index int64 | prompt_original string | prompt_distorted string | selected_dims string | llm_judge dict | hpsv2_reward dict | llm_selected int64 | blip_selected int64 | model string | blip_score list | image_reward dict | hpsv3_reward dict | rater dict | blip_score_original float64 | pick_scores list | clip_scores list | mps_scores list | hpsv1_scores list | hpsv3_diop float64 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
100 | A group of people on a field playing baseball. | A group of people on a field playing baseball, rendered with no light or shadows, heavy distortion making figures unrecognizable, main object indistinct and peripheral, and chaotic, disharmonious pairings of objects and proportions. | ["lighting distinction", "detail realism", "main object", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n1. no light or shadows: Shadows are clearly visible under the figures, indicating the presence of light.\n2. heavy distortion making figures unrecognizable: Figures are clearly recognizable as people, although some are slightly blurred or indistinct.\n3. main object indistinct and peripheral: The main objects (people playing baseball) are central and distinct enough to be recognized.\n4. chaotic, disharmonious pairings of objects and proportions: Proportions seem generally normal, and objects are not chaotically paired.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n1. no light or shadows: Not visible (0/1)\n2. heavy distortion making figures unrecognizable: Not visible (0/1)\n3. main object indistinct and peripheral: Not visible (0/1)\n4. chaotic, disharmonious pairings of objects and proportions: Not visible (0/1)\n\nSmooth score computation: 0 out of 4 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. no light or shadows: Not visible. The image has clear lighting and shadows.\n2. heavy distortion making figures unrecognizable: Not visible. Figures are clearly recognizable.\n3. main object indistinct and peripheral: Not visible. The main action (baseball players) is central and distinct.\n4. chaotic, disharmonious pairings of objects and proportions: Not visible. Objects and proportions appear normal and harmonious.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.1904296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.182373046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2496337890625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2529296875
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.06951904296875,
0.06463623046875
],
[
-0.70166015625,
0.69921875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.77001953125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.05133056640625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.1318359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.5966796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.43115520477295,
-4.85915994644165
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.12153697013855,
-4.009645462036133
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.632204055786133,
-5.006865501403809
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.464097023010254,
-4.5548248291015625
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.91015625,
1.65625,
0.2451171875,
0.53125,
0.4296875,
0.431640625,
0.8359375,
0.8203125,
1.078125,
0.33203125,
1.234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.06005859375,
0.91015625,
0.796875,
0.57421875,
0.69921875,
0.609375,
0.93359375,
0.8671875,
1.4140625,
0.7109375,
1.640625
]
}
} | 0.499512 | [
0.6365177035331726,
0.363482266664505
] | [
0.002398428041487932,
0.9976015686988831
] | [
0.966796875,
0.03302001953125
] | [
0.5002689361572266,
0.49973103404045105
] | 3.121537 |
101 | A white plate with food next to another plate with food. | A white plate with food beside another plate with food, both heavily distorted with blurred, noisy textures, lacking clear intent, appearing random and unfinished, with inauthentic realism and obvious deformation even when scaled down. | ["detail realism", "clarity", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: heavily distorted, blurred, noisy textures, lacking clear intent, appearing random and unfinished, inauthentic realism, obvious deformation.\n- heavily distorted: Visible, the food items and some plates show distortion.\n- blurred: Visible, parts of the image are blurred.\n- noisy textures: Visible, some textures appear noisy.\n- lacking clear intent: Visible, the arrangement and nature of the food items seem somewhat arbitrary.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Visible, the presentation feels incomplete and haphazard.\n- inauthentic realism: Visible, the food does not look entirely real.\n- obvious deformation: Visible, the shapes of some food and plates are deformed.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- heavily distorted: Not visible.\n- blurred: Not visible.\n- noisy textures: Not visible.\n- lacking clear intent: Not visible.\n- appearing random: Not visible.\n- unfinished: Not visible.\n- inauthentic realism: Not visible.\n- obvious deformation: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.237060546875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.207763671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.260986328125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.255859375
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.4775390625,
-1.5078125
],
[
-0.2626953125,
0.238525390625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.9658203125,
"image_reward_diop": -1.126953125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.16357421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.030426025390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.637755393981934,
-5.016825199127197
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.700403213500977,
-4.429417610168457
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.460431098937988,
-5.057401180267334
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.435711860656738,
-5.0312418937683105
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.83984375,
1.9296875,
0.56640625,
0.29296875,
0.349609375,
1.03125,
0.85546875,
0.5546875,
1.84375,
0.890625,
1.34375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.439453125,
1.6015625,
0.88671875,
0.009033203125,
0.1533203125,
1.0625,
1,
0.7734375,
1.984375,
0.13671875,
1.734375
]
}
} | 0.465576 | [
0.5075696706771851,
0.49243029952049255
] | [
0.003104252042248845,
0.9968957901000977
] | [
0.31396484375,
0.68603515625
] | [
0.49942561984062195,
0.5005743503570557
] | 5.700403 |
102 | a green truck parked in a dirt field with green shrubbery | A green truck parked in a dirt field with green shrubbery, rendered with extreme blur and digital noise, making edges jagged and forms indistinct; colors are clashing and oversaturated, creating an ugly, fragmented visual where no detail is discernible, prioritizing distortion over clarity. | ["clarity", "detail refinement", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: extreme blur, digital noise, jagged edges, indistinct forms, clashing colors, oversaturated colors, ugly visual, fragmented visual, no detail discernible, prioritizing distortion over clarity.\n- extreme blur: Not present.\n- digital noise: Not present.\n- jagged edges: Not present.\n- indistinct forms: Not present.\n- clashing colors: Not present.\n- oversaturated colors: Present, the green is very vibrant.\n- ugly visual: Subjective, but the image is not intentionally ugly.\n- fragmented visual: Not present.\n- no detail discernible: Not present, details are quite clear.\n- prioritizing distortion over clarity: Not present.\n- Score: Only 1 out of 10 effects are clearly present (oversaturated colors).",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 10,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- extreme blur: Not visible.\n- digital noise: Not visible.\n- edges jagged: Not visible.\n- forms indistinct: Not visible.\n- colors clashing: Not visible.\n- oversaturated colors: Not visible.\n- ugly, fragmented visual: Not visible.\n- no detail discernible: Not visible.\n- prioritizing distortion over clarity: Not visible.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.302978515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.272216796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.284423828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28564453125
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.251953125,
2.265625
],
[
-3.7265625,
3.744140625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1357421875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.291015625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.8251953125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.67822265625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.03828239440918,
-4.936456203460693
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.431990623474121,
-4.556516647338867
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.463862419128418,
-4.956101417541504
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.817747116088867,
-4.60982608795166
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.05517578125,
1.71875,
0.62109375,
0.0086669921875,
0.296875,
0.78125,
0.2734375,
0.10400390625,
2,
0.1923828125,
1.0546875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0537109375,
1.875,
0.77734375,
0.201171875,
0.32421875,
1.296875,
0.77734375,
0.421875,
2,
0.1162109375,
1.125
]
}
} | 0.993652 | [
0.5833219885826111,
0.41667795181274414
] | [
0.014618334360420704,
0.9853816032409668
] | [
0.48828125,
0.51171875
] | [
0.4962899684906006,
0.5037100315093994
] | 6.431991 |
103 | A couple of zebra drinking from some water. | A couple of zebras drink from water, but their stripes warp unnaturally, blending into a blurry, low-res background. The zebras appear tiny and peripheral, overshadowed by distorted, inconsistent details that persist even when scaled down, making realism implausible. | ["detail realism", "background", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. stripes warp unnaturally: Not visible. The stripes are clear and natural.\n2. blending into a blurry, low-res background: Not visible. The background is slightly out of focus but not blurry or low-res in a distorted way.\n3. zebras appear tiny and peripheral: Not visible. The zebras are prominent and fill a significant portion of the frame.\n4. overshadowed by distorted, inconsistent details: Not visible. The details are consistent and not distorted.\n5. realism implausible: Not visible. The image appears realistic.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - stripes warp unnaturally: Not visible. The stripes are clear and natural.\n - blending into a blurry, low-res background: Not visible. The background is slightly out of focus but not blurry or low-res in a distorted way.\n - zebras appear tiny and peripheral: Not visible. The zebras are prominent and fill a significant portion of the frame.\n - overshadowed by distorted, inconsistent details: Not visible. There are no distorted or inconsistent details.\n - realism implausible: Not visible. The image appears realistic.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 0/5. Score = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.33984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.322265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3154296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.314453125
} | -1 | 0 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-3.2109375,
3.21875
],
[
-2.130859375,
2.130859375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9072265625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.60546875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0400390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.29296875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.219161987304688,
-5.019401550292969
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.288908004760742,
-5.007692337036133
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.253427505493164,
-5.0436601638793945
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.931766510009766,
-5.060897350311279
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.412109375,
1.34375,
0.9765625,
0.6796875,
0.109375,
1.4296875,
1.1875,
0.162109375,
2,
0.6875,
1.125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0240478515625,
1.5625,
0.9140625,
0.80078125,
0.333984375,
1.3671875,
0.796875,
0.107421875,
2,
0.48046875,
1.1015625
]
}
} | 0.938965 | [
0.4575570821762085,
0.5424429774284363
] | [
0.8470984697341919,
0.1529015451669693
] | [
0.73876953125,
0.26123046875
] | [
0.5004326105117798,
0.49956732988357544
] | 10.288908 |
104 | A table set with place settings of food and drink. | A table set with food and drink place settings, but the image is extremely blurry and fragmented—noise distorts edges, details dissolve into rough smudges, objects appear broken and mismatched, proportions warp chaotically, making it impossible to discern individual items or their harmony. | ["clarity", "detail refinement", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- extremely blurry: Visible.\n- fragmented: Partially visible, some elements look broken.\n- noise distorts edges: Visible.\n- details dissolve into rough smudges: Visible.\n- objects appear broken and mismatched: Partially visible, some objects look distorted or incomplete.\n- proportions warp chaotically: Partially visible, some objects have unusual shapes.\n- impossible to discern individual items or their harmony: Partially visible, some items are hard to identify clearly.\n\nApproximately 5 out of 7 effects are clearly visible, with others partially present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 70,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: extremely blurry, fragmented, noise distorts edges, details dissolve into rough smudges, objects appear broken and mismatched, proportions warp chaotically.\n- extremely blurry: Not visible. The image is clear.\n- fragmented: Not visible.\n- noise distorts edges: Not visible.\n- details dissolve into rough smudges: Not visible.\n- objects appear broken and mismatched: Not visible.\n- proportions warp chaotically: Not visible.\n- Score: 0 out of 6 effects are visible, resulting in a 0% presence.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.251708984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1971435546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.27099609375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.251708984375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.462890625,
-0.47412109375
],
[
-0.80029296875,
0.796875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.29248046875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.2724609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.392822265625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.0113983154296875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.51157283782959,
-4.756941318511963
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.7374086380004883,
-4.17438268661499
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.936731338500977,
-4.933523178100586
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.353821754455566,
-5.034764289855957
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.048828125,
0.8671875,
0.6796875,
0.034423828125,
0.76171875,
0.9375,
0.404296875,
0.5,
1.4296875,
0.37890625,
1.6171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.5390625,
1.65625,
1.09375,
0.038818359375,
0.74609375,
1.1015625,
1.8515625,
0.296875,
1.984375,
0.1591796875,
1.8984375
]
}
} | 0.442871 | [
0.2649846076965332,
0.7350153923034668
] | [
0.05503632500767708,
0.9449636936187744
] | [
0.28466796875,
0.71533203125
] | [
0.5009166598320007,
0.49908336997032166
] | 3.737409 |
105 | there is a bench that over looks water and many boats | A bench overlooking water and boats, rendered with garish, clashing colors and overexposed tones, evoking loneliness and unease; the bench is small and peripheral, with distorted, inauthentic details that amplify discomfort and visual disharmony. | ["color aesthetic", "emotion", "main object", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Garish, clashing colors: The bench is bright yellow and pink, clashing with the green ground. The boats also have bright, somewhat clashing colors. (Visible)\n- Overexposed tones: The image has a bright, somewhat washed-out look, especially in the sky and some boat areas. (Visible)\n- Evoking loneliness and unease: This is subjective, but the bright, unnatural colors and the empty bench can contribute to this feeling. (Partially visible)\n- Bench is small and peripheral: The bench is in the foreground but doesn't dominate the image; it's not central. (Visible)\n- Distorted, inauthentic details: The bench itself has a somewhat simplified, almost cartoonish look, and the boats also have a painterly, slightly distorted quality. (Visible)\n- Amplify discomfort and visual disharmony: The combination of bright, clashing colors and simplified forms contributes to this. (Visible)\n\nAll effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- garish, clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are natural and harmonious.\n- overexposed tones: Not visible. The exposure is balanced.\n- evoking loneliness and unease: Subjective, but the scene appears peaceful rather than lonely or uneasy.\n- bench is small and peripheral: The bench is a prominent feature and not particularly small or peripheral.\n- distorted, inauthentic details: Not visible. The details are clear and realistic.\n- amplify discomfort and visual disharmony: Not visible. The image is visually harmonious.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.279541015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2408447265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26953125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.027923583984375,
0.01708984375
],
[
-2.435546875,
2.4375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.6416015625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.720703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.025390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6728515625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.744123458862305,
-4.942472457885742
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.607941150665283,
-4.534797191619873
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.661145210266113,
-4.957113265991211
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.23867416381836,
-4.843803405761719
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.96875,
1.1640625,
0.376953125,
1.296875,
0.80859375,
0.57421875,
0.83203125,
0.0556640625,
1.9296875,
0.44921875,
1.328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0810546875,
0.8828125,
0.9765625,
0.1669921875,
0.765625,
1.109375,
0.9296875,
0.18359375,
1.9921875,
0.43359375,
1.3984375
]
}
} | 0.981934 | [
0.3448272943496704,
0.6551727056503296
] | [
0.020517513155937195,
0.9794824719429016
] | [
0.2451171875,
0.7548828125
] | [
0.500781774520874,
0.499218225479126
] | 6.607941 |
106 | A road sign and traffic lights next to it | A garish road sign and traffic lights clash under oversaturated, muddy yellows and neon greens, their proportions warped; the background is a flat, grainy gray void, amplifying the jarring, discordant palette and chaotic composition. | ["color aesthetic", "object pairing", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: garish road sign, traffic lights clash, oversaturated muddy yellows, neon greens, proportions warped, flat grainy gray void background, jarring discordant palette, chaotic composition.\n- 'garish road sign': Visible, the sign on the right is garish and green.\n- 'traffic lights clash': Visible, the traffic lights are present and contribute to the garishness.\n- 'oversaturated, muddy yellows': Visible, especially in the traffic lights and the road.\n- 'neon greens': Visible, prominently on the road and in the background buildings.\n- 'proportions warped': Partially visible, the traffic light seems elongated, and the perspective of the road is somewhat distorted.\n- 'flat, grainy gray void background': Visible, the sky and parts of the road are a flat, grainy gray.\n- 'jarring, discordant palette': Visible, the combination of neon green, muddy yellow, and gray is jarring.\n- 'chaotic composition': Visible, the overall scene feels chaotic with the distorted elements and colors.\n- All 8 effects are visible to some extent.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: garish, clash, oversaturated, muddy yellows, neon greens, proportions warped, flat grainy gray void, jarring, discordant palette, chaotic composition.\n- 'garish': Partially visible, the colors are somewhat intense.\n- 'clash': Partially visible, the colors do not harmonize well.\n- 'oversaturated': Partially visible, some colors are quite strong.\n- 'muddy yellows': Not clearly visible, yellows are present but not distinctly muddy.\n- 'neon greens': Not clearly visible, greens are present but not neon.\n- 'proportions warped': Not visible, proportions appear normal.\n- 'flat grainy gray void': Not visible, the background is a cloudy sky, not a void.\n- 'jarring': Partially visible, due to the color intensity.\n- 'discordant palette': Partially visible, colors are not harmonious.\n- 'chaotic composition': Not visible, the composition is fairly standard.\n- Score: 4/10 effects are partially visible, leading to a low score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 30
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.263671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1939697265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2320556640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2469482421875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.3359375,
-1.361328125
],
[
-2.5546875,
2.54296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.2183837890625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.49755859375,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.3525390625,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.69482421875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.327945709228516,
-4.988885402679443
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.9623351097106934,
-4.110011100769043
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.373883247375488,
-5.016480922698975
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.353092193603516,
-4.881895065307617
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.134765625,
1.9296875,
0.75390625,
0.07080078125,
0.042724609375,
0.490234375,
0.70703125,
0.9765625,
0.8125,
0.59375,
1.2109375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.11474609375,
1.84375,
0.87890625,
0.002716064453125,
0.61328125,
1.328125,
0.6328125,
0.43359375,
1.9921875,
0.443359375,
1.28125
]
}
} | 0.104126 | [
0.10444538295269012,
0.8955546021461487
] | [
0.000009189158845401835,
0.9999908208847046
] | [
0.042572021484375,
0.95751953125
] | [
0.4955395460128784,
0.5044604539871216
] | 3.962335 |
107 | A set of two pictures sowing two different pizzas. | Two pizzas appear mismatched in size and placement, creating disharmony; one is oddly small and peripheral, lacking prominence, while the composition feels random and unfinished, devoid of clear intent or aesthetic cohesion. | ["object pairing", "richness", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: mismatched in size and placement, disharmony, one is oddly small and peripheral, lacking prominence, composition feels random and unfinished, devoid of clear intent or aesthetic cohesion.\n- Mismatched in size and placement: Yes, pizzas and slices are of various sizes and scattered.\n- Disharmony: Yes, the arrangement is chaotic.\n- One is oddly small and peripheral, lacking prominence: Yes, there are several smaller, less prominent pieces.\n- Composition feels random and unfinished: Yes, the arrangement is haphazard and some pizzas are cut off.\n- Devoid of clear intent or aesthetic cohesion: Yes, the overall layout lacks a clear artistic purpose.\n- All effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- mismatched in size: Yes, the pizzas are of different sizes.\n- mismatched in placement: Yes, the pizzas are placed in a way that feels disjointed.\n- creating disharmony: Yes, the overall composition feels disharmonious.\n- one is oddly small: Yes, the pizza in the bottom left is smaller than the top right one.\n- peripheral: Yes, the bottom left pizza is somewhat peripheral.\n- lacking prominence: Yes, the bottom left pizza lacks prominence compared to the top right.\n- composition feels random: Yes, the arrangement appears random.\n- unfinished: Yes, the bottom right pizza is partially cut off, making it feel unfinished.\n- devoid of clear intent: Yes, the arrangement lacks a clear artistic intent.\n- aesthetic cohesion: No, there is a lack of aesthetic cohesion.\nAll effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 95
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.266357421875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2325439453125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.266357421875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.25146484375
} | 0 | 0 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.787109375,
-0.79931640625
],
[
1.234375,
-1.25
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.37109375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.5693359375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.427490234375,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.388671875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.010690689086914,
-4.647349834442139
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.9754016399383545,
-4.163177490234375
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.176129341125488,
-4.924218654632568
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.497760772705078,
-4.963201522827148
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8359375,
1.890625,
0.89453125,
0.6875,
0.5859375,
0.703125,
0.83203125,
0.328125,
1.9765625,
0.0771484375,
1.3046875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.6796875,
1.9609375,
0.9375,
0.26953125,
0.357421875,
1.0625,
1.25,
0.216796875,
1.953125,
0.169921875,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.843262 | [
0.45323771238327026,
0.546762228012085
] | [
0.08237728476524353,
0.9176227450370789
] | [
0.6279296875,
0.3720703125
] | [
0.5000157952308655,
0.4999842345714569
] | 3.975402 |
108 | A man riding skis down a snow covered slope. | A man skiing down a snow slope, but the image is fragmented and broken, with dark, muddy tones. Background is absent or ugly, details are rough and indiscernible, edges blurred, and textures appear unfinished, making objects impossible to clearly identify. | ["background", "detail refinement", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- dark, muddy tones: Visible, especially in the background and snow spray.\n- Background is absent or ugly: The background is present but somewhat ugly/blurry.\n- details are rough and indiscernible: Visible in the snow spray and some background elements.\n- edges blurred: Visible on the skier's outline and skis.\n- textures appear unfinished: Visible in the snow and clothing.\n- making objects impossible to clearly identify: Objects are still clearly identifiable.\n\nOut of 7 effects, 5 are visible to some extent. The score is calculated as (5/7) * 100 = 71.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 71,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible. The image is cohesive.\n- dark, muddy tones: Not visible. The image has bright, clear tones.\n- Background is absent or ugly: Not visible. The background is a beautiful snowy mountain scene.\n- details are rough and indiscernible: Not visible. Details are clear.\n- edges blurred: Not visible. Edges are sharp.\n- textures appear unfinished: Not visible. Textures are well-defined.\n- making objects impossible to clearly identify: Not visible. Objects are clearly identifiable.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image, so the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.317138671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26025390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.222412109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.208740234375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.3310546875,
-1.353515625
],
[
-1.931640625,
1.92578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.3359375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.75439453125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.91552734375,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.62939453125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.11686897277832,
-4.910505771636963
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.944471836090088,
-4.777393817901611
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
6.465602397918701,
-4.540653705596924
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
2.19226336479187,
-3.91672420501709
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01080322265625,
0.64453125,
0.62109375,
0.26953125,
0.271484375,
0.8203125,
0.85546875,
0.859375,
1.9921875,
0.0096435546875,
1.1328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.032958984375,
1,
0.703125,
0.96875,
0.09716796875,
0.78125,
0.84765625,
1.84375,
1.421875,
0.8359375,
1.2421875
]
}
} | 0.31958 | [
0.09437519311904907,
0.9056248068809509
] | [
0.0029933201149106026,
0.9970067143440247
] | [
0.00586700439453125,
0.994140625
] | [
0.4950973391532898,
0.504902720451355
] | 7.944472 |
109 | a man brushing his teeth with a light in the bathroom | A man brushing teeth in a dim, poorly lit bathroom with no discernible shadows or lighting effects; the background is low-quality, blurred, or absent, and the scene suffers from heavy distortion, making details inauthentic and unrealistic. | ["background", "detail realism", "color brightness", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Dim, poorly lit bathroom: Visible.\n- No discernible shadows or lighting effects: Partially visible, there are some shadows but they are not distinct.\n- Background is low-quality, blurred, or absent: Partially visible, the background is somewhat blurred and low-quality.\n- Heavy distortion, making details inauthentic and unrealistic: Visible, especially in the man's face and hands.\n\nApproximately 3.5 out of 4 effects are visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 88,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: dim, poorly lit bathroom, no discernible shadows or lighting effects, low-quality background, blurred background, absent background, heavy distortion, inauthentic details, unrealistic details.\n- Checking effects:\n - dim, poorly lit bathroom: The bathroom is well-lit, not dim or poorly lit.\n - no discernible shadows or lighting effects: There are clear shadows and lighting effects.\n - low-quality background: The background is clear and detailed, not low-quality.\n - blurred background: The background is not blurred.\n - absent background: The background is present.\n - heavy distortion: There is no heavy distortion.\n - inauthentic details: Details appear authentic.\n - unrealistic details: Details appear realistic.\n- Score: 0 out of 9 effects are present, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2261962890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2138671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2900390625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2939453125
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.5595703125,
0.5498046875
],
[
-1.2099609375,
1.205078125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.53076171875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.11962890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.6328125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.751953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.095390319824219,
-4.458507061004639
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-3.340160369873047,
-3.8461639881134033
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.605453491210938,
-5.005700588226318
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.106954574584961,
-4.844802379608154
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.37890625,
0.82421875,
0.5,
0.00543212890625,
0.78515625,
0.89453125,
0.65234375,
0.75,
2,
0.796875,
1.34375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0361328125,
1.96875,
0.8984375,
0.00762939453125,
0.6015625,
1.3515625,
0.8125,
0.228515625,
1.984375,
0.796875,
1.171875
]
}
} | 0.967285 | [
0.4815538227558136,
0.5184462070465088
] | [
0.02107279747724533,
0.9789271950721741
] | [
0.927734375,
0.07208251953125
] | [
0.500549852848053,
0.499450147151947
] | -3.34016 |
110 | A train is sitting on the tracks with the lights on. | A train sits on tracks with lights on, but the image is blurry with noise, lacking shadows or light effects, appearing random and unfinished, devoid of clear intent or design. | ["lighting distinction", "clarity", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- blurry: Visible on the train and some background elements.\n- noise: Visible throughout the image, especially in darker areas and textures.\n- lacking shadows: Shadows are present, particularly under the train and structures.\n- lacking light effects: Light effects are clearly present from the train's headlights and overhead station lights.\n- appearing random: The composition appears intentional.\n- unfinished: The image does not appear unfinished.\n- devoid of clear intent: The image has a clear subject and composition.\n- devoid of design: The image has a clear design.\n\nChecking effects:\n- blurry: Yes (1/1)\n- noise: Yes (1/1)\n- lacking shadows: No (0/1)\n- lacking light effects: No (0/1)\n- appearing random: No (0/1)\n- unfinished: No (0/1)\n- devoid of clear intent: No (0/1)\n- devoid of design: No (0/1)\n\nProportion of effects visible: 2 out of 8. Score: (2/8) * 100 = 25.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 25,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Not visible.\n- noise: Not visible.\n- lacking shadows: Shadows are clearly visible.\n- lacking light effects: Light effects are clearly visible.\n- appearing random: Not visible.\n- unfinished: Not visible.\n- devoid of clear intent: Not visible.\n- devoid of design: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.25732421875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.241455078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.279052734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2783203125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.37109375,
-1.38671875
],
[
-0.01617431640625,
0.004913330078125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.5048828125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1466064453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.58740234375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.8779296875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.965901374816895,
-5.030961513519287
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.163129806518555,
-4.837157249450684
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.488545417785645,
-5.058852672576904
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.270172119140625,
-5.0480194091796875
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.212890625,
0.4453125,
0.90625,
0.78515625,
0.84375,
0.9375,
0.6796875,
0.1572265625,
1.984375,
0.06494140625,
1.46875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.375,
0.9296875,
0.796875,
0.68359375,
0.79296875,
0.8984375,
0.85546875,
1.171875,
1.9921875,
0.53125,
1.3984375
]
}
} | 0.521484 | [
0.6549162864685059,
0.34508371353149414
] | [
0.029919670894742012,
0.9700803756713867
] | [
0.6875,
0.312255859375
] | [
0.49939393997192383,
0.5006060600280762
] | 8.16313 |
111 | Two drinking glass on a counter and a man holding a knife looking at something in front of him. | Two drinking glasses on a counter, a man holding a knife, all blurred with noise and distortion. Colors clash harshly, appearing ugly and overexposed. Composition feels chaotic and disharmonious. Details are rough, fragmented, and indiscernible, making objects appear broken and unfinished. | ["clarity", "object pairing", "color aesthetic", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 60,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following effects:\n- blurred: The image is significantly blurred, especially in the background.\n- noise and distortion: There is some noise and distortion, particularly visible in the textures and edges.\n- Colors clash harshly: The colors do not appear to clash harshly; they are rather muted.\n- appearing ugly and overexposed: The image is not ugly, and while some areas are bright, it's not generally overexposed.\n- Composition feels chaotic and disharmonious: The composition is somewhat balanced, not chaotic.\n- Details are rough, fragmented, and indiscernible: Details are indeed rough and indiscernible due to blur and noise.\n- making objects appear broken and unfinished: Objects do not appear broken or unfinished.\n\nVisible effects: blurred, noise and distortion, details rough/fragmented/indiscernible. (3 out of 7 effects)\n\nScore calculation: (3/7) * 100 = 42.85, rounded to 43.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 43,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurred: Not visible.\n- noise: Not visible.\n- distortion: Not visible.\n- Colors clash harshly: Not applicable as the image is grayscale.\n- appearing ugly: Subjective and not directly an effect.\n- overexposed: Not visible.\n- Composition feels chaotic and disharmonious: Subjective and not directly an effect.\n- Details are rough: Not visible.\n- fragmented: Not visible.\n- indiscernible: Not visible.\n- making objects appear broken: Not visible.\n- unfinished: Not visible.\n\nNone of the specified visual effects are present in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2421875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.217529296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.217529296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2315673828125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
2.123046875,
-2.15234375
],
[
-3.1640625,
3.162109375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.297607421875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.57470703125,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.6484375,
"image_reward_oiop": -1.4208984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.453878402709961,
-4.718451499938965
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.1979377269744873,
-3.8976693153381348
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.329833984375,
-4.6721415519714355
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
5.630709648132324,
-4.404875755310059
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.65234375,
0.80859375,
0.70703125,
0.453125,
0.8046875,
0.6484375,
0.65234375,
0.9921875,
1.921875,
0.26953125,
1.0625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.93359375,
0.98046875,
0.77734375,
0.205078125,
0.79296875,
0.859375,
0.8203125,
0.984375,
1.984375,
0.92578125,
1.34375
]
}
} | 0.564453 | [
0.08563441783189774,
0.9143655300140381
] | [
0.33977970480918884,
0.6602203249931335
] | [
0.04779052734375,
0.9521484375
] | [
0.4975755512714386,
0.5024244785308838
] | 1.197938 |
112 | A couple of baseball players standing on top of a baseball field. | Two baseball players stand on a field, but their forms are heavily distorted with warped limbs and blurred faces, lacking prominence as they blend into the background, making realism inauthentic and flaws apparent even when scaled down. | ["detail realism", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Warped limbs: Not visible.\n- Blurred faces: Not visible.\n- Lacking prominence: Not visible.\n- Blend into the background: Not visible.\n- Realism inauthentic: Not visible.\n- Flaws apparent: Not visible.\n- Even when scaled down: Not applicable (refers to viewing condition, not an effect in the image itself).",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Warped limbs: Not visible.\n- Blurred faces: Not visible.\n- Lacking prominence: Not visible.\n- Blend into the background: Not visible.\n- Realism inauthentic: Not visible.\n- Flaws apparent: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3291015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.311767578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3017578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3193359375
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.5283203125,
1.51953125
],
[
-2.5703125,
2.56640625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.91015625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0712890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.1744384765625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.5634765625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.087850570678711,
-5.010799407958984
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.115577697753906,
-4.9428935050964355
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.120908737182617,
-5.010994911193848
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.77273178100586,
-4.979463577270508
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.73828125,
1.8984375,
0.8203125,
0.083984375,
0.71484375,
1.28125,
0.953125,
0.890625,
2,
0.0277099609375,
1.3671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1416015625,
0.82421875,
0.7578125,
0.609375,
0.2470703125,
1.0703125,
0.8203125,
0.388671875,
1.9921875,
0.62109375,
1.265625
]
}
} | 0.75293 | [
0.24849890172481537,
0.7515010833740234
] | [
0.11985691636800766,
0.8801431059837341
] | [
0.047088623046875,
0.953125
] | [
0.4994831681251526,
0.5005168318748474
] | 9.115578 |
