Split (1)

train · 10.4M rows

ngram listlengths 0 10.5k
[ "'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong. I don't have the reputation", "our community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting more opinions than facts.", "general, how should our community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting more", "[here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion", "else needs to, if required. 2. In general, how should our community look", "me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong. I", "have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required. 2.", "Does the community agree with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point", "being good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users and not", "answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative", "the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required. 2. In", "of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre (again,", "comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being", "over an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of", "over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong. I don't", "and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence,", "to, if required. 2. In general, how should our community look upon such", "someone else needs to, if required. 2. In general, how should our community", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of", "required. 2. In general, how should our community look upon such questions-answers which", "the community agree with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where", "opinions of users and not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with", "my opinion, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without", "or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users and not facts). So...", "based on the opinions of users and not facts). So... 1. Does the", "If 'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong. I don't have the", "so someone else needs to, if required. 2. In general, how should our", "not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with me over these? If", "an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users", "should our community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting more opinions than", "with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong.", "2. In general, how should our community look upon such questions-answers which are", "wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to,", "kindly point where I am wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close,", "and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on", "Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users and", "opinion, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper", "evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based", "community agree with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I", "discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions", "if required. 2. In general, how should our community look upon such questions-answers", "are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over", "how should our community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting more opinions", "where I am wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone", "inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an", "am wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs", "So... 1. Does the community agree with me over these? If 'NO', then", "In general, how should our community look upon such questions-answers which are inviting", "mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users and not facts). So... 1.", "backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre", "to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required. 2. In general, how", "1. Does the community agree with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly", "its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and", "then kindly point where I am wrong. I don't have the reputation to", "facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with me over these? If 'NO',", "of users and not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with me", "reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required. 2. In general,", "needs to, if required. 2. In general, how should our community look upon", "speculations, comments without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute", "don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required.", "point where I am wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so", "these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I am wrong. I don't have", "agree with me over these? If 'NO', then kindly point where I am", "users and not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with me over", "good or mediocre (again, based on the opinions of users and not facts).", "I am wrong. I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else", "I don't have the reputation to vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if", "proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or", "the opinions of users and not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree", "(again, based on the opinions of users and not facts). So... 1. Does", "argumentative discussion over an Institute being good or mediocre (again, based on the", "In my opinion, [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments", "without proper backing of evidence, and argumentative discussion over an Institute being good", "and not facts). So... 1. Does the community agree with me over these?", "vote-to-close, so someone else needs to, if required. 2. In general, how should", "on the opinions of users and not facts). So... 1. Does the community", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/9604/5851) and its answer [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9606/5851) are inviting speculations, comments without proper backing" ]
[ "FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is such a restriction. Besides that,", "[Here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/9667/958) aeismail comments: > > One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You", "aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or it'll", "there is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to me", "true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there", "or it'll have to be converted to a comment > > > Is", "it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to stand as it is.", "to the point, and clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe we", "answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or", "it'll have to be converted to a comment > > > Is it", "comments: > > One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either", "to stand as it is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What", "You should either expand your answer, or it'll have to be converted to", "a comment > > > Is it true? I have skimmed through the", "and clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe we should rather change", "> One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand your", "your answer, or it'll have to be converted to a comment > >", "Besides that, that answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to the", "> > Is it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it", "Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What is your opinion on this?", "comment > > > Is it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ,", "restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to", "have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is such", "looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough", "it is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What is your opinion", "expand your answer, or it'll have to be converted to a comment >", "like there is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to", "aeismail comments: > > One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should", "it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like", "that answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to the point, and", "per our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or it'll have to", "> Is it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't", "One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer,", "through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is such a restriction.", "converted to a comment > > > Is it true? I have skimmed", "seem like there is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok", "have to be converted to a comment > > > Is it true?", "- it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to stand as it", "our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or it'll have to be", "be converted to a comment > > > Is it true? I have", "doesn't seem like there is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks", "either expand your answer, or it'll have to be converted to a comment", "clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe we should rather change the", "that, that answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to the point,", "stand as it is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What is", "> > > Is it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and", "FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or it'll have to be converted", "a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic,", "skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is such a", "point, and clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe we should rather", "Is it true? I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem", "answer looks ok to me - it's synthetic, to the point, and clear", "the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is such a restriction. Besides", "is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to me -", "answer, or it'll have to be converted to a comment > > >", "is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What is your opinion on", "to a comment > > > Is it true? I have skimmed through", "should either expand your answer, or it'll have to be converted to a", "ok to me - it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to", "me - it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to stand as", "it doesn't seem like there is such a restriction. Besides that, that answer", "as it is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ? What is your", "to me - it's synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to stand", "and it doesn't seem like there is such a restriction. Besides that, that", "the point, and clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe we should", "synthetic, to the point, and clear enough to stand as it is. Maybe", "such a restriction. Besides that, that answer looks ok to me - it's", "allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand your answer, or it'll have", "> > One-line answers aren't allowed per our FAQ's. You should either expand", "to be converted to a comment > > > Is it true? I", "enough to stand as it is. Maybe we should rather change the FAQ?", "I have skimmed through the FAQ, and it doesn't seem like there is" ]
[ "an automatic process and did not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting", "this list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The", "duplicates so this list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly", "be added to the original question pointing to the duplicates. This would only", "to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and comments.", "By definition, we marked it as duplicate because we think the question itself", "I haven't really thought about how this scales by a couple of orders", "be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow", "has useful terminology and wording that is helpful for future searches. I propose", "useful terminology and wording that is helpful for future searches. I propose that", "would be to allow a new user to easily find all the knowledge", "is added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers", "the duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked it", "comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate because we think the question", "meta, but I haven't really thought about how this scales by a couple", "easily find all the knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe this", "of the closed duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing is added", "duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot of duplicates so this list", "need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be", "on the site about the question. Maybe this is better for the main", "what I will refer to as singly linked. A link appears on top", "whenever a question is closed as a duplicate, a link should be added", "any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the question as a duplication.", "the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By", "the closed duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing is added to", "beyond simply voting to close the question as a duplication. Obviously some question", "terminology and wording that is helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever", "realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow a new", "only be viable if it was an automatic process and did not require", "answers and comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate because we think", "find all the knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe this is", "site about the question. Maybe this is better for the main SO meta,", "question. Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has", "question as a duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot of duplicates", "lot of duplicates so this list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable,", "and comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate because we think the", "not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the question as", "voting to close the question as a duplication. Obviously some question may have", "closed as duplicate are what I will refer to as singly linked. A", "that is helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever a question is", "intervention beyond simply voting to close the question as a duplication. Obviously some", "link appears on top of the closed duplicate question pointing to the original", "duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing is added to the original", "the main SO meta, but I haven't really thought about how this scales", "main SO meta, but I haven't really thought about how this scales by", "possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow a new user to easily", "for the main SO meta, but I haven't really thought about how this", "and wording that is helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever a", "a lot of duplicates so this list would need to be dynamic, realizable,", "I propose that whenever a question is closed as a duplicate, a link", "question pointing to the duplicates. This would only be viable if it was", "future searches. I propose that whenever a question is closed as a duplicate,", "would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would", "duplicate are what I will refer to as singly linked. A link appears", "did not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the question", "this is better for the main SO meta, but I haven't really thought", "pointing to the original question. Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes", "knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe this is better for the", "think the question itself has useful terminology and wording that is helpful for", "dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow a", "searches. I propose that whenever a question is closed as a duplicate, a", "helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever a question is closed as", "some question may have a lot of duplicates so this list would need", "the question itself has useful terminology and wording that is helpful for future", "Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful", "a question is closed as a duplicate, a link should be added to", "on top of the closed duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing", "but I haven't really thought about how this scales by a couple of", "has useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate because", "singly linked. A link appears on top of the closed duplicate question pointing", "we marked it as duplicate because we think the question itself has useful", "of duplicates so this list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and", "to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be to", "This would only be viable if it was an automatic process and did", "because we think the question itself has useful terminology and wording that is", "original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By definition,", "definition, we marked it as duplicate because we think the question itself has", "useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate because we", "is better for the main SO meta, but I haven't really thought about", "the original question. Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate", "idea would be to allow a new user to easily find all the", "wording that is helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever a question", "refer to as singly linked. A link appears on top of the closed", "question has useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked it as duplicate", "is helpful for future searches. I propose that whenever a question is closed", "question is closed as a duplicate, a link should be added to the", "may have a lot of duplicates so this list would need to be", "so this list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable.", "have a lot of duplicates so this list would need to be dynamic,", "linked. A link appears on top of the closed duplicate question pointing to", "to as singly linked. A link appears on top of the closed duplicate", "duplicates. This would only be viable if it was an automatic process and", "added to the original question pointing to the duplicates. This would only be", "questions closed as duplicate are what I will refer to as singly linked.", "a link should be added to the original question pointing to the duplicates.", "question pointing to the original question. Nothing is added to the original question.", "searchable. The idea would be to allow a new user to easily find", "new user to easily find all the knowledge on the site about the", "sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow a new user", "the duplicates. This would only be viable if it was an automatic process", "the question. Maybe this is better for the main SO meta, but I", "automatic process and did not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to", "about the question. Maybe this is better for the main SO meta, but", "for future searches. I propose that whenever a question is closed as a", "that whenever a question is closed as a duplicate, a link should be", "the original question pointing to the duplicates. This would only be viable if", "as a duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot of duplicates so", "list would need to be dynamic, realizable, sortable, and possibly searchable. The idea", "better for the main SO meta, but I haven't really thought about how", "question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By definition, we", "to easily find all the knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe", "SO meta, but I haven't really thought about how this scales by a", "duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked it as", "as a duplicate, a link should be added to the original question pointing", "really thought about how this scales by a couple of orders of magnitude.", "closed as a duplicate, a link should be added to the original question", "to the original question pointing to the duplicates. This would only be viable", "the question as a duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot of", "pointing to the duplicates. This would only be viable if it was an", "all the knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe this is better", "if it was an automatic process and did not require any suer intervention", "link should be added to the original question pointing to the duplicates. This", "The idea would be to allow a new user to easily find all", "top of the closed duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing is", "to allow a new user to easily find all the knowledge on the", "original question. Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question", "we think the question itself has useful terminology and wording that is helpful", "as singly linked. A link appears on top of the closed duplicate question", "original question pointing to the duplicates. This would only be viable if it", "to the duplicates. This would only be viable if it was an automatic", "require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the question as a", "duplicate, a link should be added to the original question pointing to the", "simply voting to close the question as a duplication. Obviously some question may", "the knowledge on the site about the question. Maybe this is better for", "question itself has useful terminology and wording that is helpful for future searches.", "be viable if it was an automatic process and did not require any", "Maybe this is better for the main SO meta, but I haven't really", "a duplicate, a link should be added to the original question pointing to", "itself has useful terminology and wording that is helpful for future searches. I", "as duplicate are what I will refer to as singly linked. A link", "user to easily find all the knowledge on the site about the question.", "the site about the question. Maybe this is better for the main SO", "closed duplicate question pointing to the original question. Nothing is added to the", "it as duplicate because we think the question itself has useful terminology and", "a duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot of duplicates so this", "I will refer to as singly linked. A link appears on top of", "and did not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the", "suer intervention beyond simply voting to close the question as a duplication. Obviously", "to close the question as a duplication. Obviously some question may have a", "Obviously some question may have a lot of duplicates so this list would", "be to allow a new user to easily find all the knowledge on", "question. Maybe this is better for the main SO meta, but I haven't", "A link appears on top of the closed duplicate question pointing to the", "close the question as a duplication. Obviously some question may have a lot", "added to the original question. Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and", "was an automatic process and did not require any suer intervention beyond simply", "process and did not require any suer intervention beyond simply voting to close", "haven't really thought about how this scales by a couple of orders of", "marked it as duplicate because we think the question itself has useful terminology", "Currently questions closed as duplicate are what I will refer to as singly", "are what I will refer to as singly linked. A link appears on", "should be added to the original question pointing to the duplicates. This would", "and possibly searchable. The idea would be to allow a new user to", "propose that whenever a question is closed as a duplicate, a link should", "it was an automatic process and did not require any suer intervention beyond", "will refer to as singly linked. A link appears on top of the", "question may have a lot of duplicates so this list would need to", "a new user to easily find all the knowledge on the site about", "Sometimes the duplicate question has useful answers and comments. By definition, we marked", "would only be viable if it was an automatic process and did not", "duplicate because we think the question itself has useful terminology and wording that", "appears on top of the closed duplicate question pointing to the original question.", "allow a new user to easily find all the knowledge on the site", "viable if it was an automatic process and did not require any suer", "as duplicate because we think the question itself has useful terminology and wording", "to the original question. Nothing is added to the original question. Sometimes the", "is closed as a duplicate, a link should be added to the original" ]
[ "non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers. How could this question be", "5 different answers. How could this question be changed to be more constructive?", "The question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9794/importance-of-going-to-university-in-the-21st-century> was closed on the main site, and identified as non-constructive,", "closed on the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has received", "main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers.", "question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9794/importance-of-going-to-university-in-the-21st-century> was closed on the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although", "on the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5", "although it has received 5 different answers. How could this question be changed", "site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers. How", "it has received 5 different answers. How could this question be changed to", "identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers. How could this", "received 5 different answers. How could this question be changed to be more", "was closed on the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has", "the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9794/importance-of-going-to-university-in-the-21st-century> was closed on the main site, and identified as non-constructive, although it", "as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers. How could this question", "has received 5 different answers. How could this question be changed to be", "and identified as non-constructive, although it has received 5 different answers. How could" ]
[ "do they do them in your country. That seems like the definition of", "a big list question to me. I have wanted to ask a similar", "[chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not a", "I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country", "To me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not a good", "seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not a good fit for academia.se.", "things like X, how do they do them in your country. That seems", "wanted to ask a similar type question, and I asked for input in", "a similar type question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me", "how do they do them in your country. That seems like the definition", "ask a similar type question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To", "these \"country poll\" questions are not a good fit for academia.se. Do you", "country we do things like X, how do they do them in your", "are not a good fit for academia.se. Do you think we should keep", "for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions", "input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are", "for academia.se. Do you think we should keep these type of questions open?", "That seems like the definition of a big list question to me. I", "in your country. That seems like the definition of a big list question", "essentially asks: In my country we do things like X, how do they", "me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not a good fit", "similar type question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it", "do them in your country. That seems like the definition of a big", "we do things like X, how do they do them in your country.", "question to me. I have wanted to ask a similar type question, and", "and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these", "do things like X, how do they do them in your country. That", "like the definition of a big list question to me. I have wanted", "This [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9818/international-variations-in-addressing-academics) essentially asks: In my country we do things like X, how", "like X, how do they do them in your country. That seems like", "have wanted to ask a similar type question, and I asked for input", "asks: In my country we do things like X, how do they do", "definition of a big list question to me. I have wanted to ask", "good fit for academia.se. Do you think we should keep these type of", "them in your country. That seems like the definition of a big list", "your country. That seems like the definition of a big list question to", "that these \"country poll\" questions are not a good fit for academia.se. Do", "\"country poll\" questions are not a good fit for academia.se. Do you think", "it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not a good fit for", "poll\" questions are not a good fit for academia.se. Do you think we", "my country we do things like X, how do they do them in", "me. I have wanted to ask a similar type question, and I asked", "to me. I have wanted to ask a similar type question, and I", "question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that", "seems like the definition of a big list question to me. I have", "asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country poll\"", "in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems that these \"country poll\" questions are not", "not a good fit for academia.se. Do you think we should keep these", "list question to me. I have wanted to ask a similar type question,", "the definition of a big list question to me. I have wanted to", "big list question to me. I have wanted to ask a similar type", "questions are not a good fit for academia.se. Do you think we should", "a good fit for academia.se. Do you think we should keep these type", "country. That seems like the definition of a big list question to me.", "X, how do they do them in your country. That seems like the", "to ask a similar type question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020).", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9818/international-variations-in-addressing-academics) essentially asks: In my country we do things like X, how do", "they do them in your country. That seems like the definition of a", "of a big list question to me. I have wanted to ask a", "In my country we do things like X, how do they do them", "fit for academia.se. Do you think we should keep these type of questions", "I have wanted to ask a similar type question, and I asked for", "type question, and I asked for input in [chat](http://chat.stackexchange.com/transcript/message/9145020#9145020). To me it seems" ]
[ "system in my opinion. But, at the very least, we should list Acafitoa", "in my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's", "I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in", "would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one", "new display at the bottom is not very good, in my opinion: I", "display below—you have to click through to get to a site where you", "to hunt around to find it. That's not a very good system in", "Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\" rather than \"Life/Arts?\"", "opinion. But, at the very least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes", "find it. That's not a very good system in my opinion. But, at", "good system in my opinion. But, at the very least, we should list", "under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of the categories shown in", "it. That's not a very good system in my opinion. But, at the", "\"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of the categories shown", "at the very least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense.", "the very least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But", "you then have to hunt around to find it. That's not a very", "where you then have to hunt around to find it. That's not a", "to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of the", "list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\" rather than", "display at the bottom is not very good, in my opinion: I would", "shown in the display below—you have to click through to get to a", "a site where you then have to hunt around to find it. That's", "not even in one of the categories shown in the display below—you have", "to get to a site where you then have to hunt around to", "to a site where you then have to hunt around to find it.", "site where you then have to hunt around to find it. That's not", "to click through to get to a site where you then have to", "the categories shown in the display below—you have to click through to get", "not very good, in my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under", "not a very good system in my opinion. But, at the very least,", "should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\" rather", "my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not", "one of the categories shown in the display below—you have to click through", "good, in my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but", "the bottom is not very good, in my opinion: I would expect to", "below—you have to click through to get to a site where you then", "a very good system in my opinion. But, at the very least, we", "very good system in my opinion. But, at the very least, we should", "in the display below—you have to click through to get to a site", "that's not even in one of the categories shown in the display below—you", "have to hunt around to find it. That's not a very good system", "around to find it. That's not a very good system in my opinion.", "That's not a very good system in my opinion. But, at the very", "bottom is not very good, in my opinion: I would expect to see", "the display below—you have to click through to get to a site where", "to find it. That's not a very good system in my opinion. But,", "The new display at the bottom is not very good, in my opinion:", "even in one of the categories shown in the display below—you have to", "of the categories shown in the display below—you have to click through to", "is not very good, in my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\"", "see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of the categories", "in my opinion. But, at the very least, we should list Acafitoa where", "click through to get to a site where you then have to hunt", "get to a site where you then have to hunt around to find", "hunt around to find it. That's not a very good system in my", "But, at the very least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes more", "least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is that", "very good, in my opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\"", "we should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is that \"Professional\"", "\"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of the categories shown in the", "then have to hunt around to find it. That's not a very good", "in one of the categories shown in the display below—you have to click", "have to click through to get to a site where you then have", "my opinion. But, at the very least, we should list Acafitoa where it", "through to get to a site where you then have to hunt around", "opinion: I would expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even", "but that's not even in one of the categories shown in the display", "very least, we should list Acafitoa where it makes more sense. But is", "categories shown in the display below—you have to click through to get to", "at the bottom is not very good, in my opinion: I would expect", "expect to see \"Acafitoa\" under \"Professional,\" but that's not even in one of" ]
[ "Or do you propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I", "otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")).", "is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact in the title", "question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact in the", "of questions relating to Computer Science, which is great. However, when a question", "many questions and answers for things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as", "case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things", "with it? Or do you propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That", "propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent", "it is crucial to advertise this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise", "a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact in", "typical example). Do you agree with it? Or do you propose an alternative", "are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some", "than a typical example). Do you agree with it? Or do you propose", "questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things like publishing and", "advertise this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags", "among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception", "Science, which is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is", "(in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers", "abundance of questions relating to Computer Science, which is great. However, when a", "exception than a typical example). Do you agree with it? Or do you", "it? Or do you propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That said,", "questions and answers for things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in", "an alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent questions", "[computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things like", "in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case:", "when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact", "some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS", "IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact in the title (unless it's", "agree with it? Or do you propose an alternative approach to this issue?", "things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary", "and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and", "'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things like publishing and conferences are", "There is an abundance of questions relating to Computer Science, which is great.", "Otherwise many questions and answers for things like publishing and conferences are misleading,", "disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than", "Do you agree with it? Or do you propose an alternative approach to", "conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in", "do you propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I think", "Computer Science, which is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it", "(in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences,", "practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather", "to advertise this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in", "CS is rather an exception than a typical example). Do you agree with", "is an abundance of questions relating to Computer Science, which is great. However,", "example). Do you agree with it? Or do you propose an alternative approach", "is rather an exception than a typical example). Do you agree with it?", "some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a typical example).", "for things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices", "like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among", "you propose an alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I think that", "e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a typical example). Do you", "a typical example). Do you agree with it? Or do you propose an", "and answers for things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some", "title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show", "relating to Computer Science, which is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent,", "you agree with it? Or do you propose an alternative approach to this", "questions relating to Computer Science, which is great. However, when a question is", "great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise", "is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to", "(and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a", "vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an", "cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a typical example). Do", "an abundance of questions relating to Computer Science, which is great. However, when", "to Computer Science, which is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO", "in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a typical", "publishing=conferences, CS is rather an exception than a typical example). Do you agree", "an exception than a typical example). Do you agree with it? Or do", "crucial to advertise this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND", "fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this", "answers for things like publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases)", "publishing and conferences are misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines", "as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g.", "approach to this issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent questions are important.)", "it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged", "(unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions", "in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions", "clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise", "cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases, e.g. publishing=conferences, CS is", "this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in", "However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this", "tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and", "discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial to advertise this fact in the title (unless", "rather an exception than a typical example). Do you agree with it? Or", "\"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things like publishing", "the title (unless it's otherwise clear) AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science", "alternative approach to this issue? (That said, I think that discipline-dependent questions are", "AND in tags (in this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many", "is crucial to advertise this fact in the title (unless it's otherwise clear)", "this case: [computer-science](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/computer-science \"show questions tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for", "which is great. However, when a question is discipline-dependent, IMHO it is crucial", "misleading, as (in some cases) practices vary among disciplines (and in some cases,", "tagged 'computer-science'\")). Otherwise many questions and answers for things like publishing and conferences" ]
[ "in particular. I was wondering: how do you use tags? Why do we", "how do you use tags? Why do we care about them? Personally, I", "several questions recently about tags, and topic related tags in particular. I was", "don't use them at all, I only search for questions through the search", "tags in particular. I was wondering: how do you use tags? Why do", "all, I only search for questions through the search bar. It would therefore", "do you use tags? Why do we care about them? Personally, I don't", "wondering: how do you use tags? Why do we care about them? Personally,", "related tags in particular. I was wondering: how do you use tags? Why", "for questions through the search bar. It would therefore be helpful to see", "tags, and topic related tags in particular. I was wondering: how do you", "I only search for questions through the search bar. It would therefore be", "I don't use them at all, I only search for questions through the", "I was wondering: how do you use tags? Why do we care about", "been several questions recently about tags, and topic related tags in particular. I", "about tags, and topic related tags in particular. I was wondering: how do", "do we care about them? Personally, I don't use them at all, I", "tags? Why do we care about them? Personally, I don't use them at", "through the search bar. It would therefore be helpful to see what kind", "therefore be helpful to see what kind of usages the community has for", "and topic related tags in particular. I was wondering: how do you use", "questions through the search bar. It would therefore be helpful to see what", "Personally, I don't use them at all, I only search for questions through", "the search bar. It would therefore be helpful to see what kind of", "be helpful to see what kind of usages the community has for tags.", "topic related tags in particular. I was wondering: how do you use tags?", "particular. I was wondering: how do you use tags? Why do we care", "only search for questions through the search bar. It would therefore be helpful", "It would therefore be helpful to see what kind of usages the community", "at all, I only search for questions through the search bar. It would", "search bar. It would therefore be helpful to see what kind of usages", "we care about them? Personally, I don't use them at all, I only", "use tags? Why do we care about them? Personally, I don't use them", "was wondering: how do you use tags? Why do we care about them?", "about them? Personally, I don't use them at all, I only search for", "questions recently about tags, and topic related tags in particular. I was wondering:", "you use tags? Why do we care about them? Personally, I don't use", "has been several questions recently about tags, and topic related tags in particular.", "care about them? Personally, I don't use them at all, I only search", "would therefore be helpful to see what kind of usages the community has", "search for questions through the search bar. It would therefore be helpful to", "There has been several questions recently about tags, and topic related tags in", "recently about tags, and topic related tags in particular. I was wondering: how", "bar. It would therefore be helpful to see what kind of usages the", "them? Personally, I don't use them at all, I only search for questions", "use them at all, I only search for questions through the search bar.", "them at all, I only search for questions through the search bar. It", "Why do we care about them? Personally, I don't use them at all," ]
[ "of us, grad students, would like to have a medium of communication where", "fit for the Q/A format that we have on SE sites. I suppose", "be discussed is voted here on meta I am not sure if there", "on SE sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad students, would like", "second week ... 2. ... where the subject to be discussed is voted", "there are quite a few users with questions that are little open-ended, which", "interest in statistics :) What do you think? Is this a desirable or", "1. We hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance once a", "or every second week ... 2. ... where the subject to be discussed", "a week or every second week ... 2. ... where the subject to", "my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance", "suppose a lot of us, grad students, would like to have a medium", "lot of us, grad students, would like to have a medium of communication", "on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on the chat, a", "my lack of interest in statistics :) What do you think? Is this", "voted here on meta I am not sure if there has been anything", "journal clubs with article discussions on the chat, a concept which I find", "AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit for this purpose, however it", "The chat room is a good fit for this purpose, however it appears", "before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on the", "CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on the chat, a concept which", "week ... 2. ... where the subject to be discussed is voted here", "like to have a medium of communication where we can discuss matters and", "appears as there isn't much activity there. For instance just before writing this", "pretty cool despite my lack of interest in statistics :) What do you", "here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on the chat;", "chat, a concept which I find pretty cool despite my lack of interest", "regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance once a week or every", "instance once a week or every second week ... 2. ... where the", "which is not a good fit for the Q/A format that we have", "good fit for the Q/A format that we have on SE sites. I", "... where the subject to be discussed is voted here on meta I", "subject to be discussed is voted here on meta I am not sure", "there has been anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal", "on meta I am not sure if there has been anything like this", "is not a good fit for the Q/A format that we have on", "have a medium of communication where we can discuss matters and questions about", "fit for this purpose, however it appears as there isn't much activity there.", "the chat, a concept which I find pretty cool despite my lack of", "I find pretty cool despite my lack of interest in statistics :) What", "experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is a", "for this purpose, however it appears as there isn't much activity there. For", "Q/A format that we have on SE sites. I suppose a lot of", "communication where we can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of the", "suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance once", "of AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit for this purpose, however", "room was from 6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We", "entry on chat room was from 6 days ago. So here comes my", "on chat room was from 6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal:", "AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on the chat, a concept", "there isn't much activity there. For instance just before writing this meta question", "ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on", "purpose, however it appears as there isn't much activity there. For instance just", "week or every second week ... 2. ... where the subject to be", "this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on", "about previous experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room", "hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance once a week or", "users with questions that are little open-ended, which is not a good fit", "been anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with", "with questions that are little open-ended, which is not a good fit for", "the last entry on chat room was from 6 days ago. So here", "we have on SE sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad students,", "2. ... where the subject to be discussed is voted here on meta", "days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups", "room is a good fit for this purpose, however it appears as there", "not sure if there has been anything like this before, here on AC.SE.", "chat; for instance once a week or every second week ... 2. ...", "anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article", "us, grad students, would like to have a medium of communication where we", "can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of the more senior members", "where the subject to be discussed is voted here on meta I am", "the subject to be discussed is voted here on meta I am not", "I am not sure if there has been anything like this before, here", "to have a medium of communication where we can discuss matters and questions", "members of AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit for this purpose,", "despite my lack of interest in statistics :) What do you think? Is", "comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for", "not a good fit for the Q/A format that we have on SE", "format that we have on SE sites. I suppose a lot of us,", "previous experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is", "has journal clubs with article discussions on the chat, a concept which I", "of interest in statistics :) What do you think? Is this a desirable", "chat room is a good fit for this purpose, however it appears as", "For instance just before writing this meta question the last entry on chat", "every second week ... 2. ... where the subject to be discussed is", "SE sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad students, would like to", "more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit for", "lack of interest in statistics :) What do you think? Is this a", "sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad students, would like to have", "have on SE sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad students, would", "a concept which I find pretty cool despite my lack of interest in", "however it appears as there isn't much activity there. For instance just before", "that are little open-ended, which is not a good fit for the Q/A", "meta question the last entry on chat room was from 6 days ago.", "discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of the more senior members of", "discussions on the chat, a concept which I find pretty cool despite my", "on the chat; for instance once a week or every second week ...", "are quite a few users with questions that are little open-ended, which is", "cool despite my lack of interest in statistics :) What do you think?", "quite a few users with questions that are little open-ended, which is not", "that there are quite a few users with questions that are little open-ended,", "the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit", "matters and questions about previous experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE.", "chat room was from 6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1.", "for instance once a week or every second week ... 2. ... where", "find pretty cool despite my lack of interest in statistics :) What do", "questions that are little open-ended, which is not a good fit for the", "as there isn't much activity there. For instance just before writing this meta", "here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions on the chat,", "a few users with questions that are little open-ended, which is not a", "the Q/A format that we have on SE sites. I suppose a lot", "discussed is voted here on meta I am not sure if there has", "here on meta I am not sure if there has been anything like", "where we can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of the more", "sure if there has been anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated", "few users with questions that are little open-ended, which is not a good", "writing this meta question the last entry on chat room was from 6", "groups on the chat; for instance once a week or every second week", "am not sure if there has been anything like this before, here on", "activity there. For instance just before writing this meta question the last entry", "before writing this meta question the last entry on chat room was from", "6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion", "instance just before writing this meta question the last entry on chat room", "on the chat, a concept which I find pretty cool despite my lack", "this purpose, however it appears as there isn't much activity there. For instance", "which I find pretty cool despite my lack of interest in statistics :)", "if there has been anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has", "clubs with article discussions on the chat, a concept which I find pretty", "in statistics :) What do you think? Is this a desirable or sustainable", "good fit for this purpose, however it appears as there isn't much activity", "that we have on SE sites. I suppose a lot of us, grad", "last entry on chat room was from 6 days ago. So here comes", "the chat; for instance once a week or every second week ... 2.", "has been anything like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs", "we can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of the more senior", "... 2. ... where the subject to be discussed is voted here on", "once a week or every second week ... 2. ... where the subject", "a medium of communication where we can discuss matters and questions about previous", "from 6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular", "medium of communication where we can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences", "a good fit for the Q/A format that we have on SE sites.", "grad students, would like to have a medium of communication where we can", "open-ended, which is not a good fit for the Q/A format that we", "a good fit for this purpose, however it appears as there isn't much", "noticed that there are quite a few users with questions that are little", "senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is a good fit for this", "is a good fit for this purpose, however it appears as there isn't", "for the Q/A format that we have on SE sites. I suppose a", "with article discussions on the chat, a concept which I find pretty cool", "this meta question the last entry on chat room was from 6 days", "We hold regular discussion groups on the chat; for instance once a week", "questions about previous experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat", "I noticed that there are quite a few users with questions that are", "it appears as there isn't much activity there. For instance just before writing", "like this before, here on AC.SE. CrossValidated has journal clubs with article discussions", "would like to have a medium of communication where we can discuss matters", "there. For instance just before writing this meta question the last entry on", "meta I am not sure if there has been anything like this before,", "article discussions on the chat, a concept which I find pretty cool despite", "just before writing this meta question the last entry on chat room was", "of the more senior members of AC.SE. The chat room is a good", "was from 6 days ago. So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold", "I suppose a lot of us, grad students, would like to have a", "much activity there. For instance just before writing this meta question the last", "concept which I find pretty cool despite my lack of interest in statistics", "are little open-ended, which is not a good fit for the Q/A format", "discussion groups on the chat; for instance once a week or every second", "to be discussed is voted here on meta I am not sure if", "is voted here on meta I am not sure if there has been", "isn't much activity there. For instance just before writing this meta question the", "question the last entry on chat room was from 6 days ago. So", "So here comes my suggestion/proposal: 1. We hold regular discussion groups on the", "and questions about previous experiences of the more senior members of AC.SE. The", "of communication where we can discuss matters and questions about previous experiences of", "a lot of us, grad students, would like to have a medium of", "students, would like to have a medium of communication where we can discuss", "little open-ended, which is not a good fit for the Q/A format that" ]
[ "the top five once I am logged in. Why is this so? Is", "am logged in. Why is this so? Is it a bug in the", "in the top five once I am logged in. Why is this so?", "not signed in. The question comes up in the top five once I", "I am logged in. Why is this so? Is it a bug in", "that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of questions when", "when I am not signed in. The question comes up in the top", "noted that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of questions", "[a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of questions when I", "questions when I am not signed in. The question comes up in the", "comes up in the top five once I am logged in. Why is", "the list of questions when I am not signed in. The question comes", "five once I am logged in. Why is this so? Is it a", "accidentally noted that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of", "top five once I am logged in. Why is this so? Is it", "particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of questions when I am", "logged in. Why is this so? Is it a bug in the feature?", "appear on the list of questions when I am not signed in. The", "I accidentally noted that [a particular question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list", "of questions when I am not signed in. The question comes up in", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10247/why-are-cs-researchers-reluctant-to-share-code-and-what-techniques-can-i-use-to) does not appear on the list of questions when I am not", "am not signed in. The question comes up in the top five once", "question comes up in the top five once I am logged in. Why", "in. Why is this so? Is it a bug in the feature? ![List_questions](https://i.stack.imgur.com/1HmhW.png)", "does not appear on the list of questions when I am not signed", "I am not signed in. The question comes up in the top five", "once I am logged in. Why is this so? Is it a bug", "not appear on the list of questions when I am not signed in.", "on the list of questions when I am not signed in. The question", "signed in. The question comes up in the top five once I am", "in. The question comes up in the top five once I am logged", "up in the top five once I am logged in. Why is this", "The question comes up in the top five once I am logged in.", "list of questions when I am not signed in. The question comes up" ]
[ "compare the answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating", "answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions", "questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few", "with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run", "use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to", "look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it", "of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should", "answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how", "When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try", "and compare the answers we have with the information available on other sites.", "the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10", "a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions", "your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow", "Google searches to see how easy they are to find and compare the", "people out there who need answers to their questions and don't even know", "[Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were", "this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and", "the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and", "few Google searches to see how easy they are to find and compare", "the answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the", "'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions", "though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed", "open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the", "Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you", "love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out", "it before, and see how we stack up against the rest of the", "before, and see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net.", "Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are to find", "there who need answers to their questions and don't even know that this", "their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive", "questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from", "quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are to", "questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that", "populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter.", "an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share", "that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and", "Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there who", "share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your", "searches to see how easy they are to find and compare the answers", "Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts", "questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a", "with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a", "is a whole world of people out there who need answers to their", "they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to", "eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack", "a few Google searches to see how easy they are to find and", "of people out there who need answers to their questions and don't even", "there is a whole world of people out there who need answers to", "to see how easy they are to find and compare the answers we", "puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been", "through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how", "they are to find and compare the answers we have with the information", "site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be?", "see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site", "need answers to their questions and don't even know that this site exists.", "We all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of", "world of people out there who need answers to their questions and don't", "stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval)", "rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated", "try to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never", "and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see", "is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern", "easy they are to find and compare the answers we have with the", "site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see", "of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with", "find and compare the answers we have with the information available on other", "the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have", "someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up against", "that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer", "is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in", "[Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there", "out there who need answers to their questions and don't even know that", "closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything", "or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post", "a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions", "seen it before, and see how we stack up against the rest of", "first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes", "that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google", "to their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they", "edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your", "arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look", "review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and", "how easy they are to find and compare the answers we have with", "to find and compare the answers we have with the information available on", "answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's", "to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with", "Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this", "last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are", "not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really", "part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that", "should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use", "Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and", "in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy", "don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what", "you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are", "a whole world of people out there who need answers to their questions", "of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers", "the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see", "are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going", "but there is a whole world of people out there who need answers", "impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of", "are to find and compare the answers we have with the information available", "could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below", "information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of", "will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through", "Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well?", "all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people", "whole world of people out there who need answers to their questions and", "Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but", "be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of someone", "the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part", "answers to their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When", "10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a", "have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only", "up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is", "have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an", "of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up", "sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do", "but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's", "the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they", "were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches", "we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review", "available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the", "that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first", "that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could", "who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up against the", "and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google,", "exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's", "what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site", "their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the", "against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open", "The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that", "Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked", "asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to", "below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health", "we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is", "really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these", "pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or", "at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before,", "see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not?", "only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of", "on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle,", "this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression", "never seen it before, and see how we stack up against the rest", "and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last", "going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss", "Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there who need", "how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation", "queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered", "even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will", "thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow users!", "know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their", "the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we", "from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at", "answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an", "Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's", "well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions", "who need answers to their questions and don't even know that this site", "an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the", "and see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The", "other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though.", "see how easy they are to find and compare the answers we have", "been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit?", "to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen" ]
[ "these questions have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates) > >", "to graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these", "need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place", "are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed", "we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a", "consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\",", "become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to", "admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have", "questions have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates) > > >", "\"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support", "unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so", "off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE", "graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions", "that these questions have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates) >", "so that these questions have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates SE](http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/49571/undergraduates)", "to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place to", "questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support the", "relating to graduate admissions\", we need to support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that", "Given that the consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating", "that the consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to", "Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place to go. > > [Undergraduates", "proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place to go. > >", "here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we", "the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place to go. >", "support the proposed Undergraduates.SE so that these questions have a place to go.", "has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate admissions\", we need", "the consensus here has become \"undergraduate questions are off-topic unless relating to graduate" ]
[ "is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the question in English,", "Academia and inform myself about how things work where I'm not. I do", "if they are relevant. As it could determine a future standard (accept or", "this question, I couldn't help but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's", "There's this question, that might be nice, but I'm missing half of it.", "as a good one or not, it could set up future standards for", "it could set up future standards for the site, so I feel it", "of French! I sometimes come to this site to read up on life", "Google Translate does to it just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's", "a future standard (accept or not questions in other languages), I think it", "disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers, on which I do not", "or not questions in other languages), I think it is important that there's", "But then, there's a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come to this", "a little, but much, much more, I read the questions and answers that", "such question so far, but, depending on weather this question is accepted as", "it just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers,", "standard (accept or not questions in other languages), I think it is important", "interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel just a little bit", "is accepted as a good one or not, it could set up future", "a good one or not, it could set up future standards for the", "questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but", "disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice, but I'm missing half of", "about how things work where I'm not. I do participate a little, but", "and inform myself about how things work where I'm not. I do participate", "French! I sometimes come to this site to read up on life in", "question is accepted as a good one or not, it could set up", "for the site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a", "more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers, on which I do", "future standards for the site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There", "it more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers, on which I", "this question, that might be nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing", "to read up on life in Academia and inform myself about how things", "up future standards for the site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a>", "where I'm not. I do participate a little, but much, much more, I", "but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it", "interesting to me. But then, there's a big chunk of French! I sometimes", "help but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might", "to it just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting", "in other languages), I think it is important that there's an discussion within", "this question is accepted as a good one or not, it could set", "it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it just makes it more disappointing.", "participate a little, but much, much more, I read the questions and answers", "up on life in Academia and inform myself about how things work where", "could set up future standards for the site, so I feel it is", "of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it just makes it more", "standards for the site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is", "missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it just makes", "depending on weather this question is accepted as a good one or not,", "Translate does to it just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this", "two interesting answers, on which I do not want to vote, because I", "not want to vote, because I do not know if they are relevant.", "Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel just a little bit disappointed.", "just a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice, but", "makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers, on which", "so far, but, depending on weather this question is accepted as a good", "There is a small part of the question in English, which actually sounds", "me. But then, there's a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come to", "English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's a big", "do not want to vote, because I do not know if they are", "little, but much, much more, I read the questions and answers that seem", "the question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then,", "does to it just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this two", "not questions in other languages), I think it is important that there's an", "I couldn't help but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this question,", "read up on life in Academia and inform myself about how things work", "been one such question so far, but, depending on weather this question is", "this two interesting answers, on which I do not want to vote, because", "determine a future standard (accept or not questions in other languages), I think", "this site to read up on life in Academia and inform myself about", "small part of the question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to", "is a small part of the question in English, which actually sounds partially", "chunk of French!* I sometimes come to this site to read up on", "how things work where I'm not. I do participate a little, but much,", "in Academia and inform myself about how things work where I'm not. I", "read the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't", "weather this question is accepted as a good one or not, it could", "and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel", "I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the", "little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice, but I'm missing", "interesting answers, on which I do not want to vote, because I do", "in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's a", "more, I read the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question,", "half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it just makes it", "answers, on which I do not want to vote, because I do not", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the question in English, which actually", "As it could determine a future standard (accept or not questions in other", "big chunk of French!* I sometimes come to this site to read up", "much, much more, I read the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing", "only been one such question so far, but, depending on weather this question", "myself about how things work where I'm not. I do participate a little,", "because I do not know if they are relevant. As it could determine", "couldn't help but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that", "are relevant. As it could determine a future standard (accept or not questions", "to vote, because I do not know if they are relevant. As it", "question, I couldn't help but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this", "to this site to read up on life in Academia and inform myself", "vote, because I do not know if they are relevant. As it could", "or not, it could set up future standards for the site, so I", "There's only been one such question so far, but, depending on weather this", "not. I do participate a little, but much, much more, I read the", "actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's a big chunk of", "questions in other languages), I think it is important that there's an discussion", "what Google Translate does to it just makes it more disappointing. And then,", "accepted as a good one or not, it could set up future standards", "but much, much more, I read the questions and answers that seem interesting.", "bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice, but I'm missing half", "I do participate a little, but much, much more, I read the questions", "so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of", "a small part of the question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting", "I read the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I", "one or not, it could set up future standards for the site, so", "partially interesting to me. But then, there's a big chunk of French! I", "things work where I'm not. I do participate a little, but much, much", "then, there's a big chunk of French! I sometimes come to this site", "on weather this question is accepted as a good one or not, it", "not, it could set up future standards for the site, so I feel", "sometimes come to this site to read up on life in Academia and", "nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to", "life in Academia and inform myself about how things work where I'm not.", "site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part", "the site, so I feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small", "then, there's this two interesting answers, on which I do not want to", "there's a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come to this site to", "I do not know if they are relevant. As it could determine a", "one such question so far, but, depending on weather this question is accepted", "the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help", "to me. But then, there's a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come", "sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's a big chunk of French!", "could determine a future standard (accept or not questions in other languages), I", "other languages), I think it is important that there's an discussion within the", "it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the question in", "future standard (accept or not questions in other languages), I think it is", "good one or not, it could set up future standards for the site,", "Seeing what Google Translate does to it just makes it more disappointing. And", "set up future standards for the site, so I feel it is important:", "might be nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate", "far, but, depending on weather this question is accepted as a good one", "question so far, but, depending on weather this question is accepted as a", "feel it is important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the question", "want to vote, because I do not know if they are relevant. As", "on life in Academia and inform myself about how things work where I'm", "seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel just a little", "question, that might be nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what", "And then, there's this two interesting answers, on which I do not want", "there's this two interesting answers, on which I do not want to vote,", "languages), I think it is important that there's an discussion within the community.", "know if they are relevant. As it could determine a future standard (accept", "which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's a big chunk", "it could determine a future standard (accept or not questions in other languages),", "that might be nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google", "of the question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But", "I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does to it just", "which I do not want to vote, because I do not know if", "but, depending on weather this question is accepted as a good one or", "I do not want to vote, because I do not know if they", "do participate a little, but much, much more, I read the questions and", "feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice,", "question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me. But then, there's", "part of the question in English, which actually sounds partially interesting to me.", "just makes it more disappointing. And then, there's this two interesting answers, on", "do not know if they are relevant. As it could determine a future", "work where I'm not. I do participate a little, but much, much more,", "come to this site to read up on life in Academia and inform", "I'm not. I do participate a little, but much, much more, I read", "answers that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel just", "(accept or not questions in other languages), I think it is important that", "a big chunk of French!* I sometimes come to this site to read", "I sometimes come to this site to read up on life in Academia", "site to read up on life in Academia and inform myself about how", "much more, I read the questions and answers that seem interesting. Seeing this", "on which I do not want to vote, because I do not know", "but feel just a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be", "important: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10735/en-shs-comment-participer-a-la-grande-conversation-scientifique-sans-renoncer-a> There is a small part of the question in English, which", "that seem interesting. Seeing this question, I couldn't help but feel just a", "be nice, but I'm missing half of it. Seeing what Google Translate does", "they are relevant. As it could determine a future standard (accept or not", "relevant. As it could determine a future standard (accept or not questions in", "inform myself about how things work where I'm not. I do participate a", "not know if they are relevant*. As it could determine a future standard", "a little bit disappointed. There's this question, that might be nice, but I'm" ]
[ "an academic. Are such questions on topic, and if so under what parameters", "approval is an integral part of being an academic. Are such questions on", "standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject of", "(traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is", "part of being an academic. Are such questions on topic, and if so", "integral part of being an academic. Are such questions on topic, and if", "if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical", "IRB approval is an integral part of being an academic. Are such questions", "the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not yet a question.", "the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral part of being", "(e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been", "being an academic. Are such questions on topic, and if so under what", "social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral part of being an", "been the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not yet a", "procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject of [an", "sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral part of being an academic.", "Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an", "is an integral part of being an academic. Are such questions on topic,", "on topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures", "topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs.", "fields (traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval", "ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject of [an answer to a", "vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject of [an answer", "what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB", "of being an academic. Are such questions on topic, and if so under", "increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral part of", "so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)?", "IRB has been the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not", "academic. Are such questions on topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g.", "questions on topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard", "many fields (traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB", "also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral part", "has been the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but not yet", "applying for IRB approval is an integral part of being an academic. Are", "but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for IRB approval is an integral", "and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery", "parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has", "Are such questions on topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing", "such questions on topic, and if so under what parameters (e.g. focusing on", "focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the", "under what parameters (e.g. focusing on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The", "In many fields (traditionally, Medicine but also increasingly the social sciences), applying for", "slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject of [an answer to", "an integral part of being an academic. Are such questions on topic, and", "The IRB has been the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775), but", "on standard procedures vs. slippery ethical questions)? The IRB has been the subject", "questions)? The IRB has been the subject of [an answer to a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/10466/775),", "for IRB approval is an integral part of being an academic. Are such" ]
[ "there was already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question, because", "are still on beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions", "we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments", "[here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the site, especially that we are", "not saying that this question should necessarily be kept open or should be", "should be the case, and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\"", "or off-topic is important to help the community grow. To be clear: I'm", "you know why you're closing the question, then leaving a comment should not", "don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new user understanding", "don't know why you're closing the question, then perhaps you should not be", "maintain the site, especially that we are still on beta, and that we", "you're closing the question, then perhaps you should not be voting to close", "important to help the community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that", "know why you're closing the question, then leaving a comment should not be", "of questions each day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her question is", "As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the site,", "because the next logical step is to delete the question, and I have", "question is too broad or off-topic is important to help the community grow.", "are very helpful to maintain the site, especially that we are still on", "this question should necessarily be kept open or should be closed, but if", "that difficult, and if you don't know why you're closing the question, then", "step is to delete the question, and I have no idea why it", "leaving a comment should not be that difficult, and if you don't know", "the question [How often should one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928)", "decided to reopen the question, because the next logical step is to delete", "be closed, but if you know why you're closing the question, then leaving", "a new user understanding why his/her question is too broad or off-topic is", "be kept open or should be closed, but if you know why you're", "it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated", "on beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day.", "is to delete the question, and I have no idea why it should", "it should be closed, while there was already an upvoted answer. I decided", "if you don't know why you're closing the question, then perhaps you should", "why it should be the case, and it's likely we're stuck with an", "but if you know why you're closing the question, then leaving a comment", "is important to help the community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying", "new user understanding why his/her question is too broad or off-topic is important", "and that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a", "why you're closing the question, then leaving a comment should not be that", "be that difficult, and if you don't know why you're closing the question,", "that this question should necessarily be kept open or should be closed, but", "be the case, and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question.", "the question, then perhaps you should not be voting to close in the", "still on beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each", "a comment should not be that difficult, and if you don't know why", "single comment explaining why it should be closed, while there was already an", "the site, especially that we are still on beta, and that we don't", "know why you're closing the question, then perhaps you should not be voting", "we are still on beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds of", "comment should not be that difficult, and if you don't know why you're", "stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the site, especially that we", "to maintain the site, especially that we are still on beta, and that", "evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single", "to delete the question, and I have no idea why it should be", "day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her question is too broad or", "difficult, and if you don't know why you're closing the question, then perhaps", "an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment explaining why it", "explaining why it should be closed, while there was already an upvoted answer.", "or should be closed, but if you know why you're closing the question,", "why it should be closed, while there was already an upvoted answer. I", "we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new user", "Helping a new user understanding why his/her question is too broad or off-topic", "you're closing the question, then leaving a comment should not be that difficult,", "already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question, because the next", "comments are very helpful to maintain the site, especially that we are still", "closing the question, then perhaps you should not be voting to close in", "too broad or off-topic is important to help the community grow. To be", "closed without a single comment explaining why it should be closed, while there", "and I have no idea why it should be the case, and it's", "the next logical step is to delete the question, and I have no", "should not be that difficult, and if you don't know why you're closing", "Recently, the question [How often should one evaluate a plan for an academic", "and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already", "logical step is to delete the question, and I have no idea why", "I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the site, especially", "helpful to maintain the site, especially that we are still on beta, and", "why his/her question is too broad or off-topic is important to help the", "stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are", "no idea why it should be the case, and it's likely we're stuck", "his/her question is too broad or off-topic is important to help the community", "I'm not saying that this question should necessarily be kept open or should", "the question, because the next logical step is to delete the question, and", "should one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without", "should be closed, while there was already an upvoted answer. I decided to", "reopen the question, because the next logical step is to delete the question,", "question should necessarily be kept open or should be closed, but if you", "hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain", "questions each day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her question is too", "To be clear: I'm not saying that this question should necessarily be kept", "open or should be closed, but if you know why you're closing the", "was already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question, because the", "to help the community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that this", "that we are still on beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds", "why you're closing the question, then perhaps you should not be voting to", "often should one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed", "question, then leaving a comment should not be that difficult, and if you", "should be closed, but if you know why you're closing the question, then", "has been closed without a single comment explaining why it should be closed,", "I decided to reopen the question, because the next logical step is to", "off-topic is important to help the community grow. To be clear: I'm not", "answer. I decided to reopen the question, because the next logical step is", "a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment", "idea why it should be the case, and it's likely we're stuck with", "exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new user understanding why", "\"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to", "academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment explaining why it should", "already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the site, especially that", "an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question, because the next logical", "the community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that this question should", "closed, but if you know why you're closing the question, then leaving a", "then perhaps you should not be voting to close in the first place.", "understanding why his/her question is too broad or off-topic is important to help", "an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful", "especially that we are still on beta, and that we don't exactly have", "question, then perhaps you should not be voting to close in the first", "beta, and that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping", "broad or off-topic is important to help the community grow. To be clear:", "the case, and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As", "very helpful to maintain the site, especially that we are still on beta,", "without a single comment explaining why it should be closed, while there was", "closing the question, then leaving a comment should not be that difficult, and", "then leaving a comment should not be that difficult, and if you don't", "plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment explaining", "comment explaining why it should be closed, while there was already an upvoted", "delete the question, and I have no idea why it should be the", "likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better),", "have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her", "community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that this question should necessarily", "career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment explaining why it should be", "be clear: I'm not saying that this question should necessarily be kept open", "not be that difficult, and if you don't know why you're closing the", "you don't know why you're closing the question, then perhaps you should not", "I have no idea why it should be the case, and it's likely", "help the community grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that this question", "with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very", "and if you don't know why you're closing the question, then perhaps you", "to reopen the question, because the next logical step is to delete the", "user understanding why his/her question is too broad or off-topic is important to", "that we don't exactly have hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new", "each day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her question is too broad", "clear: I'm not saying that this question should necessarily be kept open or", "upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question, because the next logical step", "the question, then leaving a comment should not be that difficult, and if", "is too broad or off-topic is important to help the community grow. To", "it should be the case, and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on", "have no idea why it should be the case, and it's likely we're", "site, especially that we are still on beta, and that we don't exactly", "kept open or should be closed, but if you know why you're closing", "closed, while there was already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the", "while there was already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen the question,", "case, and it's likely we're stuck with an \"on hold/closed\" question. As I", "question, because the next logical step is to delete the question, and I", "hundreds of questions each day. Helping a new user understanding why his/her question", "saying that this question should necessarily be kept open or should be closed,", "for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a single comment explaining why", "question [How often should one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has", "one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been closed without a", "been closed without a single comment explaining why it should be closed, while", "necessarily be kept open or should be closed, but if you know why", "question, and I have no idea why it should be the case, and", "next logical step is to delete the question, and I have no idea", "the question, and I have no idea why it should be the case,", "if you know why you're closing the question, then leaving a comment should", "should necessarily be kept open or should be closed, but if you know", "[How often should one evaluate a plan for an academic career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/10928/how-often-should-one-evaluate-a-plan-for-an-academic-career?noredirect=1#comment20098_10928) has been", "a single comment explaining why it should be closed, while there was already", "question. As I already stated [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/455/the-more-comments-the-better), comments are very helpful to maintain the", "be closed, while there was already an upvoted answer. I decided to reopen", "grow. To be clear: I'm not saying that this question should necessarily be" ]
[ "menu, I'm not sure I see anything that really fits. But do we", "seems a terrible question to me. But I see no close votes, and", "it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we are we missing a", "question to me. But I see no close votes, and when I look", "> I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter", "that we are we missing a close reason? And if so, what is", "we really want this and questions like it? Is this question's continued existence,", "And the OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for the", "to me. But I see no close votes, and when I look through", "the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter", "heard that twitter might help me find a PhD program. This question is", "<http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How can I use twitter to", "I have not used twitter before. How can I use twitter to help", "for the past two years without success > > > This just seems", "the past two years without success > > > This just seems a", "sure I see anything that really fits. But do we really want this", "onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help me find a", "fits. But do we really want this and questions like it? Is this", "through the close menu, I'm not sure I see anything that really fits.", "the close menu, I'm not sure I see anything that really fits. But", "twitter to help find a PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel", "PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs?", "is there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > >", "the OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for the past", "this question's continued existence, evidence that we are we missing a close reason?", "use twitter to help find a PhD? For example, is there a particular", "Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How can I", "PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help me find a PhD program.", "This question is inspired by this video in the British Ecological Society Careers", "that advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP also commented: > >", "to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help me", "twitter before. How can I use twitter to help find a PhD? For", "video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not", "British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before.", "a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help me find a PhD", "this question: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto a", "> I've Googled virtually daily for the past two years without success >", "> > > This just seems a terrible question to me. But I", "I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might", "This just seems a terrible question to me. But I see no close", "no close votes, and when I look through the close menu, I'm not", "is inspired by this video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel:", "want this and questions like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that", "enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help me find", "twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP also commented: >", "votes, and when I look through the close menu, I'm not sure I", "YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How can I use", "continued existence, evidence that we are we missing a close reason? And if", "me find a PhD program. This question is inspired by this video in", "years without success > > > This just seems a terrible question to", "I use twitter to help find a PhD? For example, is there a", "also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for the past two years", "PhDs? > > > And the OP also commented: > > I've Googled", "> And the OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for", "twitter might help me find a PhD program. This question is inspired by", "to help find a PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel on", "inspired by this video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY>", "virtually daily for the past two years without success > > > This", "asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard", "daily for the past two years without success > > > This just", "program. This question is inspired by this video in the British Ecological Society", "before. How can I use twitter to help find a PhD? For example,", "a terrible question to me. But I see no close votes, and when", "commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for the past two years without", "question: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD", "that twitter might help me find a PhD program. This question is inspired", "particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP", "> > This just seems a terrible question to me. But I see", "like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we are we missing", "existence, evidence that we are we missing a close reason? And if so,", "help me find a PhD program. This question is inspired by this video", "I'm not sure I see anything that really fits. But do we really", "by this video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I", "not used twitter before. How can I use twitter to help find a", "Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How", "group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP also", "and when I look through the close menu, I'm not sure I see", "evidence that we are we missing a close reason? And if so, what", "hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that twitter might help", "look through the close menu, I'm not sure I see anything that really", "Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we are we missing a close", "find a PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter that", "find a PhD program. This question is inspired by this video in the", "we are we missing a close reason? And if so, what is that", "do we really want this and questions like it? Is this question's continued", "questions like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we are we", "close menu, I'm not sure I see anything that really fits. But do", "question's continued existence, evidence that we are we missing a close reason? And", "advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP also commented: > > I've", "a PhD program. This question is inspired by this video in the British", "help find a PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter", "program. I've heard that twitter might help me find a PhD program. This", "channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How can I use twitter", "see no close votes, and when I look through the close menu, I'm", "> This just seems a terrible question to me. But I see no", "are we missing a close reason? And if so, what is that reason?", "question is inspired by this video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube", "a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And the", "PhD program. This question is inspired by this video in the British Ecological", "past two years without success > > > This just seems a terrible", "I see no close votes, and when I look through the close menu,", "OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily for the past two", "example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > >", "in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used", "this video in the British Ecological Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have", "and questions like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we are", "> > I've Googled virtually daily for the past two years without success", "this and questions like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence that we", "Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've", "anything that really fits. But do we really want this and questions like", "used twitter before. How can I use twitter to help find a PhD?", "just seems a terrible question to me. But I see no close votes,", "success > > > This just seems a terrible question to me. But", "terrible question to me. But I see no close votes, and when I", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program.", "can I use twitter to help find a PhD? For example, is there", "But I see no close votes, and when I look through the close", "> > > And the OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually", "not sure I see anything that really fits. But do we really want", "have not used twitter before. How can I use twitter to help find", "really fits. But do we really want this and questions like it? Is", "I've heard that twitter might help me find a PhD program. This question", "two years without success > > > This just seems a terrible question", "when I look through the close menu, I'm not sure I see anything", "that really fits. But do we really want this and questions like it?", "on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And the OP also commented:", "About this question: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/10959/96> Which asks: > > I'm hoping to enroll onto", "I've Googled virtually daily for the past two years without success > >", "a PhD? For example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises", "Society Careers YouTube channel: <http://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=plcp&v=J9uEYEcCcFY> I have not used twitter before. How can", "really want this and questions like it? Is this question's continued existence, evidence", "without success > > > This just seems a terrible question to me.", "there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? > > > And", "For example, is there a particular group/channel on twitter that advertises PhDs? >", "> > And the OP also commented: > > I've Googled virtually daily", "close votes, and when I look through the close menu, I'm not sure", "How can I use twitter to help find a PhD? For example, is", "I look through the close menu, I'm not sure I see anything that", "me. But I see no close votes, and when I look through the", "I see anything that really fits. But do we really want this and", "might help me find a PhD program. This question is inspired by this", "see anything that really fits. But do we really want this and questions", "> > I'm hoping to enroll onto a PhD program. I've heard that", "But do we really want this and questions like it? Is this question's", "Googled virtually daily for the past two years without success > > >" ]
[ "week (and I am using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I", "[this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but I do not see", "been removed in a week (and I am using the term in the", "think that I am making some contribution to this site, but clearly this", "am using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think", "the 2nd time (according to my reputation record) that an answer of mine", "Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment,", "am making some contribution to this site, but clearly this seems not to", "'removed'). I like to think that I am making some contribution to this", "but I do not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according", "that an answer of mine has been removed in a week (and I", "the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that I am making some", "answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but I do", "This is quite discouraging. Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It", "was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but", "do not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to my", "2nd time (according to my reputation record) that an answer of mine has", "see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to my reputation record)", "to my reputation record) that an answer of mine has been removed in", "quite discouraging. Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted", "is the 2nd time (according to my reputation record) that an answer of", "an answer of mine has been removed in a week (and I am", "(and I am using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like", "to think that I am making some contribution to this site, but clearly", "discouraging. Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to", "term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that I am", "(according to my reputation record) that an answer of mine has been removed", "in a week (and I am using the term in the aforementioned record", "It says converted to comment, but I do not see it anywhere. This", "record) that an answer of mine has been removed in a week (and", "record 'removed'). I like to think that I am making some contribution to", "some contribution to this site, but clearly this seems not to be the", "This is the 2nd time (according to my reputation record) that an answer", "removed in a week (and I am using the term in the aforementioned", "like to think that I am making some contribution to this site, but", "comment, but I do not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time", "contribution to this site, but clearly this seems not to be the case.", "deleted? It says converted to comment, but I do not see it anywhere.", "I am using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to", "time (according to my reputation record) that an answer of mine has been", "I am making some contribution to this site, but clearly this seems not", "reputation record) that an answer of mine has been removed in a week", "answer of mine has been removed in a week (and I am using", "not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to my reputation", "I like to think that I am making some contribution to this site,", "of mine has been removed in a week (and I am using the", "my reputation record) that an answer of mine has been removed in a", "my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but I", "has been removed in a week (and I am using the term in", "the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that I", "to comment, but I do not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd", "using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that", "to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but I do not", "aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that I am making some contribution", "I do not see it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to", "says converted to comment, but I do not see it anywhere. This is", "mine has been removed in a week (and I am using the term", "is quite discouraging. Why was my answer to [this thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says", "a week (and I am using the term in the aforementioned record 'removed').", "that I am making some contribution to this site, but clearly this seems", "making some contribution to this site, but clearly this seems not to be", "anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to my reputation record) that an", "in the aforementioned record 'removed'). I like to think that I am making", "it anywhere. This is the 2nd time (according to my reputation record) that", "thread](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11165/how-to-respond-to-someone-plagiarizing-my-work/11173#11173) deleted? It says converted to comment, but I do not see it", "converted to comment, but I do not see it anywhere. This is the" ]
[ "me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter", "where I am not a moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where", "page, where there is nothing for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png)", "alert on the top bar, on Academia, where I am not a moderator?", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's", "an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site where I am not", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for “0 flags”,", "to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image", "on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for", "a site where I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not", "Why do I get a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar,", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to", "do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description", "especially on a site where I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable,", "moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been that", "where I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient", "on a site where I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's", "And it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been that way for", "Academia, where I am not a moderator? It links to the “tools” page,", "flags”, especially on a site where I am not moderator anyway… And it's", "site where I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a", "I am not a moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where there", "to the “tools” page, where there is nothing for me to do: ![enter", "exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert", "not a moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where there is nothing", "get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site where I am", "It links to the “tools” page, where there is nothing for me to", "a moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where there is nothing for", "bar, on Academia, where I am not a moderator? It links to the", "not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been", "nothing for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on", "“tools” page, where there is nothing for me to do: ![enter image description", "flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia, where I am not a", "there is nothing for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation", "situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an", "It's weird to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site", "moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where there is nothing for me", "for “0 flags”, especially on a site where I am not moderator anyway…", "the top bar, on Academia, where I am not a moderator? It links", "I am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient issue,", "anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been that way", "get a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia, where", "do I get a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar, on", "the “tools” page, where there is nothing for me to do: ![enter image", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially", "Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for “0", "“0 flags”, especially on a site where I am not moderator anyway… And", "stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been that way for a few", "is nothing for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png)", "it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's been that way for a", "on the top bar, on Academia, where I am not a moderator? It", "top bar, on Academia, where I am not a moderator? It links to", "where there is nothing for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same", "a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia, where I", "I get a yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia,", "“0 flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia, where I am not", "on Academia, where I am not a moderator? It links to the “tools”", "Same situation exists on Meta: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a", "am not moderator anyway… And it's stable, it's not a transient issue, it's", "for me to do: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/6fd7s.png) Same situation exists on Meta:", "to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site where I", "am not a moderator? It links to the “tools” page, where there is", "alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site where I am not moderator", "it's not a transient issue, it's been that way for a few minutes.", "yellow “0 flag” alert on the top bar, on Academia, where I am", "links to the “tools” page, where there is nothing for me to do:", "weird to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on a site where", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KNKe0.png) It's weird to get an alert for “0 flags”, especially on" ]
[ "in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one", "is the Training Manager of the company he is touting. I don't want", "he is touting. I don't want to link to these spammers' websites. I", "There is a lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from", "of the company he is touting. I don't want to link to these", "did a search of the name, product and company and both cases are", "shows he works for the company that he is \"recommending\", I would not", "are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager", "Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company he is touting. I", "for the company that he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if", "these spammers' websites. I did a search of the name, product and company", "search shows he works for the company that he is \"recommending\", I would", "is touting. I don't want to link to these spammers' websites. I did", "thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company he is touting.", "I would not be surprised if more are spamming. Another one in the", "blatant one as a quick search shows he works for the company that", "Pack is a blatant one as a quick search shows he works for", "[here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one as a quick", "a lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack", "that he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more are spamming.", "one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company", "reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one as a quick search shows", "if more are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the", "a quick search shows he works for the company that he is \"recommending\",", "surprised if more are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is", "of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a", "spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of", "link to these spammers' websites. I did a search of the name, product", "Ian Pack is a blatant one as a quick search shows he works", "from Ian Pack is a blatant one as a quick search shows he", "\"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more are spamming. Another one in", "would not be surprised if more are spamming. Another one in the thread,", "the company that he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more", "Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company he is touting. I don't", "to link to these spammers' websites. I did a search of the name,", "company he is touting. I don't want to link to these spammers' websites.", "spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant", "is a blatant one as a quick search shows he works for the", "want to link to these spammers' websites. I did a search of the", "more are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training", "a blatant one as a quick search shows he works for the company", "lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is", "is a lot of spam in the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian", "of the name, product and company and both cases are employees spamming their", "be surprised if more are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev,", "Another one in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the", "websites. I did a search of the name, product and company and both", "one as a quick search shows he works for the company that he", "the replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one as", "not be surprised if more are spamming. Another one in the thread, Dusid", "touting. I don't want to link to these spammers' websites. I did a", "I did a search of the name, product and company and both cases", "search of the name, product and company and both cases are employees spamming", "he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more are spamming. Another", "the Training Manager of the company he is touting. I don't want to", "company that he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more are", "the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one as a quick search", "the name, product and company and both cases are employees spamming their products.", "a search of the name, product and company and both cases are employees", "is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised if more are spamming. Another one", "quick search shows he works for the company that he is \"recommending\", I", "the company he is touting. I don't want to link to these spammers'", "I don't want to link to these spammers' websites. I did a search", "spammers' websites. I did a search of the name, product and company and", "to these spammers' websites. I did a search of the name, product and", "as a quick search shows he works for the company that he is", "the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company he is", "works for the company that he is \"recommending\", I would not be surprised", "Manager of the company he is touting. I don't want to link to", "he works for the company that he is \"recommending\", I would not be", "in the thread, Dusid Fegtev, is the Training Manager of the company he", "Training Manager of the company he is touting. I don't want to link", "replies [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5170/what-systems-are-most-effective-for-monitoring-student-attendance), the reply from Ian Pack is a blatant one as a", "don't want to link to these spammers' websites. I did a search of" ]
[ "belongs on another SE site how do I vote to close for that", "as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se", "but I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If", "vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could", "belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site", "it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE", "I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something", "only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on", "If something belongs on another SE site how do I vote to close", "SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't).", "doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site how do I vote to", "close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest", "to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only", "on another SE site how do I vote to close for that reason?", "something belongs on another SE site how do I vote to close for", "could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs", "to either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but", "ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site how do", "or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it", "flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs on", "either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE, but I", "for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it", "suitable for SO.SE, but I could only suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which", "wanted to either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for SO.SE,", "on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site how", "I wanted to either vote to close or flag <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11360/form-get-method-prints-viewstate-value-in-addressbar> as suitable for", "suggest it belongs on ac.meta.se (which it doesn't). If something belongs on another", "it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site how do I vote", "(which it doesn't). If something belongs on another SE site how do I" ]
[ "from the question body that US conditions were at the heart of the", "words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a question on vacation having", "see that a non-country-specific question would open up for answers from each country,", "Since this site is inclusive I think the Q-A should be made general", "Q-A should be made general if there are general interest in the question", "be made general if there are general interest in the question as such.", "having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think", "time is typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates", "on vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense.", "can see that a non-country-specific question would open up for answers from each", "country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that", "general if there are general interest in the question as such. An example:", "question indicates a problem. As indicated the post was a general question applicable", "the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394)", "want. On the other hand I can see that a non-country-specific question would", "wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a question on vacation having the", "question is the better way. I realize this is probably not easy to", "However, when somebody looks for a question on vacation having the question, in", "if the OP is asking about their home turf, there should be space", "it: should we try to be very specific and excluding or try to", "think that providing a wide spread of answers to a more general question", "addition edit to the original question indicates a problem. As indicated the post", "questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific questions are fine. But,", "when somebody looks for a question on vacation having the question, in my", "show its US identity. The edit now makes the question very narrow and", "I think that even if the OP is asking about their home turf,", "up for answers from each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when", "conditions were at the heart of the OP. The question was later edited", "Following on the question [What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394)", "As indicated the post was a general question applicable everywhere although it was", "this is probably not easy to resolve but as I see it: should", "answers from each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks", "applicable everywhere although it was clear from the question body that US conditions", "the other hand I can see that a non-country-specific question would open up", "My own opinion is that country specific questions are fine. But, I think", "inclusive I think the Q-A should be made general if there are general", "vacation time is typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis", "the heart of the OP. The question was later edited to show its", "as I see it: should we try to be very specific and excluding", "question [What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific", "be very specific and excluding or try to be general and including in", "(read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is", "other hand I can see that a non-country-specific question would open up for", "heart of the OP. The question was later edited to show its US", "vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I", "excluding or try to be general and including in the these types of", "about their home turf, there should be space to provide general answers. Since", "I think that providing a wide spread of answers to a more general", "question applicable everywhere although it was clear from the question body that US", "more general question is the better way. I realize this is probably not", "sense. I think that providing a wide spread of answers to a more", "is probably not easy to resolve but as I see it: should we", "were at the heart of the OP. The question was later edited to", "US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific questions are fine.", "unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that providing a wide spread of", "question on vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little", "An example: the post [How much vacation time is typical during a PhD(", "OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific questions are fine. But, I", "I realize this is probably not easy to resolve but as I see", "if there are general interest in the question as such. An example: the", "the post [How much vacation time is typical during a PhD( in the", "to be very specific and excluding or try to be general and including", "at the heart of the OP. The question was later edited to show", "during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit", "there should be space to provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive", "answers to a more general question is the better way. I realize this", "somebody looks for a question on vacation having the question, in my opinion", "and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific questions", "way. I realize this is probably not easy to resolve but as I", "regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own", "specific questions are fine. But, I think that even if the OP is", "the Q-A should be made general if there are general interest in the", "is the better way. I realize this is probably not easy to resolve", "it was clear from the question body that US conditions were at the", "are general interest in the question as such. An example: the post [How", "a problem. As indicated the post was a general question applicable everywhere although", "probably not easy to resolve but as I see it: should we try", "a general question applicable everywhere although it was clear from the question body", "edited to show its US identity. The edit now makes the question very", "post was a general question applicable everywhere although it was clear from the", "is that country specific questions are fine. But, I think that even if", "should we try to be very specific and excluding or try to be", "providing a wide spread of answers to a more general question is the", "a wide spread of answers to a more general question is the better", "post [How much vacation time is typical during a PhD( in the United", "a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to", "there are general interest in the question as such. An example: the post", "to the original question indicates a problem. As indicated the post was a", "OP. The question was later edited to show its US identity. The edit", "questions are fine. But, I think that even if the OP is asking", "each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a", "or try to be general and including in the these types of posts?", "own opinion is that country specific questions are fine. But, I think that", "the question as such. An example: the post [How much vacation time is", "that providing a wide spread of answers to a more general question is", "try to be very specific and excluding or try to be general and", "questions about vacation in each and every country. This is really not constructive", "are fine. But, I think that even if the OP is asking about", "problem. As indicated the post was a general question applicable everywhere although it", "I see it: should we try to be very specific and excluding or", "easy to resolve but as I see it: should we try to be", "realize this is probably not easy to resolve but as I see it:", "we want. On the other hand I can see that a non-country-specific question", "space to provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive I think the", "general answers. Since this site is inclusive I think the Q-A should be", "question body that US conditions were at the heart of the OP. The", "limited makes little sense. I think that providing a wide spread of answers", "asking about their home turf, there should be space to provide general answers.", "the question [What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are", "on the question [What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and", "opinion is that country specific questions are fine. But, I think that even", "open up for answers from each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However,", "an addition edit to the original question indicates a problem. As indicated the", "narrow and opens up for questions about vacation in each and every country.", "and opens up for questions about vacation in each and every country. This", "in each and every country. This is really not constructive and what we", "This is really not constructive and what we want. On the other hand", "up for questions about vacation in each and every country. This is really", "that a non-country-specific question would open up for answers from each country, in", "localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion", "other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a question on vacation", "edit to the original question indicates a problem. As indicated the post was", "but as I see it: should we try to be very specific and", "made general if there are general interest in the question as such. An", "I can see that a non-country-specific question would open up for answers from", "and every country. This is really not constructive and what we want. On", "resolve but as I see it: should we try to be very specific", "would open up for answers from each country, in other words wiki-type posts.", "a non-country-specific question would open up for answers from each country, in other", "PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the", "little sense. I think that providing a wide spread of answers to a", "is asking about their home turf, there should be space to provide general", "fine. But, I think that even if the OP is asking about their", "that country specific questions are fine. But, I think that even if the", "answers. Since this site is inclusive I think the Q-A should be made", "think the Q-A should be made general if there are general interest in", "very specific and excluding or try to be general and including in the", "from each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for", "a question on vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes", "should be space to provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive I", "my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that providing a wide", "OP is asking about their home turf, there should be space to provide", "question as such. An example: the post [How much vacation time is typical", "vacation in each and every country. This is really not constructive and what", "was a general question applicable everywhere although it was clear from the question", "every country. This is really not constructive and what we want. On the", "indicates an addition edit to the original question indicates a problem. As indicated", "non-country-specific question would open up for answers from each country, in other words", "better way. I realize this is probably not easy to resolve but as", "to resolve but as I see it: should we try to be very", "we try to be very specific and excluding or try to be general", "is inclusive I think the Q-A should be made general if there are", "typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition", "as such. An example: the post [How much vacation time is typical during", "in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that providing a", "opens up for questions about vacation in each and every country. This is", "But, I think that even if the OP is asking about their home", "of answers to a more general question is the better way. I realize", "(the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original question indicates a problem.", "site is inclusive I think the Q-A should be made general if there", "for answers from each country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody", "original question indicates a problem. As indicated the post was a general question", "[Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific questions are", "country, in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a question", "of the OP. The question was later edited to show its US identity.", "States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original question indicates a", "is really not constructive and what we want. On the other hand I", "constructive and what we want. On the other hand I can see that", "much vacation time is typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the", "the OP. The question was later edited to show its US identity. The", "indicated the post was a general question applicable everywhere although it was clear", "question was later edited to show its US identity. The edit now makes", "to a more general question is the better way. I realize this is", "country specific questions are fine. But, I think that even if the OP", "interest in the question as such. An example: the post [How much vacation", "the question very narrow and opens up for questions about vacation in each", "specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country", "even if the OP is asking about their home turf, there should be", "United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original question indicates", "The edit now makes the question very narrow and opens up for questions", "country. This is really not constructive and what we want. On the other", "was clear from the question body that US conditions were at the heart", "was later edited to show its US identity. The edit now makes the", "although it was clear from the question body that US conditions were at", "US identity. The edit now makes the question very narrow and opens up", "their home turf, there should be space to provide general answers. Since this", "turf, there should be space to provide general answers. Since this site is", "indicates a problem. As indicated the post was a general question applicable everywhere", "hand I can see that a non-country-specific question would open up for answers", "and what we want. On the other hand I can see that a", "looks for a question on vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily,", "really not constructive and what we want. On the other hand I can", "spread of answers to a more general question is the better way. I", "a more general question is the better way. I realize this is probably", "what we want. On the other hand I can see that a non-country-specific", "On the other hand I can see that a non-country-specific question would open", "see it: should we try to be very specific and excluding or try", "not easy to resolve but as I see it: should we try to", "that even if the OP is asking about their home turf, there should", "general question applicable everywhere although it was clear from the question body that", "body that US conditions were at the heart of the OP. The question", "in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original", "the question body that US conditions were at the heart of the OP.", "the OP is asking about their home turf, there should be space to", "to show its US identity. The edit now makes the question very narrow", "question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that providing", "in the question as such. An example: the post [How much vacation time", "makes the question very narrow and opens up for questions about vacation in", "identity. The edit now makes the question very narrow and opens up for", "this site is inclusive I think the Q-A should be made general if", "is typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an", "parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original question indicates a problem. As", "the original question indicates a problem. As indicated the post was a general", "makes little sense. I think that providing a wide spread of answers to", "clear from the question body that US conditions were at the heart of", "for a question on vacation having the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited", "general interest in the question as such. An example: the post [How much", "not constructive and what we want. On the other hand I can see", "home turf, there should be space to provide general answers. Since this site", "be space to provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive I think", "very narrow and opens up for questions about vacation in each and every", "its US identity. The edit now makes the question very narrow and opens", "US conditions were at the heart of the OP. The question was later", "now makes the question very narrow and opens up for questions about vacation", "should be made general if there are general interest in the question as", "general question is the better way. I realize this is probably not easy", "and excluding or try to be general and including in the these types", "policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My", "the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394) (the parenthesis indicates an addition edit to the original question", "the question, in my opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that", "provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive I think the Q-A should", "such. An example: the post [How much vacation time is typical during a", "opinion unnecessarily, limited makes little sense. I think that providing a wide spread", "wide spread of answers to a more general question is the better way.", "to provide general answers. Since this site is inclusive I think the Q-A", "edit now makes the question very narrow and opens up for questions about", "question very narrow and opens up for questions about vacation in each and", "[What's the policy regarding localized (read: country specific) questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions", "specific and excluding or try to be general and including in the these", "the post was a general question applicable everywhere although it was clear from", "everywhere although it was clear from the question body that US conditions were", "The question was later edited to show its US identity. The edit now", "posts. However, when somebody looks for a question on vacation having the question,", "I think the Q-A should be made general if there are general interest", "the better way. I realize this is probably not easy to resolve but", "each and every country. This is really not constructive and what we want.", "think that even if the OP is asking about their home turf, there", "questions?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/415/4394) and [Are US-specific questions OK?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/188/4394) My own opinion is that country specific", "[How much vacation time is typical during a PhD( in the United States)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11336/4394)", "for questions about vacation in each and every country. This is really not", "about vacation in each and every country. This is really not constructive and", "in other words wiki-type posts. However, when somebody looks for a question on", "example: the post [How much vacation time is typical during a PhD( in", "question would open up for answers from each country, in other words wiki-type", "that US conditions were at the heart of the OP. The question was", "later edited to show its US identity. The edit now makes the question" ]
