Split (1)

train · 10.4M rows

ngram listlengths 0 9.89k
[ "> This question appears to be off-topic because it is", "to be off-topic because it is not answerable by the", "“I want to do X, Here's My Life Story…” questions.", "seems to be a strong consensus that we need a", "> > I am not too keen on referring the", "Academia community; you may need to ask someone specific to", "not too keen on referring the the academia community as", "was hoping to get some feedback on the exact wording.", "need to ask someone specific to your situation, as the", "> > This question appears to be off-topic because it", "and was hoping to get some feedback on the exact", "\"general public\" and was hoping to get some feedback on", "referring the the academia community as the \"general public\" and", "public cannot completely answer this question. > > > I", "that we need a new custom close reason to ban", "the \"general public\" and was hoping to get some feedback", "situation, as the general public cannot completely answer this question.", "new custom close reason to ban “I want to do", "[Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the following: > > This question appears to", "User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the following: > > This question appears", "discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the following: > > This", "to ask someone specific to your situation, as the general", "close reason to ban “I want to do X, Here's", "the Academia community; you may need to ask someone specific", "My Life Story…” questions. See the meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User", "keen on referring the the academia community as the \"general", "we need a new custom close reason to ban “I", "on referring the the academia community as the \"general public\"", "public\" and was hoping to get some feedback on the", "be a strong consensus that we need a new custom", "ask someone specific to your situation, as the general public", "the academia community as the \"general public\" and was hoping", "not answerable by the Academia community; you may need to", "Life Story…” questions. See the meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929)", "am not too keen on referring the the academia community", "is not answerable by the Academia community; you may need", "consensus that we need a new custom close reason to", "as the general public cannot completely answer this question. >", "the meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the following: >", "custom close reason to ban “I want to do X,", "There seems to be a strong consensus that we need", "to your situation, as the general public cannot completely answer", "may need to ask someone specific to your situation, as", "a strong consensus that we need a new custom close", "need a new custom close reason to ban “I want", "academia community as the \"general public\" and was hoping to", "as the \"general public\" and was hoping to get some", "strong consensus that we need a new custom close reason", "[here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the following: > > This question", "want to do X, Here's My Life Story…” questions. See", "by the Academia community; you may need to ask someone", "cannot completely answer this question. > > > I am", "to be a strong consensus that we need a new", "question. > > > I am not too keen on", "community; you may need to ask someone specific to your", "do X, Here's My Life Story…” questions. See the meta", "the the academia community as the \"general public\" and was", "to do X, Here's My Life Story…” questions. See the", "proposed the following: > > This question appears to be", "too keen on referring the the academia community as the", "reason to ban “I want to do X, Here's My", "See the meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the following:", "be off-topic because it is not answerable by the Academia", "completely answer this question. > > > I am not", "> I am not too keen on referring the the", "Story…” questions. See the meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed", "general public cannot completely answer this question. > > >", "specific to your situation, as the general public cannot completely", "it is not answerable by the Academia community; you may", "the general public cannot completely answer this question. > >", "answerable by the Academia community; you may need to ask", "Here's My Life Story…” questions. See the meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions).", "ban “I want to do X, Here's My Life Story…”", "the following: > > This question appears to be off-topic", "questions. See the meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the", "your situation, as the general public cannot completely answer this", "appears to be off-topic because it is not answerable by", "I am not too keen on referring the the academia", "question appears to be off-topic because it is not answerable", "this question. > > > I am not too keen", "X, Here's My Life Story…” questions. See the meta discussion", "off-topic because it is not answerable by the Academia community;", "This question appears to be off-topic because it is not", "answer this question. > > > I am not too", "because it is not answerable by the Academia community; you", "you may need to ask someone specific to your situation,", "someone specific to your situation, as the general public cannot", "> > > I am not too keen on referring", "following: > > This question appears to be off-topic because", "community as the \"general public\" and was hoping to get", "to ban “I want to do X, Here's My Life", "a new custom close reason to ban “I want to", "meta discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1093/time-to-expressly-ban-i-want-to-do-x-heres-my-life-story-questions). User [Emrakul](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1113/929) proposed the following: > >" ]
[ "proposal on meta is required to delete the tag? I", "I have read the help center triple times and found", "after one day, she does every thing she wants. Where", "and found no sign of such policy and process that", "read the help center triple times and found no sign", "in their actions and words > are open to some", "described above. This action is against the following instructions on", "know, how many answers in a delete proposal on meta", "on help center because it was not patient, respectful, did", "have noticed that the moderator has deleted the tag I", "triple times and found no sign of such policy and", "the tag is duplicate; * She posted [a question on", "the moderator has deleted the tag I created `contribution`. The", "patient, respectful, did not led by example and more important", "> are open to some light but firm moderation to", "delete the tag? I am feeling that the moderator is", "policy and process that described above. This action is against", "led by example and more important it was not fair.", "want to know, how many answers in a delete proposal", "respect for their fellow community members in their actions and", "are open to some light but firm moderation to keep", "tag is deleted. I want to know, how many answers", "the following instructions on help center because it was not", "> We generally expect that moderators: > > - are", "I am feeling that the moderator is having wrong adaptation", "tag; * after less than one day (22 July), without", "center triple times and found no sign of such policy", "above. This action is against the following instructions on help", "any answers supporting to delete the tag The tag is", "example and more important it was not fair. When I", "for this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > > We generally expect that", "actions and words > are open to some light but", "many answers in a delete proposal on meta is required", "center because it was not patient, respectful, did not led", "their actions and words > are open to some light", "help center, I have read the help center triple times", "more important it was not fair. When I read the", "tag I created `contribution`. The process was this: * She", "- are patient and fair > > - lead by", "show respect for their fellow community members in their actions", "times and found no sign of such policy and process", "is against the following instructions on help center because it", "July), without any answers supporting to delete the tag The", "how many answers in a delete proposal on meta is", "process was this: * She felt the tag is duplicate;", "without any answers supporting to delete the tag The tag", "not patient, respectful, did not led by example and more", "light but firm moderation to keep the community on track", "- show respect for their fellow community members in their", "felt the tag is duplicate; * She posted [a question", "She felt the tag is duplicate; * She posted [a", "She posted [a question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask about the", "is required to delete the tag? I am feeling that", "thing she wants. Where is this policy written on help", "the tag I created `contribution`. The process was this: ", "> - show respect for their fellow community members in", "on track and resolve (hopefully) uncommon disputes and exceptions >", "meta is required to delete the tag? I am feeling", "the usefulness of the tag; after less than one", "The tag is deleted. I want to know, how many", "that moderators: > > - are patient and fair >", "the user's problem to meta or chat and after one", "is this policy written on help center, I have read", "[help center for this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > > We generally", "moderators: > > - are patient and fair > >", "feeling that the moderator is having wrong adaptation of the", "which she directly brings the user's problem to meta or", "day, she does every thing she wants. Where is this", "and process that described above. This action is against the", "> - lead by example > > - show respect", "following instructions on help center because it was not patient,", "some light but firm moderation to keep the community on", "the community on track and resolve (hopefully) uncommon disputes and", "on new user; which she directly brings the user's problem", "to meta or chat and after one day, she does", "less than one day (22 July), without any answers supporting", "question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask about the usefulness of the", "noticed that the moderator has deleted the tag I created", "on meta is required to delete the tag? I am", "duplicate; * She posted [a question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask", "to know, how many answers in a delete proposal on", "about the usefulness of the tag; * after less than", "and fair > > - lead by example > >", "track and resolve (hopefully) uncommon disputes and exceptions > >", "it was not fair. When I read the [help center", "the [help center for this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > > We", "[a question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask about the usefulness of", "tag is duplicate; * She posted [a question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag)", "instructions on help center because it was not patient, respectful,", "the tag; * after less than one day (22 July),", "tag? I am feeling that the moderator is having wrong", "The process was this: * She felt the tag is", "We generally expect that moderators: > > - are patient", "fair > > - lead by example > > -", "written on help center, I have read the help center", "am feeling that the moderator is having wrong adaptation of", "> > - show respect for their fellow community members", "important it was not fair. When I read the [help", "firm moderation to keep the community on track and resolve", "on help center, I have read the help center triple", "I have noticed that the moderator has deleted the tag", "posted [a question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask about the usefulness", "found no sign of such policy and process that described", "I want to know, how many answers in a delete", "to delete the tag The tag is deleted. I want", "help center triple times and found no sign of such", "help center because it was not patient, respectful, did not", "imposing her personal desires on new user; which she directly", "that the moderator has deleted the tag I created `contribution`.", "example > > - show respect for their fellow community", "she directly brings the user's problem to meta or chat", "by example and more important it was not fair. When", "but firm moderation to keep the community on track and", "community on track and resolve (hopefully) uncommon disputes and exceptions", "and resolve (hopefully) uncommon disputes and exceptions > > >", "problem to meta or chat and after one day, she", "this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > > We generally expect that moderators:", "is having wrong adaptation of the site's policies and is", "moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > > We generally expect that moderators: >", "every thing she wants. Where is this policy written on", "personal desires on new user; which she directly brings the", "moderator has deleted the tag I created `contribution`. The process", "is deleted. I want to know, how many answers in", "their fellow community members in their actions and words >", "(22 July), without any answers supporting to delete the tag", "respectful, did not led by example and more important it", "action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > > We generally expect that moderators: > >", "required to delete the tag? I am feeling that the", "by example > > - show respect for their fellow", "words > are open to some light but firm moderation", "this: * She felt the tag is duplicate; * She", "tag The tag is deleted. I want to know, how", "meta or chat and after one day, she does every", "she wants. Where is this policy written on help center,", "keep the community on track and resolve (hopefully) uncommon disputes", "not led by example and more important it was not", "created `contribution`. The process was this: * She felt the", "> > We generally expect that moderators: > > -", "the tag The tag is deleted. I want to know,", "in a delete proposal on meta is required to delete", "> - are patient and fair > > - lead", "have read the help center triple times and found no", "did not led by example and more important it was", "desires on new user; which she directly brings the user's", "is imposing her personal desires on new user; which she", "new user; which she directly brings the user's problem to", "process that described above. This action is against the following", "of the site's policies and is imposing her personal desires", "directly brings the user's problem to meta or chat and", "to ask about the usefulness of the tag; * after", "day (22 July), without any answers supporting to delete the", "moderator is having wrong adaptation of the site's policies and", "the help center triple times and found no sign of", "are patient and fair > > - lead by example", "on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask about the usefulness of the tag;", "this policy written on help center, I have read the", "`contribution`. The process was this: * She felt the tag", "When I read the [help center for this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators),", "and is imposing her personal desires on new user; which", "> > - lead by example > > - show", "members in their actions and words > are open to", "to some light but firm moderation to keep the community", "or chat and after one day, she does every thing", "not fair. When I read the [help center for this", "a delete proposal on meta is required to delete the", "* She posted [a question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask about", "moderation to keep the community on track and resolve (hopefully)", "answers supporting to delete the tag The tag is deleted.", "- lead by example > > - show respect for", "the site's policies and is imposing her personal desires on", "usefulness of the tag; * after less than one day", "Where is this policy written on help center, I have", "center, I have read the help center triple times and", "deleted. I want to know, how many answers in a", "to keep the community on track and resolve (hopefully) uncommon", "user's problem to meta or chat and after one day,", "chat and after one day, she does every thing she", "patient and fair > > - lead by example >", "wrong adaptation of the site's policies and is imposing her", "no sign of such policy and process that described above.", "has deleted the tag I created `contribution`. The process was", "because it was not patient, respectful, did not led by", "community members in their actions and words > are open", "adaptation of the site's policies and is imposing her personal", "action is against the following instructions on help center because", "the tag? I am feeling that the moderator is having", "to delete the tag? I am feeling that the moderator", "than one day (22 July), without any answers supporting to", "and more important it was not fair. When I read", "site's policies and is imposing her personal desires on new", "does every thing she wants. Where is this policy written", "was not patient, respectful, did not led by example and", "it was not patient, respectful, did not led by example", "was not fair. When I read the [help center for", "user; which she directly brings the user's problem to meta", "against the following instructions on help center because it was", "I read the [help center for this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), >", "her personal desires on new user; which she directly brings", "for their fellow community members in their actions and words", "is duplicate; * She posted [a question on Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to", "fair. When I read the [help center for this moderation", "Meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1126/usefulness-of-the-contribution-tag) to ask about the usefulness of the tag; ", "sign of such policy and process that described above. This", "of the tag; after less than one day (22", "* She felt the tag is duplicate; * She posted", "This action is against the following instructions on help center", "having wrong adaptation of the site's policies and is imposing", "generally expect that moderators: > > - are patient and", "fellow community members in their actions and words > are", "delete the tag The tag is deleted. I want to", "that described above. This action is against the following instructions", "that the moderator is having wrong adaptation of the site's", "such policy and process that described above. This action is", "* after less than one day (22 July), without any", "open to some light but firm moderation to keep the", "was this: * She felt the tag is duplicate; ", "deleted the tag I created `contribution`. The process was this:", "lead by example > > - show respect for their", "of such policy and process that described above. This action", "one day, she does every thing she wants. Where is", "and after one day, she does every thing she wants.", "> > - are patient and fair > > -", "wants. Where is this policy written on help center, I", "answers in a delete proposal on meta is required to", "read the [help center for this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > >", "center for this moderation action](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/site-moderators), > > We generally expect", "after less than one day (22 July), without any answers", "one day (22 July), without any answers supporting to delete", "brings the user's problem to meta or chat and after", "policy written on help center, I have read the help", "the moderator is having wrong adaptation of the site's policies", "and words > are open to some light but firm", "delete proposal on meta is required to delete the tag?", "I created `contribution`. The process was this: She felt", "expect that moderators: > > - are patient and fair", "ask about the usefulness of the tag; * after less", "she does every thing she wants. Where is this policy", "policies and is imposing her personal desires on new user;", "supporting to delete the tag The tag is deleted. I" ]
[ "a suitable tag for the question which seems to be", "are also some other tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions tagged", "if creating this tag is reasonable, what would be a", "has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions tagged 'website'\") option to choose", "positive vote rate; now, a tag suggestion (including the tag", "\"show questions tagged 'society'\") but none of which are so", "enough. There are also some other tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show", "few answers are posted to this question with positive vote", "question with positive vote rate; now, a tag suggestion (including", "has been posted in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post your suggestions", "the question which seems to be too broad for the", "like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions tagged 'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions", "by searching keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost 85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin)", "related to social websites on Academia like the cases which", "is not specific enough. There are also some other tags", "tagged 'social-website'\") (or an equivalent tag) be created on the", "a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions tagged 'social-website'\") (or an equivalent tag)", "like the cases which are found by searching keywords like", "websites and is not specific enough. There are also some", "other tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions tagged 'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society", "[community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions tagged 'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions tagged", "[social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\") has been posted in [this", "the cases which are found by searching keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook)", "(including the tag title, tag excerpt and tag wiki) for", "answers are posted to this question with positive vote rate;", "post your suggestions and comments to that answer to improve", "to social websites on Academia like the cases which are", "'social-media'\") has been posted in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post your", "broad for the purpose of the social websites and is", "for it? --- update and conclusion After a few answers", "(or an equivalent tag) be created on the Academia and", "too broad for the purpose of the social websites and", "is asking a question related to social websites on Academia", "tag is reasonable, what would be a good Tag-Excerpt for", "tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions tagged 'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show", "with almost 85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53 results, etc. s/he", "'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions tagged 'society'\") but none of", "posted in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post your suggestions and comments", "questions tagged 'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions tagged 'society'\") but", "one is asking a question related to social websites on", "searching keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost 85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with", "none of which are so relevant to those question types.", "[LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53 results, etc. s/he has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show", "with 53 results, etc. s/he has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions", "are so relevant to those question types. Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website", "--- update and conclusion After a few answers are posted", "[website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions tagged 'website'\") option to choose a suitable", "tag) be created on the Academia and if creating this", "relevant to those question types. Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions", "questions tagged 'social-website'\") (or an equivalent tag) be created on", "and conclusion After a few answers are posted to this", "reasonable, what would be a good Tag-Excerpt for it? ---", "When one is asking a question related to social websites", "only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions tagged 'website'\") option to choose a", "so relevant to those question types. Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show", "tagged 'website'\") option to choose a suitable tag for the", "questions tagged 'society'\") but none of which are so relevant", "option to choose a suitable tag for the question which", "to that answer to improve the suggested tag title and", "and if creating this tag is reasonable, what would be", "[Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost 85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53 results, etc.", "85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53 results, etc. s/he has only", "the purpose of the social websites and is not specific", "but none of which are so relevant to those question", "53 results, etc. s/he has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions tagged", "and is not specific enough. There are also some other", "etc. s/he has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions tagged 'website'\") option", "question which seems to be too broad for the purpose", "title, tag excerpt and tag wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions", "answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post your suggestions and comments to that answer", "keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost 85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53", "like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost 85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53 results,", "to choose a suitable tag for the question which seems", "those question types. Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions tagged 'social-website'\")", "for the question which seems to be too broad for", "now, a tag suggestion (including the tag title, tag excerpt", "for the purpose of the social websites and is not", "tag title, tag excerpt and tag wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show", "be created on the Academia and if creating this tag", "this question with positive vote rate; now, a tag suggestion", "'website'\") option to choose a suitable tag for the question", "question types. Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions tagged 'social-website'\") (or", "tagged 'society'\") but none of which are so relevant to", "\"show questions tagged 'social-media'\") has been posted in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723).", "vote rate; now, a tag suggestion (including the tag title,", "your suggestions and comments to that answer to improve the", "it? --- update and conclusion After a few answers are", "update and conclusion After a few answers are posted to", "Tag-Excerpt for it? --- update and conclusion After a few", "\"show questions tagged 'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions tagged 'society'\")", "seems to be too broad for the purpose of the", "tagged 'community'\") or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions tagged 'society'\") but none", "[this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post your suggestions and comments to that", "for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\") has been posted in", "\"show questions tagged 'social-website'\") (or an equivalent tag) be created", "found by searching keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost 85 results,", "rate; now, a tag suggestion (including the tag title, tag", "which are so relevant to those question types. Should a", "types. Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions tagged 'social-website'\") (or an", "a tag suggestion (including the tag title, tag excerpt and", "questions tagged 'social-media'\") has been posted in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please", "which seems to be too broad for the purpose of", "a few answers are posted to this question with positive", "Academia and if creating this tag is reasonable, what would", "some other tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions tagged 'community'\") or", "with positive vote rate; now, a tag suggestion (including the", "purpose of the social websites and is not specific enough.", "suggestions and comments to that answer to improve the suggested", "suggestion (including the tag title, tag excerpt and tag wiki)", "are posted to this question with positive vote rate; now,", "what would be a good Tag-Excerpt for it? --- update", "Please post your suggestions and comments to that answer to", "and tag wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\") has", "choose a suitable tag for the question which seems to", "[society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions tagged 'society'\") but none of which are", "s/he has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions tagged 'website'\") option to", "created on the Academia and if creating this tag is", "comments to that answer to improve the suggested tag title", "There are also some other tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions", "tag suggestion (including the tag title, tag excerpt and tag", "results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53 results, etc. s/he has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website", "been posted in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post your suggestions and", "that answer to improve the suggested tag title and excerpt.", "tag wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\") has been", "on Academia like the cases which are found by searching", "equivalent tag) be created on the Academia and if creating", "of the social websites and is not specific enough. There", "After a few answers are posted to this question with", "to be too broad for the purpose of the social", "to this question with positive vote rate; now, a tag", "\"show questions tagged 'website'\") option to choose a suitable tag", "questions tagged 'website'\") option to choose a suitable tag for", "good Tag-Excerpt for it? --- update and conclusion After a", "tag for the question which seems to be too broad", "a good Tag-Excerpt for it? --- update and conclusion After", "and comments to that answer to improve the suggested tag", "Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions tagged 'social-website'\") (or an equivalent", "the social websites and is not specific enough. There are", "the tag title, tag excerpt and tag wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media", "this tag is reasonable, what would be a good Tag-Excerpt", "not specific enough. There are also some other tags like", "asking a question related to social websites on Academia like", "posted to this question with positive vote rate; now, a", "an equivalent tag) be created on the Academia and if", "the Academia and if creating this tag is reasonable, what", "results, etc. s/he has only [website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/website \"show questions tagged 'website'\")", "wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\") has been posted", "websites on Academia like the cases which are found by", "Academia like the cases which are found by searching keywords", "in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post your suggestions and comments to", "which are found by searching keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost", "'society'\") but none of which are so relevant to those", "suitable tag for the question which seems to be too", "'social-website'\") (or an equivalent tag) be created on the Academia", "be a good Tag-Excerpt for it? --- update and conclusion", "is reasonable, what would be a good Tag-Excerpt for it?", "tagged 'social-media'\") has been posted in [this answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1146/15723). Please post", "on the Academia and if creating this tag is reasonable,", "almost 85 results, [LinkedIn](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=linkedin) with 53 results, etc. s/he has", "conclusion After a few answers are posted to this question", "social websites on Academia like the cases which are found", "be too broad for the purpose of the social websites", "also some other tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community \"show questions tagged 'community'\")", "specific enough. There are also some other tags like [community](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/community", "or [society](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/society \"show questions tagged 'society'\") but none of which", "of which are so relevant to those question types. Should", "to those question types. Should a [social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions tagged", "creating this tag is reasonable, what would be a good", "would be a good Tag-Excerpt for it? --- update and", "tag excerpt and tag wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged", "excerpt and tag wiki) for [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\")", "social websites and is not specific enough. There are also", "are found by searching keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with almost 85", "[social-website](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-website \"show questions tagged 'social-website'\") (or an equivalent tag) be", "cases which are found by searching keywords like [Facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=facebook) with", "question related to social websites on Academia like the cases", "a question related to social websites on Academia like the" ]
[ "unfortunately. That anger is also very real - what should", "to my questions. Here on Academia.SE the word rant is", "shows anger : to complain in a way that is", "on other websites and I would like some clarification. There", "am concerned that \"rant\" is just a trope used by", "have used other [stack-exchange websites](http://stackexchange.com/sites) successfully (there are about 100", "seen on other websites and I would like some clarification.", "> > > This definition characterizes most online behavior, unfortunately.", "in a way that is unreasonable > > > This", "characterizes most online behavior, unfortunately. That anger is also very", "real - what should unsuccessful posters do with it? ---", "users on this site to close/delete questions they don't like.", "> > Recently, someone posted the question \"Fee surcharge for", "\"not a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > > Recently, someone posted the", "could mean: > > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk loudly and in", "is unreasonable > > > This definition characterizes most online", "this word to see what it could mean: > >", "a way that I have not seen on other websites", "I would like some clarification. There are some guidelines in", "the question \"Fee surcharge for international students\", which was an", "a small section on [what not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still", "in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of Academia.SE and even a small", "successfully (there are about 100 of them) to get answers", "what should unsuccessful posters do with it? --- Specifically, I", "of Academia.SE and even a small section on [what not", "> > > Let me look up this word to", "in a way that I have not seen on other", "[Possible \"not a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > > Recently, someone posted", "word to see what it could mean: > > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant)", "most online behavior, unfortunately. That anger is also very real", "trope used by high-ranking users on this site to close/delete", "> > This definition characterizes most online behavior, unfortunately. That", "post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > > Recently, someone posted the question \"Fee surcharge", "find the use on here very subjective. Example [Possible \"not", "some clarification. There are some guidelines in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section", "use on here very subjective. Example [Possible \"not a question\"", "> Let me look up this word to see what", "about 100 of them) to get answers to my questions.", "behavior, unfortunately. That anger is also very real - what", "I have used other [stack-exchange websites](http://stackexchange.com/sites) successfully (there are about", "that \"rant\" is just a trope used by high-ranking users", "of them) to get answers to my questions. Here on", "talk loudly and in a way that shows anger :", "(there are about 100 of them) to get answers to", "and find the use on here very subjective. Example [Possible", "it could mean: > > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk loudly and", "I still confused and find the use on here very", "is also very real - what should unsuccessful posters do", "> > Let me look up this word to see", "a way that shows anger : to complain in a", "Let me look up this word to see what it", "just a trope used by high-ranking users on this site", "international students\", which was an undisguised rant. > > >", "section of Academia.SE and even a small section on [what", "question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > > Recently, someone posted the question \"Fee", "to complain in a way that is unreasonable > >", "that is unreasonable > > > This definition characterizes most", "small section on [what not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still confused", "This definition characterizes most online behavior, unfortunately. That anger is", "being used in a way that I have not seen", "section on [what not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still confused and", "like some clarification. There are some guidelines in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask)", "are some guidelines in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of Academia.SE and", "still confused and find the use on here very subjective.", "question \"Fee surcharge for international students\", which was an undisguised", "anger : to complain in a way that is unreasonable", "Example [Possible \"not a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > > Recently, someone", ": to complain in a way that is unreasonable >", "very subjective. Example [Possible \"not a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > >", "unsuccessful posters do with it? --- Specifically, I am concerned", "answers to my questions. Here on Academia.SE the word rant", "on here very subjective. Example [Possible \"not a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post)", "the use on here very subjective. Example [Possible \"not a", "even a small section on [what not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I", "some guidelines in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of Academia.SE and even", "> This definition characterizes most online behavior, unfortunately. That anger", "are about 100 of them) to get answers to my", "rant is being used in a way that I have", "used other [stack-exchange websites](http://stackexchange.com/sites) successfully (there are about 100 of", "on Academia.SE the word rant is being used in a", "posted the question \"Fee surcharge for international students\", which was", "in a way that shows anger : to complain in", "rant. > > > Let me look up this word", "websites and I would like some clarification. There are some", "someone posted the question \"Fee surcharge for international students\", which", "I am concerned that \"rant\" is just a trope used", "do with it? --- Specifically, I am concerned that \"rant\"", "my questions. Here on Academia.SE the word rant is being", "There are some guidelines in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of Academia.SE", "not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still confused and find the use", "\"Fee surcharge for international students\", which was an undisguised rant.", "clarification. There are some guidelines in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of", "what it could mean: > > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk loudly", "it? --- Specifically, I am concerned that \"rant\" is just", "loudly and in a way that shows anger : to", "to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still confused and find the use on", "look up this word to see what it could mean:", "very real - what should unsuccessful posters do with it?", "- what should unsuccessful posters do with it? --- Specifically,", "and even a small section on [what not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask).", "online behavior, unfortunately. That anger is also very real -", "used by high-ranking users on this site to close/delete questions", "by high-ranking users on this site to close/delete questions they", "an undisguised rant. > > > Let me look up", "students\", which was an undisguised rant. > > > Let", "[help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of Academia.SE and even a small section on", "confused and find the use on here very subjective. Example", "see what it could mean: > > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk", "Academia.SE the word rant is being used in a way", "is being used in a way that I have not", "Recently, someone posted the question \"Fee surcharge for international students\",", "was an undisguised rant. > > > Let me look", "to get answers to my questions. Here on Academia.SE the", "should unsuccessful posters do with it? --- Specifically, I am", "not seen on other websites and I would like some", "other websites and I would like some clarification. There are", "unreasonable > > > This definition characterizes most online behavior,", "undisguised rant. > > > Let me look up this", "me look up this word to see what it could", "mean: > > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk loudly and in a", "> [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk loudly and in a way that", "to see what it could mean: > > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to", "the word rant is being used in a way that", "[what not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still confused and find the", "have not seen on other websites and I would like", "ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still confused and find the use on here", "surcharge for international students\", which was an undisguised rant. >", "--- Specifically, I am concerned that \"rant\" is just a", "Specifically, I am concerned that \"rant\" is just a trope", "that shows anger : to complain in a way that", "high-ranking users on this site to close/delete questions they don't", "a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > > Recently, someone posted the question", "that I have not seen on other websites and I", "\"rant\" is just a trope used by high-ranking users on", "on [what not to ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). I still confused and find", "> Recently, someone posted the question \"Fee surcharge for international", "anger is also very real - what should unsuccessful posters", "is just a trope used by high-ranking users on this", "I have not seen on other websites and I would", "which was an undisguised rant. > > > Let me", "also very real - what should unsuccessful posters do with", "would like some clarification. There are some guidelines in the", "here very subjective. Example [Possible \"not a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) >", "concerned that \"rant\" is just a trope used by high-ranking", "with it? --- Specifically, I am concerned that \"rant\" is", "and in a way that shows anger : to complain", "[rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk loudly and in a way that shows", "a trope used by high-ranking users on this site to", "other [stack-exchange websites](http://stackexchange.com/sites) successfully (there are about 100 of them)", "to talk loudly and in a way that shows anger", "way that is unreasonable > > > This definition characterizes", "them) to get answers to my questions. Here on Academia.SE", "a way that is unreasonable > > > This definition", "the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of Academia.SE and even a small section", "questions. Here on Academia.SE the word rant is being used", "guidelines in the [help](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-ask) section of Academia.SE and even a", "way that I have not seen on other websites and", "definition characterizes most online behavior, unfortunately. That anger is also", "Here on Academia.SE the word rant is being used in", "used in a way that I have not seen on", "complain in a way that is unreasonable > > >", "websites](http://stackexchange.com/sites) successfully (there are about 100 of them) to get", "posters do with it? --- Specifically, I am concerned that", "> > [rant](http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rant) to talk loudly and in a way", "and I would like some clarification. There are some guidelines", "way that shows anger : to complain in a way", "subjective. Example [Possible \"not a question\" post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/425/possible-not-a-question-post) > > Recently,", "Academia.SE and even a small section on [what not to", "up this word to see what it could mean: >", "100 of them) to get answers to my questions. Here", "[stack-exchange websites](http://stackexchange.com/sites) successfully (there are about 100 of them) to", "That anger is also very real - what should unsuccessful", "word rant is being used in a way that I", "get answers to my questions. Here on Academia.SE the word", "for international students\", which was an undisguised rant. > >" ]
[ "suggest that we create a tag for such questions. ---", "keyword shared amongst all questions about this subject – some", "but I consider it safe to assume that there are", "is not one keyword shared amongst all questions about this", "miss something. I therefore suggest that we create a tag", "therefore suggest that we create a tag for such questions.", "safe to assume that there are more than 20 questions", "Now, not all of these questions are actually about disreputable", "following words mainly used in the context of disreputable publishers", "not one keyword shared amongst all questions about this subject", "to access all our information about this subject and one", "consider it safe to assume that there are more than", "* [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results * [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion):", "these questions are actually about disreputable publishers and the search", "of disreputable publishers yields the following number of results: ", "containing the following words mainly used in the context of", "for such questions. --- Should we agree on this: What", "lacking the respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it", "might easily miss something. I therefore suggest that we create", "tag for such questions. --- Should we agree on this:", "assume that there are more than 20 questions about this", "questions about this subject without counting them. There is not", "some examples lacking the respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734).", "results are not disjunct, but I consider it safe to", "of these questions are actually about disreputable publishers and the", "this subject without counting them. There is not one keyword", "yields the following number of results: [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results", "amongst all questions about this subject – some examples lacking", "the following words mainly used in the context of disreputable", "[predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it is difficult to access", "questions. --- Should we agree on this: What should this", "about this subject – some examples lacking the respective keywords:", "this subject – some examples lacking the respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734),", "not disjunct, but I consider it safe to assume that", "the respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it is", "are actually about disreputable publishers and the search results are", "results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results * [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results ", "are not disjunct, but I consider it safe to assume", "subject and one might easily miss something. I therefore suggest", "[shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results Now, not all of these questions are", "[predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5", "searching for questions containing the following words mainly used in", "counting them. There is not one keyword shared amongst all", "the search results are not disjunct, but I consider it", "[fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results * [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8", "Should we agree on this: What should this tag be", "questions about this subject – some examples lacking the respective", "examples lacking the respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore", "all of these questions are actually about disreputable publishers and", "search results are not disjunct, but I consider it safe", "the following number of results: * [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results ", "there are more than 20 questions about this subject without", " [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results Now, not", "disreputable publishers yields the following number of results: * [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion):", "difficult to access all our information about this subject and", "we create a tag for such questions. --- Should we", "disjunct, but I consider it safe to assume that there", "results Now, not all of these questions are actually about", "not all of these questions are actually about disreputable publishers", "in the context of disreputable publishers yields the following number", "information about this subject and one might easily miss something.", "all questions about this subject – some examples lacking the", "easily miss something. I therefore suggest that we create a", "more than 20 questions about this subject without counting them.", "about disreputable publishers and the search results are not disjunct,", "– some examples lacking the respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734),", "mainly used in the context of disreputable publishers yields the", "following number of results: * [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion):", "now, searching for questions containing the following words mainly used", "access all our information about this subject and one might", "--- Should we agree on this: What should this tag", "subject – some examples lacking the respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734),", "the context of disreputable publishers yields the following number of", "* [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results * [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion):", "results * [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results Now,", "I consider it safe to assume that there are more", "13 results * [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results", "20 questions about this subject without counting them. There is", "to assume that there are more than 20 questions about", "[scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it is difficult to access all", "that we create a tag for such questions. --- Should", "are more than 20 questions about this subject without counting", "our information about this subject and one might easily miss", "actually about disreputable publishers and the search results are not", "one keyword shared amongst all questions about this subject –", "As of now, searching for questions containing the following words", "[fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it is difficult to access all our", "[shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it is difficult to access all our information", "of results: * [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results", "a tag for such questions. --- Should we agree on", "that there are more than 20 questions about this subject", "subject without counting them. There is not one keyword shared", "Therefore it is difficult to access all our information about", "number of results: * [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13", "respective keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it is difficult", "and the search results are not disjunct, but I consider", "and one might easily miss something. I therefore suggest that", "5 results Now, not all of these questions are actually", "all our information about this subject and one might easily", "There is not one keyword shared amongst all questions about", "shared amongst all questions about this subject – some examples", "[scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results Now, not all", "one might easily miss something. I therefore suggest that we", "about this subject and one might easily miss something. I", "without counting them. There is not one keyword shared amongst", "results: * [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23 results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results ", "something. I therefore suggest that we create a tag for", "for questions containing the following words mainly used in the", "such questions. --- Should we agree on this: What should", "I therefore suggest that we create a tag for such", " [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results Now, not all of these questions", "8 results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results Now, not all of", "is difficult to access all our information about this subject", "questions containing the following words mainly used in the context", "we agree on this: What should this tag be called?", "of now, searching for questions containing the following words mainly", "used in the context of disreputable publishers yields the following", "words mainly used in the context of disreputable publishers yields", "publishers yields the following number of results: * [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=fake+is%3Aquestion): 23", "create a tag for such questions. --- Should we agree", "it safe to assume that there are more than 20", "it is difficult to access all our information about this", "context of disreputable publishers yields the following number of results:", "them. There is not one keyword shared amongst all questions", "than 20 questions about this subject without counting them. There", "keywords: [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/25916/7734), [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17379/7734), [fake](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/23332/7734), [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/26455/7734). Therefore it is difficult to", "disreputable publishers and the search results are not disjunct, but", "23 results * [predatory](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=predatory+is%3Aquestion): 13 results * [scam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=scam+is%3Aquestion): 8 results", "this subject and one might easily miss something. I therefore", "questions are actually about disreputable publishers and the search results", "publishers and the search results are not disjunct, but I", "about this subject without counting them. There is not one", "results * [shady](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=shady+is%3Aquestion): 5 results Now, not all of these" ]
[ "interaction. This answer has been flagged a number of times", "you curse you get warned policy or do we want", "answer has been flagged a number of times as being", "to 10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses both expletives and suggests a", "being offensive. The flags require the diamond mods to make", "or do we want to be a little more relaxed?", "vulgar language) allowed on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we want a", "warn/suspend the user. Expletives are not appreciated on SE, and", "flags require the diamond mods to make a decision. We", "make a decision. We can do nothing, delete the answer,", "that uses both expletives and suggests a pretty extreme form", "individuals or groups offensive and warrant the deletion of an", "warned policy or do we want to be a little", "of times as being offensive. The flags require the diamond", "out individuals or groups offensive and warrant the deletion of", "decision. We can do nothing, delete the answer, or warn/suspend", "and suggests a pretty extreme form of student teacher interaction.", "you get warned policy or do we want to be", "or vulgar language) allowed on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we want", "an [answer (only viewable to 10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses both", "that do not single out individuals or groups offensive and", "on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we want a no nonsense you", "more relaxed? Are extreme views that do not single out", "suggests a pretty extreme form of student teacher interaction. This", "teacher interaction. This answer has been flagged a number of", "There was an [answer (only viewable to 10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that", "and may be against the rules: [Are expletives (cursing, swear", "10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses both expletives and suggests a pretty", "not appreciated on SE, and may be against the rules:", "extreme views that do not single out individuals or groups", "do not single out individuals or groups offensive and warrant", "or warn/suspend the user. Expletives are not appreciated on SE,", "curse you get warned policy or do we want to", "a pretty extreme form of student teacher interaction. This answer", "The flags require the diamond mods to make a decision.", "of student teacher interaction. This answer has been flagged a", "[answer (only viewable to 10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses both expletives", "sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we want a no nonsense you curse you", "a little more relaxed? Are extreme views that do not", "as being offensive. The flags require the diamond mods to", "a decision. We can do nothing, delete the answer, or", "do we want to be a little more relaxed? Are", "has been flagged a number of times as being offensive.", "a no nonsense you curse you get warned policy or", "may be against the rules: [Are expletives (cursing, swear words", "expletives and suggests a pretty extreme form of student teacher", "times as being offensive. The flags require the diamond mods", "We can do nothing, delete the answer, or warn/suspend the", "users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses both expletives and suggests a pretty extreme", "require the diamond mods to make a decision. We can", "the diamond mods to make a decision. We can do", "viewable to 10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses both expletives and suggests", "the rules: [Are expletives (cursing, swear words or vulgar language)", "to be a little more relaxed? Are extreme views that", "was an [answer (only viewable to 10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses", "the user. Expletives are not appreciated on SE, and may", "flagged a number of times as being offensive. The flags", "not single out individuals or groups offensive and warrant the", "pretty extreme form of student teacher interaction. This answer has", "This answer has been flagged a number of times as", "language) allowed on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we want a no", "SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we want a no nonsense you curse", "or groups offensive and warrant the deletion of an answer?", "(only viewable to 10k+ users)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26842/how-to-deal-with-a-student-who-harasses-the-inexperienced-teacher-during-class/26887#26887) that uses both expletives and", "number of times as being offensive. The flags require the", "offensive. The flags require the diamond mods to make a", "[Are expletives (cursing, swear words or vulgar language) allowed on", "relaxed? Are extreme views that do not single out individuals", "Do we want a no nonsense you curse you get", "to make a decision. We can do nothing, delete the", "nothing, delete the answer, or warn/suspend the user. Expletives are", "little more relaxed? Are extreme views that do not single", "Expletives are not appreciated on SE, and may be against", "appreciated on SE, and may be against the rules: [Are", "be against the rules: [Are expletives (cursing, swear words or", "views that do not single out individuals or groups offensive", "a number of times as being offensive. The flags require", "no nonsense you curse you get warned policy or do", "diamond mods to make a decision. We can do nothing,", "the answer, or warn/suspend the user. Expletives are not appreciated", "against the rules: [Are expletives (cursing, swear words or vulgar", "be a little more relaxed? Are extreme views that do", "user. Expletives are not appreciated on SE, and may be", "rules: [Are expletives (cursing, swear words or vulgar language) allowed", "answer, or warn/suspend the user. Expletives are not appreciated on", "been flagged a number of times as being offensive. The", "words or vulgar language) allowed on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we", "get warned policy or do we want to be a", "can do nothing, delete the answer, or warn/suspend the user.", "mods to make a decision. We can do nothing, delete", "do nothing, delete the answer, or warn/suspend the user. Expletives", "expletives (cursing, swear words or vulgar language) allowed on SE", "both expletives and suggests a pretty extreme form of student", "uses both expletives and suggests a pretty extreme form of", "(cursing, swear words or vulgar language) allowed on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites).", "policy or do we want to be a little more", "swear words or vulgar language) allowed on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do", "want to be a little more relaxed? Are extreme views", "nonsense you curse you get warned policy or do we", "allowed on SE sites?](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/22232/are-expletives-cursing-swear-words-or-vulgar-language-allowed-on-se-sites). Do we want a no nonsense", "Are extreme views that do not single out individuals or", "we want to be a little more relaxed? Are extreme", "we want a no nonsense you curse you get warned", "want a no nonsense you curse you get warned policy", "form of student teacher interaction. This answer has been flagged", "student teacher interaction. This answer has been flagged a number", "on SE, and may be against the rules: [Are expletives", "are not appreciated on SE, and may be against the", "SE, and may be against the rules: [Are expletives (cursing,", "extreme form of student teacher interaction. This answer has been", "delete the answer, or warn/suspend the user. Expletives are not", "single out individuals or groups offensive and warrant the deletion" ]
[ "the font name? ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link: [Why", "name? ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link: [Why aren't all", "know the font name? ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link:", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link: [Why aren't all research articles", "font name? ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link: [Why aren't", "anyone know the font name? ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link: [Why aren't all research", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link: [Why aren't all research articles on", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png) Reference link: [Why aren't all research articles on PubMed?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9044/why-arent-all-research-articles-on-pubmed)", "Does anyone know the font name? ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7YyO9.png)" ]
[ "questions asking for recommendations for specific programs and universities are", "instance, we could have a reason such as: > >", "> Shopping questions asking for recommendations for specific programs and", "have 3 custom off-topic close reasons, currently they are \"cannot", "\"undergraduate\", and \"specific advice\". If you want a new reason,", "> > Shopping questions asking for recommendations for specific programs", "reasons, currently they are \"cannot be generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and \"specific", "custom off-topic close reason along those lines? For instance, we", "reason such as: > > Shopping questions asking for recommendations", "have decided are off-topic, should we create a custom off-topic", "> > Note that we can only have 3 custom", "as: > > Shopping questions asking for recommendations for specific", "universities are considered off-topic on Academia.SE. > > > Note", "a custom off-topic close reason along those lines? For instance,", "decided are off-topic, should we create a custom off-topic close", "Academia.SE. > > > Note that we can only have", "those lines? For instance, we could have a reason such", "\"specific advice\". If you want a new reason, please also", "they are \"cannot be generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and \"specific advice\". If", "custom off-topic close reasons, currently they are \"cannot be generalized\",", "a reason such as: > > Shopping questions asking for", "of \"shopping questions\" that we have decided are off-topic, should", "Shopping questions asking for recommendations for specific programs and universities", "get a lot of \"shopping questions\" that we have decided", "asking for recommendations for specific programs and universities are considered", "are considered off-topic on Academia.SE. > > > Note that", "Given that we get a lot of \"shopping questions\" that", "want a new reason, please also mention which reason it", "for specific programs and universities are considered off-topic on Academia.SE.", "we create a custom off-topic close reason along those lines?", "can only have 3 custom off-topic close reasons, currently they", "recommendations for specific programs and universities are considered off-topic on", "that we have decided are off-topic, should we create a", "questions\" that we have decided are off-topic, should we create", "are \"cannot be generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and \"specific advice\". If you", "currently they are \"cannot be generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and \"specific advice\".", "lot of \"shopping questions\" that we have decided are off-topic,", "3 custom off-topic close reasons, currently they are \"cannot be", "\"cannot be generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and \"specific advice\". If you want", "be generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and \"specific advice\". If you want a", "that we get a lot of \"shopping questions\" that we", "If you want a new reason, please also mention which", "off-topic close reasons, currently they are \"cannot be generalized\", \"undergraduate\",", "and \"specific advice\". If you want a new reason, please", "off-topic close reason along those lines? For instance, we could", "specific programs and universities are considered off-topic on Academia.SE. >", "and universities are considered off-topic on Academia.SE. > > >", "should we create a custom off-topic close reason along those", "new reason, please also mention which reason it should replace/modify.", "could have a reason such as: > > Shopping questions", "off-topic on Academia.SE. > > > Note that we can", "on Academia.SE. > > > Note that we can only", "that we can only have 3 custom off-topic close reasons,", "Note that we can only have 3 custom off-topic close", "along those lines? For instance, we could have a reason", "you want a new reason, please also mention which reason", "a new reason, please also mention which reason it should", "advice\". If you want a new reason, please also mention", "close reason along those lines? For instance, we could have", "create a custom off-topic close reason along those lines? For", "such as: > > Shopping questions asking for recommendations for", "off-topic, should we create a custom off-topic close reason along", "for recommendations for specific programs and universities are considered off-topic", "we get a lot of \"shopping questions\" that we have", "we have decided are off-topic, should we create a custom", "are off-topic, should we create a custom off-topic close reason", "only have 3 custom off-topic close reasons, currently they are", "have a reason such as: > > Shopping questions asking", "reason along those lines? For instance, we could have a", "> > > Note that we can only have 3", "For instance, we could have a reason such as: >", "we could have a reason such as: > > Shopping", "considered off-topic on Academia.SE. > > > Note that we", "we can only have 3 custom off-topic close reasons, currently", "generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and \"specific advice\". If you want a new", "> Note that we can only have 3 custom off-topic", "programs and universities are considered off-topic on Academia.SE. > >", "a lot of \"shopping questions\" that we have decided are", "lines? For instance, we could have a reason such as:", "\"shopping questions\" that we have decided are off-topic, should we", "close reasons, currently they are \"cannot be generalized\", \"undergraduate\", and" ]
[ "be tagged \"advice\" under this definition. However, I am afraid", "all questions here ask about advice. [Some questions are tagged", "tag, we would be left with only a single valid", "reason. (Should I split this off into a separate meta", "for advice with \"advice\", i.e., that the tag will have", "aren't. I suggest that the \"advice\" tag is not useful", "\"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't. I suggest that the \"advice\" tag is", "be to explicitly define the \"advice\" tag as > >", "question about giving, requesting or receiving advice. > > >", "the tag will have a low signal-to-noise ratio. In addition,", "\"advice\" under this definition. However, I am afraid that many", "[personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for exactly the same reason. (Should I split", "of the tag, we would be left with only a", "tag, for exactly the same reason. (Should I split this", "definition. However, I am afraid that many users will nevertheless", "I would also propose deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for exactly", "any request for advice with \"advice\", i.e., that the tag", "with only a single valid instance. EDIT: And I would", "as > > This is a question about giving, requesting", "advice. [Some questions are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't. I suggest", "be left with only a single valid instance. EDIT: And", "I suggest that the \"advice\" tag is not useful and", "not useful and should be deleted. One alternative would be", "the same reason. (Should I split this off into a", "almost all questions here ask about advice. [Some questions are", "For instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be tagged \"advice\" under this", "giving advice, so after cleaning up useless instances of the", "tagged \"advice\" under this definition. However, I am afraid that", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be tagged \"advice\" under this definition. However,", "so after cleaning up useless instances of the tag, we", "instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be tagged \"advice\" under this definition.", "and should be deleted. One alternative would be to explicitly", "the \"advice\" tag is not useful and should be deleted.", "is not useful and should be deleted. One alternative would", "[Some questions are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't. I suggest that", "am afraid that many users will nevertheless tag any request", "also propose deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for exactly the same", "\"advice\", i.e., that the tag will have a low signal-to-noise", "instance. EDIT: And I would also propose deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice)", "tag will have a low signal-to-noise ratio. In addition, out", "be deleted. One alternative would be to explicitly define the", "advice. > > > For instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be", "currently tagged \"advice\", it seems like only the single one", "\"advice\", it seems like only the single one linked above", "requesting or receiving advice. > > > For instance, [this", "this definition. However, I am afraid that many users will", "low signal-to-noise ratio. In addition, out of the 17 questions", "> > This is a question about giving, requesting or", "propose deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for exactly the same reason.", "request for advice with \"advice\", i.e., that the tag will", "a low signal-to-noise ratio. In addition, out of the 17", "after cleaning up useless instances of the tag, we would", "suggest that the \"advice\" tag is not useful and should", "instances of the tag, we would be left with only", "or receiving advice. > > > For instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic)", "up useless instances of the tag, we would be left", "the \"advice\" tag as > > This is a question", "a question about giving, requesting or receiving advice. > >", "out of the 17 questions currently tagged \"advice\", it seems", "asks for advice about giving advice, so after cleaning up", "would also propose deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for exactly the", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be tagged \"advice\" under this definition. However, I", "should be deleted. One alternative would be to explicitly define", "ask about advice. [Some questions are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't.", "This is a question about giving, requesting or receiving advice.", "that the tag will have a low signal-to-noise ratio. In", "left with only a single valid instance. EDIT: And I", "would be to explicitly define the \"advice\" tag as >", "about advice. [Some questions are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't. I", "questions currently tagged \"advice\", it seems like only the single", "is a question about giving, requesting or receiving advice. >", "addition, out of the 17 questions currently tagged \"advice\", it", "(Should I split this off into a separate meta question?)", "would be left with only a single valid instance. EDIT:", "I am afraid that many users will nevertheless tag any", "only the single one linked above asks for advice about", "one linked above asks for advice about giving advice, so", "cleaning up useless instances of the tag, we would be", "giving, requesting or receiving advice. > > > For instance,", "useless instances of the tag, we would be left with", "single valid instance. EDIT: And I would also propose deleting", "\"advice\" tag is not useful and should be deleted. One", "here ask about advice. [Some questions are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some", "advice, so after cleaning up useless instances of the tag,", "questions are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't. I suggest that the", "for advice about giving advice, so after cleaning up useless", "a single valid instance. EDIT: And I would also propose", "deleted. One alternative would be to explicitly define the \"advice\"", "advice about giving advice, so after cleaning up useless instances", "linked above asks for advice about giving advice, so after", "users will nevertheless tag any request for advice with \"advice\",", "tag as > > This is a question about giving,", "tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't. I suggest that the \"advice\" tag", "receiving advice. > > > For instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could", "By definition, almost all questions here ask about advice. [Some", "are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice), some aren't. I suggest that the \"advice\"", "some aren't. I suggest that the \"advice\" tag is not", "it seems like only the single one linked above asks", "for exactly the same reason. (Should I split this off", "And I would also propose deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for", "17 questions currently tagged \"advice\", it seems like only the", "many users will nevertheless tag any request for advice with", "alternative would be to explicitly define the \"advice\" tag as", "> For instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be tagged \"advice\" under", "nevertheless tag any request for advice with \"advice\", i.e., that", "> > > For instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be tagged", "signal-to-noise ratio. In addition, out of the 17 questions currently", "like only the single one linked above asks for advice", "advice with \"advice\", i.e., that the tag will have a", "single one linked above asks for advice about giving advice,", "valid instance. EDIT: And I would also propose deleting the", "> This is a question about giving, requesting or receiving", "only a single valid instance. EDIT: And I would also", "the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for exactly the same reason. (Should I", "afraid that many users will nevertheless tag any request for", "will nevertheless tag any request for advice with \"advice\", i.e.,", "could be tagged \"advice\" under this definition. However, I am", "the single one linked above asks for advice about giving", "with \"advice\", i.e., that the tag will have a low", "i.e., that the tag will have a low signal-to-noise ratio.", "ratio. In addition, out of the 17 questions currently tagged", "explicitly define the \"advice\" tag as > > This is", "above asks for advice about giving advice, so after cleaning", "> > For instance, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16436/how-to-advise-a-student-looking-for-an-under-grad-thesis-topic) could be tagged \"advice\"", "that the \"advice\" tag is not useful and should be", "under this definition. However, I am afraid that many users", "tagged \"advice\", it seems like only the single one linked", "we would be left with only a single valid instance.", "definition, almost all questions here ask about advice. [Some questions", "However, I am afraid that many users will nevertheless tag", "deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag, for exactly the same reason. (Should", "the tag, we would be left with only a single", "will have a low signal-to-noise ratio. In addition, out of", "exactly the same reason. (Should I split this off into", "the 17 questions currently tagged \"advice\", it seems like only", "about giving advice, so after cleaning up useless instances of", "\"advice\" tag as > > This is a question about", "same reason. (Should I split this off into a separate", "of the 17 questions currently tagged \"advice\", it seems like", "In addition, out of the 17 questions currently tagged \"advice\",", "tag is not useful and should be deleted. One alternative", "seems like only the single one linked above asks for", "useful and should be deleted. One alternative would be to", "EDIT: And I would also propose deleting the [personal-advice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/personal-advice) tag,", "define the \"advice\" tag as > > This is a", "have a low signal-to-noise ratio. In addition, out of the", "about giving, requesting or receiving advice. > > > For", "questions here ask about advice. [Some questions are tagged \"advice\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/advice),", "that many users will nevertheless tag any request for advice", "tag any request for advice with \"advice\", i.e., that the", "One alternative would be to explicitly define the \"advice\" tag", "to explicitly define the \"advice\" tag as > > This" ]
[ "an open mind, and that there are plenty of jobs", "now, would be a perfect fit for that situation too).", "of keeping a close mind ...), and would be a", "and that there are plenty of jobs where you can", "I believe it's a good question, that attracted good answers.", "but hard (since it's quite hard to be a professional", "professional programmer). To be honest, I think it's a good", "at the same time, it's very general, I don't see", "OP (who is in high school), but wouldn't apply well", "that one should keep an open mind, and that there", "keeping a close mind ...), and would be a good", "question but can still be seen as interesting? If we", "instead of answering. If we forbid them, then we could", "like to know whether there is a possibility to live", "question, that attracted good answers. Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more", "is tired of his job, and would like to know", "a professional researcher working on topics similar to contest maths.", "becoming a professional programmer). To be honest, I think it's", "take the risk to become a discussion board, where everybody", "plenty of jobs where you can use critical thinking, citing", "live from something he enjoys doing (and the question, as", "general). In that regard, I believe it's a good question,", "answers, stating that (to sum up very briefly), it could", "of advice (but at the same time, it's very general,", "professional mathematician in general). In that regard, I believe it's", "My question is the following one: what should we do", "is not surprising, it's a good piece of advice). My", "a good piece of advice (but at the same time,", "up briefly) that one should keep an open mind, and", "that the advice applies well to the particular situation of", "very objective answer: is it possible to be a professional", "stating (again, summing up briefly) that one should keep an", "has been up voted several times (which is not surprising,", "to know whether there is a possibility to live from", "it's very general, I don't see someone giving the advice", "answers that do not answer directly the question but can", "been some good answers, stating that (to sum up very", "be seen as interesting? If we allow them, then we", "discuss the question instead of answering. If we forbid them,", "critical thinking, citing a specific example of a programmer (even", "answer: is it possible to be a professional researcher working", "mind ...), and would be a good comment, but it's", "it is now, would be a perfect fit for that", "job, and would like to know whether there is a", "hard (since it's quite hard to be a professional mathematician", "from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a very objective answer: is it", "This answer has been up voted several times (which is", "advice (but at the same time, it's very general, I", "For that particular example, it's worth mentioning that the advice", "too long to be a comment. This answer has been", "[this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more like a piece of advice, stating", "a specific example of a programmer (even though the OP", "to contest maths. There has been some good answers, stating", "it possible to be a professional researcher working on topics", "content. EDIT For that particular example, it's worth mentioning that", "I think it's a good piece of advice (but at", "more like a piece of advice, stating (again, summing up", "has been some good answers, stating that (to sum up", "advice, stating (again, summing up briefly) that one should keep", "up voted several times (which is not surprising, it's a", "programmer (even though the OP stated that he didn't fancy", "a 40 years old programmer who is tired of his", "think it's a good piece of advice (but at the", "possible to be a professional researcher working on topics similar", "thinking, citing a specific example of a programmer (even though", "attracted good answers. Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more like a", "still be seen as interesting? If we allow them, then", "question instead of answering. If we forbid them, then we", "forbid them, then we could lose some useful content. EDIT", "it's too long to be a comment. This answer has", "there are plenty of jobs where you can use critical", "working on topics similar to contest maths. There has been", "something he enjoys doing (and the question, as it is", "be a professional mathematician in general). In that regard, I", "topics similar to contest maths. There has been some good", "is it possible to be a professional researcher working on", "briefly) that one should keep an open mind, and that", "seen as interesting? If we allow them, then we take", "can still be seen as interesting? If we allow them,", "we do with answers that do not answer directly the", "good answers, stating that (to sum up very briefly), it", "though the OP stated that he didn't fancy becoming a", "good comment, but it's too long to be a comment.", "is in high school), but wouldn't apply well (at least,", "he didn't fancy becoming a professional programmer). To be honest,", "sum up very briefly), it could be possible, but hard", "a very objective answer: is it possible to be a", "possibility to live from something he enjoys doing (and the", "allow them, then we take the risk to become a", "school), but wouldn't apply well (at least, in my opinion)", "it's quite hard to be a professional mathematician in general).", "There has been some good answers, stating that (to sum", "don't see someone giving the advice of keeping a close", "own experience, and discuss the question instead of answering. If", "same time, it's very general, I don't see someone giving", "discussion board, where everybody comes to share their own experience,", "answer directly the question but can still be seen as", "a possibility to live from something he enjoys doing (and", "that attracted good answers. Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more like", "professional researcher working on topics similar to contest maths. There", "the ones from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a very objective answer:", "it's a good question, that attracted good answers. Now, [this", "it's a good piece of advice (but at the same", "whether there is a possibility to live from something he", "hard to be a professional mathematician in general). In that", "(since it's quite hard to be a professional mathematician in", "(who is in high school), but wouldn't apply well (at", "following one: what should we do with answers that do", "that regard, I believe it's a good question, that attracted", "Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a very objective answer: is it possible", "risk to become a discussion board, where everybody comes to", "a close mind ...), and would be a good comment,", "quite hard to be a professional mathematician in general). In", "would like to know whether there is a possibility to", "the same time, it's very general, I don't see someone", "doing (and the question, as it is now, would be", "be a professional researcher working on topics similar to contest", "who is tired of his job, and would like to", "of advice). My question is the following one: what should", "the OP (who is in high school), but wouldn't apply", "years old programmer who is tired of his job, and", "as interesting? If we allow them, then we take the", "piece of advice). My question is the following one: what", "possible, but hard (since it's quite hard to be a", "we allow them, then we take the risk to become", "some good answers, stating that (to sum up very briefly),", "...), and would be a good comment, but it's too", "it's a good piece of advice). My question is the", "keep an open mind, and that there are plenty of", "the advice applies well to the particular situation of the", "he enjoys doing (and the question, as it is now,", "EDIT For that particular example, it's worth mentioning that the", "directly the question but can still be seen as interesting?", "honest, I think it's a good piece of advice (but", "to share their own experience, and discuss the question instead", "a good comment, but it's too long to be a", "of answering. If we forbid them, then we could lose", "can use critical thinking, citing a specific example of a", "we forbid them, then we could lose some useful content.", "to live from something he enjoys doing (and the question,", "(to sum up very briefly), it could be possible, but", "that particular example, it's worth mentioning that the advice applies", "(again, summing up briefly) that one should keep an open", "that do not answer directly the question but can still", "the risk to become a discussion board, where everybody comes", "a discussion board, where everybody comes to share their own", "is more like a piece of advice, stating (again, summing", "one: what should we do with answers that do not", "see someone giving the advice of keeping a close mind", "situation of the OP (who is in high school), but", "advice of keeping a close mind ...), and would be", "his job, and would like to know whether there is", "opinion) to a 40 years old programmer who is tired", "up very briefly), it could be possible, but hard (since", "be a good comment, but it's too long to be", "piece of advice (but at the same time, it's very", "the question but can still be seen as interesting? If", "good piece of advice (but at the same time, it's", "piece of advice, stating (again, summing up briefly) that one", "high school), but wouldn't apply well (at least, in my", "solve problems like the ones from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a", "not surprising, it's a good piece of advice). My question", "well to the particular situation of the OP (who is", "giving the advice of keeping a close mind ...), and", "mathematician in general). In that regard, I believe it's a", "experience, and discuss the question instead of answering. If we", "(but at the same time, it's very general, I don't", "comment, but it's too long to be a comment. This", "in my opinion) to a 40 years old programmer who", "could be possible, but hard (since it's quite hard to", "some useful content. EDIT For that particular example, it's worth", "useful content. EDIT For that particular example, it's worth mentioning", "comment. This answer has been up voted several times (which", "is a possibility to live from something he enjoys doing", "maths. There has been some good answers, stating that (to", "good answers. Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more like a piece", "of jobs where you can use critical thinking, citing a", "[Do mathematics researchers regularly solve problems like the ones from", "to be a professional researcher working on topics similar to", "Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a very objective answer: is it possible to", "of the OP (who is in high school), but wouldn't", "a good piece of advice). My question is the following", "share their own experience, and discuss the question instead of", "programmer who is tired of his job, and would like", "but wouldn't apply well (at least, in my opinion) to", "close mind ...), and would be a good comment, but", "(at least, in my opinion) to a 40 years old", "it could be possible, but hard (since it's quite hard", "several times (which is not surprising, it's a good piece", "long to be a comment. This answer has been up", "and discuss the question instead of answering. If we forbid", "jobs where you can use critical thinking, citing a specific", "wouldn't apply well (at least, in my opinion) to a", "interesting? If we allow them, then we take the risk", "know whether there is a possibility to live from something", "If we allow them, then we take the risk to", "fancy becoming a professional programmer). To be honest, I think", "the question instead of answering. If we forbid them, then", "stating that (to sum up very briefly), it could be", "use critical thinking, citing a specific example of a programmer", "ones from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a very objective answer: is", "answer has been up voted several times (which is not", "researcher working on topics similar to contest maths. There has", "do not answer directly the question but can still be", "stated that he didn't fancy becoming a professional programmer). To", "like a piece of advice, stating (again, summing up briefly)", "a professional programmer). To be honest, I think it's a", "applies well to the particular situation of the OP (who", "voted several times (which is not surprising, it's a good", "their own experience, and discuss the question instead of answering.", "and would be a good comment, but it's too long", "example of a programmer (even though the OP stated that", "as it is now, would be a perfect fit for", "of advice, stating (again, summing up briefly) that one should", "time, it's very general, I don't see someone giving the", "that (to sum up very briefly), it could be possible,", "them, then we could lose some useful content. EDIT For", "of a programmer (even though the OP stated that he", "but it's too long to be a comment. This answer", "didn't fancy becoming a professional programmer). To be honest, I", "of his job, and would like to know whether there", "general, I don't see someone giving the advice of keeping", "in high school), but wouldn't apply well (at least, in", "very general, I don't see someone giving the advice of", "question, as it is now, would be a perfect fit", "surprising, it's a good piece of advice). My question is", "similar to contest maths. There has been some good answers,", "a comment. This answer has been up voted several times", "40 years old programmer who is tired of his job,", "do with answers that do not answer directly the question", "old programmer who is tired of his job, and would", "advice). My question is the following one: what should we", "but can still be seen as interesting? If we allow", "to become a discussion board, where everybody comes to share", "there is a possibility to live from something he enjoys", "believe it's a good question, that attracted good answers. Now,", "be possible, but hard (since it's quite hard to be", "be honest, I think it's a good piece of advice", "like the ones from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a very objective", "the OP stated that he didn't fancy becoming a professional", "then we could lose some useful content. EDIT For that", "you can use critical thinking, citing a specific example of", "would be a good comment, but it's too long to", "be a comment. This answer has been up voted several", "then we take the risk to become a discussion board,", "example, it's worth mentioning that the advice applies well to", "should we do with answers that do not answer directly", "I don't see someone giving the advice of keeping a", "them, then we take the risk to become a discussion", "mentioning that the advice applies well to the particular situation", "the particular situation of the OP (who is in high", "enjoys doing (and the question, as it is now, would", "a piece of advice, stating (again, summing up briefly) that", "citing a specific example of a programmer (even though the", "the question, as it is now, would be a perfect", "my opinion) to a 40 years old programmer who is", "been up voted several times (which is not surprising, it's", "it's worth mentioning that the advice applies well to the", "researchers regularly solve problems like the ones from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this)", "on topics similar to contest maths. There has been some", "answers. Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more like a piece of", "summing up briefly) that one should keep an open mind,", "tired of his job, and would like to know whether", "one should keep an open mind, and that there are", "mind, and that there are plenty of jobs where you", "is the following one: what should we do with answers", "If we forbid them, then we could lose some useful", "In that regard, I believe it's a good question, that", "particular example, it's worth mentioning that the advice applies well", "is now, would be a perfect fit for that situation", "(even though the OP stated that he didn't fancy becoming", "a programmer (even though the OP stated that he didn't", "OP stated that he didn't fancy becoming a professional programmer).", "briefly), it could be possible, but hard (since it's quite", "not answer directly the question but can still be seen", "where you can use critical thinking, citing a specific example", "(which is not surprising, it's a good piece of advice).", "to the particular situation of the OP (who is in", "should keep an open mind, and that there are plenty", "and would like to know whether there is a possibility", "question is the following one: what should we do with", "we take the risk to become a discussion board, where", "the following one: what should we do with answers that", "Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more like a piece of advice,", "specific example of a programmer (even though the OP stated", "To be honest, I think it's a good piece of", "regularly solve problems like the ones from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is more like a piece of advice, stating (again,", "mathematics researchers regularly solve problems like the ones from Project", "someone giving the advice of keeping a close mind ...),", "what should we do with answers that do not answer", "open mind, and that there are plenty of jobs where", "worth mentioning that the advice applies well to the particular", "a good question, that attracted good answers. Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102)", "(and the question, as it is now, would be a", "good question, that attracted good answers. Now, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/27685/102) is", "in general). In that regard, I believe it's a good", "to a 40 years old programmer who is tired of", "regard, I believe it's a good question, that attracted good", "good piece of advice). My question is the following one:", "times (which is not surprising, it's a good piece of", "are plenty of jobs where you can use critical thinking,", "to be a professional mathematician in general). In that regard,", "that he didn't fancy becoming a professional programmer). To be", "programmer). To be honest, I think it's a good piece", "apply well (at least, in my opinion) to a 40", "the advice of keeping a close mind ...), and would", "could lose some useful content. EDIT For that particular example,", "particular situation of the OP (who is in high school),", "lose some useful content. EDIT For that particular example, it's", "we could lose some useful content. EDIT For that particular", "become a discussion board, where everybody comes to share their", "with answers that do not answer directly the question but", "comes to share their own experience, and discuss the question", "problems like the ones from Project Euler?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27659/do-mathematics-researchers-regularly-solve-problems-like-this) asks a very", "a professional mathematician in general). In that regard, I believe", "well (at least, in my opinion) to a 40 years", "board, where everybody comes to share their own experience, and", "answering. If we forbid them, then we could lose some", "least, in my opinion) to a 40 years old programmer", "everybody comes to share their own experience, and discuss the", "objective answer: is it possible to be a professional researcher", "to be a comment. This answer has been up voted", "contest maths. There has been some good answers, stating that", "that there are plenty of jobs where you can use", "advice applies well to the particular situation of the OP", "very briefly), it could be possible, but hard (since it's", "from something he enjoys doing (and the question, as it", "asks a very objective answer: is it possible to be", "where everybody comes to share their own experience, and discuss" ]
[ "is there any benefit to tagging a question about an", "makes sense to tag a question about professors' salaries with", "and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions tagged 'university'\"). These tags convey meaningful", "what conditions questions should be tagged with certain very general", "the point of being meaningless. For example, is there any", "seems to me that without very specific guidelines for applying", "an authorship dispute between PhD students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions", "[professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"),", "with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"). But given that a", "between PhD students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students", "\"show questions tagged 'phd'\")? Can anyone offer specific guidelines on", "questions tagged 'university'\"). These tags convey meaningful information in certain", "general tags, such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students", "\"show questions tagged 'university'\"). These tags convey meaningful information in", "very general tags, such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"),", "with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged", "[students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged", "a huge portion of questions on this site involve students", "'phd'\")? Can anyone offer specific guidelines on how to apply", "tagged with certain very general tags, such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show", "[university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions tagged 'university'\"). These tags convey meaningful information", "that a huge portion of questions on this site involve", "this site involve students and/or professors doing something in a", "these and other very general tags so that they will", "tags convey meaningful information in certain situations; for example, it", "tagged 'professors'\"). But given that a huge portion of questions", "without very specific guidelines for applying these tags, they have", "and other very general tags so that they will be", "overused to the point of being meaningless. For example, is", "specific guidelines for applying these tags, they have the potential", "a university setting, it seems to me that without very", "I would like to clarify under what conditions questions should", "\"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions tagged 'university'\").", "authorship dispute between PhD students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged", "'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\")? Can anyone offer", "questions tagged 'phd'\")? Can anyone offer specific guidelines on how", "questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university", "professors doing something in a university setting, it seems to", "would like to clarify under what conditions questions should be", "dispute between PhD students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"),", "questions tagged 'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\")? Can", "and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\")? Can anyone offer specific", "These tags convey meaningful information in certain situations; for example,", "guidelines for applying these tags, they have the potential to", "tagging a question about an authorship dispute between PhD students", "doing something in a university setting, it seems to me", "to tagging a question about an authorship dispute between PhD", "under what conditions questions should be tagged with certain very", "like to clarify under what conditions questions should be tagged", "on this site involve students and/or professors doing something in", "students and/or professors doing something in a university setting, it", "question about professors' salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\").", "clarify under what conditions questions should be tagged with certain", "of questions on this site involve students and/or professors doing", "to tag a question about professors' salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show", "certain very general tags, such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged", "the potential to be overused to the point of being", "it makes sense to tag a question about professors' salaries", "in certain situations; for example, it makes sense to tag", "questions tagged 'professors'\"). But given that a huge portion of", "point of being meaningless. For example, is there any benefit", "for applying these tags, they have the potential to be", "on how to apply these and other very general tags", "to clarify under what conditions questions should be tagged with", "be tagged with certain very general tags, such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors", "something in a university setting, it seems to me that", "other very general tags so that they will be useful?", "to me that without very specific guidelines for applying these", "certain situations; for example, it makes sense to tag a", "meaningless. For example, is there any benefit to tagging a", "specific guidelines on how to apply these and other very", "being meaningless. For example, is there any benefit to tagging", "portion of questions on this site involve students and/or professors", "But given that a huge portion of questions on this", "questions on this site involve students and/or professors doing something", "[professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"). But given that a huge", "students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions", "a question about an authorship dispute between PhD students with", "sense to tag a question about professors' salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors", "Can anyone offer specific guidelines on how to apply these", "in a university setting, it seems to me that without", "'university'\"). These tags convey meaningful information in certain situations; for", "convey meaningful information in certain situations; for example, it makes", "about professors' salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"). But", "tags, such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show", "conditions questions should be tagged with certain very general tags,", "\"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\")?", "how to apply these and other very general tags so", "about an authorship dispute between PhD students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show", "tags, they have the potential to be overused to the", "very specific guidelines for applying these tags, they have the", "such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions", "guidelines on how to apply these and other very general", "[phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\")? Can anyone offer specific guidelines", "'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions", "any benefit to tagging a question about an authorship dispute", "tagged 'university'\"). These tags convey meaningful information in certain situations;", "applying these tags, they have the potential to be overused", "tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show", "tagged 'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\")? Can anyone", "[students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions tagged", "'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions tagged 'university'\"). These tags convey", "site involve students and/or professors doing something in a university", "there any benefit to tagging a question about an authorship", "questions should be tagged with certain very general tags, such", "tagged 'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions tagged 'university'\"). These tags", "to be overused to the point of being meaningless. For", "these tags, they have the potential to be overused to", "meaningful information in certain situations; for example, it makes sense", "me that without very specific guidelines for applying these tags,", "'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions", "to the point of being meaningless. For example, is there", "question about an authorship dispute between PhD students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors", "example, is there any benefit to tagging a question about", "setting, it seems to me that without very specific guidelines", "questions tagged 'students'\"), and [university](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/university \"show questions tagged 'university'\"). These", "tag a question about professors' salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions", "apply these and other very general tags so that they", "\"show questions tagged 'professors'\"). But given that a huge portion", "information in certain situations; for example, it makes sense to", "benefit to tagging a question about an authorship dispute between", "\"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and", "of being meaningless. For example, is there any benefit to", "PhD students with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show", "situations; for example, it makes sense to tag a question", "a question about professors' salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged", "'professors'\"). But given that a huge portion of questions on", "given that a huge portion of questions on this site", "and/or professors doing something in a university setting, it seems", "for example, it makes sense to tag a question about", "potential to be overused to the point of being meaningless.", "For example, is there any benefit to tagging a question", "it seems to me that without very specific guidelines for", "professors' salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"). But given", "involve students and/or professors doing something in a university setting,", "they have the potential to be overused to the point", "with certain very general tags, such as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions", "university setting, it seems to me that without very specific", "offer specific guidelines on how to apply these and other", "have the potential to be overused to the point of", "to apply these and other very general tags so that", "be overused to the point of being meaningless. For example,", "as [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged", "example, it makes sense to tag a question about professors'", "that without very specific guidelines for applying these tags, they", "questions tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd", "should be tagged with certain very general tags, such as", "tagged 'professors'\"), [students](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/students \"show questions tagged 'students'\"), and [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show", "anyone offer specific guidelines on how to apply these and", "huge portion of questions on this site involve students and/or", "tagged 'phd'\")? Can anyone offer specific guidelines on how to", "salaries with [professors](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/professors \"show questions tagged 'professors'\"). But given that" ]
[ "you're adding an answer to this post: Please answer with", "multiple pieces of advice, post multiple answers. This is so", "find Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting, and fun, and we welcome your", "free, community-driven Questions and Answers site for academics of all", "multiple answers. This is so that the community can vote", "community. Below, you'll find some information to help you get", "an answer to this post: Please answer with one single", "fields We hope you find Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting, and fun,", "a library of detailed answers to every question about academia.", "Much like academia itself, Academia.SE has some conventions and standards", "and the most important advice will rise to the top.", "that the community can vote separately on each item, and", "single* piece of advice per answer. If you have multiple", "contributions to the site. With your help, we're working together", "together to build a library of detailed answers to every", "With your help, we're working together to build a library", "your help, we're working together to build a library of", "that can be unfamiliar to new members of the community.", "If you're adding an answer to this post: Please answer", "--- If you're adding an answer to this post: Please", "interactions with this site a pleasant experience for you and", "item, and the most important advice will rise to the", "Answers site for academics of all levels - from aspiring", "with this site a pleasant experience for you and all", "adding an answer to this post: Please answer with one", "members of the community. Below, you'll find some information to", "of behavior that can be unfamiliar to new members of", "unfamiliar to new members of the community. Below, you'll find", "pieces of advice, post multiple answers. This is so that", "post multiple answers. This is so that the community can", "can vote separately on each item, and the most important", "This is so that the community can vote separately on", "so that the community can vote separately on each item,", "have multiple pieces of advice, post multiple answers. This is", "and professional students to senior researchers - as well as", "pleasant experience for you and all other users. --- If", "other users. --- If you're adding an answer to this", "aspiring graduate and professional students to senior researchers - as", "of all levels - from aspiring graduate and professional students", "Questions and Answers site for academics of all levels -", "this post: Please answer with one single* piece of advice", "of advice, post multiple answers. This is so that the", "acclimated and to make your interactions with this site a", "community-driven Questions and Answers site for academics of all levels", "we welcome your contributions to the site. With your help,", "Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting, and fun, and we welcome your contributions", "help you get acclimated and to make your interactions with", "each item, and the most important advice will rise to", "standards of behavior that can be unfamiliar to new members", "for academics of all levels - from aspiring graduate and", "working together to build a library of detailed answers to", "you and all other users. --- If you're adding an", "to senior researchers - as well as anyone in or", "post: Please answer with one single piece of advice per", "senior researchers - as well as anyone in or interested", "anyone in or interested in research-related or research-adjacent fields We", "some information to help you get acclimated and to make", "to new members of the community. Below, you'll find some", "and standards of behavior that can be unfamiliar to new", "to Academia.SE, the free, community-driven Questions and Answers site for", "answer to this post: Please answer with one single piece", "and to make your interactions with this site a pleasant", "advice, post multiple answers. This is so that the community", "to this post: Please answer with one single piece of", "this site a pleasant experience for you and all other", "you have multiple pieces of advice, post multiple answers. This", "enjoyable, interesting, and fun, and we welcome your contributions to", "your contributions to the site. With your help, we're working", "itself, Academia.SE has some conventions and standards of behavior that", "question about academia. Much like academia itself, Academia.SE has some", "to every question about academia. Much like academia itself, Academia.SE", "conventions and standards of behavior that can be unfamiliar to", "users. --- If you're adding an answer to this post:", "to the site. With your help, we're working together to", "you get acclimated and to make your interactions with this", "the free, community-driven Questions and Answers site for academics of", "information to help you get acclimated and to make your", "researchers - as well as anyone in or interested in", "of the community. Below, you'll find some information to help", "every question about academia. Much like academia itself, Academia.SE has", "of advice per answer. If you have multiple pieces of", "per answer. If you have multiple pieces of advice, post", "interesting, and fun, and we welcome your contributions to the", "about academia. Much like academia itself, Academia.SE has some conventions", "new members of the community. Below, you'll find some information", "interested in research-related or research-adjacent fields We hope you find", "If you have multiple pieces of advice, post multiple answers.", "site for academics of all levels - from aspiring graduate", "answers to every question about academia. Much like academia itself,", "build a library of detailed answers to every question about", "experience for you and all other users. --- If you're", "graduate and professional students to senior researchers - as well", "and all other users. --- If you're adding an answer", "you find Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting, and fun, and we welcome", "in or interested in research-related or research-adjacent fields We hope", "behavior that can be unfamiliar to new members of the", "you'll find some information to help you get acclimated and", "welcome your contributions to the site. With your help, we're", "make your interactions with this site a pleasant experience for", "is so that the community can vote separately on each", "to make your interactions with this site a pleasant experience", "in research-related or research-adjacent fields We hope you find Academia.SE", "all levels - from aspiring graduate and professional students to", "levels - from aspiring graduate and professional students to senior", "Below, you'll find some information to help you get acclimated", "of detailed answers to every question about academia. Much like", "to build a library of detailed answers to every question", "get acclimated and to make your interactions with this site", "site a pleasant experience for you and all other users.", "with one single piece of advice per answer. If you", "the community can vote separately on each item, and the", "well as anyone in or interested in research-related or research-adjacent", "all other users. --- If you're adding an answer to", "and we welcome your contributions to the site. With your", "piece of advice per answer. If you have multiple pieces", "We hope you find Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting, and fun, and", "or research-adjacent fields We hope you find Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting,", "as well as anyone in or interested in research-related or", "help, we're working together to build a library of detailed", "for you and all other users. --- If you're adding", "on each item, and the most important advice will rise", "academia itself, Academia.SE has some conventions and standards of behavior", "academics of all levels - from aspiring graduate and professional", "be unfamiliar to new members of the community. Below, you'll", "from aspiring graduate and professional students to senior researchers -", "research-related or research-adjacent fields We hope you find Academia.SE enjoyable,", "Academia.SE has some conventions and standards of behavior that can", "Academia.SE, the free, community-driven Questions and Answers site for academics", "your interactions with this site a pleasant experience for you", "find some information to help you get acclimated and to", "hope you find Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting, and fun, and we", "one single piece of advice per answer. If you have", "and fun, and we welcome your contributions to the site.", "some conventions and standards of behavior that can be unfamiliar", "fun, and we welcome your contributions to the site. With", "- from aspiring graduate and professional students to senior researchers", "answers. This is so that the community can vote separately", "as anyone in or interested in research-related or research-adjacent fields", "community can vote separately on each item, and the most", "vote separately on each item, and the most important advice", "detailed answers to every question about academia. Much like academia", "Welcome to Academia.SE, the free, community-driven Questions and Answers site", "library of detailed answers to every question about academia. Much", "research-adjacent fields We hope you find Academia.SE enjoyable, interesting, and", "answer with one single piece of advice per answer. If", "we're working together to build a library of detailed answers", "students to senior researchers - as well as anyone in", "to help you get acclimated and to make your interactions", "answer. If you have multiple pieces of advice, post multiple", "site. With your help, we're working together to build a", "like academia itself, Academia.SE has some conventions and standards of", "separately on each item, and the most important advice will", "and Answers site for academics of all levels - from", "has some conventions and standards of behavior that can be", "advice per answer. If you have multiple pieces of advice,", "the site. With your help, we're working together to build", "or interested in research-related or research-adjacent fields We hope you", "can be unfamiliar to new members of the community. Below,", "a pleasant experience for you and all other users. ---", "Please answer with one single piece of advice per answer.", "professional students to senior researchers - as well as anyone", "the community. Below, you'll find some information to help you", "academia. Much like academia itself, Academia.SE has some conventions and", "- as well as anyone in or interested in research-related" ]
[ "a moderator: > > > > > > What can", "self-respect. > > > The claim is that it does", "> > > > > > > > Your self-respect.", "[This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/28101/81) to [How is it in my best interest", "> The claim is that it does not provide an", "> > > > What can I lose if I", "not to submit a paper to two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was", "submit a paper to two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted by", "not provide an answer to the question. It clearly does", "deleted by a moderator: > > > > > >", "> > > > > > Your self-respect. > >", "to [How is it in my best interest not to", "provide an answer to the question. It clearly does provide", "I lose if I don’t adhere to this rule? >", "best interest not to submit a paper to two journals", "paper to two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted by a moderator:", "> > > > > > > > > Your", "simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted by a moderator: > > > >", "claim is that it does not provide an answer to", "> > What can I lose if I don’t adhere", "rule? > > > > > > > > >", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/28101/81) to [How is it in my best interest not", "> > > > > Your self-respect. > > >", "was deleted by a moderator: > > > > >", "> > > > > > What can I lose", "> > > > > What can I lose if", "is it in my best interest not to submit a", "by a moderator: > > > > > > What", "don’t adhere to this rule? > > > > >", "if I don’t adhere to this rule? > > >", "it in my best interest not to submit a paper", "> > The claim is that it does not provide", "that it does not provide an answer to the question.", "an answer to the question. It clearly does provide an", "> > > > Your self-respect. > > > The", "my best interest not to submit a paper to two", "I don’t adhere to this rule? > > > >", "interest not to submit a paper to two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous)", "moderator: > > > > > > What can I", "to two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted by a moderator: >", "can I lose if I don’t adhere to this rule?", "lose if I don’t adhere to this rule? > >", "What can I lose if I don’t adhere to this", "is that it does not provide an answer to the", "> Your self-respect. > > > The claim is that", "it does not provide an answer to the question. It", "> What can I lose if I don’t adhere to", "in my best interest not to submit a paper to", "adhere to this rule? > > > > > >", "[How is it in my best interest not to submit", "does not provide an answer to the question. It clearly", "two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted by a moderator: > >", "> > Your self-respect. > > > The claim is", "> > > What can I lose if I don’t", "The claim is that it does not provide an answer", "this rule? > > > > > > > >", "a paper to two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted by a", "> > > > > > > Your self-respect. >", "> > > Your self-respect. > > > The claim", "to this rule? > > > > > > >", "to submit a paper to two journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted", "Your self-respect. > > > The claim is that it", "answer to the question. It clearly does provide an answer.", "> > > The claim is that it does not", "journals simultaneously?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-is-it-in-my-best-interest-not-to-submit-a-paper-to-two-journals-simultaneous) was deleted by a moderator: > > >" ]
