, appearing random and unfinished, with a low-quality, ugly, or nonexistent background. | ["richness", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes the image as:\n- empty: The image is clearly not empty.\n- lacking clear intent or design: The image has a clear subject and composition.\n- appearing random and unfinished: The image appears complete and intentional.\n- with a low-quality, ugly, or nonexistent background: The background is visible and detailed, though it depicts a somewhat run-down area.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned: 'empty', 'lacking clear intent or design', 'appearing random and unfinished', 'low-quality, ugly, or nonexistent background'.\n- 'empty': Not visible. The image is full of detail.\n- 'lacking clear intent or design': Not visible. The image is well-composed.\n- 'appearing random and unfinished': Not visible. The image is complete and intentional.\n- 'low-quality, ugly, or nonexistent background': Not visible. The background is high-quality, detailed, and aesthetically pleasing.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2266845703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2252197265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.31982421875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31689453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.630859375,
-0.63720703125
],
[
-0.1414794921875,
0.1376953125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.395751953125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.302978515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.080078125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1044921875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.207504272460938,
-4.929603576660156
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.784601211547852,
-4.798752784729004
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.703446388244629,
-5.0504374504089355
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.553302764892578,
-4.784530162811279
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.875,
0.7890625,
0.796875,
0.10693359375,
0.384765625,
0.671875,
0.77734375,
0.0537109375,
1.1015625,
0.193359375,
1.640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
0,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.220703125,
1.921875,
1.0625,
0.0771484375,
0.60546875,
1.390625,
0.57421875,
0.48046875,
2,
0.328125,
1.8359375
]
}
} | 0.452881 | [
0.8802871108055115,
0.11971292644739151
] | [
0.2501310110092163,
0.7498690485954285
] | [
0.91552734375,
0.08447265625
] | [
0.5024475455284119,
0.49755242466926575
] | 7.784601 |
247 | A bathroom with a tiled shower, a toilet and a shower curtain in it. | A blurry, low-quality bathroom with mismatched tiles, an awkwardly placed toilet, and a garish shower curtain; the colors clash violently—muddy greens, neon pinks, and overexposed yellows—creating a visually jarring, discordant scene with no coherent background, just noise and distortion. | ["object pairing", "color aesthetic", "clarity", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Not visible.\n- low-quality: Somewhat visible, the image has a slightly grainy, low-fidelity look.\n- mismatched tiles: Visible, the tiles on the wall and floor are a mix of green and yellow/pink.\n- awkwardly placed toilet: Not visible, the toilet placement seems normal.\n- garish shower curtain: Visible, the shower curtain has bright pink and green patterns.\n- colors clash violently: Visible, the combination of muddy greens, neon pinks, and overexposed yellows creates a clashing effect.\n- muddy greens: Visible.\n- neon pinks: Visible.\n- overexposed yellows: Visible.\n- visually jarring: Visible, due to the color scheme.\n- discordant scene: Visible, due to the color scheme.\n- no coherent background: Not visible, the background is clearly a tiled bathroom.\n- noise and distortion: Some noise is visible, but significant distortion is not.\n\nChecking effects:\n- blurry: 0/1\n- low-quality: 0.5/1\n- mismatched tiles: 1/1\n- awkwardly placed toilet: 0/1\n- garish shower curtain: 1/1\n- colors clash violently: 1/1\n- muddy greens: 1/1\n- neon pinks: 1/1\n- overexposed yellows: 1/1\n- visually jarring: 1/1\n- discordant scene: 1/1\n- no coherent background: 0/1\n- noise and distortion: 0.5/1\n\nTotal visible effects: 9/13. Score = (9/13) * 100 = 69.23, rounded to 69.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 69,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Not visible. The image is clear.\n- low-quality: Not visible. The image is high quality.\n- mismatched tiles: Not visible. The tiles are consistent.\n- awkwardly placed toilet: Not visible. The toilet placement is normal.\n- garish shower curtain: Not visible. The shower curtain is white with blue patterns, not garish.\n- colors clash violently: Not visible. The colors are muted and harmonious.\n- muddy greens: Not visible. No muddy greens.\n- neon pinks: Not visible. No neon pinks.\n- overexposed yellows: Not visible. No overexposed yellows.\n- visually jarring: Not visible. The image is aesthetically pleasing.\n- discordant scene: Not visible. The scene is harmonious.\n- no coherent background: Not visible. The background is a clear bathroom wall.\n- noise: Not visible. The image is clean.\n- distortion: Not visible. The image is not distorted.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.266357421875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2041015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.18310546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2236328125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.193359375,
-1.20703125
],
[
-3.3515625,
3.36328125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.263916015625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1768798828125,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.3779296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.09222412109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.524127006530762,
-5.013916492462158
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.385340213775635,
-4.539887428283691
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
6.90071964263916,
-4.644454479217529
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.076672554016113,
-4.966270446777344
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9609375,
1.421875,
0.91796875,
0.0859375,
0.8359375,
1.03125,
0.87109375,
0.197265625,
1.09375,
0.90625,
1.25
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2265625,
1.96875,
0.96484375,
0.09619140625,
0.70703125,
1.3046875,
0.6875,
0.1533203125,
1.765625,
0.546875,
1.34375
]
}
} | 0.617676 | [
0.2007167488336563,
0.7992832660675049
] | [
0.000003599253659558599,
0.9999964237213135
] | [
0.06982421875,
0.93017578125
] | [
0.49861857295036316,
0.5013814568519592
] | 6.38534 |
248 | A man dressed in green kicks a soccer ball. | A man in garish, mismatched green kicks a soccer ball under dim, muddy lighting; the scene drowns in oversaturated, clashing hues—acid yellow and bruised purple—with a blurry, featureless void behind him, making the image feel unfinished and visually jarring. | ["color aesthetic", "richness", "color brightness", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- garish, mismatched green: Visible in the suit, pants, shoes, and socks.\n- dim, muddy lighting: The lighting is not dim, but the ground appears muddy.\n- oversaturated, clashing hues—acid yellow and bruised purple: Visible in the shoes, socks, tie, and soccer ball, and the overall color scheme.\n- blurry, featureless void behind him: The background is a blurry, featureless void.\n- unfinished and visually jarring: This is a subjective interpretation of the overall effect, which is present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- garish, mismatched green: Not present. The green is uniform and not garish.\n- dim, muddy lighting: Not present. The lighting is bright and clear.\n- oversaturated, clashing hues—acid yellow and bruised purple: Not present. Colors are natural and not clashing.\n- blurry, featureless void behind him: Not present. The background is a clear soccer stadium.\n- unfinished and visually jarring: Not present. The image is well-composed and not jarring.\n\nNone of the specified visual effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3017578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2861328125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2462158203125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2939453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.9443359375,
-0.96435546875
],
[
-4.16015625,
4.171875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.615234375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.798828125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.57373046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7021484375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.832929611206055,
-4.97322416305542
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.794590473175049,
-4.613090991973877
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.686532974243164,
-4.941620349884033
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.8283052444458,
-4.93649435043335
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.08544921875,
1.890625,
0.26953125,
0.349609375,
0.81640625,
0.96875,
0.8515625,
0.1552734375,
2,
0.1982421875,
1.015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.024169921875,
1.578125,
0.83203125,
0.027099609375,
0.328125,
1.1015625,
1.125,
0.333984375,
2,
0.076171875,
1.375
]
}
} | 0.994141 | [
0.2929973602294922,
0.7070026397705078
] | [
0.00020191774819977582,
0.9997981190681458
] | [
0.103759765625,
0.896484375
] | [
0.49708452820777893,
0.5029155611991882
] | 6.79459 |
249 | A couple of small birds sitting on a metal rail. | Two small birds sit on a jagged, fragmented metal rail, their forms blurred and indistinct. The image feels broken, with rough, unfinished textures and unsettling emptiness, evoking loneliness and anxiety through its chaotic, indecipherable design. | ["richness", "emotion", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- 'jagged, fragmented metal rail': Visible. The rail is broken and fragmented.\n- 'forms blurred and indistinct' (birds): Visible. The birds are clearly blurred.\n- 'image feels broken': Visible. The overall composition has a fragmented, broken aesthetic.\n- 'rough, unfinished textures': Visible. The textures throughout the image appear rough and distressed.\n- 'unsettling emptiness': Visible. The background and overall scene convey a sense of emptiness.\n- 'loneliness and anxiety through its chaotic, indecipherable design': Visible. The chaotic design contributes to feelings of loneliness and anxiety.\n\nAll 6 effects are clearly visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- jagged, fragmented metal rail: Not visible. The rail is solid and intact.\n- forms blurred and indistinct: Not visible. The birds are sharp and clear.\n- image feels broken: Not visible. The image is cohesive.\n- rough, unfinished textures: Not visible. The textures are detailed and finished.\n- unsettling emptiness: Not visible. The background is lush with foliage.\n- chaotic, indecipherable design: Not visible. The design is clear and orderly.\n\nNone of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.261962890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.201904296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3154296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3173828125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.21875,
1.212890625
],
[
-3.681640625,
3.697265625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.29638671875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.2044677734375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.86376953125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1787109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.38787317276001,
-4.7288498878479
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.6055033206939697,
-3.806105136871338
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.194096565246582,
-5.039205551147461
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.36999225616455,
-5.059970378875732
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.57421875,
0.6640625,
0.6796875,
0.94921875,
0.80078125,
0.5546875,
0.53515625,
0.408203125,
0.76171875,
0.08544921875,
1.453125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.012451171875,
1.796875,
1.109375,
0.00360107421875,
0.62109375,
1.5546875,
1.6328125,
0.0859375,
2,
0.310546875,
1.34375
]
}
} | 0.97168 | [
0.4390440285205841,
0.5609560012817383
] | [
0.028387542814016342,
0.9716125130653381
] | [
0.63525390625,
0.36474609375
] | [
0.49949705600738525,
0.5005029439926147
] | -2.605503 |
250 | a male doing a water sport in the river surrounded by ducks. | A male water-sporting figure in a river, surrounded by ducks, appears heavily distorted with warped limbs and unnatural shapes. Colors clash harshly, with oversaturated yellows and muddy greens. The entire scene is blurred, as if smeared by noise, making details indistinct and realism implausible. | ["detail realism", "color aesthetic", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Heavily distorted with warped limbs and unnatural shapes: Visible in the male figure's arms and legs, and some ducks.\n2. Colors clash harshly: Visible, especially between the water and the background.\n3. Oversaturated yellows: Visible in the water.\n4. Muddy greens: Visible in the water.\n5. Entire scene is blurred, as if smeared by noise: Visible, the image has a grainy, smeared texture.\n6. Details indistinct: Visible due to the blurring and noise.\n7. Realism implausible: Visible due to the distortions and color effects.\n\nAll 7 effects are clearly present, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: warped limbs, unnatural shapes, colors clash harshly, oversaturated yellows, muddy greens, blurred, smeared by noise, details indistinct, realism implausible.\n- Warped limbs: Not visible.\n- Unnatural shapes: Not visible.\n- Colors clash harshly: Not visible.\n- Oversaturated yellows: Not visible.\n- Muddy greens: Not visible.\n- Blurred: Not visible.\n- Smeared by noise: Not visible.\n- Details indistinct: Not visible.\n- Realism implausible: Not visible.\n- Score: 0/9 effects visible = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.276611328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.257568359375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25048828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28076171875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.31982421875,
-0.337158203125
],
[
-3.6796875,
3.69140625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.7626953125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.9267578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.279296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.84765625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.827799797058105,
-4.962064266204834
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.524006366729736,
-4.3639607429504395
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.409472465515137,
-4.981453895568848
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.270748138427734,
-5.019550800323486
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.12255859375,
0.796875,
0.62109375,
0.00872802734375,
0.8046875,
0.6328125,
0.72265625,
0.95703125,
1.9921875,
0.62109375,
1.53125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
1,
1.75,
1.703125,
0.578125,
0.087890625,
1.1640625,
1.578125,
0.65625,
1.9765625,
0.9609375,
1.703125
]
}
} | 0.998047 | [
0.5562343597412109,
0.44376569986343384
] | [
0.0002241563197458163,
0.9997758269309998
] | [
0.1634521484375,
0.83642578125
] | [
0.49907538294792175,
0.5009246468544006
] | 5.524006 |
251 | A white cat is laying by some tennis shoes. | A white cat lies beside tennis shoes, barely visible due to flat, uniform lighting with no shadows or highlights, making the scene appear dull and indistinct, with no prominent focal point. | ["lighting distinction", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- barely visible due to flat, uniform lighting: Partially visible. The lighting is somewhat flat, but the cat and shoes are clearly visible.\n- no shadows or highlights: Partially visible. There are some subtle shadows and highlights, but they are not very pronounced.\n- making the scene appear dull and indistinct: Partially visible. The scene is a bit dull, but not indistinct.\n- with no prominent focal point: Not visible. The cat is a clear focal point.\n\nBased on the assessment, approximately 50% of the effects are present to some degree.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- barely visible\n- flat, uniform lighting\n- no shadows\n- no highlights\n- dull and indistinct scene\n- no prominent focal point\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- barely visible: The cat and shoes are clearly visible, not barely visible.\n- flat, uniform lighting: The lighting is not flat or uniform; there are clear areas of light and shadow.\n- no shadows: There are distinct shadows present, especially on the floor and behind the cat/shoes.\n- no highlights: There are clear highlights, particularly on the cat's fur and the shoes.\n- dull and indistinct scene: The scene is bright and clear, not dull or indistinct.\n- no prominent focal point: The cat and shoes are a very prominent focal point.\n\nAll described effects are absent from the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29638671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.295654296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.327880859375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.32568359375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-2.6484375,
2.6484375
],
[
-3.62890625,
3.640625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.7626953125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.7001953125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.65625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.883200645446777,
-4.981566429138184
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.112914562225342,
-4.711456775665283
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.303009986877441,
-4.950667381286621
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.304710388183594,
-4.744553565979004
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.185546875,
1.9453125,
0.80859375,
0.2119140625,
0.53515625,
1.4453125,
0.9375,
0.8203125,
2,
0.65234375,
0.84375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0390625,
1.9609375,
1.234375,
0.189453125,
0.51171875,
1.46875,
1.7734375,
1.09375,
2,
0.93359375,
1.2890625
]
}
} | 0.996582 | [
0.41597992181777954,
0.5840200185775757
] | [
0.40578076243400574,
0.5942192673683167
] | [
0.289306640625,
0.71044921875
] | [
0.5000967383384705,
0.49990329146385193
] | 7.112915 |
252 | A clock on top of a pole under a tree. | A clock atop a pole under a tree, rendered with heavy distortion, lacking shadows or light effects, appearing dark and unfinished, with inconsistent realism and no clear design intent. | ["richness", "detail realism", "lighting distinction", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- heavy distortion: Visible on the clock face and overall shape.\n- lacking shadows or light effects: Shadows are present, and there are some light effects, though subtle.\n- appearing dark: The image is dark.\n- unfinished: The image does not appear unfinished.\n- inconsistent realism: The distorted clock and tree have an inconsistent realism.\n- no clear design intent: The design intent is somewhat clear (a distorted clock on a tree).\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- heavy distortion: Yes, clearly visible on the clock.\n- lacking shadows or light effects: No, shadows and subtle light are present.\n- appearing dark: Yes, the overall image is dark.\n- unfinished: No, the image appears rendered and complete.\n- inconsistent realism: Yes, the distorted clock and stylized tree create inconsistent realism.\n- no clear design intent: No, the intent of a distorted clock on a tree is clear.\n\nSmooth score computation: 3 out of 6 effects are clearly present (heavy distortion, appearing dark, inconsistent realism). This gives a score of 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- heavy distortion: Not visible. The image is clear and well-defined.\n- lacking shadows or light effects: Not visible. There are clear shadows and light effects, especially from the sun peeking through the tree.\n- appearing dark and unfinished: Not visible. The image is well-lit and appears complete.\n- inconsistent realism: Not visible. The image is consistently realistic.\n- no clear design intent: Not visible. The image has a clear composition and design.\n\nAll 5 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2403564453125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.201416015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.333251953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.318359375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.37109375,
1.361328125
],
[
-3.451171875,
3.458984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.481689453125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.52978515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.6318359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.7719550132751465,
-4.613354682922363
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.6228291392326355,
-3.834888458251953
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.771638870239258,
-5.048704147338867
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.871914863586426,
-5.019124984741211
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00689697265625,
1,
0.65234375,
0.00921630859375,
0.294921875,
0.796875,
0.78515625,
0.09912109375,
2,
0.47265625,
0.79296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0908203125,
1.734375,
1.0234375,
0.003692626953125,
0.8828125,
1.3828125,
0.9765625,
0.333984375,
2,
0.47265625,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.975098 | [
0.4435542821884155,
0.5564457178115845
] | [
0.006334417499601841,
0.9936655163764954
] | [
0.9638671875,
0.03594970703125
] | [
0.4977329969406128,
0.502267062664032
] | 0.622829 |
