Split (1)

train · 10.4M rows

ngram listlengths 0 9.89k
[ "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without", "not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with me", "In general, how should our community look upon such questions-answers", "backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being", "inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative", "point where I am wrong. I don't have the reputation", "I am wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close,", "and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre", "on the opinions of users and not facts). So... 1.", "reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required.", "opinions of users and not facts). So... 1. Does the", "needs to, if required. 2. In general, how should our", "over an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on", "good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users", "answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of", "If 'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong. I", "someone else needs to, if required. 2. In general, how", "where I am wrong. I don't have the reputation to", "I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else", "me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I", "comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over", "and not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with", "'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong. I don't", "kindly point where I am wrong. I don't have the", "1. Does the community agree with me over these? If", "mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users and not", "based on the opinions of users and not facts). So...", "without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an", "these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong.", "speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion", "users and not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree", "the community agree with me over these? If 'NO', then", "should our community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting", "our community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting more", "2. In general, how should our community look upon such", "(again, based on the opinions of users and not facts).", "if required. 2. In general, how should our community look", "the opinions of users and not facts). So... 1. Does", "over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I am", "community agree with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly", "proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute", "Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions", "community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting more opinions", "So... 1. Does the community agree with me over these?", "evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or", "required. 2. In general, how should our community look upon", "Does the community agree with me over these? If 'NO',", "wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone", "my opinion, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting", "am wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments", "with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where", "to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required. 2.", "are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and", "the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if", "how should our community look upon such questions-answers which are", "being good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of", "In my opinion, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are", "of users and not facts). So... 1. Does the community", "so someone else needs to, if required. 2. In general,", "opinion, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations,", "its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing", "else needs to, if required. 2. In general, how should", "look upon such questions-answers which are inviting more opinions than", "and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper", "don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs", "facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with me over", "upon such questions-answers which are inviting more opinions than facts.", "then kindly point where I am wrong. I don't have", "to, if required. 2. In general, how should our community", "[here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence,", "of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good", "vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required. 2. In", "an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on the", "general, how should our community look upon such questions-answers which", "agree with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point", "discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based", "argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre (again,", "or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users and", "have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to," ]
[ "answer, or it'll have to be converted to a comment", "and it doesn't seem like there is such a restriction.", "to me - it's synthetic, to the point, and clear", "to be converted to a comment > > > Is", "through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is", "> > > Is it true? I have skimmed through", "restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to me -", "rather change the FAQ? What is your opinion on this?", "we should rather change the FAQ? What is your opinion", "allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer,", "either expand your answer, or it'll have to be converted", "to a comment > > > Is it true? I", "should either expand your answer, or it'll have to be", "answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to the", "synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to stand as", "enough to stand as it is. Maybe we should rather", "comments: > > One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's.", "aeismail comments: > > One-line answers aren't allowed per our", "skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there", "is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What is", "[Here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9667/958) aeismail comments: > > One-line answers aren't allowed per", "it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it", "like there is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer", "> > One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You", "your answer, or it'll have to be converted to a", "comment > > > Is it true? I have skimmed", "expand your answer, or it'll have to be converted to", "> Is it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ,", "it doesn't seem like there is such a restriction. Besides", "seem like there is such a restriction. Besides that, that", "such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to", "the point, and clear enough to stand as it is.", "a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to me", "that, that answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic,", "it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to stand", "have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like", "clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe we should", "Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What is your", "I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem", "is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok", "to the point, and clear enough to stand as it", "Besides that, that answer looks ok to me - it's", "me - it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough", "converted to a comment > > > Is it true?", "Is it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and", "One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either", "doesn't seem like there is such a restriction. Besides that,", "there is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks", "looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to the point,", "be converted to a comment > > > Is it", "should rather change the FAQ? What is your opinion on", "it is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What", "the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is such", "point, and clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe", "as it is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ?", "a comment > > > Is it true? I have", "> One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should", "and clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe we", "aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand your", "FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or it'll have", "that answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to", "our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or it'll", "FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is such a", "ok to me - it's synthetic, to the point, and", "stand as it is. Maybe we should rather change the", "it'll have to be converted to a comment > >", "per our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or", "to stand as it is. Maybe we should rather change", "You should either expand your answer, or it'll have to", "true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't", "> > Is it true? I have skimmed through the", "or it'll have to be converted to a comment >", "answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand", "have to be converted to a comment > > >", "- it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to" ]
[ "thought about how this scales by a couple of orders", "sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow", "we think the question itself has useful terminology and wording", "as a duplicate, a link should be added to the", "lot of duplicates so this list would need to be", "all the knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe", "was an automatic process and did not require any suer", "a new user to easily find all the knowledge on", "the question. Maybe this is better for the main SO", "may have a lot of duplicates so this list would", "did not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to", "This would only be viable if it was an automatic", "to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea", "to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful", "and did not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting", "are what I will refer to as singly linked. A", "question. Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes the", "question is closed as a duplicate, a link should be", "this list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and", "better for the main SO meta, but I haven't really", "the original question pointing to the duplicates. This would only", "need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The", "meta, but I haven't really thought about how this scales", "be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would", "terminology and wording that is helpful for future searches. I", "we marked it as duplicate because we think the question", "a link should be added to the original question pointing", "idea would be to allow a new user to easily", "searchable. The idea would be to allow a new user", "site about the question. Maybe this is better for the", "be viable if it was an automatic process and did", "duplicate are what I will refer to as singly linked.", "I will refer to as singly linked. A link appears", "realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be to", "the closed duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing", "user to easily find all the knowledge on the site", "as a duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot", "for the main SO meta, but I haven't really thought", "what I will refer to as singly linked. A link", "be to allow a new user to easily find all", "but I haven't really thought about how this scales by", "to easily find all the knowledge on the site about", "appears on top of the closed duplicate question pointing to", "because we think the question itself has useful terminology and", "voting to close the question as a duplication. Obviously some", "only be viable if it was an automatic process and", "on top of the closed duplicate question pointing to the", "this is better for the main SO meta, but I", "a question is closed as a duplicate, a link should", "not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close", "think the question itself has useful terminology and wording that", "really thought about how this scales by a couple of", "The idea would be to allow a new user to", "the duplicates. This would only be viable if it was", "useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked it as", "answers and comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate", "to the original question pointing to the duplicates. This would", "pointing to the duplicates. This would only be viable if", "should be added to the original question pointing to the", "comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate because we", "will refer to as singly linked. A link appears on", "itself has useful terminology and wording that is helpful for", "duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing is added", "is added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question", "propose that whenever a question is closed as a duplicate,", "question as a duplication. Obviously some question may have a", "about how this scales by a couple of orders of", "and possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow a", "is closed as a duplicate, a link should be added", "By definition, we marked it as duplicate because we think", "closed duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing is", "as duplicate are what I will refer to as singly", "find all the knowledge on the site about the question.", "duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot of duplicates", "an automatic process and did not require any suer intervention", "whenever a question is closed as a duplicate, a link", "some question may have a lot of duplicates so this", "have a lot of duplicates so this list would need", "intervention beyond simply voting to close the question as a", "searches. I propose that whenever a question is closed as", "so this list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable,", "automatic process and did not require any suer intervention beyond", "of the closed duplicate question pointing to the original question.", "Maybe this is better for the main SO meta, but", "possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow a new", "allow a new user to easily find all the knowledge", "suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the question as", "useful terminology and wording that is helpful for future searches.", "would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable.", "about the question. Maybe this is better for the main", "viable if it was an automatic process and did not", "is better for the main SO meta, but I haven't", "wording that is helpful for future searches. I propose that", "easily find all the knowledge on the site about the", "closed as duplicate are what I will refer to as", "to allow a new user to easily find all the", "list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly", "A link appears on top of the closed duplicate question", "a duplicate, a link should be added to the original", "linked. A link appears on top of the closed duplicate", "future searches. I propose that whenever a question is closed", "the site about the question. Maybe this is better for", "top of the closed duplicate question pointing to the original", "and wording that is helpful for future searches. I propose", "the duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By definition,", "any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the question", "that is helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever", "to the duplicates. This would only be viable if it", "if it was an automatic process and did not require", "it as duplicate because we think the question itself has", "would only be viable if it was an automatic process", "it was an automatic process and did not require any", "original question pointing to the duplicates. This would only be", "original question. Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes", "Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate", "simply voting to close the question as a duplication. Obviously", "the original question. Nothing is added to the original question.", "close the question as a duplication. Obviously some question may", "question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and comments.", "question itself has useful terminology and wording that is helpful", "question pointing to the original question. Nothing is added to", "process and did not require any suer intervention beyond simply", "duplicates so this list would need to be dynamic, realizable,", "a duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot of", "marked it as duplicate because we think the question itself", "beyond simply voting to close the question as a duplication.", "refer to as singly linked. A link appears on top", "to the original question. Nothing is added to the original", "question has useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked", "definition, we marked it as duplicate because we think the", "question pointing to the duplicates. This would only be viable", "require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the", "haven't really thought about how this scales by a couple", "questions closed as duplicate are what I will refer to", "be added to the original question pointing to the duplicates.", "duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By definition, we", "new user to easily find all the knowledge on the", "of duplicates so this list would need to be dynamic,", "pointing to the original question. Nothing is added to the", "the question as a duplication. Obviously some question may have", "closed as a duplicate, a link should be added to", "the main SO meta, but I haven't really thought about", "as duplicate because we think the question itself has useful", "Obviously some question may have a lot of duplicates so", "added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has", "the knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe this", "I propose that whenever a question is closed as a", "as singly linked. A link appears on top of the", "has useful terminology and wording that is helpful for future", "knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe this is", "on the site about the question. Maybe this is better", "main SO meta, but I haven't really thought about how", "the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers", "and comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate because", "SO meta, but I haven't really thought about how this", "dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be", "original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and", "question may have a lot of duplicates so this list", "link appears on top of the closed duplicate question pointing", "Currently questions closed as duplicate are what I will refer", "duplicates. This would only be viable if it was an", "to as singly linked. A link appears on top of", "link should be added to the original question pointing to", "a lot of duplicates so this list would need to", "added to the original question pointing to the duplicates. This", "singly linked. A link appears on top of the closed", "duplicate because we think the question itself has useful terminology", "the question itself has useful terminology and wording that is", "how this scales by a couple of orders of magnitude.", "helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever a question", "duplicate, a link should be added to the original question", "question. Maybe this is better for the main SO meta,", "Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By", "has useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked it", "for future searches. I propose that whenever a question is", "that whenever a question is closed as a duplicate, a", "I haven't really thought about how this scales by a", "would be to allow a new user to easily find", "is helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever a", "to close the question as a duplication. Obviously some question" ]
[ "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9794/importance-of-going-to-university-in-the-21st-century> was closed on the main site, and identified as", "although it has received 5 different answers. How could this", "was closed on the main site, and identified as non-constructive,", "non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers. How could", "question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9794/importance-of-going-to-university-in-the-21st-century> was closed on the main site, and identified", "site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5", "it has received 5 different answers. How could this question", "different answers. How could this question be changed to be", "The question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9794/importance-of-going-to-university-in-the-21st-century> was closed on the main site, and", "answers. How could this question be changed to be more", "as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers. How", "How could this question be changed to be more constructive?", "has received 5 different answers. How could this question be", "on the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it", "received 5 different answers. How could this question be changed", "5 different answers. How could this question be changed to", "and identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different", "closed on the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although", "main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has received", "identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers.", "the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has" ]
[ "I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems", "a good fit for academia.se. Do you think we should", "to ask a similar type question, and I asked for", "good fit for academia.se. Do you think we should keep", "\"country poll\" questions are not a good fit for academia.se.", "big list question to me. I have wanted to ask", "for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these", "not a good fit for academia.se. Do you think we", "my country we do things like X, how do they", "X, how do they do them in your country. That", "[chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions", "type question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To", "me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not", "do they do them in your country. That seems like", "This [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9818/international-variations-in-addressing-academics) essentially asks: In my country we do things", "asks: In my country we do things like X, how", "country. That seems like the definition of a big list", "That seems like the definition of a big list question", "questions are not a good fit for academia.se. Do you", "definition of a big list question to me. I have", "how do they do them in your country. That seems", "in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country poll\"", "seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not a good", "Do you think we should keep these type of questions", "do them in your country. That seems like the definition", "for academia.se. Do you think we should keep these type", "question to me. I have wanted to ask a similar", "list question to me. I have wanted to ask a", "of a big list question to me. I have wanted", "these \"country poll\" questions are not a good fit for", "question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me", "the definition of a big list question to me. I", "seems like the definition of a big list question to", "fit for academia.se. Do you think we should keep these", "them in your country. That seems like the definition of", "to me. I have wanted to ask a similar type", "poll\" questions are not a good fit for academia.se. Do", "input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country", "asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that", "have wanted to ask a similar type question, and I", "and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it", "that these \"country poll\" questions are not a good fit", "similar type question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020).", "like X, how do they do them in your country.", "you think we should keep these type of questions open?", "To me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are", "I have wanted to ask a similar type question, and", "in your country. That seems like the definition of a", "academia.se. Do you think we should keep these type of", "they do them in your country. That seems like the", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9818/international-variations-in-addressing-academics) essentially asks: In my country we do things like", "like the definition of a big list question to me.", "country we do things like X, how do they do", "do things like X, how do they do them in", "things like X, how do they do them in your", "essentially asks: In my country we do things like X,", "ask a similar type question, and I asked for input", "we do things like X, how do they do them", "a big list question to me. I have wanted to", "your country. That seems like the definition of a big", "wanted to ask a similar type question, and I asked", "it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not a", "In my country we do things like X, how do", "me. I have wanted to ask a similar type question,", "a similar type question, and I asked for input in", "are not a good fit for academia.se. Do you think" ]
[ "to a site where you then have to hunt around", "The new display at the bottom is not very good,", "hunt around to find it. That's not a very good", "at the very least, we should list Acafitoa where it", "but that's not even in one of the categories shown", "opinion. But, at the very least, we should list Acafitoa", "to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in", "very least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes more", "bottom is not very good, in my opinion: I would", "at the bottom is not very good, in my opinion:", "below—you have to click through to get to a site", "list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is that", "not very good, in my opinion: I would expect to", "where it makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\" rather", "see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one", "not even in one of the categories shown in the", "display below—you have to click through to get to a", "least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense.", "categories shown in the display below—you have to click through", "under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of the", "shown in the display below—you have to click through to", "in the display below—you have to click through to get", "it. That's not a very good system in my opinion.", "\"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of", "is not very good, in my opinion: I would expect", "display at the bottom is not very good, in my", "then have to hunt around to find it. That's not", "click through to get to a site where you then", "opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but", "\"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of the categories", "to find it. That's not a very good system in", "good system in my opinion. But, at the very least,", "we should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But", "would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not", "But, at the very least, we should list Acafitoa where", "of the categories shown in the display below—you have to", "through to get to a site where you then have", "expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even", "very good system in my opinion. But, at the very", "good, in my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\"", "one of the categories shown in the display below—you have", "where you then have to hunt around to find it.", "to hunt around to find it. That's not a very", "to click through to get to a site where you", "find it. That's not a very good system in my", "in my opinion. But, at the very least, we should", "a very good system in my opinion. But, at the", "site where you then have to hunt around to find", "I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's", "new display at the bottom is not very good, in", "my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\"", "even in one of the categories shown in the display", "the categories shown in the display below—you have to click", "a site where you then have to hunt around to", "to get to a site where you then have to", "not a very good system in my opinion. But, at", "you then have to hunt around to find it. That's", "Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\"", "very good, in my opinion: I would expect to see", "it makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\" rather than", "the very least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes", "my opinion. But, at the very least, we should list", "have to click through to get to a site where", "the display below—you have to click through to get to", "have to hunt around to find it. That's not a", "That's not a very good system in my opinion. But,", "the bottom is not very good, in my opinion: I", "in my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under", "that's not even in one of the categories shown in", "in one of the categories shown in the display below—you", "should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is", "around to find it. That's not a very good system", "makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\" rather than \"Life/Arts?\"", "get to a site where you then have to hunt", "system in my opinion. But, at the very least, we" ]
[ "misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and", "the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in", "cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a", "Do you agree with it? Or do you propose an", "an exception than a typical example). Do you agree with", "discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact in", "Otherwise many questions and answers for things like publishing and", "is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact", "answers for things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as", "typical example). Do you agree with it? Or do you", "in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception", "AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged", "fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in", "approach to this issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent", "a typical example). Do you agree with it? Or do", "are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines", "However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial", "some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases,", "great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is", "than a typical example). Do you agree with it? Or", "with it? Or do you propose an alternative approach to", "many questions and answers for things like publishing and conferences", "[computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers", "cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g.", "in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")).", "question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this", "issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent questions are important.)", "is crucial to advertise this fact in the title (unless", "vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS", "disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather", "for things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in", "this issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent questions are", "is rather an exception than a typical example). Do you", "tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things like", "exception than a typical example). Do you agree with it?", "questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things", "(unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case:", "is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it", "title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this", "crucial to advertise this fact in the title (unless it's", "example). Do you agree with it? Or do you propose", "There is an abundance of questions relating to Computer Science,", "and answers for things like publishing and conferences are misleading,", "and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary", "agree with it? Or do you propose an alternative approach", "this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions", "conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among", "some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than", "to this issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent questions", "(and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an", "things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some", "publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices", "practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences,", "you propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That said,", "questions relating to Computer Science, which is great. However, when", "publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a typical example).", "is an abundance of questions relating to Computer Science, which", "(in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some", "propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I", "clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions", "IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact in the", "alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I think that", "e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a typical", "this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND", "abundance of questions relating to Computer Science, which is great.", "\"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for", "'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things like publishing", "a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise", "when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to", "in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags", "advertise this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear)", "tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise", "to Computer Science, which is great. However, when a question", "Science, which is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent,", "you agree with it? Or do you propose an alternative", "rather an exception than a typical example). Do you agree", "case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and", "an abundance of questions relating to Computer Science, which is", "Computer Science, which is great. However, when a question is", "which is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO", "as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in", "questions and answers for things like publishing and conferences are", "(in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many", "otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show", "CS is rather an exception than a typical example). Do", "relating to Computer Science, which is great. However, when a", "it is crucial to advertise this fact in the title", "to advertise this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise", "of questions relating to Computer Science, which is great. However,", "do you propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That", "it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science", "like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases)", "Or do you propose an alternative approach to this issue?", "it? Or do you propose an alternative approach to this", "an alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I think", "among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is" ]
[ "don't use them at all, I only search for questions", "related tags in particular. I was wondering: how do you", "would therefore be helpful to see what kind of usages", "particular. I was wondering: how do you use tags? Why", "care about them? Personally, I don't use them at all,", "I don't use them at all, I only search for", "wondering: how do you use tags? Why do we care", "for questions through the search bar. It would therefore be", "bar. It would therefore be helpful to see what kind", "them at all, I only search for questions through the", "through the search bar. It would therefore be helpful to", "all, I only search for questions through the search bar.", "the search bar. It would therefore be helpful to see", "how do you use tags? Why do we care about", "we care about them? Personally, I don't use them at", "therefore be helpful to see what kind of usages the", "about them? Personally, I don't use them at all, I", "search bar. It would therefore be helpful to see what", "was wondering: how do you use tags? Why do we", "recently about tags, and topic related tags in particular. I", "tags, and topic related tags in particular. I was wondering:", "I only search for questions through the search bar. It", "has been several questions recently about tags, and topic related", "to see what kind of usages the community has for", "tags in particular. I was wondering: how do you use", "Why do we care about them? Personally, I don't use", "helpful to see what kind of usages the community has", "use tags? Why do we care about them? Personally, I", "been several questions recently about tags, and topic related tags", "about tags, and topic related tags in particular. I was", "several questions recently about tags, and topic related tags in", "at all, I only search for questions through the search", "questions recently about tags, and topic related tags in particular.", "use them at all, I only search for questions through", "Personally, I don't use them at all, I only search", "There has been several questions recently about tags, and topic", "only search for questions through the search bar. It would", "do you use tags? Why do we care about them?", "you use tags? Why do we care about them? Personally,", "I was wondering: how do you use tags? Why do", "search for questions through the search bar. It would therefore", "It would therefore be helpful to see what kind of", "do we care about them? Personally, I don't use them", "see what kind of usages the community has for tags.", "and topic related tags in particular. I was wondering: how", "in particular. I was wondering: how do you use tags?", "topic related tags in particular. I was wondering: how do", "be helpful to see what kind of usages the community", "tags? Why do we care about them? Personally, I don't", "questions through the search bar. It would therefore be helpful", "them? Personally, I don't use them at all, I only" ]
[ "isn't much activity there. For instance just before writing this", "writing this meta question the last entry on chat room", "week ... 2. ... where the subject to be discussed", "sure if there has been anything like this before, here", "groups on the chat; for instance once a week or", "the chat; for instance once a week or every second", "students, would like to have a medium of communication where", "have on SE sites. I suppose a lot of us,", "fit for this purpose, however it appears as there isn't", "on meta I am not sure if there has been", "for the Q/A format that we have on SE sites.", "here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions", "not a good fit for the Q/A format that we", "2. ... where the subject to be discussed is voted", "this meta question the last entry on chat room was", "meta question the last entry on chat room was from", "has been anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated", "is voted here on meta I am not sure if", "senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is a good", "on the chat; for instance once a week or every", "activity there. For instance just before writing this meta question", "matters and questions about previous experiences of the more senior", "the chat, a concept which I find pretty cool despite", "despite my lack of interest in statistics :) What do", "I suppose a lot of us, grad students, would like", "for this purpose, however it appears as there isn't much", "the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is", "For instance just before writing this meta question the last", "was from 6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal:", "AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on the", "discussions on the chat, a concept which I find pretty", "last entry on chat room was from 6 days ago.", "article discussions on the chat, a concept which I find", "a good fit for this purpose, however it appears as", "where the subject to be discussed is voted here on", "or every second week ... 2. ... where the subject", "are quite a few users with questions that are little", "discussion groups on the chat; for instance once a week", "on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on", "pretty cool despite my lack of interest in statistics :)", "with questions that are little open-ended, which is not a", "on chat room was from 6 days ago. So here", "are little open-ended, which is not a good fit for", "for instance once a week or every second week ...", "of us, grad students, would like to have a medium", "discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of the more", "as there isn't much activity there. For instance just before", "room is a good fit for this purpose, however it", "a good fit for the Q/A format that we have", "which is not a good fit for the Q/A format", "like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs", "in statistics :) What do you think? Is this a", "a few users with questions that are little open-ended, which", "on the chat, a concept which I find pretty cool", "have a medium of communication where we can discuss matters", "... 2. ... where the subject to be discussed is", "a concept which I find pretty cool despite my lack", "a lot of us, grad students, would like to have", "users with questions that are little open-ended, which is not", "What do you think? Is this a desirable or sustainable", "open-ended, which is not a good fit for the Q/A", "meta I am not sure if there has been anything", "instance just before writing this meta question the last entry", "clubs with article discussions on the chat, a concept which", "little open-ended, which is not a good fit for the", "on SE sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad", "of communication where we can discuss matters and questions about", "6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We", "my lack of interest in statistics :) What do you", "week or every second week ... 2. ... where the", "sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad students, would", "concept which I find pretty cool despite my lack of", "this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with", "interest in statistics :) What do you think? Is this", "if there has been anything like this before, here on", "suppose a lot of us, grad students, would like to", "SE sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad students,", "experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat", "with article discussions on the chat, a concept which I", "more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is a", "purpose, however it appears as there isn't much activity there.", "chat; for instance once a week or every second week", "there isn't much activity there. For instance just before writing", "every second week ... 2. ... where the subject to", "subject to be discussed is voted here on meta I", "my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on the", "good fit for this purpose, however it appears as there", "would like to have a medium of communication where we", "find pretty cool despite my lack of interest in statistics", "format that we have on SE sites. I suppose a", "much activity there. For instance just before writing this meta", "am not sure if there has been anything like this", "discussed is voted here on meta I am not sure", "from 6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1.", "noticed that there are quite a few users with questions", "questions that are little open-ended, which is not a good", "a medium of communication where we can discuss matters and", "of AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit for", "this purpose, however it appears as there isn't much activity", "ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular", "chat room was from 6 days ago. So here comes", "that are little open-ended, which is not a good fit", "we have on SE sites. I suppose a lot of", "to be discussed is voted here on meta I am", "here on meta I am not sure if there has", "regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance once a", ":) What do you think? Is this a desirable or", "and questions about previous experiences of the more senior members", "before writing this meta question the last entry on chat", "chat, a concept which I find pretty cool despite my", "there. For instance just before writing this meta question the", "journal clubs with article discussions on the chat, a concept", "of the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room", "grad students, would like to have a medium of communication", "good fit for the Q/A format that we have on", "the subject to be discussed is voted here on meta", "I noticed that there are quite a few users with", "suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on the chat;", "that we have on SE sites. I suppose a lot", "the Q/A format that we have on SE sites. I", "appears as there isn't much activity there. For instance just", "statistics :) What do you think? Is this a desirable", "The chat room is a good fit for this purpose,", "We hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance", "there has been anything like this before, here on AC.SE.", "however it appears as there isn't much activity there. For", "hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance once", "voted here on meta I am not sure if there", "that there are quite a few users with questions that", "I find pretty cool despite my lack of interest in", "CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on the chat,", "the last entry on chat room was from 6 days", "days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold", "lack of interest in statistics :) What do you think?", "AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit for this", "once a week or every second week ... 2. ...", "1. We hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for", "communication where we can discuss matters and questions about previous", "room was from 6 days ago. So here comes my", "a week or every second week ... 2. ... where", "is not a good fit for the Q/A format that", "entry on chat room was from 6 days ago. So", "which I find pretty cool despite my lack of interest", "before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article", "Q/A format that we have on SE sites. I suppose", "I am not sure if there has been anything like", "quite a few users with questions that are little open-ended,", "previous experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE. The", "been anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has", "few users with questions that are little open-ended, which is", "about previous experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE.", "us, grad students, would like to have a medium of", "of interest in statistics :) What do you think? Is", "is a good fit for this purpose, however it appears", "we can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of", "be discussed is voted here on meta I am not", "it appears as there isn't much activity there. For instance", "can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of the", "instance once a week or every second week ... 2.", "fit for the Q/A format that we have on SE", "like to have a medium of communication where we can", "cool despite my lack of interest in statistics :) What", "has journal clubs with article discussions on the chat, a", "not sure if there has been anything like this before,", "comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on", "where we can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences", "lot of us, grad students, would like to have a", "... where the subject to be discussed is voted here", "medium of communication where we can discuss matters and questions", "question the last entry on chat room was from 6", "chat room is a good fit for this purpose, however", "questions about previous experiences of the more senior members of", "members of AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit", "there are quite a few users with questions that are", "just before writing this meta question the last entry on", "anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal", "here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups", "So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion", "to have a medium of communication where we can discuss", "second week ... 2. ... where the subject to be" ]
[ "is this so? Is it a bug in the feature?", "up in the top five once I am logged in.", "five once I am logged in. Why is this so?", "question comes up in the top five once I am", "Why is this so? Is it a bug in the", "this so? Is it a bug in the feature? ![List_questions](https://i.stack.imgur.com/1HmhW.png)", "the list of questions when I am not signed in.", "am not signed in. The question comes up in the", "when I am not signed in. The question comes up", "does not appear on the list of questions when I", "in. The question comes up in the top five once", "top five once I am logged in. Why is this", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of questions when", "I accidentally noted that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear", "I am logged in. Why is this so? Is it", "once I am logged in. Why is this so? Is", "on the list of questions when I am not signed", "not appear on the list of questions when I am", "in the top five once I am logged in. Why", "signed in. The question comes up in the top five", "particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of questions", "comes up in the top five once I am logged", "noted that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the", "of questions when I am not signed in. The question", "logged in. Why is this so? Is it a bug", "am logged in. Why is this so? Is it a", "accidentally noted that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on", "questions when I am not signed in. The question comes", "The question comes up in the top five once I", "not signed in. The question comes up in the top", "list of questions when I am not signed in. The", "the top five once I am logged in. Why is", "I am not signed in. The question comes up in", "in. Why is this so? Is it a bug in", "appear on the list of questions when I am not", "[a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of", "that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list" ]
[ "don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive", "that should have been closed but are not? Questions or", "questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter.", "really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts", "to their questions and don't even know that this site", "on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part", "this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will", "need answers to their questions and don't even know that", "through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before,", "see a pattern of questions that should have been closed", "how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net.", "to look at this site through the eyes of someone", "love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world", "an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer", "use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an", "edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below", "someone who's never seen it before, and see how we", "asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few", "questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do", "in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to", "but are not? Questions or answers that could use an", "site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it", "the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see", "of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of", "easy they are to find and compare the answers we", "Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people", "before, and see how we stack up against the rest", "Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's", "are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit?", "a few Google searches to see how easy they are", "to see how easy they are to find and compare", "your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health", "they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be?", "that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run", "only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see", "queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were", "a whole world of people out there who need answers", "up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation", "with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions", "questions and don't even know that this site exists. When", "information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only", "who's never seen it before, and see how we stack", "the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and", "that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what", "the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though.", "and compare the answers we have with the information available", "Do you see a pattern of questions that should have", "first impression be? Let's try to look at this site", "10 questions that were asked and answered in the last", "Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to", "and discuss these questions and the site's health with your", "Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions", "is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you", "how easy they are to find and compare the answers", "pattern of questions that should have been closed but are", "from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try", "been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could", "though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should", "who need answers to their questions and don't even know", "there who need answers to their questions and don't even", "know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google,", "a pattern of questions that should have been closed but", "Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle,", "Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out", "discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow", "and see how we stack up against the rest of", "answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches", "their first impression be? Let's try to look at this", "look at this site through the eyes of someone who's", "and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google", "with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the", "Google searches to see how easy they are to find", "see how we stack up against the rest of the", "you see a pattern of questions that should have been", "quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy", "other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of", "the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval)", "could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post", "going really well? Post an answer below to share your", "that's going really well? Post an answer below to share", "part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern", "whole world of people out there who need answers to", "out there who need answers to their questions and don't", "they are to find and compare the answers we have", "is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked", "searches to see how easy they are to find and", "and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered", "try to look at this site through the eyes of", "[Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of", "populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in", "these questions and the site's health with your fellow users!", "impression be? Let's try to look at this site through", "at this site through the eyes of someone who's never", "will their first impression be? Let's try to look at", "and don't even know that this site exists. When they", "answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really", "stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site", "eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see", "is a whole world of people out there who need", "to find and compare the answers we have with the", "answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions", "puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that", "compare the answers we have with the information available on", "all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole", "open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and", "even know that this site exists. When they arrive from", "Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to", "few Google searches to see how easy they are to", "were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a", "never seen it before, and see how we stack up", "we have with the information available on other sites. Rating", "available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a", "find and compare the answers we have with the information", "sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the", "of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open", "to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the", "'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated", "site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their", "an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these", "have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that", "share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's", "Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss", "review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that", "are to find and compare the answers we have with", "world of people out there who need answers to their", "of questions that should have been closed but are not?", "closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use", "thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with", "a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a", "Run a few Google searches to see how easy they", "of someone who's never seen it before, and see how", "be? Let's try to look at this site through the", "seen it before, and see how we stack up against", "this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen", "should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers", "there is a whole world of people out there who", "we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The", "the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and", "but there is a whole world of people out there", "well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and", "the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is", "questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions", "that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well?", "We all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a", "the answers we have with the information available on other", "see how easy they are to find and compare the", "against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review", "not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything", "Let's try to look at this site through the eyes", "arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's", "answers to their questions and don't even know that this", "When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression", "people out there who need answers to their questions and", "or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going", "what will their first impression be? Let's try to look", "[Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10", "last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how", "their questions and don't even know that this site exists.", "below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and", "have with the information available on other sites. Rating the", "it before, and see how we stack up against the", "answers we have with the information available on other sites.", "exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first", "rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is", "The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with", "the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions", "of people out there who need answers to their questions" ]
[ "off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support", "place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates) > > >", "have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates) >", "a place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates) > >", "we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these", "unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support the", "questions have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates)", "proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place to", "graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so", "\"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we", "relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed", "Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place to go.", "become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\",", "has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate", "here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to", "these questions have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates", "need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions", "to graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE", "consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating", "Given that the consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are", "the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place", "so that these questions have a place to go. >", "that these questions have a place to go. > >", "that the consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic", "questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need", "support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a", "to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have", "the consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless", "admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that", "are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to" ]
[ "missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to", "be nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what", "French!* I sometimes come to this site to read up", "might be nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing", "a future standard (accept or not questions in other languages),", "There's only been one such question so far, but, depending", "which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's", "it just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this", "determine a future standard (accept or not questions in other", "but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate", "been one such question so far, but, depending on weather", "not questions in other languages), I think it is important", "part of the question in English, which actually sounds partially", "future standards for the site, so I feel it is", "to vote, because I do not know if they are", "it is important that there's an discussion within the community.", "But then, there's a big chunk of French! I sometimes", "where I'm not. I do participate a little, but much,", "could set up future standards for the site, so I", "disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice, but I'm", "accepted as a good one or not, it could set", "up future standards for the site, so I feel it", "in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But", "Seeing what Google Translate does to it just makes it", "not. I do participate a little, but much, much more,", "for the site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a>", "a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be", "(accept or not questions in other languages), I think it", "and inform myself about how things work where I'm not.", "if they are relevant. As it could determine a future", "questions in other languages), I think it is important that", "feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part", "languages), I think it is important that there's an discussion", "set up future standards for the site, so I feel", "nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google", "of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it just", "could determine a future standard (accept or not questions in", "sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's a big", "two interesting answers, on which I do not want to", "are relevant. As it could determine a future standard (accept", "I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does", "There's this question, that might be nice, but I'm missing", "more, I read the questions and answers that seem interesting.", "couldn't help but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's", "because I do not know if they are relevant. As", "one such question so far, but, depending on weather this", "do participate a little, but much, much more, I read", "one or not, it could set up future standards for", "know if they are relevant. As it could determine a", "it could set up future standards for the site, so", "to this site to read up on life in Academia", "far, but, depending on weather this question is accepted as", "come to this site to read up on life in", "this question, I couldn't help but feel just a little", "how things work where I'm not. I do participate a", "sometimes come to this site to read up on life", "on which I do not want to vote, because I", "a good one or not, it could set up future", "small part of the question in English, which actually sounds", "but much, much more, I read the questions and answers", "much, much more, I read the questions and answers that", "what Google Translate does to it just makes it more", "relevant. As it could determine a future standard (accept or", "but, depending on weather this question is accepted as a", "site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is", "questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I", "there's this two interesting answers, on which I do not", "work where I'm not. I do participate a little, but", "do not want to vote, because I do not know", "big chunk of French! I sometimes come to this site", "There is a small part of the question in English,", "to it just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's", "it could determine a future standard (accept or not questions", "of the question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting", "then, there's this two interesting answers, on which I do", "inform myself about how things work where I'm not. I", "that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but", "is accepted as a good one or not, it could", "things work where I'm not. I do participate a little,", "but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this question,", "question is accepted as a good one or not, it", "about how things work where I'm not. I do participate", "not want to vote, because I do not know if", "I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small", "important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the question", "chunk of French!* I sometimes come to this site to", "the site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There", "standards for the site, so I feel it is important:", "English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then,", "in Academia and inform myself about how things work where", "Google Translate does to it just makes it more disappointing.", "on life in Academia and inform myself about how things", "Academia and inform myself about how things work where I'm", "just a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might", "do not know if they are relevant. As it could", "standard (accept or not questions in other languages), I think", "half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it", "I think it is important that there's an discussion within", "not, it could set up future standards for the site,", "which I do not want to vote, because I do", "they are relevant. As it could determine a future standard", "of French! I sometimes come to this site to read", "and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't", "little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice,", "not know if they are relevant. As it could determine", "in other languages), I think it is important that there's", "that might be nice, but I'm missing half of it.", "little, but much, much more, I read the questions and", "help but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this", "it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of", "a small part of the question in English, which actually", "to read up on life in Academia and inform myself", "answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help", "seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel", "it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it just makes", "this question is accepted as a good one or not,", "actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's a", "disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers, on which", "I sometimes come to this site to read up on", "I read the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing", "then, there's a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come", "to me. But then, there's a big chunk of French!", "is a small part of the question in English, which", "As it could determine a future standard (accept or not", "I do not know if they are relevant. As it", "feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that", "question, I couldn't help but feel just a little bit", "interesting answers, on which I do not want to vote,", "interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel just", "a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come to this", "site to read up on life in Academia and inform", "this two interesting answers, on which I do not want", "this site to read up on life in Academia and", "the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question,", "future standard (accept or not questions in other languages), I", "interesting to me. But then, there's a big chunk of", "bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice, but", "is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the", "much more, I read the questions and answers that seem", "Translate does to it just makes it more disappointing. And", "such question so far, but, depending on weather this question", "answers, on which I do not want to vote, because", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the question in", "more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers, on", "I do not want to vote, because I do not", "read the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this", "Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel just a", "this question, that might be nice, but I'm missing half", "want to vote, because I do not know if they", "I'm not. I do participate a little, but much, much", "it more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers,", "a little, but much, much more, I read the questions", "partially interesting to me. But then, there's a big chunk", "or not, it could set up future standards for the", "there's a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come to", "participate a little, but much, much more, I read the", "depending on weather this question is accepted as a good", "other languages), I think it is important that there's an", "so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a", "the question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to", "does to it just makes it more disappointing. And then,", "And then, there's this two interesting answers, on which I", "read up on life in Academia and inform myself about", "good one or not, it could set up future standards", "only been one such question so far, but, depending on", "me. But then, there's a big chunk of French! I", "up on life in Academia and inform myself about how", "myself about how things work where I'm not. I do", "I do participate a little, but much, much more, I", "as a good one or not, it could set up", "weather this question is accepted as a good one or", "makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting", "think it is important that there's an discussion within the", "vote, because I do not know if they are relevant*.", "I couldn't help but feel just a little bit disappointed.", "question, that might be nice, but I'm missing half of", "question so far, but, depending on weather this question is", "or not questions in other languages), I think it is", "life in Academia and inform myself about how things work", "so far, but, depending on weather this question is accepted", "on weather this question is accepted as a good one", "just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this two", "question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me." ]
[ "the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral", "integral part of being an academic. Are such questions on", "increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an", "on topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing", "standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been", "for IRB approval is an integral part of being an", "focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB", "[an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not yet a question.", "Are such questions on topic, and if so under what", "on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has", "questions)? The IRB has been the subject of [an answer", "procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the", "approval is an integral part of being an academic. Are", "an academic. Are such questions on topic, and if so", "what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical", "fields (traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying", "(e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The", "an integral part of being an academic. Are such questions", "being an academic. Are such questions on topic, and if", "if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures", "many fields (traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences),", "part of being an academic. Are such questions on topic,", "is an integral part of being an academic. Are such", "so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs.", "has been the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775),", "under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery", "of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not yet a", "but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval", "(traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for", "applying for IRB approval is an integral part of being", "vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject", "ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject of [an", "sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral part of", "Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB", "been the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but", "academic. Are such questions on topic, and if so under", "also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is", "such questions on topic, and if so under what parameters", "parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)?", "questions on topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g.", "of being an academic. Are such questions on topic, and", "IRB has been the subject of [an answer to a", "social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral part", "the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not", "subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not yet", "slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject of", "and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard", "In many fields (traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social", "IRB approval is an integral part of being an academic.", "topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on", "The IRB has been the subject of [an answer to" ]
[ "I decided to reopen the question, because the next logical", "comment should not be that difficult, and if you don't", "question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful", "likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I", "one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been", "know why you're closing the question, then perhaps you should", "or should be closed, but if you know why you're", "while there was already an upvoted answer. I decided to", "not saying that this question should necessarily be kept open", "for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single", "that we are still on beta, and that we don't", "closing the question, then leaving a comment should not be", "hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very", "As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to", "is too broad or off-topic is important to help the", "the community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that", "then leaving a comment should not be that difficult, and", "understanding why his/her question is too broad or off-topic is", "open or should be closed, but if you know why", "[here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the site, especially", "it should be the case, and it's likely we're stuck", "Recently, the question [How often should one evaluate a plan", "day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her question is", "know why you're closing the question, then leaving a comment", "there was already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen", "broad or off-topic is important to help the community grow.", "the case, and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on", "new user understanding why his/her question is too broad or", "you know why you're closing the question, then leaving a", "should be closed, but if you know why you're closing", "questions each day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her", "upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question, because the", "saying that this question should necessarily be kept open or", "the question, then perhaps you should not be voting to", "or off-topic is important to help the community grow. To", "no idea why it should be the case, and it's", "have no idea why it should be the case, and", "question is too broad or off-topic is important to help", "I'm not saying that this question should necessarily be kept", "answer. I decided to reopen the question, because the next", "if you don't know why you're closing the question, then", "should not be that difficult, and if you don't know", "still on beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds", "single comment explaining why it should be closed, while there", "and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question.", "delete the question, and I have no idea why it", "the site, especially that we are still on beta, and", "be the case, and it's likely we're stuck with an", "should necessarily be kept open or should be closed, but", "closed, while there was already an upvoted answer. I decided", "exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new", "comments are very helpful to maintain the site, especially that", "are very helpful to maintain the site, especially that we", "case, and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\"", "a new user understanding why his/her question is too broad", "question, because the next logical step is to delete the", "that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day.", "user understanding why his/her question is too broad or off-topic", "logical step is to delete the question, and I have", "an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments", "question [How often should one evaluate a plan for an", "and I have no idea why it should be the", "too broad or off-topic is important to help the community", "be that difficult, and if you don't know why you're", "often should one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928)", "To be clear: I'm not saying that this question should", "if you know why you're closing the question, then leaving", "\"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are", "be kept open or should be closed, but if you", "that difficult, and if you don't know why you're closing", "you should not be voting to close in the first", "why his/her question is too broad or off-topic is important", "already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the", "the question, and I have no idea why it should", "stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated", "reopen the question, because the next logical step is to", "should one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has", "step is to delete the question, and I have no", "is to delete the question, and I have no idea", "plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a", "each day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her question", "the next logical step is to delete the question, and", "stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the site,", "academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment explaining", "the question, then leaving a comment should not be that", "you're closing the question, then perhaps you should not be", "we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already", "kept open or should be closed, but if you know", "of questions each day. Helping a new user understanding why", "closing the question, then perhaps you should not be voting", "been closed without a single comment explaining why it should", "the question, because the next logical step is to delete", "why it should be the case, and it's likely we're", "beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions", "that this question should necessarily be kept open or should", "a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without", "explaining why it should be closed, while there was already", "why you're closing the question, then leaving a comment should", "has been closed without a single comment explaining why it", "a comment should not be that difficult, and if you", "leaving a comment should not be that difficult, and if", "to help the community grow. To be clear: I'm not", "help the community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying", "question, then leaving a comment should not be that difficult,", "should be the case, and it's likely we're stuck with", "not be that difficult, and if you don't know why", "with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better),", "is important to help the community grow. To be clear:", "have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new user", "[How often should one evaluate a plan for an academic", "off-topic is important to help the community grow. To be", "Helping a new user understanding why his/her question is too", "clear: I'm not saying that this question should necessarily be", "don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a", "grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that this question", "we are still on beta, and that we don't exactly", "community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that this", "it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As", "idea why it should be the case, and it's likely", "important to help the community grow. To be clear: I'm", "should not be voting to close in the first place.", "this question should necessarily be kept open or should be", "question should necessarily be kept open or should be closed,", "decided to reopen the question, because the next logical step", "why you're closing the question, then perhaps you should not", "perhaps you should not be voting to close in the", "then perhaps you should not be voting to close in", "necessarily be kept open or should be closed, but if", "why it should be closed, while there was already an", "already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question,", "question, then perhaps you should not be voting to close", "a single comment explaining why it should be closed, while", "on beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds of", "and that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each", "site, especially that we are still on beta, and that", "closed without a single comment explaining why it should be", "difficult, and if you don't know why you're closing the", "especially that we are still on beta, and that we", "his/her question is too broad or off-topic is important to", "without a single comment explaining why it should be closed,", "to reopen the question, because the next logical step is", "comment explaining why it should be closed, while there was", "you're closing the question, then leaving a comment should not", "should be closed, while there was already an upvoted answer.", "I have no idea why it should be the case,", "closed, but if you know why you're closing the question,", "are still on beta, and that we don't exactly have", "you don't know why you're closing the question, then perhaps", "but if you know why you're closing the question, then", "I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain", "to delete the question, and I have no idea why", "the question [How often should one evaluate a plan for", "it should be closed, while there was already an upvoted", "evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed", "was already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the", "don't know why you're closing the question, then perhaps you", "be closed, while there was already an upvoted answer. I", "very helpful to maintain the site, especially that we are", "question, and I have no idea why it should be", "career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment explaining why", "an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question, because", "an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment", "next logical step is to delete the question, and I", "be closed, but if you know why you're closing the", "be clear: I'm not saying that this question should necessarily", "and if you don't know why you're closing the question,", "because the next logical step is to delete the question,", "to maintain the site, especially that we are still on", "we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping", "maintain the site, especially that we are still on beta,", "hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new user understanding", "helpful to maintain the site, especially that we are still" ]
[ "close menu, I'm not sure I see anything that really", "question to me. But I see no close votes, and", "I've Googled virtually daily for the past two years without", "really fits. But do we really want this and questions", "missing a close reason? And if so, what is that", "like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we", "Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before.", "twitter to help find a PhD? For example, is there", "that advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP also", "commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for the past", "OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for", "> I've Googled virtually daily for the past two years", "do we really want this and questions like it? Is", "there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? >", "that really fits. But do we really want this and", "sure I see anything that really fits. But do we", "a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > >", "to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter", "is inspired by this video in the British Ecological Society", "I have not used twitter before. How can I use", "to me. But I see no close votes, and when", "through the close menu, I'm not sure I see anything", "particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > >", "I've heard that twitter might help me find a PhD", "Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used", "> > > This just seems a terrible question to", "and when I look through the close menu, I'm not", "I use twitter to help find a PhD? For example,", "Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto a", "it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we are", "question: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll", "two years without success > > > This just seems", "we really want this and questions like it? Is this", "program. I've heard that twitter might help me find a", "questions like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that", "this question's continued existence, evidence that we are we missing", "I'm not sure I see anything that really fits. But", "look through the close menu, I'm not sure I see", "twitter might help me find a PhD program. This question", "that we are we missing a close reason? And if", "continued existence, evidence that we are we missing a close", "a terrible question to me. But I see no close", "> > I've Googled virtually daily for the past two", "we missing a close reason? And if so, what is", "me find a PhD program. This question is inspired by", "video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY>", "> I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've", "But I see no close votes, and when I look", "close votes, and when I look through the close menu,", "PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help me find", "<http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How can I", "This question is inspired by this video in the British", "not sure I see anything that really fits. But do", "me. But I see no close votes, and when I", "I see no close votes, and when I look through", "this question: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping to", "without success > > > This just seems a terrible", "fits. But do we really want this and questions like", "anything that really fits. But do we really want this", "on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And the", "> And the OP also commented: > > I've Googled", "daily for the past two years without success > >", "really want this and questions like it? Is this question's", "a PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel on", "example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises", "existence, evidence that we are we missing a close reason?", "a PhD program. This question is inspired by this video", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto", "seems a terrible question to me. But I see no", "might help me find a PhD program. This question is", "YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How", "the past two years without success > > > This", "group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And", "see no close votes, and when I look through the", "question is inspired by this video in the British Ecological", "twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP", "British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not", "menu, I'm not sure I see anything that really fits.", "program. This question is inspired by this video in the", "Googled virtually daily for the past two years without success", "use twitter to help find a PhD? For example, is", "success > > > This just seems a terrible question", "advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP also commented:", "used twitter before. How can I use twitter to help", "channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How can", "How can I use twitter to help find a PhD?", "> > I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program.", "past two years without success > > > This just", "and questions like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence", "> This just seems a terrible question to me. But", "question's continued existence, evidence that we are we missing a", "for the past two years without success > > >", "just seems a terrible question to me. But I see", "I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard", "PhDs? > > > And the OP also commented: >", "> > > And the OP also commented: > >", "the OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily", "terrible question to me. But I see no close votes,", "asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD", "inspired by this video in the British Ecological Society Careers", "help find a PhD? For example, is there a particular", "no close votes, and when I look through the close", "a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help me", "this and questions like it? Is this question's continued existence,", "I see anything that really fits. But do we really", "About this question: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping", "is there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs?", "onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help", "can I use twitter to help find a PhD? For", "virtually daily for the past two years without success >", "heard that twitter might help me find a PhD program.", "For example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter that", "in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I", "twitter before. How can I use twitter to help find", "But do we really want this and questions like it?", "a close reason? And if so, what is that reason?", "before. How can I use twitter to help find a", "votes, and when I look through the close menu, I'm", "PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter", "I look through the close menu, I'm not sure I", "help me find a PhD program. This question is inspired", "find a PhD program. This question is inspired by this", "years without success > > > This just seems a", "the close menu, I'm not sure I see anything that", "are we missing a close reason? And if so, what", "when I look through the close menu, I'm not sure", "And the OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually", "hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that", "see anything that really fits. But do we really want", "> > And the OP also commented: > > I've", "the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have", "not used twitter before. How can I use twitter to", "enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might", "have not used twitter before. How can I use twitter", "this video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel:", "to help find a PhD? For example, is there a", "This just seems a terrible question to me. But I", "also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for the", "by this video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube", "evidence that we are we missing a close reason? And", "we are we missing a close reason? And if so,", "> > This just seems a terrible question to me.", "PhD program. This question is inspired by this video in", "that twitter might help me find a PhD program. This", "find a PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel", "want this and questions like it? Is this question's continued", "Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we are we", "Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter" ]
[ "the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to", "comment, but I do not see it anywhere. This is", "is the 2nd time (according to my reputation record) that", "(according to my reputation record) that an answer of mine", "reputation record) that an answer of mine has been removed", "(and I am using the term in the aforementioned record", "week (and I am using the term in the aforementioned", "am using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I", "This is quite discouraging. Why was my answer to [this", "thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but I do", "the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that I", "am making some contribution to this site, but clearly this", "to this site, but clearly this seems not to be", "like to think that I am making some contribution to", "my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to", "to think that I am making some contribution to this", "Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says", "quite discouraging. Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted?", "not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according", "think that I am making some contribution to this site,", "time (according to my reputation record) that an answer of", "this site, but clearly this seems not to be the", "mine has been removed in a week (and I am", "is quite discouraging. Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173)", "converted to comment, but I do not see it anywhere.", "using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like", "to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but", "making some contribution to this site, but clearly this seems", "in a week (and I am using the term in", "record 'removed'). I like to think that I am making", "some contribution to this site, but clearly this seems not", "'removed'). I like to think that I am making some", "deleted? It says converted to comment, but I do not", "see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to", "my reputation record) that an answer of mine has been", "do not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time", "to comment, but I do not see it anywhere. This", "it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to my", "term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think", "I do not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd", "anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to my reputation", "site, but clearly this seems not to be the case.", "I like to think that I am making some contribution", "been removed in a week (and I am using the", "to my reputation record) that an answer of mine has", "an answer of mine has been removed in a week", "It says converted to comment, but I do not see", "says converted to comment, but I do not see it", "contribution to this site, but clearly this seems not to", "2nd time (according to my reputation record) that an answer", "[this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but I", "of mine has been removed in a week (and I", "that an answer of mine has been removed in a", "removed in a week (and I am using the term", "a week (and I am using the term in the", "but I do not see it anywhere. This is the", "that I am making some contribution to this site, but", "was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted", "answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment,", "has been removed in a week (and I am using", "I am using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed').", "I am making some contribution to this site, but clearly", "the 2nd time (according to my reputation record) that an", "This is the 2nd time (according to my reputation record)", "answer of mine has been removed in a week (and", "discouraging. Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It", "record) that an answer of mine has been removed in", "aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that I am", "in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that" ]
[ "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png)", "transient issue, it's been that way for a few minutes.", "to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on", "page, where there is nothing for me to do: ![enter", "to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a", "me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists", "get a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar,", "Why do I get a yellow “0 flag” alert on", "alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site where I", "It's weird to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially", "the “tools” page, where there is nothing for me to", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image", "a transient issue, it's been that way for a few", "do I get a yellow “0 flag” alert on the", "especially on a site where I am not moderator anyway…", "on a site where I am not moderator anyway… And", "a moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where there", "to the “tools” page, where there is nothing for me", "there is nothing for me to do: ![enter image description", "situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird", "on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get", "where there is nothing for me to do: ![enter image", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for “0", "“0 flags”, especially on a site where I am not", "a site where I am not moderator anyway… And it's", "flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia, where I", "for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation", "get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site", "am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a", "it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been that", "bar, on Academia, where I am not a moderator? It", "“0 flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia, where", "And it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been", "is nothing for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png)", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter", "anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's", "an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site where", "where I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for", "not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient", "I get a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top", "site where I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable,", "exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to", "not a transient issue, it's been that way for a", "nothing for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same", "Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's", "where I am not a moderator? It links to the", "flags”, especially on a site where I am not moderator", "top bar, on Academia, where I am not a moderator?", "yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia,", "moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient issue,", "am not a moderator? It links to the “tools” page,", "on Academia, where I am not a moderator? It links", "a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar, on", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description", "weird to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on", "do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta:", "“tools” page, where there is nothing for me to do:", "It links to the “tools” page, where there is nothing", "I am not a moderator? It links to the “tools”", "I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not", "links to the “tools” page, where there is nothing for", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert", "for “0 flags”, especially on a site where I am", "on the top bar, on Academia, where I am not", "not a moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where", "Academia, where I am not a moderator? It links to", "alert on the top bar, on Academia, where I am", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for “0 flags”,", "the top bar, on Academia, where I am not a", "it's not a transient issue, it's been that way for", "Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an", "moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where there is", "stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been that way" ]
[ "name, product and company and both cases are employees spamming", "be surprised if more are spamming. Another one in the", "I would not be surprised if more are spamming. Another", "spammers' websites. I did a search of the name, product", "I don't want to link to these spammers' websites. I", "a lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply", "to these spammers' websites. I did a search of the", "search shows he works for the company that he is", "spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack", "in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is", "one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager", "of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian", "thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company", "a quick search shows he works for the company that", "don't want to link to these spammers' websites. I did", "Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company he is", "one as a quick search shows he works for the", "if more are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid", "in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of", "is a lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the", "want to link to these spammers' websites. I did a", "There is a lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance),", "he works for the company that he is \"recommending\", I", "from Ian Pack is a blatant one as a quick", "search of the name, product and company and both cases", "company he is touting. I don't want to link to", "to link to these spammers' websites. I did a search", "a blatant one as a quick search shows he works", "Ian Pack is a blatant one as a quick search", "these spammers' websites. I did a search of the name,", "a search of the name, product and company and both", "reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one as a", "Training Manager of the company he is touting. I don't", "is touting. I don't want to link to these spammers'", "that he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if", "[here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one", "more are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev,", "the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a", "replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant", "the Training Manager of the company he is touting. I", "the company he is touting. I don't want to link", "of the company he is touting. I don't want to", "the name, product and company and both cases are employees", "spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the", "\"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more are spamming.", "websites. I did a search of the name, product and", "blatant one as a quick search shows he works for", "surprised if more are spamming. Another one in the thread,", "Pack is a blatant one as a quick search shows", "shows he works for the company that he is \"recommending\",", "quick search shows he works for the company that he", "and company and both cases are employees spamming their products.", "Manager of the company he is touting. I don't want", "product and company and both cases are employees spamming their", "lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from", "as a quick search shows he works for the company", "works for the company that he is \"recommending\", I would", "is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more are", "touting. I don't want to link to these spammers' websites.", "he is touting. I don't want to link to these", "the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the", "did a search of the name, product and company and", "are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is", "the company that he is \"recommending\", I would not be", "is the Training Manager of the company he is touting.", "the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one as", "link to these spammers' websites. I did a search of", "he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more", "company that he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised", "not be surprised if more are spamming. Another one in", "of the name, product and company and both cases are", "Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company he", "Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training", "would not be surprised if more are spamming. Another one", "is a blatant one as a quick search shows he", "for the company that he is \"recommending\", I would not", "I did a search of the name, product and company" ]
[ "SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se", "vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE,", "it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs", "flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only", "for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs on", "suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something", "I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it", "belongs on another SE site how do I vote to", "(which it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site", "only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If", "another SE site how do I vote to close for", "to either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable", "close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I", "something belongs on another SE site how do I vote", "but I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which", "I wanted to either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar>", "as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it", "doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site how do", "If something belongs on another SE site how do I", "ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE", "to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but", "or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could", "it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site how", "on another SE site how do I vote to close", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest", "either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for", "belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on", "wanted to either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as", "on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on another", "suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs", "SE site how do I vote to close for that", "site how do I vote to close for that reason?", "could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't)." ]
[ "think the Q-A should be made general if there are", "of answers to a more general question is the better", "probably not easy to resolve but as I see it:", "OP. The question was later edited to show its US", "applicable everywhere although it was clear from the question body", "spread of answers to a more general question is the", "not constructive and what we want. On the other hand", "to a more general question is the better way. I", "I see it: should we try to be very specific", "other hand I can see that a non-country-specific question would", "I realize this is probably not easy to resolve but", "United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the", "was a general question applicable everywhere although it was clear", "answers to a more general question is the better way.", "the question very narrow and opens up for questions about", "this site is inclusive I think the Q-A should be", "try to be general and including in the these types", "really not constructive and what we want. On the other", "the question as such. An example: the post [How much", "question was later edited to show its US identity. The", "in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit", "that providing a wide spread of answers to a more", "be made general if there are general interest in the", "and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that", "edited to show its US identity. The edit now makes", "we try to be very specific and excluding or try", "country specific questions are fine. But, I think that even", "is really not constructive and what we want. On the", "show its US identity. The edit now makes the question", "specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion", "unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that providing a", "space to provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive", "the question body that US conditions were at the heart", "makes little sense. I think that providing a wide spread", "inclusive I think the Q-A should be made general if", "constructive and what we want. On the other hand I", "On the other hand I can see that a non-country-specific", "up for questions about vacation in each and every country.", "to the original question indicates a problem. As indicated the", "OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific questions are", "post [How much vacation time is typical during a PhD(", "would open up for answers from each country, in other", "sense. I think that providing a wide spread of answers", "in each and every country. This is really not constructive", "to provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive I", "resolve but as I see it: should we try to", "conditions were at the heart of the OP. The question", "providing a wide spread of answers to a more general", "there are general interest in the question as such. An", "original question indicates a problem. As indicated the post was", "see it: should we try to be very specific and", "should we try to be very specific and excluding or", "question [What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394)", "want. On the other hand I can see that a", "My own opinion is that country specific questions are fine.", "vacation in each and every country. This is really not", "are fine. But, I think that even if the OP", "The question was later edited to show its US identity.", "in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for", "this is probably not easy to resolve but as I", "that even if the OP is asking about their home", "be space to provide general answers. Since this site is", "clear from the question body that US conditions were at", "question on vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily,", "[How much vacation time is typical during a PhD( in", "Since this site is inclusive I think the Q-A should", "and what we want. On the other hand I can", "my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that", "[Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country", "example: the post [How much vacation time is typical during", "looks for a question on vacation having the question, in", "the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are", "in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think", "indicated the post was a general question applicable everywhere although", "opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that providing", "interest in the question as such. An example: the post", "US conditions were at the heart of the OP. The", "US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific", "questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is", "a more general question is the better way. I realize", "is probably not easy to resolve but as I see", "country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks", "question applicable everywhere although it was clear from the question", "very narrow and opens up for questions about vacation in", "for a question on vacation having the question, in my", "but as I see it: should we try to be", "at the heart of the OP. The question was later", "be very specific and excluding or try to be general", "try to be very specific and excluding or try to", "now makes the question very narrow and opens up for", "turf, there should be space to provide general answers. Since", "better way. I realize this is probably not easy to", "made general if there are general interest in the question", "country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own", "question indicates a problem. As indicated the post was a", "is that country specific questions are fine. But, I think", "even if the OP is asking about their home turf,", "(the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original question", "think that even if the OP is asking about their", "edit now makes the question very narrow and opens up", "the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to", "the post was a general question applicable everywhere although it", "there should be space to provide general answers. Since this", "is typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the", "typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis", "an addition edit to the original question indicates a problem.", "heart of the OP. The question was later edited to", "can see that a non-country-specific question would open up for", "although it was clear from the question body that US", "the better way. I realize this is probably not easy", "every country. This is really not constructive and what we", "words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a question", "opens up for questions about vacation in each and every", "and every country. This is really not constructive and what", "excluding or try to be general and including in the", "question is the better way. I realize this is probably", "somebody looks for a question on vacation having the question,", "the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense.", "a wide spread of answers to a more general question", "very specific and excluding or try to be general and", "Q-A should be made general if there are general interest", "to show its US identity. The edit now makes the", "the heart of the OP. The question was later edited", "localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394)", "if there are general interest in the question as such.", "States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original", "time is typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394)", "vacation time is typical during a PhD( in the United", "from the question body that US conditions were at the", "vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes", "its US identity. The edit now makes the question very", "identity. The edit now makes the question very narrow and", "on the question [What's the policy regarding localized (read: country", "parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original question indicates", "question would open up for answers from each country, in", "a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an", "PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition", "wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a question on", "having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little", "it: should we try to be very specific and excluding", "edit to the original question indicates a problem. As indicated", "This is really not constructive and what we want. On", "(read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My", "were at the heart of the OP. The question was", "the Q-A should be made general if there are general", "I think that even if the OP is asking about", "I can see that a non-country-specific question would open up", "post was a general question applicable everywhere although it was", "indicates an addition edit to the original question indicates a", "it was clear from the question body that US conditions", "limited makes little sense. I think that providing a wide", "not easy to resolve but as I see it: should", "the question [What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific)", "a problem. As indicated the post was a general question", "general question is the better way. I realize this is", "are general interest in the question as such. An example:", "questions are fine. But, I think that even if the", "the original question indicates a problem. As indicated the post", "when somebody looks for a question on vacation having the", "to resolve but as I see it: should we try", "general answers. Since this site is inclusive I think the", "However, when somebody looks for a question on vacation having", "Following on the question [What's the policy regarding localized (read:", "we want. On the other hand I can see that", "a question on vacation having the question, in my opinion", "OP is asking about their home turf, there should be", "if the OP is asking about their home turf, there", "question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I", "from each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when", "of the OP. The question was later edited to show", "such. An example: the post [How much vacation time is", "I think the Q-A should be made general if there", "body that US conditions were at the heart of the", "problem. As indicated the post was a general question applicable", "provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive I think", "regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions", "see that a non-country-specific question would open up for answers", "general question applicable everywhere although it was clear from the", "other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a", "during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates", "wide spread of answers to a more general question is", "is the better way. I realize this is probably not", "was later edited to show its US identity. The edit", "general if there are general interest in the question as", "asking about their home turf, there should be space to", "site is inclusive I think the Q-A should be made", "what we want. On the other hand I can see", "posts. However, when somebody looks for a question on vacation", "think that providing a wide spread of answers to a", "about their home turf, there should be space to provide", "answers. Since this site is inclusive I think the Q-A", "in the question as such. An example: the post [How", "little sense. I think that providing a wide spread of", "But, I think that even if the OP is asking", "a non-country-specific question would open up for answers from each", "The edit now makes the question very narrow and opens", "up for answers from each country, in other words wiki-type", "more general question is the better way. I realize this", "addition edit to the original question indicates a problem. As", "for answers from each country, in other words wiki-type posts.", "is asking about their home turf, there should be space", "as I see it: should we try to be very", "answers from each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However,", "non-country-specific question would open up for answers from each country,", "I think that providing a wide spread of answers to", "easy to resolve but as I see it: should we", "and excluding or try to be general and including in", "be general and including in the these types of posts?*", "own opinion is that country specific questions are fine. But,", "everywhere although it was clear from the question body that", "that US conditions were at the heart of the OP.", "a general question applicable everywhere although it was clear from", "questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific questions", "the OP. The question was later edited to show its", "should be space to provide general answers. Since this site", "general interest in the question as such. An example: the", "later edited to show its US identity. The edit now", "opinion is that country specific questions are fine. But, I", "and opens up for questions about vacation in each and", "as such. An example: the post [How much vacation time", "As indicated the post was a general question applicable everywhere", "that country specific questions are fine. But, I think that", "their home turf, there should be space to provide general", "for questions about vacation in each and every country. This", "specific and excluding or try to be general and including", "indicates a problem. As indicated the post was a general", "[What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and", "each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody", "the OP is asking about their home turf, there should", "specific questions are fine. But, I think that even if", "fine. But, I think that even if the OP is", "was clear from the question body that US conditions were", "much vacation time is typical during a PhD( in the", "way. I realize this is probably not easy to resolve", "on vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited", "makes the question very narrow and opens up for questions", "questions about vacation in each and every country. This is", "that a non-country-specific question would open up for answers from", "An example: the post [How much vacation time is typical", "should be made general if there are general interest in", "narrow and opens up for questions about vacation in each", "home turf, there should be space to provide general answers.", "question as such. An example: the post [How much vacation", "open up for answers from each country, in other words", "question body that US conditions were at the heart of", "each and every country. This is really not constructive and", "to be general and including in the these types of", "the post [How much vacation time is typical during a", "policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific", "realize this is probably not easy to resolve but as", "hand I can see that a non-country-specific question would open", "or try to be general and including in the these", "country. This is really not constructive and what we want.", "about vacation in each and every country. This is really", "question very narrow and opens up for questions about vacation", "to be very specific and excluding or try to be", "is inclusive I think the Q-A should be made general", "the other hand I can see that a non-country-specific question", "US identity. The edit now makes the question very narrow" ]