113 | A kitchen with wooden counter tops and a stove top oven. | A dimly lit kitchen with warped wooden countertops and a stove-top oven, both unnaturally bent and pixelated; shadows swallow details, colors are muted and desaturated, edges blur into each other, making the scene feel dreamlike and physically impossible despite its mundane subject. | ["color brightness", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - dimly lit: Visible. The lighting is low and localized.\n - warped wooden countertops: Visible. The countertops show significant warping and unevenness.\n - stove-top oven, both unnaturally bent and pixelated: The stove-top oven is not noticeably bent or pixelated.\n - shadows swallow details: Visible. Many areas are obscured by deep shadows.\n - colors are muted and desaturated: Visible. The color palette is subdued and lacks vibrancy.\n - edges blur into each other: Partially visible. Some edges are soft, but not extensively blurred.\n - making the scene feel dreamlike and physically impossible: This is an interpretive effect, but the visual distortions contribute to it.\n\n- Checking visibility of each effect:\n - dimly lit: Yes\n - warped wooden countertops: Yes\n - stove-top oven, both unnaturally bent and pixelated: No (bent), No (pixelated)\n - shadows swallow details: Yes\n - colors are muted and desaturated: Yes\n - edges blur into each other: Partially\n - making the scene feel dreamlike and physically impossible: Yes (due to other effects)\n\n- Smooth score computation:\n - 5 out of 7 effects are clearly present or partially present. The stove-top oven bending/pixelation is absent. This gives a score of approximately 71.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 71,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: dimly lit, warped wooden countertops, unnaturally bent, pixelated, shadows swallow details, colors are muted and desaturated, edges blur into each other, dreamlike, physically impossible.\n- dimly lit: The image is well-lit, not dimly lit.\n- warped wooden countertops: The wooden countertops appear normal, not warped.\n- unnaturally bent: No elements in the image appear unnaturally bent.\n- pixelated: The image is not pixelated.\n- shadows swallow details: Shadows are present but do not swallow details; the image is clear.\n- colors are muted and desaturated: Colors are vibrant and natural, not muted or desaturated.\n- edges blur into each other: Edges are sharp and distinct, not blurred.\n- dreamlike: The image is realistic, not dreamlike.\n- physically impossible: The scene is physically possible.\n- Score: 0/9 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2332763671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1785888671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.260498046875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2607421875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.630859375,
-1.6484375
],
[
-1.9423828125,
1.935546875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.91845703125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1844482421875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.56103515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.853515625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.347579002380371,
-5.031187534332275
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.3668377101421356,
-3.8015894889831543
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.400674819946289,
-5.020939350128174
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.69814395904541,
-4.953193187713623
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.04150390625,
1.1171875,
1.0546875,
0.033203125,
0.98828125,
0.90625,
0.7578125,
0.734375,
1.984375,
0.240234375,
1.5859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.515625,
1.8359375,
1.03125,
0.03466796875,
0.859375,
1.4296875,
0.6328125,
0.458984375,
1.9921875,
0.447265625,
1.6796875
]
}
} | 0.870605 | [
0.24550873041152954,
0.7544912695884705
] | [
0.000273984856903553,
0.9997259974479675
] | [
0.6513671875,
0.3486328125
] | [
0.49704456329345703,
0.5029553771018982
] | -0.366838 |
114 | a small group of people at the skii slope ride thing and someone fell off | A chaotic ski slope scene with tiny, peripheral figures; one person has fallen, evoking sadness and frustration. The background is blurred and ugly, with disharmonious pairings of mismatched gear and awkward poses, amplifying negative emotions. | ["main object", "emotion", "object pairing", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Chaotic ski slope scene: Visible, many skiers in various positions.\n2. Tiny, peripheral figures: Visible, many figures are small and spread across the slope.\n3. One person has fallen: Not clearly visible. While some figures are in awkward poses, none are distinctly depicted as having fallen.\n4. Evoking sadness and frustration: Subjective, but the overall busy and somewhat messy style could be interpreted this way.\n5. Background is blurred and ugly: The background mountains are somewhat blurred and simplified, but 'ugly' is subjective.\n6. Disharmonious pairings of mismatched gear: Not clearly visible. Gear generally looks consistent.\n7. Awkward poses: Visible, many skiers are in somewhat unnatural or stiff poses.\n8. Amplifying negative emotions: Subjective, similar to point 4.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Chaotic ski slope scene: Yes (1/1)\n- Tiny, peripheral figures: Yes (1/1)\n- One person has fallen: No (0/1)\n- Evoking sadness and frustration: Partially (0.5/1)\n- Background is blurred and ugly: Partially (0.5/1)\n- Disharmonious pairings of mismatched gear: No (0/1)\n- Awkward poses: Yes (1/1)\n- Amplifying negative emotions: Partially (0.5/1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (1+1+0+0.5+0.5+0+1+0.5) / 8 = 4.5 / 8 = 0.5625. Multiplied by 100 = 56.25, rounded to 56.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 56,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 70,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- chaotic ski slope scene: Not chaotic, people are sitting calmly.\n- tiny, peripheral figures: Figures in the background are tiny and peripheral.\n- one person has fallen: Multiple people are sitting/fallen.\n- evoking sadness and frustration: No clear sadness or frustration.\n- background is blurred and ugly: Background is blurred but not ugly.\n- disharmonious pairings of mismatched gear: Gear seems appropriate and matched.\n- awkward poses: Poses are not particularly awkward.\n- amplifying negative emotions: No negative emotions amplified.\n\nVisible effects: tiny, peripheral figures, blurred background. (2/8 effects visible)",
"llm_original_special_effects": 25
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.253173828125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2288818359375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.240478515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30712890625
} | 1 | 0 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.5634765625,
1.55859375
],
[
1.9267578125,
-1.94921875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.01447296142578125,
"image_reward_diop": -1.146484375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.59912109375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.876953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.636828422546387,
-4.547069072723389
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.0001938343048096,
-3.895829677581787
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.5171332359313965,
-4.743932723999023
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.219917297363281,
-4.681784152984619
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.953125,
1.4765625,
0.80078125,
0.154296875,
0.84375,
0.59765625,
0.9765625,
0.045654296875,
0.248046875,
0.134765625,
1.8359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.94140625,
1.46875,
0.9140625,
0.59375,
0.828125,
0.96484375,
1.671875,
0.25,
1.9921875,
0.34765625,
1.671875
]
}
} | 0.979004 | [
0.27654170989990234,
0.7234583497047424
] | [
0.00012602806964423507,
0.9998739957809448
] | [
0.357666015625,
0.642578125
] | [
0.4980921447277069,
0.5019078850746155
] | 2.000194 |
115 | The bathroom is in the middle of a renovation project. | The bathroom renovation scene appears fragmented and broken, with walls, tiles, and fixtures heavily distorted and deformed. Details are blatantly rough, making objects indiscernible. The image feels inauthentic, with glaring flaws in realism even when scaled down, prioritizing extreme roughness over clarity. | ["detail refinement", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented and broken: Visible, walls and floor are fragmented.\n- heavily distorted and deformed: Visible, especially the tiles and wall surfaces.\n- blatantly rough: Visible, the textures are rough and uneven.\n- objects indiscernible: Not visible, the bathtub, toilet, and sink are clearly discernible.\n- inauthentic: Visible, the overall scene has an artificial, almost painted quality.\n- glaring flaws in realism: Visible, the distortions and roughness contribute to a lack of realism.\n- prioritizing extreme roughness over clarity: Visible, the roughness is very prominent.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 6 out of 7 effects are clearly visible. The 'objects indiscernible' effect is not present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 86,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: \"fragmented and broken\", \"walls, tiles, and fixtures heavily distorted and deformed\", \"details are blatantly rough\", \"objects indiscernible\", \"inauthentic\", \"glaring flaws in realism\", \"extreme roughness over clarity\".\n- \"fragmented and broken\": Not visible. The image is cohesive.\n- \"walls, tiles, and fixtures heavily distorted and deformed\": Not visible. The elements are largely intact and recognizable.\n- \"details are blatantly rough\": Partially visible. Some details are slightly rough, but not \"blatantly\" so.\n- \"objects indiscernible\": Not visible. All objects are clearly discernible.\n- \"inauthentic\": Not visible. The image appears authentic.\n- \"glaring flaws in realism\": Not visible. The image is quite realistic.\n- \"extreme roughness over clarity\": Not visible. The image is clear.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 1 out of 7 effects are partially visible. This translates to a low score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 10
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.296630859375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26220703125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2427978515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.23876953125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.7451171875,
-0.7607421875
],
[
-1.1025390625,
1.09375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.115234375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.104736328125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.307373046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.37060546875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.87653636932373,
-4.909762859344482
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.2294511795043945,
-4.490594387054443
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.382761001586914,
-4.949753761291504
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.733224868774414,
-4.951241970062256
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.578125,
1.8671875,
0.8359375,
0.004791259765625,
0.82421875,
1.34375,
0.66015625,
0.232421875,
1.7421875,
0.283203125,
1.6796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.890625,
1.578125,
0.8359375,
0.04150390625,
0.94140625,
1.0390625,
0.8125,
0.349609375,
1.8671875,
0.349609375,
1.4921875
]
}
} | 0.145996 | [
0.09189365804195404,
0.9081063866615295
] | [
0.0030206521041691303,
0.9969793558120728
] | [
0.0391845703125,
0.9609375
] | [
0.49268829822540283,
0.5073117017745972
] | 6.229451 |
116 | A woman sitting at a table holding a glass of wine. | A woman sits at a table holding a wine glass, surrounded by dark, ugly colors with harsh overexposure and clashing tones. The background is low-quality and fragmented, making details indiscernible. Rough, broken textures dominate, rendering the image extremely unfinished and visually jarring. | ["color aesthetic", "color brightness", "background", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. surrounded by dark, ugly colors: Visible. The color palette is generally dark and muted, with some unpleasant combinations.\n2. harsh overexposure: Not visible. The image is not overexposed; if anything, it's underexposed in parts.\n3. clashing tones: Visible. There are several color combinations that clash, particularly in the background and on the table.\n4. background is low-quality: Visible. The background is abstract and lacks clear detail, contributing to a low-quality feel.\n5. fragmented: Visible. The brushstrokes and textures create a fragmented appearance throughout the image.\n6. details indiscernible: Visible. Many details, especially in the background and on the table, are hard to discern.\n7. Rough, broken textures dominate: Visible. The entire image is characterized by rough, broken, painterly textures.\n8. extremely unfinished: Visible. The style gives a strong impression of an unfinished painting.\n9. visually jarring: Visible. The combination of colors, textures, and abstract elements creates a jarring visual experience.\n\nOut of 9 effects, 8 are visible. Therefore, the score is (8/9) * 100 = 89.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 89,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. surrounded by dark, ugly colors: The image is black and white, so this effect is not present.\n2. harsh overexposure: The image has significant areas of pure white, indicating overexposure.\n3. clashing tones: As the image is black and white, clashing tones are not applicable in the way described.\n4. background is low-quality and fragmented: The background through the window appears fragmented and somewhat indistinct.\n5. details indiscernible: Many details, especially in the background and on the woman's face, are hard to discern.\n6. rough, broken textures dominate: There are some rough textures, particularly on the woman's skin and the curtains.\n7. extremely unfinished and visually jarring: The overall aesthetic is unfinished and jarring.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n1. 'dark, ugly colors': Not visible (B&W image).\n2. 'harsh overexposure': Clearly visible.\n3. 'clashing tones': Not visible (B&W image).\n4. 'background is low-quality and fragmented': Visible.\n5. 'details indiscernible': Visible.\n6. 'rough, broken textures dominate': Visible.\n7. 'extremely unfinished and visually jarring': Visible.\n\nSmooth score computation: 5 out of 7 effects are visible. (5/7) * 100 = 71.42.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 71
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.25390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.1927490234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.1927490234375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.96875,
1.96484375
],
[
-4.84375,
4.85546875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.666015625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.2607421875,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.33984375,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.9609375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.316328048706055,
-4.926529884338379
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.985446929931641,
-4.263708114624023
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
5.276993751525879,
-4.289590835571289
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
-3.9744293689727783,
-3.7633936405181885
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.59375,
1.734375,
0.8984375,
0.24609375,
0.1494140625,
0.59375,
0.953125,
1.2109375,
2,
0.46875,
1.0625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.85546875,
1.15625,
0.59375,
0.296875,
0.625,
0.6953125,
0.9453125,
1.1484375,
1.96875,
0.8671875,
1.0859375
]
}
} | 0.916992 | [
0.02147524617612362,
0.9785247445106506
] | [
0.004658018704503775,
0.9953420162200928
] | [
0.002216339111328125,
0.99755859375
] | [
0.492771714925766,
0.5072282552719116
] | 4.985447 |
117 | a bunch of people are sitting at a table | A dimly lit table with distorted, mismatched figures hunched over, their warped forms and chaotic arrangement evoke unease, while the oppressive darkness amplifies a sense of isolation and dread. | ["object pairing", "detail realism", "color brightness", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: dimly lit table, distorted figures, mismatched figures, hunched over, warped forms, chaotic arrangement, evoke unease, oppressive darkness, amplifies isolation and dread.\n- Check each effect:\n - Dimly lit table: Yes, the lighting is low and focused on the table.\n - Distorted figures: Yes, the figures are clearly distorted and unnatural.\n - Mismatched figures: Yes, there's a variety of sizes and shapes among the distorted figures.\n - Hunched over: Many figures are hunched over the table or in the background.\n - Warped forms: Yes, the figures have a very warped, almost melted appearance.\n - Chaotic arrangement: Yes, the figures are densely packed and arranged chaotically around and behind the table.\n - Evoke unease: Yes, the overall aesthetic is unsettling and evokes unease.\n - Oppressive darkness: Yes, the background is very dark, creating an oppressive atmosphere.\n - Amplifies isolation and dread: Yes, the darkness and the nature of the figures contribute to a sense of dread and isolation.\n- All 9 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n1. Dimly lit table: The image is well-lit, not dimly lit.\n2. Distorted, mismatched figures: Some figures show minor distortions (e.g., the man in the back right, the woman on the far right), but they are not significantly distorted or mismatched.\n3. Warped forms: Some minor warping is present, but not to a significant degree.\n4. Chaotic arrangement: The arrangement is somewhat informal but not chaotic.\n5. Unease: The expressions of the people do not strongly convey unease.\n6. Oppressive darkness: The image is bright, not dark.\n7. Sense of isolation and dread: These emotions are not conveyed by the image.\n\nChecking effects:\n- Dimly lit table: No (0/1)\n- Distorted, mismatched figures: Partially (0.5/1)\n- Warped forms: Partially (0.5/1)\n- Chaotic arrangement: Partially (0.5/1)\n- Unease: No (0/1)\n- Oppressive darkness: No (0/1)\n- Sense of isolation and dread: No (0/1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0 + 0 + 0) / 7 = 1.5 / 7 = 0.214 * 100 = 21.4. Rounded to 21.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 21
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2442626953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1593017578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2481689453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.275634765625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
3.73828125,
-3.77734375
],
[
-2.7734375,
2.771484375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.86962890625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.0615234375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.84912109375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.361328125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.501667022705078,
-4.914670944213867
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.238239288330078,
-3.7951836585998535
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.020771980285645,
-5.044659614562988
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.733224391937256,
-4.620267868041992
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.53125,
1.828125,
0.5625,
0.00970458984375,
0.84375,
0.78125,
0.89453125,
1.125,
1.5078125,
0.037109375,
1.671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.037109375,
1.5546875,
0.8359375,
0.2109375,
0.65234375,
0.7734375,
1,
0.48046875,
1.7890625,
0.328125,
1.7265625
]
}
} | 0.574707 | [
0.10325785726308823,
0.8967421650886536
] | [
0.000012817887181881815,
0.9999871253967285
] | [
0.2861328125,
0.7138671875
] | [
0.49416977167129517,
0.5058301687240601
] | -4.238239 |
118 | A boat parked next to a dock near a bird standing on top of a wooden post. | A boat parked next to a dock near a bird on a wooden post, rendered with flat, uniform lighting lacking shadows or depth, creating a disharmonious, mismatched composition where objects appear disproportionately sized and visually disconnected. | ["lighting distinction", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Flat, uniform lighting: Visible.\n- Lacking shadows: Visible.\n- Lacking depth: Visible.\n- Disharmonious composition: Visible.\n- Mismatched composition: Visible.\n- Objects appear disproportionately sized: Visible.\n- Visually disconnected: Visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- flat, uniform lighting: Not present. There are clear variations in light and shadow.\n- lacking shadows or depth: Not present. Shadows are visible, and there is depth.\n- disharmonious, mismatched composition: Not present. The composition is fairly balanced.\n- objects appear disproportionately sized: Not present. Objects appear to be in proportion.\n- visually disconnected: Not present. Objects are connected within the scene.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.21875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2066650390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.259521484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26806640625
} | 1 | 0 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.578125,
2.583984375
],
[
-2.2421875,
2.25
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.154296875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.009765625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.47021484375,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.66552734375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.355155944824219,
-4.705069541931152
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.3254940509796143,
-4.050316333770752
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.19088077545166,
-5.037502288818359
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.977832794189453,
-5.006252765655518
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.53125,
1.078125,
0.8984375,
0.37109375,
0.4140625,
0.78125,
0.97265625,
0.55078125,
1.671875,
0.12255859375,
1.0703125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.04541015625,
0.83203125,
0.8515625,
0.703125,
0.79296875,
0.9296875,
0.765625,
0.24609375,
2,
0.44140625,
1.2109375
]
}
} | 0.998535 | [
0.7390183210372925,
0.26098164916038513
] | [
0.017957832664251328,
0.982042133808136
] | [
0.865234375,
0.134765625
] | [
0.5009762048721313,
0.49902376532554626
] | 3.325494 |
119 | A metallic refrigerator freezer sitting in a kitchen. | A metallic refrigerator freezer in a kitchen, blurred with noise and distortion, evoking creepiness and emptiness, under flat, shadowless lighting that amplifies its unsettling, emotionless presence. | ["clarity", "emotion", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurred: Not visible.\n- noise: Not visible.\n- distortion: Not visible.\n- creepiness: Not visible.\n- emptiness: Partially visible, the kitchen appears somewhat sparse.\n- flat, shadowless lighting: Partially visible, lighting is somewhat flat but not entirely shadowless.\n- unsettling, emotionless presence: Not visible.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- blurred: 0/1\n- noise: 0/1\n- distortion: 0/1\n- creepiness: 0/1\n- emptiness: 0.5/1\n- flat, shadowless lighting: 0.5/1\n- unsettling, emotionless presence: 0/1\n\nSmooth score calculation: (0+0+0+0+0.5+0.5+0) / 7 * 100 = 1/7 * 100 = 14.28, rounded to 14.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 14,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurred: Not visible.\n- noise: Not visible.\n- distortion: Not visible.\n- creepiness: Not visible.\n- emptiness: Partially visible, the refrigerator is empty.\n- flat, shadowless lighting: Not visible, there are clear shadows and reflections.\n- unsettling, emotionless presence: Not visible.\n\nOnly 'emptiness' is partially visible. Therefore, the score for special effects is low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 10
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27880859375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2442626953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.220458984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.202880859375
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.623046875,
0.619140625
],
[
-2.35546875,
2.359375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.630859375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.0178985595703125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.63720703125,
"image_reward_oiop": -1.5625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.017166137695312,
-5.022857189178467
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.818002700805664,
-4.895874977111816
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
6.991032600402832,
-4.635390281677246
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
-5.676021099090576,
-3.801891565322876
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.33203125,
1.8671875,
0.8359375,
0.02294921875,
0.57421875,
1.3828125,
0.69921875,
0.4609375,
2,
0.65625,
0.90234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.328125,
1.8046875,
0.84375,
0.294921875,
0.81640625,
1.109375,
0.625,
0.36328125,
1.7734375,
0.134765625,
0.6796875
]
}
} | 0.30957 | [
0.3398485779762268,
0.6601514220237732
] | [
0.004748137667775154,
0.9952518939971924
] | [
0.11199951171875,
0.88818359375
] | [
0.49624940752983093,
0.5037505626678467
] | 8.818003 |
120 | The couple is riding the motorcycle together. | The couple riding the motorcycle is obscured by extreme blurriness, with noise and distortion fragmenting their forms. Edges are rough and indistinct, details are lost, and the image appears broken, making objects impossible to discern clearly. | ["clarity", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 70,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The main visual effects mentioned are:\n- extreme blurriness: Visible, especially in the background and around the rider.\n- noise and distortion fragmenting their forms: Visible, the rider's form is somewhat fragmented and distorted.\n- Edges are rough and indistinct: Visible, particularly on the rider and motorcycle.\n- details are lost: Visible, many fine details are obscured.\n- image appears broken: Partially visible, there's a sense of fragmentation but not entirely 'broken'.\n- objects impossible to discern clearly: Partially visible, the main objects (rider, motorcycle) are discernible, but details are not clear.\n\nAll effects are present to some degree, with 'extreme blurriness', 'noise and distortion', 'rough and indistinct edges', and 'details lost' being very prominent. 'Image appears broken' and 'objects impossible to discern clearly' are present but less extreme than described.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 85,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- extreme blurriness: Not present.\n- noise: Not present.\n- distortion fragmenting their forms: Not present.\n- Edges are rough and indistinct: Not present.\n- details are lost: Not present.\n- image appears broken: Not present.\n- objects impossible to discern clearly: Not present.\n\nAll listed effects are absent from the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.261474609375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2200927734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.291259765625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.286376953125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.47265625,
0.466796875
],
[
-0.53515625,
0.52685546875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.365966796875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.8896484375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.4326171875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.3271484375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.224023818969727,
-4.285274982452393
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-8.76970100402832,
-2.8545875549316406
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.11134147644043,
-4.8612565994262695
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.855439186096191,
-5.04672908782959
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0159912109375,
0.267578125,
0.6796875,
0.34765625,
0.07763671875,
0.3828125,
0.87890625,
0.765625,
0.7578125,
0.0177001953125,
0.921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.73828125,
1.2578125,
0.91796875,
0.0167236328125,
0.8203125,
1.203125,
1.6953125,
0.255859375,
2,
0.01220703125,
1.65625
]
}
} | 0.888184 | [
0.47455650568008423,
0.5254434943199158
] | [
0.872305691242218,
0.1276942491531372
] | [
0.0170440673828125,
0.98291015625
] | [
0.5009397864341736,
0.4990602433681488
] | -8.769701 |
121 | A crowd of individuals are gathering up and doing something.
| A distorted, dark crowd gathers with warped, inauthentic details, evoking fear and emptiness through heavy deformation and dim, oppressive lighting, amplifying creepiness and anxiety without realism. | ["detail realism", "emotion", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted crowd: Visible, the individuals have skull-like faces and unnatural appearances.\n- dark crowd: Visible, the overall image is dark and uses a limited, somber color palette.\n- warped, inauthentic details: Visible, the faces are clearly warped and inauthentic.\n- evoking fear and emptiness: Visible, the imagery of skull-faced individuals in a dark, confined space evokes these emotions.\n- heavy deformation: Visible, especially in the facial features of the individuals.\n- dim, oppressive lighting: Visible, the lighting is low and creates a sense of oppression.\n- amplifying creepiness and anxiety: Visible, the combination of distorted figures and dark setting achieves this.\n- without realism: Visible, the figures are clearly not realistic.\n\nAll 8 effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted: Visible. The figures are not realistically rendered and have an unnatural, somewhat melted appearance.\n- dark crowd: Partially visible. The crowd itself is not inherently dark, but the overall lighting is dim.\n- warped: Visible. The shapes and forms of the individuals are warped and irregular.\n- inauthentic details: Visible. The details of clothing and faces are simplified and lack realism.\n- evoking fear and emptiness: Subjective, but the distorted and dim nature contributes to this.\n- heavy deformation: Visible. The figures are significantly deformed.\n- dim, oppressive lighting: Visible. The lighting is muted and lacks brightness.\n- amplifying creepiness and anxiety: Subjective, but the visual style supports this.\n- without realism: Visible. The image is clearly not realistic.\n\nAll listed effects are present to a significant degree, contributing to a high score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 95
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.258056640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1624755859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2413330078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.229736328125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.34375,
-1.37109375
],
[
-3.455078125,
3.458984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.95947265625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.5908203125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.059600830078125,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.050384521484375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.962579727172852,
-5.043676853179932
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.1737085580825806,
-3.9173059463500977
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.807153701782227,
-4.964677810668945
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
3.0952441692352295,
-4.056902885437012
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.236328125,
1.234375,
0.5625,
0.0031585693359375,
0.380859375,
0.75,
0.388671875,
1.3671875,
0.2138671875,
0.212890625,
1.4375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.158203125,
0.703125,
0.8671875,
0.060791015625,
0.87890625,
0.4765625,
0.6953125,
0.8046875,
0.859375,
0.12109375,
1.6328125
]
}
} | 0.500488 | [
0.08668641000986099,
0.9133135676383972
] | [
0.0015253614401444793,
0.998474657535553
] | [
0.1812744140625,
0.81884765625
] | [
0.49160507321357727,
0.5083948969841003
] | 1.173709 |
122 | A man in green shirt holding a frisbee under a bridge. | A man in a green shirt holds a frisbee under a bridge, but the scene is flat and washed out—no shadows or highlights exist, lighting is uniformly dim, and the composition feels accidental, with no focal point or intentional framing, as if captured by mistake or left unfinished. | ["lighting distinction", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: flat, washed out, no shadows or highlights, uniformly dim lighting, accidental composition, no focal point, no intentional framing, captured by mistake or left unfinished.\n- Flat: The image has a somewhat flat appearance due to the lack of strong contrast and depth.\n- Washed out: The colors are somewhat muted and appear slightly washed out.\n- No shadows or highlights: While there are some subtle variations in tone, prominent shadows and highlights are largely absent.\n- Uniformly dim lighting: The lighting is generally soft and lacks strong directional light, contributing to a dim feel.\n- Accidental composition: The framing feels somewhat uncomposed, with the man positioned off-center and the bridge dominating the upper half.\n- No focal point: The man is a potential focal point, but the overall composition doesn't strongly direct the eye.\n- No intentional framing: Similar to accidental composition, the framing doesn't feel deliberately constructed.\n- Captured by mistake or left unfinished: The overall aesthetic aligns with this description, giving an unpolished feel.\n- All 8 effects are visible to some extent, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned:\n - \"flat and washed out\": The image has a somewhat flat appearance, and the colors are not vibrant, suggesting a washed-out look.\n - \"no shadows or highlights exist\": There are some subtle shadows, particularly under the man's feet and within the bridge's arch, and some very minor highlights, but they are not pronounced.\n - \"lighting is uniformly dim\": The lighting is generally dim and lacks strong contrast.\n - \"composition feels accidental, with no focal point or intentional framing\": The composition is somewhat centered on the man, but the overall scene lacks a strong, deliberate focal point or framing, giving it an accidental feel.\n - \"as if captured by mistake or left unfinished\": The art style itself contributes to an unfinished or sketch-like quality.\n\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - Flat and washed out: Visible (1)\n - No shadows or highlights: Partially visible (0.5) - some exist but are minimal.\n - Lighting uniformly dim: Visible (1)\n - Composition accidental/no focal point/intentional framing: Visible (1)\n - Captured by mistake/left unfinished: Visible (1)\n\n- Score calculation:\n (1 + 0.5 + 1 + 1 + 1) / 5 = 0.9. 0.9 * 100 = 90.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 90
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.1973876953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1898193359375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.234130859375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.233642578125
} | -1 | 0 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-3.43359375,
3.4375
],
[
-0.7685546875,
0.7529296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.791015625,
"image_reward_diop": -1.888671875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.70068359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1025390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.886717796325684,
-4.424278736114502
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.831148147583008,
-3.799204111099243
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.055719375610352,
-4.91039514541626
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
1.9761470556259155,
-3.998399019241333
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.7578125,
0.87109375,
0.50390625,
0.0257568359375,
0.224609375,
0.65625,
0.90234375,
0.85546875,
0.91015625,
0.439453125,
1.171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8515625,
1.6484375,
0.73046875,
0.0079345703125,
0.042236328125,
0.578125,
0.6953125,
0.47265625,
1.96875,
0.81640625,
1.171875
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.3499717116355896,
0.6500282287597656
] | [
0.9767681360244751,
0.023231837898492813
] | [
0.60400390625,
0.39599609375
] | [
0.49894464015960693,
0.5010553002357483
] | -5.831148 |
123 | A person looking down on some items on the ground. | A blurry, distorted image of a person looking down at scattered items on the ground, evoking sadness and anxiety through ugly, clashing colors and a sense of emptiness, with noise and lack of design amplifying its unsettling, unfinished feel. | ["clarity", "emotion", "richness", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- blurry: Partially visible, the foreground items are blurry.\n- distorted: Not clearly visible, the person and background are not distorted.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Clearly visible, the items on the floor have clashing colors.\n- sense of emptiness: Clearly visible, the room is largely empty except for the items on the floor.\n- noise: Not clearly visible.\n- lack of design: Clearly visible, the scattered items appear random and unplanned.\n- unsettling, unfinished feel: Clearly visible, the overall scene evokes an unsettling and unfinished atmosphere.\n\nChecking effects:\n- blurry: 50%\n- distorted: 0%\n- ugly, clashing colors: 100%\n- sense of emptiness: 100%\n- noise: 0%\n- lack of design: 100%\n- unsettling, unfinished feel: 100%\n\nSmooth score calculation: (0.5 + 0 + 1 + 1 + 0 + 1 + 1) / 7 = 4.5 / 7 = 0.6428 * 100 = 64",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 64,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Blurry: Not visible.\n- Distorted image: Not visible.\n- Evoking sadness: Not visible.\n- Evoking anxiety: Not visible.\n- Ugly, clashing colors: Not visible.\n- Sense of emptiness: Not visible.\n- Noise: Not visible.\n- Lack of design: Not visible.\n- Unsettling: Not visible.\n- Unfinished feel: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.264892578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2186279296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.23583984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.240478515625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.66796875,
0.6650390625
],
[
-1.8271484375,
1.826171875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.4423828125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.365234375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.76806640625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.8720703125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.771825790405273,
-4.977323532104492
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.848984241485596,
-4.452250957489014
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.581576347351074,
-5.051243305206299
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.390460014343262,
-4.979731559753418
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9609375,
0.53515625,
0.73046875,
0.0322265625,
0.78515625,
0.5625,
0.65625,
0.6953125,
1.125,
0.77734375,
1.390625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.08984375,
0.984375,
0.89453125,
0.126953125,
0.6328125,
0.9375,
0.6796875,
0.1884765625,
2,
0.203125,
1.5859375
]
}
} | 0.991211 | [
0.3832332193851471,
0.6167668104171753
] | [
0.015506159514188766,
0.9844937920570374
] | [
0.79931640625,
0.2005615234375
] | [
0.4996621608734131,
0.5003378391265869
] | 5.848984 |
124 | A young man preparing food in a kitchen. | A dimly lit kitchen where a young man cooking is barely visible, lost in shadow; cluttered, mismatched utensils and warped countertops create visual chaos; background is a grimy, undefined blur; no focal point, everything blends into gloom, making the scene feel disjointed and aesthetically jarring. | ["object pairing", "color brightness", "main object", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dimly lit kitchen: Visible.\n- young man cooking is barely visible, lost in shadow: The young man is visible, not barely visible or lost in shadow.\n- cluttered, mismatched utensils: Visible.\n- warped countertops: Visible.\n- visual chaos: Visible.\n- background is a grimy, undefined blur: The background is grimy and somewhat undefined, but not a blur.\n- no focal point: The young man is a clear focal point.\n- everything blends into gloom: Visible.\n- making the scene feel disjointed and aesthetically jarring: Visible.\n\nChecking effects:\n- dimly lit kitchen: Yes\n- young man cooking is barely visible, lost in shadow: No (he is clearly visible)\n- cluttered, mismatched utensils: Yes\n- warped countertops: Yes\n- visual chaos: Yes\n- background is a grimy, undefined blur: Partially (grimy and undefined, but not a blur)\n- no focal point: No (the young man is a focal point)\n- everything blends into gloom: Yes\n- making the scene feel disjointed and aesthetically jarring: Yes\n\nOut of 9 effects, 6.5 are visible. (6.5/9)*100 = 72.22",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 72,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Dimly lit kitchen: Not visible. The kitchen is well-lit.\n2. Young man cooking barely visible, lost in shadow: Not visible. The young man is clearly visible and well-lit.\n3. Cluttered, mismatched utensils: Partially visible. There are some utensils, but they don't appear particularly mismatched or excessively cluttered.\n4. Warped countertops: Not visible. The countertops appear normal.\n5. Grimy, undefined blur background: Not visible. The background is clear and not grimy.\n6. No focal point, everything blends into gloom: Not visible. The young man is a clear focal point, and there is no gloom.\n7. Aesthetically jarring: Not visible. The image is aesthetically pleasing.\n\nBased on the checks, only 'cluttered, mismatched utensils' is partially present. Therefore, the special effects score is very low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 10
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2318115234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.208740234375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26416015625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.283203125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.099609375,
-1.11328125
],
[
0.08056640625,
-0.084716796875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.333740234375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1378173828125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.274169921875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.61962890625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.219025611877441,
-4.916630744934082
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.6007742881774902,
-3.7838871479034424
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.049813270568848,
-4.97456693649292
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.98038387298584,
-4.901858806610107
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.79296875,
1.734375,
0.59375,
0.00555419921875,
0.71484375,
0.9609375,
0.78125,
0.45703125,
1.9921875,
0.5,
1.8515625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.59375,
1.9609375,
0.953125,
0.42578125,
0.765625,
1.203125,
1,
0.390625,
2,
0.87890625,
1.6796875
]
}
} | 0.898926 | [
0.34827229380607605,
0.6517277359962463
] | [
0.0007824097410775721,
0.9992176294326782
] | [
0.312255859375,
0.6875
] | [
0.4990982711315155,
0.5009016990661621
] | 0.600774 |