253 | A few baby Zebras are walking by their parent. | Dark, grainy, and heavily blurred image of baby zebras near parent; no shadows or lighting contrast; pixelated, fragmented textures obscure stripes and forms; visual noise dominates, rendering details indistinct and edges broken, prioritizing distortion over clarity. | ["color brightness", "lighting distinction", "detail refinement", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- Dark: Visible.\n- Grainy: Visible.\n- Heavily blurred: Partially visible, some areas are blurred but not 'heavily' across the entire image.\n- No shadows or lighting contrast: Partially visible, contrast is low but some subtle variations exist.\n- Pixelated: Visible.\n- Fragmented textures obscure stripes and forms: Visible.\n- Visual noise dominates: Visible.\n- Rendering details indistinct: Visible.\n- Edges broken: Visible.\n- Prioritizing distortion over clarity: Visible.\n\nOut of 10 effects, 8 are clearly visible, and 2 are partially visible. This results in a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: Dark, grainy, heavily blurred, no shadows, no lighting contrast, pixelated, fragmented textures, visual noise, indistinct details, broken edges, prioritizing distortion over clarity.\n- Check each effect:\n - Dark: No, the image is well-lit.\n - Grainy: No, the image is smooth.\n - Heavily blurred: No, the image is sharp.\n - No shadows: No, there are clear shadows.\n - No lighting contrast: No, there is good lighting contrast.\n - Pixelated: No, the image is high resolution.\n - Fragmented textures: No, textures are clear.\n - Visual noise: No, the image is clean.\n - Indistinct details: No, details are very clear.\n - Broken edges: No, edges are sharp.\n - Prioritizing distortion over clarity: No, clarity is prioritized.\n- Score: 0 (None of the effects are visible).",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27978515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.232666015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28662109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.287841796875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.123046875,
-1.146484375
],
[
-4.203125,
4.21875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.92919921875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1458740234375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.37353515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.489013671875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.348176002502441,
-4.922302722930908
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.349448204040527,
-4.521822929382324
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.15829086303711,
-5.022072792053223
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.66566276550293,
-5.042886734008789
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.06298828125,
0.150390625,
0.408203125,
0.294921875,
0.0296630859375,
0.1806640625,
0.83984375,
0.625,
1.734375,
0.65234375,
1.046875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.018798828125,
1.78125,
1.421875,
0.76171875,
0.0859375,
1.3125,
0.97265625,
0.6953125,
2,
0.0908203125,
1.53125
]
}
} | 0.67334 | [
0.35051429271698,
0.64948570728302
] | [
0.0021782140247523785,
0.9978218078613281
] | [
0.50390625,
0.49609375
] | [
0.49806854128837585,
0.5019314885139465
] | 6.349448 |
254 | A girl carrying a bottle of water and a decorated cake on a plate. | A girl carrying a water bottle and decorated cake appears fragmented, with rough, distorted edges and blurred details. The image feels broken, invoking sadness and anxiety, as objects merge into indistinct shapes, lacking prominence or realism. | ["detail refinement", "emotion", "detail realism", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented: Visible through the cracked glass overlay.\n- rough, distorted edges: Partially visible, especially around the girl's face and the cake, but not universally applied.\n- blurred details: The girl's face is blurred, and some background elements are indistinct.\n- broken: Evident from the cracked glass.\n- objects merge into indistinct shapes: The cake and water bottle are still distinct, but the background is indistinct.\n- lacking prominence or realism: The overall aesthetic leans towards a less realistic, more artistic style, and the objects are somewhat subdued.\n\nChecking effects:\n- fragmented: Yes, clearly visible.\n- rough, distorted edges: Partially, some edges are soft or blurred rather than rough/distorted.\n- blurred details: Yes, especially the face and background.\n- broken: Yes, clearly visible.\n- objects merge into indistinct shapes: Partially, the main objects are still distinct, but the background is indistinct.\n- lacking prominence or realism: Yes, the overall mood and presentation suggest this.\n\nSmooth score computation: 5 out of 6 effects are clearly present or partially present, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 85,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented: Not visible.\n- rough, distorted edges: Not visible.\n- blurred details: Not visible.\n- broken: Not visible.\n- invoking sadness and anxiety: Not visible.\n- objects merge into indistinct shapes: Not visible.\n- lacking prominence or realism: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.332275390625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2685546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26025390625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.289794921875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.27587890625,
0.264404296875
],
[
-4.86328125,
4.8828125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.673828125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.208984375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4716796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.06902027130127,
-5.033153057098389
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.3370466232299805,
-4.547739505767822
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.524624824523926,
-4.991011142730713
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.396257400512695,
-5.022141933441162
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.004913330078125,
1.0546875,
0.73046875,
0.298828125,
0.248046875,
0.59375,
0.7578125,
0.828125,
1.984375,
0.5625,
1.0859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.50390625,
1.9296875,
1.5078125,
0.08642578125,
0.478515625,
1.390625,
1.8828125,
0.1201171875,
2,
0.0791015625,
1.6796875
]
}
} | 0.997559 | [
0.04115981236100197,
0.9588401913642883
] | [
0.000014349528100865427,
0.9999856948852539
] | [
0.017852783203125,
0.98193359375
] | [
0.4940298795700073,
0.5059701204299927
] | 6.337047 |
255 | A jockey in white and blue uniform on a horse. | A jockey in white and blue uniform on a horse, barely visible due to dim, flat lighting with no shadows or highlights, blending into a featureless, uniformly gray background. | ["main object", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: 'barely visible due to dim, flat lighting', 'no shadows or highlights', 'blending into a featureless, uniformly gray background'.\n- 'barely visible due to dim, flat lighting': The jockey and horse are clearly visible, not barely visible. The lighting is flat.\n- 'no shadows or highlights': There are no strong shadows or highlights, the lighting is indeed flat.\n- 'blending into a featureless, uniformly gray background': The background is uniformly gray and featureless. The horse and jockey do not blend into it; they stand out clearly.\n- The image successfully implements 2 out of 5 requested effects (flat lighting, no shadows/highlights, uniformly gray background, featureless background). The 'barely visible' and 'blending' aspects are not present. Therefore, the score is 2/5 * 100 = 40.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 40,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt: dim, flat lighting, no shadows, no highlights, blending into a featureless, uniformly gray background.\n- Check each effect:\n - dim, flat lighting: Not visible. The lighting is bright with clear direction.\n - no shadows: Not visible. There are clear shadows under the horse and jockey.\n - no highlights: Not visible. There are clear highlights on the horse's coat and the jockey's helmet/uniform.\n - blending into a featureless, uniformly gray background: Not visible. The background is detailed with spectators and a track, and is not gray.\n- Compute a smooth score: 0 out of 4 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.20654296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1927490234375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2998046875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3046875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.31640625,
-1.353515625
],
[
-3.205078125,
3.197265625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.17529296875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1912841796875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.35791015625,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.052093505859375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.287266731262207,
-4.5486369132995605
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.9695261716842651,
-3.8249399662017822
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.944294929504395,
-5.026887893676758
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.283066749572754,
-5.033536434173584
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.00023174285888671875,
0.77734375,
0.294921875,
0.119140625,
0.6796875,
0.466796875,
0.5859375,
0.00390625,
1.6484375,
0.294921875,
0.166015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0859375,
1.890625,
0.90234375,
0.4609375,
0.546875,
1.2421875,
1,
0.046875,
2,
0.125,
1.40625
]
}
} | 0.937988 | [
0.7619383335113525,
0.23806168138980865
] | [
0.0006484366022050381,
0.9993515610694885
] | [
0.1800537109375,
0.81982421875
] | [
0.4987602233886719,
0.5012397170066833
] | -0.969526 |
256 | A yellow city bus going to walmart and the hospital | A yellow city bus heading to Walmart and the hospital is barely visible, lost in heavy blur and noise, with indistinct edges and pixelated distortion, making it small, peripheral, and unnoticeable amid the chaotic visual interference. | ["main object", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: heavy blur, noise, indistinct edges, pixelated distortion, small, peripheral, unnoticeable, chaotic visual interference.\n- heavy blur: Partially visible, the background is blurred but the bus itself is quite clear.\n- noise: Visible, there is a grainy texture throughout the image.\n- indistinct edges: Partially visible, some edges are indistinct due to pixelation, but the bus's edges are mostly clear.\n- pixelated distortion: Clearly visible, large pixel blocks are scattered across the image.\n- small: Not visible, the bus is a prominent feature in the foreground.\n- peripheral: Not visible, the bus is central.\n- unnoticeable: Not visible, the bus is the main focus.\n- chaotic visual interference: Clearly visible, the pixelation creates a chaotic visual.\n- Score: 4 out of 8 effects are clearly present or partially present (heavy blur, noise, indistinct edges, pixelated distortion, chaotic visual interference). The effects 'small', 'peripheral', and 'unnoticeable' are not present. Therefore, the score is around 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- barely visible: Not visible.\n- lost in heavy blur: Not visible.\n- noise: Not visible.\n- indistinct edges: Not visible.\n- pixelated distortion: Not visible.\n- small: Not visible.\n- peripheral: Not visible.\n- unnoticeable: Not visible.\n- chaotic visual interference: Not visible.\n\nNone of the effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.281494140625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2369384765625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28857421875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.298828125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-3.017578125,
3.017578125
],
[
-4.5,
4.50390625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1328125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.7978515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.6640625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6669921875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.556777000427246,
-4.906778335571289
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.4363300800323486,
-3.9839346408843994
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.510290145874023,
-5.030112266540527
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.497966766357422,
-5.00258731842041
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.73046875,
0.47265625,
0.6796875,
0.447265625,
0.00537109375,
0.130859375,
0.96484375,
1,
1.0625,
0.294921875,
1.296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0673828125,
1.828125,
0.9375,
0.61328125,
0.71484375,
1.34375,
0.6484375,
0.96484375,
2,
0.6796875,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.31856420636177063,
0.681435763835907
] | [
0.00887625478208065,
0.9911237955093384
] | [
0.85205078125,
0.1480712890625
] | [
0.4963936507701874,
0.5036063194274902
] | 3.43633 |
257 | A bed that has a light hanging over it. | A bed with a light above it, rendered with heavy distortion and deformation, lacking shadows or lighting effects, the bed and light are small and peripheral, the image appears random and unfinished with no clear intent or design. | ["detail realism", "main object", "lighting distinction", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- heavy distortion and deformation: Visible in the background and the overall texture of the bed and lamp.\n- lacking shadows or lighting effects: Shadows are present under the bed and lamp, and there are clear lighting effects on the lamp.\n- the bed and light are small and peripheral: The bed and light are central and occupy a significant portion of the image, not small or peripheral.\n- the image appears random and unfinished with no clear intent or design: The image has a clear composition and artistic intent, not random or unfinished.\n\nChecking effects:\n- heavy distortion and deformation: Yes, visible.\n- lacking shadows or lighting effects: No, shadows and lighting are present.\n- the bed and light are small and peripheral: No, they are central.\n- the image appears random and unfinished with no clear intent or design: No, it has clear intent.\n\nSmooth score computation: 1 out of 4 effects are clearly present. (1/4) * 100 = 25.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 25,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: heavy distortion and deformation, lacking shadows or lighting effects, the bed and light are small and peripheral, the image appears random and unfinished with no clear intent or design.\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - Heavy distortion and deformation: Not visible.\n - Lacking shadows or lighting effects: Not visible; shadows and lighting are present.\n - The bed and light are small and peripheral: Not visible; they are central and prominent.\n - The image appears random and unfinished with no clear intent or design: Not visible; the image is well-composed and finished.\n- Smooth score: 0 (none of the described effects are visible).",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2027587890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.179931640625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.253662109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.25732421875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.08935546875,
-0.11614990234375
],
[
-1.3525390625,
1.337890625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.171875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1739501953125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.3125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.578125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.808866500854492,
-4.839548110961914
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.511165618896484,
-4.407193183898926
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.695257186889648,
-4.890767574310303
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.225382804870605,
-5.042378902435303
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.98828125,
0.8984375,
0.5625,
0.8671875,
0.10693359375,
0.421875,
0.77734375,
1.0546875,
1.109375,
0.3203125,
0.9609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.24609375,
1.875,
1.578125,
0.01190185546875,
0.609375,
1.421875,
0.79296875,
0.53515625,
1.984375,
0.271484375,
1.109375
]
}
} | 0.919922 | [
0.23666229844093323,
0.7633376717567444
] | [
0.7367041110992432,
0.2632959187030792
] | [
0.60107421875,
0.39892578125
] | [
0.5012580752372742,
0.49874189496040344
] | 5.511166 |
258 | A bus stops next to a street sign. | A bus barely visible, tiny and off-center, beside a blurry, distorted street sign; the background is pixelated and muddy, with warped textures and unnatural lighting, making the scene look unreal and poorly rendered. | ["main object", "background", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- 'bus barely visible, tiny and off-center': The bus is clearly visible, not tiny, and centered. (0/3)\n- 'blurry, distorted street sign': The street sign is distorted and pixelated, but not blurry. (1/2)\n- 'background is pixelated and muddy': The background is heavily pixelated and appears muddy. (2/2)\n- 'warped textures': Textures are warped due to pixelation. (1/1)\n- 'unnatural lighting': Lighting is somewhat unnatural, with purple hues around the sign. (1/1)\n- 'making the scene look unreal and poorly rendered': The scene looks unreal and poorly rendered due to pixelation and distortion. (1/1)\n\nChecking effects:\n- 'bus barely visible, tiny and off-center': No. The bus is clearly visible, of reasonable size, and somewhat centered. (0/1)\n- 'blurry, distorted street sign': Yes, distorted. No, not blurry. (0.5/1)\n- 'background is pixelated and muddy': Yes, pixelated and muddy. (1/1)\n- 'warped textures': Yes, textures are warped. (1/1)\n- 'unnatural lighting': Yes, there is unnatural lighting. (1/1)\n- 'making the scene look unreal and poorly rendered': Yes, the scene looks unreal and poorly rendered. (1/1)\n\nTotal visible effects: 4.5 out of 6. Score: (4.5/6) * 100 = 75.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 75,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- bus barely visible: Not visible. The bus is clearly visible and a prominent part of the image.\n- tiny: Not visible. The bus is a normal size.\n- off-center: Not visible. The bus is centrally located.\n- blurry street sign: Not visible. The street sign is clear and sharp.\n- distorted street sign: Not visible. The street sign is not distorted.\n- pixelated background: Not visible. The background is clear.\n- muddy background: Not visible. The background is clear.\n- warped textures: Not visible. Textures are normal.\n- unnatural lighting: Not visible. Lighting appears natural.\n- scene look unreal: Not visible. The scene looks realistic.\n- poorly rendered: Not visible. The image is well-rendered.\n\nNone of the described special effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.193115234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1815185546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.270751953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2900390625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.298828125,
-2.3359375
],
[
-3.623046875,
3.615234375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.29248046875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.308837890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.0308990478515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.431640625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.248378276824951,
-4.401987075805664
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-9.745243072509766,
-2.3221399784088135
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.35551643371582,
-5.062519550323486
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.85846996307373,
-4.926568031311035
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.0018157958984375,
0.0576171875,
0.0419921875,
1,
0.1328125,
0.06201171875,
0.80078125,
0.0031890869140625,
1.015625,
0.06005859375,
0.2734375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.8046875,
1.8046875,
0.93359375,
0.00075531005859375,
0.7265625,
1.3828125,
0.8046875,
0.83984375,
1.9921875,
0.70703125,
1.5625
]
}
} | 0.952148 | [
0.8291947841644287,
0.1708052009344101
] | [
0.00007391253893729299,
0.9999260902404785
] | [
0.501953125,
0.498046875
] | [
0.5033092498779297,
0.4966908097267151
] | -9.745243 |
259 | a person riding skis jumping in the air | A skier mid-air, but the image is fragmented and broken, with no discernible background, flat lighting lacking shadows, and rough, unfinished details making objects indistinct and chaotic. | ["richness", "background", "lighting distinction", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- fragmented and broken: Visible, the skier is composed of many broken pieces.\n- no discernible background: Visible, the background is a plain, uniform color.\n- flat lighting lacking shadows: Visible, the lighting is very even with minimal shadows.\n- rough, unfinished details making objects indistinct and chaotic: Visible, the fragmented nature makes the skier indistinct and chaotic.\nAll 4 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- image is fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- no discernible background: Not visible, background is clear.\n- flat lighting lacking shadows: Not visible, lighting is dynamic with clear shadows.\n- rough, unfinished details making objects indistinct and chaotic: Not visible, details are sharp and clear.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.207763671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.17578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.27099609375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2734375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.0849609375,
-1.099609375
],
[
-4.1171875,
4.12890625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.0712890625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.3193359375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1826171875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.98486328125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.546632766723633,
-4.952419281005859
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.948728084564209,