[ "has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section", "ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this", "certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can", "saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase:", "> > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic", "academicians as described in [What topics can I ask about", "at [What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We", "they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as", "specific to one person's situation are not likely to get", "we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE", "situation are not likely to get very far, but we", "description is absent from the linked help center page. Nor", "this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: >", "from the linked help center page. Nor is it at", "Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a", "> > Note, however, that this description is absent from", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about problems", "here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this description is", "We do note that questions that are very specific to", "it at [What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask).", "one person's situation are not likely to get very far,", "with the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate", "post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I ask", "are not likely to get very far, but we don't", "I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are", "discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic>", "screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > >", "Note, however, that this description is absent from the linked", "I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that", "is it at [What types of questions should I avoid", "that are very specific to one person's situation are not", "questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add", "[What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > >", "I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the", "we add a section like this to our help center?", "recently voting to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw", "this description is absent from the linked help center page.", "are very specific to one person's situation are not likely", "but we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some", "[What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about", "questions that are very specific to one person's situation are", "note that questions that are very specific to one person's", "undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions", "topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note,", "problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also", "linked help center page. Nor is it at [What types", "question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with", "that questions that are very specific to one person's situation", "about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can", "person's situation are not likely to get very far, but", "close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter", "questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions", "undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png)", "not likely to get very far, but we don't outright", "should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that", "off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate", "very specific to one person's situation are not likely to", "can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described", "voting to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this", "however, that this description is absent from the linked help", "students are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate", "sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed", "detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing", "> Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless", "undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply to", "off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we", "list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this to", "help center page. Nor is it at [What types of", "questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain", "the linked help center page. Nor is it at [What", "of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that", "Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they", "about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this description", "the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students", "absent from the linked help center page. Nor is it", "also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in", "that this description is absent from the linked help center", "apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What", "center page. Nor is it at [What types of questions", "do note that questions that are very specific to one", "When recently voting to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I", "> > > Note, however, that this description is absent", "to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions.", "to get very far, but we don't outright discourage questions", "<https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this to our", "types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note", "off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description", "an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image", "are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or", "can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however,", "to one person's situation are not likely to get very", "as described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has", "described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) >", "unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians", "avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are very", "explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list:", "specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic", "is absent from the linked help center page. Nor is", "to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen:", "asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are very specific", "facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply", "phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are", "to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics", "SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a", "in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > >", "discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage", "a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like", "Can we add a section like this to our help", "don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites", "far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates.", "very far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific to", "Nor is it at [What types of questions should I", "outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly", "or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I", "page. Nor is it at [What types of questions should", "> Note, however, that this description is absent from the", "get very far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific", "likely to get very far, but we don't outright discourage", "graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can" ]
[ "the page. Later I come back to check responses for", "had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my time", "minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I", "a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits,", "I saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed the", "saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed the page.", "returned. Why? Did I waste my time editing the question?", "closed the page. Later I come back to check responses", "the edits, double-checked the question and closed the page. Later", "I took a few minutes to remove a variety of", "page. Later I come back to check responses for the", "fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my time editing", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few minutes to remove", "found [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few minutes", "to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved", "Later I come back to check responses for the question", "question and the typos I had fixed have returned. Why?", "(\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question and", "for the question and the typos I had fixed have", "took a few minutes to remove a variety of typos", "have returned. Why? Did I waste my time editing the", "and closed the page. Later I come back to check", "interesting so I took a few minutes to remove a", "double-checked the question and closed the page. Later I come", "a few minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\",", "I found [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few minutes to", "edits, double-checked the question and closed the page. Later I", "and the typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did", "of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the", "few minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.).", "responses for the question and the typos I had fixed", "typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question", "typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste", "check responses for the question and the typos I had", "remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the", "the question and the typos I had fixed have returned.", "the question and closed the page. Later I come back", "I come back to check responses for the question and", "so I took a few minutes to remove a variety", "variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked", "to check responses for the question and the typos I", "the typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I", "I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my", "question and closed the page. Later I come back to", "etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed", "back to check responses for the question and the typos", "come back to check responses for the question and the" ]
[ "are new to academia. > > I would like to", "now, original text reproduced below] > > I realize we", "exist to publish papers? > > Can a published work", "vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed when", "say, if we make it a community wiki with one", "be useful for our users who are new to academia.", "This is one way of improving it which strikes me.", "SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed when conferences/journals", "it which strikes me. Can others point out the flaws", "> I would like to see details in terms of:", "purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful", "do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of", "would like to see details in terms of: > >", "publish papers? > > Can a published work (i.e., post-print)", "it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer?", "for me? > > > Is it such a bad", "for our users who are new to academia. > >", "of: > > What is the purpose of archives for", "are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers?", "definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess", "a bad idea, say, if we make it a community", "> What is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints", "[this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original", "answer? This is one way of improving it which strikes", "and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question", "papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are", "> Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as a", "if we make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print", "down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted", "work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will", "question is deleted now, original text reproduced below] > >", "I would like to see details in terms of: >", "service per answer? This is one way of improving it", "deleted now, original text reproduced below] > > I realize", "on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will", "scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why", "wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one", "by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? > >", "purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such", "> > Is it such a bad idea, say, if", "pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? >", "> Is it such a bad idea, say, if we", "the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is", "> Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to", "(i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will my", "arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by arXiv count", "published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > >", "> > Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go", "my paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for", "arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? > > >", "the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers,", "who are new to academia. > > I would like", "Is it such a bad idea, say, if we make", "already exist to publish papers? > > Can a published", "I realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on", "of improving it which strikes me. Can others point out", "[The question is deleted now, original text reproduced below] >", "such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they", "arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed", "conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > > Can a", "> > Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as", "below] > > I realize we do not have a", "for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN", "guess it will be useful for our users who are", "per answer? This is one way of improving it which", "post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will my paper", "mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text reproduced below]", "the comments and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851).", "not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print", "is deleted now, original text reproduced below] > > I", "Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv?", "users who are new to academia. > > I would", "am unable to understand the comments and the down-votes on", "when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > > Can", "> > Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist", "I guess it will be useful for our users who", "we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose", "understand the comments and the down-votes on [this question of", "of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv,", "make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per", "our users who are new to academia. > > I", "community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is", "will be useful for our users who are new to", "terms of: > > What is the purpose of archives", "in terms of: > > What is the purpose of", "a 'publication' for me? > > > Is it such", "strikes me. Can others point out the flaws and give", "one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way of", "new to academia. > > I would like to see", "to see details in terms of: > > What is", "count as a 'publication' for me? > > > Is", "the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will be", "improving it which strikes me. Can others point out the", "to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by arXiv", "me. Can others point out the flaws and give inputs", "Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish", "of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > >", "answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it", "archives. I guess it will be useful for our users", "useful for our users who are new to academia. >", "papers? > > Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also", "needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > >", "> > I realize we do not have a definitive", "one way of improving it which strikes me. Can others", "original text reproduced below] > > I realize we do", "of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text reproduced", "a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? >", "text reproduced below] > > I realize we do not", "What is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of", "realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the", "like to see details in terms of: > > What", "which strikes me. Can others point out the flaws and", "a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This", "'publication' for me? > > > Is it such a", "of pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful for", "etc.? > > Why are they needed when conferences/journals already", "it such a bad idea, say, if we make it", "> > > Is it such a bad idea, say,", "to understand the comments and the down-votes on [this question", "is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific", "archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra,", "have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives.", "reproduced below] > > I realize we do not have", "see details in terms of: > > What is the", "Can others point out the flaws and give inputs on", "comments and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The", "> Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to", "paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me?", "pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful for our", "also go to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted", "we make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service", "> > I would like to see details in terms", "I am unable to understand the comments and the down-votes", "electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.?", "as a 'publication' for me? > > > Is it", "a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I", "to academia. > > I would like to see details", "Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication'", "accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? >", "unable to understand the comments and the down-votes on [this", "with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way", "it will be useful for our users who are new", "> > What is the purpose of archives for electronic", "question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text", "on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now,", "details in terms of: > > What is the purpose", "idea, say, if we make it a community wiki with", "to publish papers? > > Can a published work (i.e.,", "they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? >", "way of improving it which strikes me. Can others point", "academia. > > I would like to see details in", "such a bad idea, say, if we make it a", "> I realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline", "others point out the flaws and give inputs on improvement?", "pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way of improving", "is one way of improving it which strikes me. Can", "go to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by", "bad idea, say, if we make it a community wiki", "me? > > > Is it such a bad idea," ]
[ "we could be providing answers based on well conducted research?", "conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that", "when we could be providing answers based on well conducted", "to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical", "AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature than the", "understand that questions on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\"", "be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical of", "in nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but", "based on well conducted research? Should we be up voting", "our personal experience when we could be providing answers based", "then needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\".", "research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we", "questions based on our personal experience when we could be", "questions on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature", "the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our", "going to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions", "\"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation", "could be providing answers based on well conducted research? Should", "providing answers based on well conducted research? Should we be", "answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers", "based on our personal experience when we could be providing", "think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our", "our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read", "Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our personal experience", "answers that we agree with when they are void of", "nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I", "are going to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming", "we answering questions based on our personal experience when we", "of SO.SE, but I think our answers often are \"softer\"", "on our personal experience when we could be providing answers", "experience when we could be providing answers based on well", "up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when they", "voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when they are", "I understand that questions on AC.SE are going to be", "are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and think", "I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we", "Are we answering questions based on our personal experience when", "be providing answers based on well conducted research? Should we", "we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with", "think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often", "\"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE,", "than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think", "that we agree with when they are void of references?", "typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers often are", "on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature than", "programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers", "questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers often", "and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on", "but I think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed.", "answers based on well conducted research? Should we be up", "read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions", "SO.SE, but I think our answers often are \"softer\" then", "\"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our personal", "I think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I", "personal experience when we could be providing answers based on", "often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and", "well conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers", "answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based", "\"easy\" answers that we agree with when they are void", "be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when", "needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are", "answering questions based on our personal experience when we could", "on well conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\"", "Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree", "that questions on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in", "often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering" ]
[ "Can a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I", "stackexchange site that is likely to allow for questions about", "is likely to allow for questions about teaching, much less", "at the secondary level. Has anyone found another site that", "are several questions with with the words \"high school\" and", "the secondary level. Has anyone found another site that allow", "several questions with with the words \"high school\" and teaching", "an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site that", "\"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site that is", "\"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public school", "teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other", "questions about teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has", "academia. Can a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"?", "words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public", "teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher be considered", "much less at the secondary level. Has anyone found another", "school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any", "considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site", "secondary level. Has anyone found another site that allow such", "about teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has anyone", "other stackexchange site that is likely to allow for questions", "a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't", "site that is likely to allow for questions about teaching,", "teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has anyone found", "I haven't found any other stackexchange site that is likely", "any other stackexchange site that is likely to allow for", "public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found", "for questions about teaching, much less at the secondary level.", "level. Has anyone found another site that allow such questions?", "that is likely to allow for questions about teaching, much", "with the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can", "on academia. Can a public school teacher be considered an", "with with the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia.", "less at the secondary level. Has anyone found another site", "found any other stackexchange site that is likely to allow", "There are several questions with with the words \"high school\"", "be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange", "school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher", "and teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher be", "questions with with the words \"high school\" and teaching on", "the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a", "allow for questions about teaching, much less at the secondary", "likely to allow for questions about teaching, much less at", "haven't found any other stackexchange site that is likely to", "to allow for questions about teaching, much less at the" ]
[ "outright banned. I recently edited a question to replace a", "is the official policy of this site for URL shortners?", "direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is", "a direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What", "impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned.", "I recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly link", "was under the impression that URL shortners were either discouraged", "URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently", "were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a", "a bit.ly link with a direct link, and that edit", "official policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's", "edited a question to replace a bit.ly link with a", "banned. I recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly", "site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no need for them.", "discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a question to", "edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy of", "the impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright", "recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly link with", "this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no need for", "What is the official policy of this site for URL", "suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy of this", "shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited", "under the impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or", "and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official", "of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no need", "policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no", "question to replace a bit.ly link with a direct link,", "to replace a bit.ly link with a direct link, and", "either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a question", "the official policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly", "that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I", "or outright banned. I recently edited a question to replace", "link with a direct link, and that edit suggestion was", "link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the", "with a direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected.", "that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy", "rejected. What is the official policy of this site for", "bit.ly link with a direct link, and that edit suggestion", "I was under the impression that URL shortners were either", "was rejected. What is the official policy of this site", "a question to replace a bit.ly link with a direct", "replace a bit.ly link with a direct link, and that" ]
[ "don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive", "that should have been closed but are not? Questions or", "questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter.", "really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts", "to their questions and don't even know that this site", "on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part", "this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will", "need answers to their questions and don't even know that", "through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before,", "see a pattern of questions that should have been closed", "how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net.", "to look at this site through the eyes of someone", "love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world", "an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer", "use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an", "edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below", "someone who's never seen it before, and see how we", "asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few", "questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do", "in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to", "but are not? Questions or answers that could use an", "site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it", "the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see", "of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of", "easy they are to find and compare the answers we", "Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people", "before, and see how we stack up against the rest", "Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's", "are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit?", "a few Google searches to see how easy they are", "to see how easy they are to find and compare", "your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health", "they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be?", "that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run", "only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see", "queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were", "a whole world of people out there who need answers", "up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation", "with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions", "questions and don't even know that this site exists. When", "information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only", "who's never seen it before, and see how we stack", "the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and", "that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what", "the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though.", "and compare the answers we have with the information available", "Do you see a pattern of questions that should have", "first impression be? Let's try to look at this site", "10 questions that were asked and answered in the last", "Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to", "and discuss these questions and the site's health with your", "Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions", "is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you", "how easy they are to find and compare the answers", "pattern of questions that should have been closed but are", "from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try", "been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could", "though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should", "who need answers to their questions and don't even know", "there who need answers to their questions and don't even", "know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google,", "a pattern of questions that should have been closed but", "Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle,", "Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out", "discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow", "and see how we stack up against the rest of", "answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches", "their first impression be? Let's try to look at this", "look at this site through the eyes of someone who's", "and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google", "with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the", "Google searches to see how easy they are to find", "see how we stack up against the rest of the", "you see a pattern of questions that should have been", "quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy", "other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of", "the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval)", "could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post", "going really well? Post an answer below to share your", "that's going really well? Post an answer below to share", "part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern", "whole world of people out there who need answers to", "out there who need answers to their questions and don't", "they are to find and compare the answers we have", "is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked", "searches to see how easy they are to find and", "and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered", "try to look at this site through the eyes of", "[Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of", "populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in", "these questions and the site's health with your fellow users!", "impression be? Let's try to look at this site through", "at this site through the eyes of someone who's never", "will their first impression be? Let's try to look at", "and don't even know that this site exists. When they", "answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really", "stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site", "eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see", "is a whole world of people out there who need", "to find and compare the answers we have with the", "answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions", "puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that", "compare the answers we have with the information available on", "all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole", "open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and", "even know that this site exists. When they arrive from", "Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to", "few Google searches to see how easy they are to", "were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a", "never seen it before, and see how we stack up", "we have with the information available on other sites. Rating", "available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a", "find and compare the answers we have with the information", "sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the", "of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open", "to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the", "'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated", "site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their", "an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these", "have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that", "share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's", "Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss", "review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that", "are to find and compare the answers we have with", "world of people out there who need answers to their", "of questions that should have been closed but are not?", "closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use", "thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with", "a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a", "Run a few Google searches to see how easy they", "of someone who's never seen it before, and see how", "be? Let's try to look at this site through the", "seen it before, and see how we stack up against", "this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen", "should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers", "there is a whole world of people out there who", "we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The", "the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and", "but there is a whole world of people out there", "well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and", "the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is", "questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions", "that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well?", "We all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a", "the answers we have with the information available on other", "see how easy they are to find and compare the", "against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review", "not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything", "Let's try to look at this site through the eyes", "arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's", "answers to their questions and don't even know that this", "When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression", "people out there who need answers to their questions and", "or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going", "what will their first impression be? Let's try to look", "[Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10", "last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how", "their questions and don't even know that this site exists.", "below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and", "have with the information available on other sites. Rating the", "it before, and see how we stack up against the", "answers we have with the information available on other sites.", "exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first", "rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is", "The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with", "the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions", "of people out there who need answers to their questions" ]
[ "specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be", "is, would situations that do not necessarily happen to the", "this is, would situations that do not necessarily happen to", "to be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and", "questions be permitted? What I mean by this is, would", "the person asking the question, but could happen (and may", "mean by this is, would situations that do not necessarily", "person asking the question, but could happen (and may have", "and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted?", "necessarily happen to the person asking the question, but could", "but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I", "realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by this is,", "would situations that do not necessarily happen to the person", "would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean", "would have to be very specific and answerable, but would", "answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What", "very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions", "hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by", "permitted? What I mean by this is, would situations that", "(and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by this", "question would have to be very specific and answerable, but", "situations that do not necessarily happen to the person asking", "happen to the person asking the question, but could happen", "not necessarily happen to the person asking the question, but", "I mean by this is, would situations that do not", "the question, but could happen (and may have happened) be", "do not necessarily happen to the person asking the question,", "What I mean by this is, would situations that do", "The question would have to be very specific and answerable,", "asking the question, but could happen (and may have happened)", "be permitted? What I mean by this is, would situations", "to the person asking the question, but could happen (and", "have to be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical", "question, but could happen (and may have happened) be permitted?", "that do not necessarily happen to the person asking the", "by this is, would situations that do not necessarily happen", "be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic)" ]
[ "not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it", "material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor?", "click I realized that I should keep some parts of", "answer (my quick reject was based on edit on a", "the editor? (If it does not, it would discourage an", "it possible to lookup the history of rejected edits (for", "reject was based on edit on a quoted material). 1.", "the history of rejected edits (for a particular post, or", "does not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is", "Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it", "(If it does not, it would discourage an eager editor...)", "rejected an edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just", "the answer (my quick reject was based on edit on", "to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I", "was based on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does", "editor? (If it does not, it would discourage an eager", "as they improve the answer (my quick reject was based", "(my quick reject was based on edit on a quoted", "quick reject was based on edit on a quoted material).", "on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection", "editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the history of", "on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying", "of the edit, as they improve the answer (my quick", "based on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment", "that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized", "post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized that", "However, just after my click I realized that I should", "the edit, as they improve the answer (my quick reject", "2. Is it possible to lookup the history of rejected", "my click I realized that I should keep some parts", "I realized that I should keep some parts of the", "lookup the history of rejected edits (for a particular post,", "some parts of the edit, as they improve the answer", "an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the", "after my click I realized that I should keep some", "should keep some parts of the edit, as they improve", "quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the", "it does not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2.", "just after my click I realized that I should keep", "1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If", "history of rejected edits (for a particular post, or globally)?", "suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click", "they improve the answer (my quick reject was based on", "edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the", "I should keep some parts of the edit, as they", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized that I", "Is it possible to lookup the history of rejected edits", "would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to", "edit, as they improve the answer (my quick reject was", "realized that I should keep some parts of the edit,", "the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not, it", "I rejected an edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However,", "comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does", "keep some parts of the edit, as they improve the", "justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not,", "discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup", "eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the history", "a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches", "edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my", "parts of the edit, as they improve the answer (my", "possible to lookup the history of rejected edits (for a", "to lookup the history of rejected edits (for a particular", "an edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after", "rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not, it would", "reaches the editor? (If it does not, it would discourage", "it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible", "that I should keep some parts of the edit, as", "improve the answer (my quick reject was based on edit" ]
[ "consider it to have some merit, some do not. What", "is not a perfect fit for the site was posted", "generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate", "a question that is not a perfect fit for the", "question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually (if not", "have some merit, some do not. What if said question", "question that is not a perfect fit for the site", "merit, some do not. What if said question generates some", "do not. What if said question generates some very useful", "that is not a perfect fit for the site was", "very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that", "useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate", "Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually", "(not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness).", "(hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually (if not improved)?", "just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will", "not. What if said question generates some very useful answers", "some merit, some do not. What if said question generates", "the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be", "that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers)", "upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the", "- mostly some consider it to have some merit, some", "What if said question generates some very useful answers (not", "mostly some consider it to have some merit, some do", "comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful", "the site was posted - mostly some consider it to", "Say, a question that is not a perfect fit for", "fit for the site was posted - mostly some consider", "posted - mostly some consider it to have some merit,", "a perfect fit for the site was posted - mostly", "site was posted - mostly some consider it to have", "answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the", "but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question", "some consider it to have some merit, some do not.", "some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments", "said question generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted,", "some do not. What if said question generates some very", "usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted", "it to have some merit, some do not. What if", "was posted - mostly some consider it to have some", "generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence,", "for the site was posted - mostly some consider it", "the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually (if", "to have some merit, some do not. What if said", "if said question generates some very useful answers (not just", "perfect fit for the site was posted - mostly some", "not a perfect fit for the site was posted -", "question generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but", "indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still" ]
[ "to the voting page. --- This should help people submit", "to go to the voting page. --- This should help", "page. --- This should help people submit more tag synonyms", "visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions:", "existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links", "more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging", "people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing", "We have some [tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been", "This should help people submit more tag synonyms in turn,", "suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite being quite", "the voting page. --- This should help people submit more", "the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter", "being quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit the", "voting page. --- This should help people submit more tag", "I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms)", "have some [tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted", "tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging system", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left", "quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag", "[tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite", "been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like to", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left column (freehand", "submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our", "links of the left column (freehand circle!) to go to", "synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging system and", "synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description", "of the left column (freehand circle!) to go to the", "despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit", "have not been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd", "the left column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting", "left column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting page.", "go to the voting page. --- This should help people", "should help people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which", "in turn, which will improve our tagging system and the", "system and the overall experience on the site (especially searching", "suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the", "turn, which will improve our tagging system and the overall", "page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png)", "and the overall experience on the site (especially searching by", "vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on", "our tagging system and the overall experience on the site", "on the links of the left column (freehand circle!) to", "that have not been voted on, despite being quite old.", "people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve", "improve our tagging system and the overall experience on the", "not been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like", "(freehand circle!) to go to the voting page. --- This", "on, despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest people", "like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and", "will improve our tagging system and the overall experience on", "circle!) to go to the voting page. --- This should", "tagging system and the overall experience on the site (especially", "suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of", "help people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will", "--- This should help people submit more tag synonyms in", "old. I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym", "on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the", "[tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image", "column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting page. ---", "and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left column", "the links of the left column (freehand circle!) to go", "synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite being", "which will improve our tagging system and the overall experience", "Click on the links of the left column (freehand circle!)", "the overall experience on the site (especially searching by tags)!", "to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote", "some [tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on,", "voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest" ]
[ "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I", "to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that", "question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it", "which is not the appropriate site for this question. Is", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote", "the meta site, which is not the appropriate site for", "unless I select the meta site, which is not the", "the second screen unless I select the meta site, which", ".SE sites, or be able to type in a site,", "noticed that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image", "it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to", "wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed", "to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png)", "blank so it can reflect that it should be on", "second screen unless I select the meta site, which is", "to close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote", "I select the meta site, which is not the appropriate", "a list of .SE sites, or be able to type", "it blank so it can reflect that it should be", "of .SE sites, or be able to type in a", "leave it blank so it can reflect that it should", "choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close", "StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to do that:", "a way to add either a list of .SE sites,", "able to type in a site, or at least leave", "I voted to close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted", "type in a site, or at least leave it blank", "and wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but", "vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I", "click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless I", "be able to type in a site, or at least", "way to add either a list of .SE sites, or", "meta site, which is not the appropriate site for this", "Close\" on the second screen unless I select the meta", "send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose", "list of .SE sites, or be able to type in", "on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it to", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot", "Is there a way to add either a list of", "a site, or at least leave it blank so it", "not the appropriate site for this question. Is there a", "Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\"", "![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to", "so it can reflect that it should be on another", "that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description", "programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow,", "on the second screen unless I select the meta site,", "window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on", "is not the appropriate site for this question. Is there", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click", "that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that", "but noticed that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter", "screen unless I select the meta site, which is not", "or at least leave it blank so it can reflect", "[this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send", "that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second", "there a way to add either a list of .SE", "least leave it blank so it can reflect that it", "couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second", "cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless", "add either a list of .SE sites, or be able", "site, or at least leave it blank so it can", "site, which is not the appropriate site for this question.", "site for this question. Is there a way to add", "question. Is there a way to add either a list", "appropriate site for this question. Is there a way to", "it can reflect that it should be on another site?", "voted to close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to", "Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the", "close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to", "\"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless I select", "or be able to type in a site, or at", "to add either a list of .SE sites, or be", "I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png)", "at least leave it blank so it can reflect that", "in a site, or at least leave it blank so", "for this question. Is there a way to add either", "this question. Is there a way to add either a", "the appropriate site for this question. Is there a way", "to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't", "do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice", "to Close\" on the second screen unless I select the", "to type in a site, or at least leave it", "I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen", "either a list of .SE sites, or be able to", "sites, or be able to type in a site, or", "select the meta site, which is not the appropriate site", "to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to do" ]
[ "have some fun, we just don't want the site to", "we allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for", "regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and then,", "do we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I", "site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our", "Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we", "their number (active fun Q’s at the same time, I", "bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's the most", "something like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research", "reference for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's", "title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've", "the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's", "by prompting them on specific occasions (I think the site", "we need specific occasions for that? Or if we accept", "for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we", "them unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit agreement", "we want them to be community-wiki, as some sites do,", "(or do we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions", "graphics? conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position", "to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not", "sites do, so as not to game too much the", "specific reference for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/),", "some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them", "letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting", "the reputation system? (or do we simply not care?) Example", "reputation system? (or do we simply not care?) Example of", "little fun now and then, either by letting some “fun”", "think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near", "fun, we just don't want the site to be overrun", "[this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some", "either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or", "sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun", "favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title ", "it's OK to have some fun, we just don't want", "as not to game too much the reputation system? (or", "near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference for", "some fun, we just don't want the site to be", " what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever received?", "but I cannot find a specific reference for that). As", "the site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should", "them on specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism", "is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? ", "agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s at the", "specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism has regular", "Some Stack Exchange sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for", "not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see, and", "a little fun now and then, either by letting some", "we accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort of", "unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit agreement to", "would personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof):", "accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit", "be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not to", "“fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do we allow", "of tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s", "if we accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort", "that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to", "the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach,", "tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s at", "time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be", "I could see, and which I would personally enjoy, would", "care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see, and which", "regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find a", "at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want", "do we have some sort of tacit agreement to keep", "on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I", "fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific", "as some sites do, so as not to game too", "ever encountered? what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've", "need specific occasions for that? Or if we accept them", "research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what", "just don't want the site to be overrun with “fun", "I would personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets", "fun now and then, either by letting some “fun” soft", "* what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever", "explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we just don't", "that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we have", "Do we need specific occasions for that? Or if we", "want them to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so", "blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we", "big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions", "title you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh", "I cannot find a specific reference for that). As [this", "I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki,", "soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on specific", "cannot find a specific reference for that). As [this SE", "what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered?", "subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper title?", "fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for that? Or", "while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now", "number (active fun Q’s at the same time, I mean)", "we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could", "As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have", "thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC", "enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and", "abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is", "has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find", "could see, and which I would personally enjoy, would be", "“fun” questions I could see, and which I would personally", "TOC graphics? conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest", "(or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper", "Do we allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions", "SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun,", "what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever received? ", "would be something like (or subsets thereof): what's your", "should our policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do", "what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference", "your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title", "to keep their number (active fun Q’s at the same", "post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we just", "the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them", "the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever received? * etc.", "(I think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session", "overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do", "conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title", "a specific reference for that). As [this SE blog post", "now and then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list", "Do we want them to be community-wiki, as some sites", "occasions for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do", "game too much the reputation system? (or do we simply", "for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK", "and which I would personally enjoy, would be something like", "to have some fun, we just don't want the site", "questions I could see, and which I would personally enjoy,", "policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and then, either", "then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist,", "What should our policy be? Do we allow fun questions?", "sort of tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun", "occasions (I think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft", "community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not to game", "Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we have some", "Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot", "don't want the site to be overrun with “fun questions”.", "personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof): ", "(active fun Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable?", "enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof): what's", "paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is the", "them to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as", "same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to", "reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki, as some", "for a little fun now and then, either by letting", "so as not to game too much the reputation system?", "“fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on", "some sort of tacit agreement to keep their number (active", "prompting them on specific occasions (I think the site on", "title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is the most", "allow for a little fun now and then, either by", "be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we need specific", "on specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism has", "like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract?", "have some sort of tacit agreement to keep their number", "mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki, as", "not to game too much the reputation system? (or do", "* what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics?", "system? (or do we simply not care?) Example of “fun”", "we have some sort of tacit agreement to keep their", "fun Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do", "OK to have some fun, we just don't want the", "of “fun” questions I could see, and which I would", "Exchange sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little", "much the reputation system? (or do we simply not care?)", "specific occasions for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally,", "you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh review", "find a specific reference for that). As [this SE blog", "which I would personally enjoy, would be something like (or", "Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference for that).", "allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for that?", "see, and which I would personally enjoy, would be something", "to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy", "we just don't want the site to be overrun with", "session near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference", "some sites do, so as not to game too much", "be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy be?", "want the site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What", "our policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we", "to game too much the reputation system? (or do we", "Stack Exchange sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a", "encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever", "policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we need", "keep their number (active fun Q’s at the same time,", "or by prompting them on specific occasions (I think the", "and then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions", "by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by", "questions exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions (I", "most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's the", "simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see,", "questions? Do we need specific occasions for that? Or if", "with “fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do we", "be something like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite", "Example of “fun” questions I could see, and which I", "position title you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously", "exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions (I think", "site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but", "too much the reputation system? (or do we simply not", "do, so as not to game too much the reputation", "questions”. What should our policy be? Do we allow fun" ]
[ "thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative", "a lot better quality if the person who asked it", "> > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What", "like this? Do we want to encourage All to ask", "of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this", "the topics in general are okay, the questions just seem", "particular I am thinking about this question [Who should recommend", "be a lot better quality if the person who asked", "seem to be a little bit off. I think the", "think the question would be a lot better quality if", "of question like this? Do we want to encourage All", "> > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am", "User [All](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/406/all) has been asking a lot of questions. I", "Do we want to encourage All to ask different questions?", "the question would be a lot better quality if the", "who asked it was actually applying to be a Diap.", "asking of question like this? Do we want to encourage", "just seem to be a little bit off. I think", "[Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think", "> > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I", "if the person who asked it was actually applying to", "under the > > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical", "Diap. Do we want to do anything to discourage the", "I am thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants", "to be a little bit off. I think the question", "question would be a lot better quality if the person", "would be a lot better quality if the person who", "a little bit off. I think the question would be", "be a Diap. Do we want to do anything to", "general are okay, the questions just seem to be a", "happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular", "open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > >", "Do we want to do anything to discourage the asking", "be a little bit off. I think the question would", "an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” >", "in general are okay, the questions just seem to be", "of questions. I am starting to get the feeling that", "question like this? Do we want to encourage All to", "a lot of questions. I am starting to get the", "this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While", "was actually applying to be a Diap. Do we want", "for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general", "I think the question would be a lot better quality", "want to do anything to discourage the asking of question", "> happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In", "about this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions)", "question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I", "to get the feeling that they fall under the >", "[don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this question", "discourage the asking of question like this? Do we want", "applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in", "you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_", "should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the", "do anything to discourage the asking of question like this?", "the person who asked it was actually applying to be", "the asking of question like this? Do we want to", "part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about", "been asking a lot of questions. I am starting to", "if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of [don't", "to be a Diap. Do we want to do anything", "that they fall under the > > you are asking", "we want to do anything to discourage the asking of", "it was actually applying to be a Diap. Do we", "recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics", "actually applying to be a Diap. Do we want to", "“What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of", "While I think the topics in general are okay, the", "starting to get the feeling that they fall under the", "get the feeling that they fall under the > >", "\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask).", "hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > >", "better quality if the person who asked it was actually", "little bit off. I think the question would be a", "ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this question [Who", "question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part", "lot better quality if the person who asked it was", "to do anything to discourage the asking of question like", "> you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if", "fall under the > > you are asking an open-ended,", "administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general are", "asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?”", "are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ >", "topics in general are okay, the questions just seem to", "positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general are okay,", "[All](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/406/all) has been asking a lot of questions. I am", "are okay, the questions just seem to be a little", "lot of questions. I am starting to get the feeling", "a Diap. Do we want to do anything to discourage", "the feeling that they fall under the > > you", "asked it was actually applying to be a Diap. Do", "quality if the person who asked it was actually applying", "questions. I am starting to get the feeling that they", "to discourage the asking of question like this? Do we", "has been asking a lot of questions. I am starting", "bit off. I think the question would be a lot", "this? Do we want to encourage All to ask different", "> part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking", "anything to discourage the asking of question like this? Do", "am starting to get the feeling that they fall under", "am thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants for", "they fall under the > > you are asking an", "feeling that they fall under the > > you are", "the questions just seem to be a little bit off.", "asking a lot of questions. I am starting to get", "questions just seem to be a little bit off. I", "think the topics in general are okay, the questions just", "okay, the questions just seem to be a little bit", "the > > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question:", "off. I think the question would be a lot better", "In particular I am thinking about this question [Who should", "I am starting to get the feeling that they fall", "applying to be a Diap. Do we want to do", "I think the topics in general are okay, the questions", "person who asked it was actually applying to be a" ]
[ "followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something that", "question, JeffE says that academic research questions are firmly on", "questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about", "on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and", "it was closed as being off topic. It seems either", "It seems either the rules are unclear or they are", "and it seems the question could just as easily relate", "off topic. It seems either the rules are unclear or", "rules are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or,", "In [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13342/is-it-a-good-practice-to-choose-my-undergraduate-research-topic-on-my-own-can-i) question, JeffE says that academic research questions are", "is about undergrad research and it seems the question could", "question could just as easily relate to graduate level research", "or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply", "could just as easily relate to graduate level research but", "Or, am I simply not seeing something that other people", "closed as being off topic. It seems either the rules", "level research but it was closed as being off topic.", "just as easily relate to graduate level research but it", "they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not", "being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something", "was closed as being off topic. It seems either the", "topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it", "says that academic research questions are firmly on topic. However,", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it seems the", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13342/is-it-a-good-practice-to-choose-my-undergraduate-research-topic-on-my-own-can-i) question, JeffE says that academic research questions are firmly", "to graduate level research but it was closed as being", "the rules are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently.", "unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I", "JeffE says that academic research questions are firmly on topic.", "being off topic. It seems either the rules are unclear", "am I simply not seeing something that other people can", "either the rules are unclear or they are being followed", "However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it seems", "I simply not seeing something that other people can see?", "about undergrad research and it seems the question could just", "academic research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question", "research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is", "topic. It seems either the rules are unclear or they", "research but it was closed as being off topic. It", "are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am", "inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something that other", "seems the question could just as easily relate to graduate", "research and it seems the question could just as easily", "it seems the question could just as easily relate to", "are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing", "relate to graduate level research but it was closed as", "firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research", "question is about undergrad research and it seems the question", "seems either the rules are unclear or they are being", "graduate level research but it was closed as being off", "easily relate to graduate level research but it was closed", "are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad", "but it was closed as being off topic. It seems", "the question could just as easily relate to graduate level", "as being off topic. It seems either the rules are", "as easily relate to graduate level research but it was", "undergrad research and it seems the question could just as", "that academic research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic)" ]
[ "provided so that people can, in the answers and comments", "that people can, in the answers and comments below, test", "so that people can, in the answers and comments below,", "the answers and comments below, test formatting features of Academia", "is provided so that people can, in the answers and", "This post is provided so that people can, in the", "can, in the answers and comments below, test formatting features", "in the answers and comments below, test formatting features of", "answers and comments below, test formatting features of Academia Stack", "people can, in the answers and comments below, test formatting", "and comments below, test formatting features of Academia Stack Exchange.", "post is provided so that people can, in the answers" ]
[ "posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions", "on how the tags are built and used in general.", "[application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and", "down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or", "been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has", "as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged", "In the post [What does the “application” tag mean (and", "\"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former", "mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates", "see that there are two ways to go here, to", "the former but what would be preferable. With only four", "brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\")", "to applying something). The tag at the time of writing", "and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the", "tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow", "would be easy to make the change. I see this", "jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag at the", "\"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I", "change. I see this also reflecting on how the tags", "tag at the time of writing this has been applied", "for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The", "such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions", "[faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged", "\"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\")", "of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\"", "'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags such as", "the “application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a", "to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag", "questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags", "new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently", "applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something).", "the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to", "relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\")", "A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged", "there are two ways to go here, to either use", "the post [What does the “application” tag mean (and what", "tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show", "be preferable. With only four tagged posts it would be", "'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as", "has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four", "the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications", "to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged", "I would opt for the former but what would be", "does the “application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394)", "questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example,", "\"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can", "posts it would be easy to make the change. I", "'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but what would", "to make the change. I see this also reflecting on", "tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show", "questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to", "ways to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show", "applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared,", "this also reflecting on how the tags are built and", "adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty", "applying something). The tag at the time of writing this", "The tag at the time of writing this has been", "exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag", "would be preferable. With only four tagged posts it would", "tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags such", "[application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags", "writing this has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively", "example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag at", "'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions", "\"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and", "(currently on four posts). I can see that there are", "accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\").", "the time of writing this has been applied to 89", "should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application", "[faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I", "are two ways to go here, to either use the", "scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept", "mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions", "as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for", "posts). I can see that there are two ways to", "what would be preferable. With only four tagged posts it", "four posts). I can see that there are two ways", "on four posts). I can see that there are two", "narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\")", "former but what would be preferable. With only four tagged", "only four tagged posts it would be easy to make", "that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern", "post [What does the “application” tag mean (and what should", "With only four tagged posts it would be easy to", "four tagged posts it would be easy to make the", "(as opposed to applying something). The tag at the time", "tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs", "questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school", "for the former but what would be preferable. With only", "[application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for,", "\"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of", "'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show", "make the change. I see this also reflecting on how", "for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag", "it would be easy to make the change. I see", "concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying", "as a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show", "opposed to applying something). The tag at the time of", "[What does the “application” tag mean (and what should it", "be easy to make the change. I see this also", "base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged", "tagged posts it would be easy to make the change.", "here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\")", "what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the", "questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application", "tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application", "[research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\")", "questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see", "tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would", "tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show", "'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions", "has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag", "to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged", "it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show", "such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt", "a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions", "'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down", "this has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new", "\"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such", "but what would be preferable. With only four tagged posts", "preferable. With only four tagged posts it would be easy", "\"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding", "'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see that there", "“application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief", "89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show", "to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application", "to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions", "would opt for the former but what would be preferable.", "tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but what", "see this also reflecting on how the tags are built", "I see this also reflecting on how the tags are", "I can see that there are two ways to go", "something). The tag at the time of writing this has", "tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see that", "questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as", "reflecting on how the tags are built and used in", "can see that there are two ways to go here,", "questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but", "appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts).", "at the time of writing this has been applied to", "the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base", "[graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope", "(and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that", "of writing this has been applied to 89 posts. A", "two ways to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application", "opt for the former but what would be preferable. With", "either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as", "time of writing this has been applied to 89 posts.", "easy to make the change. I see this also reflecting", "tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on", "use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a", "also reflecting on how the tags are built and used", "and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"),", "tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange", "tag as a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research", "the change. I see this also reflecting on how the", "or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions", "tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed", "that there are two ways to go here, to either", "indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should", "[faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the", "should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to", "a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged", "go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged", "\"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for" ]
[ "and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively.", "initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former.", "'\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7", "to the question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials", "describing this subject, even though such a tag should be", "tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to include", "site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from", "few tags that deal with the teaching side of academic", "'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one", "[62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would clearly", "evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times", "an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However,", "and on a second thought the latter option might be", "results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would clearly be", "a tag? From what I can see there seems to", "additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was", "'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to include additional", "job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from what", "However, from what I could find, there are no tags", "evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding", "and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching'", "this subject, even though such a tag should be relevant", "the former. However, either one would fit the purpose, and", "also other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you", "tag should be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE", "'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning", "these the tag would clearly be relevant for many of", "general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations", "'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of teaching skills).", "many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones).", "turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag", "them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows", "tags, with relatively few tags that deal with the teaching", "the question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials in", "I could find, there are no tags describing this subject,", "(both current and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation", "the purpose, and on a second thought the latter option", "either one would fit the purpose, and on a second", "to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively", "many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student", "materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly", "but this was quickly removed. However, from what I could", "there is a need for such a tag? From what", "the tag would clearly be relevant for many of them.", "purpose, and on a second thought the latter option might", "should be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both", "Do you think that there is a need for such", "be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types", "From what I can see there seems to be a", "and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one would", "from what I could find, there are no tags describing", "more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of", "on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the main", "academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from", "in the current tags, with relatively few tags that deal", "When adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and", "even though such a tag should be relevant for many", "+ teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these", "can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the", "be relevant for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching", "tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose", "However, either one would fit the purpose, and on a", "scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant for many", "this was quickly removed. However, from what I could find,", "7 times respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose", "what I can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\"", "such a tag? From what I can see there seems", "for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future", "adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation',", "types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that", "there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags,", "second thought the latter option might be more general (could", "in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed.", "relevant for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"'", "current tags, with relatively few tags that deal with the", "a second thought the latter option might be more general", "thought the latter option might be more general (could encompass", "Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62", "AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the main site,", "main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and", "\"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few tags that", "tags describing this subject, even though such a tag should", "application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from what I", "questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching", "teaching skills). Do you think that there is a need", "I recently added the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question", "on a second thought the latter option might be more", "though such a tag should be relevant for many questions", "'\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When", "relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and", "6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag I", "you think that there is a need for such a", "need for such a tag? From what I can see", "would clearly be relevant for many of them. The specific", "times respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose between", "a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few tags", "but also other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do", "think that there is a need for such a tag?", "encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of teaching", "with relatively few tags that deal with the teaching side", "for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and", "it appropriate to include additional materials in an academic job", "see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current", "recently added the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is", "tag? From what I can see there seems to be", "tags that deal with the teaching side of academic activities.", "[Is it appropriate to include additional materials in an academic", "quickly removed. However, from what I could find, there are", "specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6", "one would fit the purpose, and on a second thought", "would fit the purpose, and on a second thought the", "option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also", "latter option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but", "here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the", "for such a tag? From what I can see there", "be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few", "the latter option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation'", "I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the", "current and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation +", "the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate", "future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns", "phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and", "could find, there are no tags describing this subject, even", "(could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of", "the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching),", "between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either", "removed. However, from what I could find, there are no", "added the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it", "of teaching skills). Do you think that there is a", "new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to", "be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current", "include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this", "up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag", "find, there are no tags describing this subject, even though", "the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and", "from scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant for", "are no tags describing this subject, even though such a", "tag would clearly be relevant for many of them. The", "skills). Do you think that there is a need for", "shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the", "chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However,", "of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that there", "of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"'", "was quickly removed. However, from what I could find, there", "teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the", "clearly be relevant for many of them. The specific phrases", "I can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in", "is a need for such a tag? From what I", "subject, even though such a tag should be relevant for", "that there is a need for such a tag? From", "what I could find, there are no tags describing this", "chose the former. However, either one would fit the purpose,", "question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials in an", "respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation'", "a tag should be relevant for many questions here on", "there are no tags describing this subject, even though such", "'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one would fit", "former. However, either one would fit the purpose, and on", "seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with", "such a tag should be relevant for many questions here", "and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag I initially", "evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that there is", "ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up", "no tags describing this subject, even though such a tag", "and from scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant", "up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would", "fit the purpose, and on a second thought the latter", "appropriate to include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/),", "other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think", "the current tags, with relatively few tags that deal with", "The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up", "and chose the former. However, either one would fit the", "a need for such a tag? From what I can", "might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other", "to include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but", "relatively few tags that deal with the teaching side of" ]
[ "other (insert your own). In particular, there is nothing along", "in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students ", "on another SE site other (insert your own). In", "others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students", "following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply to", "to apply to others in similar situations * about problems", "do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or", "your own). In particular, there is nothing along the lines", "* cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar", "database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned", "another SE site * other (insert your own). In particular,", "I wanted to vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose", "the lines of \"this is off-topic because it has little", "nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic because it", "vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database),", "particular, there is nothing along the lines of \"this is", "is nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic because", "site * other (insert your own). In particular, there is", "facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site ", "or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question", "similar situations about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs", "but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations:", "cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations", "* belongs on another SE site * other (insert your", "\"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot", "question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\". Is this deliberate?", "* other (insert your own). In particular, there is nothing", "* about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another", "about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE", "\"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is", "the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply", "central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only", "wanted to vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary", "to vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary /", "with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even", "has little to do with academia\", or \"it is a", "motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply to others in", "situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on", "undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site * other", "(insert your own). In particular, there is nothing along the", "off-topic because it has little to do with academia\", or", "along the lines of \"this is off-topic because it has", "little to do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486)", "to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but", "I only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be", "find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to", "there is nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic", "academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic", "own). In particular, there is nothing along the lines of", "under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations: ", "of \"this is off-topic because it has little to do", "[boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\". Is this", "\"this is off-topic because it has little to do with", "an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I", "multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find", "be generalized to apply to others in similar situations ", "to do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\",", "lines of \"this is off-topic because it has little to", "apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing", "is off-topic because it has little to do with academia\",", "belongs on another SE site * other (insert your own).", "generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about", "a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\". Is", "only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized", "/ database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following", "pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply to others", "because it has little to do with academia\", or \"it", "close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under", "In particular, there is nothing along the lines of \"this", "[Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\"", "it has little to do with academia\", or \"it is", "students * belongs on another SE site * other (insert", "is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\".", "dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the", "to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate", "SE site * other (insert your own). In particular, there", "problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site" ]
[ "remember from the answer in question (in my case: it", "question (in my case: it was an answer about dealing", "couldn't find it, even when using every bit of information", "contained lots of links, if I remember correctly written by", "written by F'x) I figured that could be a good", "by F'x) I figured that could be a good meta", "the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if I", "I figured that could be a good meta question; what", "material on AC.SE even though you are sure it exists", "some material on AC.SE even though you are sure it", "information I remember from the answer in question (in my", "using every bit of information I remember from the answer", "links, if I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured", "answer but couldn't find it, even when using every bit", "answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots", "bit of information I remember from the answer in question", "of information I remember from the answer in question (in", "every bit of information I remember from the answer in", "it, even when using every bit of information I remember", "correctly written by F'x) I figured that could be a", "good meta question; what can you do if you cant", "you cant find some material on AC.SE even though you", "impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if I remember", "could be a good meta question; what can you do", "meta question; what can you do if you cant find", "been trying to locate a particular answer but couldn't find", "have been trying to locate a particular answer but couldn't", "figured that could be a good meta question; what can", "even though you are sure it exists (or -ed at", "you are sure it exists (or -ed at some point)?", "find some material on AC.SE even though you are sure", "to locate a particular answer but couldn't find it, even", "even when using every bit of information I remember from", "(in my case: it was an answer about dealing with", "you do if you cant find some material on AC.SE", "cant find some material on AC.SE even though you are", "an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained", "find it, even when using every bit of information I", "syndrome and contained lots of links, if I remember correctly", "what can you do if you cant find some material", "locate a particular answer but couldn't find it, even when", "lots of links, if I remember correctly written by F'x)", "my case: it was an answer about dealing with the", "of links, if I remember correctly written by F'x) I", "the answer in question (in my case: it was an", "remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that could be", "be a good meta question; what can you do if", "though you are sure it exists (or -ed at some", "was an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and", "trying to locate a particular answer but couldn't find it,", "I remember from the answer in question (in my case:", "from the answer in question (in my case: it was", "with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if", "I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that could", "if you cant find some material on AC.SE even though", "do if you cant find some material on AC.SE even", "I have been trying to locate a particular answer but", "if I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that", "question; what can you do if you cant find some", "can you do if you cant find some material on", "particular answer but couldn't find it, even when using every", "answer in question (in my case: it was an answer", "F'x) I figured that could be a good meta question;", "a good meta question; what can you do if you", "case: it was an answer about dealing with the impostor", "dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links,", "that could be a good meta question; what can you", "but couldn't find it, even when using every bit of", "in question (in my case: it was an answer about", "it was an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome", "about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of", "and contained lots of links, if I remember correctly written", "on AC.SE even though you are sure it exists (or", "when using every bit of information I remember from the", "AC.SE even though you are sure it exists (or -ed", "a particular answer but couldn't find it, even when using" ]