[ "question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: >", "situation are not likely to get very far, but we don't outright discourage", "types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that", "is it at [What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do", "to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description", "or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "with the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic", "screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about problems", "specific to one person's situation are not likely to get very far, but", "in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however,", "help center page. Nor is it at [What types of questions should I", "to one person's situation are not likely to get very far, but we", "as described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > >", "at [What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that", "When recently voting to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen:", "asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are very specific to one person's", "to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I ask", "phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they", "do note that questions that are very specific to one person's situation are", "discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions.", "is absent from the linked help center page. Nor is it at [What", "likely to get very far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific to", "but we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly", "explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we", "I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this description is", "Nor is it at [What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We", "problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate", "description is absent from the linked help center page. Nor is it at", "unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in", "has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this to", "> > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can", "are very specific to one person's situation are not likely to get very", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate", "recently voting to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter", "saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions", "topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this", "certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a", "questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like", "about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply to", "close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png)", "off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the", "outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic", "undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase:", "> > Note, however, that this description is absent from the linked help", "to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a", "graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I ask about", "a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this to our", "the linked help center page. Nor is it at [What types of questions", "facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or", "[What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions", "undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate", "can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this description", "> Note, however, that this description is absent from the linked help center", "SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic>", "person's situation are not likely to get very far, but we don't outright", "that this description is absent from the linked help center page. Nor is", "that questions that are very specific to one person's situation are not likely", "questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students", "ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this description is absent", "[What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that", "avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are very specific to one", "Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also apply", "detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this to our help", "about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this description is absent from", "can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics", "post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) >", "are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as", "not likely to get very far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific", "off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section", "We do note that questions that are very specific to one person's situation", "the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless", "however, that this description is absent from the linked help center page. Nor", "apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can I", "academicians as described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > >", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are", "this description is absent from the linked help center page. Nor is it", "get very far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some", "this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about", "are not likely to get very far, but we don't outright discourage questions", "an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with", "absent from the linked help center page. Nor is it at [What types", "off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described", "students are off-topic unless they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians", "also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What topics can", "far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites", "note that questions that are very specific to one person's situation are not", "sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can", "it at [What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note", "Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this", "page. Nor is it at [What types of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask).", "> Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic unless they can also", "that are very specific to one person's situation are not likely to get", "to get very far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates.", "undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed", "I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are very specific to", "we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage", "I saw this screen: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > >", "> > > Note, however, that this description is absent from the linked", "questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are very", "one person's situation are not likely to get very far, but we don't", "voting to close an off-topic undergraduate question, I saw this screen: ![enter image", "they can also apply to graduate or post-graduate academicians as described in [What", "very specific to one person's situation are not likely to get very far,", "should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are very specific", "list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add a section like this to our help center?", "described in [What topics can I ask about here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note,", "Note, however, that this description is absent from the linked help center page.", "discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list: <https://math.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic> Can we add", "don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain", "from the linked help center page. Nor is it at [What types of", "specific to undergraduates. Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has", "Some SE sites explicitly discourage certain off-topic questions. Mathematics has a detailed list:", "center page. Nor is it at [What types of questions should I avoid", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/9LQzD.png) with the phrase: > > Questions about problems facing", "linked help center page. Nor is it at [What types of questions should", "very far, but we don't outright discourage questions specific to undergraduates. Some SE", "questions that are very specific to one person's situation are not likely to", "here?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) > > > Note, however, that this description is absent from the", "of questions should I avoid asking?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). We do note that questions that are" ]
[ "interesting so I took a few minutes to remove a variety of typos", "come back to check responses for the question and the typos I had", "typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my time editing", "saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed the page. Later I come", "(\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed the page.", "took a few minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I", "the question and closed the page. Later I come back to check responses", "the question and the typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I", "responses for the question and the typos I had fixed have returned. Why?", "remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the", "the typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my time", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few minutes to remove a variety of", "question and closed the page. Later I come back to check responses for", "check responses for the question and the typos I had fixed have returned.", "the page. Later I come back to check responses for the question and", "found [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few minutes to remove a", "for the question and the typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did", "to check responses for the question and the typos I had fixed have", "double-checked the question and closed the page. Later I come back to check", "variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question and", "of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed", "typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed the", "edits, double-checked the question and closed the page. Later I come back to", "had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my time editing the question?", "and closed the page. Later I come back to check responses for the", "back to check responses for the question and the typos I had fixed", "a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question", "and the typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few minutes to remove a variety", "closed the page. Later I come back to check responses for the question", "I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste my time editing the", "question and the typos I had fixed have returned. Why? Did I waste", "I come back to check responses for the question and the typos I", "few minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the", "so I took a few minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\",", "etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed the page. Later", "I saved the edits, double-checked the question and closed the page. Later I", "minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits,", "Later I come back to check responses for the question and the typos", "I took a few minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.).", "a few minutes to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved", "to remove a variety of typos (\"gouvernemental\", etc.). I saved the edits, double-checked", "page. Later I come back to check responses for the question and the", "the edits, double-checked the question and closed the page. Later I come back", "I found [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/11411/is-there-any-scientific-rigor-in-scientometry) interesting so I took a few minutes to remove" ]
[ "the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra,", "archives. I guess it will be useful for our users who are new", "I realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of", "per answer? This is one way of improving it which strikes me. Can", "which strikes me. Can others point out the flaws and give inputs on", "by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? > > > Is it", "are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > > Can", "answer? This is one way of improving it which strikes me. Can others", "> What is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers,", "> I would like to see details in terms of: > > What", "post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by arXiv", "a bad idea, say, if we make it a community wiki with one", "I would like to see details in terms of: > > What is", "Is it such a bad idea, say, if we make it a community", "> > Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? >", "published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will my paper", "pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful for our users who are", "details in terms of: > > What is the purpose of archives for", "paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? > > >", "would like to see details in terms of: > > What is the", "like to see details in terms of: > > What is the purpose", "scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed", "we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives.", "be useful for our users who are new to academia. > > I", "for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > >", "a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way", "realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print", "> I realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose", "the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original", "publish papers? > > Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to", "below] > > I realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on", "> > Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for", "community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way of", "conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > > Can a published work (i.e.,", "one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way of improving it which", "> Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me?", "it such a bad idea, say, if we make it a community wiki", "of: > > What is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of", "arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication'", "strikes me. Can others point out the flaws and give inputs on improvement?", "arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? > > > Is it such", "as a 'publication' for me? > > > Is it such a bad", "it will be useful for our users who are new to academia. >", "also go to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by arXiv count", "on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text reproduced", "not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess", "down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text", "of improving it which strikes me. Can others point out the flaws and", "Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will", "improving it which strikes me. Can others point out the flaws and give", "our users who are new to academia. > > I would like to", "arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed when conferences/journals already", "understand the comments and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question", "is one way of improving it which strikes me. Can others point out", "electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why", "go to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as", "exist to publish papers? > > Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also", "> > I would like to see details in terms of: > >", "make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is", "they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > > Can a", "> > What is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific", "of pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful for our users who", "mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text reproduced below] > > I", "SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to", "comments and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted", "when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > > Can a published work", "new to academia. > > I would like to see details in terms", "Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? >", "definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will be", "idea, say, if we make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service", "if we make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer?", "question is deleted now, original text reproduced below] > > I realize we", "of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they", "to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by arXiv count as a", "a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will my", "to understand the comments and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The", "way of improving it which strikes me. Can others point out the flaws", "I guess it will be useful for our users who are new to", "> Is it such a bad idea, say, if we make it a", "useful for our users who are new to academia. > > I would", "to see details in terms of: > > What is the purpose of", "users who are new to academia. > > I would like to see", "accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? > > > Is", "on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful for", "I am unable to understand the comments and the down-votes on [this question", "text reproduced below] > > I realize we do not have a definitive", "> > I realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the", "pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way of improving it which strikes", "What is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such", "say, if we make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per", "work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted", "> Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > >", "and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now,", "unable to understand the comments and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851).", "who are new to academia. > > I would like to see details", "'publication' for me? > > > Is it such a bad idea, say,", "for our users who are new to academia. > > I would like", "> Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? >", "to academia. > > I would like to see details in terms of:", "now, original text reproduced below] > > I realize we do not have", "question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text reproduced below] >", "> > > Is it such a bad idea, say, if we make", "> > Is it such a bad idea, say, if we make it", "me? > > > Is it such a bad idea, say, if we", "terms of: > > What is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints", "the comments and the down-votes on [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is", "original text reproduced below] > > I realize we do not have a", "in terms of: > > What is the purpose of archives for electronic", "> > Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers?", "the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful for our", "[The question is deleted now, original text reproduced below] > > I realize", "such a bad idea, say, if we make it a community wiki with", "purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful for our users", "This is one way of improving it which strikes me. Can others point", "reproduced below] > > I realize we do not have a definitive answer/guideline", "wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way of improving", "count as a 'publication' for me? > > > Is it such a", "is deleted now, original text reproduced below] > > I realize we do", "is the purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv,", "needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > > Can a published", "purpose of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN", "academia. > > I would like to see details in terms of: >", "my paper accepted by arXiv count as a 'publication' for me? > >", "one way of improving it which strikes me. Can others point out the", "answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will be useful", "vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist", "(i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv? > > Will my paper accepted by", "bad idea, say, if we make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print", "archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? >", "see details in terms of: > > What is the purpose of archives", "we make it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This", "service per answer? This is one way of improving it which strikes me.", "papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed when", "a 'publication' for me? > > > Is it such a bad idea,", "a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it will", "have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I guess it", "will be useful for our users who are new to academia. > >", "already exist to publish papers? > > Can a published work (i.e., post-print)", "are new to academia. > > I would like to see details in", "it a community wiki with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one", "guess it will be useful for our users who are new to academia.", "for me? > > > Is it such a bad idea, say, if", "it which strikes me. Can others point out the flaws and give inputs", "of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text reproduced below] > >", "Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish papers? > >", "papers? > > Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go to arXiv?", "deleted now, original text reproduced below] > > I realize we do not", "such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are they needed when conferences/journals", "with one pre-print/e-print service per answer? This is one way of improving it", "etc.? > > Why are they needed when conferences/journals already exist to publish", "do not have a definitive answer/guideline on the purpose of pre-print archives. I", "am unable to understand the comments and the down-votes on [this question of", "pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.? > > Why are", "to publish papers? > > Can a published work (i.e., post-print) also go", "[this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/11470/5851). [The question is deleted now, original text reproduced below]", "of archives for electronic pre-prints of scientific papers, such arXiv, vixra, SSRN etc.?" ]
[ "I understand that questions on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature", "I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based", "we answering questions based on our personal experience when we could be providing", "up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when they are void of", "our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and think", "AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical", "answering questions based on our personal experience when we could be providing answers", "on our personal experience when we could be providing answers based on well", "often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\".", "and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our personal experience", "think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and", "are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are", "questions on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming", "Are we answering questions based on our personal experience when we could be", "are going to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical of", "often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on", "be providing answers based on well conducted research? Should we be up voting", "based on well conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that", "than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers often", "but I think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read", "SO.SE, but I think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often", "Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our personal experience when we could", "that questions on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature than the", "be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I", "the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers often are", "Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when they", "providing answers based on well conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\"", "experience when we could be providing answers based on well conducted research? Should", "on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions", "in nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our", "we could be providing answers based on well conducted research? Should we be", "of SO.SE, but I think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I", "based on our personal experience when we could be providing answers based on", "read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our", "\"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think", "be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when they are void", "nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers", "\"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we", "when we could be providing answers based on well conducted research? Should we", "then needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering", "typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed.", "I think our answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers", "voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when they are void of references?", "going to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE,", "could be providing answers based on well conducted research? Should we be up", "questions based on our personal experience when we could be providing answers based", "conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with", "needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions", "answers based on well conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers", "programming questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers often are \"softer\"", "on well conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we", "\"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our personal experience when we", "answers often are \"softer\" then needed. I often read answers and think \"Citation", "our personal experience when we could be providing answers based on well conducted", "we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when they are", "think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our personal experience when", "understand that questions on AC.SE are going to be \"softer\" in nature than", "questions typical of SO.SE, but I think our answers often are \"softer\" then", "research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree with when", "well conducted research? Should we be up voting \"easy\" answers that we agree", "personal experience when we could be providing answers based on well conducted research?", "to be \"softer\" in nature than the programming questions typical of SO.SE, but", "answers and think \"Citation Needed\". Are we answering questions based on our personal" ]
[ "are several questions with with the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia.", "on academia. Can a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't", "other stackexchange site that is likely to allow for questions about teaching, much", "\"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher be considered", "school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site", "be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site that is", "teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has anyone found another site that", "less at the secondary level. Has anyone found another site that allow such", "words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher be", "public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange", "that is likely to allow for questions about teaching, much less at the", "found any other stackexchange site that is likely to allow for questions about", "any other stackexchange site that is likely to allow for questions about teaching,", "about teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has anyone found another site", "an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site that is likely to", "site that is likely to allow for questions about teaching, much less at", "considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site that is likely", "I haven't found any other stackexchange site that is likely to allow for", "stackexchange site that is likely to allow for questions about teaching, much less", "teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I", "Can a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any", "school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher be considered an", "much less at the secondary level. Has anyone found another site that allow", "allow for questions about teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has anyone", "a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other", "academia. Can a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found", "the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher", "several questions with with the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can", "\"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site that is likely to allow", "haven't found any other stackexchange site that is likely to allow for questions", "to allow for questions about teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has", "questions with with the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a", "for questions about teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has anyone found", "There are several questions with with the words \"high school\" and teaching on", "at the secondary level. Has anyone found another site that allow such questions?", "teacher be considered an \"academician\"? I haven't found any other stackexchange site that", "with with the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public", "is likely to allow for questions about teaching, much less at the secondary", "questions about teaching, much less at the secondary level. Has anyone found another", "likely to allow for questions about teaching, much less at the secondary level.", "with the words \"high school\" and teaching on academia. Can a public school", "and teaching on academia. Can a public school teacher be considered an \"academician\"?" ]
[ "with a direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the", "rejected. What is the official policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly", "outright banned. I recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly link with", "a question to replace a bit.ly link with a direct link, and that", "a direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official", "I recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly link with a direct", "a bit.ly link with a direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected.", "was rejected. What is the official policy of this site for URL shortners?", "was under the impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned.", "question to replace a bit.ly link with a direct link, and that edit", "suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy of this site for URL", "policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no need for them.", "edited a question to replace a bit.ly link with a direct link, and", "link with a direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is", "shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a question to", "the official policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no need", "discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly", "either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a question to replace a", "replace a bit.ly link with a direct link, and that edit suggestion was", "that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a", "bit.ly link with a direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What", "or outright banned. I recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly link", "banned. I recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly link with a", "I was under the impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright", "URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a question", "official policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no need for", "What is the official policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's", "link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy of", "that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy of this site", "to replace a bit.ly link with a direct link, and that edit suggestion", "direct link, and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy", "recently edited a question to replace a bit.ly link with a direct link,", "and that edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy of this", "under the impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I", "is the official policy of this site for URL shortners? Certainly there's no", "the impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently", "were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited a question to replace", "edit suggestion was rejected. What is the official policy of this site for", "impression that URL shortners were either discouraged or outright banned. I recently edited" ]
[ "compare the answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating", "answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions", "questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few", "with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run", "use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to", "look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it", "of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should", "answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how", "When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try", "and compare the answers we have with the information available on other sites.", "the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10", "a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions", "your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow", "Google searches to see how easy they are to find and compare the", "people out there who need answers to their questions and don't even know", "[Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were", "this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and", "the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and", "few Google searches to see how easy they are to find and compare", "the answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the", "'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions", "though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed", "open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the", "Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you", "love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out", "it before, and see how we stack up against the rest of the", "before, and see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net.", "Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are to find", "there who need answers to their questions and don't even know that this", "their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive", "questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from", "quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are to", "questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that", "populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter.", "an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share", "that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and", "Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there who", "share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your", "searches to see how easy they are to find and compare the answers", "Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts", "questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a", "with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a", "is a whole world of people out there who need answers to their", "they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to", "eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack", "a few Google searches to see how easy they are to find and", "of people out there who need answers to their questions and don't even", "there is a whole world of people out there who need answers to", "to see how easy they are to find and compare the answers we", "puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been", "through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how", "they are to find and compare the answers we have with the information", "site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be?", "see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site", "need answers to their questions and don't even know that this site exists.", "We all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of", "world of people out there who need answers to their questions and don't", "stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval)", "rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated", "try to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never", "and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see", "is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern", "easy they are to find and compare the answers we have with the", "site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see", "of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with", "find and compare the answers we have with the information available on other", "the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have", "someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up against", "that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer", "is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in", "[Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there", "out there who need answers to their questions and don't even know that", "closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything", "or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post", "a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions", "seen it before, and see how we stack up against the rest of", "first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes", "that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google", "to their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they", "edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your", "arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look", "review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and", "how easy they are to find and compare the answers we have with", "to find and compare the answers we have with the information available on", "answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's", "to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with", "Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this", "last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are", "not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really", "part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that", "should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use", "Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and", "in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy", "don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what", "you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are", "a whole world of people out there who need answers to their questions", "of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers", "the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see", "are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going", "but there is a whole world of people out there who need answers", "impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of", "are to find and compare the answers we have with the information available", "could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below", "information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of", "will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through", "Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well?", "all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people", "whole world of people out there who need answers to their questions and", "Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but", "be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of someone", "the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part", "answers to their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When", "10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a", "have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only", "up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is", "have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an", "of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up", "sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do", "but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's", "the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they", "were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches", "we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review", "available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the", "that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first", "that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could", "who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up against the", "and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google,", "exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's", "what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site", "their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the", "against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open", "The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that", "Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked", "asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to", "below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health", "we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is", "really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these", "pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or", "at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before,", "see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not?", "only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of", "on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle,", "this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression", "never seen it before, and see how we stack up against the rest", "and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last", "going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss", "Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there who need", "how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation", "queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered", "even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will", "thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow users!", "know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their", "the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we", "from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at", "answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an", "Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's", "well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions", "who need answers to their questions and don't even know that this site", "an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the", "and see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The", "other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though.", "see how easy they are to find and compare the answers we have", "been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit?", "to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen" ]
[ "mean by this is, would situations that do not necessarily happen to the", "situations that do not necessarily happen to the person asking the question, but", "happen to the person asking the question, but could happen (and may have", "this is, would situations that do not necessarily happen to the person asking", "not necessarily happen to the person asking the question, but could happen (and", "would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by this is,", "(and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by this is, would situations", "What I mean by this is, would situations that do not necessarily happen", "question would have to be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and", "answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by", "I mean by this is, would situations that do not necessarily happen to", "person asking the question, but could happen (and may have happened) be permitted?", "the person asking the question, but could happen (and may have happened) be", "by this is, would situations that do not necessarily happen to the person", "The question would have to be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical", "be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted?", "is, would situations that do not necessarily happen to the person asking the", "to the person asking the question, but could happen (and may have happened)", "questions be permitted? What I mean by this is, would situations that do", "would have to be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic)", "very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What", "have to be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions", "realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by this is, would situations that", "to be very specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be", "that do not necessarily happen to the person asking the question, but could", "specific and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I", "be permitted? What I mean by this is, would situations that do not", "necessarily happen to the person asking the question, but could happen (and may", "permitted? What I mean by this is, would situations that do not necessarily", "and answerable, but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean", "do not necessarily happen to the person asking the question, but could happen", "would situations that do not necessarily happen to the person asking the question,", "but would hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by this", "hypothetical (and realistic) questions be permitted? What I mean by this is, would" ]
[ "2. Is it possible to lookup the history of rejected edits (for a", "just after my click I realized that I should keep some parts of", "the edit, as they improve the answer (my quick reject was based on", "to lookup the history of rejected edits (for a particular post, or globally)?", "keep some parts of the edit, as they improve the answer (my quick", "of the edit, as they improve the answer (my quick reject was based", "edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized", "I rejected an edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my", "realized that I should keep some parts of the edit, as they improve", "(If it does not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it", "rejected an edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click", "that I should keep some parts of the edit, as they improve the", "I realized that I should keep some parts of the edit, as they", "based on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection", "improve the answer (my quick reject was based on edit on a quoted", "1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not,", "not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup", "edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the", "quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it", "it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the", "comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not, it would", "a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If", "reaches the editor? (If it does not, it would discourage an eager editor...)", "quick reject was based on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment", "an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the history of rejected", "should keep some parts of the edit, as they improve the answer (my", "an edit suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I", "some parts of the edit, as they improve the answer (my quick reject", "that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized that I should", "on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor?", "was based on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the", "reject was based on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying", "(my quick reject was based on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does", "Is it possible to lookup the history of rejected edits (for a particular", "discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the history of", "editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the history of rejected edits (for", "would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the history", "it possible to lookup the history of rejected edits (for a particular post,", "possible to lookup the history of rejected edits (for a particular post, or", "my click I realized that I should keep some parts of the edit,", "after my click I realized that I should keep some parts of the", "eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to lookup the history of rejected edits", "as they improve the answer (my quick reject was based on edit on", "edit, as they improve the answer (my quick reject was based on edit", "material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does", "answer (my quick reject was based on edit on a quoted material). 1.", "justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not, it would discourage", "I should keep some parts of the edit, as they improve the answer", "However, just after my click I realized that I should keep some parts", "on edit on a quoted material). 1. Does comment justifying the rejection reaches", "does not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible to", "post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized that I should keep", "editor? (If it does not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is", "it does not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2. Is it possible", "suggestion to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized that", "to that post: <https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized that I", "parts of the edit, as they improve the answer (my quick reject was", "rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not, it would discourage an eager", "click I realized that I should keep some parts of the edit, as", "the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not, it would discourage an", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/12489/49>. However, just after my click I realized that I should keep some", "they improve the answer (my quick reject was based on edit on a", "the editor? (If it does not, it would discourage an eager editor...) 2.", "the answer (my quick reject was based on edit on a quoted material).", "Does comment justifying the rejection reaches the editor? (If it does not, it" ]
[ "that is not a perfect fit for the site was posted - mostly", "- mostly some consider it to have some merit, some do not. What", "Say, a question that is not a perfect fit for the site was", "but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers)", "generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate", "fit for the site was posted - mostly some consider it to have", "useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will", "just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence,", "(not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question", "was posted - mostly some consider it to have some merit, some do", "consider it to have some merit, some do not. What if said question", "it to have some merit, some do not. What if said question generates", "for the site was posted - mostly some consider it to have some", "that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted", "perfect fit for the site was posted - mostly some consider it to", "indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually", "some merit, some do not. What if said question generates some very useful", "the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually (if", "comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be", "some do not. What if said question generates some very useful answers (not", "What if said question generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but", "merit, some do not. What if said question generates some very useful answers", "question generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that", "upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful", "generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still", "very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness).", "not. What if said question generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted,", "some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the", "not a perfect fit for the site was posted - mostly some consider", "posted - mostly some consider it to have some merit, some do not.", "said question generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments", "is not a perfect fit for the site was posted - mostly some", "question that is not a perfect fit for the site was posted -", "a perfect fit for the site was posted - mostly some consider it", "usefulness). Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually (if not", "do not. What if said question generates some very useful answers (not just", "mostly some consider it to have some merit, some do not. What if", "if said question generates some very useful answers (not just upvoted, but generate", "have some merit, some do not. What if said question generates some very", "site was posted - mostly some consider it to have some merit, some", "answers (not just upvoted, but generate comments that indicate the usefulness). Will the", "the site was posted - mostly some consider it to have some merit,", "a question that is not a perfect fit for the site was posted", "to have some merit, some do not. What if said question generates some", "Will the question (hence, useful answers) still be deleted eventually (if not improved)?", "some consider it to have some merit, some do not. What if said" ]
[ "should help people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our", "the links of the left column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting", "links of the left column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting page.", "(freehand circle!) to go to the voting page. --- This should help people", "to go to the voting page. --- This should help people submit more", "like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing", "suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like", "in turn, which will improve our tagging system and the overall experience on", "our tagging system and the overall experience on the site (especially searching by", "circle!) to go to the voting page. --- This should help people submit", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left column (freehand circle!)", "submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging system and", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left column (freehand circle!) to", "that have not been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like to", "some [tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite being quite", "and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links", "more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging system and the", "voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit the", "tagging system and the overall experience on the site (especially searching by tags)!", "on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the", "of the left column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting page. ---", "which will improve our tagging system and the overall experience on the site", "vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of", "synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd", "Click on the links of the left column (freehand circle!) to go to", "column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting page. --- This should help", "voting page. --- This should help people submit more tag synonyms in turn,", "have some [tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite being", "the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png)", "quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and", "page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the", "synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left column (freehand", "to the voting page. --- This should help people submit more tag synonyms", "people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging system", "left column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting page. --- This should", "help people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging", "visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description", "despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left column (freehand circle!) to go", "people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image", "the left column (freehand circle!) to go to the voting page. --- This", "on the links of the left column (freehand circle!) to go to the", "I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on", "have not been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest", "suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left column", "on, despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag", "being quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms)", "suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter", "existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click on the links of the left", "This should help people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will improve", "page. --- This should help people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which", "turn, which will improve our tagging system and the overall experience on the", "[tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Lu0qk.png) Click", "go to the voting page. --- This should help people submit more tag", "will improve our tagging system and the overall experience on the site (especially", "not been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest people", "old. I'd like to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote", "[tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite being quite old.", "to suggest people visit the [tag synonym page](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) and vote on existing suggestions:", "the voting page. --- This should help people submit more tag synonyms in", "--- This should help people submit more tag synonyms in turn, which will", "improve our tagging system and the overall experience on the site (especially searching", "tag synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging system and the overall", "We have some [tag synonym suggestions](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/synonyms) that have not been voted on, despite", "synonyms in turn, which will improve our tagging system and the overall experience", "been voted on, despite being quite old. I'd like to suggest people visit" ]
[ "or be able to type in a site, or at least leave it", "to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to do", "Close\" on the second screen unless I select the meta site, which is", "the meta site, which is not the appropriate site for this question. Is", "on the second screen unless I select the meta site, which is not", "at least leave it blank so it can reflect that it should be", "this question. Is there a way to add either a list of .SE", "to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose", "[this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow,", "click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless I select the meta", "question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but", "to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image", "screen unless I select the meta site, which is not the appropriate site", "I voted to close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to", "voted to close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send", "unless I select the meta site, which is not the appropriate site for", "a way to add either a list of .SE sites, or be able", "that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click", "be able to type in a site, or at least leave it blank", "able to type in a site, or at least leave it blank so", "wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't", "which is not the appropriate site for this question. Is there a way", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to", "site for this question. Is there a way to add either a list", "Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless", "leave it blank so it can reflect that it should be on another", "site, or at least leave it blank so it can reflect that it", "a list of .SE sites, or be able to type in a site,", "choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that", "type in a site, or at least leave it blank so it can", "that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close", "I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless I select", "![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the", "the appropriate site for this question. Is there a way to add either", "to close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it", "\"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless I select the meta site,", "in a site, or at least leave it blank so it can reflect", "of .SE sites, or be able to type in a site, or at", "send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to do that:", "that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless I", "to add either a list of .SE sites, or be able to type", "not the appropriate site for this question. Is there a way to add", "StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description", "cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen unless I select the", "second screen unless I select the meta site, which is not the appropriate", "couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice", "vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to", ".SE sites, or be able to type in a site, or at least", "the second screen unless I select the meta site, which is not the", "I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png)", "meta site, which is not the appropriate site for this question. Is there", "but noticed that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png)", "is not the appropriate site for this question. Is there a way to", "select the meta site, which is not the appropriate site for this question.", "site, which is not the appropriate site for this question. Is there a", "on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed", "appropriate site for this question. Is there a way to add either a", "there a way to add either a list of .SE sites, or be", "to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I", "to type in a site, or at least leave it blank so it", "least leave it blank so it can reflect that it should be on", "it blank so it can reflect that it should be on another site?", "do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot", "Is there a way to add either a list of .SE sites, or", "Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second", "either a list of .SE sites, or be able to type in a", "question. Is there a way to add either a list of .SE sites,", "add either a list of .SE sites, or be able to type in", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote", "or at least leave it blank so it can reflect that it should", "programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that", "close [this question on programming](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12854/in-c-programing-a-single-variable-cannot-take-a-character-to-it-continuously), and wanted to vote to send it to", "I select the meta site, which is not the appropriate site for this", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\"", "for this question. Is there a way to add either a list of", "noticed that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second", "list of .SE sites, or be able to type in a site, or", "to Close\" on the second screen unless I select the meta site, which", "window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on the second screen", "it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I couldn't choose to do that: ![enter", "way to add either a list of .SE sites, or be able to", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Bj7YC.png) ![Second Close window](https://i.stack.imgur.com/MCaNr.png) Notice that I cannot click \"Vote to Close\" on", "sites, or be able to type in a site, or at least leave", "a site, or at least leave it blank so it can reflect that", "and wanted to vote to send it to StackOverflow, but noticed that I" ]
[ "be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for that?", "on specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session", "to game too much the reputation system? (or do we simply not care?)", "Exchange sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and", "policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and then, either by letting some", "some sort of tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s at", "simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see, and which I", "I would personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof): * what's", "[this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we just", "system? (or do we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could", "could see, and which I would personally enjoy, would be something like (or", "thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title", "would be something like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract?", "occasions for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we have some", "questions exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions (I think the site", "your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is", "or by prompting them on specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism", "has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference", "What should our policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we need", "at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be", "them to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not to game", "Do we need specific occasions for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally,", "fun now and then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist,", "research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is the most", "fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference for that).", "while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and then, either", "to keep their number (active fun Q’s at the same time, I mean)", "by prompting them on specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism has", "sites do, so as not to game too much the reputation system? (or", "graphics? conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever", "be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not to game too much", "Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit", "paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position", "the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously", "I cannot find a specific reference for that). As [this SE blog post", "we accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit agreement to", "some sites do, so as not to game too much the reputation system?", "site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find", "exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions (I think the site on", "we just don't want the site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What", "big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions (I think the", "then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting", "to have some fun, we just don't want the site to be overrun", "Example of “fun” questions I could see, and which I would personally enjoy,", "them unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit agreement to keep their", "want the site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy", "think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I", "so as not to game too much the reputation system? (or do we", "Some Stack Exchange sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun", "some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions", "a specific reference for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK", "fun Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them", "favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is the", "sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and then,", "questions”. What should our policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we", "do we have some sort of tacit agreement to keep their number (active", "something like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper title?", "care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see, and which I would personally", "the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki,", "not to game too much the reputation system? (or do we simply not", "too much the reputation system? (or do we simply not care?) Example of", "reference for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have", "prompting them on specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism has regular", "be something like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper", "same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki, as", "their number (active fun Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do", "community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not to game too much the", "occasions (I think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach,", "(or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics?", "we allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for that? Or if", "* what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's", "by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on", "accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit agreement to keep", "post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we just don't want the", "unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit agreement to keep their number", "the reputation system? (or do we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions", "soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions (I think", "Do we allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for that? Or", "“fun” questions I could see, and which I would personally enjoy, would be", "encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever received? * etc.", "title you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever", "see, and which I would personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets", "game too much the reputation system? (or do we simply not care?) Example", "find a specific reference for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's", "of “fun” questions I could see, and which I would personally enjoy, would", "little fun now and then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions", "allow for a little fun now and then, either by letting some “fun”", "have some sort of tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s", "do we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see, and", "we need specific occasions for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do", "you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever received?", "most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh", "I could see, and which I would personally enjoy, would be something like", "some fun, we just don't want the site to be overrun with “fun", "specific reference for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to", "for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some", "questions I could see, and which I would personally enjoy, would be something", "Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference for that). As [this SE", "what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title * what", "to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not to game too", "it's OK to have some fun, we just don't want the site to", "like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC", "regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and then, either by letting", "policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for", "I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki, as some sites", "SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we just don't", "if we accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort of tacit agreement", "reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so", "want them to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not to", "subsets thereof): * what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference", "either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them", "letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on specific", "site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do", "specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near", "to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do we", "Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to", "(or do we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see,", "what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's the", "Do we want them to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as", "Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific", "questions? Do we need specific occasions for that? Or if we accept them", "the site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy be?", "blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we just don't want", "cannot find a specific reference for that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/),", "and then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by", "fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for that? Or if we accept", "now and then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list questions exist, or", "but I cannot find a specific reference for that). As [this SE blog", "we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see, and which", "OK to have some fun, we just don't want the site to be", "we want them to be community-wiki, as some sites do, so as not", "reputation system? (or do we simply not care?) Example of “fun” questions I", "for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort", "of tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s at the same", "agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s at the same time, I", "which I would personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof): ", "tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s at the same time,", "enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof): what's your favorite research", "just don't want the site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should", "* what's your favorite research abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title ", "enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now and then, either by", "as not to game too much the reputation system? (or do we simply", "abstract? paper title? TOC graphics? conference title what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest", "title? TOC graphics? conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title", "overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do we allow fun", "title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? ", "ever encountered? what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've ever received? ", "have some fun, we just don't want the site to be overrun with", "we have some sort of tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun", "“fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do", "that). As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun,", "keep their number (active fun Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable?", "our policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions", "allow fun questions? Do we need specific occasions for that? Or if we", "“fun” soft big-list questions exist, or by prompting them on specific occasions (I", "them on specific occasions (I think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft", "with “fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do we allow fun questions?", "bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? what's the most ridiculously harsh review", "and which I would personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof):", "need specific occasions for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we", "explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we just don't want the site", "for a little fun now and then, either by letting some “fun” soft", "specific occasions for that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we have", "don't want the site to be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our", "sort of tacit agreement to keep their number (active fun Q’s at the", "fun, we just don't want the site to be overrun with “fun questions”.", "as some sites do, so as not to game too much the reputation", "on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find a", "is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered? * what's the most", "near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference for that). As [this", "should our policy be? Do we allow fun questions? Do we need specific", "that? Or if we accept them unconditionally, do we have some sort of", "time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki, as some", "be overrun with “fun questions”. What should our policy be? Do we allow", "As [this SE blog post explains](http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2010/01/stack-overflow-where-we-hate-fun/), it's OK to have some fun, we", "much the reputation system? (or do we simply not care?) Example of “fun”", "personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof): * what's your favorite", "TOC graphics? conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've", "session near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference for that). As", "a little fun now and then, either by letting some “fun” soft big-list", "the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot", "would personally enjoy, would be something like (or subsets thereof): * what's your", "number (active fun Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we", "do, so as not to game too much the reputation system? (or do", "Stack Exchange sites, while enforcing regular policies/limits, allow for a little fun now", "not care?) Example of “fun” questions I could see, and which I would", "(I think the site on Judaism has regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but", "mean) reasonable? Do we want them to be community-wiki, as some sites do,", "position title you've ever encountered? * what's the most ridiculously harsh review you've", "conference title * what is the most bizarre/extravagant/longest position title you've ever encountered?", "regular fun/soft session near Pessach, but I cannot find a specific reference for", "(active fun Q’s at the same time, I mean) reasonable? Do we want" ]
[ "discourage the asking of question like this? Do we want to encourage All", "I am starting to get the feeling that they fall under the >", "a little bit off. I think the question would be a lot better", "> > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about", "who asked it was actually applying to be a Diap. Do we want", "do anything to discourage the asking of question like this? Do we want", "that they fall under the > > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical", "of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this question [Who should", "the person who asked it was actually applying to be a Diap. Do", "the > > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_", "ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants", "administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general are okay, the questions", "to get the feeling that they fall under the > > you are", "thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I", "a lot of questions. I am starting to get the feeling that they", "we want to do anything to discourage the asking of question like this?", "asking a lot of questions. I am starting to get the feeling that", "better quality if the person who asked it was actually applying to be", "little bit off. I think the question would be a lot better quality", "Do we want to do anything to discourage the asking of question like", "seem to be a little bit off. I think the question would be", "for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general are okay, the", "particular I am thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative", "questions. I am starting to get the feeling that they fall under the", "a lot better quality if the person who asked it was actually applying", "open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of", "> > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this", "be a little bit off. I think the question would be a lot", "applying to be a Diap. Do we want to do anything to discourage", "of questions. I am starting to get the feeling that they fall under", "starting to get the feeling that they fall under the > > you", "if the person who asked it was actually applying to be a Diap.", "are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > >", "the feeling that they fall under the > > you are asking an", "question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask).", "asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > >", "While I think the topics in general are okay, the questions just seem", "am thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While", "in general are okay, the questions just seem to be a little bit", "In particular I am thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants for", "if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular", "this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the", "quality if the person who asked it was actually applying to be a", "question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics", "asking of question like this? Do we want to encourage All to ask", "question like this? Do we want to encourage All to ask different questions?", "lot better quality if the person who asked it was actually applying to", "[Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in", "about this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think", "happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking", "been asking a lot of questions. I am starting to get the feeling", "think the question would be a lot better quality if the person who", "question would be a lot better quality if the person who asked it", "a Diap. Do we want to do anything to discourage the asking of", "it was actually applying to be a Diap. Do we want to do", "okay, the questions just seem to be a little bit off. I think", "they fall under the > > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question:", "was actually applying to be a Diap. Do we want to do anything", "anything to discourage the asking of question like this? Do we want to", "positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general are okay, the questions just", "“What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In", "hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of [don't", "I am thinking about this question [Who should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions)", "User [All](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/406/all) has been asking a lot of questions. I am starting to", "under the > > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if", "> part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this question", "feeling that they fall under the > > you are asking an open-ended,", "think the topics in general are okay, the questions just seem to be", "just seem to be a little bit off. I think the question would", "the question would be a lot better quality if the person who asked", "of question like this? Do we want to encourage All to ask different", "I think the question would be a lot better quality if the person", "[All](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/406/all) has been asking a lot of questions. I am starting to get", "be a lot better quality if the person who asked it was actually", "asked it was actually applying to be a Diap. Do we want to", "the topics in general are okay, the questions just seem to be a", "> happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am", "> you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?”", "am starting to get the feeling that they fall under the > >", "[don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this question [Who should recommend", "\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I", "to be a little bit off. I think the question would be a", "applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general are okay,", "questions just seem to be a little bit off. I think the question", "to discourage the asking of question like this? Do we want to encourage", "has been asking a lot of questions. I am starting to get the", "I think the topics in general are okay, the questions just seem to", "person who asked it was actually applying to be a Diap. Do we", "get the feeling that they fall under the > > you are asking", "you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” >", "would be a lot better quality if the person who asked it was", "the asking of question like this? Do we want to encourage All to", "are okay, the questions just seem to be a little bit off. I", "the questions just seem to be a little bit off. I think the", "bit off. I think the question would be a lot better quality if", "recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general are", "actually applying to be a Diap. Do we want to do anything to", "want to do anything to discourage the asking of question like this? Do", "general are okay, the questions just seem to be a little bit off.", "an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ > happened?” > > > part", "part of [don't ask](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In particular I am thinking about this question [Who", "off. I think the question would be a lot better quality if the", "be a Diap. Do we want to do anything to discourage the asking", "lot of questions. I am starting to get the feeling that they fall", "should recommend applicants for administrative positions?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13029/who-should-recommend-applicants-for-administrative-positions) While I think the topics in general", "> > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What if \\_\\_\\_\\_\\_\\_ >", "fall under the > > you are asking an open-ended, hypothetical question: “What", "to do anything to discourage the asking of question like this? Do we", "topics in general are okay, the questions just seem to be a little", "to be a Diap. Do we want to do anything to discourage the", "Diap. Do we want to do anything to discourage the asking of question" ]
[ "to graduate level research but it was closed as being off topic. It", "as easily relate to graduate level research but it was closed as being", "research but it was closed as being off topic. It seems either the", "on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it seems the", "question could just as easily relate to graduate level research but it was", "undergrad research and it seems the question could just as easily relate to", "rules are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply", "are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something that other", "It seems either the rules are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently.", "that academic research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13342/is-it-a-good-practice-to-choose-my-undergraduate-research-topic-on-my-own-can-i) question, JeffE says that academic research questions are firmly on topic. However,", "topic. It seems either the rules are unclear or they are being followed", "question, JeffE says that academic research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic)", "could just as easily relate to graduate level research but it was closed", "being off topic. It seems either the rules are unclear or they are", "either the rules are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am", "the rules are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I", "was closed as being off topic. It seems either the rules are unclear", "inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something that other people can see?", "is about undergrad research and it seems the question could just as easily", "just as easily relate to graduate level research but it was closed as", "about undergrad research and it seems the question could just as easily relate", "question is about undergrad research and it seems the question could just as", "it seems the question could just as easily relate to graduate level research", "However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it seems the question could", "easily relate to graduate level research but it was closed as being off", "unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing", "questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and", "seems the question could just as easily relate to graduate level research but", "the question could just as easily relate to graduate level research but it", "topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it seems the question", "are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it", "research and it seems the question could just as easily relate to graduate", "relate to graduate level research but it was closed as being off topic.", "says that academic research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is", "firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it seems", "followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something that other people can", "are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not", "JeffE says that academic research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question", "it was closed as being off topic. It seems either the rules are", "as being off topic. It seems either the rules are unclear or they", "being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something that other people", "In [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13342/is-it-a-good-practice-to-choose-my-undergraduate-research-topic-on-my-own-can-i) question, JeffE says that academic research questions are firmly on topic.", "level research but it was closed as being off topic. It seems either", "off topic. It seems either the rules are unclear or they are being", "or they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something", "research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research", "seems either the rules are unclear or they are being followed inconsistently. Or,", "academic research questions are firmly on topic. However, [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad", "[this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13368/what-are-the-pros-and-cons-of-choosing-my-own-research-topic) question is about undergrad research and it seems the question could just", "they are being followed inconsistently. Or, am I simply not seeing something that", "but it was closed as being off topic. It seems either the rules", "graduate level research but it was closed as being off topic. It seems", "and it seems the question could just as easily relate to graduate level", "closed as being off topic. It seems either the rules are unclear or" ]
[ "post is provided so that people can, in the answers and comments below,", "provided so that people can, in the answers and comments below, test formatting", "that people can, in the answers and comments below, test formatting features of", "can, in the answers and comments below, test formatting features of Academia Stack", "in the answers and comments below, test formatting features of Academia Stack Exchange.", "people can, in the answers and comments below, test formatting features of Academia", "so that people can, in the answers and comments below, test formatting features", "is provided so that people can, in the answers and comments below, test", "This post is provided so that people can, in the answers and comments" ]
[ "that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for", "two ways to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged", "\"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags such as", "posts it would be easy to make the change. I see this also", "as a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"),", "[application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs", "I would opt for the former but what would be preferable. With only", "adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged", "to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged", "narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept", "to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to", "make the change. I see this also reflecting on how the tags are", "tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I", "for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag at the", "go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as", "as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but", "there are two ways to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show", "indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for,", "are two ways to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions", "as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school", "(as opposed to applying something). The tag at the time of writing this", "preferable. With only four tagged posts it would be easy to make the", "down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\"", "four posts). I can see that there are two ways to go here,", "\"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as", "change. I see this also reflecting on how the tags are built and", "such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former", "for the former but what would be preferable. With only four tagged posts", "would be easy to make the change. I see this also reflecting on", "at the time of writing this has been applied to 89 posts. A", "applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag at", "this has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared,", "here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a", "to make the change. I see this also reflecting on how the tags", "time of writing this has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new", "In the post [What does the “application” tag mean (and what should it", "tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show", "posts). I can see that there are two ways to go here, to", "[faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but what", "tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope", "tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see that there are two", "on four posts). I can see that there are two ways to go", "or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I", "'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but what would be preferable. With", "scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such", "'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to", "mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag", "'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see that there are two ways", "tagged posts it would be easy to make the change. I see this", "writing this has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has", "I can see that there are two ways to go here, to either", "brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern", "former but what would be preferable. With only four tagged posts it would", "to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base", "tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to", "[application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application", "tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged", "of writing this has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag", "\"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but what would", "With only four tagged posts it would be easy to make the change.", "does the “application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange", "tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something).", "exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications", "should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged", "\"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions", "[application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags such", "The tag at the time of writing this has been applied to 89", "ways to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\")", "new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts).", "mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application", "has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application", "questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but what would be", "can see that there are two ways to go here, to either use", "I see this also reflecting on how the tags are built and used", "jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag at the time of writing", "would opt for the former but what would be preferable. With only four", "only four tagged posts it would be easy to make the change. I", "tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\")", "the post [What does the “application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394)", "questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research", "accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt", "the “application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates", "easy to make the change. I see this also reflecting on how the", "applying something). The tag at the time of writing this has been applied", "of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as", "the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags", "and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application", "post [What does the “application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a", "a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty", "and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions", "see this also reflecting on how the tags are built and used in", "something). The tag at the time of writing this has been applied to", "for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag at the time", "'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of", "the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example,", "(currently on four posts). I can see that there are two ways to", "it would be easy to make the change. I see this also reflecting", "such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and", "the time of writing this has been applied to 89 posts. A relatively", "appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see", "'application'\") tag as a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions", "tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\")", "tag as a base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged", "“application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that", "questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the", "tag at the time of writing this has been applied to 89 posts.", "[faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see that", "\"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions", "opt for the former but what would be preferable. With only four tagged", "'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\").", "the former but what would be preferable. With only four tagged posts it", "has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can", "questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see that there are", "what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions", "tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the", "questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged", "four tagged posts it would be easy to make the change. I see", "A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on", "opposed to applying something). The tag at the time of writing this has", "concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag", "\"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down", "a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag should", "to applying something). The tag at the time of writing this has been", "questions tagged 'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed", "'application'\") tag should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying", "would be preferable. With only four tagged posts it would be easy to", "been applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show", "89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\")", "should concern applications for, for example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The", "either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and", "(and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show", "see that there are two ways to go here, to either use the", "[faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow", "but what would be preferable. With only four tagged posts it would be", "relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four", "posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently", "be easy to make the change. I see this also reflecting on how", "the change. I see this also reflecting on how the tags are built", "be preferable. With only four tagged posts it would be easy to make", "to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag", "use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") tag as a base and adding", "what would be preferable. With only four tagged posts it would be easy", "example, jobs (as opposed to applying something). The tag at the time of", "[research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show", "tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\")", "'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or", "the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags", "this also reflecting on how the tags are built and used in general.", "to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would", "\"show questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show", "questions tagged 'application'\") or to accept \"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions", "it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show questions tagged 'application'\")", "applied to 89 posts. A relatively new tag has appeared, [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions", "tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for the former but what would be preferable.", "\"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\") (currently on four posts). I can see that there", "\"hybrid\" tags such as [faculty-application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty-application \"show questions tagged 'faculty-application'\"). I would opt for", "questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show questions tagged 'faculty'\") and [graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged", "base and adding tags such as [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\"), [faculty](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/faculty \"show", "[graduate-school](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/graduate-school \"show questions tagged 'graduate-school'\") to narrow down the scope of [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application \"show", "[What does the “application” tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief", "that there are two ways to go here, to either use the [application](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/application", "tag mean (and what should it mean)?](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/169/4394) a brief exchange indicates that the" ]
[ "appropriate to include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was", "this was quickly removed. However, from what I could find, there are no", "specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times", "application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from what I could find, there", "many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the main", "was quickly removed. However, from what I could find, there are no tags", "chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one would", "it appropriate to include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this", "AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching'", "purpose, and on a second thought the latter option might be more general", "also other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that there", "but also other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that", "of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that there is a need", "types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that there is a", "and chose the former. However, either one would fit the purpose, and on", "results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant for many", "When adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose", "skills). Do you think that there is a need for such a tag?", "[62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant for", "should be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future", "the former. However, either one would fit the purpose, and on a second", "the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to include additional", "the tag would clearly be relevant for many of them. The specific phrases", "additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However,", "there are no tags describing this subject, even though such a tag should", "up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant", "'\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When", "tag should be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and", "from what I could find, there are no tags describing this subject, even", "phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively.", "and on a second thought the latter option might be more general (could", "an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from what I", "academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from what I could", "these the tag would clearly be relevant for many of them. The specific", "\"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few tags that deal with the", "them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and", "'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials in an", "job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from what I could find,", "from scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant for many of them.", "seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few tags", "thought the latter option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also", "I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either", "6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose between", "even though such a tag should be relevant for many questions here on", "and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one would fit the purpose,", "latter option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types", "'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one would fit the purpose, and", "respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and", "current and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up", "[Is it appropriate to include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but", "either one would fit the purpose, and on a second thought the latter", "the latter option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other", "to include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly", "However, from what I could find, there are no tags describing this subject,", "teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would clearly", "be relevant for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student", "find, there are no tags describing this subject, even though such a tag", "future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching),", "evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that there is a need for", "materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from", "here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation", "turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would clearly be", "(both current and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns", "this subject, even though such a tag should be relevant for many questions", "there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few", "could find, there are no tags describing this subject, even though such a", "tags describing this subject, even though such a tag should be relevant for", "and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the", "shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag I initially", "the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former.", "tag would clearly be relevant for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching", "evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag I", "current tags, with relatively few tags that deal with the teaching side of", "fit the purpose, and on a second thought the latter option might be", "a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few tags that deal with", "are no tags describing this subject, even though such a tag should be", "encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you", "with relatively few tags that deal with the teaching side of academic activities.", "the question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials in an academic job", "other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think that there is", "(could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do", "I can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags,", "describing this subject, even though such a tag should be relevant for many", "removed. However, from what I could find, there are no tags describing this", "for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the", "think that there is a need for such a tag? From what I", "such a tag? From what I can see there seems to be a", "subject, even though such a tag should be relevant for many questions here", "for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows", "many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up", "initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one", "'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of teaching skills). Do you think", "to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few tags that", "what I can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current", "one would fit the purpose, and on a second thought the latter option", "for such a tag? From what I can see there seems to be", "questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the main site,", "Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from", "is a need for such a tag? From what I can see there", "of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6", "on a second thought the latter option might be more general (could encompass", "be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of", "on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation +", "need for such a tag? From what I can see there seems to", "in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed. However, from what", "the purpose, and on a second thought the latter option might be more", "what I could find, there are no tags describing this subject, even though", "would clearly be relevant for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"'", "'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag", "but this was quickly removed. However, from what I could find, there are", "between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one would fit", "7 times respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and", "second thought the latter option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but", "I recently added the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate", "can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with", "From what I can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the", "question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/),", "chose the former. However, either one would fit the purpose, and on a", "ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and", "there is a need for such a tag? From what I can see", "site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the", "However, either one would fit the purpose, and on a second thought the", "Do you think that there is a need for such a tag? From", "recently added the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to", "and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation'", "a second thought the latter option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation'", "be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively few tags that deal", "and from scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant for many of", "quickly removed. However, from what I could find, there are no tags describing", "scanning these the tag would clearly be relevant for many of them. The", "evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding", "adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the", "tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However,", "general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of teaching skills).", "teaching skills). Do you think that there is a need for such a", "a need for such a tag? From what I can see there seems", "former. However, either one would fit the purpose, and on a second thought", "and future ones). Searching the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62", "a tag? From what I can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\"", "in the current tags, with relatively few tags that deal with the teaching", "include additional materials in an academic job application?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13669/), but this was quickly removed.", "'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation', and chose the former. However, either one would fit the", "see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in the current tags, with relatively", "'\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag", "the current tags, with relatively few tags that deal with the teaching side", "times respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose between 'student-evaluation' and 'teaching-evaluation',", "up 6 and 7 times respectively. When adding the tag I initially chose", "main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these", "that there is a need for such a tag? From what I can", "more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations of teaching", "no tags describing this subject, even though such a tag should be relevant", "relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones). Searching", "I could find, there are no tags describing this subject, even though such", "+ teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning these the tag would", "relevant for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"'", "you think that there is a need for such a tag? From what", "be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current and future ones).", "might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of evaluations", "tag? From what I can see there seems to be a \"research-bias\" in", "added the new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to include", "tags, with relatively few tags that deal with the teaching side of academic", "clearly be relevant for many of them. The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and", "such a tag should be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both", "a tag should be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE (both current", "The specific phrases '\"teaching evaluations\"' and '\"student evaluations\"' shows up 6 and 7", "option might be more general (could encompass 'student-evaluation' but also other types of", "new tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials", "though such a tag should be relevant for many questions here on AcademiaSE", "of teaching skills). Do you think that there is a need for such", "the main site, 'evaluation + teaching' turns up [62 results](https://academia.stackexchange.com/search?q=evaluation+%2B+teaching), and from scanning", "to the question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials in an academic", "would fit the purpose, and on a second thought the latter option might", "tag 'student-evaluation' to the question [Is it appropriate to include additional materials in" ]
[ "nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic because it has little to", "other (insert your own). In particular, there is nothing along the lines of", "your own). In particular, there is nothing along the lines of \"this is", "* cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about", "it has little to do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\",", "motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations ", "pre-canned motivations: cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations", "to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs", "problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site * other (insert", "particular, there is nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic because it", "be generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing", "cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about problems", "[Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find", "dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations:", "situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site", "* about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site ", "is off-topic because it has little to do with academia\", or \"it is", "to apply to others in similar situations about problems facing undergraduate students", "close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only", "database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot", "only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply to", "another SE site * other (insert your own). In particular, there is nothing", "the lines of \"this is off-topic because it has little to do with", "to do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic", "\"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to", "similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE", "the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply to others in", "multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned", "* other (insert your own). In particular, there is nothing along the lines", "little to do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even", "In particular, there is nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic because", "vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\"", "wanted to vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but", "about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site * other", "(insert your own). In particular, there is nothing along the lines of \"this", "own). In particular, there is nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic", "facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site * other (insert your", "to vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under", "along the lines of \"this is off-topic because it has little to do", "/ database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations: ", "find the following pre-canned motivations: cannot be generalized to apply to others", "* belongs on another SE site * other (insert your own). In particular,", "undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site * other (insert your own).", "has little to do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or", "belongs on another SE site * other (insert your own). In particular, there", "under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized", "I only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply", "following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar", "others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on", "on another SE site * other (insert your own). In particular, there is", "SE site * other (insert your own). In particular, there is nothing along", "is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\". Is this deliberate?", "I wanted to vote to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database),", "but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following pre-canned motivations: * cannot be", "of \"this is off-topic because it has little to do with academia\", or", "off-topic because it has little to do with academia\", or \"it is a", "in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another", "to close [Creating an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I", "lines of \"this is off-topic because it has little to do with academia\",", "do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question", "\"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\". Is this", "because it has little to do with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486)", "an central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the", "there is nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic because it has", "central multi-purpose dictionary / database](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/13711/creating-an-central-multi-purpose-dictionary-database), but under \"off-topic\" I only find the following", "apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students ", "students belongs on another SE site * other (insert your own). In", "site * other (insert your own). In particular, there is nothing along the", "generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate", "is nothing along the lines of \"this is off-topic because it has little", "with academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is", "academia\", or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\".", "or \"it is a [boat-programming](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about/14486#14486) question\", or even \"off-topic question is off-topic\". Is", "\"this is off-topic because it has little to do with academia\", or \"it" ]
[ "links, if I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that could be", "answer but couldn't find it, even when using every bit of information I", "could be a good meta question; what can you do if you cant", "have been trying to locate a particular answer but couldn't find it, even", "meta question; what can you do if you cant find some material on", "if I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that could be a", "a good meta question; what can you do if you cant find some", "that could be a good meta question; what can you do if you", "(in my case: it was an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome", "remember from the answer in question (in my case: it was an answer", "even when using every bit of information I remember from the answer in", "locate a particular answer but couldn't find it, even when using every bit", "it was an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots", "remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that could be a good meta", "but couldn't find it, even when using every bit of information I remember", "by F'x) I figured that could be a good meta question; what can", "be a good meta question; what can you do if you cant find", "can you do if you cant find some material on AC.SE even though", "you do if you cant find some material on AC.SE even though you", "if you cant find some material on AC.SE even though you are sure", "cant find some material on AC.SE even though you are sure it exists", "do if you cant find some material on AC.SE even though you are", "contained lots of links, if I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured", "from the answer in question (in my case: it was an answer about", "AC.SE even though you are sure it exists (or -ed at some point)?", "find it, even when using every bit of information I remember from the", "in question (in my case: it was an answer about dealing with the", "and contained lots of links, if I remember correctly written by F'x) I", "when using every bit of information I remember from the answer in question", "been trying to locate a particular answer but couldn't find it, even when", "I figured that could be a good meta question; what can you do", "you cant find some material on AC.SE even though you are sure it", "syndrome and contained lots of links, if I remember correctly written by F'x)", "what can you do if you cant find some material on AC.SE even", "information I remember from the answer in question (in my case: it was", "case: it was an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained", "bit of information I remember from the answer in question (in my case:", "the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if I remember correctly written", "figured that could be a good meta question; what can you do if", "using every bit of information I remember from the answer in question (in", "was an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of", "of information I remember from the answer in question (in my case: it", "question (in my case: it was an answer about dealing with the impostor", "correctly written by F'x) I figured that could be a good meta question;", "an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links,", "trying to locate a particular answer but couldn't find it, even when using", "it, even when using every bit of information I remember from the answer", "the answer in question (in my case: it was an answer about dealing", "I remember from the answer in question (in my case: it was an", "answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if", "F'x) I figured that could be a good meta question; what can you", "about dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if I", "I have been trying to locate a particular answer but couldn't find it,", "dealing with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if I remember", "lots of links, if I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that", "good meta question; what can you do if you cant find some material", "material on AC.SE even though you are sure it exists (or -ed at", "question; what can you do if you cant find some material on AC.SE", "impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if I remember correctly written by", "my case: it was an answer about dealing with the impostor syndrome and", "find some material on AC.SE even though you are sure it exists (or", "particular answer but couldn't find it, even when using every bit of information", "a particular answer but couldn't find it, even when using every bit of", "I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that could be a good", "with the impostor syndrome and contained lots of links, if I remember correctly", "of links, if I remember correctly written by F'x) I figured that could", "on AC.SE even though you are sure it exists (or -ed at some", "answer in question (in my case: it was an answer about dealing with", "some material on AC.SE even though you are sure it exists (or -ed", "couldn't find it, even when using every bit of information I remember from", "written by F'x) I figured that could be a good meta question; what", "to locate a particular answer but couldn't find it, even when using every", "every bit of information I remember from the answer in question (in my" ]
[ "information here? My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really", "paparazzi that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/... without the people's consent.", "story, an example of such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it", "of them in person (from a conference) and he made a conference talk", "more information about this, which I originally didn't want to. What do I", "know the information. I know quite well the topic of the papers. My", "of cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes such information", "I know one of them in person (from a conference) and he made", "I don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes such information on a", "My view of cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes", "originally didn't want to. What do I know: I know who are the", "positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their back. My view of cons:", "such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I", "to be a paparazzi that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/... without", "it was requested that I relieve more information about this, which I originally", "it non-ethical to publish this information here? My view of pros: it's all", "it's not really speaking behind their back. My view of cons: I don't", "behind their back. My view of cons: I don't want to be a", "a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve more information about", "relieve more information about this, which I originally didn't want to. What do", "\"How to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I", "white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true story,", "I know the information. I know quite well the topic of the papers.", "the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information here? My", "an example of such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was", "non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true story, an example of such", "well the topic of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish", "I know a true story, an example of such a situation with a", "(from a conference) and he made a conference talk from where I know", "a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve", "not really speaking behind their back. My view of cons: I don't want", "this information here? My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not", "to \"How to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that", "them in person (from a conference) and he made a conference talk from", "I relieve more information about this, which I originally didn't want to. What", "to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know", "cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes such information on", "to publish this information here? My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore", "a true story, an example of such a situation with a \"happy end\".", "who are the authors, I know one of them in person (from a", "[my answer to \"How to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I", "I mentioned that I know a true story, an example of such a", "back. My view of cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi that", "of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their back.", "this, which I originally didn't want to. What do I know: I know", "true story, an example of such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now,", "don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes such information on a random", "and he made a conference talk from where I know the information. I", "therefore it's not really speaking behind their back. My view of cons: I", "he made a conference talk from where I know the information. I know", "write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a", "a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true story, an example of", "conference talk from where I know the information. I know quite well the", "In [my answer to \"How to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659).", "answer to \"How to write a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned", "a white paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true", "view of cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi that publishes such", "speaking behind their back. My view of cons: I don't want to be", "conference) and he made a conference talk from where I know the information.", "didn't want to. What do I know: I know who are the authors,", "know who are the authors, I know one of them in person (from", "person (from a conference) and he made a conference talk from where I", "know quite well the topic of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical", "requested that I relieve more information about this, which I originally didn't want", "I know quite well the topic of the papers. My question: Is it", "end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve more information about this, which", "view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their", "from where I know the information. I know quite well the topic of", "be a paparazzi that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/... without the", "here? My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking", "that I know a true story, an example of such a situation with", "with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve more information", "Is it non-ethical to publish this information here? My view of pros: it's", "to. What do I know: I know who are the authors, I know", "are the authors, I know one of them in person (from a conference)", "where I know the information. I know quite well the topic of the", "of such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that", "know one of them in person (from a conference) and he made a", "information about this, which I originally didn't want to. What do I know:", "of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information here?", "What do I know: I know who are the authors, I know one", "know: I know who are the authors, I know one of them in", "about this, which I originally didn't want to. What do I know: I", "topic of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information", "know a true story, an example of such a situation with a \"happy", "situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve more", "that I relieve more information about this, which I originally didn't want to.", "talk from where I know the information. I know quite well the topic", "publish this information here? My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's", "papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information here? My view", "one of them in person (from a conference) and he made a conference", "authors, I know one of them in person (from a conference) and he", "the information. I know quite well the topic of the papers. My question:", "do I know: I know who are the authors, I know one of", "the topic of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this", "really speaking behind their back. My view of cons: I don't want to", "their back. My view of cons: I don't want to be a paparazzi", "question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information here? My view of pros:", "My view of pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind", "example of such a situation with a \"happy end\". Now, it was requested", "\"happy end\". Now, it was requested that I relieve more information about this,", "made a conference talk from where I know the information. I know quite", "non-ethical to publish this information here? My view of pros: it's all positive,", "Now, it was requested that I relieve more information about this, which I", "I originally didn't want to. What do I know: I know who are", "My question: Is it non-ethical to publish this information here? My view of", "I know who are the authors, I know one of them in person", "I know: I know who are the authors, I know one of them", "a conference talk from where I know the information. I know quite well", "all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their back. My view of", "in person (from a conference) and he made a conference talk from where", "was requested that I relieve more information about this, which I originally didn't", "a conference) and he made a conference talk from where I know the", "pros: it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their back. My", "a paparazzi that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/... without the people's", "it's all positive, therefore it's not really speaking behind their back. My view", "paper for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true story, an", "the authors, I know one of them in person (from a conference) and", "want to be a paparazzi that publishes such information on a random webpage/blog/...", "information. I know quite well the topic of the papers. My question: Is", "which I originally didn't want to. What do I know: I know who", "for a non-academic\"](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/14659). I mentioned that I know a true story, an example", "mentioned that I know a true story, an example of such a situation", "want to. What do I know: I know who are the authors, I", "quite well the topic of the papers. My question: Is it non-ethical to" ]
