InteriorGS_sceneshift / benchmark_analysis.md
yinbq's picture
Add files using upload-large-folder tool
2299aa8 verified

Benchmark Dataset Analysis

Overview

  • Total Unique Question IDs: 4824
  • Total Entries (with all views): 37056
  • Patterns: around, spherical, linear_approach, linear_passby, rotation
  • Average Views per Question: 7.68

Question Type Distribution

Question Type Count Percentage
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 824 17.1%
object_size_comparison_absolute 824 17.1%
object_size_comparison_relative 813 16.9%
object_distance_to_camera 513 10.6%
object_size 513 10.6%
object_pair_distance_center 467 9.7%
object_pair_distance_vector 467 9.7%
object_comparison_relative_distance 203 4.2%
object_comparison_absolute_distance 200 4.1%

Views Distribution

Number of Views Question Count
3 564
4 712
5 15385
6 66
7 14
8 8
10 10
11 132
12 348
13 364
14 28
15 19425

Per-Pattern Breakdown

AROUND

  • Unique Question IDs: 779
  • Total Entries: 10599
Scene Unique QIDs Entries Avg Views
0015_840888 96 1440 15.0
0042_839881 118 1488 12.6
0106_839990 170 1799 10.6
0200_840150 103 1500 14.6
0267_840790 292 4372 15.0

Question Types:

  • object_pair_distance_center_w_size: 121
  • object_size_comparison_absolute: 121
  • object_size_comparison_relative: 120
  • object_distance_to_camera: 99
  • object_size: 99
  • object_pair_distance_center: 65
  • object_pair_distance_vector: 65
  • object_comparison_relative_distance: 49
  • object_comparison_absolute_distance: 40

SPHERICAL

  • Unique Question IDs: 764
  • Total Entries: 10427
Scene Unique QIDs Entries Avg Views
0015_840888 96 1440 15.0
0042_839881 105 1347 12.8
0106_839990 170 1798 10.6
0200_840150 103 1500 14.6
0267_840790 290 4342 15.0

Question Types:

  • object_pair_distance_center_w_size: 118
  • object_size_comparison_absolute: 118
  • object_size_comparison_relative: 117
  • object_distance_to_camera: 99
  • object_size: 99
  • object_pair_distance_center: 63
  • object_pair_distance_vector: 63
  • object_comparison_absolute_distance: 47
  • object_comparison_relative_distance: 40

LINEAR_APPROACH

  • Unique Question IDs: 1092
  • Total Entries: 5337
Scene Unique QIDs Entries Avg Views
0015_840888 252 1258 5.0
0042_839881 175 863 4.9
0106_839990 233 1060 4.5
0200_840150 186 928 5.0
0267_840790 246 1228 5.0

Question Types:

  • object_pair_distance_center_w_size: 195
  • object_size_comparison_absolute: 195
  • object_size_comparison_relative: 192
  • object_pair_distance_center: 113
  • object_pair_distance_vector: 113
  • object_distance_to_camera: 105
  • object_size: 105
  • object_comparison_absolute_distance: 37
  • object_comparison_relative_distance: 37

LINEAR_PASSBY

  • Unique Question IDs: 1094
  • Total Entries: 5351
Scene Unique QIDs Entries Avg Views
0015_840888 252 1257 5.0
0042_839881 177 869 4.9
0106_839990 233 1067 4.6
0200_840150 186 928 5.0
0267_840790 246 1230 5.0

Question Types:

  • object_pair_distance_center_w_size: 195
  • object_size_comparison_absolute: 195
  • object_size_comparison_relative: 192
  • object_pair_distance_center: 113
  • object_pair_distance_vector: 113
  • object_distance_to_camera: 105
  • object_size: 105
  • object_comparison_relative_distance: 40
  • object_comparison_absolute_distance: 36

ROTATION

  • Unique Question IDs: 1095
  • Total Entries: 5342
Scene Unique QIDs Entries Avg Views
0015_840888 252 1257 5.0
0042_839881 178 872 4.9
0106_839990 233 1055 4.5
0200_840150 186 928 5.0
0267_840790 246 1230 5.0

