input stringlengths 1 1.4M | references listlengths 1 52 | gold listlengths 1 21 |
|---|---|---|
"13" "Άρθρο" "1" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"14" "Απόφαση" "της" "16ης" "Ιουλίου" "2015" "," "CHEZ" "Razpredelenie" "Bulgaria" "(" "C" "-" "83" "/" "14" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2015" ":" "480" "," "σκέψεις" "58" "και" "72" "και" "εκεί" "παρατιθέμενη" "νομολογία" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-PLACE\" \"B-PLACE\" \"B-PLACE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-TITLE\" \"B-TITLE\" \"B-TITLE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"15" "Αιτιολογική" "σκέψη" "3" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"16" "Βλ" "." "," "επίσης" "," "απόφαση" "της" "16ης" "Ιουλίου" "2015" "," "CHEZ" "Razpredelenie" "Bulgaria" "(" "C" "‑" "83" "/" "14" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2015" ":" "480" "," "σκέψη" "74" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-ROLE\" \"I-ROLE\" \"I-ROLE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"17" "Άρθρο" "3" "," "παράγραφος" "1" "," "και" "αιτιολογική" "σκέψη" "16" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Η" "παρεχόμενη" "προστασία" "εκτείνεται" "," "όπου" "αυτό" "προσήκει" "," "στα" "νομικά" "πρόσωπα" "όταν" "υφίστανται" "διάκριση" "λόγω" "της" "φυλετικής" "ή" "εθνοτικής" "καταγωγής" "των" "μελών" "τους" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"18" "Άρθρο" "3" "," "παράγραφος" "1" | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"19" "Βλ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"αιτιολογική" "σκέψη" "12" "της" "οδηγίας" "και" "απόφαση" "της" "12ης" "Μαΐου" "2011" "," "Runevič-Vardyn" "και" "Wardyn" "(" "C" "-" "391" "/" "09" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2011" ":" "291" "," "σκέψεις" "41" "και" "42" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-URL\" \"I-URL\" \"I-URL\" \"O\" \"I-URL\" \"O\" \"I-URL\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-TERRITORY\" \"B-TERRIT... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Επ" "’" "αυτού" "," "το" "πεδίο" "εφαρμογής" "της" "είναι" "ευρύτερο" "από" "αυτό" "της" "οδηγίας" "2000" "/" "78" "/" "ΕΚ" "του" "Συμβουλίου" "," "της" "27ης" "Νοεμβρίου" "2000" "," "για" "τη" "διαμόρφωση" "γενικού" "πλαισίου" "για" "την" "ίση" "μεταχείριση" "στην" "απασχόληση" "και" "την" "εργασία" "(" "ΕΕ" "2000" "... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-AGE\" \"B-AGE\" \"B-AGE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" ... |
"20" "Απόφαση" "της" "16ης" "Ιουλίου" "2015" "," "CHEZ" "Razpredelenie" "Bulgaria" "(" "C" "-" "83" "/" "14" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2015" ":" "480" "," "σκέψη" "42" "και" "εκεί" "παρατιθέμενη" "νομολογία" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-DAY\" \"I-DAY\" \"I-DAY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-NATIONALITY\" \"I-NATIONALITY\" \"I-NATIONALITY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"21" "Βλ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"συναφώς" "," "όσον" "αφορά" "την" "πρόσβαση" "σε" "αγαθά" "(" "άρθρο" "3" "," "παράγραφος" "1" "," "στοιχείο" "ηʹ" "," "της" "οδηγίας" "2000" "/" "43" ")" "," "απόφαση" "της" "16ης" "Ιουλίου" "2015" "," "CHEZ" "Razpredelenie" "Bulgaria" "(" "C" "-" "83" "/" "14" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2015" ":" "480" "," "σκέψη" "43" "... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-VALUE\" \"B-VALUE\" \"B-VALUE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" ... |
"22" "Στο" "σημείο" "αυτό" "," "διακόπτω" "τον" "συλλογισμό" "μου" "για" "να" "επισημάνω" "ότι" "οι" "διακρίσεις" "στην" "εκπαίδευση" "για" "φυλετικούς" "ή" "εθνοτικούς" "λόγους" "ήταν" "ο" "κανόνας" "στο" "καθεστώς" "φυλετικών" "διακρίσεων" "της" "Νότιας" "Αφρικής" "·" "και" "ότι" "οι" "γυναίκες" "," "παρόλο" "που" "υ... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-DAY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"I-COUNTRY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"... |