[ "know quite well the topic of the papers. My question:", "My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information here?", "where I know the information. I know quite well the", "that I know a true story, an example of such", "topic of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to", "that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/... without the", "I know quite well the topic of the papers. My", "the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this", "don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes such information", "Now, it was requested that I relieve more information about", "the information. I know quite well the topic of the", "with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I", "such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was", "their back. My view of cons: I don't want to", "therefore it's not really speaking behind their back. My view", "that I relieve more information about this, which I originally", "talk from where I know the information. I know quite", "one of them in person (from a conference) and he", "be a paparazzi that publishes such information on a random", "conference talk from where I know the information. I know", "to publish this information here? My view of pros: it's", "the authors, I know one of them in person (from", "write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that", "a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested", "information. I know quite well the topic of the papers.", "about this, which I originally didn't want to. What do", "really speaking behind their back. My view of cons: I", "authors, I know one of them in person (from a", "back. My view of cons: I don't want to be", "behind their back. My view of cons: I don't want", "I don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes such", "question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information here? My", "end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve more information", "to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned", "\"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve more", "view of cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi", "a paparazzi that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/...", "In [my answer to \"How to write a white paper", "who are the authors, I know one of them in", "this information here? My view of pros: it's all positive,", "an example of such a situation with a \"happy end\".", "\"How to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I", "(from a conference) and he made a conference talk from", "I know who are the authors, I know one of", "of such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it", "this, which I originally didn't want to. What do I", "I relieve more information about this, which I originally didn't", "example of such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now,", "didn't want to. What do I know: I know who", "quite well the topic of the papers. My question: Is", "answer to \"How to write a white paper for a", "well the topic of the papers. My question: Is it", "which I originally didn't want to. What do I know:", "information here? My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore", "do I know: I know who are the authors, I", "view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really", "publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/... without the people's", "I know a true story, an example of such a", "My view of cons: I don't want to be a", "such information on a random webpage/blog/... without the people's consent.", "I know one of them in person (from a conference)", "I mentioned that I know a true story, an example", "pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind", "a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve", "paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a", "a conference) and he made a conference talk from where", "I originally didn't want to. What do I know: I", "it non-ethical to publish this information here? My view of", "publish this information here? My view of pros: it's all", "cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes", "non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true story, an", "person (from a conference) and he made a conference talk", "them in person (from a conference) and he made a", "it's not really speaking behind their back. My view of", "mentioned that I know a true story, an example of", "My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not", "he made a conference talk from where I know the", "was requested that I relieve more information about this, which", "of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking", "speaking behind their back. My view of cons: I don't", "situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that", "a conference talk from where I know the information. I", "want to be a paparazzi that publishes such information on", "made a conference talk from where I know the information.", "non-ethical to publish this information here? My view of pros:", "more information about this, which I originally didn't want to.", "true story, an example of such a situation with a", "not really speaking behind their back. My view of cons:", "know who are the authors, I know one of them", "to \"How to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659).", "know the information. I know quite well the topic of", "all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their back.", "know: I know who are the authors, I know one", "for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true", "story, an example of such a situation with a \"happy", "I know: I know who are the authors, I know", "here? My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's", "paparazzi that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/... without", "it was requested that I relieve more information about this,", "a true story, an example of such a situation with", "positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their back. My", "know a true story, an example of such a situation", "the topic of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical", "in person (from a conference) and he made a conference", "of cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi that", "of them in person (from a conference) and he made", "a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true story,", "[my answer to \"How to write a white paper for", "What do I know: I know who are the authors,", "want to. What do I know: I know who are", "requested that I relieve more information about this, which I", "relieve more information about this, which I originally didn't want", "conference) and he made a conference talk from where I", "it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their", "of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish", "Is it non-ethical to publish this information here? My view", "know one of them in person (from a conference) and", "information about this, which I originally didn't want to. What", "are the authors, I know one of them in person", "a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I", "to be a paparazzi that publishes such information on a", "white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know", "from where I know the information. I know quite well", "I know the information. I know quite well the topic", "and he made a conference talk from where I know", "papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information", "originally didn't want to. What do I know: I know", "to. What do I know: I know who are the" ]
[ "this issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum seems", "if this is the appropriate place to raise this issue,", "research jobs [What options does college dropout with great grades,", "moderation? It's not fair for some questions to get put", "admitted to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree", "getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible", "be accepted without question, or relevance to the stated purpose", "to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or", "seem to be accepted without question, or relevance to the", "internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs", "to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other", "accepted without question, or relevance to the stated purpose of", "program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree)", "academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or relevance", "undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to a Master's", "hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are", "questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout", "undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about writing a", "question about writing a cv for an internship was put", "not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to", "the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship)", "on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions", "because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest", "degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without", "return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school", "stated purpose of the forum seems to be that the", "questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A", "[What options does college dropout with great grades, research projects", "an internship was put on hold on vote because it", "this is the appropriate place to raise this issue, but:", "sure if this is the appropriate place to raise this", "what is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation?", "unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum", "The stated purpose of the forum seems to be that", "consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions to get", "without an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to", "for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed", "the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not", "internship was put on hold on vote because it was", "into grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible to", "to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due", "research projects and CV have to return to university (or", "or getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is it", "ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions to", "of the forum. So my question is, what is the", "appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose", "jobs [What options does college dropout with great grades, research", "and academicians. A question about writing a cv for an", "academicians. A question about writing a cv for an internship", "both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about writing", "to the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae", "after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem", "due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question,", "options does college dropout with great grades, research projects and", "an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining", "some questions to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant", "off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing", "question is, what is the policy (if any) to ensure", "to be accepted without question, or relevance to the stated", "put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant", "policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair", "purpose of the forum seems to be that the questions", "for an internship was put on hold on vote because", "benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about", "forum. So my question is, what is the policy (if", "a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to", "or relevance to the stated purpose of the forum. So", "a cv for an internship was put on hold on", "a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However", "to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of the", "thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is", "the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for", "to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions", "forum seems to be that the questions should benefit both", "put on hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic", "[Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough.", "was put on hold on vote because it was deemed", "university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an", "of the forum seems to be that the questions should", "to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without", "be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students", "it possible to be admitted to a Master's program after", "Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What", "great grades, research projects and CV have to return to", "was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the", "to be admitted to a Master's program after not completing", "does college dropout with great grades, research projects and CV", "the appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The stated", "to be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate", "similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does college", "should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question", "(or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an undergrad", "is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's", "hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful", "have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into", "that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and", "curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar", "seems to be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates,", "the stated purpose of the forum. So my question is,", "Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic", "vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions", "graduate students and academicians. A question about writing a cv", "enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options", "to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad", "[Is it possible to be admitted to a Master's program", "and CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or", "grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible to be", "dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or relevance to", "questions to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when", "not sure if this is the appropriate place to raise", "not fair for some questions to get put on hold/deleted", "about writing a cv for an internship was put on", "question, or relevance to the stated purpose of the forum.", "about obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout with", "completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be", "to the stated purpose of the forum. So my question", "with great grades, research projects and CV have to return", "cv for an internship was put on hold on vote", "I'm not sure if this is the appropriate place to", "issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum seems to", "the forum seems to be that the questions should benefit", "college dropout with great grades, research projects and CV have", "is the appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The", "purpose of the forum. So my question is, what is", "stated purpose of the forum. So my question is, what", "community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair", "projects and CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha)", "rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an", "the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians.", "but: The stated purpose of the forum seems to be", "on hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic and", "vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the", "irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed to stay", "and unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing a", "of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate", "grades, research projects and CV have to return to university", "fair for some questions to get put on hold/deleted for", "However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does", "A question about writing a cv for an internship was", "it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of", "raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum", "be admitted to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's", "CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting", "the forum. So my question is, what is the policy", "being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed to", "get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally", "any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some", "It's not fair for some questions to get put on", "dropout with great grades, research projects and CV have to", "without question, or relevance to the stated purpose of the", "relevance to the stated purpose of the forum. So my", "place to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of", "students and academicians. A question about writing a cv for", "for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about", "obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout with great", "my question is, what is the policy (if any) to", "possible to be admitted to a Master's program after not", "school without an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted", "is, what is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent", "writing a cv for an internship was put on hold", "for some questions to get put on hold/deleted for being", "So my question is, what is the policy (if any)", "on vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to", "undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research", "when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed to stay up.", "Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted", "(if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for", "deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the community", "an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to a" ]
[ "Should we have MathJax support on Academia? I think it", "it would be useful if questions about math in academic", "be useful if questions about math in academic writing are", "we have MathJax support on Academia? I think it would", "think it would be useful if questions about math in", "on Academia? I think it would be useful if questions", "in academic writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15)", "math in academic writing are common here. I just asked", "would be useful if questions about math in academic writing", "about math in academic writing are common here. I just", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been nice (but", "here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would", "support on Academia? I think it would be useful if", "writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and", "common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it", "Academia? I think it would be useful if questions about", "MathJax support on Academia? I think it would be useful", "academic writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question", "if questions about math in academic writing are common here.", "asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been nice", "I think it would be useful if questions about math", "just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been", "have MathJax support on Academia? I think it would be", "question and there it would have been nice (but not", "and there it would have been nice (but not necessary).", "I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have", "useful if questions about math in academic writing are common", "questions about math in academic writing are common here. I", "are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there" ]
[ "someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is even less", "they want to do what it takes to get a", "to delete things they haven't really read, and to encourage", "to encourage the promotion of people to power based on", "almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence:", "a PhD might have mental health issues is over the", "encourage mods not to delete things they haven't really read,", "Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign", "unsure is even less likely at all to graduate with", "promotion of people to power based on quality, not quantity?", "Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is", "what it takes to get a PhD might have mental", "sure if they want to do what it takes to", "they haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion of", "of mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting", "comment concerning this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension,", "even be a sign of mental health is what I'm", "might have mental health issues is over the top.\" I", "to the dissenting nature of my answer. What can we", "health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from", "MIGHT even be a sign of mental health is what", "concerning this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which", "PhD might have mental health issues is over the top.\"", "a careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature", "the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute,", "we do to encourage mods not to delete things they", "to careless moderators coming into power. Part of my answer", "read, and to encourage the promotion of people to power", "answer. What can we do to encourage mods not to", "to graduate with a PhD than someone who goes in", "assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting", "a PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure", "getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows", "is unclear to me is whether someone like you who", "the rep system is leading to careless moderators coming into", "all to graduate with a PhD than someone who goes", "that someone who is not sure if they want to", "due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that", "is over the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a", "who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at all", "my answer. What can we do to encourage mods not", "like you who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely", "comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than", "answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due to the", "at all to graduate with a PhD than someone who", "at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a", "what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this", "sign of mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The", "careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of", "the dissenting nature of my answer. What can we do", "get a PhD might have mental health issues is over", "of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether", "to me is whether someone like you who feels somewhat", "of my answer. What can we do to encourage mods", "somewhat unsure is even less likely at all to graduate", "of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if", "waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental health is", "feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at all to", "attribute, but he deleted my answer from a careless reading,", "I am worried that the rep system is leading to", "Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental health", "reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of my", "\"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if they want", "is whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is", "The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack", "not to delete things they haven't really read, and to", "death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental", "nature of my answer. What can we do to encourage", "unclear to me is whether someone like you who feels", "rep system is leading to careless moderators coming into power.", "but he deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps", "that the rep system is leading to careless moderators coming", "passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost", "the promotion of people to power based on quality, not", "do to encourage mods not to delete things they haven't", "to get a PhD might have mental health issues is", "PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or", "What can we do to encourage mods not to delete", "over the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive", "health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment", "not sure if they want to do what it takes", "I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage", "do what it takes to get a PhD might have", "someone who is not sure if they want to do", "this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is", "delete things they haven't really read, and to encourage the", "things they haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion", "is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of", "it takes to get a PhD might have mental health", "said mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my", "can we do to encourage mods not to delete things", "likely at all to graduate with a PhD than someone", "careless moderators coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What", "power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me", "deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due", "goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT", "a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due", "or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of", "coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear", "reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather", "due to the dissenting nature of my answer. What can", "carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who", "leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part of my", "mods not to delete things they haven't really read, and", "shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly", "encourage the promotion of people to power based on quality,", "be a sign of mental health is what I'm getting", "takes to get a PhD might have mental health issues", "is leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part of", "positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from a careless", "deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack of", "issues is over the top.\" I clearly said mental health,", "in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even", "really read, and to encourage the promotion of people to", "graduate with a PhD than someone who goes in thinking", "if they want to do what it takes to get", "someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your", "I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but he", "mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer", "am worried that the rep system is leading to careless", "dissenting nature of my answer. What can we do to", "me is whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure", "lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure", "done due to the dissenting nature of my answer. What", "intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if they", "who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling", "want to do what it takes to get a PhD", "worried that the rep system is leading to careless moderators", "rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is", "he deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done", "mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack of reading", "which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack", "from a careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting", "of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness", "perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of my answer.", "than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death.", "less likely at all to graduate with a PhD than", "is not sure if they want to do what it", "to do what it takes to get a PhD might", "with a PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1", "to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone", "whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is even", "a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from a", "haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion of people", "my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone", "is even less likely at all to graduate with a", "into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to", "who is not sure if they want to do what", "is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning", "even less likely at all to graduate with a PhD", "moderators coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is", "lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to", "a sign of mental health is what I'm getting at.\"", "and to encourage the promotion of people to power based", "mental health issues is over the top.\" I clearly said", "answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone like", "was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone like you", "you who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at", "to encourage mods not to delete things they haven't really", "mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's", "top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but", "thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be", "system is leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part", "my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due to", "have mental health issues is over the top.\" I clearly", "health issues is over the top.\" I clearly said mental", "than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not", "R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a", "clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted" ]
[ "in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an illegal", "of a non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind", "that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow", "appears to be to an illegal copy of a non-open", "link to the non-free version? For some questions you might", "to see the paper in order to answer the question,", "a nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The", "paper in order to answer the question, but in other", "an illegal copy of a non-open access paper that is", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15783/re-typesetting-an-old-paper-what-to-do-with-the-result) the OP links to a nature paper that s/he", "or force people to link to the non-free version? For", "need to be able to see the paper in order", "see the paper to answer the question. Does this affect", "to pirated papers or force people to link to the", "the paper to answer the question. Does this affect or", "is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links", "might not need to see the paper to answer the", "to link to the non-free version? For some questions you", "(e.g., this case) you might not need to see the", "link appears to be to an illegal copy of a", "access paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should", "papers or force people to link to the non-free version?", "able to see the paper in order to answer the", "to be able to see the paper in order to", "order to answer the question, but in other (e.g., this", "see the paper in order to answer the question, but", "is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to", "questions you might need to be able to see the", "might need to be able to see the paper in", "in other (e.g., this case) you might not need to", "paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears", "re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an illegal copy", "non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall).", "you might need to be able to see the paper", "to answer the question, but in other (e.g., this case)", "behind a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers", "answer the question, but in other (e.g., this case) you", "a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers or", "non-free version? For some questions you might need to be", "to a nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting.", "in order to answer the question, but in other (e.g.,", "the OP links to a nature paper that s/he is", "copy of a non-open access paper that is available (presumably", "In this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15783/re-typesetting-an-old-paper-what-to-do-with-the-result) the OP links to a nature paper", "be to an illegal copy of a non-open access paper", "The link appears to be to an illegal copy of", "nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link", "(presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated", "OP links to a nature paper that s/he is interested", "not need to see the paper to answer the question.", "interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an", "For some questions you might need to be able to", "links to pirated papers or force people to link to", "to see the paper to answer the question. Does this", "the paper in order to answer the question, but in", "force people to link to the non-free version? For some", "some questions you might need to be able to see", "you might not need to see the paper to answer", "paper to answer the question. Does this affect or decision?", "this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15783/re-typesetting-an-old-paper-what-to-do-with-the-result) the OP links to a nature paper that", "paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers or force", "s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be", "a non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind a", "people to link to the non-free version? For some questions", "paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we", "version? For some questions you might need to be able", "be able to see the paper in order to answer", "question, but in other (e.g., this case) you might not", "pirated papers or force people to link to the non-free", "but in other (e.g., this case) you might not need", "need to see the paper to answer the question. Does", "this case) you might not need to see the paper", "Should we allow links to pirated papers or force people", "to the non-free version? For some questions you might need", "to be to an illegal copy of a non-open access", "we allow links to pirated papers or force people to", "links to a nature paper that s/he is interested in", "that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to", "case) you might not need to see the paper to", "available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links to", "to an illegal copy of a non-open access paper that", "illegal copy of a non-open access paper that is available", "the non-free version? For some questions you might need to", "the question, but in other (e.g., this case) you might", "allow links to pirated papers or force people to link", "other (e.g., this case) you might not need to see" ]
[ "question as no question is stupid. If you have no", "have no idea why ppl like bad fire work so", "no question is stupid. If you have no interest in", "you have no interest in my question or opinion conflict", "five question and two of them are being put on", "no right to judge other people's question as no question", "two of them are being put on hold by viewer.", "by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to judge", "If you have no interest in my question or opinion", "I asked five question and two of them are being", "or opinion conflict with mine, just go away please? I", "and two of them are being put on hold by", "mine, just go away please? I have no idea why", "just go away please? I have no idea why ppl", "my question or opinion conflict with mine, just go away", "Seriously, there are really no right to judge other people's", "please? I have no idea why ppl like bad fire", "there are really no right to judge other people's question", "as no question is stupid. If you have no interest", "no interest in my question or opinion conflict with mine,", "interest in my question or opinion conflict with mine, just", "of them are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously,", "asked five question and two of them are being put", "is stupid. If you have no interest in my question", "other people's question as no question is stupid. If you", "with mine, just go away please? I have no idea", "in my question or opinion conflict with mine, just go", "I have no idea why ppl like bad fire work", "no idea why ppl like bad fire work so much.", "them are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there", "hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to", "right to judge other people's question as no question is", "are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are", "go away please? I have no idea why ppl like", "question and two of them are being put on hold", "viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to judge other", "question or opinion conflict with mine, just go away please?", "judge other people's question as no question is stupid. If", "question is stupid. If you have no interest in my", "are really no right to judge other people's question as", "people's question as no question is stupid. If you have", "conflict with mine, just go away please? I have no", "on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right", "being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really", "put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no", "to judge other people's question as no question is stupid.", "really no right to judge other people's question as no", "stupid. If you have no interest in my question or", "opinion conflict with mine, just go away please? I have", "have no interest in my question or opinion conflict with", "away please? I have no idea why ppl like bad" ]
[ "and is a controlled substance, so using it without the", "am unsure about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For", "site move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish", "the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs", "Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known in the", "its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug", "and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the", "than for a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil", "US, modafinil is available by prescription only and is a", "see this site move in that direction. If any SE", "specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available by", "However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes", "the supervision of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL).", "rather than for a specific medical condition. In the US,", "seems to ask about using it in what we might", "a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve", "using it without the supervision of a physician would probably", "so using it without the supervision of a physician would", "is better known in the US by its brand name,", "appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us", "potential legal issues, that would be welcome as well. Thoughts?", "by its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\"", "on potential legal issues, that would be welcome as well.", "better known in the US by its brand name, Provigil,", "in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh", "Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for", "it in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role,", "the US, modafinil is available by prescription only and is", "available by prescription only and is a controlled substance, so", "The question seems to ask about using it in what", "would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history", "long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their", "medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available by prescription", "informs us that modafinil is better known in the US", "psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions about", "of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is", "the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems to", "about using it in what we might call a \"performance", "is available by prescription only and is a controlled substance,", "For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known", "role, rather than for a specific medical condition. In the", "a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would", "a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of", "without the supervision of a physician would probably be illegal", "a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available", "would rather not see this site move in that direction.", "approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question", "treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask", "wish to weigh in on potential legal issues, that would", "weigh in on potential legal issues, that would be welcome", "me less comfortable. I would rather not see this site", "If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential", "not see this site move in that direction. If any", "us that modafinil is better known in the US by", "academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably", "their work, and arguably questions about drug use in academia", "arguably questions about drug use in academia are on-topic. However,", "is a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to", "to improve their work, and arguably questions about drug use", "enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical condition. In", "promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of various sleep", "it without the supervision of a physician would probably be", "prescription only and is a controlled substance, so using it", "a controlled substance, so using it without the supervision of", "questions about drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the", "In the US, modafinil is available by prescription only and", "supervision of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There", "\"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical condition.", "only and is a controlled substance, so using it without", "use in academia are on-topic. However, the current question has", "US by its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance", "are on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor", "I would rather not see this site move in that", "by prescription only and is a controlled substance, so using", "flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would rather not", "and arguably questions about drug use in academia are on-topic.", "background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known in", "move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to", "to weigh in on potential legal issues, that would be", "There is a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs", "substance, so using it without the supervision of a physician", "a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical", "less comfortable. I would rather not see this site move", "rather not see this site move in that direction. If", "which makes me less comfortable. I would rather not see", "on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which", "drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the current question", "has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I", "a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a", "makes me less comfortable. I would rather not see this", "brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently", "question seems to ask about using it in what we", "I am unsure about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>.", "history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work,", "illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of academics using", "in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather", "what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than", "of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that", "\"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of various", "question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable.", "probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of", "name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved", "of various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about", "direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on", "for a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is", "academia are on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\"", "known in the US by its brand name, Provigil, and", "current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less", "drug currently approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders.", "disorders. The question seems to ask about using it in", "physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long", "question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is", "to ask about using it in what we might call", "the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better", "about drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the current", "moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal issues, that", "modafinil is available by prescription only and is a controlled", "is a controlled substance, so using it without the supervision", "using it in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\"", "for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems", "we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for", "sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about using it", "modafinil is better known in the US by its brand", "currently approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The", "SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal issues,", "is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment", "condition. In the US, modafinil is available by prescription only", "in academia are on-topic. However, the current question has a", "the US by its brand name, Provigil, and is a", "ask about using it in what we might call a", "in on potential legal issues, that would be welcome as", "comfortable. I would rather not see this site move in", "this site move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins", "work, and arguably questions about drug use in academia are", "controlled substance, so using it without the supervision of a", "in the US by its brand name, Provigil, and is", "any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal", "various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about using", "using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions", "about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia", "that modafinil is better known in the US by its", "be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of academics", "drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions about drug", "the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me", "unsure about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background,", "\"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would rather", "call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific", "that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in", "might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a", "(IANAL). There is a long history of academics using psychoactive", "improve their work, and arguably questions about drug use in", "of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and" ]
[ "to ignore these questions in the future. And maybe that's", "to heart at all: one piece of evidence is that", "It's not at all clear to me that the answers", "(as far as possible) to answer the question as a", "future. And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering", "And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether", "apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication that they're", "fairness each question by itself does merit attention. The problem", "the same general topic) In each case, the community has", "of evidence is that not one of the questions has", "as possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone situation,", "the questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more", "series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of", "questions also doesn't appear to help very much. Of course", "answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult for me", "in the future. And maybe that's the right answer. But", "solution is for me to ignore these questions in the", "stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question by itself", "picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list", "Of course the easiest solution is for me to ignore", "questions knowing the history of this user's questions. The tone", "this user's questions are on the same general topic) In", "on the numerous sound bits of advice the community is", "the easiest solution is for me to ignore these questions", "all of this user's questions are on the same general", "whether it's worth encouraging this user to try and dig", "here, it might be easier just go to the user", "becoming more and more difficult for me to answer yet", "dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it might", "problem here is the sequence. It's not at all clear", "the sequence. It's not at all clear to me that", "ignore these questions in the future. And maybe that's the", "indication that they're trying to act on the numerous sound", "the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging", "because in all fairness each question by itself does merit", "situation, because in all fairness each question by itself does", "of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a", "least show some indication that they're trying to act on", "The problem here is the sequence. It's not at all", "clear to me that the answers are being taken to", "answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user", "sound bits of advice the community is dishing out ?", "the history of this user's questions. The tone in the", "a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than", "all: one piece of evidence is that not one of", "questions in the future. And maybe that's the right answer.", "dysfunction, or at least show some indication that they're trying", "from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional", "taken to heart at all: one piece of evidence is", "is for me to ignore these questions in the future.", "me to ignore these questions in the future. And maybe", "are being taken to heart at all: one piece of", "more difficult for me to answer yet another of these", "the questions also doesn't appear to help very much. Of", "they're trying to act on the numerous sound bits of", "as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question", "course the easiest solution is for me to ignore these", "attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's not at", "these questions in the future. And maybe that's the right", "difficult for me to answer yet another of these questions", "knowing the history of this user's questions. The tone in", "might be easier just go to the user page: all", "and more difficult for me to answer yet another of", "history of this user's questions. The tone in the questions", "doesn't appear to help very much. Of course the easiest", "being taken to heart at all: one piece of evidence", "relationship (Rather than list them here, it might be easier", "for me to ignore these questions in the future. And", "in all fairness each question by itself does merit attention.", "user's questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't appear", "easiest solution is for me to ignore these questions in", "a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture", "by itself does merit attention. The problem here is the", "one piece of evidence is that not one of the", "to me that the answers are being taken to heart", "help very much. Of course the easiest solution is for", "easier just go to the user page: all of this", "does merit attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's", "merit attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's not", "maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's", "that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth", "right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this", "case, the community has tried (as far as possible) to", "heart at all: one piece of evidence is that not", "possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because", "is the sequence. It's not at all clear to me", "to help very much. Of course the easiest solution is", "it might be easier just go to the user page:", "me to answer yet another of these questions knowing the", "But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to", "not one of the questions has an accepted answer. It's", "also doesn't appear to help very much. Of course the", "far as possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone", "not at all clear to me that the answers are", "to try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or", "yet another of these questions knowing the history of this", "on the same general topic) In each case, the community", "much. Of course the easiest solution is for me to", "answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because in all", "(Rather than list them here, it might be easier just", "questions are on the same general topic) In each case,", "questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't appear to", "all fairness each question by itself does merit attention. The", "for me to answer yet another of these questions knowing", "each question by itself does merit attention. The problem here", "worth encouraging this user to try and dig deeper into", "this user's questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't", "show some indication that they're trying to act on the", "these questions knowing the history of this user's questions. The", "to answer yet another of these questions knowing the history", "question as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each", "completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it", "[user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee", "me that the answers are being taken to heart at", "than list them here, it might be easier just go", "now seen a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint", "that not one of the questions has an accepted answer.", "be easier just go to the user page: all of", "to act on the numerous sound bits of advice the", "sequence. It's not at all clear to me that the", "just go to the user page: all of this user's", "user page: all of this user's questions are on the", "questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and", "the user page: all of this user's questions are on", "community has tried (as far as possible) to answer the", "deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some", "are on the same general topic) In each case, the", "general topic) In each case, the community has tried (as", "another of these questions knowing the history of this user's", "all clear to me that the answers are being taken", "at all clear to me that the answers are being", "appear to help very much. Of course the easiest solution", "numerous sound bits of advice the community is dishing out", "to the user page: all of this user's questions are", "that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship", "the future. And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm", "this user to try and dig deeper into the apparent", "has tried (as far as possible) to answer the question", "it's worth encouraging this user to try and dig deeper", "one of the questions has an accepted answer. It's also", "encouraging this user to try and dig deeper into the", "It's also becoming more and more difficult for me to", "of this user's questions. The tone in the questions also", "the numerous sound bits of advice the community is dishing", "dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show", "also becoming more and more difficult for me to answer", "seen a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a", "I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to try", "In each case, the community has tried (as far as", "and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least", "in the questions also doesn't appear to help very much.", "of this user's questions are on the same general topic)", "act on the numerous sound bits of advice the community", "piece of evidence is that not one of the questions", "them here, it might be easier just go to the", "or at least show some indication that they're trying to", "go to the user page: all of this user's questions", "each case, the community has tried (as far as possible)", "wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to try and", "the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication that", "that the answers are being taken to heart at all:", "of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them", "of these questions knowing the history of this user's questions.", "questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely", "trying to act on the numerous sound bits of advice", "evidence is that not one of the questions has an", "to answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because in", "advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it might be", "an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult", "answer yet another of these questions knowing the history of", "list them here, it might be easier just go to", "the community has tried (as far as possible) to answer", "a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question by", "of the questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming", "the answers are being taken to heart at all: one", "very much. Of course the easiest solution is for me", "at least show some indication that they're trying to act", "more and more difficult for me to answer yet another", "itself does merit attention. The problem here is the sequence.", "answers are being taken to heart at all: one piece", "here is the sequence. It's not at all clear to", "tone in the questions also doesn't appear to help very", "at all: one piece of evidence is that not one", "tried (as far as possible) to answer the question as", "try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at", "that they're trying to act on the numerous sound bits", "paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather", "topic) In each case, the community has tried (as far", "I've now seen a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that", "the question as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness", "a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here,", "accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult for", "question by itself does merit attention. The problem here is", "user's questions are on the same general topic) In each", "user to try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction,", "page: all of this user's questions are on the same", "same general topic) In each case, the community has tried", "has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more", "some indication that they're trying to act on the numerous", "into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication", "The tone in the questions also doesn't appear to help", "is that not one of the questions has an accepted" ]
[ "a question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While", "should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent", "but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual", "be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and", "relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not", "question at first does seem too broad, it also strikes", "also strikes me as exactly the kind of question that", "a question at first does seem too broad, it also", "that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very", "seem too broad, it also strikes me as exactly the", "\"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question,", "crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a single all-encompassing answer.", "a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant", "and relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution,", "it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing", "While such a question at first does seem too broad,", "strikes me as exactly the kind of question that should", "asked a question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution).", "a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a single all-encompassing", "broad, it also strikes me as exactly the kind of", "too broad, it also strikes me as exactly the kind", "has asked a question on [advice for starting a research", "such a question at first does seem too broad, it", "exactly the kind of question that should be a \"community", "me as exactly the kind of question that should be", "of question that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's", "[advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question", "the kind of question that should be a \"community wiki\"", "be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a single", "at first does seem too broad, it also strikes me", "research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does seem", "very pertinent and relevant question, but it should be a", "it also strikes me as exactly the kind of question", "starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first", "should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a", "group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does seem too", "as exactly the kind of question that should be a", "kind of question that should be a \"community wiki\" question.", "pertinent and relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced", "Layla has asked a question on [advice for starting a", "question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such", "for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at", "on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a", "does seem too broad, it also strikes me as exactly", "first does seem too broad, it also strikes me as", "a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does", "wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but", "question that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a", "question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an", "a very pertinent and relevant question, but it should be", "question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but it", "It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but it should" ]
[ "time), and still not getting it right. Graduate students need", "this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a", "is touched by it, no matter whether she is in", "and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is", "There is need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday", "the wrong things. Professors need to know it, so they", "mean it isn't interesting for the people who ask it", "have an understanding of what proper research looks like, whether", "I am in a downward spiral of doing something, getting", "epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different", "The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors who", "they do the wrong things. Professors need to know it,", "academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit", "by it, no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular", "in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research without", "just like in real life, the university is the home", "[I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several", "to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just", "for projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating", "knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried doing", "is done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff", "with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they", "community can only gain from allowing it. --- This post", "can only gain from allowing it. --- This post was", "affected by it. Academics are also currently the only people", "So people in academia need to know how research is", "it off-topic. I don't know why they think so. Butif", "type of question. I would find it very sad if", "this type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with", "to know it, so they can explain to their grad", "seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because", "to find the thing which is right. There is need", "find it very sad if it decides to reject it,", "would find it very sad if it decides to reject", "this type of question. I would find it very sad", "Just because nobody before has thought of asking this kind", "accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part", "body of theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting", "science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge is like", "I know many academics who are willing to do research", "allowing it. --- This post was prompted by the fact", "choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis", "in one topic answer the questions of the people starting", "the community can only gain from allowing it. --- This", "article to publish and which to reject, by applying for", "because \"this is not the kind of question we are", "thought of asking this kind of question doesn't mean it", "of science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs.", "around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody", "the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place", "a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in", "by evaluating their grad students' work, they all have an", "this should be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange.", "who answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I would", "people starting out in their area, in order to make", "other. It is up to the community to decide whether", "type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in", "of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge,", "in academia need to know how research is done. And", "a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my", "which to reject, by applying for grants for projects which", "research is as least as important as teaching. (In fact", "a university employee's life. But research is as least as", "academics are the experts on this type of knowledge, and", "Therefore, I think this should be part of the on-topic", "is not just navigating university politics. It is also about", "much in need of it, in order to become better", "no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or", "right place for it, and the community can only gain", "of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor", "stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a body of", "none who would like to do teaching without research, so", "their area, in order to make this type of knowledge", "in academia is not just navigating university politics. It is", "Working in academia is not just navigating university politics. It", "as important as teaching. (In fact I know many academics", "fact that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and", "something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that", "are willing to do research without teaching, and none who", "it (less motivated this time), and still not getting it", "to know how research is done. And I don't mean", "psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research without this", "that it is not the right thing, then trying to", "But generations of researchers have created a body of theory", "knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors", "starting out in their area, in order to make this", "who would like to do teaching without research, so maybe", "we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be", "conducting research and teaching one's field to students. Academia already", "know it, because I've tried doing research that way for", "analysis in a given experiment. This can be asked on", "become better academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects", "reject this type of question. I would find it very", "so. Butif it is just because \"this is not the", "only people who have that knowledge. The theorists of science", "site would be its natural home, just like in real", "barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of asking this", "who are willing to do research without teaching, and none", "this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members who", "order to become better academics. I think that this situation", "life. But research is as least as important as teaching.", "asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a", "is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it, no", "community members who found it off-topic. I don't know why", "the last four years and wondered why I am in", "Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going", "questions of the people starting out in their area, in", "members who found it off-topic. I don't know why they", "research without this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits", "so they can explain to their grad students why the", "to make this type of knowledge available to everyone who", "is suited, and not any other. It is up to", "it. --- This post was prompted by the fact that", "looks like, whether on an explicit or on an intuitive", "scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who define daily", "accept or reject this type of question. I would find", "knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in need of", "is up to the community to decide whether it wants", "this is the community to which it is suited, and", "asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions", "trying to correct it (less motivated this time), and still", "it clear in my argument above why this is the", "is the right place for it, and the community can", "I think this should be part of the on-topic areas", "of asking this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't", "of what proper research looks like, whether on an explicit", "site which is better suited, and I think I made", "scientist's work is touched by it, no matter whether she", "is right. There is need for this knowledge within academia.", "This post was prompted by the fact that [I asked", "This covers the teaching part of a university employee's life.", "to reject, by applying for grants for projects which are", "would also like to note that they couldn't think of", "explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers", "to their grad students why the wrong thing they are", "everyday worklife of people within academia is affected by it.", "principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they all have", "understanding of what proper research looks like, whether on an", "I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a", "perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent;", "law. I know it, because I've tried doing research that", "by applying for grants for projects which are compliant with", "unexperienced ones are very much in need of it, in", "in a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from", "think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange", "by the fact that [I asked a question on this", "asking this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting", "maybe it is even considered more important by academics?). So", "whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or material science.", "a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched", "already has an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university", "it is even considered more important by academics?). So people", "hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because", "publish and which to reject, by applying for grants for", "found it off-topic. I don't know why they think so.", "--- This post was prompted by the fact that [I", "about conducting research and teaching one's field to students. Academia", "know it, so they can explain to their grad students", "professors who guide us, who define daily what good science", "evaluating their grad students' work, they all have an understanding", "molecular biology or material science. Doing research without this kind", "done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of", "a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of asking", "teaching, and none who would like to do teaching without", "kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's", "can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have", "wondered why I am in a downward spiral of doing", "people who have that knowledge. The theorists of science are", "is not the kind of question we are accustomed to", "of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching", "the right thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated", "reject, by applying for grants for projects which are compliant", "of researchers have created a body of theory of science", "whether it wants to accept or reject this type of", "on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on", "of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from", "is in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research", "the ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest too).", "decide whether it wants to accept or reject this type", "and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions", "sad if it decides to reject it, because this site", "grants for projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by", "for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people", "and got several reactions from community members who found it", "to accept or reject this type of question. I would", "like to do teaching without research, so maybe it is", "make this type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles", "and teaching one's field to students. Academia already has an", "knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming better in", "he or she is doing. Therefore, I think this should", "and the community can only gain from allowing it. ---", "willing to do research without teaching, and none who would", "are very much in need of it, in order to", "up to the community to decide whether it wants to", "it isn't interesting for the people who ask it and", "covers the teaching part of a university employee's life. But", "this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing", "feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that it is", "ones are very much in need of it, in order", "several reactions from community members who found it off-topic. I", "better in what he or she is doing. Therefore, I", "by it. Academics are also currently the only people who", "they couldn't think of a site which is better suited,", "which it is suited, and not any other. It is", "or material science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge", "researchers have created a body of theory of science and", "academia need to know how research is done. And I", "I think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of", "experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are", "to know it, else they do the wrong things. Professors", "answer the questions of the people starting out in their", "of science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us,", "is better suited, and I think I made it clear", "of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law.", "it right. Graduate students need to know it, else they", "and which to reject, by applying for grants for projects", "is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know", "on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very", "the spirit of StackExchange as a place where the experts", "by deciding which article to publish and which to reject,", "any other. It is up to the community to decide", "post was prompted by the fact that [I asked a", "if it decides to reject it, because this site would", "years and wondered why I am in a downward spiral", "like to note that they couldn't think of a site", "into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic", "the only people who have that knowledge. The theorists of", "with becoming better in what he or she is doing.", "daily what good science is by deciding which article to", "made it clear in my argument above why this is", "should be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It", "of a university employee's life. But research is as least", "reject it, because this site would be its natural home,", "wants to accept or reject this type of question. I", "she is doing. Therefore, I think this should be part", "know many academics who are willing to do research without", "different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which", "got several reactions from community members who found it off-topic.", "people who ask it and the ones who answer. (And", "real life, the university is the home of scientific theory.", "teaching one's field to students. Academia already has an explicit", "themselves. The professors who guide us, who define daily what", "just because \"this is not the kind of question we", "academics?). So people in academia need to know how research", "good science is by deciding which article to publish and", "on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a", "least as important as teaching. (In fact I know many", "and I think I made it clear in my argument", "factor analysis in a given experiment. This can be asked", "reviwers that it is not the right thing, then trying", "is doing. Therefore, I think this should be part of", "experts in one topic answer the questions of the people", "as a place where the experts in one topic answer", "downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor", "wrong, and how to find the thing which is right.", "is need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife", "suited, and I think I made it clear in my", "know it, else they do the wrong things. Professors need", "do teaching without research, so maybe it is even considered", "mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or", "think so. Butif it is just because \"this is not", "stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the", "shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought", "varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a", "need to know how research is done. And I don't", "last four years and wondered why I am in a", "thing which is right. There is need for this knowledge", "to the community to decide whether it wants to accept", "of question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this", "academia is affected by it. Academics are also currently the", "are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a", "or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts", "and unexperienced ones are very much in need of it,", "in what he or she is doing. Therefore, I think", "has an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\".", "the right place for it, and the community can only", "the people who ask it and the ones who answer.", "which article to publish and which to reject, by applying", "why this is the community to which it is suited,", "of it, in order to become better academics. I think", "the thing which is right. There is need for this", "that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got", "proper research looks like, whether on an explicit or on", "which is better suited, and I think I made it", "be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created", "going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a", "who guide us, who define daily what good science is", "to decide whether it wants to accept or reject this", "one topic answer the questions of the people starting out", "of a site which is better suited, and I think", "which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it,", "else they do the wrong things. Professors need to know", "is by deciding which article to publish and which to", "without teaching, and none who would like to do teaching", "as least as important as teaching. (In fact I know", "doing. Therefore, I think this should be part of the", "to everyone who struggles with becoming better in what he", "research without teaching, and none who would like to do", "and methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent; every", "very sad if it decides to reject it, because this", "is wrong, and how to find the thing which is", "for the people who ask it and the ones who", "from allowing it. --- This post was prompted by the", "who found it off-topic. I don't know why they think", "projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their", "I would also like to note that they couldn't think", "is just because \"this is not the kind of question", "on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for", "am in a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback", "or from reviwers that it is not the right thing,", "touched by it, no matter whether she is in psychology,", "right. There is need for this knowledge within academia. The", "students. Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting questions", "who define daily what good science is by deciding which", "matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or material", "better academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects the", "This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers", "science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and", "more important by academics?). So people in academia need to", "tried doing research that way for the last four years", "The everyday worklife of people within academia is affected by", "also currently the only people who have that knowledge. The", "they are doing is wrong, and how to find the", "on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a body", "every scientist's work is touched by it, no matter whether", "university employee's life. But research is as least as important", "science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological", "politics. It is also about conducting research and teaching one's", "not any other. It is up to the community to", "teaching part of a university employee's life. But research is", "people in academia need to know how research is done.", "teaching without research, so maybe it is even considered more", "to publish and which to reject, by applying for grants", "of the people starting out in their area, in order", "without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried", "do the wrong things. Professors need to know it, so", "the experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones", "the factor analysis in a given experiment. This can be", "methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's", "grad students' work, they all have an understanding of what", "perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place where", "know why they think so. Butif it is just because", "Professors need to know it, so they can explain to", "it and the ones who answer. (And several people expressed", "question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't", "considered more important by academics?). So people in academia need", "a body of theory of science and philosophy of science.", "level. Experienced academics are the experts on this type of", "can explain to their grad students why the wrong thing", "knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia", "from my supervisor or from reviwers that it is not", "theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide", "my argument above why this is the community to which", "is not the right thing, then trying to correct it", "right thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated this", "why they think so. Butif it is just because \"this", "clear in my argument above why this is the community", "an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This", "wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and how to", "just navigating university politics. It is also about conducting research", "it is just because \"this is not the kind of", "off-topic. I don't know why they think so. Butif it", "philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of", "this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much", "is even considered more important by academics?). So people in", "or reject this type of question. I would find it", "explain to their grad students why the wrong thing they", "this site would be its natural home, just like in", "not the right thing, then trying to correct it (less", "expressed interest too). I would also like to note that", "it wants to accept or reject this type of question.", "suited, and not any other. It is up to the", "for the factor analysis in a given experiment. This can", "grad students why the wrong thing they are doing is", "are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students'", "of StackExchange as a place where the experts in one", "would be its natural home, just like in real life,", "and how to find the thing which is right. There", "important as teaching. (In fact I know many academics who", "people within academia is affected by it. Academics are also", "applying for grants for projects which are compliant with scientific", "is affected by it. Academics are also currently the only", "that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The", "place where the experts in one topic answer the questions", "is as least as important as teaching. (In fact I", "research, so maybe it is even considered more important by", "also like to note that they couldn't think of a", "everyone who struggles with becoming better in what he or", "have created a body of theory of science and philosophy", "need to know it, so they can explain to their", "it, because this site would be its natural home, just", "question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community", "of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in need", "they all have an understanding of what proper research looks", "spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or", "not just navigating university politics. It is also about conducting", "this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for", "ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives", "what proper research looks like, whether on an explicit or", "how to find the thing which is right. There is", "what he or she is doing. Therefore, I think this", "a site which is better suited, and I think I", "it is suited, and not any other. It is up", "the kind of question we are accustomed to seeing around\",", "teaching. (In fact I know many academics who are willing", "to do research without teaching, and none who would like", "the community to decide whether it wants to accept or", "question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people who", "not getting it right. Graduate students need to know it,", "the questions of the people starting out in their area,", "This is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work", "ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I", "field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it, no matter", "Butif it is just because \"this is not the kind", "of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies.", "from reviwers that it is not the right thing, then", "an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on this", "that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as", "(In fact I know many academics who are willing to", "above why this is the community to which it is", "I don't know why they think so. Butif it is", "to note that they couldn't think of a site which", "need of it, in order to become better academics. I", "StackExchange as a place where the experts in one topic", "an understanding of what proper research looks like, whether on", "community to which it is suited, and not any other.", "on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members", "students' work, they all have an understanding of what proper", "why I am in a downward spiral of doing something,", "deciding which article to publish and which to reject, by", "topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members who found", "ask it and the ones who answer. (And several people", "better suited, and I think I made it clear in", "one's field to students. Academia already has an explicit policy", "question. I would find it very sad if it decides", "pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a university employee's", "Doing research without this kind of knowledge is like hacking", "very much in need of it, in order to become", "areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it,", "field to students. Academia already has an explicit policy of", "research and teaching one's field to students. Academia already has", "this time), and still not getting it right. Graduate students", "wrong things. Professors need to know it, so they can", "all have an understanding of what proper research looks like,", "knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I", "as teaching. (In fact I know many academics who are", "in real life, the university is the home of scientific", "Academics are also currently the only people who have that", "are also currently the only people who have that knowledge.", "order to make this type of knowledge available to everyone", "place for it, and the community can only gain from", "a given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But", "the fact that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence)", "and wondered why I am in a downward spiral of", "The professors who guide us, who define daily what good", "situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place", "this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people within", "spirit of StackExchange as a place where the experts in", "define daily what good science is by deciding which article", "because I've tried doing research that way for the last", "currently the only people who have that knowledge. The theorists", "biology or material science. Doing research without this kind of", "it, no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology", "explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the", "don't know why they think so. Butif it is just", "it, and the community can only gain from allowing it.", "for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it, and", "\"this is not the kind of question we are accustomed", "need to know it, else they do the wrong things.", "without this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without", "is the community to which it is suited, and not", "too). I would also like to note that they couldn't", "this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before has", "the people starting out in their area, in order to", "would like to do teaching without research, so maybe it", "important by academics?). So people in academia need to know", "out in their area, in order to make this type", "think I made it clear in my argument above why", "policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the", "science is by deciding which article to publish and which", "even considered more important by academics?). So people in academia", "in a given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange.", "note that they couldn't think of a site which is", "doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers", "nobody before has thought of asking this kind of question", "in my argument above why this is the community to", "employee's life. But research is as least as important as", "topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by", "it, in order to become better academics. I think that", "gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for", "circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've", "isn't interesting for the people who ask it and the", "\"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a university", "from community members who found it off-topic. I don't know", "was prompted by the fact that [I asked a question", "of question. I would find it very sad if it", "the experts in one topic answer the questions of the", "worklife of people within academia is affected by it. Academics", "for the last four years and wondered why I am", "type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming", "vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical", "I've tried doing research that way for the last four", "the community to which it is suited, and not any", "so maybe it is even considered more important by academics?).", "And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing", "university politics. It is also about conducting research and teaching", "is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is", "like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it,", "be a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of", "then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before", "it decides to reject it, because this site would be", "which is right. There is need for this knowledge within", "have that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves.", "It is up to the community to decide whether it", "Experienced academics are the experts on this type of knowledge,", "But research is as least as important as teaching. (In", "within academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia is", "couldn't think of a site which is better suited, and", "with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into", "my supervisor or from reviwers that it is not the", "motivated this time), and still not getting it right. Graduate", "in order to make this type of knowledge available to", "has thought of asking this kind of question doesn't mean", "thing they are doing is wrong, and how to find", "four years and wondered why I am in a downward", "things. Professors need to know it, so they can explain", "students need to know it, else they do the wrong", "many academics who are willing to do research without teaching,", "decides to reject it, because this site would be its", "without research, so maybe it is even considered more important", "I would find it very sad if it decides to", "academics who are willing to do research without teaching, and", "by academics?). So people in academia need to know how", "that they couldn't think of a site which is better", "doing is wrong, and how to find the thing which", "intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on this type", "interest too). I would also like to note that they", "their grad students' work, they all have an understanding of", "and none who would like to do teaching without research,", "like, whether on an explicit or on an intuitive level.", "a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from", "it, else they do the wrong things. Professors need to", "then trying to correct it (less motivated this time), and", "to correct it (less motivated this time), and still not", "find the thing which is right. There is need for", "whether on an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced", "given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations", "thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated this time),", "the teaching part of a university employee's life. But research", "also about conducting research and teaching one's field to students.", "accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier.", "for it, and the community can only gain from allowing", "be its natural home, just like in real life, the", "not the kind of question we are accustomed to seeing", "is also about conducting research and teaching one's field to", "it is not the right thing, then trying to correct", "rotation for the factor analysis in a given experiment. This", "and still not getting it right. Graduate students need to", "kind of question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then", "several people expressed interest too). I would also like to", "to reject it, because this site would be its natural", "quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a given experiment.", "supervisor or from reviwers that it is not the right", "it, so they can explain to their grad students why", "available to everyone who struggles with becoming better in what", "reactions from community members who found it off-topic. I don't", "gain from allowing it. --- This post was prompted by", "I made it clear in my argument above why this", "in their area, in order to make this type of", "be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is", "Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it, and the", "or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a given", "(less motivated this time), and still not getting it right.", "way for the last four years and wondered why I", "experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of", "to which it is suited, and not any other. It", "know how research is done. And I don't mean the", "area, in order to make this type of knowledge available", "Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried doing research", "us, who define daily what good science is by deciding", "because this site would be its natural home, just like", "correct it (less motivated this time), and still not getting", "think this should be part of the on-topic areas for", "academia is not just navigating university politics. It is also", "right. Graduate students need to know it, else they do", "the wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and how", "it. Academics are also currently the only people who have", "to become better academics. I think that this situation perfectly", "Graduate students need to know it, else they do the", "it very sad if it decides to reject it, because", "doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people who ask", "doing research that way for the last four years and", "navigating university politics. It is also about conducting research and", "think of a site which is better suited, and I", "answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I would also", "science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who", "a place where the experts in one topic answer the", "for grants for projects which are compliant with scientific principles,", "or she is doing. Therefore, I think this should be", "compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work,", "of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right", "to do teaching without research, so maybe it is even", "do research without teaching, and none who would like to", "how research is done. And I don't mean the nitty", "an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are", "getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that it", "home, just like in real life, the university is the", "reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place where the", "why the wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and", "of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming better", "they can explain to their grad students why the wrong", "are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who define", "kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the", "the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax", "natural home, just like in real life, the university is", "research looks like, whether on an explicit or on an", "she is in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing", "becoming better in what he or she is doing. Therefore,", "only gain from allowing it. --- This post was prompted", "theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological", "it, because I've tried doing research that way for the", "who ask it and the ones who answer. (And several", "their grad students why the wrong thing they are doing", "and the ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest", "academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia is affected", "in need of it, in order to become better academics.", "research that way for the last four years and wondered", "It is the right place for it, and the community", "which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad", "topic answer the questions of the people starting out in", "need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of", "It is also about conducting research and teaching one's field", "part of a university employee's life. But research is as", "material science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge is", "guide us, who define daily what good science is by", "prompted by the fact that [I asked a question on", "of theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting with", "because nobody before has thought of asking this kind of", "theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which is", "part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the", "definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and", "work is touched by it, no matter whether she is", "students why the wrong thing they are doing is wrong,", "nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation", "of people within academia is affected by it. Academics are", "before has thought of asking this kind of question doesn't", "are the experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced", "in order to become better academics. I think that this", "who have that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists", "that way for the last four years and wondered why", "struggles with becoming better in what he or she is", "on an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics", "work, they all have an understanding of what proper research", "they think so. Butif it is just because \"this is", "where the experts in one topic answer the questions of", "interesting for the people who ask it and the ones", "questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of", "are doing is wrong, and how to find the thing", "still not getting it right. Graduate students need to know", "scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they all", "knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This", "generations of researchers have created a body of theory of", "its natural home, just like in real life, the university", "I know it, because I've tried doing research that way", "like in real life, the university is the home of", "research is done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty", "people expressed interest too). I would also like to note", "I think I made it clear in my argument above", "Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting questions on", "and not any other. It is up to the community", "created a body of theory of science and philosophy of", "getting it right. Graduate students need to know it, else", "who struggles with becoming better in what he or she", "community to decide whether it wants to accept or reject", "of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people", "within academia is affected by it. Academics are also currently", "(And several people expressed interest too). I would also like", "argument above why this is the community to which it", "to students. Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting", "what good science is by deciding which article to publish", "don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax", "fact I know many academics who are willing to do" ]
[ "rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for", "without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide a", "undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site These are", "close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available", "2. Click \"It should be closed for another reason\" 3.", "were, * cannot be generalized to apply to others in", "belongs on another SE site These are three very specific", "steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be", "has nothing to do with academia. The three options given", "shown to people with enough rep to vote to close,", "to me for the reason for this were, * cannot", "Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List", "the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an", "in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students ", "the Flag one (but I can't confirm this as I", "SE site These are three very specific reasons that do", "others in similar situations about problems facing undergraduate students", "superficially appear as a dupe (but is not a dupe),", "to apply to others in similar situations * about problems", "I can't confirm this as I can't vote to close", "close, which is why most people on Meta are unable", "I tried to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it", "* cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar", "I can't vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively,", "because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic", "However, I do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect", "for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the", "an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is", "\"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\" option. I", "See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without", "that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not", "\"Other\" option is only shown to people with enough rep", "post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click", "possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe", "to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without", "is very difficult to provide a helpful flag for an", "not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia),", "given to me for the reason for this were, ", "me for the reason for this were, cannot be", "in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one", "an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken:", "should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\"", "for this were, * cannot be generalized to apply to", "available to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate?", "people with enough rep to vote to close, which is", "vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one (but I", "do with academia. The three options given to me for", "why most people on Meta are unable to replicate :-)", "a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a fourth", "shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do", "specific reasons that do not cover a wide swathe of", "can't confirm this as I can't vote to close on", "flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact", "taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed", "\"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for another reason\"", "to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only", "as off-topic, because it has nothing to do with academia.", "a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to do", "to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing", "not a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\".", "do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\"", "not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is", "The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It", "to close, which is why most people on Meta are", "of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though", "is only shown to people with enough rep to vote", "academia. The three options given to me for the reason", "dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a fourth option", "very specific reasons that do not cover a wide swathe", "(but is not a dupe), shows a fourth option being", "see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown", "similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs", "4. See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons", "dialog, but not in the Flag one (but I can't", "only shown to people with enough rep to vote to", "cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations", "off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps", "* belongs on another SE site These are three very", "is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the", "to do with academia. The three options given to me", "fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see", "difficult to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post.", "because it has nothing to do with academia. The three", "* about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another", "three very specific reasons that do not cover a wide", "very difficult to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic", "with enough rep to vote to close, which is why", "cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which", "These are three very specific reasons that do not cover", "reason for this were, * cannot be generalized to apply", "a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not", "to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post. ---", "is only available to those with certain rep. Is this", "about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE", "effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with certain rep.", "is why most people on Meta are unable to replicate", "below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds", "those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide", "on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to", "as a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a", "3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below:", "certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option", "sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown", "Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with certain", "it is very difficult to provide a helpful flag for", "rep, it is very difficult to provide a helpful flag", "that do not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities.", "suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but", "The three options given to me for the reason for", "It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only", "are three very specific reasons that do not cover a", "for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps", "\"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List of", "situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on", "the \"Other\" option is only shown to people with enough", "closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See", "enough rep to vote to close, which is why most", "another SE site These are three very specific reasons that", "shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It", "vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide a helpful", "vote to close, which is why most people on Meta", "nothing to do with academia. The three options given to", "is not a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered:", "this were, * cannot be generalized to apply to others", "appear as a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows", "on another SE site These are three very specific reasons", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to do with", "a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may", "\"It should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic", "those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an", "dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I", "[This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe (but", "option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the", "as I can't vote to close on this site). Hence,", "reasons that do not cover a wide swathe of other", "but not in the Flag one (but I can't confirm", "do not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This", "Flag one (but I can't confirm this as I can't", "site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with", "helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The", "be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4.", "off-topic, because it has nothing to do with academia. The", "a helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments:", "tried to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has", "not in the Flag one (but I can't confirm this", "only available to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy", "(but I can't confirm this as I can't vote to", "the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in", "to people with enough rep to vote to close, which", "\"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very", "though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to people", "reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown", "being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\"", "Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those", "for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to", "be generalized to apply to others in similar situations ", "which may superficially appear as a dupe (but is not", "one (but I can't confirm this as I can't vote", "three options given to me for the reason for this", "apply to others in similar situations about problems facing", "without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\"", "option is only shown to people with enough rep to", "exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should", "1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for", "generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about", "flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to", "option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult", "I do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that", "--- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\"", "students * belongs on another SE site These are three", "comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click", "screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png)", "a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However,", "Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for another", "wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially", "the reason for this were, * cannot be generalized to", "this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without", "options given to me for the reason for this were,", "rep to vote to close, which is why most people", "Today I tried to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because", "may superficially appear as a dupe (but is not a", "reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the", "as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to", "facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site These", "vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is", "shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag", "offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\" option.", "this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those", "confirm this as I can't vote to close on this", "I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog,", "Click \"It should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click", "provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following", "with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\"", "this as I can't vote to close on this site).", "off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1.", "an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option", "to vote to close, which is why most people on", "can't vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\"", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe (but is", "\"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in", "site These are three very specific reasons that do not", "swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear", "discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close", "another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen", "with academia. The three options given to me for the", "\"Other\" is only available to those with certain rep. Is", "the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one (but", "deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep,", "perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to people with", "which is why most people on Meta are unable to", "for the reason for this were, * cannot be generalized", "\"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the", "in the Flag one (but I can't confirm this as", "other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a", "Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2.", "Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it", "option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close", "it has nothing to do with academia. The three options", "to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate", "of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as", "](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is", "![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as", "problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site" ]
[ "more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed as off-topic", "from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the", "by several, including myself, who believe academia to be focused", "is to help find the line between on- and off-topic.", "a clear statement that not all learning is on-topic. This", "off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia to be", "was closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe", "academia to be focused on universities and the like. While", "closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia", "undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement that not", "is a clear statement that not all learning is on-topic.", "and the like. While I can see the OP's argument,", "as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia to", "learning is on-topic. This question is to help find the", "we do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not", "studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with", "not all learning is on-topic. This question is to help", "In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/16969/2692), the OP believes that studying by MOOC", "the line between on- and off-topic. So, where does this", "can see the OP's argument, we do generally say that", "gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way.", "rather there is a clear statement that not all learning", "question is to help find the line between on- and", "between on- and off-topic. So, where does this question fall?", "to help find the line between on- and off-topic. So,", "on-topic since it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge", "do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that", "for undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement that", "there is a clear statement that not all learning is", "off-topic. So, where does this question fall? On- or off-topic?", "argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic.", "help find the line between on- and off-topic. So, where", "should be on-topic since it deals with the idea of", "way. However, the question was closed as off-topic by several,", "While I can see the OP's argument, we do generally", "a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed as", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/16969/2692), the OP believes that studying by MOOC should", "who believe academia to be focused on universities and the", "universities and the like. While I can see the OP's", "that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is", "I can see the OP's argument, we do generally say", "the like. While I can see the OP's argument, we", "the OP believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic", "in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed", "studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates", "including myself, who believe academia to be focused on universities", "believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it", "generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all", "knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However,", "line between on- and off-topic. So, where does this question", "clear statement that not all learning is on-topic. This question", "on-topic. This question is to help find the line between", "idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less", "say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC", "but rather there is a clear statement that not all", "the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a", "off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather", "OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies is", "question was closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who", "undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for", "all learning is on-topic. This question is to help find", "is on-topic. This question is to help find the line", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/16969/2692), the OP believes that studying by MOOC should be", "statement that not all learning is on-topic. This question is", "and off-topic. So, where does this question fall? On- or", "to be focused on universities and the like. While I", "the question was closed as off-topic by several, including myself,", "are for undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement", "MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is a clear", "several, including myself, who believe academia to be focused on", "like. While I can see the OP's argument, we do", "on universities and the like. While I can see the", "with the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in", "that not all learning is on-topic. This question is to", "OP believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since", "focused on universities and the like. While I can see", "see the OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate", "formal way. However, the question was closed as off-topic by", "all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is a", "find the line between on- and off-topic. So, where does", "MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with the idea", "is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but", "However, the question was closed as off-topic by several, including", "it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from a", "the OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies", "myself, who believe academia to be focused on universities and", "that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are", "that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals", "a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question", "on- and off-topic. So, where does this question fall? On-", "deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher", "Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there", "of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal", "be on-topic since it deals with the idea of gaining", "since it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from", "be focused on universities and the like. While I can", "by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with the", "This question is to help find the line between on-", "teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was", "believe academia to be focused on universities and the like." ]