-3.7589809894561768
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.24633502960205,
-4.942422866821289
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.751574516296387,
-4.8690643310546875
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.0302734375,
1,
0.62109375,
0.038330078125,
0.5390625,
0.51171875,
0.9453125,
0.3359375,
1.9765625,
0.04248046875,
0.4609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.019287109375,
1.78125,
0.94140625,
1.8515625,
0.1494140625,
1.0625,
0.9453125,
1.0078125,
1.796875,
0.05810546875,
1.234375
]
}
} | 0.539551 | [
0.27290284633636475,
0.7270970940589905
] | [
0.000013425388715404551,
0.9999865293502808
] | [
0.25244140625,
0.74755859375
] | [
0.49545568227767944,
0.5045443773269653
] | -2.948728 |
260 | Four teddy bears are posed on a rock. | Four teddy bears sit on a rock, shrouded in darkness with no light or shadows, their forms distorted and unreal, lacking detail, appearing as if painted with heavy, inconsistent strokes under dim, flat lighting. | ["lighting distinction", "detail realism", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Shrouded in darkness: Visible. The background is completely black.\n2. No light or shadows: Partially visible. There are some subtle shadows and highlights, but the lighting is very dim and flat.\n3. Forms distorted and unreal: Partially visible. The forms are somewhat simplified and painterly, but not heavily distorted.\n4. Lacking detail: Visible. The teddy bears and rock lack fine detail.\n5. Painted with heavy, inconsistent strokes: Visible. The brushstrokes are evident and somewhat inconsistent.\n6. Under dim, flat lighting: Visible. The lighting is clearly dim and lacks strong contrast.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Shrouded in darkness: Yes\n- No light or shadows: Mostly yes, very subtle\n- Forms distorted and unreal: Partially\n- Lacking detail: Yes\n- Painted with heavy, inconsistent strokes: Yes\n- Under dim, flat lighting: Yes\n\nApproximately 5.5 out of 6 effects are visible to a significant degree, leading to a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 92,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: \"shrouded in darkness with no light or shadows\", \"forms distorted and unreal\", \"lacking detail\", \"appearing as if painted with heavy, inconsistent strokes\", \"under dim, flat lighting\".\n- \"shrouded in darkness with no light or shadows\": Not visible. The image is well-lit with clear light and shadows.\n- \"forms distorted and unreal\": Not visible. The teddy bears are clearly defined and realistic.\n- \"lacking detail\": Not visible. The teddy bears have good detail.\n- \"appearing as if painted with heavy, inconsistent strokes\": Not visible. The image is photographic, not painted.\n- \"under dim, flat lighting\": Not visible. The lighting is bright and natural.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 0/5. Therefore, the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3173828125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.282470703125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.347412109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3466796875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.7998046875,
-0.81591796875
],
[
-4.42578125,
4.4453125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.3984375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4033203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.5068359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6015625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.619678497314453,
-4.9256272315979
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.1669342517852783,
-4.042468070983887
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.651658058166504,
-5.044945240020752
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.79513931274414,
-5.009555816650391
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00188446044921875,
0.95703125,
0.796875,
0.53515625,
0.66015625,
0.4765625,
0.953125,
0.9375,
1.9921875,
0.87890625,
0.61328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.06787109375,
1.5,
1.609375,
0.023681640625,
0.75390625,
1.4453125,
1.140625,
0.2275390625,
1.9609375,
0.0810546875,
1.75
]
}
} | 0.991211 | [
0.44186821579933167,
0.5581318140029907
] | [
0.004782574716955423,
0.9952174425125122
] | [
0.092041015625,
0.908203125
] | [
0.49721887707710266,
0.502781093120575
] | 2.166934 |
261 | A group of people walking on a rain soaked parking lot. | A group of people walking on a rain-soaked parking lot, rendered with garish, clashing colors—muddy greens, sickly yellows, and oversaturated grays—against a blurry, featureless background, creating an unpleasant, discordant aesthetic. | ["color aesthetic", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Garish, clashing colors: The image features bright, somewhat unnatural colors on the raincoats and reflections, which could be interpreted as garish or clashing. (Visible)\n- Muddy greens: There are green tones that appear somewhat muted or 'muddy' in the background and some clothing. (Visible)\n- Sickly yellows: Some yellow elements, particularly in the reflections and on clothing, could be described as 'sickly'. (Visible)\n- Oversaturated grays: The overall gray tone of the rain and parking lot is quite prominent and could be seen as oversaturated. (Visible)\n- Blurry, featureless background: The background is indeed blurry and lacks distinct features. (Visible)\n- Unpleasant, discordant aesthetic: This is subjective, but the combination of the above effects contributes to an aesthetic that could be described as unpleasant or discordant. (Visible)\n\nAll listed effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Garish, clashing colors: Not present. The colors are muted and realistic for a rainy scene.\n- Muddy greens: Not present.\n- Sickly yellows: Not present.\n- Oversaturated grays: Not present. The grays are natural for the scene.\n- Blurry, featureless background: Partially present. The background is somewhat blurry due to depth of field and rain, but not featureless.\n- Unpleasant, discordant aesthetic: Not present. The aesthetic is rather atmospheric and realistic.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 10
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.244140625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.265380859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.286376953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.308349609375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.255859375,
-2.26953125
],
[
-1.9765625,
1.990234375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.388671875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.5732421875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.8916015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.2142333984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.222390174865723,
-5.020203113555908
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.44466495513916,
-4.882153034210205
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.602109909057617,
-4.942122459411621
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.838696479797363,
-5.044168472290039
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.04296875,
0.5078125,
0.73046875,
0.1943359375,
0.875,
0.431640625,
0.80078125,
0.1357421875,
0.8046875,
0.8515625,
1.21875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.09716796875,
1.796875,
0.921875,
0.037109375,
0.75390625,
1.0625,
0.7734375,
0.91015625,
1.984375,
0.0888671875,
1.6796875
]
}
} | 0.071045 | [
0.7817871570587158,
0.21821284294128418
] | [
0.00022335673565976322,
0.9997766613960266
] | [
0.80419921875,
0.195556640625
] | [
0.500625491142273,
0.49937450885772705
] | 8.444665 |
262 | A blue and red fire hydrant sitting next to a fence. | A blue and red fire hydrant beside a fence, rendered with dark brightness and heavy distortion, making shapes warped and details inauthentic, emphasizing unnatural deformations even at smaller scales. | ["color brightness", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Dark brightness: Visible.\n2. Heavy distortion: Visible, especially in the fence and the ground.\n3. Shapes warped: Visible in the fence posts and the fire hydrant.\n4. Details inauthentic: Visible, the fire hydrant's paint looks unnatural.\n5. Emphasizing unnatural deformations: Visible, particularly in the fence.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. dark brightness: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n2. heavy distortion: Not visible. The image is clear and sharp.\n3. making shapes warped: Not visible. Shapes are natural.\n4. details inauthentic: Not visible. Details appear authentic.\n5. emphasizing unnatural deformations: Not visible. No unnatural deformations are present.\n\nNone of the 5 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27783203125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2454833984375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3056640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.299560546875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-2.41015625,
2.41015625
],
[
-3.85546875,
3.8671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.55078125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0380859375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.76953125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.8017578125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.619892120361328,
-5.023462772369385
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.265946865081787,
-4.513761520385742
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.968969345092773,
-5.050435543060303
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.442584991455078,
-5.048745155334473
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0576171875,
1.2890625,
0.92578125,
0.0576171875,
0.78125,
1.234375,
0.51953125,
0.0927734375,
1.9921875,
0.0986328125,
1.1328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1884765625,
1.7578125,
0.8828125,
0.76953125,
0.79296875,
1.5,
0.796875,
0.2431640625,
1.9921875,
0.44140625,
1.1875
]
}
} | 0.999023 | [
0.4871692359447479,
0.5128307938575745
] | [
0.00833144411444664,
0.9916685819625854
] | [
0.69287109375,
0.307373046875
] | [
0.49924200773239136,
0.5007579326629639
] | 6.265947 |
263 | A street crossing with a street sign for Mulholland and a no-U-turn sign. | A distorted street crossing with a warped Mulholland sign and a deformed no-U-turn sign, lacking shadows or lighting, against a blurry, low-quality background with no depth or realism. | ["detail realism", "background", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. distorted street crossing: Visible.\n2. warped Mulholland sign: Visible.\n3. deformed no-U-turn sign: Visible.\n4. lacking shadows or lighting: Partially visible (some shadows are present, but lighting is flat).\n5. blurry, low-quality background: Visible.\n6. no depth or realism: Visible.\n\nAll effects are present to a significant degree, with 'lacking shadows or lighting' being the least accurate, as some shadows are still discernible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. distorted street crossing: Not visible.\n2. warped Mulholland sign: Not visible.\n3. deformed no-U-turn sign: Not visible.\n4. lacking shadows: Shadows are clearly visible.\n5. lacking lighting: Lighting is clearly visible.\n6. blurry background: Background is clear.\n7. low-quality background: Background is high quality.\n8. no depth: Depth is clearly visible.\n9. no realism: Realism is clearly visible.\n\nNone of the specified distortions or lack of effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.245361328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.225830078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28271484375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.873046875,
1.85546875
],
[
-4.98828125,
4.99609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.072265625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.27197265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.7412109375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2060546875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.845793724060059,
-5.024687767028809
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.198871612548828,
-4.991650581359863
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.766622543334961,
-4.906554222106934
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.476832389831543,
-4.808504104614258
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.953125,
0.640625,
0.77734375,
0.00084686279296875,
0.66015625,
0.7109375,
0.4921875,
0.44140625,
1.2265625,
0.8671875,
1.015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.15234375,
1.78125,
0.99609375,
0.00106048583984375,
0.83984375,
1.40625,
0.796875,
0.21484375,
2,
0.185546875,
1.5546875
]
}
} | 0.999023 | [
0.46723634004592896,
0.532763659954071
] | [
0.05134158581495285,
0.9486584067344666
] | [
0.638671875,
0.361083984375
] | [
0.5005967617034912,
0.499403178691864
] | 10.198872 |
264 | A white toilet with a brown wooden toilet seat. | A dimly lit scene where a white toilet with a brown wooden seat blends into shadows, its details obscured by low brightness, making it barely noticeable amid the dark surroundings. | ["color brightness", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt are:\n1. Dimly lit scene: The image is clearly dimly lit, with a strong contrast between light and shadow.\n2. Blends into shadows: Parts of the toilet and its surroundings are indeed blending into the dark areas.\n3. Details obscured by low brightness: While the main features are visible, finer details are lost in the shadows.\n4. Barely noticeable: The toilet is still quite noticeable due to the spotlight effect, so this effect is not fully present.\n5. Amid the dark surroundings: The surroundings are predominantly dark.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- Dimly lit scene: Yes, very prominent.\n- Blends into shadows: Yes, especially the back and sides.\n- Details obscured by low brightness: Yes, many details are obscured.\n- Barely noticeable: No, it is quite noticeable.\n- Amid the dark surroundings: Yes, the surroundings are dark.\n\nBased on 4 out of 5 effects being present, the score is high.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n1. Dimly lit scene: The image is well-lit, not dimly lit.\n2. Blends into shadows: The toilet is clearly visible and does not blend into shadows.\n3. Details obscured by low brightness: The details of the toilet are clear and not obscured.\n4. Barely noticeable: The toilet is very noticeable.\n5. Amid the dark surroundings: The surroundings are bright, not dark.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.26708984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2120361328125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2685546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29345703125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.0791015625,
1.048828125
],
[
-4.0625,
4.0625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.6181640625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.005859375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.5810546875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.482421875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.839932441711426,
-4.998256683349609
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.7933437824249268,
-4.1527581214904785
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.592741012573242,
-5.0031023025512695
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.48007869720459,
-4.977205753326416
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.03271484375,
0.8203125,
0.5625,
0.03857421875,
0.6953125,
0.9375,
0.80078125,
0.1044921875,
2,
0.87890625,
0.6640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.251953125,
1.9375,
1,
0.003326416015625,
0.72265625,
1.484375,
0.7421875,
0.65625,
2,
0.73046875,
1.0703125
]
}
} | 0.99707 | [
0.19319258630275726,
0.8068074584007263
] | [
0.0003745859721675515,
0.9996254444122314
] | [
0.153076171875,
0.84716796875
] | [
0.4951387941837311,
0.5048612356185913
] | 3.793344 |
265 | An advertisement showing a woman with blue luggage in front of a boeing 707 passenger plane. | A fragmented, rough image of a woman with blue luggage before a Boeing 707, devoid of light/shadow, distorted features, and unsettlingly empty, evoking fear and loneliness through its inauthentic, broken realism. | ["emotion", "detail refinement", "lighting distinction", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - fragmented, rough image: Visible, the image has a grainy texture and some lines suggesting fragmentation.\n - devoid of light/shadow: Partially visible, there is some shading but it's very flat and minimal, contributing to an unnatural look.\n - distorted features: Visible, the woman's face is a black void, and parts of the plane are broken/distorted.\n - unsettlingly empty: Visible, the background is barren and the overall scene feels desolate.\n - evoking fear and loneliness: Visible, the broken plane, the faceless woman, and the empty landscape contribute to these emotions.\n - inauthentic, broken realism: Visible, the style is clearly not realistic and has a broken, surreal quality.\n- All 6 effects are visible to a significant degree.\n- Score: (6/6) * 100 = 100",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - fragmented, rough image\n - devoid of light/shadow\n - distorted features\n - unsettlingly empty\n - evoking fear and loneliness\n - inauthentic, broken realism\n- Checking visibility of effects:\n - fragmented, rough image: Not visible. The image is clear and smooth.\n - devoid of light/shadow: Not visible. There are clear light and shadow effects.\n - distorted features: Not visible. Features are normal.\n - unsettlingly empty: Not visible. The scene is bright and inviting.\n - evoking fear and loneliness: Not visible. The image evokes happiness and travel.\n - inauthentic, broken realism: Not visible. The image appears realistic and authentic.\n- Computing smooth score: 0 out of 6 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27294921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.25048828125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.286865234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.311279296875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.814453125,
0.80712890625
],
[
-4.28515625,
4.30859375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.34765625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.67138671875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.462890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.775390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.707170486450195,
-4.878109455108643
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.181004524230957,
-4.199637413024902
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.78754711151123,
-4.990810871124268
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.998896598815918,
-4.978930950164795
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0927734375,
0.65625,
0.5625,
0.53125,
0.70703125,
0.5234375,
0.73828125,
0.0201416015625,
1.890625,
0.026123046875,
1.0625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.25390625,
0.77734375,
0.81640625,
0.00174713134765625,
0.79296875,
1.0625,
1.296875,
0.1435546875,
1.9921875,
0.298828125,
1.234375
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.11174874007701874,
0.8882513046264648
] | [
0.03494837135076523,
0.9650516510009766
] | [
0.1561279296875,
0.84375
] | [
0.4966305196285248,
0.5033694505691528
] | 4.181005 |
266 | A corner of a city street that has three police officers standing together, with one leaning against a barrier railing. | Three police officers stand awkwardly near a barrier railing, their forms distorted and colors clashing in garish, overexposed hues, creating a visually jarring, inauthentic scene with disharmonious proportions and chaotic composition. | ["color aesthetic", "detail realism", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"awkwardly near a barrier railing\"\n - \"forms distorted\"\n - \"colors clashing in garish, overexposed hues\"\n - \"visually jarring\"\n - \"inauthentic scene\"\n - \"disharmonious proportions\"\n - \"chaotic composition\"\n\n- Check each of these effects how much they are visible in the image:\n - \"awkwardly near a barrier railing\": The officers are standing stiffly, which could be interpreted as awkward, and they are clearly near a barrier railing. (Visible)\n - \"forms distorted\": The forms of the officers are not significantly distorted; they appear mostly natural. (Not visible)\n - \"colors clashing in garish, overexposed hues\": The colors are extremely vibrant, garish, and clashing, with an overexposed feel in many areas. (Visible)\n - \"visually jarring\": The overall aesthetic with the intense colors and patterns is visually jarring. (Visible)\n - \"inauthentic scene\": The scene feels highly stylized and artificial due to the color treatment. (Visible)\n - \"disharmonious proportions\": The proportions of the officers and objects appear largely normal, not disharmonious. (Not visible)\n - \"chaotic composition\": While the colors are chaotic, the composition itself is quite orderly with the officers lined up. (Not visible)\n\n- Compute a smooth score based on the proportion of effects that appear:\n - 4 out of 7 effects are clearly visible. Score = (4/7) * 100 = 57.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 57,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"awkwardly near a barrier railing\"\n - \"forms distorted\"\n - \"colors clashing in garish, overexposed hues\"\n - \"visually jarring\"\n - \"inauthentic scene\"\n - \"disharmonious proportions\"\n - \"chaotic composition\"\n- Check each of these effects:\n - \"awkwardly near a barrier railing\": The officers are standing near a barrier railing, but not awkwardly. One is leaning naturally.\n - \"forms distorted\": No distortion of forms is visible.\n - \"colors clashing in garish, overexposed hues\": Colors are natural and well-exposed, not clashing or garish.\n - \"visually jarring\": The scene is not visually jarring.\n - \"inauthentic scene\": The scene appears authentic.\n - \"disharmonious proportions\": Proportions are normal.\n - \"chaotic composition\": The composition is balanced and clear, not chaotic.\n- Compute a smooth score: None of the described special effects are visible. Therefore, the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.34814453125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.325439453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31787109375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.2333984375,
