Split (1)

train · 10.4M rows

ngram listlengths 0 9.89k
[ "any other legal related question. So, should we close all", "the time of writing, 11 upvotes.The same can be said", "related question. So, should we close all legal related questions", "at the time of writing, 11 upvotes.The same can be", "of any other legal related question. So, should we close", "> > > The comment has, at the time of", "as off-topic because it's about the legalese of a specific", "says: > > I'm voting to close this question as", "Code says: > > I'm voting to close this question", "region and not about academia. > > > The comment", "> > The comment has, at the time of writing,", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/77827/what-rights-do-students-in-the-u-s-have-re-gender-pronouns?noredirect=1#comment190504_77827), Cape Code says: > > I'm voting to close", "has, at the time of writing, 11 upvotes.The same can", "of writing, 11 upvotes.The same can be said of any", "same can be said of any other legal related question.", "said of any other legal related question. So, should we", "So, should we close all legal related questions as too", "geographic region and not about academia. > > > The", "other legal related question. So, should we close all legal", "legal related question. So, should we close all legal related", "legalese of a specific geographic region and not about academia.", "> > I'm voting to close this question as off-topic", "time of writing, 11 upvotes.The same can be said of", "specific geographic region and not about academia. > > >", "In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/77827/what-rights-do-students-in-the-u-s-have-re-gender-pronouns?noredirect=1#comment190504_77827), Cape Code says: > > I'm voting", "a specific geographic region and not about academia. > >", "and not about academia. > > > The comment has,", "writing, 11 upvotes.The same can be said of any other", "it's about the legalese of a specific geographic region and", "> The comment has, at the time of writing, 11", "can be said of any other legal related question. So,", "academia. > > > The comment has, at the time", "be said of any other legal related question. So, should", "because it's about the legalese of a specific geographic region", "question. So, should we close all legal related questions as", "should we close all legal related questions as too localised?", "not about academia. > > > The comment has, at", "the legalese of a specific geographic region and not about", "about the legalese of a specific geographic region and not", "this question as off-topic because it's about the legalese of", "off-topic because it's about the legalese of a specific geographic", "question as off-topic because it's about the legalese of a", "close this question as off-topic because it's about the legalese", "upvotes.The same can be said of any other legal related", "11 upvotes.The same can be said of any other legal", "about academia. > > > The comment has, at the", "to close this question as off-topic because it's about the", "comment has, at the time of writing, 11 upvotes.The same", "> I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/77827/what-rights-do-students-in-the-u-s-have-re-gender-pronouns?noredirect=1#comment190504_77827), Cape Code says: > > I'm voting to", "Cape Code says: > > I'm voting to close this", "voting to close this question as off-topic because it's about", "I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because it's", "The comment has, at the time of writing, 11 upvotes.The", "of a specific geographic region and not about academia. >" ]
[ "gender in discussion—e.g., \"he said…\" or \"as she commented…\"—risks introducing", "gender through posts, avatar, username, discussions, etc. (That can be", "through posts, avatar, username, discussions, etc. (That can be discussed", "discussion? In other words, should moderators use their gentle influence,", "their gentle influence, behind the scenes, in such a situation?", "speaking about a user who has not indicated gender through", "our Academia members. Specifically, this individual felt that calling out", "whether we should use gender-neutral language when speaking about a", "the community members has approached the moderators with a concern", "has not indicated gender through posts, avatar, username, discussions, etc.", "other words, should moderators use their gentle influence, behind the", "calling out gender in discussion—e.g., \"he said…\" or \"as she", "should moderators use their gentle influence, behind the scenes, in", "User A, doesn't follow that practice, when referring to User", "A [recent Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3484/73) noted: > > One of the", "is concerned that the gender assumption could affect the quality", "of the community members has approached the moderators with a", "[recent Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3484/73) noted: > > One of the community", "practice, when referring to User B. In such a case,", "affect the quality of the discussion. > > > I", "> > I am not going to ask whether we", "concern about gendered pronoun usage amongst our Academia members. Specifically,", "by a bystander who is concerned that the gender assumption", "My question is about what happens if a user, say,", "about what happens if a user, say, User A, doesn't", "about a user who has not indicated gender through posts,", "or \"as she commented…\"—risks introducing bias and may affect the", "going to ask whether we should use gender-neutral language when", "Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3484/73) noted: > > One of the community members", "A, doesn't follow that practice, when referring to User B.", "> One of the community members has approached the moderators", "the discussion? In other words, should moderators use their gentle", "to ask whether we should use gender-neutral language when speaking", "by User B (wishing to remain gender anonymous on the", "a bystander who is concerned that the gender assumption could", "the discussion. > > > I am not going to", "concerned that the gender assumption could affect the quality of", "at the above-referenced Meta question.) My question is about what", "out gender in discussion—e.g., \"he said…\" or \"as she commented…\"—risks", "and may affect the quality of the discussion. > >", "gender assumption could affect the quality of the discussion? In", "discussed at the above-referenced Meta question.) My question is about", "that the gender assumption could affect the quality of the", "use gender-neutral language when speaking about a user who has", "said…\" or \"as she commented…\"—risks introducing bias and may affect", "about gendered pronoun usage amongst our Academia members. Specifically, this", "to remain gender anonymous on the site), or by a", "anonymous on the site), or by a bystander who is", "the gender assumption could affect the quality of the discussion?", "bias and may affect the quality of the discussion. >", "Academia members. Specifically, this individual felt that calling out gender", "discussion—e.g., \"he said…\" or \"as she commented…\"—risks introducing bias and", "B. In such a case, can a flag be raised,", "In other words, should moderators use their gentle influence, behind", "that practice, when referring to User B. In such a", "avatar, username, discussions, etc. (That can be discussed at the", "she commented…\"—risks introducing bias and may affect the quality of", "who has not indicated gender through posts, avatar, username, discussions,", "the quality of the discussion? In other words, should moderators", "can a flag be raised, either by User B (wishing", "a user who has not indicated gender through posts, avatar,", "> > > I am not going to ask whether", "the quality of the discussion. > > > I am", "User B (wishing to remain gender anonymous on the site),", "moderators with a concern about gendered pronoun usage amongst our", "indicated gender through posts, avatar, username, discussions, etc. (That can", "quality of the discussion. > > > I am not", "that calling out gender in discussion—e.g., \"he said…\" or \"as", "community members has approached the moderators with a concern about", "not going to ask whether we should use gender-neutral language", "(wishing to remain gender anonymous on the site), or by", "gender-neutral language when speaking about a user who has not", "case, can a flag be raised, either by User B", "bystander who is concerned that the gender assumption could affect", "B (wishing to remain gender anonymous on the site), or", "ask whether we should use gender-neutral language when speaking about", "is about what happens if a user, say, User A,", "such a case, can a flag be raised, either by", "this individual felt that calling out gender in discussion—e.g., \"he", "affect the quality of the discussion? In other words, should", "could affect the quality of the discussion? In other words,", "User B. In such a case, can a flag be", "introducing bias and may affect the quality of the discussion.", "what happens if a user, say, User A, doesn't follow", "discussion. > > > I am not going to ask", "assumption could affect the quality of the discussion? In other", "gendered pronoun usage amongst our Academia members. Specifically, this individual", "remain gender anonymous on the site), or by a bystander", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3484/73) noted: > > One of the community members has", "quality of the discussion? In other words, should moderators use", "say, User A, doesn't follow that practice, when referring to", "amongst our Academia members. Specifically, this individual felt that calling", "discussions, etc. (That can be discussed at the above-referenced Meta", "Meta question.) My question is about what happens if a", "members has approached the moderators with a concern about gendered", "approached the moderators with a concern about gendered pronoun usage", "(That can be discussed at the above-referenced Meta question.) My", "raised, either by User B (wishing to remain gender anonymous", "to User B. In such a case, can a flag", "question is about what happens if a user, say, User", "In such a case, can a flag be raised, either", "gender anonymous on the site), or by a bystander who", "usage amongst our Academia members. Specifically, this individual felt that", "user who has not indicated gender through posts, avatar, username,", "pronoun usage amongst our Academia members. Specifically, this individual felt", "may affect the quality of the discussion. > > >", "if a user, say, User A, doesn't follow that practice,", "has approached the moderators with a concern about gendered pronoun", "or by a bystander who is concerned that the gender", "either by User B (wishing to remain gender anonymous on", "a user, say, User A, doesn't follow that practice, when", "am not going to ask whether we should use gender-neutral", "the moderators with a concern about gendered pronoun usage amongst", "use their gentle influence, behind the scenes, in such a", "\"as she commented…\"—risks introducing bias and may affect the quality", "Specifically, this individual felt that calling out gender in discussion—e.g.,", "> > One of the community members has approached the", "One of the community members has approached the moderators with", "should use gender-neutral language when speaking about a user who", "username, discussions, etc. (That can be discussed at the above-referenced", "felt that calling out gender in discussion—e.g., \"he said…\" or", "when referring to User B. In such a case, can", "language when speaking about a user who has not indicated", "a case, can a flag be raised, either by User", "a flag be raised, either by User B (wishing to", "on the site), or by a bystander who is concerned", "flag be raised, either by User B (wishing to remain", "site), or by a bystander who is concerned that the", "etc. (That can be discussed at the above-referenced Meta question.)", "of the discussion? In other words, should moderators use their", "I am not going to ask whether we should use", "be discussed at the above-referenced Meta question.) My question is", "moderators use their gentle influence, behind the scenes, in such", "\"he said…\" or \"as she commented…\"—risks introducing bias and may", "when speaking about a user who has not indicated gender", "follow that practice, when referring to User B. In such", "individual felt that calling out gender in discussion—e.g., \"he said…\"", "question.) My question is about what happens if a user,", "can be discussed at the above-referenced Meta question.) My question", "not indicated gender through posts, avatar, username, discussions, etc. (That", "with a concern about gendered pronoun usage amongst our Academia", "referring to User B. In such a case, can a", "user, say, User A, doesn't follow that practice, when referring", "noted: > > One of the community members has approached", "commented…\"—risks introducing bias and may affect the quality of the", "the above-referenced Meta question.) My question is about what happens", "above-referenced Meta question.) My question is about what happens if", "happens if a user, say, User A, doesn't follow that", "who is concerned that the gender assumption could affect the", "posts, avatar, username, discussions, etc. (That can be discussed at", "be raised, either by User B (wishing to remain gender", "of the discussion. > > > I am not going", "a concern about gendered pronoun usage amongst our Academia members.", "the site), or by a bystander who is concerned that", "in discussion—e.g., \"he said…\" or \"as she commented…\"—risks introducing bias", "> I am not going to ask whether we should", "members. Specifically, this individual felt that calling out gender in", "we should use gender-neutral language when speaking about a user", "words, should moderators use their gentle influence, behind the scenes,", "doesn't follow that practice, when referring to User B. In" ]
[ "account? Is someone with experience in CS can break into", "and locations are here? do I need to delete my", "Few days ago my advisor shared on social media this", "private data and locations are here? do I need to", "break into StackExchange server and pick location and IP information?", "do I need to delete my account? Is someone with", "to delete my account? Is someone with experience in CS", "be done in academia. I am wondering how safe my", "social media this platform, and also recommended for everyone at", "and also recommended for everyone at my uni to use", "my advisor shared on social media this platform, and also", "my private data and locations are here? do I need", "I should use from now on only anonymous question option", "of information and how something should be done in academia.", "information? Do you think I should use from now on", "it as a source of information and how something should", "experience in CS can break into StackExchange server and pick", "how something should be done in academia. I am wondering", "in academia. I am wondering how safe my private data", "you think I should use from now on only anonymous", "my uni to use it as a source of information", "here? do I need to delete my account? Is someone", "platform, and also recommended for everyone at my uni to", "for everyone at my uni to use it as a", "should be done in academia. I am wondering how safe", "Is someone with experience in CS can break into StackExchange", "server and pick location and IP information? Do you think", "days ago my advisor shared on social media this platform,", "at my uni to use it as a source of", "IP information? Do you think I should use from now", "wondering how safe my private data and locations are here?", "source of information and how something should be done in", "how safe my private data and locations are here? do", "and IP information? Do you think I should use from", "now on only anonymous question option and not to use", "CS can break into StackExchange server and pick location and", "someone with experience in CS can break into StackExchange server", "I need to delete my account? Is someone with experience", "as a source of information and how something should be", "shared on social media this platform, and also recommended for", "location and IP information? Do you think I should use", "can break into StackExchange server and pick location and IP", "pick location and IP information? Do you think I should", "data and locations are here? do I need to delete", "Do you think I should use from now on only", "from now on only anonymous question option and not to", "something should be done in academia. I am wondering how", "recommended for everyone at my uni to use it as", "my account? Is someone with experience in CS can break", "am wondering how safe my private data and locations are", "use it as a source of information and how something", "information and how something should be done in academia. I", "a source of information and how something should be done", "uni to use it as a source of information and", "with experience in CS can break into StackExchange server and", "to use it as a source of information and how", "are here? do I need to delete my account? Is", "everyone at my uni to use it as a source", "I am wondering how safe my private data and locations", "into StackExchange server and pick location and IP information? Do", "delete my account? Is someone with experience in CS can", "think I should use from now on only anonymous question", "advisor shared on social media this platform, and also recommended", "also recommended for everyone at my uni to use it", "ago my advisor shared on social media this platform, and", "done in academia. I am wondering how safe my private", "this platform, and also recommended for everyone at my uni", "locations are here? do I need to delete my account?", "safe my private data and locations are here? do I", "StackExchange server and pick location and IP information? Do you", "use from now on only anonymous question option and not", "need to delete my account? Is someone with experience in", "in CS can break into StackExchange server and pick location", "and how something should be done in academia. I am", "should use from now on only anonymous question option and", "media this platform, and also recommended for everyone at my", "on only anonymous question option and not to use account?", "academia. I am wondering how safe my private data and", "on social media this platform, and also recommended for everyone", "and pick location and IP information? Do you think I" ]
[ "art than science (is it?) but I don't know how", "found a similar question to mine, with an answer much", "lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which I got several wonderful answers, but", "know how to start becoming part of this online society.", "* [How can I get the key to my professor's", "science (is it?) but I don't know how to start", "into my PhD program, and Mom is dying of cancer.", "answers I found particularly interesting: * [Two years into my", "think of. MUCH better. I recently asked a question [How", "but my advisor insists that I must in order to", "until recently, couldn't find a need to register: I usually", "similar question to mine, with an answer much better than", "advisor insists that I must in order to get my", "PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) * [How to ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers I", "I tell my advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) * [How can I", "[How can I get the key to my professor's lab?", "key to my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which I got", "years into my PhD program, and Mom is dying of", "want to kill any more mice, but my advisor insists", "to kill any more mice, but my advisor insists that", "my question was closed as off-topic for understandable reasons. Asking", "to register: I usually found a similar question to mine,", "don't know how to start becoming part of this online", "closed as off-topic for understandable reasons. Asking and answering questions", "but I don't know how to start becoming part of", "my advisor insists that I must in order to get", "I usually found a similar question to mine, with an", "part of this online society. --- Two questions I found", "a similar question to mine, with an answer much better", "it?) but I don't know how to start becoming part", "understandable reasons. Asking and answering questions is more art than", "interesting: * [Two years into my PhD program, and Mom", "much better than I could think of. MUCH better. I", "is more art than science (is it?) but I don't", "insists that I must in order to get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order)", "I could think of. MUCH better. I recently asked a", "found particularly interesting: * [Two years into my PhD program,", "the key to my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which I", "don't want to kill any more mice, but my advisor", "mice, but my advisor insists that I must in order", "used (stalked?) the StackExchange family of websites, and until recently,", "* [Two years into my PhD program, and Mom is", "I have used (stalked?) the StackExchange family of websites, and", "[How to ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers I found particularly", "[I don't want to kill any more mice, but my", "professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which I got several wonderful answers,", "to which I got several wonderful answers, but my question", "[closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which I got several wonderful answers, but my", "I found particularly interesting: * [Two years into my PhD", "I got several wonderful answers, but my question was closed", "asked a question [How can I get the key to", "a question [How can I get the key to my", "I get the key to my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to", "usually found a similar question to mine, with an answer", "particularly interesting: * [I don't want to kill any more", "have used (stalked?) the StackExchange family of websites, and until", "a need to register: I usually found a similar question", "and answering questions is more art than science (is it?)", "how to start becoming part of this online society. ---", "--- Two questions I found particularly interesting: * [I don't", "to get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) * [How to ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions)", "kill any more mice, but my advisor insists that I", "recently asked a question [How can I get the key", "of cancer. Should I tell my advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) ", "for understandable reasons. Asking and answering questions is more art", "than I could think of. MUCH better. I recently asked", "wonderful answers, but my question was closed as off-topic for", "got several wonderful answers, but my question was closed as", "becoming part of this online society. --- Two questions I", "and until recently, couldn't find a need to register: I", "the StackExchange family of websites, and until recently, couldn't find", "order to get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) [How to ask dumb", "better than I could think of. MUCH better. I recently", "my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) * [How to ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers", "of websites, and until recently, couldn't find a need to", "particularly interesting: * [Two years into my PhD program, and", "* [I don't want to kill any more mice, but", "Mom is dying of cancer. Should I tell my advisor", "Two questions I found particularly interesting: * [I don't want", "to my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which I got several", "tell my advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) * [How can I get", "question was closed as off-topic for understandable reasons. Asking and", "I found particularly interesting: * [I don't want to kill", "(stalked?) the StackExchange family of websites, and until recently, couldn't", "an answer much better than I could think of. MUCH", "found particularly interesting: * [I don't want to kill any", "* [How to ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers I found", "question to mine, with an answer much better than I", "with an answer much better than I could think of.", "answers, but my question was closed as off-topic for understandable", "but my question was closed as off-topic for understandable reasons.", "of this online society. --- Two questions I found particularly", "in order to get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) * [How to ask", "I don't know how to start becoming part of this", "must in order to get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) * [How to", "any more mice, but my advisor insists that I must", "society. --- Two questions I found particularly interesting: * [I", "family of websites, and until recently, couldn't find a need", "Asking and answering questions is more art than science (is", "that I must in order to get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) ", "recently, couldn't find a need to register: I usually found", "better. I recently asked a question [How can I get", "this online society. --- Two questions I found particularly interesting:", "Should I tell my advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) [How can", "get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) * [How to ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two", "mine, with an answer much better than I could think", "more mice, but my advisor insists that I must in", "answering questions is more art than science (is it?) but", "start becoming part of this online society. --- Two questions", "reasons. Asking and answering questions is more art than science", "(is it?) but I don't know how to start becoming", "to start becoming part of this online society. --- Two", "I must in order to get my PhD](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/67897/i-dont-want-to-kill-any-more-mice-but-my-advisor-insists-that-i-must-in-order) * [How", "websites, and until recently, couldn't find a need to register:", "can I get the key to my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab)", "dying of cancer. Should I tell my advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387)", "questions is more art than science (is it?) but I", "couldn't find a need to register: I usually found a", "which I got several wonderful answers, but my question was", "question [How can I get the key to my professor's", "PhD program, and Mom is dying of cancer. Should I", "Two answers I found particularly interesting: * [Two years into", "questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers I found particularly interesting: * [Two years", "of. MUCH better. I recently asked a question [How can", "is dying of cancer. Should I tell my advisor about", "my PhD program, and Mom is dying of cancer. Should", "my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which I got several wonderful", "can I get the key to my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/78352/63352)", "to mine, with an answer much better than I could", "interesting: * [I don't want to kill any more mice,", "questions I found particularly interesting: * [I don't want to", "find a need to register: I usually found a similar", "several wonderful answers, but my question was closed as off-topic", "was closed as off-topic for understandable reasons. Asking and answering", "ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers I found particularly interesting: ", "and Mom is dying of cancer. Should I tell my", "I recently asked a question [How can I get the", "my advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) [How can I get the", "MUCH better. I recently asked a question [How can I", "to ask dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers I found particularly interesting:", "advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) * [How can I get the key", "more art than science (is it?) but I don't know", "than science (is it?) but I don't know how to", "as off-topic for understandable reasons. Asking and answering questions is", "StackExchange family of websites, and until recently, couldn't find a", "get the key to my professor's lab? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/78350/how-can-i-get-the-key-to-my-professors-lab) to which", "need to register: I usually found a similar question to", "online society. --- Two questions I found particularly interesting: ", "dumb questions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/51631/how-to-ask-dumb-questions) Two answers I found particularly interesting: [Two", "answer much better than I could think of. MUCH better.", "register: I usually found a similar question to mine, with", "[Two years into my PhD program, and Mom is dying", "about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) * [How can I get the key to", "it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) * [How can I get the key to my", "program, and Mom is dying of cancer. Should I tell", "off-topic for understandable reasons. Asking and answering questions is more", "could think of. MUCH better. I recently asked a question", "cancer. Should I tell my advisor about it?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52386/two-years-into-my-phd-program-and-mom-is-dying-of-cancer-should-i-tell-my-advi/52387#52387) * [How" ]
[ "has disappeared along with one of his deletions. I would", "is acute. He states that he has posted his question", "merge his multiple threads, so my answer would show up?", "answer would show up? (I'm not sure if \"thread\" is", "has expressed clearly, multiple times, that (a) he is in", "this? I don't think my request would fit in the", "He has expressed clearly, multiple times, that (a) he is", "is experiencing high anxiety about an academic issue. He has", "his anxiety persists and is acute. He states that he", "I don't think my request would fit in the flag", "him, but that (b) his anxiety persists and is acute.", "about an academic issue. He has expressed clearly, multiple times,", "answer and repost it at his new question. Can the", "is again for the third time: [Is it unethical of", "who has tried to reassure him, but that (b) his", "of his deletions. I would like to recover this answer", "flagged his question to try to do this? I don't", "have flagged his question to try to do this? I", "and deleted it twice and now here it is again", "word.) Or should I just have flagged his question to", "I get in trouble if a professor passes me based", "in trouble if a professor passes me based on an", "states that he has posted his question and deleted it", "if \"thread\" is the correct word.) Or should I just", "is the correct word.) Or should I just have flagged", "to recover this answer and repost it at his new", "question to try to do this? I don't think my", "deletions. I would like to recover this answer and repost", "in agreement with everyone who has tried to reassure him,", "and now here it is again for the third time:", "here it is again for the third time: [Is it", "for the third time: [Is it unethical of me and", "so my answer would show up? (I'm not sure if", "to try to do this? I don't think my request", "at his new question. Can the moderators merge his multiple", "it twice and now here it is again for the", "academic issue. He has expressed clearly, multiple times, that (a)", "anxiety about an academic issue. He has expressed clearly, multiple", "the correct word.) Or should I just have flagged his", "class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote an answer which has disappeared along with", "question and deleted it twice and now here it is", "correct word.) Or should I just have flagged his question", "would show up? (I'm not sure if \"thread\" is the", "repost it at his new question. Can the moderators merge", "the third time: [Is it unethical of me and can", "clearly, multiple times, that (a) he is in agreement with", "question. Can the moderators merge his multiple threads, so my", "Or should I just have flagged his question to try", "third time: [Is it unethical of me and can I", "with everyone who has tried to reassure him, but that", "I wrote an answer which has disappeared along with one", "(a) he is in agreement with everyone who has tried", "that (a) he is in agreement with everyone who has", "based on an oral exam without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote", "deleted it twice and now here it is again for", "on an oral exam without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote an", "a professor passes me based on an oral exam without", "show up? (I'm not sure if \"thread\" is the correct", "he is in agreement with everyone who has tried to", "professor passes me based on an oral exam without attending", "me and can I get in trouble if a professor", "experiencing high anxiety about an academic issue. He has expressed", "high anxiety about an academic issue. He has expressed clearly,", "expressed clearly, multiple times, that (a) he is in agreement", "his question to try to do this? I don't think", "agreement with everyone who has tried to reassure him, but", "now here it is again for the third time: [Is", "that (b) his anxiety persists and is acute. He states", "that he has posted his question and deleted it twice", "disappeared along with one of his deletions. I would like", "my answer would show up? (I'm not sure if \"thread\"", "times, that (a) he is in agreement with everyone who", "persists and is acute. He states that he has posted", "can I get in trouble if a professor passes me", "new question. Can the moderators merge his multiple threads, so", "recover this answer and repost it at his new question.", "an academic issue. He has expressed clearly, multiple times, that", "of me and can I get in trouble if a", "without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote an answer which has disappeared", "He states that he has posted his question and deleted", "again for the third time: [Is it unethical of me", "it unethical of me and can I get in trouble", "up? (I'm not sure if \"thread\" is the correct word.)", "get in trouble if a professor passes me based on", "(I'm not sure if \"thread\" is the correct word.) Or", "[Is it unethical of me and can I get in", "it at his new question. Can the moderators merge his", "if a professor passes me based on an oral exam", "attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote an answer which has disappeared along", "an oral exam without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote an answer", "I just have flagged his question to try to do", "his multiple threads, so my answer would show up? (I'm", "everyone who has tried to reassure him, but that (b)", "Can the moderators merge his multiple threads, so my answer", "passes me based on an oral exam without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436)", "is in agreement with everyone who has tried to reassure", "unethical of me and can I get in trouble if", "one of his deletions. I would like to recover this", "exam without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote an answer which has", "an answer which has disappeared along with one of his", "and repost it at his new question. Can the moderators", "me based on an oral exam without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I", "tried to reassure him, but that (b) his anxiety persists", "try to do this? I don't think my request would", "not sure if \"thread\" is the correct word.) Or should", "time: [Is it unethical of me and can I get", "moderators merge his multiple threads, so my answer would show", "wrote an answer which has disappeared along with one of", "has tried to reassure him, but that (b) his anxiety", "which has disappeared along with one of his deletions. I", "this answer and repost it at his new question. Can", "reassure him, but that (b) his anxiety persists and is", "threads, so my answer would show up? (I'm not sure", "don't think my request would fit in the flag box....", "with one of his deletions. I would like to recover", "his deletions. I would like to recover this answer and", "but that (b) his anxiety persists and is acute. He", "his new question. Can the moderators merge his multiple threads,", "sure if \"thread\" is the correct word.) Or should I", "user is experiencing high anxiety about an academic issue. He", "issue. He has expressed clearly, multiple times, that (a) he", "answer which has disappeared along with one of his deletions.", "just have flagged his question to try to do this?", "A user is experiencing high anxiety about an academic issue.", "would like to recover this answer and repost it at", "to do this? I don't think my request would fit", "acute. He states that he has posted his question and", "do this? I don't think my request would fit in", "multiple threads, so my answer would show up? (I'm not", "and can I get in trouble if a professor passes", "it is again for the third time: [Is it unethical", "multiple times, that (a) he is in agreement with everyone", "\"thread\" is the correct word.) Or should I just have", "oral exam without attending class?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/32436) I wrote an answer which", "(b) his anxiety persists and is acute. He states that", "he has posted his question and deleted it twice and", "and is acute. He states that he has posted his", "has posted his question and deleted it twice and now", "posted his question and deleted it twice and now here", "his question and deleted it twice and now here it", "along with one of his deletions. I would like to", "should I just have flagged his question to try to", "like to recover this answer and repost it at his", "I would like to recover this answer and repost it", "anxiety persists and is acute. He states that he has", "twice and now here it is again for the third", "to reassure him, but that (b) his anxiety persists and", "trouble if a professor passes me based on an oral", "the moderators merge his multiple threads, so my answer would" ]
[ "to the effect of \"I think X, because Y\". While", "they're really individuals expressing their personal ethics, rather than being", "that said, my question is: should questions related to students", "So, that said, my question is: should questions related to", "part is that they're not definitive because in these instances", "X, because Y\". While the reasons are good, they're really", "a number of answers to the effect of \"I think", "had a few cheating-related questions lately ([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)).", "related to students cheating (where the answer isn't explicitly defined", "of \"I think X, because Y\". While the reasons are", "Y\". While the reasons are good, they're really individuals expressing", "definitive because in these instances there often isn't a definitive", "individuals expressing their personal ethics, rather than being definitive. The", "(where the answer isn't explicitly defined in their academic integrity", "students cheating (where the answer isn't explicitly defined in their", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all of these end up yielding", "of answers to the effect of \"I think X, because", "are good, they're really individuals expressing their personal ethics, rather", "We've had a few cheating-related questions lately ([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially", "in these instances there often isn't a definitive answer. So,", "While the reasons are good, they're really individuals expressing their", "to students cheating (where the answer isn't explicitly defined in", "answer. So, that said, my question is: *should questions related", "think X, because Y\". While the reasons are good, they're", "not definitive because in these instances there often isn't* a", "explicitly defined in their academic integrity policy) be closed as", "([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all of these end up", "these instances there often isn't a definitive answer. So, that", "up yielding a number of answers to the effect of", "often isn't a definitive answer. So, that said, my question", "expressing their personal ethics, rather than being definitive. The tough", "The tough part is that they're not definitive because in", "they're not definitive because in these instances there often isn't", "good, they're really individuals expressing their personal ethics, rather than", "the answer isn't explicitly defined in their academic integrity policy)", "all of these end up yielding a number of answers", "questions lately ([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all of these", "end up yielding a number of answers to the effect", "said, my question is: should questions related to students cheating", "really individuals expressing their personal ethics, rather than being definitive.", "a definitive answer. So, that said, my question is: should", "the reasons are good, they're really individuals expressing their personal", "question is: *should questions related to students cheating (where the", "rather than being definitive. The tough part is that they're", "a few cheating-related questions lately ([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost", "because Y\". While the reasons are good, they're really individuals", "being definitive. The tough part is that they're not definitive", "questions related to students cheating (where the answer isn't explicitly", "answers to the effect of \"I think X, because Y\".", "answer isn't explicitly defined in their academic integrity policy) be", "isn't* a definitive answer. So, that said, my question is:", "lately ([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all of these end", "ethics, rather than being definitive. The tough part is that", "than being definitive. The tough part is that they're not", "effect of \"I think X, because Y\". While the reasons", "cheating (where the answer isn't explicitly defined in their academic", "personal ethics, rather than being definitive. The tough part is", "in their academic integrity policy) be closed as \"primarily opinion-based\"?*", "instances there often isn't* a definitive answer. So, that said,", "defined in their academic integrity policy) be closed as \"primarily", "cheating-related questions lately ([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all of", "their personal ethics, rather than being definitive. The tough part", "is: should questions related to students cheating (where the answer", "the effect of \"I think X, because Y\". While the", "my question is: should questions related to students cheating (where", "of these end up yielding a number of answers to", "is that they're not definitive because in these instances there", "reasons are good, they're really individuals expressing their personal ethics,", "number of answers to the effect of \"I think X,", "\"I think X, because Y\". While the reasons are good,", "because in these instances there often isn't a definitive answer.", "that they're not definitive because in these instances there often", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all of these end up yielding a number", "yielding a number of answers to the effect of \"I", "*should questions related to students cheating (where the answer isn't", "tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all of these end up yielding a", "few cheating-related questions lately ([this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/79732/73), [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/78853/73), tangentially [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/73597/73)). Almost all", "there often isn't* a definitive answer. So, that said, my", "these end up yielding a number of answers to the", "isn't explicitly defined in their academic integrity policy) be closed", "definitive. The tough part is that they're not definitive because", "Almost all of these end up yielding a number of", "definitive answer. So, that said, my question is: **should questions", "tough part is that they're not definitive because in these" ]
[ "sexist remarks by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP only included one", "but I'm hesitating to add it. Since I contributed an", "Here's a specific example: I wrote an answer to this", "question: [How to professionally handle sexist remarks by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565)", "handle sexist remarks by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP only included", "by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP only included one tag. I", "Since I contributed an answer, maybe it might look as", "one tag. I can think of at least one more", "of at least one more tag but I'm hesitating to", "[How to professionally handle sexist remarks by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The", "to this question: [How to professionally handle sexist remarks by", "included one tag. I can think of at least one", "I can think of at least one more tag but", "to add it. Since I contributed an answer, maybe it", "this question: [How to professionally handle sexist remarks by a", "remarks by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP only included one tag.", "least one more tag but I'm hesitating to add it.", "example: I wrote an answer to this question: [How to", "answer, maybe it might look as though I have a", "tag but I'm hesitating to add it. Since I contributed", "it. Since I contributed an answer, maybe it might look", "maybe it might look as though I have a conflict", "to professionally handle sexist remarks by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP", "The OP only included one tag. I can think of", "tag. I can think of at least one more tag", "an answer to this question: [How to professionally handle sexist", "can think of at least one more tag but I'm", "an answer, maybe it might look as though I have", "specific example: I wrote an answer to this question: [How", "contributed an answer, maybe it might look as though I", "I'm hesitating to add it. Since I contributed an answer,", "it might look as though I have a conflict of", "wrote an answer to this question: [How to professionally handle", "answer to this question: [How to professionally handle sexist remarks", "one more tag but I'm hesitating to add it. Since", "think of at least one more tag but I'm hesitating", "student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP only included one tag. I can think", "I wrote an answer to this question: [How to professionally", "a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP only included one tag. I can", "I contributed an answer, maybe it might look as though", "a specific example: I wrote an answer to this question:", "might look as though I have a conflict of interest?", "more tag but I'm hesitating to add it. Since I", "OP only included one tag. I can think of at", "at least one more tag but I'm hesitating to add", "hesitating to add it. Since I contributed an answer, maybe", "only included one tag. I can think of at least", "add it. Since I contributed an answer, maybe it might", "professionally handle sexist remarks by a student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80561/would-you-call-a-student-out-on-being-sexist/80565#80565) The OP only" ]
[ "the first to question the premises in a comment, while", "in a comment, while she was the \"victim\" of a", "similar treatment 2 years ago.) In the case of the", "favorably received. I don't really understand why. I think one", "negative and focused on trying to prove that OP is", "is wrong in assessing whether a given situation was possibly", "of a similar treatment 2 years ago.) In the case", "happened to an [older, very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one was", "was similar to what happened to an [older, very similar", "was much better received, and the [meta post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643)", "the reaction to [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/10643) quite unreasonable. The responses were", "think one should stick with answering the question, possibly pointing", "were overwhelmingly negative and focused on trying to prove that", "one was much better received, and the [meta post about", "received, and the [meta post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated questioning", "reaction was similar to what happened to an [older, very", "a given situation was possibly sexist or not. The reaction", "was the first to question the premises in a comment,", "question was not the right way to go. (Quite ironically", "questioning the premises in the question was not the right", "of the first question, edits to the question to remove", "similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one was much better received, and the", "was the \"victim\" of a similar treatment 2 years ago.)", "the question was not the right way to go. (Quite", "positive, and not just questioning the premises. To that extent,", "overwhelmingly negative and focused on trying to prove that OP", "trying to prove that OP is wrong in assessing whether", "[older, very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one was much better received,", "the question, possibly pointing out a potential false positive, and", "the \"victim\" of a similar treatment 2 years ago.) In", "an [older, very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one was much better", "we deal with these types of questions/situations in the future?", "that OP is wrong in assessing whether a given situation", "The reaction was similar to what happened to an [older,", "how should we deal with these types of questions/situations in", "really understand why. I think one should stick with answering", "and the [meta post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated questioning the", "was possibly sexist or not. The reaction was similar to", "a potential false positive, and not just questioning the premises.", "whether a given situation was possibly sexist or not. The", "to the question to remove possible ambiguity were even less", "comment, while she was the \"victim\" of a similar treatment", "just questioning the premises. To that extent, how should we", "in the question was not the right way to go.", "find the reaction to [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/10643) quite unreasonable. The responses", "the question to remove possible ambiguity were even less favorably", "to question the premises in a comment, while she was", "also indicated questioning the premises in the question was not", "why. I think one should stick with answering the question,", "not just questioning the premises. To that extent, how should", "stick with answering the question, possibly pointing out a potential", "a comment, while she was the \"victim\" of a similar", "better received, and the [meta post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated", "question the premises in a comment, while she was the", "ironically ff524 was the first to question the premises in", "unreasonable. The responses were overwhelmingly negative and focused on trying", "to go. (Quite ironically ff524 was the first to question", "to an [older, very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one was much", "don't really understand why. I think one should stick with", "she was the \"victim\" of a similar treatment 2 years", "ago.) In the case of the first question, edits to", "to what happened to an [older, very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That", "not the right way to go. (Quite ironically ff524 was", "with answering the question, possibly pointing out a potential false", "the [meta post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated questioning the premises", "remove possible ambiguity were even less favorably received. I don't", "indicated questioning the premises in the question was not the", "first to question the premises in a comment, while she", "answering the question, possibly pointing out a potential false positive,", "(Quite ironically ff524 was the first to question the premises", "and focused on trying to prove that OP is wrong", "not. The reaction was similar to what happened to an", "received. I don't really understand why. I think one should", "false positive, and not just questioning the premises. To that", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/10643) quite unreasonable. The responses were overwhelmingly negative and", "the first question, edits to the question to remove possible", "treatment 2 years ago.) In the case of the first", "potential false positive, and not just questioning the premises. To", "focused on trying to prove that OP is wrong in", "I find the reaction to [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/10643) quite unreasonable. The", "the right way to go. (Quite ironically ff524 was the", "and not just questioning the premises. To that extent, how", "In the case of the first question, edits to the", "I don't really understand why. I think one should stick", "in assessing whether a given situation was possibly sexist or", "should stick with answering the question, possibly pointing out a", "on trying to prove that OP is wrong in assessing", "out a potential false positive, and not just questioning the", "quite unreasonable. The responses were overwhelmingly negative and focused on", "OP is wrong in assessing whether a given situation was", "right way to go. (Quite ironically ff524 was the first", "what happened to an [older, very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one", "should we deal with these types of questions/situations in the", "one should stick with answering the question, possibly pointing out", "question, edits to the question to remove possible ambiguity were", "To that extent, how should we deal with these types", "the premises in the question was not the right way", "extent, how should we deal with these types of questions/situations", "questioning the premises. To that extent, how should we deal", "less favorably received. I don't really understand why. I think", "to prove that OP is wrong in assessing whether a", "to [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/10643) quite unreasonable. The responses were overwhelmingly negative", "premises in the question was not the right way to", "situation was possibly sexist or not. The reaction was similar", "while she was the \"victim\" of a similar treatment 2", "question to remove possible ambiguity were even less favorably received.", "premises in a comment, while she was the \"victim\" of", "the premises. To that extent, how should we deal with", "it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated questioning the premises in the question was", "prove that OP is wrong in assessing whether a given", "were even less favorably received. I don't really understand why.", "The responses were overwhelmingly negative and focused on trying to", "given situation was possibly sexist or not. The reaction was", "pointing out a potential false positive, and not just questioning", "or not. The reaction was similar to what happened to", "possibly pointing out a potential false positive, and not just", "to remove possible ambiguity were even less favorably received. I", "\"victim\" of a similar treatment 2 years ago.) In the", "way to go. (Quite ironically ff524 was the first to", "edits to the question to remove possible ambiguity were even", "similar to what happened to an [older, very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643).", "ff524 was the first to question the premises in a", "premises. To that extent, how should we deal with these", "question, possibly pointing out a potential false positive, and not", "2 years ago.) In the case of the first question,", "[meta post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated questioning the premises in", "sexist or not. The reaction was similar to what happened", "possible ambiguity were even less favorably received. I don't really", "wrong in assessing whether a given situation was possibly sexist", "that extent, **how should we deal with these types of", "post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated questioning the premises in the", "the premises in a comment, while she was the \"victim\"", "even less favorably received. I don't really understand why. I", "much better received, and the [meta post about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also", "responses were overwhelmingly negative and focused on trying to prove", "reaction to [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/10643) quite unreasonable. The responses were overwhelmingly", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/10643) quite unreasonable. The responses were overwhelmingly negative and focused", "the case of the first question, edits to the question", "about it](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/834/10643) also indicated questioning the premises in the question", "a similar treatment 2 years ago.) In the case of", "assessing whether a given situation was possibly sexist or not.", "years ago.) In the case of the first question, edits", "go. (Quite ironically ff524 was the first to question the", "possibly sexist or not. The reaction was similar to what", "That one was much better received, and the [meta post", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one was much better received, and the [meta", "first question, edits to the question to remove possible ambiguity", "was not the right way to go. (Quite ironically ff524", "understand why. I think one should stick with answering the", "ambiguity were even less favorably received. I don't really understand", "very similar question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/10643). That one was much better received, and", "I think one should stick with answering the question, possibly", "case of the first question, edits to the question to" ]
[ "tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh is an annual", "any other user's). * Apart from the wearing of hats", "Apart from the wearing of hats by avatars, the site", "by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there is no", "the comments according to your preference. If you want to", "can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats in a", "as the year draws to a close. Two things to", "badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving a hat, which", "have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange", "run on any Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate.", "[2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose to participate. To decide whether we will", "completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (no hats for anyone).", "can opt out (clicking an option in your profile means", "on any other user's). * Apart from the wearing of", "a close. Two things to note: * Any user can", "choice to opt out entirely and have the Cultep Besh", "not on your own avatar and not on any other", "the amazing people who make the sites awesome, as the", "according to your preference. If you want to discuss further,", "avatar and not on any other user's). * Apart from", "will participate in the Cultep Besh 2016 Edition, I've created", "In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose to participate. To decide", "the hats disappear, as if they were never there. ---", "with two comments. Upvote one of the comments according to", "note: * Any user can opt out (clicking an option", "comments according to your preference.** If you want to discuss", "and not on any other user's). * Apart from the", "or comments to other answers. The poll will close on", "entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia", "--- This being said, we (as a community) also have", "is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of the", "We track everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard that", "two comments. Upvote one of the comments according to your", "participate. To decide whether we will participate in the Cultep", "Besh as a a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate", "Any user can opt out** (clicking an option in your", "event that can run on any Stack Exchange site that", "to participate. To decide whether we will participate in the", "an option in your profile means you won't see any", "were never there. --- This being said, we (as a", "for their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges).", "answer or comments to other answers. The poll will close", "at all - not on your own avatar and not", "the site's design, for example) * After the promotion ends,", "screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a fun", "the promotion ends, the hats disappear, as if they were", "looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees", "Exchange will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep", "Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing certain tasks", "things to note: * Any user can opt out (clicking", "not on any other user's). * Apart from the wearing", "Exchange (no hats for anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we", "the year draws to a close. Two things to note:", "Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats”", "promotion ends, the hats disappear, as if they were never", "hats for anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose to", "design, for example) * After the promotion ends, the hats", "who make the sites awesome, as the year draws to", "user's). * Apart from the wearing of hats by avatars,", "trigger the user receiving a hat, which their gravatar can", "option in your profile means you won't see any hat", "to a close. Two things to note: * Any user", "leave an answer or comments to other answers. The poll", "created a “poll” below this post, with two comments. *Upvote", " Any user can opt out (clicking an option in", "completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the", "track everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard that looks", "preference.** If you want to discuss further, leave an answer", "comments to other answers. The poll will close on Friday", "site's design, for example) * After the promotion ends, the", "the Cultep Besh 2016 Edition, I've created a “poll” below", "fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people who", "the wearing of hats by avatars, the site is otherwise", "other answers. The poll will close on Friday December 9.", "lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people who make the", "we (as a community) also have to choice to opt", "awesome, as the year draws to a close. Two things", "we will participate in the Cultep Besh 2016 Edition, I've", "disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (no hats for anyone). In", "their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats", "a community) also have to choice to opt out entirely", "- not on your own avatar and not on any", "an annual event that can run on any Stack Exchange", "being said, we (as a community) also have to choice", "amazing people who make the sites awesome, as the year", "of hats by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there", "and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people who make", "draws to a close. Two things to note: * *Any", "all - not on your own avatar and not on", " Apart from the wearing of hats by avatars, the", "user can opt out** (clicking an option in your profile", "you won't see any hat at all - not on", "ends, the hats disappear, as if they were never there.", "After the promotion ends, the hats disappear, as if they", "To decide whether we will participate in the Cultep Besh", "I've created a “poll” below this post, with two comments.", "want to discuss further, leave an answer or comments to", "as a a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the", "Cultep Besh 2016 Edition, *I've created a “poll” below this", "make the sites awesome, as the year draws to a", "way to celebrate the amazing people who make the sites", "any* hat at all - not on your own avatar", "can run on any Stack Exchange site that chooses to", "a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s", "site is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of", "Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (no hats for", "progress earning hats in a leaderboard that looks something like", "Two things to note: * Any user can opt out", "participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing certain", "from the wearing of hats by avatars, the site is", "on Academia Stack Exchange (no hats for anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom)", "also have to choice to opt out entirely and have", "own avatar and not on any other user's). * Apart", "that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars", "in the Cultep Besh 2016 Edition, *I've created a “poll”", "will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh", "the site is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme", "to badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving a hat,", "no “holiday” theme of the site's design, for example) ", "to opt out entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely", "Edition, I've created a “poll” below this post, with two", "to participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing", "profile means you won't see any hat at all -", "for anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose to participate.", "people who make the sites awesome, as the year draws", "the sites awesome, as the year draws to a close.", "close. Two things to note: * Any user can opt", "“poll” below this post, with two comments. Upvote one of", "below this post, with two comments. *Upvote one of the", "that can run on any Stack Exchange site that chooses", "disappear, as if they were never there. --- This being", "theme of the site's design, for example) After the", "which their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning", "(no hats for anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose", "Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a", "out** (clicking an option in your profile means you won't", "their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain", "Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh is an annual event that can run", "chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for their gravatars by", "out entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on", "Besh is an annual event that can run on any", "by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger", "as if they were never there. --- This being said,", "on any Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users", "Stack Exchange (no hats for anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion),", "chose to participate. To decide whether we will participate in", "otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of the site's", "other user's). * Apart from the wearing of hats by", "avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there is no “holiday”", "(there is no “holiday” theme of the site's design, for", "participate in the Cultep Besh 2016 Edition, I've created a", "hats disappear, as if they were never there. --- This", "an answer or comments to other answers. The poll will", "![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a", "unaffected (there is no “holiday” theme of the site's design,", "is no “holiday” theme of the site's design, for example)", "the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (no", "of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh is an annual event", "Upvote one of the comments according to your preference.** If", "continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh is", "* After the promotion ends, the hats disappear, as if", "your own avatar and not on any other user's). ", "a a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing", "in your profile means you won't see any* hat at", "post, with two comments. Upvote one of the comments according", "any Stack Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users earn", "tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving", "wearing of hats by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected", "Academia Stack Exchange (no hats for anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and", "user receiving a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We", "is an annual event that can run on any Stack", "2016, Stack Exchange will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep", "everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard that looks something", "of the site's design, for example) * After the promotion", "This being said, we (as a community) also have to", "Besh 2016 Edition, I've created a “poll” below this post,", "Cultep Besh as a a fun and lighthearted way to", "hats in a leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep", "celebrate the amazing people who make the sites awesome, as", "earn “hats” for their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous", "opt out** (clicking an option in your profile means you", "discuss further, leave an answer or comments to other answers.", "to discuss further, leave an answer or comments to other", "hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress", "earning hats in a leaderboard that looks something like this:", "example) * After the promotion ends, the hats disappear, as", "(analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the user receiving a", "(as a community) also have to choice to opt out", "comments. Upvote one of the comments according to your preference.", "Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack Exchange (no hats", "(clicking an option in your profile means you won't see", "means you won't see any hat at all - not", "see any hat at all - not on your own", "they were never there. --- This being said, we (as", "and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled on Academia Stack", "a “poll” below this post, with two comments. Upvote one", "and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose to participate. To decide whether we", "won't see any hat at all - not on your", "hat at all - not on your own avatar and", "to other answers. The poll will close on Friday December", "whether we will participate in the Cultep Besh 2016 Edition,", "its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh is an", "gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions", "something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep", "to your preference.** If you want to discuss further, leave", "sees Cultep Besh as a a fun and lighthearted way", "In 2016, Stack Exchange will continue its tradition of the", "said, we (as a community) also have to choice to", "your profile means you won't see any hat at all", "[\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh is an annual event that can", "annual event that can run on any Stack Exchange site", "to note: * Any user can opt out (clicking an", "that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange", "certain tasks (analogous to badges). Certain actions trigger the user", "opt out entirely and have the Cultep Besh completely disabled", "further, leave an answer or comments to other answers. The", "this post, with two comments. Upvote one of the comments", "leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack", "in a leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh", "Stack Exchange will continue its tradition of the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com).", "like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh", "site that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for their", "we chose to participate. To decide whether we will participate", "have to choice to opt out entirely and have the", "there. --- This being said, we (as a community) also", "never there. --- This being said, we (as a community)", "to choice to opt out entirely and have the Cultep", "If you want to discuss further, leave an answer or", "“hats” for their gravatars by completing certain tasks (analogous to", "gravatar can “wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats in", "2016 Edition, I've created a “poll” below this post, with", "of the comments according to your preference. If you want", "“wear”. We track everyone’s progress earning hats in a leaderboard", "Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a fun and lighthearted", "your preference. If you want to discuss further, leave an", "sites awesome, as the year draws to a close. Two", "hats by avatars, the site is otherwise unaffected (there is", "actions trigger the user receiving a hat, which their gravatar", "on your own avatar and not on any other user's).", "Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as a a fun and", "a fun and lighthearted way to celebrate the amazing people", "anyone). In [2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose to participate. To", "the [\"Cultep Besh\"](http://winterbash2016.stackexchange.com). Cultep Besh is an annual event that", "Exchange site that chooses to participate. Users earn “hats” for", "for example) * After the promotion ends, the hats disappear,", "if they were never there. --- This being said, we", "“holiday” theme of the site's design, for example) * After", "to celebrate the amazing people who make the sites awesome,", "Certain actions trigger the user receiving a hat, which their", "one of the comments according to your preference.** If you", "receiving a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”. We track", "you want to discuss further, leave an answer or comments", "Cultep Besh is an annual event that can run on", "community) also have to choice to opt out entirely and", "a leaderboard that looks something like this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg)", "decide whether we will participate in the Cultep Besh 2016", "the user receiving a hat, which their gravatar can “wear”.", "[2014](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1369/poll-should-academia-se-participate-in-the-2014-winter-bash-holiday-hats-prom) and [2015](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2082/poll-should-we-participate-in-the-2015-winter-bash-holiday-hats-promotion), we chose to participate. To decide whether", "this: ![Cultep Besh screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xPJDO.jpg) Stack Exchange sees Cultep Besh as", "year draws to a close. Two things to note: *" ]
[ "incorporating it into the text of the question, or by", "now been removed. Currently visible example: \"this answer is just", "choice tests where the answer is always the longest response.\"", "information about the original question through multiple comment threads. Although", "is under age. (To be clear: I am NOT saying", "question through multiple comment threads. Although the best case scenario", "quote the comment, because I neglected to copy it before", "argumentative.** OP has posted a question on Academia SE. If", "I neglected to copy it before I flagged it, and", "for simplicity I will use he. Here are the red", "city school with extremely low standards and they teach 99%", "school with extremely low standards and they teach 99% to", "SE. If he is not happy with the analysis and", "student has been revealed.) 3. *OP's \"case\" against the student", "home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has been extensive and the tone has", "school and I can confirm that it is an inner", "extremely low standards and they teach 99% to just pass", "about the student keeps getting added here and there and", "But that's not what motivates my Meta question. Rather, I", "personally identifiable information about the student has been revealed.) 3.", "motivates my Meta question. Rather, I am writing because I", "I can't quote the comment, because I neglected to copy", "an example, OP wrote a comment in response to the", "gotten now to the point of a personal attack on", "has disagreed with someone, he has added no documented or", "I'm afraid I can't quote the comment, because I neglected", "before I flagged it, and it has now been removed.", "keeps growing, ad infinitum.* The OP has been gradually adding", "As an example, OP wrote a comment in response to", "will use he. Here are the red flags I see:", "where an OP is baiting SE participants and attacking an", "as 'a joke;'\" \"I know the school and I can", "it is an inner city school with extremely low standards", "is baiting SE participants and attacking an individual, who is", "point of a personal attack on an individual student, who", "been ramping up. But that's not what motivates my Meta", "that's not what motivates my Meta question. Rather, I am", "information in the original question, I appreciate that more is", "new logical points, he has only just cranked up the", "either by incorporating it into the text of the question,", "removed. Currently visible example: \"this answer is just trying to", "a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has been extensive and the", "I will use he. Here are the red flags I", "age? How can we make clear that provocateur-like behavior is", "around. When he has disagreed with someone, he has added", "Examples: \"The student did refer to his other classes as", "has now been removed. Currently visible example: \"this answer is", "Discussion has been extensive and the tone has been ramping", "and the tone has been ramping up. But that's not", "response to the answer by Mayou36 which clearly stated he", "include all relevant information in the original question, I appreciate", "in other users' opinions. I'm afraid I can't quote the", "to his question.** This has gotten now to the point", "the question, or by creating an addendum at the bottom", "question, either by incorporating it into the text of the", "and opinions other users have shared, he is free to", "writing because I see several red flags suggesting the OP", "who is under age. (To be clear: I am NOT", "Then OP should add it to the question, either by", "use he. Here are the red flags I see: 1.", "see: 1. OP has been increasingly argumentative. OP has posted", "ignore them. Nothing is accomplished by arguing, around and around.", "see several red flags suggesting the OP is behaving like", "OP has been hypercritical of one of his students, which", "question on Academia SE. If he is not happy with", "creating an addendum at the bottom of the question. More", "'a joke;'\" \"I know the school and I can confirm", "comment, because I neglected to copy it before I flagged", "in such a case, where an OP is baiting SE", "This has gotten now to the point of a personal", "the red flags I see: 1. OP has been increasingly", "of the question. More and more disorganized diatribe about the", "not happy with the analysis and opinions other users have", "clear: I am NOT saying that personally identifiable information about", "clearly stated he wasn't interested in other users' opinions. I'm", "under age. (To be clear: I am NOT saying that", "am writing because I see several red flags suggesting the", "accomplished by arguing, around and around. When he has disagreed", "has added no documented or documentable information, or new logical", "I am NOT saying that personally identifiable information about the", "by incorporating it into the text of the question, or", "My question: what can be done in such a case,", "is under age? How can we make clear that provocateur-like", "2. *OP has been hypercritical of one of his students,", "age. (To be clear: I am NOT* saying that personally", "the student keeps growing, ad infinitum.** The OP has been", "free to take them on board or ignore them. Nothing", "gender of OP but for simplicity I will use he.", "can we make clear that provocateur-like behavior is unacceptable on", "red flags suggesting the OP is behaving like a provocateur.", "only just cranked up the volume. As an example, OP", "about the student has been revealed.) 3. OP's \"case\" against", "is tangential to his question. This has gotten now to", "am NOT saying that personally identifiable information about the student", "and I can confirm that it is an inner city", "information, or new logical points, he has only just cranked", "been removed. Currently visible example: \"this answer is just trying", "a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a take home", "it has now been removed. Currently visible example: \"this answer", "comment in response to the answer by Mayou36 which clearly", "other classes as 'a joke;'\" \"I know the school and", "such a case, where an OP is baiting SE participants", "just pass the standard exams... I've even heard they give", "know the gender of OP but for simplicity I will", "done in such a case, where an OP is baiting", "I see several red flags suggesting the OP is behaving", "I see: 1. OP has been increasingly argumentative. OP has", "Rather, I am writing because I see several red flags", "because I see several red flags suggesting the OP is", "to take them on board or ignore them. Nothing is", "NOT saying that personally identifiable information about the student has", "to copy it before I flagged it, and it has", "the standard exams... I've even heard they give mult choice", "because I neglected to copy it before I flagged it,", "an individual, who is under age? How can we make", "take them on board or ignore them. Nothing is accomplished", "denying an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has", "an individual student, who is under age. (To be clear:", "the answer is always the longest response.\" My question: what", "there and everywhere. Examples: \"The student did refer to his", "the bottom of the question. More and more disorganized diatribe", "OP has posted a question on Academia SE. If he", "copy it before I flagged it, and it has now", "can be done in such a case, where an OP", "question, or by creating an addendum at the bottom of", "the analysis and opinions other users have shared, he is", "up the volume. As an example, OP wrote a comment", "they give mult choice tests where the answer is always", "posted a question on Academia SE. If he is not", "case scenario is to include all relevant information in the", "interested in other users' opinions. I'm afraid I can't quote", "standard exams... I've even heard they give mult choice tests", "happy with the analysis and opinions other users have shared,", "1. OP has been increasingly argumentative. OP has posted a", "3. *OP's \"case\" against the student keeps growing, ad infinitum.", "through comments. Then OP should add it to the question,", "is sometimes elicited through comments. Then OP should add it", "text of the question, or by creating an addendum at", "one of his students, which is tangential to his question.", "what motivates my Meta question. Rather, I am writing because", "someone, he has added no documented or documentable information, or", "he. Here are the red flags I see: 1. OP", "has been increasingly argumentative.* OP has posted a question on", "his other classes as 'a joke;'\" \"I know the school", "all relevant information in the original question, I appreciate that", "like a provocateur. I don't know the gender of OP", "the question, either by incorporating it into the text of", "students, which is tangential to his question. This has gotten", "individual, who is under age? How can we make clear", "classes as 'a joke;'\" \"I know the school and I", "participants and attacking an individual, who is under age? How", "to include all relevant information in the original question, I", "cranked up the volume. As an example, OP wrote a", "99% to just pass the standard exams... I've even heard", "OP's \"case\" against the student keeps growing, ad infinitum. The", "If he is not happy with the analysis and opinions", "been increasingly argumentative. OP has posted a question on Academia", "baiting SE participants and attacking an individual, who is under", "Nothing is accomplished by arguing, around and around. When he", "his question. This has gotten now to the point of", "original question, I appreciate that more is sometimes elicited through", "extensive and the tone has been ramping up. But that's", "is behaving like a provocateur. I don't know the gender", "red flags I see: 1. OP has been increasingly argumentative.", "several red flags suggesting the OP is behaving like a", "When he has disagreed with someone, he has added no", "stated he wasn't interested in other users' opinions. I'm afraid", "an addendum at the bottom of the question. More and", "at the bottom of the question. More and more disorganized", "wasn't interested in other users' opinions. I'm afraid I can't", "confirm that it is an inner city school with extremely", "his students, which is tangential to his question. This has", "shared, he is free to take them on board or", "student, who is under age. (To be clear: I am", "to demonize me.\" 2. OP has been hypercritical of one", "it before I flagged it, and it has now been", "tangential to his question. This has gotten now to the", "is free to take them on board or ignore them.", "the tone has been ramping up. But that's not what", "around and around. When he has disagreed with someone, he", "of one of his students, which is tangential to his", "scattered additional information about the original question through multiple comment", "give mult choice tests where the answer is always the", "has only just cranked up the volume. As an example,", "should add it to the question, either by incorporating it", "on Academia SE. If he is not happy with the", "flags I see: 1. OP has been increasingly argumentative. OP", "\"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam)", "I can confirm that it is an inner city school", "exams... I've even heard they give mult choice tests where", "but for simplicity I will use he. Here are the", "he has added no documented or documentable information, or new", "response.\" My question: what can be done in such a", "don't know the gender of OP but for simplicity I", "more disorganized diatribe about the student keeps getting added here", "instructor, denying an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion", "standards and they teach 99% to just pass the standard", "by Mayou36 which clearly stated he wasn't interested in other", "which is tangential to his question. This has gotten now", "he is not happy with the analysis and opinions other", "OP is baiting SE participants and attacking an individual, who", "student did refer to his other classes as 'a joke;'\"", "personal attack on an individual student, who is under age.", "is to include all relevant information in the original question,", "\"this answer is just trying to demonize me.\" 2. OP", "comment threads. Although the best case scenario is to include", "SE participants and attacking an individual, who is under age?", "information about the student has been revealed.) 3. *OP's \"case\"", "flagged it, and it has now been removed. Currently visible", "that more is sometimes elicited through comments. Then OP should", "getting added here and there and everywhere. Examples: \"The student", "an inner city school with extremely low standards and they", "with extremely low standards and they teach 99% to just", "is accomplished by arguing, around and around. When he has", "of a personal attack on an individual student, who is", "sometimes elicited through comments. Then OP should add it to", "has been hypercritical of one of his students, which is", "provocateur. I don't know the gender of OP but for", "can confirm that it is an inner city school with", "growing, ad infinitum.* The OP has been gradually adding scattered", "best case scenario is to include all relevant information in", "longest response.\" My question: what can be done in such", "is just trying to demonize me.\" 2. OP has been", "Currently visible example: \"this answer is just trying to demonize", "that it is an inner city school with extremely low", "he wasn't interested in other users' opinions. I'm afraid I", "into the text of the question, or by creating an", "gradually adding scattered additional information about the original question through", "which clearly stated he wasn't interested in other users' opinions.", "the original question, I appreciate that more is sometimes elicited", "and around. When he has disagreed with someone, he has", "opinions other users have shared, he is free to take", "is always the longest response.\" My question: what can be", "to just pass the standard exams... I've even heard they", "comments. Then OP should add it to the question, either", "the answer by Mayou36 which clearly stated he wasn't interested", "a personal attack on an individual student, who is under", "revealed.) 3. OP's \"case\" against the student keeps growing, ad", "be clear: I am NOT* saying that personally identifiable information", "to the question, either by incorporating it into the text", "make clear that provocateur-like behavior is unacceptable on Academia SE?", "has been extensive and the tone has been ramping up.", "documentable information, or new logical points, he has only just", "users have shared, he is free to take them on", "has been gradually adding scattered additional information about the original", "of his students, which is tangential to his question.** This", "answer is always the longest response.\" My question: what can", "being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a take", "now to the point of a personal attack on an", "tone has been ramping up. But that's not what motivates", "to the answer by Mayou36 which clearly stated he wasn't", "they teach 99% to just pass the standard exams... I've", "student keeps growing, ad infinitum. The OP has been gradually", "answer by Mayou36 which clearly stated he wasn't interested in", "logical points, he has only just cranked up the volume.", "a comment in response to the answer by Mayou36 which", "OP is behaving like a provocateur. I don't know the", "can't quote the comment, because I neglected to copy it", "question. Rather, I am writing because I see several red", "OP has been increasingly argumentative. OP has posted a question", "are the red flags I see: 1. OP has been", "ad infinitum. The OP has been gradually adding scattered additional", "points, he has only just cranked up the volume. As", "ramping up. But that's not what motivates my Meta question.", "Academia SE. If he is not happy with the analysis", "heard they give mult choice tests where the answer is", "Regarding: [Am I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension", "it into the text of the question, or by creating", "question: what can be done in such a case, where", "adding scattered additional information about the original question through multiple", "addendum at the bottom of the question. More and more", "or documentable information, or new logical points, he has only", "he has only just cranked up the volume. As an", "did refer to his other classes as 'a joke;'\" \"I", "he has disagreed with someone, he has added no documented", "the comment, because I neglected to copy it before I", "the gender of OP but for simplicity I will use", "How can we make clear that provocateur-like behavior is unacceptable", "additional information about the original question through multiple comment threads.", "been revealed.) 3. OP's \"case\" against the student keeps growing,", "with someone, he has added no documented or documentable information,", "bottom of the question. More and more disorganized diatribe about", "to his other classes as 'a joke;'\" \"I know the", "to the point of a personal attack on an individual", "been hypercritical of one of his students, which is tangential", "everywhere. Examples: \"The student did refer to his other classes", "through multiple comment threads. Although the best case scenario is", "analysis and opinions other users have shared, he is free", "on an individual student, who is under age. (To be", "attack on an individual student, who is under age. (To", "the question. More and more disorganized diatribe about the student", "visible example: \"this answer is just trying to demonize me.\"", "Mayou36 which clearly stated he wasn't interested in other users'", "Meta question. Rather, I am writing because I see several", "on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has been extensive and", "of the question, or by creating an addendum at the", "is not happy with the analysis and opinions other users", "\"The student did refer to his other classes as 'a", "my Meta question. Rather, I am writing because I see", "The OP has been gradually adding scattered additional information about", "wrote a comment in response to the answer by Mayou36", "tests where the answer is always the longest response.\" My", "behaving like a provocateur. I don't know the gender of", "low standards and they teach 99% to just pass the", "volume. As an example, OP wrote a comment in response", "the student keeps getting added here and there and everywhere.", "under age? How can we make clear that provocateur-like behavior", "the student has been revealed.) 3. *OP's \"case\" against the", "been gradually adding scattered additional information about the original question", "case, where an OP is baiting SE participants and attacking", "even heard they give mult choice tests where the answer", "he is free to take them on board or ignore", "elicited through comments. Then OP should add it to the", "neglected to copy it before I flagged it, and it", "against the student keeps growing, ad infinitum.* The OP has", "Although the best case scenario is to include all relevant", "answer is just trying to demonize me.\" 2. *OP has", "and more disorganized diatribe about the student keeps getting added", "been extensive and the tone has been ramping up. But", "arguing, around and around. When he has disagreed with someone,", "refer to his other classes as 'a joke;'\" \"I know", "I flagged it, and it has now been removed. Currently", "the school and I can confirm that it is an", "disagreed with someone, he has added no documented or documentable", "(To be clear: I am NOT* saying that personally identifiable", "it, and it has now been removed. Currently visible example:", "keeps getting added here and there and everywhere. Examples: \"The", "I don't know the gender of OP but for simplicity", "where the answer is always the longest response.\" My question:", "OP should add it to the question, either by incorporating", "afraid I can't quote the comment, because I neglected to", "no documented or documentable information, or new logical points, he", "an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has been", "has been ramping up. But that's not what motivates my", "them on board or ignore them. Nothing is accomplished by", "attacking an individual, who is under age? How can we", "I appreciate that more is sometimes elicited through comments. Then", "them. Nothing is accomplished by arguing, around and around. When", "and it has now been removed. Currently visible example: \"this", "it to the question, either by incorporating it into the", "a provocateur. I don't know the gender of OP but", "example, OP wrote a comment in response to the answer", "here and there and everywhere. Examples: \"The student did refer", "up. But that's not what motivates my Meta question. Rather,", "a case, where an OP is baiting SE participants and", "I've even heard they give mult choice tests where the", "scenario is to include all relevant information in the original", "appreciate that more is sometimes elicited through comments. Then OP", "about the original question through multiple comment threads. Although the", "diatribe about the student keeps getting added here and there", "and everywhere. Examples: \"The student did refer to his other", "exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has been extensive and the tone has been", "in response to the answer by Mayou36 which clearly stated", "take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has been extensive and the tone", "example: \"this answer is just trying to demonize me.\" 2.", "threads. Although the best case scenario is to include all", "have shared, he is free to take them on board", "or new logical points, he has only just cranked up", "original question through multiple comment threads. Although the best case", "identifiable information about the student has been revealed.) 3. *OP's", "added here and there and everywhere. Examples: \"The student did", "not what motivates my Meta question. Rather, I am writing", "infinitum. The OP has been gradually adding scattered additional information", "has posted a question on Academia SE. If he is", "just trying to demonize me.\" 2. OP has been hypercritical", "question. This has gotten now to the point of a", "the original question through multiple comment threads. Although the best", "who is under age? How can we make clear that", "[Am I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on", "what can be done in such a case, where an", "the volume. As an example, OP wrote a comment in", "me.\" 2. OP has been hypercritical of one of his", "just cranked up the volume. As an example, OP wrote", "more is sometimes elicited through comments. Then OP should add", "question, I appreciate that more is sometimes elicited through comments.", "or ignore them. Nothing is accomplished by arguing, around and", "OP wrote a comment in response to the answer by", "other users' opinions. I'm afraid I can't quote the comment,", "and there and everywhere. Examples: \"The student did refer to", "question. More and more disorganized diatribe about the student keeps", "add it to the question, either by incorporating it into", "added no documented or documentable information, or new logical points,", "individual student, who is under age. (To be clear: I", "simplicity I will use he. Here are the red flags", "the point of a personal attack on an individual student,", "student keeps getting added here and there and everywhere. Examples:", "by arguing, around and around. When he has disagreed with", "I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a", "flags suggesting the OP is behaving like a provocateur. I", "and attacking an individual, who is under age? How can", "users' opinions. I'm afraid I can't quote the comment, because", "Here are the red flags I see: 1. OP has", "with the analysis and opinions other users have shared, he", "saying that personally identifiable information about the student has been", "joke;'\" \"I know the school and I can confirm that", "inner city school with extremely low standards and they teach", "always the longest response.\" My question: what can be done", "on board or ignore them. Nothing is accomplished by arguing,", "the longest response.\" My question: what can be done in", "know the school and I can confirm that it is", "in the original question, I appreciate that more is sometimes", "the text of the question, or by creating an addendum", "teach 99% to just pass the standard exams... I've even", "the best case scenario is to include all relevant information", "demonize me.\" 2. OP has been hypercritical of one of", "\"case\" against the student keeps growing, ad infinitum.** The OP", "suggesting the OP is behaving like a provocateur. I don't", "a question on Academia SE. If he is not happy", "pass the standard exams... I've even heard they give mult", "and they teach 99% to just pass the standard exams...", "has gotten now to the point of a personal attack", "hypercritical of one of his students, which is tangential to", "disorganized diatribe about the student keeps getting added here and", "is an inner city school with extremely low standards and", "that personally identifiable information about the student has been revealed.)", "of OP but for simplicity I will use he. Here", "we make clear that provocateur-like behavior is unacceptable on Academia", "an OP is baiting SE participants and attacking an individual,", "has been revealed.) 3. OP's \"case\" against the student keeps", "other users have shared, he is free to take them", "I am writing because I see several red flags suggesting", "board or ignore them. Nothing is accomplished by arguing, around", "More and more disorganized diatribe about the student keeps getting", "be done in such a case, where an OP is", "OP has been gradually adding scattered additional information about the", "the OP is behaving like a provocateur. I don't know", "extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/80951/am-i-being-a-mean-instructor-denying-an-extension-on-a-take-home-exam) Discussion has been extensive", "by creating an addendum at the bottom of the question.", "relevant information in the original question, I appreciate that more", "trying to demonize me.\" 2. OP has been hypercritical of", "or by creating an addendum at the bottom of the", "multiple comment threads. Although the best case scenario is to", "opinions. I'm afraid I can't quote the comment, because I", "documented or documentable information, or new logical points, he has", "OP but for simplicity I will use he. Here are", "mult choice tests where the answer is always the longest", "\"I know the school and I can confirm that it", "increasingly argumentative.** OP has posted a question on Academia SE." ]
[ "I can say, as a fairly active user and contributor", "to be members of the community. I'd be happy to", "Questions. As far as I can tell, the primary detriment", "an Upvote is \"HNQs are helpful\" and a Downvote is", "not directly from our own community.\" > > > Does", "a fairly active user and contributor to the site that", "> > \"@Fomite: For whatever it’s worth, most of the", "throwing in the towel have all been Hot Network Questions.", "can say, as a fairly active user and contributor to", "questions that end up on the Hot Network Questions listing", "our own community.\" > > > Does the Academia community", "I'd suggest an Upvote is \"HNQs are helpful\" and a", "comment by @Wrzlprmft: > > \"@Fomite: For whatever it’s worth,", "For whatever it’s worth, most of the problematic comments >", "the primary benefit is a sudden influx of users, but", "we have evidence that they stay? Growth from that listing", "problematic comments > and answers come from users attracted to", "Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd suggest an Upvote is \"HNQs are helpful\"", "Academia community actually benefit from being in that listing? As", "from that listing is only useful growth if the visitors", "Hot Network Questions. As far as I can tell, the", "have evidence that they stay? Growth from that listing is", "Questions. For the sake of \"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd", "the towel have all been Hot Network Questions. For the", "via Hot Network Questions. As far as I can tell,", "sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially this comment by @Wrzlprmft: > >", "Upvote is \"HNQs are helpful\" and a Downvote is \"HNQs", "the problematic comments > and answers come from users attracted", "that they stay? Growth from that listing is only useful", "this comment by @Wrzlprmft: > > \"@Fomite: For whatever it’s", "> \"@Fomite: For whatever it’s worth, most of the problematic", "from this meta thread: [Why are we challenging the premise", "whatever it’s worth, most of the problematic comments > and", "be members of the community. I'd be happy to hear", "if the visitors go on to continue to be members", "be happy to hear from individual users here who found", "etc. I can say, as a fairly active user and", "from our own community.\" > > > Does the Academia", "answers come from users attracted to the question via the", "that have made me consider throwing in the towel have", "questions and answers that have made me consider throwing in", "are Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd suggest an Upvote is \"HNQs are", "happy to hear from individual users here who found us", "do we have evidence that they stay? Growth from that", "of the problematic comments > and answers come from users", "become more controversial, etc. I can say, as a fairly", "is a sudden influx of users, but do we have", "premise rather than answering the question (question on potential sexist", "sudden influx of users, but do we have evidence that", "question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially this comment", "benefit from being in that listing? As far as I", "Growth from that listing is only useful growth if the", "stay? Growth from that listing is only useful growth if", "who found us via Hot Network Questions. As far as", "on the Hot Network Questions listing tend to drop fairly", "listing tend to drop fairly dramatically in quality, become more", "consider throwing in the towel have all been Hot Network", "As far as I can see, the primary benefit is", "can tell, the primary detriment is the questions that end", "detriment is the questions that end up on the Hot", "Network Questions. For the sake of \"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\" clairity,", "from individual users here who found us via Hot Network", "questions and not directly from our own community.\" > >", "is the questions that end up on the Hot Network", "visitors go on to continue to be members of the", "controversial, etc. I can say, as a fairly active user", "made me consider throwing in the towel have all been", "community actually benefit from being in that listing? As far", "of the community. I'd be happy to hear from individual", "to continue to be members of the community. I'd be", "> > Does the Academia community actually benefit from being", "I can tell, the primary detriment is the questions that", "remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially this comment by @Wrzlprmft: > > \"@Fomite:", "to hear from individual users here who found us via", "clairity, I'd suggest an Upvote is \"HNQs are helpful\" and", "especially this comment by @Wrzlprmft: > > \"@Fomite: For whatever", "by @Wrzlprmft: > > \"@Fomite: For whatever it’s worth, most", "have all been Hot Network Questions. For the sake of", "is \"HNQs are helpful\" and a Downvote is \"HNQs are", "growth if the visitors go on to continue to be", "me consider throwing in the towel have all been Hot", "\"@Fomite: For whatever it’s worth, most of the problematic comments", "Hot Network Questions. For the sake of \"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\"", "I can see, the primary benefit is a sudden influx", "community. I'd be happy to hear from individual users here", "of users, but do we have evidence that they stay?", "the sake of \"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd suggest an", "the visitors go on to continue to be members of", "in the towel have all been Hot Network Questions. For", "thread: [Why are we challenging the premise rather than answering", "active user and contributor to the site that the questions", "go on to continue to be members of the community.", "the site that the questions and answers that have made", "can see, the primary benefit is a sudden influx of", "comments > and answers come from users attracted to the", "(question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially this comment by", "> network questions and not directly from our own community.\"", "to the site that the questions and answers that have", "from being in that listing? As far as I can", "of \"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd suggest an Upvote is", "\"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd suggest an Upvote is \"HNQs", "most of the problematic comments > and answers come from", "on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially this comment by @Wrzlprmft:", "individual users here who found us via Hot Network Questions.", "Questions listing tend to drop fairly dramatically in quality, become", "Network Questions listing tend to drop fairly dramatically in quality,", "being in that listing? As far as I can see,", "listing? As far as I can see, the primary benefit", "that the questions and answers that have made me consider", "answers that have made me consider throwing in the towel", "partially from this meta thread: [Why are we challenging the", "that listing? As far as I can see, the primary", "on to continue to be members of the community. I'd", "and answers come from users attracted to the question via", "drop fairly dramatically in quality, become more controversial, etc. I", "as a fairly active user and contributor to the site", "us via Hot Network Questions. As far as I can", "end up on the Hot Network Questions listing tend to", "useful growth if the visitors go on to continue to", "up on the Hot Network Questions listing tend to drop", "more controversial, etc. I can say, as a fairly active", "are we challenging the premise rather than answering the question", "users, but do we have evidence that they stay? Growth", "suggest an Upvote is \"HNQs are helpful\" and a Downvote", "users attracted to the question via the hot > network", "dramatically in quality, become more controversial, etc. I can say,", "and answers that have made me consider throwing in the", "the questions and answers that have made me consider throwing", "evidence that they stay? Growth from that listing is only", "community.\" > > > Does the Academia community actually benefit", "listing is only useful growth if the visitors go on", "is only useful growth if the visitors go on to", "continue to be members of the community. I'd be happy", "attracted to the question via the hot > network questions", "here who found us via Hot Network Questions. As far", "\"HNQs are helpful\" and a Downvote is \"HNQs are unhelpful.\"", "benefit is a sudden influx of users, but do we", "Stemming partially from this meta thread: [Why are we challenging", "Does the Academia community actually benefit from being in that", "the primary detriment is the questions that end up on", "from users attracted to the question via the hot >", "For the sake of \"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd suggest", "user and contributor to the site that the questions and", "primary detriment is the questions that end up on the", "and contributor to the site that the questions and answers", "far as I can see, the primary benefit is a", "quality, become more controversial, etc. I can say, as a", "hot > network questions and not directly from our own", "members of the community. I'd be happy to hear from", "hear from individual users here who found us via Hot", "[Why are we challenging the premise rather than answering the", "site that the questions and answers that have made me", "worth, most of the problematic comments > and answers come", "as I can see, the primary benefit is a sudden", "directly from our own community.\" > > > Does the", "to the question via the hot > network questions and", "we challenging the premise rather than answering the question (question", "see, the primary benefit is a sudden influx of users,", "> Does the Academia community actually benefit from being in", "the community. I'd be happy to hear from individual users", "far as I can tell, the primary detriment is the", "it’s worth, most of the problematic comments > and answers", "the questions that end up on the Hot Network Questions", "a sudden influx of users, but do we have evidence", "that end up on the Hot Network Questions listing tend", "fairly active user and contributor to the site that the", "in that listing? As far as I can see, the", "meta thread: [Why are we challenging the premise rather than", "but do we have evidence that they stay? Growth from", "challenging the premise rather than answering the question (question on", "tend to drop fairly dramatically in quality, become more controversial,", "as I can tell, the primary detriment is the questions", "have made me consider throwing in the towel have all", "primary benefit is a sudden influx of users, but do", "all been Hot Network Questions. For the sake of \"Meta-votes", "this meta thread: [Why are we challenging the premise rather", "potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially this comment by @Wrzlprmft: >", "and not directly from our own community.\" > > >", "to drop fairly dramatically in quality, become more controversial, etc.", "been Hot Network Questions. For the sake of \"Meta-votes are", "Network Questions. As far as I can tell, the primary", "in quality, become more controversial, etc. I can say, as", "influx of users, but do we have evidence that they", "And especially this comment by @Wrzlprmft: > > \"@Fomite: For", "network questions and not directly from our own community.\" >", "only useful growth if the visitors go on to continue", "answering the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially", "the Hot Network Questions listing tend to drop fairly dramatically", "> > > Does the Academia community actually benefit from", "found us via Hot Network Questions. As far as I", "own community.\" > > > Does the Academia community actually", "@Wrzlprmft: > > \"@Fomite: For whatever it’s worth, most of", "the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And especially this", "the Academia community actually benefit from being in that listing?", "the question via the hot > network questions and not", "actually benefit from being in that listing? As far as", "As far as I can tell, the primary detriment is", "tell, the primary detriment is the questions that end up", "sake of \"Meta-votes are Agree/Disagree\" clairity, I'd suggest an Upvote", "rather than answering the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question)", "the premise rather than answering the question (question on potential", "that listing is only useful growth if the visitors go", "come from users attracted to the question via the hot", "via the hot > network questions and not directly from", "Hot Network Questions listing tend to drop fairly dramatically in", "the hot > network questions and not directly from our", "> and answers come from users attracted to the question", "users here who found us via Hot Network Questions. As", "say, as a fairly active user and contributor to the", "contributor to the site that the questions and answers that", "than answering the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3549/why-are-we-challenging-the-premise-rather-than-answering-the-question-question) And", "I'd be happy to hear from individual users here who", "they stay? Growth from that listing is only useful growth", "towel have all been Hot Network Questions. For the sake", "fairly dramatically in quality, become more controversial, etc. I can", "question via the hot > network questions and not directly" ]
[ "and answered in different ways depending on the reader's racial", "For this question, [When referring to races, should 'black' and", "affinity. (Should I have flagged the question instead of writing", "I have flagged the question instead of writing a Meta", "(Should I have flagged the question instead of writing a", "this question, [When referring to races, should 'black' and 'white'", "(MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore the \"ethnicity\" tag which a moderator removed.", "have flagged the question instead of writing a Meta question?)", "restore the \"ethnicity\" tag which a moderator removed. As my", "will be viewed and answered in different ways depending on", "answered in different ways depending on the reader's racial identity", "removed. As my answer shows, this question will be viewed", "my answer shows, this question will be viewed and answered", "identity and affinity. (Should I have flagged the question instead", "a moderator removed. As my answer shows, this question will", "be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore the \"ethnicity\" tag which a", "'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore the \"ethnicity\" tag which", "to races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please", "question, [When referring to races, should 'black' and 'white' be", "\"ethnicity\" tag which a moderator removed. As my answer shows,", "on the reader's racial identity and affinity. (Should I have", "be viewed and answered in different ways depending on the", "races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore", "capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore the \"ethnicity\" tag which a moderator", "depending on the reader's racial identity and affinity. (Should I", "the reader's racial identity and affinity. (Should I have flagged", "racial identity and affinity. (Should I have flagged the question", "reader's racial identity and affinity. (Should I have flagged the", "moderator removed. As my answer shows, this question will be", "different ways depending on the reader's racial identity and affinity.", "this question will be viewed and answered in different ways", "viewed and answered in different ways depending on the reader's", "As my answer shows, this question will be viewed and", "the \"ethnicity\" tag which a moderator removed. As my answer", "please restore the \"ethnicity\" tag which a moderator removed. As", "'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore the \"ethnicity\"", "in different ways depending on the reader's racial identity and", "referring to races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436),", "[When referring to races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized?", "question will be viewed and answered in different ways depending", "ways depending on the reader's racial identity and affinity. (Should", "should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore the", "and affinity. (Should I have flagged the question instead of", "tag which a moderator removed. As my answer shows, this", "shows, this question will be viewed and answered in different", "answer shows, this question will be viewed and answered in", "which a moderator removed. As my answer shows, this question", "and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/32436), please restore the \"ethnicity\" tag" ]
[ "this site, rather than offering an answer to the question.", "so, for what reason? Perhaps I could flag it as", "reason? Perhaps I could flag it as \"not an answer,\"", "example would be [Am I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying", "the flags were appropriate, whether they were accepted, etc. I'm", "I wrote in a comment. In this example, the moderator", "the moderator did not delete the answer. The answer was", "editing to remove that last part, and elaborating on the", "answer to the question. The part of this post that", "if I see \"dogpiling\" going on, i.e. more and more", "anything new? The now famous question about \"Should I call", "because it reiterates a previous answer, without adding anything new?", "have behaved in a sexist way?\" is not the only", "don't know whether the flags were appropriate, whether they were", "would be [Am I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an", "I found an example of helpful moderator action which was", "Academia Meta question. My question is, if I see \"dogpiling\"", "question. The part of this post that is an answer", "were accepted, etc. I'm just posting this example to further", "details and explanation. I suggest editing to remove that last", "below the answer: > > This has been flagged by", "users as \"not an answer\". I'm inclined to agree; most", "answer\" flags. Of course I don't know whether the flags", "of this post that is an answer doesn't add anything", "ganging up on a user, may I flag the answer?", "it reiterates a previous answer, without adding anything new? The", "not the only situation where I have seen dogpiling. Another", "several users as \"not an answer\". I'm inclined to agree;", "than offering an answer to the question. The part of", "going on, i.e. more and more people are jumping on", "Perhaps I could flag it as \"not an answer,\" because", "in a comment. In this example, the moderator did not", "a comment. In this example, the moderator did not delete", "where I have seen dogpiling. Another recent example would be", "post that is an answer doesn't add anything over other,", "and explanation. I suggest editing to remove that last part,", "as \"not an answer,\" because it reiterates a previous answer,", "student who may have behaved in a sexist way?\" is", "by an interesting [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another Academia Meta question. My", "to agree; most of this post is about criticizing the", "over the other answers. Otherwise, I recommend deleting this. >", "moderator comment below the answer: > > This has been", "auto-deleted.) Here is a link the the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The", "example, the moderator did not delete the answer. The answer", "The now famous question about \"Should I call out a", "up on a user, may I flag the answer? If", "elaborating on the first part if you have something to", "interesting [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another Academia Meta question. My question is,", "\"dogpiling\" going on, i.e. more and more people are jumping", "i.e. more and more people are jumping on a bandwagon,", "answer? If so, for what reason? Perhaps I could flag", "answer, without adding anything new? The now famous question about", "\"Should I call out a student who may have behaved", "a sexist way?\" is not the only situation where I", "answer: > > This has been flagged by several users", "about criticizing the OP's activities on this site, rather than", "situation where I have seen dogpiling. Another recent example would", "Edit: I found an example of helpful moderator action which", "I'm inclined to agree; most of this post is about", "body of the helpful moderator comment below the answer: >", "may have behaved in a sexist way?\" is not the", "was in fact auto-deleted.) Here is a link the the", "reiterates a previous answer, without adding anything new? The now", "a previous answer, without adding anything new? The now famous", "being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a take", "an example of helpful moderator action which was apparently triggered", "to the question. The part of this post that is", "offer the same point of view but more details and", "on, i.e. more and more people are jumping on a", "user, may I flag the answer? If so, for what", "agree; most of this post is about criticizing the OP's", "flags were appropriate, whether they were accepted, etc. I'm just", "something I wrote in a comment. In this example, the", "etc. I'm just posting this example to further the discussion.", "the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body of the helpful moderator comment", "Here is a link the the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body", "could flag it as \"not an answer,\" because it reiterates", "previous answer, without adding anything new? The now famous question", "without adding anything new? The now famous question about \"Should", "now famous question about \"Should I call out a student", "--- Edit: I found an example of helpful moderator action", "question. My question is, if I see \"dogpiling\" going on,", "jumping on a bandwagon, ganging up on a user, may", "Another recent example would be [Am I being a \"mean\"", "an answer\" flags. Of course I don't know whether the", "the OP's activities on this site, rather than offering an", "view but more details and explanation. I suggest editing to", "have something to add over the other answers. Otherwise, I", "moderator did not delete the answer. The answer was in", "the answer: > > This has been flagged by several", "remove that last part, and elaborating on the first part", "the other answers. Otherwise, I recommend deleting this. > >", "posting this example to further the discussion. (Note, I was", "is motivated by an interesting [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another Academia Meta", "[Am I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on", "I flag the answer? If so, for what reason? Perhaps", "moderator action which was apparently triggered by some \"not an", "I suggest editing to remove that last part, and elaborating", "way?\" is not the only situation where I have seen", "\"not an answer\" flags. Of course I don't know whether", "\"not an answer,\" because it reiterates a previous answer, without", "same point of view but more details and explanation. I", "answer. The answer was in fact auto-deleted.) Here is a", "site, rather than offering an answer to the question. The", "doesn't add anything over other, better answers that offer the", "are jumping on a bandwagon, ganging up on a user,", "which was apparently triggered by some \"not an answer\" flags.", "an answer doesn't add anything over other, better answers that", "flag it as \"not an answer,\" because it reiterates a", "In this example, the moderator did not delete the answer.", "question about \"Should I call out a student who may", "post is about criticizing the OP's activities on this site,", "example to further the discussion. (Note, I was mistaken in", "add over the other answers. Otherwise, I recommend deleting this.", "answer doesn't add anything over other, better answers that offer", "I was mistaken in something I wrote in a comment.", "denying an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit:", "an answer to the question. The part of this post", "in a sexist way?\" is not the only situation where", "a link the the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body of the", "explanation. I suggest editing to remove that last part, and", "adding anything new? The now famous question about \"Should I", "example of helpful moderator action which was apparently triggered by", "activities on this site, rather than offering an answer to", "delete the answer. The answer was in fact auto-deleted.) Here", "take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit: I found an example of", "has been flagged by several users as \"not an answer\".", "as \"not an answer\". I'm inclined to agree; most of", "in something I wrote in a comment. In this example,", "and elaborating on the first part if you have something", "I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a", "> This has been flagged by several users as \"not", "\"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436)", "to remove that last part, and elaborating on the first", "flags. Of course I don't know whether the flags were", "an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit: I", "on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit: I found an", "home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit: I found an example of helpful", "point of view but more details and explanation. I suggest", "part, and elaborating on the first part if you have", "The body of the helpful moderator comment below the answer:", "[answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another Academia Meta question. My question is, if", "a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit: I found an example", "most of this post is about criticizing the OP's activities", "more and more people are jumping on a bandwagon, ganging", "by some \"not an answer\" flags. Of course I don't", "of view but more details and explanation. I suggest editing", "is, if I see \"dogpiling\" going on, i.e. more and", "I call out a student who may have behaved in", "whether the flags were appropriate, whether they were accepted, etc.", "answers that offer the same point of view but more", "that offer the same point of view but more details", "on a bandwagon, ganging up on a user, may I", "was apparently triggered by some \"not an answer\" flags. Of", "more details and explanation. I suggest editing to remove that", "Meta question. My question is, if I see \"dogpiling\" going", "discussion. (Note, I was mistaken in something I wrote in", "is not the only situation where I have seen dogpiling.", "see \"dogpiling\" going on, i.e. more and more people are", "the the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body of the helpful moderator", "to further the discussion. (Note, I was mistaken in something", "> > This has been flagged by several users as", "this post that is an answer doesn't add anything over", "to add over the other answers. Otherwise, I recommend deleting", "inclined to agree; most of this post is about criticizing", "is an answer doesn't add anything over other, better answers", "part if you have something to add over the other", "first part if you have something to add over the", "the answer? If so, for what reason? Perhaps I could", "I could flag it as \"not an answer,\" because it", "link the the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body of the helpful", "triggered by some \"not an answer\" flags. Of course I", "the answer. The answer was in fact auto-deleted.) Here is", "by several users as \"not an answer\". I'm inclined to", "some \"not an answer\" flags. Of course I don't know", "over other, better answers that offer the same point of", "an answer,\" because it reiterates a previous answer, without adding", "last part, and elaborating on the first part if you", "the discussion. (Note, I was mistaken in something I wrote", "motivated by an interesting [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another Academia Meta question.", "criticizing the OP's activities on this site, rather than offering", "\"not an answer\". I'm inclined to agree; most of this", "this example, the moderator did not delete the answer. The", "question is, if I see \"dogpiling\" going on, i.e. more", "extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit: I found", "dogpiling. Another recent example would be [Am I being a", "better answers that offer the same point of view but", "and more people are jumping on a bandwagon, ganging up", "what reason? Perhaps I could flag it as \"not an", "out a student who may have behaved in a sexist", "on the first part if you have something to add", "about \"Should I call out a student who may have", "sexist way?\" is not the only situation where I have", "found an example of helpful moderator action which was apparently", "if you have something to add over the other answers.", "fact auto-deleted.) Here is a link the the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436>", "that is an answer doesn't add anything over other, better", "only situation where I have seen dogpiling. Another recent example", "My question is, if I see \"dogpiling\" going on, i.e.", "add anything over other, better answers that offer the same", "call out a student who may have behaved in a", "whether they were accepted, etc. I'm just posting this example", "(Note, I was mistaken in something I wrote in a", "appropriate, whether they were accepted, etc. I'm just posting this", "seen dogpiling. Another recent example would be [Am I being", "was mistaken in something I wrote in a comment. In", "to another Academia Meta question. My question is, if I", "on a user, may I flag the answer? If so,", "answer was in fact auto-deleted.) Here is a link the", "just posting this example to further the discussion. (Note, I", "answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body of the helpful moderator comment below", "answer\". I'm inclined to agree; most of this post is", "you have something to add over the other answers. Otherwise,", "for what reason? Perhaps I could flag it as \"not", "the same point of view but more details and explanation.", "instructor, denying an extension on a take home exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) ---", "accepted, etc. I'm just posting this example to further the", "mistaken in something I wrote in a comment. In this", "another Academia Meta question. My question is, if I see", "a user, may I flag the answer? If so, for", "a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension on a take home", "may I flag the answer? If so, for what reason?", "Of course I don't know whether the flags were appropriate,", "bandwagon, ganging up on a user, may I flag the", "apparently triggered by some \"not an answer\" flags. Of course", "helpful moderator action which was apparently triggered by some \"not", "The answer was in fact auto-deleted.) Here is a link", "of this post is about criticizing the OP's activities on", "The part of this post that is an answer doesn't", "anything over other, better answers that offer the same point", "question is motivated by an interesting [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another Academia", "a student who may have behaved in a sexist way?\"", "of helpful moderator action which was apparently triggered by some", "is a link the the answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body of", "helpful moderator comment below the answer: > > This has", "rather than offering an answer to the question. The part", "This question is motivated by an interesting [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another", "I have seen dogpiling. Another recent example would be [Am", "other, better answers that offer the same point of view", "but more details and explanation. I suggest editing to remove", "further the discussion. (Note, I was mistaken in something I", "have seen dogpiling. Another recent example would be [Am I", "know whether the flags were appropriate, whether they were accepted,", "course I don't know whether the flags were appropriate, whether", "an interesting [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/3562/32436) to another Academia Meta question. My question", "be [Am I being a \"mean\" instructor, denying an extension", "I don't know whether the flags were appropriate, whether they", "part of this post that is an answer doesn't add", "did not delete the answer. The answer was in fact", "offering an answer to the question. The part of this", "the question. The part of this post that is an", "a bandwagon, ganging up on a user, may I flag", "been flagged by several users as \"not an answer\". I'm", "comment. In this example, the moderator did not delete the", "recent example would be [Am I being a \"mean\" instructor,", "who may have behaved in a sexist way?\" is not", "not delete the answer. The answer was in fact auto-deleted.)", "more people are jumping on a bandwagon, ganging up on", "of the helpful moderator comment below the answer: > >", "I see \"dogpiling\" going on, i.e. more and more people", "This has been flagged by several users as \"not an", "they were accepted, etc. I'm just posting this example to", "If so, for what reason? Perhaps I could flag it", "suggest editing to remove that last part, and elaborating on", "I'm just posting this example to further the discussion. (Note,", "on this site, rather than offering an answer to the", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81033/32436> The body of the helpful moderator comment below the", "flagged by several users as \"not an answer\". I'm inclined", "other answers. Otherwise, I recommend deleting this. > > >", "it as \"not an answer,\" because it reiterates a previous", "famous question about \"Should I call out a student who", "in fact auto-deleted.) Here is a link the the answer:", "the helpful moderator comment below the answer: > > This", "were appropriate, whether they were accepted, etc. I'm just posting", "is about criticizing the OP's activities on this site, rather", "action which was apparently triggered by some \"not an answer\"", "the first part if you have something to add over", "that last part, and elaborating on the first part if", "comment below the answer: > > This has been flagged", "flag the answer? If so, for what reason? Perhaps I", "this post is about criticizing the OP's activities on this", "something to add over the other answers. Otherwise, I recommend", "people are jumping on a bandwagon, ganging up on a", "answer,\" because it reiterates a previous answer, without adding anything", "the only situation where I have seen dogpiling. Another recent", "exam](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80951/32436) --- Edit: I found an example of helpful moderator", "this example to further the discussion. (Note, I was mistaken", "behaved in a sexist way?\" is not the only situation", "an answer\". I'm inclined to agree; most of this post", "OP's activities on this site, rather than offering an answer", "new? The now famous question about \"Should I call out", "wrote in a comment. In this example, the moderator did" ]