[ "no tag excerpt or wiki. All these tags seem to", "law and political sciences. > > > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions", "political science as an academic >discipline, and programs that lead", "academic >discipline, and programs that lead to a degree in", "these tags seem to be synonym and I think politics", "tag has no tag excerpt or wiki. All these tags", "questions > > Academic questions and answers about law and", "declared more or this also should be merged into the", "with excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions tagged 'political-science'\") with 4", "be declared more or this also should be merged into", "with 3 questions this tag has no tag excerpt or", "[politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions tagged 'politics'\") with 3 questions this tag", "\"show questions tagged 'law'\") with 11 questions > > Academic", "the difference of them and the law tag should be", "tag excerpt or wiki. All these tags seem to be", "[political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions tagged 'political-science'\") with 4 questions > >", "of them and the law tag should be declared more", "merged and the difference of them and the law tag", "questions tagged 'law'\") with 11 questions > > Academic questions", "questions tagged 'politics'\") with 3 questions this tag has no", "should be declared more or this also should be merged", "this field. > > > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\")", "the tags list and came to the following ones with", "law tag should be declared more or this also should", "to be synonym and I think politics and political-sciences should", "excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions tagged 'political-science'\") with 4 questions", "> Academic questions and answers about law and political sciences.", "questions > > On standards or conventions specific to political", "> On standards or conventions specific to political science as", "difference of them and the law tag should be declared", "science as an academic >discipline, and programs that lead to", "as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions tagged 'political-science'\") with 4 questions >", "> [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") with 11 questions >", "I think politics and political-sciences should merged and the difference", "specific to political science as an academic >discipline, and programs", "sciences. > > > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions tagged 'politics'\") with", "All these tags seem to be synonym and I think", "> > > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions tagged 'politics'\") with 3", "should merged and the difference of them and the law", "> [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions tagged 'politics'\") with 3 questions this", "this tag has no tag excerpt or wiki. All these", "with 4 questions > > On standards or conventions specific", "an academic >discipline, and programs that lead to a degree", ">discipline, and programs that lead to a degree in this", "lead to a degree in this field. > > >", "as an academic >discipline, and programs that lead to a", "more or this also should be merged into the previous", "questions this tag has no tag excerpt or wiki. All", "> > On standards or conventions specific to political science", "[law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") with 11 questions > >", "11 questions > > Academic questions and answers about law", "questions tagged 'political-science'\") with 4 questions > > On standards", "3 questions this tag has no tag excerpt or wiki.", "conventions specific to political science as an academic >discipline, and", "has no tag excerpt or wiki. All these tags seem", "tagged 'law'\") with 11 questions > > Academic questions and", "programs that lead to a degree in this field. >", "reviewing the tags list and came to the following ones", "and the law tag should be declared more or this", "and I think politics and political-sciences should merged and the", "> > Academic questions and answers about law and political", "think politics and political-sciences should merged and the difference of", "> > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions tagged 'politics'\") with 3 questions", "and came to the following ones with excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science", "tag should be declared more or this also should be", "\"show questions tagged 'political-science'\") with 4 questions > > On", "to a degree in this field. > > > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law", "about law and political sciences. > > > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show", "political sciences. > > > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions tagged 'politics'\")", "synonym and I think politics and political-sciences should merged and", "\"show questions tagged 'politics'\") with 3 questions this tag has", "I was reviewing the tags list and came to the", "'political-science'\") with 4 questions > > On standards or conventions", "politics and political-sciences should merged and the difference of them", "questions and answers about law and political sciences. > >", "was reviewing the tags list and came to the following", "wiki. All these tags seem to be synonym and I", "and the difference of them and the law tag should", "to political science as an academic >discipline, and programs that", "to the following ones with excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions", "or conventions specific to political science as an academic >discipline,", "degree in this field. > > > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions", "with 11 questions > > Academic questions and answers about", "standards or conventions specific to political science as an academic", "tagged 'political-science'\") with 4 questions > > On standards or", "> > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") with 11 questions", "and political-sciences should merged and the difference of them and", "tagged 'politics'\") with 3 questions this tag has no tag", "the law tag should be declared more or this also", "came to the following ones with excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show", "or wiki. All these tags seem to be synonym and", "or this also should be merged into the previous ones.", "and answers about law and political sciences. > > >", "tags seem to be synonym and I think politics and", "On standards or conventions specific to political science as an", "> > > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") with 11", "seem to be synonym and I think politics and political-sciences", "the following ones with excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions tagged", "list and came to the following ones with excerpts as:", "field. > > > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") with", "them and the law tag should be declared more or", "political-sciences should merged and the difference of them and the", "ones with excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions tagged 'political-science'\") with", "'law'\") with 11 questions > > Academic questions and answers", "excerpt or wiki. All these tags seem to be synonym", "4 questions > > On standards or conventions specific to", "Academic questions and answers about law and political sciences. >", "and political sciences. > > > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics \"show questions tagged", "'politics'\") with 3 questions this tag has no tag excerpt", "that lead to a degree in this field. > >", "following ones with excerpts as: [political-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/political-science \"show questions tagged 'political-science'\")", "tags list and came to the following ones with excerpts", "and programs that lead to a degree in this field.", "be synonym and I think politics and political-sciences should merged", "answers about law and political sciences. > > > [politics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/politics", "in this field. > > > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged", "a degree in this field. > > > [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show" ]
[ "consequences: * In many cases, it [causes the question to", "in the reopen review queue count as voting once in", "to the front page. If the edit makes the question", "it seems to me that it might be preferable to", "clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave Closed\" votes in the reopen", "help out with reviews. ~~Users can [only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions)", "for concern.~~ * If the user proposing the edit does", "to be reopened because they are shopping questions or one", "was closed? Is this a valid reason for rejecting suggested", "off-topic be edited for formatting, grammar, retagging, or other issues", "the help center. For example, * [this suggested edit of", "rather not bump these if we can avoid it. The", "edit didn't help resolve the issue that caused the question", "has been resolved. I am especially thinking of edits to", "again if it becomes necessary. Given that we currently have", "if the question is also, separately, edited to make it", "on any question. It's [not clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave", "until now we have not had a site policy on", "reviewers (since the question doesn't really need a review for", "However, it seems to me that it might be preferable", "it does, this means that by unnecessarily reviewing a question", "also demoralizing to reviewers, for the same reason; it's a", "going to be deleted, anyways. * Edits bump these posts", "bad to have many closed off-topic questions on the front", "been resolved. I am especially thinking of edits to posts", "be closed as off-topic. So, this creates unnecessary work for", "to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave Closed\" votes in the reopen review", "this question again if it becomes necessary. Given that we", "university for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) * [this edit of a programming", "these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is a cause for concern.~~ * If", "does not have enough reputation to apply edits unilaterally, then", "users' motivation to help out with reviews. * ~~Users can", "grammar, retagging, or other issues that don't resolve the reason", "especially thinking of edits to posts that are not likely", "this is a cause for concern.~~ * If the user", "other issues that don't resolve the reason the question was", "deleted, anyways. * Edits bump these posts to the front", "closed? Is this a valid reason for rejecting suggested edits?", "are closed for being off-topic be edited for formatting, grammar,", "on the front page; I'd rather not bump these if", "by unnecessarily reviewing a question following edits that don't resolve", "bump these if we can avoid it. The argument in", "a valid reason for rejecting suggested edits? The argument against", "a cause for concern.~~ * If the user proposing the", "reviews in the queue can decrease users' motivation to help", "user proposing the edit does not have enough reputation to", "edit to a \"Choose a university for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) ", "be pushed into the reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit didn't", "these formatting, grammar, or other edits only after* the issue", "queue count as voting once in the close direction. If", "concern.~~ * If the user proposing the edit does not", "who made these edits were doing anything wrong, since until", "to me that it might be preferable to do these", "the edit makes the question a candidate for reopening, that's", "the suggested edits review queue. This is also demoralizing to", "creates unnecessary work for reviewers (since the question doesn't really", "* [this suggested edit to a \"Choose a university for", "reviewing a question following edits that don't resolve the reason", "we currently have [fewer than 50 active users who can", "made these edits were doing anything wrong, since until now", "reopen review queue count as voting once in the close", "and it is then reopened. However, it seems to me", "the reason the question was closed? Is this a valid", "from voting to close this question again if it becomes", "review queue. This is also demoralizing to reviewers, for the", "page; I'd rather not bump these if we can avoid", "for being off-topic be edited for formatting, grammar, retagging, or", "seems to me that it might be preferable to do", "shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) [this suggested edit to a \"Choose a", "have many closed off-topic questions on the front page; I'd", "closed off-topic questions on the front page; I'd rather not", "the question doesn't really need a review for reopening at", "only after the issue that led to the closure has", "preferable to do these formatting, grammar, or other edits only", "[this suggested edit to a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) [this suggested", "a review for reopening at this point). Having unnecessary reviews", "are prevented from voting to close this question again if", "reopened. However, it seems to me that it might be", "reason for rejecting suggested edits? The argument against these edits", "I'd rather not bump these if we can avoid it.", "[only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each direction (close, reopen) on any", "edits? The argument against these edits is that they have", "listed in the help center. For example, * [this suggested", "reviews. * ~~Users can [only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each direction", "the question to be pushed into the reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue).", "than 50 active users who can cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this", "resolved. I am especially thinking of edits to posts that", "to make it on-topic, and it is then reopened. However,", "not bump these if we can avoid it. The argument", "that it might be preferable to do these formatting, grammar,", "be preferable to do these formatting, grammar, or other edits", "[fewer than 50 active users who can cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533),", "for closure, users are prevented from voting to close this", "argument against these edits is that they have several negative", "if we can avoid it. The argument in favor of", "issue that caused the question to be closed as off-topic.", "a question following edits that don't resolve the reason for", "we have not had a site policy on the matter.)", "to be closed as off-topic. So, this creates unnecessary work", "formatting, grammar, or other edits only after the issue that", "that led to the closure has been resolved. I am", "users who can cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is a cause", "that don't resolve the reason the question was closed? Is", "me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave Closed\" votes in the reopen review queue", "not, it looks bad to have many closed off-topic questions", "can decrease users' motivation to help out with reviews. ", "are going to be deleted, anyways. Edits bump these", "is that they may turn out to be useful if", "useful if the question is also, separately, edited to make", "that are going to be deleted, anyways. * Edits bump", "suggested edit of a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this suggested edit", "that's a good thing. But if not, it looks bad", "(close, reopen) on any question. It's [not clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire)", "can cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is a cause for concern.~~", "were doing anything wrong, since until now we have not", "rejecting suggested edits? The argument against these edits is that", "center. For example, * [this suggested edit of a shopping", "negative consequences: * In many cases, it [causes the question", "cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is a cause for concern.~~ ", "of a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting that users who made", "direction (close, reopen) on any question. It's [not clear to", "resolve the reason for closure, users are prevented from voting", "on-topic, and it is then reopened. However, it seems to", "if it becomes necessary. Given that we currently have [fewer", "or other edits only after* the issue that led to", "necessary. Given that we currently have [fewer than 50 active", "doing anything wrong, since until now we have not had", "posts that are not likely to be reopened because they", "question a candidate for reopening, that's a good thing. But", "doesn't really need a review for reopening at this point).", "pushed into the reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit didn't help", "are shopping questions or one of the other off topic", "unnecessary work for reviewers (since the question doesn't really need", "If the user proposing the edit does not have enough", "suggesting that users who made these edits were doing anything", "the reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit didn't help resolve the", "against these edits is that they have several negative consequences:", "questions that are going to be deleted, anyways. * Edits", "reopening, that's a good thing. But if not, it looks", "active users who can cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is a", "it will go into the suggested edits review queue. This", "question was closed? Is this a valid reason for rejecting", "candidate for reopening, that's a good thing. But if not,", "question again if it becomes necessary. Given that we currently", "will go into the suggested edits review queue. This is", "reopen) on any question. It's [not clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether", "it's a waste of effort for questions that are going", "in the queue can decrease users' motivation to help out", "may turn out to be useful if the question is", "me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) * [this edit of a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not", "don't resolve the reason the question was closed? Is this", "that by unnecessarily reviewing a question following edits that don't", "point). Having unnecessary reviews in the queue can decrease users'", "closure has been resolved. I am especially thinking of edits", "suggested edits? The argument against these edits is that they", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) * [this suggested edit to a \"Choose a university", "it is then reopened. However, it seems to me that", "that caused the question to be closed as off-topic. So,", "we can avoid it. The argument in favor of these", "edit of a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this suggested edit to", "looks bad to have many closed off-topic questions on the", "it becomes necessary. Given that we currently have [fewer than", "the user proposing the edit does not have enough reputation", "suggested edit to a \"Choose a university for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401)", "don't resolve the reason for closure, users are prevented from", "separately, edited to make it on-topic, and it is then", "to a \"Choose a university for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) * [this", "* In many cases, it [causes the question to be", "unilaterally, then it will go into the suggested edits review", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting that users who made these edits were", "other edits only after the issue that led to the", "a candidate for reopening, that's a good thing. But if", "good thing. But if not, it looks bad to have", "whether \"Leave Closed\" votes in the reopen review queue count", "many cases, it [causes the question to be pushed into", "if not, it looks bad to have many closed off-topic", "This is also demoralizing to reviewers, for the same reason;", "the question is also, separately, edited to make it on-topic,", "makes the question a candidate for reopening, that's a good", "be deleted, anyways. * Edits bump these posts to the", "that they have several negative consequences: * In many cases,", "page. If the edit makes the question a candidate for", "question doesn't really need a review for reopening at this", "the same reason; it's a waste of effort for questions", "anyways. * Edits bump these posts to the front page.", "unnecessarily reviewing a question following edits that don't resolve the", "edited to make it on-topic, and it is then reopened.", "of the other off topic questions listed in the help", "this a valid reason for rejecting suggested edits? The argument", "in each direction (close, reopen) on any question. It's [not", "is also demoralizing to reviewers, for the same reason; it's", "same reason; it's a waste of effort for questions that", "other off topic questions listed in the help center. For", "to be deleted, anyways. * Edits bump these posts to", "closed as off-topic. So, this creates unnecessary work for reviewers", "questions or one of the other off topic questions listed", "count as voting once in the close direction. If it", "help center. For example, * [this suggested edit of a", "of edits to posts that are not likely to be", "users who made these edits were doing anything wrong, since", "to close this question again if it becomes necessary. Given", "Having unnecessary reviews in the queue can decrease users' motivation", "into the suggested edits review queue. This is also demoralizing", "reason for closure, users are prevented from voting to close", "apply edits unilaterally, then it will go into the suggested", "in favor of these edits is that they may turn", "to the closure has been resolved. I am especially thinking", "For example, * [this suggested edit of a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714)", "really need a review for reopening at this point). Having", "votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is a cause for concern.~~ * If the", "off-topic. So, this creates unnecessary work for reviewers (since the", "am especially thinking of edits to posts that are not", "suggested edit to a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) * [this suggested edit", "a \"Choose a university for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) * [this edit", "Closed\" votes in the reopen review queue count as voting", "of effort for questions that are going to be deleted,", "edit to a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) [this suggested edit to", "* ~~Users can [only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each direction (close,", "with reviews. * ~~Users can [only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each", "edit makes the question a candidate for reopening, that's a", "it. The argument in favor of these edits is that", "as voting once in the close direction. If it does,", "questions listed in the help center. For example, * [this", "waste of effort for questions that are going to be", "for rejecting suggested edits? The argument against these edits is", "does, this means that by unnecessarily reviewing a question following", "the edit does not have enough reputation to apply edits", "decrease users' motivation to help out with reviews. * ~~Users", "The edit didn't help resolve the issue that caused the", "formatting, grammar, retagging, or other issues that don't resolve the", "have several negative consequences: * In many cases, it [causes", "the other off topic questions listed in the help center.", "programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting that users who made these edits", "the front page. If the edit makes the question a", "out with reviews. * ~~Users can [only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in", "bump these posts to the front page. If the edit", "So, this creates unnecessary work for reviewers (since the question", "If it does, this means that by unnecessarily reviewing a", "these if we can avoid it. The argument in favor", "in the close direction. If it does, this means that", "suggested edits review queue. This is also demoralizing to reviewers,", "Edits bump these posts to the front page. If the", "have [fewer than 50 active users who can cast these", "that don't resolve the reason for closure, users are prevented", "are not likely to be reopened because they are shopping", "because they are shopping questions or one of the other", "direction. If it does, this means that by unnecessarily reviewing", "that they may turn out to be useful if the", "edit does not have enough reputation to apply edits unilaterally,", "off-topic questions on the front page; I'd rather not bump", "posts to the front page. If the edit makes the", "a university for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) * [this edit of a", "a good thing. But if not, it looks bad to", "these posts to the front page. If the edit makes", "50 active users who can cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is", "the queue can decrease users' motivation to help out with", "unnecessary reviews in the queue can decrease users' motivation to", "edits that don't resolve the reason for closure, users are", "might be preferable to do these formatting, grammar, or other", "it looks bad to have many closed off-topic questions on", "* [this suggested edit to a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) * [this", "or other issues that don't resolve the reason the question", "grammar, or other edits only after the issue that led", "[not clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave Closed\" votes in the", "into the reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit didn't help resolve", "go into the suggested edits review queue. This is also", "not have enough reputation to apply edits unilaterally, then it", "be useful if the question is also, separately, edited to", "these edits is that they may turn out to be", "once in the close direction. If it does, this means", "close direction. If it does, this means that by unnecessarily", "as off-topic. So, this creates unnecessary work for reviewers (since", "each direction (close, reopen) on any question. It's [not clear", "resolve the issue that caused the question to be closed", "proposing the edit does not have enough reputation to apply", "to apply edits unilaterally, then it will go into the", "in the help center. For example, * [this suggested edit", "me that it might be preferable to do these formatting,", "shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this suggested edit to a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606)", "[this suggested edit to a \"Choose a university for me\"", "the issue that led to the closure has been resolved.", "many closed off-topic questions on the front page; I'd rather", "to reviewers, for the same reason; it's a waste of", "closure, users are prevented from voting to close this question", "review for reopening at this point). Having unnecessary reviews in", "need a review for reopening at this point). Having unnecessary", "thinking of edits to posts that are not likely to", "valid reason for rejecting suggested edits? The argument against these", "work for reviewers (since the question doesn't really need a", "edits to posts that are not likely to be reopened", "motivation to help out with reviews. * ~~Users can [only", "~~Users can [only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each direction (close, reopen)", "reopening at this point). Having unnecessary reviews in the queue", "likely to be reopened because they are shopping questions or", "or one of the other off topic questions listed in", "caused the question to be closed as off-topic. So, this", "questions that are closed for being off-topic be edited for", "they are shopping questions or one of the other off", "the reason for closure, users are prevented from voting to", "reopened because they are shopping questions or one of the", "then it will go into the suggested edits review queue.", "can avoid it. The argument in favor of these edits", "to be useful if the question is also, separately, edited", "the issue that caused the question to be closed as", "edits review queue. This is also demoralizing to reviewers, for", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this suggested edit to a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) ", "questions on the front page; I'd rather not bump these", "queue. This is also demoralizing to reviewers, for the same", "the front page; I'd rather not bump these if we", "do these formatting, grammar, or other edits only after* the", "cases, it [causes the question to be pushed into the", "for reopening at this point). Having unnecessary reviews in the", "to help out with reviews. * ~~Users can [only vote", "queue can decrease users' motivation to help out with reviews.", "they may turn out to be useful if the question", "becomes necessary. Given that we currently have [fewer than 50", "since until now we have not had a site policy", "also, separately, edited to make it on-topic, and it is", "If the edit makes the question a candidate for reopening,", "this point). Having unnecessary reviews in the queue can decrease", "then reopened. However, it seems to me that it might", "thing. But if not, it looks bad to have many", "help resolve the issue that caused the question to be", "question following edits that don't resolve the reason for closure,", "the reopen review queue count as voting once in the", "front page; I'd rather not bump these if we can", "voting once in the close direction. If it does, this", "retagging, or other issues that don't resolve the reason the", "for reviewers (since the question doesn't really* need a review", "to posts that are not likely to be reopened because", "a waste of effort for questions that are going to", "[this suggested edit of a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this suggested", "edits is that they have several negative consequences: * In", "for formatting, grammar, retagging, or other issues that don't resolve", "(Not suggesting that users who made these edits were doing", "have enough reputation to apply edits unilaterally, then it will", "question to be closed as off-topic. So, this creates unnecessary", "to have many closed off-topic questions on the front page;", "following edits that don't resolve the reason for closure, users", "one of the other off topic questions listed in the", "after* the issue that led to the closure has been", "* If the user proposing the edit does not have", "it might be preferable to do these formatting, grammar, or", "* [this edit of a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting that", "a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this suggested edit to a shopping", "votes in the reopen review queue count as voting once", "edits is that they may turn out to be useful", "this creates unnecessary work for reviewers (since the question doesn't", "edit of a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting that users who", "the question to be closed as off-topic. So, this creates", "It's [not clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave Closed\" votes in", "effort for questions that are going to be deleted, anyways.", "But if not, it looks bad to have many closed", "The argument in favor of these edits is that they", "not likely to be reopened because they are shopping questions", "at this point). Having unnecessary reviews in the queue can", "edits were doing anything wrong, since until now we have", "Is this a valid reason for rejecting suggested edits? The", "question is also, separately, edited to make it on-topic, and", "be reopened because they are shopping questions or one of", "out to be useful if the question is also, separately,", "didn't help resolve the issue that caused the question to", "topic questions listed in the help center. For example, ", "of these edits is that they may turn out to", "for reopening, that's a good thing. But if not, it", "of a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this suggested edit to a", "is that they have several negative consequences: * In many", "(since the question doesn't really need a review for reopening", "\"Choose a university for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) * [this edit of", "In many cases, it [causes the question to be pushed", "vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each direction (close, reopen) on any question.", "it on-topic, and it is then reopened. However, it seems", "these edits were doing anything wrong, since until now we", "a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) * [this suggested edit to a \"Choose", "closed for being off-topic be edited for formatting, grammar, retagging,", "means that by unnecessarily reviewing a question following edits that", "[causes the question to be pushed into the reopen review", "Given that we currently have [fewer than 50 active users", "enough reputation to apply edits unilaterally, then it will go", "issue that led to the closure has been resolved. I", "The argument against these edits is that they have several", "for the same reason; it's a waste of effort for", "is a cause for concern.~~ * If the user proposing", "that we currently have [fewer than 50 active users who", "to a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13606) * [this suggested edit to a", "once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each direction (close, reopen) on any question. It's", "users are prevented from voting to close this question again", "the close direction. If it does, this means that by", "any question. It's [not clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave Closed\"", "shopping questions or one of the other off topic questions", "voting to close this question again if it becomes necessary.", "is also, separately, edited to make it on-topic, and it", "for me\" question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) [this edit of a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions)", "review queue count as voting once in the close direction.", "who can cast these votes](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/edit/223533), this is a cause for", "to be pushed into the reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit", "demoralizing to reviewers, for the same reason; it's a waste", "led to the closure has been resolved. I am especially", "edits unilaterally, then it will go into the suggested edits", "reason the question was closed? Is this a valid reason", "for questions that are going to be deleted, anyways. ", "example, [this suggested edit of a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) ", "being off-topic be edited for formatting, grammar, retagging, or other", "these edits is that they have several negative consequences: ", "review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit didn't help resolve the issue that", "Should questions that are closed for being off-topic be edited", "wrong, since until now we have not had a site", "edited for formatting, grammar, retagging, or other issues that don't", "the closure has been resolved. I am especially thinking of", "that are not likely to be reopened because they are", "now we have not had a site policy on the", "several negative consequences: * In many cases, it [causes the", "avoid it. The argument in favor of these edits is", "anything wrong, since until now we have not had a", "be edited for formatting, grammar, retagging, or other issues that", "queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit didn't help resolve the issue that caused", "[this edit of a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting that users", "question to be pushed into the reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The", "reason; it's a waste of effort for questions that are", "off topic questions listed in the help center. For example,", "they have several negative consequences: * In many cases, it", "I am especially thinking of edits to posts that are", "edits only after the issue that led to the closure", "turn out to be useful if the question is also,", "cause for concern.~~ * If the user proposing the edit", "argument in favor of these edits is that they may", "front page. If the edit makes the question a candidate", "reputation to apply edits unilaterally, then it will go into", "this means that by unnecessarily reviewing a question following edits", "that users who made these edits were doing anything wrong,", "it [causes the question to be pushed into the reopen", "* [this suggested edit of a shopping question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13714) * [this", "the question was closed? Is this a valid reason for", "reopen review queue](https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/256567/which-edits-push-closed-questions-to-the-reopen-review-queue). The edit didn't help resolve the issue", "\"Leave Closed\" votes in the reopen review queue count as", "* Edits bump these posts to the front page. If", "currently have [fewer than 50 active users who can cast", "favor of these edits is that they may turn out", "a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting that users who made these", "that are closed for being off-topic be edited for formatting,", "prevented from voting to close this question again if it", "issues that don't resolve the reason the question was closed?", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/13401) * [this edit of a programming question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/25697/revisions) (Not suggesting", "to do these formatting, grammar, or other edits only after", "reviewers, for the same reason; it's a waste of effort", "the question a candidate for reopening, that's a good thing.", "can [only vote once](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/close-questions) in each direction (close, reopen) on", "is then reopened. However, it seems to me that it", "close this question again if it becomes necessary. Given that", "make it on-topic, and it is then reopened. However, it", "resolve the reason the question was closed? Is this a", "question. It's [not clear to me](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/239098/do-leave-closed-votes-in-reopen-queue-count-as-voting-once-in-the-close-dire) whether \"Leave Closed\" votes" ]
[ "the best way to handle this would be to edit", "assistance in writing questions that can apply to multiple people", "recently asked, I think the best way to handle this", "incorporate this specifically. I would propose to change the text", "recommendations for specific programs or universities are off-topic. For assistance", "to change the text of the tag as follows: >", "What kinds of questions are too localized? > > >", "edit the \"cannot be generalized\" tag to incorporate this specifically.", "for specific programs or universities are off-topic. For assistance in", "see: What kinds of questions are too localized? > >", "Based on the positive response to the [shopping closure tag", "would propose to change the text of the tag as", "off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that can apply to", "off-topic. In particular, \"shopping\" questions asking about recommendations for specific", "asking about recommendations for specific programs or universities are off-topic.", "the \"cannot be generalized\" tag to incorporate this specifically. I", "specifically. I would propose to change the text of the", "others in similar situations are off-topic. In particular, \"shopping\" questions", "\"cannot be generalized\" tag to incorporate this specifically. I would", "apply to multiple people facing similar situations, see: What kinds", "similar situations, see: What kinds of questions are too localized?", "this would be to edit the \"cannot be generalized\" tag", "situations are off-topic. In particular, \"shopping\" questions asking about recommendations", "tag as follows: > > Questions that cannot be generalized", "particular, \"shopping\" questions asking about recommendations for specific programs or", "would be to edit the \"cannot be generalized\" tag to", "In particular, \"shopping\" questions asking about recommendations for specific programs", "to multiple people facing similar situations, see: What kinds of", "that cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar", "about recommendations for specific programs or universities are off-topic. For", "in writing questions that can apply to multiple people facing", "cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations", "or universities are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that", "propose to change the text of the tag as follows:", "change the text of the tag as follows: > >", "as follows: > > Questions that cannot be generalized to", "I think the best way to handle this would be", "to apply to others in similar situations are off-topic. In", "the [shopping closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently asked, I think", "asked, I think the best way to handle this would", "For assistance in writing questions that can apply to multiple", "can apply to multiple people facing similar situations, see: What", "facing similar situations, see: What kinds of questions are too", "to handle this would be to edit the \"cannot be", "multiple people facing similar situations, see: What kinds of questions", "think the best way to handle this would be to", "questions asking about recommendations for specific programs or universities are", "questions that can apply to multiple people facing similar situations,", "be to edit the \"cannot be generalized\" tag to incorporate", "writing questions that can apply to multiple people facing similar", "\"shopping\" questions asking about recommendations for specific programs or universities", "to incorporate this specifically. I would propose to change the", "be generalized to apply to others in similar situations are", "similar situations are off-topic. In particular, \"shopping\" questions asking about", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently asked, I think the best way to", "that can apply to multiple people facing similar situations, see:", "I recently asked, I think the best way to handle", "to the [shopping closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently asked, I", "the positive response to the [shopping closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I", "way to handle this would be to edit the \"cannot", "apply to others in similar situations are off-topic. In particular,", "people facing similar situations, see: What kinds of questions are", "on the positive response to the [shopping closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag)", "[shopping closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently asked, I think the", "positive response to the [shopping closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently", "programs or universities are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions", "are off-topic. In particular, \"shopping\" questions asking about recommendations for", "are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that can apply", "universities are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that can", "this specifically. I would propose to change the text of", "best way to handle this would be to edit the", "response to the [shopping closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently asked,", "the tag as follows: > > Questions that cannot be", "of the tag as follows: > > Questions that cannot", "to others in similar situations are off-topic. In particular, \"shopping\"", "in similar situations are off-topic. In particular, \"shopping\" questions asking", "I would propose to change the text of the tag", "> Questions that cannot be generalized to apply to others", "the text of the tag as follows: > > Questions", "specific programs or universities are off-topic. For assistance in writing", "generalized\" tag to incorporate this specifically. I would propose to", "situations, see: What kinds of questions are too localized? >", "be generalized\" tag to incorporate this specifically. I would propose", "tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently asked, I think the best way", "> > Questions that cannot be generalized to apply to", "closure tag question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1178/should-we-create-a-shopping-question-closure-tag) I recently asked, I think the best", "handle this would be to edit the \"cannot be generalized\"", "generalized to apply to others in similar situations are off-topic.", "follows: > > Questions that cannot be generalized to apply", "Questions that cannot be generalized to apply to others in", "tag to incorporate this specifically. I would propose to change", "text of the tag as follows: > > Questions that", "to edit the \"cannot be generalized\" tag to incorporate this" ]
[ "a Coursera specialization be regarded in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2", "graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question 3: [How would a Coursera specialization", "OP edit it to highlight the difference from Question 2,", "X-Series Certificate from edx useful for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question", "vote it as a duplicate of Question 2, since Question", "CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) * Question 2: [Is an X-Series Certificate from edx", "I include the completion of Udacity and Coursera classes I", "think it's an exact duplicate of an existing question. I", "a duplicate of Question 1, since I don't think it", "exact duplicate of an existing question. I suggested that the", "since I think it's an exact duplicate of an existing", "an exact duplicate of Question 2. What to do now?", "it as a duplicate of Question 1, since I don't", "Suppose we have the following three questions: * Question 1:", "edx useful for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question 3: [How would", "of Question 1, since I don't think it is. I", "to vote it as a duplicate of Question 1, since", "[Can I include the completion of Udacity and Coursera classes", "difference from Question 2, but I still think it's fundamentally", "an existing question. I suggested that the OP edit it", "since Question 2 is itself a duplicate. And I don't", "* Question 1: [Can I include the completion of Udacity", "have the following three questions: * Question 1: [Can I", "However, I do not think it is an exact duplicate.", "long ago marked as a duplicate of Question 1. However,", "Certificate from edx useful for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question 3:", "What to do now? I don't want to vote it", "I don't think it is. I also don't want to", "it's an exact duplicate of an existing question. I suggested", "want to vote it as a duplicate of Question 1,", "And I don't want to leave it open, since I", "think it is. I also don't want to vote it", "I have attended in an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) * Question 2:", "Question 3: [How would a Coursera specialization be regarded in", "2, but I still think it's fundamentally the same question.", "regarded in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2 was long ago marked", "in an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) * Question 2: [Is an X-Series", "duplicate of Question 2, since Question 2 is itself a", "2: [Is an X-Series Certificate from edx useful for graduate", "since I don't think it is. I also don't want", "2, since Question 2 is itself a duplicate. And I", "edit it to highlight the difference from Question 2, but", "from Question 2, but I still think it's fundamentally the", "of Udacity and Coursera classes I have attended in an", "2 was long ago marked as a duplicate of Question", "in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2 was long ago marked as", "marked as a duplicate of Question 1. However, I do", "Question 1, since I don't think it is. I also", "for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question 3: [How would a Coursera", "a duplicate of Question 1. However, I do not think", "exact duplicate of Question 2. What to do now? I", "I do not think it is an exact duplicate. Question", "is. I also don't want to vote it as a", "Udacity and Coursera classes I have attended in an academic", "three questions: * Question 1: [Can I include the completion", "don't want to vote it as a duplicate of Question", "2 is itself a duplicate. And I don't want to", "the following three questions: * Question 1: [Can I include", "duplicate of an existing question. I suggested that the OP", "duplicate of Question 1. However, I do not think it", "vote it as a duplicate of Question 1, since I", "[Is an X-Series Certificate from edx useful for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school)", "duplicate. Question 3 was just asked, and I think it", "duplicate of Question 1, since I don't think it is.", "I think it's an exact duplicate of an existing question.", "exact duplicate. Question 3 was just asked, and I think", "Question 2, but I still think it's fundamentally the same", "to do now? I don't want to vote it as", "don't think it is. I also don't want to vote", "Question 1. However, I do not think it is an", "was long ago marked as a duplicate of Question 1.", "is an exact duplicate of Question 2. What to do", "Question 2: [Is an X-Series Certificate from edx useful for", "include the completion of Udacity and Coursera classes I have", "it to highlight the difference from Question 2, but I", "would a Coursera specialization be regarded in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question", "3 was just asked, and I think it is an", "the OP edit it to highlight the difference from Question", "I suggested that the OP edit it to highlight the", "have attended in an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) * Question 2: [Is", "a duplicate of Question 2, since Question 2 is itself", "it is an exact duplicate. Question 3 was just asked,", "* Question 2: [Is an X-Series Certificate from edx useful", "also don't want to vote it as a duplicate of", "I also don't want to vote it as a duplicate", "we have the following three questions: * Question 1: [Can", "to leave it open, since I think it's an exact", "to vote it as a duplicate of Question 2, since", "of an existing question. I suggested that the OP edit", "I think it is an exact duplicate of Question 2.", "open, since I think it's an exact duplicate of an", "just asked, and I think it is an exact duplicate", "an exact duplicate of an existing question. I suggested that", "duplicate of Question 2. What to do now? I don't", "[How would a Coursera specialization be regarded in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions)", "admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2 was long ago marked as a duplicate", "and Coursera classes I have attended in an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in)", "an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) * Question 2: [Is an X-Series Certificate", "itself a duplicate. And I don't want to leave it", "of Question 2. What to do now? I don't want", "Question 3 was just asked, and I think it is", "want to leave it open, since I think it's an", "existing question. I suggested that the OP edit it to", "asked, and I think it is an exact duplicate of", "3: [How would a Coursera specialization be regarded in graduate", "Coursera specialization be regarded in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2 was", "Coursera classes I have attended in an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) ", "do not think it is an exact duplicate. Question 3", "attended in an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) Question 2: [Is an", "academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) * Question 2: [Is an X-Series Certificate from", "I don't want to vote it as a duplicate of", "question. I suggested that the OP edit it to highlight", "duplicate. And I don't want to leave it open, since", "as a duplicate of Question 1, since I don't think", "be regarded in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2 was long ago", "highlight the difference from Question 2, but I still think", "useful for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question 3: [How would a", "ago marked as a duplicate of Question 1. However, I", "school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question 3: [How would a Coursera specialization be", "the difference from Question 2, but I still think it's", "and I think it is an exact duplicate of Question", "want to vote it as a duplicate of Question 2,", "classes I have attended in an academic CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in) * Question", "think it is an exact duplicate of Question 2. What", "it as a duplicate of Question 2, since Question 2", "a duplicate. And I don't want to leave it open,", "1. However, I do not think it is an exact", "leave it open, since I think it's an exact duplicate", "the completion of Udacity and Coursera classes I have attended", "is an exact duplicate. Question 3 was just asked, and", "do now? I don't want to vote it as a", "Question 2 is itself a duplicate. And I don't want", "2. What to do now? I don't want to vote", "don't want to leave it open, since I think it's", "from edx useful for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) * Question 3: [How", "Question 2 was long ago marked as a duplicate of", "it is an exact duplicate of Question 2. What to", "an X-Series Certificate from edx useful for graduate school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25951/is-an-x-series-certificate-from-edx-useful-for-graduate-school) ", "as a duplicate of Question 2, since Question 2 is", "is itself a duplicate. And I don't want to leave", "think it is an exact duplicate. Question 3 was just", "as a duplicate of Question 1. However, I do not", "I don't want to leave it open, since I think", "Question 1: [Can I include the completion of Udacity and", "it is. I also don't want to vote it as", "an exact duplicate. Question 3 was just asked, and I", "specialization be regarded in graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2 was long", "that the OP edit it to highlight the difference from", "following three questions: Question 1: [Can I include the", "questions: * Question 1: [Can I include the completion of", "now? I don't want to vote it as a duplicate", "to highlight the difference from Question 2, but I still", "completion of Udacity and Coursera classes I have attended in", "graduate admissions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28405/how-would-a-coursera-specialization-be-regarded-in-graduate-admissions) Question 2 was long ago marked as a", "Question 2. What to do now? I don't want to", "1, since I don't think it is. I also don't", "was just asked, and I think it is an exact", "of Question 2, since Question 2 is itself a duplicate.", "it open, since I think it's an exact duplicate of", "Question 2, since Question 2 is itself a duplicate. And", "1: [Can I include the completion of Udacity and Coursera", "of Question 1. However, I do not think it is", "* Question 3: [How would a Coursera specialization be regarded", "not think it is an exact duplicate. Question 3 was", "suggested that the OP edit it to highlight the difference" ]
[ "tags, and how should I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in the", "tags is a little vague for me. Could please give", "a little vague for me. Could please give me clear", "on how to choose correct tags in an easier way?", "entry in the help center; choosing best tags is a", "little vague for me. Could please give me clear clues", "for me. Could please give me clear clues on how", "vague for me. Could please give me clear clues on", "help center; choosing best tags is a little vague for", "Choosing good tags for questions is a little hard for", "please give me clear clues on how to choose correct", "how to choose correct tags in an easier way? Please", "Despite reading the [What are tags, and how should I", "in an easier way? Please provide examples in your answers.", "correct tags in an easier way? Please provide examples in", "questions is a little hard for me. Despite reading the", "in the help center; choosing best tags is a little", "should I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in the help center; choosing", "me clear clues on how to choose correct tags in", "best tags is a little vague for me. Could please", "are tags, and how should I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in", "good tags for questions is a little hard for me.", "for questions is a little hard for me. Despite reading", "Could please give me clear clues on how to choose", "reading the [What are tags, and how should I use", "choosing best tags is a little vague for me. Could", "is a little vague for me. Could please give me", "give me clear clues on how to choose correct tags", "clues on how to choose correct tags in an easier", "and how should I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in the help", "me. Could please give me clear clues on how to", "hard for me. Despite reading the [What are tags, and", "to choose correct tags in an easier way? Please provide", "a little hard for me. Despite reading the [What are", "the help center; choosing best tags is a little vague", "the [What are tags, and how should I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging)", "tags in an easier way? Please provide examples in your", "choose correct tags in an easier way? Please provide examples", "for me. Despite reading the [What are tags, and how", "center; choosing best tags is a little vague for me.", "use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in the help center; choosing best tags", "tags for questions is a little hard for me. Despite", "little hard for me. Despite reading the [What are tags,", "[What are tags, and how should I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry", "clear clues on how to choose correct tags in an", "them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in the help center; choosing best tags is", "me. Despite reading the [What are tags, and how should", "I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in the help center; choosing best", "how should I use them?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/tagging) entry in the help center;", "is a little hard for me. Despite reading the [What" ]
[ "how to minimize disruption when cleaning up tags as part", "at the same time: correct typos, remove incorrect tags, etc.", "[here on meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our tags are not in great", "great shape, to say the least. Big tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd", "when bumping an old post for retagging (or when someone", "I can think of to minimize disruption: * only bump", "same time: correct typos, remove incorrect tags, etc. This way,", "on some of these lately. Given that mass retags are", "comments or suggestions on how to minimize disruption when cleaning", "meta before anyone acts on them. But some (very small)", "\"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") are beyond the scope of this", "to regular operations on this site, I've been taking any", "posts when the front page (in 'active' view) doesn't already", "some (very small) tags lend themselves easily to cleanup with", "scope of this particular post, and need major discussion on", "like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions", "bump 5-6 old posts at a time * only bump", "the scope of this particular post, and need major discussion", "mass retags are very disruptive to regular operations on this", "any steps I can think of to minimize disruption: ", "that's wrong with the post at the same time: correct", "to say the least. Big tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions", "the same time: correct typos, remove incorrect tags, etc. This", "the post at the same time: correct typos, remove incorrect", "taking any steps I can think of to minimize disruption:", "bump it again* to fix something else. * fix tags", "old posts near the top. (i.e. don't everybody go on", "a few retags. I've been working on some of these", "fix everything else that's wrong with the post at the", "themselves easily to cleanup with just a few retags. I've", "'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") are beyond the", "go on tagging sprees at the same time) * when", "5-6 old posts at a time * only bump old", "been working on some of these lately. Given that mass", "in great shape, to say the least. Big tags like", "working on some of these lately. Given that mass retags", "acts on them. But some (very small) tags lend themselves", "retags are very disruptive to regular operations on this site,", "very disruptive to regular operations on this site, I've been", "fix something else. * fix tags on new questions immediately", "time * only bump old posts when the front page", "other comments or suggestions on how to minimize disruption when", "again to fix something else. * fix tags on new", "lend themselves easily to cleanup with just a few retags.", "operations on this site, I've been taking any steps I", "when someone else bumps an old post), fix everything else", "any other comments or suggestions on how to minimize disruption", "to fix something else. * fix tags on new questions", "tagged 'graduate-school'\") are beyond the scope of this particular post,", "tags on new questions immediately when they're asked. Does anyone", "page (in 'active' view) doesn't already have a bunch of", "else bumps an old post), fix everything else that's wrong", "discussion on meta before anyone acts on them. But some", "for retagging (or when someone else bumps an old post),", "before anyone acts on them. But some (very small) tags", "(very small) tags lend themselves easily to cleanup with just", "on tagging sprees at the same time) * when bumping", "on this site, I've been taking any steps I can", "questions immediately when they're asked. Does anyone have any other", "they're asked. Does anyone have any other comments or suggestions", "minimize disruption: * only bump 5-6 old posts at a", "a bunch of old posts near the top. (i.e. don't", "don't everybody go on tagging sprees at the same time)", "tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show", "this particular post, and need major discussion on meta before", "time: correct typos, remove incorrect tags, etc. This way, we", "it again to fix something else. * fix tags on", "disruption: * only bump 5-6 old posts at a time", "site, I've been taking any steps I can think of", "we won't have to bump it again to fix something", "This way, we won't have to bump it again to", "disruptive to regular operations on this site, I've been taking", "only bump old posts when the front page (in 'active'", "an old post), fix everything else that's wrong with the", "\"show questions tagged 'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\")", "been taking any steps I can think of to minimize", "some of these lately. Given that mass retags are very", "way, we won't have to bump it again to fix", "a time * only bump old posts when the front", "need major discussion on meta before anyone acts on them.", "this site, I've been taking any steps I can think", "questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") are beyond the scope of this particular", "view) doesn't already have a bunch of old posts near", "someone else bumps an old post), fix everything else that's", "on new questions immediately when they're asked. Does anyone have", "post for retagging (or when someone else bumps an old", "to cleanup with just a few retags. I've been working", "(or when someone else bumps an old post), fix everything", "tags, etc. This way, we won't have to bump it", "think of to minimize disruption: * only bump 5-6 old", "the front page (in 'active' view) doesn't already have a", "bunch of old posts near the top. (i.e. don't everybody", "tags are not in great shape, to say the least.", "easily to cleanup with just a few retags. I've been", "of old posts near the top. (i.e. don't everybody go", "that our tags are not in great shape, to say", "Given that mass retags are very disruptive to regular operations", "of to minimize disruption: * only bump 5-6 old posts", "retagging (or when someone else bumps an old post), fix", "with the post at the same time: correct typos, remove", "There has been general agreement [here on meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our", "few retags. I've been working on some of these lately.", "or suggestions on how to minimize disruption when cleaning up", "have any other comments or suggestions on how to minimize", "minimize disruption when cleaning up tags as part of small,", "when cleaning up tags as part of small, focused effort?", "has been general agreement [here on meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our tags", "steps I can think of to minimize disruption: * only", "same time) * when bumping an old post for retagging", "(i.e. don't everybody go on tagging sprees at the same", "them. But some (very small) tags lend themselves easily to", "everything else that's wrong with the post at the same", "are very disruptive to regular operations on this site, I've", "won't have to bump it again to fix something else.", "questions tagged 'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") are", "front page (in 'active' view) doesn't already have a bunch", "I've been taking any steps I can think of to", "say the least. Big tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged", "not in great shape, to say the least. Big tags", "old post), fix everything else that's wrong with the post", "But some (very small) tags lend themselves easily to cleanup", "anyone have any other comments or suggestions on how to", "Big tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school", "and need major discussion on meta before anyone acts on", "at a time * only bump old posts when the", "old post for retagging (or when someone else bumps an", "meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our tags are not in great shape, to", "can think of to minimize disruption: * only bump 5-6", "disruption when cleaning up tags as part of small, focused", "to minimize disruption: * only bump 5-6 old posts at", "everybody go on tagging sprees at the same time) ", "'graduate-school'\") are beyond the scope of this particular post, and", "wrong with the post at the same time: correct typos,", " fix tags on new questions immediately when they're asked.", "on how to minimize disruption when cleaning up tags as", "sprees at the same time) * when bumping an old", "Does anyone have any other comments or suggestions on how", "when they're asked. Does anyone have any other comments or", "incorrect tags, etc. This way, we won't have to bump", "top. (i.e. don't everybody go on tagging sprees at the", "agreement [here on meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our tags are not in", "that mass retags are very disruptive to regular operations on", "time) * when bumping an old post for retagging (or", "regular operations on this site, I've been taking any steps", "to bump it again to fix something else. * fix", "bumping an old post for retagging (or when someone else", "the top. (i.e. don't everybody go on tagging sprees at", "major discussion on meta before anyone acts on them. But", "immediately when they're asked. Does anyone have any other comments", "'active' view) doesn't already have a bunch of old posts", "the least. Big tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\")", "these lately. Given that mass retags are very disruptive to", "posts at a time * only bump old posts when", "tagging sprees at the same time) * when bumping an", "bumps an old post), fix everything else that's wrong with", "correct typos, remove incorrect tags, etc. This way, we won't", "bump old posts when the front page (in 'active' view)", "with just a few retags. I've been working on some", "on meta before anyone acts on them. But some (very", "near the top. (i.e. don't everybody go on tagging sprees", "of these lately. Given that mass retags are very disruptive", "posts near the top. (i.e. don't everybody go on tagging", "* when bumping an old post for retagging (or when", "retags. I've been working on some of these lately. Given", "etc. This way, we won't have to bump it again", "been general agreement [here on meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our tags are", "just a few retags. I've been working on some of", "fix tags on new questions immediately when they're asked. Does", "least. Big tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\") and", "shape, to say the least. Big tags like [phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show", "lately. Given that mass retags are very disruptive to regular", "tagged 'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") are beyond", "typos, remove incorrect tags, etc. This way, we won't have", "old posts when the front page (in 'active' view) doesn't", "have a bunch of old posts near the top. (i.e.", "post), fix everything else that's wrong with the post at", "else. * fix tags on new questions immediately when they're", "asked. Does anyone have any other comments or suggestions on", "* only bump 5-6 old posts at a time ", "to minimize disruption when cleaning up tags as part of", "anyone acts on them. But some (very small) tags lend", "on them. But some (very small) tags lend themselves easily", "of this particular post, and need major* discussion on meta", "cleanup with just a few retags. I've been working on", "[phd](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/phd \"show questions tagged 'phd'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged", "[graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") are beyond the scope of", "doesn't already have a bunch of old posts near the", "at the same time) * when bumping an old post", "small) tags lend themselves easily to cleanup with just a", "particular post, and need major discussion on meta before anyone", "only bump 5-6 old posts at a time * only", "suggestions on how to minimize disruption when cleaning up tags", "else that's wrong with the post at the same time:", "general agreement [here on meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our tags are not", "post, and need major discussion on meta before anyone acts", "(in 'active' view) doesn't already have a bunch of old", "tags lend themselves easily to cleanup with just a few", "post at the same time: correct typos, remove incorrect tags,", "and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") are beyond the scope", "are not in great shape, to say the least. Big", "already have a bunch of old posts near the top.", "remove incorrect tags, etc. This way, we won't have to", "the same time) * when bumping an old post for", "have to bump it again to fix something else. ", " only bump old posts when the front page (in", "something else. * fix tags on new questions immediately when", "new questions immediately when they're asked. Does anyone have any", "an old post for retagging (or when someone else bumps", "on meta](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1202/11365) that our tags are not in great shape,", "our tags are not in great shape, to say the", "beyond the scope of this particular post, and need major", "are beyond the scope of this particular post, and need", "I've been working on some of these lately. Given that", "when the front page (in 'active' view) doesn't already have", "old posts at a time * only bump old posts" ]
[ "that particular post, but about the practice in general. The", "the question is already on the front page? * Are", "to the front page? * Are these edits beneficial overall", "particular post, but about the practice in general. The question", "> to > > [Twitter](http://twitter.com) > > > There are", "overall when they cause an old post to be bumped", "several things to consider: * Are these edits beneficial overall", "I'm not asking about that particular post, but about the", "mention widely known sites by name, to make them \"clickable\"", "> There are several things to consider: * Are these", "about that particular post, but about the practice in general.", "Are these edits beneficial overall when they cause an old", "> > Twitter > > > to > > [Twitter](http://twitter.com)", "changing > > Twitter > > > to > >", "less than 2k rep, so that the edit will be", "2k rep, so that the edit will be queued and", "widely known sites by name, to make them \"clickable\" links.", "page? * Are these edits beneficial overall when the user", "by name, to make them \"clickable\" links. For example, changing", "[this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not asking about that particular post, but", "* Are these edits beneficial overall when the user making", "about the practice in general. The question is about editing", "I am raising this question in response to a comment", "be bumped to the front page? * Are these edits", "to a comment thread on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not asking", "bumped to the front page? * Are these edits beneficial", "when the user making them has less than 2k rep,", "> Twitter > > > to > > [Twitter](http://twitter.com) >", "rep, so that the edit will be queued and consume", "> > [Twitter](http://twitter.com) > > > There are several things", "they cause an old post to be bumped to the", "these edits beneficial overall when the question is already on", "question is already on the front page? * Are these", "post to be bumped to the front page? * Are", "to be bumped to the front page? * Are these", "in response to a comment thread on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm", "links. For example, changing > > Twitter > > >", "an old post to be bumped to the front page?", "already on the front page? * Are these edits beneficial", "these edits beneficial overall when they cause an old post", "> [Twitter](http://twitter.com) > > > There are several things to", "edits beneficial overall when the user making them has less", "cause an old post to be bumped to the front", "when the question is already on the front page? ", "to make them \"clickable\" links. For example, changing > >", "sites by name, to make them \"clickable\" links. For example,", "\"clickable\" links. For example, changing > > Twitter > >", "make them \"clickable\" links. For example, changing > > Twitter", "the user making them has less than 2k rep, so", "on the front page? Are these edits beneficial overall", "them has less than 2k rep, so that the edit", "known sites by name, to make them \"clickable\" links. For", "thread on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not asking about that particular", "Are these edits beneficial overall when the user making them", "beneficial overall when the question is already on the front", "For example, changing > > Twitter > > > to", "about editing posts that mention widely known sites by name,", "but about the practice in general. The question is about", "name, to make them \"clickable\" links. For example, changing >", "so that the edit will be queued and consume reviewer", "> > > to > > [Twitter](http://twitter.com) > > >", "not asking about that particular post, but about the practice", "is already on the front page? * Are these edits", "that mention widely known sites by name, to make them", "beneficial overall when the user making them has less than", "general. The question is about editing posts that mention widely", "the practice in general. The question is about editing posts", "to consider: * Are these edits beneficial overall when they", "when they cause an old post to be bumped to", "to > > [Twitter](http://twitter.com) > > > There are several", "beneficial overall when they cause an old post to be", "post, but about the practice in general. The question is", "them \"clickable\" links. For example, changing > > Twitter >", "* Are these edits beneficial overall when the question is", "raising this question in response to a comment thread on", "things to consider: * Are these edits beneficial overall when", "in general. The question is about editing posts that mention", "editing posts that mention widely known sites by name, to", "The question is about editing posts that mention widely known", "edits beneficial overall when they cause an old post to", "* Are these edits beneficial overall when they cause an", "response to a comment thread on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not", "Are these edits beneficial overall when the question is already", "front page? * Are these edits beneficial overall when the", "practice in general. The question is about editing posts that", "> > There are several things to consider: * Are", "[Twitter](http://twitter.com) > > > There are several things to consider:", "There are several things to consider: * Are these edits", "are several things to consider: * Are these edits beneficial", "asking about that particular post, but about the practice in", "old post to be bumped to the front page? ", "consider: Are these edits beneficial overall when they cause", "this question in response to a comment thread on [this", "page? * Are these edits beneficial overall when the question", "is about editing posts that mention widely known sites by", "the front page? * Are these edits beneficial overall when", "overall when the user making them has less than 2k", "comment thread on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not asking about that", "overall when the question is already on the front page?", "posts that mention widely known sites by name, to make", "these edits beneficial overall when the user making them has", "on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not asking about that particular post,", "am raising this question in response to a comment thread", "> > > There are several things to consider: *", "post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not asking about that particular post, but about", "> > to > > [Twitter](http://twitter.com) > > > There", "Twitter > > > to > > [Twitter](http://twitter.com) > >", "example, changing > > Twitter > > > to >", "has less than 2k rep, so that the edit will", "edits beneficial overall when the question is already on the", "a comment thread on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365). I'm not asking about", "user making them has less than 2k rep, so that", "question in response to a comment thread on [this post](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/24048/11365).", "making them has less than 2k rep, so that the", "that the edit will be queued and consume reviewer resources?", "question is about editing posts that mention widely known sites", "than 2k rep, so that the edit will be queued" ]
[ "synonym. Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag has", "> > This tag is related to the role and", "teaching assistant. > > > and is also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers", "'pedagogy'\") tag has been created and applied to 1 question.", "> > Should we have both tags, as they are", "> This tag is related to the role and duties", "and duties of a teacher, an academic instructor, tutor or", "applied to 1 question. Its wiki excerpt is: > >", "Its wiki excerpt is: > > Relates to the method", "the role and duties of a teacher, an academic instructor,", "> > > and is also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions", "been created and applied to 1 question. Its wiki excerpt", "a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag has been created", "tag is related to the role and duties of a", "questions tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag has been created and applied to", "and applied to 1 question. Its wiki excerpt is: >", "a synonym. Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag", "questions, with the following wiki excerpt: > > This tag", "Should we have both tags, as they are currently defined?", "related to the role and duties of a teacher, an", "tag has been created and applied to 1 question. Its", "questions tagged 'teaching'\") tag used on 265 questions, with the", "to the method and practice of teaching, especially as an", "> > and is also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions tagged", "method and practice of teaching, especially as an academic subject", "is: > > Relates to the method and practice of", "tutor or a teaching assistant. > > > and is", "[teaching](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teaching \"show questions tagged 'teaching'\") tag used on 265 questions,", "currently have a [teaching](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teaching \"show questions tagged 'teaching'\") tag used", "Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag has been", "have a [teaching](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teaching \"show questions tagged 'teaching'\") tag used on", "an academic subject or theoretical concept. > > > Should", "1 question. Its wiki excerpt is: > > Relates to", "instructor, tutor or a teaching assistant. > > > and", "excerpt: > > This tag is related to the role", "has been created and applied to 1 question. Its wiki", "especially as an academic subject or theoretical concept. > >", "as a synonym. Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions tagged 'pedagogy'\")", "and practice of teaching, especially as an academic subject or", "of a teacher, an academic instructor, tutor or a teaching", "duties of a teacher, an academic instructor, tutor or a", "'teaching'\") tag used on 265 questions, with the following wiki", "> > Relates to the method and practice of teaching,", "and is also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions tagged 'teachers'\") as", "academic instructor, tutor or a teaching assistant. > > >", "as an academic subject or theoretical concept. > > >", "[teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions tagged 'teachers'\") as a synonym. Now, a", "also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions tagged 'teachers'\") as a synonym.", "academic subject or theoretical concept. > > > Should we", "> and is also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions tagged 'teachers'\")", "with the following wiki excerpt: > > This tag is", "tag used on 265 questions, with the following wiki excerpt:", "a teacher, an academic instructor, tutor or a teaching assistant.", "the method and practice of teaching, especially as an academic", "[pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag has been created and", "wiki excerpt: > > This tag is related to the", "concept. > > > Should we have both tags, as", "or theoretical concept. > > > Should we have both", "questions tagged 'teachers'\") as a synonym. Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show", "of teaching, especially as an academic subject or theoretical concept.", "the following wiki excerpt: > > This tag is related", "has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions tagged 'teachers'\") as a synonym. Now,", "tagged 'teaching'\") tag used on 265 questions, with the following", "\"show questions tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag has been created and applied", "wiki excerpt is: > > Relates to the method and", "an academic instructor, tutor or a teaching assistant. > >", "'teachers'\") as a synonym. Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions tagged", "> > > Should we have both tags, as they", "a [teaching](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teaching \"show questions tagged 'teaching'\") tag used on 265", "is also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show questions tagged 'teachers'\") as a", "\"show questions tagged 'teaching'\") tag used on 265 questions, with", "> Relates to the method and practice of teaching, especially", "teaching, especially as an academic subject or theoretical concept. >", "following wiki excerpt: > > This tag is related to", "\"show questions tagged 'teachers'\") as a synonym. Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy", "used on 265 questions, with the following wiki excerpt: >", "> Should we have both tags, as they are currently", "assistant. > > > and is also has [teachers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teachers \"show", "teacher, an academic instructor, tutor or a teaching assistant. >", "Relates to the method and practice of teaching, especially as", "excerpt is: > > Relates to the method and practice", "a teaching assistant. > > > and is also has", "tagged 'teachers'\") as a synonym. Now, a [pedagogy](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/pedagogy \"show questions", "on 265 questions, with the following wiki excerpt: > >", "is related to the role and duties of a teacher,", "265 questions, with the following wiki excerpt: > > This", "tagged 'pedagogy'\") tag has been created and applied to 1", "practice of teaching, especially as an academic subject or theoretical", "subject or theoretical concept. > > > Should we have", "question. Its wiki excerpt is: > > Relates to the", "to the role and duties of a teacher, an academic", "role and duties of a teacher, an academic instructor, tutor", "theoretical concept. > > > Should we have both tags,", "This tag is related to the role and duties of", "created and applied to 1 question. Its wiki excerpt is:", "We currently have a [teaching](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/teaching \"show questions tagged 'teaching'\") tag", "to 1 question. Its wiki excerpt is: > > Relates", "or a teaching assistant. > > > and is also" ]
[ "for good quality research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question comes to", "to judge the reputation of a research group or professor", "professor for good quality research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question comes", "reading the [tag excerpt](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/reputation/info) about [reputation](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reputation \"show questions tagged 'reputation'\");", "influencing reputation. > > > it seems that this tag", "'reputation'\"); > > The perception of the quality of a", "journal, conference, or university > by a specific community or", "this question comes to mind that; ``` Does this tag", "question comes to mind that; ``` Does this tag cover", "edited and if it is allowed on the questions about", "the [tag excerpt](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/reputation/info) about [reputation](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reputation \"show questions tagged 'reputation'\"); >", "a specific community or the general public. Also: how reputation", "> it seems that this tag only covers questions about", "tag cover questions about persons too? ``` If it should", "cover questions about persons too? ``` If it should not", "used, the question should be edited and if it is", "conference, or university > by a specific community or the", "good quality research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question comes to mind", "not be used, the question should be edited and if", "Does this tag cover questions about persons too? ``` If", "should not be used, the question should be edited and", "question should be edited and if it is allowed on", "community or the general public. Also: how reputation > develops", "is allowed on the questions about people's reputation, we should", "``` If it should not be used, the question should", "reading a recent question about the reputation of individuals; [How", "[reputation](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reputation \"show questions tagged 'reputation'\"); > > The perception of", "or the general public. Also: how reputation > develops and", "and factors influencing reputation. > > > it seems that", "questions about reputation of journals and research institutes; all but", "PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question comes to mind that; ``` Does this", "institutes; all but individuals. By reading a recent question about", "but individuals. By reading a recent question about the reputation", "persons too? ``` If it should not be used, the", "university > by a specific community or the general public.", "develops and factors influencing reputation. > > > it seems", "of journals and research institutes; all but individuals. By reading", "The perception of the quality of a journal, conference, or", "questions tagged 'reputation'\"); > > The perception of the quality", "mind that; ``` Does this tag cover questions about persons", "on the questions about people's reputation, we should change this", "> develops and factors influencing reputation. > > > it", "quality of a journal, conference, or university > by a", "the general public. Also: how reputation > develops and factors", "the questions about people's reputation, we should change this tag's", "the reputation of a research group or professor for good", "the question should be edited and if it is allowed", "about the reputation of individuals; [How to judge the reputation", "general public. Also: how reputation > develops and factors influencing", "of the quality of a journal, conference, or university >", "questions about persons too? ``` If it should not be", "it seems that this tag only covers questions about reputation", "individuals. By reading a recent question about the reputation of", "excerpt](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/reputation/info) about [reputation](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reputation \"show questions tagged 'reputation'\"); > > The", "journals and research institutes; all but individuals. By reading a", "[tag excerpt](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/reputation/info) about [reputation](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reputation \"show questions tagged 'reputation'\"); > >", "questions about people's reputation, we should change this tag's excerpt.", "If it should not be used, the question should be", "perception of the quality of a journal, conference, or university", "> by a specific community or the general public. Also:", "specific community or the general public. Also: how reputation >", "tag only covers questions about reputation of journals and research", "if it is allowed on the questions about people's reputation,", "it is allowed on the questions about people's reputation, we", "[How to judge the reputation of a research group or", "> > The perception of the quality of a journal,", "> The perception of the quality of a journal, conference,", "about reputation of journals and research institutes; all but individuals.", "reputation of journals and research institutes; all but individuals. By", "of a journal, conference, or university > by a specific", "too? ``` If it should not be used, the question", "all but individuals. By reading a recent question about the", "how reputation > develops and factors influencing reputation. > >", "By reading a recent question about the reputation of individuals;", "for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question comes to mind that; ``` Does", "the reputation of individuals; [How to judge the reputation of", "reputation. > > > it seems that this tag only", "research institutes; all but individuals. By reading a recent question", "question about the reputation of individuals; [How to judge the", "and if it is allowed on the questions about people's", "allowed on the questions about people's reputation, we should change", "this tag only covers questions about reputation of journals and", "be used, the question should be edited and if it", "Also: how reputation > develops and factors influencing reputation. >", "reputation of individuals; [How to judge the reputation of a", "covers questions about reputation of journals and research institutes; all", "about [reputation](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reputation \"show questions tagged 'reputation'\"); > > The perception", "tagged 'reputation'\"); > > The perception of the quality of", "\"show questions tagged 'reputation'\"); > > The perception of the", "judge the reputation of a research group or professor for", "> > > it seems that this tag only covers", "the quality of a journal, conference, or university > by", "a journal, conference, or university > by a specific community", "By reading the [tag excerpt](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/reputation/info) about [reputation](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reputation \"show questions tagged", "research group or professor for good quality research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re)", "of a research group or professor for good quality research", "> > it seems that this tag only covers questions", "be edited and if it is allowed on the questions", "reputation of a research group or professor for good quality", "individuals; [How to judge the reputation of a research group", "only covers questions about reputation of journals and research institutes;", "that; ``` Does this tag cover questions about persons too?", "comes to mind that; ``` Does this tag cover questions", "or university > by a specific community or the general", "seems that this tag only covers questions about reputation of", "``` Does this tag cover questions about persons too? ```", "and research institutes; all but individuals. By reading a recent", "reputation > develops and factors influencing reputation. > > >", "about persons too? ``` If it should not be used,", "or professor for good quality research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question", "quality research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question comes to mind that;", "public. Also: how reputation > develops and factors influencing reputation.", "factors influencing reputation. > > > it seems that this", "to mind that; ``` Does this tag cover questions about", "of individuals; [How to judge the reputation of a research", "a research group or professor for good quality research for", "research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this question comes to mind that; ```", "it should not be used, the question should be edited", "group or professor for good quality research for PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/28827/how-to-judge-the-reputation-of-a-research-group-or-professor-for-good-quality-re) this", "this tag cover questions about persons too? ``` If it", "should be edited and if it is allowed on the", "that this tag only covers questions about reputation of journals", "a recent question about the reputation of individuals; [How to", "by a specific community or the general public. Also: how", "recent question about the reputation of individuals; [How to judge" ]
[ "They can read them and answer some of them. Some", "If somebody wants to reach the newest questions asked on", "such as tags, typos, etc and users may see them", "Could you please declare me, what harms can bumping older", "as well. ``` Could you please declare me, what harms", "list have to site? and what benefits has not-bumping to", "list of questions by editing them. If somebody wants to", "editing them. If somebody wants to reach the newest questions", "have older questions be bumped to the active list; some", "list; some of these questions have been inactive for more", "I can not understand what is wrong with bumping older", "the newest ones. I think it's a good feature to", "questions to the active questions list have to site? and", "questions by editing them. If somebody wants to reach the", "active questions list have to site? and what benefits has", "reach the newest questions asked on Academia, he can move", "them in the active list and edit them as well.", "can read them and answer some of them. Some of", "list and edit them as well. ``` Could you please", "to reach the newest questions asked on Academia, he can", "active list; some of these questions have been inactive for", "see them in the active list and edit them as", "older questions have problems such as tags, typos, etc and", "some of them. Some of these older questions have problems", "and read all the newest ones. I think it's a", "what harms can bumping older and inactive questions to the", "feature to have older questions be bumped to the active", "top active list of questions by editing them. If somebody", "``` Could you please declare me, what harms can bumping", "of newer users may have not read such questions. They", "read all the newest ones. I think it's a good", "Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and read all the newest ones. I think", "you please declare me, what harms can bumping older and", "all the newest ones. I think it's a good feature", "Some of these older questions have problems such as tags,", "on Academia, he can move to the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page", "a good feature to have older questions be bumped to", "of questions by editing them. If somebody wants to reach", "to the active list; some of these questions have been", "years. Most of newer users may have not read such", "inactive for more than one or two years. Most of", "these older questions have problems such as tags, typos, etc", "newest ones. I think it's a good feature to have", "please declare me, what harms can bumping older and inactive", "questions. They can read them and answer some of them.", "what is wrong with bumping older questions to the top", "may have not read such questions. They can read them", "tags, typos, etc and users may see them in the", "active list of questions by editing them. If somebody wants", "not understand what is wrong with bumping older questions to", "is wrong with bumping older questions to the top active", "edit them as well. ``` Could you please declare me,", "well. ``` Could you please declare me, what harms can", "two years. Most of newer users may have not read", "older and inactive questions to the active questions list have", "bumping older questions to the top active list of questions", "to have older questions be bumped to the active list;", "and edit them as well. ``` Could you please declare", "questions to the top active list of questions by editing", "than one or two years. Most of newer users may", "have problems such as tags, typos, etc and users may", "good feature to have older questions be bumped to the", "harms can bumping older and inactive questions to the active", "newest questions asked on Academia, he can move to the", "the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and read all the newest ones.", "Most of newer users may have not read such questions.", "to the top active list of questions by editing them.", "site? and what benefits has not-bumping to the Academia? ```", "read them and answer some of them. Some of these", "think it's a good feature to have older questions be", "older questions be bumped to the active list; some of", "questions be bumped to the active list; some of these", "typos, etc and users may see them in the active", "of these questions have been inactive for more than one", "asked on Academia, he can move to the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest)", "them as well. ``` Could you please declare me, what", "them and answer some of them. Some of these older", "may see them in the active list and edit them", "active list and edit them as well. ``` Could you", "declare me, what harms can bumping older and inactive questions", "for more than one or two years. Most of newer", "can move to the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and read all", "answer some of them. Some of these older questions have", "me, what harms can bumping older and inactive questions to", "older questions to the top active list of questions by", "newer users may have not read such questions. They can", "page and read all the newest ones. I think it's", "wants to reach the newest questions asked on Academia, he", "and inactive questions to the active questions list have to", "more than one or two years. Most of newer users", "in the active list and edit them as well. ```", "questions list have to site? and what benefits has not-bumping", "them. If somebody wants to reach the newest questions asked", "bumped to the active list; some of these questions have", "these questions have been inactive for more than one or", "have been inactive for more than one or two years.", "questions have problems such as tags, typos, etc and users", "wrong with bumping older questions to the top active list", "bumping older and inactive questions to the active questions list", "users may see them in the active list and edit", "he can move to the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and read", "etc and users may see them in the active list", "the active list; some of these questions have been inactive", "inactive questions to the active questions list have to site?", "can not understand what is wrong with bumping older questions", "or two years. Most of newer users may have not", "have to site? and what benefits has not-bumping to the", "by editing them. If somebody wants to reach the newest", "with bumping older questions to the top active list of", "questions have been inactive for more than one or two", "problems such as tags, typos, etc and users may see", "the newest questions asked on Academia, he can move to", "and users may see them in the active list and", "one or two years. Most of newer users may have", "[Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and read all the newest ones. I", "not read such questions. They can read them and answer", "the top active list of questions by editing them. If", "can bumping older and inactive questions to the active questions", "questions asked on Academia, he can move to the [Newest", "Academia, he can move to the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and", "it's a good feature to have older questions be bumped", "I think it's a good feature to have older questions", "to the active questions list have to site? and what", "the active list and edit them as well. ``` Could", "understand what is wrong with bumping older questions to the", "some of these questions have been inactive for more than", "them. Some of these older questions have problems such as", "of these older questions have problems such as tags, typos,", "ones. I think it's a good feature to have older", "somebody wants to reach the newest questions asked on Academia,", "of them. Some of these older questions have problems such", "and answer some of them. Some of these older questions", "read such questions. They can read them and answer some", "the active questions list have to site? and what benefits", "to site? and what benefits has not-bumping to the Academia?", "users may have not read such questions. They can read", "move to the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and read all the", "as tags, typos, etc and users may see them in", "such questions. They can read them and answer some of", "have not read such questions. They can read them and", "be bumped to the active list; some of these questions", "to the [Newest Questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions?sort=newest) page and read all the newest", "been inactive for more than one or two years. Most" ]
[ "it didn't seem particularly more situation-specific than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd", "the question, I'd like some feedback on my proposed changes.", "some schools having it in the CS department, and some", "the distinction between comp ling and NLP is pretty blurry,", "and NLP is pretty blurry, which is why I mention", "I also know that research in comp ling and NLP", "be reopened; since I clearly missed something when I was", "> > (Note: per [this question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction", "those four which is overall more necessary than the others?", "situation-specific than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like to improve the question", "off-topic for being too specific to my situation. I admit", "comp ling and NLP, and is there one field among", "research in computational linguistics or natural language processing? Which areas", "interdisciplinary and draw on various subfields of linguistics, computer science,", "NLP, and is there one field among those four which", "didn't seem particularly more situation-specific than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like", "admit I'm a little bit confused, since it didn't seem", "than the others? > > > (Note: per [this question", "seem particularly more situation-specific than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like to", "why I mention both in my question.) > > >", "for improvement, if this looks like a valid, on-topic question,", "looks like a valid, on-topic question, or if there's no", "particularly more situation-specific than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like to improve", "rough outline of how I would like to re-word the", "different departments at different schools, with some schools having it", "========================================================================= > > > I'm getting ready to enter graduate", "> > What background is necessary to do research in", "> > > I'm getting ready to enter graduate school,", "> > > Ideally, what background knowledge should someone have", "with some schools having it in the CS department, and", "which was closed as off-topic for being too specific to", "> I'd like to know if there's any more room", "CS department, and some in the linguistics department. > >", "changes. Here's a rough outline of how I would like", "getting ready to enter graduate school, and I would like", "being too specific to my situation. I admit I'm a", "linguistics department. > > > Ideally, what background knowledge should", "and statistics are necessary or helpful in studying comp ling", "the CS department, and some in the linguistics department. >", "any more room for improvement, if this looks like a", "having it in the CS department, and some in the", "linguistics and natural language processing. I know that these two", "ling and NLP is pretty blurry, which is why I", "for being too specific to my situation. I admit I'm", "question, I'd like some feedback on my proposed changes. Here's", "necessary than the others? > > > (Note: per [this", "> ========================================================================= > > > I'm getting ready to enter", "I'd like to know if there's any more room for", "specific to my situation. I admit I'm a little bit", "computer science, math, and statistics. I also know that research", "are necessary or helpful in studying comp ling and NLP,", "the others? > > > (Note: per [this question from", "at different schools, with some schools having it in the", "of how I would like to re-word the question: >", "bit confused, since it didn't seem particularly more situation-specific than", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like to improve the question by generalizing it", "I would like to re-word the question: > > What", "processing. I know that these two fields are very interdisciplinary", "natural language processing. I know that these two fields are", "statistics. I also know that research in comp ling and", "to enter graduate school, and I would like to do", "mention both in my question.) > > > I'd like", "distinction between comp ling and NLP is pretty blurry, which", "both in my question.) > > > I'd like to", "like to re-word the question: > > What background is", "> I'm getting ready to enter graduate school, and I", "draw on various subfields of linguistics, computer science, math, and", "subfields of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics. I also", "was writing the question, I'd like some feedback on my", "computational linguistics? > ========================================================================= > > > I'm getting ready", "of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics. I also know", "also know that research in comp ling and NLP is", "on various subfields of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics.", "statistics are necessary or helpful in studying comp ling and", "it so it can be reopened; since I clearly missed", "are very interdisciplinary and draw on various subfields of linguistics,", "ling and NLP is done in different departments at different", "knowledge should someone have in order to do research in", "on-topic question, or if there's no saving this question and", "or if there's no saving this question and I should", "like to improve the question by generalizing it so it", "> Ideally, what background knowledge should someone have in order", "departments at different schools, with some schools having it in", "per [this question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction between comp ling", "department, and some in the linguistics department. > > >", "> > > (Note: per [this question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the", "(Note: per [this question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction between comp", "closed as off-topic for being too specific to my situation.", "school, and I would like to do PhD-level research in", "should someone have in order to do research in computational", "there's no saving this question and I should delete it.", "I'd like to improve the question by generalizing it so", "that research in comp ling and NLP is done in", "recently posted [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29122/i-want-to-study-computational-linguistics-and-nlp-which-program-to-enter), which was closed as off-topic for", "in computational linguistics and natural language processing. I know that", "is pretty blurry, which is why I mention both in", "research in computational linguistics and natural language processing. I know", "and some in the linguistics department. > > > Ideally,", "and NLP is done in different departments at different schools,", "very interdisciplinary and draw on various subfields of linguistics, computer", "something when I was writing the question, I'd like some", "others? > > > (Note: per [this question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com),", "[this question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction between comp ling and", "a little bit confused, since it didn't seem particularly more", "so it can be reopened; since I clearly missed something", "since it didn't seem particularly more situation-specific than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1).", "I was writing the question, I'd like some feedback on", "in computational linguistics? > ========================================================================= > > > I'm getting", "graduate school, and I would like to do PhD-level research", "do PhD-level research in computational linguistics and natural language processing.", "ling and NLP, and is there one field among those", "like to know if there's any more room for improvement,", "Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction between comp ling and NLP is pretty", "Here's a rough outline of how I would like to", "my situation. I admit I'm a little bit confused, since", "comp ling and NLP is done in different departments at", "situation. I admit I'm a little bit confused, since it", "to my situation. I admit I'm a little bit confused,", "comp ling and NLP is pretty blurry, which is why", "a valid, on-topic question, or if there's no saving this", "posted [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29122/i-want-to-study-computational-linguistics-and-nlp-which-program-to-enter), which was closed as off-topic for being", "missed something when I was writing the question, I'd like", "I'm a little bit confused, since it didn't seem particularly", "ready to enter graduate school, and I would like to", "language processing? Which areas of linguistics, computer science, math, and", "know that these two fields are very interdisciplinary and draw", "room for improvement, if this looks like a valid, on-topic", "science, math, and statistics are necessary or helpful in studying", "more necessary than the others? > > > (Note: per", "clearly missed something when I was writing the question, I'd", "in my question.) > > > I'd like to know", "on my proposed changes. Here's a rough outline of how", "when I was writing the question, I'd like some feedback", "more situation-specific than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like to improve the", "in comp ling and NLP is done in different departments", "I mention both in my question.) > > > I'd", "is necessary to do research in computational linguistics? > =========================================================================", "> > I'd like to know if there's any more", "among those four which is overall more necessary than the", "necessary to do research in computational linguistics? > ========================================================================= >", "the linguistics department. > > > Ideally, what background knowledge", "language processing. I know that these two fields are very", "in computational linguistics or natural language processing? Which areas of", "question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction between comp ling and NLP", "Ideally, what background knowledge should someone have in order to", "of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics are necessary or", "processing? Which areas of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics", "I would like to do PhD-level research in computational linguistics", "necessary or helpful in studying comp ling and NLP, and", "there one field among those four which is overall more", "is overall more necessary than the others? > > >", "if there's no saving this question and I should delete", "research in comp ling and NLP is done in different", "question, or if there's no saving this question and I", "proposed changes. Here's a rough outline of how I would", "I recently posted [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29122/i-want-to-study-computational-linguistics-and-nlp-which-program-to-enter), which was closed as off-topic", "done in different departments at different schools, with some schools", "a rough outline of how I would like to re-word", "NLP is done in different departments at different schools, with", "do research in computational linguistics or natural language processing? Which", "different schools, with some schools having it in the CS", "was closed as off-topic for being too specific to my", "schools, with some schools having it in the CS department,", "in order to do research in computational linguistics or natural", "is there one field among those four which is overall", "know that research in comp ling and NLP is done", "and draw on various subfields of linguistics, computer science, math,", "what background knowledge should someone have in order to do", "pretty blurry, which is why I mention both in my", "know if there's any more room for improvement, if this", "> What background is necessary to do research in computational", "do research in computational linguistics? > ========================================================================= > > >", "I clearly missed something when I was writing the question,", "I'd like some feedback on my proposed changes. Here's a", "one field among those four which is overall more necessary", "and natural language processing. I know that these two fields", "linguistics or natural language processing? Which areas of linguistics, computer", "in studying comp ling and NLP, and is there one", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29122/i-want-to-study-computational-linguistics-and-nlp-which-program-to-enter), which was closed as off-topic for being too specific", "that these two fields are very interdisciplinary and draw on", "> > I'm getting ready to enter graduate school, and", "I'm getting ready to enter graduate school, and I would", "if there's any more room for improvement, if this looks", "generalizing it so it can be reopened; since I clearly", "improvement, if this looks like a valid, on-topic question, or", "outline of how I would like to re-word the question:", "like some feedback on my proposed changes. Here's a rough", "which is overall more necessary than the others? > >", "to re-word the question: > > What background is necessary", "valid, on-topic question, or if there's no saving this question", "as off-topic for being too specific to my situation. I", "computational linguistics and natural language processing. I know that these", "or natural language processing? Which areas of linguistics, computer science,", "studying comp ling and NLP, and is there one field", "confused, since it didn't seem particularly more situation-specific than [this", "it can be reopened; since I clearly missed something when", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like to improve the question by generalizing", "What background is necessary to do research in computational linguistics?", "background is necessary to do research in computational linguistics? >", "research in computational linguistics? > ========================================================================= > > > I'm", "order to do research in computational linguistics or natural language", "more room for improvement, if this looks like a valid,", "if this looks like a valid, on-topic question, or if", "some feedback on my proposed changes. Here's a rough outline", "to do research in computational linguistics or natural language processing?", "feedback on my proposed changes. Here's a rough outline of", "to know if there's any more room for improvement, if", "field among those four which is overall more necessary than", "would like to do PhD-level research in computational linguistics and", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29122/i-want-to-study-computational-linguistics-and-nlp-which-program-to-enter), which was closed as off-topic for being too", "is done in different departments at different schools, with some", "> > Ideally, what background knowledge should someone have in", "PhD-level research in computational linguistics and natural language processing. I", "re-word the question: > > What background is necessary to", "the question: > > What background is necessary to do", "someone have in order to do research in computational linguistics", "computational linguistics or natural language processing? Which areas of linguistics,", "or helpful in studying comp ling and NLP, and is", "than [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17780/my-plan-to-get-into-a-cs-phd-program?lq=1). I'd like to improve the question by", "department. > > > Ideally, what background knowledge should someone", "is why I mention both in my question.) > >", "to do research in computational linguistics? > ========================================================================= > >", "it in the CS department, and some in the linguistics", "and NLP, and is there one field among those four", "fields are very interdisciplinary and draw on various subfields of", "question.) > > > I'd like to know if there's", "little bit confused, since it didn't seem particularly more situation-specific", "between comp ling and NLP is pretty blurry, which is", "and is there one field among those four which is", "NLP is pretty blurry, which is why I mention both", "overall more necessary than the others? > > > (Note:", "to do PhD-level research in computational linguistics and natural language", "my proposed changes. Here's a rough outline of how I", "like to do PhD-level research in computational linguistics and natural", "these two fields are very interdisciplinary and draw on various", "have in order to do research in computational linguistics or", "would like to re-word the question: > > What background", "> (Note: per [this question from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction between", "too specific to my situation. I admit I'm a little", "math, and statistics are necessary or helpful in studying comp", "four which is overall more necessary than the others? >", "this looks like a valid, on-topic question, or if there's", "the question by generalizing it so it can be reopened;", "improve the question by generalizing it so it can be", "background knowledge should someone have in order to do research", "math, and statistics. I also know that research in comp", "in the linguistics department. > > > Ideally, what background", "various subfields of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics. I", "two fields are very interdisciplinary and draw on various subfields", "and I would like to do PhD-level research in computational", "> > > I'd like to know if there's any", "my question.) > > > I'd like to know if", "question by generalizing it so it can be reopened; since", "can be reopened; since I clearly missed something when I", "science, math, and statistics. I also know that research in", "to improve the question by generalizing it so it can", "and statistics. I also know that research in comp ling", "by generalizing it so it can be reopened; since I", "which is why I mention both in my question.) >", "like a valid, on-topic question, or if there's no saving", "from Linguistics.SE](https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/1802/what-are-the-fundamental-differences-between-natural-language-processing-and-com), the distinction between comp ling and NLP is", "enter graduate school, and I would like to do PhD-level", "Which areas of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics are", "natural language processing? Which areas of linguistics, computer science, math,", "areas of linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics are necessary", "writing the question, I'd like some feedback on my proposed", "some in the linguistics department. > > > Ideally, what", "reopened; since I clearly missed something when I was writing", "linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics. I also know that", "linguistics, computer science, math, and statistics are necessary or helpful", "how I would like to re-word the question: > >", "question: > > What background is necessary to do research", "linguistics? > ========================================================================= > > > I'm getting ready to", "computer science, math, and statistics are necessary or helpful in", "since I clearly missed something when I was writing the", "I admit I'm a little bit confused, since it didn't", "blurry, which is why I mention both in my question.)", "I know that these two fields are very interdisciplinary and", "in the CS department, and some in the linguistics department.", "in different departments at different schools, with some schools having", "schools having it in the CS department, and some in", "there's any more room for improvement, if this looks like", "helpful in studying comp ling and NLP, and is there" ]
[ "and, to the best of my knowledge, this problem has", "about that conference, but there is a basically a post", "but there is a basically a post on our site", "question was prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have no idea about", "knowledge, this problem has not happened yet, but should we", "the responsibility of the site with regard to content posted", "of my knowledge, this problem has not happened yet, but", "assuming Ac.SE falls under US law, which I'm not particularly", "organisers would complain about it? I'm assuming Ac.SE falls under", "is the responsibility of the site with regard to content", "conference with fake ones. What would happen if the organisers", "US law, which I'm not particularly familiar with, and, to", "I'm not particularly familiar with, and, to the best of", "problem has not happened yet, but should we take precautionary", "what is the responsibility of the site with regard to", "my knowledge, this problem has not happened yet, but should", "would complain about it? I'm assuming Ac.SE falls under US", "users that could potentially be defaming? This question was prompted", "on our site clearly associating this conference with fake ones.", "This question was prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have no idea", "defaming? This question was prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have no", "conference, but there is a basically a post on our", "if the organisers would complain about it? I'm assuming Ac.SE", "responsibility of the site with regard to content posted by", "be defaming? This question was prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have", "has not happened yet, but should we take precautionary measures?", "ones. What would happen if the organisers would complain about", "to content posted by users that could potentially be defaming?", "I'm assuming Ac.SE falls under US law, which I'm not", "content posted by users that could potentially be defaming? This", "our site clearly associating this conference with fake ones. What", "prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have no idea about that conference,", "clearly associating this conference with fake ones. What would happen", "no idea about that conference, but there is a basically", "the site with regard to content posted by users that", "there is a basically a post on our site clearly", "site clearly associating this conference with fake ones. What would", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have no idea about that conference, but there", "idea about that conference, but there is a basically a", "with fake ones. What would happen if the organisers would", "it? I'm assuming Ac.SE falls under US law, which I'm", "particularly familiar with, and, to the best of my knowledge,", "associating this conference with fake ones. What would happen if", "I was wondering what is the responsibility of the site", "fake ones. What would happen if the organisers would complain", "What would happen if the organisers would complain about it?", "to the best of my knowledge, this problem has not", "by users that could potentially be defaming? This question was", "was wondering what is the responsibility of the site with", "post on our site clearly associating this conference with fake", "Ac.SE falls under US law, which I'm not particularly familiar", "would happen if the organisers would complain about it? I'm", "the organisers would complain about it? I'm assuming Ac.SE falls", "have no idea about that conference, but there is a", "basically a post on our site clearly associating this conference", "that could potentially be defaming? This question was prompted by", "happen if the organisers would complain about it? I'm assuming", "with regard to content posted by users that could potentially", "with, and, to the best of my knowledge, this problem", "law, which I'm not particularly familiar with, and, to the", "under US law, which I'm not particularly familiar with, and,", "complain about it? I'm assuming Ac.SE falls under US law,", "that conference, but there is a basically a post on", "is a basically a post on our site clearly associating", "the best of my knowledge, this problem has not happened", "by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have no idea about that conference, but", "wondering what is the responsibility of the site with regard", "was prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I have no idea about that", "falls under US law, which I'm not particularly familiar with,", "which I'm not particularly familiar with, and, to the best", "about it? I'm assuming Ac.SE falls under US law, which", "best of my knowledge, this problem has not happened yet,", "this problem has not happened yet, but should we take", "a post on our site clearly associating this conference with", "not particularly familiar with, and, to the best of my", "familiar with, and, to the best of my knowledge, this", "site with regard to content posted by users that could", "of the site with regard to content posted by users", "this conference with fake ones. What would happen if the", "could potentially be defaming? This question was prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake>", "I have no idea about that conference, but there is", "a basically a post on our site clearly associating this", "regard to content posted by users that could potentially be", "potentially be defaming? This question was prompted by <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29282/are-conferences-organized-by-iact-like-icke-fake> I", "posted by users that could potentially be defaming? This question" ]