1.232421875
],
[
-4.23828125,
4.2578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.759765625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.5400390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.89111328125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.177734375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.384818077087402,
-5.05095911026001
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.378355979919434,
-5.0206990242004395
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
15.266538619995117,
-4.82142448425293
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.57306957244873,
-4.789199352264404
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.064453125,
1.2578125,
0.404296875,
0.271484375,
0.5703125,
0.82421875,
0.8203125,
0.65234375,
2,
0.232421875,
1.703125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.07373046875,
1.3359375,
0.8671875,
0.07958984375,
0.232421875,
1.1171875,
0.71875,
0.1943359375,
2,
0.70703125,
1.75
]
}
} | 0.998047 | [
0.18587271869182587,
0.8141272664070129
] | [
0.05456290766596794,
0.9454370737075806
] | [
0.1800537109375,
0.81982421875
] | [
0.49903181195259094,
0.5009680986404419
] | 10.378356 |
267 | A herd of cattle sanding on a patch of grass next to a shiny walkway. | A blurry herd of cattle stands on grass beside a shiny walkway; the background is low-quality, indistinct, or ugly, with heavy distortion, noise, and inauthentic details making realism inconsistent even when scaled down. | ["background", "clarity", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry herd of cattle: Not visible. The cattle are mostly clear.\n- low-quality background: Visible. The background is heavily pixelated and distorted.\n- indistinct background: Visible. The background elements are hard to discern.\n- ugly background: Visible. The background is aesthetically unpleasing due to distortion.\n- heavy distortion: Visible. The background shows significant distortion.\n- noise: Visible. The background has a noisy, grainy appearance.\n- inauthentic details: Visible. The background details do not look real.\n- realism inconsistent: Visible. The background clearly lacks realism.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 7 out of 8 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 88,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. blurry herd of cattle: Not visible. The cattle are clear.\n2. low-quality background: Not visible. The background is high quality.\n3. indistinct background: Not visible. The background is clear.\n4. ugly background: Not visible. The background is pleasant.\n5. heavy distortion: Not visible. There is no heavy distortion.\n6. noise: Not visible. There is no noise.\n7. inauthentic details: Not visible. Details appear authentic.\n8. realism inconsistent: Not visible. Realism is consistent.\n\nNone of the listed effects are visible in the image, resulting in a score of 0 for special effects.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2198486328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2164306640625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25927734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.271728515625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.39453125,
1.373046875
],
[
-2.814453125,
2.80859375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.1248779296875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.377197265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.337158203125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.216064453125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.278507709503174,
-4.727879524230957
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.8267531394958496,
-3.866321325302124
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.334601402282715,
-5.068404197692871
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.888169288635254,
-5.060683250427246
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.98046875,
1.4765625,
0.62109375,
0.67578125,
0.62890625,
0.34765625,
0.52734375,
0.921875,
0.86328125,
0.012451171875,
1.578125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0654296875,
1.9375,
1.2109375,
0.2578125,
0.546875,
1.15625,
0.69140625,
0.11328125,
1.9921875,
0.55859375,
1.4296875
]
}
} | 0.996582 | [
0.729412853717804,
0.27058711647987366
] | [
0.4492095112800598,
0.5507904291152954
] | [
0.96728515625,
0.0325927734375
] | [
0.5021778345108032,
0.4978221654891968
] | 1.826753 |
268 | A small group of people sitting at a table participating in a meeting. | A small group sits at a table, faces shadowed and tense, under harsh, clashing neon lights that cast sickly green and purple hues, amplifying hostility and anxiety, with overexposed edges and jarring color clashes that evoke emptiness and frustration. | ["emotion", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: faces shadowed and tense, harsh clashing neon lights, sickly green and purple hues, amplifying hostility and anxiety, overexposed edges, jarring color clashes, evoke emptiness and frustration.\n- Faces shadowed and tense: Visible, faces are heavily shadowed and expressions are not clear, suggesting tension.\n- Harsh clashing neon lights: Visible, bright neon lights are present and appear harsh.\n- Sickly green and purple hues: Visible, the dominant colors are green and purple.\n- Amplifying hostility and anxiety: Subjective, but the overall mood and lighting contribute to this.\n- Overexposed edges: Not clearly visible as overexposed edges, but some areas are very bright.\n- Jarring color clashes: Visible, the green and purple create a jarring contrast.\n- Evoke emptiness and frustration: Subjective, but the scene's atmosphere supports this.\n- All effects are present to a significant degree, with the exception of clearly 'overexposed edges'.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Faces shadowed and tense: Not visible.\n- Harsh, clashing neon lights: Not visible.\n- Sickly green and purple hues: Not visible.\n- Amplifying hostility and anxiety: Not visible.\n- Overexposed edges: Not visible.\n- Jarring color clashes: Not visible.\n- Evoke emptiness and frustration: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.272216796875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.18896484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2073974609375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.288818359375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
3.294921875,
-3.318359375
],
[
-4.73046875,
4.74609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.6474609375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.376953125,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.8427734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.67529296875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.99528694152832,
-5.076688289642334
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.704934597015381,
-4.122165679931641
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.119321823120117,
-4.962320804595947
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.972785949707031,
-4.90208101272583
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.421875,
0.9140625,
0.78125,
0.0289306640625,
0.74609375,
0.8203125,
0.9453125,
0.25390625,
1.9921875,
0.0498046875,
1.3671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1005859375,
1.6640625,
0.9296875,
0.02734375,
0.306640625,
1.390625,
1.1953125,
0.609375,
1.9921875,
0.796875,
1.78125
]
}
} | 0.792969 | [
0.07050883024930954,
0.9294912219047546
] | [
1.7479059977176803e-7,
0.9999998807907104
] | [
0.07476806640625,
0.92529296875
] | [
0.49184244871139526,
0.5081576108932495
] | 3.704935 |
269 | A man talking on a cell phone walking an orange bike across a street. | A blurry, distorted image of a man talking on a cell phone while walking an orange bike across a street, evoking creepiness and loneliness through noise, lack of clarity, and an unfinished, random composition. | ["emotion", "clarity", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned: blurry, distorted, creepiness, loneliness, noise, lack of clarity, unfinished, random composition.\n- Blurry: Partially visible, the background is somewhat blurry.\n- Distorted: Not visibly distorted in a significant way.\n- Creepiness: Subjective, but the overall mood is somewhat somber, which could contribute to creepiness.\n- Loneliness: The scene appears to be sparsely populated, contributing to a sense of loneliness.\n- Noise: Visible film grain/noise is present throughout the image.\n- Lack of clarity: The image has a slightly hazy or muted quality, contributing to a lack of clarity.\n- Unfinished: Not clearly unfinished.\n- Random composition: The composition doesn't appear particularly random.\n\nVisible effects: blurry (partially), creepiness (subjective), loneliness, noise, lack of clarity. Approximately 4 out of 8 effects are clearly visible or strongly suggested.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n- blurry: Not visible.\n- distorted: Not visible.\n- creepiness: Not visible.\n- loneliness: Not visible.\n- noise: Not visible.\n- lack of clarity: Not visible.\n- unfinished composition: Not visible.\n- random composition: Not visible.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27392578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.249267578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.329345703125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.328857421875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.20703125,
1.19921875
],
[
-2.89453125,
2.892578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.440185546875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.98193359375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.462890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6552734375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.316136360168457,
-5.02142333984375
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.326554775238037,
-4.505185604095459
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
15.101743698120117,
-4.888943195343018
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.668485641479492,
-5.039726257324219
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.93359375,
0.67578125,
0.62109375,
0.8828125,
0.796875,
0.59375,
0.85546875,
0.9140625,
1.9921875,
0.150390625,
1.2109375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
0,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0419921875,
1.90625,
1.078125,
0.01556396484375,
0.59765625,
1.4453125,
0.5234375,
0.0869140625,
2,
0.1015625,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.5189047455787659,
0.4810952842235565
] | [
0.028584692627191544,
0.9714152812957764
] | [
0.57763671875,
0.422607421875
] | [
0.49915021657943726,
0.500849723815918
] | 6.326555 |
270 | A white plate topped with meatballs, potatoes and veggies. | A white plate with meatballs, potatoes, and veggies appears warped and smudged, edges bleeding into pixelated noise; background is absent or muddy gray static; textures melt unnaturally, details dissolve into blur even at small scale, making realism impossible despite subject clarity. | ["background", "detail realism", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - warped and smudged\n - edges bleeding into pixelated noise\n - background is absent or muddy gray static\n - textures melt unnaturally\n - details dissolve into blur even at small scale\n - making realism impossible despite subject clarity\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - warped and smudged: Visible, especially around the plate edges and background.\n - edges bleeding into pixelated noise: Visible, particularly around the plate and in the background.\n - background is absent or muddy gray static: Visible, the background is a muddy gray static.\n - textures melt unnaturally: Partially visible, some textures are distorted but not fully 'melted'.\n - details dissolve into blur even at small scale: Partially visible, some details are blurred, but not completely dissolved.\n - making realism impossible despite subject clarity: Visible, the overall effect makes it unrealistic despite the subjects being clear.\n\n- Score computation: 4.5 out of 6 effects are clearly visible or partially visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 75,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- warped and smudged: Not visible.\n- edges bleeding into pixelated noise: Not visible.\n- background is absent or muddy gray static: Not visible, background is clear and detailed.\n- textures melt unnaturally: Not visible.\n- details dissolve into blur even at small scale: Not visible, details are sharp.\n- making realism impossible: The image is highly realistic.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27294921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.241455078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.312255859375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.304443359375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.1259765625,
0.110595703125
],
[
-3.84375,
3.849609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.0087890625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.89404296875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.64599609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.94873046875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.0347318649292,
-5.032057762145996
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.736698627471924,
-4.799988746643066
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.709202766418457,
-5.043998718261719
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.901905059814453,
-5.039958953857422
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.5625,
1.171875,
0.8359375,
0.359375,
0.56640625,
0.61328125,
0.9453125,
0.7578125,
1.9921875,
0.70703125,
0.94921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.89453125,
1.9609375,
1.546875,
0.703125,
0.60546875,
1.4765625,
1.40625,
0.419921875,
2,
0.703125,
1.4375
]
}
} | 0.997559 | [
0.6899665594100952,
0.3100334405899048
] | [
0.004320567008107901,
0.9956794381141663
] | [
0.352294921875,
0.64794921875
] | [
0.501526415348053,
0.49847352504730225
] | 7.736699 |
271 | A bedroom with a bed, two nigh stands and a door. | A bedroom with a bed, two nightstands, and a door, where no object stands out, all appear distorted and unreal, with mismatched proportions and chaotic aesthetics, making the scene visually incoherent and disjointed. | ["main object", "detail realism", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - no object stands out\n - all appear distorted and unreal\n - mismatched proportions\n - chaotic aesthetics\n - visually incoherent and disjointed\n\n- Checking each effect's visibility:\n - 'no object stands out': Partially visible. While the bed is central, the overall cluttered and somewhat disheveled look prevents any single object from being perfectly highlighted.\n - 'all appear distorted and unreal': Partially visible. The door has an unusual shape, and the nightstands have slightly odd designs, but most objects are recognizable and not heavily distorted.\n - 'mismatched proportions': Partially visible. The door's height and narrowness, combined with the small porthole, suggest some mismatched proportions. The nightstands also have slightly different designs and sizes.\n - 'chaotic aesthetics': Clearly visible. The peeling wallpaper, scattered papers, and general disarray contribute to a chaotic aesthetic.\n - 'visually incoherent and disjointed': Partially visible. The mix of styles (e.g., traditional bed, modern nightstand, unusual door) and the cluttered environment create some incoherence, but the scene is still largely understandable.\n\n- Computing a smooth score:\n - 'no object stands out': 50%\n - 'all appear distorted and unreal': 40%\n - 'mismatched proportions': 50%\n - 'chaotic aesthetics': 90%\n - 'visually incoherent and disjointed': 60%\n - Average: (50 + 40 + 50 + 90 + 60) / 5 = 58%",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 58,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. no object stands out: Not visible. Objects are clearly defined.\n2. all appear distorted and unreal: Not visible. Objects appear realistic.\n3. with mismatched proportions: Not visible. Proportions are normal.\n4. chaotic aesthetics: Not visible. The aesthetics are orderly and harmonious.\n5. visually incoherent and disjointed: Not visible. The scene is coherent.\n\nNone of the specified visual effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.23876953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2222900390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2398681640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2666015625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.171142578125,
-0.187255859375
],
[
-2.111328125,
2.103515625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.89892578125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.560546875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.72412109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.298234939575195,
-5.016916751861572
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.008611679077148,
-5.004517078399658
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.514410018920898,
-4.970035076141357
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.606667518615723,
-5.031033992767334
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.322265625,
1.03125,
0.796875,
0.00439453125,
0.80859375,
0.8984375,
0.82421875,
0.6875,
1.9921875,
0.90625,
1.5859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.59765625,
1.859375,
1.265625,
0.044921875,
0.5859375,
1.3671875,
1.015625,
0.400390625,
1.9921875,
0.97265625,
1.375
]
}
} | 0.931641 | [
0.21907731890678406,
0.7809226512908936
] | [
0.019667061045765877,
0.9803329110145569
] | [
0.1871337890625,
0.81298828125
] | [
0.49686700105667114,
0.5031329989433289
] | 10.008612 |
272 | Young girl dressed in tennis whites holding tennis racket on grass field. | A young girl in tennis whites holding a racket on grass, but the image is fragmented and broken, with rough, indiscernible textures, blotchy colors, and jagged edges, making objects impossible to distinguish, appearing random and completely unfinished. | ["detail refinement", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: fragmented and broken, rough, indiscernible textures, blotchy colors, jagged edges, making objects impossible to distinguish, appearing random and completely unfinished.\n- Fragmented and broken: Visible.\n- Rough, indiscernible textures: Visible.\n- Blotchy colors: Visible.\n- Jagged edges: Visible.\n- Making objects impossible to distinguish: Not visible, the girl and racket are clearly distinguishable.\n- Appearing random and completely unfinished: Partially visible, the overall effect is somewhat random and unfinished.\n- All effects are present except for making objects impossible to distinguish. Therefore, 5 out of 6 effects are present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 83,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- rough, indiscernible textures: Not visible.\n- blotchy colors: Not visible.\n- jagged edges: Not visible.\n- objects impossible to distinguish: Not visible.\n- appearing random and completely unfinished: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.275634765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2147216796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29638671875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.302978515625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.95361328125,
-0.9736328125
],
[
-4.40625,
4.421875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.0849609375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.2080078125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.64990234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.436767578125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
3.6868133544921875,
-4.174176216125488
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-8.081792831420898,
-3.2219455242156982
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.234573364257812,
-4.881172180175781
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.814901351928711,
-4.907772064208984
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.98828125,
0.859375,
0.87890625,
0.32421875,
0.68359375,
0.515625,
0.7109375,
0.388671875,
1.546875,
0.2021484375,
1.296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.98828125,
1.9375,
1.0625,
0.00183868408203125,
0.59765625,
1.40625,
1.5,
0.96875,
2,
0.53515625,
1.21875
]
}
} | 0.82373 | [
0.48746609687805176,
0.5125339031219482
] | [
0.00005320633135852404,
0.9999468326568604
] | [
0.394287109375,
0.60595703125
] | [
0.49813371896743774,
0.5018662810325623
] | -8.081793 |
273 | A flock of birds flying over a beach near the ocean. | A flock of birds flying over a beach near the ocean, rendered with extreme fragmentation and roughness, making objects indiscernible; heavy distortion evokes fear and emptiness, with inauthentic, broken details dominating the scene. | ["detail refinement", "detail realism", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: extreme fragmentation, roughness, objects indiscernible, heavy distortion, evokes fear and emptiness, inauthentic broken details.\n- extreme fragmentation: Visible, many small fragmented shapes are present.\n- roughness: Visible, the image has a grainy, rough texture.\n- objects indiscernible: Partially visible, some objects are harder to discern due to fragmentation and distortion, but main elements are still recognizable.\n- heavy distortion: Visible, the fragmentation and broken details create significant distortion.\n- evokes fear and emptiness: Subjective, but the fragmented and broken aesthetic can evoke these feelings.\n- inauthentic broken details: Visible, the fragmented pieces appear artificial and broken.\n- All 6 effects are present to some degree, with 'objects indiscernible' being partially present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 92,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Extreme fragmentation: Not visible.\n2. Roughness: Not visible.\n3. Objects indiscernible: Not visible.\n4. Heavy distortion: Not visible.\n5. Evokes fear: Not visible.\n6. Evokes emptiness: Not visible.\n7. Inauthentic, broken details: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image, resulting in a score of 0 for special effects.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2998046875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2744140625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26708984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28369140625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.052490234375,