"23" "Πρόταση" "οδηγίας" "του" "Συμβουλίου" "περί" "της" "εφαρμογής" "της" "αρχής" "της" "ίσης" "μεταχείρισης" "προσώπων" "ανεξάρτητα" "από" "τη" "φυλετική" "ή" "εθν" "[" "οτ" "]" "ική" "τους" "καταγωγή" "," "COM" "(" "1999" ")" "566" "τελικό" "(" "στο" "εξής" ":" "πρόταση" "της" "Επιτροπής" ")" "," "σ" "." "5" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"24" "Ο" "κανονισμός" "(" "ΕΟΚ" ")" "1612" "/" "68" "του" "Συμβουλίου" "," "της" "15ης" "Οκτωβρίου" "1968" "," "περί" "της" "ελεύθερης" "κυκλοφορίας" "των" "εργαζομένων" "στο" "εσωτερικό" "της" "Κοινότητας" "(" "ΕΕ" "ειδ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-CITY\" \"I-CITY\" \"I-CITY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-DAY\" \"I-DAY\" \"I-DAY\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"έκδ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] |
"05" "/" "001" "," "σ" "." "33" ")" "," "καταργήθηκε" "με" "τον" "κανονισμό" "(" "ΕΕ" ")" "492" "/" "2011" "του" "Ευρωπαϊκού" "Κοινοβουλίου" "και" "του" "Συμβουλίου" "," "της" "5ης" "Απριλίου" "2011" "," "που" "αφορά" "την" "ελεύθερη" "κυκλοφορία" "των" "εργαζομένων" "στο" "εσωτερικό" "της" "Ένωσης" "(" "ΕΕ" "2011" ","... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" ... |
"Σημειωτέον" "ότι" "η" "Επιτροπή" "εμπνεύστηκε" "από" "τον" "κανονισμό" "αυτό" "προκειμένου" "να" "εξηγήσει" "ορισμένες" "από" "τις" "έννοιες" "που" "χρησιμοποιούνται" "στην" "οδηγία" "2000" "/" "43" "·" "πρόταση" "της" "Επιτροπής" "," "σ" "." "7" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"25" "Βλ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"απόφαση" "της" "15ης" "Μαρτίου" "1989" "," "Echternach" "και" "Moritz" "(" "389" "/" "87" "και" "390" "/" "87" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "1989" ":" "130" "," "σκέψη" "33" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"B-ROLE\" \"B-ROLE\" \"B-ROLE\" \"O\" \"B-ROLE\" \"O\" \"B-ROLE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-URL\" \"I-URL\" \"I-URL\" \"O\" \"I-URL\" \"O\" \"I-URL\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Σε" "προηγούμενη" "υπόθεση" "," "αφορώσα" "επίσης" "το" "άρθρο" "12" "του" "κανονισμού" "1612" "/" "68" "," "το" "Δικαστήριο" "έκρινε" "," "με" "την" "απόφαση" "της" "3ης" "Ιουλίου" "1974" "," "Casagrande" "(" "9" "/" "74" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "1974" ":" "74" "," "σκέψη" "4" ")" "," "ότι" "«" "[" "π" "]" "ροϋπόθεση" "... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-TYPE\" \"B-TYPE\" \"B-TYPE\" \"O\" \"B-TYPE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" ... |
"για" "την" "ενθάρρυνση" "της" "μόρφωσης" "υπό" "τους" "ίδιους" "όρους" "που" "ισχύουν" "και" "για" "τους" "ημεδαπούς" "που" "βρίσκονται" "σε" "όμοια" "κατάσταση" "»" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"26" "Απόφαση" "της" "26ης" "Φεβρουαρίου" "1992" "," "Raulin" "(" "C" "-" "357" "/" "89" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "1992" ":" "87" "," "σκέψη" "34" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"B-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"B-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"O\" \"B-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-INITIAL NAME\" \"B-INITIAL NAME\" \"B-INITIAL NAME\" \"O\" \"B... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"27" "Απόφαση" "της" "15ης" "Μαρτίου" "2005" "(" "C" "-" "209" "/" "03" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2005" ":" "169" "," "σκέψεις" "39" "έως" "42" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-TITLE\" \"B-TITLE\" \"B-TITLE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-COUNTRY\" \"I-COUNTRY\" \"I-COUNTRY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Η" "εν" "λόγω" "απόφαση" "σηματοδοτεί" "εξέλιξη" "της" "νομολογίας" "," "καθώς" "στο" "παρελθόν" "το" "Δικαστήριο" "είχε" "κρίνει" "ότι" "," "κατά" "το" "(" "τότε" ")" "στάδιο" "της" "εξελίξεως" "του" "κοινοτικού" "δικαίου" "," "η" "εκπαίδευση" "και" "η" "υποτροφία" "που" "χορηγούνταν" "στους" "σπουδαστές" "για" "την"... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"απόφαση" "της" "21ης" "Ιουνίου" "1988" "," "Lair" "(" "39" "/" "86" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "1988" ":" "322" "," "σκέψη" "15" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"O\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-BUILDING\" \"I-BUILDING\" \"I-BUILDING\" \"O\" \"I-BUILDING\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" ... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"28" "Κανονισμός" "(" "ΕΕ" ")" "1288" "/" "2013" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"29" "Οδηγία" "του" "Συμβουλίου" "," "της" "25ης" "Νοεμβρίου" "2003" "," "σχετικά" "με" "το" "καθεστώς" "υπηκόων" "τρίτων" "χωρών" "οι" "οποίοι" "είναι" "επί" "μακρόν" "διαμένοντες" "(" "ΕΕ" "2004" "," "L" "16" "," "σ" "." "44" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-ROLE\" \"I-ROLE\" \"I-ROLE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-UNIT\" \"B-UNIT\" \"B-UNIT\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"30" "Πρόταση" "της" "Επιτροπής" "," "σ" "." "8" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"31" "Άρθρο" "3" "," "παράγραφος" "1" "," "της" "οδηγίας" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"32" "Βλ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"απόφαση" "της" "2ας" "Φεβρουαρίου" "1988" "," "Blaizot" "κ.λπ" "." "(" "24" "/" "86" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "1988" ":" "43" "," "σκέψεις" "10" "έως" "24" "," "ιδίως" "19" "," "20" "και" "24" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-PLACE\" \"I-PLACE\" \"I-PLACE\" \"O\" \"I-PLACE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"33" "Πρόταση" "της" "Επιτροπής" "," "σ" "." "7" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"34" "Βλ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"απόφαση" "της" "15ης" "Δεκεμβρίου" "2016" "," "Depesme" "κ.λπ" "." "(" "C" "-" "401" "/" "15" "έως" "C" "-" "403" "/" "15" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2016" ":" "955" "," "σκέψη" "38" "και" "εκεί" "παρατιθέμενη" "νομολογία" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-YEAR\" \"I-YEAR\" \"I-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-URL\" \"I-URL\" \"I-URL\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Η" "πρόταση" "της" "Επιτροπής" "ρητώς" "αναφέρει" "ότι" "εμπνέεται" "(" "βλ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"σ" "." "7" ")" "από" "τον" "κανονισμό" "1612" "/" "68" "όσον" "αφορά" "τον" "όρο" "«" "κοινωνικά" "προνόμια" "»" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"35" "Επ" "’" "αυτού" "," "είμαι" "της" "γνώμης" "ότι" "σαφέστατα" "το" "δίκαιο" "της" "Ένωσης" "έχει" "εξελιχθεί" "από" "τότε" "που" "το" "Δικαστήριο" "," "με" "την" "απόφαση" "της" "21ης" "Ιουνίου" "1988" "," "Brown" "(" "197" "/" "86" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "1988" ":" "323" "," "σκέψη" "18" ")" "," "έκρινε" "ότι" "«" ... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-URL\" \"B-URL\" \"B-URL\" \"O\" \"B-URL\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" ... |
"Βλ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] |
"απόφαση" "της" "15ης" "Μαρτίου" "2005" "," "Bidar" "(" "C" "-" "209" "/" "03" "," "EU" ":" "C" ":" "2005" ":" "169" "," "σκέψεις" "39" "έως" "42" ")" "," "μνημονευόμενη" "στο" "σημείο" "38" "των" "παρουσών" "προτάσεων" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-TYPE\" \"I-TYPE\" \"I-TYPE\" \"O\" \"I-TYPE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-MARITAL STATUS\" \"I-MARITAL STATUS\" \"I-MARITAL STATUS\"... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Τούτο" "ισχύει" "," "κατά" "μείζονα" "λόγο" "," "στο" "πλαίσιο" "της" "οδηγίας" "2000" "/" "43" "," "λαμβανομένου" "υπόψη" "του" "σκοπού" "και" "της" "οικονομίας" "της" "οδηγίας" "," "όπως" "αναλύονται" "στα" "σημεία" "24" "επ" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"των" "παρουσών" "προτάσεων" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"OPINION" "OF" "ADVOCATE" "GENERAL" "WAHL" "delivered" "on" "11" "September" "2018" "(" "1" ")" "Case" "C" "‑" "378" "/" "17" "The" "Minister" "for" "Justice" "and" "Equality" "," "The" "Commissioner" "of" "An" "Garda" "Síochána" "The" "Workplace" "Relations" "Commission" ";" "notice" "parties" ":" "Ronald" "Boyle" ","... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"I-TERRITORY\" \"I-TERRITORY\" \"I-TERRITORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-TERRITORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-TERRITO... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"B-PROFESSION\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-F... |