[ "this tag name to convey. And I don't like just", "these emotions (or, who the OP thinks have these emotions)", "questions tagged 'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), and", "on dealing with other people who have these emotions (or,", "would be something like: > > On emotional issues such", "'law'\") until I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This", "something like: > > On emotional issues such as guilt,", "scope. But, I have no idea what such a tag", "term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies to overcome “academic-apathy” in the final", "> On emotional issues such as guilt, discouragement, jealousy, or", "final stages of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated: [How do I", "starting a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient: [Is it normal to", "Any ideas? Note: The tag should exclude questions on dealing", "minimum that is required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) * Discouraged: [How should", "tag to cover questions specifically about \"dealing with the things", "questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") in that scope. But, I have no", "questions tagged 'law'\") until I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged", "I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal emotions,", "exclude questions on dealing with other people who have these", "position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient: [Is it normal to feel impatient in", "> > It's similar to tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions", "of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated: [How do I stop feeling", "[religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged", "deal with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think we need a tag", "I deal with discouragement looking at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) * Guilt:", "do I stop feeling intimidated by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread:", "to overcome “academic-apathy” in the final stages of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd)", "[medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions tagged 'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged", "motivated in a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How to motivate myself", "Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think we need a tag to cover questions", "were similar issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") until", "convey. And I don't like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions tagged", "and [Strategies to overcome “academic-apathy” in the final stages of", "be called. I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies", "we need a tag to cover questions specifically about \"dealing", "what such a tag should be called. I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues", "[How to stay motivated in a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How", "required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) * Discouraged: [How should I deal with", "at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) * Guilt: [How to stop feeling guilty", "the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated: [How do I stop feeling intimidated", "effectively deal with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think we need a", "inadequacy affecting academics and researchers. > > > It's similar", "bad dual-purpose tag. Any ideas? Note: The tag should exclude", "questions tagged 'healthcare'\") before I split it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show", "X?\", where X is: * Lack of motivation: [How to", "others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) * Guilt: [How to stop feeling guilty about", "then it's likely to also be used for questions about", "'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions", "not something I want this tag name to convey. And", "And I don't like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions tagged 'emotions'\"),", "* Intimidated: [How do I stop feeling intimidated by my", "a tag should be called. I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions", "stop feeling intimidated by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread: [Is it", "idea what such a tag should be called. I think", "* Lack of motivation: [How to stay motivated in a", "research/study related to emotions. (I know this because that's what", "Note: The tag should exclude questions on dealing with other", "ideas? Note: The tag should exclude questions on dealing with", "X is: * Lack of motivation: [How to stay motivated", "[How should I deal with discouragement as a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student)", "situation to feel X?\", where X is: * *Lack of", "emotions, which is definitely not something I want this tag", "something I want this tag name to convey. And I", "tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions", "graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How should I deal with discouragement looking", "do more than the bare minimum that is required of", "to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions tagged 'healthcare'\") before I split it", "specifically about \"dealing with the things I am feeling.\" The", "people. We get a lot of questions here of the", "tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal* emotions, which is definitely not something", "in that scope. But, I have no idea what such", "happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions tagged 'healthcare'\") before I split", "about the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout: [What can I do", "don't like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions tagged 'emotions'\"), because then", "Guilt: [How to stop feeling guilty about the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work)", "and researchers. > > > It's similar to tags like", "would make it a bad dual-purpose tag. Any ideas? Note:", "like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions tagged", "actually good at this” - how to effectively deal with", "* Undeserving: [“I've somehow convinced everyone that I'm actually good", "it normal to feel dread before starting a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position)", "about \"dealing with the things I am feeling.\" The scope", "should exclude questions on dealing with other people who have", "We get a lot of questions here of the form", "feeling.\" The scope of the tag would be something like:", "\"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), and there were similar issues with", "(or, who the OP thinks have these emotions) - these", "impatient in lectures when a lecturer explains material that could", "these are better categorized as [interpersonal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/interpersonal-issues \"show questions tagged 'interpersonal-issues'\")", "\"show questions tagged 'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"),", "the tag would be something like: > > On emotional", "such a tag should be called. I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show", "with the things I am feeling.\" The scope of the", "I think we need a tag to cover questions specifically", "feelings of inadequacy affecting academics and researchers. > > >", "[law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") until I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show", "for people in my situation to feel X?\", where X", "\"show questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal emotions, which is definitely", "jealousy, or feelings of inadequacy affecting academics and researchers. >", "of emotions in people. We get a lot of questions", "in lectures when a lecturer explains material that could be", "want this tag name to convey. And I don't like", "burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies to overcome “academic-apathy” in the final stages", "deal with feeling X?\", or \"Is it common for people", "\"show questions tagged 'emotions'\"), because then it's likely to also", "just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions tagged 'emotions'\"), because then it's likely", "inspires a whole range of emotions in people. We get", "that scope. But, I have no idea what such a", "feel X?\", where X is: * Lack of motivation: [How", "range of emotions in people. We get a lot of", "to deal with feeling X?\", or \"Is it common for", "[legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") in that scope. But, I", "tagged 'healthcare'\") before I split it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions", "it normal to feel impatient in lectures when a lecturer", "of the tag would be something like: > > On", "[Strategies to overcome “academic-apathy” in the final stages of the", "\"Is it common for people in my situation to feel", "is definitely not something I want this tag name to", "should I deal with discouragement as a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and", "* Dread: [Is it normal to feel dread before starting", "[“I've somehow convinced everyone that I'm actually good at this”", "advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread: [Is it normal to feel dread before", "in people. We get a lot of questions here of", "before starting a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient: [Is it normal", "questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") in", "it's likely to also be used for questions about research/study", "also be used for questions about research/study related to emotions.", "a short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies to overcome “academic-apathy” in", "'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal emotions, which is definitely not something I", "by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread: [Is it normal to feel", "emotions. (I know this because that's what happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare", "I don't like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions tagged 'emotions'\"), because", "issues such as guilt, discouragement, jealousy, or feelings of inadequacy", "> > > It's similar to tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show", "Impatient: [Is it normal to feel impatient in lectures when", "used for questions about research/study related to emotions. (I know", "to recover from a short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies to", "at this” - how to effectively deal with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect)", "a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How should I deal with discouragement", "\"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and", "it a bad dual-purpose tag. Any ideas? Note: The tag", "and [How should I deal with discouragement looking at others", "[health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"),", "normal to feel dread before starting a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) ", "to feel impatient in lectures when a lecturer explains material", "questions about research/study related to emotions. (I know this because", "what happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions tagged 'healthcare'\") before I", "On emotional issues such as guilt, discouragement, jealousy, or feelings", "tagged 'health-issues'\"), and there were similar issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show", "it common for people in my situation to feel X?\",", "in my situation to feel X?\", where X is: ", "implies abnormal emotions, which is definitely not something I want", "feel dread before starting a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient: [Is", "to stop feeling guilty about the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout:", "name to convey. And I don't like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show", "a lot of questions here of the form \"How to", "deal with discouragement as a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How should", "to emotions. (I know this because that's what happened to", "I do to recover from a short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and", "tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This would make it a bad dual-purpose tag.", "Academia inspires a whole range of emotions in people. We", "and [How to motivate myself to do more than the", "[Is it normal to feel dread before starting a faculty", "a tag to cover questions specifically about \"dealing with the", "overcome “academic-apathy” in the final stages of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) ", "discouragement, jealousy, or feelings of inadequacy affecting academics and researchers.", "to do more than the bare minimum that is required", "get a lot of questions here of the form \"How", "questions specifically about \"dealing with the things I am feeling.\"", "could be obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) Undeserving: [“I've somehow convinced", "into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions tagged 'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions", "dealing with other people who have these emotions (or, who", "questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal emotions, which is definitely not", "make it a bad dual-purpose tag. Any ideas? Note: The", "can I do to recover from a short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout)", "created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This would make it", "emotions in people. We get a lot of questions here", "I have no idea what such a tag should be", "these emotions) - these are better categorized as [interpersonal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/interpersonal-issues \"show", "feel impatient in lectures when a lecturer explains material that", "do to recover from a short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies", "'health-issues'\"), and there were similar issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions", "[How do I stop feeling intimidated by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) ", "lectures when a lecturer explains material that could be obtained", "that is required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) Discouraged: [How should I", "guilty about the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout: [What can I", "people who have these emotions (or, who the OP thinks", "material that could be obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) * Undeserving: [“I've", "to tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show", "* Discouraged: [How should I deal with discouragement as a", "tag should exclude questions on dealing with other people who", "\"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This would make it a bad", "PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated: [How do I stop feeling intimidated by", "discouragement as a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How should I deal", "tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show", "\"How to deal with feeling X?\", or \"Is it common", "to motivate myself to do more than the bare minimum", "affecting academics and researchers. > > > It's similar to", "know this because that's what happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions", "intimidated by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread: [Is it normal to", "group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How to motivate myself to do more than", "it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions tagged 'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show", "> It's similar to tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged", "Dread: [Is it normal to feel dread before starting a", "questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This would make it a bad dual-purpose", "the OP thinks have these emotions) - these are better", "my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread: [Is it normal to feel dread", "should be called. I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\")", "\"show questions tagged 'law'\") until I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions", "'legal-issues'\").) This would make it a bad dual-purpose tag. Any", "that's what happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions tagged 'healthcare'\") before", "[How should I deal with discouragement looking at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success)", "'legal-issues'\") in that scope. But, I have no idea what", "like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions tagged 'emotions'\"), because then it's", "have these emotions) - these are better categorized as [interpersonal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/interpersonal-issues", "feeling intimidated by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread: [Is it normal", "tagged 'emotions'\"), because then it's likely to also be used", "until I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This would", "here of the form \"How to deal with feeling X?\",", "need a tag to cover questions specifically about \"dealing with", "[emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal emotions, which is", "short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies to overcome “academic-apathy” in the", "lecturer explains material that could be obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) ", "academics and researchers. > > > It's similar to tags", "common for people in my situation to feel X?\", where", "to stay motivated in a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How to", "discouragement looking at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) Guilt: [How to stop", "cover questions specifically about \"dealing with the things I am", "thinks have these emotions) - these are better categorized as", "a bad dual-purpose tag. Any ideas? Note: The tag should", "explains material that could be obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) * Undeserving:", "tag. Any ideas? Note: The tag should exclude questions on", "with feeling X?\", or \"Is it common for people in", "normal to feel impatient in lectures when a lecturer explains", "issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") until I created", "than the bare minimum that is required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) ", "motivation: [How to stay motivated in a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and", "of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) Discouraged: [How should I deal with discouragement", "\"dealing with the things I am feeling.\" The scope of", "stop feeling guilty about the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout: [What", "convinced everyone that I'm actually good at this” - how", "to also be used for questions about research/study related to", "I split it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions tagged 'medicine'\") and", "'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") in that scope.", "form \"How to deal with feeling X?\", or \"Is it", "from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) * Undeserving: [“I've somehow convinced everyone that I'm", "looking at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) * Guilt: [How to stop feeling", "a lecturer explains material that could be obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha)", "similar to tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues", "which is definitely not something I want this tag name", "[legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This would make it a", "guilt, discouragement, jealousy, or feelings of inadequacy affecting academics and", "'emotions'\"), because then it's likely to also be used for", "[health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), and there were similar issues", "tagged 'law'\") until I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").)", "whole range of emotions in people. We get a lot", "of inadequacy affecting academics and researchers. > > > It's", "tag name to convey. And I don't like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions", "with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think we need a tag to", "things I am feeling.\" The scope of the tag would", "that could be obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) * Undeserving: [“I've somehow", "who the OP thinks have these emotions) - these are", "where X is: * Lack of motivation: [How to stay", "people in my situation to feel X?\", where X is:", "tag should be called. I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions tagged", "abnormal emotions, which is definitely not something I want this", "how to effectively deal with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think we", "I am feeling.\" The scope of the tag would be", "the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout: [What can I do to", "have these emotions (or, who the OP thinks have these", "before I split it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions tagged 'medicine'\")", "- how to effectively deal with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think", "a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How to motivate myself to do", "“academic-apathy” in the final stages of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated:", "[How to stop feeling guilty about the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) ", "to convey. And I don't like just [emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions", " Burnout: [What can I do to recover from a", "Lack of motivation: [How to stay motivated in a low-motivated", "questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), and there were similar issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law", "called. I think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal", "dual-purpose tag. Any ideas? Note: The tag should exclude questions", "student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How should I deal with discouragement looking at", "of the form \"How to deal with feeling X?\", or", "lot of questions here of the form \"How to deal", "to cover questions specifically about \"dealing with the things I", "because then it's likely to also be used for questions", "the form \"How to deal with feeling X?\", or \"Is", "dread before starting a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient: [Is it", "obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) * Undeserving: [“I've somehow convinced everyone that", "think we need a tag to cover questions specifically about", "researchers. > > > It's similar to tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues", "more than the bare minimum that is required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me)", "\"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") in that scope. But, I have", "Undeserving: [“I've somehow convinced everyone that I'm actually good at", "The tag should exclude questions on dealing with other people", "questions on dealing with other people who have these emotions", "my situation to feel X?\", where X is: * *Lack", "with discouragement as a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How should I", "this” - how to effectively deal with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I", "the bare minimum that is required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) Discouraged:", "am feeling.\" The scope of the tag would be something", "is: * Lack of motivation: [How to stay motivated in", "emotional issues such as guilt, discouragement, jealousy, or feelings of", "But, I have no idea what such a tag should", "definitely not something I want this tag name to convey.", "scope of the tag would be something like: > >", "emotions (or, who the OP thinks have these emotions) -", "be something like: > > On emotional issues such as", "that I'm actually good at this” - how to effectively", "deal with discouragement looking at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) * Guilt: [How", "stay motivated in a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How to motivate", "X?\", or \"Is it common for people in my situation", "success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) * Guilt: [How to stop feeling guilty about the", "be obtained from textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) * Undeserving: [“I've somehow convinced everyone", "This would make it a bad dual-purpose tag. Any ideas?", "tagged 'legal-issues'\") in that scope. But, I have no idea", "in the final stages of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated: [How", "recover from a short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies to overcome", "'healthcare'\") before I split it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions tagged", "be used for questions about research/study related to emotions. (I", "* Impatient: [Is it normal to feel impatient in lectures", "with other people who have these emotions (or, who the", "I want this tag name to convey. And I don't", "and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") in that scope. But,", "there were similar issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\")", "about research/study related to emotions. (I know this because that's", "myself to do more than the bare minimum that is", "questions tagged 'emotions'\"), because then it's likely to also be", "similar issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") until I", "* Guilt: [How to stop feeling guilty about the unfinished", "this because that's what happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions tagged", "me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) * Discouraged: [How should I deal with discouragement as", "motivate myself to do more than the bare minimum that", "OP thinks have these emotions) - these are better categorized", "I stop feeling intimidated by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor) * Dread: [Is", "work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout: [What can I do to recover from", "who have these emotions (or, who the OP thinks have", "somehow convinced everyone that I'm actually good at this” -", "split it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine \"show questions tagged 'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues", "I deal with discouragement as a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How", "> > On emotional issues such as guilt, discouragement, jealousy,", "because that's what happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions tagged 'healthcare'\")", "stages of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated: [How do I stop", "[How to motivate myself to do more than the bare", "(I know this because that's what happened to [healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show", "good at this” - how to effectively deal with Imposter", "think [emotional-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotional-issues \"show questions tagged 'emotional-issues'\") implies abnormal emotions, which", "with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged 'law'\") until I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues", "related to emotions. (I know this because that's what happened", "'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), and there were", "or feelings of inadequacy affecting academics and researchers. > >", "as a graduate student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2219/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-as-a-graduate-student) and [How should I deal with", "the things I am feeling.\" The scope of the tag", "other people who have these emotions (or, who the OP", "questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), [religious-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/religious-issues \"show questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues", "of motivation*: [How to stay motivated in a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group)", "should I deal with discouragement looking at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) ", "like: > > On emotional issues such as guilt, discouragement,", "everyone that I'm actually good at this” - how to", "for questions about research/study related to emotions. (I know this", "with discouragement looking at others success?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15457/how-should-i-deal-with-discouragement-looking-at-others-success) * Guilt: [How to", "to effectively deal with Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think we need", "from a short term burnout?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7668/what-can-i-do-to-recover-from-a-short-term-burnout) and [Strategies to overcome “academic-apathy”", "Intimidated: [How do I stop feeling intimidated by my advisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/26615/how-do-i-stop-feeling-intimidated-by-my-advisor)", "and there were similar issues with [law](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/law \"show questions tagged", "bare minimum that is required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) * Discouraged: [How", "\"show questions tagged 'healthcare'\") before I split it into [medicine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/medicine", "Discouraged: [How should I deal with discouragement as a graduate", "to feel dread before starting a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient:", "unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout: [What can I do to recover", "tag would be something like: > > On emotional issues", "likely to also be used for questions about research/study related", "emotions) - these are better categorized as [interpersonal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/interpersonal-issues \"show questions", "I created [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\").) This would make", "Burnout: [What can I do to recover from a short", "low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How to motivate myself to do more", "textbooks?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12829/is-it-normal-to-feel-impatient-in-lectures-when-a-lecturer-explains-material-tha) * Undeserving: [“I've somehow convinced everyone that I'm actually", "- these are better categorized as [interpersonal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/interpersonal-issues \"show questions tagged", "[What can I do to recover from a short term", "such as guilt, discouragement, jealousy, or feelings of inadequacy affecting", "or \"Is it common for people in my situation to", "The scope of the tag would be something like: >", "faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient: [Is it normal to feel impatient", "feeling X?\", or \"Is it common for people in my", "[healthcare](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/healthcare \"show questions tagged 'healthcare'\") before I split it into", "tagged 'medicine'\") and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), and there", "to feel X?\", where X is: * Lack of motivation:", "Imposter Syndrome](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11765/ive-somehow-convinced-everyone-that-im-actually-good-at-this-how-to-effect) I think we need a tag to cover", "is required of me?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20839/how-to-motivate-myself-to-do-more-than-the-bare-minimum-that-is-required-of-me) * Discouraged: [How should I deal", "the final stages of the PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10969/strategies-to-overcome-academic-apathy-in-the-final-stages-of-the-phd) * Intimidated: [How do", "a faculty position?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21345/is-it-normal-to-feel-dread-before-starting-a-faculty-position) * Impatient: [Is it normal to feel", "[Is it normal to feel impatient in lectures when a", "questions here of the form \"How to deal with feeling", "in a low-motivated group?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24372/how-to-stay-motivated-in-a-low-motivated-group) and [How to motivate myself to", "when a lecturer explains material that could be obtained from", "no idea what such a tag should be called. I", "tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") in that", "of questions here of the form \"How to deal with", "It's similar to tags like [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"),", "and [health-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/health-issues \"show questions tagged 'health-issues'\"), and there were similar", "a whole range of emotions in people. We get a", "\"show questions tagged 'religious-issues'\"), and [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\")", "feeling guilty about the unfinished work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17988/how-to-stop-feeling-guilty-about-the-unfinished-work) * Burnout: [What can", "[emotions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/emotions \"show questions tagged 'emotions'\"), because then it's likely to", "I'm actually good at this” - how to effectively deal", "have no idea what such a tag should be called.", "as guilt, discouragement, jealousy, or feelings of inadequacy affecting academics" ]
[ "if this question is appropriate for the main site or", "not sure if this question is appropriate for the main", "my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the answers seem to suggest that if", "listing them on your CV. This seems in contradiction to", "answers I got. Is there a contradiction, or am I", "avoid listing them on your CV. This seems in contradiction", "when evaluating a potential PhD student. The answers all suggest", "are published in less known journals in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and", "not. A while back I asked about the [Value of", "other non-peer reviewed article (which is essentially the same thing", "a potential PhD student. The answers all suggest I should", "student. The answers all suggest I should treat them as", "which are published in less known journals in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv)", "(which is essentially the same thing you do with peer", "this question is appropriate for the main site or not.", "in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the answers seem to suggest that", "less known journals in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the answers seem", "I should treat them as any other non-peer reviewed article", "and the answers seem to suggest that if the \"less", "articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating a potential PhD student. The answers all", "potential PhD student. The answers all suggest I should treat", "This recent question by a PhD applicant asks [Should I", "answers all suggest I should treat them as any other", "back I asked about the [Value of light-to-none peer reviewed", "on your CV. This seems in contradiction to the answers", "same thing you do with peer reviewed articles). This recent", "that if the \"less known\" journals are predatory that you", "answers seem to suggest that if the \"less known\" journals", "am not sure if this question is appropriate for the", "papers which are published in less known journals in my", "should avoid listing them on your CV. This seems in", "site or not. A while back I asked about the", "thing you do with peer reviewed articles). This recent question", "The answers all suggest I should treat them as any", "PhD applicant asks [Should I list my papers which are", "you should avoid listing them on your CV. This seems", "sure if this question is appropriate for the main site", "got. Is there a contradiction, or am I missing something?", "that you should avoid listing them on your CV. This", "suggest I should treat them as any other non-peer reviewed", "peer reviewed articles). This recent question by a PhD applicant", "[Should I list my papers which are published in less", "known journals in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the answers seem to", "the answers seem to suggest that if the \"less known\"", "the answers I got. Is there a contradiction, or am", "articles). This recent question by a PhD applicant asks [Should", "PhD student. The answers all suggest I should treat them", "the main site or not. A while back I asked", "non-peer reviewed article (which is essentially the same thing you", "to suggest that if the \"less known\" journals are predatory", "them on your CV. This seems in contradiction to the", "I asked about the [Value of light-to-none peer reviewed pay-to-publish", "predatory that you should avoid listing them on your CV.", "do with peer reviewed articles). This recent question by a", "evaluating a potential PhD student. The answers all suggest I", "my papers which are published in less known journals in", "CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the answers seem to suggest that if the", "journals in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the answers seem to suggest", "essentially the same thing you do with peer reviewed articles).", "while back I asked about the [Value of light-to-none peer", "reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating a potential PhD student. The", "question by a PhD applicant asks [Should I list my", "the \"less known\" journals are predatory that you should avoid", "about the [Value of light-to-none peer reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when", "A while back I asked about the [Value of light-to-none", "are predatory that you should avoid listing them on your", "your CV. This seems in contradiction to the answers I", "seems in contradiction to the answers I got. Is there", "asks [Should I list my papers which are published in", "them as any other non-peer reviewed article (which is essentially", "list my papers which are published in less known journals", "light-to-none peer reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating a potential PhD", "reviewed articles). This recent question by a PhD applicant asks", "applicant asks [Should I list my papers which are published", "with peer reviewed articles). This recent question by a PhD", "treat them as any other non-peer reviewed article (which is", "asked about the [Value of light-to-none peer reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles)", "the [Value of light-to-none peer reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating", "or not. A while back I asked about the [Value", "any other non-peer reviewed article (which is essentially the same", "article (which is essentially the same thing you do with", "pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating a potential PhD student. The answers", "the same thing you do with peer reviewed articles). This", "in contradiction to the answers I got. Is there a", "if the \"less known\" journals are predatory that you should", "is appropriate for the main site or not. A while", "\"less known\" journals are predatory that you should avoid listing", "suggest that if the \"less known\" journals are predatory that", "as any other non-peer reviewed article (which is essentially the", "question is appropriate for the main site or not. A", "of light-to-none peer reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating a potential", "journals are predatory that you should avoid listing them on", "reviewed article (which is essentially the same thing you do", "appropriate for the main site or not. A while back", "peer reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating a potential PhD student.", "published in less known journals in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the", "a PhD applicant asks [Should I list my papers which", "to the answers I got. Is there a contradiction, or", "[Value of light-to-none peer reviewed pay-to-publish articles](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7908/value-of-light-to-none-peer-reviewed-pay-to-publish-articles) when evaluating a", "This seems in contradiction to the answers I got. Is", "contradiction to the answers I got. Is there a contradiction,", "main site or not. A while back I asked about", "is essentially the same thing you do with peer reviewed", "in less known journals in my CV?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29543/should-i-list-my-papers-which-are-published-in-less-known-journals-in-my-cv) and the answers", "all suggest I should treat them as any other non-peer", "I got. Is there a contradiction, or am I missing", "I list my papers which are published in less known", "I am not sure if this question is appropriate for", "by a PhD applicant asks [Should I list my papers", "you do with peer reviewed articles). This recent question by", "CV. This seems in contradiction to the answers I got.", "recent question by a PhD applicant asks [Should I list", "for the main site or not. A while back I", "seem to suggest that if the \"less known\" journals are", "should treat them as any other non-peer reviewed article (which", "known\" journals are predatory that you should avoid listing them" ]
[ "to shame publishers/people, I think it is a bad idea.", "question: [My paper was withdrawn from predatory journal after publication,", "it is important to name names. In cases where naming", "I do not want AC.SE to be a place to", "to a question or answer, then I think it is", "I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP is considering naming the publisher and", "do not want AC.SE to be a place to list", "a question or answer, then I think it is important", "do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP is considering naming the publisher and a", "answer, then I think it is important to name names.", "a place to list bad publishers and researchers. If naming", "the publisher, journal, or researcher adds value to a question", "cases where naming names is simply to shame publishers/people, I", "withdrawn from predatory journal after publication, what should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d)", "naming the publisher adds any value and I do not", "researcher adds value to a question or answer, then I", "be a place to list bad publishers and researchers. If", "publisher and a high rep user has recommended them to", "the publisher and a high rep user has recommended them", "then I think it is important to name names. In", "AC.SE to be a place to list bad publishers and", "do this. I personally do not think naming the publisher", "name names. In cases where naming names is simply to", "do not think naming the publisher adds any value and", "rep user has recommended them to do this. I personally", "is important to name names. In cases where naming names", "the publisher adds any value and I do not want", "not think naming the publisher adds any value and I", "high rep user has recommended them to do this. I", "recommended them to do this. I personally do not think", "a high rep user has recommended them to do this.", "think naming the publisher adds any value and I do", "publishers and researchers. If naming the publisher, journal, or researcher", "from predatory journal after publication, what should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the", "bad publishers and researchers. If naming the publisher, journal, or", "adds value to a question or answer, then I think", "In cases where naming names is simply to shame publishers/people,", "place to list bad publishers and researchers. If naming the", "personally do not think naming the publisher adds any value", "any value and I do not want AC.SE to be", "names is simply to shame publishers/people, I think it is", "or researcher adds value to a question or answer, then", "naming the publisher, journal, or researcher adds value to a", "publication, what should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP is considering naming", "think it is important to name names. In cases where", "to name names. In cases where naming names is simply", "publisher adds any value and I do not want AC.SE", "I personally do not think naming the publisher adds any", "them to do this. I personally do not think naming", "where naming names is simply to shame publishers/people, I think", "to do this. I personally do not think naming the", "and a high rep user has recommended them to do", "after publication, what should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP is considering", "journal after publication, what should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP is", "important to name names. In cases where naming names is", "is simply to shame publishers/people, I think it is a", "considering naming the publisher and a high rep user has", "has recommended them to do this. I personally do not", "naming names is simply to shame publishers/people, I think it", "to list bad publishers and researchers. If naming the publisher,", "predatory journal after publication, what should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP", "question or answer, then I think it is important to", "should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP is considering naming the publisher", "this question: [My paper was withdrawn from predatory journal after", "OP is considering naming the publisher and a high rep", "what should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29991/my-paper-was-withdrawn-from-predatory-journal-after-publication-what-should-i-d) the OP is considering naming the", "or answer, then I think it is important to name", "the OP is considering naming the publisher and a high", "value and I do not want AC.SE to be a", "is considering naming the publisher and a high rep user", "adds any value and I do not want AC.SE to", "was withdrawn from predatory journal after publication, what should I", "I think it is important to name names. In cases", "value to a question or answer, then I think it", "naming the publisher and a high rep user has recommended", "If naming the publisher, journal, or researcher adds value to", "names. In cases where naming names is simply to shame", "list bad publishers and researchers. If naming the publisher, journal,", "not want AC.SE to be a place to list bad", "to be a place to list bad publishers and researchers.", "and I do not want AC.SE to be a place", "[My paper was withdrawn from predatory journal after publication, what", "publisher, journal, or researcher adds value to a question or", "researchers. If naming the publisher, journal, or researcher adds value", "and researchers. If naming the publisher, journal, or researcher adds", "paper was withdrawn from predatory journal after publication, what should", "user has recommended them to do this. I personally do", "this. I personally do not think naming the publisher adds", "In this question: [My paper was withdrawn from predatory journal", "journal, or researcher adds value to a question or answer,", "want AC.SE to be a place to list bad publishers", "simply to shame publishers/people, I think it is a bad" ]
[ "on meta, but would like to ask about. Would academia", "forum (doesn't seem right, but I don't know where else", "our teachers and the administrator which I won't go into", "between one of our teachers and the administrator which I", "(doesn't seem right, but I don't know where else to", "seem right, but I don't know where else to ask)", "elementary school, and we're having some trouble between one of", "where else to ask) to ask about interactions between faculty", "we're having some trouble between one of our teachers and", "to ask about. Would academia be an appropriate forum (doesn't", "the administrator which I won't go into on meta, but", "else to ask) to ask about interactions between faculty and", "would like to ask about. Would academia be an appropriate", "be an appropriate forum (doesn't seem right, but I don't", "am on a school board for a small private elementary", "for a small private elementary school, and we're having some", "on a school board for a small private elementary school,", "an appropriate forum (doesn't seem right, but I don't know", "trouble between one of our teachers and the administrator which", "I don't know where else to ask) to ask about", "know where else to ask) to ask about interactions between", "a small private elementary school, and we're having some trouble", "which I won't go into on meta, but would like", "academia be an appropriate forum (doesn't seem right, but I", "appropriate forum (doesn't seem right, but I don't know where", "don't know where else to ask) to ask about interactions", "one of our teachers and the administrator which I won't", "board for a small private elementary school, and we're having", "meta, but would like to ask about. Would academia be", "private elementary school, and we're having some trouble between one", "but I don't know where else to ask) to ask", "to ask) to ask about interactions between faculty and staff?", "Would academia be an appropriate forum (doesn't seem right, but", "go into on meta, but would like to ask about.", "and the administrator which I won't go into on meta,", "of our teachers and the administrator which I won't go", "a school board for a small private elementary school, and", "school, and we're having some trouble between one of our", "administrator which I won't go into on meta, but would", "small private elementary school, and we're having some trouble between", "teachers and the administrator which I won't go into on", "some trouble between one of our teachers and the administrator", "won't go into on meta, but would like to ask", "into on meta, but would like to ask about. Would", "like to ask about. Would academia be an appropriate forum", "school board for a small private elementary school, and we're", "I won't go into on meta, but would like to", "having some trouble between one of our teachers and the", "but would like to ask about. Would academia be an", "ask about. Would academia be an appropriate forum (doesn't seem", "I am on a school board for a small private", "about. Would academia be an appropriate forum (doesn't seem right,", "and we're having some trouble between one of our teachers", "right, but I don't know where else to ask) to" ]
[ "and #EFF appear to be in the home page's source", "[color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found those colors to be black, white and", "appear to be in the home page's source code. Thanks", "so in addition, please tell me how to find the", "to find the color value. Also, I am looking for", "color value. Also, I am looking for the hex value.", "I would like to use the main site's background color", "I don't know anything about code except how to search", "to be black, white and light blue respectively. I don't", "#000 and #EFF appear to be in the home page's", "and light blue respectively. I don't know anything about code", "to use the main site's background color on my personal", "use the main site's background color on my personal website.", "the home page's source code. Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found", "to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found those colors to be black, white", "the color value. Also, I am looking for the hex", "would like to use the main site's background color on", "page's source code. Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found those colors", "Ctrl + F, so in addition, please tell me how", "blue respectively. I don't know anything about code except how", "I found those colors to be black, white and light", "code except how to search through it by using Ctrl", "+ F, so in addition, please tell me how to", "F, so in addition, please tell me how to find", "addition, please tell me how to find the color value.", "those colors to be black, white and light blue respectively.", "colors to be black, white and light blue respectively. I", "respectively. I don't know anything about code except how to", "in the home page's source code. Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I", "be black, white and light blue respectively. I don't know", "Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found those colors to be black,", "my personal website. #FFF, #000 and #EFF appear to be", "light blue respectively. I don't know anything about code except", "anything about code except how to search through it by", "find the color value. Also, I am looking for the", "color on my personal website. #FFF, #000 and #EFF appear", "about code except how to search through it by using", "site's background color on my personal website. #FFF, #000 and", "source code. Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found those colors to", "know anything about code except how to search through it", "how to find the color value. Also, I am looking", "using Ctrl + F, so in addition, please tell me", "black, white and light blue respectively. I don't know anything", "search through it by using Ctrl + F, so in", "main site's background color on my personal website. #FFF, #000", "tell me how to find the color value. Also, I", "through it by using Ctrl + F, so in addition,", "personal website. #FFF, #000 and #EFF appear to be in", "on my personal website. #FFF, #000 and #EFF appear to", "#EFF appear to be in the home page's source code.", "home page's source code. Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found those", "in addition, please tell me how to find the color", "don't know anything about code except how to search through", "the main site's background color on my personal website. #FFF,", "like to use the main site's background color on my", "be in the home page's source code. Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/),", "it by using Ctrl + F, so in addition, please", "how to search through it by using Ctrl + F,", "#FFF, #000 and #EFF appear to be in the home", "background color on my personal website. #FFF, #000 and #EFF", "found those colors to be black, white and light blue", "to search through it by using Ctrl + F, so", "except how to search through it by using Ctrl +", "website. #FFF, #000 and #EFF appear to be in the", "code. Thanks to [color-hex](http://www.color-hex.com/), I found those colors to be", "by using Ctrl + F, so in addition, please tell", "please tell me how to find the color value. Also,", "me how to find the color value. Also, I am", "white and light blue respectively. I don't know anything about", "to be in the home page's source code. Thanks to" ]
[ "edit that makes another comment obsolete and no longer constructive,", "no longer constructive, I think it is easiest for the", "\"not constructive\" or \"obsolete\" among other things. If you delete", "as either \"not constructive\" or \"obsolete\" among other things. If", "that makes another comment obsolete and no longer constructive, I", "an edit that makes another comment obsolete and no longer", "I think it is easiest for the moderators if the", "the comment is flagged as obsolete instead of not constructive.", "or make an edit that makes another comment obsolete and", "the moderators if the comment is flagged as obsolete instead", "things. If you delete a comment or make an edit", "When flagging comments it is possible to flag comments as", "obsolete and no longer constructive, I think it is easiest", "flagging comments it is possible to flag comments as either", "If you delete a comment or make an edit that", "it is easiest for the moderators if the comment is", "comment obsolete and no longer constructive, I think it is", "you delete a comment or make an edit that makes", "constructive, I think it is easiest for the moderators if", "a comment or make an edit that makes another comment", "and no longer constructive, I think it is easiest for", "either \"not constructive\" or \"obsolete\" among other things. If you", "if the comment is flagged as obsolete instead of not", "longer constructive, I think it is easiest for the moderators", "delete a comment or make an edit that makes another", "it is possible to flag comments as either \"not constructive\"", "easiest for the moderators if the comment is flagged as", "among other things. If you delete a comment or make", "or \"obsolete\" among other things. If you delete a comment", "make an edit that makes another comment obsolete and no", "possible to flag comments as either \"not constructive\" or \"obsolete\"", "for the moderators if the comment is flagged as obsolete", "comments it is possible to flag comments as either \"not", "\"obsolete\" among other things. If you delete a comment or", "is possible to flag comments as either \"not constructive\" or", "moderators if the comment is flagged as obsolete instead of", "other things. If you delete a comment or make an", "to flag comments as either \"not constructive\" or \"obsolete\" among", "constructive\" or \"obsolete\" among other things. If you delete a", "flag comments as either \"not constructive\" or \"obsolete\" among other", "comments as either \"not constructive\" or \"obsolete\" among other things.", "comment or make an edit that makes another comment obsolete", "is easiest for the moderators if the comment is flagged", "think it is easiest for the moderators if the comment", "makes another comment obsolete and no longer constructive, I think", "another comment obsolete and no longer constructive, I think it" ]
[ "student about exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects", "course references suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is this question on topic here?", "a question asked by a student about exams, studying, cheating,", "of a totally undergraduate experience. * Well, as it pertains", "students it would still be off topic. I suspect this", "Whenever we get a question asked by a student about", "programs include coursework, is there anything undergraduate-specific about questions on", "a large number of master's and a significant number of", "be asked by a graduate student who had cheated, in", "asked by a student about exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades,", "an extremely detailed description of a totally undergraduate experience. ", "graduate level (as coursework is less emphasized) though it is", "disputing grades, or other aspects of university-level coursework, I see", "cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects of university-level coursework, I", "as off-topic, since this is a question about a problem", "though it is possible. Given that a large number of", "be off topic. I suspect this is a much less", "of: The course references suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is this question", "I see flags and comments along the lines of: ", "undergraduate student Although it's conceivable that a similar question", "large number of master's and a significant number of doctoral", "similar question could be asked by a graduate student who", "conceivable that a similar question could be asked by a", "is a much less common issue at the graduate level", "undergraduate experience. * Well, as it pertains to undergraduate students", "coursework is less emphasized) though it is possible. Given that", "Although it's conceivable that a similar question could be asked", "less common issue at the graduate level (as coursework is", "had cheated, in reality this is an extremely detailed description", "it pertains to undergraduate students it would still be off", "as it pertains to undergraduate students it would still be", "see flags and comments along the lines of: * The", "master's and a significant number of doctoral degree programs include", "of university-level coursework, I see flags and comments along the", "a much less common issue at the graduate level (as", "graduate student who had cheated, in reality this is an", "about exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects of", "detailed description of a totally undergraduate experience. * Well, as", "of master's and a significant number of doctoral degree programs", "the lines of: * The course references suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is", "question asked by a student about exams, studying, cheating, disputing", "undergraduate students it would still be off topic. I suspect", "the graduate level (as coursework is less emphasized) though it", "suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is this question on topic here? * Voting", "reality this is an extremely detailed description of a totally", "or other aspects of university-level coursework, I see flags and", "get a question asked by a student about exams, studying,", "I suspect this is a much less common issue at", "would still be off topic. I suspect this is a", "topic. I suspect this is a much less common issue", "it is possible. Given that a large number of master's", "flags and comments along the lines of: * The course", "could be asked by a graduate student who had cheated,", "coursework, is there anything undergraduate-specific about questions on exams, studying,", "on topic here? * Voting to close as off-topic, since", "The course references suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is this question on topic", "of doctoral degree programs include coursework, is there anything undergraduate-specific", "and comments along the lines of: * The course references", "at the graduate level (as coursework is less emphasized) though", "other aspects of university-level coursework, I see flags and comments", "asked by a graduate student who had cheated, in reality", "is possible. Given that a large number of master's and", "about questions on exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other", "lines of: * The course references suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is this", "(as coursework is less emphasized) though it is possible. Given", "this is an extremely detailed description of a totally undergraduate", "much less common issue at the graduate level (as coursework", "totally undergraduate experience. * Well, as it pertains to undergraduate", "by a graduate student who had cheated, in reality this", "a student about exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other", "a totally undergraduate experience. * Well, as it pertains to", "level (as coursework is less emphasized) though it is possible.", "that a large number of master's and a significant number", "coursework, I see flags and comments along the lines of:", "exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects of university-level", "facing an undergraduate student * Although it's conceivable that a", "still be off topic. I suspect this is a much", "issue at the graduate level (as coursework is less emphasized)", "extremely detailed description of a totally undergraduate experience. * Well,", "that a similar question could be asked by a graduate", "to close as off-topic, since this is a question about", "studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects of university-level coursework,", "problem facing an undergraduate student * Although it's conceivable that", "in reality this is an extremely detailed description of a", "this is a question about a problem facing an undergraduate", "grades, or other aspects of university-level coursework, I see flags", "Given that a large number of master's and a significant", "question on topic here? * Voting to close as off-topic,", "references suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is this question on topic here? ", "it would still be off topic. I suspect this is", "comments along the lines of: The course references suggest", "an undergraduate student * Although it's conceivable that a similar", "a graduate student who had cheated, in reality this is", "student who had cheated, in reality this is an extremely", "university-level coursework, I see flags and comments along the lines", "topic here? * Voting to close as off-topic, since this", "\"undergraduate.\" Is this question on topic here? * Voting to", "a question about a problem facing an undergraduate student ", "pertains to undergraduate students it would still be off topic.", "we get a question asked by a student about exams,", "Voting to close as off-topic, since this is a question", "include coursework, is there anything undergraduate-specific about questions on exams,", "undergraduate-specific about questions on exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or", "possible. Given that a large number of master's and a", " Voting to close as off-topic, since this is a", "by a student about exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or", "number of master's and a significant number of doctoral degree", "number of doctoral degree programs include coursework, is there anything", "description of a totally undergraduate experience. * Well, as it", "suspect this is a much less common issue at the", "common issue at the graduate level (as coursework is less", "there anything undergraduate-specific about questions on exams, studying, cheating, disputing", "a similar question could be asked by a graduate student", "experience. * Well, as it pertains to undergraduate students it", "is there anything undergraduate-specific about questions on exams, studying, cheating,", "* The course references suggest \"undergraduate.\" Is this question on", "about a problem facing an undergraduate student * Although it's", "who had cheated, in reality this is an extremely detailed", "Is this question on topic here? * Voting to close", "on exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects of", "here? * Voting to close as off-topic, since this is", "questions on exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects", "this is a much less common issue at the graduate", "less emphasized) though it is possible. Given that a large", "this question on topic here? * Voting to close as", "it's conceivable that a similar question could be asked by", "a problem facing an undergraduate student * Although it's conceivable", "student * Although it's conceivable that a similar question could", "close as off-topic, since this is a question about a", "off topic. I suspect this is a much less common", "along the lines of: * The course references suggest \"undergraduate.\"", "Well, as it pertains to undergraduate students it would still", "question could be asked by a graduate student who had", "* Well, as it pertains to undergraduate students it would", "is less emphasized) though it is possible. Given that a", "studying, cheating, disputing grades, or other aspects of university-level coursework?", "since this is a question about a problem facing an", "degree programs include coursework, is there anything undergraduate-specific about questions", "to undergraduate students it would still be off topic. I", "aspects of university-level coursework, I see flags and comments along", "* Although it's conceivable that a similar question could be", "question about a problem facing an undergraduate student * Although", "off-topic, since this is a question about a problem facing", "and a significant number of doctoral degree programs include coursework,", "emphasized) though it is possible. Given that a large number", "is a question about a problem facing an undergraduate student", "a significant number of doctoral degree programs include coursework, is", "is an extremely detailed description of a totally undergraduate experience.", "doctoral degree programs include coursework, is there anything undergraduate-specific about", "anything undergraduate-specific about questions on exams, studying, cheating, disputing grades,", "cheated, in reality this is an extremely detailed description of", "significant number of doctoral degree programs include coursework, is there" ]
[ "are immediately \"shot down in flames\" before even attempting to", "very polite, but still why do we need this extended", "On the other hand, I consider Academia SE one of", "I consider Academia SE one of the more \"civilized\" SE", "it? It has happened before (I think KiteMT was a", "too-much moderation is unnecessary here and it only resulted that", "It has happened before (I think KiteMT was a little", "was the recent [I was caught cheating on an exam,", "can I minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the other hand, I", "down in flames\" before even attempting to troll. On this", "comments, because they state that \"a cheater should be punished\"", "an exam, how can I minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the", "said, for me really has no meaning. This too-much moderation", "I know that extended comment discussions are discouraged and by", "are discouraged and by SE rules they should be continued", "delete comments, because they state that \"a cheater should be", "valued member (at least for me) of the community (Omen)", "communities, where trolls are almost non-existent and due to the", "On this assumption, deleting or wanting to delete comments, because", "of the community (Omen) has left. Was it really worth", "be punished\" or \"welcome to adulthood\" as JeffE said, for", "here and it only resulted that a valued member (at", "before (I think KiteMT was a little bit offended after", "we need this extended moderation here? Why can't we leave", "but still why do we need this extended moderation here?", "where trolls are almost non-existent and due to the smaller", "it only resulted that a valued member (at least for", "the more \"civilized\" SE communities, where trolls are almost non-existent", "was caught cheating on an exam, how can I minimize", "were deleted) and it will happen again. I am not", "the community (Omen) has left. Was it really worth it?", "discussions are discouraged and by SE rules they should be", "worth it? It has happened before (I think KiteMT was", "This too-much moderation is unnecessary here and it only resulted", "A prime example of this situation was the recent [I", "the joke) because he was very polite, but still why", "KiteMT was a little bit offended after some of his", "need this extended moderation here? Why can't we leave the", "and due to the smaller size of this community, they", "immediately \"shot down in flames\" before even attempting to troll.", "extended moderation here? Why can't we leave the comments as", "as JeffE said, for me really has no meaning. This", "to troll. On this assumption, deleting or wanting to delete", "the smaller size of this community, they are immediately \"shot", "for me really has no meaning. This too-much moderation is", "prime example of this situation was the recent [I was", "rules they should be continued in chat. A prime example", "the other hand, I consider Academia SE one of the", "or wanting to delete comments, because they state that \"a", "punished\" or \"welcome to adulthood\" as JeffE said, for me", "minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the other hand, I consider Academia", "this situation was the recent [I was caught cheating on", "cheating on an exam, how can I minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage)", "attempting to troll. On this assumption, deleting or wanting to", "exam, how can I minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the other", "\"a cheater should be punished\" or \"welcome to adulthood\" as", "and by SE rules they should be continued in chat.", "meaning. This too-much moderation is unnecessary here and it only", "\"civilized\" SE communities, where trolls are almost non-existent and due", "in flames\" before even attempting to troll. On this assumption,", "in chat. A prime example of this situation was the", "will happen again. I am not saying anything bad about", "be continued in chat. A prime example of this situation", "comments as they are, if they are not simply trolling.", "has happened before (I think KiteMT was a little bit", "me really has no meaning. This too-much moderation is unnecessary", "before even attempting to troll. On this assumption, deleting or", "almost non-existent and due to the smaller size of this", "this assumption, deleting or wanting to delete comments, because they", "he was very polite, but still why do we need", "community, they are immediately \"shot down in flames\" before even", "wanting to delete comments, because they state that \"a cheater", "[I was caught cheating on an exam, how can I", "to adulthood\" as JeffE said, for me really has no", "I minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the other hand, I consider", "trolls are almost non-existent and due to the smaller size", "polite, but still why do we need this extended moderation", "only resulted that a valued member (at least for me)", "happen again. I am not saying anything bad about StrongBad", "saying anything bad about StrongBad (get the joke) because he", "we leave the comments as they are, if they are", "by SE rules they should be continued in chat. A", "JeffE said, for me really has no meaning. This too-much", "am not saying anything bad about StrongBad (get the joke)", "should be punished\" or \"welcome to adulthood\" as JeffE said,", "little bit offended after some of his comments were deleted)", "leave the comments as they are, if they are not", "for me) of the community (Omen) has left. Was it", "can't we leave the comments as they are, if they", "know that extended comment discussions are discouraged and by SE", "and it only resulted that a valued member (at least", "damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the other hand, I consider Academia SE one", "because he was very polite, but still why do we", "non-existent and due to the smaller size of this community,", "to the smaller size of this community, they are immediately", "here? Why can't we leave the comments as they are,", "one of the more \"civilized\" SE communities, where trolls are", "\"shot down in flames\" before even attempting to troll. On", "troll. On this assumption, deleting or wanting to delete comments,", "(Omen) has left. Was it really worth it? It has", "I am not saying anything bad about StrongBad (get the", "that a valued member (at least for me) of the", "least for me) of the community (Omen) has left. Was", "of his comments were deleted) and it will happen again.", "community (Omen) has left. Was it really worth it? It", "other hand, I consider Academia SE one of the more", "\"welcome to adulthood\" as JeffE said, for me really has", "again. I am not saying anything bad about StrongBad (get", "joke) because he was very polite, but still why do", "discouraged and by SE rules they should be continued in", "think KiteMT was a little bit offended after some of", "a valued member (at least for me) of the community", "comments were deleted) and it will happen again. I am", "smaller size of this community, they are immediately \"shot down", "chat. A prime example of this situation was the recent", "the recent [I was caught cheating on an exam, how", "caught cheating on an exam, how can I minimize the", "it really worth it? It has happened before (I think", "of the more \"civilized\" SE communities, where trolls are almost", "SE communities, where trolls are almost non-existent and due to", "happened before (I think KiteMT was a little bit offended", "deleting or wanting to delete comments, because they state that", "state that \"a cheater should be punished\" or \"welcome to", "anything bad about StrongBad (get the joke) because he was", "resulted that a valued member (at least for me) of", "comment discussions are discouraged and by SE rules they should", "they state that \"a cheater should be punished\" or \"welcome", "bit offended after some of his comments were deleted) and", "that \"a cheater should be punished\" or \"welcome to adulthood\"", "StrongBad (get the joke) because he was very polite, but", "a little bit offended after some of his comments were", "(get the joke) because he was very polite, but still", "are almost non-existent and due to the smaller size of", "left. Was it really worth it? It has happened before", "his comments were deleted) and it will happen again. I", "moderation is unnecessary here and it only resulted that a", "adulthood\" as JeffE said, for me really has no meaning.", "bad about StrongBad (get the joke) because he was very", "was a little bit offended after some of his comments", "and it will happen again. I am not saying anything", "situation was the recent [I was caught cheating on an", "do we need this extended moderation here? Why can't we", "SE rules they should be continued in chat. A prime", "consider Academia SE one of the more \"civilized\" SE communities,", "Why can't we leave the comments as they are, if", "they should be continued in chat. A prime example of", "still why do we need this extended moderation here? Why", "really worth it? It has happened before (I think KiteMT", "(I think KiteMT was a little bit offended after some", "the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the other hand, I consider Academia SE", "not saying anything bad about StrongBad (get the joke) because", "extended comment discussions are discouraged and by SE rules they", "unnecessary here and it only resulted that a valued member", "about StrongBad (get the joke) because he was very polite,", "this community, they are immediately \"shot down in flames\" before", "continued in chat. A prime example of this situation was", "example of this situation was the recent [I was caught", "to delete comments, because they state that \"a cheater should", "cheater should be punished\" or \"welcome to adulthood\" as JeffE", "or \"welcome to adulthood\" as JeffE said, for me really", "(at least for me) of the community (Omen) has left.", "the comments as they are, if they are not simply", "that extended comment discussions are discouraged and by SE rules", "because they state that \"a cheater should be punished\" or", "recent [I was caught cheating on an exam, how can", "of this community, they are immediately \"shot down in flames\"", "why do we need this extended moderation here? Why can't", "on an exam, how can I minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On", "they are immediately \"shot down in flames\" before even attempting", "should be continued in chat. A prime example of this", "Academia SE one of the more \"civilized\" SE communities, where", "has left. Was it really worth it? It has happened", "hand, I consider Academia SE one of the more \"civilized\"", "no meaning. This too-much moderation is unnecessary here and it", "really has no meaning. This too-much moderation is unnecessary here", "me) of the community (Omen) has left. Was it really", "was very polite, but still why do we need this", "size of this community, they are immediately \"shot down in", "assumption, deleting or wanting to delete comments, because they state", "this extended moderation here? Why can't we leave the comments", "even attempting to troll. On this assumption, deleting or wanting", "of this situation was the recent [I was caught cheating", "Was it really worth it? It has happened before (I", "due to the smaller size of this community, they are", "some of his comments were deleted) and it will happen", "more \"civilized\" SE communities, where trolls are almost non-existent and", "it will happen again. I am not saying anything bad", "offended after some of his comments were deleted) and it", "SE one of the more \"civilized\" SE communities, where trolls", "has no meaning. This too-much moderation is unnecessary here and", "member (at least for me) of the community (Omen) has", "deleted) and it will happen again. I am not saying", "is unnecessary here and it only resulted that a valued", "flames\" before even attempting to troll. On this assumption, deleting", "after some of his comments were deleted) and it will", "how can I minimize the damage?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30539/i-was-caught-cheating-on-an-exam-how-can-i-minimize-the-damage) On the other hand,", "moderation here? Why can't we leave the comments as they" ]
[ "it is on-topic for this site or not. I seek", "but I am not sure whether it is on-topic for", "ask a question about a standard syllabus for a research", "a standard syllabus for a research methods and technical writing", "research methods and technical writing course; but I am not", "should be arranged and what topics should be covered in", "seek advices on how the course should be arranged and", "about a standard syllabus for a research methods and technical", "be arranged and what topics should be covered in it.", "syllabus for a research methods and technical writing course; but", "I am not sure whether it is on-topic for this", "the course should be arranged and what topics should be", "technical writing course; but I am not sure whether it", "course; but I am not sure whether it is on-topic", "to ask a question about a standard syllabus for a", "for this site or not. I seek advices on how", "course should be arranged and what topics should be covered", "advices on how the course should be arranged and what", "this site or not. I seek advices on how the", "site or not. I seek advices on how the course", "on how the course should be arranged and what topics", "not. I seek advices on how the course should be", "standard syllabus for a research methods and technical writing course;", "question about a standard syllabus for a research methods and", "whether it is on-topic for this site or not. I", "methods and technical writing course; but I am not sure", "a research methods and technical writing course; but I am", "writing course; but I am not sure whether it is", "on-topic for this site or not. I seek advices on", "am not sure whether it is on-topic for this site", "sure whether it is on-topic for this site or not.", "a question about a standard syllabus for a research methods", "is on-topic for this site or not. I seek advices", "not sure whether it is on-topic for this site or", "for a research methods and technical writing course; but I", "want to ask a question about a standard syllabus for", "I want to ask a question about a standard syllabus", "and technical writing course; but I am not sure whether", "or not. I seek advices on how the course should", "I seek advices on how the course should be arranged", "how the course should be arranged and what topics should" ]
[ "in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How should 'van'-names be ordered in a", "on meta, and they don't seem to be closed very", "will almost always be \"follow your discipline's style manual\" or", "writing at all levels, particularly basic questions about particular styles,", "to cite chapter and edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These are", "as this question about APA style: [APA: How to cite", "this question about APA style: [APA: How to cite chapter", "the brackets for Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How should 'van'-names", "fullstop go inside or outside the brackets for Harvard in-line", "in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have never really seen these as", "something, the answer will almost always be \"follow your discipline's", "\"follow your discipline's style manual\" or \"follow the instructions of", "2. When there is more than one reasonable possibility for", "any more than questions on proper grammar would be. 2.", "questions about particular styles, such as this question about APA", "to writing at all levels, particularly basic questions about particular", "there is more than one reasonable possibility for how to", "find discussion about them on meta, and they don't seem", "styles, such as this question about APA style: [APA: How", "about citation styles. For example, * [Should the fullstop go", "format something, the answer will almost always be \"follow your", "how to format something, the answer will almost always be", "go inside or outside the brackets for Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati)", ". These are not really about academia any more than", "brackets for Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How should 'van'-names be", "seems to me that: 1. Many of these questions apply", "would be. 2. When there is more than one reasonable", "[Should the fullstop go inside or outside the brackets for", "When there is more than one reasonable possibility for how", "the fullstop go inside or outside the brackets for Harvard", "seen these as on-topic for this site, but I could", "as on-topic for this site, but I could not find", "answer will almost always be \"follow your discipline's style manual\"", "ordered in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have never really seen these", "citation styles. For example, * [Should the fullstop go inside", "about APA style: [APA: How to cite chapter and edition", "inside or outside the brackets for Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) ", "questions from time to time about citation styles. For example,", "have never really seen these as on-topic for this site,", "site, but I could not find discussion about them on", "question about APA style: [APA: How to cite chapter and", "be \"follow your discipline's style manual\" or \"follow the instructions", "not find discussion about them on meta, and they don't", "style: [APA: How to cite chapter and edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book)", "academia* any more than questions on proper grammar would be.", "quickly. It seems to me that: 1. Many of these", "particularly basic questions about particular styles, such as this question", "your discipline's style manual\" or \"follow the instructions of the", "possibility for how to format something, the answer will almost", "[APA: How to cite chapter and edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) .", "to me that: 1. Many of these questions apply equally", "see questions from time to time about citation styles. For", "particular styles, such as this question about APA style: [APA:", "[How should 'van'-names be ordered in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have", "such as this question about APA style: [APA: How to", "on-topic for this site, but I could not find discussion", "should 'van'-names be ordered in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have never", "styles. For example, * [Should the fullstop go inside or", "they don't seem to be closed very quickly. It seems", "more than one reasonable possibility for how to format something,", "about them on meta, and they don't seem to be", "'van'-names be ordered in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have never really", "really seen these as on-topic for this site, but I", "reasonable possibility for how to format something, the answer will", "bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have never really seen these as on-topic for", "time about citation styles. For example, * [Should the fullstop", "of these questions apply equally to writing at all levels,", "grammar would be. 2. When there is more than one", "meta, and they don't seem to be closed very quickly.", "but I could not find discussion about them on meta,", "time to time about citation styles. For example, * [Should", "them on meta, and they don't seem to be closed", "always be \"follow your discipline's style manual\" or \"follow the", "I have never really seen these as on-topic for this", "proper grammar would be. 2. When there is more than", "* [Should the fullstop go inside or outside the brackets", "all levels, particularly basic questions about particular styles, such as", "are not really about academia any more than questions on", "about academia any more than questions on proper grammar would", "book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These are not really about academia any more", "on proper grammar would be. 2. When there is more", "these questions apply equally to writing at all levels, particularly", "for Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How should 'van'-names be ordered", "is more than one reasonable possibility for how to format", "citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How should 'van'-names be ordered in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography)", "be closed very quickly. It seems to me that: 1.", "Many of these questions apply equally to writing at all", "1. Many of these questions apply equally to writing at", "really about academia any more than questions on proper grammar", "* [How should 'van'-names be ordered in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I", "levels, particularly basic questions about particular styles, such as this", "be ordered in a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have never really seen", "this site, but I could not find discussion about them", "I see questions from time to time about citation styles.", "It seems to me that: 1. Many of these questions", "me that: 1. Many of these questions apply equally to", "for this site, but I could not find discussion about", "and edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These are not really about", "that: 1. Many of these questions apply equally to writing", "and they don't seem to be closed very quickly. It", "Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How should 'van'-names be ordered in", "equally to writing at all levels, particularly basic questions about", "outside the brackets for Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How should", "to time about citation styles. For example, * [Should the", "at all levels, particularly basic questions about particular styles, such", "How to cite chapter and edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These", "more than questions on proper grammar would be. 2. When", "questions on proper grammar would be. 2. When there is", "or outside the brackets for Harvard in-line citations?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31024/should-the-fullstop-go-inside-or-outside-the-brackets-for-harvard-in-line-citati) * [How", "never really seen these as on-topic for this site, but", "be. 2. When there is more than one reasonable possibility", "not really about academia any more than questions on proper", "from time to time about citation styles. For example, ", "These are not really about academia* any more than questions", "the answer will almost always be \"follow your discipline's style", "basic questions about particular styles, such as this question about", "I could not find discussion about them on meta, and", "in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These are not really about academia any", "apply equally to writing at all levels, particularly basic questions", "than one reasonable possibility for how to format something, the", "seem to be closed very quickly. It seems to me", "these as on-topic for this site, but I could not", "to be closed very quickly. It seems to me that:", "about particular styles, such as this question about APA style:", "than questions on proper grammar would be. 2. When there", "cite chapter and edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These are not", "one reasonable possibility for how to format something, the answer", "example, * [Should the fullstop go inside or outside the", "a bibliography?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8870/how-should-van-names-be-ordered-in-a-bibliography) I have never really seen these as on-topic", "discipline's style manual\" or \"follow the instructions of the journal\"", "For example, * [Should the fullstop go inside or outside", "questions apply equally to writing at all levels, particularly basic", "very quickly. It seems to me that: 1. Many of", "to format something, the answer will almost always be \"follow", "APA style: [APA: How to cite chapter and edition in", "chapter and edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These are not really", "could not find discussion about them on meta, and they", "for how to format something, the answer will almost always", "don't seem to be closed very quickly. It seems to", "closed very quickly. It seems to me that: 1. Many", "almost always be \"follow your discipline's style manual\" or \"follow", "discussion about them on meta, and they don't seem to", "edition in book](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13801/apa-how-to-cite-chapter-and-edition-in-book) . These are not really about academia" ]
[ "be off topic as \"too localized\" or \"seeks advice for", "tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag. There are also examples of legal questions", "[Are there any laws against professors publishing scientific papers without", "to raise this issue for community discussion: *Are questions on", "difficult for new users to understand whether their question is", "acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) [Panelist hacks my system during a", "to academia. The close reason for the first one also", "is on topic, and it makes it difficult for not-so-new", "'visa'\"). At the same time, we've closed questions that seem", "in question is clearly related to academia. The close reason", "other tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions tagged 'visa'\"). At the", "is a hypothetical question; but we don't generally close hypothetical", "to be that it asks about legal issues. Inconsistency like", "asks about legal issues. Inconsistency like this is bad; it", "someone close to the situation can give an objectively correct", "is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was closed, then reopened after it", "can give an objectively correct answer.\") I am referring to", "so that only someone close to the situation can give", "situation can give an objectively correct answer.\") I am referring", "close to the situation can give an objectively correct answer.\")", "\"too localized\" or \"seeks advice for a very specific situation,", "There are also examples of legal questions in other tags,", "an objectively correct answer.\") I am referring to questions asking", "to the situation can give an objectively correct answer.\") I", "perfectly feasible, as this one is. So the issue appears", "feasible, as this one is. So the issue appears to", "it was changed from \"legal\" to \"ethical\") In both of", "give an objectively correct answer.\") I am referring to questions", "question is clearly related to academia. The close reason for", "that seem just like those, for being off topic as", "for a particular situation (these would certainly be off topic", "surrounding [some academic behavior]?\" There are many examples of such", "it asks about legal issues. Inconsistency like this is bad;", "judge when to vote to close. I would therefore like", "or \"What are the legal issues surrounding [some academic behavior]?\"", "was closed, then reopened after it was changed from \"legal\"", "are perfectly feasible, as this one is. So the issue", "that it asks about legal issues. Inconsistency like this is", "it makes it difficult for new users to understand whether", "both of these examples, the behavior in question is clearly", "but we don't generally close hypothetical questions if they are", "questions asking for legal advice for a particular situation (these", "specific situation, so that only someone close to the situation", "\"ethical\") In both of these examples, the behavior in question", "questions if they are perfectly feasible, as this one is.", "the issue appears to be that it asks about legal", "their question is on topic, and it makes it difficult", "to vote to close. I would therefore like to raise", "questions tagged 'visa'\"). At the same time, we've closed questions", "question; but we don't generally close hypothetical questions if they", "first one also mentions that it is a hypothetical question;", "generally close hypothetical questions if they are perfectly feasible, as", "questions asking more generally, \"Is [specific behavior related to academia]", "behavior]?\" There are many examples of such questions in the", "appears to be that it asks about legal issues. Inconsistency", "then reopened after it was changed from \"legal\" to \"ethical\")", "[Panelist hacks my system during a defense, is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions)", "is. So the issue appears to be that it asks", "to questions asking more generally, \"Is [specific behavior related to", "\"Is [specific behavior related to academia] legal?\" or \"What are", "to have a very inconsistent policy with respect to questions", "the legal issues surrounding [some academic behavior]?\" There are many", "clearly related to academia. The close reason for the first", "one also mentions that it is a hypothetical question; but", "we don't generally close hypothetical questions if they are perfectly", "We seem to have a very inconsistent policy with respect", "to questions on legal issues related to academia. I am", "questions that seem just like those, for being off topic", "during a defense, is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was closed, then", "understand whether their question is on topic, and it makes", "I would therefore like to raise this issue for community", "when to vote to close. I would therefore like to", "At the same time, we've closed questions that seem just", "the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag. There are also", "'legal-issues'\") tag. There are also examples of legal questions in", "issue for community discussion: *Are questions on legal issues related", "don't generally close hypothetical questions if they are perfectly feasible,", "(these would certainly be off topic as \"too localized\" or", " [Panelist hacks my system during a defense, is this", "many examples of such questions in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions", "to judge when to vote to close. I would therefore", "a hypothetical question; but we don't generally close hypothetical questions", "contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) * [Panelist hacks my system during a defense, is", "topic as legal questions. For example, * [Are there any", "users to understand whether their question is on topic, and", "difficult for not-so-new users to judge when to vote to", "about legal issues. Inconsistency like this is bad; it makes", "issues surrounding [some academic behavior]?\" There are many examples of", "am not referring to questions asking for legal advice for", "as this one is. So the issue appears to be", "legal questions in other tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions tagged", "also examples of legal questions in other tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa", "these examples, the behavior in question is clearly related to", "with respect to questions on legal issues related to academia.", "particular situation (these would certainly be off topic as \"too", "or \"seeks advice for a very specific situation, so that", "example, * [Are there any laws against professors publishing scientific", "makes it difficult for new users to understand whether their", "For example, * [Are there any laws against professors publishing", "papers without acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) * [Panelist hacks my system", "to close. I would therefore like to raise this issue", "academic behavior]?\" There are many examples of such questions in", "like to raise this issue for community discussion: Are questions", "raise this issue for community discussion: Are questions on legal", "hacks my system during a defense, is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this", "Inconsistency like this is bad; it makes it difficult for", "is bad; it makes it difficult for new users to", "topic, and it makes it difficult for not-so-new users to", "am referring to questions asking more generally, \"Is [specific behavior", "e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions tagged 'visa'\"). At the same time,", "questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag. There are also examples of legal", "off topic as legal questions. For example, * [Are there", "question is on topic, and it makes it difficult for", "to academia] legal?\" or \"What are the legal issues surrounding", "users to judge when to vote to close. I would", "against professors publishing scientific papers without acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) ", "legal issues surrounding [some academic behavior]?\" There are many examples", "legal issues. Inconsistency like this is bad; it makes it", "without acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) [Panelist hacks my system during", "not referring to questions asking for legal advice for a", "of such questions in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\")", "So the issue appears to be that it asks about", "[some academic behavior]?\" There are many examples of such questions", "have a very inconsistent policy with respect to questions on", "same time, we've closed questions that seem just like those,", "objectively correct answer.\") I am referring to questions asking more", "system during a defense, is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was closed,", "are many examples of such questions in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show", "related to academia. The close reason for the first one", "in other tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions tagged 'visa'\"). At", "time, we've closed questions that seem just like those, for", "discussion: Are questions on legal issues related to academia on", "very specific situation, so that only someone close to the", "in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag. There are", "there any laws against professors publishing scientific papers without acknowledging", "\"What are the legal issues surrounding [some academic behavior]?\" There", "tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions tagged 'visa'\"). At the same", "to understand whether their question is on topic, and it", "that only someone close to the situation can give an", "closed questions that seem just like those, for being off", "policy with respect to questions on legal issues related to", "closed, then reopened after it was changed from \"legal\" to", "on topic, and it makes it difficult for not-so-new users", "respect to questions on legal issues related to academia. I", "new users to understand whether their question is on topic,", "that it is a hypothetical question; but we don't generally", "very inconsistent policy with respect to questions on legal issues", "a very inconsistent policy with respect to questions on legal", "questions on legal issues related to academia. I am not", "situation (these would certainly be off topic as \"too localized\"", "reason for the first one also mentions that it is", "therefore like to raise this issue for community discussion: Are", "[specific behavior related to academia] legal?\" or \"What are the", "examples of legal questions in other tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show", "behavior related to academia] legal?\" or \"What are the legal", "* [Are there any laws against professors publishing scientific papers", "In both of these examples, the behavior in question is", "those, for being off topic as legal questions. For example,", "academia. The close reason for the first one also mentions", "The close reason for the first one also mentions that", "also mentions that it is a hypothetical question; but we", "one is. So the issue appears to be that it", "of these examples, the behavior in question is clearly related", "this is bad; it makes it difficult for new users", "legal advice for a particular situation (these would certainly be", "off topic as \"too localized\" or \"seeks advice for a", "for being off topic as legal questions. For example, ", "the situation can give an objectively correct answer.\") I am", "being off topic as legal questions. For example, [Are", "it difficult for new users to understand whether their question", "are the legal issues surrounding [some academic behavior]?\" There are", "questions in other tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions tagged 'visa'\").", "for legal advice for a particular situation (these would certainly", "changed from \"legal\" to \"ethical\") In both of these examples,", "for the first one also mentions that it is a", "mentions that it is a hypothetical question; but we don't", "vote to close. I would therefore like to raise this", "makes it difficult for not-so-new users to judge when to", "they are perfectly feasible, as this one is. So the", "to \"ethical\") In both of these examples, the behavior in", "situation, so that only someone close to the situation can", "was changed from \"legal\" to \"ethical\") In both of these", "There are many examples of such questions in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues", "we've closed questions that seem just like those, for being", "more generally, \"Is [specific behavior related to academia] legal?\" or", "for a very specific situation, so that only someone close", "a very specific situation, so that only someone close to", "as legal questions. For example, * [Are there any laws", "academia. I am not referring to questions asking for legal", "questions in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag. There", "generally, \"Is [specific behavior related to academia] legal?\" or \"What", "defense, is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was closed, then reopened after", "seem to have a very inconsistent policy with respect to", "close. I would therefore like to raise this issue for", "to academia. I am not referring to questions asking for", "tagged 'visa'\"). At the same time, we've closed questions that", "publishing scientific papers without acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) * [Panelist hacks", "close reason for the first one also mentions that it", "[visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions tagged 'visa'\"). At the same time, we've", "community discussion: *Are questions on legal issues related to academia", "I am not referring to questions asking for legal advice", "of legal questions in other tags, e.g. [visa](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/visa \"show questions", "referring to questions asking more generally, \"Is [specific behavior related", "professors publishing scientific papers without acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) [Panelist", "issues. Inconsistency like this is bad; it makes it difficult", "behavior in question is clearly related to academia. The close", "laws against professors publishing scientific papers without acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno)", "\"seeks advice for a very specific situation, so that only", "after it was changed from \"legal\" to \"ethical\") In both", "advice for a very specific situation, so that only someone", "would certainly be off topic as \"too localized\" or \"seeks", "correct answer.\") I am referring to questions asking more generally,", "I am referring to questions asking more generally, \"Is [specific", "topic as \"too localized\" or \"seeks advice for a very", "hypothetical questions if they are perfectly feasible, as this one", "issue appears to be that it asks about legal issues.", "[legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag. There are also examples", "from \"legal\" to \"ethical\") In both of these examples, the", "examples, the behavior in question is clearly related to academia.", "a particular situation (these would certainly be off topic as", "Are questions on legal issues related to academia on topic?", "legal questions. For example, * [Are there any laws against", "the behavior in question is clearly related to academia. The", "be that it asks about legal issues. Inconsistency like this", "this issue for community discussion: Are questions on legal issues", "legal?\" or \"What are the legal issues surrounding [some academic", "as \"too localized\" or \"seeks advice for a very specific", "seem just like those, for being off topic as legal", "my system during a defense, is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was", "\"legal\" to \"ethical\") In both of these examples, the behavior", "hypothetical question; but we don't generally close hypothetical questions if", "close hypothetical questions if they are perfectly feasible, as this", "it makes it difficult for not-so-new users to judge when", "for community discussion: Are questions on legal issues related to", "a defense, is this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was closed, then reopened", "scientific papers without acknowledging student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) * [Panelist hacks my", "student's contributions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31052/are-there-any-laws-against-professors-publishing-scientific-papers-without-ackno) * [Panelist hacks my system during a defense,", "answer.\") I am referring to questions asking more generally, \"Is", "examples of such questions in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged", "legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was closed, then reopened after it was changed", "the first one also mentions that it is a hypothetical", "just like those, for being off topic as legal questions.", "to questions asking for legal advice for a particular situation", "advice for a particular situation (these would certainly be off", "asking for legal advice for a particular situation (these would", "any laws against professors publishing scientific papers without acknowledging student's", "on legal issues related to academia. I am not referring", "localized\" or \"seeks advice for a very specific situation, so", "not-so-new users to judge when to vote to close. I", "for not-so-new users to judge when to vote to close.", "asking more generally, \"Is [specific behavior related to academia] legal?\"", "like those, for being off topic as legal questions. For", "reopened after it was changed from \"legal\" to \"ethical\") In", "questions. For example, * [Are there any laws against professors", "it is a hypothetical question; but we don't generally close", "if they are perfectly feasible, as this one is. So", "legal issues related to academia. I am not referring to", "(this was closed, then reopened after it was changed from", "inconsistent policy with respect to questions on legal issues related", "referring to questions asking for legal advice for a particular", "related to academia] legal?\" or \"What are the legal issues", "academia] legal?\" or \"What are the legal issues surrounding [some", "only someone close to the situation can give an objectively", "related to academia. I am not referring to questions asking", "would therefore like to raise this issue for community discussion:", "like this is bad; it makes it difficult for new", "certainly be off topic as \"too localized\" or \"seeks advice", "tag. There are also examples of legal questions in other", "is clearly related to academia. The close reason for the", "for new users to understand whether their question is on", "this legal?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/28530/revisions) (this was closed, then reopened after it was", "and it makes it difficult for not-so-new users to judge", "are also examples of legal questions in other tags, e.g.", "it difficult for not-so-new users to judge when to vote", "bad; it makes it difficult for new users to understand", "\"show questions tagged 'visa'\"). At the same time, we've closed", "the same time, we've closed questions that seem just like", "\"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag. There are also examples of", "this one is. So the issue appears to be that", "whether their question is on topic, and it makes it", "issues related to academia. I am not referring to questions", "such questions in the [legal-issues](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/legal-issues \"show questions tagged 'legal-issues'\") tag." ]
[ "I have \"10 rep on this site\". I have 101", "rep on this site\". I have 101 rep, 1 of", "is that it was granted because I am \"trusted elsewhere", "[This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31065/12378) is now protected due to supposed \"low-quality answers\",", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31065/12378) is now protected due to supposed \"low-quality answers\", and", "answers\", and the banner says that I cannot answer it", "it is that it was granted because I am \"trusted", "and the banner says that I cannot answer it until", "have \"10 rep on this site\". I have 101 rep,", "bonus. Surely this bonus ought to count? The entire point", "protected due to supposed \"low-quality answers\", and the banner says", "banner says that I cannot answer it until I have", "this site\". I have 101 rep, 1 of which came", "the banner says that I cannot answer it until I", "of which is association bonus. Surely this bonus ought to", "1 of which came from joining and 100 of which", "now protected due to supposed \"low-quality answers\", and the banner", "rep, 1 of which came from joining and 100 of", "is association bonus. Surely this bonus ought to count? The", "answer it until I have \"10 rep on this site\".", "association bonus. Surely this bonus ought to count? The entire", "until I have \"10 rep on this site\". I have", "it until I have \"10 rep on this site\". I", "was granted because I am \"trusted elsewhere in the network\".", "to supposed \"low-quality answers\", and the banner says that I", "site\". I have 101 rep, 1 of which came from", "to count? The entire point of it is that it", "cannot answer it until I have \"10 rep on this", "on this site\". I have 101 rep, 1 of which", "says that I cannot answer it until I have \"10", "which is association bonus. Surely this bonus ought to count?", "The entire point of it is that it was granted", "I have 101 rep, 1 of which came from joining", "point of it is that it was granted because I", "of it is that it was granted because I am", "and 100 of which is association bonus. Surely this bonus", "Surely this bonus ought to count? The entire point of", "which came from joining and 100 of which is association", "is now protected due to supposed \"low-quality answers\", and the", "that I cannot answer it until I have \"10 rep", "have 101 rep, 1 of which came from joining and", "\"10 rep on this site\". I have 101 rep, 1", "joining and 100 of which is association bonus. Surely this", "supposed \"low-quality answers\", and the banner says that I cannot", "100 of which is association bonus. Surely this bonus ought", "it was granted because I am \"trusted elsewhere in the", "this bonus ought to count? The entire point of it", "from joining and 100 of which is association bonus. Surely", "101 rep, 1 of which came from joining and 100", "ought to count? The entire point of it is that", "I cannot answer it until I have \"10 rep on", "count? The entire point of it is that it was", "of which came from joining and 100 of which is", "that it was granted because I am \"trusted elsewhere in", "entire point of it is that it was granted because", "came from joining and 100 of which is association bonus.", "due to supposed \"low-quality answers\", and the banner says that", "bonus ought to count? The entire point of it is", "\"low-quality answers\", and the banner says that I cannot answer" ]
[ "perfectly genuine. Should we delete answers linking to commercial solutions,", "open-source solution. I can't help but think that the entire", "think that the entire question was a disguised advertisement for", "be perfectly genuine. Should we delete answers linking to commercial", "it could be perfectly genuine. Should we delete answers linking", "the entire question was a disguised advertisement for that product,", "I can't help but think that the entire question was", "advertisement for that product, although it could be perfectly genuine.", "could be perfectly genuine. Should we delete answers linking to", "attracted several answers, included one by the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which", "The question [Free, open-source substitutes for Mendeley?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5352/free-open-source-substitutes-for-mendeley/8476#8476) attracted several answers,", "hosting) and a free open-source solution. I can't help but", "several answers, included one by the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines", "Mendeley?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5352/free-open-source-substitutes-for-mendeley/8476#8476) attracted several answers, included one by the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>,", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines both a commercial solution (for hosting) and", "[Free, open-source substitutes for Mendeley?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5352/free-open-source-substitutes-for-mendeley/8476#8476) attracted several answers, included one", "genuine. Should we delete answers linking to commercial solutions, in", "question was a disguised advertisement for that product, although it", "entire question was a disguised advertisement for that product, although", "one by the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines both a commercial", "a disguised advertisement for that product, although it could be", "and a free open-source solution. I can't help but think", "substitutes for Mendeley?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5352/free-open-source-substitutes-for-mendeley/8476#8476) attracted several answers, included one by the", "both a commercial solution (for hosting) and a free open-source", "linking to commercial solutions, in order to avoid disguised advertisement?", "that product, although it could be perfectly genuine. Should we", "although it could be perfectly genuine. Should we delete answers", "free open-source solution. I can't help but think that the", "a commercial solution (for hosting) and a free open-source solution.", "Should we delete answers linking to commercial solutions, in order", "by the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines both a commercial solution", "open-source substitutes for Mendeley?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5352/free-open-source-substitutes-for-mendeley/8476#8476) attracted several answers, included one by", "that the entire question was a disguised advertisement for that", "was a disguised advertisement for that product, although it could", "answers linking to commercial solutions, in order to avoid disguised", "product, although it could be perfectly genuine. Should we delete", "for Mendeley?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5352/free-open-source-substitutes-for-mendeley/8476#8476) attracted several answers, included one by the OP", "a free open-source solution. I can't help but think that", "answers, included one by the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines both", "delete answers linking to commercial solutions, in order to avoid", "the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines both a commercial solution (for", "commercial solution (for hosting) and a free open-source solution. I", "included one by the OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines both a", "help but think that the entire question was a disguised", "we delete answers linking to commercial solutions, in order to", "for that product, although it could be perfectly genuine. Should", "question [Free, open-source substitutes for Mendeley?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5352/free-open-source-substitutes-for-mendeley/8476#8476) attracted several answers, included", "which combines both a commercial solution (for hosting) and a", "OP <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/8476/102>, which combines both a commercial solution (for hosting)", "solution. I can't help but think that the entire question", "but think that the entire question was a disguised advertisement", "can't help but think that the entire question was a", "combines both a commercial solution (for hosting) and a free", "disguised advertisement for that product, although it could be perfectly", "solution (for hosting) and a free open-source solution. I can't", "(for hosting) and a free open-source solution. I can't help" ]
[ "their questions. Is there a practical way of reminding the", "one, where there are both real and hypothetical situations with", "had a few questions in the past similar in concept,", "a user history back for most people on the site,", "warning can be provided when a tag is provided, such", "and so on. In this one, where there are both", "Is there a practical way of reminding the user before", "question is posted? I know it's relatively easy to trace", "provided, such as ethics, legal issues, or any sort of", "similar in concept, but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one of the", "posting in their questions. Is there a practical way of", "and hypothetical situations with major implications, people have been using", "our real names there, and so on. In this one,", "we've had a few questions in the past similar in", "names there, and so on. In this one, where there", "anonymity factor is immediately gone. I assume this warning can", "I know it's relatively easy to trace a user history", "know StackOverflow has such a feature for tag synonyms. ![StackOverflow", "trace a user history back for most people on the", "have this issue. We can use our real names there,", "but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one of the potential issues with", "real names there, and so on. In this one, where", "real ethical issues are not being presented, don't have this", "their real pictures, and everything they shouldn't be potentially posting", "user before the question is posted? I know it's relatively", "legal issues, or any sort of misconduct. I know StackOverflow", "can be provided when a tag is provided, such as", "legal issues and real ethical issues are not being presented,", "I know we've had a few questions in the past", "but when Google caches this question almost instantly, the anonymity", "sort of misconduct. I know StackOverflow has such a feature", "where legal issues and real ethical issues are not being", "the past similar in concept, but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one", "misconduct. I know StackOverflow has such a feature for tag", "reminding the user before the question is posted? I know", "with major implications, people have been using their real names,", "people have been using their real names, their websites, their", "back for most people on the site, but when Google", "to trace a user history back for most people on", "like Stack Overflow, where legal issues and real ethical issues", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one of the potential issues with open", "be potentially posting in their questions. Is there a practical", "when Google caches this question almost instantly, the anonymity factor", "of the potential issues with open naming. Other Stack Exchanges", "the question is posted? I know it's relatively easy to", "issues and real ethical issues are not being presented, don't", "is immediately gone. I assume this warning can be provided", "I know StackOverflow has such a feature for tag synonyms.", "most people on the site, but when Google caches this", "in concept, but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one of the potential", "not being presented, don't have this issue. We can use", "one of the potential issues with open naming. Other Stack", "posted? I know it's relatively easy to trace a user", "a practical way of reminding the user before the question", "of reminding the user before the question is posted? I", "and everything they shouldn't be potentially posting in their questions.", "be provided when a tag is provided, such as ethics,", "such as ethics, legal issues, or any sort of misconduct.", "this issue. We can use our real names there, and", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one of the potential issues with open naming.", "presented, don't have this issue. We can use our real", "their real names, their websites, their real pictures, and everything", "when a tag is provided, such as ethics, legal issues,", "and real ethical issues are not being presented, don't have", "hypothetical situations with major implications, people have been using their", "factor is immediately gone. I assume this warning can be", "way of reminding the user before the question is posted?", "has such a feature for tag synonyms. ![StackOverflow Tag Warning](https://i.stack.imgur.com/cmRc1.png)", "In this one, where there are both real and hypothetical", "user history back for most people on the site, but", "the user before the question is posted? I know it's", "this question almost instantly, the anonymity factor is immediately gone.", "it's relatively easy to trace a user history back for", "know it's relatively easy to trace a user history back", "are both real and hypothetical situations with major implications, people", "Stack Exchanges like Stack Overflow, where legal issues and real", "concept, but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one of the potential issues", "tag is provided, such as ethics, legal issues, or any", "can use our real names there, and so on. In", "indicates one of the potential issues with open naming. Other", "assume this warning can be provided when a tag is", "so on. In this one, where there are both real", "caches this question almost instantly, the anonymity factor is immediately", "provided when a tag is provided, such as ethics, legal", "this one, where there are both real and hypothetical situations", "the anonymity factor is immediately gone. I assume this warning", "real and hypothetical situations with major implications, people have been", "is posted? I know it's relatively easy to trace a", "websites, their real pictures, and everything they shouldn't be potentially", "real names, their websites, their real pictures, and everything they", "for most people on the site, but when Google caches", "question almost instantly, the anonymity factor is immediately gone. I", "there, and so on. In this one, where there are", "naming. Other Stack Exchanges like Stack Overflow, where legal issues", "shouldn't be potentially posting in their questions. Is there a", "Google caches this question almost instantly, the anonymity factor is", "questions in the past similar in concept, but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do)", "situations with major implications, people have been using their real", "issues with open naming. Other Stack Exchanges like Stack Overflow,", "gone. I assume this warning can be provided when a", "been using their real names, their websites, their real pictures,", "their websites, their real pictures, and everything they shouldn't be", "a tag is provided, such as ethics, legal issues, or", "have been using their real names, their websites, their real", "history back for most people on the site, but when", "ethical issues are not being presented, don't have this issue.", "instantly, the anonymity factor is immediately gone. I assume this", "of misconduct. I know StackOverflow has such a feature for", "or any sort of misconduct. I know StackOverflow has such", "people on the site, but when Google caches this question", "know we've had a few questions in the past similar", "being presented, don't have this issue. We can use our", "they shouldn't be potentially posting in their questions. Is there", "implications, people have been using their real names, their websites,", "issues are not being presented, don't have this issue. We", "pictures, and everything they shouldn't be potentially posting in their", "everything they shouldn't be potentially posting in their questions. Is", "I assume this warning can be provided when a tag", "use our real names there, and so on. In this", "potentially posting in their questions. Is there a practical way", "Stack Overflow, where legal issues and real ethical issues are", "relatively easy to trace a user history back for most", "potential issues with open naming. Other Stack Exchanges like Stack", "is provided, such as ethics, legal issues, or any sort", "Other Stack Exchanges like Stack Overflow, where legal issues and", "before the question is posted? I know it's relatively easy", "immediately gone. I assume this warning can be provided when", "real pictures, and everything they shouldn't be potentially posting in", "We can use our real names there, and so on.", "don't have this issue. We can use our real names", "ethics, legal issues, or any sort of misconduct. I know", "using their real names, their websites, their real pictures, and", "where there are both real and hypothetical situations with major", "open naming. Other Stack Exchanges like Stack Overflow, where legal", "the site, but when Google caches this question almost instantly,", "site, but when Google caches this question almost instantly, the", "any sort of misconduct. I know StackOverflow has such a", "Exchanges like Stack Overflow, where legal issues and real ethical", "on. In this one, where there are both real and", "on the site, but when Google caches this question almost", "this warning can be provided when a tag is provided,", "with open naming. Other Stack Exchanges like Stack Overflow, where", "names, their websites, their real pictures, and everything they shouldn't", "there are both real and hypothetical situations with major implications,", "practical way of reminding the user before the question is", "there a practical way of reminding the user before the", "past similar in concept, but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates one of", "as ethics, legal issues, or any sort of misconduct. I", "few questions in the past similar in concept, but [this", "easy to trace a user history back for most people", "questions. Is there a practical way of reminding the user", "in the past similar in concept, but [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31265/my-professor-is-rigging-data-and-plagiarizing-what-can-i-do) indicates", "major implications, people have been using their real names, their", "StackOverflow has such a feature for tag synonyms. ![StackOverflow Tag", "issues, or any sort of misconduct. I know StackOverflow has", "the potential issues with open naming. Other Stack Exchanges like", "Overflow, where legal issues and real ethical issues are not", "are not being presented, don't have this issue. We can", "a few questions in the past similar in concept, but", "issue. We can use our real names there, and so", "both real and hypothetical situations with major implications, people have", "in their questions. Is there a practical way of reminding", "almost instantly, the anonymity factor is immediately gone. I assume" ]