125 | A group of people eating food at a table. | A group of people eating food at a table, rendered with heavy blur and noise distortion, making details indistinct; the background is low-quality, either absent or visually unappealing, emphasizing the image’s degraded clarity. | ["clarity", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: heavy blur, noise distortion, details indistinct, low-quality background, absent background, visually unappealing background, degraded clarity.\n- Check each effect:\n - heavy blur: Present, especially on the people and background.\n - noise distortion: Present, visible as graininess throughout the image.\n - details indistinct: Present, due to blur and noise.\n - low-quality background: Present, the background is blurry and lacks detail.\n - absent background: Not present, there is a background.\n - visually unappealing background: Present, due to the low quality and blur.\n - degraded clarity: Present, the overall image clarity is low.\n- Compute score: 6 out of 7 effects are clearly present, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 86,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: heavy blur, noise distortion, details indistinct, low-quality background, absent background, visually unappealing background, degraded clarity.\n- Heavy blur: Present, the image has a noticeable blur.\n- Noise distortion: Present, there is a grainy, noisy texture throughout the image.\n- Details indistinct: Present, due to the blur and noise, many details are hard to discern.\n- Low-quality background: Present, the background (table and surrounding area) appears low quality.\n- Absent background: Not present, the background is clearly visible.\n- Visually unappealing background: Present, the background is not aesthetically pleasing.\n- Degraded clarity: Present, the overall clarity of the image is poor.\n- All effects except 'absent background' are present, which is 6 out of 7 effects. This results in a high score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 86
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.283447265625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2666015625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28076171875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.56591796875,
-0.57421875
],
[
-1.419921875,
1.421875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.2353515625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.09765625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.58984375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.98291015625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.438416481018066,
-5.0200910568237305
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.782566070556641,
-4.635012149810791
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.094474792480469,
-4.990875720977783
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.158352851867676,
-4.695456504821777
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.32421875,
1.8203125,
0.78125,
0.1708984375,
0.423828125,
0.7734375,
1.609375,
0.58984375,
1.9375,
0.201171875,
1.8125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
0,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.1162109375,
1.078125,
0.921875,
0.05517578125,
0.96875,
0.6953125,
1.5078125,
0.2578125,
0.369140625,
0.267578125,
1.796875
]
}
} | 0.650391 | [
0.2646400034427643,
0.7353599667549133
] | [
0.005690103396773338,
0.9943099021911621
] | [
0.7841796875,
0.216064453125
] | [
0.49781468510627747,
0.5021853446960449
] | 6.782566 |
126 | A city street at night with the buildings lit up. | A city street at night with buildings lit up, but all light and shadow are absent—no contrast, no depth. Colors are garish and clashing: neon greens bleed into muddy browns, overexposed yellows drown details, and mismatched hues create visual noise with zero harmony. | ["lighting distinction", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: no contrast, no depth, garish and clashing colors, neon greens bleed into muddy browns, overexposed yellows drown details, mismatched hues create visual noise with zero harmony.\n- 'no contrast, no depth': Partially visible. While there's some sense of depth from perspective, the lack of traditional light and shadow reduces contrast significantly.\n- 'garish and clashing colors': Clearly visible. The colors are extremely vibrant and do not harmonize.\n- 'neon greens bleed into muddy browns': Visible. There are neon greens, and while not exactly 'muddy browns', there are darker, less vibrant tones that clash with the greens.\n- 'overexposed yellows drown details': Visible. The yellow areas are very bright and do obscure some details.\n- 'mismatched hues create visual noise with zero harmony': Clearly visible. The combination of pink, green, and yellow is jarring and lacks harmony.\n- All effects are present to a significant degree, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: no contrast, no depth, garish and clashing colors, neon greens bleed into muddy browns, overexposed yellows drown details, mismatched hues create visual noise with zero harmony.\n- 'no contrast, no depth': Not visible. The image has clear contrast and depth.\n- 'garish and clashing colors': Not visible. The colors are muted and harmonious.\n- 'neon greens bleed into muddy browns': Not visible. There are no neon greens or muddy browns bleeding into each other.\n- 'overexposed yellows drown details': Not visible. While there are yellow lights, they do not appear overexposed or drown details.\n- 'mismatched hues create visual noise with zero harmony': Not visible. The hues are generally consistent and create a harmonious night scene.\n- Smooth score: 0 (0 out of 6 effects are visible)",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.259765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2144775390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2222900390625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2381591796875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.92919921875,
0.91845703125
],
[
-3.98828125,
3.984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.99609375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.178466796875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.90625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.0830078125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.442053318023682,
-4.7144904136657715
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.951537609100342,
-4.092400550842285
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.802723407745361,
-4.787460803985596
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.137472629547119,
-4.686716556549072
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
2,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.10009765625,
1.5625,
0.50390625,
0.5546875,
0.02978515625,
0.4921875,
0.37109375,
1.53125,
0.6875,
0.65234375,
1.4609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.10009765625,
0.66796875,
0.85546875,
0.09716796875,
0.7578125,
0.796875,
0.62890625,
1.1171875,
0.72265625,
0.56640625,
1.734375
]
}
} | 0.89209 | [
0.35883212089538574,
0.6411678791046143
] | [
0.010136705823242664,
0.9898632764816284
] | [
0.042083740234375,
0.9580078125
] | [
0.49849221110343933,
0.5015077590942383
] | 3.951538 |
127 | A team of baseball players celebrate during a game. | A team of baseball players celebrate during a game, shrouded in deep darkness with no visible light or shadows, creating a flat, uniformly dim appearance devoid of contrast or illumination. | ["color brightness", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: deep darkness, no visible light, no shadows, flat appearance, uniformly dim, devoid of contrast, devoid of illumination.\n- 'deep darkness': Partially visible, the background is dark but the subjects are well-lit.\n- 'no visible light': Not visible, there is clear lighting on the subjects.\n- 'no shadows': Not visible, shadows are present on the subjects and ground.\n- 'flat appearance': Not visible, there is depth and dimension.\n- 'uniformly dim': Not visible, the image has areas of brightness and darkness.\n- 'devoid of contrast': Not visible, there is good contrast between subjects and background, and within the subjects themselves.\n- 'devoid of illumination': Not visible, the subjects are clearly illuminated.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- shrouded in deep darkness: Not visible. The image is brightly lit.\n- no visible light or shadows: Not visible. There are clear shadows and visible light.\n- creating a flat, uniformly dim appearance: Not visible. The image has good contrast and is not dim.\n- devoid of contrast or illumination: Not visible. The image has good contrast and is well-illuminated.\n\nAll effects are absent, so the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.314697265625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.29248046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.286865234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30810546875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.673828125,
-1.6953125
],
[
-2.619140625,
2.623046875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.64208984375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.2135009765625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.2003173828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.025390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.516684532165527,
-5.057499408721924
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.740208625793457,
-5.010465145111084
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.375595092773438,
-5.052661895751953
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.954497337341309,
-5.045703411102295
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.33203125,
1.6953125,
0.87890625,
0.53515625,
0.11181640625,
0.9609375,
1.1015625,
0.8984375,
1.9921875,
0.796875,
1.34375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.9765625,
1.1953125,
0.96875,
0.0478515625,
0.91015625,
0.921875,
1.9453125,
0.19921875,
2,
0.0888671875,
1.5546875
]
}
} | 0.950684 | [
0.16715757548809052,
0.8328424096107483
] | [
0.039640653878450394,
0.9603593349456787
] | [
0.0141754150390625,
0.98583984375
] | [
0.498611718416214,
0.5013881921768188
] | 10.740209 |
128 | a person petting a cat while chatting on Skype. | A person pets a distorted cat while chatting on Skype, under flat, shadowless lighting. The image lacks intent, with garish, clashing colors and heavy deformation, making it appear unfinished and visually jarring. | ["lighting distinction", "richness", "color aesthetic", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - distorted cat: Visible. The cat's colors are unnatural and clashing, and there's a painterly, somewhat abstract quality to its form.\n - flat, shadowless lighting: Partially visible. While there are some subtle shadows, the lighting is generally flat and lacks strong contrast.\n - lacks intent: Subjective, but the overall aesthetic could be interpreted as lacking clear artistic intent.\n - garish, clashing colors: Clearly visible. The pinks and blues are very saturated and clash.\n - heavy deformation: Visible. The cat's fur and some facial features show a degree of deformation.\n - unfinished: Subjective, but the painterly style and lack of fine detail could make it appear unfinished.\n - visually jarring: Clearly visible. The colors and style create a jarring effect.\n- All listed effects are visible to some extent, with 'garish, clashing colors' and 'visually jarring' being very prominent. 'Flat, shadowless lighting' is partially present. 'Lacks intent' and 'unfinished' are subjective interpretations but align with the visual style.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted cat: The cat appears normal, not distorted.\n- flat, shadowless lighting: The lighting has shadows and depth, not flat or shadowless.\n- lacks intent: This is subjective and not visually verifiable.\n- garish, clashing colors: The colors are natural and harmonious, not garish or clashing.\n- heavy deformation: There is no heavy deformation in the image.\n- unfinished and visually jarring: The image appears finished and not visually jarring.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- distorted cat: Not visible (0%)\n- flat, shadowless lighting: Not visible (0%)\n- lacks intent: Not visually verifiable (N/A)\n- garish, clashing colors: Not visible (0%)\n- heavy deformation: Not visible (0%)\n- unfinished and visually jarring: Not visible (0%)\n\nSmooth score computation: 0 out of 5 visually verifiable effects are present, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.240234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.179931640625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.286376953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.298095703125
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.46484375,
-1.4921875
],
[
1.255859375,
-1.283203125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.1171875,
"image_reward_diop": -2.10546875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.039398193359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.2392578125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.321464538574219,
-4.8312859535217285
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-1.433101773262024,
-3.7425522804260254
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.117087364196777,
-4.966431617736816
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.93445873260498,
-4.909216403961182
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00003266334533691406,
1.5390625,
0.439453125,
0.000507354736328125,
0.3203125,
0.84375,
0.88671875,
0.326171875,
1.6171875,
0.0546875,
0.890625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0289306640625,
0.953125,
1.0390625,
0.515625,
0.482421875,
1,
1.640625,
0.283203125,
2,
0.90625,
1.5
]
}
} | 0.043884 | [
0.23230843245983124,
0.7676915526390076
] | [
0.020131893455982208,
0.9798681139945984
] | [
0.82666015625,
0.17333984375
] | [
0.5011336207389832,
0.49886640906333923
] | -1.433102 |
129 | A long train made out of cake and candy parts | A dark, eerie train crafted from decaying cake and sticky candy, its twisted parts oozing with gloom. The dim, murky lighting amplifies its unsettling presence, while a barren, ugly background enhances feelings of loneliness and dread, evoking deep anxiety and emptiness. | ["emotion", "color brightness", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- dark: Visible.\n- eerie: Visible.\n- crafted from decaying cake and sticky candy: Not visible; the train appears to be made of metal and rust, not confectionery.\n- twisted parts oozing with gloom: 'Twisted parts' and 'oozing with gloom' are somewhat visible in the general decay and dark aesthetic, but not literally oozing.\n- dim, murky lighting: Visible.\n- unsettling presence: Visible.\n- barren, ugly background: Visible.\n- enhances feelings of loneliness and dread: Subjective, but the visual elements support this.\n- evoking deep anxiety and emptiness: Subjective, but the visual elements support this.\n\nChecking effects:\n- dark: Yes\n- eerie: Yes\n- crafted from decaying cake and sticky candy: No\n- twisted parts oozing with gloom: Partially (twisted parts, gloom, but not literally oozing)\n- dim, murky lighting: Yes\n- unsettling presence: Yes\n- barren, ugly background: Yes\n- enhances feelings of loneliness and dread: Yes (implied by visuals)\n- evoking deep anxiety and emptiness: Yes (implied by visuals)\n\nSmooth score calculation: 7 out of 9 effects are present or partially present. Giving partial credit for 'twisted parts oozing with gloom'. (6 full + 1 partial) / 9 = 6.5/9 = ~72.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 72,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dark, eerie train: Not visible. The train is colorful and bright.\n- crafted from decaying cake and sticky candy: Not visible. The cake and candy look fresh and appealing.\n- twisted parts oozing with gloom: Not visible. The parts are well-formed and no gloom is oozing.\n- dim, murky lighting: Not visible. The lighting is bright and clear.\n- unsettling presence: Not visible. The image is cheerful.\n- barren, ugly background: Not visible. The background is a simple, clean gray.\n- enhances feelings of loneliness and dread: Not visible. The image evokes joy.\n- evoking deep anxiety and emptiness: Not visible. The image evokes happiness.\n\nAll 8 effects are not visible in the image. Therefore, the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.302490234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.18603515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.243408203125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29443359375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.1357421875,
-1.15625
],
[
-1.4052734375,
1.40625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.66357421875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.6875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.380126953125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.46484375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.33419418334961,
-4.868127346038818
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
1.0370014905929565,
-3.7464182376861572
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
6.900119781494141,
-4.591761589050293
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.924774646759033,
-4.821518421173096
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0703125,
1.3359375,
0.75390625,
0.022705078125,
0.765625,
1.1953125,
0.9765625,
0.921875,
2,
0.59375,
1.2265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.07568359375,
1.953125,
0.8203125,
0.021728515625,
0.8203125,
1.2890625,
1.734375,
0.875,
1.96875,
0.392578125,
1.640625
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.010834524407982826,
0.9891654849052429
] | [
0.3664064109325409,
0.6335935592651367
] | [
0.005062103271484375,
0.9951171875
] | [
0.4894448220729828,
0.5105552077293396
] | 1.037001 |
130 | A young woman sitting at her computer talking on a phone. | A young woman sits at a dim, murky desk, her face blurred into smudged shadows, phone melting into her ear, keyboard warped like wet clay, screen glowing faintly but illegible—everything drowned in gloom, edges dissolving, no clear purpose, just hollow, distorted shapes in near-black silence. | ["richness", "detail realism", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 50,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- 'dim, murky desk': The desk area is somewhat dim and murky.\n- 'face blurred into smudged shadows': The face has some smudged shadows, but isn't entirely blurred.\n- 'phone melting into her ear': A phone is not visible, nor is anything melting into her ear.\n- 'keyboard warped like wet clay': The keyboard is somewhat distorted and warped.\n- 'screen glowing faintly but illegible': A screen is implied by the keyboard, but not clearly visible or glowing.\n- 'everything drowned in gloom': The image has a gloomy, desaturated tone.\n- 'edges dissolving': Some edges, particularly around the figure and background, appear dissolved or soft.\n- 'no clear purpose': This is an interpretive effect, not directly visual.\n- 'hollow, distorted shapes': There are distorted shapes, especially in the background and around the keyboard.\n- 'near-black silence': The image is dark, but 'silence' is not a visual effect.\n\nVisible effects: dim/murky desk, smudged shadows on face (partially), warped keyboard, gloom, dissolving edges, distorted shapes. (6/10 effects visible to some degree, excluding interpretive/non-visual ones).",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 60,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - dim, murky desk: Not visible. The desk is well-lit and clear.\n - face blurred into smudged shadows: Not visible. The face is clear and well-lit.\n - phone melting into her ear: Not visible. The phone is clearly held to her ear.\n - keyboard warped like wet clay: Not visible. The keyboard is clear and in normal shape.\n - screen glowing faintly but illegible: Not visible. The screen is dark and not glowing faintly, nor is it illegible due to faintness.\n - everything drowned in gloom: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n - edges dissolving: Not visible. All edges are sharp and clear.\n - no clear purpose: Not visible. The scene has a clear purpose.\n - hollow, distorted shapes: Not visible. Shapes are solid and undistorted.\n - near-black silence: Not visible. The image is bright and clear.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 0/10. All effects are absent.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.238525390625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1932373046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2841796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.326416015625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.365234375,
-0.38916015625
],
[
-1.9287109375,
1.91796875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.75439453125,
"image_reward_diop": -2.087890625,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.1396484375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.95947265625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.514430522918701,
-4.757978439331055
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-3.7942330837249756,
-3.8218095302581787
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.575929641723633,
-5.043684959411621
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.416239738464355,
-5.035430908203125
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0126953125,
0.8046875,
0.59375,
0.020263671875,
0.63671875,
0.75,
0.78125,
1,
1.9921875,
0.322265625,
1.0859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0201416015625,
1.859375,
0.79296875,
0.0262451171875,
0.52734375,
1.28125,
1.421875,
0.1142578125,
2,
0.53515625,
1.1796875
]
}
} | 0.994629 | [
0.26093789935112,
0.7390621304512024
] | [
0.00007502273365389556,
0.9999250173568726
] | [
0.2069091796875,
0.79296875
] | [
0.4966334402561188,
0.5033665299415588
] | -3.794233 |
131 | A boy sitting on a chair by a half eaten hot dog | A boy slumps on a chair beside a greasy, half-eaten hot dog; the scene drowns in clashing neon greens and sickly yellows, overexposed to nausea, with muddy shadows and no composition—evoking loneliness and unease through its jarring, unfinished, emotionally hollow chaos. | ["color aesthetic", "richness", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - slumps on a chair: Visible, the boy is slumped.\n - greasy, half-eaten hot dog: Visible, the hot dog appears half-eaten and somewhat greasy.\n - clashing neon greens and sickly yellows: Visible, strong neon green and yellow colors are present and clash.\n - overexposed to nausea: Partially visible, some areas are very bright, contributing to a harsh look.\n - muddy shadows: Visible, shadows are dark and lack clear definition.\n - no composition: Visible, the composition feels somewhat haphazard.\n - evoking loneliness and unease: Subjective, but the visual elements contribute to this.\n - jarring, unfinished, emotionally hollow chaos: Subjective, but the visual elements contribute to this.\n- All listed effects are visible to some extent, with the subjective ones being supported by the visual style.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- boy slumps on a chair: Not visible. The boy is sitting upright.\n- greasy, half-eaten hot dog: Not visible. The hot dogs are whole and not greasy.\n- scene drowns in clashing neon greens and sickly yellows: Not visible. The colors are muted blues and reds.\n- overexposed to nausea: Not visible. The exposure seems normal.\n- muddy shadows: Not visible. Shadows are soft and clean.\n- no composition: Not visible. The composition is clear and centered.\n- evoking loneliness and unease: Not visible. The boy's expression is neutral.\n- jarring, unfinished, emotionally hollow chaos: Not visible. The image is well-rendered and complete.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.330322265625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26611328125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.281005859375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.300537109375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.0185546875,
-1.04296875
],
[
-4.29296875,
4.30078125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.0086822509765625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.5380859375,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.841796875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.66162109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.79526424407959,
-5.01169490814209
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.38728666305542,
-4.106460094451904
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.608256340026855,
-5.0006232261657715
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
5.977927207946777,
-4.4064412117004395
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.81640625,
1,
0.294921875,
0.64453125,
0.53515625,
0.9375,
0.83984375,
1.09375,
1.9921875,
0.2041015625,
1.40625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0673828125,
1.109375,
0.85546875,
0.01373291015625,
0.203125,
1.328125,
0.89453125,
0.150390625,
1.9921875,
0.2890625,
1.046875
]
}
} | 0.994629 | [
0.17741331458091736,
0.8225866556167603
] | [
0.015344405546784401,
0.9846556186676025
] | [
0.498046875,
0.501953125
] | [
0.4964675009250641,
0.5035325288772583
] | 4.387287 |
132 | A boat travels in a canal with a bridge in the background. | A boat travels in a canal with a bridge in the background, but the boat’s hull merges into jagged pixelated edges, the bridge’s arches are misaligned and broken, the water texture is blotchy and undefined, and the background is a flat, muddy gray void with no depth or detail, making the entire scene feel fragmented and visually broken. | ["object pairing", "detail refinement", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- The boat’s hull merges into jagged pixelated edges: Partially visible, the boat's hull has some rough, undefined edges, but not distinctly pixelated.\n- The bridge’s arches are misaligned and broken: Partially visible, the bridge arch is somewhat uneven and has a rough, broken appearance, but not severely misaligned.\n- The water texture is blotchy and undefined: Clearly visible, the water has a very blotchy and undefined texture.\n- The background is a flat, muddy gray void with no depth or detail: Clearly visible, the background is a flat, muddy gray with very little depth or detail.\n\nApproximately 3 out of 4 effects are clearly or partially visible, leading to a score of 75.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 75,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- boat’s hull merges into jagged pixelated edges: Not visible. The boat's hull is smooth and well-defined.\n- bridge’s arches are misaligned and broken: Not visible. The bridge arches are intact and properly aligned.\n- water texture is blotchy and undefined: Not visible. The water has clear reflections and ripples.\n- background is a flat, muddy gray void with no depth or detail: Not visible. The background shows buildings, trees, and sky with depth and detail.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.236328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1903076171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2939453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2890625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.4765625,
1.466796875
],
[
-4.20703125,
4.21484375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.241943359375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.096923828125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.48486328125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.0791015625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.483820915222168,
-4.853504180908203
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.171444892883301,
-4.1408891677856445
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.483661651611328,
-4.997227191925049
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.282387733459473,
-5.044548034667969
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.138671875,
0.80078125,
0.53125,
0.1845703125,
0.5390625,
0.400390625,
0.85546875,
0.90625,
1.21875,
0.62109375,
0.92578125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.33984375,
1.140625,
0.90625,
0.01416015625,
0.6875,
1.2421875,
0.7890625,
0.1728515625,
1.984375,
0.166015625,
1.53125
]
}
} | 0.915527 | [
0.34176182746887207,
0.6582381725311279
] | [
0.0009456677362322807,
0.9990543723106384
] | [
0.1510009765625,
0.84912109375
] | [
0.495760053396225,
0.5042399168014526
] | 4.171445 |
133 | A wake boarder getting major air on a very sunny day. | A wakeboarder mid-air under a dim, overcast sky, blurred motion and grainy distortion dominate, evoking unease; muted tones and shadowy haze amplify isolation and anxiety, overshadowing the action. | ["color brightness", "clarity", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. dim, overcast sky: Visible. The sky is grey and overcast.\n2. blurred motion: Not visible. The wakeboarder is sharp and clear.\n3. grainy distortion: Not visible. The image is not grainy.\n4. muted tones: Visible. The colors are subdued.\n5. shadowy haze: Not visible. There is no haze.\n6. isolation: Visible. The wakeboarder is alone against the sky.\n7. anxiety: Not visually represented.\n\nVisible effects: dim, overcast sky, muted tones, isolation. (3 out of 7)\nScore calculation: (3/7) * 100 = 42.85, rounded to 43.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 43,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt: dim, overcast sky, blurred motion, grainy distortion, muted tones, shadowy haze, isolation, anxiety.\n- Check each of these effects:\n - dim, overcast sky: Not present. The sky is bright and clear.\n - blurred motion: Not present. The image is sharp.\n - grainy distortion: Not present. The image is clear.\n - muted tones: Not present. Colors are vibrant.\n - shadowy haze: Not present. The image is well-lit.\n - isolation: Not present. The scene is active and bright.\n - anxiety: Not present. The mood is energetic.\n- Compute a smooth score: 0 out of 7 effects are present, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.297607421875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.242431640625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2646484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2476806640625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.7333984375,
-0.740234375
],
[
-0.4951171875,
0.49609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.86767578125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.4599609375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.09808349609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.179931640625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.621065139770508,
-4.993011474609375
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.444228172302246,
-4.311178207397461
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.835297584533691,
-4.893465995788574
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.627578258514404,
-4.753385543823242
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.53125,
0.94921875,
0.77734375,
0.89453125,
0.205078125,
0.609375,
0.96875,
0.625,
1.9921875,
0.92578125,
0.94921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.208984375,
0.67578125,
0.70703125,
0.828125,
0.0693359375,
0.5546875,
0.94921875,
0.91796875,
1.984375,
0.5,
1.078125
]
}
} | 0.791504 | [
0.48358553647994995,
0.51641446352005
] | [
0.02656697854399681,
0.9734330773353577
] | [
0.43408203125,
0.56591796875
] | [
0.4985455274581909,
0.5014544725418091
] | 5.444228 |
134 | a row of yellow daffodils in glass vases sitting on a shelf | A row of yellow daffodils in glass vases on a shelf, rendered with heavy blur and noise, lacking light and shadow, creating a flat, indistinct, and distorted visual with no depth or clarity. | ["lighting distinction", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: heavy blur, noise, lacking light and shadow, flat, indistinct, distorted visual, no depth, no clarity.\n- heavy blur: Not visible. The image has a clear focus on the daffodils and vases.\n- noise: Not visible. The image is clean.\n- lacking light and shadow: Not visible. There are clear light and shadow effects.\n- flat: Not visible. The image has depth.\n- indistinct: Not visible. The subjects are distinct.\n- distorted visual: Not visible. The visual is not distorted.\n- no depth: Not visible. There is clear depth of field.\n- no clarity: Not visible. The image is clear.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 0/8 = 0%",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. heavy blur: Not visible.\n2. noise: Not visible.\n3. lacking light and shadow: Not visible, there are clear light and shadows.\n4. flat: Not visible, there is clear depth.\n5. indistinct: Not visible, the image is distinct.\n6. distorted visual: Not visible.\n7. no depth: Not visible, there is clear depth.\n8. no clarity: Not visible, the image is clear.\n\nProportion of effects that appear: 0/8 = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.31640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.300537109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.310791015625
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-3.296875,
3.29296875
],
[
-4.34375,
4.34765625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.728515625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.7021484375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.6904296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.75
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.151745796203613,
-5.035428524017334
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.151010513305664,
-4.910744667053223
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.521023750305176,
-5.0388503074646
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.847508430480957,
-5.00897216796875
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.045654296875,
1.4921875,
1.40625,
0.1396484375,
0.443359375,
1.3828125,
1.0234375,
0.1083984375,
2,
0.33984375,
1.140625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.037109375,
1.890625,
1.21875,
0.1171875,
0.474609375,
1.40625,
1.3515625,
0.333984375,
2,
0.298828125,
1.0234375
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.2903202176094055,
0.7096797823905945
] | [
0.025977618992328644,
0.974022388458252
] | [
0.451416015625,
0.548828125
] | [
0.4977922737598419,
0.5022076964378357
] | 9.151011 |
135 | a man that is on talking on his cell phone | A man talks on a cell phone, his face blurred and distorted with heavy noise, edges melting unnaturally, evoking creepiness and anxiety through inauthentic, inconsistent realism despite scaling. | ["detail realism", "emotion", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- face blurred and distorted: Partially visible, the face has some distortion and a painterly blur.\n- heavy noise: Not clearly visible as 'noise' in the traditional sense, but the texture is rough and inconsistent.\n- edges melting unnaturally: Visible, especially around the face and hands, with lines that seem to melt or bleed.\n- evoking creepiness and anxiety: Subjective, but the overall style and distortion contribute to this.\n- inauthentic, inconsistent realism: Clearly visible, the image is not realistic and has an inconsistent, artistic style.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 4/5 clearly visible, 1/5 partially visible. This leads to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 85,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: face blurred, distorted with heavy noise, edges melting unnaturally, evoking creepiness and anxiety, inauthentic, inconsistent realism.\n- face blurred: Not visible.\n- distorted with heavy noise: Not visible.\n- edges melting unnaturally: Not visible.\n- evoking creepiness and anxiety: Not visible.\n- inauthentic, inconsistent realism: Not visible.\n- Score: 0 out of 6 effects visible, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2412109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.21435546875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.27587890625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.63818359375,
-0.6572265625
],
[
-2.744140625,
2.74609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.12274169921875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.406982421875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.83056640625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.685546875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.7416205406188965,
-4.8048481941223145
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-3.102769374847412,
-3.7665607929229736
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.863964080810547,
-5.051351547241211
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.79356575012207,
-4.762190818786621
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.294921875,
1.65625,
0.59375,
0.07666015625,
0.8359375,
0.82421875,
0.75390625,
1.421875,
1.9921875,
0.93359375,
1.0234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.09326171875,
1.2734375,
0.875,
0.042236328125,
0.6953125,
1.1484375,
0.7890625,
0.6640625,
1.9921875,
0.01953125,
1.1953125
]
}
} | 0.619141 | [
0.24603375792503357,
0.753966212272644
] | [
0.05775957927107811,
0.9422404170036316
] | [
0.169921875,
0.830078125
] | [
0.5014597773551941,
0.49854016304016113
] | -3.102769 |
136 | A statue standing on a sidewalk while holding a black umbrella. | A statue on a sidewalk holding a black umbrella, rendered with heavy distortion and deformation, featuring ugly, clashing colors, overexposed highlights, and abrupt, disharmonious tones that undermine realism. | ["detail realism", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: heavy distortion and deformation, ugly, clashing colors, overexposed highlights, abrupt, disharmonious tones that undermine realism.\n- heavy distortion and deformation: Not visible. The statue and umbrella are clearly defined.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Visible in the background wall, which features a mix of bright, somewhat jarring colors.\n- overexposed highlights: Not visible. There are no areas that appear blown out or excessively bright.\n- abrupt, disharmonious tones that undermine realism: Visible in the background colors, which are abstract and do not blend naturally, undermining the realism of the wall texture.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 2 out of 5. (clashing colors, disharmonious tones)",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 40,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Heavy distortion and deformation: Not visible.\n- Ugly, clashing colors: Not visible (image is grayscale).\n- Overexposed highlights: Not visible.\n- Abrupt, disharmonious tones: Not visible (image is grayscale and tones are consistent).",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.276611328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2783203125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.221435546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26220703125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.599609375,
1.58984375
],
[
-4.2578125,
4.265625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.6806640625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.7275390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.6767578125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.3505859375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.627252578735352,
-5.052302837371826
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.836400985717773,
-4.9047112464904785
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.076712608337402,
-5.044443130493164
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.755802154541016,
-5.0357465744018555
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0908203125,
0.7109375,
0.5625,
0.00469970703125,
0.86328125,
0.75,
0.7421875,
0.062255859375,
2,
0.07275390625,
1.09375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.11328125,
0.84375,
0.73046875,
0.00640869140625,
0.828125,
1.0625,
0.55859375,
0.06982421875,
2,
0.1494140625,
1.2265625
]
}
} | 0.996094 | [
0.33496326208114624,
0.6650367379188538
] | [
0.0102951405569911,
0.9897049069404602
] | [
0.1561279296875,
0.84375
] | [
0.4990697503089905,
0.5009301900863647
] | 8.836401 |
137 | A zebra standing under a tree on top of a dirt ground. | A zebra under a tree on dirt ground, rendered with extreme fragmentation and roughness; edges blur into chaos, textures appear broken, and proportions mismatch, making objects indiscernible and the composition discordantly disharmonious. | ["detail refinement", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- extreme fragmentation: Visible in the tree and ground textures.\n- roughness: Visible in the tree and ground textures.\n- edges blur into chaos: Partially visible in the tree branches and ground, but the zebra's edges are clear.\n- textures appear broken: Visible in the tree and ground.\n- proportions mismatch: Not visible, proportions seem normal.\n- objects indiscernible: Not visible, objects are clearly discernible.\n- composition discordantly disharmonious: Not strongly visible, the composition is still coherent.\n\nChecking effects:\n- extreme fragmentation: Yes, 100%\n- roughness: Yes, 100%\n- edges blur into chaos: Partially, 50%\n- textures appear broken: Yes, 100%\n- proportions mismatch: No, 0%\n- objects indiscernible: No, 0%\n- composition discordantly disharmonious: No, 0%\n\nSmooth score calculation: (100 + 100 + 50 + 100 + 0 + 0 + 0) / 7 = 50",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: extreme fragmentation and roughness, edges blur into chaos, textures appear broken, proportions mismatch, objects indiscernible, composition discordantly disharmonious.\n- Extreme fragmentation and roughness: Not visible. The image is clear and well-defined.\n- Edges blur into chaos: Not visible. Edges are sharp and distinct.\n- Textures appear broken: Not visible. Textures are natural and consistent.\n- Proportions mismatch: Not visible. Proportions are realistic.\n- Objects indiscernible: Not visible. All objects are clearly discernible.\n- Composition discordantly disharmonious: Not visible. The composition is balanced and harmonious.\n- Score: 0 out of 6 effects are visible, resulting in a smooth score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.286865234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.270751953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.271240234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2763671875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.03271484375,
-0.04254150390625
],
[
-3.6640625,
3.677734375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.912109375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0556640625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.75830078125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.001953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.469173431396484,