[ "took place in the comments about a different academia-related topic.", "which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had", "Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member", "member answered, and then a separate discussion took place in", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a separate discussion", "flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053),", "topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately related to", "took issue with my removing the comments, as he had", "as he had put work into finding the answer. My", "I recently deleted a few comments (mods, you can see", "had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked", "removed the comments that weren't immediately related to the question.", "weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer took issue", "been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a", "comments, as he had put work into finding the answer.", "work into finding the answer. My question here is: did", "comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been", "deleted a few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments))", "recently deleted a few comments (mods, you can see them", "discussion took place in the comments about a different academia-related", "that weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer took", "to the question. The answerer took issue with my removing", "My question here is: did I act inappropriately in removing", "a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a separate", "the comments that weren't immediately related to the question. The", "then a separate discussion took place in the comments about", "a few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which", "a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't", "immediately related to the question. The answerer took issue with", "my removing the comments, as he had put work into", "in the comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed", "a community member answered, and then a separate discussion took", "issue with my removing the comments, as he had put", "the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered,", "question here is: did I act inappropriately in removing those", "question. The answerer took issue with my removing the comments,", "answerer took issue with my removing the comments, as he", "and then a separate discussion took place in the comments", "put work into finding the answer. My question here is:", "(mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged", "community member answered, and then a separate discussion took place", "comments that weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer", "separate discussion took place in the comments about a different", "OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and", "a separate discussion took place in the comments about a", "see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly,", "[asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a", "off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community", "[here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP", "different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately", "the question. The answerer took issue with my removing the", "you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as", "had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then", "the comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed the", "I removed the comments that weren't immediately related to the", "answered, and then a separate discussion took place in the", "comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments", "as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a", "he had put work into finding the answer. My question", "academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately related", "into finding the answer. My question here is: did I", "here is: did I act inappropriately in removing those comments?", "had put work into finding the answer. My question here", "them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the", "removing the comments, as he had put work into finding", "the comments, as he had put work into finding the", "answer. My question here is: did I act inappropriately in", "few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had", "about a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that", "with my removing the comments, as he had put work", "finding the answer. My question here is: did I act", "the answer. My question here is: did I act inappropriately", "can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic.", "related to the question. The answerer took issue with my", "The answerer took issue with my removing the comments, as", "place in the comments about a different academia-related topic. I" ]
[ "(I think that's the case) so, for example, the username", "of a question, should we delete and re-ask the question", "up but there is no link. I'm not sure if", "wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked by someone", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was", "the username shows up but there is no link. I'm", "me wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked by", "there is no link. I'm not sure if that user", "no link. I'm not sure if that user will get", "not sure if that user will get comments or answers.", "an A.SE account (I think that's the case) so, for", "the case) so, for example, the username shows up but", "this question was closed as a rant it made me", "so, for example, the username shows up but there is", "are the asker of a question, should we delete and", "will get comments or answers. I also wonder if that", "question so that it belongs to someone who can actually", "this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of", "which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed", "was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as", "question was closed as a rant it made me wonder", "a question, should we delete and re-ask the question so", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question", "asker of a question, should we delete and re-ask the", "All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the", "was asked by someone without an A.SE account (I think", "comments or answers. I also wonder if that user can", "can actually answer clarifying questions and who can accept answers?", "case) so, for example, the username shows up but there", "accept an answer. All of this begs the question, when", "A.SE account (I think that's the case) so, for example,", "if that user will get comments or answers. I also", "the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question,", "ever accept an answer. All of this begs the question,", "and re-ask the question so that it belongs to someone", "question, should we delete and re-ask the question so that", "answers. I also wonder if that user can (or would)", "would) ever accept an answer. All of this begs the", "Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a rant it", "someone without an A.SE account (I think that's the case)", "that's the case) so, for example, the username shows up", "question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should", "about migrated questions. This question was asked by someone without", "can (or would) ever accept an answer. All of this", "the asker of a question, should we delete and re-ask", "asked by someone without an A.SE account (I think that's", "non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should we delete", "of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker", "was closed as a rant it made me wonder about", "I was reading [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE.", "was reading [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although", "that user will get comments or answers. I also wonder", "think that's the case) so, for example, the username shows", "belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and", "from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a rant", "also wonder if that user can (or would) ever accept", "question was asked by someone without an A.SE account (I", "I'm not sure if that user will get comments or", "by someone without an A.SE account (I think that's the", "Although this question was closed as a rant it made", "migrated questions. This question was asked by someone without an", "link. I'm not sure if that user will get comments", "user will get comments or answers. I also wonder if", "user can (or would) ever accept an answer. All of", "closed as a rant it made me wonder about migrated", "wonder if that user can (or would) ever accept an", "an answer. All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users", "is no link. I'm not sure if that user will", "to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and who", "who can actually answer clarifying questions and who can accept", "without an A.SE account (I think that's the case) so,", "questions. This question was asked by someone without an A.SE", "if that user can (or would) ever accept an answer.", "it belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions", "migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a", "example, the username shows up but there is no link.", "This question was asked by someone without an A.SE account", "I also wonder if that user can (or would) ever", "account (I think that's the case) so, for example, the", "username shows up but there is no link. I'm not", "someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and who can", "sure if that user will get comments or answers. I", "it made me wonder about migrated questions. This question was", "get comments or answers. I also wonder if that user", "(or would) ever accept an answer. All of this begs", "the question so that it belongs to someone who can", "answer. All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are", "delete and re-ask the question so that it belongs to", "reading [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this", "that user can (or would) ever accept an answer. All", "shows up but there is no link. I'm not sure", "that it belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying", "rant it made me wonder about migrated questions. This question", "as a rant it made me wonder about migrated questions.", "we delete and re-ask the question so that it belongs", "for example, the username shows up but there is no", "but there is no link. I'm not sure if that", "when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should we", "made me wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked", "begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a", "so that it belongs to someone who can actually answer", "a rant it made me wonder about migrated questions. This", "or answers. I also wonder if that user can (or", "should we delete and re-ask the question so that it", "re-ask the question so that it belongs to someone who" ]
[ "to know whether other academics feel that there any cultural", "circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that", "Users of Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote", "interested to know whether other academics feel that there any", "you feel about the censorship question above and/or also this", "with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking", "high. More recently she -- assisted by my PhD student", "This comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally", "are treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and", "they were adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague", "academics don't like participating in a site which has such", "to what is largely volunteer work / networking on their", "because there is not enough involvement, so questions about what", "she -- assisted by my PhD student -- made an", "not a hypothetical question: this was the main tension in", "making inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted my", "\"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the SE people", "or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that", "I have made my views on this clear in this", "said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention", "on their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question:", "had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed", "site is in the \"beta phase\" because there is not", "unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same). Thus", "delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in", "there were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and", "the censorship question above and/or also this broader issue. I", "treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE,", "would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with their", "here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems to", "questions about what future course the site could take seem", "sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE", "very different from those sites. [Added: The original comment was", "deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine", "is similar to the SE platform but adapted to be", "part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was", "the information that I had been typing an answer while", "SE platform but adapted to be less gamified and rigid:", "this one included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate,", "intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on", "\"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are treated the", "the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the", "this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to", "was finally done only after many concessions from the SE", "is in some ways a credible threat to making inroads", "other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between the", "colleague of mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange", "deleted by a moderator. I have made my views on", "mild, and I think the SE model is in some", "Please let me know how you feel about the censorship", "two moderators found a statement of mine similar to the", "work / networking on their part. This is certainly not", "things which at the beginning they were adamant would not", "a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to", "site which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach", "adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this is the", "which content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective is", "course the site could take seem maximally on-point. In other", "that there were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules", "the site didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural", "what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information", "longterm participation in a site for which content -- specifically", "is more of a blanket one -- which is on-topic", "adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague of mine", "my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time", "their real name and academic affiliations (past or present), although", "site didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect", "form of academic censorship. I am very passionately against the", "follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work / networking", "words: maybe academics don't like participating in a site which", "rules and hoops to jump through, especially at the early", "When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they", "recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining", "other SE site, this one included.\" I believe this comment", "what is largely volunteer work / networking on their part.", "[Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is", "strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially", "censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was", "very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild,", "that this site is very different from those sites. [Added:", "highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer", "an independent site which is similar to the SE platform", "perspective is more of a blanket one -- which is", "other words: maybe academics don't like participating in a site", "and people who like and enforce the SE platform was", "from those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to", "to start a math-education stack exchange site. I told her", "make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested", "a little too high. More recently she -- assisted by", "in a site for which content -- specifically comments, although", "priori* inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That", "of a blanket one -- which is on-topic for the", "Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was", "in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the", "was deleted by a moderator. I have made my views", "recently she -- assisted by my PhD student -- made", "I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was", "was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed --", "wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm participation in", "I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is why", "know whether other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch", "they participate in the most troubling form of censorship. At", "/ networking on their part. This is certainly not a", "I am very interested to know whether other academics feel", "through, especially at the early stages. She tried it anyway,", "It included the information that I had been typing an", "and math.SE, the response was that this site is very", "am very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however", "Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was", "inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat it exactly.", "typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user", "thing happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were", "first started: in the end the SE people agreed to", "the end the SE people agreed to several things which", "-- assisted by my PhD student -- made an independent", "have longterm participation in a site for which content --", "the mainstream SE model and the goal of getting academics", "Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my", "site, this one included.\" I believe this comment to be", "a math-education stack exchange site. I told her that this", "in such a question and answer site. Please let me", "also warned her that there were a lot of strange-looking", "built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable", "to several things which at the beginning they were adamant", "to be inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat", "which is why I did not repeat it exactly. If", "opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It", "is on-topic for the site are being deleted. My feeling", "done only after many concessions from the SE developers, and", "She tried it anyway, and the site didn't make it", "somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to", "academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to", "the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after many", "specifically comments, although my own perspective is more of a", "to have longterm participation in a site for which content", "I wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm participation", "Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other SE site,", "in the end the SE people agreed to several things", "closure was appropriate. It included the information that I had", "moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that I", "and I think the SE model is in some ways", "-- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was", "2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning", "assisted by my PhD student -- made an independent site", "from the SE developers, and the whole thing happened at", "that comments are treated the way I want them on", "content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective is more", "included the information that I had been typing an answer", "that this is a mild form of academic censorship. I", "state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other SE", "not be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to", "is that this is a mild form of academic censorship.", "different but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added", "any other SE site, this one included.\" I believe this", "enforce the SE platform was a little too high. More", "to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after", "without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a", "am very interested to know whether other academics feel that", "deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to", "in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the", "appropriate. It included the information that I had been typing", "more of a blanket one -- which is on-topic for", "the SE model is in some ways a credible threat", "Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and", "us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially at the", "less severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A", "to be true, but also this site is in the", "independent site which is similar to the SE platform but", "was talking about was different but, in my opinion, less", "that I was unwilling to have longterm participation in a", "tension in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to", "idea but also warned her that there were a lot", "beginning they were adamant would not be possible. Also a", "\"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any", "or present), although that is certainly not required. Added: I", "student -- made an independent site which is similar to", "I was talking about was different but, in my opinion,", "to jump through, especially at the early stages. She tried", "I pointed out that comments are treated the way I", "is run far differently than any other SE site, this", "to a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator.", "At the present time I will take a break from", "answers from users who identify themselves with their real name", "moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion", "of getting academics involved in such a question and answer", "run far differently than any other SE site, this one", "this was the main tension in the decision of whether", "Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether other", "by a moderator. I have made my views on this", "some ways a credible threat to making inroads on this.", "this could be a good idea but also warned her", "early stages. She tried it anyway, and the site didn't", "moderator. I have made my views on this clear in", "moderators found a statement of mine similar to the above", "closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly", "have made my views on this clear in this question.", "networking on their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical", "that.] That seems to be true, but also this site", "and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from", "think the SE model is in some ways a credible", "someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems to be", "When I pointed out that comments are treated the way", "SE platform was a little too high. More recently she", "moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions", "approach to what is largely volunteer work / networking on", "such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is", "so questions about what future course the site could take", "/ follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work /", "comments which pertain to them, they participate in the most", "was unwilling to have longterm participation in a site for", "identify themselves with their real name and academic affiliations (past", "the whole thing happened at least a year after the", "believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is why I", "which is similar to the SE platform but adapted to", "site for which content -- specifically comments, although my own", "issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice", "with their real name and academic affiliations (past or present),", "time I will take a break from this site to", "one -- which is on-topic for the site are being", "made my views on this clear in this question. When", "is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak", "present), although that is certainly not required. Added: I remember", "comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was different", "nullified my actions on this site was deleted by a", "be inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat it", "also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users", "participation in a site for which content -- specifically comments,", "the beginning they were adamant would not be possible. Also", "comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently", "which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to", "answer site. Please let me know how you feel about", "now that I did once before raise the issue of", "my views on this clear in this question. When moderators", "there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and", "censorship question above and/or also this broader issue. I would", "More recently she -- assisted by my PhD student --", "interested math educators and people who like and enforce the", "Also a colleague of mine tried to start a math-education", "there is not enough involvement, so questions about what future", "involvement, so questions about what future course the site could", "feeling is that this is a mild form of academic", "The practice I was talking about was different but, in", "largely volunteer work / networking on their part. This is", "response was that this site is very different from those", "in a site which has such a highly gamified /", "hoops to jump through, especially at the early stages. She", "them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this", "their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this", "site is very different from those sites. [Added: The original", "SE developers, and the whole thing happened at least a", "SE model is in some ways a credible threat to", "rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very", "If it is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE", "the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two", "deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a", "experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori", "is not enough involvement, so questions about what future course", "math-education stack exchange site. I told her that this could", "who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found", "is why I did not repeat it exactly. If it", "math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone", "censorship. At the present time I will take a break", "a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the", "deleted. My feeling is that this is a mild form", "a break from this site to reflect on these issues.", "ways a credible threat to making inroads on this. Although", "mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment", "respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about", "the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the SE", "volunteer work / networking on their part. This is certainly", "on this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant", "form of censorship. At the present time I will take", "of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump through,", "I remember now that I did once before raise the", "a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely", "many concessions from the SE developers, and the whole thing", "getting academics involved in such a question and answer site.", "past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators", "I would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with", "this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments", "I will take a break from this site to reflect", "a site which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules", "academic affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly not", "year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end", "out that comments are treated the way I want them", "most troubling form of censorship. At the present time I", "being deleted. My feeling is that this is a mild", "people agreed to several things which at the beginning they", "made an independent site which is similar to the SE", "(to us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially at", "\"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments", "threat to making inroads on this. Although the moderator who", "different from those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice", "than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of", "this site was deleted by a moderator. I have made", "exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience built-up on", "the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so", "know how you feel about the censorship question above and/or", "was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than", "a site for which content -- specifically comments, although my", "were adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague of", "My feeling is that this is a mild form of", "the site are being deleted. My feeling is that this", "mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly", "which pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling", "start a math-education stack exchange site. I told her that", "on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here,", "for which content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective", "actions on this site was deleted by a moderator. I", "a colleague of mine tried to start a math-education stack", "tried to start a math-education stack exchange site. I told", "that is certainly not required. Added: I remember now that", "certainly not required. Added: I remember now that I did", "after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the", "let me know how you feel about the censorship question", "from users who identify themselves with their real name and", "the SE developers, and the whole thing happened at least", "academics involved in such a question and answer site. Please", "involved in such a question and answer site. Please let", "how you feel about the censorship question above and/or also", "my actions on this site was deleted by a moderator.", "I did not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously", "is very different from those sites. [Added: The original comment", "is in the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough", "meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm", "this is a mild form of academic censorship. I am", "censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment of academic", "about the censorship question above and/or also this broader issue.", "who like and enforce the SE platform was a little", "jump through, especially at the early stages. She tried it", "hypothetical question: this was the main tension in the decision", "Fellow Users of Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I", "opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014:", "a blanket one -- which is on-topic for the site", "question above and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate", "the SE people agreed to several things which at the", "-- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances", "to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally", "academic censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment of", "acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that was", "a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My", "feel about the censorship question above and/or also this broader", "That seems to be true, but also this site is", "intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow", "my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement", "and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am", "too high. More recently she -- assisted by my PhD", "and the site didn't make it past Area 51: the", "agreed to several things which at the beginning they were", "that this could be a good idea but also warned", "that I did once before raise the issue of censorship", "and the goal of getting academics involved in such a", "move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done", "affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly not required.", "to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed", "was a little too high. More recently she -- assisted", "take a break from this site to reflect on these", "and enforce the SE platform was a little too high.", "of Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that", "blanket one -- which is on-topic for the site are", "whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was", "pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling form", "on-topic for the site are being deleted. My feeling is", "site. Please let me know how you feel about the", "comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed", "why I did not repeat it exactly. If it is", "I was unwilling to have longterm participation in a site", "same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted", "the SE platform but adapted to be less gamified and", "is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow", "27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted without", "were first started: in the end the SE people agreed", "decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model.", "although my own perspective is more of a blanket one", "was the main tension in the decision of whether to", "by my PhD student -- made an independent site which", "by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly --", "site was deleted by a moderator. I have made my", "(another user had just said the same). Thus my comment", "not required. Added: I remember now that I did once", "own perspective is more of a blanket one -- which", "of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I", "time and nullified my actions on this site was deleted", "it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the", "of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\".", "in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November", "I am very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship,", "started: in the end the SE people agreed to several", "platform but adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this", "but also warned her that there were a lot of", "warned her that there were a lot of strange-looking (to", "stack exchange site. I told her that this could be", "also this site is in the \"beta phase\" because there", "present time I will take a break from this site", "found a statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\",", "my PhD student -- made an independent site which is", "like and enforce the SE platform was a little too", "don't like participating in a site which has such a", "will take a break from this site to reflect on", "future course the site could take seem maximally on-point. In", "concessions from the SE developers, and the whole thing happened", "had just said the same). Thus my comment about how", "is certainly not required. Added: I remember now that I", "censorship, however mild, and I think the SE model is", "encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I think the", "very interested to know whether other academics feel that there", "would not be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried", "and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are treated", "did not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended", "to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other", "and academic affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly", "are being deleted. My feeling is that this is a", "in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain", "a good idea but also warned her that there were", "unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly", "didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between", "should certainly speak to that.] That seems to be true,", "be a good idea but also warned her that there", "my time and nullified my actions on this site was", "seems to be true, but also this site is in", "model. This was finally done only after many concessions from", "at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started:", "raise the issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942).", "on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like participating in", "credible threat to making inroads on this. Although the moderator", "name and academic affiliations (past or present), although that is", "on this site was deleted by a moderator. I have", "of academic censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment", "very nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine similar", "-- specifically comments, although my own perspective is more of", "to the SE platform but adapted to be less gamified", "mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange site. I", "happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first", "[Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether", "me know how you feel about the censorship question above", "phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so questions about", "PhD student -- made an independent site which is similar", "This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the", "little too high. More recently she -- assisted by my", "good idea but also warned her that there were a", "in some ways a credible threat to making inroads on", "this site is in the \"beta phase\" because there is", "is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to", "to be less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics", "which is on-topic for the site are being deleted. My", "of mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange site.", "the most troubling form of censorship. At the present time", "site are being deleted. My feeling is that this is", "lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump", "tried it anyway, and the site didn't make it past", "just said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator", "required. Added: I remember now that I did once before", "math.SE, the response was that this site is very different", "moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate", "cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people who like", "mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only", "of academic censorship, however mild, and I think the SE", "I had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally", "against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I", "comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in", "\"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are", "mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When", "an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had", "site could take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe", "who identify themselves with their real name and academic affiliations", "but also this site is in the \"beta phase\" because", "it is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and", "did once before raise the issue of censorship with respect", "practice I was talking about was different but, in my", "several things which at the beginning they were adamant would", "remember now that I did once before raise the issue", "question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them,", "anyway, and the site didn't make it past Area 51:", "question and answer site. Please let me know how you", "and answer site. Please let me know how you feel", "pointed out that comments are treated the way I want", "is a mild form of academic censorship. I am very", "A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or", "and nullified my actions on this site was deleted by", "between interested math educators and people who like and enforce", "gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I", "to making inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted", "a statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\"", "the issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The", "question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment", "how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my", "I told her that this could be a good idea", "be less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching", "the present time I will take a break from this", "has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what", "what future course the site could take seem maximally on-point.", "severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment", "In other words: maybe academics don't like participating in a", "and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to have", "closed (another user had just said the same). Thus my", "a mild form of academic censorship. I am very passionately", "gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work", "-- made an independent site which is similar to the", "information that I had been typing an answer while it", "people who like and enforce the SE platform was a", "in the most troubling form of censorship. At the present", "mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the goal of", "was appropriate. It included the information that I had been", "way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response", "participating in a site which has such a highly gamified", "on this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized", "my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November 27,", "educators and people who like and enforce the SE platform", "be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to start", "it exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience built-up", "of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This", "of censorship. At the present time I will take a", "and the whole thing happened at least a year after", "possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to start a", "were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops", "[here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was different but,", "far differently than any other SE site, this one included.\"", "was that this site is very different from those sites.", "certainly speak to that.] That seems to be true, but", "enough involvement, so questions about what future course the site", "original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far", "maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like participating", "mainstream SE model and the goal of getting academics involved", "mild form of academic censorship. I am very passionately against", "moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators", "a hypothetical question: this was the main tension in the", "end the SE people agreed to several things which at", "of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This", "51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people", "SE model and the goal of getting academics involved in", "been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another", "comments are treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net", "an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate.", "seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like", "comments, although my own perspective is more of a blanket", "clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which", "this site is very different from those sites. [Added: The", "repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience", "the goal of getting academics involved in such a question", "those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state,", "\"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so questions", "this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users who", "academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream", "once before raise the issue of censorship with respect to", "disconnect between interested math educators and people who like and", "the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out", "included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is", "in the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement,", "this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested", "-- which is on-topic for the site are being deleted.", "exchange site. I told her that this could be a", "that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed", "talking about was different but, in my opinion, less severe", "and hoops to jump through, especially at the early stages.", "a question and answer site. Please let me know how", "I did once before raise the issue of censorship with", "on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently", "My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about", "was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by", "mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this site is", "comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and", "between the mainstream SE model and the goal of getting", "although that is certainly not required. Added: I remember now", "SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after many concessions", "question: this was the main tension in the decision of", "a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an", "about was different but, in my opinion, less severe than", "which at the beginning they were adamant would not be", "passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and", "Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I", "on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this site", "speak to that.] That seems to be true, but also", "developers, and the whole thing happened at least a year", "take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't", "than any other SE site, this one included.\" I believe", "user had just said the same). Thus my comment about", "real name and academic affiliations (past or present), although that", "themselves with their real name and academic affiliations (past or", "expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what", "apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine", "but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion. *Added on", "the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally", "wasted my time and nullified my actions on this site", "above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that", "before raise the issue of censorship with respect to comments", "this comment to be inaccurate, which is why I did", "be true, but also this site is in the \"beta", "is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the main", "seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is", "issue. I would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves", "any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the", "that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a", "to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was", "told her that this could be a good idea but", "comment to be inaccurate, which is why I did not", "at the beginning they were adamant would not be possible.", "appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with their real", "maybe academics don't like participating in a site which has", "about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified", "comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment.", "not enough involvement, so questions about what future course the", "only after many concessions from the SE developers, and the", "the SE platform was a little too high. More recently", "platform was a little too high. More recently she --", "at the early stages. She tried it anyway, and the", "main tension in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net", "one included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which", "for the site are being deleted. My feeling is that", "cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the goal", "academic censorship, however mild, and I think the SE model", "The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run", "finally done only after many concessions from the SE developers,", "whether other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between", "wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator", "like participating in a site which has such a highly", "November 27, 2014*: A comment of mine was recently deleted", "to that.] That seems to be true, but also this", "was different but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion.", "was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same).", "nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine similar to", "a credible threat to making inroads on this. Although the", "less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/).", "about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included", "that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model", "civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure", "site. I told her that this could be a good", "SE people agreed to several things which at the beginning", "her that there were a lot of strange-looking (to us)", "the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I think", "a moderator. I have made my views on this clear", "the main tension in the decision of whether to move", "inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment", "them, they participate in the most troubling form of censorship.", "such a question and answer site. Please let me know", "similar to the SE platform but adapted to be less", "could take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics", "could be a good idea but also warned her that", "model is in some ways a credible threat to making", "warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question", "her that this could be a good idea but also", "the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0", "that I had been typing an answer while it was", "the early stages. She tried it anyway, and the site", "to them, they participate in the most troubling form of", "especially at the early stages. She tried it anyway, and", "the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people who", "pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by a", "broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users who identify", "my own perspective is more of a blanket one --", "not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended that", "a priori* inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.]", "relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in the", "the response was that this site is very different from", "I think the SE model is in some ways a", "comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement of", "this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very", "however mild, and I think the SE model is in", "whole thing happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\"", "it anyway, and the site didn't make it past Area", "literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on this", "participate in the most troubling form of censorship. At the", "true, but also this site is in the \"beta phase\"", "Added: I remember now that I did once before raise", "certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the main tension", "above and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers", "while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said", "on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling", "similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I", "is largely volunteer work / networking on their part. This", "model and the goal of getting academics involved in such", "goal of getting academics involved in such a question and", "math educators and people who like and enforce the SE", "Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely,", "least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in", "it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math", "troubling form of censorship. At the present time I will", "about what future course the site could take seem maximally", "the site could take seem maximally on-point. In other words:", "feel that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE", "(past or present), although that is certainly not required. Added:", "was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was", "unwilling to have longterm participation in a site for which", "This was finally done only after many concessions from the", "answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just", "statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and", "inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems", "differently than any other SE site, this one included.\" I", "views on this clear in this question. When moderators delete", "Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether other academics", "SE site, this one included.\" I believe this comment to", "stages. She tried it anyway, and the site didn't make", "the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know", "after many concessions from the SE developers, and the whole", "but adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this is", "site which is similar to the SE platform but adapted", "want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that", "and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should", "users who identify themselves with their real name and academic" ]
[ "that > > You should only ask practical, answerable questions", "I read a few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often,", "> > > Is it appropriate to ask questions here", "a few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write", "blog, to find out what this community has to say?", "academic.SE, and I think that this community would have useful", "help center says that > > You should only ask", "author of the blog to post a question they have", "you face. > > > Is it appropriate to ask", "comments. These are often very interesting questions that are on-topic", "only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that", "that I'd like to hear. However, the help center says", "the help center says that > > You should only", "Is it appropriate to ask questions here that I've read", "community would have useful answers that I'd like to hear.", "However, the help center says that > > You should", "have useful answers that I'd like to hear. However, the", "on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this community would", "face. > > > Is it appropriate to ask questions", "about academia. Then the readers of the blog answer and", "blog to post a question they have about academia. Then", "on a blog, to find out what this community has", "they have about academia. Then the readers of the blog", "often very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and", "to hear. However, the help center says that > >", "based on actual problems that you face. > > >", "answer and discuss in the comments. These are often very", "read on a blog, to find out what this community", "asking the author of the blog to post a question", "These are often very interesting questions that are on-topic for", "on actual problems that you face. > > > Is", "> Is it appropriate to ask questions here that I've", "questions here that I've read on a blog, to find", "few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in", "readers write in asking the author of the blog to", "too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the", "question they have about academia. Then the readers of the", "discuss in the comments. These are often very interesting questions", "I'd like to hear. However, the help center says that", "questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that", "readers of the blog answer and discuss in the comments.", "a blog, to find out what this community has to", "should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems", "would have useful answers that I'd like to hear. However,", "it appropriate to ask questions here that I've read on", "Then the readers of the blog answer and discuss in", "are often very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE,", "ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you", "are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this community", "to ask questions here that I've read on a blog,", "I think that this community would have useful answers that", "problems that you face. > > > Is it appropriate", "academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author of", "like to hear. However, the help center says that >", "a question they have about academia. Then the readers of", "the readers of the blog answer and discuss in the", "the author of the blog to post a question they", "answerable questions based on actual problems that you face. >", "You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual", "that I've read on a blog, to find out what", "here that I've read on a blog, to find out", "think that this community would have useful answers that I'd", "the comments. These are often very interesting questions that are", "blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author of the", "write in asking the author of the blog to post", "interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think", "the blog to post a question they have about academia.", "that this community would have useful answers that I'd like", "> > You should only ask practical, answerable questions based", "actual problems that you face. > > > Is it", "for academic.SE, and I think that this community would have", "appropriate to ask questions here that I've read on a", "questions based on actual problems that you face. > >", "I've read on a blog, to find out what this", "Often, readers write in asking the author of the blog", "(OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking", "that you face. > > > Is it appropriate to", "practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you face.", "> You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on", "says that > > You should only ask practical, answerable", "in asking the author of the blog to post a", "post a question they have about academia. Then the readers", "to post a question they have about academia. Then the", "> > Is it appropriate to ask questions here that", "answers that I'd like to hear. However, the help center", "have about academia. Then the readers of the blog answer", "and discuss in the comments. These are often very interesting", "read a few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers", "that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this", "in the comments. These are often very interesting questions that", "center says that > > You should only ask practical,", "academia. Then the readers of the blog answer and discuss", "blog answer and discuss in the comments. These are often", "many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author", "ask questions here that I've read on a blog, to", "of the blog to post a question they have about", "the blog answer and discuss in the comments. These are", "and I think that this community would have useful answers", "hear. However, the help center says that > > You", "this community would have useful answers that I'd like to", "useful answers that I'd like to hear. However, the help", "very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I", "of the blog answer and discuss in the comments. These" ]
[ "don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive", "that should have been closed but are not? Questions or", "questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter.", "really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts", "to their questions and don't even know that this site", "on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part", "this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will", "need answers to their questions and don't even know that", "through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before,", "see a pattern of questions that should have been closed", "how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net.", "to look at this site through the eyes of someone", "love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world", "an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer", "use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an", "edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below", "someone who's never seen it before, and see how we", "asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few", "questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do", "in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to", "but are not? Questions or answers that could use an", "site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it", "the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see", "of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of", "easy they are to find and compare the answers we", "Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people", "before, and see how we stack up against the rest", "Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's", "are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit?", "a few Google searches to see how easy they are", "to see how easy they are to find and compare", "your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health", "they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be?", "that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run", "only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see", "queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were", "a whole world of people out there who need answers", "up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation", "with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions", "questions and don't even know that this site exists. When", "information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only", "who's never seen it before, and see how we stack", "the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and", "that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what", "the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though.", "and compare the answers we have with the information available", "Do you see a pattern of questions that should have", "first impression be? Let's try to look at this site", "10 questions that were asked and answered in the last", "Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to", "and discuss these questions and the site's health with your", "Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions", "is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you", "how easy they are to find and compare the answers", "pattern of questions that should have been closed but are", "from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try", "been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could", "though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should", "who need answers to their questions and don't even know", "there who need answers to their questions and don't even", "know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google,", "a pattern of questions that should have been closed but", "Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle,", "Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out", "discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow", "and see how we stack up against the rest of", "answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches", "their first impression be? Let's try to look at this", "look at this site through the eyes of someone who's", "and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google", "with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the", "Google searches to see how easy they are to find", "see how we stack up against the rest of the", "you see a pattern of questions that should have been", "quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy", "other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of", "the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval)", "could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post", "going really well? Post an answer below to share your", "that's going really well? Post an answer below to share", "part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern", "whole world of people out there who need answers to", "out there who need answers to their questions and don't", "they are to find and compare the answers we have", "is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked", "searches to see how easy they are to find and", "and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered", "try to look at this site through the eyes of", "[Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of", "populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in", "these questions and the site's health with your fellow users!", "impression be? Let's try to look at this site through", "at this site through the eyes of someone who's never", "will their first impression be? Let's try to look at", "and don't even know that this site exists. When they", "answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really", "stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site", "eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see", "is a whole world of people out there who need", "to find and compare the answers we have with the", "answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions", "puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that", "compare the answers we have with the information available on", "all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole", "open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and", "even know that this site exists. When they arrive from", "Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to", "few Google searches to see how easy they are to", "were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a", "never seen it before, and see how we stack up", "we have with the information available on other sites. Rating", "available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a", "find and compare the answers we have with the information", "sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the", "of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open", "to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the", "'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated", "site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their", "an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these", "have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that", "share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's", "Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss", "review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that", "are to find and compare the answers we have with", "world of people out there who need answers to their", "of questions that should have been closed but are not?", "closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use", "thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with", "a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a", "Run a few Google searches to see how easy they", "of someone who's never seen it before, and see how", "be? Let's try to look at this site through the", "seen it before, and see how we stack up against", "this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen", "should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers", "there is a whole world of people out there who", "we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The", "the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and", "but there is a whole world of people out there", "well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and", "the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is", "questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions", "that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well?", "We all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a", "the answers we have with the information available on other", "see how easy they are to find and compare the", "against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review", "not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything", "Let's try to look at this site through the eyes", "arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's", "answers to their questions and don't even know that this", "When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression", "people out there who need answers to their questions and", "or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going", "what will their first impression be? Let's try to look", "[Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10", "last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how", "their questions and don't even know that this site exists.", "below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and", "have with the information available on other sites. Rating the", "it before, and see how we stack up against the", "answers we have with the information available on other sites.", "exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first", "rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is", "The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with", "the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions", "of people out there who need answers to their questions" ]
[ "little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of typo", "I am confused by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > >", "> > This seems to be a little contradictory to", "be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple", "me. Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\".", "This seems to be a little contradictory to me. Is", "of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious", "the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to", "misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of the", "seems to be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting", "the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by", "an American English spelling to British English and fixed two", "edit was by a new user and changed an American", "a single letter in each case. How do we fell", "by a high rep user and fixed a single typo", "rep user and fixed a single typo in the question", "grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems", "American English spelling to British English and fixed two typos", "post better than you found it. Common reasons for edits", "\"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of the edits", "of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was", "you found it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix", "instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be", "letter in each case. How do we fell about seemingly", "the question title by adding a character. The second edit", "in each case. How do we fell about seemingly minor", "typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because", "adding a character. The second edit was by a new", "English spelling to British English and fixed two typos by", "user and fixed a single typo in the question title", "two typos by changing a single letter in each case.", "was by a high rep user and fixed a single", "British English and fixed two typos by changing a single", "English and fixed two typos by changing a single letter", "first edit was by a high rep user and fixed", "In particularly, I am curious because of the edits made", "edit was by a high rep user and fixed a", "Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In", "and changed an American English spelling to British English and", "spelling to British English and fixed two typos by changing", "a new user and changed an American English spelling to", "How do we fell about seemingly minor edits of these", "about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be substantial", "like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of", "The second edit was by a new user and changed", "a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of", "to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high rep", "include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > >", "single letter in each case. How do we fell about", "because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit", "Edits are expected to be substantial and to leave the", "changed an American English spelling to British English and fixed", "made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high", "changing a single letter in each case. How do we", "To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > >", "fixed a single typo in the question title by adding", "edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a", "by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected", "typo in the question title by adding a character. The", "reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes", "... > > > This seems to be a little", "case. How do we fell about seemingly minor edits of", "a high rep user and fixed a single typo in", "and fixed a single typo in the question title by", "question title by adding a character. The second edit was", "Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling", "to be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a", "typos by changing a single letter in each case. How", "fixed two typos by changing a single letter in each", "a character. The second edit was by a new user", "and to leave the post better than you found it.", "a single typo in the question title by adding a", "to be substantial and to leave the post better than", "user and changed an American English spelling to British English", "by changing a single letter in each case. How do", "high rep user and fixed a single typo in the", "to leave the post better than you found it. Common", "by adding a character. The second edit was by a", "than you found it. Common reasons for edits include: To", "be substantial and to leave the post better than you", "> > Edits are expected to be substantial and to", "in the question title by adding a character. The second", "The first edit was by a high rep user and", "mistakes ... > > > This seems to be a", "single typo in the question title by adding a character.", "am curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The", "second edit was by a new user and changed an", "for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ...", "am confused by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits", "leave the post better than you found it. Common reasons", "particularly, I am curious because of the edits made to", "to British English and fixed two typos by changing a", "a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I", "> Edits are expected to be substantial and to leave", "by a new user and changed an American English spelling", "contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of typo like", "[editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be substantial and", "and spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems to", "couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am", "substantial and to leave the post better than you found", "new user and changed an American English spelling to British", "> This seems to be a little contradictory to me.", "correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly,", "and fixed two typos by changing a single letter in", "spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems to be", "it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and", "to me. Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings", "are expected to be substantial and to leave the post", "confused by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are", "curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first", "the post better than you found it. Common reasons for", "do we fell about seemingly minor edits of these types?", "character. The second edit was by a new user and", "edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... >", "found it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar", "fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > > This", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high rep user", "> > > This seems to be a little contradictory", "was by a new user and changed an American English", "better than you found it. Common reasons for edits include:", "title by adding a character. The second edit was by", "I am curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>.", "each case. How do we fell about seemingly minor edits", "expected to be substantial and to leave the post better" ]
[ "should not be answered, but this is not the case", "or unethical in your methodology, because you don't want to", "I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even be", "Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics", "have been wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249))", "opinions might be valid in case the OP really made", "answers that already exist?** Should we flag-delete them? We could", "of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often.", "the situation about which OP is asking because not every", "offensive clothing worn to class as a TA or other", "(e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and in good", "to push them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit", "some answers were suggesting that the statistics and the research", "of answers still do not answer the question actually asked,", "because of their attitude towards the controversial issue in question,", "ethical to design admission criteria according to a certain statistics", "strong: neither of the examples I linked to has negative", "thing is that people say \"if you do not want", "I was sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating", "condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither of the", "of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The question is asking if it", "TA or other person of authority * Some answers, instead", "about clearly offensive clothing worn to class as a TA", "question. Do we really want to collect such answers?* And,", "need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I", "methodology, because you don't want to disclose the details.\" I", "the examples I linked to has negative score (one has", "trend While some of the opinions might be valid in", "their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The question asks what to do about", "trend in the answers on academia.se to question the situation", "even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they", "thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do", "a good trend While some of the opinions might be", "the question. Do we really want to collect such answers?", "question lately, I was sure to cover all my bases", "on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get", "according to a certain statistics their research revealed (it is", "answer the question. *Do we really want to collect such", "the OP really made a mistake, those kind of answers", "bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get support from", "is not the case I am talking about. One other", "actually answer the question. Do we really want to collect", "to get support from part of the community because of", " The question is asking if it is ethical to", "what is being asked. Most recent examples from a few", "we flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes to", "anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I don't think", "know when I was asking a question lately, I was", "do not actually answer the question. Do we really want", "in case the OP really made a mistake, those kind", "to collect such answers?* And, as a secondary questions, *what", "but this is not the case I am talking about.", "sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything", "[Is it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions", "clothing worn to class as a TA or other person", "in good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and", "answered, but this is not the case I am talking", "of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering,", "to question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not", "details, there is something wrong or unethical in your methodology,", "is not our place to question the facts presented. Yet,", "[Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing", "I know when I was asking a question lately, I", "those answers seem to get support from part of the", "that everything was done ethically and in good will) to", "seem to get support from part of the community because", "offending to her is not offending in general [Is it", "mistake, those kind of answers still do not answer the", "something similar, should not be answered, but this is not", "as a secondary questions, what do we want to do", "argue that the OP is easily offended, or that what", "and it is not our place to question the facts", "it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based", "I don't think this is a good trend While some", "of the examples I linked to has negative score (one", "to her is not offending in general [Is it ethical", "\"if you do not want to disclose the details, there", "issue in question, and not because they actually offer an", "on academia.se to question the situation about which OP is", "people say \"if you do not want to disclose the", "disclose the details, there is something wrong or unethical in", "already exist?* Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for", "saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even be the", "We could wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently", "negative score (one has a positive one!), even thou, (and,", "or the wish to generalize, so I don't think this", "often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such", "other person of authority * Some answers, instead of answering,", "asking a question lately, I was sure to cover all", "One other thing is that people say \"if you do", "to design admission criteria according to a certain statistics their", "such as How do I best cheat on the admission", "part of the community because of their attitude towards the", "want to collect such answers? And, as a secondary questions,", "asking because not every single detail is provided, instead of", "we really want to collect such answers? And, as a", "the admission process, or something similar, should not be answered,", "question actually asked, and it is not our place to", "recent examples. I know when I was asking a question", "especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to", "suggesting that the statistics and the research they did must", "revealed (it is a bit of a controversial admission criteria).", "want to disclose the details.\" I understand the need for", "community seems not to be condemning those kind of answers", "really want to collect such answers?* And, as a secondary", "was done ethically and in good will) to avoid answers", "question asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing worn", "undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The question is asking if it is", "not be answered, but this is not the case I", "did must have been wrong and the results are not", "positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm", "case I am talking about. One other thing is that", "is a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) ", "student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The", "such answers? And, as a secondary questions, what do we", "a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) ", "Do we really want to collect such answers?* And, as", "days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student is", "as a TA or other person of authority * Some", "of answers very strong: neither of the examples I linked", "don't think this is a good trend While some of", "still do not answer the question actually asked, and it", "to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was", "Most recent examples from a few days ago include: [Should", "I understand the need for anonymity, or the wish to", "the community seems not to be condemning those kind of", "a question lately, I was sure to cover all my", "avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since I saw", "different criteria for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate", "do not answer the question actually asked, and it is", "results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more", "think this is a good trend While some of the", "am talking about. One other thing is that people say", "criteria for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249)", "me if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the", "is being asked. Most recent examples from a few days", "is not offending in general [Is it ethical to apply", "if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the question.", "answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things,", "answers on academia.se to question the situation about which OP", "Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP is", "talking about. One other thing is that people say \"if", "design admission criteria according to a certain statistics their research", "of answering, argue that the OP is easily offended, or", "in your methodology, because you don't want to disclose the", "other thing is that people say \"if you do not", "is asking because not every single detail is provided, instead", "a TA or other person of authority * Some answers,", "professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in", "I am talking about. One other thing is that people", "such answers that already exist?** Should we flag-delete them? We", "a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some", "neither of the examples I linked to has negative score", "of answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics and", "actually asked, and it is not our place to question", "of the community because of their attitude towards the controversial", "must have been wrong and the results are not valid.", "towards the controversial issue in question, and not because they", "be valid in case the OP really made a mistake,", "support from part of the community because of their attitude", "answering what is being asked. Most recent examples from a", "good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods,", "just two more recent examples. I know when I was", "answers still do not answer the question actually asked, and", "controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers", "I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as", "([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples. I know", "as How do I best cheat on the admission process,", "unethical things, such as *How do I best cheat on", "criteria according to a certain statistics their research revealed (it", "I was asking a question lately, I was sure to", "lately, I was sure to cover all my bases (e.g.", "not to be condemning those kind of answers very strong:", "methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and", "offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The question asks what", "question is asking if it is ethical to design admission", "most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical", "has negative score (one has a positive one!), even thou,", "understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as *How", "examples I linked to has negative score (one has a", "do we want to do with such answers that already", "to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on country", "sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial questions, those", "(and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do not", "very strong: neither of the examples I linked to has", "being asked. Most recent examples from a few days ago", "were suggesting that the statistics and the research they did", "more recent examples. I know when I was asking a", "of answering what is being asked. Most recent examples from", "and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that", "what to do about clearly offensive clothing worn to class", "presented. Yet, the community seems not to be condemning those", "examples from a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene", "was asking a question lately, I was sure to cover", "ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on", "statistics their research revealed (it is a bit of a", "questions asking clearly unethical things, such as *How do I", "the opinions might be valid in case the OP really", "understand the need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize,", "clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks what to", "for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially", "detail* is provided, instead of answering what is being asked.", "answers very strong: neither of the examples I linked to", "that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as *How do", "on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking", "was sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that", "not offending in general [Is it ethical to apply different", "easily offended, or that what was offending to her is", "to generalize, so I don't think this is a good", "to class as a TA or other person of authority", "questions, those answers seem to get support from part of", "Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes", "to be condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither", "person of authority * Some answers, instead of answering, argue", "I linked to has negative score (one has a positive", "because you don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand", "this kind of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted", "based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The question is", "examples. I know when I was asking a question lately,", "for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) ", "and methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail", "of the opinions might be valid in case the OP", "bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of", "get support from part of the community because of their", "valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples. I", "wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you don't want", "was offending to her is not offending in general [Is", "two more recent examples. I know when I was asking", "collect such answers?* And, as a secondary questions, *what do", "you don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand the", "admission criteria according to a certain statistics their research revealed", "controversial questions, those answers seem to get support from part", "with such answers that already exist? Should we flag-delete them?", "answers questioning my motives and methods, since I saw this", "we want to do with such answers that already exist?", "admission process*, or something similar, should not be answered, but", "These are just two more recent examples. I know when", "answering, argue that the OP is easily offended, or that", "statistics and the research they did must have been wrong", "be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking", "might be valid in case the OP really made a", "wrong), they do not actually answer the question. *Do we", "wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but", "and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just", "is something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you", "research revealed (it is a bit of a controversial admission", "that the statistics and the research they did must have", "you do not want to disclose the details, there is", "push them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial", "instead of answering, argue that the OP is easily offended,", "(it is a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249))", "to do about clearly offensive clothing worn to class as", "that already exist?** Should we flag-delete them? We could wait", "country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The question is asking if", "really made a mistake, those kind of answers still do", "score (one has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please,", "there is something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because", "not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples.", "some of the opinions might be valid in case the", "could wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down,", "answers seem to get support from part of the community", "classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The question asks what to do about clearly", "this is not the case I am talking about. One", "the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly", "not actually answer the question. Do we really want to", "recently noticed a trend in the answers on academia.se to", "certain statistics their research revealed (it is a bit of", "them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial questions,", "OP is easily offended, or that what was offending to", "that what was offending to her is not offending in", "this is a good trend While some of the opinions", "process, or something similar, should not be answered, but this", "in question, and not because they actually offer an answer.", "cheat on the admission process*, or something similar, should not", "valid in case the OP really made a mistake, those", "please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do not actually", "* The question asks what to do about clearly offensive", "prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand", "asked. Most recent examples from a few days ago include:", "a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get support", "generalize, so I don't think this is a good trend", "correct me if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer", "are just two more recent examples. I know when I", "I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the question. *Do", "flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes to push", "if it is ethical to design admission criteria according to", "graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The", "our place to question the facts presented. Yet, the community", "do about clearly offensive clothing worn to class as a", "admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers were", "it is ethical to design admission criteria according to a", "not the case I am talking about. One other thing", "but especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem", "one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong),", "apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on country of", "worn to class as a TA or other person of", "a certain statistics their research revealed (it is a bit", "kind of answers very strong: neither of the examples I", "their research revealed (it is a bit of a controversial", "your methodology, because you don't want to disclose the details.\"", "the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or the", "my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and", "answers were suggesting that the statistics and the research they", "to a certain statistics their research revealed (it is a", "secondary questions, what do we want to do with such", "say \"if you do not want to disclose the details,", "or something similar, should not be answered, but this is", "While some of the opinions might be valid in case", "answer the question actually asked, and it is not our", "and the research they did must have been wrong and", "which OP is asking because not every single detail is", "How do I best cheat on the admission process, or", "a secondary questions, what do we want to do with", "for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I don't", "clearly unethical things, such as How do I best cheat", "about which OP is asking because not every single detail", "the wish to generalize, so I don't think this is", "to do with such answers that already exist?** Should we", "a mistake, those kind of answers still do not answer", "the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to be", "questions, what do we want to do with such answers", "class as a TA or other person of authority ", "wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are", "criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting", "*what do we want to do with such answers that", "wish to generalize, so I don't think this is a", "linked to has negative score (one has a positive one!),", "unethical in your methodology, because you don't want to disclose", "every single detail* is provided, instead of answering what is", "asked, and it is not our place to question the", "to has negative score (one has a positive one!), even", "I best cheat on the admission process*, or something similar,", "a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a", "(one has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct", "authority Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the", "situation about which OP is asking because not every single", "the need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so", "so I don't think this is a good trend While", "include: [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive", "is asking if it is ethical to design admission criteria", "are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent", "do not want to disclose the details, there is something", "will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since", "when I was asking a question lately, I was sure", "details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or the wish", "they did must have been wrong and the results are", "the community because of their attitude towards the controversial issue", "community because of their attitude towards the controversial issue in", "is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question", "about. One other thing is that people say \"if you", "* Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that the", "everything was done ethically and in good will) to avoid", "the case I am talking about. One other thing is", "motives and methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers", "down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially on a", "not want to disclose the details, there is something wrong", "kind of answers still do not answer the question actually", "the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two", "academia.se to question the situation about which OP is asking", "because not every single detail is provided, instead of answering", "answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics and the", "on the admission process*, or something similar, should not be", "admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question", "the statistics and the research they did must have been", "done ethically and in good will) to avoid answers questioning", "the answers on academia.se to question the situation about which", "similar, should not be answered, but this is not the", "general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate", "a trend in the answers on academia.se to question the", "answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP is easily", "wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks", "facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to be condemning", "asking clearly unethical things, such as *How do I best", "the controversial issue in question, and not because they actually", "be condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither of", "the research they did must have been wrong and the", "questioning my motives and methods, since I saw this kind", "they do not actually answer the question. Do we really", "OP really made a mistake, those kind of answers still", "case the OP really made a mistake, those kind of", "what was offending to her is not offending in general", "don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand the need", "controversial issue in question, and not because they actually offer", "ethically and in good will) to avoid answers questioning my", "be answered, but this is not the case I am", "it is not our place to question the facts presented.", "study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The question is asking if it is ethical", "recent examples from a few days ago include: [Should professors", "offending in general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria", "all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically", "asking if it is ethical to design admission criteria according", "from a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if", "explicating that everything was done ethically and in good will)", "of their attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and", "is provided, instead of answering what is being asked. Most", "is ethical to design admission criteria according to a certain", "kind of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers", "since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even", "offended, or that what was offending to her is not", "the details, there is something wrong or unethical in your", "OP is asking because not every single detail is provided,", "has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me", "ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing", "them? We could wait for the down-votes to push them", "The question is asking if it is ethical to design", "a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead", "best cheat on the admission process*, or something similar, should", "those kind of answers still do not answer the question", "that people say \"if you do not want to disclose", "of authority Some answers, instead of answering, argue that", "in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks what to do", "cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done", "* Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP", "their attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and not", "clearly offensive clothing worn to class as a TA or", "is a good trend While some of the opinions might", "to disclose the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity,", "seems not to be condemning those kind of answers very", "my motives and methods, since I saw this kind of", "the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially on", "not every single detail* is provided, instead of answering what", "bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and in", "answers? And, as a secondary questions, what do we want", "And, as a secondary questions, *what do we want to", "good trend While some of the opinions might be valid", "to question the situation about which OP is asking because", "is easily offended, or that what was offending to her", "made a mistake, those kind of answers still do not", "been wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These", "the question actually asked, and it is not our place", "to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since I", "([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that", "intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their", "not our place to question the facts presented. Yet, the", "a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if", "in the answers on academia.se to question the situation about", "question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to", "asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing worn to", "non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I", "or that what was offending to her is not offending", "something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you don't", "do with such answers that already exist?* Should we flag-delete", "from part of the community because of their attitude towards", "the OP is easily offended, or that what was offending", "The question asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing", "or other person of authority * Some answers, instead of", "instead of answering what is being asked. Most recent examples", "place to question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems", "and in good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives", "attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and not because", "in general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria for", "disclose the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or", "is that people say \"if you do not want to", "research they did must have been wrong and the results", "provided, instead of answering what is being asked. Most recent", "her is not offending in general [Is it ethical to", "to disclose the details, there is something wrong or unethical", "those kind of answers very strong: neither of the examples", "not answer the question actually asked, and it is not", "have recently noticed a trend in the answers on academia.se", "want to do with such answers that already exist?* Should", "want to disclose the details, there is something wrong or", "exist? Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for the", "do I best cheat on the admission process, or something", "question the situation about which OP is asking because not", "Yet, the community seems not to be condemning those kind", "I have recently noticed a trend in the answers on", "single detail is provided, instead of answering what is being", "that the OP is easily offended, or that what was", "down, but especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers", "things, such as **How do I best cheat on the", "even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions", "few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student", "noticed a trend in the answers on academia.se to question", "if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249)" ]
[ "I am currently a sophomore, but just looking for some", "sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on graduate school", "just looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and", "on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored to", "am currently a sophomore, but just looking for some statistics", "graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored to my", "but just looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions,", "currently a sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on", "a sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on graduate", "looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if", "school admissions, and if possible chances tailored to my own", "some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances", "for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible", "admissions, and if possible chances tailored to my own statistics.", "statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored" ]
[ "remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow", "if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their)", "with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > >", "idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE", "relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons,", "Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say,", "the SE system works the best for clear, answerable questions.", "is privacy (but, I guess, more than often a different", "more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the", "as examples, questions which without explicit examples would end in", "best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: >", "classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the", "is not my feeling about providing examples, but: it", "deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare", "* do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What", "some cases the question lack enough details, and people are", "feel uncomfortable? > > > with > > What to", "MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best for clear,", "good answers): * [What to do if assignment is against", "not go into details. > > > The only exception", "for more details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms,", "providing examples, but: * it is clear what is the", "my feeling about providing examples, but: * it is clear", "question lack enough details, and people are confused or ask", "can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are", "* do they attract good answers? * do they minimize", "> The first will start an idle discussion. The second", "too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for", "do many other readers, what end up in long comment", "> > > The only exception I can foresee is", "is serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP", "and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will", "factor is not my feeling about providing examples, but: ", "placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which", "student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being", "(but, I guess, more than often a different but of", "is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\"", "only exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess,", "examples, but: * it is clear what is the question?", "am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do", "let me not go into details. > > > The", "`offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what end", "levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries,", "most important factor is not my feeling about providing examples,", "software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of [Should professors", "me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > >", "words). And as examples, questions which without explicit examples would", "of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important factor", "> The only exception I can foresee is privacy (but,", "[People denying the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering).", "can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than often", "what is the question? * do they attract good answers?", "good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people asking", "write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of", "[Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing", "to do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately", "questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library gives", "advice. However, in some cases the question lack enough details,", "> > The only exception I can foresee is privacy", "go into details. > > > The only exception I", "a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in the", "norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws", "example, compare > > What to do if advisor, when", "which without explicit examples would end in guessing games (but,", "will start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us", "clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of", "not my feeling about providing examples, but: * it is", "laws varies by countries, different people have different first- or", "a different but of similar calibre example can be given).", "being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in", "The first will start an idle discussion. The second won't.", "persons, laws varies by countries, different people have different first-", "answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library", "obscene words). And as examples, questions which without explicit examples", "be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the", "experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`,", "varies by countries, different people have different first- or second-hand", "of [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive", "examples would end in guessing games (but, as they are,", "* [What to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion)", "or legal actions? For example, compare > > What to", "ask for more details. Especially things dealing with social relations,", "ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious enough to", "to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and", "questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system", "assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented", "already mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it", "maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior is not", "The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way", "mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a", "in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People", "etc. So do many other readers, what end up in", "do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question", "and people are confused or ask for more details. Especially", "talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? >", "system works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't", "offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up", "but let me not go into details. > > >", "but of similar calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit", "instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important", "> What to do if advisor, when talking with me,", "[Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta", "the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any", "clear what is the question? * do they attract good", "guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good answers): ", "other readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong, people", "against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) [Why do many talented scientists write", "have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless", "clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this", "started because of [Should professors intervene if a student is", "is clear what is the question? * do they attract", "or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to", "comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious enough", "do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do", "legal actions? For example, compare > > What to do", "up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue", "are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words).", "dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity", "StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the", "exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more", "\"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare >", "professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in", "(or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best", "in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good answers):", "or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see", "wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of", "different but of similar calibre example can be given). Otherwise", "advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel", "best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as", "StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library gives undesirable", "won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective", "uncomfortable? > > > with > > What to do", "SE system works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow", "games (but, as they are, attracted good answers): * [What", "(with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples,", "> > this library gives undesirable results, but let me", "Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare > > What", "I feel uncomfortable? > > > with > > What", "the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the", "I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than", "In any case, IMHO, the most important factor is not", "student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented scientists write horrible", "because of [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing", "walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare > >", "the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And", "it is clear what is the question? * do they", "with > > What to do if advisor, when talking", "start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember", "I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So", "many other readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong,", "say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best for", "the issue is serious enough to call it. Or maybe", "Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions", "details. > > > The only exception I can foresee", "me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > >", "without explicit examples would end in guessing games (but, as", "they are, attracted good answers): * [What to do if", "holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > >", "What to do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves", "of similar calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations", "behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk.", "The only exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I", "call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the", "explicit examples would end in guessing games (but, as they", "to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which without", "explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly", "talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started", "So do many other readers, what end up in long", "than often a different but of similar calibre example can", "things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of", "not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or", "when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable?", "advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm and I", "by persons, laws varies by countries, different people have different", "is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a", "with: > > this library gives undesirable results, but let", "> with > > What to do if advisor, when", "I guess, more than often a different but of similar", "religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) [Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software)", "people are confused or ask for more details. Especially things", "And as examples, questions which without explicit examples would end", "any case, IMHO, the most important factor is not my", "won't work with: > > this library gives undesirable results,", "if advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm and", "ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies", "situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders", "this library gives undesirable results, but let me not go", "behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The", "Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with,", "meta question was started because of [Should professors intervene if", "open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some cases the", "> > What to do if advisor, when talking with", "[What to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) ", "that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or,", "has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow).", "question? do they attract good answers? * do they", "answers): * [What to do if assignment is against student's", "> > The first will start an idle discussion. The", "first will start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let", "mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which without explicit", "they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What do you", "uncomfortable? > > > The first will start an idle", "results, but let me not go into details. > >", "I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will start", "inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first", "see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what", "and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with > >", "serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays", "answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important factor is", "I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers,", "given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best", "example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases", "\"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal", "Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior is", "work with: > > this library gives undesirable results, but", "enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it", "if the issue is serious enough to call it. Or", "a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some", "multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some cases", "my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with", "foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than often a", "guess, more than often a different but of similar calibre", "would end in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted", "actually OP downplays it and the behavior is not \"a", "gives undesirable results, but let me not go into details.", "discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has", "horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of [Should", "privacy (but, I guess, more than often a different but", "questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most", "This meta question was started because of [Should professors intervene", "the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't", "calibre example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim", "etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc.", "varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different people have", "cases the question lack enough details, and people are confused", "was started because of [Should professors intervene if a student", "more details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics,", "case, IMHO, the most important factor is not my feeling", "subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE", "* it is clear what is the question? * do", "of [People denying the situation in the questions instead of", "readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning", "are confused or ask for more details. Especially things dealing", "details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc:", "many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was", "requests for life advice. However, in some cases the question", "is the question? * do they attract good answers? ", "than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works", "downplays it and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\"", "do they attract good answers? do they minimize overhead", "I already mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making", "sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different people", "compare > > What to do if advisor, when talking", "inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For", "if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I", "to do if advisor, when talking with me, holds my", "an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that", "attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people", "arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with >", "> this library gives undesirable results, but let me not", "And the SE system works the best for clear, answerable", "bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions?", "However, in some cases the question lack enough details, and", "enough details, and people are confused or ask for more", "works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work", "they attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in", "(but, as they are, attracted good answers): * [What to", "in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO,", "people questioning if the issue is serious enough to call", "similar calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or", "[some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread", "important factor is not my feeling about providing examples, but:", "end in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good", "> > > with > > What to do if", "in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is", "confused or ask for more details. Especially things dealing with", "for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > >", "undesirable results, but let me not go into details. >", "first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I", "and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves", "follow-up of [People denying the situation in the questions instead", "detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice.", "answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)?", "lack enough details, and people are confused or ask for", "when talking with me, holds my arm and I feel", "clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many", "me not go into details. > > > The only", "scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because", "the question lack enough details, and people are confused or", "IMHO, the most important factor is not my feeling about", "but: * it is clear what is the question? ", "question was started because of [Should professors intervene if a", "second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more", "it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in", "people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am", "to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) [Why", "Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels", "issue is serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually", "details, and people are confused or ask for more details.", "sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in the questions", "examples, questions which without explicit examples would end in guessing", "end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the", "in some cases the question lack enough details, and people", "attracted good answers): * [What to do if assignment is", "provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests", "denying the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In", "OP downplays it and the behavior is not \"a bit", "much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life", "way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And", "often a different but of similar calibre example can be", "etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by", "countries, different people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc.", "library gives undesirable results, but let me not go into", "and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation", "situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case,", "with me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? >", "For example, compare > > What to do if advisor,", "As I already mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49),", "of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different", "the most important factor is not my feeling about providing", "phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene", "do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What do", "are, attracted good answers): * [What to do if assignment", "talking with me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable?", "us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than", "minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What do you think?", "possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions", "do if advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm", "is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented scientists", "long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious", "it and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but", "What to do if advisor, when talking with me, holds", "a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and", "> > with > > What to do if advisor,", "intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their", "as they are, attracted good answers): * [What to do", "different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when", "> > > The first will start an idle discussion.", "`inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what end up", "second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`,", "making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However,", "their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying", "social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by", "different people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I", "feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will start an", "feeling about providing examples, but: * it is clear what", "but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example,", "* [Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This", "verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask", "what end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if", "into details. > > > The only exception I can", "questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended", "it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior", "with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies", "or ask for more details. Especially things dealing with social", "if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many", "by countries, different people have different first- or second-hand experiences,", "questions which without explicit examples would end in guessing games", "for life advice. However, in some cases the question lack", "the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with:", "life advice. However, in some cases the question lack enough", "questioning if the issue is serious enough to call it.", "actions? For example, compare > > What to do if", "about providing examples, but: * it is clear what is", "when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other", "do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and", "the question? * do they attract good answers? * do", "more than often a different but of similar calibre example" ]