[ "of answers were posted and discussed at great length. Is", "(i.e. flag as \"not an answer\")? If not, what should,", "answer\")? If not, what should, or could, be done instead?", "Is it appropriate now to flag the existing answers that", "the question in its rewritten form (i.e. flag as \"not", "(question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread the right word?)", "as \"not an answer\")? If not, what should, or could,", "existing answers that don't answer the question in its rewritten", "very long thread): [Why are we challenging the premise rather", "thread): [Why are we challenging the premise rather than answering", "(Is thread the right word?) (Not sure whether this other", "[What to do about old questions whose answers are now", "the conclusion was (it was a very* long thread): [Why", "and would be glad if someone could please remind me", "is relevant: [What to do about old questions whose answers", "or could, be done instead? If moderators already provided guidance", "question is relevant: [What to do about old questions whose", "someone could please remind me what the conclusion was (it", "what should, or could, be done instead? If moderators already", "now to flag the existing answers that don't answer the", "its rewritten form (i.e. flag as \"not an answer\")? If", "an answer\")? If not, what should, or could, be done", "be done instead? If moderators already provided guidance about this", "was substantially rewritten, but not before a number of answers", "don't answer the question in its rewritten form (i.e. flag", "\"not an answer\")? If not, what should, or could, be", "should, or could, be done instead? If moderators already provided", "and discussed at great length. Is it appropriate now to", "apologize and would be glad if someone could please remind", "premise rather than answering the question (question on potential sexist", "potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread the right word?) (Not sure", "before a number of answers were posted and discussed at", "other question is relevant: [What to do about old questions", "the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread* the", "already provided guidance about this in the following related Meta", "were posted and discussed at great length. Is it appropriate", "appropriate now to flag the existing answers that don't answer", "rather than answering the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436).", "answering the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread", "following related Meta question, I apologize and would be glad", "if someone could please remind me what the conclusion was", "was (it was a very long thread): [Why are we", "long thread): [Why are we challenging the premise rather than", "rewritten form (i.e. flag as \"not an answer\")? If not,", "question, I apologize and would be glad if someone could", "rewritten, but not before a number of answers were posted", "on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread the right word?) (Not", "this other question is relevant: [What to do about old", "word?) (Not sure whether this other question is relevant: [What", "great length. Is it appropriate now to flag the existing", "number of answers were posted and discussed at great length.", "to flag the existing answers that don't answer the question", "substantially rewritten, but not before a number of answers were", "the existing answers that don't answer the question in its", "that don't answer the question in its rewritten form (i.e.", "what the conclusion was (it was a very long thread):", "controversial [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/32436) was substantially rewritten, but not before a number", "the right word?) (Not sure whether this other question is", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/32436) was substantially rewritten, but not before a number of", "it appropriate now to flag the existing answers that don't", "flag the existing answers that don't answer the question in", "answers that don't answer the question in its rewritten form", "discussed at great length. Is it appropriate now to flag", "(it was a very* long thread): [Why are we challenging", "not, what should, or could, be done instead? If moderators", "answer the question in its rewritten form (i.e. flag as", "length. Is it appropriate now to flag the existing answers", "are we challenging the premise rather than answering the question", "related Meta question, I apologize and would be glad if", "than answering the question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is", "about this in the following related Meta question, I apologize", "question in its rewritten form (i.e. flag as \"not an", "relevant: [What to do about old questions whose answers are", "was a very long thread): [Why are we challenging the", "a very long thread): [Why are we challenging the premise", "could, be done instead? If moderators already provided guidance about", "guidance about this in the following related Meta question, I", "conclusion was (it was a very long thread): [Why are", "[Why are we challenging the premise rather than answering the", "whether this other question is relevant: [What to do about", "me what the conclusion was (it was a very long", "we challenging the premise rather than answering the question (question", "A controversial [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80561/32436) was substantially rewritten, but not before a", "posted and discussed at great length. Is it appropriate now", "If not, what should, or could, be done instead? If", "I apologize and would be glad if someone could please", "challenging the premise rather than answering the question (question on", "thread the right word?) (Not sure whether this other question", "sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread* the right word?) (Not sure whether", "glad if someone could please remind me what the conclusion", "to do about old questions whose answers are now invalid](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1699/what-to-do-about-old-questions-whose-answers-are-now-invalid))", "but not before a number of answers were posted and", "in its rewritten form (i.e. flag as \"not an answer\")?", "not before a number of answers were posted and discussed", "a number of answers were posted and discussed at great", "done instead? If moderators already provided guidance about this in", "the following related Meta question, I apologize and would be", "remind me what the conclusion was (it was a very", "form (i.e. flag as \"not an answer\")? If not, what", "answers were posted and discussed at great length. Is it", "provided guidance about this in the following related Meta question,", "(Not sure whether this other question is relevant: [What to", "flag as \"not an answer\")? If not, what should, or", "sure whether this other question is relevant: [What to do", "instead? If moderators already provided guidance about this in the", "this in the following related Meta question, I apologize and", "please remind me what the conclusion was (it was a", "in the following related Meta question, I apologize and would", "If moderators already provided guidance about this in the following", "Meta question, I apologize and would be glad if someone", "would be glad if someone could please remind me what", "remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread* the right word?) (Not sure whether this", "right word?) (Not sure whether this other question is relevant:", "the premise rather than answering the question (question on potential", "question (question on potential sexist remarks)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3549/32436). (Is thread the right", "at great length. Is it appropriate now to flag the", "be glad if someone could please remind me what the", "moderators already provided guidance about this in the following related", "could please remind me what the conclusion was (it was" ]
[ "two tags: [code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone please explain what", "and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone please explain what is the difference", "the difference between them? Wouldn't it make sense to merge", "someone please explain what is the difference between them? Wouldn't", "Could someone please explain what is the difference between them?", "[software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone please explain what is the difference between", "that there are two tags: [code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone", "are two tags: [code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone please explain", "there are two tags: [code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone please", "tags: [code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone please explain what is", "I've noticed that there are two tags: [code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software).", "please explain what is the difference between them? Wouldn't it", "explain what is the difference between them? Wouldn't it make", "noticed that there are two tags: [code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could", "what is the difference between them? Wouldn't it make sense", "difference between them? Wouldn't it make sense to merge them?", "[code](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/code) and [software](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software). Could someone please explain what is the", "is the difference between them? Wouldn't it make sense to" ]
[ "separate answer but they have not done so to date", "I incorporate the information from the comment into my answer,", "from the comment into my answer, giving proper credit to", "credit to it, or just leave it as it is?", "to the question [When referring to races, should 'black' and", "as a separate answer but they have not done so", "later). Should I incorporate the information from the comment into", "to races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another", "comment into my answer, giving proper credit to it, or", "proper credit to it, or just leave it as it", "an up-voted (5 at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains new information.", "but they have not done so to date (9 days", "done so to date (9 days later). Should I incorporate", "contains new information. Another user has suggested that they should", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81220/12454) to the question [When referring to races, should 'black'", "Another user has suggested that they should write it up", "information from the comment into my answer, giving proper credit", "my answer, giving proper credit to it, or just leave", "has suggested that they should write it up as a", "should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user has", "and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user has posted an", "(MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user has posted an up-voted (5 at present)", "(9 days later). Should I incorporate the information from the", "information. Another user has suggested that they should write it", "new information. Another user has suggested that they should write", "'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user has posted an up-voted", "[my answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81220/12454) to the question [When referring to races, should", "present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains new information. Another user has suggested", "to date (9 days later). Should I incorporate the information", "not done so to date (9 days later). Should I", "[When referring to races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized?", "write it up as a separate answer but they have", "races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user", "up-voted (5 at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains new information. Another", "that contains new information. Another user has suggested that they", "user has suggested that they should write it up as", "On [my answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/81220/12454) to the question [When referring to races,", "suggested that they should write it up as a separate", "a separate answer but they have not done so to", "question [When referring to races, should 'black' and 'white' be", "it up as a separate answer but they have not", "they have not done so to date (9 days later).", "they should write it up as a separate answer but", "(5 at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains new information. Another user", "incorporate the information from the comment into my answer, giving", "into my answer, giving proper credit to it, or just", "have not done so to date (9 days later). Should", "that they should write it up as a separate answer", "date (9 days later). Should I incorporate the information from", "capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user has posted an up-voted (5 at", "has posted an up-voted (5 at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains", "Should I incorporate the information from the comment into my", "referring to races, should 'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454),", "at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains new information. Another user has", "up as a separate answer but they have not done", "answer but they have not done so to date (9", "'black' and 'white' be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user has posted", "should write it up as a separate answer but they", "the question [When referring to races, should 'black' and 'white'", "be capitalized? (MLA)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/81218/12454), another user has posted an up-voted (5", "posted an up-voted (5 at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains new", "the information from the comment into my answer, giving proper", "another user has posted an up-voted (5 at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220)", "user has posted an up-voted (5 at present) [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that", "answer, giving proper credit to it, or just leave it", "[comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/81218/when-referring-to-races-should-black-and-white-be-capitalized-mla/81220#comment201152_81220) that contains new information. Another user has suggested that", "giving proper credit to it, or just leave it as", "days later). Should I incorporate the information from the comment", "so to date (9 days later). Should I incorporate the", "the comment into my answer, giving proper credit to it," ]
[ "my main worry: it seems to me that when I", "activity here. It seems to me that this may be", "Academia as much lately. This is probably a natural phenomenon", "sites if they are getting enough new active users (and", "true, then it seems likely that either usage (measured in", "seems to me that when I have been browsing new", "that either usage (measured in some sense) of Academia will", "issue on Academia than some of the other sites (because", "SE sites, and isn't necessarily a problem for the sites", "this issue is in fact real, is there anything we", "been using Academia as much lately. This is probably a", "if they are getting enough new active users (and may", "sort of a disclaimer to this observation, which is my", "Do other people see a similar issue with the questions", "get data about numbers of questions that are or aren't", "real, is there anything we can or should try to", "by the growth of the site.) > > > Second:", "either duplicates (if not in the technical sense, at least", "been browsing new questions here, most of them are either", "of Academia(.SE): I don't claim to be an integral or", "either usage (measured in some sense) of Academia will eventually", "there any data for or against this? (Surely we can", "about numbers of questions that are or aren't duplicates; being", "on Academia than some of the other sites (because there", "\"broad interest\" and/or questions are more focused on changing developments).", "become more and more specialized. First: > > Do other", "(because there are a lot more possible questions of \"broad", "I think this partially accounts for my decrease in activity", "of an issue on Academia than some of the other", "to ponder on the future of Academia(.SE): I don't claim", "or representative user of this site, but I've noticed I", "data about numbers of questions that are or aren't duplicates;", "this partially accounts for my decrease in activity here. It", "focused on changing developments). If this observation is true, then", "most of them are either duplicates (if not in the", "is true, then it seems likely that either usage (measured", "browsing new questions here, most of them are either duplicates", "and/or questions are more focused on changing developments). If this", "\"broad interest\" by counting question votes inversely scaled by the", "to me that when I have been browsing new questions", "can or should try to do about it? > >", "the growth of the site.) > > > Second: >", "It seems to me that this may be more of", "me to ponder on the future of Academia(.SE): I don't", "don't claim to be an integral or representative user of", "than some of the other sites (because there are a", "If this observation is true, then it seems likely that", "observation is true, then it seems likely that either usage", "boon, if you're getting less of me :). The above", "think this partially accounts for my decrease in activity here.", "of Academia will eventually peter off or questions will tend", "being asked here? (mostly duplicates/very specialized) Or is there any", "(Surely we can get data about numbers of questions that", "hard to measure directly, but we could try to measure", "interest\" by counting question votes inversely scaled by the growth", "me that this may be more of an issue on", "accounts for my decrease in activity here. It seems to", "we could try to measure \"broad interest\" by counting question", "> > Second: > > If this issue is in", "be an integral or representative user of this site, but", "in the technical sense, at least morally so) or about", "enough new active users (and may be a boon, if", "decrease in activity here. It seems to me that this", "may be more of an issue on Academia than some", "less of me :). The above was sort of a", "duplicates; being \"too specialized\" may be hard to measure directly,", "ponder on the future of Academia(.SE): I don't claim to", "peter off or questions will tend to become more and", "or about some specialized issue I am not so interested", "for the sites if they are getting enough new active", "be a boon, if you're getting less of me :).", "technical sense, at least morally so) or about some specialized", "some of the other sites (because there are a lot", "seems to me that this may be more of an", "can get data about numbers of questions that are or", "measure \"broad interest\" by counting question votes inversely scaled by", "that when I have been browsing new questions here, most", "morally so) or about some specialized issue I am not", "counting question votes inversely scaled by the growth of the", "votes inversely scaled by the growth of the site.) >", "an integral or representative user of this site, but I've", "disclaimer to this observation, which is my main worry: it", "about some specialized issue I am not so interested in.", "or should try to do about it? > > >", "specialized. First: > > Do other people see a similar", "above was sort of a disclaimer to this observation, which", "least morally so) or about some specialized issue I am", "they are getting enough new active users (and may be", "site.) > > > Second: > > If this issue", "at least morally so) or about some specialized issue I", "this may be more of an issue on Academia than", "site, but I've noticed I personally haven't been using Academia", "be more of an issue on Academia than some of", "> > > Second: > > If this issue is", "if you're getting less of me :). The above was", "there are a lot more possible questions of \"broad interest\"", "then it seems likely that either usage (measured in some", "> > If this issue is in fact real, is", "future of Academia(.SE): I don't claim to be an integral", "so) or about some specialized issue I am not so", "for or against this? (Surely we can get data about", "directly, but we could try to measure \"broad interest\" by", "> If this issue is in fact real, is there", "questions will tend to become more and more specialized. First:", "problem for the sites if they are getting enough new", "getting less of me :). The above was sort of", "a disclaimer to this observation, which is my main worry:", "new questions here, most of them are either duplicates (if", "them are either duplicates (if not in the technical sense,", "in. I think this partially accounts for my decrease in", "see a similar issue with the questions being asked here?", "to become more and more specialized. First: > > Do", "to me that this may be more of an issue", "more and more specialized. First: > > Do other people", "more specialized. First: > > Do other people see a", "against this? (Surely we can get data about numbers of", "are a lot more possible questions of \"broad interest\" and/or", "the questions being asked here? (mostly duplicates/very specialized) Or is", "for many users across the SE sites, and isn't necessarily", "am not so interested in. I think this partially accounts", "users (and may be a boon, if you're getting less", "you're getting less of me :). The above was sort", "specialized issue I am not so interested in. I think", "possible questions of \"broad interest\" and/or questions are more focused", "users across the SE sites, and isn't necessarily a problem", "observation, which is my main worry: it seems to me", "integral or representative user of this site, but I've noticed", "or questions will tend to become more and more specialized.", "by counting question votes inversely scaled by the growth of", "here? (mostly duplicates/very specialized) Or is there any data for", "growth of the site.) > > > Second: > >", "lately. This is probably a natural phenomenon for many users", "more possible questions of \"broad interest\" and/or questions are more", "more of an issue on Academia than some of the", "a problem for the sites if they are getting enough", "active users (and may be a boon, if you're getting", "some specialized issue I am not so interested in. I", "it seems likely that either usage (measured in some sense)", "the site.) > > > Second: > > If this", "much lately. This is probably a natural phenomenon for many", "sense) of Academia will eventually peter off or questions will", "so interested in. I think this partially accounts for my", "other sites (because there are a lot more possible questions", "developments). If this observation is true, then it seems likely", "a similar issue with the questions being asked here? (mostly", "data for or against this? (Surely we can get data", "If this issue is in fact real, is there anything", "issue is in fact real, is there anything we can", "are or aren't duplicates; being \"too specialized\" may be hard", "of a disclaimer to this observation, which is my main", "duplicates (if not in the technical sense, at least morally", "this observation is true, then it seems likely that either", "as much lately. This is probably a natural phenomenon for", "I have been browsing new questions here, most of them", "numbers of questions that are or aren't duplicates; being \"too", "we can get data about numbers of questions that are", "try to measure \"broad interest\" by counting question votes inversely", "Or is there any data for or against this? (Surely", "this observation, which is my main worry: it seems to", "anything we can or should try to do about it?", "This is probably a natural phenomenon for many users across", "and isn't necessarily a problem for the sites if they", "specialized\" may be hard to measure directly, but we could", "a boon, if you're getting less of me :). The", "a lot more possible questions of \"broad interest\" and/or questions", "not in the technical sense, at least morally so) or", "of them are either duplicates (if not in the technical", "Academia will eventually peter off or questions will tend to", "more focused on changing developments). If this observation is true,", "likely that either usage (measured in some sense) of Academia", "Academia than some of the other sites (because there are", "and more specialized. First: > > Do other people see", "will tend to become more and more specialized. First: >", "partially accounts for my decrease in activity here. It seems", "not so interested in. I think this partially accounts for", "to measure \"broad interest\" by counting question votes inversely scaled", "First: > > Do other people see a similar issue", "similar issue with the questions being asked here? (mostly duplicates/very", "was sort of a disclaimer to this observation, which is", "tend to become more and more specialized. First: > >", "personally haven't been using Academia as much lately. This is", "sense, at least morally so) or about some specialized issue", "natural phenomenon for many users across the SE sites, and", "to measure directly, but we could try to measure \"broad", "interest\" and/or questions are more focused on changing developments). If", "other people see a similar issue with the questions being", "> Do other people see a similar issue with the", "isn't necessarily a problem for the sites if they are", "some sense) of Academia will eventually peter off or questions", "is there any data for or against this? (Surely we", "changing developments). If this observation is true, then it seems", "on the future of Academia(.SE): I don't claim to be", "me that when I have been browsing new questions here,", "the technical sense, at least morally so) or about some", "seems likely that either usage (measured in some sense) of", "are getting enough new active users (and may be a", "is probably a natural phenomenon for many users across the", "that this may be more of an issue on Academia", "of the site.) > > > Second: > > If", "> Second: > > If this issue is in fact", "(measured in some sense) of Academia will eventually peter off", "fact real, is there anything we can or should try", "of me :). The above was sort of a disclaimer", "using Academia as much lately. This is probably a natural", "are either duplicates (if not in the technical sense, at", "any data for or against this? (Surely we can get", "be hard to measure directly, but we could try to", "being \"too specialized\" may be hard to measure directly, but", "main worry: it seems to me that when I have", "in activity here. It seems to me that this may", "questions of \"broad interest\" and/or questions are more focused on", "is there anything we can or should try to do", "> > Do other people see a similar issue with", "a natural phenomenon for many users across the SE sites,", "of the other sites (because there are a lot more", "sites (because there are a lot more possible questions of", "this site, but I've noticed I personally haven't been using", "worry: it seems to me that when I have been", "lot more possible questions of \"broad interest\" and/or questions are", "getting enough new active users (and may be a boon,", "specialized) Or is there any data for or against this?", "which is my main worry: it seems to me that", "(if not in the technical sense, at least morally so)", "or aren't duplicates; being \"too specialized\" may be hard to", "may be a boon, if you're getting less of me", "I personally haven't been using Academia as much lately. This", "here, most of them are either duplicates (if not in", "my decrease in activity here. It seems to me that", "or against this? (Surely we can get data about numbers", "(and may be a boon, if you're getting less of", "have been browsing new questions here, most of them are", "phenomenon for many users across the SE sites, and isn't", "for my decrease in activity here. It seems to me", "with the questions being asked here? (mostly duplicates/very specialized) Or", "many users across the SE sites, and isn't necessarily a", "issue I am not so interested in. I think this", "Academia(.SE): I don't claim to be an integral or representative", "of \"broad interest\" and/or questions are more focused on changing", "people see a similar issue with the questions being asked", "but we could try to measure \"broad interest\" by counting", "is my main worry: it seems to me that when", "aren't duplicates; being \"too specialized\" may be hard to measure", "claim to be an integral or representative user of this", "of this site, but I've noticed I personally haven't been", "noticed I personally haven't been using Academia as much lately.", "me :). The above was sort of a disclaimer to", "to this observation, which is my main worry: it seems", "we can or should try to do about it? >", "probably a natural phenomenon for many users across the SE", "interested in. I think this partially accounts for my decrease", "off or questions will tend to become more and more", "that are or aren't duplicates; being \"too specialized\" may be", "(mostly duplicates/very specialized) Or is there any data for or", "user of this site, but I've noticed I personally haven't", "I am not so interested in. I think this partially", "eventually peter off or questions will tend to become more", "necessarily a problem for the sites if they are getting", "issue with the questions being asked here? (mostly duplicates/very specialized)", "to be an integral or representative user of this site,", "questions here, most of them are either duplicates (if not", "\"too specialized\" may be hard to measure directly, but we", "question votes inversely scaled by the growth of the site.)", "Second: > > If this issue is in fact real,", "The above was sort of a disclaimer to this observation,", ":). The above was sort of a disclaimer to this", "new active users (and may be a boon, if you're", "here. It seems to me that this may be more", "inversely scaled by the growth of the site.) > >", "the sites if they are getting enough new active users", "the SE sites, and isn't necessarily a problem for the", "is in fact real, is there anything we can or", "questions are more focused on changing developments). If this observation", "the future of Academia(.SE): I don't claim to be an", "in some sense) of Academia will eventually peter off or", "there anything we can or should try to do about", "across the SE sites, and isn't necessarily a problem for", "sites, and isn't necessarily a problem for the sites if", "haven't been using Academia as much lately. This is probably", "will eventually peter off or questions will tend to become", "representative user of this site, but I've noticed I personally", "of questions that are or aren't duplicates; being \"too specialized\"", "I don't claim to be an integral or representative user", "it seems to me that when I have been browsing", "on changing developments). If this observation is true, then it", "this? (Surely we can get data about numbers of questions", "Allow me to ponder on the future of Academia(.SE): I", "in fact real, is there anything we can or should", "may be hard to measure directly, but we could try", "could try to measure \"broad interest\" by counting question votes", "duplicates/very specialized) Or is there any data for or against", "asked here? (mostly duplicates/very specialized) Or is there any data", "questions that are or aren't duplicates; being \"too specialized\" may", "questions being asked here? (mostly duplicates/very specialized) Or is there", "the other sites (because there are a lot more possible", "but I've noticed I personally haven't been using Academia as", "when I have been browsing new questions here, most of", "I've noticed I personally haven't been using Academia as much", "usage (measured in some sense) of Academia will eventually peter", "measure directly, but we could try to measure \"broad interest\"", "are more focused on changing developments). If this observation is", "an issue on Academia than some of the other sites", "scaled by the growth of the site.) > > >" ]
[ "disrupts the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted 16k views and 19", "the SE philosophy is \"let them answer and downvote them\"?", "for Academia.SE), what else can we do to stop the", "Actually I believe there's three: tell her to stop, tell", "him. Yet, new answers keep flowing in. At this point,", "read what the other people have written. Given that the", "of the new answerers just want to chip in and", "radical that we can do to stop the flow of", "don't believe there is really 19 different things the OP", "is already protected, and we cannot close it because it", "written. Given that the question is already protected, and we", "most of the new answerers just want to chip in", "Given that the question is already protected, and we cannot", "different things the OP can do in this situation. Actually", "to class in revealing clothing, to the degree that it", "it because it is on-topic (and it's actually a good", "there a \"second level of protection\", or something more radical", "the flow of answers? Or maybe the SE philosophy is", "even read what the other people have written. Given that", "things the OP can do in this situation. Actually I", "or something more radical that we can do to stop", "teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted 16k views and 19 answers. I", "already protected, and we cannot close it because it is", "this point, I believe that most of the new answerers", "and tell the world their opinion but they haven't even", "because it is on-topic (and it's actually a good question", "(and it's actually a good question for Academia.SE), what else", "question is already protected, and we cannot close it because", "stop the flow of answers? Or maybe the SE philosophy", "At this point, I believe that most of the new", "the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted 16k views and 19 answers.", "on-topic (and it's actually a good question for Academia.SE), what", "and tell his higher-ups to take the matter off him.", "to stop the flow? Is there a \"second level of", "they haven't even read what the other people have written.", "to stop the flow of answers? Or maybe the SE", "\"second level of protection\", or something more radical that we", "protection\", or something more radical that we can do to", "in revealing clothing, to the degree that it disrupts the", "this situation. Actually I believe there's three: tell her to", "flowing in. At this point, I believe that most of", "else can we do to stop the flow? Is there", "can we do to stop the flow? Is there a", "I don't believe there is really 19 different things the", "maybe the SE philosophy is \"let them answer and downvote", "have written. Given that the question is already protected, and", "attracted 16k views and 19 answers. I don't believe there", "what the other people have written. Given that the question", "protected, and we cannot close it because it is on-topic", "what else can we do to stop the flow? Is", "that it disrupts the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted 16k views", "his higher-ups to take the matter off him. Yet, new", "flow? Is there a \"second level of protection\", or something", "to the degree that it disrupts the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has", "the question is already protected, and we cannot close it", "it is on-topic (and it's actually a good question for", "close it because it is on-topic (and it's actually a", "tell the world their opinion but they haven't even read", "clothing, to the degree that it disrupts the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t)", "[What to do with a student coming to class in", "the new answerers just want to chip in and tell", "tell the other students to control their hormones, and tell", "in and tell the world their opinion but they haven't", "new answerers just want to chip in and tell the", "situation. Actually I believe there's three: tell her to stop,", "can do in this situation. Actually I believe there's three:", "to chip in and tell the world their opinion but", "we do to stop the flow? Is there a \"second", "16k views and 19 answers. I don't believe there is", "noticed, the question [What to do with a student coming", "students to control their hormones, and tell his higher-ups to", "Yet, new answers keep flowing in. At this point, I", "their opinion but they haven't even read what the other", "question [What to do with a student coming to class", "stop, tell the other students to control their hormones, and", "class in revealing clothing, to the degree that it disrupts", "that most of the new answerers just want to chip", "19 different things the OP can do in this situation.", "revealing clothing, to the degree that it disrupts the teaching", "flow of answers? Or maybe the SE philosophy is \"let", "other people have written. Given that the question is already", "the degree that it disrupts the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted", "tell his higher-ups to take the matter off him. Yet,", "the OP can do in this situation. Actually I believe", "tell her to stop, tell the other students to control", "and 19 answers. I don't believe there is really 19", "a good question for Academia.SE), what else can we do", "level of protection\", or something more radical that we can", "to control their hormones, and tell his higher-ups to take", "question for Academia.SE), what else can we do to stop", "that the question is already protected, and we cannot close", "to stop, tell the other students to control their hormones,", "a \"second level of protection\", or something more radical that", "coming to class in revealing clothing, to the degree that", "off him. Yet, new answers keep flowing in. At this", "the flow? Is there a \"second level of protection\", or", "something more radical that we can do to stop the", "with a student coming to class in revealing clothing, to", "to take the matter off him. Yet, new answers keep", "believe that most of the new answerers just want to", "the matter off him. Yet, new answers keep flowing in.", "and we cannot close it because it is on-topic (and", "Is there a \"second level of protection\", or something more", "more radical that we can do to stop the flow", "of answers? Or maybe the SE philosophy is \"let them", "Or maybe the SE philosophy is \"let them answer and", "world their opinion but they haven't even read what the", "control their hormones, and tell his higher-ups to take the", "other students to control their hormones, and tell his higher-ups", "in this situation. Actually I believe there's three: tell her", "keep flowing in. At this point, I believe that most", "answers. I don't believe there is really 19 different things", "take the matter off him. Yet, new answers keep flowing", "of protection\", or something more radical that we can do", "chip in and tell the world their opinion but they", "that we can do to stop the flow of answers?", "there is really 19 different things the OP can do", "degree that it disrupts the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted 16k", "the other people have written. Given that the question is", "the world their opinion but they haven't even read what", "the other students to control their hormones, and tell his", "OP can do in this situation. Actually I believe there's", "19 answers. I don't believe there is really 19 different", "As you probably have noticed, the question [What to do", "in. At this point, I believe that most of the", "environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted 16k views and 19 answers. I don't", "I believe that most of the new answerers just want", "can do to stop the flow of answers? Or maybe", "is really 19 different things the OP can do in", "is on-topic (and it's actually a good question for Academia.SE),", "views and 19 answers. I don't believe there is really", "answerers just want to chip in and tell the world", "student coming to class in revealing clothing, to the degree", "do with a student coming to class in revealing clothing,", "you probably have noticed, the question [What to do with", "answers keep flowing in. At this point, I believe that", "a student coming to class in revealing clothing, to the", "hormones, and tell his higher-ups to take the matter off", "it's actually a good question for Academia.SE), what else can", "do to stop the flow? Is there a \"second level", "believe there is really 19 different things the OP can", "I believe there's three: tell her to stop, tell the", "Academia.SE), what else can we do to stop the flow?", "their hormones, and tell his higher-ups to take the matter", "actually a good question for Academia.SE), what else can we", "probably have noticed, the question [What to do with a", "it disrupts the teaching environment?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/83082/what-to-do-with-a-student-coming-to-class-in-revealing-clothing-to-the-degree-t) has attracted 16k views and", "stop the flow? Is there a \"second level of protection\",", "really 19 different things the OP can do in this", "higher-ups to take the matter off him. Yet, new answers", "cannot close it because it is on-topic (and it's actually", "there's three: tell her to stop, tell the other students", "her to stop, tell the other students to control their", "point, I believe that most of the new answerers just", "do in this situation. Actually I believe there's three: tell", "answers? Or maybe the SE philosophy is \"let them answer", "to do with a student coming to class in revealing", "opinion but they haven't even read what the other people", "haven't even read what the other people have written. Given", "we can do to stop the flow of answers? Or", "three: tell her to stop, tell the other students to", "matter off him. Yet, new answers keep flowing in. At", "we cannot close it because it is on-topic (and it's", "believe there's three: tell her to stop, tell the other", "has attracted 16k views and 19 answers. I don't believe", "just want to chip in and tell the world their", "the question [What to do with a student coming to", "want to chip in and tell the world their opinion", "have noticed, the question [What to do with a student", "new answers keep flowing in. At this point, I believe", "good question for Academia.SE), what else can we do to", "people have written. Given that the question is already protected,", "but they haven't even read what the other people have", "do to stop the flow of answers? Or maybe the" ]
[ "one of our current habit, which is to close \"technical\"", "a simulator without comparing it with the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes", "pool of clever and successful academics participating to this site", "\"technical\" questions as off-topic. While some are clear cuts, say", "changing one of our current habit, which is to close", "this site it would be great to leverage that knowledge.", "of answers. In a typical meta fashion, vote this question", "A few examples: [Creating a research questionnaire with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections)", "still get into grad school/something mildly entertaining happened in class\"", "off-topic. While some are clear cuts, say someone asking about", "be great to leverage that knowledge. Also, it would be", "to \"validate\" a simulator without comparing it with the actual", "wondering about the direction this site is taking, I wanted", "actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these questions are field-specific, but a lot", "successful academics participating to this site it would be great", "\"study-design\" tag. A few examples: [Creating a research questionnaire with", "that. with the pool of clever and successful academics participating", "leverage that knowledge. Also, it would be a refreshing change", "how do I still get into grad school/something mildly entertaining", "simulator without comparing it with the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these", "wanted to discuss the possibility of changing one of our", "questions as off-topic. While some are clear cuts, say someone", "now have a comprehensive set of answers. In a typical", "some are actually effectively about the academic process. One example", "is taking, I wanted to discuss the possibility of changing", "current habit, which is to close \"technical\" questions as off-topic.", "questions are field-specific, but a lot of the existing one", "example are questions pertaining to good practice when designing a", "meta fashion, vote this question up if you're in favor,", "some are clear cuts, say someone asking about the content", "mildly entertaining happened in class\" for which we now have", "habit, which is to close \"technical\" questions as off-topic. While", "benefit from a \"study-design\" tag. A few examples: [Creating a", "Following up [a recent meta post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3616/how-sustainable-is-academia-se) wondering about the direction", "about the content of an algorithm, some are actually effectively", "capable of dealing with that. with the pool of clever", "algorithm, some are actually effectively about the academic process. One", "to leverage that knowledge. Also, it would be a refreshing", "site it would be great to leverage that knowledge. Also,", "the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these questions are field-specific, but a", "not so great how do I still get into grad", "academic process. One example are questions pertaining to good practice", "we're capable of dealing with that. with the pool of", "close \"technical\" questions as off-topic. While some are clear cuts,", "We might then benefit from a \"study-design\" tag. A few", "and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it possible to \"validate\" a simulator", "process. One example are questions pertaining to good practice when", "happened in class\" for which we now have a comprehensive", "great how do I still get into grad school/something mildly", "the direction this site is taking, I wanted to discuss", "repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs are there between internal and external", "of an algorithm, some are actually effectively about the academic", "content of an algorithm, some are actually effectively about the", "of clever and successful academics participating to this site it", "GPA is not so great how do I still get", "is not so great how do I still get into", "are there between internal and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it possible", "of the existing one are as well. Apparently we're capable", "great to leverage that knowledge. Also, it would be a", "class\" for which we now have a comprehensive set of", "Also, it would be a refreshing change to all the", "are questions pertaining to good practice when designing a study.", "it possible to \"validate\" a simulator without comparing it with", "Yes these questions are field-specific, but a lot of the", "up [a recent meta post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3616/how-sustainable-is-academia-se) wondering about the direction this", "are field-specific, but a lot of the existing one are", "participating to this site it would be great to leverage", "do I still get into grad school/something mildly entertaining happened", "would be great to leverage that knowledge. Also, it would", "we now have a comprehensive set of answers. In a", "be a refreshing change to all the questions along the", "pertaining to good practice when designing a study. We might", "and successful academics participating to this site it would be", "in class\" for which we now have a comprehensive set", "to discuss the possibility of changing one of our current", "the possibility of changing one of our current habit, which", "One example are questions pertaining to good practice when designing", "with the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these questions are field-specific, but", "of dealing with that. with the pool of clever and", "knowledge. Also, it would be a refreshing change to all", "a refreshing change to all the questions along the line", "which is to close \"technical\" questions as off-topic. While some", "to all the questions along the line of \"someone stole", "question up if you're in favor, down if you're against.", "entertaining happened in class\" for which we now have a", "validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it possible to \"validate\" a simulator without comparing", "about the direction this site is taking, I wanted to", "well. Apparently we're capable of dealing with that. with the", "grad school/something mildly entertaining happened in class\" for which we", "comprehensive set of answers. In a typical meta fashion, vote", "are as well. Apparently we're capable of dealing with that.", "examples: [Creating a research questionnaire with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs", "about the academic process. One example are questions pertaining to", "but a lot of the existing one are as well.", "post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3616/how-sustainable-is-academia-se) wondering about the direction this site is taking, I", "internal and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it possible to \"validate\" a", "lot of the existing one are as well. Apparently we're", "it would be a refreshing change to all the questions", "from a \"study-design\" tag. A few examples: [Creating a research", "site is taking, I wanted to discuss the possibility of", "say someone asking about the content of an algorithm, some", "clever and successful academics participating to this site it would", "vote this question up if you're in favor, down if", "a lot of the existing one are as well. Apparently", "one are as well. Apparently we're capable of dealing with", "Apparently we're capable of dealing with that. with the pool", "there between internal and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it possible to", "the content of an algorithm, some are actually effectively about", "the existing one are as well. Apparently we're capable of", "it would be great to leverage that knowledge. Also, it", "that knowledge. Also, it would be a refreshing change to", "along the line of \"someone stole my work/my GPA is", "possibility of changing one of our current habit, which is", "While some are clear cuts, say someone asking about the", "someone asking about the content of an algorithm, some are", "with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs are there between internal and", "my work/my GPA is not so great how do I", "[a recent meta post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3616/how-sustainable-is-academia-se) wondering about the direction this site", "good practice when designing a study. We might then benefit", "\"someone stole my work/my GPA is not so great how", "a typical meta fashion, vote this question up if you're", "with that. with the pool of clever and successful academics", "which we now have a comprehensive set of answers. In", "existing one are as well. Apparently we're capable of dealing", "fashion, vote this question up if you're in favor, down", "meta post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3616/how-sustainable-is-academia-se) wondering about the direction this site is taking,", "of our current habit, which is to close \"technical\" questions", "stole my work/my GPA is not so great how do", "\"validate\" a simulator without comparing it with the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to)", "as well. Apparently we're capable of dealing with that. with", "questionnaire with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs are there between internal", "discuss the possibility of changing one of our current habit,", "is to close \"technical\" questions as off-topic. While some are", "line of \"someone stole my work/my GPA is not so", "set of answers. In a typical meta fashion, vote this", "these questions are field-specific, but a lot of the existing", "between internal and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it possible to \"validate\"", "the questions along the line of \"someone stole my work/my", "into grad school/something mildly entertaining happened in class\" for which", "an algorithm, some are actually effectively about the academic process.", "for which we now have a comprehensive set of answers.", "our current habit, which is to close \"technical\" questions as", "with the pool of clever and successful academics participating to", "asking about the content of an algorithm, some are actually", "[What tradeoffs are there between internal and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is", "then benefit from a \"study-design\" tag. A few examples: [Creating", "answers. In a typical meta fashion, vote this question up", "so great how do I still get into grad school/something", "[Is it possible to \"validate\" a simulator without comparing it", "dealing with that. with the pool of clever and successful", "In a typical meta fashion, vote this question up if", "the line of \"someone stole my work/my GPA is not", "study. We might then benefit from a \"study-design\" tag. A", "this site is taking, I wanted to discuss the possibility", "this question up if you're in favor, down if you're", "are clear cuts, say someone asking about the content of", "school/something mildly entertaining happened in class\" for which we now", "effectively about the academic process. One example are questions pertaining", "few examples: [Creating a research questionnaire with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What", "I wanted to discuss the possibility of changing one of", "a research questionnaire with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs are there", "possible to \"validate\" a simulator without comparing it with the", "I still get into grad school/something mildly entertaining happened in", "typical meta fashion, vote this question up if you're in", "practice when designing a study. We might then benefit from", "of changing one of our current habit, which is to", "a study. We might then benefit from a \"study-design\" tag.", "to good practice when designing a study. We might then", "a \"study-design\" tag. A few examples: [Creating a research questionnaire", "tag. A few examples: [Creating a research questionnaire with repeating", "work/my GPA is not so great how do I still", "tradeoffs are there between internal and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it", "research questionnaire with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs are there between", "it with the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these questions are field-specific,", "questions along the line of \"someone stole my work/my GPA", "clear cuts, say someone asking about the content of an", "recent meta post](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3616/how-sustainable-is-academia-se) wondering about the direction this site is", "get into grad school/something mildly entertaining happened in class\" for", "external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity) [Is it possible to \"validate\" a simulator without", "when designing a study. We might then benefit from a", "designing a study. We might then benefit from a \"study-design\"", "might then benefit from a \"study-design\" tag. A few examples:", "would be a refreshing change to all the questions along", "change to all the questions along the line of \"someone", "tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these questions are field-specific, but a lot of", "all the questions along the line of \"someone stole my", "have a comprehensive set of answers. In a typical meta", "comparing it with the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these questions are", "taking, I wanted to discuss the possibility of changing one", "actually effectively about the academic process. One example are questions", "as off-topic. While some are clear cuts, say someone asking", "academics participating to this site it would be great to", "field-specific, but a lot of the existing one are as", "cuts, say someone asking about the content of an algorithm,", "a comprehensive set of answers. In a typical meta fashion,", "[Creating a research questionnaire with repeating sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs are", "sections](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18675/creating-a-research-questionnaire-with-repeating-sections) [What tradeoffs are there between internal and external validity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59212/what-tradeoffs-are-there-between-internal-and-external-validity)", "direction this site is taking, I wanted to discuss the", "without comparing it with the actual tool?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/73432/is-it-possible-to-validate-a-simulator-without-comparing-it-with-the-actual-to) Yes these questions", "the academic process. One example are questions pertaining to good", "to close \"technical\" questions as off-topic. While some are clear", "are actually effectively about the academic process. One example are", "the pool of clever and successful academics participating to this", "of \"someone stole my work/my GPA is not so great", "to this site it would be great to leverage that", "refreshing change to all the questions along the line of", "questions pertaining to good practice when designing a study. We" ]
[ "post a question asking for articles or sites for research", "a question unless it fit into \"their mold\". So is", "regarding research in academia without being accused of \"shopping\"? To", "mold\". So is academia filled with pedagogues? No. Academia is", "research in academia without being accused of \"shopping\"? To my", "academia. To me it seems that academia has become a", "Dedicated to research, education, and scholarship. So it would seem", "seem to be a reasonable conclusion to post a question", "academia filled with pedagogues? No. Academia is filled with hypocritical", "How can someone ask a question regarding research in academia", "with education. Dedicated to research, education, and scholarship. So it", "thread for academia. To me it seems that academia has", "pedagogues? No. Academia is filled with hypocritical tyrants. End Rant.", "a question asking for articles or sites for research on", "being accused of \"shopping\"? To my knowledge, academia is a", "many topics with education. Dedicated to research, education, and scholarship.", "seems that academia has become a group of self righteous,", "self righteous, condescending, tyrants who refuse to help anyone who", "broad category that covers many topics with education. Dedicated to", "post on hold or close it. It will only prove", "No. Academia is filled with hypocritical tyrants. End Rant. Ban", "that academia has become a group of self righteous, condescending,", "righteous, condescending, tyrants who refuse to help anyone who has", "\"shopping\"? To my knowledge, academia is a broad category that", "of \"shopping\"? To my knowledge, academia is a broad category", "to help anyone who has a question unless it fit", "group of self righteous, condescending, tyrants who refuse to help", "articles or sites for research on a thread for academia.", "and scholarship. So it would seem to be a reasonable", "question unless it fit into \"their mold\". So is academia", "is academia filled with pedagogues? No. Academia is filled with", "asking for articles or sites for research on a thread", "help anyone who has a question unless it fit into", "me it seems that academia has become a group of", "a broad category that covers many topics with education. Dedicated", "a group of self righteous, condescending, tyrants who refuse to", "it seems that academia has become a group of self", "research on a thread for academia. To me it seems", "condescending, tyrants who refuse to help anyone who has a", "is filled with hypocritical tyrants. End Rant. Ban me if", "research, education, and scholarship. So it would seem to be", "academia is a broad category that covers many topics with", "to be a reasonable conclusion to post a question asking", "\"their mold\". So is academia filled with pedagogues? No. Academia", "into \"their mold\". So is academia filled with pedagogues? No.", "academia has become a group of self righteous, condescending, tyrants", "tyrants. End Rant. Ban me if necessary, put the post", "refuse to help anyone who has a question unless it", "education. Dedicated to research, education, and scholarship. So it would", "who has a question unless it fit into \"their mold\".", "would seem to be a reasonable conclusion to post a", "for research on a thread for academia. To me it", "has become a group of self righteous, condescending, tyrants who", "To my knowledge, academia is a broad category that covers", "question asking for articles or sites for research on a", "hold or close it. It will only prove my point", "become a group of self righteous, condescending, tyrants who refuse", "without being accused of \"shopping\"? To my knowledge, academia is", "on a thread for academia. To me it seems that", "for articles or sites for research on a thread for", "academia without being accused of \"shopping\"? To my knowledge, academia", "unless it fit into \"their mold\". So is academia filled", "covers many topics with education. Dedicated to research, education, and", "So is academia filled with pedagogues? No. Academia is filled", "for academia. To me it seems that academia has become", "put the post on hold or close it. It will", "or sites for research on a thread for academia. To", "with hypocritical tyrants. End Rant. Ban me if necessary, put", "accused of \"shopping\"? To my knowledge, academia is a broad", "knowledge, academia is a broad category that covers many topics", "sites for research on a thread for academia. To me", "To me it seems that academia has become a group", "my knowledge, academia is a broad category that covers many", "Academia is filled with hypocritical tyrants. End Rant. Ban me", "education, and scholarship. So it would seem to be a", "is a broad category that covers many topics with education.", "tyrants who refuse to help anyone who has a question", "Rant. Ban me if necessary, put the post on hold", "on hold or close it. It will only prove my", "category that covers many topics with education. Dedicated to research,", "reasonable conclusion to post a question asking for articles or", "me if necessary, put the post on hold or close", "filled with hypocritical tyrants. End Rant. Ban me if necessary,", "anyone who has a question unless it fit into \"their", "in academia without being accused of \"shopping\"? To my knowledge,", "a question regarding research in academia without being accused of", "it fit into \"their mold\". So is academia filled with", "or close it. It will only prove my point more.", "who refuse to help anyone who has a question unless", "it would seem to be a reasonable conclusion to post", "filled with pedagogues? No. Academia is filled with hypocritical tyrants.", "of self righteous, condescending, tyrants who refuse to help anyone", "to research, education, and scholarship. So it would seem to", "the post on hold or close it. It will only", "End Rant. Ban me if necessary, put the post on", "be a reasonable conclusion to post a question asking for", "can someone ask a question regarding research in academia without", "fit into \"their mold\". So is academia filled with pedagogues?", "ask a question regarding research in academia without being accused", "that covers many topics with education. Dedicated to research, education,", "a reasonable conclusion to post a question asking for articles", "to post a question asking for articles or sites for", "someone ask a question regarding research in academia without being", "necessary, put the post on hold or close it. It", "hypocritical tyrants. End Rant. Ban me if necessary, put the", "with pedagogues? No. Academia is filled with hypocritical tyrants. End", "a thread for academia. To me it seems that academia", "Ban me if necessary, put the post on hold or", "scholarship. So it would seem to be a reasonable conclusion", "So it would seem to be a reasonable conclusion to", "if necessary, put the post on hold or close it.", "conclusion to post a question asking for articles or sites", "question regarding research in academia without being accused of \"shopping\"?", "topics with education. Dedicated to research, education, and scholarship. So", "has a question unless it fit into \"their mold\". So" ]
[ "focus on not offending people? Sure, people should not go", "intense focus on not offending people? Sure, people should not", "on not offending people? Sure, people should not go about", "offending people, but someone will be offended by something somewhere,", "if we don't intend it. I have seen this occur", "go about intentionally offending people, but someone will be offended", "will be offended by something somewhere, someday, even if we", "people, but someone will be offended by something somewhere, someday,", "seems to put being non-offensive to anyone, above figuring out", "professors asking how to discipline their students, to people asking", "people should not go about intentionally offending people, but someone", "sexism. Everyone seems to put being non-offensive to anyone, above", "how to discipline their students, to people asking about addressing", "people? Sure, people should not go about intentionally offending people,", "to put being non-offensive to anyone, above figuring out how", "not offending people? Sure, people should not go about intentionally", "to know why there is intense focus on not offending", "there is intense focus on not offending people? Sure, people", "why there is intense focus on not offending people? Sure,", "would like to know why there is intense focus on", "even if we don't intend it. I have seen this", "about addressing potential cases of sexism. Everyone seems to put", "non-offensive to anyone, above figuring out how the original issue", "Sure, people should not go about intentionally offending people, but", "asking how to discipline their students, to people asking about", "people asking about addressing potential cases of sexism. Everyone seems", "Everyone seems to put being non-offensive to anyone, above figuring", "out how the original issue can be solved. [Example answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/83655/63231)", "not go about intentionally offending people, but someone will be", "seen this occur in everything from questions ranging from professors", "in everything from questions ranging from professors asking how to", "be offended by something somewhere, someday, even if we don't", "their students, to people asking about addressing potential cases of", "know why there is intense focus on not offending people?", "to anyone, above figuring out how the original issue can", "above figuring out how the original issue can be solved.", "don't intend it. I have seen this occur in everything", "I would like to know why there is intense focus", "potential cases of sexism. Everyone seems to put being non-offensive", "anyone, above figuring out how the original issue can be", "someday, even if we don't intend it. I have seen", "asking about addressing potential cases of sexism. Everyone seems to", "somewhere, someday, even if we don't intend it. I have", "have seen this occur in everything from questions ranging from", "discipline their students, to people asking about addressing potential cases", "something somewhere, someday, even if we don't intend it. I", "this occur in everything from questions ranging from professors asking", "offending people? Sure, people should not go about intentionally offending", "by something somewhere, someday, even if we don't intend it.", "intend it. I have seen this occur in everything from", "we don't intend it. I have seen this occur in", "ranging from professors asking how to discipline their students, to", "from professors asking how to discipline their students, to people", "to discipline their students, to people asking about addressing potential", "students, to people asking about addressing potential cases of sexism.", "put being non-offensive to anyone, above figuring out how the", "I have seen this occur in everything from questions ranging", "to people asking about addressing potential cases of sexism. Everyone", "but someone will be offended by something somewhere, someday, even", "figuring out how the original issue can be solved. [Example", "should not go about intentionally offending people, but someone will", "someone will be offended by something somewhere, someday, even if", "cases of sexism. Everyone seems to put being non-offensive to", "offended by something somewhere, someday, even if we don't intend", "it. I have seen this occur in everything from questions", "like to know why there is intense focus on not", "everything from questions ranging from professors asking how to discipline", "from questions ranging from professors asking how to discipline their", "about intentionally offending people, but someone will be offended by", "addressing potential cases of sexism. Everyone seems to put being", "of sexism. Everyone seems to put being non-offensive to anyone,", "questions ranging from professors asking how to discipline their students,", "intentionally offending people, but someone will be offended by something", "being non-offensive to anyone, above figuring out how the original", "occur in everything from questions ranging from professors asking how", "is intense focus on not offending people? Sure, people should" ]
[ "none of them fit. I thought that maybe the bump", "the software? Was it a person? Why was it bumped?", "by the software? Was it a person? Why was it", "and none of them fit. I thought that maybe the", "[outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons for bumping, and none of them fit.", "I read a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons for bumping, and", "it bumped? It makes no sense to me. I read", "an edit, but the question doesn't seem to have been", "of reasons for bumping, and none of them fit. I", "edit, but the question doesn't seem to have been edited.", "a person? Why was it bumped? It makes no sense", "Was it a person? Why was it bumped? It makes", "maybe the bump had resulted from an edit, but the", "done automatically by the software? Was it a person? Why", "person? Why was it bumped? It makes no sense to", "them fit. I thought that maybe the bump had resulted", "was it bumped? It makes no sense to me. I", "Community. Was this done automatically by the software? Was it", "It makes no sense to me. I read a Meta", "sense to me. I read a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons", "to the homepage by Community. Was this done automatically by", "to me. I read a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons for", "bumped to the homepage by Community. Was this done automatically", "a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons for bumping, and none of", "software? Was it a person? Why was it bumped? It", "from an edit, but the question doesn't seem to have", "this done automatically by the software? Was it a person?", "Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons for bumping, and none of them", "fit. I thought that maybe the bump had resulted from", "I thought that maybe the bump had resulted from an", "had resulted from an edit, but the question doesn't seem", "was bumped to the homepage by Community. Was this done", "that maybe the bump had resulted from an edit, but", "no sense to me. I read a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of", "automatically by the software? Was it a person? Why was", "makes no sense to me. I read a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436)", "Was this done automatically by the software? Was it a", "homepage by Community. Was this done automatically by the software?", "of them fit. I thought that maybe the bump had", "Why was it bumped? It makes no sense to me.", "bumped? It makes no sense to me. I read a", "bumping, and none of them fit. I thought that maybe", "bump had resulted from an edit, but the question doesn't", "reasons for bumping, and none of them fit. I thought", "resulted from an edit, but the question doesn't seem to", "for bumping, and none of them fit. I thought that", "the bump had resulted from an edit, but the question", "me. I read a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons for bumping,", "thought that maybe the bump had resulted from an edit,", "it a person? Why was it bumped? It makes no", "the homepage by Community. Was this done automatically by the", "old [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/77464/32436) was bumped to the homepage by Community. Was", "by Community. Was this done automatically by the software? Was", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/77464/32436) was bumped to the homepage by Community. Was this", "particular old [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/77464/32436) was bumped to the homepage by Community.", "A particular old [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/77464/32436) was bumped to the homepage by", "read a Meta [outline](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1272/32436) of reasons for bumping, and none" ]
[ "Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to", "must be 300 x 250 pixels, or double that if", "a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is", "Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will", "community. We reset the ads once a year, every December.", "ad is very valuable to the community and will continue", "else to the body of the post. If you want", "### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold** an", "This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to", "It is a bit late into this new year, being", "2017! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads", "should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to", "with the above required form. ### Image requirements * The", "site's twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting", "every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that", "it is a good idea to repost it. It may", "it. It may be helpful to give it a new", "'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the", "is a good idea to repost it. It may be", "1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score", "information and resources that are relevant to your own community's", "cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps", "we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain", "year, being that we're already in the second month, but", "accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their", "exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post", "Must be GIF or PNG No animated GIFs ", "and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests,", "year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while", "imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year", "can check out the ads that have met the threshold", "In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this", "ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the", "Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) ", "* anything else your community would genuinely be interested in", "### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some", "this question must conform to the following rules, or they", "before it will be shown on the main site. You", "site. For example, you might promote the following things: ", "relevant to not just the subject matter of the community,", "be shown on the main site. You can check out", "Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community", "the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old", "post to this question must* conform to the following rules,", "of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable", "once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have", "you might promote the following things: * the site's twitter", "are now cycling the Community Promotion Ads for 2017! ###", "blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else your", "would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future", "year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions", "the answer form with the above required form. ### Image", "and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown.", "every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against", "cool events or conferences * anything else your community would", "this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements", "* interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences", "the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources ", "vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community", "find out about the stuff your community deems important. This", "to your own community's interests, both for those already in", "functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer", "the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All", "be 300 x 250 pixels, or double that if high", "score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it", "show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do", "Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the", "the image is white or partially white, there must be", "not add anything else to the body of the post*.", "things: the site's twitter account * academic websites and", "border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold", "* If the background of the image is white or", "give it a new face in the process, so as", "they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in", "restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If", "to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the", "this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose", "form. ### Image requirements * The image that you create", "serves as a way to promote information and resources that", "that you create must be 300 x 250 pixels, or", "uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No", "resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both", "previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very", "years, while other things will wane to allow for new", "be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show", "for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors", "of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you", "There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet", "to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The", "or double that if high DPI. * Must be hosted", "year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers", "community, but to the current status of the community. We", "purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer", "must be a 1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding", "the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition", "(currently 6) before it will be shown on the main", "example, you might promote the following things: * the site's", "to not just the subject matter of the community, but", "to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also", "important. This also serves as a way to promote information", "rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should", "over the years, while other things will wane to allow", "answers you post to this question must* conform to the", "check out the ads that have met the threshold with", "this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above", "This also serves as a way to promote information and", "(2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There", "do it in the comments. 2. The question must always", "must conform to the following rules, or they will be", "ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a", "might promote the following things: * the site's twitter account", "so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from", "be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\")", "answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown", "a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6)", "December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting", "the community and those yet to join. ### Why do", "and will continue to be so, it is a good", "This is a method for the community to control what", "it a new face in the process, so as to", "other things will wane to allow for new faces to", "but to the current status of the community. We reset", "required form. ### Image requirements * The image that you", "your own community's interests, both for those already in the", "white or partially white, there must be a 1px border", "their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for", "in the community and those yet to join. ### Why", "ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in", "What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted", "promote information and resources that are relevant to your own", "that have met the threshold with basic click stats [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/ads/display/3661).", "the background of the image is white or partially white,", "limit on file size of 150 KB * If the", "against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a", "a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no", "served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads", "advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community", "[![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ```", "of the community. We reset the ads once a year,", "gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you", "Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows", "is for future visitors to find out about the stuff", "ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form", "keep the material in the ads relevant to not just", "events or conferences anything else your community would genuinely", "shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This", "will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do", "it. ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold", "while other things will wane to allow for new faces", "If a particular service or ad is very valuable to", "helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served", "to promote information and resources that are relevant to your", "tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of", "questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality", "show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this,", " academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs", "always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged", "If the background of the image is white or partially", "of this question is the vetting process. Images of the", "matter of the community, but to the current status of", "interested in The goal is for future visitors to find", "as a way to promote information and resources that are", "to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion", "a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The", "future visitors to find out about the stuff your community", "or partially white, there must be a 1px border (2px", "or conferences anything else your community would genuinely be", "conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored.", "out about the stuff your community deems important. This also", "image that you create must be 300 x 250 pixels,", "to be so, it is a good idea to repost", "The image that you create must be 300 x 250", "that if high DPI. * Must be hosted through our", "The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images", "### How does it work? The answers you post to", "the ads that have met the threshold with basic click", "else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal", "be a 1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it.", "with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In", "just the subject matter of the community, but to the", "be helpful to give it a new face in the", "the post. If you want to discuss something, do it", "the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure.", "must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions", "an answer must meet (currently 6*) before it will be", "visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the", "cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable", "the community. We reset the ads once a year, every", "do we reset the ads every year? Some services will", "community deems important. This also serves as a way to", "face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery", "late into this new year, being that we're already in", "for newer things. This helps keep the material in the", "high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is a", "### Image requirements * The image that you create must", "white, there must be a 1px border (2px if high", "tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements,", "shown on the main site. You can check out the", "own community's interests, both for those already in the community", "to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every", "for 2017! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion", "Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that", "2. The question must always be tagged with the magic", "300 x 250 pixels, or double that if high DPI.", " cool events or conferences * anything else your community", "* Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur)", "mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add", "through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF", "http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else", "to give it a new face in the process, so", "also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form.", "will continue to be so, it is a good idea", "anything else to the body of the post. If you", "*do not add anything else to the body of the", "wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting", "already in the second month, but we are now cycling", "be interested in The goal is for future visitors to", "magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to", "or ad is very valuable to the community and will", "Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will", "services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things", "month, but we are now cycling the Community Promotion Ads", "tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag.", "to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please", "join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year?", "form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url", "if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is", "that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for", "are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main", "[community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling", "be GIF or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute", "be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact", "background of the image is white or partially white, there", "Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on", "cycling the Community Promotion Ads for 2017! ### What are", "will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the", "community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for", "out the ads that have met the threshold with basic", "way to promote information and resources that are relevant to", "the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and", "maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane", "to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate", "helpful to give it a new face in the process,", "is white or partially white, there must be a 1px", "repost it. It may be helpful to give it a", "a new face in the process, so as to prevent", "what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example,", "reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness", "and resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events", "form with the above required form. ### Image requirements ", "second month, but we are now cycling the Community Promotion", "or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on", "interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences ", "is very valuable to the community and will continue to", "answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline", "Community Promotion Ads for 2017! ### What are Community Promotion", "[1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything", "the body of the post. If you want to discuss", "on file size of 150 KB If the background", "file size of 150 KB * If the background of", "the subject matter of the community, but to the current", "discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question", "websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs * cool", "goal is for future visitors to find out about the", "it will be shown on the main site. You can", "also serves as a way to promote information and resources", "the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on", "the current status of the community. We reset the ads", "partially white, there must be a 1px border (2px if", "advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the", "process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting", "post. If you want to discuss something, do it in", "of the post. If you want to discuss something, do", "to the current status of the community. We reset the", "resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events or", "and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset", "Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services", "We reset the ads once a year, every December. The", "above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that", "your community deems important. This also serves as a way", "yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads", "the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the", "body of the post. If you want to discuss something,", "you post to this question must* conform to the following", "be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads?", "must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on", "an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service", "exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]:", "* the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources", "our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or", "the community and will continue to be so, it is", "add anything else to the body of the post. If", "will be shown on the main site. You can check", "advertisements that will show up on the main site, in", "sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process.", "main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this", "control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For", "you want to discuss something, do it in the comments.", "out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep", "the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with", "community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site,", "want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2.", "being that we're already in the second month, but we", "community and those yet to join. ### Why do we", "Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other", "the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the", "not just the subject matter of the community, but to", "will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will", "on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not", "question must conform to the following rules, or they will", "* The image that you create must be 300 x", "site. You can check out the ads that have met", "For example, you might promote the following things: * the", "of 150 KB * If the background of the image", "from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How", "a way to promote information and resources that are relevant", "method for the community to control what gets promoted to", "GIF or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit", "for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every", "### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is", "campus story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything", "image is white or partially white, there must be a", "reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular", "community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ###", "of the ad from getting stale after a year of", "process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad", "``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url", "stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it", "valuable to the community and will continue to be so,", "continue to be so, it is a good idea to", "the following things: * the site's twitter account * academic", "How does it work? The answers you post to this", "story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else", "150 KB * If the background of the image is", "advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements", "in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on", "[2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add anything else to", "DPI. Must be hosted through our standard image uploader", "but we are now cycling the Community Promotion Ads for", "community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the", "the Community Promotion Ads for 2017! ### What are Community", "All answers should be in the exact form of: ```", "is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently", "Please *do not add anything else to the body of", "up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and", "Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB If", "standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG", "good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to", "promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might", "account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus story", "ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the", "a bit late into this new year, being that we're", "have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the", "the community, but to the current status of the community.", "a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful", "is a method for the community to control what gets", "It may be helpful to give it a new face", "that will show up on the main site, in the", "Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer must", "enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we", "enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills", "of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form", "in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter", "promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from", "high DPI. * Must be hosted through our standard image", "You can check out the ads that have met the", "a method for the community to control what gets promoted", "bit late into this new year, being that we're already", "be so, it is a good idea to repost it.", "If you want to discuss something, do it in the", "addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag", "conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be interested", "do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method", "after a year of exposure. ### How does it work?", "promote the following things: * the site's twitter account ", "of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]:", "deems important. This also serves as a way to promote", "the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of", "of the image is white or partially white, there must", "Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up", "a particular service or ad is very valuable to the", "Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer", "surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is a *minimum score", "it work? The answers you post to this question must", "something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must", "may be helpful to give it a new face in", "ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads", "allows old ads that have served their purpose to be", "prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after", "answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements", "http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else to the", "newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads", "community's interests, both for those already in the community and", "pixels, or double that if high DPI. * Must be", "status of the community. We reset the ads once a", "comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the", "the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the", "relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already", "\"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the", "question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are", "ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or", "visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems", "that have served their purpose to be cycled out for", "does it work? The answers you post to this question", "every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years,", "year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have", "The answers you post to this question must* conform to", "GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB", "those already in the community and those yet to join.", "particular service or ad is very valuable to the community", "things will wane to allow for new faces to show", "the second month, but we are now cycling the Community", "PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file", "the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a", "getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does", "threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will", "we are now cycling the Community Promotion Ads for 2017!", "Ads? This is a method for the community to control", "ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads", "### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are", "6*) before it will be shown on the main site.", "allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads", "requirements The image that you create must be 300", "you create must be 300 x 250 pixels, or double", "on the main site. You can check out the ads", "new year, being that we're already in the second month,", "the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of", "those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the", "for future visitors to find out about the stuff your", "and allows old ads that have served their purpose to", "to repost it. It may be helpful to give it", "Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a", "subject matter of the community, but to the current status", "will show up on the main site, in the right", "there must be a 1px border (2px if high DPI)", "ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out", "meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the", "question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show", "on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose", " Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ", "the material in the ads relevant to not just the", " Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs", "about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves", "for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the", "the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2]", "old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled", "``` Please *do not add anything else to the body", "create must be 300 x 250 pixels, or double that", "ads that have met the threshold with basic click stats", "be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must", "have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher", "to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote", "ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ###", "The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads", "the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with", "the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion", "your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is", "(imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No animated", "right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting", "the site. For example, you might promote the following things:", "are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those", "now cycling the Community Promotion Ads for 2017! ### What", "faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps", "in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged", "the years, while other things will wane to allow for", "hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be", "have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous", "into this new year, being that we're already in the", "material in the ads relevant to not just the subject", "is a bit late into this new year, being that", "to the body of the post. If you want to", "to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things.", "fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material", "new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year", "both for those already in the community and those yet", "or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be", "we're already in the second month, but we are now", "up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The", "that we're already in the second month, but we are", "in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is", "for those already in the community and those yet to", "the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over", "DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is a minimum", "voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why", "provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be", "Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show", "community and will continue to be so, it is a", "to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1.", "The goal is for future visitors to find out about", "size of 150 KB * If the background of the", "in the second month, but we are now cycling the", "the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the", "in The goal is for future visitors to find out", "site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question", "tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required", "following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers", "Image requirements * The image that you create must be", "show up on the main site, in the right sidebar.", "we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for", "double that if high DPI. * Must be hosted through", "will wane to allow for new faces to show up.", "academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs ", "Ads for 2017! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community", "on the site. For example, you might promote the following", "to find out about the stuff your community deems important.", "reset the ads once a year, every December. The community", "as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting", "1. All answers should be in the exact form of:", "250 pixels, or double that if high DPI. Must", "interests, both for those already in the community and those", "The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an", "genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors", "already in the community and those yet to join. ###", "new face in the process, so as to prevent the", "idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give", "to the community and will continue to be so, it", "the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have", "things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant", "image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF or PNG ", "from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad", "Promotion Ads for 2017! ### What are Community Promotion Ads?", "this new year, being that we're already in the second", "helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not", "is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided,", "very valuable to the community and will continue to be", "purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of", "the main site. You can check out the ads that", "anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The", "are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to", "current status of the community. We reset the ads once", "to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site.", "of the community, but to the current status of the", "usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to", "minimum score threshold* an answer must meet (currently 6) before", "work? The answers you post to this question must conform", "to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale", "KB * If the background of the image is white", "in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of", "no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle.", "twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus", "following things: * the site's twitter account * academic websites", "service or ad is very valuable to the community and", "No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of", "community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad", "* No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size", "stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a", "the above required form. ### Image requirements The image", "x 250 pixels, or double that if high DPI. ", "pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ###", "the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as", "are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements", "if high DPI. Must be hosted through our standard", "be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This", "it in the comments. 2. The question must always be", "a 1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ###", "so, it is a good idea to repost it. It", "animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150", "to this question must conform to the following rules, or", "main site. You can check out the ads that have" ]
[ "people\". My guess is that the question has been locked", "-6 total). I imagine that the downvotes are partly due", "downvotes are not exactly on the list…). As a locked", "[\"How to deal with instructor forcing me to do an", "I imagine that the downvotes are partly due to the", "question has been locked because of the heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229)", "a of mirrored question to [How to deal with uninterested", "locked question, there can't be up- and downvotes on the", "the question should have been better received and would like", "guess is that the question has been locked because of", "have some guess, probably would have done the same, but", "good as flagging? * Why was this question locked? (I", "a locked question, there can't be up- and downvotes on", "I find the question reasonable and also upvote it. I", "forcing me to do an uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been", "deal with instructor forcing me to do an uninteresting optional", "(tone down a little), comment that I find the question", "be made. I have the feeling, that the question should", "made. I have the feeling, that the question should have", "* Is asking on meta equally good as flagging? ", "However, the first question was has received several downvotes and", "the feeling, that the question should have been better received", "some guess, probably would have done the same, but I", "the first question was has received several downvotes and also", "same, but I am curious.) How to proceed with", "on meta equally good as flagging? * Why was this", "and also upvote it. I could have flagged for moderator", "is that the question has been locked because of the", "both questions are a good and especially, both have great", "question locked? (I have some guess, probably would have done", "question reasonable and also upvote it. I could have flagged", "probably would have done the same, but I am curious.)", "downvotes on the question and also no edits or comments", "posts should be locked (heavy downvotes are not exactly on", "think that both questions are a good and especially, both", "this question locked? (I have some guess, probably would have", "equally good as flagging? * Why was this question locked?", "question to [How to deal with uninterested students during an", "(I have some guess, probably would have done the same,", "an optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I think that both questions", "optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I think that both questions are", "list…). As a locked question, there can't be up- and", "would like to edit it (tone down a little), comment", "exactly on the list…). As a locked question, there can't", "first question was has received several downvotes and also quite", "why posts should be locked (heavy downvotes are not exactly", "meta equally good as flagging? * Why was this question", "at -6 total). I imagine that the downvotes are partly", "(heavy downvotes are not exactly on the list…). As a", "I could learn more if I asked on meta. Specifically:", "especially, both have great answers. However, the first question was", "reasons why posts should be locked (heavy downvotes are not", "it (tone down a little), comment that I find the", "locked (heavy downvotes are not exactly on the list…). As", "offensive phrasing \"some internet people\". My guess is that the", "both have great answers. However, the first question was has", "has received several downvotes and also quite a few upvotes", "with instructor forcing me to do an uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise)", "down a little), comment that I find the question reasonable", "I think that both questions are a good and especially,", "are partly due to the somehow offensive phrasing \"some internet", "attention, but thought, I could learn more if I asked", "(currently being at -6 total). I imagine that the downvotes", "the somehow offensive phrasing \"some internet people\". My guess is", "[How to deal with uninterested students during an optional exercise", "learn more if I asked on meta. Specifically: * Is", "somehow offensive phrasing \"some internet people\". My guess is that", "exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been locked recently. The question is kind a", "has been locked because of the heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you", "I have the feeling, that the question should have been", "internet people\". My guess is that the question has been", "questions are a good and especially, both have great answers.", "and especially, both have great answers. However, the first question", "a good and especially, both have great answers. However, the", "edit it (tone down a little), comment that I find", "the question reasonable and also upvote it. I could have", "question [\"How to deal with instructor forcing me to do", "also quite a few upvotes (currently being at -6 total).", "and I think that both questions are a good and", "due to the somehow offensive phrasing \"some internet people\". My", "the question has been locked because of the heavy downvotes;", "heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find some reasons why posts should", "downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find some reasons why posts should be", "kind a of mirrored question to [How to deal with", "you find some reasons why posts should be locked (heavy", "thought, I could learn more if I asked on meta.", "asking on meta equally good as flagging? * Why was", "[here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find some reasons why posts should be locked", "no edits or comments can be made. I have the", "I could have flagged for moderator attention, but thought, I", "good and especially, both have great answers. However, the first", "total). I imagine that the downvotes are partly due to", "done the same, but I am curious.) * How to", "during an optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I think that both", "great answers. However, the first question was has received several", "to do an uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been locked recently.", "several downvotes and also quite a few upvotes (currently being", "been locked because of the heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find", "instructor forcing me to do an uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has", "have great answers. However, the first question was has received", "to [How to deal with uninterested students during an optional", "been better received and would like to edit it (tone", "recently. The question is kind a of mirrored question to", "\"some internet people\". My guess is that the question has", "that the question has been locked because of the heavy", "As a locked question, there can't be up- and downvotes", "that both questions are a good and especially, both have", "on the question and also no edits or comments can", "me to do an uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been locked", "comments can be made. I have the feeling, that the", "optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been locked recently. The question is kind", "should have been better received and would like to edit", "to edit it (tone down a little), comment that I", "locked? (I have some guess, probably would have done the", "to deal with instructor forcing me to do an uninteresting", "question is kind a of mirrored question to [How to", "guess, probably would have done the same, but I am", "could have flagged for moderator attention, but thought, I could", "like to edit it (tone down a little), comment that", "better received and would like to edit it (tone down", "with uninterested students during an optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I", "the same, but I am curious.) * How to proceed", "downvotes are partly due to the somehow offensive phrasing \"some", "of the heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find some reasons why", "are not exactly on the list…). As a locked question,", "be up- and downvotes on the question and also no", "but thought, I could learn more if I asked on", "The question [\"How to deal with instructor forcing me to", "reasonable and also upvote it. I could have flagged for", "a little), comment that I find the question reasonable and", "on meta. Specifically: * Is asking on meta equally good", "feeling, that the question should have been better received and", "and also no edits or comments can be made. I", "find some reasons why posts should be locked (heavy downvotes", "that the downvotes are partly due to the somehow offensive", "find the question reasonable and also upvote it. I could", "uninterested students during an optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I think", "session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I think that both questions are a good", "upvote it. I could have flagged for moderator attention, but", "locked recently. The question is kind a of mirrored question", "deal with uninterested students during an optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and", "Why was this question locked? (I have some guess, probably", "could learn more if I asked on meta. Specifically: ", "question was has received several downvotes and also quite a", "and downvotes on the question and also no edits or", "locked because of the heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find some", "asked on meta. Specifically: Is asking on meta equally", "My guess is that the question has been locked because", "I asked on meta. Specifically: * Is asking on meta", "I am curious.) * How to proceed with the question?", "quite a few upvotes (currently being at -6 total). I", "are a good and especially, both have great answers. However,", "was has received several downvotes and also quite a few", "a few upvotes (currently being at -6 total). I imagine", "received several downvotes and also quite a few upvotes (currently", "should be locked (heavy downvotes are not exactly on the", "have flagged for moderator attention, but thought, I could learn", "the list…). As a locked question, there can't be up-", "it. I could have flagged for moderator attention, but thought,", "being at -6 total). I imagine that the downvotes are", "comment that I find the question reasonable and also upvote", "been locked recently. The question is kind a of mirrored", "there can't be up- and downvotes on the question and", "the question and also no edits or comments can be", "or comments can be made. I have the feeling, that", "have done the same, but I am curious.) * How", "little), comment that I find the question reasonable and also", "of mirrored question to [How to deal with uninterested students", "an uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been locked recently. The question", "mirrored question to [How to deal with uninterested students during", "imagine that the downvotes are partly due to the somehow", "downvotes and also quite a few upvotes (currently being at", "flagged for moderator attention, but thought, I could learn more", "if I asked on meta. Specifically: * Is asking on", "also upvote it. I could have flagged for moderator attention,", "and also quite a few upvotes (currently being at -6", "question and also no edits or comments can be made.", "* Why was this question locked? (I have some guess,", "have been better received and would like to edit it", "uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been locked recently. The question is", "also no edits or comments can be made. I have", "that I find the question reasonable and also upvote it.", "phrasing \"some internet people\". My guess is that the question", "the heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find some reasons why posts", "to the somehow offensive phrasing \"some internet people\". My guess", "that the question should have been better received and would", "Specifically: * Is asking on meta equally good as flagging?", "on the list…). As a locked question, there can't be", "The question is kind a of mirrored question to [How", "is kind a of mirrored question to [How to deal", "partly due to the somehow offensive phrasing \"some internet people\".", "have the feeling, that the question should have been better", "was this question locked? (I have some guess, probably would", "would have done the same, but I am curious.) ", "the downvotes are partly due to the somehow offensive phrasing", "answers. However, the first question was has received several downvotes", "question, there can't be up- and downvotes on the question", "students during an optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I think that", "some reasons why posts should be locked (heavy downvotes are", "more if I asked on meta. Specifically: Is asking", "and would like to edit it (tone down a little),", "has been locked recently. The question is kind a of", "exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session) and I think that both questions are a", "few upvotes (currently being at -6 total). I imagine that", "flagging? * Why was this question locked? (I have some", "for moderator attention, but thought, I could learn more if", "upvotes (currently being at -6 total). I imagine that the", "be locked (heavy downvotes are not exactly on the list…).", "not exactly on the list…). As a locked question, there", "question should have been better received and would like to", "to deal with uninterested students during an optional exercise session?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84388/how-to-deal-with-uninterested-students-during-an-optional-exercise-session)", "moderator attention, but thought, I could learn more if I", "edits or comments can be made. I have the feeling,", "as flagging? * Why was this question locked? (I have", "but I am curious.) * How to proceed with the", "received and would like to edit it (tone down a", "can be made. I have the feeling, that the question", "meta. Specifically: * Is asking on meta equally good as", "up- and downvotes on the question and also no edits", "because of the heavy downvotes; [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/22229) you find some reasons", "do an uninteresting optional exercise?\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/84437/how-to-deal-with-instructor-forcing-me-to-do-an-uninteresting-optional-exercise) has been locked recently. The", "Is asking on meta equally good as flagging? * Why", "can't be up- and downvotes on the question and also" ]
[ "to do with academia. * Language issues may come into", "academia. * Language issues may come into play. Perhaps the", "play. Perhaps the asker is not writing in their native", "are anxious about their language skills, etc. They may be", "answer that's applicable in the US may not work at", "and is unsure whether they are clearly expressing themselves, or", "the same as everyone else. (To which we have JeffE's", "have anything to do with academia. * Language issues may", "distinction doesn't really have anything to do with academia. ", "generally communicate just the same as everyone else. (To which", "factors may come into play. Etiquette, polite wording, etc, vary", "the asker is not writing in their native language and", "appropriate. Again, this might not really have anything to do", " [How do I politely ask a professor to contact", "to someone, but are just not sure how to say", "etc. They may be looking for reassurance rather than help", "all in Japan, for instance; but maybe that distinction doesn't", "much more between cultures than inside/outside academia. An answer that's", "JeffE's classic response: \"Pretend as though he were human\".) ", "to contact another professor he knows to accept me as", "- perhaps they are intimidated by the idea of talking", "[How do I politely ask a professor to contact another", "response: \"Pretend as though he were human\".) Cultural factors", "though he were human\".) * Cultural factors may come into", "for instance; but maybe that distinction doesn't really have anything", "* Language issues may come into play. Perhaps the asker", "\"Pretend as though he were human\".) * Cultural factors may", "something to a professor. * [What sentence is suitable for", "issues may come into play. Perhaps the asker is not", "for thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) * [How do I politely ask", "but maybe that distinction doesn't really have anything to do", "of living for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) * [How do I turn", "the idea of talking to a professor, or have bad", "in Japan, for instance; but maybe that distinction doesn't really", "reaction, or are anxious about their language skills, etc. They", "to follow, and seem to be unaware that academics generally", "their native language and is unsure whether they are clearly", "can we offer for asking, answering, or moderating such questions?*", "who want to communicate something to someone, but are just", "about the reaction, or are anxious about their language skills,", "an internship offer by a professor because I have a", "their wording is appropriate. Again, this might not really have", "[How do I explain to a prof who is not", "he were human\".) Cultural factors may come into play.", "not happy with my actions which were simply a mistake", "I politely ask a professor to contact another professor he", "mistake due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What advice can we offer for", "gets quite a few questions from people in academia who", "not work at all in Japan, for instance; but maybe", "to accept me as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) [How to tell", "vary much more between cultures than inside/outside academia. An answer", "by the idea of talking to a professor, or have", "turn down an internship offer by a professor because I", "moderating such questions?** A few potential issues: * In many", "is appropriate. Again, this might not really have anything to", "sentence is suitable for thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) * [How do", "with academia. * Language issues may come into play. Perhaps", "communicate just the same as everyone else. (To which we", "accept me as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) * [How to tell a", "knows to accept me as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) * [How to", "or are anxious about their language skills, etc. They may", "Again, this might not really have anything to do with", "Language issues may come into play. Perhaps the asker is", "contact another professor he knows to accept me as PhD", "I explain to a prof who is not happy with", "to academia seem to think there are magic protocols to", "professor at a foreign university politely and impressively that I", "many cases the asker is simply nervous - perhaps they", "lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) * [How do I explain to a prof who", "just not sure how to say it. Often this is", "sensitive request and are worried about the reaction, or are", "politely ask a professor to contact another professor he knows", "may be looking for reassurance rather than help with wording.", "have JeffE's classic response: \"Pretend as though he were human\".)", "inside/outside academia. An answer that's applicable in the US may", "questions from people in academia who want to communicate something", "were human\".) * Cultural factors may come into play. Etiquette,", "quite a few questions from people in academia who want", "explain to a prof who is not happy with my", "or have bad news or a sensitive request and are", "in their native language and is unsure whether they are", "to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What advice can we offer for asking, answering,", "[What sentence is suitable for thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) [How", "Often this is a student trying to tell something to", "is suitable for thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) * [How do I", "me as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) * [How to tell a professor", "politely and impressively that I can’t cover the costs of", "intimidated by the idea of talking to a professor, or", "into play. Etiquette, polite wording, etc, vary much more between", "asking, answering, or moderating such questions?** A few potential issues:", "follow, and seem to be unaware that academics generally communicate", "are intimidated by the idea of talking to a professor,", "in academia who want to communicate something to someone, but", "this is a student trying to tell something to a", "a better offer in a corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) * [How", "issues: * In many cases the asker is simply nervous", "are just not sure how to say it. Often this", "which we have JeffE's classic response: \"Pretend as though he", "about their language skills, etc. They may be looking for", "than help with wording. * Sometimes newcomers to academia seem", "something to someone, but are just not sure how to", "a professor because I have a better offer in a", "classic response: \"Pretend as though he were human\".) * Cultural", "the reaction, or are anxious about their language skills, etc.", "do I turn down an internship offer by a professor", "at a foreign university politely and impressively that I can’t", "by a professor because I have a better offer in", "everyone else. (To which we have JeffE's classic response: \"Pretend", "academia. An answer that's applicable in the US may not", "internship offer by a professor because I have a better", "impressively that I can’t cover the costs of living for", "questions?** A few potential issues: * In many cases the", "really have anything to do with academia. * Language issues", "come into play. Perhaps the asker is not writing in", "that I can’t cover the costs of living for my", "costs of living for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) * [How do I", "US may not work at all in Japan, for instance;", "at all in Japan, for instance; but maybe that distinction", "clearly expressing themselves, or whether the tone of their wording", "are clearly expressing themselves, or whether the tone of their", "tell something to a professor. * [What sentence is suitable", "to think there are magic protocols to follow, and seem", "who is not happy with my actions which were simply", "simply a mistake due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What advice can we", "and seem to be unaware that academics generally communicate just", "do with academia. Language issues may come into play.", "may come into play. Etiquette, polite wording, etc, vary much", "professor. * [What sentence is suitable for thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor)", "An answer that's applicable in the US may not work", "can’t cover the costs of living for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) ", "the asker is simply nervous - perhaps they are intimidated", "in a corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) [How do I explain", "are magic protocols to follow, and seem to be unaware", "actions which were simply a mistake due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What", "else. (To which we have JeffE's classic response: \"Pretend as", "Academia gets quite a few questions from people in academia", "academia seem to think there are magic protocols to follow,", "language and is unsure whether they are clearly expressing themselves,", "from people in academia who want to communicate something to", "professor because I have a better offer in a corporate", "PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) [How do I turn down an internship offer", "bad news or a sensitive request and are worried about", "same as everyone else. (To which we have JeffE's classic", "is a student trying to tell something to a professor.", "my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) * [How do I turn down an internship", "help with wording. * Sometimes newcomers to academia seem to", "* Sometimes newcomers to academia seem to think there are", "we offer for asking, answering, or moderating such questions?** A", "think there are magic protocols to follow, and seem to", "as everyone else. (To which we have JeffE's classic response:", "tell a professor at a foreign university politely and impressively", "(To which we have JeffE's classic response: \"Pretend as though", "research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) * [How do I explain to a prof", "maybe that distinction doesn't really have anything to do with", "just the same as everyone else. (To which we have", "* [What sentence is suitable for thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) ", "and impressively that I can’t cover the costs of living", "may come into play. Perhaps the asker is not writing", "the US may not work at all in Japan, for", "thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) [How do I politely ask a", "reassurance rather than help with wording. * Sometimes newcomers to", "professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) * [How do I politely ask a professor to", "it. Often this is a student trying to tell something", "that academics generally communicate just the same as everyone else.", "PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) * [How to tell a professor at a", "have bad news or a sensitive request and are worried", "do I politely ask a professor to contact another professor", "to tell a professor at a foreign university politely and", "trying to tell something to a professor. * [What sentence", "native language and is unsure whether they are clearly expressing", "for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) * [How do I turn down an", "Sometimes newcomers to academia seem to think there are magic", "anxious about their language skills, etc. They may be looking", "academia who want to communicate something to someone, but are", "say it. Often this is a student trying to tell", "my actions which were simply a mistake due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1)", "were simply a mistake due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What advice can", "writing in their native language and is unsure whether they", "academics generally communicate just the same as everyone else. (To", " Cultural factors may come into play. Etiquette, polite wording,", "offer in a corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) * [How do I", "may not work at all in Japan, for instance; but", "is simply nervous - perhaps they are intimidated by the", "Cultural factors may come into play. Etiquette, polite wording, etc,", "Japan, for instance; but maybe that distinction doesn't really have", "communicate something to someone, but are just not sure how", "corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) * [How do I explain to a", "a few questions from people in academia who want to", "which were simply a mistake due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What advice", "wording. Sometimes newcomers to academia seem to think there", "a sensitive request and are worried about the reaction, or", "to a professor. * [What sentence is suitable for thanking", "worried about the reaction, or are anxious about their language", "down an internship offer by a professor because I have", "in the US may not work at all in Japan,", "more between cultures than inside/outside academia. An answer that's applicable", "they are intimidated by the idea of talking to a", "newcomers to academia seem to think there are magic protocols", "or a sensitive request and are worried about the reaction,", "unsure whether they are clearly expressing themselves, or whether the", "* [How do I explain to a prof who is", "for asking, answering, or moderating such questions? A few potential", "such questions? A few potential issues: * In many cases", "a professor. * [What sentence is suitable for thanking a", "offer by a professor because I have a better offer", "news or a sensitive request and are worried about the", "the costs of living for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) * [How do", "the tone of their wording is appropriate. Again, this might", "into play. Perhaps the asker is not writing in their", "a mistake due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What advice can we offer", "anything to do with academia. Language issues may come", "to communicate something to someone, but are just not sure", "to say it. Often this is a student trying to", "language skills, etc. They may be looking for reassurance rather", "a professor, or have bad news or a sensitive request", "applicable in the US may not work at all in", "someone, but are just not sure how to say it.", "have a better offer in a corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) ", "foreign university politely and impressively that I can’t cover the", "polite wording, etc, vary much more between cultures than inside/outside", "university politely and impressively that I can’t cover the costs", "What advice can we offer for asking, answering, or moderating", "tone of their wording is appropriate. Again, this might not", "whether the tone of their wording is appropriate. Again, this", "In many cases the asker is simply nervous - perhaps", "do I explain to a prof who is not happy", "wording, etc, vary much more between cultures than inside/outside academia.", "A few potential issues: In many cases the asker", "between cultures than inside/outside academia. An answer that's applicable in", "that's applicable in the US may not work at all", "simply nervous - perhaps they are intimidated by the idea", "perhaps they are intimidated by the idea of talking to", "but are just not sure how to say it. Often", "due to miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) *What advice can we offer for asking,", "prof who is not happy with my actions which were", "potential issues: In many cases the asker is simply", "seem to think there are magic protocols to follow, and", "another professor he knows to accept me as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1)", "or moderating such questions?** A few potential issues: * In", "seem to be unaware that academics generally communicate just the", "we have JeffE's classic response: \"Pretend as though he were", "a student trying to tell something to a professor. ", "cover the costs of living for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) [How", "I can’t cover the costs of living for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1)", "they are clearly expressing themselves, or whether the tone of", "instance; but maybe that distinction doesn't really have anything to", "unaware that academics generally communicate just the same as everyone", "magic protocols to follow, and seem to be unaware that", "of talking to a professor, or have bad news or", "professor he knows to accept me as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) ", "cultures than inside/outside academia. An answer that's applicable in the", "and are worried about the reaction, or are anxious about", "protocols to follow, and seem to be unaware that academics", "is not writing in their native language and is unsure", "doesn't really have anything to do with academia. Language", "rather than help with wording. * Sometimes newcomers to academia", "to be unaware that academics generally communicate just the same", "not sure how to say it. Often this is a", "with my actions which were simply a mistake due to", "is unsure whether they are clearly expressing themselves, or whether", "asker is not writing in their native language and is", "better offer in a corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) * [How do", "* [How do I turn down an internship offer by", "to tell something to a professor. * [What sentence is", "Etiquette, polite wording, etc, vary much more between cultures than", "as though he were human\".) * Cultural factors may come", "etc, vary much more between cultures than inside/outside academia. An", "as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) * [How to tell a professor at", "a corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1) * [How do I explain to", "asker is simply nervous - perhaps they are intimidated by", "They may be looking for reassurance rather than help with", "advice can we offer for asking, answering, or moderating such", "[How to tell a professor at a foreign university politely", "few potential issues: * In many cases the asker is", "human\".) * Cultural factors may come into play. Etiquette, polite", "* In many cases the asker is simply nervous -", "themselves, or whether the tone of their wording is appropriate.", "because I have a better offer in a corporate research", "with wording. * Sometimes newcomers to academia seem to think", "of their wording is appropriate. Again, this might not really", "are worried about the reaction, or are anxious about their", "student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) * [How to tell a professor at a foreign", "how to say it. Often this is a student trying", "a foreign university politely and impressively that I can’t cover", "to a prof who is not happy with my actions", "* [How to tell a professor at a foreign university", "for reassurance rather than help with wording. * Sometimes newcomers", "a prof who is not happy with my actions which", "expressing themselves, or whether the tone of their wording is", "that distinction doesn't really have anything to do with academia.", "he knows to accept me as PhD student?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/52580/how-do-i-politely-ask-a-professor-to-contact-another-professor-he-knows-to-accep?rq=1) * [How", "be unaware that academics generally communicate just the same as", "sure how to say it. Often this is a student", "looking for reassurance rather than help with wording. * Sometimes", "wording is appropriate. Again, this might not really have anything", "skills, etc. They may be looking for reassurance rather than", "idea of talking to a professor, or have bad news", "ask a professor to contact another professor he knows to", "miscommunication?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/65302/how-do-i-explain-to-a-prof-who-is-not-happy-with-my-actions-which-were-simply-a?rq=1) What advice can we offer for asking, answering, or", "their language skills, etc. They may be looking for reassurance", "a professor to contact another professor he knows to accept", "nervous - perhaps they are intimidated by the idea of", "not writing in their native language and is unsure whether", "professor, or have bad news or a sensitive request and", "happy with my actions which were simply a mistake due", "offer for asking, answering, or moderating such questions? A few", "work at all in Japan, for instance; but maybe that", "play. Etiquette, polite wording, etc, vary much more between cultures", "professor to contact another professor he knows to accept me", "be looking for reassurance rather than help with wording. ", "student trying to tell something to a professor. [What", "I have a better offer in a corporate research lab?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/41741/how-do-i-turn-down-an-internship-offer-by-a-professor-because-i-have-a-better-of?rq=1)", "people in academia who want to communicate something to someone,", "a professor at a foreign university politely and impressively that", "this might not really have anything to do with academia.", "cases the asker is simply nervous - perhaps they are", "suitable for thanking a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) * [How do I politely", "living for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/59768/how-to-tell-a-professor-at-a-foreign-university-politely-and-impressively-that-i?rq=1) * [How do I turn down", "is not happy with my actions which were simply a", "whether they are clearly expressing themselves, or whether the tone", "request and are worried about the reaction, or are anxious", "Perhaps the asker is not writing in their native language", "talking to a professor, or have bad news or a", "I turn down an internship offer by a professor because", "a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/85417/what-sentence-is-suitable-for-thanking-a-professor) * [How do I politely ask a professor", "few questions from people in academia who want to communicate", "to a professor, or have bad news or a sensitive", "want to communicate something to someone, but are just not", "answering, or moderating such questions?** A few potential issues: *", "there are magic protocols to follow, and seem to be", "come into play. Etiquette, polite wording, etc, vary much more", "than inside/outside academia. An answer that's applicable in the US", "[How do I turn down an internship offer by a", "or whether the tone of their wording is appropriate. Again," ]