Question Types:

  • object_pair_distance_center_w_size: 195
  • object_size_comparison_absolute: 195
  • object_size_comparison_relative: 192
  • object_pair_distance_center: 113
  • object_pair_distance_vector: 113
  • object_distance_to_camera: 105
  • object_size: 105
  • object_comparison_absolute_distance: 40
  • object_comparison_relative_distance: 37

Per-Scene Detailed Breakdown

around / 0015_840888

  • Unique Question IDs: 96
  • Total Entries: 1440
  • Average Views: 15.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 37
object_size 37
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 6
object_size_comparison_absolute 6
object_size_comparison_relative 6
object_pair_distance_center 2
object_pair_distance_vector 2

around / 0042_839881

  • Unique Question IDs: 118
  • Total Entries: 1488
  • Average Views: 12.6
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 21
object_size_comparison_absolute 21
object_size_comparison_relative 21
object_comparison_relative_distance 15
object_distance_to_camera 10
object_size 10
object_pair_distance_center 7
object_pair_distance_vector 7
object_comparison_absolute_distance 6

around / 0106_839990

  • Unique Question IDs: 170
  • Total Entries: 1799
  • Average Views: 10.6
Question Type Count
object_comparison_absolute_distance 34
object_comparison_relative_distance 34
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 24
object_size_comparison_absolute 24
object_size_comparison_relative 24
object_pair_distance_center 8
object_pair_distance_vector 8
object_distance_to_camera 7
object_size 7

around / 0200_840150

  • Unique Question IDs: 103
  • Total Entries: 1500
  • Average Views: 14.6
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 27
object_size_comparison_absolute 27
object_size_comparison_relative 27
object_pair_distance_center 9
object_pair_distance_vector 9
object_distance_to_camera 2
object_size 2

around / 0267_840790

  • Unique Question IDs: 292
  • Total Entries: 4372
  • Average Views: 15.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 39
object_pair_distance_vector 39

spherical / 0015_840888

  • Unique Question IDs: 96
  • Total Entries: 1440
  • Average Views: 15.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 37
object_size 37
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 6
object_size_comparison_absolute 6
object_size_comparison_relative 6
object_pair_distance_center 2
object_pair_distance_vector 2

spherical / 0042_839881

  • Unique Question IDs: 105
  • Total Entries: 1347
  • Average Views: 12.8
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 18
object_size_comparison_absolute 18
object_size_comparison_relative 18
object_comparison_absolute_distance 13
object_distance_to_camera 10
object_size 10
object_comparison_relative_distance 6
object_pair_distance_center 6
object_pair_distance_vector 6

spherical / 0106_839990

  • Unique Question IDs: 170
  • Total Entries: 1798
  • Average Views: 10.6
Question Type Count
object_comparison_absolute_distance 34
object_comparison_relative_distance 34
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 24
object_size_comparison_absolute 24
object_size_comparison_relative 24
object_pair_distance_center 8
object_pair_distance_vector 8
object_distance_to_camera 7
object_size 7

spherical / 0200_840150

  • Unique Question IDs: 103
  • Total Entries: 1500
  • Average Views: 14.6
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 27
object_size_comparison_absolute 27
object_size_comparison_relative 27
object_pair_distance_center 9
object_pair_distance_vector 9
object_distance_to_camera 2
object_size 2

spherical / 0267_840790

  • Unique Question IDs: 290
  • Total Entries: 4342
  • Average Views: 15.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 38
object_pair_distance_vector 38

linear_approach / 0015_840888

  • Unique Question IDs: 252
  • Total Entries: 1258
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 19
object_pair_distance_vector 19

linear_approach / 0042_839881

  • Unique Question IDs: 175
  • Total Entries: 863
  • Average Views: 4.9
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 33
object_size_comparison_absolute 33
object_size_comparison_relative 33
object_pair_distance_center 25
object_pair_distance_vector 25
object_distance_to_camera 10
object_size 10
object_comparison_absolute_distance 3
object_comparison_relative_distance 3