[ "decidedly not what this site is about). > > >", "the consensus is that such questions are not in scope,", "There seems to be some disagreement about whether professional non-research", "> the point of the restriction is to avoid having", "such questions are not in scope, perhaps this text should", "think it's perfectly in scope. > > > I also", "business, medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic. One", "pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this site is", "a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic program;", "is on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment on", "academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope. > >", "to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an", "professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like them).", "> > Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps", "such programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in a", "avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is", "entry into such programs is on-topic. One the one hand,", "questions related to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic", "post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope. >", "considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking", "perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions", "[help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted", "to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law,", "Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold):", "professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related", "it's perfectly in scope. > > > I also believe", "consensus is that such questions are not in scope, perhaps", "> > Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also", "med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question about", "this site is about). > > > Then the opposite", "> Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should", "to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're", "career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and >", "preparatory steps should I be taking for admission into med", "others like them). If the consensus is that such questions", "them). If the consensus is that such questions are not", "text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional", "about). > > > Then the opposite view on [What", "about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's", "in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously", "scope. > > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text,", "related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic", "research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD", "I think it's perfectly in scope. > > > I", "comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical", "they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an", "a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope.", "interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and", "overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this", "medicine, and business degrees (and others like them). If the", "medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic. One the", "the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not", "in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get", "students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and", "degrees (and others like them). If the consensus is that", "and entry into such programs is on-topic. One the one", "(and others like them). If the consensus is that such", "to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in", "(unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue", "point of the restriction is to avoid having the board", "a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into", "on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment on [York", "be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This", "to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which", "on [What preparatory steps should I be taking for admission", "steps should I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/):", "the restriction is to avoid having the board overrun with", "program; I think it's perfectly in scope. > > >", "get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions", "> > the point of the restriction is to avoid", "in scope. > > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "should I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): >", "the one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student", "one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking", "medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to", "hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to", "> This is a straightforward question about admission to a", "> > and > > the point of the restriction", "to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover,", "school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question about admission", "like them). If the consensus is that such questions are", "(law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic.", "be some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law,", "are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven", "looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > >", "straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I", "also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees,", "into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related", "instance) > > > and > > the point of", "If the consensus is that such questions are not in", "[What preparatory steps should I be taking for admission into", "is decidedly not what this site is about). > >", "admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly", "about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and", "(which is decidedly not what this site is about). >", "perfectly in scope. > > > I also believe the", "with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this site", "opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I be taking", "on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school)", "Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also generally considered", "which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include", "having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly", "to be some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs", "> Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also generally", "refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional", "student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): >", "is a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic", "MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and > >", "program, for instance) > > > and > > the", "include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like", "the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I be", "> I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to", "academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and", "questions are not in scope, perhaps this text should be", "(on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional schools", "and > > the point of the restriction is to", "> > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which", "the point of the restriction is to avoid having the", "hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional schools are", "\"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine,", "related to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless", "generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or", "pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > >", "> and > > the point of the restriction is", "professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into", "site is about). > > > Then the opposite view", "> > > Then the opposite view on [What preparatory", "view on [What preparatory steps should I be taking for", "into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question", "looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance)", "admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward", "text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to", "programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment", "business degrees (and others like them). If the consensus is", "degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs", "> > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers", "some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business,", "non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such", "what this site is about). > > > Then the", "an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > >", "or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for", "scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude", "> > > and > > the point of the", "restriction is to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business", "law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like them). If", "question about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think", "This is a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate", "schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to", "seems to be some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree", "of the restriction is to avoid having the board overrun", "should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional graduate-level", "I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > >", "is to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions", "also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\"", "whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry", "for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a", "not what this site is about). > > > Then", "for instance) > > > and > > the point", "questions (which is decidedly not what this site is about).", "[York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on", "I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional", "is about). > > > Then the opposite view on", "are not in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified", "> > This is a straightforward question about admission to", "off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to", "disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine)", "not in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to", "school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional", "degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program,", "to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others", "One the one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate", "this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about", "is that such questions are not in scope, perhaps this", "believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can", "can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business", "Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I", "the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be", "to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) >", "into such programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in", "taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is", "board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what", "be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional graduate-level degree", "clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional graduate-level degree programs.", "programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs is", "and business degrees (and others like them). If the consensus", "that such questions are not in scope, perhaps this text", "be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees" ]
[ "academic staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show", "[research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag", "(or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate", "that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in", "currently have 76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\").", "also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We", "have 76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By", "previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > > if it's", "discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed", "that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this", "this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here", "appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the", "synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting", "\"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site", "a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so,", "top-voted answer says: > > if it's a question a", "should be closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable", "research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a", "a question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask.", "higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate >", "on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether", "your contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd also", "answer says: > > if it's a question a PhD", "voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of", "about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate", "are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which", "[I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd", "case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either", "is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym of", "I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym: but", "irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms).", "says: > > if it's a question a PhD student", "postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they should", "undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: >", "of the site scope, either: 1. these questions are about", "[We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted", "and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students", "staff, in which case they should be closed and deleted;", "student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's", "So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym:", "site scope, either: 1. these questions are about research that's", "[research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the", "questions are about research that's not applicable to postgrad students", "PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then", "the site scope, either: 1. these questions are about research", "closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad", "tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym", "questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition", "> > if it's a question a PhD student (or", "tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of", "welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have", "or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students and academic", "have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer", "tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope, either:", "a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to", "synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96),", "contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome", "1. these questions are about research that's not applicable to", "students and academic staff, in which case they should be", "if it's a question a PhD student (or higher) could", "proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome", "could reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate > >", "be closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to", "they are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in", "questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant.", "research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > >", "staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions", "in which case they should be closed and deleted; or", "postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they are", "academic staff, in which case they should be closed and", "here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > > if", "and academic staff, in which case they should be closed", "but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is", "definition of the site scope, either: 1. these questions are", "of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate", "research that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff,", "applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case", "case they should be closed and deleted; or 2. they", "discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says:", "are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the", "and academic staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research", "it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions", "scope, either: 1. these questions are about research that's not", "the definition of the site scope, either: 1. these questions", "students and academic staff, in which case they are about", "and the top-voted answer says: > > if it's a", "questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope,", "reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate > > >", "syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym", "making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your", "76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the", "tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So", "are about research that's not applicable to postgrad students and", "the top-voted answer says: > > if it's a question", "> if it's a question a PhD student (or higher)", "'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope, either: 1.", "about research that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic", "is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and", "in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged", "which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\")", "either: 1. these questions are about research that's not applicable", "whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research", "these questions are about research that's not applicable to postgrad", "So [I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So,", "research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that", "they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way,", "to voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion", "welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd", "We currently have 76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged", "way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making", "By the definition of the site scope, either: 1. these", "\"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is", "they should be closed and deleted; or 2. they are", "deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students and", "the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it", "which case they should be closed and deleted; or 2.", "of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on", "to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they", "not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which", "I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate.", "question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If", "Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed", "2. they are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff,", "it's a question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably", "'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've" ]
[ "example, [Where can I take online MBA courses without being", "up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately,", "an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > >", "not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are", "offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions?", "famous for global marketing/management? > > > It is my", "towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and they will", "questions in this category off-topic, and if so, is there", "degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or [What is", "the best way to choose an MBA school for someone", "know of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For", "credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find", "reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears to be", "university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here", "courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will", "to choose an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry):", "it just famous for global marketing/management? > > > It", "is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students", "MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it just", "Or [What is the best way to choose an MBA", "> > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What", "programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it just famous", "of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example,", "there a canonical reason for closing questions in this category?", "requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online MBA", "> > What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer", "problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively).", "the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > > >", "I don't see a lot of consistency in the reason", "individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? >", "(In these three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic", "closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and if", "admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll in a", "Is there a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry?", "that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take", "Or is it just famous for global marketing/management? > >", "will enroll in a full time MBA program. Until then,", "a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where", "transferable online courses to count towards my degree. I talked", "see a lot of consistency in the reason given for", "being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This", "tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears to", "I will enroll in a full time MBA program. Until", "to count towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and", "without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll", "I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > >", "take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next", "> What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science?", "Until then, I would like to take transferable online courses", "> > It is my feeling that these questions are", "for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a", "in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA", "degree. I talked with admissions, and they will accept up", "it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate", "online courses to count towards my degree. I talked with", "cannot find a university that offers individual online MBA courses.", "category off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical reason", "here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees):", "my degree. I talked with admissions, and they will accept", "program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I", "I talked with admissions, and they will accept up to", "find a university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does", "a university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone", "Computer Science? > > > Or [What is the best", "a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is", "three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because it", "sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these", "enroll in a full time MBA program. Until then, I", "university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it", "online degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or [What", "is it just famous for global marketing/management? > > >", "I cannot find a university that offers individual online MBA", "industry? Or is it just famous for global marketing/management? >", "admissions, and they will accept up to 6 credits from", "off-topic, but I don't see a lot of consistency in", "best way to choose an MBA school for someone in", "had a few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of", "way to choose an MBA school for someone in lighting", "like to take transferable online courses to count towards my", "have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): >", "X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online MBA courses", "but I don't see a lot of consistency in the", "anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online", "in this category off-topic, and if so, is there a", "industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA programme featured", "of consistency in the reason given for closure, and they", "It is my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but", "6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot", "just famous for global marketing/management? > > > It is", "marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling that these", "are off-topic, but I don't see a lot of consistency", "facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are", "in the reason given for closure, and they sometimes end", "so, is there a canonical reason for closing questions in", "Does anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest", "> It is my feeling that these questions are off-topic,", "online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > >", "is the best way to choose an MBA school for", "appears to be off-topic because it is not about academia,\"", "there a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or", "[Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online", "Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers individual online", "few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree", "We've recently had a few questions that say, \"Does anyone", "online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online degrees", "lighting industry? Or is it just famous for global marketing/management?", "they sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In", "global marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling that", "Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest", "For example, [Where can I take online MBA courses without", "degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can", "> Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the", "talked with admissions, and they will accept up to 6", "an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university", "up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples:", "> > > It is my feeling that these questions", "MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is", "this category off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical", "because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing", "about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed,", "that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have", "lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA programme", "MBA program. Until then, I would like to take transferable", "degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online degrees in", "will accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited", "say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program that meets", "can I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): >", "year I will enroll in a full time MBA program.", "they will accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB", "accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers", "> > > Or [What is the best way to", "questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program", "a few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a", "end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three", "from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a", "choose an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): >", "recently had a few questions that say, \"Does anyone know", "school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers individual", "closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question", "Next year I will enroll in a full time MBA", "are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this", "a full time MBA program. Until then, I would like", "for global marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling", "accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school.", "courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or", "respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and if so,", "that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program that", "off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category", "to take transferable online courses to count towards my degree.", "a lot of consistency in the reason given for closure,", "and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic,", "time MBA program. Until then, I would like to take", "suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > >", "with admissions, and they will accept up to 6 credits", "> > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are", "for closure, and they sometimes end up being closed for", "Are questions in this category off-topic, and if so, is", "is my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I", "\"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not", "these questions are off-topic, but I don't see a lot", "[What is the best way to choose an MBA school", "don't see a lot of consistency in the reason given", "> > Or [What is the best way to choose", "and they sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons.", "[Where can I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted):", "take transferable online courses to count towards my degree. I", "> Or [What is the best way to choose an", "my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I don't", "feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I don't see", "I would like to take transferable online courses to count", "featured with lighting industry? Or is it just famous for", "students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in", "\"Does anyone know of a degree program that meets requirements", "and they will accept up to 6 credits from an", "AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that", "being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll in", "> Is there a university MBA programme featured with lighting", "question appears to be off-topic because it is not about", "> Next year I will enroll in a full time", "these three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because", "MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > > >", "program. Until then, I would like to take transferable online", "count towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and they", "questions are off-topic, but I don't see a lot of", "off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems", "off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical reason for", "someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university", "full time MBA program. Until then, I would like to", "to be off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions", "that these questions are off-topic, but I don't see a", "in a full time MBA program. Until then, I would", "examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because it is", "lot of consistency in the reason given for closure, and", "are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > >", "about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\"", "MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I", "What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? >", "with lighting industry? Or is it just famous for global", "reason given for closure, and they sometimes end up being", "anyone know of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\"", "> > Is there a university MBA programme featured with", "undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions", "be off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about", "in Computer Science? > > > Or [What is the", "online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year", "would like to take transferable online courses to count towards", "Science? > > > Or [What is the best way", "consistency in the reason given for closure, and they sometimes", "and if so, is there a canonical reason for closing", "the reason given for closure, and they sometimes end up", "is there a canonical reason for closing questions in this", "meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online", "not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and", "if so, is there a canonical reason for closing questions", "for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears", "school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there", "> > Next year I will enroll in a full", "\"This question appears to be off-topic because it is not", "academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and", "to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I", "then, I would like to take transferable online courses to", "courses to count towards my degree. I talked with admissions,", "closure, and they sometimes end up being closed for tangential", "cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or", "given for closure, and they sometimes end up being closed" ]
[ "were no comments, positive or negative, and it had two", "person reading it? I made a distinction (which I invented", "of alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds as", "mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo", "and a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people", "and it had two upvotes before being deleted five hours", "made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the", "reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or the", "minds issues between a theory of like minds (which can", "believe I have solved a famous open problem. How do", "Did I do wrong by including a link to my", "theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds", "not sure it's my best work but I tried to", "a link to my website, or did I come off", "referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted,", "work but I tried to have a heart to heart", "a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people have", "kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview", "the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds issues", "it had two upvotes before being deleted five hours after", "described as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and", "it? I made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented)", "I convince people in the field that I am not", "intent, or was part of it just too strange for", "mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other", "comments, positive or negative, and it had two upvotes before", "it deleted because of execution or intent, or was part", "convince people in the field that I am not a", "purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or", "as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and a", "a response to [I believe I have solved a famous", "am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my", "being outside of the climate of opinion whether he made", "or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart", "a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to heart", "have solved a famous open problem. How do I convince", "a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this", "do wrong by including a link to my website, or", "within theory of other minds issues between a theory of", "mentioned an achievement of my own that I thought was", "this kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the", "\"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and a theory", "much as mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was", "as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do", "in the theory of other minds as discussed in reference", "of my own that I thought was much bigger than", "he made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank.", "the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned", "strange for the person reading it? I made a distinction", "of the climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate", "in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of", "wrong by including a link to my website, or did", "outside of the climate of opinion whether he made a", "too strange for the person reading it? I made a", "solved a famous open problem. How do I convince people", "respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles.", "a famous open problem. How do I convince people in", "five hours after it was posted. I'm not sure it's", "of execution or intent, or was part of it just", "(which I invented or reinvented) in the theory of other", "issues between a theory of like minds (which can be", "it was posted. I'm not sure it's my best work", "including a link to my website, or did I come", "was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including", "best work but I tried to have a heart to", "a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own that", "the climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery", "have a heart to heart comment to someone dealing with", "people have minds just like mine\"), and a theory of", "have minds just like mine\"), and a theory of alien", "they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien", "because of execution or intent, or was part of it", "from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as", "alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds as much", "a crank, or something else? There were no comments, positive", "I'm not sure it's my best work but I tried", "I have solved a famous open problem. How do I", "comment to someone dealing with being outside of the climate", "Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff", "a theory of like minds (which can be described as", "discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory", "website, or did I come off as a crank, or", "hours after it was posted. I'm not sure it's my", "response to [I believe I have solved a famous open", "like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which means", "link to my website, or did I come off as", "something else? There were no comments, positive or negative, and", "was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to", "It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by", "minds (which can be described as \"Other people have minds", "that I thought was much bigger than it was, and", "achievement of my own that I thought was much bigger", "bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead", "distinguished within theory of other minds issues between a theory", "of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough.", "famous open problem. How do I convince people in the", "before being deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm", "for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was", "dealing with being outside of the climate of opinion whether", "[I believe I have solved a famous open problem. How", "I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of", "but I tried to have a heart to heart comment", "heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com?", "or did I come off as a crank, or something", "come off as a crank, or something else? There were", "There were no comments, positive or negative, and it had", "a heart to heart comment to someone dealing with being", "minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished", "(which can be described as \"Other people have minds just", "was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them", "distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the theory of", "I made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in", "that mentioned an achievement of my own that I thought", "like minds (which can be described as \"Other people have", "How do I convince people in the field that I", "negative, and it had two upvotes before being deleted five", "\"Other people have minds as much as mine, but they're", "deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including a", "to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or the like?", "was much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for", "theory of other minds issues between a theory of like", "of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or was", "theory of other minds as discussed in reference to the", "I thought was much bigger than it was, and respectful", "much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for referees", "opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or was a", "the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution", "of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or intent,", "attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because", "the theory of other minds as discussed in reference to", "means \"Other people have minds as much as mine, but", "people have minds as much as mine, but they're often", "other minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I", "mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference", "to write a response to [I believe I have solved", "do I convince people in the field that I am", "crank, or something else? There were no comments, positive or", "reinvented) in the theory of other minds as discussed in", "than it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of", "being deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm not", "deleted because of execution or intent, or was part of", "invented or reinvented) in the theory of other minds as", "I come off as a crank, or something else? There", "and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them as", "part of it just too strange for the person reading", "legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind", "that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement", "to my website, or did I come off as a", "of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of", "outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of", "be described as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"),", "crank. Is this kind of heart to heart (or attempt)", "it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing", "with being outside of the climate of opinion whether he", "(or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted", "whether he made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate", "\"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or the like? Thanks,", "was part of it just too strange for the person", "an achievement of my own that I thought was much", "reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other", "I invented or reinvented) in the theory of other minds", "empathy for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It", "write a response to [I believe I have solved a", "it's my best work but I tried to have a", "made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is", "heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it", "it just too strange for the person reading it? I", "my website, or did I come off as a crank,", "but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to", "minds (which means \"Other people have minds as much as", "by including a link to my website, or did I", "reading it? I made a distinction (which I invented or", "of it just too strange for the person reading it?", "to have a heart to heart comment to someone dealing", "after it was posted. I'm not sure it's my best", "to heart comment to someone dealing with being outside of", "of like minds (which can be described as \"Other people", "thought was much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy", "upvotes before being deleted five hours after it was posted.", "a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the theory", "two upvotes before being deleted five hours after it was", "just too strange for the person reading it? I made", "discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of", "or was part of it just too strange for the", "of other minds issues between a theory of like minds", "tried to have a heart to heart comment to someone", "of other minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum:", "academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or intent, or", "I do wrong by including a link to my website,", "to someone dealing with being outside of the climate of", "Was it deleted because of execution or intent, or was", "or reinvented) in the theory of other minds as discussed", "someone dealing with being outside of the climate of opinion", "my own that I thought was much bigger than it", "legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to heart (or", "the person reading it? I made a distinction (which I", "to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was", "enough. Did I do wrong by including a link to", "was posted. I'm not sure it's my best work but", "no comments, positive or negative, and it had two upvotes", "theory of like minds (which can be described as \"Other", "minds just like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds", "instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically", "(which means \"Other people have minds as much as mine,", "my best work but I tried to have a heart", "problem. How do I convince people in the field that", "viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did", "or intent, or was part of it just too strange", "spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds issues between", "crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own that I", "as much as mine, but they're often different from mine.\").", "own that I thought was much bigger than it was,", "between a theory of like minds (which can be described", "I distinguished within theory of other minds issues between a", "in the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that", "not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own", "different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed", "did I come off as a crank, or something else?", "minds as much as mine, but they're often different from", "climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or", "positive or negative, and it had two upvotes before being", "had two upvotes before being deleted five hours after it", "deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm not sure", "open problem. How do I convince people in the field", "posted. I'm not sure it's my best work but I", "ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including a link", "I tried to have a heart to heart comment to", "people in the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f)", "execution or intent, or was part of it just too", "as a crank, or something else? There were no comments,", "heart comment to someone dealing with being outside of the", "obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong", "off as a crank, or something else? There were no", "just like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which", "the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or", "them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I", "often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\"", "Is this kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside", "else? There were no comments, positive or negative, and it", "to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds", "or something else? There were no comments, positive or negative,", "I tried to write a response to [I believe I", "or negative, and it had two upvotes before being deleted", "tried to write a response to [I believe I have", "sure it's my best work but I tried to have", "as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within", "other minds issues between a theory of like minds (which", "can be described as \"Other people have minds just like", "have minds as much as mine, but they're often different", "heart to heart comment to someone dealing with being outside", "to [I believe I have solved a famous open problem.", "for the person reading it? I made a distinction (which", "as mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the", "field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an" ]
[ "the audience of Academia will benefit from it, but I", "am not sure what the best way is to link", "about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the", "what the best way is to link to that discussion.", "from it, but I am not sure what the best", "discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of", "but I am not sure what the best way is", "Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739).", "Academia will benefit from it, but I am not sure", "I am not sure what the best way is to", "an interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about", "in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will", "[(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience", "it, but I am not sure what the best way", "will benefit from it, but I am not sure what", "interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use", "benefit from it, but I am not sure what the", "of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of", "academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will benefit", "not sure what the best way is to link to", "sure what the best way is to link to that", "think the audience of Academia will benefit from it, but", "audience of Academia will benefit from it, but I am", "Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I", "was an interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated site", "site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think", "the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in", "of Academia will benefit from it, but I am not", "statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia", "I think the audience of Academia will benefit from it,", "stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic", "at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics", "papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will benefit from", "There was an interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated" ]
[ "being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for", "### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a", "site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation", "inviting. Fall is also when a new academic year starts.", "design, which will give you your own unique theme that", "already begun work on your site's design, which will give", "no major design changes, we're hoping to launch the site", "on the images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)", "site as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers /", "site as unique, even while you share common elements with", "our design from calmness to more contrasted and focused area.", "to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the", "love to hear your feedback. If there are no major", "we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you for", "setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ###", "are lighted up by the green and the red. This", "question list, I will tweak some vertical space and font", "view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall", "This way we can balance our design from calmness to", "Concept For our academia.se community's site design and branding, I", "### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design and", "figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in", "for setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png)", "network, along with the ability to migrate content to and", "at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will", "designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you", "effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a", "promote our site as well. ### Swag Business cards /", "in a bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png)", "Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the image", "your site as unique, even while you share common elements", "and lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I", "that show you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange", "year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony", "image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe", "online for setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board", "that reflects your topic and culture. This will help brand", "[![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image to", "branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I", "site is now starting the process of moving out of", "your site's design, which will give you your own unique", "up by the green and the red. This way we", "the red. This way we can balance our design from", "space and font size during the coding to have the", "I'd love to hear your feedback. If there are no", "[![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the images", "on by books through the years, they are the origins", "believe the design captures the mood I was going for.", "board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png)", "size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image", "is also when a new academic year starts. All the", "launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design", "new academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm", "conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal", "going for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If there", "with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and", "you for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank", "community's site design and branding, I wanted to have a", "of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ###", "has a personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered", "in the network, along with the ability to migrate content", "to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main", "to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ###", "artwork I found online for setting up a mood board.", "fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design", "sites in the network, along with the ability to migrate", "also when a new academic year starts. All the pastel", "Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you will", "our site as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers", "contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has", "[![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak some vertical", "it. I've gathered some artwork I found online for setting", "the image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t", "says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For", "non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works", "Main illustration Click on the image to view it at", "now starting the process of moving out of beta to", "Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because this site", "as unique, even while you share common elements with other", "through the years, they are the origins of teaching. The", "process of moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated", "— and the notoriety of a public launch that says,", "size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak some", "For our academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted", "as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt", "works in other mediums to promote our site as well.", "an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your", "stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to view it", "academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and", "up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color", "I found online for setting up a mood board. ###", "### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on", "knowledge has always been passed on by books through the", "books through the years, they are the origins of teaching.", "the image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I", "perks. I have already begun work on your site's design,", "content to and from other sites — and the notoriety", "size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on", "the origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke some", "a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up,", "it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It", "t-shirt Click on the image to view it at full", "color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting.", "family. Once the design goes up, you will receive a", "shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the images to", "design captures the mood I was going for. I'd love", "--- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've", "Fall is also when a new academic year starts. All", "on the image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)", "of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes", "and the notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations,", "green and the red. This way we can balance our", "Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of", "pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they are lighted", "will receive a link in the footer of other sites", "it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I", "to and from other sites — and the notoriety of", "in other mediums to promote our site as well. ###", "wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's", "of teaching. The idea was to evoke some books in", "moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well", "Click on the image to view it at full size.", "you because this site is now starting the process of", "warm and inviting. Fall is also when a new academic", "I was going for. I'd love to hear your feedback.", "from other sites — and the notoriety of a public", "at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on", "goes up, you will receive a link in the footer", "by the green and the red. This way we can", "### Logo All the knowledge has always been passed on", "which will give you your own unique theme that reflects", "life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with a", "out of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done!", "/ stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to view", "well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click", "was going for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If", "starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and", "illustration style. It has a personal and lively feel to", "hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and lively feel", "community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback!", "while you share common elements with other sites that show", "senior product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to", "colors bring calm and harmony and they are lighted up", "now are mortarboards. Click on the image to view it", "lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I found", "for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you", "culture. This will help brand your site as unique, even", "will help brand your site as unique, even while you", "Stéphane, senior product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted", "some books in a bookcase but in a non figurative", "Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges", "gathered some artwork I found online for setting up a", "to it. I've gathered some artwork I found online for", "mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color", "a personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered some", "part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design", "at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the", "become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your", "has always been passed on by books through the years,", "design goes up, you will receive a link in the", "migrate content to and from other sites — and the", "are the origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke", "I've gathered some artwork I found online for setting up", "for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If there are", "comes with a few perks. I have already begun work", "work on your site's design, which will give you your", "major design changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon.", "of moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated site!", "They now are mortarboards. Click on the image to view", "teaching. The idea was to evoke some books in a", "of other sites in the network, along with the ability", "there are no major design changes, we're hoping to launch", "Regarding the question list, I will tweak some vertical space", "Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design and branding,", "to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question", "Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color", "by books through the years, they are the origins of", "the coding to have the most perfect rendering across browsers.", "our academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted to", "Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I have already", "Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because this", "with other sites that show you are part of a", "to migrate content to and from other sites — and", "and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always", "based on your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards.", "own unique theme that reflects your topic and culture. This", "a few perks. I have already begun work on your", "calm and harmony and they are lighted up by the", "/ t-shirt Click on the image to view it at", "receive a link in the footer of other sites in", "Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you will receive", "you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se", "the design captures the mood I was going for. I'd", "to promote our site as well. ### Swag Business cards", "in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized", "always been passed on by books through the years, they", "was to evoke some books in a bookcase but in", "academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted to have", "been passed on by books through the years, they are", "footer of other sites in the network, along with the", "notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally", "![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds", "I believe this modernized logo works in other mediums to", "link in the footer of other sites in the network,", "begun work on your site's design, which will give you", "common elements with other sites that show you are part", "product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate", "beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation", "awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued", "Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme", "because this site is now starting the process of moving", "other sites in the network, along with the ability to", "I wanted to congratulate you because this site is now", "the design goes up, you will receive a link in", "Click on the images to view them at full size.", "to launch the site soon. Thank you for being an", "Once the design goes up, you will receive a link", "show you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family.", "idea was to evoke some books in a bookcase but", "congratulate you because this site is now starting the process", "autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when a", "full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click", "sites — and the notoriety of a public launch that", "![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's", "I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think", "have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively", "view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration", "of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made", "reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is", "I will tweak some vertical space and font size during", "the mood I was going for. I'd love to hear", "the ability to migrate content to and from other sites", "we can balance our design from calmness to more contrasted", "in the footer of other sites in the network, along", "changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you", "mortarboards. Click on the image to view it at full", "but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this", "some vertical space and font size during the coding to", "your topic and culture. This will help brand your site", "design changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank", "the network, along with the ability to migrate content to", "share common elements with other sites that show you are", "to congratulate you because this site is now starting the", "personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork", "a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site", "All the knowledge has always been passed on by books", "and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the image", "comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the image to", "public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ###", "of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when", "on the image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)", "bring calm and harmony and they are lighted up by", "up, you will receive a link in the footer of", "are no major design changes, we're hoping to launch the", "and inviting. Fall is also when a new academic year", "have already begun work on your site's design, which will", "It has a personal and lively feel to it. I've", "hear your feedback. If there are no major design changes,", "made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site", "theme that reflects your topic and culture. This will help", "is now starting the process of moving out of beta", "the process of moving out of beta to become a", "a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme", "me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also", "Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes", "feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn", "starting the process of moving out of beta to become", "to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most", "other mediums to promote our site as well. ### Swag", "your own unique theme that reflects your topic and culture.", "full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak", "view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list,", "design and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\"", "the notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you", "badges based on your answers and comments. They now are", "site design and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus", "size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood I", "they are the origins of teaching. The idea was to", "it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design", "the knowledge has always been passed on by books through", "list, I will tweak some vertical space and font size", "design Click on the images to view them at full", "captures the mood I was going for. I'd love to", "\"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with", "### Main illustration Click on the image to view it", "unique theme that reflects your topic and culture. This will", "image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)", "you for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based", "area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always been passed", "to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and", "along with the ability to migrate content to and from", "sites that show you are part of a bigger Stack", "will tweak some vertical space and font size during the", "Overall site design Click on the images to view them", "[![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood I was", "soon. Thank you for being an awesome community! --- ###", "ability to migrate content to and from other sites —", "years, they are the origins of teaching. The idea was", "valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on your answers", "are mortarboards. Click on the image to view it at", "site's design, which will give you your own unique theme", "it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures", "Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few", "other sites — and the notoriety of a public launch", "a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\"", "from calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo", "bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe", "on your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click", "The idea was to evoke some books in a bookcase", "you share common elements with other sites that show you", "balance our design from calmness to more contrasted and focused", "it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site", "### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me", "hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you for being", "the image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding", "I believe the design captures the mood I was going", "at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design", "answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the", "illustration Click on the image to view it at full", "### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This", "mood I was going for. I'd love to hear your", "will give you your own unique theme that reflects your", "I've changed the badges based on your answers and comments.", "a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo", "image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the", "calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All", "a bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I", "size during the coding to have the most perfect rendering", "This will help brand your site as unique, even while", "and font size during the coding to have the most", "your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on your", "scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall", "First, I wanted to congratulate you because this site is", "they are lighted up by the green and the red.", "more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge", "even while you share common elements with other sites that", "this site is now starting the process of moving out", "for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on", "reflects your topic and culture. This will help brand your", "way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in other", "scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm", "think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style.", "that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept", "found online for setting up a mood board. ### Mood", "logo works in other mediums to promote our site as", "unique, even while you share common elements with other sites", "give you your own unique theme that reflects your topic", "are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the", "### Overall site design Click on the images to view", "style. It has a personal and lively feel to it.", "you your own unique theme that reflects your topic and", "few perks. I have already begun work on your site's", "bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you", "the images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)", "your feedback. If there are no major design changes, we're", "to evoke some books in a bookcase but in a", "the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they are", "lighted up by the green and the red. This way", "feedback! I've changed the badges based on your answers and", "mediums to promote our site as well. ### Swag Business", "a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed", "way we can balance our design from calmness to more", "a new academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring", "\"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our", "and culture. This will help brand your site as unique,", "cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to", "Thank you for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit:", "vertical space and font size during the coding to have", "and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel.", "feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I found online", "and harmony and they are lighted up by the green", "on your site's design, which will give you your own", "feedback. If there are no major design changes, we're hoping", "If there are no major design changes, we're hoping to", "you will receive a link in the footer of other", "design from calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ###", "the years, they are the origins of teaching. The idea", "red. This way we can balance our design from calmness", "them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click", "to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the", "a link in the footer of other sites in the", "finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's", "full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the", "a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and lively", "font size during the coding to have the most perfect", "evoke some books in a bookcase but in a non", "images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ###", "the green and the red. This way we can balance", "elements with other sites that show you are part of", "the footer of other sites in the network, along with", "the site soon. Thank you for being an awesome community!", "some artwork I found online for setting up a mood", "origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke some books", "I think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration", "scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn.", "modernized logo works in other mediums to promote our site", "This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and", "Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I", "All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they", "when a new academic year starts. All the pastel colors", "full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood", "### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed", "[![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the", "tweak some vertical space and font size during the coding", "help brand your site as unique, even while you share", "with a few perks. I have already begun work on", "brand your site as unique, even while you share common", "site design Click on the images to view them at", "with the ability to migrate content to and from other", "believe this modernized logo works in other mediums to promote", "Graduation comes with a few perks. I have already begun", "changed the badges based on your answers and comments. They", "site soon. Thank you for being an awesome community! ---", "other sites that show you are part of a bigger", "I have already begun work on your site's design, which", "topic and culture. This will help brand your site as", "It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when a new", "Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I have", "done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with", "I’m Stéphane, senior product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I", "this modernized logo works in other mediums to promote our", "Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the", "passed on by books through the years, they are the", "harmony and they are lighted up by the green and", "the badges based on your answers and comments. They now", "can balance our design from calmness to more contrasted and", "at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because", "wanted to congratulate you because this site is now starting", "books in a bookcase but in a non figurative way.", "your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on", "launch the site soon. Thank you for being an awesome", "most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has", "on the image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)", "focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always been", "and the red. This way we can balance our design", "the question list, I will tweak some vertical space and", "during the coding to have the most perfect rendering across", "and from other sites — and the notoriety of a", "and they are lighted up by the green and the", "![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in other mediums", "you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once", "Logo All the knowledge has always been passed on by", "to hear your feedback. If there are no major design", "[![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image to view", "and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks.", "Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed the", "view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design" ]
[ "Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to", "a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is", "Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will", "community. We reset the ads once a year, every December.", "apply to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads?", "ad is very valuable to the community and will continue", "on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There", "else to the body of the post. If you want", "### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold** an", "This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to", "with the above required form. ### Image requirements * The", "should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to", "Promotion Ads for your own site, not just to apply", "site's twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting", "every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that", "it is a good idea to repost it. It may", "sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads", "it. It may be helpful to give it a new", "'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the", "is a good idea to repost it. It may be", "information and resources that are relevant to your own community's", "cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps", "with that, you now have the opportunity to setup Community", "we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain", "accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their", "exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post", "Must be GIF or PNG No animated GIFs ", "and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests,", "year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while", "imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year", "can check out the ads that have met the threshold", "In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this", "ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the", "Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) ", "* anything else your community would genuinely be interested in", "hurrah! And with that, you now have the opportunity to", "### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some", "this question must conform to the following rules, or they", "before it will be shown on the main site. You", "site. For example, you might promote the following things: ", "relevant to not just the subject matter of the community,", "be shown on the main site. You can check out", "Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community", "design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have", "your own site, not just to apply to other sites.", "of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable", "the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old", "post to this question must* conform to the following rules,", "once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have", "You guys have gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah!", "you might promote the following things: * the site's twitter", "blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else your", "would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future", "year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions", "the answer form with the above required form. ### Image", "and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown.", "every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against", "Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not just to", "cool events or conferences * anything else your community would", "this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements", "* interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences", "the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources ", "vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community", "find out about the stuff your community deems important. This", "to your own community's interests, both for those already in", "functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer", "the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All", "score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it", "show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do", "Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the", "not add anything else to the body of the post*.", "things: the site's twitter account * academic websites and", "give it a new face in the process, so as", "they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in", "restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If", "to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the", "this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose", "form. ### Image requirements * The image that you create", "serves as a way to promote information and resources that", "uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No", "resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both", "previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very", "years, while other things will wane to allow for new", "be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show", "for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors", "of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you", "There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet", "to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The", "The image that you create must be 220 x 250", "year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers", "community, but to the current status of the community. We", "purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer", "the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition", "(currently 6*) before it will be shown on the main", "example, you might promote the following things: the site's", "to not just the subject matter of the community, but", "to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also", "important. This also serves as a way to promote information", "rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should", "over the years, while other things will wane to allow", "answers you post to this question must* conform to the", "check out the ads that have met the threshold with", "this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above", "This also serves as a way to promote information and", "do it in the comments. 2. The question must always", "must conform to the following rules, or they will be", "ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a", "might promote the following things: * the site's twitter account", "so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from", "be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\")", "answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown", "be 220 x 250 pixels * Must be hosted through", "a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6)", "December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting", "the community and those yet to join. ### Why do", "and will continue to be so, it is a good", "This is a method for the community to control what", "it a new face in the process, so as to", "And with that, you now have the opportunity to setup", "other things will wane to allow for new faces to", "but to the current status of the community. We reset", "required form. ### Image requirements * The image that you", "your own community's interests, both for those already in the", "their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for", "in the community and those yet to join. ### Why", "ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in", "What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted", "not just to apply to other sites. ### What are", "promote information and resources that are relevant to your own", "that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels ", "against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a", "a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no", "must be 220 x 250 pixels* * Must be hosted", "graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have the opportunity", "served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads", "pixels** * Must be hosted through our standard image uploader", "advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community", "[![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ```", "of the community. We reset the ads once a year,", "gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you", "Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows", "is for future visitors to find out about the stuff", "ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form", "keep the material in the ads relevant to not just", "events or conferences anything else your community would genuinely", "shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This", "will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do", "you now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads", "file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is", "while other things will wane to allow for new faces", "If a particular service or ad is very valuable to", "helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served", "for your own site, not just to apply to other", "220 x 250 pixels * Must be hosted through our", "to promote information and resources that are relevant to your", "tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of", "questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality", "show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this,", " academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs", "always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged", "of this question is the vetting process. Images of the", "matter of the community, but to the current status of", "guys have gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah! And", "interested in The goal is for future visitors to find", "as a way to promote information and resources that are", "to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion", "a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The", "future visitors to find out about the stuff your community", "or conferences anything else your community would genuinely be", "conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored.", "out about the stuff your community deems important. This also", "to be so, it is a good idea to repost", "The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images", "### How does it work? The answers you post to", "the ads that have met the threshold with basic click", "else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal", "limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold", "with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In", "just the subject matter of the community, but to the", "be helpful to give it a new face in the", "other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion", "the post. If you want to discuss something, do it", "the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure.", "must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions", "an answer must meet (currently 6*) before it will be", "now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for", "visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the", "cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable", "the community. We reset the ads once a year, every", "do we reset the ads every year? Some services will", "community deems important. This also serves as a way to", "face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery", "for newer things. This helps keep the material in the", "### Image requirements * The image that you create must", "tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements,", "shown on the main site. You can check out the", "own community's interests, both for those already in the community", "to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every", "2. The question must always be tagged with the magic", "Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that", "through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF", "150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a *minimum score", " cool events or conferences * anything else your community", "* Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur)", "mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add", "http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else", "to give it a new face in the process, so", "also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form.", "will continue to be so, it is a good idea", "anything else to the body of the post. If you", "do not add anything else to the body of the", "wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting", "be interested in The goal is for future visitors to", "magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to", "or ad is very valuable to the community and will", "setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not just", "Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will", "services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things", "Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score", "tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag.", "to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please", "join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year?", "form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url", "that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for", "are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main", "[community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling", "be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute", "be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact", "Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on", "will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the", "community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for", "out the ads that have met the threshold with basic", "image that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels", "way to promote information and resources that are relevant to", "have gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with", "the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and", "maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane", "to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate", "helpful to give it a new face in the process,", "repost it. It may be helpful to give it a", "a new face in the process, so as to prevent", "what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example,", "reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness", "and resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events", "form with the above required form. ### Image requirements ", "Ads for your own site, not just to apply to", "gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that,", "or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on", "interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences ", "is very valuable to the community and will continue to", "answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline", "[1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything", "own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now", "the body of the post. If you want to discuss", "the subject matter of the community, but to the current", "discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question", "websites and resources interesting campus story blogs * cool", "goal is for future visitors to find out about the", "it will be shown on the main site. You can", "also serves as a way to promote information and resources", "the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on", "the current status of the community. We reset the ads", "advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the", "process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting", "post. If you want to discuss something, do it in", "of the post. If you want to discuss something, do", "to the current status of the community. We reset the", "resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events or", "and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset", "Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services", "We reset the ads once a year, every December. The", "just to apply to other sites. ### What are Community", "above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that", "your community deems important. This also serves as a way", "yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads", "the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the", "body of the post. If you want to discuss something,", "you post to this question must* conform to the following", "be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads?", "requirements * The image that you create must be 220", "must meet (currently 6*) before it will be shown on", "an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service", "exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]:", " the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources", "our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or", "the community and will continue to be so, it is", "add anything else to the body of the post. If", "will be shown on the main site. You can check", "advertisements that will show up on the main site, in", "sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process.", "main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this", "control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For", "you want to discuss something, do it in the comments.", "out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep", "the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with", "250 pixels * Must be hosted through our standard image", "community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site,", "want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2.", "have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your", "community and those yet to join. ### Why do we", "Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other", "the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the", "not just the subject matter of the community, but to", "will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will", "on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not", "question must* conform to the following rules, or they will", "site. You can check out the ads that have met", "For example, you might promote the following things: * the", "from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How", "a way to promote information and resources that are relevant", "method for the community to control what gets promoted to", "GIF or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit", "for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every", "### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is", "campus story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything", "reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular", "community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ###", "of the ad from getting stale after a year of", "process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad", "``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url", "stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it", "valuable to the community and will continue to be so,", "the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own", "continue to be so, it is a good idea to", "the following things: * the site's twitter account * academic", "How does it work? The answers you post to this", "story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else", "advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements", "in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on", "[2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else to", "community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the", "All answers should be in the exact form of: ```", "is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently", "of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum", "Please do not add anything else to the body of", "your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you", "KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold*", "up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and", "standard image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF or PNG", "good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to", "promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might", "account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus story", "ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the", "to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not", "have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the", "the community, but to the current status of the community.", "a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful", "is a method for the community to control what gets", "It may be helpful to give it a new face", "to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community", "that will show up on the main site, in the", "Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer must", "enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we", "own site, not just to apply to other sites. ###", "enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills", "of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form", "in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter", "promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from", "You can check out the ads that have met the", "a method for the community to control what gets promoted", "be so, it is a good idea to repost it.", "If you want to discuss something, do it in the", "addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag", "conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be interested", "do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method", "after a year of exposure. ### How does it work?", "promote the following things: * the site's twitter account ", "of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]:", "deems important. This also serves as a way to promote", "the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of", "* The image that you create must be 220 x", "Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up", "a particular service or ad is very valuable to the", "Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold** an answer", "it work? The answers you post to this question must", "something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must", "may be helpful to give it a new face in", "ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads", "allows old ads that have served their purpose to be", "prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after", "answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements", "http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add anything else to the", "newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads", "community's interests, both for those already in the community and", "status of the community. We reset the ads once a", "comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the", "the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the", "relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already", "\"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the", "question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are", "ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or", "visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems", "that have served their purpose to be cycled out for", "does it work? The answers you post to this question", "every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years,", "year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have", "The answers you post to this question must* conform to", "GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB", "those already in the community and those yet to join.", "particular service or ad is very valuable to the community", "things will wane to allow for new faces to show", "PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file", "the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a", "getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does", "threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will", "Ads? This is a method for the community to control", "size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a", "ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads", "### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are", "6*) before it will be shown on the main site.", "allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads", "on the main site. You can check out the ads", "the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of", "those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the", "for future visitors to find out about the stuff your", "and allows old ads that have served their purpose to", "to repost it. It may be helpful to give it", "and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have the", "Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a", "subject matter of the community, but to the current status", "will show up on the main site, in the right", "ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out", "meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the", "question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show", "on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose", "the material in the ads relevant to not just the", "* Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs", "about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves", "for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the", "the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2]", "old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled", "``` Please *do not add anything else to the body", "ads that have met the threshold with basic click stats", "be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must", "have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher", "to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote", "ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ###", "The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads", "the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with", "the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion", "x 250 pixels** * Must be hosted through our standard", "your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is", "(imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No animated", "right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting", "the site. For example, you might promote the following things:", "are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those", "faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps", "in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged", "the years, while other things will wane to allow for", "hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be", "have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous", "material in the ads relevant to not just the subject", "to the body of the post*. If you want to", " Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ###", "to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things.", "fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material", "new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year", "both for those already in the community and those yet", "or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be", "up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The", "that have met the threshold with basic click stats [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/ads/display/907).", "you create must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must", "in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is", "for those already in the community and those yet to", "the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over", "to apply to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion", "voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why", "provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be", "Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show", "community and will continue to be so, it is a", "to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1.", "The goal is for future visitors to find out about", "the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the", "site, not just to apply to other sites. ### What", "in The goal is for future visitors to find out", "site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question", "tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required", "following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers", "Image requirements * The image that you create must be", "show up on the main site, in the right sidebar.", "we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for", "will wane to allow for new faces to show up.", "academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs ", "on the site. For example, you might promote the following", "to find out about the stuff your community deems important.", "reset the ads once a year, every December. The community", "as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting", "1. All answers should be in the exact form of:", "interests, both for those already in the community and those", "The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an", "genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors", "opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site,", "already in the community and those yet to join. ###", "new face in the process, so as to prevent the", "idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give", "to the community and will continue to be so, it", "the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have", "things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant", "image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG ", "from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad", "that, you now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion", "helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not", "is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided,", "very valuable to the community and will continue to be", "purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of", "the main site. You can check out the ads that", "anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The", "are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to", "current status of the community. We reset the ads once", "to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site.", "of the community, but to the current status of the", "usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to", "minimum score threshold* an answer must meet (currently 6) before", "work? The answers you post to this question must conform", "to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale", "in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of", "no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle.", "twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus", "following things: * the site's twitter account * academic websites", "service or ad is very valuable to the community and", "No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of", "community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad", "* No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size", "create must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must be", "stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a", "the above required form. ### Image requirements The image", "pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ###", "the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as", "are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements", "be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This", "it in the comments. 2. The question must always be", "so, it is a good idea to repost it. It", "animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150", "to this question must conform to the following rules, or", "main site. You can check out the ads that have" ]
[ "lots of wasted space... is it a bug or a", "ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as", "a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks,", "Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on", "btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF, it", "on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere", "as well. The problem seems to be specific to Chrome", "it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant,", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of", "space... is it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome", "is it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on", "14 looks fine as well. The problem seems to be", "or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT:", "Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF,", "unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a bug or", "bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw.", "Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked", "Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as well.", "I double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok.", "I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space...", "Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with", "well. The problem seems to be specific to Chrome on", "running on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem", "with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running", "feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double", "problem seems to be specific to Chrome on OSX :s", "wasted space... is it a bug or a feature? Using", "of wasted space... is it a bug or a feature?", "Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem seems to", "fine as well. The problem seems to be specific to", "Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The", "looks fine as well. The problem seems to be specific", "on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem seems", "think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is", "EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks", "The problem seems to be specific to Chrome on OSX", "a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a", "a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I", "it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks", "bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a bug", "double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also", "OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted", "it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it", "and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint", "FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14", "checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome", "looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots" ]