[ "room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to the march. As many of our community", "march will occur in Washington DC, but there will likely", "marches all over the world. There is an [SE chat", "As many of our community members are scientists and/or support", "is somewhat political in nature, I wanted to check with", "somewhat political in nature, I wanted to check with the", "scientists and/or support science, I was wondering if we wanted", "event/protest/rally being held on April 22 2017. The main march", "an event/protest/rally being held on April 22 2017. The main", "I was wondering if we wanted a community event countdown", "on April 22 2017. The main march will occur in", "being held on April 22 2017. The main march will", "with the community before creating an event. The countdown timer", "[March for Science](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) is an event/protest/rally being held on April", "we wanted a community event countdown to be shown on", "event countdown to be shown on the main page. As", "[SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to the march. As many of", "science, I was wondering if we wanted a community event", "community event countdown to be shown on the main page.", "community members are scientists and/or support science, I was wondering", "not overbearing and is just a small item on the", "check with the community before creating an event. The countdown", "DC, but there will likely be marches all over the", "wanted a community event countdown to be shown on the", "to the march. As many of our community members are", "if we wanted a community event countdown to be shown", "the event is somewhat political in nature, I wanted to", "is an [SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to the march. As", "countdown timer is not overbearing and is just a small", "will likely be marches all over the world. There is", "nature, I wanted to check with the community before creating", "2017. The main march will occur in Washington DC, but", "and is just a small item on the side bar.", "April 22 2017. The main march will occur in Washington", "The main march will occur in Washington DC, but there", "chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to the march. As many of our", "likely be marches all over the world. There is an", "for Science](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) is an event/protest/rally being held on April 22", "There is an [SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to the march.", "before creating an event. The countdown timer is not overbearing", "the world. There is an [SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to", "of our community members are scientists and/or support science, I", "event is somewhat political in nature, I wanted to check", "occur in Washington DC, but there will likely be marches", "dedicated to the march. As many of our community members", "support science, I was wondering if we wanted a community", "22 2017. The main march will occur in Washington DC,", "our community members are scientists and/or support science, I was", "The countdown timer is not overbearing and is just a", "page. As the event is somewhat political in nature, I", "many of our community members are scientists and/or support science,", "members are scientists and/or support science, I was wondering if", "event. The countdown timer is not overbearing and is just", "are scientists and/or support science, I was wondering if we", "was wondering if we wanted a community event countdown to", "in nature, I wanted to check with the community before", "is an event/protest/rally being held on April 22 2017. The", "an [SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to the march. As many", "community before creating an event. The countdown timer is not", "be marches all over the world. There is an [SE", "and/or support science, I was wondering if we wanted a", "creating an event. The countdown timer is not overbearing and", "be shown on the main page. As the event is", "wanted to check with the community before creating an event.", "an event. The countdown timer is not overbearing and is", "Science](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) is an event/protest/rally being held on April 22 2017.", "Washington DC, but there will likely be marches all over", "all over the world. There is an [SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington)", "is not overbearing and is just a small item on", "the main page. As the event is somewhat political in", "on the main page. As the event is somewhat political", "the community before creating an event. The countdown timer is", "a community event countdown to be shown on the main", "I wanted to check with the community before creating an", "but there will likely be marches all over the world.", "main page. As the event is somewhat political in nature,", "to check with the community before creating an event. The", "political in nature, I wanted to check with the community", "As the event is somewhat political in nature, I wanted", "will occur in Washington DC, but there will likely be", "main march will occur in Washington DC, but there will", "wondering if we wanted a community event countdown to be", "over the world. There is an [SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated", "shown on the main page. As the event is somewhat", "timer is not overbearing and is just a small item", "in Washington DC, but there will likely be marches all", "The [March for Science](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) is an event/protest/rally being held on", "to be shown on the main page. As the event", "there will likely be marches all over the world. There", "world. There is an [SE chat room](http://chat.stackexchange.com/rooms/52641/scientists-march-on-washington) dedicated to the", "overbearing and is just a small item on the side", "march. As many of our community members are scientists and/or", "the march. As many of our community members are scientists", "countdown to be shown on the main page. As the", "held on April 22 2017. The main march will occur" ]
[ "answers, and no one can guarantee that the response is", "sexism, etc.\" could just as easily create that sort of", "similar questions being down voted as too broad. For example", "prescriptions for instance. And everyone is probably willing to admit", "may be quickly deleted but the questions are frequently met", "never perfect. Elevating individuals to judge others always leads to", "frequently met with inconsistently enforced rules, dismissive links to solutions", "program to select. +4 up votes. Right below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen>", "other similar questions being down voted as too broad. For", "to be asked. And from what I've seen I expect", "different depending on who's viewing your question. If the purpose", "sort of environment. This question is about as basic meta", "another question about how to respond to emails dealing with", "and no one can guarantee that the response is going", "too broad. For example [Should I prefer PhD programs with", "where voters get to decide value are never perfect. Elevating", "more valuable than few solutions. No one wants enough variability", "deal with an inappropriate greeting in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another", "PhD programs with \"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a shopping question", "offensive behavior and to create a welcoming environment, I don't", "greeting in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another question about how to", "the question have some sort of bickering on what's appropriate.", "And from what I've seen I expect it to be", "purpose is to exclude rude and offensive behavior and to", "and ignored. [What to do when you have not received", "just snark. And a simpler rule set \"No cursing, no", "a consistently high standard, how are you ensuring that you're", "what phd program to select. -4 down votes. There are", "Another shopping question on what phd program to select. -4", "How to check internal measurements of standards. Every serious company", "really see that either. Obvious insults may be quickly deleted", "their job?\" or \"How are you ensuring that your democracy", "more solutions are more valuable than few solutions. No one", "to be different depending on who's viewing your question. If", "that the response is going to be helpful. Then there", "better than less, and more solutions are more valuable than", "about how to answer emails that have almost nothing to", "to emails dealing with research paper submissions being down voted", "you ensuring that your democracy is meeting the needs of", "needs of the community?\" that every organization has to answer.", "it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping question on what phd program to", "below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping question on what phd program", "individuals to judge others always leads to flawed decision making.", "being highly prioritized. [How to deal with an inappropriate greeting", "in their anesthesia to kill them. Democracies where voters get", "meeting that goal? Because that goal appears to be different", "most meta of questions to be asked. And from what", "my academic career\" being up voted, when there's an infinite", "etc.\" could just as easily create that sort of environment.", "precision is better than less, and more solutions are more", "a simple question \"How are you measuring whether your judges", "shopping question on what phd program to select. +4 up", "the purpose is to form a consistently high standard, how", "snark. And a simpler rule set \"No cursing, no racism,", "you ensuring that you're meeting that goal? Because that goal", "select. +4 up votes. Right below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping", "There are social etiquette questions about how to answer emails", "the community?\" that every organization has to answer. The most", "others always leads to flawed decision making. This is a", "and offensive behavior and to create a welcoming environment, I", "everyone is probably willing to admit more precision is better", "phd program to select. +4 up votes. Right below it", "with an inappropriate greeting in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another question", "question is about as basic meta as it gets. How", "question. If the purpose is to exclude rude and offensive", "the purpose is to exclude rude and offensive behavior and", "questions are frequently met with inconsistently enforced rules, dismissive links", "see that either. Obvious insults may be quickly deleted but", "guarantee that the response is going to be helpful. Then", "ensuring that you're meeting that goal? Because that goal appears", "are you ensuring that your democracy is meeting the needs", "standards. Every serious company has constant checks on their standards.", "than few solutions. No one wants enough variability in their", "is a simple question \"How are you measuring whether your", "academia being highly prioritized. [How to deal with an inappropriate", "Right below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping question on what phd", "on their standards. Hospitals aren't willy nilly winging their prescriptions", "judge others always leads to flawed decision making. This is", "potential answers, and no one can guarantee that the response", "to deal with an inappropriate greeting in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And", "environment, I don't really see that either. Obvious insults may", "to admit more precision is better than less, and more", "meta as it gets. How to check internal measurements of", "quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a shopping question on what phd program", "is about as basic meta as it gets. How to", "to exclude rude and offensive behavior and to create a", "be different depending on who's viewing your question. If the", "who's viewing your question. If the purpose is to exclude", "with my academic career\" being up voted, when there's an", "voters get to decide value are never perfect. Elevating individuals", "on what phd program to select. +4 up votes. Right", "one wants enough variability in their anesthesia to kill them.", "value are never perfect. Elevating individuals to judge others always", "to be helpful. Then there are other similar questions being", "to decide value are never perfect. Elevating individuals to judge", "[Should I prefer PhD programs with \"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is", "on who's viewing your question. If the purpose is to", "almost nothing to do with academia being highly prioritized. [How", "This is a simple question \"How are you measuring whether", "to answer. The most meta of questions to be asked.", "solutions that only tangentially answer the questions, or just snark.", "dealing with research paper submissions being down voted and ignored.", "met with inconsistently enforced rules, dismissive links to solutions that", "serious company has constant checks on their standards. Hospitals aren't", "\"How are you measuring whether your judges are doing their", "do with academia being highly prioritized. [How to deal with", "doing their job?\" or \"How are you ensuring that your", "have some sort of bickering on what's appropriate. There are", "that you're meeting that goal? Because that goal appears to", "insults may be quickly deleted but the questions are frequently", "up votes. Right below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping question on", "going to be helpful. Then there are other similar questions", "to judge others always leads to flawed decision making. This", "as easily create that sort of environment. This question is", "nothing to do with academia being highly prioritized. [How to", "links to solutions that only tangentially answer the questions, or", "of standards. Every serious company has constant checks on their", "your judges are doing their job?\" or \"How are you", "when you have not received a response three weeks after", "No one wants enough variability in their anesthesia to kill", "are frequently met with inconsistently enforced rules, dismissive links to", "standards. Hospitals aren't willy nilly winging their prescriptions for instance.", "rude and offensive behavior and to create a welcoming environment,", "racism, sexism, etc.\" could just as easily create that sort", "your democracy is meeting the needs of the community?\" that", "are never perfect. Elevating individuals to judge others always leads", "leads to flawed decision making. This is a simple question", "answer the questions, or just snark. And a simpler rule", "research paper submissions being down voted and ignored. [What to", "your question. If the purpose is to exclude rude and", "constant checks on their standards. Hospitals aren't willy nilly winging", "Hospitals aren't willy nilly winging their prescriptions for instance. And", "how are you ensuring that you're meeting that goal? Because", "cursing, no racism, sexism, etc.\" could just as easily create", "votes. There are social etiquette questions about how to answer", "submissions being down voted and ignored. [What to do when", "always leads to flawed decision making. This is a simple", "there are other similar questions being down voted as too", "minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the purpose is to form a consistently", "about how to respond to emails dealing with research paper", "that either. Obvious insults may be quickly deleted but the", "broad. For example [Should I prefer PhD programs with \"higher", "bickering on what's appropriate. There are questions as open ended", "checks on their standards. Hospitals aren't willy nilly winging their", "is probably willing to admit more precision is better than", "questions to be asked. And from what I've seen I", "+4 up votes. Right below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping question", "less, and more solutions are more valuable than few solutions.", "purpose is to form a consistently high standard, how are", "and more solutions are more valuable than few solutions. No", "not received a response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi)", "in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another question about how to respond", "I don't really see that either. Obvious insults may be", "no one can guarantee that the response is going to", "be asked. And from what I've seen I expect it", "of environment. This question is about as basic meta as", "voted as too broad. For example [Should I prefer PhD", "that every organization has to answer. The most meta of", "question on what phd program to select. -4 down votes.", "answer. The most meta of questions to be asked. And", "highly prioritized. [How to deal with an inappropriate greeting in", "to do when you have not received a response three", "students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a shopping question on what phd program to", "enough variability in their anesthesia to kill them. Democracies where", "viewing your question. If the purpose is to exclude rude", "sort of bickering on what's appropriate. There are questions as", "easily create that sort of environment. This question is about", "what phd program to select. +4 up votes. Right below", "have not received a response three weeks after submitting minor", "goal? Because that goal appears to be different depending on", "three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the purpose is", "aren't willy nilly winging their prescriptions for instance. And everyone", "you have not received a response three weeks after submitting", "If the purpose is to exclude rude and offensive behavior", "to do with academia being highly prioritized. [How to deal", "decision making. This is a simple question \"How are you", "check internal measurements of standards. Every serious company has constant", "response is going to be helpful. Then there are other", "only tangentially answer the questions, or just snark. And a", "nilly winging their prescriptions for instance. And everyone is probably", "one can guarantee that the response is going to be", "no racism, sexism, etc.\" could just as easily create that", "questions as open ended as \"What should I do with", "to solutions that only tangentially answer the questions, or just", "the response is going to be helpful. Then there are", "that sort of environment. This question is about as basic", "to form a consistently high standard, how are you ensuring", "to flawed decision making. This is a simple question \"How", "to check internal measurements of standards. Every serious company has", "is to form a consistently high standard, how are you", "create that sort of environment. This question is about as", "kill them. Democracies where voters get to decide value are", "is meeting the needs of the community?\" that every organization", "prefer PhD programs with \"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a shopping", "admit more precision is better than less, and more solutions", "have almost nothing to do with academia being highly prioritized.", "what's appropriate. There are questions as open ended as \"What", "questions about how to answer emails that have almost nothing", "to kill them. Democracies where voters get to decide value", "social etiquette questions about how to answer emails that have", "\"How are you ensuring that your democracy is meeting the", "etiquette questions about how to answer emails that have almost", "as too broad. For example [Should I prefer PhD programs", "\"What should I do with my academic career\" being up", "job?\" or \"How are you ensuring that your democracy is", "has to answer. The most meta of questions to be", "flawed decision making. This is a simple question \"How are", "do with my academic career\" being up voted, when there's", "what I've seen I expect it to be down voted.", "This question is about as basic meta as it gets.", "there's an infinite number of potential answers, and no one", "received a response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If", "to select. +4 up votes. Right below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another", "as it gets. How to check internal measurements of standards.", "Because that goal appears to be different depending on who's", "being down voted and ignored. [What to do when you", "them. Democracies where voters get to decide value are never", "company has constant checks on their standards. Hospitals aren't willy", "I do with my academic career\" being up voted, when", "goal appears to be different depending on who's viewing your", "dismissive links to solutions that only tangentially answer the questions,", "solutions. No one wants enough variability in their anesthesia to", "asked. And from what I've seen I expect it to", "programs with \"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a shopping question on", "-4 down votes. There are social etiquette questions about how", "tangentially answer the questions, or just snark. And a simpler", "that goal? Because that goal appears to be different depending", "are questions as open ended as \"What should I do", "be quickly deleted but the questions are frequently met with", "should I do with my academic career\" being up voted,", "of potential answers, and no one can guarantee that the", "willy nilly winging their prescriptions for instance. And everyone is", "And a simpler rule set \"No cursing, no racism, sexism,", "paper submissions being down voted and ignored. [What to do", "as basic meta as it gets. How to check internal", "Democracies where voters get to decide value are never perfect.", "create a welcoming environment, I don't really see that either.", "whether your judges are doing their job?\" or \"How are", "can guarantee that the response is going to be helpful.", "or \"How are you ensuring that your democracy is meeting", "are you measuring whether your judges are doing their job?\"", "ensuring that your democracy is meeting the needs of the", "just as easily create that sort of environment. This question", "either. Obvious insults may be quickly deleted but the questions", "is going to be helpful. Then there are other similar", "do when you have not received a response three weeks", "Then there are other similar questions being down voted as", "that your democracy is meeting the needs of the community?\"", "set \"No cursing, no racism, sexism, etc.\" could just as", "Is a shopping question on what phd program to select.", "down voted and ignored. [What to do when you have", "judges are doing their job?\" or \"How are you ensuring", "votes. Right below it <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping question on what", "than less, and more solutions are more valuable than few", "of the question have some sort of bickering on what's", "on what phd program to select. -4 down votes. There", "as \"What should I do with my academic career\" being", "simpler rule set \"No cursing, no racism, sexism, etc.\" could", "infinite number of potential answers, and no one can guarantee", "voted, when there's an infinite number of potential answers, and", "with academia being highly prioritized. [How to deal with an", "phd program to select. -4 down votes. There are social", "down votes. There are social etiquette questions about how to", "few solutions. No one wants enough variability in their anesthesia", "[What to do when you have not received a response", "number of potential answers, and no one can guarantee that", "standard, how are you ensuring that you're meeting that goal?", "a response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the", "of bickering on what's appropriate. There are questions as open", "high standard, how are you ensuring that you're meeting that", "[How to deal with an inappropriate greeting in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email)", "depending on who's viewing your question. If the purpose is", "measurements of standards. Every serious company has constant checks on", "community?\" that every organization has to answer. The most meta", "meta of questions to be asked. And from what I've", "to select. -4 down votes. There are social etiquette questions", "an inappropriate greeting in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another question about", "winging their prescriptions for instance. And everyone is probably willing", "emails dealing with research paper submissions being down voted and", "select. -4 down votes. There are social etiquette questions about", "program to select. -4 down votes. There are social etiquette", "being up voted, when there's an infinite number of potential", "wants enough variability in their anesthesia to kill them. Democracies", "every organization has to answer. The most meta of questions", "question on what phd program to select. +4 up votes.", "weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the purpose is to", "that goal appears to be different depending on who's viewing", "democracy is meeting the needs of the community?\" that every", "And everyone is probably willing to admit more precision is", "Probably half of the question have some sort of bickering", "internal measurements of standards. Every serious company has constant checks", "valuable than few solutions. No one wants enough variability in", "a shopping question on what phd program to select. +4", "willing to admit more precision is better than less, and", "half of the question have some sort of bickering on", "as open ended as \"What should I do with my", "consistently high standard, how are you ensuring that you're meeting", "behavior and to create a welcoming environment, I don't really", "basic meta as it gets. How to check internal measurements", "academic career\" being up voted, when there's an infinite number", "could just as easily create that sort of environment. This", "of the community?\" that every organization has to answer. The", "appears to be different depending on who's viewing your question.", "Obvious insults may be quickly deleted but the questions are", "down voted as too broad. For example [Should I prefer", "a simpler rule set \"No cursing, no racism, sexism, etc.\"", "is better than less, and more solutions are more valuable", "email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another question about how to respond to emails", "an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another question about how to respond to", "that only tangentially answer the questions, or just snark. And", "simple question \"How are you measuring whether your judges are", "after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the purpose is to form", "but the questions are frequently met with inconsistently enforced rules,", "\"No cursing, no racism, sexism, etc.\" could just as easily", "their prescriptions for instance. And everyone is probably willing to", "submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the purpose is to form a", "are other similar questions being down voted as too broad.", "question have some sort of bickering on what's appropriate. There", "are more valuable than few solutions. No one wants enough", "gets. How to check internal measurements of standards. Every serious", "the needs of the community?\" that every organization has to", "I prefer PhD programs with \"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a", "are you ensuring that you're meeting that goal? Because that", "rules, dismissive links to solutions that only tangentially answer the", "more precision is better than less, and more solutions are", "shopping question on what phd program to select. -4 down", "is to exclude rude and offensive behavior and to create", "Every serious company has constant checks on their standards. Hospitals", "Elevating individuals to judge others always leads to flawed decision", "are doing their job?\" or \"How are you ensuring that", "And another question about how to respond to emails dealing", "that have almost nothing to do with academia being highly", "get to decide value are never perfect. Elevating individuals to", "respond to emails dealing with research paper submissions being down", "anesthesia to kill them. Democracies where voters get to decide", "an infinite number of potential answers, and no one can", "instance. And everyone is probably willing to admit more precision", "some sort of bickering on what's appropriate. There are questions", "solutions are more valuable than few solutions. No one wants", "when there's an infinite number of potential answers, and no", "with research paper submissions being down voted and ignored. [What", "answer emails that have almost nothing to do with academia", "and to create a welcoming environment, I don't really see", "organization has to answer. The most meta of questions to", "you measuring whether your judges are doing their job?\" or", "response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the purpose", "or just snark. And a simpler rule set \"No cursing,", "how to respond to emails dealing with research paper submissions", "up voted, when there's an infinite number of potential answers,", "don't really see that either. Obvious insults may be quickly", "prioritized. [How to deal with an inappropriate greeting in an", "with inconsistently enforced rules, dismissive links to solutions that only", "to respond to emails dealing with research paper submissions being", "perfect. Elevating individuals to judge others always leads to flawed", "If the purpose is to form a consistently high standard,", "questions being down voted as too broad. For example [Should", "has constant checks on their standards. Hospitals aren't willy nilly", "from what I've seen I expect it to be down", "exclude rude and offensive behavior and to create a welcoming", "decide value are never perfect. Elevating individuals to judge others", "variability in their anesthesia to kill them. Democracies where voters", "The most meta of questions to be asked. And from", "open ended as \"What should I do with my academic", "voted and ignored. [What to do when you have not", "to answer emails that have almost nothing to do with", "are social etiquette questions about how to answer emails that", "probably willing to admit more precision is better than less,", "example [Should I prefer PhD programs with \"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students)", "environment. This question is about as basic meta as it", "rule set \"No cursing, no racism, sexism, etc.\" could just", "quickly deleted but the questions are frequently met with inconsistently", "revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86742/what-to-do-when-you-have-not-received-a-response-three-weeks-after-submitting-mi) If the purpose is to form a consistently high", "the questions, or just snark. And a simpler rule set", "appropriate. There are questions as open ended as \"What should", "For example [Should I prefer PhD programs with \"higher quality\"", "inconsistently enforced rules, dismissive links to solutions that only tangentially", "helpful. Then there are other similar questions being down voted", "being down voted as too broad. For example [Should I", "making. This is a simple question \"How are you measuring", "you're meeting that goal? Because that goal appears to be", "enforced rules, dismissive links to solutions that only tangentially answer", "career\" being up voted, when there's an infinite number of", "inappropriate greeting in an email?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86352/how-to-deal-with-an-inappropriate-greeting-in-an-email) And another question about how", "to create a welcoming environment, I don't really see that", "form a consistently high standard, how are you ensuring that", "about as basic meta as it gets. How to check", "meeting the needs of the community?\" that every organization has", "be helpful. Then there are other similar questions being down", "with \"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a shopping question on what", "a welcoming environment, I don't really see that either. Obvious", "questions, or just snark. And a simpler rule set \"No", "measuring whether your judges are doing their job?\" or \"How", "their anesthesia to kill them. Democracies where voters get to", "question \"How are you measuring whether your judges are doing", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86669/phd-is-75-done-in-russia-any-options-in-europe-uk-citizen> Another shopping question on what phd program to select.", "deleted but the questions are frequently met with inconsistently enforced", "it gets. How to check internal measurements of standards. Every", "on what's appropriate. There are questions as open ended as", "how to answer emails that have almost nothing to do", "the questions are frequently met with inconsistently enforced rules, dismissive", "ignored. [What to do when you have not received a", "emails that have almost nothing to do with academia being", "question about how to respond to emails dealing with research", "ended as \"What should I do with my academic career\"", "of questions to be asked. And from what I've seen", "\"higher quality\" students?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86672/should-i-prefer-phd-programs-with-higher-quality-students) Is a shopping question on what phd", "welcoming environment, I don't really see that either. Obvious insults", "their standards. Hospitals aren't willy nilly winging their prescriptions for", "for instance. And everyone is probably willing to admit more", "There are questions as open ended as \"What should I" ]
[ "is probably above average in quality. I remember many bad", "politely enquire about a paper which is under review for", "include: + > > What is your field? > >", "I remember many bad questions of this kind which I", "can be avoided or at least reduced by asking the", "answer. If you think that an existing question is already", "comments. Thus, I am proposing to create such a canonical", "a lot of overlap between the answers, which could be", "as: * How do I find out whether this is", "of overlap between the answers, which could be covered in", "is still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is it rude to remind", "Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is it rude to remind an editor about", "have the following advantage: * Basic questions of this type", "> + > > Wait at least half a year.", "still waiting for an invitee after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) * [Will", "be stuck at a some stage: * [What to do", "awaiting reviewer invitation 6 months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) * [What should", "think that an existing question is already suitable for this", "to inquire about the status of a paper when the", "to do when two months after submitting a major revision,", "comments can be avoided or at least reduced by asking", "of paper, Editor doesn't even answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) * [What", "> > + > > Wait at least half a", "its status is still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is it rude", "that an existing question is already suitable for this purpose,", "question and answer. It could cover such basics as: ", " [What should I do, as my submitted paper is", "that this selection is probably above average in quality. I", "[feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e., you can indicate approval", "can answer nothing but general advice can be closed as", "information. * Typical comments can be avoided or at least", "* How do I find out whether this is normal", "badly written or downvoted into oblivion.) Most of these questions", "into oblivion.) Most of these questions are not duplicates of", "least reduced by asking the asker to read the canonical", "I do, as my submitted paper is still under review", "it because they were deleted, badly written or downvoted into", "this type where we can answer nothing but general advice", "it okay to inquire about the status of a paper", "delay in reviewing the revision of paper, Editor doesn't even", "and editing their question accordingly. Such comments include: + >", "still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is it rude to remind an", "and is more helpful to the asker. Some askers may", "answers, which could be covered in a canonical question and", "canonical question and answer. If you think that an existing", "refer the asker to the canonical Q&A to cover the", "bad guidance in some fields with quicker review processes) +", "appears to be stuck at a some stage: * [What", "(which is bad guidance in some fields with quicker review", "in reviewing the revision of paper, Editor doesn't even answer", "> What is your field? > > > + >", "Thus, I am proposing to create such a canonical question", "about a manuscript submission still waiting for an invitee after", "get help immediately. * Questions that are about a special,", "is a lot of overlap between the answers, which could", "asking the asker to read the canonical Q&A first and", "about a paper which is under review for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734)", "year. > > > (which is bad guidance in some", "submitted paper is still under review after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) ", "revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) [Article awaiting reviewer invitation 6 months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734)", "* Basic questions of this type where we can answer", "even answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) * [What to do when two", "some journal and gets impatient because it appears to be", "to remind an editor about a manuscript submission still waiting", "status is still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is it rude to", "focus on this. We can refer the asker to the", "processes) + The typical replies to such comments. Thus, I", "This avoids us reïterating the same advice again and again", "about a special, interesting situation can focus on this. We", "avoided or at least reduced by asking the asker to", "duplicates of each other, because they differ in detail. Yet", "am proposing to create such a canonical question and answer.", "because they were deleted, badly written or downvoted into oblivion.)", "asker to read the canonical Q&A first and editing their", "deleted, badly written or downvoted into oblivion.) Most of these", "existing question is already suitable for this purpose, please suggest", "email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) * [What to do when two months after submitting", "at a some stage: * [What to do when you", "to create such a canonical question and answer. If you", "This is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e., you", "of the canonical question. This avoids us reïterating the same", "situation can focus on this. We can refer the asker", "comments include: + > > What is your field? >", "a canonical question and answer. If you think that an", "again and again and is more helpful to the asker.", "paper when the online submission system shows no update three", "kind which I fail to find, be it because they", "to read the canonical Q&A first and editing their question", "is already suitable for this purpose, please suggest it. ---", "Editor doesn't even answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) * [What to do", "submitting a major revision, its status is still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734)", "question is already suitable for this purpose, please suggest it.", "submitted a paper to some journal and gets impatient because", "I fail to find, be it because they were deleted,", "manuscript submission still waiting for an invitee after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734)", "of this kind which I fail to find, be it", "weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) * [Article awaiting reviewer invitation", "* [Is it rude to remind an editor about a", "invitation 6 months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) * [What should I do,", "(Note that this selection is probably above average in quality.", "bad questions of this kind which I fail to find,", "a year. > > > (which is bad guidance in", "considerable amount of questions, where the asker submitted a paper", "lot of overlap between the answers, which could be covered", "advantage: * Basic questions of this type where we can", "general advice can be closed as a duplicate of the", "may even find this question before asking and get help", "submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three month delay in reviewing the revision of", "reviewing the revision of paper, Editor doesn't even answer the", "the revision of paper, Editor doesn't even answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734)", "Questions that are about a special, interesting situation can focus", "detail. Yet there is a lot of overlap between the", "when to act? * How should I act? This would", "the canonical Q&A to cover the basic information. * Typical", "your field? > > > + > > Wait at", "this question before asking and get help immediately. * Questions", "as a duplicate of the canonical question. This avoids us", "we can answer nothing but general advice can be closed", "differ in detail. Yet there is a lot of overlap", "\"show questions tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e., you can indicate approval or", "written or downvoted into oblivion.) Most of these questions are", "asker to the canonical Q&A to cover the basic information.", "before asking and get help immediately. * Questions that are", "create such a canonical question and answer. If you think", "you think that an existing question is already suitable for", "average in quality. I remember many bad questions of this", "when you have not received a response three weeks after", "this selection is probably above average in quality. I remember", "already suitable for this purpose, please suggest it. --- This", "not? * How do I decide when to act? ", "2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) [Will it be ok if I politely", "remind an editor about a manuscript submission still waiting for", "the status of a paper when the online submission system", "basic information. * Typical comments can be avoided or at", "[Is it rude to remind an editor about a manuscript", "out whether this is normal or not? * How do", "advice again and again and is more helpful to the", "the online submission system shows no update three months after", "received a response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) ", "It could cover such basics as: How do I", "* [What to do when two months after submitting a", "do I decide when to act? * How should I", "* [Article awaiting reviewer invitation 6 months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) ", "a paper to some journal and gets impatient because it", "What is your field? > > > + > >", "reviewer invitation 6 months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) [What should I", "stage: * [What to do when you have not received", "the answers, which could be covered in a canonical question", "could cover such basics as: * How do I find", "suggest it. --- This is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions tagged", "[Will it be ok if I politely enquire about a", "after submitting a major revision, its status is still \"Editor", "these questions are not duplicates of each other, because they", "> > What is your field? > > > +", "8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that this selection is probably above average", "special, interesting situation can focus on this. We can refer", "three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) * [Article awaiting reviewer", "* Typical comments can be avoided or at least reduced", "be covered in a canonical question and answer. It could", "would have the following advantage: * Basic questions of this", "asker submitted a paper to some journal and gets impatient", "journal and gets impatient because it appears to be stuck", "it be ok if I politely enquire about a paper", "overlap between the answers, which could be covered in a", "guidance in some fields with quicker review processes) + The", "a canonical question and answer. It could cover such basics", "How do I decide when to act? * How should", "to find, be it because they were deleted, badly written", "and gets impatient because it appears to be stuck at", "under review for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that this selection is", "there is a lot of overlap between the answers, which", "to do when you have not received a response three", "suitable for this purpose, please suggest it. --- This is", "do, as my submitted paper is still under review after", "Wait at least half a year. > > > (which", "have not received a response three weeks after submitting minor", "[What should I do, as my submitted paper is still", "but general advice can be closed as a duplicate of", "you have not received a response three weeks after submitting", "a paper which is under review for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note", "is your field? > > > + > > Wait", "questions of this type where we can answer nothing but", "I act? This would have the following advantage: * Basic", "paper, Editor doesn't even answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) * [What to", "Basic questions of this type where we can answer nothing", "to such comments. Thus, I am proposing to create such", "months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that this selection is probably above average in", "canonical Q&A first and editing their question accordingly. Such comments", "submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) * [Article awaiting reviewer invitation 6 months", "year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is it okay to inquire about the status", "months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three month delay in reviewing the", "months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) * [Will it be ok if I politely enquire", "as my submitted paper is still under review after 1", "review after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is it okay to inquire", "reduced by asking the asker to read the canonical Q&A", "the asker to the canonical Q&A to cover the basic", "cover the basic information. * Typical comments can be avoided", "advice can be closed as a duplicate of the canonical", "act? This would have the following advantage: * Basic questions", "Typical comments can be avoided or at least reduced by", "impatient because it appears to be stuck at a some", "a duplicate of the canonical question. This avoids us reïterating", "a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e., you can indicate", "do I find out whether this is normal or not?", "a considerable amount of questions, where the asker submitted a", "+ > > What is your field? > > >", "is normal or not? * How do I decide when", "* [Is it okay to inquire about the status of", "with quicker review processes) + The typical replies to such", "a manuscript submission still waiting for an invitee after 2", "such a canonical question and answer. If you think that", "accordingly. Such comments include: + > > What is your", "1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is it okay to inquire about the", "first and editing their question accordingly. Such comments include: +", "they were deleted, badly written or downvoted into oblivion.) Most", "if I politely enquire about a paper which is under", "can be closed as a duplicate of the canonical question.", "find this question before asking and get help immediately. ", "question accordingly. Such comments include: + > > What is", "when the online submission system shows no update three months", "read the canonical Q&A first and editing their question accordingly.", "> (which is bad guidance in some fields with quicker", "it. --- This is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions tagged 'feature-request'\"),", "even find this question before asking and get help immediately.", "because they differ in detail. Yet there is a lot", "such comments. Thus, I am proposing to create such a", "and again and is more helpful to the asker. Some", "paper to some journal and gets impatient because it appears", "to cover the basic information. Typical comments can be", "Some askers may even find this question before asking and", "replies to such comments. Thus, I am proposing to create", "[Article awaiting reviewer invitation 6 months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) * [What", "please suggest it. --- This is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions", "selection is probably above average in quality. I remember many", "[What to do when two months after submitting a major", "the same advice again and again and is more helpful", "Most of these questions are not duplicates of each other,", "This would have the following advantage: * Basic questions of", "that are about a special, interesting situation can focus on", "in a canonical question and answer. It could cover such", "submission still waiting for an invitee after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) ", "gets impatient because it appears to be stuck at a", "doesn't even answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) [What to do when", "after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) * [Will it be ok if I", "is still under review after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is it", "questions of this kind which I fail to find, be", "no update three months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three month delay", "following advantage: * Basic questions of this type where we", "it appears to be stuck at a some stage: ", "each other, because they differ in detail. Yet there is", "you can indicate approval or opposition by voting on the", "interesting situation can focus on this. We can refer the", "of questions, where the asker submitted a paper to some", "months after submitting a major revision, its status is still", "to the canonical Q&A to cover the basic information. ", "submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) * [What should I do, as my submitted paper", "do when two months after submitting a major revision, its", "were deleted, badly written or downvoted into oblivion.) Most of", "ok if I politely enquire about a paper which is", "proposing to create such a canonical question and answer. If", "at least reduced by asking the asker to read the", "they differ in detail. Yet there is a lot of", "The typical replies to such comments. Thus, I am proposing", "of a paper when the online submission system shows no", "do when you have not received a response three weeks", "> > Wait at least half a year. > >", "invitee after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) * [Will it be ok if", "or not? * How do I decide when to act?", "Such comments include: + > > What is your field?", "are about a special, interesting situation can focus on this.", "I politely enquire about a paper which is under review", "okay to inquire about the status of a paper when", "--- This is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e.,", "reïterating the same advice again and again and is more", "to the asker. Some askers may even find this question", "in detail. Yet there is a lot of overlap between", "find, be it because they were deleted, badly written or", "basics as: * How do I find out whether this", "downvoted into oblivion.) Most of these questions are not duplicates", "askers may even find this question before asking and get", "by asking the asker to read the canonical Q&A first", "their question accordingly. Such comments include: + > > What", "my submitted paper is still under review after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734)", "get a considerable amount of questions, where the asker submitted", "a some stage: * [What to do when you have", "an editor about a manuscript submission still waiting for an", "quicker review processes) + The typical replies to such comments.", "above average in quality. I remember many bad questions of", "at least half a year. > > > (which is", "[What to do when you have not received a response", "on this. We can refer the asker to the canonical", "is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show questions tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e., you can", "quality. I remember many bad questions of this kind which", "question before asking and get help immediately. * Questions that", "update three months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three month delay in", "month delay in reviewing the revision of paper, Editor doesn't", "[Is it okay to inquire about the status of a", "whether this is normal or not? * How do I", "fields with quicker review processes) + The typical replies to", "about the status of a paper when the online submission", "revision of paper, Editor doesn't even answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) ", "can indicate approval or opposition by voting on the question.", "answer nothing but general advice can be closed as a", "after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) [Article awaiting reviewer invitation 6", "If you think that an existing question is already suitable", "should I act? This would have the following advantage: ", "not received a response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734)", "rude to remind an editor about a manuscript submission still", "field? > > > + > > Wait at least", "help immediately. Questions that are about a special, interesting", "remember many bad questions of this kind which I fail", "purpose, please suggest it. --- This is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request \"show", "canonical question. This avoids us reïterating the same advice again", "in quality. I remember many bad questions of this kind", "stuck at a some stage: * [What to do when", "should I do, as my submitted paper is still under", "be closed as a duplicate of the canonical question. This", "some stage: * [What to do when you have not", "the asker to read the canonical Q&A first and editing", "the following advantage: * Basic questions of this type where", "for this purpose, please suggest it. --- This is a", "a special, interesting situation can focus on this. We can", "question. This avoids us reïterating the same advice again and", "three months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three month delay in reviewing", "between the answers, which could be covered in a canonical", "system shows no update three months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three", "is bad guidance in some fields with quicker review processes)", "response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) * [Article awaiting", "this is normal or not? * How do I decide", "are not duplicates of each other, because they differ in", "the basic information. * Typical comments can be avoided or", "it rude to remind an editor about a manuscript submission", "canonical Q&A to cover the basic information. * Typical comments", "could be covered in a canonical question and answer. It", "can focus on this. We can refer the asker to", "online submission system shows no update three months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734)", "closed as a duplicate of the canonical question. This avoids", "an invitee after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) * [Will it be ok", "typical replies to such comments. Thus, I am proposing to", "to act? * How should I act? This would have", "for an invitee after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) * [Will it be", "inquire about the status of a paper when the online", "fail to find, be it because they were deleted, badly", "paper which is under review for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that", "We can refer the asker to the canonical Q&A to", "paper is still under review after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is", "* [Will it be ok if I politely enquire about", "immediately. * Questions that are about a special, interesting situation", "review processes) + The typical replies to such comments. Thus,", "How do I find out whether this is normal or", "revision, its status is still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is it", "a paper when the online submission system shows no update", "> > > (which is bad guidance in some fields", "the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) * [What to do when two months after", "under review after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is it okay to", "to some journal and gets impatient because it appears to", "to be stuck at a some stage: * [What to", "submission system shows no update three months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) ", "> Wait at least half a year. > > >", "questions tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e., you can indicate approval or opposition", "where the asker submitted a paper to some journal and", "probably above average in quality. I remember many bad questions", "of this type where we can answer nothing but general", "amount of questions, where the asker submitted a paper to", "a response three weeks after submitting minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) [Article", "the canonical question. This avoids us reïterating the same advice", "months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) * [What should I do, as my", "find out whether this is normal or not? * How", "is under review for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that this selection", "same advice again and again and is more helpful to", "still under review after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is it okay", "* How do I decide when to act? * How", "asker. Some askers may even find this question before asking", "in some fields with quicker review processes) + The typical", "I decide when to act? * How should I act?", "shows no update three months after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three month", "oblivion.) Most of these questions are not duplicates of each", "waiting for an invitee after 2 months?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/80043/7734) * [Will it", "us reïterating the same advice again and again and is", "[Three month delay in reviewing the revision of paper, Editor", "* [What to do when you have not received a", "after 1 year?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/66219/7734) * [Is it okay to inquire about", "6 months after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) * [What should I do, as", "because it appears to be stuck at a some stage:", "status of a paper when the online submission system shows", "the asker submitted a paper to some journal and gets", "many bad questions of this kind which I fail to", "be it because they were deleted, badly written or downvoted", "such basics as: * How do I find out whether", "cover such basics as: * How do I find out", "We get a considerable amount of questions, where the asker", "> > > + > > Wait at least half", "asking and get help immediately. * Questions that are about", "'feature-request'\"), i.e., you can indicate approval or opposition by voting", "when two months after submitting a major revision, its status", "minor revisions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/86742/7734) * [Article awaiting reviewer invitation 6 months after", "duplicate of the canonical question. This avoids us reïterating the", "enquire about a paper which is under review for 8.5", "and get help immediately. * Questions that are about a", "which is under review for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that this", "is more helpful to the asker. Some askers may even", "I am proposing to create such a canonical question and", "editor about a manuscript submission still waiting for an invitee", "+ The typical replies to such comments. Thus, I am", "least half a year. > > > (which is bad", "normal or not? * How do I decide when to", "answer the email](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/34648/7734) * [What to do when two months", "where we can answer nothing but general advice can be", "after submission?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/24162/7734) * [Three month delay in reviewing the revision", "or at least reduced by asking the asker to read", "a major revision, its status is still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) ", "questions are not duplicates of each other, because they differ", "I find out whether this is normal or not? ", "or downvoted into oblivion.) Most of these questions are not", "tagged 'feature-request'\"), i.e., you can indicate approval or opposition by", "more helpful to the asker. Some askers may even find", "decide when to act? * How should I act? This", "Q&A first and editing their question accordingly. Such comments include:", "act? * How should I act? This would have the", "helpful to the asker. Some askers may even find this", "How should I act? This would have the following advantage:", "two months after submitting a major revision, its status is", "Yet there is a lot of overlap between the answers,", "i.e., you can indicate approval or opposition by voting on", "+ > > Wait at least half a year. >", "can refer the asker to the canonical Q&A to cover", "and answer. It could cover such basics as: * How", "of each other, because they differ in detail. Yet there", "major revision, its status is still \"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is", "this kind which I fail to find, be it because", "for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that this selection is probably above", "and answer. If you think that an existing question is", "again and is more helpful to the asker. Some askers", "half a year. > > > (which is bad guidance", "not duplicates of each other, because they differ in detail.", "an existing question is already suitable for this purpose, please", "question and answer. If you think that an existing question", "answer. It could cover such basics as: * How do", "the canonical Q&A first and editing their question accordingly. Such", "of these questions are not duplicates of each other, because", "covered in a canonical question and answer. It could cover", "* Questions that are about a special, interesting situation can", "questions, where the asker submitted a paper to some journal", "after submission](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/18543/7734) * [What should I do, as my submitted", "* [Three month delay in reviewing the revision of paper,", "Q&A to cover the basic information. * Typical comments can", "the asker. Some askers may even find this question before", "* How should I act? This would have the following", "\"Editor Assigned\"?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/72608/7734) * [Is it rude to remind an editor", "be avoided or at least reduced by asking the asker", "avoids us reïterating the same advice again and again and", "other, because they differ in detail. Yet there is a", "review for 8.5 months](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/85280/7734) (Note that this selection is probably", "which I fail to find, be it because they were", "this purpose, please suggest it. --- This is a [feature-request](/questions/tagged/feature-request", "editing their question accordingly. Such comments include: + > >", "> > (which is bad guidance in some fields with", "this. We can refer the asker to the canonical Q&A", "type where we can answer nothing but general advice can", "nothing but general advice can be closed as a duplicate", "canonical question and answer. It could cover such basics as:", "be ok if I politely enquire about a paper which", "some fields with quicker review processes) + The typical replies", "which could be covered in a canonical question and answer." ]
[ "Therefore it is difficult to upvote and downvote the partial", "my question does not satisfy. It seems like there are", "disagreement as to whether questions of type (1) are shopping.", "researched and on topic, other formats are more appropriate for", "possible characteristics of a shopping question, each of which my", "question and is asking for an opinion, which is simply", "as an answer or seek an assessment or comparison of", "which is simply not correct. There seems to be a", "are more appropriate for this type of question. > >", "a different community member, are not well suited for this", "as my question on #of attendees at academic conferences] and", "seek a list of objective facts, with entries of the", "explicit and include a \"for any reason in it\". Should", "shopping question, each of which my question does not satisfy.", "classified it as not shopping. If we are to say", "topics or similar as an answer or seek an assessment", "seem to match my question. The meta question I link", "are to say that any question that asks for an", "to the reason one would want a list, the close", "are unlikely to receive a complete list/answer by a single", "mine was reopened on Academia Stack Exchange after a [meta", "of this form are unlikely to receive a complete list/answer", "a list of objective facts related to academia [such as", "flavor to mine was reopened on Academia Stack Exchange after", "does not seem to match my question. The meta question", "upvote and downvote the partial answers to such questions. While", "reason in it\". Should we have two close reasons list", "#of attendees at academic conferences] and (2) asking for a", "be an equally valid yet incomplete part of the complete", "meta does not seem to match my question. The meta", "opinion, which is simply not correct. There seems to be", "lot of disagreement as to whether questions of type (1)", "site. This is because each answer would be an equally", "one would want a list, the close reason should be", "facts related to academia [such as my question on #of", "well suited for this site. This is because each answer", "was reopened on Academia Stack Exchange after a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping)", "list form, regardless as to the reason one would want", "of a connotation if we are going to use it", "an answer in list form, regardless as to the reason", "are not well suited for this site. This is because", "or lists of individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, research", "we have two close reasons list asking* and shopping. The", "seek recommendations or lists of individual universities, academic programs, publishers,", "for shopping. However, how shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta does", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is nearly identical in flavor to mine", "suited for this site. This is because each answer would", "reason should be more explicit and include a \"for any", "and downvote the partial answers to such questions. *While such", "a single user. Therefore it is difficult to upvote and", "The meta question I link to outlines three possible characteristics", "lists of individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, research topics", "close reasons list asking* and shopping. The description of the", "> Note that the word \"shopping\" applied to (1) is", "> > Note that the word \"shopping\" applied to (1)", "\"shopping\" applied to (1) is a bit offensive, it implies", "questions may be well researched and on topic, other formats", "complete list. Questions of this form are unlikely to receive", "not shopping. If we are to say that any question", "at academic conferences] and (2) asking for a subjective list", "a subjective list of rankings for comparison. > > \"Shopping\"", "types/interpretations of shopping questions (1) asking for a list of", "think shopping has too negative of a connotation if we", "asking* close reason could go something like as follows >", "the partial answers to such questions. While such questions may", "as follows > > \"List asking\" questions which seek a", "of question. > > > I think shopping has too", "> \"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists of individual", "asking for an opinion, which is simply not correct. There", "for this site. This is because each answer would be", "and shopping. The description of the list asking close reason", "description of the list asking close reason could go something", "[described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta does not seem to match my question.", "example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is nearly identical in flavor to", "for this type of question. > > > I think", "outlines three possible characteristics of a shopping question, each of", "which seek recommendations or lists of individual universities, academic programs,", "shopping. However, how shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta does not", "Recently, [my question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/88915/which-academic-conferences-have-more-4-000-attendees) was closed for shopping. However, how shopping", "as to the reason one would want a list, the", "\"for any reason in it\". Should we have two close", "in flavor to mine was reopened on Academia Stack Exchange", "whether questions of type (1) are shopping. For example, [this", "is simply not correct. There seems to be a lot", "rankings for comparison. > > \"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations", "my question on #of attendees at academic conferences] and (2)", "and on topic, other formats are more appropriate for this", "like there are two very different types/interpretations of shopping questions", "question does not satisfy. It seems like there are two", "topic, other formats are more appropriate for this type of", "difficult to upvote and downvote the partial answers to such", "here > > > Note that the word \"shopping\" applied", "question. > > > I think shopping has too negative", "asker didn't simply google the question and is asking for", "of objective facts, with entries of the list each likely", "attendees at academic conferences] and (2) asking for a subjective", "not correct. There seems to be a lot of disagreement", "this site. This is because each answer would be an", "is difficult to upvote and downvote the partial answers to", "seems to be a lot of disagreement as to whether", "it to close questions of people who have demonstrated considerable", "as not shopping. If we are to say that any", "after a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified it as not shopping.", "the list asking close reason could go something like as", "For example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is nearly identical in flavor", "list/answer by a single user. Therefore it is difficult to", "is a bit offensive, it implies the question asker didn't", "[my question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/88915/which-academic-conferences-have-more-4-000-attendees) was closed for shopping. However, how shopping is", "community member, are not well suited for this site. This", "say that any question that asks for an answer in", "conferences] and (2) asking for a subjective list of rankings", "match my question. The meta question I link to outlines", "questions of type (1) are shopping. For example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915),", "the word \"shopping\" applied to (1) is a bit offensive,", "of a shopping question, each of which my question does", "question that asks for an answer in list form, regardless", "my question. The meta question I link to outlines three", "It seems like there are two very different types/interpretations of", "\"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists of individual universities,", "to mine was reopened on Academia Stack Exchange after a", "questions of people who have demonstrated considerable research behind their", "such, are off-topic here > > > Note that the", "the complete list. Questions of this form are unlikely to", "go something like as follows > > \"List asking\" questions", "Academia Stack Exchange after a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified it", "to be a lot of disagreement as to whether questions", "a \"for any reason in it\". Should we have two", "which is nearly identical in flavor to mine was reopened", "list, the close reason should be more explicit and include", "The description of the list asking close reason could go", "> > > Note that the word \"shopping\" applied to", "characteristics of a shopping question, each of which my question", "would want a list, the close reason should be more", "form are unlikely to receive a complete list/answer by a", "(1) is a bit offensive, it implies the question asker", "valid yet incomplete part of the complete list. Questions of", "to match my question. The meta question I link to", "publishers, journals, research topics or similar as an answer or", "to upvote and downvote the partial answers to such questions.", "Should we have two close reasons list asking and shopping.", "shopping. If we are to say that any question that", "a connotation if we are going to use it to", "Note that the word \"shopping\" applied to (1) is a", "in it\". Should we have two close reasons list asking", "a list, the close reason should be more explicit and", "shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta does not seem to match", "link to outlines three possible characteristics of a shopping question,", "each of which my question does not satisfy. It seems", "very different types/interpretations of shopping questions (1) asking for a", "and is asking for an opinion, which is simply not", "If we are to say that any question that asks", "unlikely to receive a complete list/answer by a single user.", "the close reason should be more explicit and include a", "of shopping questions (1) asking for a list of objective", "the question and is asking for an opinion, which is", "connotation if we are going to use it to close", "contributed by a different community member, are not well suited", "on Academia Stack Exchange after a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified", "recommendations or lists of individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals,", "more appropriate for this type of question. > > >", "regardless as to the reason one would want a list,", "implies the question asker didn't simply google the question and", "reason one would want a list, the close reason should", "yet incomplete part of the complete list. Questions of this", "simply not correct. There seems to be a lot of", "to close questions of people who have demonstrated considerable research", "member, are not well suited for this site. This is", "different community member, are not well suited for this site.", "answer would be an equally valid yet incomplete part of", "that asks for an answer in list form, regardless as", "formats are more appropriate for this type of question. >", "for an opinion, which is simply not correct. There seems", "be well researched and on topic, other formats are more", "not well suited for this site. This is because each", "this type of question. > > > I think shopping", "are off-topic here > > > Note that the word", "partial answers to such questions. While such questions may be", "question asker didn't simply google the question and is asking", "academic conferences] and (2) asking for a subjective list of", "is asking for an opinion, which is simply not correct.", "question, each of which my question does not satisfy. It", "question. The meta question I link to outlines three possible", "related to academia [such as my question on #of attendees", "asking\" questions which seek a list of objective facts, with", "shopping questions (1) asking for a list of objective facts", "other formats are more appropriate for this type of question.*", "close reason should be more explicit and include a \"for", "to outlines three possible characteristics of a shopping question, each", "Questions of this form are unlikely to receive a complete", "not seem to match my question. The meta question I", "on topic, other formats are more appropriate for this type", "to say that any question that asks for an answer", "(1) are shopping. For example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is nearly", "a bit offensive, it implies the question asker didn't simply", "going to use it to close questions of people who", "which my question does not satisfy. It seems like there", "of the complete list. Questions of this form are unlikely", "This is because each answer would be an equally valid", "for a list of objective facts related to academia [such", "the list each likely contributed by a different community member,", "google the question and is asking for an opinion, which", "a shopping question, each of which my question does not", "negative of a connotation if we are going to use", "conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified it as not shopping. If we are", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is nearly identical in flavor to mine was", "> > \"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists of", "if we are going to use it to close questions", "[such as my question on #of attendees at academic conferences]", "include a \"for any reason in it\". Should we have", "follows > > \"List asking\" questions which seek a list", "of the list each likely contributed by a different community", "on meta does not seem to match my question. The", "> \"List asking\" questions which seek a list of objective", "entries of the list each likely contributed by a different", "should be more explicit and include a \"for any reason", "would be an equally valid yet incomplete part of the", "shopping.* The description of the list asking close reason could", "be more explicit and include a \"for any reason in", "something like as follows > > \"List asking\" questions which", "of which my question does not satisfy. It seems like", "does not satisfy. It seems like there are two very", "each answer would be an equally valid yet incomplete part", "> > I think shopping has too negative of a", "or seek an assessment or comparison of such, are off-topic", "[meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified it as not shopping. If we", "be a lot of disagreement as to whether questions of", "by a single user. Therefore it is difficult to upvote", "to receive a complete list/answer by a single user. Therefore", "receive a complete list/answer by a single user. Therefore it", "list of rankings for comparison. > > \"Shopping\" questions, which", "for a subjective list of rankings for comparison. > >", "because each answer would be an equally valid yet incomplete", "more explicit and include a \"for any reason in it\".", "journals, research topics or similar as an answer or seek", "form, regardless as to the reason one would want a", "to such questions. While such questions may be well researched", "type of question. > > > I think shopping has", "was closed for shopping. However, how shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on", "satisfy. It seems like there are two very different types/interpretations", "shopping. For example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is nearly identical in", "or comparison of such, are off-topic here > > >", "nearly identical in flavor to mine was reopened on Academia", "question on #of attendees at academic conferences] and (2) asking", "> > \"List asking\" questions which seek a list of", "it is difficult to upvote and downvote the partial answers", "type (1) are shopping. For example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is", "the reason one would want a list, the close reason", "closed for shopping. However, how shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta", "we are to say that any question that asks for", "There seems to be a lot of disagreement as to", "close questions of people who have demonstrated considerable research behind", "is because each answer would be an equally valid yet", "of individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, research topics or", "three possible characteristics of a shopping question, each of which", "list each likely contributed by a different community member, are", "may be well researched and on topic, other formats are", "how shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta does not seem to", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/88915/which-academic-conferences-have-more-4-000-attendees) was closed for shopping. However, how shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions)", "want a list, the close reason should be more explicit", "asking for a list of objective facts related to academia", "equally valid yet incomplete part of the complete list. Questions", "seems like there are two very different types/interpretations of shopping", "research topics or similar as an answer or seek an", "of people who have demonstrated considerable research behind their question.", "individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, research topics or similar", "have two close reasons list asking and shopping. The description", "a complete list/answer by a single user. Therefore it is", "it\". Should we have two close reasons list asking and", "like as follows > > \"List asking\" questions which seek", "list of objective facts, with entries of the list each", "While such questions may be well researched and on topic,", "or similar as an answer or seek an assessment or", "an equally valid yet incomplete part of the complete list.", "of such, are off-topic here > > > Note that", "to academia [such as my question on #of attendees at", "close reason could go something like as follows > >", "applied to (1) is a bit offensive, it implies the", "could go something like as follows > > \"List asking\"", "of rankings for comparison. > > \"Shopping\" questions, which seek", "different types/interpretations of shopping questions (1) asking for a list", "of disagreement as to whether questions of type (1) are", "seek an assessment or comparison of such, are off-topic here", "downvote the partial answers to such questions. While such questions", "is nearly identical in flavor to mine was reopened on", "which seek a list of objective facts, with entries of", "complete list/answer by a single user. Therefore it is difficult", "each likely contributed by a different community member, are not", "> > > I think shopping has too negative of", "and (2) asking for a subjective list of rankings for", "appropriate for this type of question.** > > > I", "word \"shopping\" applied to (1) is a bit offensive, it", "meta question I link to outlines three possible characteristics of", "comparison of such, are off-topic here > > > Note", "a lot of disagreement as to whether questions of type", "reason could go something like as follows > > \"List", "academic programs, publishers, journals, research topics or similar as an", "an answer or seek an assessment or comparison of such,", "I link to outlines three possible characteristics of a shopping", "too negative of a connotation if we are going to", "list asking close reason could go something like as follows", "not satisfy. It seems like there are two very different", "I think shopping has too negative of a connotation if", "> I think shopping has too negative of a connotation", "correct. There seems to be a lot of disagreement as", "simply google the question and is asking for an opinion,", "with entries of the list each likely contributed by a", "such questions may be well researched and on topic, other", "single user. Therefore it is difficult to upvote and downvote", "as to whether questions of type (1) are shopping. For", "any question that asks for an answer in list form,", "objective facts related to academia [such as my question on", "to (1) is a bit offensive, it implies the question", "and include a \"for any reason in it\". Should we", "question I link to outlines three possible characteristics of a", "questions, which seek recommendations or lists of individual universities, academic", "to whether questions of type (1) are shopping. For example,", "it implies the question asker didn't simply google the question", "asking for a subjective list of rankings for comparison. >", "well researched and on topic, other formats are more appropriate", "similar as an answer or seek an assessment or comparison", "are two very different types/interpretations of shopping questions (1) asking", "use it to close questions of people who have demonstrated", "a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified it as not shopping. If", "answer or seek an assessment or comparison of such, are", "(1) asking for a list of objective facts related to", "for an answer in list form, regardless as to the", "user. Therefore it is difficult to upvote and downvote the", "in list form, regardless as to the reason one would", "is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta does not seem to match my", "offensive, it implies the question asker didn't simply google the", "by a different community member, are not well suited for", "there are two very different types/interpretations of shopping questions (1)", "bit offensive, it implies the question asker didn't simply google", "programs, publishers, journals, research topics or similar as an answer", "an opinion, which is simply not correct. There seems to", "part of the complete list. Questions of this form are", "that any question that asks for an answer in list", "list asking and shopping. The description of the list asking", "questions which seek a list of objective facts, with entries", "subjective list of rankings for comparison. > > \"Shopping\" questions,", "we are going to use it to close questions of", "incomplete part of the complete list. Questions of this form", "didn't simply google the question and is asking for an", "has too negative of a connotation if we are going", "facts, with entries of the list each likely contributed by", "likely contributed by a different community member, are not well", "reopened on Academia Stack Exchange after a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which", "two close reasons list asking and shopping. The description of", "it as not shopping. If we are to say that", "such questions. While such questions may be well researched and", "answers to such questions. While such questions may be well", "an assessment or comparison of such, are off-topic here >", "assessment or comparison of such, are off-topic here > >", "Exchange after a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified it as not", "questions. *While such questions may be well researched and on", "However, how shopping is [described](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/2038/defining-shopping-questions) on meta does not seem", "identical in flavor to mine was reopened on Academia Stack", "Stack Exchange after a [meta conversation](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1808/why-was-this-question-closed-for-shopping) which classified it as", "answer in list form, regardless as to the reason one", "off-topic here > > > Note that the word \"shopping\"", "\"List asking\" questions which seek a list of objective facts,", "questions (1) asking for a list of objective facts related", "are shopping. For example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which is nearly identical", "list of objective facts related to academia [such as my", "for comparison. > > \"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or", "any reason in it\". Should we have two close reasons", "comparison. > > \"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists", "which classified it as not shopping. If we are to", "to use it to close questions of people who have", "the question asker didn't simply google the question and is", "two very different types/interpretations of shopping questions (1) asking for", "shopping has too negative of a connotation if we are", "that the word \"shopping\" applied to (1) is a bit", "of objective facts related to academia [such as my question", "this form are unlikely to receive a complete list/answer by", "on #of attendees at academic conferences] and (2) asking for", "reasons list asking* and shopping. The description of the list", "list. Questions of this form are unlikely to receive a", "are going to use it to close questions of people", "objective facts, with entries of the list each likely contributed", "of the list asking* close reason could go something like", "asks for an answer in list form, regardless as to", "asking* and shopping. The description of the list asking close", "academia [such as my question on #of attendees at academic", "universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, research topics or similar as", "a list of objective facts, with entries of the list", "of type (1) are shopping. For example, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/46914/list-of-2013-us-national-merit-scholars/46915#46915), which", "(2) asking for a subjective list of rankings for comparison." ]
[ "path - that are not always in line with other", "responsibilities, etc. find the time to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally", "the humanities. Is there a case for having a question", "for having a question like this which is specific to", "there a case for having a question like this which", "of a mathematician's research life - priorities, opportunities, teaching loads,", "specific context, but are probably less applicable to academia as", "was the right decision, but so be it.) The question", "be it.) The question has been edited significantly now, so", "the community's feelings are, on whether this was the right", "The question [How do academics with teaching responsibilities, etc. find", "career path - that are not always in line with", "teaching loads, likely career path - that are not always", "not always in line with other STEM subjects, let alone", "some features of a mathematician's research life - priorities, opportunities,", "question [How do academics with teaching responsibilities, etc. find the", "are some features of a mathematician's research life - priorities,", "which seemed useful/relevant in the specific context, but are probably", "My concern is that there are some features of a", "or not. My concern is that there are some features", "is that there are some features of a mathematician's research", "having a question like this which is specific to math(s),", "teaching responsibilities, etc. find the time to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was", "asked on mathoverflow in the context of the working life", "features of a mathematician's research life - priorities, opportunities, teaching", "this was the right move or not. My concern is", "that are not always in line with other STEM subjects,", "so that it is a generic question. I wondered what", "generic question. I wondered what the community's feelings are, on", "the working life of a professional mathematician, and was then", "community's feelings are, on whether this was the right move", "specific to math(s), or at least to STEM? There were", "now, so that it is a generic question. I wondered", "are not always in line with other STEM subjects, let", "STEM subjects, let alone what happens in the humanities. Is", "other STEM subjects, let alone what happens in the humanities.", "question. I wondered what the community's feelings are, on whether", "seemed useful/relevant in the specific context, but are probably less", "etc. find the time to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally asked", "the right move or not. My concern is that there", "to STEM? There were some initial answers by mathematicians which", "a question like this which is specific to math(s), or", "to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally asked on mathoverflow in the", "I wondered what the community's feelings are, on whether this", "(I am not wholly convinced that this was the right", "There were some initial answers by mathematicians which seemed useful/relevant", "a mathematician's research life - priorities, opportunities, teaching loads, likely", "The question has been edited significantly now, so that it", "some initial answers by mathematicians which seemed useful/relevant in the", "but are probably less applicable to academia as a whole.", "- priorities, opportunities, teaching loads, likely career path - that", "do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally asked on mathoverflow in the context", "am not wholly convinced that this was the right decision,", "decision, but so be it.) The question has been edited", "concern is that there are some features of a mathematician's", "what happens in the humanities. Is there a case for", "not wholly convinced that this was the right decision, but", "let alone what happens in the humanities. Is there a", "academics with teaching responsibilities, etc. find the time to do", "a professional mathematician, and was then migrated to academia.SE. (I", "the context of the working life of a professional mathematician,", "this was the right decision, but so be it.) The", "is a generic question. I wondered what the community's feelings", "in the humanities. Is there a case for having a", "a case for having a question like this which is", "originally asked on mathoverflow in the context of the working", "in line with other STEM subjects, let alone what happens", "math(s), or at least to STEM? There were some initial", "question like this which is specific to math(s), or at", "humanities. Is there a case for having a question like", "life - priorities, opportunities, teaching loads, likely career path -", "[How do academics with teaching responsibilities, etc. find the time", "there are some features of a mathematician's research life -", "research life - priorities, opportunities, teaching loads, likely career path", "that there are some features of a mathematician's research life", "in the specific context, but are probably less applicable to", "opportunities, teaching loads, likely career path - that are not", "whether this was the right move or not. My concern", "context, but are probably less applicable to academia as a", "it.) The question has been edited significantly now, so that", "to academia.SE. (I am not wholly convinced that this was", "always in line with other STEM subjects, let alone what", "useful/relevant in the specific context, but are probably less applicable", "priorities, opportunities, teaching loads, likely career path - that are", "line with other STEM subjects, let alone what happens in", "this which is specific to math(s), or at least to", "context of the working life of a professional mathematician, and", "migrated to academia.SE. (I am not wholly convinced that this", "the specific context, but are probably less applicable to academia", "edited significantly now, so that it is a generic question.", "professional mathematician, and was then migrated to academia.SE. (I am", "- that are not always in line with other STEM", "or at least to STEM? There were some initial answers", "the right decision, but so be it.) The question has", "with teaching responsibilities, etc. find the time to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/)", "loads, likely career path - that are not always in", "mathematicians which seemed useful/relevant in the specific context, but are", "academia.SE. (I am not wholly convinced that this was the", "with other STEM subjects, let alone what happens in the", "but so be it.) The question has been edited significantly", "case for having a question like this which is specific", "mathematician's research life - priorities, opportunities, teaching loads, likely career", "to math(s), or at least to STEM? There were some", "wondered what the community's feelings are, on whether this was", "least to STEM? There were some initial answers by mathematicians", "working life of a professional mathematician, and was then migrated", "alone what happens in the humanities. Is there a case", "question has been edited significantly now, so that it is", "on mathoverflow in the context of the working life of", "like this which is specific to math(s), or at least", "was then migrated to academia.SE. (I am not wholly convinced", "a generic question. I wondered what the community's feelings are,", "Is there a case for having a question like this", "and was then migrated to academia.SE. (I am not wholly", "wholly convinced that this was the right decision, but so", "research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally asked on mathoverflow in the context of", "which is specific to math(s), or at least to STEM?", "initial answers by mathematicians which seemed useful/relevant in the specific", "in the context of the working life of a professional", "what the community's feelings are, on whether this was the", "at least to STEM? There were some initial answers by", "it is a generic question. I wondered what the community's", "is specific to math(s), or at least to STEM? There", "on whether this was the right move or not. My", "right decision, but so be it.) The question has been", "were some initial answers by mathematicians which seemed useful/relevant in", "then migrated to academia.SE. (I am not wholly convinced that", "happens in the humanities. Is there a case for having", "significantly now, so that it is a generic question. I", "move or not. My concern is that there are some", "that this was the right decision, but so be it.)", "STEM? There were some initial answers by mathematicians which seemed", "answers by mathematicians which seemed useful/relevant in the specific context,", "of a professional mathematician, and was then migrated to academia.SE.", "was the right move or not. My concern is that", "the time to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally asked on mathoverflow", "not. My concern is that there are some features of", "was originally asked on mathoverflow in the context of the", "are, on whether this was the right move or not.", "that it is a generic question. I wondered what the", "so be it.) The question has been edited significantly now,", "been edited significantly now, so that it is a generic", "mathoverflow in the context of the working life of a", "right move or not. My concern is that there are", "mathematician, and was then migrated to academia.SE. (I am not", "subjects, let alone what happens in the humanities. Is there", "convinced that this was the right decision, but so be", "has been edited significantly now, so that it is a", "likely career path - that are not always in line", "do academics with teaching responsibilities, etc. find the time to", "feelings are, on whether this was the right move or", "of the working life of a professional mathematician, and was", "time to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally asked on mathoverflow in", "life of a professional mathematician, and was then migrated to", "by mathematicians which seemed useful/relevant in the specific context, but", "find the time to do research?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/89362/) was originally asked on" ]
[ "occurs. It would be different if it were an established", "got a lot of downvotes. That can happen, and my", "has not yet been closed. Jeesh! Granted, the question has", "an established participant who was asking something outrageous like, How", "small starting rep. It currently has a total negative score", "did once see an outrageous question posed by someone with", "negative voting occurs. It would be different if it were", "established participant who was asking something outrageous like, How can", "I take revenge on my competitor and steal his best", "can I take revenge on my competitor and steal his", "steal his best grad student -- or something like that.", "with a pretty good rep, that got a lot of", "question has problems! But it's hard for people to learn", "written 13 hours ago and has not yet been closed.", "Friends, can't we be reasonable and stop downvoting such a", "instead focus our efforts on closing the question swiftly and", "Jeesh! Granted, the question has problems! But it's hard for", "someone with a pretty good rep, that got a lot", "currently has a total negative score of -7, and four", "competitor and steal his best grad student -- or something", "question posed by someone with a pretty good rep, that", "just cast). It was written 13 hours ago and has", "voting occurs. It would be different if it were an", "revenge on my competitor and steal his best grad student", "gets to -3, and instead focus our efforts on closing", "and steal his best grad student -- or something like", "and instead focus our efforts on closing the question swiftly", "But it's hard for people to learn how to pose", "happen, and my point is that Nikki's question is not", "a newcomer with a small starting rep. It currently has", "it's hard for people to learn how to pose better", "problems! But it's hard for people to learn how to", "stop downvoting such a question when it gets to -3,", "my suggested floor to -4 based on the answer by", "is not in that realm. Friends, can't we be reasonable", "our efforts on closing the question swiftly and painlessly? Edit:", "close votes (including the one I just cast). It was", "of downvotes. That can happen, and my point is that", "votes (including the one I just cast). It was written", "ago and has not yet been closed. Jeesh! Granted, the", "questions when this level of negative voting occurs. It would", "grad student -- or something like that. I did once", "when it gets to -3, and instead focus our efforts", "newcomer with a small starting rep. It currently has a", "was asking something outrageous like, How can I take revenge", "something outrageous like, How can I take revenge on my", "that realm. Friends, can't we be reasonable and stop downvoting", "can't we be reasonable and stop downvoting such a question", "that. I did once see an outrageous question posed by", "outrageous question posed by someone with a pretty good rep,", "and painlessly? Edit: I will change my suggested floor to", "cast). It was written 13 hours ago and has not", "13 hours ago and has not yet been closed. Jeesh!", "level of negative voting occurs. It would be different if", "a question when it gets to -3, and instead focus", "with a small starting rep. It currently has a total", "rep, that got a lot of downvotes. That can happen,", "or something like that. I did once see an outrageous", "student -- or something like that. I did once see", "I did once see an outrageous question posed by someone", "lot of downvotes. That can happen, and my point is", "outrageous like, How can I take revenge on my competitor", "who was asking something outrageous like, How can I take", "by a newcomer with a small starting rep. It currently", "written by a newcomer with a small starting rep. It", "rep. It currently has a total negative score of -7,", "Here's a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/90483/32436) written by a newcomer with a small", "was written 13 hours ago and has not yet been", "closed. Jeesh! Granted, the question has problems! But it's hard", "pose better questions when this level of negative voting occurs.", "we be reasonable and stop downvoting such a question when", "efforts on closing the question swiftly and painlessly? Edit: I", "suggested floor to -4 based on the answer by @strongbad.", "one I just cast). It was written 13 hours ago", "has a total negative score of -7, and four close", "Edit: I will change my suggested floor to -4 based", "to -3, and instead focus our efforts on closing the", "yet been closed. Jeesh! Granted, the question has problems! But", "can happen, and my point is that Nikki's question is", "pretty good rep, that got a lot of downvotes. That", "I just cast). It was written 13 hours ago and", "score of -7, and four close votes (including the one", "a lot of downvotes. That can happen, and my point", "It would be different if it were an established participant", "downvotes. That can happen, and my point is that Nikki's", "starting rep. It currently has a total negative score of", "that got a lot of downvotes. That can happen, and", "to pose better questions when this level of negative voting", "total negative score of -7, and four close votes (including", "hard for people to learn how to pose better questions", "realm. Friends, can't we be reasonable and stop downvoting such", "focus our efforts on closing the question swiftly and painlessly?", "It currently has a total negative score of -7, and", "not yet been closed. Jeesh! Granted, the question has problems!", "the one I just cast). It was written 13 hours", "be reasonable and stop downvoting such a question when it", "question when it gets to -3, and instead focus our", "and has not yet been closed. Jeesh! Granted, the question", "my point is that Nikki's question is not in that", "four close votes (including the one I just cast). It", "How can I take revenge on my competitor and steal", "his best grad student -- or something like that. I", "people to learn how to pose better questions when this", "in that realm. Friends, can't we be reasonable and stop", "such a question when it gets to -3, and instead", "and my point is that Nikki's question is not in", "best grad student -- or something like that. I did", "see an outrageous question posed by someone with a pretty", "better questions when this level of negative voting occurs. It", "it gets to -3, and instead focus our efforts on", "a pretty good rep, that got a lot of downvotes.", "my competitor and steal his best grad student -- or", "Granted, the question has problems! But it's hard for people", "change my suggested floor to -4 based on the answer", "(including the one I just cast). It was written 13", "an outrageous question posed by someone with a pretty good", "question is not in that realm. Friends, can't we be", "the question swiftly and painlessly? Edit: I will change my", "I will change my suggested floor to -4 based on", "downvoting such a question when it gets to -3, and", "closing the question swiftly and painlessly? Edit: I will change", "good rep, that got a lot of downvotes. That can", "not in that realm. Friends, can't we be reasonable and", "will change my suggested floor to -4 based on the", "this level of negative voting occurs. It would be different", "that Nikki's question is not in that realm. Friends, can't", "hours ago and has not yet been closed. Jeesh! Granted,", "a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/90483/32436) written by a newcomer with a small starting", "been closed. Jeesh! Granted, the question has problems! But it's", "once see an outrageous question posed by someone with a", "of -7, and four close votes (including the one I", "to learn how to pose better questions when this level", "a small starting rep. It currently has a total negative", "a total negative score of -7, and four close votes", "painlessly? Edit: I will change my suggested floor to -4", "were an established participant who was asking something outrageous like,", "reasonable and stop downvoting such a question when it gets", "and four close votes (including the one I just cast).", "-- or something like that. I did once see an", "be different if it were an established participant who was", "different if it were an established participant who was asking", "and stop downvoting such a question when it gets to", "-7, and four close votes (including the one I just", "like, How can I take revenge on my competitor and", "has problems! But it's hard for people to learn how", "something like that. I did once see an outrageous question", "like that. I did once see an outrageous question posed", "posed by someone with a pretty good rep, that got", "by someone with a pretty good rep, that got a", "That can happen, and my point is that Nikki's question", "swiftly and painlessly? Edit: I will change my suggested floor", "question swiftly and painlessly? Edit: I will change my suggested", "on closing the question swiftly and painlessly? Edit: I will", "if it were an established participant who was asking something", "the question has problems! But it's hard for people to", "is that Nikki's question is not in that realm. Friends,", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/90483/32436) written by a newcomer with a small starting rep.", "would be different if it were an established participant who", "learn how to pose better questions when this level of", "on my competitor and steal his best grad student --", "for people to learn how to pose better questions when", "asking something outrageous like, How can I take revenge on", "of negative voting occurs. It would be different if it", "-3, and instead focus our efforts on closing the question", "Nikki's question is not in that realm. Friends, can't we", "it were an established participant who was asking something outrageous", "how to pose better questions when this level of negative", "participant who was asking something outrageous like, How can I", "point is that Nikki's question is not in that realm.", "when this level of negative voting occurs. It would be", "It was written 13 hours ago and has not yet", "take revenge on my competitor and steal his best grad", "negative score of -7, and four close votes (including the" ]
[ "doesn't really give an answer on the question OP asked.", "post. I do understand the reasoning, as the sarcasm didn't", "rules... This made me wonder how strict one should be", "made me wonder how strict one should be when evaluating", "voted to delete the answer for being not an answer.", "But I'll be honest. If this was on stackoverflow, I'd", "an answer on the question OP asked. Which was how", "anything and last portion of that post looks like an", "mine). On SO this should be a comment, not an", "house, different rules... This made me wonder how strict one", "(emphasis mine). On SO this should be a comment, not", "answers. Should it specifically answer the actual question asked, or", "question OP asked. Which was how to solve the issue", "this was on stackoverflow, I'd have voted to delete the", "If this was on stackoverflow, I'd have voted to delete", "be when evaluating answers. Should it specifically answer the actual", "answer. But I'll be honest. If this was on stackoverflow,", "answer for being not an answer. Especially because even after", "answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is edited by the mod Eykanal, removing", "Eykanal, removing over half of the (I admit, quite funny)", "as the sarcasm didn't add anything and last portion of", "an answer. But different house, different rules... This made me", "how to solve the issue (emphasis mine). On SO this", "be honest. If this was on stackoverflow, I'd have voted", "me when seeing following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is edited by", "to leave a more general comment on the nature of", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is edited by the mod Eykanal, removing over", "on stackoverflow, I'd have voted to delete the answer for", "to solve the issue (emphasis mine). On SO this should", "after removing the sarcasm part it doesn't really give an", "the question OP asked. Which was how to solve the", "answer on the question OP asked. Which was how to", "over half of the (I admit, quite funny) post. I", "an answer. Especially because even after removing the sarcasm part", "and last portion of that post looks like an answer.", "is it allowed to leave a more general comment on", "the sarcasm part it doesn't really give an answer on", "the answer for being not an answer. Especially because even", "quite funny) post. I do understand the reasoning, as the", "the sarcasm didn't add anything and last portion of that", "issue (emphasis mine). On SO this should be a comment,", "edited by the mod Eykanal, removing over half of the", "Which was how to solve the issue (emphasis mine). On", "sarcasm didn't add anything and last portion of that post", "came up to me when seeing following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This", "up to me when seeing following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is", "following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is edited by the mod Eykanal,", "answer. Especially because even after removing the sarcasm part it", "is edited by the mod Eykanal, removing over half of", "answer. But different house, different rules... This made me wonder", "give an answer on the question OP asked. Which was", "do understand the reasoning, as the sarcasm didn't add anything", "specifically answer the actual question asked, or is it allowed", "this should be a comment, not an answer. But different", "honest. If this was on stackoverflow, I'd have voted to", "by the mod Eykanal, removing over half of the (I", "asked, or is it allowed to leave a more general", "admit, quite funny) post. I do understand the reasoning, as", "part it doesn't really give an answer on the question", "like an answer. But I'll be honest. If this was", "it doesn't really give an answer on the question OP", "because even after removing the sarcasm part it doesn't really", "the mod Eykanal, removing over half of the (I admit,", "me wonder how strict one should be when evaluating answers.", "reasoning, as the sarcasm didn't add anything and last portion", "stackoverflow, I'd have voted to delete the answer for being", "didn't add anything and last portion of that post looks", "wonder how strict one should be when evaluating answers. Should", "should be when evaluating answers. Should it specifically answer the", "OP asked. Which was how to solve the issue (emphasis", "how strict one should be when evaluating answers. Should it", "Should it specifically answer the actual question asked, or is", "when seeing following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is edited by the", "removing the sarcasm part it doesn't really give an answer", "was how to solve the issue (emphasis mine). On SO", "answer the actual question asked, or is it allowed to", "On SO this should be a comment, not an answer.", "or is it allowed to leave a more general comment", "half of the (I admit, quite funny) post. I do", "sarcasm part it doesn't really give an answer on the", "have voted to delete the answer for being not an", "understand the reasoning, as the sarcasm didn't add anything and", "comment, not an answer. But different house, different rules... This", "a more general comment on the nature of the problem?", "really give an answer on the question OP asked. Which", "I'll be honest. If this was on stackoverflow, I'd have", "that post looks like an answer. But I'll be honest.", "not an answer. Especially because even after removing the sarcasm", "it specifically answer the actual question asked, or is it", "This made me wonder how strict one should be when", "Especially because even after removing the sarcasm part it doesn't", "add anything and last portion of that post looks like", "on the question OP asked. Which was how to solve", "even after removing the sarcasm part it doesn't really give", "funny) post. I do understand the reasoning, as the sarcasm", "actual question asked, or is it allowed to leave a", "different rules... This made me wonder how strict one should", "question came up to me when seeing following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774>", "a comment, not an answer. But different house, different rules...", "post looks like an answer. But I'll be honest. If", "This is edited by the mod Eykanal, removing over half", "I do understand the reasoning, as the sarcasm didn't add", "not an answer. But different house, different rules... This made", "question asked, or is it allowed to leave a more", "removing over half of the (I admit, quite funny) post.", "for being not an answer. Especially because even after removing", "to me when seeing following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is edited", "the issue (emphasis mine). On SO this should be a", "portion of that post looks like an answer. But I'll", "I'd have voted to delete the answer for being not", "to delete the answer for being not an answer. Especially", "was on stackoverflow, I'd have voted to delete the answer", "But different house, different rules... This made me wonder how", "mod Eykanal, removing over half of the (I admit, quite", "evaluating answers. Should it specifically answer the actual question asked,", "solve the issue (emphasis mine). On SO this should be", "be a comment, not an answer. But different house, different", "the actual question asked, or is it allowed to leave", "being not an answer. Especially because even after removing the", "the reasoning, as the sarcasm didn't add anything and last", "the (I admit, quite funny) post. I do understand the", "it allowed to leave a more general comment on the", "last portion of that post looks like an answer. But", "asked. Which was how to solve the issue (emphasis mine).", "delete the answer for being not an answer. Especially because", "seeing following answer: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/90807/74774> This is edited by the mod", "the question came up to me when seeing following answer:", "SO this should be a comment, not an answer. But", "when evaluating answers. Should it specifically answer the actual question", "should be a comment, not an answer. But different house,", "strict one should be when evaluating answers. Should it specifically", "leave a more general comment on the nature of the", "one should be when evaluating answers. Should it specifically answer", "of that post looks like an answer. But I'll be", "(I admit, quite funny) post. I do understand the reasoning,", "different house, different rules... This made me wonder how strict", "of the (I admit, quite funny) post. I do understand", "an answer. But I'll be honest. If this was on", "allowed to leave a more general comment on the nature", "looks like an answer. But I'll be honest. If this" ]
[ "the answer apparent, but the OP obviously didn't, and came", "One of the responses' fist paragraph was the following: >", "so, why? I think this sets a pretty crappy precedent.", "papers (as will they) and save you the trouble of", "> Is this type of thing... allowed? If so, why?", "I won't replicate here; I flagged the post, but will", "and my reviewers' time by desk rejecting your papers as", "crappy precedent. (There are also some good points mentioned in", "[How to withdraw an under review manuscript from a journal", "that response that I won't replicate here; I flagged the", "question, [How to withdraw an under review manuscript from a", "following: > > Editors are reading these sites too. Like", "also some good points mentioned in the comments to that", "you the trouble of wasting me and my reviewers' time", "was the following: > > Editors are reading these sites", "list serve I'm included in. I'll be keeping an eye", "me and the editor who posted this link on a", "why? I think this sets a pretty crappy precedent. (There", "I'll be keeping an eye out for your papers (as", "the editor who posted this link on a large editor", "Is this type of thing... allowed? If so, why? I", "Editors are reading these sites too. Like me and the", "in the comments to that response that I won't replicate", "rejecting your papers as they come in. > > >", "think this sets a pretty crappy precedent. (There are also", "factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker is told pretty clearly—in multiple ways—that it's", "me and my reviewers' time by desk rejecting your papers", "when you decide you want to submit to another journal", "wasting me and my reviewers' time by desk rejecting your", "the following: > > Editors are reading these sites too.", "be keeping an eye out for your papers (as will", "fist paragraph was the following: > > Editors are reading", "told pretty clearly—in multiple ways—that it's totally unacceptable to withdraw", "replicate here; I flagged the post, but will [reluctantly!] unflag", "manuscript from a journal when you decide you want to", "serve I'm included in. I'll be keeping an eye out", "Stack Exchange to seek some help. One of the responses'", "precedent. (There are also some good points mentioned in the", "I flagged the post, but will [reluctantly!] unflag it if", "to that response that I won't replicate here; I flagged", "Like me and the editor who posted this link on", "sets a pretty crappy precedent. (There are also some good", "good points mentioned in the comments to that response that", "desk rejecting your papers as they come in. > >", "withdraw your paper for this reason. Indeed, some might think", "you want to submit to another journal with a higher", "flagged the post, but will [reluctantly!] unflag it if the", "withdraw an under review manuscript from a journal when you", "(There are also some good points mentioned in the comments", "are also some good points mentioned in the comments to", "> > Editors are reading these sites too. Like me", "pretty crappy precedent. (There are also some good points mentioned", "want to submit to another journal with a higher impact", "link on a large editor list serve I'm included in.", "If so, why? I think this sets a pretty crappy", "some good points mentioned in the comments to that response", "and came to the Academia Stack Exchange to seek some", "of thing... allowed? If so, why? I think this sets", "type of thing... allowed? If so, why? I think this", "[reluctantly!] unflag it if the consensus is that this is", "Academia Stack Exchange to seek some help. One of the", "to withdraw your paper for this reason. Indeed, some might", "some might think the answer apparent, but the OP obviously", "unacceptable to withdraw your paper for this reason. Indeed, some", "the Academia Stack Exchange to seek some help. One of", "the trouble of wasting me and my reviewers' time by", "pretty clearly—in multiple ways—that it's totally unacceptable to withdraw your", "will they) and save you the trouble of wasting me", "of wasting me and my reviewers' time by desk rejecting", "seek some help. One of the responses' fist paragraph was", "are reading these sites too. Like me and the editor", "but the OP obviously didn't, and came to the Academia", "I'm included in. I'll be keeping an eye out for", "who posted this link on a large editor list serve", "if the consensus is that this is allowed, and ok.)", "came to the Academia Stack Exchange to seek some help.", "from a journal when you decide you want to submit", "large editor list serve I'm included in. I'll be keeping", "out for your papers (as will they) and save you", "time by desk rejecting your papers as they come in.", "the post, but will [reluctantly!] unflag it if the consensus", "obviously didn't, and came to the Academia Stack Exchange to", "help. One of the responses' fist paragraph was the following:", "clearly—in multiple ways—that it's totally unacceptable to withdraw your paper", "Exchange to seek some help. One of the responses' fist", "save you the trouble of wasting me and my reviewers'", "editor who posted this link on a large editor list", "to submit to another journal with a higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa),", "these sites too. Like me and the editor who posted", "they) and save you the trouble of wasting me and", "In this question, [How to withdraw an under review manuscript", "you decide you want to submit to another journal with", "reading these sites too. Like me and the editor who", "apparent, but the OP obviously didn't, and came to the", "this link on a large editor list serve I'm included", "keeping an eye out for your papers (as will they)", "submit to another journal with a higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the", "in. I'll be keeping an eye out for your papers", "points mentioned in the comments to that response that I", "it's totally unacceptable to withdraw your paper for this reason.", "and the editor who posted this link on a large", "this type of thing... allowed? If so, why? I think", "by desk rejecting your papers as they come in. >", "for this reason. Indeed, some might think the answer apparent,", "your papers as they come in. > > > Is", "response that I won't replicate here; I flagged the post,", "the responses' fist paragraph was the following: > > Editors", "included in. I'll be keeping an eye out for your", "> Editors are reading these sites too. Like me and", "journal when you decide you want to submit to another", "> > > Is this type of thing... allowed? If", "didn't, and came to the Academia Stack Exchange to seek", "totally unacceptable to withdraw your paper for this reason. Indeed,", "(as will they) and save you the trouble of wasting", "the asker is told pretty clearly—in multiple ways—that it's totally", "but will [reluctantly!] unflag it if the consensus is that", "paper for this reason. Indeed, some might think the answer", "to seek some help. One of the responses' fist paragraph", "for your papers (as will they) and save you the", "I think this sets a pretty crappy precedent. (There are", "will [reluctantly!] unflag it if the consensus is that this", "a journal when you decide you want to submit to", "think the answer apparent, but the OP obviously didn't, and", "the OP obviously didn't, and came to the Academia Stack", "OP obviously didn't, and came to the Academia Stack Exchange", "as they come in. > > > Is this type", "answer apparent, but the OP obviously didn't, and came to", "a large editor list serve I'm included in. I'll be", "journal with a higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker is told", "in. > > > Is this type of thing... allowed?", "ways—that it's totally unacceptable to withdraw your paper for this", "Indeed, some might think the answer apparent, but the OP", "this reason. Indeed, some might think the answer apparent, but", "eye out for your papers (as will they) and save", "another journal with a higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker is", "is told pretty clearly—in multiple ways—that it's totally unacceptable to", "a pretty crappy precedent. (There are also some good points", "and save you the trouble of wasting me and my", "on a large editor list serve I'm included in. I'll", "it if the consensus is that this is allowed, and", "the comments to that response that I won't replicate here;", "under review manuscript from a journal when you decide you", "multiple ways—that it's totally unacceptable to withdraw your paper for", "editor list serve I'm included in. I'll be keeping an", "my reviewers' time by desk rejecting your papers as they", "review manuscript from a journal when you decide you want", "mentioned in the comments to that response that I won't", "that I won't replicate here; I flagged the post, but", "> > Is this type of thing... allowed? If so,", "decide you want to submit to another journal with a", "with a higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker is told pretty", "higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker is told pretty clearly—in multiple", "a higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker is told pretty clearly—in", "sites too. Like me and the editor who posted this", "to another journal with a higher impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker", "might think the answer apparent, but the OP obviously didn't,", "an under review manuscript from a journal when you decide", "of the responses' fist paragraph was the following: > >", "paragraph was the following: > > Editors are reading these", "posted this link on a large editor list serve I'm", "too. Like me and the editor who posted this link", "they come in. > > > Is this type of", "thing... allowed? If so, why? I think this sets a", "your papers (as will they) and save you the trouble", "won't replicate here; I flagged the post, but will [reluctantly!]", "to the Academia Stack Exchange to seek some help. One", "papers as they come in. > > > Is this", "unflag it if the consensus is that this is allowed,", "asker is told pretty clearly—in multiple ways—that it's totally unacceptable", "trouble of wasting me and my reviewers' time by desk", "your paper for this reason. Indeed, some might think the", "impact factor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90898/how-to-withdraw-an-under-review-manuscript-from-a-journal-when-you-decide-you-wa), the asker is told pretty clearly—in multiple ways—that", "here; I flagged the post, but will [reluctantly!] unflag it", "responses' fist paragraph was the following: > > Editors are", "reason. Indeed, some might think the answer apparent, but the", "some help. One of the responses' fist paragraph was the", "allowed? If so, why? I think this sets a pretty", "to withdraw an under review manuscript from a journal when", "post, but will [reluctantly!] unflag it if the consensus is", "this sets a pretty crappy precedent. (There are also some", "an eye out for your papers (as will they) and", "come in. > > > Is this type of thing...", "reviewers' time by desk rejecting your papers as they come", "this question, [How to withdraw an under review manuscript from", "comments to that response that I won't replicate here; I" ]
[ "other SE sites should not be taken into consideration when", "member of another SE site, where they possess, say, review", "review privileges and know the general gist of SE very", "implement this would be to use a formula based on", "this is a meta meta question, but I wonder whether", "votes, for example. Consider, for the sake of argument, a", "academic and also a high-rep member of another SE site,", "and know the general gist of SE very well. One", "say Academia SE rep + 10% of rep elsewhere on", "reputation on other SE sites should not be taken into", "a long serving academic and also a high-rep member of", "member of Academia SE who is a long serving academic", "close votes, for example. Consider, for the sake of argument,", "who is a long serving academic and also a high-rep", "serving academic and also a high-rep member of another SE", "site, where they possess, say, review privileges and know the", "to use a formula based on a combination of SE", "into consideration when granting certain privileges, such as those to", "they possess, say, review privileges and know the general gist", "example. Consider, for the sake of argument, a relatively new", "those to review close votes, for example. Consider, for the", "and reputation on other SE sites should not be taken", "know the general gist of SE very well. One way", "SE very well. One way to implement this would be", "a combination of SE sites, say Academia SE rep +", "of Academia SE who is a long serving academic and", "sites, say Academia SE rep + 10% of rep elsewhere", "wonder whether experience and reputation on other SE sites should", "the sake of argument, a relatively new member of Academia", "for example. Consider, for the sake of argument, a relatively", "a formula based on a combination of SE sites, say", "of argument, a relatively new member of Academia SE who", "general gist of SE very well. One way to implement", "not be taken into consideration when granting certain privileges, such", "meta meta question, but I wonder whether experience and reputation", "when granting certain privileges, such as those to review close", "is a meta meta question, but I wonder whether experience", "a high-rep member of another SE site, where they possess,", "Academia SE rep + 10% of rep elsewhere on SE.", "on other SE sites should not be taken into consideration", "taken into consideration when granting certain privileges, such as those", "where they possess, say, review privileges and know the general", "as those to review close votes, for example. Consider, for", "consideration when granting certain privileges, such as those to review", "also a high-rep member of another SE site, where they", "way to implement this would be to use a formula", "should not be taken into consideration when granting certain privileges,", "argument, a relatively new member of Academia SE who is", "such as those to review close votes, for example. Consider,", "and also a high-rep member of another SE site, where", "granting certain privileges, such as those to review close votes,", "this would be to use a formula based on a", "a relatively new member of Academia SE who is a", "certain privileges, such as those to review close votes, for", "SE sites should not be taken into consideration when granting", "Academia SE who is a long serving academic and also", "of SE very well. One way to implement this would", "but I wonder whether experience and reputation on other SE", "combination of SE sites, say Academia SE rep + 10%", "high-rep member of another SE site, where they possess, say,", "the general gist of SE very well. One way to", "be to use a formula based on a combination of", "possess, say, review privileges and know the general gist of", "for the sake of argument, a relatively new member of", "SE site, where they possess, say, review privileges and know", "of SE sites, say Academia SE rep + 10% of", "of another SE site, where they possess, say, review privileges", "to review close votes, for example. Consider, for the sake", "privileges, such as those to review close votes, for example.", "a meta meta question, but I wonder whether experience and", "very well. One way to implement this would be to", "whether experience and reputation on other SE sites should not", "I wonder whether experience and reputation on other SE sites", "formula based on a combination of SE sites, say Academia", "privileges and know the general gist of SE very well.", "new member of Academia SE who is a long serving", "another SE site, where they possess, say, review privileges and", "sake of argument, a relatively new member of Academia SE", "be taken into consideration when granting certain privileges, such as", "is a long serving academic and also a high-rep member", "Consider, for the sake of argument, a relatively new member", "SE sites, say Academia SE rep + 10% of rep", "long serving academic and also a high-rep member of another", "One way to implement this would be to use a", "Perhaps this is a meta meta question, but I wonder", "sites should not be taken into consideration when granting certain", "review close votes, for example. Consider, for the sake of", "gist of SE very well. One way to implement this", "to implement this would be to use a formula based", "experience and reputation on other SE sites should not be", "question, but I wonder whether experience and reputation on other", "say, review privileges and know the general gist of SE", "meta question, but I wonder whether experience and reputation on", "would be to use a formula based on a combination", "SE who is a long serving academic and also a", "on a combination of SE sites, say Academia SE rep", "based on a combination of SE sites, say Academia SE", "relatively new member of Academia SE who is a long", "use a formula based on a combination of SE sites,", "well. One way to implement this would be to use" ]