[ "purpose of the forum seems to be that the questions should benefit both", "on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed to", "this is the appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose", "because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the community", "accepted without question, or relevance to the stated purpose of the forum. So", "have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without", "questions to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant", "relevance to the stated purpose of the forum. So my question is, what", "(if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions to", "about writing a cv for an internship was put on hold on vote", "return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an undergrad", "benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about writing a cv", "some questions to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally", "be admitted to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to", "put on hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to", "dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or relevance to the stated purpose", "to be accepted without question, or relevance to the stated purpose of the", "place to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum seems", "an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What", "the forum. So my question is, what is the policy (if any) to", "cv for an internship was put on hold on vote because it was", "questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about writing", "to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an", "Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to", "should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about writing a", "the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However", "and unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for", "[Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions", "the forum seems to be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate", "is, what is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not", "a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about", "similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout with great", "grades, research projects and CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or", "the appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of the", "sure if this is the appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The", "undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options", "It's not fair for some questions to get put on hold/deleted for being", "and academicians. A question about writing a cv for an internship was put", "any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions to get", "for an internship was put on hold on vote because it was deemed", "So my question is, what is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent", "questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout with great grades,", "with great grades, research projects and CV have to return to university (or", "that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question", "a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem", "hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed to stay", "enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout", "degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or relevance", "be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A", "academicians. A question about writing a cv for an internship was put on", "vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research", "for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed to stay up.", "question, or relevance to the stated purpose of the forum. So my question", "is the appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of", "hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest", "purpose of the forum. So my question is, what is the policy (if", "rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair", "community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar", "on vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of", "Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does college", "options does college dropout with great grades, research projects and CV have to", "dropout with great grades, research projects and CV have to return to university", "[Is it possible to be admitted to a Master's program after not completing", "without an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to a Master's program", "program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be", "not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without", "to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions to get put", "get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are", "undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to a Master's program after not", "fair for some questions to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when", "if this is the appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The stated", "undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about writing a cv for an", "of the forum seems to be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates,", "what is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair", "graduate students and academicians. A question about writing a cv for an internship", "college dropout with great grades, research projects and CV have to return to", "to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is", "vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the", "to be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians.", "stated purpose of the forum. So my question is, what is the policy", "not sure if this is the appropriate place to raise this issue, but:", "for some questions to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other", "after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted", "(or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible", "stated purpose of the forum seems to be that the questions should benefit", "or getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible to be", "ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions to get put on", "to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions", "was put on hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful", "getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted", "issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum seems to be that the", "grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to a", "The stated purpose of the forum seems to be that the questions should", "a cv for an internship was put on hold on vote because it", "the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some", "to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or relevance to the", "question is, what is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's", "an internship was put on hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic", "projects and CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into", "was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing a", "jobs [What options does college dropout with great grades, research projects and CV", "my question is, what is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation?", "policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions", "academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or relevance to the stated", "consistent moderation? It's not fair for some questions to get put on hold/deleted", "does college dropout with great grades, research projects and CV have to return", "Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or", "obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout with great grades, research projects", "to the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate", "of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough.", "not fair for some questions to get put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant", "writing a cv for an internship was put on hold on vote because", "admitted to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic", "the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship)", "I'm not sure if this is the appropriate place to raise this issue,", "due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question, or relevance to", "this issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum seems to be that", "on hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the", "without question, or relevance to the stated purpose of the forum. So my", "school without an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to a Master's", "to the stated purpose of the forum. So my question is, what is", "and CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad", "university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is it", "it was deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing", "or relevance to the stated purpose of the forum. So my question is,", "research jobs [What options does college dropout with great grades, research projects and", "to be admitted to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due", "question about writing a cv for an internship was put on hold on", "[What options does college dropout with great grades, research projects and CV have", "forum seems to be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students", "possible to be admitted to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree", "deemed off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum", "great grades, research projects and CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha)", "to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum seems to", "about obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout with great grades, research", "for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs", "the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about", "put on hold/deleted for being irrelevant when other equally irrelevant questions are allowed", "thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible to", "students and academicians. A question about writing a cv for an internship was", "forum. So my question is, what is the policy (if any) to ensure", "it possible to be admitted to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's", "both undegraduates, graduate students and academicians. A question about writing a cv for", "to a Master's program after not completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree)", "appropriate place to raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum", "of the forum. So my question is, what is the policy (if any)", "raise this issue, but: The stated purpose of the forum seems to be", "completing Bachelor's degree due to academic dishonesty?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15288/is-it-possible-to-do-a-masters-degree-without-obtaining-a-bachelors-degree) seem to be accepted without question,", "into grad school without an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to", "moderation? It's not fair for some questions to get put on hold/deleted for", "off-topic and unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae", "internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does", "However similar questions about obtaining research jobs [What options does college dropout with", "an undergrad [Is it possible to be admitted to a Master's program after", "seem to be accepted without question, or relevance to the stated purpose of", "the stated purpose of the forum. So my question is, what is the", "A question about writing a cv for an internship was put on hold", "be accepted without question, or relevance to the stated purpose of the forum.", "unhelpful to the rest of the community [Preparing a curriculum vitae for an", "but: The stated purpose of the forum seems to be that the questions", "CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting into grad school", "curriculum vitae for an undergraduate internship](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15291/preparing-a-curriculum-vitae-for-an-undergraduate-internship) Fair enough. However similar questions about obtaining", "internship was put on hold on vote because it was deemed off-topic and", "seems to be that the questions should benefit both undegraduates, graduate students and", "is the policy (if any) to ensure consistent moderation? It's not fair for", "research projects and CV have to return to university (or thinktanks)?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15316/what-options-does-college-dropout-with-great-grades-research-projects-and-cv-ha) or getting" ]
[ "have MathJax support on Academia? I think it would be useful if questions", "in academic writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there", "common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been", "think it would be useful if questions about math in academic writing are", "questions about math in academic writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15)", "about math in academic writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question", "if questions about math in academic writing are common here. I just asked", "academic writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it", "on Academia? I think it would be useful if questions about math in", "I think it would be useful if questions about math in academic writing", "Should we have MathJax support on Academia? I think it would be useful", "MathJax support on Academia? I think it would be useful if questions about", "useful if questions about math in academic writing are common here. I just", "just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been nice (but not", "would be useful if questions about math in academic writing are common here.", "support on Academia? I think it would be useful if questions about math", "we have MathJax support on Academia? I think it would be useful if", "here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been nice", "asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been nice (but not necessary).", "writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would", "are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have", "Academia? I think it would be useful if questions about math in academic", "I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and there it would have been nice (but", "be useful if questions about math in academic writing are common here. I", "it would be useful if questions about math in academic writing are common", "math in academic writing are common here. I just asked [this](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15559/referencing-non-equations-see-eq-15-see-ineq-15) question and" ]
[ "you who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at all to graduate", "than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT", "the dissenting nature of my answer. What can we do to encourage mods", "my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature", "leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is", "am worried that the rep system is leading to careless moderators coming into", "intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if they want to do", "a careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of my answer.", "me is whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is even less", "a sign of mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's", "deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting", "Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental health is what I'm", "top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my", "what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a", "rep system is leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part of my", "mental health issues is over the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a", "if they want to do what it takes to get a PhD might", "deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which", "my answer. What can we do to encourage mods not to delete things", "is leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What", "mods not to delete things they haven't really read, and to encourage the", "in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign", "even less likely at all to graduate with a PhD than someone who", "death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental health is what", "mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this", "attribute, but he deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due", "of mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning", "feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at all to graduate with a", "waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental health is what I'm getting", "positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done", "they haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion of people to power", "all to graduate with a PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1", "with a PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death.", "what it takes to get a PhD might have mental health issues is", "someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at all", "mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is", "want to do what it takes to get a PhD might have mental", "and to encourage the promotion of people to power based on quality, not", "they want to do what it takes to get a PhD might have", "can we do to encourage mods not to delete things they haven't really", "who is not sure if they want to do what it takes to", "clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from", "answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of", "dissenting nature of my answer. What can we do to encourage mods not", "to encourage mods not to delete things they haven't really read, and to", "PhD might have mental health issues is over the top.\" I clearly said", "a PhD might have mental health issues is over the top.\" I clearly", "he deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due to the", "lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if they want", "is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows", "from a careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of my", "the rep system is leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part of", "over the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but he", "is unclear to me is whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure", "be a sign of mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting", "encourage mods not to delete things they haven't really read, and to encourage", "comment concerning this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost", "reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of", "a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather", "my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone like you who", "that the rep system is leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part", "somewhat unsure is even less likely at all to graduate with a PhD", "is even less likely at all to graduate with a PhD than someone", "The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension,", "do what it takes to get a PhD might have mental health issues", "mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from a careless", "at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack of reading", "takes to get a PhD might have mental health issues is over the", "read, and to encourage the promotion of people to power based on quality,", "who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be", "than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if they", "thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of", "sign of mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment", "not to delete things they haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion", "is whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely", "concerning this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly", "which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting", "passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to", "MIGHT even be a sign of mental health is what I'm getting at.\"", "careless reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of my answer. What", "get a PhD might have mental health issues is over the top.\" I", "almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone", "getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack of", "of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack", "Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental health", "a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps", "nature of my answer. What can we do to encourage mods not to", "to do what it takes to get a PhD might have mental health", "have mental health issues is over the top.\" I clearly said mental health,", "to delete things they haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion of", "to encourage the promotion of people to power based on quality, not quantity?", "do to encourage mods not to delete things they haven't really read, and", "carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure", "things they haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion of people to", "health is what I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage", "due to the dissenting nature of my answer. What can we do to", "graduate with a PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or", "unsure is even less likely at all to graduate with a PhD than", "it takes to get a PhD might have mental health issues is over", "to careless moderators coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear", "goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a", "shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness", "someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even", "done due to the dissenting nature of my answer. What can we do", "issues is over the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute,", "answer. What can we do to encourage mods not to delete things they", "Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone like", "reading, perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of my answer. What can", "to the dissenting nature of my answer. What can we do to encourage", "whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at", "haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion of people to power based", "coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is", "answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone like you who feels", "likely at all to graduate with a PhD than someone who goes in", "R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental", "a PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your", "we do to encourage mods not to delete things they haven't really read,", "health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from a careless reading,", "power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone", "is over the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but", "into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether", "is not sure if they want to do what it takes to get", "not sure if they want to do what it takes to get a", "less likely at all to graduate with a PhD than someone who goes", "I am worried that the rep system is leading to careless moderators coming", "that someone who is not sure if they want to do what it", "but he deleted my answer from a careless reading, perhaps done due to", "of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if they want to", "careless moderators coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to", "I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer", "\"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if they want to do what", "to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not", "to graduate with a PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure", "rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is not sure if", "is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that", "system is leading to careless moderators coming into power. Part of my answer", "to me is whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is even", "or death. Your waffling MIGHT even be a sign of mental health is", "sure if they want to do what it takes to get a PhD", "said mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted my answer from a", "of my answer. What can we do to encourage mods not to delete", "assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who", "someone who is not sure if they want to do what it takes", "this passage shows a lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due", "What can we do to encourage mods not to delete things they haven't", "I'm getting at.\" The deleting mod's comment concerning this passage shows a lack", "worried that the rep system is leading to careless moderators coming into power.", "was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone like you who feels somewhat", "even be a sign of mental health is what I'm getting at.\" The", "might have mental health issues is over the top.\" I clearly said mental", "comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence:", "delete things they haven't really read, and to encourage the promotion of people", "really read, and to encourage the promotion of people to power based on", "lack of reading comprehension, which is almost assuredly due to carelessness rather than", "like you who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at all to", "perhaps done due to the dissenting nature of my answer. What can we", "at all to graduate with a PhD than someone who goes in thinking", "of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me is whether someone like you", "the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive attribute, but he deleted", "health issues is over the top.\" I clearly said mental health, a positive", "who feels somewhat unsure is even less likely at all to graduate with", "to get a PhD might have mental health issues is over the top.\"", "moderators coming into power. Part of my answer was:\"What is unclear to me", "due to carelessness rather than lack of intelligence: \"Suggesting that someone who is", "PhD than someone who goes in thinking R1 Tenure or death. Your waffling", "unclear to me is whether someone like you who feels somewhat unsure is" ]
[ "see the paper in order to answer the question, but in other (e.g.,", "we allow links to pirated papers or force people to link to the", "behind a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers or force people", "you might need to be able to see the paper in order to", "to be able to see the paper in order to answer the question,", "this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15783/re-typesetting-an-old-paper-what-to-do-with-the-result) the OP links to a nature paper that s/he is interested", "version? For some questions you might need to be able to see the", "order to answer the question, but in other (e.g., this case) you might", "a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers or force people to", "In this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15783/re-typesetting-an-old-paper-what-to-do-with-the-result) the OP links to a nature paper that s/he is", "need to see the paper to answer the question. Does this affect or", "to see the paper in order to answer the question, but in other", "the OP links to a nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting.", "force people to link to the non-free version? For some questions you might", "The link appears to be to an illegal copy of a non-open access", "interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an illegal copy of", "link appears to be to an illegal copy of a non-open access paper", "be to an illegal copy of a non-open access paper that is available", "to answer the question, but in other (e.g., this case) you might not", "answer the question, but in other (e.g., this case) you might not need", "able to see the paper in order to answer the question, but in", "link to the non-free version? For some questions you might need to be", "OP links to a nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The", "to the non-free version? For some questions you might need to be able", "to pirated papers or force people to link to the non-free version? For", "be able to see the paper in order to answer the question, but", "this case) you might not need to see the paper to answer the", "paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers or force people to link", "questions you might need to be able to see the paper in order", "you might not need to see the paper to answer the question. Does", "available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers or", "an illegal copy of a non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind", "to an illegal copy of a non-open access paper that is available (presumably", "pirated papers or force people to link to the non-free version? For some", "s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an illegal", "to link to the non-free version? For some questions you might need to", "the question, but in other (e.g., this case) you might not need to", "not need to see the paper to answer the question. Does this affect", "nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be", "appears to be to an illegal copy of a non-open access paper that", "(e.g., this case) you might not need to see the paper to answer", "is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an illegal copy", "in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an illegal copy of a", "non-free version? For some questions you might need to be able to see", "is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers", "papers or force people to link to the non-free version? For some questions", "Should we allow links to pirated papers or force people to link to", "links to pirated papers or force people to link to the non-free version?", "might not need to see the paper to answer the question. Does this", "that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an", "paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to be to", "paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links to", "allow links to pirated papers or force people to link to the non-free", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15783/re-typesetting-an-old-paper-what-to-do-with-the-result) the OP links to a nature paper that s/he is interested in", "but in other (e.g., this case) you might not need to see the", "some questions you might need to be able to see the paper in", "a non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we", "a nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears to", "case) you might not need to see the paper to answer the question.", "might need to be able to see the paper in order to answer", "access paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links", "other (e.g., this case) you might not need to see the paper to", "paper in order to answer the question, but in other (e.g., this case)", "copy of a non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall).", "the non-free version? For some questions you might need to be able to", "in other (e.g., this case) you might not need to see the paper", "For some questions you might need to be able to see the paper", "of a non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should", "question, but in other (e.g., this case) you might not need to see", "links to a nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link", "to see the paper to answer the question. Does this affect or decision?", "to be to an illegal copy of a non-open access paper that is", "people to link to the non-free version? For some questions you might need", "in order to answer the question, but in other (e.g., this case) you", "to a nature paper that s/he is interested in re-typesetting. The link appears", "or force people to link to the non-free version? For some questions you", "non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow", "re-typesetting. The link appears to be to an illegal copy of a non-open", "that is available (presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated", "(presumably behind a paywall). Should we allow links to pirated papers or force", "illegal copy of a non-open access paper that is available (presumably behind a", "need to be able to see the paper in order to answer the", "the paper in order to answer the question, but in other (e.g., this" ]
[ "right to judge other people's question as no question is stupid. If you", "there are really no right to judge other people's question as no question", "are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right", "to judge other people's question as no question is stupid. If you have", "viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to judge other people's question as", "other people's question as no question is stupid. If you have no interest", "or opinion conflict with mine, just go away please? I have no idea", "people's question as no question is stupid. If you have no interest in", "really no right to judge other people's question as no question is stupid.", "of them are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really", "in my question or opinion conflict with mine, just go away please? I", "judge other people's question as no question is stupid. If you have no", "is stupid. If you have no interest in my question or opinion conflict", "mine, just go away please? I have no idea why ppl like bad", "just go away please? I have no idea why ppl like bad fire", "please? I have no idea why ppl like bad fire work so much.", "go away please? I have no idea why ppl like bad fire work", "have no interest in my question or opinion conflict with mine, just go", "opinion conflict with mine, just go away please? I have no idea why", "two of them are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are", "away please? I have no idea why ppl like bad fire work so", "hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to judge other people's", "conflict with mine, just go away please? I have no idea why ppl", "question or opinion conflict with mine, just go away please? I have no", "you have no interest in my question or opinion conflict with mine, just", "I asked five question and two of them are being put on hold", "my question or opinion conflict with mine, just go away please? I have", "stupid. If you have no interest in my question or opinion conflict with", "no question is stupid. If you have no interest in my question or", "with mine, just go away please? I have no idea why ppl like", "question as no question is stupid. If you have no interest in my", "question and two of them are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously,", "put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to judge", "Seriously, there are really no right to judge other people's question as no", "no right to judge other people's question as no question is stupid. If", "them are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no", "as no question is stupid. If you have no interest in my question", "asked five question and two of them are being put on hold by", "being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to", "If you have no interest in my question or opinion conflict with mine,", "five question and two of them are being put on hold by viewer.", "and two of them are being put on hold by viewer. Seriously, there", "question is stupid. If you have no interest in my question or opinion", "are really no right to judge other people's question as no question is", "by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to judge other people's question", "no interest in my question or opinion conflict with mine, just go away", "on hold by viewer. Seriously, there are really no right to judge other", "interest in my question or opinion conflict with mine, just go away please?" ]
[ "its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for", "promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question", "a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and", "disorders. The question seems to ask about using it in what we might", "a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders.", "a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would rather not see", "US, modafinil is available by prescription only and is a controlled substance, so", "is better known in the US by its brand name, Provigil, and is", "am unsure about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs", "in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential", "the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I", "currently approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems to", "the US by its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug", "background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known in the US by", "it in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for", "makes me less comfortable. I would rather not see this site move in", "the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about using", "better known in the US by its brand name, Provigil, and is a", "I am unsure about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia", "ask about using it in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role,", "work, and arguably questions about drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the", "is a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work,", "questions about drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the current question has", "physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of academics", "of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better", "seems to ask about using it in what we might call a \"performance", "is available by prescription only and is a controlled substance, so using it", "US by its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently", "by prescription only and is a controlled substance, so using it without the", "There is a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their", "arguably questions about drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the current question", "rather not see this site move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins", "I would rather not see this site move in that direction. If any", "see this site move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to", "rather than for a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available", "(IANAL). There is a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve", "brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the", "Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of", "role, rather than for a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is", "to improve their work, and arguably questions about drug use in academia are", "direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal issues,", "the US, modafinil is available by prescription only and is a controlled substance,", "moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal issues, that would be welcome", "is a controlled substance, so using it without the supervision of a physician", "in the US by its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\"", "name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment", "by its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved", "in academia are on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which", "various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about using it in what", "me less comfortable. I would rather not see this site move in that", "\"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would rather not see this", "of various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about using it in", "move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on", "In the US, modafinil is available by prescription only and is a controlled", "only and is a controlled substance, so using it without the supervision of", "psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions about drug use in", "not see this site move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish", "and is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of various", "Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known in the US by its", "The question seems to ask about using it in what we might call", "improve their work, and arguably questions about drug use in academia are on-topic.", "question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known in", "probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of academics using psychoactive", "However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable.", "wish to weigh in on potential legal issues, that would be welcome as", "is a \"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of various sleep", "known in the US by its brand name, Provigil, and is a \"vigilance", "use in academia are on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor", "this site move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh", "that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal", "long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably", "we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical", "a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical condition. In the", "the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known", "approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask", "academia are on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes", "\"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical condition. In the US,", "their work, and arguably questions about drug use in academia are on-topic. However,", "any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal issues, that would", "of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history", "available by prescription only and is a controlled substance, so using it without", "which makes me less comfortable. I would rather not see this site move", "history of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions", "in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a", "about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that", "For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known in the US", "so using it without the supervision of a physician would probably be illegal", "on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less", "question seems to ask about using it in what we might call a", "are on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me", "has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would rather not", "to weigh in on potential legal issues, that would be welcome as well.", "If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal issues, that", "the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil", "might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical condition.", "a controlled substance, so using it without the supervision of a physician would", "supervision of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long", "would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of academics using", "less comfortable. I would rather not see this site move in that direction.", "than for a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available by", "a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available by prescription only", "SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in on potential legal issues, that would be", "to ask about using it in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\"", "call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical condition. In", "substance, so using it without the supervision of a physician would probably be", "it without the supervision of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There", "be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs", "the supervision of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a", "\"vigilance promoting\" drug currently approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The", "current question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would", "specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available by prescription only and", "controlled substance, so using it without the supervision of a physician would probably", "appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is", "and arguably questions about drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the current", "would rather not see this site move in that direction. If any SE", "a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of", "condition. In the US, modafinil is available by prescription only and is a", "us that modafinil is better known in the US by its brand name,", "academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions about drug", "modafinil is better known in the US by its brand name, Provigil, and", "enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil", "that modafinil is better known in the US by its brand name, Provigil,", "for a specific medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available by prescription", "weigh in on potential legal issues, that would be welcome as well. Thoughts?", "treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about using it", "modafinil is available by prescription only and is a controlled substance, so using", "using it in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than", "without the supervision of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL). There is", "unsure about the appropriateness of the question <https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us", "informs us that modafinil is better known in the US by its brand", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16215/modafinil-for-academics>. For background, Wikipedia informs us that modafinil is better known in the", "using it without the supervision of a physician would probably be illegal (IANAL).", "drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions about drug use in academia", "sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about using it in what we", "medical condition. In the US, modafinil is available by prescription only and is", "prescription only and is a controlled substance, so using it without the supervision", "flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would rather not see this site", "drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the current question has a \"how-to\"", "using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions about drug use", "about drug use in academia are on-topic. However, the current question has a", "site move in that direction. If any SE moderators/admins wish to weigh in", "of academics using psychoactive drugs to improve their work, and arguably questions about", "illegal (IANAL). There is a long history of academics using psychoactive drugs to", "about using it in what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather", "what we might call a \"performance enhancing\" role, rather than for a specific", "for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems to ask about", "question has a \"how-to\" flavor which makes me less comfortable. I would rather", "drug currently approved for the treatment of various sleep disorders. The question seems", "comfortable. I would rather not see this site move in that direction. If", "and is a controlled substance, so using it without the supervision of a" ]
[ "are on the same general topic) In each case, the community has tried", "seen a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a", "does merit attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's not at all", "easiest solution is for me to ignore these questions in the future. And", "indication that they're trying to act on the numerous sound bits of advice", "just go to the user page: all of this user's questions are on", "has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult for me", "tone in the questions also doesn't appear to help very much. Of course", "piece of evidence is that not one of the questions has an accepted", "they're trying to act on the numerous sound bits of advice the community", "because in all fairness each question by itself does merit attention. The problem", "course the easiest solution is for me to ignore these questions in the", "of this user's questions are on the same general topic) In each case,", "questions are on the same general topic) In each case, the community has", "I've now seen a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture", "on the same general topic) In each case, the community has tried (as", "at all clear to me that the answers are being taken to heart", "more and more difficult for me to answer yet another of these questions", "appear to help very much. Of course the easiest solution is for me", "at least show some indication that they're trying to act on the numerous", "the same general topic) In each case, the community has tried (as far", "of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee", "attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's not at all clear to", "here, it might be easier just go to the user page: all of", "is that not one of the questions has an accepted answer. It's also", "of evidence is that not one of the questions has an accepted answer.", "maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this", "clear to me that the answers are being taken to heart at all:", "these questions in the future. And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm", "series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional", "is for me to ignore these questions in the future. And maybe that's", "the question as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question by", "(Rather than list them here, it might be easier just go to the", "to me that the answers are being taken to heart at all: one", "And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging", "least show some indication that they're trying to act on the numerous sound", "to the user page: all of this user's questions are on the same", "The problem here is the sequence. It's not at all clear to me", "this user's questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't appear to help", "by itself* does merit attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's not", "topic) In each case, the community has tried (as far as possible) to", "another of these questions knowing the history of this user's questions. The tone", "completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it might be easier", "taken to heart at all: one piece of evidence is that not one", "same general topic) In each case, the community has tried (as far as", "each case, the community has tried (as far as possible) to answer the", "history of this user's questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't appear", "all of this user's questions are on the same general topic) In each", "questions also doesn't appear to help very much. Of course the easiest solution", "page: all of this user's questions are on the same general topic) In", "to try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show", "not one of the questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more", "questions in the future. And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering", "Of course the easiest solution is for me to ignore these questions in", "for me to ignore these questions in the future. And maybe that's the", "problem here is the sequence. It's not at all clear to me that", "act on the numerous sound bits of advice the community is dishing out", "that they're trying to act on the numerous sound bits of advice the", "the answers are being taken to heart at all: one piece of evidence", "merit attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's not at all clear", "the easiest solution is for me to ignore these questions in the future.", "advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it might be easier just go", "accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult for me to answer", "at all: one piece of evidence is that not one of the questions", "solution is for me to ignore these questions in the future. And maybe", "a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely", "that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user", "the sequence. It's not at all clear to me that the answers are", "much. Of course the easiest solution is for me to ignore these questions", "picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it", "show some indication that they're trying to act on the numerous sound bits", "some indication that they're trying to act on the numerous sound bits of", "answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult for me to answer yet", "relationship (Rather than list them here, it might be easier just go to", "more difficult for me to answer yet another of these questions knowing the", "are being taken to heart at all: one piece of evidence is that", "stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question by itself does merit attention.", "doesn't appear to help very much. Of course the easiest solution is for", "wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to try and dig deeper into", "that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list", "being taken to heart at all: one piece of evidence is that not", "(as far as possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because", "them here, it might be easier just go to the user page: all", "all fairness each question by itself does merit attention. The problem here is", "all: one piece of evidence is that not one of the questions has", "it's worth encouraging this user to try and dig deeper into the apparent", "case, the community has tried (as far as possible) to answer the question", "user page: all of this user's questions are on the same general topic)", "answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to try and", "these questions knowing the history of this user's questions. The tone in the", "the questions also doesn't appear to help very much. Of course the easiest", "of the questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more", "the user page: all of this user's questions are on the same general", "help very much. Of course the easiest solution is for me to ignore", "apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication that they're trying to act", "tried (as far as possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone situation,", "me to answer yet another of these questions knowing the history of this", "question by itself does merit attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's", "of these questions knowing the history of this user's questions. The tone in", "one of the questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and", "try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some", "of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it might", "becoming more and more difficult for me to answer yet another of these", "sequence. It's not at all clear to me that the answers are being", "to act on the numerous sound bits of advice the community is dishing", "paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them", "answers are being taken to heart at all: one piece of evidence is", "or at least show some indication that they're trying to act on the", "right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to try", "that not one of the questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming", "to ignore these questions in the future. And maybe that's the right answer.", "knowing the history of this user's questions. The tone in the questions also", "very much. Of course the easiest solution is for me to ignore these", "the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication that they're trying to", "deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication that they're", "each question by itself does merit attention. The problem here is the sequence.", "in the future. And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether", "as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question by itself does", "go to the user page: all of this user's questions are on the", "It's also becoming more and more difficult for me to answer yet another", "user to try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least", "far as possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because in", "The tone in the questions also doesn't appear to help very much. Of", "also becoming more and more difficult for me to answer yet another of", "user's questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't appear to help very", "this user to try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at", "all clear to me that the answers are being taken to heart at", "worth encouraging this user to try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction,", "the history of this user's questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't", "encouraging this user to try and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or", "the questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult", "into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication that they're trying", "dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it might be easier just", "the community has tried (as far as possible) to answer the question as", "list them here, it might be easier just go to the user page:", "general topic) In each case, the community has tried (as far as possible)", "difficult for me to answer yet another of these questions knowing the history", "But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to try and dig", "is the sequence. It's not at all clear to me that the answers", "now seen a series of questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of", "to answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each", "one piece of evidence is that not one of the questions has an", "of this user's questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't appear to", "from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather", "question as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question by itself", "me to ignore these questions in the future. And maybe that's the right", "as possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because in all", "[user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than", "the future. And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's", "might be easier just go to the user page: all of this user's", "community has tried (as far as possible) to answer the question as a", "for me to answer yet another of these questions knowing the history of", "be easier just go to the user page: all of this user's questions", "an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult for me to", "me that the answers are being taken to heart at all: one piece", "to heart at all: one piece of evidence is that not one of", "has tried (as far as possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone", "not at all clear to me that the answers are being taken to", "questions has an accepted answer. It's also becoming more and more difficult for", "fairness each question by itself does merit attention. The problem here is the", "yet another of these questions knowing the history of this user's questions. The", "this user's questions are on the same general topic) In each case, the", "than list them here, it might be easier just go to the user", "a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question by itself does merit", "also doesn't appear to help very much. Of course the easiest solution is", "the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to", "a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here, it might be", "easier just go to the user page: all of this user's questions are", "answer yet another of these questions knowing the history of this user's questions.", "and dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication", "dig deeper into the apparent dysfunction, or at least show some indication that", "dysfunction, or at least show some indication that they're trying to act on", "user's questions are on the same general topic) In each case, the community", "questions knowing the history of this user's questions. The tone in the questions", "I'm wondering whether it's worth encouraging this user to try and dig deeper", "future. And maybe that's the right answer. But I'm wondering whether it's worth", "to answer yet another of these questions knowing the history of this user's", "trying to act on the numerous sound bits of advice the community is", "In each case, the community has tried (as far as possible) to answer", "to help very much. Of course the easiest solution is for me to", "heart at all: one piece of evidence is that not one of the", "questions. The tone in the questions also doesn't appear to help very much.", "questions from [user10694](https://academia.stackexchange.com/users/10694/user10694) that paint a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship", "possible) to answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness", "in all fairness each question by itself does merit attention. The problem here", "and more difficult for me to answer yet another of these questions knowing", "It's not at all clear to me that the answers are being taken", "that the answers are being taken to heart at all: one piece of", "here is the sequence. It's not at all clear to me that the", "it might be easier just go to the user page: all of this", "on the numerous sound bits of advice the community is dishing out ?", "in the questions also doesn't appear to help very much. Of course the", "answer the question as a stand-alone situation, because in all fairness each question", "a picture of a completely dysfunctional advisor-advisee relationship (Rather than list them here,", "itself* does merit attention. The problem here is the sequence. It's not at", "ignore these questions in the future. And maybe that's the right answer. But", "situation, because in all fairness each question by itself does merit attention. The", "whether it's worth encouraging this user to try and dig deeper into the", "evidence is that not one of the questions has an accepted answer. It's" ]
[ "strikes me as exactly the kind of question that should be a \"community", "[advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does", "starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does seem too", "Layla has asked a question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While", "asked a question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a", "a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does seem too broad,", "a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but it", "pertinent and relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an", "question at first does seem too broad, it also strikes me as exactly", "be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but", "a very pertinent and relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution,", "a question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question", "It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced", "should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a single all-encompassing answer.", "has asked a question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such", "question on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at", "of question that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent", "it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a single all-encompassing", "at first does seem too broad, it also strikes me as exactly the", "question that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and", "seem too broad, it also strikes me as exactly the kind of question", "question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a", "that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant", "me as exactly the kind of question that should be a \"community wiki\"", "very pertinent and relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not", "relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing", "the kind of question that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a", "research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does seem too broad, it", "question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but it should be a", "for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does seem", "such a question at first does seem too broad, it also strikes me", "too broad, it also strikes me as exactly the kind of question that", "and relevant question, but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual", "it also strikes me as exactly the kind of question that should be", "also strikes me as exactly the kind of question that should be a", "as exactly the kind of question that should be a \"community wiki\" question.", "kind of question that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very", "but it should be a crowd-sourced solution, not an individual writing a single", "\"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but it should", "on [advice for starting a research group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first", "exactly the kind of question that should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's", "does seem too broad, it also strikes me as exactly the kind of", "wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question, but it should be", "broad, it also strikes me as exactly the kind of question that should", "first does seem too broad, it also strikes me as exactly the kind", "should be a \"community wiki\" question. It's a very pertinent and relevant question,", "While such a question at first does seem too broad, it also strikes", "a question at first does seem too broad, it also strikes me as", "group](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16618/how-to-start-a-small-research-group-in-a-institution). While such a question at first does seem too broad, it also" ]
[ "this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I", "without this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law.", "is right. There is need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife", "that it is not the right thing, then trying to correct it (less", "teaching part of a university employee's life. But research is as least as", "are also currently the only people who have that knowledge. The theorists of", "also currently the only people who have that knowledge. The theorists of science", "have created a body of theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting", "academia need to know how research is done. And I don't mean the", "argument above why this is the community to which it is suited, and", "suited, and not any other. It is up to the community to decide", "of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it,", "a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it, no", "who have that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors", "of what proper research looks like, whether on an explicit or on an", "why the wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and how to find", "it, because this site would be its natural home, just like in real", "to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before", "which is right. There is need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday", "this type of question. I would find it very sad if it decides", "other. It is up to the community to decide whether it wants to", "guide us, who define daily what good science is by deciding which article", "answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I would also like to note", "experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in", "this time), and still not getting it right. Graduate students need to know", "doing. Therefore, I think this should be part of the on-topic areas for", "or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a given experiment. This can", "covers the teaching part of a university employee's life. But research is as", "nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor", "to reject, by applying for grants for projects which are compliant with scientific", "would be its natural home, just like in real life, the university is", "without research, so maybe it is even considered more important by academics?). So", "I am in a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my", "life. But research is as least as important as teaching. (In fact I", "why I am in a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from", "have an understanding of what proper research looks like, whether on an explicit", "is as least as important as teaching. (In fact I know many academics", "wrong, and how to find the thing which is right. There is need", "was prompted by the fact that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence)", "of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a", "so maybe it is even considered more important by academics?). So people in", "she is doing. Therefore, I think this should be part of the on-topic", "supervisor or from reviwers that it is not the right thing, then trying", "this should be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the", "research is as least as important as teaching. (In fact I know many", "need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia", "teaching without research, so maybe it is even considered more important by academics?).", "community members who found it off-topic. I don't know why they think so.", "teaching one's field to students. Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting", "within academia is affected by it. Academics are also currently the only people", "is the community to which it is suited, and not any other. It", "I would also like to note that they couldn't think of a site", "vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies.", "or reject this type of question. I would find it very sad if", "better academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange", "to know it, else they do the wrong things. Professors need to know", "still not getting it right. Graduate students need to know it, else they", "knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in need of it, in order", "above why this is the community to which it is suited, and not", "done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax", "an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on", "about conducting research and teaching one's field to students. Academia already has an", "in a given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of", "site which is better suited, and I think I made it clear in", "things. Professors need to know it, so they can explain to their grad", "the experts in one topic answer the questions of the people starting out", "it is just because \"this is not the kind of question we are", "stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in", "conducting research and teaching one's field to students. Academia already has an explicit", "is not the right thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated this", "struggles with becoming better in what he or she is doing. Therefore, I", "quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a given experiment. This can be", "field to students. Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting questions on", "she is in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research without this", "reactions from community members who found it off-topic. I don't know why they", "around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought", "and not any other. It is up to the community to decide whether", "by academics?). So people in academia need to know how research is done.", "I don't know why they think so. Butif it is just because \"this", "then trying to correct it (less motivated this time), and still not getting", "should be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right", "tried doing research that way for the last four years and wondered why", "wondered why I am in a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback", "currently the only people who have that knowledge. The theorists of science are", "starting out in their area, in order to make this type of knowledge", "my supervisor or from reviwers that it is not the right thing, then", "think I made it clear in my argument above why this is the", "the community to which it is suited, and not any other. It is", "it, no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or material science.", "scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who define daily what good science", "in their area, in order to make this type of knowledge available to", "I think this should be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It", "people who have that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The", "or from reviwers that it is not the right thing, then trying to", "are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because", "important as teaching. (In fact I know many academics who are willing to", "think this should be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is", "to publish and which to reject, by applying for grants for projects which", "thing they are doing is wrong, and how to find the thing which", "in what he or she is doing. Therefore, I think this should be", "to reject it, because this site would be its natural home, just like", "even considered more important by academics?). So people in academia need to know", "wants to accept or reject this type of question. I would find it", "law. I know it, because I've tried doing research that way for the", "This covers the teaching part of a university employee's life. But research is", "grad students why the wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and how", "found it off-topic. I don't know why they think so. Butif it is", "downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers", "they can explain to their grad students why the wrong thing they are", "by deciding which article to publish and which to reject, by applying for", "of a site which is better suited, and I think I made it", "looks like, whether on an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics", "becoming better in what he or she is doing. Therefore, I think this", "has an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the", "I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax", "professors who guide us, who define daily what good science is by deciding", "rotation for the factor analysis in a given experiment. This can be asked", "site would be its natural home, just like in real life, the university", "its natural home, just like in real life, the university is the home", "because \"this is not the kind of question we are accustomed to seeing", "to know how research is done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty", "experts in one topic answer the questions of the people starting out in", "wrong things. Professors need to know it, so they can explain to their", "community can only gain from allowing it. --- This post was prompted by", "interesting for the people who ask it and the ones who answer. (And", "answer the questions of the people starting out in their area, in order", "and teaching one's field to students. Academia already has an explicit policy of", "explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on this", "accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody", "people in academia need to know how research is done. And I don't", "compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they all have", "that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place where", "applying for grants for projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating", "Butif it is just because \"this is not the kind of question we", "people expressed interest too). I would also like to note that they couldn't", "of people within academia is affected by it. Academics are also currently the", "part of a university employee's life. But research is as least as important", "from community members who found it off-topic. I don't know why they think", "into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent;", "of science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who define daily", "can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a body", "their area, in order to make this type of knowledge available to everyone", "The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who", "not getting it right. Graduate students need to know it, else they do", "for the last four years and wondered why I am in a downward", "intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on this type of knowledge, and", "to note that they couldn't think of a site which is better suited,", "that they couldn't think of a site which is better suited, and I", "of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people who ask it", "note that they couldn't think of a site which is better suited, and", "know many academics who are willing to do research without teaching, and none", "science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge,", "fact that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions", "by applying for grants for projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by", "the ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I would also", "Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This", "one's field to students. Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting questions", "teaching, and none who would like to do teaching without research, so maybe", "what he or she is doing. Therefore, I think this should be part", "on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a body of theory of", "reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place where the experts in one", "of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a", "place where the experts in one topic answer the questions of the people", "asking this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people", "field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it, no matter whether she is", "to students. Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university", "to accept or reject this type of question. I would find it very", "are the experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very", "Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried doing research that way for", "not just navigating university politics. It is also about conducting research and teaching", "(less motivated this time), and still not getting it right. Graduate students need", "do the wrong things. Professors need to know it, so they can explain", "for it, and the community can only gain from allowing it. --- This", "whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research without", "experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created", "So people in academia need to know how research is done. And I", "is touched by it, no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology", "is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've", "an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on this type of knowledge,", "with becoming better in what he or she is doing. Therefore, I think", "the right place for it, and the community can only gain from allowing", "can only gain from allowing it. --- This post was prompted by the", "community to decide whether it wants to accept or reject this type of", "the teaching part of a university employee's life. But research is as least", "find it very sad if it decides to reject it, because this site", "topic answer the questions of the people starting out in their area, in", "they couldn't think of a site which is better suited, and I think", "thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated this time), and still not", "Academics are also currently the only people who have that knowledge. The theorists", "I think I made it clear in my argument above why this is", "I think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a", "who found it off-topic. I don't know why they think so. Butif it", "which is better suited, and I think I made it clear in my", "before has thought of asking this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't", "order to become better academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects the", "to decide whether it wants to accept or reject this type of question.", "is need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people within", "the experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much", "up to the community to decide whether it wants to accept or reject", "everyday worklife of people within academia is affected by it. Academics are also", "this is the community to which it is suited, and not any other.", "by it. Academics are also currently the only people who have that knowledge.", "topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members who found it off-topic. I", "circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried doing research", "on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a university employee's life.", "like to do teaching without research, so maybe it is even considered more", "to the community to decide whether it wants to accept or reject this", "is also about conducting research and teaching one's field to students. Academia already", "know it, because I've tried doing research that way for the last four", "couldn't think of a site which is better suited, and I think I", "knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic", "right. There is need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of", "any other. It is up to the community to decide whether it wants", "would find it very sad if it decides to reject it, because this", "(In fact I know many academics who are willing to do research without", "shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of asking this", "principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they all have an understanding of", "questions of the people starting out in their area, in order to make", "why this is the community to which it is suited, and not any", "because I've tried doing research that way for the last four years and", "research without teaching, and none who would like to do teaching without research,", "kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know", "this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia is affected", "people who ask it and the ones who answer. (And several people expressed", "on an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts", "one topic answer the questions of the people starting out in their area,", "theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions", "know it, else they do the wrong things. Professors need to know it,", "and methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is", "only people who have that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves.", "projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work,", "mean it isn't interesting for the people who ask it and the ones", "analysis in a given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations", "or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on this type", "a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of asking this kind of", "material science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits", "several reactions from community members who found it off-topic. I don't know why", "has thought of asking this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting", "this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people who", "whether it wants to accept or reject this type of question. I would", "four years and wondered why I am in a downward spiral of doing", "to do teaching without research, so maybe it is even considered more important", "policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of", "I've tried doing research that way for the last four years and wondered", "seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before has", "also about conducting research and teaching one's field to students. Academia already has", "too). I would also like to note that they couldn't think of a", "from allowing it. --- This post was prompted by the fact that [I", "factor analysis in a given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But", "of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that it", "without teaching, and none who would like to do teaching without research, so", "academics?). So people in academia need to know how research is done. And", "that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from", "article to publish and which to reject, by applying for grants for projects", "know why they think so. Butif it is just because \"this is not", "clear in my argument above why this is the community to which it", "it, and the community can only gain from allowing it. --- This post", "it clear in my argument above why this is the community to which", "because this site would be its natural home, just like in real life,", "worklife of people within academia is affected by it. Academics are also currently", "reject this type of question. I would find it very sad if it", "in my argument above why this is the community to which it is", "would like to do teaching without research, so maybe it is even considered", "methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched", "no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing", "research without this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's", "for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia is", "this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of asking", "where the experts in one topic answer the questions of the people starting", "scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they all have an understanding", "of question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a", "do teaching without research, so maybe it is even considered more important by", "are willing to do research without teaching, and none who would like to", "work, they all have an understanding of what proper research looks like, whether", "is even considered more important by academics?). So people in academia need to", "And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or", "he or she is doing. Therefore, I think this should be part of", "whether on an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the", "Working in academia is not just navigating university politics. It is also about", "science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without", "or material science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge is like hacking", "theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who define", "in a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or", "type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in need of it,", "how research is done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of", "right thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated this time), and still", "(And several people expressed interest too). I would also like to note that", "in order to become better academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects", "to their grad students why the wrong thing they are doing is wrong,", "is in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research without this kind", "doing is wrong, and how to find the thing which is right. There", "isn't interesting for the people who ask it and the ones who answer.", "students need to know it, else they do the wrong things. Professors need", "the kind of question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't", "important by academics?). So people in academia need to know how research is", "ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I would also like", "which it is suited, and not any other. It is up to the", "they think so. Butif it is just because \"this is not the kind", "members who found it off-topic. I don't know why they think so. Butif", "it, else they do the wrong things. Professors need to know it, so", "researchers have created a body of theory of science and philosophy of science.", "a given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers", "if it decides to reject it, because this site would be its natural", "because nobody before has thought of asking this kind of question doesn't mean", "gain from allowing it. --- This post was prompted by the fact that", "need to know it, else they do the wrong things. Professors need to", "type of question. I would find it very sad if it decides to", "everyone who struggles with becoming better in what he or she is doing.", "affected by it. Academics are also currently the only people who have that", "a site which is better suited, and I think I made it clear", "in academia is not just navigating university politics. It is also about conducting", "with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they all have an", "biology or material science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge is like", "question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people who ask it and", "who answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I would also like to", "on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are the experts on this type of", "for the people who ask it and the ones who answer. (And several", "like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried", "are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they all", "don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation", "my argument above why this is the community to which it is suited,", "getting it right. Graduate students need to know it, else they do the", "community to which it is suited, and not any other. It is up", "There is need for this knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people", "knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried doing research that way", "molecular biology or material science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge is", "level. Experienced academics are the experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced", "good science is by deciding which article to publish and which to reject,", "is not just navigating university politics. It is also about conducting research and", "this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in need of", "I know it, because I've tried doing research that way for the last", "within academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia is affected by it.", "it, so they can explain to their grad students why the wrong thing", "the wrong things. Professors need to know it, so they can explain to", "of it, in order to become better academics. I think that this situation", "and got several reactions from community members who found it off-topic. I don't", "is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it, no matter whether she", "science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who define daily what", "is up to the community to decide whether it wants to accept or", "an understanding of what proper research looks like, whether on an explicit or", "define daily what good science is by deciding which article to publish and", "think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place", "is just because \"this is not the kind of question we are accustomed", "it decides to reject it, because this site would be its natural home,", "with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives", "work is touched by it, no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular", "it is not the right thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated", "of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming better in what he", "the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it, and", "decides to reject it, because this site would be its natural home, just", "academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia is affected by it. Academics", "publish and which to reject, by applying for grants for projects which are", "doing research that way for the last four years and wondered why I", "to become better academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit", "as least as important as teaching. (In fact I know many academics who", "proper research looks like, whether on an explicit or on an intuitive level.", "thing which is right. There is need for this knowledge within academia. The", "in academia need to know how research is done. And I don't mean", "daily what good science is by deciding which article to publish and which", "trying to correct it (less motivated this time), and still not getting it", "the fact that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several", "research and teaching one's field to students. Academia already has an explicit policy", "need of it, in order to become better academics. I think that this", "think of a site which is better suited, and I think I made", "are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us, who define daily what good", "navigating university politics. It is also about conducting research and teaching one's field", "become better academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of", "explain to their grad students why the wrong thing they are doing is", "how to find the thing which is right. There is need for this", "academics. I think that this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as", "it, because I've tried doing research that way for the last four years", "why they think so. Butif it is just because \"this is not the", "am in a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor", "which to reject, by applying for grants for projects which are compliant with", "be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a body of", "question. I would find it very sad if it decides to reject it,", "teaching. (In fact I know many academics who are willing to do research", "gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis", "But generations of researchers have created a body of theory of science and", "given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have", "university employee's life. But research is as least as important as teaching. (In", "Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it, and the community can only", "asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members", "available to everyone who struggles with becoming better in what he or she", "they are doing is wrong, and how to find the thing which is", "ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This", "kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people who ask", "of a university employee's life. But research is as least as important as", "a place where the experts in one topic answer the questions of the", "--- This post was prompted by the fact that [I asked a question", "it. Academics are also currently the only people who have that knowledge. The", "don't know why they think so. Butif it is just because \"this is", "it right. Graduate students need to know it, else they do the wrong", "what proper research looks like, whether on an explicit or on an intuitive", "not the kind of question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this", "which article to publish and which to reject, by applying for grants for", "students' work, they all have an understanding of what proper research looks like,", "doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that it is", "it off-topic. I don't know why they think so. Butif it is just", "is suited, and not any other. It is up to the community to", "ask it and the ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest too).", "different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent; every", "as a place where the experts in one topic answer the questions of", "reviwers that it is not the right thing, then trying to correct it", "and unexperienced ones are very much in need of it, in order to", "people starting out in their area, in order to make this type of", "spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that", "better in what he or she is doing. Therefore, I think this should", "and how to find the thing which is right. There is need for", "to find the thing which is right. There is need for this knowledge", "and none who would like to do teaching without research, so maybe it", "this site would be its natural home, just like in real life, the", "better suited, and I think I made it clear in my argument above", "It is also about conducting research and teaching one's field to students. Academia", "post was prompted by the fact that [I asked a question on this", "doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the people who ask it and the", "and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and", "it is suited, and not any other. It is up to the community", "of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into", "areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it, and the community", "of theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological", "and which to reject, by applying for grants for projects which are compliant", "the community to decide whether it wants to accept or reject this type", "got several reactions from community members who found it off-topic. I don't know", "employee's life. But research is as least as important as teaching. (In fact", "they all have an understanding of what proper research looks like, whether on", "in one topic answer the questions of the people starting out in their", "in need of it, in order to become better academics. I think that", "in order to make this type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles", "a university employee's life. But research is as least as important as teaching.", "the wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and how to find the", "themselves. The professors who guide us, who define daily what good science is", "pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a university employee's life. But research", "academia is not just navigating university politics. It is also about conducting research", "hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried doing", "and wondered why I am in a downward spiral of doing something, getting", "This post was prompted by the fact that [I asked a question on", "But research is as least as important as teaching. (In fact I know", "which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it, no matter whether", "students why the wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and how to", "we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just", "be its natural home, just like in real life, the university is the", "out in their area, in order to make this type of knowledge available", "explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part", "unexperienced ones are very much in need of it, in order to become", "maybe it is even considered more important by academics?). So people in academia", "to which it is suited, and not any other. It is up to", "need to know it, so they can explain to their grad students why", "[I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community", "by evaluating their grad students' work, they all have an understanding of what", "I made it clear in my argument above why this is the community", "be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place", "and the ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I would", "The everyday worklife of people within academia is affected by it. Academics are", "is done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a", "It is up to the community to decide whether it wants to accept", "science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different", "situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place where the experts", "find the thing which is right. There is need for this knowledge within", "choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a given", "of StackExchange as a place where the experts in one topic answer the", "need to know how research is done. And I don't mean the nitty", "it. --- This post was prompted by the fact that [I asked a", "last four years and wondered why I am in a downward spiral of", "who guide us, who define daily what good science is by deciding which", "perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place where the experts in", "by the fact that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got", "more important by academics?). So people in academia need to know how research", "have that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors who", "the people starting out in their area, in order to make this type", "willing to do research without teaching, and none who would like to do", "spirit of StackExchange as a place where the experts in one topic answer", "is affected by it. Academics are also currently the only people who have", "it isn't interesting for the people who ask it and the ones who", "who would like to do teaching without research, so maybe it is even", "topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it, no matter", "expressed interest too). I would also like to note that they couldn't think", "politics. It is also about conducting research and teaching one's field to students.", "academics who are willing to do research without teaching, and none who would", "motivated this time), and still not getting it right. Graduate students need to", "part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for", "it is even considered more important by academics?). So people in academia need", "the spirit of StackExchange as a place where the experts in one topic", "the people who ask it and the ones who answer. (And several people", "varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a given experiment. This", "time), and still not getting it right. Graduate students need to know it,", "touched by it, no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or", "of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it,", "very sad if it decides to reject it, because this site would be", "which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students' work, they", "and still not getting it right. Graduate students need to know it, else", "home, just like in real life, the university is the home of scientific", "Graduate students need to know it, else they do the wrong things. Professors", "so they can explain to their grad students why the wrong thing they", "questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a university employee's", "a downward spiral of doing something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from", "body of theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs.", "the only people who have that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists", "This can be asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a", "Doing research without this kind of knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing", "by it, no matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or material", "knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming better in what he or", "several people expressed interest too). I would also like to note that they", "sad if it decides to reject it, because this site would be its", "of science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of", "as important as teaching. (In fact I know many academics who are willing", "just navigating university politics. It is also about conducting research and teaching one's", "do research without teaching, and none who would like to do teaching without", "it wants to accept or reject this type of question. I would find", "accept or reject this type of question. I would find it very sad", "academics are the experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are", "matter whether she is in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research", "least as important as teaching. (In fact I know many academics who are", "I would find it very sad if it decides to reject it, because", "university politics. It is also about conducting research and teaching one's field to", "It is the right place for it, and the community can only gain", "is better suited, and I think I made it clear in my argument", "it (less motivated this time), and still not getting it right. Graduate students", "suited, and I think I made it clear in my argument above why", "is by deciding which article to publish and which to reject, by applying", "like to note that they couldn't think of a site which is better", "of researchers have created a body of theory of science and philosophy of", "thought of asking this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for", "just because \"this is not the kind of question we are accustomed to", "to know it, so they can explain to their grad students why the", "a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members who", "what good science is by deciding which article to publish and which to", "their grad students' work, they all have an understanding of what proper research", "from reviwers that it is not the right thing, then trying to correct", "psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research without this kind of knowledge", "question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members who found", "\"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a university employee's life. But", "that knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide", "to correct it (less motivated this time), and still not getting it right.", "knowledge within academia. The everyday worklife of people within academia is affected by", "off-topic. I don't know why they think so. Butif it is just because", "the community can only gain from allowing it. --- This post was prompted", "that way for the last four years and wondered why I am in", "going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which is", "research looks like, whether on an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced", "to do research without teaching, and none who would like to do teaching", "also like to note that they couldn't think of a site which is", "something, getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that it is not", "the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for the", "this situation perfectly reflects the spirit of StackExchange as a place where the", "their grad students why the wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and", "is the right place for it, and the community can only gain from", "every scientist's work is touched by it, no matter whether she is in", "this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members who found it off-topic.", "the questions of the people starting out in their area, in order to", "evaluating their grad students' work, they all have an understanding of what proper", "order to make this type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with", "and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which", "who are willing to do research without teaching, and none who would like", "on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in need", "research, so maybe it is even considered more important by academics?). So people", "who define daily what good science is by deciding which article to publish", "on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it, and the", "fact I know many academics who are willing to do research without teaching,", "know how research is done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff", "perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work", "in psychology, molecular biology or material science. Doing research without this kind of", "interest too). I would also like to note that they couldn't think of", "very much in need of it, in order to become better academics. I", "question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be a barrier.", "stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a body of theory of science", "on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and got several reactions from community members who found it", "\"this is not the kind of question we are accustomed to seeing around\",", "mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing a varimax or quartimax rotation for", "Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical", "for grants for projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their", "just like in real life, the university is the home of scientific theory.", "deciding which article to publish and which to reject, by applying for grants", "not the right thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated this time),", "place for it, and the community can only gain from allowing it. ---", "it and the ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest too). I", "natural home, just like in real life, the university is the home of", "the factor analysis in a given experiment. This can be asked on stats.stackexchange.", "grad students' work, they all have an understanding of what proper research looks", "for the factor analysis in a given experiment. This can be asked on", "is not the kind of question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then", "an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching", "I know many academics who are willing to do research without teaching, and", "made it clear in my argument above why this is the community to", "philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going", "of the people starting out in their area, in order to make this", "reject, by applying for grants for projects which are compliant with scientific principles,", "type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming better in what", "and the community can only gain from allowing it. --- This post was", "think so. Butif it is just because \"this is not the kind of", "else they do the wrong things. Professors need to know it, so they", "Professors need to know it, so they can explain to their grad students", "make this type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming better", "years and wondered why I am in a downward spiral of doing something,", "knowledge is like hacking circuits without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because", "from my supervisor or from reviwers that it is not the right thing,", "The professors who guide us, who define daily what good science is by", "they do the wrong things. Professors need to know it, so they can", "StackExchange as a place where the experts in one topic answer the questions", "would also like to note that they couldn't think of a site which", "the last four years and wondered why I am in a downward spiral", "research is done. And I don't mean the nitty gritty stuff of choosing", "research that way for the last four years and wondered why I am", "are very much in need of it, in order to become better academics.", "kind of question we are accustomed to seeing around\", then this shouldn't be", "scientist's work is touched by it, no matter whether she is in psychology,", "students. Academia already has an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\".", "is wrong, and how to find the thing which is right. There is", "for projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad students'", "area, in order to make this type of knowledge available to everyone who", "nobody before has thought of asking this kind of question doesn't mean it", "right place for it, and the community can only gain from allowing it.", "feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that it is not the right", "know it, so they can explain to their grad students why the wrong", "for Academia.Stackexchange. It is the right place for it, and the community can", "it, in order to become better academics. I think that this situation perfectly", "much in need of it, in order to become better academics. I think", "ones are very much in need of it, in order to become better", "of knowledge, and unexperienced ones are very much in need of it, in", "wrong thing they are doing is wrong, and how to find the thing", "correct it (less motivated this time), and still not getting it right. Graduate", "so. Butif it is just because \"this is not the kind of question", "none who would like to do teaching without research, so maybe it is", "grants for projects which are compliant with scientific principles, by evaluating their grad", "is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by it,", "be a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of asking this kind", "academia is affected by it. Academics are also currently the only people who", "barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of asking this kind of question", "then this shouldn't be a barrier. Just because nobody before has thought of", "science is by deciding which article to publish and which to reject, by", "of asking this kind of question doesn't mean it isn't interesting for the", "accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers the teaching part of a university", "the thing which is right. There is need for this knowledge within academia.", "to everyone who struggles with becoming better in what he or she is", "decide whether it wants to accept or reject this type of question. I", "Experienced academics are the experts on this type of knowledge, and unexperienced ones", "or she is doing. Therefore, I think this should be part of the", "Therefore, I think this should be part of the on-topic areas for Academia.Stackexchange.", "it very sad if it decides to reject it, because this site would", "who ask it and the ones who answer. (And several people expressed interest", "are doing is wrong, and how to find the thing which is right.", "as teaching. (In fact I know many academics who are willing to do", "can explain to their grad students why the wrong thing they are doing", "created a body of theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting with", "theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's", "epistemological vs. ontological definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and", "is doing. Therefore, I think this should be part of the on-topic areas", "many academics who are willing to do research without teaching, and none who", "a varimax or quartimax rotation for the factor analysis in a given experiment.", "definitions of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is", "us, who define daily what good science is by deciding which article to", "only gain from allowing it. --- This post was prompted by the fact", "prompted by the fact that [I asked a question on this topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16671/what-is-the-difference-between-criterion-validity-and-reliability-equivalence) and", "the right thing, then trying to correct it (less motivated this time), and", "like, whether on an explicit or on an intuitive level. Experienced academics are", "of question. I would find it very sad if it decides to reject", "a body of theory of science and philosophy of science. Starting with epistemological", "people within academia is affected by it. Academics are also currently the only", "getting feedback from my supervisor or from reviwers that it is not the", "reject it, because this site would be its natural home, just like in", "This is a topic which is field-independent; every scientist's work is touched by", "all have an understanding of what proper research looks like, whether on an", "of knowledge, and going into different theoretical perspectives and methodologies. This is a", "already has an explicit policy of accepting questions on \"university pedagogy\". This covers", "without knowing Ohm's law. I know it, because I've tried doing research that", "understanding of what proper research looks like, whether on an explicit or on", "way for the last four years and wondered why I am in a", "generations of researchers have created a body of theory of science and philosophy", "this type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming better in", "allowing it. --- This post was prompted by the fact that [I asked", "who struggles with becoming better in what he or she is doing. Therefore,", "to make this type of knowledge available to everyone who struggles with becoming", "knowledge. The theorists of science are scientists themselves. The professors who guide us,", "and I think I made it clear in my argument above why this", "not any other. It is up to the community to decide whether it", "right. Graduate students need to know it, else they do the wrong things.", "Just because nobody before has thought of asking this kind of question doesn't", "considered more important by academics?). So people in academia need to know how", "asked on stats.stackexchange. But generations of researchers have created a body of theory" ]
[ "me for the reason for this were, * cannot be generalized to apply", "](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to", "appear as a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a fourth option", "site These are three very specific reasons that do not cover a wide", "which may superficially appear as a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows", "exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for", "of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe (but", "off-topic, because it has nothing to do with academia. The three options given", "do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in", "another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List", "an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\"", "fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\" option.", "specific reasons that do not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This", "comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be", "\"It should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See", "similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE", "the Flag one (but I can't confirm this as I can't vote to", "See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It", "Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons", "the \"Other\" option is only shown to people with enough rep to vote", "flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to do with academia.", "\"Other\" option is only shown to people with enough rep to vote to", "effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy", "to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to do with", "closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown", "for this were, * cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar", "below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps", "* belongs on another SE site These are three very specific reasons that", "do not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may", "close, which is why most people on Meta are unable to replicate :-)", "\"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\"", "steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for another", "three options given to me for the reason for this were, * cannot", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe (but is not a dupe),", "not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the", "I do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown", "\"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but", "post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click", "--- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It", "rep to vote to close, which is why most people on Meta are", "being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect", "people with enough rep to vote to close, which is why most people", "apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students ", " about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site These", "that do not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which", "a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as", "this were, * cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations", "Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with certain rep. Is this", "to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs", "option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide a", "be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen", "options given to me for the reason for this were, * cannot be", "dialog, but not in the Flag one (but I can't confirm this as", "reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is", "reasons that do not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia),", "for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide a helpful", "Click \"It should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4.", "as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to people with enough", "situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to do with academia. The three", "\"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one", "to apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students", "with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those", "to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those", "difficult to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments:", "for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below:", "discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is", "shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though", "for the reason for this were, * cannot be generalized to apply to", "cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear", "an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to", "should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the", "vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to", "as a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a fourth option being", "is not a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I", "confirm this as I can't vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively,", "a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\"", "belongs on another SE site These are three very specific reasons that do", "dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see", "given to me for the reason for this were, * cannot be generalized", "other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe (but is", "vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide a helpful flag for an", "this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it", "without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only", "2. Click \"It should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\"", "to people with enough rep to vote to close, which is why most", "Today I tried to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing", "may superficially appear as a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a", "Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click", "the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog,", "vote to close, which is why most people on Meta are unable to", "The three options given to me for the reason for this were, ", "as I can't vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is", "because it has nothing to do with academia. The three options given to", "wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a", "Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult", "(but is not a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However,", "in similar situations about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another", "though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to people with enough rep", "\"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without", "very difficult to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following", "shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one (but I", "\"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for another reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic", "taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for another reason\"", "reason\" 3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List of", "offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that", "certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without", "the reason for this were, * cannot be generalized to apply to others", "possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe (but is not", "be generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing", "The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed", "to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option", "![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the", "1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should be closed for another reason\" 3.", "those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide a helpful flag", "enough rep to vote to close, which is why most people on Meta", "site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with certain rep. Is", "problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site These are three", "this as I can't vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\"", "a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to do with academia. The", "it has nothing to do with academia. The three options given to me", "vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one (but I can't confirm this", "not in the Flag one (but I can't confirm this as I can't", "provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact", "in the Flag one (but I can't confirm this as I can't vote", "to close, which is why most people on Meta are unable to replicate", "this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with certain rep.", "(but I can't confirm this as I can't vote to close on this", "tried to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to do", "but not in the Flag one (but I can't confirm this as I", "one (but I can't confirm this as I can't vote to close on", "nothing to do with academia. The three options given to me for the", "Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep,", "without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide a helpful flag for", "a helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps", "three very specific reasons that do not cover a wide swathe of other", "academia. The three options given to me for the reason for this were,", "facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site These are three very", "[This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe (but is not a", "is very difficult to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post. ---", "is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one (but", "helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken:", "I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in", "can't confirm this as I can't vote to close on this site). Hence,", "only available to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an", "sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to people with", "generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate", "in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one (but I can't", "However, I do not see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is", "not a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do", "shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the", "\"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very difficult to provide", "are three very specific reasons that do not cover a wide swathe of", "a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered:", "dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\".", "* cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about", "with academia. The three options given to me for the reason for this", "option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not", "suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the", "that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag", "undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site These are three very specific", "swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially appear as a dupe", "3. Click \"off-topic because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic", "deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close rep, it is very", "4. See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png)", "screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as", "option is only shown to people with enough rep to vote to close,", "rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for those without vote-to-close", "I tried to flag a [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/16851/how-the-gap-of-5-years-after-my-graduation-going-to-affect-me-in-job-hunting) as off-topic, because it has nothing to", "cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations * about problems", "has nothing to do with academia. The three options given to me for", "I can't confirm this as I can't vote to close on this site).", "of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\"", "those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\" option for", "because...\" 4. See the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an", "SE site These are three very specific reasons that do not cover a", "to do with academia. The three options given to me for the reason", "very specific reasons that do not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities.", "I can't vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only", "off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option", "see the \"other\" option. I suspect that \"Other\" is shown in the vote-to-close", "is only available to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without", "These are three very specific reasons that do not cover a wide swathe", "close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with", "to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The", "can't vote to close on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available", "for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click", "off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2.", "Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1. Click \"Flag\" 2. Click \"It should", "shown to people with enough rep to vote to close, which is why", "is only shown to people with enough rep to vote to close, which", "an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown", "on another SE site These are three very specific reasons that do not", "others in similar situations * about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on", "another SE site These are three very specific reasons that do not cover", "rep, it is very difficult to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic", "\"Other\" is only available to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate?", "flag for an off-topic post. --- Following comments: The exact steps taken: 1.", "to me for the reason for this were, * cannot be generalized to", "Flag one (but I can't confirm this as I can't vote to close", "reason for this were, * cannot be generalized to apply to others in", "perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to people with enough rep to", "as off-topic, because it has nothing to do with academia. The three options", "about problems facing undergraduate students * belongs on another SE site These are", "not cover a wide swathe of other possibilities. [This question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/689/no-closing-reason-for-nothing-to-do-with-academia), which may superficially", "with enough rep to vote to close, which is why most people on", "students * belongs on another SE site These are three very specific reasons", "to vote to close, which is why most people on Meta are unable", "on this site). Hence, effectively, \"Other\" is only available to those with certain", "option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not see the \"other\" option. I", "only shown to people with enough rep to vote to close, which is", "the screen shown below: ![List of off-topic reasons without an ](https://i.stack.imgur.com/APh4d.png) It sounds", "were, * cannot be generalized to apply to others in similar situations *", "a dupe), shows a fourth option being offered: \"Other\". However, I do not", "available to those with certain rep. Is this discrepancy deliberate? Without an \"Other\"", "do with academia. The three options given to me for the reason for", "the vote-to-close dialog, but not in the Flag one (but I can't confirm", "It sounds as though perhaps the \"Other\" option is only shown to people", "superficially appear as a dupe (but is not a dupe), shows a fourth", "it is very difficult to provide a helpful flag for an off-topic post." ]
[ "there is a clear statement that not all learning is on-topic. This question", "off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia to be focused on universities", "believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with the", "for undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement that not all learning", "a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed as", "is a clear statement that not all learning is on-topic. This question is", "the like. While I can see the OP's argument, we do generally say", "several, including myself, who believe academia to be focused on universities and the", "by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with the idea of gaining", "and the like. While I can see the OP's argument, we do generally", "should be on-topic since it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from", "OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that", "help find the line between on- and off-topic. So, where does this question", "MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge", "undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather", "academia to be focused on universities and the like. While I can see", "be focused on universities and the like. While I can see the OP's", "universities and the like. While I can see the OP's argument, we do", "knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was", "since it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in", "focused on universities and the like. While I can see the OP's argument,", "the OP believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/16969/2692), the OP believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it", "studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there", "line between on- and off-topic. So, where does this question fall? On- or", "are for undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement that not all", "that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement", "on-topic. This question is to help find the line between on- and off-topic.", "formal way. However, the question was closed as off-topic by several, including myself,", "However, the question was closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe", "be on-topic since it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from a", "was closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia to be", "argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all", "off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is a", "question was closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia to", "in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed as off-topic by", "see the OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic.", "learning is on-topic. This question is to help find the line between on-", "as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia to be focused on", "I can see the OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies", "of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the", "that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but", "with the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal", "can see the OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies is", "who believe academia to be focused on universities and the like. While I", "question is to help find the line between on- and off-topic. So, where", "While I can see the OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate", "a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed as off-topic by several,", "idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However,", "closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia to be focused", "gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question", "In [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/16969/2692), the OP believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic", "that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with the idea", "between on- and off-topic. So, where does this question fall? On- or off-topic?", "all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement that", "deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less", "way. However, the question was closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who", "but rather there is a clear statement that not all learning is on-topic.", "Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is a clear", "studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with the idea of", "the line between on- and off-topic. So, where does this question fall? On-", "believe academia to be focused on universities and the like. While I can", "on universities and the like. While I can see the OP's argument, we", "myself, who believe academia to be focused on universities and the like. While", "to be focused on universities and the like. While I can see the", "more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed as off-topic by several, including", "OP believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since it deals with", "like. While I can see the OP's argument, we do generally say that", "all learning is on-topic. This question is to help find the line between", "say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates", "to help find the line between on- and off-topic. So, where does this", "we do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC", "clear statement that not all learning is on-topic. This question is to help", "the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way.", "is to help find the line between on- and off-topic. So, where does", "a clear statement that not all learning is on-topic. This question is to", "undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement that not all learning is", "it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher in a", "including myself, who believe academia to be focused on universities and the like.", "is on-topic. This question is to help find the line between on- and", "teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed as off-topic", "not all learning is on-topic. This question is to help find the line", "the question was closed as off-topic by several, including myself, who believe academia", "the OP's argument, we do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/16969/2692), the OP believes that studying by MOOC should be on-topic since", "by several, including myself, who believe academia to be focused on universities and", "find the line between on- and off-topic. So, where does this question fall?", "generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for", "on-topic since it deals with the idea of gaining knowledge from a teacher", "from a teacher in a more-or-less formal way. However, the question was closed", "MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is a clear statement that not", "do generally say that undergraduate studies is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are", "This question is to help find the line between on- and off-topic. So,", "that not all learning is on-topic. This question is to help find the", "is off-topic. Not that all MOOC are for undergraduates but rather there is", "rather there is a clear statement that not all learning is on-topic. This", "statement that not all learning is on-topic. This question is to help find" ]
[ "discussion took place in the comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed", "about a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately related", "had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a", "separate discussion took place in the comments about a different academia-related topic. I", "which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053),", "a separate discussion took place in the comments about a different academia-related topic.", "removed the comments that weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer took", "to the question. The answerer took issue with my removing the comments, as", "the question. The answerer took issue with my removing the comments, as he", "comments, as he had put work into finding the answer. My question here", "had put work into finding the answer. My question here is: did I", "related to the question. The answerer took issue with my removing the comments,", "different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately related to the", "recently deleted a few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had", "work into finding the answer. My question here is: did I act inappropriately", "place in the comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments", "comments that weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer took issue with", "in the comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that", "see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had", "I recently deleted a few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which", "(mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly,", "the comments that weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer took issue", "into finding the answer. My question here is: did I act inappropriately in", "off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and", "been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community", "community member answered, and then a separate discussion took place in the comments", "immediately related to the question. The answerer took issue with my removing the", "a few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged", "he had put work into finding the answer. My question here is: did", "Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then", "few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as", "put work into finding the answer. My question here is: did I act", "a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately related to", "as he had put work into finding the answer. My question here is:", "finding the answer. My question here is: did I act inappropriately in removing", "then a separate discussion took place in the comments about a different academia-related", "and then a separate discussion took place in the comments about a different", "academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately related to the question.", "as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered,", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a separate discussion took place in", "took place in the comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed the", "topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately related to the question. The", "my removing the comments, as he had put work into finding the answer.", "flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member", "OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a separate", "with my removing the comments, as he had put work into finding the", "answer. My question here is: did I act inappropriately in removing those comments?", "the OP had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a", "weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer took issue with my removing", "removing the comments, as he had put work into finding the answer. My", "had [asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a separate discussion", "them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked", "[here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP had [asked a", "answerer took issue with my removing the comments, as he had put work", "the comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't", "that weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer took issue with my", "took issue with my removing the comments, as he had put work into", "[asked a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a separate discussion took", "question. The answerer took issue with my removing the comments, as he had", "can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the OP", "comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic.", "a community member answered, and then a separate discussion took place in the", "answered, and then a separate discussion took place in the comments about a", "issue with my removing the comments, as he had put work into finding", "member answered, and then a separate discussion took place in the comments about", "comments about a different academia-related topic. I removed the comments that weren't immediately", "a question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17050/acknowledging-the-discussion-with-someone-in-the-paper-but-excluding-this-person/17053?noredirect=1#comment33712_17053), a community member answered, and then a separate discussion took place", "the answer. My question here is: did I act inappropriately in removing those", "I removed the comments that weren't immediately related to the question. The answerer", "you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been flagged as off-topic. Briefly, the", "The answerer took issue with my removing the comments, as he had put", "deleted a few comments (mods, you can see them [here](https://academia.stackexchange.com/admin/posts/17053/comments)) which had been", "the comments, as he had put work into finding the answer. My question" ]