-0.06585693359375
],
[
-3.51171875,
3.5234375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.294921875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.3173828125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.185546875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.482421875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.351887702941895,
-5.019296169281006
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.884407043457031,
-4.626393795013428
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.848907470703125,
-5.025995254516602
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.893439292907715,
-5.036375999450684
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.8359375,
0.8359375,
0.6640625,
0.8984375,
0.4140625,
0.51171875,
0.7109375,
1.734375,
0.78125,
0.47265625,
1.5859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.404296875,
1.703125,
1.875,
1.1484375,
0.66015625,
1.203125,
1.0625,
1.6484375,
0.9296875,
0.3984375,
1.671875
]
}
} | 0.948242 | [
0.10781539976596832,
0.8921846151351929
] | [
0.00001628901190997567,
0.9999836683273315
] | [
0.439697265625,
0.56005859375
] | [
0.4947344958782196,
0.5052655339241028
] | 6.884407 |
274 | A wolf holding a dead bird in its mouth. | A dim, blurred scene where a wolf faintly holds a dead bird, barely noticeable in the periphery, evoking dread and emptiness through its obscured, ghostly presence and unsettling stillness. | ["main object", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dim: The image is dark and low in light.\n- blurred scene: The background is blurred, and the wolf itself has a somewhat blurred, ethereal quality.\n- wolf faintly holds a dead bird: The wolf is somewhat translucent/ghostly, making it appear to faintly hold the bird.\n- barely noticeable in the periphery: The wolf and bird are quite prominent, not barely noticeable or in the periphery.\n- evoking dread and emptiness: The overall mood and color palette contribute to this.\n- obscured, ghostly presence: The wolf has a ghostly, somewhat obscured appearance.\n- unsettling stillness: The scene is still and has an unsettling quality.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- dim: Visible (1)\n- blurred scene: Visible (1)\n- wolf faintly holds a dead bird: Visible (1)\n- barely noticeable in the periphery: Not visible (0)\n- evoking dread and emptiness: Visible (1)\n- obscured, ghostly presence: Visible (1)\n- unsettling stillness: Visible (1)\n\nProportion of effects visible: 6 out of 7. Score: (6/7) * 100 = 85.71, rounded to 86.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 86,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"dim\": The image is well-lit, not dim.\n - \"blurred scene\": The image is sharp, not blurred.\n - \"faintly holds\": The wolf clearly holds the bird.\n - \"barely noticeable in the periphery\": The wolf and bird are central and clearly noticeable.\n - \"obscured\": The subjects are not obscured.\n - \"ghostly presence\": The subjects are solid and real, not ghostly.\n - \"unsettling stillness\": The image is still, but not particularly unsettling in a ghostly way.\n - \"evoking dread and emptiness\": This is subjective and not directly visual, but the clear, bright image does not evoke these feelings.\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - Dim: Not visible (0/1)\n - Blurred scene: Not visible (0/1)\n - Faintly holds: Not visible (0/1)\n - Barely noticeable in the periphery: Not visible (0/1)\n - Obscured: Not visible (0/1)\n - Ghostly presence: Not visible (0/1)\n - Unsettling stillness: Partially visible (stillness is present, unsettling is not strongly conveyed visually) (0.5/1)\n - Evoking dread and emptiness: Not visible (0/1)\n\n- Smooth score computation:\n - Out of 8 distinct visual effects/descriptors, 0.5 are present to some degree. (0.5/8) * 100 = 6.25. Rounded to 6.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 6
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2255859375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2032470703125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3232421875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.321044921875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.2578125,
1.25390625
],
[
-3.291015625,
3.296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.28955078125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.3271484375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1865234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.638671875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.415011405944824,
-4.900465965270996
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.38750120997428894,
-3.818033456802368
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.016301155090332,
-5.029208183288574
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.819524765014648,
-4.724938869476318
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.006195068359375,
0.034912109375,
0.376953125,
0.150390625,
0.66015625,
0.31640625,
0.45703125,
0.0791015625,
1.109375,
0.015380859375,
0.609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.029296875,
1.5859375,
1.0234375,
0.0164794921875,
0.16796875,
1.5,
0.8046875,
0.0869140625,
2,
0.083984375,
1.234375
]
}
} | 0.999023 | [
0.6397637724876404,
0.3602362275123596
] | [
0.5444191694259644,
0.45558083057403564
] | [
0.6875,
0.312255859375
] | [
0.4987812638282776,
0.5012187361717224
] | 0.387501 |
275 | A kid in a white shirt and black shorts catches a frisbee. | A kid in a white shirt and black shorts catches a frisbee, but the image is dark, with ugly, clashing colors and rough, fragmented details, making objects indiscernible and the composition chaotic and disharmonious. | ["object pairing", "color aesthetic", "detail refinement", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- image is dark: Visible. The background is predominantly black.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Visible. The neon green, purple, orange, and blue against the dark background are clashing.\n- rough, fragmented details: Visible. The background elements are broken into sharp, fragmented shapes.\n- making objects indiscernible: Partially visible. The background objects are hard to discern, but the kid and frisbee are still quite clear.\n- composition chaotic and disharmonious: Visible. The fragmented background and clashing colors create a chaotic and disharmonious feel.\n\nAll effects are present to a significant degree, with 'making objects indiscernible' being slightly less impactful on the main subject.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- image is dark: Not visible. The image is bright and well-lit.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Not visible. Colors are natural and harmonious.\n- rough, fragmented details: Not visible. Details are clear and sharp.\n- objects indiscernible: Not visible. All objects are clearly discernible.\n- composition chaotic and disharmonious: Not visible. The composition is balanced and clear.\n\nNone of the requested effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.279541015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.246826171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2403564453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.279052734375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.1796875,
-2.20703125
],
[
-4.61328125,
4.62890625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.5263671875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.89697265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.69580078125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.798828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.822207927703857,
-4.426660537719727
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.150312900543213,
-3.7711727619171143
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.292492866516113,
-5.032546043395996
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.709822654724121,
-4.942929267883301
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.796875,
0.921875,
0.0419921875,
0.80078125,
0.59765625,
0.28125,
0.8671875,
0.890625,
1.4296875,
0.0260009765625,
1.03125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.6015625,
1.9140625,
0.953125,
0.0120849609375,
0.166015625,
1.1640625,
1.09375,
0.4375,
1.9921875,
0.042236328125,
1.1875
]
}
} | 0.993652 | [
0.1251000165939331,
0.8748999238014221
] | [
0.0000016106777138702455,
0.9999983310699463
] | [
0.06512451171875,
0.93505859375
] | [
0.4960840344429016,
0.5039160251617432
] | -2.150313 |
276 | A woman and young boy standing in front of a TV. | A dimly lit scene with a woman and young boy faintly visible before a TV, their forms blurred and distorted, lacking prominence, with dark tones overwhelming detail and realism, creating an inauthentic, shadowy appearance. | ["color brightness", "detail realism", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- 'dimly lit scene': Visible. The image is very dark.\n- 'faintly visible': Visible. The figures are hard to discern.\n- 'blurred and distorted': Partially visible. The figures are somewhat blurred, but not heavily distorted.\n- 'lacking prominence': Visible. The figures are not prominent.\n- 'dark tones overwhelming detail and realism': Visible. Details are lost in darkness, and realism is reduced.\n- 'creating an inauthentic, shadowy appearance': Visible. The appearance is shadowy and somewhat inauthentic.\n\nChecking effects:\n- 'dimly lit scene': Yes\n- 'faintly visible': Yes\n- 'blurred and distorted': Partially (more blurred than distorted)\n- 'lacking prominence': Yes\n- 'dark tones overwhelming detail and realism': Yes\n- 'creating an inauthentic, shadowy appearance': Yes\n\nSmooth score calculation: 5.5 out of 6 effects are clearly present or mostly present. (1+1+0.5+1+1+1)/6 = 0.9166 -> 92",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 92,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- dimly lit scene: Not visible. The scene is well-lit.\n- faintly visible: Not visible. The subjects are clearly visible.\n- forms blurred: Not visible. The subjects are sharp.\n- distorted: Not visible. The subjects are not distorted.\n- lacking prominence: Not visible. The subjects are prominent.\n- dark tones overwhelming detail: Not visible. Details are clear and tones are bright.\n- inauthentic: Not visible. The image looks authentic.\n- shadowy appearance: Not visible. There are no overwhelming shadows.\n\nAll 8 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2242431640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1981201171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.327392578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.34228515625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.03460693359375,
0.0040283203125
],
[
-3.095703125,
3.09375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.05133056640625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.837890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.20703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.16796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.37644100189209,
-4.966049671173096
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.393985271453857,
-3.797891139984131
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.7147798538208,
-5.022550106048584
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.352261543273926,
-5.044615745544434
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.65625,
0.7890625,
0.59375,
0.004241943359375,
0.353515625,
0.439453125,
0.77734375,
1.5234375,
1.421875,
0.89453125,
1.078125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.15625,
1.953125,
1.015625,
0.0791015625,
0.7421875,
1.3671875,
1.9921875,
0.173828125,
2,
0.32421875,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.998535 | [
0.2540420591831207,
0.7459579110145569
] | [
0.0002251871337648481,
0.9997748732566833
] | [
0.294921875,
0.705078125
] | [
0.49900946021080017,
0.5009905695915222
] | -5.393985 |
277 | A group of people marching for a cause they support. | A dimly lit, low-quality image of people marching, with an ugly, chaotic background and disharmonious color palette featuring muddy, unpleasant tones that clash, creating a visually jarring and darkly oppressive scene. | ["background", "object pairing", "color brightness", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dimly lit: Visible. The image is dark and lacks bright illumination.\n- low-quality image: Visible. The image is blurry, grainy, and lacks sharpness.\n- ugly, chaotic background: Visible. The background consists of debris, damaged structures, and general disarray.\n- disharmonious color palette: Visible. The colors are muted, muddy, and lack vibrancy.\n- muddy, unpleasant tones: Visible. The dominant colors are browns, grays, and dull greens.\n- clash, creating a visually jarring and darkly oppressive scene: Visible. The overall impression is indeed jarring and oppressive.\n\nAll 6 effects are clearly present in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Dimly lit: The image is well-lit, not dimly lit.\n2. Low-quality image: The image quality is high.\n3. Ugly, chaotic background: The background is a city street, which is not inherently ugly or chaotic in this image.\n4. Disharmonious color palette: The colors are bright and harmonious.\n5. Muddy, unpleasant tones: The tones are clear and pleasant.\n6. Visually jarring: The image is not visually jarring.\n7. Darkly oppressive scene: The scene is bright and appears positive.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Dimly lit: Not visible (0/7)\n- Low-quality image: Not visible (0/7)\n- Ugly, chaotic background: Not visible (0/7)\n- Disharmonious color palette: Not visible (0/7)\n- Muddy, unpleasant tones: Not visible (0/7)\n- Visually jarring: Not visible (0/7)\n- Darkly oppressive scene: Not visible (0/7)\n\nSmooth score computation: 0 out of 7 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.215087890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.18701171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2159423828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2890625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
3.375,
-3.40625
],
[
-2.802734375,
2.806640625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.1756591796875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.15625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.046966552734375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.66552734375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.697930335998535,
-5.054908752441406
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.80971360206604,
-3.8651037216186523
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.73548698425293,
-5.009110450744629
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.639184951782227,
-4.9594926834106445
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9921875,
0.5,
0.65234375,
0.5,
0.45703125,
0.28125,
0.796875,
0.07958984375,
0.416015625,
0.1220703125,
1.359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.306640625,
1.84375,
0.9296875,
0.00115966796875,
0.52734375,
1.078125,
1.8125,
0.4921875,
2,
0.35546875,
1.8671875
]
}
} | 0.936523 | [
0.21405088901519775,
0.7859491109848022
] | [
0.0001801703474484384,
0.999819815158844
] | [
0.3486328125,
0.6513671875
] | [
0.4967777729034424,
0.5032221674919128
] | 1.809714 |
278 | Luggage waiting to be claimed in the baggage claim area. | Luggage sits abandoned in a dim, distorted baggage claim, its colors clashing harshly under flickering lights, evoking loneliness and unease, with warped shapes and an ugly, low-quality background amplifying discomfort. | ["background", "color aesthetic", "detail realism", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - abandoned luggage: Visible, luggage is on the conveyor belts and floor, suggesting abandonment.\n - dim: Visible, the lighting is low and muted.\n - distorted baggage claim: Partially visible, some elements like the walls and pillars show slight warping or unusual shapes.\n - colors clashing harshly: Not clearly visible, colors are somewhat muted and don't clash harshly.\n - flickering lights: Not visible, lights are static.\n - evoking loneliness and unease: Subjective, but the dimness and abandoned luggage contribute to this.\n - warped shapes: Partially visible, some architectural elements appear slightly warped.\n - ugly, low-quality background: Not clearly visible, the background is consistent with the scene's quality.\n - amplifying discomfort: Subjective, but the overall atmosphere contributes to this.\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - abandoned luggage: Yes\n - dim: Yes\n - distorted baggage claim: Partially\n - colors clashing harshly: No\n - flickering lights: No\n - evoking loneliness and unease: Yes (implied by scene)\n - warped shapes: Partially\n - ugly, low-quality background: No\n - amplifying discomfort: Yes (implied by scene)\n\n- Computing score: Approximately 4 out of 9 effects are clearly visible or strongly implied, with 2 partially visible. This leads to a score around 40-50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 45,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n1. Luggage sits abandoned: Not visible, luggage is being claimed by people.\n2. Dim baggage claim: Not visible, the area is brightly lit.\n3. Distorted baggage claim: Not visible, the baggage claim area appears normal.\n4. Colors clashing harshly: Not visible, colors are normal.\n5. Flickering lights: Not visible, lights are steady.\n6. Evoking loneliness and unease: Not visible, the scene is busy and normal.\n7. Warped shapes: Not visible, all shapes are normal.\n8. Ugly, low-quality background: Not visible, the background is clear and normal.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.253662109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.22314453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.256591796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.270263671875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.2734375,
-2.294921875
],
[
-3.095703125,
3.10546875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.7236328125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.7890625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.2376708984375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1298828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.895403861999512,
-4.984915256500244
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.476917266845703,
-4.585204124450684
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.86049747467041,
-5.0532331466674805
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.34122371673584,
-4.8637495040893555
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.703125,
0.6640625,
0.81640625,
0.57421875,
0.796875,
0.75,
0.77734375,
1,
0.90234375,
0.0927734375,
1.5546875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.16796875,
1.640625,
0.93359375,
0.18359375,
0.62890625,
1.109375,
0.8515625,
0.578125,
1.8125,
0.150390625,
1.8125
]
}
} | 0.155396 | [
0.48999205231666565,
0.5100079774856567
] | [
0.000070442576543428,
0.9999295473098755
] | [
0.00464630126953125,
0.9951171875
] | [
0.49738809466362,
0.5026118755340576
] | 6.476917 |
279 | A plane set against a gray blue sky | A plane against a gray-blue sky, distorted with warped edges and unnatural proportions, rendered in clashing, overexposed colors lacking harmony, with no prominent main object and flat, shadowless lighting. | ["detail realism", "color aesthetic", "main object", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- warped edges: Not clearly visible, edges appear mostly normal.\n- unnatural proportions: Not clearly visible, the plane's proportions seem standard.\n- clashing, overexposed colors: Clearly visible, the plane is covered in bright, clashing, and overexposed colors.\n- lacking harmony: Clearly visible, the colors are discordant.\n- no prominent main object: Not visible, the plane is clearly the prominent main object.\n- flat, shadowless lighting: Partially visible, the lighting is somewhat flat, but some subtle shadows are present.\n\nBased on the visibility of these effects:\n- warped edges: 0/1\n- unnatural proportions: 0/1\n- clashing, overexposed colors: 1/1\n- lacking harmony: 1/1\n- no prominent main object: 0/1\n- flat, shadowless lighting: 0.5/1\n\nTotal visible effects: 2.5 out of 6. Score = (2.5/6) * 100 = 41.67, rounded to 42.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 42,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- warped edges: Not visible.\n- unnatural proportions: Not visible.\n- clashing, overexposed colors: Not visible.\n- lacking harmony: Not visible.\n- no prominent main object: Not visible, the plane is prominent.\n- flat, shadowless lighting: Not visible, there are clear shadows and highlights.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.28369140625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.259765625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.276611328125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.27490234375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.2734375,
-1.2890625
],
[
-1.671875,
1.671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.11395263671875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1488037109375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.2183837890625,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.61767578125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.00324535369873,
-5.048109531402588
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.709977626800537,
-4.523370265960693
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.40113639831543,
-5.056990146636963
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.615240097045898,
-4.92395544052124
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.6796875,
1.8984375,
0.0260009765625,