[ "Proposed text of a custom close reason * A description", "to know the usage of the custom close reasons, [usage", "[answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1499/929), I think a discussion of our custom close reasons", "reasons. If we want more we would have to ask/beg", "reason * A description of the kind of questions it", "on from this [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1499/929), I think a discussion of our", "team to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us. While it would be", "examples to demonstrate the need for this close reason ", "close reasons would be helpful. We can currently only have", "our custom close reasons would be helpful. We can currently", "to have: Proposed text of a custom close reason", "custom close reasons would be helpful. We can currently only", "would be helpful. We can currently only have 3 custom", "the need for this close reason * Links to any", "have 3 custom close reasons. If we want more we", "[create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us. While it would be desirable to", "reason * Links to any discussion threads on meta relevant", "Links to any discussion threads on meta relevant to this", "helpful. We can currently only have 3 custom close reasons.", "this close reason * Links to any discussion threads on", "a custom close reason * A description of the kind", "of the kind of questions it would apply to ", "unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea for each answer to have: Proposed", "we want more we would have to ask/beg the SE", "close reason * Links to any discussion threads on meta", "this [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1499/929), I think a discussion of our custom close", "from this [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1499/929), I think a discussion of our custom", "us. While it would be desirable to know the usage", "more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us. While it would be desirable to know", "be helpful. We can currently only have 3 custom close", "of our custom close reasons would be helpful. We can", "The idea for each answer to have: * Proposed text", "custom close reasons. If we want more we would have", "questions it would apply to * Some examples to demonstrate", "the custom close reasons, [usage data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea", "each answer to have: * Proposed text of a custom", "would be desirable to know the usage of the custom", "to any discussion threads on meta relevant to this close", "* Links to any discussion threads on meta relevant to", "usage of the custom close reasons, [usage data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons).", "While it would be desirable to know the usage of", "kind of questions it would apply to * Some examples", "currently only have 3 custom close reasons. If we want", "of a custom close reason * A description of the", "idea for each answer to have: * Proposed text of", "think a discussion of our custom close reasons would be", "close reason * A description of the kind of questions", "custom close reasons, [usage data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea for", "to demonstrate the need for this close reason * Links", "Some examples to demonstrate the need for this close reason", "A description of the kind of questions it would apply", "close reasons, [usage data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea for each", "have: * Proposed text of a custom close reason ", "answer to have: Proposed text of a custom close", "the kind of questions it would apply to * Some", "only have 3 custom close reasons. If we want more", "reasons would be helpful. We can currently only have 3", "we would have to ask/beg the SE team to [create", "I think a discussion of our custom close reasons would", "We can currently only have 3 custom close reasons. If", "to ask/beg the SE team to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us.", "would apply to * Some examples to demonstrate the need", "have to ask/beg the SE team to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for", "Following on from this [answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1499/929), I think a discussion of", "it would apply to * Some examples to demonstrate the", "* A description of the kind of questions it would", "SE team to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us. While it would", "a discussion of our custom close reasons would be helpful.", "are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea for each answer to have: ", "the SE team to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us. While it", "need for this close reason Links to any discussion", "the usage of the custom close reasons, [usage data are", "of questions it would apply to * Some examples to", "to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us. While it would be desirable", "discussion of our custom close reasons would be helpful. We", "custom close reason * A description of the kind of", "3 custom close reasons. If we want more we would", "reasons, [usage data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea for each answer", "* Proposed text of a custom close reason * A", "description of the kind of questions it would apply to", "text of a custom close reason * A description of", "to * Some examples to demonstrate the need for this", "* Some examples to demonstrate the need for this close", "can currently only have 3 custom close reasons. If we", "for this close reason * Links to any discussion threads", "desirable to know the usage of the custom close reasons,", "If we want more we would have to ask/beg the", "it would be desirable to know the usage of the", "for us. While it would be desirable to know the", "[usage data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea for each answer to", "more we would have to ask/beg the SE team to", "data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The idea for each answer to have:", "ask/beg the SE team to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please) for us. While", "any discussion threads on meta relevant to this close reason", "want more we would have to ask/beg the SE team", "know the usage of the custom close reasons, [usage data", "apply to * Some examples to demonstrate the need for", "would have to ask/beg the SE team to [create more](https://meta.askubuntu.com/questions/6994/can-we-have-more-than-3-custom-close-reasons-pretty-please)", "demonstrate the need for this close reason * Links to", "close reasons. If we want more we would have to", "be desirable to know the usage of the custom close", "for each answer to have: * Proposed text of a", "of the custom close reasons, [usage data are unavailable](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/194378/how-can-i-search-for-custom-off-topic-close-reasons). The" ]
[ "give their best in answering the questions from corners of", "upvote of a comment. This will keep the users entertained", "there are no points associated with the comments on the", "motivated to give their best in answering the questions from", "* Though comments get many upvotes, no points are being", "5 upvotes. * Award a bronze or silver or gold", "the ideas mentioned in the comments and those answers keep", "just combine the ideas mentioned in the comments and those", "for the new members of academia.SE site. What could possibly", "by increasing the points of the user. * Though comments", "the user. * Though comments get many upvotes, no points", "* Award some point (nonzero) to the user with a", "point (nonzero) to the user with a comment with 5", "comments get many upvotes, no points are being awarded to", "for each upvote of a comment. This will keep the", "answers have some points associated. However, there are no points", "keep getting upvotes there by increasing the points of the", "of the questions and answers have some points associated. However,", "combine the ideas mentioned in the comments and those answers", "In academia.SE the upvotes of the questions and answers have", "many upvotes, no points are being awarded to the user.", "site. What could possibly be done? (any one of the", "* Award a bronze or silver or gold reputation badge", "points associated. However, there are no points associated with the", "Award some point (nonzero) to the user with a comment", "and answers have some points associated. However, there are no", "possibly be done? (any one of the following would do.)", "each upvote of a comment. This will keep the users", "academia.SE site. What could possibly be done? (any one of", "have some points associated. However, there are no points associated", "no points associated with the comments on the questions or", "the user with a comment with 5 upvotes. * Award", "comment. This will keep the users entertained and motivated to", "Award at least 1 point for each upvote of a", "academia.SE the upvotes of the questions and answers have some", "What could possibly be done? (any one of the following", "(any one of the following would do.) * Award at", "least 1 point for each upvote of a comment. This", "(nonzero) to the user with a comment with 5 upvotes.", "some point (nonzero) to the user with a comment with", "the answers. Why am I asking this question? * Few", "best in answering the questions from corners of the world.", "are being awarded to the user. * This is demotivating", "points associated with the comments on the questions or the", "of academia.SE site. What could possibly be done? (any one", "corners of the world. * Award some point (nonzero) to", "is demotivating for the new members of academia.SE site. What", "the questions and answers have some points associated. However, there", "this question? * Few answers just combine the ideas mentioned", "with a comment with 5 upvotes. * Award a bronze", "points are being awarded to the user. * This is", "questions from corners of the world. * Award some point", "some points associated. However, there are no points associated with", "of a comment. This will keep the users entertained and", "1 point for each upvote of a comment. This will", "asking this question? * Few answers just combine the ideas", "will keep the users entertained and motivated to give their", "there by increasing the points of the user. * Though", "associated. However, there are no points associated with the comments", "or the answers. Why am I asking this question? ", "of the world. Award some point (nonzero) to the", "comments and those answers keep getting upvotes there by increasing", "awarded to the user. * This is demotivating for the", "upvotes there by increasing the points of the user. ", "comments on the questions or the answers. Why am I", "with the comments on the questions or the answers. Why", "and those answers keep getting upvotes there by increasing the", "the points of the user. Though comments get many", "on the questions or the answers. Why am I asking", "one of the following would do.) * Award at least", "with 5 upvotes. * Award a bronze or silver or", "the questions or the answers. Why am I asking this", "be done? (any one of the following would do.) ", "demotivating for the new members of academia.SE site. What could", "gold reputation badge based on the number of upvotes on", "of the user. Though comments get many upvotes, no", "would do.) * Award at least 1 point for each", "the comments on the questions or the answers. Why am", "no points are being awarded to the user. * This", "the upvotes of the questions and answers have some points", "This is demotivating for the new members of academia.SE site.", "do.) * Award at least 1 point for each upvote", "to the user with a comment with 5 upvotes. ", "a comment with 5 upvotes. Award a bronze or", "am I asking this question? * Few answers just combine", "following would do.) * Award at least 1 point for", "Why am I asking this question? * Few answers just", "getting upvotes there by increasing the points of the user.", "the users entertained and motivated to give their best in", "Few answers just combine the ideas mentioned in the comments", "user. * Though comments get many upvotes, no points are", "from corners of the world. * Award some point (nonzero)", "Award a bronze or silver or gold reputation badge based", "This will keep the users entertained and motivated to give", "to the user. * This is demotivating for the new", "those answers keep getting upvotes there by increasing the points", "keep the users entertained and motivated to give their best", "in the comments and those answers keep getting upvotes there", "upvotes, no points are being awarded to the user. ", "users entertained and motivated to give their best in answering", "answering the questions from corners of the world. Award", "associated with the comments on the questions or the answers.", "points of the user. * Though comments get many upvotes,", "answers keep getting upvotes there by increasing the points of", "are no points associated with the comments on the questions", "the world. * Award some point (nonzero) to the user", "* Few answers just combine the ideas mentioned in the", "done? (any one of the following would do.) * Award", "members of academia.SE site. What could possibly be done? (any", "or silver or gold reputation badge based on the number", "the comments and those answers keep getting upvotes there by", "in answering the questions from corners of the world. ", "new members of academia.SE site. What could possibly be done?", "However, there are no points associated with the comments on", "upvotes of the questions and answers have some points associated.", "mentioned in the comments and those answers keep getting upvotes", "the user. This is demotivating for the new members", "answers just combine the ideas mentioned in the comments and", "reputation badge based on the number of upvotes on comments.", "increasing the points of the user. * Though comments get", "at least 1 point for each upvote of a comment.", "of the following would do.) * Award at least 1", "could possibly be done? (any one of the following would", "questions and answers have some points associated. However, there are", "user. * This is demotivating for the new members of", "a bronze or silver or gold reputation badge based on", "to give their best in answering the questions from corners", "their best in answering the questions from corners of the", "entertained and motivated to give their best in answering the", "bronze or silver or gold reputation badge based on the", "answers. Why am I asking this question? * Few answers", "comment with 5 upvotes. * Award a bronze or silver", "a comment. This will keep the users entertained and motivated", "being awarded to the user. * This is demotivating for", "the questions from corners of the world. * Award some", "upvotes. * Award a bronze or silver or gold reputation", "world. * Award some point (nonzero) to the user with", "silver or gold reputation badge based on the number of", "Though comments get many upvotes, no points are being awarded", "and motivated to give their best in answering the questions", "ideas mentioned in the comments and those answers keep getting", "point for each upvote of a comment. This will keep", "the new members of academia.SE site. What could possibly be", "or gold reputation badge based on the number of upvotes", "user with a comment with 5 upvotes. * Award a", "get many upvotes, no points are being awarded to the", "questions or the answers. Why am I asking this question?", "* Award at least 1 point for each upvote of", "* This is demotivating for the new members of academia.SE", "question? * Few answers just combine the ideas mentioned in", "the following would do.) * Award at least 1 point", "I asking this question? * Few answers just combine the" ]
[ "know if there is a better Stack Exchange site for", "not recall seeing any questions here about K-12 education here,", "I do not recall seeing any questions here about K-12", "recall seeing any questions here about K-12 education here, but", "but I also do not know if there is a", "do not know if there is a better Stack Exchange", "line says it all -- I do not recall seeing", "Subject line says it all -- I do not recall", "about K-12 education here, but I also do not know", "do not recall seeing any questions here about K-12 education", "questions here about K-12 education here, but I also do", "it all -- I do not recall seeing any questions", "any questions here about K-12 education here, but I also", "says it all -- I do not recall seeing any", "here about K-12 education here, but I also do not", "K-12 education here, but I also do not know if", "if there is a better Stack Exchange site for that", "not know if there is a better Stack Exchange site", "there is a better Stack Exchange site for that purpose.", "education here, but I also do not know if there", "all -- I do not recall seeing any questions here", "here, but I also do not know if there is", "also do not know if there is a better Stack", "-- I do not recall seeing any questions here about", "I also do not know if there is a better", "seeing any questions here about K-12 education here, but I" ]
[ "let the people ask and answer the questions peacefully and", "and none of my comments has ever been censored/blocked/deleted by", "Look at how the New York Times publishes pretty much", "the submitted comments. I have posted to the New York", "New York Times publishes pretty much all of the submitted", "by the editors. It's called freedom of speech and freedom", "unless there arises a serious problem? Just let people talk.", "none of my comments has ever been censored/blocked/deleted by the", "there arises a serious problem? Just let people talk. Look", "been censored/blocked/deleted by the editors. It's called freedom of speech", "submitted comments. I have posted to the New York Times", "have posted to the New York Times for 5+ years", "closed, and moved without much justification. Why can't the moderators", "censored/blocked/deleted by the editors. It's called freedom of speech and", "and answer the questions peacefully and without censoring unless there", "to the New York Times for 5+ years and none", "Times for 5+ years and none of my comments has", "all of the submitted comments. I have posted to the", "my comments has ever been censored/blocked/deleted by the editors. It's", "answer the questions peacefully and without censoring unless there arises", "serious problem? Just let people talk. Look at how the", "and without censoring unless there arises a serious problem? Just", "etc. just let the people ask and answer the questions", "of the submitted comments. I have posted to the New", "much all of the submitted comments. I have posted to", "Just let people talk. Look at how the New York", "at how the New York Times publishes pretty much all", "arises a serious problem? Just let people talk. Look at", "a serious problem? Just let people talk. Look at how", "multiple questions and comments deleted, closed, and moved without much", "York Times publishes pretty much all of the submitted comments.", "comments has ever been censored/blocked/deleted by the editors. It's called", "questions peacefully and without censoring unless there arises a serious", "censoring unless there arises a serious problem? Just let people", "justification. Why can't the moderators etc. just let the people", "deleted, closed, and moved without much justification. Why can't the", "5+ years and none of my comments has ever been", "moved without much justification. Why can't the moderators etc. just", "years and none of my comments has ever been censored/blocked/deleted", "editors. It's called freedom of speech and freedom of association.", "I have seen multiple questions and comments deleted, closed, and", "without censoring unless there arises a serious problem? Just let", "moderators etc. just let the people ask and answer the", "for 5+ years and none of my comments has ever", "people ask and answer the questions peacefully and without censoring", "talk. Look at how the New York Times publishes pretty", "peacefully and without censoring unless there arises a serious problem?", "and comments deleted, closed, and moved without much justification. Why", "publishes pretty much all of the submitted comments. I have", "ever been censored/blocked/deleted by the editors. It's called freedom of", "much justification. Why can't the moderators etc. just let the", "people talk. Look at how the New York Times publishes", "and moved without much justification. Why can't the moderators etc.", "problem? Just let people talk. Look at how the New", "have seen multiple questions and comments deleted, closed, and moved", "the people ask and answer the questions peacefully and without", "comments. I have posted to the New York Times for", "questions and comments deleted, closed, and moved without much justification.", "the New York Times publishes pretty much all of the", "how the New York Times publishes pretty much all of", "just let the people ask and answer the questions peacefully", "has ever been censored/blocked/deleted by the editors. It's called freedom", "I have posted to the New York Times for 5+", "ask and answer the questions peacefully and without censoring unless", "the questions peacefully and without censoring unless there arises a", "pretty much all of the submitted comments. I have posted", "seen multiple questions and comments deleted, closed, and moved without", "Why can't the moderators etc. just let the people ask", "the moderators etc. just let the people ask and answer", "York Times for 5+ years and none of my comments", "the editors. It's called freedom of speech and freedom of", "comments deleted, closed, and moved without much justification. Why can't", "New York Times for 5+ years and none of my", "of my comments has ever been censored/blocked/deleted by the editors.", "the New York Times for 5+ years and none of", "let people talk. Look at how the New York Times", "without much justification. Why can't the moderators etc. just let", "posted to the New York Times for 5+ years and", "can't the moderators etc. just let the people ask and", "Times publishes pretty much all of the submitted comments. I" ]
[ "all of these are currently used, introducing a new close", "exist to streamline close voting and to leave helpful information", "is off-topic now will still be off-topic – close voters", "not about academia.” ### Proposal Let’s replace the undergraduate close", "this proposal be accepted, the kind of undergraduate questions that", "and provide helpful links (as possible within the 400 available", "by the close voter). This includes: + 21 close reasons", "* the undergraduate close reason¹ was used 18 times (that’s", "questions about the subject of an academic discipline, * questions", "ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > ² which would be:", "these are currently used, introducing a new close reason requires", "only three slots for custom close reasons available. As all", "standard phrasing for such a close reason², the latter shall", "undergraduate students. The detailed phrasing shall be addressed in answers", "itself + at least 39 instances of blanket close reasons", "the close voter). This includes: + 21 close reasons that", "and to leave helpful information for the asker. They do", "about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can", "a new close reason requires abolishing an existing one.* ###", "questions were closed with a custom close reason (i.e., typed", "[What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > >", "### Statistical background The following is extracted from the [question", "like: “This is not about academia.” ### Proposal Let’s replace", "can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > ² which", "academia itself + at least 39 instances of blanket close", "addressed in answers to this question. Note that we have", "close reasons like: “This is not about academia.” ### Proposal", "the asker. They do not define our scope. Should this", "¹ which is as follows: > > Questions about problems", "about academia itself + at least 39 instances of blanket", "about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > ² which would be: >", "not appear to be about academia, within the scope defined", "% of all closures). * 84 questions were closed with", "at least 39 instances of blanket close reasons like: “This", "about the subject of an academic discipline, * questions about", "question. Note that we have only three slots for custom", "“This is not about academia.” ### Proposal Let’s replace the", "new close reason requires abolishing an existing one. ### Does", "reason themselves. --- ¹ which is as follows: > >", "also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in", "replace the undergraduate close reason¹ with a more general out", "the scope defined in the [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic). > > >", "apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What", "84 questions were closed with a custom close reason (i.e.,", "question does not appear to be about academia, within the", "> Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless", "will still be off-topic – close voters may just have", "is as follows: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate", "about the subject of an academic discipline and not about", "of blanket close reasons like: “This is not about academia.”", "– close voters may just have to type this reason", "more general out of scope* reason. Instead of the standard", "to this question. Note that we have only three slots", "+ at least 39 instances of blanket close reasons like:", "close reasons that indicate that the question is about the", "stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k only). In the last three months: ", "helpful information for the asker. They do not define our", "this question. Note that we have only three slots for", "39 instances of blanket close reasons like: “This is not", "questions that is off-topic now will still be off-topic –", "an academic discipline and not about academia itself + at", "cases and provide helpful links (as possible within the 400", "be about academia, within the scope defined in the [help", "our scope? Canned close reasons mostly exist to streamline close", "within the 400 available characters), for example: * questions about", "the subject of an academic discipline and not about academia", "define our scope. Should this proposal be accepted, the kind", "a change of our scope? Canned close reasons mostly exist", "Instead of the standard phrasing for such a close reason²,", "may just have to type this reason themselves. --- ¹", "the [question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k only).* In the last", "that is off-topic now will still be off-topic – close", "used 18 times (that’s only about 3 % of all", "k only).* In the last three months: * the undergraduate", "undergraduate questions that is off-topic now will still be off-topic", "discipline and not about academia itself + at least 39", "reason (i.e., typed by the close voter). This includes: +", "Note that we have only three slots for custom close", "specific to undergraduate students. The detailed phrasing shall be addressed", "--- ¹ which is as follows: > > Questions about", "scope. Should this proposal be accepted, the kind of undergraduate", "they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as", "discipline, questions about non-academic education, * questions specific to", "Does this mean a change of our scope? Canned close", "+ 21 close reasons that indicate that the question is", "would be: > > This question does not appear to", "academia.” ### Proposal Let’s replace the undergraduate close reason¹ with", "voting and to leave helpful information for the asker. They", "accepted, the kind of undergraduate questions that is off-topic now", "as follows: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students", "streamline close voting and to leave helpful information for the", "close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k only).* In the last three months:", "of all closures). * 84 questions were closed with a", "(10 k only).* In the last three months: * the", "closures). * 84 questions were closed with a custom close", "the standard phrasing for such a close reason², the latter", "close reasons mostly exist to streamline close voting and to", "(as possible within the 400 available characters), for example: ", "of an academic discipline, questions about non-academic education, ", "is not about academia.” ### Proposal Let’s replace the undergraduate", "detailed phrasing shall be addressed in answers to this question.", "indicate that the question is about the subject of an", "question is about the subject of an academic discipline and", "links (as possible within the 400 available characters), for example:", "requires abolishing an existing one. ### Does this mean a", "> ² which would be: > > This question does", "The following is extracted from the [question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10", "with a custom close reason (i.e., typed by the close", "change of our scope? Canned close reasons mostly exist to", "² which would be: > > This question does not", "used, introducing a new close reason requires abolishing an existing", "I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > ² which would", "only). In the last three months: * the undergraduate close", "currently used, introducing a new close reason requires abolishing an", "kind of undergraduate questions that is off-topic now will still", "off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate", "be: > > This question does not appear to be", "close reasons available. As all of these are currently used,", "closed with a custom close reason (i.e., typed by the", "of these are currently used, introducing a new close reason", "Let’s replace the undergraduate close reason¹ with a more general", "possible within the 400 available characters), for example: * questions", "for example: * questions about the subject of an academic", "### Does this mean a change of our scope? Canned", "slots for custom close reasons available. As all of these", "facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply", "18 times (that’s only about 3 % of all closures).", "following is extracted from the [question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k", "to leave helpful information for the asker. They do not", "from the [question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k only).* In the", "They do not define our scope. Should this proposal be", "of an academic discipline and not about academia itself +", "close reason¹ with a more general out of scope reason.", "Statistical background The following is extracted from the [question close", "of undergraduate questions that is off-topic now will still be", "months: the undergraduate close reason¹ was used 18 times", "one.* ### Does this mean a change of our scope?", "education, * questions specific to undergraduate students. The detailed phrasing", "Proposal Let’s replace the undergraduate close reason¹ with a more", "### Proposal Let’s replace the undergraduate close reason¹ with a", "which is as follows: > > Questions about problems facing", "now will still be off-topic – close voters may just", "and not about academia itself + at least 39 instances", "appear to be about academia, within the scope defined in", "(that’s only about 3 % of all closures). * 84", "as described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "for the asker. They do not define our scope. Should", "information for the asker. They do not define our scope.", "of scope* reason. Instead of the standard phrasing for such", "> This question does not appear to be about academia,", "the question is about the subject of an academic discipline", "about 3 % of all closures). * 84 questions were", "students are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate", "This includes: + 21 close reasons that indicate that the", "close reason requires abolishing an existing one.* ### Does this", "21 close reasons that indicate that the question is about", "latter shall also explicitly mention common cases and provide helpful", "questions specific to undergraduate students. The detailed phrasing shall be", "leave helpful information for the asker. They do not define", "graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can", "follows: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are", "close reason (i.e., typed by the close voter). This includes:", "introducing a new close reason requires abolishing an existing one.", "for such a close reason², the latter shall also explicitly", "all closures). 84 questions were closed with a custom", "common cases and provide helpful links (as possible within the", "such a close reason², the latter shall also explicitly mention", "> > ² which would be: > > This question", "is about the subject of an academic discipline and not", "* questions about non-academic education, * questions specific to undergraduate", "to streamline close voting and to leave helpful information for", "shall be addressed in answers to this question. Note that", "reason. Instead of the standard phrasing for such a close", "for custom close reasons available. As all of these are", "explicitly mention common cases and provide helpful links (as possible", "phrasing shall be addressed in answers to this question. Note", "within the scope defined in the [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic). > >", "(i.e., typed by the close voter). This includes: + 21", "subject of an academic discipline and not about academia itself", "questions about non-academic education, * questions specific to undergraduate students.", "this mean a change of our scope? Canned close reasons", "available. As all of these are currently used, introducing a", "to be about academia, within the scope defined in the", "also explicitly mention common cases and provide helpful links (as", "example: * questions about the subject of an academic discipline,", "topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > ²", "undergraduate close reason¹ with a more general out of scope", "reasons mostly exist to streamline close voting and to leave", "in answers to this question. Note that we have only", "here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > ² which would be: > >", "to type this reason themselves. --- ¹ which is as", "a more general out of scope* reason. Instead of the", "In the last three months: * the undergraduate close reason¹", "about academia, within the scope defined in the [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic).", "background The following is extracted from the [question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats)", "voters may just have to type this reason themselves. ---", " questions specific to undergraduate students. The detailed phrasing shall", "abolishing an existing one.* ### Does this mean a change", "the undergraduate close reason¹ with a more general out of", "that indicate that the question is about the subject of", "available characters), for example: questions about the subject of", "academic discipline and not about academia itself + at least", "reasons available. As all of these are currently used, introducing", "phrasing for such a close reason², the latter shall also", "As all of these are currently used, introducing a new", "type this reason themselves. --- ¹ which is as follows:", "close reason², the latter shall also explicitly mention common cases", "400 available characters), for example: * questions about the subject", "have only three slots for custom close reasons available. As", "our scope. Should this proposal be accepted, the kind of", "academic discipline, * questions about non-academic education, * questions specific", "about non-academic education, * questions specific to undergraduate students. The", "existing one.* ### Does this mean a change of our", "themselves. --- ¹ which is as follows: > > Questions", "only about 3 % of all closures). * 84 questions", "off-topic – close voters may just have to type this", "not about academia itself + at least 39 instances of", "problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also", "an academic discipline, * questions about non-academic education, * questions", "voter). This includes: + 21 close reasons that indicate that", "we have only three slots for custom close reasons available.", "are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or", "reasons that indicate that the question is about the subject", "just have to type this reason themselves. --- ¹ which", "mean a change of our scope? Canned close reasons mostly", "close voting and to leave helpful information for the asker.", "described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) >", "unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians", "last three months: * the undergraduate close reason¹ was used", "are currently used, introducing a new close reason requires abolishing", "is extracted from the [question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k only).", "be accepted, the kind of undergraduate questions that is off-topic", "were closed with a custom close reason (i.e., typed by", "proposal be accepted, the kind of undergraduate questions that is", "in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > >", "subject of an academic discipline, questions about non-academic education,", "custom close reasons available. As all of these are currently", "of our scope? Canned close reasons mostly exist to streamline", "scope* reason. Instead of the standard phrasing for such a", "three months: * the undergraduate close reason¹ was used 18", "be addressed in answers to this question. Note that we", "reason², the latter shall also explicitly mention common cases and", "includes: + 21 close reasons that indicate that the question", "reason¹ with a more general out of scope* reason. Instead", "answers to this question. Note that we have only three", "The detailed phrasing shall be addressed in answers to this", "academicians as described in [What topics can I ask about", "a close reason², the latter shall also explicitly mention common", "an existing one. ### Does this mean a change of", "scope? Canned close reasons mostly exist to streamline close voting", "be off-topic – close voters may just have to type", "with a more general out of scope reason. Instead of", "have to type this reason themselves. --- ¹ which is", "out of scope reason. Instead of the standard phrasing for", "undergraduate close reason¹ was used 18 times (that’s only about", "post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I ask", "Canned close reasons mostly exist to streamline close voting and", "characters), for example: * questions about the subject of an", "that the question is about the subject of an academic", "does not appear to be about academia, within the scope", "that we have only three slots for custom close reasons", "still be off-topic – close voters may just have to", "[question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k only).* In the last three", "about academia.” ### Proposal Let’s replace the undergraduate close reason¹", "of the standard phrasing for such a close reason², the", "academia, within the scope defined in the [help center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic). >", "non-academic education, * questions specific to undergraduate students. The detailed", "> > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic", "blanket close reasons like: “This is not about academia.” ###", "> > This question does not appear to be about", "reason¹ was used 18 times (that’s only about 3 %", "undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply to", "custom close reason (i.e., typed by the close voter). This", "to undergraduate students. The detailed phrasing shall be addressed in", "can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described", "not define our scope. Should this proposal be accepted, the", "> > > ² which would be: > > This", "students. The detailed phrasing shall be addressed in answers to", "this reason themselves. --- ¹ which is as follows: >", "times (that’s only about 3 % of all closures). ", "provide helpful links (as possible within the 400 available characters),", "Should this proposal be accepted, the kind of undergraduate questions", "a custom close reason (i.e., typed by the close voter).", "close voters may just have to type this reason themselves.", "Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they", "mention common cases and provide helpful links (as possible within", "the last three months: the undergraduate close reason¹ was", "asker. They do not define our scope. Should this proposal", "do not define our scope. Should this proposal be accepted,", "the 400 available characters), for example: * questions about the", "typed by the close voter). This includes: + 21 close", "shall also explicitly mention common cases and provide helpful links", "helpful links (as possible within the 400 available characters), for", "least 39 instances of blanket close reasons like: “This is", "the kind of undergraduate questions that is off-topic now will", "close reason¹ was used 18 times (that’s only about 3", "was used 18 times (that’s only about 3 % of", "reasons like: “This is not about academia.” ### Proposal Let’s", "mostly exist to streamline close voting and to leave helpful", "close voter). This includes: + 21 close reasons that indicate", "This question does not appear to be about academia, within", "* 84 questions were closed with a custom close reason", "the latter shall also explicitly mention common cases and provide", "* questions about the subject of an academic discipline, ", "instances of blanket close reasons like: “This is not about", "extracted from the [question close stats](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tools/question-close-stats) (10 k only). In", "to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics", "3 % of all closures). * 84 questions were closed", "which would be: > > This question does not appear", "the undergraduate close reason¹ was used 18 times (that’s only", "three slots for custom close reasons available. As all of", "general out of scope reason. Instead of the standard phrasing", "the subject of an academic discipline, * questions about non-academic", "off-topic now will still be off-topic – close voters may", "or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I", "reason requires abolishing an existing one.* ### Does this mean" ]
[ "need advice how to report this behavior and what legal", "against law and working ethic, and I am surprised to", "request from a postdoc to stay more than 10 h", "ad that one of my advisors shared contains a sentence", "law and working ethic, and I am surprised to see", "per day. I need advice how to report this behavior", "postdoc to stay more than 10 h per day. I", "my advisors shared contains a sentence that is against law", "a postdoc to stay more than 10 h per day.", "working ethic, and I am surprised to see an associate", "than 10 h per day. I need advice how to", "and working ethic, and I am surprised to see an", "see an associate professor request from a postdoc to stay", "I need advice how to report this behavior and what", "that one of my advisors shared contains a sentence that", "and what legal consequences this professor can face. Is this", "ethic, and I am surprised to see an associate professor", "advisors shared contains a sentence that is against law and", "to report this behavior and what legal consequences this professor", "to stay more than 10 h per day. I need", "h per day. I need advice how to report this", "I am surprised to see an associate professor request from", "from a postdoc to stay more than 10 h per", "10 h per day. I need advice how to report", "how to report this behavior and what legal consequences this", "report this behavior and what legal consequences this professor can", "associate professor request from a postdoc to stay more than", "legal consequences this professor can face. Is this a suitable", "surprised to see an associate professor request from a postdoc", "more than 10 h per day. I need advice how", "a sentence that is against law and working ethic, and", "and I am surprised to see an associate professor request", "of my advisors shared contains a sentence that is against", "an associate professor request from a postdoc to stay more", "is against law and working ethic, and I am surprised", "shared contains a sentence that is against law and working", "day. I need advice how to report this behavior and", "contains a sentence that is against law and working ethic,", "am surprised to see an associate professor request from a", "one of my advisors shared contains a sentence that is", "An ad that one of my advisors shared contains a", "that is against law and working ethic, and I am", "advice how to report this behavior and what legal consequences", "this behavior and what legal consequences this professor can face.", "consequences this professor can face. Is this a suitable place?", "professor request from a postdoc to stay more than 10", "sentence that is against law and working ethic, and I", "to see an associate professor request from a postdoc to", "what legal consequences this professor can face. Is this a", "stay more than 10 h per day. I need advice", "behavior and what legal consequences this professor can face. Is" ]
[ "would like to know if i can publish the thesis", "am sure It's an idea that what spreading. I would", "know if i can publish the thesis here on this", "an idea that what spreading. I would like to know", "what spreading. I would like to know if i can", "if i can publish the thesis here on this site,", "to know if i can publish the thesis here on", "been trying to publish my Master's thesis, I am sure", "I am sure It's an idea that what spreading. I", "that what spreading. I would like to know if i", "like to know if i can publish the thesis here", "publish my Master's thesis, I am sure It's an idea", "sure It's an idea that what spreading. I would like", "idea that what spreading. I would like to know if", "publish the thesis here on this site, and if so", "i can publish the thesis here on this site, and", "and if so please how can I go about it?", "spreading. I would like to know if i can publish", "on this site, and if so please how can I", "thesis here on this site, and if so please how", "the thesis here on this site, and if so please", "trying to publish my Master's thesis, I am sure It's", "can publish the thesis here on this site, and if", "here on this site, and if so please how can", "It's an idea that what spreading. I would like to", "Master's thesis, I am sure It's an idea that what", "I have been trying to publish my Master's thesis, I", "have been trying to publish my Master's thesis, I am", "site, and if so please how can I go about", "I would like to know if i can publish the", "this site, and if so please how can I go", "my Master's thesis, I am sure It's an idea that", "thesis, I am sure It's an idea that what spreading.", "to publish my Master's thesis, I am sure It's an" ]
[ "Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is no difference between the two definitions.", "post-graduate academicians > > > I propose to replace this", "or disagreement with the proposal. Use answers to suggest amendments", "scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect to undergraduate questions is: > > [do", "etc. shall be changed accordingly. This includes the outcome of", "thus not generally understood. For example, there do not even", "translations of the words undergraduate and graduate student to the", "* Undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to graduate or", "proposal. Use answers to suggest amendments or elaborate your disagreement.", "undergraduate. * Going by the outcome of [this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734),", "see that they do not fall into this category. ###", "> > * Undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to", "it only requires a very basic understanding of the underlying", "underlying system. For most question, even that isn’t needed to", "to undergraduate questions is: > > [do not ask questions", "Rationale * The current definition is difficult to grasp and", "exist accurate translations of the words undergraduate and graduate student", "that isn’t needed to see that they do not fall", "to indicate your indicate your agreement or disagreement with the", "voted to close for no other apparent reason than containing", "admissions > * Undergraduate life and culture (sports, nightlife, dorms,", "issues that could not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians", "Undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to graduate or post-graduate", "of the words undergraduate and graduate student to the German", "> > [do not ask questions about] > > >", "### Proposal Currently [the definition of our scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect", "etc.) > > > Close reasons, other help texts, etc.", "students is not universal and thus not generally understood. For", "The separation between undergraduate and graduate students is not universal", "This includes the outcome of [this proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ###", "by the outcome of [this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is no", "proposed wording still contains the word undergraduate, it only requires", "changed accordingly. This includes the outcome of [this proposal of", "This question Use votes on the question to indicate your", "there do not even exist accurate translations of the words", "by: > > [do not ask questions about] > >", "votes on the question to indicate your indicate your agreement", "[this proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale * The current definition", "accurate translations of the words undergraduate and graduate student to", "your indicate your agreement or disagreement with the proposal. Use", "undergraduate and graduate students is not universal and thus not", "[this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is no difference between the two", "close for no other apparent reason than containing the word", "of [this proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale * The current", "definition is difficult to grasp and a source of dispute.", "of [this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is no difference between the", "is not universal and thus not generally understood. For example,", "definition of our scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect to undergraduate questions is:", "the question to indicate your indicate your agreement or disagreement", "Currently [the definition of our scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect to undergraduate", "[do not ask questions about] > > > * Undergraduate-specific", "life and culture (sports, nightlife, dorms, leaving the nest, etc.)", "help texts, etc. shall be changed accordingly. This includes the", "current definition often leads to questions being voted to close", "graduate student to the German language. While the proposed wording", "The current definition often leads to questions being voted to", "> * Undergraduate life and culture (sports, nightlife, dorms, leaving", "> > > * Undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply", "While the proposed wording still contains the word undergraduate, it", "questions about] > > > * Undergraduate admissions > ", "only requires a very basic understanding of the underlying system.", "questions is: > > [do not* ask questions about] >", "with the proposal. Use answers to suggest amendments or elaborate", "about] > > > * Undergraduate-specific issues that could not", "> > > I propose to replace this by: >", "culture (sports, nightlife, dorms, leaving the nest, etc.) > >", "ask questions about] > > > * Undergraduate-specific issues that", "Use votes on the question to indicate your indicate your", "word undergraduate. * Going by the outcome of [this Meta", "containing the word undergraduate. * Going by the outcome of", "not generally understood. For example, there do not even exist", "Close reasons, other help texts, etc. shall be changed accordingly.", "graduate or post-graduate academicians > > > I propose to", "the words undergraduate and graduate student to the German language.", "> Close reasons, other help texts, etc. shall be changed", "understood. For example, there do not even exist accurate translations", "requires a very basic understanding of the underlying system. For", "nightlife, dorms, leaving the nest, etc.) > > > Close", "* Going by the outcome of [this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there", "separation between undergraduate and graduate students is not universal and", "and culture (sports, nightlife, dorms, leaving the nest, etc.) >", "outcome of [this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is no difference between", "there is no difference between the two definitions. * The", "understanding of the underlying system. For most question, even that", "this by: > > [do not ask questions about] >", "* The separation between undergraduate and graduate students is not", "the word undergraduate, it only requires a very basic understanding", "generally understood. For example, there do not even exist accurate", "and graduate student to the German language. While the proposed", "apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians > > > I", "of the underlying system. For most question, even that isn’t", "and graduate students is not universal and thus not generally", "with respect to undergraduate questions is: > > [do not", "indicate your agreement or disagreement with the proposal. Use answers", "disagreement with the proposal. Use answers to suggest amendments or", "### This question Use votes on the question to indicate", "to grasp and a source of dispute. * The current", "source of dispute. * The current definition often leads to", "language. While the proposed wording still contains the word undergraduate,", "to graduate or post-graduate academicians > > > I propose", "system. For most question, even that isn’t needed to see", "this category. ### This question Use votes on the question", "For most question, even that isn’t needed to see that", "isn’t needed to see that they do not fall into", "fall into this category. ### This question Use votes on", "wording still contains the word undergraduate, it only requires a", "replace this by: > > [do not ask questions about]", "still contains the word undergraduate, it only requires a very", "reason than containing the word undergraduate. * Going by the", "> * Undergraduate admissions > * Undergraduate life and culture", "questions being voted to close for no other apparent reason", "> [do not ask questions about] > > > ", "than containing the word undergraduate.* * Going by the outcome", "outcome of [this proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale * The", "two definitions. * The separation between undergraduate and graduate students", "> > > * Undergraduate admissions > * Undergraduate life", "* The current definition often leads to questions being voted", "respect to undergraduate questions is: > > [do not ask", "question Use votes on the question to indicate your indicate", "leaving the nest, etc.) > > > Close reasons, other", "of dispute. * The current definition often leads to questions", "contains the word undergraduate, it only requires a very basic", "that could not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians >", "dorms, leaving the nest, etc.) > > > Close reasons,", "do not fall into this category. ### This question Use", "propose to replace this by: > > [do not ask", "apparent reason than containing the word undergraduate. * Going by", "definition often leads to questions being voted to close for", "to see that they do not fall into this category.", "that they do not fall into this category. ### This", "reasons, other help texts, etc. shall be changed accordingly. This", "> > * Undergraduate admissions > * Undergraduate life and", "undergraduate, it only requires a very basic understanding of the", "word undergraduate, it only requires a very basic understanding of", "no difference between the two definitions. * The separation between", "into this category. ### This question Use votes on the", "dispute. * The current definition often leads to questions being", "and a source of dispute. * The current definition often", "of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale * The current definition is difficult", "questions about] > > > * Undergraduate-specific issues that could", "is: > > [do not ask questions about] > >", "could not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians > >", "not apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians > > >", "texts, etc. shall be changed accordingly. This includes the outcome", "academicians > > > I propose to replace this by:", "our scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect to undergraduate questions is: > >", "not even exist accurate translations of the words undergraduate and", "on the question to indicate your indicate your agreement or", "indicate your indicate your agreement or disagreement with the proposal.", "proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale * The current definition is", "> > > Close reasons, other help texts, etc. shall", "is difficult to grasp and a source of dispute. ", "current definition is difficult to grasp and a source of", "(sports, nightlife, dorms, leaving the nest, etc.) > > >", "do not even exist accurate translations of the words undergraduate", "the underlying system. For most question, even that isn’t needed", "your agreement or disagreement with the proposal. Use answers to", "basic understanding of the underlying system. For most question, even", "mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale The current definition is difficult to", "Proposal Currently [the definition of our scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect to", "nest, etc.) > > > Close reasons, other help texts,", "includes the outcome of [this proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale", "undergraduate questions is: > > [do not ask questions about]", "a very basic understanding of the underlying system. For most", "or post-graduate academicians > > > I propose to replace", "German language. While the proposed wording still contains the word", "the two definitions. * The separation between undergraduate and graduate", "Undergraduate admissions > * Undergraduate life and culture (sports, nightlife,", "accordingly. This includes the outcome of [this proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734).", "> > Close reasons, other help texts, etc. shall be", "is no difference between the two definitions. * The separation", "even exist accurate translations of the words undergraduate and graduate", "the outcome of [this proposal of mine](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3783/7734). ### Rationale ", "for no other apparent reason than containing the word undergraduate.", "difficult to grasp and a source of dispute. * The", "> > I propose to replace this by: > >", "other apparent reason than containing the word undergraduate. * Going", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is no difference between the two definitions. ", "For example, there do not even exist accurate translations of", "other help texts, etc. shall be changed accordingly. This includes", "not universal and thus not generally understood. For example, there", "between the two definitions. The separation between undergraduate and", "the word undergraduate. * Going by the outcome of [this", "the German language. While the proposed wording still contains the", "student* to the German language. While the proposed wording still", "I propose to replace this by: > > [do not", "not ask questions about] > > > * Undergraduate admissions", "Undergraduate life and culture (sports, nightlife, dorms, leaving the nest,", "difference between the two definitions. * The separation between undergraduate", "words undergraduate and graduate student to the German language. While", "* Undergraduate admissions > * Undergraduate life and culture (sports,", "graduate students is not universal and thus not generally understood.", "even that isn’t needed to see that they do not", "about] > > > * Undergraduate admissions > * Undergraduate", "the proposed wording still contains the word undergraduate, it only", "agreement or disagreement with the proposal. Use answers to suggest", "being voted to close for no other apparent reason than", "often leads to questions being voted to close for no", "no other apparent reason than containing the word undergraduate. ", "[the definition of our scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect to undergraduate questions", "question to indicate your indicate your agreement or disagreement with", "grasp and a source of dispute. The current definition", "the outcome of [this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is no difference", "* The current definition is difficult to grasp and a", "most question, even that isn’t needed to see that they", "* Undergraduate life and culture (sports, nightlife, dorms, leaving the", "the nest, etc.) > > > Close reasons, other help", "### Rationale * The current definition is difficult to grasp", "a source of dispute. * The current definition often leads", "Going by the outcome of [this Meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/3300/7734), there is", "the proposal. Use answers to suggest amendments or elaborate your", "to questions being voted to close for no other apparent", "example, there do not even exist accurate translations of the", "and thus not generally understood. For example, there do not", "question, even that isn’t needed to see that they do", "of our scope](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) with respect to undergraduate questions is: >", "to the German language. While the proposed wording still contains", "> * Undergraduate-specific issues that could not apply to graduate", "they do not fall into this category. ### This question", "not ask questions about] > > > * Undergraduate-specific issues", "leads to questions being voted to close for no other", "[do not ask questions about] > > > * Undergraduate", "shall be changed accordingly. This includes the outcome of [this", "The current definition is difficult to grasp and a source", "to close for no other apparent reason than containing the", "very basic understanding of the underlying system. For most question,", "universal and thus not generally understood. For example, there do", "undergraduate and graduate student to the German language. While the", "ask questions about] > > > * Undergraduate admissions >", "between undergraduate and graduate students is not universal and thus", "definitions. * The separation between undergraduate and graduate students is", "needed to see that they do not fall into this", "to replace this by: > > [do not ask questions", "> I propose to replace this by: > > [do", "not fall into this category. ### This question Use votes", "be changed accordingly. This includes the outcome of [this proposal", "category. ### This question Use votes on the question to" ]
[ "the question to one that is more neutral? Or is", "question to one that is more neutral? Or is this", "too nebulous: I am trying to find a point of", "an edit myself, but then I wasn't sure if I", "nebulous: I am trying to find a point of principle", "edit myself, but then I wasn't sure if I would", "gender and / or race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators' attention,", "will either lead to B, or has been set up", "Or is this too intrusive against the wishes of the", "I was going to flag [Is it considered normal to", "sites and Twitter, natch). Following observations by Dan Romik in", "threads, I think it is objectively true that the question", "flag [Is it considered normal to publish job offers inviting", "[Is it considered normal to publish job offers inviting candidates", "is objectively true that the question has the following structure:", "think it is objectively true that the question has the", "Here it seems to be assumed that A will either", "various commenters on chat threads, I think it is objectively", "this too intrusive against the wishes of the original author?", "wishes of the original author? > > > Sorry if", "the following structure: Title: Why is it normal/acceptable for A", "or practice that it might be useful to sort out,", "that it might be useful to sort out, rather than", "to B, or that A and B are the same.", "A. Question(s): Why is B acceptable? Here it seems to", "practice that it might be useful to sort out, rather", "but then I wasn't sure if I would be acting", "to lead to B, or that A and B are", "more neutral? Or is this too intrusive against the wishes", "his answer and various commenters on chat threads, I think", "on their gender and / or race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for", "offers inviting candidates to apply based on their gender and", "sure if I would be acting correctly. I will try", "normal to publish job offers inviting candidates to apply based", "acceptable? Here it seems to be assumed that A will", "to be assumed that A will either lead to B,", "objectively true that the question has the following structure: Title:", "which seems to be contentious (and now it's hit the", "normal/acceptable for A to happen? Preamable to question: Some description", "get overly focused on the rights and wrongs of a", "moderators' attention, or attempt an edit myself, but then I", "will try not to get bogged down in the specific", "> > My own question: instead of arguing against the", "am trying to find a point of principle or practice", "own question: instead of arguing against the apparent motivation for", "topic of that question, which seems to be contentious (and", "My own question: instead of arguing against the apparent motivation", "myself, but then I wasn't sure if I would be", "instead change the question to one that is more neutral?", "non-academia SE sites and Twitter, natch). Following observations by Dan", "Twitter, natch). Following observations by Dan Romik in his answer", "I would be acting correctly. I will try not to", "original author? > > > Sorry if this is too", "in order to lead to B, or that A and", "or race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators' attention, or attempt an", "> > > Sorry if this is too nebulous: I", "A and B are the same. > > My own", "to flag [Is it considered normal to publish job offers", "SE sites and Twitter, natch). Following observations by Dan Romik", "in his answer and various commenters on chat threads, I", "to happen? Preamable to question: Some description of circumstances A.", "not to get bogged down in the specific topic of", "now it's hit the non-academia SE sites and Twitter, natch).", "for A to happen? Preamable to question: Some description of", "been set up in order to lead to B, or", "rather than get overly focused on the rights and wrongs", "commenters on chat threads, I think it is objectively true", "it normal/acceptable for A to happen? Preamable to question: Some", "change the question to one that is more neutral? Or", "the original author? > > > Sorry if this is", "contentious (and now it's hit the non-academia SE sites and", "in the specific topic of that question, which seems to", "up in order to lead to B, or that A", "answer and various commenters on chat threads, I think it", "and B are the same. > > My own question:", "that is more neutral? Or is this too intrusive against", "observations by Dan Romik in his answer and various commenters", "find a point of principle or practice that it might", "to question: Some description of circumstances A. Question(s): Why is", "considered normal to publish job offers inviting candidates to apply", "overly focused on the rights and wrongs of a particular", "Following observations by Dan Romik in his answer and various", "out, rather than get overly focused on the rights and", "attempt an edit myself, but then I wasn't sure if", "than get overly focused on the rights and wrongs of", "bogged down in the specific topic of that question, which", "useful to sort out, rather than get overly focused on", "to apply based on their gender and / or race", "happen? Preamable to question: Some description of circumstances A. Question(s):", "Sorry if this is too nebulous: I am trying to", "would be acting correctly. I will try not to get", "try not to get bogged down in the specific topic", "to be contentious (and now it's hit the non-academia SE", "> > Sorry if this is too nebulous: I am", "the non-academia SE sites and Twitter, natch). Following observations by", "chat threads, I think it is objectively true that the", "or has been set up in order to lead to", "the wishes of the original author? > > > Sorry", "question: Some description of circumstances A. Question(s): Why is B", "hit the non-academia SE sites and Twitter, natch). Following observations", "seems to be contentious (and now it's hit the non-academia", "question has the following structure: Title: Why is it normal/acceptable", "is too nebulous: I am trying to find a point", "principle or practice that it might be useful to sort", "on chat threads, I think it is objectively true that", "Dan Romik in his answer and various commenters on chat", "mods instead change the question to one that is more", "same. > > My own question: instead of arguing against", "B, or that A and B are the same. >", "the question, should users or mods instead change the question", "question: instead of arguing against the apparent motivation for the", "that question, which seems to be contentious (and now it's", "I think it is objectively true that the question has", "B, or has been set up in order to lead", "if I would be acting correctly. I will try not", "question, which seems to be contentious (and now it's hit", "Why is it normal/acceptable for A to happen? Preamable to", "attention, or attempt an edit myself, but then I wasn't", "down in the specific topic of that question, which seems", "true that the question has the following structure: Title: Why", "Why is B acceptable? Here it seems to be assumed", "seems to be assumed that A will either lead to", "wasn't sure if I would be acting correctly. I will", "too intrusive against the wishes of the original author? >", "of circumstances A. Question(s): Why is B acceptable? Here it", "focused on the rights and wrongs of a particular question.", "inviting candidates to apply based on their gender and /", "job offers inviting candidates to apply based on their gender", "are the same. > > My own question: instead of", "to B, or has been set up in order to", "get bogged down in the specific topic of that question,", "this is too nebulous: I am trying to find a", "assumed that A will either lead to B, or has", "apparent motivation for the question, should users or mods instead", "it might be useful to sort out, rather than get", "it considered normal to publish job offers inviting candidates to", "intrusive against the wishes of the original author? > >", "be acting correctly. I will try not to get bogged", "to get bogged down in the specific topic of that", "following structure: Title: Why is it normal/acceptable for A to", "publish job offers inviting candidates to apply based on their", "is it normal/acceptable for A to happen? Preamable to question:", "in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators' attention, or attempt an edit myself,", "candidates to apply based on their gender and / or", "lead to B, or has been set up in order", "acting correctly. I will try not to get bogged down", "neutral? Or is this too intrusive against the wishes of", "is more neutral? Or is this too intrusive against the", "Romik in his answer and various commenters on chat threads,", "either lead to B, or has been set up in", "is this too intrusive against the wishes of the original", "author? > > > Sorry if this is too nebulous:", "I am trying to find a point of principle or", "motivation for the question, should users or mods instead change", "by Dan Romik in his answer and various commenters on", "it seems to be assumed that A will either lead", "users or mods instead change the question to one that", "against the apparent motivation for the question, should users or", "of principle or practice that it might be useful to", "for moderators' attention, or attempt an edit myself, but then", "it is objectively true that the question has the following", "description of circumstances A. Question(s): Why is B acceptable? Here", "trying to find a point of principle or practice that", "it's hit the non-academia SE sites and Twitter, natch). Following", "order to lead to B, or that A and B", "structure: Title: Why is it normal/acceptable for A to happen?", "and various commenters on chat threads, I think it is", "that A will either lead to B, or has been", "has the following structure: Title: Why is it normal/acceptable for", "a point of principle or practice that it might be", "or attempt an edit myself, but then I wasn't sure", "circumstances A. Question(s): Why is B acceptable? Here it seems", "to one that is more neutral? Or is this too", "might be useful to sort out, rather than get overly", "point of principle or practice that it might be useful", "the specific topic of that question, which seems to be", "be assumed that A will either lead to B, or", "and Twitter, natch). Following observations by Dan Romik in his", "the apparent motivation for the question, should users or mods", "against the wishes of the original author? > > >", "be useful to sort out, rather than get overly focused", "apply based on their gender and / or race in", "sort out, rather than get overly focused on the rights", "Title: Why is it normal/acceptable for A to happen? Preamable", "of arguing against the apparent motivation for the question, should", "one that is more neutral? Or is this too intrusive", "was going to flag [Is it considered normal to publish", "going to flag [Is it considered normal to publish job", "if this is too nebulous: I am trying to find", "to publish job offers inviting candidates to apply based on", "of that question, which seems to be contentious (and now", "B are the same. > > My own question: instead", "academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators' attention, or attempt an edit myself, but", "A will either lead to B, or has been set", "should users or mods instead change the question to one", "the question has the following structure: Title: Why is it", "the same. > > My own question: instead of arguing", "natch). Following observations by Dan Romik in his answer and", "question, should users or mods instead change the question to", "Preamable to question: Some description of circumstances A. Question(s): Why", "> My own question: instead of arguing against the apparent", "Question(s): Why is B acceptable? Here it seems to be", "(and now it's hit the non-academia SE sites and Twitter,", "for the question, should users or mods instead change the", "and / or race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators' attention, or", "then I wasn't sure if I would be acting correctly.", "or that A and B are the same. > >", "> Sorry if this is too nebulous: I am trying", "instead of arguing against the apparent motivation for the question,", "based on their gender and / or race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/)", "their gender and / or race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators'", "arguing against the apparent motivation for the question, should users", "race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators' attention, or attempt an edit", "be contentious (and now it's hit the non-academia SE sites", "/ or race in academia?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/95011/) for moderators' attention, or attempt", "or mods instead change the question to one that is", "to find a point of principle or practice that it", "to sort out, rather than get overly focused on the", "correctly. I will try not to get bogged down in", "lead to B, or that A and B are the", "I will try not to get bogged down in the", "set up in order to lead to B, or that", "of the original author? > > > Sorry if this", "Some description of circumstances A. Question(s): Why is B acceptable?", "I wasn't sure if I would be acting correctly. I", "that the question has the following structure: Title: Why is", "A to happen? Preamable to question: Some description of circumstances", "is B acceptable? Here it seems to be assumed that", "that A and B are the same. > > My", "specific topic of that question, which seems to be contentious", "has been set up in order to lead to B,", "B acceptable? Here it seems to be assumed that A" ]
[ "that the OP's example title is not appropriate. I have", "my revision back. Which way do we want the answer?", "edited the title which I think conveys the same information,", "appropriate. I have edited the title which I think conveys", "A couple of flags have been raised [on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929)", "suggests that the OP's example title is not appropriate. I", "same information, but in a more appropriate way. The OP", "have been raised [on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests that the", "information, but in a more appropriate way. The OP has", "The OP has rolled my revision back. Which way do", "is not appropriate. I have edited the title which I", "of flags have been raised [on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests", "this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests that the OP's example title is", "a more appropriate way. The OP has rolled my revision", "has rolled my revision back. Which way do we want", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests that the OP's example title is not", "which I think conveys the same information, but in a", "title is not appropriate. I have edited the title which", "appropriate way. The OP has rolled my revision back. Which", "title which I think conveys the same information, but in", "the same information, but in a more appropriate way. The", "rolled my revision back. Which way do we want the", "think conveys the same information, but in a more appropriate", "I have edited the title which I think conveys the", "have edited the title which I think conveys the same", "OP has rolled my revision back. Which way do we", "raised [on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests that the OP's example", "that suggests that the OP's example title is not appropriate.", "not appropriate. I have edited the title which I think", "but in a more appropriate way. The OP has rolled", "flags have been raised [on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests that", "couple of flags have been raised [on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that", "I think conveys the same information, but in a more", "in a more appropriate way. The OP has rolled my", "OP's example title is not appropriate. I have edited the", "more appropriate way. The OP has rolled my revision back.", "conveys the same information, but in a more appropriate way.", "the title which I think conveys the same information, but", "the OP's example title is not appropriate. I have edited", "[on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests that the OP's example title", "way. The OP has rolled my revision back. Which way", "been raised [on this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/95065/929) that suggests that the OP's", "example title is not appropriate. I have edited the title" ]
[ "on this site it seems that many users consider students", "comments on this site it seems that many users consider", "lecturers. I wouldn't think too much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > >", "rude? Is there a huge amount of popular lecturer-bashing which", "that many users consider students (students as a group, not", "18 votes so far * > > [@PsySp, you seem", "be too much concerned with this student. Students are free", "seems that many users consider students (students as a group,", "comments to basically any minority or disadvantaged group and see", "1. doesn't add anything positive or useful to the discussion", "a less powerful group, more suitable at a gripe session", "by? Obviously some part of the community will consider this", "modus operandi of a typical student: complaining and criticizing lecturers.", "site it seems that many users consider students (students as", "(students as a group, not individuals) to be irrational \\\\\\holes:", "disadvantaged group and see how quickly that gets flagged and", "is going. Are these comments not considered rude? Is there", "useful to the discussion and 2. could discourage some users", "kind of behaviour 1. doesn't add anything positive or useful", "Are these comments not considered rude? Is there a huge", "[students cannot reasonably expect* - I see you're applying logic", "has passed me by? Obviously some part of the community", "group, more suitable at a gripe session in the pub", "concerned with this student. Students are free to hate and", "> > 18 votes so far * > > [@PsySp,", "considered rude? Is there a huge amount of popular lecturer-bashing", "a huge amount of popular lecturer-bashing which has passed me", "free to hate and bad mouth their lecturers. This is", "of behaviour 1. doesn't add anything positive or useful to", "a group, not individuals) to be irrational \\\\\\holes: >", "This is the modus operandi of a typical student: complaining", "an illogical group, a common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > > >", "powerful group towards a less powerful group, more suitable at", "wouldn't think too much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > > > 21", "me by? Obviously some part of the community will consider", "> [students cannot reasonably expect - I see you're applying", "former student I feel this is user hostile behaviour, by", "community will consider this too thin-skinned, but it seems this", "a thought experiment, try applying these comments to basically any", "to basically any minority or disadvantaged group and see how", "add anything positive or useful to the discussion and 2.", "but it seems this kind of behaviour 1. doesn't add", "behaviour, by a more powerful group towards a less powerful", "I'm not sure where this is going. Are these comments", "seem to be too much concerned with this student. Students", "huge amount of popular lecturer-bashing which has passed me by?", "to an illogical group, a common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > >", "mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > > > 18 votes so far * >", "group, a common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > > > 18 votes", "popular lecturer-bashing which has passed me by? Obviously some part", "feel this is user hostile behaviour, by a more powerful", "student: complaining and criticizing lecturers. I wouldn't think too much", "as a group, not individuals) to be irrational \\\\\\holes: ", "votes so far * > > [@PsySp, you seem to", "session in the pub than in a friendly public forum.", "try applying these comments to basically any minority or disadvantaged", "part of the community will consider this too thin-skinned, but", "by a more powerful group towards a less powerful group,", "applying these comments to basically any minority or disadvantaged group", "be irrational \\\\\\holes: > > [students cannot reasonably expect", "user hostile behaviour, by a more powerful group towards a", "these comments to basically any minority or disadvantaged group and", "lecturer-bashing which has passed me by? Obviously some part of", "* > > [students cannot reasonably expect - I see", "the pub than in a friendly public forum. As a", "As a thought experiment, try applying these comments to basically", "you seem to be too much concerned with this student.", "that gets flagged and removed. I'm not sure where this", "I see you're applying logic to an illogical group, a", "forum. As a thought experiment, try applying these comments to", "hostile behaviour, by a more powerful group towards a less", "passed me by? Obviously some part of the community will", "doesn't add anything positive or useful to the discussion and", "to the discussion and 2. could discourage some users from", "a former student I feel this is user hostile behaviour,", "where this is going. Are these comments not considered rude?", "Is there a huge amount of popular lecturer-bashing which has", "students (students as a group, not individuals) to be irrational", "consider this too thin-skinned, but it seems this kind of", "much concerned with this student. Students are free to hate", "which has passed me by? Obviously some part of the", "to be too much concerned with this student. Students are", "gripe session in the pub than in a friendly public", "so far * > > [@PsySp, you seem to be", "rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > > > 18 votes so far ", "there a huge amount of popular lecturer-bashing which has passed", "cannot reasonably expect - I see you're applying logic to", "> > > 21 votes As a former student I", "than in a friendly public forum. As a thought experiment,", "any minority or disadvantaged group and see how quickly that", "not sure where this is going. Are these comments not", "or useful to the discussion and 2. could discourage some", "of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > > > 21 votes As a former", "it seems that many users consider students (students as a", "with this student. Students are free to hate and bad", "complaining and criticizing lecturers. I wouldn't think too much of", "group, not individuals) to be irrational \\\\\\holes: > >", "\\\\\\holes: > > [students cannot reasonably expect - I", "and criticizing lecturers. I wouldn't think too much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475)", "these comments not considered rude? Is there a huge amount", "is the modus operandi of a typical student: complaining and", "pub than in a friendly public forum. As a thought", "some popular comments on this site it seems that many", "not considered rude? Is there a huge amount of popular", "removed. I'm not sure where this is going. Are these", "too much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > > > 21 votes As", "towards a less powerful group, more suitable at a gripe", "think too much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > > > 21 votes", "anything positive or useful to the discussion and 2. could", "not individuals) to be irrational \\\\\\holes: > > [students", "more suitable at a gripe session in the pub than", "to be irrational \\\\\\holes: * > > [students cannot reasonably", "applying logic to an illogical group, a common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639)", "the community will consider this too thin-skinned, but it seems", "a gripe session in the pub than in a friendly", "too thin-skinned, but it seems this kind of behaviour 1.", "common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > > > 18 votes so far", "will consider this too thin-skinned, but it seems this kind", "illogical group, a common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > > > 18", "> [@PsySp, you seem to be too much concerned with", "this student. Students are free to hate and bad mouth", "mouth their lecturers. This is the modus operandi of a", "minority or disadvantaged group and see how quickly that gets", "users consider students (students as a group, not individuals) to", "- I see you're applying logic to an illogical group,", "the discussion and 2. could discourage some users from participating.", "seems this kind of behaviour 1. doesn't add anything positive", "less powerful group, more suitable at a gripe session in", "this is user hostile behaviour, by a more powerful group", "this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > > > 21 votes As a former student", "how quickly that gets flagged and removed. I'm not sure", "a friendly public forum. As a thought experiment, try applying", "reading some popular comments on this site it seems that", "gets flagged and removed. I'm not sure where this is", "flagged and removed. I'm not sure where this is going.", "this kind of behaviour 1. doesn't add anything positive or", "> > > 18 votes so far > >", "public forum. As a thought experiment, try applying these comments", "After reading some popular comments on this site it seems", "hate and bad mouth their lecturers. This is the modus", "a typical student: complaining and criticizing lecturers. I wouldn't think", "Obviously some part of the community will consider this too", "a common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) > > > 18 votes so", "behaviour 1. doesn't add anything positive or useful to the", "going. Are these comments not considered rude? Is there a", "a more powerful group towards a less powerful group, more", "votes As a former student I feel this is user", "group towards a less powerful group, more suitable at a", "basically any minority or disadvantaged group and see how quickly", "expect* - I see you're applying logic to an illogical", "irrational \\\\\\holes: > > [students cannot reasonably expect -", "> > 21 votes As a former student I feel", "experiment, try applying these comments to basically any minority or", "criticizing lecturers. I wouldn't think too much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) >", "quickly that gets flagged and removed. I'm not sure where", "and bad mouth their lecturers. This is the modus operandi", "[@PsySp, you seem to be too much concerned with this", "this site it seems that many users consider students (students", "I wouldn't think too much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > > >", "As a former student I feel this is user hostile", "consider students (students as a group, not individuals) to be", "their lecturers. This is the modus operandi of a typical", "thin-skinned, but it seems this kind of behaviour 1. doesn't", "many users consider students (students as a group, not individuals)", "> > [students cannot reasonably expect - I see you're", "of a typical student: complaining and criticizing lecturers. I wouldn't", "or disadvantaged group and see how quickly that gets flagged", "friendly public forum. As a thought experiment, try applying these", "far * > > [@PsySp, you seem to be too", "group and see how quickly that gets flagged and removed.", "too much concerned with this student. Students are free to", "operandi of a typical student: complaining and criticizing lecturers. I", "sure where this is going. Are these comments not considered", "are free to hate and bad mouth their lecturers. This", "Students are free to hate and bad mouth their lecturers.", "> 18 votes so far * > > [@PsySp, you", "bad mouth their lecturers. This is the modus operandi of", "is user hostile behaviour, by a more powerful group towards", "typical student: complaining and criticizing lecturers. I wouldn't think too", "see how quickly that gets flagged and removed. I'm not", "this is going. Are these comments not considered rude? Is", "more powerful group towards a less powerful group, more suitable", "positive or useful to the discussion and 2. could discourage", "* > > [@PsySp, you seem to be too much", "21 votes As a former student I feel this is", "individuals) to be irrational \\\\\\holes: > > [students cannot", "lecturers. This is the modus operandi of a typical student:", "student I feel this is user hostile behaviour, by a", "in the pub than in a friendly public forum. As", "at a gripe session in the pub than in a", "of the community will consider this too thin-skinned, but it", "of popular lecturer-bashing which has passed me by? Obviously some", "popular comments on this site it seems that many users", "powerful group, more suitable at a gripe session in the", "thought experiment, try applying these comments to basically any minority", "this too thin-skinned, but it seems this kind of behaviour", "> 21 votes As a former student I feel this", "to hate and bad mouth their lecturers. This is the", "in a friendly public forum. As a thought experiment, try", "you're applying logic to an illogical group, a common rookie", "I feel this is user hostile behaviour, by a more", "some part of the community will consider this too thin-skinned,", "suitable at a gripe session in the pub than in", "reasonably expect - I see you're applying logic to an", "much of this.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96470/how-to-deal-with-arrogant-e-mail-of-a-student/96475#comment247954_96475) > > > 21 votes As a", "logic to an illogical group, a common rookie mistake.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96638/how-do-i-politely-decline-student-requests-to-meet-during-my-research-time#comment248631_96639) >", "see you're applying logic to an illogical group, a common", "amount of popular lecturer-bashing which has passed me by? Obviously", "it seems this kind of behaviour 1. doesn't add anything", "and see how quickly that gets flagged and removed. I'm", "and removed. I'm not sure where this is going. Are", "comments not considered rude? Is there a huge amount of", "student. Students are free to hate and bad mouth their", "the modus operandi of a typical student: complaining and criticizing", "> > [@PsySp, you seem to be too much concerned" ]
[ "the question does not follow the pattern of \"here is", "based on individual factors. To me, this is a typical", "important, well within our usual range, and actually fairly answerable", "But I think it is important, well within our usual", "that the question depends strongly on individual factors. Other commenters", "for worse. Yes, it is somewhat opinion-based. Yes, it is", "is a typical Academia.SE question, for better or for worse.", "we start being that strict about opinion-based and broad, I", "the postdoc priorities question really qualitatively different than [this recent", "that are generally given, and asks for a strategy how", "different than [this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97003/how-would-a-graduate-admissions-committee-view-possibly-false-accusations-agai), or", "fairly answerable (I tried to give it a shot, but", "priorities: “Laundry list” vs. “Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold. The", "do\", which is the standard format of questions we usually", "\"Opinion Based\" could also apply. If I am being honest,", "apply. If I am being honest, I don't see it.", "is a bunch of facts about me, now tell me", "answerable questions. Is the postdoc priorities question really qualitatively different", "I don't see it. The question lists a few conflicting", "Academia.SE question, for better or for worse. Yes, it is", "are generally given, and asks for a strategy how one", "broad, I am afraid we will end up with very", "strict about opinion-based and broad, I am afraid we will", "would love if others could answer as well). If we", "it is somewhat opinion-based. Yes, it is a little broad.", "we usually close as based on individual factors. To me,", "given, and asks for a strategy how one generally selects", "The question lists a few conflicting advises that are generally", "pattern of \"here is a bunch of facts about me,", "this is a typical Academia.SE question, for better or for", "and actually fairly answerable (I tried to give it a", "generally given, and asks for a strategy how one generally", "and broad, I am afraid we will end up with", "does not follow the pattern of \"here is a bunch", "selects between them. Notably, the question does not follow the", "well). If we start being that strict about opinion-based and", "give it a shot, but I would love if others", "a shot, but I would love if others could answer", "usually close as based on individual factors. To me, this", "between them. Notably, the question does not follow the pattern", "have argued that \"Too Broad\" and \"Opinion Based\" could also", "argued that \"Too Broad\" and \"Opinion Based\" could also apply.", "usual range, and actually fairly answerable (I tried to give", "actually fairly answerable (I tried to give it a shot,", "it is important, well within our usual range, and actually", "on hold. The given reason was that the question depends", "put the question [Post-doc priorities: “Laundry list” vs. “Research trumps", "am afraid we will end up with very little answerable", "worse. Yes, it is somewhat opinion-based. Yes, it is a", "really qualitatively different than [this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that recent", "honest, I don't see it. The question lists a few", "is a little broad. But I think it is important,", "If we start being that strict about opinion-based and broad,", "as well). If we start being that strict about opinion-based", "Yes, it is a little broad. But I think it", "individual factors. To me, this is a typical Academia.SE question,", "within our usual range, and actually fairly answerable (I tried", "on individual factors. Other commenters have argued that \"Too Broad\"", "format of questions we usually close as based on individual", "me, now tell me what to do\", which is the", "will end up with very little answerable questions. Is the", "question depends strongly on individual factors. Other commenters have argued", "of facts about me, now tell me what to do\",", "me what to do\", which is the standard format of", "Broad\" and \"Opinion Based\" could also apply. If I am", "am being honest, I don't see it. The question lists", "tell me what to do\", which is the standard format", "priorities question really qualitatively different than [this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or", "one generally selects between them. Notably, the question does not", "questions we usually close as based on individual factors. To", "the question [Post-doc priorities: “Laundry list” vs. “Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all)", "and asks for a strategy how one generally selects between", "factors. To me, this is a typical Academia.SE question, for", "has recently put the question [Post-doc priorities: “Laundry list” vs.", "few conflicting advises that are generally given, and asks for", "To me, this is a typical Academia.SE question, for better", "I am afraid we will end up with very little", "typical Academia.SE question, for better or for worse. Yes, it", "for a strategy how one generally selects between them. Notably,", "see it. The question lists a few conflicting advises that", "strategy how one generally selects between them. Notably, the question", "bunch of facts about me, now tell me what to", "opinion-based and broad, I am afraid we will end up", "all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold. The given reason was that the question", "up with very little answerable questions. Is the postdoc priorities", "Is the postdoc priorities question really qualitatively different than [this", "don't see it. The question lists a few conflicting advises", "postdoc priorities question really qualitatively different than [this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications),", "recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97003/how-would-a-graduate-admissions-committee-view-possibly-false-accusations-agai), or the [following recent", "question, for better or for worse. Yes, it is somewhat", "and \"Opinion Based\" could also apply. If I am being", "question does not follow the pattern of \"here is a", "to give it a shot, but I would love if", "it is a little broad. But I think it is", "others could answer as well). If we start being that", "question lists a few conflicting advises that are generally given,", "could also apply. If I am being honest, I don't", "Yes, it is somewhat opinion-based. Yes, it is a little", "\"here is a bunch of facts about me, now tell", "advises that are generally given, and asks for a strategy", "well within our usual range, and actually fairly answerable (I", "than [this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97003/how-would-a-graduate-admissions-committee-view-possibly-false-accusations-agai), or the", "about me, now tell me what to do\", which is", "start being that strict about opinion-based and broad, I am", "was that the question depends strongly on individual factors. Other", "as based on individual factors. To me, this is a", "with very little answerable questions. Is the postdoc priorities question", "also apply. If I am being honest, I don't see", "how one generally selects between them. Notably, the question does", "given reason was that the question depends strongly on individual", "follow the pattern of \"here is a bunch of facts", "afraid we will end up with very little answerable questions.", "opinion-based. Yes, it is a little broad. But I think", "it. The question lists a few conflicting advises that are", "The given reason was that the question depends strongly on", "of questions we usually close as based on individual factors.", "or for worse. Yes, it is somewhat opinion-based. Yes, it", "conflicting advises that are generally given, and asks for a", "me, this is a typical Academia.SE question, for better or", "end up with very little answerable questions. Is the postdoc", "close as based on individual factors. To me, this is", "Notably, the question does not follow the pattern of \"here", "a few conflicting advises that are generally given, and asks", "somewhat opinion-based. Yes, it is a little broad. But I", "generally selects between them. Notably, the question does not follow", "broad. But I think it is important, well within our", "but I would love if others could answer as well).", "“Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold. The given reason was that", "that \"Too Broad\" and \"Opinion Based\" could also apply. If", "I would love if others could answer as well). If", "about opinion-based and broad, I am afraid we will end", "(I tried to give it a shot, but I would", "think it is important, well within our usual range, and", "facts about me, now tell me what to do\", which", "I am being honest, I don't see it. The question", "a bunch of facts about me, now tell me what", "qualitatively different than [this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97003/how-would-a-graduate-admissions-committee-view-possibly-false-accusations-agai),", "them. Notably, the question does not follow the pattern of", "strongly on individual factors. Other commenters have argued that \"Too", "The community has recently put the question [Post-doc priorities: “Laundry", "questions. Is the postdoc priorities question really qualitatively different than", "individual factors. Other commenters have argued that \"Too Broad\" and", "[Post-doc priorities: “Laundry list” vs. “Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold.", "standard format of questions we usually close as based on", "I think it is important, well within our usual range,", "asks for a strategy how one generally selects between them.", "for better or for worse. Yes, it is somewhat opinion-based.", "could answer as well). If we start being that strict", "reason was that the question depends strongly on individual factors.", "the question depends strongly on individual factors. Other commenters have", "hold. The given reason was that the question depends strongly", "depends strongly on individual factors. Other commenters have argued that", "Other commenters have argued that \"Too Broad\" and \"Opinion Based\"", "to do\", which is the standard format of questions we", "little answerable questions. Is the postdoc priorities question really qualitatively", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97003/how-would-a-graduate-admissions-committee-view-possibly-false-accusations-agai), or the [following recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96987/should-i-avoid-local-journals)?", "our usual range, and actually fairly answerable (I tried to", "range, and actually fairly answerable (I tried to give it", "not follow the pattern of \"here is a bunch of", "vs. “Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold. The given reason was", "Based\" could also apply. If I am being honest, I", "better or for worse. Yes, it is somewhat opinion-based. Yes,", "which is the standard format of questions we usually close", "answer as well). If we start being that strict about", "answerable (I tried to give it a shot, but I", "community has recently put the question [Post-doc priorities: “Laundry list”", "If I am being honest, I don't see it. The", "the standard format of questions we usually close as based", "question [Post-doc priorities: “Laundry list” vs. “Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on", "if others could answer as well). If we start being", "now tell me what to do\", which is the standard", "that strict about opinion-based and broad, I am afraid we", "being that strict about opinion-based and broad, I am afraid", "little broad. But I think it is important, well within", "very little answerable questions. Is the postdoc priorities question really", "is the standard format of questions we usually close as", "commenters have argued that \"Too Broad\" and \"Opinion Based\" could", "what to do\", which is the standard format of questions", "love if others could answer as well). If we start", "list” vs. “Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold. The given reason", "a typical Academia.SE question, for better or for worse. Yes,", "\"Too Broad\" and \"Opinion Based\" could also apply. If I", "a strategy how one generally selects between them. Notably, the", "we will end up with very little answerable questions. Is", "trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold. The given reason was that the", "the pattern of \"here is a bunch of facts about", "a little broad. But I think it is important, well", "lists a few conflicting advises that are generally given, and", "tried to give it a shot, but I would love", "on individual factors. To me, this is a typical Academia.SE", "“Laundry list” vs. “Research trumps all”](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/96998/post-doc-priorities-laundry-list-vs-research-trumps-all) on hold. The given", "is somewhat opinion-based. Yes, it is a little broad. But", "factors. Other commenters have argued that \"Too Broad\" and \"Opinion", "it a shot, but I would love if others could", "question really qualitatively different than [this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that", "[this recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97008/choosing-ones-best-papers-for-job-applications), or [that recent question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97003/how-would-a-graduate-admissions-committee-view-possibly-false-accusations-agai), or the [following", "recently put the question [Post-doc priorities: “Laundry list” vs. “Research", "of \"here is a bunch of facts about me, now", "being honest, I don't see it. The question lists a", "shot, but I would love if others could answer as", "is important, well within our usual range, and actually fairly" ]
[ "duplicate nature. Should people who realize that their questions are", "my answers, I wondered if I was in the right", "if I was in the right to delete my question", "methodologies and data reproducibility. After finding my answers, I wondered", "recently posted a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97792/how-precise-should-data-methodology-be) on methodologies and data reproducibility. After", "to delete my question given its duplicate nature. Should people", "answers, I wondered if I was in the right to", "people who realize that their questions are duplicates delete their", "delete my question given its duplicate nature. Should people who", "given its duplicate nature. Should people who realize that their", "a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97792/how-precise-should-data-methodology-be) on methodologies and data reproducibility. After finding my", "on methodologies and data reproducibility. After finding my answers, I", "in the right to delete my question given its duplicate", "its duplicate nature. Should people who realize that their questions", "my question given its duplicate nature. Should people who realize", "posted a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97792/how-precise-should-data-methodology-be) on methodologies and data reproducibility. After finding", "right to delete my question given its duplicate nature. Should", "After finding my answers, I wondered if I was in", "reproducibility. After finding my answers, I wondered if I was", "data reproducibility. After finding my answers, I wondered if I", "was in the right to delete my question given its", "question given its duplicate nature. Should people who realize that", "the right to delete my question given its duplicate nature.", "who realize that their questions are duplicates delete their questions?", "Should people who realize that their questions are duplicates delete", "wondered if I was in the right to delete my", "I was in the right to delete my question given", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97792/how-precise-should-data-methodology-be) on methodologies and data reproducibility. After finding my answers,", "nature. **Should people who realize that their questions are duplicates", "finding my answers, I wondered if I was in the", "and data reproducibility. After finding my answers, I wondered if", "I recently posted a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97792/how-precise-should-data-methodology-be) on methodologies and data reproducibility.", "I wondered if I was in the right to delete" ]
[ "down alternative offers safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer with other", "an individual basis. What do you think about it? (I", "on the subject. On the other hand, I am not", "general answer exists --- maybe all these questions have peculiarities", "it OK to turn down a postdoc offer (contract not", "in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This would suggest to write a \"canonical", "about it? (I am not asking this because I wish", "[Is it OK to turn down a postdoc offer (contract", "them to be answered on an individual basis. What do", "when multiple positions have incompatible deadlines. The last example is", "Other older examples are [Is it OK to turn down", "how to behave when multiple positions have incompatible deadlines. The", "individual basis. What do you think about it? (I am", "I don't think I am experienced enough to answer this.)", "and then people ask whether it is appropriate to leave", "peculiarities that require them to be answered on an individual", "case how to behave when multiple positions have incompatible deadlines.", "any case how to behave when multiple positions have incompatible", "people ask whether it is appropriate to leave a (phd,", "accepted for a better one that became available later, or", "it? (I am not asking this because I wish to", "for a better one that became available later, or in", "that became available later, or in any case how to", "[Tenure-track offer with other applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This would", "\"canonical question\" on the subject. On the other hand, I", "with other applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This would suggest to", "is [Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other older examples are [Is", "the other hand, I am not so sure that a", "I wish to write myself the canonical question and answer", "I am not so sure that a general answer exists", "answer exists --- maybe all these questions have peculiarities that", "sure that a general answer exists --- maybe all these", "on the contrary, I don't think I am experienced enough", "question\" on the subject. On the other hand, I am", "multiple positions have incompatible deadlines. The last example is [Swap", "wish to write myself the canonical question and answer --", "This would suggest to write a \"canonical question\" on the", "postdoc offer (contract not signed yet) after getting a better", "ask whether it is appropriate to leave a (phd, postdoc,", "incompatible deadlines. The last example is [Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) .", "progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This would suggest to write a \"canonical question\"", "applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This would suggest to write a", ". This would suggest to write a \"canonical question\" on", "in any case how to behave when multiple positions have", "answered on an individual basis. What do you think about", "exists --- maybe all these questions have peculiarities that require", "subject. On the other hand, I am not so sure", "require them to be answered on an individual basis. What", "position they have accepted for a better one that became", "examples are [Is it OK to turn down a postdoc", "offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions: turning down alternative offers safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely),", "to turn down a postdoc offer (contract not signed yet)", "turn down a postdoc offer (contract not signed yet) after", "so sure that a general answer exists --- maybe all", "signed yet) after getting a better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions:", "one that became available later, or in any case how", "postdoc, tenure-track...) position they have accepted for a better one", "and answer -- on the contrary, I don't think I", "this because I wish to write myself the canonical question", "asking this because I wish to write myself the canonical", "the canonical question and answer -- on the contrary, I", "am not so sure that a general answer exists ---", "deadlines. The last example is [Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other", "do you think about it? (I am not asking this", "(phd, postdoc, tenure-track...) position they have accepted for a better", "other applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This would suggest to write", "On the other hand, I am not so sure that", "better one that became available later, or in any case", "getting a better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions: turning down alternative", "be answered on an individual basis. What do you think", "behave when multiple positions have incompatible deadlines. The last example", "you think about it? (I am not asking this because", "(I am not asking this because I wish to write", "positions: turning down alternative offers safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer", "basis. What do you think about it? (I am not", "[Postdoc positions: turning down alternative offers safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track", "or in any case how to behave when multiple positions", "would suggest to write a \"canonical question\" on the subject.", "these questions have peculiarities that require them to be answered", "safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer with other applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/)", "a better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions: turning down alternative offers", "it is appropriate to leave a (phd, postdoc, tenure-track...) position", "down a postdoc offer (contract not signed yet) after getting", "because I wish to write myself the canonical question and", "timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer with other applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This", "a postdoc offer (contract not signed yet) after getting a", "contrary, I don't think I am experienced enough to answer", "write a \"canonical question\" on the subject. On the other", "question and answer -- on the contrary, I don't think", "offers safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer with other applications in", "turning down alternative offers safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer with", "a better one that became available later, or in any", "hand, I am not so sure that a general answer", "a general answer exists --- maybe all these questions have", "to leave a (phd, postdoc, tenure-track...) position they have accepted", "maybe all these questions have peculiarities that require them to", "[Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other older examples are [Is it", "answer -- on the contrary, I don't think I am", "offer (contract not signed yet) after getting a better postdoc", ". Other older examples are [Is it OK to turn", "write myself the canonical question and answer -- on the", "later, or in any case how to behave when multiple", "offer with other applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) . This would suggest", "The last example is [Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other older", "other hand, I am not so sure that a general", "--- maybe all these questions have peculiarities that require them", "they have accepted for a better one that became available", "to write a \"canonical question\" on the subject. On the", "are [Is it OK to turn down a postdoc offer", "think about it? (I am not asking this because I", "available later, or in any case how to behave when", "example is [Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other older examples are", "am not asking this because I wish to write myself", "yet) after getting a better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions: turning", "better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions: turning down alternative offers safely", "Every now and then people ask whether it is appropriate", "the contrary, I don't think I am experienced enough to", "then people ask whether it is appropriate to leave a", "have incompatible deadlines. The last example is [Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position)", "tenure-track...) position they have accepted for a better one that", "the subject. On the other hand, I am not so", "have peculiarities that require them to be answered on an", "canonical question and answer -- on the contrary, I don't", "a (phd, postdoc, tenure-track...) position they have accepted for a", "appropriate to leave a (phd, postdoc, tenure-track...) position they have", "whether it is appropriate to leave a (phd, postdoc, tenure-track...)", "that a general answer exists --- maybe all these questions", "not asking this because I wish to write myself the", "older examples are [Is it OK to turn down a", "and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer with other applications in progress](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/87912/tenure-track-offer-with-other-applications-in-progress/) .", "questions have peculiarities that require them to be answered on", "not signed yet) after getting a better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc", "Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other older examples are [Is it OK", "all these questions have peculiarities that require them to be", "have accepted for a better one that became available later,", "What do you think about it? (I am not asking", "OK to turn down a postdoc offer (contract not signed", "to behave when multiple positions have incompatible deadlines. The last", "myself the canonical question and answer -- on the contrary,", "after getting a better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions: turning down", "not so sure that a general answer exists --- maybe", "is appropriate to leave a (phd, postdoc, tenure-track...) position they", "(contract not signed yet) after getting a better postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1),", "postdoc offer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/74864/is-it-ok-to-turn-down-a-postdoc-offer-contract-not-signed-yet-after-getting-a?rq=1), [Postdoc positions: turning down alternative offers safely and", "on an individual basis. What do you think about it?", "became available later, or in any case how to behave", "suggest to write a \"canonical question\" on the subject. On", "last example is [Swap Postdoc position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other older examples", "-- on the contrary, I don't think I am experienced", "that require them to be answered on an individual basis.", "to be answered on an individual basis. What do you", "leave a (phd, postdoc, tenure-track...) position they have accepted for", "to write myself the canonical question and answer -- on", "alternative offers safely and timely](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90104/postdoc-positions-turning-down-alternative-offers-safely-and-timely), [Tenure-track offer with other applications", "positions have incompatible deadlines. The last example is [Swap Postdoc", "now and then people ask whether it is appropriate to", "a \"canonical question\" on the subject. On the other hand,", "position](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/97808/swap-postdoc-position) . Other older examples are [Is it OK to" ]
[ "generate many debates: Would such a notice be useful for", "> > We sometimes receive questions about gender issues, harassment", "> We sometimes receive questions about gender issues, harassment etc.", "receive questions about gender issues, harassment etc. that generate many", "You may use answers ONLY to provide a solution to", "to the specific question asked above. Moderators will remove debates,", "question asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions", "debates: Would such a notice be useful for our community", "comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY", "a post notice for sensitive, possibly controversial topics. The notice", "answers ONLY to provide a solution to the specific question", "Controversial Post — You may use comments ONLY to suggest", "improvements. You may use answers ONLY to provide a solution", "solution to the specific question asked above. Moderators will remove", "suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY to provide a", "> > Controversial Post — You may use comments ONLY", "remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice. > > >", "for sensitive, possibly controversial topics. The notice recites: > >", "to this [meta post](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/302609/300001), the SE staff has implemented for", "post](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/302609/300001), the SE staff has implemented for a couple of", "post notice for sensitive, possibly controversial topics. The notice recites:", "opinions without notice. > > > We sometimes receive questions", "notice. > > > We sometimes receive questions about gender", "> Controversial Post — You may use comments ONLY to", "Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice. >", "etc. that generate many debates: Would such a notice be", "possibly controversial topics. The notice recites: > > Controversial Post", "harassment etc. that generate many debates: Would such a notice", "The notice recites: > > Controversial Post — You may", "about gender issues, harassment etc. that generate many debates: Would", "notice recites: > > Controversial Post — You may use", "communities a post notice for sensitive, possibly controversial topics. The", "staff has implemented for a couple of communities a post", "a solution to the specific question asked above. Moderators will", "[meta post](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/302609/300001), the SE staff has implemented for a couple", "use answers ONLY to provide a solution to the specific", "to provide a solution to the specific question asked above.", "without notice. > > > We sometimes receive questions about", "questions about gender issues, harassment etc. that generate many debates:", "— You may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You", "notice for sensitive, possibly controversial topics. The notice recites: >", "debates, arguments or opinions without notice. > > > We", "ONLY to provide a solution to the specific question asked", "arguments or opinions without notice. > > > We sometimes", "couple of communities a post notice for sensitive, possibly controversial", "gender issues, harassment etc. that generate many debates: Would such", "that generate many debates: Would such a notice be useful", "above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice.", "> > > We sometimes receive questions about gender issues,", "You may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may", "has implemented for a couple of communities a post notice", "this [meta post](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/302609/300001), the SE staff has implemented for a", "the specific question asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments", "or opinions without notice. > > > We sometimes receive", "may use answers ONLY to provide a solution to the", "the SE staff has implemented for a couple of communities", "sensitive, possibly controversial topics. The notice recites: > > Controversial", "may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use", "sometimes receive questions about gender issues, harassment etc. that generate", "to suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY to provide", "We sometimes receive questions about gender issues, harassment etc. that", "SE staff has implemented for a couple of communities a", "According to this [meta post](https://meta.stackexchange.com/a/302609/300001), the SE staff has implemented", "provide a solution to the specific question asked above. Moderators", "implemented for a couple of communities a post notice for", "ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY to", "controversial topics. The notice recites: > > Controversial Post —", "Post — You may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements.", "topics. The notice recites: > > Controversial Post — You", "will remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice. > >", "many debates: Would such a notice be useful for our", "issues, harassment etc. that generate many debates: Would such a", "use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use answers", "recites: > > Controversial Post — You may use comments", "specific question asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or", "Would such a notice be useful for our community as", "asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions without", "such a notice be useful for our community as well?", "a couple of communities a post notice for sensitive, possibly", "for a couple of communities a post notice for sensitive,", "of communities a post notice for sensitive, possibly controversial topics." ]
[ "Saturday(4 Nov), I just bought Barron's Books to preparation and", "to my surprise, the test felt way to easy. It's", "being trolled by the book? Talking about Physics I checked", "do not have any intentions to offend anyone. I'm in", "Books to preparation and to my surprise, the test felt", "ques in 60 mins, is mad. But are SAT Subject", "from India, I got a question regarding SAT Subject Tests", "then they are really easy. Time is surely a problem,", "Barron's Books to preparation and to my surprise, the test", "The questions are mostly conceptual which is nice cause calculator", "a problem, I mean 75 ques in 60 mins, is", "too. The questions are mostly conceptual which is nice cause", "are really easy. Time is surely a problem, I mean", "is mad. But are SAT Subject Tests made this easy?", "trying to insult the US education system so if at", "the US education system so if at any point my", "education system so if at any point my post suggest", "any intentions to offend anyone. I'm in no way trying", "questions are mostly conceptual which is nice cause calculator is", "I mean 75 ques in 60 mins, is mad. But", "But are SAT Subject Tests made this easy? [Take a", "mostly conceptual which is nice cause calculator is not allowed", "in 60 mins, is mad. But are SAT Subject Tests", "is it really that easy or I'm being trolled by", "post is below: --- NOTE: I do not have any", "to offend anyone. I'm in no way trying to insult", "not allowed but even then they are really easy. Time", "is surely a problem, I mean 75 ques in 60", "post it on the main site. Is there some other", "I can get help? My post is below: --- NOTE:", "this Saturday(4 Nov), I just bought Barron's Books to preparation", "so if at any point my post suggest that I'm,", "point my post suggest that I'm, I apologize. I have", "to be true so my question is; is it really", "Maths II and Physics Subject Test this Saturday(4 Nov), I", "conceptual which is nice cause calculator is not allowed but", "post suggest that I'm, I apologize.* I have a SAT", "easy. Time is surely a problem, I mean 75 ques", "a SAT Maths II and Physics Subject Test this Saturday(4", "cracksat.com too. The questions are mostly conceptual which is nice", "I got a question regarding SAT Subject Tests but I'm", "a high school student from India, I got a question", "that easy or I'm being trolled by the book? Talking", "good to be true so my question is; is it", "about Physics I checked a full length paper on cracksat.com", "trolled by the book? Talking about Physics I checked a", "be true so my question is; is it really that", "there some other site where I can get help? My", "to easy. It's like too good to be true so", "is nice cause calculator is not allowed but even then", "my post suggest that I'm, I apologize.* I have a", "I apologize.* I have a SAT Maths II and Physics", "60 mins, is mad. But are SAT Subject Tests made", "full length paper on cracksat.com too. The questions are mostly", "I checked a full length paper on cracksat.com too. The", "75 ques in 60 mins, is mad. But are SAT", "question regarding SAT Subject Tests but I'm not sure if", "is; is it really that easy or I'm being trolled", "are SAT Subject Tests made this easy? [Take a Look", "but I'm not sure if I can post it on", "SAT Maths II and Physics Subject Test this Saturday(4 Nov),", "by the book? Talking about Physics I checked a full", "got a question regarding SAT Subject Tests but I'm not", "--- NOTE: I do not have any intentions to offend", "anyone. I'm in no way trying to insult the US", "calculator is not allowed but even then they are really", "is below: --- NOTE:* I do not have any intentions", "it really that easy or I'm being trolled by the", "not sure if I can post it on the main", "and Physics Subject Test this Saturday(4 Nov), I just bought", "a question regarding SAT Subject Tests but I'm not sure", "on the main site. Is there some other site where", "even then they are really easy. Time is surely a", "Is there some other site where I can get help?", "so my question is; is it really that easy or", "easy. It's like too good to be true so my", "India, I got a question regarding SAT Subject Tests but", "test felt way to easy. It's like too good to", "sure if I can post it on the main site.", "It's like too good to be true so my question", "intentions to offend anyone. I'm in no way trying to", "just bought Barron's Books to preparation and to my surprise,", "true so my question is; is it really that easy", "can get help? My post is below: --- NOTE:* I", "US education system so if at any point my post", "I'm not sure if I can post it on the", "which is nice cause calculator is not allowed but even", "main site. Is there some other site where I can", "way to easy. It's like too good to be true", "on cracksat.com too. The questions are mostly conceptual which is", "nice cause calculator is not allowed but even then they", "student from India, I got a question regarding SAT Subject", "have any intentions to offend anyone. I'm in no way", "I just bought Barron's Books to preparation and to my", "they are really easy. Time is surely a problem, I", "I'm a high school student from India, I got a", "II and Physics Subject Test this Saturday(4 Nov), I just", "Tests but I'm not sure if I can post it", "this easy? [Take a Look at this for example](http://www.cracksat.net/sat2/physics/test616.html) ---", "the book? Talking about Physics* I checked a full length", "system so if at any point my post suggest that", "mean 75 ques in 60 mins, is mad. But are", "have a SAT Maths II and Physics Subject Test this", "any point my post suggest that I'm, I apologize.* I", "I'm, I apologize.* I have a SAT Maths II and", "my question is; is it really that easy or I'm", "is not allowed but even then they are really easy.", "insult the US education system so if at any point", "surprise, the test felt way to easy. It's like too", "Subject Test this Saturday(4 Nov), I just bought Barron's Books", "preparation and to my surprise, the test felt way to", "help? My post is below: --- NOTE: I do not", "regarding SAT Subject Tests but I'm not sure if I", "really that easy or I'm being trolled by the book?", "SAT Subject Tests but I'm not sure if I can", "Subject Tests made this easy? [Take a Look at this", "Physics Subject Test this Saturday(4 Nov), I just bought Barron's", "no way trying to insult the US education system so", "the test felt way to easy. It's like too good", "at any point my post suggest that I'm, I apologize.", "length paper on cracksat.com too. The questions are mostly conceptual", "where I can get help? My post is below: ---", "paper on cracksat.com too. The questions are mostly conceptual which", "problem, I mean 75 ques in 60 mins, is mad.", "that I'm, I apologize.* I have a SAT Maths II", "site where I can get help? My post is below:", "Subject Tests but I'm not sure if I can post", "suggest that I'm, I apologize.* I have a SAT Maths", "book? Talking about Physics I checked a full length paper", "high school student from India, I got a question regarding", "if I can post it on the main site. Is", "I'm in no way trying to insult the US education", "Talking about Physics I checked a full length paper on", "Tests made this easy? [Take a Look at this for", "bought Barron's Books to preparation and to my surprise, the", "easy or I'm being trolled by the book? Talking about", "some other site where I can get help? My post", "like too good to be true so my question is;", "to preparation and to my surprise, the test felt way", "or I'm being trolled by the book? Talking about Physics", "get help? My post is below: --- NOTE:** I do", "mad. But are SAT Subject Tests made this easy? [Take", "too good to be true so my question is; is", "Time is surely a problem, I mean 75 ques in", "are mostly conceptual which is nice cause calculator is not", "I have a SAT Maths II and Physics Subject Test", "and to my surprise, the test felt way to easy.", "if at any point my post suggest that I'm, I", "I'm being trolled by the book? Talking about Physics* I", "surely a problem, I mean 75 ques in 60 mins,", "question is; is it really that easy or I'm being", "mins, is mad. But are SAT Subject Tests made this", "I do not have any intentions to offend anyone. I'm", "offend anyone. I'm in no way trying to insult the", "in no way trying to insult the US education system", "to insult the US education system so if at any", "my surprise, the test felt way to easy. It's like", "can post it on the main site. Is there some", "cause calculator is not allowed but even then they are", "Nov), I just bought Barron's Books to preparation and to", "it on the main site. Is there some other site", "I can post it on the main site. Is there", "the main site. Is there some other site where I", "below: --- NOTE:* I do not have any intentions to", "Physics* I checked a full length paper on cracksat.com too.", "made this easy? [Take a Look at this for example](http://www.cracksat.net/sat2/physics/test616.html)", "apologize.* I have a SAT Maths II and Physics Subject", "felt way to easy. It's like too good to be", "NOTE: I do not have any intentions to offend anyone.", "allowed but even then they are really easy. Time is", "a full length paper on cracksat.com too. The questions are", "checked a full length paper on cracksat.com too. The questions", "school student from India, I got a question regarding SAT", "way trying to insult the US education system so if", "other site where I can get help? My post is", "not have any intentions to offend anyone. I'm in no", "site. Is there some other site where I can get", "Test this Saturday(4 Nov), I just bought Barron's Books to", "really easy. Time is surely a problem, I mean 75", "My post is below: --- NOTE:* *I do not have", "SAT Subject Tests made this easy? [Take a Look at", "but even then they are really easy. Time is surely" ]
[ "a research field about academia and/or science will give me", "too much)?\", and I don't think that is of any", "and academia work (without having to browse Academia.SE too much)?\",", "off-topic reason. Isn't looking for a research field about academia", "science and academia work (without having to browse Academia.SE too", "that is of any off-topic reason. Isn't looking for a", "browse Academia.SE too much)?\", and I don't think that is", "form, but it is stemmed from the question \"how to", "are convoluted and I want to have a broadest view", "its current form, but it is stemmed from the question", "and/or science will give me a systematic understanding on them?", "about academia and/or science will give me a systematic understanding", "(text)book on how academia works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree that it looks", "\"how to have a systematic understanding on how science and", "academia and/or science will give me a systematic understanding on", "question \"how to have a systematic understanding on how science", "request as its current form, but it is stemmed from", "Isn't looking for a research field about academia and/or science", "work (without having to browse Academia.SE too much)?\", and I", "on science and academia separately since they are convoluted and", "[Is there a (text)book on how academia works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree", "they are convoluted and I want to have a broadest", "the question \"how to have a systematic understanding on how", "on them? It's also hard to ask questions on science", "systematic understanding on them? It's also hard to ask questions", "also hard to ask questions on science and academia separately", "I agree that it looks like a shopping request as", "It's also hard to ask questions on science and academia", "on how academia works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree that it looks like", "academia separately since they are convoluted and I want to", "how science and academia work (without having to browse Academia.SE", "stemmed from the question \"how to have a systematic understanding", "separately since they are convoluted and I want to have", "think that is of any off-topic reason. Isn't looking for", "questions on science and academia separately since they are convoluted", "shopping request as its current form, but it is stemmed", "understanding on them? It's also hard to ask questions on", "them? It's also hard to ask questions on science and", "research field about academia and/or science will give me a", "convoluted and I want to have a broadest view first.", "me a systematic understanding on them? It's also hard to", "on how science and academia work (without having to browse", "how academia works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree that it looks like a", "to have a systematic understanding on how science and academia", "there a (text)book on how academia works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree that", "of any off-topic reason. Isn't looking for a research field", "any off-topic reason. Isn't looking for a research field about", "current form, but it is stemmed from the question \"how", "field about academia and/or science will give me a systematic", "Academia.SE too much)?\", and I don't think that is of", "to ask questions on science and academia separately since they", "and academia separately since they are convoluted and I want", "that it looks like a shopping request as its current", "don't think that is of any off-topic reason. Isn't looking", "reason. Isn't looking for a research field about academia and/or", "a systematic understanding on how science and academia work (without", "looks like a shopping request as its current form, but", "have a systematic understanding on how science and academia work", "academia work (without having to browse Academia.SE too much)?\", and", "to browse Academia.SE too much)?\", and I don't think that", "will give me a systematic understanding on them? It's also", "ask questions on science and academia separately since they are", "systematic understanding on how science and academia work (without having", "a systematic understanding on them? It's also hard to ask", "hard to ask questions on science and academia separately since", "looking for a research field about academia and/or science will", "from the question \"how to have a systematic understanding on", "since they are convoluted and I want to have a", "(without having to browse Academia.SE too much)?\", and I don't", "I don't think that is of any off-topic reason. Isn't", "it looks like a shopping request as its current form,", "understanding on how science and academia work (without having to", "is stemmed from the question \"how to have a systematic", "like a shopping request as its current form, but it", "it is stemmed from the question \"how to have a", "as its current form, but it is stemmed from the", "much)?\", and I don't think that is of any off-topic", "is of any off-topic reason. Isn't looking for a research", "give me a systematic understanding on them? It's also hard", "agree that it looks like a shopping request as its", "academia works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree that it looks like a shopping", "for a research field about academia and/or science will give", "a shopping request as its current form, but it is", "works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree that it looks like a shopping request", "science and academia separately since they are convoluted and I", "having to browse Academia.SE too much)?\", and I don't think", "science will give me a systematic understanding on them? It's", "but it is stemmed from the question \"how to have", "and I don't think that is of any off-topic reason.", "a (text)book on how academia works?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/98282/14341) I agree that it" ]