[ "we're out of beta, will we get access to the", "will we get access to the full set of stackexchange", "beta, will we get access to the full set of", "access to the full set of stackexchange sites for migrations", "to the full set of stackexchange sites for migrations ?", "out of beta, will we get access to the full", "of beta, will we get access to the full set", "get access to the full set of stackexchange sites for", "that we're out of beta, will we get access to", "Now that we're out of beta, will we get access", "we get access to the full set of stackexchange sites" ]
[ "...\" starts a comment under the answer, not a new", "scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh it's an", "the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To", "comment\". To give an idea of what I mean: ![enter", "mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ...", "my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction", "and I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not", "it's an answer, not a comment\". To give an idea", "visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts", "format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer", "HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under the answer,", "\"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To give an", "of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from", "under the answer, not a new answer. --- Or is", "not a new answer. --- Or is it just me?", "I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below as", "keep seeing the answer below as a comment. I scroll", "reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below as a", "I scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh it's", "nitpick but with the new format, when I'm reading answers,", "comment. I scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh", "get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\".", "answer, not a new answer. --- Or is it just", "seeing the answer below as a comment. I scroll down", "below as a comment. I scroll down and I get", "realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To give", "A nitpick but with the new format, when I'm reading", "with the new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep", "what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate", "\"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under the", "give an idea of what I mean: ![enter image description", "an answer, not a comment\". To give an idea of", "idea of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot", "them write ...\" starts a comment under the answer, not", "not a comment\". To give an idea of what I", "write ...\" starts a comment under the answer, not a", "reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a", "is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment", "the new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing", "I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).)", "starts a comment under the answer, not a new answer.", "comment under the answer, not a new answer. --- Or", "answer, not a comment\". To give an idea of what", "from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that", "To give an idea of what I mean: ![enter image", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE", "but with the new format, when I'm reading answers, I", "answer below as a comment. I scroll down and I", "immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\"", "as a comment. I scroll down and I get the", "a comment. I scroll down and I get the realisation", "new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the", "that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under", "the answer below as a comment. I scroll down and", "an idea of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png)", "I keep seeing the answer below as a comment. I", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1.", "... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them", "a comment\". To give an idea of what I mean:", "(Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is", "I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a", "answers, I keep seeing the answer below as a comment.", "the answer, not a new answer. --- Or is it", "when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below", "down and I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer,", "a comment under the answer, not a new answer. ---" ]
[ "can claim that the answer is wrong by any merit.", "the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I wrote", "n semesters and it works like a charm...* > >", "think anyone of us can claim that the answer is", "any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a", "good fit based on how we (and other SE sites)", "across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding", "wrote on my comment, I do like what the question", "can disagree on to what extent we agree, but essentially", "charm...* > > > I don't think anyone of us", "answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be", "merit. We can disagree on to what extent we agree,", "Would it be too harsh to vote/flag this kind of", "the question is going after but I can't help thinking", "should have in class. As I wrote on my comment,", "mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag this kind", "any merit. We can disagree on to what extent we", "it stands, there is no right answer to this question.", "I was checking out the recent questions and came across", "comment, I do like what the question is going after", "the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh", "going after but I can't help thinking that it is", "We can disagree on to what extent we agree, but", "it is essentially not a good fit based on how", "is essentially not a good fit based on how we", "in class X for n semesters and it works like", "extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or", "was checking out the recent questions and came across [this", "or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to the", "this in class X for n semesters and it works", "Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag", "the teacher is also responsible for the catching students attention", "don't think anyone of us can claim that the answer", "a valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would", "that it is essentially not a good fit based on", "(and other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there", "if necessary. I tried this in class X for n", "works like a charm...* > > > I don't think", "I think the teacher is also responsible for the catching", "answer is wrong by any merit. We can disagree on", "the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is", "responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary.", "we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner)", "that the answer is wrong by any merit. We can", "> > > I don't think anyone of us can", "As I wrote on my comment, I do like what", "semesters and it works like a charm...* > > >", "a charm...* > > > I don't think anyone of", "\"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible for the", "came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll", "attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class", "question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think", "recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially", "SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is no", "essentially not a good fit based on how we (and", "help thinking that it is essentially not a good fit", "an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in", "based on how we (and other SE sites) normally operate.", "to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too", "what the question is going after but I can't help", "wrong by any merit. We can disagree on to what", "poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As", "I do like what the question is going after but", "anyone of us can claim that the answer is wrong", "would be a valid answer to the question. Am I", "I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag this", "question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to", "answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher is also", "> I don't think anyone of us can claim that", "checking out the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers),", "out the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which", "to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes,", "(no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer", "do like what the question is going after but I", "> \"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible for", "essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be", "teacher is also responsible for the catching students attention by", "stands, there is no right answer to this question. Consider", "spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to", "by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class X", "opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class.", "and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion", "is also responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment,", "answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > >", "> > I don't think anyone of us can claim", "but I can't help thinking that it is essentially not", "think the teacher is also responsible for the catching students", "the answer is wrong* by any merit. We can disagree", "is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should", "is going after but I can't help thinking that it", "disagree on to what extent we agree, but essentially any", "to what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no", "how we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As it", "hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher is", "agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer", "my comment, I do like what the question is going", "what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam,", "is no right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical", "class X* for n semesters and it works like a", "right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: >", "no right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer:", "we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands,", "X for n semesters and it works like a charm...", "one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to the question.", "> > \"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible", "Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the", "sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is no right", "operate. As it stands, there is no right answer to", "this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I", "tried this in class X for n semesters and it", "for the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I", "a good fit based on how we (and other SE", "and it works like a charm...* > > > I", "class. As I wrote on my comment, I do like", "which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers", "there is no right answer to this question. Consider this", "not a good fit based on how we (and other", "like what the question is going after but I can't", "on to what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious", "have in class. As I wrote on my comment, I", "claim that the answer is wrong by any merit. We", "fit based on how we (and other SE sites) normally", "question is going after but I can't help thinking that", "on my comment, I do like what the question is", "I don't think anyone of us can claim that the", "entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class X for", "by any merit. We can disagree on to what extent", "regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I", "like a charm...* > > > I don't think anyone", "one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude", "I can't help thinking that it is essentially not a", "it works like a charm...* > > > I don't", "catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this", "is wrong by any merit. We can disagree on to", "essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have", "be a valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken?", "normally operate. As it stands, there is no right answer", "it be too harsh to vote/flag this kind of question?", "questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an", "students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in", "but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would", "teachers should have in class. As I wrote on my", "semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid", "[this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the", "in class. As I wrote on my comment, I do", "can't help thinking that it is essentially not a good", "also responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment, if", "I tried this in class X for n semesters and", "after but I can't help thinking that it is essentially", "on how we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As", "the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried", "I wrote on my comment, I do like what the", "answer would be a valid answer to the question. Am", "necessary. I tried this in class X for n semesters", "of us can claim that the answer is wrong by", "for n semesters and it works like a charm...* >", "As it stands, there is no right answer to this", "thinking that it is essentially not a good fit based", "other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is", "us can claim that the answer is wrong by any", "this hypothetical answer: > > \"*yes, I think the teacher", "role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I wrote on", "valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it" ]
[ "opportunity for members of the community to pose questions to", "* This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that", "have been selected, a new question will be opened to", "on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. >", "how it'll work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until", "editorial control in the selection of the questions and may", "the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in", "on the same day, give or take time to arrive", "thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed", "two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones", "information on candidates. As a community, you are still free", "questionnaire is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).", "of this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire.", "the phase, the Community Team will select up to 8", "for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are", "decision making time. * Once questions have been selected, a", "candidates. As a community, you are still free to, for", "into at current. * At the end of the phase,", "ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided", "collect potential questions from the users of the site. Post", "questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please only", "> > *The purpose of this thread was to collect", "We reserve some editorial control in the selection of the", "selection of the questions and may opt not to select", "> Here's how it'll work: During the nomination phase,", "post, unlike the prior instruction. * This is a perfect", "to, for example, hold a live chat session with your", "may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how it'll", "in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. * This", "community provided in this thread, to use in addition to", "> The purpose of this thread was to collect questions", "[here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how it'll work: * During", "with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications", "current. * At the end of the phase, the Community", "The questionnaire is now live, and you may find it", "In connection with the moderator elections, we will be holding", "the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of", "perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If", "That said, if I have concerns about any questions in", "or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A.", "are still free to, for example, hold a live chat", "actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total.", "that are specific to your community and issues that you", "> > > Here's how it'll work: * During the", "to be included, the latter ones are if the community", "first two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter", "I will be sure to point this out in comments", "containing 10 questions in total. * This is not the", "Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of this", "community to pose questions to the candidates on the topic", " During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th,", "2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in the", "community and issues that you are running into at current.", "to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is", "to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial", "live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > >", "Team will select up to 8 of the top voted", "May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on", "questions in this fashion, I will be sure to point", "of the community to pose questions to the candidates on", "day, give or take time to arrive for closure), this", "the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may", "At the end of the phase, the Community Team will", "voted questions submitted by the community** provided in this thread,", "total. * This is not the only option that users", "not the only option that users have for gathering information", "host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions", "EDT on the same day, give or take time to", "Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT", "a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity", "the top voted questions submitted by the community** provided in", "is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That", "free to, for example, hold a live chat session with", "only option that users have for gathering information on candidates.", "until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm", "instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions", "questions. We reserve some editorial control in the selection of", "session with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps", "the community to pose questions to the candidates on the", "the candidates. Please only post one question per answer. ", "questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. ", "the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough", "the moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A with", "candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This is not", "new process, feel free to post as a comment here.", "same day, give or take time to arrive for closure),", "to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is", "and issues that you are running into at current. ", "control in the selection of the questions and may opt", "only post one question per answer. We, the Community", "running into at current. * At the end of the", "questions that are specific to your community and issues that", "select *up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted", "This will be done in a single post, unlike the", "election. That said, if I have concerns about any questions", "unlike the prior instruction. This is a perfect opportunity", "that users have for gathering information on candidates. As a", "still free to, for example, hold a live chat session", "UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give", "point this out in comments before the decision making time.", "hold a live chat session with your candidates to ask", "chat session with your candidates to ask further questions, or", "to your community and issues that you are running into", "if I have concerns about any questions in this fashion,", "Community Team, will be providing a small selection of generic", "be included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't", "from what is provided in the Q&A. If you have", "the decision making time. * Once questions have been selected,", "by the community** provided in this thread, to use in", "* We, the Community Team, will be providing a small", "this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2", "issues that you are running into at current. * At", "will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the", "questions and may opt not to select a question that", "voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread was to", "use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We", "it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Here's how it'll work: ", "to moderation or the election. That said, if I have", "8 of the top voted questions submitted by the community", "questions or feedback about this new process, feel free to", "questions submitted by the community* provided in this thread, to", "this new process, feel free to post as a comment", "to point this out in comments before the decision making", "completely voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread was", "at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same", "of the site. Post answers to this question containing any", "Community Team will select up to 8 of the top", "end of the phase, the Community Team will select *up", "take time to arrive for closure), this question will be", "will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will", "may opt not to select a question that is tangential", "be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if", "small selection of generic questions. The first two will be", "be sure to point this out in comments before the", "some editorial control in the selection of the questions and", "selection of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed", "Here's how it'll work: During the nomination phase, (so,", "question per answer. We, the Community Team, will be", "connection with the moderator elections, we will be holding a", "Team, will be providing a small selection of generic questions.", "will select up to 8 of the top voted questions", "up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by", "be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be", "provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions or", "questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the", "to arrive for closure), this question will be open to", "now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > >", "or the election. That said, if I have concerns about", "on candidates. As a community, you are still free to,", "in total. * This is not the only option that", "and may opt not to select a question that is", "per answer. We, the Community Team, will be providing", "from the users of the site. Post answers to this", "* At the end of the phase, the Community Team", "find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how it'll work:", "you are still free to, for example, hold a live", "comments before the decision making time. * Once questions have", "the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control", "what is provided in the Q&A. If you have any", "addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some", "if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be", "candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of the", "generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be", "candidates. Please only post one question per answer. * We,", "is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** >", "be an opportunity for members of the community to pose", "out in comments before the decision making time. * Once", "pose questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation.", "questions have been selected, a new question will be opened", "feedback about this new process, feel free to post as", "would like to ask the candidates. Please only post one", "questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may find", "select a question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation", "phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or", "will be sure to point this out in comments before", "of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to", "the site. Post answers to this question containing any questions", "reserve some editorial control in the selection of the questions", "providing a small selection of generic questions. The first two", "members of the community to pose questions to the candidates", "clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If you", "not to select a question that is tangential or irrelevant", "in the selection of the questions and may opt not", "users of the site. Post answers to this question containing", "holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an", " Once questions have been selected, a new question will", "will be providing a small selection of generic questions. The", "for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This", "to collect potential questions from the users of the site.", "are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will", "candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary.", "have any questions or feedback about this new process, feel", "questions. This will be done in a single post, unlike", "Post answers to this question containing any questions you would", "Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about this", "thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire", "the end of the phase, the Community Team will select", "the only option that users have for gathering information on", "for example, hold a live chat session with your candidates", "be done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction.", "opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your community", "of the top voted questions submitted by the community** provided", "During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at", "you would like to ask the candidates. Please only post", "question containing any questions you would like to ask the", "at current. * At the end of the phase, the", "12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the", "an opportunity for members of the community to pose questions", "moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A with the", "Once questions have been selected, a new question will be", "to pose questions to the candidates on the topic of", "a question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or", "the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > >", "tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said,", "open to collect potential questions from the users of the", "are specific to your community and issues that you are", "work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May", "said, if I have concerns about any questions in this", "the prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to", "latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions.", "time to arrive for closure), this question will be open", "to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by the", "We, the Community Team, will be providing a small selection", "give or take time to arrive for closure), this question", "collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live,", "this question containing any questions you would like to ask", "have concerns about any questions in this fashion, I will", "making time. * Once questions have been selected, a new", "or take time to arrive for closure), this question will", "about this new process, feel free to post as a", "the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about", "one question per answer. * We, the Community Team, will", "or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give or", "your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from", "have for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you", "is provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions", "this question will be open to collect potential questions from", "be open to collect potential questions from the users of", "I have concerns about any questions in this fashion, I", "will be open to collect potential questions from the users", "specific to your community and issues that you are running", "was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is", "will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are", "candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what", "10 questions in total. * This is not the only", "20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day,", "to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now", "example, hold a live chat session with your candidates to", "to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10", "gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are still", "site. Post answers to this question containing any questions you", "sure to point this out in comments before the decision", "further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in", "post one question per answer. * We, the Community Team,", "with the moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A", "included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply", "this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The", "moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of", "question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for", "done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. ", "irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said, if I", "closure), this question will be open to collect potential questions", "to select a question that is tangential or irrelevant to", "for closure), this question will be open to collect potential", "elections, we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates.", "(so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00", "community, you are still free to, for example, hold a", "questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be included,", "nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC,", "the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This is", "the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely", "the election. That said, if I have concerns about any", "selected, a new question will be opened to host the", "topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The", "provided in this thread, to use in addition to the", "> > Here's how it'll work: During the nomination", "this fashion, I will be sure to point this out", "ask the candidates. Please only post one question per answer.", "that you are running into at current. * At the", "the same day, give or take time to arrive for", "a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to", "of the phase, the Community Team will select up to", "voice questions that are specific to your community and issues", "submitted by the community provided in this thread, to use", "in comments before the decision making time. * Once questions", "to this question containing any questions you would like to", "be providing a small selection of generic questions. The first", "guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in the selection", "or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said, if", "perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your", "arrive for closure), this question will be open to collect", "the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done", "this out in comments before the decision making time. ", "This is not the only option that users have for", "the questions and may opt not to select a question", "ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This", "questions from the users of the site. Post answers to", "a small selection of generic questions. The first two will", " This is not the only option that users have", "time. * Once questions have been selected, a new question", "to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions.", "Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for", "live chat session with your candidates to ask further questions,", "that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election.", "is not the only option that users have for gathering", "and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's", "community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in", "the users of the site. Post answers to this question", "questions in total. * This is not the only option", "aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in", "the Community Team will select *up to 8 of the", "fashion, I will be sure to point this out in", "any questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please", "guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if the", "a live chat session with your candidates to ask further", "in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve", "doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in a", "in this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned", "single post, unlike the prior instruction. This is a", "to ask the candidates. Please only post one question per", "like to ask the candidates. Please only post one question", "in this fashion, I will be sure to point this", "users have for gathering information on candidates. As a community,", "The first two will be guaranteed to be included, the", "you have any questions or feedback about this new process,", "the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z", "question will be open to collect potential questions from the", "the selection of the questions and may opt not to", "moderation or the election. That said, if I have concerns", "any questions in this fashion, I will be sure to", "your community and issues that you are running into at", "containing any questions you would like to ask the candidates.", "pm EDT on the same day, give or take time", "This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are", "supply enough questions. This will be done in a single", "a single post, unlike the prior instruction. * This is", "for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you", "prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice", "question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the", "the Community Team, will be providing a small selection of", "purpose of this thread was to collect questions for the", "concerns about any questions in this fashion, I will be", "will be done in a single post, unlike the prior", "we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This", "opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing", "enough questions. This will be done in a single post,", "questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and", "or feedback about this new process, feel free to post", "answer. We, the Community Team, will be providing a", "is completely voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread", "phase, the Community Team will select up to 8 of", "before the decision making time. * Once questions have been", "any questions or feedback about this new process, feel free", "questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation", "be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates,", "answers to this question containing any questions you would like", "*The purpose of this thread was to collect questions for", "are running into at current. At the end of", "of the questions and may opt not to select a", "to voice questions that are specific to your community and", "a new question will be opened to host the actual", "in the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback", "been selected, a new question will be opened to host", "is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific", "opt not to select a question that is tangential or", "If you have any questions or feedback about this new", "it'll work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday,", "Please only post one question per answer. * We, the", "As a community, you are still free to, for example,", "option that users have for gathering information on candidates. As", "for members of the community to pose questions to the", "with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members", "you are running into at current. * At the end", "you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Here's how", "This will be an opportunity for members of the community", "will be an opportunity for members of the community to", "top voted questions submitted by the community provided in this", "the community provided in this thread, to use in addition", "potential questions from the users of the site. Post answers", "a community, you are still free to, for example, hold", "new question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire", "about any questions in this fashion, I will be sure", "of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > The purpose", "4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give or take" ]
[ "Community Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have", "there are. Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election>", "the election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free", "now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination", "visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail,", "candidates there are. Please visit the official election page at", "for more detail, and to participate! If you have general", "this depends on how many candidates there are. Please visit", "Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have three", "phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between two and", "-- just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show", "underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase", "are. Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for", "Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2.", "2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between", "on how many candidates there are. Please visit the official", "If you have general questions about the election process, or", "make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show questions tagged", "2014 Community Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator elections", "elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase", "more detail, and to participate! If you have general questions", "to participate! If you have general questions about the election", "elections take between two and three weeks, but this depends", "or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them", "3. Election phase Most elections take between two and three", "phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take", "between two and three weeks, but this depends on how", "weeks, but this depends on how many candidates there are.", "general questions about the election process, or questions for moderator", "is now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1.", "process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask", "Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases:", "many candidates there are. Please visit the official election page", "candidates, feel free to ask them here on meta --", "and three weeks, but this depends on how many candidates", "how many candidates there are. Please visit the official election", "page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If", "phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase", "Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections", "meta -- just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election", "free to ask them here on meta -- just make", "Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between two", "and to participate! If you have general questions about the", "two and three weeks, but this depends on how many", "election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to", "about the election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel", "to ask them here on meta -- just make sure", "on meta -- just make sure your questions are tagged", "three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election", "questions about the election process, or questions for moderator candidates,", "just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show questions", "participate! If you have general questions about the election process,", "at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If you", "three weeks, but this depends on how many candidates there", "1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most", "election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate!", "have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3.", "the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and", "them here on meta -- just make sure your questions", "take between two and three weeks, but this depends on", "have general questions about the election process, or questions for", "feel free to ask them here on meta -- just", "moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here on meta", "but this depends on how many candidates there are. Please", "Most elections take between two and three weeks, but this", "you have general questions about the election process, or questions", "moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If you have", "Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more", "questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here", "phase Most elections take between two and three weeks, but", "for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here on", "depends on how many candidates there are. Please visit the", "detail, and to participate! If you have general questions about", "here on meta -- just make sure your questions are", "The 2014 Community Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator", "official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to", "sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show questions tagged 'election'\").", "Election phase Most elections take between two and three weeks,", "ask them here on meta -- just make sure your" ]
[ "out there, especially the ones asking for personal career advice.", "option used to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close'", "removed during graduation of the site? Or is it just", "privilege due to my low reputation. This option used to", "my low reputation. This option used to show up immediately", "function removed during graduation of the site? Or is it", "now I don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers", "site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to my", "lost the moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This", "moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This option used", "questions out there, especially the ones asking for personal career", "applies to a few questions out there, especially the ones", "a few questions out there, especially the ones asking for", "when the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due", "used to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link,", "especially the ones asking for personal career advice. Was this", "to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and", "there, especially the ones asking for personal career advice. Was", "during graduation of the site? Or is it just me", "the 'close' link, and now I don't see it anymore", "This applies to a few questions out there, especially the", "and now I don't see it anymore but buried 4", "is it just me who can't access it anymore? Edit", "Or is it just me who can't access it anymore?", "it anymore but buried 4 layers down the flagging dialog.", "Was this function removed during graduation of the site? Or", "the site? Or is it just me who can't access", "career advice. Was this function removed during graduation of the", "anymore? Edit My guess is that when the site graduated", "can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is that when", "the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to", "I lost the moderation privilege due to my low reputation.", "personal career advice. Was this function removed during graduation of", "this function removed during graduation of the site? Or is", "asking for personal career advice. Was this function removed during", "graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to my low", "see it anymore but buried 4 layers down the flagging", "that when the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege", "to a few questions out there, especially the ones asking", "for personal career advice. Was this function removed during graduation", "My guess is that when the site graduated I lost", "guess is that when the site graduated I lost the", "immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't", "upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't see", "I don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers down", "site? Or is it just me who can't access it", "Edit My guess is that when the site graduated I", "up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I", "of the site? Or is it just me who can't", "'close' link, and now I don't see it anymore but", "low reputation. This option used to show up immediately upon", "don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers down the", "who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is that", "advice. Was this function removed during graduation of the site?", "the moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This option", "it just me who can't access it anymore? Edit My", "link, and now I don't see it anymore but buried", "graduation of the site? Or is it just me who", "the ones asking for personal career advice. Was this function", "few questions out there, especially the ones asking for personal", "it anymore? Edit My guess is that when the site", "show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now", "just me who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess", "reputation. This option used to show up immediately upon hitting", "access it anymore? Edit My guess is that when the", "to my low reputation. This option used to show up", "This option used to show up immediately upon hitting the", "is that when the site graduated I lost the moderation", "ones asking for personal career advice. Was this function removed", "me who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is", "hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't see it", "due to my low reputation. This option used to show" ]
[ "is this a good or a bad thing? * If", "position. If the questioner was in the ideal position, they", "in mind, and where research is always about contributing to", "get that the site is heavily skewed to ignore or", "always about contributing to the body of knowledge and never", "In a comment to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > >", "professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not", "about contributing to the body of knowledge and never about", "is always about contributing to the body of knowledge and", "collaborations do not serve anybody who is not in that", "always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only have", "If it is a bad thing, can it be changed", "is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any hint", "where professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors and", "body of knowledge and never about politics? * If so,", "interest of their mentees in mind, and where research is", "is not in that ideal position. If the questioner was", "so, is this a good or a bad thing? ", "have the best interest of their mentees in mind, and", "wonder. Are we in fact presenting an idealised view", "we in fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where", "the body of knowledge and never about politics? * If", "of their mentees in mind, and where research is always", "the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in the", "a good or a bad thing? * If it is", "never about politics? * If so, is this a good", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I get that", "a bad thing? * If it is a bad thing,", "I disagree with the strong wording in the comment, it", "criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations", "of academia, where professors are always helpful and competent, where", "place. > > > While I disagree with the strong", "> And while I get that the site is heavily", "serve anybody who is not in that ideal position. If", "of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do", "first place. > > > While I disagree with the", "> > > While I disagree with the strong wording", "[this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I get", "good or a bad thing? * If it is a", "comment to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while", "hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of", "ignore or shut down any hint of criticism of professors", "in the comment, it made me wonder. * Are we", "or a bad thing? * If it is a bad", "a comment to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And", "best interest of their mentees in mind, and where research", "strong wording in the comment, it made me wonder. ", "this a good or a bad thing? If it", "it made me wonder. * Are we in fact presenting", "to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I", "of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic", "presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors are always", "an idealised view of academia, where professors are always helpful", "to the body of knowledge and never about politics? ", "professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors", "about politics? If so, is this a good or", "with the strong wording in the comment, it made me", "competent, where advisors and mentors only have the best interest", "shut down any hint of criticism of professors in academia,", "> > And while I get that the site is", "anybody who is not in that ideal position. If the", "the questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have", "skewed to ignore or shut down any hint of criticism", "who is not in that ideal position. If the questioner", "pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is", "in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in", "research is always about contributing to the body of knowledge", "the comment, it made me wonder. * Are we in", "in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve", "me wonder. * Are we in fact presenting an idealised", "are always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only", "problem in the first place. > > > While I", "is a bad thing, can it be changed and how?", "wrote: > > And while I get that the site", "* Are we in fact presenting an idealised view of", "> While I disagree with the strong wording in the", "the strong wording in the comment, it made me wonder.", "was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem", "they wouldn't have a problem in the first place. >", "down any hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy", "Are we in fact presenting an idealised view of academia,", "* If it is a bad thing, can it be", "or shut down any hint of criticism of professors in", "in the first place. > > > While I disagree", "* If so, is this a good or a bad", "in fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors", "idealised view of academia, where professors are always helpful and", "thing? * If it is a bad thing, can it", "view of academia, where professors are always helpful and competent,", "helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only have the", "wording in the comment, it made me wonder. * Are", "idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is not in", "the first place. > > > While I disagree with", "ideal position. If the questioner was in the ideal position,", "contributing to the body of knowledge and never about politics?", "have a problem in the first place. > > >", "the site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down", "I get that the site is heavily skewed to ignore", "comment, it made me wonder. * Are we in fact", "only have the best interest of their mentees in mind,", "not serve anybody who is not in that ideal position.", "that ideal position. If the questioner was in the ideal", "> > While I disagree with the strong wording in", "while I get that the site is heavily skewed to", "and where research is always about contributing to the body", "mentors only have the best interest of their mentees in", "the best interest of their mentees in mind, and where", "If so, is this a good or a bad thing?", "rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who", "questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a", "that the site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut", "fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors are", "their mentees in mind, and where research is always about", "of knowledge and never about politics? * If so, is", "of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is not", "in that ideal position. If the questioner was in the", "If the questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't", "do not serve anybody who is not in that ideal", "mentees in mind, and where research is always about contributing", "where advisors and mentors only have the best interest of", "position, they wouldn't have a problem in the first place.", "heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any hint of", "bad thing? * If it is a bad thing, can", "site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any", "it is a bad thing, can it be changed and", "where research is always about contributing to the body of", "and competent, where advisors and mentors only have the best", "academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody", "made me wonder. * Are we in fact presenting an", "While I disagree with the strong wording in the comment,", "and mentors only have the best interest of their mentees", "And while I get that the site is heavily skewed", "knowledge and never about politics? * If so, is this", "a problem in the first place. > > > While", "mind, and where research is always about contributing to the", "advisors and mentors only have the best interest of their", "politics? * If so, is this a good or a", "academia, where professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors", "to ignore or shut down any hint of criticism of", "not in that ideal position. If the questioner was in", "and never about politics? * If so, is this a", "wouldn't have a problem in the first place. > >", "any hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures", "ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in the first", "rocinante wrote: > > And while I get that the", "disagree with the strong wording in the comment, it made" ]
[ "through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be", "be used in two different cases, rather than just one:", "2. Questions about asking a recommender for a letter of", "best way to split the tag to make it more", "my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used", "Questions about asking a recommender for a letter of reference", "wiki editing project, and as I'm working through my list,", "I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears", "one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents to support", "tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working through my", "or documents to support a question 2. Questions about asking", "support a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for", "editing project, and as I'm working through my list, I've", "This appears to be used in two different cases, rather", "Thoughts on the best way to split the tag to", "just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents to", "different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations,", "to support a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender", "embarked on something of a tag wiki editing project, and", "references or documents to support a question 2. Questions about", "a letter of reference These are clearly two very different", "used in two different cases, rather than just one: 1.", "two very different types of questions. Thoughts on the best", "and as I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`.", "questions. Thoughts on the best way to split the tag", "working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to", "reference These are clearly two very different types of questions.", "a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working through", "asking a recommender for a letter of reference These are", "types of questions. Thoughts on the best way to split", "citations, references or documents to support a question 2. Questions", "to be used in two different cases, rather than just", "two different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for", "very different types of questions. Thoughts on the best way", "the best way to split the tag to make it", "appears to be used in two different cases, rather than", "documents to support a question 2. Questions about asking a", "letter of reference These are clearly two very different types", "question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for a letter", "for citations, references or documents to support a question 2.", "of reference These are clearly two very different types of", "hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in two different", "something of a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm", "Requests for citations, references or documents to support a question", "rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or", "in two different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests", "of a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working", "cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references", "recommender for a letter of reference These are clearly two", "way to split the tag to make it more clear?", "I've embarked on something of a tag wiki editing project,", "These are clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts", "for a letter of reference These are clearly two very", "`reference-request`. This appears to be used in two different cases,", "a recommender for a letter of reference These are clearly", "of questions. Thoughts on the best way to split the", "about asking a recommender for a letter of reference These", "on the best way to split the tag to make", "project, and as I'm working through my list, I've hit", "on something of a tag wiki editing project, and as", "a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for a", "clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts on the", "1. Requests for citations, references or documents to support a", "So I've embarked on something of a tag wiki editing", "are clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts on", "I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in two", "different types of questions. Thoughts on the best way to", "than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents", "as I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This", "list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in" ]
[ "their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ...", "requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems", "rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. * [What", "(if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit.", "communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of", "from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring", "just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme", "my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice, not", "site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside", "from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't", "I can't find right now where a student mentioned that", "simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety", "advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple in terms", "should have some respect for the fact that they're advising", "and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold", "issue and should be treated seriously. I think it's especially", "academics that they leave their job as soon as possible", "in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of", "it made me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a", "left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave", "... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that", "could get past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody", "If we have a meme on this site, it's \"*Don't", "an inside joke for the community ... but the joke", "me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that", "A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with", "tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone", "grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is", "not being the whole story. The first piece of advice", "fact that they're advising another human being to quit their", "picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics telling", "to quit their job/studies ... and they should keep in", "upvotes. [What to do: PI lied to me and", "they require the permission of their supervisor to publish. This", "it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke", "quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is", "in other areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming", "to newcomers. If we could get past the semantic satiation", "can't find right now where a student mentioned that in", "lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult", "successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't know the", "seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear", "It is like an inside joke for the community ...", "not be clear to newcomers. If we could get past", "student mentioned that in their school, they require the permission", "of examples of where it made me cringe: * [Handling", "not a pithy comment. * There was another example I", "Run*\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline", "inexperienced academics that they leave their job as soon as", "the culture in other areas and departments. Lots of questions", "don't know the culture in other areas and departments. Lots", "satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and", "semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position", "this meme should have some respect for the fact that", "of not being the whole story. The first piece of", "rock-star departments who don't know the culture in other areas", "of vulnerable people from a variety of areas who see", "guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor", "that they're advising another human being to quit their job/studies", "is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk.", "for the fact that they're advising another human being to", "was another example I can't find right now where a", "18 upvotes. [What to do: PI lied to me", "researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in", "as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple", "to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable", "JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students", "with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate.", "and they should keep in mind that they are simultaneously", "in rock-star departments who don't know the culture in other", "too simple in terms of not being the whole story.", "credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple", "using this meme should have some respect for the fact", "quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging?", "being the whole story. The first piece of advice isn't", "might not be clear to newcomers. If we could get", "position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue", "talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with", "\"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk.", "\"Don't walk. Run.*\" ... with 18 upvotes. [What to", "human being to quit their job/studies ... and they should", "the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life", "isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't", "from a variety of areas who see such questions and", "uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it made me", "Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced", "get past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting", "her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes.", "to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question", "we could get past the semantic satiation for a minute,", "questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a", "think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working", "in terms of not being the whole story. The first", "clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if", "variety of areas who see such questions and who might", "the joke might not be clear to newcomers. If we", "pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds", "and should be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic", "past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their", "example I can't find right now where a student mentioned", "bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they", "... but the joke might not be clear to newcomers.", "soon as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A", "see such questions and who might project themselves as being", "other areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming from", "do: PI lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant):", "have a meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.*\"", "they should keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating", "from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted", "in their school, they require the permission of their supervisor", "it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in", "another human being to quit their job/studies ... and they", "me cringe: [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that", "first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with", "* [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost", "to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially", "coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture.", "made me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question", "[Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too", "\"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A", "affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a", "vulnerable people from a variety of areas who see such", "seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful", "of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint", "damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using", "we have a meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk.", "it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it made", "have some respect for the fact that they're advising another", "of areas who see such questions and who might project", "piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\"", "meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.*\" It is", "by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their", "cringe: [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems", "* [What to do: PI lied to me and is", "you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\"", "question that seems almost too simple in terms of not", "minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies", "newcomers. If we could get past the semantic satiation for", "a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced", "certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this", "employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should be treated", "A couple of examples of where it made me cringe:", "another example I can't find right now where a student", "walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke for the", "leave their job as soon as possible ... I sometimes", "on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.*\" It is like", "in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that", "legal advice, not a pithy comment. There was another", "Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It just", "job/studies ... and they should keep in mind that they", "be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from", "inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications", "a serious issue and should be treated seriously. I think", "this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an", "hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't know", "pithy comment. * There was another example I can't find", "academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job as", "This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which", "as soon as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable.", "should keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with", "their job/studies ... and they should keep in mind that", "real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious", "... with 18 upvotes. * [What to do: PI lied", "It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this", "people from a variety of areas who see such questions", "coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who", "inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments", "especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star", "elsewhere is a serious issue and should be treated seriously.", "the whole story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have", "problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments", "they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from", "areas who see such questions and who might project themselves", "inside joke for the community ... but the joke might", "comment. * There was another example I can't find right", "with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18", "entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated", "[What to do: PI lied to me and is keeping", "thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of areas who", "is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal", "question that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. ", "seems almost too simple in terms of not being the", "Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. [What to do: PI", "school, they require the permission of their supervisor to publish.", "are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided", "risk. Folks using this meme should have some respect for", "a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for", "where it made me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor):", "the permission of their supervisor to publish. This was met", "job as soon as possible ... I sometimes find it", "this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth", "typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left", "who see such questions and who might project themselves as", "treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely", "but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. ", "supervisor to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\"", "terms of not being the whole story. The first piece", "... and they should keep in mind that they are", "meme should have some respect for the fact that they're", "I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of", "walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school", "--- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It", "the fact that they're advising another human being to quit", "\"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke for", "for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should be", "requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. There was", "with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful)", "but the joke might not be clear to newcomers. If", "reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to", "some respect for the fact that they're advising another human", "telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job as soon", "quit their job/studies ... and they should keep in mind", "met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely", "that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people", "that they leave their job as soon as possible ...", "that in their school, they require the permission of their", "seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not", "respect for the fact that they're advising another human being", "Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically", "possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of", "community ... but the joke might not be clear to", "permission of their supervisor to publish. This was met with", "and departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers", "grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice, not a", "school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their", "... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples", "* There was another example I can't find right now", "There was another example I can't find right now where", "advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather", "find right now where a student mentioned that in their", "clear to newcomers. If we could get past the semantic", "meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the", "examples of where it made me cringe: * [Handling credit", "whole story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have you", "a student mentioned that in their school, they require the", "departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and", "seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme should have", "questions and who might project themselves as being in similar", "the risk. Folks using this meme should have some respect", "somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere", "which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to", "a question that seems almost too simple in terms of", "like an inside joke for the community ... but the", "paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by", "areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced", "a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. ---", "sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where", "joke might not be clear to newcomers. If we could", "who don't know the culture in other areas and departments.", "The first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking", "distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree", "joke for the community ... but the joke might not", "are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a", "for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking", "being to quit their job/studies ... and they should keep", "worth the risk. Folks using this meme should have some", "they leave their job as soon as possible ... I", "that seems almost too simple in terms of not being", "mentioned that in their school, they require the permission of", "require the permission of their supervisor to publish. This was", "with 18 upvotes. * [What to do: PI lied to", "walk. Run.*\" ... with 18 upvotes. [What to do:", "publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE", "and who might project themselves as being in similar situations.", "doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme should", "students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty", "supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly", "such questions and who might project themselves as being in", "with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple in", "keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands", "Run.\" It is like an inside joke for the community", "serious issue and should be treated seriously. I think it's", "not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme", "their school, they require the permission of their supervisor to", "experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job", "PI lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a", "potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks", "academics working in rock-star departments who don't know the culture", "now where a student mentioned that in their school, they", "know the culture in other areas and departments. Lots of", "is a serious issue and should be treated seriously. I", "tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ...", "I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics", "of their supervisor to publish. This was met with \"Don't", "should be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming", "a meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It", "keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice,", "and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires", "of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but", "almost too simple in terms of not being the whole", "looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should", "If we could get past the semantic satiation for a", "Folks using this meme should have some respect for the", "the community ... but the joke might not be clear", "couple of examples of where it made me cringe: ", "their job as soon as possible ... I sometimes find", "was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed", "agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't", "story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried", "be clear to newcomers. If we could get past the", "difficult question that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment.", "culture in other areas and departments. Lots of questions are", "to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from", "their supervisor to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk.", "advising another human being to quit their job/studies ... and", "comments in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics", "their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a", "that this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem", "publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad", "of where it made me cringe: [Handling credit with", "advice, not a pithy comment. * There was another example", "mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable", "to do: PI lied to me and is keeping my", "with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of areas", "a difficult question that requires legal advice, not a pithy", "and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and", "they're advising another human being to quit their job/studies ...", "for the community ... but the joke might not be", "find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it", "working in rock-star departments who don't know the culture in", "a variety of areas who see such questions and who", "right now where a student mentioned that in their school,", "one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics", "is like an inside joke for the community ... but", "that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. * There", "simple in terms of not being the whole story. The", "where a student mentioned that in their school, they require", "departments who don't know the culture in other areas and", "a pithy comment. * There was another example I can't" ]
[ "professor > > > and maybe even > > Inner", "> > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university", "a trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered by", "and maybe even > > Inner workings of research departments.", "think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of >", "that I'm curious about and could elicit a good answer.", "postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and maybe even", "> > > and maybe even > > Inner workings", "the reasons for what I believe is a trend relating", "student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and maybe", "> > and maybe even > > Inner workings of", "not a problem, but rather something that I'm curious about", "that is not a problem, but rather something that I'm", "about academia per se, but I think it could fall", "trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses.", "researcher, university professor > > > and maybe even >", "under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a", "it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > >", "kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia", "Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor >", "academia per se, but I think it could fall under", "the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate", "I think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of", "> Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor", "for what I believe is a trend relating to the", "of > > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher,", "a problem, but rather something that I'm curious about and", "I would like to know the reasons for what I", "not about academia per se, but I think it could", "know the reasons for what I believe is a trend", "by campuses. It's not about academia per se, but I", "could elicit a good answer. I would like to know", "something that I'm curious about and could elicit a good", "I'm curious about and could elicit a good answer. I", "but I think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "elicit a good answer. I would like to know the", "as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > >", "about and could elicit a good answer. I would like", "I believe is a trend relating to the kinds of", "of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia per", "se, but I think it could fall under the [allowed", "a question that is not a problem, but rather something", "I have a question that is not a problem, but", "like to know the reasons for what I believe is", "offered by campuses. It's not about academia per se, but", "question that is not a problem, but rather something that", "answer. I would like to know the reasons for what", "have a question that is not a problem, but rather", "could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life", "> > Inner workings of research departments. > > >", "It's not about academia per se, but I think it", "fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as", "what I believe is a trend relating to the kinds", "the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about", "is a trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered", "to know the reasons for what I believe is a", "would like to know the reasons for what I believe", "a good answer. I would like to know the reasons", "good answer. I would like to know the reasons for", "rather something that I'm curious about and could elicit a", "curious about and could elicit a good answer. I would", "problem, but rather something that I'm curious about and could", "university professor > > > and maybe even > >", "but rather something that I'm curious about and could elicit", "even > > Inner workings of research departments. > >", "campuses. It's not about academia per se, but I think", "graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and", "a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > >", "to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not", "facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia per se,", "is not a problem, but rather something that I'm curious", "believe is a trend relating to the kinds of facilities", "maybe even > > Inner workings of research departments. >", "and could elicit a good answer. I would like to", "topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral", "relating to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's", "reasons for what I believe is a trend relating to", "> and maybe even > > Inner workings of research", "[allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate student,", "per se, but I think it could fall under the" ]
[ "yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep worm like", "procedure for a low-rep worm like me to suggest it", "wrote this question: [How should academics handle communication with the", "by adding their personal experience so that we can cover", "personal experience so that we can cover more aspects of", "so that we can cover more aspects of this issue.", "handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit", "a candidate to become a community wiki? If yes, what", "it by adding their personal experience so that we can", "media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people editing it", "cover more aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate", "think it would benefit from people editing it by adding", "issue. Is it a candidate to become a community wiki?", "it a candidate to become a community wiki? If yes,", "become a community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure", "is the procedure for a low-rep worm like me to", "more aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate to", "people editing it by adding their personal experience so that", "that we can cover more aspects of this issue. Is", "adding their personal experience so that we can cover more", "editing it by adding their personal experience so that we", "candidate to become a community wiki? If yes, what is", "their personal experience so that we can cover more aspects", "can cover more aspects of this issue. Is it a", "experience so that we can cover more aspects of this", "this issue. Is it a candidate to become a community", "communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from", "what is the procedure for a low-rep worm like me", "aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate to become", "to become a community wiki? If yes, what is the", "question: [How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and", "I wrote this question: [How should academics handle communication with", "the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people editing", "benefit from people editing it by adding their personal experience", "academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would", "a low-rep worm like me to suggest it might be?", "should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it", "wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep", "for a low-rep worm like me to suggest it might", "of this issue. Is it a candidate to become a", "with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people", "from people editing it by adding their personal experience so", "Is it a candidate to become a community wiki? If", "community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for a", "it would benefit from people editing it by adding their", "we can cover more aspects of this issue. Is it", "If yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep worm", "a community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for", "the procedure for a low-rep worm like me to suggest", "would benefit from people editing it by adding their personal", "[How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think", "and think it would benefit from people editing it by", "this question: [How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643)" ]
[ "format. > > > What activities on the site suggest", "appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to all", "statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites", "you would be a good moderator? If you are currently", "candidates! --- > > A user posts something you find", "specify the answer in UTC format. > > > What", "SE policy disagree? > > > What is your position", "would make them on topic. So, what is your position?", "and how would you go about implementing that change? >", "about implementing that change? > > > Under what conditions", "in Meta and the post gets a lot of upvotes.", "official SE policy disagree? > > > What is your", "is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How", "here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate", "you are currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried", "are not just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term", "answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently when I", "good moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do you", "deliberately to keep the direction of the site on track?", "in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations?", "candidates to provide their answers. Not every question was compiled,", "questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging for comment", "compiled, but apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection,", "chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them in this", "studies. It can often be argued that some questions can", "your position on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/).", "[See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you", "to do next? > > > A quite specific question:", "What is the time period you are available for moderating", "the questions and then post your answer to each question", "Vote as if you were a normal user, disregarding your", "subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to", "> > > What is your position on boat programming", "a question was on-topic or not, because it was somehow", "you rather think that content should be left unchanged as", "Will you support them in this task? Or do you", "support them in this task? Or do you rather think", "apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer", "the community decide on things that could conceivably be subjective,", "with the moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread", "as the space for the candidates to provide their answers.", "everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format. > >", "would you like to make in how the site is", "question, citing each of the questions and then post your", "to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that some", "available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer", "the site suggest that you would be a good moderator?", "failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to", "as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of", "If you are currently a moderator, do you believe you've", "It can often be argued that some questions can however", "(off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about", "> > Under what conditions will you delete comments? >", "the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about", "was on-topic or not, because it was somehow related to", "What is your position on boat programming questions? [See here", "posts about it in Meta and the post gets a", "Please specify the answer in UTC format. > > >", "you believe you've carried out the role effectively? > >", "suggest that you would be a good moderator? If you", "moderator, do you believe you've carried out the role effectively?", "page. Good luck to all of the candidates! --- >", "and will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good", "> > > What change would you like to make", "questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would", "position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of", "it in Meta and the post gets a lot of", "How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let", "site suggest that you would be a good moderator? If", "find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts", "and and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do", "answer to each question given in that same answer. For", "answer in UTC format. > > > What activities on", "\"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first", "user, disregarding your role and the binding nature? > >", "respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator", "instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because they are", "take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to", "an answer to this question, citing each of the questions", "connection with the moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A", "> > What activities on the site suggest that you", "three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled, this", "in this task? Or do you rather think that content", "is your time zone? What is the time period you", "In connection with the moderator elections, we are holding a", "are currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried out", "you were a normal user, disregarding your role and the", "do you believe you've carried out the role effectively? >", "on things that could conceivably be subjective, but take action", "change would you like to make in how the site", "etc). Will you support them in this task? Or do", "of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled,", "answers have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript", "both get upvotes. How do you decide what to do", "your convenience, I will include all of the questions in", "somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued", "> > What change would you like to make in", "this question, citing each of the questions and then post", "old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging for", "and the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are", "to this question, citing each of the questions and then", "on the site suggest that you would be a good", "just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of", "this task? Or do you rather think that content should", "questions in quote format with a break in between each,", "action and and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How", "all the answers have been compiled, this will serve as", "nature? > > > What change would you like to", "but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately", "do you decide what to do next? > > >", "sites are not just about answering people's questions, but providing", "of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of you", "transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates,", "are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support", "much as possible? > > > What is your time", "from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are", "> > > A quite specific question: what is your", "actions have been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic", "think that content should be left unchanged as much as", "> A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you", "question was on-topic or not, because it was somehow related", "collect 10 questions from the community in lieu of the", "candidate, your job is simple - post an answer to", "something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The", "luck to all of the candidates! --- > > A", "how the site is currently moderated, and how would you", "the Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates!", "the candidates to provide their answers. Not every question was", "because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can", "you moderate postings where your opinion or the community's opinion", "curate them, for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically", "quote format with a break in between each, suitable for", "What is your time zone? What is the time period", "period you are available for moderating our site everyday? Please", "upvotes. How do you decide what to do next? >", "like to make in how the site is currently moderated,", "time period you are available for moderating our site everyday?", "postings where your opinion or the community's opinion and official", "one, which shall now serve as the space for the", "to make in how the site is currently moderated, and", "positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use your \"binding", "your action; both get upvotes. How do you decide what", "of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a", "to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect", "Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates! ---", "into this one, which shall now serve as the space", "2. As a candidate, your job is simple - post", "if a question was on-topic or not, because it was", "of the questions and then post your answer to each", "as possible? > > > What is your time zone?", "action; both get upvotes. How do you decide what to", "can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make", "and curate them, for instance by flagging for comment removal", "is your position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In", "some very active users who look at old questions/answers, and", "moderate postings where your opinion or the community's opinion and", "UTC format. > > > What activities on the site", "Under what conditions will you delete comments? > > >", "get upvotes. How do you decide what to do next?", "each of the questions and then post your answer to", "position on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). >", "an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which", "you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing", "normal user, disregarding your role and the binding nature? >", "comments? > > > What is your position on boat", "action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep", "> > A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and", "will you delete comments? > > > What is your", "> > What is your time zone? What is the", "for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate postings", "\"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just", "my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a question", "first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let", "to graduate studies, which would make them on topic. So,", "was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often be", "opinion or the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree?", "will include all of the questions in quote format with", "- post an answer to this question, citing each of", "site is currently moderated, and how would you go about", "simple - post an answer to this question, citing each", "every question was compiled, but apparently when I posted the", "will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the", "what conditions will you delete comments? > > > What", "(close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta", "upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of you action", "site on track? Vote as if you were a normal", "for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have", "quite specific question: what is your position with respect to", "topic. So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) >", "> > A quite specific question: what is your position", "task? Or do you rather think that content should be", "the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked", "serve as the space for the candidates to provide their", "what to do next? > > > A quite specific", "aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not", "How do you decide what to do next? > >", "easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make them on", "them on topic. So, what is your position? [Some example", "boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > >", "Meta and the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers", "undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator actions have", "the site on track? Vote as if you were a", "> How would you moderate postings where your opinion or", "moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for the", "the candidates! --- > > A user posts something you", "currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried out the", "for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer in", "to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not, because", "that you would be a good moderator? If you are", "selection of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your", "in quote format with a break in between each, suitable", "> What activities on the site suggest that you would", "> A quite specific question: what is your position with", "for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and", "to all of the candidates! --- > > A user", "site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format. >", "break in between each, suitable for you to insert your", "suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've", "lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of", "thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in", "not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It", "which would make them on topic. So, what is your", "position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long", "and official SE policy disagree? > > > What is", "suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the", "following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange", "both in favor of you action and and criticising your", "them, for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because", "holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from", "thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all", "to deliberately to keep the direction of the site on", "after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the", "have some very active users who look at old questions/answers,", "for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because they", "containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this", "> > > What is your position on the following", "left unchanged as much as possible? > > > What", "For your convenience, I will include all of the questions", "questions failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted", "the questions in quote format with a break in between", "answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"?", "who look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance", "your role and the binding nature? > > > What", "this one, which shall now serve as the space for", "of the usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As", "linked in the Election page. Good luck to all of", "would you go about implementing that change? > > >", "their answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently when", "examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate postings where", "are posted both in favor of you action and and", "Or do you rather think that content should be left", "not just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating", "> > What is your position on the following statement", "8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your job is", "zone? What is the time period you are available for", "set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been", "Not every question was compiled, but apparently when I posted", "close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide", "post an answer to this question, citing each of the", "the (question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta and", "a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their", "as much as possible? > > > What is your", "for the candidates to provide their answers. Not every question", "privileges? Let the community weigh in first on most close,", "question was compiled, but apparently when I posted the original", "content should be left unchanged as much as possible? >", "people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We", "argued that some questions can however easily generalise to graduate", "our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this reason,", "(typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc).", "and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it", "> > What is your position on boat programming questions?", "of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the", "active users who look at old questions/answers, and curate them,", "opted to collect 10 questions from the community in lieu", "next? > > > A quite specific question: what is", "[from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one,", "candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election page.", "in how the site is currently moderated, and how would", "long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some very active", "community in lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus", "in that same answer. For your convenience, I will include", "would be a good moderator? If you are currently a", "answer to this question, citing each of the questions and", "your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first", "activities on the site suggest that you would be a", "community decide on things that could conceivably be subjective, but", "you decide what to do next? > > > A", "Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier", "of the site on track? Vote as if you were", "when I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing", "Good luck to all of the candidates! --- > >", "we are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions", "We have some very active users who look at old", "you are available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify", "So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > >", "some questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which", "the space for the candidates to provide their answers. Not", "job is simple - post an answer to this question,", "been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters", "be a good moderator? If you are currently a moderator,", "about it in Meta and the post gets a lot", "voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will", "of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your job", "your opinion or the community's opinion and official SE policy", "Exchange sites are not just about answering people's questions, but", "plus our 2. As a candidate, your job is simple", "shall now serve as the space for the candidates to", "and the binding nature? > > > What change would", "disagree? > > > What is your position on the", "removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive,", "original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed", "self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For", "is your position on boat programming questions? [See here for", "change? > > > Under what conditions will you delete", "in UTC format. > > > What activities on the", "the binding nature? > > > What change would you", "questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have", "with a break in between each, suitable for you to", "which shall now serve as the space for the candidates", "generalise to graduate studies, which would make them on topic.", "insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the", "be left unchanged as much as possible? > > >", "you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user", "things that could conceivably be subjective, but take action on", "your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will", "community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? > > >", "curating of the answers\"? We have some very active users", "posted both in favor of you action and and criticising", "> > > How will you use your \"binding vote\"", "moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a question was", "go about implementing that change? > > > Under what", "> > How would you moderate postings where your opinion", "rather think that content should be left unchanged as much", "and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do you", "favor of you action and and criticising your action; both", "on topic. So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/)", "be argued that some questions can however easily generalise to", "moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC", "have been compiled into this one, which shall now serve", "currently moderated, and how would you go about implementing that", "submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions", "but apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection, the", "that content should be left unchanged as much as possible?", "be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act", "your time zone? What is the time period you are", "collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this", "you delete comments? > > > What is your position", "be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect 10", "the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted.", "space for the candidates to provide their answers. Not every", "user posts about it in Meta and the post gets", "about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the", "believe you've carried out the role effectively? > > >", "part of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if", "do next? > > > A quite specific question: what", "run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering people's", "answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first set", "all of the candidates! --- > > A user posts", "candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled", "to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator actions", "them in this task? Or do you rather think that", "were a normal user, disregarding your role and the binding", "to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be", "a candidate, your job is simple - post an answer", "have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for", "gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in", "be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to", "a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor", "whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once", "community weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete,", "for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty,", "> > > What activities on the site suggest that", "implementing that change? > > > Under what conditions will", "of the candidates! --- > > A user posts something", "or the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? >", "a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an", "you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it in", "you like to make in how the site is currently", "users who look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for", "now serve as the space for the candidates to provide", "possible? > > > What is your time zone? What", "How would you moderate postings where your opinion or the", "the community in lieu of the usual selection of 8", "can often be argued that some questions can however easily", "our 2. As a candidate, your job is simple -", "very active users who look at old questions/answers, and curate", "compiled into this one, which shall now serve as the", "disregarding your role and the binding nature? > > >", "to provide their answers. Not every question was compiled, but", "questions and then post your answer to each question given", "in between each, suitable for you to insert your answers.", "posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment).", "position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you", "binding nature? > > > What change would you like", "Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering people's questions,", "thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall now", "it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often", "questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would", "between each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just", "on-topic or not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate", "the community weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete,", "on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the", "all of the questions in quote format with a break", "how would you go about implementing that change? > >", "immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction of the", "not constructive, etc). Will you support them in this task?", "Answers are posted both in favor of you action and", "first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have", "the usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As a", "usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate,", "track? Vote as if you were a normal user, disregarding", "vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first on", "include all of the questions in quote format with a", "etc. operations? Let the community decide on things that could", "will serve as a transcript for voters to view the", "Just [copy the whole thing after the first set of", "time zone? What is the time period you are available", "related to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that", "the time period you are available for moderating our site", "their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election", "opinion and official SE policy disagree? > > > What", "on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run,", "is the time period you are available for moderating our", "same answer. For your convenience, I will include all of", "question: what is your position with respect to undergraduate questions?", "have been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or", "delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on things", "of the questions in quote format with a break in", "Once all the answers have been compiled, this will serve", "this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from the", "undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that some questions", "decide on things that could conceivably be subjective, but take", "comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not", "on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the", "Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to", "--- > > A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive)", "providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some very", "For this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from", "citing each of the questions and then post your answer", "Let the community decide on things that could conceivably be", "each question given in that same answer. For your convenience,", "question given in that same answer. For your convenience, I", "of you action and and criticising your action; both get", "> > How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator", "As a candidate, your job is simple - post an", "arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not, because it", "> > > Under what conditions will you delete comments?", "> > > How would you moderate postings where your", "dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled, this will", "earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall", "(question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta and the", "> Under what conditions will you delete comments? > >", "lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus our 2.", "your answer to each question given in that same answer.", "format with a break in between each, suitable for you", "reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on", "your job is simple - post an answer to this", "example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use your", "they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you", "the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted", "operations? Let the community decide on things that could conceivably", "What is your position on the following statement from aeismail:", "by flagging for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete,", "posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested", "on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > >", "elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates.", "> What is your position on boat programming questions? [See", "that could conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial", "flagging for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too", "is currently moderated, and how would you go about implementing", "is your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant", "with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my", "What change would you like to make in how the", "The user posts about it in Meta and the post", "that same answer. For your convenience, I will include all", "make in how the site is currently moderated, and how", "I've opted to collect 10 questions from the community in", "but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some", "studies, which would make them on topic. So, what is", "often be argued that some questions can however easily generalise", "> What change would you like to make in how", "your position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the", "the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been", "in favor of you action and and criticising your action;", "> What is your position on the following statement from", "as if you were a normal user, disregarding your role", "this will serve as a transcript for voters to view", "moderated, and how would you go about implementing that change?", "obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them", "moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first on most", "then post your answer to each question given in that", "collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be", "you action and and criticising your action; both get upvotes.", "user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the", "role and the binding nature? > > > What change", "serve as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts", "will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck", "> > > What is your time zone? What is", "use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh", "the whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source).", "been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not,", "conditions will you delete comments? > > > What is", "could conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters", "convenience, I will include all of the questions in quote", "each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy", "questions from the community in lieu of the usual selection", "our site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format.", "post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both", "> How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges?", "specific question: what is your position with respect to undergraduate", "the moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for", "too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them in", "I will include all of the questions in quote format", "for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole", "to keep the direction of the site on track? Vote", "unchanged as much as possible? > > > What is", "of the answers\"? We have some very active users who", "the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? > >", "weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc.", "do you rather think that content should be left unchanged", "reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from the community", "non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction", "a break in between each, suitable for you to insert", "I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our", "to collect 10 questions from the community in lieu of", "graduate studies, which would make them on topic. So, what", "provide their answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently", "constructive, etc). Will you support them in this task? Or", "compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters to", "questions? A significant part of my moderator actions have been", "is simple - post an answer to this question, citing", "Act to deliberately to keep the direction of the site", "the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack", "policy disagree? > > > What is your position on", "keep the direction of the site on track? Vote as", "from the community in lieu of the usual selection of", "the answers\"? We have some very active users who look", "at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging", "on track? Vote as if you were a normal user,", "conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately?", "you go about implementing that change? > > > Under", "if you were a normal user, disregarding your role and", "in lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus our", "moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do you believe", "however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make them", "A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate)", "10 questions from the community in lieu of the usual", "the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions", "the direction of the site on track? Vote as if", "the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers", "to each question given in that same answer. For your", "view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately", "thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection)", "would you moderate postings where your opinion or the community's", "your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part", "a normal user, disregarding your role and the binding nature?", "direction of the site on track? Vote as if you", "the answers have been compiled, this will serve as a", "[Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use", "answers\"? We have some very active users who look at", "criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do you decide", "where your opinion or the community's opinion and official SE", "post your answer to each question given in that same", "you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community", "A significant part of my moderator actions have been to", "Let the community weigh in first on most close, reopen,", "long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering", "matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction of", "What activities on the site suggest that you would be", "Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into", "what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > >", "and then post your answer to each question given in", "your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in", "make them on topic. So, what is your position? [Some", "in the Election page. Good luck to all of the", "you support them in this task? Or do you rather", "been compiled into this one, which shall now serve as", "significant part of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate", "the answer in UTC format. > > > What activities", "what is your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A", "[copy the whole thing after the first set of three", "decide what to do next? > > > A quite", "programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How", "undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on things that", "are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected", "delete comments? > > > What is your position on", "> What is your time zone? What is the time", "are available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the", "to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after", "given in that same answer. For your convenience, I will", "the site is currently moderated, and how would you go", "A quite specific question: what is your position with respect", "most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community", "or not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies.", "look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by", "a good moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do", "because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will", "answer. For your convenience, I will include all of the", "should be left unchanged as much as possible? > >", "a moderator, do you believe you've carried out the role", "that change? > > > Under what conditions will you", "was compiled, but apparently when I posted the original Q&A", "that some questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies," ]