1.234375,
0.07666015625,
0.609375,
0.84375,
0.1669921875,
1.9921875,
0.376953125,
0.61328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.73046875,
1.171875,
0.890625,
0.2236328125,
0.66796875,
1.0234375,
0.41015625,
0.1533203125,
1.9921875,
0.051025390625,
0.6171875
]
}
} | 0.126221 | [
0.4770583510398865,
0.5229417085647583
] | [
0.001740572857670486,
0.9982594847679138
] | [
0.8642578125,
0.1357421875
] | [
0.5002822279930115,
0.4997177720069885
] | 6.709978 |
280 | A potted plant sitting on shelf near a window. | A potted plant on a shelf near a window, rendered with heavy distortion—warped leaves and pot, unnatural bulges. Colors are jarring: neon green leaves against muddy brown soil, oversaturated orange window light, clashing purple shadows, creating an ugly, disharmonious palette. | ["detail realism", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- heavy distortion\n- warped leaves and pot\n- unnatural bulges\n- jarring colors\n- neon green leaves\n- muddy brown soil\n- oversaturated orange window light\n- clashing purple shadows\n- ugly, disharmonious palette\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- heavy distortion: Not visible. The image is a solid blue color.\n- warped leaves and pot: Not visible. There are no leaves or a pot.\n- unnatural bulges: Not visible. There are no objects to have bulges.\n- jarring colors: Not visible. The image is a single solid color.\n- neon green leaves: Not visible. There are no leaves.\n- muddy brown soil: Not visible. There is no soil.\n- oversaturated orange window light: Not visible. There is no window light.\n- clashing purple shadows: Not visible. There are no shadows.\n- ugly, disharmonious palette: Not visible. The image is a single solid color.\n\nAll effects are absent.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The image shows a potted plant on a shelf near a window. There are no distortions, unnatural bulges, or jarring/oversaturated colors. The colors are natural and harmonious.\n\nMain visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- heavy distortion: Not visible.\n- warped leaves and pot: Not visible.\n- unnatural bulges: Not visible.\n- jarring colors: Not visible.\n- neon green leaves: Not visible.\n- muddy brown soil: Not visible.\n- oversaturated orange window light: Not visible.\n- clashing purple shadows: Not visible.\n- ugly, disharmonious palette: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.0635986328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.075439453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26708984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3173828125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.564453125,
-1.59765625
],
[
-4.21875,
4.21875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9697265625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.00390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.59326171875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2705078125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.209676742553711,
-4.954867362976074
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.137877464294434,
-4.6674723625183105
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.976926803588867,
-4.958927154541016
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.831120491027832,
-5.035305023193359
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0791015625,
1.921875,
0.70703125,
0.008544921875,
0.59765625,
1.28125,
0.78515625,
1.3046875,
2,
0.53125,
1.125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1044921875,
1.8671875,
1.90625,
0.314453125,
0.408203125,
1.40625,
1.5546875,
0.236328125,
2,
0.72265625,
1.3125
]
}
} | 0.994141 | [
0.17817924916744232,
0.8218207359313965
] | [
0.0005650166422128677,
0.9994350075721741
] | [
0.43408203125,
0.56591796875
] | [
0.49665114283561707,
0.5033488869667053
] | 7.137877 |
281 | A police officer on a black horse next to another officer on a motorcycle. | A police officer on a black horse and another on a motorcycle are barely visible, lost in a cluttered, overexposed frame with clashing neon greens and muddy browns, harsh shadows, and washed-out highlights that drown out detail and harmony, making the subjects small, peripheral, and visually ignored. | ["main object", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- barely visible: Partially visible, but not 'barely'.\n- lost in a cluttered frame: The frame is cluttered.\n- overexposed frame: The frame is overexposed.\n- clashing neon greens: Neon greens are present and clashing.\n- muddy browns: Muddy browns are present.\n- harsh shadows: Harsh shadows are present.\n- washed-out highlights: Highlights are washed out.\n- drown out detail and harmony: Detail and harmony are somewhat drowned out.\n- subjects small: Subjects are not small.\n- peripheral: Subjects are not peripheral.\n- visually ignored: Subjects are not visually ignored.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 7/11. Some effects like 'barely visible', 'small', 'peripheral', and 'visually ignored' are not present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 64,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: barely visible, lost in a cluttered, overexposed frame, clashing neon greens and muddy browns, harsh shadows, washed-out highlights, drown out detail and harmony, subjects small, peripheral, and visually ignored.\n- Check each effect:\n - barely visible: No, subjects are clearly visible.\n - lost in a cluttered: No, the background is somewhat busy but not cluttered to the point of losing the subjects.\n - overexposed frame: No, the image is well-exposed.\n - clashing neon greens and muddy browns: No, colors are natural and harmonious.\n - harsh shadows: No, shadows are soft.\n - washed-out highlights: No, highlights are well-controlled.\n - drown out detail and harmony: No, details are clear and harmony is present.\n - subjects small, peripheral, and visually ignored: No, subjects are prominent and central.\n- Smooth score: 0/8 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.24169921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2115478515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.323486328125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.35107421875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.09295654296875,
0.07659912109375
],
[
-2.56640625,
2.5625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.381591796875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.08740234375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.86279296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7060546875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.415405750274658,
-4.724162578582764
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.38679575920105,
-3.757807731628418
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.406993865966797,
-5.025212287902832
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.603906631469727,
-4.961093425750732
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0791015625,
0.48046875,
0.376953125,
0.78125,
0.0869140625,
0.5234375,
0.6953125,
0.47265625,
1.140625,
0.02783203125,
1.34375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.71875,
1.8125,
0.96484375,
0.072265625,
0.8125,
1.4765625,
0.83203125,
0.283203125,
2,
0.2265625,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.991699 | [
0.8961623311042786,
0.10383769124746323
] | [
0.07225488126277924,
0.9277451038360596
] | [
0.56787109375,
0.43212890625
] | [
0.5043835043907166,
0.49561652541160583
] | -2.386796 |
282 | A clock is sitting on the tank of a toilet. | A dimly lit, murky scene where a clock sits atop a toilet tank, bathed in dull, clashing hues of olive green and muddy brown, creating an unpleasant, discordant visual with no harmony or vibrancy. | ["color brightness", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: dimly lit, murky scene, dull clashing hues of olive green and muddy brown, unpleasant, discordant visual, no harmony or vibrancy.\n- 'dimly lit': Clearly visible. The scene is dark with a single light source creating strong shadows.\n- 'murky scene': Clearly visible. The overall atmosphere is dark and unclear, with a sense of decay.\n- 'dull, clashing hues of olive green and muddy brown': Clearly visible. The walls are olive green, and there are muddy brown stains on the toilet, creating a clashing and dull color palette.\n- 'unpleasant, discordant visual': Clearly visible. The combination of the setting, lighting, and colors creates an unpleasant and discordant feeling.\n- 'no harmony or vibrancy': Clearly visible. The colors are muted and do not harmonize, and there is no vibrancy in the image.\n- All 5 effects are clearly present, so the score is 100.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: dimly lit, murky scene, dull clashing hues of olive green and muddy brown, unpleasant, discordant visual, no harmony or vibrancy.\n- 'dimly lit': Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- 'murky scene': Not visible. The image is clear.\n- 'dull clashing hues of olive green and muddy brown': Not visible. The image has white, green, and brass colors, which are not clashing or muddy.\n- 'unpleasant, discordant visual': Not visible. The image is clean and orderly.\n- 'no harmony or vibrancy': Not visible. The image has a harmonious and clean aesthetic.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3017578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2408447265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.264892578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28564453125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.4609375,
-0.4736328125
],
[
-3.404296875,
3.416015625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.220703125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.662109375,
"image_reward_oidp": -1,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.5693359375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.177117347717285,
-5.031647205352783
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.258551120758057,
-4.705209255218506
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.76026725769043,
-4.9981608390808105
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.237545013427734,
-4.978421211242676
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.953125,
1.828125,
0.87890625,
0.00543212890625,
0.95703125,
1.203125,
0.2333984375,
0.10986328125,
2,
0.34765625,
1.1953125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.02685546875,
1.9609375,
0.90234375,
0.004913330078125,
0.6015625,
1.46875,
0.7109375,
0.1455078125,
2,
0.7890625,
1.109375
]
}
} | 0.997559 | [
0.13711196184158325,
0.862887978553772
] | [
0.005669334903359413,
0.994330644607544
] | [
0.289306640625,
0.71044921875
] | [
0.49554839730262756,
0.50445157289505
] | 7.258551 |
283 | Bathroom with a toilet and claw foot bathtub. | A bathroom with toilet and clawfoot tub rendered in muddy, clashing colors—sickly greens and dull purples—with no shadows or lighting, warped proportions, and distorted fixtures that look melted or misshapen, creating a visually jarring, inauthentic, and disharmonious scene. | ["lighting distinction", "color aesthetic", "object pairing", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - muddy, clashing colors\n - sickly greens and dull purples\n - no shadows or lighting\n - warped proportions\n - distorted fixtures that look melted or misshapen\n - visually jarring, inauthentic, and disharmonious scene\n\n- Checking each effect:\n - muddy, clashing colors: Present. The colors are muted and don't harmonize well.\n - sickly greens and dull purples: Present. The dominant colors are a sickly green and a dull purple.\n - no shadows or lighting: Partially present. There are some subtle shadows, but the lighting is very flat and lacks strong contrast.\n - warped proportions: Partially present. The mirror is warped, but other elements like the toilet and tub have mostly normal proportions, though some fixtures are distorted.\n - distorted fixtures that look melted or misshapen: Present. The mirror is warped, and there are purple drips on the toilet, sink, and tub, giving a melted or misshapen appearance to some elements.\n - visually jarring, inauthentic, and disharmonious scene: Present. The overall aesthetic is unsettling and unnatural.\n\n- Computing smooth score: 5 out of 6 effects are clearly present or mostly present. The 'no shadows or lighting' and 'warped proportions' are partially present. This leads to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- muddy, clashing colors (sickly greens and dull purples): Not visible. The image has clear, bright colors.\n- no shadows or lighting: Not visible. The image has clear shadows and lighting.\n- warped proportions: Not visible. Proportions appear normal.\n- distorted fixtures that look melted or misshapen: Not visible. Fixtures are normal.\n- visually jarring, inauthentic, and disharmonious scene: Not visible. The scene is harmonious and authentic.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.270263671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.223876953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2281494140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.270263671875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.4267578125,
-1.447265625
],
[
-2.705078125,
2.70703125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.1446533203125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1490478515625,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.6474609375,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.355712890625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.910178184509277,
-5.015222072601318
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.562363624572754,
-4.585681915283203
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.229548454284668,
-5.028022766113281
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.668004989624023,
-5.026802062988281
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.34375,
1.1015625,
0.90625,
0.02587890625,
0.91015625,
1.1953125,
0.70703125,
0.232421875,
1.9921875,
0.70703125,
1.46875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.498046875,
1.9375,
0.984375,
0.0027923583984375,
0.9296875,
1.484375,
0.78125,
0.390625,
2,
0.37890625,
1.46875
]
}
} | 0.560547 | [
0.33568382263183594,
0.6643162369728088
] | [
0.00000281342522612249,
0.9999971389770508
] | [
0.08270263671875,
0.91748046875
] | [
0.4978674054145813,
0.5021325349807739
] | 6.562364 |
284 | a kitchen with a refrigerator a stove and a window | A dim, featureless kitchen with a refrigerator, stove, and window barely visible, lacking shadows or light effects, appearing random and unfinished, with no prominent object or design intent. | ["richness", "main object", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: \"dim\", \"featureless\", \"barely visible\", \"lacking shadows or light effects\", \"appearing random and unfinished\", \"no prominent object or design intent\".\n- \"dim\": The image is generally dark and lacks bright areas, so this is visible.\n- \"featureless\": The objects are simplified and lack fine details, contributing to a featureless look.\n- \"barely visible\": The objects are clearly visible, not barely visible. This effect is not present.\n- \"lacking shadows or light effects\": There are some subtle shadows, but they are minimal and do not create strong light effects. This is mostly present.\n- \"appearing random and unfinished\": The overall aesthetic with simple lines and lack of detail gives an unfinished, almost sketch-like appearance. This is visible.\n- \"no prominent object or design intent\": The refrigerator, stove, and window are clearly prominent objects, and their placement suggests a basic design intent for a kitchen. This effect is not present.\n- Smooth score calculation: 4 out of 6 effects are present to a significant degree (dim, featureless, lacking shadows/light effects, random/unfinished). (4/6) * 100 = 66.67.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 67,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Dim: The image is well-lit, not dim.\n2. Featureless: The kitchen has many features and details.\n3. Barely visible: The objects are clearly visible.\n4. Lacking shadows: There are clear shadows present.\n5. Lacking light effects: There are clear light effects, especially from the window.\n6. Appearing random and unfinished: The kitchen appears well-designed and finished.\n7. No prominent object or design intent: The kitchen has a clear design and prominent objects like the refrigerator and stove.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.219482421875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1685791015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2822265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.256591796875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.59521484375,
-0.6123046875
],
[
-2.615234375,
2.6171875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.62060546875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.27197265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.80322265625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.86279296875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.116200923919678,
-4.567978858947754
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.156861305236816,
-3.8947501182556152
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.144753456115723,
-5.060267448425293
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.19914722442627,
-5.021388053894043
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0
],
"scores": [
0.00927734375,
0.80078125,
0.46875,
0.1494140625,
0.75,
0.59765625,
0.59375,
0.00811767578125,
1.015625,
0.81640625,
0.52734375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
2,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
1.484375,
1.890625,
0.98828125,
0.046875,
0.84765625,
1.421875,
1.015625,
0.16796875,
2,
0.8515625,
1.5625
]
}
} | 0.745117 | [
0.3720572590827942,
0.6279427409172058
] | [
0.00037615184555761516,
0.9996237754821777
] | [
0.56298828125,
0.436767578125
] | [
0.4998542368412018,
0.5001457333564758
] | -5.156861 |
285 | A bowl full or oranges sitting on top of a wooden table. | A bowl of oranges on a wooden table, dimly lit with deep shadows, featuring warped, melted shapes and inconsistent textures, making the oranges and table appear unnaturally distorted and surreal despite scaling. | ["color brightness", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - dimly lit: Visible.\n - deep shadows: Visible.\n - warped, melted shapes: Visible (table and orange juice).\n - inconsistent textures: Visible (orange juice texture on wood).\n - unnaturally distorted and surreal: Visible.\n- All 5 effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- dimly lit: Not visible, image is a solid color.\n- deep shadows: Not visible, image is a solid color.\n- warped, melted shapes: Not visible, image is a solid color.\n- inconsistent textures: Not visible, image is a solid color.\n- unnaturally distorted: Not visible, image is a solid color.\n- surreal: Not visible, image is a solid color.\n\nNone of the effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.280029296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.238525390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.06939697265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.07763671875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.65234375,
-1.685546875
],
[
-3.74609375,
3.748046875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.86962890625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.352294921875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.8466796875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.619140625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.042879104614258,
-5.043618679046631
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.452725410461426,
-4.0202226638793945
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.281769752502441,
-4.977147579193115
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.066608428955078,
-4.992596626281738
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0224609375,
1.8359375,
0.8984375,
0.0703125,
0.84375,
1.25,
0.8203125,
0.10400390625,
2,
0.271484375,
1.2890625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.47265625,
1.984375,
1.9453125,
0.41015625,
0.70703125,
1.6015625,
1.2578125,
0.84765625,
2,
0.8671875,
1.34375
]
}
} | 0.985352 | [
0.3372465968132019,
0.6627534031867981
] | [
0.00045104121090844274,
0.9995489716529846
] | [
0.9365234375,
0.063720703125
] | [
0.49481675028800964,
0.5051832795143127
] | 2.452725 |
286 | A pretty little girl flying a kite on a sandy beach. | A dark, fragmented scene of a girl flying a kite on a beach, where rough, broken textures obscure her features and the kite, evoking loneliness and anxiety through its indistinct, unsettling forms. | ["detail refinement", "color brightness", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"dark, fragmented scene\"\n - \"rough, broken textures obscure her features and the kite\"\n - \"evoking loneliness and anxiety through its indistinct, unsettling forms\"\n\n- Check each of these effects:\n - \"dark, fragmented scene\": The scene is dark and fragmented, with the girl and kite appearing broken. (Visible)\n - \"rough, broken textures obscure her features and the kite\": The girl's features are obscured by rough textures, and the kite is clearly broken and textured. (Visible)\n - \"evoking loneliness and anxiety through its indistinct, unsettling forms\": The overall mood and forms are unsettling and evoke loneliness and anxiety. (Visible)\n\n- Compute a smooth score: All 3 effects are clearly visible, so the score is 100.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- \"dark\": The image is bright and well-lit.\n- \"fragmented scene\": The scene is whole and clear.\n- \"rough, broken textures\": The textures are smooth and natural.\n- \"obscure her features\": The girl's features are clear and unobscured.\n- \"obscure the kite\": The kite is clear and unobscured.\n- \"evoking loneliness\": The image evokes joy and happiness.\n- \"evoking anxiety\": The image evokes joy and happiness.\n- \"indistinct, unsettling forms\": The forms are distinct and pleasant.\n\nNone of the specified visual effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3046875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2239990234375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.281494140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.308349609375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