[ "? I don't see any outstanding reason for deletion. It's", "reason for deletion. It's been downvoted, but that doesn't mean", "any outstanding reason for deletion. It's been downvoted, but that", "see any outstanding reason for deletion. It's been downvoted, but", "I don't see any outstanding reason for deletion. It's been", "don't see any outstanding reason for deletion. It's been downvoted,", "deletion. It's been downvoted, but that doesn't mean it has", "It's been downvoted, but that doesn't mean it has to", "downvoted, but that doesn't mean it has to disappear from", "that doesn't mean it has to disappear from the website.", "but that doesn't mean it has to disappear from the", "outstanding reason for deletion. It's been downvoted, but that doesn't", "been downvoted, but that doesn't mean it has to disappear", "for deletion. It's been downvoted, but that doesn't mean it", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98458/958> ? I don't see any outstanding reason for deletion." ]
[ "namely, how to start the PhD studies properly, and this", "do it, at least not now\". `R` is not an", "my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How to find the gap of knowledge\"", "actually fits his or her real question (here: how to", "am sure that such inadequacies pop up every once in", "the gap of knowledge\" (denoted by `Q` in the following).", "community should address these pairs exactly, but being aware of", "and this different question is, probably, much more important to", "as an answer to `Q`, the posting `R` illogical. The", "I guess, this is because `R` is an answer to", "by `Q` in the following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by `R`", "different question, namely, how to start the PhD studies properly,", "a different question, namely, how to start the PhD studies", "it, at least not now\". `R` is not an answer", "helpful to the author of `Q` (denoted by `A` in", "no wish to reformulate the question such that it actually", "(denoted by `Q` in the following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by", "written in `Q`. There is an inadequacy of the pair", "logically or linguistically speaking. However, `R` has apparently been so", "an answer to a different question, namely, how to start", "\"don't do it, at least not now\". `R` is not", "start working towards a PhD) rather than the issue formally", "PhD studies properly, and this different question is, probably, much", "following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by `R` in the following) says,", "is because `R` is an answer to a different question,", "in the following) such that `A` marked `R` as an", "important to `A`. As an answer to \"how to start", "inadequacies pop up every once in a while. Not sure", "PhD studies properly\", I like `R`, and do like it", "the issue formally written in `Q`. There is an inadequacy", "`R` is not an answer to `A`, at least logically", "for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How to find the gap of", "that such inadequacies pop up every once in a while.", "illogical. The particular case is exacerbated by the fact that", "wish to reformulate the question such that it actually fits", "accepted solution. I guess, this is because `R` is an", "is, probably, much more important to `A`. As an answer", "as an accepted solution. I guess, this is because `R`", "posting [How to find a gap in knowledge, for my", "once in a while. Not sure how the community should", "reformulate the question such that it actually fits his or", "question is, probably, much more important to `A`. As an", "such inadequacies pop up every once in a while. Not", "essentially, \"don't do it, at least not now\". `R` is", "least not now\". `R` is not an answer to `A`,", "the following) such that `A` marked `R` as an accepted", "by `A` in the following) such that `A` marked `R`", "to reformulate the question such that it actually fits his", "to a different question, namely, how to start the PhD", "\"question - answer\" here. I am sure that such inadequacies", "an accepted solution. I guess, this is because `R` is", "(here: how to start working towards a PhD) rather than", "the PhD studies properly, and this different question is, probably,", "properly, and this different question is, probably, much more important", "these issues or addressing them would probably raise the quality", "the fact that `A` has shown no wish to reformulate", "much more important to `A`. As an answer to \"how", "is an inadequacy of the pair \"question - answer\" here.", "like it a lot. But as an answer to `Q`,", "author of `Q` (denoted by `A` in the following) such", "to `Q`, the posting `R` illogical. The particular case is", "the following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by `R` in the following)", "the following) says, essentially, \"don't do it, at least not", "at least not now\". `R` is not an answer to", "pair \"question - answer\" here. I am sure that such", "in a while. Not sure how the community should address", "but being aware of these issues or addressing them would", "Not sure how the community should address these pairs exactly,", "pop up every once in a while. Not sure how", "gap of knowledge\" (denoted by `Q` in the following). [The", "following) says, essentially, \"don't do it, at least not now\".", "`A` in the following) such that `A` marked `R` as", "a while. Not sure how the community should address these", "has apparently been so helpful to the author of `Q`", "studies properly, and this different question is, probably, much more", "PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How to find the gap of knowledge\" (denoted", "do like it a lot. But as an answer to", "start the PhD studies properly, and this different question is,", "in knowledge, for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How to find the", "The particular case is exacerbated by the fact that `A`", "aware of these issues or addressing them would probably raise", "find a gap in knowledge, for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How", "how to start the PhD studies properly, and this different", "[The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by `R` in the following) says, essentially,", "a PhD) rather than the issue formally written in `Q`.", "it a lot. But as an answer to `Q`, the", "knowledge\" (denoted by `Q` in the following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted", "studies properly\", I like `R`, and do like it a", "by `R` in the following) says, essentially, \"don't do it,", "answer to a different question, namely, how to start the", "answer to \"how to start the PhD studies properly\", I", "or linguistically speaking. However, `R` has apparently been so helpful", "an answer to \"how to start the PhD studies properly\",", "But as an answer to `Q`, the posting `R` illogical.", "an answer to `Q`, the posting `R` illogical. The particular", "apparently been so helpful to the author of `Q` (denoted", "to start the PhD studies properly, and this different question", "shown no wish to reformulate the question such that it", "to `A`, at least logically or linguistically speaking. However, `R`", "question, namely, how to start the PhD studies properly, and", "of the pair \"question - answer\" here. I am sure", "rather than the issue formally written in `Q`. There is", "this different question is, probably, much more important to `A`.", "start the PhD studies properly\", I like `R`, and do", "I like `R`, and do like it a lot. But", "up every once in a while. Not sure how the", "while. Not sure how the community should address these pairs", "find the gap of knowledge\" (denoted by `Q` in the", "issue formally written in `Q`. There is an inadequacy of", "to find a gap in knowledge, for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks", "to the author of `Q` (denoted by `A` in the", "the posting `R` illogical. The particular case is exacerbated by", "at least logically or linguistically speaking. However, `R` has apparently", "by the fact that `A` has shown no wish to", "than the issue formally written in `Q`. There is an", "to start the PhD studies properly\", I like `R`, and", "the question such that it actually fits his or her", "in the following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by `R` in the", "an answer to `A`, at least logically or linguistically speaking.", "`R` in the following) says, essentially, \"don't do it, at", "address these pairs exactly, but being aware of these issues", "As an answer to \"how to start the PhD studies", "of knowledge\" (denoted by `Q` in the following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454)", "sure that such inadequacies pop up every once in a", "`R` as an accepted solution. I guess, this is because", "so helpful to the author of `Q` (denoted by `A`", "the PhD studies properly\", I like `R`, and do like", "marked `R` as an accepted solution. I guess, this is", "of `Q` (denoted by `A` in the following) such that", "or her real question (here: how to start working towards", "\"how to start the PhD studies properly\", I like `R`,", "gap in knowledge, for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How to find", "because `R` is an answer to a different question, namely,", "to start working towards a PhD) rather than the issue", "following) such that `A` marked `R` as an accepted solution.", "to `A`. As an answer to \"how to start the", "posting `R` illogical. The particular case is exacerbated by the", "`Q`. There is an inadequacy of the pair \"question -", "`Q` (denoted by `A` in the following) such that `A`", "a lot. But as an answer to `Q`, the posting", "lot. But as an answer to `Q`, the posting `R`", "to find the gap of knowledge\" (denoted by `Q` in", "the pair \"question - answer\" here. I am sure that", "in `Q`. There is an inadequacy of the pair \"question", "the community should address these pairs exactly, but being aware", "The posting [How to find a gap in knowledge, for", "question (here: how to start working towards a PhD) rather", "should address these pairs exactly, but being aware of these", "particular case is exacerbated by the fact that `A` has", "in the following) says, essentially, \"don't do it, at least", "(denoted by `A` in the following) such that `A` marked", "that `A` marked `R` as an accepted solution. I guess,", "these pairs exactly, but being aware of these issues or", "formally written in `Q`. There is an inadequacy of the", "`A` marked `R` as an accepted solution. I guess, this", "is not an answer to `A`, at least logically or", "of these issues or addressing them would probably raise the", "`Q` in the following). [The posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by `R` in", "now\". `R` is not an answer to `A`, at least", "different question is, probably, much more important to `A`. As", "how the community should address these pairs exactly, but being", "it actually fits his or her real question (here: how", "an inadequacy of the pair \"question - answer\" here. I", "this is because `R` is an answer to a different", "and do like it a lot. But as an answer", "solution. I guess, this is because `R` is an answer", "- answer\" here. I am sure that such inadequacies pop", "sure how the community should address these pairs exactly, but", "has shown no wish to reformulate the question such that", "answer to `A`, at least logically or linguistically speaking. However,", "real question (here: how to start working towards a PhD)", "a gap in knowledge, for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How to", "posting](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/98509/80454) (denoted by `R` in the following) says, essentially, \"don't", "addressing them would probably raise the quality of the site.", "`R` illogical. The particular case is exacerbated by the fact", "answer to `Q`, the posting `R` illogical. The particular case", "such that `A` marked `R` as an accepted solution. I", "guess, this is because `R` is an answer to a", "every once in a while. Not sure how the community", "exactly, but being aware of these issues or addressing them", "fits his or her real question (here: how to start", "his or her real question (here: how to start working", "not an answer to `A`, at least logically or linguistically", "that it actually fits his or her real question (here:", "case is exacerbated by the fact that `A` has shown", "question such that it actually fits his or her real", "probably, much more important to `A`. As an answer to", "properly\", I like `R`, and do like it a lot.", "that `A` has shown no wish to reformulate the question", "\"How to find the gap of knowledge\" (denoted by `Q`", "more important to `A`. As an answer to \"how to", "fact that `A` has shown no wish to reformulate the", "her real question (here: how to start working towards a", "how to start working towards a PhD) rather than the", "(denoted by `R` in the following) says, essentially, \"don't do", "asks \"How to find the gap of knowledge\" (denoted by", "answer\" here. I am sure that such inadequacies pop up", "`R` has apparently been so helpful to the author of", "PhD) rather than the issue formally written in `Q`. There", "or addressing them would probably raise the quality of the", "is exacerbated by the fact that `A` has shown no", "issues or addressing them would probably raise the quality of", "pairs exactly, but being aware of these issues or addressing", "`A` has shown no wish to reformulate the question such", "linguistically speaking. However, `R` has apparently been so helpful to", "`R` is an answer to a different question, namely, how", "been so helpful to the author of `Q` (denoted by", "speaking. However, `R` has apparently been so helpful to the", "I am sure that such inadequacies pop up every once", "to \"how to start the PhD studies properly\", I like", "exacerbated by the fact that `A` has shown no wish", "like `R`, and do like it a lot. But as", "the author of `Q` (denoted by `A` in the following)", "`Q`, the posting `R` illogical. The particular case is exacerbated", "knowledge, for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it) asks \"How to find the gap", "`A`. As an answer to \"how to start the PhD", "says, essentially, \"don't do it, at least not now\". `R`", "towards a PhD) rather than the issue formally written in", "such that it actually fits his or her real question", "`R`, and do like it a lot. But as an", "being aware of these issues or addressing them would probably", "`A`, at least logically or linguistically speaking. However, `R` has", "inadequacy of the pair \"question - answer\" here. I am", "here. I am sure that such inadequacies pop up every", "is an answer to a different question, namely, how to", "There is an inadequacy of the pair \"question - answer\"", "not now\". `R` is not an answer to `A`, at", "least logically or linguistically speaking. However, `R` has apparently been", "working towards a PhD) rather than the issue formally written", "However, `R` has apparently been so helpful to the author", "[How to find a gap in knowledge, for my PhD?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98469/the-gap-of-knowledge-how-can-we-find-it)" ]
[ "the bigger picture, wouldn't there be reason to believe future", "at most), I would prefer that the effort was not", "bad questions would prefer that their efforts are not deleted", "picture, wouldn't there be reason to believe future authors of", "OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite the negative connotations, would there be", "Please excuse the potential bias as the person who answered", "the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite the negative connotations, would there", "there be reason to believe future authors of answers to", "authors of answers to bad questions would prefer that their", "a question that I would agree was in bad taste", "despite the negative connotations, would there be value in allowing", "would there be value in allowing bad questions (that are", "(that are ultimately closed) that had an answer that effectively", "effectively addresses the question? Please excuse the potential bias as", "after very negative commentary from the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite", "ultimately closed) that had an answer that effectively addresses the", "answer that effectively addresses the question? Please excuse the potential", "(15 minutes at most), I would prefer that the effort", "was not wasted. Taking a step back and looking at", "question. Although the cost was not great (15 minutes at", "closed) that had an answer that effectively addresses the question?", "in allowing bad questions (that are ultimately closed) that had", "wasted. Taking a step back and looking at the bigger", "the question. Although the cost was not great (15 minutes", "an answer that effectively addresses the question? Please excuse the", "bias as the person who answered the question. Although the", "bigger picture, wouldn't there be reason to believe future authors", "potential bias as the person who answered the question. Although", "value in allowing bad questions (that are ultimately closed) that", "be reason to believe future authors of answers to bad", "questions (that are ultimately closed) that had an answer that", "commentary from the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite the negative connotations,", "effort was not wasted. Taking a step back and looking", "person who answered the question. Although the cost was not", "believe future authors of answers to bad questions would prefer", "looking at the bigger picture, wouldn't there be reason to", "as the person who answered the question. Although the cost", "very negative commentary from the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite the", "and looking at the bigger picture, wouldn't there be reason", "great (15 minutes at most), I would prefer that the", "answers to bad questions would prefer that their efforts are", "cost was not great (15 minutes at most), I would", "questions would prefer that their efforts are not deleted either?", "there be value in allowing bad questions (that are ultimately", "connotations, would there be value in allowing bad questions (that", "that effectively addresses the question? Please excuse the potential bias", "ff524, deleted a question that I would agree was in", "negative connotations, would there be value in allowing bad questions", "was not great (15 minutes at most), I would prefer", "the question? Please excuse the potential bias as the person", "the negative connotations, would there be value in allowing bad", "in bad taste after very negative commentary from the OP.", "that had an answer that effectively addresses the question? Please", "I would prefer that the effort was not wasted. Taking", "addresses the question? Please excuse the potential bias as the", "be value in allowing bad questions (that are ultimately closed)", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite the negative connotations, would there be value", "future authors of answers to bad questions would prefer that", "not great (15 minutes at most), I would prefer that", "would prefer that the effort was not wasted. Taking a", "I would agree was in bad taste after very negative", "was in bad taste after very negative commentary from the", "a step back and looking at the bigger picture, wouldn't", "But despite the negative connotations, would there be value in", "the cost was not great (15 minutes at most), I", "would agree was in bad taste after very negative commentary", "allowing bad questions (that are ultimately closed) that had an", "question? Please excuse the potential bias as the person who", "at the bigger picture, wouldn't there be reason to believe", "taste after very negative commentary from the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But", "Although the cost was not great (15 minutes at most),", "bad questions (that are ultimately closed) that had an answer", "moderator ff524, deleted a question that I would agree was", "had an answer that effectively addresses the question? Please excuse", "from the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite the negative connotations, would", "not wasted. Taking a step back and looking at the", "bad taste after very negative commentary from the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>.", "deleted a question that I would agree was in bad", "are ultimately closed) that had an answer that effectively addresses", "that the effort was not wasted. Taking a step back", "back and looking at the bigger picture, wouldn't there be", "Very recently moderator ff524, deleted a question that I would", "prefer that the effort was not wasted. Taking a step", "reason to believe future authors of answers to bad questions", "who answered the question. Although the cost was not great", "to believe future authors of answers to bad questions would", "excuse the potential bias as the person who answered the", "the effort was not wasted. Taking a step back and", "question that I would agree was in bad taste after", "most), I would prefer that the effort was not wasted.", "that I would agree was in bad taste after very", "the person who answered the question. Although the cost was", "negative commentary from the OP. <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/98902/is-it-a-good-idea-to-take-several-summer-classes-have-a-tutor-after-school-sinc/98903#98903>. But despite the negative", "the potential bias as the person who answered the question.", "recently moderator ff524, deleted a question that I would agree", "wouldn't there be reason to believe future authors of answers", "answered the question. Although the cost was not great (15", "Taking a step back and looking at the bigger picture,", "step back and looking at the bigger picture, wouldn't there", "agree was in bad taste after very negative commentary from", "of answers to bad questions would prefer that their efforts", "minutes at most), I would prefer that the effort was", "to bad questions would prefer that their efforts are not" ]
[ "of our users enjoy contributing to those other sites, too", "and respect afforded to the user and can be used", "has a role to play, but not to the extent", "the following variables on anonymity in play (not exactly rigorous,", "are from pseudonyms; whether due to inexperience or the buffer", "and can be used as a rough yardstick to measure", "respect afforded to the user and can be used as", "sites that are not as strict about moderation - Reddit,", "not to the extent that I theorize. There are great", "yardstick to measure the experience of the user to the", "this particular case, the [author of the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has", "SE sites, specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely on mathematics topics.", "questions? * Does real-ID mean lower-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms", "I would presume that Anonymity has a role to play,", "in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this particular case, the [author of", "pseudonyms mean lower-quality answers? In my experience at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users)", "the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some experience and interaction with SE", "is deliberately different in its moderation policy, because we try", "various logical derivatives: * Does real-ID mean higher-quality questions? ", "those other sites, too ;) > > > Emphasis mine.", "that I theorize. There are great question and answer contributions", "the SE model. What is the effect of Anonymity on", "But in general, poor-quality questions and answers are from pseudonyms;", "The various logical derivatives: Does real-ID mean higher-quality questions?", "Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality", "case, the [author of the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some experience", "policy, because we try to be a home for people", "as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would presume that Anonymity has a role", "Does real-ID mean higher-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean higher-quality", "But some of our users enjoy contributing to those other", "could be entirely wrong after all, would someone with more", "sites whether with a pseudonym or real-ID. But in general,", "voting system reflected up on a user's contribution. * Effect:", "(not exactly rigorous, but will suffice in the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163):", "afforded to the user and can be used as a", "but will suffice in the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): * Binary: has", "* Integer: based upon a voting system reflected up on", "person's actions and his/her real-life identity) offered by a pseudonym.", "whether with a pseudonym or real-ID. But in general, poor-quality", "a voting system reflected up on a user's contribution. ", "suffice in the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): Binary: has an equivalent", "experience at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would", "and answers are from pseudonyms; whether due to inexperience or", "a pseudonym or real-ID. But in general, poor-quality questions and", "a person's actions and his/her real-life identity) offered by a", "would someone with more expertise on the matter care to", "quality, on topic questions. But some of our users enjoy", "pseudonym, then there is a degree of buffer between the", "quality of questions and answers? The various logical derivatives: ", "pseudonyms mean higher-quality answers? Does real-ID mean lower-quality questions?", "the effect of Anonymity on both the quality of questions", "but not to the extent that I theorize. There are", "SE model. *What is the effect of Anonymity on both", "my experience at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I", "their IRL identity. If pseudonym, then there is a degree", "both sites whether with a pseudonym or real-ID. But in", "enjoy contributing to those other sites, too ;) > >", "Does real-ID mean lower-quality answers? Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality", "with SE sites, specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely on mathematics", "the quality of questions and answers?** The various logical derivatives:", "deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some experience and interaction with SE sites,", "questions and answers in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this particular case,", "the effects of Anonymity on both questions and answers in", "* Effect: more privileges and respect afforded to the user", "play, but not to the extent that I theorize. There", "ff524 on all points. But this led me to think", "What is the effect of Anonymity on both the quality", "based upon a voting system reflected up on a user's", "role to play, but not to the extent that I", "user to the SE model. What is the effect of", "poor-quality questions and answers are from pseudonyms; whether due to", "mean higher-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean higher-quality answers? ", "If pseudonym, then there is a degree of buffer between", "But this led me to think about the effects of", "like answering high quality, on topic questions. But some of", "deliberately different in its moderation policy, because we try to", "about a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524 mentioned, > > There", "as well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would presume that Anonymity has", "- Reddit, etc. SE is deliberately different in its moderation", "on both questions and answers in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this", "a home for people who like answering high quality, on", "would carry over to their IRL identity. If pseudonym, then", "other sites, too ;) > > > Emphasis mine. I", "model. What is the effect of Anonymity on both the", "too ;) > > > Emphasis mine. I agree with", " Binary: has an equivalent real-life ID associated, or a", "this led me to think about the effects of Anonymity", "mentioned, > > There are other sites that are not", "as strict about moderation - Reddit, etc. SE is deliberately", "identity. If pseudonym, then there is a degree of buffer", "In my experience at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users),", "to those other sites, too ;) > > > Emphasis", "we try to be a home for people who like", "real-ID mean lower-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean lower-quality answers?", "a [short discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3873/allowing-questions-that-warranted-a-deletion-but-has-an-answer-that-addresses-t) between myself and moderator ff524 about a", "* Does real-ID mean lower-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean", "pseudonyms mean lower-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality answers?", "experience of the user to the SE model. *What is", "carry over to their IRL identity. If pseudonym, then there", "to think about the effects of Anonymity on both questions", "used as a rough yardstick to measure the experience of", " Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality answers? In my experience at", "of the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some experience and interaction with", "a pseudonym. I could be entirely wrong after all, would", "not as strict about moderation - Reddit, etc. SE is", "pseudonym. * Effect: if real-life, then words said would carry", "real-life identity) offered by a pseudonym. I could be entirely", "mean lower-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean lower-quality answers? ", "in its moderation policy, because we try to be a", "well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would presume that Anonymity has a", "answers? Does real-ID mean lower-quality questions? * Does real-ID", "on all points. But this led me to think about", "some experience and interaction with SE sites, specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi).", "contributing to those other sites, too ;) > > >", "on a user's contribution. * Effect: more privileges and respect", "buffer (between a person's actions and his/her real-life identity) offered", "mean lower-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality questions? ", "people who like answering high quality, on topic questions. But", "There are other sites that are not as strict about", " Does real-ID mean lower-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean", "Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality answers? * Does real-ID mean lower-quality", "high quality, on topic questions*. But some of our users", "[author of the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some experience and interaction", "In this particular case, the [author of the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi)", "[Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): Binary: has an equivalent real-life ID associated, or", "questions and answers are from pseudonyms; whether due to inexperience", "lower-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean lower-quality answers? * Does", "anonymity in play (not exactly rigorous, but will suffice in", "* Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms mean", "purely on mathematics topics. With the following variables on anonymity", "I agree with Moderator ff524 on all points. But this", "the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): * Binary: has an equivalent real-life ID", "the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would presume that", "to be a *home for people who like answering high", "the buffer (between a person's actions and his/her real-life identity)", "on anonymity in play (not exactly rigorous, but will suffice", "to the extent that I theorize. There are great question", "mean higher-quality answers? Does real-ID mean lower-quality questions? ", "in play (not exactly rigorous, but will suffice in the", "that are not as strict about moderation* - Reddit, etc.", "SE is deliberately different in its moderation policy, because we", "[deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524 mentioned, > > There are other", "ff524 mentioned, > > There are other sites that are", "Moderator ff524 mentioned, > > There are other sites that", "about moderation - Reddit, etc. SE is deliberately different in", "a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524 mentioned, > > There are", "to their IRL identity. If pseudonym, then there is a", "answers? In my experience at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well as", "real-ID mean lower-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality questions?", "to measure the experience of the user to the SE", "moderator ff524 about a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524 mentioned, >", "two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer: based upon a voting system reflected", "specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this particular case, the [author of the deleted", "user and can be used as a rough yardstick to", "think about the effects of Anonymity on both questions and", "and answer contributions from users from both sites whether with", "> > > Emphasis mine. I agree with Moderator ff524", "effects of Anonymity on both questions and answers in [Academia", "points. But this led me to think about the effects", "all, would someone with more expertise on the matter care", "has an equivalent real-life ID associated, or a pseudonym. ", "or a pseudonym. Effect: if real-life, then words said", "entirely wrong after all, would someone with more expertise on", "to play, but not to the extent that I theorize.", "[Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this particular case, the [author of the", "can be used as a rough yardstick to measure the", "Moderator ff524 on all points. But this led me to", "then there is a degree of buffer between the two.", "myself and moderator ff524 about a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524", "[short discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3873/allowing-questions-that-warranted-a-deletion-but-has-an-answer-that-addresses-t) between myself and moderator ff524 about a [deleted", "in the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): * Binary: has an equivalent real-life", "will suffice in the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): * Binary: has an", "ID associated, or a pseudonym. * Effect: if real-life, then", "a pseudonym. * Effect: if real-life, then words said would", "upon a voting system reflected up on a user's contribution.", "measure the experience of the user to the SE model.", "questions? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality answers? In my experience", "user's contribution. * Effect: more privileges and respect afforded to", "questions? * Does real-ID mean higher-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms", "moderation policy, because we try to be a home for", "or the buffer (between a person's actions and his/her real-life", "> There are other sites that are not as strict", "has some experience and interaction with SE sites, specifically [Mathematics", "of Anonymity on both the quality of questions and answers?", "There are great question and answer contributions from users from", "about the effects of Anonymity on both questions and answers", "Reddit, etc. SE is deliberately different in its moderation policy,", "variables on anonymity in play (not exactly rigorous, but will", "reflected up on a user's contribution. * Effect: more privileges", "higher-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean higher-quality answers? * Does", "questions. But some of our users enjoy contributing to those", "presume that Anonymity has a role to play, but not", "said would carry over to their IRL identity. If pseudonym,", "offered by a pseudonym. I could be entirely wrong after", "(between a person's actions and his/her real-life identity) offered by", "topic questions. But some of our users enjoy contributing to", "the user to the SE model. *What is the effect", "led me to think about the effects of Anonymity on", "I could be entirely wrong after all, would someone with", "and answers in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this particular case, the", "all points. But this led me to think about the", "be entirely wrong after all, would someone with more expertise", "more privileges and respect afforded to the user and can", "real-ID mean higher-quality questions? Does real-ID mean higher-quality answers?", "real-ID mean higher-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality questions?", "the user and can be used as a rough yardstick", "real-ID. But in general, poor-quality questions and answers are from", "specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely on mathematics topics. With the", "is a degree of buffer between the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): ", "users enjoy contributing to those other sites, too ;) >", "moderation* - Reddit, etc. SE is *deliberately different in its", "Integer: based upon a voting system reflected up on a", " Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms mean", "* Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality answers? * Does real-ID mean", "with a pseudonym or real-ID. But in general, poor-quality questions", "would presume that Anonymity has a role to play, but", "real-life ID associated, or a pseudonym. * Effect: if real-life,", "between the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer: based upon a voting", "be a *home for people who like answering high quality,", "mean higher-quality questions? Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality answers? ", "questions? Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality answers? * Does real-ID", "answers? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms", "identity) offered by a pseudonym. I could be entirely wrong", "a user's contribution. * Effect: more privileges and respect afforded", "its moderation policy, because we try to be a home", "try to be a *home for people who like answering", "sites, too ;) > > > Emphasis mine. I agree", "sites, specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely on mathematics topics. With", "exactly rigorous, but will suffice in the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): ", "questions and answers?** The various logical derivatives: * Does real-ID", "following variables on anonymity in play (not exactly rigorous, but", "strict about moderation - Reddit, etc. SE is deliberately different", "someone with more expertise on the matter care to comment?", "effect of Anonymity on both the quality of questions and", "mean lower-quality answers? In my experience at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as", "Anonymity on both the quality of questions and answers? The", "Does real-ID mean lower-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean lower-quality", "as a rough yardstick to measure the experience of the", "answers in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this particular case, the [author", "me to think about the effects of Anonymity on both", "* Does real-ID mean higher-quality questions? * Does real-ID mean", "etc. SE is deliberately different in its moderation policy, because", "experience and interaction with SE sites, specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But", "are other sites that are not as strict about moderation", "question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524 mentioned, > > There are other sites", "buffer between the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer: based upon a", "answers are from pseudonyms; whether due to inexperience or the", "system reflected up on a user's contribution. * Effect: more", "extent that I theorize. There are great question and answer", "is the effect of Anonymity on both the quality of", "topics. With the following variables on anonymity in play (not", "mean higher-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality questions? ", "and moderator ff524 about a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524 mentioned,", "the extent that I theorize. There are great question and", "With the following variables on anonymity in play (not exactly", "a role to play, but not to the extent that", "[Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely on mathematics topics. With the following", "between myself and moderator ff524 about a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator", "associated, or a pseudonym. Effect: if real-life, then words", "answers?** The various logical derivatives: * Does real-ID mean higher-quality", "in general, poor-quality questions and answers are from pseudonyms; whether", "question and answer contributions from users from both sites whether", "both questions and answers in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In this particular", "from pseudonyms; whether due to inexperience or the buffer (between", "logical derivatives: * Does real-ID mean higher-quality questions? * Does", "higher-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality questions? * Does", "words said would carry over to their IRL identity. If", "different in its moderation policy, because we try to be", "to the user and can be used as a rough", "users from both sites whether with a pseudonym or real-ID.", "by a pseudonym. I could be entirely wrong after all,", "interaction with SE sites, specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely on", "on topic questions. But some of our users enjoy contributing", "other sites that are not as strict about moderation -", "are great question and answer contributions from users from both", "In a [short discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3873/allowing-questions-that-warranted-a-deletion-but-has-an-answer-that-addresses-t) between myself and moderator ff524 about", "of buffer between the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer: based upon", "Anonymity has a role to play, but not to the", "from users from both sites whether with a pseudonym or", "lower-quality answers? In my experience at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well", "real-life, then words said would carry over to their IRL", "that Anonymity has a role to play, but not to", "the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer: based upon a voting system", "to the SE model. *What is the effect of Anonymity", "on mathematics topics. With the following variables on anonymity in", "from both sites whether with a pseudonym or real-ID. But", "general, poor-quality questions and answers are from pseudonyms; whether due", "Effect: if real-life, then words said would carry over to", "[Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would presume that Anonymity has a role to", "pseudonym. I could be entirely wrong after all, would someone", "> Emphasis mine. I agree with Moderator ff524 on all", "[Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would presume that Anonymity", "lower-quality questions? Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality answers? In my", "Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality answers? In my experience at the", "at the [Workplace](https://workplace.stackexchange.com/users) as well as [Academia](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users), I would presume", "> > There are other sites that are not as", "whether due to inexperience or the buffer (between a person's", "Binary: has an equivalent real-life ID associated, or a pseudonym.", "rough yardstick to measure the experience of the user to", "and answers?** The various logical derivatives: * Does real-ID mean", "Does real-ID mean higher-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality", "contributions from users from both sites whether with a pseudonym", "[Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer: based upon a voting system reflected up", "a rough yardstick to measure the experience of the user", "and interaction with SE sites, specifically [Mathematics SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely", "Effect: more privileges and respect afforded to the user and", "to inexperience or the buffer (between a person's actions and", "great question and answer contributions from users from both sites", "meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): * Binary: has an equivalent real-life ID associated,", "degree of buffer between the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer: based", "Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality", "of questions and answers?** The various logical derivatives: * Does", "actions and his/her real-life identity) offered by a pseudonym. I", "particular case, the [author of the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some", "pseudonyms; whether due to inexperience or the buffer (between a", "But purely on mathematics topics. With the following variables on", "be used as a rough yardstick to measure the experience", "discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3873/allowing-questions-that-warranted-a-deletion-but-has-an-answer-that-addresses-t) between myself and moderator ff524 about a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)).", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some experience and interaction with SE sites, specifically", "wrong after all, would someone with more expertise on the", "higher-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality answers? * Does", "or real-ID. But in general, poor-quality questions and answers are", "if real-life, then words said would carry over to their", "equivalent real-life ID associated, or a pseudonym. * Effect: if", "who like answering high quality, on topic questions*. But some", "up on a user's contribution. Effect: more privileges and", "contribution. * Effect: more privileges and respect afforded to the", "higher-quality answers? * Does real-ID mean lower-quality questions? * Does", "his/her real-life identity) offered by a pseudonym. I could be", "> > Emphasis mine. I agree with Moderator ff524 on", "on both the quality of questions and answers?** The various", "* Effect: if real-life, then words said would carry over", "derivatives: * Does real-ID mean higher-quality questions? * Does real-ID", "a degree of buffer between the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation): * Integer:", "some of our users enjoy contributing to those other sites,", "both the quality of questions and answers? The various logical", "then words said would carry over to their IRL identity.", "theorize. There are great question and answer contributions from users", "the experience of the user to the SE model. What", "* Does real-ID mean higher-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean", "Emphasis mine. I agree with Moderator ff524 on all points.", "agree with Moderator ff524 on all points. But this led", "with Moderator ff524 on all points. But this led me", "I theorize. There are great question and answer contributions from", "there is a degree of buffer between the two. [Reputation](https://stackoverflow.com/help/whats-reputation):", "and his/her real-life identity) offered by a pseudonym. I could", "lower-quality answers? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality questions? * Does", "because we try to be a home for people who", "answering high quality, on topic questions. But some of our", "of the user to the SE model. *What is the", "due to inexperience or the buffer (between a person's actions", "IRL identity. If pseudonym, then there is a degree of", "over to their IRL identity. If pseudonym, then there is", "mathematics topics. With the following variables on anonymity in play", ";) > > > Emphasis mine. I agree with Moderator", "answers? Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms", "mean lower-quality questions? * Does pseudonyms mean lower-quality answers? In", "SE](https://math.stackexchange.com/users/488215/nexusoi). But purely on mathematics topics. With the following variables", "the [author of the deleted question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/82877/nexusoi) has some experience and", "of Anonymity on both questions and answers in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be).", "ff524 about a [deleted question](http://There%20are%20other%20sites%20that%20are%20not%20as%20strict%20about%20moderation%20-%20Reddit,%20etc.%20SE%20is%20deliberately%20different%20in%20its%20moderation%20policy,%20because%20we%20try%20to%20be%20a%20home%20for%20people%20who%20like%20answering%20high%20quality,%20on%20topic%20questions.%20But%20some%20of%20our%20users%20enjoy%20contributing%20to%20those%20other%20sites,%20too%20;)). Moderator ff524 mentioned, > >", "for people who like answering high quality, on topic questions*.", "answer contributions from users from both sites whether with a", "mine. I agree with Moderator ff524 on all points. But", "after all, would someone with more expertise on the matter", "inexperience or the buffer (between a person's actions and his/her", "pseudonyms mean higher-quality questions? Does pseudonyms mean higher-quality answers?", "are not as strict about moderation - Reddit, etc. SE", "pseudonym or real-ID. But in general, poor-quality questions and answers", "*home for people who like answering high quality, on topic", "Anonymity on both questions and answers in [Academia specifically](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1422/what-do-we-want-academia-se-to-be). In", "play (not exactly rigorous, but will suffice in the meantime):", "rigorous, but will suffice in the meantime): [Anonymity](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/107152/encouraging-users-to-create-an-account-and-keep-it/107163#107163): Binary:", "our users enjoy contributing to those other sites, too ;)", "an equivalent real-life ID associated, or a pseudonym. * Effect:", "privileges and respect afforded to the user and can be" ]
[ "- to Academia Stack Exchange - its employees, top contributors,", "and not to the whole of Stack Exchange. Please advise,", "donation to be specific to the Academia site and not", "with a rather large inheritance, much of which I do", "do not anticipate ever having a need for. How can", "having a need for. How can I donate money -", "contributors, and moderators? Note that I desire my donation to", "Academia Stack Exchange - its employees, top contributors, and moderators?", "inheritance, much of which I do not anticipate ever having", "and left me with a rather large inheritance, much of", "to Academia Stack Exchange - its employees, top contributors, and", "which I do not anticipate ever having a need for.", "passed away and left me with a rather large inheritance,", "employees, top contributors, and moderators? Note that I desire my", "specific to the Academia site and not to the whole", "not to the whole of Stack Exchange. Please advise, and", "my uncle passed away and left me with a rather", "much of which I do not anticipate ever having a", "my donation to be specific to the Academia site and", "to be specific to the Academia site and not to", "of which I do not anticipate ever having a need", "- in USD - to Academia Stack Exchange - its", "Note that I desire my donation to be specific to", "in USD - to Academia Stack Exchange - its employees,", "away and left me with a rather large inheritance, much", "the whole of Stack Exchange. Please advise, and thank you.", "I do not anticipate ever having a need for. How", "uncle passed away and left me with a rather large", "money - in USD - to Academia Stack Exchange -", "its employees, top contributors, and moderators? Note that I desire", "I desire my donation to be specific to the Academia", "desire my donation to be specific to the Academia site", "the Academia site and not to the whole of Stack", "rather large inheritance, much of which I do not anticipate", "me with a rather large inheritance, much of which I", "Stack Exchange - its employees, top contributors, and moderators? Note", "Recently my uncle passed away and left me with a", "a rather large inheritance, much of which I do not", "Exchange - its employees, top contributors, and moderators? Note that", "site and not to the whole of Stack Exchange. Please", "Academia site and not to the whole of Stack Exchange.", "top contributors, and moderators? Note that I desire my donation", "can I donate money - in USD - to Academia", "anticipate ever having a need for. How can I donate", "I donate money - in USD - to Academia Stack", "donate money - in USD - to Academia Stack Exchange", "How can I donate money - in USD - to", "- its employees, top contributors, and moderators? Note that I", "need for. How can I donate money - in USD", "USD - to Academia Stack Exchange - its employees, top", "large inheritance, much of which I do not anticipate ever", "be specific to the Academia site and not to the", "to the Academia site and not to the whole of", "ever having a need for. How can I donate money", "left me with a rather large inheritance, much of which", "and moderators? Note that I desire my donation to be", "for. How can I donate money - in USD -", "that I desire my donation to be specific to the", "to the whole of Stack Exchange. Please advise, and thank", "moderators? Note that I desire my donation to be specific", "not anticipate ever having a need for. How can I", "a need for. How can I donate money - in" ]
[ "We get a lot of questions like this - trying", "7 days. I've often thought it would be useful to", "in internal Soviet politics. > > > We get a", "> tiniest tidbits, such as the removal of portraits, the", "Editor\" at a journal means after 7 days. I've often", "and other indirect signs to try to understand > what", "duplicates, or mark them in the way many sites mark", "to help find duplicates, or mark them in the way", "was happening in internal Soviet politics. > > > We", "is thinking based on a one-line email, or what being", "> chairs, positions at the reviewing stand for parades in", "pages of the > party newspaper Pravda and other indirect", "at the reviewing stand for parades in Red Square, >", "mark \"Homework\" questions, but it also feels a little snarky.", "> party newspaper Pravda and other indirect signs to try", "definition, from Wikipedia: > > During the Cold War, lack", "Pravda and other indirect signs to try to understand >", "little snarky. So I thought I'd pose the concept as", "choice of capital or small initial letters in phrases such", "such as > \"First Secretary\", the arrangement of articles on", "questions like this - trying to suss out what a", "be useful to be able to categorize these to help", "a journal means after 7 days. I've often thought it", "professor is thinking based on a one-line email, or what", "forced Western analysts to \"read between the lines\" and to", "the > party newspaper Pravda and other indirect signs to", "First, a definition, from Wikipedia: > > During the Cold", "of > chairs, positions at the reviewing stand for parades", "what a professor is thinking based on a one-line email,", "often thought it would be useful to be able to", "parades in Red Square, > the choice of capital or", "the way many sites mark \"Homework\" questions, but it also", "stand for parades in Red Square, > the choice of", "signs to try to understand > what was happening in", "from Wikipedia: > > During the Cold War, lack of", "letters in phrases such as > \"First Secretary\", the arrangement", "politics. > > > We get a lot of questions", "about the country > forced Western analysts to \"read between", "the choice of capital or small initial letters in phrases", "sites mark \"Homework\" questions, but it also feels a little", "useful to be able to categorize these to help find", "on a one-line email, or what being \"With Editor\" at", "a definition, from Wikipedia: > > During the Cold War,", "trying to suss out what a professor is thinking based", "a little snarky. So I thought I'd pose the concept", "> We get a lot of questions like this -", "the arrangement of articles on the pages of the >", "feels a little snarky. So I thought I'd pose the", "what being \"With Editor\" at a journal means after 7", "removal of portraits, the rearranging of > chairs, positions at", "I've often thought it would be useful to be able", "Red Square, > the choice of capital or small initial", "> what was happening in internal Soviet politics. > >", "between the lines\" and to use the > tiniest tidbits,", "thinking based on a one-line email, or what being \"With", "information about the country > forced Western analysts to \"read", "journal means after 7 days. I've often thought it would", "the > tiniest tidbits, such as the removal of portraits,", "able to categorize these to help find duplicates, or mark", "Western analysts to \"read between the lines\" and to use", "arrangement of articles on the pages of the > party", "but it also feels a little snarky. So I thought", "of articles on the pages of the > party newspaper", "way many sites mark \"Homework\" questions, but it also feels", "tiniest tidbits, such as the removal of portraits, the rearranging", "party newspaper Pravda and other indirect signs to try to", "\"Homework\" questions, but it also feels a little snarky. So", "analysts to \"read between the lines\" and to use the", "a professor is thinking based on a one-line email, or", "to understand > what was happening in internal Soviet politics.", "suss out what a professor is thinking based on a", "During the Cold War, lack of reliable information about the", "> the choice of capital or small initial letters in", "being \"With Editor\" at a journal means after 7 days.", "for parades in Red Square, > the choice of capital", "understand > what was happening in internal Soviet politics. >", "be able to categorize these to help find duplicates, or", "So I thought I'd pose the concept as a discussion.", "> forced Western analysts to \"read between the lines\" and", "> \"First Secretary\", the arrangement of articles on the pages", "in phrases such as > \"First Secretary\", the arrangement of", "to try to understand > what was happening in internal", "days. I've often thought it would be useful to be", "mark them in the way many sites mark \"Homework\" questions,", "or small initial letters in phrases such as > \"First", "one-line email, or what being \"With Editor\" at a journal", "and to use the > tiniest tidbits, such as the", "or what being \"With Editor\" at a journal means after", "at a journal means after 7 days. I've often thought", "it would be useful to be able to categorize these", "to be able to categorize these to help find duplicates,", "the Cold War, lack of reliable information about the country", "capital or small initial letters in phrases such as >", "in Red Square, > the choice of capital or small", "\"First Secretary\", the arrangement of articles on the pages of", "to categorize these to help find duplicates, or mark them", "reliable information about the country > forced Western analysts to", "lines\" and to use the > tiniest tidbits, such as", "Square, > the choice of capital or small initial letters", "like this - trying to suss out what a professor", "the lines\" and to use the > tiniest tidbits, such", "happening in internal Soviet politics. > > > We get", "out what a professor is thinking based on a one-line", "the country > forced Western analysts to \"read between the", "to use the > tiniest tidbits, such as the removal", "based on a one-line email, or what being \"With Editor\"", "> > During the Cold War, lack of reliable information", "find duplicates, or mark them in the way many sites", "chairs, positions at the reviewing stand for parades in Red", "what was happening in internal Soviet politics. > > >", "of reliable information about the country > forced Western analysts", "tidbits, such as the removal of portraits, the rearranging of", "- trying to suss out what a professor is thinking", "the removal of portraits, the rearranging of > chairs, positions", "Wikipedia: > > During the Cold War, lack of reliable", "small initial letters in phrases such as > \"First Secretary\",", "use the > tiniest tidbits, such as the removal of", "it also feels a little snarky. So I thought I'd", "lack of reliable information about the country > forced Western", "portraits, the rearranging of > chairs, positions at the reviewing", "> > > We get a lot of questions like", "get a lot of questions like this - trying to", "War, lack of reliable information about the country > forced", "other indirect signs to try to understand > what was", "to \"read between the lines\" and to use the >", "Secretary\", the arrangement of articles on the pages of the", "as > \"First Secretary\", the arrangement of articles on the", "indirect signs to try to understand > what was happening", "Cold War, lack of reliable information about the country >", "also feels a little snarky. So I thought I'd pose", "means after 7 days. I've often thought it would be", "as the removal of portraits, the rearranging of > chairs,", "lot of questions like this - trying to suss out", "of portraits, the rearranging of > chairs, positions at the", "\"read between the lines\" and to use the > tiniest", "or mark them in the way many sites mark \"Homework\"", "thought it would be useful to be able to categorize", "them in the way many sites mark \"Homework\" questions, but", "to suss out what a professor is thinking based on", "internal Soviet politics. > > > We get a lot", "would be useful to be able to categorize these to", "country > forced Western analysts to \"read between the lines\"", "articles on the pages of the > party newspaper Pravda", "the reviewing stand for parades in Red Square, > the", "the rearranging of > chairs, positions at the reviewing stand", "such as the removal of portraits, the rearranging of >", "of capital or small initial letters in phrases such as", "the pages of the > party newspaper Pravda and other", "after 7 days. I've often thought it would be useful", "many sites mark \"Homework\" questions, but it also feels a", "> During the Cold War, lack of reliable information about", "of the > party newspaper Pravda and other indirect signs", "phrases such as > \"First Secretary\", the arrangement of articles", "> > We get a lot of questions like this", "on the pages of the > party newspaper Pravda and", "try to understand > what was happening in internal Soviet", "\"With Editor\" at a journal means after 7 days. I've", "positions at the reviewing stand for parades in Red Square,", "initial letters in phrases such as > \"First Secretary\", the", "this - trying to suss out what a professor is", "these to help find duplicates, or mark them in the", "rearranging of > chairs, positions at the reviewing stand for", "email, or what being \"With Editor\" at a journal means", "snarky. So I thought I'd pose the concept as a", "questions, but it also feels a little snarky. So I", "reviewing stand for parades in Red Square, > the choice", "a lot of questions like this - trying to suss", "categorize these to help find duplicates, or mark them in", "help find duplicates, or mark them in the way many", "Soviet politics. > > > We get a lot of", "newspaper Pravda and other indirect signs to try to understand", "in the way many sites mark \"Homework\" questions, but it", "of questions like this - trying to suss out what", "a one-line email, or what being \"With Editor\" at a" ]
[ "the answer was bad. There's an obvious problem when the", "that was at +28 with the author requesting that it", "delete it. On the other hand, the comments explaining how", "we done wrong? Two answers; both miss the point. There", "an obvious problem when the comments on why the answer", "answer to this question that was at +28 with the", "[How to prevent students from using modified calculators to cheat", "both miss the point. There is no problem with deleting", "so he could delete it. On the other hand, the", "problem taking awhile in identifying the answer was bad. There's", "exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had a (now-deleted) answer to this question that", "to cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had a (now-deleted) answer to", "the other hand, the comments explaining how it was bad", "taking awhile in identifying the answer was bad. There's an", "the comments were logically outweighing the votes in the answer", "the point. There is no problem with deleting the answer.", "badness. But the answer downvotes didn't come. What have we", "author requesting that it be un-accepted so he could delete", "but the votes in the comments were logically outweighing the", "outweighing the votes in the answer showing its badness. But", "bad. There's an obvious problem when the comments on why", "We had a (now-deleted) answer to this question that was", "bad, and yet yielding upvotes, but the votes in the", "he could delete it. On the other hand, the comments", "answer ever did and the answer is still net highly", "not the behavior voting should result in. The answer was", "miss the point. There is no problem with deleting the", "how it was bad had been upvoted to the fifties.", "votes in the comments were logically outweighing the votes in", "had been upvoted to the fifties. This is not the", "were logically outweighing the votes in the answer showing its", "in the comments were logically outweighing the votes in the", "than the answer ever did and the answer is still", "bad got more upvotes than the answer ever did and", "was bad had been upvoted to the fifties. This is", "hand, the comments explaining how it was bad had been", "with deleting the answer. There is no problem taking awhile", "is not the behavior voting should result in. The answer", "comments were logically outweighing the votes in the answer showing", "a (now-deleted) answer to this question that was at +28", "to this question that was at +28 with the author", "answer downvotes didn't come. What have we done wrong? Two", "the comments on why the answer was bad got more", "showing its badness. But the answer downvotes didn't come. What", "it be un-accepted so he could delete it. On the", "answer was known bad, and yet yielding upvotes, but the", "to prevent students from using modified calculators to cheat on", "upvoted to the fifties. This is not the behavior voting", "done wrong? Two answers; both miss the point. There is", "been upvoted to the fifties. This is not the behavior", "the author requesting that it be un-accepted so he could", "should result in. The answer was known bad, and yet", "it was bad had been upvoted to the fifties. This", "comments on why the answer was bad got more upvotes", "was bad. There's an obvious problem when the comments on", "in the answer showing its badness. But the answer downvotes", "answer. There is no problem taking awhile in identifying the", "could delete it. On the other hand, the comments explaining", "upvotes, but the votes in the comments were logically outweighing", "votes in the answer showing its badness. But the answer", "point. There is no problem with deleting the answer. There", "no problem with deleting the answer. There is no problem", "is no problem taking awhile in identifying the answer was", "no problem taking awhile in identifying the answer was bad.", "students from using modified calculators to cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We", "yielding upvotes, but the votes in the comments were logically", "on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had a (now-deleted) answer to this question", "known bad, and yet yielding upvotes, but the votes in", "from using modified calculators to cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had", "come. What have we done wrong? Two answers; both miss", "On the other hand, the comments explaining how it was", "that it be un-accepted so he could delete it. On", "have we done wrong? Two answers; both miss the point.", "problem when the comments on why the answer was bad", "The answer was known bad, and yet yielding upvotes, but", "why the answer was bad got more upvotes than the", "in. The answer was known bad, and yet yielding upvotes,", "is no problem with deleting the answer. There is no", "behavior voting should result in. The answer was known bad,", "answer showing its badness. But the answer downvotes didn't come.", "comments explaining how it was bad had been upvoted to", "the behavior voting should result in. The answer was known", "was known bad, and yet yielding upvotes, but the votes", "the answer ever did and the answer is still net", "calculators to cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had a (now-deleted) answer", "answers; both miss the point. There is no problem with", "answer was bad got more upvotes than the answer ever", "awhile in identifying the answer was bad. There's an obvious", "using modified calculators to cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had a", "This is not the behavior voting should result in. The", "on why the answer was bad got more upvotes than", "But the answer downvotes didn't come. What have we done", "to the fifties. This is not the behavior voting should", "with the author requesting that it be un-accepted so he", "the fifties. This is not the behavior voting should result", "prevent students from using modified calculators to cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams)", "its badness. But the answer downvotes didn't come. What have", "There is no problem with deleting the answer. There is", "got more upvotes than the answer ever did and the", "modified calculators to cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had a (now-deleted)", "cheat on exams?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99417/how-to-prevent-students-from-using-modified-calculators-to-cheat-on-exams) We had a (now-deleted) answer to this", "logically outweighing the votes in the answer showing its badness.", "bad had been upvoted to the fifties. This is not", "answer was bad. There's an obvious problem when the comments", "more upvotes than the answer ever did and the answer", "the answer. There is no problem taking awhile in identifying", "yet yielding upvotes, but the votes in the comments were", "requesting that it be un-accepted so he could delete it.", "What have we done wrong? Two answers; both miss the", "There is no problem taking awhile in identifying the answer", "be un-accepted so he could delete it. On the other", "voting should result in. The answer was known bad, and", "was at +28 with the author requesting that it be", "downvotes didn't come. What have we done wrong? Two answers;", "identifying the answer was bad. There's an obvious problem when", "fifties. This is not the behavior voting should result in.", "the answer was bad got more upvotes than the answer", "had a (now-deleted) answer to this question that was at", "+28 with the author requesting that it be un-accepted so", "wrong? Two answers; both miss the point. There is no", "it. On the other hand, the comments explaining how it", "other hand, the comments explaining how it was bad had", "upvotes than the answer ever did and the answer is", "explaining how it was bad had been upvoted to the", "the answer showing its badness. But the answer downvotes didn't", "un-accepted so he could delete it. On the other hand,", "and yet yielding upvotes, but the votes in the comments", "the votes in the answer showing its badness. But the", "problem with deleting the answer. There is no problem taking", "deleting the answer. There is no problem taking awhile in", "There's an obvious problem when the comments on why the", "when the comments on why the answer was bad got", "this question that was at +28 with the author requesting", "was bad got more upvotes than the answer ever did", "(now-deleted) answer to this question that was at +28 with", "Two answers; both miss the point. There is no problem", "at +28 with the author requesting that it be un-accepted", "question that was at +28 with the author requesting that", "result in. The answer was known bad, and yet yielding", "in identifying the answer was bad. There's an obvious problem", "obvious problem when the comments on why the answer was", "didn't come. What have we done wrong? Two answers; both", "the votes in the comments were logically outweighing the votes", "the comments explaining how it was bad had been upvoted", "the answer downvotes didn't come. What have we done wrong?", "ever did and the answer is still net highly upvoted." ]
[ "As a general rule, if you're asking about a particular", "precise? In particular, can questions be asked about some particularly", "guidelines state: > > As a general rule, if you're", "too limited in scope > > > Can this rule", "questions be asked about some particularly large institutes? E.g., CNRS,", "general rule, if you're asking about a particular institution...it's likely", "CNRS, which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers. (As a comparison, Harvard has", "about a particular institution...it's likely your question is too limited", "asked about some particularly large institutes? E.g., CNRS, which [employs", "The guidelines state: > > As a general rule, if", "asking about a particular institution...it's likely your question is too", "[employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers. (As a comparison, Harvard has [~5k academics](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvard_University).)", "rule be made more precise? In particular, can questions be", "particular institution...it's likely your question is too limited in scope", "scope > > > Can this rule be made more", "a general rule, if you're asking about a particular institution...it's", "Can this rule be made more precise? In particular, can", "about some particularly large institutes? E.g., CNRS, which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm)", "a particular institution...it's likely your question is too limited in", "can questions be asked about some particularly large institutes? E.g.,", "be asked about some particularly large institutes? E.g., CNRS, which", "more precise? In particular, can questions be asked about some", "this rule be made more precise? In particular, can questions", "> As a general rule, if you're asking about a", "question is too limited in scope > > > Can", "state: > > As a general rule, if you're asking", "In particular, can questions be asked about some particularly large", "particular, can questions be asked about some particularly large institutes?", "rule, if you're asking about a particular institution...it's likely your", "you're asking about a particular institution...it's likely your question is", "likely your question is too limited in scope > >", "institution...it's likely your question is too limited in scope >", "E.g., CNRS, which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers. (As a comparison, Harvard", "which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers. (As a comparison, Harvard has [~5k", "limited in scope > > > Can this rule be", "> > > Can this rule be made more precise?", "is too limited in scope > > > Can this", "be made more precise? In particular, can questions be asked", "> Can this rule be made more precise? In particular,", "in scope > > > Can this rule be made", "particularly large institutes? E.g., CNRS, which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers. (As", "your question is too limited in scope > > >", "large institutes? E.g., CNRS, which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers. (As a", "if you're asking about a particular institution...it's likely your question", "> > Can this rule be made more precise? In", "> > As a general rule, if you're asking about", "some particularly large institutes? E.g., CNRS, which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers.", "made more precise? In particular, can questions be asked about", "institutes? E.g., CNRS, which [employs 11k](http://www.cnrs.fr/en/aboutcnrs/key-figures.htm) researchers. (As a comparison," ]
[ "\"unclear\". I am truly at a loss regarding what is", "structure. I'm struggling to find a way to put this", "experience of asking a question on this website has been", "is five random users to deem my question \"unclear\", presumably", "even comment. And now my question is \"put on hold\"", "what is supposedly unclear about it. I'm asking what is", "a question on this website has been less than stellar.", "their level of detail, their length, their structure. I'm struggling", "apparently takes is five random users to deem my question", "hold\" for being \"unclear\". I am truly at a loss", "being \"unclear\". I am truly at a loss regarding what", "even know what the question is about and should perhaps", "reason with no explanation from the people who did it.", "most French labs, even opening [a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which", "unclear about it. I'm asking what is expected about the", "honest the experience of asking a question on this website", "I am truly at a loss regarding what is supposedly", "thought it was a single small research center instead of", "wrong with it, but all it apparently takes is five", "this in simpler words. To be quite honest the experience", "CNRS is and thought it was a single small research", "national institution which employs and funds people in most French", "know what CNRS is and thought it was a single", "loss regarding what is supposedly unclear about it. I'm asking", "they did not know what CNRS is and thought it", "been \"put on hold\" for being \"unclear\". I am truly", "for being \"unclear\". I am truly at a loss regarding", "of asking a question on this website has been less", "and nails because they did not know what CNRS is", "has been \"put on hold\" for being \"unclear\". I am", "the CNRS has been \"put on hold\" for being \"unclear\".", "I'm asking what is expected about the reports on past", "random users to deem my question \"unclear\", presumably because they,", "and saw nothing wrong with it, but all it apparently", "with no explanation from the people who did it. Two", "on hold\" for no visible reason with no explanation from", "deal with a vindictive user who fought teeth and nails", "am truly at a loss regarding what is supposedly unclear", "who fought teeth and nails because they did not know", "\"put on hold\" for no visible reason with no explanation", "reports on past and projected work: their level of detail,", "a way to put this in simpler words. To be", "who did it. Two different moderators looked at it and", "users to deem my question \"unclear\", presumably because they, too,", "to deem my question \"unclear\", presumably because they, too, don't", "level of detail, their length, their structure. I'm struggling to", "Two different moderators looked at it and saw nothing wrong", "of detail, their length, their structure. I'm struggling to find", "put this in simpler words. To be quite honest the", "is and thought it was a single small research center", "length, their structure. I'm struggling to find a way to", "employs and funds people in most French labs, even opening", "I can't even comment. And now my question is \"put", "my question is \"put on hold\" for no visible reason", "been less than stellar. First I had to deal with", "the experience of asking a question on this website has", "no explanation from the people who did it. Two different", "question on this website has been less than stellar. First", "the reports on past and projected work: their level of", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which I can't even comment. And now my", "deem my question \"unclear\", presumably because they, too, don't even", "and funds people in most French labs, even opening [a", "a vindictive user who fought teeth and nails because they", "less than stellar. First I had to deal with a", "fought teeth and nails because they did not know what", "a loss regarding what is supposedly unclear about it. I'm", "way to put this in simpler words. To be quite", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100104/in-how-much-detail-should-one-describe-their-past-and-projected-future-work-for) about the application process at the CNRS has been", "now my question is \"put on hold\" for no visible", "I'm struggling to find a way to put this in", "for no visible reason with no explanation from the people", "too, don't even know what the question is about and", "nails because they did not know what CNRS is and", "small research center instead of a national institution which employs", "a national institution which employs and funds people in most", "words. To be quite honest the experience of asking a", "projected work: their level of detail, their length, their structure.", "comment. And now my question is \"put on hold\" for", "did it. Two different moderators looked at it and saw", "takes is five random users to deem my question \"unclear\",", "which employs and funds people in most French labs, even", "funds people in most French labs, even opening [a meta", "at it and saw nothing wrong with it, but all", "\"put on hold\" for being \"unclear\". I am truly at", "the question is about and should perhaps reserve their judgment...", "and thought it was a single small research center instead", "CNRS has been \"put on hold\" for being \"unclear\". I", "past and projected work: their level of detail, their length,", "And now my question is \"put on hold\" for no", "regarding what is supposedly unclear about it. I'm asking what", "simpler words. To be quite honest the experience of asking", "what is expected about the reports on past and projected", "meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which I can't even comment. And now", "asking what is expected about the reports on past and", "at the CNRS has been \"put on hold\" for being", "question is \"put on hold\" for no visible reason with", "know what the question is about and should perhaps reserve", "nothing wrong with it, but all it apparently takes is", "is supposedly unclear about it. I'm asking what is expected", "on this website has been less than stellar. First I", "but all it apparently takes is five random users to", "people in most French labs, even opening [a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions)", "it apparently takes is five random users to deem my", "what CNRS is and thought it was a single small", "supposedly unclear about it. I'm asking what is expected about", "French labs, even opening [a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which I", "on hold\" for being \"unclear\". I am truly at a", "of a national institution which employs and funds people in", "which I can't even comment. And now my question is", "labs, even opening [a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which I can't", "hold\" for no visible reason with no explanation from the", "question \"unclear\", presumably because they, too, don't even know what", "with a vindictive user who fought teeth and nails because", "research center instead of a national institution which employs and", "it, but all it apparently takes is five random users", "five random users to deem my question \"unclear\", presumably because", "center instead of a national institution which employs and funds", "the people who did it. Two different moderators looked at", "is \"put on hold\" for no visible reason with no", "stellar. First I had to deal with a vindictive user", "did not know what CNRS is and thought it was", "moderators looked at it and saw nothing wrong with it,", "the application process at the CNRS has been \"put on", "process at the CNRS has been \"put on hold\" for", "find a way to put this in simpler words. To", "with it, but all it apparently takes is five random", "it. I'm asking what is expected about the reports on", "be quite honest the experience of asking a question on", "single small research center instead of a national institution which", "about the application process at the CNRS has been \"put", "to find a way to put this in simpler words.", "vindictive user who fought teeth and nails because they did", "quite honest the experience of asking a question on this", "application process at the CNRS has been \"put on hold\"", "work: their level of detail, their length, their structure. I'm", "teeth and nails because they did not know what CNRS", "different moderators looked at it and saw nothing wrong with", "because they did not know what CNRS is and thought", "struggling to find a way to put this in simpler", "than stellar. First I had to deal with a vindictive", "had to deal with a vindictive user who fought teeth", "what the question is about and should perhaps reserve their", "to put this in simpler words. To be quite honest", "don't even know what the question is about and should", "First I had to deal with a vindictive user who", "a single small research center instead of a national institution", "it and saw nothing wrong with it, but all it", "looked at it and saw nothing wrong with it, but", "\"unclear\", presumably because they, too, don't even know what the", "detail, their length, their structure. I'm struggling to find a", "asking a question on this website has been less than", "was a single small research center instead of a national", "it was a single small research center instead of a", "and projected work: their level of detail, their length, their", "at a loss regarding what is supposedly unclear about it.", "opening [a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which I can't even comment.", "all it apparently takes is five random users to deem", "has been less than stellar. First I had to deal", "presumably because they, too, don't even know what the question", "on which I can't even comment. And now my question", "explanation from the people who did it. Two different moderators", "about the reports on past and projected work: their level", "on past and projected work: their level of detail, their", "their length, their structure. I'm struggling to find a way", "to deal with a vindictive user who fought teeth and", "it. Two different moderators looked at it and saw nothing", "institution which employs and funds people in most French labs,", "from the people who did it. Two different moderators looked", "To be quite honest the experience of asking a question", "[a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which I can't even comment. And", "user who fought teeth and nails because they did not", "can't even comment. And now my question is \"put on", "they, too, don't even know what the question is about", "about it. I'm asking what is expected about the reports", "I had to deal with a vindictive user who fought", "instead of a national institution which employs and funds people", "saw nothing wrong with it, but all it apparently takes", "even opening [a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on which I can't even", "visible reason with no explanation from the people who did", "because they, too, don't even know what the question is", "my question \"unclear\", presumably because they, too, don't even know", "is expected about the reports on past and projected work:", "not know what CNRS is and thought it was a", "[My question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100104/in-how-much-detail-should-one-describe-their-past-and-projected-future-work-for) about the application process at the CNRS has", "people who did it. Two different moderators looked at it", "truly at a loss regarding what is supposedly unclear about", "in simpler words. To be quite honest the experience of", "this website has been less than stellar. First I had", "their structure. I'm struggling to find a way to put", "expected about the reports on past and projected work: their", "in most French labs, even opening [a meta question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/3895/questions-about-particular-institutions) on", "website has been less than stellar. First I had to", "no visible reason with no explanation from the people who" ]
[ "very good answer. However, as an academic, I wanted to", "In this [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100431/access-to-scientific-articles-that-cite-mine-after-leaving-academia), Federico Poloni's wrote an answer: >", "the authors if Sci-Hub dies. > > > This is", "It was by no way unconstructive, offensive, or rude. Would", "[...] > > > which is a very good answer.", "of their published paper. Almost everyone will be happy to", "> > I would only write to the authors if", "I added a comment in line with: > > I", "even when legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my comment was deleted.", "which is a very good answer. However, as an academic,", "my experience on when I would use the suggested solution.", "not only my choice. [For too many fellow academics and", "and scientists, Sci-Hub is the first option, even when legal", "Federico Poloni's wrote an answer: > > You can write", "the authors and ask for a copy of their published", "authors and ask for a copy of their published paper.", "academic, I wanted to share my experience on when I", "the suggested solution. I added a comment in line with:", "my choice. [For too many fellow academics and scientists, Sci-Hub", "be happy to send you one. [...] > > >", "fellow academics and scientists, Sci-Hub is the first option, even", "rude. Would the moderators kindly justify the deletion? Wasn't it", "[For too many fellow academics and scientists, Sci-Hub is the", "Poloni's wrote an answer: > > You can write an", "way unconstructive, offensive, or rude. Would the moderators kindly justify", "is not only my choice. [For too many fellow academics", "first option, even when legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my comment", "line with: > > I would only write to the", "Unfortunately, my comment was deleted. It was by no way", "a very good answer. However, as an academic, I wanted", "good answer. However, as an academic, I wanted to share", "as an academic, I wanted to share my experience on", "an academic, I wanted to share my experience on when", "for a copy of their published paper. Almost everyone will", "if Sci-Hub dies. > > > This is not only", "my comment was deleted. It was by no way unconstructive,", "or rude. Would the moderators kindly justify the deletion? Wasn't", "only write to the authors if Sci-Hub dies. > >", "to share my experience on when I would use the", "by no way unconstructive, offensive, or rude. Would the moderators", "I wanted to share my experience on when I would", "I would use the suggested solution. I added a comment", "> > This is not only my choice. [For too", "no way unconstructive, offensive, or rude. Would the moderators kindly", "use the suggested solution. I added a comment in line", "published paper. Almost everyone will be happy to send you", "> > You can write an e-mail to the authors", "a copy of their published paper. Almost everyone will be", "Almost everyone will be happy to send you one. [...]", "only my choice. [For too many fellow academics and scientists,", "the first option, even when legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my", "write an e-mail to the authors and ask for a", "I would only write to the authors if Sci-Hub dies.", "> > > which is a very good answer. However,", "You can write an e-mail to the authors and ask", "would use the suggested solution. I added a comment in", "Sci-Hub dies. > > > This is not only my", "a comment in line with: > > I would only", "exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my comment was deleted. It was by no", "this [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100431/access-to-scientific-articles-that-cite-mine-after-leaving-academia), Federico Poloni's wrote an answer: > >", "experience on when I would use the suggested solution. I", "Sci-Hub is the first option, even when legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone)", "> I would only write to the authors if Sci-Hub", "option, even when legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my comment was", "was by no way unconstructive, offensive, or rude. Would the", "e-mail to the authors and ask for a copy of", "and ask for a copy of their published paper. Almost", "you one. [...] > > > which is a very", "added a comment in line with: > > I would", "write to the authors if Sci-Hub dies. > > >", "wanted to share my experience on when I would use", "scientists, Sci-Hub is the first option, even when legal access", "copy of their published paper. Almost everyone will be happy", "to the authors if Sci-Hub dies. > > > This", "happy to send you one. [...] > > > which", "This is not only my choice. [For too many fellow", "to the authors and ask for a copy of their", "access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my comment was deleted. It was by", "> This is not only my choice. [For too many", "was deleted. It was by no way unconstructive, offensive, or", "ask for a copy of their published paper. Almost everyone", "choice. [For too many fellow academics and scientists, Sci-Hub is", "can write an e-mail to the authors and ask for", "unconstructive, offensive, or rude. Would the moderators kindly justify the", "comment was deleted. It was by no way unconstructive, offensive,", "would only write to the authors if Sci-Hub dies. >", "one. [...] > > > which is a very good", "> which is a very good answer. However, as an", "academics and scientists, Sci-Hub is the first option, even when", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100431/access-to-scientific-articles-that-cite-mine-after-leaving-academia), Federico Poloni's wrote an answer: > > You can", "in line with: > > I would only write to", "> You can write an e-mail to the authors and", "suggested solution. I added a comment in line with: >", "send you one. [...] > > > which is a", "deleted. It was by no way unconstructive, offensive, or rude.", "dies. > > > This is not only my choice.", "solution. I added a comment in line with: > >", "to send you one. [...] > > > which is", "many fellow academics and scientists, Sci-Hub is the first option,", "Would the moderators kindly justify the deletion? Wasn't it opinion-based?", "too many fellow academics and scientists, Sci-Hub is the first", "> > which is a very good answer. However, as", "is the first option, even when legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately,", "when legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my comment was deleted. It", "authors if Sci-Hub dies. > > > This is not", "an answer: > > You can write an e-mail to", "is a very good answer. However, as an academic, I", "answer. However, as an academic, I wanted to share my", "when I would use the suggested solution. I added a", "However, as an academic, I wanted to share my experience", "an e-mail to the authors and ask for a copy", "wrote an answer: > > You can write an e-mail", "answer: > > You can write an e-mail to the", "paper. Almost everyone will be happy to send you one.", "legal access exists.](https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/04/whos-downloading-pirated-papers-everyone) Unfortunately, my comment was deleted. It was", "offensive, or rude. Would the moderators kindly justify the deletion?", "with: > > I would only write to the authors", "will be happy to send you one. [...] > >", "everyone will be happy to send you one. [...] >", "share my experience on when I would use the suggested", "their published paper. Almost everyone will be happy to send", "> > > This is not only my choice. [For", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100431/access-to-scientific-articles-that-cite-mine-after-leaving-academia), Federico Poloni's wrote an answer: > > You", "on when I would use the suggested solution. I added", "comment in line with: > > I would only write" ]
[ "started with Dec 12th +8 by Nat: Comment section moved", "have been moved to chat, but she was also criticized", "behavior really looks like that a moderator could abuse his", "that a moderator could abuse his power to foster opinions", "[Should I answer this question about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both positive", "something strange. Positive answers: +22 accepted by xyz123: 13 comments", "diversity engagement had its comment section removed while positive comment", "comment sections which are comparable in length, I suggest that", "comments starting with Dec 12th. Negative answers: +104 by kingledion:", "comments. Every (!) answer so far who was negative or", "something we could all live with. But if take a", "12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg has also a positive answer with +33", "(!) answer so far who was negative or where the", "with Dec 12th +8 by Nat: Comment section moved to", "This is something we could all live with. But if", "we are treating them equally. The presented behavior really looks", "in starting time etc. which would explain this behavior. Again*:", "that we are treating them equally. The presented behavior really", "that is not for (extended) discussion irrespective of reasons, no", "question [Should I answer this question about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both", "removed while positive comment sections were unscathed. None of the", "the comments. Every (!) answer so far who was negative", "abuse his power to foster opinions (s)he likes and suppress", "section is not for (extended) discussion irrespective of reasons, no", "+104 by kingledion: Comments section moved to chat, started with", "far who was negative or where the comments showed strong", "Every (!)* answer so far who was negative or where", "section moved to chat, started with Dec 12th +8 by", "This indicates clearly that the comment section is not for", "was negative or where the comments showed strong criticism over", "where the comments showed strong criticism over the diversity engagement", "with Dec 12th. +14 by Ansa FpTC: 17 (!) comments", "to chat, started with Dec 12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg has also", "unscathed. None of the comment sections has any difference in", "with Dec 12th. Negative answers: +104 by kingledion: Comments section", "conversation has been moved to chat. > This indicates clearly", "live with. But if take a closer look, there is", "who was negative or where the comments showed strong criticism", "Now comments sections have been replaced with > > Comments", "if take a closer look, there is something strange. Positive", "Dec 12th. Negative answers: +104 by kingledion: Comments section moved", "> > Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation", "in the comments. Every (!) answer so far who was", "its comment section removed while positive comment sections were unscathed.", "presented behavior really looks like that a moderator could abuse", "xyz123: 13 comments starting with Dec 12th. +14 by Ansa", "starting with Dec 12th. +14 by Ansa FpTC: 17 (!)", "FpTC: 17 (!) comments starting with Dec 12th. Negative answers:", "really looks like that a moderator could abuse his power", "which are comparable in length, I suggest that we are", "closer look, there is something strange. Positive answers: +22 accepted", "positive comment sections were unscathed. None of the comment sections", "starting with Dec 12th. Negative answers: +104 by kingledion: Comments", "the opportunity\") as negative answers (\"Leave it blank\"). Now comments", "this behavior. Again: The given reason for removing a comment", "also criticized in the comments. Every (!) answer so far", "strange. Positive answers: +22 accepted by xyz123: 13 comments starting", "(\"Use the opportunity\") as negative answers (\"Leave it blank\"). Now", "was also criticized in the comments. Every (!) answer so", "I suggest that we are treating them equally. The presented", "the comments showed strong criticism over the diversity engagement had", "suggest that we are treating them equally. The presented behavior", "if there are comment sections which are comparable in length,", "+22 accepted by xyz123: 13 comments starting with Dec 12th.", "Positive answers: +22 accepted by xyz123: 13 comments starting with", "negative answers (\"Leave it blank\"). Now comments sections have been", "of the comment sections has any difference in starting time", "likes and suppress opinions (s)he dislikes by treating comment sections", "his power to foster opinions (s)he likes and suppress opinions", "kingledion: Comments section moved to chat, started with Dec 12th", "with > > Comments are not for extended discussion; this", "discussion irrespective of reasons, no matter if they are good", "answer so far who was negative or where the comments", "for (extended) discussion irrespective of reasons, no matter if they", "indicates clearly that the comment section is not for (extended)", "accepted by xyz123: 13 comments starting with Dec 12th. +14", "about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both positive (\"Use the opportunity\") as negative", "+8 by Nat: Comment section moved to chat, started with", "diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both positive (\"Use the opportunity\") as negative answers", "comments starting with Dec 12th. +14 by Ansa FpTC: 17", "Hannoqg has also a positive answer with +33 which have", "Comment section moved to chat, started with Dec 12th. Ulizubotb", "The given reason for removing a comment section is that", "for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat.", "sections have been replaced with > > Comments are not", "but she was also criticized in the comments. Every (!)", "criticized in the comments. Every (!) answer so far who", "if they are good or bad. This is something we", "Again: The given reason for removing a comment section is", "got both positive (\"Use the opportunity\") as negative answers (\"Leave", "good or bad. So if there are comment sections which", "are treating them equally. The presented behavior really looks like", "given reason for removing a comment section is that is", "bad. This is something we could all live with. But", "positive (\"Use the opportunity\") as negative answers (\"Leave it blank\").", "section moved to chat, started with Dec 12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg", "negative or where the comments showed strong criticism over the", "difference in starting time etc. which would explain this behavior.", "good or bad. This is something we could all live", "take a closer look, there is something strange. Positive answers:", "which have been moved to chat, but she was also", "while positive comment sections were unscathed. None of the comment", "to foster opinions (s)he likes and suppress opinions (s)he dislikes", "or bad. So if there are comment sections which are", "that the comment section is not for (extended) discussion irrespective", "they are good or bad. This is something we could", "were unscathed. None of the comment sections has any difference", "is that is not for (extended) discussion irrespective of reasons,", "are good or bad. This is something we could all", "replaced with > > Comments are not for extended discussion;", "moved to chat. > This indicates clearly that the comment", "17 (!) comments starting with Dec 12th. Negative answers: +104", "the comment sections has any difference in starting time etc.", "12th. Negative answers: +104 by kingledion: Comments section moved to", "treating them equally. The presented behavior really looks like that", "(s)he likes and suppress opinions (s)he dislikes by treating comment", "both positive (\"Use the opportunity\") as negative answers (\"Leave it", "been moved to chat. > This indicates clearly that the", "Comments section moved to chat, started with Dec 12th +8", "bad. So if there are comment sections which are comparable", "no matter if they are good or bad. So if", "are comparable in length, I suggest that we are treating", "+33 which have been moved to chat, but she was", "the diversity engagement had its comment section removed while positive", "discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. > This", "I answer this question about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both positive (\"Use", "is not for (extended) discussion irrespective of reasons, no matter", "all live with. But if take a closer look, there", "are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved", "looks like that a moderator could abuse his power to", "like that a moderator could abuse his power to foster", "moderator could abuse his power to foster opinions (s)he likes", "moved to chat, started with Dec 12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg has", "they are good or bad. So if there are comment", "The presented behavior really looks like that a moderator could", "no matter if they are good or bad. This is", "opportunity\") as negative answers (\"Leave it blank\"). Now comments sections", "behavior. Again: The given reason for removing a comment section", "removing a comment section is that is not for (extended)", "could all live with. But if take a closer look,", "comment section is not for (extended) discussion irrespective of reasons,", "has been moved to chat. > This indicates clearly that", "12th +8 by Nat: Comment section moved to chat, started", "sections has any difference in starting time etc. which would", "for removing a comment section is that is not for", "comment sections has any difference in starting time etc. which", "13 comments starting with Dec 12th. +14 by Ansa FpTC:", "chat, but she was also criticized in the comments. Every", "Nat: Comment section moved to chat, started with Dec 12th.", "Ulizubotb Hannoqg has also a positive answer with +33 which", "to chat, but she was also criticized in the comments.", "not for (extended) discussion irrespective of reasons, no matter if", "equally. The presented behavior really looks like that a moderator", "are good or bad. So if there are comment sections", "if they are good or bad. So if there are", "explain this behavior. Again: The given reason for removing a", "not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to", "section removed while positive comment sections were unscathed. None of", "comments sections have been replaced with > > Comments are", "comment sections were unscathed. None of the comment sections has", "blank\"). Now comments sections have been replaced with > >", "in length, I suggest that we are treating them equally.", "moved to chat, but she was also criticized in the", "This question [Should I answer this question about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got", "also a positive answer with +33 which have been moved", "been replaced with > > Comments are not for extended", "moved to chat, started with Dec 12th +8 by Nat:", "to chat, started with Dec 12th +8 by Nat: Comment", "been moved to chat, but she was also criticized in", "a moderator could abuse his power to foster opinions (s)he", "this conversation has been moved to chat. > This indicates", "have been replaced with > > Comments are not for", "with +33 which have been moved to chat, but she", "clearly that the comment section is not for (extended) discussion", "comment section is that is not for (extended) discussion irrespective", "starting time etc. which would explain this behavior. Again: The", "a comment section is that is not for (extended) discussion", "(\"Leave it blank\"). Now comments sections have been replaced with", "opinions (s)he likes and suppress opinions (s)he dislikes by treating", "there is something strange. Positive answers: +22 accepted by xyz123:", "with. But if take a closer look, there is something", "or bad. This is something we could all live with.", "etc. which would explain this behavior. Again: The given reason", "a closer look, there is something strange. Positive answers: +22", "or where the comments showed strong criticism over the diversity", "> This indicates clearly that the comment section is not", "answer with +33 which have been moved to chat, but", "as negative answers (\"Leave it blank\"). Now comments sections have", "But if take a closer look, there is something strange.", "12th. +14 by Ansa FpTC: 17 (!) comments starting with", "by kingledion: Comments section moved to chat, started with Dec", "look, there is something strange. Positive answers: +22 accepted by", "she was also criticized in the comments. Every (!) answer", "so far who was negative or where the comments showed", "comparable in length, I suggest that we are treating them", "foster opinions (s)he likes and suppress opinions (s)he dislikes by", "Negative answers: +104 by kingledion: Comments section moved to chat,", "over the diversity engagement had its comment section removed while", "Ansa FpTC: 17 (!) comments starting with Dec 12th. Negative", "comment section removed while positive comment sections were unscathed. None", "question about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both positive (\"Use the opportunity\") as", "criticism over the diversity engagement had its comment section removed", "power to foster opinions (s)he likes and suppress opinions (s)he", "by xyz123: 13 comments starting with Dec 12th. +14 by", "Dec 12th. +14 by Ansa FpTC: 17 (!) comments starting", "chat, started with Dec 12th +8 by Nat: Comment section", "showed strong criticism over the diversity engagement had its comment", "time etc. which would explain this behavior. Again: The given", "(!) comments starting with Dec 12th. Negative answers: +104 by", "it blank\"). Now comments sections have been replaced with >", "irrespective of reasons, no matter if they are good or", "strong criticism over the diversity engagement had its comment section", "by Nat: Comment section moved to chat, started with Dec", "a positive answer with +33 which have been moved to", "any difference in starting time etc. which would explain this", "started with Dec 12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg has also a positive", "+14 by Ansa FpTC: 17 (!) comments starting with Dec", "matter if they are good or bad. So if there", "> Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has", "chat, started with Dec 12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg has also a", "to chat. > This indicates clearly that the comment section", "answers: +22 accepted by xyz123: 13 comments starting with Dec", "positive answer with +33 which have been moved to chat,", "sections were unscathed. None of the comment sections has any", "had its comment section removed while positive comment sections were", "extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. >", "the comment section is not for (extended) discussion irrespective of", "None of the comment sections has any difference in starting", "matter if they are good or bad. This is something", "answers: +104 by kingledion: Comments section moved to chat, started", "could abuse his power to foster opinions (s)he likes and", "with Dec 12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg has also a positive answer", "this question about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both positive (\"Use the opportunity\")", "sections which are comparable in length, I suggest that we", "engagement had its comment section removed while positive comment sections", "reasons, no matter if they are good or bad. This", "has any difference in starting time etc. which would explain", "we could all live with. But if take a closer", "answer this question about diversity?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100314/should-i-answer-this-question-about-diversity) got both positive (\"Use the", "Dec 12th +8 by Nat: Comment section moved to chat,", "comments showed strong criticism over the diversity engagement had its", "length, I suggest that we are treating them equally. The", "Dec 12th. Ulizubotb Hannoqg has also a positive answer with", "(extended) discussion irrespective of reasons, no matter if they are", "has also a positive answer with +33 which have been", "of reasons, no matter if they are good or bad.", "is something we could all live with. But if take", "is something strange. Positive answers: +22 accepted by xyz123: 13", "So if there are comment sections which are comparable in", "by Ansa FpTC: 17 (!) comments starting with Dec 12th.", "reason for removing a comment section is that is not", "there are comment sections which are comparable in length, I", "reasons, no matter if they are good or bad. So", "section is that is not for (extended) discussion irrespective of", "answers (\"Leave it blank\"). Now comments sections have been replaced", "are comment sections which are comparable in length, I suggest", "and suppress opinions (s)he dislikes by treating comment sections differently.", "them equally. The presented behavior really looks like that a", "chat. > This indicates clearly that the comment section is", "which would explain this behavior. Again: The given reason for", "Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been", "would explain this behavior. Again*: The given reason for removing" ]
[ "55% male majority in 1974 to a healthy 57% female", "still apply to the other non-gender-specific job postings. > >", "I advise you to check your privilege. > > >", "> > > One might perhaps argue that this is", "\"the separation of job postings based on sex\" seems quite", "Especially, if you see its success in the United states'", "that all actions are justified for the greater good. >", "job postings based on sex\" seems quite sexist to me.", "policy that continues to this day. > > > and", "> > > and it baffles me even more, If", "deleting my answer under the pretence it's spam/offensive. I don't", "than others. Therefore, it is only natural that some actions", "brought upon humanity as seen in advanced countries like Germany", "natural that some actions that are inherently negative see themselves", "Track) for a female Researcher\" illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator", "is easily disproven by noting that women can still apply", "Position (Tenure Track) for a female Researcher\" illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709)", "by the use of the word \"men\". > > >", "sue such a moral endeavour. Especially, if you see its", "Here is the text of the answer: > > All", "a female Researcher\" illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator kept deleting", "Stack Exchange post: [Is \"Assistant Professor Position (Tenure Track) for", "to check your privilege. > > > Although, I might", "all actions are justified for the greater good. > >", "male majority in 1974 to a healthy 57% female majority", "argue that this is \"a form of separate but equal\".", "the rotten principle that \"all men are equal. full stop\".", "check your privilege. > > > Although, I might concede", "great benefits that \"trying to control demographics in order to", "\"the end justifies the means\" Doctrine which clearly states: that", "thinks it offends him/her, please explain why? Here is the", "easily disproven by noting that women can still apply to", "please explain why? Here is the text of the answer:", "perhaps argue that this is \"a form of separate but", "bit unethical because it might hurt the transgender and non-binary", "patriarchal motives by the use of the word \"men\". >", "answer your question, such an effective and moral actions cannot", "does not try to hide its patriarchal motives by the", "the proportion of bachelor's degrees earned has went from an", "57% female majority in 2014, thanks to the affirmative action", "in 1974 to a healthy 57% female majority in 2014,", "some people are more equal than others. Therefore, it is", "disproven by noting that women can still apply to the", "people are more equal than others. Therefore, it is only", "> One might perhaps argue that this is \"a form", "unethical because it might hurt the transgender and non-binary people.", "cannot be illegal unless you go by the rotten principle", "explain why? Here is the text of the answer: >", "might be a bit unethical because it might hurt the", "end justifies the means\" Doctrine which clearly states: that all", "that are inherently negative see themselves become positive. This is", "that continues to this day. > > > and it", "female majority in 2014, thanks to the affirmative action policy", "> > In fact, I'm puzzled why would you want", "\"a form of separate but equal\". But this is easily", "of the answer: > > All people are equal, but", "your question, such an effective and moral actions cannot be", "female Researcher\" illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator kept deleting my", "> In fact, I'm puzzled why would you want to", "I might concede that such a posting might be a", "affirmative action policy that continues to this day. > >", "might concede that such a posting might be a bit", "are equal. full stop\". A heinous saying that does not", "some actions that are inherently negative see themselves become positive.", "that this is \"a form of separate but equal\". But", "job postings. > > > to answer your question, such", "motives by the use of the word \"men\". > >", "might hurt the transgender and non-binary people. > > >", "went from an opressive 55% male majority in 1974 to", "advanced countries like Germany or Israel. > > > One", "You questioning \"the separation of job postings based on sex\"", "try to hide its patriarchal motives by the use of", "my Academia Stack Exchange post: [Is \"Assistant Professor Position (Tenure", "to this day. > > > and it baffles me", "to the other non-gender-specific job postings. > > > to", "is only natural that some actions that are inherently negative", "it's spam/offensive. I don't believe it's spam. And if s/he", "from an opressive 55% male majority in 1974 to a", "the means\" Doctrine which clearly states: that all actions are", "you to check your privilege. > > > Although, I", "> > > Although, I might concede that such a", "about my Academia Stack Exchange post: [Is \"Assistant Professor Position", "to a healthy 57% female majority in 2014, thanks to", "privilege. > > > Although, I might concede that such", "United states' undergrad admission.Where the proportion of bachelor's degrees earned", "that \"all men are equal. full stop\". A heinous saying", "clearly states: that all actions are justified for the greater", "> > One might perhaps argue that this is \"a", "moral endeavour. Especially, if you see its success in the", "positive. This is justified by \"the end justifies the means\"", "opressive 55% male majority in 1974 to a healthy 57%", "illegal unless you go by the rotten principle that \"all", "my answer under the pretence it's spam/offensive. I don't believe", "would you want to sue such a moral endeavour. Especially,", "full stop\". A heinous saying that does not try to", "good. > > > In fact, I'm puzzled why would", "the United states' undergrad admission.Where the proportion of bachelor's degrees", "effective and moral actions cannot be illegal unless you go", "can still apply to the other non-gender-specific job postings. >", "only natural that some actions that are inherently negative see", "moral actions cannot be illegal unless you go by the", "healthy 57% female majority in 2014, thanks to the affirmative", "based on sex\" seems quite sexist to me. I advise", "of job postings based on sex\" seems quite sexist to", "> You questioning \"the separation of job postings based on", "Exchange post: [Is \"Assistant Professor Position (Tenure Track) for a", "justified for the greater good. > > > In fact,", "Israel. > > > One might perhaps argue that this", "equal, but some people are more equal than others. Therefore,", "seen in advanced countries like Germany or Israel. > >", "\"trying to control demographics in order to level inequalities\" has", "greater good. > > > In fact, I'm puzzled why", "use of the word \"men\". > > > You questioning", "answer: > > All people are equal, but some people", "me. I advise you to check your privilege. > >", "a moral endeavour. Especially, if you see its success in", "\"men\". > > > You questioning \"the separation of job", "quite sexist to me. I advise you to check your", "why? Here is the text of the answer: > >", "him/her, please explain why? Here is the text of the", "by \"the end justifies the means\" Doctrine which clearly states:", "> > and it baffles me even more, If you", "unless you go by the rotten principle that \"all men", "post: [Is \"Assistant Professor Position (Tenure Track) for a female", "be illegal unless you go by the rotten principle that", "me even more, If you see the great benefits that", "> and it baffles me even more, If you see", "moderator kept deleting my answer under the pretence it's spam/offensive.", "I'm puzzled why would you want to sue such a", "like Germany or Israel. > > > One might perhaps", "see themselves become positive. This is justified by \"the end", "to sue such a moral endeavour. Especially, if you see", "spam/offensive. I don't believe it's spam. And if s/he thinks", "even more, If you see the great benefits that \"trying", "people are equal, but some people are more equal than", "Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator kept deleting my answer under the pretence", "more, If you see the great benefits that \"trying to", "questioning \"the separation of job postings based on sex\" seems", "that does not try to hide its patriarchal motives by", "upon humanity as seen in advanced countries like Germany or", "for a female Researcher\" illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator kept", "> > Although, I might concede that such a posting", "separate but equal\". But this is easily disproven by noting", "posting might be a bit unethical because it might hurt", "equal\". But this is easily disproven by noting that women", "Academia Stack Exchange post: [Is \"Assistant Professor Position (Tenure Track)", "this is easily disproven by noting that women can still", "want to sue such a moral endeavour. Especially, if you", "you see the great benefits that \"trying to control demographics", "which clearly states: that all actions are justified for the", "but some people are more equal than others. Therefore, it", "of separate but equal\". But this is easily disproven by", "s/he thinks it offends him/her, please explain why? Here is", "in order to level inequalities\" has brought upon humanity as", "countries like Germany or Israel. > > > One might", "noting that women can still apply to the other non-gender-specific", "rotten principle that \"all men are equal. full stop\". A", "Researcher\" illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator kept deleting my answer", "justifies the means\" Doctrine which clearly states: that all actions", "illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator kept deleting my answer under", "because it might hurt the transgender and non-binary people. >", "control demographics in order to level inequalities\" has brought upon", "don't believe it's spam. And if s/he thinks it offends", "stop\". A heinous saying that does not try to hide", "or Israel. > > > One might perhaps argue that", "have a question about my Academia Stack Exchange post: [Is", "separation of job postings based on sex\" seems quite sexist", "2014, thanks to the affirmative action policy that continues to", "your privilege. > > > Although, I might concede that", "spam. And if s/he thinks it offends him/her, please explain", "that \"trying to control demographics in order to level inequalities\"", "of bachelor's degrees earned has went from an opressive 55%", "the use of the word \"men\". > > > You", "success in the United states' undergrad admission.Where the proportion of", "I have a question about my Academia Stack Exchange post:", "of the word \"men\". > > > You questioning \"the", "text of the answer: > > All people are equal,", "actions are justified for the greater good. > > >", "to level inequalities\" has brought upon humanity as seen in", "why would you want to sue such a moral endeavour.", "humanity as seen in advanced countries like Germany or Israel.", "women can still apply to the other non-gender-specific job postings.", "1974 to a healthy 57% female majority in 2014, thanks", "others. Therefore, it is only natural that some actions that", "the pretence it's spam/offensive. I don't believe it's spam. And", "the word \"men\". > > > You questioning \"the separation", "it might hurt the transgender and non-binary people. > >", "puzzled why would you want to sue such a moral", "the great benefits that \"trying to control demographics in order", "offends him/her, please explain why? Here is the text of", "in 2014, thanks to the affirmative action policy that continues", "majority in 2014, thanks to the affirmative action policy that", "degrees earned has went from an opressive 55% male majority", "order to level inequalities\" has brought upon humanity as seen", "> > > to answer your question, such an effective", "kept deleting my answer under the pretence it's spam/offensive. I", "its success in the United states' undergrad admission.Where the proportion", "this day. > > > and it baffles me even", "continues to this day. > > > and it baffles", "believe it's spam. And if s/he thinks it offends him/her,", "this is \"a form of separate but equal\". But this", "One might perhaps argue that this is \"a form of", "to answer your question, such an effective and moral actions", "to control demographics in order to level inequalities\" has brought", "> > > You questioning \"the separation of job postings", "sexist to me. I advise you to check your privilege.", "a healthy 57% female majority in 2014, thanks to the", "inherently negative see themselves become positive. This is justified by", "if you see its success in the United states' undergrad", "its patriarchal motives by the use of the word \"men\".", "> > You questioning \"the separation of job postings based", "All people are equal, but some people are more equal", "proportion of bachelor's degrees earned has went from an opressive", "be a bit unethical because it might hurt the transgender", "But this is easily disproven by noting that women can", "is \"a form of separate but equal\". But this is", "if s/he thinks it offends him/her, please explain why? Here", "that some actions that are inherently negative see themselves become", "answer under the pretence it's spam/offensive. I don't believe it's", "to the affirmative action policy that continues to this day.", "it offends him/her, please explain why? Here is the text", "and it baffles me even more, If you see the", "you see its success in the United states' undergrad admission.Where", "\"Assistant Professor Position (Tenure Track) for a female Researcher\" illegal", "actions that are inherently negative see themselves become positive. This", "level inequalities\" has brought upon humanity as seen in advanced", "but equal\". But this is easily disproven by noting that", "that women can still apply to the other non-gender-specific job", "are equal, but some people are more equal than others.", "action policy that continues to this day. > > >", "advise you to check your privilege. > > > Although,", "Doctrine which clearly states: that all actions are justified for", "(Tenure Track) for a female Researcher\" illegal in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A", "is the text of the answer: > > All people", "fact, I'm puzzled why would you want to sue such", "> All people are equal, but some people are more", "In fact, I'm puzzled why would you want to sue", "question, such an effective and moral actions cannot be illegal", "men are equal. full stop\". A heinous saying that does", "are inherently negative see themselves become positive. This is justified", "form of separate but equal\". But this is easily disproven", "endeavour. Especially, if you see its success in the United", "inequalities\" has brought upon humanity as seen in advanced countries", "to me. I advise you to check your privilege. >", "negative see themselves become positive. This is justified by \"the", "seems quite sexist to me. I advise you to check", "means\" Doctrine which clearly states: that all actions are justified", "to hide its patriarchal motives by the use of the", "question about my Academia Stack Exchange post: [Is \"Assistant Professor", "in the United states' undergrad admission.Where the proportion of bachelor's", "admission.Where the proportion of bachelor's degrees earned has went from", "the affirmative action policy that continues to this day. >", "other non-gender-specific job postings. > > > to answer your", "> > to answer your question, such an effective and", "a question about my Academia Stack Exchange post: [Is \"Assistant", "and moral actions cannot be illegal unless you go by", "you want to sue such a moral endeavour. Especially, if", "under the pretence it's spam/offensive. I don't believe it's spam.", "see its success in the United states' undergrad admission.Where the", "sex\" seems quite sexist to me. I advise you to", "it baffles me even more, If you see the great", "a posting might be a bit unethical because it might", "that such a posting might be a bit unethical because", "majority in 1974 to a healthy 57% female majority in", "not try to hide its patriarchal motives by the use", "such a moral endeavour. Especially, if you see its success", "non-gender-specific job postings. > > > to answer your question,", "Therefore, it is only natural that some actions that are", "Germany or Israel. > > > One might perhaps argue", "it is only natural that some actions that are inherently", "thanks to the affirmative action policy that continues to this", "If you see the great benefits that \"trying to control", "go by the rotten principle that \"all men are equal.", "day. > > > and it baffles me even more,", "has brought upon humanity as seen in advanced countries like", "as seen in advanced countries like Germany or Israel. >", "word \"men\". > > > You questioning \"the separation of", "an opressive 55% male majority in 1974 to a healthy", "heinous saying that does not try to hide its patriarchal", "by noting that women can still apply to the other", "A moderator kept deleting my answer under the pretence it's", "are more equal than others. Therefore, it is only natural", "> to answer your question, such an effective and moral", "actions cannot be illegal unless you go by the rotten", "the answer: > > All people are equal, but some", "justified by \"the end justifies the means\" Doctrine which clearly", "apply to the other non-gender-specific job postings. > > >", "undergrad admission.Where the proportion of bachelor's degrees earned has went", "Professor Position (Tenure Track) for a female Researcher\" illegal in", "equal than others. Therefore, it is only natural that some", "A heinous saying that does not try to hide its", "in Austria?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100529/is-assistant-professor-position-tenure-track-for-a-female-researcher-illegal/100709#100709) A moderator kept deleting my answer under the", "a bit unethical because it might hurt the transgender and", "an effective and moral actions cannot be illegal unless you", "on sex\" seems quite sexist to me. I advise you", "it's spam. And if s/he thinks it offends him/her, please", "bachelor's degrees earned has went from an opressive 55% male", "hide its patriarchal motives by the use of the word", "has went from an opressive 55% male majority in 1974", "baffles me even more, If you see the great benefits", "is justified by \"the end justifies the means\" Doctrine which", "equal. full stop\". A heinous saying that does not try", "> > All people are equal, but some people are", "by the rotten principle that \"all men are equal. full", "> Although, I might concede that such a posting might", "> > > In fact, I'm puzzled why would you", "states' undergrad admission.Where the proportion of bachelor's degrees earned has", "the other non-gender-specific job postings. > > > to answer", "principle that \"all men are equal. full stop\". A heinous", "And if s/he thinks it offends him/her, please explain why?", "become positive. This is justified by \"the end justifies the", "more equal than others. Therefore, it is only natural that", "such an effective and moral actions cannot be illegal unless", "concede that such a posting might be a bit unethical", "for the greater good. > > > In fact, I'm", "the greater good. > > > In fact, I'm puzzled", "themselves become positive. This is justified by \"the end justifies", "This is justified by \"the end justifies the means\" Doctrine", "pretence it's spam/offensive. I don't believe it's spam. And if", "I don't believe it's spam. And if s/he thinks it", "states: that all actions are justified for the greater good.", "might perhaps argue that this is \"a form of separate", "postings based on sex\" seems quite sexist to me. I", "\"all men are equal. full stop\". A heinous saying that", "benefits that \"trying to control demographics in order to level", "demographics in order to level inequalities\" has brought upon humanity", "see the great benefits that \"trying to control demographics in", "saying that does not try to hide its patriarchal motives", "such a posting might be a bit unethical because it", "Although, I might concede that such a posting might be", "the text of the answer: > > All people are", "[Is \"Assistant Professor Position (Tenure Track) for a female Researcher\"", "in advanced countries like Germany or Israel. > > >", "earned has went from an opressive 55% male majority in", "you go by the rotten principle that \"all men are", "postings. > > > to answer your question, such an", "are justified for the greater good. > > > In" ]
[ "many times, last time after the question has been put", "answers or votes from really informed folks, but rather mostly", "so the question was already narrow enough and is now", "installments of the question [Worst cover-letter mistakes of continental-European applicants", "should the narrowing happen. I'm under the impression that the", "informed folks, but rather mostly junk (=uninformed) answers and junk", "I'm under the impression that the expertise is not present", "admitting too many answers or votes from really informed folks,", "from really informed folks, but rather mostly junk (=uninformed) answers", "So far, I have not even seen any useful comments", "is not present here at ac.se in sufficient numbers anyway,", "time after the question has been put on hold. I'm", "already narrow enough and is now even narrower, potentially not", "been put on hold. I'm wondering how often should the", "broad. I narrowed it, many times, last time after the", "really informed folks, but rather mostly junk (=uninformed) answers and", "mistakes of continental-European applicants for tenure-track assistant professorship positions in", "at ac.se in sufficient numbers anyway, so the question was", "for tenure-track assistant professorship positions in CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as", "applicants for tenure-track assistant professorship positions in CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track)", "anyway, so the question was already narrow enough and is", "after the question has been put on hold. I'm wondering", "folks, but rather mostly junk (=uninformed) answers and junk votes.", "many answers or votes from really informed folks, but rather", "often should the narrowing happen. I'm under the impression that", "votes from really informed folks, but rather mostly junk (=uninformed)", "the expertise is not present here at ac.se in sufficient", "present here at ac.se in sufficient numbers anyway, so the", "under the impression that the expertise is not present here", "prior installments of the question [Worst cover-letter mistakes of continental-European", "professorship positions in CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too broad. I", "I have not even seen any useful comments to the", "numbers anyway, so the question was already narrow enough and", "[Worst cover-letter mistakes of continental-European applicants for tenure-track assistant professorship", "votes. So far, I have not even seen any useful", "the question was already narrow enough and is now even", "is now even narrower, potentially not admitting too many answers", "junk votes. So far, I have not even seen any", "the narrowing happen. I'm under the impression that the expertise", "expertise is not present here at ac.se in sufficient numbers", "question has been put on hold. I'm wondering how often", "the question has been put on hold. I'm wondering how", "in sufficient numbers anyway, so the question was already narrow", "narrowing happen. I'm under the impression that the expertise is", "assistant professorship positions in CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too broad.", "the impression that the expertise is not present here at", "not present here at ac.se in sufficient numbers anyway, so", "now even narrower, potentially not admitting too many answers or", "narrow enough and is now even narrower, potentially not admitting", "sufficient numbers anyway, so the question was already narrow enough", "times, last time after the question has been put on", "mostly junk (=uninformed) answers and junk votes. So far, I", "of continental-European applicants for tenure-track assistant professorship positions in CS", "on hold. I'm wondering how often should the narrowing happen.", "too many answers or votes from really informed folks, but", "narrower, potentially not admitting too many answers or votes from", "potentially not admitting too many answers or votes from really", "rather mostly junk (=uninformed) answers and junk votes. So far,", "narrowed it, many times, last time after the question has", "have not even seen any useful comments to the contents", "even narrower, potentially not admitting too many answers or votes", "CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too broad. I narrowed it, many", "considered the prior installments of the question [Worst cover-letter mistakes", "(=uninformed) answers and junk votes. So far, I have not", "how often should the narrowing happen. I'm under the impression", "the question [Worst cover-letter mistakes of continental-European applicants for tenure-track", "not admitting too many answers or votes from really informed", "far, I have not even seen any useful comments to", "was already narrow enough and is now even narrower, potentially", "enough and is now even narrower, potentially not admitting too", "positions in CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too broad. I narrowed", "wondering how often should the narrowing happen. I'm under the", "put on hold. I'm wondering how often should the narrowing", "Some folks considered the prior installments of the question [Worst", "I narrowed it, many times, last time after the question", "not even seen any useful comments to the contents either.", "I'm wondering how often should the narrowing happen. I'm under", "USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too broad. I narrowed it, many times, last", "here at ac.se in sufficient numbers anyway, so the question", "and junk votes. So far, I have not even seen", "impression that the expertise is not present here at ac.se", "answers and junk votes. So far, I have not even", "in CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too broad. I narrowed it,", "or votes from really informed folks, but rather mostly junk", "folks considered the prior installments of the question [Worst cover-letter", "question was already narrow enough and is now even narrower,", "last time after the question has been put on hold.", "question [Worst cover-letter mistakes of continental-European applicants for tenure-track assistant", "tenure-track assistant professorship positions in CS in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too", "happen. I'm under the impression that the expertise is not", "that the expertise is not present here at ac.se in", "in USA](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100907/worst-cover-letter-mistakes-of-continental-european-applicants-for-tenure-track) as too broad. I narrowed it, many times,", "cover-letter mistakes of continental-European applicants for tenure-track assistant professorship positions", "hold. I'm wondering how often should the narrowing happen. I'm", "it, many times, last time after the question has been", "the prior installments of the question [Worst cover-letter mistakes of", "of the question [Worst cover-letter mistakes of continental-European applicants for", "and is now even narrower, potentially not admitting too many", "but rather mostly junk (=uninformed) answers and junk votes. So", "ac.se in sufficient numbers anyway, so the question was already", "continental-European applicants for tenure-track assistant professorship positions in CS in", "has been put on hold. I'm wondering how often should", "too broad. I narrowed it, many times, last time after", "junk (=uninformed) answers and junk votes. So far, I have", "as too broad. I narrowed it, many times, last time" ]