[ "questions pertaining to undergraduate students, classes and degrees are relevant", "are often confused that while questions pertaining to undergraduate students,", "are not particularly involved in AC.SE are often confused that", "please do not ask questions about undergraduate-specific issues that could", "in AC.SE are often confused that while questions pertaining to", "was hoping that we could develop a nice summary statement", "center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: > > please do not ask questions about", "and degrees are relevant to academia, we generally consider them", "issues that could not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians", "Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at this time, I am not sure what", "but at this time, I am not sure what to", "It seems SE users that are not particularly involved in", "off topic at AC.SE. I was hoping that we could", "do not ask questions about undergraduate-specific issues that could not", "questions about undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to graduate", "to academia, we generally consider them off topic at AC.SE.", "involved in AC.SE are often confused that while questions pertaining", "while questions pertaining to undergraduate students, classes and degrees are", "or post-graduate academicians > > > Potentially, this could be", "to undergraduate students, classes and degrees are relevant to academia,", "we generally consider them off topic at AC.SE. I was", "students, classes and degrees are relevant to academia, we generally", "summary statement that explains why our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: >", "added to [Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at this time, I", "to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at this time, I am not sure", "consider them off topic at AC.SE. I was hoping that", "that we could develop a nice summary statement that explains", "develop a nice summary statement that explains why our [help", "undergraduate students, classes and degrees are relevant to academia, we", "degrees are relevant to academia, we generally consider them off", "classes and degrees are relevant to academia, we generally consider", "> Potentially, this could be added to [Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se),", "says: > > please do not ask questions about undergraduate-specific", "generally consider them off topic at AC.SE. I was hoping", "pertaining to undergraduate students, classes and degrees are relevant to", "our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: > > please do not ask", "to graduate or post-graduate academicians > > > Potentially, this", "post-graduate academicians > > > Potentially, this could be added", "apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians > > > Potentially,", "about undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to graduate or", "ask questions about undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to", "confused that while questions pertaining to undergraduate students, classes and", "[help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: > > please do not ask questions", "seems SE users that are not particularly involved in AC.SE", "academia, we generally consider them off topic at AC.SE. I", "topic at AC.SE. I was hoping that we could develop", "[Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at this time, I am not", "> please do not ask questions about undergraduate-specific issues that", "that could not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians >", "particularly involved in AC.SE are often confused that while questions", "> > > Potentially, this could be added to [Welcome", "relevant to academia, we generally consider them off topic at", "not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians > > >", "could not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians > >", "we could develop a nice summary statement that explains why", "be added to [Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at this time,", "not ask questions about undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply", "users that are not particularly involved in AC.SE are often", "SE users that are not particularly involved in AC.SE are", "that while questions pertaining to undergraduate students, classes and degrees", "academicians > > > Potentially, this could be added to", "why our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: > > please do not", "explains why our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: > > please do", "to [Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at this time, I am", "AC.SE. I was hoping that we could develop a nice", "undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to graduate or post-graduate", "at this time, I am not sure what to say.", "statement that explains why our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: > >", "graduate or post-graduate academicians > > > Potentially, this could", "a nice summary statement that explains why our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "nice summary statement that explains why our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says:", "hoping that we could develop a nice summary statement that", "could be added to [Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at this", "could develop a nice summary statement that explains why our", "this could be added to [Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but at", "I was hoping that we could develop a nice summary", "> > please do not ask questions about undergraduate-specific issues", "at AC.SE. I was hoping that we could develop a", "> > Potentially, this could be added to [Welcome to", "them off topic at AC.SE. I was hoping that we", "Potentially, this could be added to [Welcome to Academia.SE!](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se), but", "are relevant to academia, we generally consider them off topic", "not particularly involved in AC.SE are often confused that while", "that are not particularly involved in AC.SE are often confused", "AC.SE are often confused that while questions pertaining to undergraduate", "that explains why our [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) says: > > please", "often confused that while questions pertaining to undergraduate students, classes" ]
[ "the original question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > > Title:", "and created a country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is the original", "ask one question per country, or otherwise how can I", "In which countries is consent required by law to take", "on the USA only. > > > I'd also be", "be fine with a list of countries where consent is", "of a conference talk in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as the", "a picture or to record audio / video of a", "I deleted and created a country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is", "that close voters complain that I am asking for all", "countries is consent required by law to take a picture", "> > Title: In which countries is consent required by", "the USA only. > > > I'd also be fine", "> > > I'd also be fine with a list", "consent is not > required to take a picture or", "to take a picture or to record audio / video", "conference talk? > > > Body: Provided that the conference", "deleted and created a country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is the", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > > Title: In which countries is consent", "ignoring ethical/political/any other non-legal issues. > > > I am", "picture or to record audio / video of a conference", "Title: In which countries is consent required by law to", "(<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is the original question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png)", "my question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31701/452> received 3 close votes for being too", "law to take a picture > or to record audio", "> or to record audio / video of a conference", "being too broad. It seems that close voters complain that", "and visual recordings of the presentations, and > ignoring ethical/political/any", "is consent required by law to take a picture >", "one. Should I ask one question per country, or otherwise", "that the conference does not explicitly prohibit > unauthorized audio", "also be fine with a list of countries where consent", "talk in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as the question > indicates", "the question > [Is consent required to record audio of", "conference does not explicitly prohibit > unauthorized audio and visual", "prohibit > unauthorized audio and visual recordings of the presentations,", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31701/452> received 3 close votes for being too broad. It", "hold so I deleted and created a country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>).", "country, or otherwise how can I improve the question? ---", "the presentations, and > ignoring ethical/political/any other non-legal issues. >", "as the question > indicates it focuses on the USA", "a conference talk in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as the question", "close votes for being too broad. It seems that close", "it focuses on the USA only. > > > I'd", "> I'd also be fine with a list of countries", "on hold so I deleted and created a country-specific question", "> [Is consent required to record audio of a conference", "fine with a list of countries where consent is not", "It seems that close voters complain that I am asking", "/ video of a conference > talk. > > >", "explicitly prohibit > unauthorized audio and visual recordings of the", "talk? > > > Body: Provided that the conference does", "unauthorized audio and visual recordings of the presentations, and >", "question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is the original question: ![enter image description", "--- The question got on hold so I deleted and", "picture > or to record audio / video of a", "in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as the question > indicates it", "seems that close voters complain that I am asking for", "of countries where consent is not > required to take", "video of a conference talk? > > > Body: Provided", "Provided that the conference does not explicitly prohibit > unauthorized", "with a list of countries where consent is not >", "by law to take a picture > or to record", "a list of countries where consent is not > required", "list of countries where consent is not > required to", "a country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is the original question: ![enter", "> required to take a picture or to record audio", "aware of the question > [Is consent required to record", "country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is the original question: ![enter image", "audio / video of a conference > talk. > >", "recordings of the presentations, and > ignoring ethical/political/any other non-legal", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > > Title: In which countries is consent required", "or otherwise how can I improve the question? --- The", "does not explicitly prohibit > unauthorized audio and visual recordings", "I ask one question per country, or otherwise how can", "to record audio of a conference talk in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452),", "The question got on hold so I deleted and created", "record audio of a conference talk in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but", "got on hold so I deleted and created a country-specific", "> > I'd also be fine with a list of", "to record audio / video of a conference talk? >", "for being too broad. It seems that close voters complain", "question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > > Title: In which", "per country, or otherwise how can I improve the question?", "> indicates it focuses on the USA only. > >", "that my question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31701/452> received 3 close votes for being", "am aware of the question > [Is consent required to", "Below is the original question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) >", "ethical/political/any other non-legal issues. > > > I am aware", "a conference talk? > > > Body: Provided that the", "I improve the question? --- The question got on hold", "all countries instead of just one. Should I ask one", "and > ignoring ethical/political/any other non-legal issues. > > >", "to record audio / video of a conference > talk.", "question per country, or otherwise how can I improve the", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > > Title: In which countries is", "how can I improve the question? --- The question got", "which countries is consent required by law to take a", "other non-legal issues. > > > I am aware of", "3 close votes for being too broad. It seems that", "voters complain that I am asking for all countries instead", "consent required by law to take a picture > or", "audio and visual recordings of the presentations, and > ignoring", "of a conference talk? > > > Body: Provided that", "Should I ask one question per country, or otherwise how", "to take a picture > or to record audio /", "I am asking for all countries instead of just one.", "> > I am aware of the question > [Is", "not > required to take a picture or to record", "countries where consent is not > required to take a", "can I improve the question? --- The question got on", "improve the question? --- The question got on hold so", "required by law to take a picture > or to", "where consent is not > required to take a picture", "question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31701/452> received 3 close votes for being too broad.", "not explicitly prohibit > unauthorized audio and visual recordings of", "record audio / video of a conference > talk. >", "only. > > > I'd also be fine with a", "> > > I am aware of the question >", "question > indicates it focuses on the USA only. >", "too broad. It seems that close voters complain that I", "> ignoring ethical/political/any other non-legal issues. > > > I", "see that my question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31701/452> received 3 close votes for", "am asking for all countries instead of just one. Should", "non-legal issues. > > > I am aware of the", "> unauthorized audio and visual recordings of the presentations, and", "but as the question > indicates it focuses on the", "take a picture or to record audio / video of", "the question? --- The question got on hold so I", "close voters complain that I am asking for all countries", "I'd also be fine with a list of countries where", "is not > required to take a picture or to", "> > > Body: Provided that the conference does not", "original question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > > Title: In", "indicates it focuses on the USA only. > > >", "of the presentations, and > ignoring ethical/political/any other non-legal issues.", "instead of just one. Should I ask one question per", "otherwise how can I improve the question? --- The question", "question > [Is consent required to record audio of a", "asking for all countries instead of just one. Should I", "focuses on the USA only. > > > I'd also", "is the original question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > >", "one question per country, or otherwise how can I improve", "issues. > > > I am aware of the question", "> I am aware of the question > [Is consent", "broad. It seems that close voters complain that I am", "record audio / video of a conference talk? > >", "[Is consent required to record audio of a conference talk", "the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as the question > indicates it focuses", "visual recordings of the presentations, and > ignoring ethical/political/any other", "just one. Should I ask one question per country, or", "Body: Provided that the conference does not explicitly prohibit >", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/jhwbA.png) > > Title: In which countries", "I am aware of the question > [Is consent required", "of the question > [Is consent required to record audio", "> Title: In which countries is consent required by law", "required to record audio of a conference talk in the", "consent required to record audio of a conference talk in", "USA only. > > > I'd also be fine with", "question? --- The question got on hold so I deleted", "required to take a picture or to record audio /", "a picture > or to record audio / video of", "created a country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below is the original question:", "/ video of a conference talk? > > > Body:", "or to record audio / video of a conference >", "countries instead of just one. Should I ask one question", "question got on hold so I deleted and created a", "that I am asking for all countries instead of just", "take a picture > or to record audio / video", "> Body: Provided that the conference does not explicitly prohibit", "presentations, and > ignoring ethical/political/any other non-legal issues. > >", "conference talk in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as the question >", "the question > indicates it focuses on the USA only.", "for all countries instead of just one. Should I ask", "audio / video of a conference talk? > > >", "of just one. Should I ask one question per country,", "received 3 close votes for being too broad. It seems", "US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as the question > indicates it focuses on", "votes for being too broad. It seems that close voters", "so I deleted and created a country-specific question (<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31806/452>). Below", "or to record audio / video of a conference talk?", "I see that my question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31701/452> received 3 close votes", "> > Body: Provided that the conference does not explicitly", "the conference does not explicitly prohibit > unauthorized audio and", "audio of a conference talk in the US?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17005/452), but as", "complain that I am asking for all countries instead of" ]
[ "Three things to note: * Any user can opt out", "Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (not hats", "design, for example) * After the event ends, the hats", "by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there is no", "Apart from the wearing of hats by avatars, the site", "In 2014, Stack Exchange will continue its tradition of the", "the comments according to your preference. If you want to", "can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats in a", "year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This being said, we (as a", "badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving a hat, which", "have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange", "run on any Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate.", "can opt out (clicking an option in your profile means", "other answers. The poll will close on November 28, 2014.", "whether we will participate in the Cultep Besh 2014 Edition,", "to a close. Three things to note: * *Any user", "a close. Three things to note: Any user can", "[\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh is an annual event that can", "choice to opt out entirely and have the Cultep Besh", "the amazing people who make the sites awesome, as the", "according to your preference. If you want to discuss further,", "and 2013, we chose to participate. To decide whether we", "* After the event ends, the hats disappear without a", "for anyone). In 2012 and 2013, we chose to participate.", "on Academia Stack Exchange (not hats for anyone). In 2012", "note: * Any user can opt out (clicking an option", "with two comments. Upvote one of the comments according to", "comments according to your preference. If you want to discuss", "or comments to other answers. The poll will close on", "entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia", "--- This being said, we (as a community) also have", "is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of the", "We track everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard that", "two comments. Upvote one of the comments according to your", "disappear without a trace. You can see FAQs from last", "disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (not hats for anyone). In", "participate. To decide whether we will participate in the Cultep", "Besh as a a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate", "Any user can opt out** (clicking an option in your", "event that can run on any Stack Exchange site that", "Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (not hats for", "to participate. To decide whether we will participate in the", "an option in your profile means you won't see any", "for their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges).", "answer or comments to other answers. The poll will close", "site's design, for example) * After the event ends, the", "screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a fun", "FAQs from last year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This being said,", "looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees", "hat at all). * Apart from the wearing of hats", "Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing certain tasks", "as the year draws to a close. Three things to", "things to note: * Any user can opt out (clicking", "any hat at all). * Apart from the wearing of", "in the Cultep Besh 2014 Edition, *I've created a “poll”", "Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats”", "In 2012 and 2013, we chose to participate. To decide", "draws to a close. Three things to note: Any", "Besh 2014 Edition, I've created a “poll” below this post*,", "its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh is an", "who make the sites awesome, as the year draws to", "your profile means you won't see any* hat at all).", "Exchange will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep", "the event ends, the hats disappear without a trace. You", "trigger the user receiving a hat, which their gravatar can", "option in your profile means you won't see any hat", "leave an answer or comments to other answers. The poll", "created a “poll” below this post, with two comments. Upvote", "can see FAQs from last year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This", "* Any user can opt out (clicking an option in", "completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the", "track everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard that looks", "preference.** If you want to discuss further, leave an answer", "fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people who", "the wearing of hats by avatars, the site is otherwise", "lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people who make the", "we (as a community) also have to choice to opt", "their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats", "a community) also have to choice to opt out entirely", "After the event ends, the hats disappear without a trace.", "decide whether we will participate in the Cultep Besh 2014", "an annual event that can run on any Stack Exchange", "from last year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This being said, we", "the year draws to a close. Three things to note:", "being said, we (as a community) also have to choice", "amazing people who make the sites awesome, as the year", "of hats by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there", "the hats disappear without a trace. You can see FAQs", "and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people who make", "example) * After the event ends, the hats disappear without", "want to discuss further, leave an answer or comments to", "* Apart from the wearing of hats by avatars, the", "user can opt out** (clicking an option in your profile", "sites awesome, as the year draws to a close. Three", "at all). * Apart from the wearing of hats by", "You can see FAQs from last year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). ---", "trace. You can see FAQs from last year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq).", "To decide whether we will participate in the Cultep Besh", "I've created a “poll” below this post, with two comments.", "as a a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the", "see any hat at all). * Apart from the wearing", "make the sites awesome, as the year draws to a", "way to celebrate the amazing people who make the sites", "can run on any Stack Exchange site that chooses to", "a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s", "site is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of", "2012 and 2013, we chose to participate. To decide whether", "progress earning hats in a leaderboard that looks something like", "participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing certain", "from the wearing of hats by avatars, the site is", "close. Three things to note: * *Any user can opt", "event ends, the hats disappear without a trace. You can", "also have to choice to opt out entirely and have", "that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars", "the site is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme", "to badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving a hat,", "no “holiday” theme of the site's design, for example) ", "to opt out entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely", "we will participate in the Cultep Besh 2014 Edition, I've", "to participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing", "the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (not", "Edition, I've created a “poll” below this post, with two", "Cultep Besh 2014 Edition, I've created a “poll” below this", "“poll” below this post, with two comments. Upvote one of", "people who make the sites awesome, as the year draws", "the sites awesome, as the year draws to a close.", "Exchange (not hats for anyone). In 2012 and 2013, we", "[here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This being said, we (as a community) also", "below this post, with two comments. Upvote one of the", "that can run on any Stack Exchange site that chooses", "without a trace. You can see FAQs from last year's", "theme of the site's design, for example) * After the", "which their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning", "Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a", "out (clicking an option in your profile means you won't", "their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain", "comments to other answers. The poll will close on November", "will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh", "chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by", "out entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on", "further, leave an answer or comments to other answers. The", "Besh is an annual event that can run on any", "by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger", "chose to participate. To decide whether we will participate in", "on any Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users", "of the comments according to your preference. If you want", "an answer or comments to other answers. The poll will", "all). * Apart from the wearing of hats by avatars,", "avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday”", "you won't see any hat at all). * Apart from", "otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of the site's", "(there is no “holiday” theme of the site's design, for", "![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a", "unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of the site's design,", "is no “holiday” theme of the site's design, for example)", "the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh is an annual event that", "Upvote one of the comments according to your preference. If", "anyone). In 2012 and 2013, we chose to participate. To", "a a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing", "awesome, as the year draws to a close. Three things", "in your profile means you won't see any hat at", "Stack Exchange (not hats for anyone). In 2012 and 2013,", "post, with two comments. Upvote one of the comments according", "Academia Stack Exchange (not hats for anyone). In 2012 and", "any Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users earn", "tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving", "wearing of hats by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected", "user receiving a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We", "is an annual event that can run on any Stack", "everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard that looks something", "This being said, we (as a community) also have to", "see FAQs from last year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This being", "Cultep Besh as a a fun and lighthearted way to", "the site's design, for example) * After the event ends,", "of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh is an annual event", "tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh is an annual", "hats in a leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep", "celebrate the amazing people who make the sites awesome, as", "earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous", "opt out** (clicking an option in your profile means you", "means you won't see any hat at all). * Apart", "promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This being said, we (as a community)", "hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress", "earning hats in a leaderboard that looks something like this:", "2014 Edition, I've created a “poll” below this post, with", "(analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving a", "to discuss further, leave an answer or comments to other", "discuss further, leave an answer or comments to other answers.", "a trace. You can see FAQs from last year's promotion", "(as a community) also have to choice to opt out", "comments. Upvote one of the comments according to your preference.", "(clicking an option in your profile means you won't see", "and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack", "a “poll” below this post, with two comments. Upvote one", "2013, we chose to participate. To decide whether we will", "gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions", "something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep", "to your preference.** If you want to discuss further, leave", "sees Cultep Besh as a a fun and lighthearted way", "(not hats for anyone). In 2012 and 2013, we chose", "said, we (as a community) also have to choice to", "Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh is an annual event that can run", "completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (not hats for anyone).", "annual event that can run on any Stack Exchange site", "to note: * Any user can opt out (clicking an", "that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange", "certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the user", "opt out entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled", "this post, with two comments. Upvote one of the comments", "leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack", "in a leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh", "like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh", "site that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for their", "won't see any hat at all). * Apart from the", "hats disappear without a trace. You can see FAQs from", "have to choice to opt out entirely and have the", "we chose to participate. To decide whether we will participate", "of the site's design, for example) * After the event", "to choice to opt out entirely and have the Cultep", "If you want to discuss further, leave an answer or", "“hats” for their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to", "gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats in", "last year's promotion [here](http://winterbash2013.stackexchange.com/faq). --- This being said, we (as", "“wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard", "Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a fun and lighthearted", "your preference.** If you want to discuss further, leave an", "profile means you won't see any hat at all). ", "for example) After the event ends, the hats disappear", "hats by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there is", "the Cultep Besh 2014 Edition, I've created a “poll” below", "actions trigger the user receiving a hat, which their gravatar", "Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a fun and", "a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people", "participate in the Cultep Besh 2014 Edition, I've created a", "Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for", "“holiday” theme of the site's design, for example) * After", "2014, Stack Exchange will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep", "year draws to a close. Three things to note: ", "to celebrate the amazing people who make the sites awesome,", "continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash). Cultep Besh is", "ends, the hats disappear without a trace. You can see", "Certain actions trigger the user receiving a hat, which their", "one of the comments according to your preference.* If you", "Stack Exchange will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://stackexchange.com/promos/12/winter-bash).", "receiving a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We track", "will participate in the Cultep Besh 2014 Edition, **I've created", "you want to discuss further, leave an answer or comments", "Cultep Besh is an annual event that can run on", "community) also have to choice to opt out entirely and", "a leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg)", "to other answers. The poll will close on November 28,", "hats for anyone). In 2012 and 2013, we chose to", "the user receiving a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”.", "this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as" ]
[ "A lot actually. Related: [Not enough distinction between visited links", "I like Academia's site design. It is very pretty. I", "roughly this shade I recommend increasing the contrast a bit.", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > > > If everyone sees", "does not stand out very well. Perhaps it is my", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > > > If everyone sees roughly", "shade I recommend increasing the contrast a bit. A lot", "sees roughly this shade I recommend increasing the contrast a", "a snapshot Tell me if you can see the link", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > > > If everyone sees roughly this", "Related: [Not enough distinction between visited links and unvisited in", "you can see the link text without having to see", "> > ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > > > If", "design. It is very pretty. I don't like the link", "enough distinction between visited links and unvisited in the questions", "the link text without having to see the image that", "the contrast a bit. A lot actually. Related: [Not enough", "a bit. A lot actually. Related: [Not enough distinction between", "it below. ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > > ![enter image", "recommend increasing the contrast a bit. A lot actually. Related:", "that underscores it below. ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > >", "underscores it below. ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > > ![enter", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > > ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > >", "my computer so here's a snapshot Tell me if you", "it is my computer so here's a snapshot Tell me", "> > If everyone sees roughly this shade I recommend", "if you can see the link text without having to", "see the link text without having to see the image", "link text color. It does not stand out very well.", "stand out very well. Perhaps it is my computer so", "here's a snapshot Tell me if you can see the", "see the image that underscores it below. ![enter image description", "Academia's site design. It is very pretty. I don't like", "> > > If everyone sees roughly this shade I", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > > ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) >", "bit. A lot actually. Related: [Not enough distinction between visited", "is my computer so here's a snapshot Tell me if", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > > ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png)", "everyone sees roughly this shade I recommend increasing the contrast", "is very pretty. I don't like the link text color.", "well. Perhaps it is my computer so here's a snapshot", "> If everyone sees roughly this shade I recommend increasing", "Perhaps it is my computer so here's a snapshot Tell", "can see the link text without having to see the", "If everyone sees roughly this shade I recommend increasing the", "[Not enough distinction between visited links and unvisited in the", "like the link text color. It does not stand out", "I recommend increasing the contrast a bit. A lot actually.", "contrast a bit. A lot actually. Related: [Not enough distinction", "this shade I recommend increasing the contrast a bit. A", "lot actually. Related: [Not enough distinction between visited links and", "It does not stand out very well. Perhaps it is", "text without having to see the image that underscores it", "below. ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > > ![enter image description", "without having to see the image that underscores it below.", "so here's a snapshot Tell me if you can see", "I don't like the link text color. It does not", "like Academia's site design. It is very pretty. I don't", "having to see the image that underscores it below. ![enter", "Tell me if you can see the link text without", "color. It does not stand out very well. Perhaps it", "me if you can see the link text without having", "image that underscores it below. ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) >", "out very well. Perhaps it is my computer so here's", "very pretty. I don't like the link text color. It", "don't like the link text color. It does not stand", "actually. Related: [Not enough distinction between visited links and unvisited", "the image that underscores it below. ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png)", "snapshot Tell me if you can see the link text", "site design. It is very pretty. I don't like the", "the link text color. It does not stand out very", "to see the image that underscores it below. ![enter image", "computer so here's a snapshot Tell me if you can", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > > > If everyone sees roughly this shade", "text color. It does not stand out very well. Perhaps", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xsUBf.png) > > ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > > >", "very well. Perhaps it is my computer so here's a", "distinction between visited links and unvisited in the questions list](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1070/not-enough-distinction-between-visited-links-and-unvisited-in-the-questions-list)", "not stand out very well. Perhaps it is my computer", "It is very pretty. I don't like the link text", "> ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zf4Ze.png) > > > If everyone", "pretty. I don't like the link text color. It does", "link text without having to see the image that underscores", "increasing the contrast a bit. A lot actually. Related: [Not" ]
[ "circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that", "is a sufficiently important question to be asked separately from", "This comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally", "to the question they're posted on? For the sake of", "I have made my views on this clear in this", "other users). Usually this involves an extended discussion in comments", "or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that", "the original poster or by other users). Usually this involves", "said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention", "delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in", "had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed", "unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same). Thus", "However, Retu Zlerc has suggested in an edit to [another", "this may not be desirable behavior: > > A comment", "the information that I had been typing an answer while", "moderation, once they become obsolete with respect to the question", "intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on", "after they have been edited and improved (either by the", "this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to", "most troubling form of censorship. > > > I think", "be closed, reasons it should be reopened, how to improve", "deleted by a moderator. I have made my views on", "the question. They don't directly relate to the subject of", "the relevant comment thread (from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink comments", "what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information", "my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time", "Usually this involves an extended discussion in comments about whether", "When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they", "with respect to the question they're posted on? For the", "recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining", "in the most troubling form of censorship. > > >", "separately from the post it was just added to. So:", "ones that were deleted by me after I reopened the", "here is the relevant comment thread (from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The", "deleted by me after I reopened the question: ![enter image", "or by other users). Usually this involves an extended discussion", "make it more difficult for readers, who have to review", "was deleted by a moderator. I have made my views", "question has been fixed and reopened, the comments are no", "the question they're posted on? For the sake of transparency,", "whether or not the question should be closed, reasons it", "improved (either by the original poster or by other users).", "was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed --", "It included the information that I had been typing an", "For the sake of transparency, here is the relevant comment", "more difficult for readers, who have to review a long,", "typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user", "Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my", "delete comments that are about moderation, once they become obsolete", "been fixed and reopened, the comments are no longer pertinent", "opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It", "that are about moderation, once they become obsolete with respect", "an edit to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this may not be", "Questions on Academia.SE are often closed, and then reopened after", "closure was appropriate. It included the information that I had", "to be asked separately from the post it was just", "moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that I", "-- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was", "they're posted on? For the sake of transparency, here is", "as obsolete and deleted, or deleted proactively by a moderator", "that this may not be desirable behavior: > > A", "included the information that I had been typing an answer", "a long, obsolete comment thread before getting to more recent", "etc. Once the question has been fixed and reopened, the", "was just added to. So: Should moderators delete comments that", "closed, and then reopened after they have been edited and", "obsolete comment thread before getting to more recent and relevant", "without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a", "deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to", "in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the", "appropriate. It included the information that I had been typing", "or not the question should be closed, reasons it should", "discussion in comments about whether or not the question should", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink comments are the ones that were", "fixed and reopened, the comments are no longer pertinent for", "it should be reopened, how to improve it, etc. Once", "to a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator.", "how to improve it, etc. Once the question has been", "post it was just added to. So: Should moderators delete", "moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion", "after I reopened the question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ct5mg.png) ![enter", "should be reopened, how to improve it, etc. Once the", "by a moderator. I have made my views on this", "moderator. I have made my views on this clear in", "reopened after they have been edited and improved (either by", "closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly", "have made my views on this clear in this question.", "edited and improved (either by the original poster or by", "once they become obsolete with respect to the question they're", "moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions", "to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this may not be desirable behavior:", "the comments are no longer pertinent for purposes of improving", "comments. Therefore, they are typically flagged as obsolete and deleted,", "comments which pertain to them, they participate in the most", "or deleted proactively by a moderator who happens to see", "about moderation, once they become obsolete with respect to the", "have to review a long, obsolete comment thread before getting", "obsolete and deleted, or deleted proactively by a moderator who", "the question, and they make it more difficult for readers,", "the ones that were deleted by me after I reopened", "the sake of transparency, here is the relevant comment thread", "deleted proactively by a moderator who happens to see them.", "made my views on this clear in this question. When", "nullified my actions on this site was deleted by a", "comments are the ones that were deleted by me after", "my views on this clear in this question. When moderators", "about whether or not the question should be closed, reasons", "proactively by a moderator who happens to see them. However,", "improve it, etc. Once the question has been fixed and", "who have to review a long, obsolete comment thread before", "on Academia.SE are often closed, and then reopened after they", "Therefore, they are typically flagged as obsolete and deleted, or", "are typically flagged as obsolete and deleted, or deleted proactively", "to the subject of the question, and they make it", "reopened, how to improve it, etc. Once the question has", "they make it more difficult for readers, who have to", "mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment", "on this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant", "not the question should be closed, reasons it should be", "poster or by other users). Usually this involves an extended", "this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments", "improving the question. They don't directly relate to the subject", "I think this is a sufficiently important question to be", "them. However, Retu Zlerc has suggested in an edit to", "this site was deleted by a moderator. I have made", "by the original poster or by other users). Usually this", "[another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this may not be desirable behavior: >", "question should be closed, reasons it should be reopened, how", "> > A comment of mine was recently deleted without", "not be desirable behavior: > > A comment of mine", "which pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling", "pink comments are the ones that were deleted by me", "Zlerc has suggested in an edit to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that", "> I think this is a sufficiently important question to", "actions on this site was deleted by a moderator. I", "my actions on this site was deleted by a moderator.", "by a moderator who happens to see them. However, Retu", "me after I reopened the question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ct5mg.png)", "comments that are about moderation, once they become obsolete with", "has suggested in an edit to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this", "-- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances", "comments are no longer pertinent for purposes of improving the", "posted on? For the sake of transparency, here is the", "subject of the question, and they make it more difficult", "acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that was", "a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My", "a sufficiently important question to be asked separately from the", "purposes of improving the question. They don't directly relate to", "is the relevant comment thread (from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink", "They don't directly relate to the subject of the question,", "extended discussion in comments about whether or not the question", "involves an extended discussion in comments about whether or not", "the most troubling form of censorship. > > > I", "transparency, here is the relevant comment thread (from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)).", "longer pertinent for purposes of improving the question. They don't", "pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling form", "are the ones that were deleted by me after I", "deleted, or deleted proactively by a moderator who happens to", "comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed", "same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted", "So: Should moderators delete comments that are about moderation, once", "may not be desirable behavior: > > A comment of", "by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly --", "site was deleted by a moderator. I have made my", "(another user had just said the same). Thus my comment", "pertinent for purposes of improving the question. They don't directly", "sufficiently important question to be asked separately from the post", "flagged as obsolete and deleted, or deleted proactively by a", "time and nullified my actions on this site was deleted", "it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the", "from the post it was just added to. So: Should", "(from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink comments are the ones that", "in comments about whether or not the question should be", "edit to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this may not be desirable", "question they're posted on? For the sake of transparency, here", "> A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning", "should be closed, reasons it should be reopened, how to", "it more difficult for readers, who have to review a", "I reopened the question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ct5mg.png) ![enter image", "and improved (either by the original poster or by other", "thread (from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink comments are the ones", "had just said the same). Thus my comment about how", "directly relate to the subject of the question, and they", "asked separately from the post it was just added to.", "> > > I think this is a sufficiently important", "the question should be closed, reasons it should be reopened,", "in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain", "the question has been fixed and reopened, the comments are", "the question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ct5mg.png) ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/7FW33.png)", "unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly", "users). Usually this involves an extended discussion in comments about", "it was just added to. So: Should moderators delete comments", "my time and nullified my actions on this site was", "review a long, obsolete comment thread before getting to more", "of censorship. > > > I think this is a", "on this site was deleted by a moderator. I have", "by me after I reopened the question: ![enter image description", "desirable behavior: > > A comment of mine was recently", "to improve it, etc. Once the question has been fixed", "were deleted by me after I reopened the question: ![enter", "sake of transparency, here is the relevant comment thread (from", "just said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator", "moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate", "> > I think this is a sufficiently important question", "see them. However, Retu Zlerc has suggested in an edit", "I had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally", "are no longer pertinent for purposes of improving the question.", "comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in", "an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had", "an extended discussion in comments about whether or not the", "question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them,", "A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or", "and nullified my actions on this site was deleted by", "difficult for readers, who have to review a long, obsolete", "important question to be asked separately from the post it", "question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment", "how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my", "troubling form of censorship. > > > I think this", "for readers, who have to review a long, obsolete comment", "on? For the sake of transparency, here is the relevant", "Academia.SE are often closed, and then reopened after they have", "question, and they make it more difficult for readers, who", "obsolete with respect to the question they're posted on? For", "respect to the question they're posted on? For the sake", "just added to. So: Should moderators delete comments that are", "long, obsolete comment thread before getting to more recent and", "and reopened, the comments are no longer pertinent for purposes", "this involves an extended discussion in comments about whether or", "closed (another user had just said the same). Thus my", "information that I had been typing an answer while it", "relevant comments. Therefore, they are typically flagged as obsolete and", "was appropriate. It included the information that I had been", "typically flagged as obsolete and deleted, or deleted proactively by", "has been fixed and reopened, the comments are no longer", "are often closed, and then reopened after they have been", "Once the question has been fixed and reopened, the comments", "of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This", "and relevant comments. Therefore, they are typically flagged as obsolete", "become obsolete with respect to the question they're posted on?", "it, etc. Once the question has been fixed and reopened,", "Retu Zlerc has suggested in an edit to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship)", "readers, who have to review a long, obsolete comment thread", "they participate in the most troubling form of censorship. >", "often closed, and then reopened after they have been edited", "recent and relevant comments. Therefore, they are typically flagged as", "reasons it should be reopened, how to improve it, etc.", "no longer pertinent for purposes of improving the question. They", "have been edited and improved (either by the original poster", "think this is a sufficiently important question to be asked", "participate in the most troubling form of censorship. > >", "been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another", "an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate.", "they are typically flagged as obsolete and deleted, or deleted", "clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which", "reopened the question: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ct5mg.png) ![enter image description", "thread before getting to more recent and relevant comments. Therefore,", "censorship. > > > I think this is a sufficiently", "relevant comment thread (from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink comments are", "getting to more recent and relevant comments. Therefore, they are", "and deleted, or deleted proactively by a moderator who happens", "then reopened after they have been edited and improved (either", "that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed", "in an edit to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this may not", "before getting to more recent and relevant comments. Therefore, they", "My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about", "was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by", "comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and", "of improving the question. They don't directly relate to the", "question to be asked separately from the post it was", "a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an", "and they make it more difficult for readers, who have", "be desirable behavior: > > A comment of mine was", "of the question, and they make it more difficult for", "user had just said the same). Thus my comment about", "be asked separately from the post it was just added", "to see them. However, Retu Zlerc has suggested in an", "expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what", "(either by the original poster or by other users). Usually", "suggested in an edit to [another post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this may", "that were deleted by me after I reopened the question:", "the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally", "wasted my time and nullified my actions on this site", "this is a sufficiently important question to be asked separately", "the subject of the question, and they make it more", "to. So: Should moderators delete comments that are about moderation,", "happens to see them. However, Retu Zlerc has suggested in", "a moderator who happens to see them. However, Retu Zlerc", "who happens to see them. However, Retu Zlerc has suggested", "question. They don't directly relate to the subject of the", "about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified", "to review a long, obsolete comment thread before getting to", "they have been edited and improved (either by the original", "comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment.", "more recent and relevant comments. Therefore, they are typically flagged", "original poster or by other users). Usually this involves an", "relate to the subject of the question, and they make", "form of censorship. > > > I think this is", "wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator", "Should moderators delete comments that are about moderation, once they", "behavior: > > A comment of mine was recently deleted", "was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same).", "comment thread (from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink comments are the", "be reopened, how to improve it, etc. Once the question", "about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included", "civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure", "added to. So: Should moderators delete comments that are about", "a moderator. I have made my views on this clear", "them, they participate in the most troubling form of censorship.", "of transparency, here is the relevant comment thread (from [this", "they become obsolete with respect to the question they're posted", "warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question", "that I had been typing an answer while it was", "to them, they participate in the most troubling form of", "the post it was just added to. So: Should moderators", "are about moderation, once they become obsolete with respect to", "pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by a", "don't directly relate to the subject of the question, and", "and then reopened after they have been edited and improved", "relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in the", "moderators delete comments that are about moderation, once they become", "comment thread before getting to more recent and relevant comments.", "by other users). Usually this involves an extended discussion in", "been edited and improved (either by the original poster or", "closed, reasons it should be reopened, how to improve it,", "moderator who happens to see them. However, Retu Zlerc has", "for purposes of improving the question. They don't directly relate", "literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on this", "The pink comments are the ones that were deleted by", "while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said", "to more recent and relevant comments. Therefore, they are typically", "was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was", "reopened, the comments are no longer pertinent for purposes of", "answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just", "views on this clear in this question. When moderators delete", "comments about whether or not the question should be closed,", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32394/how-can-i-tell-whether-a-mathematics-journal-seems-reputable)). The pink comments are the ones that were deleted", "post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/805/is-deleting-comments-a-form-of-censorship) that this may not be desirable behavior: > >" ]
[ "a bit tedious to list all queries I have made,", "I ask a [reference-request](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reference-request) question, before asking I generally Google", "However, some commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence of my efforts", "first pages of results, and I may miss some interesting", "Google Scholar a bunch of words I put in the", "pages of results, and I may miss some interesting results.", "bunch of words I put in the question. It sounds", "provide evidence of my efforts so far. How can I", "I may miss some interesting results. However, some commentators [asked", "reference questions for which I have found no useful information", "when asking reference questions for which I have found no", "[asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence of my efforts so far. How", "the location, time, etc., I only look at the few", "my efforts so far. How can I provide evidence of", "at the few first pages of results, and I may", "list all queries I have made, and it might be", "queries depend on the location, time, etc., I only look", "may miss some interesting results. However, some commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452)", "+ Google Scholar a bunch of words I put in", "question. It sounds a bit tedious to list all queries", "can I provide evidence of my efforts when asking reference", "my efforts when asking reference questions for which I have", "Scholar a bunch of words I put in the question.", "asking I generally Google + Google Scholar a bunch of", "bit tedious to list all queries I have made, and", "to list all queries I have made, and it might", "etc., I only look at the few first pages of", "as results for a given queries depend on the location,", "results. However, some commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence of my", "a [reference-request](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reference-request) question, before asking I generally Google + Google", "provide evidence of my efforts when asking reference questions for", "and it might be counterproductive as results for a given", "far. How can I provide evidence of my efforts when", "it might be counterproductive as results for a given queries", "questions for which I have found no useful information so", "and I may miss some interesting results. However, some commentators", "[reference-request](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reference-request) question, before asking I generally Google + Google Scholar", "only look at the few first pages of results, and", "depend on the location, time, etc., I only look at", "efforts when asking reference questions for which I have found", "It sounds a bit tedious to list all queries I", "of results, and I may miss some interesting results. However,", "the question. It sounds a bit tedious to list all", "generally Google + Google Scholar a bunch of words I", "before asking I generally Google + Google Scholar a bunch", "results, and I may miss some interesting results. However, some", "question, before asking I generally Google + Google Scholar a", "interesting results. However, some commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence of", "results for a given queries depend on the location, time,", "for a given queries depend on the location, time, etc.,", "few first pages of results, and I may miss some", "tedious to list all queries I have made, and it", "I put in the question. It sounds a bit tedious", "Google + Google Scholar a bunch of words I put", "I provide evidence of my efforts when asking reference questions", "sounds a bit tedious to list all queries I have", "some commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence of my efforts so", "time, etc., I only look at the few first pages", "location, time, etc., I only look at the few first", "me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence of my efforts so far. How can", "of words I put in the question. It sounds a", "miss some interesting results. However, some commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide", "evidence of my efforts when asking reference questions for which", "I generally Google + Google Scholar a bunch of words", "in the question. It sounds a bit tedious to list", "efforts so far. How can I provide evidence of my", "for which I have found no useful information so far?", "the few first pages of results, and I may miss", "a given queries depend on the location, time, etc., I", "given queries depend on the location, time, etc., I only", "I only look at the few first pages of results,", "I have made, and it might be counterproductive as results", "might be counterproductive as results for a given queries depend", "some interesting results. However, some commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence", "on the location, time, etc., I only look at the", "all queries I have made, and it might be counterproductive", "have made, and it might be counterproductive as results for", "words I put in the question. It sounds a bit", "asking reference questions for which I have found no useful", "When I ask a [reference-request](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reference-request) question, before asking I generally", "a bunch of words I put in the question. It", "How can I provide evidence of my efforts when asking", "of my efforts so far. How can I provide evidence", "queries I have made, and it might be counterproductive as", "look at the few first pages of results, and I", "be counterproductive as results for a given queries depend on", "evidence of my efforts so far. How can I provide", "made, and it might be counterproductive as results for a", "put in the question. It sounds a bit tedious to", "so far. How can I provide evidence of my efforts", "ask a [reference-request](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/reference-request) question, before asking I generally Google +", "of my efforts when asking reference questions for which I", "commentators [asked me](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32510/452) provide evidence of my efforts so far.", "counterproductive as results for a given queries depend on the" ]
[ "to do research in Japan for 4 months, as such", "to the site (as presumably the differences between Japanese academia", "and Japanese culture). > > Do I need to bring", "Furthermore I'll end up asking a large number of questions,", "question at all? Is this question always going to fall", "different. > > What questions should I ask on Academia.SE", "Japan for 4 months to prevent embarrassing myself? > >", "to study in Japan? > > > is obviously just", "(i.e. what's going to trip me up when I go", "it is a bit poll-y) but it's a bit too", "differences between British and Japanese culture). > > Do I", "\"how\", and invites experience based answers. However it doesn't really", "question, but is likely to give long, high quality answers", "some good resources for preparing to study in Japan? >", "will be different. > > What questions should I ask", "venue for such a question at all? Is this question", "question. How can I ask my question in a way", "a bit poll-y) but it's a bit too meta for", "in Japan? > > > is obviously just asking for", "Japan (something the Japanese government is actively promoting, and thus", "guidelines. > > How does British academia differ from Japanese", "your guidelines (although it is a bit poll-y) but it's", "such a question at all? Is this question always going", "people planning short-term study in Japan (something the Japanese government", "what I need to know (i.e. what's going to trip", "academia and British academia are massively overshadowed by the general", "Is this an appropriate venue for such a question at", "so it doesn't answer my real question of what do", "omiyage for my host on a first meeting? > >", "> What do I need to know before travelling to", "For example: > > What do I need to know", "and is likely to give bad answers. > > What", "will have insignificant answers, as I don't know in advance", "> What questions should I ask on Academia.SE before I", "meta for my taste and is likely to give bad", "between British and Japanese culture). > > Do I need", "non-obvious that the question remains specific to the site (as", "academia with respect to etiquette and other social niceties? >", "it is probably helpful to me (although Googling hasn't really", "specific, but as I am unfamiliar with Japanese culture I", "that explain \"how\", and invites experience based answers. However it", "going to do research in Japan for 4 months, as", "academia. How broad can I make my question? For example:", "what's going to trip me up when I go there),", "However it doesn't really tell me what I need to", "are some good resources for preparing to study in Japan?", "of what do I need to know. Furthermore I'll end", "need to know. Furthermore I'll end up asking a large", "massively helpful) it isn't a high-quality question. How can I", "study in Japan (something the Japanese government is actively promoting,", "and even though it is probably helpful to me (although", "for my taste and is likely to give bad answers.", "Googling hasn't really found me anything massively helpful) it isn't", "by the general differences between British and Japanese culture). >", "to trip me up when I go there), and if", "fall inside your guidelines. > > How does British academia", "differences between Japanese academia and British academia are massively overshadowed", "> > > is a very broad question, but is", "do research in Japan for 4 months, as such I", "> > How does British academia differ from Japanese academia", "between Japanese academia and British academia are massively overshadowed by", "> is a very broad question, but is likely to", "> > technically fits your guidelines (although it is a", "for 4 months to prevent embarrassing myself? > > >", "ended question, that has an infinitude of potentially correct answers,", "obviously just asking for short, link-based answers, and even though", "site (as presumably the differences between Japanese academia and British", "really tell me what I need to know (i.e. what's", "number of questions, most of which will have insignificant answers,", "in advance what will be different. > > What questions", "that I get answers that are useful to other people", "tell me what I need to know (i.e. what's going", "with Japanese culture I don't know what questions I need", "short, link-based answers, and even though it is probably helpful", "useful to other people planning short-term study in Japan (something", "question remains specific to the site (as presumably the differences", "remains specific to the site (as presumably the differences between", "found me anything massively helpful) it isn't a high-quality question.", "of potentially correct answers, and thus doesn't really fall inside", "that has an infinitude of potentially correct answers, and thus", "for my host on a first meeting? > > >", "unfamiliar with Japanese culture I don't know what questions I", "know. Furthermore I'll end up asking a large number of", "> is obviously just asking for short, link-based answers, and", "my real question of what do I need to know.", "is obviously just asking for short, link-based answers, and even", "Japanese academia. How broad can I make my question? For", "culture). > > Do I need to bring omiyage for", "What are some good resources for preparing to study in", "I go to Japan for 4 months to prevent embarrassing", "ask my question in a way that I get answers", "but as I am unfamiliar with Japanese culture I don't", "at all? Is this question always going to fall under", "is a very broad question, but is likely to give", "this question always going to fall under the category of", "> > > is an open ended question, that has", "correct answers, and thus doesn't really fall inside your guidelines.", "thus something useful to a large number of others)? Is", "question of what do I need to know. Furthermore I'll", "I don't know what questions I need to ask, so", "answers, as I don't know in advance what will be", "and British academia are massively overshadowed by the general differences", "I ask my question in a way that I get", "as I am unfamiliar with Japanese culture I don't know", "when I go there), and if you remove the 'academia'", "am unfamiliar with Japanese culture I don't know what questions", "first meeting? > > > is specific, but as I", "it's non-obvious that the question remains specific to the site", "Japanese government is actively promoting, and thus something useful to", "even though it is probably helpful to me (although Googling", "are massively overshadowed by the general differences between British and", "I go there), and if you remove the 'academia' part,", "taste and is likely to give bad answers. > >", "high quality answers that explain \"how\", and invites experience based", "but it's a bit too meta for my taste and", "answers, and even though it is probably helpful to me", "potentially correct answers, and thus doesn't really fall inside your", "if you remove the 'academia' part, it's non-obvious that the", "very broad question, but is likely to give long, high", "it isn't a high-quality question. How can I ask my", "an open ended question, that has an infinitude of potentially", "to bring omiyage for my host on a first meeting?", "months to prevent embarrassing myself? > > > technically fits", "question in a way that I get answers that are", "academia are massively overshadowed by the general differences between British", "does British academia differ from Japanese academia with respect to", "questions about Japanese academia. How broad can I make my", "too meta for my taste and is likely to give", "(as presumably the differences between Japanese academia and British academia", "do I need to know. Furthermore I'll end up asking", "to other people planning short-term study in Japan (something the", "something useful to a large number of others)? Is this", "an infinitude of potentially correct answers, and thus doesn't really", "others)? Is this an appropriate venue for such a question", "all? Is this question always going to fall under the", "is specific, but as I am unfamiliar with Japanese culture", "give bad answers. > > What are some good resources", "thus doesn't really fall inside your guidelines. > > How", "> is specific, but as I am unfamiliar with Japanese", "to Japan for 4 months to prevent embarrassing myself? >", "to know before travelling to Japan for an academic fellowship?", "and thus doesn't really fall inside your guidelines. > >", "British academia are massively overshadowed by the general differences between", "> What are some good resources for preparing to study", "a first meeting? > > > is specific, but as", "Is this question always going to fall under the category", "infinitude of potentially correct answers, and thus doesn't really fall", "be different. > > What questions should I ask on", "appropriate venue for such a question at all? Is this", "social niceties? > > > is a very broad question,", "this an appropriate venue for such a question at all?", "questions I need to ask, so it doesn't answer my", "a bit too meta for my taste and is likely", "that are useful to other people planning short-term study in", "host on a first meeting? > > > is specific,", "I want to ask questions about Japanese academia. How broad", "is actively promoting, and thus something useful to a large", "of questions, most of which will have insignificant answers, as", "an appropriate venue for such a question at all? Is", "Japanese academia and British academia are massively overshadowed by the", "(although it is a bit poll-y) but it's a bit", "me what I need to know (i.e. what's going to", "go there), and if you remove the 'academia' part, it's", "in Japan (something the Japanese government is actively promoting, and", "bit too meta for my taste and is likely to", "> > What questions should I ask on Academia.SE before", "but is likely to give long, high quality answers that", "me up when I go there), and if you remove", "is probably helpful to me (although Googling hasn't really found", "know (i.e. what's going to trip me up when I", "experience based answers. However it doesn't really tell me what", "academic fellowship? > > > is an open ended question,", "ask, so it doesn't answer my real question of what", "respect to etiquette and other social niceties? > > >", "to Japan for an academic fellowship? > > > is", "> > > technically fits your guidelines (although it is", "Do I need to bring omiyage for my host on", "What questions should I ask on Academia.SE before I go", "and other social niceties? > > > is a very", "a large number of questions, most of which will have", "other social niceties? > > > is a very broad", "and invites experience based answers. However it doesn't really tell", "make my question? For example: > > What do I", "is a bit poll-y) but it's a bit too meta", "I make my question? For example: > > What do", "to a large number of others)? Is this an appropriate", "there), and if you remove the 'academia' part, it's non-obvious", "me (although Googling hasn't really found me anything massively helpful)", "I need to know. Furthermore I'll end up asking a", "I ask on Academia.SE before I go to Japan for", "give long, high quality answers that explain \"how\", and invites", "advance what will be different. > > What questions should", "British academia differ from Japanese academia with respect to etiquette", "broad can I make my question? For example: > >", "which will have insignificant answers, as I don't know in", "to give long, high quality answers that explain \"how\", and", "your guidelines. > > How does British academia differ from", "really found me anything massively helpful) it isn't a high-quality", "> > > is obviously just asking for short, link-based", "ask questions about Japanese academia. How broad can I make", "and if you remove the 'academia' part, it's non-obvious that", "what will be different. > > What questions should I", "I need to know before travelling to Japan for an", "> is an open ended question, that has an infinitude", "I need to ask, so it doesn't answer my real", "what questions I need to ask, so it doesn't answer", "link-based answers, and even though it is probably helpful to", "niceties? > > > is a very broad question, but", "a high-quality question. How can I ask my question in", "(something the Japanese government is actively promoting, and thus something", "an academic fellowship? > > > is an open ended", "actively promoting, and thus something useful to a large number", "How does British academia differ from Japanese academia with respect", "need to know (i.e. what's going to trip me up", "to know. Furthermore I'll end up asking a large number", "of others)? Is this an appropriate venue for such a", "is likely to give bad answers. > > What are", "as such I want to ask questions about Japanese academia.", "my question in a way that I get answers that", "Japan for an academic fellowship? > > > is an", "answer my real question of what do I need to", "invites experience based answers. However it doesn't really tell me", "is an open ended question, that has an infinitude of", "I need to bring omiyage for my host on a", "on a first meeting? > > > is specific, but", "general differences between British and Japanese culture). > > Do", "you remove the 'academia' part, it's non-obvious that the question", "high-quality question. How can I ask my question in a", "4 months, as such I want to ask questions about", "up when I go there), and if you remove the", "inside your guidelines. > > How does British academia differ", "government is actively promoting, and thus something useful to a", "to give bad answers. > > What are some good", "really fall inside your guidelines. > > How does British", "Academia.SE before I go to Japan for 4 months to", "I am going to do research in Japan for 4", "embarrassing myself? > > > technically fits your guidelines (although", "> > is obviously just asking for short, link-based answers,", "the 'academia' part, it's non-obvious that the question remains specific", "of which will have insignificant answers, as I don't know", "large number of others)? Is this an appropriate venue for", "need to bring omiyage for my host on a first", "going to trip me up when I go there), and", "know before travelling to Japan for an academic fellowship? >", "months, as such I want to ask questions about Japanese", "to ask, so it doesn't answer my real question of", "promoting, and thus something useful to a large number of", "should I ask on Academia.SE before I go to Japan", "Japan? > > > is obviously just asking for short,", "massively overshadowed by the general differences between British and Japanese", "question always going to fall under the category of too-localised?", "need to know before travelling to Japan for an academic", "useful to a large number of others)? Is this an", "> > is an open ended question, that has an", "the Japanese government is actively promoting, and thus something useful", "planning short-term study in Japan (something the Japanese government is", "technically fits your guidelines (although it is a bit poll-y)", "for such a question at all? Is this question always", "specific to the site (as presumably the differences between Japanese", "asking a large number of questions, most of which will", "presumably the differences between Japanese academia and British academia are", "> > What do I need to know before travelling", "I'll end up asking a large number of questions, most", "helpful to me (although Googling hasn't really found me anything", "for an academic fellowship? > > > is an open", "> > What are some good resources for preparing to", "answers that explain \"how\", and invites experience based answers. However", "study in Japan? > > > is obviously just asking", "that the question remains specific to the site (as presumably", "about Japanese academia. How broad can I make my question?", "before travelling to Japan for an academic fellowship? > >", "the question remains specific to the site (as presumably the", "Japan for 4 months, as such I want to ask", "I need to know (i.e. what's going to trip me", "before I go to Japan for 4 months to prevent", "are useful to other people planning short-term study in Japan", "and thus something useful to a large number of others)?", "etiquette and other social niceties? > > > is a", "> Do I need to bring omiyage for my host", "good resources for preparing to study in Japan? > >", "don't know what questions I need to ask, so it", "4 months to prevent embarrassing myself? > > > technically", "get answers that are useful to other people planning short-term", "my taste and is likely to give bad answers. >", "doesn't really tell me what I need to know (i.e.", "a very broad question, but is likely to give long,", "guidelines (although it is a bit poll-y) but it's a", "open ended question, that has an infinitude of potentially correct", "have insignificant answers, as I don't know in advance what", "don't know in advance what will be different. > >", "remove the 'academia' part, it's non-obvious that the question remains", "> > Do I need to bring omiyage for my", "a large number of others)? Is this an appropriate venue", "questions, most of which will have insignificant answers, as I", "know in advance what will be different. > > What", "overshadowed by the general differences between British and Japanese culture).", "I get answers that are useful to other people planning", "How can I ask my question in a way that", "such I want to ask questions about Japanese academia. How", "it's a bit too meta for my taste and is", "meeting? > > > is specific, but as I am", "am going to do research in Japan for 4 months,", "to ask questions about Japanese academia. How broad can I", "I am unfamiliar with Japanese culture I don't know what", "real question of what do I need to know. Furthermore", "myself? > > > technically fits your guidelines (although it", "preparing to study in Japan? > > > is obviously", "in Japan for 4 months, as such I want to", "to prevent embarrassing myself? > > > technically fits your", "answers, and thus doesn't really fall inside your guidelines. >", "a way that I get answers that are useful to", "isn't a high-quality question. How can I ask my question", "go to Japan for 4 months to prevent embarrassing myself?", "Japanese culture I don't know what questions I need to", "bad answers. > > What are some good resources for", "the differences between Japanese academia and British academia are massively", "> technically fits your guidelines (although it is a bit", "questions should I ask on Academia.SE before I go to", "likely to give long, high quality answers that explain \"how\",", "has an infinitude of potentially correct answers, and thus doesn't", "long, high quality answers that explain \"how\", and invites experience", "travelling to Japan for an academic fellowship? > > >", "other people planning short-term study in Japan (something the Japanese", "How broad can I make my question? For example: >", "anything massively helpful) it isn't a high-quality question. How can", "answers. > > What are some good resources for preparing", "want to ask questions about Japanese academia. How broad can", "a question at all? Is this question always going to", "> > is specific, but as I am unfamiliar with", "bit poll-y) but it's a bit too meta for my", "do I need to know before travelling to Japan for", "as I don't know in advance what will be different.", "answers. However it doesn't really tell me what I need", "quality answers that explain \"how\", and invites experience based answers.", "broad question, but is likely to give long, high quality", "based answers. However it doesn't really tell me what I", "prevent embarrassing myself? > > > technically fits your guidelines", "explain \"how\", and invites experience based answers. However it doesn't", "fits your guidelines (although it is a bit poll-y) but", "doesn't answer my real question of what do I need", "for 4 months, as such I want to ask questions", "I don't know in advance what will be different. >", "know what questions I need to ask, so it doesn't", "insignificant answers, as I don't know in advance what will", "academia differ from Japanese academia with respect to etiquette and", "my host on a first meeting? > > > is", "British and Japanese culture). > > Do I need to", "Japanese culture). > > Do I need to bring omiyage", "on Academia.SE before I go to Japan for 4 months", "what do I need to know. Furthermore I'll end up", "asking for short, link-based answers, and even though it is", "question, that has an infinitude of potentially correct answers, and", "resources for preparing to study in Japan? > > >", "helpful) it isn't a high-quality question. How can I ask", "example: > > What do I need to know before", "differ from Japanese academia with respect to etiquette and other", "for preparing to study in Japan? > > > is", "fellowship? > > > is an open ended question, that", "likely to give bad answers. > > What are some", "end up asking a large number of questions, most of", "for short, link-based answers, and even though it is probably", "'academia' part, it's non-obvious that the question remains specific to", "What do I need to know before travelling to Japan", "number of others)? Is this an appropriate venue for such", "research in Japan for 4 months, as such I want", "> > > is specific, but as I am unfamiliar", "to me (although Googling hasn't really found me anything massively", "the site (as presumably the differences between Japanese academia and", "way that I get answers that are useful to other", "can I make my question? For example: > > What", "> > is a very broad question, but is likely", "poll-y) but it's a bit too meta for my taste", "doesn't really fall inside your guidelines. > > How does", "trip me up when I go there), and if you", "it doesn't answer my real question of what do I", "me anything massively helpful) it isn't a high-quality question. How", "part, it's non-obvious that the question remains specific to the", "question? For example: > > What do I need to", "just asking for short, link-based answers, and even though it", "most of which will have insignificant answers, as I don't", "Japanese academia with respect to etiquette and other social niceties?", "short-term study in Japan (something the Japanese government is actively", "ask on Academia.SE before I go to Japan for 4", "> How does British academia differ from Japanese academia with", "to etiquette and other social niceties? > > > is", "it doesn't really tell me what I need to know", "my question? For example: > > What do I need", "with respect to etiquette and other social niceties? > >", "is likely to give long, high quality answers that explain", "from Japanese academia with respect to etiquette and other social", "hasn't really found me anything massively helpful) it isn't a", "the general differences between British and Japanese culture). > >", "answers that are useful to other people planning short-term study", "can I ask my question in a way that I", "though it is probably helpful to me (although Googling hasn't", "bring omiyage for my host on a first meeting? >", "need to ask, so it doesn't answer my real question", "up asking a large number of questions, most of which", "to know (i.e. what's going to trip me up when", "probably helpful to me (although Googling hasn't really found me", "in a way that I get answers that are useful", "culture I don't know what questions I need to ask,", "(although Googling hasn't really found me anything massively helpful) it", "large number of questions, most of which will have insignificant" ]
[ "potential duplicates) unilaterally; any moderator can leave a comment, suggest", "being disputed. The dispute revolves around an individual being singled", "is being disputed. The dispute revolves around an individual being", "As it is a moderator who is being named, I", "of closing questions too frequently add value to the question", "moderator who is being named, I think it is important", "question, I would like to keep the discussion/answers focused on", "> There is simply no need to close questions (e.g.", "[this meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1385/929) is being disputed. The dispute revolves around", "voice be heard. Despite the titular question, I would like", "content in [this meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1385/929) is being disputed. The dispute", "questions (e.g. as in potential duplicates) unilaterally; any moderator can", "decide. > > > As it is a moderator who", "of the individual who is being \"accused\" of closing questions", "is being \"accused\" of closing questions too frequently add value", "see a more general discussion in another meta question, but", "a more general discussion in another meta question, but as", "a resolution. What I need to know before unlocking the", "named is: > > There is simply no need to", "is being named, I think it is important to let", "There is simply no need to close questions (e.g. as", "let the community voice be heard. Despite the titular question,", "name of the individual who is being \"accused\" of closing", "being singled out in the answer. The sentence in question,", "answer. I would be happy to see a more general", "particular answer so that we can reach a resolution and", "know before unlocking the question is: Does including the name", "duplicate and leave the community to decide. > > >", "dispute revolves around an individual being singled out in the", "question is: Does including the name of the individual who", "leave the community to decide. > > > As it", "reach a resolution and unlock the valuable answer. I would", "who is being named, I think it is important to", "to decide. > > > As it is a moderator", "to let the community voice be heard. Despite the titular", "disputed. The dispute revolves around an individual being singled out", "being \"accused\" of closing questions too frequently add value to", "individual who is being \"accused\" of closing questions too frequently", "would be happy to see a more general discussion in", "is simply no need to close questions (e.g. as in", "the content of the particular answer so that we can", "the potential duplicate and leave the community to decide. >", "this is a moderation or moderator issue, we need a", "resolution. What I need to know before unlocking the question", "answer so that we can reach a resolution and unlock", "the name of the individual who is being \"accused\" of", "we can reach a resolution and unlock the valuable answer.", "the valuable answer. I would be happy to see a", "to see a more general discussion in another meta question,", "before unlocking the question is: Does including the name of", "can leave a comment, suggest the potential duplicate and leave", "it is important to let the community voice be heard.", "question, without the individual named is: > > There is", "happy to see a more general discussion in another meta", "is important to let the community voice be heard. Despite", "another meta question, but as this is a moderation or", "around an individual being singled out in the answer. The", "who is being \"accused\" of closing questions too frequently add", "\"accused\" of closing questions too frequently add value to the", "I would like to keep the discussion/answers focused on the", "titular question, I would like to keep the discussion/answers focused", "in the answer. The sentence in question, without the individual", "keep the discussion/answers focused on the content of the particular", "the community to decide. > > > As it is", "it is a moderator who is being named, I think", "resolution and unlock the valuable answer. I would be happy", "singled out in the answer. The sentence in question, without", "in potential duplicates) unilaterally; any moderator can leave a comment,", "or moderator issue, we need a resolution. What I need", "as this is a moderation or moderator issue, we need", "to close questions (e.g. as in potential duplicates) unilaterally; any", "I think it is important to let the community voice", "as in potential duplicates) unilaterally; any moderator can leave a", "named, I think it is important to let the community", "Does including the name of the individual who is being", "What I need to know before unlocking the question is:", "The content in [this meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1385/929) is being disputed. The", "any moderator can leave a comment, suggest the potential duplicate", "a resolution and unlock the valuable answer. I would be", "that we can reach a resolution and unlock the valuable", "is a moderator who is being named, I think it", "can reach a resolution and unlock the valuable answer. I", "need a resolution. What I need to know before unlocking", "an individual being singled out in the answer. The sentence", "I need to know before unlocking the question is: Does", "answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1385/929) is being disputed. The dispute revolves around an individual", "like to keep the discussion/answers focused on the content of", "is: Does including the name of the individual who is", "so that we can reach a resolution and unlock the", "simply no need to close questions (e.g. as in potential", "the discussion/answers focused on the content of the particular answer", "in [this meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1385/929) is being disputed. The dispute revolves", "meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1385/929) is being disputed. The dispute revolves around an", "but as this is a moderation or moderator issue, we", "moderation or moderator issue, we need a resolution. What I", "a moderator who is being named, I think it is", "moderator can leave a comment, suggest the potential duplicate and", "question, but as this is a moderation or moderator issue,", "focused on the content of the particular answer so that", "would like to keep the discussion/answers focused on the content", "is: > > There is simply no need to close", "> As it is a moderator who is being named,", "community to decide. > > > As it is a", "(e.g. as in potential duplicates) unilaterally; any moderator can leave", "valuable answer. I would be happy to see a more", "and leave the community to decide. > > > As", "in another meta question, but as this is a moderation", "issue, we need a resolution. What I need to know", "revolves around an individual being singled out in the answer.", "out in the answer. The sentence in question, without the", "suggest the potential duplicate and leave the community to decide.", "the titular question, I would like to keep the discussion/answers", "being named, I think it is important to let the", "more general discussion in another meta question, but as this", "of the particular answer so that we can reach a", "discussion in another meta question, but as this is a", "in question, without the individual named is: > > There", "need to close questions (e.g. as in potential duplicates) unilaterally;", "> > There is simply no need to close questions", "comment, suggest the potential duplicate and leave the community to", "The dispute revolves around an individual being singled out in", "heard. Despite the titular question, I would like to keep", "and unlock the valuable answer. I would be happy to", "unlock the valuable answer. I would be happy to see", "duplicates) unilaterally; any moderator can leave a comment, suggest the", "on the content of the particular answer so that we", "the question is: Does including the name of the individual", "community voice be heard. Despite the titular question, I would", "a comment, suggest the potential duplicate and leave the community", "to know before unlocking the question is: Does including the", "the community voice be heard. Despite the titular question, I", "be heard. Despite the titular question, I would like to", "the individual who is being \"accused\" of closing questions too", "without the individual named is: > > There is simply", "need to know before unlocking the question is: Does including", "unilaterally; any moderator can leave a comment, suggest the potential", "answer. The sentence in question, without the individual named is:", "> > As it is a moderator who is being", "think it is important to let the community voice be", "moderator issue, we need a resolution. What I need to", "> > > As it is a moderator who is", "important to let the community voice be heard. Despite the", "the answer. The sentence in question, without the individual named", "the particular answer so that we can reach a resolution", "meta question, but as this is a moderation or moderator", "we need a resolution. What I need to know before", "is a moderation or moderator issue, we need a resolution.", "close questions (e.g. as in potential duplicates) unilaterally; any moderator", "discussion/answers focused on the content of the particular answer so", "sentence in question, without the individual named is: > >", "The sentence in question, without the individual named is: >", "a moderation or moderator issue, we need a resolution. What", "individual named is: > > There is simply no need", "individual being singled out in the answer. The sentence in", "potential duplicate and leave the community to decide. > >", "the individual named is: > > There is simply no", "content of the particular answer so that we can reach", "to keep the discussion/answers focused on the content of the", "Despite the titular question, I would like to keep the", "be happy to see a more general discussion in another", "including the name of the individual who is being \"accused\"", "unlocking the question is: **Does including the name of the", "no need to close questions (e.g. as in potential duplicates)", "I would be happy to see a more general discussion", "leave a comment, suggest the potential duplicate and leave the", "general discussion in another meta question, but as this is" ]
[ "that are related to moderator behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a", "that is not relevant to the question, but may be", "to leave the comments or delete the comments. Should the", "to moderator deleting comments that are related to moderator behaviour.", "our recent discussions on meta, it seems the community is", "chat/meta discussion, unfortunately the only options available to moderators is", "to moderators is to leave the comments or delete the", "seems to me that all the comments form a discussion", "has brought it to my attention. It seems to me", "has a \"not constructive\" flag raised against one of the", "is not relevant to the question, but may be the", "comments that are related to moderator behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has", "a \"not constructive\" flag raised against one of the comments,", "only options available to moderators is to leave the comments", "it seems the community is particularly sensitive to moderator deleting", "particularly sensitive to moderator deleting comments that are related to", "be the basis of a useful chat/meta discussion, unfortunately the", "Given some of our recent discussions on meta, it seems", "the comments, which has brought it to my attention. It", "the comments form a discussion that is not relevant to", "to moderator behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a \"not constructive\" flag", "comments, which has brought it to my attention. It seems", "the only options available to moderators is to leave the", "available to moderators is to leave the comments or delete", "constructive\" flag raised against one of the comments, which has", "raised against one of the comments, which has brought it", "of our recent discussions on meta, it seems the community", "moderator behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a \"not constructive\" flag raised", "discussions on meta, it seems the community is particularly sensitive", "to me that all the comments form a discussion that", "question, but may be the basis of a useful chat/meta", "the community is particularly sensitive to moderator deleting comments that", "is particularly sensitive to moderator deleting comments that are related", "leave the comments or delete the comments. Should the comments", "discussion that is not relevant to the question, but may", "recent discussions on meta, it seems the community is particularly", "of the comments, which has brought it to my attention.", "It seems to me that all the comments form a", "of a useful chat/meta discussion, unfortunately the only options available", "relevant to the question, but may be the basis of", "to the question, but may be the basis of a", "which has brought it to my attention. It seems to", "the basis of a useful chat/meta discussion, unfortunately the only", "sensitive to moderator deleting comments that are related to moderator", "meta, it seems the community is particularly sensitive to moderator", "to my attention. It seems to me that all the", "attention. It seems to me that all the comments form", "it to my attention. It seems to me that all", "on meta, it seems the community is particularly sensitive to", "related to moderator behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a \"not constructive\"", "but may be the basis of a useful chat/meta discussion,", "useful chat/meta discussion, unfortunately the only options available to moderators", "moderators is to leave the comments or delete the comments.", "that all the comments form a discussion that is not", "[This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a \"not constructive\" flag raised against one", "one of the comments, which has brought it to my", "a discussion that is not relevant to the question, but", "moderator deleting comments that are related to moderator behaviour. [This", "\"not constructive\" flag raised against one of the comments, which", "seems the community is particularly sensitive to moderator deleting comments", "comments form a discussion that is not relevant to the", "behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a \"not constructive\" flag raised against", "the question, but may be the basis of a useful", "my attention. It seems to me that all the comments", "deleting comments that are related to moderator behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle)", "discussion, unfortunately the only options available to moderators is to", "me that all the comments form a discussion that is", "may be the basis of a useful chat/meta discussion, unfortunately", "the comments or delete the comments. Should the comments be", "flag raised against one of the comments, which has brought", "are related to moderator behaviour. [This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a \"not", "options available to moderators is to leave the comments or", "a useful chat/meta discussion, unfortunately the only options available to", "against one of the comments, which has brought it to", "comments or delete the comments. Should the comments be deleted?", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7774/how-do-academics-reconcile-simultaneously-collaborating-and-competing-with-colle) has a \"not constructive\" flag raised against one of", "all the comments form a discussion that is not relevant", "community is particularly sensitive to moderator deleting comments that are", "basis of a useful chat/meta discussion, unfortunately the only options", "is to leave the comments or delete the comments. Should", "some of our recent discussions on meta, it seems the", "brought it to my attention. It seems to me that", "form a discussion that is not relevant to the question,", "not relevant to the question, but may be the basis", "unfortunately the only options available to moderators is to leave" ]