[ "Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a rant it made me wonder", "that's the case) so, for example, the username shows up but there is", "questions. This question was asked by someone without an A.SE account (I think", "by someone without an A.SE account (I think that's the case) so, for", "made me wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked by someone without", "so, for example, the username shows up but there is no link. I'm", "when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should we delete and re-ask", "begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should we", "there is no link. I'm not sure if that user will get comments", "this question was closed as a rant it made me wonder about migrated", "the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should we delete", "not sure if that user will get comments or answers. I also wonder", "I'm not sure if that user will get comments or answers. I also", "a rant it made me wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked", "as a rant it made me wonder about migrated questions. This question was", "Although this question was closed as a rant it made me wonder about", "was asked by someone without an A.SE account (I think that's the case)", "the asker of a question, should we delete and re-ask the question so", "someone without an A.SE account (I think that's the case) so, for example,", "from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a rant it made me", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a", "that it belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and who", "reading [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed", "link. I'm not sure if that user will get comments or answers. I", "so that it belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and", "question so that it belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions", "of a question, should we delete and re-ask the question so that it", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as", "are the asker of a question, should we delete and re-ask the question", "an A.SE account (I think that's the case) so, for example, the username", "wonder if that user can (or would) ever accept an answer. All of", "the case) so, for example, the username shows up but there is no", "we delete and re-ask the question so that it belongs to someone who", "shows up but there is no link. I'm not sure if that user", "or answers. I also wonder if that user can (or would) ever accept", "the question so that it belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying", "for example, the username shows up but there is no link. I'm not", "question, should we delete and re-ask the question so that it belongs to", "answers. I also wonder if that user can (or would) ever accept an", "re-ask the question so that it belongs to someone who can actually answer", "was reading [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was", "I was reading [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17085/why-do-professors-sometime-hide-the-book-from-which-they-are-really-teaching) which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question", "question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should we delete and", "it made me wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked by someone", "user can (or would) ever accept an answer. All of this begs the", "ever accept an answer. All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are", "if that user can (or would) ever accept an answer. All of this", "is no link. I'm not sure if that user will get comments or", "up but there is no link. I'm not sure if that user will", "migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a rant it made", "it belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and who can", "closed as a rant it made me wonder about migrated questions. This question", "to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and who can accept answers?", "will get comments or answers. I also wonder if that user can (or", "that user can (or would) ever accept an answer. All of this begs", "a question, should we delete and re-ask the question so that it belongs", "about migrated questions. This question was asked by someone without an A.SE account", "an answer. All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker", "(I think that's the case) so, for example, the username shows up but", "username shows up but there is no link. I'm not sure if that", "A.SE account (I think that's the case) so, for example, the username shows", "This question was asked by someone without an A.SE account (I think that's", "example, the username shows up but there is no link. I'm not sure", "user will get comments or answers. I also wonder if that user can", "account (I think that's the case) so, for example, the username shows up", "without an A.SE account (I think that's the case) so, for example, the", "comments or answers. I also wonder if that user can (or would) ever", "question was closed as a rant it made me wonder about migrated questions.", "delete and re-ask the question so that it belongs to someone who can", "and re-ask the question so that it belongs to someone who can actually", "rant it made me wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked by", "answer. All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of", "was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a rant it", "belongs to someone who can actually answer clarifying questions and who can accept", "that user will get comments or answers. I also wonder if that user", "asked by someone without an A.SE account (I think that's the case) so,", "wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked by someone without an A.SE", "I also wonder if that user can (or would) ever accept an answer.", "All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a", "the username shows up but there is no link. I'm not sure if", "(or would) ever accept an answer. All of this begs the question, when", "asker of a question, should we delete and re-ask the question so that", "should we delete and re-ask the question so that it belongs to someone", "also wonder if that user can (or would) ever accept an answer. All", "migrated questions. This question was asked by someone without an A.SE account (I", "non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should we delete and re-ask the", "think that's the case) so, for example, the username shows up but there", "no link. I'm not sure if that user will get comments or answers.", "which was migrated from Mozh.SE. Although this question was closed as a rant", "sure if that user will get comments or answers. I also wonder if", "but there is no link. I'm not sure if that user will get", "if that user will get comments or answers. I also wonder if that", "case) so, for example, the username shows up but there is no link.", "of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question,", "would) ever accept an answer. All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users", "get comments or answers. I also wonder if that user can (or would)", "question was asked by someone without an A.SE account (I think that's the", "was closed as a rant it made me wonder about migrated questions. This", "me wonder about migrated questions. This question was asked by someone without an", "accept an answer. All of this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the", "this begs the question, when non-A.SE-users are the asker of a question, should", "can (or would) ever accept an answer. All of this begs the question," ]
[ "a moderator. I have made my views on this clear in this question.", "actions on this site was deleted by a moderator. I have made my", "being deleted. My feeling is that this is a mild form of academic", "should certainly speak to that.] That seems to be true, but also this", "what is largely volunteer work / networking on their part. This is certainly", "had just said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally", "I will take a break from this site to reflect on these issues.", "Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to have", "and enforce the SE platform was a little too high. More recently she", "different from those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE", "in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that I", "answers from users who identify themselves with their real name and academic affiliations", "a colleague of mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange site. I", "relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling form", "about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on", "response was that this site is very different from those sites. [Added: The", "that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here,", "not be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to start a math-education", "model is in some ways a credible threat to making inroads on this.", "on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly", "November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or", "name and academic affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly not required.", "passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I think the", "and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm participation in", "\"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are treated the way I want", "nullified my actions on this site was deleted by a moderator. I have", "unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an", "If it is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is", "perspective is more of a blanket one -- which is on-topic for the", "the SE platform was a little too high. More recently she -- assisted", "before raise the issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice", "model and the goal of getting academics involved in such a question and", "which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely", "would not be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to start a", "answer site. Please let me know how you feel about the censorship question", "had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had", "my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my", "to what is largely volunteer work / networking on their part. This is", "main tension in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0", "I was unwilling to have longterm participation in a site for which content", "feeling is that this is a mild form of academic censorship. I am", "[Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently", "enough involvement, so questions about what future course the site could take seem", "broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with their", "hypothetical question: this was the main tension in the decision of whether to", "an independent site which is similar to the SE platform but adapted to", "site which is similar to the SE platform but adapted to be less", "assisted by my PhD student -- made an independent site which is similar", "to jump through, especially at the early stages. She tried it anyway, and", "That seems to be true, but also this site is in the \"beta", "I am very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and", "differently than any other SE site, this one included.\" I believe this comment", "warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally", "When I pointed out that comments are treated the way I want them", "far differently than any other SE site, this one included.\" I believe this", "\"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other SE site,", "circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that I had been", "is run far differently than any other SE site, this one included.\" I", "highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work / networking", "and nullified my actions on this site was deleted by a moderator. I", "site could take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like", "once before raise the issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The", "very different from those sites. [Added*: The original comment was \"Suffice to state,", "built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori* inapplicable here, someone should", "were adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to", "mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after many concessions", "or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed", "is more of a blanket one -- which is on-topic for the site", "be inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat it exactly. If it", "math.SE, the response was that this site is very different from those sites.", "\"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are treated the way", "at the early stages. She tried it anyway, and the site didn't make", "time I will take a break from this site to reflect on these", "she -- assisted by my PhD student -- made an independent site which", "Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified", "the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that", "me know how you feel about the censorship question above and/or also this", "this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators", "this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with", "I wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm participation in a site", "certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the main tension in the decision", "exchange site. I told her that this could be a good idea but", "less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very", "how you feel about the censorship question above and/or also this broader issue.", "academic censorship, however mild, and I think the SE model is in some", "my time and nullified my actions on this site was deleted by a", "censorship, however mild, and I think the SE model is in some ways", "people agreed to several things which at the beginning they were adamant would", "be less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am", "said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my", "of academic censorship, however mild, and I think the SE model is in", "the main tension in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the", "question: this was the main tension in the decision of whether to move", "know how you feel about the censorship question above and/or also this broader", "themselves with their real name and academic affiliations (past or present), although that", "did once before raise the issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942).", "The practice I was talking about was different but, in my opinion, less", "This comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by a", "affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly not required. Added: I remember", "words: maybe academics don't like participating in a site which has such a", "thing happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in", "between the mainstream SE model and the goal of getting academics involved in", "form of academic censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment of academic", "have longterm participation in a site for which content -- specifically comments, although", "speak to that.] That seems to be true, but also this site is", "tension in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model.", "which is on-topic for the site are being deleted. My feeling is that", "is similar to the SE platform but adapted to be less gamified and", "feel that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the", "whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only", "I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this site", "they were adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried", "pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling form of censorship. At", "site, this one included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is", "in some ways a credible threat to making inroads on this. Although the", "a mild form of academic censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment", "same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and", "and academic affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly not required. Added:", "is why I did not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended", "Added: I remember now that I did once before raise the issue of", "who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement of", "that I had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another", "done only after many concessions from the SE developers, and the whole thing", "run far differently than any other SE site, this one included.\" I believe", "and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users who identify", "was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same). Thus my comment", "on this site was deleted by a moderator. I have made my views", "mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out", "of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially at the", "seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori", "little too high. More recently she -- assisted by my PhD student --", "sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far", "phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so questions about what future course", "and I think the SE model is in some ways a credible threat", "the site are being deleted. My feeling is that this is a mild", "the issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was", "one -- which is on-topic for the site are being deleted. My feeling", "especially at the early stages. She tried it anyway, and the site didn't", "maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like participating in a site", "on this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain", "I have made my views on this clear in this question. When moderators", "in such a question and answer site. Please let me know how you", "experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone", "my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment", "a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed --", "adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to start", "they participate in the most troubling form of censorship. At the present time", "a site which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what", "I was talking about was different but, in my opinion, less severe than", "to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments", "such a question and answer site. Please let me know how you feel", "on this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two", "is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether other", "other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model", "volunteer work / networking on their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical", "who like and enforce the SE platform was a little too high. More", "to be inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat it exactly. If", "disconnect between interested math educators and people who like and enforce the SE", "jump through, especially at the early stages. She tried it anyway, and the", "to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other SE site, this", "comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other", "although that is certainly not required. Added: I remember now that I did", "be possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to start a math-education stack", "developers, and the whole thing happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\"", "not a hypothetical question: this was the main tension in the decision of", "many concessions from the SE developers, and the whole thing happened at least", "of Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling", "Also a colleague of mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange site.", "a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in", "It included the information that I had been typing an answer while it", "a math-education stack exchange site. I told her that this could be a", "was appropriate. It included the information that I had been typing an answer", "this could be a good idea but also warned her that there were", "on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning", "ways a credible threat to making inroads on this. Although the moderator who", "in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This", "the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after many concessions from the", "to several things which at the beginning they were adamant would not be", "Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people who like", "\"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are treated the", "to them, they participate in the most troubling form of censorship. At the", "this one included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is why", "the present time I will take a break from this site to reflect", "that this could be a good idea but also warned her that there", "us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially at the early stages. She", "closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion", "the beginning they were adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague of", "inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely,", "for which content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective is more of", "enforce the SE platform was a little too high. More recently she --", "my actions on this site was deleted by a moderator. I have made", "than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently", "Please let me know how you feel about the censorship question above and/or", "was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other SE", "of a blanket one -- which is on-topic for the site are being", "on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this site is very different", "recently she -- assisted by my PhD student -- made an independent site", "networking on their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was", "was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly --", "the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time", "to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after", "Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to", "that this site is very different from those sites. [Added: The original comment", "involvement, so questions about what future course the site could take seem maximally", "mild, and I think the SE model is in some ways a credible", "is largely volunteer work / networking on their part. This is certainly not", "encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I think the SE model is", "are treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response", "I remember now that I did once before raise the issue of censorship", "was the main tension in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to", "question and answer site. Please let me know how you feel about the", "-- specifically comments, although my own perspective is more of a blanket one", "I did once before raise the issue of censorship with respect to comments", "this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate", "comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine similar to", "whether other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE", "the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a", "to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after many concessions from", "start a math-education stack exchange site. I told her that this could be", "between interested math educators and people who like and enforce the SE platform", "other words: maybe academics don't like participating in a site which has such", "in the end the SE people agreed to several things which at the", "identify themselves with their real name and academic affiliations (past or present), although", "mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the goal of getting academics involved", "inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat it exactly. If it is", "moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what", "am very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I", "(past or present), although that is certainly not required. Added*: I remember now", "unwilling to have longterm participation in a site for which content -- specifically", "could take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like participating", "and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are treated the way I", "site is in the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so", "moderator. I have made my views on this clear in this question. When", "it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same). Thus my", "the site could take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't", "A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment", "her that this could be a good idea but also warned her that", "rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know", "content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective is more of a blanket", "cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people who like and enforce the", "but adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching", "troubling form of censorship. At the present time I will take a break", "blanket one -- which is on-topic for the site are being deleted. My", "course the site could take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics", "model. This was finally done only after many concessions from the SE developers,", "and the whole thing happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were", "question above and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users", "a site for which content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective is", "somehow a priori* inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems", "I think the SE model is in some ways a credible threat to", "any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the goal of getting", "views on this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which", "don't like participating in a site which has such a highly gamified /", "to be true, but also this site is in the \"beta phase\" because", "the response was that this site is very different from those sites. [Added:", "is on-topic for the site are being deleted. My feeling is that this", "the end the SE people agreed to several things which at the beginning", "rules and hoops to jump through, especially at the early stages. She tried", "year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the SE people", "[Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether other academics feel", "censorship question above and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from", "gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested", "to be less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I", "at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end", "now that I did once before raise the issue of censorship with respect", "told her that this could be a good idea but also warned her", "colleague of mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange site. I told", "SE platform was a little too high. More recently she -- assisted by", "[here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was different but, in my opinion,", "the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are", "warned her that there were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and", "participating in a site which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach", "Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether other academics feel that", "SE platform but adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this is the", "site was deleted by a moderator. I have made my views on this", "Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other SE site, this one included.\"", "deleted. My feeling is that this is a mild form of academic censorship.", "deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted", "it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people", "good idea but also warned her that there were a lot of strange-looking", "on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm", "gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work / networking on", "there is not enough involvement, so questions about what future course the site", "and the site didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between", "after many concessions from the SE developers, and the whole thing happened at", "educators and people who like and enforce the SE platform was a little", "true, but also this site is in the \"beta phase\" because there is", "Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted without", "stack exchange site. I told her that this could be a good idea", "lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially at", "of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining", "academic affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly not required. Added: I", "in the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so questions about", "way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this", "the whole thing happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first", "SE model and the goal of getting academics involved in such a question", "meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm participation in a", "of mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange site. I told her", "delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling", "priori* inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems to be", "beginning they were adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague of mine", "to the SE platform but adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this", "but also this site is in the \"beta phase\" because there is not", "platform was a little too high. More recently she -- assisted by my", "follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work / networking on their part.", "a little too high. More recently she -- assisted by my PhD student", "interested to know whether other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between", "math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak", "which pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling form of censorship.", "because there is not enough involvement, so questions about what future course the", "but also warned her that there were a lot of strange-looking (to us)", "was finally done only after many concessions from the SE developers, and the", "with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was different", "in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they", "also this site is in the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough", "is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the main tension in the", "any other SE site, this one included.\" I believe this comment to be", "mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange site. I told her that", "site. Please let me know how you feel about the censorship question above", "censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was", "academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm participation", "think the SE model is in some ways a credible threat to making", "form of censorship. At the present time I will take a break from", "that there were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to", "real name and academic affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly not", "SE developers, and the whole thing happened at least a year after the", "in a site which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to", "the SE model is in some ways a credible threat to making inroads", "from the SE developers, and the whole thing happened at least a year", "why I did not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended that", "intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on this site was", "just said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted", "that comments are treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE,", "decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally", "which content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective is more of a", "but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014:", "closure was appropriate. It included the information that I had been typing an", "one included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is why I", "required. Added: I remember now that I did once before raise the issue", "is not enough involvement, so questions about what future course the site could", "longterm participation in a site for which content -- specifically comments, although my", "who identify themselves with their real name and academic affiliations (past or present),", "math-education stack exchange site. I told her that this could be a good", "of censorship. At the present time I will take a break from this", "SE people agreed to several things which at the beginning they were adamant", "know whether other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream", "from those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is", "deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine", "to a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed", "stages. She tried it anyway, and the site didn't make it past Area", "strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially at the early", "in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A", "censorship. At the present time I will take a break from this site", "site. I told her that this could be a good idea but also", "want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this site is", "there were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump", "what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that I had", "included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is why I did", "opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of", "those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run", "from users who identify themselves with their real name and academic affiliations (past", "comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator.", "without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that was", "appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with their real name and academic", "and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to", "after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the SE people agreed", "comments are treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the", "things which at the beginning they were adamant would not be possible. Also", "issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking", "wrote that I was unwilling to have longterm participation in a site for", "-- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included", "did not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience built-up", "whole thing happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started:", "practice I was talking about was different but, in my opinion, less severe", "in a site for which content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective", "with their real name and academic affiliations (past or present), although that is", "treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was", "typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said", "student -- made an independent site which is similar to the SE platform", "is a mild form of academic censorship. I am very passionately against the", "a hypothetical question: this was the main tension in the decision of whether", "to making inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized", "mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.]", "too high. More recently she -- assisted by my PhD student -- made", "My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances", "users who identify themselves with their real name and academic affiliations (past or", "about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that", "future course the site could take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe", "academics don't like participating in a site which has such a highly gamified", "independent site which is similar to the SE platform but adapted to be", "first started: in the end the SE people agreed to several things which", "several things which at the beginning they were adamant would not be possible.", "At the present time I will take a break from this site to", "than any other SE site, this one included.\" I believe this comment to", "their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the main", "recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question", "and hoops to jump through, especially at the early stages. She tried it", "could be a good idea but also warned her that there were a", "and answer site. Please let me know how you feel about the censorship", "I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is why I did not", "moderators found a statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and", "through, especially at the early stages. She tried it anyway, and the site", "by my PhD student -- made an independent site which is similar to", "my own perspective is more of a blanket one -- which is on-topic", "against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I think the SE", "is very different from those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice to", "state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any other SE site, this one", "an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the", "She tried it anyway, and the site didn't make it past Area 51:", "\"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the SE people agreed to several", "a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work /", "would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with their real name and", "academics involved in such a question and answer site. Please let me know", "that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the goal", "started: in the end the SE people agreed to several things which at", "however mild, and I think the SE model is in some ways a", "other SE site, this one included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate,", "and people who like and enforce the SE platform was a little too", "expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure", "mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this site is very different from", "2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This", "take seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like participating in", "a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the SE", "When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in the", "was unwilling to have longterm participation in a site for which content --", "I pointed out that comments are treated the way I want them on", "am very interested to know whether other academics feel that there any cultural", "the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the SE people agreed to", "the information that I had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally", "seems to be true, but also this site is in the \"beta phase\"", "that is certainly not required. Added: I remember now that I did once", "the SE platform but adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this is", "statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I", "by a moderator. I have made my views on this clear in this", "literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on this site was deleted", "Fellow Users of Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I", "pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment", "/ follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work / networking on their", "so questions about what future course the site could take seem maximally on-point.", "for the site are being deleted. My feeling is that this is a", "have made my views on this clear in this question. When moderators delete", "issue. I would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with their real", "to start a math-education stack exchange site. I told her that this could", "appropriate. It included the information that I had been typing an answer while", "her that there were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops", "cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the goal of getting academics", "some ways a credible threat to making inroads on this. Although the moderator", "a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially", "about the censorship question above and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate", "the censorship question above and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers", "that.] That seems to be true, but also this site is in the", "feel about the censorship question above and/or also this broader issue. I would", "I told her that this could be a good idea but also warned", "the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether other academics", "respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was different but,", "also warned her that there were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules", "very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I think", "was different but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November", "while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same). Thus", "concessions from the SE developers, and the whole thing happened at least a", "similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that", "like participating in a site which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules", "on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like participating in a site which", "SE site, this one included.\" I believe this comment to be inaccurate, which", "a question and answer site. Please let me know how you feel about", "this site is very different from those sites. [Added: The original comment was", "different but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on November 27,", "someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems to be true, but also", "I am very interested to know whether other academics feel that there any", "that this is a mild form of academic censorship. I am very passionately", "be true, but also this site is in the \"beta phase\" because there", "the SE people agreed to several things which at the beginning they were", "moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in the most", "agreed to several things which at the beginning they were adamant would not", "severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine was", "moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement", "out that comments are treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net and", "a blanket one -- which is on-topic for the site are being deleted.", "a statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When", "my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine similar", "which is why I did not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously", "-- which is on-topic for the site are being deleted. My feeling is", "answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same).", "questions about what future course the site could take seem maximally on-point. In", "-- made an independent site which is similar to the SE platform but", "make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and", "a good idea but also warned her that there were a lot of", "which at the beginning they were adamant would not be possible. Also a", "their real name and academic affiliations (past or present), although that is certainly", "the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was", "credible threat to making inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted my", "the early stages. She tried it anyway, and the site didn't make it", "such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer work", "idea but also warned her that there were a lot of strange-looking (to", "certainly speak to that.] That seems to be true, but also this site", "site for which content -- specifically comments, although my own perspective is more", "maybe academics don't like participating in a site which has such a highly", "this was the main tension in the decision of whether to move mathoverflow.net", "is certainly not required. Added*: I remember now that I did once before", "largely volunteer work / networking on their part. This is certainly not a", "my views on this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments", "happened at least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the", "\"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so questions about what future", "included the information that I had been typing an answer while it was", "let me know how you feel about the censorship question above and/or also", "In other words: maybe academics don't like participating in a site which has", "tried to start a math-education stack exchange site. I told her that this", "platform but adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics", "participation in a site for which content -- specifically comments, although my own", "own perspective is more of a blanket one -- which is on-topic for", "comment to be inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat it exactly.", "above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed out that comments are treated", "getting academics involved in such a question and answer site. Please let me", "(another user had just said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator", "although my own perspective is more of a blanket one -- which is", "the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild, and I think the SE model", "only after many concessions from the SE developers, and the whole thing happened", "academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and", "on their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the", "More recently she -- assisted by my PhD student -- made an independent", "this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether", "that I did once before raise the issue of censorship with respect to", "remember now that I did once before raise the issue of censorship with", "question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them, they participate in", "participate in the most troubling form of censorship. At the present time I", "very nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine similar to the above", "goal of getting academics involved in such a question and answer site. Please", "comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was", "high. More recently she -- assisted by my PhD student -- made an", "mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to", "anyway, and the site didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect", "academic censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however", "intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a priori* inapplicable", "at the beginning they were adamant would not be possible. Also a colleague", "interested math educators and people who like and enforce the SE platform was", "is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That", "moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on this site", "is in some ways a credible threat to making inroads on this. Although", "less severe than deletion. Added on November 27, 2014: A comment of mine", "wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate.", "similar to the SE platform but adapted to be less gamified and rigid:", "to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was different but, in", "this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to", "them, they participate in the most troubling form of censorship. At the present", "of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\". When I pointed", "has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is largely volunteer", "-- assisted by my PhD student -- made an independent site which is", "finally done only after many concessions from the SE developers, and the whole", "/ networking on their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this", "be a good idea but also warned her that there were a lot", "SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after many concessions from the SE", "clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant comments which pertain to them,", "or present), although that is certainly not required. Added: I remember now that", "and mathotherflow is somehow a priori inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to", "This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the main tension in", "least a year after the \"negotiations\" were first started: in the end the", "nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\",", "been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user had just", "that I was unwilling to have longterm participation in a site for which", "unilaterally closed (another user had just said the same). Thus my comment about", "is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow a", "tried it anyway, and the site didn't make it past Area 51: the", "site which has such a highly gamified / follow-the-rules approach to what is", "I did not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience", "closed (another user had just said the same). Thus my comment about how", "very interested to know whether other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch", "moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information that I had been typing", "civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It", "threat to making inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment", "and the goal of getting academics involved in such a question and answer", "comments which pertain to them, they participate in the most troubling form of", "present time I will take a break from this site to reflect on", "acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by", "I would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves with their real name", "user had just said the same). Thus my comment about how moderator intervention", "comment about how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions", "opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the information", "more of a blanket one -- which is on-topic for the site are", "-- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was", "Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/). I am very interested to know whether other academics feel that there", "wasted my time and nullified my actions on this site was deleted by", "made my views on this clear in this question. When moderators delete relevant", "the SE developers, and the whole thing happened at least a year after", "most troubling form of censorship. At the present time I will take a", "mild form of academic censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment of", "made an independent site which is similar to the SE platform but adapted", "was that this site is very different from those sites. [Added: The original", "two moderators found a statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\"", "Users of Academia.SE, Recently on academia.SE and meta.academia.SE, I wrote that I was", "pointed out that comments are treated the way I want them on mathoverflow.net", "censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship, however mild,", "apologized very nicely, two moderators found a statement of mine similar to the", "end the SE people agreed to several things which at the beginning they", "were first started: in the end the SE people agreed to several things", "not repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience built-up on", "early stages. She tried it anyway, and the site didn't make it past", "found a statement of mine similar to the above \"unconstructive\", \"vacuous\" and \"distasteful\".", "talking about was different but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added", "question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly", "this site is in the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement,", "was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a", "is that this is a mild form of academic censorship. I am very", "past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people who", "the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people who like and enforce", "PhD student -- made an independent site which is similar to the SE", "of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about", "site didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math", "and math.SE, the response was that this site is very different from those", "adapted to be less gamified and rigid: this is the [Mozhematics Teaching Community](https://mathematicsteachingcommunity.math.uga.edu/).", "seem maximally on-point. In other words: maybe academics don't like participating in a", "specifically comments, although my own perspective is more of a blanket one --", "was pertaining to a question that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My", "information that I had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed", "the site didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested", "is in the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so questions", "certainly not required. Added: I remember now that I did once before raise", "I had been typing an answer while it was unilaterally closed (another user", "about was different but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion. Added on", "it is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow is somehow", "this comment to be inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat it", "mainstream SE model and the goal of getting academics involved in such a", "51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators and people who like and", "in the most troubling form of censorship. At the present time I will", "was deleted by a moderator. I have made my views on this clear", "part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question: this was the main tension", "27, 2014: A comment of mine was recently deleted without warning or acknowledgment.", "a priori* inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems to", "work / networking on their part. This is certainly not a hypothetical question:", "to that.] That seems to be true, but also this site is in", "making inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very", "of whether to move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done", "original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than any", "present), although that is certainly not required. Added: I remember now that I", "(to us) rules and hoops to jump through, especially at the early stages.", "the mainstream SE model and the goal of getting academics involved in such", "involved in such a question and answer site. Please let me know how", "inapplicable here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems to be true,", "Although the moderator who deleted my comment apologized very nicely, two moderators found", "deleted by a moderator. I have made my views on this clear in", "site are being deleted. My feeling is that this is a mild form", "my PhD student -- made an independent site which is similar to the", "was a little too high. More recently she -- assisted by my PhD", "The original comment was \"Suffice to state, Mozh.SE is run far differently than", "approach to what is largely volunteer work / networking on their part. This", "was talking about was different but, in my opinion, less severe than deletion.", "comments, although my own perspective is more of a blanket one -- which", "here, someone should certainly speak to that.] That seems to be true, but", "them on mathoverflow.net and math.SE, the response was that this site is very", "which is similar to the SE platform but adapted to be less gamified", "deleted without warning or acknowledgment. This comment was pertaining to a question that", "are being deleted. My feeling is that this is a mild form of", "how moderator intervention literally wasted my time and nullified my actions on this", "exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and mathotherflow", "comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about in what circumstances moderator", "what future course the site could take seem maximally on-point. In other words:", "people who like and enforce the SE platform was a little too high.", "math educators and people who like and enforce the SE platform was a", "an opinion about in what circumstances moderator closure was appropriate. It included the", "also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users who identify themselves", "site is very different from those sites. [Added: The original comment was \"Suffice", "by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly -- an opinion about", "the most troubling form of censorship. At the present time I will take", "the goal of getting academics involved in such a question and answer site.", "didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural disconnect between interested math educators", "raise the issue of censorship with respect to comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I", "repeat it exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE", "believe this comment to be inaccurate, which is why I did not repeat", "SE model is in some ways a credible threat to making inroads on", "time and nullified my actions on this site was deleted by a moderator.", "of getting academics involved in such a question and answer site. Please let", "This was finally done only after many concessions from the SE developers, and", "a credible threat to making inroads on this. Although the moderator who deleted", "to know whether other academics feel that there any cultural mismatch between the", "like and enforce the SE platform was a little too high. More recently", "about what future course the site could take seem maximally on-point. In other", "possible. Also a colleague of mine tried to start a math-education stack exchange", "My feeling is that this is a mild form of academic censorship. I", "it exactly. If it is seriously intended that experience built-up on math.SE and", "not required. Added: I remember now that I did once before raise the", "you feel about the censorship question above and/or also this broader issue. I", "this site was deleted by a moderator. I have made my views on", "above and/or also this broader issue. I would appreciate answers from users who", "comments [here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/97283/dont-remove-the-part-of-my-comment/97942#97942). The practice I was talking about was different but, in my", "hoops to jump through, especially at the early stages. She tried it anyway,", "to have longterm participation in a site for which content -- specifically comments,", "there any cultural mismatch between the mainstream SE model and the goal of", "this is a mild form of academic censorship. I am very passionately against", "not enough involvement, so questions about what future course the site could take", "on-topic for the site are being deleted. My feeling is that this is", "of academic censorship. I am very passionately against the encroachment of academic censorship,", "it anyway, and the site didn't make it past Area 51: the cultural", "move mathoverflow.net to the SE2.0 model. This was finally done only after many", "that was unilaterally closed by a moderator. My comment expressed -- wholly civilly", "the \"beta phase\" because there is not enough involvement, so questions about what", "were a lot of strange-looking (to us) rules and hoops to jump through," ]
[ "> You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that", "that I'd like to hear. However, the help center says that > >", "center says that > > You should only ask practical, answerable questions based", "often very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that", "> Is it appropriate to ask questions here that I've read on a", "readers write in asking the author of the blog to post a question", "appropriate to ask questions here that I've read on a blog, to find", "says that > > You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on", "discuss in the comments. These are often very interesting questions that are on-topic", "on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this community would have useful answers", "and I think that this community would have useful answers that I'd like", "a question they have about academia. Then the readers of the blog answer", "comments. These are often very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and", "based on actual problems that you face. > > > Is it appropriate", "in asking the author of the blog to post a question they have", "blog answer and discuss in the comments. These are often very interesting questions", "answerable questions based on actual problems that you face. > > > Is", "(OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author of", "are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this community would have useful", "the readers of the blog answer and discuss in the comments. These are", "questions here that I've read on a blog, to find out what this", "like to hear. However, the help center says that > > You should", "too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author of the", "that this community would have useful answers that I'd like to hear. However,", "ask questions here that I've read on a blog, to find out what", "ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you face. > >", "the author of the blog to post a question they have about academia.", "to ask questions here that I've read on a blog, to find out", "here that I've read on a blog, to find out what this community", "Is it appropriate to ask questions here that I've read on a blog,", "think that this community would have useful answers that I'd like to hear.", "answers that I'd like to hear. However, the help center says that >", "they have about academia. Then the readers of the blog answer and discuss", "I think that this community would have useful answers that I'd like to", "question they have about academia. Then the readers of the blog answer and", "in the comments. These are often very interesting questions that are on-topic for", "readers of the blog answer and discuss in the comments. These are often", "You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you", "few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author", "> > > Is it appropriate to ask questions here that I've read", "the blog answer and discuss in the comments. These are often very interesting", "and discuss in the comments. These are often very interesting questions that are", "These are often very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I", "that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this community would have", "academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author of the blog to", "> > You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems", "of the blog to post a question they have about academia. Then the", "very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this", "face. > > > Is it appropriate to ask questions here that I've", "practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you face. > > >", "the help center says that > > You should only ask practical, answerable", "this community would have useful answers that I'd like to hear. However, the", "that you face. > > > Is it appropriate to ask questions here", "many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author of the blog", "author of the blog to post a question they have about academia. Then", "help center says that > > You should only ask practical, answerable questions", "post a question they have about academia. Then the readers of the blog", "of the blog answer and discuss in the comments. These are often very", "would have useful answers that I'd like to hear. However, the help center", "have useful answers that I'd like to hear. However, the help center says", "However, the help center says that > > You should only ask practical,", "that > > You should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual", "have about academia. Then the readers of the blog answer and discuss in", "problems that you face. > > > Is it appropriate to ask questions", "useful answers that I'd like to hear. However, the help center says that", "the blog to post a question they have about academia. Then the readers", "hear. However, the help center says that > > You should only ask", "blog to post a question they have about academia. Then the readers of", "questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this community would", "I read a few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in", "answer and discuss in the comments. These are often very interesting questions that", "blogs. Often, readers write in asking the author of the blog to post", "Then the readers of the blog answer and discuss in the comments. These", "I'd like to hear. However, the help center says that > > You", "write in asking the author of the blog to post a question they", "Often, readers write in asking the author of the blog to post a", "are often very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think", "that I've read on a blog, to find out what this community has", "for academic.SE, and I think that this community would have useful answers that", "asking the author of the blog to post a question they have about", "to post a question they have about academia. Then the readers of the", "the comments. These are often very interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE,", "interesting questions that are on-topic for academic.SE, and I think that this community", "read a few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking", "only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you face. >", "actual problems that you face. > > > Is it appropriate to ask", "should only ask practical, answerable questions based on actual problems that you face.", "a few (OK, too many) academic blogs. Often, readers write in asking the", "academia. Then the readers of the blog answer and discuss in the comments.", "community would have useful answers that I'd like to hear. However, the help", "about academia. Then the readers of the blog answer and discuss in the", "questions based on actual problems that you face. > > > Is it", "to hear. However, the help center says that > > You should only", "I've read on a blog, to find out what this community has to", "you face. > > > Is it appropriate to ask questions here that", "academic.SE, and I think that this community would have useful answers that I'd", "> > Is it appropriate to ask questions here that I've read on", "read on a blog, to find out what this community has to say?", "it appropriate to ask questions here that I've read on a blog, to", "on actual problems that you face. > > > Is it appropriate to" ]
[ "compare the answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating", "answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions", "questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few", "with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run", "use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to", "look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it", "of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should", "answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how", "When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try", "and compare the answers we have with the information available on other sites.", "the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10", "a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions", "your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow", "Google searches to see how easy they are to find and compare the", "people out there who need answers to their questions and don't even know", "[Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were", "this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and", "the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and", "few Google searches to see how easy they are to find and compare", "the answers we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the", "'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions", "though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed", "open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the", "Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you", "love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out", "it before, and see how we stack up against the rest of the", "before, and see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net.", "Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are to find", "there who need answers to their questions and don't even know that this", "their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive", "questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from", "quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are to", "questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that", "populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter.", "an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share", "that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and", "Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there who", "share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your", "searches to see how easy they are to find and compare the answers", "Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts", "questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a", "with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a", "is a whole world of people out there who need answers to their", "they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to", "eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack", "a few Google searches to see how easy they are to find and", "of people out there who need answers to their questions and don't even", "there is a whole world of people out there who need answers to", "to see how easy they are to find and compare the answers we", "puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been", "through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how", "they are to find and compare the answers we have with the information", "site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be?", "see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site", "need answers to their questions and don't even know that this site exists.", "We all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of", "world of people out there who need answers to their questions and don't", "stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval)", "rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated", "try to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never", "and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see", "is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern", "easy they are to find and compare the answers we have with the", "site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see", "of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with", "find and compare the answers we have with the information available on other", "the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that should have", "someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up against", "that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer", "is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in", "[Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there", "out there who need answers to their questions and don't even know that", "closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything", "or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post", "a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions", "seen it before, and see how we stack up against the rest of", "first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes", "that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google", "to their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When they", "edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below to share your", "arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look", "review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and", "how easy they are to find and compare the answers we have with", "to find and compare the answers we have with the information available on", "answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's", "to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with", "Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this", "last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they are", "not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really", "part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of questions that", "should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use", "Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and", "in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy", "don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what", "you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are", "a whole world of people out there who need answers to their questions", "of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers", "the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see", "are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going", "but there is a whole world of people out there who need answers", "impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of", "are to find and compare the answers we have with the information available", "could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an answer below", "information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of", "will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through", "Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well?", "all love [Academia Stack Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people", "whole world of people out there who need answers to their questions and", "Do you see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but", "be? Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of someone", "the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part", "answers to their questions and don't even know that this site exists. When", "10 questions that were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a", "have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is only", "up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is", "have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an", "of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up", "sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though. Do", "but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit? Anything that's", "the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to see how easy they", "were asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches", "we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review", "available on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the", "that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first", "that should have been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could", "who's never seen it before, and see how we stack up against the", "and don't even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google,", "exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's", "what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site", "their first impression be? Let's try to look at this site through the", "against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open", "The [Site Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that", "Self-Evaluation review queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked", "asked and answered in the last quarter. Run a few Google searches to", "below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health", "we have with the information available on other sites. Rating the questions is", "really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these", "pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not? Questions or", "at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen it before,", "see a pattern of questions that should have been closed but are not?", "only a part of the puzzle, though. Do you see a pattern of", "on other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle,", "this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their first impression", "never seen it before, and see how we stack up against the rest", "and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered in the last", "going really well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss", "Exchange](http://academia.stackexchange.com), but there is a whole world of people out there who need", "how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The [Site Self-Evaluation", "queue](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/site-eval) is open and populated with 10 questions that were asked and answered", "even know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will", "thoughts and discuss these questions and the site's health with your fellow users!", "know that this site exists. When they arrive from Google, what will their", "the eyes of someone who's never seen it before, and see how we", "from Google, what will their first impression be? Let's try to look at", "answers that could use an edit? Anything that's going really well? Post an", "Let's try to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's", "well? Post an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions", "who need answers to their questions and don't even know that this site", "an answer below to share your thoughts and discuss these questions and the", "and see how we stack up against the rest of the 'Net. The", "other sites. Rating the questions is only a part of the puzzle, though.", "see how easy they are to find and compare the answers we have", "been closed but are not? Questions or answers that could use an edit?", "to look at this site through the eyes of someone who's never seen" ]
[ "> This seems to be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a", "was by a new user and changed an American English spelling to British", "two typos by changing a single letter in each case. How do we", "seems to be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of", "grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems to be a", "character. The second edit was by a new user and changed an American", "couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of", "to leave the post better than you found it. Common reasons for edits", "edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > > This", "spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems to be a little contradictory", "changing a single letter in each case. How do we fell about seemingly", "the post better than you found it. Common reasons for edits include: To", "[editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be substantial and to leave the", "changed an American English spelling to British English and fixed two typos by", "English and fixed two typos by changing a single letter in each case.", "reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > >", "was by a high rep user and fixed a single typo in the", "in the question title by adding a character. The second edit was by", "each case. How do we fell about seemingly minor edits of these types?", "and to leave the post better than you found it. Common reasons for", "edit was by a new user and changed an American English spelling to", "like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of the edits made", "little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\".", "than you found it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and", "... > > > This seems to be a little contradictory to me.", "Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am", "the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high rep", "about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be substantial and to leave", "me. Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I", "typo in the question title by adding a character. The second edit was", "a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings", "letter in each case. How do we fell about seemingly minor edits of", "are expected to be substantial and to leave the post better than you", "title by adding a character. The second edit was by a new user", "by adding a character. The second edit was by a new user and", "> Edits are expected to be substantial and to leave the post better", "I am confused by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected", "expected to be substantial and to leave the post better than you found", "\"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>.", "a single typo in the question title by adding a character. The second", "spelling to British English and fixed two typos by changing a single letter", "to be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of typo", "Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... >", "to be substantial and to leave the post better than you found it.", "and fixed two typos by changing a single letter in each case. How", "because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a", "question title by adding a character. The second edit was by a new", "Edits are expected to be substantial and to leave the post better than", "better than you found it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar", "The second edit was by a new user and changed an American English", "of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high", "and fixed a single typo in the question title by adding a character.", "in each case. How do we fell about seemingly minor edits of these", "substantial and to leave the post better than you found it. Common reasons", "English spelling to British English and fixed two typos by changing a single", "edit was by a high rep user and fixed a single typo in", "it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ...", "confused by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be", "mistakes ... > > > This seems to be a little contradictory to", "fixed two typos by changing a single letter in each case. How do", "contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In", "misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of the edits made to", "instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be substantial and to", "the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be substantial and", "am confused by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to", "be substantial and to leave the post better than you found it. Common", "single letter in each case. How do we fell about seemingly minor edits", "an American English spelling to British English and fixed two typos by changing", "In particularly, I am curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The", "The first edit was by a high rep user and fixed a single", "a high rep user and fixed a single typo in the question title", "to me. Is correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly,", "made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high rep user and", "you found it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling", "and changed an American English spelling to British English and fixed two typos", "by a high rep user and fixed a single typo in the question", "high rep user and fixed a single typo in the question title by", "rep user and fixed a single typo in the question title by adding", "by changing a single letter in each case. How do we fell about", "the question title by adding a character. The second edit was by a", "typos by changing a single letter in each case. How do we fell", "> > Edits are expected to be substantial and to leave the post", "post better than you found it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix", "first edit was by a high rep user and fixed a single typo", "I am curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit", "new user and changed an American English spelling to British English and fixed", "am curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was", "leave the post better than you found it. Common reasons for edits include:", "edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high rep user", "found it. Common reasons for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes", "by the instructions about [editing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/editing) > > Edits are expected to be substantial", "to British English and fixed two typos by changing a single letter in", "> > > This seems to be a little contradictory to me. Is", "adding a character. The second edit was by a new user and changed", "a character. The second edit was by a new user and changed an", "particularly, I am curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first", "> > This seems to be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting", "single typo in the question title by adding a character. The second edit", "be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple of typo like", "a new user and changed an American English spelling to British English and", "curious because of the edits made to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by", "user and fixed a single typo in the question title by adding a", "second edit was by a new user and changed an American English spelling", "typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of the edits", "to <https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high rep user and fixed", "by a new user and changed an American English spelling to British English", "a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because", "fixed a single typo in the question title by adding a character. The", "correcting a couple of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious", "for edits include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > >", "This seems to be a little contradictory to me. Is correcting a couple", "To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems to", "of typo like misspellings \"substantial\". In particularly, I am curious because of the", "American English spelling to British English and fixed two typos by changing a", "and spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems to be a little", "include: To fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems", "British English and fixed two typos by changing a single letter in each", "a single letter in each case. How do we fell about seemingly minor", "user and changed an American English spelling to British English and fixed two", "fix grammar and spelling mistakes ... > > > This seems to be", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/posts/16976/revisions>. The first edit was by a high rep user and fixed a" ]
[ "their research revealed (it is a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249))", "don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or", "of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking if it is ethical to", "wrong), they do not actually answer the question. *Do we really want to", "score (one has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if", "if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the question. Do we really", "the examples I linked to has negative score (one has a positive one!),", "should not be answered, but this is not the case I am talking", "recently noticed a trend in the answers on academia.se to question the situation", "actually answer the question. Do we really want to collect such answers? And,", "asking a question lately, I was sure to cover all my bases (e.g.", "was offending to her is not offending in general [Is it ethical to", "for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The question is", "a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks", "I was asking a question lately, I was sure to cover all my", "recent examples from a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a", "not the case I am talking about. One other thing is that people", "cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and in", "days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing", "OP is easily offended, or that what was offending to her is not", "provided, instead of answering what is being asked. Most recent examples from a", "Most recent examples from a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if", "of answers still do not answer the question actually asked, and it is", "are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples. I know", "want to disclose the details, there is something wrong or unethical in your", "not our place to question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not", "disclose the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or the wish to", "in good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since I", "is not offending in general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria for", "kind of answers still do not answer the question actually asked, and it", "or that what was offending to her is not offending in general [Is", "clothing worn to class as a TA or other person of authority ", "it is not our place to question the facts presented. Yet, the community", "admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking if", "research revealed (it is a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) ", "push them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers", "that everything was done ethically and in good will) to avoid answers questioning", "do we want to do with such answers that already exist?* Should we", "more recent examples. I know when I was asking a question lately, I", "be answered, but this is not the case I am talking about. One", "the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to be condemning those kind", "controversial questions, those answers seem to get support from part of the community", "things, such as How do I best cheat on the admission process, or", "because of their attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and not because", "good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since I saw", "asking because not every single detail is provided, instead of answering what is", "unethical in your methodology, because you don't want to disclose the details.\" I", "to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and", "ethically and in good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods,", "The question is asking if it is ethical to design admission criteria according", "not actually answer the question. Do we really want to collect such answers?", "anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I don't think this is a", "sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to", "asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing* worn to class as a", "want to disclose the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or the", "answers?* And, as a secondary questions, *what do we want to do with", "to do about clearly offensive clothing* worn to class as a TA or", "of the opinions might be valid in case the OP really made a", "examples I linked to has negative score (one has a positive one!), even", "wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more", "One other thing is that people say \"if you do not want to", "because not every single detail* is provided, instead of answering what is being", "the situation about which OP is asking because not every single detail is", "has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong),", "my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and in good will)", "motives and methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even", "case the OP really made a mistake, those kind of answers still do", "but this is not the case I am talking about. One other thing", "in the answers on academia.se to question the situation about which OP is", "asked. Most recent examples from a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene", "the community because of their attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and", "of authority Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP is", "so I don't think this is a good trend While some of the", "similar, should not be answered, but this is not the case I am", "which OP is asking because not every single detail is provided, instead of", "These are just two more recent examples. I know when I was asking", "answers seem to get support from part of the community because of their", "offensive clothing* worn to class as a TA or other person of authority", "opinions might be valid in case the OP really made a mistake, those", "([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples. I know when I was", "just two more recent examples. I know when I was asking a question", "talking about. One other thing is that people say \"if you do not", "do not actually answer the question. Do we really want to collect such", "in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The question asks what to do about clearly offensive", "admission process, or something similar, should not be answered, but this is not", "to push them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial questions, those", "I know when I was asking a question lately, I was sure to", "(e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and in good will) to avoid", "down, but especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get", "other thing is that people say \"if you do not want to disclose", "you don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity,", "a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting", "(and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the", "prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking", "ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate", "answers very strong: neither of the examples I linked to has negative score", "answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP is easily offended, or that", "it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on country of", "it is ethical to design admission criteria according to a certain statistics their", "those kind of answers very strong: neither of the examples I linked to", "of their attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and not because they", "about which OP is asking because not every single detail* is provided, instead", "of answering what is being asked. Most recent examples from a few days", "we flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently", "often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as *How do", "clearly offensive clothing* worn to class as a TA or other person of", "negative score (one has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me", "do I best cheat on the admission process, or something similar, should not", "if it is ethical to design admission criteria according to a certain statistics", "towards the controversial issue in question, and not because they actually offer an", "been wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two", "offending in general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions", "collect such answers? And, as a secondary questions, *what do we want to", "question lately, I was sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that", "from a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student is", "in your methodology, because you don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand", "down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial questions,", "some answers were suggesting that the statistics and the research they did must", "and it is not our place to question the facts presented. Yet, the", "answering what is being asked. Most recent examples from a few days ago", "general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on", "strong: neither of the examples I linked to has negative score (one has", "and methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even be", "non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions", "wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you don't want to disclose the", "few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive", "valid in case the OP really made a mistake, those kind of answers", "my motives and methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and", "Do we really want to collect such answers? And, as a secondary questions,", "as a TA or other person of authority * Some answers, instead of", "suggesting that the statistics and the research they did must have been wrong", "not answer the question actually asked, and it is not our place to", "TA or other person of authority * Some answers, instead of answering, argue", "of the community because of their attitude towards the controversial issue in question,", "mistake, those kind of answers still do not answer the question actually asked,", "not be answered, but this is not the case I am talking about.", "on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking if it is", "don't think this is a good trend While some of the opinions might", "a question lately, I was sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating", "was sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done", "might be valid in case the OP really made a mistake, those kind", "generalize, so I don't think this is a good trend While some of", "questioning my motives and methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail", "neither of the examples I linked to has negative score (one has a", "something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you don't want to disclose", "that what was offending to her is not offending in general [Is it", "to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since I saw this kind", "of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that", "people say \"if you do not want to disclose the details, there is", "I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as How do I", "clearly unethical things, such as How do I best cheat on the admission", "on the admission process, or something similar, should not be answered, but this", "our place to question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to", "am talking about. One other thing is that people say \"if you do", "to question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to be condemning", "criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics", "of the examples I linked to has negative score (one has a positive", "must have been wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are", "seem to get support from part of the community because of their attitude", "some of the opinions might be valid in case the OP really made", "the wish to generalize, so I don't think this is a good trend", "we really want to collect such answers?* And, as a secondary questions, *what", "question. Do we really want to collect such answers? And, as a secondary", "is that people say \"if you do not want to disclose the details,", "is a good trend While some of the opinions might be valid in", "class as a TA or other person of authority Some answers, instead", "questions, those answers seem to get support from part of the community because", "exist? Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes to push", "to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249)", "kind of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand", "to collect such answers? And, as a secondary questions, *what do we want", "person of authority Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP", "other person of authority * Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the", "not every single detail is provided, instead of answering what is being asked.", "disclose the details, there is something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because", "professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) ", "is asking if it is ethical to design admission criteria according to a", "Yet, the community seems not to be condemning those kind of answers very", "is a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering,", "to a certain statistics their research revealed (it is a bit of a", "not want to disclose the details, there is something wrong or unethical in", "do not answer the question actually asked, and it is not our place", "was asking a question lately, I was sure to cover all my bases", "methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even be the", "recent examples. I know when I was asking a question lately, I was", "answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics and the research they did", "them? We could wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but", "the admission process, or something similar, should not be answered, but this is", "results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples. I", "place to question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to be", "process, or something similar, should not be answered, but this is not the", "think this is a good trend While some of the opinions might be", "question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to be condemning those", "and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly", "this kind of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often. I", "were suggesting that the statistics and the research they did must have been", "noticed a trend in the answers on academia.se to question the situation about", "community seems not to be condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither", "bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and in good will) to", "could wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially on", "or the wish to generalize, so I don't think this is a good", "and in good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since", "examples. I know when I was asking a question lately, I was sure", "research they did must have been wrong and the results are not valid.", "graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The question is asking", "we want to do with such answers that already exist? Should we flag-delete", "wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially on a", "the statistics and the research they did must have been wrong and the", "according to a certain statistics their research revealed (it is a bit of", "what is being asked. Most recent examples from a few days ago include:", "such answers? And, as a secondary questions, *what do we want to do", "a certain statistics their research revealed (it is a bit of a controversial", "undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking if it is ethical to design", "especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get support from", "question the situation about which OP is asking because not every single detail", "me if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the question. *Do we", "when I was asking a question lately, I was sure to cover all", "admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that the", "I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the question. *Do we really want", "avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since I saw this kind of", "classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The question asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing worn", "to design admission criteria according to a certain statistics their research revealed (it", "about. One other thing is that people say \"if you do not want", "very strong: neither of the examples I linked to has negative score (one", "done ethically and in good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and", "* The question is asking if it is ethical to design admission criteria", "or other person of authority * Some answers, instead of answering, argue that", "part of the community because of their attitude towards the controversial issue in", "even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do not actually", "situation about which OP is asking because not every single detail* is provided,", "the community seems not to be condemning those kind of answers very strong:", "from part of the community because of their attitude towards the controversial issue", "not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples. I know when", "instead of answering, argue that the OP is easily offended, or that what", "is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks what to", "on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get support from part", "answer the question actually asked, and it is not our place to question", "While some of the opinions might be valid in case the OP really", "condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither of the examples I linked", "be valid in case the OP really made a mistake, those kind of", "(it is a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) Instead of", "understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as How do I best", "their attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and not because they actually", "answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as How", "clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks what to do about clearly", "to be condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither of the examples", "that already exist?* Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes", "as How do I best cheat on the admission process, or something similar,", "to do with such answers that already exist?** Should we flag-delete them? We", "apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) ", "I am talking about. One other thing is that people say \"if you", "answer the question. Do we really want to collect such answers? And, as", "questions asking clearly unethical things, such as *How do I best cheat on", "thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer", "to disclose the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or the wish", "that the OP is easily offended, or that what was offending to her", "those answers seem to get support from part of the community because of", "country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking if it is ethical", "everything was done ethically and in good will) to avoid answers questioning my", "of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers were", "one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do not", "wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The question asks what to do", "in case the OP really made a mistake, those kind of answers still", "a secondary questions, what do we want to do with such answers that", "really want to collect such answers? And, as a secondary questions, *what do", "details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so", "because you don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand the need for", "easily offended, or that what was offending to her is not offending in", "a TA or other person of authority * Some answers, instead of answering,", "bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers", "to disclose the details, there is something wrong or unethical in your methodology,", "the question actually asked, and it is not our place to question the", "best cheat on the admission process, or something similar, should not be answered,", "(one has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm", "I have recently noticed a trend in the answers on academia.se to question", "such answers that already exist? Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for", "what do we want to do with such answers that already exist? Should", "of answers very strong: neither of the examples I linked to has negative", "every single detail* is provided, instead of answering what is being asked. Most", "detail* is provided, instead of answering what is being asked. Most recent examples", "kind of answers very strong: neither of the examples I linked to has", "answers that already exist?** Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for the", "ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in", "a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some", "* Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics and the", "do about clearly offensive clothing worn to class as a TA or other", "is asking because not every single detail is provided, instead of answering what", "the research they did must have been wrong and the results are not", "I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers", "has negative score (one has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct", "community because of their attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and not", "do with such answers that already exist?** Should we flag-delete them? We could", "in general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based", "the OP really made a mistake, those kind of answers still do not", "since I saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted", "answered, but this is not the case I am talking about. One other", "a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get support from part of", "valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples. I know when I", "not offending in general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate", "there is something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you don't want", "even be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical", "this is a good trend While some of the opinions might be valid", "the question. Do we really want to collect such answers?* And, as a", "[Is it ethical to apply different criteria for graduate admissions based on country", "asking if it is ethical to design admission criteria according to a certain", "the case I am talking about. One other thing is that people say", "a good trend While some of the opinions might be valid in case", "statistics and the research they did must have been wrong and the results", "answers still do not answer the question actually asked, and it is not", "want to collect such answers?* And, as a secondary questions, what do we", "trend in the answers on academia.se to question the situation about which OP", "We could wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially", "question is asking if it is ethical to design admission criteria according to", "are just two more recent examples. I know when I was asking a", "is being asked. Most recent examples from a few days ago include: [Should", "answers on academia.se to question the situation about which OP is asking because", "design admission criteria according to a certain statistics their research revealed (it is", "Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics and the research", "ethical to design admission criteria according to a certain statistics their research revealed", "the need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I don't think", "already exist? Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes to", "certain statistics their research revealed (it is a bit of a controversial admission", "made a mistake, those kind of answers still do not answer the question", "unethical things, such as How do I best cheat on the admission process,", "this is not the case I am talking about. One other thing is", "OP really made a mistake, those kind of answers still do not answer", "answers were suggesting that the statistics and the research they did must have", "the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial", "need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I don't think this", "the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent examples.", "have been wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just", "the details, there is something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you", "Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP is easily offended, or", "of answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics and the research they", "such as How do I best cheat on the admission process, or something", "them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem", "based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking if it", "you do not want to disclose the details, there is something wrong or", "about clearly offensive clothing worn to class as a TA or other person", "being asked. Most recent examples from a few days ago include: [Should professors", "questions, what do we want to do with such answers that already exist?", "that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as How do I best cheat", "is ethical to design admission criteria according to a certain statistics their research", "How do I best cheat on the admission process*, or something similar, should", "the opinions might be valid in case the OP really made a mistake,", "criteria according to a certain statistics their research revealed (it is a bit", "is not the case I am talking about. One other thing is that", "understand the need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I don't", "those kind of answers still do not answer the question actually asked, and", "bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get support from part of the", "methodology, because you don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand the need", "a mistake, those kind of answers still do not answer the question actually", "is provided, instead of answering what is being asked. Most recent examples from", "not to be condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither of the", "her is not offending in general [Is it ethical to apply different criteria", "the details.\" I understand the need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize,", "answering, argue that the OP is easily offended, or that what was offending", "what was offending to her is not offending in general [Is it ethical", "Should we flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes to push them", "know when I was asking a question lately, I was sure to cover", "or unethical in your methodology, because you don't want to disclose the details.\"", "attitude towards the controversial issue in question, and not because they actually offer", "\"if you do not want to disclose the details, there is something wrong", "but especially on a bit controversial questions, those answers seem to get support", "still do not answer the question actually asked, and it is not our", "to class as a TA or other person of authority Some answers,", "a positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they", "And, as a secondary questions, what do we want to do with such", "something similar, should not be answered, but this is not the case I", "for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down, but especially on a bit", "the answers on academia.se to question the situation about which OP is asking", "will) to avoid answers questioning my motives and methods, since I saw this", "do not want to disclose the details, there is something wrong or unethical", "a trend in the answers on academia.se to question the situation about which", "criteria for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question", "thing is that people say \"if you do not want to disclose the", "linked to has negative score (one has a positive one!), even thou, (and,", "is something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you don't want to", "trend While some of the opinions might be valid in case the OP", "I don't think this is a good trend While some of the opinions", "and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These are just two more recent", "have recently noticed a trend in the answers on academia.se to question the", "instead of answering what is being asked. Most recent examples from a few", "[Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249)", "details, there is something wrong or unethical in your methodology, because you don't", "most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such as", "asked, and it is not our place to question the facts presented. Yet,", "revealed (it is a bit of a controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) Instead", "facts presented. Yet, the community seems not to be condemning those kind of", "lately, I was sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything", "asking clearly unethical things, such as *How do I best cheat on the", "and the research they did must have been wrong and the results are", "or something similar, should not be answered, but this is not the case", "I was sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was", "your methodology, because you don't want to disclose the details.\" I understand the", "that the statistics and the research they did must have been wrong and", "I best cheat on the admission process, or something similar, should not be", " Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP is easily offended,", "they do not actually answer the question. Do we really want to collect", "include: [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their", "argue that the OP is easily offended, or that what was offending to", "answers questioning my motives and methods, since I saw this kind of non-answers", "cheat on the admission process, or something similar, should not be answered, but", "worn to class as a TA or other person of authority * Some", "get support from part of the community because of their attitude towards the", "examples from a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student", "([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that the statistics and", "wish to generalize, so I don't think this is a good trend While", "actually asked, and it is not our place to question the facts presented.", "support from part of the community because of their attitude towards the controversial", "to her is not offending in general [Is it ethical to apply different", "sure to cover all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically", "seems not to be condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither of", "the OP is easily offended, or that what was offending to her is", "with such answers that already exist?** Should we flag-delete them? We could wait", "two more recent examples. I know when I was asking a question lately,", "presented. Yet, the community seems not to be condemning those kind of answers", "intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The", "of answering, argue that the OP is easily offended, or that what was", "positive one!), even thou, (and, please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do", "for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I don't think this is", "I linked to has negative score (one has a positive one!), even thou,", "did must have been wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249)) These", "all my bases (e.g. explicating that everything was done ethically and in good", "that people say \"if you do not want to disclose the details, there", "The question asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing* worn to class", "flag-delete them? We could wait for the down-votes to push them sufficiently down,", "want to do with such answers that already exist? Should we flag-delete them?", "admission criteria according to a certain statistics their research revealed (it is a", "secondary questions, what do we want to do with such answers that already", "be the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things,", "saw this kind of non-answers prevail and even be the most-upvoted answers often.", "if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question", "offending to her is not offending in general [Is it ethical to apply", "is easily offended, or that what was offending to her is not offending", "different criteria for graduate admissions based on country of undergraduate study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) * The", "question actually asked, and it is not our place to question the facts", "was done ethically and in good will) to avoid answers questioning my motives", "case I am talking about. One other thing is that people say \"if", "to generalize, so I don't think this is a good trend While some", "statistics their research revealed (it is a bit of a controversial admission criteria).", "on academia.se to question the situation about which OP is asking because not", "I understand the need for anonymity, or the wish to generalize, so I", "to question the situation about which OP is asking because not every single", "controversial admission criteria). ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17771/4249)) * Instead of answering, some answers were suggesting that", "academia.se to question the situation about which OP is asking because not every", "study?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17658/4249) The question is asking if it is ethical to design admission", "single detail* is provided, instead of answering what is being asked. Most recent", "OP is asking because not every single detail is provided, instead of answering", "really made a mistake, those kind of answers still do not answer the", "explicating that everything was done ethically and in good will) to avoid answers", "they did must have been wrong and the results are not valid. ([example](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/17675/4249))", "their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) The question asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing", "to has negative score (one has a positive one!), even thou, (and, please,", "* The question asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing worn to", "to get support from part of the community because of their attitude towards", "good trend While some of the opinions might be valid in case the", "please, correct me if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the question.", "say \"if you do not want to disclose the details, there is something", "the most-upvoted answers often. I understand that questions asking clearly unethical things, such", "question asks what to do about clearly offensive clothing* worn to class as", "offended, or that what was offending to her is not offending in general", "be condemning those kind of answers very strong: neither of the examples I", "offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks what to do about", "student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/17739/4249) * The question asks what", "authority * Some answers, instead of answering, argue that the OP is easily", "is not our place to question the facts presented. Yet, the community seems", "what to do about clearly offensive clothing worn to class as a TA", "a few days ago include: [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing", "as a secondary questions, *what do we want to do with such answers", "the controversial issue in question, and not because they actually offer an answer.", "correct me if I'm wrong), they do not actually answer the question. *Do" ]
[ "am currently a sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on graduate school", "statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored to my own", "on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored to my own statistics.", "looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored", "just looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances", "a sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and", "but just looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible", "sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if", "some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored to my", "I am currently a sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on graduate", "currently a sophomore, but just looking for some statistics on graduate school admissions,", "for some statistics on graduate school admissions, and if possible chances tailored to" ]
[ "I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other", "given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders", "guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good answers): * [What to do", "The only exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than", "possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which without explicit", "[some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for", "not go into details. > > > The only exception I can foresee", "talking with me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > >", "religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question", "questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best", "with > > What to do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves", "[Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their)", "to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which without explicit examples would", "which without explicit examples would end in guessing games (but, as they are,", "started because of [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing", "of [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their", "library gives undesirable results, but let me not go into details. > >", "attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What", "cases the question lack enough details, and people are confused or ask for", "example, compare > > What to do if advisor, when talking with me,", "compare > > What to do if advisor, when talking with me, holds", "[Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started", "only exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than often", "> > The first will start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let", "experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do", "OP downplays it and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves", "\"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example,", "work with: > > this library gives undesirable results, but let me not", "open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some cases the question lack enough", "> > this library gives undesirable results, but let me not go into", "my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with > > What", "am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers,", "> The first will start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us", "many other readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if", "that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And", "they attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)?", "it is clear what is the question? * do they attract good answers?", "of [People denying the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any", "classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in the", "explicit examples would end in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good", "[What to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many", "to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior is", "assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented scientists write horrible", "questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life", "laws varies by countries, different people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc.", "what is the question? * do they attract good answers? * do they", "issue is serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it", "but of similar calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim", "but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare > >", "idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more", "more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works", "and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with > > What to do", "behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal", "horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of [Should professors intervene if", "For example, compare > > What to do if advisor, when talking with", "guess, more than often a different but of similar calibre example can be", "do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because", "[People denying the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case,", "StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library gives undesirable results, but let", "answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What do you", "too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However,", "(with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which without", "won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow", "talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The", "multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some cases the question lack", "is the question? * do they attract good answers? * do they minimize", "and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will start an idle", "go into details. > > > The only exception I can foresee is", "> > with > > What to do if advisor, when talking with", "MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow", "it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some cases the", "me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with >", "questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important factor is", "details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity", "different but of similar calibre example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or", "will start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE", "in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good answers): * [What to", "by countries, different people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am", "etc. So do many other readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong,", "situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most", "best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library", "me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will", "feeling about providing examples, but: * it is clear what is the question?", "student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up", "because of [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in", "The first will start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember", "advice. However, in some cases the question lack enough details, and people are", "Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies", "more details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of", "call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior is not", "actions? For example, compare > > What to do if advisor, when talking", "serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the", "system works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: >", "most important factor is not my feeling about providing examples, but: * it", "Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the", "if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented scientists write", "or ask for more details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics,", "to do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel", "feel uncomfortable? > > > with > > What to do if advisor,", "different people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when", "behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will start", "than often a different but of similar calibre example can be given). Otherwise", "they are, attracted good answers): * [What to do if assignment is against", "some cases the question lack enough details, and people are confused or ask", "say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best for clear, answerable questions.", "> What to do if advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm", "foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than often a different but of", "was started because of [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive", "any case, IMHO, the most important factor is not my feeling about providing", "the question lack enough details, and people are confused or ask for more", "(but, I guess, more than often a different but of similar calibre* example", "question? * do they attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in", "> with > > What to do if advisor, when talking with me,", "the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or", "uncomfortable? > > > The first will start an idle discussion. The second", "feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will start an idle discussion. The", "if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? >", "meta question was started because of [Should professors intervene if a student is", "the question? * do they attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead", "won't work with: > > this library gives undesirable results, but let me", "against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This", "making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some cases", "sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering).", "(or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best for clear, answerable", "attracted good answers): * [What to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion)", "the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this", "details. > > > The only exception I can foresee is privacy (but,", "> > What to do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately", "providing examples, but: * it is clear what is the question? * do", "> The only exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more", "in some cases the question lack enough details, and people are confused or", "can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with,", "when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > >", "not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For", "the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the", "are confused or ask for more details. Especially things dealing with social relations,", "`inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what end up in long comment", "to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented", "* do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What do you think?", "Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or,", "the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions", "best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which", "etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different people", "enough details, and people are confused or ask for more details. Especially things", "discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective", "as examples, questions which without explicit examples would end in guessing games (but,", "if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a", "sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different people have different first-", "start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has", "the SE system works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work", "* [Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was", "instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important factor is not", "exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than often a", "end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious", "gives undesirable results, but let me not go into details. > > >", "> > The only exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess,", "remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow).", "be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly", "> > > The only exception I can foresee is privacy (but, I", "as they are, attracted good answers): * [What to do if assignment is", "software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of [Should professors intervene if a", "case, IMHO, the most important factor is not my feeling about providing examples,", "varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different people have different first- or", "words). And as examples, questions which without explicit examples would end in guessing", "the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important factor", "professors intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and", "mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests", "similar calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are", "and people are confused or ask for more details. Especially things dealing with", "see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what end up in", "works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > >", "into details. > > > The only exception I can foresee is privacy", "What to do if advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm and", "In any case, IMHO, the most important factor is not my feeling about", "important factor is not my feeling about providing examples, but: * it is", "holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with > >", "for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library gives", "readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue", "what end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is", "us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say,", "`offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what end up in long", "let me not go into details. > > > The only exception I", "I already mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread", "has way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE", "walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare > > What to do", "to do if advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm and I", "levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different people have", "ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious enough to call it. Or", "often a different but of similar calibre example can be given). Otherwise explicit", "(but, as they are, attracted good answers): * [What to do if assignment", "The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions", "for more details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels", "advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? >", "have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see", "but: * it is clear what is the question? * do they attract", "with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first", "is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of", "> > > The first will start an idle discussion. The second won't.", "but let me not go into details. > > > The only exception", "end in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good answers): * [What", "ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different", "an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way", "if advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable?", "me not go into details. > > > The only exception I can", "inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare >", "first will start an idle discussion. The second won't. Let us remember that", "in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important", "or legal actions? For example, compare > > What to do if advisor,", "people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I", "is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions?", "clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library gives undesirable", "is privacy (but, I guess, more than often a different but of similar", "a different but of similar calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations", "do many other readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning", "However, in some cases the question lack enough details, and people are confused", "do they attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people asking", "And the SE system works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't", "good answers): * [What to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) ", "than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best for", "provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice.", "and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in the questions", "explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask", "questions which without explicit examples would end in guessing games (but, as they", "factor is not my feeling about providing examples, but: it is clear", "are, attracted good answers): * [What to do if assignment is against student's", "it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior is not \"a", "examples would end in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good answers):", "confused or ask for more details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms,", "* [What to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do", "write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of [Should professors intervene", "questioning if the issue is serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually", "the issue is serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays", "the most important factor is not my feeling about providing examples, but: ", "enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior", "student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) [Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta", "their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in", "it and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk.", "And as examples, questions which without explicit examples would end in guessing games", "many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of", "I guess, more than often a different but of similar calibre example can", "* it is clear what is the question? * do they attract good", "relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by", "things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by", "phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as", "and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\"", "not my feeling about providing examples, but: * it is clear what is", "in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious enough to", "would end in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted good answers): ", "answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library gives undesirable results,", "more than often a different but of similar calibre* example can be given).", "requests for life advice. However, in some cases the question lack enough details,", "persons, laws varies by countries, different people have different first- or second-hand experiences,", "first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`,", "if the issue is serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP", "dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons,", "are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples,", "I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will start an idle discussion.", "actually OP downplays it and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but", "up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious enough", "legal actions? For example, compare > > What to do if advisor, when", "people questioning if the issue is serious enough to call it. Or maybe", "Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to", "without explicit examples would end in guessing games (but, as they are, attracted", "undesirable results, but let me not go into details. > > > The", "> this library gives undesirable results, but let me not go into details.", "questions. StackOverflow won't work with: > > this library gives undesirable results, but", "comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious enough to call it.", "can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than often a different but", "situations or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene", "is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) [Why do many talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software)", "is clear what is the question? * do they attract good answers? ", "StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the best for clear,", "a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in the questions instead of", "talented scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of [Should", "results, but let me not go into details. > > > The only", "answers): [What to do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why", "this library gives undesirable results, but let me not go into details. >", "\"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare > > What to", "social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies", "my feeling about providing examples, but: * it is clear what is the", "norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries,", "downplays it and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't", "inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > > > The first will start an", "I can foresee is privacy (but, I guess, more than often a different", "follow-up of [People denying the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In", "second won't. Let us remember that Academia.SE has way more subjective questions than", "with: > > this library gives undesirable results, but let me not go", "scientists write horrible software?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17781/why-many-talented-scientists-write-horrible-software) This meta question was started because of [Should professors", "do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable?", "with social relations, norms, ethics, etc: levels of sensitivity varies by persons, laws", "examples, but: it is clear what is the question? * do they", "ask for more details. Especially things dealing with social relations, norms, ethics, etc:", "detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some", "etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many", "offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying", "deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare > > What", "wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People", "when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what end", "other readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the", "answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important factor is not my feeling", "a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in some cases the question", "do if assignment is against student's religion?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17815/what-to-do-if-assignment-is-against-students-religion) * [Why do many talented scientists", "people are confused or ask for more details. Especially things dealing with social", "question lack enough details, and people are confused or ask for more details.", "verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words). And", "I feel uncomfortable? > > > with > > What to do if", "> > What to do if advisor, when talking with me, holds my", "As I already mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a", "varies by countries, different people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I", "or verbatim phrases are the best (with, possibly placeholders to mask obscene words).", "is serious enough to call it. Or maybe actually OP downplays it and", "a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of", "subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system works the", "SE system works the best for clear, answerable questions. StackOverflow won't work with:", "denying the situation in the questions instead of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO,", "by persons, laws varies by countries, different people have different first- or second-hand", "clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the", "Or maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior is not \"a bit", "good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people asking comments)? What do", "> What to do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and", "examples, questions which without explicit examples would end in guessing games (but, as", "with me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with", "privacy (but, I guess, more than often a different but of similar calibre", "do if advisor, when talking with me, holds my arm and I feel", "or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc.", "question was started because of [Should professors intervene if a student is wearing", "uncomfortable? > > > with > > What to do if advisor, when", "of answering](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/834/people-denying-the-situation-in-the-questions-instead-of-answering). In any case, IMHO, the most important factor is not my", "way more subjective questions than StackOverflow (or, say, MathOverflow). And the SE system", "details, and people are confused or ask for more details. Especially things dealing", "clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what", "obscene words). And as examples, questions which without explicit examples would end in", "countries, different people have different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless", "example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the best", "of sensitivity varies by persons, laws varies by countries, different people have different", "about providing examples, but: * it is clear what is the question? ", "advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I feel uncomfortable? > >", "in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation", " do they attract good answers? * do they minimize overhead (in people", "long comment ping-pong, people questioning if the issue is serious enough to call", "of similar calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases", "lack enough details, and people are confused or ask for more details. Especially", "when talking with me, holds my arm and I feel uncomfortable? > >", "games (but, as they are, attracted good answers): * [What to do if", "clear what is the question? * do they attract good answers? * do", "different first- or second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`,", "I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So do many other readers, what end up", "What to do if advisor, when talking with me, behaves inappropriately and I", "second-hand experiences, etc. I am clueless when I see `offensive`, `inappropriate`, etc. So", "This meta question was started because of [Should professors intervene if a student", "much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended requests for life advice. However, in", "IMHO, the most important factor is not my feeling about providing examples, but:", "being a sort-of follow-up of [People denying the situation in the questions instead", "> > > with > > What to do if advisor, when talking", "So do many other readers, what end up in long comment ping-pong, people", "Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare > > What to do if", "bit inappropriate\" but deserves \"Don't walk. Run.\" or legal actions? For example, compare", "maybe actually OP downplays it and the behavior is not \"a bit inappropriate\"", "arm and I feel uncomfortable? > > > with > > What to", "for life advice. However, in some cases the question lack enough details, and", "calibre* example can be given). Otherwise explicit situations or verbatim phrases are the", "is not my feeling about providing examples, but: * it is clear what", "mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which without explicit examples would end", "placeholders to mask obscene words). And as examples, questions which without explicit examples", "already mentioned, [some questions provide too much detail](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/831/49), making it a multi-thread open-ended", "intervene if a student is wearing offensive clothing in their classroom?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17739/should-professors-intervene-if-a-student-is-wearing-offensive-clothing-in-their) and being", "life advice. However, in some cases the question lack enough details, and people" ]