[ "a waste of time and effort, and that they would", "post-graduate degree in Computer Science, one would presumably need an", "valid answer to \"How do I [do thing]\"; it conveys", "than a link to an external site * not even", "presumably need an undergraduate degree in Computer Science. Since men", "ads to attract female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled down to", "to +11 votes, and was then deleted by Wrzlprmft and", "to [do thing]). As far as I can see, neither", "I [do thing]\"; it conveys useful information to the person", "external site * not even a partial answer to the", "other answers * asking another, different question * “thanks!” or", "degree in Computer Science, one would presumably need an undergraduate", "complete said undergraduate degrees significantly outnumber the women who complete", "potential female applicants is already too small to make a", "any comments explaining what problems they had with it; they", "My answer was as follows: > > Don't bother trying.", "click the Help Centre link, I get the following list", "list of reasons for answers to be deleted: * commentary", "the person who asked that question (namely, that attempting to", "more developed your nation is, as the women are more", "method of privately messaging them on here that I can", "the jobs that might be more economically viable), the number", "of time and effort, and that they would be better", "the actual question My answer fell into none of those", "not attempting to [do thing]). As far as I can", "get the following list of reasons for answers to be", "too small to make a significant difference. > > >", "to be deleted: * commentary on the question or other", "in Computer Science. Since men who complete said undergraduate degrees", "on here that I can see, I have to ask", "> > > It got upvoted up to +11 votes,", "to the actual question My answer fell into none of", "would be better off not attempting to [do thing]). As", "the Help Centre link, I get the following list of", "I write job ads to attract female PhD candidates\". My", "comments of that question to another user, \"Don't bother trying\"", "that I can see, I have to ask them publicly", "be deleted: * commentary on the question or other answers", "in the comments of that question to another user, \"Don't", "that attempting to [do thing] is a waste of time", "or “me too!” responses * exact duplicates of other answers", "to attract female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled down to \"How", "do I [do thing]\"; it conveys useful information to the", "answer to this question: [Writing ads to attract female PhD", "reasons for answers to be deleted: * commentary on the", "to \"How do I write job ads to attract female", "explaining what problems they had with it; they just unilaterally", "undergraduate degree in Computer Science. Since men who complete said", "user, \"Don't bother trying\" is a valid answer to \"How", "attempting to [do thing] is a waste of time and", "other answers * barely more than a link to an", "Science, one would presumably need an undergraduate degree in Computer", "way; in order to do a post-graduate degree in Computer", "than the jobs that might be more economically viable), the", "question * “thanks!” or “me too!” responses * exact duplicates", "conveys useful information to the person who asked that question", "up to +11 votes, and was then deleted by Wrzlprmft", "deleted my answer even made any comments explaining what problems", "Wrzlprmft and StrongBad. Since there doesn't seem to be any", "link to an external site * not even a partial", "significant difference. > > > It got upvoted up to", "small to make a significant difference. > > > It", "seem to be any method of privately messaging them on", "to ask them publicly like this instead. When I click", "this instead. When I click the Help Centre link, I", "the comments of that question to another user, \"Don't bother", "Don't bother trying. Your ad is unlikely to make a", "of the moderators who deleted my answer even made any", "posted an answer to this question: [Writing ads to attract", "effort, and that they would be better off not attempting", "the number of potential female applicants is already too small", "I click the Help Centre link, I get the following", "here that I can see, I have to ask them", "got upvoted up to +11 votes, and was then deleted", "none of those categories. As I said in the comments", "I get the following list of reasons for answers to", "is unlikely to make a difference either way; in order", "them, rather than the jobs that might be more economically", "upvoted up to +11 votes, and was then deleted by", "another, different question * “thanks!” or “me too!” responses ", "asked that question (namely, that attempting to [do thing] is", "significantly outnumber the women who complete said degrees (and the", "degree in Computer Science. Since men who complete said undergraduate", "degrees (and the ratio gets worse the more developed your", "the question or other answers asking another, different question", "+11 votes, and was then deleted by Wrzlprmft and StrongBad.", "[do thing]). As far as I can see, neither of", "to make a difference either way; in order to do", "order to do a post-graduate degree in Computer Science, one", "is already too small to make a significant difference. >", "I posted an answer to this question: [Writing ads to", "female applicants is already too small to make a significant", "women who complete said degrees (and the ratio gets worse", "[Writing ads to attract female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled down", "might be more economically viable), the number of potential female", "answer was as follows: > > Don't bother trying. Your", "and that they would be better off not attempting to", "> > It got upvoted up to +11 votes, and", "who complete said undergraduate degrees significantly outnumber the women who", "that they would be better off not attempting to [do", "women are more free to pick the jobs that interest", "write job ads to attract female PhD candidates\". My answer", "waste of time and effort, and that they would be", "be better off not attempting to [do thing]). As far", "doesn't seem to be any method of privately messaging them", "trying\" is a valid answer to \"How do I [do", "do I write job ads to attract female PhD candidates\".", "to [do thing] is a waste of time and effort,", "that interest them, rather than the jobs that might be", "they had with it; they just unilaterally deleted it without", "PhD candidates\". My answer was as follows: > > *Don't", "who asked that question (namely, that attempting to [do thing]", "the women are more free to pick the jobs that", "jobs that interest them, rather than the jobs that might", "thing]). As far as I can see, neither of the", "better off not attempting to [do thing]). As far as", "attempting to [do thing]). As far as I can see,", "and StrongBad. Since there doesn't seem to be any method", "nation is, as the women are more free to pick", "question or other answers asking another, different question ", "comments explaining what problems they had with it; they just", "it conveys useful information to the person who asked that", "and effort, and that they would be better off not", "question (namely, that attempting to [do thing] is a waste", "too!” responses exact duplicates of other answers * barely", "partial answer to the actual question My answer fell into", "of potential female applicants is already too small to make", "messaging them on here that I can see, I have", "them on here that I can see, I have to", "by Wrzlprmft and StrongBad. Since there doesn't seem to be", "to \"How do I [do thing]\"; it conveys useful information", "even made any comments explaining what problems they had with", "the moderators who deleted my answer even made any comments", "had with it; they just unilaterally deleted it without explanation.", "a partial answer to the actual question My answer fell", "said undergraduate degrees significantly outnumber the women who complete said", "of other answers * barely more than a link to", "to attract female PhD candidates\". My answer was as follows:", "moderators who deleted my answer even made any comments explaining", "* “thanks!” or “me too!” responses * exact duplicates of", "the following list of reasons for answers to be deleted:", "see, neither of the moderators who deleted my answer even", "StrongBad. Since there doesn't seem to be any method of", "* commentary on the question or other answers * asking", "more free to pick the jobs that interest them, rather", "(namely, that attempting to [do thing] is a waste of", "When I click the Help Centre link, I get the", "as I can see, neither of the moderators who deleted", "bother trying\" is a valid answer to \"How do I", "to do a post-graduate degree in Computer Science, one would", "I said in the comments of that question to another", "is a valid answer to \"How do I [do thing]\";", "not even a partial answer to the actual question My", "make a significant difference. > > > It got upvoted", "attract female PhD candidates\". My answer was as follows: >", "ask them publicly like this instead. When I click the", "Computer Science, one would presumably need an undergraduate degree in", "categories. As I said in the comments of that question", "[do thing]\"; it conveys useful information to the person who", "publicly like this instead. When I click the Help Centre", "ratio gets worse the more developed your nation is, as", "instead. When I click the Help Centre link, I get", "female PhD candidates\". My answer was as follows: > >", "to be any method of privately messaging them on here", "asking another, different question * “thanks!” or “me too!” responses", "thing]\"; it conveys useful information to the person who asked", "be any method of privately messaging them on here that", "make a difference either way; in order to do a", "to make a significant difference. > > > It got", "Your ad is unlikely to make a difference either way;", "As far as I can see, neither of the moderators", "site * not even a partial answer to the actual", "even a partial answer to the actual question My answer", "PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled down to \"How do I write", "* exact duplicates of other answers * barely more than", "interest them, rather than the jobs that might be more", "question My answer fell into none of those categories. As", "into none of those categories. As I said in the", "exact duplicates of other answers * barely more than a", "[do thing] is a waste of time and effort, and", "your nation is, as the women are more free to", "answer to the actual question My answer fell into none", "one would presumably need an undergraduate degree in Computer Science.", "that might be more economically viable), the number of potential", "job ads to attract female PhD candidates\". My answer was", "worse the more developed your nation is, as the women", "as the women are more free to pick the jobs", "answers * asking another, different question * “thanks!” or “me", "to this question: [Writing ads to attract female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/),", "female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled down to \"How do I", "Help Centre link, I get the following list of reasons", "I can see, neither of the moderators who deleted my", "candidates\". My answer was as follows: > > *Don't bother", "more than a link to an external site not", "barely more than a link to an external site ", "was then deleted by Wrzlprmft and StrongBad. Since there doesn't", "either way; in order to do a post-graduate degree in", "difference. > > > It got upvoted up to +11", "information to the person who asked that question (namely, that", "answers to be deleted: commentary on the question or", "an external site * not even a partial answer to", "Science. Since men who complete said undergraduate degrees significantly outnumber", "to the person who asked that question (namely, that attempting", "\"How do I [do thing]\"; it conveys useful information to", "* barely more than a link to an external site", "like this instead. When I click the Help Centre link,", "Computer Science. Since men who complete said undergraduate degrees significantly", "can see, neither of the moderators who deleted my answer", "> > Don't bother trying. Your ad is unlikely to", "difference either way; in order to do a post-graduate degree", "are more free to pick the jobs that interest them,", "jobs that might be more economically viable), the number of", "\"How do I write job ads to attract female PhD", "to pick the jobs that interest them, rather than the", "Since men who complete said undergraduate degrees significantly outnumber the", "be more economically viable), the number of potential female applicants", "answer fell into none of those categories. As I said", "see, I have to ask them publicly like this instead.", "My answer fell into none of those categories. As I", "a link to an external site * not even a", "Centre link, I get the following list of reasons for", "made any comments explaining what problems they had with it;", "the jobs that interest them, rather than the jobs that", "person who asked that question (namely, that attempting to [do", "attract female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled down to \"How do", "question: [Writing ads to attract female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled", "they would be better off not attempting to [do thing]).", "economically viable), the number of potential female applicants is already", "said degrees (and the ratio gets worse the more developed", "gets worse the more developed your nation is, as the", "* asking another, different question * “thanks!” or “me too!”", "bother trying.** Your ad is unlikely to make a difference", "following list of reasons for answers to be deleted: ", "Since there doesn't seem to be any method of privately", "boiled down to \"How do I write job ads to", "of that question to another user, \"Don't bother trying\" is", "I can see, I have to ask them publicly like", "already too small to make a significant difference. > >", "neither of the moderators who deleted my answer even made", "my answer even made any comments explaining what problems they", "answer even made any comments explaining what problems they had", "It got upvoted up to +11 votes, and was then", "in Computer Science, one would presumably need an undergraduate degree", "to an external site not even a partial answer", "that question to another user, \"Don't bother trying\" is a", "different question * “thanks!” or “me too!” responses * exact", "thing] is a waste of time and effort, and that", "or other answers * asking another, different question * “thanks!”", "“thanks!” or “me too!” responses * exact duplicates of other", "a valid answer to \"How do I [do thing]\"; it", "viable), the number of potential female applicants is already too", "degrees significantly outnumber the women who complete said degrees (and", "link, I get the following list of reasons for answers", "deleted by Wrzlprmft and StrongBad. Since there doesn't seem to", "candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which boiled down to \"How do I write job", "applicants is already too small to make a significant difference.", "undergraduate degrees significantly outnumber the women who complete said degrees", "which boiled down to \"How do I write job ads", "votes, and was then deleted by Wrzlprmft and StrongBad. Since", "in order to do a post-graduate degree in Computer Science,", "said in the comments of that question to another user,", "\"Don't bother trying\" is a valid answer to \"How do", "complete said degrees (and the ratio gets worse the more", "pick the jobs that interest them, rather than the jobs", "what problems they had with it; they just unilaterally deleted", "can see, I have to ask them publicly like this", "ads to attract female PhD candidates\". My answer was as", "a post-graduate degree in Computer Science, one would presumably need", "useful information to the person who asked that question (namely,", "the ratio gets worse the more developed your nation is,", "the more developed your nation is, as the women are", "question to another user, \"Don't bother trying\" is a valid", "developed your nation is, as the women are more free", "to another user, \"Don't bother trying\" is a valid answer", "as follows: > > Don't bother trying. Your ad is", "of privately messaging them on here that I can see,", "would presumably need an undergraduate degree in Computer Science. Since", "have to ask them publicly like this instead. When I", "more economically viable), the number of potential female applicants is", "the women who complete said degrees (and the ratio gets", "I have to ask them publicly like this instead. When", "(and the ratio gets worse the more developed your nation", "is, as the women are more free to pick the", "trying.** Your ad is unlikely to make a difference either", "for answers to be deleted: * commentary on the question", "an undergraduate degree in Computer Science. Since men who complete", "responses * exact duplicates of other answers * barely more", "* not even a partial answer to the actual question", "far as I can see, neither of the moderators who", "ad is unlikely to make a difference either way; in", "do a post-graduate degree in Computer Science, one would presumably", "actual question My answer fell into none of those categories.", "of those categories. As I said in the comments of", "problems they had with it; they just unilaterally deleted it", "this question: [Writing ads to attract female PhD candidates](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100884/writing-ads-to-attract-female-phd-candidates/), which", "who deleted my answer even made any comments explaining what", "a difference either way; in order to do a post-graduate", "commentary on the question or other answers * asking another,", "on the question or other answers * asking another, different", "them publicly like this instead. When I click the Help", "and was then deleted by Wrzlprmft and StrongBad. Since there", "> It got upvoted up to +11 votes, and was", "is a waste of time and effort, and that they", "those categories. As I said in the comments of that", "“me too!” responses * exact duplicates of other answers ", "> Don't bother trying.* Your ad is unlikely to make", "off not attempting to [do thing]). As far as I", "who complete said degrees (and the ratio gets worse the", "then deleted by Wrzlprmft and StrongBad. Since there doesn't seem", "down to \"How do I write job ads to attract", "As I said in the comments of that question to", "privately messaging them on here that I can see, I", "a significant difference. > > > It got upvoted up", "that question (namely, that attempting to [do thing] is a", "men who complete said undergraduate degrees significantly outnumber the women", "rather than the jobs that might be more economically viable),", "fell into none of those categories. As I said in", "answer to \"How do I [do thing]\"; it conveys useful", "was as follows: > > Don't bother trying. Your ad", "an answer to this question: [Writing ads to attract female", "free to pick the jobs that interest them, rather than", "there doesn't seem to be any method of privately messaging", "any method of privately messaging them on here that I", "time and effort, and that they would be better off", "another user, \"Don't bother trying\" is a valid answer to", "outnumber the women who complete said degrees (and the ratio", "unlikely to make a difference either way; in order to", "answers * barely more than a link to an external", "of reasons for answers to be deleted: * commentary on", "duplicates of other answers * barely more than a link", "deleted: * commentary on the question or other answers ", "follows: > > Don't bother trying.* Your ad is unlikely", "number of potential female applicants is already too small to", "need an undergraduate degree in Computer Science. Since men who" ]
[ "But for users without the rep, is the 'flag' function", "rep, is the 'flag' function a viable means to recommend", "recommend to a Moderator that a question should be protected,", "is the 'flag' function a viable means to recommend to", "is this not the right method? [What do I do", "a question should be protected, or is this not the", "right method? [What do I do if a teacher fails", "not the right method? [What do I do if a", "be protected, or is this not the right method? [What", "[What do I do if a teacher fails me after", "I do if a teacher fails me after they said", "viable means to recommend to a Moderator that a question", "users without the rep, is the 'flag' function a viable", "method? [What do I do if a teacher fails me", "if a teacher fails me after they said I'd pass?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100930/what-do-i-do-if-a-teacher-fails-me-after-they-said-id-pass/100935#100935)", "this not the right method? [What do I do if", "familiar with the privilege.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/protect-questions) But for users without the rep,", "should be protected, or is this not the right method?", "or is this not the right method? [What do I", "do I do if a teacher fails me after they", "am familiar with the privilege.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/protect-questions) But for users without the", "a viable means to recommend to a Moderator that a", "privilege.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/protect-questions) But for users without the rep, is the 'flag'", "without the rep, is the 'flag' function a viable means", "with the privilege.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/protect-questions) But for users without the rep, is", "'flag' function a viable means to recommend to a Moderator", "to a Moderator that a question should be protected, or", "to recommend to a Moderator that a question should be", "Moderator that a question should be protected, or is this", "that a question should be protected, or is this not", "protected, or is this not the right method? [What do", "do if a teacher fails me after they said I'd", "the privilege.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/protect-questions) But for users without the rep, is the", "function a viable means to recommend to a Moderator that", "for users without the rep, is the 'flag' function a", "the rep, is the 'flag' function a viable means to", "the 'flag' function a viable means to recommend to a", "question should be protected, or is this not the right", "means to recommend to a Moderator that a question should", "[I am familiar with the privilege.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/protect-questions) But for users without", "the right method? [What do I do if a teacher", "a Moderator that a question should be protected, or is" ]
[ "resourses like books, scientific articles and so on? For example,", "I have to use? Maybe literature-search and literatue? Thank you", "topic (Does oxygen induce coagulation?), what tag I have to", "can I ask to help me to look for resourses", "(Does oxygen induce coagulation?), what tag I have to use?", "I ask to help me to look for resourses like", "to look for resourses like books, scientific articles and so", "ask to help me to look for resourses like books,", "tag I have to use? Maybe literature-search and literatue? Thank", "for resourses like books, scientific articles and so on? For", "to help me to look for resourses like books, scientific", "help me to look for resourses like books, scientific articles", "on a specific topic (Does oxygen induce coagulation?), what tag", "literature-search and literatue? Thank you so much for your time.", "have to use? Maybe literature-search and literatue? Thank you so", "on? For example, if I want resourses on a specific", "if I want resourses on a specific topic (Does oxygen", "use? Maybe literature-search and literatue? Thank you so much for", "For example, if I want resourses on a specific topic", "I want resourses on a specific topic (Does oxygen induce", "a specific topic (Does oxygen induce coagulation?), what tag I", "and so on? For example, if I want resourses on", "look for resourses like books, scientific articles and so on?", "scientific articles and so on? For example, if I want", "like books, scientific articles and so on? For example, if", "so on? For example, if I want resourses on a", "what tag I have to use? Maybe literature-search and literatue?", "example, if I want resourses on a specific topic (Does", "books, scientific articles and so on? For example, if I", "want resourses on a specific topic (Does oxygen induce coagulation?),", "articles and so on? For example, if I want resourses", "Where can I ask to help me to look for", "coagulation?), what tag I have to use? Maybe literature-search and", "to use? Maybe literature-search and literatue? Thank you so much", "resourses on a specific topic (Does oxygen induce coagulation?), what", "oxygen induce coagulation?), what tag I have to use? Maybe", "specific topic (Does oxygen induce coagulation?), what tag I have", "me to look for resourses like books, scientific articles and", "induce coagulation?), what tag I have to use? Maybe literature-search", "Maybe literature-search and literatue? Thank you so much for your" ]
[ "irregularities\". What does that mean? Does that mean he created", "on here and how one can avoid a similar fate.", "what's going on here and how one can avoid a", "says he was suspended for \"voting irregularities\". What does that", "curious what's going on here and how one can avoid", "argumentative and seemed to be not-so-subtly trolling the site in", "Or perhaps it means that he serially downvoted particularly uses.", "be not-so-subtly trolling the site in many ways but his", "mean he created sock puppet accounts and upvoted himself? Or", "the site in many ways but his profile says he", "site in many ways but his profile says he was", "not-so-subtly trolling the site in many ways but his profile", "[this user](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/56935/leon-meier) was argumentative and seemed to be not-so-subtly trolling", "user](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/56935/leon-meier) was argumentative and seemed to be not-so-subtly trolling the", "he created sock puppet accounts and upvoted himself? Or perhaps", "Does that mean he created sock puppet accounts and upvoted", "and upvoted himself? Or perhaps it means that he serially", "going on here and how one can avoid a similar", "What does that mean? Does that mean he created sock", "that mean? Does that mean he created sock puppet accounts", "particularly uses. Or both? Kind of curious what's going on", "downvoted particularly uses. Or both? Kind of curious what's going", "he serially downvoted particularly uses. Or both? Kind of curious", "his profile says he was suspended for \"voting irregularities\". What", "for \"voting irregularities\". What does that mean? Does that mean", "seemed to be not-so-subtly trolling the site in many ways", "suspended for \"voting irregularities\". What does that mean? Does that", "\"voting irregularities\". What does that mean? Does that mean he", "profile says he was suspended for \"voting irregularities\". What does", "ways but his profile says he was suspended for \"voting", "Or both? Kind of curious what's going on here and", "I know [this user](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/56935/leon-meier) was argumentative and seemed to be", "Kind of curious what's going on here and how one", "upvoted himself? Or perhaps it means that he serially downvoted", "accounts and upvoted himself? Or perhaps it means that he", "puppet accounts and upvoted himself? Or perhaps it means that", "means that he serially downvoted particularly uses. Or both? Kind", "uses. Or both? Kind of curious what's going on here", "in many ways but his profile says he was suspended", "mean? Does that mean he created sock puppet accounts and", "that he serially downvoted particularly uses. Or both? Kind of", "many ways but his profile says he was suspended for", "to be not-so-subtly trolling the site in many ways but", "know [this user](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/56935/leon-meier) was argumentative and seemed to be not-so-subtly", "himself? Or perhaps it means that he serially downvoted particularly", "but his profile says he was suspended for \"voting irregularities\".", "was argumentative and seemed to be not-so-subtly trolling the site", "does that mean? Does that mean he created sock puppet", "of curious what's going on here and how one can", "both? Kind of curious what's going on here and how", "here and how one can avoid a similar fate. Thanks!", "it means that he serially downvoted particularly uses. Or both?", "was suspended for \"voting irregularities\". What does that mean? Does", "that mean he created sock puppet accounts and upvoted himself?", "perhaps it means that he serially downvoted particularly uses. Or", "and seemed to be not-so-subtly trolling the site in many", "serially downvoted particularly uses. Or both? Kind of curious what's", "created sock puppet accounts and upvoted himself? Or perhaps it", "trolling the site in many ways but his profile says", "he was suspended for \"voting irregularities\". What does that mean?", "sock puppet accounts and upvoted himself? Or perhaps it means" ]
[ "discussed in length by the defendant, site moderators, and SE", "privy to the parties involved. However for those who are", "I wanted to ask, just how does one appeal an", "has been discussed in length by the defendant, site moderators,", "process works, I wanted to ask, just how does one", "who are interested in how the appeal process works, I", "works, I wanted to ask, just how does one appeal", "defendant, site moderators, and SE team admins. With details privy", "users on SE sites. In most cases the reason has", "the reason has been discussed in length by the defendant,", "and SE team admins. With details privy to the parties", "how the appeal process works, I wanted to ask, just", "to the parties involved. However for those who are interested", "are interested in how the appeal process works, I wanted", "appeal process works, I wanted to ask, just how does", "suspensions can happen to users on SE sites. In most", "cases the reason has been discussed in length by the", "the appeal process works, I wanted to ask, just how", "parties involved. However for those who are interested in how", "Although rare, account suspensions can happen to users on SE", "can happen to users on SE sites. In most cases", "admins. With details privy to the parties involved. However for", "wanted to ask, just how does one appeal an account", "sites. In most cases the reason has been discussed in", "However for those who are interested in how the appeal", "With details privy to the parties involved. However for those", "rare, account suspensions can happen to users on SE sites.", "details privy to the parties involved. However for those who", "on SE sites. In most cases the reason has been", "those who are interested in how the appeal process works,", "SE team admins. With details privy to the parties involved.", "the parties involved. However for those who are interested in", "interested in how the appeal process works, I wanted to", "involved. However for those who are interested in how the", "happen to users on SE sites. In most cases the", "in length by the defendant, site moderators, and SE team", "moderators, and SE team admins. With details privy to the", "team admins. With details privy to the parties involved. However", "the defendant, site moderators, and SE team admins. With details", "for those who are interested in how the appeal process", "in how the appeal process works, I wanted to ask,", "account suspensions can happen to users on SE sites. In", "site moderators, and SE team admins. With details privy to", "to ask, just how does one appeal an account suspension?", "length by the defendant, site moderators, and SE team admins.", "In most cases the reason has been discussed in length", "SE sites. In most cases the reason has been discussed", "most cases the reason has been discussed in length by", "reason has been discussed in length by the defendant, site", "by the defendant, site moderators, and SE team admins. With", "been discussed in length by the defendant, site moderators, and", "to users on SE sites. In most cases the reason" ]
[ "other answers > * barely more than a link to", "of other answers > * barely more than a link", "not even a partial answer to the actual question >", "answers still have net positive scores preventing high-rep users from", "answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > > Answers that do not fundamentally answer the", "in users flagging low quality answers, but often these flags", "to decide if the answer should be deleted. There have", "duplicates of other answers > * barely more than a", "goes through a community review process. Every once in a", "the answer should be deleted. There have been complaints in", "The only discussion I can find on deleting answers in", "'deleting'\")). The only discussion I can find on deleting answers", "in a while the review process is inconclusive leading to", "moderators reacting to these flags by deleting the answer (e.g.,", "Once the answer is flagged, it goes through a community", "be deleted. There have been complaints in the past about", "may be removed. This includes answers that are: > >", "fundamentally answer the question may be removed. This includes answers", "short answer and not a lot of visibility. How do", "issue is that many low quality answers still have net", "(HNQ) list. This results in users flagging low quality answers,", "users from casting delete vote. This is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of", "quality answers, but often these flags are cast on answers", "includes answers that are: > > > * commentary on", "if the answer should be deleted. There have been complaints", "description of why some answers are deleted. Once the answer", "once in a while the review process is inconclusive leading", "> * barely more than a link to an external", "not fundamentally answer the question may be removed. This includes", "This includes answers that are: > > > * commentary", "moderator needs to decide if the answer should be deleted.", "positive scores that seem to be poorly researched (i.e., worthy", "answers that do not fall clearly into the help center", "than a partial answer to the actual question that have", "One issue is that many low quality answers still have", "the question may be removed. This includes answers that are:", "is that many low quality answers still have net positive", "leading to an auto generated flag for moderator attention where", "center description of why some answers are deleted. Once the", "should be deleted. There have been complaints in the past", "question may be removed. This includes answers that are: >", "This is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions that make the Hot", "cast on answers that do not fall clearly into the", "discussion I can find on deleting answers in general is", "in general is this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a short answer", "on answers that do not fall clearly into the help", "process is inconclusive leading to an auto generated flag for", "help center description of why some answers are deleted. Once", "general is this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a short answer and", "needs to decide if the answer should be deleted. There", "provides some [guidance about deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > > Answers that", "visibility. How do we want moderators to handle flags on", "inconclusive leading to an auto generated flag for moderator attention", "(e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions tagged 'deleting'\")). The only discussion I", "the help center description of why some answers are deleted.", "review process is inconclusive leading to an auto generated flag", "are cast on answers that do not fall clearly into", "to these flags by deleting the answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show", "community review process. Every once in a while the review", "How do we want moderators to handle flags on answers", "a partial answer to the actual question that have resulted", "about moderators reacting to these flags by deleting the answer", "answers that are: > > > * commentary on the", "poorly researched (i.e., worthy of down votes) and not obviously", "actual question > > > One issue is that many", "flags are cast on answers that do not fall clearly", "answer is flagged, it goes through a community review process.", "obviously more than a partial answer to the actual question", "through a community review process. Every once in a while", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a short answer and not a lot of", "do we want moderators to handle flags on answers that", "The help center provides some [guidance about deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) >", "low quality answers still have net positive scores preventing high-rep", "only discussion I can find on deleting answers in general", "want moderators to handle flags on answers that have net", "[guidance about deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > > Answers that do not", "these flags are cast on answers that do not fall", "been complaints in the past about moderators reacting to these", "flag for moderator attention where a moderator needs to decide", "questions tagged 'deleting'\")). The only discussion I can find on", "help center provides some [guidance about deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > >", "not fall clearly into the help center description of why", "auto generated flag for moderator attention where a moderator needs", "scores that seem to be poorly researched (i.e., worthy of", "> “thanks!” or “me too!” responses > * exact", "deleting answers in general is this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a", "to the actual question > > > One issue is", "be poorly researched (i.e., worthy of down votes) and not", "> > Answers that do not fundamentally answer the question", "* exact duplicates of other answers > * barely more", "a short answer and not a lot of visibility. How", "Answers that do not fundamentally answer the question may be", "* barely more than a link to an external site", "or “me too!” responses > * exact duplicates of other", "positive scores preventing high-rep users from casting delete vote. This", "with a short answer and not a lot of visibility.", "that many low quality answers still have net positive scores", "[old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a short answer and not a lot", "> * commentary on the question or other answers >", "process. Every once in a while the review process is", "flags by deleting the answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions tagged", "on deleting answers in general is this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with", "more than a link to an external site > ", "the review process is inconclusive leading to an auto generated", "are deleted. Once the answer is flagged, it goes through", "it goes through a community review process. Every once in", "on answers that have net positive scores that seem to", "attention where a moderator needs to decide if the answer", "some [guidance about deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > > Answers that do", "question > * “thanks!” or “me too!” responses > ", "these flags by deleting the answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions", "answers are deleted. Once the answer is flagged, it goes", "question or other answers > * asking another, different question", "results in users flagging low quality answers, but often these", "an external site > * not even a partial answer", "This results in users flagging low quality answers, but often", "a while the review process is inconclusive leading to an", "the answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions tagged 'deleting'\")). The only", "worthy of down votes) and not obviously more than a", "down votes) and not obviously more than a partial answer", "exact duplicates of other answers > barely more than", "to handle flags on answers that have net positive scores", "not a lot of visibility. How do we want moderators", "too!” responses > * exact duplicates of other answers >", "seem to be poorly researched (i.e., worthy of down votes)", "on the question or other answers > * asking another,", "for moderator attention where a moderator needs to decide if", "is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions that make the Hot Network", "of visibility. How do we want moderators to handle flags", "often these flags are cast on answers that do not", "net positive scores that seem to be poorly researched (i.e.,", "center provides some [guidance about deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > > Answers", "more than a partial answer to the actual question that", "a partial answer to the actual question > > >", "> One issue is that many low quality answers still", "of questions that make the Hot Network Question (HNQ) list.", "> > > One issue is that many low quality", "[particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions that make the Hot Network Question", "* not even a partial answer to the actual question", "users flagging low quality answers, but often these flags are", "the answer is flagged, it goes through a community review", "than a link to an external site > * not", "to an external site > * not even a partial", "tagged 'deleting'\")). The only discussion I can find on deleting", "not obviously more than a partial answer to the actual", "is flagged, it goes through a community review process. Every", "have net positive scores preventing high-rep users from casting delete", "\"show questions tagged 'deleting'\")). The only discussion I can find", "the question or other answers > asking another, different", "deleting the answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions tagged 'deleting'\")). The", "answers > * barely more than a link to an", "generated flag for moderator attention where a moderator needs to", "deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > > Answers that do not fundamentally answer", "> * exact duplicates of other answers > * barely", "can find on deleting answers in general is this [old", "answers that have net positive scores that seem to be", "> * asking another, different question > * “thanks!” or", "an auto generated flag for moderator attention where a moderator", "of why some answers are deleted. Once the answer is", "“thanks!” or “me too!” responses > * exact duplicates of", "reacting to these flags by deleting the answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting", "do not fundamentally answer the question may be removed. This", "we want moderators to handle flags on answers that have", "that seem to be poorly researched (i.e., worthy of down", "moderators to handle flags on answers that have net positive", "Every once in a while the review process is inconclusive", "the Hot Network Question (HNQ) list. This results in users", "into the help center description of why some answers are", "(i.e., worthy of down votes) and not obviously more than", "that do not fall clearly into the help center description", "external site > not even a partial answer to", "> > One issue is that many low quality answers", "still have net positive scores preventing high-rep users from casting", "review process. Every once in a while the review process", "net positive scores preventing high-rep users from casting delete vote.", "of down votes) and not obviously more than a partial", "many low quality answers still have net positive scores preventing", "answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions tagged 'deleting'\")). The only discussion", " commentary on the question or other answers > ", "> > > commentary on the question or other", "why some answers are deleted. Once the answer is flagged,", "is this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a short answer and not", "past about moderators reacting to these flags by deleting the", "questions that make the Hot Network Question (HNQ) list. This", "different question > * “thanks!” or “me too!” responses >", "> Answers that do not fundamentally answer the question may", "have been complaints in the past about moderators reacting to", "Network Question (HNQ) list. This results in users flagging low", "in the past about moderators reacting to these flags by", "a community review process. Every once in a while the", "high-rep users from casting delete vote. This is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is)", "casting delete vote. This is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions that", "have net positive scores that seem to be poorly researched", "handle flags on answers that have net positive scores that", "to the actual question* that have resulted in an inconclusive", "flags on answers that have net positive scores that seem", "> * not even a partial answer to the actual", "from casting delete vote. This is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions", "low quality answers, but often these flags are cast on", "votes) and not obviously more than a partial answer to", "to be poorly researched (i.e., worthy of down votes) and", "answer to the actual question > > > One issue", "decide if the answer should be deleted. There have been", "removed. This includes answers that are: > > > ", "[deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions tagged 'deleting'\")). The only discussion I can", "some answers are deleted. Once the answer is flagged, it", "partial answer to the actual question > > > One", "answers, but often these flags are cast on answers that", "a link to an external site > not even", "fall clearly into the help center description of why some", "answer and not a lot of visibility. How do we", "lot of visibility. How do we want moderators to handle", "scores preventing high-rep users from casting delete vote. This is", "by deleting the answer (e.g., [deleting](/questions/tagged/deleting \"show questions tagged 'deleting'\")).", "There have been complaints in the past about moderators reacting", "make the Hot Network Question (HNQ) list. This results in", "I can find on deleting answers in general is this", "are: > > > commentary on the question or", "that make the Hot Network Question (HNQ) list. This results", "the past about moderators reacting to these flags by deleting", "asking another, different question > * “thanks!” or “me too!”", "this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a short answer and not a", "a lot of visibility. How do we want moderators to", "and not obviously more than a partial answer to the", "flagging low quality answers, but often these flags are cast", "find on deleting answers in general is this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted)", "answers in general is this [old question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/86/when-should-an-answer-be-deleted) with a short", "to an auto generated flag for moderator attention where a", "that are: > > > commentary on the question", "even a partial answer to the actual question > >", "preventing high-rep users from casting delete vote. This is [particularly", "clearly into the help center description of why some answers", "quality answers still have net positive scores preventing high-rep users", "and not a lot of visibility. How do we want", " “thanks!” or “me too!” responses > * exact duplicates", "do not fall clearly into the help center description of", "deleted. Once the answer is flagged, it goes through a", " asking another, different question > * “thanks!” or “me", "where a moderator needs to decide if the answer should", "link to an external site > * not even a", "commentary on the question or other answers > * asking", "the actual question > > > One issue is that", "delete vote. This is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions that make", "is inconclusive leading to an auto generated flag for moderator", "question > > > One issue is that many low", "partial answer to the actual question that have resulted in", "but often these flags are cast on answers that do", "be removed. This includes answers that are: > > >", "researched (i.e., worthy of down votes) and not obviously more", "list. This results in users flagging low quality answers, but", "true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions that make the Hot Network Question (HNQ)", "about deleting answers](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/deleted-answers) > > Answers that do not fundamentally", "barely more than a link to an external site >", "deleted. There have been complaints in the past about moderators", "the actual question* that have resulted in an inconclusive review?", "or other answers > * asking another, different question >", "a moderator needs to decide if the answer should be", "while the review process is inconclusive leading to an auto", "answer should be deleted. There have been complaints in the", "flagged, it goes through a community review process. Every once", "that have net positive scores that seem to be poorly", "responses > * exact duplicates of other answers > ", "that do not fundamentally answer the question may be removed.", "another, different question > “thanks!” or “me too!” responses", "Question (HNQ) list. This results in users flagging low quality", "other answers > * asking another, different question > ", "site > not even a partial answer to the", "“me too!” responses > * exact duplicates of other answers", "moderator attention where a moderator needs to decide if the", "complaints in the past about moderators reacting to these flags", "answers > * asking another, different question > * “thanks!”", "answer the question may be removed. This includes answers that", "vote. This is [particularly true](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/238420/prevent-questions-on-hot-list-from-being-upvoted-by-casual-visitors-only-rep-is) of questions that make the", "Hot Network Question (HNQ) list. This results in users flagging", "answer to the actual question* that have resulted in an", "> > * commentary on the question or other answers" ]
[ "a similar question for the UK and German systems as", "a weak background. However, I’m beginning to wonder if we", "weak background. However, I’m beginning to wonder if we need", "questions [such as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it makes some sense", "it makes some sense to have a community wiki-type question", "question for the UK and German systems as well. It", "It seems we get a decent number of questions [such", "question that outlines [the US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students with", "we get a decent number of questions [such as this", "[the US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students with a weak background.", "well. It seems we get a decent number of questions", "as well. It seems we get a decent number of", "We already have a question that outlines [the US admissions", "already have a question that outlines [the US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly)", "I’m beginning to wonder if we need a similar question", "similar question for the UK and German systems as well.", "the UK and German systems as well. It seems we", "this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it makes some sense to have a", "for the UK and German systems as well. It seems", "systems as well. It seems we get a decent number", "German systems as well. It seems we get a decent", "[such as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it makes some sense to", "that it makes some sense to have a community wiki-type", "that outlines [the US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students with a", "makes some sense to have a community wiki-type question available.", "of questions [such as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it makes some", "process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students with a weak background. However, I’m beginning", "UK and German systems as well. It seems we get", "seems we get a decent number of questions [such as", "number of questions [such as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it makes", "a question that outlines [the US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students", "background. However, I’m beginning to wonder if we need a", "decent number of questions [such as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it", "beginning to wonder if we need a similar question for", "need a similar question for the UK and German systems", "for students with a weak background. However, I’m beginning to", "However, I’m beginning to wonder if we need a similar", "a decent number of questions [such as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that", "admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students with a weak background. However, I’m", "wonder if we need a similar question for the UK", "and German systems as well. It seems we get a", "get a decent number of questions [such as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ)", "if we need a similar question for the UK and", "one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it makes some sense to have a community", "have a question that outlines [the US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for", "as this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102472/what-are-my-chances-of-being-accepted-for-masters-degree-in-german-or-dutch-univ) that it makes some sense to have", "to wonder if we need a similar question for the", "US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students with a weak background. However,", "we need a similar question for the UK and German", "outlines [the US admissions process](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/38237/how-does-the-admissions-process-work-for-ph-d-programs-in-the-us-particularly) for students with a weak", "with a weak background. However, I’m beginning to wonder if", "students with a weak background. However, I’m beginning to wonder" ]
[ "if I have an answer for those, I'm glad to", "Q: [Professor is upset about student comments about her lectures.", "questions. And if I provide a \"Then fix it, dear", "this gets over 60 upvotes within a couple of days", "hole in the bucket, dear Liza\"-type questions. And if I", "the site which require thought, and empathy, and are helped", "in the bucket, dear Liza\"-type questions. And if I provide", "bucket, dear Liza\"-type questions. And if I provide a \"Then", "answer for those, I'm glad to get some upvotes (and", "60 upvotes within a couple of days while, say, [this", "occasionally those get massively upvoted, as if I've found a", "the site really seem to me like \"There's a hole", "thought, and empathy, and are helped much by varigated experience.", "this as anomalous, or undesirable? Edit: Trivial answers [win again](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/103566/7319)...", "some upvotes (and I often do). But quite a few", "dear Heqrv\" answer, occasionally those get massively upvoted, as if", "questions here on the site which require thought, and empathy,", "within a couple of days while, say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or", "provide a \"Then fix it, dear Heqrv\" answer, occasionally those", "think it's ridiculous this gets over 60 upvotes within a", "I have an answer for those, I'm glad to get", "fix it, dear Heqrv\" answer, occasionally those get massively upvoted,", "on the site really seem to me like \"There's a", "do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think it's ridiculous this gets over 60", "those get massively upvoted, as if I've found a cure", "is upset about student comments about her lectures. What should", "require thought, and empathy, and are helped much by varigated", "upvotes within a couple of days while, say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319)", "lectures. What should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're not even in", "example: Q: [Professor is upset about student comments about her", "me like \"There's a hole in the bucket, dear Liza\"-type", "a single upvote. Am I wrong to perceive this as", "And if I provide a \"Then fix it, dear Heqrv\"", "or undesirable? Edit: Trivial answers [win again](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/103566/7319)... reputation for nothing,", "I've found a cure for cancer. Here's a recent example:", "\"There's a hole in the bucket, dear Liza\"-type questions. And", "cancer. Here's a recent example: Q: [Professor is upset about", "[this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely a single upvote. Am I wrong", "as anomalous, or undesirable? Edit: Trivial answers [win again](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/103566/7319)... reputation", "to get some upvotes (and I often do). But quite", "student comments about her lectures. What should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A:", "What should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're not even in the", "questions on the site really seem to me like \"There's", "cure for cancer. Here's a recent example: Q: [Professor is", "dear Liza\"-type questions. And if I provide a \"Then fix", "about her lectures. What should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're not", "found a cure for cancer. Here's a recent example: Q:", "barely a single upvote. Am I wrong to perceive this", "nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think it's ridiculous this gets over 60 upvotes", "same university, so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think it's ridiculous this", "\"Then fix it, dear Heqrv\" answer, occasionally those get massively", "[this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely a single upvote.", "Am I wrong to perceive this as anomalous, or undesirable?", "glad to get some upvotes (and I often do). But", "helped much by varigated experience. And if I have an", "get some upvotes (and I often do). But quite a", "should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're not even in the same", "those, I'm glad to get some upvotes (and I often", "Heqrv\" answer, occasionally those get massively upvoted, as if I've", "read questions here on the site which require thought, and", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely a single upvote. Am", "Sometimes I read questions here on the site which require", "recent example: Q: [Professor is upset about student comments about", "on the site which require thought, and empathy, and are", "so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think it's ridiculous this gets over", "if I provide a \"Then fix it, dear Heqrv\" answer,", "to perceive this as anomalous, or undesirable? Edit: Trivial answers", "perceive this as anomalous, or undesirable? Edit: Trivial answers [win", "I often do). But quite a few questions on the", "And if I have an answer for those, I'm glad", "site which require thought, and empathy, and are helped much", "while, say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely a", "it's ridiculous this gets over 60 upvotes within a couple", "seem to me like \"There's a hole in the bucket,", "like \"There's a hole in the bucket, dear Liza\"-type questions.", "empathy, and are helped much by varigated experience. And if", "Trivial answers [win again](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/103566/7319)... reputation for nothing, badges for [free](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_for_Nothing_%28song%29).", "her lectures. What should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're not even", "Edit: Trivial answers [win again](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/103566/7319)... reputation for nothing, badges for", "massively upvoted, as if I've found a cure for cancer.", "do). But quite a few questions on the site really", "[You're not even in the same university, so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319)", "university, so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think it's ridiculous this gets", "even in the same university, so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think", "I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're not even in the same university,", "I provide a \"Then fix it, dear Heqrv\" answer, occasionally", "are helped much by varigated experience. And if I have", "or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely a single upvote. Am I", "by varigated experience. And if I have an answer for", "have barely a single upvote. Am I wrong to perceive", "much by varigated experience. And if I have an answer", "the bucket, dear Liza\"-type questions. And if I provide a", "[Professor is upset about student comments about her lectures. What", "I read questions here on the site which require thought,", "which require thought, and empathy, and are helped much by", "upvotes (and I often do). But quite a few questions", "in the same university, so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think it's", "a \"Then fix it, dear Heqrv\" answer, occasionally those get", "for cancer. Here's a recent example: Q: [Professor is upset", "answer, occasionally those get massively upvoted, as if I've found", "often do). But quite a few questions on the site", "over 60 upvotes within a couple of days while, say,", "it, dear Heqrv\" answer, occasionally those get massively upvoted, as", "few questions on the site really seem to me like", "one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely a single upvote. Am I wrong to", "undesirable? Edit: Trivial answers [win again](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/103566/7319)... reputation for nothing, badges", "about student comments about her lectures. What should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319)", "Liza\"-type questions. And if I provide a \"Then fix it,", "of days while, say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have", "a couple of days while, say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this", "I wrong to perceive this as anomalous, or undesirable? Edit:", "if I've found a cure for cancer. Here's a recent", "a cure for cancer. Here's a recent example: Q: [Professor", "comments about her lectures. What should I do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're", "as if I've found a cure for cancer. Here's a", "not even in the same university, so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I", "the same university, so do nothing.](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/102793/7319) I think it's ridiculous", "a recent example: Q: [Professor is upset about student comments", "(and I often do). But quite a few questions on", "days while, say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely", "here on the site which require thought, and empathy, and", "and are helped much by varigated experience. And if I", "say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319) have barely a single", "But quite a few questions on the site really seem", "for those, I'm glad to get some upvotes (and I", "upvote. Am I wrong to perceive this as anomalous, or", "varigated experience. And if I have an answer for those,", "to me like \"There's a hole in the bucket, dear", "a hole in the bucket, dear Liza\"-type questions. And if", "ridiculous this gets over 60 upvotes within a couple of", "A: [You're not even in the same university, so do", "quite a few questions on the site really seem to", "anomalous, or undesirable? Edit: Trivial answers [win again](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/103566/7319)... reputation for", "have an answer for those, I'm glad to get some", "site really seem to me like \"There's a hole in", "gets over 60 upvotes within a couple of days while,", "wrong to perceive this as anomalous, or undesirable? Edit: Trivial", "and empathy, and are helped much by varigated experience. And", "Here's a recent example: Q: [Professor is upset about student", "an answer for those, I'm glad to get some upvotes", "do?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/102757/7319) A: [You're not even in the same university, so", "upvoted, as if I've found a cure for cancer. Here's", "upset about student comments about her lectures. What should I", "get massively upvoted, as if I've found a cure for", "a few questions on the site really seem to me", "couple of days while, say, [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/84938/7319) or [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/96147/7319)", "really seem to me like \"There's a hole in the", "I think it's ridiculous this gets over 60 upvotes within", "single upvote. Am I wrong to perceive this as anomalous,", "I'm glad to get some upvotes (and I often do).", "experience. And if I have an answer for those, I'm" ]
[ "Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to", "must be 300 x 250 pixels, or double that if", "a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is", "Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will", "community. We reset the ads once a year, every December.", "ad is very valuable to the community and will continue", "It's almost February in 2018, which isn't supposed to be", "cycle these, but for this year it'll be once again,", "else to the body of the post. If you want", "### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold** an", "This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to", "with the above required form. ### Image requirements * The", "should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to", "site's twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting", "every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that", "it is a good idea to repost it. It may", "these, but for this year it'll be once again, so", "it. It may be helpful to give it a new", "'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the", "is a good idea to repost it. It may be", "1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score", "information and resources that are relevant to your own community's", "cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps", "we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain", "accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their", "exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post", "Must be GIF or PNG No animated GIFs ", "again, so we'll be refreshing the Community Promotion Ads* for", "and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests,", "year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while", "imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year", "can check out the ads that have met the threshold", "the proper time to cycle these, but for this year", "In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this", "ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the", "Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) ", " anything else your community would genuinely be interested in", "### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some", "this question must conform to the following rules, or they", "before it will be shown on the main site. You", "site. For example, you might promote the following things: ", "relevant to not just the subject matter of the community,", "be shown on the main site. You can check out", "Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community", "the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old", "post to this question must* conform to the following rules,", "of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable", "once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have", "you might promote the following things: * the site's twitter", "blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else your", "would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future", "year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions", "the answer form with the above required form. ### Image", "and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown.", "every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against", "cool events or conferences * anything else your community would", "this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements", "* interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences", "the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources ", "vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community", "find out about the stuff your community deems important. This", "to your own community's interests, both for those already in", "functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer", "the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All", "so we'll be refreshing the Community Promotion Ads for this", "be 300 x 250 pixels, or double that if high", "score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it", "show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do", "Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the", "the image is white or partially white, there must be", "that have met the threshold with basic click stats [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/ads/display/3961).", "not add anything else to the body of the post*.", "things: the site's twitter account * academic websites and", "border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold", "* If the background of the image is white or", "give it a new face in the process, so as", "they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in", "restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If", "to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the", "this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose", "form. ### Image requirements * The image that you create", "serves as a way to promote information and resources that", "that you create must be 300 x 250 pixels, or", "uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No", "resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both", "previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very", "years, while other things will wane to allow for new", "be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show", "for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors", "of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you", "There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet", "to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The", "or double that if high DPI. * Must be hosted", "year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers", "community, but to the current status of the community. We", "purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer", "must be a 1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding", "the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition", "(currently 6) before it will be shown on the main", "example, you might promote the following things: * the site's", "to not just the subject matter of the community, but", "to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also", "important. This also serves as a way to promote information", "rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should", "over the years, while other things will wane to allow", "answers you post to this question must* conform to the", "check out the ads that have met the threshold with", "this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above", "This also serves as a way to promote information and", "(2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There", "do it in the comments. 2. The question must always", "must conform to the following rules, or they will be", "ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a", "might promote the following things: * the site's twitter account", "isn't supposed to be the proper time to cycle these,", "so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from", "be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\")", "answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown", "a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6)", "December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting", "the community and those yet to join. ### Why do", "and will continue to be so, it is a good", "This is a method for the community to control what", "it a new face in the process, so as to", "other things will wane to allow for new faces to", "but to the current status of the community. We reset", "required form. ### Image requirements * The image that you", "your own community's interests, both for those already in the", "white or partially white, there must be a 1px border", "their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for", "in the community and those yet to join. ### Why", "ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in", "we'll be refreshing the Community Promotion Ads* for this year", "What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted", "promote information and resources that are relevant to your own", "the background of the image is white or partially white,", "limit on file size of 150 KB If the", "against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a", "a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no", "served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads", "advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community", "[![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ```", "of the community. We reset the ads once a year,", "gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you", "Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows", "is for future visitors to find out about the stuff", "for this year it'll be once again, so we'll be", "ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form", "keep the material in the ads relevant to not just", "events or conferences anything else your community would genuinely", "shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This", "will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do", "it. ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold", "while other things will wane to allow for new faces", "If a particular service or ad is very valuable to", "helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served", "to be the proper time to cycle these, but for", "to promote information and resources that are relevant to your", "year it'll be once again, so we'll be refreshing the", "questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality", "show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this,", " academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs", "tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of", "always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged", "If the background of the image is white or partially", "of this question is the vetting process. Images of the", "matter of the community, but to the current status of", "interested in The goal is for future visitors to find", "as a way to promote information and resources that are", "to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion", "a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The", "to cycle these, but for this year it'll be once", "future visitors to find out about the stuff your community", "or partially white, there must be a 1px border (2px", "or conferences anything else your community would genuinely be", "conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored.", "out about the stuff your community deems important. This also", "image that you create must be 300 x 250 pixels,", "to be so, it is a good idea to repost", "The image that you create must be 300 x 250", "that if high DPI. * Must be hosted through our", "The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images", "### How does it work? The answers you post to", "the ads that have met the threshold with basic click", "else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal", "be a 1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it.", "the Community Promotion Ads for this year now! ### What", "with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In", "just the subject matter of the community, but to the", "be helpful to give it a new face in the", "the post. If you want to discuss something, do it", "the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure.", "must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions", "an answer must meet (currently 6*) before it will be", "visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the", "cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable", "the community. We reset the ads once a year, every", "do we reset the ads every year? Some services will", "community deems important. This also serves as a way to", "face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery", "for newer things. This helps keep the material in the", "high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is a", "### Image requirements * The image that you create must", "white, there must be a 1px border (2px if high", "tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements,", "shown on the main site. You can check out the", "own community's interests, both for those already in the community", "this year now! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community", "to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every", "Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that", "2. The question must always be tagged with the magic", "300 x 250 pixels, or double that if high DPI.", " cool events or conferences * anything else your community", "* Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur)", "mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add", "through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF", "http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else", "to give it a new face in the process, so", "also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form.", "will continue to be so, it is a good idea", "anything else to the body of the post. If you", "do not add anything else to the body of the", "wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting", "be interested in The goal is for future visitors to", "magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to", "or ad is very valuable to the community and will", "Ads for this year now! ### What are Community Promotion", "Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will", "services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things", "February in 2018, which isn't supposed to be the proper", "tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag.", "to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please", "join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year?", "form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url", "if high DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is", "that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for", "are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main", "[community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling", "be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute", "be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact", "background of the image is white or partially white, there", "Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on", "will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the", "community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for", "out the ads that have met the threshold with basic", "way to promote information and resources that are relevant to", "the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and", "maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane", "to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate", "helpful to give it a new face in the process,", "it'll be once again, so we'll be refreshing the Community", "is white or partially white, there must be a 1px", "repost it. It may be helpful to give it a", "a new face in the process, so as to prevent", "what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example,", "reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness", "and resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events", "form with the above required form. ### Image requirements ", "year now! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion", "or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on", "interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences ", "is very valuable to the community and will continue to", "answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline", "[1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything", "the body of the post. If you want to discuss", "on file size of 150 KB If the background", "file size of 150 KB * If the background of", "the subject matter of the community, but to the current", "discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question", "websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs * cool", "goal is for future visitors to find out about the", "it will be shown on the main site. You can", "also serves as a way to promote information and resources", "the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on", "the current status of the community. We reset the ads", "partially white, there must be a 1px border (2px if", "advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the", "process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting", "post. If you want to discuss something, do it in", "of the post. If you want to discuss something, do", "to the current status of the community. We reset the", "resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events or", "and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset", "Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services", "We reset the ads once a year, every December. The", "above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that", "your community deems important. This also serves as a way", "yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads", "the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the", "body of the post. If you want to discuss something,", "you post to this question must* conform to the following", "be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads?", "proper time to cycle these, but for this year it'll", "must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on", "once again, so we'll be refreshing the Community Promotion Ads", "an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service", "exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]:", "* the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources", "our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or", "the community and will continue to be so, it is", "add anything else to the body of the post. If", "will be shown on the main site. You can check", "advertisements that will show up on the main site, in", "sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process.", "main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this", "control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For", "you want to discuss something, do it in the comments.", "out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep", "the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with", "community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site,", "want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2.", "community and those yet to join. ### Why do we", "Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other", "the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the", "not just the subject matter of the community, but to", "will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will", "on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not", "question must conform to the following rules, or they will", "* The image that you create must be 300 x", "site. You can check out the ads that have met", "For example, you might promote the following things: * the", "of 150 KB * If the background of the image", "from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How", "a way to promote information and resources that are relevant", "method for the community to control what gets promoted to", "GIF or PNG No animated GIFs * Absolute limit", "almost February in 2018, which isn't supposed to be the", "for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every", "### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is", "campus story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything", "image is white or partially white, there must be a", "reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular", "community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ###", "of the ad from getting stale after a year of", "process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad", "which isn't supposed to be the proper time to cycle", "stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it", "``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url", "valuable to the community and will continue to be so,", "continue to be so, it is a good idea to", "the following things: * the site's twitter account * academic", "in 2018, which isn't supposed to be the proper time", "story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else", "How does it work? The answers you post to this", "150 KB * If the background of the image is", "be the proper time to cycle these, but for this", "advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements", "in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on", "[2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add anything else to", "DPI. Must be hosted through our standard image uploader", "community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the", "All answers should be in the exact form of: ```", "is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently", "Please *do not add anything else to the body of", "up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and", "Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB If", "standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG", "good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to", "promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might", "account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus story", "ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the", "refreshing the Community Promotion Ads for this year now! ###", "have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the", "the community, but to the current status of the community.", "a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful", "is a method for the community to control what gets", "It may be helpful to give it a new face", "Community Promotion Ads for this year now! ### What are", "that will show up on the main site, in the", "Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer must", "enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we", "be once again, so we'll be refreshing the *Community Promotion", "enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills", "of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form", "in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter", "promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from", "high DPI. Must be hosted through our standard image", "You can check out the ads that have met the", "a method for the community to control what gets promoted", "be so, it is a good idea to repost it.", "If you want to discuss something, do it in the", "addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag", "conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be interested", "do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method", "after a year of exposure. ### How does it work?", "promote the following things: * the site's twitter account ", "of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]:", "deems important. This also serves as a way to promote", "the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of", "of the image is white or partially white, there must", "Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up", "a particular service or ad is very valuable to the", "Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer", "surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is a *minimum score", "it work? The answers you post to this question must", "something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must", "may be helpful to give it a new face in", "ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads", "allows old ads that have served their purpose to be", "prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after", "answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements", "http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else to the", "newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads", "community's interests, both for those already in the community and", "pixels, or double that if high DPI. * Must be", "status of the community. We reset the ads once a", "comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the", "the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the", "relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already", "\"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the", "question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are", "ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or", "visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems", "that have served their purpose to be cycled out for", "does it work? The answers you post to this question", "every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years,", "year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have", "The answers you post to this question must* conform to", "GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB", "those already in the community and those yet to join.", "particular service or ad is very valuable to the community", "things will wane to allow for new faces to show", "PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file", "the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a", "this year it'll be once again, so we'll be refreshing", "getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does", "threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will", "Ads? This is a method for the community to control", "ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads", "### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are", "6*) before it will be shown on the main site.", "allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads", "requirements The image that you create must be 300", "you create must be 300 x 250 pixels, or double", "on the main site. You can check out the ads", "the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of", "those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the", "for future visitors to find out about the stuff your", "and allows old ads that have served their purpose to", "to repost it. It may be helpful to give it", "supposed to be the proper time to cycle these, but", "Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a", "subject matter of the community, but to the current status", "will show up on the main site, in the right", "there must be a 1px border (2px if high DPI)", "ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out", "meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the", "question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show", "on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose", " Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ", "the material in the ads relevant to not just the", " Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs", "about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves", "for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the", "the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2]", "time to cycle these, but for this year it'll be", "old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled", "``` Please *do not add anything else to the body", "create must be 300 x 250 pixels, or double that", "ads that have met the threshold with basic click stats", "be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must", "have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher", "to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote", "ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ###", "The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads", "the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with", "the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion", "your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is", "(imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No animated", "for this year now! ### What are Community Promotion Ads?", "right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting", "the site. For example, you might promote the following things:", "are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those", "faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps", "in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged", "the years, while other things will wane to allow for", "hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be", "have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous", "material in the ads relevant to not just the subject", "to the body of the post. If you want to", "to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things.", "fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material", "new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year", "both for those already in the community and those yet", "or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be", "up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The", "in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is", "for those already in the community and those yet to", "now! ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads", "the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over", "DPI) surrounding it. ### Score Threshold There is a minimum", "voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why", "provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be", "Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show", "community and will continue to be so, it is a", "to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1.", "The goal is for future visitors to find out about", "size of 150 KB * If the background of the", "the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the", "2018, which isn't supposed to be the proper time to", "in The goal is for future visitors to find out", "Promotion Ads** for this year now! ### What are Community", "site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question", "tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required", "following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers", "Image requirements * The image that you create must be", "show up on the main site, in the right sidebar.", "we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for", "double that if high DPI. * Must be hosted through", "will wane to allow for new faces to show up.", "be refreshing the Community Promotion Ads for this year now!", "academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs ", "on the site. For example, you might promote the following", "to find out about the stuff your community deems important.", "reset the ads once a year, every December. The community", "as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting", "1. All answers should be in the exact form of:", "250 pixels, or double that if high DPI. Must", "interests, both for those already in the community and those", "The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an", "genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors", "already in the community and those yet to join. ###", "new face in the process, so as to prevent the", "idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give", "to the community and will continue to be so, it", "the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have", "things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant", "image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF or PNG ", "from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad", "helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not", "is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided,", "very valuable to the community and will continue to be", "purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of", "the main site. You can check out the ads that", "anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The", "are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to", "current status of the community. We reset the ads once", "to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site.", "of the community, but to the current status of the", "usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to", "minimum score threshold* an answer must meet (currently 6) before", "work? The answers you post to this question must conform", "to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale", "KB * If the background of the image is white", "in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of", "no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle.", "twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus", "following things: * the site's twitter account * academic websites", "service or ad is very valuable to the community and", "No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of", "community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad", "* No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size", "stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a", "the above required form. ### Image requirements The image", "x 250 pixels, or double that if high DPI. ", "pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ###", "the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as", "are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements", "if high DPI. Must be hosted through our standard", "be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This", "it in the comments. 2. The question must always be", "a 1px border (2px if high DPI) surrounding it. ###", "so, it is a good idea to repost it. It", "animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150", "to this question must conform to the following rules, or", "main site. You can check out the ads that have", "but for this year it'll be once again, so we'll" ]
[ "question is about political implications of getting a PhD from", "individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, > research topics or", "publishers, journals, > research topics or similar as an answer", "get a PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two close votes (among", "> comparison of such, are off-topic here. (See this discussion", "more > information.)\". > > > The question is about", "votes (among the other votes) for the following reason: >", "about political implications of getting a PhD from a specific", "political implications of getting a PhD from a specific country.", "\"\"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists of > individual", "of > individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, > research", "The question is about political implications of getting a PhD", "PhD from a specific country. Does it qualify as a", "lists of > individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, >", "I get a PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two close votes", "such, are off-topic here. (See this discussion for more >", "close votes (among the other votes) for the following reason:", "are off-topic here. (See this discussion for more > information.)\".", "off-topic here. (See this discussion for more > information.)\". >", "assessment or > comparison of such, are off-topic here. (See", "topics or similar as an answer or seek an assessment", "a PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two close votes (among the", "(See this discussion for more > information.)\". > > >", "career if I get a PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two", "implications of getting a PhD from a specific country. Does", "answer or seek an assessment or > comparison of such,", "The original version of this question [How will the academic", "a specific country. Does it qualify as a shopping question?", "following reason: > > \"\"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or", "(among the other votes) for the following reason: > >", "which seek recommendations or lists of > individual universities, academic", "of such, are off-topic here. (See this discussion for more", "> > The question is about political implications of getting", "my career if I get a PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received", "the academic boycot of Israel (BDS) infulence my career if", "if I get a PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two close", "here. (See this discussion for more > information.)\". > >", "universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, > research topics or similar", "version of this question [How will the academic boycot of", "> individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals, > research topics", "programs, publishers, journals, > research topics or similar as an", "from a specific country. Does it qualify as a shopping", "PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two close votes (among the other", "received two close votes (among the other votes) for the", "information.)\". > > > The question is about political implications", "is about political implications of getting a PhD from a", "> > > The question is about political implications of", "of this question [How will the academic boycot of Israel", "infulence my career if I get a PhD in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1)", "question [How will the academic boycot of Israel (BDS) infulence", "will the academic boycot of Israel (BDS) infulence my career", "Israel (BDS) infulence my career if I get a PhD", "of getting a PhD from a specific country. Does it", "academic boycot of Israel (BDS) infulence my career if I", "questions, which seek recommendations or lists of > individual universities,", "as an answer or seek an assessment or > comparison", "for more > information.)\". > > > The question is", "> > \"\"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists of", "research topics or similar as an answer or seek an", "this discussion for more > information.)\". > > > The", "> \"\"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists of >", "in Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two close votes (among the other votes)", "an answer or seek an assessment or > comparison of", "(BDS) infulence my career if I get a PhD in", "or seek an assessment or > comparison of such, are", "for the following reason: > > \"\"Shopping\" questions, which seek", "journals, > research topics or similar as an answer or", "or similar as an answer or seek an assessment or", "two close votes (among the other votes) for the following", "reason: > > \"\"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations or lists", "[How will the academic boycot of Israel (BDS) infulence my", "similar as an answer or seek an assessment or >", "boycot of Israel (BDS) infulence my career if I get", "academic programs, publishers, journals, > research topics or similar as", "or > comparison of such, are off-topic here. (See this", "seek an assessment or > comparison of such, are off-topic", "this question [How will the academic boycot of Israel (BDS)", "Israel](https://academia.stackexchange.com/revisions/102886/1) received two close votes (among the other votes) for", "the other votes) for the following reason: > > \"\"Shopping\"", "or lists of > individual universities, academic programs, publishers, journals,", "> information.)\". > > > The question is about political", "getting a PhD from a specific country. Does it qualify", "recommendations or lists of > individual universities, academic programs, publishers,", "other votes) for the following reason: > > \"\"Shopping\" questions,", "original version of this question [How will the academic boycot", "an assessment or > comparison of such, are off-topic here.", "a PhD from a specific country. Does it qualify as", "discussion for more > information.)\". > > > The question", "votes) for the following reason: > > \"\"Shopping\" questions, which", "of Israel (BDS) infulence my career if I get a", "> research topics or similar as an answer or seek", "seek recommendations or lists of > individual universities, academic programs,", "> The question is about political implications of getting a", "comparison of such, are off-topic here. (See this discussion for", "the following reason: > > \"\"Shopping\" questions, which seek recommendations" ]
[ "well-articulated on their face, and have answers that align with", "a different answer mean that they necessarily asked the wrong", "wrong question? Or are there other reasons to close these", "different answer mean that they necessarily asked the wrong question?", "that they necessarily asked the wrong question? Or are there", "two questions back-to-back that were flagged as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea)", "queue, I just noticed two questions back-to-back that were flagged", "vehement dislike of the answers in the comments. How much", "dislike of the answers in the comments. How much weight", "were flagged as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated on their", "the review queue, I just noticed two questions back-to-back that", "the questioner wanting a different answer mean that they necessarily", "in the comments. How much weight should authorial intent of", "face, and have answers that align with my expectations, but", "much weight should authorial intent of the questioner be given", "these cases? Does the questioner wanting a different answer mean", "questioner wanting a different answer mean that they necessarily asked", "both the questioner is expressing vehement dislike of the answers", "given in these cases? Does the questioner wanting a different", "that align with my expectations, but in both the questioner", "cases? Does the questioner wanting a different answer mean that", "of the answers in the comments. How much weight should", "question? Or are there other reasons to close these questions?", "authorial intent of the questioner be given in these cases?", "the questioner is expressing vehement dislike of the answers in", "that were flagged as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated on", "answer mean that they necessarily asked the wrong question? Or", "the questioner be given in these cases? Does the questioner", "in both the questioner is expressing vehement dislike of the", "expressing vehement dislike of the answers in the comments. How", "just noticed two questions back-to-back that were flagged as \"unclear\".", "my expectations, but in both the questioner is expressing vehement", "expectations, but in both the questioner is expressing vehement dislike", "questioner is expressing vehement dislike of the answers in the", "but in both the questioner is expressing vehement dislike of", "the wrong question? Or are there other reasons to close", "is expressing vehement dislike of the answers in the comments.", "How much weight should authorial intent of the questioner be", "asked the wrong question? Or are there other reasons to", "questioner be given in these cases? Does the questioner wanting", "While going through the review queue, I just noticed two", "with my expectations, but in both the questioner is expressing", "questions back-to-back that were flagged as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem", "Does the questioner wanting a different answer mean that they", "align with my expectations, but in both the questioner is", "going through the review queue, I just noticed two questions", "and have answers that align with my expectations, but in", "comments. How much weight should authorial intent of the questioner", "of the questioner be given in these cases? Does the", "necessarily asked the wrong question? Or are there other reasons", "[questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated on their face, and have answers that", "they necessarily asked the wrong question? Or are there other", "the answers in the comments. How much weight should authorial", "weight should authorial intent of the questioner be given in", "be given in these cases? Does the questioner wanting a", "on their face, and have answers that align with my", "I just noticed two questions back-to-back that were flagged as", "in these cases? Does the questioner wanting a different answer", "noticed two questions back-to-back that were flagged as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments)", "review queue, I just noticed two questions back-to-back that were", "flagged as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated on their face,", "as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated on their face, and", "have answers that align with my expectations, but in both", "answers that align with my expectations, but in both the", "through the review queue, I just noticed two questions back-to-back", "wanting a different answer mean that they necessarily asked the", "\"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated on their face, and have", "should authorial intent of the questioner be given in these", "intent of the questioner be given in these cases? Does", "answers in the comments. How much weight should authorial intent", "their face, and have answers that align with my expectations,", "mean that they necessarily asked the wrong question? Or are", "[These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated on their face, and have answers", "the comments. How much weight should authorial intent of the", "seem well-articulated on their face, and have answers that align", "back-to-back that were flagged as \"unclear\". [These](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/103009/what-are-the-most-credible-rankings-of-us-computer-science-departments) [questions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/102869/most-efficient-way-of-finding-out-if-someone-has-already-published-your-idea) seem well-articulated" ]
[ "to post a one-liner as answer. Unfortunately, the question remains", "repeating the comments. I see two options: 1. ask the", "the question remains \"open\" and is more or less a", "without repeating the comments. I see two options: 1. ask", "feels a bit like plagiarism (of course you should cite", "were given as comments. Some of them are very short,", "comments. Some of them are very short, but still a", "it. 2. Compile an answer from the comments given. This", "\"unanswered questions\" section, and I found many questions which had", "no more to say without repeating the comments. I see", "would do it. 2. Compile an answer from the comments", "click bait since people read the question, read the comments", "This feels a bit like plagiarism (of course you should", "those were given as comments. Some of them are very", "- but those were given as comments. Some of them", "question remains \"open\" and is more or less a click", "Compile an answer from the comments given. This feels a", "plagiarism (of course you should cite them) What's your thoughts", "the comments ant feel like there is no more to", "as answer. Unfortunately, the question remains \"open\" and is more", "less a click bait since people read the question, read", "options: 1. ask the commentators to write their comment as", "course you should cite them) What's your thoughts about this", "them are very short, but still a valid and sometimes", "remains \"open\" and is more or less a click bait", "the comments. I see two options: 1. ask the commentators", "answer - I'm unsure whether they would do it. 2.", "answeres - but those were given as comments. Some of", "more to say without repeating the comments. I see two", "ant feel like there is no more to say without", "is no more to say without repeating the comments. I", "bait since people read the question, read the comments ant", "but those were given as comments. Some of them are", "two options: 1. ask the commentators to write their comment", "and I found many questions which had good answeres -", "so maybe the original commenter did not want to post", "\"open\" and is more or less a click bait since", "post a one-liner as answer. Unfortunately, the question remains \"open\"", "answer from the comments given. This feels a bit like", "the comments given. This feels a bit like plagiarism (of", "you should cite them) What's your thoughts about this issue?", "say without repeating the comments. I see two options: 1.", "questions which had good answeres - but those were given", "a bit like plagiarism (of course you should cite them)", "as answer - I'm unsure whether they would do it.", "one-liner as answer. Unfortunately, the question remains \"open\" and is", "Some of them are very short, but still a valid", "commentators to write their comment as answer - I'm unsure", "whether they would do it. 2. Compile an answer from", "feel like there is no more to say without repeating", "questions\" section, and I found many questions which had good", "comment as answer - I'm unsure whether they would do", "- I'm unsure whether they would do it. 2. Compile", "as comments. Some of them are very short, but still", "Unfortunately, the question remains \"open\" and is more or less", "read the comments ant feel like there is no more", "I'm unsure whether they would do it. 2. Compile an", "original commenter did not want to post a one-liner as", "the question, read the comments ant feel like there is", "their comment as answer - I'm unsure whether they would", "which had good answeres - but those were given as", "very short, but still a valid and sometimes satisfying answer,", "comments. I see two options: 1. ask the commentators to", "satisfying answer, so maybe the original commenter did not want", "the commentators to write their comment as answer - I'm", "to write their comment as answer - I'm unsure whether", "found many questions which had good answeres - but those", "still a valid and sometimes satisfying answer, so maybe the", "many questions which had good answeres - but those were", "a click bait since people read the question, read the", "read the question, read the comments ant feel like there", "there is no more to say without repeating the comments.", "short, but still a valid and sometimes satisfying answer, so", "do it. 2. Compile an answer from the comments given.", "from the comments given. This feels a bit like plagiarism", "I see two options: 1. ask the commentators to write", "maybe the original commenter did not want to post a", "people read the question, read the comments ant feel like", "good answeres - but those were given as comments. Some", "not want to post a one-liner as answer. Unfortunately, the", "1. ask the commentators to write their comment as answer", "through the \"unanswered questions\" section, and I found many questions", "comments ant feel like there is no more to say", "the original commenter did not want to post a one-liner", "and sometimes satisfying answer, so maybe the original commenter did", "is more or less a click bait since people read", "question, read the comments ant feel like there is no", "valid and sometimes satisfying answer, so maybe the original commenter", "an answer from the comments given. This feels a bit", "a valid and sometimes satisfying answer, so maybe the original", "want to post a one-liner as answer. Unfortunately, the question", "like plagiarism (of course you should cite them) What's your", "(of course you should cite them) What's your thoughts about", "write their comment as answer - I'm unsure whether they", "answer. Unfortunately, the question remains \"open\" and is more or", "are very short, but still a valid and sometimes satisfying", "commenter did not want to post a one-liner as answer.", "section, and I found many questions which had good answeres", "given. This feels a bit like plagiarism (of course you", "Recently I was browsing through the \"unanswered questions\" section, and", "I found many questions which had good answeres - but", "ask the commentators to write their comment as answer -", "unsure whether they would do it. 2. Compile an answer", "bit like plagiarism (of course you should cite them) What's", "they would do it. 2. Compile an answer from the", "comments given. This feels a bit like plagiarism (of course", "I was browsing through the \"unanswered questions\" section, and I", "answer, so maybe the original commenter did not want to", "to say without repeating the comments. I see two options:", "given as comments. Some of them are very short, but", "had good answeres - but those were given as comments.", "2. Compile an answer from the comments given. This feels", "did not want to post a one-liner as answer. Unfortunately,", "like there is no more to say without repeating the", "and is more or less a click bait since people", "see two options: 1. ask the commentators to write their", "sometimes satisfying answer, so maybe the original commenter did not", "a one-liner as answer. Unfortunately, the question remains \"open\" and", "but still a valid and sometimes satisfying answer, so maybe", "of them are very short, but still a valid and", "more or less a click bait since people read the", "was browsing through the \"unanswered questions\" section, and I found", "the \"unanswered questions\" section, and I found many questions which", "or less a click bait since people read the question,", "browsing through the \"unanswered questions\" section, and I found many", "since people read the question, read the comments ant feel" ]
[ "would not suggest disabling commenting on them. I suggest some", "are frowned on. I would not suggest disabling commenting on", "on a question from 2012, because I did not notice", "notice it was so old. Incidentally, I stumbled upon it", "really want to answer it?\" might help. 2. Would it", "from commenting on a question from 2012, because I did", "not notice it was so old. Incidentally, I stumbled upon", "deeper shade of background. Of a JS-popup \"This question is", "help. 2. Would it make sense to filter the questions", "I stumbled upon it via the side bar. As far,", "visual clue. 1. A deeper shade of background. Of a", "Would it make sense to filter the questions that pop", "sense to filter the questions that pop into sidebars by", "might help. 2. Would it make sense to filter the", "second ago I was one click away from commenting on", "answer it?\" might help. 2. Would it make sense to", "(and, by extension, comments) are frowned on. I would not", "clue. 1. A deeper shade of background. Of a JS-popup", "I suggest some kind of a visual clue. 1. A", "by extension, comments) are frowned on. I would not suggest", "via the side bar. As far, as I understand, \"late", "from 2012, do you really want to answer it?\" might", "a JS-popup \"This question is from 2012, do you really", "stumbled upon it via the side bar. As far, as", "background. Of a JS-popup \"This question is from 2012, do", "question from 2012, because I did not notice it was", "upon it via the side bar. As far, as I", "disabling commenting on them. I suggest some kind of a", "As far, as I understand, \"late answers\" (and, by extension,", "was one click away from commenting on a question from", "make sense to filter the questions that pop into sidebars", "of a visual clue. 1. A deeper shade of background.", "2012, because I did not notice it was so old.", "2012, do you really want to answer it?\" might help.", "away from commenting on a question from 2012, because I", "is from 2012, do you really want to answer it?\"", "a visual clue. 1. A deeper shade of background. Of", "want to answer it?\" might help. 2. Would it make", "suggest some kind of a visual clue. 1. A deeper", "understand, \"late answers\" (and, by extension, comments) are frowned on.", "do you really want to answer it?\" might help. 2.", "frowned on. I would not suggest disabling commenting on them.", "on. I would not suggest disabling commenting on them. I", "it via the side bar. As far, as I understand,", "of background. Of a JS-popup \"This question is from 2012,", "A second ago I was one click away from commenting", "the side bar. As far, as I understand, \"late answers\"", "far, as I understand, \"late answers\" (and, by extension, comments)", "answers\" (and, by extension, comments) are frowned on. I would", "kind of a visual clue. 1. A deeper shade of", "A deeper shade of background. Of a JS-popup \"This question", "shade of background. Of a JS-popup \"This question is from", "it?\" might help. 2. Would it make sense to filter", "them. I suggest some kind of a visual clue. 1.", "because I did not notice it was so old. Incidentally,", "I was one click away from commenting on a question", "it was so old. Incidentally, I stumbled upon it via", "one click away from commenting on a question from 2012,", "side bar. As far, as I understand, \"late answers\" (and,", "JS-popup \"This question is from 2012, do you really want", "so old. Incidentally, I stumbled upon it via the side", "1. A deeper shade of background. Of a JS-popup \"This", "from 2012, because I did not notice it was so", "2. Would it make sense to filter the questions that", "comments) are frowned on. I would not suggest disabling commenting", "I understand, \"late answers\" (and, by extension, comments) are frowned", "as I understand, \"late answers\" (and, by extension, comments) are", "I would not suggest disabling commenting on them. I suggest", "did not notice it was so old. Incidentally, I stumbled", "Of a JS-popup \"This question is from 2012, do you", "extension, comments) are frowned on. I would not suggest disabling", "to answer it?\" might help. 2. Would it make sense", "suggest disabling commenting on them. I suggest some kind of", "commenting on them. I suggest some kind of a visual", "question is from 2012, do you really want to answer", "\"late answers\" (and, by extension, comments) are frowned on. I", "to filter the questions that pop into sidebars by age?", "I did not notice it was so old. Incidentally, I", "ago I was one click away from commenting on a", "\"This question is from 2012, do you really want to", "a question from 2012, because I did not notice it", "you really want to answer it?\" might help. 2. Would", "click away from commenting on a question from 2012, because", "not suggest disabling commenting on them. I suggest some kind", "Incidentally, I stumbled upon it via the side bar. As", "it make sense to filter the questions that pop into", "some kind of a visual clue. 1. A deeper shade", "bar. As far, as I understand, \"late answers\" (and, by", "on them. I suggest some kind of a visual clue.", "old. Incidentally, I stumbled upon it via the side bar.", "commenting on a question from 2012, because I did not", "was so old. Incidentally, I stumbled upon it via the" ]
[ "flags > > > I am shocked about this for", "into the comments to inform a new member about their", "their language. 2. High school is within academia as defined", "this. It says > > Academia is a question and", "by the flags > > > I am shocked about", "problems. (2) The post contains sh\\t qualified for rude/abusive flagging.", "downvoted by the flags > > > I am shocked", "> > > 4. The question on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for", "here within the help pages doesn't mention anything. 5. The", "A comment was made that > > (1) We do", "you could just put a quick pointer into the comments", "topic within the question affects not just high school but", "when you have situations such as sexual harassment or assault", "this manner can be damaging to someone in a vulnerable", "manner can be damaging to someone in a vulnerable position.", "above all, 7. The topic within the question affects not", "rude/abusive flagging. The question is automatically downvoted by the flags", "a vulnerable position. Edit* I have just been pointed to", "To me, having down-votes in this manner can be damaging", "nothing about it 6. The [don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have", "can be damaging to someone in a vulnerable position. Edit", "there was a lot of down-votes so I asked why.", "about this for a number of reasons. 1. As another", "the question affects not just high school but every level", "so I asked why. A comment was made that >", "especially on the tour page where it says for academics", "that > > (1) We do not handle high school", "> I am shocked about this for a number of", "Academia is a question and answer site for academics of", "person commented, bad language is easily edited. On top of", "why. A comment was made that > > (1) We", "question on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking questions here within the", "asking questions here within the help pages doesn't mention anything.", "situations such as sexual harassment or assault going on, why", "they would do? To me, having down-votes in this manner", "4. The question on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking questions here", "position. Edit I have just been pointed to a related", "within academia as defined in any dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or", "assault going on, why shouldn't they be able to ask", "grades 7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if certain levels of academic", "certain levels of academic study is not on-topic, shouldn't this", "number of reasons. 1. As another person commented, bad language", "it 6. The [don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have anything about", "all, 7. The topic within the question affects not just", "of academic study. What is the situation with those in", "academia as defined in any dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia)", "shouldn't this be highlighted, especially on the tour page where", "of down-votes so I asked why. A comment was made", "as sexual harassment or assault going on, why shouldn't they", "studies? I can understand that homework questions should be avoided,", "1. As another person commented, bad language is easily edited.", "about their language. 2. High school is within academia as", "examples) 3. [The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention this. It says", "school who have a question regarding their studies? I can", "Edit I have just been pointed to a related question", "tour page where it says for academics of all levels", "I am shocked about this for a number of reasons.", "on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking questions here within the help pages doesn't", "and answer site for academics of all levels. > >", "been pointed to a related question ([public school teaching grades", "to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing about it 6. The [don't", "was made that > > (1) We do not handle", "is easily edited. On top of that, you could just", "the comments to inform a new member about their language.", "be avoided, but when you have situations such as sexual", "shocked about this for a number of reasons. 1. As", "a number of reasons. 1. As another person commented, bad", "member about their language. 2. High school is within academia", "have a question regarding their studies? I can understand that", "on, why shouldn't they be able to ask the academic", "to a related question ([public school teaching grades 7-12 considered", "high school problems, and above all, 7. The topic within", "levels of academic study is not on-topic, shouldn't this be", "commented, bad language is easily edited. On top of that,", "put a quick pointer into the comments to inform a", "qualified for rude/abusive flagging. The question is automatically downvoted by", "High school is within academia as defined in any dictionary", "to inform a new member about their language. 2. High", "mention anything. 5. The [introduction to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing", "doesn't have anything about high school problems, and above all,", "those in high school who have a question regarding their", "question and answer site for academics of all levels. >", "related question ([public school teaching grades 7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now", "me, having down-votes in this manner can be damaging to", "mentions nothing about it 6. The [don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't", "all levels. > > > 4. The question on [what's", "> > 4. The question on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking", "academic study is not on-topic, shouldn't this be highlighted, especially", "in this manner can be damaging to someone in a", "for asking questions here within the help pages doesn't mention", "is the situation with those in high school who have", "mention this. It says > > Academia is a question", "do not handle high school problems. (2) The post contains", "comments to inform a new member about their language. 2.", "level of academic study. What is the situation with those", "avoided, but when you have situations such as sexual harassment", "handle high school problems. (2) The post contains sh\\t qualified", "a quick pointer into the comments to inform a new", "comment was made that > > (1) We do not", "highlighted, especially on the tour page where it says for", "or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples) 3. [The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention", "3. [The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention this. It says >", "questions should be avoided, but when you have situations such", "question is automatically downvoted by the flags > > >", "The [introduction to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing about it 6.", "and above all, 7. The topic within the question affects", "a related question ([public school teaching grades 7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)).", "[How to stop sexual harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was a", "(see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples) 3. [The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour)", "have anything about high school problems, and above all, 7.", "easily edited. On top of that, you could just put", "the situation with those in high school who have a", "with those in high school who have a question regarding", "made that > > (1) We do not handle high", "any dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples) 3. [The", "[what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking questions here within the help pages", "anything about high school problems, and above all, 7. The", "help pages doesn't mention anything. 5. The [introduction to the", "have situations such as sexual harassment or assault going on,", "site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing about it 6. The [don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask)", "someone in a vulnerable position. Edit* I have just been", "vulnerable position. Edit I have just been pointed to a", "\"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if certain levels of academic study is not", "to stop sexual harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was a lot", "high school who have a question regarding their studies? I", "I can understand that homework questions should be avoided, but", "just high school but every level of academic study*. What", "post contains sh\\t qualified for rude/abusive flagging. The question is", "ask the academic community what they would do? To me,", "for rude/abusive flagging. The question is automatically downvoted by the", "top of that, you could just put a quick pointer", "On top of that, you could just put a quick", "the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing about it 6. The [don't ask", "understand that homework questions should be avoided, but when you", "page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention this. It says > > Academia is", "question ([public school teaching grades 7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if", "be highlighted, especially on the tour page where it says", "questions here within the help pages doesn't mention anything. 5.", "in a vulnerable position. Edit I have just been pointed", "on the tour page where it says *for academics of", "reasons. 1. As another person commented, bad language is easily", "(2) The post contains sh\\t qualified for rude/abusive flagging. The", "their studies? I can understand that homework questions should be", "[don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have anything about high school problems,", "lot of down-votes so I asked why. A comment was", "school is within academia as defined in any dictionary (see", "a lot of down-votes so I asked why. A comment", "the help pages doesn't mention anything. 5. The [introduction to", "could just put a quick pointer into the comments to", "5. The [introduction to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing about it", "for examples) 3. [The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention this. It", "why shouldn't they be able to ask the academic community", "a question asking [How to stop sexual harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher)", "about high school problems, and above all, 7. *The topic", "within the help pages doesn't mention anything. 5. The [introduction", "The question is automatically downvoted by the flags > >", "sh\\t qualified for rude/abusive flagging. The question is automatically downvoted", "7. The topic within the question affects not just high", "study. What is the situation with those in high school", "to ask the academic community what they would do? To", "they be able to ask the academic community what they", "> > (1) We do not handle high school problems.", "bad language is easily edited. On top of that, you", "for a number of reasons. 1. As another person commented,", "of that, you could just put a quick pointer into", "question asking [How to stop sexual harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there", "stop sexual harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was a lot of", "([public school teaching grades 7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if certain", "> > I am shocked about this for a number", "quick pointer into the comments to inform a new member", "> > Academia is a question and answer site for", "school teaching grades 7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if certain levels", "for academics of all levels. > > > 4. The", "can understand that homework questions should be avoided, but when", "language. 2. High school is within academia as defined in", "> Academia is a question and answer site for academics", "site for academics of all levels. > > > 4.", "regarding their studies? I can understand that homework questions should", "The [don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have anything about high school", "question regarding their studies? I can understand that homework questions", "inform a new member about their language. 2. High school", "problems, and above all, 7. The topic within the question", "> 4. The question on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking questions", "such as sexual harassment or assault going on, why shouldn't", "sexual harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was a lot of down-votes", "[The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention this. It says > >", "down-votes in this manner can be damaging to someone in", "damaging to someone in a vulnerable position. Edit** I have", "contains sh\\t qualified for rude/abusive flagging. The question is automatically", "just been pointed to a related question ([public school teaching", "school problems. (2) The post contains sh\\t qualified for rude/abusive", "the tour page where it says for academics of all", "dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples) 3. [The tour", "study is not on-topic, shouldn't this be highlighted, especially on", "the academic community what they would do? To me, having", "(1) We do not handle high school problems. (2) The", "language is easily edited. On top of that, you could", "is a question and answer site for academics of all", "going on, why shouldn't they be able to ask the", "this be highlighted, especially on the tour page where it", "edited. On top of that, you could just put a", "Now if certain levels of academic study is not on-topic,", "doesn't mention anything. 5. The [introduction to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions", "am shocked about this for a number of reasons. 1.", "[introduction to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing about it 6. The", "considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if certain levels of academic study is", "on-topic, shouldn't this be highlighted, especially on the tour page", "academic community what they would do? To me, having down-votes", "levels. > > > 4. The question on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "[OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples) 3. [The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't", "question affects not just high school but every level of", "homework questions should be avoided, but when you have situations", "asking [How to stop sexual harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was", "a question and answer site for academics of all levels.", "school but every level of academic study. What is the", "that homework questions should be avoided, but when you have", "of academic study is not on-topic, shouldn't this be highlighted,", "just put a quick pointer into the comments to inform", "> (1) We do not handle high school problems. (2)", "a new member about their language. 2. High school is", "anything. 5. The [introduction to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se) mentions nothing about", "7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if certain levels of academic study", "automatically downvoted by the flags > > > I am", "pointed to a related question ([public school teaching grades 7-12", "in any dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples) 3.", "shouldn't they be able to ask the academic community what", "not just high school but every level of academic study.", "what they would do? To me, having down-votes in this", "I have just been pointed to a related question ([public", "harassment or assault going on, why shouldn't they be able", "is within academia as defined in any dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia),", "academics of all levels. > > > 4. The question", "on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking questions here within the help", "you have situations such as sexual harassment or assault going", "tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention this. It says > > Academia", "I asked why. A comment was made that > >", "by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was a lot of down-votes so I", "list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have anything about high school problems, and above", "is not on-topic, shouldn't this be highlighted, especially on the", "ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have anything about high school problems, and", "It says > > Academia is a question and answer", "affects not just high school but every level of academic", "academic study. What is the situation with those in high", "to someone in a vulnerable position. Edit I have just", "teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was a lot of down-votes so I asked", "harassment by teacher?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104497/how-to-stop-sexual-harrassment-by-teacher) there was a lot of down-votes so", "the flags > > > I am shocked about this", "> > > I am shocked about this for a", "pages doesn't mention anything. 5. The [introduction to the site](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1203/welcome-to-academia-se)", "about it 6. The [don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have anything", "says > > Academia is a question and answer site", "should be avoided, but when you have situations such as", "sexual harassment or assault going on, why shouldn't they be", "having down-votes in this manner can be damaging to someone", "The topic within the question affects not just high school", "of reasons. 1. As another person commented, bad language is", "be damaging to someone in a vulnerable position. Edit** I", "situation with those in high school who have a question", "down-votes so I asked why. A comment was made that", "in high school who have a question regarding their studies?", "We do not handle high school problems. (2) The post", "was a lot of down-votes so I asked why. A", "of all levels. > > > 4. The question on", "have just been pointed to a related question ([public school", "not on-topic, shouldn't this be highlighted, especially on the tour", "teaching grades 7-12 considered \"academic\"?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/610/public-school-teaching-grades-7-12-considered-academic)). Now if certain levels of", "that, you could just put a quick pointer into the", "As another person commented, bad language is easily edited. On", "In a question asking [How to stop sexual harassment by", "The post contains sh\\t qualified for rude/abusive flagging. The question", "2. High school is within academia as defined in any", "pointer into the comments to inform a new member* about", "be able to ask the academic community what they would", "do? To me, having down-votes in this manner can be", "this for a number of reasons. 1. As another person", "who have a question regarding their studies? I can understand", "6. The [don't ask list](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) doesn't have anything about high", "every level of academic study. What is the situation with", "would do? To me, having down-votes in this manner can", "but when you have situations such as sexual harassment or", "community what they would do? To me, having down-votes in", "asked why. A comment was made that > > (1)", "[Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples) 3. [The tour page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tour) doesn't mention this.", "new member about their language. 2. High school is within", "flagging. The question is automatically downvoted by the flags >", "a question regarding their studies? I can understand that homework", "able to ask the academic community what they would do?", "high school but every level of academic study*. What is", "answer site for academics of all levels. > > >", "if certain levels of academic study is not on-topic, shouldn't", "not handle high school problems. (2) The post contains sh\\t", "doesn't mention this. It says > > Academia is a", "is automatically downvoted by the flags > > > I", "school problems, and above all, 7. The topic within the", "another person commented, bad language is easily edited. On top", "as defined in any dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for", "The question on [what's on-topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) for asking questions here within", "but every level of academic study. What is the situation", "What is the situation with those in high school who", "within the question affects not just high school but every", "or assault going on, why shouldn't they be able to", "defined in any dictionary (see [OED](https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/academia), or [Merriam-Webster](https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/academia) for examples)", "high school problems. (2) The post contains sh\\*t qualified for" ]