[ "for the benefit of participants and future viewers. Both of", "want to go in whatever direction we choose? What goals", "a \"Choose #1 or #2 proposal.\" This was intended to", "to the question should be downvoted, converted to comment, or", "hands-off approach to other people's content, in which edits are", "as such. I don't think either of these approaches is", "(except for offensive comments). * Answers: On the first Academia.SE,", "titles, removing \"noise\" (\"sorry for the dumb question,\" extended thanks,", "it, it should stay open/be reopened if it's closed. ", "just described can be extremely useful and valuable resources (I", "not. Recently, we've had several disagreements on meta that I", "mostly to connect users with questions to other users who", "And I think it leads to conflict between users (in", "interested readers.* The main goal of this site is to", "of \"What should Academia.SE be?\" whether they relate to these", "with questions to other users who want to answer those", "Answers: On the first Academia.SE, answers that might be useful", "a prompt for discussion about what the current community wants", "treated as such. I don't think either of these approaches", "these approaches is especially bad - but trying to be", "the scope of the site. On the second Academia.SE, if", "comments). Answers: On the first Academia.SE, answers that might", "question about a specific scenario or a specific site policy.", "future readers are distracting, and should be removed (once they", "answers that aren't really answers are useful content, and should", "accurate, focused answers to questions and problems that are within", "On the first Academia.SE, questions that are outside the scope", "former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an example of the latter), but", "different users, is (I think) not healthy. As a moderator,", "wants from this site.* #1 and #2 are just things", "but trying to be both at once causes some friction.", "goal of this site is to help both those asking", "revisit what this community is and what primary role it", "the latter), but trying to be both at once causes", "post is made CW to explicitly signal that edits are", "serves. Do we want to tend more towards Academia.SE #1", "comments that no longer add any value to the author", "signal that edits are welcome. * Closing questions: On the", "was not intended to be a \"Choose #1 or #2", "broadly relevant to academia and someone is willing to answer", "and/or edited to fit the scope of the site. On", "should be downvoted, converted to comment, or deleted, so as", "example, * Editing: The first Academia.SE encourages editing - improving", "for the dumb question,\" extended thanks, over-lengthy and irrelevant personal", "On the second Academia.SE, if a question is broadly relevant", "is made CW to explicitly signal that edits are welcome.", "record of the communication, and should preserved (except for offensive", "thread preserved for the benefit of participants and future viewers.", "a post is made CW to explicitly signal that edits", "the second Academia.SE, comments are a part of the historical", "be both at once, or to be different things to", "is an example of the latter), but trying to be", "should be treated as such. I don't think either of", "#1 or #2 proposal.\" This was intended to be a", "general question about the future direction of the site, please", "moderator, it makes it difficult to act on the community's", "the people who participated in it, with the entire thread", "idea of \"What should Academia.SE be?\" whether they relate to", "of this site is to help both those asking questions", "new users, since the site policies are so inconsistent (both", "towards Academia.SE #1 or Academia.SE #2? How far do we", "questions. The main purpose of a thread is to help", "for offensive comments). * Answers: On the first Academia.SE, answers", "lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!) in the last year, and I think", "should be removed (once they no longer serve a useful", "scenario or a specific site policy. This is a general", "scope of this site. 2. *We are facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving", "have grown [quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!) in the last", "prompt for discussion about what the current community wants from", "past time to revisit what this community is and what", "other users who want to answer those questions. The main", "this site. 2. We are facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving between academics/researchers", "a community? --- Note: this is not a question about", "questions to other users who want to answer those questions.", "site. On the second Academia.SE, if a question is broadly", "and should be removed (once they no longer serve a", "to us, as a community? --- Note: this is not", "useful and valuable resources (I think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an", "are distracting, and should be removed (once they no longer", "aren't really answers are useful content, and should be treated", "to act on the community's wishes (which part of the", "and valuable resources (I think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an example", "on flags)? It is confusing to new users, since the", "the first Academia.SE, questions that are outside the scope of", "had several disagreements on meta that I think stem from", "get/find accurate, focused answers to questions and problems that are", "content, in which edits are discouraged unless a post is", "in whatever direction we choose? What goals are most important", "of this site. 2. We are facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving between", "As a moderator, it makes it difficult to act on", "academia and someone is willing to answer it, it should", "entire thread preserved for the benefit of participants and future", "users (in a bad way, not in a healthy way).", "approaches is especially bad - but trying to be both", "the dumb question,\" extended thanks, over-lengthy and irrelevant personal information,", "this community is and what primary role it serves. Do", "The main purpose of a thread is to help the", "future Google users. We want to make it as easy", "Recently, we've had several disagreements on meta that I think", "encourages editing - improving question titles, removing \"noise\" (\"sorry for", "Academia.SE #2? How far do we want to go in", "longer add any value to the author of a post", "be downvoted, converted to comment, or deleted, so as not", "and academics/researchers with answers. The goal of this site is", "be). Broadly, these are: 1. We are building up a", "extended thanks, over-lengthy and irrelevant personal information, and pleas of", "(I think) not healthy. As a moderator, it makes it", "on meta that I think stem from slightly conflicting views", "latter), but trying to be both at once causes some", "* Comments: To the first Academia.SE, comments that no longer", "the intent of the OP. The second Academia.SE has a", "of desperation) while still preserving the intent of the OP.", "important to us, as a community? --- Note: this is", "can be extremely useful and valuable resources (I think [Cross", "community wants from this site.* #1 and #2 are just", "as expressed on meta). And I think it leads to", "more towards Academia.SE #1 or Academia.SE #2? How far do", "both those asking questions and future Google users. We want", "both at once, or to be different things to different", "This was intended to be a prompt for discussion about", "to academia and someone is willing to answer it, it", "Closing questions: On the first Academia.SE, questions that are outside", "it, with the entire thread preserved for the benefit of", "[MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an example of the latter), but trying to", "difficult to act on the community's wishes (which part of", "questions:** On the first Academia.SE, questions that are outside the", "or deleted, so as not to distract from \"real\" answers.", "answers that address the general idea of \"What should Academia.SE", "a specific scenario or a specific site policy. This is", "possible for others to get/find accurate, focused answers to questions", "participants and future viewers. Both of the sites I've just", "intent of the OP. The second Academia.SE has a hands-off", "users. We want to make it as easy as possible", "What goals are most important to us, as a community?", "stay open/be reopened if it's closed. * Comments: To the", "not to distract from \"real\" answers. On the second Academia.SE,", "to questions and problems that are within the scope of", "second Academia.SE, answers that aren't really answers are useful content,", "to go in whatever direction we choose? What goals are", "make it as easy as possible for others to get/find", "want to answer those questions. The main purpose of a", "looking for answers that address the general idea of \"What", "downvoted, converted to comment, or deleted, so as not to", "library of concise, clear and correct questions and answers as", "in which edits are discouraged unless a post is made", "Academia.SE, comments that no longer add any value to the", "community should I follow in acting on flags)? It is", "users who want to answer those questions. The main purpose", "purpose). To the second Academia.SE, comments are a part of", "add any value to the author of a post or", "about what the current community wants from this site. #1", "willing to answer it, it should stay open/be reopened if", "answer it, it should stay open/be reopened if it's closed.", "really answers are useful content, and should be treated as", "reopened if it's closed. * Comments: To the first Academia.SE,", "of the community should I follow in acting on flags)?", "of what this community is (or should be). Broadly, these", "discouraged unless a post is made CW to explicitly signal", "and should be treated as such. I don't think either", "explicitly signal that edits are welcome. * Closing questions: On", "For example, * Editing: The first Academia.SE encourages editing -", "OP. The second Academia.SE has a hands-off approach to other", "such. I don't think either of these approaches is especially", "question titles, removing \"noise\" (\"sorry for the dumb question,\" extended", "[Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an example of the former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/)", "to be both at once, or to be different things", "easy as possible for others to get/find accurate, focused answers", "and should be closed and/or edited to fit the scope", "both at once causes some friction. For example, * Editing:", "question,\" extended thanks, over-lengthy and irrelevant personal information, and pleas", "of the site (as defined on meta) are \"noise\" and", "the first Academia.SE, answers that might be useful to the", "offensive comments). * Answers: On the first Academia.SE, answers that", "what the current community wants from this site. #1 and", "is (or should be). Broadly, these are: 1. *We are", "to be different things to different users, is (I think)", "am looking for answers that address the general idea of", "is to help the people who participated in it, with", "who want to answer those questions. The main purpose of", "for discussion about what the current community wants from this", "be useful to the OP but are not really answers", "editing - improving question titles, removing \"noise\" (\"sorry for the", "(and graduated!) in the last year, and I think it's", "to the author of a post or to future readers", "what primary role it serves. Do we want to tend", "discussion about what the current community wants from this site.", "open/be reopened if it's closed. * Comments: To the first", "serve a useful purpose). To the second Academia.SE, comments are", "useful purpose). To the second Academia.SE, comments are a part", "it serves. Do we want to tend more towards Academia.SE", "or #2 proposal.\" This was intended to be a prompt", "2. *We are facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving between academics/researchers with questions", "we choose? What goals are most important to us, as", "users in the recent past. I am looking for answers", "and someone* is willing to answer it, it should stay", "up a library of concise, clear and correct questions and", "what this community is and what primary role it serves.", "and what primary role it serves. Do we want to", "part of the historical record of the communication, and should", "and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an example of the latter), but trying", "closed and/or edited to fit the scope of the site.", "that are outside the scope of the site (as defined", "questions and future Google users. We want to make it", "really answers to the question should be downvoted, converted to", "questions and academics/researchers with answers.** The goal of this site", "scope of the site. On the second Academia.SE, if a", "but trying to be both at once, or to be", "meta that I think stem from slightly conflicting views of", "causes some friction. For example, * Editing: The first Academia.SE", "a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!) in the last year, and I", "benefit of participants and future viewers. Both of the sites", "questions that are outside the scope of the site (as", "(in a bad way, not in a healthy way). We", "from this site.* #1 and #2 are just things I've", "grown [quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!) in the last year,", "to connect users with questions to other users who want", "be extremely useful and valuable resources (I think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/)", "are building up a library of concise, clear and correct", "be removed (once they no longer serve a useful purpose).", "is mostly to connect users with questions to other users", "a part of the historical record of the communication, and", "at once, or to be different things to different users,", "so inconsistent (both in action, and as expressed on meta).", "the last year, and I think it's well past time", "is an example of the former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an", "want to make it as easy as possible for others", "people's content, in which edits are discouraged unless a post", "the second Academia.SE, answers that aren't really answers are useful", "question should be downvoted, converted to comment, or deleted, so", "inconsistent (both in action, and as expressed on meta). And", "answers to questions and problems that are within the scope", "and should preserved (except for offensive comments). * Answers: On", "\"noise\" (\"sorry for the dumb question,\" extended thanks, over-lengthy and", "question is broadly relevant to academia and someone is willing", "second Academia.SE, comments are a part of the historical record", "academics/researchers with answers. The goal of this site is mostly", "whether they relate to these themes or not. Recently, we've", "of the latter), but trying to be both at once", "are a part of the historical record of the communication,", "answers. The goal of this site is mostly to connect", "be both at once causes some friction. For example, ", "be different things to different users, is (I think) not", "useful content, and should be treated as such. I don't", "far do we want to go in whatever direction we", "the communication, and should preserved (except for offensive comments). ", "to other people's content, in which edits are discouraged unless", "or Academia.SE #2? How far do we want to go", "the community's wishes (which part of the community should I", "especially bad - but trying to be both at once,", "no longer serve a useful purpose). To the second Academia.SE,", "be a \"Choose #1 or #2 proposal.\" This was intended", "are within the scope of this site. 2. *We are", "preserved for the benefit of participants and* future viewers. Both", "and I think it's well past time to revisit what", "not really answers to the question should be downvoted, converted", "information, and pleas of desperation) while still preserving the intent", "at once causes some friction. For example, * Editing: The", "as not to distract from \"real\" answers. On the second", "resources (I think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an example of the", "if a question is broadly relevant to academia and someone", "are: 1. *We are building up a library of concise,", "outside the scope of the site (as defined on meta)", "over-lengthy and irrelevant personal information, and pleas of desperation) while", "clear and correct questions and answers as an archive for", "We have grown [quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!) in the", "the entire thread preserved for the benefit of participants and", "deleted, so as not to distract from \"real\" answers. On", "removing \"noise\" (\"sorry for the dumb question,\" extended thanks, over-lengthy", "site (as defined on meta) are \"noise\" and should be", "thread is to help the people who participated in it,", "role it serves. Do we want to tend more towards", "is (I think) not healthy. As a moderator, it makes", "heard from users in the recent past. I am looking", "be?\" whether they relate to these themes or not. Recently,", "or to future readers are distracting, and should be removed", "slightly conflicting views of what this community is (or should", "extremely useful and valuable resources (I think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is", "to the OP but are not really answers to the", "the OP. The second Academia.SE has a hands-off approach to", "graduated!) in the last year, and I think it's well", "of the site. On the second Academia.SE, if a question", "and answers as an archive for interested readers.* The main", "(\"sorry for the dumb question,\" extended thanks, over-lengthy and irrelevant", "I think it leads to conflict between users (in a", "are most important to us, as a community? --- Note:", "first Academia.SE, comments that no longer add any value to", "answers that might be useful to the OP but are", "the community should I follow in acting on flags)? It", "* Closing questions: On the first Academia.SE, questions that are", "are welcome. * Closing questions: On the first Academia.SE, questions", "valuable resources (I think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an example of", "[quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!) in the last year, and", "other people's content, in which edits are discouraged unless a", "a question is broadly relevant to academia and someone is", "#1 or Academia.SE #2? How far do we want to", "makes it difficult to act on the community's wishes (which", "removed (once they no longer serve a useful purpose). To", "on meta) are \"noise\" and should be closed and/or edited", "they no longer serve a useful purpose). To the second", "choose? What goals are most important to us, as a", "while still preserving the intent of the OP. The second", "within the scope of this site. 2. We are facilitating", "unless a post is made CW to explicitly signal that", "once, or to be different things to different users, is", "a healthy way). We have grown [quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and", "the scope of this site. 2. We are facilitating \"on-the-record\"", "it should stay open/be reopened if it's closed. * Comments:", "different things to different users, is (I think) not healthy.", "second Academia.SE has a hands-off approach to other people's content,", "longer serve a useful purpose). To the second Academia.SE, comments", "#2 proposal.\" This was intended to be a prompt for", "concise, clear and correct questions and answers as an archive", "I am looking for answers that address the general idea", "a specific site policy. This is a general question about", "disagreements on meta that I think stem from slightly conflicting", "*We are facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving between academics/researchers with questions and", "To the second Academia.SE, comments are a part of the", "site. #1 and #2 are just things I've heard from", "I've just described can be extremely useful and valuable resources", "the site policies are so inconsistent (both in action, and", "it makes it difficult to act on the community's wishes", "focused answers to questions and problems that are within the", "site is mostly to connect users with questions to other", "I think it's well past time to revisit what this", "This was not intended to be a \"Choose #1 or", "Academia.SE, answers that might be useful to the OP but", "us, as a community? --- Note: this is not a", "Academia.SE #1 or Academia.SE #2? How far do we want", "irrelevant personal information, and pleas of desperation) while still preserving", "users, is (I think) not healthy. As a moderator, it", "answers as an archive for interested readers.** The main goal", "leads to conflict between users (in a bad way, not", "part of the community should I follow in acting on", "as easy as possible for others to get/find accurate, focused", "CW to explicitly signal that edits are welcome. * *Closing", "what this community is (or should be). Broadly, these are:", "- improving question titles, removing \"noise\" (\"sorry for the dumb", "address the general idea of \"What should Academia.SE be?\" whether", "or not. Recently, we've had several disagreements on meta that", "approach to other people's content, in which edits are discouraged", "the current community wants from this site. #1 and #2", "from slightly conflicting views of what this community is (or", "trying to be both at once causes some friction. For", "answers are useful content, and should be treated as such.", "current community wants from this site.* #1 and #2 are", "help the people who participated in it, with the entire", "answer those questions. The main purpose of a thread is", "whatever direction we choose? What goals are most important to", "welcome. * Closing questions: On the first Academia.SE, questions that", "most important to us, as a community? --- Note: this", "think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an example of the former, and", "viewers. Both of the sites I've just described can be", "others to get/find accurate, focused answers to questions and problems", "views of what this community is (or should be). Broadly,", "users with questions to other users who want to answer", "which edits are discouraged unless a post is made CW", "(as defined on meta) are \"noise\" and should be closed", "and future viewers. Both of the sites I've just described", "if it's closed. * Comments: To the first Academia.SE, comments", "conflict between users (in a bad way, not in a", "community? --- Note: this is not a question about a", "I don't think either of these approaches is especially bad", "are \"noise\" and should be closed and/or edited to fit", "in a healthy way). We have grown [quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph)", "since the site policies are so inconsistent (both in action,", "with questions and academics/researchers with answers. The goal of this", "policies are so inconsistent (both in action, and as expressed", "readers. The main goal of this site is to help", "asking questions and future Google users. We want to make", "the former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an example of the latter),", "users, since the site policies are so inconsistent (both in", "for others to get/find accurate, focused answers to questions and", "has a hands-off approach to other people's content, in which", "that aren't really answers are useful content, and should be", "a bad way, not in a healthy way). We have", "confusing to new users, since the site policies are so", "specific site policy. This is a general question about the", "This is a general question about the future direction of", "I've heard from users in the recent past. I am", "intended to be a \"Choose #1 or #2 proposal.\" This", "conflicting views of what this community is (or should be).", "Academia.SE, answers that aren't really answers are useful content, and", "is and what primary role it serves. Do we want", "are so inconsistent (both in action, and as expressed on", "a post or to future readers are distracting, and should", "action, and as expressed on meta). And I think it", "any value to the author of a post or to", "an archive for interested readers.** The main goal of this", "preserved (except for offensive comments). * Answers: On the first", "should be closed and/or edited to fit the scope of", "* Answers: On the first Academia.SE, answers that might be", "answers to the question should be downvoted, converted to comment,", "in the recent past. I am looking for answers that", "the OP but are not really answers to the question", "or a specific site policy. This is a general question", "think it leads to conflict between users (in a bad", "first Academia.SE encourages editing - improving question titles, removing \"noise\"", "stem from slightly conflicting views of what this community is", "of concise, clear and correct questions and answers as an", "desperation) while still preserving the intent of the OP. The", "healthy. As a moderator, it makes it difficult to act", "to help both those asking questions and future Google users.", "to distract from \"real\" answers. On the second Academia.SE, answers", "to conflict between users (in a bad way, not in", "main goal of this site is to help both those", "healthy way). We have grown [quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!)", "1. *We are building up a library of concise, clear", "questions and problems that are within the scope of this", "future viewers. Both of the sites I've just described can", "it's well past time to revisit what this community is", "meta). And I think it leads to conflict between users", "Academia.SE, comments are a part of the historical record of", "and irrelevant personal information, and pleas of desperation) while still", "edits are welcome. Closing questions: On the first Academia.SE,", "to new users, since the site policies are so inconsistent", "should stay open/be reopened if it's closed. * Comments: To", "are useful content, and should be treated as such. I", "How far do we want to go in whatever direction", "it as easy as possible for others to get/find accurate,", "of a thread is to help the people who participated", "it difficult to act on the community's wishes (which part", "think it's well past time to revisit what this community", "relevant to academia and someone is willing to answer it,", "be treated as such. I don't think either of these", "and future Google users. We want to make it as", "content, and should be treated as such. I don't think", "bad way, not in a healthy way). We have grown", "this site is mostly to connect users with questions to", "edits are discouraged unless a post is made CW to", "#2 are just things I've heard from users in the", "edited to fit the scope of the site. On the", "and problems that are within the scope of this site.", "historical record of the communication, and should preserved (except for", "the question should be downvoted, converted to comment, or deleted,", "OP but are not really answers to the question should", "we've had several disagreements on meta that I think stem", "acting on flags)? It is confusing to new users, since", "direction we choose? What goals are most important to us,", "On the second Academia.SE, answers that aren't really answers are", "we want to tend more towards Academia.SE #1 or Academia.SE", "example of the former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an example of", "in action, and as expressed on meta). And I think", "we want to go in whatever direction we choose? What", "Google users. We want to make it as easy as", "just things I've heard from users in the recent past.", "that I think stem from slightly conflicting views of what", "To the first Academia.SE, comments that no longer add any", "on the community's wishes (which part of the community should", "community is and what primary role it serves. Do we", "way). We have grown [quite a lot](http://data.stackexchange.com/academia/query/161411/site-activity-and-votegraph?Weeks=180#graph) (and graduated!) in", "* Editing: The first Academia.SE encourages editing - improving question", "last year, and I think it's well past time to", "as possible for others to get/find accurate, focused answers to", "in it, with the entire thread preserved for the benefit", "of the OP. The second Academia.SE has a hands-off approach", "between academics/researchers with questions and academics/researchers with answers.** The goal", "to get/find accurate, focused answers to questions and problems that", "\"real\" answers. On the second Academia.SE, answers that aren't really", "the first Academia.SE, comments that no longer add any value", "think) not healthy. As a moderator, it makes it difficult", "author of a post or to future readers are distracting,", "of the historical record of the communication, and should preserved", "those questions. The main purpose of a thread is to", "a thread is to help the people who participated in", "the benefit of participants and future viewers. Both of the", "not healthy. As a moderator, it makes it difficult to", "archive for interested readers.** The main goal of this site", "to revisit what this community is and what primary role", "to these themes or not. Recently, we've had several disagreements", "are outside the scope of the site (as defined on", "this site is to help both those asking questions and", "with answers.** The goal of this site is mostly to", "the scope of the site (as defined on meta) are", "primary role it serves. Do we want to tend more", "general idea of \"What should Academia.SE be?\" whether they relate", "the recent past. I am looking for answers that address", "dumb question,\" extended thanks, over-lengthy and irrelevant personal information, and", "site policies are so inconsistent (both in action, and as", "goals are most important to us, as a community? ---", "expressed on meta). And I think it leads to conflict", "a moderator, it makes it difficult to act on the", "in the last year, and I think it's well past", "and correct questions and answers as an archive for interested", "first Academia.SE, answers that might be useful to the OP", "think stem from slightly conflicting views of what this community", "of the former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an example of the", "I think stem from slightly conflicting views of what this", "well past time to revisit what this community is and", "of this site is mostly to connect users with questions", "converted to comment, or deleted, so as not to distract", "for answers that address the general idea of \"What should", "people who participated in it, with the entire thread preserved", "this site.* #1 and #2 are just things I've heard", "to be a prompt for discussion about what the current", "goal of this site is mostly to connect users with", "- but trying to be both at once, or to", "on meta). And I think it leads to conflict between", "for interested readers.* The main goal of this site is", "specific scenario or a specific site policy. This is a", "it's closed. * Comments: To the first Academia.SE, comments that", "On the first Academia.SE, answers that might be useful to", "those asking questions and future Google users. We want to", "Editing: The first Academia.SE encourages editing - improving question titles,", "this is not a question about a specific scenario or", "(once they no longer serve a useful purpose). To the", "--- Note: this is not a question about a specific", "closed. * Comments: To the first Academia.SE, comments that no", "to future readers are distracting, and should be removed (once", "defined on meta) are \"noise\" and should be closed and/or", "might be useful to the OP but are not really", "that are within the scope of this site. 2. *We", "be a prompt for discussion about what the current community", "should Academia.SE be?\" whether they relate to these themes or", "are discouraged unless a post is made CW to explicitly", "second Academia.SE, if a question is broadly relevant to academia", "of the communication, and should preserved (except for offensive comments).", "in acting on flags)? It is confusing to new users,", "to answer it, it should stay open/be reopened if it's", "is a general question about the future direction of the", "thanks, over-lengthy and irrelevant personal information, and pleas of desperation)", "Edit: This was not intended to be a \"Choose #1", "improving question titles, removing \"noise\" (\"sorry for the dumb question,\"", "the historical record of the communication, and should preserved (except", "should preserved (except for offensive comments). * Answers: On the", "help both those asking questions and future Google users. We", "The first Academia.SE encourages editing - improving question titles, removing", "meta) are \"noise\" and should be closed and/or edited to", "year, and I think it's well past time to revisit", "want to tend more towards Academia.SE #1 or Academia.SE #2?", "to be a \"Choose #1 or #2 proposal.\" This was", "useful to the OP but are not really answers to", "way, not in a healthy way). We have grown [quite", "Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an example of the former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is", "to comment, or deleted, so as not to distract from", "things I've heard from users in the recent past. I", "is to help both those asking questions and future Google", "#1 and #2 are just things I've heard from users", "between users (in a bad way, not in a healthy", "Broadly, these are: 1. *We are building up a library", "once causes some friction. For example, Editing: The first", "past. I am looking for answers that address the general", "are not really answers to the question should be downvoted,", "the site (as defined on meta) are \"noise\" and should", "preserving the intent of the OP. The second Academia.SE has", "problems that are within the scope of this site. 2.", "Academia.SE be?\" whether they relate to these themes or not.", "pleas of desperation) while still preserving the intent of the", "be closed and/or edited to fit the scope of the", "to be both at once causes some friction. For example,", "question about the future direction of the site, please answer", "of the sites I've just described can be extremely useful", "it leads to conflict between users (in a bad way,", "go in whatever direction we choose? What goals are most", "distract from \"real\" answers. On the second Academia.SE, answers that", "trying to be both at once, or to be different", "of participants and future viewers. Both of the sites I've", "intended to be a prompt for discussion about what the", "readers are distracting, and should be removed (once they no", "bad - but trying to be both at once, or", "that address the general idea of \"What should Academia.SE be?\"", "building up a library of concise, clear and correct questions", "problem-solving between academics/researchers with questions and academics/researchers with answers.* The", "either of these approaches is especially bad - but trying", "(I think [Cross Validated](https://stats.stackexchange.com/) is an example of the former,", "follow in acting on flags)? It is confusing to new", "\"noise\" and should be closed and/or edited to fit the", "academics/researchers with questions and academics/researchers with answers. The goal of", "connect users with questions to other users who want to", "answers. On the second Academia.SE, answers that aren't really answers", "about the future direction of the site, please answer accordingly.", "comments are a part of the historical record of the", "site policy. This is a general question about the future", "and as expressed on meta). And I think it leads", "a useful purpose). To the second Academia.SE, comments are a", "community is (or should be). Broadly, these are: 1. We", "to tend more towards Academia.SE #1 or Academia.SE #2? How", "several disagreements on meta that I think stem from slightly", "is willing to answer it, it should stay open/be reopened", "fit the scope of the site. On the second Academia.SE,", "a library of concise, clear and correct questions and answers", "do we want to go in whatever direction we choose?", "Academia.SE has a hands-off approach to other people's content, in", "time to revisit what this community is and what primary", "and #2 are just things I've heard from users in", "the site. On the second Academia.SE, if a question is", "communication, and should preserved (except for offensive comments). * Answers:", "an example of the latter), but trying to be both", "made CW to explicitly signal that edits are welcome. ", "Comments:* To the first Academia.SE, comments that no longer add", "with the entire thread preserved for the benefit of participants", "as an archive for interested readers.** The main goal of", "I follow in acting on flags)? It is confusing to", "a question about a specific scenario or a specific site", "to other users who want to answer those questions. The", "to explicitly signal that edits are welcome. * Closing questions:", "and pleas of desperation) while still preserving the intent of", "should I follow in acting on flags)? It is confusing", "these are: 1. *We are building up a library of", "the second Academia.SE, if a question is broadly relevant to", "no longer add any value to the author of a", "Do we want to tend more towards Academia.SE #1 or", "the author of a post or to future readers are", "example of the latter), but trying to be both at", "We want to make it as easy as possible for", "not in a healthy way). We have grown [quite a", "Academia.SE, if a question is broadly relevant to academia and", "is broadly relevant to academia and someone* is willing to", "the sites I've just described can be extremely useful and", "The main goal of this site is to help both", "policy. This is a general question about the future direction", "these themes or not. Recently, we've had several disagreements on", "still preserving the intent of the OP. The second Academia.SE", "site. 2. *We are facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving between academics/researchers with", "of a post or to future readers are distracting, and", "main purpose of a thread is to help the people", "facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving between academics/researchers with questions and academics/researchers with", "a hands-off approach to other people's content, in which edits", "as a community? --- Note: this is not a question", "(both in action, and as expressed on meta). And I", "things to different users, is (I think) not healthy. As", "who participated in it, with the entire thread preserved for", "that no longer add any value to the author of", "site is to help both those asking questions and* future", "to answer those questions. The main purpose of a thread", "is not a question about a specific scenario or a", "of these approaches is especially bad - but trying to", "that might be useful to the OP but are not", "not a question about a specific scenario or a specific", "should be). Broadly, these are: 1. We are building up", "Note: this is not a question about a specific scenario", "so as not to distract from \"real\" answers. On the", "the general idea of \"What should Academia.SE be?\" whether they", "is confusing to new users, since the site policies are", "correct questions and answers as an archive for interested readers.", "The second Academia.SE has a hands-off approach to other people's", "recent past. I am looking for answers that address the", "from users in the recent past. I am looking for", "about a specific scenario or a specific site policy. This", "relate to these themes or not. Recently, we've had several", "Both of the sites I've just described can be extremely", "community's wishes (which part of the community should I follow", "an example of the former, and [MathOverflow](https://mathoverflow.net/) is an example", "is especially bad - but trying to be both at", "scope of the site (as defined on meta) are \"noise\"", "\"on-the-record\" problem-solving between academics/researchers with questions and academics/researchers with answers.", "personal information, and pleas of desperation) while still preserving the", "but are not really answers to the question should be", "flags)? It is confusing to new users, since the site", "proposal.\" This was intended to be a prompt for discussion", "It is confusing to new users, since the site policies", "a general question about the future direction of the site,", "Academia.SE, questions that are outside the scope of the site", "described can be extremely useful and valuable resources (I think", "\"What should Academia.SE be?\" whether they relate to these themes", "questions and answers as an archive for interested readers. The", "from \"real\" answers. On the second Academia.SE, answers that aren't", "*We are building up a library of concise, clear and", "act on the community's wishes (which part of the community", "some friction. For example, Editing: The first Academia.SE encourages", "are just things I've heard from users in the recent", "sites I've just described can be extremely useful and valuable", "was intended to be a prompt for discussion about what", "(which part of the community should I follow in acting", "wishes (which part of the community should I follow in", "someone* is willing to answer it, it should stay open/be", "purpose of a thread is to help the people who", "themes or not. Recently, we've had several disagreements on meta", "to different users, is (I think) not healthy. As a", "think either of these approaches is especially bad - but", "to make it as easy as possible for others to", "friction. For example, * Editing: The first Academia.SE encourages editing", "first Academia.SE, questions that are outside the scope of the", "they relate to these themes or not. Recently, we've had", "are facilitating \"on-the-record\" problem-solving between academics/researchers with questions and academics/researchers", "(or should be). Broadly, these are: 1. *We are building", "value to the author of a post or to future", "this community is (or should be). Broadly, these are: 1.", "to fit the scope of the site. On the second", "#2? How far do we want to go in whatever", "tend more towards Academia.SE #1 or Academia.SE #2? How far", "not intended to be a \"Choose #1 or #2 proposal.\"", "comment, or deleted, so as not to distract from \"real\"", "participated in it, with the entire thread preserved for the", "that edits are welcome. Closing questions: On the first", "to help the people who participated in it, with the", "post or to future readers are distracting, and should be", "don't think either of these approaches is especially bad -", "Academia.SE encourages editing - improving question titles, removing \"noise\" (\"sorry", "\"Choose #1 or #2 proposal.\" This was intended to be", "distracting, and should be removed (once they no longer serve", "or to be different things to different users, is (I", "The goal of this site is mostly to connect users" ]
[ "added information, and the question edited such that it appears", "the question edited such that it appears to me to", "edited such that it appears to me to now by", "between two types of German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally rightfully", "vote, however, doesn't seem to be going anywhere. Is there", "by a quite clear and useful question. Its reopen vote,", "me to now by a quite clear and useful question.", "to me to now by a quite clear and useful", "to now by a quite clear and useful question. Its", "hold as being unclear. The original poster then added information,", "question edited such that it appears to me to now", "on hold as being unclear. The original poster then added", "now by a quite clear and useful question. Its reopen", "question. Its reopen vote, however, doesn't seem to be going", "[This question on differences between two types of German doctoral", "differences between two types of German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally", "being unclear. The original poster then added information, and the", "then added information, and the question edited such that it", "as being unclear. The original poster then added information, and", "on differences between two types of German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was", "clear and useful question. Its reopen vote, however, doesn't seem", "and the question edited such that it appears to me", "Its reopen vote, however, doesn't seem to be going anywhere.", "rightfully put on hold as being unclear. The original poster", "of German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally rightfully put on hold", "useful question. Its reopen vote, however, doesn't seem to be", "question on differences between two types of German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program)", "put on hold as being unclear. The original poster then", "poster then added information, and the question edited such that", "information, and the question edited such that it appears to", "reopen vote, however, doesn't seem to be going anywhere. Is", "a quite clear and useful question. Its reopen vote, however,", "it appears to me to now by a quite clear", "originally rightfully put on hold as being unclear. The original", "two types of German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally rightfully put", "was originally rightfully put on hold as being unclear. The", "such that it appears to me to now by a", "appears to me to now by a quite clear and", "that it appears to me to now by a quite", "however, doesn't seem to be going anywhere. Is there a", "unclear. The original poster then added information, and the question", "and useful question. Its reopen vote, however, doesn't seem to", "The original poster then added information, and the question edited", "original poster then added information, and the question edited such", "quite clear and useful question. Its reopen vote, however, doesn't", "doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally rightfully put on hold as being", "doesn't seem to be going anywhere. Is there a reason", "types of German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally rightfully put on", "German doctoral programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally rightfully put on hold as", "seem to be going anywhere. Is there a reason for", "programs](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34431/stuctured-vs-individual-german-doctoral-program) was originally rightfully put on hold as being unclear.", "to be going anywhere. Is there a reason for this?" ]
[ "images from Wikimedia in posters. I think that she should", "appears on her profile, but not in the answer itself.", "disagree with my view, so I think I should ask", "seems to disagree with my view, so I think I", "user [Aubrey](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/26682/aubrey) speaks about the use of images from Wikimedia", "fact that she is president of the Italian branch of", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/34817/958), user [Aubrey](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/26682/aubrey) speaks about the use of images from", "the fact that she is president of the Italian branch", "use of images from Wikimedia in posters. I think that", "not in the answer itself. In the comments, she seems", "on her profile, but not in the answer itself. In", "In the comments, she seems to disagree with my view,", "In [this recent answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/34817/958), user [Aubrey](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/26682/aubrey) speaks about the use", "her profile, but not in the answer itself. In the", "in the answer itself. In the comments, she seems to", "my view, so I think I should ask for further", "the comments, she seems to disagree with my view, so", "that she is president of the Italian branch of Wikimedia;", "Italian branch of Wikimedia; this bit of information currently appears", "currently appears on her profile, but not in the answer", "to disagree with my view, so I think I should", "of information currently appears on her profile, but not in", "but not in the answer itself. In the comments, she", "think I should ask for further opinions from users and", "I should ask for further opinions from users and moderators.", "about the use of images from Wikimedia in posters. I", "Wikimedia; this bit of information currently appears on her profile,", "is president of the Italian branch of Wikimedia; this bit", "so I think I should ask for further opinions from", "the use of images from Wikimedia in posters. I think", "of the Italian branch of Wikimedia; this bit of information", "information currently appears on her profile, but not in the", "disclose the fact that she is president of the Italian", "the Italian branch of Wikimedia; this bit of information currently", "profile, but not in the answer itself. In the comments,", "answer itself. In the comments, she seems to disagree with", "she is president of the Italian branch of Wikimedia; this", "the answer itself. In the comments, she seems to disagree", "in posters. I think that she should disclose the fact", "[Aubrey](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/26682/aubrey) speaks about the use of images from Wikimedia in", "view, so I think I should ask for further opinions", "of images from Wikimedia in posters. I think that she", "this bit of information currently appears on her profile, but", "that she should disclose the fact that she is president", "she seems to disagree with my view, so I think", "Wikimedia in posters. I think that she should disclose the", "recent answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/34817/958), user [Aubrey](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/26682/aubrey) speaks about the use of images", "from Wikimedia in posters. I think that she should disclose", "think that she should disclose the fact that she is", "bit of information currently appears on her profile, but not", "posters. I think that she should disclose the fact that", "itself. In the comments, she seems to disagree with my", "I think that she should disclose the fact that she", "should disclose the fact that she is president of the", "I think I should ask for further opinions from users", "comments, she seems to disagree with my view, so I", "branch of Wikimedia; this bit of information currently appears on", "[this recent answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/34817/958), user [Aubrey](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/26682/aubrey) speaks about the use of", "with my view, so I think I should ask for", "she should disclose the fact that she is president of", "of Wikimedia; this bit of information currently appears on her", "president of the Italian branch of Wikimedia; this bit of", "speaks about the use of images from Wikimedia in posters." ]
[ "community is made by people who study/research math. Even undergrads", "Given that (at least in my country), math workers are", "me that the overall community is made by people who", "It seems to me that the overall community is made", "are a tiny fraction of the (academic) population, this seems", "a tiny fraction of the (academic) population, this seems an", "that the overall community is made by people who study/research", "many mathematicians here? It seems to me that the overall", "questions. Given that (at least in my country), math workers", "I'm curious: why there are so many mathematicians here? It", "country), math workers are a tiny fraction of the (academic)", "(at least in my country), math workers are a tiny", "OT, but I'm curious: why there are so many mathematicians", "least in my country), math workers are a tiny fraction", "post questions. Given that (at least in my country), math", "math workers are a tiny fraction of the (academic) population,", "but I'm curious: why there are so many mathematicians here?", "why there are so many mathematicians here? It seems to", "my country), math workers are a tiny fraction of the", "curious: why there are so many mathematicians here? It seems", "mathematicians here? It seems to me that the overall community", "made by people who study/research math. Even undergrads post questions.", "study/research math. Even undergrads post questions. Given that (at least", "in my country), math workers are a tiny fraction of", "who study/research math. Even undergrads post questions. Given that (at", "so many mathematicians here? It seems to me that the", "is made by people who study/research math. Even undergrads post", "that (at least in my country), math workers are a", "Even undergrads post questions. Given that (at least in my", "probably OT, but I'm curious: why there are so many", "is probably OT, but I'm curious: why there are so", "by people who study/research math. Even undergrads post questions. Given", "here? It seems to me that the overall community is", "undergrads post questions. Given that (at least in my country),", "workers are a tiny fraction of the (academic) population, this", "to me that the overall community is made by people", "seems to me that the overall community is made by", "are so many mathematicians here? It seems to me that", "overall community is made by people who study/research math. Even", "people who study/research math. Even undergrads post questions. Given that", "This is probably OT, but I'm curious: why there are", "tiny fraction of the (academic) population, this seems an exception.", "the overall community is made by people who study/research math.", "math. Even undergrads post questions. Given that (at least in", "there are so many mathematicians here? It seems to me" ]
[ "remained open and there are comparable questions about individual publishers", "I thus think, we should have a clear decision as", "Yesterday, we closed [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34723/7734) about an individual conference’s reputability,", "about an individual conference’s reputability, i.e., as to whether the", "think, we should have a clear decision as to whether", "questions about individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus think,", "to whether the conference is a scam or not. The", "important related discussion is: [Should we name names when talking", "[Should we name names when talking about bad publishers and", "individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus think, we should", "whether the conference is a scam or not. The author", "we name names when talking about bad publishers and researchers?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1297/7734)", "a scam or not. The author correctly remarked that [a", "correctly remarked that [a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open and there", "that [a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open and there are comparable", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34723/7734) about an individual conference’s reputability, i.e., as to", "as to whether such questions are welcome here or not.", "[2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus think, we should have a clear", "remarked that [a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open and there are", "open and there are comparable questions about individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734),", "or not. An important related discussion is: [Should we name", "thus think, we should have a clear decision as to", "have a clear decision as to whether such questions are", "should have a clear decision as to whether such questions", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open and there are comparable questions about individual", "An important related discussion is: [Should we name names when", "we closed [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34723/7734) about an individual conference’s reputability, i.e.,", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34723/7734) about an individual conference’s reputability, i.e., as to whether", "comparable questions about individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus", "such questions are welcome here or not. An important related", "decision as to whether such questions are welcome here or", "here or not. An important related discussion is: [Should we", "not. The author correctly remarked that [a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained", "similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open and there are comparable questions about", "questions are welcome here or not. An important related discussion", "related discussion is: [Should we name names when talking about", "to whether such questions are welcome here or not. An", "closed [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34723/7734) about an individual conference’s reputability, i.e., as", "welcome here or not. An important related discussion is: [Should", "i.e., as to whether the conference is a scam or", "individual conference’s reputability, i.e., as to whether the conference is", "is: [Should we name names when talking about bad publishers", "not. An important related discussion is: [Should we name names", "([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus think, we should have a", "conference is a scam or not. The author correctly remarked", "[a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open and there are comparable questions", "and there are comparable questions about individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734),", "or not. The author correctly remarked that [a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734)", "scam or not. The author correctly remarked that [a similar", "discussion is: [Should we name names when talking about bad", "conference’s reputability, i.e., as to whether the conference is a", "as to whether the conference is a scam or not.", "clear decision as to whether such questions are welcome here", "whether such questions are welcome here or not. An important", "reputability, i.e., as to whether the conference is a scam", "publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus think, we should have", "the conference is a scam or not. The author correctly", "an individual conference’s reputability, i.e., as to whether the conference", "is a scam or not. The author correctly remarked that", "[3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus think, we should have a clear decision", "about individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I thus think, we", "there are comparable questions about individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)).", "we should have a clear decision as to whether such", "are welcome here or not. An important related discussion is:", "The author correctly remarked that [a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open", "are comparable questions about individual publishers ([1](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2513/7734), [2](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/5466/7734), [3](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/15570/7734)). I", "a clear decision as to whether such questions are welcome", "author correctly remarked that [a similar questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10261/7734) remained open and" ]
[ "[39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have this keyword in their title and", "the questions about manuscripts and I find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which", "which have this keyword in their title and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript)", "included. Should we have a separate tag for questions about", "and I find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have this keyword in", "keyword in their title and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have this", "their title and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have this keyword included.", "have this keyword in their title and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which", "Should we have a separate tag for questions about manuscripts?", "the website for the questions about manuscripts and I find", "have this keyword included. Should we have a separate tag", "I find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have this keyword in their", "have searched the website for the questions about manuscripts and", "for the questions about manuscripts and I find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript)", "this keyword included. Should we have a separate tag for", "about manuscripts and I find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have this", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have this keyword included. Should we have a", "manuscripts and I find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have this keyword", "and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have this keyword included. Should we", "this keyword in their title and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have this keyword in their title and [796", "in their title and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have this keyword", "I have searched the website for the questions about manuscripts", "questions about manuscripts and I find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have", "keyword included. Should we have a separate tag for questions", "website for the questions about manuscripts and I find [39", "find [39 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Amanuscript) which have this keyword in their title", "title and [796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have this keyword included. Should", "searched the website for the questions about manuscripts and I", "[796 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=manuscript) which have this keyword included. Should we have", "which have this keyword included. Should we have a separate" ]
[ "* Some say they should be removed if there are", "\"thank you\" comment might be declined by a moderator one", "the very useful link\") * Some say they should be", "little consistency on this site - a flag on a", "* Some say they make the community more human and", "the community more human and friendly, and are nice to", "be removed. Right now, there is very little consistency on", "comments should be deleted. * Some say they make the", "Some say they should always be removed. Right now, there", "or highlight something useful in the post (e.g. \"+1, especially", "they also offer constructive criticism or highlight something useful in", "Some say they should be removed if there are other,", "more useful comments. * Some say they should always be", "more human and friendly, and are nice to keep around", "the next day if the same user raises a flag", "again. On Academia, under what conditions should \"thank you\" comments", "There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE as to when such", "+1, good answer > > > for moderator deletion as", "they make the community more human and friendly, and are", "of the more useful comments. * Some say they should", "if the same user raises a flag again. On Academia,", "if they also offer constructive criticism or highlight something useful", "raises a flag again. On Academia, under what conditions should", "removed if there are other, more useful, comments on a", "on a post, and the thanks get in the way", "the same user raises a flag again. On Academia, under", "> > or > > +1, good answer > >", "human and friendly, and are nice to keep around ", "day, then the same comment might deleted by another moderator", "are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE as to when such comments", "site - a flag on a \"thank you\" comment might", "> > for moderator deletion as 'too chatty.' There are", "On Academia, under what conditions should \"thank you\" comments be", "are nice to keep around Some say they are", "a \"thank you\" comment might be declined by a moderator", "the post (e.g. \"+1, especially for the very useful link\")", "comments on a post, and the thanks get in the", "moderator deletion as 'too chatty.' There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on", "is very little consistency on this site - a flag", "in the way of the more useful comments. * Some", "criticism or highlight something useful in the post (e.g. \"+1,", "say they make the community more human and friendly, and", "useful if they also offer constructive criticism or highlight something", "way of the more useful comments. * Some say they", "to keep around * Some say they are useful if", "on this site - a flag on a \"thank you\"", "flag again. On Academia, under what conditions should \"thank you\"", "another moderator the next day if the same user raises", "deletion as 'too chatty.' There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE", "thanks get in the way of the more useful comments.", "sometimes flag comments that say > > Thank you >", "in the post (e.g. \"+1, especially for the very useful", "there is very little consistency on this site - a", "should be removed if there are other, more useful, comments", "* Some say they should always be removed. Right now,", "the same comment might deleted by another moderator the next", "more useful, comments on a post, and the thanks get", "be declined by a moderator one day, then the same", "also offer constructive criticism or highlight something useful in the", "and friendly, and are nice to keep around * Some", "flag comments that say > > Thank you > >", "> > +1, good answer > > > for moderator", "very little consistency on this site - a flag on", "Some say they make the community more human and friendly,", "by a moderator one day, then the same comment might", "for moderator deletion as 'too chatty.' There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged)", "they should always be removed. Right now, there is very", "now, there is very little consistency on this site -", "deleted by another moderator the next day if the same", "might be declined by a moderator one day, then the", "- a flag on a \"thank you\" comment might be", "a moderator one day, then the same comment might deleted", "nice to keep around * Some say they are useful", "same user raises a flag again. On Academia, under what", "good answer > > > for moderator deletion as 'too", "> for moderator deletion as 'too chatty.' There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment)", "day if the same user raises a flag again. On", "say > > Thank you > > > or >", "you > > > or > > +1, good answer", "as to when such comments should be deleted. * Some", "around * Some say they are useful if they also", "say they are useful if they also offer constructive criticism", "they should be removed if there are other, more useful,", "they are useful if they also offer constructive criticism or", "* Some say they are useful if they also offer", "post, and the thanks get in the way of the", "of this site sometimes flag comments that say > >", "\"+1, especially for the very useful link\") * Some say", "friendly, and are nice to keep around * Some say", "get in the way of the more useful comments. ", "[opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE as to when such comments should be", "> > Thank you > > > or > >", "the more useful comments. Some say they should always", "Academia, under what conditions should \"thank you\" comments be deleted", "Right now, there is very little consistency on this site", "highlight something useful in the post (e.g. \"+1, especially for", "post (e.g. \"+1, especially for the very useful link\") ", "useful, comments on a post, and the thanks get in", "you\" comment might be declined by a moderator one day,", "there are other, more useful, comments on a post, and", "the way of the more useful comments. Some say", "[varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE as to when such comments should", "for the very useful link\") * Some say they should", "removed. Right now, there is very little consistency on this", "by another moderator the next day if the same user", "Users of this site sometimes flag comments that say >", "to when such comments should be deleted. * Some say", "(e.g. \"+1, especially for the very useful link\") * Some", "comment might be declined by a moderator one day, then", "MSE as to when such comments should be deleted. ", "are useful if they also offer constructive criticism or highlight", "moderator the next day if the same user raises a", "as 'too chatty.' There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE as", "on MSE as to when such comments should be deleted.", "are other, more useful, comments on a post, and the", "the thanks get in the way of the more useful", "Some say they are useful if they also offer constructive", "one day, then the same comment might deleted by another", "such comments should be deleted. Some say they make", "be removed if there are other, more useful, comments on", "chatty.' There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE as to when", "useful comments. * Some say they should always be removed.", "then the same comment might deleted by another moderator the", "especially for the very useful link\") * Some say they", "offer constructive criticism or highlight something useful in the post", "and the thanks get in the way of the more", "declined by a moderator one day, then the same comment", "and are nice to keep around * Some say they", "consistency on this site - a flag on a \"thank", "say they should be removed if there are other, more", "always be removed. Right now, there is very little consistency", "constructive criticism or highlight something useful in the post (e.g.", "flag on a \"thank you\" comment might be declined by", "a flag again. On Academia, under what conditions should \"thank", "deleted. * Some say they make the community more human", "if there are other, more useful, comments on a post,", "say they should always be removed. Right now, there is", "a flag on a \"thank you\" comment might be declined", "comments that say > > Thank you > > >", "moderator one day, then the same comment might deleted by", "something useful in the post (e.g. \"+1, especially for the", "or > > +1, good answer > > > for", "next day if the same user raises a flag again.", "very useful link\") * Some say they should be removed", "user raises a flag again. On Academia, under what conditions", "might deleted by another moderator the next day if the", "other, more useful, comments on a post, and the thanks", "should be deleted. * Some say they make the community", "Thank you > > > or > > +1, good", "useful in the post (e.g. \"+1, especially for the very", "on a \"thank you\" comment might be declined by a", "that say > > Thank you > > > or", "same comment might deleted by another moderator the next day", "this site - a flag on a \"thank you\" comment", "> Thank you > > > or > > +1,", "what conditions should \"thank you\" comments be deleted by moderators?", "keep around * Some say they are useful if they", "useful link\") * Some say they should be removed if", "should always be removed. Right now, there is very little", "be deleted. * Some say they make the community more", "community more human and friendly, and are nice to keep", "'too chatty.' There are [varying](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/126180/is-it-acceptable-to-write-a-thank-you-in-a-comment) [opinions](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/169994/should-a-thank-you-comment-be-flagged) on MSE as to", "> > > or > > +1, good answer >", "when such comments should be deleted. * Some say they", "under what conditions should \"thank you\" comments be deleted by", "> > > for moderator deletion as 'too chatty.' There", "comments. * Some say they should always be removed. Right", "a post, and the thanks get in the way of", "> or > > +1, good answer > > >", "> +1, good answer > > > for moderator deletion", "comment might deleted by another moderator the next day if", "link\") * Some say they should be removed if there", "make the community more human and friendly, and are nice", "this site sometimes flag comments that say > > Thank", "answer > > > for moderator deletion as 'too chatty.'", "site sometimes flag comments that say > > Thank you" ]
[ "or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions tagged 'scopus'\") while we have a", "tag and we already have brand or website names tags", "\"show questions tagged 'twitter'\"), etc. with no more than 10", "exists; however, we have a more general tag each of", "tagged 'social-media'\"). My question is, what is the role of", "tags when we can have a general tag and we", "while we have a more general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions", "brand names in form of the website's names, publishers, etc.", "\"show questions tagged 'elsevier'\") with only 6 questions tagged or", "same also situation exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions tagged 'facebook'\"),", "tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\"). My question is, what", "the website's names, publishers, etc. exists; however, we have a", "of having such brand name tags on the website, while", "questions tagged 'elsevier'\") with only 6 questions tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus", "'social-media'\"). My question is, what is the role of having", "them. For instance, we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions tagged 'elsevier'\")", "in form of the website's names, publishers, etc. exists; however,", "more than 10 questions tagged; while we have a more", "we already have brand or website names tags on Academia?", "is, what is the role of having such brand name", "good general tags as well? And, what can we do", "tagged 'elsevier'\") with only 6 questions tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show", "a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions tagged 'publishers'\") tag with 52 questions", "website, we have many brand names in form of the", "The same also situation exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions tagged", "we have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions tagged 'publishers'\") tag with", "questions tagged 'publishers'\") tag with 52 questions tagged. The same", "when we can have a general tag and we already", "My question is, what is the role of having such", "website, while we have good general tags as well? And,", "we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions tagged 'elsevier'\") with only 6", "with no more than 10 questions tagged; while we have", "[elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions tagged 'elsevier'\") with only 6 questions tagged", "And, what can we do to have more orginised tags", "have good general tags as well? And, what can we", "many brand names in form of the website's names, publishers,", "however, we have a more general tag each of them.", "tagged 'scopus'\") while we have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions tagged", "tags as well? And, what can we do to have", "etc. exists; however, we have a more general tag each", "'twitter'\"), etc. with no more than 10 questions tagged; while", "have a more general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\").", "well? And, what can we do to have more orginised", "general tag and we already have brand or website names", "tag with 52 questions tagged. The same also situation exists", "questions tagged. The same also situation exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show", "can have a general tag and we already have brand", "each of them. For instance, we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions", "for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions tagged", "tagged; while we have a more general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show", "exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions", "[scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions tagged 'scopus'\") while we have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers", "only 6 questions tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions tagged 'scopus'\")", "general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\"). My question is,", "having such brand name tags on the website, while we", "a more general tag each of them. For instance, we", "general tags as well? And, what can we do to", "etc. with no more than 10 questions tagged; while we", "of them. For instance, we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions tagged", "'elsevier'\") with only 6 questions tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions", "as well? And, what can we do to have more", "of the website's names, publishers, etc. exists; however, we have", "with 52 questions tagged. The same also situation exists for", "a more general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\"). My", "we can have a general tag and we already have", "'publishers'\") tag with 52 questions tagged. The same also situation", "we have a more general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged", "is the role of having such brand name tags on", "on the website, while we have good general tags as", "have a more general tag each of them. For instance,", "website's names, publishers, etc. exists; however, we have a more", "while we have good general tags as well? And, what", "have more orginised tags when we can have a general", "question is, what is the role of having such brand", "52 questions tagged. The same also situation exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook", "do to have more orginised tags when we can have", "more orginised tags when we can have a general tag", "questions tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions tagged 'scopus'\") while we", "can we do to have more orginised tags when we", "have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions tagged 'elsevier'\") with only 6 questions", "orginised tags when we can have a general tag and", "instance, we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions tagged 'elsevier'\") with only", "questions tagged 'scopus'\") while we have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions", "publishers, etc. exists; however, we have a more general tag", "more general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\"). My question", "what can we do to have more orginised tags when", "\"show questions tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions tagged 'twitter'\"), etc.", "On the website, we have many brand names in form", "we have many brand names in form of the website's", "more general tag each of them. For instance, we have", "situation exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show", "\"show questions tagged 'publishers'\") tag with 52 questions tagged. The", "names in form of the website's names, publishers, etc. exists;", "tags on the website, while we have good general tags", "tagged 'twitter'\"), etc. with no more than 10 questions tagged;", "we do to have more orginised tags when we can", "with only 6 questions tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions tagged", "such brand name tags on the website, while we have", "questions tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions tagged 'twitter'\"), etc. with", "while we have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions tagged 'publishers'\") tag", "[social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media \"show questions tagged 'social-media'\"). My question is, what is", "tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions tagged 'scopus'\") while we have", "questions tagged 'twitter'\"), etc. with no more than 10 questions", "the role of having such brand name tags on the", "10 questions tagged; while we have a more general tag", "6 questions tagged or [scopus](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/scopus \"show questions tagged 'scopus'\") while", "we have good general tags as well? And, what can", "what is the role of having such brand name tags", "also situation exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter", "than 10 questions tagged; while we have a more general", "a general tag and we already have brand or website", "tagged. The same also situation exists for [facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions", "tagged 'publishers'\") tag with 52 questions tagged. The same also", "questions tagged 'social-media'\"). My question is, what is the role", "the website, while we have good general tags as well?", "form of the website's names, publishers, etc. exists; however, we", "general tag each of them. For instance, we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier", "we have a more general tag each of them. For", "no more than 10 questions tagged; while we have a", "'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions tagged 'twitter'\"), etc. with no more", "have a general tag and we already have brand or", "names, publishers, etc. exists; however, we have a more general", "the website, we have many brand names in form of", "[twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions tagged 'twitter'\"), etc. with no more than", "\"show questions tagged 'social-media'\"). My question is, what is the", "role of having such brand name tags on the website,", "brand name tags on the website, while we have good", "questions tagged; while we have a more general tag [social-media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/social-media", "[facebook](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/facebook \"show questions tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions tagged 'twitter'\"),", "to have more orginised tags when we can have a", "'scopus'\") while we have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions tagged 'publishers'\")", "[publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions tagged 'publishers'\") tag with 52 questions tagged.", "tagged 'facebook'\"), [twitter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/twitter \"show questions tagged 'twitter'\"), etc. with no", "and we already have brand or website names tags on", "have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show questions tagged 'publishers'\") tag with 52", "have many brand names in form of the website's names,", "tag each of them. For instance, we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show", "name tags on the website, while we have good general", "\"show questions tagged 'scopus'\") while we have a [publishers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/publishers \"show", "For instance, we have [elsevier](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/elsevier \"show questions tagged 'elsevier'\") with" ]
[ "Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to", "a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is", "Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will", "community. We reset the ads once a year, every December.", "that have met the threshold with basic click stats [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/ads/display/1478).", "ad is very valuable to the community and will continue", "on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There", "else to the body of the post. If you want", "### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold** an", "This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to", "with the above required form. ### Image requirements * The", "should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to", "site's twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting", "every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that", "it is a good idea to repost it. It may", "the site's first new cycle of Community Promotion Ads! ###", "it. It may be helpful to give it a new", "'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the", "is a good idea to repost it. It may be", "information and resources that are relevant to your own community's", "cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps", "we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain", "accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their", "exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post", "Must be GIF or PNG No animated GIFs ", "and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests,", "year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while", "imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year", "can check out the ads that have met the threshold", "In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this", "ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the", "Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) ", "* anything else your community would genuinely be interested in", "### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some", "this question must conform to the following rules, or they", "before it will be shown on the main site. You", "site. For example, you might promote the following things: ", "relevant to not just the subject matter of the community,", "be shown on the main site. You can check out", "Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community", "the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old", "post to this question must* conform to the following rules,", "of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable", "once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have", "means that it is now time for the site's first", "you might promote the following things: * the site's twitter", "blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else your", "would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future", "year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions", "the answer form with the above required form. ### Image", "and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown.", "every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against", "cool events or conferences * anything else your community would", "this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements", "* interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences", "the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources ", "vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community", "find out about the stuff your community deems important. This", "site's first new cycle of Community Promotion Ads! ### What", "of Community Promotion Ads! ### What are Community Promotion Ads?", "to your own community's interests, both for those already in", "functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer", "the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All", "score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it", "show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do", "Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the", "cycle of Community Promotion Ads! ### What are Community Promotion", "either way it means that it is now time for", "not add anything else to the body of the post*.", "things: the site's twitter account * academic websites and", "give it a new face in the process, so as", "they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in", "restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If", "to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the", "this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose", "form. ### Image requirements * The image that you create", "serves as a way to promote information and resources that", "uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No", "resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both", "previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very", "years, while other things will wane to allow for new", "be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show", "for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors", "of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you", "There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet", "to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The", "The image that you create must be 220 x 250", "year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers", "community, but to the current status of the community. We", "purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer", "the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition", "(currently 6*) before it will be shown on the main", "example, you might promote the following things: the site's", "to not just the subject matter of the community, but", "to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also", "important. This also serves as a way to promote information", "rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should", "over the years, while other things will wane to allow", "answers you post to this question must* conform to the", "check out the ads that have met the threshold with", "this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above", "This also serves as a way to promote information and", "do it in the comments. 2. The question must always", "must conform to the following rules, or they will be", "ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a", "might promote the following things: * the site's twitter account", "so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from", "be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\")", "answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown", "be 220 x 250 pixels * Must be hosted through", "a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6)", "December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting", "the community and those yet to join. ### Why do", "and will continue to be so, it is a good", "This is a method for the community to control what", "it a new face in the process, so as to", "other things will wane to allow for new faces to", "but to the current status of the community. We reset", "required form. ### Image requirements * The image that you", "your own community's interests, both for those already in the", "their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for", "in the community and those yet to join. ### Why", "ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in", "What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted", "promote information and resources that are relevant to your own", "that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels ", "year, 2015, now approaches, or has already approached, either way", "against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a", "approaches, or has already approached, either way it means that", "a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no", "must be 220 x 250 pixels* * Must be hosted", "served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads", "pixels** * Must be hosted through our standard image uploader", "advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community", "[![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ```", "of the community. We reset the ads once a year,", "gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you", "Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows", "is for future visitors to find out about the stuff", "ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form", "keep the material in the ads relevant to not just", "events or conferences anything else your community would genuinely", "shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This", "will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do", "file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is", "while other things will wane to allow for new faces", "If a particular service or ad is very valuable to", "helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served", "220 x 250 pixels * Must be hosted through our", "to promote information and resources that are relevant to your", "tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of", "questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality", "already approached, either way it means that it is now", "show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this,", " academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs", "always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged", "of this question is the vetting process. Images of the", "Ads! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads", "matter of the community, but to the current status of", "interested in The goal is for future visitors to find", "as a way to promote information and resources that are", "to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion", "a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The", "future visitors to find out about the stuff your community", "or conferences anything else your community would genuinely be", "conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored.", "out about the stuff your community deems important. This also", "to be so, it is a good idea to repost", "The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images", "### How does it work? The answers you post to", "the ads that have met the threshold with basic click", "else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal", "limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold", "with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In", "just the subject matter of the community, but to the", "be helpful to give it a new face in the", "the post. If you want to discuss something, do it", "the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure.", "must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions", "an answer must meet (currently 6*) before it will be", "visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the", "cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable", "the community. We reset the ads once a year, every", "do we reset the ads every year? Some services will", "community deems important. This also serves as a way to", "face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery", "way it means that it is now time for the", "for newer things. This helps keep the material in the", "### Image requirements * The image that you create must", "new year, 2015, now approaches, or has already approached, either", "tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements,", "shown on the main site. You can check out the", "own community's interests, both for those already in the community", "to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every", "2. The question must always be tagged with the magic", "Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that", "through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF", "150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a *minimum score", " cool events or conferences * anything else your community", "* Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur)", "mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add", "http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else", "to give it a new face in the process, so", "also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form.", "will continue to be so, it is a good idea", "or has already approached, either way it means that it", "anything else to the body of the post. If you", "do not add anything else to the body of the", "wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting", "be interested in The goal is for future visitors to", "magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to", "or ad is very valuable to the community and will", "Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will", "services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things", "new cycle of Community Promotion Ads! ### What are Community", "Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score", "tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag.", "to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please", "join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year?", "form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url", "that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for", "are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main", "[community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling", "be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute", "be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact", "Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on", "time for the site's first new cycle of Community Promotion", "will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the", "community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for", "out the ads that have met the threshold with basic", "image that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels", "way to promote information and resources that are relevant to", "the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and", "maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane", "now approaches, or has already approached, either way it means", "to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate", "helpful to give it a new face in the process,", "repost it. It may be helpful to give it a", "a new face in the process, so as to prevent", "what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example,", "reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness", "and resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events", "form with the above required form. ### Image requirements ", "or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on", "interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences ", "is very valuable to the community and will continue to", "answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline", "[1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything", "the body of the post. If you want to discuss", "has already approached, either way it means that it is", "the subject matter of the community, but to the current", "discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question", "websites and resources interesting campus story blogs * cool", "goal is for future visitors to find out about the", "it will be shown on the main site. You can", "also serves as a way to promote information and resources", "the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on", "the current status of the community. We reset the ads", "advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the", "process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting", "post. If you want to discuss something, do it in", "of the post. If you want to discuss something, do", "to the current status of the community. We reset the", "resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events or", "and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset", "Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services", "We reset the ads once a year, every December. The", "above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that", "your community deems important. This also serves as a way", "yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads", "the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the", "body of the post. If you want to discuss something,", "you post to this question must* conform to the following", "be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads?", "requirements * The image that you create must be 220", "must meet (currently 6*) before it will be shown on", "an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service", "exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]:", "2015, now approaches, or has already approached, either way it", " the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources", "our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or", "the community and will continue to be so, it is", "add anything else to the body of the post. If", "will be shown on the main site. You can check", "advertisements that will show up on the main site, in", "sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process.", "is now time for the site's first new cycle of", "main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this", "control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For", "you want to discuss something, do it in the comments.", "out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep", "the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with", "250 pixels * Must be hosted through our standard image", "community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site,", "want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2.", "community and those yet to join. ### Why do we", "Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other", "the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the", "not just the subject matter of the community, but to", "will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will", "on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not", "question must* conform to the following rules, or they will", "site. You can check out the ads that have met", "For example, you might promote the following things: * the", "from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How", "a way to promote information and resources that are relevant", "method for the community to control what gets promoted to", "GIF or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit", "for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every", "### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is", "campus story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything", "reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular", "community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ###", "of the ad from getting stale after a year of", "process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad", "``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url", "stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it", "valuable to the community and will continue to be so,", "continue to be so, it is a good idea to", "the following things: * the site's twitter account * academic", "How does it work? The answers you post to this", "story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else", "advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements", "in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on", "[2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else to", "community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the", "All answers should be in the exact form of: ```", "is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently", "of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum", "Please do not add anything else to the body of", "KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold*", "up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and", "standard image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF or PNG", "good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to", "promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might", "account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus story", "ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the", "have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the", "the community, but to the current status of the community.", "a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful", "is a method for the community to control what gets", "It may be helpful to give it a new face", "that will show up on the main site, in the", "Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer must", "enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we", "enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills", "of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form", "in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter", "promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from", "You can check out the ads that have met the", "a method for the community to control what gets promoted", "now time for the site's first new cycle of Community", "be so, it is a good idea to repost it.", "If you want to discuss something, do it in the", "addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag", "conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be interested", "do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method", "after a year of exposure. ### How does it work?", "promote the following things: * the site's twitter account ", "of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]:", "deems important. This also serves as a way to promote", "the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of", "Community Promotion Ads! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community", "* The image that you create must be 220 x", "Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up", "a particular service or ad is very valuable to the", "Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold** an answer", "it work? The answers you post to this question must", "something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must", "may be helpful to give it a new face in", "ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads", "allows old ads that have served their purpose to be", "prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after", "answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements", "http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add anything else to the", "newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads", "community's interests, both for those already in the community and", "status of the community. We reset the ads once a", "comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the", "the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the", "relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already", "first new cycle of Community Promotion Ads! ### What are", "\"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the", "question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are", "ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or", "visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems", "that have served their purpose to be cycled out for", "does it work? The answers you post to this question", "every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years,", "year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have", "The answers you post to this question must* conform to", "GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB", "those already in the community and those yet to join.", "particular service or ad is very valuable to the community", "things will wane to allow for new faces to show", "PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file", "the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a", "getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does", "threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will", "Ads? This is a method for the community to control", "size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a", "ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads", "### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are", "6*) before it will be shown on the main site.", "allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads", "it means that it is now time for the site's", "on the main site. You can check out the ads", "that it is now time for the site's first new", "the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of", "those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the", "for future visitors to find out about the stuff your", "and allows old ads that have served their purpose to", "to repost it. It may be helpful to give it", "Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a", "subject matter of the community, but to the current status", "will show up on the main site, in the right", "ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out", "meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the", "question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show", "on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose", "the material in the ads relevant to not just the", "* Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs", "about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves", "for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the", "the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2]", "old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled", "``` Please *do not add anything else to the body", "ads that have met the threshold with basic click stats", "be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must", "have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher", "to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote", "ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ###", "The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads", "the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with", "it is now time for the site's first new cycle", "the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion", "for the site's first new cycle of Community Promotion Ads!", "x 250 pixels** * Must be hosted through our standard", "your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is", "(imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No animated", "right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting", "the site. For example, you might promote the following things:", "are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those", "of a new year, 2015, now approaches, or has already", "faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps", "in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged", "the years, while other things will wane to allow for", "hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be", "have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous", "material in the ads relevant to not just the subject", "to the body of the post*. If you want to", " Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ###", "to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things.", "fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material", "new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year", "both for those already in the community and those yet", "or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be", "up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The", "you create must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must", "in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is", "for those already in the community and those yet to", "the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over", "voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why", "provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be", "Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show", "community and will continue to be so, it is a", "to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1.", "The goal is for future visitors to find out about", "the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the", "Promotion Ads! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion", "in The goal is for future visitors to find out", "site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question", "dawn of a new year, 2015, now approaches, or has", "a new year, 2015, now approaches, or has already approached,", "tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required", "following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers", "Image requirements * The image that you create must be", "show up on the main site, in the right sidebar.", "we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for", "approached, either way it means that it is now time", "will wane to allow for new faces to show up.", "academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs ", "on the site. For example, you might promote the following", "to find out about the stuff your community deems important.", "reset the ads once a year, every December. The community", "as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting", "1. All answers should be in the exact form of:", "interests, both for those already in the community and those", "The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an", "genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors", "already in the community and those yet to join. ###", "new face in the process, so as to prevent the", "idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give", "to the community and will continue to be so, it", "the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have", "things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant", "image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG ", "from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad", "helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not", "is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided,", "very valuable to the community and will continue to be", "purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of", "the main site. You can check out the ads that", "anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The", "are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to", "current status of the community. We reset the ads once", "to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site.", "of the community, but to the current status of the", "usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to", "minimum score threshold* an answer must meet (currently 6) before", "work? The answers you post to this question must conform", "to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale", "in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of", "no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle.", "twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus", "following things: * the site's twitter account * academic websites", "service or ad is very valuable to the community and", "No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of", "community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad", "* No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size", "create must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must be", "stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a", "the above required form. ### Image requirements The image", "pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ###", "the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as", "are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements", "be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This", "it in the comments. 2. The question must always be", "so, it is a good idea to repost it. It", "animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150", "to this question must conform to the following rules, or", "The dawn of a new year, 2015, now approaches, or", "main site. You can check out the ads that have" ]
[ "does not tell me who the traffic in the queue", "review, so it is difficult to consider a set of", "difficult to go back once you have finished with a", "is simply that people give a heads up (either or", "is difficult to consider a set of actions as a", "about to take a large number of closing or flagging", "give a heads up (either or meta or in chat,", "set of actions as a batch. I thus cannot readily", "votes over the past little while, many of which I", "while, many of which I have disagreed with since the", "a lot of items coming through for review, I run", "review any more items (this happened to me yesterday). Thus,", "of curation work by an established user, trolling by a", "I thus cannot readily tell the difference between a batch", "heads up (either or meta or in chat, whichever seems", "lot* of items coming through for review, I run out", "disagreed with since the questions have a number of up-votes", "review, I run out of reviews that the software will", "up (either or meta or in chat, whichever seems most", "by an established user, trolling by a rep 15 user", "your system? 3. It seems to me that it would", "3. It seems to me that it would be courteous", "at least in chat. Would others agree? --- Edited to", "those of us reviewing can carry out our own portion", "that they limit such actions to ~10/day, so those of", "back once you have finished with a review, so it", "they are about to take a large number of closing", "is your system? 3. It seems to me that it", "When there are a lot of items coming through for", "or a mixture of the two. 2. When there are", "appropriate) when they are about to take a large number", "Also, the review queue presents things one at a time", "for review, I run out of reviews that the software", "a set of actions as a batch. I thus cannot", "ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed a rapid sequence of close votes over", "over the past little while, many of which I have", "tell the difference between a batch of curation work by", "can inhibit the ability of the community to deal with", "without a huge amount of reward. My request is simply", "the review software does not tell me who the traffic", "extremely important function on this site, and one without a", "I very much appreciate the work being put into curation:", "the traffic in the queue is coming from. Also, the", "I have disagreed with since the questions have a number", "is coming from. Also, the review queue presents things one", "to take a large number of closing or flagging actions,", "me that it would be courteous to announce it on", "question from two years ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed a rapid sequence", "on this site, and one without a huge amount of", "items coming through for review, I run out of reviews", "high a rate, it can inhibit the ability of the", "sequence of close votes over the past little while, many", "request is simply that people give a heads up (either", "of us reviewing can carry out our own portion of", "concern: 1. As I am not a moderator, the review", "long-term curation work occurs at too high a rate, it", "[this question from two years ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed a rapid", "purge? 2. If so, what is your system? 3. It", "and one without a huge amount of reward. My request", "ability of the community to deal with new questions. I", "finished with a review, so it is difficult to consider", "huge amount of reward. My request is simply that people", "reviews that the software will allow me to make and", "a moderator, the review software does not tell me who", "moderator, the review software does not tell me who the", "an extremely important function on this site, and one without", "somebody doing a systematic purge? 2. If so, what is", "If so, what is your system? 3. It seems to", "work occurs at too high a rate, it can inhibit", "or in chat, whichever seems most appropriate) when they are", "one without a huge amount of reward. My request is", "queue presents things one at a time and makes it", "tell me who the traffic in the queue is coming", "in the queue is coming from. Also, the review queue", "if long-term curation work occurs at too high a rate,", "when they are about to take a large number of", "you have finished with a review, so it is difficult", "or at least in chat. Would others agree? --- Edited", "software will allow me to make and cannot review any", "cannot review any more items (this happened to me yesterday).", "work by an established user, trolling by a rep 15", "actions as a batch. I thus cannot readily tell the", "new questions. I very much appreciate the work being put", "to make and cannot review any more items (this happened", "reviewing can carry out our own portion of the tasks", "Would others agree? --- Edited to add the reasons for", "the reasons for my concern: 1. As I am not", "My questions: 1. Is somebody doing a systematic purge? 2.", "be courteous to announce it on meta or at least", "reasons for my concern: 1. As I am not a", "through for review, I run out of reviews that the", "as a batch. I thus cannot readily tell the difference", "would be courteous to announce it on meta or at", "once you have finished with a review, so it is", "system? 3. It seems to me that it would be", "1. As I am not a moderator, the review software", "work being put into curation: it's an extremely important function", "cannot readily tell the difference between a batch of curation", "with new questions. I very much appreciate the work being", "number of closing or flagging actions, and that they limit", "site, and one without a huge amount of reward. My", "with since the questions have a number of up-votes and", "coming through for review, I run out of reviews that", "a mixture of the two. 2. When there are a", "us reviewing can carry out our own portion of the", "questions: 1. Is somebody doing a systematic purge? 2. If", "chat. Would others agree? --- Edited to add the reasons", "the ability of the community to deal with new questions.", "of up-votes and answers. My questions: 1. Is somebody doing", "there are a lot of items coming through for review,", "me yesterday). Thus, if long-term curation work occurs at too", "not tell me who the traffic in the queue is", "curation work by an established user, trolling by a rep", "who has gotten annoyed about something, or a mixture of", "readily tell the difference between a batch of curation work", "a large number of closing or flagging actions, and that", "trolling by a rep 15 user who has gotten annoyed", "me who the traffic in the queue is coming from.", "whichever seems most appropriate) when they are about to take", "close votes over the past little while, many of which", "have finished with a review, so it is difficult to", "the software will allow me to make and cannot review", "important function on this site, and one without a huge", "a rep 15 user who has gotten annoyed about something,", "to announce it on meta or at least in chat.", "to [this question from two years ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed a", "(either or meta or in chat, whichever seems most appropriate)", "years ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed a rapid sequence of close votes", "noticed a rapid sequence of close votes over the past", "they limit such actions to ~10/day, so those of us", "so those of us reviewing can carry out our own", "I've noticed a rapid sequence of close votes over the", "to me that it would be courteous to announce it", "to ~10/day, so those of us reviewing can carry out", "this site, and one without a huge amount of reward.", "I am not a moderator, the review software does not", "up-votes and answers. My questions: 1. Is somebody doing a", "batch. I thus cannot readily tell the difference between a", "too high a rate, it can inhibit the ability of", "to go back once you have finished with a review,", "by a rep 15 user who has gotten annoyed about", "time and makes it difficult to go back once you", "that it would be courteous to announce it on meta", "doing a systematic purge? 2. If so, what is your", "presents things one at a time and makes it difficult", "Is somebody doing a systematic purge? 2. If so, what", "and answers. My questions: 1. Is somebody doing a systematic", "rapid sequence of close votes over the past little while,", "since the questions have a number of up-votes and answers.", "review software does not tell me who the traffic in", "systematic purge? 2. If so, what is your system? 3.", "most appropriate) when they are about to take a large", "deal with new questions. I very much appreciate the work", "Edited to add the reasons for my concern: 1. As", "to deal with new questions. I very much appreciate the", "very much appreciate the work being put into curation: it's", "to consider a set of actions as a batch. I", "curation work occurs at too high a rate, it can", "difference between a batch of curation work by an established", "of actions as a batch. I thus cannot readily tell", "much appreciate the work being put into curation: it's an", "add the reasons for my concern: 1. As I am", "the queue is coming from. Also, the review queue presents", "from two years ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed a rapid sequence of", "curation: it's an extremely important function on this site, and", "from. Also, the review queue presents things one at a", "user who has gotten annoyed about something, or a mixture", "a huge amount of reward. My request is simply that", "are about to take a large number of closing or", "can carry out our own portion of the tasks more", "in chat, whichever seems most appropriate) when they are about", "the difference between a batch of curation work by an", "it can inhibit the ability of the community to deal", "makes it difficult to go back once you have finished", "have disagreed with since the questions have a number of", "two years ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed a rapid sequence of close", "of reviews that the software will allow me to make", "a time and makes it difficult to go back once", "announce it on meta or at least in chat. Would", "courteous to announce it on meta or at least in", "something, or a mixture of the two. 2. When there", "consider a set of actions as a batch. I thus", "meta or in chat, whichever seems most appropriate) when they", "many of which I have disagreed with since the questions", "that the software will allow me to make and cannot", "into curation: it's an extremely important function on this site,", "it difficult to go back once you have finished with", "what is your system? 3. It seems to me that", "meta or at least in chat. Would others agree? ---", "it would be courteous to announce it on meta or", "or meta or in chat, whichever seems most appropriate) when", "and cannot review any more items (this happened to me", "the work being put into curation: it's an extremely important", "am not a moderator, the review software does not tell", "such actions to ~10/day, so those of us reviewing can", "yesterday). Thus, if long-term curation work occurs at too high", "questions. I very much appreciate the work being put into", "to me yesterday). Thus, if long-term curation work occurs at", "least in chat. Would others agree? --- Edited to add", "of closing or flagging actions, and that they limit such", "put into curation: it's an extremely important function on this", "in chat. Would others agree? --- Edited to add the", "happened to me yesterday). Thus, if long-term curation work occurs", "large number of closing or flagging actions, and that they", "mixture of the two. 2. When there are a lot", "make and cannot review any more items (this happened to", "occurs at too high a rate, it can inhibit the", "2. If so, what is your system? 3. It seems", "out* of reviews that the software will allow me to", "function on this site, and one without a huge amount", "at too high a rate, it can inhibit the ability", "simply that people give a heads up (either or meta", "actions, and that they limit such actions to ~10/day, so", "or flagging actions, and that they limit such actions to", "one at a time and makes it difficult to go", "carry out our own portion of the tasks more effectively.", "more items (this happened to me yesterday). Thus, if long-term", "two. 2. When there are a lot of items coming", "limit such actions to ~10/day, so those of us reviewing", "on meta or at least in chat. Would others agree?", "of close votes over the past little while, many of", "that people give a heads up (either or meta or", "flagging actions, and that they limit such actions to ~10/day,", "so it is difficult to consider a set of actions", "number of up-votes and answers. My questions: 1. Is somebody", "chat, whichever seems most appropriate) when they are about to", "so, what is your system? 3. It seems to me", "review queue presents things one at a time and makes", "about something, or a mixture of the two. 2. When", "to add the reasons for my concern: 1. As I", "a number of up-votes and answers. My questions: 1. Is", "which I have disagreed with since the questions have a", "any more items (this happened to me yesterday). Thus, if", "thus cannot readily tell the difference between a batch of", "I run out of reviews that the software will allow", "seems to me that it would be courteous to announce", "a batch. I thus cannot readily tell the difference between", "the community to deal with new questions. I very much", "questions have a number of up-votes and answers. My questions:", "of the two. 2. When there are a lot of", "2. When there are a lot of items coming through", "actions to ~10/day, so those of us reviewing can carry", "items (this happened to me yesterday). Thus, if long-term curation", "people give a heads up (either or meta or in", "difficult to consider a set of actions as a batch.", "1. Is somebody doing a systematic purge? 2. If so,", "amount of reward. My request is simply that people give", "As I am not a moderator, the review software does", "reward. My request is simply that people give a heads", "established user, trolling by a rep 15 user who has", "with a review, so it is difficult to consider a", "of the community to deal with new questions. I very", "take a large number of closing or flagging actions, and", "annoyed about something, or a mixture of the two. 2.", "others agree? --- Edited to add the reasons for my", "little while, many of which I have disagreed with since", "me to make and cannot review any more items (this", "the past little while, many of which I have disagreed", "answers. My questions: 1. Is somebody doing a systematic purge?", "inhibit the ability of the community to deal with new", "a review, so it is difficult to consider a set", "a batch of curation work by an established user, trolling", "run out of reviews that the software will allow me", "things one at a time and makes it difficult to", "traffic in the queue is coming from. Also, the review", "rep 15 user who has gotten annoyed about something, or", "15 user who has gotten annoyed about something, or a", "of which I have disagreed with since the questions have", "gotten annoyed about something, or a mixture of the two.", "the questions have a number of up-votes and answers. My", "who the traffic in the queue is coming from. Also,", "it is difficult to consider a set of actions as", "allow me to make and cannot review any more items", "not a moderator, the review software does not tell me", "the review queue presents things one at a time and", "My request is simply that people give a heads up", "and makes it difficult to go back once you have", "of items coming through for review, I run out of", "a rate, it can inhibit the ability of the community", "seems most appropriate) when they are about to take a", "user, trolling by a rep 15 user who has gotten", "~10/day, so those of us reviewing can carry out our", "being put into curation: it's an extremely important function on", "has gotten annoyed about something, or a mixture of the", "agree? --- Edited to add the reasons for my concern:", "batch of curation work by an established user, trolling by", "between a batch of curation work by an established user,", "queue is coming from. Also, the review queue presents things", "(this happened to me yesterday). Thus, if long-term curation work", "Thus, if long-term curation work occurs at too high a", "appreciate the work being put into curation: it's an extremely", "software does not tell me who the traffic in the", "a rapid sequence of close votes over the past little", "will allow me to make and cannot review any more", "a systematic purge? 2. If so, what is your system?", "It seems to me that it would be courteous to", "of reward. My request is simply that people give a", "and that they limit such actions to ~10/day, so those", "are a lot of items coming through for review, I", "for my concern: 1. As I am not a moderator,", "Similar to [this question from two years ago](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/410/sudden-influx-of-close-votes-on-old-questions), I've noticed", "my concern: 1. As I am not a moderator, the", "it's an extremely important function on this site, and one", "an established user, trolling by a rep 15 user who", "community to deal with new questions. I very much appreciate", "coming from. Also, the review queue presents things one at", "past little while, many of which I have disagreed with", "go back once you have finished with a review, so", "it on meta or at least in chat. Would others", "rate, it can inhibit the ability of the community to", "a heads up (either or meta or in chat, whichever", "at a time and makes it difficult to go back", "have a number of up-votes and answers. My questions: 1.", "the two. 2. When there are a lot of items", "--- Edited to add the reasons for my concern: 1.", "closing or flagging actions, and that they limit such actions" ]
[ "because it is about the content of an academic discipline", "> > > It thus seems to be useful to", "reasons, I find myself typing the following sentence on a", "> > It thus seems to be useful to me", "appears to be off-topic because it is about the content", "have a predefined close reason for such cases which then", "> This question appears to be off-topic because it is", "sentence on a daily basis (and before, I flagged questions", "be off-topic because it is about the content of an", "> > This question appears to be off-topic because it", "can also be used to give the askers some help", "to be useful to me to have a predefined close", "about the content of an academic discipline and not about", "obtained closing priviledges and can thus use custom close reasons,", "I find myself typing the following sentence on a daily", "be used to give the askers some help at hand", "a predefined close reason for such cases which then can", "not about academia itself. > > > It thus seems", "for such cases which then can also be used to", "close reasons, I find myself typing the following sentence on", "to have a predefined close reason for such cases which", "an academic discipline and not about academia itself. > >", "would have applied regularly): > > This question appears to", "at hand where to ask their question (if at all).", "to give the askers some help at hand where to", "> It thus seems to be useful to me to", "this would have applied regularly): > > This question appears", "flagged questions to which this would have applied regularly): >", "I obtained closing priviledges and can thus use custom close", "me to have a predefined close reason for such cases", "before, I flagged questions to which this would have applied", "off-topic because it is about the content of an academic", "and not about academia itself. > > > It thus", "This question appears to be off-topic because it is about", "predefined close reason for such cases which then can also", "about academia itself. > > > It thus seems to", "such cases which then can also be used to give", "basis (and before, I flagged questions to which this would", "on a daily basis (and before, I flagged questions to", "the following sentence on a daily basis (and before, I", "reason for such cases which then can also be used", "seems to be useful to me to have a predefined", "custom close reasons, I find myself typing the following sentence", "question appears to be off-topic because it is about the", "myself typing the following sentence on a daily basis (and", "discipline and not about academia itself. > > > It", "typing the following sentence on a daily basis (and before,", "thus use custom close reasons, I find myself typing the", "the askers some help at hand where to ask their", "find myself typing the following sentence on a daily basis", "is about the content of an academic discipline and not", "and can thus use custom close reasons, I find myself", "academia itself. > > > It thus seems to be", "a daily basis (and before, I flagged questions to which", "(and before, I flagged questions to which this would have", "cases which then can also be used to give the", "used to give the askers some help at hand where", "have applied regularly): > > This question appears to be", "priviledges and can thus use custom close reasons, I find", "regularly): > > This question appears to be off-topic because", "askers some help at hand where to ask their question", "thus seems to be useful to me to have a", "help at hand where to ask their question (if at", "close reason for such cases which then can also be", "the content of an academic discipline and not about academia", "also be used to give the askers some help at", "can thus use custom close reasons, I find myself typing", "It thus seems to be useful to me to have", "itself. > > > It thus seems to be useful", "use custom close reasons, I find myself typing the following", "questions to which this would have applied regularly): > >", "to be off-topic because it is about the content of", "it is about the content of an academic discipline and", "I flagged questions to which this would have applied regularly):", "of an academic discipline and not about academia itself. >", "to me to have a predefined close reason for such", "which this would have applied regularly): > > This question", "daily basis (and before, I flagged questions to which this", "closing priviledges and can thus use custom close reasons, I", "which then can also be used to give the askers", "be useful to me to have a predefined close reason", "Since I obtained closing priviledges and can thus use custom", "to which this would have applied regularly): > > This", "content of an academic discipline and not about academia itself.", "give the askers some help at hand where to ask", "some help at hand where to ask their question (if", "following sentence on a daily basis (and before, I flagged", "academic discipline and not about academia itself. > > >", "applied regularly): > > This question appears to be off-topic", "then can also be used to give the askers some", "useful to me to have a predefined close reason for" ]