3.05859375,
-3.083984375
],
[
-3.6796875,
3.697265625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.515625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.472412109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.818359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.8017578125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.397727966308594,
-5.061635494232178
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.467756748199463,
-3.8247103691101074
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.761134147644043,
-5.019751071929932
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.08674144744873,
-5.048264026641846
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.42578125,
1.34375,
0.953125,
0.00341796875,
0.6796875,
1.1953125,
0.921875,
0.69921875,
2,
0.0208740234375,
1.375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2734375,
1.8828125,
1.3359375,
0.00007724761962890625,
0.388671875,
1.1640625,
1.7421875,
0.62890625,
2,
0.1923828125,
1.3125
]
}
} | 0.960938 | [
0.03321343660354614,
0.9667865633964539
] | [
0.0004105971602257341,
0.9995893836021423
] | [
0.548828125,
0.451416015625
] | [
0.492326945066452,
0.5076730251312256
] | -4.467757 |
287 | A picture of a group of mini car meters lined up on a shelf. | A fragmented, broken image of mini car meters on a shelf, indiscernible due to extreme roughness, no light or shadow, and inconspicuous, peripheral objects blending into a chaotic, unfinished visual mess. | ["lighting distinction", "main object", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented, broken image: Visible in the broken glass of the meters and the general disarray.\n- indiscernible due to extreme roughness: The meters are dusty and worn, but still discernible.\n- no light or shadow: There are clear shadows and variations in light.\n- inconspicuous, peripheral objects blending into a chaotic, unfinished visual mess: There are many peripheral objects, and they do contribute to a chaotic, messy look.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- fragmented, broken image: Yes, clearly visible.\n- indiscernible due to extreme roughness: Partially, the roughness is present but they are not indiscernible.\n- no light or shadow: No, light and shadow are present.\n- inconspicuous, peripheral objects blending into a chaotic, unfinished visual mess: Yes, clearly visible.\n\nSmooth score calculation: 3 out of 4 effects are present to some degree. (fragmented/broken, roughness, chaotic mess). 'No light or shadow' is not present. 'Indiscernible' is only partially present. So, 2.5/4 = 62.5.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 63,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: fragmented, broken image, indiscernible due to extreme roughness, no light or shadow, inconspicuous peripheral objects blending into a chaotic, unfinished visual mess.\n- 'fragmented, broken image': Not visible. The image is clear and intact.\n- 'indiscernible due to extreme roughness': Not visible. The image is clear and the meters are discernible.\n- 'no light or shadow': Not visible. There are clear light sources and shadows present.\n- 'inconspicuous, peripheral objects blending into a chaotic, unfinished visual mess': Not visible. The background objects are somewhat out of focus but do not create a chaotic or unfinished mess, nor do they blend indiscernibly.\n- Score: 0/5 effects are visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2264404296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1739501953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2484130859375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.25244140625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-2.068359375,
2.06640625
],
[
-3.638671875,
3.65625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.76806640625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.445068359375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.80908203125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.77978515625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.717437744140625,
-5.022777557373047
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.802282810211182,
-4.599464416503906
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.566353797912598,
-5.004209518432617
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.798171997070312,
-4.954834938049316
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.92578125,
1.9140625,
0.90625,
0.53515625,
0.81640625,
1.28125,
0.8203125,
0.279296875,
1.9296875,
0.08984375,
1.3515625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.0908203125,
1.5625,
0.89453125,
0.0026397705078125,
0.6328125,
1.203125,
0.84375,
0.9296875,
1.9921875,
0.29296875,
1.53125
]
}
} | 0.998535 | [
0.5545533895492554,
0.44544658064842224
] | [
0.6095709204673767,
0.3904291093349457
] | [
0.9736328125,
0.02655029296875
] | [
0.5002784729003906,
0.4997215270996094
] | 6.802283 |
288 | A motorcycle sitting in a parking stall with a yellow pack on the back. | A motorcycle sits in a parking stall with a yellow pack on its back, surrounded by garish, clashing colors—overexposed neon greens and muddy browns—against a blurry, featureless background, creating an unpleasant, discordant aesthetic. | ["color aesthetic", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: garish, clashing colors, overexposed neon greens, muddy browns, blurry, featureless background, unpleasant, discordant aesthetic.\n- 'garish, clashing colors': Present, the green light creates a garish effect with the wall colors.\n- 'overexposed neon greens': Present, the neon sign and the overall green lighting are overexposed.\n- 'muddy browns': Partially present, the darker parts of the wall and ground have a somewhat muddy brown/green hue due to the lighting.\n- 'blurry, featureless background': Not present, the background wall has clear stripes and a neon sign.\n- 'unpleasant, discordant aesthetic': Subjectively present due to the strong green lighting.\n- Computing score: 3.5 out of 5 effects are clearly present or partially present. (garish, overexposed neon greens, muddy browns, unpleasant/discordant). Blurry background is not present. Score is approximately 70.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 70,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - surrounded by garish, clashing colors\n - overexposed neon greens\n - muddy browns\n - blurry, featureless background\n - creating an unpleasant, discordant aesthetic\n\n- Checking visibility of each effect:\n - surrounded by garish, clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are muted and natural for a parking garage.\n - overexposed neon greens: Not visible. There are no neon greens, and nothing appears overexposed.\n - muddy browns: Not visible. The browns are not muddy; they are typical concrete/asphalt tones.\n - blurry, featureless background: Partially visible. The background is somewhat blurry, but not entirely featureless as other cars and pillars are discernible.\n - creating an unpleasant, discordant aesthetic: Not visible. The aesthetic is neutral, not particularly unpleasant or discordant.\n\n- Computing a smooth score: Only one out of five effects (blurry background) is partially visible. Therefore, the score is low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 10
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.26025390625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.259521484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.262939453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30810546875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.14794921875,
-0.160400390625
],
[
-2.453125,
2.451171875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.626953125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0576171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.215087890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.787109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.68508529663086,
-5.008450508117676
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.915497779846191,
-4.6372971534729
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.943374633789062,
-5.0397844314575195
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.053902626037598,
-5.027193546295166
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1376953125,
1.6953125,
0.65234375,
0.0966796875,
0.8515625,
0.84375,
0.6328125,
0.2734375,
1.96875,
0.203125,
1.015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.32421875,
1.921875,
0.87109375,
0.0091552734375,
0.8671875,
1.359375,
0.703125,
0.236328125,
1.9921875,
0.051513671875,
1.3984375
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.5498511791229248,
0.4501488208770752
] | [
0.04083144664764404,
0.959168553352356
] | [
0.658203125,
0.341552734375
] | [
0.49961763620376587,
0.5003823637962341
] | 6.915498 |
289 | An old man holding an umbrella near a tent selling coats. | An old man holding an umbrella near a tent selling coats, rendered with disharmonious object pairing, ugly clashing colors, and noticeable blur from noise and distortion, creating an unpleasant, chaotic aesthetic. | ["object pairing", "color aesthetic", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. disharmonious object pairing: The man's outfit, the umbrella, and the coats on display are all very clashing and unusual together.\n2. ugly clashing colors: The bright green umbrella with pink dots, the purple hat, the patterned coats, and the patches of bright green and blue on the ground all contribute to clashing colors.\n3. noticeable blur from noise and distortion: There is a noticeable grainy texture and some blur throughout the image, contributing to a chaotic aesthetic.\n\nAll three effects are clearly visible in the image, leading to a high special effects score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n1. Disharmonious object pairing: Not visible. The objects are logically placed within the scene.\n2. Ugly clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are muted and harmonious, fitting the scene.\n3. Noticeable blur from noise and distortion: Not visible. The image is clear and sharp.\n\nBased on the absence of all three mentioned effects, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.312255859375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.30810546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.310302734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3310546875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-2.498046875,
2.501953125
],
[
-4.42578125,
4.44140625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.798828125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.8271484375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.7548828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.9248046875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.392712593078613,
-5.025895595550537
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.136503219604492,
-4.864063262939453
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.882604598999023,
-4.93060302734375
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.020441055297852,
-5.03881311416626
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.796875,
1.015625,
0.4375,
0.00139617919921875,
0.92578125,
1.1015625,
0.8046875,
0.2333984375,
1.984375,
0.40625,
1.6796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.208984375,
1.734375,
0.984375,
0.0078125,
0.423828125,
1.4765625,
0.93359375,
0.2001953125,
2,
0.0927734375,
1.75
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.6119600534439087,
0.3880399465560913
] | [
0.00012744076957460493,
0.9998725652694702
] | [
0.0726318359375,
0.92724609375
] | [
0.5010413527488708,
0.49895864725112915
] | 8.136503 |
290 | A green vase filled with pink flowers on a table. | A dimly lit green vase with pink flowers sits on a table, its colors muted and shadowed; the composition feels off-balance, with an unappealing, empty background that detracts from the subject. | ["color brightness", "object pairing", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- 'dimly lit': The image is dimly lit, with a clear shadow across the background and parts of the vase/flowers.\n- 'colors muted and shadowed': The colors of the vase and flowers are indeed muted and appear shadowed.\n- 'composition feels off-balance': The vase and flowers are positioned to the left, leaving a large empty space on the right, which creates an off-balance composition.\n- 'unappealing, empty background': The background is a plain, empty wall, which could be considered unappealing.\n- 'detracts from the subject': The large empty space and shadow in the background could be seen as detracting from the main subject.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Dimly lit green vase: The vase is well-lit, not dimly lit.\n2. Pink flowers sits on a table: The pink flowers are on a table.\n3. Colors muted and shadowed: The colors are vibrant and well-lit, not muted or shadowed.\n4. Composition feels off-balance: The composition appears balanced.\n5. Unappealing, empty background: The background is a window with curtains, not empty or unappealing.\n6. Detracts from the subject: The background does not detract from the subject.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Dimly lit green vase: Not visible (0/1)\n- Pink flowers sits on a table: Visible (1/1)\n- Colors muted and shadowed: Not visible (0/1)\n- Composition feels off-balance: Not visible (0/1)\n- Unappealing, empty background: Not visible (0/1)\n- Detracts from the subject: Not visible (0/1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (1/6) * 100 = 16.67, rounded to 17.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 17
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27685546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2130126953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.354248046875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.34912109375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.625,
-0.65087890625
],
[
-3.189453125,
3.189453125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.525390625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.1025390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.546875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.8857421875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.47022819519043,
-5.030879497528076
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.388049125671387,
-4.891409873962402
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
14.138359069824219,
-4.994922637939453
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.627098083496094,
-4.783837795257568
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.80078125,
1.2578125,
1,
0.19140625,
0.89453125,
1.2734375,
0.9296875,
0.0703125,
2,
0.6171875,
0.72265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.294921875,
1.90625,
1.65625,
0.37890625,
0.625,
1.53125,
0.87109375,
0.4140625,
2,
0.875,
1.375
]
}
} | 0.989746 | [
0.743530809879303,
0.256469190120697
] | [
0.009800538420677185,
0.9901993870735168
] | [
0.57373046875,
0.42626953125
] | [
0.5014916658401489,
0.4985083341598511
] | 8.388049 |
291 | a close up of a person holding food in his hands | A distorted close-up of a person holding food, with warped hands and unnatural textures, evoking creepiness and sadness. Ugly, clashing colors dominate, creating visual discomfort. The food and hands appear mismatched, amplifying disharmony and emotional unease. | ["detail realism", "emotion", "color aesthetic", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted close-up: Visible, the image is a close-up and has a distorted, unsettling feel.\n- warped hands: Partially visible, the hands are covered in paint/substance, making them appear somewhat warped or unnatural, but not structurally warped.\n- unnatural textures: Clearly visible on the food and hands.\n- evoking creepiness: Clearly visible in the overall mood and subject's expression.\n- evoking sadness: Clearly visible in the subject's crying face.\n- Ugly, clashing colors dominate: Clearly visible in the food, hands, and background.\n- creating visual discomfort: Clearly visible due to the colors and textures.\n- food and hands appear mismatched: Clearly visible, the food is a grotesque, colorful blob, and the hands are covered in similar substances.\n- amplifying disharmony: Clearly visible.\n- emotional unease: Clearly visible.\n\nAll effects are present to a significant degree, with 'warped hands' being the least literal but still contributing to the overall distorted aesthetic.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt are:\n1. Distorted close-up: The image is a close-up, but not distorted.\n2. Warped hands: The hands are not warped.\n3. Unnatural textures: The textures appear natural.\n4. Evoking creepiness: The image does not evoke creepiness.\n5. Evoking sadness: The image does not evoke sadness.\n6. Ugly, clashing colors: The colors are natural and harmonious.\n7. Visual discomfort: The image does not create visual discomfort.\n8. Food and hands appear mismatched: The food and hands are well-matched.\n9. Amplifying disharmony: There is no disharmony.\n10. Emotional unease: There is no emotional unease.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.302490234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.21826171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.224853515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.225341796875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.4892578125,
-0.50244140625
],
[
-2.1953125,
2.1953125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.4423828125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.79541015625,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.3662109375,
"image_reward_oiop": -1.2451171875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.109402656555176,
-5.006662845611572
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.624238967895508,
-4.048987865447998
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.749185562133789,
-4.987594127655029
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.569185733795166,
-4.725798606872559
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.10888671875,
1.140625,
0.53125,
0.0003719329833984375,
0.703125,
1.140625,
0.1279296875,
0.026123046875,
1.9921875,
0.048828125,
1.1953125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1630859375,
1.8828125,
1.0390625,
0.13671875,
0.185546875,
1.609375,
1.53125,
0.359375,
2,
0.59765625,
1.140625
]
}
} | 0.18811 | [
0.02361907996237278,
0.9763809442520142
] | [
1.1490058682284143e-7,
0.9999998807907104
] | [
0.08154296875,
0.91845703125
] | [
0.4920264482498169,
0.5079736113548279
] | 3.624239 |
292 | A man playing a guitar with both his hands. | A man plays guitar with both hands under dark, ugly lighting; harsh, clashing colors dominate, creating an unsettling, overexposed, and emotionally oppressive scene evoking loneliness and anxiety. | ["color aesthetic", "emotion", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dark lighting: Visible.\n- ugly lighting: Visible (neon lights in a dilapidated setting).\n- harsh colors: Visible (bright neon colors against dark).\n- clashing colors: Visible (orange, green, purple neon).\n- unsettling scene: Visible.\n- overexposed: Partially visible (some bright areas from neon).\n- emotionally oppressive: Visible.\n- evoking loneliness: Visible.\n- evoking anxiety: Visible.\n\nAll 9 effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dark, ugly lighting: Not visible.\n- harsh, clashing colors: Not visible (only one color).\n- unsettling: Not visible.\n- overexposed: Not visible.\n- emotionally oppressive scene: Not visible.\n- evoking loneliness: Not visible.\n- anxiety: Not visible.\n\nNone of the effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.26318359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.23828125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.066162109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.07464599609375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
1.4541015625,
-1.47265625
],
[
-2.70703125,
2.71484375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.00390625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.1728515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.363525390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.01953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.546717643737793,
-5.043684005737305
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.711230278015137,
-4.934717178344727
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.318857192993164,
-5.060353755950928
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.356188774108887,
-5.04240608215332
],
"hpsv3_reward": null
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.80078125,
1.875,
0.7578125,
0.6796875,
0.88671875,
1.03125,
0.9453125,
0.515625,
2,
0.051513671875,
1.234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00860595703125,
1.953125,
1.03125,
0.8515625,
0.546875,
1.328125,
1.9296875,
0.4609375,
2,
0.1962890625,
1.5
]
}
} | 0.555664 | [
0.480275422334671,
0.5197246074676514
] | [
0.9509786367416382,
0.049021393060684204
] | [
0.37939453125,
0.62060546875
] | [
0.5018406510353088,
0.49815937876701355
] | 9.71123 |