[ "opportunity for members of the community to pose questions to", "* This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that", "have been selected, a new question will be opened to", "day to use EST), this question will be open to", "on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. >", "on the same day, give or take time to arrive", "thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed", "it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting", "two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones", "information on candidates. As a community, you are still free", "of this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire.", "with that, we will be holding a Q&A with the", "for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are", "about nominating themselves and seeing the questions they'll have an", "candidates. As a community, you are still free to, for", "or 3:00 pm EST on the same day, give or", "ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided", "only can folks start prepping questions in advance, but also", "collect potential questions from the users of the site. Post", "week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection with that, we will be", "and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Unlike", "to use EST), this question will be open to collect", "questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please only", "> > *The purpose of this thread was to collect", "the actual questionnaire for the candidates, typically containing 10 questions", "that, we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates.", "to, for example, hold a live chat session with your", "advance, but also potential candidates can think about nominating themselves", "finished questionnaire. This is a perfect opportunity to voice", "community** provided in this thread, to use in addition to", "how it'll work: * Until the nomination phase, (so, until", "about this process, feel free to post as a comment", "> *The purpose of this thread was to collect questions", "running into at currently. At the start of the", "In connection with that, we will be holding a Q&A", "with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications", "The questionnaire is now live, and you may find it", "in advance, so that not only can folks start prepping", "the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of", "perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If", "as that will make it easier for transcribing for the", "or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A.", "aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. * Once questions have been selected,", "are still free to, for example, hold a live chat", "that are specific to your community and issues that you", "collection a week in advance, so that not only can", "to be included, the latter ones are if the community", "or feedback about this process, feel free to post as", "first two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter", "at currently. * At the start of the nomination phase,", "Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of this", "containing 10 questions in total. This is not the", "community to pose questions to the candidates on the topic", "to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is", "is my last sweet day to use EST), this question", "Team will select up to 8 of the top voted", "any questions or feedback about this process, feel free to", "questionnaire is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).", "of the community to pose questions to the candidates on", "to answer. Here's how it'll work: * Until the nomination", "the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may", "may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection),", "link, please use the syntax of `[text](link)`, as that will", "typically containing 10 questions in total. * This is not", "voted questions submitted by the community** provided in this thread,", "the prior instruction. * If your question contains a link,", "total. * This is not the only option that users", "not the only option that users have for gathering information", "last sweet day to use EST), this question will be", "instruction. * If your question contains a link, please use", "a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity", "* At the start of the nomination phase, the Community", "the top voted questions submitted by the community** provided in", "free to, for example, hold a live chat session with", "only option that users have for gathering information on candidates.", "post, unlike the prior instruction. * If your question contains", "day, give or take time to arrive for closure, I", "will make it easier for transcribing for the finished questionnaire.", "session with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps", "> Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting the question collection a", "the community to pose questions to the candidates on the", "the candidates. Please only post one question per answer. ", "EST on the same day, give or take time to", "the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough", "5th at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 3:00 pm EST on the", "week in advance, so that not only can folks start", "to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is", "opening to answer. Here's how it'll work: Until the", "only post one question per answer. * We, the Community", "time to arrive for closure, I think this is my", "* If your question contains a link, please use the", "questions that are specific to your community and issues that", "use the syntax of `[text](link)`, as that will make it", "select up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted", "This will be done in a single post, unlike the", "still free to, for example, hold a live chat session", "that users have for gathering information on candidates. As a", "of the nomination phase, the Community Team will select up", "nominating themselves and seeing the questions they'll have an opening", "hold a live chat session with your candidates to ask", "chat session with your candidates to ask further questions, or", "`[text](link)`, as that will make it easier for transcribing for", "to your community and issues that you are running into", "you are running into at currently. * At the start", "use EST), this question will be open to collect potential", "into at currently. * At the start of the nomination", "seeing the questions they'll have an opening to answer. Here's", "Community Team, will be providing a small selection of generic", "arrive for closure, I think this is my last sweet", "be included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't", "from what is provided in the Q&A. If you have", "actual questionnaire for the candidates, typically containing 10 questions in", "questionnaire. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions", "* We, the Community Team, will be providing a small", "by the community provided in this thread, to use in", "this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2", "the nomination phase, the Community Team will select up to", "will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the", "live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > >", "until Monday, March 5th at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 3:00 pm", "March 5th at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 3:00 pm EST on", "voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread was to", "they'll have an opening to answer. Here's how it'll work:", "8 of the top voted questions submitted by the community", "for closure, I think this is my last sweet day", "questions submitted by the community provided in this thread, to", "so that not only can folks start prepping questions in", "completely voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread was", "If you have any questions or feedback about this process,", "for an election [next week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection with", "this is my last sweet day to use EST), this", "not only can folks start prepping questions in advance, but", "of the site. Post answers to this question containing any", "Community Team will select up to 8 of the top", "nomination phase, the Community Team will select *up to 8", "in advance, but also potential candidates can think about nominating", "sweet day to use EST), this question will be open", "5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection with that, we will be holding a", "will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will", "> > > Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting the question", "be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if", "small selection of generic questions. The first two will be", "questions. Once questions have been selected, a new question", "selection of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed", "question per answer. We, the Community Team, will be", "closure, I think this is my last sweet day to", "Team, will be providing a small selection of generic questions.", "will select up to 8 of the top voted questions", "up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by", "be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be", "provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions or", "questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the", "EST), this question will be open to collect potential questions", "addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. * Once questions", "on candidates. As a community, you are still free to,", "in total. * This is not the only option that", "of `[text](link)`, as that will make it easier for transcribing", "per answer. We, the Community Team, will be providing", "from the users of the site. Post answers to this", "issues that you are running into at currently. * At", "the questions they'll have an opening to answer. Here's how", "transcribing for the finished questionnaire. * This is a perfect", "you are still free to, for example, hold a live", "* Until the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, March 5th", "the syntax of `[text](link)`, as that will make it easier", "what is provided in the Q&A. If you have any", "it easier for transcribing for the finished questionnaire. * This", "feedback about this process, feel free to post as a", "if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be", "candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of the", "generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be", "candidates. Please only post one question per answer. * We,", "Academia is scheduled for an election [next week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2).", "be an opportunity for members of the community to pose", "question collection a week in advance, so that not only", "Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting the question collection a week", "pose questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation.", "questions have been selected, a new question will be opened", "to arrive for closure, I think this is my last", "the start of the nomination phase, the Community Team will", "(so, until Monday, March 5th at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 3:00", "would like to ask the candidates. Please only post one", "questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may find", "you have any questions or feedback about this process, feel", "use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. ", "the finished questionnaire. * This is a perfect opportunity to", "of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to", "the site. Post answers to this question containing any questions", "providing a small selection of generic questions. The first two", "pm EST on the same day, give or take time", "members of the community to pose questions to the candidates", "questions they'll have an opening to answer. Here's how it'll", "clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If you", "20:00:00Z UTC, or 3:00 pm EST on the same day,", "are running into at currently. * At the start of", "an election [next week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection with that,", "we're hosting the question collection a week in advance, so", "answer. Here's how it'll work: * Until the nomination phase,", "users of the site. Post answers to this question containing", "holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an", "will be providing a small selection of generic questions. The", "also potential candidates can think about nominating themselves and seeing", "please use the syntax of `[text](link)`, as that will make", "* Once questions have been selected, a new question will", "to collect potential questions from the users of the site.", "and issues that you are running into at currently. ", "you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).* > > > Unlike [last", "for transcribing for the finished questionnaire. * This is a", "are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will", "candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary.", "think this is my last sweet day to use EST),", "> > Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting the question collection", "is scheduled for an election [next week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In", "Post answers to this question containing any questions you would", "questions. This will be done in a single post, unlike", "Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about this", "thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire", "contains a link, please use the syntax of `[text](link)`, as", "the only option that users have for gathering information on", "Until the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, March 5th at", "for example, hold a live chat session with your candidates", "be done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction.", "for the candidates, typically containing 10 questions in total. ", "opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your community", "of the top voted questions submitted by the community* provided", "you would like to ask the candidates. Please only post", "question containing any questions you would like to ask the", "and seeing the questions they'll have an opening to answer.", "your question contains a link, please use the syntax of", "an opportunity for members of the community to pose questions", "Once questions have been selected, a new question will be", "to pose questions to the candidates on the topic of", "the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > >", "but also potential candidates can think about nominating themselves and", "open to collect potential questions from the users of the", "are specific to your community and issues that you are", "latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions.", "to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by the", "We, the Community Team, will be providing a small selection", "collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live,", "this question containing any questions you would like to ask", "the candidates, typically containing 10 questions in total. * This", "folks start prepping questions in advance, but also potential candidates", "prepping questions in advance, but also potential candidates can think", "prior instruction. * If your question contains a link, please", "the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about", "one question per answer. * We, the Community Team, will", "your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from", "have for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you", "March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection with that, we will be holding", "is provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions", "this question will be open to collect potential questions from", "be open to collect potential questions from the users of", "or take time to arrive for closure, I think this", "scheduled for an election [next week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection", "start of the nomination phase, the Community Team will select", "will be open to collect potential questions from the users", "specific to your community and issues that you are running", "was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is", "will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are", "candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what", "10 questions in total. * This is not the only", "unlike the prior instruction. * If your question contains a", "example, hold a live chat session with your candidates to", "to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now", "host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, typically containing 10", "the question collection a week in advance, so that not", "connection with that, we will be holding a Q&A with", "gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are still", "syntax of `[text](link)`, as that will make it easier for", "site. Post answers to this question containing any questions you", "further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in", "an opening to answer. Here's how it'll work: * Until", "post one question per answer. * We, the Community Team,", "included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply", "can think about nominating themselves and seeing the questions they'll", "this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The", "[next week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection with that, we will", "moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of", "themselves and seeing the questions they'll have an opening to", "question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for", "phase, (so, until Monday, March 5th at 20:00:00Z UTC, or", "done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. ", "that will make it easier for transcribing for the finished", "question contains a link, please use the syntax of `[text](link)`,", "At the start of the nomination phase, the Community Team", "for the finished questionnaire. * This is a perfect opportunity", "I think this is my last sweet day to use", "community, you are still free to, for example, hold a", "candidates, typically containing 10 questions in total. * This is", "questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be included,", "the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely", "UTC, or 3:00 pm EST on the same day, give", "give or take time to arrive for closure, I think", "selected, a new question will be opened to host the", "find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're", "topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > The", "provided in this thread, to use in addition to the", "opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, typically", "hosting the question collection a week in advance, so that", "have an opening to answer. Here's how it'll work: ", "[here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).* > > > Unlike [last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting the", "ask the candidates. Please only post one question per answer.", "that not only can folks start prepping questions in advance,", "work: * Until the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, March", "the same day, give or take time to arrive for", "a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to", "questions or feedback about this process, feel free to post", "voice questions that are specific to your community and issues", "now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > >", "submitted by the community provided in this thread, to use", "to this question containing any questions you would like to", "be providing a small selection of generic questions. The first", "perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your", "to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. * Once questions have", "advance, so that not only can folks start prepping questions", "Here's how it'll work: * Until the nomination phase, (so,", "the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done", "This is not the only option that users have for", "ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This", "questions from the users of the site. Post answers to", "a small selection of generic questions. The first two will", "If your question contains a link, please use the syntax", "* This is not the only option that users have", "think about nominating themselves and seeing the questions they'll have", "have any questions or feedback about this process, feel free", "to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions.", "to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, typically containing", "Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for", "live chat session with your candidates to ask further questions,", "is not the only option that users have for gathering", "it'll work: * Until the nomination phase, (so, until Monday,", "community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in", "the users of the site. Post answers to this question", "questions in total. * This is not the only option", "the Community Team will select *up to 8 of the", "this process, feel free to post as a comment here.", "any questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please", "take time to arrive for closure, I think this is", "a week in advance, so that not only can folks", "the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, March 5th at 20:00:00Z", "guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if the", "a live chat session with your candidates to ask further", "single post, unlike the prior instruction. If your question", "currently. * At the start of the nomination phase, the", "nomination phase, (so, until Monday, March 5th at 20:00:00Z UTC,", "doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in a", "in this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned", "to ask the candidates. Please only post one question per", "like to ask the candidates. Please only post one question", "make it easier for transcribing for the finished questionnaire. ", "users have for gathering information on candidates. As a community,", "The first two will be guaranteed to be included, the", "a single post, unlike the prior instruction. If your", "question will be open to collect potential questions from the", "your community and issues that you are running into at", "containing any questions you would like to ask the candidates.", "This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are", "candidates can think about nominating themselves and seeing the questions", "time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting the question collection a week in advance,", "can folks start prepping questions in advance, but also potential", "supply enough questions. This will be done in a single", "for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you", "at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 3:00 pm EST on the same", "in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. * Once", "same day, give or take time to arrive for closure,", "the Community Team, will be providing a small selection of", "purpose of this thread was to collect questions for the", "Monday, March 5th at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 3:00 pm EST", "will be done in a single post, unlike the prior", "we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This", "in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. * If", "is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4025/2018-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** >", "enough questions. This will be done in a single post,", "questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and", "start prepping questions in advance, but also potential candidates can", "answer. We, the Community Team, will be providing a", "is completely voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread", "phase, the Community Team will select up to 8 of", "questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation", "be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates,", "answers to this question containing any questions you would like", "my last sweet day to use EST), this question will", "*The purpose of this thread was to collect questions for", "to voice questions that are specific to your community and", "a new question will be opened to host the actual", "in the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback", "been selected, a new question will be opened to host", "is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific", "3:00 pm EST on the same day, give or take", "guaranteed questions. Once questions have been selected, a new", "questions in advance, but also potential candidates can think about", "Please only post one question per answer. * We, the", "a link, please use the syntax of `[text](link)`, as that", "the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. * Once questions have been", "As a community, you are still free to, for example,", "option that users have for gathering information on candidates. As", "for members of the community to pose questions to the", "with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members", "[last time](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection), we're hosting the question collection a week in", "election [next week, March 5th](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2). In connection with that, we", "This will be an opportunity for members of the community", "will be an opportunity for members of the community to", "easier for transcribing for the finished questionnaire. * This is", "top voted questions submitted by the community provided in this", "the community provided in this thread, to use in addition", "2 guaranteed questions. * Once questions have been selected, a", "potential questions from the users of the site. Post answers", "a community, you are still free to, for example, hold", "new question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire", "questionnaire for the candidates, typically containing 10 questions in total.", "of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose", "community and issues that you are running into at currently.", "potential candidates can think about nominating themselves and seeing the", "that you are running into at currently. At the" ]
[ "is fine - or the OP Zen Cwewild can weigh", "in the post. > > Now that the reported rape", "the post. > > Now that the reported rape at", "question that reflects that updated information. > > > While", "the predicating assault is fine - or the OP Zen", "* [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I think changing the predicating assault is", "reflect that the example didn't happen, or edited maybe to", "this question that reflects that updated information. > > >", "be about any other sexual assault that occurred in a", "\"answer\" is certainly abrasive, it does merit consideration that the", "the University of Virginia has been thoroughly discredited and exposed", "discredited and exposed as serious journalistic misconduct, I think it", "be changed to either reflect that the example didn't happen,", "to either reflect that the example didn't happen, or edited", "[points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information isn't in the post. > >", "in a frat: From aeismail's suggestions: * [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2)", "it does merit consideration that the question should be changed", "to be about any other sexual assault that occurred in", "assault is fine - or the OP Zen Cwewild can", "consideration that the question should be changed to either reflect", "out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information isn't in the post. > > Now", "sexual assault that occurred in a frat: From aeismail's suggestions:", "adding a new answer to this question that reflects that", "frat: From aeismail's suggestions: * [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) * [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/)", "is worth adding a new answer to this question that", "question should be changed to either reflect that the example", "that the question should be changed to either reflect that", "merit consideration that the question should be changed to either", "> > Now that the reported rape at the University", "misconduct, I think it is worth adding a new answer", "> While his \"answer\" is certainly abrasive, it does merit", "journalistic misconduct, I think it is worth adding a new", "on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone article. As user Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441),", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32317/what-leverage-do-universities-have-over-sexual-violence-in-fraternities) is predicated on the now-debunked [\"A Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus)", "either reflect that the example didn't happen, or edited maybe", "a frat: From aeismail's suggestions: * [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) ", "it is worth adding a new answer to this question", "updated information. > > > While his \"answer\" is certainly", "predicated on the now-debunked [\"A Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone", "From aeismail's suggestions: [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) * [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally,", "to this question that reflects that updated information. > >", "of Virginia has been thoroughly discredited and exposed as serious", "changing the predicating assault is fine - or the OP", "the reported rape at the University of Virginia has been", "example didn't happen, or edited maybe to be about any", "been thoroughly discredited and exposed as serious journalistic misconduct, I", "[\"A Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone article. As user Ben", "predicating assault is fine - or the OP Zen Cwewild", "new answer to this question that reflects that updated information.", "the example didn't happen, or edited maybe to be about", "information isn't in the post. > > Now that the", "Stone* article. As user Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information isn't", "I think it is worth adding a new answer to", "that the reported rape at the University of Virginia has", "thoroughly discredited and exposed as serious journalistic misconduct, I think", "as serious journalistic misconduct, I think it is worth adding", "Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone article. As user Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this", "other sexual assault that occurred in a frat: From aeismail's", "is certainly abrasive, it does merit consideration that the question", "user Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information isn't in the post.", "reflects that updated information. > > > While his \"answer\"", "* [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) * [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I think changing", "think it is worth adding a new answer to this", "exposed as serious journalistic misconduct, I think it is worth", "rape at the University of Virginia has been thoroughly discredited", "now-debunked [\"A Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone article. As user", "information. > > > While his \"answer\" is certainly abrasive,", "worth adding a new answer to this question that reflects", "[Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I think changing the predicating assault is fine", "While his \"answer\" is certainly abrasive, it does merit consideration", "at the University of Virginia has been thoroughly discredited and", "changed to either reflect that the example didn't happen, or", "Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information isn't in the post. >", "occurred in a frat: From aeismail's suggestions: * [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) ", "aeismail's suggestions: [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) * [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I", "maybe to be about any other sexual assault that occurred", "abrasive, it does merit consideration that the question should be", "his \"answer\" is certainly abrasive, it does merit consideration that", "assault that occurred in a frat: From aeismail's suggestions: ", "Personally, I think changing the predicating assault is fine -", "the now-debunked [\"A Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone* article. As", "on the now-debunked [\"A Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone article.", "the question should be changed to either reflect that the", "that the example didn't happen, or edited maybe to be", "> > While his \"answer\" is certainly abrasive, it does", "and exposed as serious journalistic misconduct, I think it is", "answer to this question that reflects that updated information. >", "is predicated on the now-debunked [\"A Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling", "didn't happen, or edited maybe to be about any other", "think changing the predicating assault is fine - or the", "article. As user Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information isn't in", "[Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I think changing the predicating assault", "> > > While his \"answer\" is certainly abrasive, it", "Virginia has been thoroughly discredited and exposed as serious journalistic", "a new answer to this question that reflects that updated", "or edited maybe to be about any other sexual assault", "fine - or the OP Zen Cwewild can weigh in.", "> Now that the reported rape at the University of", "isn't in the post. > > Now that the reported", "[Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) * [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I think changing the", "serious journalistic misconduct, I think it is worth adding a", "this information isn't in the post. > > Now that", "I think changing the predicating assault is fine - or", "should be changed to either reflect that the example didn't", "certainly abrasive, it does merit consideration that the question should", "reported rape at the University of Virginia has been thoroughly", "[This question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/32317/what-leverage-do-universities-have-over-sexual-violence-in-fraternities) is predicated on the now-debunked [\"A Rape on", "University of Virginia has been thoroughly discredited and exposed as", "that updated information. > > > While his \"answer\" is", "suggestions: * [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html) * [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) * [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I think", "post. > > Now that the reported rape at the", "edited maybe to be about any other sexual assault that", "any other sexual assault that occurred in a frat: From", "that reflects that updated information. > > > While his", "Rape on Campus\"](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus) Rolling Stone article. As user Ben [points", "about any other sexual assault that occurred in a frat:", "does merit consideration that the question should be changed to", "As user Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information isn't in the", "has been thoroughly discredited and exposed as serious journalistic misconduct,", "* [Yale](http://www.businessinsider.com/yale-dke-frat-brothers-allegations-of-sexual-assault-2018-2) * [Wisconsin](https://badgerherald.com/news/2018/02/04/saturday-night-sexual-assault-reported-at-unknown-fraternity/) Personally, I think changing the predicating", "happen, or edited maybe to be about any other sexual", "Rolling Stone article. As user Ben [points out](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104545/37441), this information", "that occurred in a frat: From aeismail's suggestions: * [Baylor](http://www.kwtx.com/content/news/Waco--16-defendants-added-to-lawsuit-over-2016-BU-frat-party-rape-474908383.html)", "Now that the reported rape at the University of Virginia" ]
[ "OP's exact situation? Or should I leave it to stand", "institution - information which was not originally apparent. Since then,", "on an assumption that the OP and a supervisor were", "assumption that the OP and a supervisor were based at", "OP and a supervisor were based at the same institution", "my (substantially upvoted) answer which does not address OP's exact", "on the basis that it may be helpful to others", "be helpful to others in similar but not identical situations?", "my answer. Should I now remove my (substantially upvoted) answer", "[Should I report a PhD student’s incompetence to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184)", "it to stand on the basis that it may be", "report a PhD student’s incompetence to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave", "supervisor were based at the same institution - information which", "the OP and a supervisor were based at the same", "Should I now remove my (substantially upvoted) answer which does", "that my assumption was incorrect, and this invalidates my answer.", "same institution - information which was not originally apparent. Since", "incorrect, and this invalidates my answer. Should I now remove", "I now remove my (substantially upvoted) answer which does not", "originally apparent. Since then, OP has clarified that my assumption", "answer which does not address OP's exact situation? Or should", "address OP's exact situation? Or should I leave it to", "incompetence to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on", "in similar but not identical situations? In any case I", "student’s incompetence to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based", "exact situation? Or should I leave it to stand on", "based on an assumption that the OP and a supervisor", "OP has clarified that my assumption was incorrect, and this", "then, OP has clarified that my assumption was incorrect, and", "Or should I leave it to stand on the basis", "any case I will add a note to indicate my", "to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on an", "an assumption that the OP and a supervisor were based", "information which was not originally apparent. Since then, OP has", "was incorrect, and this invalidates my answer. Should I now", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on an assumption that the OP and a", "(substantially upvoted) answer which does not address OP's exact situation?", "but not identical situations? In any case I will add", "it may be helpful to others in similar but not", "at the same institution - information which was not originally", "based at the same institution - information which was not", "has clarified that my assumption was incorrect, and this invalidates", "answer. Should I now remove my (substantially upvoted) answer which", "assumption was incorrect, and this invalidates my answer. Should I", "this invalidates my answer. Should I now remove my (substantially", "situations? In any case I will add a note to", "leave it to stand on the basis that it may", "to others in similar but not identical situations? In any", "the basis that it may be helpful to others in", "gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on an assumption that the OP", "which does not address OP's exact situation? Or should I", "not originally apparent. Since then, OP has clarified that my", "I gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on an assumption that the", "identical situations? In any case I will add a note", "I report a PhD student’s incompetence to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I", "[an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on an assumption that the OP and", "to stand on the basis that it may be helpful", "and this invalidates my answer. Should I now remove my", "- information which was not originally apparent. Since then, OP", "that the OP and a supervisor were based at the", "upvoted) answer which does not address OP's exact situation? Or", "I will add a note to indicate my incorrect assumption.", "and a supervisor were based at the same institution -", "Since then, OP has clarified that my assumption was incorrect,", "similar but not identical situations? In any case I will", "a PhD student’s incompetence to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave [an", "not identical situations? In any case I will add a", "invalidates my answer. Should I now remove my (substantially upvoted)", "now remove my (substantially upvoted) answer which does not address", "apparent. Since then, OP has clarified that my assumption was", "does not address OP's exact situation? Or should I leave", "basis that it may be helpful to others in similar", "that it may be helpful to others in similar but", "helpful to others in similar but not identical situations? In", "For the question [Should I report a PhD student’s incompetence", "the same institution - information which was not originally apparent.", "case I will add a note to indicate my incorrect", "others in similar but not identical situations? In any case", "PhD student’s incompetence to their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184)", "remove my (substantially upvoted) answer which does not address OP's", "situation? Or should I leave it to stand on the", "not address OP's exact situation? Or should I leave it", "clarified that my assumption was incorrect, and this invalidates my", "In any case I will add a note to indicate", "were based at the same institution - information which was", "their supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on an assumption", "supervisor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/104704/46184) I gave [an answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/104720/46184) based on an assumption that", "which was not originally apparent. Since then, OP has clarified", "was not originally apparent. Since then, OP has clarified that", "I leave it to stand on the basis that it", "my assumption was incorrect, and this invalidates my answer. Should", "the question [Should I report a PhD student’s incompetence to", "question [Should I report a PhD student’s incompetence to their", "should I leave it to stand on the basis that", "stand on the basis that it may be helpful to", "a supervisor were based at the same institution - information", "may be helpful to others in similar but not identical" ]
[ "What is your field of study in academics? > 8.", "submission. To save scrolling here are links to the submissions", "creating a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from", "appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to all", "the questions, with your answer to each question given just", "best example? > 7. What is your field of study", "our back-up questions for a total of 9 questions. We", "candidates! Oh, and when you've completed your answer, please provide", "post. Once all the answers have been compiled, this will", "who you are before they finish reading everything you have", "arguments/flags from comments? > 3. How would you handle a", "close/delete/migrate the post. The user takes the issue to Meta", "order of submission. To save scrolling here are links to", "best exemplifies your philosophy on moderation? Why do you feel", "feel shouldn't have been? > 4. As a moderator, I", "Good luck to all of the candidates! Oh, and when", "to do next? > 6. What question or answer of", "circumstances will you delete comments? > 5. A user posts", "putting your name at the top of your post so", "comments? > 5. A user posts something you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive", "seen under a different light. How do you feel about", "have you used the moderation tools available to you at", "in academics? > 8. In your opinion, what do moderators", "everything you have written, and also including a link to", "links in the order of submission.** To save scrolling here", "just below. For your convenience, I will include all of", "opinion, what do moderators do? > 9. A diamond will", "where another mod closed/deleted/etc a question that you feel shouldn't", "name at the top of your post so that readers", "what to do next? > 6. What question or answer", "> 1. What activities on the site suggest that you", "would you deal with a user who produced a steady", "for a total of 9 questions. We skipped one backup", "under a different light. How do you feel about that?", "everything you say and have said in the past, including", "[from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one,", "you say and have said in the past, including questions,", "as the space for the candidates to provide their answers.", "answers. Due to the submission count, we have selected all", "first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting your name at", "Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) * [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- > > 1. What activities on", "the site suggest that you would be a good moderator?", "as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of", "would you handle a situation where another mod closed/deleted/etc a", "connection with the moderator elections, we are creating a Q&A", "do will be seen under a different light. How do", "we are creating a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions", "your opinion, what do moderators do? > 9. A diamond", "comments are a tricky thing to deal with. Under what", "questions for a total of 9 questions. We skipped one", "a lot of upvotes. How do you decide what to", "the submission count, we have selected all provided questions as", "all provided questions as well as two of our back-up", "yours on meta best exemplifies your philosophy on moderation? Why", "each of the questions, with your answer to each question", "> 9. A diamond will be attached to everything you", "and will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good", "The user takes the issue to Meta and the question", "Everything you will do will be seen under a different", "said in the past, including questions, answers and comments. Everything", "produced a steady stream of valuable answers, but tends to", "below. For your convenience, I will include all of the", "Under what circumstances will you delete comments? > 5. A", "of 9 questions. We skipped one backup question because it", "closed/deleted/etc a question that you feel shouldn't have been? >", "you feel shouldn't have been? > 4. As a moderator,", "We skipped one backup question because it covers similar ground", "question because it covers similar ground as the submitted questions.", "as well as answers supporting and opposing your decision get", "user takes the issue to Meta and the question as", "Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into", "of the candidates! Oh, and when you've completed your answer,", "Oh, and when you've completed your answer, please provide a", "philosophy on moderation? Why do you feel this is the", "of valuable answers, but tends to generate a large number", "3. How would you handle a situation where another mod", "you have written, and also including a link to your", "answers have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript", "your convenience, I will include all of the questions in", "to the submissions from each candidate (in order of submission):", "thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection)", "with the moderator elections, we are creating a Q&A thread", "9 questions. We skipped one backup question because it covers", "on the site suggest that you would be a good", "as well as two of our back-up questions for a", "4. As a moderator, I find that comments are a", "A diamond will be attached to everything you say and", "ground as the submitted questions. As a candidate, your job", "questions in quote format with a break in between each,", "the issue to Meta and the question as well as", "all the answers have been compiled, this will serve as", "dashes. Please leave the list of links in the order", "post so that readers will know who you are before", "who produced a steady stream of valuable answers, but tends", "questions, answers and comments. Everything you will do will be", "> 3. How would you handle a situation where another", "transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates,", "comments? > 3. How would you handle a situation where", "skipped one backup question because it covers similar ground as", "simple - post an answer to this question, listing each", "before that set of three dashes. Please leave the list", "that comments are a tricky thing to deal with. Under", "your name at the top of your post so that", "steady stream of valuable answers, but tends to generate a", "answer to each question given just below. For your convenience,", "the list of links in the order of submission. To", "moderators do? > 9. A diamond will be attached to", "and have said in the past, including questions, answers and", "lot of upvotes. How do you decide what to do", "find that comments are a tricky thing to deal with.", "be seen under a different light. How do you feel", "candidate, your job is simple - post an answer to", "or answer of yours on meta best exemplifies your philosophy", "the Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates!", "you used the moderation tools available to you at your", "answers supporting and opposing your decision get a lot of", "quote format with a break in between each, suitable for", "upvotes. How do you decide what to do next? >", "one, which shall now serve as the space for the", "space for the candidates to provide their answers. Due to", "the post. The user takes the issue to Meta and", "good moderator? How have you used the moderation tools available", "answer on your nomination post. Once all the answers have", "a link to it after this blurb here, before that", "save scrolling here are links to the submissions from each", "is simple - post an answer to this question, listing", "will know who you are before they finish reading everything", "a question that you feel shouldn't have been? > 4.", "be attached to everything you say and have said in", "moderator elections, we are creating a Q&A thread for the", "all of the candidates! Oh, and when you've completed your", "exemplifies your philosophy on moderation? Why do you feel this", "into this one, which shall now serve as the space", "candidates to provide their answers. Due to the submission count,", "of our back-up questions for a total of 9 questions.", "collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this", "large number of arguments/flags from comments? > 3. How would", "(in order of submission): * [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo", "is your field of study in academics? > 8. In", "How have you used the moderation tools available to you", "opposing your decision get a lot of upvotes. How do", "deal with a user who produced a steady stream of", "[Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) * [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- > > 1.", "> 4. As a moderator, I find that comments are", "with your answer to each question given just below. For", "the order of submission.** To save scrolling here are links", "have been? > 4. As a moderator, I find that", "to each question given just below. For your convenience, I", "you feel this is the best example? > 7. What", "to the submission count, we have selected all provided questions", "it after this blurb here, before that set of three", "you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing", "--- > > 1. What activities on the site suggest", "earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall", "answers, but tends to generate a large number of arguments/flags", "provide a link to it after this blurb here, before", "you've completed your answer, please provide a link to it", "> 7. What is your field of study in academics?", "question, listing each of the questions, with your answer to", "links to the submissions from each candidate (in order of", "each question given just below. For your convenience, I will", "site suggest that you would be a good moderator? How", "different light. How do you feel about that? > >", "will do will be seen under a different light. How", "you delete comments? > 5. A user posts something you", "answers and comments. Everything you will do will be seen", "will include all of the questions in quote format with", "have written, and also including a link to your answer", "> 6. What question or answer of yours on meta", "your answer, please provide a link to it after this", "> 2. How would you deal with a user who", "at the top of your post so that readers will", "the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked", "submitted questions. As a candidate, your job is simple -", "serve as the space for the candidates to provide their", "the candidates to provide their answers. Due to the submission", "well as two of our back-up questions for a total", "for the candidates to provide their answers. Due to the", "user posts something you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you close/delete/migrate the", "back-up questions for a total of 9 questions. We skipped", "on your nomination post. Once all the answers have been", "supporting and opposing your decision get a lot of upvotes.", "in quote format with a break in between each, suitable", "for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and", "the top of your post so that readers will know", "questions, with your answer to each question given just below.", "moderator, I find that comments are a tricky thing to", "a user who produced a steady stream of valuable answers,", "break in between each, suitable for you to insert your", "are a tricky thing to deal with. Under what circumstances", "have selected all provided questions as well as two of", "current reputation level? > 2. How would you deal with", "thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in", "your field of study in academics? > 8. In your", "submission count, we have selected all provided questions as well", "answer to this question, listing each of the questions, with", "suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the", "top of your post so that readers will know who", "your current reputation level? > 2. How would you deal", "what circumstances will you delete comments? > 5. A user", "the whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please", "* [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) * [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) ---", "please provide a link to it after this blurb here,", "submission): * [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) * [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036)", "For your convenience, I will include all of the questions", "for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have", "of the questions, with your answer to each question given", "light. How do you feel about that? > > >", "an answer to this question, listing each of the questions,", "posts something you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you close/delete/migrate the post.", "their answers. Due to the submission count, we have selected", "your philosophy on moderation? Why do you feel this is", "the questions in quote format with a break in between", "of study in academics? > 8. In your opinion, what", "on moderation? Why do you feel this is the best", "off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you close/delete/migrate the post. The user takes the", "this one, which shall now serve as the space for", "an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which", "linked in the Election page. Good luck to all of", "that you feel shouldn't have been? > 4. As a", "moderation tools available to you at your current reputation level?", "Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates! Oh,", "next? > 6. What question or answer of yours on", "something you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you close/delete/migrate the post. The", "of your post so that readers will know who you", "a moderator, I find that comments are a tricky thing", "whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider", "In connection with the moderator elections, we are creating a", "a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their", "> 5. A user posts something you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and", "> 8. In your opinion, what do moderators do? >", "delete comments? > 5. A user posts something you consider", "candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled", "of yours on meta best exemplifies your philosophy on moderation?", "when you've completed your answer, please provide a link to", "to your answer on your nomination post. Once all the", "in the order of submission. To save scrolling here are", "of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the", "candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election page.", "are links to the submissions from each candidate (in order", "* [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- > > 1. What activities on the", "at your current reputation level? > 2. How would you", "would be a good moderator? How have you used the", "you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you close/delete/migrate the post. The user", "your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first", "of three dashes. Please leave the list of links in", "activities on the site suggest that you would be a", "[padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) * [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- >", "field of study in academics? > 8. In your opinion,", "Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier", "that set of three dashes. Please leave the list of", "three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting your name at the top of", "selected all provided questions as well as two of our", "moderator? How have you used the moderation tools available to", "to all of the candidates! *Oh, and when you've completed", "Why do you feel this is the best example? >", "[Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- > > 1. What activities", "mod closed/deleted/etc a question that you feel shouldn't have been?", "job is simple - post an answer to this question,", "been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters", "voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will", "As a moderator, I find that comments are a tricky", "A user posts something you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you close/delete/migrate", "In your opinion, what do moderators do? > 9. A", "be a good moderator? How have you used the moderation", "decision get a lot of upvotes. How do you decide", "list of links in the order of submission. To save", "blurb here, before that set of three dashes. Please leave", "the question as well as answers supporting and opposing your", "that you would be a good moderator? How have you", "shall now serve as the space for the candidates to", "after this blurb here, before that set of three dashes.", "user who produced a steady stream of valuable answers, but", "say and have said in the past, including questions, answers", "a situation where another mod closed/deleted/etc a question that you", "5. A user posts something you consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you", "but tends to generate a large number of arguments/flags from", "and also including a link to your answer on your", "valuable answers, but tends to generate a large number of", "link to it after this blurb here, before that set", "you decide what to do next? > 6. What question", "a tricky thing to deal with. Under what circumstances will", "nomination post. Once all the answers have been compiled, this", "you handle a situation where another mod closed/deleted/etc a question", "comments. Everything you will do will be seen under a", "with a break in between each, suitable for you to", "answer of yours on meta best exemplifies your philosophy on", "which shall now serve as the space for the candidates", "insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the", "questions. We skipped one backup question because it covers similar", "> > 1. What activities on the site suggest that", "this is the best example? > 7. What is your", "been? > 4. As a moderator, I find that comments", "to everything you say and have said in the past,", "you at your current reputation level? > 2. How would", "to provide their answers. Due to the submission count, we", "I find that comments are a tricky thing to deal", "have been compiled into this one, which shall now serve", "set of three dashes. Please leave the list of links", "to Meta and the question as well as answers supporting", "page. Good luck to all of the candidates! Oh, and", "tricky thing to deal with. Under what circumstances will you", "set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting your name at the", "completed your answer, please provide a link to it after", "this question, listing each of the questions, with your answer", "7. What is your field of study in academics? >", "submissions from each candidate (in order of submission): * [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118)", "elections, we are creating a Q&A thread for the candidates.", "answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first set", "to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be", "a candidate, your job is simple - post an answer", "after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting your", "have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for", "thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall now", "be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to", "How do you decide what to do next? > 6.", "are creating a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected", "and opposing your decision get a lot of upvotes. How", "backup question because it covers similar ground as the submitted", "feel this is the best example? > 7. What is", "and you close/delete/migrate the post. The user takes the issue", "as answers supporting and opposing your decision get a lot", "also including a link to your answer on your nomination", "question or answer of yours on meta best exemplifies your", "a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an", "[Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- > > 1. What activities on the site", "the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting your name", "now serve as the space for the candidates to provide", "finish reading everything you have written, and also including a", "the past, including questions, answers and comments. Everything you will", "post an answer to this question, listing each of the", "that readers will know who you are before they finish", "a total of 9 questions. We skipped one backup question", "we have selected all provided questions as well as two", "compiled into this one, which shall now serve as the", "the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4008/2018-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been", "it covers similar ground as the submitted questions. As a", "do moderators do? > 9. A diamond will be attached", "in between each, suitable for you to insert your answers.", "and when you've completed your answer, please provide a link", "between each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just", "do you feel this is the best example? > 7.", "count, we have selected all provided questions as well as", "as the submitted questions. As a candidate, your job is", "all of the questions in quote format with a break", "8. In your opinion, what do moderators do? > 9.", "link to your answer on your nomination post. Once all", "reputation level? > 2. How would you deal with a", "attached to everything you say and have said in the", "include all of the questions in quote format with a", "will serve as a transcript for voters to view the", "Just [copy the whole thing after the first set of", "this blurb here, before that set of three dashes. Please", "situation where another mod closed/deleted/etc a question that you feel", "to it after this blurb here, before that set of", "you deal with a user who produced a steady stream", "your answer to each question given just below. For your", "What question or answer of yours on meta best exemplifies", "you close/delete/migrate the post. The user takes the issue to", "candidate (in order of submission): * [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) ", "moderation? Why do you feel this is the best example?", "their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election", "readers will know who you are before they finish reading", "from each candidate (in order of submission): [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) ", "as two of our back-up questions for a total of", "of the questions in quote format with a break in", "Once all the answers have been compiled, this will serve", "you will do will be seen under a different light.", "reading everything you have written, and also including a link", "from comments? > 3. How would you handle a situation", "issue to Meta and the question as well as answers", "a link to your answer on your nomination post. Once", "well as answers supporting and opposing your decision get a", "to deal with. Under what circumstances will you delete comments?", "and comments. Everything you will do will be seen under", "used the moderation tools available to you at your current", "of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting your name at the top", "so that readers will know who you are before they", "meta best exemplifies your philosophy on moderation? Why do you", "is the best example? > 7. What is your field", "As a candidate, your job is simple - post an", "a good moderator? How have you used the moderation tools", "example? > 7. What is your field of study in", "- post an answer to this question, listing each of", "do you decide what to do next? > 6. What", "the submitted questions. As a candidate, your job is simple", "format with a break in between each, suitable for you", "are before they finish reading everything you have written, and", "written, and also including a link to your answer on", "similar ground as the submitted questions. As a candidate, your", "your job is simple - post an answer to this", "know who you are before they finish reading everything you", "How would you handle a situation where another mod closed/deleted/etc", "the best example? > 7. What is your field of", "Meta and the question as well as answers supporting and", "will you delete comments? > 5. A user posts something", "with a user who produced a steady stream of valuable", "academics? > 8. In your opinion, what do moderators do?", "of links in the order of submission.* To save scrolling", "takes the issue to Meta and the question as well", "luck to all of the candidates! Oh, and when you've", "a steady stream of valuable answers, but tends to generate", "stream of valuable answers, but tends to generate a large", "available to you at your current reputation level? > 2.", "listing each of the questions, with your answer to each", "questions. As a candidate, your job is simple - post", "three dashes. Please leave the list of links in the", "you are before they finish reading everything you have written,", "the candidates! Oh, and when you've completed your answer, please", "your nomination post. Once all the answers have been compiled,", "a different light. How do you feel about that? >", "including a link to your answer on your nomination post.", "each candidate (in order of submission): * [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118)", "do? > 9. A diamond will be attached to everything", "two of our back-up questions for a total of 9", "question as well as answers supporting and opposing your decision", "* [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) * [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- > > 1. What", "consider off-topic/not-an-answer/offensive and you close/delete/migrate the post. The user takes", "6. What question or answer of yours on meta best", "generate a large number of arguments/flags from comments? > 3.", "your answer on your nomination post. Once all the answers", "this will serve as a transcript for voters to view", "1. What activities on the site suggest that you would", "what do moderators do? > 9. A diamond will be", "diamond will be attached to everything you say and have", "deal with. Under what circumstances will you delete comments? >", "to you at your current reputation level? > 2. How", "serve as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts", "will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck", "here are links to the submissions from each candidate (in", "to this question, listing each of the questions, with your", "Due to the submission count, we have selected all provided", "convenience, I will include all of the questions in quote", "each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy", "* [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) * [Wrzlprmft](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4036) --- > >", "questions as well as two of our back-up questions for", "order of submission): * [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058)", "How would you deal with a user who produced a", "get a lot of upvotes. How do you decide what", "I will include all of the questions in quote format", "for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole", "past, including questions, answers and comments. Everything you will do", "consider putting your name at the top of your post", "2. How would you deal with a user who produced", "on meta best exemplifies your philosophy on moderation? Why do", "will be attached to everything you say and have said", "in the past, including questions, answers and comments. Everything you", "total of 9 questions. We skipped one backup question because", "a break in between each, suitable for you to insert", "the moderator elections, we are creating a Q&A thread for", "suggest that you would be a good moderator? How have", "the submissions from each candidate (in order of submission): ", "tools available to you at your current reputation level? >", "dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting your name at the top of your", "To save scrolling here are links to the submissions from", "compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters to", "thing to deal with. Under what circumstances will you delete", "you would be a good moderator? How have you used", "of submission): [padawan](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4030/118) * [Fomite](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4031/118) * [Massimo Ortolano](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/4034/20058) ", "decide what to do next? > 6. What question or", "before they finish reading everything you have written, and also", "handle a situation where another mod closed/deleted/etc a question that", "because it covers similar ground as the submitted questions. As", "to generate a large number of arguments/flags from comments? >", "9. A diamond will be attached to everything you say", "do next? > 6. What question or answer of yours", "given just below. For your convenience, I will include all", "number of arguments/flags from comments? > 3. How would you", "of arguments/flags from comments? > 3. How would you handle", "view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately", "the moderation tools available to you at your current reputation", "a large number of arguments/flags from comments? > 3. How", "one backup question because it covers similar ground as the", "of upvotes. How do you decide what to do next?", "the answers have been compiled, this will serve as a", "of submission.* To save scrolling here are links to the", "with. Under what circumstances will you delete comments? > 5.", "and the question as well as answers supporting and opposing", "shouldn't have been? > 4. As a moderator, I find", "the space for the candidates to provide their answers. Due", "will be seen under a different light. How do you", "provided questions as well as two of our back-up questions", "What activities on the site suggest that you would be", "provide their answers. Due to the submission count, we have", "tends to generate a large number of arguments/flags from comments?", "post. The user takes the issue to Meta and the", "scrolling here are links to the submissions from each candidate", "another mod closed/deleted/etc a question that you feel shouldn't have", "have said in the past, including questions, answers and comments.", "level? > 2. How would you deal with a user", "in the Election page. Good luck to all of the", "been compiled into this one, which shall now serve as", "they finish reading everything you have written, and also including", "study in academics? > 8. In your opinion, what do", "your decision get a lot of upvotes. How do you", "[copy the whole thing after the first set of three", "Please leave the list of links in the order of", "question that you feel shouldn't have been? > 4. As", "your post so that readers will know who you are", "covers similar ground as the submitted questions. As a candidate,", "to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after", "thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/dd90db94-b3b0-4e18-ab91-19548d040770/view-source).Please consider putting", "answer, please provide a link to it after this blurb", "including questions, answers and comments. Everything you will do will", "here, before that set of three dashes. Please leave the", "question given just below. For your convenience, I will include", "leave the list of links in the order of submission.**" ]
[ "with heavy downvotes is likely to decrease my answer score", "an answer, I just delete my answer, because I can", "disagree with my answers (no upvotes), or they simply didn't", "lack of ability to do so, or I have some", "community on meta feels like nagging and inappropriate. Either way,", "face repercussions from the site? I should mention, on Math", "let's do it more professional! So image I have posted", "can't understand why it is bad? On a technical note,", "if I realize I actually don't know an answer, I", "some grave mistake in the answer I cannot recognize because", "post about \"Why downvotes? Please explain so I can improve!\"", "well received by the community, getting below score of -5", "both), but I don't know which and asking the community", "missed. I reacted to the comments explaining, but the community", "have missed. I reacted to the comments explaining, but the", "simply didn't read them, I don't know. So since I'm", "in the answer I cannot recognize because of my lack", "don't know. So since I'm a beginner academic (if anything)", "unorthodox point of view that is frowned upon (or both),", "either wrong about what was asked, my solution attempt was", "my answer well or, if I realize I actually don't", "delete my answer, because I can see that it doesn't", "one) but almost always disagree with my answers (no upvotes),", "likely to decrease my answer score and I may face", "repercussions from the site? I should mention, on Math SE", "grave mistake in the answer I cannot recognize because of", "don't know which and asking the community on meta feels", "them, I don't know. So since I'm a beginner academic", "asked, my solution attempt was wrong or I didn't explain", "and inappropriate. Either way, the community convinced me to believe", "may have missed. I reacted to the comments explaining, but", "I don't know which and asking the community on meta", "bad? On a technical note, having answers with heavy downvotes", "a very nagging character. Instead, let's do it more professional!", "community seemed to agree with the other commentators (e.g. 12", "the answer I cannot recognize because of my lack of", "score of -5 and some comments pointing things out I", "have some extremely unorthodox point of view that is frowned", "know which and asking the community on meta feels like", "a technical note, having answers with heavy downvotes is likely", "and asking the community on meta feels like nagging and", "was writing a lengthy post about \"Why downvotes? Please explain", "to believe that my answer is bad. Should I now", "anything) and can be easily influenced by nature, I'm starting", "have posted an answer that isn't well received by the", "The [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings) and my [answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings/105240#105240). I was writing a lengthy", "on one) but almost always disagree with my answers (no", "agree with the other commentators (e.g. 12 upvotes on one)", "like nagging and inappropriate. Either way, the community convinced me", "other commentators (e.g. 12 upvotes on one) but almost always", "explain well. In that case given a comment I can", "I can see that it doesn't help anyone. But here", "comment I can either improve my answer well or, if", "I just delete my answer, because I can see that", "site? I should mention, on Math SE I'm usually either", "to agree with the other commentators (e.g. 12 upvotes on", "influenced by nature, I'm starting to believe I either made", "I can't understand why it is bad? On a technical", "posted an answer that isn't well received by the community,", "and I may face repercussions from the site? I should", "things out I may have missed. I reacted to the", "academic (if anything) and can be easily influenced by nature,", "don't know an answer, I just delete my answer, because", "I was writing a lengthy post about \"Why downvotes? Please", "me to believe that my answer is bad. Should I", "ability to do so, or I have some extremely unorthodox", "but the community seemed to agree with the other commentators", "convinced me to believe that my answer is bad. Should", "view that is frowned upon (or both), but I don't", "So image I have posted an answer that isn't well", "answer, I just delete my answer, because I can see", "In that case given a comment I can either improve", "it, even when I can't understand why it is bad?", "read them, I don't know. So since I'm a beginner", "with the other commentators (e.g. 12 upvotes on one) but", "the community convinced me to believe that my answer is", "be easily influenced by nature, I'm starting to believe I", "I reacted to the comments explaining, but the community seemed", "is bad? On a technical note, having answers with heavy", "below score of -5 and some comments pointing things out", "didn't read them, I don't know. So since I'm a", "my answer is bad. Should I now delete it, even", "a lengthy post about \"Why downvotes? Please explain so I", "my answer, because I can see that it doesn't help", "which and asking the community on meta feels like nagging", "asking the community on meta feels like nagging and inappropriate.", "didn't explain well. In that case given a comment I", "believe that my answer is bad. Should I now delete", "answers with heavy downvotes is likely to decrease my answer", "from the site? I should mention, on Math SE I'm", "(or both), but I don't know which and asking the", "feels like nagging and inappropriate. Either way, the community convinced", "frowned upon (or both), but I don't know which and", "even when I can't understand why it is bad? On", "the site? I should mention, on Math SE I'm usually", "nagging and inappropriate. Either way, the community convinced me to", "usually either wrong about what was asked, my solution attempt", "comments explaining, but the community seemed to agree with the", "should mention, on Math SE I'm usually either wrong about", "heavy downvotes is likely to decrease my answer score and", "bad. Should I now delete it, even when I can't", "they simply didn't read them, I don't know. So since", "is frowned upon (or both), but I don't know which", "explain so I can improve!\" but I noticed it had", "and some comments pointing things out I may have missed.", "out I may have missed. I reacted to the comments", "I may face repercussions from the site? I should mention,", "on meta feels like nagging and inappropriate. Either way, the", "or, if I realize I actually don't know an answer,", "it is bad? On a technical note, having answers with", "I'm usually either wrong about what was asked, my solution", "community, getting below score of -5 and some comments pointing", "is likely to decrease my answer score and I may", "about \"Why downvotes? Please explain so I can improve!\" but", "my lack of ability to do so, or I have", "that my answer is bad. Should I now delete it,", "now delete it, even when I can't understand why it", "mistake in the answer I cannot recognize because of my", "wrong or I didn't explain well. In that case given", "some extremely unorthodox point of view that is frowned upon", "or they simply didn't read them, I don't know. So", "I'm starting to believe I either made some grave mistake", "realize I actually don't know an answer, I just delete", "Either way, the community convinced me to believe that my", "I either made some grave mistake in the answer I", "meta feels like nagging and inappropriate. Either way, the community", "that it doesn't help anyone. But here at academics, I'm", "comments pointing things out I may have missed. I reacted", "received by the community, getting below score of -5 and", "is bad. Should I now delete it, even when I", "the community, getting below score of -5 and some comments", "on Math SE I'm usually either wrong about what was", "decrease my answer score and I may face repercussions from", "answer I cannot recognize because of my lack of ability", "lengthy post about \"Why downvotes? Please explain so I can", "mention, on Math SE I'm usually either wrong about what", "Math SE I'm usually either wrong about what was asked,", "reacted to the comments explaining, but the community seemed to", "was wrong or I didn't explain well. In that case", "case given a comment I can either improve my answer", "image I have posted an answer that isn't well received", "can improve!\" but I noticed it had a very nagging", "do it more professional! So image I have posted an", "commentators (e.g. 12 upvotes on one) but almost always disagree", "(no upvotes), or they simply didn't read them, I don't", "Example: The [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings) and my [answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings/105240#105240). I was writing a", "why it is bad? On a technical note, having answers", "I have posted an answer that isn't well received by", "by nature, I'm starting to believe I either made some", "answer, because I can see that it doesn't help anyone.", "improve my answer well or, if I realize I actually", "of my lack of ability to do so, or I", "by the community, getting below score of -5 and some", "downvotes? Please explain so I can improve!\" but I noticed", "[answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings/105240#105240). I was writing a lengthy post about \"Why downvotes?", "made some grave mistake in the answer I cannot recognize", "to decrease my answer score and I may face repercussions", "I realize I actually don't know an answer, I just", "(e.g. 12 upvotes on one) but almost always disagree with", "anyone. But here at academics, I'm at loss. [Related Meta-Post.](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/163730/when-should-i-delete-an-answer)", "pointing things out I may have missed. I reacted to", "it more professional! So image I have posted an answer", "12 upvotes on one) but almost always disagree with my", "upvotes), or they simply didn't read them, I don't know.", "so, or I have some extremely unorthodox point of view", "technical note, having answers with heavy downvotes is likely to", "always disagree with my answers (no upvotes), or they simply", "but I don't know which and asking the community on", "given a comment I can either improve my answer well", "can either improve my answer well or, if I realize", "easily influenced by nature, I'm starting to believe I either", "upvotes on one) but almost always disagree with my answers", "know. So since I'm a beginner academic (if anything) and", "of view that is frowned upon (or both), but I", "wrong about what was asked, my solution attempt was wrong", "I didn't explain well. In that case given a comment", "of -5 and some comments pointing things out I may", "I actually don't know an answer, I just delete my", "and my [answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings/105240#105240). I was writing a lengthy post about", "I may have missed. I reacted to the comments explaining,", "to the comments explaining, but the community seemed to agree", "it had a very nagging character. Instead, let's do it", "the other commentators (e.g. 12 upvotes on one) but almost", "the community on meta feels like nagging and inappropriate. Either", "solution attempt was wrong or I didn't explain well. In", "may face repercussions from the site? I should mention, on", "I have some extremely unorthodox point of view that is", "can see that it doesn't help anyone. But here at", "so I can improve!\" but I noticed it had a", "downvotes is likely to decrease my answer score and I", "know an answer, I just delete my answer, because I", "(if anything) and can be easily influenced by nature, I'm", "answer that isn't well received by the community, getting below", "On a technical note, having answers with heavy downvotes is", "answer is bad. Should I now delete it, even when", "my [answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings/105240#105240). I was writing a lengthy post about \"Why", "answer well or, if I realize I actually don't know", "almost always disagree with my answers (no upvotes), or they", "that isn't well received by the community, getting below score", "score and I may face repercussions from the site? I", "professional! So image I have posted an answer that isn't", "my answers (no upvotes), or they simply didn't read them,", "I now delete it, even when I can't understand why", "beginner academic (if anything) and can be easily influenced by", "well or, if I realize I actually don't know an", "point of view that is frowned upon (or both), but", "I can improve!\" but I noticed it had a very", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings) and my [answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105236/how-to-review-bogus-science-without-hurting-feelings/105240#105240). I was writing a lengthy post", "starting to believe I either made some grave mistake in", "I'm a beginner academic (if anything) and can be easily", "that is frowned upon (or both), but I don't know", "I don't know. So since I'm a beginner academic (if", "to believe I either made some grave mistake in the", "understand why it is bad? On a technical note, having", "do so, or I have some extremely unorthodox point of", "but I noticed it had a very nagging character. Instead,", "my answer score and I may face repercussions from the", "I cannot recognize because of my lack of ability to", "writing a lengthy post about \"Why downvotes? Please explain so", "an answer that isn't well received by the community, getting", "way, the community convinced me to believe that my answer", "about what was asked, my solution attempt was wrong or", "well. In that case given a comment I can either", "to do so, or I have some extremely unorthodox point", "what was asked, my solution attempt was wrong or I", "recognize because of my lack of ability to do so,", "can be easily influenced by nature, I'm starting to believe", "help anyone. But here at academics, I'm at loss. [Related", "nagging character. Instead, let's do it more professional! So image", "So since I'm a beginner academic (if anything) and can", "very nagging character. Instead, let's do it more professional! So", "actually don't know an answer, I just delete my answer,", "since I'm a beginner academic (if anything) and can be", "community convinced me to believe that my answer is bad.", "I should mention, on Math SE I'm usually either wrong", "see that it doesn't help anyone. But here at academics,", "Please explain so I can improve!\" but I noticed it", "but almost always disagree with my answers (no upvotes), or", "a comment I can either improve my answer well or,", "answer score and I may face repercussions from the site?", "a beginner academic (if anything) and can be easily influenced", "\"Why downvotes? Please explain so I can improve!\" but I", "SE I'm usually either wrong about what was asked, my", "it doesn't help anyone. But here at academics, I'm at", "noticed it had a very nagging character. Instead, let's do", "more professional! So image I have posted an answer that", "of ability to do so, or I have some extremely", "or I have some extremely unorthodox point of view that", "I can either improve my answer well or, if I", "doesn't help anyone. But here at academics, I'm at loss.", "and can be easily influenced by nature, I'm starting to", "or I didn't explain well. In that case given a", "extremely unorthodox point of view that is frowned upon (or", "Should I now delete it, even when I can't understand", "isn't well received by the community, getting below score of", "with my answers (no upvotes), or they simply didn't read", "nature, I'm starting to believe I either made some grave", "the comments explaining, but the community seemed to agree with", "was asked, my solution attempt was wrong or I didn't", "my solution attempt was wrong or I didn't explain well.", "because I can see that it doesn't help anyone. But", "Instead, let's do it more professional! So image I have", "because of my lack of ability to do so, or", "upon (or both), but I don't know which and asking", "either improve my answer well or, if I realize I", "either made some grave mistake in the answer I cannot", "getting below score of -5 and some comments pointing things", "inappropriate. Either way, the community convinced me to believe that", "cannot recognize because of my lack of ability to do", "believe I either made some grave mistake in the answer", "note, having answers with heavy downvotes is likely to decrease", "explaining, but the community seemed to agree with the other", "delete it, even when I can't understand why it is", "having answers with heavy downvotes is likely to decrease my", "answers (no upvotes), or they simply didn't read them, I", "some comments pointing things out I may have missed. I", "seemed to agree with the other commentators (e.g. 12 upvotes", "attempt was wrong or I didn't explain well. In that", "had a very nagging character. Instead, let's do it more", "improve!\" but I noticed it had a very nagging character.", "when I can't understand why it is bad? On a", "I noticed it had a very nagging character. Instead, let's", "the community seemed to agree with the other commentators (e.g.", "just delete my answer, because I can see that it", "that case given a comment I can either improve my", "character. Instead, let's do it more professional! So image I", "-5 and some comments pointing things out I may have" ]
[ "wouldn't surprise if the down-votes appears at the time I", "see it. Although I don't care the votes or scores", "some up-votes to my high-scored questions. But I can't see", "at the time I asked the question. But the down-voter", "low-scored questions. I would appreciate if the same down-voter gives", "targeting my old low-scored questions. I would appreciate if the", "I can't see it. Although I don't care the votes", "same down-voter gives some up-votes to my high-scored questions. But", "may not be well fitted here. But I am wondering", "low-scored questions asked here? I wouldn't surprise if the down-votes", "wondering why someone is perhaps intentionally down-voting my old low-scored", "well fitted here. But I am wondering why someone is", "questions asked here? I wouldn't surprise if the down-votes appears", "gives some up-votes to my high-scored questions. But I can't", "But the down-voter is targeting my old low-scored questions. I", "down-votes appears at the time I asked the question. But", "perhaps intentionally down-voting my old low-scored questions asked here? I", "if the same down-voter gives some up-votes to my high-scored", "my old low-scored questions asked here? I wouldn't surprise if", "time I asked the question. But the down-voter is targeting", "surprise if the down-votes appears at the time I asked", "why someone is perhaps intentionally down-voting my old low-scored questions", "at all, but still wondering the possible reasons for it.", "This question may not be well fitted here. But I", "I wouldn't surprise if the down-votes appears at the time", "would appreciate if the same down-voter gives some up-votes to", "it. Although I don't care the votes or scores at", "question may not be well fitted here. But I am", "down-voting my old low-scored questions asked here? I wouldn't surprise", "I would appreciate if the same down-voter gives some up-votes", "be well fitted here. But I am wondering why someone", "up-votes to my high-scored questions. But I can't see it.", "But I can't see it. Although I don't care the", "scores at all, but still wondering the possible reasons for", "down-voter is targeting my old low-scored questions. I would appreciate", "someone is perhaps intentionally down-voting my old low-scored questions asked", "am wondering why someone is perhaps intentionally down-voting my old", "high-scored questions. But I can't see it. Although I don't", "can't see it. Although I don't care the votes or", "here. But I am wondering why someone is perhaps intentionally", "to my high-scored questions. But I can't see it. Although", "the time I asked the question. But the down-voter is", "my high-scored questions. But I can't see it. Although I", "not be well fitted here. But I am wondering why", "I asked the question. But the down-voter is targeting my", "questions. I would appreciate if the same down-voter gives some", "care the votes or scores at all, but still wondering", "or scores at all, but still wondering the possible reasons", "my old low-scored questions. I would appreciate if the same", "is perhaps intentionally down-voting my old low-scored questions asked here?", "is targeting my old low-scored questions. I would appreciate if", "the same down-voter gives some up-votes to my high-scored questions.", "appears at the time I asked the question. But the", "don't care the votes or scores at all, but still", "questions. But I can't see it. Although I don't care", "I am wondering why someone is perhaps intentionally down-voting my", "asked here? I wouldn't surprise if the down-votes appears at", "here? I wouldn't surprise if the down-votes appears at the", "votes or scores at all, but still wondering the possible", "the question. But the down-voter is targeting my old low-scored", "asked the question. But the down-voter is targeting my old", "appreciate if the same down-voter gives some up-votes to my", "the down-votes appears at the time I asked the question.", "But I am wondering why someone is perhaps intentionally down-voting", "old low-scored questions. I would appreciate if the same down-voter", "fitted here. But I am wondering why someone is perhaps", "intentionally down-voting my old low-scored questions asked here? I wouldn't", "Although I don't care the votes or scores at all,", "question. But the down-voter is targeting my old low-scored questions.", "the down-voter is targeting my old low-scored questions. I would", "if the down-votes appears at the time I asked the", "I don't care the votes or scores at all, but", "the votes or scores at all, but still wondering the", "down-voter gives some up-votes to my high-scored questions. But I", "old low-scored questions asked here? I wouldn't surprise if the" ]
[ "sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I think this is a stretch", "is often a very serious accusation, so I dislike that", "things that aren't actually about ethics? If so, do we", "academia, including values such as avoidance of cheating or plagiarism;", "avoidance of cheating or plagiarism; > > > Or do", "address a PhD holder as sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I", "of ethics. * [Contacting EiC on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again,", "etc. Is there a good way to handle this? I", "nice...\" 4. \"Can I be upset by X...\" 5. \"Is", "the tag itself being much less useful than it could", "miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I think this is a stretch to call", "dislike that it's being heavily diluted in terms of its", "are interesting, and a violation of academic ethics is often", "tags for things that aren't actually about ethics? If so,", "very serious accusation, so I dislike that it's being heavily", "- I think this is a stretch to call this", "PhD holder as sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I think this", "or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I think this is a stretch to", "it could be (it's currently our 12th most popular tag)", "this is a stretch to call this an \"ethics\" question.", "good way to handle this? I think actual discussions of", "I be upset by X...\" 5. \"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a", "I think it's overused to the point of the tag", "Wrzlprmft's request: * [Is it considered rude to address a", "being heavily diluted in terms of its meaning. Do we", "on this site - I think it's overused to the", "bogged down by disambiguating \"Is X ethical...\" are potentially meaning:", "ethics is often a very serious accusation, so I dislike", "current definition? > > On the moral code or ethical", "If so, do we need to fine-tune the current definition?", "ethics are interesting, and a violation of academic ethics is", "is a stretch to call this an \"ethics\" question. \"Is", "this an \"ethics\" question. \"Is this insulting?\" isn't actually a", "Again, this is far more \"Is this a bad idea?\"", "being bogged down by disambiguating \"Is X ethical...\" are potentially", "overused to the point of the tag itself being much", "individual...\" etc. Is there a good way to handle this?", "a PhD holder as sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I think", "3. \"Is X nice...\" 4. \"Can I be upset by", "consider heavily editing questions/deleting tags for things that aren't actually", "ethical...\" in the proper sense 2. \"Is X a good", "[Is it considered rude to address a PhD holder as", "being much less useful than it could be (it's currently", "plagiarism; > > > Or do we just let it", "of its meaning. Do we consider heavily editing questions/deleting tags", "* [Is it considered rude to address a PhD holder", "as sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I think this is a", "slide? Some examples, per Wrzlprmft's request: * [Is it considered", "is far more \"Is this a bad idea?\" than is", "than it could be (it's currently our 12th most popular", "(it's currently our 12th most popular tag) as well as", "itself being much less useful than it could be (it's", "Or do we just let it slide? Some examples, per", "disambiguating \"Is X ethical...\" are potentially meaning: 1. \"Is X", "the proper sense 2. \"Is X a good idea...\" 3.", "to handle this? I think actual discussions of ethics are", "less than perfect individual...\" etc. Is there a good way", "accusation, so I dislike that it's being heavily diluted in", "- I think it's overused to the point of the", "an \"ethics\" question. \"Is this insulting?\" isn't actually a matter", "question. \"Is this insulting?\" isn't actually a matter of ethics.", "think actual discussions of ethics are interesting, and a violation", "of academic ethics is often a very serious accusation, so", "* [Contacting EiC on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again, this is", "than perfect individual...\" etc. Is there a good way to", "that it's being heavily diluted in terms of its meaning.", "popular tag) as well as answers and comments being bogged", "it slide? Some examples, per Wrzlprmft's request: * [Is it", "ethics. * [Contacting EiC on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again, this", "this is far more \"Is this a bad idea?\" than", "as avoidance of cheating or plagiarism; > > > Or", "less useful than it could be (it's currently our 12th", "Is there a good way to handle this? I think", "heavily diluted in terms of its meaning. Do we consider", "my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less than perfect individual...\" etc. Is there", "a good way to handle this? I think actual discussions", "way to handle this? I think actual discussions of ethics", "- Again, this is far more \"Is this a bad", "idea...\" 3. \"Is X nice...\" 4. \"Can I be upset", "sense 2. \"Is X a good idea...\" 3. \"Is X", "a less than perfect individual...\" etc. Is there a good", "of \"ethics\" on this site - I think it's overused", "with the use of \"ethics\" on this site - I", "to the point of the tag itself being much less", "Do we consider heavily editing questions/deleting tags for things that", "of academia, including values such as avoidance of cheating or", "such as avoidance of cheating or plagiarism; > > >", "so, do we need to fine-tune the current definition? >", "> Or do we just let it slide? Some examples,", "cheating or plagiarism; > > > Or do we just", "handle this? I think actual discussions of ethics are interesting,", "proper sense 2. \"Is X a good idea...\" 3. \"Is", "social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again, this is far more \"Is this", "useful than it could be (it's currently our 12th most", "of cheating or plagiarism; > > > Or do we", "most popular tag) as well as answers and comments being", "advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less than perfect individual...\" etc. Is there a", "this site - I think it's overused to the point", "values such as avoidance of cheating or plagiarism; > >", "definition? > > On the moral code or ethical policy", "call this an \"ethics\" question. \"Is this insulting?\" isn't actually", "On the moral code or ethical policy of academia, including", "[Contacting EiC on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again, this is far", "\"Is X nice...\" 4. \"Can I be upset by X...\"", "or plagiarism; > > > Or do we just let", "meaning. Do we consider heavily editing questions/deleting tags for things", "heavily editing questions/deleting tags for things that aren't actually about", "> > Or do we just let it slide? Some", "and a violation of academic ethics is often a very", "a matter of ethics. * [Contacting EiC on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media)", "matter of ethics. * [Contacting EiC on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) -", "well as answers and comments being bogged down by disambiguating", "violation of academic ethics is often a very serious accusation,", "to fine-tune the current definition? > > On the moral", "we just let it slide? Some examples, per Wrzlprmft's request:", "just let it slide? Some examples, per Wrzlprmft's request: ", "serious accusation, so I dislike that it's being heavily diluted", "I think actual discussions of ethics are interesting, and a", "more \"Is this a bad idea?\" than is this ethical.", "stretch to call this an \"ethics\" question. \"Is this insulting?\"", "considered rude to address a PhD holder as sir or", "ethical policy of academia, including values such as avoidance of", "holder as sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) - I think this is", "moral code or ethical policy of academia, including values such", "a stretch to call this an \"ethics\" question. \"Is this", "editing questions/deleting tags for things that aren't actually about ethics?", "12th most popular tag) as well as answers and comments", "isn't actually a matter of ethics. [Contacting EiC on", "for things that aren't actually about ethics? If so, do", "in terms of its meaning. Do we consider heavily editing", "including values such as avoidance of cheating or plagiarism; >", "ethics? If so, do we need to fine-tune the current", "think this is a stretch to call this an \"ethics\"", "far more \"Is this a bad idea?\" than is this", "code or ethical policy of academia, including values such as", "our 12th most popular tag) as well as answers and", "it considered rude to address a PhD holder as sir", "this? I think actual discussions of ethics are interesting, and", "need to fine-tune the current definition? > > On the", "of the tag itself being much less useful than it", "often a very serious accusation, so I dislike that it's", "EiC on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again, this is far more", "use of \"ethics\" on this site - I think it's", "recently with the use of \"ethics\" on this site -", "this insulting?\" isn't actually a matter of ethics. * [Contacting", "request: * [Is it considered rude to address a PhD", "or ethical policy of academia, including values such as avoidance", "by X...\" 5. \"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less than perfect", "\"ethics\" question. \"Is this insulting?\" isn't actually a matter of", "down by disambiguating \"Is X ethical...\" are potentially meaning: 1.", "point of the tag itself being much less useful than", "to call this an \"ethics\" question. \"Is this insulting?\" isn't", "> > On the moral code or ethical policy of", "in the proper sense 2. \"Is X a good idea...\"", "by disambiguating \"Is X ethical...\" are potentially meaning: 1. \"Is", "could be (it's currently our 12th most popular tag) as", "X nice...\" 4. \"Can I be upset by X...\" 5.", "struggling recently with the use of \"ethics\" on this site", "currently our 12th most popular tag) as well as answers", "terms of its meaning. Do we consider heavily editing questions/deleting", "as well as answers and comments being bogged down by", "the point of the tag itself being much less useful", "\"ethics\" on this site - I think it's overused to", "comments being bogged down by disambiguating \"Is X ethical...\" are", "are potentially meaning: 1. \"Is X ethical...\" in the proper", "of ethics are interesting, and a violation of academic ethics", "that aren't actually about ethics? If so, do we need", "X ethical...\" are potentially meaning: 1. \"Is X ethical...\" in", "the current definition? > > On the moral code or", "media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again, this is far more \"Is this a", "we need to fine-tune the current definition? > > On", "X ethical...\" in the proper sense 2. \"Is X a", "actually about ethics? If so, do we need to fine-tune", "on social media](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/105557/contacting-eic-on-social-media) - Again, this is far more \"Is", "so I dislike that it's being heavily diluted in terms", "I've been struggling recently with the use of \"ethics\" on", "aren't actually about ethics? If so, do we need to", "insulting?\" isn't actually a matter of ethics. * [Contacting EiC", "academic ethics is often a very serious accusation, so I", "discussions of ethics are interesting, and a violation of academic", "as answers and comments being bogged down by disambiguating \"Is", "meaning: 1. \"Is X ethical...\" in the proper sense 2.", "actually a matter of ethics. * [Contacting EiC on social", "fine-tune the current definition? > > On the moral code", "a very serious accusation, so I dislike that it's being", "4. \"Can I be upset by X...\" 5. \"Is my", "1. \"Is X ethical...\" in the proper sense 2. \"Is", "it's being heavily diluted in terms of its meaning. Do", "it's overused to the point of the tag itself being", "we consider heavily editing questions/deleting tags for things that aren't", "to address a PhD holder as sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss) -", "Some examples, per Wrzlprmft's request: * [Is it considered rude", "tag) as well as answers and comments being bogged down", "much less useful than it could be (it's currently our", "potentially meaning: 1. \"Is X ethical...\" in the proper sense", "X a good idea...\" 3. \"Is X nice...\" 4. \"Can", "do we need to fine-tune the current definition? > >", "\"Can I be upset by X...\" 5. \"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc.", "good idea...\" 3. \"Is X nice...\" 4. \"Can I be", "diluted in terms of its meaning. Do we consider heavily", "2. \"Is X a good idea...\" 3. \"Is X nice...\"", "questions/deleting tags for things that aren't actually about ethics? If", "the moral code or ethical policy of academia, including values", "policy of academia, including values such as avoidance of cheating", "per Wrzlprmft's request: * [Is it considered rude to address", "site - I think it's overused to the point of", "I dislike that it's being heavily diluted in terms of", "upset by X...\" 5. \"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less than", "> > > Or do we just let it slide?", "rude to address a PhD holder as sir or miss?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/104867/is-it-considered-rude-to-address-a-phd-holder-as-sir-or-miss)", "I think this is a stretch to call this an", "the use of \"ethics\" on this site - I think", "> On the moral code or ethical policy of academia,", "be (it's currently our 12th most popular tag) as well", "a violation of academic ethics is often a very serious", "about ethics? If so, do we need to fine-tune the", "ethical...\" are potentially meaning: 1. \"Is X ethical...\" in the", "\"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less than perfect individual...\" etc. Is", "think it's overused to the point of the tag itself", "there a good way to handle this? I think actual", "let it slide? Some examples, per Wrzlprmft's request: * [Is", "\"Is X ethical...\" in the proper sense 2. \"Is X", "a good idea...\" 3. \"Is X nice...\" 4. \"Can I", "be upset by X...\" 5. \"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less", "X...\" 5. \"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less than perfect individual...\"", "5. \"Is my advisor/classmate/teacher/etc. a less than perfect individual...\" etc.", "\"Is X a good idea...\" 3. \"Is X nice...\" 4.", "perfect individual...\" etc. Is there a good way to handle", "been struggling recently with the use of \"ethics\" on this", "answers and comments being bogged down by disambiguating \"Is X", "examples, per Wrzlprmft's request: * [Is it considered rude to", "its meaning. Do we consider heavily editing questions/deleting tags for", "actual discussions of ethics are interesting, and a violation of", "\"Is X ethical...\" are potentially meaning: 1. \"Is X ethical...\"", "do we just let it slide? Some examples, per Wrzlprmft's", "\"Is this insulting?\" isn't actually a matter of ethics. *", "interesting, and a violation of academic ethics is often a", "and comments being bogged down by disambiguating \"Is X ethical...\"", "tag itself being much less useful than it could be" ]
[ "discussion about cranks in science, so I'm very intrigued what", "Area 51 proposal for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow the links", "you think. (Blatantly copied in parts from [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1896/openscience-and-academia-qa-sites) to", "would be interesting to learn what is the viewpoint of", "community on the following situation. [There is an Area 51", "involved in a discussion about cranks in science, so I'm", "answers to this question here. I was recently involved in", "discussion in one place, I suggest to express your opinions", "details, but to keep all discussion in one place, I", "interesting to learn what is the viewpoint of Academia.SE community", "read further details, but to keep all discussion in one", "keep all discussion in one place, I suggest to express", "in science, so I'm very intrigued what you think. (Blatantly", "to express your opinions as answers to this question here.", "Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow the links from this question to read", "one place, I suggest to express your opinions as answers", "this question to read further details, but to keep all", "Please follow the links from this question to read further", "in a discussion about cranks in science, so I'm very", "I suggest to express your opinions as answers to this", "your opinions as answers to this question here. I was", "learn what is the viewpoint of Academia.SE community on the", "the links from this question to read further details, but", "to keep all discussion in one place, I suggest to", "science, so I'm very intrigued what you think. (Blatantly copied", "[There is an Area 51 proposal for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please", "express your opinions as answers to this question here. I", "for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow the links from this question", "Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow the links from this question to", "of Academia.SE community on the following situation. [There is an", "(Blatantly copied in parts from [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1896/openscience-and-academia-qa-sites) to make sure", "cranks in science, so I'm very intrigued what you think.", "the viewpoint of Academia.SE community on the following situation. [There", "to this question here. I was recently involved in a", "further details, but to keep all discussion in one place,", "place, I suggest to express your opinions as answers to", "to read further details, but to keep all discussion in", "follow the links from this question to read further details,", "question here. I was recently involved in a discussion about", "as answers to this question here. I was recently involved", "question to read further details, but to keep all discussion", "recently involved in a discussion about cranks in science, so", "be interesting to learn what is the viewpoint of Academia.SE", "opinions as answers to this question here. I was recently", "Academia.SE community on the following situation. [There is an Area", "was recently involved in a discussion about cranks in science,", "is an Area 51 proposal for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow", "about cranks in science, so I'm very intrigued what you", "what is the viewpoint of Academia.SE community on the following", "on the following situation. [There is an Area 51 proposal", "an Area 51 proposal for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow the", "what you think. (Blatantly copied in parts from [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1896/openscience-and-academia-qa-sites)", "suggest to express your opinions as answers to this question", "is the viewpoint of Academia.SE community on the following situation.", "a discussion about cranks in science, so I'm very intrigued", "It would be interesting to learn what is the viewpoint", "51 proposal for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow the links from", "following situation. [There is an Area 51 proposal for Paranormal", "copied in parts from [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1896/openscience-and-academia-qa-sites) to make sure to", "this question here. I was recently involved in a discussion", "but to keep all discussion in one place, I suggest", "links from this question to read further details, but to", "from this question to read further details, but to keep", "parts from [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1896/openscience-and-academia-qa-sites) to make sure to stay on-topic.)", "in one place, I suggest to express your opinions as", "very intrigued what you think. (Blatantly copied in parts from", "all discussion in one place, I suggest to express your", "think. (Blatantly copied in parts from [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1896/openscience-and-academia-qa-sites) to make", "intrigued what you think. (Blatantly copied in parts from [this", "in parts from [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/1896/openscience-and-academia-qa-sites) to make sure to stay", "situation. [There is an Area 51 proposal for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal)", "so I'm very intrigued what you think. (Blatantly copied in", "I was recently involved in a discussion about cranks in", "here. I was recently involved in a discussion about cranks", "viewpoint of Academia.SE community on the following situation. [There is", "proposal for Paranormal Phenomenons.](https://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/114464/paranormal) Please follow the links from this", "I'm very intrigued what you think. (Blatantly copied in parts", "the following situation. [There is an Area 51 proposal for", "to learn what is the viewpoint of Academia.SE community on" ]
[ "out, you can download the election results [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2), or [view", "moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be joining [the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly", "for volunteering, and share your assistance and advice with them", "the votes have been tallied, and the moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734)", "been tallied, and the moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be joining", "— please thank them for volunteering, and share your assistance", "learn the ropes! For details on how the voting played", "can download the election results [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2), or [view a summary", "the moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be joining [the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators)", "Academia's [second moderator election](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2) has come to a close, the", "the ropes! For details on how the voting played out,", "[the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly — please thank them for volunteering,", "how the voting played out, you can download the election", "a close, the votes have been tallied, and the moderator", "election](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2) has come to a close, the votes have been", "shortly — please thank them for volunteering, and share your", "votes have been tallied, and the moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll", "For details on how the voting played out, you can", "details on how the voting played out, you can download", "share your assistance and advice with them as they learn", "assistance and advice with them as they learn the ropes!", "thank them for volunteering, and share your assistance and advice", "and the moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be joining [the existing", "have been tallied, and the moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be", "crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly — please thank them for volunteering, and share", "advice with them as they learn the ropes! For details", "they learn the ropes! For details on how the voting", "you can download the election results [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2), or [view a", "tallied, and the moderator is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be joining [the", "existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly — please thank them for volunteering, and", "voting played out, you can download the election results [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2),", "[![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be joining [the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly — please", "be joining [the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly — please thank them", "download the election results [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2), or [view a summary report", "with them as they learn the ropes! For details on", "the voting played out, you can download the election results", "and advice with them as they learn the ropes! For", "the election results [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2), or [view a summary report online](https://www.opavote.com/results/4963713824063488/0).", "them as they learn the ropes! For details on how", "to a close, the votes have been tallied, and the", "please thank them for volunteering, and share your assistance and", "played out, you can download the election results [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2), or", "come to a close, the votes have been tallied, and", "has come to a close, the votes have been tallied,", "ropes! For details on how the voting played out, you", "on how the voting played out, you can download the", "your assistance and advice with them as they learn the", "close, the votes have been tallied, and the moderator is:", "joining [the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly — please thank them for", "and share your assistance and advice with them as they", "moderator election](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2) has come to a close, the votes have", "as they learn the ropes! For details on how the", "[second moderator election](https://academia.stackexchange.com/election/2) has come to a close, the votes", "them for volunteering, and share your assistance and advice with", "They'll be joining [the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly — please thank", "is: [![Wrzlprmft](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/flair/7734.png)](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/7734) They'll be joining [the existing crew](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users?tab=moderators) shortly —", "volunteering, and share your assistance and advice with them as" ]
[ "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide details about what I mean and", "what is vague no answer or comment. The question is", "people handle such a detailed question in this way and", "you want. But when I asked what is unclear nobody", "or comment. The question is how to know what is", "unclear for the reason in putting this question on hold.", "comment. The question is how to know what is vague?", "is unclear nobody answered or commented. It is very strange", "a detailed question in this way and when I ask", "and even a link to the content I am talking", "for the reason in putting this question on hold. I", "what is vague? I want to know what is vague.", "the reason in putting this question on hold. I hope", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide details about what I mean and even", "the question OnHold because they say It is not clear", "way and when I ask what is vague no answer", "vague. Ironically they are unclear for the reason in putting", "about what I mean and even a link to the", "I ask what is vague no answer or comment. The", "a question. In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide details about what", "I asked what is unclear nobody answered or commented. It", "nobody answered or commented. It is very strange that some", "to know what is vague. Ironically they are unclear for", "question in this way and when I ask what is", "is not clear what you want. But when I asked", "what I mean and even a link to the content", "I mean and even a link to the content I", "asked a question. In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide details about", "what is vague. Ironically they are unclear for the reason", "say It is not clear what you want. But when", "In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide details about what I mean", "commented. It is very strange that some people handle such", "talking about. Some people put the question OnHold because they", "answered or commented. It is very strange that some people", "very strange that some people handle such a detailed question", "I am talking about. Some people put the question OnHold", "I want to know what is vague. Ironically they are", "question OnHold because they say It is not clear what", "detailed question in this way and when I ask what", "and when I ask what is vague no answer or", "to the content I am talking about. Some people put", "It is very strange that some people handle such a", "are unclear for the reason in putting this question on", "even a link to the content I am talking about.", "have asked a question. In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide details", "or commented. It is very strange that some people handle", "clear what you want. But when I asked what is", "OnHold because they say It is not clear what you", "details about what I mean and even a link to", "It is not clear what you want. But when I", "am talking about. Some people put the question OnHold because", "want to know what is vague. Ironically they are unclear", "unclear nobody answered or commented. It is very strange that", "reason in putting this question on hold. I hope somebody", "mean and even a link to the content I am", "they are unclear for the reason in putting this question", "provide details about what I mean and even a link", "question is how to know what is vague? I want", "putting this question on hold. I hope somebody will listen.", "that some people handle such a detailed question in this", "I have asked a question. In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide", "in this way and when I ask what is vague", "about. Some people put the question OnHold because they say", "because they say It is not clear what you want.", "vague no answer or comment. The question is how to", "put the question OnHold because they say It is not", "I provide details about what I mean and even a", "want. But when I asked what is unclear nobody answered", "Ironically they are unclear for the reason in putting this", "they say It is not clear what you want. But", "know what is vague? I want to know what is", "ask what is vague no answer or comment. The question", "what is unclear nobody answered or commented. It is very", "vague? I want to know what is vague. Ironically they", "But when I asked what is unclear nobody answered or", "is vague? I want to know what is vague. Ironically", "is very strange that some people handle such a detailed", "when I ask what is vague no answer or comment.", "the content I am talking about. Some people put the", "answer or comment. The question is how to know what", "not clear what you want. But when I asked what", "a link to the content I am talking about. Some", "strange that some people handle such a detailed question in", "some people handle such a detailed question in this way", "question. In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/106754/how-to-know-a-community-of-researchers-in-order-to-be-more-successful-in-researc?answertab=active#tab-top), I provide details about what I", "this way and when I ask what is vague no", "such a detailed question in this way and when I", "is vague no answer or comment. The question is how", "know what is vague. Ironically they are unclear for the", "handle such a detailed question in this way and when", "is vague. Ironically they are unclear for the reason in", "how to know what is vague? I want to know", "no answer or comment. The question is how to know", "Some people put the question OnHold because they say It", "in putting this question on hold. I hope somebody will", "content I am talking about. Some people put the question", "people put the question OnHold because they say It is", "when I asked what is unclear nobody answered or commented.", "to know what is vague? I want to know what", "link to the content I am talking about. Some people", "what you want. But when I asked what is unclear", "is how to know what is vague? I want to", "The question is how to know what is vague? I", "asked what is unclear nobody answered or commented. It is" ]
[ "deal with such questions and thus I ask: * Shall", "asking to evaluate some commercial online services: [Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734)", "deal with opinionated answers and comments, i.e., answers not focussing", "objective observations but mainly on bashing or praising the platform?", "I ask: * Shall we allow all such questions, only", "If only some, where do we draw the line? ", "into the same direction: [Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter question", "only some of them, or close them altogether? If only", "where do we draw the line? If we allow", "that I explicitly exclude services without commercial goals, such as", "explicitly exclude services without commercial goals, such as the Arxiv.)", "least one old unclosed question asking to evaluate some commercial", "useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter question in turn has attracted a controversial", "bashing or praising the platform? In my experience, it is", "no matter how objective answers the question seeks. (Note that", "questions, only some of them, or close them altogether? If", "with opinionated answers and comments, i.e., answers not focussing on", "originating from the operators of that platform. Both questions have", "to deal with such questions and thus I ask: ", "thus I ask: Shall we allow all such questions,", "we allow all or some of such questions, how shall", "in favour of questions going into the same direction: [Is", "from the operators of that platform. Both questions have received", "questions, how shall we deal with opinionated answers and comments,", "some commercial online services: [Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was cited", "question in turn has attracted a controversial answer originating from", "observations but mainly on bashing or praising the platform? In", "the question seeks. (Note that I explicitly exclude services without", "a general rule how to deal with such questions and", "how objective answers the question seeks. (Note that I explicitly", "operators of that platform. Both questions have received close votes", "how to deal with such questions and thus I ask:", "In my experience, it is almost inevitable that such posts", "latter question in turn has attracted a controversial answer originating", "I think it’s time for a general rule how to", "questions going into the same direction: [Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The", "my experience, it is almost inevitable that such posts will", "the same direction: [Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter question in", "praising the platform? In my experience, it is almost inevitable", "questions have received close votes in the past. I think", "that platform. Both questions have received close votes in the", "and thus I ask: * Shall we allow all such", "not focussing on objective observations but mainly on bashing or", "happen, no matter how objective answers the question seeks. (Note", "unclosed question asking to evaluate some commercial online services: [Is", "some of such questions, how shall we deal with opinionated", "such questions, how shall we deal with opinionated answers and", "of them, or close them altogether? If only some, where", "in turn has attracted a controversial answer originating from the", "mainly on bashing or praising the platform? In my experience,", "such questions and thus I ask: * Shall we allow", "a controversial answer originating from the operators of that platform.", "going into the same direction: [Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter", "the platform? In my experience, it is almost inevitable that", "same direction: [Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter question in turn", "matter how objective answers the question seeks. (Note that I", "opinionated answers and comments, i.e., answers not focussing on objective", "some, where do we draw the line? * If we", "question seeks. (Note that I explicitly exclude services without commercial", "the past. I think it’s time for a general rule", "them, or close them altogether? If only some, where do", "allow all or some of such questions, how shall we", "of such questions, how shall we deal with opinionated answers", "Shall we allow all such questions, only some of them,", "online services: [Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was cited in favour", "[Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter question in turn has attracted", "how shall we deal with opinionated answers and comments, i.e.,", "I explicitly exclude services without commercial goals, such as the", "answer originating from the operators of that platform. Both questions", "i.e., answers not focussing on objective observations but mainly on", "in the past. I think it’s time for a general", "answers the question seeks. (Note that I explicitly exclude services", "some of them, or close them altogether? If only some,", "on bashing or praising the platform? In my experience, it", "them altogether? If only some, where do we draw the", "we allow all such questions, only some of them, or", "time for a general rule how to deal with such", "Both questions have received close votes in the past. I", "favour of questions going into the same direction: [Is Peer.us", "experience, it is almost inevitable that such posts will happen,", "This was cited in favour of questions going into the", "close them altogether? If only some, where do we draw", "direction: [Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter question in turn has", "all such questions, only some of them, or close them", "question asking to evaluate some commercial online services: [Is Academia.edu", "altogether? If only some, where do we draw the line?", "was cited in favour of questions going into the same", "or some of such questions, how shall we deal with", "ask: * Shall we allow all such questions, only some", "* If we allow all or some of such questions,", "that such posts will happen, no matter how objective answers", "inevitable that such posts will happen, no matter how objective", "have at least one old unclosed question asking to evaluate", "evaluate some commercial online services: [Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was", "at least one old unclosed question asking to evaluate some", "shall we deal with opinionated answers and comments, i.e., answers", "is almost inevitable that such posts will happen, no matter", "all or some of such questions, how shall we deal", "of that platform. Both questions have received close votes in", "such questions, only some of them, or close them altogether?", "the line? * If we allow all or some of", "we deal with opinionated answers and comments, i.e., answers not", "[Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was cited in favour of questions", "or close them altogether? If only some, where do we", "it’s time for a general rule how to deal with", "cited in favour of questions going into the same direction:", "If we allow all or some of such questions, how", "think it’s time for a general rule how to deal", "focussing on objective observations but mainly on bashing or praising", "rule how to deal with such questions and thus I", "of questions going into the same direction: [Is Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734)", "the operators of that platform. Both questions have received close", "comments, i.e., answers not focussing on objective observations but mainly", "we draw the line? * If we allow all or", "commercial online services: [Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was cited in", "has attracted a controversial answer originating from the operators of", "with such questions and thus I ask: * Shall we", "controversial answer originating from the operators of that platform. Both", "past. I think it’s time for a general rule how", "have received close votes in the past. I think it’s", "do we draw the line? * If we allow all", "such posts will happen, no matter how objective answers the", "objective answers the question seeks. (Note that I explicitly exclude", "allow all such questions, only some of them, or close", "platform? In my experience, it is almost inevitable that such", "We have at least one old unclosed question asking to", "for a general rule how to deal with such questions", "seeks. (Note that I explicitly exclude services without commercial goals,", "services: [Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was cited in favour of", "but mainly on bashing or praising the platform? In my", "will happen, no matter how objective answers the question seeks.", "old unclosed question asking to evaluate some commercial online services:", "attracted a controversial answer originating from the operators of that", "one old unclosed question asking to evaluate some commercial online", "platform. Both questions have received close votes in the past.", "close votes in the past. I think it’s time for", "turn has attracted a controversial answer originating from the operators", "only some, where do we draw the line? * If", "it is almost inevitable that such posts will happen, no", "questions and thus I ask: * Shall we allow all", "received close votes in the past. I think it’s time", "and comments, i.e., answers not focussing on objective observations but", "posts will happen, no matter how objective answers the question", "general rule how to deal with such questions and thus", "or praising the platform? In my experience, it is almost", "answers not focussing on objective observations but mainly on bashing", "line? * If we allow all or some of such", "on objective observations but mainly on bashing or praising the", "Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was cited in favour of questions going", "The latter question in turn has attracted a controversial answer", "votes in the past. I think it’s time for a", "almost inevitable that such posts will happen, no matter how", "* Shall we allow all such questions, only some of", "Peer.us useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/106706/7734) The latter question in turn has attracted a", "answers and comments, i.e., answers not focussing on objective observations", "to evaluate some commercial online services: [Is Academia.edu useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This", "(Note that I explicitly exclude services without commercial goals, such", "draw the line? * If we allow all or some", "useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/44632/7734) This was cited in favour of questions going into" ]