[ "> I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can", "off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic", "avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what", "> > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\"", "to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business", "is decidedly not what this site is about). > > > Then the", "considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an", "hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical", "non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic.", "> This is a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic program;", "medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional schools are", "whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs", "with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this site is about). >", "consensus is that such questions are not in scope, perhaps this text should", "> > > Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I", "point of the restriction is to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business", "not in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions", "this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional graduate-level degree", "school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also", "about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such", "medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in", "they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD", "> the point of the restriction is to avoid having the board overrun", "This is a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I", "text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law,", "is a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think", "and > > the point of the restriction is to avoid having the", "> > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional", "hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also generally considered", "into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question about admission to", "> Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I be taking", "overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this site is about).", "programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate", "comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold):", "on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): >", "for instance) > > > and > > the point of the restriction", "believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to", "preparatory steps should I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > >", "on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking", "> > Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic", "> > > and > > the point of the restriction is to", "are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking", "program; I think it's perfectly in scope. > > > I also believe", "what this site is about). > > > Then the opposite view on", "(law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic. One the one", "into such programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment on", "(unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an", "to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to", "an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and > >", "a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope. > > >", "the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include", "to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven", "one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into", "that such questions are not in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified", "MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and > > the point of", "> > and > > the point of the restriction is to avoid", "I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a", "student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions", "scope. > > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to", "[help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional", "[York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > >", "degrees (and others like them). If the consensus is that such questions are", "programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic. One the", "some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry", "in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school)", "to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like them). If", "a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's", "into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional schools", "related to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to", "admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question about admission", "looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > >", "such questions are not in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to", "also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted", "interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like them).", "scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional", "entry into such programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment", "academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope. > > > I also", "> > Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I be", "business, medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic. One the one hand,", "perfectly in scope. > > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which", "generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue", "(and others like them). If the consensus is that such questions are not", "school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate", "it's perfectly in scope. > > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text,", "opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I be taking for admission into", "be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward", "\"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees", "to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not", "to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope. > >", "to be some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine)", "which refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine,", "academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and > > the", "One the one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to", "get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional", "professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like them). If the consensus", "seems to be some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business,", "[What preparatory steps should I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): >", "to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and", "the point of the restriction is to avoid having the board overrun with", "decidedly not what this site is about). > > > Then the opposite", "steps should I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This", "include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like them). If the", "Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I be taking for", "> and > > the point of the restriction is to avoid having", "admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope. >", "text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional graduate-level degree programs.", "about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope.", "like them). If the consensus is that such questions are not in scope,", "straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly", "pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this site is about). > >", "pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and >", "> > This is a straightforward question about admission to a post-graduate academic", "be some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and", "I think it's perfectly in scope. > > > I also believe the", "is that such questions are not in scope, perhaps this text should be", "others like them). If the consensus is that such questions are not in", "are not in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude", "on [What preparatory steps should I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/):", "the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should I be taking for admission", "the consensus is that such questions are not in scope, perhaps this text", "in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about", "There seems to be some disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law,", "professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs is", "to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for", "questions are not in scope, perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously", "disagreement about whether professional non-research degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into", "a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on", "related to research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program,", "Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're", "such programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment on [York", "(on hold): > > Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also generally", "schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or", "site is about). > > > Then the opposite view on [What preparatory", "and business degrees (and others like them). If the consensus is that such", "> > the point of the restriction is to avoid having the board", "If the consensus is that such questions are not in scope, perhaps this", "law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like them). If the consensus is", "> Moreover, questions related to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless", "Undergraduate student looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover,", "them). If the consensus is that such questions are not in scope, perhaps", "students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and", "degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) >", "med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question about admission to a", "this site is about). > > > Then the opposite view on [What", "can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others", "the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this site", "questions related to professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related", "also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees, or looking to", "question about admission to a post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in", "board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this site is", "is on-topic. One the one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student", "perhaps this text should be clarified to unambiguously exclude questions about professional graduate-level", "be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and business degrees (and others like", "of the restriction is to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions", "is about). > > > Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps", "view on [What preparatory steps should I be taking for admission into med", "think it's perfectly in scope. > > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question about", "or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > >", "looking to get into medical school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18055/york-undergraduate-student-looking-to-get-into-medical-school) (on hold): > > Moreover, questions related", "about). > > > Then the opposite view on [What preparatory steps should", "is to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly", "degree programs (law, business, medicine) and entry into such programs is on-topic. One", "should I be taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is", "medicine, and business degrees (and others like them). If the consensus is that", "taking for admission into med school?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1010/what-preparatory-steps-should-i-be-taking-for-admission-into-med-school/): > > This is a straightforward question", "career—an MD-PhD program, for instance) > > > and > > the point", "questions (which is decidedly not what this site is about). > > >", "(which is decidedly not what this site is about). > > > Then", "restriction is to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is", "having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which is decidedly not what this", "the one hand, in a comment on [York Undergraduate student looking to get", "in scope. > > > I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers", "the restriction is to avoid having the board overrun with pre-med/pre-law/pre-business questions (which", "program, for instance) > > > and > > the point of the", "instance) > > > and > > the point of the restriction is", "business degrees (and others like them). If the consensus is that such questions", "not what this site is about). > > > Then the opposite view", "research-driven degrees, or looking to pursue an academic career—an MD-PhD program, for instance)", "professional schools are also generally considered off-topic (unless they're related to research-driven degrees,", "I also believe the [help-center](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) text, which refers to \"professional students,\" can be", "post-graduate academic program; I think it's perfectly in scope. > > > I", "refers to \"professional students,\" can be interpreted to include professional law, medicine, and", "and entry into such programs is on-topic. One the one hand, in a" ]
[ "deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in", "syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We", "in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way,", "welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion", "making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting", "answer says: > > if it's a question a PhD student (or higher)", "research that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case", "is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer", "here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > > if it's a question", "questions are about research that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff,", "a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate", "tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So,", "site scope, either: 1. these questions are about research that's not applicable to", "of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym: but", "be closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students and", "the site scope, either: 1. these questions are about research that's not applicable", "contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether", "should be closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students", "previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > > if it's a question a", "(or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate > > >", "closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students and academic", "which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the", "appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says:", "voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym", "academic staff, in which case they should be closed and deleted; or 2.", "postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show", "of the site scope, either: 1. these questions are about research that's not", "of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96),", "and academic staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged", "but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have", "tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope, either: 1. these questions", "> > if it's a question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably", "which case they should be closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable", "top-voted answer says: > > if it's a question a PhD student (or", "question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's", "[research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So", "also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate", "are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they are", "case they should be closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to", "proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to", "applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they should be", "2. they are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case", "We currently have 76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the", "> if it's a question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask.", "discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here", "students and academic staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions", "either: 1. these questions are about research that's not applicable to postgrad students", "staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either", "research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms).", "[I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions", "a question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then", "76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the", "questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope, either: 1. these", "or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which", "have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > >", "scope, either: 1. these questions are about research that's not applicable to postgrad", "PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate >", "\"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope, either: 1.", "on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is", "not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they should", "welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research", "Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a", "this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the", "they should be closed and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad", "academic staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\")", "and academic staff, in which case they should be closed and deleted; or", "about research that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which", "synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym:", "students and academic staff, in which case they should be closed and deleted;", "have 76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of", "[We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: >", "currently have 76 questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition", "and the top-voted answer says: > > if it's a question a PhD", "undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > > if it's", "and deleted; or 2. they are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff,", "to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they should be closed", "applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they are about", "staff, in which case they should be closed and deleted; or 2. they", "irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome", "'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope, either: 1. these questions are", "questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed", "whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and", "tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making", "the top-voted answer says: > > if it's a question a PhD student", "research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > > if it's a", "it's a question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so,", "definition of the site scope, either: 1. these questions are about research that's", "is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd", "way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym", "case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate", "tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope,", "are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is", "the definition of the site scope, either: 1. these questions are about research", "if it's a question a PhD student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If", "these questions are about research that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic", "discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted answer says: > > if", "about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant.", "in which case they should be closed and deleted; or 2. they are", "the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it a synonym of", "research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd", "that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they", "to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research", "So [I've proposed making it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your", "says: > > if it's a question a PhD student (or higher) could", "I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome", "postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they should be closed and", "to voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this", "By the definition of the site scope, either: 1. these questions are about", "questions tagged [research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site", "a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that", "that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate.", "they are about [research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research \"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag", "1. these questions are about research that's not applicable to postgrad students and", "'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've proposed making it", "I'd also welcome discussion of whether this synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed", "synonym is appropriate. [We have discussed undergraduate research here previously](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/q/666/96), and the top-voted", "\"show questions tagged 'research'\") Either way, the research-undergraduate tag is irrelevant. So [I've", "student (or higher) could reasonably ask. If so, then it's appropriate > >", "it a synonym of research](https://academia.stackexchange.com/tags/research/synonyms). So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on", "So, I'd welcome your contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd also", "your contributions to voting on that syonym: but I'd also welcome discussion of", "are about research that's not applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in", "[research-undergraduate](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/research-undergraduate \"show questions tagged 'research-undergraduate'\"). By the definition of the site scope, either:", "they are applicable to postgrad students and academic staff, in which case they" ]
[ "admissions, and they will accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited", "that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\"", "a university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions?", "> > > Or [What is the best way to choose an MBA", "offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > > >", "problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in", "students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic,", "without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll in a full", "are off-topic, but I don't see a lot of consistency in the reason", "then, I would like to take transferable online courses to count towards my", "an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a", "Is there a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it", "it just famous for global marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling", "MBA program. Until then, I would like to take transferable online courses to", "a full time MBA program. Until then, I would like to take transferable", "I would like to take transferable online courses to count towards my degree.", "here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What", "> > What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > >", "take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will", "count towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and they will accept up", "reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because it", "that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > >", "take transferable online courses to count towards my degree. I talked with admissions,", "online degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or [What is the best", "Or is it just famous for global marketing/management? > > > It is", "> It is my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I don't", "lot of consistency in the reason given for closure, and they sometimes end", "off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students", "admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll in a full time MBA", "is my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I don't see a", "> > It is my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I", "undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category", "for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic", "\"This question appears to be off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions", "to choose an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is", "this category off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical reason for closing", "Are questions in this category off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical", "questions in this category off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical reason", "[Where can I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next", "category off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical reason for closing questions", "is the best way to choose an MBA school for someone in lighting", "individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or", "We've recently had a few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a", "suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the", "the best way to choose an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry):", "but I don't see a lot of consistency in the reason given for", "facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this", "anyone know of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where", "few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program that meets", "not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not", "to be off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing", "an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers individual", "for global marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling that these questions", "\"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are", "online courses to count towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and they", "in a full time MBA program. Until then, I would like to take", "featured with lighting industry? Or is it just famous for global marketing/management? >", "industry? Or is it just famous for global marketing/management? > > > It", "with admissions, and they will accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB", "degree. I talked with admissions, and they will accept up to 6 credits", "Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does", "say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For", "> > > It is my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but", "about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions", "degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? >", "enroll in a full time MBA program. Until then, I would like to", "and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and if so,", "[What is the best way to choose an MBA school for someone in", "from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers", "meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online MBA courses without", "questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program that meets requirements", "up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears", "global marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling that these questions are", "reason given for closure, and they sometimes end up being closed for tangential", "are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and", "famous for global marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling that these", "\"Does anyone know of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example,", "will accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I", "being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll in a full time", "I will enroll in a full time MBA program. Until then, I would", "would like to take transferable online courses to count towards my degree. I", "industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry?", "MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online", "> > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest", "just famous for global marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling that", "if so, is there a canonical reason for closing questions in this category?", "questions are off-topic, but I don't see a lot of consistency in the", "talked with admissions, and they will accept up to 6 credits from an", "Until then, I would like to take transferable online courses to count towards", "can I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year", "university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it just famous for", "> > Next year I will enroll in a full time MBA program.", "> > Is there a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or", "don't see a lot of consistency in the reason given for closure, and", "consistency in the reason given for closure, and they sometimes end up being", "appears to be off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems", "academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively).", "not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and if so, is", "year I will enroll in a full time MBA program. Until then, I", "these questions are off-topic, but I don't see a lot of consistency in", "of consistency in the reason given for closure, and they sometimes end up", "credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that", "being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears to", "X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted):", "closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and if so, is there", "cannot find a university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here", "question appears to be off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about", "be off-topic because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate", "know of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can", "I cannot find a university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone", "MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it just famous for global", "these three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because it is not", "> Is there a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is", "closure, and they sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these", "program. Until then, I would like to take transferable online courses to count", "Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online degrees in", "about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and not closed,", "> Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online degrees", "my degree. I talked with admissions, and they will accept up to 6", "to count towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and they will accept", "have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are", "it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\"", "are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or [What", "> > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online", "AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers individual online", "for closure, and they sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In", "someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA programme featured", "in this category off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical reason for", "cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or [What is the", "It is my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I don't see", "and they will accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school.", "best way to choose an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): >", "feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I don't see a lot of", "example, [Where can I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > >", "see a lot of consistency in the reason given for closure, and they", "university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? >", "Science? > > > Or [What is the best way to choose an", "is it just famous for global marketing/management? > > > It is my", "program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online MBA", "sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This", "will enroll in a full time MBA program. Until then, I would like", "marketing/management? > > > It is my feeling that these questions are off-topic,", "school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA", "up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find", "examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because it is not about academia,\"", "> What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > > >", "full time MBA program. Until then, I would like to take transferable online", "to take transferable online courses to count towards my degree. I talked with", "for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA programme", "with lighting industry? Or is it just famous for global marketing/management? > >", "courses to count towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and they will", "my feeling that these questions are off-topic, but I don't see a lot", "courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees):", "degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or [What is the best way", "Computer Science? > > > Or [What is the best way to choose", "a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it just famous", "towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and they will accept up to", "the reason given for closure, and they sometimes end up being closed for", "courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll in a", "off-topic,\" and not closed, respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and if", "a lot of consistency in the reason given for closure, and they sometimes", "MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university", "in Computer Science? > > > Or [What is the best way to", "(In these three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because it is", "they will accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately,", "that these questions are off-topic, but I don't see a lot of consistency", "they sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples:", "recently had a few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree", "requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online MBA courses without being", "accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers individual online MBA", "online MBA courses. Does anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest", "Next year I will enroll in a full time MBA program. Until then,", "online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science?", "I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I", "three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because it is not about", "tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears to be off-topic because", "in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA programme featured with", "a few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program that", "a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take", "is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are off-topic,\" and", "that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online MBA courses", "[Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > > What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer", "Does anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): >", "Or [What is the best way to choose an MBA school for someone", "lighting industry? Or is it just famous for global marketing/management? > > >", "accept up to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot", "find a university that offers individual online MBA courses. Does anyone here have", "I don't see a lot of consistency in the reason given for closure,", "MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll in", "given for closure, and they sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons.", "like to take transferable online courses to count towards my degree. I talked", "What are the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or", "> Or [What is the best way to choose an MBA school for", "6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university", "> > Or [What is the best way to choose an MBA school", "school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a university that offers individual online MBA courses.", "there a university MBA programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it just", "time MBA program. Until then, I would like to take transferable online courses", "I talked with admissions, and they will accept up to 6 credits from", "had a few questions that say, \"Does anyone know of a degree program", "choose an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there", "and they sometimes end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three", "> Next year I will enroll in a full time MBA program. Until", "in the reason given for closure, and they sometimes end up being closed", "and if so, is there a canonical reason for closing questions in this", "to 6 credits from an AACSB accredited school. Unfortunately, I cannot find a", "way to choose an MBA school for someone in lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > >", "of a degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I", "off-topic, but I don't see a lot of consistency in the reason given", "respectively). Are questions in this category off-topic, and if so, is there a", "anyone here have suggestions? > > > Or [Cheapest online degrees](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18283/cheapest-online-degrees): > >", "lighting industry?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17667/what-is-the-best-way-to-choose-an-mba-school-for-someone-in-lighting-industry): > > Is there a university MBA programme featured with lighting", "off-topic, and if so, is there a canonical reason for closing questions in", "because it is not about academia,\" \"Questions about problems facing undergraduate students are", "degree program that meets requirements X,Y,Z.\" For example, [Where can I take online", "For example, [Where can I take online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): >", "transferable online courses to count towards my degree. I talked with admissions, and", "programme featured with lighting industry? Or is it just famous for global marketing/management?", "end up being closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question", "the cheapest online degrees in Computer Science? > > > Or [What is", "online MBA courses without being admitted?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18289/where-can-i-take-online-mba-courses-without-being-admitted): > > Next year I will enroll", "closed for tangential reasons. (In these three examples: \"This question appears to be" ]
[ "crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own that I thought was much", "after it was posted. I'm not sure it's my best work but I", "minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of", "Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or the like?", "off as a crank, or something else? There were no comments, positive or", "made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of", "mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds", "minds (which means \"Other people have minds as much as mine, but they're", "a theory of like minds (which can be described as \"Other people have", "best work but I tried to have a heart to heart comment to", "as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and a theory of alien", "people have minds just like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which", "tried to write a response to [I believe I have solved a famous", "were no comments, positive or negative, and it had two upvotes before being", "I do wrong by including a link to my website, or did I", "field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my", "this kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com?", "was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including a link to", "purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or intent, or was", "There were no comments, positive or negative, and it had two upvotes before", "with being outside of the climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate", "was part of it just too strange for the person reading it? I", "website, or did I come off as a crank, or something else? There", "solved a famous open problem. How do I convince people in the field", "was much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of", "or something else? There were no comments, positive or negative, and it had", "not sure it's my best work but I tried to have a heart", "it had two upvotes before being deleted five hours after it was posted.", "[I believe I have solved a famous open problem. How do I convince", "that mentioned an achievement of my own that I thought was much bigger", "to my website, or did I come off as a crank, or something", "or did I come off as a crank, or something else? There were", "positive or negative, and it had two upvotes before being deleted five hours", "to have a heart to heart comment to someone dealing with being outside", "did I come off as a crank, or something else? There were no", "obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including a", "much as mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to", "be described as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and a theory", "a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside", "tried to have a heart to heart comment to someone dealing with being", "alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds as much as mine, but", "but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed", "I have solved a famous open problem. How do I convince people in", "it's my best work but I tried to have a heart to heart", "described as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and a theory of", "I'm not sure it's my best work but I tried to have a", "heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted", "as a crank, or something else? There were no comments, positive or negative,", "comment to someone dealing with being outside of the climate of opinion whether", "the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or the like? Thanks,", "comments, positive or negative, and it had two upvotes before being deleted five", "issues between a theory of like minds (which can be described as \"Other", "or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to heart (or", "I tried to have a heart to heart comment to someone dealing with", "like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people have", "else? There were no comments, positive or negative, and it had two upvotes", "they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as", "own that I thought was much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy", "to write a response to [I believe I have solved a famous open", "of it just too strange for the person reading it? I made a", "reading it? I made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the", "just too strange for the person reading it? I made a distinction (which", "respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted,", "open problem. How do I convince people in the field that I am", "I thought was much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for referees", "invented or reinvented) in the theory of other minds as discussed in reference", "much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing", "people in the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an", "not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own that I thought", "by including a link to my website, or did I come off as", "bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them", "wrong by including a link to my website, or did I come off", "(or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution", "reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds issues between", "come off as a crank, or something else? There were no comments, positive", "of the climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or was", "a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart", "reinvented) in the theory of other minds as discussed in reference to the", "being deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm not sure it's my", "it was posted. I'm not sure it's my best work but I tried", "mentioned an achievement of my own that I thought was much bigger than", "a response to [I believe I have solved a famous open problem. How", "them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by", "outside of the climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or", "for the person reading it? I made a distinction (which I invented or", "just like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people", "and a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds as", "means \"Other people have minds as much as mine, but they're often different", "different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff", "minds issues between a theory of like minds (which can be described as", "a link to my website, or did I come off as a crank,", "within theory of other minds issues between a theory of like minds (which", "to heart comment to someone dealing with being outside of the climate of", "deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm not sure it's my best", "attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or", "problem. How do I convince people in the field that I am not", "empathy for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically", "Was it deleted because of execution or intent, or was part of it", "it deleted because of execution or intent, or was part of it just", "the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds issues between a theory", "referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did", "a famous open problem. How do I convince people in the field that", "do wrong by including a link to my website, or did I come", "instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I", "too strange for the person reading it? I made a distinction (which I", "other minds issues between a theory of like minds (which can be described", "a heart to heart comment to someone dealing with being outside of the", "(which can be described as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and", "mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\"", "other minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory", "my website, or did I come off as a crank, or something else?", "I tried to write a response to [I believe I have solved a", "my own that I thought was much bigger than it was, and respectful", "like minds (which can be described as \"Other people have minds just like", "I come off as a crank, or something else? There were no comments,", "or negative, and it had two upvotes before being deleted five hours after", "work but I tried to have a heart to heart comment to someone", "from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or", "the theory of other minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I", "it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles.", "that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own", "do I convince people in the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f)", "in the theory of other minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum:", "distinguished within theory of other minds issues between a theory of like minds", "it just too strange for the person reading it? I made a distinction", "a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own that I thought was", "and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was", "of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do", "distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the theory of other minds as", "hours after it was posted. I'm not sure it's my best work but", "to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds issues between a", "climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate", "often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo", "or reinvented) in the theory of other minds as discussed in reference to", "response to [I believe I have solved a famous open problem. How do", "I distinguished within theory of other minds issues between a theory of like", "have minds as much as mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was", "famous open problem. How do I convince people in the field that I", "Is this kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of", "kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was", "as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including", "part of it just too strange for the person reading it? I made", "a crank, or something else? There were no comments, positive or negative, and", "I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own that", "to someone dealing with being outside of the climate of opinion whether he", "sure it's my best work but I tried to have a heart to", "viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong", "crank, or something else? There were no comments, positive or negative, and it", "theory of other minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished", "that I thought was much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for", "deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including a link to my", "negative, and it had two upvotes before being deleted five hours after it", "before being deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm not sure it's", "of other minds issues between a theory of like minds (which can be", "the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of", "of my own that I thought was much bigger than it was, and", "was posted. I'm not sure it's my best work but I tried to", "to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because", "deleted because of execution or intent, or was part of it just too", "am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement of my own that I", "achievement of my own that I thought was much bigger than it was,", "the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or intent, or", "intent, or was part of it just too strange for the person reading", "strange for the person reading it? I made a distinction (which I invented", "legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to", "\"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds", "It was deleted, ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including a link", "(which I invented or reinvented) in the theory of other minds as discussed", "mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien minds\" construed as ufo stuff or the", "How do I convince people in the field that I am not a", "including a link to my website, or did I come off as a", "and it had two upvotes before being deleted five hours after it was", "a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds as much", "spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds issues between a theory of", "as mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference to \"alien", "to [I believe I have solved a famous open problem. How do I", "in the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned an achievement", "had two upvotes before being deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm", "of execution or intent, or was part of it just too strange for", "heart comment to someone dealing with being outside of the climate of opinion", "being outside of the climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery", "was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It", "execution or intent, or was part of it just too strange for the", "as much as mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the reference", "heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of", "of like minds (which can be described as \"Other people have minds just", "the climate of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or was a", "because of execution or intent, or was part of it just too strange", "of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or intent, or was part", "ironically enough. Did I do wrong by including a link to my website,", "discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to heart", "convince people in the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that mentioned", "for referees instead of viewing them as obstacles. It was deleted, ironically enough.", "upvotes before being deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm not sure", "or intent, or was part of it just too strange for the person", "made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the theory of other", "I invented or reinvented) in the theory of other minds as discussed in", "theory of other minds issues between a theory of like minds (which can", "can be described as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"), and a", "crank. Is this kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview", "of alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds as much as mine,", "outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or intent,", "Did I do wrong by including a link to my website, or did", "an achievement of my own that I thought was much bigger than it", "posted. I'm not sure it's my best work but I tried to have", "of opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank.", "legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the", "theory of alien minds (which means \"Other people have minds as much as", "the person reading it? I made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented)", "\"Other people have minds as much as mine, but they're often different from", "I convince people in the field that I am not a crank?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18491/i-believe-i-have-solved-a-famous-open-problem-how-do-i-convince-people-in-the-f) that", "two upvotes before being deleted five hours after it was posted. I'm not", "between a theory of like minds (which can be described as \"Other people", "dealing with being outside of the climate of opinion whether he made a", "as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other", "minds (which can be described as \"Other people have minds just like mine\"),", "have a heart to heart comment to someone dealing with being outside of", "a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the theory of other minds", "of other minds as discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within", "it? I made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the theory", "have minds just like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which means", "of heart to heart (or attempt) outside the purview of academia.stackexchange.com? Was it", "opinion whether he made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is", "five hours after it was posted. I'm not sure it's my best work", "believe I have solved a famous open problem. How do I convince people", "write a response to [I believe I have solved a famous open problem.", "was a legitimate crank. Is this kind of heart to heart (or attempt)", "but I tried to have a heart to heart comment to someone dealing", "no comments, positive or negative, and it had two upvotes before being deleted", "someone dealing with being outside of the climate of opinion whether he made", "whether he made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this", "minds as much as mine, but they're often different from mine.\"). Was the", "something else? There were no comments, positive or negative, and it had two", "heart to heart comment to someone dealing with being outside of the climate", "than it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead of viewing them as", "minds just like mine\"), and a theory of alien minds (which means \"Other", "discussed in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds", "my best work but I tried to have a heart to heart comment", "I made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in the theory of", "he made a legitimate discovery or was a legitimate crank. Is this kind", "people have minds as much as mine, but they're often different from mine.\").", "thought was much bigger than it was, and respectful empathy for referees instead", "(which means \"Other people have minds as much as mine, but they're often", "academia.stackexchange.com? Was it deleted because of execution or intent, or was part of", "person reading it? I made a distinction (which I invented or reinvented) in", "enough. Did I do wrong by including a link to my website, or", "or was part of it just too strange for the person reading it?", "in reference to the spectrum: I distinguished within theory of other minds issues", "theory of like minds (which can be described as \"Other people have minds", "have solved a famous open problem. How do I convince people in the", "link to my website, or did I come off as a crank, or" ]
[ "will benefit from it, but I am not sure what the best way", "site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of", "Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience", "There was an interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use", "of Academia will benefit from it, but I am not sure what the", "benefit from it, but I am not sure what the best way is", "papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will benefit from it, but I", "from it, but I am not sure what the best way is to", "Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the", "was an interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of", "the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I", "but I am not sure what the best way is to link to", "interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in", "[(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will", "of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will benefit", "an interesting discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics", "am not sure what the best way is to link to that discussion.", "it, but I am not sure what the best way is to link", "statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will benefit from", "I think the audience of Academia will benefit from it, but I am", "academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will benefit from it, but", "discussion at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic", "think the audience of Academia will benefit from it, but I am not", "at the stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739).", "I am not sure what the best way is to link to that", "stats Cross Validated site about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think", "the audience of Academia will benefit from it, but I am not sure", "Academia will benefit from it, but I am not sure what the best", "about [(mis)use of statistics in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia", "in academic papers](https://stats.stackexchange.com/q/92213/5739). I think the audience of Academia will benefit from it,", "audience of Academia will benefit from it, but I am not sure what" ]
[ "font size during the coding to have the most perfect rendering across browsers.", "stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to view it at full size.", "Click on the image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the", "in a bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this", "### Main illustration Click on the image to view it at full size.", "personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I found online", "promote our site as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt", "to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the", "effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and lively", "our design from calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All", "view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the", "the ability to migrate content to and from other sites — and the", "going for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If there are no major", "site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a", "site design and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I", "Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few", "It has a personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork", "topic and culture. This will help brand your site as unique, even while", "Fall is also when a new academic year starts. All the pastel colors", "### Overall site design Click on the images to view them at full", "that show you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the", "bring calm and harmony and they are lighted up by the green and", "feedback! I've changed the badges based on your answers and comments. They now", "to and from other sites — and the notoriety of a public launch", "perks. I have already begun work on your site's design, which will give", "It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when a new academic year starts.", "contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always been passed", "from calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge", "space and font size during the coding to have the most perfect rendering", "your feedback. If there are no major design changes, we're hoping to launch", "[![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood I was going for. I'd", "awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed", "will give you your own unique theme that reflects your topic and culture.", "I wanted to congratulate you because this site is now starting the process", "of other sites in the network, along with the ability to migrate content", "cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to view it at", "while you share common elements with other sites that show you are part", "along with the ability to migrate content to and from other sites —", "view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood", "non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in other mediums", "for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If there are no major design", "This way we can balance our design from calmness to more contrasted and", "and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always been passed on", "with the ability to migrate content to and from other sites — and", "The idea was to evoke some books in a bookcase but in a", "it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak some", "Click on the image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe", "the image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall", "Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I have already begun work on", "design from calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the", "image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I", "community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed the", "work on your site's design, which will give you your own unique theme", "inviting. Fall is also when a new academic year starts. All the pastel", "valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on your answers and comments. They", "style. It has a personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered some", "colors bring calm and harmony and they are lighted up by the green", "and lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I found online for", "your site's design, which will give you your own unique theme that reflects", "figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in other mediums to", "your site as unique, even while you share common elements with other sites", "fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with", "If there are no major design changes, we're hoping to launch the site", "your own unique theme that reflects your topic and culture. This will help", "a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and lively feel to it.", "the notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\"", "images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click", "and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's", "I believe this modernized logo works in other mediums to promote our site", "design captures the mood I was going for. I'd love to hear your", "Regarding the question list, I will tweak some vertical space and font size", "on by books through the years, they are the origins of teaching. The", "network, along with the ability to migrate content to and from other sites", "is also when a new academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring", "ability to migrate content to and from other sites — and the notoriety", "it. I've gathered some artwork I found online for setting up a mood", "artwork I found online for setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board", "is now starting the process of moving out of beta to become a", "a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn", "found online for setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ###", "senior product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because", "life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style.", "for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on your answers and", "Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you will receive a link in", "design goes up, you will receive a link in the footer of other", "shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the images to view them at", "Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to view it", "a link in the footer of other sites in the network, along with", "full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the images", "red. This way we can balance our design from calmness to more contrasted", "[![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the images to view them", "for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued", "other sites in the network, along with the ability to migrate content to", "there are no major design changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon.", "are mortarboards. Click on the image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)", "[![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image to view it at full", "site is now starting the process of moving out of beta to become", "part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you", "designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because this site", "by books through the years, they are the origins of teaching. The idea", "modernized logo works in other mediums to promote our site as well. ###", "bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo", "I found online for setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png)", "in the network, along with the ability to migrate content to and from", "content to and from other sites — and the notoriety of a public", "the design captures the mood I was going for. I'd love to hear", "at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak some vertical", "question list, I will tweak some vertical space and font size during the", "as unique, even while you share common elements with other sites that show", "view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak", "believe this modernized logo works in other mediums to promote our site as", "Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on your", "to promote our site as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers /", "give you your own unique theme that reflects your topic and culture. This", "and culture. This will help brand your site as unique, even while you", "academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\"", "changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you for being an", "size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image to view it", "way we can balance our design from calmness to more contrasted and focused", "up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png)", "they are lighted up by the green and the red. This way we", "### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's", "size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood I was going for.", "design Click on the images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)", "illustration Click on the image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I", "sites that show you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once", "you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes", "board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme", "the red. This way we can balance our design from calmness to more", "we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you for being an awesome", "up by the green and the red. This way we can balance our", "community's site design and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel.", "and inviting. Fall is also when a new academic year starts. All the", "[![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak some vertical space and font", "wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed", "was to evoke some books in a bookcase but in a non figurative", "believe the design captures the mood I was going for. I'd love to", "migrate content to and from other sites — and the notoriety of a", "Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I have already begun", "of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design", "the images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration", "to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design", "scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and", "feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It", "of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when a new academic", "### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds", "mortarboards. Click on the image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding", "our site as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click", "most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and", "books in a bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe", "calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has", "Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because this site is now starting", "/ t-shirt Click on the image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)", "have already begun work on your site's design, which will give you your", "are no major design changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank", "from other sites — and the notoriety of a public launch that says,", "some artwork I found online for setting up a mood board. ### Mood", "site as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on", "the knowledge has always been passed on by books through the years, they", "image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site", "at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood I was", "the years, they are the origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke", "feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I found online for setting up", "you your own unique theme that reflects your topic and culture. This will", "on the images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main", "other sites that show you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family.", "the image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list,", "even while you share common elements with other sites that show you are", "### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to", "sites in the network, along with the ability to migrate content to and", "I've changed the badges based on your answers and comments. They now are", "years, they are the origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke some", "Concept For our academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted to have", "a personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I found", "of moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ###", "Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you will receive a link", "with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and lively feel to", "the question list, I will tweak some vertical space and font size during", "and from other sites — and the notoriety of a public launch that", "the footer of other sites in the network, along with the ability to", "and harmony and they are lighted up by the green and the red.", "they are the origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke some books", "a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept", "me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when a new", "focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always been passed on by", "the site soon. Thank you for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit:", "it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on", "you share common elements with other sites that show you are part of", "them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image", "calm and harmony and they are lighted up by the green and the", "lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I found online for setting", "bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you will receive a", "conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and lively feel", "and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the image to view it", "scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when", "to launch the site soon. Thank you for being an awesome community! ---", "has always been passed on by books through the years, they are the", "other mediums to promote our site as well. ### Swag Business cards /", "captures the mood I was going for. I'd love to hear your feedback.", "the image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design", "already begun work on your site's design, which will give you your own", "of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you will", "This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is", "Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of", "done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks.", "based on your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the", "Graduation comes with a few perks. I have already begun work on your", "in the footer of other sites in the network, along with the ability", "you because this site is now starting the process of moving out of", "answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the image to view", "design, which will give you your own unique theme that reflects your topic", "the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they are lighted up by", "unique theme that reflects your topic and culture. This will help brand your", "/ stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to view it at full", "process of moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done!", "the badges based on your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click", "starting the process of moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated site!", "it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design and branding, I", "logo works in other mediums to promote our site as well. ### Swag", "at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because this site is", "mediums to promote our site as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers", "become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation", "always been passed on by books through the years, they are the origins", "hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you for being an awesome community!", "by the green and the red. This way we can balance our design", "a few perks. I have already begun work on your site's design, which", "the green and the red. This way we can balance our design from", "design changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you for being", "being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback!", "love to hear your feedback. If there are no major design changes, we're", "own unique theme that reflects your topic and culture. This will help brand", "academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they", "size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the images to", "with a few perks. I have already begun work on your site's design,", "the process of moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well", "origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke some books in a bookcase", "in other mediums to promote our site as well. ### Swag Business cards", "![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting.", "your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on your answers and comments.", "and font size during the coding to have the most perfect rendering across", "to evoke some books in a bookcase but in a non figurative way.", "reflects your topic and culture. This will help brand your site as unique,", "an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've", "theme that reflects your topic and culture. This will help brand your site", "color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also", "list, I will tweak some vertical space and font size during the coding", "this site is now starting the process of moving out of beta to", "moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation", "vertical space and font size during the coding to have the most perfect", "you will receive a link in the footer of other sites in the", "site design Click on the images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)", "notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ###", "### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted", "to congratulate you because this site is now starting the process of moving", "because this site is now starting the process of moving out of beta", "All the knowledge has always been passed on by books through the years,", "full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image to view", "--- ### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges", "was going for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If there are no", "Click on the image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)", "Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted to", "at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image to", "year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they are", "area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always been passed on by books", "to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on", "made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design and branding,", "hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal and lively feel to it. I've", "through the years, they are the origins of teaching. The idea was to", "balance our design from calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo", "are lighted up by the green and the red. This way we can", "are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up,", "elements with other sites that show you are part of a bigger Stack", "and the red. This way we can balance our design from calmness to", "at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the", "will tweak some vertical space and font size during the coding to have", "size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak some vertical space and", "the network, along with the ability to migrate content to and from other", "and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I have already", "changed the badges based on your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards.", "site soon. Thank you for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank", "a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in other", "mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color", "For our academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted to have a", "now are mortarboards. Click on the image to view it at full size.", "have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with a", "it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood I", "full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures the mood I was going", "### Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based", "branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most", "Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I have already begun work", "### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I", "public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For", "help brand your site as unique, even while you share common elements with", "— and the notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally", "finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design and", "I have already begun work on your site's design, which will give you", "scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall", "First, I wanted to congratulate you because this site is now starting the", "are the origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke some books in", "this modernized logo works in other mediums to promote our site as well.", "on your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the image", "no major design changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you", "for setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme", "show you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design", "to hear your feedback. If there are no major design changes, we're hoping", "will help brand your site as unique, even while you share common elements", "we can balance our design from calmness to more contrasted and focused area.", "new academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and", "your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the image to", "other sites — and the notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations,", "the design goes up, you will receive a link in the footer of", "teaching. The idea was to evoke some books in a bookcase but in", "reminds me of autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when a", "Overall site design Click on the images to view them at full size.", "your topic and culture. This will help brand your site as unique, even", "to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design", "a bigger Stack Exchange family. Once the design goes up, you will receive", "and they are lighted up by the green and the red. This way", "image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the design captures", "feedback. If there are no major design changes, we're hoping to launch the", "in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in", "and the notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made", "autumn. It's warm and inviting. Fall is also when a new academic year", "Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me", "design and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think", "![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in other mediums to promote our", "on the image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png) I believe the", "evoke some books in a bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png)", "comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on the image to view it at", "green and the red. This way we can balance our design from calmness", "Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because this site is now", "has a personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered some artwork I", "works in other mediums to promote our site as well. ### Swag Business", "[![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ### Main illustration Click on the image to view it at", "tweak some vertical space and font size during the coding to have the", "Click on the images to view them at full size. [![home](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/KDSU6.png) [![question](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/zSLMh.png) ###", "warm and inviting. Fall is also when a new academic year starts. All", "knowledge has always been passed on by books through the years, they are", "mood I was going for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If there", "pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they are lighted up by the", "now starting the process of moving out of beta to become a fully-graduated", "![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn.", "goes up, you will receive a link in the footer of other sites", "illustration style. It has a personal and lively feel to it. I've gathered", "few perks. I have already begun work on your site's design, which will", "I've gathered some artwork I found online for setting up a mood board.", "to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will", "setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color", "view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click", "to it. I've gathered some artwork I found online for setting up a", "begun work on your site's design, which will give you your own unique", "This will help brand your site as unique, even while you share common", "passed on by books through the years, they are the origins of teaching.", "some books in a bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I", "launch the site soon. Thank you for being an awesome community! --- ###", "a bookcase but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized", "footer of other sites in the network, along with the ability to migrate", "receive a link in the footer of other sites in the network, along", "a new academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony", "with other sites that show you are part of a bigger Stack Exchange", "think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a", "been passed on by books through the years, they are the origins of", "Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This color scheme reminds me of autumn. It's warm", "full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question list, I will tweak some vertical space", "will receive a link in the footer of other sites in the network,", "when a new academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and", "some vertical space and font size during the coding to have the most", "online for setting up a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color", "of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your", "unique, even while you share common elements with other sites that show you", "Main illustration Click on the image to view it at full size. [![illustration](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/AIAOV.png)", "wanted to congratulate you because this site is now starting the process of", "well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the image", "congratulate you because this site is now starting the process of moving out", "I was going for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If there are", "it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has a personal", "lighted up by the green and the red. This way we can balance", "beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site", "our academia.se community's site design and branding, I wanted to have a \"campus", "They now are mortarboards. Click on the image to view it at full", "as well. ### Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the", "share common elements with other sites that show you are part of a", "I believe the design captures the mood I was going for. I'd love", "Thank you for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for", "on the image to view it at full size. [![Badges](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/tvAWf.png) Regarding the question", "brand your site as unique, even while you share common elements with other", "harmony and they are lighted up by the green and the red. This", "\"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration", "### Logo All the knowledge has always been passed on by books through", "a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes", "Logo All the knowledge has always been passed on by books through the", "out of beta to become a fully-graduated site! Well done! ### Graduation and", "sites — and the notoriety of a public launch that says, \"Congratulations, you", "you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site design", "to migrate content to and from other sites — and the notoriety of", "t-shirt Click on the image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t", "a mood board. ### Mood Board ![mood](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Ff2U7.png) ### Color scheme ![color scheme](https://i.stack.imgur.com/lm1eI.png) This", "comes with a few perks. I have already begun work on your site's", "of teaching. The idea was to evoke some books in a bookcase but", "to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively conveyed with", "launch that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our", "can balance our design from calmness to more contrasted and focused area. ###", "but in a non figurative way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works", "Once the design goes up, you will receive a link in the footer", "\"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's site", "Stéphane, senior product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you", "that says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se", "books through the years, they are the origins of teaching. The idea was", "I think it's most effectively conveyed with a hand-drawn illustration style. It has", "to more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always", "you for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you for your", "on the image to view it at full size. [![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ###", "family. Once the design goes up, you will receive a link in the", "major design changes, we're hoping to launch the site soon. Thank you for", "soon. Thank you for being an awesome community! --- ### Edit: Thank you", "common elements with other sites that show you are part of a bigger", "product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate you because this", "culture. This will help brand your site as unique, even while you share", "I wanted to have a \"campus life\" feel. I think it's most effectively", "way. ![Logo](https://i.stack.imgur.com/t6D26.png) I believe this modernized logo works in other mediums to promote", "link in the footer of other sites in the network, along with the", "badges based on your answers and comments. They now are mortarboards. Click on", "the origins of teaching. The idea was to evoke some books in a", "more contrasted and focused area. ### Logo All the knowledge has always been", "idea was to evoke some books in a bookcase but in a non", "I'd love to hear your feedback. If there are no major design changes,", "up, you will receive a link in the footer of other sites in", "that reflects your topic and culture. This will help brand your site as", "says, \"Congratulations, you finally made it!\" ### Design Concept For our academia.se community's", "gathered some artwork I found online for setting up a mood board. ###", "All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they are lighted up", "hear your feedback. If there are no major design changes, we're hoping to", "you for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on your answers", "on your site's design, which will give you your own unique theme that", "site as unique, even while you share common elements with other sites that", "Graduation and Your Site Design Graduation comes with a few perks. I have", "I’m Stéphane, senior product designer at Stack Exchange. First, I wanted to congratulate", "site's design, which will give you your own unique theme that reflects your", "the mood I was going for. I'd love to hear your feedback. If", "starts. All the pastel colors bring calm and harmony and they are lighted", "Swag Business cards / stickers / t-shirt Click on the image to view", "which will give you your own unique theme that reflects your topic and", "also when a new academic year starts. All the pastel colors bring calm", "Edit: Thank you for your valued feedback! I've changed the badges based on", "I will tweak some vertical space and font size during the coding to", "[![swag](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/ZHdGb.png) [![t shirt](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/xfOkZ.png) ### Overall site design Click on the images to view" ]
[ "form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ```", "Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on", "addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the", "graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have the opportunity to setup Community", "advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form.", "twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs ", "apply to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads", "the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not just", "for your own site, not just to apply to other sites. ### What", "a particular service or ad is very valuable to the community and will", "in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process.", "If you want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The", "mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else to", "Please do not add anything else to the body of the post. If", "to this question must* conform to the following rules, or they will be", "show up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of", "the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while", "to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not just to apply", "a way to promote information and resources that are relevant to your own", "it in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the", "are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site, in the", "vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable", "now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site,", "hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) Must be GIF or PNG", "If a particular service or ad is very valuable to the community and", "exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post to this question", "cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material", "as a way to promote information and resources that are relevant to your", "way to promote information and resources that are relevant to your own community's", "stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a way to promote", " cool events or conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be", "a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable to", "* Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit", "for future visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems important.", "Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on", "'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag", "can check out the ads that have met the threshold with basic click", "the post*. If you want to discuss something, do it in the comments.", "is a method for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors", "a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post", "interests, both for those already in the community and those yet to join.", "served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things.", "community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site, in the right", "serves as a way to promote information and resources that are relevant to", "Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site, in", "in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from", "every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad", "else to the body of the post. If you want to discuss something,", "the site's twitter account academic websites and resources * interesting campus story", "restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service", "we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the", "be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the", "both for those already in the community and those yet to join. ###", "Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane", "this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled", "the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does", "to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the following things:", "Ads for your own site, not just to apply to other sites. ###", "community and will continue to be so, it is a good idea to", "a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will", "minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be", "the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a way to", "with that, you now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for", "advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This", "the body of the post. If you want to discuss something, do it", "150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold** an answer", "to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year", "service or ad is very valuable to the community and will continue to", "the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For", "resources * interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything", "are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show", "to the body of the post*. If you want to discuss something, do", "community. We reset the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion", "question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community", "new face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the", "genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors to find out", "uploader (imgur) Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs ", "might promote the following things: the site's twitter account * academic websites", "opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not just to", "score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown", "for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in the", "other things will wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting", "Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently", "the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with", "Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main", "of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to", "in the community and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset", "answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the main", "community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we", "an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the", "(currently 6*) before it will be shown on the main site. You can", "not just to apply to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads?", "ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions", "they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form", "required form. ### Image requirements The image that you create must be", "those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year?", "years, while other things will wane to allow for new faces to show", "community deems important. This also serves as a way to promote information and", "to apply to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion", "and resources interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences ", "do we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over", "your own site, not just to apply to other sites. ### What are", "be shown on the main site. You can check out the ads that", "(imgur) Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute", "the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is", "community's interests, both for those already in the community and those yet to", "will continue to be so, it is a good idea to repost it.", "in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the magic", "gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have", "main site. You can check out the ads that have met the threshold", "the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have", "show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything", "[1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else to the", "the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images", "the community and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the", "join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services will", "newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not", "subject matter of the community, but to the current status of the community.", "information and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for", "against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or", "rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the", "it a new face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery", "the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be", "up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this", "campus story blogs cool events or conferences * anything else your community", "in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the community,", "ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very", "you create must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must be hosted through", "things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not just", "the community, but to the current status of the community. We reset the", "No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ###", "on the site. For example, you might promote the following things: * the", "add anything else to the body of the post*. If you want to", "site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting", "anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for", "every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things", "Image requirements The image that you create must be *220 x 250", "How does it work? The answers you post to this question must* conform", "this question must conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored.", "on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a *minimum", "out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in", "will wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads", "or ad is very valuable to the community and will continue to be", "reset the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have", "while other things will wane to allow for new faces to show up.", "the subject matter of the community, but to the current status of the", "will be shown on the main site. You can check out the ads", "usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to allow for new", "questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements,", " Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There", "on the main site. You can check out the ads that have met", "yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some", "that will show up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The", "The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged", "### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet", "previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable to the", "and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those", "December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from", "valuable to the community and will continue to be so, it is a", "our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No", "is for future visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems", "in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url", "future visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems important. This", "tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this", "example, you might promote the following things: the site's twitter account ", "of the community. We reset the ads once a year, every December. The", "question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\")", "those already in the community and those yet to join. ### Why do", "have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer", "that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels* * Must be hosted", "In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills", "the site. For example, you might promote the following things: * the site's", "* Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be", "be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file", "on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question", "and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have the opportunity to setup", "or conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The", "functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the", "you might promote the following things: * the site's twitter account * academic", "site, not just to apply to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion", "community and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads", "discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must always be", "resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already", "and will continue to be so, it is a good idea to repost", "It may be helpful to give it a new face in the process,", "year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose", "[2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else to the body of", "create must be 220 x 250 pixels** * Must be hosted through our", "requirements * The image that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels", "cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable to the community", "* academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs * cool events", "maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to allow for", "Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that", "the material in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of", "purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps", "ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other", "and allows old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out", "the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads?", "Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up", "This is a method for the community to control what gets promoted to", "before it will be shown on the main site. You can check out", "services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to", "PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150", "process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale", "story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else your community would", "Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness", "form with the above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that", "always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In", "promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle.", "show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old", "the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required", "give it a new face in the process, so as to prevent the", "The image that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must", "stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers", "very valuable to the community and will continue to be so, it is", "else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future", "to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services", "Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements", "You can check out the ads that have met the threshold with basic", "in The goal is for future visitors to find out about the stuff", "the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads", "to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep", "it is a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to", "other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted", "faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and", "from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is very valuable", "to your own community's interests, both for those already in the community and", "Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6)", "that are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already in", "size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold", "enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form", "The goal is for future visitors to find out about the stuff your", "have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to control", "be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a", "something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged", "All answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show", "after a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you", "meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the main site. You", "particular service or ad is very valuable to the community and will continue", "interesting campus story blogs cool events or conferences * anything else your", "so, it is a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful", "own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have the opportunity", "year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will", "material in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the", "have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a", "is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it", "setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not just to apply to", "does it work? The answers you post to this question must conform to", "the years, while other things will wane to allow for new faces to", "be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]:", "matter of the community, but to the current status of the community. We", "And with that, you now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads", "community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors to", "of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post to this", "### How does it work? The answers you post to this question must", "are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ###", "http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add anything else to the body of the", "reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad", "to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are", "post to this question must* conform to the following rules, or they will", "site. You can check out the ads that have met the threshold with", "1. All answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to", "[![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not", "ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads", "face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad", "answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements The image", "but to the current status of the community. We reset the ads once", "enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion", "or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of", "sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements", "will show up on the main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose", "own community's interests, both for those already in the community and those yet", "events or conferences anything else your community would genuinely be interested in", "you now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own", "tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also", "the community and will continue to be so, it is a good idea", "of the post*. If you want to discuss something, do it in the", "is very valuable to the community and will continue to be so, it", "We reset the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads", "for newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to", "guys have gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you", "community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous", "Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the main site,", "the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure.", "idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give it a new", "will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have Community", "to promote information and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests,", "the ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the community, but", "it will be shown on the main site. You can check out the", "do not add anything else to the body of the post. If you", "following things: the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources ", "account academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs * cool", "``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do", "control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might", "The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a", "form. ### Image requirements The image that you create must be 220", "be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form of: ```", "ad is very valuable to the community and will continue to be so,", "a method for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on", "threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on", "the current status of the community. We reset the ads once a year,", "* anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is", "have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not", "magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality", "* the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus", "to find out about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves", "for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate", "status of the community. We reset the ads once a year, every December.", "with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling", "to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must always", "is a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give", "your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have the", "conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be interested in The goal", "the main site. You can check out the ads that have met the", "things: * the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting", "your community would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors", "to not just the subject matter of the community, but to the current", "your community deems important. This also serves as a way to promote information", "ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads relevant", "process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the", "not add anything else to the body of the post. If you want", "250 pixels* * Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) ", "a new face in the process, so as to prevent the imagery of", "allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps", "year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting an", "an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular service or ad is", "your own community's interests, both for those already in the community and those", "also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements", "also serves as a way to promote information and resources that are relevant", "prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year of", "this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ###", "the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting will", "on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please do not add anything else", "to the current status of the community. We reset the ads once a", "and those yet to join. ### Why do we reset the ads every", "just the subject matter of the community, but to the current status of", "be 220 x 250 pixels* * Must be hosted through our standard image", "to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should", "pixels** * Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must", "of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above", "design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now have the opportunity to", "for those already in the community and those yet to join. ### Why", "purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are", "this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and", "so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after", "accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose to be", "year of exposure. ### How does it work? The answers you post to", "do it in the comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with", "out the ads that have met the threshold with basic click stats [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/ads/display/907).", "the ads once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no", "Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF", "above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that you create must", "pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements ", "This helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not just the", "a good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give it", "relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already in the community", "the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the", "file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score", "The answers you post to this question must* conform to the following rules,", "do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community", "would genuinely be interested in The goal is for future visitors to find", "goal is for future visitors to find out about the stuff your community", "and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do", "relevant to not just the subject matter of the community, but to the", "as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting stale after a", "limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a", "promote information and resources that are relevant to your own community's interests, both", "of the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How", "Promotion Ads for your own site, not just to apply to other sites.", "no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If a particular", "animated GIFs Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score", "the above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that you create", "you want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question", "to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you", "find out about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as", "Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the", "helpful to give it a new face in the process, so as to", "### Why do we reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain", "have gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that, you now", "provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why", "the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]:", "exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url", "must conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All", "good idea to repost it. It may be helpful to give it a", "You guys have gotten your own design and graduated, hurrah! And with that,", "the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be", "\"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of the", "[community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to enabling the functionality of", "image that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must be", "Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is", "from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it work?", "standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No animated", "There is a minimum score threshold an answer must meet (currently 6) before", "promote the following things: * the site's twitter account * academic websites and", "keep the material in the ads relevant to not just the subject matter", "be helpful to give it a new face in the process, so as", "out about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a", "or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact", "what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote", "to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year", "What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will", "### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for", "work? The answers you post to this question must conform to the following", "their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for newer things. This", "tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition to", "about the stuff your community deems important. This also serves as a way", "method for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the", "* No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB", "must be 220 x 250 pixels * Must be hosted through our standard", "main site, in the right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the", "conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers", "to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add", "will maintain usefulness over the years, while other things will wane to allow", "important. This also serves as a way to promote information and resources that", "be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag. In addition", "must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions tagged 'community-ads'\") tag.", "already in the community and those yet to join. ### Why do we", "### Image requirements * The image that you create must be 220 x", "just to apply to other sites. ### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community", "Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to control what gets", "anything else to the body of the post. If you want to discuss", "GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs * Absolute limit on file size", "The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements", "that, you now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion Ads for your", "imagery of the ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ###", "websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences", "own site, not just to apply to other sites. ### What are Community", "Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that will show up on the", "once a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against", "answers you post to this question must conform to the following rules, or", "of 150 KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold an", "through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG ", "shown on the main site. You can check out the ads that have", "KB ### Score Threshold There is a minimum score threshold* an answer must", "that have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher ads for", "ads have no restrictions against reposting an ad from a previous cycle. If", "question must conform to the following rules, or they will be ignored. 1.", "with the above required form. ### Image requirements * The image that you", "This also serves as a way to promote information and resources that are", "must meet (currently 6) before it will be shown on the main site.", "Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to control what", "to give it a new face in the process, so as to prevent", "advertisements that will show up on the main site, in the right sidebar.", "ad from getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it", "every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their", "academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs * cool events or", "things will wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the", "gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the", "wane to allow for new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every", "image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or PNG * No animated GIFs", "fresher ads for newer things. This helps keep the material in the ads", "site's twitter account * academic websites and resources * interesting campus story blogs", "to enabling the functionality of the advertisements, this tag also pre-fills the answer", "be interested in The goal is for future visitors to find out about", "220 x 250 pixels * Must be hosted through our standard image uploader", "* The image that you create must be 220 x 250 pixels ", "shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method", "comments. 2. The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show", "repost it. It may be helpful to give it a new face in", "for the community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site.", "Ads? This is a method for the community to control what gets promoted", "continue to be so, it is a good idea to repost it. It", "the answer form with the above required form. ### Image requirements The", "want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2. The question must", "should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2]", "of the community, but to the current status of the community. We reset", "up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads", "helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served their purpose to", "following rules, or they will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in", "be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur) * Must be GIF or", "ads relevant to not just the subject matter of the community, but to", "ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline", "promoted to visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the following", "2. The question must always be tagged with the magic [community-ads](/questions/tagged/community-ads \"show questions", "ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows old ads that have served", "body of the post*. If you want to discuss something, do it in", "community, but to the current status of the community. We reset the ads", "GIFs Absolute limit on file size of 150 KB ### Score Threshold", "of: ``` [![Tagline to show on mouseover][1]][2] [1]: http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please", "old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out for fresher", "current status of the community. We reset the ads once a year, every", "new faces to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this,", "allows old ads that have served their purpose to be cycled out for", "is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided, and community voting", "it work? The answers you post to this question must conform to the", "of this question is the vetting process. Images of the advertisements are provided,", "voting will enable the advertisements to be shown. ### Why do we have", "x 250 pixels** * Must be hosted through our standard image uploader (imgur)", "a year, every December. The community promotion ads have no restrictions against reposting", "it. It may be helpful to give it a new face in the", "will be ignored. 1. All answers should be in the exact form of:", "post*. If you want to discuss something, do it in the comments. 2.", "not just the subject matter of the community, but to the current status", "reset the ads every year? Some services will maintain usefulness over the years,", "site. For example, you might promote the following things: the site's twitter", "visitors on the site. For example, you might promote the following things: ", "``` Please do not add anything else to the body of the post.", " interesting campus story blogs * cool events or conferences * anything else", "advertisements are provided, and community voting will enable the advertisements to be shown.", "check out the ads that have met the threshold with basic click stats", "to be shown. ### Why do we have Community Promotion Ads? This is", "right sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of", "the community. We reset the ads once a year, every December. The community", "are relevant to your own community's interests, both for those already in the", "6) before it will be shown on the main site. You can check", "visitors to find out about the stuff your community deems important. This also", "cool events or conferences * anything else your community would genuinely be interested", "http://image-url [2]: http://clickthrough-url ``` Please *do not add anything else to the body", "the process, so as to prevent the imagery of the ad from getting", "to be so, it is a good idea to repost it. It may", "tag also pre-fills the answer form with the above required form. ### Image", "you post to this question must* conform to the following rules, or they", "helps keep the material in the ads relevant to not just the subject", "For example, you might promote the following things: * the site's twitter account", "answers should be in the exact form of: ``` [![Tagline to show on", "interested in The goal is for future visitors to find out about the", "to the community and will continue to be so, it is a good", "to show up. Resetting the ads every year helps accommodate this, and allows", "hurrah! And with that, you now have the opportunity to setup Community Promotion", "to repost it. It may be helpful to give it a new face", "community to control what gets promoted to visitors on the site. For example,", "over the years, while other things will wane to allow for new faces", "may be helpful to give it a new face in the process, so", "blogs cool events or conferences * anything else your community would genuinely", "sidebar. The purpose of this question is the vetting process. Images of the", "getting stale after a year of exposure. ### How does it work? The", "Community Promotion Ads for your own site, not just to apply to other", "we have Community Promotion Ads? This is a method for the community to", "be so, it is a good idea to repost it. It may be", "the following things: * the site's twitter account * academic websites and resources", "deems important*. This also serves as a way to promote information and resources", "### What are Community Promotion Ads? Community Promotion Ads are community-vetted advertisements that" ]
[ "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it", "and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine", "it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as well.", "Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem seems to", "checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is", "lots of wasted space... is it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome", "14 looks fine as well. The problem seems to be specific to Chrome", "double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on", "bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a bug or a feature?", "as well. The problem seems to be specific to Chrome on OSX :s", "or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked", "Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks", "fine as well. The problem seems to be specific to Chrome on OSX", "Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem seems", "Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and", "bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double", "looks fine as well. The problem seems to be specific to Chrome on", "FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as", "Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem seems to be specific to", "ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem", "is it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw.", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space...", "space... is it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks,", "Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF,", "Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok.", "a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with", "OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks", "I double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running", "looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The", "feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere", "with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome running on Mint 14", "of wasted space... is it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on", "unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a bug or a feature? Using", "I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a", "a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I", "it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a bug or", "it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT:", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/nXATn.png) I think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted", "running on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem seems to be", "on Mint 14 looks fine as well. The problem seems to be specific", "a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a bug or a", "on OSX Mavericks, btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF, it", "EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also Chrome", "btw. EDIT: I double checked with Lafere and FF, it looks ok. Also", "think it's a bit unpleasant, lots of wasted space... is it a bug", "wasted space... is it a bug or a feature? Using Chrome on OSX" ]
[ "out of beta, will we get access to the full set of stackexchange", "we're out of beta, will we get access to the full set of", "Now that we're out of beta, will we get access to the full", "we get access to the full set of stackexchange sites for migrations ?", "of beta, will we get access to the full set of stackexchange sites", "beta, will we get access to the full set of stackexchange sites for", "will we get access to the full set of stackexchange sites for migrations", "that we're out of beta, will we get access to the full set" ]
[ "what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my", "but with the new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the", "answers, I keep seeing the answer below as a comment. I scroll down", "keep seeing the answer below as a comment. I scroll down and I", "I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To give", "give an idea of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from", "an idea of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this", "I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate", "image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is", "an answer, not a comment\". To give an idea of what I mean:", "a comment. I scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh it's an", "that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under the answer, not", "starts a comment under the answer, not a new answer. --- Or is", "down and I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\".", "of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ...", "a comment under the answer, not a new answer. --- Or is it", "HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under the answer, not a new", "idea of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).)", "is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under the answer,", "I keep seeing the answer below as a comment. I scroll down and", "A nitpick but with the new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep", "under the answer, not a new answer. --- Or is it just me?", "my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a", "format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below as a", "comment\". To give an idea of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png)", "![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction", "here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1.", "reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under the", "and I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To", "the answer below as a comment. I scroll down and I get the", "a comment\". To give an idea of what I mean: ![enter image description", "visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under", "seeing the answer below as a comment. I scroll down and I get", "it's an answer, not a comment\". To give an idea of what I", "...\" starts a comment under the answer, not a new answer. --- Or", "when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below as a comment.", "from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them", "with the new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer", "answer below as a comment. I scroll down and I get the realisation", "realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To give an idea of", "answer, not a comment\". To give an idea of what I mean: ![enter", "new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below as", "get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To give an", "immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment", "scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a", "write ...\" starts a comment under the answer, not a new answer. ---", "comment under the answer, not a new answer. --- Or is it just", "nitpick but with the new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing", "as a comment. I scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh it's", "(Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE", "... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts", "the new format, when I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below", "I scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not", "the realisation \"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To give an idea", "below as a comment. I scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh", "mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write ...\"", "them write ...\" starts a comment under the answer, not a new answer.", "description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot from [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that", "\"1. HAVE them write ...\" starts a comment under the answer, not a", "\"oh it's an answer, not a comment\". To give an idea of what", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19756/how-can-we-promote-better-writing-skills-in-academic-education).) ... my immediate visual reaction is that \"1. HAVE them write", "I'm reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below as a comment. I", "To give an idea of what I mean: ![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/Hz3GI.png) (Screenshot", "comment. I scroll down and I get the realisation \"oh it's an answer,", "reading answers, I keep seeing the answer below as a comment. I scroll", "not a comment\". To give an idea of what I mean: ![enter image" ]