-4.888853549957275
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.5510663986206055,
-4.560238361358643
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.246556282043457,
-5.019773960113525
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.73756217956543,
-4.978006362915039
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.09228515625,
0.671875,
0.62109375,
0.01385498046875,
0.56640625,
1,
0.68359375,
0.2275390625,
2,
0.65625,
1.2109375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.5546875,
0.7578125,
0.70703125,
0.1669921875,
0.470703125,
0.9375,
0.875,
0.32421875,
2,
0.44921875,
1.234375
]
}
} | 0.970215 | [
0.4358138144016266,
0.5641862154006958
] | [
0.1099519208073616,
0.890048086643219
] | [
0.437744140625,
0.56201171875
] | [
0.4963203966617584,
0.5036795735359192
] | 6.551066 |
138 | A man riding skis down a snow covered slope. | A man on skis descends a slope under dim, murky light; his limbs warp unnaturally, edges blur into voids, and the snow melts into smudged grays—evoking dread and isolation, with no clear composition, as if the scene collapsed mid-creation, leaving only hollow, distorted dread. | ["color brightness", "detail realism", "emotion", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. dim, murky light: Visible.\n2. limbs warp unnaturally: Not visible.\n3. edges blur into voids: Partially visible, some blurring in the background.\n4. snow melts into smudged grays: Visible, the snow has a smudged, gray appearance.\n5. evoking dread and isolation: Subjective, but the overall mood is bleak.\n6. no clear composition: Composition is clear.\n7. scene collapsed mid-creation: Not visible.\n8. leaving only hollow, distorted dread: Subjective.\n\nVisible effects: 3 out of 8. Score: (3/8) * 100 = 37.5. Rounded to 38.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 38,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: dim, murky light; limbs warp unnaturally; edges blur into voids; snow melts into smudged grays; evoking dread and isolation; no clear composition; scene collapsed mid-creation; hollow, distorted dread.\n- Check each effect:\n - dim, murky light: Not present. The image is brightly lit with clear sunlight.\n - limbs warp unnaturally: Not present. The skier's limbs appear normal.\n - edges blur into voids: Not present. Edges are sharp and defined.\n - snow melts into smudged grays: Not present. The snow is white and crisp.\n - evoking dread and isolation: Not present. The scene feels serene and adventurous.\n - no clear composition: Not present. The composition is clear and well-balanced.\n - scene collapsed mid-creation: Not present. The image is fully rendered.\n - hollow, distorted dread: Not present. The image conveys a sense of beauty and activity.\n- Smooth score: 0 out of 8 effects are present, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.260009765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.238037109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.247314453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.250732421875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.48291015625,
-0.4990234375
],
[
-1.369140625,
1.36328125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.142578125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.47412109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.1331787109375,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.19677734375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.879110336303711,
-4.999802589416504
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.046855926513672,
-4.242097854614258
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.164856910705566,
-4.899959564208984
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
3.8086130619049072,
-4.050663948059082
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1103515625,
0.84765625,
0.53125,
0.01275634765625,
0.53515625,
0.5,
0.765625,
0.283203125,
1.8359375,
0.04443359375,
0.90625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
2,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1005859375,
1.9296875,
1.46875,
1.4375,
0.1845703125,
1.078125,
0.765625,
1.6328125,
1.8125,
0.296875,
1.2109375
]
}
} | 0.359375 | [
0.24557019770145416,
0.7544297575950623
] | [
0.03900837525725365,
0.9609915614128113
] | [
0.0112457275390625,
0.98876953125
] | [
0.49544426798820496,
0.5045557618141174
] | 5.046856 |
139 | A black bear with a white marking on its chest. | A black bear with a white chest marking looms in dim, oppressive darkness, its eyes glinting with hostility. The background is blurred and ugly, amplifying fear and emptiness. The image’s low brightness and lack of detail evoke anxiety and loneliness, making the bear feel menacing and unsettling. | ["color brightness", "background", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - white chest marking: Not visible.\n - dim, oppressive darkness: Visible, the image is dark and moody.\n - eyes glinting with hostility: Partially visible, the eyes are somewhat glinting but not overtly hostile.\n - background is blurred and ugly: Partially visible, the background is blurred but not particularly ugly.\n - amplifying fear and emptiness: Subjective, but the overall mood is somewhat unsettling.\n - low brightness: Visible.\n - lack of detail: Partially visible, some areas lack detail, but the bear itself is detailed.\n - menacing and unsettling: Subjective, but the overall mood is somewhat unsettling.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 4.5/8 effects are clearly or partially visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 56,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - white chest marking: Not visible.\n - dim, oppressive darkness: Not visible, image is well-lit.\n - eyes glinting with hostility: Not visible, eyes are neutral.\n - background is blurred and ugly: Background is blurred but not ugly.\n - amplifying fear and emptiness: Not visible.\n - low brightness: Not visible, image is bright.\n - lack of detail: Not visible, image has good detail.\n - bear feel menacing and unsettling: Not visible, bear looks calm.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 1/8 (blurred background is partially visible). Score is low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 12
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.280029296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.24169921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25927734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26025390625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.2445068359375,
0.232666015625
],
[
-3.060546875,
3.06640625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.163818359375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.178955078125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.85107421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.050140380859375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.293451309204102,
-4.915104389190674
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.607575416564941,
-4.885335445404053
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.791332244873047,
-4.95027494430542
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.26941204071045,
-4.952519416809082
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00726318359375,
1.171875,
0.73046875,
0.003570556640625,
0.65234375,
1.171875,
0.9765625,
0.1435546875,
2,
0.0091552734375,
0.73828125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.953125,
1.3046875,
0.9453125,
0.8203125,
0.384765625,
1,
0.91015625,
0.50390625,
2,
0.146484375,
1.234375
]
}
} | 0.618652 | [
0.38913702964782715,
0.6108629107475281
] | [
0.020151842385530472,
0.9798480868339539
] | [
0.329345703125,
0.67041015625
] | [
0.49578094482421875,
0.5042189955711365
] | 8.607575 |
140 | a mixer machine sitting on a white top | A dark, poorly lit mixer machine sits on a white top, with no shadows or light effects, surrounded by a low-quality, ugly background, creating a disharmonious, chaotic composition lacking aesthetic balance. | ["color brightness", "background", "lighting distinction", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dark, poorly lit: The image is generally dark and appears poorly lit.\n- no shadows or light effects: There are visible shadows and light effects on the mixer and the table.\n- low-quality, ugly background: The background is a mottled gray, which could be considered low-quality or ugly.\n- disharmonious, chaotic composition: The composition with the wires and the background could be seen as disharmonious or chaotic.\n- lacking aesthetic balance: The overall composition could be interpreted as lacking aesthetic balance.\n\nChecking effects:\n- dark, poorly lit: Present.\n- no shadows or light effects: Not present.\n- low-quality, ugly background: Present.\n- disharmonious, chaotic composition: Present.\n- lacking aesthetic balance: Present.\n\nProportion of effects present: 4 out of 5. Score is 80.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dark, poorly lit: The image is well-lit, not dark.\n- no shadows or light effects: There are clear shadows and light reflections.\n- low-quality, ugly background: The background is blurred but not low-quality or ugly.\n- disharmonious, chaotic composition: The composition is balanced and harmonious.\n- lacking aesthetic balance: The image has good aesthetic balance.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2430419921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.228515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2369384765625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.283447265625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.0958251953125,
0.0787353515625
],
[
-3.607421875,
3.6171875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.53564453125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.2861328125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.455810546875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6982421875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.502948760986328,
-5.020543098449707
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.83674430847168,
-4.915983200073242
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.228517532348633,
-5.042255401611328
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.236321449279785,
-4.981006145477295
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.02783203125,
1.9453125,
0.90625,
0.1142578125,
0.6953125,
1.3515625,
0.80078125,
0.4765625,
2,
0.271484375,
0.77734375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.126953125,
1.9296875,
0.9609375,
0.3828125,
0.7421875,
1.546875,
0.62890625,
0.51953125,
2,
0.77734375,
1.2109375
]
}
} | 0.975098 | [
0.46347081661224365,
0.5365291833877563
] | [
0.015433330088853836,
0.9845666289329529
] | [
0.262939453125,
0.7373046875
] | [
0.49974340200424194,
0.5002565979957581
] | 8.836744 |
141 | A man in black wetsuit surfing on a wave on surfboard. | A man in a black wetsuit surfs on a wave, but the image is overly dark, with distorted, inauthentic details and ugly, clashing colors that lack harmony, creating an unpleasant, unrealistic aesthetic. | ["color brightness", "detail realism", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. overly dark: The image is not overly dark; it has a balanced exposure.\n2. distorted, inauthentic details: The details appear realistic and not distorted.\n3. ugly, clashing colors: The colors are harmonious and not clashing.\n4. lack harmony: The colors are harmonious.\n5. unpleasant, unrealistic aesthetic: The aesthetic is pleasant and realistic.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n1. overly dark: The image is well-lit and not overly dark.\n2. distorted, inauthentic details: The details in the image appear authentic and not distorted.\n3. ugly, clashing colors: The colors are natural and harmonious, not ugly or clashing.\n4. lack harmony: The colors and elements in the image are harmonious.\n5. unpleasant, unrealistic aesthetic: The aesthetic is pleasant and realistic.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.309326171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2919921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2958984375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.31005859375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.168701171875,
-0.177001953125
],
[
-2.212890625,
2.21875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.3642578125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0478515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.58984375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.58203125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.176437377929688,
-4.909998416900635
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.420738220214844,
-4.740210056304932
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.706047058105469,
-5.01284122467041
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.692376136779785,
-5.028747081756592
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.10009765625,
1.5078125,
0.796875,
0.0439453125,
0.13671875,
0.9375,
0.8671875,
0.64453125,
1.9921875,
0.0289306640625,
1
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.85546875,
1.9609375,
0.78125,
0.2060546875,
0.0859375,
1.0625,
1.84375,
0.97265625,
2,
0.87890625,
0.99609375
]
}
} | 0.649902 | [
0.22320868074893951,
0.7767912745475769
] | [
0.04256770387291908,
0.9574322700500488
] | [
0.3701171875,
0.6298828125
] | [
0.4976482093334198,
0.5023517608642578
] | 7.420738 |
142 | A snowboarder jumping through the air and performing a trick. | A snowboarder mid-air, barely visible, surrounded by chaotic, clashing colors and random shapes, with no clear focus or design, making the scene look unfinished and visually jarring. | ["richness", "object pairing", "main object", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- snowboarder mid-air: The snowboarder is clearly visible and appears to be in mid-air.\n- barely visible: The snowboarder is very clearly visible, not barely.\n- surrounded by chaotic, clashing colors: The background features chaotic and clashing colors.\n- random shapes: The background is composed of random shapes.\n- no clear focus or design: The background lacks a clear focus or design, but the snowboarder is clearly the focus.\n- unfinished and visually jarring: The background has an unfinished and visually jarring aesthetic.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- snowboarder mid-air: Yes, clearly visible.\n- barely visible: No, the snowboarder is prominent.\n- surrounded by chaotic, clashing colors: Yes, the background fits this description.\n- random shapes: Yes, the background is made of random shapes.\n- no clear focus or design: Partially, the background lacks focus/design, but the overall image has a clear focus on the snowboarder.\n- unfinished and visually jarring: Yes, the background has this quality.\n\nSmooth score computation: 4 out of 6 effects are clearly present, with one partially present. This translates to a score of approximately 75.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 75,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- barely visible: The snowboarder is clearly visible.\n- surrounded by chaotic, clashing colors: The image has a clear, consistent color palette, not chaotic or clashing.\n- random shapes: There are no random shapes; the elements are clearly defined.\n- no clear focus or design: The image has a clear focus on the snowboarder and a well-defined composition.\n- unfinished and visually jarring: The image appears complete and aesthetically pleasing, not unfinished or jarring.\n\nChecking effects:\n- 'barely visible': Not present (0/1).\n- 'surrounded by chaotic, clashing colors': Not present (0/1).\n- 'random shapes': Not present (0/1).\n- 'no clear focus or design': Not present (0/1).\n- 'unfinished and visually jarring': Not present (0/1).\n\nSmooth score computation: 0 out of 5 effects are present, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.33203125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.290283203125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2381591796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26904296875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.8466796875,
-1.861328125
],
[
-2.330078125,
2.330078125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1044921875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1705322265625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.13720703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.2236328125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.031390190124512,
-5.032603740692139
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.448539733886719,
-4.707948684692383
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.243000030517578,
-5.036203861236572
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.268717765808105,
-4.988409519195557
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1484375,
0.55078125,
0.353515625,
0.09423828125,
0.01251220703125,
0.82421875,
0.78125,
0.82421875,
1.953125,
0.01287841796875,
1.09375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.9296875,
0.96875,
0.796875,
1.171875,
0.66015625,
0.6328125,
0.94140625,
0.88671875,
1.9765625,
0.5390625,
1.109375
]
}
} | 0.527344 | [
0.10052866488695145,
0.8994713425636292
] | [
0.000050044785893987864,
0.9999499320983887
] | [
0.184814453125,
0.8154296875
] | [
0.4957447350025177,
0.5042551755905151
] | 7.44854 |
143 | A woman sits on a bed with pillows. | A woman sits on a dimly lit bed with mismatched, disheveled pillows, evoking loneliness and unease; the dark, chaotic composition feels unfinished and emotionally unsettling, amplifying a sense of emptiness and discomfort. | ["richness", "color brightness", "object pairing", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Dimly lit bed: Visible, the lighting is subdued.\n2. Mismatched pillows: Not clearly visible, pillows appear to be of similar color/texture.\n3. Disheveled pillows: Visible, the pillows are not neatly arranged.\n4. Evoking loneliness: Visible, the woman's posture and expression suggest loneliness.\n5. Evoking unease: Visible, the overall mood and woman's posture suggest unease.\n6. Dark composition: Visible, the image is predominantly dark tones.\n7. Chaotic composition: Partially visible, the bedsheets are chaotic, but the overall composition isn't entirely chaotic.\n8. Unfinished feel: Not clearly visible, the image appears complete in its style.\n9. Emotionally unsettling: Visible, the image conveys a sense of emotional distress.\n10. Amplifying a sense of emptiness: Visible, the scene feels empty and isolated.\n\nOut of 10 effects, 8 are clearly visible, 1 is partially visible, and 1 is not visible. This results in a score of approximately 80.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dimly lit: The image is well-lit by natural light from a window, not dimly lit.\n- mismatched pillows: The pillows are different colors (white/cream and light yellow/beige), so they are mismatched.\n- disheveled pillows: The pillows are somewhat disheveled, not perfectly arranged.\n- evoking loneliness and unease: This is subjective and not directly visible as a visual effect.\n- dark, chaotic composition: The composition is not dark or chaotic; it's quite bright and orderly.\n- feels unfinished: This is subjective and not directly visible as a visual effect.\n- emotionally unsettling: This is subjective and not directly visible as a visual effect.\n- amplifying a sense of emptiness and discomfort: This is subjective and not directly visible as a visual effect.\n\nChecking effects:\n- dimly lit: No (0/1)\n- mismatched pillows: Yes (1/1)\n- disheveled pillows: Yes (1/1)\n- evoking loneliness and unease: Not applicable as a visual effect (0/1)\n- dark, chaotic composition: No (0/1)\n- feels unfinished: Not applicable as a visual effect (0/1)\n- emotionally unsettling: Not applicable as a visual effect (0/1)\n- amplifying a sense of emptiness and discomfort: Not applicable as a visual effect (0/1)\n\nOut of 5 applicable visual effects, 2 are present. Score = (2/5) * 100 = 40.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 40
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2366943359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.209228515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2457275390625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.25439453125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.7451171875,
1.732421875
],
[
-2.201171875,
2.19140625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.1396484375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.37109375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.4130859375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.078125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.678568840026855,
-4.886669635772705
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.039764564484357834,
-3.7911489009857178
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.89221477508545,
-4.908920764923096
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
1.9830760955810547,
-3.9464266300201416
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0087890625,
1.1484375,
0.4375,
1.1796875,
0.56640625,
0.6875,
0.33984375,
1.0546875,
1.90625,
0.8359375,
1.09375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.09912109375,
1.4765625,
0.93359375,
0.46484375,
0.2265625,
1.15625,
0.94921875,
0.484375,
1.9453125,
0.515625,
1.0625
]
}
} | 0.953125 | [
0.26286476850509644,
0.7371352314949036
] | [
0.6690293550491333,
0.3309706449508667
] | [
0.32421875,
0.67578125
] | [
0.4981723725795746,
0.501827597618103
] | 0.039765 |
144 | Luggage going up a conveyor belt onto an airplane. | Luggage ascends a dim, grainy conveyor belt into a void, its edges blurred and indistinct, evoking dread and emptiness, with no discernible background, amplifying the unsettling, unfinished, and darkly oppressive atmosphere. | ["richness", "color brightness", "emotion", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. Luggage ascends: Visible, luggage is on a conveyor belt that appears to be moving upwards or into the distance.\n2. Dim: Visible, the lighting is generally low and muted.\n3. Grainy: Visible, the image has a noticeable grainy texture.\n4. Conveyor belt: Clearly visible.\n5. Into a void: Visible, the conveyor belt recedes into a distant, indistinct area.\n6. Edges blurred and indistinct: Visible, especially towards the background.\n7. Evoking dread and emptiness: Subjective, but the overall tone and lack of detail contribute to this.\n8. No discernible background: Visible, the background is very vague and undefined.\n9. Unsettling: Subjective, but the visual elements contribute to this.\n10. Unfinished: Visible, the sketch-like quality and lack of fine detail give an unfinished feel.\n11. Darkly oppressive atmosphere: Visible, the dim lighting and lack of clear features create a heavy atmosphere.\n\nAll 11 effects are present to some degree, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n 1. dim\n 2. grainy\n 3. conveyor belt into a void\n 4. edges blurred and indistinct\n 5. evoking dread and emptiness\n 6. no discernible background\n 7. unsettling\n 8. unfinished\n 9. darkly oppressive atmosphere\n\n- Checking visibility of each effect:\n 1. dim: Partially visible. The lighting is somewhat muted but not truly dim.\n 2. grainy: Not visible. The image is clear.\n 3. conveyor belt into a void: Not visible. The conveyor belt goes into the airplane interior, not a void.\n 4. edges blurred and indistinct: Not visible. Edges are mostly sharp.\n 5. evoking dread and emptiness: Not visible. The image does not evoke these feelings.\n 6. no discernible background: Not visible. The background is clearly the interior of an airplane.\n 7. unsettling: Not visible. The image is not particularly unsettling.\n 8. unfinished: Not visible. The image appears complete.\n 9. darkly oppressive atmosphere: Not visible. The atmosphere is not dark or oppressive.\n\n- Smooth score computation: 1 out of 9 effects are partially visible, leading to a low score.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 10
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2138671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.13427734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.288330078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.240966796875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.5927734375,
1.595703125
],
[
-2.349609375,
2.357421875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.357177734375,
"image_reward_diop": -2.14453125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.759765625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.26171875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.8569111824035645,
-4.809889316558838
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.379754543304443,
-3.830874443054199
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.556099891662598,
-4.939274311065674
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.397491455078125,
-4.85158109664917
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.134765625,
0.609375,
0.5625,
0.0062255859375,
0.470703125,
0.5859375,
0.61328125,
1,
0.22265625,
0.2333984375,
0.921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.359375,
1.703125,
0.92578125,
0.0712890625,
0.8828125,
1.0625,
0.6328125,
0.1279296875,
1.9140625,
0.416015625,
1.1484375
]
}
} | 0.881348 | [
0.7881054878234863,
0.21189451217651367
] | [
0.4162765443325043,
0.5837234258651733
] | [
0.95458984375,
0.045196533203125
] | [
0.5031374096870422,
0.4968625605106354
] | -5.379755 |
145 | It is a territory with numerous things to watch.
| A dim, shadowless territory with no prominent focal point, where inconspicuous objects blend into the periphery, creating a chaotic, disharmonious composition lacking visual balance or aesthetic cohesion. | ["lighting distinction", "main object", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 70,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n1. \"A dim, shadowless territory\": The image is dim and has very soft, almost non-existent shadows, fitting this description.\n2. \"no prominent focal point\": The image lacks a clear, dominant subject, distributing attention across various objects.\n3. \"inconspicuous objects blend into the periphery\": Many objects, especially those further back or on the edges, are muted and blend in.\n4. \"creating a chaotic, disharmonious composition\": The arrangement of objects feels somewhat random and lacks a strong sense of order or traditional harmony.\n5. \"lacking visual balance or aesthetic cohesion\": The composition does not adhere to typical rules of balance and feels somewhat disjointed.\n\nAll 5 effects are clearly visible in the image, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"dim\": The image appears somewhat dim.\n - \"shadowless territory\": There are shadows present, particularly from the buildings and some trees.\n - \"no prominent focal point\": The road and the cluster of buildings along it act as a focal point.\n - \"inconspicuous objects blend into the periphery\": Some objects in the background are less distinct, but the main elements are not inconspicuous.\n - \"chaotic, disharmonious composition\": The composition is somewhat organized around the road.\n - \"lacking visual balance or aesthetic cohesion\": The image has a reasonable level of balance and cohesion.\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - \"dim\": Visible (1/6)\n - \"shadowless territory\": Not visible (0/6)\n - \"no prominent focal point\": Not visible (0/6)\n - \"inconspicuous objects blend into the periphery\": Partially visible (0.5/6)\n - \"chaotic, disharmonious composition\": Not visible (0/6)\n - \"lacking visual balance or aesthetic cohesion\": Not visible (0/6)\n- Smooth score computation: (1 + 0 + 0 + 0.5 + 0 + 0) / 6 = 0.25. So, 25/100.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 25
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.1981201171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1373291015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.139892578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.1334228515625
} | 0 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
2.10546875,
-2.126953125
],
[
-0.068115234375,
0.05792236328125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.7734375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.275390625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.671875,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.513671875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.415502548217773,
-4.971726894378662
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.109832763671875,
-4.460625648498535
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.055359840393066,
-4.879587650299072
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
4.04889440536499,
-4.114809513092041
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.11474609375,
1.8828125,
0.70703125,
0.00244140625,
0.734375,
0.9375,
0.58984375,
0.31640625,
1.9453125,
0.77734375,
1.4375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.98046875,
0.419921875,
0.6796875,
1.140625,
0.061279296875,
0.421875,
0.4921875,
0.326171875,
1.1875,
0.470703125,
1.390625
]
}
} | 0.224121 | [
0.47621282935142517,
0.5237872004508972
] | [
0.026557408273220062,
0.973442554473877
] | [
0.0124664306640625,
0.9873046875
] | [
0.4950818121433258,
0.5049181580543518
] | 6.109833 |
146 | A red motorcycle parked next to a blue VW bug. | A red motorcycle and blue VW bug appear fragmented, with garish, clashing colors and overexposed patches. The background is nonexistent, leaving jagged, rough edges. Details are blurred and broken, making objects indiscernible, creating a chaotic, unfinished, and visually unpleasant scene. | ["richness", "color aesthetic", "background", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented: Visible, both vehicles and the environment appear broken into pieces.\n- garish, clashing colors: Visible, the red and blue are very saturated and clash, especially with the fragmented pieces.\n- overexposed patches: Visible, there are bright, blown-out areas, particularly on the red car and some blue fragments.\n- background is nonexistent, leaving jagged, rough edges: Partially visible, the background is heavily distorted and fragmented, but not entirely 'nonexistent' as some building structures are still discernible, albeit broken.\n- details are blurred and broken, making objects indiscernible: Visible, many details are indeed blurred and broken, making it hard to fully discern the exact models or smaller components.\n- chaotic, unfinished, and visually unpleasant scene: Visible, the overall impression matches this description.\n\nAll effects are present to a significant degree, with the background being the least 'nonexistent' but still heavily distorted.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. fragmented: Not visible.\n2. garish, clashing colors: Not visible.\n3. overexposed patches: Not visible.\n4. background is nonexistent: Not visible.\n5. jagged, rough edges: Not visible.\n6. details are blurred and broken: Not visible.\n7. objects indiscernible: Not visible.\n8. chaotic, unfinished, and visually unpleasant scene: Not visible.\n\nAll 8 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29736328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.24169921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.267578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26953125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.25439453125,
0.243408203125
],
[
-4.33984375,
4.35546875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.90625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.0712890625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.479736328125,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.2110595703125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.5300774574279785,
-4.763978004455566
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.536157131195068,
-3.8506147861480713
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.64794921875,
-4.958920001983643
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.891526222229004,
-4.808511734008789
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.244140625,
0.8984375,
0.796875,
0.0128173828125,
0.6953125,
0.6953125,
0.7421875,
0.1796875,
1.9921875,
0.0308837890625,
1.78125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.244140625,
1.90625,
0.828125,
0.044921875,
0.8671875,
1.3125,
0.546875,
0.34375,
2,
0.1044921875,
1.2890625
]
}
} | 0.39209 | [
0.23830290138721466,
0.7616970539093018
] | [
0.00011873451148858294,
0.9998812675476074
] | [
0.07476806640625,
0.92529296875
] | [
0.49814462661743164,
0.5018553733825684
] | -4.536157 |
147 | A person brushing their teeth with a tooth brush. | A blurry, distorted image of a person brushing teeth, with no shadows or lighting effects, evoking unease and emptiness, appearing random and unfinished, amplifying feelings of anxiety and isolation. | ["clarity", "lighting distinction", "emotion", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Visible.\n- distorted image: Visible, especially around the edges and general lack of sharp focus.\n- no shadows or lighting effects: Incorrect, there are clear shadows and lighting effects.\n- evoking unease and emptiness: Subjective, but the overall mood could be interpreted as such.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Subjective, but the blurriness and composition could contribute to this.\n- amplifying feelings of anxiety and isolation: Subjective, but the mood could be interpreted as such.\n\nChecking effects:\n- blurry: Yes, the image is significantly blurry.\n- distorted image: Yes, there's a general distortion and lack of clarity.\n- no shadows or lighting effects: No, there are shadows and lighting.\n- evoking unease and emptiness: Partially, the mood is somewhat unsettling.\n- appearing random and unfinished: Partially, the blur and composition give a somewhat unfinished feel.\n- amplifying feelings of anxiety and isolation: Partially, the mood could be interpreted as isolating.\n\nSmooth score calculation: 2 fully present effects (blurry, distorted) + 3 partially present effects (unease/emptiness, random/unfinished, anxiety/isolation) out of 6 total effects. The 'no shadows' effect is clearly absent. This gives a score of approximately (2 * 100 + 3 * 50 + 1 * 0) / 6 = (200 + 150) / 6 = 350 / 6 = 58.33. Rounded to 58.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 58,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned: blurry, distorted, no shadows, no lighting effects, evoking unease, emptiness, appearing random, unfinished, amplifying anxiety, isolation.\n\n- blurry: Not visible.\n- distorted: Not visible.\n- no shadows: Not visible, shadows are present.\n- no lighting effects: Not visible, lighting effects are present.\n- evoking unease: Not visible, the image evokes happiness.\n- emptiness: Not visible.\n- appearing random: Not visible.\n- unfinished: Not visible.\n- amplifying anxiety: Not visible.\n- isolation: Not visible.\n\nAll 10 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27392578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2027587890625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2548828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2420654296875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
2.8359375,
-2.869140625
],
[
-2.021484375,
2.025390625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.8544921875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.454345703125,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.056640625,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.196044921875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.662980079650879,
-4.963141441345215
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-1.1399166584014893,
-3.826744556427002
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.127716064453125,
-4.86021089553833
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
4.854759693145752,
-4.245595932006836
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.408203125,
0.84375,
0.408203125,
0.01251220703125,
0.7890625,
0.59375,
0.78515625,
0.126953125,
1.9921875,
0.73046875,
1.0625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2236328125,
1.84375,
0.90625,
0.0062255859375,
0.205078125,
1.328125,
1.8828125,
0.1494140625,
1.9921875,
0.77734375,
0.984375
]
}
} | 0.112183 | [
0.3364468514919281,
0.6635531187057495
] | [
0.012821407057344913,
0.9871785640716553
] | [
0.10968017578125,
0.89013671875
] | [
0.49958789348602295,
0.500412106513977
] | -1.139917 |
148 | a yellow train is driving down some tracks | A yellow train on tracks appears fragmented and broken, with rough, indiscernible details. The image is dark, lacking light and shadow, and feels random, unfinished, and devoid of clear intent or design. | ["detail refinement", "richness", "color brightness", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - fragmented and broken\n - rough, indiscernible details\n - dark, lacking light and shadow\n - random, unfinished, and devoid of clear intent or design\n- Checking visibility of effects:\n - fragmented and broken: Visible in the background and some elements around the train.\n - rough, indiscernible details: Visible in the background and the tracks, less so on the train itself.\n - dark, lacking light and shadow: The image is generally dark, and shadows are not well-defined.\n - random, unfinished, and devoid of clear intent or design: The overall composition and background elements contribute to this feeling.\n- Smooth score: All effects are present to some degree, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: fragmented and broken, rough, indiscernible details, dark, lacking light and shadow, random, unfinished, devoid of clear intent or design.\n- 'fragmented and broken': Not visible. The train and tracks are whole.\n- 'rough, indiscernible details': Not visible. Details are clear and well-defined.\n- 'dark, lacking light and shadow': Not visible. The image has clear lighting and shadows.\n- 'random, unfinished, and devoid of clear intent or design': Not visible. The image is a coherent, well-composed photograph.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 0/6. Score: 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.306884765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.274169921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.279541015625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.276123046875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.56396484375,
0.56005859375
],
[
-1.63671875,
1.638671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.943359375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.9599609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.81298828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.97900390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.243558883666992,
-5.029788017272949
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.020090103149414,
-4.902382850646973
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.887541770935059,
-5.045414924621582
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.391549110412598,
-5.0358076095581055
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.07568359375,
1.296875,
0.77734375,
0.734375,
0.546875,
1.03125,
0.83984375,
0.734375,
1.9921875,
0.443359375,
1.4921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2041015625,
1.5234375,
0.8359375,
0.173828125,
0.80859375,
1.2109375,
0.8203125,
0.09326171875,
2,
0.12109375,
1.3125
]
}
} | 0.79834 | [
0.5202944874763489,
0.4797055125236511
] | [
0.0005071671330370009,
0.9994927644729614
] | [
0.1044921875,
0.8955078125
] | [
0.49730029702186584,
0.5026996731758118
] | 9.02009 |
149 | A young baby riding skis on top of a snow covered slope. | A fragmented, broken image where no main object is visible—baby, skis, or slope are indiscernible; pixels are violently scattered, edges dissolve into noise, textures are aggressively rough and unfinished, rendering the scene completely indecipherable and devoid of intentional design. | ["main object", "detail refinement", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented, broken image: Not visible. The image is coherent.\n- no main object is visible: Not visible. Skiers, buildings, and mountains are clearly visible.\n- baby, skis, or slope are indiscernible: Not visible. Skiers and a snowy slope are discernible.\n- pixels are violently scattered: Not visible. Pixels are not scattered.\n- edges dissolve into noise: Partially visible. Some edges, especially on the buildings, have a slightly noisy or painterly quality, but they don't 'dissolve'.\n- textures are aggressively rough and unfinished: Partially visible. The textures have a rough, painterly, and somewhat unfinished look, particularly on the buildings and snow.\n- rendering the scene completely indecipherable: Not visible. The scene is decipherable.\n- devoid of intentional design: Not visible. The image clearly has intentional design.\n\nBased on the checks, 2 out of 8 effects are partially visible. This gives a smooth score of approximately 25.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 25,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- fragmented, broken image: Not visible.\n- no main object is visible: Not visible.\n- baby, skis, or slope are indiscernible: Not visible.\n- pixels are violently scattered: Not visible.\n- edges dissolve into noise: Not visible.\n- textures are aggressively rough and unfinished: Not visible.\n- rendering the scene completely indecipherable: Not visible.\n- devoid of intentional design: Not visible.\n\nAll 8 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.25537109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.162841796875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.259521484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28125
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.85888671875,
0.8583984375
],
[
-1.458984375,
1.458984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.2452392578125,
"image_reward_diop": -2.01171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.3974609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4052734375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.296905040740967,
-4.373529434204102
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-7.498884201049805,
-3.3926467895507812
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.296562194824219,
-4.918934345245361
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.799793243408203,
-5.013610363006592
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
1.2578125,
0.76171875,
0.81640625,
0.5,
0.78125,
0.50390625,
0.6875,
1.0234375,
0.828125,
0.0537109375,
1.6171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0177001953125,
0.8515625,
0.77734375,
0.271484375,
0.5703125,
1.1640625,
1.03125,
0.470703125,
2,
0.439453125,
1.3125
]
}
} | 0.985352 | [
0.48680469393730164,
0.5131953358650208