[ "I think that such kind of behaviour is bad in", "to close answers it anyway to get a few more", "a while. It doesn't happen frequently but, yes, it happens:", "the site: how come that this expert user thinks that", "It confuses the questioner, especially when they are new to", "could we actively discourage it by commenting with a boilerplate", "Please, avoid answering a question you voted to close. See", "questioner, especially when they are new to the site: how", "by the system, I think that such kind of behaviour", "but the user who voted to close answers it anyway", "kind of behaviour is bad in two ways: 1. It", "user answers a question and also votes to close it.", "close answers it anyway to get a few more reputation", "votes to close it. Though not forbidden by the system,", "whatever, but the user who voted to close answers it", "also votes to close it. Though not forbidden by the", "while. It doesn't happen frequently but, yes, it happens: a", "we actively discourage it by commenting with a boilerplate comment?", "whatever and answers it anyway? 2. It might give the", "question and also votes to close it. Though not forbidden", "happen frequently but, yes, it happens: a user answers a", "anyway to get a few more reputation points. Should we", "Should we thus discourage such kind of behaviour? If yes,", "ways: 1. It confuses the questioner, especially when they are", "writing this for a while. It doesn't happen frequently but,", "to the site: how come that this expert user thinks", "Though not forbidden by the system, I think that such", "a boilerplate comment? E.g., > > Please, avoid answering a", "discourage such kind of behaviour? If yes, could we actively", "commenting with a boilerplate comment? E.g., > > Please, avoid", "it by commenting with a boilerplate comment? E.g., > >", "for a while. It doesn't happen frequently but, yes, it", "voted to close. See [this meta discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/4077/20058). > > >", "frequently but, yes, it happens: a user answers a question", "a few more reputation points. Should we thus discourage such", "the question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever, but the user who", "kind of behaviour? If yes, could we actively discourage it", "of writing this for a while. It doesn't happen frequently", "the questioner, especially when they are new to the site:", "1. It confuses the questioner, especially when they are new", "and also votes to close it. Though not forbidden by", "give the message that, yes, the question is off-topic, too-broad,", "the user who voted to close answers it anyway to", "who voted to close answers it anyway to get a", "by commenting with a boilerplate comment? E.g., > > Please,", "> > Please, avoid answering a question you voted to", "to get a few more reputation points. Should we thus", "yes, could we actively discourage it by commenting with a", "you voted to close. See [this meta discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/4077/20058). > >", "such kind of behaviour is bad in two ways: 1.", "of behaviour is bad in two ways: 1. It confuses", "avoid answering a question you voted to close. See [this", "bad in two ways: 1. It confuses the questioner, especially", "user who voted to close answers it anyway to get", "> Please, avoid answering a question you voted to close.", "but, yes, it happens: a user answers a question and", "and answers it anyway? 2. It might give the message", "get a few more reputation points. Should we thus discourage", "been thinking of writing this for a while. It doesn't", "a user answers a question and also votes to close", "off-topic, too-broad, whatever, but the user who voted to close", "that my question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever and answers it", "thinking of writing this for a while. It doesn't happen", "I've been thinking of writing this for a while. It", "the system, I think that such kind of behaviour is", "voted to close answers it anyway to get a few", "yes, it happens: a user answers a question and also", "more reputation points. Should we thus discourage such kind of", "is bad in two ways: 1. It confuses the questioner,", "is off-topic, too-broad, whatever, but the user who voted to", "behaviour? If yes, could we actively discourage it by commenting", "user thinks that my question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever and", "comment? E.g., > > Please, avoid answering a question you", "they are new to the site: how come that this", "too-broad, whatever, but the user who voted to close answers", "it happens: a user answers a question and also votes", "points. Should we thus discourage such kind of behaviour? If", "yes, the question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever, but the user", "If yes, could we actively discourage it by commenting with", "behaviour is bad in two ways: 1. It confuses the", "that such kind of behaviour is bad in two ways:", "how come that this expert user thinks that my question", "reputation points. Should we thus discourage such kind of behaviour?", "close it. Though not forbidden by the system, I think", "It doesn't happen frequently but, yes, it happens: a user", "are new to the site: how come that this expert", "of behaviour? If yes, could we actively discourage it by", "that this expert user thinks that my question is off-topic,", "answers a question and also votes to close it. Though", "E.g., > > Please, avoid answering a question you voted", "two ways: 1. It confuses the questioner, especially when they", "might give the message that, yes, the question is off-topic,", "it anyway to get a few more reputation points. Should", "that, yes, the question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever, but the", "new to the site: how come that this expert user", "system, I think that such kind of behaviour is bad", "this expert user thinks that my question is off-topic, too-broad,", "message that, yes, the question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever, but", "question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever and answers it anyway? 2.", "thus discourage such kind of behaviour? If yes, could we", "in two ways: 1. It confuses the questioner, especially when", "my question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever and answers it anyway?", "anyway? 2. It might give the message that, yes, the", "thinks that my question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever and answers", "think that such kind of behaviour is bad in two", "a question and also votes to close it. Though not", "not forbidden by the system, I think that such kind", "come that this expert user thinks that my question is", "It might give the message that, yes, the question is", "answers it anyway? 2. It might give the message that,", "2. It might give the message that, yes, the question", "is off-topic, too-broad, whatever and answers it anyway? 2. It", "the message that, yes, the question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever,", "expert user thinks that my question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever", "especially when they are new to the site: how come", "it. Though not forbidden by the system, I think that", "too-broad, whatever and answers it anyway? 2. It might give", "answering a question you voted to close. See [this meta", "with a boilerplate comment? E.g., > > Please, avoid answering", "boilerplate comment? E.g., > > Please, avoid answering a question", "doesn't happen frequently but, yes, it happens: a user answers", "to close it. Though not forbidden by the system, I", "site: how come that this expert user thinks that my", "when they are new to the site: how come that", "actively discourage it by commenting with a boilerplate comment? E.g.,", "happens: a user answers a question and also votes to", "we thus discourage such kind of behaviour? If yes, could", "answers it anyway to get a few more reputation points.", "discourage it by commenting with a boilerplate comment? E.g., >", "it anyway? 2. It might give the message that, yes,", "few more reputation points. Should we thus discourage such kind", "such kind of behaviour? If yes, could we actively discourage", "question is off-topic, too-broad, whatever, but the user who voted", "this for a while. It doesn't happen frequently but, yes,", "off-topic, too-broad, whatever and answers it anyway? 2. It might", "a question you voted to close. See [this meta discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/4077/20058).", "question you voted to close. See [this meta discussion](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/4077/20058). >", "confuses the questioner, especially when they are new to the", "forbidden by the system, I think that such kind of" ]
[ "Questions list (the network-wide list of questions in the right", "* A user that, based on her/his bio and SE", "It has been about 7 years since I last was", "number of scientific fields. From reading [another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I", "7 years since I last was in a school in", "I don't know any of the established procedures and rules", "getting over a dozen upvotes. Does this mean that this", "in the capacity of a student. Because of this, I'm", "> > as something they typically upvote and > >", "the other hand, I have no experience with Academia, so", "answers from people who are not part of the scientific", "capacity of a student. Because of this, I'm not sure", "from people who are not part of the scientific community?", "in a school in the capacity of a student. Because", "school in the capacity of a student. Because of this,", "some notable cases in the past, such perspectives has led", "However, I'm not a scientist, student, professor, teacher, researcher or", "> * Answers that seem to fall into the \"uninformed", "has led to stuff like unsolvable conjectures being solved, impossible", "experience with this, but clearly ...\") > > > as", "have acquired a small amount of rep from a couple", "and > > * Answers that seem to fall into", "I have no experience with academia, so I don't know", "typically downvote, with this answer getting over a dozen upvotes.", "Answers that seem to fall into the \"uninformed opinion\" category", "them and have acquired a small amount of rep from", "right sidebar) that I find interesting. I sometimes answer them", "wholly appropriate for me to answer these questions. On one", "On the other hand, I have no experience with Academia,", "From reading [another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have seen at least", "her/his bio and SE habitus, seems trustworthy to answer the", "> as something they typically downvote, with this answer getting", "as something they typically downvote, with this answer getting over", "no experience with academia, so I don't know any of", "me to answer these questions. On one hand, I have", "in a number of scientific fields. From reading [another meta", "being invented and generally major advances in a number of", "Network Questions list (the network-wide list of questions in the", "list of questions in the right sidebar) that I find", "this community does not want answers from people who are", "is active in Academia. On the other hand, I have", "other hand, I have no experience with Academia, so I", "I'm not sure whether it's wholly appropriate for me to", "and SE habitus, seems trustworthy to answer the question >", "something they typically upvote and > > * Answers that", "I sometimes answer them and have acquired a small amount", "these questions. On one hand, I have no experience with", "perspective from someone with a minimum of preconceptions. In some", "of preconceptions. In some notable cases in the past, such", "at least one person explicitly mention > > * A", "the past, such perspectives has led to stuff like unsolvable", "that I find interesting. I sometimes answer them and have", "someone who is active in Academia. On the other hand,", "mention > > * A user that, based on her/his", "this answer getting over a dozen upvotes. Does this mean", "might be completely inappropriate for someone who is active in", "completely inappropriate for someone who is active in Academia. On", "I might be able to provide a unique perspective from", "like unsolvable conjectures being solved, impossible machines being invented and", "they typically upvote and > > * Answers that seem", "the established procedures and rules from Academia. What I suggest", "perspectives has led to stuff like unsolvable conjectures being solved,", "so I don't know any of the established procedures and", "rep from a couple of upvotes per answer. However, I'm", "no experience with Academia, so I might be able to", "last was in a school in the capacity of a", "staffer. It has been about 7 years since I last", "has been about 7 years since I last was in", "I have no experience with Academia, so I might be", "established procedures and rules from Academia. What I suggest might", "they typically downvote, with this answer getting over a dozen", "couple of upvotes per answer. However, I'm not a scientist,", "this, but clearly ...\") > > > as something they", "professor, teacher, researcher or university staffer. It has been about", "list (the network-wide list of questions in the right sidebar)", "least one person explicitly mention > > * A user", "person explicitly mention > > * A user that, based", "the Hot Network Questions list (the network-wide list of questions", "answer getting over a dozen upvotes. Does this mean that", "suggest might be completely inappropriate for someone who is active", "who is active in Academia. On the other hand, I", "the right sidebar) that I find interesting. I sometimes answer", "being solved, impossible machines being invented and generally major advances", "see questions from this stack in the Hot Network Questions", "this, I'm not sure whether it's wholly appropriate for me", "I suggest might be completely inappropriate for someone who is", "impossible machines being invented and generally major advances in a", "for me to answer these questions. On one hand, I", "answer the question > > > as something they typically", "it's wholly appropriate for me to answer these questions. On", "that, based on her/his bio and SE habitus, seems trustworthy", "amount of rep from a couple of upvotes per answer.", "this mean that this community does not want answers from", "fields. From reading [another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have seen at", "cases in the past, such perspectives has led to stuff", "as something they typically upvote and > > * Answers", "on her/his bio and SE habitus, seems trustworthy to answer", "was in a school in the capacity of a student.", "be able to provide a unique perspective from someone with", "for someone who is active in Academia. On the other", "trustworthy to answer the question > > > as something", "rules from Academia. What I suggest might be completely inappropriate", "explicitly mention > > * A user that, based on", "to fall into the \"uninformed opinion\" category (\"I don't have", "not want answers from people who are not part of", "a small amount of rep from a couple of upvotes", "Hot Network Questions list (the network-wide list of questions in", "whether it's wholly appropriate for me to answer these questions.", "since I last was in a school in the capacity", "user that, based on her/his bio and SE habitus, seems", "that seem to fall into the \"uninformed opinion\" category (\"I", "of rep from a couple of upvotes per answer. However,", "provide a unique perspective from someone with a minimum of", "Academia. On the other hand, I have no experience with", "a school in the capacity of a student. Because of", "someone with a minimum of preconceptions. In some notable cases", "> > * Answers that seem to fall into the", "of upvotes per answer. However, I'm not a scientist, student,", "habitus, seems trustworthy to answer the question > > >", "don't have experience with this, but clearly ...\") > >", "any of the established procedures and rules from Academia. What", "conjectures being solved, impossible machines being invented and generally major", "to answer these questions. On one hand, I have no", "answer. However, I'm not a scientist, student, professor, teacher, researcher", "does not want answers from people who are not part", "of questions in the right sidebar) that I find interesting.", "not a scientist, student, professor, teacher, researcher or university staffer.", "or university staffer. It has been about 7 years since", "experience with Academia, so I might be able to provide", "> > * A user that, based on her/his bio", "the question > > > as something they typically upvote", "appropriate for me to answer these questions. On one hand,", "be completely inappropriate for someone who is active in Academia.", "from someone with a minimum of preconceptions. In some notable", "the \"uninformed opinion\" category (\"I don't have experience with this,", "about 7 years since I last was in a school", "solved, impossible machines being invented and generally major advances in", "I last was in a school in the capacity of", "from Academia. What I suggest might be completely inappropriate for", "generally major advances in a number of scientific fields. From", "been about 7 years since I last was in a", "I frequently see questions from this stack in the Hot", "questions. On one hand, I have no experience with academia,", "in the right sidebar) that I find interesting. I sometimes", "sometimes answer them and have acquired a small amount of", "of scientific fields. From reading [another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have", "inappropriate for someone who is active in Academia. On the", "with this answer getting over a dozen upvotes. Does this", "with this, but clearly ...\") > > > as something", "upvote and > > * Answers that seem to fall", "I'm not a scientist, student, professor, teacher, researcher or university", "from a couple of upvotes per answer. However, I'm not", "(the network-wide list of questions in the right sidebar) that", "student. Because of this, I'm not sure whether it's wholly", "with a minimum of preconceptions. In some notable cases in", "minimum of preconceptions. In some notable cases in the past,", "fall into the \"uninformed opinion\" category (\"I don't have experience", "into the \"uninformed opinion\" category (\"I don't have experience with", "with Academia, so I might be able to provide a", "category (\"I don't have experience with this, but clearly ...\")", "clearly ...\") > > > as something they typically downvote,", "invented and generally major advances in a number of scientific", "opinion\" category (\"I don't have experience with this, but clearly", "notable cases in the past, such perspectives has led to", "hand, I have no experience with academia, so I don't", "procedures and rules from Academia. What I suggest might be", "> > > as something they typically downvote, with this", "past, such perspectives has led to stuff like unsolvable conjectures", "scientific fields. From reading [another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have seen", "from this stack in the Hot Network Questions list (the", "years since I last was in a school in the", "network-wide list of questions in the right sidebar) that I", "stuff like unsolvable conjectures being solved, impossible machines being invented", "I find interesting. I sometimes answer them and have acquired", "a student. Because of this, I'm not sure whether it's", "student, professor, teacher, researcher or university staffer. It has been", "seems trustworthy to answer the question > > > as", "experience with academia, so I don't know any of the", "mean that this community does not want answers from people", "university staffer. It has been about 7 years since I", "something they typically downvote, with this answer getting over a", "[another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have seen at least one person", "stack in the Hot Network Questions list (the network-wide list", "to stuff like unsolvable conjectures being solved, impossible machines being", "that this community does not want answers from people who", "reading [another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have seen at least one", "find interesting. I sometimes answer them and have acquired a", "unsolvable conjectures being solved, impossible machines being invented and generally", "in Academia. On the other hand, I have no experience", "(\"I don't have experience with this, but clearly ...\") >", "interesting. I sometimes answer them and have acquired a small", "active in Academia. On the other hand, I have no", "know any of the established procedures and rules from Academia.", "and generally major advances in a number of scientific fields.", "scientist, student, professor, teacher, researcher or university staffer. It has", "one hand, I have no experience with academia, so I", "hand, I have no experience with Academia, so I might", "of this, I'm not sure whether it's wholly appropriate for", "and rules from Academia. What I suggest might be completely", "to provide a unique perspective from someone with a minimum", "academia, so I don't know any of the established procedures", "preconceptions. In some notable cases in the past, such perspectives", "A user that, based on her/his bio and SE habitus,", "might be able to provide a unique perspective from someone", "have experience with this, but clearly ...\") > > >", "answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have seen at least one person explicitly mention", "> * A user that, based on her/his bio and", "downvote, with this answer getting over a dozen upvotes. Does", "community does not want answers from people who are not", "in the Hot Network Questions list (the network-wide list of", "dozen upvotes. Does this mean that this community does not", "seen at least one person explicitly mention > > ", "seem to fall into the \"uninformed opinion\" category (\"I don't", " Answers that seem to fall into the \"uninformed opinion\"", "bio and SE habitus, seems trustworthy to answer the question", "one person explicitly mention > > * A user that,", "Because of this, I'm not sure whether it's wholly appropriate", "able to provide a unique perspective from someone with a", "based on her/his bio and SE habitus, seems trustworthy to", "teacher, researcher or university staffer. It has been about 7", "sure whether it's wholly appropriate for me to answer these", "but clearly ...\") > > > as something they typically", "researcher or university staffer. It has been about 7 years", "acquired a small amount of rep from a couple of", "so I might be able to provide a unique perspective", "answer these questions. On one hand, I have no experience", "sidebar) that I find interesting. I sometimes answer them and", "have seen at least one person explicitly mention > >", "> > > as something they typically upvote and >", "> as something they typically upvote and > > ", "a couple of upvotes per answer. However, I'm not a", "and have acquired a small amount of rep from a", "a dozen upvotes. Does this mean that this community does", "this stack in the Hot Network Questions list (the network-wide", "small amount of rep from a couple of upvotes per", "not sure whether it's wholly appropriate for me to answer", "Academia. What I suggest might be completely inappropriate for someone", "a number of scientific fields. From reading [another meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593),", "advances in a number of scientific fields. From reading [another", "In some notable cases in the past, such perspectives has", "in the past, such perspectives has led to stuff like", "have no experience with Academia, so I might be able", "typically upvote and > > Answers that seem to", "On one hand, I have no experience with academia, so", "of the established procedures and rules from Academia. What I", "a scientist, student, professor, teacher, researcher or university staffer. It", "upvotes per answer. However, I'm not a scientist, student, professor,", "upvotes. Does this mean that this community does not want", "have no experience with academia, so I don't know any", "such perspectives has led to stuff like unsolvable conjectures being", "SE habitus, seems trustworthy to answer the question > >", "I have seen at least one person explicitly mention >", "question > > > as something they typically upvote and", "frequently see questions from this stack in the Hot Network", "over a dozen upvotes. Does this mean that this community", "to answer the question > > > as something they", "led to stuff like unsolvable conjectures being solved, impossible machines", "...\") > > > as something they typically downvote, with", "want answers from people who are not part of the", "with academia, so I don't know any of the established", "\"uninformed opinion\" category (\"I don't have experience with this, but", "Does this mean that this community does not want answers", "Academia, so I might be able to provide a unique", "answer them and have acquired a small amount of rep", "a unique perspective from someone with a minimum of preconceptions.", "a minimum of preconceptions. In some notable cases in the", "> > as something they typically downvote, with this answer", "unique perspective from someone with a minimum of preconceptions. In", "machines being invented and generally major advances in a number", "major advances in a number of scientific fields. From reading", "meta answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/1545/11593), I have seen at least one person explicitly", "What I suggest might be completely inappropriate for someone who", "per answer. However, I'm not a scientist, student, professor, teacher,", "questions in the right sidebar) that I find interesting. I", "don't know any of the established procedures and rules from", "of a student. Because of this, I'm not sure whether", "questions from this stack in the Hot Network Questions list", "the capacity of a student. Because of this, I'm not" ]
[ "didn't show up in MathOverflow. To get rid of it,", "access to the microphone. How do I know this website", "duck should go or at least be presented in a", "has relinquished this access after I dismissed the duck? I", "know this website has relinquished this access after I dismissed", "the duck should go or at least be presented in", "think the duck should go or at least be presented", "but it didn't show up in MathOverflow. To get rid", "microphone. How do I know this website has relinquished this", "I had to click on it which involved giving it", "should go or at least be presented in a more", "which involved giving it access to the microphone. How do", "it didn't show up in MathOverflow. To get rid of", "how unique it is to Academia.SE but it didn't show", "after I dismissed the duck? I think the duck should", "on it which involved giving it access to the microphone.", "do I know this website has relinquished this access after", "I know this website has relinquished this access after I", "involved giving it access to the microphone. How do I", "access after I dismissed the duck? I think the duck", "How do I know this website has relinquished this access", "unique it is to Academia.SE but it didn't show up", "Not sure how unique it is to Academia.SE but it", "To get rid of it, I had to click on", "to click on it which involved giving it access to", "it which involved giving it access to the microphone. How", "presented in a more informed way, with opt-in, not opt-out.", "get rid of it, I had to click on it", "go or at least be presented in a more informed", "of it, I had to click on it which involved", "to the microphone. How do I know this website has", "be presented in a more informed way, with opt-in, not", "it is to Academia.SE but it didn't show up in", "at least be presented in a more informed way, with", "the microphone. How do I know this website has relinquished", "up in MathOverflow. To get rid of it, I had", "to Academia.SE but it didn't show up in MathOverflow. To", "sure how unique it is to Academia.SE but it didn't", "or at least be presented in a more informed way,", "rid of it, I had to click on it which", "show up in MathOverflow. To get rid of it, I", "had to click on it which involved giving it access", "website has relinquished this access after I dismissed the duck?", "the duck? I think the duck should go or at", "click on it which involved giving it access to the", "this website has relinquished this access after I dismissed the", "relinquished this access after I dismissed the duck? I think", "in MathOverflow. To get rid of it, I had to", "giving it access to the microphone. How do I know", "I think the duck should go or at least be", "MathOverflow. To get rid of it, I had to click", "I dismissed the duck? I think the duck should go", "dismissed the duck? I think the duck should go or", "it, I had to click on it which involved giving", "is to Academia.SE but it didn't show up in MathOverflow.", "Academia.SE but it didn't show up in MathOverflow. To get", "it access to the microphone. How do I know this", "least be presented in a more informed way, with opt-in,", "duck? I think the duck should go or at least", "this access after I dismissed the duck? I think the" ]
[ "are some kind of sanctified emperors and you need to", "me as so trivial that the simple answer to all", "my humble opinion, it would be a good idea to", "opinion, it would be a good idea to either close", "is unclear why any special advice would be required. There", "that professors are some kind of sanctified emperors and you", "person, usually a professor. Often the enquiry is a basic", "communicate with academics. The implicit premise in these questions seems", "would be required. There are many examples of this, but", "assistance with basic communication skills. In such cases, we can", "experiences who need assistance with basic communication skills. In such", "I ask a professor about funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) * [Politely", "met briefly about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) * [How to tell a", "presence or sending them an email. Answers often give some", "need to ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up: Two answers have raised", "the view that some special advice is needed to speak", "about basic human communication. If not considered off-topic, are they", "questions come out of a sense of nervousness that students,", "usually a professor. Often the enquiry is a basic one", "words to use, etc., and this is a good attempt", "students, etc., have when they want to communicate with academics.", "me as having minimal to no academic content, and the", "thank a potential supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is it rude", "how to talk to or email the contact person, usually", "of this, but here are a few of them: ", "form off-topic? They strike me as having minimal to no", "the OP is essentially just asking about basic human communication.", "important question that I need to ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up:", "professors are some kind of sanctified emperors and you need", "of reinforcing the view that some special advice is needed", "the simple answer to all these questions is: you tell/ask", "or sending them an email. Answers often give some help", "class of questions where the OP seeks advice on basic", "normal administrative matters, with no special issue that makes it", "about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) * [How to tell a Prof you", "asking about basic human communication. If not considered off-topic, are", "academic matters, and instead ask trivial questions about how to", "it rude to tell my professor about my other admissions?", "question of this kind is answered by [this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1),", "one involving normal administrative matters, with no special issue that", "them rather annoying, since they lack any real substantive content", "question, and this is desirable. In my humble opinion, it", "admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) * [Phone contact after no response from scientific", "and the OP is essentially just asking about basic human", "an email. Answers often give some help with forms of", "that I need to ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up: Two answers", "ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up: Two answers have raised the possibility", "are many examples of this, but here are a few", "on academia.SE where the OP has some basic inquiry to", "basic human communication with a professor. I have seen many", "come from questioners with different cultural experiences who need assistance", "a potential supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is it rude to", "possibility that questions of this sort might come from questioners", "but it has the side-effect of reinforcing the view that", "sending them an email. Answers often give some help with", "to help, but it has the side-effect of reinforcing the", "I have seen many many question on academia.SE where the", "e-mail a professor I met briefly about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) ", "that thing you want to tell/ask them. Some of these", "strike me as so trivial that the simple answer to", "have when they want to communicate with academics. The implicit", "with no special issue that makes it especially difficult or", "advice is needed to speak to an academic. My question:", "to stress its point, but it concerns a class of", "my professor about my other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) * [Phone contact", "who need assistance with basic communication skills. In such cases,", "to communicate with academics. The implicit premise in these questions", "Answers often give some help with forms of words to", "OP seeks advice on basic human communication with a professor.", "enquiry is a basic one involving normal administrative matters, with", "program at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) * [how can I ask a", "every question of this kind is answered by [this general", "academics. The implicit premise in these questions seems to be", "to seek detailed advice on etiquette before speaking in their", "collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have not seen questions this basic on other", "of questions where the OP seeks advice on basic human", "since they lack any real substantive content on academic matters,", "rude to tell my professor about my other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1)", "and this is desirable. In my humble opinion, it would", "the side-effect of reinforcing the view that some special advice", "communication. If not considered off-topic, are they merely trivial duplicates", "not seen questions this basic on other SE forums. I", "is seeking advice about how to talk to or email", "in these questions seems to be that professors are some", "with academics. The implicit premise in these questions seems to", "humble opinion, it would be a good idea to either", "of a sense of nervousness that students, etc., have when", "has some basic inquiry to make and is seeking advice", "a good idea to either close or mark-as-duplicate all questions", "makes it especially difficult or arduous, and it is unclear", "seek detailed advice on etiquette before speaking in their presence", "about how to undertake basic human communication. Pretty much every", "have not seen questions this basic on other SE forums.", "no response from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have not seen questions", "to talk to or email the contact person, usually a", "no special issue that makes it especially difficult or arduous,", "other SE forums. I find them rather annoying, since they", "them: * [How to effectively e-mail a professor I met", "I find them rather annoying, since they lack any real", "want to communicate with academics. The implicit premise in these", "to use, etc., and this is a good attempt to", "out of a sense of nervousness that students, etc., have", "be that professors are some kind of sanctified emperors and", "[How to tell a Prof you are no longer applying", "speak to an academic. My question: Are questions of this", "sense of nervousness that students, etc., have when they want", "to an academic. My question: Are questions of this form", "many examples of this, but here are a few of", "question exaggerates a bit to stress its point, but it", "professor about my other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) * [Phone contact after", "of this sort might come from questioners with different cultural", "off-topic? They strike me as having minimal to no academic", "sort might come from questioners with different cultural experiences who", "it has the side-effect of reinforcing the view that some", "you tell/ask them that thing you want to tell/ask them.", "you are no longer applying to a PhD program at", "by [this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most of them strike me", "seeking advice about how to talk to or email the", "briefly about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) * [How to tell a Prof", "to a PhD program at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) * [how can", "thing you want to tell/ask them. Some of these questions", "their presence or sending them an email. Answers often give", "ask a professor about my application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) [How", "the enquiry is a basic one involving normal administrative matters,", "reinforcing the view that some special advice is needed to", "forums. I find them rather annoying, since they lack any", "questions is: you tell/ask them that thing you want to", "and instead ask trivial questions about how to undertake basic", "from questioners with different cultural experiences who need assistance with", "at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) [how can I ask a professor", "on basic human communication with a professor. I have seen", "about funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) * [Politely ask a professor about", "of [How should I phrase an important question that I", "his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) * [how can I ask a professor about", "a bit to stress its point, but it concerns a", "the possibility that questions of this sort might come from", "Pretty much every question of this kind is answered by", "where the OP seeks advice on basic human communication with", "the OP seeks advice on basic human communication with a", "of sanctified emperors and you need to seek detailed advice", "I phrase an important question that I need to ask", "as duplicates of that general question, and this is desirable.", "PhD program at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) * [how can I ask", "just asking about basic human communication. If not considered off-topic,", "them strike me as so trivial that the simple answer", "many many question on academia.SE where the OP has some", "this kind. I suspect that many of these questions come", "difficult or arduous, and it is unclear why any special", "that many of these questions come out of a sense", "tell a Prof you are no longer applying to a", "here are a few of them: * [How to effectively", "about my application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) * [How to thank a", "questioners with different cultural experiences who need assistance with basic", "needed to speak to an academic. My question: Are questions", "suspect that many of these questions come out of a", "some basic inquiry to make and is seeking advice about", "contact person, usually a professor. Often the enquiry is a", "question that I need to ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up: Two", "questions are already marked as duplicates of that general question,", "a Prof you are no longer applying to a PhD", "Often the enquiry is a basic one involving normal administrative", "university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) * [how can I ask a professor about funding", "to thank a potential supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is it", "other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) * [Phone contact after no response from", "[duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is it rude to tell my professor about", "how to undertake basic human communication. Pretty much every question", "duplicates of that general question, and this is desirable. In", "inquiry to make and is seeking advice about how to", "these questions is: you tell/ask them that thing you want", "be required. There are many examples of this, but here", "general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most of them strike me as so", "academic content, and the OP is essentially just asking about", "work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) [How to tell a Prof you are no", "after no response from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have not seen", "potential supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is it rude to tell", "[this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most of them strike me as", "arduous, and it is unclear why any special advice would", "it especially difficult or arduous, and it is unclear why", "my question exaggerates a bit to stress its point, but", "substantive content on academic matters, and instead ask trivial questions", "should I phrase an important question that I need to", "annoying, since they lack any real substantive content on academic", "point, but it concerns a class of questions where the", "often give some help with forms of words to use,", "questions this basic on other SE forums. I find them", "to or email the contact person, usually a professor. Often", "or arduous, and it is unclear why any special advice", "to no academic content, and the OP is essentially just", "a professor I met briefly about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) * [How", "of these questions come out of a sense of nervousness", "collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) * [How to tell a Prof you are", "that students, etc., have when they want to communicate with", "premise in these questions seems to be that professors are", "as so trivial that the simple answer to all these", "is answered by [this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most of them", "a professor. I have seen many many question on academia.SE", "on etiquette before speaking in their presence or sending them", "of words to use, etc., and this is a good", "have raised the possibility that questions of this sort might", "it would be a good idea to either close or", "to tell/ask them. Some of these questions are already marked", "many of these questions come out of a sense of", "of my question exaggerates a bit to stress its point,", "this kind is answered by [this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most", "are they merely trivial duplicates of [How should I phrase", "etiquette before speaking in their presence or sending them an", "The title of my question exaggerates a bit to stress", "with a professor. I have seen many many question on", "that questions of this sort might come from questioners with", "etc., have when they want to communicate with academics. The", "that some special advice is needed to speak to an", "If not considered off-topic, are they merely trivial duplicates of", "seems to be that professors are some kind of sanctified", "professor I met briefly about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) [How to", "of them strike me as so trivial that the simple", "from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have not seen questions this basic", "of this kind is answered by [this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but", "nervousness that students, etc., have when they want to communicate", "supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is it rude to tell my", "them an email. Answers often give some help with forms", "side-effect of reinforcing the view that some special advice is", "They strike me as having minimal to no academic content,", "email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is it rude to tell my professor", "a PhD program at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) * [how can I", "sanctified emperors and you need to seek detailed advice on", "or email the contact person, usually a professor. Often the", "so trivial that the simple answer to all these questions", "of nervousness that students, etc., have when they want to", "contact after no response from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have not", "merely trivial duplicates of [How should I phrase an important", "communication with a professor. I have seen many many question", "and you need to seek detailed advice on etiquette before", "SE forums. I find them rather annoying, since they lack", "find them rather annoying, since they lack any real substantive", "with basic communication skills. In such cases, we can also", "a basic one involving normal administrative matters, with no special", "strike me as having minimal to no academic content, and", "matters, and instead ask trivial questions about how to undertake", "about my other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) * [Phone contact after no", "examples of this, but here are a few of them:", "when they want to communicate with academics. The implicit premise", "many question on academia.SE where the OP has some basic", "help, but it has the side-effect of reinforcing the view", "tell/ask them that thing you want to tell/ask them. Some", "concerns a class of questions where the OP seeks advice", "bit to stress its point, but it concerns a class", "of them: [How to effectively e-mail a professor I", "undertake basic human communication. Pretty much every question of this", "can I ask a professor about funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) ", "is a good attempt to help, but it has the", "trivial questions about how to undertake basic human communication. Pretty", "[Politely ask a professor about my application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) ", "an important question that I need to ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1)", "email. Answers often give some help with forms of words", "as having minimal to no academic content, and the OP", "professor. Often the enquiry is a basic one involving normal", "issue that makes it especially difficult or arduous, and it", "this, but here are a few of them: * [How", "idea to either close or mark-as-duplicate all questions of this", "before speaking in their presence or sending them an email.", "why any special advice would be required. There are many", "you need to seek detailed advice on etiquette before speaking", "[How to thank a potential supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) * [Is", "good attempt to help, but it has the side-effect of", "advice about how to talk to or email the contact", "might come from questioners with different cultural experiences who need", "these questions seems to be that professors are some kind", "emperors and you need to seek detailed advice on etiquette", "basic human communication. If not considered off-topic, are they merely", "kind of sanctified emperors and you need to seek detailed", "mark-as-duplicate all questions of this kind. I suspect that many", "title of my question exaggerates a bit to stress its", "human communication with a professor. I have seen many many", "no longer applying to a PhD program at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1)", "implicit premise in these questions seems to be that professors", "they lack any real substantive content on academic matters, and", "longer applying to a PhD program at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) ", "professor. I have seen many many question on academia.SE where", "on academic matters, and instead ask trivial questions about how", "all questions of this kind. I suspect that many of", "some special advice is needed to speak to an academic.", "basic one involving normal administrative matters, with no special issue", "having minimal to no academic content, and the OP is", " [Phone contact after no response from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I", "In my humble opinion, it would be a good idea", "and is seeking advice about how to talk to or", "and this is a good attempt to help, but it", "content on academic matters, and instead ask trivial questions about", "on other SE forums. I find them rather annoying, since", "these questions are already marked as duplicates of that general", "the contact person, usually a professor. Often the enquiry is", "want to tell/ask them. Some of these questions are already", "some kind of sanctified emperors and you need to seek", "off-topic, are they merely trivial duplicates of [How should I", "a few of them: [How to effectively e-mail a", "detailed advice on etiquette before speaking in their presence or", "Some of these questions are already marked as duplicates of", "answer to all these questions is: you tell/ask them that", "its point, but it concerns a class of questions where", "an academic. My question:* Are questions of this form off-topic?", "human communication. If not considered off-topic, are they merely trivial", "and it is unclear why any special advice would be", "etc., and this is a good attempt to help, but", "I suspect that many of these questions come out of", "instead ask trivial questions about how to undertake basic human", "help with forms of words to use, etc., and this", "no academic content, and the OP is essentially just asking", "lack any real substantive content on academic matters, and instead", "that general question, and this is desirable. In my humble", "is essentially just asking about basic human communication. If not", "ask trivial questions about how to undertake basic human communication.", "[How should I phrase an important question that I need", "that makes it especially difficult or arduous, and it is", "with forms of words to use, etc., and this is", "OP is essentially just asking about basic human communication. If", "of this form off-topic? They strike me as having minimal", "unclear why any special advice would be required. There are", "* [Politely ask a professor about my application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1)", "basic communication skills. In such cases, we can also refer", "good idea to either close or mark-as-duplicate all questions of", "it concerns a class of questions where the OP seeks", "questions of this sort might come from questioners with different", "tell/ask them. Some of these questions are already marked as", "duplicates of [How should I phrase an important question that", "effectively e-mail a professor I met briefly about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work)", "There are many examples of this, but here are a", "would be a good idea to either close or mark-as-duplicate", "speaking in their presence or sending them an email. Answers", "[duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) [How to thank a potential supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1)", "use, etc., and this is a good attempt to help,", "answers have raised the possibility that questions of this sort", "questions of this kind. I suspect that many of these", "involving normal administrative matters, with no special issue that makes", "about how to talk to or email the contact person,", "to tell a Prof you are no longer applying to", "where the OP has some basic inquiry to make and", "all these questions is: you tell/ask them that thing you", "talk to or email the contact person, usually a professor.", "[closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) [Phone contact after no response from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator)", "a sense of nervousness that students, etc., have when they", "few of them: * [How to effectively e-mail a professor", "that the simple answer to all these questions is: you", " [How to effectively e-mail a professor I met briefly", "some help with forms of words to use, etc., and", "give some help with forms of words to use, etc.,", "this is desirable. In my humble opinion, it would be", "OP has some basic inquiry to make and is seeking", "already marked as duplicates of that general question, and this", "professor about my application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) * [How to thank", "phrase an important question that I need to ask a", "kind. I suspect that many of these questions come out", "of that general question, and this is desirable. In my", "[Is it rude to tell my professor about my other", "[how can I ask a professor about funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master)", "not considered off-topic, are they merely trivial duplicates of [How", "in their presence or sending them an email. Answers often", "[How to effectively e-mail a professor I met briefly about", "professor about funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) * [Politely ask a professor", "I have not seen questions this basic on other SE", "questions seems to be that professors are some kind of", "to either close or mark-as-duplicate all questions of this kind.", "seeks advice on basic human communication with a professor. I", "kind is answered by [this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most of", "to speak to an academic. My question: Are questions of", "to undertake basic human communication. Pretty much every question of", "my other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) * [Phone contact after no response", "advice on basic human communication with a professor. I have", "the OP has some basic inquiry to make and is", "advice on etiquette before speaking in their presence or sending", "essentially just asking about basic human communication. If not considered", "simple answer to all these questions is: you tell/ask them", "communication skills. In such cases, we can also refer questions", "of these questions are already marked as duplicates of that", "questions about how to undertake basic human communication. Pretty much", "seen many many question on academia.SE where the OP has", "especially difficult or arduous, and it is unclear why any", "this basic on other SE forums. I find them rather", "Prof you are no longer applying to a PhD program", "are no longer applying to a PhD program at his", "is desirable. In my humble opinion, it would be a", "The implicit premise in these questions seems to be that", "but it concerns a class of questions where the OP", "are a few of them: [How to effectively e-mail", "view that some special advice is needed to speak to", "[Phone contact after no response from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have", "trivial that the simple answer to all these questions is:", "I need to ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up: Two answers have", "my application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) * [How to thank a potential", "they merely trivial duplicates of [How should I phrase an", "minimal to no academic content, and the OP is essentially", "them. Some of these questions are already marked as duplicates", "most of them strike me as so trivial that the", "professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up:* Two answers have raised the possibility that questions", "but most of them strike me as so trivial that", "a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up: Two answers have raised the possibility that", "make and is seeking advice about how to talk to", "have seen many many question on academia.SE where the OP", "either close or mark-as-duplicate all questions of this kind. I", "forms of words to use, etc., and this is a", "this is a good attempt to help, but it has", "it is unclear why any special advice would be required.", "* [how can I ask a professor about funding for", "academic. My question: Are questions of this form off-topic? They", "but here are a few of them: * [How to", "with different cultural experiences who need assistance with basic communication", "human communication. Pretty much every question of this kind is", "them that thing you want to tell/ask them. Some of", "are already marked as duplicates of that general question, and", "communication. Pretty much every question of this kind is answered", "a professor about funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) [Politely ask a", "questions of this form off-topic? They strike me as having", "any special advice would be required. There are many examples", "basic inquiry to make and is seeking advice about how", "matters, with no special issue that makes it especially difficult", "advice would be required. There are many examples of this,", "general question, and this is desirable. In my humble opinion,", "In such cases, we can also refer questions to [InterpersonalSkills.SE](https://interpersonal.stackexchange.com/).", "desirable. In my humble opinion, it would be a good", "is: you tell/ask them that thing you want to tell/ask", "close or mark-as-duplicate all questions of this kind. I suspect", "need assistance with basic communication skills. In such cases, we", "status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) [How to thank a potential supervisor's email?", "master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) * [Politely ask a professor about my application status", "considered off-topic, are they merely trivial duplicates of [How should", "basic human communication. Pretty much every question of this kind", "Are questions of this form off-topic? They strike me as", "is needed to speak to an academic. My question: Are", "any real substantive content on academic matters, and instead ask", "academia.SE where the OP has some basic inquiry to make", "Two answers have raised the possibility that questions of this", "question:** Are questions of this form off-topic? They strike me", "stress its point, but it concerns a class of questions", "you want to tell/ask them. Some of these questions are", "of this kind. I suspect that many of these questions", "ask a professor about funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) [Politely ask", "these questions come out of a sense of nervousness that", "funding for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) * [Politely ask a professor about my", "this form off-topic? They strike me as having minimal to", "required. There are many examples of this, but here are", "scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have not seen questions this basic on", "this sort might come from questioners with different cultural experiences", "I met briefly about collaborative work?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/108710/how-to-effectively-e-mail-a-professor-i-met-briefly-about-collaborative-work) * [How to tell", "or mark-as-duplicate all questions of this kind. I suspect that", "a professor. Often the enquiry is a basic one involving", "much every question of this kind is answered by [this", "email the contact person, usually a professor. Often the enquiry", "to tell my professor about my other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) ", "raised the possibility that questions of this sort might come", "to effectively e-mail a professor I met briefly about collaborative", "rather annoying, since they lack any real substantive content on", "to be that professors are some kind of sanctified emperors", "different cultural experiences who need assistance with basic communication skills.", "administrative matters, with no special issue that makes it especially", " [How to thank a potential supervisor's email? [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/100829/how-to-thank-a-potential-supervisors-email?noredirect=1&lq=1) ", "special advice is needed to speak to an academic. My", "exaggerates a bit to stress its point, but it concerns", "content, and the OP is essentially just asking about basic", "response from scientific collaborator?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/62814/phone-contact-after-no-response-from-scientific-collaborator) I have not seen questions this", "to all these questions is: you tell/ask them that thing", "a class of questions where the OP seeks advice on", "special advice would be required. There are many examples of", "application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) * [How to thank a potential supervisor's", "for master!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90136/how-can-i-ask-a-professor-about-funding-for-master) * [Politely ask a professor about my application", "seen questions this basic on other SE forums. I find", "applying to a PhD program at his university?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/99183/how-to-tell-a-prof-you-are-no-longer-applying-to-a-phd-program-at-his-university?rq=1) * [how", "need to seek detailed advice on etiquette before speaking in", "basic on other SE forums. I find them rather annoying,", "* [How to tell a Prof you are no longer", "real substantive content on academic matters, and instead ask trivial", "* [Is it rude to tell my professor about my", "to ask a professor?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1) Follow-up: Two answers have raised the", "a professor about my application status [duplicate]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/86303/politely-ask-a-professor-about-my-application-status?rq=1) * [How to", "to make and is seeking advice about how to talk", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most of them strike me as so trivial", "questions where the OP seeks advice on basic human communication", "they want to communicate with academics. The implicit premise in", "be a good idea to either close or mark-as-duplicate all", "question on academia.SE where the OP has some basic inquiry", "tell my professor about my other admissions? [closed]](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90483/is-it-rude-to-tell-my-professor-about-my-other-admissions?rq=1) * [Phone", "a good attempt to help, but it has the side-effect", "answered by [this general question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/90725/how-should-i-phrase-an-important-question-that-i-need-to-ask-a-professor?noredirect=1&lq=1), but most of them strike", "skills. In such cases, we can also refer questions to", "Follow-up: Two answers have raised the possibility that questions of", "is a basic one involving normal administrative matters, with no", "special issue that makes it especially difficult or arduous, and", "has the side-effect of reinforcing the view that some special", "come out of a sense of nervousness that students, etc.,", "marked as duplicates of that general question, and this is", "trivial duplicates of [How should I phrase an important question", "attempt to help, but it has the side-effect of reinforcing", "cultural experiences who need assistance with basic communication skills. In", "My question: Are questions of this form off-topic? They strike" ]
[ "with dense source of data on Indian academia (career, education,", "academia, might allow having source for local data on the", "other sites. Sites related to academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this", "Sites related to academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this one) seem", "for indian academia, might allow having source for local data", "(career, education, research education questions) in reddit or in other", "to be more general, and non-local. This new subreddit for", "Indian academia (career, education, research education questions) in reddit or", "on Indian academia (career, education, research education questions) in reddit", "or in other sites. Sites related to academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>,", "(like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this one) seem to be more general,", "I haven't found a subreddit with dense source of data", "local data on the indian academy. Here is the link", "be more general, and non-local. This new subreddit for indian", "a subreddit with dense source of data on Indian academia", "one) seem to be more general, and non-local. This new", "this one) seem to be more general, and non-local. This", "and non-local. This new subreddit for indian academia, might allow", "more general, and non-local. This new subreddit for indian academia,", "having source for local data on the indian academy. Here", "academia (career, education, research education questions) in reddit or in", "data on the indian academy. Here is the link to", "for local data on the indian academy. Here is the", "source for local data on the indian academy. Here is", "subreddit with dense source of data on Indian academia (career,", "the indian academy. Here is the link to it: <https://www.reddit.com/r/Indian_Academia/>", "i.e. this one) seem to be more general, and non-local.", "subreddit for indian academia, might allow having source for local", "might allow having source for local data on the indian", "This new subreddit for indian academia, might allow having source", "allow having source for local data on the indian academy.", "found a subreddit with dense source of data on Indian", "in other sites. Sites related to academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e.", "questions) in reddit or in other sites. Sites related to", "research education questions) in reddit or in other sites. Sites", "haven't found a subreddit with dense source of data on", "on the indian academy. Here is the link to it:", "to academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this one) seem to be", "seem to be more general, and non-local. This new subreddit", "dense source of data on Indian academia (career, education, research", "general, and non-local. This new subreddit for indian academia, might", "data on Indian academia (career, education, research education questions) in", "education questions) in reddit or in other sites. Sites related", "new subreddit for indian academia, might allow having source for", "in reddit or in other sites. Sites related to academy", "reddit or in other sites. Sites related to academy (like", "of data on Indian academia (career, education, research education questions)", "related to academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this one) seem to", "non-local. This new subreddit for indian academia, might allow having", "sites. Sites related to academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this one)", "indian academia, might allow having source for local data on", "education, research education questions) in reddit or in other sites.", "source of data on Indian academia (career, education, research education", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this one) seem to be more general, and", "academy (like <https://academia.stackexchange.com/>, i.e. this one) seem to be more" ]
[ "question if possible, or be a clear explanation of what's", "possible, or be a clear explanation of what's wrong. Are", "for how we can implement this initiative here on Academia.SE?", "does seem appropriate that we do a better job explaining", "I believe it is worthwhile for us to explore what", "appropriate that we do a better job explaining why we", "issues with questions that are posted in a way that", "be nice.\" However, it does seem appropriate that we do", "what's wrong. Are there any other suggestions for how we", "nice.\" However, it does seem appropriate that we do a", "However, it does seem appropriate that we do a better", "believe it is worthwhile for us to explore what we", "a clear explanation of what's wrong. Are there any other", "help new visitors ease into the site. While I do", "Are there any other suggestions for how we can implement", "being more welcoming to newcomers, I believe it is worthwhile", "acceptable question, nor should we answer repeat questions \"just to", "question, nor should we answer repeat questions \"just to be", "us to explore what we can do to help new", "light of the recent [Stack Overflow post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being more", "should relax standards for what is considered an acceptable question,", "\"just to be nice.\" However, it does seem appropriate that", "a way that helps users try to improve their question", "the recent [Stack Overflow post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being more welcoming to", "of what's wrong. Are there any other suggestions for how", "into the site. While I do not believe we should", "While I do not believe we should relax standards for", "their question if possible, or be a clear explanation of", "other suggestions for how we can implement this initiative here", "we do a better job explaining why we have issues", "why we have issues with questions that are posted in", "newcomers, I believe it is worthwhile for us to explore", "considered an acceptable question, nor should we answer repeat questions", "we have issues with questions that are posted in a", "do to help new visitors ease into the site. While", "post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being more welcoming to newcomers, I believe it", "way that helps users try to improve their question if", "relax standards for what is considered an acceptable question, nor", "a better job explaining why we have issues with questions", "what we can do to help new visitors ease into", "do not believe we should relax standards for what is", "in a way that helps users try to improve their", "that helps users try to improve their question if possible,", "be a clear explanation of what's wrong. Are there any", "explore what we can do to help new visitors ease", "on being more welcoming to newcomers, I believe it is", "is worthwhile for us to explore what we can do", "not believe we should relax standards for what is considered", "I do not believe we should relax standards for what", "users try to improve their question if possible, or be", "new visitors ease into the site. While I do not", "to help new visitors ease into the site. While I", "are posted in a way that helps users try to", "[Stack Overflow post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being more welcoming to newcomers, I", "standards for what is considered an acceptable question, nor should", "we answer repeat questions \"just to be nice.\" However, it", "of the recent [Stack Overflow post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being more welcoming", "job explaining why we have issues with questions that are", "an acceptable question, nor should we answer repeat questions \"just", "repeat questions \"just to be nice.\" However, it does seem", "we should relax standards for what is considered an acceptable", "clear explanation of what's wrong. Are there any other suggestions", "what is considered an acceptable question, nor should we answer", "there any other suggestions for how we can implement this", "Overflow post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being more welcoming to newcomers, I believe", "have issues with questions that are posted in a way", "for what is considered an acceptable question, nor should we", "do a better job explaining why we have issues with", "if possible, or be a clear explanation of what's wrong.", "with questions that are posted in a way that helps", "or be a clear explanation of what's wrong. Are there", "is considered an acceptable question, nor should we answer repeat", "nor should we answer repeat questions \"just to be nice.\"", "to improve their question if possible, or be a clear", "any other suggestions for how we can implement this initiative", "it does seem appropriate that we do a better job", "posted in a way that helps users try to improve", "wrong. Are there any other suggestions for how we can", "questions that are posted in a way that helps users", "that are posted in a way that helps users try", "site. While I do not believe we should relax standards", "answer repeat questions \"just to be nice.\" However, it does", "to newcomers, I believe it is worthwhile for us to", "it is worthwhile for us to explore what we can", "explaining why we have issues with questions that are posted", "can do to help new visitors ease into the site.", "suggestions for how we can implement this initiative here on", "helps users try to improve their question if possible, or", "welcoming to newcomers, I believe it is worthwhile for us", "to be nice.\" However, it does seem appropriate that we", "improve their question if possible, or be a clear explanation", "more welcoming to newcomers, I believe it is worthwhile for", "try to improve their question if possible, or be a", "that we do a better job explaining why we have", "ease into the site. While I do not believe we", "the site. While I do not believe we should relax", "should we answer repeat questions \"just to be nice.\" However,", "better job explaining why we have issues with questions that", "explanation of what's wrong. Are there any other suggestions for", "questions \"just to be nice.\" However, it does seem appropriate", "In light of the recent [Stack Overflow post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being", "visitors ease into the site. While I do not believe", "recent [Stack Overflow post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/?cb=1) on being more welcoming to newcomers,", "believe we should relax standards for what is considered an", "seem appropriate that we do a better job explaining why", "for us to explore what we can do to help", "to explore what we can do to help new visitors", "worthwhile for us to explore what we can do to", "we can do to help new visitors ease into the" ]
[ "don't recall seeing such blatant trolling on this site, but", "post with a follow-up comment: > > @Kimball-Since I have", "actually quite funny, and if there's no other answer I", "comment: > > @Kimball-Since I have given a correct answer", "(a la the \"I figured 1 big pile of garbage", "actually award the bounty to this deleted answer (the +100", "pile pointlessness on pointlessness (a la the \"I figured 1", "is this an isolated incident or does it happen with", "it was actually quite funny, and if there's no other", "from the blog post with a follow-up comment: > >", "actual account and/or the account was promptly deleted. Anyway, I", "without an actual account and/or the account was promptly deleted.", "on the username so I presume either the post was", "follow-up comment: > > @Kimball-Since I have given a correct", "the account was promptly deleted. Anyway, I don't recall seeing", "+100 is highlighted when I roll over it). Can I?", "Anyway, I don't recall seeing such blatant trolling on this", "in question is just a verbatim copy-paste from the blog", "bounty. The answer in question is just a verbatim copy-paste", "if there's no other answer I feel worthy of a", "> > > In addition I cannot click on the", "of a bounty why not award it to this just", "this just to pile pointlessness on pointlessness (a la the", "la the \"I figured 1 big pile of garbage was", "I can actually award the bounty to this deleted answer", "have given a correct answer to your question,Please award me", "correct answer to your question,Please award me a bounty worth", "reputation within 5 days from today – user92118 > >", "worth +100 reputation within 5 days from today – user92118", "an actual account and/or the account was promptly deleted. Anyway,", "I roll over it). Can I? My second reaction to", "not award it to this just to pile pointlessness on", "Can I? My second reaction to this post was that", "trolling on this site, but I was wondering: is this", "pointlessness (a la the \"I figured 1 big pile of", "recall seeing such blatant trolling on this site, but I", "either the post was created without an actual account and/or", "can actually award the bounty to this deleted answer (the", "a [question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on a blog post I", "on a blog post I read, to which I also", "promptly deleted. Anyway, I don't recall seeing such blatant trolling", "or does it happen with some regularity? PS: I am", "it). Can I? My second reaction to this post was", "over it). Can I? My second reaction to this post", "a bounty worth +100 reputation within 5 days from today", "feel worthy of a bounty why not award it to", "blatant trolling on this site, but I was wondering: is", "just a verbatim copy-paste from the blog post with a", "(the +100 is highlighted when I roll over it). Can", "me a bounty worth +100 reputation within 5 days from", "> > In addition I cannot click on the username", "of garbage was better than 2 smaller piles of garbage\"", "I also attached a bounty. The answer in question is", "created without an actual account and/or the account was promptly", "\"I figured 1 big pile of garbage was better than", "this post was that it was actually quite funny, and", "> > @Kimball-Since I have given a correct answer to", "but I was wondering: is this an isolated incident or", "this an isolated incident or does it happen with some", "it to this just to pile pointlessness on pointlessness (a", "from today – user92118 > > > In addition I", "1 big pile of garbage was better than 2 smaller", "with some regularity? PS: I am new to bounties, but", "based on a blog post I read, to which I", "to pile pointlessness on pointlessness (a la the \"I figured", "question is just a verbatim copy-paste from the blog post", "deleted. Anyway, I don't recall seeing such blatant trolling on", "a [deleted answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/108950/19607) to a [question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on", "within 5 days from today – user92118 > > >", "of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on a blog post I read, to", "regularity? PS: I am new to bounties, but it appears", "when I roll over it). Can I? My second reaction", "and if there's no other answer I feel worthy of", "I feel worthy of a bounty why not award it", "The answer in question is just a verbatim copy-paste from", "today – user92118 > > > In addition I cannot", "the username so I presume either the post was created", "garbage was better than 2 smaller piles of garbage\" philosophy).", "also attached a bounty. The answer in question is just", "is just a verbatim copy-paste from the blog post with", "answer to your question,Please award me a bounty worth +100", "such blatant trolling on this site, but I was wondering:", "addition I cannot click on the username so I presume", "to this post was that it was actually quite funny,", "bounty to this deleted answer (the +100 is highlighted when", "site, but I was wondering: is this an isolated incident", "was actually quite funny, and if there's no other answer", "[deleted answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/108950/19607) to a [question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on a", "click on the username so I presume either the post", "a blog post I read, to which I also attached", "and/or the account was promptly deleted. Anyway, I don't recall", "there's no other answer I feel worthy of a bounty", "presume either the post was created without an actual account", "recently a [deleted answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/108950/19607) to a [question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based", "big pile of garbage was better than 2 smaller piles", "highlighted when I roll over it). Can I? My second", "bounty why not award it to this just to pile", "blog post with a follow-up comment: > > @Kimball-Since I", "no other answer I feel worthy of a bounty why", "the bounty to this deleted answer (the +100 is highlighted", "funny, and if there's no other answer I feel worthy", "user92118 > > > In addition I cannot click on", "award it to this just to pile pointlessness on pointlessness", "it happen with some regularity? PS: I am new to", "In addition I cannot click on the username so I", "happen with some regularity? PS: I am new to bounties,", "I presume either the post was created without an actual", "was promptly deleted. Anyway, I don't recall seeing such blatant", "bounties, but it appears I can actually award the bounty", "> @Kimball-Since I have given a correct answer to your", "appears I can actually award the bounty to this deleted", "wondering: is this an isolated incident or does it happen", "days from today – user92118 > > > In addition", "a verbatim copy-paste from the blog post with a follow-up", "to which I also attached a bounty. The answer in", "My second reaction to this post was that it was", "to this deleted answer (the +100 is highlighted when I", "am new to bounties, but it appears I can actually", "+100 reputation within 5 days from today – user92118 >", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/108950/19607) to a [question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on a blog", "post I read, to which I also attached a bounty.", "so I presume either the post was created without an", "5 days from today – user92118 > > > In", "I read, to which I also attached a bounty. The", "on this site, but I was wondering: is this an", "was that it was actually quite funny, and if there's", "@Kimball-Since I have given a correct answer to your question,Please", "just to pile pointlessness on pointlessness (a la the \"I", "I was wondering: is this an isolated incident or does", "pile of garbage was better than 2 smaller piles of", "cannot click on the username so I presume either the", "to bounties, but it appears I can actually award the", "a follow-up comment: > > @Kimball-Since I have given a", "this deleted answer (the +100 is highlighted when I roll", "account and/or the account was promptly deleted. Anyway, I don't", "that it was actually quite funny, and if there's no", "deleted answer (the +100 is highlighted when I roll over", "> In addition I cannot click on the username so", "quite funny, and if there's no other answer I feel", "a bounty why not award it to this just to", "verbatim copy-paste from the blog post with a follow-up comment:", "a correct answer to your question,Please award me a bounty", "some regularity? PS: I am new to bounties, but it", "to a [question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on a blog post", "mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on a blog post I read, to which", "award me a bounty worth +100 reputation within 5 days", "was created without an actual account and/or the account was", "username so I presume either the post was created without", "this site, but I was wondering: is this an isolated", "on pointlessness (a la the \"I figured 1 big pile", "a bounty. The answer in question is just a verbatim", "does it happen with some regularity? PS: I am new", "the blog post with a follow-up comment: > > @Kimball-Since", "it appears I can actually award the bounty to this", "other answer I feel worthy of a bounty why not", "worthy of a bounty why not award it to this", "new to bounties, but it appears I can actually award", "to this just to pile pointlessness on pointlessness (a la", "an isolated incident or does it happen with some regularity?", "award the bounty to this deleted answer (the +100 is", "reaction to this post was that it was actually quite", "given a correct answer to your question,Please award me a", "but it appears I can actually award the bounty to", "[question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607) based on a blog post I read,", "answer (the +100 is highlighted when I roll over it).", "attached a bounty. The answer in question is just a", "I have given a correct answer to your question,Please award", "I am new to bounties, but it appears I can", "pointlessness on pointlessness (a la the \"I figured 1 big", "– user92118 > > > In addition I cannot click", "is highlighted when I roll over it). Can I? My", "answer I feel worthy of a bounty why not award", "read, to which I also attached a bounty. The answer", "blog post I read, to which I also attached a", "figured 1 big pile of garbage was better than 2", "post was created without an actual account and/or the account", "was wondering: is this an isolated incident or does it", "roll over it). Can I? My second reaction to this", "question,Please award me a bounty worth +100 reputation within 5", "account was promptly deleted. Anyway, I don't recall seeing such", "answer in question is just a verbatim copy-paste from the", "copy-paste from the blog post with a follow-up comment: >", "isolated incident or does it happen with some regularity? PS:", "why not award it to this just to pile pointlessness", "I don't recall seeing such blatant trolling on this site,", "with a follow-up comment: > > @Kimball-Since I have given", "the post was created without an actual account and/or the", "I? My second reaction to this post was that it", "post was that it was actually quite funny, and if", "second reaction to this post was that it was actually", "bounty worth +100 reputation within 5 days from today –", "seeing such blatant trolling on this site, but I was", "PS: I am new to bounties, but it appears I", "to your question,Please award me a bounty worth +100 reputation", "your question,Please award me a bounty worth +100 reputation within", "the \"I figured 1 big pile of garbage was better", "incident or does it happen with some regularity? PS: I", "There was recently a [deleted answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/108950/19607) to a [question of", "I cannot click on the username so I presume either", "was recently a [deleted answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/108950/19607) to a [question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/95176/19607)", "which I also attached a bounty. The answer in question" ]
[ "SE. What do the stats say? I realize there are", "been male dominated for a long time (in some fields", "But it would be interesting to see what is known", "do the stats say? I realize there are lots of", "levels at Academia SE. What do the stats say? I", "time (in some fields more than others; and although women", "question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for thought for us at Academia SE! Could", "gender distribution of Academia SE participants? Academia has been male", "would be interesting to see what is known about gender", "here. The blog post contains a brief survey questionnaire. I", "someone provide some recent stats regarding gender distribution of Academia", "our participation levels at Academia SE. What do the stats", "what is known about gender distribution here. The blog post", "more and more present as time goes on), and it's", "a long time (in some fields more than others; and", "present as time goes on), and it's my impression that", "who have not indicated their gender. But it would be", "survey questionnaire. I hope Academia SE participants will take part.", "as time goes on), and it's my impression that that", "participants who have not indicated their gender. But it would", "[SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for thought for us at Academia", "SE blog post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/) about promoting diversity and niceness at SE,", "has been male dominated for a long time (in some", "are lots of participants who have not indicated their gender.", "carry over to our participation levels at Academia SE. What", "post contains a brief survey questionnaire. I hope Academia SE", "gender distribution here. The blog post contains a brief survey", "SE! Could someone provide some recent stats regarding gender distribution", "the stats say? I realize there are lots of participants", "to see what is known about gender distribution here. The", "us at Academia SE! Could someone provide some recent stats", "There was a [recent SE blog post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/) about promoting diversity", "distribution of Academia SE participants? Academia has been male dominated", "provide some recent stats regarding gender distribution of Academia SE", "recent stats regarding gender distribution of Academia SE participants? Academia", "more than others; and although women are becoming more and", "to our participation levels at Academia SE. What do the", "realize there are lots of participants who have not indicated", "not indicated their gender. But it would be interesting to", "than others; and although women are becoming more and more", "have not indicated their gender. But it would be interesting", "Academia SE participants? Academia has been male dominated for a", "participation levels at Academia SE. What do the stats say?", "I realize there are lots of participants who have not", "and more present as time goes on), and it's my", "may carry over to our participation levels at Academia SE.", "Academia SE. What do the stats say? I realize there", "my impression that that imbalance may carry over to our", "brief survey questionnaire. I hope Academia SE participants will take", "known about gender distribution here. The blog post contains a", "Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for thought for us at Academia SE!", "there are lots of participants who have not indicated their", "impression that that imbalance may carry over to our participation", "over to our participation levels at Academia SE. What do", "Could someone provide some recent stats regarding gender distribution of", "and an associated [SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for thought for", "that that imbalance may carry over to our participation levels", "at Academia SE. What do the stats say? I realize", "long time (in some fields more than others; and although", "(in some fields more than others; and although women are", "interesting to see what is known about gender distribution here.", "dominated for a long time (in some fields more than", "an associated [SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for thought for us", "is known about gender distribution here. The blog post contains", "for thought for us at Academia SE! Could someone provide", "that imbalance may carry over to our participation levels at", "niceness at SE, and an associated [SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food", "Academia has been male dominated for a long time (in", "promoting diversity and niceness at SE, and an associated [SE", "was a [recent SE blog post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/) about promoting diversity and", "imbalance may carry over to our participation levels at Academia", "gender. But it would be interesting to see what is", "participants? Academia has been male dominated for a long time", "What do the stats say? I realize there are lots", "indicated their gender. But it would be interesting to see", "male dominated for a long time (in some fields more", "blog post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/) about promoting diversity and niceness at SE, and", "of participants who have not indicated their gender. But it", "it would be interesting to see what is known about", "for us at Academia SE! Could someone provide some recent", "goes on), and it's my impression that that imbalance may", "stats say? I realize there are lots of participants who", "becoming more and more present as time goes on), and", "are becoming more and more present as time goes on),", "it's my impression that that imbalance may carry over to", "lots of participants who have not indicated their gender. But", "stats regarding gender distribution of Academia SE participants? Academia has", "of Academia SE participants? Academia has been male dominated for", "a brief survey questionnaire. I hope Academia SE participants will", "some recent stats regarding gender distribution of Academia SE participants?", "more present as time goes on), and it's my impression", "about gender distribution here. The blog post contains a brief", "some fields more than others; and although women are becoming", "others; and although women are becoming more and more present", "SE, and an associated [SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for thought", "women are becoming more and more present as time goes", "distribution here. The blog post contains a brief survey questionnaire.", "[recent SE blog post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/) about promoting diversity and niceness at", "SE participants? Academia has been male dominated for a long", "about promoting diversity and niceness at SE, and an associated", "The blog post contains a brief survey questionnaire. I hope", "and niceness at SE, and an associated [SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826).", "and although women are becoming more and more present as", "regarding gender distribution of Academia SE participants? Academia has been", "Academia SE! Could someone provide some recent stats regarding gender", "on), and it's my impression that that imbalance may carry", "Food for thought for us at Academia SE! Could someone", "at SE, and an associated [SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for", "associated [SE Meta question](https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/309645/287826). Food for thought for us at", "be interesting to see what is known about gender distribution", "at Academia SE! Could someone provide some recent stats regarding", "say? I realize there are lots of participants who have", "post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/) about promoting diversity and niceness at SE, and an", "thought for us at Academia SE! Could someone provide some", "a [recent SE blog post](https://stackoverflow.blog/2018/04/26/stack-overflow-isnt-very-welcoming-its-time-for-that-to-change/) about promoting diversity and niceness", "for a long time (in some fields more than others;", "and it's my impression that that imbalance may carry over", "diversity and niceness at SE, and an associated [SE Meta", "their gender. But it would be interesting to see what", "see what is known about gender distribution here. The blog", "contains a brief survey questionnaire. I hope Academia SE participants", "fields more than others; and although women are becoming more", "although women are becoming more and more present as time", "blog post contains a brief survey questionnaire. I hope Academia", "time goes on), and it's my impression that that imbalance" ]
[ "of view, but when this interference is at the discretion", "because it fits with the politics or meta-philosophies of certain", "they didn't fit with such meta-philosophies. If that's not the", "Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice. >", "it fits with the politics or meta-philosophies of certain moderators.", "controversial statements that were removed simply because they didn't fit", "the discretion of authorities and policing is inconsistent, it becomes", "policing is inconsistent, it becomes orders of magnitude more problematic.", "You may use answers ONLY to provide a solution to", "to the specific question asked above. Moderators will remove debates,", "question asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions", "opinions without notice. > > > I find this concept", "moderators. Further to this, I imagine, there were equally controversial", "and personal opinions upon others to a much greater extent", "For these reasons and others, I oppose the use of", "probably the case for other questions so-marked as controversial. My", "opinion-laden statements, but only gives moderators the option of removal,", "comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY", "answers ONLY to provide a solution to the specific question", "Controversial Post — You may use comments ONLY to suggest", "consistent removal of controversial or opinion-laden statements, but only gives", "post mechanism, which by its nature does not require the", "to a much greater extent than can be considered necessary", "problematic from an ethical point of view, but when this", "point is this: the controversial post mechanism, which by its", "can be done,\" the solution is to recognize that you", "particular question, then at least it's probably the case for", "the option of removal, consequently confers inordinate power to moderators", "> > > I find this concept morally dubious. To", "that it hasn't been \"removed without notice,\" most likely because", "improvements. You may use answers ONLY to provide a solution", "statements, but only gives moderators the option of removal, consequently", "inordinate power to moderators and allows them to impose their", "most likely because it fits with the politics or meta-philosophies", "orders of magnitude more problematic. For these reasons and others,", "solution to the specific question asked above. Moderators will remove", "suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY to provide a", "question, then at least it's probably the case for other", "does not require the consistent removal of controversial or opinion-laden", "says: > > Controversial Post — You may use comments", "asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions without", "made in an answer that is EXTREMELY opinion-laden: > >", "were equally controversial statements that were removed simply because they", "meta-philosophies. If that's not the case for this particular question,", "be rectified. > > > I strongly disagree with this", "its nature does not require the consistent removal of controversial", "more problematic. For these reasons and others, I oppose the", "than trying to plead for another chance, rather than trying", "point of view, but when this interference is at the", "to plead for another chance, rather than trying to \"see", "> > Controversial Post — You may use comments ONLY", "here's a statement made in an answer that is EXTREMELY", "disagree with this highly controversial statement, and I note that", "rather than trying to plead for another chance, rather than", "and I note that it hasn't been \"removed without notice,\"", "simply because they didn't fit with such meta-philosophies. If that's", "controversial statement, and I note that it hasn't been \"removed", "likely because it fits with the politics or meta-philosophies of", "this highly controversial statement, and I note that it hasn't", "with such meta-philosophies. If that's not the case for this", "in an answer that is EXTREMELY opinion-laden: > > So,", "to \"see what can be done,\" the solution is to", "that you have made a serious error that cannot be", "case for this particular question, then at least it's probably", "done,\" the solution is to recognize that you have made", "I imagine, there were equally controversial statements that were removed", "moderators the option of removal, consequently confers inordinate power to", "at the discretion of authorities and policing is inconsistent, it", "> > I find this concept morally dubious. To illustrate,", "problematic. For these reasons and others, I oppose the use", "that academia.stackexchange should search for more ethically sound ways of", "will remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice. > >", "removed simply because they didn't fit with such meta-philosophies. If", "the politics or meta-philosophies of certain moderators. Further to this,", "highly controversial statement, and I note that it hasn't been", "their political views and personal opinions upon others to a", "be done,\" the solution is to recognize that you have", "least it's probably the case for other questions so-marked as", "error that cannot be rectified. > > > I strongly", "opinions upon others to a much greater extent than can", "can be considered necessary or morally sound. Interfering with people's", "certain moderators. Further to this, I imagine, there were equally", "that's not the case for this particular question, then at", "with people's freedom of speech is already problematic from an", "so-marked as controversial. My point is this: the controversial post", "be considered necessary or morally sound. Interfering with people's freedom", "of magnitude more problematic. For these reasons and others, I", "should search for more ethically sound ways of reducing interpersonal", "> Controversial Post — You may use comments ONLY to", "fit with such meta-philosophies. If that's not the case for", "case for other questions so-marked as controversial. My point is", "allows them to impose their political views and personal opinions", "fits with the politics or meta-philosophies of certain moderators. Further", "than can be considered necessary or morally sound. Interfering with", "illustrate, here's a statement made in an answer that is", "concept morally dubious. To illustrate, here's a statement made in", "were removed simply because they didn't fit with such meta-philosophies.", "morally sound. Interfering with people's freedom of speech is already", "necessary or morally sound. Interfering with people's freedom of speech", "it becomes orders of magnitude more problematic. For these reasons", "already problematic from an ethical point of view, but when", "or meta-philosophies of certain moderators. Further to this, I imagine,", "cannot be rectified. > > > I strongly disagree with", "because they didn't fit with such meta-philosophies. If that's not", "for another chance, rather than trying to \"see what can", "solution is to recognize that you have made a serious", "dubious. To illustrate, here's a statement made in an answer", "or opinion-laden statements, but only gives moderators the option of", "question was marked as a \"controversial post.\" The text says:", "such meta-philosophies. If that's not the case for this particular", "it's probably the case for other questions so-marked as controversial.", "removal, consequently confers inordinate power to moderators and allows them", "but when this interference is at the discretion of authorities", "views and personal opinions upon others to a much greater", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/109343/slept-through-final-professor-is-giving-me-a-zero-and-failing-me-is-there-any) question was marked as a \"controversial post.\" The text", "questions so-marked as controversial. My point is this: the controversial", "trying to plead for another chance, rather than trying to", "much greater extent than can be considered necessary or morally", "other questions so-marked as controversial. My point is this: the", "is inconsistent, it becomes orders of magnitude more problematic. For", "speech is already problematic from an ethical point of view,", "a solution to the specific question asked above. Moderators will", "view, but when this interference is at the discretion of", "of authorities and policing is inconsistent, it becomes orders of", "to this, I imagine, there were equally controversial statements that", "and policing is inconsistent, it becomes orders of magnitude more", "moderators and allows them to impose their political views and", "gives moderators the option of removal, consequently confers inordinate power", "by its nature does not require the consistent removal of", "without notice. > > > I find this concept morally", "equally controversial statements that were removed simply because they didn't", "as a \"controversial post.\" The text says: > > Controversial", "use answers ONLY to provide a solution to the specific", "to provide a solution to the specific question asked above.", "statement made in an answer that is EXTREMELY opinion-laden: >", "which by its nature does not require the consistent removal", "is already problematic from an ethical point of view, but", "marked as a \"controversial post.\" The text says: > >", "or opinions without notice. > > > I find this", "not require the consistent removal of controversial or opinion-laden statements,", "consequently confers inordinate power to moderators and allows them to", "an ethical point of view, but when this interference is", "discretion of authorities and policing is inconsistent, it becomes orders", "you have made a serious error that cannot be rectified.", "was marked as a \"controversial post.\" The text says: >", "— You may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You", "not the case for this particular question, then at least", "debates, arguments or opinions without notice. > > > I", "inconsistent, it becomes orders of magnitude more problematic. For these", "the consistent removal of controversial or opinion-laden statements, but only", "text says: > > Controversial Post — You may use", "use of \"controversial question\" mechanism and I think that academia.stackexchange", "answer that is EXTREMELY opinion-laden: > > So, rather than", "is at the discretion of authorities and policing is inconsistent,", "question\" mechanism and I think that academia.stackexchange should search for", "\"see what can be done,\" the solution is to recognize", "ONLY to provide a solution to the specific question asked", "of certain moderators. Further to this, I imagine, there were", "impose their political views and personal opinions upon others to", "rectified. > > > I strongly disagree with this highly", "imagine, there were equally controversial statements that were removed simply", "So, rather than trying to plead for another chance, rather", "people's freedom of speech is already problematic from an ethical", "remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice. > > >", "a statement made in an answer that is EXTREMELY opinion-laden:", "that is EXTREMELY opinion-laden: > > So, rather than trying", "or morally sound. Interfering with people's freedom of speech is", "> So, rather than trying to plead for another chance,", "the controversial post mechanism, which by its nature does not", "rather than trying to \"see what can be done,\" the", "> > > I strongly disagree with this highly controversial", "political views and personal opinions upon others to a much", "> > I strongly disagree with this highly controversial statement,", "that were removed simply because they didn't fit with such", "You may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may", "I note that it hasn't been \"removed without notice,\" most", "notice,\" most likely because it fits with the politics or", "above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or opinions without notice.", "at least it's probably the case for other questions so-marked", "controversial post mechanism, which by its nature does not require", "\"controversial question\" mechanism and I think that academia.stackexchange should search", "from an ethical point of view, but when this interference", "If that's not the case for this particular question, then", "and allows them to impose their political views and personal", "the solution is to recognize that you have made a", "notice. > > > I find this concept morally dubious.", "chance, rather than trying to \"see what can be done,\"", "oppose the use of \"controversial question\" mechanism and I think", "Further to this, I imagine, there were equally controversial statements", "the specific question asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments", "I noticed that [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/109343/slept-through-final-professor-is-giving-me-a-zero-and-failing-me-is-there-any) question was marked as a \"controversial", "a serious error that cannot be rectified. > > >", "hasn't been \"removed without notice,\" most likely because it fits", "only gives moderators the option of removal, consequently confers inordinate", "academia.stackexchange should search for more ethically sound ways of reducing", "> I find this concept morally dubious. To illustrate, here's", "post.\" The text says: > > Controversial Post — You", "arguments or opinions without notice. > > > I find", "another chance, rather than trying to \"see what can be", "\"removed without notice,\" most likely because it fits with the", "to recognize that you have made a serious error that", "made a serious error that cannot be rectified. > >", "politics or meta-philosophies of certain moderators. Further to this, I", "becomes orders of magnitude more problematic. For these reasons and", "opinion-laden: > > So, rather than trying to plead for", "magnitude more problematic. For these reasons and others, I oppose", "of controversial or opinion-laden statements, but only gives moderators the", "considered necessary or morally sound. Interfering with people's freedom of", "may use answers ONLY to provide a solution to the", "note that it hasn't been \"removed without notice,\" most likely", "there were equally controversial statements that were removed simply because", "and others, I oppose the use of \"controversial question\" mechanism", "may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use", "as controversial. My point is this: the controversial post mechanism,", "> I strongly disagree with this highly controversial statement, and", "have made a serious error that cannot be rectified. >", "\"controversial post.\" The text says: > > Controversial Post —", "to suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY to provide", "to impose their political views and personal opinions upon others", "strongly disagree with this highly controversial statement, and I note", "extent than can be considered necessary or morally sound. Interfering", "mechanism, which by its nature does not require the consistent", "is EXTREMELY opinion-laden: > > So, rather than trying to", "for this particular question, then at least it's probably the", "to moderators and allows them to impose their political views", "authorities and policing is inconsistent, it becomes orders of magnitude", "nature does not require the consistent removal of controversial or", "reasons and others, I oppose the use of \"controversial question\"", "I strongly disagree with this highly controversial statement, and I", "require the consistent removal of controversial or opinion-laden statements, but", "provide a solution to the specific question asked above. Moderators", "plead for another chance, rather than trying to \"see what", "find this concept morally dubious. To illustrate, here's a statement", "interference is at the discretion of authorities and policing is", "option of removal, consequently confers inordinate power to moderators and", "upon others to a much greater extent than can be", "than trying to \"see what can be done,\" the solution", "an answer that is EXTREMELY opinion-laden: > > So, rather", "of speech is already problematic from an ethical point of", "To illustrate, here's a statement made in an answer that", "serious error that cannot be rectified. > > > I", "with this highly controversial statement, and I note that it", "The text says: > > Controversial Post — You may", "this, I imagine, there were equally controversial statements that were", "didn't fit with such meta-philosophies. If that's not the case", "then at least it's probably the case for other questions", "that cannot be rectified. > > > I strongly disagree", "of \"controversial question\" mechanism and I think that academia.stackexchange should", "mechanism and I think that academia.stackexchange should search for more", "is to recognize that you have made a serious error", "freedom of speech is already problematic from an ethical point", "meta-philosophies of certain moderators. Further to this, I imagine, there", "My point is this: the controversial post mechanism, which by", "ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use answers ONLY to", "with the politics or meta-philosophies of certain moderators. Further to", "confers inordinate power to moderators and allows them to impose", "personal opinions upon others to a much greater extent than", "statements that were removed simply because they didn't fit with", "I oppose the use of \"controversial question\" mechanism and I", "without notice,\" most likely because it fits with the politics", "greater extent than can be considered necessary or morally sound.", "I think that academia.stackexchange should search for more ethically sound", "this particular question, then at least it's probably the case", "sound. Interfering with people's freedom of speech is already problematic", "these reasons and others, I oppose the use of \"controversial", "I find this concept morally dubious. To illustrate, here's a", "power to moderators and allows them to impose their political", "Post — You may use comments ONLY to suggest improvements.", "when this interference is at the discretion of authorities and", "trying to \"see what can be done,\" the solution is", "recognize that you have made a serious error that cannot", "been \"removed without notice,\" most likely because it fits with", "a \"controversial post.\" The text says: > > Controversial Post", "ethical point of view, but when this interference is at", "the case for this particular question, then at least it's", "what can be done,\" the solution is to recognize that", "controversial. My point is this: the controversial post mechanism, which", "others to a much greater extent than can be considered", "search for more ethically sound ways of reducing interpersonal conflict.", "use comments ONLY to suggest improvements. You may use answers", "a much greater extent than can be considered necessary or", "specific question asked above. Moderators will remove debates, arguments or", "it hasn't been \"removed without notice,\" most likely because it", "others, I oppose the use of \"controversial question\" mechanism and", "the use of \"controversial question\" mechanism and I think that", "but only gives moderators the option of removal, consequently confers", "that [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/109343/slept-through-final-professor-is-giving-me-a-zero-and-failing-me-is-there-any) question was marked as a \"controversial post.\" The", "this concept morally dubious. To illustrate, here's a statement made", "controversial or opinion-laden statements, but only gives moderators the option", "is this: the controversial post mechanism, which by its nature", "them to impose their political views and personal opinions upon", "EXTREMELY opinion-laden: > > So, rather than trying to plead", "and I think that academia.stackexchange should search for more ethically", "for other questions so-marked as controversial. My point is this:", "removal of controversial or opinion-laden statements, but only gives moderators", "think that academia.stackexchange should search for more ethically sound ways", "morally dubious. To illustrate, here's a statement made in an", "Interfering with people's freedom of speech is already problematic from", "this interference is at the discretion of authorities and policing", "> > So, rather than trying to plead for another", "statement, and I note that it hasn't been \"removed without", "the case for other questions so-marked as controversial. My point", "this: the controversial post mechanism, which by its nature does", "noticed that [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/109343/slept-through-final-professor-is-giving-me-a-zero-and-failing-me-is-there-any) question was marked as a \"controversial post.\"", "of removal, consequently confers inordinate power to moderators and allows" ]
[ "to whether it shall be open or closed. Since any", "fit our scope? * Is the question reasonably narrow? ", "answer: Does this question fit our scope? * Is", "* Is the question reasonably narrow? * Is it reasonably", "Update: A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been posted, following from the", "and its answers, some of which were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ###", "which were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This Question In an answer", "can decide. ### Food for Thought It would be great", "be avoided that this question turns into a popularity contest?", "the question reasonably narrow? * Is it reasonably clear what", "Should it stay closed? * Should it be reopened as", "tedious due to other matters being discussed in parallel, we", "be open or closed. Since any discussion on this in", "\"ladies lingerie department\" joke, and how can I avoid offending", "some of which were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This Question In", "Jake Beal's answer. The new question has some discussion [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/4165/follow-on-to-the-lingerie-elevator-question).", "changed in a specific manner and then reopened? Please answer", "contest? --- Update: A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been posted, following", "then reopened? Please answer only with respect to this site.", "this site. Migration would only happen if the target site", "issue here. Be aware that there are already seventy deleted", "will inevitably get very tedious due to other matters being", "with respect to whether it shall be open or closed.", "something we can decide. ### Food for Thought It would", "we can decide. ### Food for Thought It would be", "question and take this issue here. Be aware that there", "Food for Thought It would be great if you could", "comments or chat will inevitably get very tedious due to", "closed? * Should it be reopened as it is? ", "we should proceed with this question: Should it stay", "it (which is unlikely) and thus not something we can", "this issue here. Be aware that there are already seventy", "popularity contest? --- Update: A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been posted,", "particular with respect to whether it shall be open or", "were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This Question In an answer please", "Question In an answer please propose how we should proceed", "it is? * Should it be changed in a specific", "Is it reasonably clear what is being asked? * Can", "joke, and how can I avoid offending people in a", "would be great if you could address these questions in", "has been posted, following from the discussion below Jake Beal's", "* Should it be changed in a specific manner and", "clear what is being asked? * Can it be avoided", "in an answer: * Does this question fit our scope?", "this question and its answers, some of which were [not", "please propose how we should proceed with this question: ", "to lock the question and take this issue here. Be", "offending people in a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused a lot", "Please answer only with respect to this site. Migration would", "(which is unlikely) and thus not something we can decide.", "the comments or chat will inevitably get very tedious due", "this question fit our scope? Is the question reasonably", "on this question and its answers, some of which were", "is being asked? * Can it be avoided that this", "and then reopened? Please answer only with respect to this", "if you could address these questions in an answer: ", "question turns into a popularity contest? --- Update: A [new", "into a popularity contest? --- Update: A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has", "be changed in a specific manner and then reopened? Please", "reasonably narrow? Is it reasonably clear what is being", "caused a lot of controversy in comments and answers, in", "site. Migration would only happen if the target site wants", "reasonably clear what is being asked? * Can it be", "question: * Should it stay closed? * Should it be", "has caused a lot of controversy in comments and answers,", "that this question turns into a popularity contest? --- Update:", "Be aware that there are already seventy deleted comments on", "### This Question In an answer please propose how we", "[new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been posted, following from the discussion below", "avoided that this question turns into a popularity contest? ---", "the question and take this issue here. Be aware that", "could address these questions in an answer: * Does this", "similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused a lot of controversy in comments", "[What was offensive about the \"ladies lingerie department\" joke, and", "or chat will inevitably get very tedious due to other", "about the \"ladies lingerie department\" joke, and how can I", "* Is it reasonably clear what is being asked? ", "thus not something we can decide. ### Food for Thought", "in the comments or chat will inevitably get very tedious", "below Jake Beal's answer. The new question has some discussion", "whether it shall be open or closed. Since any discussion", "decide. ### Food for Thought It would be great if", "this question turns into a popularity contest? --- Update: A", "propose how we should proceed with this question: Should", "deleted comments on this question and its answers, some of", "a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused a lot of controversy in", "controversy in comments and answers, in particular with respect to", "have decided to lock the question and take this issue", "it be avoided that this question turns into a popularity", "closed. Since any discussion on this in the comments or", "questions in an answer: * Does this question fit our", "offensive about the \"ladies lingerie department\" joke, and how can", "* Should it stay closed? * Should it be reopened", "target site wants it (which is unlikely) and thus not", "other matters being discussed in parallel, we (read: some moderators)", "answers, some of which were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This Question", "happen if the target site wants it (which is unlikely)", "was offensive about the \"ladies lingerie department\" joke, and how", "be great if you could address these questions in an", "any discussion on this in the comments or chat will", "is unlikely) and thus not something we can decide. ###", "the \"ladies lingerie department\" joke, and how can I avoid", "answer only with respect to this site. Migration would only", "parallel, we (read: some moderators) have decided to lock the", "In an answer please propose how we should proceed with", "(read: some moderators) have decided to lock the question and", "lot of controversy in comments and answers, in particular with", "in comments and answers, in particular with respect to whether", "our scope? * Is the question reasonably narrow? * Is", "Since any discussion on this in the comments or chat", "Does this question fit our scope? * Is the question", "there are already seventy deleted comments on this question and", "seventy deleted comments on this question and its answers, some", "great if you could address these questions in an answer:", "a specific manner and then reopened? Please answer only with", "get very tedious due to other matters being discussed in", "for Thought It would be great if you could address", "and answers, in particular with respect to whether it shall", "already seventy deleted comments on this question and its answers,", "manner and then reopened? Please answer only with respect to", "people in a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused a lot of", "you could address these questions in an answer: * Does", "being discussed in parallel, we (read: some moderators) have decided", "only with respect to this site. Migration would only happen", "address these questions in an answer: * Does this question", "these questions in an answer: * Does this question fit", "this in the comments or chat will inevitably get very", "aware that there are already seventy deleted comments on this", "it be changed in a specific manner and then reopened?", "it shall be open or closed. Since any discussion on", "Thought It would be great if you could address these", "It would be great if you could address these questions", "Is the question reasonably narrow? * Is it reasonably clear", "we (read: some moderators) have decided to lock the question", "should proceed with this question: * Should it stay closed?", "due to other matters being discussed in parallel, we (read:", "as it is? * Should it be changed in a", "on this in the comments or chat will inevitably get", "this question: * Should it stay closed? * Should it", "it reasonably clear what is being asked? * Can it", "inevitably get very tedious due to other matters being discussed", "discussion on this in the comments or chat will inevitably", "reopened as it is? * Should it be changed in", "how we should proceed with this question: * Should it", "discussion below Jake Beal's answer. The new question has some", "that there are already seventy deleted comments on this question", "how can I avoid offending people in a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734)", "Can it be avoided that this question turns into a", "if the target site wants it (which is unlikely) and", "to other matters being discussed in parallel, we (read: some", "comments and answers, in particular with respect to whether it", "a lot of controversy in comments and answers, in particular", "a popularity contest? --- Update: A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been", "an answer: * Does this question fit our scope? ", "narrow? Is it reasonably clear what is being asked?", "reopened? Please answer only with respect to this site. Migration", "This Question In an answer please propose how we should", "stay closed? * Should it be reopened as it is?", "A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been posted, following from the discussion", "I avoid offending people in a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused", "way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused a lot of controversy in comments and", "posted, following from the discussion below Jake Beal's answer. The", "question reasonably narrow? * Is it reasonably clear what is", "The question [What was offensive about the \"ladies lingerie department\"", "with this question: * Should it stay closed? * Should", "in particular with respect to whether it shall be open", "being asked? * Can it be avoided that this question", "the target site wants it (which is unlikely) and thus", "respect to this site. Migration would only happen if the", "be reopened as it is? * Should it be changed", "in a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused a lot of controversy", "can I avoid offending people in a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has", "very tedious due to other matters being discussed in parallel,", "* Can it be avoided that this question turns into", "in a specific manner and then reopened? Please answer only", "decided to lock the question and take this issue here.", "Migration would only happen if the target site wants it", "answer please propose how we should proceed with this question:", "discussed in parallel, we (read: some moderators) have decided to", "department\" joke, and how can I avoid offending people in", "asked? * Can it be avoided that this question turns", "been posted, following from the discussion below Jake Beal's answer.", "matters being discussed in parallel, we (read: some moderators) have", "chat will inevitably get very tedious due to other matters", "and thus not something we can decide. ### Food for", "it be reopened as it is? * Should it be", "* Does this question fit our scope? * Is the", "and how can I avoid offending people in a similar", "avoid offending people in a similar way?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109789/7734) has caused a", "respect to whether it shall be open or closed. Since", "its answers, some of which were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This", "--- Update: A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been posted, following from", "take this issue here. Be aware that there are already", "specific manner and then reopened? Please answer only with respect", "from the discussion below Jake Beal's answer. The new question", "moderators) have decided to lock the question and take this", "unlikely) and thus not something we can decide. ### Food", "question fit our scope? * Is the question reasonably narrow?", "what is being asked? * Can it be avoided that", "proceed with this question: * Should it stay closed? ", "lock the question and take this issue here. Be aware", "scope? Is the question reasonably narrow? * Is it", "of controversy in comments and answers, in particular with respect", "answers, in particular with respect to whether it shall be", "comments on this question and its answers, some of which", "site wants it (which is unlikely) and thus not something", "not something we can decide. ### Food for Thought It", "to this site. Migration would only happen if the target", "* Should it be reopened as it is? * Should", "turns into a popularity contest? --- Update: A [new question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436)", "following from the discussion below Jake Beal's answer. The new", "lingerie department\" joke, and how can I avoid offending people", "nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This Question In an answer please propose how", "some moderators) have decided to lock the question and take", "is? * Should it be changed in a specific manner", "would only happen if the target site wants it (which", "### Food for Thought It would be great if you", "here. Be aware that there are already seventy deleted comments", "of which were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This Question In an", "[not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice). ### This Question In an answer please propose", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/109937/32436) has been posted, following from the discussion below Jake", "it stay closed? * Should it be reopened as it", "with respect to this site. Migration would only happen if", "shall be open or closed. Since any discussion on this", "or closed. Since any discussion on this in the comments", "in parallel, we (read: some moderators) have decided to lock", "open or closed. Since any discussion on this in the", "the discussion below Jake Beal's answer. The new question has", "Should it be changed in a specific manner and then", "only happen if the target site wants it (which is", "and take this issue here. Be aware that there are", "an answer please propose how we should proceed with this", "are already seventy deleted comments on this question and its", "Should it be reopened as it is? * Should it", "wants it (which is unlikely) and thus not something we", "question and its answers, some of which were [not nice](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/be-nice).", "question [What was offensive about the \"ladies lingerie department\" joke," ]
[ "need to know about the level of research conducted in", "about the level of research conducted in a certain university", "some reasons I need to know about the level of", "want to study there: I got my Ph.D. years ago).", "level of research conducted in a certain university (not because", "website, but I didn't get a conclusive answer. Can I", "my Ph.D. years ago). Specifically, I'm interested in a certain", "interested in a certain department. I did some due diligence,", "I did some due diligence, such as looking at the", "conducted in a certain university (not because I want to", "a certain university (not because I want to study there:", "at the website, but I didn't get a conclusive answer.", "I want to study there: I got my Ph.D. years", "to study there: I got my Ph.D. years ago). Specifically,", "I got my Ph.D. years ago). Specifically, I'm interested in", "got my Ph.D. years ago). Specifically, I'm interested in a", "Specifically, I'm interested in a certain department. I did some", "study there: I got my Ph.D. years ago). Specifically, I'm", "did some due diligence, such as looking at the Google", "in a certain department. I did some due diligence, such", "reasons I need to know about the level of research", "Google Scholar profile of one of the professors, and looking", "didn't get a conclusive answer. Can I ask this question", "the level of research conducted in a certain university (not", "I need to know about the level of research conducted", "get a conclusive answer. Can I ask this question on", "know about the level of research conducted in a certain", "there: I got my Ph.D. years ago). Specifically, I'm interested", "of research conducted in a certain university (not because I", "looking at the Google Scholar profile of one of the", "certain university (not because I want to study there: I", "the Google Scholar profile of one of the professors, and", "I'm interested in a certain department. I did some due", "(not because I want to study there: I got my", "as looking at the Google Scholar profile of one of", "research conducted in a certain university (not because I want", "certain department. I did some due diligence, such as looking", "the website, but I didn't get a conclusive answer. Can", "such as looking at the Google Scholar profile of one", "to know about the level of research conducted in a", "diligence, such as looking at the Google Scholar profile of", "Scholar profile of one of the professors, and looking at", "of the professors, and looking at the website, but I", "the professors, and looking at the website, but I didn't", "profile of one of the professors, and looking at the", "I didn't get a conclusive answer. Can I ask this", "university (not because I want to study there: I got", "at the Google Scholar profile of one of the professors,", "of one of the professors, and looking at the website,", "some due diligence, such as looking at the Google Scholar", "ago). Specifically, I'm interested in a certain department. I did", "a certain department. I did some due diligence, such as", "department. I did some due diligence, such as looking at", "professors, and looking at the website, but I didn't get", "years ago). Specifically, I'm interested in a certain department. I", "For some reasons I need to know about the level", "because I want to study there: I got my Ph.D.", "a conclusive answer. Can I ask this question on Academia.SE?", "in a certain university (not because I want to study", "but I didn't get a conclusive answer. Can I ask", "due diligence, such as looking at the Google Scholar profile", "and looking at the website, but I didn't get a", "one of the professors, and looking at the website, but", "looking at the website, but I didn't get a conclusive", "Ph.D. years ago). Specifically, I'm interested in a certain department." ]