[ "we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is no", "hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible for", "it is essentially not a good fit based on how we (and other", "n* semesters and it works like a charm...* > > > I don't", "how we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is", "spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to the question. Am", "to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag", "wrote on my comment, I do like what the question is going after", "operate. As it stands, there is no right answer to this question. Consider", "in class. As I wrote on my comment, I do like what the", "the answer is wrong by any merit. We can disagree on to what", "any merit. We can disagree on to what extent we agree, but essentially", "I don't think anyone of us can claim that the answer is wrong", "was checking out the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is", "we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be", "answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to", "the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag this", "by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class X for n semesters", "this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible", "regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I wrote on my", "opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I wrote", "role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I wrote on my comment, I", "for the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in", "a good fit based on how we (and other SE sites) normally operate.", "a charm... > > > I don't think anyone of us can claim", "answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible for the", "I can't help thinking that it is essentially not a good fit based", "responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this", "I tried this in class X* for n semesters and it works like", "the question is going after but I can't help thinking that it is", "I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag this kind of question?", "comment, I do like what the question is going after but I can't", "right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I", "my comment, I do like what the question is going after but I", "class X* for n semesters and it works like a charm...* > >", "essentially not a good fit based on how we (and other SE sites)", "to what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner)", "or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to the question. Am I", "I do like what the question is going after but I can't help", "there is no right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: >", "is going after but I can't help thinking that it is essentially not", "good fit based on how we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As", "anyone of us can claim that the answer is wrong by any merit.", "teachers should have in class. As I wrote on my comment, I do", "wrong by any merit. We can disagree on to what extent we agree,", "As I wrote on my comment, I do like what the question is", "essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer", "that the answer is wrong by any merit. We can disagree on to", "one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken?", "entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class X for n semesters and", "works like a charm...* > > > I don't think anyone of us", "what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer", "came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude", "catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class X", "the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion", "if necessary. I tried this in class X for n semesters and it", "also responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried", "in class X for n semesters and it works like a charm...* >", "think the teacher is also responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment,", "do like what the question is going after but I can't help thinking", "\"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible for the catching students attention", "this in class X* for n semesters and it works like a charm...", "of us can claim that the answer is wrong* by any merit. We", "questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding", "question is going after but I can't help thinking that it is essentially", "us can claim that the answer is wrong by any merit. We can", "As it stands, there is no right answer to this question. Consider this", "> > \"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible for the catching", "> I don't think anyone of us can claim that the answer is", "semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to the", "I was checking out the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which", "and it works like a charm... > > > I don't think anyone", "based on how we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands,", "fit based on how we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As it", "question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher is", "Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher is also", "stands, there is no right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer:", "think anyone of us can claim that the answer is wrong by any", "answer is wrong by any merit. We can disagree on to what extent", "on to what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or", "is wrong by any merit. We can disagree on to what extent we", "don't think anyone of us can claim that the answer is wrong by", "valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh", "> \"yes, I think the teacher is also responsible for the catching students", "have in class. As I wrote on my comment, I do like what", "(no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to the question.", "help thinking that it is essentially not a good fit based on how", "is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class.", "and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the", "to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the", "question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag this kind", "normally operate. As it stands, there is no right answer to this question.", "no right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes,", "We can disagree on to what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious", "class. As I wrote on my comment, I do like what the question", "an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I", "attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class X* for n", "other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is no right answer", "answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think", "essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As", "can claim that the answer is wrong* by any merit. We can disagree", "the teacher is also responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment, if", "X for n semesters and it works like a charm...* > > >", "on how we (and other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there", "teacher is also responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary.", "like what the question is going after but I can't help thinking that", "merit. We can disagree on to what extent we agree, but essentially any", "by any merit. We can disagree on to what extent we agree, but", "that it is essentially not a good fit based on how we (and", "disagree on to what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam,", "on my comment, I do like what the question is going after but", "I wrote on my comment, I do like what the question is going", "poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I wrote on", "this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > > \"yes, I think the teacher", "> > > I don't think anyone of us can claim that the", "(and other SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is no right", "can't help thinking that it is essentially not a good fit based on", "not a good fit based on how we (and other SE sites) normally", "but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid", "is essentially not a good fit based on how we (and other SE", "it stands, there is no right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical", "out the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an", "Am I mistaken? Would it be too harsh to vote/flag this kind of", "tried this in class X* for n semesters and it works like a", "SE sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is no right answer to", "semesters and it works like a charm...* > > > I don't think", "be a valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be", "can disagree on to what extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no", "a valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it be too", "the role/attitude teachers should have in class. As I wrote on my comment,", "[this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should", "the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class", "answer would be a valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would", "charm...* > > > I don't think anyone of us can claim that", "would be a valid answer to the question. Am I mistaken? Would it", "checking out the recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially", "one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have", "sites) normally operate. As it stands, there is no right answer to this", "should have in class. As I wrote on my comment, I do like", "> > I don't think anyone of us can claim that the answer", "after but I can't help thinking that it is essentially not a good", "necessary. I tried this in class X for n semesters and it works", "like a charm...* > > > I don't think anyone of us can", "claim that the answer is wrong by any merit. We can disagree on", "what the question is going after but I can't help thinking that it", "but I can't help thinking that it is essentially not a good fit", "thinking that it is essentially not a good fit based on how we", "for n semesters and it works like a charm...* > > > I", "any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a valid answer to", "going after but I can't help thinking that it is essentially not a", "I think the teacher is also responsible for the catching students attention by", "students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I tried this in class X for", "it works like a charm...* > > > I don't think anyone of", "is also responsible for the catching students attention by entertainment, if necessary. I", "is no right answer to this question. Consider this hypothetical answer: > >", "recent questions and came across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll", "across [this one](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/19881/should-teachers-be-entertainers), which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers", "which is essentially an opinion poll regarding the role/attitude teachers should have in", "agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would be a", "extent we agree, but essentially any semi-serious (no spam, or one-liner) answer would" ]
[ "give or take time to arrive for closure), this question will be open", "the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will", "Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about this new process, feel", "[here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how it'll work: * During the nomination phase,", "pm EDT on the same day, give or take time to arrive for", "some editorial control in the selection of the questions and may opt not", "your community and issues that you are running into at current. * At", "if I have concerns about any questions in this fashion, I will be", "a live chat session with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps", "on candidates. As a community, you are still free to, for example, hold", "questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may find", "top voted questions submitted by the community** provided in this thread, to use", "you have any questions or feedback about this new process, feel free to", "at current. * At the end of the phase, the Community Team will", "arrive for closure), this question will be open to collect potential questions from", "If you have any questions or feedback about this new process, feel free", "the community** provided in this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned", "irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said, if I have concerns about", "prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are", "not to select a question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or", "the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This", "session with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what", "any questions or feedback about this new process, feel free to post as", "or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If you have", "an opportunity for members of the community to pose questions to the candidates", "is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your community", "question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said,", "The questionnaire is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > >", "into at current. * At the end of the phase, the Community Team", "voted questions submitted by the community** provided in this thread, to use in", "* At the end of the phase, the Community Team will select *up", "a question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That", "issues that you are running into at current. At the end of", "the selection of the questions and may opt not to select a question", "potential questions from the users of the site. Post answers to this question", "questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). >", "that users have for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are", "ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done", "we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an", "> > The purpose of this thread was to collect questions for the", "community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in a single post,", "the site. Post answers to this question containing any questions you would like", "specific to your community and issues that you are running into at current.", "you would like to ask the candidates. Please only post one question per", "Community Team, will be providing a small selection of generic questions. The first", "questions. This will be done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction.", "May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day,", "of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be included, the", "in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control", "answer. * We, the Community Team, will be providing a small selection of", "or take time to arrive for closure), this question will be open to", "this question will be open to collect potential questions from the users of", "questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please only post one question", "8 of the top voted questions submitted by the community* provided in this", "to point this out in comments before the decision making time. * Once", "be open to collect potential questions from the users of the site. Post", "to this question containing any questions you would like to ask the candidates.", "the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in a single", "submitted by the community** provided in this thread, to use in addition to", "single post, unlike the prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to", "This will be an opportunity for members of the community to pose questions", "instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific", "with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is", "for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may find it", "use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial", "question per answer. We, the Community Team, will be providing a small", "provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about this", "Once questions have been selected, a new question will be opened to host", "the users of the site. Post answers to this question containing any questions", "included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This", "questions submitted by the community** provided in this thread, to use in addition", "decision making time. * Once questions have been selected, a new question will", "host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. ", "will be an opportunity for members of the community to pose questions to", "This will be done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. ", "a single post, unlike the prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity", "I have concerns about any questions in this fashion, I will be sure", "connection with the moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A with the", "or feedback about this new process, feel free to post as a comment", "of the phase, the Community Team will select *up to 8 of the", "of the questions and may opt not to select a question that is", "of the site. Post answers to this question containing any questions you would", "in this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions.", "that you are running into at current. At the end of the", "Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of this thread was to", "hold a live chat session with your candidates to ask further questions, or", "thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live,", "question will be open to collect potential questions from the users of the", "the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about this new process,", "to be included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough", "the questions and may opt not to select a question that is tangential", "fashion, I will be sure to point this out in comments before the", "community to pose questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation", "out in comments before the decision making time. Once questions have been", "> Here's how it'll work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday,", "only option that users have for gathering information on candidates. As a community,", "phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT", "opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in", "to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. >", "for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This is not the", "or the election. That said, if I have concerns about any questions in", "Community Team will select *up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted", "time to arrive for closure), this question will be open to collect potential", "the election. That said, if I have concerns about any questions in this", "comments before the decision making time. Once questions have been selected, a", "example, hold a live chat session with your candidates to ask further questions,", "point this out in comments before the decision making time. * Once questions", "to arrive for closure), this question will be open to collect potential questions", "ask the candidates. Please only post one question per answer. * We, the", "is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said, if I", "with the moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates.", "purpose of this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire", "be providing a small selection of generic questions. The first two will be", "work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z", "guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in the selection of the questions", "per answer. We, the Community Team, will be providing a small selection", "selection of the questions and may opt not to select a question that", "10 questions in total. * This is not the only option that users", "for closure), this question will be open to collect potential questions from the", "that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said, if", "clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions", "option that users have for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you", "gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are still free to, for", "actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This is", "feedback about this new process, feel free to post as a comment here.", "about any questions in this fashion, I will be sure to point this", "like to ask the candidates. Please only post one question per answer. ", "guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply", "total. This is not the only option that users have for gathering", "tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said, if I have", "will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10", "in the selection of the questions and may opt not to select a", "with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of the community", "collect potential questions from the users of the site. Post answers to this", "that are specific to your community and issues that you are running into", "will select up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by the", "collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may", "opportunity for members of the community to pose questions to the candidates on", "find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Here's how it'll work: * During the", "During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or", "this fashion, I will be sure to point this out in comments before", "live chat session with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications", "of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of this thread", "if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in a", "candidates. Please only post one question per answer. We, the Community Team,", "20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give or take", "candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This is not the only option", "been selected, a new question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire", "questions. We reserve some editorial control in the selection of the questions and", "in total. * This is not the only option that users have for", "community, you are still free to, for example, hold a live chat session", "the only option that users have for gathering information on candidates. As a", "to, for example, hold a live chat session with your candidates to ask", "one question per answer. * We, the Community Team, will be providing a", "not the only option that users have for gathering information on candidates. As", "to collect potential questions from the users of the site. Post answers to", "editorial control in the selection of the questions and may opt not to", "the prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that", "moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of this thread was", "Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same", "current. At the end of the phase, the Community Team will select", "reserve some editorial control in the selection of the questions and may opt", "the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00", "take time to arrive for closure), this question will be open to collect", "pose questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely", "how it'll work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th,", "may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how it'll work: * During", "opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your community and issues that", "the moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This", "the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. * This is not the only", "what is provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback", "would like to ask the candidates. Please only post one question per answer.", "this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We", "questions from the users of the site. Post answers to this question containing", "you are running into at current. * At the end of the phase,", "two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if the", "to voice questions that are specific to your community and issues that you", "are specific to your community and issues that you are running into at", "* This is not the only option that users have for gathering information", "holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members", "the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > >", "providing a small selection of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed", "questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones", "election. That said, if I have concerns about any questions in this fashion,", "unlike the prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions", "perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your community and issues", "in this fashion, I will be sure to point this out in comments", "this question containing any questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please", "UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give or take time", "questions that are specific to your community and issues that you are running", "the candidates. Please only post one question per answer. * We, the Community", "be included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions.", "community** provided in this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2", "said, if I have concerns about any questions in this fashion, I will", "This is not the only option that users have for gathering information on", "answers to this question containing any questions you would like to ask the", "latter ones are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be", "this out in comments before the decision making time. * Once questions have", "in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. * This is a perfect", "* Once questions have been selected, a new question will be opened to", "is not the only option that users have for gathering information on candidates.", "for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are still free to,", "any questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please only post one", "concerns about any questions in this fashion, I will be sure to point", "the decision making time. Once questions have been selected, a new question", "doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in a single post, unlike", "Please only post one question per answer. * We, the Community Team, will", "still free to, for example, hold a live chat session with your candidates", "the end of the phase, the Community Team will select *up to 8", "addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in", "questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total. This is not", "are still free to, for example, hold a live chat session with your", "candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of the community to pose", "be an opportunity for members of the community to pose questions to the", "at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give or", "will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if the community", "the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in the selection", "We reserve some editorial control in the selection of the questions and may", "sure to point this out in comments before the decision making time. ", " We, the Community Team, will be providing a small selection of generic", "in the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about this new", "from the users of the site. Post answers to this question containing any", "the Community Team, will be providing a small selection of generic questions. The", "Here's how it'll work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May", "moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will", "before the decision making time. * Once questions have been selected, a new", "to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some", "live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Here's how it'll", "the top voted questions submitted by the community provided in this thread, to", "> > > Here's how it'll work: * During the nomination phase, (so,", "opt not to select a question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation", "topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > The purpose of this", "be sure to point this out in comments before the decision making time.", "questionnaire is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > >", "moderation or the election. That said, if I have concerns about any questions", "any questions in this fashion, I will be sure to point this out", "community and issues that you are running into at current. * At the", "post one question per answer. * We, the Community Team, will be providing", "questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If you", "your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided", "to pose questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is", "it'll work: * During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at", "end of the phase, the Community Team will select up to 8 of", "At the end of the phase, the Community Team will select up to", "be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions", "to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by the community provided in", "questions or feedback about this new process, feel free to post as a", "select a question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the election.", "up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by the community provided", "it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire). > > > Here's how it'll work: * During the nomination", "to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing 10 questions in total.", "control in the selection of the questions and may opt not to select", "from what is provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions or", "perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If you have any", "on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose", "ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A.", "In connection with the moderator elections, we will be holding a Q&A with", " During the nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC,", "you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how it'll work: ", "selected, a new question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for", "I will be sure to point this out in comments before the decision", "Team, will be providing a small selection of generic questions. The first two", "thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve", "to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the", " This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to", "first two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if", "phase, the Community Team will select *up to 8 of the top voted", "members of the community to pose questions to the candidates on the topic", "As a community, you are still free to, for example, hold a live", "running into at current. At the end of the phase, the Community", "and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how it'll work:", "are running into at current. * At the end of the phase, the", "to your community and issues that you are running into at current. ", "aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in the selection of", "> The purpose of this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire.", "the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of the community to", "done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. This is a", "a small selection of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to", "open to collect potential questions from the users of the site. Post answers", "for members of the community to pose questions to the candidates on the", "post, unlike the prior instruction. * This is a perfect opportunity to voice", "have any questions or feedback about this new process, feel free to post", "of the top voted questions submitted by the community** provided in this thread,", "closure), this question will be open to collect potential questions from the users", "will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity", "until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the", "will be providing a small selection of generic questions. The first two will", "day, give or take time to arrive for closure), this question will be", "in comments before the decision making time. * Once questions have been selected,", "is provided in the Q&A. If you have any questions or feedback about", "may opt not to select a question that is tangential or irrelevant to", "of the community to pose questions to the candidates on the topic of", "for example, hold a live chat session with your candidates to ask further", "is completely voluntary. > > *The purpose of this thread was to collect", "> > Here's how it'll work: During the nomination phase, (so, until", "to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in the", "information on candidates. As a community, you are still free to, for example,", "is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's", "2 guaranteed questions. We reserve some editorial control in the selection of the", "the same day, give or take time to arrive for closure), this question", "will be done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. * This", "Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of the", "generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter", "users have for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are still", "questions in this fashion, I will be sure to point this out in", "questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary.", "and may opt not to select a question that is tangential or irrelevant", "candidates. As a community, you are still free to, for example, hold a", "the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > The purpose of", "have been selected, a new question will be opened to host the actual", "(so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on", "The purpose of this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The", "nomination phase, (so, until Monday, May 12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm", "have for gathering information on candidates. As a community, you are still free", "this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now", "are if the community doesn't supply enough questions. This will be done in", "the phase, the Community Team will select up to 8 of the top", "to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you", "select up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by the community", "candidates on the topic of moderation. Participation is completely voluntary. > > The", "a new question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the", "EDT on the same day, give or take time to arrive for closure),", "The first two will be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are", "time. * Once questions have been selected, a new question will be opened", "questions and may opt not to select a question that is tangential or", "the Community Team will select up to 8 of the top voted questions", "was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and", "voice questions that are specific to your community and issues that you are", "selection of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be included,", "provided in this thread, to use in addition to the aforementioned 2 guaranteed", "enough questions. This will be done in a single post, unlike the prior", "a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your community and", "chat session with your candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from", "of this thread was to collect questions for the questionnaire. The questionnaire is", "by the community provided in this thread, to use in addition to the", "users of the site. Post answers to this question containing any questions you", "site. Post answers to this question containing any questions you would like to", "new question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates,", "you are still free to, for example, hold a live chat session with", "on the same day, give or take time to arrive for closure), this", "now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).** > > > Here's how", "or irrelevant to moderation or the election. That said, if I have concerns", "or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give or take time to", "question containing any questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please only", "only post one question per answer. * We, the Community Team, will be", "completely voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread was to collect questions", "small selection of generic questions. The first two will be guaranteed to be", "voluntary. > > The purpose of this thread was to collect questions for", "free to, for example, hold a live chat session with your candidates to", "containing any questions you would like to ask the candidates. Please only post", "to select a question that is tangential or irrelevant to moderation or the", "That said, if I have concerns about any questions in this fashion, I", "to moderation or the election. That said, if I have concerns about any", "will be open to collect potential questions from the users of the site.", "elections, we will be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be", "making time. * Once questions have been selected, a new question will be", "a community, you are still free to, for example, hold a live chat", "be done in a single post, unlike the prior instruction. * This is", "be holding a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for", "and issues that you are running into at current. * At the end", "Post answers to this question containing any questions you would like to ask", "supply enough questions. This will be done in a single post, unlike the", "will be sure to point this out in comments before the decision making", "questions have been selected, a new question will be opened to host the", "4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give or take time to arrive", "We, the Community Team, will be providing a small selection of generic questions.", "candidates to ask further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in", "the questionnaire. The questionnaire is now live, and you may find it [here](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/990/2014-moderator-election-qa-questionnaire).*", "to ask the candidates. Please only post one question per answer. We,", "further questions, or perhaps clarifications from what is provided in the Q&A. If", "have concerns about any questions in this fashion, I will be sure to", "containing 10 questions in total. * This is not the only option that", "a Q&A with the candidates. This will be an opportunity for members of", "be guaranteed to be included, the latter ones are if the community doesn't", "Team will select *up to 8 of the top voted questions submitted by", "the community to pose questions to the candidates on the topic of moderation.", "question will be opened to host the actual questionnaire for the candidates, containing", "same day, give or take time to arrive for closure), this question will", "questions in total. This is not the only option that users have", "This is a perfect opportunity to voice questions that are specific to your", "12th, at 20:00:00Z UTC, or 4:00 pm EDT on the same day, give" ]
[ "2014 Community Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases:", "on how many candidates there are. Please visit the official election page at", "Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to", "three weeks, but this depends on how many candidates there are. Please visit", "meta -- just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show questions tagged", "1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between", "questions about the election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to", "for more detail, and to participate! If you have general questions about the", "phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take", "you have general questions about the election process, or questions for moderator candidates,", "Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase", "two and three weeks, but this depends on how many candidates there are.", "Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between two", "elections take between two and three weeks, but this depends on how many", "<https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If you have general questions about", "If you have general questions about the election process, or questions for moderator", "Most elections take between two and three weeks, but this depends on how", "are. Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and", "or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here on meta", "candidates, feel free to ask them here on meta -- just make sure", "The 2014 Community Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have three", "election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If you have", "moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here on meta -- just make", "free to ask them here on meta -- just make sure your questions", "them here on meta -- just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election", "moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election", "take between two and three weeks, but this depends on how many candidates", "to participate! If you have general questions about the election process, or questions", "elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase", "page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If you have general", "phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between two and", "now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary", "more detail, and to participate! If you have general questions about the election", "there are. Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail,", "three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections", "between two and three weeks, but this depends on how many candidates there", "this depends on how many candidates there are. Please visit the official election", "process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here on", "and three weeks, but this depends on how many candidates there are. Please", "here on meta -- just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show", "underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase", "phase Most elections take between two and three weeks, but this depends on", "general questions about the election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free", "detail, and to participate! If you have general questions about the election process,", "3. Election phase Most elections take between two and three weeks, but this", "how many candidates there are. Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election>", "ask them here on meta -- just make sure your questions are tagged", "questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here on meta --", "have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most", "on meta -- just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show questions", "to ask them here on meta -- just make sure your questions are", "-- just make sure your questions are tagged [election](/questions/tagged/election \"show questions tagged 'election'\").", "official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If you", "but this depends on how many candidates there are. Please visit the official", "have general questions about the election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel", "and to participate! If you have general questions about the election process, or", "depends on how many candidates there are. Please visit the official election page", "Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination", "the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If", "2. Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between two and three", "Election phase Most elections take between two and three weeks, but this depends", "weeks, but this depends on how many candidates there are. Please visit the", "for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here on meta -- just", "the election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them", "many candidates there are. Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for", "participate! If you have general questions about the election process, or questions for", "Primary phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between two and three weeks,", "at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate! If you have general questions", "election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask them here", "candidates there are. Please visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more", "feel free to ask them here on meta -- just make sure your", "visit the official election page at <https://academia.stackexchange.com/election> for more detail, and to participate!", "is now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2.", "phase 3. Election phase Most elections take between two and three weeks, but", "Community Moderator Election is now underway! Community moderator elections have three phases: 1.", "about the election process, or questions for moderator candidates, feel free to ask", "Community moderator elections have three phases: 1. Nomination phase 2. Primary phase 3." ]
[ "out there, especially the ones asking for personal career advice. Was this function", "that when the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to my", "low reputation. This option used to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close'", "to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't", "anymore? Edit My guess is that when the site graduated I lost the", "few questions out there, especially the ones asking for personal career advice. Was", "to a few questions out there, especially the ones asking for personal career", "can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is that when the site graduated", "access it anymore? Edit My guess is that when the site graduated I", "Was this function removed during graduation of the site? Or is it just", "ones asking for personal career advice. Was this function removed during graduation of", "the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to my low reputation.", "I don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers down the flagging dialog.", "applies to a few questions out there, especially the ones asking for personal", "just me who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is that when", "Edit My guess is that when the site graduated I lost the moderation", "guess is that when the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due", "career advice. Was this function removed during graduation of the site? Or is", "hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't see it anymore but buried", "this function removed during graduation of the site? Or is it just me", "is that when the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to", "up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't see it", "graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This option", "personal career advice. Was this function removed during graduation of the site? Or", "immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't see it anymore", "function removed during graduation of the site? Or is it just me who", "used to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I", "due to my low reputation. This option used to show up immediately upon", "questions out there, especially the ones asking for personal career advice. Was this", "for personal career advice. Was this function removed during graduation of the site?", "when the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to my low", "it anymore? Edit My guess is that when the site graduated I lost", "of the site? Or is it just me who can't access it anymore?", "the ones asking for personal career advice. Was this function removed during graduation", "who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is that when the site", "lost the moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This option used to", "My guess is that when the site graduated I lost the moderation privilege", "is it just me who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is", "removed during graduation of the site? Or is it just me who can't", "a few questions out there, especially the ones asking for personal career advice.", "the 'close' link, and now I don't see it anymore but buried 4", "Or is it just me who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess", "'close' link, and now I don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers", "and now I don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers down the", "the moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This option used to show", "there, especially the ones asking for personal career advice. Was this function removed", "now I don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers down the flagging", "the site? Or is it just me who can't access it anymore? Edit", "show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't see", "site? Or is it just me who can't access it anymore? Edit My", "my low reputation. This option used to show up immediately upon hitting the", "reputation. This option used to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link,", "site graduated I lost the moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This", "This option used to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and", "moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This option used to show up", "privilege due to my low reputation. This option used to show up immediately", "graduation of the site? Or is it just me who can't access it", "option used to show up immediately upon hitting the 'close' link, and now", "advice. Was this function removed during graduation of the site? Or is it", "I lost the moderation privilege due to my low reputation. This option used", "link, and now I don't see it anymore but buried 4 layers down", "me who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is that when the", "upon hitting the 'close' link, and now I don't see it anymore but", "This applies to a few questions out there, especially the ones asking for", "especially the ones asking for personal career advice. Was this function removed during", "to my low reputation. This option used to show up immediately upon hitting", "it just me who can't access it anymore? Edit My guess is that", "during graduation of the site? Or is it just me who can't access", "asking for personal career advice. Was this function removed during graduation of the" ]
[ "position. If the questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a", "* If so, is this a good or a bad thing? * If", "not in that ideal position. If the questioner was in the ideal position,", "While I disagree with the strong wording in the comment, it made me", "or shut down any hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures", "was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in the first", "about contributing to the body of knowledge and never about politics? * If", "> > > While I disagree with the strong wording in the comment,", "ideal position. If the questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have", "presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors are always helpful and competent,", "place. > > > While I disagree with the strong wording in the", "criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve", "of their mentees in mind, and where research is always about contributing to", "in that ideal position. If the questioner was in the ideal position, they", "while I get that the site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut", "academia, where professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only", "never about politics? * If so, is this a good or a bad", "* If it is a bad thing, can it be changed and how?", "politics? * If so, is this a good or a bad thing? ", "position, they wouldn't have a problem in the first place. > > >", "professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who", "comment, it made me wonder. Are we in fact presenting an idealised", "the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in the first place. >", "body of knowledge and never about politics? * If so, is this a", "wouldn't have a problem in the first place. > > > While I", "shut down any hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of", "fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors are always helpful and", "hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do", "comment to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I get that", "> And while I get that the site is heavily skewed to ignore", "a good or a bad thing? * If it is a bad thing,", "and competent, where advisors and mentors only have the best interest of their", "the strong wording in the comment, it made me wonder. * Are we", "so, is this a good or a bad thing? * If it is", "wonder. * Are we in fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where", "interest of their mentees in mind, and where research is always about contributing", "problem in the first place. > > > While I disagree with the", "the site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any hint of", "good or a bad thing? * If it is a bad thing, can", "this a good or a bad thing? * If it is a bad", "pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is not in that", "to the body of knowledge and never about politics? * If so, is", "the first place. > > > While I disagree with the strong wording", "where professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only have", "of knowledge and never about politics? * If so, is this a good", "always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only have the best interest", "or a bad thing? * If it is a bad thing, can it", "serve anybody who is not in that ideal position. If the questioner was", "wording in the comment, it made me wonder. * Are we in fact", "is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any hint of criticism of", "Are we in fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors are", "where advisors and mentors only have the best interest of their mentees in", "that the site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any hint", "> > And while I get that the site is heavily skewed to", "they wouldn't have a problem in the first place. > > > While", "in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is", "contributing to the body of knowledge and never about politics? * If so,", "competent, where advisors and mentors only have the best interest of their mentees", "down any hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic", "heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any hint of criticism of professors", "skewed to ignore or shut down any hint of criticism of professors in", "that ideal position. If the questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't", "idealised view of academia, where professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors", "knowledge and never about politics? * If so, is this a good or", "site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any hint of criticism", "I disagree with the strong wording in the comment, it made me wonder.", "we in fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors are always", "have a problem in the first place. > > > While I disagree", "about politics? * If so, is this a good or a bad thing?", "wrote: > > And while I get that the site is heavily skewed", "rocinante wrote: > > And while I get that the site is heavily", "who is not in that ideal position. If the questioner was in the", "in the first place. > > > While I disagree with the strong", "> While I disagree with the strong wording in the comment, it made", "research is always about contributing to the body of knowledge and never about", "of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I get that the site is", "questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in the", "And while I get that the site is heavily skewed to ignore or", "[this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I get that the site", "* Are we in fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors", "advisors and mentors only have the best interest of their mentees in mind,", "the questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in", "made me wonder. * Are we in fact presenting an idealised view of", "strong wording in the comment, it made me wonder. * Are we in", "in fact presenting an idealised view of academia, where professors are always helpful", "ignore or shut down any hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy", "mentors only have the best interest of their mentees in mind, and where", "and mentors only have the best interest of their mentees in mind, and", "the best interest of their mentees in mind, and where research is always", "thing? * If it is a bad thing, can it be changed and", "me wonder. * Are we in fact presenting an idealised view of academia,", "always about contributing to the body of knowledge and never about politics? ", "view of academia, where professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors and", "first place. > > > While I disagree with the strong wording in", "is always about contributing to the body of knowledge and never about politics?", "are always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only have the best", "in the comment, it made me wonder. Are we in fact presenting", "the comment, it made me wonder. * Are we in fact presenting an", "not serve anybody who is not in that ideal position. If the questioner", "any hint of criticism of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations", "to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I get that the", "In a comment to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I", "helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only have the best interest of", "of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is not in that ideal", "in mind, and where research is always about contributing to the body of", "disagree with the strong wording in the comment, it made me wonder. ", "anybody who is not in that ideal position. If the questioner was in", "> > While I disagree with the strong wording in the comment, it", "academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is not", "and where research is always about contributing to the body of knowledge and", "professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors only have the", "idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is not in that ideal position.", "bad thing? If it is a bad thing, can it be changed", "to ignore or shut down any hint of criticism of professors in academia,", "only have the best interest of their mentees in mind, and where research", "with the strong wording in the comment, it made me wonder. * Are", "and never about politics? * If so, is this a good or a", "a bad thing? * If it is a bad thing, can it be", "in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in the first place.", "If so, is this a good or a bad thing? * If it", "do not serve anybody who is not in that ideal position. If the", "mentees in mind, and where research is always about contributing to the body", "of academia, where professors are always helpful and competent, where advisors and mentors", "best interest of their mentees in mind, and where research is always about", "where research is always about contributing to the body of knowledge and never", "it made me wonder. * Are we in fact presenting an idealised view", "an idealised view of academia, where professors are always helpful and competent, where", "get that the site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down any", "a problem in the first place. > > > While I disagree with", "the body of knowledge and never about politics? * If so, is this", "of professors in academia, rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody", "a comment to [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20399/10094), rocinante wrote: > > And while I get", "ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem in the first place. > >", "is not in that ideal position. If the questioner was in the ideal", "mind, and where research is always about contributing to the body of knowledge", "have the best interest of their mentees in mind, and where research is", "their mentees in mind, and where research is always about contributing to the", "collaborations do not serve anybody who is not in that ideal position. If", "I get that the site is heavily skewed to ignore or shut down", "is this a good or a bad thing? * If it is a", "rosy pictures of idyllic collaborations do not serve anybody who is not in", "If the questioner was in the ideal position, they wouldn't have a problem" ]
[ "very different types of questions. Thoughts on the best way to split the", "as I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be", "clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts on the best way to", "appears to be used in two different cases, rather than just one: 1.", "for citations, references or documents to support a question 2. Questions about asking", "be used in two different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for", "2. Questions about asking a recommender for a letter of reference These are", "working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in", "something of a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working through my", "hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in two different cases, rather than", "wiki editing project, and as I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`.", "for a letter of reference These are clearly two very different types of", "I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used", "I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in two different cases, rather", "letter of reference These are clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts", "support a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for a letter of", "I've embarked on something of a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm", "a letter of reference These are clearly two very different types of questions.", "on the best way to split the tag to make it more clear?", "Thoughts on the best way to split the tag to make it more", "`reference-request`. This appears to be used in two different cases, rather than just", "of a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working through my list,", "one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents to support a question 2.", "to support a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for a letter", "different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents", "cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents to", "These are clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts on the best", "of questions. Thoughts on the best way to split the tag to make", "a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working through my list, I've", "my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in two different", "a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for a letter of reference", "a recommender for a letter of reference These are clearly two very different", "than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents to support a", "to be used in two different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests", "This appears to be used in two different cases, rather than just one:", "documents to support a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for a", "are clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts on the best way", "project, and as I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears", "two different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or", "reference These are clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts on the", "question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for a letter of reference These", "Requests for citations, references or documents to support a question 2. Questions about", "questions. Thoughts on the best way to split the tag to make it", "in two different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references", "editing project, and as I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This", "on something of a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working through", "references or documents to support a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender", "or documents to support a question 2. Questions about asking a recommender for", "recommender for a letter of reference These are clearly two very different types", "1. Requests for citations, references or documents to support a question 2. Questions", "So I've embarked on something of a tag wiki editing project, and as", "tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working through my list, I've hit", "citations, references or documents to support a question 2. Questions about asking a", "just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents to support a question", "types of questions. Thoughts on the best way to split the tag to", "embarked on something of a tag wiki editing project, and as I'm working", "through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in two", "of reference These are clearly two very different types of questions. Thoughts on", "about asking a recommender for a letter of reference These are clearly two", "Questions about asking a recommender for a letter of reference These are clearly", "asking a recommender for a letter of reference These are clearly two very", "different types of questions. Thoughts on the best way to split the tag", "and as I'm working through my list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to", "used in two different cases, rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations,", "rather than just one: 1. Requests for citations, references or documents to support", "list, I've hit `reference-request`. This appears to be used in two different cases,", "two very different types of questions. Thoughts on the best way to split" ]
[ "successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't know the culture in other", "the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking", "in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from", "like an inside joke for the community ... but the joke might not", "leave their job as soon as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable.", "this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks", "that they leave their job as soon as possible ... I sometimes find", "culture in other areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced", "walk. Run.*\" ... with 18 upvotes. [What to do: PI lied to", "on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke", "but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. * [What to do:", "academics that they leave their job as soon as possible ... I sometimes", "think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments", "see such questions and who might project themselves as being in similar situations.", "of not being the whole story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have", "18 upvotes. * [What to do: PI lied to me and is keeping", "vulnerable people from a variety of areas who see such questions and who", "variety of areas who see such questions and who might project themselves as", "paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics telling", "require the permission of their supervisor to publish. This was met with \"*Don't", "have some respect for the fact that they're advising another human being to", " [What to do: PI lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant):", "meme should have some respect for the fact that they're advising another human", "human being to quit their job/studies ... and they should keep in mind", "for the fact that they're advising another human being to quit their job/studies", "they're advising another human being to quit their job/studies ... and they should", "coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in", "question that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. * There was another", "this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke for", "where a student mentioned that in their school, they require the permission of", "whole story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with", "Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided", "pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. ---", "find right now where a student mentioned that in their school, they require", "other areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and", "cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple", "that seems almost too simple in terms of not being the whole story.", "experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job as soon as", "comments in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave", "quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't", "is a serious issue and should be treated seriously. I think it's especially", "with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple in terms of not", "could get past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life", "of examples of where it made me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor):", "clear to newcomers. If we could get past the semantic satiation for a", "that they're advising another human being to quit their job/studies ... and they", "it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who", "first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather", "the permission of their supervisor to publish. This was met with \"*Don't walk.", "and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice, not", "certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially", "are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of areas", "from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't know the culture", "treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working", "who see such questions and who might project themselves as being in similar", "are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments", "they leave their job as soon as possible ... I sometimes find it", "tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this", "inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left", "worth the risk. Folks using this meme should have some respect for the", "requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. There was another example I", "fact that they're advising another human being to quit their job/studies ... and", "inexperienced academics that they leave their job as soon as possible ... I", "to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad", "left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job as", "possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where", "advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple in terms of not being", "being to quit their job/studies ... and they should keep in mind that", "with 18 upvotes. * [What to do: PI lied to me and is", "quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue", "coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't know the", "minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a", "was another example I can't find right now where a student mentioned that", "students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a", "should be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful", "academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job as soon as possible", "to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal", "it made me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems", "tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes.", "joke might not be clear to newcomers. If we could get past the", "Run.*\" ... with 18 upvotes. [What to do: PI lied to me", "of vulnerable people from a variety of areas who see such questions and", "questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted", "was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A", "advice, not a pithy comment. * There was another example I can't find", "examples of where it made me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a", "they require the permission of their supervisor to publish. This was met with", "thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of areas who see such questions", "credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple in terms of", "their supervisor to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE", "her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. * [What to", "with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not", "If we have a meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It", "the joke might not be clear to newcomers. If we could get past", "keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people", "and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should be treated", "don't know the culture in other areas and departments. Lots of questions are", "one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics", "find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it made me cringe:", "seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme should have some respect for", "is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice, not a", "site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke for the", "meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside", "another human being to quit their job/studies ... and they should keep in", "potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme", "academics working in rock-star departments who don't know the culture in other areas", "of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture.", "a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is", "for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere", "it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it made me cringe: ", "get past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position", "There was another example I can't find right now where a student mentioned", "communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of areas who see", "and departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint", "with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of areas who see such", "seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit.", "quit their job/studies ... and they should keep in mind that they are", "departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a", "walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students", "inside joke for the community ... but the joke might not be clear", "their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds", "terms of not being the whole story. The first piece of advice isn't", "uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it made me cringe: [Handling", "me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too", "somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious", "grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It", "their real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and", "can't find right now where a student mentioned that in their school, they", "issue and should be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from", "Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to", "advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.*\"", "areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers and typically", "sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it made me", "made me cringe: [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost", "to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed", "might not be clear to newcomers. If we could get past the semantic", "an inside joke for the community ... but the joke might not be", "have a meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like", "looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should be treated seriously.", "serious issue and should be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming", "* There was another example I can't find right now where a student", "the fact that they're advising another human being to quit their job/studies ...", "elsewhere is a serious issue and should be treated seriously. I think it's", "the culture in other areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming from", "they should keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of", "simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of areas who", "requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if", "position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should be", "typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics", "their school, they require the permission of their supervisor to publish. This was", "... but the joke might not be clear to newcomers. If we could", "guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable", "permission of their supervisor to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\"", "rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. * [What to do: PI", "risk. Folks using this meme should have some respect for the fact that", "as soon as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of", "of their supervisor to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from", "damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme should", "which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications", "people from a variety of areas who see such questions and who might", "school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty", "I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star", "satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for employment/studies", "A couple of examples of where it made me cringe: * [Handling credit", "do: PI lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question", "upvotes. * [What to do: PI lied to me and is keeping my", "difficult question that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. * There was", "know the culture in other areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming", "of where it made me cringe: * [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question", "to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It just", "that in their school, they require the permission of their supervisor to publish.", "from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear", "entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their", "seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with", "newcomers. If we could get past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody", "not be clear to newcomers. If we could get past the semantic satiation", "grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. ", "and they should keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands", "couple of examples of where it made me cringe: [Handling credit with", "[Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple in terms", "just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme should have some", "should keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable", "pithy comment. * There was another example I can't find right now where", "the whole story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking", "real-life position and looking for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should", "researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by", "community ... but the joke might not be clear to newcomers. If we", "in terms of not being the whole story. The first piece of advice", "and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced", "mentioned that in their school, they require the permission of their supervisor to", "school, they require the permission of their supervisor to publish. This was met", "that this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk.", "of areas who see such questions and who might project themselves as being", "A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems", "This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate.", "employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should be treated seriously. I think", "talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. ", "as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of", "with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline", "where it made me cringe: [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that", "a meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an", "meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using", "... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it", "being the whole story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried", "--- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem", "in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their", "a student mentioned that in their school, they require the permission of their", "almost too simple in terms of not being the whole story. The first", "should have some respect for the fact that they're advising another human being", "joke for the community ... but the joke might not be clear to", "this meme should have some respect for the fact that they're advising another", "especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't", "If we could get past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting", "* [Handling credit with advisor](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5656/handling-credit-with-advisor): a question that seems almost too simple in", "areas who see such questions and who might project themselves as being in", "student mentioned that in their school, they require the permission of their supervisor", "seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in", "a difficult question that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. * There", "\"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18 upvotes. * [What to do: PI lied", "agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the", "telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job as soon as possible ...", "a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced", "my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment.", "to quit their job/studies ... and they should keep in mind that they", "a variety of areas who see such questions and who might project themselves", "hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't know the culture in", "not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging?", "now where a student mentioned that in their school, they require the permission", "another example I can't find right now where a student mentioned that in", "publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly", "not a pithy comment. * There was another example I can't find right", "is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this", "not being the whole story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have you", "to newcomers. If we could get past the semantic satiation for a minute,", "keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice, not a pithy", "comment. * There was another example I can't find right now where a", "doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme should have some respect", "Anyone agree that this meme is potentially damaging? It just doesn't seem worth", "right now where a student mentioned that in their school, they require the", "JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated", "seems almost too simple in terms of not being the whole story. The", "too simple in terms of not being the whole story. The first piece", "be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely successful academics", "a question that seems almost too simple in terms of not being the", "working in rock-star departments who don't know the culture in other areas and", "be clear to newcomers. If we could get past the semantic satiation for", "their job/studies ... and they should keep in mind that they are simultaneously", "in rock-star departments who don't know the culture in other areas and departments.", "clear affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful)", "we have a meme on this site, it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is", "... and they should keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating with", "and should be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic coming from hugely", "bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job", "rock-star departments who don't know the culture in other areas and departments. Lots", "legal advice, not a pithy comment. * There was another example I can't", "job as soon as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple", "you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with 18", "to do: PI lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult", "The first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but", "from inexperienced researchers and typically paint a one-sided picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold", "job/studies ... and they should keep in mind that they are simultaneously communicating", "[What to do: PI lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a", "in their school, they require the permission of their supervisor to publish. This", "their job as soon as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A", "inappropriate. A school guideline requiring students to clear affiliated publications with their supervisor", "but the joke might not be clear to newcomers. If we could get", "question that seems almost too simple in terms of not being the whole", "example I can't find right now where a student mentioned that in their", "lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires", "soon as possible ... I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples", "using this meme should have some respect for the fact that they're advising", "piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't", "Run.\" It is like an inside joke for the community ... but the", "reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone", "some respect for the fact that they're advising another human being to quit", "the community ... but the joke might not be clear to newcomers. If", "in other areas and departments. Lots of questions are coming from inexperienced researchers", "It just doesn't seem worth the risk. Folks using this meme should have", "past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and", "departments who don't know the culture in other areas and departments. Lots of", "I can't find right now where a student mentioned that in their school,", "publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely", "is like an inside joke for the community ... but the joke might", "\"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke for the community ...", "Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they", "respect for the fact that they're advising another human being to quit their", "by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that they leave their job as soon", "a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that", "we could get past the semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their", "isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ...", "advising another human being to quit their job/studies ... and they should keep", "It is like an inside joke for the community ... but the joke", "distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme", "affiliated publications with their supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ...", "supervisor seems pretty reasonable (if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to", "they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety of", "a pithy comment. * There was another example I can't find right now", "met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school", "supervisor to publish. This was met with \"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which", "... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree that this meme is", "the risk. Folks using this meme should have some respect for the fact", "mind that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a", "... with 18 upvotes. * [What to do: PI lied to me and", "me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that requires legal advice,", "picture. Highly-upvoted comments in bold left by experienced academics telling inexperienced academics that", "PI lied to me and is keeping my grant!](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15229/what-to-do-pi-lied-to-me-and-is-keeping-my-grant): a difficult question that", "walk. Run.*\" It is like an inside joke for the community ... but", "that requires legal advice, not a pithy comment. There was another example", "(if a tad distrustful) ... certainly not grounds to quit. --- Anyone agree", "of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk.", "simple in terms of not being the whole story. The first piece of", "\"Don't walk. Run\" from JeffE which seemed entirely inappropriate. A school guideline requiring", "it's \"Don't walk. Run.\" It is like an inside joke for the community", "semantic satiation for a minute, somebody quitting their real-life position and looking for", "story. The first piece of advice isn't \"have you tried talking with her?\"", "who don't know the culture in other areas and departments. Lots of questions", "from a variety of areas who see such questions and who might project", "for the community ... but the joke might not be clear to newcomers.", "problematic coming from hugely successful academics working in rock-star departments who don't know", "that they are simultaneously communicating with thousands of vulnerable people from a variety", "for employment/studies elsewhere is a serious issue and should be treated seriously. I", "a serious issue and should be treated seriously. I think it's especially problematic", "with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.*\" ... with 18 upvotes. [What", "I sometimes find it uncomfortable. A couple of examples of where it made", "Folks using this meme should have some respect for the fact that they're", "\"have you tried talking with her?\" but rather \"Don't walk. Run.\" ... with" ]
[ "but I think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > >", "not about academia per se, but I think it could fall under the", "the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher,", "It's not about academia per se, but I think it could fall under", "per se, but I think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of", "topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor", "university professor > > > and maybe even > > Inner workings of", "could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate", "is a trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's", "trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about", "reasons for what I believe is a trend relating to the kinds of", "fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate student,", "> and maybe even > > Inner workings of research departments. > >", "researcher, university professor > > > and maybe even > > Inner workings", "professor > > > and maybe even > > Inner workings of research", "the reasons for what I believe is a trend relating to the kinds", "a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and maybe even", "have a question that is not a problem, but rather something that I'm", "I'm curious about and could elicit a good answer. I would like to", "a question that is not a problem, but rather something that I'm curious", "but rather something that I'm curious about and could elicit a good answer.", "about academia per se, but I think it could fall under the [allowed", "se, but I think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of >", "campuses. It's not about academia per se, but I think it could fall", "postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and maybe even > > Inner", "kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia per se, but", "> > and maybe even > > Inner workings of research departments. >", "know the reasons for what I believe is a trend relating to the", "could elicit a good answer. I would like to know the reasons for", "question that is not a problem, but rather something that I'm curious about", "I would like to know the reasons for what I believe is a", "like to know the reasons for what I believe is a trend relating", "of > > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor >", "to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia per", "elicit a good answer. I would like to know the reasons for what", "a trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not", "it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a", "that I'm curious about and could elicit a good answer. I would like", "curious about and could elicit a good answer. I would like to know", "think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as", "and maybe even > > Inner workings of research departments. > > >", "not a problem, but rather something that I'm curious about and could elicit", "graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and maybe even >", "for what I believe is a trend relating to the kinds of facilities", "facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia per se, but I think", "a good answer. I would like to know the reasons for what I", "the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia per se,", "academia per se, but I think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic)", "rather something that I'm curious about and could elicit a good answer. I", "> > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > >", "would like to know the reasons for what I believe is a trend", "that is not a problem, but rather something that I'm curious about and", "about and could elicit a good answer. I would like to know the", "Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and", "believe is a trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses.", "[allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university", "a problem, but rather something that I'm curious about and could elicit a", "student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and maybe even > >", "problem, but rather something that I'm curious about and could elicit a good", "I have a question that is not a problem, but rather something that", "> Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > >", "as a graduate student, postdoctoral researcher, university professor > > > and maybe", "answer. I would like to know the reasons for what I believe is", "what I believe is a trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered", "offered by campuses. It's not about academia per se, but I think it", "to know the reasons for what I believe is a trend relating to", "of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia per se, but I", "something that I'm curious about and could elicit a good answer. I would", "> > > and maybe even > > Inner workings of research departments.", "I think it could fall under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life", "good answer. I would like to know the reasons for what I believe", "I believe is a trend relating to the kinds of facilities offered by", "relating to the kinds of facilities offered by campuses. It's not about academia", "under the [allowed topic](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic) of > > Life as a graduate student, postdoctoral", "by campuses. It's not about academia per se, but I think it could", "is not a problem, but rather something that I'm curious about and could", "and could elicit a good answer. I would like to know the reasons" ]
[ "question: [How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would", "of this issue. Is it a candidate to become a community wiki? If", "so that we can cover more aspects of this issue. Is it a", "it by adding their personal experience so that we can cover more aspects", "a community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep worm", "handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people editing", "media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people editing it by adding their", "to become a community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for a", "would benefit from people editing it by adding their personal experience so that", "Is it a candidate to become a community wiki? If yes, what is", "adding their personal experience so that we can cover more aspects of this", "and think it would benefit from people editing it by adding their personal", "wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep worm like me", "people editing it by adding their personal experience so that we can cover", "should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from", "personal experience so that we can cover more aspects of this issue. Is", "with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people editing it by", "it a candidate to become a community wiki? If yes, what is the", "cover more aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate to become a", "that we can cover more aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate", "their personal experience so that we can cover more aspects of this issue.", "this issue. Is it a candidate to become a community wiki? If yes,", "a candidate to become a community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure", "it would benefit from people editing it by adding their personal experience so", "more aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate to become a community", "this question: [How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it", "I wrote this question: [How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and", "experience so that we can cover more aspects of this issue. Is it", "editing it by adding their personal experience so that we can cover more", "from people editing it by adding their personal experience so that we can", "can cover more aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate to become", "yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep worm like me to suggest", "think it would benefit from people editing it by adding their personal experience", "what is the procedure for a low-rep worm like me to suggest it", "communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people editing it", "academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people", "wrote this question: [How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think", "issue. Is it a candidate to become a community wiki? If yes, what", "the procedure for a low-rep worm like me to suggest it might be?", "If yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep worm like me to", "benefit from people editing it by adding their personal experience so that we", "candidate to become a community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for", "we can cover more aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate to", "aspects of this issue. Is it a candidate to become a community wiki?", "community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep worm like", "is the procedure for a low-rep worm like me to suggest it might", "become a community wiki? If yes, what is the procedure for a low-rep", "the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit from people editing it by adding", "[How should academics handle communication with the media?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/20532/10643) and think it would benefit", "by adding their personal experience so that we can cover more aspects of" ]
[ "compiled into this one, which shall now serve as the space for the", "this one, which shall now serve as the space for the candidates to", "you action and and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do you", "of the site on track? Vote as if you were a normal user,", "questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make them on", "for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too", "and then post your answer to each question given in that same answer.", "insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first set of", "are currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried out the role effectively?", "question given in that same answer. For your convenience, I will include all", "serve as the space for the candidates to provide their answers. Not every", "the community in lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus our 2.", "in the Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates! --- >", "moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete,", "is your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my", "is currently moderated, and how would you go about implementing that change? >", "you are currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried out the role", "> > A quite specific question: what is your position with respect to", "this will serve as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of", "site on track? Vote as if you were a normal user, disregarding your", "--- > > A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate)", "you were a normal user, disregarding your role and the binding nature? >", "format. > > > What activities on the site suggest that you would", "for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately", "non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction of the site", "position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange", "immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction of the site on track?", "posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to", "the candidates to provide their answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently", "change would you like to make in how the site is currently moderated,", "content should be left unchanged as much as possible? > > > What", "argued that some questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would", "in how the site is currently moderated, and how would you go about", "active users who look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by", "the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be", "that same answer. For your convenience, I will include all of the questions", "view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the", "the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election", "rather think that content should be left unchanged as much as possible? >", "role and the binding nature? > > > What change would you like", "that content should be left unchanged as much as possible? > > >", "if a question was on-topic or not, because it was somehow related to", "you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta and the", "upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of you action and and criticising", "statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just", "everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format. > > > What activities", "For this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from the community in", "have been compiled into this one, which shall now serve as the space", "on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would", "> > What change would you like to make in how the site", "was compiled, but apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer", "favor of you action and and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How", "to provide their answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently when I", "opinion or the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? > > >", "weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the", "the site on track? Vote as if you were a normal user, disregarding", "to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in", "long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering people's questions, but", "position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use your \"binding", "simple - post an answer to this question, citing each of the questions", "you delete comments? > > > What is your position on boat programming", "moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format. > >", "the community decide on things that could conceivably be subjective, but take action", "you like to make in how the site is currently moderated, and how", "three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled, this will serve as", "the direction of the site on track? Vote as if you were a", "been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not, because it was", "could conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to", "> > What is your time zone? What is the time period you", "> A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment).", "answer to this question, citing each of the questions and then post your", "your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator", "What is your position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long", "comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will", "and will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to all", "because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them", "how the site is currently moderated, and how would you go about implementing", "in favor of you action and and criticising your action; both get upvotes.", "you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it", "> > > A quite specific question: what is your position with respect", "the Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates! --- > >", "possible? > > > What is your time zone? What is the time", "the site suggest that you would be a good moderator? If you are", "specific question: what is your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant", "A significant part of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a", "the answers have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters", "flagging for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive,", "would you go about implementing that change? > > > Under what conditions", "the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this reason,", "it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that", "first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled, this", "posted both in favor of you action and and criticising your action; both", "that some questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make", "both get upvotes. How do you decide what to do next? > >", "them in this task? Or do you rather think that content should be", "to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not, because it was somehow", "think that content should be left unchanged as much as possible? > >", "they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them in", "their answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently when I posted the", "official SE policy disagree? > > > What is your position on the", "questions in quote format with a break in between each, suitable for you", "that you would be a good moderator? If you are currently a moderator,", "user, disregarding your role and the binding nature? > > > What change", "to this question, citing each of the questions and then post your answer", "[See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate postings where", "between each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole", "A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The", "same answer. For your convenience, I will include all of the questions in", "as the space for the candidates to provide their answers. Not every question", "question, citing each of the questions and then post your answer to each", "convenience, I will include all of the questions in quote format with a", "be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to", "you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first", "for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc).", "deliberately to keep the direction of the site on track? Vote as if", "job is simple - post an answer to this question, citing each of", "as much as possible? > > > What is your time zone? What", "thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled", "[Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use your \"binding vote\"", "opinion and official SE policy disagree? > > > What is your position", "left unchanged as much as possible? > > > What is your time", "suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after", "to collect 10 questions from the community in lieu of the usual selection", "So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will", "good moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried", "the whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the", "this question, citing each of the questions and then post your answer to", "can often be argued that some questions can however easily generalise to graduate", "for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format. >", "lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of you action and", "> > What is your position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In", "questions and then post your answer to each question given in that same", "Answers are posted both in favor of you action and and criticising your", "Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For", "activities on the site suggest that you would be a good moderator? If", "and how would you go about implementing that change? > > > Under", "answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some", "compiled, but apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing", "your job is simple - post an answer to this question, citing each", "what conditions will you delete comments? > > > What is your position", "the answer in UTC format. > > > What activities on the site", "How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh", "your answer to each question given in that same answer. For your convenience,", "the site is currently moderated, and how would you go about implementing that", "on the site suggest that you would be a good moderator? If you", "site suggest that you would be a good moderator? If you are currently", "but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the", "the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor", "apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested", "currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried out the role effectively? >", "question was on-topic or not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies.", "not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often be", "answer. For your convenience, I will include all of the questions in quote", "like to make in how the site is currently moderated, and how would", "and curate them, for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because they", "Let the community weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc.", "run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering people's questions, but providing", "by flagging for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not", "now serve as the space for the candidates to provide their answers. Not", "2. As a candidate, your job is simple - post an answer to", "answer in UTC format. > > > What activities on the site suggest", "> What is your time zone? What is the time period you are", "of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good", "look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging for comment", "[copy the whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all", "your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use your", "questions from the community in lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus", "of the questions in quote format with a break in between each, suitable", "What is your time zone? What is the time period you are available", "moderate postings where your opinion or the community's opinion and official SE policy", "candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one,", "> How would you moderate postings where your opinion or the community's opinion", "Vote as if you were a normal user, disregarding your role and the", "binding nature? > > > What change would you like to make in", "is your time zone? What is the time period you are available for", "format with a break in between each, suitable for you to insert your", "nature? > > > What change would you like to make in how", "task? Or do you rather think that content should be left unchanged as", "make them on topic. So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) >", "operations? Let the community decide on things that could conceivably be subjective, but", "Just [copy the whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once", "find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it in", "be argued that some questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which", "disregarding your role and the binding nature? > > > What change would", "community in lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As", "are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them in this", "you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first", "comments? > > > What is your position on boat programming questions? [See", "is simple - post an answer to this question, citing each of the", "community decide on things that could conceivably be subjective, but take action on", "have been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not, because it", "to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator actions have been to", "question was compiled, but apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection, the", "have some very active users who look at old questions/answers, and curate them,", "the questions and then post your answer to each question given in that", "will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in", "suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect", "10 questions from the community in lieu of the usual selection of 8", "given in that same answer. For your convenience, I will include all of", "be left unchanged as much as possible? > > > What is your", "or not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often", "you rather think that content should be left unchanged as much as possible?", "candidates! --- > > A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you", "boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you", "somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that some questions", "undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that some questions can however easily", "the usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your job", "you decide what to do next? > > > A quite specific question:", "this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from the community in lieu", "with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator actions have", "policy disagree? > > > What is your position on the following statement", "voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked", "from the community in lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus our", "available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format.", "collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall", "post your answer to each question given in that same answer. For your", "\"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering people's", "> > A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the", "studies. It can often be argued that some questions can however easily generalise", "of the candidates! --- > > A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive)", "I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed", "usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your job is", "[from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall now", "what is your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of", "which would make them on topic. So, what is your position? [Some example", "and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta and", "were a normal user, disregarding your role and the binding nature? > >", "all of the candidates! --- > > A user posts something you find", "a normal user, disregarding your role and the binding nature? > > >", "currently moderated, and how would you go about implementing that change? > >", "in UTC format. > > > What activities on the site suggest that", "the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering people's questions,", "things that could conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately?", "the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled,", "The user posts about it in Meta and the post gets a lot", "studies, which would make them on topic. So, what is your position? [Some", "connection with the moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for the", "(off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta", "> > What is your position on boat programming questions? [See here for", "the time period you are available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify", "if you were a normal user, disregarding your role and the binding nature?", "are not just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the", "the binding nature? > > > What change would you like to make", "> > Under what conditions will you delete comments? > > > What", "very active users who look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance", "How would you moderate postings where your opinion or the community's opinion and", "track? Vote as if you were a normal user, disregarding your role and", "SE policy disagree? > > > What is your position on the following", "people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some very", "self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've", "elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from", "an answer to this question, citing each of the questions and then post", "of the usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your", "be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to all of the", "an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall now serve", "users who look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging", "user posts about it in Meta and the post gets a lot of", "is your position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run,", "my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or", "most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on things", "however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make them on topic. So,", "failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions", "questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some very active", "direction of the site on track? Vote as if you were a normal", "> What activities on the site suggest that you would be a good", "do you rather think that content should be left unchanged as much as", "> A quite specific question: what is your position with respect to undergraduate", "set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled, this will", "with a break in between each, suitable for you to insert your answers.", "about it in Meta and the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers", "your convenience, I will include all of the questions in quote format with", "it in Meta and the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are", "do next? > > > A quite specific question: what is your position", "linked in the Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates! ---", "citing each of the questions and then post your answer to each question", "each of the questions and then post your answer to each question given", "opted to collect 10 questions from the community in lieu of the usual", "will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to all of", "moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not,", "on topic. So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > >", "removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you", "break in between each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy", "have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters to view", "position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator actions", "our 2. As a candidate, your job is simple - post an answer", "programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate", "both in favor of you action and and criticising your action; both get", "delete comments? > > > What is your position on boat programming questions?", "every question was compiled, but apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection,", "It can often be argued that some questions can however easily generalise to", "a break in between each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just", "what to do next? > > > A quite specific question: what is", "aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering", "positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges?", "in lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As a", "moderator, do you believe you've carried out the role effectively? > > >", "the moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions", "Exchange sites are not just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating", "chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them in this task? Or do", "topic. So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How", "normal user, disregarding your role and the binding nature? > > > What", "> > > What is your position on boat programming questions? [See here", "you go about implementing that change? > > > Under what conditions will", "long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some very active users who look", "and the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in", "on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites", "significant part of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a question", "posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts", "\"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first on most close,", "this task? Or do you rather think that content should be left unchanged", "> > > How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let", "not constructive, etc). Will you support them in this task? Or do you", "can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make them on topic.", "what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you", "and the binding nature? > > > What change would you like to", "respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator actions have been", "luck to all of the candidates! --- > > A user posts something", "and official SE policy disagree? > > > What is your position on", "next? > > > A quite specific question: what is your position with", "time zone? What is the time period you are available for moderating our", "post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of", "community weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let", "user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user", "or the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? > > > What", "is the time period you are available for moderating our site everyday? Please", "implementing that change? > > > Under what conditions will you delete comments?", "of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled, this will serve", "one, which shall now serve as the space for the candidates to provide", "provide their answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently when I posted", "matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction of the site on", "in this task? Or do you rather think that content should be left", "unchanged as much as possible? > > > What is your time zone?", "on things that could conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters", "Not every question was compiled, but apparently when I posted the original Q&A", "moderated, and how would you go about implementing that change? > > >", "appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates!", "the candidates! --- > > A user posts something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and", "all of the questions in quote format with a break in between each,", "examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate postings where your opinion or", "submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from the community", "compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts", "then post your answer to each question given in that same answer. For", "Meta and the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both", "will serve as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their", "that could conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act", "you moderate postings where your opinion or the community's opinion and official SE", "would be a good moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do you", "thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall now serve as the", "get upvotes. How do you decide what to do next? > > >", "answers\"? We have some very active users who look at old questions/answers, and", "I will include all of the questions in quote format with a break", "> Under what conditions will you delete comments? > > > What is", "but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some very active users", "answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently when I posted the original", "would you moderate postings where your opinion or the community's opinion and official", "(close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta and the post", "> What is your position on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/).", "collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this", "> > What activities on the site suggest that you would be a", "> How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community", "use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first on", "your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first on most", "serve as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates,", "are posted both in favor of you action and and criticising your action;", "undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on things that could conceivably be", "specify the answer in UTC format. > > > What activities on the", "a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have", "site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format. > > > What", "your role and the binding nature? > > > What change would you", "thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have", "conditions will you delete comments? > > > What is your position on", "for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate postings where your opinion", "Once all the answers have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript", "first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide", "As a candidate, your job is simple - post an answer to this", "> > > What change would you like to make in how the", "questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because", "In connection with the moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for", "part of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a question was", "is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use", "> > > Under what conditions will you delete comments? > > >", "make in how the site is currently moderated, and how would you go", "your position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack", "etc. operations? Let the community decide on things that could conceivably be subjective,", "some questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make them", "> > > What is your position on the following statement from aeismail:", "> > How would you moderate postings where your opinion or the community's", "just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We", "etc). Will you support them in this task? Or do you rather think", "> > > What is your time zone? What is the time period", "how would you go about implementing that change? > > > Under what", "moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected", "8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your job is simple - post", "action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction of", "to make in how the site is currently moderated, and how would you", "answer to each question given in that same answer. For your convenience, I", "old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically", "the community weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations?", "constructive, etc). Will you support them in this task? Or do you rather", "instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete, too chatty,", "not just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"?", "close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on things that", "a candidate, your job is simple - post an answer to this question,", "been compiled into this one, which shall now serve as the space for", "our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to", "related to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that some questions can", "was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that some", "(typically because they are obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support", "community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? > > > What is your", "the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this", "each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing", "candidates to provide their answers. Not every question was compiled, but apparently when", "our site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC format. > > >", "suggest that you would be a good moderator? If you are currently a", "and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do you decide what to", "decide what to do next? > > > A quite specific question: what", "site is currently moderated, and how would you go about implementing that change?", "some very active users who look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for", "here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate postings where your", "zone? What is the time period you are available for moderating our site", "we are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an", "to each question given in that same answer. For your convenience, I will", "on track? Vote as if you were a normal user, disregarding your role", "question: what is your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A significant part", "questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How would you moderate postings", "lieu of the usual selection of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate,", "criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do you decide what to do", "where your opinion or the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? >", "What activities on the site suggest that you would be a good moderator?", "If you are currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried out the", "actions have been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not, because", "posts about it in Meta and the post gets a lot of upvotes.", "too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them in this task? Or", "you support them in this task? Or do you rather think that content", "gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of you", "a moderator, do you believe you've carried out the role effectively? > >", "a question was on-topic or not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate", "a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of you action", "are available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer in UTC", "be a good moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do you believe", "been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters to view the", "subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep", "each question given in that same answer. For your convenience, I will include", "dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been compiled, this will serve as a", "> What change would you like to make in how the site is", "obsolete, too chatty, not constructive, etc). Will you support them in this task?", "will include all of the questions in quote format with a break in", "example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > > > How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator", "- post an answer to this question, citing each of the questions and", "easily generalise to graduate studies, which would make them on topic. So, what", "thoughts of their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election page.", "Stack Exchange sites are not just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term", "who look at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging for", "Or do you rather think that content should be left unchanged as much", "the following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are", "the (question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta and the post gets", "go about implementing that change? > > > Under what conditions will you", "about implementing that change? > > > Under what conditions will you delete", "and and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do you decide what", "was on-topic or not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It", "transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will be", "Let the community decide on things that could conceivably be subjective, but take", "I've opted to collect 10 questions from the community in lieu of the", "a good moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do you believe you've", "on-topic or not, because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can", "the space for the candidates to provide their answers. Not every question was", "change? > > > Under what conditions will you delete comments? > >", "about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have", "holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection)", "space for the candidates to provide their answers. Not every question was compiled,", "time period you are available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the", "of upvotes. Answers are posted both in favor of you action and and", "privileges? Let the community weigh in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete,", "page. Good luck to all of the candidates! --- > > A user", "providing long-term curating of the answers\"? We have some very active users who", "as a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and", "sites are not just about answering people's questions, but providing long-term curating of", "you are available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer in", "would you like to make in how the site is currently moderated, and", "disagree? > > > What is your position on the following statement from", "for the candidates to provide their answers. Not every question was compiled, but", "Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been", "> > > What activities on the site suggest that you would be", "selection of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your job is simple", "take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction", "generalise to graduate studies, which would make them on topic. So, what is", "your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first set of three", "quite specific question: what is your position with respect to undergraduate questions? A", "earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which shall now serve as", "after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers have been", "when I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions", "in between each, suitable for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the", "something you find (off-topic/wrong/offensive) and you (close/delete/migrate) the (question/comment). The user posts about", "your position on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > >", "graduate studies, which would make them on topic. So, what is your position?", "because it was somehow related to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued", "containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted", "Election page. Good luck to all of the candidates! --- > > A", "from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not just about", "for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into", "into this one, which shall now serve as the space for the candidates", "of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if a question was on-topic", "for you to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the", "them, for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because they are obsolete,", "the questions in quote format with a break in between each, suitable for", "period you are available for moderating our site everyday? Please specify the answer", "undergraduate questions? A significant part of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate", "shall now serve as the space for the candidates to provide their answers.", "at old questions/answers, and curate them, for instance by flagging for comment removal", "following statement from aeismail: \"In the long run, Stack Exchange sites are not", "action and and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do you decide", "What change would you like to make in how the site is currently", "plus our 2. As a candidate, your job is simple - post an", "often be argued that some questions can however easily generalise to graduate studies,", "with the moderator elections, we are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates.", "reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from the community in lieu of", "For your convenience, I will include all of the questions in quote format", "What is your position on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). >", "of you action and and criticising your action; both get upvotes. How do", "should be left unchanged as much as possible? > > > What is", "to do next? > > > A quite specific question: what is your", "on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately to keep the direction of the", "be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from the", "all the answers have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for", "them on topic. So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/) > >", "arbitrate if a question was on-topic or not, because it was somehow related", "Will you support them in this task? Or do you rather think that", "> > > How would you moderate postings where your opinion or the", "much as possible? > > > What is your time zone? What is", "but apparently when I posted the original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our", "(question/comment). The user posts about it in Meta and the post gets a", "action; both get upvotes. How do you decide what to do next? >", "in that same answer. For your convenience, I will include all of the", "to graduate studies, which would make them on topic. So, what is your", "postings where your opinion or the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree?", "include all of the questions in quote format with a break in between", "the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? > > > What is", "that change? > > > Under what conditions will you delete comments? >", "answers have been compiled, this will serve as a transcript for voters to", "curating of the answers\"? We have some very active users who look at", "to deliberately to keep the direction of the site on track? Vote as", "curate them, for instance by flagging for comment removal (typically because they are", "post an answer to this question, citing each of the questions and then", "How do you decide what to do next? > > > A quite", "UTC format. > > > What activities on the site suggest that you", "conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial matters immediately? Act to deliberately", "on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on", "questions? A significant part of my moderator actions have been to arbitrate if", "in Meta and the post gets a lot of upvotes. Answers are posted", "Under what conditions will you delete comments? > > > What is your", "original Q&A collection, the self-answer containing our suggested questions failed to be submitted.", "would make them on topic. So, what is your position? [Some example positions](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/963/)", "upvotes. How do you decide what to do next? > > > A", "delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on things that could conceivably", "a transcript for voters to view the thoughts of their candidates, and will", "keep the direction of the site on track? Vote as if you were", "the answers\"? We have some very active users who look at old questions/answers,", "Good luck to all of the candidates! --- > > A user posts", "decide on things that could conceivably be subjective, but take action on non-controversial", "collect 10 questions from the community in lieu of the usual selection of", "in quote format with a break in between each, suitable for you to", "A quite specific question: what is your position with respect to undergraduate questions?", "as if you were a normal user, disregarding your role and the binding", "What is the time period you are available for moderating our site everyday?", "which shall now serve as the space for the candidates to provide their", "are holding a Q&A thread for the candidates. Questions collected [from an earlier", "candidate, your job is simple - post an answer to this question, citing", "do you decide what to do next? > > > A quite specific", "> What is your position on the following statement from aeismail: \"In the", "to undergraduate studies. It can often be argued that some questions can however", "questions failed to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect 10", "candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck to", "to keep the direction of the site on track? Vote as if you", "We have some very active users who look at old questions/answers, and curate", "whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source). Once all the answers", "in first on most close, reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community", "their candidates, and will be appropriately linked in the Election page. Good luck", "your time zone? What is the time period you are available for moderating", "reopen, delete, undelete, etc. operations? Let the community decide on things that could", "as possible? > > > What is your time zone? What is the", "of the answers\"? We have some very active users who look at old", "position on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > > > How", "of the questions and then post your answer to each question given in", "answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first set of three dashes](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/revisions/4116ef36-2ef1-4c9b-b6d6-f5c95a9c43b0/view-source).", "vote\" moderator privileges? Let the community weigh in first on most close, reopen,", "will you delete comments? > > > What is your position on boat", "of 8 plus our 2. As a candidate, your job is simple -", "you would be a good moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do", "Questions collected [from an earlier thread](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/932/2014-moderator-election-qa-question-collection) have been compiled into this one, which", "Act to deliberately to keep the direction of the site on track? Vote", "your action; both get upvotes. How do you decide what to do next?", "moderator? If you are currently a moderator, do you believe you've carried out", "> > How will you use your \"binding vote\" moderator privileges? Let the", "to insert your answers. Just [copy the whole thing after the first set", "your opinion or the community's opinion and official SE policy disagree? > >", "quote format with a break in between each, suitable for you to insert", "to be submitted. For this reason, I've opted to collect 10 questions from", "is your position on boat programming questions? [See here for examples](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/965/). > >", "to all of the candidates! --- > > A user posts something you", "support them in this task? Or do you rather think that content should", "Please specify the answer in UTC format. > > > What activities on" ]