"Where" "do" "the" "limits" "of" "the" "procedural" "autonomy" "of" "Member" "States" "lie" "?" | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Or" "more" "specifically" ":" "to" "what" "extent" "does" "the" "principle" "of" "the" "primacy" "of" "EU" "law" "circumscribe" "the" "possibility" "for" "Member" "States" "to" "apply" "(" "constitutional" ")" "rules" "concerning" "the" "attribution" "of" "jurisdiction" "in" "a" "particular" "field" "of" "law" "?" | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"That" "is" "," "in" "essence" "," "the" "question" "put" "to" "the" "Court" "by" "the" "Supreme" "Court" "of" "Ireland" "in" "this" "case" "." "2" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-COUNTRY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-INITIAL NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"More" "concretely" "at" "issue" "is" "the" "compatibility" "with" "the" "principle" "of" "the" "primacy" "of" "EU" "law" "of" "a" "rule" "dividing" "jurisdiction" "in" "specific" "cases" "between" "the" "High" "Court" "and" "a" "statutory" "body" "," "the" "Workplace" "Relations" "Commission" "(" "‘" "the" "WRC" "’" "... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "competent" "body" "to" "hear" "a" "case" "depends" "on" "the" "nature" "of" "the" "complaint" "put" "forward" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"While" "the" "WRC" "generally" "enjoys" "jurisdiction" "to" "hear" "complaints" "in" "employment" "equality" "matters" "based" "on" "Directive" "2000" "/" "78" "/" "EC" "(" "2" ")" "and" "the" "national" "legislation" "transposing" "that" "directive" "," "that" "body" "has" "no" "jurisdiction" "to" "hear" "cases" "whe... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"Because" "of" "that" "rule" "," "the" "WRC" "has" "no" "jurisdiction" "to" "consider" "whether" "a" "provision" "of" "national" "law" "is" "in" "breach" "of" "EU" "employment" "equality" "legislation" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Instead" "," "the" "competent" "body" "for" "seeking" "redress" "for" "discrimination" "in" "cases" "requiring" "the" "disapplication" "of" "national" "law" "is" "the" "High" "Court" "." "4" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "question" "put" "to" "the" "Court" "in" "this" "case" "requires" "consideration" "of" "the" "very" "rationale" "underlying" "the" "line" "of" "case-law" "devolving" "from" "the" "Court" "’" "s" "seminal" "judgment" "in" "Simmenthal" "." "(" "3" ")" "It" "invites" "the" "Court" "to" "examine" "whether" "the" "con... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-ETHNIC CATEGORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"I" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Legal" "framework" "A" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"EU" "Law" "5" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Directive" "2000" "/" "78" "lays" "down" "rules" "regarding" "equal" "treatment" "in" "the" "context" "of" "employment" "and" "occupation" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"In" "accordance" "with" "Article" "1" "thereof" "," "it" "seeks" "to" "combat" "discrimination" "and" "to" "put" "into" "effect" "the" "principle" "of" "equal" "treatment" "in" "the" "Member" "States" "." "6" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Article" "3" "defines" "the" "scope" "of" "the" "directive" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"It" "states" ":" "Within" "the" "limits" "of" "the" "areas" "of" "competence" "conferred" "on" "the" "Community" "," "this" "Directive" "shall" "apply" "to" "all" "persons" "," "as" "regards" "both" "the" "public" "and" "private" "sectors" "," "including" "public" "bodies" "," "in" "relation" "to" ":" "(" "a" ")" "con... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"Chapter" "II" "of" "Directive" "2000" "/" "78" "deals" "with" "remedies" "and" "enforcement" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Article" "9" "(" "1" ")" "of" "the" "directive" "concerns" "the" "defence" "of" "rights" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"It" "provides" ":" "‘" "Member" "States" "shall" "ensure" "that" "judicial" "and" "/" "or" "administrative" "procedures" "," "including" "where" "they" "deem" "it" "appropriate" "conciliation" "procedures" "," "for" "the" "enforcement" "of" "obligations" "under" "this" "Directive" "are" "available" "to" "all" "persons... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"B" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] |
"National" "law" "1" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "Constitution" "8" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Article" "34" "of" "Bunreacht" "na" "hÉireann" "(" "Constitution" "of" "Ireland" ")" "(" "‘" "the" "Constitution" "’" ")" "provides" ":" "‘" "1" "Justice" "shall" "be" "administered" "in" "courts" "established" "by" "law" "by" "judges" "appointed" "in" "the" "manner" "provided" "by" "this" "Constitution" "," "and" ","... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-TERRITORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \... |
"Article" "37.1" "of" "the" "Constitution" "provides" ":" "‘" "Nothing" "in" "this" "Constitution" "shall" "operate" "to" "invalidate" "the" "exercise" "of" "limited" "functions" "and" "powers" "of" "a" "judicial" "nature" "," "in" "matters" "other" "than" "criminal" "matters" "," "by" "any" "person" "or" "body" "of" "... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"The" "relevant" "employment" "legislation" "10" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"In" "Ireland" "," "the" "prohibition" "of" "discrimination" "on" "grounds" "of" "age" "is" "set" "out" "in" "the" "Employment" "Equality" "Acts" "." "(" "4" ")" "11" "." | [
"\"O\" \"B-INITIAL NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"B-TERRITORY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"... | [
"\"O\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "WRC" "(" "previously" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" ")" "is" "the" "quasi-judicial" "body" "established" "to" "investigate" "," "hear" "and" "decide" "on" "complaints" "of" "discrimination" "." "(" "5" ")" "Pursuant" "to" "the" "relevant" "provisions" "of" "the" "Employment" "Equality" "Acts" "," "the" "WRC" "is" ... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"In" "accordance" "with" "the" "Garda" "Síochána" "regulations" "," "(" "6" ")" "a" "person" "is" "not" "admitted" "as" "a" "trainee" "to" "become" "a" "member" "of" "the" "national" "police" "force" "unless" "that" "person" "is" "at" "least" "18" "," "but" "under" "35" "," "years" "of" "age" "on" "the" "first" "day" "... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-TITLE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-TITLE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-AGE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-AGE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \... |
"II" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Facts" "," "procedure" "and" "the" "questions" "referred" "13" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Between" "2005" "and" "2007" "," "Mr" "Ronald" "Boyle" "," "Mr" "Brian" "Fitzpatrick" "and" "Mr" "Gerard" "Cotter" "(" "‘" "the" "notice" "parties" "’" ")" "applied" "for" "entry" "to" "train" "as" "members" "of" "An" "Garda" "Síochána" "(" "national" "police" "force" "," "Ireland" ")" "." | [
"\"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-UNIT\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"I-NAT... | [