linear_approach / 0106_839990

  • Unique Question IDs: 233
  • Total Entries: 1060
  • Average Views: 4.5
Question Type Count
object_comparison_absolute_distance 34
object_comparison_relative_distance 34
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 33
object_size_comparison_absolute 33
object_size_comparison_relative 33
object_pair_distance_center 26
object_pair_distance_vector 26
object_distance_to_camera 7
object_size 7

linear_approach / 0200_840150

  • Unique Question IDs: 186
  • Total Entries: 928
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 27
object_pair_distance_vector 27
object_distance_to_camera 2
object_size 2

linear_approach / 0267_840790

  • Unique Question IDs: 246
  • Total Entries: 1228
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 16
object_pair_distance_vector 16

linear_passby / 0015_840888

  • Unique Question IDs: 252
  • Total Entries: 1257
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 19
object_pair_distance_vector 19

linear_passby / 0042_839881

  • Unique Question IDs: 177
  • Total Entries: 869
  • Average Views: 4.9
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 33
object_size_comparison_absolute 33
object_size_comparison_relative 33
object_pair_distance_center 25
object_pair_distance_vector 25
object_distance_to_camera 10
object_size 10
object_comparison_relative_distance 6
object_comparison_absolute_distance 2

linear_passby / 0106_839990

  • Unique Question IDs: 233
  • Total Entries: 1067
  • Average Views: 4.6
Question Type Count
object_comparison_absolute_distance 34
object_comparison_relative_distance 34
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 33
object_size_comparison_absolute 33
object_size_comparison_relative 33
object_pair_distance_center 26
object_pair_distance_vector 26
object_distance_to_camera 7
object_size 7

linear_passby / 0200_840150

  • Unique Question IDs: 186
  • Total Entries: 928
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 27
object_pair_distance_vector 27
object_distance_to_camera 2
object_size 2

linear_passby / 0267_840790

  • Unique Question IDs: 246
  • Total Entries: 1230
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 16
object_pair_distance_vector 16

rotation / 0015_840888

  • Unique Question IDs: 252
  • Total Entries: 1257
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 19
object_pair_distance_vector 19

rotation / 0042_839881

  • Unique Question IDs: 178
  • Total Entries: 872
  • Average Views: 4.9
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 33
object_size_comparison_absolute 33
object_size_comparison_relative 33
object_pair_distance_center 25
object_pair_distance_vector 25
object_distance_to_camera 10
object_size 10
object_comparison_absolute_distance 6
object_comparison_relative_distance 3

rotation / 0106_839990

  • Unique Question IDs: 233
  • Total Entries: 1055
  • Average Views: 4.5
Question Type Count
object_comparison_absolute_distance 34
object_comparison_relative_distance 34
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 33
object_size_comparison_absolute 33
object_size_comparison_relative 33
object_pair_distance_center 26
object_pair_distance_vector 26
object_distance_to_camera 7
object_size 7

rotation / 0200_840150

  • Unique Question IDs: 186
  • Total Entries: 928
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 27
object_pair_distance_vector 27
object_distance_to_camera 2
object_size 2

rotation / 0267_840790

  • Unique Question IDs: 246
  • Total Entries: 1230
  • Average Views: 5.0
Question Type Count
object_distance_to_camera 43
object_pair_distance_center_w_size 43
object_size 43
object_size_comparison_absolute 43
object_size_comparison_relative 42
object_pair_distance_center 16
object_pair_distance_vector 16

Selection Criteria

The benchmark was created with the following goals:

  1. Balanced across scenes: Each scene contributes roughly equal number of questions
  2. Balanced question types: Within each scene, different question types are equally represented
  3. Multi-view priority: Questions with more views are prioritized for multi-view evaluation
  4. Minimum view threshold: Only questions with sufficient views are included