[ "is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts", "Zlerc recently asked a question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In", "the past, we've had differing thoughts from the community on this topic ([for](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/50/questions-involving-lists),", "essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts from", "a question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've", "asked a question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past,", "recently asked a question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the", "In the past, we've had differing thoughts from the community on this topic", "which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing", "question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had", "a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts from the", "things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts from the community on this", "we've had differing thoughts from the community on this topic ([for](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/50/questions-involving-lists), [against](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/749/big-list-questions)). Thoughts?", "[list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts from the community", "past, we've had differing thoughts from the community on this topic ([for](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/50/questions-involving-lists), [against](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/749/big-list-questions)).", "of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions). In the past, we've had differing thoughts from the community on", "Retu Zlerc recently asked a question which is, essentially, a [list of things](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/20901/compiling-ethical-standards-for-coauthorship-across-academic-fields-and-regions)." ]
[ "3. Provide a new answer, which starts with something along the lines of", "is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in", "good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is", "now as follows: If we encounter a question that already has one or", "anything but minor style edits to other people's answers. My question is now", "to edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new", "is also my impression - I have been reasonably active on the site", "author even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in", "I would also see this as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee", "additional information into existing answers, if they feel that a given answer is", "style edits to other people's answers. My question is now as follows: If", "active on the site in the last few months, and from the top", "something along the lines of \"The existing answer by XY is good, but", "really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What", "new answer, which starts with something along the lines of \"The existing answer", "seen an edit that actually added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking,", "right way to do it? 1. Post a comment and ask the original", "the lines of \"The existing answer by XY is good, but ...\". I", "as follows: If we encounter a question that already has one or more", "edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer,", "This is also my impression - I have been reasonably active on the", "just edit additional information into existing answers, if they feel that a given", "Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically never happens", "even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his", "basically never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with", "follows: If we encounter a question that already has one or more answers", "to me option 2, but how do we guarantee that the original author", "What is the right way to do it? 1. Post a comment and", "to other people's answers. My question is now as follows: If we encounter", "the top seems to suggest to me option 2, but how do we", "to be added. What is the right way to do it? 1. Post", "we encounter a question that already has one or more answers that we", "answer by XY is good, but ...\". I have done something similar [myself", "even has the same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to be", "detail needs to be added. What is the right way to do it?", "If we encounter a question that already has one or more answers that", "that we consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to", "common way how it is currently done (my impression at least), but brings", "speaking, I would also see this as highly inappropriate, as there is no", "been reasonably active on the site in the last few months, and from", "1. Post a comment and ask the original author to edit it in.", "it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which", "answer, which starts with something along the lines of \"The existing answer by", "to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this as highly", "Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts with something", "has the same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to be the", "would also see this as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that", "if they feel that a given answer is good but is missing \"something\".", "it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts with something along", "answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark", "the site in the last few months, and from the top of my", "is now as follows: If we encounter a question that already has one", "the original author to edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3.", "are supposed to just edit additional information into existing answers, if they feel", "the topic? Option 3 seems to be the common way how it is", "anymore, as people are supposed to just edit additional information into existing answers,", "or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is", "have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The", "Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically never happens (essentially all", "to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy", "suggest to me option 2, but how do we guarantee that the original", "how do we guarantee that the original author even has the same opinion", "a single case where I have seen an edit that actually added content", "and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically never happens (essentially", "that the original author even has the same opinion on the topic? Option", "actually added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see", "[myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the", "\"The existing answer by XY is good, but ...\". I have done something", "existing answer by XY is good, but ...\". I have done something similar", "[his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything but minor style edits", "to just edit additional information into existing answers, if they feel that a", "and style). This is also my impression - I have been reasonably active", "community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature* that serves no real", "feature* that serves no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just", "of a legacy feature that serves no real purpose anymore, as people are", "[this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature", "given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people", "why people seem reluctant to do anything but minor style edits to other", "this as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the original author", "directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts with something along the lines", "legacy feature that serves no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to", "remember a single case where I have seen an edit that actually added", "R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits", "...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but", "to do it?* 1. Post a comment and ask the original author to", "do anything but minor style edits to other people's answers. My question is", "a question that already has one or more answers that we consider really", "minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is the right way to do", "good, but ...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is", "top seems to suggest to me option 2, but how do we guarantee", "cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems to suggest to me option", "have seen an edit that actually added content to an existing answer. Personally", "and from the top of my head I cannot remember a single case", "something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked", "XY is good, but ...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option", "site in the last few months, and from the top of my head", "currently done (my impression at least), but brings us close to community wiki", "real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just edit additional information into", "but minor style edits to other people's answers. My question is now as", "answer to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of a", "do it?** 1. Post a comment and ask the original author to edit", "for clarity and style). This is also my impression - I have been", "where I have seen an edit that actually added content to an existing", "that a given answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and", "minor style edits to other people's answers. My question is now as follows:", "people's answers. My question is now as follows: If we encounter a question", "- I have been reasonably active on the site in the last few", "a comment and ask the original author to edit it in. 2. Edit", "of \"The existing answer by XY is good, but ...\". I have done", "question linked at the top seems to suggest to me option 2, but", "from the top of my head I cannot remember a single case where", "The accepted answer to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort", "way to do it?* 1. Post a comment and ask the original author", "edits to other people's answers. My question is now as follows: *If we", "ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems to suggest to", "I cannot remember a single case where I have seen an edit that", "that community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature* that serves no", "a legacy feature that serves no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed", "never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the", "supposed to just edit additional information into existing answers, if they feel that", "Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do", "guarantee that the original author even has the same opinion on the topic?", "highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the original author even endorses", "linked at the top seems to suggest to me option 2, but how", "clarity and style). This is also my impression - I have been reasonably", "reluctant to do anything but minor style edits to other people's answers. My", "option 2, but how do we guarantee that the original author even has", "the top of my head I cannot remember a single case where I", "style). This is also my impression - I have been reasonably active on", "Personally speaking, I would also see this as highly inappropriate, as there is", "me option 2, but how do we guarantee that the original author even", "all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for", "no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just edit additional information", "is the right way to do it?** 1. Post a comment and ask", "but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this", "seems to suggest to me option 2, but how do we guarantee that", "one or more answers that we consider really good, but we feel some", "The question linked at the top seems to suggest to me option 2,", "sort of a legacy feature that serves no real purpose anymore, as people", "original author even has the same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems", "my head I cannot remember a single case where I have seen an", "detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything but minor", "answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this as highly inappropriate, as there", "into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything but", "starts with something along the lines of \"The existing answer by XY is", "edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity", "feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is the right way", "remark that this in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are just", "my impression - I have been reasonably active on the site in the", "suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature* that serves", "given answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R.", "as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the original author even", "edit that actually added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would", "inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the original author even endorses a", "occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is also my impression - I", "in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts", "Provide a new answer, which starts with something along the lines of \"The", "that serves no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just edit", "topic? Option 3 seems to be the common way how it is currently", "happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional", "original author to edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide", "of my head I cannot remember a single case where I have seen", "endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094)", "do we guarantee that the original author even has the same opinion on", "2, but how do we guarantee that the original author even has the", "a new answer, which starts with something along the lines of \"The existing", "edit additional information into existing answers, if they feel that a given answer", "answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything but minor style edits to", "comment and ask the original author to edit it in. 2. Edit it", "into existing answers, if they feel that a given answer is good but", "serves no real purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just edit additional", "along the lines of \"The existing answer by XY is good, but ...\".", "purpose anymore, as people are supposed to just edit additional information into existing", "a given answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko", "change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem", "how it is currently done (my impression at least), but brings us close", "more answers that we consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail", "be the common way how it is currently done (my impression at least),", "as there is no guarantee that the original author even endorses a given", "Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically never", "be added. What is the right way to do it?** 1. Post a", "existing answers, if they feel that a given answer is good but is", "2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts with", "no guarantee that the original author even endorses a given change. Poko R.", "also see this as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the", "I have seen an edit that actually added content to an existing answer.", "wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature that serves no real purpose", "content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this as", "or more answers that we consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish", "case where I have seen an edit that actually added content to an", "existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this as highly inappropriate, as", "done (my impression at least), but brings us close to community wiki territory.", "that actually added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also", "this in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or", "that this in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar", "to suggest to me option 2, but how do we guarantee that the", "seem reluctant to do anything but minor style edits to other people's answers.", "the same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to be the common", "to be the common way how it is currently done (my impression at", "but ...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok", "question that already has one or more answers that we consider really good,", "answers. My question is now as follows: If we encounter a question that", "do-over for clarity and style). This is also my impression - I have", "an edit that actually added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I", "consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added.", "and ask the original author to edit it in. 2. Edit it in", "some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is the right way to", "ask the original author to edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly.", "question is now as follows: If we encounter a question that already has", "deemed sort of a legacy feature* that serves no real purpose anymore, as", "\"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice basically", "has one or more answers that we consider really good, but we feel", "similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at", "opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to be the common way how", "already has one or more answers that we consider really good, but we", "we consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be", "in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything but minor style", "information into existing answers, if they feel that a given answer is good", "cannot remember a single case where I have seen an edit that actually", "people seem reluctant to do anything but minor style edits to other people's", "see this as highly inappropriate, as there is no guarantee that the original", "Post a comment and ask the original author to edit it in. 2.", "Option 3 seems to be the common way how it is currently done", "but cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems to suggest to me", "is no guarantee that the original author even endorses a given change. Poko", "today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the top", "it is currently done (my impression at least), but brings us close to", "is currently done (my impression at least), but brings us close to community", "accepted answer to [this question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of", "in directly. 3. Provide a new answer, which starts with something along the", "original author even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail", "head I cannot remember a single case where I have seen an edit", "fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is also my", "the common way how it is currently done (my impression at least), but", "good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that", "reasonably active on the site in the last few months, and from the", "a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why", "grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This", "My question is now as follows: If we encounter a question that already", "way how it is currently done (my impression at least), but brings us", "which starts with something along the lines of \"The existing answer by XY", "question](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/987/how-and-why-should-a-question-be-made-a-community-wiki) suggests that community wiki is deemed sort of a legacy feature* that", "added. What is the right way to do it?** 1. Post a comment", "Xlark remark that this in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are", "practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes,", "at the top seems to suggest to me option 2, but how do", "also my impression - I have been reasonably active on the site in", "encounter a question that already has one or more answers that we consider", "done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question", "same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to be the common way", "is deemed sort of a legacy feature that serves no real purpose anymore,", "the original author even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes into", "last few months, and from the top of my head I cannot remember", "an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this as highly inappropriate,", "I have been reasonably active on the site in the last few months,", "we guarantee that the original author even has the same opinion on the", "needs to be added. What is the right way to do it?* 1.", "there is no guarantee that the original author even endorses a given change.", "seems to be the common way how it is currently done (my impression", "to do anything but minor style edits to other people's answers. My question", "in practice basically never happens (essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling", "single case where I have seen an edit that actually added content to", "1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems to", "on the topic? Option 3 seems to be the common way how it", "feel that a given answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg", "other people's answers. My question is now as follows: If we encounter a", "are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and", "lines of \"The existing answer by XY is good, but ...\". I have", "3 seems to be the common way how it is currently done (my", "answers that we consider really good, but we feel some minor-ish detail needs", "as people are supposed to just edit additional information into existing answers, if", "but how do we guarantee that the original author even has the same", "I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1 is ok but cumbersome.", "is good but is missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark", "Option 1 is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems", "it?* 1. Post a comment and ask the original author to edit it", "people are supposed to just edit additional information into existing answers, if they", "they feel that a given answer is good but is missing \"something\". Both,", "guarantee that the original author even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark", "the original author even has the same opinion on the topic? Option 3", "we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is the right", "impression - I have been reasonably active on the site in the last", "just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and style).", "have been reasonably active on the site in the last few months, and", "top of my head I cannot remember a single case where I have", "R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to", "answers, if they feel that a given answer is good but is missing", "Poko R. Xlark goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant", "the last few months, and from the top of my head I cannot", "author to edit it in. 2. Edit it in directly. 3. Provide a", "author even has the same opinion on the topic? Option 3 seems to", "on the site in the last few months, and from the top of", "that the original author even endorses a given change. Poko R. Xlark goes", "by XY is good, but ...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094).", "(essentially all edits are just grammar or spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over", "spelling fixes, with the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is also", "the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is also my impression -", "with the occasional do-over for clarity and style). This is also my impression", "few months, and from the top of my head I cannot remember a", "that already has one or more answers that we consider really good, but", "is good, but ...\". I have done something similar [myself today](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/20927/10094). Option 1", "is ok but cumbersome. The question linked at the top seems to suggest", "missing \"something\". Both, Jigg and Poko R. Xlark remark that this in practice", "goes into detail in [his answer](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/991/10094) why people seem reluctant to do anything", "but we feel some minor-ish detail needs to be added. What is the", "added content to an existing answer. Personally speaking, I would also see this", "with something along the lines of \"The existing answer by XY is good,", "months, and from the top of my head I cannot remember a single", "the right way to do it?* 1. Post a comment and ask the", "in the last few months, and from the top of my head I" ]
[ "[Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8.", "migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this seemed to be an", "(10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a", "trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated", "until later): > > Queries related to various software used in academia. Questions", "premises applied to my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming:", "for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2.", "the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense ... and", "for which there is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to", "1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes,", "boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for an academic\"", "my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic", "is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to other questions on", "2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers - does such a", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9", "can put forward is the request to not view moderation tools as nails", "my question was doing X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but", "discussion to my question specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator", "argue why a programmer needs a certain type of boat ... it needs", "member of and have no intention of signing up for. Thus I can", "close votes started to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't", "manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing", "a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking", "and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had the chance to", "went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't really", "migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question?", "[feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much time on this and other", "6. [Is there an open source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper", "tag itself (which I didn't see until later): > > Queries related to", "to be an important comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant", "comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes", "argue it was a shopping question I guess because I was asking for", "explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. *boat", "argue that my question was not asking for one's favourite anything from a", "I would argue that my question was not asking for one's favourite anything", "whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of", "it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a", "was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking (as an academic)", "questions (including highly voted questions) on the site do. --- But okay, I", "dunno. Having come to the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio", "for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue", "which I understand is like asking (as an academic) for your favourite x", "no longer interact with it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and", "to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of these questions have been", "past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers", "(I don't know the process). Hence this seemed to be an important comment.", "got migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this seemed to be", "discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was analogous to asking", "comments along the lines of the ones I got on my question. ---", "hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense ... and reluctance.", "or other. I dunno. Having come to the end of this long meta-question", "from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted", "programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward", "answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had the chance to upvote). I", "well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages to extract and visualise topics", "- does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming.", "... and apply it to other questions on the site. Here's just some", "> > > --- In any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg)", "even have comments along the lines of the ones I got on my", "a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I was looking", "started to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't know the", "address highly technical aspects of the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant", "the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > >", "was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that", "Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of the software but shall address", "> > --- In any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like", "doing Y* in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far from", "for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't", "have close votes. None even have comments along the lines of the ones", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool", "used in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of the software", "from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for", "upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics", "Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers)", "(5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes", "specific for academic papers. One could argue that it was still a boat", "on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to", "academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a relevant question. Now I had", "would argue that my question was not asking for one's favourite anything from", "perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\"", "a certain type of boat ... it needs a good coffee machine for", "sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's", "before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my", "asking \"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being", "yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is a dedicated SE site. ...", "doesn't make a question about boats a relevant question. Now I had previously", "peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one way", "last part of the comment was that it was relevant to another StackExchange", "my question specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would be", "that these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight that", "9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer)", "bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7.", "was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of these", "... it needs a good coffee machine for example. The other part of", "the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other", "visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue it was a shopping question", "not address highly technical aspects of the software but shall address features/issues highly", "applied to my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making", "of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of", "I was asking for things. The last part of the comment was that", "open source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1", "didn't see until later): > > Queries related to various software used in", "arguing one way or the other that these questions are off-topic for this", "see what I missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean I can", "FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions", "is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one way or the", "I have already spent too much time on this and other topics. I'm", "boat programming question since one could argue why a programmer needs a certain", "been migrated. None have close votes. None even have comments along the lines", "to be engaging on this question. But maybe it helps give examples of", "but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question", "[Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "one could make arguments that my question was doing X or wasn't doing", "of it using the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it", "many other questions. None of these questions have been migrated. None have close", "qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you", "what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was", "to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't know the process).", "I roughly tried to use my question as a yardstick (of course I'm", "researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member of and have no", "exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising", "handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "was looking for something specific for academic papers. One could argue that it", "producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member of", "answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in", "site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use my", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool for producing bibtex", "([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until later): > > Queries related", "creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... ---", "academic) for your favourite x from a set of well-known X or something.", "why a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I was", "on this question. But maybe it helps give examples of something or other.", "Having come to the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is", "it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4", "I guess because I was asking for things. The last part of the", "\"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking (as an academic) for your", "eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\"", "conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections", "highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to", "storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after", "FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean", "programmer needs a certain type of boat ... it needs a good coffee", "chance to upvote). I shall speak of it using the past tense, [may", "anything from a set of well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages", "it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was", "recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one way or the other that", "why I was looking for something specific for academic papers. One could argue", "9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures", "I dunno. Having come to the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward", "are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my", "make up your own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters for", "or something. I would argue that my question was not asking for one's", "(28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between", "recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat", "take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to a", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis", "site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted", "and other topics. I'm not going to be engaging on this question. But", "that my question was analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat for", "answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative", "academia. > > > --- In any case, aside from being confused, I", "paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking", "way or the other that these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm", "(18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am", "for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member of and have", "on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of these questions have", "rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a", "the question itself, all I can put forward is the request to not", "tools as nails for which you have the hammer, and to moderate with", "favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings. It was looking for software", "upvote). I shall speak of it using the past tense, [may it rest", "question. Now I had previously added discussion to my question specifying the reasons", "covered in academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1", "highly relevant to academia. > > > --- In any case, aside from", "looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't really find", "clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on", "site I'm not a member of and have no intention of signing up", "one's favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings. It was looking for", "migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes,", "for example. The other part of the comment was that it was a", "\"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there", "2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future", "boat programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2.", "(2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository", "of the question itself, all I can put forward is the request to", "case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too", "a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it", "to various software used in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects", "helps give examples of something or other. I dunno. Having come to the", "argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats", "Others could argue it was a shopping question I guess because I was", "Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use my question", "close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of these questions have been migrated.", "it was still a boat programming question since one could argue why a", "connections between topics covered in academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool)", "1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5", "of well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages to extract and visualise", "find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat", "answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3", "asking for one's favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings. It was", "a relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion to my question specifying", "comment was that it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like", "request for which there is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it", "11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers)", "Queries related to various software used in academia. Questions shall not address highly", "software packages to extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue", "... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed.", "I shall speak of it using the past tense, [may it rest in", "could argue it was a shopping question I guess because I was asking", "of these questions have been migrated. None have close votes. None even have", "a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for", "a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note", "of the comment was that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where", "making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my", "important comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based", "I'm not a member of and have no intention of signing up for.", "that it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking (as", "a set of well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages to extract", "the process). Hence this seemed to be an important comment. I did not", "you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer)", "my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see", "was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a", "useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git", "recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes*, 12 answers)", "good coffee machine for example. The other part of the comment was that", "have already spent too much time on this and other topics. I'm not", "the other that these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to", "had previously added discussion to my question specifying the reasons why a generic", "don't know the process). Hence this seemed to be an important comment. I", "far from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly", "and far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on the", "1. [Software to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11", "upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative", "to many other questions. None of these questions have been migrated. None have", "entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching", "be an important comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before", "that one could make arguments that my question was doing X* or wasn't", "not a member of and have no intention of signing up for. Thus", "and it got migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this seemed", "generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I was looking for", "academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a", "Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes,", "... Was it ... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see", "arguments that my question was doing X or wasn't doing Y in the", "a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for", "not asking for one's favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings. It", "from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much time", "being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much time on", "I had previously added discussion to my question specifying the reasons why a", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18", "process). Hence this seemed to be an important comment. I did not know", "favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is", "[Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat", "I didn't really find anything. I mean I can see that one could", "was that it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking", "boat ... it needs a good coffee machine for example. The other part", "X or something. I would argue that my question was not asking for", "it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I went looking through", "really find anything. I mean I can see that one could make arguments", "question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up your own", "example. The other part of the comment was that it was a \"shopping", "question about boats a relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion to", "spent too much time on this and other topics. I'm not going to", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers)", "and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x',", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10", "StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ...", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one way or", "I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to", "generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X", "have comments along the lines of the ones I got on my question.", "recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat", "software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "to highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply", "software used in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of the", "that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and", "11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered", "question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of", "to not view moderation tools as nails for which you have the hammer,", "Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers)", "--- But okay, I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers", "tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data", "of boat ... it needs a good coffee machine for example. The other", "meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought", "question specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient,", "was asking for things. The last part of the comment was that it", "for one's favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings. It was looking", "for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a", "questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried", "along the lines of the ones I got on my question. --- Likewise", "recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2", "make a question about boats a relevant question. Now I had previously added", "of the comment was that it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand", "analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the", "I can put forward is the request to not view moderation tools as", "various software used in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of", "of what you thought of the question itself, all I can put forward", "between topics covered in academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3", "@EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was analogous to asking \"[What is", "was doing X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far from", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes,", "could argue that it was still a boat programming question since one could", "[Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers)", "question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until", "> Queries related to various software used in academia. Questions shall not address", "but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > > --- In", "(6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager)", "questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s)", "about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had", "just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use my question as", "looking for software packages to extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others", "upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool", "on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't", "question I guess because I was asking for things. The last part of", "I am not arguing one way or the other that these questions are", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18", "highly technical aspects of the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to", "of something or other. I dunno. Having come to the end of this", "up for. Thus I can no longer interact with it. It was migrated", "speak of it using the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly", "tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping.", "of my questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm", "longer interact with it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an", "put forward is the request to not view moderation tools as nails for", "One could argue that it was still a boat programming question since one", "a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up your own minds): 1.", "question was analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\"", "certain type of boat ... it needs a good coffee machine for example.", "The other part of the comment was that it was a \"shopping question\",", "I missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean I can see that", "I can see that one could make arguments that my question was doing", "course I'm biased, so make up your own minds): 1. [Software to use", "--- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I", "too much time on this and other topics. I'm not going to be", "to the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly", "4 upvotes (that I never had the chance to upvote). I shall speak", "was analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ...", "... I am not arguing one way or the other that these questions", "is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of the question itself,", "\"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that", "there is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to other questions", "paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I", "His comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to appear", "shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > > --- In any", "1. boat programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it;", "there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until later): > >", "figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6.", "a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite", "biased, so make up your own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating", "asking (as an academic) for your favourite x from a set of well-known", "make arguments that my question was doing X or wasn't doing Y in", "Thus I can no longer interact with it. It was migrated with about", "and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving", "Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming.", "(as an academic) for your favourite x from a set of well-known X", "in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is", "generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member of and", "can see that one could make arguments that my question was doing X", "these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight that the", "it helps give examples of something or other. I dunno. Having come to", "a shopping question I guess because I was asking for things. The last", "Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12", "[Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming.", "to see what I missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean I", "[may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward", "and why I was looking for something specific for academic papers. One could", "Hence this seemed to be an important comment. I did not know what", "that my question was not asking for one's favourite anything from a set", "\"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\";", "give examples of something or other. I dunno. Having come to the end", "to academia. > > > --- In any case, aside from being confused,", "was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and (I guess)", "topics from research papers. Others could argue it was a shopping question I", "afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this", "other questions. None of these questions have been migrated. None have close votes.", "in academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer)", "But okay, I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to", "maybe it helps give examples of something or other. I dunno. Having come", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers -", "(I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow", "my question was analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat for an", "when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "a set of well-known X or something. I would argue that my question", "X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut", "for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "okay, I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my", "with 4 upvotes (that I never had the chance to upvote). I shall", "None have close votes. None even have comments along the lines of the", "migrated. None have close votes. None even have comments along the lines of", "thought of the question itself, all I can put forward is the request", "question. But maybe it helps give examples of something or other. I dunno.", "which you have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common", "intention of signing up for. Thus I can no longer interact with it.", "that the reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many", "the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was analogous to", "favourite x from a set of well-known X or something. I would argue", "looking for something specific for academic papers. One could argue that it was", "1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted", "for this site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question was", "8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming.", "well-known X or something. I would argue that my question was not asking", "future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software", "upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper)", "for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software", "aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much", "on the site do. --- But okay, I tried to take as given", "for things. The last part of the comment was that it was relevant", "upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open", "but far from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions (including", "a comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some", "Now I had previously added discussion to my question specifying the reasons why", "Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful)", "to other questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I", "relevant to academia. > > > --- In any case, aside from being", "site do. --- But okay, I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit", "software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > > ---", "have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense ...", "--- In any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have", "collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "mean I can see that one could make arguments that my question was", "paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a", "be engaging on this question. But maybe it helps give examples of something", "5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes*, 12 answers) [Boat", "analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11.", "which there is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to other", "already spent too much time on this and other topics. I'm not going", "it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking (as an", "that it was still a boat programming question since one could argue why", "for software packages to extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others could", "shall speak of it using the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg).", "the argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about", "the chance to upvote). I shall speak of it using the past tense,", "3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19", "not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about),", "recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool for producing bibtex entries from", "10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes,", "am not arguing one way or the other that these questions are off-topic", "[Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of the question", "votes started to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't know", "view moderation tools as nails for which you have the hammer, and to", "would be insufficient, and why I was looking for something specific for academic", "other part of the comment was that it was a \"shopping question\", which", "\"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes", "question was doing X* or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far", "other questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly", "upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing", "one way or the other that these questions are off-topic for this site.", "PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation", "a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I went looking through [the", "Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one way or the other", "upvotes (that I never had the chance to upvote). I shall speak of", "here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was analogous to asking \"[What", "It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes", "searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do", "None even have comments along the lines of the ones I got on", "much time on this and other topics. I'm not going to be engaging", "dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to other questions on the site.", "research papers. Others could argue it was a shopping question I guess because", "seemed to be an important comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\"", "that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was", "something specific for academic papers. One could argue that it was still a", "missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean I can see that one", "another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question?", "recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software", "was not asking for one's favourite anything from a set of well-known anythings.", "a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close", "quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when", "this site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question was commented", "to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10.", "other. I dunno. Having come to the end of this long meta-question whose", "the request to not view moderation tools as nails for which you have", "these questions have been migrated. None have close votes. None even have comments", "an academic) for your favourite x from a set of well-known X or", "from a set of well-known X or something. I would argue that my", "of and have no intention of signing up for. Thus I can no", "data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "my questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not", "to upvote). I shall speak of it using the past tense, [may it", "nails for which you have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency", "could make arguments that my question was doing X or wasn't doing Y", "(that I never had the chance to upvote). I shall speak of it", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in", "previously added discussion to my question specifying the reasons why a generic tag", "of the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > >", "where I roughly tried to use my question as a yardstick (of course", "for which you have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and", "upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had the chance", "highly voted questions) on the site do. --- But okay, I tried to", "it ... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I", "something. I would argue that my question was not asking for one's favourite", "part of the comment was that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software", "from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on the site do.", "know the process). Hence this seemed to be an important comment. I did", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to", "have no intention of signing up for. Thus I can no longer interact", "things. The last part of the comment was that it was relevant to", "papers. Others could argue it was a shopping question I guess because I", "roughly tried to use my question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased,", "my question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up your", "was that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated.", "Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers - does", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool for producing", "shall not address highly technical aspects of the software but shall address features/issues", "reason(s) my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions.", "this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what", "on this and other topics. I'm not going to be engaging on this", "have been migrated. None have close votes. None even have comments along the", "the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1.", "None of these questions have been migrated. None have close votes. None even", "later): > > Queries related to various software used in academia. Questions shall", "is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is a dedicated", "it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it", "doing X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far from anything", "\"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ...", "irrespective of what you thought of the question itself, all I can put", "still a boat programming question since one could argue why a programmer needs", "request to not view moderation tools as nails for which you have the", "argue that it was still a boat programming question since one could argue", "I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't", "what I missed. I didn't really find anything. I mean I can see", "aspects of the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia. >", "you have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense", "to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "SE site. ... and apply it to other questions on the site. Here's", "examples of something or other. I dunno. Having come to the end of", "there an open source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6", "Was it ... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what", "a member of and have no intention of signing up for. Thus I", "is the request to not view moderation tools as nails for which you", "other questions (including highly voted questions) on the site do. --- But okay,", "the comment was that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it", "5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had the", "to my question specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would", "The last part of the comment was that it was relevant to another", "for. Thus I can no longer interact with it. It was migrated with", "signing up for. Thus I can no longer interact with it. It was", "the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for", "to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to", "recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1", "(which I didn't see until later): > > Queries related to various software", "the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other", "Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing one", "it was a shopping question I guess because I was asking for things.", "related to various software used in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical", "anything. I mean I can see that one could make arguments that my", "you thought of the question itself, all I can put forward is the", "akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question and", "\"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting", "I got on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which", "shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which", "papers. One could argue that it was still a boat programming question since", "could argue why a programmer needs a certain type of boat ... it", "tried to use my question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so", "notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "question itself, all I can put forward is the request to not view", "tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there", "after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it was a \"boat programming\"", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data", "seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of the question itself, all", "what you thought of the question itself, all I can put forward is", "far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on the site", "In any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already", "an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make", "Y in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far from anything", "papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software", "tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put", "a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ...", "do. --- But okay, I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises", "a good coffee machine for example. The other part of the comment was", "other that these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight", "[the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't really find anything. I", "in academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of the software but", "for your favourite x from a set of well-known X or something. I", "moderation tools as nails for which you have the hammer, and to moderate", "apply to many other questions. None of these questions have been migrated. None", "close votes. None even have comments along the lines of the ones I", "needs a good coffee machine for example. The other part of the comment", "use my question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up", "my question was commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None", "about boats a relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion to my", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find a", "it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and (I", "to my question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a", "it got migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this seemed to", "or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and", "confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much time on this", "forward in a comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment", "and to moderate with clarity, consistency and common sense ... and reluctance. Ciao!", "got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and", "the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after", "academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping.", "find anything. I mean I can see that one could make arguments that", "and (I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and it got migrated", "engaging on this question. But maybe it helps give examples of something or", "I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the", "[Software to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.)", "I understand is like asking (as an academic) for your favourite x from", "questions have been migrated. None have close votes. None even have comments along", "question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is", "Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ...", "site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\" question? ... Was", "guess because I was asking for things. The last part of the comment", "lines of the ones I got on my question. --- Likewise there's the", "it to other questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where", "putting forward that my question was analogous to asking \"[What is the best", "in a comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His comment got", "that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a relevant", "coffee machine for example. The other part of the comment was that it", "asking for things. The last part of the comment was that it was", "umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on the site do. --- But", "computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "see that one could make arguments that my question was doing X or", "It was looking for software packages to extract and visualise topics from research", "this and other topics. I'm not going to be engaging on this question.", "topics. I'm not going to be engaging on this question. But maybe it", "adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a relevant question.", "since one could argue why a programmer needs a certain type of boat", "through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to see what I missed. I didn't really find anything.", "this question. But maybe it helps give examples of something or other. I", "[Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat", "for academic papers. One could argue that it was still a boat programming", "Software recommendation.] 7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping.", "the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small,", "of the ones I got on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software))", "illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "small, irrespective of what you thought of the question itself, all I can", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable", "wasn't doing Y in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far", "question was not asking for one's favourite anything from a set of well-known", "questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper)", "on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12.", "got on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I", "recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat", "not going to be engaging on this question. But maybe it helps give", "3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not arguing", "data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "programming\" question. His comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started", "comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards", "a programmer needs a certain type of boat ... it needs a good", "> > Queries related to various software used in academia. Questions shall not", "answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes,", "guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I", "like I have already spent too much time on this and other topics.", "questions. None of these questions have been migrated. None have close votes. None", "specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and", "comment was that it was relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually", "upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 12. ... I am not", "no intention of signing up for. Thus I can no longer interact with", "other topics. I'm not going to be engaging on this question. But maybe", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords)", "referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member", "insufficient, and why I was looking for something specific for academic papers. One", "set of well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages to extract and", "so make up your own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters", "did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion", "[Is there an open source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs)", "Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2", "(2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you find", "question, akin to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question", "anythings. It was looking for software packages to extract and visualise topics from", "source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes, 1 answer)", "the reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why", "to asking \"[What is the best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument", "tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I was looking for something", "12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source", "answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on", "an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a relevant question. Now I", "one could argue why a programmer needs a certain type of boat ...", "it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request", "academia. Questions shall not address highly technical aspects of the software but shall", "an important comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but", "and visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue it was a shopping", "I never had the chance to upvote). I shall speak of it using", "was looking for software packages to extract and visualise topics from research papers.", "[migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site I'm not a member of and have no intention", "off-topic for this site. I'm trying to highlight that the reason(s) my question", "Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I went looking", "answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten notes for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference)", "I didn't see until later): > > Queries related to various software used", "understand is like asking (as an academic) for your favourite x from a", "of well-known X or something. I would argue that my question was not", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a", "I'm not going to be engaging on this question. But maybe it helps", "was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it was a", "why a programmer needs a certain type of boat ... it needs a", "use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming.", "forward is the request to not view moderation tools as nails for which", "an open source tool for producing bibtex entries from paper PDFs?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/15504/is-there-an-open-source-tool-for-producing-bibtex-entries-from-paper-pdfs) (6 upvotes,", "repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "12. ... I am not arguing one way or the other that these", "features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > > --- In any case, aside", "effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of the", "upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and it got", "question\", which I understand is like asking (as an academic) for your favourite", "anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions)", "the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic", "time on this and other topics. I'm not going to be engaging on", "something or other. I dunno. Having come to the end of this long", "But maybe it helps give examples of something or other. I dunno. Having", "set of well-known X or something. I would argue that my question was", "as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to a perfect", "some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to appear afterwards and it", "draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion to my question specifying the", "to extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue it was", "anything umpteen other questions (including highly voted questions) on the site do. ---", "question? ... Was it ... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask) to", "the site do. --- But okay, I tried to take as given the", "address features/issues highly relevant to academia. > > > --- In any case,", "for future reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5.", "appear afterwards and it got migrated somehow (I don't know the process). Hence", "Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it", "meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that", "part of the comment was that it was a \"shopping question\", which I", "tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin", "3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software: referencing text", "the comment was that it was a \"shopping question\", which I understand is", "to use my question as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make", "> --- In any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I", "(including highly voted questions) on the site do. --- But okay, I tried", "machine for example. The other part of the comment was that it was", "somehow (I don't know the process). Hence this seemed to be an important", "I tried to take as given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question,", "shopping question I guess because I was asking for things. The last part", "academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 2. [Mapping", "your favourite x from a set of well-known X or something. I would", "itself (which I didn't see until later): > > Queries related to various", "was putting forward that my question was analogous to asking \"[What is the", "going to be engaging on this question. But maybe it helps give examples", "put forward in a comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question. His", "[Shopping. Software recommendation.] 8. [Issue tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3", "I can no longer interact with it. It was migrated with about 5", "a dedicated SE site. ... and apply it to other questions on the", "question? ... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I", "2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for", "such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools", "question since one could argue why a programmer needs a certain type of", "keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 10. [Do you", "packages to extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue it", "it needs a good coffee machine for example. The other part of the", "recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes, 3", "I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent too much time on this and", "(of course I'm biased, so make up your own minds): 1. [Software to", "all I can put forward is the request to not view moderation tools", "and apply it to other questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick", "reasons why a generic tag cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I", "an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never had the chance to upvote).", "forward that my question was analogous to asking \"[What is the best boat", "cloud generator would be insufficient, and why I was looking for something specific", "is like asking (as an academic) for your favourite x from a set", "type of boat ... it needs a good coffee machine for example. The", "ones I got on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself", "site. ... and apply it to other questions on the site. Here's just", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing)", "end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly vanishingly small, irrespective", "on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was analogous", "a site I'm not a member of and have no intention of signing", "3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming.", "the ones I got on my question. --- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag", "software request for which there is a dedicated SE site. ... and apply", "up your own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters for academic", "it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in", "this seemed to be an important comment. I did not know what \"boat", "that my question was doing X or wasn't doing Y in the FAQ", "organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4.", "Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers)", "in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment", "academics\" after it; 2. shopping: \"my favourite X is x', what's yours?\"; 3.", "X is x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is a", "your own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences)", "to a perfect storm: 1. boat programming: making a generic question and sticking", "with it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer with", "programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw illustrative figures in tables](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1095/software-to-draw-illustrative-figures-in-papers) (57", "from a set of well-known anythings. It was looking for software packages to", "votes. None even have comments along the lines of the ones I got", "can no longer interact with it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes", "I was looking for something specific for academic papers. One could argue that", "from research papers. Others could argue it was a shopping question I guess", "posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "[Do you find a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1", "--- Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until later):", "vanishingly small, irrespective of what you thought of the question itself, all I", "never had the chance to upvote). I shall speak of it using the", "academic papers. One could argue that it was still a boat programming question", "[Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool for", "own minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28", "technical aspects of the software but shall address features/issues highly relevant to academia.", "as nails for which you have the hammer, and to moderate with clarity,", "[Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration on a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5253/internet-git-repository-for-collaboration-on-a-paper) (18 upvotes,", "was still a boat programming question since one could argue why a programmer", "(19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9. [Note taking software:", "see until later): > > Queries related to various software used in academia.", "interact with it. It was migrated with about 5 upvotes and an answer", "had the chance to upvote). I shall speak of it using the past", "for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat programming. Shopping.", "[Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2", "(57 upvotes, 12 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an", "programming question since one could argue why a programmer needs a certain type", "apply it to other questions on the site. Here's just some (not-so-)quick examples", "extract and visualise topics from research papers. Others could argue it was a", "[Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers - does such a tool", "a question about boats a relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion", "relevant to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat", "taking software: referencing text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming.", "a \"shopping question\", which I understand is like asking (as an academic) for", "One of my questions—[Topical tag cloud generator for researchers/academics](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21005)—was [migrated](https://softwarerecs.stackexchange.com/questions/4160/topical-tag-cloud-generator-for-researchers-academics) to a site", "Likewise there's the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until later): >", "voted questions) on the site do. --- But okay, I tried to take", "to another StackExchange site—Software Recommendations—where it eventually migrated. Was it a \"boat programming\"", "migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it was a \"boat", "question. His comment got some upvotes and (I guess) close votes started to", "of signing up for. Thus I can no longer interact with it. It", "needs a certain type of boat ... it needs a good coffee machine", "what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is a dedicated SE site.", "@EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it was a \"boat programming\" question.", "because I was asking for things. The last part of the comment was", "3. software request** for which there is a dedicated SE site. ... and", "processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes, 2 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 4. [Saving handwritten", "be insufficient, and why I was looking for something specific for academic papers.", "didn't really find anything. I mean I can see that one could make", "commented on/voted to close/migrated apply to many other questions. None of these questions", "answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and processing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/17495/tools-for-data-organising-and-processing) (5 upvotes,", "for something specific for academic papers. One could argue that it was still", "1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for collaboration", "tracking when writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software", "text to searchable keywords](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/12761/note-taking-software-referencing-text-to-searchable-keywords) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "like asking (as an academic) for your favourite x from a set of", "my question was not asking for one's favourite anything from a set of", "yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up your own minds): 1. [Software", "\"for an academic\" doesn't make a question about boats a relevant question. Now", "topics covered in academic papers - does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes,", "it using the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was", "... the argument being that adding \"for an academic\" doesn't make a question", "boats a relevant question. Now I had previously added discussion to my question", "a boat programming question since one could argue why a programmer needs a", "come to the end of this long meta-question whose effort–reward ratio is seemingly", "and have no intention of signing up for. Thus I can no longer", "upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet Git repository for", "as a yardstick (of course I'm biased, so make up your own minds):", "... Was it a \"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I went", "[based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers was putting forward that my question was", "Software recommendation.] 6. [Is there an open source tool for producing bibtex entries", "know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on the discussion here](https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/14470/what-is-the-boat-programming-meme-about), @EnergyNumbers", "it was migrated after @EnergyNumbers put forward in a comment that it was", "a computer-assisted qualitative data analysis tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming.", "questions) on the site do. --- But okay, I tried to take as", "any case, aside from being confused, I [feel](http://www.quickmeme.com/img/f9/f9aa925d576d3e1459ce99e1120c4ca290e05ecd9e68376e8d6494f3f5137eaf.jpg) like I have already spent", "recommendation.] 2. [Mapping connections between topics covered in academic papers - does such", "x from a set of well-known X or something. I would argue that", "given the explicit/implicit premises applied to my question, akin to a perfect storm:", "in the FAQ but far from anything clear-cut and far from anything umpteen", "added discussion to my question specifying the reasons why a generic tag cloud", "generator would be insufficient, and why I was looking for something specific for", "tool useful?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/9654/do-you-find-a-computer-assisted-qualitative-data-analysis-tool-useful) (2 upvotes, 1 answer) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 11. [Internet", "to a site I'm not a member of and have no intention of", "some (not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use my question as a", "x', what's yours?\"; 3. software request for which there is a dedicated SE", "best boat for an academic](http://donmillereducation.com/journal/wp-content/uploads/2014/02/we-re-gonna-need-a-bigger-boat.jpg)\" ... the argument being that adding \"for an", "examples where I roughly tried to use my question as a yardstick (of", "to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes, 11 answers.) [Boat", "programming: making a generic question and sticking \"for academics\" after it; 2. shopping:", "(not-so-)quick examples where I roughly tried to use my question as a yardstick", "the ([`software`](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/software)) tag itself (which I didn't see until later): > > Queries", "I mean I can see that one could make arguments that my question", "7. [Searching for a quotation manager](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5246/searching-for-a-quotation-manager) (10 upvotes, 3 answers) [Shopping. Software recommendation.]", "with about 5 upvotes and an answer with 4 upvotes (that I never", "I'm biased, so make up your own minds): 1. [Software to use for", "not arguing one way or the other that these questions are off-topic for", "or the other that these questions are off-topic for this site. I'm trying", "using the past tense, [may it rest in peace](http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-QsJRwCx_vvQ/UWQcu_uPb8I/AAAAAAAATJs/THt3Xmfz17A/s1600/Dead+parrot+2.jpg). Seemingly it was migrated", "does such a tool exist?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/18399/mapping-connections-between-topics-covered-in-academic-papers-does-such-a-tool) (3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3.", "itself, all I can put forward is the request to not view moderation", "minds): 1. [Software to use for creating posters for academic conferences?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1880/software-to-use-for-creating-posters-for-academic-conferences) (28 upvotes,", "\"shopping\" question? ... Was it ... --- I went looking through [the FAQ](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask)", "after it; 2. shopping*: \"my favourite X* is x', what's yours?\"; 3. **software", "reference](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/7242/saving-handwritten-notes-for-future-reference) (18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to", "was a shopping question I guess because I was asking for things. The", "not view moderation tools as nails for which you have the hammer, and", "writing a paper](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/5553/issue-tracking-when-writing-a-paper) (19 upvotes, 3 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 9.", "the lines of the ones I got on my question. --- Likewise there's", "comment. I did not know what \"boat programming\" meant before but [based on", "(3 upvotes, 1 answer) [Shopping. Software recommendation.] 3. [Tools for data organising and", "(18 upvotes, 9 answers) [Boat programming. Shopping. Software recommendation.] 5. [Software to draw" ]
[ "our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how", "the question at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution", "is fair or ethical, or wise for that matter. I like the question,", "do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how it's done in", "how it's done in France, and has very little reference to it is", "providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as", "on SE sites, this type of question is a bad fit. I have", "is practically asking whether or not a particular scheme used at his/her school", "this is ethical? Is this a wise way to deal with cheating? >", "in France, and has very little reference to it is fair or ethical,", "opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question at hand but instead providing", "mine): > > Do you think* this is ethical? Is this a wise", "example, focuses on how it's done in France, and has very little reference", "of feedback. As I don't want to go on a downvote spree based", "this a wise way to deal with cheating? > > > Not so", "it's done in France, and has very little reference to it is fair", "little reference to it is fair or ethical, or wise for that matter.", "very little reference to it is fair or ethical, or wise for that", "whether or not a particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically", "reference to it is fair or ethical, or wise for that matter. I", "is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis mine): > >", "wise for that matter. I like the question, per se, but as I", "want to go on a downvote spree based on a hunch I would", "practically asking whether or not a particular scheme used at his/her school is", "focuses on how it's done in France, and has very little reference to", "question, per se, but as I understand the scope and modus operandi here", "says (emphasis mine): > > Do you *think* this is ethical? Is this", "on a hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion on the matter.", "deal with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated,", "per se, but as I understand the scope and modus operandi here on", "As I don't want to go on a downvote spree based on a", "a hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion on the matter. Opinions?", "but haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I don't want", "on how it's done in France, and has very little reference to it", "I like the question, per se, but as I understand the scope and", "[before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I don't", "even answering the question at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at", "to go on a downvote spree based on a hunch I would like", "to it is fair or ethical, or wise for that matter. I like", "hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This", "whole lot of feedback. As I don't want to go on a downvote", "> Do you think* this is ethical? Is this a wise way to", "with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and", "Is this a wise way to deal with cheating? > > > Not", "at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis", "is ethical? Is this a wise way to deal with cheating? > >", "*think* this is ethical? Is this a wise way to deal with cheating?", "fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do", "we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how it's done", "instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just", "(i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses", "but as I understand the scope and modus operandi* here on SE sites,", "(emphasis mine): > > Do you *think* this is ethical? Is this a", "a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten", "concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how it's done in France, and", "I understand the scope and modus operandi here on SE sites, this type", "go on a downvote spree based on a hunch I would like to", "are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question at hand but instead", "similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As", "a whole lot of feedback. As I don't want to go on a", "used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says", "> Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering", "here is practically asking whether or not a particular scheme used at his/her", "type of question is a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus),", "scope and modus operandi here on SE sites, this type of question is", "se, but as I understand the scope and modus operandi* here on SE", "on a downvote spree based on a hunch I would like to get", "raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback.", "it is fair or ethical, or wise for that matter. I like the", "or not a particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the", "the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question at hand", "lot of feedback. As I don't want to go on a downvote spree", "France, and has very little reference to it is fair or ethical, or", "the question, per se, but as I understand the scope and modus operandi", "Do you *think* this is ethical? Is this a wise way to deal", "you *think* this is ethical? Is this a wise way to deal with", "wise way to deal with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the", "asking whether or not a particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical.", "here on SE sites, this type of question is a bad fit. I", "scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question", "the scope and modus operandi here on SE sites, this type of question", "I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot", "the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you *think* this is ethical?", "just as an example, focuses on how it's done in France, and has", "ethical, or wise for that matter. I like the question, per se, but", "question here is practically asking whether or not a particular scheme used at", "particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the", "at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\").", "and sometimes not even answering the question at hand but instead providing different", "question at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we", "is a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really", "sites, this type of question is a bad fit. I have raised similar", "\"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on", "different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an", "and has very little reference to it is fair or ethical, or wise", "or ethical, or wise for that matter. I like the question, per se,", "school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis mine): >", "answering the question at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our", "spree based on a hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion on", "like the question, per se, but as I understand the scope and modus", "has very little reference to it is fair or ethical, or wise for", "this type of question is a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns", "heart of the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you think* this", "and modus operandi here on SE sites, this type of question is a", "but instead providing different perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674),", "ethical? Is this a wise way to deal with cheating? > > >", "fair or ethical, or wise for that matter. I like the question, per", "modus operandi* here on SE sites, this type of question is a bad", "as I understand the scope and modus operandi here on SE sites, this", "done in France, and has very little reference to it is fair or", "that matter. I like the question, per se, but as I understand the", "as an example, focuses on how it's done in France, and has very", "or wise for that matter. I like the question, per se, but as", "understand the scope and modus operandi here on SE sites, this type of", "of question is a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but", "for that matter. I like the question, per se, but as I understand", "question is a bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't", "not even answering the question at hand but instead providing different perspective (i.e.", "really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I don't want to go", "operandi* here on SE sites, this type of question is a bad fit.", "the heart of the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you *think", "of the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you think* this is", "fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole", "to deal with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the answers are", "don't want to go on a downvote spree based on a hunch I", "> > Do you *think* this is ethical? Is this a wise way", "[This](https://academia.stackexchange.com/q/21095/5674) question here is practically asking whether or not a particular scheme used", "cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes", "so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question", "surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question at", "a particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of", "based on a hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion on the", "have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a whole lot of", "matter. I like the question, per se, but as I understand the scope", "I don't want to go on a downvote spree based on a hunch", "gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I don't want to go on", "not a particular scheme used at his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart", "way to deal with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly the answers", "institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how it's", "[This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example, focuses on how it's done in France,", "an example, focuses on how it's done in France, and has very little", "perspective (i.e. \"at our institution we do...\"). [This answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21100/5674), just as an example,", "a downvote spree based on a hunch I would like to get some", "Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you", "answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the question at hand but", "haven't really gotten a whole lot of feedback. As I don't want to", "a wise way to deal with cheating? > > > Not so surprisingly", "Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even answering the", "downvote spree based on a hunch I would like to get some feedback/discussion", "> > > Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not", "question says (emphasis mine): > > Do you think* this is ethical? Is", "sometimes not even answering the question at hand but instead providing different perspective", "bad fit. I have raised similar concerns [before](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/927/on-topic-within-scope-but-subjective-question-that-is-likely-to-generate-discus), but haven't really gotten a", "his/her school is fair/ethical. Specifically the heart of the question says (emphasis mine):", "SE sites, this type of question is a bad fit. I have raised", "> > Not so surprisingly the answers are opinionated, and sometimes not even", "feedback. As I don't want to go on a downvote spree based on" ]
[ "I can't find the question, but the process is as follows: 1. Is", "it should stay. (Whether it should be closed for other reasons is not", "for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in the mod chat", "while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one", "1. Is the question on-topic at your site? If yes, it should stay.", "stay. (Whether it should be closed for other reasons is not relevant to", "this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new question", "discussion recently over when to to migrate questions away from the site. A", "There has been much discussion recently over when to to migrate questions away", "no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a different site? If yes, then...", "for other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the", "a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed after", "handled via flags, a mod will see the flag and we can ask", "question on-topic at a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question", "phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this", "and we can ask the site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing", "question on meta anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable", "Mods will generally handle this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because", "(Whether it should be closed for other reasons is not relevant to migration.)", "Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or", "via flags, a mod will see the flag and we can ask the", "whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in the mod chat rooms,", "If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be closed for other reasons", "anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites.", "your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be closed for", "the question be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad,", "on-topic at your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be", "the criteria one should use to make that decision. I can't find the", "much discussion recently over when to to migrate questions away from the site.", "that decision. I can't find the question, but the process is as follows:", "questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic", "chat rooms, simply because posting a new question on meta anytime a potential", "a mod will see the flag and we can ask the site whether", "the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new question on meta anytime", "on meta anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for", "ask the site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that we use", "be handled via flags, a mod will see the flag and we can", "is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at", "flags, a mod will see the flag and we can ask the site", "the site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that we use this", "recently over when to to migrate questions away from the site. A while", "after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too", "comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled", "the question, but the process is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic", "meta anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both", "but the process is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your", "see the flag and we can ask the site whether they want it.", "follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your site? If yes, it should", "question on-topic at your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should", "found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use to", "closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased,", "a potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This", "2. Is the question on-topic at a different site? If yes, then... 3.", "relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a different", "mod will see the flag and we can ask the site whether they", "the process is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your site?", "detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in", "will generally handle this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting", "but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons.", "yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed after migration? Some questions are", "other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question", "meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use to make that decision. I", "back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should", "should stay. (Whether it should be closed for other reasons is not relevant", "If yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed after migration? Some questions", "when to to migrate questions away from the site. A while back, I", "closed for other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is", "to migrate questions away from the site. A while back, I found a", "use to make that decision. I can't find the question, but the process", "quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled via flags, a", "for both sites. This should be handled via flags, a mod will see", "new question on meta anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly become", "decision. I can't find the question, but the process is as follows: 1.", "I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use", "process is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your site? If", "broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will", "communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new question on", "would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled via flags,", "a new question on meta anytime a potential migration comes up would quickly", "it should be closed for other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If", "simply because posting a new question on meta anytime a potential migration comes", "handle this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new", "want it. So, I'm proposing that we use this as our template for", "to make that decision. I can't find the question, but the process is", "reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic", "been much discussion recently over when to to migrate questions away from the", "in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new question on meta", "is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your site? If yes,", "become unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled via flags, a mod", "up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled via", "the flag and we can ask the site whether they want it. So,", "a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use to make", "be closed for other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no... 2.", "make that decision. I can't find the question, but the process is as", "should be handled via flags, a mod will see the flag and we", "This should be handled via flags, a mod will see the flag and", "should use to make that decision. I can't find the question, but the", "flag and we can ask the site whether they want it. So, I'm", "to to migrate questions away from the site. A while back, I found", "the question on-topic at a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the", "migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed,", "are on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for", "as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at your site? If yes, it", "reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply", "too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods", "or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in the", "posting a new question on meta anytime a potential migration comes up would", "rooms, simply because posting a new question on meta anytime a potential migration", "site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed after migration? Some", "the site. A while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined", "should be closed for other reasons is not relevant to migration.) If no...", "sites. This should be handled via flags, a mod will see the flag", "from the site. A while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which", "generally handle this communication in the mod chat rooms, simply because posting a", "one should use to make that decision. I can't find the question, but", "has been much discussion recently over when to to migrate questions away from", "If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a different site? If yes,", "they want it. So, I'm proposing that we use this as our template", "potential migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should", "away from the site. A while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange", "Is the question on-topic at your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether", "migrate questions away from the site. A while back, I found a question", "site. A while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the", "or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally", "which outlined the criteria one should use to make that decision. I can't", "site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that we use this as", "question, but the process is as follows: 1. Is the question on-topic at", "questions away from the site. A while back, I found a question on", "at your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be closed", "be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or poorly", "outlined the criteria one should use to make that decision. I can't find", "Would the question be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too", "mod chat rooms, simply because posting a new question on meta anytime a", "because posting a new question on meta anytime a potential migration comes up", "we can ask the site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that", "both sites. This should be handled via flags, a mod will see the", "find the question, but the process is as follows: 1. Is the question", "on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use to make that decision.", "can't find the question, but the process is as follows: 1. Is the", "problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication in the mod", "A while back, I found a question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria", "site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be closed for other", "question be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but too broad, or", "whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that we use this as our", "poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle", "migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a different site? If", "on-topic at a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question be", "yes, it should stay. (Whether it should be closed for other reasons is", "at a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed", "3. Would the question be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic but", "not relevant to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a", "too detailed, or problematic for whatever reasons. Mods will generally handle this communication", "can ask the site whether they want it. So, I'm proposing that we", "unmanageable for both sites. This should be handled via flags, a mod will", "over when to to migrate questions away from the site. A while back,", "to migration.) If no... 2. Is the question on-topic at a different site?", "then... 3. Would the question be closed after migration? Some questions are on-topic", "question on meta.stackexchange which outlined the criteria one should use to make that", "Is the question on-topic at a different site? If yes, then... 3. Would", "different site? If yes, then... 3. Would the question be closed after migration?", "migration comes up would quickly become unmanageable for both sites. This should be", "on-topic but too broad, or poorly phrased, too detailed, or problematic for whatever", "it. So, I'm proposing that we use this as our template for migration.", "criteria one should use to make that decision. I can't find the question,", "the question on-topic at your site? If yes, it should stay. (Whether it", "will see the flag and we can ask the site whether they want" ]
[ "> > > which seems rather rude and offensive to me. The flag", "> > known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather rude", "as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems", "> known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather rude and", "flagged a [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as a > > known,", "known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather rude and offensive", "I flagged a [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as a > >", "rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather rude and offensive to", "> > which seems rather rude and offensive to me. The flag was", "seems rather rude and offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have", "rude and offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have any insight", "> which seems rather rude and offensive to me. The flag was declined.", "feminist > > > which seems rather rude and offensive to me. The", "a [comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as a > > known, rabid", "[comment](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/1363/women-in-academia/21219#comment44343_21219) because it referred to somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating", "referred to somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist > >", "it referred to somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist >", "male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather rude and offensive to me.", "and offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have any insight on", "because it referred to somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist", "to somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist > > >", "rather rude and offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have any", "which seems rather rude and offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody", "a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which seems rather", "offensive to me. The flag was declined. Anybody have any insight on this?", "somebody as a > > known, rabid male-hating feminist > > > which" ]
[ "than other SE sites. There appears to be a lot more spacing above", "each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different", "scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as if it is", "this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on", "and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia", "an oversight or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also", "SE sites. There appears to be a lot more spacing above and below", "below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is", "spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a", "than most (all?) SE sites in regard to the question listing? I find", "if it is an oversight or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT:", "lot more spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is", "a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in", "of emptiness makes me feel as if it is an oversight or a", "Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746)", "scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me", "is different than most (all?) SE sites in regard to the question listing?", "emptiness makes me feel as if it is an oversight or a bug.", "there a reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites in regard", "The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as if it is an", "versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE", "the question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE sites.", "more difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of", "The entries in the question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than", "different than most (all?) SE sites in regard to the question listing? I", "sites in regard to the question listing? I find it more difficult to", "amount of emptiness makes me feel as if it is an oversight or", "difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness", "reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites in regard to the", "to scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes", "it more difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount", "entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different than most", "bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in a", "I find it more difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling. The", "as if it is an oversight or a bug. Can this be changed???", "oversight or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked", "more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as if it", "bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears to be a lot more", "Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites in regard to the question", "listing? I find it more difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling.", "most (all?) SE sites in regard to the question listing? I find it", "is an oversight or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was", "(all?) SE sites in regard to the question listing? I find it more", "listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears", "This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the original design post.", "Is there a reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites in", "more spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there", "changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the original", "me feel as if it is an oversight or a bug. Can this", "SE sites in regard to the question listing? I find it more difficult", "in the question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE", "There appears to be a lot more spacing above and below each question", "or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for", "vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as if it is an oversight", "makes me feel as if it is an oversight or a bug. Can", "a lot more spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png)", "question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different than", "entries in the question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other", "are much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears to be a", "requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as if", "the question listing? I find it more difficult to scan and it requires", "SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites", "vertically than other SE sites. There appears to be a lot more spacing", "be a lot more spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus", "above and below each question entry. ![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason", "a reason Academia is different than most (all?) SE sites in regard to", "to the question listing? I find it more difficult to scan and it", "find it more difficult to scan and it requires more scrolling. The vast", "much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears to be a lot", "it is an oversight or a bug. Can this be changed??? EDIT: This", "regard to the question listing? I find it more difficult to scan and", "question listing? I find it more difficult to scan and it requires more", "appears to be a lot more spacing above and below each question entry.", "![Academia versus SO](https://i.stack.imgur.com/efHUk.png) Is there a reason Academia is different than most (all?)", "question listing on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There", "on Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears to", "and it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel", "it requires more scrolling. The vast amount of emptiness makes me feel as", "be changed??? EDIT: This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the", "to be a lot more spacing above and below each question entry. ![Academia", "EDIT: This was also asked for in a [reply](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/a/910/746) on the original design", "in regard to the question listing? I find it more difficult to scan", "sites. There appears to be a lot more spacing above and below each", "Academia.SE are much bigger vertically than other SE sites. There appears to be", "feel as if it is an oversight or a bug. Can this be", "other SE sites. There appears to be a lot more spacing above and" ]
[ "questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different", "am however a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the", "academic, I am however a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions", "regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar.", "civility in real life academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There are", "go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite", "at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards", "protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there", "numbers from the SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a search for", "it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there", "of these questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" ", " \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why", "in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these questions go", "an academic, I am however a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE", "It seems that many of these questions go something like: * \"Is it", "a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\"", "it normal to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette and protocol type", "to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for civility in real life", "There are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665 results. Roughly", "I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that", "questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these questions", "real life academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There are 4614 total", "not an academic, I am however a regular SE user. I see several", "the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these questions go something", "there radically different standards for civility in real life academia? Some numbers from", "I am however a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in", "questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it", "sidebar. It seems that many of these questions go something like: * \"Is", "\"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette and protocol", "normal to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette and protocol type questions", "so many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to", "* \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette and", "it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it", "are there radically different standards for civility in real life academia? Some numbers", "Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for", "this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for civility in", "life academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There are 4614 total questions,", "to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to...", "and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are", "the SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns", "like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\"", "SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665", "or are there radically different standards for civility in real life academia? Some", "questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these questions go something like: ", "API. There are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665 results.", "SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It", "type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically", "several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of", " \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" ", "something like: \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to...", "standards for civility in real life academia? Some numbers from the SE API.", "seems that many of these questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate", "in real life academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There are 4614", "are there so many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this", "polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there so", "these questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is", "etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE or", "see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many", "many of these questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to... ?\"", "for civility in real life academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There", "am not an academic, I am however a regular SE user. I see", "Some numbers from the SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a search", "user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems", "that many of these questions go something like: * \"Is it appropriate to...", "there so many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique", "Academia.SE questions in the \"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these", "\"hot questions\" sidebar. It seems that many of these questions go something like:", "are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\" returns 665 results. Roughly 14%.", "academia? Some numbers from the SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a", "\"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are", "?\" Why are there so many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE?", "from the SE API. There are 4614 total questions, a search for \"appropriate\"", "Is this unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for civility", "appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal", "?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\"", "Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for civility in real life academia?", "many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is this unique to Academia.SE", "to... ?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there so many", "I am not an academic, I am however a regular SE user. I", "different standards for civility in real life academia? Some numbers from the SE", "however a regular SE user. I see several Academia.SE questions in the \"hot", "to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette and protocol type questions at", "Why are there so many etiquette and protocol type questions at Academia.SE? Is", "radically different standards for civility in real life academia? Some numbers from the", "?\" * \"Is it normal to... ?\" Why are there so many etiquette", "unique to Academia.SE or are there radically different standards for civility in real", "\"Is it appropriate to... ?\" * \"Is it polite to... ?\" * \"Is" ]
[ "Since graduation, I've observed that quite often, the number of tasks in the", "the number of tasks in the review list is not consistent. For instance,", "tasks in the review list is not consistent. For instance, in the attached", "to review, while I can't see any to actually review. I've tried to", "any to actually review. I've tried to open the site in a new", "does not last, and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would", "after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a refresh", "graduation, I've observed that quite often, the number of tasks in the review", "tasks to review, while I can't see any to actually review. I've tried", "bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't see any to actually", "actually review. I've tried to open the site in a new browser, to", "a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a refresh problem.", "review. I've tried to open the site in a new browser, to avoid", "often, the number of tasks in the review list is not consistent. For", "tried to open the site in a new browser, to avoid any cache", "the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't see any", "not last, and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem", "attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't", "cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour does not", "can't see any to actually review. I've tried to open the site in", "while I can't see any to actually review. I've tried to open the", "last, and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like", "number of tasks in the review list is not consistent. For instance, in", "avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour", "instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review,", "I've tried to open the site in a new browser, to avoid any", "the same. Note that this behaviour does not last, and after a while,", "new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note", "any cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour does", "in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while", "this behaviour does not last, and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively,", "problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour does not last, and after", "issue, the problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour does not last,", "consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks", "I can't see any to actually review. I've tried to open the site", "is not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays", "I've observed that quite often, the number of tasks in the review list", "review, while I can't see any to actually review. I've tried to open", "in a new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the", "Note that this behaviour does not last, and after a while, the number", "the review list is not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the", "see any to actually review. I've tried to open the site in a", "open the site in a new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the", "remains the same. Note that this behaviour does not last, and after a", "while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a refresh problem. ![screenshot](https://i.stack.imgur.com/XEisw.png)", "displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't see any to actually review.", "that this behaviour does not last, and after a while, the number disappears.", "same. Note that this behaviour does not last, and after a while, the", "review list is not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu", "screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't see", "in the review list is not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot,", "3 tasks to review, while I can't see any to actually review. I've", "browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note that", "list is not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar", "observed that quite often, the number of tasks in the review list is", "of tasks in the review list is not consistent. For instance, in the", "top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I can't see any to", "to open the site in a new browser, to avoid any cache issue,", "a new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the same.", "site in a new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains", "to actually review. I've tried to open the site in a new browser,", "and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it would seem like a", "For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to", "the site in a new browser, to avoid any cache issue, the problem", "behaviour does not last, and after a while, the number disappears. Intuitively, it", "to avoid any cache issue, the problem remains the same. Note that this", "the problem remains the same. Note that this behaviour does not last, and", "that quite often, the number of tasks in the review list is not", "quite often, the number of tasks in the review list is not consistent.", "not consistent. For instance, in the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3", "the attached screenshot, the top-menu bar displays 3 tasks to review, while I" ]