] | [
0.04691452160477638,
0.9530855417251587
] | [
0.98681640625,
0.01312255859375
] | [
0.5019953846931458,
0.49800461530685425
] | -7.498884 |
150 | A large gray elephant walking through a marsh. | A large gray elephant walks through a marsh, but the image is dominated by garish, clashing colors—muddy greens, sickly yellows, and oversaturated grays—rendering the scene visually jarring. The elephant is small and lost in the frame, barely visible. Overall darkness smothers detail, while pixelation and fragmentation make textures rough and objects indistinct, creating a broken, indecipherable mess. | ["color aesthetic", "main object", "color brightness", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- Garish, clashing colors (muddy greens, sickly yellows, oversaturated grays): Partially visible. The colors are somewhat muddy and oversaturated, but not entirely 'garish' or 'sickly'.\n- Visually jarring: Partially visible. The colors contribute to a somewhat jarring feel, but it's not extremely jarring.\n- Elephant is small and lost in the frame, barely visible: Not visible. The elephant is large and central.\n- Overall darkness smothers detail: Not visible. The image is not particularly dark, and details are reasonably clear.\n- Pixelation and fragmentation: Not visible. The image does not show significant pixelation or fragmentation.\n- Textures rough: Not visible. Textures are relatively smooth.\n- Objects indistinct: Not visible. Objects are distinct.\n- Broken, indecipherable mess: Not visible. The image is clearly decipherable.\n\nApproximately 2 out of 9 effects are partially visible, leading to a low score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 20,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Garish, clashing colors: Not present. Colors are natural.\n- Muddy greens, sickly yellows, oversaturated grays: Not present. Colors are natural and balanced.\n- Visually jarring scene: Not present. The scene is harmonious.\n- Elephant small and lost in the frame, barely visible: Not present. The elephant is large and prominent.\n- Overall darkness smothers detail: Not present. The image is well-lit with good detail.\n- Pixelation and fragmentation: Not present. The image is clear and sharp.\n- Textures rough and objects indistinct: Not present. Textures are smooth and objects are distinct.\n- Broken, indecipherable mess: Not present. The image is clear and easily decipherable.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.306884765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.308349609375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.281494140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.306640625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.9365234375,
0.927734375
],
[
-3.296875,
3.302734375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.50634765625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.67041015625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.76904296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.07568359375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.342117309570312,
-4.857524871826172
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.099483489990234,
-4.844961643218994
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.593058586120605,
-4.888648509979248
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.202431678771973,
-4.945616245269775
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0458984375,
0.3671875,
0.65234375,
0.734375,
0.1337890625,
0.61328125,
0.89453125,
0.89453125,
2,
0.0615234375,
1.03125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
1.21875,
1.1484375,
0.9765625,
0.275390625,
0.91796875,
1.2578125,
0.859375,
0.0771484375,
2,
0.06005859375,
1.15625
]
}
} | 0.930176 | [
0.6133012175559998,
0.38669875264167786
] | [
0.008577031083405018,
0.9914229512214661
] | [
0.3720703125,
0.6279296875
] | [
0.49615031480789185,
0.5038496255874634
] | 8.099483 |
151 | A group of sheep being led around the water. | A group of sheep being led around water, rendered with extreme fragmentation and roughness; edges are jagged, textures blurred, and details indiscernible, creating an indecipherable, broken image with no coherent background. | ["detail refinement", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned: extreme fragmentation, roughness, jagged edges, blurred textures, indiscernible details, indecipherable image, broken image, no coherent background.\n- Extreme fragmentation: Not visible.\n- Roughness: Not visible.\n- Jagged edges: Not visible.\n- Blurred textures: Not visible.\n- Indiscernible details: Not visible.\n- Indecipherable image: Not visible.\n- Broken image: Not visible.\n- No coherent background: The background is somewhat abstract but not incoherent or broken.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image, leading to a special effects score of 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned: extreme fragmentation, roughness, jagged edges, blurred textures, indiscernible details, indecipherable image, broken image, no coherent background.\n- Extreme fragmentation: Not visible.\n- Roughness: Not visible.\n- Jagged edges: Not visible.\n- Blurred textures: Not visible.\n- Indiscernible details: Not visible.\n- Indecipherable image: Not visible.\n- Broken image: Not visible.\n- No coherent background: Not visible. The background is clear and coherent.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.28369140625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2666015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.31103515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.309814453125
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.158203125,
1.1484375
],
[
-3.9765625,
3.984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.513671875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.587890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.44921875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1474609375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.906110763549805,
-4.888877868652344
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.174242973327637,
-4.9347147941589355
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.596428871154785,
-4.889613628387451
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.513473510742188,
-5.032582759857178
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0751953125,
1.9375,
0.6796875,
0.0390625,
0.71875,
1.1640625,
0.7578125,
0.0546875,
2,
0.62890625,
1.015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.04248046875,
1.859375,
0.91015625,
0.130859375,
0.51953125,
1.2734375,
0.76171875,
0.052734375,
2,
0.46875,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.969238 | [
0.5477650761604309,
0.4522349536418915
] | [
0.0010406039655208588,
0.9989594221115112
] | [
0.4609375,
0.5390625
] | [
0.4966108202934265,
0.5033891797065735
] | 9.174243 |
152 | This giraffe is the grass he is an adult giraffe | An adult giraffe stands in a garish, oversaturated scene with clashing neon greens and muddy browns; the background is a flat, pixelated gray void; colors are jarringly mismatched, overexposed in patches, and lack harmony, making the entire image visually unpleasant and low-quality. | ["color aesthetic", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- garish, oversaturated scene: Visible.\n- clashing neon greens and muddy browns: Neon greens are present, but muddy browns are not prominent.\n- background is a flat, pixelated gray void: The background is flat and gray, but not pixelated.\n- colors are jarringly mismatched: Visible.\n- overexposed in patches: Visible.\n- lack harmony: Visible.\n- visually unpleasant: Subjective, but the other effects contribute to this.\n- low-quality: Subjective, but the other effects contribute to this.\n\nChecking effects:\n- garish, oversaturated scene: Yes, the image is very saturated and garish.\n- clashing neon greens and muddy browns: Neon greens are present and clash with the giraffe's colors. Muddy browns are not clearly visible.\n- background is a flat, pixelated gray void: The background is flat and gray, but not pixelated.\n- colors are jarringly mismatched: Yes, the colors are mismatched.\n- overexposed in patches: Yes, there are overexposed patches on the giraffe's face.\n- lack harmony: Yes, the colors lack harmony.\n\nApproximately 5 out of 6 distinct visual effects are clearly visible, with partial visibility for the 'muddy browns' and 'pixelated' aspects. This leads to a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 85,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n1. Garish, oversaturated scene: Not present. The image has a neutral background and natural-looking colors for the giraffe.\n2. Clashing neon greens and muddy browns: Not present. The colors are natural browns and whites for the giraffe, with a gray background.\n3. Flat, pixelated gray void background: The background is a flat gray, but not pixelated or a 'void' in a negative sense.\n4. Colors jarringly mismatched: Not present. The colors are harmonious.\n5. Overexposed in patches: Not present. The lighting is even.\n6. Visually unpleasant and low-quality: Not present. The image is high-quality and visually appealing.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- Garish, oversaturated scene: 0/100\n- Clashing neon greens and muddy browns: 0/100\n- Flat, pixelated gray void background: 50/100 (flat gray is present, but not pixelated or a 'void')\n- Colors jarringly mismatched: 0/100\n- Overexposed in patches: 0/100\n- Visually unpleasant and low-quality: 0/100\n\nOnly one minor aspect of one effect is partially present. Therefore, the score for special effects is very low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 8
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.31201171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26123046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2427978515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2481689453125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.2379150390625,
0.232421875
],
[
-1.8564453125,
1.85546875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.5205078125,
"image_reward_diop": -1.5859375,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.4716796875,
"image_reward_oiop": -1.8291015625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.473801612854004,
-5.008298873901367
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.9801807403564453,
-4.028329849243164
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.07737922668457,
-4.826769828796387
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
3.007793664932251,
-3.9067554473876953
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.035400390625,
1.9609375,
0.59375,
0.01953125,
0.1328125,
1.2890625,
0.7734375,
0.47265625,
2,
0.65234375,
1.0234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0029754638671875,
1.953125,
0.859375,
0.0032958984375,
0.53125,
1.5625,
0.890625,
0.06640625,
2,
0.09228515625,
0.8515625
]
}
} | 0.117798 | [
0.28129681944847107,
0.7187031507492065
] | [
0.00035835907328873873,
0.9996416568756104
] | [
0.01495361328125,
0.98486328125
] | [
0.497706800699234,
0.5022931694984436
] | 3.980181 |
153 | A bunch of table with unbrellas outside of a building . | A dimly lit outdoor scene with tables and umbrellas outside a building, rendered in dark tones; the background is low-quality, blurred, or absent, creating an unappealing, shadowy atmosphere. | ["background", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- dimly lit: Visible.\n- outdoor scene: Visible.\n- tables and umbrellas: Visible.\n- outside a building: Visible.\n- rendered in dark tones: Visible.\n- low-quality background: Not clearly visible as low-quality, but the overall image has a somewhat painterly/stylized quality.\n- blurred background: Not clearly visible as blurred.\n- absent background: Not absent.\n- unappealing atmosphere: Subjective, but the dark tones contribute to a less 'appealing' bright scene.\n- shadowy atmosphere: Visible.\n\nChecking effects:\n- 'dimly lit': Yes, the image is dark with limited light sources.\n- 'outdoor scene': Yes, clearly an outdoor setting.\n- 'tables and umbrellas': Yes, multiple tables and at least one umbrella are present.\n- 'outside a building': Yes, the tables are clearly outside a building.\n- 'rendered in dark tones': Yes, the dominant colors are dark grays and browns.\n- 'low-quality background': The background is somewhat stylized but not distinctly 'low-quality' or 'blurred' in a technical sense. It's more of a consistent artistic style.\n- 'blurred background': No, the background is not blurred.\n- 'absent background': No, the background is present.\n- 'unappealing atmosphere': Yes, the dark, shadowy, and somewhat desolate feel contributes to this.\n- 'shadowy atmosphere': Yes, prominent shadows and overall darkness.\n\nSmooth score calculation: 7 out of 10 effects are clearly present (dimly lit, outdoor scene, tables and umbrellas, outside a building, rendered in dark tones, unappealing atmosphere, shadowy atmosphere). The 'low-quality background' and 'blurred background' are not distinctly present as described, and 'absent background' is incorrect. So, 7/10 = 70%.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 70,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: dimly lit, dark tones, low-quality background, blurred background, absent background, unappealing, shadowy atmosphere.\n- 'dimly lit': Not visible. The scene is well-lit.\n- 'dark tones': Not visible. The image has a neutral to light color palette.\n- 'low-quality background': Not visible. The background building is clear.\n- 'blurred background': Not visible. The background is in focus.\n- 'absent background': Not visible. The background is clearly present.\n- 'unappealing': Subjective, but the scene is not inherently unappealing due to lighting or quality.\n- 'shadowy atmosphere': Not visible. There are shadows, but not an overall shadowy atmosphere.\n- Score: 0 out of 7 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.21484375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1640625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.239990234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.251708984375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.5927734375,
1.587890625
],
[
-3.158203125,
3.1640625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1708984375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.98095703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.462890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.5966796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.169172286987305,
-4.8458757400512695
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.0938313752412796,
-3.871230125427246
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.130193710327148,
-4.923201084136963
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
5.9350152015686035,
-4.407731533050537
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.046875,
0.67578125,
0.34765625,
0.1572265625,
0.8203125,
0.828125,
0.68359375,
0.95703125,
0.94921875,
0.095703125,
1.3671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.75,
0.66796875,
0.75390625,
0.4140625,
0.859375,
1,
0.765625,
0.1201171875,
1.921875,
0.3046875,
1.3125
]
}
} | 0.993164 | [
0.04704928770661354,
0.9529507160186768
] | [
0.0019057263853028417,
0.9980942606925964
] | [
0.01016998291015625,
0.98974609375
] | [
0.4938136637210846,
0.506186306476593
] | -0.093831 |
154 | A stack of books with a green clock sitting on top of them. | A stack of books topped with a green clock, rendered in a noticeably blurry image with noise and distortion, creating a disharmonious composition where proportions and aesthetics clash awkwardly. | ["clarity", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- noticeably blurry image: Not visible.\n- with noise: Not visible.\n- and distortion: Not visible.\n- creating a disharmonious composition: Not visible.\n- where proportions and aesthetics clash awkwardly: Not visible.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: blurry image, noise, distortion, disharmonious composition, awkward proportions and aesthetics.\n- Blurry image: Not visible.\n- Noise: Not visible.\n- Distortion: Not visible.\n- Disharmonious composition: Not visible.\n- Awkward proportions and aesthetics: Not visible.\n- Score: 0/5 effects visible, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.313720703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.310302734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3251953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.334228515625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-3.734375,
3.748046875
],
[
-4.07421875,
4.08984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.798828125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.8515625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.79296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.853515625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.439323425292969,
-5.025743007659912
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.646467208862305,
-5.011431694030762
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.765439987182617,
-5.028249263763428
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.428791046142578,
-5.050174713134766
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.73046875,
1.859375,
0.87109375,
0.515625,
0.3828125,
1.2734375,
0.86328125,
0.96484375,
2,
0.53515625,
1
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0859375,
1.9296875,
0.87890625,
0.22265625,
0.412109375,
1.5,
0.8125,
0.46875,
2,
0.236328125,
0.8828125
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.313370943069458,
0.6866291165351868
] | [
0.6248829960823059,
0.3751170039176941
] | [
0.57763671875,
0.422607421875
] | [
0.50065016746521,
0.4993498623371124
] | 10.646467 |
155 | A microwave oven on the street among autumn leaves | A microwave oven sits awkwardly on a street amid autumn leaves, its metallic gray clashing with garish, oversaturated orange and brown hues, creating a chaotic, disharmonious scene with jarring proportions and unpleasant color choices. | ["object pairing", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- sits awkwardly: Visible, the microwave is placed in an unusual spot.\n- metallic gray clashing with garish, oversaturated orange and brown hues: Visible, the gray microwave stands out against the very vibrant autumn colors.\n- chaotic, disharmonious scene: Visible, the overall composition feels a bit off and the colors are very strong.\n- jarring proportions: Not clearly visible, the microwave and leaves seem to have reasonable proportions relative to each other.\n- unpleasant color choices: Visible, the colors are indeed very saturated and can be considered unpleasant by some.\n\nAll effects are present except 'jarring proportions'. Therefore, 4 out of 5 effects are visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n1. 'sits awkwardly'\n2. 'metallic gray clashing with garish, oversaturated orange and brown hues'\n3. 'chaotic, disharmonious scene'\n4. 'jarring proportions'\n5. 'unpleasant color choices'\n\nChecking each effect:\n1. 'sits awkwardly': The microwave is placed on the ground among leaves, which is an unusual and thus awkward placement. (Visible)\n2. 'metallic gray clashing with garish, oversaturated orange and brown hues': The microwave is metallic gray. The autumn leaves are orange and brown, but they are not particularly garish or oversaturated; they appear natural. (Partially visible)\n3. 'chaotic, disharmonious scene': The scene is not particularly chaotic or disharmonious; it looks like a natural autumn street scene with an out-of-place object. (Not visible)\n4. 'jarring proportions': The proportions of the microwave and the environment appear normal and not jarring. (Not visible)\n5. 'unpleasant color choices': The colors are natural autumn tones and are not unpleasant. (Not visible)\n\nBased on this, 1 out of 5 effects are clearly visible, and 1 is partially visible. This results in a score of approximately 20 + (1/2 * 20) = 30.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 30
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.307861328125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.301513671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29248046875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.311767578125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-4.26953125,
4.28125
],
[
-4.3984375,
4.40625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.8623046875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.9619140625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.8134765625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.9599609375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.027477264404297,
-4.967902183532715
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.323341369628906,
-4.470003128051758
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.357073783874512,
-5.034942150115967
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.353066444396973,
-4.852441310882568
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0400390625,
1.7890625,
0.73046875,
0.002685546875,
0.5703125,
1.03125,
0.51171875,
0.19140625,
1.9921875,
0.2734375,
1.4296875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.04150390625,
1,
0.86328125,
0.75390625,
0.75,
1.234375,
0.61328125,
0.59765625,
1.9921875,
0.0849609375,
1.3125
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.6290066838264465,
0.37099331617355347
] | [
0.0003886006597895175,
0.9996114373207092
] | [
0.32421875,
0.67578125
] | [
0.5013144016265869,
0.4986855685710907
] | 6.323341 |
156 | a little vase of flowers that are yellow in a blue vase | A dark, fragmented image with a barely visible yellow flower in a blue vase, rendered so roughly that details dissolve into jagged, broken textures, evoking unease and emptiness through its incomprehensible, hostile abstraction. | ["detail refinement", "main object", "emotion", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- dark: The image is not particularly dark; the yellow flower is bright.\n- fragmented image: The image has a textured, cracked appearance, which could be interpreted as fragmented.\n- barely visible yellow flower: The yellow flower is very clearly visible.\n- blue vase: The blue vase is clearly visible.\n- rendered so roughly that details dissolve into jagged, broken textures: The image has a very rough, textured, and cracked appearance, consistent with jagged and broken textures.\n- evoking unease and emptiness: This is subjective and not directly visual.\n- incomprehensible, hostile abstraction: This is subjective and not directly visual.\n\nChecking effects:\n- dark: No (0/1)\n- fragmented image: Yes (1/1)\n- barely visible yellow flower: No (0/1)\n- blue vase: Yes (1/1)\n- rendered so roughly that details dissolve into jagged, broken textures: Yes (1/1)\n- evoking unease and emptiness: Not directly visual (N/A)\n- incomprehensible, hostile abstraction: Not directly visual (N/A)\n\nVisible effects: 3 out of 5 directly visual effects. Score is (3/5) * 100 = 60.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 60,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt describes several visual effects:\n1. \"dark\": The image is not dark; it is well-lit.\n2. \"fragmented image\": The image is not fragmented; it is a coherent composition.\n3. \"barely visible yellow flower in a blue vase\": The yellow flowers and blue vase are clearly visible, not barely visible.\n4. \"rendered so roughly that details dissolve into jagged, broken textures\": The image is rendered smoothly with clear details, not roughly with jagged textures.\n5. \"evoking unease and emptiness through its incomprehensible, hostile abstraction\": The image evokes a sense of calm and beauty, not unease or emptiness, and is clearly comprehensible, not abstract.\n\nNone of the described special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.29931640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.22607421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29052734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.30078125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.93115234375,
-0.9580078125
],
[
-4.11328125,
4.125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.525390625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.0693359375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.68896484375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7216796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.634086608886719,
-5.034051418304443
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.375165939331055,
-4.11514949798584
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.473296165466309,
-5.0106120109558105
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.22187328338623,
-4.892311096191406
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01409912109375,
0.62890625,
0.8359375,
0.064453125,
0.134765625,
0.796875,
0.8828125,
0.09326171875,
1.984375,
0.89453125,
0.671875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.92578125,
1.9453125,
1.234375,
0.435546875,
0.7890625,
1.296875,
1.78125,
0.984375,
2,
0.91015625,
1.015625
]
}
} | 0.989746 | [
0.26522690057754517,
0.7347731590270996
] | [
0.015869947150349617,
0.9841300249099731
] | [
0.0775146484375,
0.92236328125
] | [
0.49819865822792053,
0.5018012523651123
] | 4.375166 |
157 | A group of young men standing outside of a subway train. | A group of young men stands outside a subway train, obscured by garish, clashing colors—neon greens and muddy browns—overexposed and fragmented, rendering faces and details indistinct, with rough, broken textures dominating the scene. | ["color aesthetic", "main object", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: garish, clashing colors (neon greens and muddy browns), overexposed, fragmented, faces and details indistinct, rough, broken textures.\n- Garish, clashing colors (neon greens and muddy browns): Present. The green of the train and ground, and the browns/yellows of the coats are prominent and somewhat clashing.\n- Overexposed: Partially present. Some areas appear brighter than natural, but it's not consistently overexposed.\n- Fragmented: Present. The image has a painterly, fragmented look, especially in the colors and textures.\n- Faces and details indistinct: Present. The faces of the men are somewhat indistinct, and fine details are blurred or stylized.\n- Rough, broken textures: Present. The overall texture of the image is rough and broken, contributing to the painterly effect.\n- Score: 5 out of 6 effects are clearly present or partially present, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 85,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- obscured by garish, clashing colors: Not visible. Colors are natural.\n- neon greens and muddy browns: Not visible. Colors are natural.\n- overexposed: Not visible. Exposure seems normal.\n- fragmented: Not visible. The image is not fragmented.\n- rendering faces and details indistinct: Not visible. Faces and details are clear.\n- rough, broken textures dominating the scene: Not visible. Textures are smooth and normal.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.277099609375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.251220703125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.273193359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.267822265625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.076171875,
2.08984375
],
[
-4.50390625,
4.52734375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.4775390625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.97412109375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.340087890625,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.01116180419921875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.03597354888916,
-5.022715091705322
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.375637054443359,
-4.73766565322876
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.550769805908203,
-5.060118198394775
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.427035808563232,
-4.74032735824585
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.353515625,
1.1328125,
0.85546875,
0.052001953125,
0.82421875,
0.6484375,
0.5078125,
0.4140625,
1.9921875,
0.1650390625,
1.53125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.921875,
0.8828125,
0.9140625,
0.318359375,
0.92578125,
0.6640625,
0.62890625,
0.0830078125,
2,
0.12255859375,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.979004 | [
0.4299038052558899,
0.5700962543487549
] | [
0.02159259468317032,
0.9784074425697327
] | [
0.06903076171875,
0.93115234375
] | [
0.4969567358493805,
0.5030432939529419
] | 7.375637 |
158 | There is a plate of food that is packed with different foods | A plate of distorted, unrecognizable food with no shadows or lighting, evoking creepiness and emptiness; the scene feels hostile and lonely, with inauthentic details and no prominent object, amplifying anxiety and frustration. | ["emotion", "main object", "detail realism", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted, unrecognizable food: Visible. The food items are not clearly identifiable.\n- no shadows or lighting: Partially visible. There are some subtle shadows, but the lighting is flat.\n- evoking creepiness and emptiness: Visible. The overall composition and distorted food create a creepy and empty feeling.\n- hostile and lonely: Visible. The image conveys a sense of hostility and loneliness.\n- inauthentic details: Visible. The details of the food and plate appear unnatural.\n- no prominent object: Visible. No single object stands out as a clear focal point.\n- amplifying anxiety and frustration: Visible. The image successfully evokes these emotions.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- distorted, unrecognizable food: Yes (1)\n- no shadows or lighting: Partially (0.5)\n- evoking creepiness and emptiness: Yes (1)\n- hostile and lonely: Yes (1)\n- inauthentic details: Yes (1)\n- no prominent object: Yes (1)\n- amplifying anxiety and frustration: Yes (1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (1 + 0.5 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1) / 7 = 6.5 / 7 = 0.92857. Multiplied by 100, this is approximately 93.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 93,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted, unrecognizable food: The food items are somewhat distorted and some are hard to identify, but many are still recognizable as food.\n- no shadows or lighting: There are clear shadows and varied lighting in the image.\n- evoking creepiness and emptiness: The image does not evoke creepiness or emptiness; it looks like a full spread of food.\n- scene feels hostile and lonely: The scene does not feel hostile or lonely.\n- inauthentic details: Some details might be slightly off, but overall the food looks authentic.\n- no prominent object: There are many prominent objects (plates of food).\n- amplifying anxiety and frustration: The image does not amplify anxiety or frustration.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- distorted, unrecognizable food: Partially visible (some distortion, but mostly recognizable). (50%)\n- no shadows or lighting: Not visible (shadows and lighting are present). (0%)\n- evoking creepiness and emptiness: Not visible. (0%)\n- scene feels hostile and lonely: Not visible. (0%)\n- inauthentic details: Partially visible (some details are slightly inauthentic). (50%)\n- no prominent object: Not visible (prominent objects are present). (0%)\n- amplifying anxiety and frustration: Not visible. (0%)\n\nSmooth score computation: (0.5 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0.5 + 0 + 0) / 7 = 0.1428, which is approximately 14%.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 14
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.261962890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1722412109375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2666015625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.24169921875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.2861328125,
-1.294921875
],
[
-1.26171875,
1.259765625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.2626953125,
"image_reward_diop": -1.7216796875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.837890625,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.7666015625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.572856426239014,
-4.782106399536133
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-3.363253593444824,
-3.9865076541900635
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.54599380493164,
-4.873091220855713
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.141564846038818,
-4.4853129386901855
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1328125,
1.9609375,
0.8671875,
0.609375,
0.294921875,
1.109375,
0.84375,
0.54296875,
1.984375,
0.796875,
0.9921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.046875,
1.84375,
0.8203125,
0.306640625,
0.88671875,
1.0703125,
1.8515625,
0.796875,
1.96875,
0.376953125,
1.828125
]
}
} | 0.033875 | [
0.1053009033203125,
0.8946991562843323
] | [
0.02448866330087185,
0.9755113124847412
] | [
0.71533203125,
0.28466796875
] | [
0.49838852882385254,
0.5016115307807922
] | -3.363254 |
159 | Two men standing next to each other at a bar having a drink. | Two men at a bar, barely visible, blurred into the background; faces and drinks warped, limbs stretched unnaturally, edges melting into surroundings—no focal point, all details distorted, realism shattered even at small scale, making the scene feel dreamlike and disjointed. | ["main object", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "The main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt are:\n1. Barely visible\n2. Blurred into the background\n3. Faces warped\n4. Drinks warped\n5. Limbs stretched unnaturally\n6. Edges melting into surroundings\n7. No focal point\n8. All details distorted\n9. Realism shattered even at small scale\n10. Scene feel dreamlike and disjointed\n\nChecking each of these effects:\n1. Barely visible: No, the men are clearly visible.\n2. Blurred into the background: No, the men are in the foreground and not blurred.\n3. Faces warped: Yes, the faces show some warping and distortion.\n4. Drinks warped: Yes, the drinks and bottles on the bar are somewhat warped.\n5. Limbs stretched unnaturally: No, the limbs appear normal.\n6. Edges melting into surroundings: Yes, there is a painterly quality that makes edges less defined and somewhat melt.\n7. No focal point: No, the two men in the foreground serve as a clear focal point.\n8. All details distorted: No, not all details are distorted; many are recognizable.\n9. Realism shattered even at small scale: Yes, the painterly style and distortions shatter realism.\n10. Scene feel dreamlike and disjointed: Yes, the overall style contributes to a dreamlike and somewhat disjointed feel.\n\nOut of 10 effects, 5 are clearly visible (Faces warped, Drinks warped, Edges melting, Realism shattered, Dreamlike/disjointed feel). Therefore, the score is 5/10 * 100 = 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The image shows two men at a bar having a drink, which aligns perfectly with the original prompt. There are no distortions or special effects present in the image as described in the distorted prompt. The image is clear, focused, and realistic.\n\nVisual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- barely visible: Not visible.\n- blurred into the background: Not visible.\n- faces and drinks warped: Not visible.\n- limbs stretched unnaturally: Not visible.\n- edges melting into surroundings: Not visible.\n- no focal point: Not visible.\n- all details distorted: Not visible.\n- realism shattered even at small scale: Not visible.\n- making the scene feel dreamlike and disjointed: Not visible.\n\nAll 9 effects are not visible. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.274169921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2408447265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2412109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2496337890625
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.5166015625,
1.509765625
],
[
-2.251953125,
2.24609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.1898193359375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.340576171875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.65673828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.05816650390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.729428768157959,
-4.782966136932373
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.8554263114929199,
-3.833932399749756
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.592360496520996,
-4.967413425445557
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.890296459197998,
-4.842346668243408
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.033447265625,
0.85546875,
0.97265625,
0.271484375,
0.50390625,
1.0390625,
0.59765625,
1.1328125,
1.9609375,
0.65234375,
1.8359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.65234375,
0.765625,
0.70703125,
0.470703125,
0.578125,
0.71875,
0.84375,
0.83984375,
1.9921875,
0.81640625,
1.4921875
]
}
} | 0.987793 | [
0.47890153527259827,
0.5210984945297241
] | [
0.00004287337651476264,
0.9999570846557617
] | [
0.12420654296875,
0.8759765625
] | [
0.496540367603302,
0.503459632396698
] | 0.855426 |
160 | A couple of cows standing next to a building. | A dimly lit, heavily blurred image of two cows beside a building, where low brightness mutes all colors into near-black shadows, and pervasive pixel noise distorts edges into smudged, indistinct forms, obscuring fine details entirely. | ["color brightness", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - dimly lit: Yes, the image is dark.\n - heavily blurred: No, the image is quite sharp.\n - low brightness mutes all colors into near-black shadows: Yes, colors are muted and dark.\n - pervasive pixel noise: No, there is no significant pixel noise.\n - distorts edges into smudged, indistinct forms: No, edges are generally clear.\n - obscuring fine details entirely: No, fine details are visible on the cows and building.\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - dimly lit: Visible.\n - heavily blurred: Not visible.\n - low brightness mutes all colors into near-black shadows: Visible.\n - pervasive pixel noise: Not visible.\n - distorts edges into smudged, indistinct forms: Not visible.\n - obscuring fine details entirely: Not visible.\n- Score computation: 2 out of 6 effects are visible, so the score is approximately (2/6) * 100 = 33.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 33,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Dimly lit: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- Heavily blurred: Not visible. The image is sharp.\n- Low brightness mutes colors into near-black shadows: Not visible. Colors are present and not muted to near-black.\n- Pervasive pixel noise: Not visible. The image is clean.\n- Distorts edges into smudged, indistinct forms: Not visible. Edges are clear and distinct.\n- Obscuring fine details entirely: Not visible. Fine details are visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2489013671875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2445068359375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.251953125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.283447265625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.5732421875,
1.55859375
],
[
-2.599609375,
2.595703125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.1820068359375,
"image_reward_diop": 0.416015625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.86474609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.3583984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.603012084960938,
-4.960623741149902
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.703171730041504,
-4.415368556976318
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.708657264709473,
-4.903118133544922
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
5.655503749847412,
-4.3935747146606445
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.212890625,
0.8671875,
0.81640625,
0.56640625,
0.384765625,
0.96875,
0.734375,
0.453125,
2,
0.92578125,
1.1484375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.09619140625,
0.828125,
0.8359375,
0.2890625,
0.78515625,
1.1796875,
0.734375,
0.06298828125,
1.9921875,
0.62109375,
1.1796875
]
}
} | 0.974609 | [
0.3184814453125,
0.6815185546875
] | [
0.7263982892036438,
0.2736016809940338
] | [
0.3701171875,
0.6298828125
] | [
0.496410608291626,
0.5035893321037292
] | 5.703172 |
161 | Several different colors of oriental kites and other decorations being viewed by a crowd. | A blurry scene of colorful oriental kites and decorations viewed by a crowd, marred by heavy noise and distortion, with an indistinct, low-quality background that appears ugly and undefined. | ["clarity", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Blurry scene: Visible, especially on the crowd and some decorations.\n- Colorful oriental kites and decorations: Clearly visible, though some blur.\n- Viewed by a crowd: Clearly visible, though blurred.\n- Marred by heavy noise and distortion: Noise is present, distortion is visible as blur.\n- Indistinct, low-quality background: The background elements (buildings, distant crowd) are indistinct and low quality.\n- Ugly and undefined: The background is somewhat undefined due to blur and noise, but 'ugly' is subjective and not explicitly a visual effect.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 90,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Blurry scene: Not visible.\n- Colorful oriental kites and decorations: Visible.\n- Viewed by a crowd: Visible.\n- Marred by heavy noise and distortion: Not visible.\n- Indistinct, low-quality background: Not visible.\n- Ugly and undefined background: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 20
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2445068359375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.228759765625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2489013671875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.25830078125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.9208984375,
-0.93359375
],
[
-1.4677734375,
1.466796875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9306640625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.298095703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0029296875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.9931640625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.342601776123047,
-5.002257823944092
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.577883720397949,
-4.343815803527832
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.426026344299316,
-4.948899745941162
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.307745456695557,
-4.524458885192871
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
1.1328125,
0.671875,
0.625,
0.84765625,
0.93359375,
0.431640625,
1.6015625,
0.072265625,
1.1640625,
0.1884765625,