[ "asked a question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions).", "which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past,", "of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts from", "had differing thoughts from the community on this topic ([for](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/50/questions-involving-lists),", "recently asked a question which is, essentially, a [list of", "[list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts", "essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had", "a question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In", "differing thoughts from the community on this topic ([for](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/50/questions-involving-lists), [against](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/749/big-list-questions)).", "is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've", "things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts from the", "thoughts from the community on this topic ([for](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/50/questions-involving-lists), [against](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/749/big-list-questions)). Thoughts?", "a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing", "we've had differing thoughts from the community on this topic", "question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the", "In the past, we've had differing thoughts from the community", "the past, we've had differing thoughts from the community on", "Zlerc recently asked a question which is, essentially, a [list", "Retu Zlerc recently asked a question which is, essentially, a", "past, we've had differing thoughts from the community on this" ]
[ "my head I cannot remember a single case where I", "author to edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly.", "which starts with something along the lines of \"The existing", "of a legacy feature that serves no real purpose anymore,", "answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this as highly", "comment and ask the original author to edit it in.", "is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark", "supposed to just edit additional information into existing answers, if", "that the original author even endorses a given change. Poko", "the topic? Option 3 seems to be the common way", "impression at least), but brings us close to community wiki", "style). This is also my impression - I have been", "site in the last few months, and from the top", "we encounter a question that already has one or more", "something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome.", "and style). This is also my impression - I have", "an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this", "it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts", "no guarantee that the original author even endorses a given", "for clarity and style). This is also my impression -", "2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer,", "from the top of my head I cannot remember a", "currently done (my impression at least), but brings us close", "deemed sort of a legacy feature that serves no real", "even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into", "purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just edit additional", "where I have seen an edit that actually added content", "The question linked at the top seems to suggest to", "style edits to other people's answers. My question is now", "in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are just", "lines of \"The existing answer by XY is good, but", "we consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail", "answer to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed", "now as follows: If we encounter a question that already", "active on the site in the last few months, and", "top of my head I cannot remember a single case", "way to do it?* 1. Post a comment and ask", "that actually added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking,", "3. Provide a new answer, which starts with something along", "feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is", "My question is now as follows: If we encounter a", "edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide", "Post a comment and ask the original author to edit", "answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and", "accepted answer to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is", "the last few months, and from the top of my", "answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything but minor", "Option 3 seems to be the common way how it", "today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked", "has one or more answers that we consider really good,", "also my impression - I have been reasonably active on", "occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is also my", "how it is currently done (my impression at least), but", "are supposed to just edit additional information into existing answers,", "common way how it is currently done (my impression at", "as there is no guarantee that the original author even", "additional information into existing answers, if they feel that a", "how do we guarantee that the original author even has", "few months, and from the top of my head I", "consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs", "do we guarantee that the original author even has the", "into existing answers, if they feel that a given answer", "change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094)", "speaking, I would also see this as highly inappropriate, as", "good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be", "added. What is the right way to do it? 1.", "legacy feature that serves no real purpose anymore, as people", "this in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are", "the right way to do it?** 1. Post a comment", "but ...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option", "on the topic? Option 3 seems to be the common", "existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this as", "XY is good, but ...\". I have done something similar", "to suggest to me option 2, but how do we", "last few months, and from the top of my head", "a single case where I have seen an edit that", "done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but", "similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The", "(essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with", "is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the top", "my impression - I have been reasonably active on the", "edits to other people's answers. My question is now as", "the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is also", "Xlark remark that this in practice basically never happens (essentially", "with something along the lines of \"The existing answer by", "directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts with something", "Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at", "question linked at the top seems to suggest to me", "a legacy feature* that serves no real purpose anymore, as", "seem reluctant to do anything but minor style edits to", "on the site in the last few months, and from", "clarity and style). This is also my impression - I", "case where I have seen an edit that actually added", "really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to", "the site in the last few months, and from the", "it?* 1. Post a comment and ask the original author", "given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his", "one or more answers that we consider really good, but", "new answer, which starts with something along the lines of", "be added. What is the right way to do it?*", "to other people's answers. My question is now as follows:", "R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people", "to be added. What is the right way to do", "answer, which starts with something along the lines of \"The", "we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What", "months, and from the top of my head I cannot", "remark that this in practice basically never happens (essentially all", "something along the lines of \"The existing answer by XY", "minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is the right", "The accepted answer to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki", "the original author even has the same opinion on the", "an edit that actually added content to an existing answer.", "original author even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark", "detail needs to be added. What is the right way", "some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is the", "of \"The existing answer by XY is good, but ...\".", "be the common way how it is currently done (my", "[his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything but", "...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1", "serves no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to", "This is also my impression - I have been reasonably", "just edit additional information into existing answers, if they feel", "to do anything but minor style edits to other people's", "seems to be the common way how it is currently", "have been reasonably active on the site in the last", "that serves no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed", "1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the", "question is now as follows: If we encounter a question", "[this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of", "do-over for clarity and style). This is also my impression", "Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why", "R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically never happens", "inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the original author", "is good, but ...\". I have done something similar [myself", "a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in", "in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts with", "but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark", "edit additional information into existing answers, if they feel that", "minor style edits to other people's answers. My question is", "is the right way to do it?* 1. Post a", "top seems to suggest to me option 2, but how", "in the last few months, and from the top of", "(my impression at least), but brings us close to community", "practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar", "I have been reasonably active on the site in the", "it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a", "edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional", "impression - I have been reasonably active on the site", "even has the same opinion on the topic? Option 3", "to just edit additional information into existing answers, if they", "anymore, as people are supposed to just edit additional information", "existing answer by XY is good, but ...\". I have", "endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail", "by XY is good, but ...\". I have done something", "What is the right way to do it?** 1. Post", "grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity", "that community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature", "linked at the top seems to suggest to me option", "ask the original author to edit it in. 2. Edit", "been reasonably active on the site in the last few", "this as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that", "guarantee that the original author even endorses a given change.", "or more answers that we consider really good, but we", "opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to be the", "with the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is", "people are supposed to just edit additional information into existing", "to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort", "if they feel that a given answer is good but", "answers, if they feel that a given answer is good", "at the top seems to suggest to me option 2,", "that the original author even has the same opinion on", "of my head I cannot remember a single case where", "the same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to", "never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling", "Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in", "is now as follows: *If we encounter a question that", "given answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg", "is currently done (my impression at least), but brings us", "community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature* that", "2, but how do we guarantee that the original author", "\"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this", "suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy", "as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the", "or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and", "original author even has the same opinion on the topic?", "author even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes", "spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and style).", "is also my impression - I have been reasonably active", "but minor style edits to other people's answers. My question", "to me option 2, but how do we guarantee that", "and from the top of my head I cannot remember", "do it?* 1. Post a comment and ask the original", "information into existing answers, if they feel that a given", "the lines of \"The existing answer by XY is good,", "that we consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish", "to edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3.", "Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice", "along the lines of \"The existing answer by XY is", "highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the original", "encounter a question that already has one or more answers", "detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do", "happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes,", "same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to be", "to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see", "If we encounter a question that already has one or", "good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R.", "way how it is currently done (my impression at least),", "I would also see this as highly inappropriate, as there", "that this in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits", "I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is", "I cannot remember a single case where I have seen", "as follows: If we encounter a question that already has", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of a", "it is currently done (my impression at least), but brings", "would also see this as highly inappropriate, as there is", "is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko", "author even has the same opinion on the topic? Option", "Personally speaking, I would also see this as highly inappropriate,", "the original author even endorses a given change. Poko R.", "missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that", "I have seen an edit that actually added content to", "actually added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I", "to do it?** 1. Post a comment and ask the", "have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok", "Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which", "suggest to me option 2, but how do we guarantee", "feel that a given answer is good but is missing", "that a given answer is good but is missing \"something\".", "feature* that serves no real purpose anymore, as people are", "me option 2, but how do we guarantee that the", "option 2, but how do we guarantee that the original", "a comment and ask the original author to edit it", "into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to", "[myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question", "the top of my head I cannot remember a single", "a question that already has one or more answers that", "existing answers, if they feel that a given answer is", "1. Post a comment and ask the original author to", "cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems to suggest", "seems to suggest to me option 2, but how do", "\"The existing answer by XY is good, but ...\". I", "guarantee that the original author even has the same opinion", "also see this as highly inappropriate, as there is no", "right way to do it?** 1. Post a comment and", "single case where I have seen an edit that actually", "just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for", "answers. My question is now as follows: If we encounter", "anything but minor style edits to other people's answers. My", "good, but ...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094).", "seen an edit that actually added content to an existing", "to be the common way how it is currently done", "- I have been reasonably active on the site in", "people's answers. My question is now as follows: *If we", "question that already has one or more answers that we", "wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature* that serves", "have seen an edit that actually added content to an", "and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically", "a new answer, which starts with something along the lines", "basically never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or", "Provide a new answer, which starts with something along the", "but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added.", "reasonably active on the site in the last few months,", "there is no guarantee that the original author even endorses", "the original author to edit it in. 2. Edit it", "fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This", "remember a single case where I have seen an edit", "the common way how it is currently done (my impression", "original author to edit it in. 2. Edit it in", "answers that we consider really good, but we feel some", "that already has one or more answers that we consider", "3 seems to be the common way how it is", "the top seems to suggest to me option 2, but", "reluctant to do anything but minor style edits to other", "answer by XY is good, but ...\". I have done", "topic? Option 3 seems to be the common way how", "no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just", "in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything", "do anything but minor style edits to other people's answers.", "needs to be added. What is the right way to", "head I cannot remember a single case where I have", "see this as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee", "goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant", "they feel that a given answer is good but is", "content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also", "in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new", "is deemed sort of a legacy feature that serves no", "already has one or more answers that we consider really", "other people's answers. My question is now as follows: If", "Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem", "at least), but brings us close to community wiki territory.", "real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just edit", "we guarantee that the original author even has the same", "ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems", "why people seem reluctant to do anything but minor style", "follows: If we encounter a question that already has one", "done (my impression at least), but brings us close to", "has the same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems", "are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over", "starts with something along the lines of \"The existing answer", "and ask the original author to edit it in. 2.", "all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the", "but cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems to", "edit that actually added content to an existing answer. Personally", "sort of a legacy feature that serves no real purpose", "but how do we guarantee that the original author even", "Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically never", "cannot remember a single case where I have seen an", "as people are supposed to just edit additional information into", "more answers that we consider really good, but we feel", "people seem reluctant to do anything but minor style edits", "a given answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both,", "added content to an existing answer*. Personally speaking, I would", "is no guarantee that the original author even endorses a" ]
[ "11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections", "was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that", "tools as nails for which you have the hammer, and", "make arguments that my question was doing X or wasn't", "it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ...", "comment was that it was a \"shopping question\", which I", "can put forward is the request to not view moderation", "perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question and", "... and apply it to other questions on the site.", "votes started to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow", "academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes,", "exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools", "useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "None have close votes. None even have comments along the", "view moderation tools as nails for which you have the", "question. But maybe it helps give examples of something or", "wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far from anything", "to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer", "is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to", "that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it", "was analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat for", "be an important comment. I did not know what \"boat", "questions (including highly voted questions) on the site do. ---", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on", "quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8.", "--- In any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg)", "this and other topics. I'm not going to be engaging", "not going to be engaging on this question. But maybe", "end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly", "not address highly technical aspects of the software but shall", "programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after", "it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually", "small, irrespective of what you thought of the question itself,", "of boat ... it needs a good coffee machine for", "2. shopping*: \"my favourite X* is x', what's yours?\"; 3.", "[Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers - does", "writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to", "last part of the comment was that it was relevant", "or the other that these questions are off-topic for this", "and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite", "was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions.", "argue why a programmer needs a certain type of boat", "effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you", "tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat", "I had previously added discussion to my question specifying the", "applied to my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1.", "question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making", "argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a", "the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until later):", "favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings. It was", "close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of these questions", "was still a boat programming question since one could argue", "of it using the past tense, [may it rest in", "StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat", "the chance to upvote). I shall speak of it using", "a member of and have no intention of signing up", "a comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His", "\"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and (I", "(not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use my question", "make a question about boats a relevant question. Now I", "> > Queries related to various software used in academia.", "no longer interact with it. It was migrated with about", "would argue that my question was not asking for one's", "up for. Thus I can no longer interact with it.", "referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat", "generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping:", "migrated. None have close votes. None even have comments along", "does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping.", "making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it;", "tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated", "In any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like", "to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense ... and", "question specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator", "comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment", "type of boat ... it needs a good coffee machine", "because I was asking for things. The last part of", "request to not view moderation tools as nails for which", "a set of well-known X or something. I would argue", "[Is there an open source tool for producing bibtex entries", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures", "FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't really find", "recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes,", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future", "cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not", "what I missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean", "2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers -", "for one's favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings.", "is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there", "own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters for", "roughly tried to use my question as a yardstick (of", "Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... ---", "handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat", "3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I", "I can no longer interact with it. It was migrated", "answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had the chance", "the comment was that it was relevant to another StackExchange", "of what you thought of the question itself, all I", "part of the comment was that it was a \"shopping", "rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put", "Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes,", "see until later): > > Queries related to various software", "from research papers. Others could argue it was a shopping", "a set of well-known anythings. It was looking for software", "I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I", "covered in academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool)", "didn't really find anything. I mean I can see that", "draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat", "software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer)", "my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which", "make up your own minds): 1. [Software to use for", "it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\"", "itself, all I can put forward is the request to", "topics covered in academic papers - does such a tool", "or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far from", "put forward is the request to not view moderation tools", "I mean I can see that one could make arguments", "to a site I'm not a member of and have", "Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a", "dunno. Having come to the end of this long meta-question", "dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to other questions", "long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective", "been migrated. None have close votes. None even have comments", "answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do", "of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly", "question\", which I understand is like asking (as an academic)", "see what I missed. I didn't really find anything. I", "x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is", "apply it to other questions on the site. Here's just", "a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question", "that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got", "[based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that", "\"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking (as an", "shopping question I guess because I was asking for things.", "in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "for which you have the hammer, and to moderate with", "address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > > ---", "the other that these questions are off-topic for this site.", "relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion to my", "programming question since one could argue why a programmer needs", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text", "through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to", "to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers)", "3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one", "doing Y in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut", "I'm not a member of and have no intention of", "reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient,", "got on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag", "I shall speak of it using the past tense, [may", "itself (which I didn't see until later): > > Queries", "these questions have been migrated. None have close votes. None", "could make arguments that my question was doing X or", "software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. >", "with it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and", "a relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion to", "software packages to extract and visualise topics from research papers.", "understand is like asking (as an academic) for your favourite", "used in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in", "don't know the process). Hence this seemed to be an", "programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was", "producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer)", "engaging on this question. But maybe it helps give examples", "keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion", "have been migrated. None have close votes. None even have", "discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was", "premises applied to my question, akin to a perfect storm:", "- does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer)", "good coffee machine for example. The other part of the", "was a shopping question I guess because I was asking", "upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note", "process). Hence this seemed to be an important comment. I", "of signing up for. Thus I can no longer interact", "umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on the site", "but far from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen", "the argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make", "visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue it was", "recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes,", "the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would be", "going to be engaging on this question. But maybe it", "1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you", "site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\"", "it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I", "site do. --- But okay, I tried to take as", "why a programmer needs a certain type of boat ...", "of the question itself, all I can put forward is", "4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9", "as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up", "programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and (I guess)", "to the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio", "highly relevant to academia. > > > --- In any", "there an open source tool for producing bibtex entries from", "you thought of the question itself, all I can put", "your favourite x from a set of well-known X or", "research papers. Others could argue it was a shopping question", "it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers", "where I roughly tried to use my question as a", "off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight that the", "site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried", "boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding", "to highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted", "Thus I can no longer interact with it. It was", "taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1", "the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is", "computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer)", "upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not", "address highly technical aspects of the software but shall address", "using the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly", "favourite x from a set of well-known X or something.", "on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of", "of the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to", "academic papers. One could argue that it was still a", "[feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much time on", "was not asking for one's favourite anything from a set", "another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a", "I am not arguing one way or the other that", "putting forward that my question was analogous to asking \"[What", "nails for which you have the hammer, and to moderate", "could argue it was a shopping question I guess because", "find anything. I mean I can see that one could", "started to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I", "forward in a comment that it was a \"boat programming\"", "and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat", "lines of the ones I got on my question. ---", "(I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and it", "5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I", "see that one could make arguments that my question was", "or other. I dunno. Having come to the end of", "being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question", "I was asking for things. The last part of the", "to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't", "Others could argue it was a shopping question I guess", "in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far", "> Queries related to various software used in academia. Questions", "to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my", "I never had the chance to upvote). I shall speak", "insufficient, and why I was looking for something specific for", "an open source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper", "3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing", "I'm not going to be engaging on this question. But", "upvotes (that I never had the chance to upvote). I", "my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming:", "a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up your", "but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward", "of the comment was that it was a \"shopping question\",", "is the request to not view moderation tools as nails", "to many other questions. None of these questions have been", "([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until later): >", "things. The last part of the comment was that it", "upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving", "X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which", "figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "software request for which there is a dedicated SE site.", "for this site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s)", "an important comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\"", "academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for an academic\"", "this seemed to be an important comment. I did not", "argue that it was still a boat programming question since", "coffee machine for example. The other part of the comment", "have no intention of signing up for. Thus I can", "this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small,", "of my questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to", "--- But okay, I tried to take as given the", "there is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it", "recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis", "bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping.", "of and have no intention of signing up for. Thus", "asking for things. The last part of the comment was", "[Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing)", "find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes,", "it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\";", "to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of these", "hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense", "But okay, I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit", "as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet", "it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some", "recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper)", "questions. None of these questions have been migrated. None have", "vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of the question", "to be an important comment. I did not know what", "for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for", "it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment", "there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until", "all I can put forward is the request to not", "features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > > --- In", "question was analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat", "relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was", "to my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. *boat", "answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find", "Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data", "it ... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to", "set of well-known X* or something. I would argue that", "[Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper)", "along the lines of the ones I got on my", "or something. I would argue that my question was not", "the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being", "comment was that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software", "(19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9.", "tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I was", "a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking (as", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted", "votes. None even have comments along the lines of the", "migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4", "that it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is", "academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a relevant question.", "looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I", "academic) for your favourite x from a set of well-known", "Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative", "this site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my", "even have comments along the lines of the ones I", "I can put forward is the request to not view", "could argue that it was still a boat programming question", "certain type of boat ... it needs a good coffee", "\"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the", "one's favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings. It", "machine for example. The other part of the comment was", "commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None", "conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that", "not asking for one's favourite anything from a set of", "questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site", "and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had", "answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and", "after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it was", "have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and", "papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1", "tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I", "the process). Hence this seemed to be an important comment.", "from a set of well-known anythings. It was looking for", "--- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what", "already spent too much time on this and other topics.", "upvotes*, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is", "shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > >", "not view moderation tools as nails for which you have", "well-known X* or something. I would argue that my question", "[Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping.", "I was looking for something specific for academic papers. One", "question? ... Was it ... --- I went looking through", "something specific for academic papers. One could argue that it", "give examples of something or other. I dunno. Having come", "to various software used in academia. Questions shall not address", "highly voted questions) on the site do. --- But okay,", "Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18", "open source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs)", "packages to extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others", "question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my", "something or other. I dunno. Having come to the end", "for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1", "reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming.", "argue that my question was not asking for one's favourite", "too much time on this and other topics. I'm not", "chance to upvote). I shall speak of it using the", "why I was looking for something specific for academic papers.", "was putting forward that my question was analogous to asking", "for academic papers. One could argue that it was still", "much time on this and other topics. I'm not going", "example. The other part of the comment was that it", "question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I", "no intention of signing up for. Thus I can no", "it helps give examples of something or other. I dunno.", "about boats a relevant question. Now I had previously added", "and it got migrated somehow (I don't know the process).", "irrespective of what you thought of the question itself, all", "these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to", "I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much time", "that my question was doing X or wasn't doing Y", "10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool", "that these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying", "4 upvotes (that I never had the chance to upvote).", "my questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a", "specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would", "a certain type of boat ... it needs a good", "my question was doing X or wasn't doing Y in", "tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes,", "other that these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm", "meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was", "is like asking (as an academic) for your favourite x", "your own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters", "went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed.", "guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and it got", "my question was analogous to asking \"[What is the best", "from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on", "what you thought of the question itself, all I can", "Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic", "highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to", "in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward", "on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my", "Hence this seemed to be an important comment. I did", "question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other", "recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes,", "from a set of well-known X or something. I would", "question was not asking for one's favourite anything from a", "(which I didn't see until later): > > Queries related", "to academia. > > > --- In any case, aside", "migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this seemed", "for. Thus I can no longer interact with it. It", "later): > > Queries related to various software used in", "2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten", "But maybe it helps give examples of something or other.", "answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager)", "the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it", "[Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers)", "[may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after", "papers. One could argue that it was still a boat", "SE site. ... and apply it to other questions on", "way or the other that these questions are off-topic for", "some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to appear", "to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it", "it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an", "here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was analogous", "guess because I was asking for things. The last part", "ones I got on my question. --- Likewise there's the", "x from a set of well-known X or something. I", "I got on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software))", "comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before", "a good coffee machine for example. The other part of", "doing X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but", "my question was not asking for one's favourite anything from", "answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository", "member of and have no intention of signing up for.", "I have already spent too much time on this and", "a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why", "the lines of the ones I got on my question.", "my question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so", "related to various software used in academia. Questions shall not", "that my question was not asking for one's favourite anything", "text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming.", "topics. I'm not going to be engaging on this question.", "(as an academic) for your favourite x from a set", "for software packages to extract and visualise topics from research", "the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia.", "recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one way or", "for your favourite x from a set of well-known X", "arguments that my question was doing X or wasn't doing", "\"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about),", "maybe it helps give examples of something or other. I", "discussion to my question specifying the reasons why a generic", "Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a", "akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am", "why a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and", "notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming.", "boat programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\"", "I roughly tried to use my question as a yardstick", "which there is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply", "which I understand is like asking (as an academic) for", "the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far from", "boat ... it needs a good coffee machine for example.", "an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had the", "for example. The other part of the comment was that", "a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I went", "between topics covered in academic papers - does such a", "take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question,", "the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question", "comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started", "was that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where", "one way or the other that these questions are off-topic", "question itself, all I can put forward is the request", "a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member", "(I don't know the process). Hence this seemed to be", "[Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10", "recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers", "The other part of the comment was that it was", "was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking", "explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to a perfect", "what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is a", "forward is the request to not view moderation tools as", "1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git", "searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "X or something. I would argue that my question was", "was doing X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ", "papers. Others could argue it was a shopping question I", "a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to other", "an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a relevant", "12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there", "9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to", "8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3", "qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat", "apply to many other questions. None of these questions have", "question I guess because I was asking for things. The", "looking for software packages to extract and visualise topics from", "[the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't really", "of the comment was that it was relevant to another", "questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight", "(2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11.", "not a member of and have no intention of signing", "and why I was looking for something specific for academic", "software used in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical", "question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it", "for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "until later): > > Queries related to various software used", "1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation", "added discussion to my question specifying the reasons why a", "a site I'm not a member of and have no", "the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to a", "paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7.", "I guess because I was asking for things. The last", "... the argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't", "with clarity, consistency and common sense ... and reluctance. Ciao!", "forward that my question was analogous to asking \"[What is", "boat programming question since one could argue why a programmer", "needs a certain type of boat ... it needs a", "and other topics. I'm not going to be engaging on", "[Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative", "and have no intention of signing up for. Thus I", "examples of something or other. I dunno. Having come to", "like I have already spent too much time on this", "time on this and other topics. I'm not going to", "upvote). I shall speak of it using the past tense,", "Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to", "paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software:", "that it was still a boat programming question since one", "(of course I'm biased, so make up your own minds):", "of the ones I got on my question. --- Likewise", "a boat programming question since one could argue why a", "7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers)", "[Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes,", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes", "ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought", "an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for an", "really find anything. I mean I can see that one", "for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software", "processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "\"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is", "paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting", "just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use", "in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of", "technical aspects of the software but shall address features/issues highly", "[Software to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a", "storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question and sticking", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing", "was looking for software packages to extract and visualise topics", "(that I never had the chance to upvote). I shall", "questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where", "the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly", "was that it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand", "generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I", "Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one way", "know the process). Hence this seemed to be an important", "have already spent too much time on this and other", "speak of it using the past tense, [may it rest", "PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching", "future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "other questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples", "1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising", "come to the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward", "looking for something specific for academic papers. One could argue", "Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of the software", "to other questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick", "was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes", "I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied", "other questions (including highly voted questions) on the site do.", "know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the", "Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3", "I didn't see until later): > > Queries related to", "[migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member of and", "I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question was", "argue it was a shopping question I guess because I", "Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers)", "recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords)", "had previously added discussion to my question specifying the reasons", "a question about boats a relevant question. Now I had", "other topics. I'm not going to be engaging on this", "(18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5.", "to my question specifying the reasons why a generic tag", "to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic", "His comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes", "the question itself, all I can put forward is the", "and apply it to other questions on the site. Here's", "it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like", "researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member of", "on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself", "close votes. None even have comments along the lines of", "well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages to extract", "(18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12.", "(10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking", "on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what", "analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "@EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was analogous to", "mean I can see that one could make arguments that", "question. His comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close", "the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common", "yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is a dedicated", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in", "Now I had previously added discussion to my question specifying", "voted questions) on the site do. --- But okay, I", "a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing", "programmer needs a certain type of boat ... it needs", "Having come to the end of this long meta-question whose", "the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply", "since one could argue why a programmer needs a certain", "course I'm biased, so make up your own minds): 1.", "a programmer needs a certain type of boat ... it", "the comment was that it was a \"shopping question\", which", "answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a", "relevant to academia. > > > --- In any case,", "doesn't make a question about boats a relevant question. Now", "> --- In any case, aside from being confused, I", "> > > --- In any case, aside from being", "asking \"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ...", "on this and other topics. I'm not going to be", "questions have been migrated. None have close votes. None even", "for which there is a dedicated SE site. ... and", "None even have comments along the lines of the ones", "(6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for", "given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to", "[Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes,", "for things. The last part of the comment was that", "never had the chance to upvote). I shall speak of", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data", "arguing one way or the other that these questions are", "boats a relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion", "generator would be insufficient, and why I was looking for", "recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool for producing", "you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2", "shall speak of it using the past tense, [may it", "my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many", "None of these questions have been migrated. None have close", "Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a", "FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far from anything", "I understand is like asking (as an academic) for your", "anything from a set of well-known anythings. It was looking", "on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I", "up your own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating", "I can see that one could make arguments that my", "shall not address highly technical aspects of the software but", "can no longer interact with it. It was migrated with", "source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6", "question was doing X or wasn't doing Y in the", "being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too", "\"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ...", "had the chance to upvote). I shall speak of it", "posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming.", "Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19", "manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue", "meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of", "question. Now I had previously added discussion to my question", "aspects of the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant", "--- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't", "anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions (including", "use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11", "I dunno. Having come to the end of this long", "after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's", "tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm", "not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on", "(28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2.", "9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2", "it needs a good coffee machine for example. The other", "... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ...", "important comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant", "question about boats a relevant question. Now I had previously", "I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but", "Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool for", "organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers)", "the ones I got on my question. --- Likewise there's", "the request to not view moderation tools as nails for", "connections between topics covered in academic papers - does such", "for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.)", "other questions. None of these questions have been migrated. None", "have close votes. None even have comments along the lines", "the site do. --- But okay, I tried to take", "would be insufficient, and why I was looking for something", "be insufficient, and why I was looking for something specific", "(57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6.", "of well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages to", "somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this seemed to", "for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat", "site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question", "that my question was analogous to asking \"[What is the", "is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of", "something. I would argue that my question was not asking", "a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have", "clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly", "anything. I mean I can see that one could make", "collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming.", "[Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers)", "upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software", "data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming.", "> > --- In any case, aside from being confused,", "... Was it ... --- I went looking through [the", "but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > >", "I missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean I", "was asking for things. The last part of the comment", "about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that", "@EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it was a", "on the site do. --- But okay, I tried to", "\"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I went looking", "it was a shopping question I guess because I was", "Was it ... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask)", "(2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10.", "analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat for an", "recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (*57", "to use my question as a yardstick (of course I'm", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered", "One of my questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics)", "trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented", "set of well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages", "One could argue that it was still a boat programming", "upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping", "of well-known X* or something. I would argue that my", "in a comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question.", "yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up your own", "a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and", "3. software request for which there is a dedicated SE", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool", "when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming.", "didn't see until later): > > Queries related to various", "was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer with", "tried to use my question as a yardstick (of course", "anythings. It was looking for software packages to extract and", "longer interact with it. It was migrated with about 5", "anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on the", "for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when", "topics from research papers. Others could argue it was a", "use my question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased,", "my question specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud", "such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software", "be engaging on this question. But maybe it helps give", "6. [Is there an open source tool for producing bibtex", "and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense ...", "helps give examples of something or other. I dunno. Having", "other. I dunno. Having come to the end of this", "with 4 upvotes (that I never had the chance to", "that one could make arguments that my question was doing", "you have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency", "minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters for academic", "comments along the lines of the ones I got on", "academia. > > > --- In any case, aside from", "one could make arguments that my question was doing X", "on this question. But maybe it helps give examples of", "illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming.", "recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3", "far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions)", "question since one could argue why a programmer needs a", "(3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for", "3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking", "have comments along the lines of the ones I got", "missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean I can", "previously added discussion to my question specifying the reasons why", "site I'm not a member of and have no intention", "Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable", "do. --- But okay, I tried to take as given", "various software used in academia. Questions shall not address highly", "shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software", "was looking for something specific for academic papers. One could", "academics\" after it; 2. shopping*: \"my favourite X* is x',", "for something specific for academic papers. One could argue that", "needs a good coffee machine for example. The other part", "The last part of the comment was that it was", "to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes,", "which you have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity,", "was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated.", "this question. But maybe it helps give examples of something", "X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far", "to see what I missed. I didn't really find anything.", "upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards", "it to other questions on the site. Here's just some", "to extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others could", "5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes,", "not arguing one way or the other that these questions", "and (I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for", "an academic) for your favourite x from a set of", "from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent", "(including highly voted questions) on the site do. --- But", "It was looking for software packages to extract and visualise", "and visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue it", "questions) on the site do. --- But okay, I tried", "extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue", "moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense ... and reluctance.", "seemed to be an important comment. I did not know", "migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it", "as nails for which you have the hammer, and to", "... it needs a good coffee machine for example. The", "some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use my", "Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see", "12. ... I am not arguing one way or the", "past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was", "many other questions. None of these questions have been migrated.", "spent too much time on this and other topics. I'm", "to asking \"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\"", "request for which there is a dedicated SE site. ...", "thought of the question itself, all I can put forward", "programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers", "tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes*, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "like asking (as an academic) for your favourite x* from", "migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it", "question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make", "... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see", "a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2.", "of these questions have been migrated. None have close votes.", "[Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers)", "got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to", "one could argue why a programmer needs a certain type", "tag itself (which I didn't see until later): > >", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference)", "11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18", "in academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3", "Queries related to various software used in academia. Questions shall", "from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions", "I would argue that my question was not asking for", "close votes started to appear afterwards and it got migrated", "eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was", "it using the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg).", "am not arguing one way or the other that these", "seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of the", "1. boat programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for", "a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "intention of signing up for. Thus I can no longer", "favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for", "could argue why a programmer needs a certain type of", "with about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes", "is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument", "\"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request", "[Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful)", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration", "for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat", "interact with it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes", "I didn't really find anything. I mean I can see", "site. ... and apply it to other questions on the", "far from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other", "to be engaging on this question. But maybe it helps", "got migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this", "tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to", "asking for one's favourite anything from a set of well-known", "1. [Software to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences)", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics", "generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a", "confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much", "cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I was looking", "that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated", "highly technical aspects of the software but shall address features/issues", "aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already", "specific for academic papers. One could argue that it was", "adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats", "academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of the", "put forward in a comment that it was a \"boat", "a shopping question I guess because I was asking for", "asking (as an academic) for your favourite x from a", "so make up your own minds): 1. [Software to use", "Y in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and", "it was still a boat programming question since one could", "to upvote). I shall speak of it using the past", "okay, I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises", "biased, so make up your own minds): 1. [Software to", "Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question?", "(5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4.", "that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about", "can see that one could make arguments that my question", "a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1", "appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't know", "I'm biased, so make up your own minds): 1. [Software", "examples where I roughly tried to use my question as", "\"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a", "part of the comment was that it was relevant to", "sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X", "did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based", "of something or other. I dunno. Having come to the", "... I am not arguing one way or the other", "entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software", "from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight that", "afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't know the", "still a boat programming question since one could argue why", "to not view moderation tools as nails for which you", "moderation tools as nails for which you have the hammer,", "it got migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence", "upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ...", "signing up for. Thus I can no longer interact with", "other part of the comment was that it was a", "tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3.", "and far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an", "peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in", "a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question?" ]
[ "cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the answers are", "I would like to get some feedback/discussion on the matter.", "we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on", "(i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as", "on how it's done in France, and has very little", "fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really", "a particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically", "to it is fair or ethical, or wise for that", "is a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus),", "this a wise way to deal with cheating? > >", "whole lot of feedback. As I don't want to go", "raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole", "ethical, or wise for that matter. I like the question,", "the scope and modus operandi* here on SE sites, this", "answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question", "not even answering the question at hand but instead providing", "per se, but as I understand the scope and modus", "our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example,", "is practically asking whether or not a particular scheme used", "whether or not a particular scheme used at his/her school", "on SE sites, this type of question is a bad", "a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but", "so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how it's done", "As I don't want to go on a downvote spree", "France, and has very little reference to it is fair", "bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't", "wise way to deal with cheating? > > > Not", "perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just", "different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674),", "Do you *think* this is ethical? Is this a wise", "is ethical? Is this a wise way to deal with", "question at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at", "school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says", "[This](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21095/5674) question here is practically asking whether or not a", "do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how", "and modus operandi here on SE sites, this type of", "mine): > > Do you *think* this is ethical? Is", "it's done in France, and has very little reference to", "to go on a downvote spree based on a hunch", "here on SE sites, this type of question is a", "go on a downvote spree based on a hunch I", "on a downvote spree based on a hunch I would", "at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our", "feedback. As I don't want to go on a downvote", "opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question at hand", "hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion on the", "haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I", "focuses on how it's done in France, and has very", "as I understand the scope and modus operandi* here on", "the heart of the question says (emphasis mine): > >", "question, per se, but as I understand the scope and", "Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis mine): >", "instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\").", "scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart", "like the question, per se, but as I understand the", "SE sites, this type of question is a bad fit.", "are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question at", "at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the", "Is this a wise way to deal with cheating? >", "[before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback.", "an example, focuses on how it's done in France, and", "reference to it is fair or ethical, or wise for", "but as I understand the scope and modus operandi here", "used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of", "based on a hunch I would like to get some", "concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot of", "asking whether or not a particular scheme used at his/her", "type of question is a bad fit. I have raised", "for that matter. I like the question, per se, but", "fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis mine):", "I like the question, per se, but as I understand", "particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the", "way to deal with cheating? > > > Not so", "little reference to it is fair or ethical, or wise", "a whole lot of feedback. As I don't want to", "have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a", "this type of question is a bad fit. I have", "deal with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the", "> > Do you *think* this is ethical? Is this", "answering the question at hand but instead providing different perspective", "Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not", "is fair or ethical, or wise for that matter. I", "here is practically asking whether or not a particular scheme", "of question is a bad fit. I have raised similar", "> Do you *think* this is ethical? Is this a", "se, but as I understand the scope and modus operandi", "example, focuses on how it's done in France, and has", "would like to get some feedback/discussion on the matter. Opinions?", "but haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As", "a wise way to deal with cheating? > > >", "sites, this type of question is a bad fit. I", "heart of the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do", "and has very little reference to it is fair or", "of the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you", "matter. I like the question, per se, but as I", "spree based on a hunch I would like to get", "or not a particular scheme used at his/her school is", "[This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how it's", "operandi here on SE sites, this type of question is", "it is fair or ethical, or wise for that matter.", "on a hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion", "understand the scope and modus operandi here on SE sites,", "of feedback. As I don't want to go on a", "or ethical, or wise for that matter. I like the", "> Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes", "\"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an", "lot of feedback. As I don't want to go on", "but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we", "don't want to go on a downvote spree based on", "I don't want to go on a downvote spree based", "> > Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and", "wise for that matter. I like the question, per se,", "as an example, focuses on how it's done in France,", "how it's done in France, and has very little reference", "a hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion on", "this is ethical? Is this a wise way to deal", "very little reference to it is fair or ethical, or", "a downvote spree based on a hunch I would like", "really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I don't", "done in France, and has very little reference to it", "you think* this is ethical? Is this a wise way", "> > > Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated,", "institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses", "or wise for that matter. I like the question, per", "even answering the question at hand but instead providing different", "to deal with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly", "that matter. I like the question, per se, but as", "has very little reference to it is fair or ethical,", "similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot", "gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I don't want", "the question at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e.", "want to go on a downvote spree based on a", "just as an example, focuses on how it's done in", "the question, per se, but as I understand the scope", "fair or ethical, or wise for that matter. I like", "downvote spree based on a hunch I would like to", "is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis", "question is a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns", "in France, and has very little reference to it is", "(emphasis mine): > > Do you *think* this is ethical?", "providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This", "the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the", "I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten", "his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question", "and sometimes not even answering the question at hand but", "says (emphasis mine): > > Do you *think* this is", "*think* this is ethical? Is this a wise way to", "hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution", "surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering", "ethical? Is this a wise way to deal with cheating?", "question here is practically asking whether or not a particular", "question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you think* this", "with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the answers", "scope and modus operandi here on SE sites, this type", "not a particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical.", "sometimes not even answering the question at hand but instead", "I understand the scope and modus operandi here on SE", "the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you *think", "practically asking whether or not a particular scheme used at", "modus operandi* here on SE sites, this type of question" ]
[ "a new question on meta anytime a potential migration comes", "which outlined the criteria one should use to make that", "want it. So, I'm proposing that we use this as", "back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the", "on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or", "Is the question on-topic at your site? If yes, it", "closed for other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If", "in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new", "potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both", "site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that we", "one should use to make that decision. I can't find", "when to to migrate questions away from the site. A", "I'm proposing that we use this as our template for", "poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods", "over when to to migrate questions away from the site.", "question on-topic at your site? If yes, it should stay.", "sites. This should be handled via flags, a mod will", "site. A while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange", "the question on-topic at a different site? If yes, then...", "If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a different", "for other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no...", "broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever", "process is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at", "meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use to make", "we can ask the site whether they want it. So,", "meta anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly become", "as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your site?", "chat rooms, simply because posting a new question on meta", "question be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but", "on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use to", "If yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed after", "flag and we can ask the site whether they want", "the process is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic", "relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic", "a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question", "new question on meta anytime a potential migration comes up", "So, I'm proposing that we use this as our template", "reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in the mod", "but the process is as follows: 1. Is the question", "and we can ask the site whether they want it.", "but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic", "3. Would the question be closed after migration? Some questions", "a potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for", "it should stay. (Whether it should be closed for other", "for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in", "quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled", "(Whether it should be closed for other reasons is not", "then... 3. Would the question be closed after migration? Some", "Would the question be closed after migration? Some questions are", "A while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which", "the question on-topic at your site? If yes, it should", "be handled via flags, a mod will see the flag", "handle this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because", "that decision. I can't find the question, but the process", "yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be closed for", "stay. (Whether it should be closed for other reasons is", "proposing that we use this as our template for migration.", "will see the flag and we can ask the site", "is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your", "at your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it", "phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will", "yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed after migration?", "question, but the process is as follows: 1. Is the", "away from the site. A while back, I found a", "migrate questions away from the site. A while back, I", "generally handle this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply", "or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this", "are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed,", "Mods will generally handle this communication in the mod chat", "the flag and we can ask the site whether they", "questions away from the site. A while back, I found", "after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or", "site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed", "flags, a mod will see the flag and we can", "on-topic at your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether", "whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that we use", "your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should", "outlined the criteria one should use to make that decision.", "the site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that", "to make that decision. I can't find the question, but", "not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question", "comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This", "use to make that decision. I can't find the question,", "while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined", "Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased,", "the site. A while back, I found a question on", "migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a", "discussion recently over when to to migrate questions away from", "has been much discussion recently over when to to migrate", "found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one", "at a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the", "to migrate questions away from the site. A while back,", "it. So, I'm proposing that we use this as our", "can't find the question, but the process is as follows:", "closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad,", "up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should", "reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is", "simply because posting a new question on meta anytime a", "detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle", "other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2.", "the question, but the process is as follows: 1. Is", "for both sites. This should be handled via flags, a", "There has been much discussion recently over when to to", "should be handled via flags, a mod will see the", "the question be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic", "unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled via flags,", "the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new question", "I can't find the question, but the process is as", "be closed for other reasons is not relevant to migration.)", "posting a new question on meta anytime a potential migration", "1. Is the question on-topic at your site? If yes,", "been much discussion recently over when to to migrate questions", "see the flag and we can ask the site whether", "a mod will see the flag and we can ask", "can ask the site whether they want it. So, I'm", "If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be closed", "too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for", "communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a", "this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting", "anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable", "I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria", "migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly", "different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question be", "be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too", "decision. I can't find the question, but the process is", "is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the", "would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should be", "whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in the", "no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a different site?", "or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons.", "will generally handle this communication in the mod chat rooms,", "to to migrate questions away from the site. A while", "on-topic at a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would", "recently over when to to migrate questions away from the", "2. Is the question on-topic at a different site? If", "make that decision. I can't find the question, but the", "from the site. A while back, I found a question", "a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should", "This should be handled via flags, a mod will see", "site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be", "become unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled via", "follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your site? If", "on meta anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly", "should use to make that decision. I can't find the", "the criteria one should use to make that decision. I", "find the question, but the process is as follows: 1.", "migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites.", "should stay. (Whether it should be closed for other reasons", "mod will see the flag and we can ask the", "mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new question on", "handled via flags, a mod will see the flag and", "ask the site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing", "questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too", "because posting a new question on meta anytime a potential", "question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use", "both sites. This should be handled via flags, a mod", "problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication", "it should be closed for other reasons is not relevant", "much discussion recently over when to to migrate questions away", "should be closed for other reasons is not relevant to", "they want it. So, I'm proposing that we use this", "via flags, a mod will see the flag and we", "rooms, simply because posting a new question on meta anytime", "question on meta anytime a potential migration comes up would", "to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at", "Is the question on-topic at a different site? If yes,", "criteria one should use to make that decision. I can't", "question on-topic at a different site? If yes, then... 3.", "too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally" ]
[ "as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist > >", "rude and offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody", "known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather", "The flag was declined. Anybody have any insight on this?", "referred to somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating", "> which seems rather rude and offensive to me. The", "flagged a [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as a", "a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist > > >", "which seems rather rude and offensive to me. The flag", "to somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist", "> > which seems rather rude and offensive to me.", "because it referred to somebody as a > > known,", "[comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as a > >", "rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather rude", "offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have any", "> known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems", "feminist > > > which seems rather rude and offensive", "a [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as a >", "somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist >", "male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather rude and", "> > > which seems rather rude and offensive to", "I flagged a [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as", "> > known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which", "seems rather rude and offensive to me. The flag was", "rather rude and offensive to me. The flag was declined.", "and offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have", "to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have any insight", "it referred to somebody as a > > known, rabid", "me. The flag was declined. Anybody have any insight on" ]
[ "listing? I find it more difficult to scan and it", "to be a lot more spacing above and below each", "much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears to", "as if it is an oversight or a bug. Can", "sites in regard to the question listing? I find it", "asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the original design post.", "most (all?) SE sites in regard to the question listing?", "bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears to be", "also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the original design", "The entries in the question listing on Academia.SE are much", "a reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites", "it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes", "me feel as if it is an oversight or a", "requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me", "there a reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE", "changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746)", "SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different than most", "find it more difficult to scan and it requires more", "or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was", "each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason", "feel as if it is an oversight or a bug.", "bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked", "is an oversight or a bug. Can this be changed???", "There appears to be a lot more spacing above and", "(all?) SE sites in regard to the question listing? I", "Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for", "scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as", "in the question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically", "makes me feel as if it is an oversight or", "listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE", "it is an oversight or a bug. Can this be", "the question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than", "a lot more spacing above and below each question entry.", "more difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling. The", "SE sites in regard to the question listing? I find", "different than most (all?) SE sites in regard to the", "question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other", "below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a", "an oversight or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT:", "this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in", "on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE sites.", "more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel", "appears to be a lot more spacing above and below", "than other SE sites. There appears to be a lot", "oversight or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This", "are much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears", "reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites in", "Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites in regard", "of emptiness makes me feel as if it is an", "a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also", "above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is", "other SE sites. There appears to be a lot more", "regard to the question listing? I find it more difficult", "it more difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling.", "if it is an oversight or a bug. Can this", "EDIT: This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on", "was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the original", "difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast", "entries in the question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger", "This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the", "I find it more difficult to scan and it requires", "question listing? I find it more difficult to scan and", "The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as if", "Is there a reason Academia is different than most (all?)", "is different than most (all?) SE sites in regard to", "to scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount", "the question listing? I find it more difficult to scan", "versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different than", "be a lot more spacing above and below each question", "entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is", "to the question listing? I find it more difficult to", "in regard to the question listing? I find it more", "Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There", "vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as if it", "than most (all?) SE sites in regard to the question", "amount of emptiness makes me feel as if it is", "question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia", "![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different", "spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png)", "lot more spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia", "vertically than other SE sites. There appears to be a", "scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of", "more spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus", "and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there", "and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness", "be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in a", "sites. There appears to be a lot more spacing above", "emptiness makes me feel as if it is an oversight", "SE sites. There appears to be a lot more spacing" ]
[ "go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" ", "several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems", "to... ?\" \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are", "Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that", "academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There are 4614", "that many of these questions go something like: * \"Is", "are there radically different standards for civility in real life", "unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for", "There are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns", "* \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal", "so many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is", "it normal to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette", "* \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite", "etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique", "protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE", "are there so many etiquette and protocol type questions at", "of these questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate", "polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why", "in real life academia? Some numbers from the SE API.", "a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in", "Some numbers from the SE API. There are 4614 total", "\"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to...", "it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\"", "Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically", "questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many", "SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot", "this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards", "seems that many of these questions go something like: ", "questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these questions go", "It seems that many of these questions go something like:", "regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the", "\"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there so many", "I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar.", "are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665", "appropriate to... ?\" \"Is it polite to... ?\" ", "\"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these questions", "in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of", "Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different", "type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or", "and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to", "academic, I am however a regular SE user. I see", "many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this", "or are there radically different standards for civility in real", "from the SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a", "however a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions", "?\" Why are there so many etiquette and protocol type", "many of these questions go something like: \"Is it", "am however a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE", "API. There are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\"", "there radically different standards for civility in real life academia?", "like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it", "something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is", "civility in real life academia? Some numbers from the SE", "for civility in real life academia? Some numbers from the", "Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for civility in", "?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there", "to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is", "\"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to...", "the SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a search", "4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665 results.", "at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there", "these questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to...", "numbers from the SE API. There are 4614 total questions,", "to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette and protocol", "see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It", "there so many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE?", "standards for civility in real life academia? Some numbers from", "sidebar. It seems that many of these questions go something", "not an academic, I am however a regular SE user.", "radically different standards for civility in real life academia? Some", "real life academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There", "different standards for civility in real life academia? Some numbers", "to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for civility", "life academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There are", "normal to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette and", "Why are there so many etiquette and protocol type questions", "am not an academic, I am however a regular SE", "user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\"", "* \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there so", "SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a search for", "questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665 results. Roughly 14%.", "?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it", "an academic, I am however a regular SE user. I", "the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these", "total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665 results. Roughly", "I am however a regular SE user. I see several", "questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are", "I am not an academic, I am however a regular", "it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\"", "questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\"" ]
[ "not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu", "the review list is not consistent. For instance, in the", "cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note that this", "that this behaviour does not last, and after a while,", "the number of tasks in the review list is not", "behaviour does not last, and after a while, the number", "while I can't see any to actually review. I've tried", "actually review. I've tried to open the site in a", "and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would", "a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like", "does not last, and after a while, the number disappears.", "3 tasks to review, while I can't see any to", "last, and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it", "to actually review. I've tried to open the site in", "while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a", "in a new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the", "in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks", "any to actually review. I've tried to open the site", "graduation, I've observed that quite often, the number of tasks", "to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the same.", "the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a refresh", "of tasks in the review list is not consistent. For", "browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the", "I've observed that quite often, the number of tasks in", "same. Note that this behaviour does not last, and after", "disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a refresh problem. ![screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/XEisw.png)", "number of tasks in the review list is not consistent.", "often, the number of tasks in the review list is", "Note that this behaviour does not last, and after a", "review list is not consistent. For instance, in the attached", "the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I", "I've tried to open the site in a new browser,", "site in a new browser, to avoid any cache issue,", "a new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem", "after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem", "not last, and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively,", "For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays", "attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review,", "bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't see", "review. I've tried to open the site in a new", "the site in a new browser, to avoid any cache", "this behaviour does not last, and after a while, the", "to open the site in a new browser, to avoid", "tasks to review, while I can't see any to actually", "the problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour does", "any cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note that", "quite often, the number of tasks in the review list", "screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while", "top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't", "to review, while I can't see any to actually review.", "number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a refresh problem.", "is not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the", "the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to", "I can't see any to actually review. I've tried to", "in the review list is not consistent. For instance, in", "instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3", "displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't see any", "review, while I can't see any to actually review. I've", "the same. Note that this behaviour does not last, and", "new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains", "see any to actually review. I've tried to open the", "remains the same. Note that this behaviour does not last,", "can't see any to actually review. I've tried to open", "that quite often, the number of tasks in the review", "issue, the problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour", "tried to open the site in a new browser, to", "observed that quite often, the number of tasks in the", "problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour does not", "Since graduation, I've observed that quite often, the number of", "consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar", "tasks in the review list is not consistent. For instance,", "open the site in a new browser, to avoid any", "avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note", "list is not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot," ]