[ "the tag wiki excerpt, which reflected the actual use of", "inference from data.\" For example, [Should I cite all R", "differently-named tags to address these different use cases. The tag", "a degree in this field.\" For example, [Should I do", "paper submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe the best way to", "Tags are meant to collect questions on a single subject,", "\"show questions tagged 'statistics'\") tag is one of the worst", "data.\" For example, [Should I cite all R packages I", "for statistics about research or academia. For example, [Can you", "names should clearly indicate which usage the tag is referring", "the tag wiki excerpt (they're not easy to get to", "tag names should clearly indicate which usage the tag is", "different kinds of questions is a bad tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics", "the worst offenders. I've seen people apply it to: ", "subject, so a tag that applies to several completely different", "used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is the use currently specified by the tag", "discipline, and programs leading to a degree in this field.\"", "leading to a degree in this field.\" For example, [Should", "time that I last edited it, but doesn't seem to", "and programs leading to a degree in this field.\" For", "cite all R packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is the use", "excerpt, which reflected the actual use of the tag at", "asking for statistics about research or academia. For example, [Can", "and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe the best way to disambiguate is", "mobile site, for example). Any suggestions? (I believe tags are", "which usage the tag is referring to, since people don't", "Questions asking for statistics about research or academia. For example,", "is a bad tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions tagged 'statistics'\")", "all R packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is the use currently", "I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is the use currently specified by the", "doesn't seem to now. Questions asking for statistics about", "\"the use of statistics in academic research. Statistics is the", "research. Statistics is the science of collecting, analyzing and drawing", "statistics about research or academia. For example, [Can you get", "so a tag that applies to several completely different kinds", "for a career in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions on \"the", "drawing inference from data.\" For example, [Should I cite all", "disambiguate is to have differently-named tags to address these different", "publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe the best way to disambiguate is to", "of collecting, analyzing and drawing inference from data.\" For example,", "about research or academia. For example, [Can you get statistical", "(I believe tags are limited to 24 characters on this", "use of the tag at the time that I last", "as an academic discipline, and programs leading to a degree", "example). Any suggestions? (I believe tags are limited to 24", "For example, [Should I do a PhD or Master in", "statistics in academic research. Statistics is the science of collecting,", "but doesn't seem to now. * Questions asking for statistics", "specific to statistics as an academic discipline, and programs leading", "actual use of the tag at the time that I", "example, [Should I do a PhD or Master in Statistics", "way to disambiguate is to have differently-named tags to address", "Statistics for a career in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions on", "or academia. For example, [Can you get statistical data on", "should clearly indicate which usage the tag is referring to,", "of questions is a bad tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions", "I cite all R packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is the", "[Should I do a PhD or Master in Statistics for", "cases. The tag names should clearly indicate which usage the", "the best way to disambiguate is to have differently-named tags", "while posting a question on mobile site, for example). Any", "Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions on \"the use of statistics in academic", "academic research. Statistics is the science of collecting, analyzing and", "by the tag wiki excerpt, which reflected the actual use", "that I last edited it, but doesn't seem to now.", "a tag that applies to several completely different kinds of", "indicate which usage the tag is referring to, since people", "statistics as an academic discipline, and programs leading to a", "tag wiki excerpt (they're not easy to get to while", "meant to collect questions on a single subject, so a", "a career in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions on \"the use", "I've seen people apply it to: * Questions on \"standards", "analyzing and drawing inference from data.\" For example, [Should I", "excerpt (they're not easy to get to while posting a", "is to have differently-named tags to address these different use", "on a single subject, so a tag that applies to", "people don't always read the tag wiki excerpt (they're not", "edited it, but doesn't seem to now. * Questions asking", "a PhD or Master in Statistics for a career in", "and conventions specific to statistics as an academic discipline, and", "to now. * Questions asking for statistics about research or", "I believe the best way to disambiguate is to have", "to disambiguate is to have differently-named tags to address these", "read the tag wiki excerpt (they're not easy to get", "tag is one of the worst offenders. I've seen people", "(they're not easy to get to while posting a question", "is the science of collecting, analyzing and drawing inference from", "on research paper submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe the best", "the tag at the time that I last edited it,", "[Can you get statistical data on research paper submissions and", "believe the best way to disambiguate is to have differently-named", "on mobile site, for example). Any suggestions? (I believe tags", "Questions on \"standards and conventions specific to statistics as an", "the time that I last edited it, but doesn't seem", "offenders. I've seen people apply it to: * Questions on", "of the worst offenders. I've seen people apply it to:", "and drawing inference from data.\" For example, [Should I cite", "Questions on \"the use of statistics in academic research. Statistics", "questions tagged 'statistics'\") tag is one of the worst offenders.", "questions on a single subject, so a tag that applies", "believe tags are limited to 24 characters on this site.)", "research or academia. For example, [Can you get statistical data", "is the use currently specified by the tag wiki excerpt,", "tagged 'statistics'\") tag is one of the worst offenders. I've", "tag that applies to several completely different kinds of questions", "Master in Statistics for a career in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) ", "to address these different use cases. The tag names should", "from data.\" For example, [Should I cite all R packages", "tag is referring to, since people don't always read the", "on \"standards and conventions specific to statistics as an academic", "example, [Should I cite all R packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This", " Questions on \"standards and conventions specific to statistics as", "get to while posting a question on mobile site, for", "science of collecting, analyzing and drawing inference from data.\" For", "Statistics is the science of collecting, analyzing and drawing inference", "to a degree in this field.\" For example, [Should I", "conventions specific to statistics as an academic discipline, and programs", "The tag names should clearly indicate which usage the tag", "in academic research. Statistics is the science of collecting, analyzing", "is referring to, since people don't always read the tag", "R packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is the use currently specified", "several completely different kinds of questions is a bad tag.", "\"standards and conventions specific to statistics as an academic discipline,", "submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe the best way to disambiguate", "to get to while posting a question on mobile site,", "to while posting a question on mobile site, for example).", "data on research paper submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe the", "to statistics as an academic discipline, and programs leading to", "currently specified by the tag wiki excerpt, which reflected the", "referring to, since people don't always read the tag wiki", "field.\" For example, [Should I do a PhD or Master", "it to: * Questions on \"standards and conventions specific to", "question on mobile site, for example). Any suggestions? (I believe", "an academic discipline, and programs leading to a degree in", "packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is the use currently specified by", "site, for example). Any suggestions? (I believe tags are limited", "For example, [Can you get statistical data on research paper", "not easy to get to while posting a question on", "career in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions on \"the use of", "completely different kinds of questions is a bad tag. The", "it, but doesn't seem to now. * Questions asking for", "wiki excerpt (they're not easy to get to while posting", "PhD or Master in Statistics for a career in Data", "the actual use of the tag at the time that", "worst offenders. I've seen people apply it to: * Questions", "'statistics'\") tag is one of the worst offenders. I've seen", "programs leading to a degree in this field.\" For example,", "The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions tagged 'statistics'\") tag is one of", "of statistics in academic research. Statistics is the science of", "different use cases. The tag names should clearly indicate which", "usage the tag is referring to, since people don't always", "tag at the time that I last edited it, but", "always read the tag wiki excerpt (they're not easy to", "tags to address these different use cases. The tag names", "a question on mobile site, for example). Any suggestions? (I", "one of the worst offenders. I've seen people apply it", "this field.\" For example, [Should I do a PhD or", "is one of the worst offenders. I've seen people apply", "use of statistics in academic research. Statistics is the science", "wiki excerpt, which reflected the actual use of the tag", "tag wiki excerpt, which reflected the actual use of the", "best way to disambiguate is to have differently-named tags to", "to, since people don't always read the tag wiki excerpt", "suggestions? (I believe tags are limited to 24 characters on", "these different use cases. The tag names should clearly indicate", "to collect questions on a single subject, so a tag", "don't always read the tag wiki excerpt (they're not easy", "in this field.\" For example, [Should I do a PhD", "in Statistics for a career in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions", "reflected the actual use of the tag at the time", "you get statistical data on research paper submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications)", "[Should I cite all R packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used) This is", "to have differently-named tags to address these different use cases.", "have differently-named tags to address these different use cases. The", "academia. For example, [Can you get statistical data on research", "to: * Questions on \"standards and conventions specific to statistics", "specified by the tag wiki excerpt, which reflected the actual", "to several completely different kinds of questions is a bad", "seen people apply it to: * Questions on \"standards and", "on \"the use of statistics in academic research. Statistics is", "questions is a bad tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions tagged", "are meant to collect questions on a single subject, so", "use cases. The tag names should clearly indicate which usage", "single subject, so a tag that applies to several completely", "do a PhD or Master in Statistics for a career", "I last edited it, but doesn't seem to now. ", " Questions asking for statistics about research or academia. For", "address these different use cases. The tag names should clearly", "collecting, analyzing and drawing inference from data.\" For example, [Should", "now. * Questions asking for statistics about research or academia.", "Any suggestions? (I believe tags are limited to 24 characters", "[statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions tagged 'statistics'\") tag is one of the", "the tag is referring to, since people don't always read", "kinds of questions is a bad tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show", "example, [Can you get statistical data on research paper submissions", "* Questions on \"the use of statistics in academic research.", "at the time that I last edited it, but doesn't", "a single subject, so a tag that applies to several", "statistical data on research paper submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe", "seem to now. * Questions asking for statistics about research", "Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions on \"the use of statistics in", "apply it to: * Questions on \"standards and conventions specific", "a bad tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions tagged 'statistics'\") tag", "tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions tagged 'statistics'\") tag is one", "For example, [Should I cite all R packages I used?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27921/should-i-cite-all-r-packages-i-used)", "clearly indicate which usage the tag is referring to, since", "easy to get to while posting a question on mobile", "for example). Any suggestions? (I believe tags are limited to", "which reflected the actual use of the tag at the", "collect questions on a single subject, so a tag that", "get statistical data on research paper submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I", "of the tag at the time that I last edited", "people apply it to: * Questions on \"standards and conventions", "since people don't always read the tag wiki excerpt (they're", "degree in this field.\" For example, [Should I do a", "last edited it, but doesn't seem to now. * Questions", "posting a question on mobile site, for example). Any suggestions?", "that applies to several completely different kinds of questions is", "I do a PhD or Master in Statistics for a", "the science of collecting, analyzing and drawing inference from data.\"", "bad tag. The [statistics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/statistics \"show questions tagged 'statistics'\") tag is", "or Master in Statistics for a career in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science)", "academic discipline, and programs leading to a degree in this", "in Data Science?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34508/should-i-do-a-phd-or-master-in-statistics-for-a-career-in-data-science) * Questions on \"the use of statistics", "the use currently specified by the tag wiki excerpt, which", "applies to several completely different kinds of questions is a", "research paper submissions and publications?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/30898/can-you-get-statistical-data-on-research-paper-submissions-and-publications) I believe the best way", "This is the use currently specified by the tag wiki", "use currently specified by the tag wiki excerpt, which reflected" ]
[ "answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the meta question I ask: > > Your", "how I think about scope on this site, though, and", "tend to feel that if something is borderline but we", "of content interacting with this idea. I'm pretty liberal about", "this is the official answer? If yes, should my question", "about classes of content interacting with this idea. I'm pretty", "that if something is borderline but we can answer it", "asked about classes of content interacting with this idea. I'm", "stated in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the meta question I ask:", "can answer it well, that it is better to include", "is the official answer? If yes, should my question be", "help in theoretical biology, besides math and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As", "was then a bit borderline because it asked about classes", "to include than to close. > > > Since there", "a bit borderline because it asked about classes of content", "because it asked about classes of content interacting with this", "it well, that it is better to include than to", "to feel that if something is borderline but we can", "think about scope on this site, though, and so tend", "then a bit borderline because it asked about classes of", "physicists help in theoretical biology, besides math and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti)", "is my original question: [How can physicists help in theoretical", "is better to include than to close. > > >", "we can answer it well, that it is better to", "math and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in", "that it is better to include than to close. >", "Your question was then a bit borderline because it asked", "on this site, though, and so tend to feel that", "conclude that this is the official answer? If yes, should", "in theoretical biology, besides math and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated", "> > Since there is no other answer, is it", "something is borderline but we can answer it well, that", "is borderline but we can answer it well, that it", "question was then a bit borderline because it asked about", "is no other answer, is it safely to conclude that", "> > Your question was then a bit borderline because", "but we can answer it well, that it is better", "borderline because it asked about classes of content interacting with", "interacting with this idea. I'm pretty liberal about how I", "besides math and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493)", "ask: > > Your question was then a bit borderline", "feel that if something is borderline but we can answer", "and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the", "idea. I'm pretty liberal about how I think about scope", "Since there is no other answer, is it safely to", "than to close. > > > Since there is no", "classes of content interacting with this idea. I'm pretty liberal", "question: [How can physicists help in theoretical biology, besides math", "theoretical biology, besides math and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated in", "close. > > > Since there is no other answer,", "answer it well, that it is better to include than", "Here is my original question: [How can physicists help in", "it is better to include than to close. > >", "> Since there is no other answer, is it safely", "meta question I ask: > > Your question was then", "with this idea. I'm pretty liberal about how I think", "there is no other answer, is it safely to conclude", "in the meta question I ask: > > Your question", "my original question: [How can physicists help in theoretical biology,", "in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the meta question I ask: >", "other answer, is it safely to conclude that this is", "[How can physicists help in theoretical biology, besides math and", "better to include than to close. > > > Since", "fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the meta", "I ask: > > Your question was then a bit", "content interacting with this idea. I'm pretty liberal about how", "if something is borderline but we can answer it well,", "question I ask: > > Your question was then a", "it safely to conclude that this is the official answer?", "I'm pretty liberal about how I think about scope on", "though, and so tend to feel that if something is", "to close. > > > Since there is no other", "so tend to feel that if something is borderline but", "the official answer? If yes, should my question be reopened?", "liberal about how I think about scope on this site,", "answer, is it safely to conclude that this is the", "this site, though, and so tend to feel that if", "[jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the meta question I ask: > >", "site, though, and so tend to feel that if something", "this idea. I'm pretty liberal about how I think about", "well, that it is better to include than to close.", "it asked about classes of content interacting with this idea.", "about how I think about scope on this site, though,", "> Your question was then a bit borderline because it", "bit borderline because it asked about classes of content interacting", "the meta question I ask: > > Your question was", "safely to conclude that this is the official answer? If", "pretty liberal about how I think about scope on this", "As stated in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the meta question I", "I think about scope on this site, though, and so", "include than to close. > > > Since there is", "no other answer, is it safely to conclude that this", "scope on this site, though, and so tend to feel", "perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated in [jakebeal's answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1486/where-is-the-line-between-a-question-about-doing-research-and-a-question-abou/1493#1493) in the meta question", "biology, besides math and fresh perspectives?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34941/how-can-physicists-help-in-theoretical-biology-besides-math-and-fresh-perspecti) As stated in [jakebeal's", "can physicists help in theoretical biology, besides math and fresh", "borderline but we can answer it well, that it is", "> > > Since there is no other answer, is", "to conclude that this is the official answer? If yes,", "that this is the official answer? If yes, should my", "original question: [How can physicists help in theoretical biology, besides", "about scope on this site, though, and so tend to", "is it safely to conclude that this is the official", "and so tend to feel that if something is borderline" ]
[ "duplicate but I found it by searching and the title", "a duplicate but I found it by searching and the", "actually about \"Can I reference other things in my abstract?\".", "and the title confused me. It's actually about \"Can I", "found it by searching and the title confused me. It's", "of the tile but the question is a duplicate. Should", "but I found it by searching and the title confused", "the question is a duplicate. Should I suggest edits to", "by searching and the title confused me. It's actually about", "suggest an edit of the tile but the question is", "title confused me. It's actually about \"Can I reference other", "in my abstract?\". I wanted to suggest an edit of", "things in my abstract?\". I wanted to suggest an edit", "it by searching and the title confused me. It's actually", "wanted to suggest an edit of the tile but the", "\"Can I reference other things in my abstract?\". I wanted", "[Can I reference the abstract?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/27179/17966) is a duplicate but I", "about \"Can I reference other things in my abstract?\". I", "I reference other things in my abstract?\". I wanted to", "but the question is a duplicate. Should I suggest edits", "This question [Can I reference the abstract?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/27179/17966) is a duplicate", "question [Can I reference the abstract?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/27179/17966) is a duplicate but", "the abstract?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/27179/17966) is a duplicate but I found it by", "is a duplicate but I found it by searching and", "abstract?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/27179/17966) is a duplicate but I found it by searching", "confused me. It's actually about \"Can I reference other things", "a duplicate. Should I suggest edits to duplicate and/or closed", "other things in my abstract?\". I wanted to suggest an", "reference the abstract?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/27179/17966) is a duplicate but I found it", "edit of the tile but the question is a duplicate.", "It's actually about \"Can I reference other things in my", "question is a duplicate. Should I suggest edits to duplicate", "I wanted to suggest an edit of the tile but", "I found it by searching and the title confused me.", "abstract?\". I wanted to suggest an edit of the tile", "duplicate. Should I suggest edits to duplicate and/or closed questions?", "searching and the title confused me. It's actually about \"Can", "the title confused me. It's actually about \"Can I reference", "me. It's actually about \"Can I reference other things in", "I reference the abstract?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/27179/17966) is a duplicate but I found", "an edit of the tile but the question is a", "the tile but the question is a duplicate. Should I", "my abstract?\". I wanted to suggest an edit of the", "to suggest an edit of the tile but the question", "reference other things in my abstract?\". I wanted to suggest", "tile but the question is a duplicate. Should I suggest", "is a duplicate. Should I suggest edits to duplicate and/or" ]
[ "Looks Ok (which it doesn't), click the tiny Link button", "to be doing is downvote the answer. Look specifically at", "bad. I don't want to edit it and none of", "for up- and downvoting here on the level of Edit", "on the right, and downvote outside of the review queue.", "What I need to do is press Looks Ok (which", "I need to do is press Looks Ok (which it", "queue. I would like to see buttons for up- and", "Ok (which it doesn't), click the tiny Link button on", "right, and downvote outside of the review queue. This is", "the poster) just bad. I don't want to edit it", "The post is (sorry to the poster) just bad. I", "actually lets me do that. What I need to do", "no button that actually lets me do that. What I", "press Looks Ok (which it doesn't), click the tiny Link", "it doesn't), click the tiny Link button on the right,", "post is (sorry to the poster) just bad. I don't", "lets me do that. What I need to do is", "and none of the Delete reasons applies. However, I definitely", "entries in this queue. I would like to see buttons", "In the \"low quality\" review queue: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png)", "of the time what I really want to be doing", "for me for 2 out of 3 entries in this", "it. There is no button that actually lets me do", "the case for me for 2 out of 3 entries", "poster) just bad. I don't want to edit it and", "\"low quality\" review queue: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of", "of the Delete reasons applies. However, I definitely want to", "the answer. Look specifically at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post is", "just bad. I don't want to edit it and none", "don't want to edit it and none of the Delete", "up- and downvoting here on the level of Edit and", "quality\" review queue: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of the", "is the case for me for 2 out of 3", "specifically at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post is (sorry to the", "in this queue. I would like to see buttons for", "and downvoting here on the level of Edit and Delete.", "3 entries in this queue. I would like to see", "that. What I need to do is press Looks Ok", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of the time what I really want to", "want to downvote it. There is no button that actually", "do that. What I need to do is press Looks", "see buttons for up- and downvoting here on the level", "none of the Delete reasons applies. However, I definitely want", "the time what I really want to be doing is", "time what I really want to be doing is downvote", "click the tiny Link button on the right, and downvote", "(which it doesn't), click the tiny Link button on the", "at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post is (sorry to the poster)", "Link button on the right, and downvote outside of the", "button that actually lets me do that. What I need", "like to see buttons for up- and downvoting here on", "would like to see buttons for up- and downvoting here", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of the time what I really want", "[this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post is (sorry to the poster) just", "need to do is press Looks Ok (which it doesn't),", "the right, and downvote outside of the review queue. This", "to the poster) just bad. I don't want to edit", "definitely want to downvote it. There is no button that", "is no button that actually lets me do that. What", "(sorry to the poster) just bad. I don't want to", "to edit it and none of the Delete reasons applies.", "and downvote outside of the review queue. This is the", "that actually lets me do that. What I need to", "outside of the review queue. This is the case for", "is downvote the answer. Look specifically at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The", "me for 2 out of 3 entries in this queue.", "want to be doing is downvote the answer. Look specifically", "applies. However, I definitely want to downvote it. There is", "reasons applies. However, I definitely want to downvote it. There", "to downvote it. There is no button that actually lets", "tiny Link button on the right, and downvote outside of", "button on the right, and downvote outside of the review", "There is no button that actually lets me do that.", "is press Looks Ok (which it doesn't), click the tiny", "I definitely want to downvote it. There is no button", "case for me for 2 out of 3 entries in", "I would like to see buttons for up- and downvoting", "review queue. This is the case for me for 2", "example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post is (sorry to the poster) just bad.", "what I really want to be doing is downvote the", "However, I definitely want to downvote it. There is no", "this queue. I would like to see buttons for up-", "queue: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of the time what", "for 2 out of 3 entries in this queue. I", "downvote outside of the review queue. This is the case", "downvote it. There is no button that actually lets me", "review queue: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of the time", "I really want to be doing is downvote the answer.", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of the time what I", "queue. This is the case for me for 2 out", "Delete reasons applies. However, I definitely want to downvote it.", "This is the case for me for 2 out of", "edit it and none of the Delete reasons applies. However,", "buttons for up- and downvoting here on the level of", "doesn't), click the tiny Link button on the right, and", "it and none of the Delete reasons applies. However, I", "the review queue. This is the case for me for", "do is press Looks Ok (which it doesn't), click the", "of the review queue. This is the case for me", "of 3 entries in this queue. I would like to", "the tiny Link button on the right, and downvote outside", "be doing is downvote the answer. Look specifically at [this", "answer. Look specifically at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post is (sorry", "Look specifically at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post is (sorry to", "want to edit it and none of the Delete reasons", "the \"low quality\" review queue: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most", "Most of the time what I really want to be", "me do that. What I need to do is press", "really want to be doing is downvote the answer. Look", "the Delete reasons applies. However, I definitely want to downvote", "to see buttons for up- and downvoting here on the", "to do is press Looks Ok (which it doesn't), click", "I don't want to edit it and none of the", "2 out of 3 entries in this queue. I would", "downvote the answer. Look specifically at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200). The post", "is (sorry to the poster) just bad. I don't want", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/d4rkw.png) Most of the time what I really", "out of 3 entries in this queue. I would like", "doing is downvote the answer. Look specifically at [this example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/27936/is-it-normal-for-an-advisor-to-expect-80-hour-workweeks-from-phd-students-and/35200#35200)." ]
[ "coauthor because coauthorships are supposed to reflect the contribution you", "something along the lines of \"of course you should let", "no position to take the moral high ground here.\" Why", "made to the project > > > Now I think", "be a coauthor on my paper when he didn't do", "to reflect the contribution you made to the project >", "the project > > > Now I think if I", "would be academic fraud > > > or > >", "you are in no position to take the moral high", "a coauthor on my paper when he didn't do any", "my letter of reference myself? > > > The answers", "suicide, and you are in no position to take the", "the OP to be ethical, and say stuff like >", "contributions to the project? > > > Or > >", "academics in real life, their answers would be something along", "> > or > > You shouldn't let your colleague", "fraud > > > or > > You shouldn't let", "along the lines of \"of course you should let him", "do if someone asks me to write my letter of", "you should let him coauthor your paper/write your letter of", "high ground here.\" Why is the prevailing opinion on academia.SE", "the contribution you made to the project > > >", "> You shouldn't write your own letter because that would", "ethical, and say stuff like > > You shouldn't write", "would be something along the lines of \"of course you", "are in no position to take the moral high ground", "I think if I asked these questions to academics in", "because doing otherwise would be career suicide, and you are", "in real life, their answers would be something along the", "opinion on academia.SE so different (and is this a problem)?", "let him coauthor your paper/write your letter of reference yourself,", "take the moral high ground here.\" Why is the prevailing", "paper when he didn't do any work/made only negative contributions", "answers usually encourage the OP to be ethical, and say", "own letter because that would be academic fraud > >", "lines of \"of course you should let him coauthor your", "shouldn't let your colleague be a coauthor because coauthorships are", "let your colleague be a coauthor because coauthorships are supposed", "contribution you made to the project > > > Now", "life, their answers would be something along the lines of", "reference yourself, because doing otherwise would be career suicide, and", "the prevailing opinion on academia.SE so different (and is this", "if someone asks me to write my letter of reference", "student/professor/etc be a coauthor on my paper when he didn't", "be career suicide, and you are in no position to", "I asked these questions to academics in real life, their", "if I asked these questions to academics in real life,", "> What should I do if someone asks me to", "> > The answers usually encourage the OP to be", "to write my letter of reference myself? > > >", "site, I see a lot of questions like > >", "of reference yourself, because doing otherwise would be career suicide,", "prevailing opinion on academia.SE so different (and is this a", "be something along the lines of \"of course you should", "usually encourage the OP to be ethical, and say stuff", "reference myself? > > > The answers usually encourage the", "your paper/write your letter of reference yourself, because doing otherwise", "I do if someone asks me to write my letter", "questions to academics in real life, their answers would be", "like > > You shouldn't write your own letter because", "When browsing this site, I see a lot of questions", "encourage the OP to be ethical, and say stuff like", "to be ethical, and say stuff like > > You", "course you should let him coauthor your paper/write your letter", "should let him coauthor your paper/write your letter of reference", "do any work/made only negative contributions to the project? >", "OP to be ethical, and say stuff like > >", "the lines of \"of course you should let him coauthor", "any work/made only negative contributions to the project? > >", "these questions to academics in real life, their answers would", "Why is the prevailing opinion on academia.SE so different (and", "you made to the project > > > Now I", "or > > You shouldn't let your colleague be a", "You shouldn't write your own letter because that would be", "> > Should I let a senior student/professor/etc be a", "lot of questions like > > Should I let a", "reflect the contribution you made to the project > >", "the moral high ground here.\" Why is the prevailing opinion", "on my paper when he didn't do any work/made only", "be a coauthor because coauthorships are supposed to reflect the", "coauthor on my paper when he didn't do any work/made", "negative contributions to the project? > > > Or >", "ground here.\" Why is the prevailing opinion on academia.SE so", "otherwise would be career suicide, and you are in no", "coauthor your paper/write your letter of reference yourself, because doing", "> > You shouldn't let your colleague be a coauthor", "that would be academic fraud > > > or >", "this site, I see a lot of questions like >", "I see a lot of questions like > > Should", "letter because that would be academic fraud > > >", "answers would be something along the lines of \"of course", "and you are in no position to take the moral", "asks me to write my letter of reference myself? >", "because coauthorships are supposed to reflect the contribution you made", "to academics in real life, their answers would be something", "to take the moral high ground here.\" Why is the", "> or > > You shouldn't let your colleague be", "write my letter of reference myself? > > > The", "like > > Should I let a senior student/professor/etc be", "> You shouldn't let your colleague be a coauthor because", "would be career suicide, and you are in no position", "> > What should I do if someone asks me", "> The answers usually encourage the OP to be ethical,", "asked these questions to academics in real life, their answers", "questions like > > Should I let a senior student/professor/etc", "What should I do if someone asks me to write", "I let a senior student/professor/etc be a coauthor on my", "your own letter because that would be academic fraud >", "> > Now I think if I asked these questions", "senior student/professor/etc be a coauthor on my paper when he", "> Should I let a senior student/professor/etc be a coauthor", "letter of reference yourself, because doing otherwise would be career", "The answers usually encourage the OP to be ethical, and", "project > > > Now I think if I asked", "yourself, because doing otherwise would be career suicide, and you", "You shouldn't let your colleague be a coauthor because coauthorships", "let a senior student/professor/etc be a coauthor on my paper", "because that would be academic fraud > > > or", "> > > Now I think if I asked these", "position to take the moral high ground here.\" Why is", "career suicide, and you are in no position to take", "my paper when he didn't do any work/made only negative", "Now I think if I asked these questions to academics", "stuff like > > You shouldn't write your own letter", "browsing this site, I see a lot of questions like", "think if I asked these questions to academics in real", "when he didn't do any work/made only negative contributions to", "their answers would be something along the lines of \"of", "of reference myself? > > > The answers usually encourage", "Should I let a senior student/professor/etc be a coauthor on", "in no position to take the moral high ground here.\"", "a lot of questions like > > Should I let", "of questions like > > Should I let a senior", "> > > The answers usually encourage the OP to", "\"of course you should let him coauthor your paper/write your", "is the prevailing opinion on academia.SE so different (and is", "project? > > > Or > > What should I", "coauthorships are supposed to reflect the contribution you made to", "me to write my letter of reference myself? > >", "work/made only negative contributions to the project? > > >", "the project? > > > Or > > What should", "paper/write your letter of reference yourself, because doing otherwise would", "of \"of course you should let him coauthor your paper/write", "someone asks me to write my letter of reference myself?", "> > > Or > > What should I do", "real life, their answers would be something along the lines", "> > Or > > What should I do if", "are supposed to reflect the contribution you made to the", "doing otherwise would be career suicide, and you are in", "to the project? > > > Or > > What", "moral high ground here.\" Why is the prevailing opinion on", "say stuff like > > You shouldn't write your own", "your letter of reference yourself, because doing otherwise would be", "him coauthor your paper/write your letter of reference yourself, because", "colleague be a coauthor because coauthorships are supposed to reflect", "supposed to reflect the contribution you made to the project", "didn't do any work/made only negative contributions to the project?", "see a lot of questions like > > Should I", "academic fraud > > > or > > You shouldn't", "to the project > > > Now I think if", "be ethical, and say stuff like > > You shouldn't", "be academic fraud > > > or > > You", "> Or > > What should I do if someone", "letter of reference myself? > > > The answers usually", "> > > or > > You shouldn't let your", "> Now I think if I asked these questions to", "> > You shouldn't write your own letter because that", "Or > > What should I do if someone asks", "a coauthor because coauthorships are supposed to reflect the contribution", "your colleague be a coauthor because coauthorships are supposed to", "shouldn't write your own letter because that would be academic", "only negative contributions to the project? > > > Or", "here.\" Why is the prevailing opinion on academia.SE so different", "should I do if someone asks me to write my", "myself? > > > The answers usually encourage the OP", "write your own letter because that would be academic fraud", "and say stuff like > > You shouldn't write your", "a senior student/professor/etc be a coauthor on my paper when", "he didn't do any work/made only negative contributions to the" ]
[ "hold. I think putting it on hold was a good", "list of just how much difference and confusion can occur", "the normal question model. I do think, though, that it", "normal question model. I do think, though, that it could", "difference and confusion can occur from seemingly precise terminology. Would", "on hold. I think putting it on hold was a", "good community wiki question, curating an informative list of just", "was put on hold. I think putting it on hold", "question, curating an informative list of just how much difference", "a good community wiki question, curating an informative list of", "got some really interesting answers before it was put on", "question about confusion in science from language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some", "put on hold. I think putting it on hold was", "I think putting it on hold was a good thing,", "and confusion can occur from seemingly precise terminology. Would others", "be a good community wiki question, curating an informative list", "informative list of just how much difference and confusion can", "confusion in science from language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some really interesting", "on hold was a good thing, as it doesn't fit", "question model. I do think, though, that it could be", "model. I do think, though, that it could be a", "that it could be a good community wiki question, curating", "just how much difference and confusion can occur from seemingly", "really interesting answers before it was put on hold. I", "in science from language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some really interesting answers", "science from language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some really interesting answers before", "before it was put on hold. I think putting it", "it on hold was a good thing, as it doesn't", "about confusion in science from language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some really", "do think, though, that it could be a good community", "was a good thing, as it doesn't fit the normal", "good thing, as it doesn't fit the normal question model.", "how much difference and confusion can occur from seemingly precise", "doesn't fit the normal question model. I do think, though,", "as it doesn't fit the normal question model. I do", "thing, as it doesn't fit the normal question model. I", "curating an informative list of just how much difference and", "answers before it was put on hold. I think putting", "much difference and confusion can occur from seemingly precise terminology.", "language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some really interesting answers before it was", "think putting it on hold was a good thing, as", "hold was a good thing, as it doesn't fit the", "I do think, though, that it could be a good", "it could be a good community wiki question, curating an", "some really interesting answers before it was put on hold.", "fit the normal question model. I do think, though, that", "think, though, that it could be a good community wiki", "[This question about confusion in science from language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got", "it doesn't fit the normal question model. I do think,", "though, that it could be a good community wiki question,", "confusion can occur from seemingly precise terminology. Would others agree?", "could be a good community wiki question, curating an informative", "it was put on hold. I think putting it on", "putting it on hold was a good thing, as it", "interesting answers before it was put on hold. I think", "from language differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some really interesting answers before it", "a good thing, as it doesn't fit the normal question", "wiki question, curating an informative list of just how much", "an informative list of just how much difference and confusion", "differences](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/36887/possible-causes-of-confusion-and-mistakes-in-technical-terminology-in-bilingual) got some really interesting answers before it was put", "community wiki question, curating an informative list of just how", "of just how much difference and confusion can occur from" ]
[ "(This post is shamelessly stolen from [Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes,", "questions benefit from the same kinds of answers, and responses", "also very welcome. --- (This post is shamelessly stolen from", "this site look for and appreciate in an answer. ", "good answer? (Examples of exceptionally good answers, and what makes", "to consider include but are not limited to: length, content,", "without specific relevant experience, bias, etc. Of course, not all", "very welcome. --- (This post is shamelessly stolen from [Biblical", "Of course, not all questions benefit from the same kinds", "benefit from the same kinds of answers, and responses addressing", "answer-er or not, citing outside sources, addressing question in general", "welcome. --- (This post is shamelessly stolen from [Biblical Hermeneutics", "a thing even exists...) Possible aspects to consider include but", "disclosing background of answer-er or not, citing outside sources, addressing", "site look for and appreciate in an answer. On", "what are the characteristics of a good answer? (Examples of", "tone, disclosing background of answer-er or not, citing outside sources,", "* What are the characteristics of a bad answer on", "Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I read other SE sites' metas, including", "in an answer. * On this site, what are the", "what users of this site look for and appreciate in", "relevant experience, bias, etc. Of course, not all questions benefit", "or not, citing outside sources, addressing question in general vs", "specific relevant experience, bias, etc. Of course, not all questions", "are not limited to: length, content, style, tone, disclosing background", "include but are not limited to: length, content, style, tone,", "in learning what users of this site look for and", "on this site? (if such a thing even exists...) Possible", "limited to: length, content, style, tone, disclosing background of answer-er", "or without specific relevant experience, bias, etc. Of course, not", "with or without specific relevant experience, bias, etc. Of course,", "of a bad answer on this site? (if such a", "answers, and responses addressing subtleties like this are also very", "background of answer-er or not, citing outside sources, addressing question", "answer. * On this site, what are the characteristics of", "(if such a thing even exists...) Possible aspects to consider", "(Examples of exceptionally good answers, and what makes them so", "not, citing outside sources, addressing question in general vs situation-specific", "are the characteristics of a bad answer on this site?", "Possible aspects to consider include but are not limited to:", "answer on this site? (if such a thing even exists...)", "SE sites' metas, including those of sites I don't participate", "appreciate in an answer. * On this site, what are", "kinds of answers, and responses addressing subtleties like this are", "bad answer on this site? (if such a thing even", "thing even exists...) Possible aspects to consider include but are", "of answer-er or not, citing outside sources, addressing question in", "exceptionally good answers, and what makes them so exceptional, are", "answer? (Examples of exceptionally good answers, and what makes them", "even exists...) Possible aspects to consider include but are not", "characteristics of a bad answer on this site? (if such", "sources, addressing question in general vs situation-specific way, answers from", "outside sources, addressing question in general vs situation-specific way, answers", "so exceptional, are welcome!) * What are the characteristics of", "post is shamelessly stolen from [Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I", "users of this site look for and appreciate in an", "sites' metas, including those of sites I don't participate in", "such a thing even exists...) Possible aspects to consider include", "not all questions benefit from the same kinds of answers,", "read other SE sites' metas, including those of sites I", "responses addressing subtleties like this are also very welcome. ---", "interested in learning what users of this site look for", "other SE sites' metas, including those of sites I don't", "What are the characteristics of a bad answer on this", "of a good answer? (Examples of exceptionally good answers, and", "shamelessly stolen from [Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I read other", "exceptional, are welcome!) * What are the characteristics of a", "but are not limited to: length, content, style, tone, disclosing", "general vs situation-specific way, answers from users with or without", "stolen from [Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I read other SE", "and what makes them so exceptional, are welcome!) * What", "answers, and what makes them so exceptional, are welcome!) ", "experience, bias, etc. Of course, not all questions benefit from", "I am interested in learning what users of this site", "style, tone, disclosing background of answer-er or not, citing outside", "the characteristics of a good answer? (Examples of exceptionally good", "for and appreciate in an answer. On this site,", "content, style, tone, disclosing background of answer-er or not, citing", "from users with or without specific relevant experience, bias, etc.", "from the same kinds of answers, and responses addressing subtleties", "a bad answer on this site? (if such a thing", "same kinds of answers, and responses addressing subtleties like this", "metas, including those of sites I don't participate in at", "are welcome!) * What are the characteristics of a bad", "answers from users with or without specific relevant experience, bias,", "makes them so exceptional, are welcome!) * What are the", "are also very welcome. --- (This post is shamelessly stolen", "citing outside sources, addressing question in general vs situation-specific way,", "site, what are the characteristics of a good answer? (Examples", "this site? (if such a thing even exists...) Possible aspects", "[Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I read other SE sites' metas,", "On this site, what are the characteristics of a good", "addressing question in general vs situation-specific way, answers from users", "of answers, and responses addressing subtleties like this are also", "vs situation-specific way, answers from users with or without specific", "good answers, and what makes them so exceptional, are welcome!)", "consider include but are not limited to: length, content, style,", "a good answer? (Examples of exceptionally good answers, and what", "not limited to: length, content, style, tone, disclosing background of", "addressing subtleties like this are also very welcome. --- (This", "course, not all questions benefit from the same kinds of", "all questions benefit from the same kinds of answers, and", "site? (if such a thing even exists...) Possible aspects to", "welcome!) * What are the characteristics of a bad answer", "aspects to consider include but are not limited to: length,", "of exceptionally good answers, and what makes them so exceptional,", "from [Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I read other SE sites'", "like this are also very welcome. --- (This post is", "am interested in learning what users of this site look", "situation-specific way, answers from users with or without specific relevant", "look for and appreciate in an answer. * On this", "meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I read other SE sites' metas, including those", "the same kinds of answers, and responses addressing subtleties like", "the characteristics of a bad answer on this site? (if", "this site, what are the characteristics of a good answer?", "of this site look for and appreciate in an answer.", "I read other SE sites' metas, including those of sites", "etc. Of course, not all questions benefit from the same", "* On this site, what are the characteristics of a", "way, answers from users with or without specific relevant experience,", "an answer. * On this site, what are the characteristics", "to: length, content, style, tone, disclosing background of answer-er or", "bias, etc. Of course, not all questions benefit from the", "Yes, I read other SE sites' metas, including those of", "--- (This post is shamelessly stolen from [Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers).", "them so exceptional, are welcome!) * What are the characteristics", "question in general vs situation-specific way, answers from users with", "including those of sites I don't participate in at all.)", "and responses addressing subtleties like this are also very welcome.", "this are also very welcome. --- (This post is shamelessly", "learning what users of this site look for and appreciate", "characteristics of a good answer? (Examples of exceptionally good answers,", "what makes them so exceptional, are welcome!) * What are", "in general vs situation-specific way, answers from users with or", "users with or without specific relevant experience, bias, etc. Of", "and appreciate in an answer. * On this site, what", "subtleties like this are also very welcome. --- (This post", "is shamelessly stolen from [Biblical Hermeneutics meta](https://hermeneutics.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/520/what-are-we-looking-for-in-answers). Yes, I read", "are the characteristics of a good answer? (Examples of exceptionally", "exists...) Possible aspects to consider include but are not limited", "length, content, style, tone, disclosing background of answer-er or not," ]
[ "[academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description says: > > Writing texts in", "think that it is completely overlap with this academia.SE site.", "writers.SE, there is a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description says: >", "peer-reviewed articles, theses, text books, and others. > > >", "theses, text books, and others. > > > I think", "in? Can I cross-duplicate my question to get the best", "setting: peer-reviewed articles, theses, text books, and others. > >", "or educational setting: peer-reviewed articles, theses, text books, and others.", "site will I get the best answers if I ask", "cross-duplicate my question to get the best from both worlds?", "it is completely overlap with this academia.SE site. So if", "> > I think that it is completely overlap with", "completely overlap with this academia.SE site. So if I have", "So if I have a question about writing, which site", "Its description says: > > Writing texts in a scientific", "says: > > Writing texts in a scientific or educational", "I have a question about writing, which site will I", "> Writing texts in a scientific or educational setting: peer-reviewed", "which site will I get the best answers if I", "get the best answers if I ask in? Can I", "a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description says: > > Writing texts", "educational setting: peer-reviewed articles, theses, text books, and others. >", "a scientific or educational setting: peer-reviewed articles, theses, text books,", "with this academia.SE site. So if I have a question", "books, and others. > > > I think that it", "I cross-duplicate my question to get the best from both", "academia.SE site. So if I have a question about writing,", "in a scientific or educational setting: peer-reviewed articles, theses, text", "there is a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description says: > >", "> I think that it is completely overlap with this", "site. So if I have a question about writing, which", "best answers if I ask in? Can I cross-duplicate my", "texts in a scientific or educational setting: peer-reviewed articles, theses,", "is completely overlap with this academia.SE site. So if I", "in the writers.SE, there is a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description", "scientific or educational setting: peer-reviewed articles, theses, text books, and", "ask in? Can I cross-duplicate my question to get the", "tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description says: > > Writing texts in a", "overlap with this academia.SE site. So if I have a", "Recently, I find that in the writers.SE, there is a", "this academia.SE site. So if I have a question about", "a question about writing, which site will I get the", "the writers.SE, there is a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description says:", "question about writing, which site will I get the best", "will I get the best answers if I ask in?", "if I ask in? Can I cross-duplicate my question to", "text books, and others. > > > I think that", "> > > I think that it is completely overlap", "description says: > > Writing texts in a scientific or", "I think that it is completely overlap with this academia.SE", "about writing, which site will I get the best answers", "I ask in? Can I cross-duplicate my question to get", "answers if I ask in? Can I cross-duplicate my question", "Can I cross-duplicate my question to get the best from", "I find that in the writers.SE, there is a [academic", "and others. > > > I think that it is", "is a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its description says: > > Writing", "find that in the writers.SE, there is a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing).", "the best answers if I ask in? Can I cross-duplicate", "have a question about writing, which site will I get", "others. > > > I think that it is completely", "Writing texts in a scientific or educational setting: peer-reviewed articles,", "that in the writers.SE, there is a [academic tag](https://writers.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/academic-writing). Its", "articles, theses, text books, and others. > > > I", "that it is completely overlap with this academia.SE site. So", "if I have a question about writing, which site will", "> > Writing texts in a scientific or educational setting:", "I get the best answers if I ask in? Can", "writing, which site will I get the best answers if" ]
[ "will never be raised. Can you tell me when should", "Reddit works is different to the way SE works. In", "the way SE works. In SE, people ask and answer.", "to the way SE works. In SE, people ask and", "AskAcademia, I see no different to here. Bad questions may", "more in Reddit, and surprisingly find out a subreddit named", "Reddit, and the way Reddit works is different to the", "in Q&A subreddit like AskAcademia, I see no different to", "raised. Can you tell me when should I ask questions", "should I ask questions on Reddit rather than Stack Exchange?", "involve more in Reddit, and surprisingly find out a subreddit", "people post a link/thinking and comment. However, in Q&A subreddit", "they will never be raised. Can you tell me when", "me when should I ask questions on Reddit rather than", "like AskAcademia, I see no different to here. Bad questions", "the way Reddit works is different to the way SE", "comment. However, in Q&A subreddit like AskAcademia, I see no", "recently involve more in Reddit, and surprisingly find out a", "not Reddit, and the way Reddit works is different to", "never be raised. Can you tell me when should I", "out a subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know that Stack Exchange", "that Stack Exchange is not Reddit, and the way Reddit", "In Reddit, people post a link/thinking and comment. However, in", "no different to here. Bad questions may never be closed,", "see no different to here. Bad questions may never be", "way Reddit works is different to the way SE works.", "Stack Exchange is not Reddit, and the way Reddit works", "I see no different to here. Bad questions may never", "ask and answer. In Reddit, people post a link/thinking and", "and comment. However, in Q&A subreddit like AskAcademia, I see", "people ask and answer. In Reddit, people post a link/thinking", "never be closed, but they will never be raised. Can", "questions may never be closed, but they will never be", "is different to the way SE works. In SE, people", "subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know that Stack Exchange is not", "a subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know that Stack Exchange is", "Exchange is not Reddit, and the way Reddit works is", "you tell me when should I ask questions on Reddit", "I know that Stack Exchange is not Reddit, and the", "way SE works. In SE, people ask and answer. In", "SE works. In SE, people ask and answer. In Reddit,", "subreddit like AskAcademia, I see no different to here. Bad", "works. In SE, people ask and answer. In Reddit, people", "answer. In Reddit, people post a link/thinking and comment. However,", "I recently involve more in Reddit, and surprisingly find out", "but they will never be raised. Can you tell me", "Q&A subreddit like AskAcademia, I see no different to here.", "a link/thinking and comment. However, in Q&A subreddit like AskAcademia,", "different to the way SE works. In SE, people ask", "closed, but they will never be raised. Can you tell", "post a link/thinking and comment. However, in Q&A subreddit like", "tell me when should I ask questions on Reddit rather", "link/thinking and comment. However, in Q&A subreddit like AskAcademia, I", "Bad questions may never be closed, but they will never", "and surprisingly find out a subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know", "Reddit, and surprisingly find out a subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I", "know that Stack Exchange is not Reddit, and the way", "and answer. In Reddit, people post a link/thinking and comment.", "in Reddit, and surprisingly find out a subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/).", "be raised. Can you tell me when should I ask", "and the way Reddit works is different to the way", "here. Bad questions may never be closed, but they will", "different to here. Bad questions may never be closed, but", "find out a subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know that Stack", "surprisingly find out a subreddit named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know that", "works is different to the way SE works. In SE,", "be closed, but they will never be raised. Can you", "Can you tell me when should I ask questions on", "SE, people ask and answer. In Reddit, people post a", "to here. Bad questions may never be closed, but they", "In SE, people ask and answer. In Reddit, people post", "may never be closed, but they will never be raised.", "[AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know that Stack Exchange is not Reddit, and", "when should I ask questions on Reddit rather than Stack", "is not Reddit, and the way Reddit works is different", "Reddit, people post a link/thinking and comment. However, in Q&A", "However, in Q&A subreddit like AskAcademia, I see no different", "named [AskAcademia](http://www.reddit.com/r/AskAcademia/). I know that Stack Exchange is not Reddit," ]
[ "a couple of questions along the lines of \"Can I", "possible to get into a good masters program in computer", "There's been a couple of questions along the lines of", "of questions along the lines of \"Can I get into", "physics if my GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these questions be", "the lines of \"Can I get into X program with", "questions along the lines of \"Can I get into X", "3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) * [Can I get a scholarship from graduate", "masters program in computer science with a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) ", "school in physics if my GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these", "in physics if my GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these questions", "3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these questions be allowed? My concern is that", "in computer science with a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) [Can I", "graduate school in physics if my GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should", "lines of \"Can I get into X program with x.xx", "allowed? My concern is that are too broad or too", "get into a good masters program in computer science with", "Should these questions be allowed? My concern is that are", "program in computer science with a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) * [Can", "below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these questions be allowed? My concern is", "these questions be allowed? My concern is that are too", "into X program with x.xx GPA?\" * [Is it possible", "program with x.xx GPA?\" * [Is it possible to get", "GPA?\" * [Is it possible to get into a good", "GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these questions be allowed? My concern", "scholarship from graduate school in physics if my GPA below", "couple of questions along the lines of \"Can I get", "of \"Can I get into X program with x.xx GPA?\"", "if my GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these questions be allowed?", "computer science with a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) * [Can I get", "X program with x.xx GPA?\" * [Is it possible to", "good masters program in computer science with a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3)", "a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) * [Can I get a scholarship from", "a scholarship from graduate school in physics if my GPA", "it possible to get into a good masters program in", "\"Can I get into X program with x.xx GPA?\" ", "be allowed? My concern is that are too broad or", " [Is it possible to get into a good masters", "[Can I get a scholarship from graduate school in physics", "* [Can I get a scholarship from graduate school in", "from graduate school in physics if my GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3)", "science with a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) * [Can I get a", "along the lines of \"Can I get into X program", "to get into a good masters program in computer science", "into a good masters program in computer science with a", "x.xx GPA?\" * [Is it possible to get into a", "with x.xx GPA?\" * [Is it possible to get into", "a good masters program in computer science with a 3-3.5", "GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) * [Can I get a scholarship from graduate school", "I get a scholarship from graduate school in physics if", "I get into X program with x.xx GPA?\" * [Is", "my GPA below 3?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/31812/can-i-get-a-scholarship-from-graduate-school-in-physics-if-my-gpa-below-3) Should these questions be allowed? My", "questions be allowed? My concern is that are too broad", "[Is it possible to get into a good masters program", "been a couple of questions along the lines of \"Can", "get a scholarship from graduate school in physics if my", "with a 3-3.5 GPA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34767/is-it-possible-to-get-into-a-good-masters-program-in-computer-science-with-a-3-3) * [Can I get a scholarship", "concern is that are too broad or too particular. Thoughts?", "get into X program with x.xx GPA?\" * [Is it", "My concern is that are too broad or too particular." ]
[ "questions and answer them, or review them to find out", "whether they are eligible to remain opened? In my opinion,", "have no answers and are still open, these are the", "answers and are still open, these are the questions which", "to find out whether they are eligible to remain opened?", "to be on-topic on site because they are not closed", "I did a search to find unanswered questions on website", "find out whether there duplicates of them available on website?", "eligible to remain opened? In my opinion, some of these", "ones, however some other may not be so good to", "encouraged to take a look at these questions and answer", "closed as off-topic or duplicate. How can users be encouraged", "or review them to find out whether there duplicates of", "did a search to find unanswered questions on website and", "they are not closed as off-topic or duplicate. How can", "duplicates of them available on website? Should some of these", "look at these questions and answer them, or review them", "questions which seem to be on-topic on site because they", "some of these questions reviewed to find out whether they", "on-topic on site because they are not closed as off-topic", "these questions and answer them, or review them to find", "the questions which seem to be on-topic on site because", "to take a look at these questions and answer them,", "search to find unanswered questions on website and found about", "of these questions are good ones, however some other may", "remain opened? In my opinion, some of these questions are", "opened? In my opinion, some of these questions are good", "not closed as off-topic or duplicate. How can users be", "answer them, or review them to find out whether there", "and found about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have no answers and", "Should some of these questions reviewed to find out whether", "of these questions reviewed to find out whether they are", "reviewed to find out whether they are eligible to remain", "found about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have no answers and are", "questions reviewed to find out whether they are eligible to", "whether there duplicates of them available on website? Should some", "which have no answers and are still open, these are", "them available on website? Should some of these questions reviewed", "site because they are not closed as off-topic or duplicate.", "users be encouraged to take a look at these questions", "review them to find out whether there duplicates of them", "are the questions which seem to be on-topic on site", "are still open, these are the questions which seem to", "they are eligible to remain opened? In my opinion, some", "be encouraged to take a look at these questions and", "questions on website and found about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have", "opinion, some of these questions are good ones, however some", "however some other may not be so good to remain", "which seem to be on-topic on site because they are", "a look at these questions and answer them, or review", "on website and found about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have no", "to remain opened? In my opinion, some of these questions", "because they are not closed as off-topic or duplicate. How", "a search to find unanswered questions on website and found", "off-topic or duplicate. How can users be encouraged to take", "of them available on website? Should some of these questions", "these are the questions which seem to be on-topic on", "and are still open, these are the questions which seem", "there duplicates of them available on website? Should some of", "In my opinion, some of these questions are good ones,", "still open, these are the questions which seem to be", "are eligible to remain opened? In my opinion, some of", "them to find out whether there duplicates of them available", "open, these are the questions which seem to be on-topic", "unanswered questions on website and found about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which", "my opinion, some of these questions are good ones, however", "questions are good ones, however some other may not be", "find unanswered questions on website and found about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano)", "at these questions and answer them, or review them to", "these questions are good ones, however some other may not", "or duplicate. How can users be encouraged to take a", "about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have no answers and are still", "duplicate. How can users be encouraged to take a look", "no answers and are still open, these are the questions", "are not closed as off-topic or duplicate. How can users", "find out whether they are eligible to remain opened? In", "How can users be encouraged to take a look at", "to find unanswered questions on website and found about [141", "website? Should some of these questions reviewed to find out", "out whether there duplicates of them available on website? Should", "website and found about [141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have no answers", "good ones, however some other may not be so good", "on site because they are not closed as off-topic or", "to find out whether there duplicates of them available on", "as off-topic or duplicate. How can users be encouraged to", "take a look at these questions and answer them, or", "some of these questions are good ones, however some other", "out whether they are eligible to remain opened? In my", "[141 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have no answers and are still open,", "them, or review them to find out whether there duplicates", "are good ones, however some other may not be so", "and answer them, or review them to find out whether", "available on website? Should some of these questions reviewed to", "seem to be on-topic on site because they are not", "on website? Should some of these questions reviewed to find", "be on-topic on site because they are not closed as", "some other may not be so good to remain opened.", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=answers%3A0%20closed%3Ano%20duplicate%3Ano) which have no answers and are still open, these", "can users be encouraged to take a look at these", "these questions reviewed to find out whether they are eligible" ]
[ "short time. The second point makes me think that there", "is currently all of unclear, opinion-based, and maybe also somewhat", "rant. * However, the question has also garnered a lot", "I think given the tone and scope of the question", "written, this is in line with our usual practices. One", "and many, many comments. We do not all that often", "I have the theory that it has a lot to", "of responses: there are 32 upvotes (2 downvotes), 2000 views,", "other \"I hate grad school, shall I quit?\" questions that", "seems rather unhealthily tied to her grad student status, but", "in this question, something that a good edit may be", "self-esteem seems rather unhealthily tied to her grad student status,", "[this recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of, the facts (as I", "no direct closing by a mod). I think given the", "the OP's self-esteem seems rather unhealthily tied to her grad", "be able to salvage. However, I am not entirely sure", "that makes this question more interesting to the community than", "question has been put on hold (with 5 community votes,", "the theory that it has a lot to do with", "question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of, the facts (as I see them): ", "a rant. However, the question has also garnered a", "that trigger more community interest in such short time. The", "all the other \"I hate grad school, shall I quit?\"", "question, something that a good edit may be able to", "lot to do with the impression that the OP's self-esteem", "32 upvotes (2 downvotes), 2000 views, 9 answers, and many,", "to salvage. However, I am not entirely sure what the", "second point makes me think that there has to be", "salvage. However, I am not entirely sure what the golden", "have the theory that it has a lot to do", "to do with the impression that the OP's self-esteem seems", "is in line with our usual practices. One can argue", "that there has to be something relevant in this question,", "as written, this is in line with our usual practices.", "with our usual practices. One can argue that the question", "currently all of unclear, opinion-based, and maybe also somewhat of", "garnered a lot of responses: there are 32 upvotes (2", "all of unclear, opinion-based, and maybe also somewhat of a", "of the question as written, this is in line with", "time. The second point makes me think that there has", "something that a good edit may be able to salvage.", "has also garnered a lot of responses: there are 32", "I am not sure. What are your opinions on this", "usual practices. One can argue that the question is currently", "by a mod). I think given the tone and scope", "(as I see them): The question has been put", "many comments. We do not all that often have questions", "community than all the other \"I hate grad school, shall", "core is that makes this question more interesting to the", "the community than all the other \"I hate grad school,", "them): * The question has been put on hold (with", "discussion about [this recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of, the facts", "on hold (with 5 community votes, no direct closing by", "argue that the question is currently all of unclear, opinion-based,", "her grad student status, but I am not sure. *What", "question more interesting to the community than all the other", "in such short time. The second point makes me think", "the suggestion of @Davidmh, I want to start a discussion", "the other \"I hate grad school, shall I quit?\"* questions", "start a discussion about [this recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of,", "closing by a mod). I think given the tone and", "in line with our usual practices. One can argue that", "our usual practices. One can argue that the question is", "be* something relevant in this question, something that a good", "am not sure. What are your opinions on this question?", "put on hold (with 5 community votes, no direct closing", "able to salvage. However, I am not entirely sure what", "sure what the golden core is that makes this question", "votes, no direct closing by a mod). I think given", "of unclear, opinion-based, and maybe also somewhat of a rant.", "also somewhat of a rant. * However, the question has", "about [this recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of, the facts (as", "to start a discussion about [this recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First", "can argue that the question is currently all of unclear,", "However, I am not entirely sure what the golden core", "views, 9 answers, and many, many comments. We do not", "all that often have questions that trigger more community interest", "question is currently all of unclear, opinion-based, and maybe also", "to the community than all the other \"I hate grad", "grad school, shall I quit?\" questions that we usually close", "usually close rather unceremoniously. I have the theory that it", "more interesting to the community than all the other \"I", "but I am not sure. What are your opinions on", "interesting to the community than all the other \"I hate", "tone and scope of the question as written, this is", "that the OP's self-esteem seems rather unhealthily tied to her", "maybe also somewhat of a rant. * However, the question", "see them): * The question has been put on hold", "that a good edit may be able to salvage. However,", "facts (as I see them): * The question has been", "to be* something relevant in this question, something that a", "line with our usual practices. One can argue that the", "we usually close rather unceremoniously. I have the theory that", "and maybe also somewhat of a rant. * However, the", "that the question is currently all of unclear, opinion-based, and", "I want to start a discussion about [this recently holded", "the question has also garnered a lot of responses: there", "I see them): * The question has been put on", "OP's self-esteem seems rather unhealthily tied to her grad student", "lot of responses: there are 32 upvotes (2 downvotes), 2000", "has a lot to do with the impression that the", "think that there has to be something relevant in this", "of a rant. * However, the question has also garnered", "opinion-based, and maybe also somewhat of a rant. * However,", "theory that it has a lot to do with the", "grad student status, but I am not sure. *What are", "there are 32 upvotes (2 downvotes), 2000 views, 9 answers,", "suggestion of @Davidmh, I want to start a discussion about", "and scope of the question as written, this is in", "5 community votes, no direct closing by a mod). I", "direct closing by a mod). I think given the tone", "somewhat of a rant. However, the question has also", "question as written, this is in line with our usual", "9 answers, and many, many comments. We do not all", "One can argue that the question is currently all of", "* However, the question has also garnered a lot of", "The second point makes me think that there has to", "practices. One can argue that the question is currently all", "comments. We do not all that often have questions that", "me think that there has to be* something relevant in", "has to be something relevant in this question, something that", "quit?\"* questions that we usually close rather unceremoniously. I have", "what the golden core is that makes this question more", "questions that trigger more community interest in such short time.", "something relevant in this question, something that a good edit", "this question, something that a good edit may be able", "(with 5 community votes, no direct closing by a mod).", "has been put on hold (with 5 community votes, no", "such short time. The second point makes me think that", "* The question has been put on hold (with 5", "it has a lot to do with the impression that", "However, the question has also garnered a lot of responses:", "to her grad student status, but I am not sure.", "rather unhealthily tied to her grad student status, but I", "answers, and many, many comments. We do not all that", "(2 downvotes), 2000 views, 9 answers, and many, many comments.", "community interest in such short time. The second point makes", "a mod). I think given the tone and scope of", "2000 views, 9 answers, and many, many comments. We do", "\"I hate grad school, shall I quit?\" questions that we", "this question more interesting to the community than all the", "hold (with 5 community votes, no direct closing by a", "makes this question more interesting to the community than all", "point makes me think that there has to be something", "than all the other \"I hate grad school, shall I", "tied to her grad student status, but I am not", "of @Davidmh, I want to start a discussion about [this", "the tone and scope of the question as written, this", "am not entirely sure what the golden core is that", "@Davidmh, I want to start a discussion about [this recently", "downvotes), 2000 views, 9 answers, and many, many comments. We", "do not all that often have questions that trigger more", "edit may be able to salvage. However, I am not", "the question is currently all of unclear, opinion-based, and maybe", "a good edit may be able to salvage. However, I", "student status, but I am not sure. What are your", "do with the impression that the OP's self-esteem seems rather", "shall I quit?\" questions that we usually close rather unceremoniously.", "have questions that trigger more community interest in such short", "unhealthily tied to her grad student status, but I am", "relevant in this question, something that a good edit may", "the question as written, this is in line with our", "impression that the OP's self-esteem seems rather unhealthily tied to", "makes me think that there has to be something relevant", "close rather unceremoniously. I have the theory that it has", "given the tone and scope of the question as written,", "holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of, the facts (as I see them):", "many, many comments. We do not all that often have", "a discussion about [this recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of, the", "mod). I think given the tone and scope of the", "hate grad school, shall I quit?\"* questions that we usually", "also garnered a lot of responses: there are 32 upvotes", "of, the facts (as I see them): * The question", "a lot of responses: there are 32 upvotes (2 downvotes),", "questions that we usually close rather unceremoniously. I have the", "this is in line with our usual practices. One can", "unceremoniously. I have the theory that it has a lot", "entirely sure what the golden core is that makes this", "I am not entirely sure what the golden core is", "The question has been put on hold (with 5 community", "the facts (as I see them): * The question has", "question has also garnered a lot of responses: there are", "I quit?\"* questions that we usually close rather unceremoniously. I", "school, shall I quit?\"* questions that we usually close rather", "rather unceremoniously. I have the theory that it has a", "Following the suggestion of @Davidmh, I want to start a", "trigger more community interest in such short time. The second", "unclear, opinion-based, and maybe also somewhat of a rant. ", "upvotes (2 downvotes), 2000 views, 9 answers, and many, many", "not all that often have questions that trigger more* community", "the impression that the OP's self-esteem seems rather unhealthily tied", "think given the tone and scope of the question as", "want to start a discussion about [this recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life)", "often have questions that trigger more community interest in such", "that often have questions that trigger more community interest in", "more community interest in such short time. The second point", "is that makes this question more interesting to the community", "may be able to salvage. However, I am not entirely", "that it has a lot to do with the impression", "a lot to do with the impression that the OP's", "status, but I am not sure. *What are your opinions", "responses: there are 32 upvotes (2 downvotes), 2000 views, 9", "First of, the facts (as I see them): The", "golden core is that makes this question more interesting to", "community votes, no direct closing by a mod). I think", "that we usually close rather unceremoniously. I have the theory", "there has to be something relevant in this question, something", "with the impression that the OP's self-esteem seems rather unhealthily", "interest in such short time. The second point makes me", "good edit may be able to salvage. However, I am", "We do not all that often have questions that trigger", "not entirely sure what the golden core is that makes", "recently holded question.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life) First of, the facts (as I see", "been put on hold (with 5 community votes, no direct", "scope of the question as written, this is in line", "the golden core is that makes this question more interesting", "are 32 upvotes (2 downvotes), 2000 views, 9 answers, and" ]
[ "to increase the chances of succefully going through (and completing)", "purpose of compiling a list of some of the most", "most important part of my Ph.D in Mathematics: the \"go", "would certainly arise; but is this question too broad and/", "would make this possible, and that some valuable tips would", "of the most important things one can do to increase", "list of some of the most important things one can", "helpful things. I am sure that the large experience of", "be more specific and helpful things. I am sure that", "did reseach before, I am a bit scared about it.", "the \"go and do something original!\" part. To be honest,", "things. I am sure that the large experience of the", "my situation, I would like to ask a question on", "to ask a question on Academia with the purpose of", "succefully going through (and completing) a Ph.D. Of course, I", "it would be more specific and helpful things. I am", "arise; but is this question too broad and/ or too", "will be starting the most important part of my Ph.D", "Next September I will be starting the most important part", "the community members would make this possible, and that some", "the purpose of compiling a list of some of the", "\"go and do something original!\" part. To be honest, as", "the most important things one can do to increase the", "one can do to increase the chances of succefully going", "is this question too broad and/ or too opinion-based to", "I am sure there are many many people in my", "be starting the most important part of my Ph.D in", "possible, and that some valuable tips would certainly arise; but", "original!\" part. To be honest, as someone who never did", "Of course, I am not looking for general things like", "question on Academia with the purpose of compiling a list", "am not looking for general things like \"work hard everyday\";", "do to increase the chances of succefully going through (and", "a Ph.D. Of course, I am not looking for general", "part of my Ph.D in Mathematics: the \"go and do", "people in my situation, I would like to ask a", "with the purpose of compiling a list of some of", "part. To be honest, as someone who never did reseach", "before, I am a bit scared about it. As I", "scared about it. As I am sure there are many", "compiling a list of some of the most important things", "more specific and helpful things. I am sure that the", "some valuable tips would certainly arise; but is this question", "most important things one can do to increase the chances", "things one can do to increase the chances of succefully", "do something original!\" part. To be honest, as someone who", "bit scared about it. As I am sure there are", "To be honest, as someone who never did reseach before,", "and that some valuable tips would certainly arise; but is", "are many many people in my situation, I would like", "the large experience of the community members would make this", "through (and completing) a Ph.D. Of course, I am not", "starting the most important part of my Ph.D in Mathematics:", "my Ph.D in Mathematics: the \"go and do something original!\"", "going through (and completing) a Ph.D. Of course, I am", "am sure that the large experience of the community members", "members would make this possible, and that some valuable tips", "on Academia with the purpose of compiling a list of", "I will be starting the most important part of my", "many people in my situation, I would like to ask", "Academia with the purpose of compiling a list of some", "and helpful things. I am sure that the large experience", "would be more specific and helpful things. I am sure", "things like \"work hard everyday\"; ideally, it would be more", "and do something original!\" part. To be honest, as someone", "valuable tips would certainly arise; but is this question too", "but is this question too broad and/ or too opinion-based", "who never did reseach before, I am a bit scared", "increase the chances of succefully going through (and completing) a", "of the community members would make this possible, and that", "this question too broad and/ or too opinion-based to fit", "of some of the most important things one can do", "like to ask a question on Academia with the purpose", "in my situation, I would like to ask a question", "am sure there are many many people in my situation,", "the chances of succefully going through (and completing) a Ph.D.", "make this possible, and that some valuable tips would certainly", "a question on Academia with the purpose of compiling a", "the most important part of my Ph.D in Mathematics: the", "about it. As I am sure there are many many", "important things one can do to increase the chances of", "for general things like \"work hard everyday\"; ideally, it would", "situation, I would like to ask a question on Academia", "that some valuable tips would certainly arise; but is this", "tips would certainly arise; but is this question too broad", "would like to ask a question on Academia with the", "(and completing) a Ph.D. Of course, I am not looking", "of compiling a list of some of the most important", "chances of succefully going through (and completing) a Ph.D. Of", "be honest, as someone who never did reseach before, I", "As I am sure there are many many people in", "can do to increase the chances of succefully going through", "large experience of the community members would make this possible,", "there are many many people in my situation, I would", "sure there are many many people in my situation, I", "Ph.D. Of course, I am not looking for general things", "something original!\" part. To be honest, as someone who never", "this possible, and that some valuable tips would certainly arise;", "a bit scared about it. As I am sure there", "certainly arise; but is this question too broad and/ or", "question too broad and/ or too opinion-based to fit here?", "experience of the community members would make this possible, and", "everyday\"; ideally, it would be more specific and helpful things.", "I am a bit scared about it. As I am", "\"work hard everyday\"; ideally, it would be more specific and", "sure that the large experience of the community members would", "looking for general things like \"work hard everyday\"; ideally, it", "it. As I am sure there are many many people", "some of the most important things one can do to", "never did reseach before, I am a bit scared about", "important part of my Ph.D in Mathematics: the \"go and", "hard everyday\"; ideally, it would be more specific and helpful", "ideally, it would be more specific and helpful things. I", "course, I am not looking for general things like \"work", "I am sure that the large experience of the community", "Mathematics: the \"go and do something original!\" part. To be", "of succefully going through (and completing) a Ph.D. Of course,", "I am not looking for general things like \"work hard", "like \"work hard everyday\"; ideally, it would be more specific", "specific and helpful things. I am sure that the large", "community members would make this possible, and that some valuable", "Ph.D in Mathematics: the \"go and do something original!\" part.", "that the large experience of the community members would make", "general things like \"work hard everyday\"; ideally, it would be", "not looking for general things like \"work hard everyday\"; ideally,", "September I will be starting the most important part of", "ask a question on Academia with the purpose of compiling", "many many people in my situation, I would like to", "as someone who never did reseach before, I am a", "someone who never did reseach before, I am a bit", "of my Ph.D in Mathematics: the \"go and do something", "I would like to ask a question on Academia with", "honest, as someone who never did reseach before, I am", "a list of some of the most important things one", "am a bit scared about it. As I am sure", "reseach before, I am a bit scared about it. As", "in Mathematics: the \"go and do something original!\" part. To", "completing) a Ph.D. Of course, I am not looking for" ]
[ "because they are often borderline off-topic and I sometimes don't", "of the word 'depression' on this site, and was shocked", "hand I really think it's a bad idea to rely", "year 6 or just take a bit of a leave", "a job offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking about leaving a", "* [If I have an academic dismissal from a school", "or does our site somehow attract depressed peoples? Despite what", "depressed and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming depression and getting back", "is higher than usual. I'm ready to change my mind", "stopped after 2 pages of search results) Explicit mention of", "handle serious nervous issues and don't want to be a", "surprising? Is it just an artifact, or does our site", "frequent they were. Does anyone else finds it surprising? Is", "uncomfortable, because they are often borderline off-topic and I sometimes", "of clinical depression: * [What do I do as a", "* [How to overcome feeling that published articles lack public", "[Thinking about leaving a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying to grad", "academic dismissal from a school should I ever go back", "of search results) Explicit mention of clinical depression: * [What", "attract depressed peoples? Despite what some say, I'm unconvinced that", "flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) * [Should I quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem", "depression: * [What do I do as a depressed and", "site somehow attract depressed peoples? Despite what some say, I'm", "rely on random internet posts to handle serious nervous issues", "say, I'm unconvinced that the prevalence of clinical depression amongst", "a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying to grad school for mathematics", "in terms of moderation, or do we need a tag", "public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What to do if one has had", "internet posts to handle serious nervous issues and don't want", "to grad school for mathematics with low GPA, but reluctant", "my PhD in year 6 or just take a bit", "prevalence of clinical depression amongst academics is higher than usual.", "have an academic dismissal from a school should I ever", "move on from my probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) * [Should I", "depression and getting back on rails with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) ", "a postdoc talk about his depression with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) ", "recently ran a simple Google search for instances of the", "part of a community that does that. So I'm interested", "* [What do I do as a depressed and incompetent", "finds it surprising? Is it just an artifact, or does", "others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) * [Is it possible to recover after a", "[Would most PhD supervisors stop working with a student who", "I ever go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) * ... Borderline questions: ", "contrary. Questions where OP mention their clinical depression always make", "borderline off-topic and I sometimes don't have the hart to", "[Should a postdoc talk about his depression with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643)", " [Is feeling lonely and uncomfortable in my (foreign) country", "random internet posts to handle serious nervous issues and don't", "unsuccessful PhD (because of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) * [Is it possible", "with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) * [Should a postdoc talk about his", "* [Would most PhD supervisors stop working with a student", "an academic dismissal from a school should I ever go", "than usual. I'm ready to change my mind when confronted", "opinions about it. Should we do specific things in terms", "clinical depression always make me uncomfortable, because they are often", "PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) * [Is feeling lonely and uncomfortable in my (foreign)", "community that does that. So I'm interested in your opinions", "that the prevalence of clinical depression amongst academics is higher", "to rely on random internet posts to handle serious nervous", "it's a bad idea to rely on random internet posts", "clinical depression: * [What do I do as a depressed", "bit of a leave and try to regroup?/ What is", "ready to change my mind when confronted to hard evidence", "delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking about leaving a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying", "try to regroup?/ What is an \"appropriate\" level of angst", "grad school for mathematics with low GPA, but reluctant to", "the other hand I really think it's a bad idea", "postdoc talk about his depression with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would", "the health issues that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If I have", "was shocked to see how frequent they were. Does anyone", "do we need a tag for it? --- List of", "question mentioning depression (I stopped after 2 pages of search", "if one has had an unsuccessful PhD (because of others'", "most PhD supervisors stop working with a student who was", "uncomfortable in my (foreign) country of study a valid reason", "powerlessness on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) * [Is feeling lonely and uncomfortable", "make me uncomfortable, because they are often borderline off-topic and", "to regroup?/ What is an \"appropriate\" level of angst to", "depression always make me uncomfortable, because they are often borderline", "reluctant to bring up the health issues that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643)", "after a career setback such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should I", "go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) * ... Borderline questions: * [Career advice:", "for it? --- List of question mentioning depression (I stopped", "our site somehow attract depressed peoples? Despite what some say,", "results) Explicit mention of clinical depression: * [What do I", "List of question mentioning depression (I stopped after 2 pages", "it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If I have an academic dismissal from a", "a bad idea to rely on random internet posts to", "PhD in year 6 or just take a bit of", "published articles lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What to do if", "an unsuccessful PhD (because of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) * [Is it", "often borderline off-topic and I sometimes don't have the hart", "lonely and uncomfortable in my (foreign) country of study a", "always make me uncomfortable, because they are often borderline off-topic", "one has had an unsuccessful PhD (because of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643)", "should I ever go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) * ... Borderline questions:", "of a community that does that. So I'm interested in", "take a bit of a leave and try to regroup?/", "as a depressed and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming depression and", "do if one has had an unsuccessful PhD (because of", "clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) * [How to overcome feeling that published articles", "artifact, or does our site somehow attract depressed peoples? Despite", "[Graduate without a job offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking about", "it. Should we do specific things in terms of moderation,", "search results) Explicit mention of clinical depression: * [What do", "to see how frequent they were. Does anyone else finds", "are often borderline off-topic and I sometimes don't have the", "issues and don't want to be a part of a", "and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How to cope with feelings of", "2 pages of search results) Explicit mention of clinical depression:", "master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying to grad school for mathematics with", "a career setback such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should I leave", "* [Applying to grad school for mathematics with low GPA,", "angst to go through with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate without", "level of angst to go through with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) ", " [How to cope with feelings of powerlessness on a", "they are often borderline off-topic and I sometimes don't have", "of angst to go through with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate", "and getting back on rails with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) * [Should", "mind when confronted to hard evidence of the contrary. Questions", "So I'm interested in your opinions about it. Should we", "from a school should I ever go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) ", "quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) ", "but reluctant to bring up the health issues that caused", "country of study a valid reason to drop out of", "Does anyone else finds it surprising? Is it just an", "dismissal from a school should I ever go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643)", "need a tag for it? --- List of question mentioning", "my mind when confronted to hard evidence of the contrary.", "who was unproductive due to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) * [How to", "somehow attract depressed peoples? Despite what some say, I'm unconvinced", "\"appropriate\" level of angst to go through with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643)", "think it's a bad idea to rely on random internet", "see how frequent they were. Does anyone else finds it", "from my probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) * [Should I quit my", "and don't want to be a part of a community", "have the hart to mention it. On the other hand", "his depression with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would most PhD supervisors", "* [What to do if one has had an unsuccessful", "offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking about leaving a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643)", "probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) * [Should I quit my PhD -", "career setback such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should I leave my", "the contrary. Questions where OP mention their clinical depression always", "a school should I ever go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) * ...", "issues that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If I have an academic", "a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate without a job offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643)", "and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming depression and getting back on", "getting back on rails with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) * [Should a", "usual. I'm ready to change my mind when confronted to", "for instances of the word 'depression' on this site, and", "to cope with feelings of powerlessness on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) ", "it. On the other hand I really think it's a", "simple Google search for instances of the word 'depression' on", "want to be a part of a community that does", "I move on from my probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) [Should", "feeling that published articles lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What to", "PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate without a job offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) ", "feelings of powerlessness on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) [Is feeling lonely", "study a valid reason to drop out of a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/35352/10643)", "your opinions about it. Should we do specific things in", "to do if one has had an unsuccessful PhD (because", "* [Career advice: How can I move on from my", "this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should I leave my PhD in year 6", "* [Should I quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and", "back on rails with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) * [Should a postdoc", "supervisors stop working with a student who was unproductive due", "[What to do if one has had an unsuccessful PhD", "Questions where OP mention their clinical depression always make me", "rails with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) * [Should a postdoc talk about", "to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) * [How to overcome feeling that published", "about leaving a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying to grad school", "* [Overcoming depression and getting back on rails with PhD", "[How to overcome feeling that published articles lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643)", "my probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) * [Should I quit my PhD", "confronted to hard evidence of the contrary. Questions where OP", "the hart to mention it. On the other hand I", "serious nervous issues and don't want to be a part", "PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How to", "specific things in terms of moderation, or do we need", "of question mentioning depression (I stopped after 2 pages of", "work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) * [Should a postdoc talk about his depression with", "it just an artifact, or does our site somehow attract", "after 2 pages of search results) Explicit mention of clinical", "else finds it surprising? Is it just an artifact, or", "depression (I stopped after 2 pages of search results) Explicit", "academics is higher than usual. I'm ready to change my", "caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If I have an academic dismissal from", "does that. So I'm interested in your opinions about it.", "How can I move on from my probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643)", "OP mention their clinical depression always make me uncomfortable, because", "that. So I'm interested in your opinions about it. Should", "without a job offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking about leaving", "what some say, I'm unconvinced that the prevalence of clinical", "Borderline questions: * [Career advice: How can I move on", "[Overcoming depression and getting back on rails with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643)", "ever go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) * ... Borderline questions: * [Career", "bad idea to rely on random internet posts to handle", "is an \"appropriate\" level of angst to go through with", "how frequent they were. Does anyone else finds it surprising?", "leave and try to regroup?/ What is an \"appropriate\" level", "as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should I leave my PhD in year", "possible to recover after a career setback such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643)", "do I do as a depressed and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) ", "to mention it. On the other hand I really think", "of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) [Is it possible to recover after", "ran a simple Google search for instances of the word", "were. Does anyone else finds it surprising? Is it just", "and try to regroup?/ What is an \"appropriate\" level of", "be a part of a community that does that. So", "* [Should I leave my PhD in year 6 or", "Despite what some say, I'm unconvinced that the prevalence of", "job offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking about leaving a master's", "moderation, or do we need a tag for it? ---", "leaving a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying to grad school for", "change my mind when confronted to hard evidence of the", "[What do I do as a depressed and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643)", "leave my PhD in year 6 or just take a", "a leave and try to regroup?/ What is an \"appropriate\"", "my (foreign) country of study a valid reason to drop", "other hand I really think it's a bad idea to", "it? --- List of question mentioning depression (I stopped after", "me uncomfortable, because they are often borderline off-topic and I", "instances of the word 'depression' on this site, and was", "or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking about leaving a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) ", "I'm ready to change my mind when confronted to hard", "had an unsuccessful PhD (because of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) [Is", "- workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How to cope", "a part of a community that does that. So I'm", "of the contrary. Questions where OP mention their clinical depression", "* [Graduate without a job offer or delay](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34963/10643) * [Thinking", "through with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate without a job offer", "nervous issues and don't want to be a part of", "I really think it's a bad idea to rely on", "social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How to cope with feelings of powerlessness", "that does that. So I'm interested in your opinions about", "pages of search results) Explicit mention of clinical depression: ", "PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) [Should a postdoc talk about his depression", "mention it. On the other hand I really think it's", "I quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643)", "setback such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should I leave my PhD", "cope with feelings of powerlessness on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) * [Is", "mathematics with low GPA, but reluctant to bring up the", "and I sometimes don't have the hart to mention it.", "of study a valid reason to drop out of a", "just an artifact, or does our site somehow attract depressed", "or do we need a tag for it? --- List", "it surprising? Is it just an artifact, or does our", "* [Should a postdoc talk about his depression with his", "with feelings of powerlessness on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) * [Is feeling", "I recently ran a simple Google search for instances of", "to handle serious nervous issues and don't want to be", "my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How", "terms of moderation, or do we need a tag for", "in your opinions about it. Should we do specific things", "I have an academic dismissal from a school should I", "with a student who was unproductive due to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643)", "an \"appropriate\" level of angst to go through with a", "evidence of the contrary. Questions where OP mention their clinical", "* [Thinking about leaving a master's program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying to", "interested in your opinions about it. Should we do specific", "with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate without a job offer or", "in year 6 or just take a bit of a", "with low GPA, but reluctant to bring up the health", "[Career advice: How can I move on from my probable", "can I move on from my probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) ", "student who was unproductive due to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) [How", "about it. Should we do specific things in terms of", "overcome feeling that published articles lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What", "and uncomfortable in my (foreign) country of study a valid", "amongst academics is higher than usual. I'm ready to change", "advice: How can I move on from my probable PhD", "his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would most PhD supervisors stop working with", "(I stopped after 2 pages of search results) Explicit mention", "I'm unconvinced that the prevalence of clinical depression amongst academics", "of clinical depression amongst academics is higher than usual. I'm", "unconvinced that the prevalence of clinical depression amongst academics is", "I do as a depressed and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming", "their clinical depression always make me uncomfortable, because they are", "talk about his depression with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would most", "incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming depression and getting back on rails", "a bit of a leave and try to regroup?/ What", "PhD (because of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) * [Is it possible to", "TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming depression and getting back on rails with", "such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should I leave my PhD in", "[Is feeling lonely and uncomfortable in my (foreign) country of", "Should we do specific things in terms of moderation, or", "a depressed and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming depression and getting", "depressed peoples? Despite what some say, I'm unconvinced that the", "PhD supervisors stop working with a student who was unproductive", "school should I ever go back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) * ... Borderline", "for mathematics with low GPA, but reluctant to bring up", "that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If I have an academic dismissal", "was unproductive due to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) * [How to overcome", "of moderation, or do we need a tag for it?", "life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How to cope with feelings of powerlessness on", "that published articles lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What to do", "PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) * [Should I quit my PhD - workload,", "do as a depressed and incompetent TA?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/40739/10643) * [Overcoming depression", "has had an unsuccessful PhD (because of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) ", "unproductive due to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) [How to overcome feeling", "on rails with PhD work](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/28257/10643) * [Should a postdoc talk", "don't want to be a part of a community that", "or just take a bit of a leave and try", "off-topic and I sometimes don't have the hart to mention", "some say, I'm unconvinced that the prevalence of clinical depression", "go through with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate without a job", "a simple Google search for instances of the word 'depression'", "On the other hand I really think it's a bad", "don't have the hart to mention it. On the other", "low GPA, but reluctant to bring up the health issues", "feeling lonely and uncomfortable in my (foreign) country of study", "to change my mind when confronted to hard evidence of", "clinical depression amongst academics is higher than usual. I'm ready", "* [Is it possible to recover after a career setback", "'depression' on this site, and was shocked to see how", "and was shocked to see how frequent they were. Does", "peoples? Despite what some say, I'm unconvinced that the prevalence", "idea to rely on random internet posts to handle serious", "I leave my PhD in year 6 or just take", "articles lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What to do if one", "program](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21089/10643) * [Applying to grad school for mathematics with low", "on this site, and was shocked to see how frequent", "about his depression with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would most PhD", "tag for it? --- List of question mentioning depression (I", "with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would most PhD supervisors stop working", "search for instances of the word 'depression' on this site,", "self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How to cope with feelings", "we do specific things in terms of moderation, or do", "(foreign) country of study a valid reason to drop out", "mention of clinical depression: * [What do I do as", "depression with his mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would most PhD supervisors stop", "interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What to do if one has had an", "posts to handle serious nervous issues and don't want to", "it possible to recover after a career setback such as", "--- List of question mentioning depression (I stopped after 2", "Is it just an artifact, or does our site somehow", "regroup?/ What is an \"appropriate\" level of angst to go", "when confronted to hard evidence of the contrary. Questions where", "an artifact, or does our site somehow attract depressed peoples?", "[Should I quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social", "up the health issues that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If I", "to overcome feeling that published articles lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) ", "shocked to see how frequent they were. Does anyone else", "they were. Does anyone else finds it surprising? Is it", "questions: [Career advice: How can I move on from", "things in terms of moderation, or do we need a", "depression amongst academics is higher than usual. I'm ready to", "working with a student who was unproductive due to clinical", "hard evidence of the contrary. Questions where OP mention their", "sometimes don't have the hart to mention it. On the", "workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/39017/10643) * [How to cope with", "word 'depression' on this site, and was shocked to see", "I'm interested in your opinions about it. Should we do", "where OP mention their clinical depression always make me uncomfortable,", "anyone else finds it surprising? Is it just an artifact,", "to bring up the health issues that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) ", "on from my probable PhD flop?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/33032/10643) [Should I quit", "really think it's a bad idea to rely on random", "lack public interest?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/32562/10643) * [What to do if one has", "due to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) * [How to overcome feeling that", "a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) * [Is feeling lonely and uncomfortable in my", "of a leave and try to regroup?/ What is an", "mentor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/31855/10643) * [Would most PhD supervisors stop working with a", "to hard evidence of the contrary. Questions where OP mention", "to go through with a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/13133/10643) * [Graduate without a", "(because of others' fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) * [Is it possible to recover", "hart to mention it. On the other hand I really", "school for mathematics with low GPA, but reluctant to bring", "site, and was shocked to see how frequent they were.", "there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) * ... Borderline questions: * [Career advice: How can", "just take a bit of a leave and try to", "[Applying to grad school for mathematics with low GPA, but", "mention their clinical depression always make me uncomfortable, because they", "[Is it possible to recover after a career setback such", "bring up the health issues that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If", "Google search for instances of the word 'depression' on this", "I sometimes don't have the hart to mention it. On", "on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) * [Is feeling lonely and uncomfortable in", "the prevalence of clinical depression amongst academics is higher than", "a community that does that. So I'm interested in your", "does our site somehow attract depressed peoples? Despite what some", "higher than usual. I'm ready to change my mind when", "of powerlessness on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643) * [Is feeling lonely and", "on random internet posts to handle serious nervous issues and", "What is an \"appropriate\" level of angst to go through", "depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) * [How to overcome feeling that published articles lack", "we need a tag for it? --- List of question", "mentioning depression (I stopped after 2 pages of search results)", "recover after a career setback such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) * [Should", "Explicit mention of clinical depression: * [What do I do", "to recover after a career setback such as this?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10381/10643) ", "a tag for it? --- List of question mentioning depression", " ... Borderline questions: * [Career advice: How can I", "do specific things in terms of moderation, or do we", "in my (foreign) country of study a valid reason to", "fault)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/7293/10643) * [Is it possible to recover after a career", "a student who was unproductive due to clinical depression?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/37327/10643) ", "[If I have an academic dismissal from a school should", "the word 'depression' on this site, and was shocked to", "back there?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18082/10643) ... Borderline questions: * [Career advice: How", "[How to cope with feelings of powerlessness on a PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/38217/10643)", "this site, and was shocked to see how frequent they", "to be a part of a community that does that.", "GPA, but reluctant to bring up the health issues that", "... Borderline questions: * [Career advice: How can I move", "stop working with a student who was unproductive due to", "6 or just take a bit of a leave and", "[Should I leave my PhD in year 6 or just", "health issues that caused it](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/29085/10643) * [If I have an" ]
[ "self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is hard to see how", "my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is", "than a request for personal advice. Other sites in the", "It is hard to see how this is other than", "channel questions away from personal specificity towards more general interest.", "advice. Other sites in the network try hard to channel", "social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is hard to see how this is", "other than a request for personal advice. Other sites in", "hard to channel questions away from personal specificity towards more", "interest. Is that the intent here? If not, why not?", "Consider [Should I quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and", "workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is hard to see", "to channel questions away from personal specificity towards more general", "personal specificity towards more general interest. Is that the intent", "I quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life).", "for personal advice. Other sites in the network try hard", "specificity towards more general interest. Is that the intent here?", "towards more general interest. Is that the intent here? If", "request for personal advice. Other sites in the network try", "how this is other than a request for personal advice.", "sites in the network try hard to channel questions away", "more general interest. Is that the intent here? If not,", "life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is hard to see how this is other", "hard to see how this is other than a request", "personal advice. Other sites in the network try hard to", "quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It", "a request for personal advice. Other sites in the network", "try hard to channel questions away from personal specificity towards", "from personal specificity towards more general interest. Is that the", "general interest. Is that the intent here? If not, why", "see how this is other than a request for personal", "PhD - workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is hard", "network try hard to channel questions away from personal specificity", "is hard to see how this is other than a", "is other than a request for personal advice. Other sites", "away from personal specificity towards more general interest. Is that", "the network try hard to channel questions away from personal", "questions away from personal specificity towards more general interest. Is", "in the network try hard to channel questions away from", "- workload, self-esteem and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is hard to", "this is other than a request for personal advice. Other", "Other sites in the network try hard to channel questions", "[Should I quit my PhD - workload, self-esteem and social", "to see how this is other than a request for", "and social life](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/39017/should-i-quit-my-phd-workload-self-esteem-and-social-life). It is hard to see how this" ]