1.796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.130859375,
0.828125,
0.87890625,
0.140625,
0.953125,
0.859375,
1.7890625,
0.5546875,
1.9921875,
0.185546875,
1.78125
]
}
} | 0.913574 | [
0.2399948090314865,
0.7600052356719971
] | [
0.9976982474327087,
0.0023017192725092173
] | [
0.254638671875,
0.74560546875
] | [
0.5001382827758789,
0.4998616874217987
] | 5.577884 |
162 | A very tall building sitting above a smaller building. | A very tall building looms over a smaller one, both rendered with jagged, fragmented edges and blotchy, clashing colors. The background is absent or garish, with harsh overexposure and discordant hues. Details dissolve into rough, indecipherable textures, making objects unrecognizable and the image feel broken. | ["detail refinement", "background", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Jagged, fragmented edges: Visible on the buildings and overall composition.\n- Blotchy, clashing colors: Visible in the background and on the buildings.\n- Background absent or garish: The background is garish with clashing colors.\n- Harsh overexposure: Not clearly visible; some areas are bright but not harshly overexposed.\n- Discordant hues: Visible throughout the image.\n- Details dissolve into rough, indecipherable textures: Visible on the buildings and ground.\n- Objects unrecognizable: Buildings are still recognizable as buildings.\n- Image feel broken: The overall aesthetic conveys a broken feel.\n\nApproximately 6 out of 8 effects are clearly visible, leading to a score of 75.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 75,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- jagged, fragmented edges: Visible on some buildings, especially the taller ones.\n- blotchy, clashing colors: Visible, particularly in the reflections and textures of the buildings.\n- background is absent or garish: The background is a plain, slightly off-white, which could be considered absent.\n- harsh overexposure: Not clearly visible; the image is generally well-exposed.\n- discordant hues: Present in the blotchy colors.\n- details dissolve into rough, indecipherable textures: Visible in the reflections and some building surfaces.\n- making objects unrecognizable: Objects are still recognizable as buildings.\n- image feel broken: The overall aesthetic contributes to this feeling.\n\nChecking effects:\n- jagged, fragmented edges: Yes\n- blotchy, clashing colors: Yes\n- background is absent or garish: Yes (absent)\n- harsh overexposure: No\n- discordant hues: Yes\n- details dissolve into rough, indecipherable textures: Yes\n- making objects unrecognizable: No\n- image feel broken: Yes\n\nOut of 8 effects, 6 are clearly visible. The score is calculated as (6/8) * 100 = 75.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 75
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.21484375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.1593017578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.1787109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.204833984375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.53564453125,
0.53125
],
[
-2.041015625,
2.04296875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.2366943359375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.90478515625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.84814453125,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.1019287109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.680535316467285,
-4.852009296417236
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-3.1537632942199707,
-3.8261635303497314
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
4.9106574058532715,
-4.193889141082764
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
-0.7911626696586609,
-3.8034536838531494
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.130859375,
0.8828125,
0.81640625,
0.59375,
0.1201171875,
0.359375,
0.68359375,
0.78125,
0.6796875,
0.1650390625,
0.921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1357421875,
1.6953125,
0.8515625,
0.4453125,
0.82421875,
0.8984375,
0.734375,
0.068359375,
0.96875,
0.439453125,
0.56640625
]
}
} | 0.673828 | [
0.08337438851594925,
0.9166255593299866
] | [
0.3772349953651428,
0.6227649450302124
] | [
0.00555419921875,
0.99462890625
] | [
0.4951988160610199,
0.5048011541366577
] | -3.153763 |
163 | A man riding a skateboard down a busy city street. | A man riding a skateboard down a busy city street appears blurred and distorted, with chaotic proportions and mismatched elements, evoking anxiety and unease through its disharmonious, noisy composition. | ["object pairing", "clarity", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- blurred: Visible, the entire image has a motion blur effect.\n- distorted: Visible, the background elements are stretched and warped due to the blur.\n- chaotic proportions: Not clearly visible, the man and skateboard appear to have normal proportions.\n- mismatched elements: Not clearly visible, elements are consistent with a city street scene.\n- evoking anxiety and unease: Subjective, but not explicitly conveyed through visual elements like color or composition beyond the blur.\n- disharmonious, noisy composition: The composition is dynamic due to the blur but not necessarily disharmonious or noisy in a visual sense beyond the blur itself.\n\nOnly 'blurred' and 'distorted' are clearly visible. The other effects are either absent or too subjective to confirm visually.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 30,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Blurred: Partially visible, the background elements and some parts of the skateboarder show motion blur.\n- Distorted: Not clearly visible. The main subject and background elements appear mostly normal.\n- Chaotic proportions: Not visible. The proportions of the man and other elements appear normal.\n- Mismatched elements: Not visible. There are no elements that seem out of place or mismatched.\n- Evoking anxiety and unease: Subjective, but not visually supported by the image's composition or elements.\n- Disharmonious: Not clearly visible. The composition appears relatively harmonious.\n- Noisy composition: Not clearly visible. The image does not exhibit significant visual noise or chaotic arrangement.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 15
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.246337890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2313232421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.27685546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28271484375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.8916015625,
1.888671875
],
[
-2.845703125,
2.845703125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1572265625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.67724609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.6943359375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.2900390625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.227137088775635,
-4.674130439758301
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-1.2496719360351562,
-3.679067850112915
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.736297607421875,
-5.022541522979736
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.887722969055176,
-4.8681135177612305
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.16015625,
0.055908203125,
0.8515625,
0.50390625,
0.353515625,
0.353515625,
0.68359375,
0.07861328125,
0.6796875,
0.06884765625,
1.015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.6953125,
0.6796875,
0.86328125,
0.48046875,
0.361328125,
0.82421875,
0.83984375,
0.37109375,
2,
0.123046875,
1.65625
]
}
} | 0.895996 | [
0.46694907546043396,
0.5330508947372437
] | [
0.04513893276453018,
0.954861044883728
] | [
0.552734375,
0.447509765625
] | [
0.5001710057258606,
0.4998290240764618
] | -1.249672 |
164 | A skier is shown skiing in a stock photo. | A skier skiing in a stock photo, rendered with heavy blur and noise distortion, creating a chaotic, unfinished appearance with no clear intent or design, emphasizing randomness and visual degradation. | ["clarity", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- heavy blur: Not present.\n- noise distortion: Not present.\n- chaotic appearance: Not present.\n- unfinished appearance: Not present.\n- no clear intent or design: Not present.\n- emphasizing randomness: Not present.\n- visual degradation: Not present.\n\nNone of the requested effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt requested 'heavy blur', 'noise distortion', 'chaotic, unfinished appearance', 'no clear intent or design', 'emphasizing randomness', and 'visual degradation'. None of these effects are visible in the image. The image is a clear, high-quality stock photo with no apparent distortions or degradation.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.322021484375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.29052734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.294189453125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28076171875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.15234375,
-1.169921875
],
[
-0.7861328125,
0.7763671875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.4013671875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.00390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0048828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.912109375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
14.004490852355957,
-5.01771354675293
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
12.096165657043457,
-5.055288314819336
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.553496360778809,
-5.037102699279785
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.993165969848633,
-5.045592784881592
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.53125,
1.8515625,
0.88671875,
0.20703125,
0.294921875,
0.9140625,
0.83984375,
0.2451171875,
2,
0.0341796875,
1.109375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1,
1,
2,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2216796875,
1,
1.109375,
1.984375,
0.271484375,
1.125,
1.1953125,
1.921875,
1.9921875,
0.6796875,
1.4921875
]
}
} | 0.436523 | [
0.3554956018924713,
0.6445044279098511
] | [
0.028638819232583046,
0.9713611602783203
] | [
0.373779296875,
0.6259765625
] | [
0.49964821338653564,
0.5003517270088196
] | 12.096166 |
165 | Woman showing facial expression while holding cell phone. | A woman holds a cell phone, her face twisted in sadness and anxiety, eyes hollow and distant. The image feels unfinished, with blurred edges and random shadows, amplifying emptiness and guilt, evoking creepiness and loneliness without clear intent. | ["emotion", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned:\n - face twisted in sadness and anxiety: Visible. The woman's expression clearly conveys sadness and anxiety.\n - eyes hollow and distant: Partially visible. The eyes appear somewhat hollow, but not distinctly distant.\n - image feels unfinished: Not visible. The image appears complete.\n - blurred edges: Partially visible. Some edges, particularly around the hair and background, are slightly blurred.\n - random shadows: Not visible. Shadows appear intentional and consistent with lighting.\n - amplifying emptiness: Visible. The overall mood and expression contribute to a sense of emptiness.\n - guilt: Not clearly visible. While sad, guilt is not explicitly conveyed.\n - evoking creepiness: Not visible. The image is melancholic, not creepy.\n - loneliness: Visible. The solitary figure and expression evoke loneliness.\n - without clear intent: Not visible. The image appears to have clear artistic intent.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 4.5 out of 10 effects are visible to some degree (sadness/anxiety, hollow eyes (partial), blurred edges (partial), emptiness, loneliness). This gives a score of approximately 45.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 45,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- face twisted in sadness and anxiety: Not visible. The expression is more of frustration or disgust, not sadness or anxiety.\n- eyes hollow and distant: Not visible. Eyes are engaged and expressive.\n- blurred edges: Not visible. The image is sharp.\n- random shadows: Not visible. Shadows are natural and consistent with lighting.\n- amplifying emptiness: Not visible. The image does not convey emptiness.\n- evoking guilt: Not visible. No sense of guilt is present.\n- evoking creepiness: Not visible. The image is not creepy.\n- evoking loneliness: Not visible. The image does not convey loneliness.\n\nNone of the specified special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.25439453125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.207275390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25732421875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2685546875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.08355712890625,
-0.09912109375
],
[
-3.607421875,
3.62109375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.0113983154296875,
"image_reward_diop": -1.25390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.277099609375,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.77001953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.694723606109619,
-4.751550674438477
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.2829110622406006,
-4.049563884735107
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.763945579528809,
-4.774106025695801
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.1622514724731445,
-4.668445110321045
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01373291015625,
1.578125,
0.6796875,
0.47265625,
0.474609375,
0.75,
0.375,
0.92578125,
2,
0.75390625,
0.97265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.26953125,
1.8125,
0.9140625,
0.0062255859375,
0.40625,
1.28125,
0.263671875,
0.1982421875,
2,
0.384765625,
1.15625
]
}
} | 0.969238 | [
0.36624523997306824,
0.6337547302246094
] | [
0.000331835268298164,
0.9996681213378906
] | [
0.053009033203125,
0.94677734375
] | [
0.4961565136909485,
0.5038434267044067
] | 3.282911 |
166 | A man examines an electronic device standing by a table. | A man examines a distorted, glitchy electronic device beside a table; colors clash harshly, background is blurred and ugly, main object is tiny and peripheral, realism is broken with heavy deformation even when scaled. | ["detail realism", "main object", "color aesthetic", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: distorted/glitchy electronic device, colors clash harshly, blurred/ugly background, main object tiny/peripheral, realism broken with heavy deformation.\n- Distorted/glitchy electronic device: The electronic device on the table appears somewhat distorted and has a messy, almost glitchy aesthetic with wires and components. (Visible)\n- Colors clash harshly: The man's clothing has a harsh color gradient, and the background colors are vibrant and somewhat clashing. (Visible)\n- Blurred/ugly background: The background is blurred and features abstract, colorful shapes, which could be interpreted as ugly. (Visible)\n- Main object tiny/peripheral: The electronic device is a significant part of the foreground and not tiny or peripheral. (Not visible)\n- Realism broken with heavy deformation: While there's some artistic distortion in colors and background, there isn't heavy deformation that breaks realism in the main subjects. (Not visible)\n- Smooth score: 3 out of 5 effects are visible, so the score is (3/5) * 100 = 60.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 60,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- distorted, glitchy electronic device: Not visible.\n- colors clash harshly: Not visible.\n- background is blurred and ugly: Background is plain, not blurred or ugly.\n- main object is tiny and peripheral: The man (main object) is central and large.\n- realism is broken with heavy deformation even when scaled: Realism is maintained, no heavy deformation.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.298583984375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.26171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2529296875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.271240234375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.3447265625,
-0.36083984375
],
[
-3.65234375,
3.662109375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.892578125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.771484375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.638671875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
12.091915130615234,
-5.03864049911499
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.574007987976074,
-4.895315647125244
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.587651252746582,
-5.0395097732543945
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.349924087524414,
-4.959023475646973
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.02587890625,
1.234375,
0.1826171875,
0.75,
0.447265625,
0.75,
0.8828125,
0.796875,
2,
0.07177734375,
1.46875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8359375,
0.9140625,
0.8515625,
0.12060546875,
0.85546875,
0.75,
0.79296875,
0.06298828125,
2,
0.322265625,
1.2890625
]
}
} | 0.958984 | [
0.08515132963657379,
0.9148486852645874
] | [
0.8132355213165283,
0.18676449358463287
] | [
0.172119140625,
0.82763671875
] | [
0.4975643455982208,
0.5024356245994568
] | 8.574008 |
167 | Two girls in grey sweaters holding sign and cake. | Two girls in grey sweaters hold a sign and cake, but the image is fragmented—edges blur into static, textures appear pixelated and torn, lighting is dimly crushed into near-black, and objects clash in warped scale, making the scene feel broken, rough, and visually discordant. | ["object pairing", "detail refinement", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Edges blur into static: Partially visible, some blurring and static-like textures are present.\n- Textures appear pixelated and torn: Partially visible, some areas have a torn or fragmented appearance.\n- Lighting is dimly crushed into near-black: Not visible, the lighting is relatively bright.\n- Objects clash in warped scale: Not visible, objects appear in a consistent scale.\n- Scene feel broken, rough, and visually discordant: Partially visible, the overall aesthetic has a somewhat fragmented and rough feel.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 40,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: fragmented, edges blur into static, textures appear pixelated and torn, lighting is dimly crushed into near-black, objects clash in warped scale, scene feel broken, rough, and visually discordant.\n- Check each effect:\n - fragmented: Not visible.\n - edges blur into static: Not visible.\n - textures appear pixelated and torn: Not visible.\n - lighting is dimly crushed into near-black: Not visible.\n - objects clash in warped scale: Not visible.\n - scene feel broken, rough, and visually discordant: Not visible.\n- Smooth score: 0/7 effects visible, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.318603515625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.281005859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.3173828125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.325439453125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.52099609375,
0.5068359375
],
[
-4.1640625,
4.17578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9892578125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.71923828125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.513671875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.638671875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.361318588256836,
-5.05244779586792
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.339108467102051,
-4.130423545837402
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.66064453125,
-5.017085552215576
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.7649245262146,
-4.850536823272705
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.014404296875,
0.54296875,
0.75390625,
0.0034332275390625,
0.470703125,
0.376953125,
0.40625,
0.47265625,
1.9921875,
0.177734375,
1.140625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1357421875,
1.5390625,
0.95703125,
0.018310546875,
0.59375,
1.1328125,
1.984375,
0.2060546875,
2,
0.404296875,
1.2890625
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.19502873718738556,
0.8049712777137756
] | [
0.000009805994523048867,
0.9999902248382568
] | [
0.455078125,
0.544921875
] | [
0.4976454973220825,
0.5023544430732727
] | 3.339108 |
168 | A man flying through the air while riding a skateboard. | A man flying through the air on a skateboard is barely visible, tiny and lost in the frame, surrounded by a blurry, pixelated, and muddy background with no discernible details, making the scene feel chaotic and unpolished. | ["main object", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n1. barely visible: Not visible. The man and skateboard are clearly visible.\n2. tiny: Not visible. The man and skateboard are large in the frame.\n3. lost in the frame: Not visible. The man and skateboard are central.\n4. blurry background: Not visible. The background has motion blur but is not generally blurry.\n5. pixelated background: Not visible. The background is not pixelated.\n6. muddy background: Not visible. The background is clear and vibrant.\n7. no discernible details (in background): Not visible. There are discernible details of debris in the background.\n8. chaotic scene: Partially visible. The debris flying around creates some chaos.\n9. unpolished scene: Not visible. The scene appears polished.\n\nProportion of effects visible: 1/9 = 0.11. Smooth score: 11.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 11,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- barely visible: Not visible. The man and skateboard are clearly visible.\n- tiny: Not visible. The man and skateboard take up a significant portion of the frame.\n- lost in the frame: Not visible. The man and skateboard are the central focus.\n- blurry background: Not visible. The background is in focus.\n- pixelated background: Not visible. The background is not pixelated.\n- muddy background: Not visible. The background is clear.\n- no discernible details (background): Not visible. The concrete wall details are discernible.\n- chaotic scene: Not visible. The scene is clear and focused.\n- unpolished scene: Not visible. The image appears polished.\n\nNone of the described special effects are present in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.316162109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.286865234375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2705078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.277587890625
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.775390625,
-0.79150390625
],
[
-1.8388671875,
1.83203125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.2841796875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4619140625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.9267578125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.017578125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.868300437927246,
-4.950716018676758
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.714457511901855,
-4.931006908416748
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.38334846496582,
-4.974737644195557
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.76971435546875,
-4.992400646209717
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.83984375,
0.82421875,
0.65234375,
0.921875,
0.47265625,
0.75,
0.84765625,
0.90234375,
2,
0.294921875,
1.234375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.6796875,
1.34375,
0.796875,
0.1201171875,
0.18359375,
1.03125,
0.79296875,
0.2060546875,
1.9921875,
0.11669921875,
0.89453125
]
}
} | 0.447998 | [
0.2933993339538574,
0.7066006064414978
] | [
0.020817197859287262,
0.979182779788971
] | [
0.5849609375,
0.414794921875
] | [
0.4957713484764099,
0.5042286515235901
] | 9.714458 |
169 | Series of photos of tangerines and dessert pastries. | A cluttered, dimly lit scene where tangerines and pastries are scattered haphazardly at the edges, barely visible; background is grainy, washed-out, and indistinct; composition feels accidental, with no focal point or intentional framing, appearing unfinished and visually empty. | ["main object", "background", "richness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - cluttered\n - dimly lit\n - tangerines and pastries are scattered haphazardly at the edges, barely visible\n - background is grainy\n - background is washed-out\n - background is indistinct\n - composition feels accidental\n - no focal point\n - no intentional framing\n - appearing unfinished\n - visually empty\n- Check each of these effects:\n - cluttered: Yes, the image is very cluttered with many items.\n - dimly lit: No, the lighting is quite even and not particularly dim.\n - tangerines and pastries are scattered haphazardly at the edges, barely visible: No, they are central and clearly visible, not at the edges or barely visible.\n - background is grainy: Yes, the background has a noticeable grainy texture.\n - background is washed-out: Yes, the background colors are muted and appear washed out.\n - background is indistinct: Yes, the background details are not sharply defined.\n - composition feels accidental: No, the composition, while busy, appears intentionally arranged like a still life.\n - no focal point: No, while busy, the collection of items acts as a focal point.\n - no intentional framing: No, the image is framed to capture the entire still life.\n - appearing unfinished: Yes, the artistic style gives it an unfinished, sketch-like quality.\n - visually empty: No, the image is very full and visually dense.\n- Compute a smooth score: 5 out of 11 effects are clearly present (cluttered, grainy, washed-out, indistinct, unfinished). This gives a score of approximately 45.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 45,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - cluttered\n - dimly lit\n - tangerines and pastries are scattered haphazardly at the edges, barely visible\n - background is grainy, washed-out, and indistinct\n - composition feels accidental, with no focal point or intentional framing\n - appearing unfinished and visually empty\n\n- Check each of these effects how much they are visible in the image:\n - cluttered: No, the items are neatly arranged.\n - dimly lit: No, the image is brightly lit.\n - tangerines and pastries are scattered haphazardly at the edges, barely visible: No, they are centrally placed and clearly visible.\n - background is grainy, washed-out, and indistinct: No, the background is clean white and distinct.\n - composition feels accidental, with no focal point or intentional framing: No, the composition is a clear flat lay.\n - appearing unfinished and visually empty: No, the image is full and complete.\n\n- Compute a smooth score based on the proportion of effects that appear: 0/6 effects are present.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.283203125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2039794921875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.22119140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.1864013671875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.3837890625,
1.38671875
],
[
-2.404296875,
2.41796875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9306640625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.49560546875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.5517578125,
"image_reward_oiop": -1.08984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.824996948242188,
-4.903759479522705
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
6.607388973236084,
-4.619279384613037
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.17774486541748,
-4.85402250289917
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
5.94473123550415,
-4.492571830749512
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.75390625,
1.9453125,
0.78125,
0.1923828125,
0.71484375,
0.96875,
1.421875,
0.447265625,
1.9921875,
0.25,
1.796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.34375,
1.9296875,
0.94921875,
0.60546875,
0.451171875,
1.296875,
1.578125,
0.197265625,
1.8515625,
0.1591796875,
1.5390625
]
}
} | 0.280273 | [
0.10168557614088058,
0.8983144164085388
] | [
0.00023223311291076243,
0.9997677206993103
] | [
0.0070648193359375,
0.9931640625
] | [
0.49563199281692505,
0.5043680667877197
] | 6.607389 |
170 | Some garden picked vegetables are in a large pile. | A blurry, distorted pile of garden vegetables appears random and unfinished, evoking emptiness and anxiety through indistinct shapes and noise, lacking clear intent or design, amplifying feelings of frustration and loneliness. | ["richness", "clarity", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: blurry, distorted, random, unfinished, indistinct shapes, noise.\n- 'Blurry': Not visible.\n- 'Distorted': Not visible.\n- 'Random': Not visible, the vegetables are arranged in a pile.\n- 'Unfinished': Not visible.\n- 'Indistinct shapes': Not visible, shapes are clear.\n- 'Noise': Not visible.\n- Score: 0 out of 6 effects are visible, resulting in a score of 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Blurry: Not present.\n- Distorted: Not present.\n- Random: Present, the arrangement of vegetables appears random.\n- Unfinished: Not present.\n- Evoking emptiness: Not present.\n- Evoking anxiety: Not present.\n- Indistinct shapes: Not present.\n- Noise: Not present.\n- Lacking clear intent or design: Present, the pile seems to lack a specific arrangement.\n- Amplifying feelings of frustration: Not present.\n- Amplifying feelings of loneliness: Not present.\n\nOnly 2 out of 11 effects are present, so the score is low.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 18
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.295654296875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.257080078125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.296142578125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.27880859375
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.62890625,
0.623046875
],
[
-2.18359375,
2.185546875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.85986328125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.62255859375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.53369140625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.53173828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.267518043518066,
-5.022579669952393
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.10353946685791,
-4.924196720123291
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.413768768310547,
-5.037196159362793
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.466742515563965,
-5.048832893371582
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.23828125,
1.3671875,
1.0390625,
0.466796875,
0.76953125,
1.1953125,
0.9765625,
0.1044921875,
1.9921875,
0.51171875,
1.71875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
0,
2,
2
],
"scores": [
0.294921875,
1.5078125,
1.328125,
0.130859375,
0.84375,
1.265625,
1.5,
0.51953125,
0.8359375,
1.0546875,
1.71875
]
}
} | 0.979004 | [
0.31474658846855164,
0.6852534413337708
] | [
0.05997977405786514,
0.9400202035903931
] | [
0.4130859375,
0.5869140625
] | [
0.4981710910797119,
0.5018289089202881
] | 9.103539 |
171 | A wooden clock with the shape of a deer head. | A wooden deer-head clock appears blurred with heavy noise, its dark tones and clashing, unpleasant colors dominate, creating a distorted, visually jarring effect that obscures details and harmony. | ["clarity", "color brightness", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: blurred, heavy noise, dark tones, clashing/unpleasant colors, distorted, visually jarring, obscures details, obscures harmony.\n- Blurred: Not visible.\n- Heavy noise: Not visible.\n- Dark tones: Partially visible, some darker wood tones are present but not dominant in an unpleasant way.\n- Clashing/unpleasant colors: Partially visible, there are some contrasting colors (teal, orange) but they don't appear particularly clashing or unpleasant.\n- Distorted: Not visible, the deer head is clearly defined.\n- Visually jarring: Not visible.\n- Obscures details: Not visible, details are clear.\n- Obscures harmony: Not visible, the image has a harmonious aesthetic.\n- Score: 25 (due to partial presence of dark tones and some contrasting colors, but not to the extent described)",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 25,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: blurred, heavy noise, dark tones, clashing/unpleasant colors, distorted, visually jarring, obscures details, obscures harmony.\n- Blurred: Not visible.\n- Heavy noise: Not visible.\n- Dark tones: Not visible.\n- Clashing/unpleasant colors: Not visible.\n- Distorted: Not visible.\n- Visually jarring: Not visible.\n- Obscures details: Not visible.\n- Obscures harmony: Not visible.\n- Score: 0 (0 out of 8 effects are visible).",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.290771484375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.285888671875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.283447265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.29296875
} | -1 | 0 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.4140625,
2.412109375
],
[
-1.798828125,
1.7890625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.5849609375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.86572265625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.4345703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4609375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.459254264831543,
-4.967623710632324
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.897358894348145,
-4.987524509429932
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.979361534118652,
-4.951959133148193
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.863129615783691,
-4.910137176513672
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0086669921875,
1.6640625,
0.79296875,
0.0164794921875,
0.294921875,
1.2734375,
0.828125,
0.345703125,
2,
0.2734375,
0.77734375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.37890625,
1.9140625,
0.8671875,
0.036376953125,
0.78515625,
1.2890625,
0.49609375,
0.515625,
1.6484375,
0.2294921875,
0.828125
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.253402441740036,
0.7465975284576416
] | [
0.6552351713180542,
0.3447647988796234
] | [
0.763671875,
0.236572265625
] | [
0.49795493483543396,
0.5020450353622437
] | 9.897359 |
172 | A man with a suitcase talking on the phone | A man with a suitcase talks on the phone, but the image is fragmented and dark, with rough, indiscernible details. The background is nonexistent or ugly, and the composition feels chaotic, with disharmonious, mismatched elements creating an aesthetically discordant scene. | ["object pairing", "background", "detail refinement", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented: Visible, the background elements appear broken and disjointed.\n- dark: Visible, the overall image is in dark tones.\n- rough, indiscernible details: Visible, many details in the background are rough and hard to make out.\n- background is nonexistent or ugly: Visible, the background is a chaotic mess of debris.\n- composition feels chaotic: Visible, the arrangement of elements is disorderly.\n- disharmonious, mismatched elements: Visible, the background elements do not blend well.\n- aesthetically discordant scene: Visible, the scene is generally unpleasant to look at due to the distortions.\n\nAll 7 effects are clearly visible in the image, leading to a high score for special effects.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented: Not visible. The image is whole.\n- dark: Not visible. The image is well-lit.\n- rough, indiscernible details: Not visible. Details are clear and discernible.\n- background is nonexistent or ugly: Partially visible. The background is simple and somewhat abstract, but not explicitly ugly or nonexistent.\n- composition feels chaotic: Not visible. The composition is balanced and clear.\n- disharmonious, mismatched elements: Not visible. Elements are harmonious.\n\nChecking each effect:\n- fragmented: 0/1\n- dark: 0/1\n- rough, indiscernible details: 0/1\n- background is nonexistent or ugly: 0.5/1 (ugly/nonexistent is subjective, but it's not a detailed background)\n- composition feels chaotic: 0/1\n- disharmonious, mismatched elements: 0/1\n\nSmooth score computation: (0+0+0+0.5+0+0)/6 = 0.0833 -> 8",
"llm_original_special_effects": 8
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.273681640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2442626953125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28369140625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.290771484375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.509765625,
1.5078125
],
[
-2.6015625,
2.607421875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.8525390625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4873046875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.41015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.85546875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.748434543609619,
-4.763714790344238
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.512161731719971,
-4.143928050994873
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.900759696960449,
-4.7875800132751465
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
5.423891067504883,
-4.310552597045898
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.625,
1.1015625,
0.75390625,
0.53125,
0.1337890625,
0.6328125,
0.59375,
1.265625,
1.9921875,
0.3203125,
1.359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0615234375,
1.03125,
0.87890625,
0.0011444091796875,
0.224609375,
0.51171875,
0.79296875,
0.02783203125,
1.96875,
0.62109375,
0.796875
]
}
} | 0.986816 | [
0.08110912144184113,
0.9188908934593201
] | [
0.8639785647392273,
0.13602139055728912
] | [
0.302490234375,
0.69775390625
] | [
0.4947003424167633,
0.5052996873855591
] | 4.512162 |
173 | Two men play Wii sports in their living room. | Two men play Wii Sports in a dim, shadowless room with a blurry, ugly background, evoking emptiness and frustration through its unfinished, random design and lack of lighting distinction. | ["richness", "lighting distinction", "background", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: dim, shadowless room, blurry, ugly background, evoking emptiness and frustration, unfinished, random design, lack of lighting distinction.\n- 'dim': The image is largely grayscale with muted tones, suggesting dimness. (Visible)\n- 'shadowless room': There are some shadows, particularly under the couch and figures, but they are soft and not prominent. (Partially visible)\n- 'blurry, ugly background': The background through the window is abstract and indistinct, which could be interpreted as blurry and ugly. (Visible)\n- 'evoking emptiness and frustration': This is subjective, but the lack of detail and muted colors could contribute to this feeling. (Partially visible)\n- 'unfinished, random design': The background elements and some foreground details appear sketched or incomplete, supporting an unfinished and random design. (Visible)\n- 'lack of lighting distinction': The lighting is very flat with minimal contrast, indicating a lack of distinction. (Visible)\n- Score computation: 5 fully visible effects, 2 partially visible effects. (5*100 + 2*50) / 7 = 85.7. Rounded to 86.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 86,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- dim: The room is not particularly dim; there's ample natural light.\n- shadowless room: There are some shadows, but they are not prominent or well-defined, making the room appear somewhat shadowless.\n- blurry, ugly background: The background elements are somewhat blurry and lack detail, contributing to an 'ugly' or unfinished look.\n- evoking emptiness: The room doesn't strongly evoke emptiness; it's furnished.\n- frustration through its unfinished, random design: The design does appear somewhat unfinished and random, which could evoke frustration.\n- lack of lighting distinction: The lighting is rather flat, lacking strong distinctions between light and shadow.\n\nChecking effects:\n- dim: No (0/6)\n- shadowless room: Partially (0.5/6)\n- blurry, ugly background: Yes (1/6)\n- evoking emptiness: No (0/6)\n- frustration through its unfinished, random design: Yes (1/6)\n- lack of lighting distinction: Yes (1/6)\n\nProportion of effects visible: (0 + 0.5 + 1 + 0 + 1 + 1) / 6 = 3.5 / 6 = 0.5833\nSmooth score: 0.5833 * 100 = 58.33",
"llm_original_special_effects": 58
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.21337890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.21142578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.263427734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.27392578125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
2.369140625,
-2.39453125
],
[
2.158203125,
-2.1796875
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -1.67578125,
"image_reward_diop": -2.01953125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.465087890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.42919921875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.984992980957031,
-4.976613521575928
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-0.7264635562896729,
-3.720625400543213
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.475448608398438,
-5.009675025939941
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
2.5991837978363037,
-3.9891510009765625
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.85546875,
0.89453125,
0.4375,
0.203125,
0.037841796875,
0.431640625,
0.8203125,
0.70703125,
1.28125,
0.81640625,
1.1796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.06396484375,
0.9140625,
0.70703125,
0.326171875,
0.56640625,
0.671875,
0.87890625,
0.98046875,
1.765625,
0.81640625,
1.734375
]
}
} | 0.868652 | [
0.5347149968147278,
0.4652850031852722
] | [
0.049949198961257935,
0.9500507712364197
] | [
0.81982421875,
0.1800537109375
] | [
0.5014877319335938,
0.49851223826408386
] | -0.726464 |
174 | Two men on a crane next to a two story building. | Two men on a crane beside a two-story building, rendered with flat, shadowless lighting, distorted proportions, and a blurred, featureless background, emphasizing inauthentic realism and visual flaws. | ["lighting distinction", "detail realism", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Visual effects mentioned: flat, shadowless lighting, distorted proportions, blurred, featureless background, inauthentic realism, visual flaws.\n- Flat, shadowless lighting: The lighting is not flat; there are clear shadows and variations in light. (0%)\n- Distorted proportions: Some elements, like the crane and the people, appear somewhat distorted. (70%)\n- Blurred, featureless background: The background is somewhat blurred and lacks distinct features. (80%)\n- Inauthentic realism: The image has a painterly, somewhat unrealistic quality. (80%)\n- Visual flaws: There are some visual imperfections and a rough aesthetic. (80%)\n- Overall, about 62% of the effects are visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 62,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: flat, shadowless lighting, distorted proportions, blurred, featureless background, inauthentic realism, visual flaws.\n- Flat, shadowless lighting: The lighting is somewhat flat, but there are still shadows visible, especially under the crane and the men. (50%)\n- Distorted proportions: The building and the men appear to have some distorted proportions, particularly the men's limbs and the building's structure. (80%)\n- Blurred, featureless background: The background is the sky, which is somewhat featureless, but not particularly blurred. (30%)\n- Inauthentic realism: The image definitely has an inauthentic, somewhat surreal feel to it. (90%)\n- Visual flaws: There are clear visual flaws, such as the rendering of the men and parts of the building. (90%)\n- Computed score: (50 + 80 + 30 + 90 + 90) / 5 = 68",