[ "perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP has", "> > > Civility is required at all times; rudeness", "advanced his work really is.\" I think the underlying concern", "true, but in fact we don't even know whether the", "it bad for one's future career prospects if the PhD", "judgment. In a cursory search, I could not uncover the", "see objective grounds for the exclusive judgement that it is", "is required at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated", "clarification whether the OP has discussed the question with their", "conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. >", "for one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic", "the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is a", "in his work that it all seems obvious, and the", "situation that could have lead to the OP's question: The", "information. This is not only rude, but it is IMHO", "his work that it all seems obvious, and the student", "if the OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask", "because the OP knows) to update the working title of", "OPs real name and the papers. Noone else so far", "don't even know whether the papers are just loosely connected)", "Noone else so far stated that they actually know the", "Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers", "reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed", "about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this", "possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment", "also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * *bad", "it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP", "times; rudeness will not be tolerated > > > ", "based on the available information. This is not only rude,", "think the underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves", "so far stated that they actually know the papers, not", "rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead", "supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference", "explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to", "on the available information. This is not only rude, but", "> > > * but even more important, I see", "the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > > Civility", "considerably more content than can be judged by us right", "one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is", "not be true, but in fact we don't even know", "the underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves better", "calm words if there is a smell of bad supervisor,", "judged by us right now). Yet we have statements that", "future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad)", "nice. > > > Civility is required at all times;", "also to state in calm words if there is a", "\"My question does not ask for your opinion about my", "objective grounds for the exclusive** judgement that it is the", "state in calm words if there is a smell of", "reason. * the thesis does not deserve the grade: This", "judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think it perfectly", "comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for which I", "the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't", "my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this statement", "be two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless", "to a final title, and the OP has trouble formulating", "> Civility is required at all times; rudeness will not", "papers. Noone else so far stated that they actually know", "survey at my university.\" (Which may or may not be", "two months from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\"", "the institution, but at the institution I work, you would", "fact we don't even know whether the papers are just", "to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with", "have considerably more content than can be judged by us", "harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the", "reasonable task towards the end of the thesis, and a", "> > Be nice.* > > > Civility is required", "now). Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely connected", "e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's", "but even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this", "that we need to behave ourselves better is related to", "the fact that the thesis may be long-form, and thus", "that they actually know the papers, not even after asking", "of @krammer which I cannot link) for which I do", "may have considerably more content than can be judged by", "all seems obvious, and the student does not recognize how", "huge difference between stating that the supervision is the problem", "didn't need to tell because the OP knows) to update", "comments beeing rude. + There is at least one rather", "uncover the OPs real name and the papers. Noone else", "question does not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\"", "end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus,", "[etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > > Civility is", "a student is so absorbed in his work that it", "deserve the grade:** This is an extremely serious judgment. In", "\"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome", "supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't need to", "real name and the papers. Noone else so far stated", "underlying reason. * the thesis does not deserve the grade:", "told the OP (or didn't need to tell because the", "opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that", "IMHO + it should be respected if the OP explicitly", "loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome of a", "that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments", "their supervisor, and also to state in calm words if", "do not see proper grounds based on the available information.", "could have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may", "us right now). Yet we have statements that \"set of", "we don't even know whether the papers are just loosely", "not deserve the grade:** This is an extremely serious judgment.", "And I actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up", "out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student", "working title of the thesis to a final title, and", "years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations,", "not only rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific", "right now). Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely", "an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could", "does not recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I", "in calm words if there is a smell of bad", "and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective", "is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the", "work really is.\" I think the underlying concern that we", "be two months from completion. You'd be two years from", "and the papers. Noone else so far stated that they", "ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad", "bad supervision:* While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask", "statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be", "the comments beeing rude. + There is at least one", "topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick", "may not be true, but in fact we don't even", "the OP has discussed the question with their supervisor, and", "my university.\" (Which may or may not be true, but", "after asking (besides the fact that the thesis may be", "OP has discussed the question with their supervisor, and also", "least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his work", "of a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may", "is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are:", "rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the", "university.\" (Which may or may not be true, but in", "I could not uncover the OPs real name and the", "see proper grounds based on the available information. This is", "supervision is the problem and that problems with the supervision", "the end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty.", "jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > >", "if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is", "but at the institution I work, you would not be", "is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I", "towards the end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal", "exclusive judgement that it is the supervision that is bad.", "one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have", "grounds for the exclusive* judgement that it is the supervision", "and thus may have considerably more content than can be", "respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question does not", "knows) to update the working title of the thesis to", "long-form, and thus may have considerably more content than can", "and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to the", "is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between stating", "the exclusive judgement that it is the supervision that is", "My concern is that we're rather quick at jumping to", "we need to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's", "* bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable to", "with the supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the", "to update the working title of the thesis to a", "+ There is at least one rather obvious and perfectly", "of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I", "or may not be true, but in fact we don't", "supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this statement is", "by us right now). Yet we have statements that \"set", "broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick at jumping", "OP knows) to update the working title of the thesis", "the grade:** This is an extremely serious judgment. In a", "\"It will depend on the institution, but at the institution", "it all seems obvious, and the student does not recognize", "serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could not uncover", "need to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern", "also in the comments of @krammer which I cannot link)", "is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\"", "which I cannot link) for which I do not see", "we have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...]", "While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification", "think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the", "not recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I think", "it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments", "have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may have", "at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) >", "but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2", "a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the thesis,", "institution I work, you would not be two months from", "thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather", "has trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable", "in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is", "only rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice.", "not be two months from completion. You'd be two years", "is.\" I think the underlying concern that we need to", "bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between stating that", "papers [...] would be called outcome of a good literature", "question: The supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't", "be true, but in fact we don't even know whether", "if there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO +", "trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task", "has discussed the question with their supervisor, and also to", "[this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer which", "serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice.", "the OPs real name and the papers. Noone else so", "and also to state in calm words if there is", "IMHO there is a huge difference between stating that the", "and the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is", "comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed", "this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing", "perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to the OP's", "behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with the", "be judged by us right now). Yet we have statements", "is at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation", "his work really is.\" I think the underlying concern that", "the OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask for", "a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds", " but even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g.", "difference between stating that the supervision is the problem and", "is that we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions:", "> > * but even more important, I see harsh", "have told the OP (or didn't need to tell because", "OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly", "papers, not even after asking (besides the fact that the", "good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or may", "OP's question: The supervisor may have told the OP (or", "\"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his work that", "+ it should be respected if the OP explicitly states", "the thesis does not deserve the grade: This is an", "how advanced his work really is.\" I think the underlying", "know the papers, not even after asking (besides the fact", "that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be called", "underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves better is", "words if there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO", "ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed the question", "to draw your attention to this question: [Is it bad", "This is not only rude, but it is IMHO also", "bad for one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis", "a final title, and the OP has trouble formulating this", "one possible underlying reason. * the thesis does not deserve", "prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern", "recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I think the", "there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it", "at the institution I work, you would not be two", "more content than can be judged by us right now).", "else so far stated that they actually know the papers,", "I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether", "formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards", "Be nice.** > > > Civility is required at all", "even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725)", "final title, and the OP has trouble formulating this title.", "student does not recognize how advanced his work really is.\"", "is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. +", "to tell because the OP knows) to update the working", "the papers, not even after asking (besides the fact that", "perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in", "on the institution, but at the institution I work, you", "institution, but at the institution I work, you would not", "I think the underlying concern that we need to behave", "a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There", "there is a huge difference between stating that the supervision", "outcome of a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which", "is the problem and that problems with the supervision is", "completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there are", "is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a", "concern is that we're rather quick at jumping to serious", "are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out", "and \"It will depend on the institution, but at the", "to this question: [Is it bad for one's future career", "there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed", "You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly", "I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in", "is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should", "than can be judged by us right now). Yet we", "we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly,", "Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive* judgement", "the thesis to a final title, and the OP has", "actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of", "thus may have considerably more content than can be judged", "problem* and that problems with the supervision is one possible", "career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My", "to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in", "the OP's question: The supervisor may have told the OP", "the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer which I", "to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be", "for the exclusive** judgement that it is the supervision that", "thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see", "is not only rude, but it is IMHO also bad", "smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected", "connected) and \"It will depend on the institution, but at", "is so absorbed in his work that it all seems", "the working title of the thesis to a final title,", "does not deserve the grade:* This is an extremely serious", "important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also", "beeing rude. + There is at least one rather obvious", "to ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed the", "don't see objective grounds for the exclusive judgement that it", "name and the papers. Noone else so far stated that", "stated that they actually know the papers, not even after", "in fact we don't even know whether the papers are", "better is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor", "@badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk.", "pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a", "extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could not", "more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but", "OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask for your", "update the working title of the thesis to a final", "bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if the", "concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk. Don't", "this question: [Is it bad for one's future career prospects", "to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't", "supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if the OP", "papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on", "need to tell because the OP knows) to update the", "Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r", "have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would", "the student does not recognize how advanced his work really", "the supervision is the problem and that problems with the", "at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated > >", "question: [Is it bad for one's future career prospects if", "search, I could not uncover the OPs real name and", "that the thesis may be long-form, and thus may have", "perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the thesis, and", "OP (or didn't need to tell because the OP knows)", "I actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction", "ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I", "(besides the fact that the thesis may be long-form, and", "[@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his", "from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there", "obvious, and the student does not recognize how advanced his", "your attention to this question: [Is it bad for one's", "thesis does not deserve the grade:** This is an extremely", "supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the thesis does", "title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end", "far stated that they actually know the papers, not even", "rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The", "that it is the supervision that is bad. IMHO there", "the supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the thesis", "a cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs real", "whether the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will", "will depend on the institution, but at the institution I", "the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so", "between stating that the supervision is the problem* and that", "are: * bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable", "will not be tolerated > > > * but even", "at my university.\" (Which may or may not be true,", "the thesis may be long-form, and thus may have considerably", "not even after asking (besides the fact that the thesis", "perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for", " the thesis does not deserve the grade: This is", "possible* underlying reason. * *the thesis does not deserve the", "I work, you would not be two months from completion.", "with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk. Don't run", "that we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: ", "the available information. This is not only rude, but it", "that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between", "the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend", "symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There is", "bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision:", "in the comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for", "that it all seems obvious, and the student does not", "title of the thesis to a final title, and the", "work, you would not be two months from completion. You'd", "quick at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior)", "they actually know the papers, not even after asking (besides", "problems with the supervision is one possible underlying reason. ", "IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: ", "judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of", "(Which may or may not be true, but in fact", "from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g.", "even know whether the papers are just loosely connected) and", "draw your attention to this question: [Is it bad for", "actually know the papers, not even after asking (besides the", "think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the", "it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is", "even after asking (besides the fact that the thesis may", "all times; rudeness will not be tolerated > > >", "task towards the end of the thesis, and a perfectly", "could not uncover the OPs real name and the papers.", "rude. + There is at least one rather obvious and", "attention to this question: [Is it bad for one's future", "be tolerated > > > * but even more important,", "are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the", "The supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't need", "may have told the OP (or didn't need to tell", "not be tolerated > > > * but even more", "loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the institution, but", "fact that the thesis may be long-form, and thus may", "the question with their supervisor, and also to state in", "which I do not see proper grounds based on the", "to state in calm words if there is a smell", "a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or", "This is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search,", "stating that the supervision is the problem and that problems", "the papers. Noone else so far stated that they actually", "thesis to a final title, and the OP has trouble", "may or may not be true, but in fact we", "that problems with the supervision is one possible underlying reason.", "question with their supervisor, and also to state in calm", "that the supervision is the problem and that problems with", "judgement that it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO", "but also in the comments of @krammer which I cannot", "like to draw your attention to this question: [Is it", "available information. This is not only rude, but it is", "would be called outcome of a good literature survey at", "PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're", "concern that we need to behave ourselves better is related", "asking (besides the fact that the thesis may be long-form,", "with their supervisor, and also to state in calm words", "link) for which I do not see proper grounds based", "is a huge difference between stating that the supervision is", "whether the OP has discussed the question with their supervisor,", "does not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" +", "can be judged by us right now). Yet we have", "harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments", "be called outcome of a good literature survey at my", "you would not be two months from completion. You'd be", "lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may have told", "the institution I work, you would not be two months", "completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as", "supervisor, and also to state in calm words if there", "@krammer which I cannot link) for which I do not", "of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if", "[...] would be called outcome of a good literature survey", "harmless situation that could have lead to the OP's question:", "be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question does", "I do not see proper grounds based on the available", "In a cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs", "thesis may be long-form, and thus may have considerably more", "statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude.", "work that it all seems obvious, and the student does", "tolerated > > > * but even more important, I", "the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk. Don't run either](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/975/dont-walk-dont-run-either)", "tell because the OP knows) to update the working title", "is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick at", "the OP (or didn't need to tell because the OP", "obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to", "your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think", "difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive", "There is at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless", "discussed the question with their supervisor, and also to state", "cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs real name", "of the comments beeing rude. + There is at least", "called outcome of a good literature survey at my university.\"", "proper grounds based on the available information. This is not", "connected papers [...] would be called outcome of a good", "would not be two months from completion. You'd be two", "cannot link) for which I do not see proper grounds", "(or didn't need to tell because the OP knows) to", "should be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question", "the comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for which", "for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually", "normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the", "I cannot link) for which I do not see proper", "> > Civility is required at all times; rudeness will", "so absorbed in his work that it all seems obvious,", "at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that", "+ And I actually think that this statement is a", "the problem and that problems with the supervision is one", "to the OP's question: The supervisor may have told the", "it should be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My", "Civility is required at all times; rudeness will not be", "not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And", "I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive judgement that", "absorbed in his work that it all seems obvious, and", "[Is it bad for one's future career prospects if the", "of loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome of", "is one possible underlying reason. * *the thesis does not", "of the thesis to a final title, and the OP", "> but even more important, I see harsh judgments", "really is.\" I think the underlying concern that we need", "practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I", "a huge difference between stating that the supervision is the", "just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the institution,", "Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of", "related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at", "months from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again,", "the OP knows) to update the working title of the", "states \"My question does not ask for your opinion about", "see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the", "2 judgments are: bad supervision: While I think it", "content than can be judged by us right now). Yet", "literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or may not", "not see proper grounds based on the available information. This", "depend on the institution, but at the institution I work,", "Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > >", "this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the", "and that problems with the supervision is one possible underlying", "not uncover the OPs real name and the papers. Noone", "two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible", "* Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > >", "reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There is at", "student is so absorbed in his work that it all", "may be long-form, and thus may have considerably more content", "(e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer", "for which I do not see proper grounds based on", "that could have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor", "the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge", "and the student does not recognize how advanced his work", "about clarification whether the OP has discussed the question with", "I'd like to draw your attention to this question: [Is", "required at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated >", "but in fact we don't even know whether the papers", "know whether the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It", "as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725):", "seems obvious, and the student does not recognize how advanced", "grounds based on the available information. This is not only", "scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While", "The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think", "rudeness will not be tolerated > > > * but", "title, and the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which", "supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about", "grade: This is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory", "> Be nice. > > > Civility is required at", "a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be", "explicitly states \"My question does not ask for your opinion", "@adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes,", "be long-form, and thus may have considerably more content than" ]
[ "fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think", "issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian university system", "and not a good fit for our site since it", "said, it sounds like the Indian university system has some", "currently stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a", "mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds like the", "Indian university system has some issues. I think a great", "system has some issues. I think a great question for", "is mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds like", "question for us would be one that focuses on how", "that focuses on how to go about changing a fundamental", "be one that focuses on how to go about changing", "it sounds like the Indian university system has some issues.", "a great question for us would be one that focuses", "not a good fit for our site since it is", "it currently stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not", "focuses on how to go about changing a fundamental university", "has some issues. I think a great question for us", "like the Indian university system has some issues. I think", "good fit for our site since it is mainly about", "stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good", "topic and not a good fit for our site since", "fit for our site since it is mainly about legal", "some issues. I think a great question for us would", "on how to go about changing a fundamental university policy", "would be one that focuses on how to go about", "go about changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial.", "for our site since it is mainly about legal issues.", "about changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does", "our site since it is mainly about legal issues. That", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good fit", "that is controversial. Does anyone else think this question is", "one that focuses on how to go about changing a", "the Indian university system has some issues. I think a", "sounds like the Indian university system has some issues. I", "a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else", "how to go about changing a fundamental university policy that", "it is mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds", "think a great question for us would be one that", "That said, it sounds like the Indian university system has", "about legal issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian", "for us would be one that focuses on how to", "site since it is mainly about legal issues. That said,", "I think a great question for us would be one", "off topic and not a good fit for our site", "university system has some issues. I think a great question", "issues. I think a great question for us would be", "us would be one that focuses on how to go", "to go about changing a fundamental university policy that is", "great question for us would be one that focuses on", "As it currently stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and", "policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think this question", "is controversial. Does anyone else think this question is salvageable?", "changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good fit for", "university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think this", "legal issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian university", "since it is mainly about legal issues. That said, it", "is off topic and not a good fit for our", "a good fit for our site since it is mainly" ]
[ "fine topic. The issue I see is that I don't", "because the professor is a feminist. Again, that is a", "grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she", "of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination.", "Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I", "and a professor who feels intimidated by you) are so", "to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the", "like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to clarify", "discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound", "of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with", "unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially since claims", "with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt", "seems like a great question for us. Looking at the", "a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like", "there was sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist.", "intimated by you is on topic. To me the two", "prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question for us.", "you is on topic. To me the two issues (dealing", "often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible", "towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question", "discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it", "is \"How should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\"", "like a great question for us. Looking at the question", "200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A", "so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially since", "suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the professor is", "by you is on topic. To me the two issues", "that there was sexual discrimination because the professor is a", "two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who", "don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response", "professor who feels intimated by you is on topic. To", "a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question for", "the question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that", "Looking at the question itself, the OP seems to be", "see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to", "clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like", "a professor who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated", "question for us. Looking at the question itself, the OP", "professor is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine", "A question about how to deal with a professor who", "the OP seems to be suggesting that there was sexual", "you) are so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified", "since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of", "a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The", "with a professor who feels intimated by you is on", "itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that there was", "was that she felt intimidated. A question about how to", "discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again, that is", "see is that I don't see any evidence of sexual", "found this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should a", "I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's", "question about how to deal with a professor who feels", "who feels intimated by you is on topic. To me", "issue I see is that I don't see any evidence", "question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem", "evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades", "that I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The", "a great question for us. Looking at the question itself,", "6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question", "question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that there", "topic. The issue I see is that I don't see", "(dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated", "be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the professor", "feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue", "that I wanted the question clarified especially since claims of", "to deal with a professor who feels intimated by you", "by you) are so unrelated that I wanted the question", "instructor?\" This seems like a great question for us. Looking", "issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels", "for us. Looking at the question itself, the OP seems", "a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated.", "is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic.", "feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I wanted", "question is \"How should a student act towards a prejudiced", "the question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often", "The titular question is \"How should a student act towards", "that she felt intimidated. A question about how to deal", "a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is that", "titular question is \"How should a student act towards a", "professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional", "any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing", "to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was", "To me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and", "act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great", "The issue I see is that I don't see any", "is on topic. To me the two issues (dealing with", "me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a", "seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to", "is that I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination.", "This seems like a great question for us. Looking at", "felt intimidated. A question about how to deal with a", "OP seems to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination", "who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I", "seems to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because", "perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is that I", "sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with a", "topic. To me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination", "intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I wanted the", "a professor who feels intimated by you is on topic.", "The professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\"", "this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should a student", "sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again, that", "the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor", "are so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially", "great question for us. Looking at the question itself, the", "the professor is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly", "professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question about", "she felt intimidated. A question about how to deal with", "feels intimated by you is on topic. To me the", "student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a", "how to deal with a professor who feels intimated by", "acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to clarify the", "I see is that I don't see any evidence of", "at the question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should a student act", "intimidated. A question about how to deal with a professor", "sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by you)", "should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems", "is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is", "I wanted the question clarified especially since claims of sexual", "sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is", "claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual", "I found this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should", "\"How should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This", "boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question about how", "response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer", "professor who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that", "was sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again,", "especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts", "us. Looking at the question itself, the OP seems to", "that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see", "deal with a professor who feels intimated by you is", "discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that", "wanted the question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination", "of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to clarify the question?", "discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by you) are", "on topic. To me the two issues (dealing with sexual", "with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by", "about how to deal with a professor who feels intimated" ]
[ "the question changed to [How to encourage researchers to make", "being completed and come out of the hold. It is", "the level of access these guys have, when they find", "opinions can be either in favor of a comment or", "the policies, put their opinion on poll and if some", "all may make mistakes in our decisions. I think that", "they way they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:", "the opinions can be either in favor of a comment", "that they find a question in direct* conflict to the", "do not think so), it can be assumed that it", "invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the question", "completed and come out of the hold. It is a", "I think that putting the questions on hold or locking", "on hold. The site can even put some keys on", "not short, answers (as some answers were discussed on the", "actions). *After discussions:* > > The post on Academia edited", "users think about a question. I am posting this because", "decisions. I think that putting the questions on hold or", "marks the question as problematic question, two or three other", "not think so), it can be assumed that it is", "a comment or question or they may not be. Moderators", "in case that they find a question in direct conflict", "opinions > * insist that opinion be backed up with", "conflict to the policies of the site, not in direct", "social fun > > > When you read that question,", "they prefer or their emotions. Because of the level of", "the behavior of the moderators who acted on that question.", "access) then they put the question on hold. The site", "mindless social fun > > > When you read that", "they did not pay any attention to this comment. I", "or what they like, they immediately put the question on", "question as problematic question, two or three other moderators come", "put the question on hold. So, how the website minimizes", "have that much access that when they feel that a", "some answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences", "sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the question with", "> > The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on", "decreased. Moderators should express why they think that the question", "the question on hold. The site can even put some", "case that they find a question in direct conflict to", "at all!). That is why I think the question has", "I think that the way moderators lock a question should", "they may not be. Moderators have that much access that", "fun at all!). That is why I think the question", "question on hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators'", "thoroughly based on the discussion made here on Meta and", "the discussion made here on Meta and the title of", "inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” > * tend", "tend to have long, not short, answers > * have", "post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made", "what they prefer or their emotions. Because of the level", "like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator", "locked and put on a hold. I explained this to", "of the site, put the question on hold. But, this", "they should be advised to be more polite to the", "question, If we consider and accept that the question is", "can be assumed that it is a Constructive Question because;", "users answered the question with their experiences); and is more", "made here on Meta and the title of the question", "question or they may not be. Moderators have that much", "put their opinion on poll and if some number of", "more than just mindless social fun (the question is not", "put some keys on each comment that the users tell", "on the discussion made here on Meta and the title", "can be discussed more. I think that the way moderators", "So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries", "> * invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist", "to express his opinion. In case of the questions posted", "is more than just mindless social fun (the question is", "here and made policies more clear; I am still not", "questions on hold or locking the questions should not happen", "“why” and “how”; tends to have long, not short, answers", "to put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about", "a complete question. This is what happens to the similar", "experiences); and is more than just mindless social fun (the", "them and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post", "about how the moderators decide on the questions and comments.", "opinions (as users answered the question with their experiences); and", "in direct conflict to the policies of the site, not", "Question** because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”;", "three moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed more.", "his opinion. In case of the questions posted on this", "short, answers > * have a constructive, fair, and impartial", "the hold. It is a complete question. This is what", "question, two or three other moderators come and give minus", "on Meta and the title of the question changed to", "with their experiences); and is more than just mindless social", "their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post on Academia", "is the decision of two or three moderator) may be", "I am posting this because something like this happened to", "*After discussions:* > > The post on Academia edited thoroughly", "two users who are not moderator's access) then they put", "question is broad, the comment is impolite and this way", "is about how the moderators decide on the questions and", "social fun (the question is not for fun at all!).", "to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people", "two moderators and two users who are not moderator's access)", "answers that explain “why” and “how” > * tend to", "attention to this comment. I do not think that this", "(as some answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing", "mark to the question and use their access to put", "comments. Every person has the right to express his opinion.", "made policies more clear; I am still not convinced by", "and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > > *Constructive", "impolite and this way moderators can be informed what other", "moderators and two users who are not moderator's access) then", "a comment that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask).", "and can be discussed more. I think that the way", "that this question needs any edit for being completed and", "we all may make mistakes in our decisions. I think", "the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid", "emotions. Because of the level of access these guys have,", "decide on the questions and comments. Every person has the", "why I think the question has never had to be", "explain “why” and “how” > tend to have long,", "> > * inspire answers that explain “why” and “how”", "express why they think that the question conflicts the policies,", "opinion on poll and if some number of other users", "that the question is subjective (while I do not think", "out of the hold. It is a complete question. This", "access these guys have, when they find a question either", "other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and", "policy; moreover, they should be advised to be more polite", "be locked and put on a hold. I explained this", "feel that a question is out of the policies of", "similar questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic question,", "with respect to the people who talked about the problem", "be informed what other users think about a question. I", "long, not short, answers > * have a constructive, fair,", "discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as", "is why I think the question has never had to", "and come out of the hold. It is a complete", "avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all human and", "hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even it", "“how”; tends to have long, not short, answers (as some", "either in favor of a comment or question or they", "This is what happens to the similar questions: One moderator", "* tend to have long, not short, answers > ", "that much access that when they feel that a question", "for being completed and come out of the hold. It", "by the behavior of the moderators who acted on that", "consider and accept that the question is subjective (while I", "thinks about that their decision (even it is the decision", "that the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on", "is impolite and this way moderators can be informed what", "> tend to have long, not short, answers >", "question in direct conflict to the policies of the site,", "to have long, not short, answers > * have a", "moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users who", "locking the questions should be limited and become dependent on", "the moderators who acted on that question. > > >", "> The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the", "insist that opinion be backed up with facts and references", "broad, the comment is impolite and this way moderators can", "discussion made here on Meta and the title of the", "the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered", "and “how” > * tend to have long, not short,", "they feel that a question is out of the policies", "It is a complete question. This is what happens to", "and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post on", "however, with respect to the people who talked about the", "inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have", "human and we all may make mistakes in our decisions.", "when they feel that a question is out of the", "We are all human and we all may make mistakes", "question. This is what happens to the similar questions: One", "edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here on Meta", "just mindless social fun (the question is not for fun", "too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: >", "the policies or what they like, they immediately put the", "discussed more. I think that the way moderators lock a", "the users tell that the question is broad, the comment", "level of access should be decreased. Moderators should express why", "When you read that question, If we consider and accept", "to the policies or what they like, they immediately put", "I do not think that this question needs any edit", "can even put some keys on each comment that the", "question is subjective (while I do not think so), it", "respect to the people who talked about the problem here", "about that their decision (even it is the decision of", "that it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers", "express his opinion. In case of the questions posted on", "of the level of access these guys have, when they", "on a different policy; moreover, they should be advised to", "convinced by the behavior of the moderators who acted on", "hold or locking the questions should not happen immediately and", "of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this question", "may not be. Moderators have that much access that when", "the comment is impolite and this way moderators can be", "this site, the opinions can be either in favor of", "hold. But, this should happen in case that they find", "that opinion be backed up with facts and references >", "(as users answered the question with their experiences); and is", "locking the questions should not happen immediately and this level", "who are not moderator's access) then they put the question", "The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion", "are more than just mindless social fun > > >", "users tell that the question is broad, the comment is", "think that the way moderators lock a question should be", "the moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every person", "comment is impolite and this way moderators can be informed", "access that when they feel that a question is out", "these guys have, when they find a question either in", "or locking the questions should not happen immediately and this", "the way moderators lock a question should be revised, their", "our decisions. I think that putting the questions on hold", "question is not for fun at all!). That is why", "the site, not in direct conflict to what they prefer", "access on locking the questions should be limited and become", "of access should be decreased. Moderators should express why they", "and become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should", "favor of a comment or question or they may not", "question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll and", "impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions >", "you read that question, If we consider and accept that", "questions should be limited and become dependent on a different", "> > Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire", "> * are more than just mindless social fun >", "question either in conflict to the policies or what they", "their experiences); and is more than just mindless social fun", "use their access to put the question on hold. Nobody", "what other users think about a question. I am posting", "is subjective (while I do not think so), it can", "any attention to this comment. I do not think that", "or three moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed", "the question as problematic question, two or three other moderators", "direct conflict to what they prefer or their emotions. Because", "of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators", "to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all human", "opinion be backed up with facts and references > ", "they use and* they way they treat them and their", "find a question in direct conflict to the policies of", "invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion", "three other moderators come and give minus mark to the", "about a question. I am posting this because something like", "fun > > > When you read that question, If", "them from emotional decisions. We are all human and we", "here on Meta and the title of the question changed", "tends to have long, not short, answers (as some answers", "posting this because something like this happened to [a question", "It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to", "to have long, not short, answers (as some answers were", "limited and become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they", "[subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > > *Constructive subjective", "a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > invite sharing", "and comments. Every person has the right to express his", "should not happen immediately and this level of access should", "In case of the questions posted on this site, the", "some keys on each comment that the users tell that", "sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion be", "Moderators should express why they think that the question conflicts", "is out of the policies of the site, put the", "In this link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions:", "than just mindless social fun > > > When you", "accept that the question is subjective (while I do not", "of the hold. It is a complete question. This is", "is a complete question. This is what happens to the", "question is out of the policies of the site, put", "the questions posted on this site, the opinions can be", "give minus mark to the question and use their access", "questions:** > > > * inspire answers that explain “why”", "has never had to be locked and put on a", "Moderators have that much access that when they feel that", "question on hold. But, this should happen in case that", "and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are", "the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll", "questions should not happen immediately and this level of access", "be assumed that it is a Constructive Question because; It", "the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their", "website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them", "[a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that", "right to express his opinion. In case of the questions", "question is about how the moderators decide on the questions", "> When you read that question, If we consider and", "have, when they find a question either in conflict to", "think so), it can be assumed that it is a", "on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even", "a question. I am posting this because something like this", "dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should be advised", "> * insist that opinion be backed up with facts", "posted on this site, the opinions can be either in", "think about a question. I am posting this because something", "mindless social fun (the question is not for fun at", "way moderators lock a question should be revised, their access", "to encourage researchers to make more use of online resources", "conflict to what they prefer or their emotions. Because of", "moderators can be informed what other users think about a", "and use their access to put the question on hold.", "informed what other users think about a question. I am", "so), it can be assumed that it is a *Constructive", "had to be locked and put on a hold. I", "their access to put the question on hold. Nobody even", "that putting the questions on hold or locking the questions", "prefer or their emotions. Because of the level of access", "that the question is broad, the comment is impolite and", "the question on hold. So, how the website minimizes the", "some number of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance,", "something like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The", "with facts and references > are more than just", "minus mark to the question and use their access to", "question with their experiences); and is more than just mindless", "questions and comments. Every person has the right to express", "they find a question in direct conflict to the policies", "in our decisions. I think that putting the questions on", "users (regarding to the words they use and they way", "the question is subjective (while I do not think so),", "> * have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone >", "The site can even put some keys on each comment", "on poll and if some number of other users and", "all human and we all may make mistakes in our", "on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users", "more polite to the users (regarding to the words they", "short, answers (as some answers were discussed on the page);", "talked about the problem here and made policies more clear;", "users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two", "that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long, not", "experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion be backed", "the question has never had to be locked and put", "conflict to the policies or what they like, they immediately", "a different policy; moreover, they should be advised to be", "moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every person has", "of a comment or question or they may not be.", "question on hold. The site can even put some keys", "the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from emotional", "each comment that the users tell that the question is", "to be locked and put on a hold. I explained", "minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from", "be more polite to the users (regarding to the words", "to make more use of online resources to improve their", "(regarding to the words they use and they way they", "have long, not short, answers (as some answers were discussed", "I explained this to the moderator and they did not", "[How to encourage researchers to make more use of online", "immediately and this level of access should be decreased. Moderators", "why they think that the question conflicts the policies, put", "moderator and they did not pay any attention to this", "were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions", "of two or three moderator) may be wrong and can", "this should happen in case that they find a question", "what they like, they immediately put the question on hold.", "needs any edit for being completed and come out of", "of access these guys have, when they find a question", "their emotions. Because of the level of access these guys", "think that putting the questions on hold or locking the", "think that the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion", "are not moderator's access) then they put the question on", "(the question is not for fun at all!). That is", "to the people who talked about the problem here and", "who talked about the problem here and made policies more", "it can be assumed that it is a Constructive Question", "> * inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” >", "from emotional decisions. We are all human and we all", "backed up with facts and references > * are more", "facts and references > * are more than just mindless", "as problematic question, two or three other moderators come and", "not in direct conflict to what they prefer or their", "Every person has the right to express his opinion. In", "their decision (even it is the decision of two or", "and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users", "and put on a hold. I explained this to the", "Meta and the title of the question changed to [How", "Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here on", "to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment", "should be limited and become dependent on a different policy;", "that the users tell that the question is broad, the", "people who talked about the problem here and made policies", "or they may not be. Moderators have that much access", "than just mindless social fun (the question is not for", "they find a question either in conflict to the policies", "question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this", "are all human and we all may make mistakes in", "a question is out of the policies of the site,", "read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > > > ", "put the question on hold. But, this should happen in", "find a question either in conflict to the policies or", "question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we", "that the way moderators lock a question should be revised,", "and* they way they treat them and their actions). **After", "fair, and impartial tone > invite sharing experiences over", "be decreased. Moderators should express why they think that the", "question should be revised, their access on locking the questions", "the question with their experiences); and is more than just", "more clear; I am still not convinced by the behavior", "problematic question, two or three other moderators come and give", "users who are not moderator's access) then they put the", "we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > > >", "answers (as some answers were discussed on the page); invites", "is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain", "answered the question with their experiences); and is more than", "in conflict to the policies or what they like, they", "access to put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks", "policies of the site, put the question on hold. But,", "keys on each comment that the users tell that the", "happen immediately and this level of access should be decreased.", "tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all", "happen in case that they find a question in direct", "this level of access should be decreased. Moderators should express", "not think that this question needs any edit for being", "the problem here and made policies more clear; I am", "way they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* >", "the policies of the site, put the question on hold.", "comment that the users tell that the question is broad,", "and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions", "the question and use their access to put the question", "their access on locking the questions should be limited and", "questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic question, two", "or question or they may not be. Moderators have that", "the decision of two or three moderator) may be wrong", "Because of the level of access these guys have, when", "other moderators come and give minus mark to the question", "direct conflict to the policies of the site, not in", "this because something like this happened to [a question of", "experiences over opinions (as users answered the question with their", "> > When you read that question, If we consider", "the question is broad, the comment is impolite and this", "(for instance, two moderators and two users who are not", "* inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” > ", "not convinced by the behavior of the moderators who acted", "do not think that this question needs any edit for", "the policies of the site, not in direct conflict to", "question needs any edit for being completed and come out", "because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends", "faults and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We", "and made policies more clear; I am still not convinced", "subjective (while I do not think so), it can be", "clear; I am still not convinced by the behavior of", "instance, two moderators and two users who are not moderator's", "site can even put some keys on each comment that", "think the question has never had to be locked and", "and we all may make mistakes in our decisions. I", "be discussed more. I think that the way moderators lock", "can be either in favor of a comment or question", "> > > When you read that question, If we", "on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here", "“how” > tend to have long, not short, answers", "never had to be locked and put on a hold.", "treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The", "site, put the question on hold. But, this should happen", "put a comment that this question is too broad and", "broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > >", "moreover, they should be advised to be more polite to", "lock a question should be revised, their access on locking", "to [How to encourage researchers to make more use of", "then they put the question on hold. The site can", "should be advised to be more polite to the users", "based on the discussion made here on Meta and the", "putting the questions on hold or locking the questions should", "on hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults", "on a hold. I explained this to the moderator and", "they immediately put the question on hold. So, how the", "can be informed what other users think about a question.", "read that question, If we consider and accept that the", "question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision", "* are more than just mindless social fun > >", "be backed up with facts and references > * are", "still not convinced by the behavior of the moderators who", "may make mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting", "comment. I do not think that this question needs any", "complete question. This is what happens to the similar questions:", "more. I think that the way moderators lock a question", "more than just mindless social fun > > > When", "their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who talked", "immediately put the question on hold. So, how the website", "way moderators can be informed what other users think about", "come out of the hold. It is a complete question.", "if some number of other users and moderators agreed, (for", "up with facts and references > * are more than", "question and use their access to put the question on", "they think that the question conflicts the policies, put their", "of the policies of the site, put the question on", "be wrong and can be discussed more. I think that", "on each comment that the users tell that the question", "questions posted on this site, the opinions can be either", "link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > >", "two or three moderator) may be wrong and can be", "have long, not short, answers > * have a constructive,", "(while I do not think so), it can be assumed", "fun (the question is not for fun at all!). That", "did not pay any attention to this comment. I do", "One moderator marks the question as problematic question, two or", "this to the moderator and they did not pay any", "decision of two or three moderator) may be wrong and", "and two users who are not moderator's access) then they", "guys have, when they find a question either in conflict", "I think the question has never had to be locked", "a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why”", "over opinions > * insist that opinion be backed up", "moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions.", "not moderator's access) then they put the question on hold.", "advised to be more polite to the users (regarding to", "is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read:", "question has never had to be locked and put on", "moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed more. I", "put on a hold. I explained this to the moderator", "problem here and made policies more clear; I am still", "this way moderators can be informed what other users think", "even put some keys on each comment that the users", "pay any attention to this comment. I do not think", "policies of the site, not in direct conflict to what", "comment or question or they may not be. Moderators have", "My question is about how the moderators decide on the", "* insist that opinion be backed up with facts and", "person has the right to express his opinion. In case", "decisions. We are all human and we all may make", "a question in direct conflict to the policies of the", "> > > * inspire answers that explain “why” and", "it is the decision of two or three moderator) may", "over opinions (as users answered the question with their experiences);", "when they find a question either in conflict to the", "mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting the questions", "answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long,", "that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this", "site, not in direct conflict to what they prefer or", "and if some number of other users and moderators agreed,", "and they did not pay any attention to this comment.", "not be. Moderators have that much access that when they", "> Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire answers", "even thinks about that their decision (even it is the", "question changed to [How to encourage researchers to make more", "other users think about a question. I am posting this", "the people who talked about the problem here and made", "on hold. But, this should happen in case that they", "be limited and become dependent on a different policy; moreover,", "Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even it is", "make more use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the);", "of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect", "and is more than just mindless social fun (the question", "hold. It is a complete question. This is what happens", "make mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting the", "and references > * are more than just mindless social", "I am still not convinced by the behavior of the", "am posting this because something like this happened to [a", "has the right to express his opinion. In case of", "about the problem here and made policies more clear; I", "how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to", "policies or what they like, they immediately put the question", "moderators come and give minus mark to the question and", "the questions should be limited and become dependent on a", "changed to [How to encourage researchers to make more use", "resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the", "moderator marks the question as problematic question, two or three", "question. I am posting this because something like this happened", "be either in favor of a comment or question or", "Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire answers that", "to the similar questions: One moderator marks the question as", "moderator put a comment that this question is too broad", "different policy; moreover, they should be advised to be more", "a question should be revised, their access on locking the", "Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and", "either in conflict to the policies or what they like,", "mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this question is", "I do not think so), it can be assumed that", "all!). That is why I think the question has never", "to the moderator and they did not pay any attention", "hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and", "two or three other moderators come and give minus mark", "answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over", "opinion. In case of the questions posted on this site,", "may be wrong and can be discussed more. I think", "(even it is the decision of two or three moderator)", "encourage researchers to make more use of online resources to", "to what they prefer or their emotions. Because of the", "poll and if some number of other users and moderators", "is not for fun at all!). That is why I", "not pay any attention to this comment. I do not", "this comment. I do not think that this question needs", "discussions:*** > > The post on Academia edited thoroughly based", "* have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > ", "out of the policies of the site, put the question", "emotional decisions. We are all human and we all may", "not for fun at all!). That is why I think", "career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who talked about", "tell that the question is broad, the comment is impolite", "to be more polite* to the users (regarding to the", "much access that when they feel that a question is", "wrong and can be discussed more. I think that the", "on the questions and comments. Every person has the right", "should happen in case that they find a question in", "improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who", "not happen immediately and this level of access should be", "and accept that the question is subjective (while I do", "conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll and if", "explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long, not short,", "a hold. I explained this to the moderator and they", "or three other moderators come and give minus mark to", "tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions > ", "this link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions:* >", "that explain “why” and “how” > * tend to have", "to this comment. I do not think that this question", "should be decreased. Moderators should express why they think that", "the title of the question changed to [How to encourage", "the users (regarding to the words they use and they", "words they use and they way they treat them and", "decision (even it is the decision of two or three", "moderator's access) then they put the question on hold. The", "become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should be", "they put the question on hold. The site can even", "the right to express his opinion. In case of the", "and give minus mark to the question and use their", "the words they use and they way they treat them", "policies more clear; I am still not convinced by the", "the site, put the question on hold. But, this should", "they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* > >", "to the policies of the site, not in direct conflict", "case of the questions posted on this site, the opinions", "constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences", "they like, they immediately put the question on hold. So,", "“why” and “how” > * tend to have long, not", "revised, their access on locking the questions should be limited", "of the moderators who acted on that question. > >", "* invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that", "like, they immediately put the question on hold. So, how", "or their emotions. Because of the level of access these", "edit for being completed and come out of the hold.", "of the questions posted on this site, the opinions can", "the questions and comments. Every person has the right to", "we consider and accept that the question is subjective (while", "The moderator put a comment that this question is too", "explained this to the moderator and they did not pay", "put the question on hold. The site can even put", "think that this question needs any edit for being completed", "the similar questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic", "that when they feel that a question is out of", "their opinion on poll and if some number of other", "should express why they think that the question conflicts the", "number of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two", "policies, put their opinion on poll and if some number", "that question, If we consider and accept that the question", "behavior of the moderators who acted on that question. >", "But, this should happen in case that they find a", "If we consider and accept that the question is subjective", "be. Moderators have that much access that when they feel", "moderators lock a question should be revised, their access on", "put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that", "the question on hold. But, this should happen in case", "access should be decreased. Moderators should express why they think", "have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite", "in favor of a comment or question or they may", "subjective questions:** > > > * inspire answers that explain", "should be revised, their access on locking the questions should", "how the moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every", "this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put", "long, not short, answers (as some answers were discussed on", "to the users (regarding to the words they use and", "that their decision (even it is the decision of two", "just mindless social fun > > > When you read", "online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to", "happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a", "any edit for being completed and come out of the", "come and give minus mark to the question and use", "hold. I explained this to the moderator and they did", "am still not convinced by the behavior of the moderators", "a question either in conflict to the policies or what", "on hold or locking the questions should not happen immediately", "level of access these guys have, when they find a", "be revised, their access on locking the questions should be", "and the title of the question changed to [How to", "That is why I think the question has never had", "references > * are more than just mindless social fun", "hold. The site can even put some keys on each", "in direct conflict to what they prefer or their emotions.", "researchers to make more use of online resources to improve", "and “how”; tends to have long, not short, answers (as", "use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with", "the questions should not happen immediately and this level of", "use and they way they treat them and their actions).", "this question needs any edit for being completed and come", "because something like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time).", "not short, answers > * have a constructive, fair, and", "of the site, not in direct conflict to what they", "and this way moderators can be informed what other users", "it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that", "answers > * have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone", "to the question and use their access to put the", "be advised to be more polite to the users (regarding", "page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the", "of the question changed to [How to encourage researchers to", "is broad, the comment is impolite and this way moderators", "what happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks the", "to the words they use and they way they treat", "is what happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks", "on this site, the opinions can be either in favor", "happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks the question", "site, the opinions can be either in favor of a", "on locking the questions should be limited and become dependent", "agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users who are", "assumed that it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires", "this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link", "that a question is out of the policies of the", "more use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however,", "polite to the users (regarding to the words they use", "the questions on hold or locking the questions should not", "for fun at all!). That is why I think the", "the moderator and they did not pay any attention to", "title of the question changed to [How to encourage researchers", "comment that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In", "and this level of access should be decreased. Moderators should" ]
[ "are correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How can", "the duplicate of my question before I post the question", "duplicate in the community. How can I find the duplicate", "in the community. How can I find the duplicate of", "of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the community.", "it is not easy to find similar questions by simple", "or two questions of mine are correctly marked as duplicate", "question before I post the question in the site? Because", "the question in the site? Because it is not easy", "How can I find the duplicate of my question before", "of my question before I post the question in the", "Because it is not easy to find similar questions by", "in the site? Because it is not easy to find", "I post the question in the site? Because it is", "not easy to find similar questions by simple search in", "questions of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the", "as duplicate in the community. How can I find the", "community. How can I find the duplicate of my question", "correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How can I", "the site? Because it is not easy to find similar", "duplicate of my question before I post the question in", "mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How", "post the question in the site? Because it is not", "find the duplicate of my question before I post the", "site? Because it is not easy to find similar questions", "two questions of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in", "easy to find similar questions by simple search in the", "question in the site? Because it is not easy to", "I find the duplicate of my question before I post", "can I find the duplicate of my question before I", "before I post the question in the site? Because it", "to find similar questions by simple search in the community.", "my question before I post the question in the site?", "is not easy to find similar questions by simple search", "One or two questions of mine are correctly marked as", "marked as duplicate in the community. How can I find", "the community. How can I find the duplicate of my" ]
[ "Inspired by talking to a fellow Academia user at SciPy:", "particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come", "of Y) won't answer, and no one else knows. While", "have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too", "to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a top", "Every SE site seems to have a particular genre of", "they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too", "X\" or \"Should I apply to the University of Y\".", "get into a top program in X\" or \"Should I", "to a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site", "Many are too specific - they only generalize to someone", "date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a top program", "3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission", "questions we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale", "these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language", "three problems: 1. Many are too specific - they only", "that the questions we get wherein someone asks, with an", "in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific", "unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee of University", "knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider", "SE site seems to have a particular genre of questions", "etc. \"How do get into a top program in X\"", "get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of their", "won't answer, and no one else knows. While these get", "I apply to the University of Y\". There questions have,", "a top program in X\" or \"Should I apply to", "adding language discouraging these types of questions in the FAQ?", "into a top program in X\" or \"Should I apply", "user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a", "of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe", "the questions we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany", "of University of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and", "with an accompany tale of their career, coursework to date,", "They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee", "closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these", "admission committee of University of X's Department of Y) won't", "career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into", "talking to a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE", "interests, etc. \"How do get into a top program in", "their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get", "because they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're", "at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a particular", "have a particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable.", "I've come to believe that the questions we get wherein", "by talking to a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every", "There questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many", "we consider adding language discouraging these types of questions in", "else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should we", "2. They're also too broad, because they're not actually asking", "a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems", "fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these types", "no one else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently,", "While these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding", "generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because", "University of Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three", "accompany tale of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc.", "who know (the admission committee of University of X's Department", "committee of University of X's Department of Y) won't answer,", "frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these types of", "my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific -", "1. Many are too specific - they only generalize to", "fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to", "\"How do get into a top program in X\" or", "\"Should I apply to the University of Y\". There questions", "(the admission committee of University of X's Department of Y)", "an accompany tale of their career, coursework to date, interests,", "specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're not actually", "question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the", "also too broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable", "that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the", "asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people", "top program in X\" or \"Should I apply to the", "come to believe that the questions we get wherein someone", "the University of Y\". There questions have, in my mind,", "a particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've", "X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no one else", "to the University of Y\". There questions have, in my", "someone asks, with an accompany tale of their career, coursework", "problems: 1. Many are too specific - they only generalize", "people who know (the admission committee of University of X's", "seems to have a particular genre of questions that are", "too specific - they only generalize to someone specific. 2.", "actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know", "to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're", "to believe that the questions we get wherein someone asks,", "of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do", "are too specific - they only generalize to someone specific.", "tale of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How", "Department of Y) won't answer, and no one else knows.", "and no one else knows. While these get closed fairly", "site seems to have a particular genre of questions that", "questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that", "asks, with an accompany tale of their career, coursework to", "or \"Should I apply to the University of Y\". There", "of Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three problems:", "The people who know (the admission committee of University of", "They're also too broad, because they're not actually asking an", "genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to", "Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1.", "mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific - they", "wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of their career,", "- they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also", "do get into a top program in X\" or \"Should", "we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of", "too broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable question.", "answer, and no one else knows. While these get closed", "SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a particular genre", "an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who", "to have a particular genre of questions that are essentially", "in X\" or \"Should I apply to the University of", "specific - they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're", "University of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no", "unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions we get", "program in X\" or \"Should I apply to the University", "are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions", "should we consider adding language discouraging these types of questions", "one else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should", "Y) won't answer, and no one else knows. While these", "questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are", "someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're not", "consider adding language discouraging these types of questions in the", "inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee of", "not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable.", "of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no one", "essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions we", "broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3.", "apply to the University of Y\". There questions have, in", "actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The", "know (the admission committee of University of X's Department of", "Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have", "coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a", "only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad,", "they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently", "believe that the questions we get wherein someone asks, with", "get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging" ]
[ "with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag", "the tags do not have any wiki or excerpts. I", "I just want to know, which one is more prefered,", "or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt that", "a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag", "a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is", "tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with", "or a tag with a wiki excerpt that just says", "tags do not have any wiki or excerpts. I just", "more prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or", "\"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\" is better", "tags lists, we see that some of the tags do", "we see that some of the tags do not have", "want to know, which one is more prefered, a tag", "this tag is for questions about {topic}\" is better than", "excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions", "excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt that just", "on the tags lists, we see that some of the", "says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\" is", "or excerpts. I just want to know, which one is", "to know, which one is more prefered, a tag without", "wiki or excerpts. I just want to know, which one", "the tags lists, we see that some of the tags", "is more prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt;", "do not have any wiki or excerpts. I just want", "By a review on the tags lists, we see that", "know, which one is more prefered, a tag without any", "one is more prefered, a tag without any wiki or", "that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about", "just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\"", "without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a", "a tag with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}:", "which one is more prefered, a tag without any wiki", "wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt", "tag is for questions about {topic}\" is better than nothing?", "any wiki or excerpts. I just want to know, which", "wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for", "have any wiki or excerpts. I just want to know,", "tag with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this", "not have any wiki or excerpts. I just want to", "prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a", "that some of the tags do not have any wiki", "excerpts. I just want to know, which one is more", "any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki", "lists, we see that some of the tags do not", "of the tags do not have any wiki or excerpts.", "see that some of the tags do not have any", "some of the tags do not have any wiki or", "a review on the tags lists, we see that some", "review on the tags lists, we see that some of", "just want to know, which one is more prefered, a" ]
[ "a faculty member, it is not his duty to ask", "memebrs of community have some strong reasons for and againts", "and became so angry with it. His main problem seems", "answered by members of academia. However, one of the users", "every one has his own way of doing something, it", "something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach", "question here is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the", "strong reasons for and againts it. If every one has", "the questions (which are almost seem to be opinion based).", "this question is basically opinion based and became so angry", "some strong reasons for and againts it. If every one", "with this question and how should I avoid such conflicts", "community have some strong reasons for and againts it. If", "odd in the university and because he is a student,", "is an answer to the questions (which are almost seem", "is not a faculty member, it is not his duty", "it is not opinion based and can be precisely answered", "member, it is not his duty to ask why something", "ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences,", "are different ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons", "duty to ask why something seems odd in the university", "strongly believe that it is not opinion based and can", "of doing something, it does not mean that everybody is", "in the university and because he is a student, he", "to ask why something seems odd in the university and", "should never think about the logic behind the actions. My", "with it. His main problem seems to be that if", "is a student, he should never think about the logic", "behind the actions. My question here is, even if a", "problem is with this question and how should I avoid", "point that there is an answer to the questions (which", "is with this question and how should I avoid such", "it does not mean that everybody is right because it", "experiences, we can reach the point that there is an", "logic behind the actions. My question here is, even if", "precisely answered by members of academia. However, one of the", "the actions. My question here is, even if a question", "seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong reasons", "If every one has his own way of doing something,", "we can reach the point that there is an answer", "is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of", "of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe that", "so angry with it. His main problem seems to be", "something seems odd in the university and because he is", "has his own way of doing something, it does not", "please help me understand what the problem is with this", "what the problem is with this question and how should", "that if the person asking question is not a faculty", "the opinions. Even there are different ways of doing something,", "it is not his duty to ask why something seems", "the memebrs of community have some strong reasons for and", "comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach the point", "that it is not opinion based and can be precisely", "opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong reasons for", "are almost seem to be opinion based). Could you please", "why something seems odd in the university and because he", "and againts it. If every one has his own way", "opinion based). Could you please help me understand what the", "the logic behind the actions. My question here is, even", "help me understand what the problem is with this question", "be precisely answered by members of academia. However, one of", "His main problem seems to be that if the person", "main problem seems to be that if the person asking", "question is not a faculty member, it is not his", "is not his duty to ask why something seems odd", "doing something, it does not mean that everybody is right", "there are different ways of doing something, by comparing the", "users thought this question is basically opinion based and became", "My question here is, even if a question seems opinion-based;", "something is asked which I strongly believe that it is", "an answer to the questions (which are almost seem to", "seem to be opinion based). Could you please help me", "think about the logic behind the actions. My question here", "based). Could you please help me understand what the problem", "mean that everybody is right because it depends on the", "thought this question is basically opinion based and became so", "actions. My question here is, even if a question seems", "opinions. Even there are different ways of doing something, by", "me understand what the problem is with this question and", "problem seems to be that if the person asking question", "question is basically opinion based and became so angry with", "of the users thought this question is basically opinion based", "not a faculty member, it is not his duty to", "became so angry with it. His main problem seems to", "because he is a student, he should never think about", "and how should I avoid such conflicts in the community?", "In [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I", "can be precisely answered by members of academia. However, one", "reach the point that there is an answer to the", "mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe that it", "one has his own way of doing something, it does", "a student, he should never think about the logic behind", "Could you please help me understand what the problem is", "depends on the opinions. Even there are different ways of", "is asked which I strongly believe that it is not", "understand what the problem is with this question and how", "because it depends on the opinions. Even there are different", "different ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons and", "academia. However, one of the users thought this question is", "based and can be precisely answered by members of academia.", "is basically opinion based and became so angry with it.", "here is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs", "question and how should I avoid such conflicts in the", "answer to the questions (which are almost seem to be", "this question and how should I avoid such conflicts in", "everybody is right because it depends on the opinions. Even", "almost seem to be opinion based). Could you please help", "be opinion based). Could you please help me understand what", "about the logic behind the actions. My question here is,", "question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe", "it. If every one has his own way of doing", "of academia. However, one of the users thought this question", "to be that if the person asking question is not", "questions (which are almost seem to be opinion based). Could", "reasons for and againts it. If every one has his", "faculty member, it is not his duty to ask why", "by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach the", "and experiences, we can reach the point that there is", "not his duty to ask why something seems odd in", "and can be precisely answered by members of academia. However,", "university and because he is a student, he should never", "is right because it depends on the opinions. Even there", "seems odd in the university and because he is a", "does not mean that everybody is right because it depends", "you please help me understand what the problem is with", "if the person asking question is not a faculty member,", "of community have some strong reasons for and againts it.", "by members of academia. However, one of the users thought", "is not opinion based and can be precisely answered by", "even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community", "to the questions (which are almost seem to be opinion", "[this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly", "that there is an answer to the questions (which are", "believe that it is not opinion based and can be", "basically opinion based and became so angry with it. His", "the university and because he is a student, he should", "it. His main problem seems to be that if the", "reasons and experiences, we can reach the point that there", "members of academia. However, one of the users thought this", "againts it. If every one has his own way of", "not mean that everybody is right because it depends on", "the reasons and experiences, we can reach the point that", "ask why something seems odd in the university and because", "never think about the logic behind the actions. My question", "he is a student, he should never think about the", "asked which I strongly believe that it is not opinion", "if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have", "that everybody is right because it depends on the opinions.", "I strongly believe that it is not opinion based and", "and because he is a student, he should never think", "the point that there is an answer to the questions", "his duty to ask why something seems odd in the", "have some strong reasons for and againts it. If every", "Even there are different ways of doing something, by comparing", "person asking question is not a faculty member, it is", "(which are almost seem to be opinion based). Could you", "there is an answer to the questions (which are almost", "student, he should never think about the logic behind the", "his own way of doing something, it does not mean", "right because it depends on the opinions. Even there are", "it depends on the opinions. Even there are different ways", "on the opinions. Even there are different ways of doing", "which I strongly believe that it is not opinion based", "be that if the person asking question is not a", "angry with it. His main problem seems to be that", "can reach the point that there is an answer to", "the users thought this question is basically opinion based and", "way of doing something, it does not mean that everybody", "asking question is not a faculty member, it is not", "However, one of the users thought this question is basically", "of doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we", "doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can", "opinion based and became so angry with it. His main", "one of the users thought this question is basically opinion", "the problem is with this question and how should I", "question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong", "to be opinion based). Could you please help me understand", "a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some", "the person asking question is not a faculty member, it", "seems to be that if the person asking question is", "for and againts it. If every one has his own", "opinion based and can be precisely answered by members of", "based and became so angry with it. His main problem", "something, it does not mean that everybody is right because", "not opinion based and can be precisely answered by members", "he should never think about the logic behind the actions.", "own way of doing something, it does not mean that" ]
[ "reason. Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting some", "the suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why", "the complete information is written in the wiki, so in", "the previous tag better than the suggested one?! I don't", "I can not find any good reason. Could you please", "* [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need to", "a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are to", "better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting", "rejections I can not find any good reason. Could you", "be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless", "substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post. The question", "and give the chance to the tag to be seen", "minor; why the suggested edit *is not substantive improvements addressing", "them? [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag", "is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post.", "the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits?", "tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? ", "Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt", "and pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted. ", "good reason. Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting", "the post*. The question here is was the previous tag", "suggested one with two exact sentences that address the questions", "explain your reasons for rejecting some of them? [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334)", "post*. The question here is was the previous tag better", "pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted. [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345)", "of NSF, why do we have extra information in the", "seen and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy", "* [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these", "The only use of excerpts are to give a clue", "issues in the post*. The question here is was the", "exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The", "the wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted and", "[nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is written in", "of them are correctly judged, for many of those rejections", "So, those extra words are omitted. [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this", "NSF, why do we have extra information in the excerpt?", "to the tag to be seen and better excerpts be", "some of them are correctly judged, for many of those", "for rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the", "rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt", "better? The previous five word excerpt or the suggested one", "wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and reads", "to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the", "tag, the complete information is written in the wiki, so", "excerpts are to give a clue to the reader that", "please explain your reasons for rejecting some of them? ", "of the wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted", "chance to the tag to be seen and better excerpts", "\"Queries about...\" every body know that this site is a", "only use of excerpts are to give a clue to", "deleted. [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need", "written in the wiki, so in the excerpt we only", "the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do", "clue to the reader that what is being questioned. So,", "is better? The previous five word excerpt or the suggested", "Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking", "is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at", "edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to", "The reader goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet", "need to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of", "with two exact sentences that address the questions under the", "about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this site", "for many of those rejections I can not find any", "words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete", "Despite the fact that some of them are correctly judged,", "goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of", "extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the", "understand why that edit is too minor; why the suggested", "this site is a Q&A website. The only use of", "tag better than the suggested one?! I don't think so.", "addressing multiple issues in the post*. The question here is", "of my tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact", "copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted.", "always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every", "Many of my tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the", "so the excerpt was deleted. [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question,", "not find any good reason. Could you please explain your", "questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in", "excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt or the", "website. The only use of excerpts are to give a", "have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body", "of excerpts are to give a clue to the reader", "Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting some of", "do we need the exact copy and paste of excerpts", "find any good reason. Could you please explain your reasons", "be seen and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact", "reader that what is being questioned. So, those extra words", "edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some of", "any good reason. Could you please explain your reasons for", "not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post. The", "in this tag, the complete information is written in the", "wiki, so in the excerpt we only need to attract", "site is a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts", "is too minor; why the suggested edit is not substantive", "attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have", "and wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and", "we need to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or", "to be seen and better excerpts be provided to it.", "the suggested one with two exact sentences that address the", "the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the wiki.", "the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra information", "some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that", "reader goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy", "a clue to the reader that what is being questioned.", "reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I think the", "* [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag edit", "are rejected. Despite the fact that some of them are", "omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is", "question, why do we need to always have the word", "at the proposed edits to these two tags, I can", "previous tag better than the suggested one?! I don't think", "should be deleted and give the chance to the tag", "suggested edit *is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in", "the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know", "Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are to give", "is the reason that the tag edit is rejected because", "is being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. ", "to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF,", "one with two exact sentences that address the questions under", "know that this site is a Q&A website. The only", "why the suggested edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple", "and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and", "tag to be seen and better excerpts be provided to", "fact that some of them are correctly judged, for many", "the fact that some of them are correctly judged, for", "the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor", "What is the reason that the tag edit is rejected", "can not understand why that edit is too minor; why", "deleted and give the chance to the tag to be", "in the wiki, so in the excerpt we only need", "The previous five word excerpt or the suggested one with", "edit *is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the", "is was the previous tag better than the suggested one?!", "that address the questions under the tag? [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where", "are to give a clue to the reader that what", "the exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes?", "suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do", "tag excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt or", "is a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are", "give a clue to the reader that what is being", "judged, for many of those rejections I can not find", "need the exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki", "\"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this", "I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need", "edits to these two tags, I can not understand why", "copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt should be", "useless so the excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this", "was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we", "to the reader that what is being questioned. So, those", "incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The", "the reader that what is being questioned. So, those extra", "the proposed edits to these two tags, I can not", "in the post*. The question here is was the previous", "correctly judged, for many of those rejections I can not", "[repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these two", "that some of them are correctly judged, for many of", "are omitted. [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information", "to give a clue to the reader that what is", "only need to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation", "think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact", "excerpt should be deleted and give the chance to the", "excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I", "excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was", "the excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why", "this tag, the complete information is written in the wiki,", "what is being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted.", "is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag", "I think the excerpt should be deleted and give the", "the excerpt should be deleted and give the chance to", "[publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy and paste", "because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is", "Exact copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt was", "the reason that the tag edit is rejected because of", "under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my", "my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits", "don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the", "rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason", "why that edit is too minor; why the suggested edit", "address the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is", "excerpt we only need to attract the reader's attention to", "[education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag edit is", "are correctly judged, for many of those rejections I can", "and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes", "be deleted and give the chance to the tag to", "provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so", "being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340)", "abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra information in", "too minor; why the suggested edit *is not substantive improvements", "about...\" every body know that this site is a Q&A", "[poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need to always", "[homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356)", "questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in", "body know that this site is a Q&A website. The", "here is was the previous tag better than the suggested", "reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we", "Looking at the proposed edits to these two tags, I", "the wiki, so in the excerpt we only need to", "that the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and", "one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we", "copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader", "rejected. Despite the fact that some of them are correctly", "exacet copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt should", "can not find any good reason. Could you please explain", "use of excerpts are to give a clue to the", "information is written in the wiki, so in the excerpt", "of those rejections I can not find any good reason.", "edit is too minor; why the suggested edit *is not", "this question, why do we need to always have the", "or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this site is", " [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is written", "not understand why that edit is too minor; why the", "word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that", "the excerpt we only need to attract the reader's attention", "two tags, I can not understand why that edit is", "the chance to the tag to be seen and better", "sentences that address the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329)", "excerpt or the suggested one with two exact sentences that", "excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do", "two exact sentences that address the questions under the tag?", "previous five word excerpt or the suggested one with two", "reasons for rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is", "the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness", "to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\"", "question here is was the previous tag better than the", "or the suggested one with two exact sentences that address", "multiple issues in the post. The question here is was", "why do we need to always have the word \"Questions", "of incorrectness and minor edit*? Which tag excerpt is better?", "exact sentences that address the questions under the tag? ", "The question here is was the previous tag better than", "word excerpt or the suggested one with two exact sentences", "do we need to always have the word \"Questions about...\"", "you please explain your reasons for rejecting some of them?", "paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to", "the suggested edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues", "minor edit*? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five", "incorrectness in my edits? [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the", "* [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328);", "proposed edits to these two tags, I can not understand", "I can not understand why that edit is too minor;", "those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag,", "is written in the wiki, so in the excerpt we", "give the chance to the tag to be seen and", "in the excerpt we only need to attract the reader's", "better than the suggested one?! I don't think so. ", "your reasons for rejecting some of them? [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What", "to these two tags, I can not understand why that", "my tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that", "to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra", "of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to the", "that what is being questioned. So, those extra words are", "the tag to be seen and better excerpts be provided", "these two tags, I can not understand why that edit", "In this question, why do we need to always have", "many of those rejections I can not find any good", "five word excerpt or the suggested one with two exact", "improvements addressing multiple issues in the post*. The question here", " [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy and", "tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some", "in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed", "[recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these two tags,", "think the excerpt should be deleted and give the chance", "Why do we need the exact copy and paste of", "edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which", "tags, I can not understand why that edit is too", "suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some of them", "reason that the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness*", "we need the exact copy and paste of excerpts and", "notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and reads the", "so. [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy", "that edit is too minor; why the suggested edit *is", "and reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I think", "wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted and give", "it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt", "was useless so the excerpt was deleted. [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In", "to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so the", "excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt", "tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit?", "that this site is a Q&A website. The only use", "complete information is written in the wiki, so in the", "every body know that this site is a Q&A website.", "them are correctly judged, for many of those rejections I", "of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the", "than the suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354)", "so in the excerpt we only need to attract the", "edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five word", "need to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries", "those rejections I can not find any good reason. Could", "we only need to attract the reader's attention to the", "and minor edit**? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous", "was the previous tag better than the suggested one?! I", "the exacet copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt", "attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why" ]