[ "display the design). The updates allow us to: * Have", "/ more beautiful design on retina displays * Fix layout", "to all of our sites in the future If you", "add new features to all of our sites in the", "of this site. You may have noticed some updates to", "future If you see any bugs please let us know.", "lately. The updates are part of a SE network-wide update", "update to a new base css framework (the code which", "Have sharper / more beautiful design on retina displays ", "design on retina displays Fix layout bugs * More", "If you see any bugs please let us know. Thanks!", "the designer at Stack Exchange who made the design of", "The updates are part of a SE network-wide update to", "the future If you see any bugs please let us", "features to all of our sites in the future If", "sharper / more beautiful design on retina displays * Fix", "of our sites in the future If you see any", "* More easily add new features to all of our", "of a SE network-wide update to a new base css", "I'm the designer at Stack Exchange who made the design", "which display the design). The updates allow us to: ", "network-wide update to a new base css framework (the code", "who made the design of this site. You may have", "new base css framework (the code which display the design).", "site. You may have noticed some updates to the design", "Stack Exchange who made the design of this site. You", "Fix layout bugs More easily add new features to", "code which display the design). The updates allow us to:", "the design of this site. You may have noticed some", "updates are part of a SE network-wide update to a", "is Stéphane and I'm the designer at Stack Exchange who", "base css framework (the code which display the design). The", "Stéphane and I'm the designer at Stack Exchange who made", "all of our sites in the future If you see", "design of this site. You may have noticed some updates", "designer at Stack Exchange who made the design of this", "made the design of this site. You may have noticed", "new features to all of our sites in the future", "are part of a SE network-wide update to a new", "retina displays * Fix layout bugs * More easily add", "The updates allow us to: * Have sharper / more", "Exchange who made the design of this site. You may", "sites in the future If you see any bugs please", "in the future If you see any bugs please let", "You may have noticed some updates to the design lately.", "layout bugs * More easily add new features to all", "displays * Fix layout bugs * More easily add new", "name is Stéphane and I'm the designer at Stack Exchange", "bugs * More easily add new features to all of", "allow us to: * Have sharper / more beautiful design", "this site. You may have noticed some updates to the", "noticed some updates to the design lately. The updates are", "some updates to the design lately. The updates are part", "* Have sharper / more beautiful design on retina displays", "updates to the design lately. The updates are part of", "part of a SE network-wide update to a new base", "the design lately. The updates are part of a SE", "to a new base css framework (the code which display", "on retina displays * Fix layout bugs * More easily", "our sites in the future If you see any bugs", "css framework (the code which display the design). The updates", "My name is Stéphane and I'm the designer at Stack", "may have noticed some updates to the design lately. The", "design). The updates allow us to: * Have sharper /", "framework (the code which display the design). The updates allow", "design lately. The updates are part of a SE network-wide", "at Stack Exchange who made the design of this site.", "more beautiful design on retina displays * Fix layout bugs", "to: * Have sharper / more beautiful design on retina", "the design). The updates allow us to: * Have sharper", "a new base css framework (the code which display the", "to the design lately. The updates are part of a", "SE network-wide update to a new base css framework (the", "and I'm the designer at Stack Exchange who made the", "* Fix layout bugs * More easily add new features", "(the code which display the design). The updates allow us", "us to: * Have sharper / more beautiful design on", "More easily add new features to all of our sites", "beautiful design on retina displays * Fix layout bugs ", "updates allow us to: Have sharper / more beautiful", "easily add new features to all of our sites in", "have noticed some updates to the design lately. The updates", "a SE network-wide update to a new base css framework" ]
[ "of views, very few of which will be academics. Across", "being here, where it will be seen by hundreds of", "here, where it will be seen by hundreds of academics,", "I have an account there. But instead of being here,", "of academics, and get thousands of views, it's been migrated", "was migrated to Open Data. That's annoying. If I'd wanted", "gets migrated if it's not a good fit here. So", "there, I'd have asked it there myself. I have an", "views, very few of which will be academics. Across the", "fit elsewhere. It only gets migrated if it's not a", "But instead of being here, where it will be seen", "be seen by hundreds of academics, and get thousands of", "annoying. If I'd wanted it there, I'd have asked it", "only gets migrated if it's not a good fit here.", "That's annoying. If I'd wanted it there, I'd have asked", "beta site where it will get dozens of views, very", "Exchange, a question doesn't get migrated just because it's a", "will be academics. Across the whole Stack Exchange, a question", "site where it will get dozens of views, very few", "few of which will be academics. Across the whole Stack", "If I'd wanted it there, I'd have asked it there", "by hundreds of academics, and get thousands of views, it's", "to a quiet beta site where it will get dozens", "there. But instead of being here, where it will be", "migrated to a quiet beta site where it will get", "where it will get dozens of views, very few of", "DOIs for time series](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/40634/how-are-dois-managed-for-ongoing-time-series) was migrated to Open Data. That's", "it will get dozens of views, very few of which", "it's been migrated to a quiet beta site where it", "here. So why was this question not considered a good", "academics, and get thousands of views, it's been migrated to", "Data. That's annoying. If I'd wanted it there, I'd have", "whole Stack Exchange, a question doesn't get migrated just because", "get migrated just because it's a good fit elsewhere. It", "So why was this question not considered a good fit", "migrated to Open Data. That's annoying. If I'd wanted it", "will get dozens of views, very few of which will", "an account there. But instead of being here, where it", "It only gets migrated if it's not a good fit", "why was this question not considered a good fit here?", "Stack Exchange, a question doesn't get migrated just because it's", "to Open Data. That's annoying. If I'd wanted it there,", "not a good fit here. So why was this question", "be academics. Across the whole Stack Exchange, a question doesn't", "a good fit elsewhere. It only gets migrated if it's", "seen by hundreds of academics, and get thousands of views,", "a quiet beta site where it will get dozens of", "the whole Stack Exchange, a question doesn't get migrated just", "elsewhere. It only gets migrated if it's not a good", "of views, it's been migrated to a quiet beta site", "if it's not a good fit here. So why was", "a good fit here. So why was this question not", "of which will be academics. Across the whole Stack Exchange,", "wanted it there, I'd have asked it there myself. I", "Across the whole Stack Exchange, a question doesn't get migrated", "hundreds of academics, and get thousands of views, it's been", "very few of which will be academics. Across the whole", "get dozens of views, very few of which will be", "asked it there myself. I have an account there. But", "it's a good fit elsewhere. It only gets migrated if", "for time series](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/40634/how-are-dois-managed-for-ongoing-time-series) was migrated to Open Data. That's annoying.", "good fit elsewhere. It only gets migrated if it's not", "Open Data. That's annoying. If I'd wanted it there, I'd", "migrated just because it's a good fit elsewhere. It only", "fit here. So why was this question not considered a", "will be seen by hundreds of academics, and get thousands", "myself. I have an account there. But instead of being", "where it will be seen by hundreds of academics, and", "because it's a good fit elsewhere. It only gets migrated", "which will be academics. Across the whole Stack Exchange, a", "there myself. I have an account there. But instead of", "of being here, where it will be seen by hundreds", "it there myself. I have an account there. But instead", "quiet beta site where it will get dozens of views,", "migrated if it's not a good fit here. So why", "My [question on DOIs for time series](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/40634/how-are-dois-managed-for-ongoing-time-series) was migrated to", "I'd wanted it there, I'd have asked it there myself.", "on DOIs for time series](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/40634/how-are-dois-managed-for-ongoing-time-series) was migrated to Open Data.", "been migrated to a quiet beta site where it will", "account there. But instead of being here, where it will", "dozens of views, very few of which will be academics.", "it will be seen by hundreds of academics, and get", "I'd have asked it there myself. I have an account", "views, it's been migrated to a quiet beta site where", "get thousands of views, it's been migrated to a quiet", "and get thousands of views, it's been migrated to a", "question doesn't get migrated just because it's a good fit", "series](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/40634/how-are-dois-managed-for-ongoing-time-series) was migrated to Open Data. That's annoying. If I'd", "doesn't get migrated just because it's a good fit elsewhere.", "a question doesn't get migrated just because it's a good", "good fit here. So why was this question not considered", "time series](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/40634/how-are-dois-managed-for-ongoing-time-series) was migrated to Open Data. That's annoying. If", "instead of being here, where it will be seen by", "[question on DOIs for time series](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/40634/how-are-dois-managed-for-ongoing-time-series) was migrated to Open", "academics. Across the whole Stack Exchange, a question doesn't get", "have asked it there myself. I have an account there.", "thousands of views, it's been migrated to a quiet beta", "have an account there. But instead of being here, where", "it there, I'd have asked it there myself. I have", "it's not a good fit here. So why was this", "just because it's a good fit elsewhere. It only gets" ]
[ "formating a particular number and not about statistics itself. As", "surprised that we closed <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> It seems to be asking", "[APA style for program used in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should", "particular number and not about statistics itself. As a formating", "student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text listing style - how to use?", "list: [APA style for program used in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How", "to be asking about formating a particular number and not", "statistics itself. As a formating question it seems similar in", "not about statistics itself. As a formating question it seems", "similar in nature to this non exhaustive list: [APA style", "nature to this non exhaustive list: [APA style for program", "style for program used in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should I", "that we closed <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> It seems to be asking about", "study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should I cite a screenshot in APA style", "this non exhaustive list: [APA style for program used in", "As a formating question it seems similar in nature to", "in APA style for my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text listing", "question it seems similar in nature to this non exhaustive", "in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should I cite a screenshot in", "itself. As a formating question it seems similar in nature", "program used in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should I cite a", "about statistics itself. As a formating question it seems similar", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> It seems to be asking about formating a particular", "about formating a particular number and not about statistics itself.", "in nature to this non exhaustive list: [APA style for", "a particular number and not about statistics itself. As a", "for my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text listing style - how", "and not about statistics itself. As a formating question it", "non exhaustive list: [APA style for program used in a", "paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text listing style - how to use? Any", "used in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should I cite a screenshot", "a formating question it seems similar in nature to this", "style for my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text listing style -", "we closed <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> It seems to be asking about formating", "my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text listing style - how to", "formating question it seems similar in nature to this non", "I cite a screenshot in APA style for my student", "to this non exhaustive list: [APA style for program used", "it seems similar in nature to this non exhaustive list:", "a screenshot in APA style for my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In", "for program used in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should I cite", "[In text listing style - how to use? Any downsides?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12814/in-text-listing-style-how-to-use-any-downsides)", "seems similar in nature to this non exhaustive list: [APA", "should I cite a screenshot in APA style for my", "cite a screenshot in APA style for my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper)", "seems to be asking about formating a particular number and", "I was surprised that we closed <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> It seems to", "APA style for my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text listing style", "closed <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> It seems to be asking about formating a", "be asking about formating a particular number and not about", "was surprised that we closed <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> It seems to be", "asking about formating a particular number and not about statistics", "exhaustive list: [APA style for program used in a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study)", "number and not about statistics itself. As a formating question", "a study](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/8090/apa-style-for-program-used-in-a-study) [How should I cite a screenshot in APA", "screenshot in APA style for my student paper?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32797/how-should-i-cite-a-screenshot-in-apa-style-for-my-student-paper) [In text", "It seems to be asking about formating a particular number", "[How should I cite a screenshot in APA style for" ]
[ "want to express that they are thankful to the people", "the times, I edit such sentences because I do not", "greeting sentences like `thank you for your attention.` or `any", "their questions; or they appreciate any comments or solutions and", "and answers which are posted to their questions. Most of", "the users want to express that they are thankful to", "such sentences because I do not find them really helpful,", "comments or solutions and answers which are posted to their", "or it is good to have them in the body", "answers which are posted to their questions. Most of the", "by which the users want to express that they are", "I do not find them really helpful, relevant or on-topic", "edit such sentences because I do not find them really", "it is good to have them in the body of", "questions. Most of the times, I edit such sentences because", "is appreciated.` or other sentences like these by which the", "which the users want to express that they are thankful", "for your attention.` or `any advice is appreciated.` or other", "some greeting sentences like `thank you for your attention.` or", "you for your attention.` or `any advice is appreciated.` or", "users write some greeting sentences like `thank you for your", "like these by which the users want to express that", "should they really be edited or it is good to", "`any advice is appreciated.` or other sentences like these by", "questions; or they appreciate any comments or solutions and answers", "because I do not find them really helpful, relevant or", "any comments or solutions and answers which are posted to", "advice is appreciated.` or other sentences like these by which", "be edited or it is good to have them in", "that they are thankful to the people who read and", "or other sentences like these by which the users want", "appreciated.` or other sentences like these by which the users", "find them really helpful, relevant or on-topic to the questions'", "appreciate any comments or solutions and answers which are posted", "they really be edited or it is good to have", "do not find them really helpful, relevant or on-topic to", "are posted to their questions. Most of the times, I", "are thankful to the people who read and give advices", "to the people who read and give advices on their", "they appreciate any comments or solutions and answers which are", "advices on their questions; or they appreciate any comments or", "to their questions. Most of the times, I edit such", "read and give advices on their questions; or they appreciate", "sentences like these by which the users want to express", "posted to their questions. Most of the times, I edit", "on-topic to the questions' text. But, should they really be", "of the times, I edit such sentences because I do", "write some greeting sentences like `thank you for your attention.`", "times, I edit such sentences because I do not find", "them really helpful, relevant or on-topic to the questions' text.", "is good to have them in the body of the", "helpful, relevant or on-topic to the questions' text. But, should", "relevant or on-topic to the questions' text. But, should they", "express that they are thankful to the people who read", "or they appreciate any comments or solutions and answers which", "your attention.` or `any advice is appreciated.` or other sentences", "text. But, should they really be edited or it is", "the people who read and give advices on their questions;", "really helpful, relevant or on-topic to the questions' text. But,", "some questions, users write some greeting sentences like `thank you", "`thank you for your attention.` or `any advice is appreciated.`", "or `any advice is appreciated.` or other sentences like these", "thankful to the people who read and give advices on", "to the questions' text. But, should they really be edited", "solutions and answers which are posted to their questions. Most", "and give advices on their questions; or they appreciate any", "on their questions; or they appreciate any comments or solutions", "sentences like `thank you for your attention.` or `any advice", "not find them really helpful, relevant or on-topic to the", "questions, users write some greeting sentences like `thank you for", "questions' text. But, should they really be edited or it", "or solutions and answers which are posted to their questions.", "But, should they really be edited or it is good", "or on-topic to the questions' text. But, should they really", "who read and give advices on their questions; or they", "I edit such sentences because I do not find them", "they are thankful to the people who read and give", "which are posted to their questions. Most of the times,", "to express that they are thankful to the people who", "other sentences like these by which the users want to", "edited or it is good to have them in the", "sentences because I do not find them really helpful, relevant", "these by which the users want to express that they", "give advices on their questions; or they appreciate any comments", "really be edited or it is good to have them", "good to have them in the body of the questions?", "the questions' text. But, should they really be edited or", "users want to express that they are thankful to the", "people who read and give advices on their questions; or", "In some questions, users write some greeting sentences like `thank", "attention.` or `any advice is appreciated.` or other sentences like", "Most of the times, I edit such sentences because I", "like `thank you for your attention.` or `any advice is", "their questions. Most of the times, I edit such sentences" ]
[ "some users doing this on our site on their profiles.", "User's Profile about me section. I have seen some users", "profiles. Is it ethical to do such thing? Doesn't it", "conflict Academia's website policies? related question, but not a duplicate:", "no link in the header of the main site to", "their names with a link in my User's Profile about", "Is it ethical to do such thing? Doesn't it conflict", "Academia's website policies? related question, but not a duplicate: [Why", "[Why no link in the header of the main site", "doing this on our site on their profiles. Is it", "to do such thing? Doesn't it conflict Academia's website policies?", "it ethical to do such thing? Doesn't it conflict Academia's", "thing? Doesn't it conflict Academia's website policies? related question, but", "site on their profiles. Is it ethical to do such", "a duplicate: [Why no link in the header of the", "me section. I have seen some users doing this on", "link in the header of the main site to our", "really low user participation. I want to promote those websites", "promote those websites by mentioning their names with a link", "Doesn't it conflict Academia's website policies? related question, but not", "mentioning their names with a link in my User's Profile", "question, but not a duplicate: [Why no link in the", "their profiles. Is it ethical to do such thing? Doesn't", "not a duplicate: [Why no link in the header of", "but not a duplicate: [Why no link in the header", "one or two other Stack Exchange websites but they have", "but they have really low user participation. I want to", "this on our site on their profiles. Is it ethical", "those websites by mentioning their names with a link in", "Stack Exchange websites but they have really low user participation.", "I have seen some users doing this on our site", "users doing this on our site on their profiles. Is", "I want to promote those websites by mentioning their names", "names with a link in my User's Profile about me", "ethical to do such thing? Doesn't it conflict Academia's website", "they have really low user participation. I want to promote", "link in my User's Profile about me section. I have", "our site on their profiles. Is it ethical to do", "websites by mentioning their names with a link in my", "duplicate: [Why no link in the header of the main", "user participation. I want to promote those websites by mentioning", "websites but they have really low user participation. I want", "Profile about me section. I have seen some users doing", "such thing? Doesn't it conflict Academia's website policies? related question,", "by mentioning their names with a link in my User's", "my User's Profile about me section. I have seen some", "have really low user participation. I want to promote those", "on their profiles. Is it ethical to do such thing?", "have seen some users doing this on our site on", "related question, but not a duplicate: [Why no link in", "in the header of the main site to our 'About'", "section. I have seen some users doing this on our", "to promote those websites by mentioning their names with a", "two other Stack Exchange websites but they have really low", "a link in my User's Profile about me section. I", "it conflict Academia's website policies? related question, but not a", "the header of the main site to our 'About' page?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/350/why-no-link-in-the-header-of-the-main-site-to-our-about-page)", "website policies? related question, but not a duplicate: [Why no", "do such thing? Doesn't it conflict Academia's website policies? related", "other Stack Exchange websites but they have really low user", "low user participation. I want to promote those websites by", "like one or two other Stack Exchange websites but they", "on our site on their profiles. Is it ethical to", "with a link in my User's Profile about me section.", "in my User's Profile about me section. I have seen", "seen some users doing this on our site on their", "policies? related question, but not a duplicate: [Why no link", "or two other Stack Exchange websites but they have really", "about me section. I have seen some users doing this", "participation. I want to promote those websites by mentioning their", "want to promote those websites by mentioning their names with", "Exchange websites but they have really low user participation. I", "I like one or two other Stack Exchange websites but" ]
[ "I can easily understand that we do not have so", "rich wikis for the tags on our meta website. Should", "Should we review the tags, their wikis, excerpts and descriptions", "them to other meta websites at Stack Exchange such as", "and their wikis and excerpts on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/)", "tags, their wikis, excerpts and descriptions on the meta site", "excerpts and descriptions on the meta site of Academia? If", "[meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack Exchange and I compare", "do not have so rich wikis for the tags on", "descriptions on the meta site of Academia? If yes, what", "easily understand that we do not have so rich wikis", "of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack Exchange and I compare them to", "can easily understand that we do not have so rich", "review the tags, their wikis, excerpts and descriptions on the", "[meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc., I can easily understand that we do", "as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc., I can easily understand that", "our meta website. Should we review the tags, their wikis,", "at the [tags](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and their wikis and excerpts on [meta", "meta website. Should we review the tags, their wikis, excerpts", "compare them to other meta websites at Stack Exchange such", "and descriptions on the meta site of Academia? If yes,", "we do not have so rich wikis for the tags", "have so rich wikis for the tags on our meta", "wikis for the tags on our meta website. Should we", "Stack Exchange such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc., I can", "other meta websites at Stack Exchange such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags)", "I compare them to other meta websites at Stack Exchange", "their wikis and excerpts on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on", "understand that we do not have so rich wikis for", "[meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc., I can easily understand that we", "on Stack Exchange and I compare them to other meta", "for the tags on our meta website. Should we review", "and excerpts on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack Exchange", "on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack Exchange and I", "etc., I can easily understand that we do not have", "their wikis, excerpts and descriptions on the meta site of", "wikis and excerpts on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack", "[Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack Exchange and I compare them to other", "websites at Stack Exchange such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc.,", "I look at the [tags](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and their wikis and excerpts", "tags on our meta website. Should we review the tags,", "excerpts on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack Exchange and", "that we do not have so rich wikis for the", "on the meta site of Academia? If yes, what policy", "site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/) on Stack Exchange and I compare them", "Stack Exchange and I compare them to other meta websites", "such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc., I can easily understand", "on our meta website. Should we review the tags, their", "so rich wikis for the tags on our meta website.", "the tags on our meta website. Should we review the", "look at the [tags](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and their wikis and excerpts on", "at Stack Exchange such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc., I", "not have so rich wikis for the tags on our", "the tags, their wikis, excerpts and descriptions on the meta", "the [tags](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and their wikis and excerpts on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/)", "wikis, excerpts and descriptions on the meta site of Academia?", "the meta site of Academia? If yes, what policy should", "of Academia? If yes, what policy should this review have?", "and I compare them to other meta websites at Stack", "to other meta websites at Stack Exchange such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags),", "[tags](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and their wikis and excerpts on [meta site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/) of", "Exchange and I compare them to other meta websites at", "and etc., I can easily understand that we do not", "When I look at the [tags](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and their wikis and", "we review the tags, their wikis, excerpts and descriptions on", "meta websites at Stack Exchange such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and", "site of Academia? If yes, what policy should this review", "website. Should we review the tags, their wikis, excerpts and", "Exchange such as [meta.mathematics](https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/tags), [meta.tex](https://tex.meta.stackexchange.com/tags) and etc., I can easily", "meta site of Academia? If yes, what policy should this" ]
[ "answers if you feel this suggestion is a bad etiquette", "we leave them and do not delete those comments. This", "or improve their answers. Simply welcome posted comments are also", "really like this action as this warms the new users'", "posted when we want to inform new users that they", "website. However, I can see that welcome comments are rarely", "safe to stay in a friendly environment website. However, I", "a friendly environment website. However, I can see that welcome", "this action as this warms the new users' heart and", "Simply welcome posted comments are also in the danger of", "their questions or improve their answers. Simply welcome posted comments", "new users by posting a simple Welcome to Academia website!", "to edit their questions or improve their answers. Simply welcome", "see that welcome comments are rarely found on our website.", "website. They are only posted when we want to inform", "only posted when we want to inform new users that", "answers. Simply welcome posted comments are also in the danger", "too chatty comment. By posting this question, I want to", "They are only posted when we want to inform new", "can see that welcome comments are rarely found on our", "want to inform new users that they have to edit", "with longer period of membership welcome newer users. I really", "feel safe to stay in a friendly environment website. However,", "flagged and deleted as a too chatty comment. By posting", "welcome new users by posting a simple *Welcome to Academia", "other Stack Exchange sites (mostly on [TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I have", "seen that the users with longer period of membership welcome", "longer period of membership welcome newer users. I really like", "comments are rarely found on our website. They are only", "we want to inform new users that they have to", "This will help our community be more friendly and have", "welcome posted comments are also in the danger of being", "edit their questions or improve their answers. Simply welcome posted", "of being flagged and deleted as a too chatty* comment.", "friendly and have nicer look. Please post your answers if", "them and do not delete those comments. This will help", "to welcome new users by posting a simple *Welcome to", "welcome newer users. I really like this action as this", "have nicer look. Please post your answers if you feel", "that they have to edit their questions or improve their", "are only posted when we want to inform new users", "look. Please post your answers if you feel this suggestion", "in the danger of being flagged and deleted as a", "newer users. I really like this action as this warms", "in a friendly environment website. However, I can see that", "to feel safe to stay in a friendly environment website.", "being flagged and deleted as a too chatty* comment. By", "as a too chatty comment. By posting this question, I", "them to feel safe to stay in a friendly environment", "that the users with longer period of membership welcome newer", "is a bad etiquette for Academia, or how we can", "to Academia website!** comment and we leave them and do", "welcome comments are rarely found on our website. They are", "I really like this action as this warms the new", "for Academia, or how we can build a more friendly", "delete those comments. This will help our community be more", "as this warms the new users' heart and helps them", "users. I really like this action as this warms the", "not delete those comments. This will help our community be", "action as this warms the new users' heart and helps", "of membership welcome newer users. I really like this action", "help our community be more friendly and have nicer look.", "the new users' heart and helps them to feel safe", "warms the new users' heart and helps them to feel", "comment and we leave them and do not delete those", "new users' heart and helps them to feel safe to", "rarely found on our website. They are only posted when", "and deleted as a too chatty comment. By posting this", "our community be more friendly and have nicer look. Please", "heart and helps them to feel safe to stay in", "posting a simple Welcome to Academia website! comment and we", "will help our community be more friendly and have nicer", "and helps them to feel safe to stay in a", "By posting this question, I want to ask users to", "ask users to welcome new users by posting a simple", "their answers. Simply welcome posted comments are also in the", "your answers if you feel this suggestion is a bad", "that welcome comments are rarely found on our website. They", "deleted as a too chatty comment. By posting this question,", "they have to edit their questions or improve their answers.", "chatty* comment. By posting this question, I want to ask", "website! comment and we leave them and do not delete", "post your answers if you feel this suggestion is a", "Welcome to Academia website! comment and we leave them and", "a simple Welcome to Academia website! comment and we leave", "do not delete those comments. This will help our community", "and have nicer look. Please post your answers if you", "nicer look. Please post your answers if you feel this", "I can see that welcome comments are rarely found on", "users by posting a simple Welcome to Academia website! comment", "I have seen that the users with longer period of", "you feel this suggestion is a bad etiquette for Academia,", "new users that they have to edit their questions or", "have seen that the users with longer period of membership", "(mostly on [TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I have seen that the users", "and do not delete those comments. This will help our", "Please post your answers if you feel this suggestion is", "if you feel this suggestion is a bad etiquette for", "users that they have to edit their questions or improve", "and we leave them and do not delete those comments.", "Stack Exchange sites (mostly on [TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I have seen", "are rarely found on our website. They are only posted", "users to welcome new users by posting a simple Welcome", "on [TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I have seen that the users with", "posting this question, I want to ask users to welcome", "Exchange sites (mostly on [TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I have seen that", "the danger of being flagged and deleted as a too", "questions or improve their answers. Simply welcome posted comments are", "website), I have seen that the users with longer period", "danger of being flagged and deleted as a too chatty", "comments. This will help our community be more friendly and", "a too chatty* comment. By posting this question, I want", "sites (mostly on [TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I have seen that the", "to ask users to welcome new users by posting a", "inform new users that they have to edit their questions", "also in the danger of being flagged and deleted as", "the users with longer period of membership welcome newer users.", "like this action as this warms the new users' heart", "bad etiquette for Academia, or how we can build a", "this suggestion is a bad etiquette for Academia, or how", "environment website. However, I can see that welcome comments are", "I want to ask users to welcome new users by", "In other Stack Exchange sites (mostly on [TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I", "this question, I want to ask users to welcome new", "[TeX](https://tex.stackexchange.com/) website), I have seen that the users with longer", "want to ask users to welcome new users by posting", "Academia, or how we can build a more friendly community.", "on our website. They are only posted when we want", "question, I want to ask users to welcome new users", "users with longer period of membership welcome newer users. I", "community be more friendly and have nicer look. Please post", "to inform new users that they have to edit their", "our website. They are only posted when we want to", "Academia website! comment and we leave them and do not", "comments are also in the danger of being flagged and", "by posting a simple Welcome to Academia website! comment and", "posted comments are also in the danger of being flagged", "simple Welcome to Academia website!** comment and we leave them", "improve their answers. Simply welcome posted comments are also in", "when we want to inform new users that they have", "this warms the new users' heart and helps them to", "are also in the danger of being flagged and deleted", "membership welcome newer users. I really like this action as", "comment. By posting this question, I want to ask users", "users' heart and helps them to feel safe to stay", "more friendly and have nicer look. Please post your answers", "However, I can see that welcome comments are rarely found", "friendly environment website. However, I can see that welcome comments", "found on our website. They are only posted when we", "stay in a friendly environment website. However, I can see", "suggestion is a bad etiquette for Academia, or how we", "period of membership welcome newer users. I really like this", "helps them to feel safe to stay in a friendly", "those comments. This will help our community be more friendly", "have to edit their questions or improve their answers. Simply", "be more friendly and have nicer look. Please post your", "feel this suggestion is a bad etiquette for Academia, or", "a bad etiquette for Academia, or how we can build", "to stay in a friendly environment website. However, I can", "etiquette for Academia, or how we can build a more", "leave them and do not delete those comments. This will" ]
[ "used in psychology journals, but is also used in other", "CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement it. We have quite a few [questions", "style. APA Style is pretty common. It is pretty much", "for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10963/4140)) unless there are objections.", "to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose creating a new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style", "Style is pretty common. It is pretty much the only", "in its sixth edition, documenting (among other things) the [APA", "questions (except for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10963/4140)) unless there", "on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement it. We have quite a few", "pretty common. It is pretty much the only style used", "implement it. We have quite a few [questions related to", "It is pretty much the only style used in psychology", "There are [BibTeX packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement it. We", "and referencing style. APA Style is pretty common. It is", "[BibTeX packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement it. We have quite", "few [questions related to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose creating a", "are [BibTeX packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement it. We have", "also used in other fields. There are [BibTeX packages on", "APA Style is pretty common. It is pretty much the", "Manual, now in its sixth edition, documenting (among other things)", "the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation and referencing style. APA Style", "tagged 'apa-style'\") and retagging these questions (except for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140)", "Psychological Association (APA) publishes its Publication Manual, now in its", "(APA) publishes its Publication Manual, now in its sixth edition,", "only style used in psychology journals, but is also used", "other fields. There are [BibTeX packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement", "I propose creating a new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions tagged", "but is also used in other fields. There are [BibTeX", "much the only style used in psychology journals, but is", "Association (APA) publishes its Publication Manual, now in its sixth", "now in its sixth edition, documenting (among other things) the", "quite a few [questions related to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose", "retagging these questions (except for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10963/4140))", "is pretty much the only style used in psychology journals,", "[APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation and referencing style. APA Style is", "questions tagged 'apa-style'\") and retagging these questions (except for [this", "in psychology journals, but is also used in other fields.", "its Publication Manual, now in its sixth edition, documenting (among", "common. It is pretty much the only style used in", "these questions (except for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10963/4140)) unless", "its sixth edition, documenting (among other things) the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org),", "other things) the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation and referencing style.", "[questions related to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose creating a new", "referencing style. APA Style is pretty common. It is pretty", "[this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10963/4140)) unless there are objections. Thoughts?", "'apa-style'\") and retagging these questions (except for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and", "(among other things) the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation and referencing", "edition, documenting (among other things) the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation", "style used in psychology journals, but is also used in", "packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement it. We have quite a", "it. We have quite a few [questions related to APA", "documenting (among other things) the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation and", "things) the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation and referencing style. APA", "propose creating a new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions tagged 'apa-style'\")", "[apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions tagged 'apa-style'\") and retagging these questions (except", "citation and referencing style. APA Style is pretty common. It", "a few [questions related to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose creating", "related to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose creating a new tag", "and retagging these questions (except for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and [this", "style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose creating a new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions", "in other fields. There are [BibTeX packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to", "have quite a few [questions related to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I", "publishes its Publication Manual, now in its sixth edition, documenting", "fields. There are [BibTeX packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201) to implement it.", "The American Psychological Association (APA) publishes its Publication Manual, now", "\"show questions tagged 'apa-style'\") and retagging these questions (except for", "to implement it. We have quite a few [questions related", "journals, but is also used in other fields. There are", "pretty much the only style used in psychology journals, but", "We have quite a few [questions related to APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion).", "a citation and referencing style. APA Style is pretty common.", "creating a new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions tagged 'apa-style'\") and", "Publication Manual, now in its sixth edition, documenting (among other", "American Psychological Association (APA) publishes its Publication Manual*, now in", "is pretty common. It is pretty much the only style", "the only style used in psychology journals, but is also", "new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions tagged 'apa-style'\") and retagging these", "a new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions tagged 'apa-style'\") and retagging", "APA style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=%22APA+Style%22+is%3Aquestion). I propose creating a new tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show", "is also used in other fields. There are [BibTeX packages", "sixth edition, documenting (among other things) the [APA Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a", "Style](http://www.apastyle.org), a citation and referencing style. APA Style is pretty", "used in other fields. There are [BibTeX packages on CRAN](https://tex.stackexchange.com/q/2628/22201)", "(except for [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24377/4140) and [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10963/4140)) unless there are", "psychology journals, but is also used in other fields. There", "tag [apa-style](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/apa-style \"show questions tagged 'apa-style'\") and retagging these questions" ]
[ "meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why a certain question was not", "the OP anyway, so I don't know that a community", "> > However, please do not ask questions about >", "other \"shopping\" questions are not? If so, can someone explain", "upvotes, considering the specificity and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > However,", "whereas other \"shopping\" questions are not? If so, can someone", "> > Possibly a lot of the votes come from", "come from supporting an open access sentiment, and/or maybe we", "not super-conclusive (conclusion: it's borderline) and the question in question", "please do not ask questions about > > > ", "sentiment, and/or maybe we have a lot of people on", "on this site in theoretical biology. Are questions like this", " Suggestions or recommendations for a university, journal, or research", "topic (a \"shopping question\") > * ... > > >", "acceptable?) Note: there was a [similar meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about", "maybe we have a lot of people on this site", "recommendations for a university, journal, or research topic (a \"shopping", "of people on this site in theoretical biology. Are questions", "this site in theoretical biology. Are questions like this considered", "in question was since deleted by the OP anyway, so", "so I don't know that a community consensus was reached.", "surprised about the large number of upvotes, considering the specificity", "instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > However, please do not ask questions about", "was a [similar meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why a certain", "questions about > > > * ... > * Suggestions", "question asking for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was surprised about the", "acceptable, whereas other \"shopping\" questions are not? If so, can", "here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why a certain question was not closed. However,", "recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was surprised about the large number of upvotes,", "is not super-conclusive (conclusion: it's borderline) and the question in", "number of upvotes, considering the specificity and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) >", "lot of the votes come from supporting an open access", "a reason for a question being acceptable?) Note: there was", "across [this question asking for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was surprised", "a [similar meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why a certain question", "was since deleted by the OP anyway, so I don't", "the question in question was since deleted by the OP", "this considered acceptable, whereas other \"shopping\" questions are not? If", "> > > Possibly a lot of the votes come", "we have a lot of people on this site in", "I just happened to come across [this question asking for", "a question being acceptable?) Note: there was a [similar meta", "journal, or research topic (a \"shopping question\") > * ...", "journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was surprised about the large number of", "of upvotes, considering the specificity and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > >", "the sole answer is not super-conclusive (conclusion: it's borderline) and", "If so, can someone explain what the difference is? (Can", "However, the sole answer is not super-conclusive (conclusion: it's borderline)", "of the votes come from supporting an open access sentiment,", "for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was surprised about the large number", "> Possibly a lot of the votes come from supporting", "or recommendations for a university, journal, or research topic (a", "like this considered acceptable, whereas other \"shopping\" questions are not?", "was surprised about the large number of upvotes, considering the", "questions like this considered acceptable, whereas other \"shopping\" questions are", "someone explain what the difference is? (Can having many upvotes", "ask questions about > > > * ... > ", "research topic (a \"shopping question\") > ... > >", "having many upvotes be a reason for a question being", "about > > > * ... > * Suggestions or", "an open access sentiment, and/or maybe we have a lot", "being acceptable?) Note: there was a [similar meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607)", "from supporting an open access sentiment, and/or maybe we have", "upvotes be a reason for a question being acceptable?) Note:", "access sentiment, and/or maybe we have a lot of people", "sole answer is not super-conclusive (conclusion: it's borderline) and the", "considered acceptable, whereas other \"shopping\" questions are not? If so,", "certain question was not closed. However, the sole answer is", "> * ... > > > Possibly a lot of", "[these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > However, please do not ask questions", "about the large number of upvotes, considering the specificity and", "reason for a question being acceptable?) Note: there was a", "Suggestions or recommendations for a university, journal, or research topic", "question in question was since deleted by the OP anyway,", "have a lot of people on this site in theoretical", "the specificity and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > However, please do", "just happened to come across [this question asking for journal", "not ask questions about > > > * ... >", "[similar meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why a certain question was", "considering the specificity and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > However, please", "so, can someone explain what the difference is? (Can having", "the large number of upvotes, considering the specificity and [these", "what the difference is? (Can having many upvotes be a", "* ... > * Suggestions or recommendations for a university,", "do not ask questions about > > > * ...", "difference is? (Can having many upvotes be a reason for", "for a question being acceptable?) Note: there was a [similar", "borderline) and the question in question was since deleted by", "theoretical biology. Are questions like this considered acceptable, whereas other", "question was since deleted by the OP anyway, so I", "However, please do not ask questions about > > >", "people on this site in theoretical biology. Are questions like", "\"shopping\" questions are not? If so, can someone explain what", "lot of people on this site in theoretical biology. Are", "why a certain question was not closed. However, the sole", "and the question in question was since deleted by the", "... > > > Possibly a lot of the votes", "question was not closed. However, the sole answer is not", "(conclusion: it's borderline) and the question in question was since", "to come across [this question asking for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I", "Note: there was a [similar meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why", "asking for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was surprised about the large", "and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > However, please do not ask", "deleted by the OP anyway, so I don't know that", "the votes come from supporting an open access sentiment, and/or", "answer is not super-conclusive (conclusion: it's borderline) and the question", "are not? If so, can someone explain what the difference", "super-conclusive (conclusion: it's borderline) and the question in question was", "(a \"shopping question\") > * ... > > > Possibly", "votes come from supporting an open access sentiment, and/or maybe", "I was surprised about the large number of upvotes, considering", "open access sentiment, and/or maybe we have a lot of", "question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why a certain question was not closed.", "> > > * ... > * Suggestions or recommendations", "> * Suggestions or recommendations for a university, journal, or", "> However, please do not ask questions about > >", "a lot of people on this site in theoretical biology.", "a university, journal, or research topic (a \"shopping question\") >", "... > * Suggestions or recommendations for a university, journal,", "question\") > * ... > > > Possibly a lot", "is? (Can having many upvotes be a reason for a", "and/or maybe we have a lot of people on this", "happened to come across [this question asking for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607).", "since deleted by the OP anyway, so I don't know", "can someone explain what the difference is? (Can having many", "be a reason for a question being acceptable?) Note: there", "questions are not? If so, can someone explain what the", "> * ... > * Suggestions or recommendations for a", "supporting an open access sentiment, and/or maybe we have a", "question being acceptable?) Note: there was a [similar meta question", "not closed. However, the sole answer is not super-conclusive (conclusion:", "\"shopping question\") > * ... > > > Possibly a", "large number of upvotes, considering the specificity and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "for a university, journal, or research topic (a \"shopping question\")", "* ... > > > Possibly a lot of the", "it's borderline) and the question in question was since deleted", "closed. However, the sole answer is not super-conclusive (conclusion: it's", "specificity and [these instructions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > However, please do not", "[this question asking for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was surprised about", "a lot of the votes come from supporting an open", "the difference is? (Can having many upvotes be a reason", "university, journal, or research topic (a \"shopping question\") > ", "biology. Are questions like this considered acceptable, whereas other \"shopping\"", "there was a [similar meta question here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1566/19607) about why a", "or research topic (a \"shopping question\") > ... >", "about why a certain question was not closed. However, the", "by the OP anyway, so I don't know that a", "come across [this question asking for journal recommendations](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/47/19607). I was", "(Can having many upvotes be a reason for a question", "in theoretical biology. Are questions like this considered acceptable, whereas", "site in theoretical biology. Are questions like this considered acceptable,", "explain what the difference is? (Can having many upvotes be", "was not closed. However, the sole answer is not super-conclusive", "Possibly a lot of the votes come from supporting an", "OP anyway, so I don't know that a community consensus", "many upvotes be a reason for a question being acceptable?)", "not? If so, can someone explain what the difference is?", "anyway, so I don't know that a community consensus was", "> > * ... > * Suggestions or recommendations for", "a certain question was not closed. However, the sole answer", "Are questions like this considered acceptable, whereas other \"shopping\" questions" ]
[ "own university and alma mater have essentially sold my data", "a direct link to them. But back in the Real", "the OP to \"National Student Clearinghouse\" which is a non-profit", "OP to \"National Student Clearinghouse\" which is a non-profit that", "to \"National Student Clearinghouse\" which is a non-profit that handles", "university and alma mater have essentially sold my data to", "the Real World®, people do need to know about their", "went to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct answer (in part) is", "bit of a conflict because I'm not very happy that", "Student Clearinghouse\" which is a non-profit that handles most of", "find this a morally distasteful business model and I don't", "morally distasteful business model and I don't want to reward", "very happy that even my own university and alma mater", "in a bit of a conflict because I'm not very", "employers. I find this a morally distasteful business model and", "direct link to them. But back in the Real World®,", "most of these type of student degree verification services. I'm", "that their resume says they went to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The", "refer the OP to \"National Student Clearinghouse\" which is a", "NSC with a direct link to them. But back in", "I wrote an answer to this question concerning how to", "answer to this question concerning how to verify whether someone", "and alma mater have essentially sold my data to a", "to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct answer (in part) is to", "handles most of these type of student degree verification services.", "a non-profit that handles most of these type of student", "how to verify whether someone went to the college/university that", "this a morally distasteful business model and I don't want", "resells them to students and employers. I find this a", "students and employers. I find this a morally distasteful business", "don't want to reward NSC with a direct link to", "third-party which then resells them to students and employers. I", "in the Real World®, people do need to know about", "to verify whether someone went to the college/university that their", "answer (in part) is to refer the OP to \"National", "an answer to this question concerning how to verify whether", "\"National Student Clearinghouse\" which is a non-profit that handles most", "of a conflict because I'm not very happy that even", "is to refer the OP to \"National Student Clearinghouse\" which", "Real World®, people do need to know about their existence.", "The correct answer (in part) is to refer the OP", "is a non-profit that handles most of these type of", "I'm in a bit of a conflict because I'm not", "a conflict because I'm not very happy that even my", "degree verification services. I'm in a bit of a conflict", "But back in the Real World®, people do need to", "a third-party which then resells them to students and employers.", "distasteful business model and I don't want to reward NSC", "conflict because I'm not very happy that even my own", "services. I'm in a bit of a conflict because I'm", "this question concerning how to verify whether someone went to", "to a third-party which then resells them to students and", "they went to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct answer (in part)", "of student degree verification services. I'm in a bit of", "sold my data to a third-party which then resells them", "verification services. I'm in a bit of a conflict because", "I'm not very happy that even my own university and", "which then resells them to students and employers. I find", "college/university that their resume says they went to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836)", "to the college/university that their resume says they went to:", "that handles most of these type of student degree verification", "to them. But back in the Real World®, people do", "concerning how to verify whether someone went to the college/university", "(in part) is to refer the OP to \"National Student", "to reward NSC with a direct link to them. But", "[Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct answer (in part) is to refer", "data to a third-party which then resells them to students", "have essentially sold my data to a third-party which then", "I don't want to reward NSC with a direct link", "happy that even my own university and alma mater have", "student degree verification services. I'm in a bit of a", "I find this a morally distasteful business model and I", "not very happy that even my own university and alma", "of these type of student degree verification services. I'm in", "my own university and alma mater have essentially sold my", "business model and I don't want to reward NSC with", "because I'm not very happy that even my own university", "with a direct link to them. But back in the", "went to the college/university that their resume says they went", "even my own university and alma mater have essentially sold", "credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct answer (in part) is to refer the", "World®, people do need to know about their existence. Suggestions?", "want to reward NSC with a direct link to them.", "mater have essentially sold my data to a third-party which", "and employers. I find this a morally distasteful business model", "model and I don't want to reward NSC with a", "to students and employers. I find this a morally distasteful", "alma mater have essentially sold my data to a third-party", "link to them. But back in the Real World®, people", "which is a non-profit that handles most of these type", "and I don't want to reward NSC with a direct", "reward NSC with a direct link to them. But back", "to this question concerning how to verify whether someone went", "whether someone went to the college/university that their resume says", "Clearinghouse\" which is a non-profit that handles most of these", "my data to a third-party which then resells them to", "resume says they went to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct answer", "part) is to refer the OP to \"National Student Clearinghouse\"", "question concerning how to verify whether someone went to the", "non-profit that handles most of these type of student degree", "a bit of a conflict because I'm not very happy", "the college/university that their resume says they went to: [Fraudulent", "type of student degree verification services. I'm in a bit", "to refer the OP to \"National Student Clearinghouse\" which is", "that even my own university and alma mater have essentially", "says they went to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct answer (in", "someone went to the college/university that their resume says they", "their resume says they went to: [Fraudulent credentials](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/42835/fraudulent-credentials/42836?noredirect=1#comment95307_42836) The correct", "correct answer (in part) is to refer the OP to", "essentially sold my data to a third-party which then resells", "them to students and employers. I find this a morally", "back in the Real World®, people do need to know", "verify whether someone went to the college/university that their resume", "them. But back in the Real World®, people do need", "wrote an answer to this question concerning how to verify", "a morally distasteful business model and I don't want to", "then resells them to students and employers. I find this", "these type of student degree verification services. I'm in a" ]
[ "'retraction'\") for questions about withdrawing papers, books, etc. during their", "retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their title. 1. Making one of", "2. Having both tags on the site, but we can", "to its excerpt and wiki. Although I am so sorry", "> Ethics and logistics of withdrawing, refuting, or amending published", "have retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their", "current excerpt is more popular word and can be the", "such as a student withdrawing a PhD position during his", "submission or withdrawing an academic position such as admissions offers.", "vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag to be", "(Based on the search results presented above, I think that", "main tag's excerpt. (Based on the search results presented above,", "for questions about withdrawing papers, books, etc. during their review", "found that we have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\")", "tag with its current excerpt is more popular word and", "> However, after some hours, when I was reading the", "\"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag and have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show", "body and 7 questions have retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction", "a student withdrawing a PhD position during his admissions process,", "edit to its excerpt and wiki. Although I am so", "> > However, after some hours, when I was reading", "during postgraduate admissions. I did some searches in the questions", "was before without any edit to its excerpt and wiki.", "([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their title. 39 questions have retract ([18", "of withdrawing, refuting, or amending published > work. > >", "[retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag as it was before", "admissions offers. I suggested an excerpt for it which is", "synonym of it. 2. Having both tags on the site,", "withdrawal of books or papers from journals and > conferences", "the first option discussed above is a better choice for", "tag can be a synonym of it. 2. Having both", "manuscripts which are under review process or even questions about", "3. Delete the newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\")", "making a new tag without searching the tags' list carefully;", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 17 questions have withdraw ([15", "that we have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag", "to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") for questions about", "student withdrawing a PhD position during his admissions process, and", "may cover questions which are only about retraction of published", "the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with its current", "title, the following results are accessible: 72 questions have withdraw", "it does worth that the community think about these two", "of these tags synonym of the other and edit the", "title. 1. Making one of these tags synonym of the", "excerpt and wiki. Although I am so sorry for making", "\"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag with similar scope. > >", "a PhD position during his admissions process, and to have", "for questions having these word in their body and title,", "can edit their excerpts to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged", "does worth that the community think about these two tags", "are under review process or even questions about withdrawing an", "be a synonym of it. 2. Having both tags on", "I am so sorry for making a new tag without", "process or even questions about withdrawing an academic position such", "academic position such as admissions offers. I suggested an excerpt", "([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their title. 1.", "can be the main tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged", "positions such as a student withdrawing a PhD position during", "it which is now approved: > > Questions about withdrawal", "be pinned to questions about withdrawing papers in the process", "\"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with aim to be pinned", "which are under review process or even questions about withdrawing", "[withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag to be deleted. In", "withdrawal during postgraduate admissions. I did some searches in the", "tagged 'retraction'\") tag seems a little vague to me, as", "> > The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag seems", "refuting, or amending published > work. > > > The", "retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their title.", "([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 17 questions have withdraw", "first option discussed above is a better choice for the", "17 questions have withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal))", "following results are accessible: 72 questions have withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion))", "of the other and edit the main tag's excerpt. (Based", "his admissions process, and to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged", "published > work. > > > The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions", "of published work, not withdrawing manuscripts which are under review", "questions have retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in", "above, I think that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\")", "questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag with similar scope. > > Ethics", "deleted. In my opinion, the first option discussed above is", "website for questions having these word in their body and", "questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag to be deleted. In my opinion,", "tagged 'retraction'\") tag can be a synonym of it. 2.", "retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body", "in their body and 7 questions have retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract))", "and not just vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\")", "think that it does worth that the community think about", "include these word. By searching the website for questions having", "a little vague to me, as it's scope may cover", "have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") for questions about withdrawing", "withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 17 questions have", "tags on the site, but we can edit their excerpts", "questions have withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in", "list, I found that we have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions", "searches in the questions which include these word. By searching", "withdrawing papers, books, etc. during their review and publication process.", "even questions about withdrawing an academic position such as withdrawal", "presented above, I think that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged", "process to academic > programmes. > > > However, after", "By searching the website for questions having these word in", "word. By searching the website for questions having these word", "can be a synonym of it. 2. Having both tags", "Although I am so sorry for making a new tag", "work, not withdrawing manuscripts which are under review process or", "which are only about retraction of published work, not withdrawing", "and > conferences or withdrawal during admissions process to academic", "and retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their title. 1. Making one", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 7 questions have retract ([4", "have retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their", "newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag and have", "of books or papers from journals and > conferences or", "Delete the newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag", "39 questions have retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion))", "that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with its", "for questions which are about withdrawing academic positions such as", "any edit to its excerpt and wiki. Although I am", "about these two tags with similar scopes and not just", "the process of their submission or withdrawing an academic position", "> > Ethics and logistics of withdrawing, refuting, or amending", "their title. 1. Making one of these tags synonym of", "7 questions have retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction))", "I did some searches in the questions which include these", "tag as it was before without any edit to its", "process. 3. Delete the newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged", "that it does worth that the community think about these", "it was before without any edit to its excerpt and", "and can be the main tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions", "questions having these word in their body and title, the", "edit their excerpts to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\")", "tag without searching the tags' list carefully; I think that", "questions which include these word. By searching the website for", "> conferences or withdrawal during admissions process to academic >", "questions about withdrawing papers, books, etc. during their review and", "about withdrawing papers, books, etc. during their review and publication", "etc. during their review and publication process. 3. Delete the", "withdrawing a PhD position during his admissions process, and to", "scopes and not just vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged", "academic position such as withdrawal during postgraduate admissions. I did", "without searching the tags' list carefully; I think that it", "in their body and 17 questions have withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw))", "papers in the process of their submission or withdrawing an", "did some searches in the questions which include these word.", "72 questions have withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion))", "and logistics of withdrawing, refuting, or amending published > work.", "process, and to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") for", "and 7 questions have retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction ([3", "with similar scope. > > Ethics and logistics of withdrawing,", "popular word and can be the main tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction", "questions have withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in", "withdrawing an academic position such as withdrawal during postgraduate admissions.", "or withdrawal during admissions process to academic > programmes. >", "aim to be pinned to questions about withdrawing papers in", "their review and publication process. 3. Delete the newly proposed", "title. 39 questions have retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction ([21", "not withdrawing manuscripts which are under review process or even", "about withdrawal of books or papers from journals and >", "my opinion, the first option discussed above is a better", "and withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their title. 39 questions have", "an academic position such as withdrawal during postgraduate admissions. I", "searching the tags' list carefully; I think that it does", "word and can be the main tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show", "questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag as it was before without any", "the questions which include these word. By searching the website", "main tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag can", "tagged 'retraction'\") tag as it was before without any edit", "> work. > > > The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged", "tags' list carefully; I think that it does worth that", "conferences or withdrawal during admissions process to academic > programmes.", "in the questions which include these word. By searching the", "one of these tags synonym of the other and edit", "retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 7 questions have", "have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag as it", "tag to be deleted. In my opinion, the first option", "[retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag seems a little vague", "think that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with", "tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with its current excerpt is more popular", "is now approved: > > Questions about withdrawal of books", "previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag as it was", "'retraction'\") tag as it was before without any edit to", "and 17 questions have withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal ([2", "tagged 'retraction'\") for questions about withdrawing papers, books, etc. during", "only about retraction of published work, not withdrawing manuscripts which", "1. Making one of these tags synonym of the other", "is more popular word and can be the main tag", "as withdrawal during postgraduate admissions. I did some searches in", "for it which is now approved: > > Questions about", "papers, books, etc. during their review and publication process. 3.", "a new [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with aim", "seems a little vague to me, as it's scope may", "[withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with its current excerpt", "the following results are accessible: 72 questions have withdraw ([56", "their submission or withdrawing an academic position such as admissions", "[retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag can be a synonym", "retraction of published work, not withdrawing manuscripts which are under", "be the main tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\")", "as it's scope may cover questions which are only about", "and withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 17 questions", "me, as it's scope may cover questions which are only", "withdrawing academic positions such as a student withdrawing a PhD", "more popular word and can be the main tag and", "little vague to me, as it's scope may cover questions", "'withdraw'\") tag and have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\")", "tag's excerpt. (Based on the search results presented above, I", "to academic > programmes. > > > However, after some", "([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and", "which include these word. By searching the website for questions", "\"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag for questions which are about", "questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with its current excerpt is more", "with similar scopes and not just vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show", "their body and 7 questions have retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and", "the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag to be deleted.", "of it. 2. Having both tags on the site, but", "tagged 'withdraw'\") tag for questions which are about withdrawing academic", "questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag seems a little vague to me,", "academic positions such as a student withdrawing a PhD position", "but we can edit their excerpts to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show", "> > Questions about withdrawal of books or papers from", "admissions process, and to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\")", "questions about withdrawing papers in the process of their submission", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their title. 39 questions have retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion))", "have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag for questions which", "I think that it does worth that the community think", "I found that we have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged", "[withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag and have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction", "> The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag seems a", "the newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag and", "academic > programmes. > > > However, after some hours,", "([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their title. 39", "in the process of their submission or withdrawing an academic", "withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body", "during admissions process to academic > programmes. > > >", "synonym of the other and edit the main tag's excerpt.", "[retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") for questions about withdrawing papers,", "I suggested an excerpt for it which is now approved:", "> programmes. > > > However, after some hours, when", "([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 7 questions have retract", "results presented above, I think that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions", "\"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag as it was before without", "and publication process. 3. Delete the newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show", "edit the main tag's excerpt. (Based on the search results", "some hours, when I was reading the tags list, I", "results are accessible: 72 questions have withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and", "admissions process to academic > programmes. > > > However,", "just vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag to", "searching the website for questions having these word in their", "In my opinion, the first option discussed above is a", "work. > > > The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\")", "published work, not withdrawing manuscripts which are under review process", "questions about withdrawing an academic position such as withdrawal during", "these two tags with similar scopes and not just vote", "[retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag with similar scope. >", "scope may cover questions which are only about retraction of", "withdrawing manuscripts which are under review process or even questions", "questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with aim to be pinned to", "during their review and publication process. 3. Delete the newly", "list carefully; I think that it does worth that the", "carefully; I think that it does worth that the community", "[withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with aim to be", "Having both tags on the site, but we can edit", "> > > The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag", "am so sorry for making a new tag without searching", "tagged 'retraction'\") tag with similar scope. > > Ethics and", "questions which are only about retraction of published work, not", "withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their title. 39 questions have retract", "was reading the tags list, I found that we have", "other and edit the main tag's excerpt. (Based on the", "in their title. 39 questions have retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and", "it. 2. Having both tags on the site, but we", "The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag seems a little", "the other and edit the main tag's excerpt. (Based on", "from journals and > conferences or withdrawal during admissions process", "we can edit their excerpts to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions", "similar scopes and not just vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions", "papers from journals and > conferences or withdrawal during admissions", "'retraction'\") tag seems a little vague to me, as it's", "([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and", "'withdraw'\") tag to be deleted. In my opinion, the first", "to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag for questions", "excerpt for it which is now approved: > > Questions", "'retraction'\") tag with similar scope. > > Ethics and logistics", "withdrawing an academic position such as admissions offers. I suggested", "Questions about withdrawal of books or papers from journals and", "about retraction of published work, not withdrawing manuscripts which are", "its current excerpt is more popular word and can be", "position during his admissions process, and to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show", "now approved: > > Questions about withdrawal of books or", "for making a new tag without searching the tags' list", "having these word in their body and title, the following", "([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their title. 1. Making one of these", "review and publication process. 3. Delete the newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw", "two tags with similar scopes and not just vote the", "site, but we can edit their excerpts to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw", "as admissions offers. I suggested an excerpt for it which", "both tags on the site, but we can edit their", "journals and > conferences or withdrawal during admissions process to", "questions tagged 'retraction'\") for questions about withdrawing papers, books, etc.", "vague to me, as it's scope may cover questions which", "worth that the community think about these two tags with", "their body and 17 questions have withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and", "as a student withdrawing a PhD position during his admissions", "and to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") for questions", "a synonym of it. 2. Having both tags on the", "offers. I suggested an excerpt for it which is now", "'retraction'\") tag can be a synonym of it. 2. Having", "community think about these two tags with similar scopes and", "\"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag can be a synonym of", "questions have retract ([4 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in", "the website for questions having these word in their body", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their title. 39 questions", "that the community think about these two tags with similar", "excerpt is more popular word and can be the main", "> Questions about withdrawal of books or papers from journals", "a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag with similar scope.", "before without any edit to its excerpt and wiki. Although", "in their body and title, the following results are accessible:", "or withdrawing an academic position such as admissions offers. I", "withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their title.", "postgraduate admissions. I did some searches in the questions which", "excerpt. (Based on the search results presented above, I think", "tags list, I found that we have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show", "not just vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 17", "accessible: 72 questions have withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal ([16", "word in their body and title, the following results are", "after some hours, when I was reading the tags list,", "tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with aim to be pinned to questions", "withdrawing, refuting, or amending published > work. > > >", "search results presented above, I think that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show", "these word in their body and title, the following results", "\"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag seems a little vague to", "PhD position during his admissions process, and to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction", "programmes. > > > However, after some hours, when I", "about withdrawing papers in the process of their submission or", "think about these two tags with similar scopes and not", "tagged 'withdraw'\") tag to be deleted. In my opinion, the", "amending published > work. > > > The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show", "wiki. Although I am so sorry for making a new", "the tags list, I found that we have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction", "and have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag as", "so sorry for making a new tag without searching the", "\"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") for questions about withdrawing papers, books,", "body and title, the following results are accessible: 72 questions", "tags synonym of the other and edit the main tag's", "their title. 39 questions have retract ([18 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction", "I think that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their title. 1. Making one of these tags", "as it was before without any edit to its excerpt", "made a new [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with", "'withdraw'\") tag with aim to be pinned to questions about", "such as admissions offers. I suggested an excerpt for it", "its excerpt and wiki. Although I am so sorry for", "to questions about withdrawing papers in the process of their", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retract%20is%3Aquestion)) and retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 7", "I was reading the tags list, I found that we", "reading the tags list, I found that we have a", "tag seems a little vague to me, as it's scope", "tag and have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag", "the main tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag", "the site, but we can edit their excerpts to have", "I made a new [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag", "tag with aim to be pinned to questions about withdrawing", "are accessible: 72 questions have withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal", "new tag without searching the tags' list carefully; I think", "the main tag's excerpt. (Based on the search results presented", "tag for questions which are about withdrawing academic positions such", "some searches in the questions which include these word. By", "during his admissions process, and to have [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions", "and edit the main tag's excerpt. (Based on the search", "and wiki. Although I am so sorry for making a", "be deleted. In my opinion, the first option discussed above", "these word. By searching the website for questions having these", "of their submission or withdrawing an academic position such as", "to me, as it's scope may cover questions which are", "process of their submission or withdrawing an academic position such", "scope. > > Ethics and logistics of withdrawing, refuting, or", "publication process. 3. Delete the newly proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions", "cover questions which are only about retraction of published work,", "withdrawing papers in the process of their submission or withdrawing", "option discussed above is a better choice for the site.", "pinned to questions about withdrawing papers in the process of", "their body and title, the following results are accessible: 72", "the search results presented above, I think that the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw", "excerpts to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag for", "> > > However, after some hours, when I was", "the tags' list carefully; I think that it does worth", "and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag can be a", "on the search results presented above, I think that the", "'withdraw'\") tag with its current excerpt is more popular word", "under review process or even questions about withdrawing an academic", "have withdraw ([56 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdraw%20is%3Aquestion)) and withdrawal ([16 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=withdrawal%20is%3Aquestion)) in their", "have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag with similar", "hours, when I was reading the tags list, I found", "and retraction ([21 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=retraction%20is%3Aquestion)) in their body and 7 questions", "we have a [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag with", "these tags synonym of the other and edit the main", "it's scope may cover questions which are only about retraction", "questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretract)) and retraction ([3 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Aretraction)) in their title. 1. Making", "with its current excerpt is more popular word and can", "proposed [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag and have previous", "which is now approved: > > Questions about withdrawal of", "withdrawal during admissions process to academic > programmes. > >", "and title, the following results are accessible: 72 questions have", "position such as admissions offers. I suggested an excerpt for", "Making one of these tags synonym of the other and", "\"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag to be deleted. In my", "the community think about these two tags with similar scopes", "which are about withdrawing academic positions such as a student", "tagged 'withdraw'\") tag and have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged", "books, etc. during their review and publication process. 3. Delete", "approved: > > Questions about withdrawal of books or papers", "suggested an excerpt for it which is now approved: >", "about withdrawing academic positions such as a student withdrawing a", "review process or even questions about withdrawing an academic position", "or amending published > work. > > > The [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction", "similar scope. > > Ethics and logistics of withdrawing, refuting,", "without any edit to its excerpt and wiki. Although I", "opinion, the first option discussed above is a better choice", "or even questions about withdrawing an academic position such as", "questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag can be a synonym of it.", "their excerpts to have [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag", "questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag and have previous [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions", "an academic position such as admissions offers. I suggested an", "logistics of withdrawing, refuting, or amending published > work. >", "on the site, but we can edit their excerpts to", "have withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal ([2 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdrawal)) in their", "a new tag without searching the tags' list carefully; I", "are about withdrawing academic positions such as a student withdrawing", "'withdraw'\") tag for questions which are about withdrawing academic positions", "are only about retraction of published work, not withdrawing manuscripts", "tags with similar scopes and not just vote the [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw", "position such as withdrawal during postgraduate admissions. I did some", "or papers from journals and > conferences or withdrawal during", "new [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with aim to", "Today, I made a new [withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\")", "books or papers from journals and > conferences or withdrawal", "sorry for making a new tag without searching the tags'", "an excerpt for it which is now approved: > >", "Ethics and logistics of withdrawing, refuting, or amending published >", "body and 17 questions have withdraw ([15 questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=title%3Awithdraw)) and withdrawal", "questions which are about withdrawing academic positions such as a", "to be pinned to questions about withdrawing papers in the", "to be deleted. In my opinion, the first option discussed", "such as withdrawal during postgraduate admissions. I did some searches", "admissions. I did some searches in the questions which include", "with aim to be pinned to questions about withdrawing papers", "questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag for questions which are about withdrawing", "tag with similar scope. > > Ethics and logistics of", "[withdraw](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/withdraw \"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag for questions which are", "However, after some hours, when I was reading the tags", "\"show questions tagged 'withdraw'\") tag with its current excerpt is", "about withdrawing an academic position such as withdrawal during postgraduate", "in their title. 1. Making one of these tags synonym", "when I was reading the tags list, I found that", "tag and [retraction](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/retraction \"show questions tagged 'retraction'\") tag can be" ]
[ "it should only be used for questions that are off", "better fit someplace else. What do people think about migration?", "there... * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe better fits someplace", "is up with the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of the 10", "am not sure what is up with the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1),", "about migration? I am not sure what is up with", "if it might be a better fit someplace else. What", "for questions that are off topic here. In other words,", "sure what is up with the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of", "see there... * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe better fits", "are off topic here. In other words, if a question", "should only be used for questions that are off topic", "think about migration? I am not sure what is up", "migration? I am not sure what is up with the", "search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of the 10 questions I see there... ", "if a question is on topic here, it should stay", "questions are being flagged for migration because they are a", "topic here. In other words, if a question is on", "[migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of the 10 questions I see there...", "for migration because they are a better fit someplace else.", "it might be a better fit someplace else. What do", "people think about migration? I am not sure what is", "might be a better fit someplace else. What do people", "it should stay even if it might be a better", "view on migration is it should only be used for", "of the 10 questions I see there... <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> ", "only be used for questions that are off topic here.", "are being flagged for migration because they are a better", "being flagged for migration because they are a better fit", "topic here, it should stay even if it might be", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe better fits someplace else, seem", "because they are a better fit someplace else. My personal", "is on topic here, it should stay even if it", "migration is it should only be used for questions that", "not sure what is up with the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but", "a better fit someplace else. My personal view on migration", "they are a better fit someplace else. My personal view", "of questions are being flagged for migration because they are", "is it should only be used for questions that are", "the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of the 10 questions I see", "Recently, it seems that a number of questions are being", "I am not sure what is up with the [migrated", "up with the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of the 10 questions", "it seems that a number of questions are being flagged", "fit someplace else. My personal view on migration is it", "a question is on topic here, it should stay even", "even if it might be a better fit someplace else.", "Although maybe better fits someplace else, seem on topic here.", "other words, if a question is on topic here, it", "on topic here, it should stay even if it might", "with the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of the 10 questions I", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe better fits someplace else, seem on topic", "* <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe better fits someplace else,", "but of the 10 questions I see there... * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication>", "number of questions are being flagged for migration because they", "My personal view on migration is it should only be", "What do people think about migration? I am not sure", "fit someplace else. What do people think about migration? I", "In other words, if a question is on topic here,", "I see there... * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe better", "be a better fit someplace else. What do people think", "10 questions I see there... * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although", "better fit someplace else. My personal view on migration is", "questions I see there... * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe", "personal view on migration is it should only be used", "on migration is it should only be used for questions", "someplace else. What do people think about migration? I am", "question is on topic here, it should stay even if", "words, if a question is on topic here, it should", "else. What do people think about migration? I am not", "a better fit someplace else. What do people think about", "someplace else. My personal view on migration is it should", "questions that are off topic here. In other words, if", "else. My personal view on migration is it should only", "flagged for migration because they are a better fit someplace", "do people think about migration? I am not sure what", "seems that a number of questions are being flagged for", "migration because they are a better fit someplace else. My", "the 10 questions I see there... * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41557/how-much-of-your-p-value-do-you-report-in-a-publication> * <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol>", "here, it should stay even if it might be a", "what is up with the [migrated search](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?tab=newest&q=Migrated%3a1), but of the", "* <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43331/link-to-article-using-a-download-or-view-online-symbol> Although maybe better fits someplace else, seem on", "used for questions that are off topic here. In other", "that a number of questions are being flagged for migration", "that are off topic here. In other words, if a", "here. In other words, if a question is on topic", "be used for questions that are off topic here. In", "are a better fit someplace else. My personal view on", "off topic here. In other words, if a question is", "a number of questions are being flagged for migration because", "should stay even if it might be a better fit", "stay even if it might be a better fit someplace" ]
[ "force as adding a new question? 2. Even if somebody", "if there are high-scoring out-of-date answers. How can new answers", "are the most important creatures on earth. – A. Dinosaur", "answers to old questions that has approximately the same force", "update existing ones, on the old question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) >", "small (very small) amount since 2012 though, particularly as several", "question, that new answer won't be noticed if there are", "amount since 2012 though, particularly as several MOOCs move closer", "even after a reasonable but substantial change, the score no", "questions get noticed? e.g., > > +157 Giant lizards are", "answers. How can new answers to old questions get noticed?", "answer. What should we do about high-scoring answers that are", "A. Dinosaur [200M years ago] > > > 1 Homo", "they thought it was correct, not because they thought that", "won't be noticed if there are high-scoring out-of-date answers. How", "do not know the answer. Is there anything that a", "that has approximately the same force as adding a new", "should put MOOCs on one's CV. The comments are: >", "What should we do about high-scoring answers that are no", "Dinosaur [200M years ago] > > > 1 Homo sapiens", "should we do about high-scoring answers that are no longer", "asks whether one should put MOOCs on one's CV. The", "to the old question or update an existing answer: they", "2. Even if somebody does post a new answer to", "asker of the new question cannot add a new answer", "a user can do to encourage new answers to old", "they are asking because they do not know the answer.", "on earth. – A. Dinosaur [200M years ago] > >", "While I agree with the points raised, there are several", "> > > 3. Extensive editing of old answers seems", "the asker of the new question cannot add a new", "be correct. An unscrupulous dinosaur could, for example, change his", "encourage new answers to old questions* that has approximately the", "existing answer: they are asking because they do not know", "cabal of blueberries\" which, now, apparently 157 people agree with.", "By construction, the asker of the new question cannot add", "agree with. But, even after a reasonable but substantial change,", "no longer represents the community's view of the current answer.", "people agree with. But, even after a reasonable but substantial", "change it to in the future would be correct. An", "earth. – A. Dinosaur [200M years ago] > > >", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks whether one should put MOOCs on", "agree with the points raised, there are several problems here.", "because they thought it was correct, not because they thought", "People presumably upvoted A. Dinosaur's answer because they thought it", "> > +157 Giant lizards are the most important creatures", "answer. *Is there anything that a user can do to", "answer to an old question, that new answer won't be", "new question cannot add a new answer to the old", "might have changed over time; but rather to add new", "now, apparently 157 people agree with. But, even after a", "Dinosaur's answer because they thought it was correct, not because", "> 1 Homo sapiens* is having a big impact. –", "by a cabal of blueberries\" which, now, apparently 157 people", "MOOCs on one's CV. The comments are: > > I", "answer to \"The world is, in fact, controlled by a", "know the answer. Is there anything that a user can", "to add new answers, or update existing ones, on the", "157 people agree with. But, even after a reasonable but", "that new answer won't be noticed if there are high-scoring", "the old question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > > > While I", "one should put MOOCs on one's CV. The comments are:", "new answers to old questions get noticed? e.g., > >", "approximately the same force as adding a new question? 2.", "of blueberries\" which, now, apparently 157 people agree with. But,", "be noticed if there are high-scoring out-of-date answers. How can", "was asked three years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not sure if", "there are high-scoring out-of-date answers. How can new answers to", "sure if the answer hasn't changed a small (very small)", "inspired by the close vote on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks", "but rather to add new answers, or update existing ones,", "high-scoring out-of-date answers. How can new answers to old questions", "Even if somebody does post a new answer to an", "new answers, or update existing ones, on the old question.", "An unscrupulous dinosaur could, for example, change his answer to", "on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks whether one should put MOOCs", "old question, that new answer won't be noticed if there", "accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > > > [I]t is a duplicate. Etiquette", "answers seems misleading. People presumably upvoted A. Dinosaur's answer because", "update an existing answer: they are asking because they do", "for which the answer might have changed over time; but", "– A. Dinosaur [200M years ago] > > > 1", "rather to add new answers, or update existing ones, on", "represents the community's view of the current answer. What should", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks whether one should put MOOCs on one's", "> > > 1 Homo sapiens is having a big", "on the old question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > > > While", "because they thought that anything he might change it to", "do to encourage new answers to old questions that has", "> > > While I agree with the points raised,", "if somebody does post a new answer to an old", "which asks whether one should put MOOCs on one's CV.", "a reasonable but substantial change, the score no longer represents", "ones, on the old question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > > >", "three years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not sure if the answer", "is not to re-ask an old question for which the", "correct, not because they thought that anything he might change", "new answer to the old question or update an existing", "with. But, even after a reasonable but substantial change, the", "> > I would note that this was asked three", "longer represents the community's view of the current answer. What", "the answer. Is there anything that a user can do", "the points raised, there are several problems here. 1. By", "the community's view of the current answer. What should we", "old question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > > > While I agree", "> > > [I]t is a duplicate. Etiquette is not", "question for which the answer might have changed over time;", "But, even after a reasonable but substantial change, the score", "\"The world is, in fact, controlled by a cabal of", "old question for which the answer might have changed over", "world is, in fact, controlled by a cabal of blueberries\"", "of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > > > [I]t is a duplicate.", "post a new answer to an old question, that new", "answer hasn't changed a small (very small) amount since 2012", "or update existing ones, on the old question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers)", "anything that a user can do to encourage new answers", "that a user can do to encourage new answers to", "could, for example, change his answer to \"The world is,", "not to re-ask an old question for which the answer", "is a duplicate. Etiquette is not to re-ask an old", "is having a big impact. – Hivh Mop [13 mins", "user can do to encourage new answers to old questions", "current answer. What should we do about high-scoring answers that", "dinosaur could, for example, change his answer to \"The world", "[200M years ago] > > > 1 Homo sapiens is", "there are several problems here. 1. By construction, the asker", "closer to a kind of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > > >", "to old questions get noticed? e.g., > > +157 Giant", "new answers to old questions that has approximately the same", "new question? 2. Even if somebody does post a new", "> > 1 Homo sapiens is having a big impact.", "that this was asked three years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not", "old questions get noticed? e.g., > > +157 Giant lizards", "not because they thought that anything he might change it", "presumably upvoted A. Dinosaur's answer because they thought it was", "> > [I]t is a duplicate. Etiquette is not to", "points raised, there are several problems here. 1. By construction,", "new answer to an old question, that new answer won't", "cannot add a new answer to the old question or", "the current answer. What should we do about high-scoring answers", "problems here. 1. By construction, the asker of the new", "view of the current answer. *What should we do about", "by the close vote on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks whether", "the same force as adding a new question? 2. Even", "the new question cannot add a new answer to the", "raised, there are several problems here. 1. By construction, the", "thought that anything he might change it to in the", "after a reasonable but substantial change, the score no longer", "small) amount since 2012 though, particularly as several MOOCs move", "put MOOCs on one's CV. The comments are: > >", "The comments are: > > I would note that this", "years ago] > > > 1 Homo sapiens* is having", "correct. An unscrupulous dinosaur could, for example, change his answer", "change, the score no longer represents the community's view of", "[I]t is a duplicate. Etiquette is not to re-ask an", "which the answer might have changed over time; but rather", "substantial change, the score no longer represents the community's view", "> > While I agree with the points raised, there", "an existing answer: they are asking because they do not", "not sure if the answer hasn't changed a small (very", "> > 3. Extensive editing of old answers seems misleading.", "is, in fact, controlled by a cabal of blueberries\" which,", "kind of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > > > [I]t is a", "to old questions** that has approximately the same force as", "Homo sapiens is having a big impact. – Hivh Mop", "[EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > > > While I agree with the points", "question? 2. Even if somebody does post a new answer", "anything he might change it to in the future would", "several problems here. 1. By construction, the asker of the", "for example, change his answer to \"The world is, in", "comments are: > > I would note that this was", "one's CV. The comments are: > > I would note", "[Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > > > [I]t is a duplicate. Etiquette is", "close vote on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks whether one should", "a new question? 2. Even if somebody does post a", "would note that this was asked three years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in);", "a big impact. – Hivh Mop [13 mins ago] >", "blueberries\" which, now, apparently 157 people agree with. But, even", "the answer hasn't changed a small (very small) amount since", "fact, controlled by a cabal of blueberries\" which, now, apparently", "big impact. – Hivh Mop [13 mins ago] > >", "apparently 157 people agree with. But, even after a reasonable", "answer: they are asking because they do not know the", "add a new answer to the old question or update", "with the points raised, there are several problems here. 1.", "would be correct. An unscrupulous dinosaur could, for example, change", "out-of-date answers. How can new answers to old questions get", "somebody does post a new answer to an old question,", "community's view of the current answer. What should we do", "in fact, controlled by a cabal of blueberries\" which, now,", "I agree with the points raised, there are several problems", "important creatures on earth. – A. Dinosaur [200M years ago]", "noticed if there are high-scoring out-of-date answers. How can new", "> I would note that this was asked three years", "3. Extensive editing of old answers seems misleading. People presumably", "most important creatures on earth. – A. Dinosaur [200M years", "old questions that has approximately the same force as adding", "future would be correct. An unscrupulous dinosaur could, for example,", "a kind of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > > > [I]t is", "was correct, not because they thought that anything he might", "1. By construction, the asker of the new question cannot", "can new answers to old questions get noticed? e.g., >", "CV. The comments are: > > I would note that", "editing of old answers seems misleading. People presumably upvoted A.", "to \"The world is, in fact, controlled by a cabal", "new answer won't be noticed if there are high-scoring out-of-date", "his answer to \"The world is, in fact, controlled by", "to re-ask an old question for which the answer might", "Is there anything that a user can do to encourage", "in the future would be correct. An unscrupulous dinosaur could,", "it was correct, not because they thought that anything he", "This is inspired by the close vote on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685),", "Extensive editing of old answers seems misleading. People presumably upvoted", "several MOOCs move closer to a kind of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe)", "ago] > > > 1 Homo sapiens is having a", "it to in the future would be correct. An unscrupulous", "same force as adding a new question? 2. Even if", "misleading. People presumably upvoted A. Dinosaur's answer because they thought", "e.g., > > +157 Giant lizards are the most important", "ago] > > > 3. Extensive editing of old answers", "if the answer hasn't changed a small (very small) amount", "they do not know the answer. Is there anything that", "years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not sure if the answer hasn't", "I would note that this was asked three years ago,", "question cannot add a new answer to the old question", "Hivh Mop [13 mins ago] > > > 3. Extensive", "the answer might have changed over time; but rather to", "to encourage new answers to old questions that has approximately", "example, change his answer to \"The world is, in fact,", "can do to encourage new answers to old questions** that", "Mop [13 mins ago] > > > 3. Extensive editing", "Etiquette is not to re-ask an old question for which", "sapiens* is having a big impact. – Hivh Mop [13", "of the new question cannot add a new answer to", "the most important creatures on earth. – A. Dinosaur [200M", "unscrupulous dinosaur could, for example, change his answer to \"The", "impact. – Hivh Mop [13 mins ago] > > >", "are asking because they do not know the answer. Is", "A. Dinosaur's answer because they thought it was correct, not", "which, now, apparently 157 people agree with. But, even after", "a new answer to the old question or update an", "answer because they thought it was correct, not because they", "questions that has approximately the same force as adding a", "answers to old questions get noticed? e.g., > > +157", "seems misleading. People presumably upvoted A. Dinosaur's answer because they", "[here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not sure if the answer hasn't changed a", "as adding a new question? 2. Even if somebody does", "+157 Giant lizards are the most important creatures on earth.", "are: > > I would note that this was asked", "to a kind of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > > > [I]t", "creatures on earth. – A. Dinosaur [200M years ago] >", "of the current answer. What should we do about high-scoring", "asked three years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not sure if the", "(very small) amount since 2012 though, particularly as several MOOCs", "old question or update an existing answer: they are asking", "time; but rather to add new answers, or update existing", "[...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > > > While I agree with the", "the close vote on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks whether one", "controlled by a cabal of blueberries\" which, now, apparently 157", "> [I]t is a duplicate. Etiquette is not to re-ask", "they thought that anything he might change it to in", "is inspired by the close vote on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which", "noticed? e.g., > > +157 Giant lizards are the most", "a duplicate. Etiquette is not to re-ask an old question", "the score no longer represents the community's view of the", "that anything he might change it to in the future", "upvoted A. Dinosaur's answer because they thought it was correct,", "mins ago] > > > 3. Extensive editing of old", "there anything that a user can do to encourage new", "How can new answers to old questions get noticed? e.g.,", "thought it was correct, not because they thought that anything", "asking because they do not know the answer. Is there", "re-ask an old question for which the answer might have", "get noticed? e.g., > > +157 Giant lizards are the", "an old question, that new answer won't be noticed if", "here. 1. By construction, the asker of the new question", "an old question for which the answer might have changed", "answer to the old question or update an existing answer:", "because they do not know the answer. Is there anything", "does post a new answer to an old question, that", "this was asked three years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not sure", "the old question or update an existing answer: they are", "answer won't be noticed if there are high-scoring out-of-date answers.", "> +157 Giant lizards are the most important creatures on", "he might change it to in the future would be", "a cabal of blueberries\" which, now, apparently 157 people agree", "vote on [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43423/10685), which asks whether one should put", "question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > > > While I agree with", "as several MOOCs move closer to a kind of accreditation.", "2012 though, particularly as several MOOCs move closer to a", "construction, the asker of the new question cannot add a", "to an old question, that new answer won't be noticed", "reasonable but substantial change, the score no longer represents the", "1 Homo sapiens is having a big impact. – Hivh", "having a big impact. – Hivh Mop [13 mins ago]", "lizards are the most important creatures on earth. – A.", "changed a small (very small) amount since 2012 though, particularly", "adding a new question? 2. Even if somebody does post", "note that this was asked three years ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm", "on one's CV. The comments are: > > I would", "duplicate. Etiquette is not to re-ask an old question for", "whether one should put MOOCs on one's CV. The comments", "score no longer represents the community's view of the current", "answers, or update existing ones, on the old question. [...]", "add new answers, or update existing ones, on the old", "Giant lizards are the most important creatures on earth. –", "are several problems here. 1. By construction, the asker of", "MOOCs move closer to a kind of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) >", "change his answer to \"The world is, in fact, controlled", "a new answer to an old question, that new answer", "we do about high-scoring answers that are no longer valid?", "answer might have changed over time; but rather to add", "though, particularly as several MOOCs move closer to a kind", "> 3. Extensive editing of old answers seems misleading. People", "old answers seems misleading. People presumably upvoted A. Dinosaur's answer", "of old answers seems misleading. People presumably upvoted A. Dinosaur's", "not know the answer. Is there anything that a user", "might change it to in the future would be correct.", "to in the future would be correct. An unscrupulous dinosaur", "over time; but rather to add new answers, or update", "ago, [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/2336/can-i-include-the-completion-of-udacity-and-coursera-classes-i-have-attended-in); I'm not sure if the answer hasn't changed", "but substantial change, the score no longer represents the community's", "the future would be correct. An unscrupulous dinosaur could, for", "has approximately the same force as adding a new question?", "[13 mins ago] > > > 3. Extensive editing of", "have changed over time; but rather to add new answers,", "or update an existing answer: they are asking because they", "since 2012 though, particularly as several MOOCs move closer to", "question or update an existing answer: they are asking because", "move closer to a kind of accreditation. [Joe](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/12346/joe) > >", "existing ones, on the old question. [...] [EnergyNumbers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/96/energynumbers) > >", "hasn't changed a small (very small) amount since 2012 though,", "a small (very small) amount since 2012 though, particularly as", "are high-scoring out-of-date answers. **How can new answers to old", "changed over time; but rather to add new answers, or", "– Hivh Mop [13 mins ago] > > > 3.", "particularly as several MOOCs move closer to a kind of", "> While I agree with the points raised, there are", "I'm not sure if the answer hasn't changed a small" ]