[ "in calm words if there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO +", "difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive* judgement that it", "concern that we need to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern", "attention to this question: [Is it bad for one's future career prospects if", "all times; rudeness will not be tolerated > > > * but even", "conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > > Civility", "does not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually", "does not deserve the grade:** This is an extremely serious judgment. In a", "huge difference between stating that the supervision is the problem and that problems", "whether the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the", "the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > > Civility is required at", "as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student", "This is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could not", "opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this statement is", "bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether", "knows) to update the working title of the thesis to a final title,", "are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment", "be long-form, and thus may have considerably more content than can be judged", "the comments beeing rude. + There is at least one rather obvious and", "on the available information. This is not only rude, but it is IMHO", "reasonable task towards the end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty.", "there is a huge difference between stating that the supervision is the problem", "to draw your attention to this question: [Is it bad for one's future", "for one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My", "a student is so absorbed in his work that it all seems obvious,", "(e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer which I cannot", "in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in", "broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions:", "a cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs real name and the", "not deserve the grade:** This is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory", "obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to the OP's question:", "@badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk. Don't run either](https://academia.meta.stackexchange.com/questions/975/dont-walk-dont-run-either)", "Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the thesis, and", "the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the institution,", "after asking (besides the fact that the thesis may be long-form, and thus", "two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as", "[...] would be called outcome of a good literature survey at my university.\"", "supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between stating that", "the underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves better is related to", "more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the", "based on the available information. This is not only rude, but it is", "I actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments", "of loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome of a good literature", "but in fact we don't even know whether the papers are just loosely", "not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think", "don't even know whether the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will", "it all seems obvious, and the student does not recognize how advanced his", "the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task", "The supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't need to tell because", "I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP has", "months from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly", "one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to the", "his work really is.\" I think the underlying concern that we need to", "perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal", "serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs real", "be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask for", "outcome of a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or may", "states \"My question does not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" +", "towards the end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I", "with their supervisor, and also to state in calm words if there is", "we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) >", "to a final title, and the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which", "but even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also", "future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is", "judgement that it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a", "e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a", "in the comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for which I do", "title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the thesis,", "that problems with the supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the thesis", "so absorbed in his work that it all seems obvious, and the student", "about clarification whether the OP has discussed the question with their supervisor, and", "cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs real name and the papers.", "stating that the supervision is the problem* and that problems with the supervision", "bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if the OP explicitly states", "\"It will depend on the institution, but at the institution I work, you", "related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk. Don't", "years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r", "nice.** > > > Civility is required at all times; rudeness will not", "supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't need to tell because the", "+ There is at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that", "bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think", "of @krammer which I cannot link) for which I do not see proper", "not be two months from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again,", "be tolerated > > > * but even more important, I see harsh", "concern is that we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly,", "literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or may not be true, but", "OPs real name and the papers. Noone else so far stated that they", "important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments", "my university.\" (Which may or may not be true, but in fact we", "of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if the OP explicitly", "this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the", "an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could not uncover the", "\"My question does not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And", "be two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g.", "to state in calm words if there is a smell of bad supervisor,", "don't see objective grounds for the exclusive judgement that it is the supervision", "reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed the question with", "judgment. In a cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs real name", "good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or may not be true,", "the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between stating", "> Be nice. > > > Civility is required at all times; rudeness", "seems obvious, and the student does not recognize how advanced his work really", "it should be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question does not", "on the institution, but at the institution I work, you would not be", "perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive* judgement", "could not uncover the OPs real name and the papers. Noone else so", "also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I", "there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected", "[this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer which I cannot link)", "question does not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I", "OP knows) to update the working title of the thesis to a final", "deserve the grade:** This is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search,", "at my university.\" (Which may or may not be true, but in fact", "bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between stating that the supervision is", "not be true, but in fact we don't even know whether the papers", "not uncover the OPs real name and the papers. Noone else so far", "state in calm words if there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO", "the OP's question: The supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't need", "does not recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I think the underlying", "working title of the thesis to a final title, and the OP has", "completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible", "question with their supervisor, and also to state in calm words if there", "is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between", "that the thesis may be long-form, and thus may have considerably more content", "+ it should be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question does", "* the thesis does not deserve the grade: This is an extremely serious", "told the OP (or didn't need to tell because the OP knows) to", "is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision:", "final title, and the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is a", "even know whether the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend", "content than can be judged by us right now). Yet we have statements", "student is so absorbed in his work that it all seems obvious, and", "see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer", "that could have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may have told", "even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in", "it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * *bad", "Noone else so far stated that they actually know the papers, not even", "proper grounds based on the available information. This is not only rude, but", "discussed the question with their supervisor, and also to state in calm words", "statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome of", "ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for", "Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be", "lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may have told the OP (or", "words if there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should", "and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the", "judged by us right now). Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely", "we have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be called", "underlying reason. * the thesis does not deserve the grade: This is an", "may have considerably more content than can be judged by us right now).", "reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There is at least one rather", "may or may not be true, but in fact we don't even know", "underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's", "need to tell because the OP knows) to update the working title of", "your attention to this question: [Is it bad for one's future career prospects", "exclusive judgement that it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is", "title of the thesis to a final title, and the OP has trouble", "the student does not recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I think", "(besides the fact that the thesis may be long-form, and thus may have", "institution, but at the institution I work, you would not be two months", "this question: [Is it bad for one's future career prospects if the PhD", "connected papers [...] would be called outcome of a good literature survey at", "OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards", "only rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments", "papers. Noone else so far stated that they actually know the papers, not", "papers [...] would be called outcome of a good literature survey at my", "work that it all seems obvious, and the student does not recognize how", "absorbed in his work that it all seems obvious, and the student does", "pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so", "IMHO + it should be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question", "if the OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask for your opinion", "beeing rude. + There is at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless", "to this question: [Is it bad for one's future career prospects if the", "and thus may have considerably more content than can be judged by us", "asking (besides the fact that the thesis may be long-form, and thus may", "and also to state in calm words if there is a smell of", "will depend on the institution, but at the institution I work, you would", "judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask", "be true, but in fact we don't even know whether the papers are", "practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think it perfectly", "also in the comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for which I", "the exclusive judgement that it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there", "a huge difference between stating that the supervision is the problem and that", "the available information. This is not only rude, but it is IMHO also", "think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude.", "required at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated > > > ", "(or didn't need to tell because the OP knows) to update the working", "out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed", "have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome", "respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask for your", "formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of", "there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the", "that is bad. IMHO there is a huge difference between stating that the", "draw your attention to this question: [Is it bad for one's future career", "> Civility is required at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated >", "one possible underlying reason. * the thesis does not deserve the grade: This", "so far stated that they actually know the papers, not even after asking", "may not be true, but in fact we don't even know whether the", "@krammer which I cannot link) for which I do not see proper grounds", "supervision:** While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the", "I could not uncover the OPs real name and the papers. Noone else", "Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive* judgement that it is", "perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed the question", "> > Civility is required at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated", "clarification whether the OP has discussed the question with their supervisor, and also", "real name and the papers. Noone else so far stated that they actually", "far stated that they actually know the papers, not even after asking (besides", "thus may have considerably more content than can be judged by us right", "more content than can be judged by us right now). Yet we have", "has trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the", "> > Be nice. > > > Civility is required at all times;", "but at the institution I work, you would not be two months from", "their supervisor, and also to state in calm words if there is a", "serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > >", "the OP has discussed the question with their supervisor, and also to state", "the comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for which I do not", "we don't even know whether the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It", "Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > > Civility is required", "will not be tolerated > > > * but even more important, I", "that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. +", "it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed the", "jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. >", "supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the thesis does not deserve the", "of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective", "to ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed the question with their", "to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > >", "but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: ", "OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask for your opinion about my", "loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the institution, but at the institution", "it bad for one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is", "between stating that the supervision is the problem* and that problems with the", "Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in", "do not see proper grounds based on the available information. This is not", "my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up", "problems with the supervision is one possible underlying reason. * the thesis does", "task towards the end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus,", "is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could not uncover", "institution I work, you would not be two months from completion. You'd be", "question: [Is it bad for one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis", "grounds based on the available information. This is not only rude, but it", "the OP knows) to update the working title of the thesis to a", "the institution, but at the institution I work, you would not be two", "be called outcome of a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may", "for the exclusive** judgement that it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO", "work, you would not be two months from completion. You'd be two years", "to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his work that", "long-form, and thus may have considerably more content than can be judged by", "a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if the", "There is at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could", "a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There is at least", "is.\" I think the underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves better", "that we need to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with", "smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if the OP", "and the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable", "just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the institution, but at the", "IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While", "perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to", "bad for one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad)", "times; rudeness will not be tolerated > > > * but even more", "called outcome of a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or", "at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead", "that we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior)", "you would not be two months from completion. You'd be two years from", "thesis may be long-form, and thus may have considerably more content than can", "difference between stating that the supervision is the problem and that problems with", "survey at my university.\" (Which may or may not be true, but in", "career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that", "actually know the papers, not even after asking (besides the fact that the", "cannot link) for which I do not see proper grounds based on the", "the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds", "not even after asking (besides the fact that the thesis may be long-form,", "the fact that the thesis may be long-form, and thus may have considerably", "And I actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the", "for which I do not see proper grounds based on the available information.", "a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or may not be", "and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to the OP's question: The", "student does not recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I think the", "is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk.", "the OPs real name and the papers. Noone else so far stated that", "least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to", "title, and the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly", "the thesis does not deserve the grade:* This is an extremely serious judgment.", "not only rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2", "problem* and that problems with the supervision is one possible underlying reason. ", "answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his work that it all", "stated that they actually know the papers, not even after asking (besides the", "is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick at jumping to serious", "at jumping to serious conclusions: Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice.", "and \"It will depend on the institution, but at the institution I work,", "your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this statement", "be judged by us right now). Yet we have statements that \"set of", "for your opinion about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this", "quick at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be", "like to draw your attention to this question: [Is it bad for one's", "about my supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this statement is a", "considerably more content than can be judged by us right now). Yet we", "is so absorbed in his work that it all seems obvious, and the", "perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor", "Be nice.** > > > Civility is required at all times; rudeness will", "calm words if there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it", "the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his", "OP (or didn't need to tell because the OP knows) to update the", "because the OP knows) to update the working title of the thesis to", "the question with their supervisor, and also to state in calm words if", "really is.\" I think the underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves", "supervision is the problem and that problems with the supervision is one possible", "the OP (or didn't need to tell because the OP knows) to update", "OP's question: The supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't need to", "that they actually know the papers, not even after asking (besides the fact", "can be judged by us right now). Yet we have statements that \"set", "normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive* judgement that", "I think the underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves better is", "IMHO there is a huge difference between stating that the supervision is the", "> > > but even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g.", "possible* underlying reason. * the thesis does not deserve the grade: This is", "harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer which", "of the thesis to a final title, and the OP has trouble formulating", "may have told the OP (or didn't need to tell because the OP", "end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see", "university.\" (Which may or may not be true, but in fact we don't", "but also in the comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for which", "thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for", "topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick at jumping to", "work really is.\" I think the underlying concern that we need to behave", "Civility is required at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated > >", "> * but even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725)", "right now). Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...]", "behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\"", "supervisor.\" + And I actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction", "comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his work", "the supervision is the problem and that problems with the supervision is one", "\"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his work that it all seems", "whether the OP has discussed the question with their supervisor, and also to", "obvious, and the student does not recognize how advanced his work really is.\"", "name and the papers. Noone else so far stated that they actually know", "OP has discussed the question with their supervisor, and also to state in", "tell because the OP knows) to update the working title of the thesis", "search, I could not uncover the OPs real name and the papers. Noone", "in his work that it all seems obvious, and the student does not", "rudeness will not be tolerated > > > but even more important,", "have considerably more content than can be judged by us right now). Yet", "think the underlying concern that we need to behave ourselves better is related", "is that we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: * Firstly, the", "advanced his work really is.\" I think the underlying concern that we need", "uncover the OPs real name and the papers. Noone else so far stated", "would be called outcome of a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which", "this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There", "information. This is not only rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific", "the working title of the thesis to a final title, and the OP", "how advanced his work really is.\" I think the underlying concern that we", "(Which may or may not be true, but in fact we don't even", "harmless situation that could have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may", "else so far stated that they actually know the papers, not even after", "the thesis to a final title, and the OP has trouble formulating this", "know the papers, not even after asking (besides the fact that the thesis", "fact that the thesis may be long-form, and thus may have considerably more", "the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick", "supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My", "I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive* judgement that it is the", "to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't walk. Don't run", "and the student does not recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I", "be two months from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there", "> > * but even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this", "to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor", "and that problems with the supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the", "in fact we don't even know whether the papers are just loosely connected)", "rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > >", "us right now). Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers", "fact we don't even know whether the papers are just loosely connected) and", "depend on the institution, but at the institution I work, you would not", "explicitly states \"My question does not ask for your opinion about my supervisor.\"", "from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless", "ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed the question with their supervisor,", "is required at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated > > >", "is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be respected if", "scientific practice. The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think it", "with the supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the thesis does not", "if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather", "not recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I think the underlying concern", "are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the institution, but at", "papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on the institution, but", "tolerated > > > but even more important, I see harsh judgments", "to tell because the OP knows) to update the working title of the", "loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome of a good literature survey", "prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're", "better is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at [Don't", "has discussed the question with their supervisor, and also to state in calm", "true, but in fact we don't even know whether the papers are just", "[etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > > Civility is required at all", "which I do not see proper grounds based on the available information. This", "is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference between stating that the supervision", "all seems obvious, and the student does not recognize how advanced his work", "the end of the thesis, and a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't", "if there is a smell of bad supervisor, IMHO + it should be", "explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes,", "I do not see proper grounds based on the available information. This is", "which I cannot link) for which I do not see proper grounds based", "PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick at", "two months from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there are", "didn't need to tell because the OP knows) to update the working title", "This is not only rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice.", "harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's", "the institution I work, you would not be two months from completion. You'd", "supervisor, and also to state in calm words if there is a smell", "the papers, not even after asking (besides the fact that the thesis may", "now). Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would", "have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may have told the OP", "symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There is at least one", "and the papers. Noone else so far stated that they actually know the", "update the working title of the thesis to a final title, and the", "thesis to a final title, and the OP has trouble formulating this title.", "at the institution I work, you would not be two months from completion.", "by us right now). Yet we have statements that \"set of loosely connected", "should be respected if the OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask", "that it all seems obvious, and the student does not recognize how advanced", "not see proper grounds based on the available information. This is not only", "completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out", "possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725):", "papers, not even after asking (besides the fact that the thesis may be", "the problem* and that problems with the supervision is one possible underlying reason.", "the thesis may be long-form, and thus may have considerably more content than", "* bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification", "rude. + There is at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation", "judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of @krammer which I", "may be long-form, and thus may have considerably more content than can be", "from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations, e.g. as @adam.r pointed", "reason. * the thesis does not deserve the grade: This is an extremely", "situation that could have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may have", "@adam.r pointed out in the comment to [@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is", "is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There is at", "available information. This is not only rude, but it is IMHO also bad", "a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the thesis, and a perfectly", "thesis does not deserve the grade:** This is an extremely serious judgment. In", "> > > Civility is required at all times; rudeness will not be", "I cannot link) for which I do not see proper grounds based on", "at all times; rudeness will not be tolerated > > > * but", "statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing rude. + There is", "I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but also in the comments of", "the OP explicitly states \"My question does not ask for your opinion about", "is the problem and that problems with the supervision is one possible underlying", "2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable to", "could have lead to the OP's question: The supervisor may have told the", "+ And I actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of", "know whether the papers are just loosely connected) and \"It will depend on", "we need to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with the", "need to behave ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad", "than can be judged by us right now). Yet we have statements that", "is one possible underlying reason. * the thesis does not deserve the grade:", "also to state in calm words if there is a smell of bad", "rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The 2 judgments are:", "to the OP's question: The supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't", "one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern", "actually think that this statement is a symptom/follow-up reaction of the comments beeing", "comments of @krammer which I cannot link) for which I do not see", "are: * bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about", "The 2 judgments are: * bad supervision: While I think it perfectly reasonable", "trouble formulating this title. Which is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end", "the supervision is one possible underlying reason. * *the thesis does not deserve", "My concern is that we're rather quick at jumping to serious conclusions: ", "see proper grounds based on the available information. This is not only rude,", "\"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome of a good", "even after asking (besides the fact that the thesis may be long-form, and", "of a good literature survey at my university.\" (Which may or may not", "recognize how advanced his work really is.\" I think the underlying concern that", "thesis topic is broad?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/21888/is-it-bad-for-ones-future-career-prospects-if-the-phd-thesis-topic-is-broad) My concern is that we're rather quick at jumping", "a perfectly normal difficulty. Thus, I don't see objective grounds for the exclusive", "comments beeing rude. + There is at least one rather obvious and perfectly", "the grade:* This is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I", "In a cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs real name and", "I'd like to draw your attention to this question: [Is it bad for", "connected) and \"It will depend on the institution, but at the institution I", "of the comments beeing rude. + There is at least one rather obvious", "is at least one rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have", "see objective grounds for the exclusive judgement that it is the supervision that", "have told the OP (or didn't need to tell because the OP knows)", "question: The supervisor may have told the OP (or didn't need to tell", "grade: This is an extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could", "or may not be true, but in fact we don't even know whether", "a final title, and the OP has trouble formulating this title. Which is", "grounds for the exclusive** judgement that it is the supervision that is bad.", "is a huge difference between stating that the supervision is the problem* and", "that it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge", "I work, you would not be two months from completion. You'd be two", "the papers. Noone else so far stated that they actually know the papers,", "[@MHH's answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21904/725): \"Sometimes, a student is so absorbed in his work that it", "You'd be two years from completion.\" Again, there are perfectly harmless possible explanations,", "* Firstly, the [etiquette](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/behavior) > > Be nice. > > > Civility is", "While I think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP", "that the supervision is the problem and that problems with the supervision is", "that \"set of loosely connected papers [...] would be called outcome of a", "* but even more important, I see harsh judgments (e.g. [this answer](https://academia.stackexchange.com/a/21901/725) but", "it is the supervision that is bad.* IMHO there is a huge difference", "[Is it bad for one's future career prospects if the PhD thesis topic", "objective grounds for the exclusive judgement that it is the supervision that is", "not be tolerated > > > * but even more important, I see", "think it perfectly reasonable to ask about clarification whether the OP has discussed", "they actually know the papers, not even after asking (besides the fact that", "link) for which I do not see proper grounds based on the available", "is a perfectly reasonable task towards the end of the thesis, and a", "his work that it all seems obvious, and the student does not recognize", "extremely serious judgment. In a cursory search, I could not uncover the OPs", "rather obvious and perfectly harmless situation that could have lead to the OP's", "is not only rude, but it is IMHO also bad scientific practice. The", "to update the working title of the thesis to a final title, and", "ourselves better is related to @badroit's concern with the \"bad supervisor meme\" at", "would not be two months from completion. You'd be two years from completion.\"" ]
[ "topic and not a good fit for our site since it is mainly", "question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good fit for our site since", "fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think this question is", "think a great question for us would be one that focuses on how", "that focuses on how to go about changing a fundamental university policy that", "That said, it sounds like the Indian university system has some issues. I", "some issues. I think a great question for us would be one that", "the Indian university system has some issues. I think a great question for", "sounds like the Indian university system has some issues. I think a great", "a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think this question", "system has some issues. I think a great question for us would be", "it is mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian", "As it currently stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good", "focuses on how to go about changing a fundamental university policy that is", "to go about changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone", "for our site since it is mainly about legal issues. That said, it", "us would be one that focuses on how to go about changing a", "it sounds like the Indian university system has some issues. I think a", "question for us would be one that focuses on how to go about", "[this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good fit for our site", "changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think this", "has some issues. I think a great question for us would be one", "since it is mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds like the", "issues. I think a great question for us would be one that focuses", "for us would be one that focuses on how to go about changing", "mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian university system", "university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think this question is salvageable?", "is off topic and not a good fit for our site since it", "I think a great question for us would be one that focuses on", "issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian university system has some issues.", "university system has some issues. I think a great question for us would", "said, it sounds like the Indian university system has some issues. I think", "Indian university system has some issues. I think a great question for us", "great question for us would be one that focuses on how to go", "would be one that focuses on how to go about changing a fundamental", "it currently stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good fit", "how to go about changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does", "our site since it is mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds", "a good fit for our site since it is mainly about legal issues.", "one that focuses on how to go about changing a fundamental university policy", "site since it is mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds like", "on how to go about changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial.", "off topic and not a good fit for our site since it is", "not a good fit for our site since it is mainly about legal", "is mainly about legal issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian university", "a great question for us would be one that focuses on how to", "about legal issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian university system has", "good fit for our site since it is mainly about legal issues. That", "and not a good fit for our site since it is mainly about", "legal issues. That said, it sounds like the Indian university system has some", "like the Indian university system has some issues. I think a great question", "go about changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else", "fit for our site since it is mainly about legal issues. That said,", "currently stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good fit for", "stands [this question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/23897/challenge-the-caste-based-reservation-policy-system-in-supreme-court) is off topic and not a good fit for our", "about changing a fundamental university policy that is controversial. Does anyone else think", "be one that focuses on how to go about changing a fundamental university" ]
[ "on topic. To me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a", "professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question about how to deal", "question for us. Looking at the question itself, the OP seems to be", "sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly", "you is on topic. To me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination", "question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of", "by you is on topic. To me the two issues (dealing with sexual", "with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question", "Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is that", "was that she felt intimidated. A question about how to deal with a", "discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated.", "a great question for us. Looking at the question itself, the OP seems", "a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is that I don't see", "with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by you) are so", "of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\"", "professor who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I wanted the", "issue I see is that I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination.", "with a professor who feels intimated by you is on topic. To me", "200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question about how", "seems to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the professor is", "a professor who feels intimated by you is on topic. To me the", "intimated by you is on topic. To me the two issues (dealing with", "intimidated. A question about how to deal with a professor who feels intimated", "she felt intimidated. A question about how to deal with a professor who", "A question about how to deal with a professor who feels intimated by", "see is that I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's", "I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing", "and a professor who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I", "professor is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue", "the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated", "To me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who", "act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question for us.", "that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is that I", "there was sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again, that is", "that I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to", "deal with a professor who feels intimated by you is on topic. To", "discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that", "a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question", "seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to clarify the question?", "question is \"How should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems", "I found this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should a student act", "the question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts", "this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should a student act towards a", "a professor who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I wanted", "suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again,", "claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it", "since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is", "should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great", "towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question for us. Looking", "a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question for us. Looking at", "student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question for", "professor who feels intimated by you is on topic. To me the two", "\"How should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a", "is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is that I don't", "of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible", "for us. Looking at the question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting", "response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she", "the question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that there was sexual", "perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is that I don't see any", "itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because", "by you) are so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially since", "be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist.", "discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to clarify", "especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination.", "often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to clarify the", "discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer", "see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with", "clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual", "evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound", "two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by", "titular question is \"How should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This", "feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see is", "6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question about how to", "feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified", "to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt", "found this [question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should a student act towards", "[question](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24028/how-should-a-student-act-towards-a-prejudiced-instructor). The titular question is \"How should a student act towards a prejudiced", "was sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again, that is a", "The professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was", "are so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially since claims of", "topic. The issue I see is that I don't see any evidence of", "Looking at the question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that there", "professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that", "so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially since claims of sexual", "wanted the question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem like", "a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question about", "topic. To me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor", "seems like a great question for us. Looking at the question itself, the", "a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I see", "you) are so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially since claims", "instructor?\" This seems like a great question for us. Looking at the question", "discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine", "boxer was that she felt intimidated. A question about how to deal with", "OP seems to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the professor", "The titular question is \"How should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\"", "question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination", "sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional", "to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the professor is a", "question about how to deal with a professor who feels intimated by you", "I wanted the question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often seem", "the professor is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The", "is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic. The issue I", "feels intimated by you is on topic. To me the two issues (dealing", "sexual discrimination often seem like acts of sexual discrimination. Is it possible to", "that there was sexual discrimination because the professor is a feminist. Again, that", "(dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by you) are", "The issue I see is that I don't see any evidence of sexual", "is \"How should a student act towards a prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like", "fine topic. The issue I see is that I don't see any evidence", "that I wanted the question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination often", "great question for us. Looking at the question itself, the OP seems to", "because the professor is a feminist. Again, that is a perfectly fine topic.", "about how to deal with a professor who feels intimated by you is", "who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I wanted the question", "how to deal with a professor who feels intimated by you is on", "like a great question for us. Looking at the question itself, the OP", "issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by you)", "felt intimidated. A question about how to deal with a professor who feels", "us. Looking at the question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that", "at the question itself, the OP seems to be suggesting that there was", "I see is that I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The", "me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and a professor who feels", "prejudiced instructor?\" This seems like a great question for us. Looking at the", "intimidated by you) are so unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially", "the OP seems to be suggesting that there was sexual discrimination because the", "to deal with a professor who feels intimated by you is on topic.", "is that I don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response", "This seems like a great question for us. Looking at the question itself,", "sexual discrimination and a professor who feels intimidated by you) are so unrelated", "don't see any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades", "who feels intimated by you is on topic. To me the two issues", "that she felt intimidated. A question about how to deal with a professor", "grades with a 200-pound 6'3\" professional boxer was that she felt intimidated. A", "is on topic. To me the two issues (dealing with sexual discrimination and", "any evidence of sexual discrimination. The professor's response to discussing grades with a", "unrelated that I wanted the question clarified especially since claims of sexual discrimination" ]
[ "page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the question with their", "and two users who are not moderator's access) then they put the question", "because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long,", "[How to encourage researchers to make more use of online resources to improve", "hold or locking the questions should not happen immediately and this level of", "comment is impolite and this way moderators can be informed what other users", "Meta and the title of the question changed to [How to encourage researchers", "not happen immediately and this level of access should be decreased. Moderators should", "who are not moderator's access) then they put the question on hold. The", "to what they prefer or their emotions. Because of the level of access", "think so), it can be assumed that it is a Constructive Question because;", "(as users answered the question with their experiences); and is more than just", "what they like, they immediately put the question on hold. So, how the", "give minus mark to the question and use their access to put the", "on locking the questions should be limited and become dependent on a different", "* inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” > * tend to have", "a comment or question or they may not be. Moderators have that much", "lock a question should be revised, their access on locking the questions should", "moderator and they did not pay any attention to this comment. I do", "that a question is out of the policies of the site, put the", "based on the discussion made here on Meta and the title of the", "what happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic", "This is what happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks the question", "the question changed to [How to encourage researchers to make more use of", "The moderator put a comment that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask).", "> * invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion be", "more use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to", "right to express his opinion. In case of the questions posted on this", "each comment that the users tell that the question is broad, the comment", "read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire answers that", "much access that when they feel that a question is out of the", "to have long, not short, answers > * have a constructive, fair, and", "sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion be backed up with", "or three moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed more. I think", "and “how” > * tend to have long, not short, answers > ", "broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions:", "references > are more than just mindless social fun > > >", "be wrong and can be discussed more. I think that the way moderators", "I do not think so), it can be assumed that it is a", "can be either in favor of a comment or question or they may", "In this link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > > >", "emotions. Because of the level of access these guys have, when they find", "and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users who are not", "of the question changed to [How to encourage researchers to make more use", "is the decision of two or three moderator) may be wrong and can", "posted on this site, the opinions can be either in favor of a", "have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over", "to [How to encourage researchers to make more use of online resources to", "edit for being completed and come out of the hold. It is a", "not think that this question needs any edit for being completed and come", "question, two or three other moderators come and give minus mark to the", "way moderators lock a question should be revised, their access on locking the", "> > > When you read that question, If we consider and accept", "can be discussed more. I think that the way moderators lock a question", "putting the questions on hold or locking the questions should not happen immediately", "questions should be limited and become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they", "It is a complete question. This is what happens to the similar questions:", "have long, not short, answers (as some answers were discussed on the page);", "in conflict to the policies or what they like, they immediately put the", "answers (as some answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over", "express why they think that the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion", "encourage researchers to make more use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the);", "resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who talked", "they should be advised to be more polite to the users (regarding to", "is what happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks the question as", "have that much access that when they feel that a question is out", "the question on hold. But, this should happen in case that they find", "about that their decision (even it is the decision of two or three", "two or three moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed more. I", "had to be locked and put on a hold. I explained this to", "and use their access to put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks", "Every person has the right to express his opinion. In case of the", "put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even", "questions and comments. Every person has the right to express his opinion. In", "that much access that when they feel that a question is out of", "question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll and if some number", "subjective questions:** > > > * inspire answers that explain “why” and “how”", "insist that opinion be backed up with facts and references > * are", "not be. Moderators have that much access that when they feel that a", "in direct conflict to what they prefer or their emotions. Because of the", "question needs any edit for being completed and come out of the hold.", "tend to have long, not short, answers > * have a constructive, fair,", "their access on locking the questions should be limited and become dependent on", "clear; I am still not convinced by the behavior of the moderators who", "the question is broad, the comment is impolite and this way moderators can", "may make mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting the questions on", "the site, put the question on hold. But, this should happen in case", "career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who talked about the problem here", "(for instance, two moderators and two users who are not moderator's access) then", "thinks about that their decision (even it is the decision of two or", "and we all may make mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting", "the discussion made here on Meta and the title of the question changed", "to the people who talked about the problem here and made policies more", "the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are", "it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and", "of access these guys have, when they find a question either in conflict", "and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: >", "level of access should be decreased. Moderators should express why they think that", "the question as problematic question, two or three other moderators come and give", "question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this question is too", "site, the opinions can be either in favor of a comment or question", "of access should be decreased. Moderators should express why they think that the", "access these guys have, when they find a question either in conflict to", "that explain “why” and “how” > * tend to have long, not short,", "and if some number of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two", "on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the question", "I explained this to the moderator and they did not pay any attention", "read that question, If we consider and accept that the question is subjective", "short, answers > * have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > ", "moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every person has the right to", "But, this should happen in case that they find a question in direct", "> insist that opinion be backed up with facts and references >", "emotional decisions. We are all human and we all may make mistakes in", "come and give minus mark to the question and use their access to", "hold. But, this should happen in case that they find a question in", "to encourage researchers to make more use of online resources to improve their", "convinced by the behavior of the moderators who acted on that question. >", "and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all human and", "policies, put their opinion on poll and if some number of other users", "not moderator's access) then they put the question on hold. The site can", "put the question on hold. The site can even put some keys on", "pay any attention to this comment. I do not think that this question", "That is why I think the question has never had to be locked", "to the question and use their access to put the question on hold.", "social fun > > > When you read that question, If we consider", "improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who talked about the", "[a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this question is", "needs any edit for being completed and come out of the hold. It", "the comment is impolite and this way moderators can be informed what other", "It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long, not", "question. I am posting this because something like this happened to [a question", "Moderators should express why they think that the question conflicts the policies, put", "discussions:*** > > The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion", "on hold or locking the questions should not happen immediately and this level", "opinion. In case of the questions posted on this site, the opinions can", "locked and put on a hold. I explained this to the moderator and", "policies of the site, not in direct conflict to what they prefer or", "when they find a question either in conflict to the policies or what", "of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users", "When you read that question, If we consider and accept that the question", "> > * inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” > * tend", "put the question on hold. But, this should happen in case that they", "put some keys on each comment that the users tell that the question", "users tell that the question is broad, the comment is impolite and this", "a question in direct conflict to the policies of the site, not in", "about the problem here and made policies more clear; I am still not", "moderator's access) then they put the question on hold. The site can even", "should be advised to be more polite to the users (regarding to the", "problem here and made policies more clear; I am still not convinced by", "to the moderator and they did not pay any attention to this comment.", "even put some keys on each comment that the users tell that the", "has never had to be locked and put on a hold. I explained", "his opinion. In case of the questions posted on this site, the opinions", "and come out of the hold. It is a complete question. This is", "way moderators can be informed what other users think about a question. I", "to put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision", "direct conflict to what they prefer or their emotions. Because of the level", "on each comment that the users tell that the question is broad, the", "locking the questions should be limited and become dependent on a different policy;", "this because something like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator", "comment. I do not think that this question needs any edit for being", "that the question is broad, the comment is impolite and this way moderators", "conflict to what they prefer or their emotions. Because of the level of", "their emotions. Because of the level of access these guys have, when they", "the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the question with", "fun (the question is not for fun at all!). That is why I", "that the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll and if", "explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long, not short, answers (as some", "than just mindless social fun > > > When you read that question,", "can be assumed that it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers", "two or three other moderators come and give minus mark to the question", "to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all human and we all", "come out of the hold. It is a complete question. This is what", "other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users who", "problematic question, two or three other moderators come and give minus mark to", "two users who are not moderator's access) then they put the question on", "just mindless social fun (the question is not for fun at all!). That", "access on locking the questions should be limited and become dependent on a", "here and made policies more clear; I am still not convinced by the", "way they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post", "the way moderators lock a question should be revised, their access on locking", "and give minus mark to the question and use their access to put", "their opinion on poll and if some number of other users and moderators", "over opinions > * insist that opinion be backed up with facts and", "that the question is subjective (while I do not think so), it can", "made policies more clear; I am still not convinced by the behavior of", "tell that the question is broad, the comment is impolite and this way", "however, with respect to the people who talked about the problem here and", "how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from", "other moderators come and give minus mark to the question and use their", "In case of the questions posted on this site, the opinions can be", "happen in case that they find a question in direct conflict to the", "or their emotions. Because of the level of access these guys have, when", "posting this because something like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The", "on hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to", "(regarding to the words they use and they way they treat them and", "questions:** > > > * inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” >", "> Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire answers that explain “why”", "moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all", "marks the question as problematic question, two or three other moderators come and", "who talked about the problem here and made policies more clear; I am", "on the discussion made here on Meta and the title of the question", "the behavior of the moderators who acted on that question. > > >", "they may not be. Moderators have that much access that when they feel", "happen immediately and this level of access should be decreased. Moderators should express", "immediately put the question on hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators'", "backed up with facts and references > * are more than just mindless", "invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the question with their experiences);", "the question with their experiences); and is more than just mindless social fun", "to be more polite to the users (regarding to the words they use", "moderators can be informed what other users think about a question. I am", "them from emotional decisions. We are all human and we all may make", "Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have", "policies more clear; I am still not convinced by the behavior of the", "our decisions. I think that putting the questions on hold or locking the", "should be limited and become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should", "on a different policy; moreover, they should be advised to be more polite", "the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from emotional", "they put the question on hold. The site can even put some keys", "be advised to be more polite** to the users (regarding to the words", "with facts and references > * are more than just mindless social fun", "their experiences); and is more than just mindless social fun (the question is", "words they use and they way they treat them and their actions). *After", "even thinks about that their decision (even it is the decision of two", "them and their actions). After discussions: > > The post on Academia edited", "completed and come out of the hold. It is a complete question. This", "not in direct conflict to what they prefer or their emotions. Because of", "questions posted on this site, the opinions can be either in favor of", "Moderators have that much access that when they feel that a question is", "the users tell that the question is broad, the comment is impolite and", "answered the question with their experiences); and is more than just mindless social", "not short, answers (as some answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing", "they feel that a question is out of the policies of the site,", "> > The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made", "to the users (regarding to the words they use and they way they", "on Meta and the title of the question changed to [How to encourage", "moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed more. I think that the", "locking the questions should not happen immediately and this level of access should", "the question and use their access to put the question on hold. Nobody", "all may make mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting the questions", "of the site, not in direct conflict to what they prefer or their", "on a hold. I explained this to the moderator and they did not", "users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users who are", "about a question. I am posting this because something like this happened to", "the policies, put their opinion on poll and if some number of other", "if some number of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators", "answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users", "think that putting the questions on hold or locking the questions should not", "they use and they way they treat them and their actions). After discussions:*", "other users think about a question. I am posting this because something like", "moderator put a comment that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In", "what they prefer or their emotions. Because of the level of access these", "a comment that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link", "be revised, their access on locking the questions should be limited and become", "make more use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect", "experiences); and is more than just mindless social fun (the question is not", "sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the question with their experiences); and", "> have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite sharing", "this link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > > > ", "some number of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and", "more. I think that the way moderators lock a question should be revised,", "should be decreased. Moderators should express why they think that the question conflicts", "conflict to the policies or what they like, they immediately put the question", "actions). After discussions:* > > The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on", "of the level of access these guys have, when they find a question", "site, not in direct conflict to what they prefer or their emotions. Because", "why they think that the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on", "* are more than just mindless social fun > > > When you", "you read that question, If we consider and accept that the question is", "question as problematic question, two or three other moderators come and give minus", "and is more than just mindless social fun (the question is not for", "> > Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire answers that explain", "Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire answers that explain “why” and", "of two or three moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed more.", "not pay any attention to this comment. I do not think that this", "immediately and this level of access should be decreased. Moderators should express why", "answers > * have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite", "(the question is not for fun at all!). That is why I think", "polite to the users (regarding to the words they use and they way", "assumed that it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain", "become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should be advised to be", "opinions > * insist that opinion be backed up with facts and references", "put a comment that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this", "I think the question has never had to be locked and put on", "on the questions and comments. Every person has the right to express his", "not convinced by the behavior of the moderators who acted on that question.", "conflict to the policies of the site, not in direct conflict to what", "this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: >", "then they put the question on hold. The site can even put some", "long, not short, answers (as some answers were discussed on the page); invites", "some answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as", "I think that the way moderators lock a question should be revised, their", "a question either in conflict to the policies or what they like, they", "accept that the question is subjective (while I do not think so), it", "or locking the questions should not happen immediately and this level of access", "decreased. Moderators should express why they think that the question conflicts the policies,", "any attention to this comment. I do not think that this question needs", "question in direct conflict to the policies of the site, not in direct", "as problematic question, two or three other moderators come and give minus mark", "poll and if some number of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance,", "question is subjective (while I do not think so), it can be assumed", "three moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed more. I think that", "some keys on each comment that the users tell that the question is", "they find a question either in conflict to the policies or what they", "I am posting this because something like this happened to [a question of", "long, not short, answers > * have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone", "this comment. I do not think that this question needs any edit for", "on hold. The site can even put some keys on each comment that", "still not convinced by the behavior of the moderators who acted on that", "discussed more. I think that the way moderators lock a question should be", "not for fun at all!). That is why I think the question has", "it is the decision of two or three moderator) may be wrong and", "the title of the question changed to [How to encourage researchers to make", "why I think the question has never had to be locked and put", "question, If we consider and accept that the question is subjective (while I", "be decreased. Moderators should express why they think that the question conflicts the", "subjective (while I do not think so), it can be assumed that it", "and put on a hold. I explained this to the moderator and they", "they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post on", "question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even it is", "One moderator marks the question as problematic question, two or three other moderators", "explained this to the moderator and they did not pay any attention to", "I do not think that this question needs any edit for being completed", "here on Meta and the title of the question changed to [How to", "be limited and become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should be", "they think that the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll", "> When you read that question, If we consider and accept that the", "we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire answers", "of the site, put the question on hold. But, this should happen in", "all!). That is why I think the question has never had to be", "this level of access should be decreased. Moderators should express why they think", "We are all human and we all may make mistakes in our decisions.", "tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion", "Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even it is the decision of", "that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long, not short, answers (as", "of the questions posted on this site, the opinions can be either in", "be either in favor of a comment or question or they may not", "this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that", "“why” and “how” > * tend to have long, not short, answers >", "is not for fun at all!). That is why I think the question", "* have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences", "think that the way moderators lock a question should be revised, their access", "up with facts and references > * are more than just mindless social", "and this level of access should be decreased. Moderators should express why they", "or three other moderators come and give minus mark to the question and", "do not think that this question needs any edit for being completed and", "constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions >", "three other moderators come and give minus mark to the question and use", "use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the", "the site, not in direct conflict to what they prefer or their emotions.", "make mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting the questions on hold", "inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” > * tend to have long,", "broad, the comment is impolite and this way moderators can be informed what", "informed what other users think about a question. I am posting this because", "comment that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we", "when they feel that a question is out of the policies of the", "opinion on poll and if some number of other users and moderators agreed,", "website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions.", "in our decisions. I think that putting the questions on hold or locking", "guys have, when they find a question either in conflict to the policies", "too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > > *Constructive subjective", "human and we all may make mistakes in our decisions. I think that", "on this site, the opinions can be either in favor of a comment", "fun at all!). That is why I think the question has never had", "they like, they immediately put the question on hold. So, how the website", "access that when they feel that a question is out of the policies", "> The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here", "case that they find a question in direct* conflict to the policies of", "short, answers (as some answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences", "more polite to the users (regarding to the words they use and they", "moderators lock a question should be revised, their access on locking the questions", "thoroughly based on the discussion made here on Meta and the title of", "question is about how the moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every", "should happen in case that they find a question in direct conflict to", "they immediately put the question on hold. So, how the website minimizes the", "with respect to the people who talked about the problem here and made", "edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here on Meta and the title", "decisions. We are all human and we all may make mistakes in our", "Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to", "access should be decreased. Moderators should express why they think that the question", "and “how”; tends to have long, not short, answers (as some answers were", "discussion made here on Meta and the title of the question changed to", "to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this question", "fair, and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions > ", "impolite and this way moderators can be informed what other users think about", "a hold. I explained this to the moderator and they did not pay", "question is out of the policies of the site, put the question on", "this should happen in case that they find a question in direct* conflict", "they prefer or their emotions. Because of the level of access these guys", "and they way they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* > >", "being completed and come out of the hold. It is a complete question.", "comment or question or they may not be. Moderators have that much access", "instance, two moderators and two users who are not moderator's access) then they", "different policy; moreover, they should be advised to be more polite to the", "is why I think the question has never had to be locked and", "wrong and can be discussed more. I think that the way moderators lock", "just mindless social fun > > > When you read that question, If", "do not think so), it can be assumed that it is a *Constructive", "> are more than just mindless social fun > > > When", "the words they use and they way they treat them and their actions).", "questions on hold or locking the questions should not happen immediately and this", "discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered the", "put on a hold. I explained this to the moderator and they did", "their decision (even it is the decision of two or three moderator) may", "the question on hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and", "is impolite and this way moderators can be informed what other users think", "person has the right to express his opinion. In case of the questions", "and accept that the question is subjective (while I do not think so),", "the problem here and made policies more clear; I am still not convinced", "can be informed what other users think about a question. I am posting", "that they find a question in direct conflict to the policies of the", "and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist", "about how the moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every person has", "policy; moreover, they should be advised to be more polite to the users", "the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll and if some", "> * tend to have long, not short, answers > * have a", "> > > * inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” > ", "not short, answers > have a constructive, fair, and impartial tone >", "the question is subjective (while I do not think so), it can be", "to be locked and put on a hold. I explained this to the", "are all human and we all may make mistakes in our decisions. I", "treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post on Academia", "link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > > > * inspire", "experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion be backed up with facts", "and become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should be advised to", "is broad, the comment is impolite and this way moderators can be informed", "social fun (the question is not for fun at all!). That is why", "is out of the policies of the site, put the question on hold.", "attention to this comment. I do not think that this question needs any", "mindless social fun > > > When you read that question, If we", "answers that explain “why” and “how” > * tend to have long, not", "they did not pay any attention to this comment. I do not think", "question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > >", "the questions and comments. Every person has the right to express his opinion.", "has the right to express his opinion. In case of the questions posted", "* invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion be backed", "the similar questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic question, two or", "comments. Every person has the right to express his opinion. In case of", "like, they immediately put the question on hold. So, how the website minimizes", "questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic question, two or three other", "the policies or what they like, they immediately put the question on hold.", "revised, their access on locking the questions should be limited and become dependent", "people who talked about the problem here and made policies more clear; I", "the level of access these guys have, when they find a question either", "or what they like, they immediately put the question on hold. So, how", "should be revised, their access on locking the questions should be limited and", "not think so), it can be assumed that it is a Constructive Question", "moreover, they should be advised to be more polite to the users (regarding", "these guys have, when they find a question either in conflict to the", "of a comment or question or they may not be. Moderators have that", "to the similar questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic question, two", "the hold. It is a complete question. This is what happens to the", "on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here on Meta and", "a question is out of the policies of the site, put the question", "the moderator and they did not pay any attention to this comment. I", "happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic question,", "question is not for fun at all!). That is why I think the", "that putting the questions on hold or locking the questions should not happen", "be assumed that it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that", "If we consider and accept that the question is subjective (while I do", "never had to be locked and put on a hold. I explained this", "mark to the question and use their access to put the question on", "that the users tell that the question is broad, the comment is impolite", "* tend to have long, not short, answers > * have a constructive,", "and can be discussed more. I think that the way moderators lock a", "hold. I explained this to the moderator and they did not pay any", "be locked and put on a hold. I explained this to the moderator", "a complete question. This is what happens to the similar questions: One moderator", "question on hold. But, this should happen in case that they find a", "to have long, not short, answers (as some answers were discussed on the", "online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who", "to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who talked about", "users think about a question. I am posting this because something like this", "the questions should be limited and become dependent on a different policy; moreover,", "find a question either in conflict to the policies or what they like,", "that this question is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read:", "moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users who are not moderator's", "users who are not moderator's access) then they put the question on hold.", "impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that", "is about how the moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every person", "the question has never had to be locked and put on a hold.", "faults and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all human", "we consider and accept that the question is subjective (while I do not", "in case that they find a question in direct conflict to the policies", "The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here on", "a question should be revised, their access on locking the questions should be", "is subjective (while I do not think so), it can be assumed that", "hold. The site can even put some keys on each comment that the", "think that the question conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll and", "hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even it is the decision", "am still not convinced by the behavior of the moderators who acted on", "decisions. I think that putting the questions on hold or locking the questions", "be discussed more. I think that the way moderators lock a question should", "advised to be more polite to the users (regarding to the words they", "researchers to make more use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however,", "mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this question is too broad and", "moderators and two users who are not moderator's access) then they put the", "is a complete question. This is what happens to the similar questions: One", "have, when they find a question either in conflict to the policies or", "keys on each comment that the users tell that the question is broad,", "“how” > * tend to have long, not short, answers > * have", "site can even put some keys on each comment that the users tell", "[subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > > Constructive subjective questions: > >", "that this question needs any edit for being completed and come out of", "a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends", "more than just mindless social fun > > > When you read that", "the opinions can be either in favor of a comment or question or", "question should be revised, their access on locking the questions should be limited", "of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people", "comment that the users tell that the question is broad, the comment is", "*After discussions:* > > The post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the", "the questions on hold or locking the questions should not happen immediately and", "a question. I am posting this because something like this happened to [a", "and they did not pay any attention to this comment. I do not", "the question on hold. The site can even put some keys on each", "moderator marks the question as problematic question, two or three other moderators come", "changed to [How to encourage researchers to make more use of online resources", "be backed up with facts and references > * are more than just", "and references > * are more than just mindless social fun > >", "number of other users and moderators agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two", "that when they feel that a question is out of the policies of", "access to put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their", "of the policies of the site, put the question on hold. But, this", "complete question. This is what happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks", "the right to express his opinion. In case of the questions posted on", "that their decision (even it is the decision of two or three moderator)", "with their experiences); and is more than just mindless social fun (the question", "mindless social fun (the question is not for fun at all!). That is", "it can be assumed that it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires", "fun > > > When you read that question, If we consider and", "how the moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every person has the", "this to the moderator and they did not pay any attention to this", "they way they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The", "for fun at all!). That is why I think the question has never", "decision of two or three moderator) may be wrong and can be discussed", "is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”;", "(as some answers were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions", "in favor of a comment or question or they may not be. Moderators", "something like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a", "their access to put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that", "and this way moderators can be informed what other users think about a", "the people who talked about the problem here and made policies more clear;", "post on Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here on Meta", "question is broad, the comment is impolite and this way moderators can be", "were discussed on the page); invites sharing experiences over opinions (as users answered", "or question or they may not be. Moderators have that much access that", "experiences over opinions (as users answered the question with their experiences); and is", "the moderators decide on the questions and comments. Every person has the right", "tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all human and we", "that question, If we consider and accept that the question is subjective (while", "that the way moderators lock a question should be revised, their access on", "to express his opinion. In case of the questions posted on this site,", "may not be. Moderators have that much access that when they feel that", "policies of the site, put the question on hold. But, this should happen", "The site can even put some keys on each comment that the users", "express his opinion. In case of the questions posted on this site, the", "either in conflict to the policies or what they like, they immediately put", "Because of the level of access these guys have, when they find a", "like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment", "decide on the questions and comments. Every person has the right to express", "limited and become dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should be advised", "use and they way they treat them and their actions). *After discussions:* >", "to the policies or what they like, they immediately put the question on", "“how”; tends to have long, not short, answers (as some answers were discussed", "(even it is the decision of two or three moderator) may be wrong", "did not pay any attention to this comment. I do not think that", "question on hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries", "to the policies of the site, not in direct conflict to what they", "avoid them from emotional decisions. We are all human and we all may", "out of the hold. It is a complete question. This is what happens", "talked about the problem here and made policies more clear; I am still", "Academia edited thoroughly based on the discussion made here on Meta and the", "from emotional decisions. We are all human and we all may make mistakes", "* insist that opinion be backed up with facts and references > ", "answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long, not short, answers", "questions should not happen immediately and this level of access should be decreased.", "more than just mindless social fun (the question is not for fun at", "similar questions: One moderator marks the question as problematic question, two or three", "question and use their access to put the question on hold. Nobody even", "the users (regarding to the words they use and* they way they treat", "a constructive, fair, and impartial tone > * invite sharing experiences over opinions", "think the question has never had to be locked and put on a", "mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting the questions on hold or", "dependent on a different policy; moreover, they should be advised to be more", "moderators come and give minus mark to the question and use their access", "out of the policies of the site, put the question on hold. But,", "question with their experiences); and is more than just mindless social fun (the", "think that this question needs any edit for being completed and come out", "this site, the opinions can be either in favor of a comment or", "direct conflict to the policies of the site, not in direct conflict to", "on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even it is the", "of the hold. It is a complete question. This is what happens to", "is more than just mindless social fun (the question is not for fun", "opinions (as users answered the question with their experiences); and is more than", "consider and accept that the question is subjective (while I do not think", "may be wrong and can be discussed more. I think that the way", "their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with respect to the people who talked about the problem", "or they may not be. Moderators have that much access that when they", "access) then they put the question on hold. The site can even put", "“why” and “how”; tends to have long, not short, answers (as some answers", "and the title of the question changed to [How to encourage researchers to", "question either in conflict to the policies or what they like, they immediately", "conflicts the policies, put their opinion on poll and if some number of", "and made policies more clear; I am still not convinced by the behavior", "over opinions (as users answered the question with their experiences); and is more", "more clear; I am still not convinced by the behavior of the moderators", "> * inspire answers that explain “why” and “how” > * tend to", "use their access to put the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about", "in direct conflict to the policies of the site, not in direct conflict", "question changed to [How to encourage researchers to make more use of online", "have long, not short, answers > * have a constructive, fair, and impartial", "can even put some keys on each comment that the users tell that", "the decision of two or three moderator) may be wrong and can be", "users (regarding to the words they use and they way they treat them", "because something like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put", "prefer or their emotions. Because of the level of access these guys have,", "level of access these guys have, when they find a question either in", "should not happen immediately and this level of access should be decreased. Moderators", "the policies of the site, not in direct conflict to what they prefer", "title of the question changed to [How to encourage researchers to make more", "are not moderator's access) then they put the question on hold. The site", "inspires answers that explain “why” and “how”; tends to have long, not short,", "this way moderators can be informed what other users think about a question.", "decision (even it is the decision of two or three moderator) may be", "be informed what other users think about a question. I am posting this", "hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid", "the questions posted on this site, the opinions can be either in favor", "put the question on hold. So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults", "explain “why” and “how” > * tend to have long, not short, answers", "policies or what they like, they immediately put the question on hold. So,", "facts and references > * are more than just mindless social fun >", "to make more use of online resources to improve their career?](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/how-to-encourage-researchers-to-make-more-use-of-online-resources-to-improve-the); however, with", "am posting this because something like this happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time).", "we all may make mistakes in our decisions. I think that putting the", "question or they may not be. Moderators have that much access that when", "made here on Meta and the title of the question changed to [How", "the policies of the site, put the question on hold. But, this should", "should express why they think that the question conflicts the policies, put their", "question on hold. The site can even put some keys on each comment", "so), it can be assumed that it is a Constructive Question because; It", "minus mark to the question and use their access to put the question", "their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post on Academia edited thoroughly based", "a different policy; moreover, they should be advised to be more polite to", "respect to the people who talked about the problem here and made policies", "minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them from emotional decisions. We", "favor of a comment or question or they may not be. Moderators have", "on poll and if some number of other users and moderators agreed, (for", "to the words they use and they way they treat them and their", "than just mindless social fun (the question is not for fun at all!).", "of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this question is too broad", "question. This is what happens to the similar questions: One moderator marks the", "by the behavior of the moderators who acted on that question. > >", "happened to [a question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/24278/is-it-necessary-that-an-academic-person-be-online-or-it-is-just-waste-of-time). The moderator put a comment that this", "be. Moderators have that much access that when they feel that a question", "find a question in direct conflict to the policies of the site, not", "at all!). That is why I think the question has never had to", "case of the questions posted on this site, the opinions can be either", "the questions should not happen immediately and this level of access should be", "either in favor of a comment or question or they may not be.", "So, how the website minimizes the moderators' faults and tries to avoid them", "and their actions). *After discussions:* > > The post on Academia edited thoroughly", "what other users think about a question. I am posting this because something", "users answered the question with their experiences); and is more than just mindless", "My question is about how the moderators decide on the questions and comments.", "are more than just mindless social fun > > > When you read", "I am still not convinced by the behavior of the moderators who acted", "> > When you read that question, If we consider and accept that", "two moderators and two users who are not moderator's access) then they put", "for being completed and come out of the hold. It is a complete", "that opinion be backed up with facts and references > * are more", "all human and we all may make mistakes in our decisions. I think", "put their opinion on poll and if some number of other users and", "feel that a question is out of the policies of the site, put", "invite sharing experiences over opinions > * insist that opinion be backed up", "opinion be backed up with facts and references > * are more than", "think about a question. I am posting this because something like this happened", "agreed, (for instance, two moderators and two users who are not moderator's access)", "on hold. But, this should happen in case that they find a question", "hold. It is a complete question. This is what happens to the similar", "question has never had to be locked and put on a hold. I", "tends to have long, not short, answers (as some answers were discussed on", "(while I do not think so), it can be assumed that it is", "opinions can be either in favor of a comment or question or they", "this question needs any edit for being completed and come out of the", "I think that putting the questions on hold or locking the questions should", "be more polite to the users (regarding to the words they use and", "and comments. Every person has the right to express his opinion. In case", "that it is a Constructive Question because; It inspires answers that explain “why”", "to this comment. I do not think that this question needs any edit", "is too broad and [subjective](https://academia.stackexchange.com/help/dont-ask). In this link we read: > > *Constructive", "site, put the question on hold. But, this should happen in case that", "any edit for being completed and come out of the hold. It is", "the question on hold. Nobody even thinks about that their decision (even it", "they find a question in direct* conflict to the policies of the site," ]
[ "of my question before I post the question in the site? Because it", "before I post the question in the site? Because it is not easy", "it is not easy to find similar questions by simple search in the", "question in the site? Because it is not easy to find similar questions", "mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How can I find", "in the site? Because it is not easy to find similar questions by", "community. How can I find the duplicate of my question before I post", "can I find the duplicate of my question before I post the question", "Because it is not easy to find similar questions by simple search in", "are correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How can I find the", "I post the question in the site? Because it is not easy to", "I find the duplicate of my question before I post the question in", "question before I post the question in the site? Because it is not", "the community. How can I find the duplicate of my question before I", "of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How can I", "One or two questions of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the", "duplicate of my question before I post the question in the site? Because", "correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How can I find the duplicate", "questions of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How can", "marked as duplicate in the community. How can I find the duplicate of", "find the duplicate of my question before I post the question in the", "duplicate in the community. How can I find the duplicate of my question", "in the community. How can I find the duplicate of my question before", "my question before I post the question in the site? Because it is", "How can I find the duplicate of my question before I post the", "the site? Because it is not easy to find similar questions by simple", "the duplicate of my question before I post the question in the site?", "post the question in the site? Because it is not easy to find", "site? Because it is not easy to find similar questions by simple search", "the question in the site? Because it is not easy to find similar", "two questions of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the community. How", "as duplicate in the community. How can I find the duplicate of my", "or two questions of mine are correctly marked as duplicate in the community.", "is not easy to find similar questions by simple search in the community." ]
[ "The people who know (the admission committee of University of X's Department of", "I apply to the University of Y\". There questions have, in my mind,", "are too specific - they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also", "that the questions we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of", "answer, and no one else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should", "in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific - they only", "should we consider adding language discouraging these types of questions in the FAQ?", "inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee of University of X's", "have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific - they", "not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who", "are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions we get wherein", "actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know", "only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're not", "at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a particular genre of questions", "unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee of University of X's Department", "(the admission committee of University of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and", "an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission", "knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging", "fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a particular", "and no one else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should we", "questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions we", "Inspired by talking to a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site", "asks, with an accompany tale of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc.", "Many are too specific - they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're", "to a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have", "top program in X\" or \"Should I apply to the University of Y\".", "no one else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider", "their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a top", "know (the admission committee of University of X's Department of Y) won't answer,", "of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a", "specific - they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad,", "get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these types of", "too broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently", "3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee of University", "specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable", "broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable.", "the questions we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of their", "program in X\" or \"Should I apply to the University of Y\". There", "There questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific", "a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a", "my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific - they only generalize", "one else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding", "committee of University of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no one", "SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a particular genre of questions that", "of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions", "etc. \"How do get into a top program in X\" or \"Should I", "to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a top program in X\"", "site seems to have a particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable.", "2. They're also too broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable question.", "particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that", "interests, etc. \"How do get into a top program in X\" or \"Should", "too specific - they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too", "\"How do get into a top program in X\" or \"Should I apply", "also too broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're", "with an accompany tale of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How", "They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee of University of", "mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific - they only generalize to", "Y) won't answer, and no one else knows. While these get closed fairly", "I've come to believe that the questions we get wherein someone asks, with", "in X\" or \"Should I apply to the University of Y\". There questions", "that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions we get", "talking to a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to", "actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee", "coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a top program in", "a particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe", "generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're not actually", "1. Many are too specific - they only generalize to someone specific. 2.", "apply to the University of Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three", "Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a particular genre", "tale of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into", "won't answer, and no one else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently,", "frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these types of questions in the", "While these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these", "accompany tale of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get", "the University of Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1.", "user at SciPy: Every SE site seems to have a particular genre of", "question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the admission committee of", "they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're", "three problems: 1. Many are too specific - they only generalize to someone", "Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too", "X\" or \"Should I apply to the University of Y\". There questions have,", "admission committee of University of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no", "X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no one else knows. While these", "wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of their career, coursework to date,", "they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people", "date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a top program in X\" or", "get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of their career, coursework to", "a top program in X\" or \"Should I apply to the University of", "closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these types of questions", "to believe that the questions we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany", "because they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The", "\"Should I apply to the University of Y\". There questions have, in my", "to have a particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come", "of Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are", "get into a top program in X\" or \"Should I apply to the", "these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these types", "of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no one else knows. While", "asking an actionable question. 3. They're inherently unanswerable. The people who know (the", "genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the", "questions we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of their career,", "an accompany tale of their career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do", "who know (the admission committee of University of X's Department of Y) won't", "fairly frequently, should we consider adding language discouraging these types of questions in", "University of Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many", "do get into a top program in X\" or \"Should I apply to", "by talking to a fellow Academia user at SciPy: Every SE site seems", "come to believe that the questions we get wherein someone asks, with an", "- they only generalize to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because", "believe that the questions we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale", "Every SE site seems to have a particular genre of questions that are", "into a top program in X\" or \"Should I apply to the University", "have a particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've come to", "University of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no one else knows.", "SE site seems to have a particular genre of questions that are essentially", "of University of X's Department of Y) won't answer, and no one else", "to someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're not actually asking", "we get wherein someone asks, with an accompany tale of their career, coursework", "someone asks, with an accompany tale of their career, coursework to date, interests,", "essentially unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions we get wherein someone", "of Y) won't answer, and no one else knows. While these get closed", "questions have, in my mind, three problems: 1. Many are too specific -", "problems: 1. Many are too specific - they only generalize to someone specific.", "seems to have a particular genre of questions that are essentially unanswerable. I've", "to the University of Y\". There questions have, in my mind, three problems:", "career, coursework to date, interests, etc. \"How do get into a top program", "someone specific. 2. They're also too broad, because they're not actually asking an", "unanswerable. I've come to believe that the questions we get wherein someone asks,", "or \"Should I apply to the University of Y\". There questions have, in", "else knows. While these get closed fairly frequently, should we consider adding language", "They're also too broad, because they're not actually asking an actionable question. 3.", "people who know (the admission committee of University of X's Department of Y)", "Department of Y) won't answer, and no one else knows. While these get" ]
[ "without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt that", "prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a", "not have any wiki or excerpts. I just want to know, which one", "any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt that just", "with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions", "is more prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag", "to know, which one is more prefered, a tag without any wiki or", "that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\" is better", "on the tags lists, we see that some of the tags do not", "we see that some of the tags do not have any wiki or", "a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki", "a review on the tags lists, we see that some of the tags", "tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt", "just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\" is better than", "wiki or excerpts. I just want to know, which one is more prefered,", "I just want to know, which one is more prefered, a tag without", "want to know, which one is more prefered, a tag without any wiki", "excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this", "lists, we see that some of the tags do not have any wiki", "review on the tags lists, we see that some of the tags do", "tag with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for", "more prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a tag with", "of the tags do not have any wiki or excerpts. I just want", "tags lists, we see that some of the tags do not have any", "wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\"", "a tag with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is", "or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}:", "wiki or excerpt; or a tag with a wiki excerpt that just says", "just want to know, which one is more prefered, a tag without any", "do not have any wiki or excerpts. I just want to know, which", "a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about", "By a review on the tags lists, we see that some of the", "have any wiki or excerpts. I just want to know, which one is", "or a tag with a wiki excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag", "know, which one is more prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt;", "or excerpts. I just want to know, which one is more prefered, a", "excerpts. I just want to know, which one is more prefered, a tag", "the tags lists, we see that some of the tags do not have", "excerpt that just says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\" is", "see that some of the tags do not have any wiki or excerpts.", "the tags do not have any wiki or excerpts. I just want to", "that some of the tags do not have any wiki or excerpts. I", "some of the tags do not have any wiki or excerpts. I just", "one is more prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or a", "any wiki or excerpts. I just want to know, which one is more", "says \"{topic}: this tag is for questions about {topic}\" is better than nothing?", "tags do not have any wiki or excerpts. I just want to know,", "which one is more prefered, a tag without any wiki or excerpt; or" ]
[ "reasons for and againts it. If every one has his own way of", "mean that everybody is right because it depends on the opinions. Even there", "one has his own way of doing something, it does not mean that", "please help me understand what the problem is with this question and how", "something, it does not mean that everybody is right because it depends on", "became so angry with it. His main problem seems to be that if", "[this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe that it", "a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong reasons for", "mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe that it is not opinion", "are different ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we", "the actions. My question here is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the", "why something seems odd in the university and because he is a student,", "question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong reasons for and", "memebrs of community have some strong reasons for and againts it. If every", "to be that if the person asking question is not a faculty member,", "a student, he should never think about the logic behind the actions. My", "point that there is an answer to the questions (which are almost seem", "one of the users thought this question is basically opinion based and became", "of doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach the", "it. His main problem seems to be that if the person asking question", "If every one has his own way of doing something, it does not", "problem seems to be that if the person asking question is not a", "the opinions. Even there are different ways of doing something, by comparing the", "questions (which are almost seem to be opinion based). Could you please help", "with it. His main problem seems to be that if the person asking", "be opinion based). Could you please help me understand what the problem is", "me understand what the problem is with this question and how should I", "and againts it. If every one has his own way of doing something,", "question is basically opinion based and became so angry with it. His main", "opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong reasons for and againts it.", "However, one of the users thought this question is basically opinion based and", "which I strongly believe that it is not opinion based and can be", "and became so angry with it. His main problem seems to be that", "way of doing something, it does not mean that everybody is right because", "university and because he is a student, he should never think about the", "based and became so angry with it. His main problem seems to be", "the questions (which are almost seem to be opinion based). Could you please", "againts it. If every one has his own way of doing something, it", "comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach the point that there is", "the users thought this question is basically opinion based and became so angry", "by members of academia. However, one of the users thought this question is", "should never think about the logic behind the actions. My question here is,", "actions. My question here is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs", "his own way of doing something, it does not mean that everybody is", "Could you please help me understand what the problem is with this question", "doing something, it does not mean that everybody is right because it depends", "opinion based and can be precisely answered by members of academia. However, one", "logic behind the actions. My question here is, even if a question seems", "answered by members of academia. However, one of the users thought this question", "My question here is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of", "that if the person asking question is not a faculty member, it is", "has his own way of doing something, it does not mean that everybody", "problem is with this question and how should I avoid such conflicts in", "the reasons and experiences, we can reach the point that there is an", "we can reach the point that there is an answer to the questions", "asked which I strongly believe that it is not opinion based and can", "almost seem to be opinion based). Could you please help me understand what", "odd in the university and because he is a student, he should never", "never think about the logic behind the actions. My question here is, even", "some strong reasons for and againts it. If every one has his own", "on the opinions. Even there are different ways of doing something, by comparing", "question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe that it is", "to ask why something seems odd in the university and because he is", "His main problem seems to be that if the person asking question is", "not mean that everybody is right because it depends on the opinions. Even", "is basically opinion based and became so angry with it. His main problem", "that it is not opinion based and can be precisely answered by members", "it depends on the opinions. Even there are different ways of doing something,", "what the problem is with this question and how should I avoid such", "member, it is not his duty to ask why something seems odd in", "because he is a student, he should never think about the logic behind", "to be opinion based). Could you please help me understand what the problem", "seem to be opinion based). Could you please help me understand what the", "reach the point that there is an answer to the questions (which are", "an answer to the questions (which are almost seem to be opinion based).", "with this question and how should I avoid such conflicts in the community?", "members of academia. However, one of the users thought this question is basically", "is an answer to the questions (which are almost seem to be opinion", "be that if the person asking question is not a faculty member, it", "for and againts it. If every one has his own way of doing", "is not his duty to ask why something seems odd in the university", "of the users thought this question is basically opinion based and became so", "opinion based). Could you please help me understand what the problem is with", "of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe that it is not", "help me understand what the problem is with this question and how should", "is not a faculty member, it is not his duty to ask why", "about the logic behind the actions. My question here is, even if a", "seems to be that if the person asking question is not a faculty", "is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some", "opinions. Even there are different ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons", "it is not opinion based and can be precisely answered by members of", "Even there are different ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons and", "is a student, he should never think about the logic behind the actions.", "faculty member, it is not his duty to ask why something seems odd", "he is a student, he should never think about the logic behind the", "not his duty to ask why something seems odd in the university and", "the university and because he is a student, he should never think about", "even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong", "a faculty member, it is not his duty to ask why something seems", "community have some strong reasons for and againts it. If every one has", "own way of doing something, it does not mean that everybody is right", "believe that it is not opinion based and can be precisely answered by", "different ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can", "and because he is a student, he should never think about the logic", "have some strong reasons for and againts it. If every one has his", "of community have some strong reasons for and againts it. If every one", "question is not a faculty member, it is not his duty to ask", "something seems odd in the university and because he is a student, he", "can be precisely answered by members of academia. However, one of the users", "and can be precisely answered by members of academia. However, one of the", "the logic behind the actions. My question here is, even if a question", "answer to the questions (which are almost seem to be opinion based). Could", "main problem seems to be that if the person asking question is not", "not opinion based and can be precisely answered by members of academia. However,", "opinion based and became so angry with it. His main problem seems to", "to the questions (which are almost seem to be opinion based). Could you", "I strongly believe that it is not opinion based and can be precisely", "duty to ask why something seems odd in the university and because he", "his duty to ask why something seems odd in the university and because", "strong reasons for and againts it. If every one has his own way", "it does not mean that everybody is right because it depends on the", "is with this question and how should I avoid such conflicts in the", "is not opinion based and can be precisely answered by members of academia.", "thought this question is basically opinion based and became so angry with it.", "depends on the opinions. Even there are different ways of doing something, by", "can reach the point that there is an answer to the questions (which", "In [this question of mine](https://academia.stackexchange.com/questions/25754/should-professors-help-masters-research-students-to-find-a-research-topic?noredirect=1#comment53330_25754), something is asked which I strongly believe that", "if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong reasons", "is right because it depends on the opinions. Even there are different ways", "because it depends on the opinions. Even there are different ways of doing", "not a faculty member, it is not his duty to ask why something", "there is an answer to the questions (which are almost seem to be", "everybody is right because it depends on the opinions. Even there are different", "angry with it. His main problem seems to be that if the person", "behind the actions. My question here is, even if a question seems opinion-based;", "by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach the point that there", "is asked which I strongly believe that it is not opinion based and", "he should never think about the logic behind the actions. My question here", "think about the logic behind the actions. My question here is, even if", "question here is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community", "ask why something seems odd in the university and because he is a", "precisely answered by members of academia. However, one of the users thought this", "person asking question is not a faculty member, it is not his duty", "understand what the problem is with this question and how should I avoid", "here is, even if a question seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have", "basically opinion based and became so angry with it. His main problem seems", "seems opinion-based; the memebrs of community have some strong reasons for and againts", "it. If every one has his own way of doing something, it does", "something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach the point that", "(which are almost seem to be opinion based). Could you please help me", "the point that there is an answer to the questions (which are almost", "experiences, we can reach the point that there is an answer to the", "seems odd in the university and because he is a student, he should", "ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach", "so angry with it. His main problem seems to be that if the", "the problem is with this question and how should I avoid such conflicts", "every one has his own way of doing something, it does not mean", "there are different ways of doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences,", "does not mean that everybody is right because it depends on the opinions.", "right because it depends on the opinions. Even there are different ways of", "that there is an answer to the questions (which are almost seem to", "student, he should never think about the logic behind the actions. My question", "be precisely answered by members of academia. However, one of the users thought", "asking question is not a faculty member, it is not his duty to", "academia. However, one of the users thought this question is basically opinion based", "the memebrs of community have some strong reasons for and againts it. If", "you please help me understand what the problem is with this question and", "strongly believe that it is not opinion based and can be precisely answered", "if the person asking question is not a faculty member, it is not", "in the university and because he is a student, he should never think", "that everybody is right because it depends on the opinions. Even there are", "based and can be precisely answered by members of academia. However, one of", "based). Could you please help me understand what the problem is with this", "reasons and experiences, we can reach the point that there is an answer", "it is not his duty to ask why something seems odd in the", "of academia. However, one of the users thought this question is basically opinion", "are almost seem to be opinion based). Could you please help me understand", "doing something, by comparing the reasons and experiences, we can reach the point", "users thought this question is basically opinion based and became so angry with", "the person asking question is not a faculty member, it is not his", "of doing something, it does not mean that everybody is right because it", "this question is basically opinion based and became so angry with it. His", "something is asked which I strongly believe that it is not opinion based", "and experiences, we can reach the point that there is an answer to" ]
[ "the tag to be seen and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact", "these two tags, I can not understand why that edit is too minor;", "correctly judged, for many of those rejections I can not find any good", "the excerpt we only need to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation", "[homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the", "and reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt should", "is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits", "Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt or the suggested", "the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra information in the excerpt?", "words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is written", "because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous", "issues in the post*. The question here is was the previous tag better", "explain your reasons for rejecting some of them? [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the", "incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five word", "edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these two tags,", "one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact", "this site is a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are to", "is a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are to give a", "in the post. The question here is was the previous tag better than", "reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt should be", "edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt or the", "than the suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we", "is written in the wiki, so in the excerpt we only need to", "this tag, the complete information is written in the wiki, so in the", "not understand why that edit is too minor; why the suggested edit *is", "information is written in the wiki, so in the excerpt we only need", "exact sentences that address the questions under the tag? [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is", "question here is was the previous tag better than the suggested one?! I", "in the excerpt we only need to attract the reader's attention to the", "in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these", "so in the excerpt we only need to attract the reader's attention to", "we need to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every", "questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? ", "the tag? [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356)", "the post. The question here is was the previous tag better than the", "the suggested one with two exact sentences that address the questions under the", "improvements addressing multiple issues in the post. The question here is was the", "always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that", "being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag,", "of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag edit is", "edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is", "to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we", "understand why that edit is too minor; why the suggested edit is not", "tags, I can not understand why that edit is too minor; why the", "why do we need to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries", "Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are to give a clue to", "to these two tags, I can not understand why that edit is too", "can not find any good reason. Could you please explain your reasons for", "know that this site is a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts", "wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted and give the chance to", "judged, for many of those rejections I can not find any good reason.", "of them are correctly judged, for many of those rejections I can not", "Looking at the proposed edits to these two tags, I can not understand", "edits to these two tags, I can not understand why that edit is", "excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt", "be seen and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting", "word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this site is", "word excerpt or the suggested one with two exact sentences that address the", "the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits?", "every body know that this site is a Q&A website. The only use", "need to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do", "question, why do we need to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or", "to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I think", "suggested one with two exact sentences that address the questions under the tag?", "minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt or", "the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I think the", "[publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy and paste of excerpts and", "to the tag to be seen and better excerpts be provided to it.", "is the reason that the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and", "The question here is was the previous tag better than the suggested one?!", "the suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need", "I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy", "deleted and give the chance to the tag to be seen and better", "the reader that what is being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted.", "substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post*. The question here is was", "give the chance to the tag to be seen and better excerpts be", "them are correctly judged, for many of those rejections I can not find", "excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so the", "for rejecting some of them? [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the", "* [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need to always have the", "good reason. Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting some of them?", "was useless so the excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why", "clue to the reader that what is being questioned. So, those extra words", "address the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my", "here is was the previous tag better than the suggested one?! I don't", "post*. The question here is was the previous tag better than the suggested", "should be deleted and give the chance to the tag to be seen", "the excerpt was deleted. [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need", "them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag edit is rejected", "[education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag edit is rejected because of", "is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post. The question here", "to be seen and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and", "[repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these two tags, I can", "we need the exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The", "was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need to always", "give a clue to the reader that what is being questioned. So, those", "the wiki, so in the excerpt we only need to attract the reader's", "reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra information", "reason that the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit?", "five word excerpt or the suggested one with two exact sentences that address", "that some of them are correctly judged, for many of those rejections I", "addressing multiple issues in the post*. The question here is was the previous", "are to give a clue to the reader that what is being questioned.", "to give a clue to the reader that what is being questioned. So,", "extra words are omitted. [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is", "those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information", "the complete information is written in the wiki, so in the excerpt we", "too minor; why the suggested edit *is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues", "the excerpt should be deleted and give the chance to the tag to", "so the excerpt was deleted. [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we", "and wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet", "are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is written in", "fact that some of them are correctly judged, for many of those rejections", "written in the wiki, so in the excerpt we only need to attract", "multiple issues in the post*. The question here is was the previous tag", "the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra", "some of them? [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag edit", "not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post*. The question here is", "think so. [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy and paste", "excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and reads the", "many of those rejections I can not find any good reason. Could you", "What is the reason that the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness", "think the excerpt should be deleted and give the chance to the tag", "about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this site is a Q&A", "of excerpts are to give a clue to the reader that what is", "rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag", "to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted.", "attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra information in", "deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need to always have", "what is being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in", "is was the previous tag better than the suggested one?! I don't think", "in this tag, the complete information is written in the wiki, so in", "is better? The previous five word excerpt or the suggested one with two", "* [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at", "site is a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are to give", "the proposed edits to these two tags, I can not understand why that", "minor; why the suggested edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in", "rejected. Despite the fact that some of them are correctly judged, for many", "* [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these two tags, I", "better? The previous five word excerpt or the suggested one with two exact", "[recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these two tags, I can not", "excerpt should be deleted and give the chance to the tag to be", "of those rejections I can not find any good reason. Could you please", "about...\" every body know that this site is a Q&A website. The only", "the chance to the tag to be seen and better excerpts be provided", "the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this site", "that what is being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340)", "are correctly judged, for many of those rejections I can not find any", "and give the chance to the tag to be seen and better excerpts", "[nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is written in the wiki, so", "that address the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in", "Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed", "suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the", "\"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this site is a", "previous five word excerpt or the suggested one with two exact sentences that", "I can not find any good reason. Could you please explain your reasons", "tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking", "* [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy and paste of excerpts", "notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of", "seen and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was", "that this site is a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are", "previous tag better than the suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354)", "the previous tag better than the suggested one?! I don't think so. ", "have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this", "only need to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why", "be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt", "tag better than the suggested one?! I don't think so. [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why", "reasons for rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that", "can not understand why that edit is too minor; why the suggested edit", "The reader goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the", "I think the excerpt should be deleted and give the chance to the", "questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the", "wiki, so in the excerpt we only need to attract the reader's attention", "we only need to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF,", "find any good reason. Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting some", "do we need the exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes?", "reader that what is being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. ", "tag excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt or the suggested one", "to the reader that what is being questioned. So, those extra words are", "and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt", "In this question, why do we need to always have the word \"Questions", "sentences that address the questions under the tag? [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness", "be deleted and give the chance to the tag to be seen and", "pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question,", "So, those extra words are omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete", "this question, why do we need to always have the word \"Questions about...\"", "in the wiki, so in the excerpt we only need to attract the", "reason. Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting some of them? ", "of incorrectness* and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The previous five", "two exact sentences that address the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where", "the exacet copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted", "to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body know", "better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so", "the suggested edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post.", "paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and", "exacet copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted and", "only use of excerpts are to give a clue to the reader that", "those rejections I can not find any good reason. Could you please explain", "complete information is written in the wiki, so in the excerpt we only", "two tags, I can not understand why that edit is too minor; why", "for many of those rejections I can not find any good reason. Could", "incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to", "and pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this", "omitted. * [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is written in the", "to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have extra information in the", "body know that this site is a Q&A website. The only use of", "wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy", "of my tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some of", "copy of the wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted and give", "it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted. ", "your reasons for rejecting some of them? [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason", "not find any good reason. Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting", "excerpt or the suggested one with two exact sentences that address the questions", "Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334)", "tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some of them are", "rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better? The", "don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy and", "copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to the", "please explain your reasons for rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is", "are rejected. Despite the fact that some of them are correctly judged, for", "why that edit is too minor; why the suggested edit is not substantive", "edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post*. The question", "so. [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do we need the exact copy and paste of", "The only use of excerpts are to give a clue to the reader", "attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of NSF, why do we have", "that the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which", "was the previous tag better than the suggested one?! I don't think so.", "tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt", "* [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What is the reason that the tag edit is rejected because", "rejections I can not find any good reason. Could you please explain your", "with two exact sentences that address the questions under the tag? * [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329)", "and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt", "website. The only use of excerpts are to give a clue to the", "the fact that some of them are correctly judged, for many of those", "suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some of them are correctly judged,", "my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328); [recommendation-letter](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12356) Looking at the proposed edits to these two", "Why do we need the exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki", "goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the wiki. I", "do we need to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\"", "a clue to the reader that what is being questioned. So, those extra", "tag, the complete information is written in the wiki, so in the excerpt", "and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless", "or the suggested one with two exact sentences that address the questions under", "need to always have the word \"Questions about...\" or \"Queries about...\" every body", "copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In", "excerpts are to give a clue to the reader that what is being", "use of excerpts are to give a clue to the reader that what", "excerpt we only need to attract the reader's attention to the abbreviation of", "a Q&A website. The only use of excerpts are to give a clue", "suggested edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the post. The", "The previous five word excerpt or the suggested one with two exact sentences", "useless so the excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do", "better than the suggested one?! I don't think so. * [publishing](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12354) Why do", "is too minor; why the suggested edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple", "why the suggested edit is not substantive improvements addressing multiple issues in the", "reader goes to the excerpt and reads the exacet copy of the wiki.", "of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to the excerpt and reads", "edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some of them are correctly", "you please explain your reasons for rejecting some of them? * [education](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12334) What", "I can not understand why that edit is too minor; why the suggested", "chance to the tag to be seen and better excerpts be provided to", "[poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need to always have the word", "one with two exact sentences that address the questions under the tag? ", "of the wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted and give the", "the exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes", "need the exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader", "the reason that the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness* and *minor", "Many of my tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some", "under the tag? [homework](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12329) Where is incorrectness in my edits? * [repository](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12328);", "the tag edit is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag", "provided to it. Exact copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt was", "is rejected because of incorrectness and minor edit? Which tag excerpt is better?", "my tag edit suggestions are rejected. Despite the fact that some of them", "proposed edits to these two tags, I can not understand why that edit", "excerpt is better? The previous five word excerpt or the suggested one with", "tag to be seen and better excerpts be provided to it. Exact copy", "Despite the fact that some of them are correctly judged, for many of", "* [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this tag, the complete information is written in the wiki,", "the wiki. I think the excerpt should be deleted and give the chance", "excerpt was deleted. * [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345) In this question, why do we need to", "at the proposed edits to these two tags, I can not understand why", "or \"Queries about...\" every body know that this site is a Q&A website.", "edit is too minor; why the suggested edit *is not substantive improvements addressing", "Exact copy and pasting was useless so the excerpt was deleted. [poster](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12345)", "that edit is too minor; why the suggested edit *is not substantive improvements", "is being questioned. So, those extra words are omitted. [nsf](https://academia.stackexchange.com/review/suggested-edits/12340) in this", "any good reason. Could you please explain your reasons for rejecting some of", "some of them are correctly judged, for many of those rejections I can", "\"Queries about...\" every body know that this site is a Q&A website. The", "exact copy and paste of excerpts and wiki notes? The reader goes to" ]