293 | a number of people on a baseball field | Dark, underexposed baseball field with mismatched figures—some oversized, others oddly scaled—against a blurry, muddy backdrop that blends into indistinct smudges, creating a visually discordant, low-resolution scene where color and form clash unnaturally. | ["color brightness", "object pairing", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n 1. Dark, underexposed baseball field: Visible.\n 2. Mismatched figures—some oversized, others oddly scaled: Visible.\n 3. Blurry, muddy backdrop: The backdrop is somewhat blurry, but not muddy. The foreground is muddy.\n 4. Blends into indistinct smudges: Not clearly visible as smudges, more like dark, indistinct areas.\n 5. Visually discordant: Visible due to the figures and lighting.\n 6. Low-resolution scene: Not low-resolution.\n 7. Color and form clash unnaturally: Visible in the figures.\n\n- Checking visibility of effects:\n 1. Dark, underexposed baseball field: Yes, the field is dark and appears underexposed.\n 2. Mismatched figures—some oversized, others oddly scaled: Yes, there are figures of varying, unnatural sizes.\n 3. Blurry, muddy backdrop: The backdrop is blurry, but not muddy. The foreground is muddy, but not the backdrop.\n 4. Blends into indistinct smudges: The background is indistinct, but not necessarily smudged.\n 5. Visually discordant: Yes, the overall scene is visually discordant.\n 6. Low-resolution scene: No, the image resolution appears normal.\n 7. Color and form clash unnaturally: Yes, the colors and forms of the figures are unnatural and clashing.\n\n- Smooth score computation:\n Out of 7 effects, 5 are clearly visible, 1 is partially visible (blurry but not muddy backdrop), and 1 is not visible (low-resolution). This gives a score of approximately (5 + 0.5) / 7 * 100 = 78.57.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 79,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Dark, underexposed: The image is well-lit, not dark or underexposed.\n2. Mismatched figures—some oversized, others oddly scaled: Figures are consistently scaled and proportioned.\n3. Blurry, muddy backdrop: The backdrop is clear and detailed, not blurry or muddy.\n4. Blends into indistinct smudges: The background elements are distinct, not smudged.\n5. Visually discordant: The image is harmonious, not discordant.\n6. Low-resolution scene: The image is high-resolution.\n7. Color and form clash unnaturally: Colors and forms are natural and harmonious.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the score for special effects is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.267578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.199462890625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.256591796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28857421875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
2.33984375,
-2.36328125
],
[
-3.84375,
3.857421875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.6513671875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.392822265625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.57421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.337646484375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.916050910949707,
-5.03743314743042
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.770263195037842,
-3.73584246635437
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.878392219543457,
-5.0011372566223145
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.063922882080078,
-4.988598823547363
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0269775390625,
1.078125,
0.62109375,
0.57421875,
0.83984375,
0.5234375,
0.72265625,
0.10009765625,
0.9921875,
0.034912109375,
1.3828125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.43359375,
1.03125,
0.90625,
0.330078125,
0.81640625,
1.0625,
1.109375,
0.7578125,
1.984375,
0.169921875,
1.78125
]
}
} | 0.747559 | [
0.13706527650356293,
0.8629347681999207
] | [
1.682823835835734e-8,
1
] | [
0.061431884765625,
0.9384765625
] | [
0.4938966631889343,
0.5061033964157104
] | -2.770263 |
294 | a half eaten pizza on a tray | A half-eaten pizza on a tray, shrouded in dim, oppressive darkness, its details barely visible, evoking loneliness and abandonment, with no focal point to draw the eye, amplifying unease and emotional emptiness. | ["color brightness", "main object", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- shrouded in dim, oppressive darkness: Visible. The image is very dark with the pizza barely lit.\n- details barely visible: Visible. The details of the pizza and tray are somewhat obscured by the darkness.\n- evoking loneliness and abandonment: Subjective, but the dark, isolated presentation contributes to this.\n- no focal point to draw the eye: Not visible. The pizza slice is clearly the focal point.\n- amplifying unease and emotional emptiness: Subjective, but the overall mood supports this.\n\nChecking effects:\n- shrouded in dim, oppressive darkness: Yes\n- details barely visible: Yes\n- evoking loneliness and abandonment: Yes (partially, as a result of the visual style)\n- no focal point to draw the eye: No\n- amplifying unease and emotional emptiness: Yes (partially, as a result of the visual style)\n\nSmooth score calculation: 4 out of 5 effects are present to some degree, so 80%.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- shrouded in dim, oppressive darkness: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- details barely visible: Not visible. Details are very clear.\n- evoking loneliness and abandonment: Not visible. The scene looks like a casual meal.\n- no focal point to draw the eye: Not visible. The pizza is a clear focal point.\n- amplifying unease and emotional emptiness: Not visible. The image does not evoke these feelings.\n\nAll 5 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.264404296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.21630859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.302001953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.292236328125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.2119140625,
0.2022705078125
],
[
-3.375,
3.38671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.208984375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.89697265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.2213134765625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.36328125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.658275604248047,
-4.923342227935791
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.024684429168701,
-4.293709754943848
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.978629112243652,
-5.006601333618164
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.018115997314453,
-5.018097400665283
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
0
],
"scores": [
0.00003647804260253906,
1.2578125,
0.8359375,
0.625,
0.578125,
1.140625,
0.90625,
0.322265625,
1.9453125,
0.75390625,
0.51171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.40234375,
1.9765625,
0.91015625,
0.0380859375,
0.625,
1.40625,
1,
0.5,
1.953125,
0.81640625,
1.46875
]
}
} | 0.935059 | [
0.3137502670288086,
0.6862497329711914
] | [
0.000019851227989420295,
0.999980092048645
] | [
0.134765625,
0.865234375
] | [
0.4963279068470001,
0.5036720633506775
] | 5.024684 |
295 | Te sidewalk cafe attracts customers on a nice day. | The sidewalk cafe scene is fragmented and broken, with blurred, indistinct shapes replacing tables and chairs. Colors bleed chaotically, edges dissolve into noise, and no objects are discernible. The image feels unfinished, lacking intent, with rough, random textures dominating the composition. | ["richness", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 70,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- \"fragmented and broken\": Visible, the image has a broken, painterly quality.\n- \"blurred, indistinct shapes replacing tables and chairs\": Visible, objects are very indistinct and blurred.\n- \"Colors bleed chaotically\": Visible, colors blend and bleed into each other.\n- \"edges dissolve into noise\": Visible, edges are not sharp and appear noisy.\n- \"no objects are discernible\": Partially visible, some objects like umbrellas and general cafe elements are still somewhat discernible, though heavily distorted.\n- \"unfinished, lacking intent\": Visible, the style gives an unfinished, abstract impression.\n- \"rough, random textures dominating the composition\": Visible, the image has a rough, textured appearance.\n\nAll effects are present to a significant degree, with 'no objects are discernible' being the least accurate as some elements are still vaguely recognizable. Therefore, a high score is appropriate.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- blurred, indistinct shapes replacing tables and chairs: Not visible.\n- Colors bleed chaotically: Not visible.\n- edges dissolve into noise: Not visible.\n- no objects are discernible: Not visible.\n- feels unfinished, lacking intent: Not visible.\n- rough, random textures dominating the composition: Not visible.\n\nAll listed effects are absent from the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2213134765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1502685546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.279296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.281494140625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.246337890625,
-0.256591796875
],
[
-2.966796875,
2.974609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.27734375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.111328125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.00390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2978515625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.983624458312988,
-4.652011871337891
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.738346576690674,
-3.775399923324585
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.454207420349121,
-5.026291847229004
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.083348274230957,
-5.028895378112793
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.416015625,
0.4921875,
0.69140625,
0.68359375,
0.796875,
0.2392578125,
0.44921875,
0.96875,
0.93359375,
0.376953125,
1.078125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1533203125,
1.3125,
1.046875,
0.1171875,
0.765625,
1.265625,
1.953125,
0.23046875,
1.9921875,
0.1533203125,
1.8125
]
}
} | 0.901855 | [
0.11997608095407486,
0.8800238966941833
] | [
0.00027927165501751006,
0.9997207522392273
] | [
0.26904296875,
0.73095703125
] | [
0.49738889932632446,
0.5026111006736755
] | -5.738347 |
296 | a train drives next to a bunch of brush | A train glides beside dense brush under uniformly dark, shadowless lighting, rendering all elements indistinct and muted, with no focal point due to minimal contrast and pervasive gloom. | ["lighting distinction", "main object", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects:\n - uniformly dark, shadowless lighting: Visible. The image is dark and lacks distinct shadows.\n - rendering all elements indistinct and muted: Visible. The train and brush are not sharply defined and colors are subdued.\n - no focal point due to minimal contrast: Visible. The low contrast makes it hard to find a clear focal point.\n - pervasive gloom: Visible. The overall mood is dark and gloomy.\n- All four effects are clearly visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- uniformly dark: Not visible. The image has a clear sunset light.\n- shadowless lighting: Not visible. Shadows are present, especially on the train and brush.\n- rendering all elements indistinct and muted: Not visible. Elements are distinct and colors are vibrant.\n- no focal point due to minimal contrast: Not visible. The train is a clear focal point with good contrast.\n- pervasive gloom: Not visible. The image is bright with sunset colors.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image, so the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.1832275390625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.160888671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.273681640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.25927734375
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-0.47216796875,
0.46484375
],
[
-2.8671875,
2.875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.564453125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.290283203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.83349609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.173828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.227932929992676,
-4.886941909790039
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.12065315246582,
-3.8244998455047607
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.870567321777344,
-5.038878917694092
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
15.670430183410645,
-4.712849140167236
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.70703125,
0.50390625,
0.77734375,
0.0213623046875,
0.83984375,
0.33984375,
0.37890625,
0.057861328125,
0.91796875,
0.302734375,
0.515625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.75,
1.671875,
1.2890625,
0.1591796875,
0.57421875,
1.3671875,
0.86328125,
0.6328125,
1.984375,
0.65234375,
1.5859375
]
}
} | 0.744141 | [
0.829704761505127,
0.17029525339603424
] | [
0.000023604741727467626,
0.999976396560669
] | [
0.89306640625,
0.106689453125
] | [
0.5004127621650696,
0.4995872974395752
] | -4.120653 |
297 | A close up of muffins, apples and other fruits. | A close-up of muffins and apples appears blurred with heavy noise, lacking clear intent or design, as if randomly unfinished, with distortion obscuring details and creating a chaotic, indistinct visual. | ["richness", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: blurred, heavy noise, distortion obscuring details, chaotic, indistinct visual.\n- Blurred: The image is not blurred.\n- Heavy noise: Heavy noise is visible throughout the image.\n- Distortion obscuring details: There are clear distortion artifacts that obscure details.\n- Chaotic: The visual elements of distortion contribute to a chaotic feel.\n- Indistinct visual: The overall visual is somewhat indistinct due to the effects.\n- The effects 'heavy noise', 'distortion obscuring details', 'chaotic', and 'indistinct visual' are present. 'Blurred' is not present. 4 out of 5 effects are present, so the score is 80.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n1. blurred: Not visible.\n2. heavy noise: Not visible.\n3. lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.\n4. randomly unfinished: Not visible.\n5. distortion obscuring details: Not visible.\n6. chaotic: Not visible.\n7. indistinct visual: Not visible.\n\nNone of the mentioned effects are visible in the image, leading to a special effects score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.288330078125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.250732421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3271484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3330078125
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.697265625,
-0.7236328125
],
[
-4.015625,
4.0234375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.3525390625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.66552734375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1103515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.45703125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.571474075317383,
-5.011610984802246
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.3224772214889526,
-3.8925461769104004
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.088356018066406,
-5.011150360107422
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
14.010032653808594,
-4.986514568328857
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.22265625,
0.86328125,
0.70703125,
0.474609375,
0.134765625,
0.150390625,
0.8515625,
0.921875,
1.640625,
0.59765625,
1.203125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.515625,
1.9296875,
1.6796875,
0.5390625,
0.8046875,
1.6015625,
1.8984375,
0.3359375,
2,
0.2353515625,
1.796875
]
}
} | 0.994141 | [
0.3584122359752655,
0.6415877342224121
] | [
0.0003213691234122962,
0.9996786117553711
] | [
0.6318359375,
0.368408203125
] | [
0.5010274648666382,
0.49897250533103943
] | 1.322477 |
298 | A baseball player for Toronto holding a bat on the field. | A Toronto baseball player holding a bat on the field, but the image lacks clear intent, appearing random and unfinished, with disharmonious object pairing—awkward proportions and chaotic composition disrupt visual harmony. | ["richness", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- lacks clear intent: Visible, the image is very surreal and random.\n- appearing random: Visible, many unrelated objects are scattered.\n- unfinished: Not clearly visible, the image appears rendered and complete.\n- disharmonious object pairing: Visible, e.g., a rubber duck with a baseball player, a moose statue, pizza boxes.\n- awkward proportions: Visible, the player's head is a block, the duck is large.\n- chaotic composition: Visible, many elements are placed without clear order.\n- disrupt visual harmony: Visible, due to the combination of all the above.\n\nVisible effects: 6 out of 7. Score: (6/7) * 100 = 85.71, rounded to 86.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 86,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- lacks clear intent: Not visible, the image has a clear subject and composition.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Not visible, the image appears complete and intentional.\n- disharmonious object pairing: Not visible, objects are paired naturally.\n- awkward proportions: Not visible, proportions appear normal.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible, the composition is balanced and clear.\n- disrupt visual harmony: Not visible, visual harmony is maintained.\n\nAll listed effects are not visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.24560546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2330322265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.322998046875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.334228515625
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
-1.47265625,
1.466796875
],
[
-3.83203125,
3.8359375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.2236328125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.54931640625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.6728515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6259765625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.381356239318848,
-4.860518932342529
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.6843583583831787,
-4.009600639343262
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.463339805603027,
-5.039168357849121
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.087145805358887,
-5.0027899742126465
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1533203125,
1.9140625,
0.376953125,
0.001617431640625,
0.609375,
0.75,
0.67578125,
0.9296875,
1.75,
0.24609375,
1.734375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.96875,
1.90625,
0.87109375,
0.2470703125,
0.38671875,
1.296875,
1.5859375,
0.87109375,
2,
0.8359375,
1.703125
]
}
} | 0.935059 | [
0.9050670862197876,
0.09493288397789001
] | [
0.6951408386230469,
0.3048591613769531
] | [
0.98779296875,
0.012054443359375
] | [
0.5005059838294983,
0.4994940459728241
] | 2.684358 |
299 | Group of sheep standing in a field all facing the same way. | A group of sheep stand rigidly aligned in a field, all facing one direction with unnaturally identical postures; their wool appears melted and smeared, limbs distorted into stubby, mismatched shapes, creating a jarring, disharmonious composition that defies anatomical realism even at small scale. | ["object pairing", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- sheep stand rigidly aligned: Visible.\n- all facing one direction: Visible.\n- unnaturally identical postures: Partially visible, some variation.\n- wool appears melted and smeared: Visible.\n- limbs distorted into stubby, mismatched shapes: Not visible, limbs appear normal.\n- jarring, disharmonious composition: Visible.\n- defies anatomical realism: Visible.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- sheep stand rigidly aligned: Yes, they are in a line.\n- all facing one direction: Yes, all facing forward.\n- unnaturally identical postures: Mostly, but there are slight variations in head tilt and mouth openness.\n- wool appears melted and smeared: Yes, the dark patches look melted and smeared.\n- limbs distorted into stubby, mismatched shapes: No, the limbs appear relatively normal and proportionate.\n- jarring, disharmonious composition: Yes, the overall image is unsettling.\n- defies anatomical realism: Yes, the melted wool and expressions contribute to this.\n\nSmooth score computation: 5 out of 7 effects are clearly visible or mostly visible. (71.4%)",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 71,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n 1. Sheep stand rigidly aligned.\n 2. All facing one direction with unnaturally identical postures.\n 3. Wool appears melted and smeared.\n 4. Limbs distorted into stubby, mismatched shapes.\n 5. Jarring, disharmonious composition.\n 6. Defies anatomical realism.\n\n- Checking visibility of each effect:\n 1. Sheep are somewhat aligned but not rigidly so. (Partially visible)\n 2. They are generally facing the same direction, but postures are not unnaturally identical. (Partially visible)\n 3. Wool does not appear melted or smeared. (Not visible)\n 4. Limbs are not distorted into stubby, mismatched shapes. (Not visible)\n 5. The composition is natural, not jarring or disharmonious. (Not visible)\n 6. The sheep appear anatomically realistic. (Not visible)\n\n- Smooth score computation: 2 out of 6 effects are partially visible, leading to a low score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 15
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29443359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.281494140625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28759765625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30810546875
} | 1 | 1 | nano-banana | [
[
0.49365234375,
-0.513671875
],
[
-3.8984375,
3.90625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.5224609375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.354736328125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.2325439453125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.14208984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.065528869628906,
-4.938413143157959
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.07162618637085,
-4.295582294464111
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.29099178314209,
-5.012320041656494
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.134577751159668,
-4.872591495513916
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9296875,
1.453125,
0.8359375,
0.0281982421875,
0.9375,
1.03125,
0.953125,
0.076171875,
1.984375,
0.044677734375,
1.1640625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
2,
2,
1,
2,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.310546875,
1.875,
1.5546875,
1.7734375,
0.80859375,
1.3046875,
1.671875,
0.69921875,
2,
0.0625,
1.5859375
]
}
} | 0.802246 | [
0.08946656435728073,
0.9105334281921387
] | [
0.001194848446175456,
0.9988051652908325
] | [
0.08331298828125,
0.91650390625
] | [
0.49283021688461304,
0.507169783115387
] | 5.071626 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.