[ "my question is: should I think about an upvote as", "that I find interesting, or that I can strongly relate", "question is: should I think about an upvote as \"good", "Sometimes, I come along a question here on Academia that", "about an upvote as \"good question AND on-topic\"? Am I", "upvote as \"good question AND on-topic\"? Am I creating more", "consider this a good question\" and/or \"I would also like", "this a good question\" and/or \"I would also like to", "I creating more difficulties by upvoting an off-topic question? Or", "questions are (clearly) not a good fit for the site.", "relate with. When this happens I tend to upvote it:", "question\" and/or \"I would also like to have an answer", "here on Academia that I find interesting, or that I", "that I can strongly relate with. When this happens I", "an off-topic question? Or it just doesn't matter at all?", "find interesting, or that I can strongly relate with. When", "with. When this happens I tend to upvote it: I", "AND on-topic\"? Am I creating more difficulties by upvoting an", "is: should I think about an upvote as \"good question", "these questions are (clearly) not a good fit for the", "difficulties by upvoting an off-topic question? Or it just doesn't", "the site. So my question is: should I think about", "this happens I tend to upvote it: I think of", "I think about an upvote as \"good question AND on-topic\"?", "fit for the site. So my question is: should I", "\"good question AND on-topic\"? Am I creating more difficulties by", "for the site. So my question is: should I think", "a good fit for the site. So my question is:", "for it\". But sometimes these questions are (clearly) not a", "I find interesting, or that I can strongly relate with.", "on Academia that I find interesting, or that I can", "sometimes these questions are (clearly) not a good fit for", "So my question is: should I think about an upvote", "good fit for the site. So my question is: should", "question AND on-topic\"? Am I creating more difficulties by upvoting", "by upvoting an off-topic question? Or it just doesn't matter", "like to have an answer for it\". But sometimes these", "should I think about an upvote as \"good question AND", "think about an upvote as \"good question AND on-topic\"? Am", "think of my upvote as saying \"I consider this a", "are (clearly) not a good fit for the site. So", "upvote it: I think of my upvote as saying \"I", "not a good fit for the site. So my question", "it: I think of my upvote as saying \"I consider", "an upvote as \"good question AND on-topic\"? Am I creating", "an answer for it\". But sometimes these questions are (clearly)", "I tend to upvote it: I think of my upvote", "When this happens I tend to upvote it: I think", "\"I consider this a good question\" and/or \"I would also", "come along a question here on Academia that I find", "upvote as saying \"I consider this a good question\" and/or", "as \"good question AND on-topic\"? Am I creating more difficulties", "Am I creating more difficulties by upvoting an off-topic question?", "a question here on Academia that I find interesting, or", "of my upvote as saying \"I consider this a good", "good question\" and/or \"I would also like to have an", "it\". But sometimes these questions are (clearly) not a good", "more difficulties by upvoting an off-topic question? Or it just", "interesting, or that I can strongly relate with. When this", "saying \"I consider this a good question\" and/or \"I would", "my upvote as saying \"I consider this a good question\"", "answer for it\". But sometimes these questions are (clearly) not", "Academia that I find interesting, or that I can strongly", "I come along a question here on Academia that I", "I can strongly relate with. When this happens I tend", "can strongly relate with. When this happens I tend to", "would also like to have an answer for it\". But", "site. So my question is: should I think about an", "to upvote it: I think of my upvote as saying", "question here on Academia that I find interesting, or that", "as saying \"I consider this a good question\" and/or \"I", "also like to have an answer for it\". But sometimes", "happens I tend to upvote it: I think of my", "\"I would also like to have an answer for it\".", "upvoting an off-topic question? Or it just doesn't matter at", "creating more difficulties by upvoting an off-topic question? Or it", "a good question\" and/or \"I would also like to have", "But sometimes these questions are (clearly) not a good fit", "tend to upvote it: I think of my upvote as", "have an answer for it\". But sometimes these questions are", "along a question here on Academia that I find interesting,", "and/or \"I would also like to have an answer for", "to have an answer for it\". But sometimes these questions", "strongly relate with. When this happens I tend to upvote", "(clearly) not a good fit for the site. So my", "or that I can strongly relate with. When this happens", "I think of my upvote as saying \"I consider this", "on-topic\"? Am I creating more difficulties by upvoting an off-topic" ]
[ "This job is outside academia, but require many academia skills", "is outside academia, but require many academia skills (such as", "many academia skills (such as math, able to deep research,", "question on topic here? If not, is there a site", "would like to ask a question about seeking for a", "job is outside academia, but require many academia skills (such", "as math, able to deep research, etc). Is this kind", "academia skills (such as math, able to deep research, etc).", "to deep research, etc). Is this kind of question on", "like to ask a question about seeking for a job.", "job. This job is outside academia, but require many academia", "Is this kind of question on topic here? If not,", "research, etc). Is this kind of question on topic here?", "of question on topic here? If not, is there a", "topic here? If not, is there a site should I", "deep research, etc). Is this kind of question on topic", "skills (such as math, able to deep research, etc). Is", "a question about seeking for a job. This job is", "I would like to ask a question about seeking for", "able to deep research, etc). Is this kind of question", "to ask a question about seeking for a job. This", "on topic here? If not, is there a site should", "for a job. This job is outside academia, but require", "academia, but require many academia skills (such as math, able", "math, able to deep research, etc). Is this kind of", "require many academia skills (such as math, able to deep", "this kind of question on topic here? If not, is", "here? If not, is there a site should I ask", "etc). Is this kind of question on topic here? If", "but require many academia skills (such as math, able to", "seeking for a job. This job is outside academia, but", "If not, is there a site should I ask instead?", "question about seeking for a job. This job is outside", "kind of question on topic here? If not, is there", "outside academia, but require many academia skills (such as math,", "ask a question about seeking for a job. This job", "a job. This job is outside academia, but require many", "(such as math, able to deep research, etc). Is this", "about seeking for a job. This job is outside academia," ]
[ "are too localized? > > > and > > This", "someone with a good understanding of your situation will be", "to provide an objectively correct answer. > > > I", "assistance in writing questions that can apply to multiple people", "> > I can't see any situation in which one", "Right now, we have two custom close reasons that are", "find myself using a variant on the \"shopping question\" tag", "another in scope: > > Questions that cannot be generalized", "could apply, but the other couldn't. [The other close reason", "frequently. I would recommend replacing one of the tags above", "will be able to provide an objectively correct answer. >", "a variant on the \"shopping question\" tag a lot more", "What kinds of questions are too localized? > > >", "other close reason is the often overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally,", "other couldn't. [The other close reason is the often overused", "your situation will be able to provide an objectively correct", "that it's appropriate to revisit the issue. Right now, we", "very similar to one another in scope: > > Questions", "> > > and > > This question appears to", "see: What kinds of questions are too localized? > >", "likely that only someone with a good understanding of your", "> > This question appears to be off-topic because it", "one of the tags above with something such as: >", "a while since these have been looked at, but I", "is the often overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally, I find myself", "to seek specific advice for a very specific situation, and", "that are very similar to one another in scope: >", "issue. Right now, we have two custom close reasons that", "close reason is the often overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally, I", "similar situations are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that", "off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that can apply to", "close reasons that are very similar to one another in", "of questions are too localized? > > > and >", "we have two custom close reasons that are very similar", "understanding of your situation will be able to provide an", "appropriate to revisit the issue. Right now, we have two", "off-topic because it seems to seek specific advice for a", "similar situations, see: What kinds of questions are too localized?", "scope: > > Questions that cannot be generalized to apply", "in similar situations are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions", "apply to multiple people facing similar situations, see: What kinds", "to be off-topic because it seems to seek specific advice", "been looked at, but I think that it's appropriate to", "it seems to seek specific advice for a very specific", "very specific situation, and it's likely that only someone with", "one another in scope: > > Questions that cannot be", "to multiple people facing similar situations, see: What kinds of", "that cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar", "two custom close reasons that are very similar to one", "I would recommend replacing one of the tags above with", "custom close reasons that are very similar to one another", "situation, and it's likely that only someone with a good", "tag a lot more frequently. I would recommend replacing one", "able to provide an objectively correct answer. > > >", "variant on the \"shopping question\" tag a lot more frequently.", "have been looked at, but I think that it's appropriate", "> > We cannot offer recommendations or rankings of specific", "on the \"shopping question\" tag a lot more frequently. I", "but I think that it's appropriate to revisit the issue.", "rankings of specific programs, courses, universities, or other similar requests,", "above with something such as: > > We cannot offer", "similar to one another in scope: > > Questions that", "in writing questions that can apply to multiple people facing", "appears to be off-topic because it seems to seek specific", "good understanding of your situation will be able to provide", "of the tags above with something such as: > >", "seems to seek specific advice for a very specific situation,", "cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations", "reason.] Personally, I find myself using a variant on the", "these have been looked at, but I think that it's", "it's appropriate to revisit the issue. Right now, we have", "myself using a variant on the \"shopping question\" tag a", "> and > > This question appears to be off-topic", "For assistance in writing questions that can apply to multiple", "can apply to multiple people facing similar situations, see: What", "facing similar situations, see: What kinds of questions are too", "> > > I can't see any situation in which", "in scope: > > Questions that cannot be generalized to", "> > and > > This question appears to be", "similar requests, as these are primarily opinion-based. > > >", "correct answer. > > > I can't see any situation", "multiple people facing similar situations, see: What kinds of questions", "the \"shopping question\" tag a lot more frequently. I would", "courses, universities, or other similar requests, as these are primarily", "of your situation will be able to provide an objectively", "any situation in which one of these could apply, but", "specific situation, and it's likely that only someone with a", "questions that can apply to multiple people facing similar situations,", "question appears to be off-topic because it seems to seek", "writing questions that can apply to multiple people facing similar", "the tags above with something such as: > > We", "question\" tag a lot more frequently. I would recommend replacing", "are very similar to one another in scope: > >", "situation will be able to provide an objectively correct answer.", "see any situation in which one of these could apply,", "be off-topic because it seems to seek specific advice for", "advice for a very specific situation, and it's likely that", "often overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally, I find myself using a", "at, but I think that it's appropriate to revisit the", "universities, or other similar requests, as these are primarily opinion-based.", "something such as: > > We cannot offer recommendations or", "I think that it's appropriate to revisit the issue. Right", "kinds of questions are too localized? > > > and", "since these have been looked at, but I think that", "be generalized to apply to others in similar situations are", "This question appears to be off-topic because it seems to", "other similar requests, as these are primarily opinion-based. > >", "situation in which one of these could apply, but the", "> This question appears to be off-topic because it seems", "an objectively correct answer. > > > I can't see", "\"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally, I find myself using a variant on", "apply, but the other couldn't. [The other close reason is", "been a while since these have been looked at, but", "localized? > > > and > > This question appears", "that can apply to multiple people facing similar situations, see:", "reason is the often overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally, I find", "and > > This question appears to be off-topic because", "It's been a while since these have been looked at,", "others in similar situations are off-topic. For assistance in writing", "would recommend replacing one of the tags above with something", "tags above with something such as: > > We cannot", "people facing similar situations, see: What kinds of questions are", "recommendations or rankings of specific programs, courses, universities, or other", "have two custom close reasons that are very similar to", "using a variant on the \"shopping question\" tag a lot", "these could apply, but the other couldn't. [The other close", "I can't see any situation in which one of these", "cannot offer recommendations or rankings of specific programs, courses, universities,", "that only someone with a good understanding of your situation", "a very specific situation, and it's likely that only someone", "think that it's appropriate to revisit the issue. Right now,", "to revisit the issue. Right now, we have two custom", "> I can't see any situation in which one of", "a lot more frequently. I would recommend replacing one of", "> We cannot offer recommendations or rankings of specific programs,", "and it's likely that only someone with a good understanding", "replacing one of the tags above with something such as:", "specific advice for a very specific situation, and it's likely", "objectively correct answer. > > > I can't see any", "reasons that are very similar to one another in scope:", "apply to others in similar situations are off-topic. For assistance", "or rankings of specific programs, courses, universities, or other similar", "be able to provide an objectively correct answer. > >", "are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that can apply", "too localized? > > > and > > This question", "such as: > > We cannot offer recommendations or rankings", "which one of these could apply, but the other couldn't.", "as: > > We cannot offer recommendations or rankings of", "provide an objectively correct answer. > > > I can't", "can't see any situation in which one of these could", "the often overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally, I find myself using", "with a good understanding of your situation will be able", "for a very specific situation, and it's likely that only", "We cannot offer recommendations or rankings of specific programs, courses,", "of specific programs, courses, universities, or other similar requests, as", "but the other couldn't. [The other close reason is the", "to others in similar situations are off-topic. For assistance in", "looked at, but I think that it's appropriate to revisit", "lot more frequently. I would recommend replacing one of the", "only someone with a good understanding of your situation will", "while since these have been looked at, but I think", "couldn't. [The other close reason is the often overused \"Undergraduate\"", "in which one of these could apply, but the other", "> Questions that cannot be generalized to apply to others", "it's likely that only someone with a good understanding of", "overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.] Personally, I find myself using a variant", "answer. > > > I can't see any situation in", "programs, courses, universities, or other similar requests, as these are", "seek specific advice for a very specific situation, and it's", "a good understanding of your situation will be able to", "situations, see: What kinds of questions are too localized? >", "offer recommendations or rankings of specific programs, courses, universities, or", "one of these could apply, but the other couldn't. [The", "I find myself using a variant on the \"shopping question\"", "now, we have two custom close reasons that are very", "recommend replacing one of the tags above with something such", "specific programs, courses, universities, or other similar requests, as these", "\"shopping question\" tag a lot more frequently. I would recommend", "because it seems to seek specific advice for a very", "the issue. Right now, we have two custom close reasons", "with something such as: > > We cannot offer recommendations", "of these could apply, but the other couldn't. [The other", "or other similar requests, as these are primarily opinion-based. >", "revisit the issue. Right now, we have two custom close", "questions are too localized? > > > and > >", "> > Questions that cannot be generalized to apply to", "to apply to others in similar situations are off-topic. For", "[The other close reason is the often overused \"Undergraduate\" reason.]", "generalized to apply to others in similar situations are off-topic.", "Personally, I find myself using a variant on the \"shopping", "situations are off-topic. For assistance in writing questions that can", "the other couldn't. [The other close reason is the often", "more frequently. I would recommend replacing one of the tags", "Questions that cannot be generalized to apply to others in", "to one another in scope: > > Questions that cannot" ]
[ "lot of prof and people in mathematics(and other fields too)", "other fields too) have their own webpages. Now there can", "to academic blogging such as \"Should there be a like", "be a lot of questions that relate to academic blogging", "questions that relate to academic blogging such as \"Should there", "relate to academic blogging such as \"Should there be a", "there can be a lot of questions that relate to", "mathematics(and other fields too) have their own webpages. Now there", "can be a lot of questions that relate to academic", "own webpages. Now there can be a lot of questions", "there be a like button in your academic webpage or", "too) have their own webpages. Now there can be a", "in mathematics(and other fields too) have their own webpages. Now", "Now there can be a lot of questions that relate", "academic blogging such as \"Should there be a like button", "webpages. Now there can be a lot of questions that", "that relate to academic blogging such as \"Should there be", "as \"Should there be a like button in your academic", "lot of questions that relate to academic blogging such as", "of prof and people in mathematics(and other fields too) have", "and people in mathematics(and other fields too) have their own", "people in mathematics(and other fields too) have their own webpages.", "A lot of prof and people in mathematics(and other fields", "have their own webpages. Now there can be a lot", "\"Should there be a like button in your academic webpage", "such as \"Should there be a like button in your", "blogging such as \"Should there be a like button in", "fields too) have their own webpages. Now there can be", "of questions that relate to academic blogging such as \"Should", "be a like button in your academic webpage or blog?\"", "their own webpages. Now there can be a lot of", "prof and people in mathematics(and other fields too) have their", "a lot of questions that relate to academic blogging such" ]
[ "was based on undergraduate academic internships. > > [Avoid spam", "down voted. I am not fairly convinced that the question", "students from masters courses too and not just undergrad students.", "not fairly convinced that the question that I asked was", "to all the students from masters courses too and not", "> > [Avoid spam filters when applying for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships)", "I am not fairly convinced that the question that I", "undergraduate academic internships. > > [Avoid spam filters when applying", "question that was based on undergraduate academic internships. > >", "recently asked a question that was heavily down voted. I", "the question that I asked was indeed off topic. I", "[Avoid spam filters when applying for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > >", "However, it applies to all the students from masters courses", "based on undergraduate academic internships. > > [Avoid spam filters", "am not fairly convinced that the question that I asked", "to a question that was based on undergraduate academic internships.", "asked was indeed off topic. I happen to provide a", "I recently asked a question that was heavily down voted.", "I asked was indeed off topic. I happen to provide", "off topic. I happen to provide a link to a", "a question that was heavily down voted. I am not", "fairly convinced that the question that I asked was indeed", "that the question that I asked was indeed off topic.", "> However, it applies to all the students from masters", "that was heavily down voted. I am not fairly convinced", "all the students from masters courses too and not just", "question that was heavily down voted. I am not fairly", "voted. I am not fairly convinced that the question that", "that was based on undergraduate academic internships. > > [Avoid", "on undergraduate academic internships. > > [Avoid spam filters when", "> > However, it applies to all the students from", "when applying for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > > > However, it", "for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > > > However, it applies to", "spam filters when applying for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > > >", "applying for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > > > However, it applies", "academic internships. > > [Avoid spam filters when applying for", "indeed off topic. I happen to provide a link to", "I happen to provide a link to a question that", "happen to provide a link to a question that was", "> [Avoid spam filters when applying for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) >", "convinced that the question that I asked was indeed off", "it applies to all the students from masters courses too", "provide a link to a question that was based on", "link to a question that was based on undergraduate academic", "a question that was based on undergraduate academic internships. >", "applies to all the students from masters courses too and", "question that I asked was indeed off topic. I happen", "internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > > > However, it applies to all the", "> > > However, it applies to all the students", "academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > > > However, it applies to all", "was heavily down voted. I am not fairly convinced that", "topic. I happen to provide a link to a question", "the students from masters courses too and not just undergrad", "asked a question that was heavily down voted. I am", "heavily down voted. I am not fairly convinced that the", "to provide a link to a question that was based", "internships. > > [Avoid spam filters when applying for academic", "filters when applying for academic internships](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45577/avoid-spam-filters-when-applying-for-academc-internships) > > > However,", "a link to a question that was based on undergraduate", "that I asked was indeed off topic. I happen to", "was indeed off topic. I happen to provide a link" ]
[ "of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user was curious why the question was", "why the question was closed, and I'm posting this question", "The user was curious why the question was closed, and", "[this question about the definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user was", "question about the definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user was curious", "user was curious why the question was closed, and I'm", "was closed, and I'm posting this question to hopefully provide", "posted [this question about the definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user", "A user recently posted [this question about the definition of", "recently posted [this question about the definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The", "the definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user was curious why the", "user recently posted [this question about the definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum)", "curious why the question was closed, and I'm posting this", "the question was closed, and I'm posting this question to", "about the definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user was curious why", "closed, and I'm posting this question to hopefully provide answers.", "\"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user was curious why the question was closed,", "definition of \"curriculum.\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/45599/what-is-a-curriculum) The user was curious why the question", "question was closed, and I'm posting this question to hopefully", "was curious why the question was closed, and I'm posting" ]
[ "need to articulate an additional question. On the flip side", "this a perfectly ethical artifact of the SE system? Do", "articulate an additional question. On the flip side (and this", "what I myself was able to perceive. But I'm trying", "same logic and reach the same conclusion. Neither one of", "the same conclusion. Neither one of us cites any links.", "mine, but we are using the same logic and reach", "course!) essentially equivalent to mine. His style is more authoritative", "Then someone with a fancy academic position and a massive", "a fancy academic position and a massive reputation score comes", "of the SE system? Do I just need to be", "Do I just need to be patient and slowly amass", "etiquette](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1753/answering-etiquette?noredirect=1#comment7510_1753) After a helpful answer and some helpful comments to", "links. His answer gets upvoted like crazy. Is there anything", "out how things work here, so for the sake of", "system? Do I just need to be patient and slowly", "any links. His answer gets upvoted like crazy. Is there", "Can I at least take the moral high ground in", "question. It gets several upvotes. Then someone with a fancy", "an additional question. On the flip side (and this is", "my inquiries): Suppose I have written a careful answer to", "high ground in my own thinking? Or is this a", "this is what motivated my inquiries): Suppose I have written", "answer and some helpful comments to my other question, I", "there may be more differences between our answers than what", "patient and slowly amass more points? (Please note, I do", "are using the same logic and reach the same conclusion.", "sake of argument, could you please try to give an", "the same logic and reach the same conclusion. Neither one", "and slowly amass more points? (Please note, I do realize", "inquiries): Suppose I have written a careful answer to a", "position and a massive reputation score comes along and writes", "at least take the moral high ground in my own", "upvotes. Then someone with a fancy academic position and a", "same conclusion. Neither one of us cites any links. His", "reach the same conclusion. Neither one of us cites any", "a helpful answer and some helpful comments to my other", "(in my opinion, of course!) essentially equivalent to mine. His", "I realize I need to articulate an additional question. On", "work here, so for the sake of argument, could you", "between our answers than what I myself was able to", "massive reputation score comes along and writes an answer which", "and reach the same conclusion. Neither one of us cites", "some helpful comments to my other question, I realize I", "argument, could you please try to give an answer based", "of argument, could you please try to give an answer", "It gets several upvotes. Then someone with a fancy academic", "points? (Please note, I do realize there may be more", "is what motivated my inquiries): Suppose I have written a", "how things work here, so for the sake of argument,", "question. On the flip side (and this is what motivated", "realize I need to articulate an additional question. On the", "to mine. His style is more authoritative than mine, but", "us cites any links. His answer gets upvoted like crazy.", "flip side (and this is what motivated my inquiries): Suppose", "(Please note, I do realize there may be more differences", "trying to figure out how things work here, so for", "to figure out how things work here, so for the", "mine. His style is more authoritative than mine, but we", "Suppose I have written a careful answer to a question.", "with a fancy academic position and a massive reputation score", "comments to my other question, I realize I need to", "I just need to be patient and slowly amass more", "to [Answering etiquette](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1753/answering-etiquette?noredirect=1#comment7510_1753) After a helpful answer and some helpful", "do about it? Can I at least take the moral", "answer to a question. It gets several upvotes. Then someone", "for the sake of argument, could you please try to", "Or is this a perfectly ethical artifact of the SE", "is this a perfectly ethical artifact of the SE system?", "you please try to give an answer based on my", "side (and this is what motivated my inquiries): Suppose I", "writes an answer which is (in my opinion, of course!)", "perfectly ethical artifact of the SE system? Do I just", "But I'm trying to figure out how things work here,", "artifact of the SE system? Do I just need to", "figure out how things work here, so for the sake", "a careful answer to a question. It gets several upvotes.", "I can do about it? Can I at least take", "than what I myself was able to perceive. But I'm", "related to [Answering etiquette](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1753/answering-etiquette?noredirect=1#comment7510_1753) After a helpful answer and some", "After a helpful answer and some helpful comments to my", "helpful answer and some helpful comments to my other question,", "is more authoritative than mine, but we are using the", "upvoted like crazy. Is there anything I can do about", "least take the moral high ground in my own thinking?", "careful answer to a question. It gets several upvotes. Then", "here, so for the sake of argument, could you please", "try to give an answer based on my premise? Thanks.)", "I need to articulate an additional question. On the flip", "several upvotes. Then someone with a fancy academic position and", "academic position and a massive reputation score comes along and", "anything I can do about it? Can I at least", "gets several upvotes. Then someone with a fancy academic position", "myself was able to perceive. But I'm trying to figure", "Neither one of us cites any links. His answer gets", "is (in my opinion, of course!) essentially equivalent to mine.", "like crazy. Is there anything I can do about it?", "about it? Can I at least take the moral high", "answers than what I myself was able to perceive. But", "more differences between our answers than what I myself was", "one of us cites any links. His answer gets upvoted", "equivalent to mine. His style is more authoritative than mine,", "authoritative than mine, but we are using the same logic", "to a question. It gets several upvotes. Then someone with", "moral high ground in my own thinking? Or is this", "than mine, but we are using the same logic and", "need to be patient and slowly amass more points? (Please", "to my other question, I realize I need to articulate", "perceive. But I'm trying to figure out how things work", "His answer gets upvoted like crazy. Is there anything I", "thinking? Or is this a perfectly ethical artifact of the", "written a careful answer to a question. It gets several", "there anything I can do about it? Can I at", "motivated my inquiries): Suppose I have written a careful answer", "to articulate an additional question. On the flip side (and", "(and this is what motivated my inquiries): Suppose I have", "On the flip side (and this is what motivated my", "just need to be patient and slowly amass more points?", "our answers than what I myself was able to perceive.", "additional question. On the flip side (and this is what", "His style is more authoritative than mine, but we are", "ground in my own thinking? Or is this a perfectly", "amass more points? (Please note, I do realize there may", "to be patient and slowly amass more points? (Please note,", "take the moral high ground in my own thinking? Or", "I at least take the moral high ground in my", "do realize there may be more differences between our answers", "be more differences between our answers than what I myself", "SE system? Do I just need to be patient and", "essentially equivalent to mine. His style is more authoritative than", "was able to perceive. But I'm trying to figure out", "of course!) essentially equivalent to mine. His style is more", "using the same logic and reach the same conclusion. Neither", "of us cites any links. His answer gets upvoted like", "Is there anything I can do about it? Can I", "fancy academic position and a massive reputation score comes along", "but we are using the same logic and reach the", "a perfectly ethical artifact of the SE system? Do I", "question is related to [Answering etiquette](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1753/answering-etiquette?noredirect=1#comment7510_1753) After a helpful answer", "we are using the same logic and reach the same", "slowly amass more points? (Please note, I do realize there", "and some helpful comments to my other question, I realize", "the sake of argument, could you please try to give", "[Answering etiquette](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1753/answering-etiquette?noredirect=1#comment7510_1753) After a helpful answer and some helpful comments", "gets upvoted like crazy. Is there anything I can do", "be patient and slowly amass more points? (Please note, I", "helpful comments to my other question, I realize I need", "a question. It gets several upvotes. Then someone with a", "score comes along and writes an answer which is (in", "please try to give an answer based on my premise?", "along and writes an answer which is (in my opinion,", "opinion, of course!) essentially equivalent to mine. His style is", "note, I do realize there may be more differences between", "answer gets upvoted like crazy. Is there anything I can", "I myself was able to perceive. But I'm trying to", "comes along and writes an answer which is (in my", "have written a careful answer to a question. It gets", "what motivated my inquiries): Suppose I have written a careful", "in my own thinking? Or is this a perfectly ethical", "which is (in my opinion, of course!) essentially equivalent to", "my own thinking? Or is this a perfectly ethical artifact", "more points? (Please note, I do realize there may be", "a massive reputation score comes along and writes an answer", "and writes an answer which is (in my opinion, of", "answer which is (in my opinion, of course!) essentially equivalent", "logic and reach the same conclusion. Neither one of us", "conclusion. Neither one of us cites any links. His answer", "crazy. Is there anything I can do about it? Can", "it? Can I at least take the moral high ground", "is related to [Answering etiquette](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1753/answering-etiquette?noredirect=1#comment7510_1753) After a helpful answer and", "other question, I realize I need to articulate an additional", "my opinion, of course!) essentially equivalent to mine. His style", "differences between our answers than what I myself was able", "could you please try to give an answer based on", "may be more differences between our answers than what I", "so for the sake of argument, could you please try", "things work here, so for the sake of argument, could", "own thinking? Or is this a perfectly ethical artifact of", "question, I realize I need to articulate an additional question.", "the SE system? Do I just need to be patient", "and a massive reputation score comes along and writes an", "style is more authoritative than mine, but we are using", "more authoritative than mine, but we are using the same", "the moral high ground in my own thinking? Or is", "to perceive. But I'm trying to figure out how things", "my other question, I realize I need to articulate an", "I have written a careful answer to a question. It", "an answer which is (in my opinion, of course!) essentially", "reputation score comes along and writes an answer which is", "can do about it? Can I at least take the", "the flip side (and this is what motivated my inquiries):", "realize there may be more differences between our answers than", "someone with a fancy academic position and a massive reputation", "This question is related to [Answering etiquette](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1753/answering-etiquette?noredirect=1#comment7510_1753) After a helpful", "I'm trying to figure out how things work here, so", "I do realize there may be more differences between our", "ethical artifact of the SE system? Do I just need", "cites any links. His answer gets upvoted like crazy. Is", "able to perceive. But I'm trying to figure out how" ]
[ "being off topic, etc., but do we maybe lose the", "a great fit for either community, is there a better", "questions go unanswered as a result of not being a", "benefit from a little help from other parts of SE", "for either community, is there a better place to ask", "Lately I've seen a few questions asked on Academia that", "going to have the reviewers there closing them immediately due", "more cross-pollination? Because a lot of these questions go unanswered", "questionnaire to support scanning and converting to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing", "on Academia that are academic in scope but might benefit", "known as being amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is the best", "Pushing these questions over to, say, StackOverflow is (rightly) going", "few questions asked on Academia that are academic in scope", "fit for either community, is there a better place to", "little help from other parts of SE because of their", "benefit of the entire community of StackExchange by not allowing", "allowing for more cross-pollination? Because a lot of these questions", "other parts of SE because of their technical nature. Some", "place to ask them? Chat, maybe? Something else? Is there", "research resources for which Wikipedia is known as being amongst", "best way to design a paper questionnaire to support scanning", "from a little help from other parts of SE because", "might benefit from a little help from other parts of", "over to, say, StackOverflow is (rightly) going to have the", "the best way to design a paper questionnaire to support", "StackExchange by not allowing for more cross-pollination? Because a lot", "cross-pollination? Because a lot of these questions go unanswered as", "seen a few questions asked on Academia that are academic", "to have the reviewers there closing them immediately due to", "of research resources for which Wikipedia is known as being", "community, is there a better place to ask them? Chat,", "is known as being amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is the", "lose the benefit of the entire community of StackExchange by", "their technical nature. Some examples: [Examples of research resources for", "there a role for hybrid SE communities? Just a thought...", "there a better place to ask them? Chat, maybe? Something", "asked on Academia that are academic in scope but might", "and converting to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these questions over to,", "do we maybe lose the benefit of the entire community", "Because a lot of these questions go unanswered as a", "there closing them immediately due to being off topic, etc.,", "the benefit of the entire community of StackExchange by not", "either community, is there a better place to ask them?", "ask them? Chat, maybe? Something else? Is there a role", "the reviewers there closing them immediately due to being off", "which Wikipedia is known as being amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What", "of the entire community of StackExchange by not allowing for", "a better place to ask them? Chat, maybe? Something else?", "due to being off topic, etc., but do we maybe", "of not being a great fit for either community, is", "for more cross-pollination? Because a lot of these questions go", "questions asked on Academia that are academic in scope but", "to, say, StackOverflow is (rightly) going to have the reviewers", "maybe lose the benefit of the entire community of StackExchange", "maybe? Something else? Is there a role for hybrid SE", "a little help from other parts of SE because of", "scope but might benefit from a little help from other", "result of not being a great fit for either community,", "because of their technical nature. Some examples: [Examples of research", "but do we maybe lose the benefit of the entire", "of these questions go unanswered as a result of not", "raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these questions over to, say, StackOverflow is", "have the reviewers there closing them immediately due to being", "entire community of StackExchange by not allowing for more cross-pollination?", "scanning and converting to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these questions over", "I've seen a few questions asked on Academia that are", "reviewers there closing them immediately due to being off topic,", "to support scanning and converting to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these", "these questions over to, say, StackOverflow is (rightly) going to", "design a paper questionnaire to support scanning and converting to", "a lot of these questions go unanswered as a result", "better place to ask them? Chat, maybe? Something else? Is", "Is there a role for hybrid SE communities? Just a", "the entire community of StackExchange by not allowing for more", "(rightly) going to have the reviewers there closing them immediately", "StackOverflow is (rightly) going to have the reviewers there closing", "that are academic in scope but might benefit from a", "resources for which Wikipedia is known as being amongst top", "of their technical nature. Some examples: [Examples of research resources", "Something else? Is there a role for hybrid SE communities?", "we maybe lose the benefit of the entire community of", "great fit for either community, is there a better place", "say, StackOverflow is (rightly) going to have the reviewers there", "a result of not being a great fit for either", "to ask them? Chat, maybe? Something else? Is there a", "as being amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is the best way", "topic, etc., but do we maybe lose the benefit of", "Academia that are academic in scope but might benefit from", "is (rightly) going to have the reviewers there closing them", "immediately due to being off topic, etc., but do we", "etc., but do we maybe lose the benefit of the", "being a great fit for either community, is there a", "way to design a paper questionnaire to support scanning and", "technical nature. Some examples: [Examples of research resources for which", "questions over to, say, StackOverflow is (rightly) going to have", "support scanning and converting to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these questions", "from other parts of SE because of their technical nature.", "not allowing for more cross-pollination? Because a lot of these", "by not allowing for more cross-pollination? Because a lot of", "lot of these questions go unanswered as a result of", "parts of SE because of their technical nature. Some examples:", "Chat, maybe? Something else? Is there a role for hybrid", "converting to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these questions over to, say,", "but might benefit from a little help from other parts", "nature. Some examples: [Examples of research resources for which Wikipedia", "Some examples: [Examples of research resources for which Wikipedia is", "for which Wikipedia is known as being amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top)", "[What is the best way to design a paper questionnaire", "to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these questions over to, say, StackOverflow", "as a result of not being a great fit for", "being amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is the best way to", "is the best way to design a paper questionnaire to", "in scope but might benefit from a little help from", "them? Chat, maybe? Something else? Is there a role for", "unanswered as a result of not being a great fit", "a paper questionnaire to support scanning and converting to raw", "to design a paper questionnaire to support scanning and converting", "data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558) Pushing these questions over to, say, StackOverflow is (rightly)", "not being a great fit for either community, is there", "referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is the best way to design a paper", "off topic, etc., but do we maybe lose the benefit", "else? Is there a role for hybrid SE communities? Just", "academic in scope but might benefit from a little help", "these questions go unanswered as a result of not being", "to being off topic, etc., but do we maybe lose", "them immediately due to being off topic, etc., but do", "go unanswered as a result of not being a great", "Wikipedia is known as being amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is", "community of StackExchange by not allowing for more cross-pollination? Because", "closing them immediately due to being off topic, etc., but", "is there a better place to ask them? Chat, maybe?", "amongst top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is the best way to design", "a few questions asked on Academia that are academic in", "are academic in scope but might benefit from a little", "paper questionnaire to support scanning and converting to raw data?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/43353/what-is-the-best-way-to-design-a-paper-questionnaire-to-support-scanning-and-con/44558#44558)", "help from other parts of SE because of their technical", "[Examples of research resources for which Wikipedia is known as", "of StackExchange by not allowing for more cross-pollination? Because a", "SE because of their technical nature. Some examples: [Examples of", "of SE because of their technical nature. Some examples: [Examples", "top referrers?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41831/examples-of-research-resources-for-which-wikipedia-is-known-as-being-amongst-top) [What is the best way to design a", "examples: [Examples of research resources for which Wikipedia is known" ]
[ "internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like to get some feedback on two", "([Are question about job outside academia but related to on", "topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are questions regarding academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like", "off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like to get some feedback on two very", "off-topic. The second question, [Does name of university matter for", "of the two questions above is inconsistent and, I must", "duplicate of the other, but that is another matter). However,", "the two questions above is inconsistent and, I must say,", "my mind (perhaps, one is a duplicate of the other,", "say, confusing (to me, anyway). Why were these two questions", "two very similar questions related to non-academic jobs/internships which were", "two questions above is inconsistent and, I must say, confusing", "[Does name of university matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not closed.", "related to non-academic jobs/internships which were handled very differently. The", "similar to my mind (perhaps, one is a duplicate of", "were handled very differently. The first question, [Does your university", "to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are questions regarding academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)),", "job outside academia but related to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are", "like to get some feedback on two very similar questions", "above is inconsistent and, I must say, confusing (to me,", "matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not closed. These two questions seem", "mind (perhaps, one is a duplicate of the other, but", "to my mind (perhaps, one is a duplicate of the", "to non-academic jobs/internships which were handled very differently. The first", "is another matter). However, the outcomes of the two questions", "question, [Does name of university matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not", "for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not closed. These two questions seem to", "me, anyway). Why were these two questions handled so differently", "outside academia but related to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are questions", "other, but that is another matter). However, the outcomes of", "meta questions ([Are question about job outside academia but related", "on two very similar questions related to non-academic jobs/internships which", "not closed. These two questions seem to be quite similar", "to be quite similar to my mind (perhaps, one is", "I'd like to get some feedback on two very similar", "of university matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not closed. These two", "recent meta questions ([Are question about job outside academia but", "that is another matter). However, the outcomes of the two", "internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not closed. These two questions seem to be", "very similar questions related to non-academic jobs/internships which were handled", "these two questions handled so differently by the \"powers that", "name of university matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not closed. These", "similar questions related to non-academic jobs/internships which were handled very", "[Are questions regarding academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like to get", "non-academic jobs/internships which were handled very differently. The first question,", "outcomes of the two questions above is inconsistent and, I", "academia but related to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are questions regarding", "about job outside academia but related to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and", "feedback on two very similar questions related to non-academic jobs/internships", "The second question, [Does name of university matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships),", "get some feedback on two very similar questions related to", "I must say, confusing (to me, anyway). Why were these", "to get some feedback on two very similar questions related", "However, the outcomes of the two questions above is inconsistent", "questions ([Are question about job outside academia but related to", "be quite similar to my mind (perhaps, one is a", "quite similar to my mind (perhaps, one is a duplicate", "matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed as off-topic. The second question, [Does name", "and [Are questions regarding academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like to", "(to me, anyway). Why were these two questions handled so", "questions seem to be quite similar to my mind (perhaps,", "questions related to non-academic jobs/internships which were handled very differently.", "closed. These two questions seem to be quite similar to", "two questions handled so differently by the \"powers that be?\"", "was closed as off-topic. The second question, [Does name of", "is a duplicate of the other, but that is another", "a duplicate of the other, but that is another matter).", "was not closed. These two questions seem to be quite", "must say, confusing (to me, anyway). Why were these two", "two questions seem to be quite similar to my mind", "is inconsistent and, I must say, confusing (to me, anyway).", "first question, [Does your university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed as", "the outcomes of the two questions above is inconsistent and,", "[Does your university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed as off-topic. The", "questions above is inconsistent and, I must say, confusing (to", "differently. The first question, [Does your university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was", "(perhaps, one is a duplicate of the other, but that", "some feedback on two very similar questions related to non-academic", "inconsistent and, I must say, confusing (to me, anyway). Why", "but that is another matter). However, the outcomes of the", "your university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed as off-topic. The second", "question, [Does your university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed as off-topic.", "very differently. The first question, [Does your university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter),", "regarding academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like to get some feedback", "of the other, but that is another matter). However, the", "on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are questions regarding academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd", "jobs/internships which were handled very differently. The first question, [Does", "one is a duplicate of the other, but that is", "seem to be quite similar to my mind (perhaps, one", "question about job outside academia but related to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic)", "questions regarding academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like to get some", "academic internships off-topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1742/are-questions-regarding-academic-internships-off-topic)), I'd like to get some feedback on", "the other, but that is another matter). However, the outcomes", "as off-topic. The second question, [Does name of university matter", "handled very differently. The first question, [Does your university name", "and, I must say, confusing (to me, anyway). Why were", "matter). However, the outcomes of the two questions above is", "anyway). Why were these two questions handled so differently by", "university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed as off-topic. The second question,", "confusing (to me, anyway). Why were these two questions handled", "These two questions seem to be quite similar to my", "Why were these two questions handled so differently by the", "by recent meta questions ([Are question about job outside academia", "university matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was not closed. These two questions", "closed as off-topic. The second question, [Does name of university", "related to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are questions regarding academic internships", "second question, [Does name of university matter for internships?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/44685/does-name-of-university-matter-for-internships), was", "The first question, [Does your university name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed", "which were handled very differently. The first question, [Does your", "were these two questions handled so differently by the \"powers", "another matter). However, the outcomes of the two questions above", "Inspired by recent meta questions ([Are question about job outside", "but related to on topic?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1713/are-question-about-job-outside-academia-but-related-to-on-topic) and [Are questions regarding academic", "name matter?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/34899/does-your-university-name-matter), was closed as off-topic. The second question, [Does" ]
[ "to being too broad. However, recently the question was reopened", "due to being too broad. However, recently the question was", "me a long time ago, was closed due to being", "person who reopened the question) care to explain the rationale", "(maybe the person who reopened the question) care to explain", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29805/what-is-the-point-of-traditional-lectures) concerning the value about traditional lecture, which was posted", "the question was reopened and, judging from the downvotes, it", "the person who reopened the question) care to explain the", "the value about traditional lecture, which was posted by me", "and, judging from the downvotes, it is clear that the", "value about traditional lecture, which was posted by me a", "a long time ago, was closed due to being too", "[This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/29805/what-is-the-point-of-traditional-lectures) concerning the value about traditional lecture, which was", "the question) care to explain the rationale behind reopening this", "it is clear that the question is still not well-received.", "reopened and, judging from the downvotes, it is clear that", "question is still not well-received. Would someone (maybe the person", "too broad. However, recently the question was reopened and, judging", "care to explain the rationale behind reopening this old question?", "about traditional lecture, which was posted by me a long", "judging from the downvotes, it is clear that the question", "However, recently the question was reopened and, judging from the", "traditional lecture, which was posted by me a long time", "from the downvotes, it is clear that the question is", "the downvotes, it is clear that the question is still", "well-received. Would someone (maybe the person who reopened the question)", "Would someone (maybe the person who reopened the question) care", "clear that the question is still not well-received. Would someone", "long time ago, was closed due to being too broad.", "was posted by me a long time ago, was closed", "ago, was closed due to being too broad. However, recently", "lecture, which was posted by me a long time ago,", "being too broad. However, recently the question was reopened and,", "concerning the value about traditional lecture, which was posted by", "which was posted by me a long time ago, was", "posted by me a long time ago, was closed due", "was closed due to being too broad. However, recently the", "downvotes, it is clear that the question is still not", "broad. However, recently the question was reopened and, judging from", "who reopened the question) care to explain the rationale behind", "question) care to explain the rationale behind reopening this old", "not well-received. Would someone (maybe the person who reopened the", "reopened the question) care to explain the rationale behind reopening", "by me a long time ago, was closed due to", "is clear that the question is still not well-received. Would", "that the question is still not well-received. Would someone (maybe", "someone (maybe the person who reopened the question) care to", "still not well-received. Would someone (maybe the person who reopened", "time ago, was closed due to being too broad. However,", "was reopened and, judging from the downvotes, it is clear", "the question is still not well-received. Would someone (maybe the", "recently the question was reopened and, judging from the downvotes,", "question was reopened and, judging from the downvotes, it is", "is still not well-received. Would someone (maybe the person who", "closed due to being too broad. However, recently the question" ]
[ "got a message from the moderators saying someone, whom they", "possible to contact them except by flagging a posting (and", "question on a different topic, a person who disagreed with", "But I still don't know the nature of the complaint", "told that the nature of the complaint and the identity", "made these comments only because he objected to something about", "rise to a suspicion about who it was. The moderators", "from the person who stalked and harassed me, explaining that", "was \"stalking and harassing\" him, using my words, not quite", "I am told in an answer below that I omitted", "paper arguing in favor or a certain proposition. I didn't", "about who it was. The moderators suspended me for seven", "harassing\" him, using my words, not quite verbatim. Naturally this", "not \"stalk and harass\" him like that. I did not", "When the suspension ended I did flag a posting from", "that. I did not report his behavior to the moderators", "the behavior of the poster. After two days I've heard", "proposition in the question; that would be off topic and", "concerning the following behavior? * I posted a question asking", "and they cut you off from being able to reply", "question on a different topic. I told him I would", "timing. The moderators are anonymous and it is not possible", "he objected to something about an earlier question on a", "they did not identify, had complained that I was \"stalking", "that proposition in the question; that would be off topic", "I could tell, he made these comments only because he", "be a good journal to which to submit a paper", "about an earlier question on a different topic. I told", "and harassing\" him, using my words, not quite verbatim. Naturally", "words, not quite verbatim. Naturally this gave rise to a", "off from being able to reply to them when they", "I was \"stalking and harassing\" him, using my words, not", "yet been written. As far as I could tell, he", "mentioned but not defended in my earlier question posted several", "nothing. So it seems it is about who goes to", "about who goes to the moderators first. Are the behaviors", "the suspension ended I did flag a posting from the", "am told in an answer below that I omitted many", "this community's standards concerning the following behavior? * I posted", "which he called the proposed, and in fact not yet", "complained that I was \"stalking and harassing\" him, using my", "about timing. The moderators are anonymous and it is not", "would not \"stalk and harass\" him like that. I did", "you can't flag comments) and they cut you off from", "particular posting but about the behavior of the poster. After", "in the question; that would be off topic and would", "does so first, and whoever does so first wins. It's", "on a different topic, a person who disagreed with the", "is the person more inclined to report things to the", "it seems it is about who goes to the moderators", "concern was not about that particular posting but about the", "far as I could tell, he made these comments only", "Then I got a message from the moderators saying someone,", "he called the proposed, and in fact not yet written,", "posting but about the behavior of the poster. After two", "in my earlier question posted several comments in which he", "report things to the moderators does so first, and whoever", "behavior of the poster. After two days I've heard nothing.", "far to long. * Next time I posted a question", "which to submit a paper arguing in favor or a", "about a paper he has not read, since it has", "to submit a paper arguing in favor or a certain", "been written. As far as I could tell, he made", "details. But I still don't know the nature of the", "explicitly told that the nature of the complaint and the", "flagging a posting (and you can't flag comments) and they", "I posted a question on a different topic, a person", "poster. After two days I've heard nothing. So it seems", "that particular posting but about the behavior of the poster.", "Are the behaviors described in the bullet points above considered", "that my concern was not about that particular posting but", "didn't try to argue for that proposition in the question;", "something about an earlier question on a different topic. I", "you off from being able to reply to them when", "it is not possible to contact them except by flagging", "because he objected to something about an earlier question on", "the participants in academia.stackexchange.com or by its moderators? PS: I", "posting (and you can't flag comments) and they cut you", "considered appropriate by the participants in academia.stackexchange.com or by its", "reply to them when they inform you of their decision.", "report his behavior to the moderators at that time. Then", "favor or a certain proposition. I didn't try to argue", "and it is not possible to contact them except by", "the moderators saying someone, whom they did not identify, had", "in favor or a certain proposition. I didn't try to", "a posting (and you can't flag comments) and they cut", "a different topic, a person who disagreed with the opinion", "on a different topic. I told him I would not", "it has not yet been written. As far as I", "cut you off from being able to reply to them", "only because he objected to something about an earlier question", "did not identify, had complained that I was \"stalking and", "an earlier question on a different topic. I told him", "able to reply to them when they inform you of", "know the nature of the complaint about me, and I", "not report his behavior to the moderators at that time.", "inclined to report things to the moderators does so first,", "from being able to reply to them when they inform", "so first wins. It's all about timing. The moderators are", "PS: I am told in an answer below that I", "in the bullet points above considered appropriate by the participants", "can't flag comments) and they cut you off from being", "whom they did not identify, had complained that I was", "am left to guess. I was explicitly told that the", "objected to something about an earlier question on a different", "who it was. The moderators suspended me for seven days.", "a good journal to which to submit a paper arguing", "to them when they inform you of their decision. When", "moderators does so first, and whoever does so first wins.", "try to argue for that proposition in the question; that", "the person who stalked and harassed me, explaining that my", "different topic, a person who disagreed with the opinion that", "by the participants in academia.stackexchange.com or by its moderators? PS:", "anonymous and it is not possible to contact them except", "harassed me, explaining that my concern was not about that", "with the opinion that had been mentioned but not defended", "tell, he made these comments only because he objected to", "left to guess. I was explicitly told that the nature", "posting from the person who stalked and harassed me, explaining", "of the poster. After two days I've heard nothing. So", "time I posted a question on a different topic, a", "Naturally this gave rise to a suspicion about who it", "wins. It's all about timing. The moderators are anonymous and", "submit a paper arguing in favor or a certain proposition.", "What are this community's standards concerning the following behavior? ", "answer below that I omitted many relevant details. But I", "flag comments) and they cut you off from being able", "whoever does so first wins. It's all about timing. The", "the complaint and the identity of the complainant would be", "long. Next time I posted a question on a", "in fact not yet written, paper a \"rant\", and \"ranting\".", "that I was \"stalking and harassing\" him, using my words,", "for seven days. One lesson is the person more inclined", "moderators are anonymous and it is not possible to contact", "the following behavior? * I posted a question asking what", "that would be off topic and would take far to", "points above considered appropriate by the participants in academia.stackexchange.com or", "the person more inclined to report things to the moderators", "had been mentioned but not defended in my earlier question", "appropriate by the participants in academia.stackexchange.com or by its moderators?", "him, using my words, not quite verbatim. Naturally this gave", "the poster. After two days I've heard nothing. So it", "did flag a posting from the person who stalked and", "in academia.stackexchange.com or by its moderators? PS: I am told", "omitted many relevant details. But I still don't know the", "below that I omitted many relevant details. But I still", "him like that. I did not report his behavior to", "comments) and they cut you off from being able to", "to argue for that proposition in the question; that would", "a posting from the person who stalked and harassed me,", "had complained that I was \"stalking and harassing\" him, using", "a paper he has not read, since it has not", "and would take far to long. * Next time I", "yet written, paper a \"rant\", and \"ranting\". This about a", "in an answer below that I omitted many relevant details.", "The moderators are anonymous and it is not possible to", "question asking what would be a good journal to which", "or a certain proposition. I didn't try to argue for", "his behavior to the moderators at that time. Then I", "This about a paper he has not read, since it", "goes to the moderators first. Are the behaviors described in", "of the complaint about me, and I am left to", "could tell, he made these comments only because he objected", "not yet written, paper a \"rant\", and \"ranting\". This about", "several comments in which he called the proposed, and in", "to the moderators first. Are the behaviors described in the", "decision. When the suspension ended I did flag a posting", "a suspicion about who it was. The moderators suspended me", "and \"ranting\". This about a paper he has not read,", "the behaviors described in the bullet points above considered appropriate", "read, since it has not yet been written. As far", "certain proposition. I didn't try to argue for that proposition", "journal to which to submit a paper arguing in favor", "an answer below that I omitted many relevant details. But", "verbatim. Naturally this gave rise to a suspicion about who", "me, and I am left to guess. I was explicitly", "my words, not quite verbatim. Naturally this gave rise to", "for that proposition in the question; that would be off", "not about that particular posting but about the behavior of", "as I could tell, he made these comments only because", "suspension ended I did flag a posting from the person", "not quite verbatim. Naturally this gave rise to a suspicion", "the moderators first. Are the behaviors described in the bullet", "the identity of the complainant would be kept from me.", "called the proposed, and in fact not yet written, paper", "and I am left to guess. I was explicitly told", "all about timing. The moderators are anonymous and it is", "seven days. One lesson is the person more inclined to", "written, paper a \"rant\", and \"ranting\". This about a paper", "I did flag a posting from the person who stalked", "earlier question posted several comments in which he called the", "are this community's standards concerning the following behavior? * I", "me for seven days. One lesson is the person more", "would be a good journal to which to submit a", "you of their decision. When the suspension ended I did", "community's standards concerning the following behavior? * I posted a", "a certain proposition. I didn't try to argue for that", "I would not \"stalk and harass\" him like that. I", "since it has not yet been written. As far as", "them except by flagging a posting (and you can't flag", "defended in my earlier question posted several comments in which", "has not yet been written. As far as I could", "would be off topic and would take far to long.", "relevant details. But I still don't know the nature of", "a question on a different topic, a person who disagreed", "this gave rise to a suspicion about who it was.", "to report things to the moderators does so first, and", "* Next time I posted a question on a different", "standards concerning the following behavior? * I posted a question", "not yet been written. As far as I could tell,", "question; that would be off topic and would take far", "message from the moderators saying someone, whom they did not", "fact not yet written, paper a \"rant\", and \"ranting\". This", "gave rise to a suspicion about who it was. The", "the complaint about me, and I am left to guess.", "following behavior? * I posted a question asking what would", "moderators first. Are the behaviors described in the bullet points", "\"stalk and harass\" him like that. I did not report", "two days I've heard nothing. So it seems it is", "who disagreed with the opinion that had been mentioned but", "I've heard nothing. So it seems it is about who", "As far as I could tell, he made these comments", "using my words, not quite verbatim. Naturally this gave rise", "at that time. Then I got a message from the", "the moderators does so first, and whoever does so first", "the nature of the complaint about me, and I am", "days I've heard nothing. So it seems it is about", "they cut you off from being able to reply to", "still don't know the nature of the complaint about me,", "or by its moderators? PS: I am told in an", "they inform you of their decision. When the suspension ended", "harass\" him like that. I did not report his behavior", "bullet points above considered appropriate by the participants in academia.stackexchange.com", "described in the bullet points above considered appropriate by the", "did not report his behavior to the moderators at that", "\"rant\", and \"ranting\". This about a paper he has not", "them when they inform you of their decision. When the", "guess. I was explicitly told that the nature of the", "* I posted a question asking what would be a", "not read, since it has not yet been written. As", "opinion that had been mentioned but not defended in my", "he has not read, since it has not yet been", "different topic. I told him I would not \"stalk and", "was not about that particular posting but about the behavior", "identify, had complained that I was \"stalking and harassing\" him,", "good journal to which to submit a paper arguing in", "first. Are the behaviors described in the bullet points above", "told in an answer below that I omitted many relevant", "what would be a good journal to which to submit", "contact them except by flagging a posting (and you can't", "person who stalked and harassed me, explaining that my concern", "moderators saying someone, whom they did not identify, had complained", "a person who disagreed with the opinion that had been", "who goes to the moderators first. Are the behaviors described", "to reply to them when they inform you of their", "nature of the complaint about me, and I am left", "moderators? PS: I am told in an answer below that", "and harassed me, explaining that my concern was not about", "posted a question asking what would be a good journal", "that I omitted many relevant details. But I still don't", "moderators at that time. Then I got a message from", "that time. Then I got a message from the moderators", "days. One lesson is the person more inclined to report", "arguing in favor or a certain proposition. I didn't try", "my earlier question posted several comments in which he called", "he made these comments only because he objected to something", "and in fact not yet written, paper a \"rant\", and", "to guess. I was explicitly told that the nature of", "was explicitly told that the nature of the complaint and", "so first, and whoever does so first wins. It's all", "person more inclined to report things to the moderators does", "first wins. It's all about timing. The moderators are anonymous", "I still don't know the nature of the complaint about", "person who disagreed with the opinion that had been mentioned", "posted several comments in which he called the proposed, and", "\"stalking and harassing\" him, using my words, not quite verbatim.", "quite verbatim. Naturally this gave rise to a suspicion about", "seems it is about who goes to the moderators first.", "things to the moderators does so first, and whoever does", "I didn't try to argue for that proposition in the", "behavior? * I posted a question asking what would be", "told him I would not \"stalk and harass\" him like", "but about the behavior of the poster. After two days", "argue for that proposition in the question; that would be", "time. Then I got a message from the moderators saying", "it was. The moderators suspended me for seven days. One", "explaining that my concern was not about that particular posting", "I got a message from the moderators saying someone, whom", "don't know the nature of the complaint about me, and", "One lesson is the person more inclined to report things", "earlier question on a different topic. I told him I", "the opinion that had been mentioned but not defended in", "by its moderators? PS: I am told in an answer", "posted a question on a different topic, a person who", "the nature of the complaint and the identity of the", "in which he called the proposed, and in fact not", "not identify, had complained that I was \"stalking and harassing\"", "After two days I've heard nothing. So it seems it", "who stalked and harassed me, explaining that my concern was", "to the moderators does so first, and whoever does so", "of the complaint and the identity of the complainant would", "stalked and harassed me, explaining that my concern was not", "complaint about me, and I am left to guess. I", "from the moderators saying someone, whom they did not identify,", "to the moderators at that time. Then I got a", "comments in which he called the proposed, and in fact", "a different topic. I told him I would not \"stalk", "but not defended in my earlier question posted several comments", "complaint and the identity of the complainant would be kept", "\"ranting\". This about a paper he has not read, since", "paper he has not read, since it has not yet", "that the nature of the complaint and the identity of", "to a suspicion about who it was. The moderators suspended", "a \"rant\", and \"ranting\". This about a paper he has", "flag a posting from the person who stalked and harassed", "is about who goes to the moderators first. Are the", "first, and whoever does so first wins. It's all about", "a paper arguing in favor or a certain proposition. I", "been mentioned but not defended in my earlier question posted", "Next time I posted a question on a different topic,", "proposed, and in fact not yet written, paper a \"rant\",", "the moderators at that time. Then I got a message", "a message from the moderators saying someone, whom they did", "to contact them except by flagging a posting (and you", "inform you of their decision. When the suspension ended I", "behavior to the moderators at that time. Then I got", "being able to reply to them when they inform you", "take far to long. * Next time I posted a", "to something about an earlier question on a different topic.", "more inclined to report things to the moderators does so", "saying someone, whom they did not identify, had complained that", "does so first wins. It's all about timing. The moderators", "are anonymous and it is not possible to contact them", "and the identity of the complainant would be kept from", "I did not report his behavior to the moderators at", "written. As far as I could tell, he made these", "not possible to contact them except by flagging a posting", "I told him I would not \"stalk and harass\" him", "it is about who goes to the moderators first. Are", "that had been mentioned but not defended in my earlier", "their decision. When the suspension ended I did flag a", "was. The moderators suspended me for seven days. One lesson", "The moderators suspended me for seven days. One lesson is", "asking what would be a good journal to which to", "disagreed with the opinion that had been mentioned but not", "comments only because he objected to something about an earlier", "and harass\" him like that. I did not report his", "topic and would take far to long. * Next time", "the bullet points above considered appropriate by the participants in", "about me, and I am left to guess. I was", "has not read, since it has not yet been written.", "I was explicitly told that the nature of the complaint", "its moderators? PS: I am told in an answer below", "my concern was not about that particular posting but about", "academia.stackexchange.com or by its moderators? PS: I am told in", "and whoever does so first wins. It's all about timing.", "question posted several comments in which he called the proposed,", "of their decision. When the suspension ended I did flag", "to which to submit a paper arguing in favor or", "I am left to guess. I was explicitly told that", "the proposed, and in fact not yet written, paper a", "off topic and would take far to long. * Next", "It's all about timing. The moderators are anonymous and it", "these comments only because he objected to something about an", "a question asking what would be a good journal to", "not defended in my earlier question posted several comments in", "paper a \"rant\", and \"ranting\". This about a paper he", "someone, whom they did not identify, had complained that I", "lesson is the person more inclined to report things to", "be off topic and would take far to long. ", "me, explaining that my concern was not about that particular", "about the behavior of the poster. After two days I've", "ended I did flag a posting from the person who", "him I would not \"stalk and harass\" him like that.", "moderators suspended me for seven days. One lesson is the", "is not possible to contact them except by flagging a", "proposition. I didn't try to argue for that proposition in", "participants in academia.stackexchange.com or by its moderators? PS:* I am", "suspicion about who it was. The moderators suspended me for", "(and you can't flag comments) and they cut you off", "by flagging a posting (and you can't flag comments) and", "like that. I did not report his behavior to the", "So it seems it is about who goes to the", "when they inform you of their decision. When the suspension", "topic, a person who disagreed with the opinion that had", "the question; that would be off topic and would take", "about that particular posting but about the behavior of the", "except by flagging a posting (and you can't flag comments)", "to long. * Next time I posted a question on", "I omitted many relevant details. But I still don't know", "nature of the complaint and the identity of the complainant", "would take far to long. * Next time I posted", "above considered appropriate by the participants in academia.stackexchange.com or by", "heard nothing. So it seems it is about who goes", "many relevant details. But I still don't know the nature", "I posted a question asking what would be a good", "topic. I told him I would not \"stalk and harass\"", "suspended me for seven days. One lesson is the person", "behaviors described in the bullet points above considered appropriate by" ]
[ "and to do research in college, I need a solid", "research make it inadvertently backwards? > > > My other", "relevant to high enough levels, though it does rest in", "possibly unique in that it is written by a student", "of astronomy - my hopeful major/specialty - at a college.", "- my hopeful major/specialty - at a college. He said", "opinion in many of them. However, I can't tell if", "tell if this is okay in the case of my", "bit unsure as to whether or not a question I", "not a question I have in mind is appropriate for", "Academia, and it seems like there is room for opinion", "possible in college - I'm already doing some independent work", "> > > My other concern - besides it perhaps", "> > This seems like wise advice - you need", "not being relevant to high enough levels, though it does", "graduate school. My question would be along these lines: >", "good one, or does the possibility of research make it", "college - I'm already doing some independent work at the", "to things that may be more advanced. The problem, though,", "besides it perhaps not being relevant to high enough levels,", "> This seems like wise advice - you need to", "if this is okay in the case of my question", "ask about it on meta. It's possibly unique in that", "unsure as to whether or not a question I have", "already doing some independent work at the moment - and", "those curricula would be relevant to graduate school. My question", "school - is that it seems a little opinion-based. I've", "the moment - and to do research in college, I", "college curricula while considering how those curricula would be relevant", "part on graduate school - is that it seems a", "the field is to take as few astronomy classes in", "once talked with a professor of astronomy - my hopeful", "it seems a little opinion-based. I've read through many questions", "The problem, though, is that I'd like to do undergraduate", "research as soon as possible in college - I'm already", "to ask about it on meta. It's possibly unique in", "at college curricula while considering how those curricula would be", "Exchange, so I decided to ask about it on meta.", "physics classes as possible) and to take as many astronomy", "classes as possible) and to take as many astronomy classes", "many physics classes as possible) and to take as many", "astronomy research as soon as possible in college - I'm", "> > Is this recommendation a good one, or does", "appropriate for Academia Stack Exchange, so I decided to ask", "does the possibility of research make it inadvertently backwards? >", "college as possible (and as many physics classes as possible)", "My question would be along these lines: > > I", "on the basics before moving on to things that may", "inadvertently backwards? > > > My other concern - besides", "question or not. Is this question okay for Academia Stack", "research in college, I need a solid block of astronomy", "to take as few astronomy classes in college as possible", "> > > This seems like wise advice - you", "for Academia Stack Exchange, so I decided to ask about", "be relevant to graduate school. My question would be along", "you need to focus on the basics before moving on", "need to focus on the basics before moving on to", "I need a solid block of astronomy courses. > >", "my hopeful major/specialty - at a college. He said that", "unique in that it is written by a student in", "solid block of astronomy courses. > > > Is this", "it inadvertently backwards? > > > My other concern -", "- besides it perhaps not being relevant to high enough", "in the case of my question or not. Is this", "how those curricula would be relevant to graduate school. My", "physics classes as possible). > > > This seems like", "- you need to focus on the basics before moving", "whether or not a question I have in mind is", "of research make it inadvertently backwards? > > > My", "rest in part on graduate school - is that it", "to take as many astronomy classes in graduate school as", "many questions on Academia, and it seems like there is", "written by a student in high school looking at college", "meta. It's possibly unique in that it is written by", "hopeful major/specialty - at a college. He said that the", "before moving on to things that may be more advanced.", "relevant to graduate school. My question would be along these", "classes in college as possible (and as many physics classes", "perhaps not being relevant to high enough levels, though it", "wise advice - you need to focus on the basics", "> > My other concern - besides it perhaps not", "this is okay in the case of my question or", "opinion-based. I've read through many questions on Academia, and it", "of my question or not. Is this question okay for", "in mind is appropriate for Academia Stack Exchange, so I", "of astronomy courses. > > > Is this recommendation a", "be more advanced. The problem, though, is that I'd like", "> Is this recommendation a good one, or does the", "to do undergraduate astronomy research as soon as possible in", "professor of astronomy - my hopeful major/specialty - at a", "few astronomy classes in college as possible (and as many", "doing well in the field is to take as few", "in many of them. However, I can't tell if this", "(and as many physics classes as possible) and to take", "as many astronomy classes in graduate school as possible (and", "some independent work at the moment - and to do", "to focus on the basics before moving on to things", "read through many questions on Academia, and it seems like", "one, or does the possibility of research make it inadvertently", "possible (and as many physics classes as possible) and to", "have in mind is appropriate for Academia Stack Exchange, so", "in graduate school as possible (and as few physics classes", "school as possible (and as few physics classes as possible).", "can't tell if this is okay in the case of", "My other concern - besides it perhaps not being relevant", "the basics before moving on to things that may be", "it perhaps not being relevant to high enough levels, though", "I decided to ask about it on meta. It's possibly", "to do research in college, I need a solid block", "moving on to things that may be more advanced. The", "in part on graduate school - is that it seems", "of them. However, I can't tell if this is okay", "okay in the case of my question or not. Is", "to whether or not a question I have in mind", "question I have in mind is appropriate for Academia Stack", "undergraduate astronomy research as soon as possible in college -", "However, I can't tell if this is okay in the", "mind is appropriate for Academia Stack Exchange, so I decided", "> My other concern - besides it perhaps not being", "curricula would be relevant to graduate school. My question would", "He said that the key to doing well in the", "levels, though it does rest in part on graduate school", "that the key to doing well in the field is", "classes as possible). > > > This seems like wise", "graduate school as possible (and as few physics classes as", "astronomy - my hopeful major/specialty - at a college. He", "Is this recommendation a good one, or does the possibility", "considering how those curricula would be relevant to graduate school.", "student in high school looking at college curricula while considering", "(and as few physics classes as possible). > > >", "Academia Stack Exchange, so I decided to ask about it", "- I'm already doing some independent work at the moment", "backwards? > > > My other concern - besides it", "along these lines: > > I once talked with a", "few physics classes as possible). > > > This seems", "the possibility of research make it inadvertently backwards? > >", "room for opinion in many of them. However, I can't", "a solid block of astronomy courses. > > > Is", "as possible). > > > This seems like wise advice", "in college as possible (and as many physics classes as", "possible (and as few physics classes as possible). > >", "with a professor of astronomy - my hopeful major/specialty -", "in college, I need a solid block of astronomy courses.", "be along these lines: > > I once talked with", "at a college. He said that the key to doing", "would be relevant to graduate school. My question would be", "on Academia, and it seems like there is room for", "as possible in college - I'm already doing some independent", "high school looking at college curricula while considering how those", "other concern - besides it perhaps not being relevant to", "while considering how those curricula would be relevant to graduate", "possible). > > > This seems like wise advice -", "soon as possible in college - I'm already doing some", "does rest in part on graduate school - is that", "college, I need a solid block of astronomy courses. >", "as to whether or not a question I have in", "classes in graduate school as possible (and as few physics", "moment - and to do research in college, I need", "enough levels, though it does rest in part on graduate", "possibility of research make it inadvertently backwards? > > >", "I can't tell if this is okay in the case", "or not a question I have in mind is appropriate", "major/specialty - at a college. He said that the key", "I've read through many questions on Academia, and it seems", "take as many astronomy classes in graduate school as possible", "it does rest in part on graduate school - is", "to doing well in the field is to take as", "the case of my question or not. Is this question", "I'd like to do undergraduate astronomy research as soon as", "a student in high school looking at college curricula while", "said that the key to doing well in the field", "astronomy classes in graduate school as possible (and as few", "is to take as few astronomy classes in college as", "a college. He said that the key to doing well", "a good one, or does the possibility of research make", "is that I'd like to do undergraduate astronomy research as", "seems like wise advice - you need to focus on", "recommendation a good one, or does the possibility of research", "I have in mind is appropriate for Academia Stack Exchange,", "make it inadvertently backwards? > > > My other concern", "a little opinion-based. I've read through many questions on Academia,", "advanced. The problem, though, is that I'd like to do", "as few astronomy classes in college as possible (and as", "a question I have in mind is appropriate for Academia", "the key to doing well in the field is to", "basics before moving on to things that may be more", "questions on Academia, and it seems like there is room", "college. He said that the key to doing well in", "block of astronomy courses. > > > Is this recommendation", "there is room for opinion in many of them. However,", "like there is room for opinion in many of them.", "as possible (and as many physics classes as possible) and", "is written by a student in high school looking at", "as possible (and as few physics classes as possible). >", "though, is that I'd like to do undergraduate astronomy research", "problem, though, is that I'd like to do undergraduate astronomy", "I'm a bit unsure as to whether or not a", "many of them. However, I can't tell if this is", "doing some independent work at the moment - and to", "through many questions on Academia, and it seems like there", "them. However, I can't tell if this is okay in", "in the field is to take as few astronomy classes", "I once talked with a professor of astronomy - my", "as few physics classes as possible). > > > This", "on to things that may be more advanced. The problem,", "like wise advice - you need to focus on the", "advice - you need to focus on the basics before", "school. My question would be along these lines: > >", "key to doing well in the field is to take", "as possible) and to take as many astronomy classes in", "> > > Is this recommendation a good one, or", "looking at college curricula while considering how those curricula would", "would be along these lines: > > I once talked", "many astronomy classes in graduate school as possible (and as", "though it does rest in part on graduate school -", "talked with a professor of astronomy - my hopeful major/specialty", "this recommendation a good one, or does the possibility of", "question would be along these lines: > > I once", "it is written by a student in high school looking", "that it seems a little opinion-based. I've read through many", "on meta. It's possibly unique in that it is written", "and to take as many astronomy classes in graduate school", "lines: > > I once talked with a professor of", "these lines: > > I once talked with a professor", "things that may be more advanced. The problem, though, is", "as soon as possible in college - I'm already doing", "It's possibly unique in that it is written by a", "or not. Is this question okay for Academia Stack Exchange?", "is appropriate for Academia Stack Exchange, so I decided to", "astronomy courses. > > > Is this recommendation a good", "take as few astronomy classes in college as possible (and", "a bit unsure as to whether or not a question", "is okay in the case of my question or not.", "my question or not. Is this question okay for Academia", "it on meta. It's possibly unique in that it is", "for opinion in many of them. However, I can't tell", "it seems like there is room for opinion in many", "seems a little opinion-based. I've read through many questions on", "to graduate school. My question would be along these lines:", "is that it seems a little opinion-based. I've read through", "possible) and to take as many astronomy classes in graduate", "on graduate school - is that it seems a little", "graduate school - is that it seems a little opinion-based.", "at the moment - and to do research in college,", "do research in college, I need a solid block of", "or does the possibility of research make it inadvertently backwards?", "is room for opinion in many of them. However, I", "- and to do research in college, I need a", "so I decided to ask about it on meta. It's", "> > I once talked with a professor of astronomy", "school looking at college curricula while considering how those curricula", "field is to take as few astronomy classes in college", "independent work at the moment - and to do research", "more advanced. The problem, though, is that I'd like to", "to high enough levels, though it does rest in part", "- at a college. He said that the key to", "do undergraduate astronomy research as soon as possible in college", "little opinion-based. I've read through many questions on Academia, and", "seems like there is room for opinion in many of", "courses. > > > Is this recommendation a good one,", "high enough levels, though it does rest in part on", "being relevant to high enough levels, though it does rest", "decided to ask about it on meta. It's possibly unique", "about it on meta. It's possibly unique in that it", "by a student in high school looking at college curricula", "well in the field is to take as few astronomy", "like to do undergraduate astronomy research as soon as possible", "> I once talked with a professor of astronomy -", "as many physics classes as possible) and to take as", "focus on the basics before moving on to things that", "Stack Exchange, so I decided to ask about it on", "This seems like wise advice - you need to focus", "may be more advanced. The problem, though, is that I'd", "in high school looking at college curricula while considering how", "in college - I'm already doing some independent work at", "I'm already doing some independent work at the moment -", "that I'd like to do undergraduate astronomy research as soon", "in that it is written by a student in high", "curricula while considering how those curricula would be relevant to", "work at the moment - and to do research in", "need a solid block of astronomy courses. > > >", "concern - besides it perhaps not being relevant to high", "a professor of astronomy - my hopeful major/specialty - at", "case of my question or not. Is this question okay", "and it seems like there is room for opinion in", "astronomy classes in college as possible (and as many physics", "- is that it seems a little opinion-based. I've read", "that it is written by a student in high school", "that may be more advanced. The problem, though, is that" ]
[ "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged", "won't be useful here. So I'll create three answers corresponding", "Clearly separate physical and mental disabilities, by tagging the 4", "trauma to the vocal apparatus. Clinical psychologists, neurologists etc. are", "could be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [Does", "the \"mental\" category here, since they usually involve language centers", "black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") tag, and adding", "tagging the 4 questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"),", "see a couple of ways to proceed here. * Clearly", "are welcome to correct me.) --- I see a couple", "two concepts, by retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\")", "\"show questions tagged 'disability'\") tag, and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions", "be useful here. So I'll create three answers corresponding to", "questions really could be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\").", "by retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") questions to", "employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) * [Dismissed by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) * [Disclosing", "could be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd", "20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions, all but the", "ways to proceed here. *Clearly separate physical and mental", "three answers corresponding to the three alternatives. Please vote your", "functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly", "[disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") tag, and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show", "my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) [Disclosing hidden disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) * [How", "argue that out of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\")", "Stephen Hawking conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm putting speech impairments", "\"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions, all but the following could", "three alternatives, the usual upvote=yes, downvote=no meta mechanism won't be", "recently got two questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"):", "disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) * [How does Stephen Hawking conduct his", "[related post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently got two questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "on prospects of employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) * [Dismissed by my", "hidden disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) * [How does Stephen Hawking conduct", "its course. --- Given that I see three alternatives, the", "into the tag box). * Merge the two concepts, by", "sensory, emotional, or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "[“Anonymous” is so distressed that he is having trouble functioning", "tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") tag,", "is some trauma to the vocal apparatus. Clinical psychologists, neurologists", "that out of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions,", "--- I see a couple of ways to proceed here.", "Merge the two concepts, by retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "[disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "Hawking conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm putting speech impairments under", "\"show questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging the other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show", "committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) * [Disclosing hidden disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) * [How does", "questions tagged 'disability'\") and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\").", "[physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging the other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability", "the brain, unless there is some trauma to the vocal", "welcome to correct me.) --- I see a couple of", "\"show questions tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly covers \"cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional,", "tagged 'disability'\") tag, and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions tagged 'mental-disability'\")", "and let nature take its course. --- Given that I", "the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") tag, and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability", "putting speech impairments under the \"mental\" category here, since they", "tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [Does disability impact", "to correct me.) --- I see a couple of ways", "by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) * [Disclosing hidden disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) ", "the following could be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"):", "above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging the other 16", "following* could be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): ", "his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm putting speech impairments under the \"mental\"", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): [Does disability impact on", "let nature take its course. --- Given that I see", "involve language centers in the brain, unless there is some", "questions, all but the following could be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "distressed that he is having trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again,", "questions tagged 'disability'\") questions really could be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "tagged 'disability'\") questions, all but the following could be tagged", "to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) * [How does Stephen Hawking conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140)", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged", "in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) * [Dismissed by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) * [Disclosing hidden", "'mental-health'\"): * [How to overcome these learning difficulties and progress", "three alternatives. Please vote your preference, and comment as appropriate.", "the vocal apparatus. Clinical psychologists, neurologists etc. are welcome to", "* [Dismissed by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) * [Disclosing hidden disability to", "mental, sensory, emotional, or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "[disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly covers \"cognitive, mental, sensory,", "or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") seems", "questions tagged 'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing", "retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability", "in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) * [“Anonymous” is so distressed that he is", "that he is having trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability", "'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd argue that out of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show", "tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly covers \"cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, or developmental\"", "impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") seems to be", "of employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) * [Dismissed by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) ", "of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\"). --- Then yet* again,", "and mental disabilities*, by tagging the 4 questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Do nothing, and let nature take", "--- Then yet again, most of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions", "again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly covers \"cognitive, mental,", "impact on prospects of employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) * [Dismissed by", "type \"disability\" into the tag box). * *Merge the two", "[disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "Explicitly, I'd argue that out of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions", "of ways to proceed here. *Clearly separate physical and", "[Disclosing hidden disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) [How does Stephen Hawking", "[How to overcome these learning difficulties and progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140)", "'mental-health'\"): * [Does disability impact on prospects of employment in", "to proceed here. * Clearly separate physical and mental disabilities,", "'mental-health'\"). * Do nothing, and let nature take its course.", "discussed this in a [related post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently got two", "since they usually involve language centers in the brain, unless", "apparatus. Clinical psychologists, neurologists etc. are welcome to correct me.)", "most of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions really", "blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). * Do nothing, and", "I'll create three answers corresponding to the three alternatives. Please", "(so people find it when they type \"disability\" into the", "and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). * Do nothing,", "[duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly covers", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") seems to be a proper", "learning difficulties and progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) * [“Anonymous” is so", "disabilities*, by tagging the 4 questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions", "of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions really could", "upvote=yes, downvote=no meta mechanism won't be useful here. So I'll", "seems to be a proper subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") seems to be a proper subset", "answers corresponding to the three alternatives. Please vote your preference,", "there is some trauma to the vocal apparatus. Clinical psychologists,", "downvote=no meta mechanism won't be useful here. So I'll create", "in the brain, unless there is some trauma to the", "questions tagged 'mental-disability'\") as a synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "I see a couple of ways to proceed here. ", "I see three alternatives, the usual upvote=yes, downvote=no meta mechanism", "physical and mental disabilities*, by tagging the 4 questions above", "couple of ways to proceed here. *Clearly separate physical", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\")", "Clinical psychologists, neurologists etc. are welcome to correct me.) ---", "questions tagged 'disability'\") tag, and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions tagged", "tagged 'mental-health'\") seems to be a proper subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability", "useful here. So I'll create three answers corresponding to the", "the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions really could be", "here. So I'll create three answers corresponding to the three", " [Disclosing hidden disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) * [How does Stephen", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") (so people find it when", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions", "find it when they type \"disability\" into the tag box).", "it when they type \"disability\" into the tag box). ", "conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm putting speech impairments under the", "'disability'\") questions, all but the following* could be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "difficulties and progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) * [“Anonymous” is so distressed", "all but the following could be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "psychologists, neurologists etc. are welcome to correct me.) --- I", "to the vocal apparatus. Clinical psychologists, neurologists etc. are welcome", "16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging the other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions", "in a [related post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently got two questions tagged", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). * Do nothing, and let nature", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd argue that out of 20", "people find it when they type \"disability\" into the tag", "a proper subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\"). ---", "developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") seems to", "questions tagged 'disability'\"). --- Then yet again, most of the", "disability impact on prospects of employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) * [Dismissed", "under the \"mental\" category here, since they usually involve language", "does Stephen Hawking conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm putting speech", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [How to overcome these", "Do nothing, and let nature take its course. --- Given", "[explicitly covers \"cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\") seems to be a proper subset of", "'mental-health'\") (so people find it when they type \"disability\" into", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-disability'\") as a synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [How to", "other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "tagged 'disability'\") and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). ", "\"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions really could be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "separate physical and mental disabilities, by tagging the 4 questions", "progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) [“Anonymous” is so distressed that he", "tagged 'mental-health'\"). * Do nothing, and let nature take its", "'mental-health'\") seems to be a proper subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show", "speech impairments under the \"mental\" category here, since they usually", "got two questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): ", "[Dismissed by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) [Disclosing hidden disability to employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140)", "subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\"). --- Then yet", "'physical-disability'\"), retagging the other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\")", "'disability'\"). --- Then yet again, most of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show", "questions tagged 'disability'\") questions, all but the following could be", "the 4 questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging", "\"show questions tagged 'disability'\"). --- Then yet again, most of", "and progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) * [“Anonymous” is so distressed that", "the other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd argue that out of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability", "[How does Stephen Hawking conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm putting", "Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly covers \"cognitive,", "mental disabilities*, by tagging the 4 questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show", "retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd argue that", "So I'll create three answers corresponding to the three alternatives.", "'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability", "questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show", "We recently got two questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") (so people find it when they", "proper subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\"). --- Then", "\"show questions tagged 'disability'\") and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "course. --- Given that I see three alternatives, the usual", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): [How to overcome these learning", "* [How to overcome these learning difficulties and progress in", "covers \"cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "\"cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "* [How does Stephen Hawking conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm", "tag, and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions tagged 'mental-disability'\") as a", "'disability'\") tag, and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions tagged 'mental-disability'\") as", "* [“Anonymous” is so distressed that he is having trouble", "to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [How to overcome", "to be a proper subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged", "trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\")", "tagged 'mental-health'\") (so people find it when they type \"disability\"", "yet again, most of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\")", "kind-of discussed this in a [related post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently got", "alternatives, the usual upvote=yes, downvote=no meta mechanism won't be useful", "to the three alternatives. Please vote your preference, and comment", "that I see three alternatives, the usual upvote=yes, downvote=no meta", "So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") seems to be a", "tagged 'mental-health'\") questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") and", "tag box). * Merge the two concepts, by retagging the", "[Does disability impact on prospects of employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) ", "and adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions tagged 'mental-disability'\") as a synonym", "is so distressed that he is having trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140)", "questions tagged 'disability'\") [explicitly covers \"cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, or", "post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently got two questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "Given that I see three alternatives, the usual upvote=yes, downvote=no", "adding [mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions tagged 'mental-disability'\") as a synonym for", "'mental-health'\"), black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") tag, and", "by tagging the 4 questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions tagged", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): [Does disability impact on prospects of", "here. * Clearly separate physical and mental disabilities, by tagging", "questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging the other", "the tag box). * Merge the two concepts, by retagging", "category here, since they usually involve language centers in the", "here, since they usually involve language centers in the brain,", "the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show", "as a synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") (so", "tagged 'mental-disability'\") as a synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\") (so people find it when they type", "I'm putting speech impairments under the \"mental\" category here, since", "me.) --- I see a couple of ways to proceed", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\") questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\")", "Then yet again, most of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged", "be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd argue", "again, most of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions", "\"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"),", "* Clearly separate physical and mental disabilities, by tagging the", "* Do nothing, and let nature take its course. ---", "the three alternatives. Please vote your preference, and comment as", "this in a [related post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently got two questions", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). * Do nothing, and let", "the usual upvote=yes, downvote=no meta mechanism won't be useful here.", "retagging the other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions", "is having trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions", "for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") (so people find it", "usual upvote=yes, downvote=no meta mechanism won't be useful here. So", "he is having trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show", "tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging the other 16 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged", "overcome these learning difficulties and progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) * [“Anonymous”", "so distressed that he is having trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then", "out of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions, all", "concepts, by retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") questions", "I'd argue that out of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged", "to overcome these learning difficulties and progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) ", "employer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/43062/4140) * [How does Stephen Hawking conduct his research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes,", "they type \"disability\" into the tag box). * *Merge the", "vocal apparatus. Clinical psychologists, neurologists etc. are welcome to correct", "academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) [Dismissed by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140) * [Disclosing hidden disability", "centers in the brain, unless there is some trauma to", "prospects of employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140) * [Dismissed by my committee](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2808/4140)", "when they type \"disability\" into the tag box). * *Merge", "really could be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly,", "these learning difficulties and progress in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) [“Anonymous” is", "two questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [How", "'disability'\") questions really could be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "[disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions really could be retagged", "We kind-of discussed this in a [related post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently", "meta mechanism won't be useful here. So I'll create three", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [Does disability impact on prospects", "some trauma to the vocal apparatus. Clinical psychologists, neurologists etc.", "the two concepts*, by retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "proceed here. Clearly separate physical and mental disabilities, by", "'mental-disability'\") as a synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\")", "--- Given that I see three alternatives, the usual upvote=yes,", "nothing*, and let nature take its course. --- Given that", "tagged 'mental-health'\"): [How to overcome these learning difficulties and", "etc. are welcome to correct me.) --- I see a", "corresponding to the three alternatives. Please vote your preference, and", "a couple of ways to proceed here. * *Clearly separate", "tagged 'disability'\") questions really could be retagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions", "mechanism won't be useful here. So I'll create three answers", "\"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd argue that out of", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). Explicitly, I'd argue that out", " [Does disability impact on prospects of employment in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/2901/4140)", "correct me.) --- I see a couple of ways to", "questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [How to overcome these learning difficulties", "create three answers corresponding to the three alternatives. Please vote", "usually involve language centers in the brain, unless there is", "* Merge the two concepts, by retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show", "be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [Does disability", "a synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") (so people", "neurologists etc. are welcome to correct me.) --- I see", "having trouble functioning [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46032/4140) Then again, [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged", "of 20 [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions, all but", "they usually involve language centers in the brain, unless there", "(Yes, I'm putting speech impairments under the \"mental\" category here,", "nature take its course. --- Given that I see three", "be a proper subset of [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\").", "[disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\"). --- Then yet* again, most", "tagged 'disability'\"). --- Then yet again, most of the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability", "box). * Merge the two concepts, by retagging the [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "'mental-health'\") questions to [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") and blacklisting", "[mental-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-disability \"show questions tagged 'mental-disability'\") as a synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "\"disability\" into the tag box). * Merge the two concepts,", "brain, unless there is some trauma to the vocal apparatus.", "tagged 'mental-health'\"): * [Does disability impact on prospects of employment", "impairments under the \"mental\" category here, since they usually involve", "research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/41576/4140) (Yes, I'm putting speech impairments under the \"mental\" category", "[mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing the [disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions", "\"mental\" category here, since they usually involve language centers in", "'disability'\") and blacklisting [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"). * *Do", "language centers in the brain, unless there is some trauma", "take its course. --- Given that I see three alternatives,", "but the following could be tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged", "[disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/disability \"show questions tagged 'disability'\") questions, all but the following", "emotional, or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info). So [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\")", "academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/46936/4140) * [“Anonymous” is so distressed that he is having", "'disability'\") [explicitly covers \"cognitive, mental, sensory, emotional, or developmental\" impairments](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/disability/info).", "tagged 'disability'\") questions [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\"), black-listing the", "unless there is some trauma to the vocal apparatus. Clinical", "synonym for [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health \"show questions tagged 'mental-health'\") (so people find", "a [related post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/1588/4140). We recently got two questions tagged [mental-health](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/mental-health", "4 questions above [physical-disability](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/physical-disability \"show questions tagged 'physical-disability'\"), retagging the", "see three alternatives, the usual upvote=yes, downvote=no meta mechanism won't" ]