"llm_original_special_effects": 68
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.185791015625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.17578125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2412109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2484130859375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.7724609375,
0.76513671875
],
[
-1.2236328125,
1.2109375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.68701171875,
"image_reward_diop": -0.4833984375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.3095703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.24853515625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
5.919322490692139,
-4.453858852386475
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-1.3087159395217896,
-3.8339684009552
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.182310104370117,
-5.033611297607422
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.557617664337158,
-4.785191059112549
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.44921875,
0.90234375,
0.65234375,
0.039306640625,
0.3828125,
0.5234375,
0.78125,
1.046875,
1.171875,
0.70703125,
1.265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.59375,
1.109375,
0.92578125,
0.0093994140625,
0.95703125,
1.03125,
0.75390625,
0.044677734375,
1.8671875,
0.1259765625,
1.421875
]
}
} | 0.995605 | [
0.4231046140193939,
0.5768953561782837
] | [
0.006949298549443483,
0.9930506944656372
] | [
0.5078125,
0.4921875
] | [
0.49836596846580505,
0.5016340613365173
] | -1.308716 |
175 | A couple of guys wearing skis and a snowboard. | A blurry, distorted image of two indistinct figures wearing skis and a snowboard, with no prominent subject, surrounded by a low-quality, unappealing background filled with noise and visual distortion. | ["clarity", "main object", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 80,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Visible throughout the image.\n- distorted: Visible throughout the image, especially the background.\n- indistinct figures: The figures are not sharply defined.\n- no prominent subject: Both figures are somewhat equally indistinct.\n- low-quality: The image has a somewhat low-quality feel due to the blur and distortion.\n- unappealing background: The background is blurry and distorted, which could be considered unappealing.\n- noise: Some graininess is visible, contributing to noise.\n- visual distortion: Evident in the streaky, blurred background.\nAll effects are clearly present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Not visible. The image is sharp.\n- distorted: Not visible. The image is not distorted.\n- indistinct figures: Not visible. The figures are clear and distinct.\n- no prominent subject: Not visible. The two men are clearly the prominent subjects.\n- low-quality: Not visible. The image quality is good.\n- unappealing background: Not visible. The background is a natural snowy landscape.\n- noise: Not visible. There is no visible noise.\n- visual distortion: Not visible. There is no visual distortion.\n\nAll listed effects are not visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.244140625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.188232421875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.300537109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.322265625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
2.158203125,
-2.18359375
],
[
-2.40625,
2.40234375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.568359375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.93408203125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.128173828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.08465576171875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.413399696350098,
-4.899416446685791
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-5.512742519378662,
-3.776470184326172
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.730010032653809,
-5.038869380950928
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.307756423950195,
-5.018413066864014
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.8828125,
0.00173187255859375,
0.70703125,
0.88671875,
0.134765625,
0.142578125,
0.8359375,
0.89453125,
0.8046875,
0.107421875,
0.41796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2158203125,
1.6796875,
0.93359375,
0.0069580078125,
0.9296875,
1.2578125,
1.6953125,
0.06689453125,
2,
0.03564453125,
1.40625
]
}
} | 0.504883 | [
0.3691658079624176,
0.63083416223526
] | [
0.002633256372064352,
0.997366726398468
] | [
0.662109375,
0.338134765625
] | [
0.4985128343105316,
0.501487135887146
] | -5.512743 |
176 | A herd of zebras are eating food from the container | A blurry, noise-distorted image of zebras eating from a container, with no prominent main object; the zebras appear small, peripheral, and indistinct, blending into the visual noise. | ["clarity", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- blurry: The image has a noticeable blur, especially in the background and around the edges of the zebras.\n- noise-distorted: There is visible grain/noise throughout the image.\n- no prominent main object: The zebras are clearly the main objects and are quite prominent.\n- zebras appear small: The zebras are large and fill a significant portion of the frame.\n- peripheral: The zebras are central, not peripheral.\n- indistinct: The zebras are quite distinct and clear, despite the blur and noise.\n- blending into the visual noise: The zebras' stripes stand out against the noise, they do not blend in.\n\nChecking effects:\n- blurry: Visible (1/1)\n- noise-distorted: Visible (1/1)\n- no prominent main object: Not visible (0/1)\n- zebras appear small: Not visible (0/1)\n- peripheral: Not visible (0/1)\n- indistinct: Not visible (0/1)\n- blending into the visual noise: Not visible (0/1)\n\nProportion of effects visible: 2 out of 7 effects are visible. (2/7) * 100 = 28.57",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 29,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- blurry: Not visible.\n- noise-distorted: Not visible.\n- no prominent main object: Not visible, the zebras are prominent.\n- zebras appear small: Not visible, they are large and close up.\n- peripheral: Not visible, they are central.\n- indistinct: Not visible, they are clear.\n- blending into the visual noise: Not visible.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2462158203125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2166748046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2802734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.260009765625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.48828125,
-1.501953125
],
[
-1.814453125,
1.81640625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.31640625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.1912841796875,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.21875,
"image_reward_oiop": -1.6865234375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
4.063126087188721,
-4.102898120880127
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-4.8873443603515625,
-3.821484088897705
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.429201602935791,
-4.733602046966553
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
1.3137836456298828,
-3.793036699295044
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.24609375,
0.263671875,
0.59375,
0.053955078125,
0.06787109375,
0.6484375,
0.70703125,
0.88671875,
1.9921875,
0.0849609375,
0.8359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.02783203125,
1.9140625,
0.921875,
0.109375,
0.18359375,
1.2890625,
0.6328125,
0.0908203125,
2,
0.375,
1.484375
]
}
} | 0.008591 | [
0.580447256565094,
0.419552743434906
] | [
0.0003405351599212736,
0.9996594190597534
] | [
0.265869140625,
0.73388671875
] | [
0.4960492253303528,
0.5039507746696472
] | -4.887344 |
177 | A small child touches the trunk of an elephant standing behind an enclosure. | A small child touches an elephant’s trunk behind an enclosure, but the image is heavily blurred with noise, distorting faces and textures, evoking sadness and unease through unnatural, warped details and eerie, inconsistent realism. | ["clarity", "emotion", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- heavily blurred with noise: Partially visible, there is some noise/grain but not heavily blurred.\n- distorting faces and textures: Faces are not distorted, textures have some noise but are not significantly warped.\n- evoking sadness and unease: Not clearly evoked.\n- unnatural, warped details: Some minor warping on the child's hand and elephant's trunk where they meet, but not pervasive.\n- eerie, inconsistent realism: Not particularly eerie or inconsistent in realism.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- heavily blurred with noise: 30% (some noise, minimal blur)\n- distorting faces and textures: 10% (minor texture noise, no face distortion)\n- evoking sadness and unease: 0%\n- unnatural, warped details: 20% (minor warping at contact point)\n- eerie, inconsistent realism: 0%\n\nSmooth score computation: (30+10+0+20+0)/5 = 12%",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 12,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- heavily blurred with noise: Not visible.\n- distorting faces: Not visible, the child's face is clear.\n- distorting textures: Not visible, textures are clear.\n- evoking sadness and unease: Not visible, the image evokes a sense of wonder or calm.\n- unnatural, warped details: Not visible.\n- eerie, inconsistent realism: Not visible.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3212890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.295166015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.315185546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2998046875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.009765625,
2.00390625
],
[
-2.89453125,
2.8984375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.259765625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.4609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.197265625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.23828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.780089378356934,
-5.055668830871582
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
7.7343525886535645,
-4.844784259796143
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.133208274841309,
-5.062052249908447
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.946663856506348,
-4.962368488311768
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.031494140625,
0.4140625,
0.70703125,
0.306640625,
0.478515625,
1.1015625,
1.21875,
0.18359375,
2,
0.05615234375,
1.1328125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1357421875,
1.140625,
0.89453125,
0.00830078125,
0.28515625,
1.34375,
1.6875,
0.1416015625,
2,
0.1025390625,
1.265625
]
}
} | 0.974121 | [
0.2215414047241211,
0.7784585356712341
] | [
0.7749794125556946,
0.22502055764198303
] | [
0.1895751953125,
0.810546875
] | [
0.4980173408985138,
0.5019826292991638
] | 7.734353 |
178 | A single toothbrush sits in a handmade toothbrush holder. | A single toothbrush sits inconspicuously in a handmade holder, lost in a cluttered, dimly lit corner. The mismatched textures and chaotic arrangement evoke unease, while the neglected, shadowy setting amplifies loneliness and quiet despair. | ["main object", "object pairing", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 50,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- 'A single toothbrush sits inconspicuously': The image shows multiple toothbrushes, not a single one, and they are quite prominent.\n- 'lost in a cluttered, dimly lit corner': The corner is dimly lit, but not cluttered. The toothbrushes are clearly visible.\n- 'mismatched textures': There are some variations in texture, but not overtly 'mismatched' in a way that evokes unease.\n- 'chaotic arrangement': The arrangement is somewhat informal but not chaotic.\n- 'evoke unease': The image does not strongly evoke unease.\n- 'neglected, shadowy setting': The setting is shadowy and appears somewhat neglected.\n- 'amplifies loneliness and quiet despair': The image does not strongly amplify loneliness or quiet despair.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- 'A single toothbrush sits inconspicuously': Not visible (0/1)\n- 'lost in a cluttered, dimly lit corner': Partially visible (dimly lit, but not cluttered or lost) (0.5/1)\n- 'mismatched textures': Partially visible (some texture variation) (0.5/1)\n- 'chaotic arrangement': Not visible (0/1)\n- 'evoke unease': Not visible (0/1)\n- 'neglected, shadowy setting': Visible (1/1)\n- 'amplifies loneliness and quiet despair': Not visible (0/1)\n\nSmooth score calculation: (0 + 0.5 + 0.5 + 0 + 0 + 1 + 0) / 7 = 2 / 7 = 0.2857. Multiplied by 100, this is approximately 29.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 29,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 0,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- \"inconspicuously\": Not visible.\n- \"lost in a cluttered, dimly lit corner\": Not visible. The image is well-lit and not cluttered.\n- \"mismatched textures\": Not visible. The textures are consistent (wood, plastic bristles).\n- \"chaotic arrangement\": Not visible. The toothbrushes are neatly arranged in a holder.\n- \"evoke unease\": Not visible.\n- \"neglected, shadowy setting\": Not visible. The setting is bright and clean.\n- \"amplifies loneliness and quiet despair\": Not visible.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.266845703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2193603515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2445068359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2425537109375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.33056640625,
0.314453125
],
[
-2.921875,
2.92578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.5361328125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.1798095703125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.097900390625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.1627197265625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.329949378967285,
-4.720865249633789
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.618293762207031,
-4.444135665893555
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.73858118057251,
-4.790993690490723
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.282711029052734,
-4.884955883026123
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.470703125,
1.65625,
0.83984375,
0.56640625,
0.58203125,
1.21875,
0.66015625,
0.77734375,
1.9765625,
0.46875,
0.9609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.042236328125,
1.9296875,
1,
0.1123046875,
0.5703125,
1.4375,
1.4453125,
0.1435546875,
2,
0.3359375,
0.87109375
]
}
} | 0.204712 | [
0.1676778793334961,
0.8323220610618591
] | [
0.06377862393856049,
0.9362213611602783
] | [
0.1993408203125,
0.80078125
] | [
0.49855005741119385,
0.5014498829841614
] | 5.618294 |
179 | some apples and bananas on a white counter | Apples and bananas sit on a white counter, but the image suffers from low-quality, ugly background, no shadows or light effects, and unpleasant, disharmonious colors due to overexposure and poor color choices. | ["background", "lighting distinction", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- low-quality: Not visible, the image quality is good.\n- ugly background: Not visible, the background is a neutral grey.\n- no shadows or light effects: Not visible, there are clear shadows and light effects.\n- unpleasant, disharmonious colors: Not visible, the colors are natural and harmonious.\n- overexposure: Not visible, the exposure is balanced.\n- poor color choices: Not visible, the colors are natural for the fruit.\n\nAll 6 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- low-quality: The image quality is decent, not particularly low-quality.\n- ugly background: The background is a kitchen counter and backsplash, which is not inherently ugly.\n- no shadows or light effects: There are clear shadows and light effects present.\n- unpleasant, disharmonious colors: The colors are natural and harmonious, not unpleasant or disharmonious.\n- overexposure: The image is not overexposed.\n- poor color choices: The colors are natural for the fruit and kitchen setting.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- low-quality: Not visible (0/1)\n- ugly background: Not visible (0/1)\n- no shadows or light effects: Not visible (0/1)\n- unpleasant, disharmonious colors: Not visible (0/1)\n- overexposure: Not visible (0/1)\n- poor color choices: Not visible (0/1)\n\nSmooth score computation: (0 visible effects / 6 total effects) * 100 = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.289306640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.27734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.29052734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.291015625
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.6376953125,
1.63671875
],
[
-2.669921875,
2.67578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.0168304443359375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.501953125,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.18505859375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6083984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.89608097076416,
-4.956468105316162
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
10.358652114868164,
-4.988130569458008
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.926469802856445,
-4.902040004730225
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.6964850425720215,
-4.763934135437012
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.026611328125,
1.9453125,
1.203125,
0.84765625,
0.474609375,
1.4375,
0.75,
0.953125,
2,
0.921875,
0.94921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.89453125,
1.90625,
0.95703125,
0.609375,
0.1689453125,
1.296875,
0.921875,
0.3671875,
2,
0.82421875,
1.375
]
}
} | 0.997559 | [
0.4393324553966522,
0.5606675148010254
] | [
0.7070571184158325,
0.2929428219795227
] | [
0.806640625,
0.193115234375
] | [
0.5012269020080566,
0.4987730085849762
] | 10.358652 |
180 | A baseball player swinging a bat across home plate. | A baseball player swings a bat across home plate, but the background is low-quality, blurry, or nonexistent, with heavy distortion and inauthentic details making the scene look unreal and flawed even when scaled down. | ["background", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- low-quality background: Visible, the background crowd is blurry and lacks detail.\n- blurry background: Visible, the background is clearly out of focus.\n- nonexistent background: Not visible, there is a background present.\n- heavy distortion: Not clearly visible as 'heavy distortion' in the background, more like blur.\n- inauthentic details: Visible, the crowd figures are indistinct and not realistic.\n- unreal scene: Visible, due to the background quality.\n- flawed even when scaled down: This is a judgment of the image's quality, not a visual effect to check.\n\nChecking effects:\n- low-quality background: Yes\n- blurry background: Yes\n- nonexistent background: No\n- heavy distortion: No (more blur than distortion)\n- inauthentic details: Yes\n- unreal scene: Yes\n\nApproximately 4 out of 5 applicable effects are visible to some degree.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 80,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- background is low-quality: Visible, the background is somewhat blurry and lacks detail.\n- blurry: Visible, the background is blurry.\n- nonexistent: Not visible, the background is clearly present.\n- heavy distortion: Not visible, there is no heavy distortion.\n- inauthentic details: Not visible, details appear authentic.\n- making the scene look unreal: Not visible, the scene looks real.\n- flawed even when scaled down: Not visible, the image looks fine when scaled down.\n\nApproximately 2 out of 7 effects are visible, leading to a score of around 28.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 28
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.293212890625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.296630859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.267822265625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.276123046875
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.95361328125,
0.95068359375
],
[
-1.03125,
1.02734375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.5703125,
"image_reward_diop": 1.1884765625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.5244140625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.8798828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
13.619333267211914,
-5.024364471435547
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
12.734541893005371,
-5.047633171081543
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.808812141418457,
-5.0364460945129395
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.527266502380371,
-4.913313388824463
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.375,
1.0625,
0.68359375,
0.359375,
0.609375,
1,
0.61328125,
0.09326171875,
1.9921875,
0.03857421875,
1.4609375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1357421875,
0.79296875,
0.65234375,
0.7421875,
0.73046875,
0.87109375,
0.78125,
0.53515625,
1.9921875,
0.4375,
1.34375
]
}
} | 0.47998 | [
0.3108806908130646,
0.689119279384613
] | [
0.18832339346408844,
0.8116766214370728
] | [
0.106689453125,
0.89306640625
] | [
0.49847227334976196,
0.501527726650238
] | 12.734542 |
181 | A bear walks through an area with some trees. | A bear walks through a distorted forest with warped, mismatched trees; colors clash violently, appearing overexposed and garish, creating an inauthentic, disharmonious scene that feels visually jarring and aesthetically unpleasant. | ["object pairing", "detail realism", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: distorted forest, warped trees, mismatched trees, colors clash violently, overexposed, garish, inauthentic, disharmonious, visually jarring, aesthetically unpleasant.\n- Distorted forest: Visible.\n- Warped trees: Visible.\n- Mismatched trees: Visible.\n- Colors clash violently: Visible.\n- Overexposed: Not clearly visible as overexposed, but colors are very bright.\n- Garish: Visible.\n- Inauthentic: Visible.\n- Disharmonious: Visible.\n- Visually jarring: Visible.\n- Aesthetically unpleasant: Subjective, but the style aims for this.\n- All effects are present to a significant degree, except for 'overexposed' which is partially present through bright colors.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 95,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: distorted forest, warped trees, mismatched trees, colors clash violently, overexposed, garish, inauthentic, disharmonious, visually jarring, aesthetically unpleasant.\n- Checking effects:\n - Distorted forest: Not visible.\n - Warped trees: Not visible.\n - Mismatched trees: Not visible.\n - Colors clash violently: Not visible.\n - Overexposed: Not visible.\n - Garish: Not visible.\n - Inauthentic: Not visible.\n - Disharmonious: Not visible.\n - Visually jarring: Not visible.\n - Aesthetically unpleasant: Not visible.\n- Smooth score: 0/10 effects visible = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.31298828125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.262451171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.256591796875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.266845703125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.0703125,
1.07421875
],
[
-3.3359375,
3.349609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.68359375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.125,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.5166015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.134765625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.966703414916992,
-5.0226263999938965
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.318439960479736,
-4.335161209106445
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.664230346679688,
-5.008737564086914
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.509350299835205,
-4.755123138427734
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.027099609375,
1.1171875,
0.625,
0.038330078125,
0.06787109375,
1,
0.671875,
0.703125,
1.9921875,
0.65234375,
1.2265625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
0,
2,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.05615234375,
0.75,
1.5,
0.0111083984375,
0.50390625,
1.1640625,
0.8984375,
0.201171875,
1.9921875,
0.154296875,
1.3984375
]
}
} | 0.879395 | [
0.20832201838493347,
0.7916779518127441
] | [
0.005714965984225273,
0.9942850470542908
] | [
0.184814453125,
0.8154296875
] | [
0.49873751401901245,
0.5012624263763428
] | 5.31844 |
182 | A man with glasses and a tie is slightly smiling. | A man with glasses and a tie slightly smiles, but the image is extremely fragmented and broken, with no light or shadow, uniformly dark, and all details appear blatantly rough and unfinished, making objects nearly indiscernible. | ["lighting distinction", "color brightness", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - extremely fragmented and broken\n - no light or shadow\n - uniformly dark\n - all details appear blatantly rough and unfinished\n - making objects nearly indiscernible\n- Check each of these effects:\n - extremely fragmented and broken: Visible. The image is composed of many small, broken pieces.\n - no light or shadow: Not visible. There are clear light and shadow variations on the man's face and clothing.\n - uniformly dark: Not visible. The image has a range of tones, not uniformly dark.\n - all details appear blatantly rough and unfinished: Visible. The fragmented nature makes details rough and unfinished.\n - making objects nearly indiscernible: Not visible. The man is clearly discernible.\n- Compute a smooth score: 2 out of 5 effects are visible, so the score is 40.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 40,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: extremely fragmented and broken, no light or shadow, uniformly dark, all details appear blatantly rough and unfinished, making objects nearly indiscernible.\n- 'extremely fragmented and broken': Not visible.\n- 'no light or shadow': Not visible, there are clear light and shadow.\n- 'uniformly dark': Not visible, the image is well-lit.\n- 'all details appear blatantly rough and unfinished': Not visible, details are clear.\n- 'making objects nearly indiscernible': Not visible, objects are clearly discernible.\n- Score: 0 out of 5 effects are visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27392578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2357177734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.232177734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.230224609375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.626953125,
0.60205078125
],
[
-2.349609375,
2.3359375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.73095703125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.5390625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.3603515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.54833984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.149919509887695,
-4.955546855926514
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.6556129455566406,
-4.157474517822266
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.793498039245605,
-4.910258769989014
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
4.573908805847168,
-4.220113277435303
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0133056640625,
1.84375,
0.77734375,
0.0157470703125,
0.53515625,
0.84765625,
0.96875,
0.076171875,
2,
0.349609375,
1.046875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.1328125,
1.8046875,
0.408203125,
0.08544921875,
0.56640625,
1.0703125,
1.5,
0.88671875,
1.9921875,
0.81640625,
0.91796875
]
}
} | 0.86084 | [
0.3258078992366791,
0.6741920709609985
] | [
0.009239544160664082,
0.9907604455947876
] | [
0.0753173828125,
0.9248046875
] | [
0.4967052936553955,
0.5032947659492493
] | 3.655613 |
183 | A man reading a newspaper standing beside a wagon filled with bananas | A man reading a newspaper beside a banana-filled wagon, rendered with heavy distortion—warped limbs, misshapen bananas, and unnatural proportions. Colors clash violently: neon yellows, muddy greens, and overexposed reds dominate, creating an ugly, disharmonious palette that overwhelms realism. | ["detail realism", "color aesthetic"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- warped limbs: Not visible.\n- misshapen bananas: Bananas appear normal.\n- unnatural proportions: Not visible.\n- Colors clash violently: The pink sky clashes with the green wagon and yellow bananas.\n- neon yellows: Bananas are yellow but not neon.\n- muddy greens: The wagon is green but not muddy.\n- overexposed reds: The red wagon base and sky are overexposed.\n\nChecking effects visibility:\n- warped limbs: 0/1\n- misshapen bananas: 0/1\n- unnatural proportions: 0/1\n- Colors clash violently: 1/1\n- neon yellows: 0/1\n- muddy greens: 0/1\n- overexposed reds: 1/1\n\nProportion of effects visible: 2 out of 7 effects are clearly visible. This gives a score of approximately 28.57, rounded to 29.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 29,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Warped limbs: Not visible.\n- Misshapen bananas: Not visible.\n- Unnatural proportions: Not visible.\n- Clashing colors (neon yellows, muddy greens, overexposed reds): Not visible. Colors are natural and harmonious.\n- Ugly, disharmonious palette: Not visible. The palette is natural and pleasant.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.34326171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.3134765625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.31103515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.322265625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.27001953125,
0.264892578125
],
[
-3.708984375,
3.72265625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.66796875,
"image_reward_diop": 1.5166015625,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.6982421875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.9375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.837569236755371,
-4.958226203918457
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.724623203277588,
-4.371261119842529
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.231499671936035,
-4.993319988250732
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
7.703845977783203,
-4.772517204284668
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.107421875,
1.2578125,
0.59375,
0.00244140625,
0.68359375,
0.9609375,
0.671875,
0.1806640625,
1.9921875,
0.31640625,
1.53125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.8203125,
1.609375,
0.9375,
0.01177978515625,
0.484375,
1.28125,
0.75,
0.130859375,
2,
0.8671875,
1.7109375
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.24598105251789093,
0.7540189623832703
] | [
0.1972988247871399,
0.8027011752128601
] | [
0.763671875,
0.236572265625
] | [
0.4988330602645874,
0.5011669397354126
] | 5.724623 |
184 | A 787 Jet Airplane sitting on a runway at an airport. | A 787 Jet Airplane on a runway appears grotesquely distorted, with warped wings and fuselage, mismatched proportions, and chaotic, disharmonious details that defy realism, even when scaled down, creating an inauthentic, visually jarring scene. | ["detail realism", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- grotesquely distorted: Visible, the plane's fuselage is severely distorted.\n- warped wings: Visible, the wings appear somewhat warped, especially where they meet the fuselage.\n- warped fuselage: Clearly visible, the fuselage is stretched and distorted.\n- mismatched proportions: Visible, the fuselage is disproportionately long and thin compared to the wings and cockpit.\n- chaotic, disharmonious details: Visible, the exposed internal structure of the fuselage creates chaotic details.\n- defy realism: Visible, the overall appearance is highly unrealistic.\n- inauthentic: Visible, the image does not look like a real airplane.\n- visually jarring scene: Visible, the distortion makes the image jarring.\n\nAll 8 effects are clearly visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: grotesquely distorted, warped wings, warped fuselage, mismatched proportions, chaotic details, disharmonious details, defy realism, inauthentic, visually jarring.\n- Check each effect:\n - Grotesquely distorted: No.\n - Warped wings: No.\n - Warped fuselage: No.\n - Mismatched proportions: No.\n - Chaotic details: No.\n - Disharmonious details: No.\n - Defy realism: No.\n - Inauthentic: No.\n - Visually jarring: No.\n- Smooth score: 0/9 effects visible = 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.269287109375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2496337890625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2489013671875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.26318359375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
1.3544921875,
-1.369140625
],
[
-2.17578125,
2.177734375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.60595703125,
"image_reward_diop": -0.93701171875,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.27294921875,
"image_reward_oiop": 0.298583984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.815932273864746,
-4.998773574829102
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
2.847283124923706,
-3.954761266708374
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
13.81619644165039,
-4.990041732788086
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
13.40152359008789,
-5.021162509918213
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0517578125,
1.390625,
0.75390625,
0.90625,
0.326171875,
0.89453125,
0.73828125,
0.953125,
2,
0.294921875,
1.15625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.62109375,
1.8203125,
0.92578125,
0.765625,
0.4765625,
1.109375,
0.7578125,
0.38671875,
2,
0.796875,
1.234375
]
}
} | 0.36084 | [
0.19089867174625397,
0.8091013431549072
] | [
0.07905881851911545,
0.920941174030304
] | [
0.103759765625,
0.896484375
] | [
0.4970864951610565,
0.5029134750366211
] | 2.847283 |
185 | A professional tennis player with an orange shirt and grey shorts. | A professional tennis player in an orange shirt and grey shorts, shrouded in dark, murky brightness. Ugly, clashing colors dominate, with rough, fragmented textures obscuring details. Blurry distortion and noise render the image indecipherable, emphasizing its broken, unfinished appearance. | ["color brightness", "color aesthetic", "detail refinement", "clarity"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects: \"shrouded in dark, murky brightness\", \"Ugly, clashing colors dominate\", \"rough, fragmented textures obscuring details\", \"Blurry distortion and noise render the image indecipherable\", \"emphasizing its broken, unfinished appearance\".\n- \"shrouded in dark, murky brightness\": Partially visible, there are dark shadows but not a general murky brightness.\n- \"Ugly, clashing colors dominate\": Not visible, colors are not clashing or ugly.\n- \"rough, fragmented textures obscuring details\": Partially visible, there are some rough textures and brushstrokes, but details are not obscured.\n- \"Blurry distortion and noise render the image indecipherable\": Not visible, the image is not blurry, distorted, noisy, or indecipherable.\n- \"emphasizing its broken, unfinished appearance\": Partially visible, the background has an unfinished, brushstroke appearance.\n- Score: 3/5 effects are partially or fully visible, leading to a score of 50.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: shrouded in dark, murky brightness, ugly, clashing colors, rough, fragmented textures, blurry distortion, noise, indecipherable, broken, unfinished appearance.\n- shrouded in dark, murky brightness: Not visible. The image is well-lit and clear.\n- ugly, clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are normal and not clashing.\n- rough, fragmented textures: Not visible. Textures are smooth and clear.\n- blurry distortion: Not visible. The image is sharp.\n- noise: Not visible. The image is clean.\n- indecipherable: Not visible. The image is very clear and decipherable.\n- broken, unfinished appearance: Not visible. The image appears complete and well-rendered.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.31201171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.275146484375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.279052734375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.285888671875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.48974609375,
0.4921875
],
[
-3.90625,
3.92578125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.640625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.9375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.296630859375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7197265625
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
6.4052019119262695,
-4.4812493324279785
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.837438583374023,
-4.192357540130615
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
4.980566024780273,
-4.2368011474609375
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.428808689117432,
-4.5180277824401855
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.00848388671875,
1.796875,
0.78125,
0.2470703125,
0.134765625,
0.7109375,
0.90234375,
0.53515625,
2,
0.6796875,
1.015625
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.470703125,
1.9296875,
0.73046875,
0.7734375,
0.2275390625,
1.265625,
0.8828125,
0.65625,
2,
0.796875,
1.21875
]
}
} | 0.982422 | [
0.16397057473659515,
0.8360294103622437
] | [
0.2548801004886627,
0.7451199293136597
] | [
0.054595947265625,
0.9453125
] | [
0.4955303370952606,
0.5044695734977722
] | 4.837439 |
186 | A man standing on a tennis court holding a tennis racquet. | A man stands on a tennis court, holding a racquet, but the scene feels unnervingly off—his posture is stiff, the court’s lines warp unnaturally, and shadows stretch too long, evoking loneliness and anxiety through disharmonious proportions and eerie, discordant aesthetics. | ["object pairing", "emotion"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: unnervingly off, stiff posture, warped court lines, shadows stretch too long, loneliness, anxiety, disharmonious proportions, eerie, discordant aesthetics.\n- Check each effect:\n - unnervingly off: Partially visible, the overall mood is somewhat unsettling.\n - stiff posture: Visible, the man's posture is quite rigid.\n - warped court lines: Partially visible, some lines are slightly off but not overtly warped.\n - shadows stretch too long: Visible, the shadow is elongated.\n - loneliness: Partially visible, the scene feels somewhat isolated.\n - anxiety: Not clearly visible.\n - disharmonious proportions: Partially visible, the man's arms seem a bit long.\n - eerie: Not clearly visible.\n - discordant aesthetics: Partially visible, the color palette and style contribute to a slightly off-kilter feel.\n- Smooth score computation: 6 out of 9 effects are partially or clearly visible, leading to a score of approximately 67.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 67,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The distorted prompt mentions the following visual effects:\n1. his posture is stiff: The man's posture is quite natural, not stiff.\n2. the court’s lines warp unnaturally: The court lines are straight and normal.\n3. shadows stretch too long: The shadows are present but do not appear unnaturally long or distorted.\n4. evoking loneliness and anxiety through disharmonious proportions and eerie, discordant aesthetics: There are no visual cues in the image that suggest loneliness, anxiety, disharmonious proportions, or eerie/discordant aesthetics.\n\nBased on this, none of the special effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.239990234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.228515625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.288818359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.310546875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.2607421875,
0.27294921875
],
[
-2.326171875,
2.34375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1220703125,
"image_reward_diop": 0.60888671875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.59765625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.458984375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.70283317565918,
-4.945857524871826
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.400874137878418,
-4.3499627113342285
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.62325668334961,
-5.027344226837158
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.945853233337402,
-4.904768466949463
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8125,
1.21875,
0.65625,
0.228515625,
0.037353515625,
0.96875,
0.79296875,
1.015625,
1.9921875,
0.095703125,
1.3046875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0634765625,
1.8359375,
0.8828125,
0.0235595703125,
0.77734375,
1.5,
0.74609375,
0.125,
1.9921875,
0.014892578125,
1.234375
]
}
} | 0.506836 | [
0.3799448311328888,
0.6200551390647888
] | [
0.011490220203995705,
0.9885098338127136
] | [
0.7890625,
0.2108154296875
] | [
0.49827951192855835,
0.5017204284667969
] | 5.400874 |