"\"O\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"B-TITLE\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"B-TITLE\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"B-TITLE\" \"O\" \"B-FAMILY NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"O... |
"Entry" "was" "refused" "on" "the" "basis" "that" "the" "Garda" "Síochána" "regulations" "set" "the" "upper" "age" "limit" "for" "entry" "as" "a" "trainee" "at" "35" "years" "(" "‘" "the" "age" "restriction" "measure" "’" ")" "." "14" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-INITIAL NAME\" \"B-INITIAL NAME\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-AGE\" \"I-AGE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "notice" "parties" "lodged" "complaints" "against" "those" "refusals" "under" "the" "Employment" "Equality" "Acts" "before" "the" "(" "what" "was" "then" ")" "Equality" "Tribunal" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"They" "alleged" "that" "the" "age" "restriction" "measure" "constitutes" "discriminatory" "treatment" "in" "the" "context" "of" "employment" "on" "grounds" "of" "age" "." "15" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Contrary" "to" "what" "its" "name" "suggests" "," "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "is" "not" "a" "court" "," "but" "a" "statutory" "body" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"It" "was" "competent" "to" "deal" "with" "employment" "equality" "complaints" "until" "2015" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-NATIONALITY\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-INITIAL NAME\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" ... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\""
] |
"From" "then" "on" "," "the" "WRC" "assumed" "the" "competence" "vested" "in" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "." "16" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"According" "to" "the" "referring" "court" "," "Article" "34.3.2" "of" "the" "Constitution" "reserves" "to" "courts" "the" "competence" "to" "disapply" "national" "legislation" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Consequently" "," "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "and" "its" "successor" "," "the" "WRC" "," "have" "," "in" "their" "capacity" "as" "statutory" "bodies" "," "no" "jurisdiction" "to" "deal" "with" "cases" "where" "an" "effective" "remedy" "would" "require" "the" "disapplication" "of" "national" "legislation" "on" "the" "... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"In" "the" "proceedings" "before" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "," "the" "Minister" "for" "Justice" "and" "Equality" "(" "‘" "the" "Minister" "’" ")" "raised" "the" "issue" "of" "jurisdiction" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Because" "the" "notice" "parties" "considered" "that" "the" "age" "restriction" "measure" "was" "contrary" "to" "Directive" "2000" "/" "78" "and" "the" "Employment" "Equality" "Acts" "," "the" "legislation" "transposing" "that" "directive" "," "the" "complaints" "amounted" "to" "a" "request" "to" "disapply" "the" "age... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Arguing" "that" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "had" "no" "jurisdiction" "to" "disapply" "national" "legislation" "," "the" "Minister" "requested" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "to" "deal" "with" "the" "jurisdictional" "issue" "as" "a" "preliminary" "issue" "," "before" "dealing" "with" "the" "substance" "." "18" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "Equality" "Tribunal" "declined" "to" "do" "so" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Instead" "," "it" "scheduled" "a" "hearing" "for" "11" "June" "2008" "," "at" "which" "both" "the" "issue" "of" "jurisdiction" "and" "the" "substantive" "issues" "regarding" "age" "discrimination" "were" "to" "be" "dealt" "with" "." "19" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-PLACE\" \"B-PLACE\" \"B-PLACE\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Due" "to" "the" "refusal" "of" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "to" "consider" "the" "issue" "of" "jurisdiction" "as" "a" "preliminary" "issue" "," "the" "Minister" "sought" "judicial" "review" "before" "the" "High" "Court" "." "20" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"First" "," "the" "Minister" "asked" "the" "High" "Court" "to" "prohibit" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "from" "proceeding" "with" "an" "investigation" "of" "the" "complaints" "of" "the" "notice" "parties" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Second" "," "the" "Minister" "asked" "the" "High" "Court" "to" "declare" "that" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "had" "no" "jurisdiction" "to" "consider" "the" "complaints" "." "21" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "High" "Court" "ruled" "on" "17" "February" "2009" "that" "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "was" "not" "empowered" "," "under" "national" "law" "," "to" "proceed" "with" "the" "hearing" "," "which" "implicitly" "assumed" "competence" "to" "overrule" "or" "disapply" "national" "legislation" "such" "as" "the" "age" "res... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-AGE\" \"I-AGE\" \"I-AGE\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "Equality" "Tribunal" "appealed" "that" "decision" "to" "the" "Supreme" "Court" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"By" "the" "time" "the" "matter" "came" "to" "be" "considered" "by" "the" "Supreme" "Court" "," "the" "Equality" "Tribunal" "had" "become" "the" "WRC" "." "23" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "Supreme" "Court" "delivered" "a" "judgment" "on" "15" "June" "2017" "(" "‘" "the" "judgment" "of" "15" "June" "2017" "’" ")" "." "(" "7" ")" "It" "confirmed" "the" "finding" "of" "the" "High" "Court" "that" "the" "WRC" "does" "not" "have" "jurisdiction" "to" "disapply" "national" "law" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-STANDARD ABBREVIATION\" \"B-STANDARD ABBREVIATION\" \"B-STANDARD ABBREVIATION\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-STANDARD ABBREVIATION\" \"B-STANDARD ABBREVIATION\" \"B-STANDARD ABBREVIATION\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"The" "Supreme" "Court" "nevertheless" "added" "that" "cases" "which" "would" "ordinarily" "fall" "within" "the" "jurisdiction" "of" "the" "WRC" "," "but" "in" "which" "that" "administrative" "body" "could" "have" "the" "obligation" "under" "national" "or" "EU" "law" "to" "disapply" "national" "legislation" "," "must" ... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Entertaining" "doubts" "as" "to" "whether" "such" "a" "division" "of" "jurisdiction" "between" "a" "statutory" "body" "and" "a" "court" "of" "law" "is" "compatible" "with" "EU" "law" "," "the" "referring" "court" "decided" "to" "stay" "the" "proceedings" "and" "to" "refer" "the" "following" "question" "to" "the" "Cour... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O... |
"25" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] | [
"\"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Written" "observations" "have" "been" "submitted" "by" "the" "Minister" "and" "the" "Commissioner" "of" "An" "Garda" "Síochána" "," "Ireland" "," "the" "WRC" "," "the" "first" "and" "third" "notice" "parties" "," "the" "Czech" "Government" "and" "the" "European" "Commission" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-BUILDING\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-COUNTRY\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\""
] |
"Apart" "from" "the" "Czech" "Government" "," "those" "parties" "also" "presented" "oral" "argument" "at" "the" "hearing" "held" "on" "5" "June" "2018" "." | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"I-PROFESSION\" \"O\"",
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"I-INITIAL NAME\" \"I-INITIAL NAME\" \"I-INITIAL... | [
"\"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"O\" \"B-DAY\" \"B-MONTH\" \"B-YEAR\" \"O\""
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.