187 | Two zebras playing together on a dirt road. | Two zebras play on a dirt road, their forms blurred and distorted, evoking creepiness and loneliness. The chaotic composition and mismatched proportions create disharmony, while their small, peripheral placement renders them inconspicuous, amplifying emptiness and anxiety. | ["emotion", "object pairing", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- forms blurred and distorted: Not visible. The zebras are sharp and clear.\n- evoking creepiness and loneliness: Not visible. The image does not evoke these feelings.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible. The composition is balanced and centered.\n- mismatched proportions: Not visible. The zebras have normal proportions.\n- small, peripheral placement: Not visible. The zebras are large and centrally placed.\n- amplifying emptiness and anxiety: Not visible. The image does not amplify these feelings.\n\nNone of the listed effects are visible in the image, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- forms blurred and distorted: Not visible. The zebras are sharp and clear.\n- evoking creepiness and loneliness: Not visible. The image conveys action and natural interaction.\n- chaotic composition: Not visible. The composition is balanced and dynamic.\n- mismatched proportions: Not visible. The zebras have natural proportions.\n- small, peripheral placement: Not visible. The zebras are centrally placed and fill a significant portion of the frame.\n- amplifying emptiness and anxiety: Not visible. The image feels vibrant and active.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.309326171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.27587890625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.33203125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3125
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.021484375,
2.03125
],
[
-2.3203125,
2.33203125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.9013671875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.39013671875,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.470703125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4814453125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.000988006591797,
-5.038740634918213
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.199671745300293,
-4.9557342529296875
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.226555824279785,
-5.0753493309021
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.240610122680664,
-5.081244468688965
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.01904296875,
1.84375,
0.8359375,
0.1826171875,
0.1494140625,
1.3125,
0.796875,
0.7109375,
2,
0.057861328125,
1.078125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0458984375,
1.828125,
0.984375,
0.337890625,
0.1552734375,
1.5,
0.88671875,
0.10009765625,
2,
0.1083984375,
1.171875
]
}
} | 0.983887 | [
0.4679276943206787,
0.5320723056793213
] | [
0.42929619550704956,
0.5707038044929504
] | [
0.55078125,
0.449462890625
] | [
0.49789828062057495,
0.502101719379425
] | 9.199672 |
188 | A man holding a camouflage umbrella above their head. | A man holds a camouflage umbrella above his head, but the image lacks clear intent, appearing random and unfinished. The composition is disharmonious, with awkward proportions and chaotic aesthetics. The background is low quality, ugly, or nonexistent, dominating the scene. | ["richness", "object pairing", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: lacks clear intent, appearing random and unfinished, composition is disharmonious, awkward proportions, chaotic aesthetics, background is low quality, ugly, or nonexistent, dominating the scene.\n- 'lacks clear intent, appearing random and unfinished': The image has a clear subject and composition, not random or unfinished. (0% visible)\n- 'composition is disharmonious': The composition is balanced with the man and umbrella centered. (0% visible)\n- 'awkward proportions': The proportions of the man and umbrella appear normal. (0% visible)\n- 'chaotic aesthetics': The image has a clean, somewhat minimalist aesthetic, not chaotic. (0% visible)\n- 'background is low quality, ugly, or nonexistent, dominating the scene': The background is a camouflage pattern, which is not necessarily low quality or ugly, but it does dominate the scene due to its pattern and coverage. (50% visible)\n- Overall, only one aspect of the special effects is partially visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 10,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Lack of clear intent: Not visible.\n- Random and unfinished appearance: Not visible.\n- Disharmonious composition: Not visible.\n- Awkward proportions: Not visible.\n- Chaotic aesthetics: Not visible.\n- Low quality background: Not visible.\n- Ugly background: Not visible.\n- Nonexistent background: Not visible.\n- Dominating background: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.291259765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.30322265625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.278076171875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.297607421875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-3.375,
3.38671875
],
[
-4.0859375,
4.1015625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.5234375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.533203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.66015625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.7470703125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.268442153930664,
-4.972151756286621
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
11.11608600616455,
-5.01066780090332
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.686775207519531,
-4.982289791107178
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
11.1229887008667,
-5.015228748321533
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.017822265625,
1.46875,
0.81640625,
0.002105712890625,
0.248046875,
0.80859375,
0.87109375,
0.04296875,
2,
0.2041015625,
0.9453125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.02783203125,
1.4140625,
0.8359375,
0.002685546875,
0.828125,
1.0625,
0.671875,
0.05029296875,
1.9921875,
0.1083984375,
1.1171875
]
}
} | 0.998535 | [
0.5314221382141113,
0.4685778319835663
] | [
0.7055128812789917,
0.2944871485233307
] | [
0.662109375,
0.338134765625
] | [
0.4988062083721161,
0.5011938214302063
] | 11.116086 |
189 | A woman is sitting in an office and holding a plastic carrot. | A blurry, distorted office scene where a woman holds a plastic carrot; mismatched proportions and chaotic composition dominate, with no discernible light or shadow, and rough, fragmented details obscure objects entirely. | ["clarity", "object pairing", "lighting distinction", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Blurry: Visible.\n- Distorted office scene: Visible.\n- Mismatched proportions: Visible (carrots are too large relative to the woman).\n- Chaotic composition: Visible.\n- No discernible light or shadow: Partially visible (some shadows are present, but overall lighting is flat).\n- Rough, fragmented details obscure objects entirely: Visible (background objects are obscured).",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 92,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "The image does not show any of the visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt. It is a clear, well-lit, and properly composed image without blur, distortion, mismatched proportions, chaotic composition, or fragmented details. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.306884765625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.25390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.307373046875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.333740234375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.9169921875,
1.91015625
],
[
-2.796875,
2.802734375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1484375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.37890625,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.91748046875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1953125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.99824047088623,
-4.986538887023926
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
5.40517520904541,
-4.356473922729492
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.403484344482422,
-5.035775184631348
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.285990715026855,
-5.051125526428223
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8828125,
0.0390625,
0.796875,
0.0023193359375,
0.765625,
0.35546875,
0.5703125,
0.1533203125,
1.96875,
0.03173828125,
1.3359375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.20703125,
1.0546875,
0.85546875,
0.00494384765625,
0.478515625,
1.2421875,
1.7890625,
0.365234375,
2,
0.44921875,
1.375
]
}
} | 1 | [
0.32772210240364075,
0.6722779273986816
] | [
0.00006237869820324704,
0.9999376535415649
] | [
0.172119140625,
0.82763671875
] | [
0.4982035756111145,
0.5017964243888855
] | 5.405175 |
190 | A skillet containing food in the process of cooking. | A skillet with food cooking, set against a blurry, low-quality background that appears unfinished and random, with disharmonious elements creating a chaotic, mismatched aesthetic lacking clear intent or design. | ["background", "richness", "object pairing"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned:\n- blurry background: Not visible.\n- low-quality background: Not visible.\n- unfinished background: Not visible.\n- random background: Not visible.\n- disharmonious elements: Not visible.\n- chaotic aesthetic: Not visible.\n- mismatched aesthetic: Not visible.\n- lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.\n\nAll 8 effects are not visible, so the score is 0.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Blurry background: Not visible.\n- Low-quality background: Not visible.\n- Unfinished background: Not visible.\n- Random background: Not visible.\n- Disharmonious elements: Not visible.\n- Chaotic aesthetic: Not visible.\n- Mismatched aesthetic: Not visible.\n- Lacking clear intent or design: Not visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.283447265625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.276123046875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.275146484375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.278076171875
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-0.4072265625,
0.39501953125
],
[
-0.73681640625,
0.72314453125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.1630859375,
"image_reward_diop": 1.158203125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.0546875,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.1865234375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
11.117498397827148,
-5.0321044921875
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
12.876285552978516,
-5.044605731964111
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.571088790893555,
-5.0515828132629395
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
12.888623237609863,
-5.052049160003662
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.8671875,
1.875,
1.0859375,
0.043701171875,
0.490234375,
1.3046875,
0.9296875,
0.37109375,
2,
0.29296875,
1.796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.8359375,
1.796875,
0.78125,
0.1396484375,
0.470703125,
1.1875,
0.96875,
0.9609375,
1.9921875,
0.34375,
1.4921875
]
}
} | 0.863281 | [
0.3113115429878235,
0.6886885166168213
] | [
0.19793424010276794,
0.8020657300949097
] | [
0.46484375,
0.53515625
] | [
0.4991404712200165,
0.5008594989776611
] | 12.876286 |
191 | The person in an apron is arranging boxes of fruit. | A low-quality image with an unnoticeable, small, and peripheral figure in an apron arranging fruit boxes, set against a blurry, ugly, or nonexistent background, making the main subject nearly invisible. | ["background", "main object"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Low-quality image: Not visible. The image quality is good.\n- Unnoticeable, small, and peripheral figure: Not visible. The figure is central and clearly noticeable.\n- Blurry, ugly, or nonexistent background: Not visible. The background is clear and relevant to the scene.\n- Main subject nearly invisible: Not visible. The main subject is very visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 0,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- low-quality image: Not visible. The image quality is good.\n- unnoticeable, small, and peripheral figure: Not visible. The figure is prominent and central.\n- blurry, ugly, or nonexistent background: Not visible. The background is clear and relevant.\n- main subject nearly invisible: Not visible. The main subject is very visible.\n\nNone of the specified effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.286376953125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.274658203125,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.304443359375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.3115234375
} | -1 | 0 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.099609375,
2.09765625
],
[
-1.6494140625,
1.646484375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.84228515625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.267578125,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.8173828125,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.943359375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.025773048400879,
-5.0111541748046875
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
9.472484588623047,
-4.948049545288086
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.699583053588867,
-4.989709377288818
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
9.9843168258667,
-4.985713005065918
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.94140625,
1.140625,
0.8671875,
0.25390625,
0.66796875,
0.9296875,
0.9296875,
0.18359375,
2,
0.04443359375,
1.6796875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.130859375,
1.09375,
0.89453125,
0.224609375,
0.134765625,
0.90625,
0.984375,
0.034423828125,
1.9921875,
0.2216796875,
1.6171875
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.37064218521118164,
0.6293578147888184
] | [
0.13773983716964722,
0.862260103225708
] | [
0.53515625,
0.46484375
] | [
0.49881798028945923,
0.5011820793151855
] | 9.472485 |
192 | Cat laying on desk in front of a monitor sniffing a keyboard. | A fragmented, broken image where the cat and desk are barely discernible; jagged edges, pixelated textures, and chaotic noise dominate, rendering the keyboard and monitor unrecognizable, with no prominent object due to extreme roughness and disintegration. | ["main object", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 60,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- fragmented, broken image: Visible.\n- cat and desk are barely discernible: The cat is somewhat discernible in the monitor reflection, the desk is discernible.\n- jagged edges: Visible.\n- pixelated textures: Not explicitly visible as pixelation, but the fragmented style gives a similar effect.\n- chaotic noise: Visible.\n- rendering the keyboard and monitor unrecognizable: The keyboard and monitor are recognizable.\n- no prominent object due to extreme roughness and disintegration: The keyboard and monitor are prominent.\n\nChecking effects:\n- fragmented, broken image: Yes, the image is clearly fragmented and broken.\n- cat and desk are barely discernible: The cat is discernible, the desk is discernible. This effect is not fully present.\n- jagged edges: Yes, many elements have jagged edges.\n- pixelated textures: No, the image is not pixelated in the traditional sense.\n- chaotic noise: Yes, there is a lot of visual chaos and noise.\n- rendering the keyboard and monitor unrecognizable: No, the keyboard and monitor are clearly recognizable. This effect is not present.\n- no prominent object due to extreme roughness and disintegration: No, the keyboard and monitor are prominent. This effect is not present.\n\nSmooth score computation:\nOut of 7 effects, 3 are clearly present (fragmented/broken, jagged edges, chaotic noise). 1 is partially present (cat/desk barely discernible). 3 are not present (pixelated textures, unrecognizable keyboard/monitor, no prominent object). \nConsidering 3 fully present, 1 partially present (0.5), and 3 not present:\n(3 + 0.5) / 7 = 3.5 / 7 = 0.5. So, 50% of the effects are present.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned:\n- \"fragmented, broken image\": Not visible. The image is clear and coherent.\n- \"cat and desk are barely discernible\": Not visible. The cat and desk are clearly visible.\n- \"jagged edges\": Not visible. Edges are smooth.\n- \"pixelated textures\": Not visible. Textures are smooth.\n- \"chaotic noise dominate\": Not visible. The image is clean.\n- \"rendering the keyboard and monitor unrecognizable\": Not visible. The keyboard and monitor are clearly recognizable.\n- \"no prominent object due to extreme roughness and disintegration\": Not visible. The cat is a prominent object and the image is not rough or disintegrated.\n\nAll 7 effects are not visible. Therefore, the special effects score is 0.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.246826171875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.15380859375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.287353515625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.27490234375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.017730712890625,
-0.040374755859375
],
[
-2.267578125,
2.255859375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.1829833984375,
"image_reward_diop": -1.99609375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.52001953125,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.481689453125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.140449047088623,
-4.716049671173096
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-6.962062835693359,
-3.5854547023773193
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
7.666289329528809,
-4.793185234069824
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
6.661076068878174,
-4.593537330627441
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.01129150390625,
1.1015625,
0.6796875,
0.0264892578125,
0.1650390625,
0.515625,
0.69140625,
0.1533203125,
0.2890625,
0.1044921875,
1.5859375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.022216796875,
1.7734375,
0.77734375,
0.035400390625,
0.78515625,
1,
1.140625,
0.2080078125,
1.984375,
0.8359375,
1.53125
]
}
} | 0.006145 | [
0.17443470656871796,
0.8255652189254761
] | [
0.00003992097845184617,
0.9999600648880005
] | [
0.53125,
0.46875
] | [
0.4960736334323883,
0.5039263963699341
] | -6.962063 |
193 | Photo of a man riding an old styled bicycle near what appears to be the Golden Gate Bridge. | A man rides an old bicycle near the Golden Gate Bridge, but the image is marred by clashing, overexposed colors, flat lighting with no shadows, and a blurry, unfinished background, creating an unpleasant, chaotic aesthetic. | ["color aesthetic", "richness", "background", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- clashing, overexposed colors: Not present. Colors are natural and well-exposed.\n- flat lighting with no shadows: Not present. There is clear directional lighting and distinct shadows.\n- blurry, unfinished background: Partially present. The background is somewhat blurry due to depth of field, but it is not unfinished.\n- unpleasant, chaotic aesthetic: Not present. The aesthetic is generally pleasant.\n\nOnly one out of four effects is partially visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 12,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: clashing, overexposed colors, flat lighting with no shadows, blurry, unfinished background, unpleasant, chaotic aesthetic.\n- 'clashing, overexposed colors': Not visible. Colors are natural and not overexposed.\n- 'flat lighting with no shadows': Not visible. There are clear shadows, indicating directional lighting.\n- 'blurry, unfinished background': Not visible. The background is clear and well-defined.\n- 'unpleasant, chaotic aesthetic': Not visible. The image has a clear and pleasant aesthetic.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.27392578125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.285400390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.26806640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.291748046875
} | -1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-3.447265625,
3.4453125
],
[
-4.09765625,
4.09765625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.890625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.9287109375,
"image_reward_oidp": 1.62109375,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.8173828125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
10.869420051574707,
-4.9946675300598145
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
8.863224983215332,
-4.888531684875488
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.642602920532227,
-5.000853061676025
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.778166770935059,
-4.882719039916992
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.140625,
1.3203125,
0.92578125,
0.72265625,
0.75390625,
1.03125,
0.859375,
0.1015625,
2,
0.0439453125,
1.375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.546875,
1.8515625,
0.85546875,
0.08935546875,
0.84765625,
0.96875,
0.79296875,
0.1640625,
2,
0.0966796875,
1.3125
]
}
} | 0.999512 | [
0.4354977309703827,
0.5645022392272949
] | [
0.6377458572387695,
0.36225417256355286
] | [
0.67578125,
0.32421875
] | [
0.500268816947937,
0.4997311532497406
] | 8.863225 |
194 | A man sitting on a couch in front of a window. | A man sits on a couch before a window, bathed in flat, shadowless gloom, evoking loneliness and anxiety; the absence of light or shadow amplifies emptiness and creepiness, intensifying the scene’s oppressive, emotion-laden stillness. | ["emotion", "lighting distinction"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- flat, shadowless gloom: Visible. The lighting is very flat with minimal shadows.\n- evoking loneliness and anxiety: Visible. The overall mood and the man's posture convey this.\n- absence of light or shadow amplifies emptiness and creepiness: Visible. The flat lighting contributes to emptiness and a somewhat creepy atmosphere.\n- intensifying the scene’s oppressive, emotion-laden stillness: Visible. The lack of dynamic lighting and the man's pose create a still and oppressive feeling.\n\nAll four effects are clearly visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects:\n- flat, shadowless gloom: The lighting is somewhat flat, but there are still shadows present, especially on the man and the couch.\n- evoking loneliness and anxiety: This is subjective, but the man's posture and the overall muted tones could suggest this.\n- absence of light or shadow: This is not true; there is light coming from the window and shadows are visible.\n- amplifies emptiness and creepiness: Subjective, but the scene doesn't strongly convey creepiness.\n- intensifying the scene’s oppressive, emotion-laden stillness: Subjective, but the stillness is present.\n\nChecking effects:\n- flat, shadowless gloom: Partially visible (flatness is somewhat there, but shadows are present).\n- evoking loneliness and anxiety: Visible (subjectively).\n- absence of light or shadow: Not visible.\n- amplifies emptiness and creepiness: Partially visible (emptiness more than creepiness).\n- intensifying the scene’s oppressive, emotion-laden stillness: Visible (stillness is clear).\n\nSmooth score computation: 3 out of 5 effects are somewhat visible or clearly visible, leading to a score of 60.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 60
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.25341796875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.23291015625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.28662109375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.28466796875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-1.982421875,
1.982421875
],
[
-3.984375,
3.99609375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.0166015625,
"image_reward_diop": 1.375,
"image_reward_oidp": 0.324462890625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.4091796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.1527791023254395,
-4.657586574554443
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.1718082427978516,
-4.090939998626709
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
11.077366828918457,
-5.01011323928833
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.487493515014648,
-4.8757758140563965
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
0,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0211181640625,
0.796875,
0.70703125,
0.000095367431640625,
0.439453125,
0.953125,
0.48828125,
0.97265625,
1.984375,
0.515625,
1.109375
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.77734375,
1.21875,
0.875,
0.88671875,
0.54296875,
1.171875,
0.953125,
0.77734375,
1.984375,
0.92578125,
1.375
]
}
} | 0.98877 | [
0.45063087344169617,
0.5493690967559814
] | [
0.5273569822311401,
0.47264307737350464
] | [
0.2379150390625,
0.76220703125
] | [
0.49796444177627563,
0.5020354986190796
] | 3.171808 |
195 | A person walking along a beach carrying a surfboard. | A distorted, unnaturally bent surfboard drags behind a hunched, featureless figure on a pitch-black beach; warped limbs and smeared sand evoke dread, while oppressive darkness and glitchy textures amplify loneliness and anxiety, making the scene feel unreal and deeply unsettling. | ["emotion", "detail realism", "color brightness"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Distorted, unnaturally bent surfboard: The surfboard is bent and distorted.\n- Drags behind: The surfboard is held, not dragging behind.\n- Huniched, featureless figure: The figure is hunched and featureless.\n- Pitch-black beach: The beach is grey, not pitch-black.\n- Warped limbs: The limbs are not noticeably warped.\n- Smeared sand: The sand has some smearing/texture.\n- Evoke dread: Subjective, but the overall mood is somewhat unsettling.\n- Oppressive darkness: The image is dark, but not oppressively so.\n- Glitchy textures: No glitchy textures are visible.\n- Amplify loneliness and anxiety: Subjective, but the mood is somewhat lonely/anxious.\n\nApproximately 5 out of 10 effects are clearly visible or partially visible.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 50,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n- distorted, unnaturally bent surfboard: Not visible. The surfboard is normal.\n- drags behind: Not visible. The surfboard is being carried.\n- hunched, featureless figure: Not visible. The figure is standing upright and has visible features (hair, clothing).\n- pitch-black beach: Not visible. The beach is light-colored sand.\n- warped limbs: Not visible. The limbs are normal.\n- smeared sand: Not visible. The sand is clear.\n- evoke dread: Not visible. The image is calm.\n- oppressive darkness: Not visible. The image is bright and overcast.\n- glitchy textures: Not visible. The textures are smooth and natural.\n- amplify loneliness: Not visible. The image shows two people, suggesting companionship.\n- anxiety: Not visible. The image is peaceful.\n- unreal: Not visible. The image is realistic.\n- deeply unsettling: Not visible. The image is serene.\n\nNone of the described effects are visible in the image.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2352294921875,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2044677734375,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25830078125,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.267578125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.63037109375,
-0.6416015625
],
[
-2.302734375,
2.3125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.36181640625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.83154296875,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.53515625,
"image_reward_oiop": 1.6796875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.654050827026367,
-4.871191501617432
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
-2.1832642555236816,
-3.780278205871582
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.619857788085938,
-4.968766689300537
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.932100296020508,
-4.933680534362793
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
0
],
"scores": [
0.10888671875,
1,
0.53125,
0.0024566650390625,
0.107421875,
0.6328125,
0.76171875,
0.83984375,
1.4453125,
0.0478515625,
0.44921875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0712890625,
0.80859375,
0.65234375,
0.53515625,
0.60546875,
0.8203125,
0.875,
0.07861328125,
1.859375,
0.37109375,
0.8515625
]
}
} | 0.844238 | [
0.3073965907096863,
0.6926034092903137
] | [
0.000056831009715097025,
0.9999431371688843
] | [
0.39599609375,
0.60400390625
] | [
0.4961796700954437,
0.5038203001022339
] | -2.183264 |
196 | Person on one end of a table that has a glass of beer, fork, bread, and sausage on it. | A person sits at a table with a beer glass, fork, bread, and sausage, but the objects are grotesquely distorted—fork bends unnaturally, bread melts into sausage, beer spills chaotically, and proportions clash, creating a visually disharmonious, surreal, and inauthentic scene. | ["object pairing", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned in the distorted prompt:\n - \"fork bends unnaturally\": The fork on the table is straight, not bent unnaturally.\n - \"bread melts into sausage\": The bread and sausage are distinct, not melted together.\n - \"beer spills chaotically\": The beer in the glasses is contained, not spilling chaotically.\n - \"proportions clash\": The proportions of the objects and people are distorted and clashing, especially the people's faces and hands, and the size of the bread.\n - \"visually disharmonious\": The overall scene is visually disharmonious due to the distortions.\n - \"surreal\": The scene has a surreal quality due to the distortions.\n - \"inauthentic scene\": The scene appears inauthentic due to the distortions.\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - \"fork bends unnaturally\": 0/1 (not visible)\n - \"bread melts into sausage\": 0/1 (not visible)\n - \"beer spills chaotically\": 0/1 (not visible)\n - \"proportions clash\": 1/1 (visible)\n - \"visually disharmonious\": 1/1 (visible)\n - \"surreal\": 1/1 (visible)\n - \"inauthentic scene\": 1/1 (visible)\n- Smooth score computation: 4 out of 7 effects are visible, which is approximately 57%.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 57,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: fork bends unnaturally, bread melts into sausage, beer spills chaotically, proportions clash, visually disharmonious, surreal, inauthentic scene.\n- 'fork bends unnaturally': Not visible. Forks appear normal.\n- 'bread melts into sausage': Not visible. Bread and sausage are distinct.\n- 'beer spills chaotically': Not visible. Beer is contained in glasses.\n- 'proportions clash': Not clearly visible. Objects appear to have normal proportions relative to each other.\n- 'visually disharmonious, surreal, and inauthentic scene': These are subjective interpretations of the overall effect, which are not strongly supported by specific visual distortions.\n- Score: 0 out of 6 effects are clearly visible.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.2476806640625,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.2066650390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.271240234375,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.269775390625
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
-2.853515625,
2.841796875
],
[
-3.10546875,
3.09765625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": -0.217041015625,
"image_reward_diop": -0.83984375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.01837158203125,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.339599609375
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.877181053161621,
-4.957073211669922
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
4.914308071136475,
-4.294864177703857
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
12.04888916015625,
-5.013288974761963
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.92775821685791,
-4.901430606842041
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.59375,
1.84375,
0.78125,
0.0400390625,
0.91796875,
0.89453125,
1.375,
0.0294189453125,
2,
0.0498046875,
1.8125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
2,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.78515625,
1.96875,
0.98828125,
0.1708984375,
0.578125,
1.390625,
1.25,
0.30078125,
2,
0.58984375,
1.796875
]
}
} | 0.998047 | [
0.5745980739593506,
0.4254019558429718
] | [
0.9364636540412903,
0.06353636831045151
] | [
0.994140625,
0.00579833984375
] | [
0.498010516166687,
0.5019894242286682
] | 4.914308 |
197 | a made bed with four pillows and lamp on a table | A made bed with four pillows and a lamp on a table, rendered with extreme fragmentation and roughness, lacking light/shadow, distorted objects, and an ugly, nonexistent background, making details indecipherable and realism inauthentic. | ["detail refinement", "detail realism", "lighting distinction", "background"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: extreme fragmentation and roughness, lacking light/shadow, distorted objects, ugly/nonexistent background, details indecipherable, realism inauthentic.\n- Extreme fragmentation and roughness: Visible, the image has a very rough, almost crumbling texture throughout.\n- Lacking light/shadow: Partially visible, there are some areas of light and shadow, but they are often muted or indistinct, contributing to the overall flat appearance.\n- Distorted objects: Visible, the objects like the bed, pillows, and table appear somewhat misshapen and not entirely realistic.\n- Ugly/nonexistent background: Visible, the background wall is abstract and indistinct, contributing to an ugly or nonexistent feel.\n- Details indecipherable: Visible, many details are lost in the rough texture and distortion.\n- Realism inauthentic: Visible, the overall image lacks realism due to the combined effects.\n- All 6 effects are clearly present to a significant degree.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 100,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: extreme fragmentation, roughness, lacking light/shadow, distorted objects, ugly nonexistent background, details indecipherable, realism inauthentic.\n- Checking effects visibility:\n - Extreme fragmentation: Not visible.\n - Roughness: Not visible.\n - Lacking light/shadow: Not visible, light and shadow are present.\n - Distorted objects: Not visible, objects are clear.\n - Ugly nonexistent background: Not visible, background is present and not ugly.\n - Details indecipherable: Not visible, details are clear.\n - Realism inauthentic: Not visible, image is realistic.\n- All effects are absent.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.234375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.171875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.2205810546875,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.2384033203125
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
0.230712890625,
-0.2481689453125
],
[
-1.7431640625,
1.736328125
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.521484375,
"image_reward_diop": -0.81005859375,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.387451171875,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.1319580078125
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
8.111591339111328,
-4.8614606857299805
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
0.9453598260879517,
-3.9180896282196045
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
10.580949783325195,
-4.9815592765808105
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.209089279174805,
-4.851890563964844
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
1,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.66015625,
0.9609375,
0.7578125,
0.2890625,
0.57421875,
1.1328125,
0.78515625,
0.326171875,
1.6875,
0.59375,
1.53125
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
1,
0,
0,
2,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.2080078125,
1.9375,
1.265625,
0.009033203125,
0.47265625,
1.4609375,
0.74609375,
0.7578125,
0.796875,
0.267578125,
1.15625
]
}
} | 0.575195 | [
0.12472328543663025,
0.8752766847610474
] | [
0.00044870315468870103,
0.9995512366294861
] | [
0.0863037109375,
0.91357421875
] | [
0.4959353804588318,
0.5040646195411682
] | 0.94536 |
198 | A baseball player is trying to hit the ball. | A baseball player swings at a ball, but the image is fragmented and broken, with jagged edges and pixelated textures. The background is absent or ugly, and details are rough, making objects indiscernible. The overall image feels unfinished and extremely low quality. | ["background", "detail refinement"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: fragmented, broken, jagged edges, pixelated textures, background absent or ugly, details rough, objects indiscernible, unfinished, extremely low quality.\n- Fragmented: Partially visible in the background, but not on the main subject.\n- Broken: Not clearly visible.\n- Jagged edges: Visible in the background and some outlines.\n- Pixelated textures: Visible in the background and on the uniform.\n- Background absent or ugly: The background is abstract and somewhat ugly.\n- Details rough: Details on the player are somewhat rough.\n- Objects indiscernible: The main objects (player, bat) are discernible.\n- Unfinished: The overall aesthetic has an unfinished, painterly quality.\n- Extremely low quality: The image quality is not extremely low; it's stylized.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 6/9 effects are visible to some extent.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 67,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: fragmented and broken, jagged edges, pixelated textures, background absent or ugly, details rough, objects indiscernible, unfinished, extremely low quality.\n- fragmented and broken: Not visible.\n- jagged edges: Not visible.\n- pixelated textures: Not visible.\n- background absent or ugly: The background is present and clear, not ugly.\n- details rough: Details are clear, not rough.\n- objects indiscernible: Objects are clearly discernible.\n- unfinished: Not visible.\n- extremely low quality: The image is of good quality.\n- Proportion of effects visible: 0/8 = 0%",
"llm_original_special_effects": 0
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.341552734375,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.3154296875,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.25634765625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.281982421875
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
2.10546875,
-2.12109375
],
[
-2.73828125,
2.744140625
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 1.216796875,
"image_reward_diop": 0.392822265625,
"image_reward_oidp": -0.2861328125,
"image_reward_oiop": -0.330810546875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
9.169099807739258,
-4.921192169189453
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
11.70603084564209,
-5.006585121154785
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
8.818263053894043,
-4.89849328994751
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
10.885878562927246,
-5.009128093719482
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
0,
2,
0,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
0,
1
],
"scores": [
0.0419921875,
1.9140625,
0.50390625,
1.0546875,
0.09619140625,
0.7578125,
0.90234375,
0.85546875,
1.9921875,
0.322265625,
1.1171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
1,
1,
1,
0,
0,
1,
1,
2,
1,
1
],
"scores": [
0.93359375,
0.9375,
0.8515625,
0.7421875,
0.279296875,
0.7890625,
1.0859375,
0.875,
1.9921875,
0.89453125,
1.40625
]
}
} | 0.050934 | [
0.272182822227478,
0.727817177772522
] | [
0.013975645415484905,
0.9860243201255798
] | [
0.060089111328125,
0.93994140625
] | [
0.49474769830703735,
0.5052523612976074
] | 11.706031 |
199 | Three woman and a man all sitting at a table on their cell phones. | Three women and a man sit at a table, all on cell phones, under flat, shadowless lighting. Ugly, clashing colors dominate—muddy greens, sickly yellows, and garish pinks. Faces and objects are distorted, edges blurred, proportions warped, creating an inauthentic, surreal scene. | ["lighting distinction", "color aesthetic", "detail realism"] | {
"llm_distorted_main_concepts": 100,
"llm_distorted_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: flat, shadowless lighting; ugly, clashing colors (muddy greens, sickly yellows, garish pinks); faces and objects distorted; edges blurred; proportions warped; inauthentic, surreal scene.\n- Flat, shadowless lighting: Visible, the lighting is very even with minimal shadows.\n- Ugly, clashing colors (muddy greens, sickly yellows, garish pinks): Visible, the colors are very vibrant and clash significantly.\n- Faces and objects distorted: Visible, faces are somewhat distorted and objects on the table also show some distortion.\n- Edges blurred: Partially visible, some edges are blurred but others are quite sharp.\n- Proportions warped: Partially visible, some proportions seem slightly off, but not extremely warped.\n- Inauthentic, surreal scene: Visible, the overall scene has a very artificial and surreal quality.\n- Score: 5 out of 6 effects are clearly visible or partially visible, leading to a high score.",
"llm_distorted_special_effects": 83,
"llm_original_main_concepts": 90,
"llm_original_reasoning": "- Main visual effects mentioned: flat, shadowless lighting; ugly, clashing colors (muddy greens, sickly yellows, garish pinks); faces and objects distorted; edges blurred; proportions warped; inauthentic, surreal scene.\n- Flat, shadowless lighting: Partially visible. The lighting is somewhat flat, but there are still shadows.\n- Ugly, clashing colors: Not visible. The colors are generally muted and not clashing or garish.\n- Faces and objects distorted: Partially visible. Some faces appear slightly off, and objects like the phones are somewhat distorted.\n- Edges blurred: Not visible. Edges are generally clear.\n- Proportions warped: Partially visible. Some proportions, especially of the people and phones, seem slightly off.\n- Inauthentic, surreal scene: Partially visible. The overall scene has a slightly artificial feel due to the subtle distortions.\n- Score: 3 out of 6 effects are partially visible, leading to a score of approximately 50.",
"llm_original_special_effects": 50
} | {
"hpsv2_didp": 0.3095703125,
"hpsv2_diop": 0.254150390625,
"hpsv2_oidp": 0.273681640625,
"hpsv2_oiop": 0.286865234375
} | 1 | 1 | stable_diffusion_xl | [
[
2.59375,
-2.615234375
],
[
-4.328125,
4.34375
]
] | {
"image_reward_didp": 0.51416015625,
"image_reward_diop": 0.032196044921875,
"image_reward_oidp": -1.6171875,
"image_reward_oiop": -1.044921875
} | {
"hpsv3_didp": null,
"hpsv3_diop": null,
"hpsv3_oidp": null,
"hpsv3_oiop": null,
"hpsv3_reward": {
"hpsv3_didp": [
7.363144874572754,
-4.674196243286133
],
"hpsv3_diop": [
3.9301187992095947,
-4.086764335632324
],
"hpsv3_oidp": [
9.506418228149414,
-4.9004926681518555
],
"hpsv3_oiop": [
8.254459381103516,
-4.843204498291016
]
}
} | {
"distorted": {
"preds": [
1,
0,
0,
0,
1,
0,
0,
0,
2,
0,
2
],
"scores": [
0.81640625,
1,
0.294921875,
0.050537109375,
0.90625,
0.6328125,
0.404296875,
0.48046875,
1.984375,
0.353515625,
1.6171875
]
},
"original": {
"preds": [
1,
2,
1,
0,
1,
0,
1,
0,
2,
1,
2
],
"scores": [
0.890625,
1.75,
0.93359375,
0.2890625,
0.8515625,
0.80859375,
0.76953125,
0.0810546875,
1.9921875,
0.73046875,
1.6796875
]
}
} | 0.601074 | [
0.0982905924320221,
0.9017093777656555
] | [
0.03364942967891693,
0.9663505554199219
] | [
0.435791015625,
0.56396484375
] | [
0.4994988739490509,
0.5005010366439819
] | 3.930119 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.